Oversight Archive: City Council meeting, 2013-06-10, recording 1 (started 17:00)
Machine transcript (faster-whisper base.en), not checked word for word; the Pledge of Allegiance is shown in its standard wording. The recording is the record.
Times are time into the recording. Passages with private details are muted in the audio and marked here.
The audio on the page below was re-encoded by software from the video the agency posted. Check any passage against
that audio before relying on it.
Page: https://oversightarchive.org/twin-falls-id/meetings/2013-06-10/

[0:00:19] I did thank you and I sort of thank you.
[0:01:02] I'm at the bottom of the agenda, right?
[0:02:35] Third?
[0:02:38] What else is on there?
[0:02:43] Nothing really big.
[0:02:44] Hey Mitch, hey Lee.
[0:03:04] I thought it was some things at the same time.
[0:03:51] It's actually a pretty good thing.
[0:03:52] I thought it might go into it.
[0:03:53] I didn't think it was about that much.
[0:04:06] I thought it was 600.
[0:04:07] I forgot about wheels and rooms and everything.
[0:04:10] So the ILA, are we ready?
[0:04:29] I'd like to call the order of the June 10th, 2013,
[0:04:34] of the Twin Falls City Council to order.
[0:04:37] First order of business is the pledge.
[0:04:39] All those like to join us, please stand.
[0:04:41] I just want to thank the United States of America and the United States for which it stands.
[0:04:53] I pledge allegiance to the Flag of the United States of America, and to the Republic for which it stands, one Nation under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all.
[0:04:58] And according to this shot we got you double duty this week.
[0:05:06] Your immediate connection this week.
[0:05:08] Alright, Wednesday and Thursday both.
[0:05:10] It's the 13th and 13th.
[0:05:12] Two hands.
[0:05:13] Alright, welcome.
[0:05:17] Welcome, welcome to a firm that we have a duo before.
[0:05:20] All seven members are here, and they're not just a staff,
[0:05:23] and they provided me quite the list today.
[0:05:25] So I'll see if I can not screw up too many names here.
[0:05:30] It's right again.
[0:05:31] City Manager, Travis Rothmuyler, City Attorney, French,
[0:05:33] Wonder Lake CFO, Lori Race, Community Development Director,
[0:05:37] Mitchell Humble, City Engineer, Jackie Fields, Airport Manager,
[0:05:42] Bill Carberry, Assistant City Engineer, Troy Vitek, Sergeant Ryan
[0:05:47] However, police department also staff started to do this pull in of our police department and
[0:05:51] Deputy said he said he clerk regarding Secretary Leidliss and chance
[0:05:58] Moving on to considerations to amendments to agenda
[0:06:02] Said manager comes across by Mr. Mayor members of the council
[0:06:06] Staff would ask the council to consider
[0:06:09] Going into executive session under 67 23 4 5 1 e
[0:06:15] to consider preliminary negotiations involving matters of trade or commerce in
[0:06:21] which the governing body is in competition with governing bodies in other states or
[0:06:25] nations. We've learned of an opportunity earlier this morning and we want to
[0:06:30] update the council on a matter that falls under that heading. So moved. Seconded.
[0:06:39] Then move by Sean Berger and seconded by Chris Tockington that we move in the section 67 to three four five one be
[0:06:48] E
[0:06:49] Excuse me. I keep hearing B. I think I did that last week to get everybody on my good side
[0:06:59] All right, uh, see no lights the other local boat season Hawkins yes Greg Lan team yes Jim mine. Yes Rebecca Mills like up. Yes
[0:07:09] Yes.
[0:07:10] Yes.
[0:07:11] Yes.
[0:07:12] John Barroker.
[0:07:13] Yes.
[0:07:14] Yes.
[0:07:15] Yes.
[0:07:16] Yes.
[0:07:17] Yes.
[0:07:18] It's approved 7-0.
[0:07:19] There are no proclamations, so we'll move on to the consent calendar, council wishes.
[0:07:23] First talking.
[0:07:24] Move except this is the consent calendar is printed.
[0:07:27] Second.
[0:07:28] Second.
[0:07:29] And moved by Chris Tockington and seconded by Don Hall to approve the consent calendar as
[0:07:34] printed.
[0:07:35] We do have a light, Rebecca Bill Sawyer.
[0:07:37] Thank you.
[0:07:38] I have a small question on item number four, I don't believe I need to remove it, it shouldn't be if I may ask, yeah.
[0:07:46] It's just a question for staff on item number four, it says that the event organizers will be responsible for any billing resulting from callouts for electrical service.
[0:07:56] In the past I've heard that there are electrical issues in the city park with the outlets.
[0:08:02] Has that been a policy in the past or is it something we've started recently?
[0:08:08] Anyone?
[0:08:14] There's more.
[0:08:17] Thank you.
[0:08:18] It depends on the occasion.
[0:08:20] Sometimes most of these large groups, we give them the keys where all the circuit breakers
[0:08:25] are at, because occasionally they overload the outlets, so it trips the circuit breakers.
[0:08:30] So instead of having them go out on a call every time they blow a circuit breaker,
[0:08:34] So you can flip it and then you just have to remind
[0:08:36] themselves to lessen the load off those circuit breakers.
[0:08:39] But normally we have, my department has not charged them
[0:08:43] for a call-out or electric service.
[0:08:45] I don't know if that meant, I don't know if that meant
[0:08:48] for electrician or balanced rocket to come in.
[0:08:52] One time we had a major blow-up of our major circuit breaker
[0:08:56] down there where balanced rocket to come in and fix it.
[0:08:58] But it wasn't nothing what the event organizers did.
[0:09:02] It's just the system was old and just blew on that time.
[0:09:04] Yeah, that's what I'm wondering.
[0:09:05] Because I've heard, even from like, you know,
[0:09:07] vendors at Western days, I've just
[0:09:09] heard a lot of complaints about, you know,
[0:09:12] they have electrical problems.
[0:09:13] And I'd never seen this in one of the reports
[0:09:15] that we would charge them for a call.
[0:09:17] But I just want to clarification on that.
[0:09:19] Those are the psychological problems.
[0:09:20] They just overload the circuits.
[0:09:21] They're only 20 amp circuits.
[0:09:23] And they're plugging in some deep rat fires, crock pots.
[0:09:26] And they just blow the small 20 amp circuits.
[0:09:30] That's most of the problems I am aware of.
[0:09:34] Pretty much what he said, we just wanted to put this in here this time.
[0:09:38] We have had issues where they've called an electrical service to come out and
[0:09:42] it needs to be clear that they are going to be built in not the city.
[0:09:45] It's not going to pay for the building if they have an electrical issue.
[0:09:49] They need to call an actual electrician now.
[0:09:51] Okay, and that's the case for anyone who uses the park?
[0:09:55] Yeah, that's always been the case.
[0:09:57] I'm just now starting to put these in there because it does come up from time to time and
[0:10:00] that way everybody's aware of it and it's the norm.
[0:10:03] Okay, thank you.
[0:10:04] Don't know, Dennis just, Dennis Boyer.
[0:10:08] I would call you Staff Sergeant.
[0:10:11] Sorry, Dennis.
[0:10:16] I mean, this is a common issue.
[0:10:18] We've got a lot of vendors that bring in their real heavy,
[0:10:21] like you say, deep fryers.
[0:10:23] I've been involved with the Hispanic Heritage Fiesta
[0:10:25] for years and we always blew them out there.
[0:10:28] And really, the only thing that we're going to do is invest a lot more money.
[0:10:33] It's just really more of a convenience.
[0:10:34] And what I told people when I was involved is bring your generator,
[0:10:37] if you really have a high load.
[0:10:39] And some of them do, you know, we have, you know, some 20 amp, I mean,
[0:10:42] 220 amp services there to handle some of the larger ones.
[0:10:45] But underneath all those trees are just 110 outlets, and they're on a 20 amp service,
[0:10:50] and occasionally they overload them.
[0:10:52] But that's why we give them keys so they can go in there.
[0:10:54] All the outlets are marked, and they know what number it is,
[0:10:57] to see which one is tripping, they just tripping themself.
[0:10:59] Instead of we implement that instead of us going out there
[0:11:02] every single time when they flip a low circuit breaker.
[0:11:06] And were they put in originally for the lights?
[0:11:08] Is that the Christmas lights?
[0:11:10] Wasn't really intended to use them for these kind of events,
[0:11:13] right?
[0:11:13] Yeah.
[0:11:14] All the big events didn't happen until Christmas
[0:11:16] and City of Park started.
[0:11:17] OK.
[0:11:17] Thank you.
[0:11:19] All right.
[0:11:19] Thank you.
[0:11:20] That's cool.
[0:11:25] Are we ready for a move, then?
[0:11:28] All right.
[0:11:28] the other roll call up Greg Lanti yes Jim on yes Rebecca Melsoika yes
[0:11:34] Chris talking yes Sean Berger yes Don Hall yes Susan Hawkins yes
[0:11:40] motion passes 7-0
[0:11:42] chamber just one brief comment I'd like to make so one of the items we just
[0:11:47] approved was the for the July fireworks event and we are three and a half weeks
[0:11:51] to the fireworks and I would encourage folks to get on their website and
[0:11:56] and participate by donating to help fund those fireworks
[0:11:59] because they are still seeking funds.
[0:12:02] And that's super easy.
[0:12:03] You can do it with your PayPal account.
[0:12:04] It takes about that long.
[0:12:08] Thank you, Sean.
[0:12:10] Moving on to item consideration.
[0:12:12] Item number one, consideration of request
[0:12:14] by Melinda Anderson, Economic Development Director
[0:12:16] to approve the grant opening event for the Columbia Corporate
[0:12:20] Office and Cheese Innovation Center
[0:12:23] to be held on Wednesday, August 7, 2013.
[0:12:28] And I don't see Melinda. Oh, there she is you're hiding. What did you want Dennis to do it? Oh
[0:12:36] I think it does say Dennis's name here apologize your name was in the title Monday, just to sue
[0:12:42] Dennis Sergeant Paul. Excuse me
[0:12:46] Land via corporate office and cheese is
[0:12:49] Going to have their grand opening coming up. We're all aware that they've been
[0:12:53] Building the new building in the area fourth Avenue in the south and so shown
[0:12:56] on the requesting that to do the grand opening on August 7th of this summer.
[0:13:01] It's my understanding that if not 100% completed, they're going to be very close.
[0:13:05] In order to do that, we need to bring this to city council due to the city ordinance,
[0:13:10] state and grand openings.
[0:13:11] We have to do this as well as we're requesting the street closure.
[0:13:14] I'm currently the 100 block of 4th Avenue South is closed due to the construction.
[0:13:19] I'm not sure whether we're going to be at that point.
[0:13:21] However, if that is completed, they are requesting that we close the street off.
[0:13:25] We'll be able to steer them in the right direction for barricades so they can do that, where it's a safe event.
[0:13:32] At that time they'll be holding events in the area of the building there along 4th Avenue, south to include people giving presentations.
[0:13:40] They'll be serving treats, things along that line.
[0:13:43] They'll be providing tours as well.
[0:13:45] So for the most part that's why we're here is because of the street closure and it is a grand opening event.
[0:13:51] We don't foresee any issues with this.
[0:13:53] Thank you, Archipole.
[0:13:55] That's how you're doing.
[0:13:57] Anyone else have any questions?
[0:13:58] Jim?
[0:13:59] No questions?
[0:14:00] I'll move to approve it.
[0:14:02] Second.
[0:14:03] Find that page.
[0:14:04] Been moved by Jim.
[0:14:10] And seconded by Suzanne Hawkins.
[0:14:13] That we approved the event on August 7th for Glamby.
[0:14:17] It's time on the list.
[0:14:18] We'll be 10 o'clock.
[0:14:20] 10 a.m.
[0:14:21] 6 a.m.
[0:14:22] to 1 p.m.
[0:14:23] 8 a.m.
[0:14:24] 1 p.m.
[0:14:25] All right, you see no additional lights.
[0:14:40] So the other roll call vote.
[0:14:42] Jim on.
[0:14:42] Yes.
[0:14:43] Rebecca Milsoica.
[0:14:44] Yes.
[0:14:45] Chris Chalkinson.
[0:14:46] Sean Berger.
[0:14:47] Yes.
[0:14:47] Don Hall.
[0:14:48] Yes.
[0:14:48] Susan Hawkins.
[0:14:49] Yes.
[0:14:50] Great glancing.
[0:14:51] Yes.
[0:14:52] I'm going to pass the seven to zero.
[0:14:55] On to item number two, consideration of request
[0:14:57] to approve the FFA, excuse me, CAAA.
[0:15:01] AIP days 34, 2013 pavement slurry seal project
[0:15:07] to straight, stripe painting incorporated in the amount of $378,690 continued upon the
[0:15:15] available funding and concurrence of the FAA.
[0:15:20] Bill Carberry, take this away from me please.
[0:15:24] Thank you very much.
[0:15:25] Good evening.
[0:15:26] Well, it's construction season again and the airport is doing its part to get some work
[0:15:32] accomplished.
[0:15:33] We've just recently bid a box seal, a slurry seal, if you will,
[0:15:38] for the main runway as well as a portion
[0:15:41] of the transient aircraft parking ramp in front of readers.
[0:15:46] We held the bid opening back on May 16th
[0:15:50] and received three bids for the job.
[0:16:04] Straight stripe painting ink at St. George, Utah was the low bit
[0:16:10] highlight markings as a New York State firm
[0:16:12] and Maxwell Asphalt is out of Salt Lake City, so a straight stripe was the low bidder there.
[0:16:21] Back to the runway, it was a mill and overlaid back in 1999, so what we're really looking
[0:16:27] to do with the seal coat is to preserve the useful life.
[0:16:30] It's very expensive to go and rehabilitate the runway, so the hope is with the product
[0:16:35] that we've chosen in coordination with the FAA and Rita Cell will do the job to give it
[0:16:41] but a good sale and rejuvenated somewhat
[0:16:43] and hopefully get us to the latter part of this decade
[0:16:45] before we have to address it again.
[0:16:47] So, as I mentioned, it's received no maintenance since 1999,
[0:16:50] so it is a timely project for us, so.
[0:16:54] With that, I'd entertain any questions
[0:16:57] and I'd also recommend the council
[0:16:59] to consider awarding a low bid
[0:17:00] to straight-stripe painting out of St. George.
[0:17:03] Who do I have for questions, Chris, talk to you?
[0:17:04] Just a usual question, Bill,
[0:17:06] on a project this size is pretty important
[0:17:08] We have satisfactory completion, is there bonding,
[0:17:12] or checks, performance checks,
[0:17:15] one way to make sure that we get goods delivered,
[0:17:18] that was promised?
[0:17:19] Yes, there are performance bonds.
[0:17:23] Thank you.
[0:17:24] All right, Donald, are you ready for a motion?
[0:17:26] Sure.
[0:17:27] Well, actually, we have other questions for Shummer.
[0:17:30] So this bid is significantly lower than the other bids,
[0:17:35] as well as the engineers' estimate.
[0:17:37] So in the review of the bids, we're still confident this is responsive and complete.
[0:17:43] I'd ask you can I ask your project manager to characterize the bid for you.
[0:17:49] Thank you.
[0:17:50] Can applicants read a cell?
[0:17:52] No, wait for them.
[0:17:53] I'm going to go ahead and see the council.
[0:17:57] In review in the bids, I actually call and talk to the folks who submitted bids and the
[0:18:02] primary difference between straight stripes and the guys that is the method of removing rubber.
[0:18:07] is you have a couple of different ways to remove the rubber off the runway because you can't
[0:18:11] seal over the rubber. The other folks who actually had a water application removal, which is
[0:18:16] a more costly and expensive method, the gentleman at a southern Utah had a different method
[0:18:23] through chemical and through removing that rubber. So there was some technique that was
[0:18:29] used by the Apparelot as far as some cost savings there. Is that an answer?
[0:18:35] I mean, not that I'm complaining that we're saving some dollars on the project, but it
[0:18:40] did stand out a bit compared to the other bits.
[0:18:42] Yeah.
[0:18:43] The project came in under budget, so we're all happy for that and we're ready to move forward.
[0:18:50] The contractor is a reputable contractor and checking with suppliers and the people that
[0:18:55] supplied it will, he did come highly recommended.
[0:18:58] Thank you.
[0:19:00] I appreciate that.
[0:19:01] Okay.
[0:19:02] And I'm a- I'm a- I'm a- I'm a- I'm a- I'm a- I'm a- I'm a- I'm a- I'm a- I'm a- I'm a- I'm a- I'm a- I'm a- I'm a- I'm a- I'm a- I'm a- I'm a- I'm a- I'm a- I'm a- I'm a- I'm a- I'm a- I'm a- I'm a- I'm a- I'm a- I'm a- I'm a- I'm a- I'm a- I'm a- I'm a- I'm a- I'm a- I'm a- I'm a- I'm a- I'm a- I'm a- I'm a- I'm a- I'm a- I'm a- I'm a- I'm a- I'm a- I'm a- I'm a- I'm a- I'm a- I'm a- I'm
[0:19:32] Is it a new technique?
[0:19:34] Is it a proven technique?
[0:19:35] Do you know about this technique?
[0:19:36] It's a proven technique that they've
[0:19:38] used on airports throughout the nation and international.
[0:19:44] And so what we're doing in Twin Falls and in this region
[0:19:50] is fairly new to this region, but it's
[0:19:52] been used throughout the country routinely.
[0:19:55] We're just kind of the first guinea pig,
[0:19:58] or the first one in Idaho anyway.
[0:20:01] Yeah, choose your words.
[0:20:02] Yeah.
[0:20:03] It's not new to everybody.
[0:20:05] I get it.
[0:20:06] I get it.
[0:20:07] Perfect.
[0:20:08] Thank you very much.
[0:20:09] Also, it's a little in our stream.
[0:20:10] I don't think we give our many bids from construction companies out of New York.
[0:20:15] That's a good idea.
[0:20:17] First.
[0:20:18] Yeah.
[0:20:19] That surprised me as well.
[0:20:20] But it was a good project and we look forward to it.
[0:20:24] Kind of a timing is what we and Bill and I worked on this quite a bit and maybe just
[0:20:29] to go away with a little bit, but the timing of this
[0:20:32] is happening in September, and we push that back
[0:20:35] just to try to coordinate with the airport
[0:20:37] and try to bring out that together to give you the time
[0:20:40] to catch a breath and go through your runway shutdown
[0:20:44] for 48 hours and all that stuff.
[0:20:45] So I think it's been well put together and well timed out,
[0:20:49] and I think that is also part of what you'll see
[0:20:51] in the price benefit there too.
[0:20:53] So it's not a rush now, now, now, but.
[0:20:55] All right, all right, thank you.
[0:20:57] Are you ready for motion?
[0:21:00] Mayor, I would move the approval of the FAAI-P 34 2013 pavement slurry seal project to straight
[0:21:08] stripe painting ink in the amount of $378,690 contingent upon the available funds and concurrence
[0:21:17] of the Federal Aviation Administration.
[0:21:20] Second.
[0:21:21] Second.
[0:21:24] Then moved by Don Hall and seconded by Rebecca Milsoyka.
[0:21:27] Then we approve the project as outline to us
[0:21:30] and to the lowest responsive bidder.
[0:21:33] It's pretty straight.
[0:21:34] Seeing all the additional lights, we have a roll call.
[0:21:37] Rebecca Milsoyka?
[0:21:39] Yes.
[0:21:40] Chris Tockington?
[0:21:40] Yes.
[0:21:41] Sean Berriger?
[0:21:42] Yes.
[0:21:43] Don Hall?
[0:21:43] Yes.
[0:21:44] Season Hawkins?
[0:21:45] Yes.
[0:21:46] Greg Lanting?
[0:21:47] Yes.
[0:21:47] Jim Mun?
[0:21:48] Yes.
[0:21:49] Motion passes seven to zero.
[0:21:55] to item number three, which is the, excuse me,
[0:22:00] item number F3.
[0:22:04] Yeah, it's not going to come up here.
[0:22:05] Presentation, City Manager, followed by citizen input
[0:22:08] and a possible general discussion
[0:22:09] about the fiscal year, 2014 budget priorities
[0:22:13] and philosophies.
[0:22:16] That was Rothwiler.
[0:22:17] Well, Mr. Mayor, members of the council, good evening.
[0:22:19] And this is already our third conversation
[0:22:23] that we've had in the development of the budget.
[0:22:26] And as we continue to move forward and have a conversation
[0:22:29] of the budget, this is a new step.
[0:22:31] This is a step that the council suggested,
[0:22:34] and that as you get thinking about it,
[0:22:38] involving the citizens on that front end of that process
[0:22:40] really does make a lot of sense.
[0:22:42] And so hopefully tonight you'll see that engagement.
[0:22:46] And citizens take advantage of this opportunity.
[0:22:48] And it's something that as we've reviewed our budget philosophy,
[0:22:51] it was something that we will continue to incorporate
[0:22:53] in the years moving forward.
[0:22:56] You'll also notice that there are department leaders here
[0:22:59] this evening, and the department leaders also played
[0:23:02] a different role in our budgeting process this year,
[0:23:05] unlike any other year in our past,
[0:23:07] and we'll also talk about what that looks like.
[0:23:10] All in the idea of really transforming
[0:23:12] our budgeting process.
[0:23:15] So I want this to be a habit.
[0:23:18] Every time that we talk about doing something
[0:23:20] in our organization, every time we talk about
[0:23:22] strategic plan every time we talk about policies, changes, finances. I hope that we can always
[0:23:29] draw back to our mission statement because it is our mission statement that should be
[0:23:34] the governing collection of thoughts and ideas that should promote us as an organization moving
[0:23:41] forward. This is just really quick but it is a discussion of why do we budget. Aside from
[0:23:50] being a legal step, it is one of those ways that we allocate all of the scariest resources
[0:23:56] that we have. And oftentimes, it is to ensure that we are applying those dollars to projects
[0:24:02] that we believe to be the most important in our organizational philosophies, that we go
[0:24:09] through really a prioritization. And one of the things that all of these department leaders
[0:24:13] need to be credited on is that when we go forward and have conversations and robust conversations
[0:24:18] about the budget that we had this year.
[0:24:21] There weren't a lot of wants.
[0:24:23] There was a large discussion about needs.
[0:24:26] And where do we draw the line in our ability
[0:24:28] to fund certain projects and tasks?
[0:24:32] And where do we have to program projects
[0:24:37] for upcoming years to fit with and available resources?
[0:24:40] We want to make sure that the costs
[0:24:41] that we're providing the services is palatable
[0:24:43] and affordable by our citizens.
[0:24:45] We want to make sure that we are optimizing
[0:24:47] our service delivery techniques.
[0:24:48] And so in our budgeting process and through a series of performance measurement we will
[0:24:52] review how do we deliver those services, we started this year to ask the question, what
[0:24:58] are we doing and is it something that we need to continue to do.
[0:25:03] And then also it's one of those things that the scope and the value of the services that
[0:25:07] we provide are really impacted by our city.
[0:25:11] The impacts really felt by our citizens as we move forward.
[0:25:15] So you'll notice that we are redesigning our approach, that as we look at this, we're
[0:25:22] trying to make sure that the citizens are engaged, that we don't want to go through a process
[0:25:27] that we start with justifying last year's expense and say that is the base and that we
[0:25:32] will continue to build upon that.
[0:25:34] That we begin the process of really looking at what are the priorities of the organization
[0:25:41] And what are the performances that we have set as the expectation for the fiscal year?
[0:25:47] So we start looking at those inputs.
[0:25:49] And then from that input, it goes into our process.
[0:25:53] The process is involved with the conversations that we have here, the conversations that we
[0:25:57] have with our citizens, the conversations that occur through Citizen Survey's strategic plan.
[0:26:04] All of that is embodied in the process, which then has an output.
[0:26:09] And the output is the delivery of that service.
[0:26:12] And then what we do is how do we measure the outcome?
[0:26:15] Did it realize, help us realize the direction we were going?
[0:26:19] And are we able to achieve the results moving forward?
[0:26:23] So from this, from this new approach, we believe that we are going to be able to better engage
[0:26:30] our citizens.
[0:26:31] So tonight is a first for us in our organization and really on several levels.
[0:26:37] It's our third conversation about the budget, and it's the second week in June.
[0:26:43] In the past, we began our first conversation about the budget in the second week of July.
[0:26:50] So there's a lot more emphasis, and this tonight is the first time that we've actively
[0:26:55] solicited the opinions of our citizens on the front end of our budget process, as opposed
[0:27:00] to waiting for the public hearing conversation.
[0:27:04] It's an opportunity to better engage our employees.
[0:27:07] In the past, we would have a conversation with the CFO, the city manager, the budget coordinator,
[0:27:16] and the department leader for every single budget would come in, and we would have a conversation
[0:27:20] about their respective services in their operating silos.
[0:27:26] This year, we brought all of the tax-supported players together, and we had a conversation
[0:27:32] about the direction moving forward collectively as an organization.
[0:27:38] You know, we really thought that this would bring some common sense and approach to budgeting.
[0:27:42] And as I shared many times that if I were the one that we're just singly balancing the budget,
[0:27:49] you would see things in here that I may not necessarily subscribe to.
[0:27:54] But I will tell you because of all of the inputs that we've had from the senior management team
[0:27:59] and the department leaders, I believe that we have a much better, more thoughtful approach
[0:28:04] to allocating our resources than had we in the past when I was just operating in my own
[0:28:10] little vacuum.
[0:28:11] It gives us the opportunity to put more people around the table to say how are we thinking
[0:28:18] strategically and what synergies can we develop amongst the departments.
[0:28:23] One of the examples we shared in the process was every time that we're laying a water
[0:28:28] or sewer line. We should be looking at the importance of laying fiber optic. And we should
[0:28:33] be looking at laying that fiber optic because we use MDCs in our patrol cars. And if we can
[0:28:41] save $50 a month for every wireless card, air card connection, what is the long term savings?
[0:28:50] What is that reliability? How do we get Wi-Fi throughout our community in key targeted locations?
[0:28:58] It starts by having the infrastructure available, it starts by planning that in advance.
[0:29:04] And so when you're looking at a water line, it's now saying, how can we benefit the police
[0:29:09] department and all other departments by having an exposed trench?
[0:29:14] So really it begins to really align all of our resources because we're talking, we're
[0:29:20] communicating, we're moving forward collectively.
[0:29:23] Which is the last bullet.
[0:29:26] through this process, maybe through greater participation and collaboration, we can transform
[0:29:31] our government the way we think our approach and ultimately we might be able to do our part
[0:29:38] as articulated in the strategic plan to transform our community.
[0:29:44] So this also has a deep alignment with our strategic plan. We made the commitment as staff
[0:29:52] that as we started that year long dialogue that this would not be a document that we
[0:29:58] would just put on the shelf. And so this budget does begin the process of incorporating the
[0:30:05] priority one and the ongoing parts of the strategic plan. Upon our review, as we look
[0:30:13] forward in having a future conversation about the strategic plan, we may have bit off a
[0:30:19] little bit more than we can chew.
[0:30:22] Apparently so.
[0:30:23] And a new fiber optic.
[0:30:27] That was operator error.
[0:30:29] That was the connection coming.
[0:30:31] That was all me.
[0:30:32] I can't even blame my friends if I ask for that one.
[0:30:35] That was me.
[0:30:38] But it will give us the opportunity to maybe review how we're doing in that first line and
[0:30:43] that first approach.
[0:30:44] And what we said is we expect the strategic plan to be a fluid living document that it
[0:30:49] will allow us to change priorities, adjust priorities based upon operating realities.
[0:30:59] So this is a graphic of how everything ties together.
[0:31:04] There's our mission.
[0:31:05] There are our seven or external objectives, our one internal objective that creates the
[0:31:13] overall vision that also calls out having partners and the budget process is laid down
[0:31:20] at the bottom.
[0:31:21] The city departments engage in the conversation collectively, we establish goals and processes,
[0:31:26] we establish those key objectives and we describe what we're going to do in the strategic plan,
[0:31:30] we implement that as a part of a budget, and we assess how we're doing.
[0:31:38] So this is really the roadmap.
[0:31:40] And in having the conversation like anything new on the day before, the members of the City
[0:31:45] Senior Management Team got together and we started to craft this out.
[0:31:50] And this is what was born.
[0:31:52] And when you look at this and you dive into it, this is truly really good work by the members
[0:31:59] of your management team.
[0:32:01] Because on the top of how we set our priorities was the primary mission of advancing the strategic
[0:32:06] planning priorities that we have set for this organization.
[0:32:10] And under that are the fiscal year outcomes.
[0:32:12] And we were able to take the eight overarching priorities of the organization and break them
[0:32:19] into three guiding statements for this upcoming budget.
[0:32:23] The first is the right people, the right tool, the right places.
[0:32:28] It really talks about the need to make sure that our employees are in the right seats,
[0:32:34] that we are able to attract and retain quality folks moving forward, that we are investing
[0:32:39] in our facilities.
[0:32:41] Protect public health and public safety is probably one of the cardinal reasons why cities
[0:32:46] These are formed, police, fire, water, sewer, sanitation.
[0:32:55] So under that we have a healthy community, a secure community, accessible environmental
[0:32:59] community, a responsible community.
[0:33:03] And then the next is really maintaining our infrastructure.
[0:33:06] It is that fabric that creates our community, so it's a learning community and a prosperous
[0:33:11] community.
[0:33:12] All eight of the strategic planning objectives fit within this first.
[0:33:18] And then we started asking the questions, what do we have to do?
[0:33:26] And we looked at what do we want to do?
[0:33:28] And we asked that by comparing that list of things that we have to do and we want to do
[0:33:35] with our citizens' expectations.
[0:33:38] As public servants, it's our role to serve them.
[0:33:42] And so we looked at how do they think we're doing?
[0:33:46] Why are we doing it?
[0:33:48] How are we going to get there?
[0:33:49] And you'll notice that we focused on the on-goings, we focused on the priority one elements as
[0:33:55] well as the priority one and them combined.
[0:34:00] And then we've looked, and if we built a litmus test in the triangle off to the side, it really
[0:34:05] describes how are we providing for the basic needs.
[0:34:08] Is the cost and benefit of the services provided meritorious of the level of funding that we're
[0:34:14] looking at moving forward, and then is their value.
[0:34:18] This single sheet was the driving force, and hopefully will always, as it continues to
[0:34:26] be perfected, will be the single place and driving force of our overall budget.
[0:34:34] So as we continue to go forward, we have established key budget drivers, and those key
[0:34:39] budget drivers were established in the prior two meetings.
[0:34:43] We said that we finally defined a way in a vehicle to implement the goals of the strategic
[0:34:47] plan.
[0:34:48] And you'll notice back on this sheet that the strategic planning priorities are the first
[0:34:55] and foremost important item on that list.
[0:34:58] That we want to be recognized and we want to be sensitive to limiting tax increases
[0:35:02] to the 3% of the growth formula, that we recognize the sensitivity of increasing our
[0:35:07] water rates, our sewer rates, and our sanitation rates, especially after what occurred with
[0:35:13] the voter approval of our bond.
[0:35:16] We wanted to be sensitive to make sure that we weren't burdening our citizens with rates
[0:35:22] that were not for projects, that were not absolutely critically needed.
[0:35:26] And we'll share a little bit tonight where we're at on this.
[0:35:30] We want to make sure that we implemented Phase 2 of the City's Compensation Strategy.
[0:35:35] We wanted to make sure that we were right-sized and we also want to make sure that we are staffed
[0:35:42] appropriately in key areas of our organization.
[0:35:46] that we want to continue to develop funding solutions,
[0:35:49] to maintain the city's infrastructure,
[0:35:51] including water sewer transportation parks,
[0:35:53] and our operating facilities.
[0:35:56] We wanted to continue to explore options and opportunities
[0:35:58] to ensure that our water system is reliable,
[0:36:02] especially after some of the experiences
[0:36:04] that we had over the course of the last couple of years.
[0:36:08] And as always, we want to make sure
[0:36:11] that we are continuing to strive
[0:36:13] for better, more efficient, effective outcomes.
[0:36:18] That's how we built the budget.
[0:36:21] So then we will, if you will,
[0:36:23] we'll go into the lab and we'll cover economic trends.
[0:36:26] And these are some of the interesting national statistics
[0:36:29] that you use as where are we at
[0:36:31] and where are we going as a nation.
[0:36:33] And what you'll see in March is house prices have began
[0:36:36] to climb to their highest rates
[0:36:40] that we've seen in a long time.
[0:36:41] That job growth is beginning to strengthen,
[0:36:44] that we're starting to see signs of improvement
[0:36:47] the economy and unemployment in the 20 largest cities in the country fell in the month of
[0:36:51] April. That stocks are beginning to rocket upward, right? And that consumer confidence
[0:36:58] was significantly higher and grew more than by comparison to where it had been and that
[0:37:04] it is its highest level since February of 2008. February 2008 is really important because that
[0:37:11] begins almost the marking of the US recession period.
[0:37:16] So people feel a little more optimistic,
[0:37:20] and that optimism is validated by true signs
[0:37:25] of strengthening US economy.
[0:37:27] But what does that mean locally?
[0:37:29] Let's take that and not only compare the state,
[0:37:31] but the state believes that unemployment growth on non-farm
[0:37:35] it will grow by 2% in 2013 and by 2.7% in 2014.
[0:37:41] So the state's economist is projecting that we'll see continued job growth within our area.
[0:37:46] And the City of Twin Falls' unemployment rate has continued to decline.
[0:37:52] And especially if you look where we were at last year at 7.3, now we're at 5.8, full employment
[0:37:58] in our area is 5%.
[0:38:01] That is the new national defined full employment.
[0:38:08] We also took a look at where we at in terms of building construction activity.
[0:38:12] is one of those things moving forward.
[0:38:16] I did some internal projecting of where I think that will be.
[0:38:19] The last year we did 151 single family homes this year.
[0:38:22] I believe based upon current data and following last year's
[0:38:25] trends, we might be about 190, or some point slightly less.
[0:38:29] After I got Mays numbers, it was a little bit different,
[0:38:31] but still very, very strong.
[0:38:35] And very, very strong also in the commercial,
[0:38:37] that if you take a look at the total number of permits
[0:38:39] and the value of the permits that we've
[0:38:41] issued in this fiscal year by comparison to last year, we've grown and we've significantly
[0:38:46] grown in the area of commercial. So here's the number of permits that have been issued.
[0:38:50] You can see that we're at 104 through April, or excuse me, through May and we're going
[0:38:55] to begin that process and that ramp up of considerable construction. You'll notice that
[0:39:00] the number of commercial permits on this sheet is significantly increased, where in
[0:39:06] And last year we did eight, and in this year we've done 23, and that we know of several
[0:39:13] projects that have not been issued plans or building permits that will only add to that
[0:39:20] list and add to the value of the community.
[0:39:25] Dwayne and his team are incredibly busy, and we're starting to see a lot more effort
[0:39:32] and energy taking place in the building trades as well as the areas of planning and zoning.
[0:39:39] And we also wanted to take a look at what is the cost of doing business.
[0:39:41] And as we shared with you, the cost of doing business has increased over the course of
[0:39:46] the year, about 1.9%.
[0:39:48] And since 2008, the total cost of doing business in government has gone up by about 12.1.
[0:39:56] We use the MCI, which is described as the Municipal Cost Index.
[0:40:01] It is a measure of the basket of goods that we often procure as a public sector entity.
[0:40:09] And it is very similar to that of a consumer price index, and the consumer price index for
[0:40:15] the same period of time has also gone up by 1%.
[0:40:20] So we take that information and we build where the budget is today.
[0:40:28] So the first thing that we are pleased to report is I got to maybe back up for a second.
[0:40:37] All of the information that we're presenting to you is subject to change, right?
[0:40:42] I mean, it's always subject to change.
[0:40:45] And one of the reasons on our taxable value is subject to change is because that is the
[0:40:49] number that is provided to us by the county assessor's office, pre your opportunity to
[0:40:55] go appeal your value.
[0:40:57] So if the county commissioners through the Board of Equalization allows for some adjustments
[0:41:02] as petitioned by homeowners or businesses, that number is subject to change.
[0:41:09] But the total value of the assessments that were mailed out by the assessor's office has
[0:41:15] grown by nearly $186 million by comparison to last year, putting the city's total taxable
[0:41:22] value at $2,337 or $338 million, which is about an 8.6% growth.
[0:41:32] We've noticed that and we believe in our conversations that all phases of property, residential,
[0:41:38] commercial, and industrial, either remain the same or then more likely all went up in value.
[0:41:46] And the other side is the homeowner's exemption decreased.
[0:41:49] The homeowner's exemption is dictated by the Idaho Tax Commission and it is indexed based
[0:41:55] upon housing sales across the state and may assign an average of all values in the state
[0:42:01] to be reduced and so therefore the homeowners exemption this year is 50% or $81,000 whichever
[0:42:09] is less. So if that number is accurate and we look at the impact of the tax rate because
[0:42:16] the tax rate is a mathematical product. It is not something that we directly set. It is
[0:42:22] something that takes the value and then we divide government spending into the value and
[0:42:29] do you get the total tax rate for the city.
[0:42:31] In the tax rate of the city, we are projecting about a 4.1%
[0:42:35] decrease based upon what we have in the budget so far
[0:42:38] and what we believe to be the taxable value is received
[0:42:41] by the assessor's office.
[0:42:42] And therefore, our tax rate in the city of Twin Falls
[0:42:45] will decrease from $7.71 to $7.40.
[0:42:50] The growth formula that we provided here as part of that
[0:42:55] grew, the city grew by $25.6 million, that's going to produce about $197,000 of new tax revenue
[0:43:04] by taking the growth formula. And the new construction net value was listed below so you
[0:43:13] can see that the annexation is, the annexation this year is generally described as insignificant.
[0:43:21] We wanted to graphically illustrate how the rise and the fall, if you will, of the homeowners
[0:43:28] exemption.
[0:43:29] Again, this is not something that we have any control over, but we wanted to make sure
[0:43:33] that you saw where that has gone.
[0:43:37] What we believe is because of what we've seen here, this significant increase in twin
[0:43:41] falls values, it impacts us two ways.
[0:43:43] Number one, we believe that the homeowners exemption next year based upon what's occurring
[0:43:47] in twin falls, and probably other states, will increase.
[0:43:51] The other thing is that because our values have grown and what we would be led to believe
[0:43:57] may be higher than other communities, that our state shared revenues should be disproportionately
[0:44:03] larger than what it was this year by comparison to others.
[0:44:07] Because it is a formula based upon community value and community census.
[0:44:11] And since both are growing and not all places, especially those larger than us are, we could
[0:44:17] to see additional revenues in the areas of state shared revenues, we did not incorporate
[0:44:23] those in here.
[0:44:24] We incorporated some increases based upon where we stand this year, but maybe not the
[0:44:30] full impact of our growth.
[0:44:32] So we describe this as the really the way to early highlights, and we describe that because
[0:44:37] it's really preliminary, right?
[0:44:39] It's subject to change.
[0:44:43] And it's important to lay out where we stand, and then as the data gets better, we can
[0:44:48] perfect it and move forward.
[0:44:50] So again, we're only taking the 3% and the growth form though.
[0:44:54] We did not incorporate any portion of the city's foregone balance.
[0:44:57] It remains intact.
[0:44:59] If you took the entire foregone balance, you don't have to take the entire foregone balance.
[0:45:03] You could take a dollar of it if you wanted to.
[0:45:06] But if you wanted to take the entire foregone balance, it would cause an increase in the
[0:45:11] tax rate to eight dollars and three cents. We wanted to present that because part of this
[0:45:17] budget is we're also not just sharing with you this year what we're doing. In my budget
[0:45:23] message we're going to share with you what we're not. And at some point in time you may
[0:45:27] feel that those things where we drew the line where we're not able to fund is of a significant
[0:45:34] priority for the community. And so we want to make sure that we as staff are keeping all
[0:45:39] all of your funding options open as we move forward.
[0:45:43] We're seeing increases in building permit revenues.
[0:45:46] Again, state shared revenues will increase,
[0:45:48] and we're also seeing increases in franchise fees.
[0:45:51] Excuse me, Travis, would you restate the figure
[0:45:53] with the foregone amount, what the rate would be?
[0:45:56] It would be $8.03 per thousand in value.
[0:45:59] The current tax rate is $7.71.
[0:46:03] If you only took the growth formula
[0:46:06] and the new in the 3% statutory,
[0:46:08] It would be $7.40, so it's 63% of difference.
[0:46:14] Thank you.
[0:46:16] The franchise fee is a bit of good news,
[0:46:20] but bad news on the back end, right?
[0:46:22] So we get a portion of the sales of electricity
[0:46:27] from Idaho Power.
[0:46:28] And as they increase their rates, we get more revenue.
[0:46:33] But as they increase rates, we pay a lot more money
[0:46:38] in electrical bills, especially in water and sewer funds.
[0:46:42] So we'll talk about that.
[0:46:44] We're seeing decreased revenues in court funds
[0:46:47] as compared to what we had estimated this year.
[0:46:51] We're seeing decrease in investments.
[0:46:54] Lori and I've talked a lot about that
[0:46:57] in the tax-supported funds.
[0:46:58] And it just has to do with our strategies
[0:47:01] in moving forward with having liquidity of assets.
[0:47:04] And then we have several dedicated funds in the street fund that we're not using cash reserves.
[0:47:11] So that we at this point are only anticipating using cash reserves, one-time capital projects
[0:47:16] in the library, Sue Ash is here and she can talk about that philosophy if you like.
[0:47:25] And then we're anticipating again only significant capital projects in the library.
[0:47:32] So we're projecting that personnel expenditures are going to increase in all tech supported
[0:47:36] funds by 712,000 or about 4.12 percent.
[0:47:41] And that has to do with the implementation of the Phase 2 plan.
[0:47:45] We're also looking at increases in health insurance.
[0:47:49] That number came in and we have tasked Susan Harris and Gretchen and they've started the
[0:47:56] process of negotiating what that looks like.
[0:47:58] We're also looking at are there other health options like becoming partially self-insurance.
[0:48:03] So they're also investigating that to ensure that the rate that is being assessed to us is
[0:48:10] something that is sustainable in the long-term future, but we also recognize that health care
[0:48:14] is one of those critical components of our overall comprehensive health care plan.
[0:48:19] We also have money in the budget for new positions.
[0:48:22] I say two police officers, but it's the funding for two police officers.
[0:48:27] One of them would be offset with assistance from the school district for SRO,
[0:48:31] And the other would be that we have applied for a federal COPS grant and that we will get
[0:48:36] four officers for the price of one in this fiscal year.
[0:48:39] And then every year you slowly begin to pay more into that.
[0:48:44] So every year on a four-year system we would buy another officer out of our budget.
[0:48:49] And so this does create a liability for us as an organization.
[0:48:53] But it does allow us to get more officers on the street in a very, very cost effective
[0:48:59] way.
[0:49:00] cops grants in the past, and then Councilman Munn can attest to the effectiveness of that,
[0:49:06] but we really looked at the number of police officers that we have on the street and moving
[0:49:11] forward.
[0:49:12] And we're not looking at ratios.
[0:49:14] What we're doing is we're looking to make sure that we're supplying the total service
[0:49:19] community, the community that we service, excuse me, effectively.
[0:49:24] And I think as the City of Twin Falls continues to look and move forward, we have to forget
[0:49:30] about our census numbers.
[0:49:33] Because our daily census on a daily basis is what we service.
[0:49:37] It's 70 plus thousand people a day come into our community
[0:49:43] and that we need to have the human and the capital resources
[0:49:47] to be able to service them.
[0:49:48] Because if someone like me who still lives
[0:49:52] in another community, not by choice, gets into a car wreck,
[0:50:02] It's the taxpayers of the city of Twin Falls
[0:50:06] who are going to pay the salary and wages
[0:50:08] of those who are going to respond.
[0:50:11] And we don't have any other real options,
[0:50:14] but we want to make sure that the level
[0:50:16] of service we're providing does not deteriorate
[0:50:19] because of the significant increase moving forward.
[0:50:23] We have a question Chris talking about.
[0:50:25] Travis, I want to make sure, and I would guess,
[0:50:27] most accounts would agree that if we're able
[0:50:30] to acquire these four extra cops in an SRO with the federal money or whatever combination.
[0:50:37] I guess it's more of a question, how can we restore insurance that they're going to be
[0:50:41] on the street instead of pushing papers behind a desk?
[0:50:46] What insurance are you going to have?
[0:50:47] Have you even achieved, figured this out?
[0:50:54] We want more tooth and less tail whenever possible.
[0:50:57] Councilman talking to do these would be line personnel and we have the same approach
[0:51:02] We would have a lean and and really have maintained a lean management team
[0:51:07] These would be positions that would be put forth in the community. So that's your bias as well. That is our plan. Good. Thanks
[0:51:15] In addition to you'll also grant writer in there. That was one of the positions that was described during our conversation
[0:51:23] We provided funding for that we provided assistance for
[0:51:26] or administrative staff person in the engineering department.
[0:51:30] That is not a new position to our organization.
[0:51:32] It's one that we eliminated funding
[0:51:34] when the building economy declined.
[0:51:37] We're seeing significant increases in workload
[0:51:39] and activity, especially in the engineering department.
[0:51:42] And frankly, they're struggling.
[0:51:43] And it's one of those things that by making sure
[0:51:46] that we have the engineers to have the support resources
[0:51:49] to help them be successful,
[0:51:50] like we provide any other department.
[0:51:53] It's important, especially when you look
[0:51:55] the level of activity that our department's moving forward.
[0:51:58] The building plan's examiner, we talked about that.
[0:52:00] That is the position that we passed the plan's review fee,
[0:52:04] and that plan's review fee has a dedicated revenue source
[0:52:07] to assist with the funding of that.
[0:52:09] And then we're looking at upgrading some other positions
[0:52:11] in the organization.
[0:52:14] Projection and increases for operating expenses.
[0:52:17] This is probably the single largest area
[0:52:20] across the organization that sees double-digit increases.
[0:52:25] And we love our friends at Idaho Power, but really, as you see this,
[0:52:30] the significant increases anywhere between 16.8 and 22%, depending upon your classification
[0:52:36] of user, that impacts us significantly.
[0:52:40] And so in these funds right here, you're noticing that 10.66% is operational cost.
[0:52:47] The single largest factor by far across our budget is the impact that the cost
[0:52:53] of electricity has in our organization,
[0:52:56] and it is incredibly apparent of what that looks like
[0:53:00] in our water and sewer funds.
[0:53:03] Contractive professional services is another one,
[0:53:06] but its increase really pales in comparison
[0:53:09] by what the impacts of the electrical are,
[0:53:12] and we're anticipating this year
[0:53:13] that fuel will remain about constant.
[0:53:20] We're looking at adding additional monies
[0:53:22] in the tax-supported capital funds.
[0:53:24] We're looking at having about $5.77 million,
[0:53:28] and we just kind of highlighted some of that laundry list.
[0:53:31] That laundry list is really, really big.
[0:53:34] And we'll be presenting that to you, obviously,
[0:53:37] what that looks like as we perfect it moving forward.
[0:53:40] But we're looking at national citizen surveys,
[0:53:42] time to do that.
[0:53:43] We're looking at technology upgrades,
[0:53:45] we're looking at making sure that we're doing
[0:53:47] vehicle replacements, we're making sure
[0:53:49] that we're doing things like LED lighting, right?
[0:53:52] Trying to become more efficient.
[0:53:53] So I wanted to give a small sampling.
[0:53:55] But we do have the entire laundry list of capital projects.
[0:53:57] There are spread out.
[0:53:59] We've allocated money for the community guard.
[0:54:01] We've allocated money for the dog park.
[0:54:04] Right Dennis?
[0:54:06] Yeah, we've allocated money for helping create better defined
[0:54:12] bike route systems within our community.
[0:54:15] So we have, just not shared here, just laundry list of
[0:54:19] capital stuff that we have been moving forward.
[0:54:22] What's important and what's not in that number, but would be added to, is $2.1 million for
[0:54:28] Chaney Drive.
[0:54:29] You're going to talk about that later this evening.
[0:54:31] It's funded and it is more passed through federal dollars, very, very similar to the airport
[0:54:37] construction projects of about 1.16.
[0:54:39] So those numbers added to the 5.7 is where you begin to get the total tax-supported funding
[0:54:48] on capital projects.
[0:54:49] Laurie has a blank that she's going to fill in for me real quickly.
[0:55:02] So I think the blank is filled in right back here.
[0:55:14] So basically what we're looking at is what amounts to a 4% rate increase in the water
[0:55:19] fund this year.
[0:55:22] And what's important to recognize is 3% of the 4% or 75% of the total adjustment is used
[0:55:30] to cover the power increase.
[0:55:33] One percent of the entire budget moving forward covers capital.
[0:55:40] In fact, you'll notice here that we are decreasing the amount of incoming revenue that we're applying
[0:55:48] to capital projects and using cash reserves to ensure that the rate that we're presenting
[0:55:54] to our citizens is palatable.
[0:55:58] So we have cash reserves and at some point it's appropriate to use cash reserves for your
[0:56:04] projects, right?
[0:56:05] But you can't build a long-term sustainable budget on using cash reserves.
[0:56:11] Now obviously, power rate increases fluctuate, and maybe we'll have a more robust winter.
[0:56:20] We don't like a lot of winter, right?
[0:56:23] But we really do need the water for the hydro plants to ensure that as that power cost adjustment
[0:56:28] comes in, it's one that maybe goes down.
[0:56:32] So rather than applying more money to operational costs, we're applying more money to asset
[0:56:40] development.
[0:56:41] So it's $1.43 per month for the average user defined as someone using 18,000.
[0:56:51] I have a slide at the back that illustrates what is the comprehensive rate adjustment.
[0:56:58] So then the sewer fund.
[0:56:59] We all know that the citizens voted by a margin of almost 70 to 30 to pass a revenue bond that
[0:57:08] will allow for the expansion of the city's waste water treatment facility as well as make improvements to our collection line system.
[0:57:17] And we're looking at a total increase in this budget of about 29% over this year, which is $5.60.
[0:57:24] $5.21 is for the voter-approved bond, 2%, or $0.39 per month, is to support all other
[0:57:33] operations and primarily, again, power cost adjustments.
[0:57:42] And that when we talk about the 29% total rate increase, it's important to remember that
[0:57:47] we are reflecting the impact here to our residential customer.
[0:57:51] The impact to our industrial customers and others is proportionately the same.
[0:57:55] They will see roughly a 29% adjustment as currently placed into the budget in their cost
[0:58:02] of doing business and operating.
[0:58:04] As you recall when we went through that process of looking at selling a bond, not selling a
[0:58:10] bond, but creating a committee and then presenting information, sewer costs in the city of Twin
[0:58:16] falls are significantly lower than those costs that are paid for by communities all around
[0:58:23] us.
[0:58:24] In fact, the city of Tumfals remains one of the most competitive when it comes to total
[0:58:31] sewer bills by any standard.
[0:58:34] You'll notice that the capital funds in this budget also do slightly decrease, but that
[0:58:42] excludes $38 million of investments that we're going to be making into our system.
[0:58:49] And so there are some projects that may have been contemplated without passage of the bond,
[0:58:53] that kind of go away with the passage of the bond.
[0:58:57] And then we're still very much in conversation with PSI.
[0:59:00] But in my conversation with PSI, I shared with them what the MCI was.
[0:59:05] And I said, we might be hard pressed for anything much more than that.
[0:59:09] And I also shared with them that I wanted to see the rate that they were passing
[0:59:12] on to all of the customers because Halloween garbage is probably has a lot of the same similar
[0:59:17] fixed costs. And so I've asked also for a survey of the rate adjustments that other
[0:59:21] communities at PSI services for that information. But if let's just say, and we took the 1.9%,
[0:59:30] it translates into a 31 cent per month increase in sanitation.
[0:59:37] So this is what an average sewer bill for our citizens would look like. The fiscal year
[0:59:41] Budget is illustrated in the first column by 2013 with the rate resolution and you'll see that it's $71.65.
[0:59:51] The fully burdened cost under the current rate adjustments and totality equals $78.99 for our average user.
[1:00:00] Our average user uses 18,000 gallons of water per month.
[1:00:04] We cap sewer at 8,000 gallons per month. That's a hard cap for residents.
[1:00:08] And then the sanitation is a fixed fee that we pay.
[1:00:12] In that fixed fee, you'll also notice that it has
[1:00:15] the tipping fee and all of those other fees.
[1:00:18] And so when residents look at the cost of sanitation
[1:00:20] and Twin Falls, it's important to remember
[1:00:23] that we pay per ton in Twin Falls.
[1:00:25] There's one other county that does.
[1:00:27] All of the other counties pay that on the property tax
[1:00:30] assessment, residents in Twin Falls will not see that.
[1:00:33] So the difference is $7.34.
[1:00:36] If you reduce the bond, if you strip out the bond,
[1:00:40] to put it in comparison sake, the monthly increase is $2.13
[1:00:45] or 2.97%.
[1:00:51] And you'll see that we struggled to get there.
[1:00:54] And in all candiness, I can't tell you
[1:00:57] what we're doing is sustainable.
[1:01:01] It is certainly palatable for a year.
[1:01:05] But when you look at the impact to the water fund
[1:01:08] And how we are spending more cash reserves than we have to support critical capital components
[1:01:14] to assist with water redundancy.
[1:01:17] We just didn't believe that that additional $800,000 could be absorbed into the rate.
[1:01:22] Because I think it's about $60,000, translates into a single percent.
[1:01:29] And so to cover that capital cost, in addition to everything else, you're looking at a 15%
[1:01:37] rate adjustment where we could use cash reserves.
[1:01:41] We felt it prudent this year to use cash reserves, but we wanted to share with you that we didn't
[1:01:46] think that that is something that is sustainable long-term.
[1:01:52] So this is kind of what the tax rate looks like by comparison.
[1:01:55] This is the side-by-side comparison of this year and last year.
[1:01:59] We illustrate the total size of the budget and you'll see that it's grown significantly.
[1:02:06] But over $3 million is new debt service associated with the wastewater treatment plant bond that
[1:02:12] we anticipate that we will make our first payment in the upcoming 2014 fiscal year.
[1:02:19] So the rest of that, when you start looking at where the monies are coming from, you can
[1:02:23] see that it's definitely in those enterprise funds.
[1:02:28] It's also important to note that Chibani will be a full year on to the system, and so
[1:02:33] we're seeing additional revenues associated with that as well.
[1:02:38] Is the money flow through CSI in there as well?
[1:02:42] Yes, the money flowing through CSI is an additional 2.1 million as well.
[1:02:46] And the airport.
[1:02:47] The airport flow through a 1.1, so.
[1:02:53] Rebecca, I'm going to second.
[1:02:55] Thank you, Mayor.
[1:02:56] So this total taxable value, 7.4, that would include the growth
[1:03:03] of the 3% statutory increase.
[1:03:04] That's everything.
[1:03:05] OK.
[1:03:06] Thank you.
[1:03:11] Yeah, so to come up with a 7.007398 number,
[1:03:20] what we did was we rounded it up in the last one.
[1:03:23] So it's $7.40.
[1:03:24] As you can see, that's what the taxes per thousand are.
[1:03:33] This is a side-by-side comparison of what that looks like.
[1:03:37] Next year, we won't have CSI pass through money,
[1:03:39] at least we don't believe we will.
[1:03:41] But there may be other projects with having a grant writer.
[1:03:44] There might be other federal funds that come in.
[1:03:45] And so it's important to recognize that total spending doesn't necessarily mean that the
[1:03:53] money is being derived directly from our citizens' tax and ratepayers.
[1:04:00] That's where your budget stands today.
[1:04:03] All of the members of the city's senior management team and many, many of the department leaders
[1:04:09] have invested a lot of time in developing this.
[1:04:14] And it was tough.
[1:04:15] It was tough to draw that line.
[1:04:17] all here because we go through a big budget balancing extravaganza meeting later this week.
[1:04:24] Some people look forward to it. Some people really don't.
[1:04:27] Some of it has been nicknamed the Big Tent.
[1:04:32] I, you know, there's probably lots of nicknames for it. That's probably one of the most
[1:04:36] popular brands. I heard the Grand Union from some of them, huh?
[1:04:40] Probably not anymore.
[1:04:46] Oh, it's still bad, but that's where it stands,
[1:04:51] and we'll, you know, staff is available,
[1:04:53] not only to respond to questions that you might have,
[1:04:57] but also to really listen to input from the citizens.
[1:05:01] Because as we go into that meeting,
[1:05:02] we wanna make sure we can either confirm, yes, that's there,
[1:05:06] or no, that's not.
[1:05:08] And as some, and as things come forward from the council.
[1:05:11] Do you have a light, Chris, talk?
[1:05:13] Travis or Susan, I'm not sure who would like to address this.
[1:05:17] if we do in fact implement the phase two
[1:05:20] at the city's comp plan.
[1:05:22] Well, that get us even with last year
[1:05:25] or are we even, we first of all,
[1:05:28] have eliminated our compression, I think,
[1:05:30] in that critical area.
[1:05:32] Is there an ensuing phase three coming up
[1:05:35] or are we in fairly decent shape?
[1:05:37] So what I would describe is-
[1:05:39] So we'll have phase three,
[1:05:42] we should probably really honestly believe
[1:05:47] that we're gonna have a phase four and a phase five and a phase six because every year
[1:05:51] that market may change. And every year that market may be something that we have to look
[1:05:56] at responding to.
[1:05:57] I guess I was responding referring more directly just to the compression.
[1:06:02] We made up incredible ground last year and in looking at just the compression we believe
[1:06:09] that it was solved last year with the strategy that we've incorporated. But it does require
[1:06:15] perpetual funding to move people through the ranks in the system. But really when
[1:06:21] we're looking at part of the system, we're looking at moving the salary table
[1:06:24] about one and a half percent this year, which is significantly lower than the
[1:06:28] eight percent that we moved in last year. So that really describes the amount of
[1:06:33] ground that we made up. One of our challenges though is those that are more
[1:06:38] tenured and senior employees that we have in our organization. They didn't
[1:06:43] benefit from a table movement. And they are the ones that as the economy returns are those
[1:06:49] quality, strong leaders in our organization that are starting to get cherry-picked or people
[1:06:56] are having conversations about as the economy improves. And so we have certain areas of our
[1:07:01] organization that become more susceptible to what that looks like.
[1:07:05] Mayors are a final follow-up if I could then, since we're now in the phase one of the comp
[1:07:11] change. Have we seen the evidence yet that retaining a higher percentage of critical
[1:07:20] positions has turned over a decrease? Has there been any evidence that is working?
[1:07:28] I want my gut tells me yes. Now we've had turnover in our organization and we've had
[1:07:33] turnover in critical areas. Those were not necessarily that turnover was not necessarily
[1:07:39] associated with finding another employment opportunity.
[1:07:43] Some of those turnover actions that occur are a result of disciplinary measures that
[1:07:48] we move forward.
[1:07:51] I think that I got some folks behind me, so hopefully they'll either validate it or they'll
[1:07:56] correct it.
[1:07:57] But I think that it's been said in the police department, it's been said in the fire department,
[1:08:03] it's been said in other areas of our organization that we defined as service and critical, that
[1:08:08] This was a good first step and it was a big first step.
[1:08:11] Probably much more significant than what we thought
[1:08:13] and I would look at Brian.
[1:08:15] I think that Brian would tell you that it was an important
[1:08:17] first step to retain quality officers,
[1:08:19] but also for attraction.
[1:08:20] And I think that Chief Clark would probably say
[1:08:22] the same thing for firemen.
[1:08:24] If it's possible to quantify it this next year,
[1:08:26] if we implement phase two,
[1:08:28] I would hope to expect that we'd have some data-driven evidence
[1:08:33] at the end of maybe 2014.
[1:08:36] Certainly.
[1:08:36] Okay, Rebecca, we're back, I'm going to sell you.
[1:08:39] Thank you, we are just a quick clarifying question.
[1:08:42] You talked about the different positions
[1:08:44] that might be added this year,
[1:08:45] and then said select position upgrades.
[1:08:49] Can you kind of define that better?
[1:08:50] Is it new positions, or what's a position upgrade?
[1:08:53] So we're not necessarily adding FTE,
[1:08:56] but we want to make sure
[1:08:57] that we have the right seats on the bus.
[1:08:59] And so we're going to want to make sure,
[1:09:01] so it's not only the right staffing,
[1:09:03] but it's also the right positions.
[1:09:04] Do we have people in the right roles?
[1:09:06] Are there internal structural changes that we can make within our organizational hierarchy
[1:09:12] that allow us to operate more effectively and more efficiently?
[1:09:15] And so that's what those select position-upgrade thing mean.
[1:09:18] So like reorganization?
[1:09:20] Some reorganization absolutely.
[1:09:21] Some looking at internal processes to make sure that it works better and it's more aligned
[1:09:28] moving forward.
[1:09:29] An example of one of them is we're looking at the possibility of turning a staff sergeant
[1:09:35] the police department into a lieutenant, have two lieutenants work directly under the patrol
[1:09:43] captain to assist with the day-to-day operations of patrol.
[1:09:49] So that staff sergeant position then would become a lieutenant and they would both function under
[1:09:55] Captain Barnard and any other questions specifically what it looks like there's a chief of police that will help me out.
[1:09:59] That would mean that they would also stand on third during the western day.
[1:10:09] That's where Brian put some.
[1:10:10] Okay.
[1:10:11] I'm Brian.
[1:10:13] Alright, we do have time allowed here where we're going to allow time for citizen input.
[1:10:21] If you would like to speak about the budget, we've asked that you sign up in the back.
[1:10:27] So if anybody's here to speak on the budget, would we have a sign up sheet?
[1:10:31] Yes.
[1:10:32] So if you haven't signed up and you would like to,
[1:10:34] if you would, and I'll have Josh bring that up to me
[1:10:37] and I'll call people off.
[1:10:41] And we're gonna give you two minutes.
[1:10:43] Vice Mayor Hall will give you a 30 second time thing
[1:10:48] that lets you know that after 30 seconds,
[1:10:53] when he gives you that you'll have 30 seconds
[1:10:54] to kind of wrap up your thoughts.
[1:10:56] I don't have very many names on here,
[1:10:58] including some of them I'm not sure I can read.
[1:11:00] So we might have, I will probably just ask those who would
[1:11:03] are moved to speak if I don't come up with your name.
[1:11:06] First thing I have on the list is Jeff Martin.
[1:11:11] Jeff, if you'd like to speak.
[1:11:15] And if you go ahead and restate your name,
[1:11:17] we do have, this is being broadcast on the web
[1:11:20] as well as on channel 17, your name and your address
[1:11:22] [Muted for privacy: home address]
[1:11:24] [Muted for privacy: home address]
[1:11:27] [Muted for privacy: home address]
[1:11:29] [Muted for privacy: home address]
[1:11:32] to Mark Alexander.
[1:11:33] a little more prepared than I am.
[1:11:35] And the Mark was next on the list.
[1:11:37] He's next on the list.
[1:11:38] So we'll give him four minutes.
[1:11:39] How's that sound?
[1:11:40] There you go.
[1:11:41] You handle it.
[1:11:44] Hi, Math.
[1:11:45] Thanks, here.
[1:11:46] So, he's waving everybody the same shirts, but they'd like to come up in the front row, so
[1:11:52] we show that they're supporting.
[1:11:53] I think I would like to have him.
[1:11:55] Mark, if the...
[1:11:56] Because I'm having him.
[1:11:57] Those who are here in the sport of Mark, if you'd like to come up here and sit in the front
[1:11:59] row, that's sometimes going to have a little more impact.
[1:12:03] Well, first off, my name is Mark Alexander, and I appreciate the time to speak with you.
[1:12:11] As a member of the trail enhancement committee, we would like the council to consider the possibility
[1:12:20] of expansion of a Twin Falls trail system.
[1:12:27] We've been in contact with Dennis Boyer regarding some of the areas that we believe would greatly
[1:12:31] enhance the existing trail system we also come to you with funds so we're not
[1:12:39] looking for a handout necessarily but we do have some money to maybe perpetuate
[1:12:46] the proposed projects and I have a map sure of the area that we have in mind
[1:12:55] I need to switch that over there.
[1:13:00] This is the area marked in yellow.
[1:13:06] That's if you look, you can see that Eastland's most
[1:13:13] of the area that we're talking about is to the east
[1:13:20] and north of Eastland there.
[1:13:22] And we just, I know that this is private property,
[1:13:26] and this is just an area that we think would really enhance
[1:13:32] the experience around the Magic Valley.
[1:13:35] and the City of Twin Falls.
[1:13:41] So anyway, that's kind of the long and short of it.
[1:13:46] If you don't mind, I'd like to show you our mission statement.
[1:13:49] And you have four minutes, Mark.
[1:13:51] So use it anyway you want to do.
[1:13:53] Well, I don't want to take it all because I
[1:13:54] don't know what you have a lot to do.
[1:13:56] But the Magic Valley Trail Enhancement Committee
[1:14:02] is made up of a community of members
[1:14:04] whose interest and passion is to update and join the trail systems in the Magic Valley
[1:14:10] as a safe, relaxing, and enjoyable place to run, walk, and bike.
[1:14:15] Our mission is to provide a healthier community.
[1:14:20] So like I said, we're not necessarily looking for a handout, but we know that some of this
[1:14:28] is private property.
[1:14:31] And it could be 20 years before this is developed, and from what I understand with visiting with
[1:14:38] Dennis Boyer, you know, 20 years is a long time for humans.
[1:14:48] So anyway, we'd like you to take that into consideration.
[1:14:54] One of the things that we do, we just recently, we had the spirit of the Magic Valley event
[1:15:04] and Twin Falls was the staging point.
[1:15:06] We used a lot of the city trails and also the county.
[1:15:13] This year we generated a fair amount of money and we'd like to perpetuate this project.
[1:15:22] project.
[1:15:23] Sure, Mark.
[1:15:24] I don't want to take it up for your time, but I have a question.
[1:15:27] The trail that you show they're going through, what I'm going to refer to is the store property.
[1:15:31] Money of money, it's probably not, doesn't been here for too long, referred to as the
[1:15:35] Mary Alice Lake property.
[1:15:39] Is that trail, as you have it drawn, somewhat with the trails of their projected, I realized
[1:15:46] that could obviously change.
[1:15:47] Is that kind of where they thought the trail was going to go?
[1:15:50] Well, actually this map is one that I was able to get from Dennis Boyer and so it's
[1:16:00] unedited.
[1:16:01] Right, okay.
[1:16:02] That was kind of the, I'm making the assumption that's the, from the P.E.V.
[1:16:09] Yeah.
[1:16:10] Thank you Sean, help me with an accident that I was struggling to find.
[1:16:15] Okay.
[1:16:16] If you, that's all you have Mark, we certainly appreciate this is something that I know
[1:16:21] that the Council has discussed on many opportunities,
[1:16:25] the connection of those two places
[1:16:26] are high on our mind as well.
[1:16:28] And you're already starting with the right direction
[1:16:32] of who to talk to, and if we, you know,
[1:16:35] after this, we've had a chance to discuss it,
[1:16:37] down the road here, we give additional direction.
[1:16:42] Through the Parks and Rec Committee
[1:16:43] is the direction of this, we'll need to go.
[1:16:45] And like I said, you have a lot of friends up here
[1:16:47] as far as trying to get this taken care of,
[1:16:49] because that connection between those two spots
[1:16:52] has been brought up numerous times.
[1:16:54] We even had several of us went to a CSI speech class
[1:17:00] where that was brought up and basically
[1:17:03] the almost the exact same trail was entertained there.
[1:17:07] And so it definitely has a lot of community interest
[1:17:10] and we understand that.
[1:17:11] And if anybody else has some comments
[1:17:13] or if you have some additional things,
[1:17:15] you still have time left,
[1:17:15] I'm not wanting to take your time.
[1:17:17] No problem.
[1:17:19] The one thing I would like to add is, even if it was a primitive type of a connection unpaved
[1:17:27] or something like that, that would, you know, from our vantage point would be a huge improvement,
[1:17:33] you know, and it would really enhance the trail system.
[1:17:37] I think we're down to two owners on that particular thing at this point.
[1:17:41] That's what I understand.
[1:17:42] The bank owns one portion of it,
[1:17:45] they've presented it to us and then the Gary Storrer,
[1:17:48] his wife owned the other portion,
[1:17:50] and so we would be happy to work with those two private owners,
[1:17:53] but a primitive trail might be something that would
[1:17:56] still work instead of trying to pay the whole thing,
[1:17:58] when we're not sure where the trail,
[1:18:00] the one section of the trail's probably pretty close,
[1:18:02] yes, but the other one, who knows, right?
[1:18:04] So, all right.
[1:18:06] Well, we'll keep generating money and we'll,
[1:18:09] and hopefully we can work together on this.
[1:18:12] And thanks for this opportunity to help promote fitness
[1:18:16] and the well-being of our community.
[1:18:20] Thank you, Mark, and thank you for the rest of us.
[1:18:22] Like I said, it's on our minds.
[1:18:23] There's no doubt about that.
[1:18:24] Mark, make sure Dennis has your contact information case.
[1:18:28] You need to talk with him and back and forth.
[1:18:30] And we don't want to lose contact with anybody
[1:18:32] that might be able to help us financially.
[1:18:37] We'd be happy to do so.
[1:18:39] Thank you.
[1:18:40] Thank you very much.
[1:18:41] The next person I apologize, but I'm not unable to read the name on here that somebody else
[1:18:47] would like to speak to the Council concerning the budget.
[1:18:51] [Muted for privacy: street address]
[1:19:06] [Muted for privacy: street address]
[1:19:10] [Muted for privacy: street address]
[1:19:11] Great.
[1:19:12] I understand.
[1:19:13] I'm lucky I got that good child there.
[1:19:15] Getting there myself, so I just don't say it.
[1:19:18] Anyway, it seems like about the only time I could show up
[1:19:21] is when there's something to do with money coming out
[1:19:24] in my pocket.
[1:19:27] But I'm just trying to recall, maybe it was longer
[1:19:29] than a year ago, that I stood up here,
[1:19:34] asking and commenting about price of water
[1:19:40] going up our city water.
[1:19:45] It seems as though we get penalized for using too much
[1:19:52] water and yet there's not enough water used to pay the bills so you raise their price
[1:20:01] up.
[1:20:04] And I mean that's, let's see if you get shaken yes, and total agreement.
[1:20:10] So I guess it's something we're going to have to pay for, but I'm going to kind of,
[1:20:18] that's my little thing, I'm going to get everything.
[1:20:21] But I do like to be able to turn my water fast on,
[1:20:24] and I have the water.
[1:20:26] I'm not opposed to the water.
[1:20:28] And the garbage thing.
[1:20:30] I know it was at least a year ago, maybe.
[1:20:34] I think I've stood up here a couple of times on the garbage
[1:20:39] increase.
[1:20:43] I haven't called the city.
[1:20:45] I'm dense.
[1:20:45] I've been getting a whole of parks and suns
[1:20:47] the last several times.
[1:20:51] But it seems like today's the first time in probably
[1:20:54] month, then my garbage is actually then picked up when it was supposed to be. Sometimes it
[1:21:01] hasn't been picked up, so I just take it back and fill it up some more and some more. Until
[1:21:08] last week it got so full I couldn't stuff any more in it and I had to call Parks and
[1:21:17] since again to have them come and pick it up.
[1:21:22] So as far as I'm concerned,
[1:21:26] till we get a little bit of service from Parks and Sons,
[1:21:30] I'm violently opposed to Pan and Miller, 50 cents,
[1:21:35] or whatever, to mount it to a month.
[1:21:38] And I think they need to have a little better control
[1:21:42] of when they dump their garbage,
[1:21:44] you know, they're banned into their truck
[1:21:47] And take off, there's a lot of papers fly out.
[1:21:52] I don't know if any of you have followed
[1:21:53] the garbage truck around and around,
[1:21:56] and watched them take off after they dumped their stuff,
[1:21:59] but there is quite a bit of paper and flies out.
[1:22:01] So I think that should also be put in part of the contract
[1:22:05] is controlling the papers that fly out of their trucks.
[1:22:11] I know if I did it, I'd get a ticket,
[1:22:15] that they seem to be doing it for quite regularly.
[1:22:18] I do have some likes for questions.
[1:22:20] I think also travels as if you wait for,
[1:22:22] wait there for the questions, appreciate it.
[1:22:25] Don Hall.
[1:22:26] Pete, I was just going to ask you,
[1:22:28] is it possible that you're putting your garbage out
[1:22:31] when there was a holiday?
[1:22:32] Because it's always a day after.
[1:22:34] No.
[1:22:34] Because if they're not picking up your garbage,
[1:22:36] they're supposed to pick up your garbage
[1:22:38] and we need to know about that so that we can contact them.
[1:22:41] So can you stay in contact with us on that?
[1:22:43] I'm sure the council, you let us know.
[1:22:45] You call us.
[1:22:46] Did you guys know?
[1:22:47] Certainly you can call me.
[1:22:48] It's not knowing.
[1:22:49] He's called Sherry quite often, I'd say Sherry,
[1:22:51] and she's like, didn't they get your garbage picked up today?
[1:22:55] It's still, it was.
[1:22:57] Yeah, please let us know because that's their obligation.
[1:22:59] They're supposed to pick your garbage up.
[1:23:00] Well, I will instruct Travis or someone
[1:23:05] of his staff to do big contact with Parks and Sun
[1:23:07] and make sure he has your address before we leave.
[1:23:10] And that's something we need remedy, without that.
[1:23:13] I don't know if I only want that.
[1:23:16] Well, probably not.
[1:23:16] So it's something we need to look into.
[1:23:19] Travis, did you have a comment as well?
[1:23:21] Absolutely.
[1:23:22] I mean, first let me apologize.
[1:23:24] There's a level of service that Mr. Johnson's paying for.
[1:23:27] And regardless if it's the city of Twin Falls
[1:23:29] or it's our contracted provider, that shouldn't matter.
[1:23:32] And so this is something that I'm glad that Mr. Johnson brought
[1:23:37] to our attention.
[1:23:37] We will have a conversation in the morning with the folks at PSI, who will describe and
[1:23:43] will share with them the importance of a level of service and will also make sure that they
[1:23:49] are aware that we know that it seems to be a habitual issue as it sounds, not picking up
[1:23:56] Mr. Johnson's trash on a regular basis and so we'll work through that.
[1:24:01] I would ask that Mr. Johnson contact city staff, and he can share with the council, but the process
[1:24:08] is a lot more expedient if he contacts us directly and he can contact me directly, and I will
[1:24:16] call PSI quickly to ensure that the level of service is something that he's paying for.
[1:24:22] It just might be a little bit faster approach
[1:24:27] with him contacting us at City Hall.
[1:24:31] He can contact both of us if you want to call him.
[1:24:32] Absolutely, that's what I'm saying.
[1:24:34] That's the little that you've called him.
[1:24:35] Yeah, okay.
[1:24:37] Thank you Mr. Johnson.
[1:24:38] Okay, thank you for your time.
[1:24:40] I don't have any other names on my list.
[1:24:45] Is anyone else that this conversation has moved them
[1:24:47] that they would like to come up and speak concerning
[1:24:49] the budget?
[1:24:51] We will have another public hearing closer to the end of the budget cycle that you're
[1:24:56] certainly welling that those that are in the audience would like to audience or on air or
[1:25:03] on Channel 17 that would like to come forth and speak at that time.
[1:25:06] You certainly may do so.
[1:25:07] We have public hearing scheduled for, can we not hear, but we are going to go into a quick
[1:25:16] is exactly session as long as I haven't missed another item on the agenda here.
[1:25:20] You might get that input input. Oh, that's tough. And then we go into the executive session.
[1:25:26] Actually, we decided to do the executive session between them.
[1:25:31] I'm sorry, I missed topic with that. No, what I'm talking about is.
[1:25:37] Oh, number four, the Republican. Yeah.
[1:25:39] But anybody else have something about other than what the items we discussed tonight that they would like to bring forth to council before we go into the executive session.
[1:25:46] We'll come back out of the executive session for the public hearings.
[1:25:49] Don Hall's lights on.
[1:25:51] I was going to mention, since it's televised, or it's on the web anyway, that there are going to be three positions on the historic preservation committee coming open here soon.
[1:26:02] This is an extremely active and important committee in our city, and we would appreciate those interested to contact us.
[1:26:11] In fact, as it looks like it's going to close,
[1:26:17] I had it right here, June 26th, so a letter of intent
[1:26:23] needs to come to us and you can email that to Kweekso,
[1:26:27] K-W-E-E-K-S, at TFID.org,
[1:26:32] or you can't fax it in to 736-2641,
[1:26:37] and we would love to have more folks involved,
[1:26:39] but this is a very good committee
[1:26:41] and we'd love to have some involvement.
[1:26:42] Thank you.
[1:26:44] Chris Tinden.
[1:26:46] I'd like to bring this up the attention of the council
[1:26:48] and hope that they would concur asking the city manager
[1:26:52] to have our water conservation free rider.
[1:26:57] I don't know what else we call him.
[1:26:59] Become a bit more assertive in noting
[1:27:02] people who are not conserving water.
[1:27:05] Driving here today, the three miles,
[1:27:08] I came across three people that were watering on Monday.
[1:27:11] I don't think we're supposed to water out for what is a 10 or 11 in the morning until
[1:27:15] about four or something like that.
[1:27:18] I've noticed a slow migration of people ignoring watering in the right time of the week, watering
[1:27:26] on Mondays and in the least efficient time of the day on the hot afternoons and I just
[1:27:35] think that we need to have more notification of people.
[1:27:38] including on our utility bills, anything and everything.
[1:27:42] Now, some people will be watering on Monday,
[1:27:44] those on PSI, they water either odd or even,
[1:27:47] so there are some people watering on Monday's.
[1:27:50] I don't think these are PSI people.
[1:27:52] And so we need to, just to know there are some
[1:27:56] who are on Monday's.
[1:27:57] Where you are in a drought condition,
[1:27:59] that's where all will work.
[1:28:00] All right, anyone else?
[1:28:03] Seeing no one else, I would entertain a motion
[1:28:05] to move into executive session 6723451E,
[1:28:12] talks about economic development opportunities
[1:28:14] where we're in competition with a foreign country
[1:28:17] or another state, so it moved on home, okay?
[1:28:22] Second.
[1:28:22] Seconded by Jelun, and I do have a light on
[1:28:28] before we'll direct me on second.
[1:28:30] Thank you.
[1:28:31] I just had a question.
[1:28:32] If people are here to voice their thoughts
[1:28:36] public hearing is this a time-sensitive issue that we're going into executive
[1:28:40] session first or well we talked about we usually take a break at this time we
[1:28:44] thought we just covered the executive session during the break okay was the we
[1:28:49] were trying to save time to be honest with you a break was probably called for
[1:28:52] at this point and we have an hour and a half and so that was our purpose okay all
[1:28:58] All right, uh, roll call vote, yeah.
[1:29:02] Chris Talkington.
[1:29:03] Yes.
[1:29:04] Sean Berger.
[1:29:05] Yes.
[1:29:06] Don Hall.
[1:29:07] Yes.
[1:29:08] Suzanne Hawkins.
[1:29:09] Yes.
[1:29:10] Greg Lantine.
[1:29:11] Yes.
[1:29:12] Jim Mann.
[1:29:13] Yes.
[1:29:14] Rebecca Milsweka.
[1:29:15] No.
[1:29:16] Okay.
[1:29:17] Motion passes six to one.
[1:29:18] Uh, we're going to try to take about, uh, Travis, you, how long are you going to take
[1:29:21] the 10 minutes?
[1:29:22] Okay.
[1:29:23] If 10 minute break, we'll be back here at, uh, six thirty five to begin the public
[1:29:28] here.
[1:29:30] We have contacted all the utility companies, all have given their blessing, and as long
[1:29:37] as the bank agreed to pay for the relocation of said utilities, which we are in the process
[1:29:43] of doing right now, if you've driven by there, you currently can see some construction and
[1:29:50] readiness.
[1:29:51] We've already relocated water main where Idaho Power and Quest and Intermount Gas and Cable
[1:29:57] One are all relocating their facilities.
[1:29:59] The intent of the vacation of this alley is so that this building right here can be torn
[1:30:06] down and we can put another building that extends over that vacated alley.
[1:30:19] So as you can see the outline of the existing building is right there and the new building
[1:30:24] is over there.
[1:30:26] So it's roughly about four times the size of the existing building and we'd like to build
[1:30:31] over your alley. Fortunately for us the utilities will be relocated and first
[1:30:37] federal owns all adjacent lots next to that alley. In our mailings we received
[1:30:43] no negative comments and also at our public hearing in front of P&Z a couple
[1:30:49] weeks ago there was no one opposed to that vacation of the alley as well. We
[1:30:54] would ask tonight for your approval of that vacation so we can move forward and
[1:30:58] demo and constructing of, it's going to be the three new three-story administration building
[1:31:16] for First Federal Bank on that corner.
[1:31:21] The existing bank is over there.
[1:31:25] Their other existing facility is behind that and this is a view from the corner of Third
[1:31:31] and Show shown.
[1:31:33] And I think it's going to be the First Federal is an excellent customer.
[1:31:37] going to be putting landscaping in around this, all new paving on site and throughout
[1:31:42] the alley and it's going to be a great addition to the city. Thank you.
[1:31:48] Thank you, Jim. The trouble?
[1:31:53] Okay, this is an item for a request to vacate the alley, as Tim explained. You know, he actually
[1:32:05] did a pretty job to explain. I was trying to think about what I might add to his request
[1:32:09] and I don't actually know that I would add a whole lot
[1:32:12] because he really was pretty through his request.
[1:32:14] Last time we talked about this at the council,
[1:32:16] I did want to talk about the first fed construction.
[1:32:20] We talked about this addition being constructed next
[1:32:26] to the bank on these lots.
[1:32:28] And you'll notice that that plan has changed now.
[1:32:31] So we're going down here to the south of the bank instead
[1:32:35] of to the west of the bank now.
[1:32:39] Just a note, last time you all saw it,
[1:32:42] it was a slightly different plan.
[1:32:43] So procedurally, it's a vacation request.
[1:32:49] We have to have a public hearing.
[1:32:51] We have a recommendation from the Planning and Zoning Commission.
[1:32:55] They did hold a hearing on May 14th,
[1:33:00] and the unanimous to the recommended approval of the request
[1:33:02] with the two conditions that are located in the staff report.
[1:33:05] The first one is a pretty standard condition subject
[1:33:09] to site plan amendments is required by building engineering,
[1:33:12] fire and zoning officials to ensure compliance
[1:33:13] with all the eligible city codes and standards.
[1:33:15] And then the second one is subject to the E.
[1:33:17] And E.S.men being recorded for the relocated alleys
[1:33:20] or relocated utilities.
[1:33:23] As Tim mentioned, the utilities are gonna be relocated
[1:33:26] into this location and there'll be a new
[1:33:29] ala, E.S.men dedicated to, you know,
[1:33:32] to cover the water line and stuff that's in there.
[1:33:35] There really is no perceivable negative impacts of making the Allian staff supports the commission's
[1:33:44] recommendation and we can try to answer your questions if you have any.
[1:33:48] With that we do have a public hearing though.
[1:33:50] Tim I have one quickly.
[1:33:53] This will change.
[1:33:54] It will no longer need to make that portion of what is that third one way now.
[1:34:01] There was a fourth one.
[1:34:03] There was a fourth one.
[1:34:05] There's always that possibility in the future, but the immediate need now has been focused
[1:34:10] on to this site.
[1:34:12] It is city right away, so the city has the ability to do whatever type of parking layout
[1:34:18] they want.
[1:34:19] I think you may see some plans in the future that may focus on that.
[1:34:28] Yes, sir.
[1:34:31] Okay, Donald.
[1:34:33] I really had the same question, you came to us before about making a one way and building
[1:34:39] it on the other side and so we went through some gyrations to make that happen and then
[1:34:43] next thing I hear is that you're not doing that anymore and you're here.
[1:34:47] So I'm just, is this a firm plan this time or where we at?
[1:34:52] This is a firm plan.
[1:34:54] Quite frankly, what was always presented to the bank was an initial concept and we went
[1:35:02] forward with that movement because that's what we thought the banks needs were when we
[1:35:08] kind of expanded that into the alley into the on the full site and first federal felt as
[1:35:17] though that they'd like to take a look at ripping down that existing building. Why didn't anybody
[1:35:24] ever pose that? We never thought, but I want to rip down a perfectly good building, but we
[1:35:31] We did move forward with that, and this suits all of their needs to get all their people
[1:35:36] on the same campus, and it also became somewhat of a logistical nightmare with the over head
[1:35:44] walk through that was on the 4th Avenue site.
[1:35:48] So this is final.
[1:35:49] We do have plans into the billing department as we speak for foundation plan approval.
[1:35:56] plant-proof is already been received from City Engineering and EQ, so we are set for this.
[1:36:02] Thank you, Tim. Thank you.
[1:36:05] Dr. Dauwie. Tim, the alley to be vacated. Does that have overhead utilities or are they
[1:36:12] all currently underground?
[1:36:14] There are currently overhead power lines running down, I would say, the East West Alley, which
[1:36:22] is in between the new and the existing facility.
[1:36:26] But I believe they stop about-
[1:36:27] Give us a pointer on that work where you're referring to.
[1:36:30] I do have one.
[1:36:32] So I believe it stops about right there as far as overhead
[1:36:35] and carries on to the web.
[1:36:37] Everything else is or will be underground.
[1:36:41] We're currently in the process of putting a new auto power
[1:36:44] structure there and running conduits for all the utilities
[1:36:49] through here.
[1:36:51] but since the applicable property does not have any overhead,
[1:36:54] that doesn't pertain to my question,
[1:36:56] except make sure that the applicant understands
[1:36:59] that the relocation utility says that there are costs,
[1:37:02] which you've already agreed to.
[1:37:04] We haven't, we've already started that
[1:37:05] in the contracts in place.
[1:37:07] Thanks.
[1:37:08] Hey, Jim, on?
[1:37:09] Yeah, just a point of order.
[1:37:11] My daughter is a officer at first fed,
[1:37:13] so I think it's probably best for me
[1:37:15] to recuse myself in this discussion.
[1:37:17] Any sort of vote that would proceed from here, so.
[1:37:20] I want to get on first, but I didn't get the light.
[1:37:23] So I apologize.
[1:37:24] Okay, Suzanne, I guess?
[1:37:27] Just curious.
[1:37:28] I saw the permit for the tree removals.
[1:37:30] Were any of the trees salvageable
[1:37:32] or able to be transplanted anywhere
[1:37:34] or were they just unfortunately gone?
[1:37:37] One, we're trying to salvage,
[1:37:40] we're hoping the room system is good.
[1:37:42] The rest were unsalvageable
[1:37:45] because of being in the sidewalk
[1:37:47] And just the fact that transplanting them didn't make sense.
[1:37:54] I have every belief in the world that first federal is going
[1:37:58] to outdo themselves in landscaping.
[1:38:00] They retained a landscaper already.
[1:38:03] And we're actually going to meet sometime this week
[1:38:06] on design for the entire parking lot.
[1:38:09] So I think you'll see an increase in the amount of landscaping
[1:38:12] that currently exists there.
[1:38:14] I know you don't have a lot of space there
[1:38:15] for landscaping with what you're working with.
[1:38:17] But we're trying to create a center meeting in the parking lot off to the west.
[1:38:23] Okay.
[1:38:24] That parking lot in the southwest corner there is part of the first federal agreement with
[1:38:38] the Urban Renewal Agency once they pull the building permit and they will be acquiring that
[1:38:45] parking lot.
[1:38:46] So we'll be upgrading that and we'll be putting interior landscaping similar to what we do
[1:38:51] in the downtown URA area with center landscaping
[1:38:55] and lighting in between.
[1:38:57] And you're still gonna have enough parking
[1:38:59] because I knew before parking was an issue,
[1:39:01] but it's all resolved.
[1:39:03] We will.
[1:39:04] Okay, thank you.
[1:39:06] That's all the lights, Tim.
[1:39:07] We'll probably move forth now
[1:39:10] and have the public hearing portion.
[1:39:12] And Don Hall again will be doing the timing.
[1:39:16] He'll give you two minutes and 30 seconds.
[1:39:19] He'll give you a 30 second notice.
[1:39:21] so you can wrap up your thoughts.
[1:39:23] So now we'll open up the public hearing.
[1:39:27] Travis is going back and getting the list.
[1:39:29] If anybody chose to speak on this issue.
[1:39:34] Seeing none, anyone who, even if you didn't sign up,
[1:39:38] you'd like to come up and speak on the issue,
[1:39:39] you're shortly welcome to.
[1:39:41] Again, not seeing anybody coming forth,
[1:39:43] I'll close the public comment portion.
[1:39:45] I'll leave it open for council for any additional questions
[1:39:48] for a moment before we move on to
[1:39:50] the voting and motion portion of this.
[1:39:56] Suzanne?
[1:39:57] I would move to re-to authorize vacation
[1:40:28] of the 15 by 125 foot alley
[1:40:33] located west of 303 Shoshone Street North,
[1:40:36] pertinent to the application drawings,
[1:40:39] and subject to P&Z's recommendations.
[1:40:44] Second.
[1:40:45] My Chris talking 10 and second is by Don Hall that we approved this vacation.
[1:40:50] Is there any other comment?
[1:40:53] I don't echo the same thing as Suzanne said, I know that there was some concern up here about the changing of one way.
[1:41:01] Of course, we've been changed one way and I think that's what sent first federal back to at least looking to make sure they had looked at all the options.
[1:41:10] And I think they took a building that some of the people who I've talked to work there
[1:41:14] I don't think it's actually a perfectly good building because it does have some issues
[1:41:18] So we'd like to thank them for their efforts as well. All right
[1:41:23] Roll call both way out Sean Berger. Yes
[1:41:26] Don Hall. Yes, she's on Hawkins. Yes, Greg Lanting. Yes, Jim. I'm staying Rebecca
[1:41:34] Thank you.
[1:41:35] Yes.
[1:41:36] Yes.
[1:41:37] Motion passes six to zero with one extension.
[1:41:40] Thank you, Tim.
[1:41:41] Moving on to item number two, which is a request for a zoning district chain and zoning map amendment
[1:41:50] C1 PUD, for the North Bridge PUD and North Bridge number two PUD, to C1 PUD, West Park commercial
[1:41:59] number seven PUD for four four two point five three plus or minus acres to allow for a commercial
[1:42:06] development consisting of a hotel and accessory uses to be located at 1810 Washington Street North
[1:42:14] is Gerald Martin's on behalf of West partners and I'm assuming you're here to let Gerald Martin's
[1:42:22] Bill first.
[1:42:23] Jarrell, welcome.
[1:42:24] Thank you.
[1:42:26] The record, my name is Jarrell Martins.
[1:42:29] I'm here this evening representing West Park Partners, the developer of the West Park subdivision,
[1:42:38] which is at property north of Falls and east, north of Pull line in east of Washington.
[1:42:46] Well, we have this evening is a very specific request for two and a half acres.
[1:42:54] It's part of two old PUDs, and we are creating a new PUD that incorporates those aspects of
[1:43:05] those old PUDs into a site-specific PUD that allows construction of a hotel and a hotel
[1:43:11] only on a piece of property.
[1:43:15] This is basically the last step.
[1:43:17] Earlier this evening on the consent calendar you approved the final plot that is a technical
[1:43:23] document that allows the sale of that piece of property.
[1:43:26] Earlier we went through a preliminary plot and a preliminary PUD presentation were planning
[1:43:32] and zoning.
[1:43:33] And then actual PUD, preliminary and final PUD steps.
[1:43:39] This is the last step in your staff report this evening is the recommendations of planning
[1:43:49] and zoning.
[1:43:50] We can turn with those recommendations.
[1:43:52] We request your approval.
[1:43:54] I can stand up here and show you site plans and elevations, but I'll be glad to show those
[1:44:02] if anybody wants to see them.
[1:44:04] Otherwise, I'd like to move your agenda along and answer questions that may come out.
[1:44:09] With that, stand for questions.
[1:44:12] We'll have one question or back in a second.
[1:44:16] Could you just show us the elevations?
[1:44:17] I know that at the preliminary, I think it was preliminary
[1:44:21] plat, there was maybe an extra few feet above the building
[1:44:27] height, but I think that's been changed.
[1:44:29] Yes, basically, other than the architectural projections
[1:44:33] is allowed for, we've maintained the height requirements.
[1:44:37] that was outlined in the PUD agreement, the 35 feet.
[1:44:40] Normally they would have built a four-story hotel,
[1:44:43] that's a model that they concur.
[1:44:45] They went to the three-story plan for this location.
[1:44:50] Vins would put the subject up.
[1:44:51] We did meet with the neighbors to the west
[1:44:54] at a neighborhood meeting.
[1:44:57] And out of that came, well initially we increased
[1:45:02] the setback to provide additional setback
[1:45:05] from the Washington Street and Washington Street is wide.
[1:45:09] We also, from the neighborhood meeting, were two issues
[1:45:15] that were expressed in planning to zoning one,
[1:45:18] was they didn't want to or to discourage truck traffic.
[1:45:25] The concern being trucks left idling in the neighborhood.
[1:45:29] This parking lot is shown on the site plan.
[1:45:39] Basically to the bottom of the sheet would be the neighborhood.
[1:45:43] If anybody gets a truck in that parking lot,
[1:45:46] we're going to have to get a crane to get him out.
[1:45:50] So the design and the access precludes the truck traffic.
[1:45:55] The other issue they brought up was
[1:45:58] concerning about headlights at night shining
[1:46:01] into the residential area.
[1:46:03] We have about a 50 foot wide landscaping strip
[1:46:07] along Washington Street, that will be burned and landscaped
[1:46:11] at elevations that preclude headlights
[1:46:14] washing across the street.
[1:46:16] So we've addressed it to neighborhood concerns
[1:46:19] and those items, those requirements have been addressed
[1:46:25] in the staff, in the recommendations
[1:46:29] and in the PUD document.
[1:46:31] Good, could you go back to that elevation picture real quick?
[1:46:34] It's hard to read the elevation
[1:46:36] so that the highest point is that 35 feet.
[1:46:41] You can't actually read it.
[1:46:51] There are architectural projections exceeding the 35 feet, but the basic shell and enclosure
[1:47:04] of the building, which has been the interpretation of the 35 feet, has been that.
[1:47:13] And I mean that's consistent with what we have basically out on that corridor, R3 story
[1:47:23] structures that are designed around that criteria, the hotels.
[1:47:27] Okay.
[1:47:28] Thank you, Daryl.
[1:47:29] Mitch Humble.
[1:47:30] City staff?
[1:47:31] Travis, I want to say something first.
[1:47:33] He's got better eyes apparently.
[1:47:39] So the first four, yep, from the top down, the first one is 44.0, it's described as a parapet.
[1:47:51] The next is 42 feet, 6 inches, described as a parapet.
[1:47:56] The next is 37 feet, 4 inches, described as a parapet.
[1:48:01] The next is 36 feet, 2 inches, described as a parapet.
[1:48:06] And then the roof line, which is the fifth one down, is at 33 feet, six inches.
[1:48:15] You just wanted to show off, let's be honest.
[1:48:20] All right, Mitch Humbles, I said to you, how are you doing that?
[1:48:29] I couldn't see him even.
[1:48:31] How we would measure the roof height though would be the 35 foot to the roof height.
[1:48:36] we do allow architectural projections above the 35.
[1:48:41] So just to orient ourselves again,
[1:48:43] Washington and Pole Line,
[1:48:46] right here is the Walgreens on the corner,
[1:48:48] where immediately north of them,
[1:48:50] that's the property we're talking about, 2.5 acres.
[1:48:54] Darryl mentioned that we have two older PUDs
[1:48:56] that bisect the property and that's accurate,
[1:48:59] and they're old and somewhat confusing,
[1:49:01] and this really does go a long way
[1:49:03] to start cleaning up that confusion
[1:49:05] for this one site-specific PUD.
[1:49:09] It is a very specific PUD,
[1:49:12] and that when it's approved, it will allow basically that.
[1:49:15] It'll be single-use hotel, PUD,
[1:49:22] with meeting all the code requirements
[1:49:26] for landscaping and all that bit.
[1:49:29] They are proposing a little bit more restrictive signage
[1:49:31] than we would allow, and so it's a monument-style sign.
[1:49:36] So some of that's going to be written into the PUD as well.
[1:49:38] The additional landscape standards,
[1:49:44] they talked about the greater buffer out in the front
[1:49:46] than code requires.
[1:49:48] Some of those will be characterized in the PUD as well.
[1:49:55] Let's see here.
[1:49:58] So again, I'm trying to avoid repeating everything you told you.
[1:50:07] We do have a public hearing process for the PUDs.
[1:50:10] They've gone through the process.
[1:50:11] There was a Planning and Zoning Commission hearing on May 14th.
[1:50:16] At that meeting, the commission reviewed it
[1:50:19] and unanimously recommended again approval
[1:50:22] of this West Park commercial number seven, C1PUD,
[1:50:26] with the four conditions that are listed in your staff report.
[1:50:28] Again, the first one being kind of a standard one,
[1:50:30] subject to site plan amendments is required
[1:50:32] by building engineering, fire, and zoning officials
[1:50:35] to ensure compliance with all of the local city code
[1:50:37] requirements and standards.
[1:50:39] Second one is also kind of a standard subject
[1:50:40] to arterial and collect the streets adjacent
[1:50:42] within the property being dedicated to the city
[1:50:45] and to be rebuilt or built to city standards
[1:50:47] upon development or change of use of the property.
[1:50:52] The plan that we approved earlier doesn't necessarily
[1:50:54] have any right of identification
[1:50:55] but there may be some work as sidewalks
[1:50:57] and things like that that they'll have to do.
[1:51:00] Let's say the third one subject to the landscape
[1:51:02] would be consistent in meeting or exceeding
[1:51:04] the present master development plan
[1:51:06] as well as city codes whichever is greater
[1:51:08] as references to the city codes.
[1:51:10] And the last condition deals with the monument sign.
[1:51:16] And that basically is just a statement there
[1:51:18] that it's forward from the city code.
[1:51:21] If you're going to put a sign in the easement,
[1:51:23] there's a 15-foot easement across the front,
[1:51:26] the street front to the property for utilities.
[1:51:28] Then we need that letter.
[1:51:29] That condition is basically says you're
[1:51:32] going to comply with the city code for signage.
[1:51:34] So with those four conditions, this planning and zoning
[1:51:37] commission recommended approval of the PUD.
[1:51:39] process-wise, we'll have the hearing tonight, get some input. If you have the
[1:51:45] council feels favorably toward the request, we'll bring back an ordinance at a future
[1:51:50] meeting as well as the PUD agreement with all of the stuff discussed tonight,
[1:51:54] kind of put in writing for us, and basically where we're at. So we can try to
[1:52:02] answer your questions if you have any. And then, other than that, we do need to open a public hearing.
[1:52:07] Shummer.
[1:52:08] Mitch, I have a question related to the arterial and collector streets.
[1:52:13] So it's difficult to tell on these drawings is, does Washington Street get some widening
[1:52:22] and reconstruction in this process as it narrows there and also, um, have any of the del Rio?
[1:52:30] I'm not sure if that's built full width right now or if it's just half width.
[1:52:35] I know Washington Street is an arterial and it is built through the ITD project to its
[1:52:42] ultimate width.
[1:52:43] The work by the development will be a minor modification at the driveway and installation
[1:52:49] of the meandering sidewalk.
[1:52:53] Well, if you know D.L. Rowe, we would build up the other side of the summit.
[1:52:57] That's not as easy of its.
[1:52:58] Is it built full width now, aren't you?
[1:53:00] Yeah, it's full width on the east side.
[1:53:04] Okay.
[1:53:05] That's right.
[1:53:07] but no widening of Washington Street from that point north.
[1:53:11] No, well it is to its ultimate design with.
[1:53:14] Okay, thank you.
[1:53:15] Correct.
[1:53:16] Well it is to its current ultimate design.
[1:53:19] Yes, Jackie, I appreciate that.
[1:53:23] All right, back to me, I'll second.
[1:53:24] Thank you, Mayor.
[1:53:26] As the applicant mentioned at the P&Z public hearing,
[1:53:29] there was a quest for the berm on the street that faces
[1:53:34] the residents is to be high enough to prevent the headlights from projecting into their homes.
[1:53:40] So will that be part of the PUD?
[1:53:42] Will that be a part of the requirement that the applicant has expressed that they're going
[1:53:46] to do that?
[1:53:47] Will that be a requirement?
[1:53:49] Yeah, that will get written into the language of the PUD agreement that we'll see as we move
[1:53:54] forward in the process.
[1:53:56] Thank you.
[1:53:59] So you know additional questions, we'll go ahead and open up the public hearing.
[1:54:03] Anyone have a public comment on this particular project?
[1:54:07] Uh, see, no one.
[1:54:10] I will close the public hearing and bring it back to council for their wishes or additional
[1:54:14] questions.
[1:54:15] Uh, we need the tonight's action would be just to approve the request and they'll bring
[1:54:21] it back to us with the final PUD and final and in order to uh, Shomburger.
[1:54:26] Are you ready for a motion?
[1:54:27] Sure.
[1:54:28] I would move to approve the request for a zoning district change and zoning map amendment
[1:54:34] from C1PUD, North Bridge PUD, and North Bridge Number 2 PUD to C1PUD, West Park Commercial
[1:54:42] Number 7 PUD, as presented, and including the recommendations of the Planning and Zoning
[1:54:49] Commission.
[1:54:51] Second.
[1:54:52] And moved by Schumburger and second by Suzanne Hawkins to approve the request as presented,
[1:54:58] including P&D recommendations.
[1:55:00] recommendations. See the lights, uh, they have a roll call vote. Those are, excuse me, I do have a light. Rebecca. Thank you. Recognize.
[1:55:09] That's all right. Um, so it's more of a question to city staff. I know that in, in the report, it says that, um, in C1, there's not a minimum lot size. Um, but so my question is actually about condition number four, and I know that's part of our city code. Um, and it's talking about if the sign needs to be placed in utility easement.
[1:55:30] The property owners shall demonstrate that there is no other viable location for a sign.
[1:55:35] But wouldn't that mean that there isn't enough square footage or lot size if you don't have room for your sign or how does that work?
[1:55:48] So in this case we'll have 15 foot utilities but there runs right down the front of the property and that's common actually for the front property lines to have easements.
[1:56:00] really the provision in the code is just that it's about maintenance of the
[1:56:05] utilities that are in the easement more so than the sign issue. It's
[1:56:10] acknowledging that yep we're putting it in the easement and if we need to
[1:56:14] maintain our lines your signs in the way that's at your risk kind of thing. So
[1:56:19] really that's what the code sections about is taking care of who's
[1:56:22] responsible to maintain the sign even though it's in the easement. It's not
[1:56:27] we've done this several times where we've gone through the process to get the letter and to prove that, you know, in this case, you could potentially, you know, maybe pop out an island in the parking lot and put it on the island instead of out in the easement, but we'll work through those issues with them.
[1:56:46] But like I said, the real issue is about maintaining the sign when it's in the easement. If there's easement, utility work that needs to be done in the easement.
[1:56:55] Right, because that main part of the code prevents someone from putting anything in that easement.
[1:57:02] And so...
[1:57:03] Without putting... without the letter and stuff first, right?
[1:57:07] Right, right, but it's discouraging them from placing it in that easement.
[1:57:10] Just, I guess, for their own convenience.
[1:57:14] But thank you for clarifying that.
[1:57:16] My other... my only concern, I think that this is, you know, relatively, you know, well-described
[1:57:24] in zone changing, but the height limit in the C1 zone is 35 feet and so I don't see any
[1:57:34] reason to exceed that 35 feet.
[1:57:39] So for the record I guess I'll just propose an amendment that we restricted to 35 feet.
[1:57:46] Opposed amendment, they restrict 35 feet.
[1:57:52] That would include the projections you're talking about?
[1:57:56] Yes.
[1:57:57] Carapets.
[1:57:58] Carapets, yes.
[1:58:00] Do you want to go where you are?
[1:58:02] Well, I was just going to, no, I'm not going to second,
[1:58:05] but I would, if there's an amendment on the, I can wait
[1:58:08] for more questions or.
[1:58:09] Sure, we're going to need to wait to see whether we
[1:58:10] had a second on this amendment first.
[1:58:12] And I'll just shut down to.
[1:58:14] Chris, I'm going to second.
[1:58:16] And move by your right, Mr. Lagan, and seconded by Chris talking that the project PUD would limit the height to 35 feet.
[1:58:27] Jim, where else you mean?
[1:58:29] Don?
[1:58:30] Don? Go ahead, Don.
[1:58:31] Don?
[1:58:32] I was just going to say that I'm not in support of the amendment because
[1:58:36] it sounds like we have allowed going above 35 feet prepare pets and those type of architectural things in other areas of this.
[1:58:45] other buildings in this area so I don't know why we would limit one building over
[1:58:51] the others.
[1:58:52] I'm not really doing this.
[1:58:56] If somebody asks you a question as part of this, I can probably do it.
[1:59:00] My question is to Mitch also. Rebecca indicated that the code says that the top
[1:59:06] is it that the top of the building shall not exceed 35 feet or the roof will
[1:59:13] not exceed 35 feet.
[1:59:14] feet. In other words, there seems to be architectural fluff or whatever that goes
[1:59:23] above the 35 feet. I'm not an architect.
[1:59:33] So are allowed to project into the. Okay, so the code allows things to go above 35 feet.
[1:59:39] The roof height of the building needs to be less than 35 feet, but it does allow for projections.
[1:59:46] Okay, and in this instance it's 33 feet, the roof.
[1:59:49] 33 something I think the tribe has indicated.
[1:59:51] So these projections that come above the roof line are well within code.
[1:59:57] And in fact our presence in the past has allowed those Laquinta or other hotels or businesses along the Poline corridor.
[2:00:07] So this is not something that would be unusual.
[2:00:11] So when we talk about other hotels in the corridor,
[2:00:15] almost all of them have come through a process
[2:00:17] to request additional height.
[2:00:20] And so when they've requested additional height,
[2:00:23] we've gone through the process to do that.
[2:00:25] And they are including their roof height.
[2:00:27] And so a lot of those are coming in at like 48, 47, 45 feet
[2:00:32] anyway.
[2:00:33] But that's where the roof line is.
[2:00:35] I think they're proposing to meet the 35 foot height.
[2:00:38] Or they're under the 35.
[2:00:40] Yeah, at 33.
[2:00:41] Okay.
[2:00:42] At the roof height, but having a few projections above.
[2:00:44] Which is within code.
[2:00:46] Which is within code, okay.
[2:00:48] And I think our attorney is showing us that right now.
[2:00:54] Okay, I just want to clarify that because I know that there was a concern there about the
[2:00:57] things shall not exceed 35 feet, but it appears that, and French, you may comment on it, it
[2:01:02] is, we are allowed to go over 35 feet, not the rough line, but the, what do you,
[2:01:08] Fluff as I call it the professionals will call something never the best example of architectural projections you see on the church's
[2:01:15] Seeple right precisely. It's not the roof line is something else very good. Thank you
[2:01:20] I have a question for Fred. So is that saying?
[2:01:24] In such case a maximum of three feet shall be considered the architectural projection
[2:01:29] So when it couldn't go above 38 feet or is that pertain to something else?
[2:01:34] Okay, so there isn't a limit on architectural projections.
[2:01:43] You could project 20, 30 feet high.
[2:01:46] We have some pretty tall steeples.
[2:01:49] How about the temple?
[2:01:51] Correct.
[2:01:52] But this, according to the, could you put the drawing up one more time?
[2:01:55] It doesn't appear to be a projection, it just appears to be the roof.
[2:02:00] I guess it's not an antenna, it's not a steeple.
[2:02:04] It actually appears to look like a roof, even though it's a projection.
[2:02:10] I might explain it, basically, it's just a taller parapet in those areas to give it some
[2:02:17] character.
[2:02:18] I think anybody would agree that if I extended that 35-foot line across there, I wouldn't lose
[2:02:24] any rooms.
[2:02:25] I wouldn't lose any space, any volume, but I would have a very ugly building.
[2:02:31] It looked like a military barracks, excuse me,
[2:02:34] but see, those features don't are just around the perimeter
[2:02:40] to give us some vertical relief.
[2:02:44] It's not occupied space.
[2:02:45] All of the occupied, roundable space
[2:02:48] is below the 35 per minute.
[2:02:50] Basically, what we required Walmart to do, right?
[2:02:54] You asked Walmart to put those projections on there.
[2:02:57] So they're not for elevators at all.
[2:02:59] Excuse me?
[2:03:01] They're not for elevators.
[2:03:02] Well, they're not in this building,
[2:03:06] but they have been in other buildings,
[2:03:09] where it's been.
[2:03:10] Up to three stories, it's hydraulic elevators,
[2:03:13] it's a lift from below.
[2:03:14] If you get four stories in higher,
[2:03:16] you have a lift on the top, which has got cable lifts
[2:03:20] on the top, and we do have cable lift elevators
[2:03:23] in this town that are within architectural projections.
[2:03:26] But not here.
[2:03:27] Not here.
[2:03:28] All right.
[2:03:29] I'm Rebecca, is that your question?
[2:03:32] Good, thank you.
[2:03:32] All right.
[2:03:33] Seeing no additional lights, we're
[2:03:35] voting on the amendment, which would
[2:03:36] be to limit the total project, all parts of the project
[2:03:41] to be at 35 feet.
[2:03:43] So yes, would be saying 35 feet.
[2:03:45] No, would be saying allowing projections higher than that.
[2:03:49] Go ahead, Leo.
[2:03:50] Don Hall?
[2:03:51] No.
[2:03:53] Tisam Hocktans?
[2:03:54] No.
[2:03:55] Greg Lanting?
[2:03:56] No.
[2:03:57] Jim Mun?
[2:03:58] No.
[2:03:59] Rebecca Melsweka. Yes, Chris Talkington. No, Sean Barrigar. No, motion pails one to six.
[2:04:06] No, no, we're back to the, nothing. Okay. I have six to one. No, no, you're good.
[2:04:18] All right, back to the main motion as I'm not amended. See, no, just lightly add a roll call vote.
[2:04:26] Susan Hawkins. Yes. Greg Lanting. Yes. Jim Mann. Yes. Rebecca Melsoika. Yes. Chris
[2:04:35] Hawkins. Yes. Sean Berger. Yes. Don Hall. Yes. Motion passes 7-0. Don Hall's lines poised.
[2:04:45] Thank you, Gerald. Don Hall. Mayor, I'm going to recuse myself and actually set
[2:04:51] down from the next item on the agenda.
[2:04:55] I as well as my wife are proud employees of the College of Southern Idaho, which in either
[2:05:02] case would require me essentially to step down for conflicts of interest.
[2:05:08] Jim, I also am an employee of the college to find the College of Southern Idaho, and I
[2:05:14] too will have to recuse myself from this and sit out in the audience.
[2:05:17] Thank you.
[2:05:18] I'll put a green on my one hazard.
[2:05:21] Sorry.
[2:05:22] I'm going to ask you.
[2:05:23] Sure.
[2:05:24] So, France and Don's come in and indicated since his spouse was also an employee of the college
[2:05:30] that he should step down.
[2:05:32] Would I need you to do that?
[2:05:34] Yeah.
[2:05:35] We're going to be sure.
[2:05:36] The college is the applicant here.
[2:05:38] Then.
[2:05:39] We're going to be sure it's warm.
[2:05:43] We've got four.
[2:05:46] No.
[2:05:47] Chris.
[2:05:48] Oh, yeah.
[2:05:49] My wife worked for the Robertson Foundation and the monies are administered through CSI for a program.
[2:05:56] No, that's not that's that's that's that would be a concern.
[2:05:58] We're good we're good we study them.
[2:06:00] Okay and then I do go over to you step down.
[2:06:03] Okay. Well we're going to consider a preliminary design for the key one for one one four nine five CSI safety and history for the chainy drive.
[2:06:22] Jackie Fields is listed on here but I think we're probably going to see here from some
[2:06:27] CSI people.
[2:06:29] Jackie, did you want to start us off?
[2:06:36] All right.
[2:06:38] We have to introduce yourself and we'll go from there.
[2:06:42] Okay, Mayor, City Council members.
[2:06:43] Thank you for this opportunity to update you and the public on the CSI Safety Initiative
[2:06:48] Project.
[2:06:49] I'm Aaron Wert, Project Manager of Real Engineering for this project.
[2:06:55] We have Mike Mason here also with the CSI and Jerry Blats with the LTCH, which is local technical,
[2:07:06] local highway technical assistance council, and push tech is here.
[2:07:13] So, moving forward here, why we're having this hearing.
[2:07:26] This is a federally funded project
[2:07:28] Requires public involvement because it's federally funded and for this project
[2:07:34] It was decided that we have a an actual public hearing on this
[2:07:39] This project to make sure we address any comments to come up
[2:07:43] also
[2:07:45] Presented this project to the City Council before about three years ago
[2:07:51] And at that point I wanted to the City Council requested that we get an update on the project
[2:07:57] So I'm here to update you on where we're at with the project.
[2:08:03] We need to sign in form.
[2:08:05] So I would like to send the sign in form around and have everybody sign up that's listening
[2:08:11] to presentation at least whether they comment or not.
[2:08:15] So we have a record of it.
[2:08:16] They're just asking that because it is federal program, everyone who is taking here listening
[2:08:22] to the information they're asking that you sign in doesn't mean you have to participate
[2:08:27] Anyway, it just means that you're here and we'll be all signing it as well. So, okay, go ahead. Thank you. Okay.
[2:08:34] How we comment on this project we you can give oral testimony here at the podium.
[2:08:40] We have a
[2:08:41] I'll have a hearing officer in this room over here for somebody wants to give private oral testimony
[2:08:47] We have written written comment sheets
[2:08:50] If you want to comment sheet can't we'll get you one?
[2:08:53] You can leave them here or you can mail them back to us
[2:08:57] We need those back in about a week.
[2:09:01] So since our last meeting, at our last meeting,
[2:09:07] we basically talked about basic design of the project,
[2:09:11] how the intersection was going to look mainly.
[2:09:14] Since then, there were some things that changed.
[2:09:20] We were trying to keep the alignment of the project
[2:09:22] so that we didn't have to redo the crossing at Frank Cooley.
[2:09:31] We couldn't get a curve to fit in there, so we wound up
[2:09:34] having to do hydraulic analysis of extending those pipes.
[2:09:39] That's what's the first option.
[2:09:42] Looking into that, it looked like we'd have to add several other
[2:09:47] large pipes to get that to work.
[2:09:50] So backing up a little bit, we decided to go ahead with a
[2:09:55] stiff-like structure instead and save quite a bit of money
[2:09:59] over extending the pipes and adding the other pipes,
[2:10:03] had to do that to meet the requirements
[2:10:05] for the hydraulics for that flood wave on the prank cooling.
[2:10:14] So the purpose of the project is to provide a route
[2:10:18] around CSI to make it easy for motorists
[2:10:23] to get around the college.
[2:10:25] Also, decrease the traffic congestion inside the college
[2:10:30] and reduce the conflicts between pedestrians
[2:10:35] and traffic in the college.
[2:10:36] So that was the main purpose of the project.
[2:10:42] Okay, so this is a layout of the project.
[2:10:46] Over on this side here is where this is Washington Street,
[2:10:49] right here, and that light is already in place, correct?
[2:10:56] That light right there is in place, that's correct.
[2:10:58] And then the chaining would go straight across,
[2:11:00] right there, that's where chaining is,
[2:11:03] next straight into Chaney. There's about 150 feet here that matches the other side,
[2:11:08] and it starts tapering back into a two-lane section, and comes all the way around
[2:11:14] two-lane, and then whitens in this area for some more turn lanes for the
[2:11:19] intersection in this area, which is the new North College approach right here.
[2:11:23] Susanne Hawkins, you want to go back to that, maybe?
[2:11:31] I'm sure this is not a... You've probably answered this in the past, but since I'm new,
[2:11:36] How does this become more cost effective than doing an over or underground walkway to connect the north and south campuses?
[2:11:45] Instead of redirecting the whole road, I mean to me it seems like it could be less costly to put in some kind of a walkway for the students to cross the road instead of redirecting traffic.
[2:11:57] I'm just curious.
[2:11:59] It would be less costly to do a qua, I'm sure, getting people to use them is another thing.
[2:12:08] Plus, this also gives people an alternative thing going through the campus to get where
[2:12:15] they need to go, to avoid the conflicts, and it's basically an expressway around the campus
[2:12:23] so you don't have to go through the campus, which is in any other campus.
[2:12:27] And as the campus expands, you would have to put more and more walkways in to the west.
[2:12:34] And like you said, getting them to use them, short of eight foot fences, kids will just walk
[2:12:41] across the street rather than go up or go down.
[2:12:45] Just curious.
[2:12:46] So it's probably, and it's also part of the overall transportation plan for the city is to
[2:12:53] have this route around the campus.
[2:12:55] That roadway section of Chaney and connecting into North College's approximately 7th-10th
[2:13:09] of a mile.
[2:13:12] And it also includes the new North College entrance, which is a stop control intersection.
[2:13:17] And we've got a better layout of that right here.
[2:13:21] So what we have at the intersection is we've got a through lane coming through on the outside,
[2:13:28] lane coming through right there, a right turn lane into the campus or on to North College,
[2:13:37] and left turn lane on to North College, free running right, which allows traffic to come
[2:13:48] around the corner and then this is going to extend around all the way to the entrance
[2:13:53] to the Expo Center.
[2:13:55] So he has a chance to merge and get off the campus and onto, again, North College down here.
[2:14:05] So it likes to expedite the traffic flow out of and onto the college.
[2:14:12] This leaves this open up here for pedestrian refuge.
[2:14:20] The rotary is looking at building a bike path along Prankouli.
[2:14:26] This would be an ideal spot to cross if that happens here,
[2:14:32] especially with no stop control on that.
[2:14:34] It gives them a refuge area in Ontario.
[2:14:37] It's a good area.
[2:14:41] Typical section, curb gutter sidewalk on the south side,
[2:14:46] with a shoulder on the north side.
[2:14:49] The sidewalk, and the sidewalks there
[2:14:51] for the pedestrians, of course, on the south side.
[2:14:55] Also includes a new storm grain system for the whole Chaney
[2:14:59] road, sort of taking care of that, and signing and pavement markings.
[2:15:06] So this is a typical section of the road, most of it's a two-lane section.
[2:15:15] So there's a curb getter on this side, sidewalk on basically the CSI side, and this leaves room
[2:15:24] for future expansion on the other side to a full build out.
[2:15:35] Okay, the environmental document on this was approved May 8th of this year.
[2:15:45] A couple of things that I highlighted out of the document, we did do a noise study along
[2:15:54] the route to see if the noise levels increased enough to make any difference at all.
[2:16:00] And through the analysis, noise levels weren't raised mainly because it's not going to be
[2:16:07] major truck route, it's given mostly passenger vehicles.
[2:16:13] Another thing is that the change in travel pattern,
[2:16:17] we looked at it a couple of different ways,
[2:16:19] but what we project is that 25% of the traffic
[2:16:24] will take the new route, and 75% will remain on
[2:16:29] and go into the, mainly into the college.
[2:16:32] I'm, I'm, I'm, I'm surprised that it's only 25%,
[2:16:35] I think of how many times I came to the,
[2:16:38] that intersection by Walmart from a variety of different directions, including the hospital
[2:16:43] Walmart or from the North. And since I live on the other side of blue legs, I almost always
[2:16:48] come up to college and turn left, and I don't think I will ever come up to college and turn
[2:16:52] left now. I will always take the new chain because it's just much more, it makes more
[2:16:58] sense. So I guess maybe I would think it's going to be more than 25%, but maybe I'm just
[2:17:02] thinking about myself.
[2:17:04] We did an origin and destination study to come up with these numbers and it also, it matches
[2:17:10] perfectly with the projections that were done in the transportation plan for the city.
[2:17:15] So we have two different sources.
[2:17:16] That's how we came up with the numbers.
[2:17:19] But we actually stopped people and asked them where they were going and a large percentage
[2:17:23] of them were going to the campus.
[2:17:30] So another part of this, because we couldn't fit that curve in, we had to go through some
[2:17:43] through the floodplain in Cooley, the front Cooley.
[2:17:48] So we're proposed taking out the two large pipes there
[2:17:55] and putting in a stiff leg structure to replace those pipes.
[2:18:00] Also up the road a little ways, almost to where it bends,
[2:18:09] There's a temporary retention pond in there
[2:18:13] that's storing, right now storing water
[2:18:16] for what comes off of Washington Street.
[2:18:19] We'll connect into that with this project
[2:18:21] and then tie all that water together,
[2:18:25] put it through a sediment cleanup.
[2:18:34] Put it through a treatment facility
[2:18:36] and then dump it into the prime cooley.
[2:18:39] We did do a clomart for that
[2:18:42] to make sure that was okay and the FEMA had no issues
[2:18:47] with the rise of the flood wave, so.
[2:18:50] We have a light, we'll sort you.
[2:18:52] Thank you, Mayor.
[2:18:53] So will that prevent flooding over the roadway,
[2:18:55] or is that still possibility even after?
[2:18:59] Yes, the roadway is not in the floodplain.
[2:19:02] Okay.
[2:19:03] It goes over the floodplain, where the culverts are.
[2:19:10] We stay out of the floodplain the rest of the time.
[2:19:13] but where it goes over the floodplain,
[2:19:15] is there a possibility of flooding there,
[2:19:17] or that will be mitigated with the drainage?
[2:19:20] With the box, the stiff leg structure
[2:19:23] would mitigate the raising of the water level.
[2:19:27] That was the problem we were having
[2:19:28] with the two barrels, is we couldn't get enough barrels in there
[2:19:32] to keep the water level down,
[2:19:35] and so we had to go to a new option.
[2:19:37] Okay, thank you.
[2:19:40] And another part of this is the wetlands.
[2:19:43] Of course, there's the Prankooly and the Lateral Poreador
[2:19:47] considered wetlands, but we don't disturb enough of them
[2:19:51] to have to mitigate through the core,
[2:19:52] so that's a good thing.
[2:19:57] Which would take replacement of wetlands usually.
[2:20:04] So the new schedule we're looking at
[2:20:08] is get the, summarize these comments from this meeting.
[2:20:13] We'll submit for design approval,
[2:20:15] which gives us the go-ahead to go forward with final design,
[2:20:20] look at it a couple months to do final design,
[2:20:24] and then it usually takes about a month to get a review,
[2:20:27] and I look to get it in another month after that for PSNE,
[2:20:33] which is the final documents for bidding, basically,
[2:20:36] Plan, specs, and estimates for bidding.
[2:20:40] We're looking at trying to get this done so we can get the
[2:20:44] the stiff leg structure and before the now water comes in or before the irrigation season
[2:20:49] next year and also get the pipe in under 41 lateral before irrigation season.
[2:20:56] And so construction next summer?
[2:20:59] That's the plan.
[2:21:06] So in conclusion this route does provide an easier way for people to get around the campus
[2:21:13] And also, it does reduce the conflicts by reducing them
[2:21:17] or cars that go through the campus
[2:21:19] and the pedestrian conflicts in the campus.
[2:21:25] So if there's any questions.
[2:21:28] I would like to say, Mike, do you have any, Mike Mason,
[2:21:30] by VP at the college?
[2:21:31] Did you have any comments?
[2:21:33] No.
[2:21:35] Oh, you can you step the mic?
[2:21:36] We have people watching on TV, so.
[2:21:39] I'm Mike Mason, Vice President of Administration
[2:21:41] for the College of Health and Health.
[2:21:42] As you know, I think we've been working on this since President
[2:21:44] Meyerhoff was was present about seven years ago.
[2:21:47] We have some funding through a federal grant.
[2:21:49] We have some other reserves,
[2:21:50] and it's a critical project to us,
[2:21:52] so we're really hopeful to get it going next summer.
[2:21:54] I think it'll make a big difference on our campus.
[2:21:57] North College, we will slow down.
[2:21:58] When we get this alternate route,
[2:22:00] we've been talking to engineered Jackie Fields,
[2:22:03] concerning some traffic calming measures,
[2:22:05] not speed bumps, but other issues to slow that down,
[2:22:08] which will greatly enhance the safety and expansion
[2:22:09] of the campus.
[2:22:11] Thank you.
[2:22:12] Thank you, Mike.
[2:22:13] Chris talked to it.
[2:22:14] Jackie, is this signal tight end of this project at all,
[2:22:18] uh, funding-wise, uh, requirement, or, uh,
[2:22:22] what, we signalized, we agreed to signalize, right,
[2:22:27] at North College and Fillmore that ties into the chaining,
[2:22:31] or is that not associated with this at all?
[2:22:34] That is not associated with this.
[2:22:36] Excuse me. Okay.
[2:22:37] It's, it's paid for with impact fees.
[2:22:40] I thought that if I thought the signal coming up with film or there was
[2:22:46] merging West with Cheney. It will the change in the new chain you will come into
[2:22:52] this signal so you she's missing she's not understanding question but there's
[2:23:00] a distance there so the right edge of the frame and then about a quarter mile up
[2:23:16] maybe a little less than a quarter-mile,
[2:23:18] less than a signal.
[2:23:19] Gotcha.
[2:23:22] Rebecca, my question's for our city engineer, Jackie Fields.
[2:23:27] Is this going to be, when it's completed,
[2:23:30] a city street maintained and funded maintenance by the city?
[2:23:37] It'll be maintained by the city, yes.
[2:23:40] So it'll be a city street?
[2:23:41] Yes.
[2:23:42] OK.
[2:23:42] And so does the width, I'm looking
[2:23:45] at the width of the typical section of Cheney,
[2:23:49] it doesn't seem like it conforms to city code.
[2:23:54] Is that going to match city code and just being a Tulane 31
[2:23:59] feet wide?
[2:24:01] It doesn't match code right now.
[2:24:05] And we are confident that it will match code as the land
[2:24:10] to the north of CSI develops.
[2:24:15] OK, so when they build it, they're
[2:24:17] not going to build it to city code, but someday it will be built to city code, is that what
[2:24:23] you're saying?
[2:24:24] Yes.
[2:24:25] This project will build enough capacity to complete the requirements of the, for federal
[2:24:31] aid for this project.
[2:24:34] In the future, when the neighborhood to the north of the CSI campus develops and the loads
[2:24:40] on Chaney increase more, they will build the rest of the road.
[2:24:47] Okay, and that was one of my questions too.
[2:24:50] Can you show the map of the alignment of the road?
[2:24:55] My concern was how the land to the north is going to develop as far as your...
[2:25:02] I would think you would want engineering wise, you would want multiple ingress and egress around that area.
[2:25:11] So how is it going to connect up with Cheney, you know?
[2:25:15] say where Lazyjay in that land to the north is, you know, they're obviously going to need
[2:25:21] to be access points that go north towards Pullline and then also south towards Chieni
[2:25:29] and, you know, kind of access north and south, which in our city in general we kind of have
[2:25:36] a need for.
[2:25:38] And so my concern with this proposed alignment is how is it going to accommodate roadways
[2:25:47] and access with the land to the north?
[2:25:56] So yeah, one isn't here so I should be in good shape.
[2:26:05] So let's see, in this area that road is full width and it is centered on the property lines.
[2:26:19] This area isn't ready to develop. The plan is that in this section the road is
[2:26:28] built to half width and then it is built by this neighborhood. There is a PUD out on
[2:26:33] this area of land and I think it extends all the way to Washington Street, yes, and
[2:26:38] there's a circulation pattern associated with that PUD that acknowledge that this
[2:26:43] This roadway was part of the plan and so the intent is that they work together and we end
[2:26:51] up with a roadway alignment and width that works for the community.
[2:26:56] This piece of land over here is endowment land.
[2:27:03] So this road is not going through the endowment land and Gold's Gym.
[2:27:09] I don't really know.
[2:27:11] I don't know if that's actually answering the question that you were asking.
[2:27:14] She's wondering if there's any roads we're going to ever go north and connect to Poland,
[2:27:18] I believe.
[2:27:19] Correct.
[2:27:20] Correct.
[2:27:21] Yeah, that's what I'm wondering.
[2:27:22] Just because, you know, for example, you have Fred Meyer where you can exit from, you
[2:27:28] know, the all different directions from the east and the west, you know, and it alleviates
[2:27:34] traffic if there's more than one exit.
[2:27:38] And so when I'm asking about, yeah, the north, the lazy JPUD, you know, will that only exit
[2:27:44] onto pole line, or will it somehow connect to the proposed genie?
[2:27:50] So I'm going to jump in here a little bit.
[2:27:54] A couple of years ago, we looked at a PUD for the Lazy J property, which includes the park,
[2:27:59] the trailer park, and then all the way over to Washington Street.
[2:28:03] They did have on that PUD master development plan.
[2:28:07] So it's all commercial.
[2:28:08] So it's a big commercial PUD.
[2:28:10] That commercial master development plan over here was actually realized with some building
[2:28:15] layouts and stuff like that.
[2:28:16] This piece of it basically said we're going to come back and do that later when all these
[2:28:22] homes go away.
[2:28:23] But what it did show was a street lining up, this is Harrison Street basically, lining up
[2:28:28] with Harrison at Poline and coming down this side of the property which we've got, half of
[2:28:32] that right away already dedicated, and then at the bottom it bends over here and then does
[2:28:38] this same kind of movement down here, just up here, and there's an intersection where
[2:28:42] you can get onto Harrison Street and up. It also shows driveway accesses at a couple of
[2:28:47] points into the commercial property. And that was approved, I want to say, two years ago,
[2:28:54] maybe.
[2:28:55] Okay, so that would be the master plan. I think that answered my question. So if you
[2:28:58] were coming down Harrison, would that street also connect over to Cheney, where you could
[2:29:04] to turn right and go south or continue on over towards.
[2:29:09] But it won't go through the endowment property.
[2:29:11] Correct.
[2:29:12] It'll turn on, follow the property line and intersect like over here on to Harrison.
[2:29:16] And the internal access for this PUD does have, there is a driveway approach out on to Pulline.
[2:29:25] And I believe there's two.
[2:29:28] And then mince as I recall to going right behind that existing house on the other side
[2:29:34] Oh over here your private road that went that full length as well because there's a driveway right up there at the end of that
[2:29:42] Yeah, there wasn't like an east-west interior road, but it was more like an access aisle
[2:29:47] It won't be a dedicated city street right and it kind of goes this way and then there was another one that kind of
[2:29:53] to buy a sex problem.
[2:29:54] It's going to be a private road, but they're utilizing it to move traffic from blue lights
[2:29:58] or should be pole line two businesses, but also it will end up moving traffic from pole
[2:30:04] line two chaining.
[2:30:05] And then if you look at pole line in Harrison right now, that curb approach on the south
[2:30:12] side is built.
[2:30:13] So we can see where the intersection will be, but the road isn't quite there yet.
[2:30:18] And we've got, like I said, 30 feet of right away dedicated already for it through here,
[2:30:22] and then this development when it develops will dedicate the other half.
[2:30:26] And that will be just a collector road.
[2:30:27] It won't be this four lane, you know, like Cheney's going to be.
[2:30:31] And like I said, it'll come down this alignment.
[2:30:33] And that will be dedicated city street owned and maintained by us.
[2:30:40] Greg mentioned another one that kind of by six probably over here.
[2:30:43] That's private and access drive.
[2:30:47] Okay. I think that answers my question.
[2:30:49] Thank you.
[2:30:49] I do have a couple more questions for Jackie fields, if I could.
[2:30:53] You're saying it will be built fully out when the land to the north develops.
[2:30:58] What about when it curves down through? That's all college owned property, right?
[2:31:03] So will that ever need to be fully built out to city standards?
[2:31:13] That section of roadway is not proposed to have accesses on it.
[2:31:20] So, the number of driveways that you have on a roadway decreases its capacity and brings
[2:31:26] forward the time at which you absolutely have to do road widening.
[2:31:31] Someday, yes, that will need to be widened.
[2:31:35] When you say someday is that, I'm just wondering about, you know, building a road and then
[2:31:42] how many years later we would need to widen it and I know you can't project out into the
[2:31:47] future.
[2:31:48] For current day capacity, is this road going to be wide enough?
[2:31:53] Yes.
[2:31:54] Yes.
[2:31:57] For current day capacity needs it will be wide enough.
[2:32:00] Otherwise, retail engineers can't build a new alignment.
[2:32:06] So they had to do a capacity analysis.
[2:32:08] Okay.
[2:32:09] That road had to be wide enough on that job or they would not be able to go for it.
[2:32:15] For the next 20 years.
[2:32:16] I'm not mocking their numbers or anything, but I want you to remember that these things
[2:32:24] are a little loose, okay? Just like when we say, I think, the road will have four more
[2:32:32] years of life and it dies a year and a half from now. We get close.
[2:32:39] So, so what is your recommendation? I mean, what, what is your...
[2:32:42] My recommendation is to build this job as in, in a way that meets the federal aid requirements
[2:32:50] and this project is doing it at this time.
[2:32:53] Okay. And, sorry, last question.
[2:32:57] The estimated 25% of the traffic that it will take, is that a significant amount or, I mean,
[2:33:04] to me it just seems insignificant, but maybe for traffic counts that significant, is it
[2:33:09] going to justify the creation of this new roadway and you know the perpetual maintenance and
[2:33:17] Further widening by the city. I mean for just that 25%
[2:33:21] But by engineering standards is that significant 25% of traffic? So
[2:33:36] 25% isn't necessarily significant but several thousand cars a day is and
[2:33:40] And so, having the lanes there will be handy, and in the long term, our alignment is set.
[2:33:50] So as we grow, we have a place to grow to, to me, that's a good thing.
[2:34:00] So this is the preferred alignment from the city's perspective?
[2:34:09] Yes.
[2:34:11] Are you sure?
[2:34:13] You know, okay, so if we're really belonging
[2:34:17] to the Flat of Earth Society, it might have been nice
[2:34:20] to have Chaney go all the way forward to Chaney
[2:34:22] at Fillmore, but there's a building in the way
[2:34:24] and there's endowment land and there's a very expensive
[2:34:27] structure that we were trying to avoid building
[2:34:30] and that was not the preferred alignment.
[2:34:32] Right, so for the current conditions, for what we have,
[2:34:35] I mean, I'm not asking for your preferred,
[2:34:37] you know, in an ideal world, but preferred for what we have.
[2:34:40] This is the preferred alignment for the project.
[2:34:45] Jackie, could you point where, or someone on city staff,
[2:34:48] point where we acquire half land or in the process of acquiring land
[2:34:53] for a potential another fire station?
[2:34:56] Where's that at on this alignment right there, right?
[2:35:02] Thank you.
[2:35:04] Okay, so maybe I'll ask the question in a different way.
[2:35:07] Is there, if you weren't going to use this alignment,
[2:35:12] just for our benefit or for the community's benefit,
[2:35:15] What would a different alignment of Cheney look like?
[2:35:21] Or would there not be one?
[2:35:22] This would be the primary preferred.
[2:35:24] This is it.
[2:35:26] OK.
[2:35:27] Thank you.
[2:35:29] Dave, that is for lights.
[2:35:31] What action or non-action do we have here for it?
[2:35:38] Are we doing public hearing?
[2:35:40] We are doing public hearing.
[2:35:41] I apologize.
[2:35:42] I missed that portion.
[2:35:43] I really didn't really say that on here.
[2:35:45] All right.
[2:35:46] Anyone in the public that I will open the public hearing
[2:35:48] to anyone in the public that would like to talk to us
[2:35:51] about this issue and about this
[2:35:54] in the alignment of Chaney Drive.
[2:35:57] This is your chance for public comment.
[2:36:01] Seeing no one close the public hearing portion.
[2:36:03] Now what action do we possibly need or not need?
[2:36:07] Friends, nothing?
[2:36:09] All right.
[2:36:10] Did you want to have some closing comments?
[2:36:14] Yeah, I'd just like to reiterate if I comment sheets
[2:36:21] And we'd like to comment.
[2:36:24] We do have other forms of commenting on this project.
[2:36:27] So we have a hearing officer here if you want to give
[2:36:30] a private oral testimony.
[2:36:32] We've got comment sheets that you can build up in
[2:36:35] and give to us or mail back to us.
[2:36:38] So if we could, I just wanted to reiterate that
[2:36:42] to make sure that everybody has an opportunity to comment.
[2:36:45] Sure.
[2:36:46] And if anybody's listening, how would somebody's
[2:36:48] watching us on the Internet or on Channel 17,
[2:36:51] How would they get a hold of those comment sheets?
[2:36:53] They can come by our office at 202 Falls Avenue and I'll get them at the comment sheet and
[2:37:00] they can fill it out there or mail back to us.
[2:37:02] There's a week.
[2:37:03] I have a time limit and I'm trying to expedite these so I can get our design approval.
[2:37:09] Do you have an email address?
[2:37:11] Yes.
[2:37:12] A W E R T.
[2:37:15] A W E R T at.
[2:37:18] R I E.
[2:37:19] R I E.
[2:37:20] E-R-I-E-D-E-D-E-S-E-L-E-N-G-E-N-G-D-E-E-E-E-E-E-E-E-E-E-E-E-E-E-E-E-E-E-E-E-E-E-E-E-E-E-E-E-E-E-E-E-E-E-E-E-E-E-E-E-E-E-E-E-E-E-E-E-E-E-E-E-E-E-E-E-E-E-E-E-E-E-E-E-E-E-E-E-E-E-E-E-E-E-E-E-E-E-E-E-E-E-E-E-E-E-E-E-E-E-E-E-E-E
[2:37:50] We've all signed and there's one in the back as well.
[2:37:53] All right, if we have anyone else from council
[2:37:56] have any other business for us tonight, Travis?
[2:38:00] Oh, I did close the vote here.
[2:38:02] I did.
[2:38:03] No.
[2:38:04] So this item is closed.
[2:38:06] I'm asking if there's anything else for the council
[2:38:09] seeing none.
[2:38:10] We're adjourned.
