Oversight Archive: City Council meeting, 2013-12-16, recording 1 (started 17:00)
Machine transcript (faster-whisper base.en), not checked word for word; the Pledge of Allegiance is shown in its standard wording. The recording is the record.
Times are time into the recording. Passages with private details are muted in the audio and marked here.
The audio on the page below was re-encoded by software from the video the agency posted. Check any passage against
that audio before relying on it.
Page: https://oversightarchive.org/twin-falls-id/meetings/2013-12-16/

[0:04:10] Call the medium to fall city council for Monday November 18 2013 to order or
[0:04:17] December 16 I got the minutes out don't I just December 16 thanks Sean if you
[0:04:25] like our first item is the pledge if you'd like Jonas please rise
[0:04:49] Let me find a page that makes sense here.
[0:04:55] There we go.
[0:04:56] All right, confirm we've got a quorum.
[0:04:58] All seven members are here.
[0:05:01] Introduction to staff.
[0:05:03] It's highlights here of city manager,
[0:05:05] Travis Rothwider, city attorney, Fritz Wunderlich,
[0:05:08] meeting development director, Mitch Humboldt
[0:05:10] and deputy city clerk,
[0:05:11] recording secretary of the out of the Sanchez.
[0:05:14] Oh, good, I've got a radio this way, okay.
[0:05:18] Mr. Rothwider, do we have any amendments to the agenda?
[0:05:21] Mr. Mayor and members of the council staff
[0:05:23] I would ask that you consider adding an alcohol license transfer to the new owners of the historic ballroom,
[0:05:30] LLC located at 205 and 210 Shoshone Street North.
[0:05:36] This item came in earlier today, and there are new owners at the historic ballroom,
[0:05:41] and they have a series of events that they have planned for the holiday season,
[0:05:46] and they would like to be operating in compliance with the law.
[0:05:49] Move to add that to the consent calendar second
[0:05:53] Then move by Chris Tackington and seconded by Don Paul who add the alcohol license for the
[0:06:00] Ballroom to the consent calendar
[0:06:02] See no white so they have a roll call vote
[0:06:07] Yes
[0:06:10] Yes
[0:06:15] Yes
[0:06:16] Motion passes 7-0.
[0:06:18] Gring to start our first item of business then
[0:06:21] is the consent calendar,
[0:06:22] council wishes, don't hold.
[0:06:24] Move approval.
[0:06:25] Second.
[0:06:26] They move by Don Hall and second by Suzanne Hawkins
[0:06:29] that we approve the consent calendar as amended.
[0:06:32] So you know, like the other roll call vote.
[0:06:37] Jim Mann.
[0:06:38] Yes.
[0:06:39] Rebecca Mann, so I guess.
[0:06:40] Yes.
[0:06:41] Chris Hawkins.
[0:06:42] Yes.
[0:06:43] Sean Berriger.
[0:06:44] Yes.
[0:06:45] Don Hall.
[0:06:45] Yes.
[0:06:47] Don Hawkins.
[0:06:47] Yes.
[0:06:48] Yes, I am passes 7 to 0 moving on to item number one on the regular agenda
[0:06:58] I was wearing an in-ceremony for Twin Falls Police Department's newest police officer Nate Egan
[0:07:05] Get there, right? All right is requested and that I will be administering the oath and
[0:07:10] Don Hall will be helped you a bit. Chief Mike's gonna talk to us about first
[0:07:14] Thank you, mary members of the council as you mentioned mary tonight
[0:07:17] We do have the honor of swearing in one of our newest officers, Nate Egan.
[0:07:22] Captain Hicks and I had the privilege of attending Nate's graduation from the Post Academy last Friday.
[0:07:27] So it's a little bit different order for us this time.
[0:07:30] If I could have Nate, if I could have you come forward, Nate.
[0:07:34] And Nate did very well at the Academy. And Nate really, one of the challenges facing you now
[0:07:39] is the forging of theory and practical application knowledge.
[0:07:42] And you'll do this over the next 16 weeks while you participate in our field training program.
[0:07:47] And the destination is ultimately to reach a point of competence and professionalism to
[0:07:52] serve our community.
[0:07:53] Council, let me introduce you to our newest hire, Nate Egan.
[0:07:57] He was hired by our department August 26, 2013.
[0:08:01] Nate was born and raised in Rexburg, Idaho.
[0:08:03] He graduated from Madison High School in Rexburg and received his equal scout.
[0:08:08] He served the LDS mission in Tokyo, Japan.
[0:08:10] He went on to further his education by attending BYU, Idaho, and Eastern Idaho Technical College.
[0:08:16] Prior to his employment with the Twin Falls Police Department, Nate worked for Summit,
[0:08:20] Investments and Rexburg Idol as a truck driver in the oil fields of North Dakota.
[0:08:25] Nate and his wife, Sarah, have two small boys.
[0:08:28] Nate looks forward to serving the community of Twin Falls and fulfilling his dream of being a police officer.
[0:08:33] Nate, tonight the ceremony consists of two parts, the painting of the police badge and the oath of officers administered by Mayor Lanting,
[0:08:42] and our police liaison on Hall.
[0:08:45] The oath that you're about to take tonight represents the heart of everything that we do.
[0:08:50] These are more than words repeated in the paper signed.
[0:08:54] The badge you received tonight is a symbol of your office and the trust that the community has placed in you to perform your job and to perform it in a professional manner.
[0:09:03] By raising your hand and affirming your commitment to provide public safety to our community, you'll be empowered to perform the functions of this job.
[0:09:11] My charge to you is always mindful of the community's trust and ever diligent in your duties.
[0:09:18] I can have the mayor and councilor John Paul join.
[0:09:41] It is all of these where will support the trustees of the United States of America.
[0:09:47] The trustees of the state of Iowa, state of Iowa, and the law of the Lord of Kingston.
[0:09:57] It's a beautiful call.
[0:09:59] It's in the rule of regulation.
[0:10:02] It's in the fall's police department and that I will well and act as a well.
[0:10:11] and basically discharged the duties of the office of police officer,
[0:10:16] the officer of the office of police officer,
[0:10:22] the most pleased partner in the office,
[0:10:28] which I have been appointed,
[0:10:31] according to law, and according to the law,
[0:10:34] I'm going to measure my middle and to the next night.
[0:10:36] Welcome.
[0:11:13] And, officer, you probably would be asked to do some special time
[0:11:16] September Summit this year, we have a special event coming up.
[0:11:19] I was afraid Chris was going to ask a constitutional question.
[0:11:24] I just figured these could let you know that the chances of vacation around that time were
[0:11:30] probably pretty thin.
[0:11:32] All right.
[0:11:33] Do we have one more as well?
[0:11:36] I really, yeah.
[0:11:37] Another award to be a captain partner.
[0:11:42] Good evening.
[0:11:43] Thank you Mr. Mayor and members of the Council for giving us this opportunity to recognize and honor the achievements of our employees tonight.
[0:11:50] It is vitally important to us that we have a well-trained professional police department capable of providing the best possible public safety to our community,
[0:11:58] and I think that everyone would agree with that.
[0:12:00] Tonight we will be recognizing Officer Dusty Solomon with our Advanced Certificate.
[0:12:05] It takes hundreds of training hours, time and service, and college credits to achieve this certificate.
[0:12:12] I would ask that Officer Sullivan please come forward at this time.
[0:12:16] I would also ask that Chief Mike, the Mayor of Landing, and our police liaison, Vice Mayor
[0:12:22] Hall please come forward and help present the certificate.
[0:12:30] Dusty Sullivan began her employment as a full-time police officer with the Twin Falls Police Department
[0:12:35] on August 15, 2007.
[0:12:38] Dusty was born in Boise, Idaho and grew up in Southern Idaho.
[0:12:41] After graduating from Wendell High School, Dusty obtained her bachelor of arts degree
[0:12:47] and Elementary Education from Lewis Clark State College in Lewis,
[0:12:50] Idaho. Dusty joined the Twin Falls Police Department as a reserve police
[0:12:55] officer in April of 2007 and became a full-time patrol officer in August of
[0:13:01] 2007. In July of 2009 Dusty became a member of the Crisis Negotiation Unit and
[0:13:07] in 2011 Dusty was assigned to the Juvenile Crimes Unit as a school
[0:13:12] resource officer. In 2012 Dusty achieved her long-term goal of becoming a canine
[0:13:18] handler for the Twin Pulse Police Department, and currently handles Caster, a dual purpose
[0:13:23] canine. Dusty was awarded her post intermediate certificate in August of 2009. It is with great
[0:13:31] pleasure that we present Dusty Solomon with her advanced certificate from the State of Idaho
[0:13:35] Peace Officer Standards and Training Council.
[0:14:20] Oh, well, it's always a pleasure for me because my background is in law enforcement. Also, currently
[0:14:27] I, along with Jim Mon, actually, we run the law enforcement program at CSI.
[0:14:33] I believe I came to your academy and taught the cheery subject of death notification, not
[0:14:38] on a go and had the privilege of engaging you there.
[0:14:42] So, congratulations and welcome aboard.
[0:14:44] And of course, Dusty, thank you for your continued hard work and your achievement of your advanced
[0:14:49] certificate.
[0:14:50] Thank you.
[0:14:51] Thank you.
[0:14:53] Moving on to item number two, consider us a request to approve the purchase of three
[0:14:58] 300 ST-1300P Police Motorcycle Sergeant Ryan Howl is going to cover this one although your
[0:15:07] sports leave it though I thought they'd let's dig around through this for the least that way
[0:15:11] if I mess something up good evening council members I'm here tonight I would like to request
[0:15:20] that we proceed with a purchase of 300 ST-1300P motorcycles for the police department in the
[0:15:28] 2013-2014 budget year, the Police Department was authorized $57,000 to replace three 2002 BMW motorcycles following the Idaho Code bid process.
[0:15:44] We requested three bids, one from Adventure Motorsports, one from Pocatello Power Sports, and one from Let's Write Honda.
[0:15:52] We received bids back from each of the three dealers and the lowest bidder was the adventure
[0:15:58] motor sports with the total price for the three motorcycles of $49,479.
[0:16:06] This included delivery to the city shop in Twin Falls as well as the black color on motorcycles.
[0:16:12] I would like to request that we proceed with this purchase.
[0:16:17] the remainder of the $57,000 is to be used
[0:16:20] for the upfitting of the motorcycles
[0:16:21] with different accessories that will be needed
[0:16:24] for police work.
[0:16:27] I do have one light, Don Hall.
[0:16:29] Sergeant Hall, I know this is already in the budget
[0:16:31] and I know that the process needs to come in front of us.
[0:16:33] I just had a curiosity more than anything.
[0:16:37] I know that we've kind of bounced around
[0:16:38] with different makes of motorcycles.
[0:16:40] We've had Harley's, we've had Kawasaki's,
[0:16:43] we've had BMW's, now we're Honda.
[0:16:46] And I'm assuming this is the newest, maybe describe the motorcycle for me a little bit,
[0:16:51] so I understand.
[0:16:52] We actually have two of the motorcycles this year.
[0:16:54] We purchased them within the last two budget years.
[0:16:57] The reason we decided to go with the Honda over the other brands of motorcycle, they
[0:17:03] were the ones that were making the motorcycle at the time.
[0:17:06] Harley has always been in the business and BMW has kept a police motorcycle.
[0:17:12] The Hondas are much less expensive than the BMWs.
[0:17:17] And the Harleys, when we had them before as a police department,
[0:17:22] we had some, I don't want to call them maintenance issues
[0:17:26] with the Harley-Davidson motorcycles,
[0:17:28] but we had to have some things that were not conducive
[0:17:30] to police work within the city.
[0:17:33] OK.
[0:17:33] So the Honda is a liquid cold motorcycle,
[0:17:37] which works better for us.
[0:17:39] OK.
[0:17:39] That's one of the better things that we found.
[0:17:42] We've got ABS braking.
[0:17:44] The police model is actually wired specifically for police work,
[0:17:48] and that's what the 1300P is for.
[0:17:51] OK.
[0:17:51] Thank you very much, Paul.
[0:17:54] Chris, I would move to accept the low-vet of $49,479
[0:17:59] for the described equipment bid by adventure motorsports.
[0:18:05] Second.
[0:18:07] Then moved by Chris talking the same way, not Hall,
[0:18:09] that we approve the bid by adventure motorsports.
[0:18:12] with Twin Falls, see no dish on lights,
[0:18:15] I have a roll call vote.
[0:18:16] Perfect, no sweat gas?
[0:18:17] Yes.
[0:18:18] Just talking to him?
[0:18:19] Yes.
[0:18:20] Dr. Sean Berger?
[0:18:21] Yes.
[0:18:22] Don Hall?
[0:18:23] Yes.
[0:18:24] Suzanne Hopkins?
[0:18:25] Yes.
[0:18:26] Greg Lanzou?
[0:18:27] Yes.
[0:18:28] Jen Mon?
[0:18:29] Yes.
[0:18:30] Motion passes, 7 to 0.
[0:18:31] Thank you for your help.
[0:18:32] We want item number three.
[0:18:34] Consideration of the request to authorize the marriage
[0:18:36] of sign a cooperative agreement with ITD for Americans
[0:18:40] of a Disability Act Curb Ramp Program Key 13990
[0:18:44] to adopt a resolution confirming this commitment.
[0:18:47] We have a resolution number said to be said
[0:18:49] to do that well, 1913, all right.
[0:18:55] Welcome.
[0:18:56] Thank you.
[0:18:57] I'm Josh Brad, I'm a staff engineer here.
[0:19:01] Real quick, the background is back in April of this year,
[0:19:04] the state came out with a program
[0:19:06] that authorized cities to apply for up to $60,000 of funds
[0:19:11] to replace delinquent curb ramps on the state highway system.
[0:19:17] The city went ahead and applied for the funds.
[0:19:20] We were notified, I believe, in July about that.
[0:19:23] But we received the full $6,000 that we applied for
[0:19:26] to construct 11 ramps.
[0:19:28] And as part of the process, the city also has completed a mandatory
[0:19:35] training, and I'm about 20 of our staff members attended that
[0:19:38] by, and it was conducted by the Federal Highway Administration.
[0:19:43] The ramp locations are, you can see here it's in your packet,
[0:19:46] a lot of them are on Blue Lakes South,
[0:19:48] or rather Blue Lakes Boulevard,
[0:19:52] and then one on US, or if you want to do us Highway 30.
[0:19:58] So with that, I guess I would ask you to consider
[0:20:01] that you authorize the contract with ITV,
[0:20:10] and replace those 11 ramps at the $60,000.
[0:20:15] Is that an estimated cost, or is that what we've been bid?
[0:20:18] Well, that is the price was fixed.
[0:20:21] We could go up to $60,000.
[0:20:24] I went ahead and estimated probably a little bit lower than that.
[0:20:27] I think I estimate about $40,000 is what I think it's actually going to cost
[0:20:31] because if there are any overtures in charge of paying for those,
[0:20:35] I didn't want to do that.
[0:20:36] So if there's overtures, we should still be covered with the grant money.
[0:20:40] Okay. Thank you.
[0:20:42] Christine.
[0:20:43] But also I was looking at the map, it's a little difficult to tell and all of them, it looks
[0:20:47] like at least some of their placements going to and from public schools, is that a fair
[0:20:53] assessment?
[0:20:54] I would say the three on the right there are intended to go to, I think it's pick a little
[0:21:00] elementary school.
[0:21:01] They're going to get up there Chris.
[0:21:03] Oh, these are great?
[0:21:04] Yeah.
[0:21:05] Well, I just looked at it.
[0:21:06] As well as the other one, it's close to Lincoln Elementary School.
[0:21:10] The locations were chosen first of all because they were on the state highway, second of all.
[0:21:16] We look for areas that were close to public facilities such as school, city hall, government facilities as well as how it helped the local network.
[0:21:26] And I mean local network.
[0:21:28] How was the sidewalk adjacent to that curb ramp?
[0:21:30] It was in very good condition.
[0:21:32] It was just a very bad ramp.
[0:21:33] That was an ideal location to put on the ramp.
[0:21:37] So, again, this is to replace old ramps, not to actually construct areas that don't
[0:21:44] have ramps at all, that are ADA.
[0:21:46] Yes, it's to update existing ramps.
[0:21:51] They may not be true ramps, a lot of them, there's an abrupt curve, I know, in one location
[0:21:56] specifically it has, and in Jackson it's an abrupt curve, so it'll be virtually brand
[0:22:00] new ramps on the city sidewalk.
[0:22:03] And this really isn't part of your presentation, and maybe you don't know Josh, so hopefully
[0:22:06] I'm not setting up for fairs or just tell me you don't know if you don't know but what you know what the plan is for us to
[0:22:12] Really start addressing this because
[0:22:14] We you know we have an older city and and there's a lot of areas that don't have 88 accessible curves
[0:22:21] For folks, I know that we are working on an 88 transition plan right now and that should be
[0:22:28] Hopefully we're getting into the public process in in the coming months and in 2014 specifically. Okay. Good answer
[0:22:36] Are you ready for it?
[0:22:38] I also have the lights here.
[0:22:40] Can I make a motion?
[0:22:42] Actually, I have Shonda.
[0:22:44] I just have a quick question.
[0:22:46] So the section of Blue Lakes Boulevard there between Addison and
[0:22:50] Kimberly Road, I guess I didn't realize that was part of the
[0:22:54] state highway system.
[0:22:56] 93 alternate.
[0:22:58] Nor did I until this project.
[0:23:00] So is that just the connection between Addison between 93 and
[0:23:04] I believe it is between the Kimberly Road and Addison.
[0:23:11] So are there state funds to address other issues on that section of roadway if it's part of the state highway system?
[0:23:19] No, so most of the projects that the state is going to invest in,
[0:23:23] fall in the state transportation improvement program, and that stretch of blue lakes does not appear on any of the state's construction schedule or list of activities.
[0:23:35] Thank you.
[0:23:36] In other words, it's not very high priority for you.
[0:23:41] We're back with us later.
[0:23:43] Thank you, Mayor.
[0:23:44] Thank you for your presentation, Josh, and appreciate the initiative on the staff's part
[0:23:49] by applying for this project.
[0:23:52] If there are no further questions, I'll just move to authorize the mayor to sign a cooperative
[0:23:57] agreement with ITD for Americans with Disabilities Act curb ramp program, key number 13990, and
[0:24:04] to approve resolution 1913.
[0:24:08] Second.
[0:24:10] Good move by Rebecca Willslek and seconded by Don Hall
[0:24:12] that we, so the louder mayor, or authorized the mayor
[0:24:17] to sign this property agreement,
[0:24:19] and that won't go through old details
[0:24:20] on also resolution 1913.
[0:24:23] Seeing no lights, will the other roll call vote?
[0:24:25] Chris Tockensall?
[0:24:26] Yes.
[0:24:27] Sean Barakar?
[0:24:28] Yes.
[0:24:29] Don Hall?
[0:24:30] Yes.
[0:24:30] Susan Hawkins?
[0:24:32] Yes.
[0:24:32] Greg Lanthine?
[0:24:33] Yes.
[0:24:34] Jim Mon?
[0:24:35] Yes.
[0:24:35] We have seconded.
[0:24:36] Yes.
[0:24:38] Motion passes 7-0.
[0:24:39] Thank you, Josh.
[0:24:40] Moving on to item number four with this presentation from municipal powers out sort grant, receptions
[0:24:50] on the use of funds received last physical year.
[0:24:53] Last week I had a little list of who were having, I don't want to hold my doubt, I'll look
[0:25:00] at that one.
[0:25:01] Looks like we're starting out to date with transfer.
[0:25:04] Lynn Barrett, I'm assuming you're who you are.
[0:25:07] We've been doing five minutes and Don Hall will give you a two minute and a 30 second well
[0:25:11] I won't take that long so we're actually going to
[0:25:15] Relinquish a little bit of my time to travel is about something that relates to this
[0:25:22] The $25,000 that we received from the municipal outsource grant was used to supply 14.2% of the match
[0:25:30] that was required to
[0:25:32] $175,644 required to receive $417,013 in FDA funds to provide public transportation
[0:25:44] for the Twin Falls and surrounding area.
[0:25:46] With April 1st through March 31st of 2015, that 14 through 15 FDA grant has tentatively
[0:25:54] been set at $471,000 and that will require $201,942 in the local match.
[0:26:06] The city's $25,000 supplied 14.2% of the local match that was required.
[0:26:13] The balance of the match for last year came from Medicaid Rides, approximately $100,000
[0:26:19] office on aging that was 6,000 living independent network
[0:26:23] rise that we provided, which was in the 30 to 40,000-dollar range
[0:26:27] and the College of Southern Idaho.
[0:26:29] We do provide some very limited service over in Jerome,
[0:26:33] and they contribute $2,500 a year to the program.
[0:26:41] We have applied for $579,000 for the 2015-2016 period.
[0:26:49] There's about $1.3 million available for this region,
[0:26:53] which includes the Ketchum-Haley,
[0:26:58] Burley-Rubert area, and the Twin Falls area.
[0:27:01] And so other than that,
[0:27:03] and I understand we're looking at possibly a planning grant,
[0:27:10] so Travis probably can do that better than I can.
[0:27:14] Any questions?
[0:27:16] Susan Hockens.
[0:27:18] I understand you use the money for the match,
[0:27:20] But can you kind of give us an idea of what the money was physically spent on after the
[0:27:24] match?
[0:27:25] Just kind of?
[0:27:26] Not really.
[0:27:27] We supply the rest of what's required.
[0:27:29] I mean, you use it for fuel or for maintenance or do you have any kind of a...
[0:27:34] Actually, it would pay about 30% of our fuel bill.
[0:27:39] Got it.
[0:27:40] You know, the labor is the most expensive thing we have.
[0:27:45] insurance used to be the second most important expensive thing but the
[0:27:49] fuel is overtaken that's it's about fifty four thousand dollars a year for the for
[0:27:55] the liability insurance got it thank you here's time to follow up on the citizens
[0:28:00] question when I give us some indication of your general ridership comparing the
[0:28:06] last couple years we were last last month we had about four thousand
[0:28:12] boardings for this area and it runs between 3,200 and 4,000
[0:28:20] boardings a month.
[0:28:23] You're looking at about 4,400, 4,600 a year or 40,000.
[0:28:30] Yeah.
[0:28:31] OK.
[0:28:32] Thank you.
[0:28:33] How does that compare?
[0:28:34] I think that was part of this question.
[0:28:35] Compare with life last year.
[0:28:36] Actually, we're up a little less here.
[0:28:38] Our general public rights have increased.
[0:28:40] One of the things that I plan on doing with the additional funds for next year is increasing
[0:28:45] our hours of service to be from 6.45 in the morning until 7 in the evening on weekdays,
[0:28:51] and then hopefully this will allow some people maybe to write it to them from work that they
[0:28:56] can't now.
[0:28:57] And if we get the additional money for next year, then we could maybe expand to the weekends.
[0:29:02] I'd have promised to do something to add on my planning grant.
[0:29:09] Mr. Mayor, members of the council.
[0:29:10] So the city has the ability to apply for what's called 5311 funds, and these are planning
[0:29:17] funds.
[0:29:18] We're going to apply for a $40,000 grant that will help us go through a process to examine
[0:29:23] the possibilities of creating a fixed route bus system as we continue to move forward.
[0:29:29] The city's responsibility would be a 10% match if we are successful, and so that would
[0:29:34] mean that the city would have to come up with $4,000.
[0:29:38] And if we are successful, that would be included in the fiscal year 2015 budget.
[0:29:43] Mandy has been working on that grant.
[0:29:45] I know that she's been in contact with the land and they've been developing that.
[0:29:48] And the application will be submitted by the city, or application of interest is submitted by the city on December 23.
[0:29:56] In some point in the middle of calendar year 14, if our project is selected to the next phase,
[0:30:04] go and make an application before the board
[0:30:07] to receive the planning funds.
[0:30:09] And we'll have to kind of go with ITD
[0:30:13] with what they say is right.
[0:30:14] And if that planning grant needs to go through,
[0:30:17] I heard a transfer that could happen also,
[0:30:20] because we are registered to apply for grants.
[0:30:24] Okay, I'd like to let's like.
[0:30:26] Thank you, Mayor.
[0:30:26] Just a follow up question on the planning grants.
[0:30:31] do you then get to choose what type of planning process that you go through or
[0:30:37] is that laid out for you and does it examine certain aspects of the community
[0:30:43] like populations with low mobility kind of where the need is is that how it goes
[0:30:49] about planning or can you describe more on that planning process? Yeah so what
[0:30:54] we'd have to do is like in all planning grants you have to go through a
[0:30:56] qualifications-based process and from that place you would have the opportunity to select a individual
[0:31:03] or firm that knows a lot more about public transportation, the establishment of routes than what we do.
[0:31:08] And then that next process is to really identify key locations for ridership and to build a network
[0:31:15] where you're going to have a good population and a good ridership to help support and advance the
[0:31:21] system. I think it's important that as we move forward this is something that we want to move
[0:31:26] I want to say very prudently through that process, recognizing that we do have some time before
[0:31:34] the certification of the 2020 census where public transportation will probably become more of
[0:31:41] responsibility based upon receiving 50,000 in population and designation of an MPO status.
[0:31:48] It will be a very, very public process.
[0:31:52] And we would imagine that that's the best way to do that.
[0:31:57] To have a good understanding of those who would be interested in writing.
[0:32:01] Land in his team would be a great valuable resource in my opinion because they're already
[0:32:05] offering a service and they have a good idea of where their customers are coming from.
[0:32:09] And so it really I think represents a good public partnership as we're taking public
[0:32:14] transportation to the logical next step.
[0:32:18] That's correct and what we do now is all demand response
[0:32:21] that if somebody calls in and they make an appointment,
[0:32:23] we pick them up.
[0:32:26] Fixed route system would probably appeal
[0:32:28] to a little different group of people
[0:32:30] because a lot of the people that we do transport now,
[0:32:33] that maybe in a wheelchair or elderly
[0:32:36] or probably couldn't get to the bus stop
[0:32:40] to catch the fixed route whereas we do transport
[0:32:45] an awful lot of that type of people.
[0:32:47] I appreciate that this is a report on the current funds that that
[0:32:53] transporters receive, but I want to echo a comment I made I think last time when
[0:32:58] we were doing the awards of this that as we continue to look forward to planning
[0:33:02] both at the city level and in partnership with the transpor with the current system
[0:33:07] I do think that we may want to consider removing this particular
[0:33:14] of organization from the municipal powers
[0:33:17] outsource grants process, understanding that funding
[0:33:22] may be needed to address those things,
[0:33:24] but I think that as we head down a pathway of knowing
[0:33:28] we're likely gonna have a responsibility
[0:33:31] at some point in the future for public transportation
[0:33:34] that it may make more sense to address that
[0:33:37] as the specific item in the budget
[0:33:39] as opposed to part of this process.
[0:33:41] Yes, I would endorse that. I would not call it an essential service yet, but 45,000 writers
[0:33:49] that are off the streets for whatever purpose that we can collectively get them, pick them
[0:33:53] up, take them to their appointments, return them home. It's just the shadow, I think, of
[0:33:59] the writership we'll have in the few years when we are mandated to have much more of a public
[0:34:04] infrastructure with public transportation. Sean's motion is entirely feasible to me to move that
[0:34:12] back in the, I guess, the, what you're saying, Sean, is back under the umbrella of regular city
[0:34:17] funding. Yeah, I think as we, as we move into the next budget planning cycle, I would certainly
[0:34:24] advocate that we take those funds that we might otherwise have sort of in this pot of M-POG for this
[0:34:30] and consider allocating those elsewhere much like we did with well with the
[0:34:37] city band where we just sort of picked the number and kind of pulled it out of
[0:34:40] the pot. But what about this here? What are you saying about the request? Because
[0:34:44] the current funding has already been awarded. So this is a report about the
[0:34:49] use of the current funds, right? Well, no. Use the last year's funds? Yes, this is where we're at.
[0:34:55] The City made a series of awards and prior in fiscal year 13, we have started fiscal year
[0:35:08] 14.
[0:35:10] These are reports on how funds were expended and have been expended since they received them
[0:35:15] in fiscal year 13.
[0:35:17] There are funds that are ready and were approved in fiscal year 14 where the application process
[0:35:23] for those funds has not yet started.
[0:35:26] It will start after the reporting phase has concluded.
[0:35:31] So if the council wanted to do, make a direct award outside of the process that was used,
[0:35:41] now would be a time to do that, or you could wait until the discussion of the fiscal year
[0:35:49] 15, let it end up.
[0:36:00] The only challenge I have now that we're discussing this, making any future decisions.
[0:36:06] First of all, I work for College of Southern Idaho, Transporters underneath the College
[0:36:11] of Southern Idaho, so I would have to excuse myself from any decision making.
[0:36:17] But if we're talking about putting it somewhere else other than M-POG where it might be a big
[0:36:25] challenge for me when it comes to the budget time.
[0:36:29] So I know Fritz stepped out for a moment.
[0:36:31] So before we start going down that path, we probably need some clear guidance from our
[0:36:36] city attorney of how to proceed.
[0:36:43] It sounds like we maybe have a little bit of time.
[0:36:45] We don't necessarily need to do that tonight, but in the near future as we allocate the funds
[0:36:51] that are in the current budget, correct?
[0:36:53] We're at the 14th budget.
[0:36:58] Yeah, you could do it as you could carry the 14th budget process as you've done his
[0:37:03] historically, or you could make a change prior to going forward.
[0:37:07] And what we will do before we send out the applications is we'll check back in with the
[0:37:11] council to see which ones the council would like to do a direct award to and which ones
[0:37:16] would be eligible to application.
[0:37:18] Fritz is now here and he might be, this might be a really good time to ask him that question.
[0:37:24] Don?
[0:37:25] Perhaps we were just discussing regarding potentially putting
[0:37:29] transport in a direct line instead of going to MPOG.
[0:37:33] The challenge that I have, and actually the more I think about it, I think there's two other members on council
[0:37:37] that would have the same challenge, is that we work for CSI,
[0:37:41] transporters underneath CSI. If we put transpor underneath the main budget,
[0:37:45] that's going to be very challenging for...
[0:37:51] So we're going to need some guidance how we proceed.
[0:37:55] Okay, well, thank you folks. Thanks, Lynn.
[0:38:01] Well, a lot of your time.
[0:38:03] By the way, that's a little bit of money that we get from Jerome.
[0:38:07] That's how they, we're on the line item over there.
[0:38:09] I just send them a bill over here.
[0:38:11] Thanks.
[0:38:13] Pat, I apologize. Your name was on here and I just, I just blundered forward.
[0:38:17] Did you want to?
[0:38:19] She's fine.
[0:38:21] I figured you probably were, but I figured I better ask. Okay.
[0:38:23] All right, next up is Jubilee House.
[0:38:34] Mayor, so council won first.
[0:38:36] Thank you so much for the funding we got last year.
[0:38:39] Mike, could you pull a mic down just a little bit?
[0:38:41] Oh, sure.
[0:38:42] I'm just going to see your face.
[0:38:43] It's all right.
[0:38:46] First, in your rent report, I want
[0:38:48] to let you know that is 2000 transports, not
[0:38:51] traspots.
[0:38:52] I guess spell check doesn't work when it's
[0:38:54] underlined and bold typed.
[0:38:57] So we do 2,000 transports a year, not trash pots.
[0:39:02] So when I came in to request somebody,
[0:39:10] I brought with me a woman that was in the program.
[0:39:13] And her name was Michelle.
[0:39:14] And she was getting ready to graduate.
[0:39:17] And she's not with me tonight because she's working.
[0:39:19] But I brought her with me.
[0:39:23] And I shared a little bit about her story.
[0:39:25] She was born addicted to heroin, heroin,
[0:39:27] Her children were born addicted to heroin in Twin Falls County.
[0:39:34] In fact, her mother was born addicted to heroin in Twin Falls County.
[0:39:37] And she had spent time in and out of jail and in and out of prison.
[0:39:41] Her father is in prison for murder.
[0:39:44] And she was with me.
[0:39:45] And I wanted to do an update.
[0:39:48] You have my written report.
[0:39:50] But Michelle's doing wonderful.
[0:39:51] She graduated with this year.
[0:39:55] She is working full-time and she has full custody of both her children and she's doing
[0:40:00] absolutely phenomenal.
[0:40:02] She checks in with Jubilee House still and some of what we said we wanted to spend the
[0:40:06] money on was to continue to help our graduates.
[0:40:10] Part of the problem is with any program is once you're out of the program then what?
[0:40:14] And so we have used the funds in part to help set up a time and a place where our graduates
[0:40:23] can come back whenever they feel the need to touch base and come back home. We have one
[0:40:30] of the young women in fact just called me today and said, I'm coming back from vacation
[0:40:35] with family and I need to come spend the night or like sure, certainly come home. And we usually
[0:40:43] see anywhere from seven to ten graduates a week coming back into the house just to talk,
[0:40:50] to spend time just to visit, we've actually put one of our graduates, our very first graduate
[0:40:55] is now on staff and working. And so it is continuing the process. We have graduated with
[0:41:07] the graduates that graduated this year. We have 75% of our graduates that are still in
[0:41:12] full and active recovery. And so that's what we've done. And we thank you very much for
[0:41:17] being part of that.
[0:41:18] Yeah, I had quite a bit of experience on success rates, and I want to make sure that you're
[0:41:26] considering success under the same terms you did for the usual graduation of only 2 to 18%
[0:41:33] is it like after two years of treatment or what specificity for that very high success
[0:41:41] rate?
[0:41:42] Well, and we will.
[0:41:44] We do expect that to lower, I guess, over a year.
[0:41:49] But this is actually after a year,
[0:41:53] after a year of graduation, from graduation.
[0:41:57] And we consider full and active recovery still employed,
[0:42:01] still working in a program, and still sober.
[0:42:04] And that's what we consider.
[0:42:06] And so we have not including the women this year,
[0:42:10] because they haven't been out for a year yet.
[0:42:13] We have 20 graduates and that have been graduated
[0:42:17] over a year and 75% of them are still
[0:42:20] and what we can consider full and active recovery.
[0:42:23] The percentages I got for two to 18%
[0:42:27] are from the Idaho Council on Drug and Alcohol.
[0:42:37] I'm trying to think the actual name of it,
[0:42:38] but that's where I got the statistic, two to 18%.
[0:42:40] The point is that they consider success after two years, and you will use that same.
[0:42:45] Yes, when we have the longer we get after two years, yes, sir.
[0:42:49] Well, how do you explain your program so highly successful and so doggone cheap to run?
[0:42:55] I mean, that's a real anachronism of $5,000 to $12,000 normal treatment.
[0:43:00] You're doing it per month and you're doing it for $1,000?
[0:43:04] Yes, and we're 24,000 supervised and have licensed drug and alcohol counseling.
[0:43:09] One, I don't get paid very much.
[0:43:12] We, partly as it's a 12 month program,
[0:43:16] that helps the success rates a great deal.
[0:43:19] We have the time to not just teach someone how to stay sober,
[0:43:23] but we have the time to help them practice life skills.
[0:43:28] And in most programs are 30 to 90 days.
[0:43:33] Another big component is the spiritual component.
[0:43:37] And I think when you use all areas of life,
[0:43:41] I believe a lot of programs miss the spiritual component.
[0:43:46] And we also set up, we're very strong,
[0:43:49] and we take a full three months of setting up a true network.
[0:43:53] No woman leaves the house unless she has a support network.
[0:43:57] She has a job.
[0:43:59] She has a budget.
[0:44:00] And she has a safe and healthy place to live.
[0:44:03] Well, I'd like to congratulate you.
[0:44:04] It sounds like though that your program is much longer than the normal program and that contributes to the success
[0:44:11] Consequently, you can't treat as many people. Yes. Well, no, we can't treat as many people
[0:44:15] Like I said, we have an eight to nine residents at any time
[0:44:18] But if you take 75% success rate compared to a 10% success rate to get the same number of people sober
[0:44:25] over five years
[0:44:27] Instead of
[0:44:29] 250 we only have to treat 25 job. Well done. Thank you very much. I
[0:44:33] That's all the lights I have. Thank you. It takes a like I said last week when we
[0:44:38] were talking to different people. It takes a lot of components of the community to make
[0:44:42] the community and you're certainly part of that. We thank you. Thank you. All right next
[0:44:47] to Salvation Army. And I probably should have each introduce yourself to come up for
[0:44:56] the audience. I apologize. Well I'm Captain Marco Smarquez with the Salvation Army and
[0:45:00] I want to thank you for the opportunity to be here to thank you for your support of
[0:45:04] of what we do.
[0:45:05] Last year we received for the MPOG grant, $5,000,
[0:45:09] and it sort of helps us to fund our youth programs
[0:45:12] which fall under the umbrella of it's all about kids,
[0:45:14] K-I-D-S sort of meaning keeping in desirable shape.
[0:45:18] We also work in partnership with St. Luke's
[0:45:20] through their foundation to do children's health initiative
[0:45:25] sort of programming that we do there.
[0:45:27] And the MPOG grant went mainly for our summer program
[0:45:30] experience, and one of the goals that we seek to do
[0:45:33] for the summer is to teach kids that you can get out,
[0:45:36] A, and the first thing is to give them the chance
[0:45:38] to come to a supervised place where they can be there
[0:45:41] at the Monday through Friday.
[0:45:43] And also, to get off the couch and that you can do fun things,
[0:45:46] you can do exercise, you can play instead of sitting
[0:45:48] and watching TV all day or playing your Xbox
[0:45:50] or your PlayStation.
[0:45:52] And during the 2013 summer day camp,
[0:45:54] we used the grant funds to pay for the bus trips,
[0:45:57] to field trips all around Southern Idaho,
[0:45:58] which included Diamond Field Jax, Creators of the Moon,
[0:46:02] thousand springs resort, zoo Boise, Shoshone Ice Caves,
[0:46:06] balanced rock, Boise ice rink, and roaring springs.
[0:46:10] And so we introduced the children to the beauty of Idaho,
[0:46:13] which I've come to love in the three years that I've been here.
[0:46:15] And also to know that you can enjoy it.
[0:46:18] You can care for it, and you can get some exercise
[0:46:20] in the process.
[0:46:21] In fact, I lost 25 pounds last summer, just by joining them.
[0:46:24] So I'm witnessing that it works.
[0:46:26] System had a lot more to go, but it helps.
[0:46:28] We spent $3,583.22 of the $5,000 for those buses
[0:46:35] to provide the transportation to those trips.
[0:46:38] The remaining $1,416.78 and then more from our operating
[0:46:44] budget was used to purchase a new 25 passenger bus,
[0:46:48] which helps us to also get the kids
[0:46:50] during our summer day camp program
[0:46:51] to field trips around town, for example,
[0:46:53] a trip to the YMCA pool, and also to do pickups
[0:46:57] for our after school program.
[0:46:58] So instead of having a 12 passenger van that we have to pick up kids and then drop them
[0:47:02] off and do another round, we can do it all in one sweep with a 25 passenger bus.
[0:47:07] And so that's what it's doing.
[0:47:09] Part of the way we measure success is through St. Luke's grant where at the beginning of the summer,
[0:47:14] we'll sort of weigh them, we'll measure them, get their BMI.
[0:47:17] And then at the end of the summer, we do the same thing.
[0:47:19] And what we found is that most of our kids either become healthier according to those numbers,
[0:47:23] or they stay the same, which is quite good considering that many of their peers will gain weight
[0:47:27] or by sitting and playing games all day.
[0:47:31] Now, the long-term impact is obviously still to be seen,
[0:47:34] but we are hoping that we are instilling good values
[0:47:37] in them and the teaching them that you can get out
[0:47:40] and enjoy things and you can do them safely.
[0:47:42] And there's so much to do,
[0:47:43] rather than just sit at home all summer.
[0:47:46] So.
[0:47:47] All right.
[0:47:48] I don't have any lights, but oh, I do too.
[0:47:50] Sean Burger.
[0:47:51] I just want to say that thank you for the report.
[0:47:53] And I especially appreciate the partnership that you've formed
[0:47:56] with another organization down St. Luke's,
[0:47:58] and actually putting some measurable goals to it,
[0:48:02] I think that helps us understand beyond just the anecdotal,
[0:48:06] good things that all these groups are doing
[0:48:08] to have some measurement there,
[0:48:09] and so I can really do for that.
[0:48:10] And that's part of our department,
[0:48:11] but they require further grant,
[0:48:12] and so we do that to keep it to the,
[0:48:13] and you know, it happens with just partnerships
[0:48:16] through many other agencies, too,
[0:48:18] as I was hearing Catherine here earlier speak
[0:48:20] about Jubilee House, we partner with them regularly
[0:48:23] and support them, and they support us.
[0:48:25] We have a lunch program and they bring their girls to come cook one day a week in that.
[0:48:29] So that's a side, but it's just partnerships is what makes it happen.
[0:48:32] And thank you for your partnership.
[0:48:33] Appreciate that.
[0:48:34] Well, Chris, thanks.
[0:48:35] I've got one question, Captain.
[0:48:37] The 6065 kids in the camp in the summer, are they, you determine them to be at risk children?
[0:48:45] A lot of them yes come from sort of low income.
[0:48:48] We do have others that you might not consider low income.
[0:48:51] We don't make it specifically a program for low income, but I would say the majority are
[0:48:55] probably considered at risk and probably from the part of town we'll wear out, which is not
[0:49:00] only low income though, but that's some of the components of the rest of kids, but I mean
[0:49:05] they'd be home alone or one parent family.
[0:49:08] Most of the parents have to work and so they stay home and many of them don't get the chance
[0:49:12] to go out and do these field trips because parents have to work and you get home from
[0:49:14] work and you're tired and you just want to cook dinner and go to bed.
[0:49:18] So we get to give the children the chance to do that,
[0:49:22] and the parents appreciate that as well.
[0:49:24] We do a lot of field trips.
[0:49:25] We don't just want to stay in our building.
[0:49:26] We want to go out and do things.
[0:49:28] So, Donald?
[0:49:29] I was just going to say all kids are at risk
[0:49:32] in our society today, whether they're two parent families,
[0:49:36] parent at home.
[0:49:37] So you're trying to fill some of their time
[0:49:38] with good positive activities,
[0:49:40] setting a network around them of support,
[0:49:43] and I couldn't ask for anything more.
[0:49:44] And you know kids, these days sitting at home
[0:49:46] access to more damaging things to the internet than they've ever had before.
[0:49:49] And so even getting them to our program where they're away from that, it
[0:49:53] tosses a huge improvement in their lifestyle.
[0:49:55] What's that? Thank you, Captain.
[0:49:58] Thank you so much. I'd just like the last one. It takes all parts of the community to make a community.
[0:50:03] And you're certainly a dinnertal part of that. We appreciate that.
[0:50:06] And everybody listening, put some money in a barrel.
[0:50:09] Yes, our contributions are lower. So it comes forward us. Thank you.
[0:50:13] The cattle, so they're okay.
[0:50:16] I thank you next is interfaith caregivers
[0:50:23] Good evening and actually it's interfaith volunteer caregivers. I apologize. That's okay
[0:50:29] Mayor and City Council. Thank you so much for the funds that you awarded us
[0:50:35] This last go-around it was our first time receiving funds from you
[0:50:39] Your report is in you have a report in front you we received $5,000 from you and we used that strictly
[0:50:46] It was strictly restricted for volunteer
[0:50:49] Miley Tree Imbursement. Our volunteers provide transportation to people who can no longer drive
[0:50:56] or they're on such heavy medication and cannot drive if they're going to the Cancer Center or the Kidney Dialysis Center.
[0:51:03] And so the numbers in front of you, the money was spent, it's gone, but it was spent on 9,000,
[0:51:11] A little over 9,000 miles were driven by our volunteers, and 596 Twin Falls residents were served, that's up 22% from this time last year.
[0:51:22] So because of that money, we were able to serve more people.
[0:51:26] We don't charge for our services.
[0:51:29] We do other things in transportation, but that is the number one request that we get.
[0:51:36] And our goal, our goal is our whole mission is to keep people out of assisted living and full-time nursing care
[0:51:44] And we were able to do that with your money. So that was really the goal to increase those numbers
[0:51:50] Okay, thank you. I don't see any lights, but we appreciate it. Thank you for your service
[0:51:55] I approach just really really okay. Thank you for serving in our community
[0:51:59] Anybody that needs that?
[0:52:04] Mr. John.
[0:52:07] Thank you.
[0:52:08] It's nice to see you.
[0:52:09] Good job.
[0:52:10] Thank you.
[0:52:11] Thank you.
[0:52:12] And the last group is the Magic Valley Arch Council.
[0:52:19] She was hoping she wasn't last, but she was wrong.
[0:52:21] You were just hoping you weren't last in the whole meeting, right?
[0:52:25] When was it in the whole night?
[0:52:26] Yes.
[0:52:27] Thank you, Mayor.
[0:52:28] And City Council.
[0:52:29] And I'm Carolyn White with Magic Valley Arts Council.
[0:52:32] We want to thank you very much for your grant funds.
[0:52:35] It's $6,150.
[0:52:37] As you can see, we have expended them.
[0:52:40] The time frame that you awarded them is probably one of our heaviest time frames for programming.
[0:52:46] And so I just wanted to, I mean, you have the breakdown, but we were able to be very successful at most of our programs this year that we were able to offer during that time frame.
[0:52:58] We had our highest record number of attendance for our Kids Art in the Perk program, which does reach a lot of children.
[0:53:05] and K through 14 and it was very interesting this year because we were overloaded with that
[0:53:11] K through second grade age range which was remarkable in that then all of a sudden you
[0:53:18] know that compared with what's happening in the school system today. We also were able
[0:53:25] to reach 350 kids throughout the local school district for our Missoula children's program.
[0:53:32] We had both adult and summer art classes as well as after school art classes.
[0:53:38] We hosted four different exhibits at the art center.
[0:53:42] We have a new one out there now if you haven't seen it.
[0:53:44] I invite you all to come.
[0:53:45] It's a father and son.
[0:53:47] It's Ron Hicks and his son Jason Hicks and it's very contrasting.
[0:53:51] One is very multi-mix media and the other one is very traditional pastels.
[0:53:57] So it's very interesting.
[0:54:00] We were able to close two PBS documentary films and this year we just to date have reached
[0:54:08] 1500 local school kids for our time to our student outreach programs which are free and
[0:54:13] no charge to the kids and we've had six open houses for 22 local artists so.
[0:54:21] Do you have any questions about how the money was spent?
[0:54:26] Shombir.
[0:54:27] I don't have a question, Caroline.
[0:54:28] I want to commend you and your staff and your volunteers for the work that you've done.
[0:54:32] This report is an outstanding example of how broadly the Arts Council can reach in our community.
[0:54:38] It's not just kids' programs, it's for adults as well.
[0:54:41] It's visual arts, it's performance hard.
[0:54:44] It's community activities like the Summer Concert Series.
[0:54:47] And so I commend you for the work that you did in stretching very limited dollars.
[0:54:52] Thank you.
[0:54:54] Yes, we rely on a huge volunteer staff.
[0:54:57] We are run by one semi full-time, not quite,
[0:55:05] and one part-time staff right now,
[0:55:06] and so, yeah, the dollars get stretched.
[0:55:11] Carolyn, I was able to attend one of your board members,
[0:55:13] and I think you've got a board member,
[0:55:14] it's like 15 or 16 years old, don't you?
[0:55:19] He's 21, but he looks like 15.
[0:55:21] Oh, okay.
[0:55:22] All right.
[0:55:23] I thought he looked like,
[0:55:25] I thought he was a bunch.
[0:55:26] We're trying to broaden our demographics,
[0:55:27] There are board of directors and hopefully reach out to even a younger group in the community, so.
[0:55:34] Okay, well thank you, Carol. We appreciate your work.
[0:55:36] You're welcome.
[0:55:37] Thank you.
[0:55:38] Anything else that we'd like to add?
[0:55:40] No, just come see a program with us in a while.
[0:55:43] All right, all right. Come and look at the art.
[0:55:45] Thank you.
[0:55:51] Hey, moving on to Pat, did you have anything to add to our discussion?
[0:55:55] Come on, I'm trying to get you up there and I'm just talking to you.
[0:55:58] She's fine.
[0:56:00] Did you, are you, what, when we're gonna start the next,
[0:56:05] this coming years grant process?
[0:56:07] Maybe I get that, I'll get you up there on that.
[0:56:09] Thank you.
[0:56:11] Well, I was kind of waiting on directions
[0:56:15] from senior staff and you guys on that.
[0:56:19] I would assume we probably want to get started sometime
[0:56:22] quickly after the first year,
[0:56:23] because if we drag it on, then these people need their funds
[0:56:27] before we're ready to hand it out.
[0:56:28] So I think if we started quicker this coming year,
[0:56:31] it would probably be a better form of the process.
[0:56:34] Last year we kind of got out in the way,
[0:56:36] and a group had to have their money right away,
[0:56:39] and I kind of think we should start right after the,
[0:56:41] maybe first of February I said a date like that.
[0:56:44] Thanks.
[0:56:45] So one of the reasons that we took a little bit of time
[0:56:48] at the front end of last year
[0:56:49] is because we rebuilt the process.
[0:56:51] And with us starting shortly after the first year,
[0:56:58] I believe it's safe to say that the Council is satisfied with the process that was created
[0:57:02] last year and we'll use that same process moving forward this year.
[0:57:05] I'm good to take care of my brother process.
[0:57:10] Everybody had their own little judging system.
[0:57:13] I don't have a problem with that.
[0:57:14] It's time to come down to make it sassy so that way we're good.
[0:57:18] Yeah.
[0:57:19] I'd like to throw a suggestion out for your through their Travis that, following on Sean's
[0:57:24] suggestion that we consider also moving besides the transfer funding.
[0:57:30] the arts of the ban shell, municipal ban off of this AMPOG process into some sort of ongoing
[0:57:44] city umbrella financing.
[0:57:47] I think the support both of the programs are shown that we're just kind of wasting time
[0:57:53] thinking about these when we should be thinking about those and maybe we can give or take
[0:57:59] a few dollars here and there about the the transport and the city band are
[0:58:03] indeed non-necessary in that order of central services or various storage
[0:58:09] services so I would really consider or like to have the council consider moving
[0:58:14] both of those off off of the impact. I think Fritz is going to tell us why it's
[0:58:18] a struggle to do so. Yeah so I reviewed the ethics and government law it's it's
[0:58:25] It's a problem because it's not illegal for the city to contract with transfer, obviously.
[0:58:32] But for Don and Jim on transfer, they would have to abstain from voting.
[0:58:38] And not try to influence any other members.
[0:58:43] And if you put it in the main budget, basically you're not voting on the budget.
[0:58:47] And I think Rebecca would have the same issue.
[0:58:49] And Rebecca has the issue with that.
[0:58:51] City Band.
[0:58:52] What if we gave you a direction to find a way to do it like you're a smart lawyer and I think that there's a way we can do it.
[0:59:00] Well, one of the things we found.
[0:59:03] We don't operate in the gray area.
[0:59:05] Good answer.
[0:59:06] Well stated.
[0:59:07] The domho.
[0:59:08] I just want to state that this is a people at home watching folks in the audience.
[0:59:12] This is another example that sometimes we as human beings and individuals on the dais up here have conflicts.
[0:59:20] and we should because that means that we're active in the community.
[0:59:23] The main thing is when we do have conflicts of interest,
[0:59:26] we state them and we've been trying to do that.
[0:59:29] So I think it's important to state that.
[0:59:33] Chris, how you doing?
[0:59:34] You may also stay there in previous councils.
[0:59:36] There were conflicts of interest that were not addressed or manned up to if you want.
[0:59:42] And this is a pretty clean council and a combination of our city management and legal staff.
[0:59:47] This is hard for a dishonest person to make a lot of politicians in the City Council.
[0:59:52] I'm proud to say that.
[0:59:54] All right.
[0:59:55] Moving on to item number five.
[0:59:59] The consideration of the request to adopt a resolution of the City Council to involve creating the economic development ready team.
[1:00:07] So Mr. Mayor and members of the Council, you actually have two resolutions under the same agenda statement here.
[1:00:13] So I want you to be aware that there are two possible motions.
[1:00:17] there would be two possible resolutions.
[1:00:19] There is one resolution to create
[1:00:21] the economic development ready team.
[1:00:23] There is a second resolution to create the ZOAC.
[1:00:26] And the reason we did that was because
[1:00:28] it really does fall under the exact same topic
[1:00:31] and rather than have you see the exact same staff report twice.
[1:00:35] What staff is going to do is it's going to present
[1:00:38] the issue and the subject as we move forward
[1:00:40] and then at the council's pleasure
[1:00:42] they'll have the opportunity to consider
[1:00:44] making a motion to adopt either one or both of the resolutions that are before you this
[1:00:51] evening for your consideration.
[1:00:53] So as you're aware on December 2nd, and this is more so that individuals who may be watching
[1:00:59] us for the first time or in the audience for the first time understand how we've got to
[1:01:04] this place.
[1:01:05] And so over the course of a series of meetings in November, we had a conversation about the
[1:01:09] value in the importance of transparency in our organization and on December 2nd through a series of conversations.
[1:01:16] The City Council adopted Resolution 1912 and in that it affirmed a series of important things that the city has done.
[1:01:25] But most importantly it declared that the city had a policy of transparency and openness in its city government
[1:01:32] in order to promote accountability and to enhance this dissemination of public information and encourage citizen participation.
[1:01:39] city government. And so then as we went forward, one of the things it had was
[1:01:44] series of sections. And section three, as we described, really had that place where
[1:01:49] it described the meat of the resolution and where it did take that next step and
[1:01:55] it transformed historical practices, legal practices, but really just kind of
[1:02:02] now is going to go forward and take those additional steps above and but
[1:02:06] beyond what was required by the Idaho Code.
[1:02:10] And so we had that conversation,
[1:02:13] the resolution passed the council,
[1:02:15] and then on December 9th, to begin that conversation,
[1:02:19] we talked about a series of different committees
[1:02:22] that were, and were groups that were in operation
[1:02:25] of the city.
[1:02:27] One of them was the Economic Development Ready Team,
[1:02:30] and as we talked about the Economic Development Ready Team,
[1:02:32] that was a creation of the city manager,
[1:02:34] We talked about how it was time for that to move forward to that to become a fully recognized
[1:02:41] committee of the city and that it was important to recognize that economic development has taken
[1:02:50] a very prominent place in the city strategic plan.
[1:02:54] And so it was important for that if you will to graduate from a creation of the city manager's
[1:03:00] office to one that is under the direction by resolution of the City Council.
[1:03:06] The second was the zoning and the ZOAC or the Zoning Ordinance Amendment Committee.
[1:03:13] And this was born out of a series of conversations and reviewing of the current comprehensive plan
[1:03:19] and how the current comprehensive plan described a series of changes to the code that needed
[1:03:23] to occur to enable that plan.
[1:03:26] And this group had been meeting and the idea now is to take that into transform that into
[1:03:32] a recognized committee of the city.
[1:03:39] In your packet or two resolu- maybe I'll go back.
[1:03:41] So then there were two others that were brought before you and discussed.
[1:03:45] One was a wastewater treatment plant service provider contract and the council decided at
[1:03:53] that time that that was best left under the city manager's office.
[1:03:58] And we describe that process that I will bring forward that contract when we reach 10 of agreement.
[1:04:04] And what I will do is I will present that to you.
[1:04:08] And we will intentionally place on the agenda that it will be a discussion item only.
[1:04:13] It will not be something that will allow for to take action on that evening.
[1:04:17] And then at a subsequent meeting, we will ask the council to take action on that negotiated
[1:04:23] agreement when that time is appropriate.
[1:04:27] The other is actually a appointment which will occur as I understand it at some point
[1:04:32] after the calendar year, looking for members to serve on a urban renewal committee that
[1:04:42] is currently charged with looking at downtown improvements in the areas of infrastructure
[1:04:47] and curve and different other types of improvements to really take our downtown in that continued
[1:04:55] reinvestment in that next step. The committee has met once and they do not
[1:05:02] have any meetings between now and the first of the year so there is appropriate
[1:05:07] time. That's not really our committee. It is not your committee but I think that
[1:05:12] it would be appropriate for through official action members of the city to
[1:05:18] be to be assigned to that. The only one that we briefly touched on and this is
[1:05:23] something that really is left to the Council to kind of work through. And that is the Council
[1:05:29] has a series of advisory committees. And Idaho Code states that the mayor has the ability
[1:05:36] to make a recommendation to the full Council for its consideration of appointment to individuals
[1:05:41] to serve on committees where vacancies may occur. Since there was guidance in the Code
[1:05:48] and those advisory committees really do serve at the pleasure of the Council, staff did not
[1:05:52] create resolution nor did they create a process shortly after the first of the
[1:05:58] year and we just we throw that out there because shortly after the first of the
[1:06:03] year it will be a process in a conversation that the council may want to
[1:06:08] discuss and entertain as we will have a series of vacancies that will begin to
[1:06:12] occur starting in February. So with that Mr. Mayor members of the council you have
[1:06:20] two resolutions before you this evening.
[1:06:23] The first resolution in your packet
[1:06:25] is the creation of the Economic Development Ready Team.
[1:06:29] And you will see that there are four sections
[1:06:34] under this after you get through the recitals.
[1:06:37] And the first is that first official step
[1:06:39] is required by Section 3 of Resolution 1912
[1:06:43] where you create the committee.
[1:06:46] Section number two describes the membership of that committee
[1:06:49] And it talks about how additional committees
[1:06:52] may be included, or members may be included,
[1:06:56] but it provides a list of individuals who probably
[1:07:01] should be included if you go back to the reason why
[1:07:04] the economic development ready team was created.
[1:07:07] And that was to encourage collaboration
[1:07:10] between all of the different economic development
[1:07:13] partners that were all working for the exact same common purpose.
[1:07:18] Prior to the creation of this, we all kind of did our own thing,
[1:07:23] and the committee was really designed to bring everyone together.
[1:07:27] Section 3 states that we're going to post our annual meeting schedule.
[1:07:32] We will post an agenda, and we will keep meeting minutes of those,
[1:07:38] but as granted by the City Council and it recognizes in here,
[1:07:41] because of the nature of the committee and the size of the committee,
[1:07:44] will not be streamed at this point in time
[1:07:47] because of the technology limitations.
[1:07:51] It also recognizes that when appropriate,
[1:07:54] and the Idaho Code provides a very specific guidance
[1:07:57] when an executive session would be appropriate,
[1:08:00] but this committee has the ability
[1:08:02] to go into an executive session when it is appropriate.
[1:08:05] The time in which it is appropriate
[1:08:07] is when the city may be in direct competition
[1:08:10] against another state or foreign nation
[1:08:11] for an economic development opportunity.
[1:08:14] If we were in competition with another Idaho City,
[1:08:17] an executive session is not permissible under the way
[1:08:22] the Idaho Code is written.
[1:08:23] Only another Idaho City.
[1:08:24] Only another Idaho City that is correct.
[1:08:27] So with that, Mr. Mayor, members of the council,
[1:08:29] we would stand for questions on this resolution,
[1:08:32] or I can introduce the other one.
[1:08:34] And why don't you talk about what you have one might know?
[1:08:38] I was just thinking, why don't we do one at a time
[1:08:40] and then we'll move to the next.
[1:08:42] Is this 1914, yeah?
[1:08:43] Yes.
[1:08:44] Are we ready for a motion?
[1:08:46] I believe I have.
[1:08:48] Mayor, I would move that we adopt resolution 1914.
[1:08:53] Second.
[1:08:57] Rebecca, like you move, are you second or?
[1:08:59] Second.
[1:09:00] Okay.
[1:09:01] Good work.
[1:09:01] First of light.
[1:09:02] I'm gonna move by Don Hall and second by Rebecca
[1:09:04] and second by Rebecca and second.
[1:09:05] We approve resolution 1914.
[1:09:09] I do have a couple of lights on there.
[1:09:10] Becca, did you want to speak to it as well?
[1:09:12] Your light was still on?
[1:09:13] I had a comment, although the resolution says that we can post an annual calendar of meetings,
[1:09:18] I would encourage staff to post these on the website and through other means, just to remind
[1:09:25] citizens that they're unavailable.
[1:09:29] I know sometimes we'll post the entire year, but just as those meetings come up, remind folks.
[1:09:36] Absolutely.
[1:09:37] Thank you.
[1:09:38] Thank you, Rebecca.
[1:09:39] So one's just a typo in section two, and C-Doo, it should be S-I-E-B-O, transposed letters in that one.
[1:09:49] And then my second question is, so section two, and this resolution talks about the membership
[1:09:54] and how that's appointed by the mayor and the council,
[1:09:58] then with other members appointed by these other groups,
[1:10:02] Are those then?
[1:10:05] Approved by the council because it's different than the way they're appointed to the second one
[1:10:09] We left this one
[1:10:12] looser so the City Council will appoint the two council members to this and I assume Travis will be in charge of
[1:10:20] Whoever those other members he believes needs to be on that
[1:10:25] Committee, but we weren't trying to have the City Council control
[1:10:30] All membership on that.
[1:10:32] Yeah, and that's, I think that's an appropriate way to handle this.
[1:10:35] When I just noticed it was different than the other,
[1:10:37] so I just wanted to make sure I understand that.
[1:10:39] I just want to make sure in 1984,
[1:10:42] came to the economic development ready team one.
[1:10:45] Yes. Correct. Not Zawak.
[1:10:46] Right. Right.
[1:10:48] Just clarification.
[1:10:50] Rebecca mentioned about posting if there's an upcoming one.
[1:10:54] I assume that was our common practice when there's,
[1:10:58] Or you don't just do it yearly.
[1:11:00] You post on the web when there's a meeting coming up.
[1:11:05] Okay.
[1:11:06] We will end the resolution actually requires us to do that.
[1:11:08] Yeah, I was just confirming that.
[1:11:10] Thank you.
[1:11:11] All right.
[1:11:13] Seeing all additional lights on resolution 1914,
[1:11:16] Lea Rojavo.
[1:11:17] Sean Derrever.
[1:11:18] Yes.
[1:11:19] John Hawke.
[1:11:20] Yes.
[1:11:21] Suzanne Hawkins.
[1:11:22] Yes.
[1:11:22] Greg Lanthine.
[1:11:23] Yes.
[1:11:24] Jim Mun.
[1:11:25] Yes.
[1:11:26] Rebecca Masleka.
[1:11:27] Yes.
[1:11:28] Chris Tock.
[1:11:28] motion passes seven to zero moving on to what I will assume will be resolution
[1:11:35] nineteen fifteen which is the Zolak community. Travis you want to talk about it
[1:11:40] from it. Mr. Mayor members of the council resolution nineteen fifteen appears
[1:11:49] next in your packet and after the recitals it goes through number one the
[1:11:54] actual creation of the committee as it's described and required by section three
[1:11:58] of Resolution 1912, and it talks about how membership and number two is to go forward,
[1:12:05] and it says that it shall consist of two members of the City Council, two members of the Planning
[1:12:13] and Zoning Committee, and two members of the Committee.
[1:12:18] And in this process, different than the other, the City Council will actually go forward,
[1:12:24] And as I understand the reading of this would actually appoint those six members to actually
[1:12:30] stand in service in this committee.
[1:12:34] And then number three is the exact same process of where we would, again, to fulfill the requirements
[1:12:41] we will publish in accordance with the Idaho meeting code, we'll also utilize the online
[1:12:48] services and other services that we have to encourage notification.
[1:12:53] Unlike the economic development one we intend to utilize the council chambers for this and we will stream
[1:13:00] in that process just a side note Josh has been looking at a series of different opportunities of
[1:13:07] helping to stream
[1:13:11] We're gonna talk about some of the maybe complexities of the diets and I don't want to say that we've made consider
[1:13:16] I want to say that at least we've started the conversation and hopefully over the course of the next
[1:13:20] This fiscal year, we'll be able to look at a series of things where we'll be able to present items for consideration of the upcoming fiscal year to allow for a workshop-style setting to occur in this room and meet the technology needs that are called out in resolution 18-12.
[1:13:41] So with that, on resolution 19, that stands for any question.
[1:13:44] Hey, Kristin, I have three questions.
[1:13:48] How many members do we have on P&C,
[1:13:50] serving on Zollock now?
[1:13:51] Do you remember, John?
[1:13:52] Two.
[1:13:53] Who are they?
[1:13:55] Kevin.
[1:13:56] Jason and Tom.
[1:13:59] Jason, as I forgot, he is.
[1:14:00] I thought he was the member at large.
[1:14:02] Yeah, I'm going to turn it.
[1:14:04] All right, thank you.
[1:14:08] Kristin moved passage 19 resolution 1915.
[1:14:11] Second.
[1:14:13] You move by Kristin and saying by Sean Berger
[1:14:15] to move adoption of it, resolution 15.
[1:14:18] We do have one light, Rebecca, in a second.
[1:14:21] Thank you, Mayor.
[1:14:23] I just had a question on this one.
[1:14:25] The Planning and Zoning Commission
[1:14:26] was talking about this on Tuesday.
[1:14:28] And they brought up an interesting point.
[1:14:31] As some of the members have expressed interest
[1:14:33] in participating, or at least observing the ZOAC committee.
[1:14:38] And so we were talking about, because of the Council's
[1:14:42] resolution that only two members be appointed to the committee, I understood that part of
[1:14:48] the resolution to mean that any of the other members are welcome to come and sit in the
[1:14:53] audience and observe because it is a public meeting and I don't know how we could exclude
[1:15:00] anyone from a public meeting whether they were commission members or not.
[1:15:03] But we did have the conversation, and Fritz had some input on that of whether that makes
[1:15:07] it more complicated but in the resolution my intent was actually to open up the conversation
[1:15:14] to more people instead of reduce it down to fewer people and so I'm not really sure what
[1:15:19] the council's take is on that so I'd like to hear.
[1:15:22] Yeah, Rebecca and I did talk about that at the planning and zoning commission meeting and
[1:15:28] my opinion, maybe I'm overly sensitive but my opinion is if you have two members there
[1:15:33] and others observing and participating, it sure looks like you have more than two there.
[1:15:39] And so I guess we just need your direction on how you want us to do that.
[1:15:47] Susan, how are you going to do that?
[1:15:49] Let me just say one more thing.
[1:15:50] Rebecca's point and it's a good point.
[1:15:52] They are open meetings and there's nothing happening because there are less than four
[1:16:01] or whatever the magic number is.
[1:16:04] that we have direction from the resolution
[1:16:07] to try to limit it, so.
[1:16:10] Two, then.
[1:16:11] I guess I take that back to the economic ready team
[1:16:14] and council, where only two of us can attend.
[1:16:17] And my concern was I wanted to have a more active part in that.
[1:16:21] So then if planning and zoning can sit in on those meetings,
[1:16:25] then actually any of us could go to economic development.
[1:16:29] So then we're kind of ruining our own rules
[1:16:32] of only having two of us at things.
[1:16:34] And so to me that that muddy is the water too much.
[1:16:37] I don't know how you address that.
[1:16:41] So I'm going to ask for it to correct me if I'm wrong.
[1:16:43] But when you have, I'm going to use the economic development
[1:16:46] ready to.
[1:16:47] And let's say that there are two members of the city council
[1:16:51] that are appointed to that.
[1:16:52] And then you have two members of the city council
[1:16:55] who want to come and watch and observe.
[1:16:58] You actually then have a quorum of the council in which
[1:17:01] we did not post.
[1:17:02] And so we would put staff in a very difficult position,
[1:17:05] probably me, of asking what are my bosses to.
[1:17:09] We were meeting just because we cannot have a quorum
[1:17:14] of the city council in an area that you may or may not
[1:17:20] be asked at some point in time to deliberate or hear
[1:17:25] an action on.
[1:17:26] I think the Frits is right.
[1:17:27] I think that when you have that limitation of the numbers
[1:17:30] bodies, it does get to be fairly complicated from a staff perspective to really make sure
[1:17:39] that organizationally what we're doing is following in line with the coordinates of resolution
[1:17:44] 1912. And we started those conversations with several of our advisory committees. Fritz
[1:17:50] and I have gone and had conversations with them sharing resolution 1912, describing
[1:17:55] what those operating ground rules are as we move forward and asking them to hold themselves
[1:18:03] accountable.
[1:18:04] And from a staff perspective, we also had the conversation with all the department leaders
[1:18:09] in making sure that we also recognize and understand the rules to provide guidance at those times
[1:18:16] in which it may be needed.
[1:18:18] Does planning and zoning commission have the same role with their having a quorum available?
[1:18:23] Would that have to be posted as well?
[1:18:24] Yes, have any group that you have,
[1:18:29] your subject to the Idaho Open Meeting laws,
[1:18:32] any time in which there is a quorum of the members present
[1:18:36] in which you may be receiving information,
[1:18:42] we should be on the safe side and we should post it,
[1:18:45] we should treat it like a real meeting
[1:18:48] of the city council, meaning that minutes shall be
[1:18:51] transcribed in accordance with the resolution,
[1:18:54] That means that you would actually go in,
[1:18:56] you would officially go into action,
[1:18:59] recognize that the council was sitting at that time.
[1:19:03] So it does, the closer the more numbers that you get,
[1:19:07] the more people that you add,
[1:19:09] the difficulty gets for us to kind of marshal policies.
[1:19:13] Well, I guess with the new ordinance,
[1:19:16] if it passes, Zowak will be agenda and meetings,
[1:19:20] minutes will be taken, but we're saying
[1:19:22] We're going to assign two planning and zoning commissioners.
[1:19:26] So if three others show up in the audience to participate, then again, we have a quorum there.
[1:19:33] Yeah, we have a quorum and we have a meeting that hasn't been noticed and without an agenda.
[1:19:38] So we would have a zoning meeting and we'd have a Z meeting all at the same time.
[1:19:44] Right, because P and Z is talking about they want more involvement, but
[1:19:48] really we need to stick to our two person rule to keep things.
[1:19:52] If we're going to have five, you know, maybe we push the whole thing over to the entire P&Z.
[1:19:57] I mean, if we want that much involvement.
[1:20:01] Thank you.
[1:20:02] I think it's important that for you to know that I have asked staff to really work on 1912,
[1:20:11] and that at some point in time, Mitch, if more members of the Planning and Zoning Commission
[1:20:19] come, then we now have a quorum of those members, midges under my direction, to ask members to
[1:20:27] leave. Because we are not going to do anything that remotely comes close to appear that we
[1:20:35] are operating in a manner that is not compliance with Resolution 1812, or in conjunction with
[1:20:43] that of open meeting laws.
[1:20:45] And in respect for Christmas, I have a Christmas tree lights going on up here.
[1:20:51] So I think everybody says Andy's turners off, so now I remember his light on.
[1:20:54] So Dom Hall is next.
[1:20:56] I think I have been ordered.
[1:20:58] I think the word conundrum comes to light.
[1:21:03] I think this is challenging.
[1:21:04] I certainly respect what you're saying, Rebecca, that we were trying to open up to more people.
[1:21:08] But we as elected officials, we as appointed officials from the city council have just
[1:21:16] a past resolution stating that we don't want any more than two at these meetings from City Council.
[1:21:25] I take in that in the spirit of that that we would ask our commissions and committees to do the same thing.
[1:21:31] Mr. Mayor, can I?
[1:21:34] I think it's important to recognize that resolution 1912 didn't create the number rule.
[1:21:41] That is created by Idaho Code.
[1:21:44] So at any time.
[1:21:46] The two, right.
[1:21:47] That's where I was going.
[1:21:49] Any time in which you had a quorum of a group in attendance,
[1:21:55] we have to follow the Idaho Open Meeting Walk.
[1:21:58] Yeah, I understand that.
[1:21:59] But I was going towards the two-person rule
[1:22:03] that we put in place that I agreed with.
[1:22:06] I think that that is a good direction for the council.
[1:22:11] But I lean that way for our commissions and committees as well because this is what we're trying to achieve.
[1:22:18] So it is challenging.
[1:22:21] The ZZO Act ones will have to go back through planning of zoning as well.
[1:22:24] So you have the same situation.
[1:22:26] If you have three or four there, you've just taken care of that that meeting, not at the actual planning of zoning.
[1:22:33] So we're back in the second.
[1:22:36] Thank you, Mayor.
[1:22:38] I just understood the resolution because it states that only two members should be appointed.
[1:22:44] We didn't really talk about in attendance or who would be there.
[1:22:48] And so my thought was that it was a public meeting that people would be open to attend
[1:22:54] commission or council.
[1:22:57] I understand that if there are four council members there, it's already a public meeting
[1:23:01] and the council is not acting as a body.
[1:23:04] I mean, they aren't the governing body of that meeting.
[1:23:07] obviously the committee would be in that. So I don't know if that makes a
[1:23:11] difference but to me it just doesn't make sense to restrict other council
[1:23:17] members from these meetings. The problem would be, Rebecca, is if you look at the
[1:23:21] definition of deliberating, you know, it's very broad and it includes a receipt of
[1:23:26] information. They're all sitting there receiving information on something that
[1:23:31] they will be asked to vote on someday if they were at a city council meeting. So
[1:23:36] What about if we're live streaming the ZOAC meetings, if you watch it on, if you're there,
[1:23:41] if you watch it on line, how will we restrict that?
[1:23:45] Here's the problem.
[1:23:46] It's absolutely open to the public, but we failed to notice a city council meeting,
[1:23:51] and we failed to post a city council agenda, and we probably don't have minutes being
[1:23:56] taken for the city council.
[1:23:58] So a ZOAC meeting with too many council members there is an illegal council meeting.
[1:24:04] So does it make it a city council meeting just because they're present?
[1:24:07] I mean we attend other meetings.
[1:24:09] They're present in receiving information about something that they'll be asked to vote on Sunday.
[1:24:15] Yes, I just don't understand that.
[1:24:19] But also, you know what, from the Planning and Zoning Commission they do want more input
[1:24:24] and I think that this committee, everything that they talk about it does come to them
[1:24:28] eventually and I think it would be appropriate to give them this, all of these, all of these
[1:24:36] items of discussion. So to me now I guess it doesn't really make sense to have a ZOAC
[1:24:41] committee. So I would just recommend that we give it all to planning and zoning.
[1:24:48] Jim. Thank you. So first of all I don't like the idea of me not being allowed to go to a
[1:24:56] meeting as a citizen of the United States of America and the City of Twin Falls. If it's
[1:25:02] an open meeting and why should I be penalized upon because I'm on the council? So I get
[1:25:07] that. I also recognize the resolution specifically says I get it, absolutely.
[1:25:14] My point is if Jim Munn and Greg Lanting, Don Holland, or Becca Milsleka want to go to
[1:25:20] a meeting, and Jim Munn and Greg Lantner, or Don and Greg are members of the committee,
[1:25:25] but Becca and I, we just want to go watch. I think we have an obligation to notify you
[1:25:33] or whoever is involved here, we're going to be there.
[1:25:37] And this needs to be posted and you need to have somebody hold minutes to that.
[1:25:40] Then we're legal, correct?
[1:25:42] Yes.
[1:25:43] So what we're talking about is these, I think any council person who just spontaneously wants
[1:25:48] to show up at one of these meetings within that 24-hour window ain't going to happen.
[1:25:55] You're out of here.
[1:25:56] But if I notify you that I'm going to be there and I want to be there, I want to represent
[1:26:02] the community I was elected to represent and Rebecca's going to be there, post it, that's
[1:26:09] make us legal, is that right, Fritz? Just post the meeting.
[1:26:12] So you have some time when it's on post.
[1:26:14] 24 hours I get all that.
[1:26:15] If it's properly posted with an agenda we're fine.
[1:26:18] Because we're going to know when that meeting's coming a month ahead, right? Probably, two
[1:26:23] weeks ahead, three weeks ahead, we're going to know. So if we're goofy enough to show up
[1:26:28] but that meeting just spontaneously,
[1:26:31] we ought to be kicked out of there.
[1:26:33] But if we notify you two or three days
[1:26:35] within that window opportunity,
[1:26:36] I know it's a pain in the butt for staff to have to post it,
[1:26:38] but it is what it is.
[1:26:40] You know, it just is what it is.
[1:26:41] Post it, keep minutes,
[1:26:43] and we're gonna go to the meeting.
[1:26:44] That's how it works now.
[1:26:45] Bottom line.
[1:26:49] All right, Chris talking to you.
[1:26:50] Yeah, I can't agree more, Jim,
[1:26:52] but it's a new way of doing business.
[1:26:54] It doesn't mean that getting a little bit more cumbersome
[1:26:57] at the beginning, it won't work itself out,
[1:27:00] And it will require us to be a bit more
[1:27:02] planful on these meetings.
[1:27:05] I was thinking of one situation, appreciate your input.
[1:27:09] Periodically, we have just general informational meetings.
[1:27:12] The last one, we had all sorts of proposals up here.
[1:27:16] I think, gosh, I can't remember, it was the bike route.
[1:27:21] And we were mixing, as a council, a number of us
[1:27:24] with the public, again, that would be legal if we
[1:27:27] posted within that period of time.
[1:27:30] It was posted in that instance.
[1:27:32] Even if it wasn't by posting, and it makes it entirely legal,
[1:27:36] I don't say anything that isn't able to be overcome,
[1:27:39] except our slight inconvenience.
[1:27:42] I would say that the two unnamed people
[1:27:44] to these various committees should
[1:27:47] be picked with the idea diversifying the spreading
[1:27:51] participation out.
[1:27:53] And if we do that, you may or may not
[1:27:56] get the committee you want.
[1:27:57] We may not all do that.
[1:27:59] but I haven't heard anything here that isn't workable.
[1:28:01] And Jim, you just provide a good solution.
[1:28:05] It's not my turn to talk,
[1:28:06] but I have a part of that that's a little less workable.
[1:28:09] Chamber, you wanna jump in to Grandma?
[1:28:13] Well, I will just jump in front of you there.
[1:28:15] My concern is, this is a concern I brought up to start.
[1:28:19] My concern is not staff time being posted to me,
[1:28:21] you know, although that does provide some things.
[1:28:24] It's the transcribing of the minutes.
[1:28:27] It's becomes the issue.
[1:28:28] These were not designed to have transcribed minutes,
[1:28:31] which are far more detail oriented
[1:28:34] than just our recording that we've done.
[1:28:35] We're not asking to transcribe them.
[1:28:37] They have to be as soon as they're a council meeting.
[1:28:39] No, not according to I'd hope a meeting loss.
[1:28:42] What do you think I'm in at the,
[1:28:44] that's the question.
[1:28:44] Just record the meeting if somebody wants them.
[1:28:46] They can get them.
[1:28:47] So for open meetings, you just have to have minutes.
[1:28:52] For zoning issues, you have to have transcribable.
[1:28:56] They don't have to be transcribed.
[1:28:58] So when we have appeals for the island has to listen or somebody does maybe Katie does it listen to all those
[1:29:06] Then the audio and they make the transcript, but we don't routinely do it
[1:29:11] Okay, so they wouldn't if
[1:29:14] Last minute 24 hours beforehand got changed into a council meeting because more than
[1:29:19] Four council members before or more want to be there then they wouldn't necessarily have to be transcribed minutes
[1:29:25] They just have to be something that could be transcribed.
[1:29:28] Yeah, if they're related to zoning,
[1:29:29] they have to be transcribable.
[1:29:31] Otherwise, they just have to be headed.
[1:29:32] All right, so transcribable is different
[1:29:34] than actually transcribing.
[1:29:36] All right, well, that's just my question.
[1:29:37] I appreciate that.
[1:29:39] Sean Burgers next.
[1:29:40] So I'm not sure who I'm agreeing with,
[1:29:44] but somebody said this.
[1:29:45] I think this is gonna be a little bit of a work in progress
[1:29:48] as we implemented.
[1:29:50] And what I'm concerned about is,
[1:29:51] I think we're spending an awful lot of time
[1:29:53] talking about the mechanics of meetings
[1:29:55] and forgetting about the purpose of these two committees.
[1:29:58] The purpose of these two committees
[1:29:59] is tied directly to our strategic plan,
[1:30:01] one in economic development,
[1:30:03] one in a number of areas related to zoning issues.
[1:30:07] And I think that the first step is create them
[1:30:11] and then let's move forward through the logistics
[1:30:13] of how that works.
[1:30:16] I would agree to a certain extent with Rebecca,
[1:30:18] if the Planning and Zoning Commission is clamoring
[1:30:20] that this is their job to review these ordinances,
[1:30:23] then maybe this is overkill
[1:30:24] to have an entire other committee.
[1:30:27] I would say the same for economic development.
[1:30:29] If the clamoring is that everybody on the council
[1:30:31] needs to be involved in that on a regular basis,
[1:30:34] then let's make that part of our council meeting agenda.
[1:30:36] And does not have us ever committed to those.
[1:30:39] But again, I think we're so caught in the minutia
[1:30:41] of what's a meeting and what's not a meeting
[1:30:44] and how do we do the agenda that we're losing the purpose of them.
[1:30:48] So I would recommend that we just move forward
[1:30:51] with the creation of it.
[1:30:53] Let's figure out the mechanics of making it work.
[1:30:55] And if it doesn't work, let's do something different.
[1:31:00] Rebecca, I'm going to slow you.
[1:31:01] And then don't hold.
[1:31:02] Thank you, Mayor.
[1:31:04] I just want to commend Councilman Munn on his solution.
[1:31:06] I think that's a great solution.
[1:31:07] And I would recommend that be true of our commission members.
[1:31:10] If we have a commission member that's really passionate
[1:31:13] about whatever the topic of ZOAC is,
[1:31:15] if ZOAC gets created, then I would recommend
[1:31:19] that they notify staff.
[1:31:20] And if they have a quorum, then properly post it.
[1:31:25] But that shouldn't be a real stumbling block for us to open up these meetings.
[1:31:30] I think it's doable, it's workable and we'll figure it out.
[1:31:33] For this real quick question, I think Zolac is if it's created is a zoning amendment committee.
[1:31:41] So is that, they need to be transcribable?
[1:31:44] Yeah, transcribable.
[1:31:45] Okay, that's the question I have.
[1:31:48] Okay, and I'm certainly have no, I really don't have a problem.
[1:31:52] I'm just paying a little bit of the devil's up here, I guess.
[1:31:55] I don't have a problem with if everybody wants to be at these different meetings.
[1:31:58] I've been at some of them, and obviously they're a port to our city.
[1:32:04] Didn't we just kind of throw out our two person rule we just had?
[1:32:09] Didn't that just be a?
[1:32:11] No, it says two people are appointed to the committee.
[1:32:14] So we're not appointing more than two people to that committee.
[1:32:17] Those are voting members of the committee.
[1:32:18] That's different than someone who just pops in every once in a while because they're interested.
[1:32:23] I would just say let's be careful saying pop in because if we're going to have more if they notify staff
[1:32:37] I don't have any more lights and we have a motion on the floor for 1915
[1:32:43] Yes
[1:32:47] Yes
[1:32:54] Yes, motion passes six to one and moving on to item six.
[1:33:02] What's your comment for Don on the Zowak Committee?
[1:33:08] I'm looking at that again in the local land use planning act and that only applies when there's an appeal provided for.
[1:33:14] And these are legislative decisions so it wouldn't even have to be transferred.
[1:33:18] It didn't need to be transferred. Okay, that's much more.
[1:33:20] Thank you.
[1:33:21] According to our 1912, it'll be recorded.
[1:33:24] Okay, thank you, Donald.
[1:33:26] It's been an hour and a half.
[1:33:28] Mayor, I would appreciate a break.
[1:33:31] Right.
[1:33:32] Did he be any better?
[1:33:33] President Winske?
[1:33:34] No, I'm glad.
[1:33:35] Maybe just clear in your hands once in a while.
[1:33:38] Sure reason.
[1:33:40] Yeah.
[1:33:41] Yeah, wait a minute.
[1:40:03] Okay.
[1:40:04] I guess we're ready to go.
[1:40:13] Lila, are you ready to turn it back on?
[1:40:15] Are we on?
[1:40:16] Reconvene the December 16th, I haven't been lost all day.
[1:40:23] December 16th, 2013 City Council meeting.
[1:40:28] Next item of business is item number six,
[1:40:30] discussion of the annual impact fee report
[1:40:33] from the development impact fee advisory committee.
[1:40:38] Mitch Humble is handling this one from city staff.
[1:40:42] Go ahead, Mitch.
[1:40:43] Thank you.
[1:40:45] Each year we're required by the statute
[1:40:47] to bring you an annual report on the activities of our impact fee fund.
[1:40:51] So that's what we're doing.
[1:40:54] Up on the board, yeah, we'll start with the financial side of it.
[1:40:59] This is a quick little spreadsheet I put it in there.
[1:41:02] It's also in all your packets.
[1:41:04] Just shows the collections that we've done for the last, I don't know, four years.
[1:41:09] I guess since August of 09, you've started collecting these fees.
[1:41:12] You can see that the total in the bank, total income, or impact fee income is $1.5 million
[1:41:20] across all the four fee types.
[1:41:25] The top one is the police fee.
[1:41:26] The fire fee is second, street fee is third, and then the last one there is the community
[1:41:32] park fees.
[1:41:34] This year will be the first time we actually get to show a report that shows some expenditures
[1:41:38] as well as some income.
[1:41:40] So we actually had a little bit of spending that we did in, let's say I guess this report
[1:41:46] was dated on 1031 of this year.
[1:41:50] So there's a 1213 column which is the close of fiscal year but then we also had some time
[1:41:55] to add the month of October in there so we went ahead and added the month of October in
[1:41:59] there.
[1:42:00] So we had some expenses, total $57,000 and expenses, that's for design work and some parts
[1:42:05] and stuff like that on the traffic signal that we're installing with these MPI fee monies.
[1:42:09] There's another 300,000 in change that's going to be spent on that as we continue on through
[1:42:14] this fiscal year.
[1:42:15] So that'll pretty well wipe out the street impact fee.
[1:42:20] They'll be a little bit left at the end of that.
[1:42:24] Anyway, so there's the money side of it.
[1:42:26] There are any questions about this before I move on.
[1:42:30] I don't know.
[1:42:31] Or if we can just get to the end and we can go back to it around up to you guys.
[1:42:37] I don't see lights, so go ahead.
[1:42:41] Part of the report needs to be a statement on the equity of the impact fee program, and
[1:42:45] so we ask that every year of the advisory board, you know, are you hearing anything out there?
[1:42:51] Among the community of the way we're implementing our program or
[1:42:57] any complaints about how we're not doing it fairly or anything like that,
[1:43:01] again this year, the committee reports no inequities or errors in the application of the program,
[1:43:08] so that's always good to hear. We do talk a little bit each year at this time of year
[1:43:15] about the capital improvement plan and whether there's any improvement or changes that are
[1:43:20] needed. We talked to this council some time ago earlier in the year about how we're about
[1:43:26] up on our five-year time frame for the current capital improvement plans and we're working
[1:43:33] with our advisory board right now to develop new capital improvement plans for each of
[1:43:38] the four fee areas. That's underway. So this report is to say, yeah, there's some needed
[1:43:45] changes but we're not going to tell you what they are just yet. You'll have to stay tuned
[1:43:48] and get with those a little bit later. We want the committee to work through those first
[1:43:52] and have a recommendation that's good and solid.
[1:43:55] And we should see those very soon though.
[1:43:57] Our five years comes up in roughly February time frame.
[1:44:02] And so we're going to work with them again.
[1:44:03] We've had one meeting on it.
[1:44:04] They've had a chance to kind of absorb all this data dump
[1:44:08] that we did with them.
[1:44:09] And we're going to come back again, probably after the first
[1:44:12] the year and hit it again and two or three or however
[1:44:16] many more it takes to get them comfortable with the recommendation
[1:44:18] that they're going to make to the council
[1:44:20] regarding the capital improvement plan.
[1:44:22] The capital improvement plan directly impacts the fee amounts
[1:44:25] because we're paying for the improvements in the plan
[1:44:28] with the collection of fees.
[1:44:29] And so there's a direct correlation there.
[1:44:32] And at the stands now, we know we're working on some amendments.
[1:44:36] We know there's some amendments that are probably going
[1:44:38] to be necessary.
[1:44:40] We've presented the staff idea of what those amendments might be
[1:44:43] to the advisory board and they are now starting their progress
[1:44:48] to process to look at them and recommend something to the council.
[1:44:51] Like I said, you'll see that probably early next year.
[1:44:53] The final thing we want to talk about in here is the automatic fee increase, as you all recall.
[1:45:00] Every year on January 1st, there's a fee increase that, or I'll say a cost increase that correlates
[1:45:09] with the MCI from January to January time frame.
[1:45:12] When we did the report for the advisory board, we are estimating from November to November,
[1:45:20] There's a 1.5% increase from the MCI.
[1:45:24] We have it reasonably, but at least similar comes January.
[1:45:27] We won't know until January comes what it exactly will be.
[1:45:31] The board looked at that number and felt like that was an appropriate increase and recommend
[1:45:35] no action be taken.
[1:45:36] So the way that that's set up is the fees will increase without action.
[1:45:41] And if we don't want that to happen, then we adopt a resolution that says, no, don't
[1:45:45] do that this year.
[1:45:46] We've done that twice in the four years that we've had it and we've let it increase twice
[1:45:49] in the four years.
[1:45:50] This year the board recommends allowing the increase of something like 1.5% to increase
[1:45:58] and we'll come back and let y'all know what that is if that's the direction we go to allow
[1:46:03] to occur in January. We'll report back what that'll be.
[1:46:07] So that's pretty much it. It's kind of a quick thing that we do here, but if you have any questions
[1:46:14] we're happy to answer them for you.
[1:46:16] I'm just starting to get on Mitch historically speaking, go back to the year two thousand eleven and twelve fees for non-residential fees for fire and streets.
[1:46:29] We had two very substantial contributions for those of us none of the council. What was the genesis of those?
[1:46:35] Probably the biggest ones would be the Chobani payment that came in right around.
[1:46:45] Well that was Chobani.
[1:46:47] Yeah, we had the permit issued from Chobani.
[1:46:51] We paid, the city paid the Chobani,
[1:46:54] the first half of the Chobani impact fee.
[1:46:57] And we did that not right at the time
[1:47:00] the permit was issued, but later in the year.
[1:47:01] And so it came along 10 or 11 months
[1:47:05] after the permit was issued.
[1:47:07] That was the late 11th.
[1:47:09] The police nor the parks.
[1:47:11] It would not impact the parks,
[1:47:13] but it would impact the police and fire and streets.
[1:47:17] significantly, actually, streets, mostly, the street impact fee is really a good chunk
[1:47:28] of the money that comes in from non-residential development is mostly going to streets.
[1:47:32] Is that one total, that one year total is almost triple, the one prior to that?
[1:47:38] Yeah, 11-12, we also just saw it generally, there was that big one, right, but then we
[1:47:42] We also just generally saw that was when we started kind of growing again and the fee
[1:47:48] collections actually reflect that.
[1:47:50] So, we had a pretty good year in 11.12 from an impact fee collection.
[1:47:55] If you take away the Chobani payment, 12 and 13, we look at that, 12 and 13 is actually
[1:48:03] bigger minus the Chobani payment, so that one impact fee, you know, it shows at the end
[1:48:10] With 12, 13 we collect $436,000 and had it not been
[1:48:13] for the 306 that we collected from Jabani,
[1:48:17] the 11, 12 would have been just over 300,000.
[1:48:21] And so we would have shown a steady gradual
[1:48:23] kind of increase every year,
[1:48:25] but then you throw in that one anomaly
[1:48:28] and it kind of messes up your averages,
[1:48:29] but we're glad to have them messing up our averages.
[1:48:34] Rebecca, I'm going to start.
[1:48:36] Thank you, Mayor, just a couple of questions.
[1:48:39] First, when you're creating the Capital Improvement Project list,
[1:48:43] do you get input, I assume that you do get input
[1:48:45] from the different departments on eligible projects
[1:48:49] that are at the top of their list, or that sort of thing?
[1:48:52] Or how do you create this Capital Improvement list?
[1:48:56] And I'm sure we've maybe seen it before,
[1:49:00] but could you send us the current list that you have?
[1:49:04] Right, yeah, so, yes.
[1:49:08] the other question. So, yeah, we do work with the department heads and of the four departments,
[1:49:17] particularly the deal with the impact. So the police have a couple of folks that show up and we get a couple of
[1:49:23] guys from the fire department to come and Jackie and I think Troy probably has been put on that
[1:49:29] street thing and then Dennis and I come and we all talk parks and all these four things. And we go
[1:49:33] through kind of what the needs might be and how they might have changed from five years
[1:49:38] ago because we are seeing a few changes from five years ago.
[1:49:42] There's some things we have to keep in mind when we're looking at the impact fee projects
[1:49:46] they have to be needed because of the growth in the community, right?
[1:49:52] So that's the key.
[1:49:53] We cannot put a project on the impact fee plan that is a current deficiency.
[1:50:02] So an easy example of that would be like a traffic signal that already has a warrant.
[1:50:09] If we do a plan today, we can't put a traffic signal on the plan to pay for within back fees
[1:50:13] because it's already had the warrant.
[1:50:14] So we can only put those in there and think, well, meet a warrant in the future.
[1:50:18] And so we look at those growth related to type projects.
[1:50:20] They also have to be capital type expenses, so we can't fund personnel or operating expenses
[1:50:27] with impact fees.
[1:50:28] We can only buy stuff or build stuff.
[1:50:31] to that end, it has to last 10 years.
[1:50:34] Otherwise, it's not gonna be impactful as well.
[1:50:37] So we build buildings, we buy 20-year fire trucks,
[1:50:42] but we don't buy five-year police cars, right?
[1:50:45] So, those are all the things that they have to look at,
[1:50:49] and we use growth projections,
[1:50:50] and we look at current levels of service,
[1:50:56] and then we cannot put projects into the plan
[1:51:00] that will improve a level of service.
[1:51:05] Trying to think about a good example, maybe for that.
[1:51:09] Okay, so an easy one would be like a fire department level
[1:51:12] of service, we measure that in a response time,
[1:51:14] an average response time.
[1:51:15] And if our average response time was three minutes,
[1:51:18] or it's probably not quite that,
[1:51:20] but if we had three minutes,
[1:51:25] we couldn't add a fire station to get us to two minutes.
[1:51:29] or five minutes to three minutes, right?
[1:51:32] So we can't improve a level of service.
[1:51:36] And that's a hard one sometimes to really get a grasp of.
[1:51:40] And sometimes level of service isn't so easily defined as average response time.
[1:51:46] So those are all the kind of factors that all the department has.
[1:51:49] And we all got them into a room and Fritz and I were there
[1:51:52] and we kind of gave them some directions and I'll go away and think about these things
[1:51:56] have questions and and we kind of work through a few different meetings to the
[1:52:00] point where we have these these draft plans and I'll tell you the draft plans
[1:52:04] that we submitted to them are ridiculously expensive right and they are
[1:52:09] gonna have to so we want any lack of projects this is what you're saying no
[1:52:13] we're not lacking for any projects they're gonna have to either be pretty darn
[1:52:20] bold and recommend a very expensive plan or really take a hard look at
[1:52:26] what we really want to spend our money on and that whole give and take much like the
[1:52:32] process five years ago.
[1:52:34] We brought a plan that was ridiculously expensive again and the impact fees per home were off
[1:52:40] the charts and we whittled out some projects and we made some tough decisions that we're
[1:52:46] going to have to do again.
[1:52:48] So the measures that you use are just measures that we currently have in writing on the book
[1:52:54] somewhere or is there a way where you can, if you're thinking about a project that may
[1:53:01] be eligible, is there a way to survey where we're at so that we're not improving service
[1:53:06] or that we can measure it as we move forward so that in the future if it qualifies, we'll
[1:53:13] be aware of it and we can have some sort of measure and something in writing.
[1:53:17] So what I'd say is most of what you'll see coming out of the board will be, I guess, tweaks
[1:53:27] to what was there in the first place.
[1:53:29] So we're not doing anything revolutionary or groundbreaking for us.
[1:53:33] We're kind of building on what we already had done and maybe tweaking a little bit would
[1:53:39] be a more appropriate way to say it.
[1:53:42] So for example, maybe the police department one would be a good one to pick on a little
[1:53:46] bit.
[1:53:47] stuff in there like five years ago, there was a plan to basically double our SWAT team
[1:53:55] and have two SWAT responses and so there was a purchase of a second SWAT vehicle that was
[1:54:00] included in with our current administration in the police department.
[1:54:05] That's not a route we're wanting to go anymore and so we've eliminated the second SWAT truck
[1:54:11] or SWAT van.
[1:54:12] to how about walking trails we talked about, you know, maybe completing some of the...
[1:54:18] On the park side, we have included some trails, and that was one where we had to actually go in,
[1:54:24] because we didn't have trails done in the last go-around. We actually had to go in and kind of calculate a level of service.
[1:54:29] Right.
[1:54:30] And so we have an existing level of service for trails, and I think how we did that was, you know,
[1:54:38] linear feet of trail per thousand population, which is a very similar measure to our park,
[1:54:45] our community park, which was in the acres per thousand.
[1:54:48] So we kind of tried to stay,
[1:54:50] so they're somewhat related, right?
[1:54:51] And we defined based on our current developed trails
[1:54:55] by our current population,
[1:54:57] and kind of figured out what that level of service is,
[1:54:59] and then in order to maintain that level of service,
[1:55:01] here's what we can build in the next eight to 10 years.
[1:55:06] And then we have a need for trails
[1:55:08] that we are not yet built that are kind of on our trail plan,
[1:55:11] and we kind of figured out how much percent
[1:55:12] of that playing you can fund with this much money
[1:55:15] to maintain that level of service.
[1:55:17] And I think that was an eye-opener for some.
[1:55:22] I don't know that we'll be able to afford as much trails
[1:55:26] with impact fees as we were hoping to afford.
[1:55:29] Thank you.
[1:55:30] One last comment, but I think you've already touched on it.
[1:55:34] I can't remember if it was a couple of years ago,
[1:55:36] but there was kind of a sentiment of,
[1:55:39] well, we don't have enough projects to spend the money on.
[1:55:41] Let's reimburse some of this money.
[1:55:43] But I think you touched on it that we have plenty of projects.
[1:55:45] And I would just encourage us to get these projects into the budget
[1:55:50] and start moving forward, because I am aware that the money does expire.
[1:55:55] Is that true or it has a certain time limit?
[1:55:59] And so we need to be mindful of that and get these projects accomplished before that happens.
[1:56:03] So specifically we have eight years to spend the money that we've collected,
[1:56:09] Unless we can show like yeah, we have an actual plan and we're gonna do it the next couple years and we can go and do it
[1:56:15] a little bit of an extension there, but
[1:56:17] The eight years isn't like all of a sudden now. We have to pay back all the money
[1:56:20] It's you know in August of 2017 if we haven't spent that money will start paying back
[1:56:27] $1,600 at a time. It's some people who paid in August of 2009
[1:56:33] And we don't want to get there either we have certainly have projects we can build we're particularly concerned
[1:56:38] to think about the fire department money, because those were some really big expenses.
[1:56:45] And they also had with them some very big ongoing operational expenses that we're still
[1:56:50] trying to figure out how to maybe fund from another side of things.
[1:56:56] Like once you build another fire station, you have to then throw 13 people to work in
[1:57:01] the fire station with 12 people to work in the fire station.
[1:57:03] And we can't pay for those people with impact fees.
[1:57:06] we have that expense every single year from then on.
[1:57:09] And so there's a real balance that we need to look at,
[1:57:13] but we also have some information now
[1:57:15] as we're moving forward that we didn't have maybe a year ago
[1:57:17] even over the summer.
[1:57:19] And there's some concerns about ISO ratings
[1:57:26] and how our fire station's in the right place,
[1:57:29] and do we need something going on in the southeast
[1:57:31] and the northwest?
[1:57:32] And if we want to maintain this ISO ready,
[1:57:35] I mean, we oughta be, find a way to get to that a little bit quicker, so you'll see that I think those two fire stations are still going to be on the plan for the fire department as we go forward.
[1:57:45] Again, expecting that we'll have a need to spend some of that money here in the next several years.
[1:57:51] So, Travis?
[1:57:53] Thank you.
[1:57:54] So speaking specifically to the fire department, one of the things that we can also do, and just as Mandy has done recently,
[1:58:02] as we can use impact fees as part of our local match to acquire equipment.
[1:58:08] And so we submitted a grant through Homeland Security for an additional ladder truck.
[1:58:16] And those ladder trucks are $800,000 plus dollars.
[1:58:20] And if you look at the total amount of money in the fire department budget,
[1:58:25] And it gives us the opportunity to take a look at maybe 521,000 of somewhere between
[1:58:35] 801.5 million dollars.
[1:58:40] And so it's important to recognize that just because the money is here doesn't mean that's
[1:58:46] our only source and that we're starting to develop some creative philosophies that allow
[1:58:51] allow us to pool these resources with other grant opportunities to further the advancement
[1:58:58] of some items that we would be able to afford just if we were working from a city of Twin
[1:59:03] Falls operating or capital budget.
[1:59:06] Can I make one clarification there to what he was just telling you.
[1:59:12] The $800,000 was the amount of the grant that we applied for.
[1:59:15] The total cost of that truck is going to be like $1,275.
[1:59:19] So what we're going to propose to do is leverage some of this 500 or so that you have an impact fees add to the 800 in the grant and by a 1.3 or 1.2 million dollar ladder truck.
[1:59:30] And that otherwise that entire 1.2 I think we have in our current plan 1.275 shows up all in the impact fee and we don't have near the money to get that today.
[1:59:43] So, I think this is a great opportunity to take that money that we do have and leverage it for this grant.
[1:59:50] And hopefully it will be successful there.
[1:59:52] We're way exceeding the minimum grant obligation there, right?
[1:59:55] Is that the same thing?
[1:59:56] I think we got like 50%.
[1:59:58] So, I mean, hopefully that looks favorably for us.
[2:00:01] Sorry.
[2:00:02] I just want to add the station to you.
[2:00:04] Thank you.
[2:00:04] The CSI, the question raised periodically about if you said that we're not a fire station.
[2:00:11] I don't see any additional lights, Mitch, so I'm assuming we're just thanking you for
[2:00:36] your year.
[2:00:37] Unless there's a direction to not increase the fee in January,
[2:00:42] then there's really no action we need tonight.
[2:00:45] If you don't want us to increase the fee,
[2:00:47] then we need to tell us that,
[2:00:48] and next week we'll bring back a resolution
[2:00:51] that says no fee increase for January 1st.
[2:00:57] So you may like, so moving on to item number seven,
[2:00:59] discussion on city issue permits for mobile food concessions
[2:01:04] and a possible amendment to the city code,
[2:01:06] I have had a request or a possible request of a citizen
[2:01:10] that would like to discuss this issue as well,
[2:01:14] so we might give her a couple minutes at some point during our discussion.
[2:01:18] Go ahead.
[2:01:22] So we had a
[2:01:27] I put kind of a lengthy
[2:01:32] staff report to you and I don't really want to talk, like read it to you guys
[2:01:36] because that would be really boring.
[2:01:39] But we have our city code for mobile food concessions.
[2:01:44] I'll try and hit on a couple of highlights there.
[2:01:47] Really deals with mobile food concessions
[2:01:49] using city property or public property, right?
[2:01:52] So the streets or public parking lots or alleys
[2:01:55] or something like that.
[2:01:57] They are intended really to be mobile.
[2:01:59] I guess that's the key and that's the defining term.
[2:02:04] They're mobile food.
[2:02:06] they're intended to be moved during operations.
[2:02:09] So what you might think of as your ice cream truck
[2:02:11] that drives you around the neighborhood
[2:02:12] and the kids all the way it down.
[2:02:14] Okay, that's the mobile food vendor
[2:02:16] that our code anticipates.
[2:02:18] Somewhere along the way,
[2:02:20] I'm gonna be back up a little bit.
[2:02:22] We have those things defined in our code
[2:02:23] and our code says we're gonna issue permits
[2:02:25] for these guys to come in every year
[2:02:27] and renew the permits and if they do that
[2:02:29] then they can stay in operation.
[2:02:32] Somewhere along the way,
[2:02:34] somehow these mobile food trucks started parking places,
[2:02:39] and people started coming to them,
[2:02:42] rather than the trucks going to the people.
[2:02:45] And so somebody would come in and request a mobile food
[2:02:51] permit because I have a food truck,
[2:02:54] but then park it somewhere,
[2:02:56] and I don't have any specifics to say this guy did it
[2:02:59] on this date and such and such,
[2:03:00] but, and we just kept on permitting those things.
[2:03:04] And then over time, we start realizing, well, that truck
[2:03:07] has just been parked there for weeks on end.
[2:03:09] And it's not really mobile.
[2:03:10] And it's in a residential zone.
[2:03:13] Well, you can't sell retail in a residential zone.
[2:03:16] And so then we started getting involved from the zoning
[2:03:17] standpoint.
[2:03:18] And so then we started kind of tweaking the way
[2:03:22] we issue those food permits and asking questions up front,
[2:03:26] like, where are you going to park this thing?
[2:03:27] Or are you going to park this thing?
[2:03:28] Are you really going to be mobile?
[2:03:30] And anyway, we started working our way through the system.
[2:03:33] And ultimately, it comes down to a deal last spring
[2:03:36] where there was a drain that had some grease
[2:03:41] dumped down this drain and our sewer department guys
[2:03:43] had to go respond.
[2:03:44] It was a big mess that they had to clean out.
[2:03:46] And then they kind of got all up in arms
[2:03:47] and said, how can you guys are issuing these permits?
[2:03:51] So then we started asking some questions about, well,
[2:03:53] what's your plan to dispose of grease, which
[2:03:55] isn't really dealt with in our current ordinance?
[2:03:58] And we had some issues with that.
[2:04:00] And some folks were having a hard time coming up
[2:04:03] with a real viable option to dispose of grease.
[2:04:06] And so Fritz and I had a conversation
[2:04:08] and we basically said,
[2:04:10] code doesn't allow these things to park on private property.
[2:04:14] They're intended to be mobile
[2:04:15] and they're intended to be driving around.
[2:04:17] And so let's not issue anymore of these permits
[2:04:19] until we can maybe address that in our code.
[2:04:23] And so we stopped issuing licenses or permits
[2:04:28] for trucks that were gonna come in and park somewhere.
[2:04:31] We'll still issue the one for the ice cream truck that's going to drive through the neighborhoods,
[2:04:37] but we aren't issuing them anymore right now for the ones that are going to park, and the
[2:04:41] intent was to kind of, we are able to code them out of them anyway, so every permit we
[2:04:46] issued for that we were issuing an error, and then we needed to kind of address that.
[2:04:54] So we intended then to go back and create a code amendment that would allow these things
[2:04:58] to happen, but given certain regulations that we could ask about Greece and we could ask about
[2:05:04] where your customer is going to go to the bathroom at, you know, those kinds of things.
[2:05:10] Because you know, you build a restaurant in town, you got to provide bathroom facilities
[2:05:14] and you got to provide parking facilities, you got to have a grease trap and you got to
[2:05:17] have a connection to the sewer system and all those kinds of things that a mobile food
[2:05:21] truck parked on a property is kind of spurting all of those issues by being in a truck. And
[2:05:28] So we're trying to figure out how to deal with all these things.
[2:05:30] In the meantime, we look at a current draft
[2:05:35] and they have this new planner out there
[2:05:37] who's like all idealistic and fresh out of school.
[2:05:40] And he goes, well, why are we doing this?
[2:05:44] The code was drafted not to allow these things
[2:05:46] in the first place, maybe that was the intent.
[2:05:49] And then I got thinking about it, you know that might be right.
[2:05:55] Why are we spending all this time trying to draft a code
[2:05:57] to Title III, when maybe the intent all along is that no of these things really should be
[2:06:01] mobile and we don't want them parked because we don't want them creating a truck restaurant,
[2:06:06] rather they should be a restaurant restaurant, you know, like all the other restaurants in
[2:06:08] town.
[2:06:09] So that was a thought.
[2:06:10] And that made me think, well, okay, let's just come and ask the council to present direction.
[2:06:16] And then if we do decide, yeah, we do want to maybe have a home for these things in our
[2:06:22] code, then what kind of regulation do we want to put in there?
[2:06:26] And so what we've done is I've attached the current code and it's, you know, in its glory,
[2:06:34] so you guys can look at it and see what it says.
[2:06:36] That's the Title III, Chapter 18.
[2:06:39] And then after that, there's an attachment in your thing and I did it intentionally this
[2:06:43] way.
[2:06:44] I left all the little comments and notes in there so you can see our, you know, our total
[2:06:49] frame of mind when we were going through it and kind of how we decided to do what we
[2:06:53] did and some of the outstanding issues that are still kind of there.
[2:06:57] This ordinance is by no means ready for adoption tonight and we are certainly
[2:07:01] not asking either about this ordinance tonight. In fact, if you were to say,
[2:07:05] let's not this ordinance tonight or say it's not ready. We don't want to.
[2:07:09] But really we just want some direction. So moving forward,
[2:07:13] are we even doing something we should be doing or do we
[2:07:17] want to leave the code as it is. I guess that's the first question. Secondly, then if we go in and
[2:07:21] say, yeah, let's do provide a home for these guys in the code. Do we want to talk about
[2:07:27] Greece disposal? We want to talk about, you know, parking. And should you locate in some of these
[2:07:34] parking spaces or, you know, those kind of things. And so with that, I think is just really the
[2:07:40] reason for this coming up. So we throw it back to you. If you have questions, let me know.
[2:07:45] That's some white, I think I might be able to try and get in on that, I think, right?
[2:07:50] Mrs. Dingwell, did you want to take a couple of short...
[2:07:54] You need to come up, though. Okay, thank you.
[2:07:56] You need to come up with a mic.
[2:08:05] My name is Rose, my ding wall.
[2:08:07] My brother and I own a piece of property, which is commercial property.
[2:08:11] I know, I'm short.
[2:08:13] Which is commercial property, yeah, I'm telling you.
[2:08:17] East Five Points, where
[2:08:20] Minidoka, Main Street, Blue Lakes, and Kimberly Road Meach.
[2:08:25] And we have a piece of property that many, many years ago it was,
[2:08:30] it had a restaurant on it.
[2:08:32] And it's been several other things along with the car lot.
[2:08:37] It had a food truck on it on one piece for about two years
[2:08:42] when Mark Worrying was renting it for a car lot.
[2:08:46] But on the very front part, he had somebody who came in
[2:08:49] and park there, little high-ish code,
[2:08:51] little mobile, traveling, whatever, and ran it there.
[2:08:57] It has parking, it's commercial property,
[2:09:00] it's our private property, it is not residential area.
[2:09:05] There's render center across the street,
[2:09:07] there's a coffee shop over here,
[2:09:09] there's a burger, a shakeout over here,
[2:09:13] there's something over here that stores a lot of stuff,
[2:09:17] So it's not residential area.
[2:09:21] About five, six months ago, a young man came to me
[2:09:24] and wanted to put, he wanted to rent the one that has an office.
[2:09:28] It does have a bathroom.
[2:09:31] It has its own electricity, et cetera.
[2:09:33] He has a way to dispose of his grease
[2:09:37] with a company that wants to pick it up and use it,
[2:09:41] because there are a lot of places that do want the restaurant
[2:09:44] grease, and they will use it and buy it for free.
[2:09:47] I mean, take it for free, so they don't charge,
[2:09:49] but even if they did, he said he's ready to pay for it.
[2:09:52] It's not a problem.
[2:09:53] But he's been held up now for about six months,
[2:09:56] trying to do something and having no idea
[2:09:59] of what's going on and where we are in the city.
[2:10:02] And I keep trying to help him and I'm not getting anywhere.
[2:10:04] So I would encourage you to try to look at,
[2:10:07] this is a young entrepreneur.
[2:10:09] He wants to do well.
[2:10:10] He's run this little stand up in Rigby,
[2:10:13] but he came down here because his parents live in Berlin.
[2:10:16] and they have a stand over there and he knows what he's doing, he knows how to store things,
[2:10:22] he knows what he's, what he's trying to set up, he and his wife would run it and he's ready
[2:10:28] to go but he cannot do it and he's been paying rent for almost six months trying to figure
[2:10:33] out something. So I would hope that you would take a look at and be favorable to the young
[2:10:38] people who are well and older people, whatever. Whoever wants to start a business wants to
[2:10:43] to do something is not infringing upon any really big
[2:10:48] restaurant area in that section.
[2:10:50] He's able to have the parking for the people to come in,
[2:10:54] not interfere with any city or other business,
[2:10:58] because we own that whole block there,
[2:11:00] and he's got plenty of room for people to come in,
[2:11:03] park, get their food.
[2:11:04] There is the bathroom if they need it in the office,
[2:11:08] and head out.
[2:11:09] So I would hope that you would take a look at it
[2:11:13] favorably try to get something done for the ordinances so that he can start his
[2:11:20] business up here in Twian. Can you have any questions for me? I think we're good. Thank you.
[2:11:25] Okay. Thank you very much. Back up, I'm sorry. Thank you Mayor. First of all, I'm
[2:11:32] sorry Mrs. Dingwall for the delay. Six months is quite a long time to not have
[2:11:39] your issue address so I apologize for that. As I read the code, it covers motorized food
[2:11:45] concessions, motorized vehicles from which food and beverages are sold. It really doesn't
[2:11:50] address whether they're parked somewhere or not. It's just they're motorized vehicles.
[2:11:55] So I believe that a taco truck or any sort of motorized vehicle from which food is being
[2:12:00] sold is covered by this piece of our code. I think it's completely appropriate for the
[2:12:06] city to try to regulate retail business and food vendors on our own property.
[2:12:13] I do question however the appropriateness of trying to regulate food vendors on other
[2:12:18] people's property.
[2:12:19] I think that that really should be up to the vendor and the property owner.
[2:12:27] I do have a question, our city permit is contingent upon a health department permit.
[2:12:33] Do we know what the health department permit entails?
[2:12:37] I would assume they might have to provide for some of these same things that we're proposing as in proper disposal of grease or garbage, et cetera.
[2:12:48] Do we know what that permit entails?
[2:12:52] We usually just have them come in and show here we have got it.
[2:12:55] And so we don't ever get involved in the process to actually obtain it.
[2:12:58] It was just saying that the thought is it just prepares to the cleanliness of the food preparation and that stuff.
[2:13:04] Yeah, maybe we can get a copy of that and just see us so that we're not being redundant, maybe if we choose to make changes.
[2:13:12] My thought is, you know, are we really the authority on, you know, grease disposal and food handling? No.
[2:13:20] There's another department for that. Obviously, it does affect us if people dispose of it improperly.
[2:13:27] And so, I guess with that, I don't oppose part of this amendment that addresses the fact that you have proper areas for disposal, garbage, so on and so forth.
[2:13:44] I think it's H under the purple highlighted.
[2:13:49] I think that's one part that I would agree with changing along with updating it.
[2:13:55] Obviously, there's not a bid district anymore and there's reference to that.
[2:13:59] A hundred dollars annually makes more sense.
[2:14:03] It's less cumbersome as far as bureaucracy.
[2:14:07] And it's the same amount if you do it $25 quarterly.
[2:14:10] So I completely agree with those types of updates.
[2:14:15] But as far as getting the building department involved and reviewing site plans,
[2:14:20] That is a lot of bureaucracy and I've heard from a couple of applicants lately that it's just taken a very long time to get their building permits.
[2:14:33] And I don't know what that would do to these food vendors that would want to be operating.
[2:14:39] And especially the hours of operation.
[2:14:41] I know one of the fun things to do in other cities, Boise or San Francisco, which is made up almost entirely of food cart.
[2:14:48] You know, it's kind of their claim to fame is food carts,
[2:14:52] but it's fun to go there and be able to get a taco at 2 a.m.
[2:14:55] So I don't know if restricting the sales from 7 to 10
[2:14:59] is a good idea either.
[2:15:01] But basically, I support general updates,
[2:15:04] but I'm not sure that we should try to overreach
[2:15:08] and regulate people's private property
[2:15:10] when it comes to food vendors.
[2:15:13] Don't know.
[2:15:13] In respect to transparency, I need
[2:15:15] to admit that Mrs. Dingwall was a teacher in a school
[2:15:20] that I was a dare officer at, and she still scares me,
[2:15:23] so I just need to make sure I say that.
[2:15:27] Mrs. Dingwall contacted me a couple of weeks
[2:15:33] ago regarding this and the process,
[2:15:35] and so I've had a little bit more time to process this issue
[2:15:39] than maybe some others, because I've had tops with Mitch
[2:15:43] and dynamics. Here's where I stand on this issue. As long as it's zoned correctly, and
[2:15:50] I don't have an issue with these taco wagons or food wagons being parked in the proper areas.
[2:15:57] And I'm a proponent of making sure that it's accessory, or I can't remember the terminology
[2:16:02] Mitch, to another building that has restroom facilities, things like that. I think that's
[2:16:07] It's important for a vendor like this and also I think we had talked about potentially
[2:16:15] putting some minimal fee on top to help mitigate or help the city build a place where they
[2:16:24] can take the grease because we can say all day long that we don't want them dumping them
[2:16:30] in our grease trap or our facilities but if these folks, it's really difficult for them
[2:16:36] to find, it sounds like this gentleman found a place, but it sounds like to me the other
[2:16:40] vendors have had a tough time, mobile truck vendors, find a place to dispose of their
[2:16:45] grease, which might lead them to dispose of it in the wrong place that could cause harm
[2:16:51] to our system and cost money to our taxpayers.
[2:16:54] So I'd be a proponent of looking at some sort of a fee attached so that that could be
[2:16:59] mitigated and maybe I meant you could clarify a little bit more than what I'm saying in
[2:17:03] in that respect, if you wouldn't mind, please.
[2:17:07] So one of the things we talked about was,
[2:17:13] so I mentioned the example we had where there was some grease
[2:17:16] dumped out of the drain that needed to be cleaned out.
[2:17:19] We've also had reports of some of the vendors
[2:17:24] that we've talked to.
[2:17:24] I've said, well, I've seen so-and-so just dump it
[2:17:28] in the tree well outside the truck
[2:17:29] where the truck was parked to start on the ground.
[2:17:32] And we've seen it happen, or we've
[2:17:34] seen the evidence of it happening, or the degrees
[2:17:37] have been dumped down our RV dump site station, which
[2:17:42] isn't set up as a grease trap either.
[2:17:45] So one thought that had come up through this process
[2:17:48] was maybe creating a place that was set up to be a grease trap.
[2:17:54] And with the permit, maybe charge a little bit more
[2:18:01] for those folks that do have a grease issue,
[2:18:02] a nice come truck may not, but a taco truck will, right?
[2:18:05] So the taco truck guy maybe pays a little more
[2:18:09] for the ability to use this facility
[2:18:11] where it is actually set up to actually dump grease
[2:18:14] and they could take it and dispose of it there
[2:18:16] and then we could maintain that with the fee
[2:18:19] that we're collecting to operate, I guess.
[2:18:22] And that's one option, another option.
[2:18:25] And what's actually in the draft ordinances
[2:18:27] that we just require them to show us some kind of a contract
[2:18:31] They've got like the one that was mentioned.
[2:18:33] I've got to contract with these guys
[2:18:35] that are going to come pick it up and prove
[2:18:37] that they got a plan for it.
[2:18:38] Then we just move on and we don't have to worry
[2:18:40] about building something or operating something.
[2:18:44] But there's different ways we can handle it.
[2:18:46] The last thing that I just want to say,
[2:18:48] this has been six months.
[2:18:50] And you know, we're trying to encourage business,
[2:18:52] small business, and I think this has been too long.
[2:18:57] I think we need to move on this as rapidly as we can.
[2:19:00] So if we could get something to us as soon as possible so that we can help these small
[2:19:05] businesses out, that would be appropriate.
[2:19:08] Hey, we got myself listed next to them.
[2:19:13] Yeah, this is this is this is got some plus complexities.
[2:19:16] I'm not sure that we've touched on.
[2:19:21] Yeah, if you're a restaurant and you want to come into Twin Falls, like the new
[2:19:24] Dickey's that just output, let's say, and, you know, we have a lot of requirements of
[2:19:28] them. One would be paved parking and suitable restrooms and all these things that all of
[2:19:35] sudden, how is it fair to them if we just have to go park on a lot and start selling
[2:19:39] tacos. I mean, where's the fairness in that for the person that falls over our regulations
[2:19:45] to put in a first class restaurant? So that bothers me. I'm a little easier on Mrs. Dingwell's
[2:19:54] That's probably because she has, that is a commercial zone, number one, number two, there's
[2:19:59] paved area there, there's access to a restroom, and so I can see where, I don't know how we
[2:20:07] write that up so it works, I'll leave that to those who break them up, but I have a difference
[2:20:12] between that and let's say one that's over there on Addison, it's on a, has been for several
[2:20:18] years on a vacant lot with no pavement, no restroom,
[2:20:23] muddy as it can be in the winter time or spring.
[2:20:27] I mean, it's completely the opposite of what Mrs. Dingwell's
[2:20:30] representing.
[2:20:31] And so I think we have to look at that if there's more than
[2:20:34] just cart blank, yes, you can do it.
[2:20:37] And even though that's probably a commercial zone,
[2:20:40] it's not the same commercial zone in the way the property
[2:20:44] is presented and the way we're going forth.
[2:20:48] So, and I too would like to know what the health department rules are on these,
[2:20:53] because I'll be honest with you, I got really sick once, from going to one and so.
[2:20:59] But I also like Rebecca's.
[2:21:01] I mean, sure, if you're down in Bodo area, Boise,
[2:21:06] when I actually Bodo, I work over more on those streets over by the Egyptian.
[2:21:10] And you're there and it's 12 o'clock at night.
[2:21:13] And there's like 10 vendors along there that you can hit.
[2:21:17] and they're obviously all have some kind of a city license
[2:21:19] prominently displayed
[2:21:21] and so they're controlling them in some manner
[2:21:23] uh... probably much is your grand of the bars right next door that are
[2:21:27] following all the same rules we just talked about so
[2:21:30] it's it's a
[2:21:31] deeper caught deeper issue than just whether or not
[2:21:34] yes they can be there yes they can't be there i think we're gonna have to
[2:21:37] work through some of those other issues before we can
[2:21:40] uh...
[2:21:41] just say
[2:21:42] no or yes i don't think it's a nor yes area question i think it's got some
[2:21:46] steps along the way and I'm willing to find those steps and I agree that we need to get moving on it though.
[2:21:53] This is it. I was going the same direction as the mayor. I think it's great to see small businesses
[2:22:00] and I believe that if it is your personal property you do have certain rights to do what you want
[2:22:05] but in the fairness of businesses that have paid their dues and followed all the rules
[2:22:11] it's not fair to let somebody else just pull into a parking lot and set up business without
[2:22:16] about having the same rules and regulations.
[2:22:19] I think we do need to get moving on it.
[2:22:20] I would like to see the ordinance finished,
[2:22:24] but I think we do need to address parking
[2:22:26] and some of the other issues,
[2:22:29] maybe even a little bit of landscaping
[2:22:32] to keep it all fair across the board.
[2:22:34] It's kind of like local bricks and mortar stores
[2:22:36] competing against the internet sales.
[2:22:38] It's not always fair,
[2:22:39] and we need to try to even it where we can.
[2:22:42] Chris, I don't have much to offer
[2:22:44] except we have about eight opinions or seven of us.
[2:22:48] It seems like the health rules
[2:22:50] kind of something we need to find out about.
[2:22:53] I wouldn't know really what the question is
[2:22:55] we're asking tonight.
[2:22:57] I don't think we're saying on private property,
[2:23:00] you can't have roach coaches,
[2:23:03] but I think it's just what attributes on either property
[2:23:09] is that what we're saying?
[2:23:10] They have to have restaurants on private property
[2:23:12] or public property.
[2:23:13] I don't think you need to make sausage on this one tonight. It's just wanted to know if
[2:23:26] generally and I think we're hearing from you generally go ahead with this. So we'll bring
[2:23:31] this back to you and then you'll see, Mitch and I will do the best job we can to deal
[2:23:36] with the problems that we see with the existing one and then you guys can work it over when
[2:23:41] get you to get trouble is we don't meet anymore yeah how's so next year this we
[2:23:47] can get this one this one's about as far as Mitch and I have been able to get it
[2:23:51] so we can get this in this week or first year okay how about first year we'll
[2:24:02] get it on the agenda so I just in some of the research I was doing I I agree I
[2:24:12] think we need to find a way to accommodate mobile food trucks because I
[2:24:15] think they are something that's happening and we need to figure out how to accommodate that.
[2:24:22] We also have a responsibility to protect public health and safety and I think that's where
[2:24:26] zoning regulations come into place.
[2:24:29] It's not about telling people what they can and can't do on their property, it's about
[2:24:32] telling them what they can and can't do that's going to protect the health and safety of the
[2:24:35] rest of us and dumping grease into open sewer grains isn't the healthiest thing for the rest
[2:24:41] of us.
[2:24:42] In some of the research here, I'm looking at the central district health department, which
[2:24:47] is the, up in the Boise area, they have an entire document that explains their rules and the things
[2:24:54] that they have to do for the health permit.
[2:24:57] I would assume there is a correlating Boise City code piece of that.
[2:25:02] I do think an important thing to think about, though, is we're talking about mobile food
[2:25:07] units.
[2:25:08] And if it's a taco truck that gets parked there and never moved, it's not mobile.
[2:25:12] Just because it can move, if it doesn't ever move, to me, that's a restaurant.
[2:25:18] So I do think we need to be careful of that, that if we're talking about mobile trucks, which
[2:25:24] is a food truck that rolls up into the parking lot of the hospital and feeds 200 employees
[2:25:29] on their lunch break or out of Chobani or over at the sugar factory or someplace, it's
[2:25:34] not parked on this corner in perpetuity.
[2:25:38] That's a restaurant in my mind.
[2:25:39] And I think we need to be clear about what we're defining, whether it truly is a mobile
[2:25:45] unit or not.
[2:25:46] Because it really is a rest, there is a sandwich truck that gets all the places Sean was talking
[2:25:52] about on a regular basis, and it truly is mobile.
[2:25:54] It never stops for longer than 20 minutes at a time.
[2:25:58] That's truly is a mobile unit.
[2:25:59] I mean, we have cupcake sellers and coffee trucks that roll up to the chamber office all
[2:26:05] the time.
[2:26:06] And we're aware of those.
[2:26:08] And we don't try to even try to regulate them because they're providing a service and some employer.
[2:26:14] So I'm all for figuring something out, but I think we need to be clear about what we're defining because if it's you're going to take a truck and park at someplace forever, that's not a mobile truck in my mind.
[2:26:27] Rebecca.
[2:26:29] Thank you, Mayor.
[2:26:31] I guess I see a little bit differently.
[2:26:32] I mean, the code says, you know, from a vehicle,
[2:26:35] food being sold from a vehicle,
[2:26:37] I don't think it's a great hazard to public health.
[2:26:41] I mean, we have maybe one of these vendors
[2:26:45] that we're even talking about.
[2:26:46] And so my question would be, you know,
[2:26:48] if we are going to have this city create a place
[2:26:51] to dump grease, I mean, do we have enough users to fund it?
[2:26:55] Or where will the funds come from?
[2:26:57] What if a few of the vendors go out of business
[2:27:00] And then we only have one do we put that cost on that one vendor?
[2:27:05] I just don't know how that would work.
[2:27:07] I think there is a difference between these mobile vendors and buildings.
[2:27:11] And they shouldn't have the same requirements.
[2:27:13] I don't think we can expect that they would have the same requirements of
[2:27:17] paving parking lots and going through plan reviews.
[2:27:20] I just think that's bureaucracy overkill and I don't think it's a government's place.
[2:27:26] And I don't think it benefits really anyone.
[2:27:28] and say it helps public safety or health,
[2:27:31] but I really don't think this is a big enough issue
[2:27:34] to regulate.
[2:27:35] I would prefer that we not regulate,
[2:27:38] I mean, just like the people selling sandwiches
[2:27:41] at different businesses, we're not trying to regulate them.
[2:27:45] I just, I don't see the concern here.
[2:27:47] I'll try to make this quick.
[2:27:49] As far as the health regulations,
[2:27:52] I know the health department comes out
[2:27:53] and inspects these folks and they give them certificates.
[2:27:55] have been a part of events in the city park where they came and did that.
[2:28:00] So that should be taken care of.
[2:28:03] And I am a little sensitive about them parking their vehicles,
[2:28:08] pulling their wheels off and then becoming a restaurant.
[2:28:12] And maybe it compromises that they have to move their vehicle every night or
[2:28:15] they have to meet their vehicle so often and go to different locations.
[2:28:20] I don't know, but again, I just wanted to reiterate this gentleman's been waiting
[2:28:25] six months. Mrs. Dingwell has been waiting six months to on this as well and I think
[2:28:31] we need to come to some kind of conclusion soon.
[2:28:34] Chumber.
[2:28:35] Just quickly point out the central health district refers to a commissary and the Salt
[2:28:42] Lake city rules do as well. Basically it's saying if you have a mobile truck you have
[2:28:46] to define a commissary which is the place you go take your truck and dump the rinse
[2:28:53] water and clean the thing out and deal with those. So it helps to define mobile because
[2:28:59] it's not your base of operations. It talks about a commissary being the base of operations
[2:29:03] and that may be something look at it, it addresses where you're going to dump your grease. It's
[2:29:08] your responsibility. You have to prove to us you have some place to go dump your grease.
[2:29:11] You're not going to dump it on the ground.
[2:29:14] All right. So you know additional lights. I think hopefully you have some direction and
[2:29:18] you bring something back to us on that meeting on January 6th.
[2:29:22] Number eight, we're about to lose our placement back.
[2:29:25] I think they got to work too early because they're both looking pretty sleepy.
[2:29:28] So we're going to move on to the discussion of the Canyon jump process.
[2:29:31] I'm sure that's why they're here.
[2:29:33] Yeah, I think that's why they're here.
[2:29:35] The Travis Rothweiler.
[2:29:38] So I will tell you why I was up as early as Chief Pike was, if not even earlier.
[2:29:43] And so there's no excuse for him falling asleep.
[2:29:47] Well, it's actually Captain Barnhart that I used to be looking pretty heavy.
[2:29:51] And I will tell you he was not writing with us at 5 a.m. So I don't know what Captain Barnhart is excuse me
[2:29:58] So mr. Mayor members of the council before we can't have go forward tonight was one of the evenings that we had set aside for the purposes of talking about
[2:30:05] Compensation
[2:30:06] And what compensation may look like and so
[2:30:09] Dennis Boyer is here because this is really lands that may impact future park and future park opportunities
[2:30:16] So the conversation about what compensation may look like is very important and is also
[2:30:22] very timely as we look forward and develop an agreement with Beckley Media.
[2:30:30] But before we get into the conversation I want to maybe talk about the events that have transpired
[2:30:35] over the course of the last week is something that we've committed that we would do each
[2:30:39] and every week.
[2:30:40] We would share with you the steps and the strides that we've made.
[2:30:44] Rod Woodruff is here this evening, he's back there in front of Captain Barnhart and Chief
[2:30:54] Pike.
[2:30:55] And Rod is a member of the Beckley Media Group and Rod is the owner of the Buffalo Chip at
[2:31:03] Sturgis, South Dakota, which has very, very large events that is used to dealing with complex
[2:31:09] public safety issues.
[2:31:11] He is in town and we were able to spend part of the morning as well as part of the afternoon
[2:31:16] with him.
[2:31:17] In addition to that Sheriff Carter and Chief Deputy Donnie Newman had joined us in those
[2:31:22] conversations and then they took and had conversations about, they took and had conversations
[2:31:29] above and beyond that and met out on the property.
[2:31:31] And so as we continue to work through the public safety issues, I think it's important
[2:31:37] that know that we're making good strides.
[2:31:40] But one of the concepts that I want to present and get by
[2:31:43] off from the Council in the area of public safety,
[2:31:45] and we spoke with the Beckley team internally as a staff.
[2:31:49] We believe that this is a good step.
[2:31:50] We want to make sure that the Council is okay with this,
[2:31:53] is that we think that the public safety element is probably
[2:31:55] one of the most important elements of this entire document.
[2:32:00] And one of the things that we don't want to do is rush
[2:32:03] that process unnecessarily.
[2:32:05] And with the timeline that we have established and created,
[2:32:10] we want to make sure that we're not missing something
[2:32:15] in that process.
[2:32:16] And so in the agreement, we would like to state
[2:32:19] that there will be a public safety plan in concept,
[2:32:24] a traffic safety plan in concept that would be submitted
[2:32:28] to the police department and approved by the chief of police,
[2:32:33] no later than an aid date certain at some point in the future.
[2:32:38] And right now, we're looking at the date that we've talked to John Simmons, the attorney
[2:32:43] with Beckley Media, would be June 1st.
[2:32:46] That still gives us 90 days before the event to have an adopted plan.
[2:32:52] We just really feel that it's something that we shouldn't really rush.
[2:32:57] And we believe that there's an acknowledgment and there is a desire to have a very safe event
[2:33:02] moving forward. We just don't believe that we can do that piece of the plan
[2:33:10] justice in the window of time that we're working in. And so if the council is
[2:33:15] agreeable to that, that's the direction that we would like to move forward.
[2:33:23] And that like Katie was given to dealing with the specifics that don't come
[2:33:28] together until some months from now. That's right.
[2:33:32] So we would have we would have all of the other aspects done or at
[2:33:37] least roughed out prior to that by the 45 days that we set the
[2:33:42] this particular one, as long as we know that they know that the
[2:33:47] final approval would require a a you know, that's right, a
[2:33:51] satisfactory plan for public safety. And we can give them
[2:33:56] additional time that we could work together. I agree. I don't want to rush the public safety
[2:34:02] part. I mean, obviously, there may be some things that come up in the next month or so
[2:34:06] that we may have not anticipated nor maybe they didn't anticipate. So I'd like to have
[2:34:10] time to make that thing. I really do want to have a strong feeling that we're heading down
[2:34:16] the right path before we just give them 90 days on the next on that part.
[2:34:22] I will give you my opinion. Mr. Woodruff is here. He can share his chief
[2:34:26] Mike and Captain Barnhart can share theirs.
[2:34:29] I will tell you that from the meetings that we had today,
[2:34:33] it's very, very positive.
[2:34:36] And I think that there's a recognition
[2:34:38] about the importance of public safety associated
[2:34:40] with this event, and I think that everyone is working
[2:34:43] in good faith to achieve an event that is very, very safe
[2:34:49] for the areas of crowd control and traffic management.
[2:34:52] And we've spent some time talking about
[2:34:55] what that may look like and Mr. Woodruff is here
[2:34:57] and not to put him on this spot,
[2:34:58] but he can also share his message.
[2:35:00] Mr. Woodruff is here,
[2:35:00] a chance you would come forward to the mic
[2:35:02] and I'll be very honest with you,
[2:35:06] your presence in the Bechley Media Group
[2:35:08] had a lot of influence on me to vote
[2:35:10] for the Bechley Media Group.
[2:35:12] And maybe that's putting too much esteem
[2:35:14] or pressure on you, I'm not sure which,
[2:35:16] but it certainly, it held sway in my vote, so.
[2:35:19] Well, thank you.
[2:35:20] I would just endorse everything that Travis
[2:35:24] I had to say actually and probably if you ask the chief and the captain, they would as well.
[2:35:28] I mean, the public safety aspect of it just is a planning process and it's a bit of a working
[2:35:34] process.
[2:35:35] You want to know more facts before you make the decisions and the public safety plan is
[2:35:40] really a decision and even after it's made, if some circumstances present themselves,
[2:35:46] you want the flexibility to be able to change to adapt to those circumstances.
[2:35:51] And so I think, I feel very good, you know, it was a very positive series of meetings
[2:35:57] that we had today, also met with Ryan Lay from the Land Department across the river.
[2:36:04] And everything was 100% positive.
[2:36:07] And these people are very dedicated.
[2:36:09] They're very concerned and they're very knowledgeable about your community.
[2:36:13] And they certainly have your community's best interests at heart.
[2:36:18] And we just want to work with them.
[2:36:20] We're not here to tell them how to do anything.
[2:36:22] We're here to make it work the best for everybody.
[2:36:25] And their input is essential for that.
[2:36:29] So we just take a one step at a time, which is really the only way I know how to do these
[2:36:35] things, just put it all together.
[2:36:38] So we talked about traffic.
[2:36:40] We talked about the city streets.
[2:36:41] We talked about the actual site.
[2:36:43] We talked about meeting a survey so that we know where the city's property actually is
[2:36:48] and what wouldn't be needed in order to have the run to the launch ramp.
[2:36:58] And there's very little city property there for people, so we talked about that.
[2:37:05] And we have more information than we need before we really make the decision.
[2:37:08] But I think we have a general idea of where to go and there are just things that I know
[2:37:13] I think that the police would like to discuss a little bit more because nobody wants to make
[2:37:18] a decision and then have to change it.
[2:37:20] So as best we can, we'd like to have that all figured out in advance.
[2:37:24] Okay.
[2:37:25] Thank you.
[2:37:26] Any questions for Mr. Wooder?
[2:37:27] Here's Doctor.
[2:37:28] What, given your experience, that there's a lot of credibility in the organization.
[2:37:36] Chief, is there any need for background checks on any people to make sure they are who and
[2:37:42] and what they claim they are.
[2:37:47] So who do you mean, Chris?
[2:37:48] I don't know.
[2:37:49] Obviously somebody in your camp,
[2:37:54] I can only reference that in times past
[2:37:56] there have been people that weren't
[2:37:58] what they've purported to be.
[2:37:59] And is that even a legitimate public safety issue?
[2:38:03] I think it's probably premature right now.
[2:38:06] One thing, we had a good productive meeting today.
[2:38:10] Mr. Woodruff has experience in event planning.
[2:38:13] He has a staff that is professional,
[2:38:17] demonstrated year after year of holding these large
[2:38:21] scale events.
[2:38:22] So, we'll do our due diligence to make sure that...
[2:38:27] Let me refocus the question.
[2:38:28] That kinda sounded stupid and demeaning to you,
[2:38:31] and I don't mean it in any sort of personal color.
[2:38:34] I am most concerned about this taking on
[2:38:36] such a magnitude of exuberance
[2:38:40] that there will be peripheral organizations
[2:38:42] or people that will be claiming to speak for a backlight, I want to have a pretty clear chain
[2:38:48] of direction and command of who to hold accountable, and if they can't directly relate to the backlight
[2:38:55] campaign, then they have no legitimacy. There will be people with the dollar signs in their
[2:39:03] eye that will be purported to be something they aren't, and they could even do some harm to us.
[2:39:08] One of the things I think was very helpful last week is talking about special events and what
[2:39:15] that calendar could look like for that week.
[2:39:17] In kind of holding those issues at bay, allowing us a chance to look at all of the different
[2:39:23] events that would be taking place and then decide how to move forward kind of as a community.
[2:39:28] So I think that we have a good working relationship with the Beckley Media Group.
[2:39:34] One of the things I mentioned last week, and I talked a little bit with Mr. Woodworth about,
[2:39:38] is we will form that executive group of key law enforcement leadership,
[2:39:43] include the hospital,
[2:39:44] and really bring everyone to the table that needs to be there,
[2:39:48] but actually what we'll try to do is make this as easy for them as possible,
[2:39:53] so that he won't have to meet with five or six different groups.
[2:39:55] They can meet with one group, and that information can be disseminated.
[2:39:59] Good.
[2:40:00] I don't know if I answered your question, but...
[2:40:02] Well, it was better than the question I asked for, but you're very quiet.
[2:40:07] My question was a work in process and as long as we have a pretty clear chain of responsibility
[2:40:14] known to the city, that's what I'm really interested in.
[2:40:17] Shummer.
[2:40:18] So Travis, with your question about establishing some timeline for this safety plan, are you
[2:40:26] asking us to push out the end of January date that we approved?
[2:40:32] No, so would I be this?
[2:40:33] So what in the agreement, what we would have is we would state that a public safety plan
[2:40:41] must be submitted and approved by the chief of police no later than June 1st of 2014.
[2:40:48] That is what the agreement would talk about and that you would move forward and it would
[2:40:52] be one of those things that we would have to accomplish as part of the agreement.
[2:40:56] And the concept kind of came from like a development agreement that we go forward with lots of
[2:41:00] of our economic development opportunities where we state,
[2:41:04] these are the things that we will accomplish
[2:41:06] and these are the timelines in which we will accomplish them.
[2:41:09] So, for example, with the current CLIFBART project,
[2:41:12] we say that we are going to go forward
[2:41:14] and we are going to acquire the property
[2:41:16] by these dates and time.
[2:41:17] So then you move forward and you have to acquire
[2:41:20] those dates and time.
[2:41:21] You create a contractual obligation to perform
[2:41:25] and what we're doing here as part of the agreement
[2:41:27] is we'd be doing the same thing.
[2:41:29] we'd be creating a contractual obligation
[2:41:31] for BECL Media to perform.
[2:41:33] So you complete a public safety plan no later than June 1st.
[2:41:38] We believe that it will occur before that,
[2:41:40] but we're just trying to provide maximum opportunity
[2:41:43] and flexibility for us to be able to make sure
[2:41:46] that we get it right.
[2:41:47] And that public safety plan will be discussed publicly.
[2:41:52] It will be presented publicly.
[2:41:54] It will be shared.
[2:41:56] What we're just trying to do is we look at that
[2:41:58] probably this is one of the single most important elements and and we've talked a
[2:42:03] lot about public involvement public inclusion making sure the neighbors in
[2:42:07] the area feel safe with the concept and you start incorporating all of that into
[2:42:13] a very narrow window of time and we don't think that we could do that part of it
[2:42:17] justice and so we we say that it's going to happen and if it doesn't happen
[2:42:23] and there's a default of the arrangement in the agreement.
[2:42:26] So my only, I appreciate the need to be thorough
[2:42:31] and prudent and have a good plan,
[2:42:34] but I will take a step back about six months,
[2:42:37] and that's what we asked all the applicants for in the first place,
[2:42:41] was give us your plan,
[2:42:44] and what we got from all the applicants was,
[2:42:46] we'll make a plan,
[2:42:48] and to just kick that can down the road now,
[2:42:51] 90 to 120 days, to me, doesn't show forward momentum.
[2:43:00] So I'd be maybe willing to be supportive of that if it's something more than, yep, we'll
[2:43:06] have a plan for you.
[2:43:07] Maybe we have pieces of that plan presented to us as part of the, because I get it.
[2:43:13] I get it that it's a big deal, but it's also a big deal that we have shared over and over
[2:43:18] over and over again for the last six months and got nothing from anybody more than we'll
[2:43:23] have a plan.
[2:43:24] Yeah, I think that we are starting to see some pretty good movement.
[2:43:28] So for example, I believe that Mr. Woodruff would share with you this evening, and correct
[2:43:34] me if I say this wrong, but as they've looked and they've contemplated, six months ago,
[2:43:40] I think that all of us really believe that a bulk of the events would occur on our side
[2:43:44] of the Canyon in utilizing our property and those type of things.
[2:43:48] And as they have looked at how small and how little real property we do have,
[2:43:54] most of those events are getting pushed over to the north side.
[2:43:57] In fact, they're contemplating having, and the range that has been discussed a couple
[2:44:01] of times, 85 plus percent of the events and the activities will occur over on the other side.
[2:44:09] But where over on our side right now is contemplated that there would be support staff.
[2:44:16] There would be possibly with the television and broadcasting opportunities, there would
[2:44:23] be trucks to support that.
[2:44:26] But most of the events, the seating, the crowds, they would be encouraged to be as part of the
[2:44:34] event on the other side, which is not something that was necessarily, at least in my mind,
[2:44:42] wasn't necessarily thought.
[2:44:43] I think the other advantage, as we've talked about, the selection of Beckley media or the
[2:44:52] selection of the preferred initial candidate to be able to move forward, has allowed us
[2:44:58] to have in, I would say, relatively engaged and intensive conversations that have allowed
[2:45:05] us to move forward as opposed to having six simultaneous conversations with six different
[2:45:10] groups.
[2:45:11] We're able to have concentrated conversations where I think that we're starting to see that
[2:45:16] progress.
[2:45:17] And it may be the case that we could submit a tentative outline of what a public safety
[2:45:21] plan would look like, but it would not necessarily have all the details.
[2:45:24] And we're not trying to delay unnecessarily, but we want to do is we want to just make
[2:45:31] sure that, like I said, the public involvement piece, and I think that we've heard a lot
[2:45:36] of citizens that have said that we would like to be, have knowledge.
[2:45:41] We'd like to be heard.
[2:45:44] We'd like to have an understanding.
[2:45:46] With the holidays and the timeline, we just don't know how achievable accomplishing all
[2:45:52] of that is in a thoughtful manner.
[2:45:55] Because I do not believe that if staff presented a draft agreement to you on the 23rd of January,
[2:46:05] or whatever the last meeting is right before the time that you were to adopt it, that would
[2:46:10] be well received.
[2:46:12] And I think that there needs to be a public vetting of that process as well.
[2:46:16] So we're trying to recognize the need to really include the public as well as a creative thoughtful
[2:46:25] document that protects public safety, protects our citizens and protects our community.
[2:46:31] We're back in the next slide.
[2:46:32] Thank you, Mayor.
[2:46:33] I appreciate the report on this and I just want to say I'm comfortable with it.
[2:46:39] the Chief's support and the applicant's support.
[2:46:46] I think that it's like you're saying,
[2:46:48] not a matter of will it happen, it's just the details.
[2:46:51] And I appreciate that you want to include the public,
[2:46:54] and that that takes time,
[2:46:56] and that all things will be addressed through that process.
[2:46:58] So I just want to say that I'm comfortable with it.
[2:47:02] Chris, thank you.
[2:47:04] Well, I'm not.
[2:47:05] Sean, I didn't think through until you start bringing it up.
[2:47:08] I think we should expect more from the applicants, and I'd like to see a weekly or a meeting
[2:47:14] progress as some template.
[2:47:16] Let's start with the simplest thing.
[2:47:18] Who are the players in this thing, the different agencies?
[2:47:22] I've already heard specifics now of 85% of the events on the North side.
[2:47:27] You know, I can start to get a real rough framework as some things that we can refine
[2:47:31] as time goes by.
[2:47:33] But it is not good planning for us to wait until June and expect everything to be perfect.
[2:47:41] We're going to put our own imprint on it.
[2:47:44] And I would just encourage you, Travis, to work with Mr. Woodruff to get us something
[2:47:49] visual, if you will, some rough work in process.
[2:47:54] Start with the simplest things.
[2:47:55] They don't even have to be in the right order.
[2:47:57] If you're going to put the money you are into this, Mr. Woodruff, you have an expectation
[2:48:02] of the actual people in situ, on site for the event.
[2:48:09] That in itself falls out to, you know, the number of Roach Coach vendors that are going
[2:48:14] to be selling tacos.
[2:48:16] That in itself tells you how many places you may need for different agencies.
[2:48:20] I think we can expect and should expect more quicker.
[2:48:23] Had we had the permit and gone ahead like we expected after the auction, we have all that stuff
[2:48:39] have all that stuff done by now. But without with the indecisiveness, the indecision, and
[2:48:46] the inability to make representations to people, you know, you're considerably hampered by that.
[2:48:52] What we don't ever do is make representations. We can't back up. So as we're talking about
[2:48:58] now about how to handle it, when we started, we thought City had a lot more property there.
[2:49:03] There's very little property there for his starters, and so that is a major, major change.
[2:49:10] We can, we can manage this thing and we can do it as close to perfect as anybody.
[2:49:16] There are different things that are going to involve other agencies and I won't make
[2:49:19] any representations for them, but talking with the WAND Bureau, Ryan Lay, how they want
[2:49:27] that property developed over there and talking with the officers today about the traffic
[2:49:33] how to expect traffic flow that you guys enjoy here. I mean, you have a very vibrant community.
[2:49:39] We're going to need some other approaches probably off the road and we'll need to get
[2:49:44] permission from different agencies to do that and then we'll have to construct it. If they say no,
[2:49:51] the plans are changed. I think we can do that. Brian tells me that there's support for all that,
[2:49:58] but until really meeting with the officers today, I wasn't really confident that we were
[2:50:03] We were going to be able to have the permission to move ahead.
[2:50:06] I feel much more confident after meeting with these folks
[2:50:10] today of where we're going.
[2:50:13] And I can pass that on to people.
[2:50:17] And so we have a checklist as a result of our meetings today
[2:50:21] of things that need to be done.
[2:50:22] And that's really the way it is.
[2:50:24] And I'll do respect.
[2:50:25] You have a horse and you have a cart.
[2:50:27] And this whole thing has kind of been mixed up
[2:50:30] about, which has been in front, the worst of the cart.
[2:50:34] And we need to get the worst pack up there,
[2:50:37] and we need to get this all stuff figured out
[2:50:40] before we put it out on paper, that this is what we're
[2:50:42] going to do, or before we tell somebody else this is what
[2:50:44] we're going to do.
[2:50:45] So do I know that we'll be able to put those approaches in?
[2:50:49] No.
[2:50:50] We talked about five different approaches today,
[2:50:53] different kinds of construction, maybe three or four.
[2:50:56] We were more likely than the fourth or the fifth one.
[2:51:00] We'll just have to find out.
[2:51:01] And when we do find out, you know,
[2:51:03] we'll be dealing pretty frequently with the chief.
[2:51:07] He'll be aware of that, but all that plays into the traffic
[2:51:10] is, and the traffic is a major factor
[2:51:14] in this whole process for the public safety in this city.
[2:51:19] So I think tremendous progress was made today.
[2:51:23] I mean, I really felt good about it, and I said that before.
[2:51:26] So I mean, that's the reason we're here
[2:51:29] Now, I mean, the way it works in business and in my experience,
[2:51:34] we make a decision, we're going to do something,
[2:51:36] then we figure out how to do it,
[2:51:37] we figure out how to do it as best we can.
[2:51:39] And that's where we're at now.
[2:51:41] So I feel confident that we're going to proceed
[2:51:43] with this thing, we're figuring out the details.
[2:51:46] If we can do it this way, it'll work better.
[2:51:48] If we can't do that, then we need to figure out
[2:51:50] another way.
[2:51:51] And we're not here to tell you that this is the way
[2:51:55] everything is going to be because we don't know that just yet.
[2:51:58] It's all a work in progress, like I said.
[2:52:01] So I can't really say any more about it than that,
[2:52:04] but we'll get it done.
[2:52:07] And that's not an empty promise or anything.
[2:52:10] I mean, we know how to do these things.
[2:52:12] We talked about everything with Ryan Lay.
[2:52:15] We went through pretty much everything
[2:52:16] with the officers today.
[2:52:18] And so the public safety aspect of that,
[2:52:23] I mean, there are different aspects of that
[2:52:25] that certainly could be addressed before other things.
[2:52:28] and part of that was one of the expectations.
[2:52:32] When the permit was an issue,
[2:52:35] like we thought it would be after the auction,
[2:52:41] I didn't know if you even wanted to have
[2:52:43] a large number of people here.
[2:52:44] And so now we're talking about having a crowd,
[2:52:49] the businesses around town are planning
[2:52:52] for an influx of people to see this
[2:52:54] and they're getting ready to deal with people
[2:52:58] very positive about it from what from what I see. We got responsibilities all
[2:53:03] the way around. We will make this all work and figure it out. You got really
[2:53:06] good people here for us to work with. We'll stay in touch with the chief regularly
[2:53:11] and get it figured out. Thank you, Mr. Woodruff. I have confidence, like I said,
[2:53:19] your your inclusion in this was one of the reasons I or one of my thought
[2:53:25] processes for the faculty media group. And to be honest with you, I attend events
[2:53:30] several times a year, or not several times, or at least twice a year that have
[2:53:35] 50,000 people at them, and they seem to get it done on a daily basis almost, and
[2:53:39] so I really believe especially where most of the events move to the other side,
[2:53:43] that makes it easier. And one of the things we talked about last time, and
[2:53:48] with the special use permits, and you brought them up, or a special event permits, and
[2:53:52] I think I sent an email to you, Chief, earlier this week.
[2:53:57] After I thought about that for a little bit,
[2:54:00] I'm not so sure that having some other events that
[2:54:03] don't attract more people, in other words,
[2:54:05] I don't want to soccer tournament in town
[2:54:06] than us that weekend, that will drag other people to town.
[2:54:10] But other events that aren't attracting other people,
[2:54:12] just giving those who are here something to do,
[2:54:15] I don't think it's a bad thing,
[2:54:17] especially if we're requiring them to handle their own security,
[2:54:19] so they're not taxing our police department.
[2:54:23] Because you've got, let's say, what's the pick a number?
[2:54:26] If we've got 25,000 people in town
[2:54:28] for this particular thing,
[2:54:29] I don't think it's a good idea
[2:54:30] they don't have anything else to do.
[2:54:32] So by wiping out all special events,
[2:54:34] I think it's actually could be counterproductive
[2:54:37] to what we're trying to accomplish
[2:54:39] and moving people around and different things.
[2:54:41] That's just a thought, whether if it gets shot down,
[2:54:43] it gets shot down, but that's my feeling
[2:54:45] that eliminating all events around it,
[2:54:48] I'm not sure is the wisest plan in my opinion.
[2:54:51] We want to tie it tonight was actually scheduled
[2:54:54] for compensation Travis, so if you want to move on
[2:54:56] to that particular aspect and saying that we have,
[2:55:03] since most of us moved to the other side,
[2:55:05] I guess my expectations have been lowered on top of it.
[2:55:08] I'm trying to play 50 moves.
[2:55:10] Yeah, okay.
[2:55:12] Right, the Parliament of the plans is agreed
[2:55:17] to allow the large crowd to be on the other side,
[2:55:20] Mr. Woodruff.
[2:55:27] question right I'm not sure that I did that we want would you repeat it this
[2:55:30] right is as the Department of Lands already agreed as part of your lease that
[2:55:34] the large crowds could be on the other side yes well I've only spoken with
[2:55:40] Ryan Lay and Ryan Lay is perfectly good with it and I assume he speaks for the
[2:55:45] department so that's that's as far as I could go there all right thank you thank
[2:55:49] you Travis did you want to lead a sort of discussion of the compensation portion
[2:55:54] That's what's on the agenda for today.
[2:56:00] Dennis Boyer is here and Dennis is here to maybe answer any questions that you might have for
[2:56:10] granted compensation. Really what I'm going to do is just say the council is definitely
[2:56:16] an appreciate direction from you in terms of what if any compensation that you believe
[2:56:23] is appropriate for this event and the purpose is that we will take this conversation and we
[2:56:30] will memorialize it as part of the agreement that we will present to you.
[2:56:36] I think that there are a couple of different options for you to consider.
[2:56:39] I think that number one, and these by the list that I'm providing you is by no means inclusive
[2:56:47] all inclusive. You could accept, I guess, improvements in lieu of funding. And so part
[2:56:56] of that may be the construction of a roadway in a parking lot that is ultimately probably
[2:57:01] going to be needed for the event, but maybe for what that looks like. You can cause and
[2:57:10] allow the construction of additional parking or trails around the evil-can-evil jumpside.
[2:57:19] You can ask for a cash payment, very similar to what the State Department of Lands had requested
[2:57:26] as part of their conflict auction process.
[2:57:31] You could require as the State Department of Lands has required a certain percentage of
[2:57:38] the gross revenues, and then an additional percentage of funds that would be earned in future years
[2:57:48] from the residual sales of events and those types of things.
[2:57:52] When we've had the conversation in the past, I think that members of the Council had very,
[2:57:56] very different thoughts and sentiments.
[2:57:59] And this is probably one of those things that the members of the Council will need to work
[2:58:05] through staff is here to assist and provide thoughts or guidance as you do.
[2:58:11] Jim, what?
[2:58:13] Here's kind of where I'm at on this whole issue.
[2:58:16] We're asking Dennis to come up here and give us a bunch of options, some of the options that
[2:58:20] we just heard from Travis.
[2:58:23] I'm not prepared to sit here tonight without some options, with a staff report, with a chance
[2:58:29] to think about this a little bit.
[2:58:31] to dream up things that we want might want financially or in compensation without having a staff report,
[2:58:37] completed staff work sent to us on all the options that are available to us and get this back on the agenda.
[2:58:44] I'm just at eight o'clock at night and just all of a sudden figured out.
[2:58:48] So, I'm not really, I guess I'm being a jerk about this, but I'm not wanting to participate in a discussion about compensation
[2:58:55] with nothing in front of me to think about to contemplate on until right now.
[2:59:02] So, Suzanne, all right.
[2:59:07] We've been working on a special use permit on this event,
[2:59:12] but have we drafted a lease where we're getting paid for the use of our land?
[2:59:16] Have I missed that somewhere?
[2:59:18] Council said they didn't want to in our last discussion.
[2:59:21] That's what tonight is about, right? Yes.
[2:59:24] No, there is.
[2:59:25] So.
[2:59:26] So the agreement right now does not contemplate a fee for the use of the property.
[2:59:35] That part is really in the past conversations from the Council and as we asked last weekend,
[2:59:43] a topic to think about for this week and what that may look like.
[2:59:48] I guess I was thinking more along compensation for staff time and that part of it and I didn't
[2:59:53] I think through the whole future myself.
[2:59:55] We've been so since last week,
[2:59:57] we've absolutely been recording our hours.
[2:59:59] And so when I met today and when we met earlier this week
[3:00:03] in the area of the agreement,
[3:00:04] we've been recording our hours and people with that looks like.
[3:00:07] There might be additional compensation
[3:00:11] that the council may want for the right
[3:00:13] to utilize the jump site.
[3:00:16] And Dennis can maybe come up and share his ideas
[3:00:20] is to probe that and then next week we can bring this back
[3:00:23] before the council and have you in a form of some
[3:00:29] agendized item to bring that back and bring that forward again to have that
[3:00:33] conversation? Well just so I can go back on my question there. I know that we've
[3:00:38] been thinking about this but you know I guess I want to see some solid options
[3:00:42] in front of me here and I don't have the brain power in me to know what all those
[3:00:46] options are and before I can sit here and have an intelligent conversation about
[3:00:52] what I want to charge somebody or do to our property or whatever.
[3:00:59] I want to see options on paper.
[3:01:03] I guess that's the way I was raised, you know,
[3:01:07] with complete staff work before me.
[3:01:13] John Bergers, then Rebecca.
[3:01:16] I'll put my name in there, except for that.
[3:01:17] So I thought the whole purpose of us bringing this back
[3:01:20] to the council is to have a discussion at the council level
[3:01:22] and try to lead this.
[3:01:24] So while I appreciate your desire
[3:01:26] to have options presented to you, Jim,
[3:01:28] I think that's what,
[3:01:30] I thought that's what we had asked to do
[3:01:32] was bring it back to the council
[3:01:33] and let's talk about really extend the conversation
[3:01:38] that we had, probably.
[3:01:39] Well, the staff is gonna go prepare,
[3:01:42] pay to work on a thousand options
[3:01:44] or we can sit up here and talk about a thousand options.
[3:01:47] So I think it sort of creates busy work for the staff
[3:01:53] on top of the other work that they're already doing
[3:01:55] on this. If we go back a while to when we had this discussion back in September and talked
[3:02:02] about do we even want to entertain this notion? We had a conversation as a council and said
[3:02:07] yes we think there's opportunity and here are some thoughts and the thoughts. We threw
[3:02:11] out were it would be great if we had the road improved to the jump site that there was some
[3:02:16] sort of parking. It could be created as a trailhead. A couple of council members talked
[3:02:20] about financial compensation to the city similar to the lease of the state.
[3:02:30] I think at a minimum we should look at accepting the contribution of the improvements that are
[3:02:38] made to the site that are developed in conjunction with us to our standards and to have that public
[3:02:44] access to the property afterward.
[3:02:46] And I would certainly be willing to discuss some financial compensation that is reasonable
[3:02:53] to make other improvements for the city.
[3:03:00] So that's what I would throw in.
[3:03:02] Rebecca Wilson.
[3:03:03] Thank you, Mayor.
[3:03:05] My recollection is similar to Councilman Berrigers.
[3:03:07] I thought that that's what we were to talk about tonight and be prepared to talk about
[3:03:11] tonight.
[3:03:12] You know, in the past we've had the discussion, most of the council wasn't comfortable with
[3:03:17] charging a fee for using the land, even though I had been a proponent and still I am a proponent
[3:03:23] of that in the past because we charge people a fee to use the city park, we charge people
[3:03:29] a fee to use all of our parks, and those are the citizens that pay for those parks, their
[3:03:34] taxes, so it's their land and we still charge them to use it.
[3:03:39] But my question, and in the past I will also reiterate that I do think it's a good opportunity
[3:03:47] for the City of Twin Falls to look forward and look at the opportunities not just this
[3:03:53] year or next year, but in years to come.
[3:03:56] And I think the state was wise in requiring royalties of 3% and 5%.
[3:04:04] I don't think it would be out of place for the city to be able to capture that residual
[3:04:09] income from this event in the smaller amount of 3% of gross revenues.
[3:04:14] I still would be willing to entertain that, but in the past, the council was not interested
[3:04:20] and I respect that.
[3:04:21] So I would move on to my second idea.
[3:04:24] I'd like to hear from Dennis what the city's plans are for this particular piece of property,
[3:04:32] But if there are any, what park plans are in place, I think that if we're not going to capture
[3:04:38] residual income from this event, then we should at least capture some improvements that our
[3:04:45] citizens and visitors can enjoy for years to come.
[3:04:49] And so I think maybe a development of this park, or what is going to be park land, maybe capture
[3:04:58] development of this park land, but I'd like to know what dollar amount roughly that would
[3:05:04] represent and what the plans are if we even have any concrete plans for this piece of land.
[3:05:10] Of course, one of our always, I say, original plans on this property is our canyon rim trail.
[3:05:15] We did, once we trade that property, we gain another approximately 650 land of your feet
[3:05:20] at the canyon rim, and that's, you know, I use that as 75 dollars per linear foot for a
[3:05:25] 10 foot wide with the two foot shoulders.
[3:05:28] That's roughly about $50,000 for the trail that would extend
[3:05:33] from where it stops right now, the centennial trail stops,
[3:05:36] and would go over to the property of Gary Stewart's property
[3:05:39] on basically the west side of the jump or meet the west side.
[3:05:43] Some of our other thoughts that we had definitely for this land
[3:05:47] is get people out there.
[3:05:49] And that's why the trade, the land, is that?
[3:05:52] 60-foot wide access from where Hankens basically did it now, get to the jump site. Then also,
[3:06:03] that's why that little property directly south of the gym site we have was the idea of putting
[3:06:07] the parking lot there because Sean will tell you, my dad when he volunteered at the Visitor
[3:06:11] Center, talk to you questions at the Visitor Center, where is Shilsham Falls and where did
[3:06:15] he go jump? Maybe now we'll be where did that back the jump, I don't know. So some of our
[3:06:21] Our thoughts is providing access to people to get out there, and we looked at a paved road
[3:06:26] also internally staff that talked about, besides a paved road from the end of Anken's, it's
[3:06:31] actually half part of our trail system, at least we can have it start end at Anken's Road,
[3:06:36] go alongside the road all the way up to the parking lot.
[3:06:39] And then also, we have never kind of formally developed plans like I have for Social and Falls,
[3:06:46] I had a master plan for that.
[3:06:48] Never have to develop a master plan for this jump site,
[3:06:51] but I envision out there is have a restroom slash souvenir
[3:06:56] shop slash concession stand.
[3:06:59] As people will go out there to, of course,
[3:07:02] we want to provide facilities out there,
[3:07:04] because also it's a trailhead.
[3:07:06] Every mile we try to have somewhere people can go
[3:07:09] and access our trail system.
[3:07:11] the Inn Hankens is another mile of our section of our Canium Trail.
[3:07:15] So people will drive out there just besides visiting the site.
[3:07:18] They will go out there to access our trail, go east or west.
[3:07:22] Hopefully they'll be able to go east right now,
[3:07:24] but hopefully soon we can go west from that area.
[3:07:27] So those are some of my thoughts of access to road access out there,
[3:07:33] have the trail alongside the road, have the trail that goes
[3:07:36] across the right along the canyon rim, develop, like I said,
[3:07:40] a restroom slash souvenir slash concessions stand out there.
[3:07:44] You know, I internally throughout, you know, say they could give us $20 million a bill to rec center, but I don't think that's going to work.
[3:07:51] I'm still trying on that, but I don't think that's going to fly anyway.
[3:07:55] But those are just some quick thoughts about what we could to develop that site.
[3:08:01] You know, and what do we do with the, you know, the dirt ramp now that we leave it as is.
[3:08:06] Do we, you know, whatever type of ramp that Mr. Ed Beckley is going to use, do we keep that up there?
[3:08:11] I don't know in that part.
[3:08:14] I think that's a great idea.
[3:08:15] And could you, maybe for next week, if we bring it back next week or whatever we do on it,
[3:08:20] maybe give a rough estimate of what all those improvements would cost.
[3:08:26] You know, and I'll just throw this at there's kind of wild idea.
[3:08:29] But we were a few weeks ago talking about Twin Falls not having a permanent museum.
[3:08:34] and I know Ed Beckley talked about, he wanted a museum for his jump site.
[3:08:39] Maybe we could split it with him and also have a Twin Falls permanent museum,
[3:08:43] but I think that's an excellent idea to have a place where people could go,
[3:08:46] maybe few trees, grass, picnic tables, whatever that would look like to be a usable space.
[3:08:53] And it doesn't have to be built out to the full aspect of what we do when we keep building on our parks.
[3:09:01] you know, from we just kind of get it started with, you know, a restroom, necessary facilities.
[3:09:08] But maybe if we could see what that would look like as far as a financial contribution,
[3:09:12] I think that maybe that's the compromise.
[3:09:16] Maybe that's a good compromise in collecting any royalties or things into the future,
[3:09:21] but requiring infrastructure to be built that citizens and visitors could use alike into the future.
[3:09:28] Yeah, one part I did miss out is part of our agreement with the when we traded property is we have to fence off on the east side
[3:09:36] Mentally on the east side from really where our road would start at Hankins all the way up to the jump side
[3:09:43] That's part of our obligations that we signed off on so I think I know I can get cost estimates for that our trail system
[3:09:51] You know we'll have to work with engineering on road costs because I don't know what it costs
[3:09:55] But I know they're expensive, right?
[3:09:57] But I think we can work with engineering on that
[3:09:59] and get some cost estimates on the road
[3:10:01] and get their linear and a parking,
[3:10:04] get a cost estimate on the parking lot too.
[3:10:06] Thank you.
[3:10:08] No.
[3:10:09] You know, my opinion hasn't changed a lot
[3:10:12] since we talked about this, first of all,
[3:10:14] I don't think the city municipalities aren't here
[3:10:17] to make money.
[3:10:18] Our job is to provide services.
[3:10:21] And if I do like the idea of potentially
[3:10:24] some infrastructure needs, roadways, park lands, trees being planted, restrooms.
[3:10:31] I like that, I hadn't thought about that before.
[3:10:34] And maybe some concession stands, I would be okay with those kind of infrastructure needs
[3:10:39] being addressed through the income through this project, and maybe some more trail.
[3:10:45] I'm not really interested in where we have a different mission than the state lands folks.
[3:10:54] And but if the council wanted to go down the direction of some sort of royalty,
[3:10:59] I would hope that we would dedicate that money towards the trail maintenance and
[3:11:04] the concession stands, those kind of things.
[3:11:06] I just, it just feels sleazy to me to be up here talking about how much money can
[3:11:11] we make on this deal when that's really not our mission.
[3:11:15] Certainly we can put things in place that will reduce some burdens on our taxpayers.
[3:11:22] I think that's appropriate, but I just don't like that whole royalty idea unless it's dedicated towards maybe that facility and a museum type of a structure with maybe some static displays of Mr. Beckley's vehicle along with maybe a replica of evil's vehicle those kind of things that would enhance that area for visitor kind of perspective.
[3:11:50] I guess I look at a little differently, Don, and I don't feel sleazy and procuring things
[3:12:04] that will ease the taxpayers' birth.
[3:12:07] That's the way I would approach it.
[3:12:10] I'm not looking for a million dollars like the state got, but I would certainly like
[3:12:14] to have that be a fully functioning park when we're done, and that's a gift to the community
[3:12:20] before they're having to put up with this particular intrusion in their life and so that to me
[3:12:27] is the reason they're, and this is maybe the sleazy part that you're talking about here
[3:12:32] done, but I feel a little bit like when I'm dealing on a car, I hate to throw my bid out
[3:12:38] first, I always make them give me one first so I can see where they're operating, probably
[3:12:43] I can operate because if I put one out there and it's too high, they're going to take
[3:12:47] and I lost myself a couple thousand dollars on a car.
[3:12:51] I have the same concern here, but I like Don though.
[3:12:55] I don't want to go overboard here, though, but I do feel that
[3:12:59] if we get a fully functioning park out of the end or with a road in
[3:13:03] and a parking lot, and some royalties that I have no problem
[3:13:07] with them putting them towards trail construction, that the royalties
[3:13:11] would be earmarked for us finishing our trail
[3:13:15] And what a rephation we can get it to happen because that's a high priority for citizens.
[3:13:21] And so I would think putting it towards that would be a good thing.
[3:13:25] That's an addition to, and I think somebody else brought it up.
[3:13:28] I haven't lost sight of additional staff and additional police and additional fire and
[3:13:33] everyone else.
[3:13:34] Whatever extra time we spend because of this, I think that we need to be compensated for that.
[3:13:39] Well, I'm not going to have a taxpayers pay extra money for this event to happen.
[3:13:44] So that's my thoughts on it.
[3:13:45] I think that's kind of, we're kind of getting where,
[3:13:47] I think we were wanting to go tonight,
[3:13:49] and people throwing out some ideas so the staff
[3:13:51] can bring us back what these particular options
[3:13:54] were asking for would cost, and whether they're feasible.
[3:13:58] Chris, talk.
[3:13:58] Well, I think with my opinion,
[3:14:01] that's at least three of us at Bill more or less the same way.
[3:14:03] First of all, despite the fact that 85% of the events
[3:14:07] may be visible from the north side,
[3:14:10] It is that iconic ramp that is the spectacle
[3:14:14] and will remain the spectacle for a foreseeable future.
[3:14:18] And I don't think we can forget that Mr. Beckley
[3:14:21] has a two year lease and he's already told us
[3:14:23] to our faces, he wants to come back a second year.
[3:14:26] That ramp is still the key to everything.
[3:14:29] I have no interest in residuals and hustling dollars.
[3:14:34] Whatever comes up of this should be free and clear
[3:14:38] and relate to the trail development.
[3:14:41] Without limited sewing to that,
[3:14:43] I would say primarily I'm very comfortable
[3:14:46] with the road access, the parking,
[3:14:48] and development of 650 feet,
[3:14:51] a trail system to city standards.
[3:14:53] That was approximately 50,000.
[3:14:55] I get those three, anything else is
[3:14:58] just a little icing on the cake,
[3:14:59] but I'm not gonna be facing dollars
[3:15:03] like a private enterprise as I agree with you on that, Don.
[3:15:06] But let's get something to show for the public's discomfort
[3:15:11] or motion for this next few months,
[3:15:14] related directly to the trail development.
[3:15:17] Jim, I.
[3:15:18] Okay, thank you, Mayor.
[3:15:20] So we don't even, do we have any idea, Brian or Chief,
[3:15:23] what are public safety reimbursements are gonna be?
[3:15:27] I can guess here, but.
[3:15:29] We do.
[3:15:30] But it's gonna be, I was to admit to you,
[3:15:32] it's gonna be in the tens of thousands of dollars.
[3:15:34] I would imagine.
[3:15:35] I mean, just to give an idea roughly, when we start talking about June, you know, working
[3:15:40] on the public safety plan, what does that really look like?
[3:15:43] What that really means is that, you know, I had a different approach to this really on.
[3:15:48] My thought was they present a plan, they carry out the plan.
[3:15:51] And I don't know if that's really the reality of an event like this.
[3:15:54] I think that we're going to find ourselves beeply involved in the process.
[3:16:00] Because at the end of the day, we were going to probably own this thing.
[3:16:04] Regardless of whether it's 15% on our side or 85% on the north side, it's a it's a twin falls event. So right now
[3:16:11] I don't have we do we do not have
[3:16:13] That number but I would imagine you're correct. Yeah, and I'm just making saying that to make a point that okay
[3:16:18] So we want to get all of our public safety and we had a discussion about
[3:16:23] Prosecatorial costs made who's going to pay for that we have those problems with crime
[3:16:28] So we have the public safety reimbursement. We're going to pay for but we'll have them pay for that I
[3:16:32] I would hope so I guess that would be and this is just off the top of my head here
[3:16:36] I haven't we have no idea how much he's trailing through it's gonna cost right we
[3:16:41] haven't seen his staff work on that or the roadways we have no idea what that's
[3:16:46] gonna cost yet we have a seen staff work on that so I guess I'm back to where I
[3:16:51] was where and I certainly recognize my my honorable friends opinion on on this
[3:16:57] evening and working through that I guess I'm just trying to maybe I'm just
[3:17:00] slow. We have no idea what a museum would cost or any of these kind of things. So I guess
[3:17:09] my point is public safety is going to have to be paid for by them. And that could, I mean,
[3:17:14] I remember looking several years ago, it could be up to $100,000, just in public safety costs
[3:17:19] for them to pay for, not just in the city's windfalls, but other jurisdictions around. It
[3:17:24] could be a lot of money.
[3:17:25] And one thing that Captain Barnhart is doing is he's working very diligently to set this
[3:17:31] event up so that we maximize the use of event security and private security so that our men
[3:17:37] and women are not out standing by gates, taking tickets, like that.
[3:17:42] So we're going to try to defer a good portion of that cost over to Mr. Woodruff and his staff.
[3:17:50] So all the necessary things, we're going to have them pay for.
[3:17:54] And then on top of that, we're going to ask them possibly to pay for other things, correct?
[3:17:59] Okay.
[3:18:00] I got it in my mind.
[3:18:02] Rebecca Millslike.
[3:18:03] Thank you, Mayor.
[3:18:04] I have a question of possibly Mike Williams, I guess.
[3:18:09] Did we get any input on the topic of compensation from emails or from the general public at the
[3:18:17] jump email address?
[3:18:21] I don't believe so that we've received something specific as of yet.
[3:18:24] The email address is still active.
[3:18:27] I don't believe we've received anything this week.
[3:18:29] All the public comments are on our webpage, on the Jump the Canyon tab.
[3:18:35] But for my review, I don't recall anything specific to that.
[3:18:38] But I mean, we can certainly get it out there.
[3:18:40] OK, thank you.
[3:18:41] I just wanted to check.
[3:18:43] I would recommend that if we're going to formally discuss this next week,
[3:18:47] may be put something out to our media partners or to the public that this is what we're discussing
[3:18:53] if anyone has any input to bring that, you know, when we discuss it and it would encourage
[3:18:59] us to take public input.
[3:19:01] And again, the web, excuse me, the email address is jump at tfid.org, so if anyone has comments
[3:19:10] and aren't able to come to a meeting to give them to us in person, it is jump at tfid.org.
[3:19:16] is the email address that comes in for information about this particular situation.
[3:19:24] Donald?
[3:19:25] I'll make this quick.
[3:19:26] I did want to reiterate or be a little more concise about my comments.
[3:19:31] All the things I was talking about were over and above the public safety side of things.
[3:19:35] I had already in my mind that's got to be paid for.
[3:19:39] And Jim brings up a good point because we've had conversations with individuals regarding
[3:19:44] the prosecution and those kind of things.
[3:19:47] potentially could be a burden on our county prosecutors on
[3:19:51] on Jerome side prosecutor. It could be on our own city
[3:19:55] prosecutor. So we need to be aware of that and we need to
[3:19:59] be reimbursed for those type of costs as well.
[3:20:03] That's all I'm saying. Alright Travis, did the staff
[3:20:08] get some direction? I think we'll at least I heard
[3:20:12] that we would like to hear back from Dennis on what
[3:20:16] So maybe some options as far as the park is concerned.
[3:20:21] I'd like to hear from the back of the media group a little bit on what their thoughts are.
[3:20:24] I remember Mr. Beckley at the presentation talked about all of these different things
[3:20:30] that we're discussing he talked about.
[3:20:33] At some point during the question and answer and things along the endlight and other conversations.
[3:20:37] So I think that they're prepared to do some of these things.
[3:20:41] And so I'm certainly going to let them up there prepared.
[3:20:44] Jim I.
[3:20:45] And I think Rebecca brings up a good point tonight on our agenda said jump what it's saying like jump discussion
[3:20:51] So, you know, I want to hear from back later. I'm done whining about staff reports
[3:20:56] But I also think that the the community had no idea what we were going to discuss tonight
[3:21:01] They had no idea that we were going to discuss any sort of improvements over and above that which is done
[3:21:05] So we got to communicate better
[3:21:15] Move on to any public input or anybody might take that back. Sorry. We're not finished with this
[3:21:20] We have said that if anyone from the public wants to speak on this issue each week, we will allow some time at the end of our discussion for that, so if anybody would like to come up and talk about it, I'm actually thinking about it.
[3:21:35] Here we go.
[3:21:37] We'll give you a couple of minutes, Max.
[3:21:40] Go back my play on this.
[3:21:41] You showed me up for 30 seconds, Mark.
[3:21:44] Does this help?
[3:21:47] I am amazed at this process.
[3:21:50] It seems like you've got a business man.
[3:21:51] Well Max, could you go ahead and say your name?
[3:21:52] Well, Max Newland, Twin Falls, I don't.
[3:21:54] OK.
[3:21:56] You've got a business man who wants to do an event.
[3:21:58] He says you have a guy who's going to do it.
[3:22:00] You've got 45 days to do it.
[3:22:02] And there's a million things you want to add on to his contract.
[3:22:05] He's buying a pig in a poke.
[3:22:07] He has no idea what he's got.
[3:22:09] I have no idea how much money he's going to make off of it.
[3:22:12] And your concern is very much appreciated by me
[3:22:18] for you're watching out for John Q. Public.
[3:22:21] I knew what was going on tonight because I'm an informed citizen.
[3:22:25] I get your minutes.
[3:22:26] I get your packets.
[3:22:28] Because it's all in the web.
[3:22:30] It's all available to people that are interested.
[3:22:32] When the backhoe comes and stuff still happens,
[3:22:35] then's when you have a crowd.
[3:22:36] You want to have a crowd in all this making saucy part.
[3:22:40] But right now is when you're laying this groundwork
[3:22:43] and you're trying to figure out the rules, what's
[3:22:45] going to happen, what's going to happen.
[3:22:47] and I'm nervous about Jerome.
[3:22:50] I don't see, I don't go to their meetings,
[3:22:52] but those guys have got a big pile of issues to deal with.
[3:22:57] Also, thank you very much.
[3:23:00] All right, thank you, Max.
[3:23:04] Seeing no one else moving forward,
[3:23:08] moving on to any other public feedback for other items,
[3:23:11] besides the jump that somebody wanted
[3:23:13] to discuss from the public.
[3:23:15] Seeing none, City Manager.
[3:23:20] Mr. Mayor, members of the Council, just two quick items.
[3:23:24] Number one, as we shared last week, the bond application was going before the bond bank today.
[3:23:30] The bond application was approved by the bond bank without any special considerations or conditions.
[3:23:34] And so we will move forward in selling that application.
[3:23:38] A reminder that on Thursday at 3.30, we're going to be meeting with our local delegation in here.
[3:23:44] And so we're going to rearrange this room in a manner that allows us to kind of have a round table
[3:23:49] conversation, if you will. We've put together an agenda of legislative topics to be discussed,
[3:23:54] and we will be getting that out tomorrow to you and to the members of our local delegation.
[3:23:59] We'll also post that online for individuals who are there. And then there has been an interest
[3:24:05] to have a conversation about our emergency communications and what that looks like. And
[3:24:09] so we've been working. We've actually had this schedule a couple of times, but because of
[3:24:14] different events that have come up on the agenda, we've kind of pushed that back and we're looking
[3:24:18] right now at January 6th at 4 o'clock. We'd like to see if the council for those that would
[3:24:23] be able to come in at 4 o'clock to take a tour of the dispatch center. We think that that would
[3:24:28] provide a fairly eye-opening account of what they do in there. And then we would go forward
[3:24:33] and Lieutenant Craig Stott would share what our tell emergency communications capacities
[3:24:39] are today and we're moving towards in the future. So wanted to check availability for January
[3:24:44] six that four o'clock. It's a council meeting so I'm assuming that most of us will be around. Travis one question back on the bond
[3:24:54] the interpretation now
[3:24:56] Does not necessitate the thought about a four percent bump to get to the one one twenty five ratio is that the consequence of this?
[3:25:04] So yeah, so we will not have to do anything
[3:25:08] Prior to where we typically normally have to go forward
[3:25:11] They were able to make a convincing case to them that the one to one 25 ratio bond covenant
[3:25:17] is the guiding principle that would cause us to have to raise our rates regardless of what
[3:25:22] that percentage is to remain in compliance.
[3:25:24] And so they were in agreement and they approved that without any special considerations moving
[3:25:30] forward.
[3:25:31] So there will be no conversations about rate adjustments for any of our funds until conversations
[3:25:39] about the budget. I just wanted to talk to the council and folks in the audience to give
[3:25:48] some clarification talking about a little bit of old business and I'll make this quick.
[3:25:53] Back when we were talking about compensation and the contract for our city attorney slash
[3:25:59] prosecutor, I mentioned that I had a conversation with our county prosecutor Jim and I had a
[3:26:07] meeting with him and we went through and we asked him and by the way I need to clarify
[3:26:13] this I said this that night but we did the county prosecutor did not contact us we contacted
[3:26:20] him okay I said that that evening but we went and asked him because we were looking at
[3:26:27] compensation models we were looking at what it would take to it suddenly we had to have
[3:26:33] have a new prosecutor and go down that road and so we asked him and he gave us an estimate
[3:26:40] that it would cost about $194,000 a year to do the prosecution for the city.
[3:26:47] That is an accurate amount and my statement was that's more than what we were paying Fritz's
[3:26:54] firm at the time for doing both prosecution as well as city attorney work.
[3:27:00] it, indeed, is also accurate.
[3:27:02] But what I failed, and then I went on to talk about what that was, would be to county
[3:27:07] prosecutors, and then we moved on to the next subject.
[3:27:10] But what I failed, and I'm going to clarify tonight, to say that that was for also support
[3:27:17] staff, a legal secretary type of our office manager type of position.
[3:27:24] I did mention that it was benefited, but I'll reiterate that.
[3:27:28] would be fully burdened positions and if you calculated out that is pretty accurate because
[3:27:34] you have to talk about taxes and insurance as well as retirement. All those things calculated
[3:27:43] out and some office supplies. So that was accurate but I wanted to make sure that I reiterated
[3:27:48] that or clarified that tonight. And also that was his rough estimate and he was kind
[3:27:54] enough to give us that so that we could have something to look at wasn't calculated perfectly
[3:28:00] it was just a rough estimate and I appreciate Grant sitting down with us and giving us that
[3:28:05] information during that time. Just a reminder to, I don't see our lights, or just a reminder
[3:28:12] that we do have the City Luncheon on Wednesday, I've come up with lunch for some reason,
[3:28:21] Luncheon on Wednesday at 12 o'clock at
[3:28:26] Was it 360 B-stroke?
[3:28:30] Event center, right? You're right. Yeah. There is now
[3:28:36] 360 event center 18 and then also on January 13th
[3:28:44] And I believe this is open the public but I'm gonna make it open the public right now even if it isn't
[3:28:48] We have a grand opening or tour or open house or what an open house is the proper term of
[3:28:56] the new water and wastewater facility out there.
[3:29:02] It's easy for me to say across from WakaSita.
[3:29:05] Yeah, the old Sunday by stages building now to see what are we saved about a million dollars
[3:29:10] out there, but we still had to spend money to save a million.
[3:29:15] that facility there and how big it is for or how much better facility for those
[3:29:21] two departments than we had previously. Lee Alec, could you send an appointment?
[3:29:26] Just thank you. And see no lights? Anything else?
[3:29:34] Yeah, dinner is right.
[3:29:37] Man.
[3:29:38] What is this?
[3:29:40] No, it's just a local license.
