Oversight Archive: City Council meeting, 2014-08-04, recording 1 (started 17:00)
Machine transcript (faster-whisper base.en), not checked word for word; the Pledge of Allegiance is shown in its standard wording. The recording is the record.
Times are time into the recording. Passages with private details are muted in the audio and marked here.
The audio on the page below was re-encoded by software from the video the agency posted. Check any passage against
that audio before relying on it.
Page: https://oversightarchive.org/twin-falls-id/meetings/2014-08-04/

[0:02:05] I'd like to call the meeting of the Twin Falls City Council to order its August 4th 2014
[0:02:10] It is 5 30 and for the purpose
[0:02:13] We're meeting at this time because we're going directly into executive session
[0:02:18] So I will read that item and if council so
[0:02:22] Decides we will go into executive session the exact for those in the audience the executive session
[0:02:28] Supposedly shouldn't take very long so we should be right back out
[0:02:31] Executive Session 6
[0:02:32] 72345-1C to conduct
[0:02:34] deliberations concerning
[0:02:35] labor negotiations or to
[0:02:37] acquire an interest in real
[0:02:39] property, which is not owned
[0:02:41] by a public agency.
[0:02:42] I'll stand for a motion.
[0:02:43] We have a motion on the floor
[0:02:45] by Chris Caukington, seconded
[0:02:47] by Greg Lanting to go into
[0:02:51] executive session.
[0:02:52] Any further on that motion
[0:02:53] council?
[0:02:54] The aye.
[0:02:55] Roll call vote, please.
[0:02:56] Yes.
[0:02:57] John Bearer.
[0:02:58] Yes.
[0:02:59] John Bearer.
[0:03:00] Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes
[0:03:45] 5.50 and first item on the agenda is the Pledge of Allegiance.
[0:03:51] So those of you wishing to join us please rise.
[0:03:53] I pledge allegiance to the Flag of the United States of America, and to the Republic for which it stands, one Nation under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all.
[0:04:12] I'd like to welcome everyone to the city council meeting this evening.
[0:04:16] We do have a quorum of the City Council.
[0:04:19] All seven members are here.
[0:04:21] Travis, do we have any amendments to the agenda?
[0:04:24] Mr. Mayor, members of the council will have one item
[0:04:26] to include on the consent calendar.
[0:04:29] Should the council see it fit to add this item?
[0:04:32] The item is also placed in front of you.
[0:04:34] It is a approval of a beer and wine license
[0:04:36] for the party center LLC doing business
[0:04:40] at 1-550 Kimberly Road in Twin Falls.
[0:04:45] So we can just add that at that time, yes, if we choose to do so.
[0:04:49] Thank you, Travis.
[0:04:50] We have no proclamations, but we do open it up to the public for anyone that would like
[0:04:57] to come forward and engage the council.
[0:05:02] We generally try to keep it outside of the agenda because there will be some space to talk
[0:05:07] about what's on the agenda later.
[0:05:09] So is there anyone from the public that would like to come forward?
[0:05:14] See no one coming forward?
[0:05:16] So the first item on the agenda is the consent counter with the potential addition of the liquor license.
[0:05:23] Greg Lanning, clear hall.
[0:05:24] I move that we have the beer and wine license for part of the center LLC to the consent hall.
[0:05:31] Second.
[0:05:33] We have motion on board by Greg Lanning, seconded by Suzanne Hawkins to add that beer license and
[0:05:39] wine license that was listed, anything further on that motion council.
[0:05:45] Leila Roquevo. Jim Young. Yes. Schabereberg. Yes. Chris Tock. Yes. Greg Lansing. Yes. Don Hall. Yes.
[0:05:55] Rebecca
[0:06:04] Second. I have a motion on the floor by Greg Lanning seconded by Chris Tockington on the consent calendar anything further on the the motion council.
[0:06:13] So, Leila, roll call vote, please.
[0:06:17] Sean Berger?
[0:06:18] Yes.
[0:06:19] Chris Tockens?
[0:06:20] Yes.
[0:06:21] Greg Lansing?
[0:06:22] Yes.
[0:06:23] Rebecca Milsoica?
[0:06:24] Yes.
[0:06:25] Suzanne Hawkins?
[0:06:26] Yes.
[0:06:27] Jim Munn?
[0:06:28] Yes.
[0:06:29] Motion passes 7-0.
[0:06:30] Moving down to items for consideration is the formal ceremony promoting Officer Kevin Loosely
[0:06:38] to the position of Sergeant.
[0:06:41] We have our esteemed chief of police, Brian Pike.
[0:06:44] Welcome, Brian.
[0:06:46] Thank you, Mayor and members of the council.
[0:06:48] It's always a pleasure to share the evolution
[0:06:51] of our department with you.
[0:06:52] I also think it's important for you and our community
[0:06:54] to have an opportunity to meet our new supervisors
[0:06:57] and understand how they've arrived at this point
[0:07:00] in their life.
[0:07:01] So tonight, we do have the privilege of promoting
[0:07:03] Kevin Loosling.
[0:07:03] He's one of our police officers and to the rank of sergeant.
[0:07:07] And I would ask Kevin to come forward.
[0:07:09] put him in the spotlight here a little bit.
[0:07:17] So, Council, let me introduce you to a little,
[0:07:18] give you a little background on Kevin Loosling.
[0:07:20] Kevin was hired by the Twin Falls Police Department
[0:07:22] on July 11th, 2005.
[0:07:25] And there's a little interesting note here,
[0:07:26] and I don't know if Kevin knows this,
[0:07:28] and I don't know if I should disclose this,
[0:07:29] but you're going on, here we go.
[0:07:31] I remember meeting with a department psychologist,
[0:07:36] and he was just a little bit concerned
[0:07:38] that Kevin, at that young age of 21,
[0:07:40] didn't have any life experience.
[0:07:42] And we all kind of chuckled about it,
[0:07:43] because what kind of life experience
[0:07:44] could you have a 21 and we hired him anyway in 2005.
[0:07:49] Kevin was born and raised in the Twin Falls area.
[0:07:52] He graduated from the Twin Falls Christian Academy
[0:07:54] and attended Northwest Nazarene University in Nampa
[0:07:57] and he received his degree in social work.
[0:08:00] Prior to his employment with the Twin Falls Police Department,
[0:08:02] Kevin worked with the Twin Falls First Church of the Nazarene
[0:08:06] as their junior high youth pastor.
[0:08:08] During his career with our department,
[0:08:10] Kevin has served as a patrol officer, a field training officer,
[0:08:14] member of the use of force review board and a canine handler. Kevin's hobbies include
[0:08:18] motorcycles and hunting. He received his basic certification in May 2006. His intermediate
[0:08:25] certification in February of 2008. His advanced certification in 2012. All of those certifications
[0:08:31] through the post council. So this is really a significant event in Kevin's career and
[0:08:37] in the department's future. Our supervisors are vital to the overall success of our organization.
[0:08:43] They're really the ones who provide leadership and direction to our officers.
[0:08:46] They're also the ones who develop, coach, and mentor our employees, really developing what
[0:08:51] we like to think of the next generation of leaders within our organization.
[0:08:55] What I've discovered is that working together, we have an opportunity to create a positive
[0:08:59] work environment that reflects our values and strives to ensure a safe community for our
[0:09:04] residents.
[0:09:05] Kevin, you understand the role that you will be assuming.
[0:09:09] We've spent some time talking about the importance of the position.
[0:09:12] You certainly know what my expectations are, and I will expect a lot from you.
[0:09:17] The community will expect a lot from you, and I think the men and women that you lead will
[0:09:21] expect a lot from you.
[0:09:23] The leadership is not just about you, and we understand that.
[0:09:26] It's about the collective good.
[0:09:28] And that is why, in turn, you can expect a lot from us.
[0:09:31] That is why this evening you'll receive a chevron for each one of our sergeants and
[0:09:35] our supervisors.
[0:09:36] And it's their way of, it's kind of a symbolic act, but it's their way of sharing their willingness
[0:09:42] us to share their lives, their experience with you to help you succeed, and I'm confident
[0:09:48] that you will meet that challenge.
[0:09:51] The badge that you receive is really assembled in your new office, the new role and responsibility
[0:09:55] that comes with that office, and your commitment to represent the high standards of the department.
[0:10:00] It also represents your commitment to the men and women of the Twin Falls Police Department.
[0:10:04] Now I have a little piece to switch this over.
[0:10:10] This is where they say this is connection before contact.
[0:10:13] Oh my God, I can't believe he's doing this to you.
[0:10:26] Somebody's blushing.
[0:10:28] Kevin, you trust me.
[0:10:33] I need more.
[0:10:36] So there's an interesting story here, and I think it's something that I want to make
[0:10:42] part of this process tonight.
[0:10:44] During our promotional process, Kevin, before the command team of our department, he's answering
[0:10:52] a series of questions. And towards the end, there's a question that says, what's the best
[0:10:56] career decision you've made and they talk about some decisions that they've made? And I always
[0:11:01] like to ask kind of a follow. What is the best personal decision that you've ever made?
[0:11:07] And Kevin shared with us, didn't hesitate at all. He said the best personal decision he
[0:11:11] ever made was his decision to marry his wife, Tiffany. And when he reflects back on his
[0:11:17] career and where he's at today, he credits her with changing him and making the better
[0:11:26] person.
[0:11:27] And so I thought that was pretty powerful.
[0:11:29] In Tiffany, tonight is I have the opportunity and the privilege of pinning this new badge
[0:11:35] on Kevin and the supervisors will line up and prepare to present Chevron.
[0:11:40] I thought it would be fitting if you presented the first Chevron to Kevin.
[0:13:06] Council Sergeant, Kevin Lizzling.
[0:13:58] Well, as we always do we give it a little bit of time for well, no, it looks like most are staying some are going
[0:14:07] Yeah, I know but some are really
[0:14:11] Kevin just before you leave
[0:14:13] From the City Council. We just want to congratulate you on this position. It is it's a big deal and
[0:14:20] Obviously your department has put a lot of trust in you. So congratulations sergeant loosely
[0:14:26] Next item on the agenda is a presentation of the City Achievement Awards to the City of
[0:14:40] Twin Falls for the 21st century policing and bully prevention received from the Association
[0:14:46] of Idaho Cities and we have our city manager I think followed by our chief of police.
[0:14:50] That's correct.
[0:14:52] So Brian just recently came back from training and he was looking at the agenda and he was
[0:14:56] wondering what am I doing on this one.
[0:14:58] Come on, keep up.
[0:15:02] So this is a great opportunity to celebrate the successes and the innovation that we have
[0:15:06] in our organization and celebrate employees who are truly making a difference in our community.
[0:15:15] Celebration is healthy.
[0:15:17] And when you start thinking that some of our programs were recognized by our peer cities,
[0:15:24] it is important to celebrate those accomplishments not only as an organization, but really to
[0:15:29] to mention those individuals who dedicate themselves, their talents, and their thoughts
[0:15:36] on making our community a better place.
[0:15:38] So we won two City Achievement Awards at this last Association of Idaho City's meeting and
[0:15:46] two other awards, or several other awards as well for some great projects.
[0:15:51] Tonight, we have the pleasure of presenting two of them.
[0:15:54] Both of them are of the police department.
[0:15:58] We'll present the first one to Steven Gasser,
[0:16:02] and we're going to present it to actually Dennis Pollan
[0:16:06] and Captain Anthony Barnhart.
[0:16:08] Steven is on vacation, and so sometimes the personal
[0:16:11] schedules don't work with our city council agendas,
[0:16:13] but really we want to recognize Steven
[0:16:15] for his bully prevention and his bully bucket.
[0:16:19] That is a program that is not only being celebrated
[0:16:24] in the Twin Falls School District,
[0:16:25] But it is trying to be modeled in other school districts
[0:16:28] across the state.
[0:16:30] And if I remember right, Stephen received a statewide
[0:16:33] recognition for that same award as well.
[0:16:35] So our congratulations to Stephen and to Dennis Poland,
[0:16:39] who oversees our school resource program
[0:16:42] and to Captain Anthony Barnhart.
[0:16:57] Well, thank you.
[0:16:58] Thank you on behalf of Officer Stephen Gassard.
[0:17:01] As Mr. Rothwater said, he's out of town this week.
[0:17:05] I just want to say a little bit about the bully bucket
[0:17:07] when he started this, it's been close to two years ago
[0:17:10] when he came up with the idea and he wanted to run with it
[0:17:12] to see if it would be successful.
[0:17:15] He was surprised at how successful it has been.
[0:17:17] He started this at Robert Stewart Jr. High.
[0:17:19] I think a lot of us are aware of that.
[0:17:21] It helped break down the barrier between himself
[0:17:24] as a police officer as well as the students and the staff.
[0:17:27] It really helped him work well with the students
[0:17:30] and they started to show a lot of trust in him
[0:17:32] because he would follow up as he promised them
[0:17:35] Each time he would look in the bucket to see what they had in there.
[0:17:39] Since that time, he has received a lot of recognition for this.
[0:17:43] Other schools in our district have taken on either similar programs or the same program.
[0:17:49] Some of the schools have kind of designed their own where they don't have an officer in them all the time.
[0:17:53] And we do have other schools outside of this district that are participating in this program or program similar to it.
[0:17:59] So it's been very successful.
[0:18:01] It's made Officer Gassert shine in the light of working in the schools as well as the City of Twin Falls and the Twin Falls Police Department and all of our school resource officers.
[0:18:11] So thank you very much.
[0:18:13] Thank you, Dennis.
[0:18:22] The next one that we have, and maybe we'll have them come up now.
[0:18:26] Captain Anthony Barnhart.
[0:18:34] So I know that if the Chief would have said that, I mean, wow.
[0:18:40] Here's John Caten when you need him most, right?
[0:18:45] So as you'll recall, one of the other activities was that data-driven solutions where we had
[0:18:51] the heat maps and the heat maps reflected those types of crimes that we could try to control
[0:18:58] or try to modify behaviors in areas and one of the things, there was the correlation
[0:19:04] between traffic activity and accidents as well as those crimes that we felt that we could
[0:19:11] have an impact on.
[0:19:13] And really that has helped drive our process and it's really an innovative approach and
[0:19:18] I know that Captain Barnhart really spearheaded that, really helped get that implemented with
[0:19:24] our patrol divisions all the way through.
[0:19:27] And it starts with leadership but it also goes to the men and women that are in the field.
[0:19:32] the concept, buying, doing something different than we've always done it, taking that new
[0:19:37] thought and that new concept and saying how can we make Twin Falls a safer place. That
[0:19:42] also was recognized by the Association about cities as an outstanding program and so tonight
[0:19:48] we get the pleasure of presenting this to Captain Barnhart, but also in recognition of
[0:19:54] all of the efforts of the men and women on the streets that are making our community safer.
[0:19:59] I was about to say, you got to talk to them.
[0:20:18] Yeah, I got to talk.
[0:20:20] Good evening, Mr. Mayor, members of the council.
[0:20:23] First of all, I'd like to thank the AIC for this award.
[0:20:26] It's really an award for the organization, the police
[0:20:29] department, and the city of Twin Falls, not myself.
[0:20:33] This really began about three years ago,
[0:20:35] when Captain Career, Lieutenant Craig Stodz, Sergeant Ryan
[0:20:39] Howe, and I attended our first Dx training.
[0:20:42] We immediately recognized that this was something
[0:20:45] that we want to bring back to our organization and implement it as an operational model,
[0:20:51] not a philosophy, and it was something that we could really get our hands on.
[0:20:56] And I'll just read a few highlights that really strike a chord with me with DEDEX.
[0:21:03] DEDEX ensures accountability and provides a dynamic, evidence-based, problem-solving approach
[0:21:08] to crime and crashes.
[0:21:10] This approach is grounded in community-oriented law enforcement and suggests that time, place,
[0:21:16] and evidence-based policing as opposed to the traditional reactionary policing is more efficient
[0:21:22] as a focus of law enforcement operations.
[0:21:26] And I think that the city manager hit it right on the head when he said that these sergeants
[0:21:30] and the officers really led the charge on this, and I would be remiss if I did not mention
[0:21:37] the fact that they all bought into this and they implemented it. We did see reductions
[0:21:43] in specific areas with crimes and crashes in specific areas in the city. So it has been
[0:21:48] successful. One person that has been a valuable member to this team is someone outside of the
[0:21:55] police department. I don't know if you guys are aware of this, but Robin Wilson, who is
[0:22:00] the GIS coordinator, was instrumental in getting D-Dax off the ground. We had to come back and
[0:22:07] we had to generate these heat maps and populate the maps with crime and had it not been for
[0:22:14] Robin Wilson's work on this, I don't know that we would have got it off the ground. So I
[0:22:20] would specifically like to thank Robin who's in the audience tonight.
[0:22:24] Robin, could you raise your hand so everyone can see who you are? We're going to zoom the
[0:22:33] camera in on you as well. Thank you. That's all I have Mr. Mayor. Thank you. I appreciate
[0:22:41] If you have a question, I'm really proud of the men and women of the Twin Falls Police
[0:22:51] Department.
[0:22:52] It's nice, as we continue to try to push decision-making down to the slowest level, it's nice to see
[0:22:57] that it works and that your department takes that challenge and is working hard to make
[0:23:03] sure the communities are safe place to live.
[0:23:05] I agree.
[0:23:06] Thank you, Chief.
[0:23:07] Appreciate it.
[0:23:09] Just to let everyone know, we have five public hearings
[0:23:13] this evening and they do not start before six o'clock,
[0:23:17] nor will they tonight, obviously.
[0:23:19] We have a couple more things on our agenda
[0:23:21] under the items for consideration,
[0:23:23] then we'll move rapidly into the public hearings this evening.
[0:23:28] Next item on the agenda is adoption of the tentative budget
[0:23:32] for the city of Twin Falls and set August 18th, 2014
[0:23:37] at 6 p.m. as the date and time for the public budget hearing.
[0:23:42] We show Travis Rothweiler as the presenter,
[0:23:46] but I see our CFO, Lori Race, welcome Lori.
[0:23:50] Thank you, just one second.
[0:23:54] Ms. Sanchez, can I just share with you
[0:23:59] that do you remember last week
[0:24:00] we had a little issue with the PowerPoint?
[0:24:03] Do you know it works so much better when it's plugged in?
[0:24:07] I will never make that mistake again.
[0:24:14] Please tell me you didn't go to New York for city manager training on that, did you?
[0:24:21] Good evening.
[0:24:23] Tonight I really just want to give you a very brief summary of the fiscal year 2015 city
[0:24:29] managers recommended budget and then just really turn it over to you folks for any
[0:24:34] questions or discussions that you'd like to have regarding where we are at this
[0:24:38] point in the process.
[0:24:52] So as Travis has stated on numerous occasions this budget was developed for
[0:25:20] many conversations including conversations with our citizens. You heard
[0:25:25] from the city's long-term planning committee at the end of March when they
[0:25:28] presented a five-year plan and the major focus is on fiscal year 2015. In mid-April
[0:25:36] you shared your priorities and strategies to be incorporated into the budget development,
[0:25:41] and citizens were invited to participate.
[0:25:44] In early June, Travis shared a rough draft of the budget,
[0:25:48] and about a month later, in early July, you received the recommended budget,
[0:25:53] and we've been reviewing and refining that weekly since.
[0:25:57] And we are not done yet.
[0:26:01] Tonight, if all goes as planned,
[0:26:04] You will be adopting the fiscal year 2015 City Manager recommended budget or our preliminary
[0:26:11] budget and setting a public hearing date and setting a maximum spending limit.
[0:26:18] You can still make adjustments, you just can't increase past the cap.
[0:26:23] Next week there will be more opportunity to review and discuss and finally on August 18th
[0:26:29] we'll hold the public hearing to formally adopt the fiscal year 2015 budget.
[0:26:37] One thing that we've shared every week
[0:26:39] since you received the recommended budget is this slide.
[0:26:43] It shares with our citizens how much more
[0:26:46] it will cost them to live in the city of Twin Falls next year.
[0:26:50] Property taxes on the medium home
[0:26:52] valued at $144,300 would increase $5.08
[0:26:57] over this year.
[0:26:59] Water bills based on an annual average consumption
[0:27:02] of 18,000 gallons per month would increase $9.
[0:27:06] Sewer bills based on a maximum cap of 8,000 gallons per month
[0:27:11] would increase $3, and sanitation bills
[0:27:14] would increase $2.28.
[0:27:18] Now these are annual figures, and they equate to less than $1.62
[0:27:22] per month.
[0:27:26] The latest taxable valuation we receive from the county
[0:27:30] for property located in the city of Twin Falls
[0:27:32] is $2,228 million.
[0:27:37] that this is down $4 million from the last number we gave you,
[0:27:41] but it's up almost $28 million from last year.
[0:27:45] Our total tax collections are not at the maximum allowed by law,
[0:27:51] but rather include only the growth formula and 0.76%
[0:27:56] increase on last year's collections,
[0:27:58] not the statutory 3% increase that we can take.
[0:28:02] At this time, we are projecting the tax rate
[0:28:05] increase from $7.85 per thousand dollars of assessed value to $7.93.
[0:28:16] This slide is simply a quick comparison and it shows how the City of Twin Falls compares
[0:28:21] to other cities of similar size providing similar services. Twin Falls continues to have lower
[0:28:27] property taxes as illustrated by that red bar. Our total net budget is $57 million including
[0:28:39] all the funds, tax supported and enterprise.
[0:28:43] If you adopt this preliminary budget as is,
[0:28:47] that will be the spending cap.
[0:28:54] This budget calls for a 2% rate increase for our water users,
[0:28:59] a 1% rate increase for the sewer fund,
[0:29:02] and a 1.11% increase for sanitation.
[0:29:09] And because we feel it's important for our citizens
[0:29:12] to understand how this will impact them financially
[0:29:15] next year, we share this slide again comparing the increases in property taxes and utility
[0:29:21] bills for 2015. And with that, we turn it over to you for any questions, concerns, or discussions
[0:29:29] you'd like to have.
[0:29:30] Thank you, Lori. I'm going to turn it over to Council, but I would ask Council maybe we
[0:29:36] should hold off before we make any motions to allow the public to speak again and get their
[0:29:42] input because when it comes to the budget we've opened it up to the community every time.
[0:29:47] And I think that's only fair. In fact, maybe we'll just go straight to the public and then
[0:29:52] we'll have some questions for you Laurie. So at this time if you have any questions or
[0:29:57] any comments that you'd like to make, why don't you come forward regarding the budget.
[0:30:02] I'll just give you another couple seconds in case you're thinking about it. This is your
[0:30:12] opportunity to engage your counsel regarding the budget. So we certainly don't
[0:30:16] want to hold you back from that. I see no one running for the microphone. So we'll
[0:30:23] turn it back over to Travis and or questions from our council. Chris
[0:30:26] talking to Laurie a little clarification here at Travis the home
[0:30:33] residential tax going up about five dollars eight cents a month 12 72 a year
[0:30:39] I've got 0.76 percent it's it's five dollars and eight cents a year a year
[0:30:45] Yes, okay. My question is still embedded in that is that net of the homeowners exemption or how will that play on that?
[0:30:53] So the average home does not qualify for the homeowners exemption under the Idaho code
[0:30:59] at the total maximum
[0:31:01] So as you recall the total maximum this year is growing from 81,000 to 83
[0:31:06] or 50% and owner-occupied homes can take whatever is less, and so this home would maintain the same homeowners exemption that they had in prior years.
[0:31:21] For those houses that are actually seeing an increased benefit as a result of the homeowners exemption,
[0:31:27] depending upon what happened to their own personal taxable value situations,
[0:31:32] They could actually pay less in property taxes next year than what they're paying this year
[0:31:37] Kind of whether I was getting out, but what is the kick in or the kick out level for homeowners?
[0:31:41] I'm 167 thousand dollars this year. Thank you
[0:31:46] Do we have any other questions or comments from our council? Travis do you want? I
[0:31:54] Think mr. Burger might have been looking for
[0:31:57] No, okay, mr. Ed. So it just
[0:32:01] Do you have a light there?
[0:32:04] There's a point that I want to make, a couple of points that I want to make as we move forward, one of the things we want to do is really illustrate the number of times that we've had this conversation.
[0:32:19] And every single time we've opened up our microphone to the citizens to share their thoughts and their sentiments about this budget, it has been placed online, and I really do appreciate the public comment.
[0:32:30] It does not appear that there might have been anything this evening, but we do know that we've had visitors
[0:32:36] have the desire to approach the mic, but we also know that we've been approached in more private settings and engaged in those conversations.
[0:32:44] So we really do appreciate the citizens in that and moving forward.
[0:32:50] The second is that taxable value or that tax rate that we're illustrating right now is really our best guess.
[0:32:58] And it's our best guess, because there is one piece of information that remains very uncertain right now.
[0:33:05] And that is what is that final total taxable value of the city going to be in December when we get notification of what the tax rate is.
[0:33:16] And what's interesting about our process is we illustrated last week that sub-roll category,
[0:33:22] those additional values that can be placed on that tax total taxable value have had a
[0:33:29] range of $35 million. And so in that $35 million swing, it is highly likely that if we follow
[0:33:39] those trends, that tax rate would be significantly lower than what we're illustrating here, if
[0:33:46] not comparable to what we're issuing this year. But we want to share with the citizens based
[0:33:52] upon our best information today so that they have a full appreciation and understanding
[0:33:57] of what's in the budget.
[0:34:02] We also want to say, like Gloria said, that we're not done, just because you're setting
[0:34:06] that maximum cap tonight does not end our conversation.
[0:34:11] It really gets to a place where we say this is the most that we can spend in this upcoming
[0:34:18] fiscal year at this point in time.
[0:34:22] you can always reduce spending from any point forward.
[0:34:30] And we will hold another conversation next week
[0:34:34] on the 11th with the opportunity
[0:34:37] to host a public hearing and ultimate final adoption
[0:34:40] on August 18th is the current schedule.
[0:34:45] Thank you Travis, great lighting.
[0:34:47] Travis, I want to congratulate you on,
[0:34:49] as usual, on a very frugal budget.
[0:34:52] get the maximum value out of it. I did a I've been in contact with several members
[0:34:58] of the AIC through the search for a new executive director and I just asked the
[0:35:04] question is anybody what is everybody taking and the same was the answer was by
[0:35:09] everybody was 3% because that's just what they do. They always take 3% every other
[0:35:15] city does on that list. I was in contact with almost every one of them during that
[0:35:20] that time span. I didn't talk to Pocatello, but I did miss them, plus the new growth plus
[0:35:26] the new growth. We take the new growth in this particular year, 0.76. Thank you for your efforts,
[0:35:33] and I'm ready to make a motion with less of the questions. Are there any other questions
[0:35:37] before we have a motion on the floor? Council. You're on, Greg. I would like to set the maximum
[0:35:44] Malala loans cap at $57,082,189 and set the public hearing at August 18th at 6 p.m.
[0:35:55] Did I get those right before we vote on them?
[0:36:00] Yeah, before we get a second, that was the amount.
[0:36:03] $57,082,189.
[0:36:08] Okay, that's what I said.
[0:36:09] Excellent, we have a motion on the floor by Greg Lanting.
[0:36:13] Seconded by Suzanne Hawkins to do so.
[0:36:18] Any comments, questions from Council Rebecca Milsoyka.
[0:36:22] Thank you, Mayor.
[0:36:23] Thank you, Travis.
[0:36:25] I agree with Councilman Lanning.
[0:36:26] I think this is a great starting point for the budget.
[0:36:28] And I appreciate your sensitivity to rate increases,
[0:36:33] which you've asked you to do.
[0:36:34] And really, in general, very pleased with where
[0:36:37] the budget is right now.
[0:36:39] I do see an opportunity to maybe examine an area where we can perhaps reduce our spending.
[0:36:47] And just the line item that stood out to me within this budget is the increases that we have in our travel and meetings.
[0:36:55] In the different departments, I'll just give you a few examples.
[0:37:01] Parks is up, 50%.
[0:37:04] The Police Department Administration is up 40%, HR is up 100%, P&Z up 40%, finance is up 72%.
[0:37:13] This is just traveling meetings, it's not.
[0:37:17] Personnel training is a separate line item.
[0:37:20] And I certainly support traveling to regional conferences.
[0:37:26] I think state conferences are a really good place for our staff to be, to make contacts,
[0:37:32] and to kind of get ideas from other communities, other cities.
[0:37:38] But I just want to throw this out.
[0:37:41] As a starting point, maybe a conversation if the council is interested.
[0:37:45] I think City Council, actually, we could maybe set a better example.
[0:37:50] Our personal budget is up 169%.
[0:37:54] It was about $4,400 in last year's budget.
[0:37:58] This year it's set to be $12,000.
[0:38:01] And we had a good discussion about maybe a per council member budget for training being at about $1,500 each,
[0:38:10] which I think is plenty, I think it's a good amount, and that would equate to if my math is right,
[0:38:16] 10,500 instead of the 12,000 in that line item.
[0:38:25] But I certainly am open to discussion, maybe we can talk about,
[0:38:30] I just want to make sure that those increases are justified, that we're taking the opportunity
[0:38:36] to attend the closest trainings that we can.
[0:38:40] And I remember one travel request that came across our desk in the recent weeks and one
[0:38:45] trip totaled $3,000.
[0:38:48] And that was in the economic development budget.
[0:38:52] That's a lot of money.
[0:38:53] And as we're asking our citizens to pay for it, we need to make sure that we're spending
[0:38:59] it on things that they can see a benefit from and that they can approve of.
[0:39:07] So I just like to throw that out to the council maybe to keep our eye on traveling meetings
[0:39:12] maybe for us to set a good example.
[0:39:16] But by and large, this is a very conservative budget and I commend staff and city manager
[0:39:23] for really doing a great job and giving us a great starting point for our discussions with the public.
[0:39:30] I see a couple of lights on here, but again what we're doing with this motion is setting the cap.
[0:39:37] We can do some more refinement.
[0:39:41] So the discussion is a valid discussion.
[0:39:44] Rebecca, thanks for bringing that to our attention.
[0:39:46] And I'm throwing it out for next week.
[0:39:48] Yes, exactly. So we have some time.
[0:39:50] I don't know if we want to address these things tonight.
[0:39:53] And there's certainly a couple that I could, but it gives us a little bit of time.
[0:39:58] But I also see some lights on here, Travis, so I'm going to go ahead and go to the council.
[0:40:02] And we'll go from there.
[0:40:04] Jim Ma.
[0:40:04] Thank you, Mayor.
[0:40:07] Travis, I remember that back in 2007, 2008, when we saw the economic decline that
[0:40:12] traveling training became virtually non-existence back.
[0:40:15] We made an executive decision of the senior staff level to really, really cut back.
[0:40:21] And so now we do see increases in our travel and training budget, where we are providing the opportunity to get our people well trained and provide services.
[0:40:29] Maybe next week could you bring us some historical documentation about what happened and where we're trying to get back to?
[0:40:38] Because I think that might help alleviate some of the difficulties some members of the Council of the community might have in that regard.
[0:40:45] Is it what we've been through to get back to where we are now?
[0:40:49] We can do that.
[0:40:50] I think, Jeff, thank you, Jim, Chris, stop here.
[0:40:52] Yeah, I want to concur with Jim's idea and Rebecca's.
[0:40:55] I think we should move ahead and vote on the motion before us.
[0:40:59] But I'm very much like the city manager to present a 2014,
[0:41:06] 2015 versus 2014 travel in the various departments.
[0:41:10] And see if there's not some economies we can get by having
[0:41:14] the web seminar or attendance.
[0:41:17] I'm not very much in favor of spending $3,000 to fly a person to have them sit in the audience
[0:41:23] and listen to people.
[0:41:24] And I think a lot of training can now be done electronically.
[0:41:28] And I wonder if we're really on the cutting edge of that.
[0:41:31] So perhaps you can kind of elaborate on that.
[0:41:34] And if we have been depressing our training because of the downturn, some of us certainly
[0:41:39] has warranted to catch up.
[0:41:41] But I think Rebecca has raised an extremely valid issue to the taxpayer to see gigantic
[0:41:47] increases in one year, we have to answer some of those questions for them.
[0:41:51] Ms. Jan Hawke.
[0:41:55] Not to be the dead horse, but while you're gathering information, maybe we can look at
[0:41:59] what's actually been spent on travel versus what we're budgeting for now, because as I
[0:42:05] read through previous history, it looked to me like we're trying to be more accurate and
[0:42:09] upfront at this end of it instead of catching up later in the year.
[0:42:14] So I would like the public to be able to see that as well if that's okay.
[0:42:18] That information is included in the budget.
[0:42:22] So there's a couple of different spots.
[0:42:24] If you've looked, if you merely reflect on the budget,
[0:42:27] you're going to talk a look that is in, let's say, page,
[0:42:35] starts on page 48 of the budget.
[0:42:39] If you're focusing on page 48 in this white section,
[0:42:43] it's not going to really tell you the true picture as opposed
[0:42:45] to looking at pages 197 and backwards.
[0:42:49] In fact, I will tell you that this is probably much better
[0:42:54] because it reflects on what the actual expenditure levels had been.
[0:42:59] One of the areas that was, and I'm just throwing it out
[0:43:02] because it's at the top and it's easiest to find
[0:43:05] and that's the Council's.
[0:43:07] The Council's proposed training budget this year is for $12,000.
[0:43:13] Last year, your proposed budget was $4,600.
[0:43:18] this travel in meetings and training, and we break it up.
[0:43:22] And Laurie and I have had this conversation that to me,
[0:43:24] it doesn't make a lot of sense to break it up for travel
[0:43:26] in meetings and training, because really,
[0:43:28] if you can't get there, you can't get there.
[0:43:31] But if you look at the history, if you look at the actuals
[0:43:34] expended in these categories, in 2011, it was 8,120.
[0:43:39] In 2012, it was $12,443.
[0:43:43] And 2013, it was $11,729.
[0:43:47] And so part of that where you see those increases
[0:43:51] is to more accurately reflect the expenditures
[0:43:54] that are truly being made.
[0:43:57] Certainly there's a part of that
[0:43:58] that we're looking at enhancing that training
[0:44:02] in certain categories.
[0:44:03] And we will definitely be in a position to talk about that
[0:44:06] and make those justifications to the city council next week.
[0:44:11] But I think that's exactly the example
[0:44:13] that we're talking about, maybe bring that
[0:44:15] in some sort of a slideshow that we can see
[0:44:18] how the actuals versus what we've been budgeting
[0:44:22] because you and I had a long conversation
[0:44:23] regarding the city council and why it was up
[0:44:26] and it made perfect sense to me.
[0:44:28] Our councils be more active in the AIC
[0:44:32] and other things like that.
[0:44:33] Sometimes we're not as active, so it's a balancing act.
[0:44:36] So I think that would be real good information for us to see
[0:44:39] and see where we've been going for training
[0:44:42] what's needed for our staff and our council.
[0:44:47] Anything further on the motion council?
[0:44:50] Leanna Rokomol, please.
[0:44:52] Greg Lassen.
[0:44:53] Yes.
[0:44:54] Don Hall.
[0:44:55] Yes.
[0:44:56] Chris Tocquenten.
[0:44:56] Yes.
[0:44:57] Rebecca Feldsweig, that?
[0:44:58] Yes.
[0:44:59] Suzanne Hawkins.
[0:45:01] Yes.
[0:45:02] Sean Berrever.
[0:45:03] Yes.
[0:45:04] Jim Mudd.
[0:45:04] Yes.
[0:45:05] Motion passes.
[0:45:06] Seven to zero.
[0:45:08] Next item on the agenda is public input and or items
[0:45:11] for city manager and city council.
[0:45:13] I'll start with the public again, and we always open it up to the public for anything that's not on the agenda
[0:45:18] If you'd like to come forward and address the council now is your chance
[0:45:22] Didn't have a lot of takers last time it'd be nice to see one person come up
[0:45:26] It's not gonna happen. So we're moving on to our city manager anything further
[0:45:33] Travis
[0:45:35] Turn it over city council one thing a couple things that I wanted to mention
[0:45:39] I had the opportunity and privilege to be able to go and do the boss lift
[0:45:43] that's the National Guard and reservists event that they put on annually I believe
[0:45:50] where folks from communities can go and see exactly what the life of a National
[0:45:55] Guard soldier or a Marine or Navy or Air Force Reserve does and and it was
[0:46:03] very enlightening I'm from the military so it was not unfamiliar to me but I
[0:46:09] think what struck me more than anything is that our National Guard, and they said this
[0:46:15] several times are not, it's not the National Guard of our grandfathers or our fathers where
[0:46:20] it was two weeks in the summer and a weekend a month. It is far more than that. In fact,
[0:46:26] when they go and train now, it's very often that they go for three weeks at a time. And
[0:46:32] this is just an event for businesses to be able to see exactly what's expected of our
[0:46:38] guardsmen and reservists. And for us to be maybe a little more understanding and
[0:46:44] patient with them because there is a huge obligation on their side and that
[0:46:49] made me very, very proud. Number two, I had the opportunity I think several
[0:46:53] council members went as well to go over to the Orpheum Theatre this weekend. They
[0:46:59] had kind of an open house and it's under new ownership. They have some great plans
[0:47:04] for that theater and it's really, really exciting. I think probably the coolest thing was to be able
[0:47:10] to walk backstage and see these big scenes backdrops that were painted in the 20s and 50s still hanging
[0:47:20] up there and the history of that building and actually being able to go up into the balcony and see it
[0:47:26] because it's been blocked off for years and years and their plans. It's really an exciting thing for
[0:47:32] community and a very admirable thing on the part of the Johnson's to take that
[0:47:38] step took a lot of courage for them to do it so I would hope that as this does
[0:47:42] open up to our community steps forward and supports them in this endeavor because
[0:47:46] what a great historic building that that is. I'll move on to Council Suzanne
[0:47:52] Hoffman's. Two quick things first of all I want to remind everybody that
[0:47:56] tomorrow night is National Night Out at City Park from five to eight it's a
[0:47:59] chance to come meet your local police officers, not only from the city, but there will be county
[0:48:04] and other representatives there.
[0:48:06] And I know last year my grandchildren had a wonderful time and they're all looking forward
[0:48:10] to doing it again tomorrow night, so come out and meet our fine officers.
[0:48:14] And secondly, it's hard to believe, but this Thursday night is already the last regular
[0:48:19] city band concert at City Park and Co-MC this week.
[0:48:24] I believe it's our esteemed Travis Rothweiler and his two boys.
[0:48:27] It's gonna be a great night and your last chance to come out and enjoy a wonderful evening. So we remember to be there
[0:48:33] Thank You Suzanne Christoff needed. I'm not gonna embarrass you. What do you want to say? I went I went over sell the co-nc thing at all
[0:48:42] I'm with a five and seven year old and you never know what comes out of the mouth of babes, right?
[0:48:47] Most of us up here of co-nc your kids will be way better than us
[0:48:51] But every quanine will be there at the picnic paying close attention to you.
[0:48:57] And judging and evaluating, Chris.
[0:49:00] My wife just came back from California.
[0:49:03] She reminded me of a desert.
[0:49:05] California is having extreme wildfire and drought conditions,
[0:49:10] a place where she was on the coast.
[0:49:12] Depends on their water from a well, potable well water only.
[0:49:18] They have an absolute ban on any water usage of anything outside a home and they have water
[0:49:25] police gigging, finding people if you, so much as water or a house plant.
[0:49:30] They have closed car washes.
[0:49:36] They have rainwater trucks that go around and actually sell you canisters of water for
[0:49:40] your outside plants, but in one year since they've been doing this, they have reduced
[0:49:45] water consumption by 44%.
[0:49:47] They are not out of the woods, they don't know what's going to happen next because the
[0:49:52] water table level is only three feet above the ambient ocean level.
[0:49:57] They're in a lot of problem.
[0:49:58] The fact is we think we have a lot of water, we live in the desert.
[0:50:03] I think that this is a message to me that the city should inexorably be pressing toward
[0:50:08] more zero escaping in its landscaping requirements.
[0:50:12] We're spending way too much of our invaluable water, potable water unnecessarily.
[0:50:19] And I say that with a third of acre of ground at my home and I feel terribly guilty.
[0:50:24] But I'm not ready to start watering with the rainwater yet since I can't collect enough drops of rainwater around here in a year to water a plant.
[0:50:32] Nonetheless, 44% is a considerable decrease in consumption.
[0:50:36] Thank you, President Brabek, Ms. Seike.
[0:50:39] Thank you, Mayor, just two questions for me, one for my fellow council members.
[0:50:45] I received an invitation from the chamber to go through their chamber leadership training.
[0:50:49] So speaking of training, I was just wanted to ask council, I know we don't have a formal process, but
[0:50:55] I thought that that would be a good opportunity.
[0:50:57] I believe the cost is around $750, and so anyway I just wondered if there were any objections.
[0:51:06] wondering if I might sign up for that training. Second question to staff is Addison Avenue East,
[0:51:14] and I realize this is the state's road. There's been a lane closure across from Smith and the
[0:51:21] eastbound lane. It's been closed for several weeks, and I haven't seen work or movement on
[0:51:29] that area since Friday, last Friday, and even as I drove by today a couple of different times,
[0:51:34] Nothing but the lane is still closed and it's kind of hampering traffic on Addison and so
[0:51:40] I was wondering, you know, how long can lanes be closed?
[0:51:42] Is there a permitting process for that and maybe what's going on there?
[0:51:46] Jackie Fields, our city engineer is with us.
[0:51:51] Hiding behind Mitch, it looked like to me.
[0:51:55] Welcome, Jackie.
[0:51:56] Still can't.
[0:51:59] So I believe that the location that you're talking about is at a brand new driveway that's
[0:52:06] has been reconstructed at where Zulu's bagels used to be in the glass shop.
[0:52:11] And once the concrete was poured, there's a gap there for plant mix,
[0:52:18] and we don't want to remove the traffic control because if somebody gets in that,
[0:52:24] they'll have trouble getting out. So if a person pulls a permit,
[0:52:30] and for something like that, they are usually allowed to keep it in place
[0:52:35] place until they can reasonably get the plant the black top to put back in there.
[0:52:41] It's a small job. But it is closing one of the two eastbound lanes so it's not
[0:52:47] just closing off that entrance so it's it's recommended that one of the lanes
[0:52:51] be closed as well. The gap is where your wheel would go. Okay or it could go or
[0:52:57] might go. Okay. Might is too close for moving the traffic control. Okay so that
[0:53:04] That should be in place for how much longer.
[0:53:06] Let's see.
[0:53:07] I don't have an answer for you.
[0:53:09] Okay.
[0:53:10] So typically we'd wait for the concrete to cure past test and then the contractor has to arrange
[0:53:15] to place the laptop.
[0:53:18] But I will follow up and let you guys know what the plan is.
[0:53:23] Thank you.
[0:53:24] Jack, could you stay before we go to your first question Rebecca?
[0:53:27] I had a question about the roads.
[0:53:29] Could you remind us what the responsibility of the property owner is when it comes to
[0:53:34] weeds and the like out into the roadway.
[0:53:37] The reason I asked this is that we were driving down
[0:53:40] with Drona Street towards the Canyon,
[0:53:43] and as it curves around by Home Depot,
[0:53:48] it looks like a weed patch in the middle of the road.
[0:53:52] And I was just wondering, is it that property owners
[0:53:55] responsibility or is that a city issue?
[0:53:59] I believe that the way the code reads
[0:54:01] is that the property owner gets to deal with the weeds
[0:54:05] to the center line of the road.
[0:54:07] So if we could get with, I think it's,
[0:54:12] we can't.
[0:54:13] Perfect.
[0:54:14] Maybe have them take a look at that.
[0:54:16] Is there a starting to get kind of tall actually out there?
[0:54:19] Well, you need to drive on the center line there.
[0:54:21] Come along.
[0:54:22] It's more, yeah.
[0:54:23] That's not a major or a true.
[0:54:24] Although, gas is kind of expensive though.
[0:54:27] Correcting the doable phone.
[0:54:28] Very good.
[0:54:29] Thank you, Jackie.
[0:54:30] Now back to Rebecca's first question regarding
[0:54:32] going to the chamber training, the leadership training.
[0:54:37] I think that we received some positive aspects
[0:54:45] from the council regarding maybe this $1,500 a year.
[0:54:49] And that sounds like it would be more than appropriate training
[0:54:54] for a council member as far as I'm concerned.
[0:54:56] Maybe the rest of the council could weigh in.
[0:55:01] Thank you.
[0:55:02] No one's weighing in, so it sounds like it's okay.
[0:55:04] Back up.
[0:55:05] Greg Lanning.
[0:55:06] If Sean's on the same issue, or is Sean Berger?
[0:55:10] I actually will weigh in, but not specifically to this issue.
[0:55:13] I mean, certainly I'm happy to have people go
[0:55:15] to the Chambers Leadership Program.
[0:55:17] But I do think that we have a relatively hefty budget
[0:55:24] for training for council members.
[0:55:29] I don't spend $1,500 a year in my real job on training for me.
[0:55:33] So I think, in general, we should be resistant to paying for personal and professional development
[0:55:44] for council members that may or may not necessarily benefit the city as a whole.
[0:55:49] If it's just personal and professional development, I think we should be paying for that out of
[0:55:52] our own pockets.
[0:55:54] I think it's a very large piece of our budget and it just doesn't feel right.
[0:56:06] I don't beyond going to the AIC trainings a few times.
[0:56:11] I don't know that I've ever even contemplated asking for funding
[0:56:16] from the city for some kind of training or travel I may be doing.
[0:56:19] So again, I'm not speaking specifically to this issue,
[0:56:23] but I think just having that large training budget for seven of us
[0:56:29] seems pretty robust.
[0:56:32] Thanks, Sean.
[0:56:32] Great learning.
[0:56:34] I would like to recommend that it kind of came up a few times when I was mayor that it
[0:56:38] seems like every time that we try to go later on a meeting, we end up making the
[0:56:43] public hearing people wait forever. It's like we went to, we went sort of 530 today
[0:56:49] and instead of five and here we're at a quarter to seven and we haven't got to the
[0:56:52] public hearing yet so I think we maybe want to rethink those and just rather have
[0:56:57] a gap in between rather than make people wait. I have actually agree with you on
[0:57:03] on that. I was really surprised that some of the agenda items took so long this evening.
[0:57:07] That certainly wasn't mapped out, but as I, people ask me all the time how long our council
[0:57:12] meetings are going to be, and I give them the shrug, because you can't, we just can't predict it.
[0:57:18] So I think that's, I think that's a good idea.
[0:57:20] Does that happen?
[0:57:21] Thank you. I haven't taken the chamber leadership class, but I am the liaison to the chamber
[0:57:27] and go to their board meetings, and I attend, I would guess, 90% of the ribbon cuttings,
[0:57:32] active with the chamber and keeping not only from the city's position but as a
[0:57:38] business owner I'm my business as a member of the chamber of commerce also and I
[0:57:42] don't I'm having a hard time understanding what training they offer that
[0:57:46] is applicable to a city council person in that role. I was just wondering if we
[0:57:50] could get clarification. I'm not sure that I have the answer but the way it was
[0:57:58] put to me from some of the people from the chamber is that it gives you a lot of
[0:58:03] insight knowledge on a lot of the businesses that we serve as council members, it gives
[0:58:09] us an insight to our own economy and to the ways in which we can better serve our businesses.
[0:58:17] I don't see how it could not be applicable.
[0:58:20] But once again, that's why I wanted to come and ask the council for their input.
[0:58:26] I don't think it would be, if I weren't on the council, I certainly wouldn't take it because
[0:58:32] that it wouldn't apply to my otherwise everyday life.
[0:58:35] And so I believe that the Chamber of Leadership,
[0:58:39] like Dawn said, I think it's really applicable
[0:58:42] to the way we understand our own economy,
[0:58:45] we understand the needs of our businesses,
[0:58:47] the way we understand how our community works.
[0:58:52] Okay, anything further, Council?
[0:58:55] We will now move into the public hearing portion
[0:58:59] of tonight's meeting.
[0:59:01] Just to let council know that we have five,
[0:59:04] I know that you've read through the agenda,
[0:59:05] but we have five different items.
[0:59:08] Item number one, four and five.
[0:59:13] If we choose to go down that road,
[0:59:16] we'll need to have an ordinance put together
[0:59:18] and brought back to us.
[0:59:19] Item number two has a resolution already in our packet.
[0:59:22] So if we choose to agree with that
[0:59:24] or move forward with that, it's available.
[0:59:28] and item number three has an ordinance attached as well.
[0:59:32] If we choose to dispense the rules
[0:59:36] and go third and final, we can go with that.
[0:59:38] So I just throw that out.
[0:59:40] There's always public input during public hearings.
[0:59:43] So when I open that up,
[0:59:45] if someone in the audience would like to come forward,
[0:59:48] actually if you would sign up in the back
[0:59:49] so we can bring you up here orderly,
[0:59:52] just mark which item it is and your name and address.
[0:59:56] And we will call you up here for that.
[0:59:58] So the first item under the public hearing is request
[1:00:01] for annexation of 53.6 acres located on the east side
[1:00:06] of the 500, 600, 700 blocks of Hankins Road North,
[1:00:12] also known as 3,200 East Road.
[1:00:17] And the applicant is the Twin Falls School District,
[1:00:21] and I believe we have Brad Wills as the spokesperson.
[1:00:25] And so welcome, we will give you 15 minutes, Brad,
[1:00:29] to make your presentation.
[1:00:32] I had a six o'clock reservation.
[1:00:35] Mm-hmm.
[1:00:37] Reservation?
[1:00:38] Good night today.
[1:00:41] So my name is Brad Wills, and I am
[1:00:44] 2-2-2-2-2-Showns Street last.
[1:00:45] OK.
[1:00:46] So I'm representing the Twin Falls School District,
[1:00:50] and this is one of four different projects
[1:00:53] that we're bringing your way.
[1:00:54] And this is the location for one of the two new middle schools
[1:00:59] that we're going to be building.
[1:01:02] The two new middle schools?
[1:01:04] I see how I did that one.
[1:01:06] P and Z two, the two elementary schools.
[1:01:09] And we are building a middle school south of town.
[1:01:12] So this is on the east side.
[1:01:15] This is on Hankins Road.
[1:01:18] Falls is the boundary at the very top of the screen.
[1:01:22] This is property the council has seen in the past.
[1:01:26] I don't know who was on the council at that point,
[1:01:28] but this was land that we did a convenience plan
[1:01:33] to lot subdivision in the very bottom is the lot two
[1:01:38] of the subdivision, which was where the irrigation pump station,
[1:01:42] the regional one for that area for pressurized irrigation
[1:01:46] was put in.
[1:01:47] Originally we had the thought that those were large structures
[1:01:51] with big pawns and since we, 10 years ago,
[1:01:56] we've gone to a smaller one.
[1:01:58] So, you know, that's extra land that will probably come back
[1:02:01] and talk to you about possibly including that in a park
[1:02:05] later, making a park bigger.
[1:02:07] But for tonight, what we're doing is asking to annex
[1:02:10] both our lot one that's owned by the Twin Falls
[1:02:12] School District and a lot two which is owned by the city
[1:02:15] of Twin Falls to annex them into the city with the idea
[1:02:20] the idea that we're going to go further with entitlements,
[1:02:26] but it'd be easier for us to put this within the city limits
[1:02:30] to have only the city to deal with and not have the county deal
[1:02:34] with it.
[1:02:35] So Jonathan will go through the staff report,
[1:02:38] but it's really simple.
[1:02:39] It's 52 acres plus the two acres that the city owns.
[1:02:46] So it's kind of exciting to see this much activity
[1:02:49] in twin for schools, you know, $74 million is a lot of money.
[1:02:53] We have this site, we have a Northwest site, we have a South Middle School, and then we are
[1:02:58] going to also take the soccer field area that the school district owns, that the city leases
[1:03:08] from there and also bring that before the P&Z and council for some work there.
[1:03:13] So this is my first visit to the council and for the city
[1:03:17] and for the school district.
[1:03:20] And so if you have any questions, just let me know.
[1:03:22] Thank you, Brad.
[1:03:24] We'll turn it over to Jonathan Spendlop for our staff report
[1:03:28] regarding this agenda item.
[1:03:31] Thank you, Mr. Mayor, members of the council.
[1:03:33] History is the, since the properties in the area of impact,
[1:03:36] current zoning designation would have been in place
[1:03:38] when you read it, the area of impact boundary group
[1:03:41] the county. And currently it's zoned R1VAR which requires city
[1:03:46] steward water. That's basically the difference between that and R2 and the SUI.
[1:03:49] The analysis is 53 plus or minus acres. The entirety of the property is zoned R1.
[1:03:56] The majority of it is being utilized as an agricultural farm. The small portion
[1:04:00] that the city's portion does have an irrigation pump station. The property
[1:04:06] proposed for annexation is contiguous to city limits on the west boundary along
[1:04:10] and thus is able to request annexation.
[1:04:13] There is a single family residence fronting hankins in the middle of lot one,
[1:04:17] which is not being proposed for annexation.
[1:04:19] That would be located right there on the map.
[1:04:24] Twin Falls City Code, sections 1011 and 1015 2 require public hearings
[1:04:31] and recommendation from the commission on planning and zoning designations for areas proposed to be annexed.
[1:04:36] After the commission hearing, which they proposed for annexation,
[1:04:40] and recommended it with the zoning district of R1, VAR,
[1:04:43] to keep it the same.
[1:04:45] The city council shall hold an additional public hearing,
[1:04:48] which we're doing tonight,
[1:04:49] to determine whether the designated areas should be annexed,
[1:04:52] and if so, what the zoning designation shall be.
[1:04:55] If approved and ordinance is prepared
[1:04:57] and presented at a later public meeting,
[1:05:00] which would then be adopted by the council,
[1:05:02] once the ordinance is published,
[1:05:03] it is sent to the state,
[1:05:05] and the official zoning map is amended.
[1:05:07] At that point, that's going to be final.
[1:05:10] Since the school district acquired the property in 1990,
[1:05:12] the property's intended use was for potential expansion
[1:05:15] of the school district's facilities,
[1:05:17] including but not limited to a potential new school site.
[1:05:21] It is appropriate for the city to annex property owned
[1:05:23] and maintained by the city in order
[1:05:25] to gain governmental jurisdiction over our own property.
[1:05:28] Staff recommends the entire 53 acres,
[1:05:32] maintain the current zoning designation of R1-VAR.
[1:05:36] And along with that, the city did sign the application
[1:05:39] for this, the co-signed by Mitch Humble Ford City's property
[1:05:42] to run on this application.
[1:05:45] On July 8th, 2014, a public hearing was held
[1:05:48] before the Planning and Zoning Commission
[1:05:50] for a recommendation regarding the zoning of the property,
[1:05:53] current zoning VAR.
[1:05:55] There was one person who spoke at the public hearing.
[1:05:56] He stated his property border,
[1:05:58] the Southern boundary of the property proposed for annexation.
[1:06:01] His concern was whether he would be required
[1:06:03] to connect the city services if his well or septic failed.
[1:06:07] Troy Vitek responded to him that upon annexation
[1:06:11] and if the city utilities are within 150 feet of his property,
[1:06:14] he would be asked to connect to if his systems failed.
[1:06:18] At the end of that public hearing, Commissioner Higley
[1:06:20] made a motion to recommend the current zoning of R1VAR
[1:06:23] as appropriate.
[1:06:24] And Commissioner Boyd seconded the motion.
[1:06:25] All members of the planning and zoning commission
[1:06:28] that were present voted in favor of the motion.
[1:06:31] That is all.
[1:06:34] Thank you, Jonathan.
[1:06:34] Any questions for either Mr. Will's or Jonathan's been left?
[1:06:39] Rebecca, may I second?
[1:06:41] Thank you, Mayor.
[1:06:42] A couple of questions for staff.
[1:06:46] Can you show us on the map where the current water boundary is
[1:06:50] for the city?
[1:06:53] I mean, where the growth boundary, the water boundary
[1:06:56] in the comp plan.
[1:07:00] I mean, I can see it in the comp plan,
[1:07:02] but I can't tell where it falls in relation to this map here.
[1:07:06] No, I don't have it on these maps.
[1:07:09] I believe it's on Hankins is where I was going to say is right along Hankins Road.
[1:07:14] So this would be outside the water boundary?
[1:07:16] Correct.
[1:07:17] Okay, and then currently who maintains Hankins Road?
[1:07:20] Is that city maintained or county maintained?
[1:07:23] I'm looking to Jackie Fields and she says both, both to the center line is what I'm being
[1:07:32] told.
[1:07:33] Okay, and so do we work on that separately or do we kind of share the costs?
[1:07:37] Because I'm looking at Jackie now.
[1:07:40] That's the question I can't answer myself so I'm going to have to look at the engineer
[1:07:43] for that one.
[1:07:44] May I have an agreement with the highway district that makes arrangements for our border roads
[1:07:52] such as Hankins for who's going to replace the stop sign and who's going to provide the
[1:08:01] snow plowing.
[1:08:02] And then we do have more and formal agreement on whether or not we're going to stop sealing
[1:08:12] the road for 200 feet of highway district roadway and whether they're going to do that to us
[1:08:18] as well, so the maintenance is shared.
[1:08:23] Okay, so generally the city pays about half of the maintenance of Hankins currently in general.
[1:08:32] I'm not asking for an exact.
[1:08:34] Because on Hankins the jurisdiction changes 15 times and a whole bunch of it is highly district.
[1:08:43] So it kind of depends what your limits are.
[1:08:45] In some places, we play 100% because we're down next to the other side of the road.
[1:08:50] In other places, we pay nothing like North.
[1:08:55] Okay, so specifically on the subject property here.
[1:08:59] I think it's a 500, 600, 700 blocks of hankings.
[1:09:03] That little spot where somebody lives here?
[1:09:09] Yes.
[1:09:10] Okay.
[1:09:11] And that red line comes out to the middle of the road.
[1:09:13] That's the place where we share jurisdiction.
[1:09:18] the private district has, the cap of the road,
[1:09:22] we have the other half over here.
[1:09:26] We have it all up in here, we have none,
[1:09:29] and down here we have none, okay?
[1:09:35] So we were along fairly well.
[1:09:38] We would not go through here and skip the seal
[1:09:41] on the northbound lane.
[1:09:43] We're just not gonna do that.
[1:09:45] In fact, we're probably going to seal to here,
[1:09:50] because that's a nice end point,
[1:09:51] And then work with Highway District on whether or not they
[1:09:55] see a little piece of an outlier over here somewhere
[1:09:58] when they come through.
[1:09:59] OK.
[1:10:00] So how would that be affected by annexation?
[1:10:02] Would it be affected at all if this is annexed?
[1:10:05] No, not for roadway maintenance.
[1:10:08] This person here, I believe, is not being annexed.
[1:10:11] And so the situation that we have existing now
[1:10:15] will remain until the point in time
[1:10:20] at which that property annexes.
[1:10:24] Okay.
[1:10:26] Thank you.
[1:10:27] So the Highway District gets the roadway dollars for half the road there.
[1:10:33] Okay.
[1:10:34] But would we then pay a hundred percent of the maintenance dollars on Hankins if we annex
[1:10:38] it in with the highway district?
[1:10:41] They would no longer be involved.
[1:10:43] When we annex the roadway, we then assume all of the responsibilities and the proportionate
[1:10:51] share of the roadway dollars come to us.
[1:10:54] Okay.
[1:10:55] Thank you.
[1:10:57] Thank you, Jackie.
[1:10:58] So I think Jackie made the point that I was going to ask about right at the end there that if it were annexed then the city would have that responsibility but also would have the revenue that goes along with it for those roadways.
[1:11:12] And also the so if that property were annexed and were developed then the developer would be required to build out that other side of Hankins.
[1:11:25] I see a head nod from Mitch from Mitch with in the firm curb curb got her in the sidewalk and such much more familiar with that original
[1:11:34] agreement than I am
[1:11:36] It's been several years, and I don't actually have that answer, but I know that it was
[1:11:42] Identified and or address somehow that that original
[1:11:49] Thank you very good
[1:11:53] any other questions from council before I open it up to the
[1:11:56] Thank you, Mayor, this is a question for the applicant or the representative of the applicant.
[1:12:05] Could you show us what portion of this property will be the future school at what is the proposed plan?
[1:12:17] So the plan is this is stadium right here.
[1:12:21] This is the LDS Church and this is morning's son.
[1:12:24] So this is all in the developed subdivision.
[1:12:27] So, stadium will extend farther east and continue on.
[1:12:33] And this is actually where the North-South Road
[1:12:38] will intersect.
[1:12:39] And so, this is 20 acres right in here.
[1:12:44] That's north of stadium.
[1:12:45] So, we're signing this area right here.
[1:12:49] The 10 acres is where the site will be for the school.
[1:12:52] Access will come off stadium.
[1:12:55] There will be no side streets on either side of the school.
[1:12:59] Okay, so that it will be accessed through stadium, kind of on the back half of that lot there.
[1:13:07] Since we're having one entrance in, this will be in, we're going to call it an enhanced collector.
[1:13:13] We're going to have two lanes, a 14 foot island landscaped and then another 26 feet.
[1:13:19] So there'll be two lanes in, two lanes out,
[1:13:22] to meet the fire department standard
[1:13:26] of two kind of two accesses in.
[1:13:29] Okay, and about 10 acres for 10 acres, yeah.
[1:13:32] That's the plan.
[1:13:33] Thank you.
[1:13:34] Brad, I have a question, just somebody asked me
[1:13:37] about this today.
[1:13:38] Maybe go over, why are you asking to annex the whole section?
[1:13:44] Is it, why are you, yeah.
[1:13:47] instead of just the section where the school's going to be.
[1:13:51] So the water boundary is right here now.
[1:13:56] And so the long-term plan is to come back to the council
[1:14:04] to ask to extend that water boundary
[1:14:06] onto this property to enable the school to be in
[1:14:11] where we're planning to.
[1:14:14] So we decide to be easier just to deal with the whole piece
[1:14:19] and because we've got infrastructure that needs to go
[1:14:23] to the irrigation pump station,
[1:14:26] we need to loop water back into the main water line here.
[1:14:31] So we're gonna actually design this whole subdivision
[1:14:34] because we're gonna have to put lines down roadways
[1:14:37] that aren't designed at this point.
[1:14:40] Even to sewer this area,
[1:14:42] we're gonna have to, our sewer connection's gonna be right here
[1:14:45] into the larger line rather than being able to connect
[1:14:49] in this area. So it was our belief that it made more sense to annex the whole place and
[1:14:56] plan the whole place. And so you'll see that in a later time. But right now, to make the
[1:15:02] city, the soldier's diction on that land, the first step from the vice of your staff was to
[1:15:09] come to do that way. The gentleman that owns his property is here tonight. It's John Martin.
[1:15:18] He's been aware of what we're doing and has, I'd have to let him say that he supports it,
[1:15:23] but he told me he did.
[1:15:28] His property is right here, there's two structures there.
[1:15:33] We may end up coming back and cleaning up his property line along the thing, but that's
[1:15:38] the plan.
[1:15:39] But the school will go up in that top area.
[1:15:40] Perfect.
[1:15:41] You bastarded well.
[1:15:42] Thank you, Brad.
[1:15:43] Rebecca.
[1:15:44] Thank you, Mayor.
[1:15:45] That brings up another question.
[1:15:47] So what is the plan?
[1:15:49] In the comp plan in the packet, the comp plan actually
[1:15:52] designates this as agricultural.
[1:15:56] And our one variable, some residential schools,
[1:15:59] can go in agricultural.
[1:16:01] But what is the ultimate plan for the rest of the property?
[1:16:08] So all of morning sun in this area
[1:16:10] is our one variable, which ends up
[1:16:15] being three lots per acre density,
[1:16:17] which you can, you see a lot of that in R2 also.
[1:16:22] So, we're asking that you annex it with the existing zone
[1:16:26] because that would meet the needs that we have.
[1:16:29] Further analysis, we may come back,
[1:16:32] because this is R2.
[1:16:34] We're seeing a trend for smaller lots
[1:16:37] when morning sun was developed.
[1:16:39] These lots in here were considerably bigger
[1:16:42] than the later lots that were put in
[1:16:44] because there's a trend towards a little higher density.
[1:16:48] people want a little less yard to most so but for right now what we're asking you is
[1:16:53] to annex this within the R1 variable and if that never change that would not
[1:16:58] stop the school we have to get a special use permit but but that's an allowed use
[1:17:02] in this. Thank you. Anything further from council before I open up to our
[1:17:10] citizens. I'm opening the public testimony portion of this hearing I don't have anyone's
[1:17:17] that signed up to be able to come forward.
[1:17:21] Oh, well, sir, why don't you come forward and just state your name.
[1:17:27] You want to make a drive for the list? Oh, did he? Okay.
[1:17:31] And give us your address. I'll try to write it down really quickly. And once you're all
[1:17:34] done with that, we're going to give you two minutes to speak.
[1:17:38] Kelly Tash. Kelly.
[1:17:40] 32, 33, Spring Creek Drive.
[1:17:43] I live in the southeast corner.
[1:17:54] Thank you. And maybe these questions are for Brad. I don't know. I miss the first meeting
[1:18:01] that's out of town for work. Behind my house, there was an underground concrete tile pipe
[1:18:08] that traveled down to the pasture that's down farther. And probably eight years ago, it caved
[1:18:15] in. So then, Ken, the guy that lived down there that has all that pasture, he came along
[1:18:22] through a piece of mainline on top of the ground and tied into the existing tile pipeline
[1:18:29] and then we have an existing mainline on top of the ground that carries the water now.
[1:18:35] And I think Twin Falls Canal kept me their responsibility into a gate, you know.
[1:18:42] That's true.
[1:18:43] We had an affirmative from our city engineer.
[1:18:46] So in being developed, who does that all fall onto?
[1:18:53] the canal system, the watering system, we'll ask that question.
[1:18:58] What we generally do is we allow public input, we get some questions from you, and then we'll
[1:19:04] center it on who needs to answer the question.
[1:19:07] And then I was wondering about fencing too.
[1:19:09] I know most of the elementary students have fencing all the way around.
[1:19:14] We have a fence on our backyard that's existing, and I'm wondering if they're going to have
[1:19:20] a right away for that pipe that's on the ground or in the ground. My water down to that pasture
[1:19:26] I'm going to have to keep the fence you know four or five feet away from my fence. There's
[1:19:32] going to be smashed right up next to you. Or about that right away that's going to be there.
[1:19:38] I have a question about that too. It sounds like the school is going to be right behind
[1:19:44] me. I'm the strength group on the southeast corner.
[1:19:51] Sir, sir, okay, sir, you need this way.
[1:19:55] Okay.
[1:19:56] And we're giving you a little bit of extra time because we're, okay, okay.
[1:20:00] Um, and then I'm glad to hear where the bros are going to go.
[1:20:04] They're going to go.
[1:20:05] Stadium is going to go clear through.
[1:20:07] And then that, that other room that comes up falls, I mean, Darren Hall, that's his
[1:20:14] private lane right now.
[1:20:16] And that will come true to have some to stay here.
[1:20:20] So I don't have problems now.
[1:20:27] Okay, you had, not your only, you had like four here,
[1:20:29] so I'm trying to frantically write them down, sir.
[1:20:32] Are you gonna have another meeting or is this it?
[1:20:35] When it's time to plan it.
[1:20:37] This is the meeting regarding the annexation.
[1:20:41] If we choose to go on and ask for an ordinance,
[1:20:45] that'll come back next week.
[1:20:47] Plus they'll be especially useful.
[1:20:49] Yeah, all kinds of other meetings as it's developed, sir.
[1:20:53] Thank you.
[1:20:54] Thank you.
[1:20:56] Okay.
[1:20:57] Is there anyone else?
[1:20:58] I have no one signed up to come forward on this item.
[1:21:02] Okay.
[1:21:05] At this time, I'm going to close the public testimony portion, but keep open so that we
[1:21:11] can ask questions of our developer and others.
[1:21:15] In fact, I'm going to ask our representative to come forward and maybe we can try to weed
[1:21:20] through some of these questions that Mr. Cheshire asked and gives you a
[1:21:25] chance to do your rebuttal to if you have any. So the property for that school
[1:21:33] will be his back property here. We're too premature to be able to really answer
[1:21:40] any of those questions including the fencing. We're just at the preliminary
[1:21:44] design stage. Fencing is is really a decision that's down the road but if you
[1:21:50] look at the schools across our city other than Lincoln and
[1:21:57] Bickel, we usually don't fence. You know, the rest of them are
[1:22:03] really closed campus and stuff. But at this point, that's just,
[1:22:08] we don't know at this point on those. The irrigation, any of the
[1:22:13] structure, the Twin Falls Canal Company is involved in all
[1:22:17] that have to do with their piping and we it's our obligation to continue delivery of watersheds across our property.
[1:22:26] So who maintains that, Brad? That underground water canal system?
[1:22:32] So Jackie's corrected. They're, you know, they're, they're rules which were already established a long time ago.
[1:22:40] to go, state that the installer of the system is responsible for the maintenance of it.
[1:22:47] So we change it, put a pipe in there, you know, we don't want to, but they say it's our problem
[1:22:53] forever.
[1:22:54] Okay.
[1:22:55] So, but Jackie Ryan stops at the head, stops at their delivery point.
[1:22:59] Okay.
[1:23:00] Is that right?
[1:23:04] I'm looking at, I'm trying to make sure that I, we answered your questions as best we could
[1:23:08] serve because obviously it's still in the process of.
[1:23:11] And we will be back with more specific information that he can see something at a later time, and
[1:23:18] he'll get noticed.
[1:23:19] Very good.
[1:23:20] Does Council have any further questions for the developer or city staff before we turn it
[1:23:28] over to deliberations on this item?
[1:23:31] Rebecca, may I say yes?
[1:23:33] Thank you, Mayor.
[1:23:34] I do have one question for staff.
[1:23:36] We recently had an application to amend the Complan to move the water boundary.
[1:23:41] This is an annexation, and so it seems to me we, especially being designated agriculture
[1:23:49] cultural in the comp plan, and with the applicant's testimony about wanting to do smaller lots,
[1:23:57] certainly our one variable is going to be allowed in, even in the agricultural designation,
[1:24:04] but somehow if it becomes any smaller that wouldn't match our comp plan.
[1:24:10] So it seems to me, and the P&Z commission actually asked about this, you'll see on page three
[1:24:17] of the July 8th minutes, they asked about it, and Steph mentioned that annexing at first
[1:24:26] does leave the final decision with the City Council, but I have a concern about using that
[1:24:34] to kind of bypass the public hearing that would be in the county.
[1:24:41] Because all of these residents that live not in city limits, I mean that's where their
[1:24:49] representation is heard and that's where they might be able to have a discussion about their
[1:24:55] comp plan.
[1:24:56] So my question is don't we need a comp plan amendment before, because if we're evaluating
[1:25:05] annexation based on the development plan for the area based on the comp plan. I just don't
[1:25:13] see how it meshes. And maybe that's a question for Fritz. I don't know.
[1:25:19] Fritz Wonder, like our city attorney?
[1:25:21] So the real request that you have before you is an annexation. So they want to be in the
[1:25:28] city. In the process of that, you have to, if you decide to annex it, you also have to
[1:25:35] determine what the proper zone is. So I think I hear you disagreeing with whether it should
[1:25:42] be R1 variable, maybe it should be agricultural. It's sort of confusing because right now it's
[1:25:51] already R1 variable within the area of impact. So I'll defer to you, but it's like it's not,
[1:25:59] I don't think it's a decision to say I don't want to annex it because I don't like R1
[1:26:04] variable it should be if it's annexed it should be ag because it shows ag in the
[1:26:10] comp plan. Right that's my concern not that I don't like it it's the concern that
[1:26:15] it doesn't seem to quite match the comp plan. Okay that's a good discussion
[1:26:19] about what should the zoning be and not what should whether it should be annexed.
[1:26:23] Right so what the only zoning that would match the comp plan would be agriculture.
[1:26:29] I'm cultural unless you do what normally is done and you leave it as is in the area of
[1:26:37] impact.
[1:26:38] We hardly ever change the zone when we bring, when we annex property, we leave youth.
[1:26:44] I don't think I've ever seen council attach different zoning than it was in the area of
[1:26:50] impact.
[1:26:51] Right.
[1:26:52] And my, the real concern is just that it seems like from the applicant, the plan, the
[1:26:58] development plan, which is something we're considering that you consider when you annex.
[1:27:02] The plan is to possibly make those smaller lots, which wouldn't comply with the R1 variable.
[1:27:09] Right, so maybe when he comes in with his application to amend the comp plan, not only with changing
[1:27:17] the water service area, but maybe also the designation of this area, because obviously
[1:27:24] the water service area changes, then it's not going to be ag anymore.
[1:27:28] It's going to be residents' development.
[1:27:36] Chris talking.
[1:27:37] So, Francis, if we motion for annexation, we would not have the option to bring it in
[1:27:43] under an R2 without sending it back to a P and Z.
[1:27:48] I would not recommend that you do that.
[1:27:50] I think they're going to be back here plenty of times.
[1:27:53] They have to come back on the complaint anyway, so they should probably make that pitch then.
[1:27:57] Thank you.
[1:27:59] Any other questions to the applicant, to our citizen who testified or to staff before I close that portion and we just go to deliberations.
[1:28:12] Did you want to add something, Beth?
[1:28:14] I'll allow that. You didn't take your full map.
[1:28:16] Well, I just want to address.
[1:28:18] Rebecca, so if you look at the comp plan, this is agriculture. This is medium density.
[1:28:28] So, when the comp plan comes back, when we make our next application, that it would make
[1:28:39] more sense that, you know, our choices are the, well, not, we have made choices, we have
[1:28:44] rural residential, but, you know, the natural growth is this direction.
[1:28:48] So, the next step on the comprehensive plan change would be to bring it in as medium density
[1:28:57] designation as opposed to an R. So, am I right, Mitch?
[1:29:03] Yeah, and thank you for that. Yeah.
[1:29:06] Because that's my only concern is it seems like we're kind of getting our process out of order.
[1:29:11] You know, it's kind of hard to make these determinations based on where we're at right now.
[1:29:15] It just seems like maybe we've gotten our cart before the horse or something.
[1:29:19] So typically, where this is all our one variable,
[1:29:24] when we bring land in that usually we don't ask for a change
[1:29:29] to that point because it's a different process of information
[1:29:35] and stuff like that.
[1:29:36] So at this point, we just want to be in the city.
[1:29:38] We'll stay with what the area of impact says it is.
[1:29:43] Because once I want to change from them,
[1:29:46] then I have to go back and change the comp plan.
[1:29:49] because it says agriculture.
[1:29:51] If I leave it R1, then I don't have to go back
[1:29:54] to the common land because the zoning's already determined.
[1:29:59] Right, but isn't your ultimate destination the same?
[1:30:01] I mean, the ultimate destination.
[1:30:03] No, that's certainly.
[1:30:04] We're at the very start.
[1:30:06] I can, we can easily develop that within this lot density.
[1:30:11] Okay.
[1:30:12] So, it just, you want sometimes to see, you're not sure
[1:30:15] what the 10 years down the road is going to look like.
[1:30:18] Right, I don't want this decision to pre-determine the future for this lot without the proper
[1:30:24] planning.
[1:30:25] Right.
[1:30:27] Thank you, Brad.
[1:30:28] Anything further before I turn it over to deliberations and or a motion from council?
[1:30:33] All right.
[1:30:34] We're in close.
[1:30:35] The public testimony portion is closed and Chris talking.
[1:30:38] I would move to approve annexation of 53.6 acres located on the east side of the 500,
[1:30:46] 700 blocks of Hank and Road North, also known as 3600 East Road.
[1:30:51] 3,200 East. 3,200, excuse me.
[1:30:55] And we need to designate the zoning.
[1:30:58] And designated zone and as R1 variable area of impact.
[1:31:02] Thank you for that.
[1:31:04] Thank you Fritz.
[1:31:05] And I think I have a winner.
[1:31:07] Chris Hockden made the motion seconded by Sean Berrigger.
[1:31:11] Anything further on that motion council?
[1:31:15] Back in the middle, so I can.
[1:31:16] Thank you, Mayor.
[1:31:18] Well, looking at our planning documents,
[1:31:20] especially the comprehensive plan under land use,
[1:31:25] goal 2.11 is to limit future urban growth
[1:31:30] to areas within the existing water limit boundary.
[1:31:33] And so it specifically tells us to forbid the extension
[1:31:36] of essential urban services, water and sewer,
[1:31:38] to areas beyond the existing water limit boundary.
[1:31:41] So that's kind of a struggle for me
[1:31:43] if we're supposed to evaluate the comp plan
[1:31:45] and see whether this request complies with it, you know, to me it doesn't.
[1:31:51] Also in our strategic plan, several of our objectives have to do with discouraging urban
[1:31:57] sprawl, discouraging.
[1:31:59] I just don't know about this annexing 50 acres at a time.
[1:32:04] When you talk about annexation, it's an exchange of services, and of course you get the revenue,
[1:32:10] but residential development is the most costly development, and you get that additional revenue,
[1:32:15] you get the additional infrastructure that the maintenance costs continue to increase
[1:32:20] from year to year.
[1:32:23] So this to me looks like sprawl.
[1:32:25] I certainly would support annexing just the school.
[1:32:29] I think that makes sense.
[1:32:32] But even the school is going to be developed without, you know, kind of in a back portion
[1:32:39] of the lot without Hankins being fully developed and there's a lot of money spent on safe routes
[1:32:44] to school, and this area just isn't very walkable.
[1:32:48] I don't know how it encourages walkability to, for an elementary school, but the cost
[1:32:57] to the citizens I think doesn't outweigh the revenue gained.
[1:33:01] It certainly doesn't match our comp plan or our strategic plan, so I'm kind of left
[1:33:06] with the only option of saying no, but I just see in our comprehensive plan that it says
[1:33:15] to limit future growth.
[1:33:17] You know, and Councilman talked about a situation that California is in with their drought.
[1:33:22] We see cities all over the Midwest having to shut down due to their urban sprawl.
[1:33:28] I don't want to see Twin Falls make the same mistake.
[1:33:30] Thank you, Rebecca.
[1:33:32] It's John Berger.
[1:33:34] So I think a lot of the issues that Rebecca is bringing up will certainly be addressed in
[1:33:41] the multitude of future interactions we're going to have with this request.
[1:33:47] I do think, and certainly if you just take it at face value today, it will need some request
[1:33:55] for modifications to things like the water boundary and like the come plan, and that's
[1:33:59] why we have a process in place for that to have that discussion.
[1:34:02] You know, as far as it's encouraging sprawl and too much growth, you know, if you flipped
[1:34:10] the school over to the other side of the street, it's going to use the same amount of water
[1:34:14] as it uses on the other side of Hankins.
[1:34:17] So it's not like we're using up resources if we're supportive of it going there.
[1:34:24] I actually think that this coming with the annexation first makes sense because of the
[1:34:32] process that's in place for doing things that are of impact and having to duplicate this.
[1:34:36] And it's not about leaving people out and leaving their voice out.
[1:34:40] I'm all of these neighboring property owners were still notified of this hearing
[1:34:45] just because it's in front of the city council and not in front of the county commission doesn't
[1:34:48] mean their voice isn't heard. So I think it's prudent to move forward with
[1:34:54] This item and then understand that there are going to be plenty of other opportunities
[1:34:58] to make those modifications as make sense in the future.
[1:35:03] Thank you, Sean.
[1:35:04] Anything further on the motion council?
[1:35:06] Leila Rokal, please.
[1:35:08] John Hall.
[1:35:09] Yes.
[1:35:10] Chris Talkington.
[1:35:11] Yes.
[1:35:12] Rebecca Melsweicke.
[1:35:13] No.
[1:35:14] Suzanne Buckends.
[1:35:16] Yes.
[1:35:17] Sean Berger.
[1:35:18] Yes.
[1:35:19] Jim Mon.
[1:35:20] Yes.
[1:35:21] Great.
[1:35:22] Glad.
[1:35:23] Yes.
[1:35:24] six to one council we will take an eight-minute break like to reconvene the meeting of the Twin
[1:42:41] Falls City Council I do want to ask do we have a couple boy scouts in the audience can you both
[1:42:49] come to the microphone introduce yourself tell us what troop you're with where you meet and what
[1:42:54] you're working on tonight there's only four questions there hi my name is Bailey Bingham I'm
[1:43:00] from troop 200. I'm working on the Maribatch citizenship in the community and what was the
[1:43:06] fourth question? Where do you meet? Oh we meet at the LDS church on Elizabeth. Excellent. Thank
[1:43:14] you for coming. Come tonight. That was my brother right there. Yeah we meet at the church
[1:43:24] building on Elizabeth. I'm working on citizenship in the community too with them and what were
[1:43:31] the other two questions. Yeah, I think you got it covered. Oh, your name. Yes. Thank you.
[1:43:35] Oh, yeah. I'm Payson Bingham. Thank you, Payson. Thank you both for being here tonight.
[1:43:40] Is there a reason why you're sitting separately? You guys in? Very good. Welcome to both of you.
[1:43:48] Next item on the agenda is a request to adopt a resolution setting, the new fees structure
[1:43:54] schedule, excuse me, for Jocelyn Field, Magic Valley Regional Airport. We have our airport
[1:43:59] manager, Bill Carberry. Welcome, Bill.
[1:44:01] Thank you, Mayor. Good evening, Council members.
[1:44:03] Oh, I did want to mention that Greg Lanning, Councilman Lanning, did have to leave. He had
[1:44:20] already a pre-arranged endeavor this evening, and so he's not going to be able to be with
[1:44:25] us the rest of the evening.
[1:44:27] Thank you. Well, in your packets, it's a resolution that lists several of the fees at the airport,
[1:44:33] and working with the airport board this spring as we do each year, we review our fees and
[1:44:41] three fees for aeronautical activity came up for consideration for some increases.
[1:44:49] Those being the ones here on the screen, the landing fee, which is assessed to commercial
[1:44:57] airlines as well as general aviation aircraft above 12,500 pounds.
[1:45:01] So that's proposed to go up about 11% or 14 cents per thousand pounds of gross landing
[1:45:09] weight, fuel flowage fee. We currently get 7 cents per gallon. Both of these were set in
[1:45:15] 2012. We're looking to pump those up 1 cent. Our fees which are aircraft rescue and firefighting
[1:45:24] fees. Those are particular to the airline. Back I think it was about 2006. There was a
[1:45:30] new mandate to provide standby firefighting services for all commercial service airports
[1:45:36] for their airlines.
[1:45:37] And we set that back, I think it was $50 to $55 initially.
[1:45:42] In 2009, that was bumped to $60.
[1:45:45] And we're looking to bump those up to $70 and $80,
[1:45:49] or about an 18% increase.
[1:45:52] Some of the metrics used for these proposals
[1:45:54] are the costs for providing service.
[1:45:57] And over the years, the operations and maintenance budget
[1:46:01] of the airport's gone up.
[1:46:02] In the last two years, about 11%.
[1:46:04] you can see that reflected in the landing fee, the fuel flowage,
[1:46:08] food is some rounding is a little more than 11%,
[1:46:10] but it's one penny per gallon.
[1:46:14] And the R fee, which has been several years,
[1:46:16] about five years now, the RF services,
[1:46:20] which are the cost structures significant with personnel,
[1:46:26] has gone up about 18% for RF services.
[1:46:28] So those are reflected here.
[1:46:32] We also took a look at some of the impacts
[1:46:36] to the users and the revenues that we are associated with our forecasts.
[1:46:52] This may be a bit small, I apologize.
[1:46:54] It is in your packet, but as a reference for the discussion I throw it up here.
[1:47:00] Currently these are our forecast revenues for these three fee areas.
[1:47:06] Landing fees are anticipated to be about 84,000 with the increase.
[1:47:11] We're looking at about $9,240 for a new estimate of about $93,000.
[1:47:17] Fuel flowage fees, we're looking at estimates of about $5,720 increase based on our forecast
[1:47:25] activity.
[1:47:26] That would bump that up to $45,720.
[1:47:30] The aircraft rescue firefighting fee, which has really been significantly hit by the reduction
[1:47:35] in flights.
[1:47:37] The forecast is for $65,700 and with an increase if that would take effect of about $11,000, $12,000
[1:47:46] for a new estimated forecast revenue of $77,526.
[1:47:53] This just breaks down landing fees on the predominant commercial service aircraft used.
[1:47:59] The Enbere 120 has been discontinued in June, as many of you know.
[1:48:03] With the regional jet, the RJ-200, we're looking at ways about twice as much, so some of our
[1:48:11] anticipated landing fees from the airliner are kind of a wash with the new aircraft because
[1:48:15] of its weight being almost twice as much.
[1:48:19] So the landing at $1.25 per thousand for an RJ would be $58.75.
[1:48:25] The new increase to $1.39 would be $65.33 for an increase of $6.58.
[1:48:34] And as I articulated earlier, the aircraft rescue firefighting fee of $10.80 increase
[1:48:43] as well.
[1:48:45] So with these, we also take a look at our fees and comparison in other airports in the region
[1:48:50] and we seem to fall somewhere in the middle of that with those surveys.
[1:48:56] So with that, I'd bring forth the airport board's recommendation that you consider these fees for adoption.
[1:49:02] They would be taking effect October 1st of the new fiscal year.
[1:49:05] So, be happy to answer any questions you might have.
[1:49:08] Thank you Bill.
[1:49:09] What would the resolution be, number B, the idea if we choose to go that direction?
[1:49:13] 1928.
[1:49:15] 1928, thank you.
[1:49:16] Council, any questions?
[1:49:21] Chris, talking to.
[1:49:24] I would move on to approval resolution 1928.
[1:49:30] Yes.
[1:49:33] I think this is a raise of the more than five or so.
[1:49:35] Oh, in public hearing and also, yeah, okay, very good.
[1:49:40] Hey, do you have any questions, Chris talking to?
[1:49:43] I always have questions.
[1:49:45] I'm just moving to what I thought this was a public hearing,
[1:49:49] right now, but you made the motion.
[1:49:52] I have to hear it first.
[1:49:53] Hearing first.
[1:49:55] Yeah, okay, Sean Berger.
[1:49:58] So, Bill, in your conclusion, in your presentation,
[1:50:02] where you talk about the fees being considered to offset the increased maintenance and operation
[1:50:10] costs from the last several years. So in your budget estimations, this is the amount
[1:50:16] that it takes to cover those increased maintenance costs.
[1:50:20] No, I usually step forward in a fairly conservative manner and we don't make that presumption that
[1:50:26] this will be adopted and those new revenues will be in there. We like to give it about
[1:50:31] Europe history based on our forecasts was our activity forecast as we imagined, you
[1:50:36] know, so we'll adjust next year. So these new, if that answers your question. So the
[1:50:42] fees really that you're looking at are to after a year under your belt you'll
[1:50:48] know how that fits with the operation. Right, we've taken our expense budget and
[1:50:53] worked it around our revenues based without these increases but with these
[1:50:57] increases, it will get some history next spring as we start to formulate the 16th budget where
[1:51:04] we are.
[1:51:05] Okay.
[1:51:06] Thank you.
[1:51:08] Jim.
[1:51:09] Thank you, Mayor.
[1:51:10] Yeah, Bill.
[1:51:11] I think I understand exactly what you're doing.
[1:51:12] I'm with you.
[1:51:14] My question that the community might have is, particularly people are flying community or
[1:51:20] traveling communities, how old to, how do I want to phrase this?
[1:51:29] Why don't you give us an overview about how these monies will be expended?
[1:51:34] Did this increase?
[1:51:35] We know the increase is good, if the increase is passive.
[1:51:38] How will this increase in revenue be spent?
[1:51:44] Well, it's really a balance.
[1:51:45] The airport tries to be as self-sustaining as it can without using any property taxes.
[1:51:51] But we're probably several years from that, hopefully that actuality someday.
[1:51:57] So the airport is not unlike many others where we synthesize from property tax support, from
[1:52:02] the city and the county, along with revenues that we generate at the airport.
[1:52:08] So with any fee increase, as we particularly try to step up with the cost of delivering service,
[1:52:16] we try to keep that ratio of that balance reasonable.
[1:52:19] So I think in a broad sense that maybe answers the question, as we look to user fees to help
[1:52:27] with costs of operating the airport,
[1:52:29] we take into due consideration the property taxes
[1:52:32] and that side of the equation as well.
[1:52:34] So.
[1:52:35] OK.
[1:52:36] You got it.
[1:52:36] Thanks.
[1:52:37] Suzanne Hawkins.
[1:52:39] Bill, you did in our notes tell us
[1:52:41] that you contacted SkyWest Airline
[1:52:43] and have out of courtesy explained to them what we're facing.
[1:52:47] And it looks like they were OK with what we're discussing
[1:52:51] tonight.
[1:52:51] Thank you for the question.
[1:52:53] That's a key point.
[1:52:55] We've had a very long history with SkyWest Airlines, and they're a good group to work with.
[1:53:01] We maintain a very open dialogue.
[1:53:02] So, as our fee structure certainly is something we talk about, and nobody likes fee increases,
[1:53:08] but the realities are cost-for-going.
[1:53:11] People understand, participate, to be provided opportunities, those things cost.
[1:53:15] So, yes, I regularly dialogue with them, and they have no objections with these.
[1:53:20] They seem to feel that they're in line with other airports that they work with.
[1:53:25] Thank you very much.
[1:53:26] Bill, I see no further questions, so I will open it up for public testimony.
[1:53:31] I have no one written down up here.
[1:53:35] Is there anyone here that would like to testify regarding this item?
[1:53:42] No one came forward, so I've closed the public testimony portion.
[1:53:46] Anything you want to wrap up with, Bill, or shall we?
[1:53:50] I think that summarizes it, so I'd be happy to answer any more questions.
[1:53:55] Is there any other questions of bill before I close the public hearing portion and we
[1:53:59] turn it over to deliberation and a motion?
[1:54:02] Chris, talking to?
[1:54:04] Well, to answer the question about no-unliking fee raising, I guess the only option that we
[1:54:10] could go through this every year and perhaps get under the 5% and not have to have a public
[1:54:16] hearing.
[1:54:17] So, at the risk of having some super charge rate increases, at least the public has the
[1:54:23] ability to have an input and they may not have redid this on a regular but a less but a continually
[1:54:30] accumulating basis. So there's some value to it.
[1:54:35] Okay. I will close the public hearing portion of this and turn it over to council for their
[1:54:39] wishes. Suzanne Hawkins.
[1:54:47] Okay. I would like to move that we accept resolution number 1928 with the fee increases
[1:54:52] as presented.
[1:54:53] We have a motion on the floor by Suzanne Hawkins, seconded by Jim Mann, to accept a resolution
[1:55:05] 1928 with the associated fee structure.
[1:55:08] Anything further on that motion council?
[1:55:12] Leila Rokalvo, please.
[1:55:13] Chris Talkington?
[1:55:14] Yes.
[1:55:15] Rebecca Milsenka?
[1:55:16] Yes.
[1:55:18] Suzanne Hawkins?
[1:55:19] Yes.
[1:55:20] John Hockens?
[1:55:21] Yes.
[1:55:22] Jim Mann?
[1:55:23] Yes.
[1:55:24] Don Hockens?
[1:55:25] Yes.
[1:55:26] Motion passes, 6-0.
[1:55:27] Thank you.
[1:55:28] Next item on the agenda is a long one.
[1:55:31] So you request for a zoning title amendment,
[1:55:34] amending city code sections, 10-4-8.3C regarding
[1:55:40] maximum building height in the C1 District,
[1:55:43] 10-4-8.3D1 regarding side and rear yard setbacks in the C1 District,
[1:55:55] 10-4. Oh, we are we are. Thank you
[1:56:02] My esteemed colleague to my right straightened me out
[1:56:06] You want to go I was just in a hurry to get moving so I could flip them so maybe it may be a mr.
[1:56:12] Mary it may be appropriate to the order of the public hearing depending upon
[1:56:17] I was extending a courtesy to the citizens who've come if they're here for item number four now it may be
[1:56:24] be appropriate to hear that now.
[1:56:28] Well, let's maybe we should poll the citizens, there's two, I think, out there, maybe three.
[1:56:36] Are you here, ladies or gentlemen, for any specific item on here that you'd like to testify?
[1:56:43] Jill, no?
[1:56:44] Sir?
[1:56:46] You're on three?
[1:56:47] Sir, all the way in the back with the New York hat?
[1:56:50] No?
[1:56:51] Okay.
[1:56:52] So we will go to item number three.
[1:56:53] John for straight me out request to adopt an ordinance amending Twin Falls City Code section
[1:57:00] 10-18-12 by increasing development impact fees and we'll turn it over to Mitch Humboldt increasing
[1:57:15] the impact fees is a heck of a process I got to tell you especially when those fees are
[1:57:21] more than 5% it just adds a whole another step per two to our process so if y'all recall
[1:57:28] On June 9th, we had a hearing in front of the council
[1:57:32] to talk about the impact fee program.
[1:57:34] That hearing was for an amendment to the COM plan.
[1:57:37] Our impact fee program is included
[1:57:39] in our comprehensive plan, the Chapter 11 of our COM plan.
[1:57:41] And so to amend the COM plan requires a public hearing
[1:57:43] in this whole, you know, process that we went through then.
[1:57:48] That process concludes with the adoption
[1:57:50] of a resolution actually making that change official.
[1:57:53] We haven't done that yet because we also have this step
[1:57:55] that we have to take tonight because these fees actually
[1:57:58] are over 5% of an increase in all but one case.
[1:58:03] So we have to do this hearing and then this will acquire an ordinance amendment because
[1:58:06] this is actually in city code and in the comp plan.
[1:58:09] So impact fees are complicated and they take some time to get through.
[1:58:15] So we're doing it again tonight to have the impact fee hearing.
[1:58:18] The hearing to raise the impact fees more than 5%.
[1:58:21] So we just spent a good amount of time talking about why the CIPs, the capital improvement
[1:58:28] plans, the changes that we made there, what the use of these fees is going to go for, and
[1:58:33] I didn't really want to like rehash all of that unless you all would like to ask those
[1:58:38] questions.
[1:58:39] That whole report is included as an attachment to tonight's report.
[1:58:42] So you have all of that stuff is in there.
[1:58:45] But again, we just had that conversation a month ago.
[1:58:49] So tonight I really just wanted to focus on the fees.
[1:58:53] And so I'm going to put in it.
[1:59:13] So we showed you this exhibit in June.
[1:59:17] But it's a good one to talk about this too.
[1:59:19] So what we have here on this exhibit,
[1:59:22] I'm going to start with like in the middle of the table.
[1:59:24] I know that makes a lot of sense, doesn't it?
[1:59:26] In the middle of the table right here we have the current fees.
[1:59:28] These are the fees that we're charging people today
[1:59:30] when they come in to develop.
[1:59:32] This first column of numbers is what the proposed impact fee
[1:59:36] is going to be after the adoption of the changes
[1:59:40] to the capital improvement plans that we did last June,
[1:59:42] or last month.
[1:59:43] And then we did a couple other columns here
[1:59:45] that shows the difference in dollars and cents
[1:59:48] and then the difference by percentage.
[1:59:50] And you can see if we go down the row here
[1:59:52] that all of these are over 5%,
[1:59:55] except for this one was a slight decrease of 7-7%.
[2:00:00] So the fees that we're gonna charge,
[2:00:02] that we're proposing charge,
[2:00:03] we $283 per dwelling unit for a police fee
[2:00:08] for residential development, $0.14 a foot for non-residential development.
[2:00:14] For fire department fees, it's $629 for a resident's, $0.32 a foot for non-residential.
[2:00:21] The street impact fees are shown here $501 for a single family unit, $329 for a multifamily
[2:00:29] unit, $2.40 per square foot for retail, $0.74 per square foot for office, $0.53 per square
[2:00:37] foot for industrial and 15 cents per square foot for institutional. Institutional would
[2:00:43] be schools and hospitals and those kinds of things. And then last on the Parks and Recreation
[2:00:50] fee, $593 per residential unit, we do not charge a Parks and Recreation impact fee for
[2:00:56] non-residential development. And so again, we go across the line and we see a 44% increase
[2:01:01] and it ranges down to 12, about 77, 79.
[2:01:06] So that's the reason, this last column,
[2:01:08] is the reason why we're here tonight.
[2:01:11] If none of those were over 5%, we'd
[2:01:13] be done with the resolution that we adopted
[2:01:16] or that we would have adopted following the June hearing.
[2:01:19] So we need to just basically have a hearing,
[2:01:22] get some input on these fees again,
[2:01:25] and then if the council is comfortable with it,
[2:01:29] we have an ordinance prepared.
[2:01:30] that can be adopted tonight or we can do this a couple of more times.
[2:01:35] The idea is to implement on October 1st.
[2:01:37] So if we want to do this and do three readings and we can do that, we want to adopt it tonight
[2:01:41] and we can do that by suspending the rules.
[2:01:45] And then so that's really all I wanted to say.
[2:01:47] If you want to ask questions about what's actually in the CIPs, we can do that again
[2:01:51] or I can just sit down and let you do your thing.
[2:01:55] We have some questions, looks like.
[2:01:57] Chris talking.
[2:01:58] I might give just a little rehash of the last time these were increased and what the CPI
[2:02:04] has done since then.
[2:02:06] The capital improvement plans, well we've done to those.
[2:02:10] So we haven't done any significant changes to these fees since the program was adopted
[2:02:16] in 2009.
[2:02:17] And when I say significant, what I mean by that is every January 1st, we have an automatic
[2:02:24] increase that's built into the plan.
[2:02:26] And that increases tight to the MCI levels, the municipal cost index.
[2:02:31] And so in the last five years, three of those years, we allowed the increase to take place
[2:02:36] and it was about 1.1%.
[2:02:39] I think it was, I think we had two years of about 1.1% and the third time was most recently
[2:02:43] with 1.9%.
[2:02:44] And then two years, we didn't have any increases at all.
[2:02:50] We didn't do any significant changes to the capital improvement plans for those first five
[2:02:54] years either. With this fee, the fees are going up because we did do significant changes to
[2:03:01] some of the capital improvement plans. In the case of the park fees, we actually removed
[2:03:08] some items from the capital improvement plan because they were completed. And we found some
[2:03:16] and things like that, so we fix those up that way.
[2:03:20] Police Department fees, we kind of tweaked a little bit some
[2:03:25] of the cost estimates that we had for some of those projects.
[2:03:29] There wasn't any significant changes to the CIP other
[2:03:32] than adjusting the cost.
[2:03:34] See, the Fire Department fees had some significant changes
[2:03:40] to the cost of particularly the apparatus
[2:03:44] and the fire station number, I think it was fire station number four that we had in there,
[2:03:48] but we also dropped out of fire station entirely.
[2:03:51] We had some dramatic increases in the cost of the stations that over those five years pan
[2:03:58] of the academy.
[2:04:01] And the biggest change, the biggest reason for the change comes to the street projects.
[2:04:04] And under the prior plan, we were funding traffic signals, five different traffic signals
[2:04:11] for the five-year span.
[2:04:14] This CIP includes those same five traffic signals,
[2:04:18] but also includes a million and a half dollars toward street
[2:04:21] construction projects that did not used to be there.
[2:04:24] And that million and a half in the street fees is the primary reason
[2:04:27] for the increase on basically everything except for,
[2:04:32] obviously, except for parks.
[2:04:33] The biggest increases there are in the street site.
[2:04:36] You can see that's where all the 70% are coming.
[2:04:39] And that's the inclusion of the $1.5 million in Street in Street projects and there's four specific street projects
[2:04:45] They're on the list and whichever one of those rise to the top end priority will be the one that gets the money spent on it
[2:04:51] Thank you Mitch Rebecca Millsoic
[2:04:54] Thank You mayor just two questions for you Mitch. We talked last time we we did talk about adjusting
[2:05:02] The park the estimated park acquisition
[2:05:06] cost we talked about maybe checking to see if it really reflected today's
[2:05:11] market and what it would really cost us to acquire park land. Did you see any
[2:05:15] changes in that? So the answer will be very, very location specific. So it really
[2:05:25] depends and that's not a very good answer I know but it really depends what land
[2:05:29] you're talking about. So in some areas we can buy 15 acres of park land for
[2:05:34] less than what we have in there, significantly less.
[2:05:37] And in other areas, it's significantly more.
[2:05:41] It just depends.
[2:05:43] So if we're looking at buying a piece on the canyon rim
[2:05:47] to preserve an open space view or something like that,
[2:05:51] those prices are $350,000 an acre in the 40 or whatever
[2:05:55] that we include in there.
[2:05:56] It's nowhere near enough.
[2:05:57] But if we're taking Ag land that's valued at $15,000 an acre,
[2:06:03] we're probably overpriced at 40, so.
[2:06:05] So are we shooting for a medium or a medium?
[2:06:08] Yeah, we're kind of trying to hit the middle of the road,
[2:06:10] sort of a thing, yeah.
[2:06:10] OK.
[2:06:12] So that we could apply it really as best we can
[2:06:17] to where the need comes up, I guess.
[2:06:19] And we don't know that until the need is there.
[2:06:22] Right, but and we're looking, so maybe we
[2:06:24] can be aware of where, I mean, there's,
[2:06:27] there really aren't too many places
[2:06:29] where we could acquire the size of a lot that we need for our parks.
[2:06:35] So, okay, so we can probably have a good idea.
[2:06:40] Sure. Okay. Well, thank you for that.
[2:06:43] My other question is just a clarification on your CIP list,
[2:06:49] you know, so just take streets, for example.
[2:06:52] You've got your CIP value and you go down to the total infrastructure,
[2:06:56] which is about 25 million, 700,000 some.
[2:07:00] And then you go to the amount included in the fees,
[2:07:03] and then it's about 3.8 million.
[2:07:06] Is all of that 25.7 million?
[2:07:09] Is that all growth related costs on this list,
[2:07:12] or is this just other needs as well?
[2:07:18] Do you, I'm trying to find the 25 you're talking about?
[2:07:22] Well, any of the totals really.
[2:07:24] My question is just on the CIP value
[2:07:26] that the capital improvement plan value it kind of totals all of exactly here.
[2:07:31] Yeah, on the total infrastructure.
[2:07:33] So all of those values are those are just growth specific.
[2:07:37] Yeah, so let me.
[2:07:40] I wanted to show the column headings and I think this will give me what I wanted to show.
[2:07:55] So we can only charge an impact fee if it's a growth related impact, right?
[2:08:00] We can't charge an impact fee of a developer to overcome a deficiency that we already have.
[2:08:06] That's not caused by the growth.
[2:08:09] And so we account for that in places like this 21% or up here that's 64% or 82%.
[2:08:17] You'll see a lot of our 100%.
[2:08:20] If it's got 100%, then the idea is that that specific project, so a Washington and Grand
[2:08:28] view is 100%. That specific project, the idea is that that is a growth related project entirely.
[2:08:36] 82% for Eastland from Cambridge to Kimberly, 82% suggest that there is somewhat of an existing
[2:08:46] problem today. And this is growth capacity, not necessarily road surface. Okay, so is there
[2:08:53] enough lanes to handle the traffic, not other potholes in the road.
[2:09:00] So the idea there is that we have a little bit of a capacity issue today, and so 82% of
[2:09:05] that project is going to be growth related, but some of that is already existing.
[2:09:10] And that's where that comes in.
[2:09:11] So if I push you down to the bottom where you came up with that question, there's 25 million
[2:09:17] there.
[2:09:18] And no, not all of that is growth related, but also on this page, more importantly, we
[2:09:24] show, I want to say there's 27 or 28 traffic signals in there, but we're only going to
[2:09:29] fund five of them.
[2:09:30] And so that total of 25 million is the total of 28 traffic signals.
[2:09:37] Over here you see that 25 only turns into 3.8.
[2:09:41] I don't think so, yeah.
[2:09:45] So the 3.8 is basically five traffic signals and those road projects.
[2:09:51] So the 25 is not all making its way into the calculation of the fees, only the 3.8 is.
[2:09:57] Okay, and then some, even if they're considered 100% growth related, that doesn't mean they're
[2:10:02] necessarily put onto the impact fees and so a lot of those are not being put into the fee
[2:10:09] plan.
[2:10:10] So we're kind of holding back, five project, five impact fee signals or five traffic
[2:10:15] signals for $418,000 each.
[2:10:18] So two million of that is, is two million of the 3.8 is, is, is, um, street, but I'll
[2:10:27] show you this one that's 21%.
[2:10:30] If, if that signal is one that we decide to build with impact fee money, we'll only be
[2:10:35] able to fund 21% of that cost with the impact fee money.
[2:10:38] The rest of that would have to come from other sources.
[2:10:41] And so because we've listed it this way on the table.
[2:10:45] Okay. That makes sense. Thank you.
[2:10:48] Any other questions for staff before I open up the public hearing portion?
[2:10:52] I probably want to know an ordinance number.
[2:10:54] Yeah. Do you have one handy?
[2:10:56] I know somebody who has the eyelid.
[2:10:59] 3074.
[2:11:00] 3074. Thank you.
[2:11:03] All right. At this time we'll open up a public testimony portion of the public hearing
[2:11:08] And I don't have a list in front of me.
[2:11:11] I know that I had at least one person that would like to come forward.
[2:11:16] You know, actually, I think you did sign up, but I assumed you signed up wrongly because
[2:11:19] you were speaking before, Mr. Wilson.
[2:11:21] Well, so I number one and number three.
[2:11:24] You got me.
[2:11:25] I know the rules.
[2:11:27] If you'd introduce yourself against her in your address, and it's all yours.
[2:11:31] Okay.
[2:11:32] I'm Brad.
[2:11:35] So, so originally I was part of the impact.
[2:11:39] Brad, could you say your name?
[2:11:41] Mad Wills to introduce your shown street west in purple.
[2:11:44] Perfect.
[2:11:45] Sorry, I wasn't listening there.
[2:11:47] It's been a long night.
[2:11:49] So I just want to compliment staff all the way to Lori left.
[2:11:55] We spent a lot of time.
[2:11:56] We met extra, extra time.
[2:11:58] We were at a stalemate and voted and we just kept going.
[2:12:03] So what you have before us is what we as a committee believe is the best balance.
[2:12:10] We'd like to do more.
[2:12:11] We'd like to do less.
[2:12:14] Because this is October 1st, it begins, I could be talking for the school district.
[2:12:21] So the difference between the fee now and the school district when we actually have the square
[2:12:28] footages and go through the process, it's $145,000 up to about $180,000.
[2:12:37] So it's probably a $35,000 difference to the school.
[2:12:42] We're budgeting the higher figure because there's no way we can get it in before the
[2:12:46] October 1st.
[2:12:47] But that just to give you a view, but we're building a lot of square foot each, like almost
[2:12:51] 300 square feet.
[2:12:52] So 300,000.
[2:12:53] 300,000.
[2:12:57] You're 300.
[2:12:58] That's not a lot of thousand.
[2:12:59] You know, it is late.
[2:13:00] Okay.
[2:13:01] What kind of school is this?
[2:13:07] So I want to assure you guys as the City Council looking out for the building community, I'm
[2:13:12] past president of the Home Builders Association, this is an increase in our single family dwelling.
[2:13:18] We had on our panel we also had commercial realtors, commercial developers and so what's
[2:13:26] before you we think is the best.
[2:13:31] We've been, I've been harp, I'm not harping, talking to Travis.
[2:13:42] So the NHB, which is what the Magic Valley Home Builders is, an area member of the National
[2:13:48] Association of Home Builders, they do what's called a price-out effect and this study is
[2:13:54] available.
[2:13:55] I'll provide it to Leyla for you guys to read, but it talks about what $1,000 increase
[2:14:03] does to the ability of people to buy homes and so they do major metro areas.
[2:14:12] So for Idaho, it was the Boise NAP area that they did, and the medium new price home in Boise
[2:14:19] area, the metro area is like $270,000, it takes us $66,000 a year household income to support
[2:14:27] that.
[2:14:29] And the average in the United States is for every $1,000, it knocks out about 324 people.
[2:14:42] So their argument is regulations cost money.
[2:14:47] The more we charge and building permit, impact fees, the more you're eliminating those buyers.
[2:14:52] So in Idaho and Boise areas, for every $1,000 it was 884 people.
[2:15:00] It's a different area than Twin Falls, but as a community we need to address that entry
[2:15:06] level.
[2:15:08] We've been working with Travis and Travis as aware of that and we're going to keep working
[2:15:12] on that, but we've lost that portion of our market here.
[2:15:17] We're not able to build homes in Boise, Corey Barton's able to get homes at 105,000, 110,000.
[2:15:25] We just can't do that here, so thank you.
[2:15:28] So I just bring that before you that we're aware that everything costs.
[2:15:32] We think Twin Falls does a great job with the money that you have.
[2:15:35] You're not increasing your property taxes like you could.
[2:15:40] you're trying to keep it down.
[2:15:41] So the main purpose I'm up is just as a committee member
[2:15:45] of the impact fee committee,
[2:15:48] I would ask that you go ahead and pass this tonight, so.
[2:15:52] Thank you, Mr. Wood.
[2:15:53] Is there anyone else that would like to come forward?
[2:15:58] I will close the public testimony portion of tonight's hearing
[2:16:02] and if there's any further information
[2:16:05] from our city staff and or any questions,
[2:16:08] you have a rattle for Brad.
[2:16:10] Okay, I actually just want to make one more point
[2:16:12] that I didn't make in my presentation,
[2:16:13] I apologize for that.
[2:16:14] When you look at the ordinance that's in your packet tonight,
[2:16:18] the numbers in the ordinance will be these numbers
[2:16:19] from the white part of the table.
[2:16:21] Those are actually the numbers that we charge
[2:16:25] that are in the ordinance, right?
[2:16:26] We total them up at the bottom here for,
[2:16:31] I guess for presentation.
[2:16:32] So when I talk to a builder,
[2:16:34] they want to know what I'm gonna pay you.
[2:16:35] Well, I don't want to tell them,
[2:16:37] they don't want to know four different numbers,
[2:16:38] I just want to know $2,006, OK?
[2:16:41] So these numbers down here, when we run these calculations,
[2:16:44] we run them out to four decimal points.
[2:16:46] And then we round it to $1 and cents.
[2:16:49] And so some of these, if you're paying attention really close
[2:16:52] and doing the math, some of these don't really quite add up.
[2:16:55] That might be 2005, not 2006.
[2:16:57] What we're adopting are these numbers up here.
[2:17:00] And these are just for presentation's sake.
[2:17:03] Thank you.
[2:17:04] Thank you.
[2:17:05] Any questions from council before I close the public hearing?
[2:17:12] Public hearing is not closed.
[2:17:15] Chris Tockett.
[2:17:16] I would move to place ordinance 3074 on the final title
[2:17:20] only by us as pension rules.
[2:17:22] Second.
[2:17:23] I have a motion on board by Chris Tockett,
[2:17:25] seconded by Rebecca Mills-Soyka.
[2:17:27] Anything further on that motion council?
[2:17:31] Leila Roquel, please.
[2:17:34] Rebecca Mills-Soyka.
[2:17:35] Yes.
[2:17:36] Suzanne Hawkins.
[2:17:37] Yes, John Berger.
[2:17:38] Yes.
[2:17:39] Jim Mun.
[2:17:40] Yes.
[2:17:41] Don Hall.
[2:17:42] Yes.
[2:17:43] Chris Tawkin.
[2:17:44] Yes.
[2:17:44] Motion passes six to zero.
[2:17:47] We'll be to the next item, which I true.
[2:17:49] I'm sorry you got to read.
[2:17:50] Thank you for that.
[2:17:52] In ordinance of the City Council of the City of Twin Falls, Idaho,
[2:17:56] amending Twin Falls City Code Section 101812 by increasing
[2:18:01] development impact fees.
[2:18:05] Council wishes.
[2:18:07] Move approval.
[2:18:09] second.
[2:18:10] We have a motion on the floor by Rebecca Mills, so I guess seconded by Sean Berger to
[2:18:15] move approval of Ordinance 374 as read anything further on that motion council.
[2:18:21] Sean Berger.
[2:18:22] I just want to echo a comment that Brad made as the development community worked closely
[2:18:28] with the city staff on this.
[2:18:30] I appreciate they were able to come to a balance.
[2:18:34] But another point he made when you look at the grand scheme of all those fees and taxes
[2:18:39] and the things that people like to grumble about.
[2:18:43] Hopefully we're finding a balance in there too of not taking the full tax increase and
[2:18:48] jacking these fees and trying to just throw money at issues and trying to work through those.
[2:18:54] So some of these do feel significant, particularly when you're looking at retail development at
[2:19:02] the dollar for it square foot, that's a big height.
[2:19:07] But hopefully with the balance in not increasing
[2:19:10] the property taxes we're able to still keep that vibrancy
[2:19:14] in the economy.
[2:19:15] Showering further, council.
[2:19:19] The a la roll call vote.
[2:19:22] Suzanne Hawkins?
[2:19:23] Yes.
[2:19:24] Sean Berger?
[2:19:25] Yes.
[2:19:26] Jim Un?
[2:19:26] Yes.
[2:19:27] Don Hall?
[2:19:28] Yes.
[2:19:29] Chris Talkington?
[2:19:29] Yes.
[2:19:30] But the bill's made down.
[2:19:31] Yes.
[2:19:32] Motion passes 6 to 0.
[2:19:35] We will move to the ordinance or the agenda item that I tried to do earlier request for a zoning title amendment amending city code sections
[2:19:43] 10-4 8.3 c regarding maximum building height in the c1 district
[2:19:51] 10-4-8.3 d1 regarding side and rear yard setbacks in the c1 district 10-4-13.3 c
[2:20:03] regarding additional building height in the OT district and 10-7-3 regarding
[2:20:12] approval process for requests for additional building height. Jonathan
[2:20:17] Spenlow you are on sir. Thank you Mr. Mayor members of the council. So I was
[2:20:24] pretty much just outlined everything that's gonna happen. I'm gonna go a little
[2:20:28] more detail on it though. Just a little bit but that's pretty much what we're
[2:20:32] here for. You approved Ordinance 2012 in 1981, which created zoning ordinance we
[2:20:39] use today. Zoning title amendments for building heights that was applied for and
[2:20:44] heard by the punning and zoning commission during public hearing February
[2:20:46] 12th in 2012. This amendment was forwarded to the City Council who held the public
[2:20:50] hearing on March 11th 2013. The City Council requested revisions be made to
[2:20:54] the title and that's what we've done. The basic of the request was initiated by
[2:20:58] the City Council on the basis that numerous applications that applied for an
[2:21:02] increase the 50 foot maximum building height as allowed in City Code 1073.
[2:21:06] That amendment went through as described earlier and during that public hearing
[2:21:11] the Council requests of the Division's to the amendment following three changes
[2:21:14] which I have tonight were made per those requests. The first request section changes
[2:21:21] two items in 1048 and that's in the C1 zone and just you may have it up here.
[2:21:25] The first one changes the building height up to 50 feet from 35, it goes up to 50 in the
[2:21:33] C1 zoning district.
[2:21:36] The second one changes the side and rear yard setbacks required under certain circumstances
[2:21:40] and that can be found here in the first change, which is D1A, eliminating this line, and then
[2:21:48] adding a D1B, which includes this paragraph where it details instances where a side and
[2:22:00] rear yard setback would be needed or required.
[2:22:04] The last section that has changed is the addition of building height, which can be approved
[2:22:09] in the OT zone, which is the old town district, and that will be increased up to 50 feet as
[2:22:15] well through those changes are in two different spots, one in the Old Town District which makes
[2:22:31] it so that except as provided by 1073 so they can go above 50 feet and then in changing 1073
[2:22:38] we add OT here and then we took out a bunch of language that was applied to Fire Springs
[2:22:44] Clerge Systems being waived by the Council based on recommendations. We felt like that
[2:22:50] is in there for certain reasons for the fire marshal to declare whether or not the apparatus
[2:22:55] was high enough, etc. etc. We want to take that out. So those codes have to be followed
[2:23:00] no matter what. This simply just allows the council to increase the building height in
[2:23:05] these separate zones CB C1 OT and 1 and M2. The only addition being the OT that is through
[2:23:12] a request for additional height following the public hearing process for zoning map amendments
[2:23:17] as described in the section.
[2:23:20] And that process will be two public hearings.
[2:23:25] First public hearing would be in front of the
[2:23:27] Planning and Zoning Commission for a recommendation,
[2:23:29] which would then be forwarded to the City Council
[2:23:31] for a final decision.
[2:23:33] So on July 8th, the Commission held the public hearing
[2:23:35] regarding the zoning title amendment.
[2:23:37] Upon the roll call vote, the Commission unanimously
[2:23:39] recommended approval of the amendment as presented.
[2:23:42] The City Council may grant the amendment as presented.
[2:23:44] It may recommend a modification of the amendment
[2:23:46] presented, which may require another public hearing, or the council may deny this amendment.
[2:23:54] Make sure that's when I'm finished, and that is all so there's no more.
[2:23:57] Very good.
[2:23:58] Do we have any questions?
[2:23:59] Yeah, are we doing all of this by one ordinance, change?
[2:24:06] The ordinance isn't here.
[2:24:07] Fritz didn't know it was done, Fritz finished it, and I didn't know it was finished, so it wasn't included.
[2:24:12] So again, we're just approving to bring back the ordinance, if we choose to do so.
[2:24:16] But it's all under the one umbrella though, okay.
[2:24:21] Rebecca Milsoica.
[2:24:22] Thank you, Eir.
[2:24:23] Thank you, Jonathan.
[2:24:24] Just two questions.
[2:24:26] Normally, we'd see a few of the requests in the manufacturing zones to waive the sprinkler
[2:24:34] system if it's not really useful.
[2:24:38] I think we saw a bean silo or something like that, and so would removing that portion would
[2:24:45] that still allow them to have a waiver of that system or now that system will be required
[2:24:51] no matter what, whether it's practical or not.
[2:24:54] Okay, so to answer that question,
[2:24:56] when we were talking about this,
[2:24:57] it was brought up that perhaps
[2:25:00] we should deal with it in the building code.
[2:25:03] We didn't want to have any part of the building code
[2:25:05] being waived.
[2:25:06] That was interesting that we had,
[2:25:08] if it can be allowed per the building code,
[2:25:11] then they don't need the fire spinger system.
[2:25:13] If it's required, we felt that that was a life safety type
[2:25:15] issue that we wanted it to continue to work
[2:25:18] through that building code and use that code
[2:25:20] to determine whether or not the fire sprinkler system.
[2:25:23] That's why we took it out.
[2:25:25] Okay, and so in the building, current building code then,
[2:25:28] is there still that opportunity?
[2:25:33] And fire code, yes.
[2:25:36] Travis?
[2:25:37] I think if you look at this, it says that,
[2:25:39] in the red language that's proposed to be removed,
[2:25:45] says providing all floors have a sprinkler system
[2:25:48] approved by the fire chief.
[2:25:49] In the example of the bean silo, you would be asking for additional height or additional
[2:25:55] setbacks requirements, right, if it had an approved or a fire sprinkler system, but in
[2:26:00] the example that you just provided, there's no need for that fire sprinkler system, but
[2:26:04] it would still be allowed.
[2:26:06] So what this does is it allows the international fire code and the international building code
[2:26:11] requirements to dictate and determine when those systems are needed.
[2:26:17] Okay, so I don't mean just to be clear so it the let's take the bean silo for example
[2:26:24] With these would not I for a waiver they wouldn't be one and we wouldn't have to come here
[2:26:30] Because if you could just do it. That's right. This time. Okay. That makes sense. Thank you
[2:26:37] I had one more question. Oh
[2:26:41] This came up at the planning and planning commission hearing and so I I thought that it was something
[2:26:47] good to consider the new setback for like front yards and rear yards, how does staff
[2:26:54] see that impacting the really narrow lots, like along Washington, for example, the ones
[2:26:59] that are kind of transitioning from residential uses to commercial retail uses, but they're
[2:27:06] really narrow lots.
[2:27:07] And so, you know, the commission, a couple members, had concern about that impact on the
[2:27:14] redevelopment of those lots because of course we want to encourage that
[2:27:18] redevelopment, that infill, I don't object to
[2:27:24] front yard or a side yard setback but how do we see it affecting
[2:27:30] maybe the more narrow lots on say Addison
[2:27:34] or Washington and probably in the future Eastland.
[2:27:38] So, a complicated question because there's a lot of variables that can happen
[2:27:43] with the clots in different areas.
[2:27:45] This, the side and rear yard setbacks
[2:27:47] would apply to the commercial zone,
[2:27:49] the commercial zone properties and used properties.
[2:27:53] They would have to meet the setback
[2:27:55] if they're adjacent to residential,
[2:27:57] either current future on the comp plan
[2:28:01] or they're all in there.
[2:28:04] Vacant properties that are potentially zone residential,
[2:28:07] they would have to have that 25 feet.
[2:28:10] As far as the narrow lots,
[2:28:11] if it's right next to a residential,
[2:28:14] they would have to meet that setback.
[2:28:17] I don't know how many there are,
[2:28:20] but I think it's my understanding
[2:28:22] that they would also not apply to anything
[2:28:23] this next to a street or an alley.
[2:28:26] That would not be adjacent to,
[2:28:28] so it's only if they're right next
[2:28:31] to the residential property.
[2:28:33] I don't know if that answers the question a bit,
[2:28:35] but there are some of those that might occur
[2:28:38] in some of those instances.
[2:28:39] They would need to meet the setback.
[2:28:42] There are ways to get variances for certain circumstances,
[2:28:46] but I don't want to get into that too much
[2:28:48] because there's just too many variables
[2:28:50] to kind of go through.
[2:28:50] Maybe they get more property.
[2:28:52] I think there's ways to deal with that.
[2:28:54] Okay, so you don't see it being prohibitive on those,
[2:29:00] maybe more narrow lots being redeveloped?
[2:29:02] I don't.
[2:29:04] I think we're trying to fix something
[2:29:06] that we saw a bigger issue,
[2:29:07] which was commercial properties going up to 50 feet now,
[2:29:11] 50 feet tall right next to a residential property without a setback and I would rather deal
[2:29:17] with that problem with maybe the commercial happening go through something more than to
[2:29:23] hurt the residential properties right next door because those occur quite a bit where
[2:29:28] you have residential right behind, say along blue lakes, have a residential that's right
[2:29:32] behind something on blue lakes and one of the present streets you could have a building
[2:29:37] Now, could have been 50 feet tall with no setback on the rear, and it could have been built right on the property line or close to that, and that could be detrimental to a lot of people in the city.
[2:29:50] Thank you.
[2:29:51] Suzanne Hawkins.
[2:29:53] Just to weigh in on that, I've always been pro-business pro-development, but just as an example, I know the Mi Pueblo on Washington.
[2:30:02] Those residents back behind there, their lives have been affected negatively in huge fashion.
[2:30:08] They don't get the sunshine in their yard now.
[2:30:10] They have the noise of delivery trucks early in the morning late at night.
[2:30:14] And if this was in place back then, it would have made that whole neighborhood much happier in the end.
[2:30:22] So I'm very supportive of this and I think even though it's a little tougher on commercial development, it is the right choice.
[2:30:31] I agree. It sounds like it protects those residents and I know some folks who live on that road too.
[2:30:36] Anything, any other questions before we open up the public
[2:30:38] testimony portion of the hearing this this evening,
[2:30:41] Council?
[2:30:44] Public testimony portion of the hearing is now open.
[2:30:47] Is there anyone from the community that would like to
[2:30:49] come forward and testify regarding this item?
[2:30:54] I don't see anybody rushing for the microphone,
[2:30:56] so at this time I'll close the public testimony portion,
[2:30:59] but leave it open for any further questions of Council.
[2:31:03] If we don't have any, then I will close the public hearing
[2:31:07] completely and turn it over to council deliberations.
[2:31:11] Public test, publicly carrying is now closed.
[2:31:15] Chris talking to.
[2:31:16] So what's the appropriate motion just to approve it?
[2:31:19] And ask for an ordinance to come back?
[2:31:22] Yeah, you would instruct staff to develop an ordinance
[2:31:26] based upon this or any subsequent changes or amendments
[2:31:31] that you would put towards the draft
[2:31:33] that has been placed before you.
[2:31:35] I would move to so authorized or so direct as city staff
[2:31:41] to prepare a zoning title amendment.
[2:31:45] Mending the city code section of 10, 4, 8, 3,
[2:31:47] C regarding maximum building heights
[2:31:49] in the C1 district 10, 4, 8, 3, D, 1,
[2:31:52] regarding side and rear yard setbacks.
[2:31:54] In the C1 district 10, 4, 13, 3, C regarding request
[2:31:58] for additional building height in the OT district
[2:32:01] and 10, 7, 3 regarding the approval process
[2:32:03] for a request for additional building height.
[2:32:07] Second.
[2:32:08] We have a motion on the floor by Chris Talkington,
[2:32:10] seconded by Suzanne Hawkins,
[2:32:12] and I am not going to read that again.
[2:32:14] It's been read 14 times tonight,
[2:32:16] anything further on that motion council.
[2:32:18] Rebecca, may I say?
[2:32:19] Thank you, Mayor.
[2:32:22] I'm still a little bit concerned
[2:32:24] with raising the building height to 50 feet.
[2:32:26] I mean, even with the setback, I think it,
[2:32:28] you know, it's probably a good idea,
[2:32:30] but I think a better way to provide input to the neighbors
[2:32:34] when you have increased building height,
[2:32:35] this is the process we have now.
[2:32:37] So I really don't have a concern about the process we have now.
[2:32:40] I mean, we've seen relatively few requests
[2:32:43] for height above 35 feet.
[2:32:45] And I think it's always a good process to come to council
[2:32:48] and get input from the people that are most closely affected
[2:32:53] by that change.
[2:32:54] And as staff stated, there's a lot of areas where
[2:32:58] in commercial property abuts right against residential.
[2:33:02] I'm not sure the setback is enough to compensate for the additional height.
[2:33:08] I think really the best process is the way that we do it now.
[2:33:14] And usually we can then determine whether it affects the neighbors, whether there's a
[2:33:18] practical matter, for example, the hotel that went in on Washington Street.
[2:33:25] The neighbors were able to come and say, yeah, we don't have a problem, we support this.
[2:33:29] That's the kind of thing that I want to hear, that I want to consider before increasing
[2:33:33] building height.
[2:33:34] And unfortunately, this ordinance changes that process and takes away that public input part
[2:33:41] of the process.
[2:33:42] So I will not be supporting this main motion.
[2:33:46] Anything from the council?
[2:33:48] Well, isn't this only for additional building height in the old town?
[2:33:51] Commercial, see one district, and old town.
[2:33:58] Anything from council?
[2:34:01] the aye.
[2:34:02] The roll call vote please.
[2:34:07] Sean Berger.
[2:34:08] Yes.
[2:34:09] Jim Munn.
[2:34:10] Yes.
[2:34:11] Don Hall.
[2:34:12] Yes.
[2:34:13] Chris Totti.
[2:34:14] Yes.
[2:34:15] Rebecca Melsweka.
[2:34:16] No.
[2:34:18] Suzanne Hawkins.
[2:34:19] Yes.
[2:34:20] Motion passes.
[2:34:21] 5 to 1.
[2:34:22] Last item hopefully on our agenda is a request for a zoning title amendment to delete Title 10,
[2:34:28] Chapter 10, Off Street Parking and Loading and Replaced with a new Title 10, Chapter 10,
[2:34:36] Street parking and loading Jonathan spend love again. Welcome. Thank you, Mr. Mayor's member of the council members of the council
[2:34:43] Suzanne also sent me a question about
[2:34:46] About these so I have an updated packet for you. How many trees died for that?
[2:34:58] Good
[2:35:01] Thank you
[2:35:02] goodness sakes
[2:35:07] But these are the same changes that we read over in our packet, right?
[2:35:15] So what I've done is identified everything in blue, hopefully everybody can see the blue.
[2:35:20] I was going to do red, but that just was too bright.
[2:35:23] The blue is the new stuff, black is the original, although it might be in a different location from previously.
[2:35:30] So what we've done is reconfigured the entire section so it reads a little bit differently, a little bit better,
[2:35:36] added some things.
[2:35:38] And what I have up on the screen is the exact same thing you have in your packet,
[2:35:44] which is a table showing the differences for the types of things we've done and changed.
[2:35:51] Basically what we have is that ordinance 2012 and 81 is when we change everything.
[2:35:56] I say that all the time, but that is really the code that we're working with.
[2:36:00] There have been two other changes to the parking code since then, and one in 2001 and another
[2:36:06] one in 2008.
[2:36:08] Both of those really only dealt with small changes.
[2:36:11] was CompactCar spaces that deleted the CompactCar space in 2001, and then they changed a multi-family
[2:36:19] parking requirement in 2008. Those are the only changes we've had in the parking code
[2:36:23] since 1981. So this is a big update. I'll hit the main points and we can kind of go over
[2:36:29] some things specifically. It's going to replace Title X, Chapter X in its entirety, the most
[2:36:35] Notable changes, previous code enumerated a total of 33 distinct uses.
[2:36:42] This code has 45 distinct uses.
[2:36:45] What we do is we use those uses to determine how many parking spaces you need.
[2:36:50] Previously, there were only 33 and we were slotting some uses into something that was
[2:36:55] similar.
[2:36:56] But we found that sometimes they really didn't act that similar.
[2:37:00] So we'd like to change that and bring them out, change them a little bit so they act differently.
[2:37:05] so they should be parked differently.
[2:37:07] The purpose behind these changes was the slotting process.
[2:37:11] One example was that came up.
[2:37:13] It was the restaurants were eating places.
[2:37:14] In the current code, it's denoted as eating places.
[2:37:18] These uses will see a potential increase.
[2:37:20] They will see an increase, actually,
[2:37:22] in required parking spaces.
[2:37:23] The proposed changes make a distinction
[2:37:25] between restaurants with a drive-through
[2:37:27] and those without.
[2:37:29] Restaurants without a drive-through act
[2:37:31] and operate inherently differently from those with one.
[2:37:34] So that is one change that is going to be a major point and I can go to that at the,
[2:37:39] okay, so the blue on the left is what's new, what's on the right and black is what we currently
[2:38:05] have in the code.
[2:38:09] Just to denote the restaurants, the new code section will basically put one's parking space
[2:38:14] for each 75 square feet of gross floor area for stand-alone buildings without a drive-through
[2:38:20] and one parking space for each 100 square feet of gross floor area for restaurants located
[2:38:25] within a multi-tenant building and for standalone buildings with a drive-thru.
[2:38:29] Outdoor seating and dining areas will be included in gross floor area calculations.
[2:38:33] Currently all we do for restaurants is one space per four seats or eight feet of bench.
[2:38:39] It's hard for us to do that especially when all they have to do is show it on the plan.
[2:38:46] We get the building plan, they show us seats, we count those seats, we assign parking spaces,
[2:38:52] We don't look at outside park, outside seating areas, which can be substantial in some spots,
[2:38:59] and there's nothing that says they can't bring in a new seat or more tables, more chairs,
[2:39:03] which is what we've found in some spots where they're under parked.
[2:39:09] And that doesn't account for anybody working at the restaurant.
[2:39:13] We wanted to bypass all of those variables and say 1 to 75, 1 to 100, some nice round
[2:39:20] numbers.
[2:39:22] I believe in your packets you're included with some businesses with the changes, parking
[2:39:28] comparison changes.
[2:39:30] That will not, we can't go back and assess those to increase their parking, those are
[2:39:35] already built, but that was simply as a, if they were to come today, the parking would
[2:39:40] be different.
[2:39:41] Or if there's a major addition, we would then assess for that addition at a certain amount.
[2:39:47] So those are some of the other notable changes.
[2:39:53] used for landscaping within parking lots.
[2:39:56] Many of the PUDs have this landscaping requirement.
[2:39:58] Basically, it's just a breakup to see a asphalt.
[2:40:01] The number we're looking at is any parking lot over 20 spaces will require that landscaping
[2:40:06] on the interior.
[2:40:07] That includes NCAP and middle landscape islands to break those up.
[2:40:13] There's quite a few businesses in town that currently do most of these forms.
[2:40:18] There's very few that would conform to what we currently have for the changes we're proposing.
[2:40:23] The best example I could come up with that I found was St. Luke's Hospital.
[2:40:27] They were the closest to actually matching what we are going to be having in our code.
[2:40:33] There's a few spaces where they may add an island, but for the most part, that parking
[2:40:38] lot that they have would be what you get with this code change, as far as NCAP and middle
[2:40:44] of the island type deals.
[2:40:50] So in conclusion on July 8th, 2014, Commission held a public hearing whereby there was no
[2:40:54] public comment.
[2:40:55] The Commission unanimously voted to recommend adoption of the amendments as presented.
[2:41:01] The Council may grant the amendments as presented.
[2:41:03] It may recommend a modification of the amendment presented, which may require another public
[2:41:07] hearing.
[2:41:08] Or the Council may deny the amendment.
[2:41:10] I will stand for any questions, it's brief in my report, but I know there's a lot of items
[2:41:16] through there that we can discuss.
[2:41:17] Thank you, John, then do we have any questions? I see no questions John
[2:41:26] So at this point I'm going to open up the public testimony portion of tonight's hearing and and allow anyone from the public to come forward
[2:41:35] I see no one coming forward, so I'll close the public testimony portion of the hearing
[2:41:42] And do we have any other questions before I close the public hearing?
[2:41:47] Council the public hearing is now closed
[2:41:52] I'll leave it to
[2:41:54] Council for their deliberations and our emotions keeping in mind that we do not have an ordinance in front of us
[2:42:01] This is just to bring one Chris talking
[2:42:04] Jonathan you might just
[2:42:08] In our
[2:42:10] Prior is out in zodiac or whatever we call our group
[2:42:14] We always wanted to have assurance that we were not going out on a limb
[2:42:18] with untested, untried or unreasonable expectations.
[2:42:24] I think you've done some research that shows
[2:42:26] that these standards are not only not onerous,
[2:42:30] but are often duplicated from other towns.
[2:42:34] And in some areas, I think we've actually decreased
[2:42:37] the requirements.
[2:42:38] Could you kind of give us an overview on that?
[2:42:40] Open up the public hearing again
[2:42:43] since we're asking staff questions.
[2:42:45] So, Jonathan.
[2:42:46] So we looked at four or five jurisdictions within Idaho.
[2:42:50] We stuck with the Idaho.
[2:42:52] We did look at Meridian, Pocatello, Idaho Falls, Boise,
[2:42:57] and Caldwell, I believe.
[2:43:01] Most of these are similar.
[2:43:03] We didn't want to duplicate problems that they may have had,
[2:43:07] but we believe that these are pretty much in line
[2:43:09] with what people have done.
[2:43:11] I know that the whole person-per-seat thing
[2:43:16] is really difficult to enforce after the fact,
[2:43:19] or even to check after the fact.
[2:43:22] The square footage is much more reliable.
[2:43:24] In a lot of these cases, we've actually made them
[2:43:27] a little bit more consistent.
[2:43:28] You'll see one to 250 square feet on a lot of items.
[2:43:32] That's a common theme that we got as feedback
[2:43:35] from developers for office, retail, those types of things.
[2:43:39] They say they don't build lower than that,
[2:43:42] that their customers require parking,
[2:43:44] and that's what they build too.
[2:43:45] So we figured that was a good number.
[2:43:49] Hopefully that answers most of your question.
[2:43:51] I didn't include all those because that would have been an even bigger
[2:43:54] packer for you killing trees and stuff.
[2:43:56] These numbers did not come out of the air.
[2:43:58] That's the point.
[2:44:01] Do we have any further questions for staff?
[2:44:05] Close the public hearing again and turn it over to staff or to
[2:44:09] Council for deliberations and emotion.
[2:44:14] Rebecca, I'm also.
[2:44:15] All right. Well, no one's jumping at the chance.
[2:44:17] So to add to Councilman talking to this question,
[2:44:23] Azalees on to the P&Z, and this came through
[2:44:26] the P&Z Commission in their new process
[2:44:28] of looking at code amendments.
[2:44:32] The staff really looked at best practices,
[2:44:35] current best practices, and this is really
[2:44:37] what they came up with, and so all of the things
[2:44:40] that Jonathan described, I think, are pretty accurate
[2:44:43] as far as it being more reliable and consistent.
[2:44:46] So, I think it's an improvement on our current code.
[2:44:50] And I will move approval of the request
[2:44:53] for zoning title amendment to delete Title 10,
[2:44:56] Chapter 10, Off Street Parking and Loading,
[2:44:59] and replace with a new Title 10, Chapter 10,
[2:45:01] Off Street Parking and Loading.
[2:45:03] And that's to bring the ordinance next week.
[2:45:05] And to bring the ordinance next week.
[2:45:09] Second.
[2:45:10] We have a motion on the floor by Rebecca Mills-Soyka,
[2:45:13] seconded by Suzanne Hawkins.
[2:45:15] Anything further on that motion council?
[2:45:20] We either roll call vote.
[2:45:25] Yes.
[2:45:26] John Hall?
[2:45:29] Yes.
[2:45:30] Yes.
[2:45:31] Rebecca Mills-Mica?
[2:45:33] Yes.
[2:45:34] Suzanne Hawkins?
[2:45:35] Yes.
[2:45:36] Sean Berringer?
[2:45:37] Yes.
[2:45:39] Motion passes six to zero.
[2:45:42] Unless there's anything further from council, I say we adjourned.
[2:45:49] We are adjourned.
