Oversight Archive: City Council meeting, 2014-09-15, recording 1 (started 17:00)
Machine transcript (faster-whisper base.en), not checked word for word; the Pledge of Allegiance is shown in its standard wording. The recording is the record.
Times are time into the recording. Passages with private details are muted in the audio and marked here.
The audio on the page below was re-encoded by software from the video the agency posted. Check any passage against
that audio before relying on it.
Page: https://oversightarchive.org/twin-falls-id/meetings/2014-09-15/

[0:10:18] I'd like to call the meeting of the Twin Falls City Council to order. It is September 15th, 2014.
[0:10:24] Those of you wishing to join us, would you please rise for the Pledge of Allegiance?
[0:10:28] I pledge allegiance to the Flag of the United States of America, and to the Republic for which it stands, one Nation under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all.
[0:10:44] I'd like to welcome everyone to the City Council meeting this evening.
[0:10:49] We do have a quorum of the city council.
[0:10:52] All seven members are present this evening.
[0:10:54] Mitch Humble, who is our acting city manager.
[0:10:58] Do we have any amendments to our agenda?
[0:11:00] You don't have any amendments,
[0:11:03] but I just want to make sure you all got the copy
[0:11:04] of the amended minutes for the agenda tonight.
[0:11:07] I did, did everyone else have a chance to take a look at that?
[0:11:10] I think there are just some minor changes in there.
[0:11:13] Thank you.
[0:11:13] So we have no amendments.
[0:11:16] We have no proclamations at this point.
[0:11:18] If there's anyone from the public that would like to address the council, we're opening
[0:11:21] it up at the beginning for the council now.
[0:11:24] Please come forward.
[0:11:25] No one's rushing for the podium, so we will move on to the consent council.
[0:11:30] Now turn that off to council wishes.
[0:11:32] Greg Lanting.
[0:11:33] I'd like to remove item two.
[0:11:34] I'm looking to say count.
[0:11:35] Okay.
[0:11:36] That's second.
[0:11:37] We have motion to remove item number two by Greg Lanting, seconded by Chris Talkington.
[0:11:48] Anything further on that motion council?
[0:11:50] We had a second.
[0:11:51] So we have a roll call vote.
[0:11:54] Suzanne Hawkins?
[0:11:55] Yes.
[0:11:56] Jim Young?
[0:11:57] Yes.
[0:11:58] Sean Berriger?
[0:11:59] Yes.
[0:12:00] Chris Tawkington?
[0:12:01] Yes.
[0:12:02] Greg Lanthine?
[0:12:03] Yes.
[0:12:04] Rebecca Milsoiket?
[0:12:05] Yes.
[0:12:06] Motion passes.
[0:12:07] Seven to zero.
[0:12:08] New passage of consent calendar.
[0:12:09] We have a motion to pass the remaining portion of the consent calendar by Chris Tawkington.
[0:12:13] Do we have a second?
[0:12:14] Second.
[0:12:15] Motion on the floor by Chris Tawkington, seconded by Sean Berriger.
[0:12:18] Anything further on that motion?
[0:12:19] Council the island roll call vote
[0:12:23] please Jim on yes Sean Baraker yes yes
[0:12:26] talking yes Greg Lansing yes Don Hall yes
[0:12:30] Rebecca milsway yes Suzanne Hawkins yes
[0:12:34] motion passes seven to zero Greg landing
[0:12:37] yes Troy this my question isn't
[0:12:51] necessarily exactly drew me into this
[0:12:53] property but and and correct me if I'm
[0:12:58] wrong on this property this property we're
[0:12:59] We're not requiring a bond or anything like that.
[0:13:03] We're taking in lieu of the sidewalk.
[0:13:06] We're taking the handicap ramps.
[0:13:09] And then so if there ever is a sidewalk in this area
[0:13:13] in the future, it will be the city responsibility
[0:13:16] or clear that up for me.
[0:13:18] So the requirements of planning, sorry,
[0:13:22] required this property to install a sidewalk
[0:13:24] across its property.
[0:13:27] When we went for the deferral,
[0:13:29] We were asked by the owners to defer the construction of a sidewalk due to some trees in the area.
[0:13:35] I think your agenda items showed some of those trees there.
[0:13:42] You can see the roots.
[0:13:43] This is the carbon gutter that was previously installed on the tree, so I'm pretty proud
[0:13:47] of it.
[0:13:48] In constructing a sidewalk, all these trees will die in this.
[0:13:52] The owners came to us and asked, can we defer this until the trees progressed to a point?
[0:13:57] And we usually don't do that, but the neighborhood is really supporting these people and love
[0:14:02] the trees and love the isolation it gives us farm ground.
[0:14:04] And in fact, they brought me pictures from the 60s and it shows us real trees in there.
[0:14:09] So in a tree city, we thought we would try to accommodate that.
[0:14:14] And so Jackie kind of came up with the idea that it's really the problem with this is
[0:14:18] as people try to maneuver around this property, their sidewalk on both sides of this, to the
[0:14:26] south and to the north, and what they're missing is so really what they need.
[0:14:29] an option here. And so what she proposed was provided on the route. And by putting in two
[0:14:34] ADA property or ramps, pedestrians can either, you know, move down. I imagine most people would
[0:14:40] stay in the roadway and then come back up on the sidewalk here. Or they can cross and use the
[0:14:44] sidewalk on the other side of the street. So there was a route available. So that's why she was
[0:14:51] opposed to deferral in this case. And the neighbor, the owners are here tonight and they could speak
[0:14:58] to it as well, but we're kind of in support of a deferral
[0:15:02] across its property at this time.
[0:15:03] And so now I have a little more of a general question.
[0:15:05] When we grant these deferrals, and I know
[0:15:10] Councilor Percine-Slic is this, is the pastor maybe
[0:15:12] as Council was talking about, do we have a performance bond?
[0:15:17] Or what do we have that will guarantee us
[0:15:19] that at some point in the future that sidewalk,
[0:15:21] when say these trees are past their prime,
[0:15:24] and it's time to take them out anyway,
[0:15:26] that we will get that sidewalk.
[0:15:28] And then another piece of property that has concerned me greatly is the portion of Washington Street North that's
[0:15:36] North of pole line where the sidewalk ends up going nowhere and you have all those condos along there with different things.
[0:15:46] There's no sidewalk.
[0:15:47] There's no, I don't even think there's getter.
[0:15:50] There's nothing there and we have sidewalk on both sides, but nowhere we can go there because apparently we didn't have what we needed
[0:15:56] at the time to guarantee they would have to put that in
[0:15:59] when sidewalks did show up.
[0:16:01] And so how do we know we'll get this sidewalk
[0:16:04] at some point on this property as well as others?
[0:16:07] Throughout time.
[0:16:08] So we don't have a situation like that one.
[0:16:09] So we do have the owner sign a defer agreement.
[0:16:12] This is something that's recorded against the property.
[0:16:14] So it did actually, essentially,
[0:16:16] if Lena gets the property,
[0:16:18] it shows up in all the record documents
[0:16:20] and the warranties on their property.
[0:16:23] In order to force it,
[0:16:25] I guess we would go to them and ask them first,
[0:16:27] and if they chose not to,
[0:16:28] then I believe Fritz would correct me if I'm wrong,
[0:16:31] with that you can actually force action on that,
[0:16:35] but it's a matter of suing, essentially.
[0:16:39] Okay, so I'm bringing it back to the other
[0:16:42] piece of property that I mean,
[0:16:43] I don't really have a problem with this one.
[0:16:45] I will be voting yes for this one,
[0:16:46] but my question is, I apologize if I'm fine.
[0:16:50] No, no, you can, my concern is that,
[0:16:53] Do we not have that possibility on North Washington there,
[0:16:57] or what did we do wrong there that we need to make sure
[0:16:59] we don't do the future, yes it'd be my thought?
[0:17:02] That came before, I actually was a point here,
[0:17:05] so I can't actually answer what happened there,
[0:17:07] and I'm guessing they probably just missed it.
[0:17:09] It had been a planning process,
[0:17:11] and I don't know how that was originally platted
[0:17:13] if it's individual law, it's a one ownership.
[0:17:16] If it was one ownership of townhouses,
[0:17:18] then they wouldn't be required as to widen that roadway
[0:17:22] do those improvements. Again, a lot of that was developed at the time, so I wonder if they
[0:17:26] just, you know, sent through. But in these cases, we do, we do put these
[0:17:31] deferrals in. We actually have a records keeping now. And once we get so many on the
[0:17:35] street, we'll come before the council and see what we would like to process these.
[0:17:39] Thank you, Troy. Chris, talking? Well, I used to live in the house just below the
[0:17:45] earth where the Google and the earth come together there. And actually before that
[0:17:49] that Colesack punched through, it was just a circle ending here, where you see the half.
[0:17:54] And in those trees, truly are a treasure, not only just for the immediate neighbors and
[0:17:59] the property owner, but for people walking.
[0:18:03] It makes a very green oasis that as long as it's a deferral agreement, I think that
[0:18:09] we're all in game by not putting in 150 feet of concrete and destroying 20 healthy trees.
[0:18:16] concern is what sort of action might trigger that deferral agreement and have you given
[0:18:22] any thought to it? I have a couple ideas but I wonder if deferral until when?
[0:18:30] So the owners actually requested a time when an arbiterist would come and say that these
[0:18:36] aren't healthy. Well, one or all of them or what percent?
[0:18:40] I don't know, I don't know.
[0:18:42] Okay.
[0:18:44] I would say.
[0:18:45] Yeah, I read that, that sounds reasonable.
[0:18:48] I also think perhaps that the property changes hands against it should be reviewed.
[0:18:53] But I'm concerned that one tree is healthy out of all twenty or thirty, probably past
[0:18:59] time for that deferral agreement to be activated.
[0:19:02] There is, I noticed what I was saying, the city engineer always has the opportunity to
[0:19:07] force something like that, say, upon city engineer.
[0:19:10] we would never try to force an owner into it,
[0:19:13] but if it got to where it was one tree,
[0:19:14] I'm sure we would approach it and say,
[0:19:15] all right, this is the entries at about this time.
[0:19:18] What, Fritz, would the property exchange,
[0:19:21] if it were sold with that trigger,
[0:19:22] the deferral agreement to come out,
[0:19:24] or would the language have to employ the?
[0:19:28] No, you should have the language in your packet
[0:19:30] of the deferral agreement.
[0:19:33] The deferral is a telematured tree
[0:19:35] whose root system's interferes with the construction
[0:19:38] of the proposed sidewalk along Lena drive died
[0:19:42] or are no longer healthy and require removal.
[0:19:47] Again, is that one or all the trees and who's opinion?
[0:19:52] Well, honestly, the mature trees whose root systems
[0:19:56] interfere with the construction of the proposed sidewalk
[0:19:59] is probably there already.
[0:20:06] So it's going to be after the discretion of the city
[0:20:08] engineer when they, I mean, it's clearly
[0:20:10] we're going to be able to prove that because I think you
[0:20:13] look at the photos, you can see that right now.
[0:20:16] There's like no way they can construct that sidewalk
[0:20:20] without interfering with those routes, so.
[0:20:22] Sure.
[0:20:23] So I wouldn't worry about that fight.
[0:20:26] It's gonna, again, it's gonna be up to the discretion
[0:20:29] of when the.
[0:20:30] So the language we have and how.
[0:20:32] It's gonna cover you because I,
[0:20:33] my opinion, you have the conditions virtually already
[0:20:36] for the city engineer to call it.
[0:20:39] Thank you for it.
[0:20:40] We're back in Melsoica.
[0:20:41] Thank you, Mayor.
[0:20:43] I just have a quick follow-up legal question for Fritz.
[0:20:46] The approval process states that the section of city code
[0:20:49] says that the city engineer made defer construction
[0:20:52] if the improvement would create a traffic hazard
[0:20:54] or an unusual drainage problem.
[0:20:57] And I don't have a problem with the request,
[0:21:01] but I was just wondering if we're covered legally
[0:21:03] because this doesn't seem to fit under either of those.
[0:21:06] There isn't anyone that can complain about it.
[0:21:12] There's no one, there is no person
[0:21:14] that can bring a complaint saying you should not have
[0:21:17] deferred this.
[0:21:19] Even other people who have to put in their sidewalks,
[0:21:22] regardless of trees and things, to complain that they're not
[0:21:27] being treated equally, they would have to prove that they
[0:21:30] are being treated differently than everyone else.
[0:21:33] OK.
[0:21:33] Well, I'm just curious if we have the legal power to do it,
[0:21:36] since it's kind of specific, the circumstances under which
[0:21:39] you can waive it or defer it.
[0:21:43] So you're sort of asking the question,
[0:21:49] do we legally have the authority to defer?
[0:21:52] Correct, yeah, I'm just curious, I guess I would say
[0:21:56] just generally that city council has the authority
[0:21:59] by the power that they have to tell the city and the area,
[0:22:03] you know, we really don't want this sidewalk bill yet.
[0:22:06] Okay, okay, just wanted to check, thank you.
[0:22:10] Council, do we have Jim Monck?
[0:22:13] I would move to approve this sidewalk to Furlough
[0:22:15] for Lingville's site revision.
[0:22:17] Second.
[0:22:18] I have a motion on floor by Jim Mon seconded by Greg Manti.
[0:22:21] I just wanted to weigh in real quickly.
[0:22:22] That is my neighborhood.
[0:22:24] We walked through there quite often.
[0:22:25] I purposely did not walk through there
[0:22:28] since it's been on the agenda though,
[0:22:29] because I know better than that.
[0:22:31] But it is.
[0:22:32] Chris hit it on the head.
[0:22:33] Those are viable trees.
[0:22:34] It makes the neighborhood.
[0:22:35] There's actually been neighbors that have contacted the city.
[0:22:38] Same, please don't take these out,
[0:22:40] because it is visually pleasing.
[0:22:43] It provides the shade, and it makes sense.
[0:22:45] This is for all makes sense to me.
[0:22:47] So with that, roll call vote.
[0:22:50] Leanna, please.
[0:22:53] Sean Berriger.
[0:22:54] Yes.
[0:22:55] Chris Tocquenten.
[0:22:56] Yes.
[0:22:56] Gray Blanton.
[0:22:57] Yes.
[0:22:58] Don Hall.
[0:22:59] Yes.
[0:23:00] Rebecca Nelsuenka.
[0:23:01] Yes.
[0:23:02] Suzanne Hawkins.
[0:23:03] Yes.
[0:23:03] Jim
[0:23:10] Yes. Motion passes seven to zero. Moving on to items for consideration. The first item is, and you folks don't need to have, you don't have to stay now.
[0:23:12] Okay. Sometimes people feel like they're obligated afterwards.
[0:23:17] Items for consideration, quest to consider the purchase of a Greco 390 grind laser for the
[0:23:24] street department and we have John Caten.
[0:23:27] Thank you, Mayor and Council.
[0:23:37] Put a picture of the grinder here but I wanted to first begin with the fact that this is an
[0:23:44] un-budgeted request for expense.
[0:23:48] And normally we try not to do that.
[0:23:52] So I know you're wondering why it's coming up now,
[0:23:55] why we can't budget for it, and the answer is we can't.
[0:23:58] We can budget for it, and we can wait.
[0:24:01] Part of the reason it didn't show up in our long-term plan
[0:24:04] as Dean has been, for a long time now,
[0:24:07] he's been looking for a viable option that works well.
[0:24:10] That is cost effective, and really didn't have one
[0:24:12] until we got this demonstration here recently this year.
[0:24:15] So it caught our attention.
[0:24:19] I really wish I could show you some video,
[0:24:21] but this is showing a writing walk behind Grinder,
[0:24:29] and we would be purchasing just the front end of that.
[0:24:49] So we would be buying just this portion.
[0:24:53] The airport owns, has a piece of equipment
[0:24:55] that uses that self-propelled portion.
[0:24:59] And so it's fully interchangeable.
[0:25:01] So in the event that we would need it, we could use it.
[0:25:07] But it works kind of like a rototailer.
[0:25:09] You just walk behind it and it pulls forward.
[0:25:12] And it grinds as fast as you can walk.
[0:25:15] It's fairly simple.
[0:25:18] Again, it's cost effective.
[0:25:19] In the past, you guys have seen what we've
[0:25:21] done with paint markings.
[0:25:23] Sometimes we leave them and hope that they'll wear away.
[0:25:28] and other times we tried to sand blast them.
[0:25:31] And in the past, Road Work Ahead used to rent equipment
[0:25:35] that kind of worked, but it's maintenance
[0:25:40] and intensive equipment, and it was getting beat up,
[0:25:42] and so they quit renting it.
[0:25:45] Also, we're not aware of any contractors locally
[0:25:48] that do this.
[0:25:51] We haven't had success contracting it out.
[0:25:54] So again, we can wait.
[0:25:58] We have several projects.
[0:26:00] I'm sure you guys are aware of these on Eastland
[0:26:02] between City and Falls.
[0:26:04] There's a skip line that needs to be obliterated right
[0:26:06] near that area as the filer and Eastland intersection
[0:26:10] has some arrows that are a little confusing
[0:26:12] because we've tried to obliterate them,
[0:26:14] but they're still there.
[0:26:18] Fillmore North College has some work.
[0:26:21] Addison, Addison near Kmart, and Cara Jean Addison for the signal this year, but we're going to
[0:26:29] have to remove some marks there.
[0:26:31] So we do have a use for it in this upcoming budget year.
[0:26:34] We have about approximately $150,000 left unspentant and seal code this year, which we're
[0:26:43] looking at potential projects, either additional mail-in overlays or maybe extending Eastland.
[0:26:49] We're going to get together so we can see what we can do.
[0:26:53] But we would like to use about $10,275 to purchase this piece of equipment this year.
[0:27:03] With that being said, if there's any questions.
[0:27:05] There are questions, but don't forget the eight cents.
[0:27:08] And the eight cents.
[0:27:09] Chris Donner.
[0:27:10] Donner, have we seen this in operation?
[0:27:13] We have.
[0:27:14] I'm wondering anything that grinds, I think, would probably have a lateral throw pattern,
[0:27:18] is it protected so we don't get complaints about damaging car paint jobs or rocks and
[0:27:25] eyes.
[0:27:26] I mean, is it a fairly safe contraption to operate?
[0:27:28] Good question, Chris.
[0:27:29] Thank you.
[0:27:30] Yeah, Dean and I just talked about that.
[0:27:31] I actually didn't get to witness the demo, but Dean just explained to me, and he's here
[0:27:35] if you want.
[0:27:36] He explained to me that part of the reason they like this is it is clean, cleaner than
[0:27:42] other grinders.
[0:27:43] There's the swath that it cuts as a box that drops down and contains most of it.
[0:27:48] And so you get to the end of your mill, you lift it, and there's the degree.
[0:27:52] So it doesn't contain it 100 percent, but it's fairly clean.
[0:27:55] Thank you.
[0:27:57] Jim.
[0:27:58] Thank you, Mayor.
[0:27:59] John, you indicated in your staff report that prior attempts to do obliteration has been
[0:28:04] hit and miss and not very effective.
[0:28:05] Have you done an analysis to see what kind of soft costs could be saved in this regard?
[0:28:10] You know, I have not looked at how much striping and milling we've done.
[0:28:21] To me, honestly, this is a safety issue.
[0:28:23] I know, especially at night or when it rains,
[0:28:26] it's really, on some of our roads,
[0:28:28] really difficult to figure out which lane is which lane
[0:28:31] when we have multiple lanes that have been striped.
[0:28:33] So I think it's, for me, it's what money well spent
[0:28:37] for the safety of our community.
[0:28:40] Council wishes.
[0:28:42] Great landing.
[0:28:43] What else is in?
[0:28:44] Suzanne Hopkins.
[0:28:45] Okay, I would move approval of the purchase.
[0:28:49] Let me get the name right.
[0:28:50] The great go 390 grind laser in the amount of 10,2708 and that we allow the money to come out of the silcoed fund and go ahead and purchase it.
[0:29:11] Second.
[0:29:12] Motion on 4-5.
[0:29:13] Second.
[0:29:14] Second by Greg Lanting.
[0:29:15] As stated.
[0:29:16] Anything further on that motion council?
[0:29:18] The aye.
[0:29:20] The roll call vote, please.
[0:29:21] First talking to Greg Lanting.
[0:29:23] Yes.
[0:29:24] John Hall.
[0:29:25] Yes.
[0:29:26] Rebecca Mille-Suecka.
[0:29:27] Yes.
[0:29:28] Susan Hawkins.
[0:29:29] Yes.
[0:29:30] Jim Young.
[0:29:31] Yes.
[0:29:32] Sean Berriger.
[0:29:33] Yes.
[0:29:34] Motion passes 7-0.
[0:29:35] Thank you, John.
[0:29:36] Next item on the agenda is a request to approve the scope of work in contract with JUB engineers
[0:29:41] to develop a master plan for Parks and Recreation. Dennis Boyer, welcome.
[0:29:46] Thank you, Mayor and Council. It's a pleasure to be here tonight. Before you, I have a proposed
[0:29:51] scope of work and fee from JUB engineers to develop a Parks and Recreation master plan for the city.
[0:29:58] As you know last month, the Council did authorize staff to start negotiating with JUB
[0:30:03] on this whole scope of work and a fee that's negotiated with that. Staff met with them,
[0:30:09] We kind of discussed the process, you know, looked at a timeline, and they came back with us,
[0:30:15] their first draft of this post-scope of work.
[0:30:19] Staff internally, mostly Mitch and I, reviewed the original scope of work, and we noticed
[0:30:25] that work looked like we were missing a couple of public meetings, so we requested back to
[0:30:29] JUV to add a couple of public meetings into their scope of work.
[0:30:34] We got back to the scope of work at that time that recently the fee that the JUB proposed.
[0:30:41] Let me step back a little bit.
[0:30:43] I do have Mark Holson with JUB is in the audience to ask some questions for JUB is easier to answer those questions.
[0:30:51] Sorry about that.
[0:30:52] But going back is that we looked at the original scope of work.
[0:30:57] The first one they gave back to us and their fee was associated with $50,000.
[0:31:02] When we staff asked for additional public input,
[0:31:06] those public meetings, they said that will cost additional dollars.
[0:31:10] So that's why that scope of work right now is that $52,000.
[0:31:13] So I just want to explain the difference on that, because internally,
[0:31:16] staff thought we'd have to have a couple additional public meetings input on that.
[0:31:20] So with that scope of work, we presented that to the Parks and Recreation Commission.
[0:31:27] They had discussion on that, really a good discussion.
[0:31:29] And the main discussion was, how is that going to affect the time schedule?
[0:31:35] Previously when JUB presented to the commission, when we had those four presentations for the
[0:31:40] company, you know, JUB had a time schedule which was starting August, September, that
[0:31:46] was original time frame.
[0:31:47] But so we asked them to come back and do a new time line, and that's what I handed out
[0:31:52] to you before the meeting, and that's what is presented on the overhead right now, is that
[0:31:56] they're a new proposed time schedule.
[0:31:59] And one of the reasons why we're looking at, you know, a six-month process, and that's
[0:32:02] what typically, you know, a master plan could take something for this size, is April, of
[0:32:08] course, is budgeting time.
[0:32:10] So we would like to, you know, we don't know if this is going to change anything from our
[0:32:13] long-term plan, because we have our five-year long-term plan that city staff is sitting on
[0:32:17] that, and also we have an idea of kind of what's upcoming in our budget.
[0:32:21] So we don't know if this might change anything on a master plan, but if we thought if it could,
[0:32:25] like to be able to have that, you know, maybe propose the next year's budget.
[0:32:29] So it's the commission that, like I said, after a discussion they unanimously recommend to the
[0:32:32] council to approve the scope of work and the new fee with additional of this proposed project
[0:32:39] schedule.
[0:32:40] Excuse me.
[0:32:41] In addition to the scope and work, the commission talked about a steering committee, you know,
[0:32:47] because we kind of discussed, you know, should the steering committee be just the Parks and
[0:32:51] Recreation Commission, but we felt like it would be best to have members from the commission
[0:32:54] also members from the general public at large and also staff members beyond that steering committee.
[0:33:01] We really look at the steering committee will do the bulk of the work for this if we have to do a lot of research on items.
[0:33:08] We believe the steering committee will be doing the bulk of the work for this master plan.
[0:33:13] So the commission also recommend to the city council to formalize that steering committee approximately nine to twelve members
[0:33:20] that consist of members from the commission, city staff, and the public at large.
[0:33:25] And before you do have the proposed schedule there, so I'm available for questions for you now,
[0:33:31] or also, like I said, Mark, from GUBE is available for questions.
[0:33:34] Thank you, Dennis. Chris, talking to me.
[0:33:36] Dennis, it looks like a substantial amount of the information for the proposed schedule is going to require
[0:33:43] gathering, correlating, prioritizing, discussing information available already.
[0:33:54] So does the city staff have that availability to help?
[0:33:58] And if so, why can't or shouldn't we just do it on our own?
[0:34:02] Or does it take kind of something objective perspective that doesn't caught up in the day-to-day things?
[0:34:08] He said already receiving his answer.
[0:34:10] Yes, I can say you know that exactly because in my mind, I can say what I believe the community
[0:34:16] want, but that's just only one person's opinion. Yes, I have 37 years experience in
[0:34:20] personal operation, but I'm not always right. But can we provide, for instance, all the GIS
[0:34:26] information required in aerial photography? Is that all pretty much in hand? We have a
[0:34:31] lot of this stuff in hand, you know, I have a lot of information when we met with them
[0:34:34] earlier, I did have a lot of information that I emailed them about our existing inventory
[0:34:39] where we have long term I see where, you know, right now,
[0:34:42] if someone asks me, you know, okay, what's the information
[0:34:45] about, I'll say, Farm and Park, okay, what year
[0:34:47] was developed, you know, actually, you know,
[0:34:49] when were the, you know, I said, okay, I can give you that,
[0:34:51] probably top of my head, okay, when were the restrooms put in?
[0:34:54] Well, we have three of them there.
[0:34:55] I can dig them out of this file over here, you know,
[0:34:59] when was this done, when was this done, you know,
[0:35:01] they're all kind of information kind of scattered.
[0:35:03] Eventually with the GIS system, I imagine us that someday
[0:35:06] We'll be able to just click on our GSI map, click on Harmon Park, and then click on restrooms
[0:35:11] of the three restrooms there when they're built, when they're kind of proposed replacement,
[0:35:15] when the sidewalks were put in, when the irrigation system is modified, you know, somewhere you
[0:35:19] have everything at your fingers tip instead of going over to my file cabinet or picking
[0:35:25] my brain occasionally about where stuff is.
[0:35:28] So I really believe that this, we need that outside expertise to help us develop this.
[0:35:34] Okay, thank you. And I just had one question concerning the inventory. Since I lived in my place, 2003, we've had that park land dedicated to the city to the north essentially east of Home Depot somewhere in that undeveloped area. That there's no way that's triggered until that land is plotted and developed or initial phases or what is the story on that.
[0:36:04] Do we still have claims to the court?
[0:36:07] I think that was like in the 94, 95, before I became director, but I remember that I think
[0:36:12] that developer guaranteed that he or she would dedicate a three, I think remember three acre
[0:36:19] part to the city of one seat for their development.
[0:36:22] Is that possible?
[0:36:23] You did research the verify that that legality is still in place?
[0:36:28] Yes, I can.
[0:36:29] Thank you.
[0:36:30] Rebecca Milsock.
[0:36:31] Thank you, Mayor.
[0:36:32] just a couple of questions. Overall I think the plan looks very thorough and it looks like
[0:36:41] a good plan. Our strategic plan has a lot to say about the parks and rec systems so it's
[0:36:47] not really said specifically but will they be using the strategic plan to kind of form
[0:36:53] their analysis?
[0:36:54] Yes, that's what some of the documents we talked about with them is our strategic plan
[0:36:59] Also our comprehensive plan.
[0:37:01] Does this master plan will eventually replace
[0:37:04] or existing comprehensive plans?
[0:37:06] So that's why one of the meetings
[0:37:07] that extra public meeting was through the planning
[0:37:11] and zoning commission because this has to be adopted
[0:37:13] by the planning zone because it will replace our current chapter
[0:37:16] nine, I think it's chapter nine
[0:37:18] of our comprehensive plan is Parks, Recreation, and Trails.
[0:37:20] So this is will replace that also.
[0:37:23] We'll look at that should you plan that we have, yes?
[0:37:26] Great, thank you.
[0:37:27] Just a couple more questions.
[0:37:30] Also, the interviews and the surveys,
[0:37:33] especially using the 3P visual system,
[0:37:36] sounds like a really good plan to get a lot of public input.
[0:37:40] When they talk about the stakeholder interviews,
[0:37:42] a couple, I'm sure that's not an exhaustive list,
[0:37:45] but a couple of groups that I thought of were the cyclists
[0:37:50] kind of led by Art Hogue in the Seastrums
[0:37:52] and also the Canyon Rim Preservation folks.
[0:37:57] They also might be stakeholders that would want to participate.
[0:38:01] Is there any preservation for the Magic Valley Development and Incident Committee?
[0:38:04] No, I think it was the Canyon Rim.
[0:38:07] Do you remember what they were called?
[0:38:09] I know who you're talking about.
[0:38:10] Yeah, but they have a lot to do with the trails and development of the Canyon Rim.
[0:38:16] The only other question is that I have is the Steering Committee, which I think is a great idea.
[0:38:25] Will those meetings be public meetings posted on the city website?
[0:38:30] Okay, that's what we're asking for the council to formulate that, so that will be open to the public.
[0:38:36] Okay, great. Thank you.
[0:38:37] So the question to me, for me, Dennis, is there's kind of like three things.
[0:38:42] You want to formalize the approval of the scope of work and the additional $2,000 as well.
[0:38:50] Is that part of the motion that you know?
[0:38:51] I would say that's part of the first motion to accept this.
[0:38:54] We'll work with the fee included.
[0:38:56] We have $50,000 in our budget to pay for this,
[0:38:58] but we know the fee is $52,000.
[0:39:01] We have additional savings throughout my...
[0:39:03] Sure, $52,000 in the second part.
[0:39:06] And then the steering committee is the second part.
[0:39:09] And the motion should be that we're going to develop
[0:39:13] a steering committee or you have it already
[0:39:15] kind of figured out or...
[0:39:17] Looking for the council to formulate the steering committee.
[0:39:20] And your suggestion was nine members?
[0:39:22] Nine to 12 members.
[0:39:24] That's what the commission did.
[0:39:26] Exactly, I look at, I don't know if you want to weigh in there too.
[0:39:31] Help us out here.
[0:39:31] So the parks commission made a specific recommendation to the council in their motion.
[0:39:38] And that was the nine to 12 members include two or three parks commission members.
[0:39:44] But, so we wanted to have the, we wanted to pass along the recommendation from the Parks
[0:39:51] Commission.
[0:39:52] But also, I think we need to have a conversation with the Council on how you want to proceed
[0:39:55] with that.
[0:39:56] So do we open it up?
[0:39:57] Do we ask for applications?
[0:39:58] Do we treat this like replacing members of a commission kind of a thing?
[0:40:02] I don't know that we need to create the commission, the steering committee tonight.
[0:40:08] But I don't know that that hurts.
[0:40:10] We obviously can't populate that entirely because we don't know who we need to have
[0:40:14] Yeah, so we need to do some of that conversation.
[0:40:18] The one thing I do like about it being formed by the council
[0:40:21] is that per our resolution for the transparency,
[0:40:24] it forces those to be open meetings.
[0:40:25] We want those to be open meetings anyway.
[0:40:29] So I think that having the council create that steering
[0:40:32] committee is a good move in that sense.
[0:40:35] So if we can create the commission tonight
[0:40:38] and then give us some feedback on how you want us to go
[0:40:40] about finding members for that, that would be good.
[0:40:42] If it's just conversation, I think we're really just open for the conversation to start at least and get as far as we can.
[0:40:49] Okay, so at the very least, we need to approve the scope and the budget and then maybe have a conversation about the steering committee.
[0:40:57] Rebecca Mill-Soyka.
[0:40:58] Move approval of the scope of work in contract with JUB engineers to develop a master plan for Parks and Recreation in the amount of $52,000.
[0:41:08] Second.
[0:41:10] We have a motion on the floor by Rebecca Milsoyka, seconded by Sean Barrier, anything further
[0:41:15] on that motion council?
[0:41:16] Lee, on the roll call vote please.
[0:41:19] Greg Lindsey.
[0:41:22] Yes.
[0:41:23] Don Hall.
[0:41:24] Yes.
[0:41:25] Rebecca Milsoyka.
[0:41:26] Yes.
[0:41:27] Suzanne Hawkins.
[0:41:28] Yes.
[0:41:29] Jim Mudd.
[0:41:30] Yes.
[0:41:31] Sean Barrier.
[0:41:32] Yes.
[0:41:33] Yes.
[0:41:34] Motion passes.
[0:41:35] Seven to zero.
[0:41:36] Conversation regarding the makeup or the steering committee.
[0:41:38] Sean Barrier.
[0:41:39] So I would agree that I think a steering committee is a key component of this process to make sure that we're engaging those various constituencies.
[0:41:48] I guess I look at it, so let's think back to the wastewater issue.
[0:41:55] We sort of threw out this, hey, who wants to be a part of this and people came and had a conversation and a few dropped off, but we ended up with a good core of people there.
[0:42:05] I would see something like that might work for the appointment of this.
[0:42:10] It's sort of a come one, come all, do you want to be a part of this?
[0:42:14] I'm less inclined to hog up some of the seats on that with Parks and Rec Commission members, council members, staff.
[0:42:23] I think we certainly can be involved in it, but I'd really rather have that broader voice from the community there.
[0:42:29] And I guess if it ends up being 15 or 18 people, then Mark will do a great job
[0:42:34] a great job of managing that meetings.
[0:42:36] But I think having the various constituencies,
[0:42:42] voices there is probably more important than council
[0:42:45] and commission members because we're all going to get
[0:42:48] our chance to weigh in on those at various times anyway.
[0:42:53] Any other thoughts, council?
[0:42:58] That's exactly what I thought of the wastewater committee.
[0:43:01] So do you need a motion in that regard?
[0:43:05] So I would move that the, that's still a mayoral appointment, right?
[0:43:09] Sure.
[0:43:10] That the mayor create a steering committee to work with JAB engineers on the perks and
[0:43:17] rec master.
[0:43:18] Second.
[0:43:19] I have motion on floor by Sean Barrow here, seconded by Rebecca Mills, so I can, any,
[0:43:26] any more on that motion council, Chris talking to.
[0:43:28] Well, I think the council should be involved in the final determination of the number
[0:43:33] and the people. I don't matter, that matter to me, I've done, recommends it to us, but
[0:43:40] I know from my public administration days that there's very strong evidence that a group
[0:43:45] over about nine people gets to be counterproductive, and if we have twice that, I'm not sure how
[0:43:52] much motion versus action could come out of it. So far as getting new people, and I really
[0:43:59] applaud that, I doubt I would have any problem on that, but I think Council at least needs
[0:44:03] to keep the spingers in the mayor's appointment process.
[0:44:07] Chris, John Berger.
[0:44:10] So I don't disagree that large groups can be difficult to manage, but I think we do have
[0:44:14] a couple of examples from the past where we had relatively large groups that stayed very
[0:44:18] focused on tasks.
[0:44:19] The wastewater is one, actually years ago when I served on the 50-year water planning committee,
[0:44:29] We had a ton of people on that one, and that stayed pretty focused.
[0:44:32] And the Auger Falls Citizens Committee actually that looked at the purchase of that was relatively
[0:44:37] large.
[0:44:38] So, I think we should throw it open and see who comes.
[0:44:41] If it looks unmanageable, I think working with JAB and with staff, the mayor can narrow
[0:44:49] that down if we need to.
[0:44:50] But I think more voices are going to be better than fewer in this process because it's not
[0:44:55] just about park land and trails, it's about recreation programs, it's about really planning
[0:45:01] well into the future and I think that we need to be careful not to make it, what are we going
[0:45:05] to put in this park? Here's the plan. And we need some of those other voices that typically
[0:45:12] maybe don't show up to those activities.
[0:45:16] Mitch, did you want to weigh in? I promise you.
[0:45:24] So I guess I heard only in the fact that I heard two different opinions here and I don't
[0:45:30] know that the motion really clarified it for me.
[0:45:33] So I heard Sean talking about maybe the mayor and council and Parks Commission shouldn't take
[0:45:39] up seats on the committee and then I heard Chris say maybe we should at least have some
[0:45:42] representation and the motion was just let's create a committee.
[0:45:50] So I don't want to go further.
[0:45:51] I know that the commissioners specifically said we should have two to three of us commissioners
[0:45:56] on this committee.
[0:45:57] And so that was something they very specifically they only specifically had two recommendations
[0:46:03] behind the 12 and three of us.
[0:46:06] And so I don't know that that really gave you mayor.
[0:46:11] Great direction on who we're asking.
[0:46:14] I like the idea of opening it up and see who comes and get the public involved.
[0:46:19] to me, the other questions are still out there a little bit.
[0:46:22] Thank you, Schumburger.
[0:46:23] Perhaps to clarify what I meant.
[0:46:25] I would like to leave it wide opening right now, assuming
[0:46:30] that some of those seats are going to be populated
[0:46:33] by Parks and Rec Commission members and council members.
[0:46:36] I don't feel comfortable saying it ought to be nine people
[0:46:39] and four of them ought to be these people.
[0:46:42] But that's not what I'm saying.
[0:46:43] I didn't say that.
[0:46:45] I didn't say you did, Chris.
[0:46:46] I'm just saying that I think if we just leave it open,
[0:46:49] If you throw the call out if 400 people respond, then you're going to have to pick and choose.
[0:46:54] If 10 respond, you probably have a pretty good community.
[0:46:59] Personally, I'm comfortable with keeping it wide open at this point.
[0:47:03] If we need to narrow it later, you've given me the authority to do that.
[0:47:07] And I will report that back to the council, whichever direction that we go out.
[0:47:10] We've worked with Dennis and Mark and making sure that we communicate that well.
[0:47:15] Since this is a mayoral appointment, we will be doing it in here and
[0:47:20] making sure that it's transparent and all those dynamics that we find very, very important.
[0:47:25] So anything further on the motion council, the aye the roll call vote, please.
[0:47:32] Don Hahn?
[0:47:33] Yes.
[0:47:34] Rebecca Masleika?
[0:47:35] Yes.
[0:47:36] Suzanne Hahnkins?
[0:47:37] Yes.
[0:47:38] Jim Mudd?
[0:47:39] Yes.
[0:47:40] Sean Berriger?
[0:47:41] Yes.
[0:47:42] Chris Tocklin?
[0:47:43] Yes.
[0:47:44] Great last year.
[0:47:45] Yes.
[0:47:46] Motion passes 7-0.
[0:47:47] Thank you, Dennis.
[0:47:48] update regarding compliance of the open house real estate sign code amendment and
[0:47:54] the on-street large parking truck parking code amendment. We do have Renee with us
[0:48:02] this evening welcome but I also want to mention that we do have members at least
[0:48:06] a few members of I would assume the real estate community that might want to
[0:48:13] weigh in later and we'll certainly give you an opportunity to do that if you'd
[0:48:16] like to folks. So we are going to go to you, right?
[0:48:19] Thank you very much. I'm here at your request based upon some ordinances that were adopted
[0:48:27] back in March and March on March 3rd, 2014, you granted ordinance 3063, which amended City
[0:48:35] Code 968 regarding the city's regulation of on-street large truck parking by only allowing
[0:48:42] large trucks and in particular the semis to park on street in the empty zoning industrial
[0:48:48] zone unless loading or unloading. That was the ordinance as approved. On March 10th, the
[0:48:55] City Council also granted ordinance 366 to the Greater Twin Falls Association of Realtors
[0:49:02] for Zoning Title Amendment to Title 10, Chapter 9, Section 9K by adding a new section to real
[0:49:10] estate signs to allow a real estate open house sign to be placed in public right away under
[0:49:16] limited conditions. On June 10th, as a follow up to the ordinance on March 10th, city staff
[0:49:26] did make a presentation at the Board of Realtors Monthly Luncheon meeting to help educate them
[0:49:32] on the new code amendment allowing open house signs under limited conditions. We also provided
[0:49:38] Nancy Glaceman, which is the Association Executive and Education Director, additional information
[0:49:45] that she could provide to new real estate agents as well as any of the follow-up or people that
[0:49:50] have had questions.
[0:49:53] You did ask that the Code Enforcement Department provide you with an update within six months
[0:50:00] of the adoption of these ordinances.
[0:50:02] So this evening we have Sean Stanley here, who is our Code Enforcement Officer tonight
[0:50:07] to provide you with a status of the compliance with both of those code amendments, and with
[0:50:12] that, I'll turn it over to Sean.
[0:50:14] Sean, if maybe we could address the open house since we have members of the public here first.
[0:50:21] I don't think, is there anyone here regarding the truck ordinance, truck parking ordinance?
[0:50:27] Yeah, so if we could do that first in case there's some comment?
[0:50:30] Okay.
[0:50:31] Welcome, Sean.
[0:50:32] Thank you.
[0:50:33] We have a very good relationship with the Real Affairs Association.
[0:50:36] been a couple violations. Other than that, there really hasn't been anything to report
[0:50:43] back on. They're following the ordinance very well. If we do have a situation, we give Nancy
[0:50:49] a call or send an email of a photo of the violation and they take care of it.
[0:50:58] So that's the report. Yeah, that's the report. I think we've had two violations.
[0:51:03] And when we have those, just reiterate, you get a hold of the association and they
[0:51:09] police themselves if you don't.
[0:51:11] They do, and they're doing a very good job with it.
[0:51:13] Do we have any questions for Sean?
[0:51:15] And I don't know if any member of the real tour association.
[0:51:22] I've been quizzed.
[0:51:23] Yeah, he's educating me on how to say that.
[0:51:26] No news is good news.
[0:51:28] Would like to address.
[0:51:30] been very positive I heard from the audience very good Suzanne Hawkins I was
[0:51:37] just wondering if they would like to explain the benefits they've seen and how
[0:51:41] it's helped their open houses and I would like to hear from one of the members
[0:51:46] well there you go the keys on PNC I don't see anybody rushing to the podium but
[0:51:55] it's like NAN is going to if when you come up if you could state your name who
[0:51:59] [Muted for privacy: home address]
[0:52:04] [Muted for privacy: home address]
[0:52:10] [Muted for privacy: home address]
[0:52:15] [Muted for privacy: home address]
[0:52:16] Thank you.
[0:52:17] Thank you.
[0:52:18] We have not had any complaints from our Realtors, as far as we're putting them out, or I think
[0:52:26] everybody's getting long fine. Open houses are running a schedule, you know, they're in
[0:52:31] the newspaper and so on. The market's getting much better, so I expect to see more open houses.
[0:52:39] But at this point, we don't have much else to report unless... So all is good in the
[0:52:49] world of real estate.
[0:52:50] Thank you.
[0:52:51] Thank you.
[0:52:52] Now, Sean, have we had any public complaints about the science being there or anything?
[0:52:56] No, we have not.
[0:52:57] the two that we didn't notice we were out enforcing the code and just noticed it so
[0:53:03] so what were the violations just they were put right in the middle of the
[0:53:07] sidewalk okay we're not allowing for three-foot clearance for pedestrians okay and
[0:53:12] two in the six months yeah okay any further questions for Sean on this
[0:53:16] subject if you go to the truck ordinance please be appreciated most of the semis
[0:53:24] Guys have been compliant with the new ordinance.
[0:53:27] Most of them are going to the industrial zones.
[0:53:29] I think you'll see a lot of them by the railroad tracks down by Deep Overill.
[0:53:36] We spent about six weeks putting brochures on windshields out in the North Haven,
[0:53:42] Canyon Crest out in that area.
[0:53:45] We have given 23 notices.
[0:53:49] Seven had a fine attached to them, but we did waive two of those because they did call in and said they had no idea about the ordinance.
[0:54:00] So five of them had been paid.
[0:54:02] Every once in a while, we will see a semi parked in the commercial zone or residential zone.
[0:54:09] We do our best to make them aware of the ordinance.
[0:54:12] We keep track of that once they're aware and hopefully they'll go to the industrial.
[0:54:18] mining. Just a comment on it, I did one day down on the trail, I talked to a couple of
[0:54:25] truckers who were in town amazingly taking jibani yogurt all the way to Florida. It
[0:54:32] made a lot of sense to me but they were they were they were they had come down
[0:54:35] just to look at the canyon and they had they ever actually they were since
[0:54:41] they were calling for jibani jibani was allowing them to put their truck there
[0:54:46] because their date to load was the next morning,
[0:54:49] they could actually put it on Jibani's property
[0:54:50] and just end up their tractor and came down to do
[0:54:53] a little sightseeing and things.
[0:54:55] But they were very aware, they knew that they couldn't park
[0:54:58] in certain areas in Twin Falls, so the grapevine,
[0:55:00] this was their first time ever in Twin Falls,
[0:55:03] and they knew about it.
[0:55:04] So at least the grapevine has spread
[0:55:06] as among the truckers as well to certain degree.
[0:55:09] But it might be in that their company had let them know,
[0:55:11] I don't know, but I still was amazed that they were,
[0:55:14] It came all the way to Twin Falls to, and they were actually, it was me, I talked to
[0:55:18] them about base jumping.
[0:55:19] They were for schedule to load till like noon and they were going to cook up with somebody
[0:55:24] to do a tandem base jump the next morning.
[0:55:26] They were really excited about that.
[0:55:27] So, anyways, my comment was that the trucking world, apparently it is let them know and apparently
[0:55:34] Chumwah Chumwah Chumwah Chumwah Chumwah Chumwah Chumwah Chumwah Chumwah Chumwah Chumwah Chumwah.
[0:55:42] When this first came to us, it came from the developers in the North Haven.
[0:55:47] Have you had any beyond your sort of patrolling?
[0:55:51] Have you had any other feedback from property owners saying, hey, get out here, there's trucks
[0:55:57] or?
[0:55:58] No.
[0:55:59] We haven't had any complaints.
[0:56:00] Every once in a while we'll get complaints from people in residential areas, so we'll
[0:56:05] go out and talk to them and they seem to move on.
[0:56:09] And I think that's encouraging that it seemed to fix itself pretty quickly.
[0:56:13] Actually both of these issues seem to sort of get taken care of since work will.
[0:56:17] Thank you to you and your team for the work you've done of it.
[0:56:20] Thank you.
[0:56:21] Sean, Herb, Sean, Suzanne, hi.
[0:56:23] Thank you.
[0:56:24] I just want to say in that North Haven area at the time of the discussion,
[0:56:29] I had mentioned the trash and how disruptive it was.
[0:56:32] And there was some comments about it being close to the high school.
[0:56:35] And since we have enacted that ordinance and the trucks have moved, the trash is gone and
[0:56:39] it is clean and it is much more friendly to walk through.
[0:56:43] So to me that just kind of answered that question for sure.
[0:56:50] Do you have any other questions for Sean or Renee?
[0:56:53] Sean, great report and thank you for your hard work as Council's state.
[0:56:57] Okay, thank you.
[0:56:59] Next item on the agenda is public input and or items from the city manager and city council.
[0:57:05] So we will open it up to the public first.
[0:57:07] Is there anyone from the public that would like to address the council your
[0:57:11] chance again get up here Nick come on city manager anything further or are
[0:57:21] acting city manager I don't really have anything further other than to say he's
[0:57:26] coming back on Thursday so very good if you need me call my phone numbers not
[0:57:33] his I'm not sitting in his office I mentioned that because Greg actually
[0:57:36] if I move it over to City Hall and I haven't so I think they call that a kudata
[0:57:42] I find it very humorous if you move it over put pictures of your family
[0:57:51] City Council anything from the City Council no lights are on so Council I think
[0:58:02] we're gonna be out of here before six we are adjourned
