Oversight Archive: City Council meeting, 2014-09-29, recording 1 (started 17:00)
Machine transcript (faster-whisper base.en), not checked word for word; the Pledge of Allegiance is shown in its standard wording. The recording is the record.
Times are time into the recording. Passages with private details are muted in the audio and marked here.
The audio on the page below was re-encoded by software from the video the agency posted. Check any passage against
that audio before relying on it.
Page: https://oversightarchive.org/twin-falls-id/meetings/2014-09-29/

[0:03:31] I'd like to call the meeting of the Twin Falls City Council to order at September 29th, 2014.
[0:03:37] It's 5 o'clock and as always the first item on our agenda is to do the Pledge of Allegiance.
[0:03:42] So those of you wishing to join us, please rise.
[0:03:47] I pledge allegiance to the Flag of the United States of America, and to the Republic for which it stands, one Nation under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all.
[0:04:03] Thank you all and welcome to our City Council meeting this evening.
[0:04:06] We do have a quorum of the City Council, all seven members are present.
[0:04:10] Mr. Rothweiler, do we have any amendments to our agenda this evening?
[0:04:15] Mr. Mayor and members of the Council staff would request the addition of an additional
[0:04:19] executive session under item number C, 6723451C to conduct deliberations concerning labor negotiations
[0:04:31] or to acquire an interest in real property,
[0:04:34] which is not owned by a public agency.
[0:04:37] Thank you, Travis.
[0:04:38] I'll stand for a motion.
[0:04:39] Greg Lanning.
[0:04:40] I will move that we add that executive session
[0:04:43] as outlined by our city manager, Travis Rothleather.
[0:04:48] Second.
[0:04:49] Have a motion on the floor by Greg Lanning,
[0:04:50] seconded by Sean Berger, to add that item to our executive,
[0:04:54] our already fairly long list of executive sessions
[0:04:58] for this evening.
[0:05:00] Anything further on that motion council?
[0:05:04] the other roll call vote, please.
[0:05:05] Suzanne Hawkins.
[0:05:06] Yes.
[0:05:07] Jim Mann.
[0:05:08] Yes.
[0:05:09] Sean Berriger.
[0:05:10] Yes.
[0:05:11] That's talking to him.
[0:05:12] Yes.
[0:05:13] Greg Lanthine.
[0:05:14] Yes.
[0:05:15] Don Hall.
[0:05:16] Yes.
[0:05:17] Rebecca Milseica.
[0:05:18] Yes.
[0:05:19] Motion passes to seven to zero.
[0:05:20] Moving on, we do not have any proclamations this evening, but as always, we open up our council
[0:05:25] meetings at the front end of it and at the tail end of it for anybody in the public that
[0:05:31] would like to come and converse with your City Council, give you a few minutes to come forward.
[0:05:37] We just generally would like to say off of any agenda item that's on the agenda because
[0:05:41] we'll have time to talk about that later.
[0:05:43] Is there anyone from the public that would like to come forward?
[0:05:47] If you come forward, sir, state your name and your address and we'll give you a couple
[0:05:50] [Muted for privacy: home address]
[0:05:51] [Muted for privacy: home address]
[0:06:00] [Muted for privacy: home address]
[0:06:07] [Muted for privacy: home address]
[0:06:14] contractors wanted to bid on that project.
[0:06:19] There wasn't a single contractor from Twin Falls in there during the bid opening.
[0:06:24] I'm kind of wondering why we're sending, you know, this was
[0:06:29] $750,000 out of town without anybody from twin even wanting to bid on it. I thought it was kind of weird as a taxpayer
[0:06:38] I don't like it
[0:06:39] I'd like to see some local guys bidding on these projects
[0:06:41] And I'd kind of like to challenge you guys the city council to look why why you have how come nobody from from twin
[0:06:49] What's the bid on these projects?
[0:06:51] Like I say, I don't, I personally don't like sending my tax dollars to Nampa and
[0:06:55] Coronavane and Salt Lake.
[0:06:57] I'd like any time it's possible to leave them here in the Valley.
[0:07:01] And I understand there's fair bidding practices and we got to let people bid.
[0:07:04] I'm not saying that.
[0:07:06] My question is, why does nobody from Twin Falls want to bid on these jobs?
[0:07:10] And I think it's worth looking into.
[0:07:12] I appreciate that, Mr. Young.
[0:07:14] And I don't know if we have an opportunity to answer that this evening regarding this.
[0:07:19] or if we need some time to research,
[0:07:22] because I don't recall this one particularly,
[0:07:24] I do know that I see local contractors bidding
[0:07:27] on a lot of things.
[0:07:28] Jonathan, would you like to address this?
[0:07:30] If you'll have a seat, sir, well, Jonathan, come up.
[0:07:33] I appreciate your concern.
[0:07:34] Thank you, Mayor.
[0:07:35] John Keaton.
[0:07:38] You know, we just, we advertise the bids,
[0:07:40] and you know, if a contractor decides to bid on it,
[0:07:45] we'll accept any bids, so I can't explain exactly why.
[0:07:49] we didn't get a response from twin. I'm not sure if Mr. Young would be willing to
[0:07:53] to comment because I believe he is with the home company.
[0:07:57] You have an opinion that I don't.
[0:08:02] Okay. I don't have an answer for that.
[0:08:07] Okay. Chris Dotton has comment. Sometimes the design specs are so
[0:08:11] narrow that if it is a piece of equipment that has
[0:08:15] either a patent on it or a licensing
[0:08:19] It excludes everybody.
[0:08:21] I don't remember that particular bidding,
[0:08:23] but was that one of the reasons that could have been such
[0:08:26] a one-dimensional bidding process?
[0:08:31] You know, excuse me, I would, you know,
[0:08:33] it'd be interesting to know what Tom, Mr. Young,
[0:08:37] would say, and also J.E.B., whenever we bid something,
[0:08:41] the objective is to make it as competitive and fair as
[0:08:45] possible so we can get the best price and not
[0:08:47] to eliminate competition.
[0:08:49] Now there's specific applications,
[0:08:51] you know, obviously we would have specific requirements.
[0:08:56] I don't think that this case that we did that.
[0:09:00] I would ask for you to reach out to maybe Mr. Young later.
[0:09:03] He doesn't seem like he wants to make a public comment,
[0:09:05] and I understand that, sir,
[0:09:07] but maybe you could converse with him
[0:09:08] and give us feedback or talk to maybe JUB or some of them.
[0:09:13] I know that Jim Munn also has come.
[0:09:14] Yeah, then I would just ask Mr. Young,
[0:09:16] If you don't feel comfortable discussing this with staff, please reach out to me.
[0:09:22] I would speak to you about that privately, if you'd like.
[0:09:25] I'm going to be leaving the meeting early tonight, but my email address is on the city website.
[0:09:31] It's jmon at tfid.org.
[0:09:34] Maybe we can coordinate a meeting to discuss it.
[0:09:36] Okay, thank you.
[0:09:40] Thank you, John.
[0:09:42] Anyone else from the public would like to make a comment?
[0:09:45] I see no one coming up.
[0:09:46] So the next item on the agenda is items for consideration,
[0:09:49] or excuse me, consent calendar,
[0:09:51] I'll turn that over to council wishes.
[0:09:54] Chris, tell me.
[0:09:56] After long search, I finally found a mistake
[0:09:59] in Layala's minutes, and it's such a rarity
[0:10:02] that I requested item to consent calendar
[0:10:05] be handled separately.
[0:10:08] That's a motion.
[0:10:09] Okay.
[0:10:10] We have a motion on the floor to pull item number two
[0:10:12] and handle it separately.
[0:10:15] We have a motion on the floor by Chris talking it,
[0:10:17] seconded by Jim not any any more comments or questions regarding that motion
[0:10:24] council. Greg Leim. Well just a little confusion on not that not Chris wants to
[0:10:30] pull it but in the past and other advice or attorney we haven't actually had a
[0:10:34] motion that a vote if any council member wants to pull an item they say I want to
[0:10:37] pull item two we just pull it we don't have to do the formality of a vote. I think
[0:10:42] you took a vote on that sometime ago and if anybody wants to pull it just
[0:10:46] to automatically just take it off and vote on what's remaining.
[0:10:49] Thank you for that clarification.
[0:10:50] I'll ask the maker of the motion.
[0:10:52] If that's all right with them, we just pull it.
[0:10:54] And we'll end the second.
[0:10:55] You're okay with that?
[0:10:58] Yes, I'm fine.
[0:10:59] So with that, the remainder of the consent calendar,
[0:11:03] Greg Landon, I move that we approve
[0:11:06] the remainder of the consent calendar.
[0:11:09] Second.
[0:11:10] I have a motion on board by Greg Lanting,
[0:11:13] seconded by Suzanne Hawkins to approve
[0:11:15] consent calendar minus item number two. Anything further on the motion council?
[0:11:22] The island roll call vote. Jim Munn. Yes. Sean Bericher. Yes. Chris
[0:11:28] talking to us. Yes. Greg Lanting. Yes. Don Hall. Yes. Rebecca Milseika. Yes.
[0:11:33] Suzanne Hawkins. Yes. Motion passes seven to zero. I'll turn it over to Chris
[0:11:37] talking. Thank you, Mayor. Again, I want to start with a statement that I did not
[0:11:43] But in my memory we call a year that has been so complex and difficult to keep track of the
[0:11:50] intricate amount of public discussion, public input, and I'd compliment Layala for an incredible
[0:11:57] track of safety.
[0:11:59] But I finally found one word that was in there.
[0:12:03] It's the September 2nd, minutes, item 3, page 4 of 15.
[0:12:11] And it's strictly a personal comment.
[0:12:14] The comment has recorded, alluded to me, when we were discussing the motion to weigh public
[0:12:21] safety fees for police and fire for non-profits.
[0:12:25] As quoted as saying, it is uncommon for fees to be waived for non-profits.
[0:12:30] I'd like to interject that I did say not uncommon, but I may have slurred the word.
[0:12:37] So I would ask for that.
[0:12:38] I need correction, and it is my new.
[0:12:43] I think that's more than appropriate,
[0:12:45] but at this time, can we go ahead
[0:12:47] and approve the minutes with that adjustment?
[0:12:51] I'll stand for a motion.
[0:12:53] Great line.
[0:12:54] I move that we make the correction as outlined
[0:12:56] by Councilman Tockington to the minutes,
[0:12:58] and then subsequently approve the minutes
[0:13:01] for September 2nd, 8th, and 15th, 2014.
[0:13:05] Second.
[0:13:06] We have a motion on the floor by Greg Lanting,
[0:13:08] seconded by Sean Barriger as stated. Anything further on the motion council?
[0:13:14] Lee, aye, the roll call vote, please. Sean Barriger? Yes.
[0:13:18] Chris Tawkington? Yes. Greg Lanting? Yes.
[0:13:21] Don Hall? Yes. Rebecca Melstika? Yes.
[0:13:24] Suzanne Hawkins? Yes. Jim Mun? Yes.
[0:13:26] Motion passes. Seven to zero. Thank you for the indulgence.
[0:13:31] Next item on the agenda under items for consideration is presentation of Peace
[0:13:35] officer standards and training. Council certificates to the following individuals.
[0:13:40] Officer Nate Egan, Officer Morgan Waite, Officer Ty Rutkin, Officer Samir,
[0:13:47] some RICO, Officer Josh Hayes and Officer Dalen Hall.
[0:13:54] And we have both our chief available as well as Captain Hicks. Welcome, sir.
[0:13:59] I got to tell you, I'm pretty impressed so far. I'm proud to see you.
[0:14:03] Mr. Mayor, members of the council, we'd like to thank you for continuing devotion to celebrate our officers' obtaining certificates.
[0:14:10] As you know, the Twin Falls Police Department strives to provide the best possible customer service.
[0:14:15] And in doing so, we place the highest level of decision-making in the officers that we hire and train.
[0:14:22] In the last three years, we've hired 20 police officers, and we are honored here to be present to honor the significant achievements of six of those officers
[0:14:31] officers by attaining career certifications.
[0:14:35] At this point, I'd like to ask Mayor Hall and she'd
[0:14:37] like to come forward.
[0:14:39] And we'd like to start with two officers obtaining their post-
[0:14:42] basic certificates.
[0:14:43] So I'd also like to ask officers an 18 and more than way to
[0:14:47] come forward, please.
[0:14:55] The process to become a police officer today is highly
[0:14:58] competitive and very demanding, according to our Human Resource
[0:15:00] Department, 130 people have applied to be a police officer
[0:15:03] so far this year to involve.
[0:15:05] Only seven of those applicants have been successful.
[0:15:09] As you know, the officers are tested on job-related knowledge
[0:15:12] and given physical tests, psychological tests.
[0:15:15] They undergo a polygraph test, as long as they're
[0:15:17] a detailed background investigation.
[0:15:20] All of those officers are put through that process.
[0:15:23] And as I said before, only seven this year have been successful
[0:15:26] in doing so.
[0:15:27] For those that are hired, they must either attend a 10-week
[0:15:29] post-academy session, or a year-long law enforcement
[0:15:32] training program, such at the colleges of the Idaho,
[0:15:35] After completing this phase, our officers complete the Department's 16-week field training
[0:15:39] program.
[0:15:40] This program is designed to be very difficult and very demanding and it focuses on customer
[0:15:44] service, officer safety, and conflict resolution.
[0:15:47] For those that make it through all of this, they are assigned to ride alone in the field
[0:15:50] and they're continually evaluated for the remainder of their first year.
[0:15:54] For those that complete this grueling pre-employment and training process, they are eligible to receive
[0:15:59] their post-based certificate.
[0:16:01] The two officers in front of you have done so, so let me introduce them to you.
[0:16:04] First of all, Officer Nate Egan.
[0:16:07] Nate was hired by the Twin Falls Police Department on August 26, 2013.
[0:16:11] Nate was born and raised in Rexburg, Idaho.
[0:16:14] He graduated from Madison High School in Rexburg and received his Eagle Scout Award.
[0:16:18] Nate also served in LDS Mission in Tokyo, Japan.
[0:16:20] He went on to further his education by attending BYU, Idaho, and the Eastern Idaho Technical
[0:16:24] College.
[0:16:25] Prior to his employment with TFPD, Nate worked for some investments in Rexburg, Idaho, and
[0:16:30] as a truck driver in the Royal Fills in North Dakota.
[0:16:33] He and his wife, Sarah, have two small boys.
[0:16:36] He graduated from the 10 week Idaho Post Academy
[0:16:39] in December of 2013.
[0:16:41] He successfully completed our 16 week field training
[0:16:44] program after that.
[0:16:45] That is a great pleasure that we award you
[0:16:47] your basic certificate from the Idaho Peace Office
[0:16:49] of Standing and Training Council.
[0:17:04] Next I'd like to introduce you to Morgan Wake.
[0:17:06] He was hired by the Twin Falls Police Department
[0:17:08] on October 7, 2013 as a full time police officer.
[0:17:12] Morgan was born in Burleigh, Idaho,
[0:17:13] and he was the 10th of 11 children.
[0:17:15] He was raised in Haberne, Idaho, graduated from medical high school.
[0:17:19] After graduation, he served a two-year church
[0:17:21] mission in Bulgaria.
[0:17:23] After returning from his mission,
[0:17:24] he attended two semesters of the College of Southern Idaho
[0:17:27] while working at Clear Talk Wireless.
[0:17:30] Morgan further pursued his educational criminal justice
[0:17:32] at Utah Valley University and at the College of Southern Nevada.
[0:17:38] Later, he tested for the city of North Las Vegas Police
[0:17:40] Department in the fall of 2007 and was hired.
[0:17:43] He graduated from the Southern Desert Regional Police
[0:17:45] Academy in July of 2008 and received his Nevada basic certification in September of 2008. Prior
[0:17:52] to being hired with our department, Morgan worked as a patrol officer with the North Las Vegas
[0:17:56] Police Department for approximately five years. He and his wife chose to come back to Idaho to be
[0:18:00] near their families and to raise their children in a smaller community. Morgan and his wife Trista
[0:18:05] have three small children. Morgan is with great pleasure that we present you with your basic
[0:18:09] certification from the Idaho Peace Officer Standards and Training Council. For those officers that
[0:18:25] receive their basic certificate the next objective they strive for is their post-intermediate
[0:18:28] certificate. So at this time I'd like to ask officers Tyler Redkin, Samir Smirko, and Josh
[0:18:35] Hayes to come forward. In order to achieve this goal, police officer must serve in their
[0:18:40] profession for a minimum of two years while possessing a college degree or serve a minimum
[0:18:44] of four years while attending at least 600 hours opposed to proved training. Officers Redkin,
[0:18:50] Smirko, and Hayes have all met and exceeded this standard. Let me start by introducing
[0:18:55] Officer Rutkin to you.
[0:18:56] Tyler Rutkin was hired by the TFPD on May 14, 2012
[0:19:00] as a full-time officer.
[0:19:02] Ty was born in Connecticut where his father was stationed
[0:19:05] with the US Navy.
[0:19:06] Because of his father's military service,
[0:19:08] Ty has also lived in Idaho, Washington, Connecticut,
[0:19:10] and Georgia.
[0:19:11] After completing high school, he attended the Arizona
[0:19:14] Western College where he graduated an associate's degree
[0:19:16] in mathematics and engineering.
[0:19:18] He then continued his education at Boise State University
[0:19:20] where he received a bachelor's degree in criminal justice.
[0:19:23] During his freshman and sophomore years in college,
[0:19:25] he also attended and successfully graduated
[0:19:28] from the officer candidate school
[0:19:29] for the United States Marine Corps at Quantico, Virginia.
[0:19:32] Ty successfully attended and graduated from the post academy.
[0:19:36] He was awarded his post certification
[0:19:37] on March 20th of 2013.
[0:19:40] He's currently serves as a member of our honor guard.
[0:19:45] Ty's with great pleasure that we present you
[0:19:47] with your intermediate certification
[0:19:49] from the Idaho Peace Officer Standards and Training Council.
[0:20:04] Samir Schmerko was hired by the Twin Falls Police on March 15, 2012.
[0:20:17] Samir was born in Bosnia and arrived in the United States in 1994.
[0:20:21] He attended Lincoln Elementary, Robert Stewart Junior High,
[0:20:24] O'Leary Junior High, and graduated from Twin Falls High School.
[0:20:27] In May of 2005, he enlisted in the Army National Guard,
[0:20:30] where he attended and completed a four-month basic training
[0:20:33] at Fort Knox, Kentucky as a Calvary Scout.
[0:20:36] In 2006, he volunteered to serve in Operation Iraqi Freedom.
[0:20:39] His primary mission was convoy security, which consisted of providing safety and security
[0:20:44] to convoy's transporting fuel and food and other supplies.
[0:20:47] Again, in 2010, Samir again was deployed to Iraq with the one 16th Bravo Company troop
[0:20:53] in support of Operation New Dawn.
[0:20:55] His mission was to supervise vehicle searches, personnel searches, and guard duties.
[0:21:00] Prior to his employment with the TFPD, Samir was employed with the Jerome Cranny Sheriff's Office
[0:21:04] from July of 2008 until March of 2012 as a correctional officer and later as a patrol deputy.
[0:21:10] Samir serves as a member of our SWAT team. He's an emergency vehicle instructor and is
[0:21:15] recently selected as a field training officer. Samir received his basic certification in December
[0:21:20] of 2009. Samir is a great pleasure to present you with your intermediate certificate from
[0:21:25] the State of Idaho Peace Officers and Training Council.
[0:21:40] Josh Hayes. Josh was hired by the TFP in October 5th, 2009 as a full-time officer. Josh was born
[0:21:47] in Twin Falls and attended Bickel Elementary, O'Leary Junior High. Later he moved to Kimberly
[0:21:52] and graduated from Kimberly High School with honors in 2003. After graduation he went on
[0:21:57] a church mission to Brazil and returned to Twin Falls in 2005. He attended and successfully
[0:22:02] completed the College of Southern Idaho law enforcement program and graduated in 2009 prior
[0:22:07] to beginning his career with our department. He is currently serving in the patrol division.
[0:22:11] He was also recently appointed as field training officer and is at present continuous education
[0:22:16] through CSI. He was awarded his basic certification in December of 2010.
[0:22:21] Josh is married to his wife Elizabeth, and they have two young sons.
[0:22:24] Josh is a great pleasure to present you with your enemy whose certificate from the state
[0:22:28] of Idaho Peace Officers, Trang, stands for Trang. Finally, for those officers that receive their
[0:22:45] intermediate certificate, the next objective they strive for is their advanced certificate.
[0:22:49] At this time, I'd like to ask Officer Dow and Hall to come forward. In order to obtain
[0:22:55] a post-advanced certificate, a police officer must serve in the profession for a minimum
[0:22:58] four years to obtain a college degree or a minimum of eight years and obtain at least
[0:23:03] 1,200 hours of post-approved training.
[0:23:06] Dowan Hall was hired by the Twin Falls Police Department in June of 2011 as a full-time
[0:23:10] officer.
[0:23:11] Dowan was born in Burley.
[0:23:12] He and his family moved to Jerome in 1996 where he attended and graduated from Jerome
[0:23:16] High School.
[0:23:17] He completed the law enforcement program at CSI in May of 2005.
[0:23:21] Dowan began his law enforcement career shortly after graduating with the Rupert Police Department.
[0:23:27] six months he obtained a full-time officer position with the City of Sun Valley. In 2008
[0:23:32] he moved to Sota Springs and was working as a full-time officer there when we hired him.
[0:23:37] Dallin is a certified EVOC instructor with our department and was also recently appointed
[0:23:42] as a field training officer. He was awarded his post basic certificate in July of 2006 and
[0:23:48] was intermediate in May of 2012. It is with great pleasure, Dallin, that we present you
[0:23:53] with your advanced certificate from the Peace Officer's Damage Training Council.
[0:23:56] Well, if I might say, I think I'm going to sleep a little better tonight, knowing that we have fine officers like this
[0:24:20] Protecting us and serving our community. So just one to on behalf of the city council. Thank you for your dedication your professionalism to achieve these
[0:24:29] levels and
[0:24:31] Continue up the the rank and really appreciate what you do for our community
[0:24:35] At this time
[0:24:36] We're going to go ahead and let you go if you would like so that you don't have to sit there in those times
[0:24:42] I'll just get back on the streets and protect us.
[0:24:47] Yeah, unless you want to stay, as Chief says.
[0:24:51] You probably have better things to do.
[0:24:54] Thank you, gentlemen.
[0:24:55] Thank you, ladies.
[0:25:05] Who made a long week change?
[0:25:14] There goes our whole audience.
[0:25:17] Next item on the agenda is request
[0:25:19] to adopt a resolution amending Twin Falls Vision 2030,
[0:25:23] a comprehensive plan for a sustainable future
[0:25:26] to update Chapter 11, development, impact fee,
[0:25:29] capital improvement plans, and we have Mitch Humble.
[0:25:32] Welcome, Mitch.
[0:25:34] Just when it was getting good too.
[0:25:35] It's just going to be better after this, go.
[0:25:38] That's right.
[0:25:40] This item in your packet is like a 120-something pages,
[0:25:44] and I really hope that this presentation doesn't go as long
[0:25:48] as the length of the packet would suggest.
[0:25:50] So I'll just back up a little bit to June 9th.
[0:25:54] I think it was June 9th when we had a public hearing here at the council.
[0:25:58] Followed a recommendation by the Planning and Zoning Commission as well as the impact fee
[0:26:02] advisory committee that we go ahead and adopt some new capital improvement plans that would
[0:26:06] lead to a different impact fee.
[0:26:09] We had that public hearing that request was approved by the council on June 9th.
[0:26:15] Move ahead to August 5th.
[0:26:16] We actually had a hearing on August 5th because the fees that we were talking about was an
[0:26:20] increase to the fee more than 5%.
[0:26:23] So along with the rest of our upcoming budget year fee hearings, we have this one on August
[0:26:28] 5th and that was also approved on the 5th.
[0:26:30] So this is the final step to actually making the changes to the impact fee document that
[0:26:36] is simply adopting a resolution that physically makes the changes to the comprehensive plan
[0:26:42] chapter 11.
[0:26:43] So what you have in your packet is a couple of things.
[0:26:46] The important one, really, is there's a one-page resolution,
[0:26:50] and it's really short, and it just says we're
[0:26:51] going to adopt this new chapter 11.
[0:26:53] And then attached behind that is the new chapter 11.
[0:26:56] That's the 36 page clean document.
[0:26:58] It doesn't show all the track changes.
[0:27:01] In talking with Fritz, we decided it'd probably be best
[0:27:03] for you guys to see the rest of it, the track changes
[0:27:07] document, just so you can see everything that
[0:27:08] were changing through there.
[0:27:09] That's why the packet looks as long as it does.
[0:27:12] But I don't really intend to go over all of those details.
[0:27:16] And in fact, this is just making the chains that we've already talked about and that we've already approved.
[0:27:21] And so we just really need the adoption of the resolution tonight.
[0:27:25] Having said that, if you want to ask me questions about anything that's in there content-wise, I'm happy to go over that with you.
[0:27:30] Otherwise, I would just recommend approval of the resolution that's presented and I don't know the number of those.
[0:27:39] What's the number of the other?
[0:27:40] 1932.
[0:27:42] 1932. Thank you. We have several questions. Looks like.
[0:27:45] I just want to reiterate that for people who may be listening in, this did go through
[0:27:51] the full public hearing process.
[0:27:54] We received public input and the council can't remember if it was a unanimous vote, but it
[0:27:59] was at least the majority passed.
[0:28:01] And so this resolution is just a housekeeping role more than anything else.
[0:28:05] Right.
[0:28:06] On June 9th, it was unanimous vote, but there wasn't seven council people here at night.
[0:28:10] It was only five.
[0:28:11] It was a five to zero vote.
[0:28:12] It actually had three, four, four different public hearings.
[0:28:17] So we had hearing with the impact fee committee, another one that planning is on the commission,
[0:28:23] another one here and then on August 5th, a second hearing in front of the council.
[0:28:29] Thank you, Mitch.
[0:28:29] Thank you, Chris.
[0:28:30] Rebecca Mill, so I can.
[0:28:32] Thanks, Mitch.
[0:28:33] So when do these new fees go into place or are they already in place?
[0:28:37] I thought that they were in place at the new budget year, but.
[0:28:40] Yeah, they won't.
[0:28:41] Actually, they'll go in effect on Wednesday.
[0:28:43] That was the recommendation back in June was give us until October 1st so that everybody
[0:28:48] can know they're coming and we've certainly put the word out and lots of people know we're
[0:28:52] coming.
[0:28:53] I expect to have a lot of building permits applied for today and tomorrow.
[0:28:55] Okay.
[0:28:56] So this resolution is just in time then.
[0:29:00] It just makes it right under the wire.
[0:29:03] Thanks.
[0:29:04] Great mining.
[0:29:05] Move approval of resolution 1932.
[0:29:08] Second.
[0:29:09] Second.
[0:29:10] We have a motion on the floor by Greg Lanting, seconded by Rebecca Mills, so I can approve
[0:29:16] resolution 1932.
[0:29:18] We don't need to read the resolution or anything.
[0:29:24] Any comments regarding this item?
[0:29:27] Well, it's a very major change.
[0:29:29] It brings us current.
[0:29:33] Thank you, Chris.
[0:29:35] with impact fees which I might say the impact fee committee voted if not unanimously solidly
[0:29:45] in favor of their approval.
[0:29:47] So if I go back, there was a lot of discussion at the committee.
[0:29:51] We worked several months worth of meetings and worked with the committee on that and they
[0:29:57] attempted, I want to say, six or seven different variations of the approval that the one that
[0:30:03] finally made it out I believe did get a unanimous vote coming out of the commission
[0:30:07] but there were six or so failed that that were really it was really they put a lot
[0:30:14] of work into it and they tried a lot of different things when it came down to it
[0:30:18] the compromise position that we see in front of us is it was supported by the
[0:30:23] committee so yeah let's say it was well-bited yeah there you go yeah if anything
[0:30:30] further from council the other roll call vote please yes Greg
[0:30:35] glanting yes Don Hall yes Rebecca Mills like that yes Suzanne Hawkins yes Jim
[0:30:41] Munn yes Sean Barrett yes motion passes seven to zero thank you Mitch next I'm
[0:30:47] known on the agenda is a presentation on the University of Virginia high
[0:30:51] performance organization training experience and we have Gretchen Scott
[0:30:57] John Caten and Anthony Barnhart and I don't know who's starting off but
[0:31:02] welcome the three of you very good
[0:31:10] knowledge is wonderful when it was it was there a little a
[0:32:02] progression hello good evening so we have the privilege of being able to come
[0:33:34] you tonight and share with you the experiences that we had while we went to the University
[0:33:40] of Virginia and so in trying to describe the value of the training, the importance of where
[0:33:51] we as participants believe that play is both in our organization and our professional careers,
[0:33:57] we wanted to put it in a framework that made sense.
[0:34:04] So it took me a while to sort of think about why as an organization what we're looking at
[0:34:13] relative to a high performance organization makes sense.
[0:34:19] You all are very aware that we are just coming out of and have gone through a period of difficult
[0:34:26] budgetary and economic times.
[0:34:30] Through that process I think a lot of what was asked of staff and of council was how are
[0:34:37] Are we doing?
[0:34:38] Can we do it better?
[0:34:39] Can we do it more efficiently?
[0:34:41] A lot of questions posed about the quality of our organization, the quality of our staff.
[0:34:47] What can we ask them to do?
[0:34:49] Really exploratory questions about how you're giving information and how we're presenting
[0:34:53] it to you and about the decisions we're asking you to make.
[0:34:58] So in terms of those about questioning and evaluating our organization, I went back to
[0:35:06] where our history has been, and what that means, how have we evaluated
[0:35:10] ourselves previously.
[0:35:18] So from a historical standpoint, for a number of years,
[0:35:23] we've been doing and participating in the community survey.
[0:35:28] I believe it has about 20 years' worth of history for us as an
[0:35:31] organization.
[0:35:33] We drafted the questions.
[0:35:35] We sent them out to members who had participated in the last
[0:35:38] elections and asked them to rate our services.
[0:35:42] everything from citizens and your initial contact with staff to their perception of timing of street lights,
[0:35:49] to how we were mowing weeds and taking care of vacant lots.
[0:35:53] So we had a long history with that survey that we gave out.
[0:35:59] We were consistently rated as meeting our community's expectations,
[0:36:04] and we had an excellent track record of good customer service and, in fact, quality service.
[0:36:12] And that repetitive history of those surveys really reinforced for us the perception that
[0:36:20] we were doing well, that we were meeting community needs, and that we were meeting our own goals
[0:36:25] that were tied to that with our strategic objectives.
[0:36:38] So prior to 2008, that was what we were doing.
[0:36:43] In 2009, we began using the National Citizen Survey, and it was different in that it did
[0:36:51] not just target people who had voted in the past elections. If you look at voting trends
[0:36:58] in demographics, they're pretty consistent about the type of person who votes in elections.
[0:37:04] The National Citizen Survey didn't tie to elections and participated in them. It tied to
[0:37:10] the demographics of our community. So it expanded to include people whose perhaps voice had not
[0:37:16] been hurt before. It was the first external comparison of our city with other cities and
[0:37:25] how their citizens felt about them. So not only did we get a new voice in our survey that
[0:37:32] was evaluating us and providing us feedback, but it also gave us an opportunity to tell the
[0:37:37] satisfaction rate of our own citizens against the satisfaction of citizens in a different
[0:37:42] community. How did those compare? What we really found is that it changed the scale. We were
[0:37:50] no longer being measured with the same stick. It was a different sample group and in truth,
[0:37:58] it was a much different result and gave us a new reality. So what we really found was
[0:38:24] that our operating environment had changed. We were no longer 80 to 90 percent meeting
[0:38:31] the expectations of our community. We were no longer at 80 to 90 percent approval ratings
[0:38:36] by our citizen.
[0:38:38] We were no longer meeting 90% of our community's needs.
[0:38:43] So now we have a new reality.
[0:38:45] And we're just coming out of a period of time
[0:38:47] with restricted budgets.
[0:38:50] We're asking more of our staff.
[0:38:52] We're asking more of our council for harder decisions
[0:38:56] about how are you going to place in priority of things.
[0:39:00] And we needed to go back with a plan
[0:39:03] of how are we going to adapt?
[0:39:05] How are we going to be more nimble,
[0:39:08] be able to react differently and quicker
[0:39:10] to the way things are changing around us?
[0:39:26] So one of the things that high performance does
[0:39:30] as an organization is to ask critical questions.
[0:39:34] Doesn't give you the cookbook for how you're going to get there.
[0:39:37] It doesn't even identify for you what your ingredients are.
[0:39:42] But what it does is it asks you what's important.
[0:39:46] So from an organization that five years ago went from,
[0:39:51] we're meeting everybody's expectations
[0:39:53] and we're doing excellent,
[0:39:55] to now we're meeting the average expectations
[0:40:00] and from an average standpoint,
[0:40:03] we're meeting our citizens goals
[0:40:05] for what they believe our organization should be doing.
[0:40:10] So what does high performance mean?
[0:40:12] Because if you had asked us five years ago,
[0:40:14] we'd have said we are.
[0:40:16] So these sets of seven questions,
[0:40:20] which we haven't answered yet, by the way,
[0:40:23] began the conversation, what is high performance
[0:40:26] for the city of Twin Falls?
[0:40:30] How would we know if we are high performing?
[0:40:33] Who do we need to ask?
[0:40:36] If it's just internally, maybe we won't be giving ourselves
[0:40:40] enough mirror moments to identify that we have got there.
[0:40:46] Why do we need to be high performing?
[0:40:50] I'd say most of us would probably say that the exercise in financial responsibility and
[0:40:57] creative applications of how we're able to stretch dollars can get us to a point where
[0:41:02] we know why we need to be high performing.
[0:41:08] Part of the problem with being in public service is that we believe that we're providing the
[0:41:12] services that our citizens want, but if we don't ask the right people, do we get all of
[0:41:17] the right answer. If we only ask a certain population of our city, do we really know what
[0:41:25] the full expectation or the full desire of our community is for what we are doing? And
[0:41:33] one of the last questions, which is very important, and one I think that was specifically addressed
[0:41:38] in the last community survey, or sorry, national citizen survey, is how are we going to treat
[0:41:44] each other and our customers? So it's kind of like an end justifying the means. And that's
[0:41:51] not our case. We want to make sure that our means are of the highest quality in
[0:41:55] order to get to the place where we need to be.
[0:41:57] Jeff and Barnhart, I can't see you now. Good evening, Mr. Mayor and members of the Council.
[0:42:22] I'm really excited about being here this evening to talk about my experience with
[0:42:26] you with HPO because I believe in the concepts and the fundamental principles
[0:42:31] behind it. I believe that this is really a game-changer for you, for city staff and
[0:42:39] and for the community of Twin Falls.
[0:42:43] And it really becomes effective
[0:42:45] when we use it to improve performance
[0:42:47] and reach our 2030 Community Strategic Plan.
[0:42:51] HBO Concepts concentrate on the interaction
[0:42:54] among organizational units, staff, customers,
[0:42:59] partners, and stakeholders to achieve strategic goals.
[0:43:04] For me, this innovative way of doing business
[0:43:06] is anchored in trust.
[0:43:08] The trust between the individuals within the organization, the trust with top management,
[0:43:14] and the entry-level workforce, and the trust with the citizens of our community and their
[0:43:20] government.
[0:43:22] Before I share with you my experiences with HBO and the training that we attended in Virginia,
[0:43:28] I would like to share some of the fundamental principles that distinguish the HBO approach
[0:43:34] to organizational performance improvement and goal achievement.
[0:43:38] Number one is leadership can be exercised by every individual at every level of the organization,
[0:43:45] commonly referred to as the work of leadership.
[0:43:49] Everyone in the organization has a special access to information that comes from his or her
[0:43:54] particular vantage point.
[0:43:56] And when this information is brought together to address challenges, it has the best results.
[0:44:03] So it will be our responsibility to install collective self-confidence versus dependency
[0:44:10] and to inspire change without disabling people.
[0:44:16] Number two is the right systems, processes, and structures can contribute to the organizational
[0:44:22] performance rather than impeded.
[0:44:24] This takes time to grapple with diverse issues and develop these processes.
[0:44:29] It also takes tactical thinking to grow these structures.
[0:44:34] What we have to do is rather than maintain norms, we must challenge the way we do business.
[0:44:42] Stewardship and engagement of all can lead to higher performance of the individual, the
[0:44:47] work group and the organization.
[0:44:49] And what we're really looking for is an engaged workforce.
[0:44:54] People who enjoy and believe in what they are doing and feel valued for doing it.
[0:44:58] It will be our challenge to encourage risk-taking and responsibility and back people up even
[0:45:05] when they air and help them recognize that they contain the solutions. Number four is vision
[0:45:13] and values and of course this relates to purpose and who we are as an organization. These must
[0:45:20] be addressed in order to reach higher performance and I think that we actually have a lock on
[0:45:25] this in public service. Let me share with you a quote from Robert Mattson. He is a director
[0:45:31] and professor with the senior executive institute for public service. Robert says this, when this
[0:45:39] This connection between how we do it and why we do it is made more visible.
[0:45:44] Our work can be part of a life at its best.
[0:45:48] Government work in this sense has the greatest opportunity to be inspiring for both the served
[0:45:57] and the servant.
[0:45:58] And I think that we can take advantage of that.
[0:46:02] Lastly, organizations must make time to do the work of leadership.
[0:46:08] Don't simply reside in the city manager's office. These challenges must be addressed from the entire organization. A holistic approach which brings a strong foundation of expertise to complex systems, our organizational culture, and performance improvement with the intended result of attaining our strategic objectives.
[0:46:30] Thank you, Anthony, and before you move on,
[0:46:51] I just wanted for the minutes that Councilman Munn
[0:46:54] needed to leave.
[0:46:55] He had a prior engagement for the evening.
[0:46:57] Go ahead, Gretchen.
[0:46:59] Mr. Caten.
[0:47:03] So I just want to preface this by saying,
[0:47:06] John had a busy week last week.
[0:47:08] So he's seen this once,
[0:47:12] but we're throwing him under the bus right now.
[0:47:14] Come on, John.
[0:47:16] I've seen this, I didn't know it was mine.
[0:47:19] Thanks to Anthony and Gretchen, she was right, I was a little distracted this week and I was
[0:47:26] a bad lab partner, they did all the heavy lifting so they asked me to really share with you
[0:47:34] my experiences at UVA and I think I can relate them to this slide quite well. Really, when
[0:47:40] I think about the first couple of things that I got out of UVA is that it's people focused.
[0:47:49] and Anthony, for example, you know, I've done a little bit with them before UVA, and since,
[0:47:55] I think we've done a lot more, my step-on, anybody's like, no, okay, that was a conclusion.
[0:48:03] But actually, we've had a few events this year where I've had to call Gretchen because
[0:48:07] of claims or insurance reasons and got an old of Anthony for traffic control and emergency
[0:48:13] And, you know, my first response in the past was thinking
[0:48:17] about the assets and resources that Public Works has,
[0:48:20] which is pretty good and pretty capable.
[0:48:25] But when I think about it, it's pretty short-sighted
[0:48:28] when I've got these, you know, beyond them assets too.
[0:48:32] So, Anthony and Gretchen have been great right there.
[0:48:35] And it's opened up another level, I think, of response.
[0:48:39] I think we've optimized our communication,
[0:48:42] especially in emergency situations.
[0:48:47] There was a quote that I remember at UVA,
[0:48:51] it was about Jack Welch, and it was a story about him.
[0:48:54] He was the CEO, as you all know, of GE for 20 years.
[0:48:58] It was a management genius, but not necessarily in the beginning.
[0:49:02] He had a gentleman that was retiring, and his secretary came to him,
[0:49:07] Jack, and said, hey, this person's retiring.
[0:49:10] retiring, we'd like you to come and have a piece of cake and say some nice things about
[0:49:15] this person. And he did, he came to the party, said his piece and had a piece of cake. And
[0:49:22] this retiree came up to Jack and said, I've worked for you and you've had my hands for
[0:49:29] 30 years. Not once did you ask me for my mind, my ideas. And it struck Jack like, whoa.
[0:49:38] And he's thinking a little bit like an engineer, how much more can I optimize?
[0:49:42] How much more can I get out of this person?
[0:49:45] And not only that, how much did I miss?
[0:49:51] And I think that was where EVA starts is about people again, is they look at Myers-Briggs,
[0:49:56] and that was an aha moment for me.
[0:49:58] It's a personality assessment.
[0:50:00] And you know, you can debate whether it's accurate or not.
[0:50:05] It's totally accurate for these two.
[0:50:09] But I don't think that's the point, I think the point is that, I think the point is that
[0:50:16] there are differences and it's really important to understand what they are and to highlight
[0:50:20] them and to take advantage of them.
[0:50:24] I did scribble if you know it's not forgetting anything.
[0:50:32] You know really Anthony hit the other thing that really struck me too was leadership's
[0:50:37] done at all levels.
[0:50:40] I see it all the time on the job.
[0:50:43] the youngest person and most inexperienced person on the job,
[0:50:46] reminding a senior person that they might either hard hat
[0:50:50] or they're earplugs, you know, I see that all the time.
[0:50:53] And that goes a long way.
[0:50:54] So leadership does happen at all levels,
[0:50:56] and we want it to happen on all levels.
[0:50:58] And I guess in closing really, I think what we're trying
[0:51:03] to do and what I think EVAs trying to do
[0:51:05] is teach us how to build a culture where we respect each other,
[0:51:09] We know who we are, and we create trust.
[0:51:15] I think of companies like Google and Cliff Barr.
[0:51:20] You want to work for those organizations, and that's really
[0:51:22] what we want.
[0:51:23] We want people that really want to be here.
[0:51:25] Mr. King?
[0:51:33] So there's two pieces on this before Anthony comes back up
[0:51:37] to talk about his additional piece, too.
[0:51:49] So part of what our takeaway was, and I believe if you were
[0:51:55] to ask the other members who have gone this year of staff,
[0:52:00] is that when we came back, I think we were excited
[0:52:04] by the possibilities and at the new way
[0:52:08] of approaching problem solving that we saw could evolve
[0:52:12] within our organization, one that which had not been here
[0:52:15] before.
[0:52:16] And part of the success of that overall strategy
[0:52:21] is to invest in additional people to have them
[0:52:25] with that same mindset.
[0:52:27] And part of what John said was right,
[0:52:33] knowing yourself, knowing how to communicate better
[0:52:36] with other people that aren't the same as you,
[0:52:38] is strong and is good.
[0:52:40] But there's also a piece of it of allowing people
[0:52:44] to expand the way that they think.
[0:52:46] and the way that they believe that they might have some ownership of things.
[0:52:50] And truly the introduction to that, the baptism to that, is through going through that process
[0:52:58] of being exposed to those concepts in the way that they structure it and immerse them in
[0:53:04] that.
[0:53:06] To that end, we believe that those concepts can go farther by exposure for more people.
[0:53:13] We think we need to gain some momentum.
[0:53:15] We're excited about it.
[0:53:16] like the way it went, we want more people in that same mindset,
[0:53:20] more people encouraged and motivated.
[0:53:24] And part of that gaining momentum that we're looking for
[0:53:28] is to actually bring the instructors
[0:53:31] for the University of Virginia program here to Twin Falls.
[0:53:35] And we are drafting that plan and putting it in motion now.
[0:53:40] And do you want to speak to that before we?
[0:53:47] So I wasn't necessarily part of this, and I think that there's a couple of things that
[0:53:54] I would share.
[0:53:55] Number one, I think it's important to recognize that this is the first group of people that
[0:53:59] we sent back to the University of Virginia, and we have subsequently sent more back.
[0:54:03] And part of our conversations, as you'll recall in our budget, we have allocated additional
[0:54:07] money for the additional training moving forward.
[0:54:11] And we've sat down and we've said, how do you get more momentum?
[0:54:14] How do you get more people involved?
[0:54:16] And we found that we will be able to bring 80 people through this process by bringing the
[0:54:23] University of Virginia to us and that concept as opposed to continuing to send many, many
[0:54:28] people back at a much higher cost.
[0:54:31] So by getting 40 people exposed to how we want to work, operate and install some new organizational
[0:54:42] value sets that are different than what have been there in the past, and then getting another
[0:54:47] 40 of individuals that really understand the mechanics of this process moving forward.
[0:54:52] I think it is a couple of things that I would emphasize from what I've heard so far, and
[0:54:58] that is, number one, it is okay to work outside of your silo.
[0:55:03] And really what happens is when we think of the level of public service and we start thinking
[0:55:08] about, let's say, the issue that was distracting John last week.
[0:55:13] Oftentimes, it's our organizational culture
[0:55:16] to look at that as a public works issue,
[0:55:18] a water department problem.
[0:55:22] It really is an organizational problem.
[0:55:24] It is an organizational issue that organizationally,
[0:55:27] if we have the tools and learning how to better collaborate,
[0:55:31] there will be more people outside of other departments
[0:55:34] that can come in and assist John.
[0:55:37] And so we had the conversation last week about public notification and what did we do and
[0:55:42] how did we move forward with public notification.
[0:55:45] And although we admit that we, and I think that everyone recognizes that we followed the letter
[0:55:51] of the law, but there is a question of did we go far enough and how do we go far enough
[0:55:56] and how do you get individuals inside of an organization to think outside of their boxes
[0:56:03] and the parameters where they've been siloed for a long period of time.
[0:56:07] How do we get people to bring their tools to assist and move forward and become more
[0:56:12] nimble?
[0:56:14] And that's really how our community wins and gains.
[0:56:18] They win and gain because we have a better ability to provide our full menu and collection
[0:56:26] of public services at a time and a moment's notice rather than relying just upon a single
[0:56:31] department to deliver that.
[0:56:34] And so in this case, as we've talked about and started our debriefing, and we will be
[0:56:38] bringing to the City Council ways and strategies in which we believe not only do we have the
[0:56:44] tools to better communicate, but how we plan on employing them, but really it talks about
[0:56:48] communicating internally first, recognizing the tools and the assets that the others bring,
[0:56:56] and then showing that it's okay to have those tools leveraged forward.
[0:57:00] I just wanted to share a few of my own personal perspectives
[0:57:09] take from the school.
[0:57:13] We attended the training together.
[0:57:14] The three of us in Virginia was just a little over one week.
[0:57:19] And the way I saw it, the training
[0:57:20] was divided up into two segments.
[0:57:22] The HPO model, talking about the change model,
[0:57:25] the fundamentals, and the principles.
[0:57:28] And the second half, which really distinguishes itself
[0:57:30] from any other leadership training that I've attended,
[0:57:33] and I've been going to leadership training
[0:57:35] since I was 18 years old.
[0:57:37] This really focused on self-development.
[0:57:39] It asked you to look within to see
[0:57:41] if you needed to change or if you could improve.
[0:57:44] And so that's really the way I saw that training
[0:57:47] as being divided.
[0:57:53] Just coming out of it, really my entire leadership
[0:57:56] philosophy has been challenged.
[0:57:59] One area that has been challenged in
[0:58:02] is really talking about leadership in describing the possibilities to the people that you lead.
[0:58:09] So leadership is about enrolling people in the sense of possibilities. Leadership is
[0:58:14] about helping others grow into the possibility, not creating expectations for them to live
[0:58:20] up to. So in the past, leadership has always been an acronym. These are the leadership traits
[0:58:25] that you must possess to be a good leader, and you will direct your people in this manner.
[0:58:31] And this is really talking about developing those people and showing them the possibilities
[0:58:36] and letting them develop into the people that they are.
[0:58:43] Coming out of the training, I actually view myself completely different now.
[0:58:49] I don't just see myself as a captain in the police department, but I also see myself as
[0:58:55] as a city employee whose responsibility it is to make public works successful as well.
[0:59:01] And also to make HR successful.
[0:59:05] So now Gretchen and John and I have this connection that we're really working with each other.
[0:59:10] There's probably not a week that goes by that I don't visit with Gretchen
[0:59:15] and it can't be any more than two weeks that I'm not visiting with John in reference to work.
[0:59:20] work. So it really has broke down those silos that Travis talks about. And actually, I think
[0:59:27] that I really enjoy my work even more by being able to work with these departments outside
[0:59:34] of the police departments. I guess we would stand for any questions at this time.
[0:59:41] Thank you. All three of you. I'm sure we're going to have some Chris talking.
[0:59:45] Well, compliments with the three of you. I'm reading between the lines with the three of
[0:59:50] you were saying, please challenge me if I'm incorrect, but it would appear one of the
[0:59:58] tenets of what do you call this, HPO, requires a flat organization with as little vertical
[1:00:07] structure as possible.
[1:00:09] In other words, if you have too many incremental steps and people up here, they can't relate
[1:00:17] to people down here, but if you have a broader this way, you're doing more not only department
[1:00:23] to department, but even within the police department, you're working more results rather
[1:00:31] than job position definitions.
[1:00:35] Is there some merit to that?
[1:00:36] Councilman, I would say that you're very observant, because that is exactly what this is talking
[1:00:41] about.
[1:00:42] It's talking about flattening out the organization.
[1:00:44] And that's a challenge to the Council on how vertical versus horizontal maker organization
[1:00:51] travels you want to make on it.
[1:00:56] So part of the HPO process, it respects the hierarchy because there are times in which
[1:01:00] you have to operate within a hierarchy.
[1:01:03] But part of that model is it says is that not all operations and not all decisions have
[1:01:08] to occur within a hierarchy.
[1:01:09] In fact, you can create this other thing called a parallel organization that has very special
[1:01:16] purposes, and they meet for very special projects.
[1:01:19] And when you walk into that, your status in a hierarchy,
[1:01:22] whatever position you may have on some organizational chart,
[1:01:25] is irrelevant because you're there to solve a problem.
[1:01:29] And a good example of where we've been doing this
[1:01:31] is the long-term planning committee.
[1:01:33] We started this process a few years ago,
[1:01:37] and one of the fruits of the high-performance process
[1:01:39] has been our long-term planning process,
[1:01:42] also with our strategic planning development process.
[1:01:45] All of those processes work outside of the hierarchy.
[1:01:49] So when you think about the long-term planning process
[1:01:53] and the makeup, it really is individuals
[1:01:56] from all across the organizations that are just interested,
[1:02:01] the first criteria is you're interested in being part
[1:02:04] of a problem-solving group.
[1:02:07] It was not all leaders.
[1:02:10] In fact, we had individuals that went forward that really
[1:02:14] learned about process, learned about the organization.
[1:02:18] We want to continue to move that forward,
[1:02:20] because I think that there are so many good,
[1:02:22] smart, talented people inside the organization
[1:02:25] that we don't want to have our own Jack Walsh moment.
[1:02:28] And I think that you can think about the individuals
[1:02:30] who presented during the long-term plan,
[1:02:32] some very, very talented people
[1:02:35] who were exposed to some new opportunities
[1:02:37] that contributed thoughts and ideas
[1:02:40] that may not have been included,
[1:02:42] because those at different levels may not have been aware.
[1:02:45] And so I think that we create better planning documents,
[1:02:48] we create better processes, we create better policies.
[1:02:55] The other comment that I was just going to make in support
[1:02:57] of both your comment and as a rebuttal.
[1:03:04] Part of having leadership be the work of everyone
[1:03:08] is that the small fires, the things that consume a huge amount
[1:03:14] of time at the higher levels of the organization that really should be spent in time of planning
[1:03:21] or driving direction of the organization versus putting out things that really probably could
[1:03:27] have been handled at a different level if people felt empowered and engaged to involve
[1:03:31] themselves in that is really one of the key factors of this.
[1:03:35] It doesn't mean that there isn't a hierarchy.
[1:03:38] In fact, there needs to be, but it means that employees at all levels are more engaged and
[1:03:44] more willing to take responsibility or ownership for things that are absolutely within their
[1:03:50] scope and appropriate for them to do so instead of passing it up.
[1:03:57] You know, I'm listening to you and it's interesting to me because today actually I taught a class
[1:04:03] in my class about this, about flattening the organization
[1:04:08] out and how police organizations are moving that direction.
[1:04:11] There's no better illustration on discretion in the work field
[1:04:17] than in police work.
[1:04:19] Officers have tremendous amount of discretion.
[1:04:22] And to push the decision making down and allow those officers
[1:04:25] to make those decisions is exactly what we're talking
[1:04:28] about here citywide.
[1:04:30] And you know, I used to say that we wanted a well-organized then,
[1:04:36] okay, we don't want a fat organization where there's a lot of employees,
[1:04:40] but just the right amount of employees that are effective and efficient and well-paid.
[1:04:46] But I want to take it one step further after hearing what you're saying is,
[1:04:51] we want the culture to be right.
[1:04:53] We want the culture that employees want to come to work for us,
[1:04:58] not just for the pay or the benefits or those kind of things,
[1:05:00] but actually the culture that I feel engaged
[1:05:03] and that my opinion matters and I can be part of the process.
[1:05:08] And I think that's powerful, powerful stuff.
[1:05:12] And that's really what I'm hearing from you.
[1:05:14] And I just can't help but I'm thinking of flood,
[1:05:18] and I'm gonna stay with water analogies, okay,
[1:05:20] because we've had enough time, but a snowball.
[1:05:22] I mean, this is growing.
[1:05:23] I really see it growing within our organization.
[1:05:26] Really, the long term planning committee is the one that really hit me first when we had Chuck
[1:05:32] Garner say, well I thought the city was the police, okay.
[1:05:36] You mean there's other departments in the city until he got together and really looked
[1:05:42] at that.
[1:05:43] And then the gentleman from the airport, Matt Barnes, holy moly, his presentation to the
[1:05:48] council that night was incredible and talking about partnerships and the like.
[1:05:53] So this is exciting and I think it's ground breaking and life changing for our organization.
[1:06:02] I've been affiliated with the city for since 1988 in one way or the other.
[1:06:07] And so I've seen the ebbs and flows of these kind of things and this to me seems like a
[1:06:12] very, very exciting time for our city.
[1:06:15] It's awesome.
[1:06:16] Rebecca Melsoica.
[1:06:17] Thank you, Mayor.
[1:06:18] Thank you all for sharing your experience and certainly the principles that you're talking
[1:06:22] about are very important about knowing who you are and respecting each other and communicating.
[1:06:27] But as a way of kind of drilling it down for the taxpayer, I mean how,
[1:06:32] it may be this a question for Travis, you know, I mean that with the, you know, $100,000 that we spent
[1:06:37] over the last two years or whatever that cost was for these nine people to visit there,
[1:06:42] you know, how can we demonstrate to our citizens, you know, what do they get?
[1:06:47] You know, what is the value? How do we quantify?
[1:06:50] and how do we demonstrate the value of what they're getting for what they're paying for?
[1:06:57] Yeah, so I think that's a really good question.
[1:06:58] I think it's a fair question.
[1:06:59] The first is the $100,000 is not only, it reflects future expenditures that may be made
[1:07:09] in the upcoming budget.
[1:07:10] So I think it's important to recognize that although it's in the budget, it certainly is
[1:07:14] something that we want to move forward with.
[1:07:17] What I would say is that whenever you develop a more collaborative culture, whenever you build
[1:07:23] the opportunities for teams to be able to work together, whenever you create those opportunities,
[1:07:28] not only with employees inside of an organization, but also bring in partners, you create a higher
[1:07:34] level of service.
[1:07:35] And does that mean that necessarily that we're going to be able to hatch potholes better?
[1:07:42] Maybe not.
[1:07:43] Is there a way that we can communicate beyond organizational lines that is very different than our current habit,
[1:07:51] where we have individuals that are engaged at all levels of the organizations working collaboratively,
[1:07:57] working collectively as part of one larger team?
[1:08:01] So as we have 40 or 50 vehicles out at any point in time and they are driving down a roadway
[1:08:09] And they notice a pothole that it doesn't go through this long up the chain down the chain process.
[1:08:16] But really it is the completion of a work order that immediately goes out and gets processed to be able to go get fixed.
[1:08:23] So number one, I use the pothole example because it's probably something that we could all relate to.
[1:08:28] But it is also an example about how those levels of services across our organization become much more expedient.
[1:08:37] Expediency allows us to deliver a higher quality service to our citizen, and that's what they expect.
[1:08:43] Number two, you can certainly help too, okay.
[1:08:48] Number two, I think that when you start looking at the ability to attract and
[1:08:54] retain individuals into an organization, it becomes incredibly important.
[1:09:00] Employees of any organization are the ones that deliver the quality services to the citizens.
[1:09:05] A fire truck doesn't drive itself or dispatch itself to that fire.
[1:09:09] And if you think about the level of service that started from the very first initiation,
[1:09:14] all the way through completion, by having individuals work collectively through that process,
[1:09:21] the citizen has that higher value of service.
[1:09:24] The last is innovation.
[1:09:26] Oftentimes we think that decision making in most organizations must occur at the top.
[1:09:33] What we're saying and we're challenging that by saying individuals across all of our organization
[1:09:38] have the ability to contribute and be a part of better making decisions, better solutions,
[1:09:44] more innovative practices, thinking how we deploy those levels of services in a manner
[1:09:50] that creates real savings for our citizens.
[1:09:55] I think that building the bridge and breaking down silos is one of the most fundamental things
[1:10:00] and most important things that we need to do in our organization.
[1:10:04] And we can say, well, why can't you just do that?
[1:10:07] And I will say that the organizational culture is something that is fully ingrained and it
[1:10:12] has been there over a long period of time and you have to take steps to change your culture.
[1:10:18] You have to take steps to change how you behave under key circumstances and situations.
[1:10:25] And you can only get there by first having an understanding of what those things are.
[1:10:32] And I think through that knowledge, it helps all of our employees become better public servants.
[1:10:39] And that becomes the high value that our citizens receive.
[1:10:43] Thank you.
[1:10:44] And that'll be something interesting to watch.
[1:10:46] I think that we can certainly gauge this through the Citizen Survey.
[1:10:49] And I hope that we can start to see our results through that Citizen Survey.
[1:10:54] And if we don't, then I would, if we do not see an increase in citizen survey,
[1:10:59] if we do not see an increase in performance measurement in our benchmarking,
[1:11:03] I will tell you that we need to stop with this vehicle and look for a different possibility.
[1:11:10] Thank you.
[1:11:12] The other thing that I would just sort of touch on in answer to your question, Rebecca,
[1:11:18] is about value and values of our community.
[1:11:22] So our strategic community vision for 2030 touches on areas that as an organization, as a city service organization, we've never gone before.
[1:11:38] And they are noble objectives, creating an active and healthy community, creating an educated community, created a networked community.
[1:11:51] Things are not, things typically that you would be looking towards a public works department
[1:11:56] or an HR department or the police force to be trying to tackle in order to accomplish
[1:12:03] those in order to exceed the expectations of both a community that helped write those
[1:12:12] and we that committed them to them.
[1:12:15] We need to be able to have employees that are really thinking much more broadly in terms
[1:12:20] of just their role within the organization.
[1:12:23] We need them to connect to that plan and we need them to be thinking about ways that they
[1:12:27] can contribute to that.
[1:12:30] As an organization we have had for a number of years a mission statement, what we don't
[1:12:35] have is a value statement and that really gets again to that seventh question, how are
[1:12:40] we going to treat each other and how are we going to treat our customers and if that extends
[1:12:44] beyond I do my role for my job that I have to how can I impact how can I contribute
[1:12:51] how can I lead how can I broaden what I bring to the table I think that's a very
[1:12:57] worthwhile objective to pursue I see no further lights John Anthony Gretchen thank
[1:13:06] you for the presentation it was enlightening and keep up good work really
[1:13:11] appreciate it next item on the agenda is public input and or items from city
[1:13:17] City Manager, City Council. This is time for City Council to obviously, if there's any
[1:13:21] advisory board information or anything like that, but we will start as we always do with
[1:13:26] the public. Is there anyone here from the public that would like to address the council?
[1:13:32] City Manager, City Council. Chris Tommy.
[1:13:37] John can give us a 32nd wrap up of when the orchard Washington intersection will be passable.
[1:13:44] Not that Chris and I have had to drive that a few times recently.
[1:13:49] know it's the rain is slowing us down a little bit. I always want to excuse for another. We've
[1:13:57] got the water lines put back together with pulled samples so which means part of the intersection
[1:14:06] we couldn't start back building and building because those pipes weren't put together. So
[1:14:12] if the weather was clear we would be starting to build the section tomorrow and we have bids
[1:14:18] out for paving, ideally we were hoping to be depending on the availability of a
[1:14:23] paver. We would be probably ready to pave at the very end of this week and
[1:14:29] that's weather dependent, you know, if we can't get out of the rain and actually
[1:14:33] having to forecast today. Start to dry out. So that's the plan. So that's the case
[1:14:42] scenario is towards the end of the week and again it's dependent on paver
[1:14:46] availability and weather.
[1:14:49] Thank you.
[1:14:50] Thank you, John.
[1:14:51] Rebecca Milsoy.
[1:14:52] Thank you, Mayor.
[1:14:53] I have a quick question for Fritz.
[1:14:55] It came up at last Tuesday's P&Z meeting.
[1:14:58] And I saw a chair with the council because it was really interesting and I wasn't aware
[1:15:02] of it.
[1:15:03] We had two SUPs come through for drive-throughs.
[1:15:06] And they noticed the map of the parking and the drive-throughs didn't match our new parking
[1:15:13] codes.
[1:15:14] But what they were saying at P&Z was that because it was submitted before the new changes
[1:15:21] were codified, those codes won't apply to this entire process.
[1:15:26] So could you maybe explain why that is and how that is?
[1:15:30] So a person's rights are established at the time of applications.
[1:15:34] In this case, they were applications for building permits.
[1:15:38] So it's not true that it applies to the entire development, but it will apply to every building
[1:15:43] permit applied for, but it's like it's sort of common sense, you know, citizens,
[1:15:48] rights are established at the time, they apply for something and the city
[1:15:52] can't change it in midstream and change the standards that they have to comply with.
[1:15:59] Yeah, well it's just interesting to me because at the end of each, especially to use permit,
[1:16:05] there's kind of a general condition that says it will comply with all current
[1:16:11] city codes at the time of building so but when this when these are built they
[1:16:18] actually won't comply with the current parking codes they will comply with the
[1:16:25] ones that in effect at the time of application okay yeah so I mean I I
[1:16:30] didn't realize that and so I guess the moral of the story for us is to really be
[1:16:35] on top of our code changes and so also I want to bring an update for how well
[1:16:40] all P and Z is doing on the task that the Council has given them with updating codes.
[1:16:48] They do have a meeting this Wednesday at noon, it's a lunch meeting, it's open to the public,
[1:16:52] and I'm happy to say that we've had several citizens come and participate and bring up issues.
[1:17:00] They're currently working on the updated notification standards that we talked about.
[1:17:07] I believe they have a couple of changes ready for public hearing one concerning the ZDA,
[1:17:15] the zone development agreement.
[1:17:17] Mitch, do you know when that's going to be up for public hearing?
[1:17:20] I think that was the next one that's going to be coming before them.
[1:17:27] That one hasn't scheduled for the council yet, but that will be the next one.
[1:17:31] Oh, for PZ, right.
[1:17:32] Yeah, that will be the next one that comes up.
[1:17:33] We've got to prepare the ordinance now.
[1:17:35] I've got all the languages changed,
[1:17:38] and we've presented it to the commission in there,
[1:17:42] that basically said, yeah, that's the one we want to have,
[1:17:44] come through our hearing process,
[1:17:46] and so we're preparing the ordinance,
[1:17:47] and once that's ready, we'll notify it.
[1:17:49] It'll probably be in, I'm guessing that second meeting
[1:17:53] in October would be the one that they would see it at,
[1:17:56] and then maybe a month later, before it got here,
[1:17:59] to the council.
[1:18:00] And on Wednesday, we are gonna go over a draft
[1:18:02] of the notification changes.
[1:18:06] Great, so for the public's benefit,
[1:18:08] that's the update on P&Z work sessions
[1:18:11] and the value of keeping our codes updated,
[1:18:15] because really it's such a delayed process.
[1:18:18] Even after you make the code,
[1:18:19] there's still a lot of development that goes through,
[1:18:22] you know, based on our current standards.
[1:18:24] Thank you, Rebecca.
[1:18:25] Anything further before we move into a German
[1:18:28] into executive session, potentially?
[1:18:32] All right, next item on the agenda is adjournment into executive session 6,723, 45, 1, a, b, c, we've added c and f, I'll read all four.
[1:18:43] To consider hiring a public officer, employees, staff member or individual agent, we're in the respective qualities of the individual are to be evaluated in order to fill a particular vacancy or need.
[1:18:54] This paragraph does not apply to filling a vacancy in an elected office or deliberations
[1:19:00] about staffing, needs in general, and B, to consider the evaluation dismissal or disciplining
[1:19:06] or to hear complaints or charges brought against a public officer, employee, staff member or
[1:19:12] individual agent or public school student, and C, to conduct deliberations concerning
[1:19:19] labor negotiations or to acquire an interest in real property which is not owned by a public
[1:19:24] agency.
[1:19:26] And F to communicate with legal counsel for the public agency to discuss the legal ramifications
[1:19:32] of and legal options for pending litigation or controversies not yet being litigated but
[1:19:38] eminently likely to be litigated.
[1:19:41] The mere presence of legal counsel at an executive session does not satisfy this requirement.
[1:19:47] Greg Lanning.
[1:19:48] All moved.
[1:19:50] Easy for you to say.
[1:19:51] Second.
[1:19:52] We have motion on the floor by Greg Lanting, seconded
[1:19:54] by Suzanne Hawkins to move into executive session as outlined.
[1:19:58] Anything further on that?
[1:20:00] Motion, council.
[1:20:03] The aye the roll call vote, please.
[1:20:06] Yes.
[1:20:09] Don Hall?
[1:20:10] Yes.
[1:20:10] Rebecca Masleka?
[1:20:11] Yes.
[1:20:12] Suzanne Hawkins?
[1:20:13] Yes.
[1:20:15] Sean Berriger?
[1:20:15] Yes.
[1:20:16] Chris Talkington.
[1:20:17] Yes.
[1:20:18] Motion passes 6-0 before we move into executive session.
[1:20:21] I want to make known that we will be going into the executive session.
[1:20:24] We will not be making any decisions in there, nor will we be coming back out and reconvening
[1:20:29] this evening.
[1:20:30] With that, we are adjourned in the executive session.
