Oversight Archive: City Council meeting, 2014-11-17, recording 1 (started 17:00)
Machine transcript (faster-whisper base.en), not checked word for word; the Pledge of Allegiance is shown in its standard wording. The recording is the record.
Times are time into the recording. Passages with private details are muted in the audio and marked here.
The audio on the page below was re-encoded by software from the video the agency posted. Check any passage against
that audio before relying on it.
Page: https://oversightarchive.org/twin-falls-id/meetings/2014-11-17/

[0:00:00] And I think he started to wonder what I was doing.
[0:00:04] Thank you.
[0:00:05] Next item on the agenda is discussion and adoption of the recommended changes to the city's organizational structure.
[0:00:12] We have our city manager, Trevor Strathweiler.
[0:00:14] Thank you.
[0:00:15] Mr. Mayor, members, the council, before you is the organizational structure conversation.
[0:00:21] We presented this to you about a month ago, and we wanted to give that time to digest and to be able to move forward.
[0:00:29] that move forward and have some conversations internally as we continue to move forward.
[0:00:34] And tonight we're asking you to take a series of steps and in those series of steps then
[0:00:40] we will act almost as a series of subsequent steps in moving forward.
[0:00:45] So tonight before you we have three pieces.
[0:00:49] The first piece is to recommend the organizational change and structure and then it is to then
[0:00:54] Assign the duties of the DCM to the two individuals that we spoke up earlier.
[0:01:00] The first would be to Mitch Humboldt as the Deputy City Manager for Community Services and Development.
[0:01:05] And the second would be to Brian Pike, the Deputy City Manager for Public Safety.
[0:01:12] Right up on the board, as we illustrated, is the current city of Twin Falls Organizational Structure.
[0:01:18] And this structure has really served us well for a long period of time.
[0:01:23] And as we continue to evolve into a new strategic planning process, what we did was we wanted
[0:01:28] to make sure that all of our systems were lined up against our strategic plan.
[0:01:41] So in February of 2014, an opportunity presented itself to begin to look at our organization.
[0:01:48] And we spent time taking a look at that organization in which 37 individuals across our organization
[0:01:53] had the opportunity to comment and to provide their thoughts, as well as members of the city
[0:01:59] council as we went forward.
[0:02:01] What we did was we aligned all of the different sections in accordance to our strategic plan
[0:02:07] and it's denoted on the colors listed above.
[0:02:12] When we started this process we had a series of goals.
[0:02:15] Those goals were established through a series of conversations.
[0:02:18] One of the first and most important things we wanted to do was to make sure that we
[0:02:22] were enhancing our organizational effectiveness.
[0:02:26] I think that we can all clearly recognize over the course of the last few years it has
[0:02:30] become very busy and things have become moving at a much faster clip and we've been doing
[0:02:38] more.
[0:02:39] We wanted to make sure that the organizational structure was not an impediment to serving
[0:02:43] the citizens and accomplishing the goals of the strategic plan which was the second
[0:02:48] piece.
[0:02:49] We wanted to make sure that we were providing an intentional emphasis to implement the
[0:02:52] strategic plan that we had clear lines of opportunity that we were looking at finding
[0:02:59] ways to enhance collaboration with our partners, not only internal partners but also external
[0:03:05] partners, finding ways that we can carry that conversation and recognizing that we're really
[0:03:11] a one city concept.
[0:03:14] One organization serving 45,000 residents in our community and 70,000 members of a larger
[0:03:21] Magic Valley area that come to our area.
[0:03:25] We wanted to make sure that we were finding opportunities to drive decision-making downward.
[0:03:31] And that comes not only with an organ structure review, but also how we communicate with our
[0:03:36] citizens and tap the energy and the initiative that our employees have in face.
[0:03:45] We spent a lot of time going through what this plan is.
[0:03:49] And I want to maybe take a few minutes to talk about some of the larger things.
[0:03:54] The first thing that we do is we create two deputy city manager positions.
[0:04:00] We move forward and we separate engineering and public works.
[0:04:05] And we have economic development report directly to me.
[0:04:09] Also we're finding a way to take information and technology and create one opportunity for
[0:04:15] technology and communication or working in harmony to ensure that our citizens have the
[0:04:21] information that they need and the opportunities to access our organization through process.
[0:04:29] Really Mary and Council I think that the best thing that I could do is open it up for questions
[0:04:33] that you might have as we continue to move forward with the conversation.
[0:04:38] Thank you Travis.
[0:04:39] Do we have any questions for Travis?
[0:04:41] Christoshina.
[0:04:42] I've asked this before it will sound redundant but I think we still need to my virtue of the
[0:04:50] departure from the existing structure have passed and the reorganization effort of all
[0:04:57] the city staff and some learning curve.
[0:05:01] We still need to look back a year from now and say, how do we measure?
[0:05:06] How did we do?
[0:05:07] Have you given us some thought and we're getting an imprecise science of public administration.
[0:05:15] Nonetheless, I think the council and probably the public will say, well, how do you know
[0:05:20] if you're succeeding or failing.
[0:05:22] Right.
[0:05:23] I think that's an incredibly fair question, and I think that part of it goes to the imprecise
[0:05:28] science that really is where we're at.
[0:05:31] I hate to say that you'll know effectiveness when you see it, but we certainly recognize
[0:05:36] them when we're not being effective and able to move forward.
[0:05:39] I believe that our organizational structure needs to be reviewed frequently.
[0:05:46] far too long I think that our organizational structure was static and it had a process
[0:05:56] that was very good for its time. I think that we're working in much more dynamic times.
[0:06:00] So some of the things that I've talked a little bit about is number one, we want to be able
[0:06:06] to measure our collaborative opportunities, which is one of the primary goals of the strategic
[0:06:12] plan, not only internally but also externally, and we want to be able to come back and report
[0:06:17] to you how these structures created intentional collaboration.
[0:06:21] We want to be able to report to you the opportunities that I've been able to better collaborate
[0:06:26] with our partners, oftentimes, and one of the things that I often hear is my schedule
[0:06:33] often becomes focused in the day-to-day tasks and not necessarily on assisting the Council
[0:06:41] achieve strategic visions and the strategic partnerships that we need to have with our partners.
[0:06:47] And I think that we've talked tonight, if that was a theme of tonight's meeting, it is
[0:06:52] about collaboration and about partnerships.
[0:06:55] I think that we'll be able to measure that.
[0:06:57] I think that when you think back into 2007 and you think that we've done, well we've
[0:07:03] committed approximately $167 million of capital projects, a lot of that is falling on the
[0:07:09] the backs of key departments and when one department is successful it is causing a significant
[0:07:15] workload and increase in another area.
[0:07:18] The ideas and the opportunities of having all of these partners working together internal
[0:07:23] and external hopefully provides a better level of service and hopefully we know that
[0:07:30] we will have gotten it right when we look back at our citizen survey and we see those
[0:07:37] key marks in our Citizen Survey as showing significant scientific improvement.
[0:07:41] So I guess it's fair to say that the strategic plan is much more of an operational guide for
[0:07:50] us day by day and the measuring through the citizens survey every couple years when we do
[0:07:59] that.
[0:08:00] We will begin preparing for this, actually the Citizen Survey in less than a year.
[0:08:08] It may not be an uptime to see a measurable move on the dial.
[0:08:13] It's worth talking about, but as long as our strategic planning has incorporated the things
[0:08:20] that we haven't, witnesses seem that are going to happen tomorrow, a business leaving
[0:08:26] town, emergency show up, I mean, we have to build into this plan that flexibility to adapt
[0:08:35] the unknown for the changes and for the emergencies?
[0:08:39] Absolutely.
[0:08:40] And I think that you bring up another good point about the structure is that it is designed to be able to grow as we grow as a community and as an organization, whatever that looks like.
[0:08:51] The box is in yellow, really illustrate that.
[0:08:54] Whether it be emergency preparedness or it talks about transportation, it begins to assign those tasks that we know that are important as we move forward.
[0:09:02] And they say that these are things that we need to take a look at.
[0:09:06] Also taking a look at economic development.
[0:09:08] If you think about the work that Melinda and the team of economic development people have
[0:09:13] done over the course of the last three years, you have to get really excited about that.
[0:09:17] And then if you think about what that could look like, if we are able to do some of our
[0:09:22] own direct campaigning and marketing to go out and capture companies to come directly
[0:09:28] into our community that we would be able to better communicate with those strong
[0:09:32] business partners that are already here to get a better sense. All things that are
[0:09:37] critical in the successful economic development process that right now because
[0:09:41] of where our focus is and the manpower that we have it is just one of those
[0:09:47] things that we'll have to continue to build and grow into.
[0:09:51] Melinda and her team they've done a great job but it's important to remember
[0:09:55] that it is Melinda, a team of one, and then a whole bunch of community partners from the
[0:10:01] Council, from the Urban Renewal Agency, from the Southern Idaho Economic Development Organization,
[0:10:07] from the Chamber of Commerce, all working collaboratively to expand our economy.
[0:10:11] Thank you for being an awful humble, you are a huge part of all that.
[0:10:17] Rebecca, Mel, so I guess.
[0:10:19] That's true.
[0:10:20] Great job, Travis.
[0:10:21] We know your leadership that you've brought to the economic development efforts, so I appreciate
[0:10:25] that.
[0:10:26] I do have a couple of questions and comments, same as Chris, you know, I know I've stated
[0:10:32] them before so I don't mean to be redundant, but I know this is the first time I think
[0:10:35] that we've had the public discussion.
[0:10:38] You know, I certainly see the need for reorganization and I do agree with the goals that you've
[0:10:44] laid out for your reorganization, especially maintaining and enhancing organizational
[0:10:50] effectiveness, enhance collaboration with partner organizations, and minimize the cost
[0:10:55] impacts and so but some areas on this flowchart do give me a little bit of
[0:11:01] concern on how they might impede those goals. For example the the two city managers
[0:11:09] and since of the one and I recognize that this right now this change is is budget
[0:11:15] neutral but I was wondering what is the exact cost of each deputy city manager.
[0:11:22] That's a great question.
[0:11:24] And so when you look at moving in terms of the market,
[0:11:27] what's important is looking at where they're at
[0:11:30] and then looking at what good logical steps will be.
[0:11:34] So let me just so folks know,
[0:11:42] we do have a public hearing set for six o'clock
[0:11:45] or beyond obviously we're going a little bit beyond six o'clock.
[0:11:49] That will be, this is the last item on the agenda
[0:11:54] other than public input and a few other things
[0:11:56] Council and then we'll move into that public hearing.
[0:12:04] So what you can see up there is the salaries for the Deputy City Manager, but to put that
[0:12:09] in context I think that you also have to look at that as where they are currently positioned
[0:12:14] based upon current salaries inside the organization.
[0:12:18] You can see that the increase to Mr. Humboldt is about $4800 a year and the increase to Chief
[0:12:29] Pike is, let's just say, under $12,000 a year, those positions, I believe, as following our
[0:12:37] policy, it is important to recognize that they are both coming in and they're starting in
[0:12:41] those roles on the exact same day. And so we would start those at the exact same place,
[0:12:47] moving forward. Also, the position in moving up in terms is in compliance with our Compensation
[0:12:57] plan, the Human Resource Department and Susan and Gretchen helped me go through this, and
[0:13:01] BDPA also went through and evaluated the roles and the positions as in terms of equity in our pay matrix.
[0:13:16] Thank you for that.
[0:13:18] So going back to the flow chart, I think the concern I have is really with the public safety area.
[0:13:25] But the breakup of the departments under each deputy city manager is a bit unequal.
[0:13:31] You have about nine plus departments under the community development, which depending on how you count them up.
[0:13:38] And then you have your two existing departments, police and fire, dispatch, which is part of police,
[0:13:45] and code enforcement currently under planning and zoning.
[0:13:49] So, I've trouble justifying the cost of this deputy city manager with, I guess, the number
[0:13:57] of departments they would be over, although I understand the task is huge and I understand
[0:14:02] that the strategic plan has a lot of safety objectives.
[0:14:08] So I like the concept of having someone specifically devoted to that strategic plan and those objectives,
[0:14:16] But I'm struggling with the concept of adding another layer of bureaucracy on the administrative
[0:14:23] end, which is pretty costly for the taxpayers versus the benefit.
[0:14:34] So just some feedback in areas where I'm concerned, you know, that it may provide a stumbling
[0:14:42] block as far as maintaining our organizational effectiveness or enhancing that, you know,
[0:14:48] if we're creating another layer of bureaucracy, usually bureaucracy and efficiency don't really
[0:14:54] go together.
[0:14:59] And I also don't support taking over any portion of emergency preparedness from the county because
[0:15:05] it is, I think, a better benefit to have a regional position.
[0:15:10] They have access to federal funds. It's a federally funded position, and I really think it benefits us more to work together with our county partners.
[0:15:19] Greg Manning, Bob, did you have a comment on that travel store?
[0:15:26] Yeah, so number one, I think it's important to recognize that when we went through the strategic planning process, we stated that all strategic plan goals were of equal importance.
[0:15:35] that there was not one strategic planning goal that was
[0:15:38] subservient to another.
[0:15:40] And so we wanted to make sure that we were breaking out
[0:15:42] all of those goals, and that was part of that strategy.
[0:15:45] I also think that when you take a look at the number
[0:15:47] of departments, don't be misled by the fact of the number
[0:15:50] of employees that are serving under each one of those
[0:15:52] different areas.
[0:15:54] Because when you start looking at the total number of bodies
[0:15:57] that we have in the organization, it's not the same number
[0:16:00] of people working in the police department as you may have
[0:16:02] working in the building department and so on and so forth.
[0:16:05] And so really when you start looking at the total number of employees that these individuals
[0:16:10] are going to report to, it becomes a lot more equal than what may be appeared here.
[0:16:15] I think it's also important to recognize that when you look at those different functions,
[0:16:20] what we wanted to try to do is try to provide common connectedness.
[0:16:39] And so one of the things that we did in addition was we created these strategic planning cabinets
[0:16:46] that are going to be parallel organizations that you're going to have really apartments
[0:16:51] not only working under their collaborative partnerships, but also reaching out beyond beyond so that
[0:16:58] we weren't driving it by silos. One of the things that we don't necessarily spend a lot
[0:17:04] of time organizationally on is thinking about those steps like Councilman Talkington was talking
[0:17:10] about earlier. In nine years from now, we may have problems associated with public transportation
[0:17:16] and what does that look like. The model that we have right now really has us focusing on
[0:17:21] critical tasks today. The model that we're trying to build allows us to focus in and move forward
[0:17:27] to anticipate some of those issues moving organization and coordination with the strategic plan.
[0:17:33] I couldn't agree more with you when it comes to what Jackie Fry and her office is able to
[0:17:40] do for us. And again, make no mistake. That up there is a task that we need to move forward
[0:17:46] with, it does not describe the creation of a position, any creation of a position would
[0:17:51] have to be approved by a council, and at this point in time, we don't know what that looks
[0:17:56] like. What we do know is that when an emergency occurs in our community, and unfortunately,
[0:18:03] we have had three issues over the course of the last 18 months that have caused us to
[0:18:08] bring all of our resources together, this is a reminder that when those incidences occur,
[0:18:15] It is absolutely critical that our teams have the ability to respond.
[0:18:20] Jackie Fry and her team are absolutely valuable resources that will be able to help us move
[0:18:25] that forward.
[0:18:26] But I believe it's critical and important for the citizens of Twin Falls to have a staff
[0:18:32] that is coordinated in emergencies that are directly occurring inside the City of Twin
[0:18:37] Falls where we have primary jurisdiction and responsibility.
[0:18:42] planning. Perhaps I want to, I guess I'm starting to discuss this. I like the looks of this plan.
[0:18:56] We obviously, I think we have been, I don't think we've slowed our community down, but we may
[0:19:03] have overworked one individual and that individual being you by investing too much responsibility
[0:19:09] in your position and my responsibility, I mean, you have to, you're under there, our current
[0:19:17] structure, you have to have a finger in everything and I know you're still going to have a small
[0:19:22] finger in everything, they're in deep doubt in my mind. But I mean by going to the two deputy city
[0:19:27] managers, I believe that we're dividing up the workload so that you can be, get back to some
[0:19:36] things from visionary things that I think you haven't had the time to to give
[0:19:41] your full attention to and so by having these two individuals take care we you
[0:19:48] know you go back and forth or who should be under who and I know I know from
[0:19:53] experience that I've been in the city long enough now to know that the police
[0:19:57] in the fire are two of our largest departments and thus have the numbers
[0:20:04] match up. I like Chris. I want to see, I obviously want to bang for a buck and I
[0:20:09] want to see that you know three years from now we're going wow yeah that's a
[0:20:12] great idea for us to separate this out and make this happen and if it doesn't I
[0:20:19] would assume this or a future council may decide to tweak this in a different
[0:20:24] way to make sure that that it is being doing what it needs to be for the
[0:20:29] citizens to in falls. Thank you for your efforts on this. I really still have a
[0:20:36] hard time believing that our police chief is going to be a civilian now. I
[0:20:41] think he's having a hard time with that a little bit too. But it works and I will
[0:20:48] be voting for this reorganization. Thank you. Jim. Thank you Mayor. I think that I'm
[0:20:54] fully supported and I think we need to proceed with this. I've heard it in one
[0:20:58] public hearing where you would feel made an extraordinary presentation so I think we're
[0:21:02] ready to proceed.
[0:21:03] May I move to approve the organizational structure changes approved by the city as proposed by the
[0:21:09] city manager?
[0:21:10] Second.
[0:21:11] We have a motion on board by Jim Montes, seconded by Chris Talkington as stated.
[0:21:16] I want to just jump in.
[0:21:18] We have an incredibly complex organization where we have to deal with dog calls, police
[0:21:27] waterfalls, trash complaints, wastewater treatment issues, water issues, potholes, it's incredibly
[0:21:39] complex. And one of the things that I think that we've done is we've put too much pressure
[0:21:49] on our city manager, especially when we've been so successful in our economic development.
[0:21:57] Every time one of these things come our way, they're a blessing for our community, but the
[0:22:02] work just begins for our staff.
[0:22:05] And I don't see that this organizational change is going to make it more complex or stymie
[0:22:14] our ability to communicate with our community.
[0:22:17] I think it's going to enhance the ability for us to communicate and to move this organization
[0:22:25] forward. And as far as trying to figure out if it's successful or not, I think one
[0:22:31] of the biggest measures that we can use in the future is just that ongoing
[0:22:35] communication with our community to find out if it's working. I was in the
[0:22:42] prevention field for many years and it's very, very difficult to prove
[0:22:48] prevention. How do you prove that you prevented something other than those
[0:22:52] one-on-one communication with our citizens and finding out if we're truly making a difference.
[0:22:58] And I think this organizational chart and structure will help us do that. It'll get, and we have the
[0:23:05] same. We want our leader, the captain of our ship, out of the engine room, greasing things, and up on
[0:23:13] the bridge helping to guide the ship forward. And I think that's what this organizational structure
[0:23:21] will allow us to do is to get our captain up on the bridge,
[0:23:25] helping to guide us forward.
[0:23:28] Rebecca, may I'll switch them?
[0:23:30] Thank you, Mayor.
[0:23:32] I think this is a difficult decision.
[0:23:34] And I certainly have gone back and forth.
[0:23:35] And I think Travis for all the information and conversations
[0:23:38] that we've had, it's certainly been helpful to me.
[0:23:41] And I have been thinking about it for these past few weeks.
[0:23:47] I think in the end, I don't 100% by the cost effectiveness or
[0:23:53] the benefit of the two deputy city managers.
[0:23:59] But please don't mistake that for a lack of confidence in city staff because I have
[0:24:04] every confidence in city staff.
[0:24:07] I don't necessarily support this flow chart, this reorganization, every aspect of it.
[0:24:13] Because I would prefer that we would enhance staff levels on the service end in the employee pool.
[0:24:21] There's people that are out there working on the streets and providing those services.
[0:24:28] For example, the deputy city clerk, I think that's definitely a position that's justified.
[0:24:33] We can see the amount of work.
[0:24:35] We can also see the benefit that will come from it.
[0:24:37] So, I'm not 100% confident in the cost benefit ratio of the two deputy city manager positions,
[0:24:50] but I do want to state that I have every confidence that we'll move forward and that your staff
[0:24:57] and you will do a great job of meeting our strategic plan and I agree with the council
[0:25:03] members that stated the importance of measuring our success and I hope that we
[0:25:08] do keep a close eye on the citizen survey and other factors that will
[0:25:13] indicate how we're doing. Thank you.
[0:25:16] The other roll call vote please.
[0:25:18] Sean Berriger.
[0:25:21] Yes.
[0:25:22] Christockington.
[0:25:23] Yes.
[0:25:24] Greg Lanthi.
[0:25:25] Yes.
[0:25:26] Don Hall.
[0:25:27] Yes.
[0:25:28] Rebecca Milsoica.
[0:25:30] No.
[0:25:31] Suzanne Hawkins.
[0:25:32] Yes.
[0:25:33] Jim Munn.
[0:25:34] Yes.
[0:25:35] Just so council knows we have two other directions that we need to go this evening, and those are the two deputy city managers
[0:25:43] Can we do it? No, I have to do this do we have to do those separately?
[0:25:47] We should we should do it separately, and we're just creating the position
[0:25:52] Correct well, we're we're appointing or we're recommending those to be appointed so the strategy will be that we will
[0:26:00] move for those to be appointed because the minute one in particular a certain
[0:26:07] chief of police role I'm assuming that Brian would would like to have some
[0:26:14] level of assurance that he has a role in our organization as we go out and
[0:26:20] begin a recruitment for a chief of police position so what we want to do is to have
[0:26:25] them slated for those slots. And then we will come back and right now on December 8th, depending
[0:26:33] upon if that works for their families, because a swearing in is a very, very big date. This
[0:26:36] isn't an official thing. This isn't, we'll have an official swearing in either on December
[0:26:42] 8th if that works for their families. And with an effective date, in my opinion, of January
[0:26:47] 1.
[0:26:48] Thank you.
[0:26:49] Jim Munn.
[0:26:50] move to approve the appointment of Mr. Brian Pike to the position of Deputy City Manager for the City of Twin Falls effective.
[0:26:58] You indicate January 1 or December 1 January 1 January 1 we have a motion on the floor by Jim Mon seconded by Suzanne Hawkins.
[0:27:08] I believe you almost called him a deputy chief manager.
[0:27:13] I can't get beyond Brian, but to appoint him January 1st as Deputy City Manager.
[0:27:20] Anything further on that motion, Council?
[0:27:23] Chris, talk?
[0:27:24] Yeah, I'm just a little confused.
[0:27:25] They will not report to the Council.
[0:27:28] They report to you, so I'm still a little unsure why we're doing this unless it has something to do with Percy.
[0:27:35] So, the city code states that all department head appointments by the city manager shall
[0:27:44] be confirmed by the city council.
[0:27:48] Now Fritz and I have looked at the city code and it does not define who a department head
[0:27:52] is.
[0:27:53] So one of the things that we're going to do is bring back your ordinance clearly defining
[0:27:56] what a department head is.
[0:27:58] I think that we could make a very strong case that deputy city managers would rise to the
[0:28:03] department head status.
[0:28:05] I personally believe that any time that the city manager wants to take this type of step
[0:28:12] organizationally, the council needs to be involved in that decision-making process.
[0:28:16] Well, explain, thank you.
[0:28:18] You know, I really look at it the same as when I make appointments as the mayor to a committee.
[0:28:24] It's always confirmed by the council.
[0:28:26] And I think that's just a great check and balance in our system and our form of government.
[0:28:31] Anything further on the motion council?
[0:28:34] The island roll call vote please.
[0:28:35] Chris talking.
[0:28:36] Yes.
[0:28:37] Greg Lansing.
[0:28:37] Yes.
[0:28:38] Don Hall.
[0:28:39] Yes.
[0:28:39] Rebecca Milsoica.
[0:28:40] No.
[0:28:43] Suzanne Hawkins.
[0:28:44] Yes.
[0:28:45] Jim Munn.
[0:28:45] Yes.
[0:28:46] Sean Garver.
[0:28:47] Yes.
[0:28:47] Motion passes 6 to 1.
[0:28:49] So who do I do?
[0:28:50] Suzanne Hawkins, I think.
[0:28:52] I would like to make a motion that we create the Office of Deputy City Manager, Community, Service, and Development, and appoint Mitch Humble to fill that role.
[0:29:02] Second.
[0:29:02] We have a motion on the floor by Suzanne Hawkins,
[0:29:05] seconded by Sean Berriger to create the second
[0:29:10] deputy city manager and that person to be named Mitch Humble.
[0:29:15] Anything further on the motion council?
[0:29:18] Lee, the roll call vote please.
[0:29:20] Greg Lanting.
[0:29:21] Yes.
[0:29:21] Don Hall.
[0:29:22] Yes.
[0:29:23] Perfect, Ms. Leika.
[0:29:24] No.
[0:29:25] Suzanne Hawkins.
[0:29:26] Yes.
[0:29:26] Jim Munn.
[0:29:27] Yes.
[0:29:28] Sean Berriger.
[0:29:29] Yes.
[0:29:30] Chris Tawkin.
[0:29:31] Yes.
[0:29:32] Motion passes 6-1.
[0:29:33] Thank you.
[0:29:34] Thank you
[0:29:36] Moving on to the next item on the agenda is public input and or items from City Manager City Council
[0:29:42] Is there anyone else from the public that would like to address the City Council not on something that's on the agenda?
[0:29:48] Especially with the public hearing that's coming next would like to come forward and address the City Council
[0:29:52] I see no one coming forward, so I will move it to our City Manager or anything further from our City Manager
[0:30:00] Thank you, Chris Dockington.
[0:30:03] Just a couple of minutes to update, Sean, our newest city commission, that of aging or senior citizens.
[0:30:09] We did meet last week.
[0:30:11] There were nine people in attendance and it was.
[0:30:15] Coordinate by Daphne Mallory, who many of us know.
[0:30:19] She's been here before and shown her interest in.
[0:30:22] Instigating, promoting, creating such a committee.
[0:30:27] She's very experienced in organizing the social matters of this nature.
[0:30:34] Within a little over an hour, there were 10 specific items for priorities at the group.
[0:30:42] Felt that are not being addressed and we say, well, we already have the office on aging at CSI.
[0:30:49] We have the senior center. We have transport.
[0:30:52] You'd be amazed at the number of anecdotes that people bringing items up, including assurance
[0:30:59] that the City of Twin Falls builds reverse speed bumps.
[0:31:03] Those are actually drains going across the road, but when you have a 49-foot view, you
[0:31:07] sometimes get high-center on those things to people in the audience not even aware of the
[0:31:16] block Main Street project that's going on.
[0:31:21] Singers are in a special category.
[0:31:23] We know that they are the largest demographic
[0:31:26] immigrating to Twin Falls.
[0:31:28] That most of them have paid taxes.
[0:31:31] Many of them have worked all their lives.
[0:31:34] They're not in any recognizable demographic.
[0:31:39] And yet, by virtue of their status,
[0:31:42] a number of them are single people.
[0:31:44] are the particular distinctive disadvantage in having the connectedness, the people, and
[0:31:50] a lot of our age groups still. Yes, even in my age group, Don.
[0:31:55] I'm trying to be nice. The group, I was also amazed at the positive attitude. They looked
[0:32:02] at this as a go-to team approach, one that would be responsible for coordinating CSI,
[0:32:09] your center, transfer, and much more.
[0:32:14] Some of the 10 concerns include isolation and access, transportation issues, that include
[0:32:24] sidewalks, which were making some progress on safety, whether it be personal safety or
[0:32:31] falling medical.
[0:32:35] Contact with City of Twin Falls.
[0:32:36] We'd be surprised how little contact people have the City of Twin Falls.
[0:32:41] Many renters don't receive water bills.
[0:32:44] They don't receive the message.
[0:32:45] They're not computer literate.
[0:32:47] They don't watch the streaming media nor access the website.
[0:32:52] Let's see.
[0:32:54] Just the senior center itself had many concerns and issues that could dovetail into this group.
[0:33:02] And just the term of handicap that we talked about a little bit today in context with transportation.
[0:33:09] So I'm really optimistic that the running start, this grip God under the direction of
[0:33:14] Daphne will attract more people, hear more about them.
[0:33:19] And this is a group that will not take no for an answer.
[0:33:23] Once they grab hold of something, I think you'll be surprised at some of the community
[0:33:29] The building will go on that we're not even aware that there was a need.
[0:33:33] So thank you.
[0:33:35] Thank you, Chris, Sean Berger.
[0:33:37] Thank you, Mayor.
[0:33:38] I just wanted to reiterate that the Parks and Recreation Department is seeking a citizen engagement with the master plan.
[0:33:46] Steering committee that they have going on.
[0:33:48] So the commission meets tomorrow and I believe around the first week of December is when they're aiming to have their initial meeting with the consultants who are assisting with this planning.
[0:33:57] So if folks are interested in the Parks and Recreation Programs, I want to be part of the future planning of that.
[0:34:04] You can get in touch with Dennis Boyer at the Parks and Rec Department, or you can actually apply it online on the city's website.
[0:34:10] Thanks, Sean.
[0:34:11] Suzanne Hawkins.
[0:34:12] Thank you.
[0:34:13] I just wanted to say thank you to Sean and Kyle at the Chamber today, and
[0:34:17] to our partners with the Twin Falls School District for the legislative tour they put on.
[0:34:21] It gave us an opportunity to meet with state and local leaders in the school and
[0:34:26] to see what our schools are doing to further education and communication with the kids and
[0:34:32] the community as a whole. It was very informative and it was a great day and I appreciate the opportunity for the learning.
[0:34:38] Thanks Suzanne. Rebecca Melsock.
[0:34:40] Thank you Mayor. I just wanted to add to Chris's point, thank you for the terminology. I've never heard of it as a reverse speed bump.
[0:34:47] But I did recently get a complaint about one of those reverse speed bumps from an elderly person.
[0:34:54] I think it was on 9th and Blue Lakes, not sure which side of 9th and Blue Lakes.
[0:35:01] But I thought this would be a good time to pass it along.
[0:35:04] I'm not sure if there is anything you can do about it.
[0:35:06] I did explain to them about the state's federal requirements and
[0:35:11] they tend to like that drainage to stay in certain areas.
[0:35:15] But I do think it's an issue, particularly with older cars and for some people in the community.
[0:35:23] We'll certainly take a look at it.
[0:35:24] Thank you.
[0:35:25] I want to see.
[0:35:26] I want to take a look at this 49-foot view.
[0:35:28] They're remaining on the run.
[0:35:31] They might have been driving the 1949 view.
[0:35:33] I thought he said 49-foot.
[0:35:35] I did.
[0:35:36] That was an inference.
[0:35:40] Anything else from council?
[0:35:42] I wanted to update the council.
[0:35:44] I told you that we would do some research.
[0:35:46] And when I say we, Leila, did some research on the two ballots that were brought to our
[0:35:53] and one was for the I-cramp representative for Region 1, I believe, actually, that was sent
[0:36:00] to us by mistake.
[0:36:01] We shouldn't have had it.
[0:36:02] I would have found it fascinating if we did vote and send it.
[0:36:05] We didn't really have the right to vote for that.
[0:36:07] So that one is Nolan Voigt, they sent it to us with a mistake.
[0:36:11] The other one is for the FSA committee election through the Department of USDA, the other was
[0:36:18] able to get ahold of those folks, to ask them to send us some bios of the five different
[0:36:22] members, and that are five different individuals that are vying for the position of the committee
[0:36:29] on the committee.
[0:36:31] And the reason that this is sent to us is because we do own some farmland.
[0:36:36] I'm assuming this land is, as we affectionately refer to it, Lake Lance, and in an ice way.
[0:36:47] Well, that's how I know where it is.
[0:36:50] Jackie, don't laugh.
[0:36:52] And so that's why the election or the ballot came to us.
[0:36:56] So we're waiting on the actual bios of these individuals and I need some guidance from council
[0:37:03] how they want me to proceed with this because this is not one that needs to necessarily come
[0:37:07] in front of the council but I'll do what the council wishes.
[0:37:10] Greg Lanning.
[0:37:11] I recommend that we have the mayor read the bios and make the decision not to vote for.
[0:37:17] I agree.
[0:37:18] Second.
[0:37:19] That's emotion.
[0:37:20] I don't know.
[0:37:21] motion but if I get kind of a head nod I will I will take that responsibility very
[0:37:27] very seriously so I will I will do that so thank you. Anything further from
[0:37:32] council folks we've been here hour and 37 minutes so we're going to take a quick
[0:37:37] five-minute break and come right back to the public hearing.
[0:37:48] I'd like to reconvene a meeting of the City Twin Falls City Council and we were
[0:44:39] We're moving to the public hearing section of our meeting.
[0:44:42] The first item on the agenda and hopefully the last is consideration of a request for
[0:44:47] a comprehensive plan amendment from AG AG to medium density and to extend the water service
[0:44:54] boundary area for property located on the east side of 500, 600, and 700 blocks of Hankins
[0:45:01] Road North.
[0:45:02] We have Brad Wills here on behalf of the Twin Falls School District as well as Brady Dickinson.
[0:45:08] What's your title against her?
[0:45:10] Director of Operations for Twin Falls School District 4-11.
[0:45:14] So without further ado, Brad, welcome.
[0:45:23] Good evening, Council.
[0:45:24] My name is Brad Wills.
[0:45:26] Two, two, two, three, so Sean Street West.
[0:45:28] Okay, thank you.
[0:45:32] You saved me introducing Ray.
[0:45:34] So I'm just here.
[0:45:35] So my capacity here is to assist the school district
[0:45:41] and the architect going through their entitlement process.
[0:45:45] It's with the City of Twin.
[0:45:46] It's always a pleasant thing to do.
[0:45:52] So, tonight we're here for the first
[0:45:57] three different projects that you're gonna see.
[0:46:00] So this is the exciting time that we're gonna get
[0:46:02] a new elementary school on the east side.
[0:46:04] So this is the site that you saw this summer
[0:46:08] when we annexed the land into the city.
[0:46:18] And also we are, we've added the city has a two acre parcel
[0:46:26] in this area right here, which is your morning sun,
[0:46:31] pressurized irrigation pump station.
[0:46:34] You traded the city, I mean the school
[0:46:38] when they did the Canyon Ridge High School
[0:46:42] and acquired those two acres for a future
[0:46:46] that time, pressurize irrigation and a possible site for your water tank, which you ended up
[0:46:52] relocating down towards Kibaly Road on Hankins. So this land is currently agriculture. We're
[0:47:00] asking that you approve the request to change the designation from agriculture to medium density
[0:47:10] residential which is what the land is to the west. It's interesting to see the
[0:47:18] residential growth. You know we don't have urban sprawl. We have urban crawl in
[0:47:24] Twin Falls. We you know I look back 20 years to see how long it's taken to move
[0:47:29] just from carriage lane to Hankins and it's been since 1993 when that crawl
[0:47:37] started. So that's the nice thing about Twin Falls is we have controlled growth.
[0:47:41] We're never out of control. We just grow onto the the boundary. So I guess
[0:47:49] there were co-applicants with the City of Twin Falls. The other part of our
[0:47:55] request is currently the water boundary is this line here that actually I'm
[0:48:03] I'm sorry, it's this line right.
[0:48:05] Thank you.
[0:48:07] It's this blue line right here.
[0:48:10] And currently, there are a lot of areas of twin
[0:48:14] that are within the water boundary,
[0:48:16] but really have no water lines near them.
[0:48:19] This has an 18-inch water line starting at Filer,
[0:48:23] goes all the way up, past the church,
[0:48:26] changes to a 12-inch, goes up, loops surrounding,
[0:48:29] connects here, and there's a 12-inch line here.
[0:48:32] So on our west boundary is a major water line.
[0:48:37] So it's a natural that this water boundary could be moved
[0:48:40] to include this location without minimal cost,
[0:48:45] additional cost.
[0:48:51] It's very simple.
[0:48:52] That's really what our application is.
[0:48:54] And we ask tonight that you approve that.
[0:48:56] And Brittany Dickinson's here, if there's any questions
[0:48:59] as far as the school.
[0:49:01] And for that, I'll sit down and let staff do its job.
[0:49:05] Very good.
[0:49:05] It looks like we might have a question right now for you.
[0:49:07] Okay.
[0:49:08] Brad, Rebecca Melsenka.
[0:49:09] Thank you, Mayor.
[0:49:10] Thank you, Brad.
[0:49:11] Rebecca.
[0:49:12] You mentioned the eight inch and the 12 inch pipe.
[0:49:14] I'm sorry?
[0:49:15] You mentioned an eight inch and a 12 inch pipe.
[0:49:17] 18 inch.
[0:49:18] 18 inch.
[0:49:19] Okay, so my question is either for you or for Jackie, would that be able to sustain or
[0:49:25] support the development within this annex area, the school and all of the 40 acres of residential?
[0:49:34] That would be a Jackie engineering question.
[0:49:36] So we're going to invite Jackie Fields, our City Engineer, forward to address your question, Rebecca.
[0:49:45] Welcome, Jackie.
[0:49:48] Thank you very much.
[0:49:50] I believe that there is enough supply in the area to support what the elementary school needs.
[0:49:59] But not the other portion that's being considered the 40 acres of medium density residential.
[0:50:05] Yeah, it can support that too, I'm sorry.
[0:50:07] Okay, so all of it.
[0:50:08] Okay, okay.
[0:50:09] Thank you.
[0:50:10] That doesn't mean that they won't need to do their own internal water lines and things like that.
[0:50:15] Okay.
[0:50:16] Thank you, Jackie.
[0:50:17] I think we'll turn it over to Jonathan Spendlove for the City of Presentation.
[0:50:21] Welcome to Jonathan.
[0:50:27] Thank you, Mr. Mayor and members of the Council.
[0:50:29] The history was, the school district required this 1990, so it's been on their books for
[0:50:32] quite a while as far as a site that was identified early on for potential school, not knowing
[0:50:38] what it was.
[0:50:39] here with the other two locations, and so we're going to be working on all three
[0:50:43] simultaneously with various zoning applications, plats, and things like that.
[0:50:49] So this will not be the last time you see this property. I'm not going to give you
[0:50:52] the full history of everything every time, so it's in your staff report. You guys
[0:50:56] can review that. This has two parts. The first part is the water service boundary
[0:51:01] that Brad identified. They would like it to go up and around the property, which
[0:51:04] would follow the annexation line that was done previously to
[0:51:09] encompass all of the property as well as the city PI station
[0:51:12] that's on the lower left corner right there.
[0:51:16] And this will allow for the school and future development to
[0:51:19] apply for connectivity to the city in our water service.
[0:51:25] All of the infrastructure will still be built as Jackie was
[0:51:27] talking about in any changes that would need to happen with
[0:51:29] modeling and things like that.
[0:51:30] They would be taken care of during the time of development.
[0:51:33] This does not guarantee service.
[0:51:35] It just allows them to apply for it.
[0:51:38] The second part is to amend the future land use map
[0:51:40] by changing from the agricultural, which is what Brad showed.
[0:51:49] That's in green, difficult to see,
[0:51:50] but mainly all of this here was agricultural designation.
[0:51:54] And that was done during the comprehensive plan amendment.
[0:51:57] It was done in 2009.
[0:52:00] Everything west of Hankins up to this point
[0:52:03] is, I think, including this point,
[0:52:05] as well as all medium density residential.
[0:52:07] This little section there is actually the scout office,
[0:52:11] which is for a professional.
[0:52:13] That was designated on the con point.
[0:52:15] And the stuff to the south, which includes high lawn and long
[0:52:18] bow, is the rural residential designation,
[0:52:22] as well as everything above and near falls.
[0:52:26] It is also rural residential.
[0:52:28] So that's what we're dealing with as far as currently there.
[0:52:31] They want to change it to medium density,
[0:52:32] which would be a lodginess with what's next to Hankins.
[0:52:35] I don't continue that type of development pattern, which would allow for different zoning designations
[0:52:41] R2, R4 if it's applicable to different things they could do besides on what they currently
[0:52:47] have.
[0:52:49] I think the narrative that offered by Brad and the school district is accurate.
[0:52:56] The agricultural designation was to preserve farm ground and direct development inward towards
[0:53:01] the corporate city limits.
[0:53:02] I believe it has done that for the last 20 some odd years.
[0:53:06] far as directing morning sun and this is now the natural lake step. 57 acre area was recently annexed
[0:53:14] and in no way does changing the water service boundary guarantee city services for these properties
[0:53:19] but it will allow for planning and modeling. In conclusion on October 14th 2014 the commission
[0:53:24] unanimously recommended approval of this request as presented to the city council and staff
[0:53:28] concurs with that conclusion. We have a couple lights on Chris talking to Jonathan
[0:53:34] should have asked this question at the time we annexed it but are you familiar
[0:53:39] of the impact of the expanded service boundary upon fire response and police
[0:53:48] public safety response? Probably occurred at the time of annexation the service
[0:53:54] boundary probably won't that change has probably already occurred Chris I believe.
[0:53:58] No I didn't ask the question the right way we're expanding to the east
[0:54:03] Therefore, it's a longer response time for the fire trucks.
[0:54:08] Are we still within the acceptable limits of response time for fire and what impact upon
[0:54:15] place maybe the chief has a knowledge of the ex-cheater?
[0:54:21] Not yet.
[0:54:22] Vic Humboldt, did you want to address that?
[0:54:25] I was just going to pipe in and say that our fire department, before this was annexed
[0:54:29] already responded to this property via our service to the district over there.
[0:54:36] So this was already a property that the fire department responded to before annexation and
[0:54:41] it will still be.
[0:54:45] Did you want to address the police piece of that chief pipe?
[0:54:53] We are currently providing service in that area and throughout that area with morning
[0:54:58] sun in a number of those properties.
[0:55:00] So I don't see a direct impact on our ability to provide service out there.
[0:55:04] Thank you.
[0:55:05] Thank you, Chief.
[0:55:06] Thank you, Mitch.
[0:55:07] Rebecca Melsuk.
[0:55:08] Thank you, Mayor.
[0:55:09] John, you mentioned that this medium density would be homogenous with the medium density
[0:55:15] there across tankins, but on our zoning designations and surrounding land use six all zoned R1 variable.
[0:55:25] So can you explain that a little bit more?
[0:55:30] Changing it to the medium density allows for, could allow for other types of zones to be used.
[0:55:36] Morning Sun is developed with an R1, stuff to the further south, and west was developed R2,
[0:55:43] all of those which are designated on the Future Land Use Plan as medium density.
[0:55:47] The Future Land Use designation doesn't call out specific zones that you have to use,
[0:55:52] but it does have a description included in the stack report about what could be used.
[0:55:57] If the school so wanted to and I'm not sure what they want to do at this time. They could develop this with the R1
[0:56:04] VAR zoning standards
[0:56:06] which has
[0:56:09] Certain lot sizes different from the R2 standards. So it's kind of gives them the option to do
[0:56:14] One or the other if they wish to rezone it
[0:56:17] The council would certainly see that application again, right? So is the medium density residential? Is that the only?
[0:56:24] designation, is that encompassed R1 variable to R6 or is there a less dense designation that
[0:56:34] you would amend the comp plan to?
[0:56:36] I don't think the medium density would encompass SUI, that would be more of a rural type deal.
[0:56:42] As far as it being R6, that's something that the council would have to make the determination
[0:56:46] of if they came back with an application.
[0:56:48] But I mean, it's allowed in the medium density and it encompasses all of the different zoning
[0:56:56] designations.
[0:56:57] Is my question?
[0:56:58] The R6 I think is actually the it's the it's a higher density.
[0:57:02] As far as the question of would we approve it?
[0:57:08] That's not our job.
[0:57:09] We would just bring the application to the city council.
[0:57:11] No, not my question is not whether you'd approve it.
[0:57:13] My question is what types of zoning are encompassed by medium density designation?
[0:57:19] Typically, R1, R2, R4.
[0:57:22] R4.
[0:57:23] Okay.
[0:57:24] Thank you.
[0:57:25] We would look at the R6 applying to the high density designation that's on the comp plan
[0:57:29] as well.
[0:57:30] So those three would be about it for medium.
[0:57:32] Okay.
[0:57:33] So there are basically two residential designations, one medium and one high.
[0:57:36] Well, there's three because you also have the rural residential designation which applies
[0:57:40] to the SUI zone as well.
[0:57:42] Okay.
[0:57:43] I have a question for you if the council decides to move this direction, should it be two
[0:57:51] motions amending it from ag to medium density and then extending it or can it be wrapped up
[0:57:57] into one motion?
[0:57:58] Just single motion.
[0:57:59] That'll work on this.
[0:58:00] Okay, very good.
[0:58:01] Any other questions from council before I open it up to the public for their comments?
[0:58:06] All right, at this time we will open up the public.
[0:58:10] Oh, I'm sorry, Chris.
[0:58:12] public for their comments regarding this application tonight or this request
[0:58:18] is there anyone from the public that would like to address the City Council
[0:58:21] you know something looking at the two of you so just all right I don't see anyone
[0:58:29] coming forward so I am going to close the public testimony portion of this
[0:58:34] evening's hearing and turn it over Council Chris talking now move we
[0:58:39] a previous zone change from egg to medium density and extend the water
[0:58:44] surface boundary line as outlined.
[0:58:47] Second.
[0:58:49] We have you got it.
[0:58:52] We have a motion on the floor by Chris talking to seconded by Greg
[0:58:56] Lanting as stated.
[0:58:58] We have a few lights on Sean Berger.
[0:59:02] Right.
[0:59:02] Chris locked up.
[0:59:03] I'm sorry.
[0:59:03] It's not actually to reason it's actually an amendment to the comp plan.
[0:59:08] So yes.
[0:59:10] that I will amend up to include the motion to amend the comp plan.
[0:59:17] So the second carries.
[0:59:19] Both the maker of the motion and the second agree to that.
[0:59:23] So moving on, is that what you were going to say, Sean?
[0:59:26] Rebecca Mills-Soyka.
[0:59:27] Thank you, Mayor.
[0:59:29] Well, we've seen a couple of amendments to the comp plan come through, you know, in recent weeks.
[0:59:35] And I think the concept is still a difficult one of amending the
[0:59:38] con plan outside of the public process and including the community.
[0:59:44] There's two parts to this request and so I want to address each of them.
[0:59:47] The first one with the land use, I think medium density
[0:59:54] may not be compatible with the area around it because it's all R1
[0:59:58] variable which is it's a much more rural
[1:00:01] development and medium density, I think is a concern for me if it goes up to R4 and so
[1:00:09] on.
[1:00:10] It just opens the door for a real change in this area, but I think the greater question
[1:00:17] I have really revolves around moving the water boundary.
[1:00:21] The current comp plan tells us to limit the future growth within the water limit.
[1:00:26] It's very specific about not extending that.
[1:00:29] And I think that that is important because of planning.
[1:00:33] It's important to weigh the impacts to the rate payers
[1:00:38] and to the costs of the current system
[1:00:41] when you do extend that boundary.
[1:00:44] And so right now, we really don't know the impacts.
[1:00:49] This request is certainly important for a school.
[1:00:53] And I think that if it were just a school,
[1:00:55] I think it would be a little easier decision.
[1:00:58] But the large majority of the request is for 40 acres of residential development,
[1:01:04] medium density residential development, which I think will have a significant impact
[1:01:09] to the system as far as maintenance, operations, extending our water lines, our sewer lines.
[1:01:17] We've already seen kind of some unexpected costs by doing that with the Northeast sewer line.
[1:01:23] We're now engineering odor reduction units, and that's certainly a cost to the rate payers.
[1:01:30] So I have my concerns about moving that water boundary line without really studying its impacts to the system and the cost to the rate payers.
[1:01:43] And I think it also adds to urban sprawl, which is not a sustainable form of land use development.
[1:01:53] We've sprawled to the south, we've sprawled to the west, the north, the northwest, and now we're rushing to sprawl to the east,
[1:02:03] which is not a sustainable pattern.
[1:02:08] I think we should use our planning documents and I think that we should not take comp plan
[1:02:15] amendments lightly and I struggle with any proposal that's kind of a spot zone sort of
[1:02:23] a thing where we're making these little amendments here and there based on just small
[1:02:28] tracks of land instead of looking at the big picture I think we really need to plan our
[1:02:35] growth and stick to that plan.
[1:02:38] Thank you.
[1:02:40] I agree that this is a big proposal to grow our city in this direction, but I have to believe that our voters were very educated when they voted in support of the bond to build these three new schools.
[1:02:55] I believe they knew when they were voting for that that would mean we're building out because that's how schools always develop and homes follow the schools.
[1:03:04] It's just a natural pattern and I would have to take from the support of the bond that the people in our community and our city want these schools and want to see this development happen in these neighborhoods.
[1:03:16] So I will be supporting it.
[1:03:19] Suzanne, Greg Lannick.
[1:03:20] Well I would like to thank Brady and Brad and Lucy who are instrumental in the passing of this bond for our community.
[1:03:30] We have to take some of the blame for the need for that bond because we want to look for
[1:03:34] jobs and look hard for jobs and brought industry to our community, which naturally means a population
[1:03:42] increase.
[1:03:43] And so I'm going to take some of that responsibility of us needing to think and having worked in
[1:03:49] education for my entire career, I understand that you have to go out very far ahead of
[1:03:56] time and buy land where you end up the situation like that we did on this one on
[1:04:00] the Northwest Elementary School. If you wait till the houses are there you can't
[1:04:05] afford the land and so you have to buy your land in the school district bought
[1:04:09] this land in 1990. That's a long time ago folks to be thinking about how long ago
[1:04:14] 1990 was for them to plan that far in advance and I command the school board
[1:04:19] at that time for looking that far into the future that they would need an
[1:04:23] Elementary School out that far because they tried to buy let's say let's say the school district right now
[1:04:28] What needed to school in the northwest and they tried to buy tried to buy any other piece of land that's within our city limits in that
[1:04:34] Corner of the city you couldn't do it. You couldn't afford the land. It's already ready to be developed at
[1:04:41] 80,000-dollar lots and so
[1:04:44] Again as Suzanne said this is the way it has to work the school district has to buy land
[1:04:48] and outside out on the edges of the community
[1:04:52] in order to be able to afford that land
[1:04:55] to be responsible for their voters.
[1:04:57] And their citizens of the school district,
[1:05:00] which are for the most part the same citizens
[1:05:03] we represent.
[1:05:05] And so I will be definitely supporting this proposal
[1:05:09] to make this change and here's hoping
[1:05:13] that the school board picks some of the names
[1:05:15] I was in favor of for the new building.
[1:05:17] I was just gonna say 1990 doesn't seem like that long ago, but thanks a lot, correct?
[1:05:24] I guess it is. Anything further on the motion council.
[1:05:28] Will you have the roll call vote, please?
[1:05:31] Yes.
[1:05:33] Rebecca Mills, would you like that?
[1:05:35] No.
[1:05:37] Suzanne Hawkins?
[1:05:38] Yes.
[1:05:39] Jim Munn?
[1:05:40] Yes.
[1:05:41] Sean Bericher?
[1:05:42] Yes.
[1:05:43] Chris Talkington?
[1:05:44] Yes.
[1:05:45] Greg Lanthine?
[1:05:46] Yes.
[1:05:47] Motion passes.
[1:05:48] Six to one.
[1:05:49] With that, meeting adjourned.
[1:05:52] I'm going to start.
[1:05:53] I'm going to start.
[1:05:54] I'm going to start.
[1:05:55] I'm going to start.
[1:05:56] I'm going to start.
[1:05:57] I'm going to start.
[1:05:58] I'm going to start.
[1:05:59] I'm going to start.
[1:06:00] I'm going to start.
[1:06:01] I'm going to start.
[1:06:02] I'm going to start.
[1:06:03] I'm going to start.
[1:06:04] I'm going to start.
[1:06:05] I'm going to start.
[1:06:06] I'm going to start.
[1:06:07] I'm going to start.
[1:06:08] I'm going to start.
[1:06:09] I'm going to start.
[1:06:10] I'm going to start.
[1:06:11] I'm going to start.
[1:06:12] I'm going to start.
[1:06:13] I'm going to start.
[1:06:14] I'm going to start.
[1:06:15] I'm going to start.
[1:06:16] I'm going to start.
[1:06:17] I'm going to start.
[1:06:18] I'm going to start.
[1:06:19] I'm going to start.
