Oversight Archive: City Council meeting, 2015-05-11, recording 1 (started 17:00)
Machine transcript (faster-whisper base.en), not checked word for word; the Pledge of Allegiance is shown in its standard wording. The recording is the record.
Times are time into the recording. Passages with private details are muted in the audio and marked here.
The audio on the page below was re-encoded by software from the video the agency posted. Check any passage against
that audio before relying on it.
Page: https://oversightarchive.org/twin-falls-id/meetings/2015-05-11/

[0:00:00] It's May 11, 2015, a little bit after five.
[0:00:03] I don't see any boy scouts or girl scouts in the audience, so I'm going to just ask all
[0:00:09] those wishing to please rise for the Pledge of Allegiance.
[0:00:12] I pledge allegiance to the Flag of the United States of America, and to the Republic for which it stands, one Nation under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all.
[0:00:30] I'd like to confirm that we do have a quorum of the City Council.
[0:00:35] One member has gone to this evening, Jim Munn had prior engagements.
[0:00:39] He's not able to be with us.
[0:00:42] Our city manager is running just a little bit late from an appointment.
[0:00:46] So we have our deputy city manager Mitch Humboldt that's going to bite us.
[0:00:50] So I'm going to start with him and ask him if there are any amendments to the agenda, sir.
[0:00:54] All right, is he ready for the extent of my guidance?
[0:00:57] No.
[0:00:59] We're not done with you yet, man.
[0:01:01] Thank you.
[0:01:02] The next item on the agenda is a proclamation and do we have Josh here?
[0:01:07] Is he going to be here?
[0:01:09] Lieutenant Wilson, after I read it, if you wouldn't mind, I'd like to hand it to you and then if you'd say a few words, sir?
[0:01:18] Absolutely.
[0:01:19] First of all, we do this proclamation every year in remembrance of our fallen heroes, police officers.
[0:01:28] And this year I did something a little bit unique. I contacted the county.
[0:01:32] We generally do two proclamations at the actual event on Saturday, and
[0:01:37] they are essentially the exact same proclamation.
[0:01:41] So I get up and read one, and then the county does.
[0:01:43] And I thought it would be more appropriate, and they agreed, the county did,
[0:01:46] the county commissioners, that we do a joint resolution.
[0:01:50] So I have the privilege of reading that this evening.
[0:01:53] Proclamation from the Twin Falls County and City of Twin Falls, Peace Officers Memorial Day and Police Week 2015.
[0:02:01] A proclamation by the County and City of Twin Falls, Idaho, declaring Sunday, May 10th
[0:02:06] through Saturday, May 16th as Police Week and Friday, May 15th, 2015 as Peace Officer Memorial Day.
[0:02:16] Whereas the Congress and President of the United States have designated the week in which
[0:02:20] May 15th falls as National Police Week, and whereas the members of the law enforcement
[0:02:25] agencies of the County and City of Twin Falls play an essential role in safeguarding the
[0:02:30] the rights and freedoms of the residents of the county and city of Twin Falls, and whereas
[0:02:36] it is important that all citizens know and understand the duties, responsibilities, hazards
[0:02:42] and sacrifices of their law enforcement agencies, and that members of our law enforcement agency
[0:02:48] recognize their duty to serve the people by safeguarding life and property, by protecting
[0:02:55] them against violence and disorder and by protecting the innocent against deception and
[0:03:00] the weak against oppression and whereas the men and women of the law enforcement agencies
[0:03:06] of the county and city of Twin Falls unceasingly provide a vital public service.
[0:03:12] Now therefore we the county commissioners and the city council call upon all citizens of
[0:03:17] the county and the city of Twin Falls and upon all patriotic civic educational organizations
[0:03:23] to observe the week of May 10th through May 16th 2015, as Police Week with appropriate
[0:03:31] ceremonies and observances in which all of our people may join in commemorating law enforcement's
[0:03:39] officers past and present who by their faithful and loyal devotion to their responsibilities
[0:03:44] have rendered a dedicated service to their communities and in doing so have established
[0:03:50] for themselves and enviable and enduring reputation for preserving the rights and security of
[0:03:56] all citizens.
[0:03:57] Furthermore, we call upon all citizens of the county and city of Twin Falls to observe May
[0:04:02] 15, 2015, as Peace Officers Memorial Day in honor of those law enforcement officers who,
[0:04:09] through their courageous deeds, have made the ultimate sacrifice in service to their communities
[0:04:15] or have become disabled in the performance of duty.
[0:04:19] And let us recognize and pay respect to the survivors of our fallen heroes.
[0:04:26] Both the county commissioner, chairperson, George Jurey, and myself as the mayor of City
[0:04:30] of Twin Falls have the honor of signing this and I'd ask Wilson to come forward.
[0:04:51] Thank you Mr. Mayor and our council members.
[0:04:56] I would first of all like to express the appreciation of myself and
[0:05:01] officers who I serve with here in the City of Twin Falls for the support that we
[0:05:05] seem to continually be getting from our City Council. It is it makes our day-to-day
[0:05:13] so much easier knowing that we are looked out for and we appreciate that and as far
[0:05:20] as our proclamation goes this is I think the 53rd year now that National Police
[0:05:25] week has been observed. President Kennedy started that in May of 1962, and we would
[0:05:34] like to recognize all the officers who have, you know, paid that ultimate price. In the
[0:05:42] last week, it's hit kind of close to home for us here in Idaho as Coeur d'Alene City lost
[0:05:46] an officer seven days ago. And again, we saw an outpouring of support from our community,
[0:05:54] as well as some of the surrounding communities.
[0:05:56] And we appreciate that.
[0:05:58] Thank you.
[0:05:59] Thank you, Lieutenant Wilson.
[0:06:00] Appreciate it.
[0:06:02] Next night on the agenda is general public input.
[0:06:05] This is a time for the public to engage the city council.
[0:06:08] If there's anything that's not on the agenda this evening,
[0:06:10] that you would like to come forward
[0:06:12] and express any concerns or thoughts to the city council.
[0:06:16] So I'll open that up.
[0:06:20] Come forward, sir, if you wouldn't mind.
[0:06:21] When you come forward, if you would state your name
[0:06:24] where you lived and try to keep it brief
[0:06:27] because we have a packed agenda this evening.
[0:06:29] So welcome, sir.
[0:06:36] My name is Randy Slickers.
[0:06:37] I've lived here for 43 years, 6, 7, 2, and you drive.
[0:06:42] And all that time I don't think I've ever experienced
[0:06:45] any more extraordinary garbage service than PSI has delivered.
[0:06:49] I find that as rather remarkable,
[0:06:52] all the changes they've had down there.
[0:06:55] I have no idea what cost and how this goes
[0:06:59] about but I would just put in my vote of confidence
[0:07:03] for their services.
[0:07:05] I appreciate that, sir.
[0:07:07] Is there anyone else that would like to come forward?
[0:07:11] All right, we will move now onto the consent calendar.
[0:07:13] I'll turn that over to council for their direction.
[0:07:16] Chris Stocky.
[0:07:17] The approval is printed.
[0:07:19] Second.
[0:07:20] We have motion on the floor by Chris Stocky
[0:07:22] and then seconded by Suzanne Hawkins
[0:07:24] to approve the consent calendar as printed.
[0:07:28] Anything further on that motion council?
[0:07:31] Sharon roll call vote please Suzanne Hawkins. Yes
[0:07:39] Sean Baraker. Yes, Chris Tockington. Yes Greg Lanting. Yes Don Hall. Yes Rebecca Mills, so I guess motion passes
[0:07:49] 60-0 Chris talking but I just have a question Sharon
[0:07:53] Been a couple weeks since we've had minutes for perusal are they coming up?
[0:07:59] Okay, all right
[0:08:02] You're gonna hit us all at once with a month or three
[0:08:06] Thank you.
[0:08:07] They're a work in progress.
[0:08:08] Thank you, Chris.
[0:08:09] Thank you, Sharon.
[0:08:11] Now, moving on to items for consideration is a first item is consideration request to
[0:08:16] authorize the mayor to sign a funding agreement between the city of Twin Falls and Idaho transportation
[0:08:21] department.
[0:08:23] We have Mandy Tonsen.
[0:08:24] Welcome, Mandy.
[0:08:25] Thank you, Mr. Mayor, Council.
[0:08:27] Good evening.
[0:08:28] I'm bringing to you tonight a request to authorize Mayor Hall to sign a funding agreement between
[0:08:34] the city and the ITD.
[0:08:36] This is the agreement that will allow us to move forward with our transit development plan.
[0:08:44] So these will be the funds that we'll expend along with our $10,000 City Match to release
[0:08:51] an RFQ and hire a consultant to help us do this or to complete this plan.
[0:08:58] Very good.
[0:08:59] Thank you, Manny.
[0:09:00] Do we have any questions for Manny for stalking?
[0:09:02] for the public, could you give us a thumbnail sketch of what some of the scope of this investigation
[0:09:08] is likely to be or goals that we've established?
[0:09:13] Sure.
[0:09:14] Well, we applied for this grant in January of 2014, and what we had, what we intend to
[0:09:23] do with this grant is to look at the future of public transportation in Twin Falls, because
[0:09:28] We will be reaching these 50,000 population mark
[0:09:32] with the next census.
[0:09:33] We will be required by federal mandate
[0:09:35] to provide public transportation to our citizens.
[0:09:37] And so this is a way for us to begin that planning process,
[0:09:41] essentially anywhere between eight to 10 years ahead of time.
[0:09:45] We hope to look at what our citizens would like to see
[0:09:49] in public transportation in Twin Falls,
[0:09:51] some of the funding mechanisms that we can look to
[0:09:54] to pay for this and kind of get into them maybe,
[0:09:58] not necessarily the nuts and bolts of the system,
[0:10:00] but understand what public transportation could look
[0:10:02] like in Twin Falls and even the possibility of some sort
[0:10:07] of regional system in the future.
[0:10:12] Suzanne Hawkins.
[0:10:15] So maybe I'm reading this wrong, but I know that you said
[0:10:18] we have a $10,000 match, but under the scope and budget
[0:10:22] of the work, it shows 31.69 for our match on page 5, it shows 40,000 federal capital
[0:10:33] 31.69 match for a total project of 43.169.
[0:10:37] Thank you for bringing that to my attention.
[0:10:41] Oh, okay, I see it right here.
[0:10:44] That is an error.
[0:10:47] We pledged 10,000, although I will say we were only obligated to a 7% match to get the
[0:10:55] the 40,000 and we obligated 10,000 to that, can you explain why?
[0:11:03] We wanted the grant to be more competitive and typically what happens, the more local ownership
[0:11:08] that you place into that in terms of financial commitment, the higher the point system they
[0:11:13] typically will show.
[0:11:15] Thank you.
[0:11:16] Just for the record and folks at home, that was our city manager who's here now and he
[0:11:21] weighed in.
[0:11:22] Additionally, this with 40,000 was really the that was what we were told was available
[0:11:27] to us and in terms of a transit development plan, that's really probably not going to get
[0:11:33] as much as we hope to.
[0:11:35] So by putting a little additional local match into that, we're hoping to accomplish, you
[0:11:40] know, more than, you know, than would be possible, which is their required match.
[0:11:44] Great.
[0:11:45] Thank you.
[0:11:47] We have any further questions?
[0:11:50] Sean Berger.
[0:11:51] I don't have a question.
[0:11:52] I'm ready for a motion if you are.
[0:11:54] I would move to authorize the mayor to sign the funding agreement between the City of Twin
[0:11:58] Falls and Idaho Transportation Department as presented.
[0:12:03] Motion 4 by Sean Berger, seconded by Greg Lanting, the little croquet voice there.
[0:12:09] That's not your name, that's the senior moment.
[0:12:13] That's what they're under, the light.
[0:12:17] It doesn't say your last name though.
[0:12:19] Motion made by Sean Verger, seconded by Greg Lanting as stated.
[0:12:23] Anything for their motion council?
[0:12:26] Sharon, roll call vote, please.
[0:12:29] Sean Verger?
[0:12:30] Yes.
[0:12:31] Chris Hockinghead.
[0:12:33] Greg Lanting?
[0:12:34] Yes.
[0:12:35] Don Hall?
[0:12:35] Yes.
[0:12:36] Rebecca Mills-Sarca?
[0:12:38] Yes.
[0:12:39] Suzanne Hocking.
[0:12:40] Yes.
[0:12:41] Motion passes 6-0.
[0:12:44] Moving on to the next item, and I think it's Mandy again.
[0:12:47] Discussion on the Municipal Powers Outsource Grant
[0:12:50] process, MPOG. Welcome back, Mandy.
[0:12:53] Thank you, Mr. Mayor, Council. Tonight, I bring you a request to have a discussion of the MPOG
[0:13:01] process. It has changed several times to my understanding over the years. Last year, we
[0:13:08] had brought to you by committee a matrix of which you were to assign a numerical value to
[0:13:17] to each, some areas that demonstration of need, work plan budget, staffing plan, sustainability
[0:13:26] and the services provided as far and again on then also their collaboration, priority
[0:13:35] management and demonstration of outcomes.
[0:13:38] These were, this matrix was developed prior to me coming to the city but this was what
[0:13:44] We gave to each of the members of City Council last year along with all of the applications for the MPOC process.
[0:13:51] It was not as seamless as I had hoped it had been.
[0:13:55] Some members of Council followed the matrix, others did not.
[0:13:58] So the city manager asked that I come tonight to ask how you would like to proceed with the MPOC.
[0:14:05] In addition to what I had provided to you in your packet, I also took the time this afternoon to put together a history of the MPOC.
[0:14:12] And who we have funded in the past, starting with 2002.
[0:14:16] The first page were the actuals because I didn't have access to the requests for those versus what they were actually funded.
[0:14:24] And then starting on the 2005, 2006 budget year, I was able to show you what was requested versus what was funded for each of the organizations.
[0:14:36] Very good. Thank you, Mandy.
[0:14:37] Do we have any? Let's open it up for discussion from Council.
[0:14:43] Chris, talking.
[0:14:45] Just generally speaking, I think we have to be able to defend our decisions in the court
[0:14:53] of public opinion of who we eventually choose for these discretionary funds, certainly with
[0:15:00] the guidance of our council that it should be a service that the city cannot realistically
[0:15:07] provider that this applicant provides that service.
[0:15:14] So I have nothing but a lot for what we're doing there, but it's probably the epitome
[0:15:21] of red meat politics for us to decide who gets on the hundred or so thousand dollars that
[0:15:27] we have and then how to judge them.
[0:15:30] And I am firmly in favor of us being held accountable for justifying individually as the
[0:15:37] to counsel how or to provide the unplugged funding
[0:15:41] to the applicants.
[0:15:43] But the application process to me,
[0:15:46] the schematic or the template before us
[0:15:48] is just far too complex with many sub parts to it
[0:15:54] that I have found totally unrelated
[0:15:56] to the individual experience.
[0:15:58] I have devised my own simply on the basis
[0:16:02] of what I think the top five criteria
[0:16:05] and put a value to them, but I've tried to follow this,
[0:16:09] and it is just almost impossible for me to use.
[0:16:12] So that's my only point.
[0:16:15] I value having a numerical judgment,
[0:16:18] but I think that we all did our own judgment
[0:16:22] by either this template or of our own.
[0:16:24] It's still defensible, if that makes sense.
[0:16:29] I would just add to what Chris says,
[0:16:31] because I agree with what he said.
[0:16:33] We need to have some kind of a system and we did variations of the system and we got to the same place.
[0:16:39] But we always, where we get hung up, always is how much.
[0:16:44] Now, several of us up here, and frankly, conflict of interest is not a bad thing to say.
[0:16:51] We have conflicts of interest because we're involved in our community.
[0:16:55] So, for example, I have a conflict with anything that's related to CSI that would come to us.
[0:17:01] to us. So I have to step back from that because I derive my income, my profession from the college,
[0:17:09] for those of us that sit on different boards, we have to step back because that's a conflict.
[0:17:14] But again, conflict of interest, sometimes we think that's a negative term, it's really not.
[0:17:19] In this term, it's really because we're involved in our community and that's a good thing.
[0:17:24] But it's always the sausage making of how much to give to who that is so difficult.
[0:17:30] And before we go on to anyone else, I'd kind of like to have Fritz come up one more time
[0:17:34] and remind us because basically we can give this money to public funds to operations that
[0:17:45] do things that we could do.
[0:17:48] I found out something very interesting in the last two weeks because I told someone no, but
[0:17:52] I would check on it further.
[0:17:54] And Fritz straightened me out because he found that cities can run hospitals.
[0:18:00] code. I don't think we want to, but we can. So this entity was able to send in a request.
[0:18:06] So, Fred, could you pin us up on that? Sure. So, first I want to remind you of the name of
[0:18:12] this process, Municipal Powers Outsource Grants. Municipal Powers are the powers granted to the
[0:18:19] city by the legislature, and you can find them mostly in Title 50, Chapter 2, and Chapter
[0:18:26] three and it lists a long line of things that cities can do.
[0:18:31] We provide most of those services internally so we have a police department, fire department,
[0:18:36] water, so we're all of those things that you think about.
[0:18:39] But there are a number of other things that we provide both internally and in the past externally.
[0:18:44] For example, parks and recreation, we have recreation programs but our Boys and Girls
[0:18:50] Club does that as well, Salvation Army does it as well.
[0:18:56] In the code we can provide for our citizens opportunities for arts and culture and we do
[0:19:03] that already through our arts council.
[0:19:05] We don't do that hardly at all internally and it's probably because we don't have a department
[0:19:11] of both devoted to that but in any event the idea is the city could contract out for certain
[0:19:18] services that it has the legal authority to perform for its citizens.
[0:19:26] I think the place in the past where probably the non-profits that have applied have gotten
[0:19:32] confused about their very worthy causes, but cities don't have the authority to perform
[0:19:39] the service that they form.
[0:19:42] And so constitutionally, the city is not able to provide funding for those, no matter how
[0:19:49] worthy those causes are, you simply don't have the legal authority to expand taxpayer
[0:19:54] monies for them.
[0:19:55] Hope I've answered I think you have two two examples of that is we had a
[0:20:00] Entity get a hold of me
[0:20:02] Regarding this and it was a clinic and and I didn't think we could give them money
[0:20:09] Through this process and I was proved wrong because there is there's a specific provision in in title three of
[0:20:17] Title 50 chapter three
[0:20:19] providing for health care services and that's why we have our city attorney to straighten us out and then about a
[0:20:25] Week later I had another entity that provides low cost if no if not no cost tax
[0:20:32] Preparation returns for folks in our community and they wanted to put in and I I didn't say any
[0:20:38] I just said let me check on this and we found out that that is not a service that we can provide so
[0:20:43] Wouldn't qualify right two examples. Yeah. Thank you for anyway think about it as these are services
[0:20:48] as we could do, we are authorized to do internally,
[0:20:51] but you choose to contract out with various non-profits.
[0:20:55] You also need to think about this in terms of,
[0:20:57] this is the service that we want to provide to our citizens,
[0:21:01] and this is not about the entities that are coming to you.
[0:21:05] Who's the most worthy of receiving funding?
[0:21:08] It's what services do we need for our citizens.
[0:21:13] Thank you, Prince.
[0:21:14] Greg Lani.
[0:21:15] Now I'm going to go back to the how we rate them and although I found problems
[0:21:24] with the rating scale we used last year I still was able to utilize it. I think I
[0:21:29] was one of the ones that utilized it. Okay good. I did want to say that I've had
[0:21:34] my head. But then when we got to down to the actual handing out the money it's
[0:21:40] just kind of like those ratings didn't really mean anything. At that point we
[0:21:43] We still, you know, funded 90% of this one and 20% of this one, even though the 20% might
[0:21:49] have been higher ranked than the other one, and so then it comes down to what they, I think
[0:21:55] I'm just ready to come in and select it out.
[0:21:57] And we used to do this in a committee form where we had a committee and Lori come in
[0:22:02] there and try to keep us in line.
[0:22:04] And if we figured out that way, we've been more transparent or attempts to be more transparent,
[0:22:11] So we're doing it in front of them.
[0:22:12] But I don't, whether we rate them ahead of time or not,
[0:22:15] it didn't seem to make any difference.
[0:22:17] So I'm not sure that I'm in favor of some sort of a form.
[0:22:20] I'm just, you know, it comes down to it,
[0:22:22] you know, you look down that list and we probably won't give
[0:22:26] trans for $65,000, but we're gonna give them a chunk of money
[0:22:29] because we know they provide a service.
[0:22:31] And that's one we're gonna be in charge of
[0:22:34] at some point in the future.
[0:22:35] So you just go down that list and you have,
[0:22:39] trying to find three other people to agree with you on the
[0:22:42] amount that works for that one and the money left at the end
[0:22:45] everybody gets something but that's not it's the I don't know
[0:22:50] sure what Chris or Chris used because I didn't hold my vote
[0:22:54] camera wasn't strong on that one but it's just awesome making
[0:22:57] and we we just have to bring it in and do it and if we want to
[0:23:00] rate it ahead of time I'll do it or not rate it I don't care
[0:23:05] great we're back in my second. Thank you mayor. Thanks
[0:23:08] for bringing the issue. I think Councilman Lanning is correct that, you know, in theory, we wanted
[0:23:16] to create a more standardized process. But in practice, I think people just do what they want.
[0:23:23] So, I mean, that's what we're here to do, you know, where each Council member has their own way
[0:23:28] of processing and pog. And I think that's just one of the difficulties of the process. And one of
[0:23:35] One of the reasons that it's, I'm not a huge fan of it because it takes a lot of time and
[0:23:42] it's $100,000 and the needs are important, so I guess that's why we do it.
[0:23:51] But I think that the Matrix was a good attempt at bringing some sort of standardization because
[0:23:59] I think we all spoke for being in favor of having more of a standardized process, but
[0:24:09] realistically I think that it's a subjective process and I think each of us comes to it
[0:24:15] subjectively and that's how it's going to be utilized probably into the future.
[0:24:25] So we tried.
[0:24:27] I tried to follow the chart we had, but I think the part we missed is the people applying for it didn't know what we were grading them on necessarily.
[0:24:42] So there were things that were on our sheet to look for that maybe weren't in their application, so it was hard to find a place to mesh the two.
[0:24:51] At least that's what I found.
[0:24:53] So, some of them would answer part of the questions and not others, and so that's where
[0:24:58] I got confused with it.
[0:25:00] I think if whatever we're grading on, they have the same format, so they're answering
[0:25:05] the questions, A, B, C, D, the same order, we're rating them, A, B, C, D. So we're all
[0:25:10] kind of together.
[0:25:11] That would be the only way I could see using a chart to make it work.
[0:25:15] But however everybody wants to do it, I don't think there's one answer.
[0:25:21] I tried last year and put together the application to kind of take more broad themes out of this
[0:25:29] because if you recall prior to last year, most people just submitted a one-page letter.
[0:25:35] Right.
[0:25:36] So I was trying to not go from one extreme to the other, but perhaps I should have.
[0:25:41] It's just unfortunately some people provide a lot of information and you can tell they're
[0:25:45] familiar with and their organization relies on the grant process and there are others that
[0:25:51] that will write a story and so I think that's really, I think regardless of what we ask
[0:25:57] of them, some will and some won't.
[0:25:59] I agree.
[0:26:00] And that's what makes it hard because you can't compare apples and oranges and the presentations
[0:26:05] or apples and oranges and our charts or apples and oranges.
[0:26:08] So it just kind of puts everything in a basket together and we have to toss it up and see
[0:26:12] where it comes out.
[0:26:14] Yes.
[0:26:17] Chris, talking to you.
[0:26:18] Are we, if we're challenged by individual or an agency and can't individually or
[0:26:27] collectively justify, are we in any sort of endangerment for the city's resources or
[0:26:36] liability or you know when I'm getting it?
[0:26:38] Yeah, I know what you're getting at and no, I don't think you are because again,
[0:26:41] I'm going to tell you that these are your funding priorities for
[0:26:48] services to your citizens, and it's not about whoever is applying to you thinks that their cause is more worthy than someone else's cause.
[0:26:56] It's what you think the funding priorities for the city should be.
[0:27:02] It's exactly what you do when you budget every year.
[0:27:04] You decide how to allocate funds to different kinds of programs.
[0:27:08] Thank you.
[0:27:12] I would just add, there's a couple on here that I think this is a comprehensive list of who we've funded in the past.
[0:27:19] For example, the visitor center that's out of play now, the Southern Idaho tourism is part of a budgetary line item, that's out of play now, correct?
[0:27:29] Yes, and as is the municipal band this year, they were taken out last year, and they are actually now in the Parks and Recreation budget.
[0:27:35] So, they're...
[0:27:37] Yeah, we voted to do that.
[0:27:39] Mm-hmm.
[0:27:40] I'm trying to remember when we voted that the only challenge with that is explain this to me.
[0:27:44] this to me, how do we do that when we have a member of the council that her
[0:27:48] husband's on the band? What did we do? I don't remember voting that.
[0:27:54] Yeah, the decision. I know we had the discussion. The decision was made and I
[0:27:59] think that Fritz had made the interpretation that Rebecca could still
[0:28:02] vote on the budget when we had the conversation. But yeah, the decision was
[0:28:07] made by the council at the very beginning of the process to incorporate
[0:28:13] the band into the line item process under parks and recreation and and exclude it
[0:28:19] from the M.P.O.G. process moving forward. That's right. And as I recall I think you
[0:28:31] had me declare conflict of interest before voting on the budget and by law
[0:28:37] tell me if I get this right they excuse me from a conflict and allow me to vote.
[0:28:41] I think that's what we did last year.
[0:28:47] I'm just struggling with that, for it's, I'll be honest with you, I don't mean to take up time, but we exclude ourselves from a lot of different items up here that actually go sit down, I don't know how a member of the council can just magically exclude.
[0:29:00] It's because it's this tiny little piece of your giant budget, and like I said before, I would say that she should not participate in any discussions about how much the ban should get this year.
[0:29:13] But once that decision is made by the rest of the council,
[0:29:17] I would say she's not excluded from voting on the rest of the budget,
[0:29:22] which includes what you've already decided on the ban.
[0:29:26] So I guess we're sort of separating it at one point, but she still votes on it as a whole.
[0:29:31] Okay.
[0:29:33] I'll go with our legal counsel's advice.
[0:29:40] All right, any further conversation about this council?
[0:29:42] Any ideas, any direction?
[0:29:44] I'll just throw in my two cents that I don't think you're going to get an answer, Mandy,
[0:29:49] and we're just going to have to make this sausage, and some of us can use this template
[0:29:54] as guidance to us to help us determine how we want to do that and guide our discussion.
[0:29:59] But I think it's going to be groupthink at its best to try to get to whatever the budget
[0:30:05] number is this year.
[0:30:07] Travis?
[0:30:08] And that was really the purpose of the conversation tonight.
[0:30:13] next week you're going to have the MPOD conversation starting at 4 o'clock, the groups are going
[0:30:17] to come in.
[0:30:18] And we wanted to make sure that the Council had the opportunity to discuss amongst its members
[0:30:25] the process that it was going to use to score the incoming applications for this year.
[0:30:32] I think that you've done that.
[0:30:34] And so I think that the purpose of the agenda item has been complete.
[0:30:40] If there was any assignment or some different thing that you guys were going to agree to,
[0:30:46] we would have tried to scramble to put that together and also notify the applicants.
[0:30:51] But it doesn't sound like that will be the case.
[0:30:54] It sounds like more of a—each have your own individual scoring process and then you
[0:31:00] will each go forward through that process to determine the allocation to the different
[0:31:05] entities who have submitted their applications.
[0:31:08] So, for instance, I have another question then.
[0:31:09] How do we reconcile our complex then?
[0:31:14] Because if somebody's on a board, somebody works for a
[0:31:16] graduate with a funding side of things.
[0:31:19] We struggle with that one every year.
[0:31:21] So, you know, I don't know which example we want to use.
[0:31:26] But.
[0:31:27] We can use transform in me.
[0:31:28] OK.
[0:31:31] Transform three of us.
[0:31:33] Transform, which is read by CSI.
[0:31:36] Correct.
[0:31:36] They're a physical management.
[0:31:37] So honestly, it's like, you're going to have to do what you've done in the past, and I know that doesn't work very well, but it makes it very difficult for you as a city council member, or as an employee of CSI, it's like which are you voting when you work on that.
[0:32:02] And what do your bosses think about how you voted on a matter affecting CSI?
[0:32:09] It's like it's, I don't know how you do it.
[0:32:11] I don't know.
[0:32:12] And it's worse when you're a board member or a chairman of a committee, it's like,
[0:32:17] which hat are you wearing when you sit up here and you can say you're wearing the city council hat?
[0:32:22] But what about the organization that you also represent?
[0:32:26] I think the whole concept of having the rating system and that we would not rate the entity
[0:32:33] that we had a conflict with was the key, but then we get into the sausage making of the actual budget,
[0:32:40] the dollars, that we go right back into that mode again.
[0:32:43] I know.
[0:32:44] It's very difficult for you.
[0:32:47] Chris, talking about...
[0:32:48] Well, last year, incidentally, we funded nine requests for $100,000,
[0:32:54] but by taking the 20 out for the band that would leave 80.
[0:32:58] I guess I'm trying to figure, did we or do we have a limit
[0:33:03] on the 80,000 for this year to be divided?
[0:33:07] It's actually 100,000.
[0:33:09] 100? Yes.
[0:33:11] So we've actually increased to 20% then.
[0:33:14] Well, we just took the municipal band out of the whole process
[0:33:17] and put them into our line item budget and then opened up.
[0:33:21] But Chris is right because if it stays at 100,
[0:33:24] I was going to mention that actually to council.
[0:33:26] Chris is right, it's been increased 20%.
[0:33:29] If we stayed at 100 grand, we'd taken one entity out
[0:33:32] that we gave 20 already.
[0:33:34] And I'm pretty uncomfortable in increasing the M talk
[0:33:37] by 20% one whole amount.
[0:33:40] And the request is we can see her for 189,
[0:33:43] close to $190,000, excluding the municipal band.
[0:33:50] So sausage making more rain.
[0:33:52] Greg Lanning, actually a couple of thoughts.
[0:33:57] One on the conflicts, just being involved in it.
[0:34:05] I mean, if you have a conflict, you have a conflict
[0:34:07] that's involved in it, because even if you're doing a rating
[0:34:09] and you don't rate that one, then you
[0:34:12] could be rating the others lower,
[0:34:13] knowing that your particular entity is going to be higher.
[0:34:17] So it's Southeast, I wonder how you look at all that.
[0:34:20] That part of concern.
[0:34:21] And I guess I'll probably be in the my own order in this, but I have no problem with increasing the amount by 20,000 and we stayed a hundred thousand of the bands out.
[0:34:30] And I misspoke as 25% increase.
[0:34:33] So before going to the next council person, Trev Strathweiler.
[0:34:39] So our CFO had shared with me that if you take a look at the budget, it was reduced by the 20,000.
[0:34:48] an opportunity to look at the $21,000.
[0:34:51] You have roughly $78,000 associated with the MPOG allocations, $21,000.
[0:35:00] And approximately $21,000, a little bit more went and slid over.
[0:35:06] The total allocation under miscellaneous illustrates $93,000, but
[0:35:10] that is for some other things, since Lori dug into the line item accounting and
[0:35:15] so give about $7,000.
[0:35:16] we did not be close to twenty twenty five percent you did not get twenty eight
[0:35:20] you have seventy eight thousand dollars to allocate
[0:35:23] rebecca masa
[0:35:25] thanks mary and that's all i was going to add as i just recall in our
[0:35:28] conversations last year i i had believed that we
[0:35:31] uh... the intent of the council
[0:35:33] in the discussions that we have to time was that we were reducing uh...
[0:35:36] the and pog total by that
[0:35:39] that's correct
[0:35:41] uh... i don't see any further lights
[0:35:43] Thank goodness, because we'll just complicate it worse.
[0:35:45] So I think we have somewhat of a direction.
[0:35:49] Okay.
[0:35:50] Thank you, Mandy.
[0:35:51] So then I will plan on getting you all of the applications
[0:35:54] tomorrow for you to have to look out over in preparation
[0:36:00] for next week's.
[0:36:01] Do you all want a copy, another copy of this, or no?
[0:36:06] No, we're good.
[0:36:08] Say thank.
[0:36:09] Okay.
[0:36:10] Well, I can.
[0:36:11] Okay.
[0:36:12] What do you just say?
[0:36:14] I'm just going to put those in our drop box.
[0:36:17] I could or I can email them to you, whatever is easier for you.
[0:36:20] Yeah, my drop box doesn't work, so just email.
[0:36:23] Okay.
[0:36:24] Okay.
[0:36:25] Or, I don't know when, I think you can come with the agenda.
[0:36:28] I'm going to leave it like it's the agenda.
[0:36:29] If you want them before that, or I can just go into the mail.
[0:36:32] I'd like to have them as soon as possible.
[0:36:33] So, I have our own city, too.
[0:36:35] I'll do that then.
[0:36:36] Thank you.
[0:36:37] Okay.
[0:36:38] So, Travis are we thinking about meeting next week at 4 o'clock?
[0:36:43] Yes, next week at 4 o'clock is with the applicants have been scheduled.
[0:36:46] Okay, very good. Thank you. Thank you, Mandy.
[0:36:49] Next item on the agenda is consideration of the request to approve the renewal of the PSI sanitary contract.
[0:36:57] And we have Bill Baxter. Welcome, Bill.
[0:37:00] Mr. I thank you mayor City Council. It's a pleasure to be here this evening although. I'm feeling a bit
[0:37:07] extraneous
[0:37:08] Dr. Slicker stepped up here and just pushed it right out in front and I have about
[0:37:14] Office from PSI back here to back me up so my comments will be fairly short
[0:37:20] Well hold you to them perfect. I'm done
[0:37:25] the
[0:37:27] The primary purpose for this presentation this evening is PSI and the City Manager's Office
[0:37:34] have been working and looking forward to the ending of the current contract in December
[0:37:40] of 2015.
[0:37:41] PSI approached us with a couple of different options for extending the contract which is
[0:37:47] actually provided for in the existing contract if the city and PSI reach terms that they can
[0:37:53] agree upon.
[0:37:56] brief history, PSI has been collecting the
[0:38:00] solid waste for the city in some form or
[0:38:02] another since 1970. In 2005 the city
[0:38:06] requested a more formal proposal for the
[0:38:10] service and PSI again won that contract.
[0:38:12] And then in 2009 city staff and the City
[0:38:16] Finance Committee worked to further beef up
[0:38:21] the process of the proposal and the bids
[0:38:24] that were submitted in PSI, won the contract again, which is the current one we're operating under.
[0:38:31] You'll see under the conclusion staff recommends the proposed terms under the 10-year contract
[0:38:37] option. It comes with a number of features including the donation of collection and container rental
[0:38:47] services for the city's permanent facilities, parks, office buildings, and the
[0:38:55] Durkis Lake Shoshone Falls facilities. So with that I think I will step aside and let
[0:39:03] PSI address any questions you may have and I certainly will be available for any
[0:39:08] others. And before the representative does that you can start making your way up
[0:39:12] sir yeah if you didn't introduce yourself when you get here Travis Rothweller I
[0:39:16] I think you had a comment, sir.
[0:39:17] Police, I just want to set the tone for the conversation.
[0:39:20] And I think that Bill kind of touched on that.
[0:39:22] And that is the contract is set to expire at the conclusion
[0:39:26] of this calendar year.
[0:39:28] The reason this item is before you now
[0:39:30] is because in the event that the Council does not
[0:39:33] want to move forward with the proposal that
[0:39:36] has been submitted by PSI, we will need
[0:39:38] to go through a request for a proposal process.
[0:39:43] And in the event that the Council elects to change
[0:39:46] its haulers and carriers, we need to make sure
[0:39:49] that they have enough time to ramp up to be able to take
[0:39:53] on the service at the conclusion
[0:39:55] of this contractual arrangement.
[0:39:57] So the reason it's coming to you in May
[0:40:00] is because we really believe that it's gonna take,
[0:40:04] should we go through a request for a qualified
[0:40:06] or proposal process, it'll take about 90 days
[0:40:09] to go through that process from start to finish
[0:40:12] And then that's the award and should you award to someone different.
[0:40:16] We're probably even a little skinny on that end of being able to make a safe transition based upon the number of containers in the capital investment possible different suitors may have to come up with.
[0:40:30] Thank you, Travis, thank you Bill.
[0:40:34] Thank you, sir.
[0:40:37] Mr. Mayor and members of the council, my name is Kevin Malone, I'm the district manager, general manager for PSI.
[0:40:46] Do you guys have any specific questions?
[0:40:48] I didn't know.
[0:40:50] Because I can go on and I just.
[0:40:52] Um, Chris, did you want?
[0:40:57] No, I want those to just counsel business, I can wait.
[0:41:00] OK.
[0:41:00] Rebecca Milsoy.
[0:41:02] Sure, I had a question.
[0:41:04] I appreciate the services that are being offered over the 10
[0:41:07] year contract.
[0:41:09] And one of those is all the collection services
[0:41:13] at our city locations.
[0:41:15] Would that include recycling for our parks?
[0:41:19] Yes.
[0:41:20] Okay.
[0:41:21] Because I do see that as a benefit.
[0:41:24] I'm a little uncomfortable with a 10-year contract just because, you know, in the past going out to bid and encouraging competition has really helped the city keep our costs down, but I certainly can't argue your track record with customer service and the great job that you've done.
[0:41:44] have done. I mean that's certainly evident through you know just citizen
[0:41:49] comment and through your responsiveness. So I do believe though that would be if
[0:41:56] that does include recycling for our parks I think that would be a great
[0:42:00] advantage to the city. Thank you. Any further questions? Kevin do you have if you
[0:42:07] want to? Well just you know we're really proud of the relationship that we have
[0:42:12] have with the city and staff and with council and we all live here and our guys are really
[0:42:22] excited they know what's going on and they know where they're at and they take it as a
[0:42:27] source of pride every day. So with us and anytime you want to haul us up here and you'll get
[0:42:35] all of us because you've got voices are office manager. So if anybody has a problem her team
[0:42:43] gets it first, and then Jared's our operations manager. He's our truck boss, so she calls
[0:42:48] him next. And then if I can't figure out the financials, I call Derek. He's our controller.
[0:42:55] Our maintenance managers at a maintenance manager conference out of town, but he would
[0:42:58] have been here too. So, you know, you can, at the drop of a hat, have us all where you
[0:43:04] need us. So we'll be responsive to your needs and the parks is a good example because we've
[0:43:09] got those pilot cans out there. We custom fabricated locks so people wouldn't steal
[0:43:14] that we're cycling and so we're willing to work with you for whatever you need and
[0:43:19] just because it's not in some paper agreement you know we'll we'll work with
[0:43:26] you we can't spend a million bucks just because but we can we can do a lot of
[0:43:30] stuff for you Chris talking to me well I'm going to bring this up to the council
[0:43:35] what Kevin perhaps you could provide information or one of your associates so
[0:43:39] So how many people do we have on the single-can 35-gallon rate?
[0:43:48] 72.
[0:43:49] Thank you.
[0:43:50] Because I would like to discuss this with the council at the time.
[0:43:56] Very good.
[0:43:57] You know Kevin, I just wanted to say that once in a while we get a complaint and I've fielded
[0:44:02] a few and taken them to council really regarding time of service and especially some of those
[0:44:11] homes that are along blue lakes and along a commercial port or where maybe
[0:44:17] their garbage is picked up fairly early and people want to sleep you know picking
[0:44:23] up garbage is big bins that are pretty noisy I two particular times that I've
[0:44:29] fielded these situations I know that you folks have been very responsive to that
[0:44:36] but I just wanted in a public forum I guess just remind you and if you could
[0:44:40] certainly share that with your drivers. I know the drivers want to get in, get their jobs done, and get home, but it's really important quality of life for folks that live along those corridors because there's mixed uses
[0:44:54] throughout the city that we try to maintain some quality of life for those folks.
[0:45:00] We those guys start early for safety because of blue leaks because that's very dangerous to maneuver and
[0:45:08] So what we've done in a couple of those instances is we've
[0:45:12] Like last week I went out it was
[0:45:14] It was me Pueblo, so I talked to there
[0:45:17] So we had to get there early for example
[0:45:19] It's weird stuff, you know because they had trucks parked there and so we got there for the trucks were parked
[0:45:23] But then the poor residents were like so what we did was when I I worked with him and we rerouted and the guy comes back now
[0:45:30] two o'clock. So when we have those issues and we certainly know that some of the
[0:45:35] parts that are in more dense areas and so we we route them as such as much as we
[0:45:40] can so and certainly if somebody has an issue that's really bugging them we can
[0:45:45] hint like I say we can we've got enough trucks going past blue lakes that we
[0:45:48] can usually move those nuisance ones. Very good. I appreciate that. Greg Lanning.
[0:45:55] Mayor Hall I would move that we extend the PSI contract with the
[0:45:59] provisions and the things that they're offering for 10 a 10 year extension. Second.
[0:46:06] Second. Second. Seconded by Suzanne Hawkins. Chris talking. I'd like to make an
[0:46:12] amendment but I'd like to back it up with some discussion first if I can do
[0:46:17] that. Absolutely sir. The last time the PSI contract came before us you may
[0:46:22] or may not recall I was asking for an opening up at a single can rate for a
[0:46:28] a very specific demographic and that's those people who are on largely single
[0:46:33] home occupants aged and don't utilize the services very much. Bell has
[0:46:39] indicated we only have 72 on the 35 gallon single can rate. Per the contract
[0:46:46] a prior counsel allowed this but since 2005 the contract has been closed for
[0:46:55] adding additional people or users, excuse me, accounts to the single can rate, which the difference
[0:47:03] would be $4.80 a month versus 10.31, am I correct, or 80 versus 10.31.
[0:47:13] As we're all aware with our doing our long range planning and the demographics of our
[0:47:19] city, people on retirement age and fixed income are some of the fastest growing demographics
[0:47:26] in Twin Falls. And we all get accosted by various special interest groups. And I guess
[0:47:33] because of my age, I get my share of seniors. We in particular, a lot of widow and widowers
[0:47:39] who do not in a month's time come close to filling up one of the 95 gallon containers.
[0:47:48] And I would really think it'd be egalitarian for the council to consider an amendment to
[0:47:55] Section 1A2, which speaks to the single-can 35-gallon rate.
[0:48:04] And I would suggest the following language as an amendment that those building addresses
[0:48:16] where all occupants are over 65 may apply to Twin Falls City to qualify for single can usage rates
[0:48:29] and may be required to verify age qualifications upon request or future age qualifications upon request.
[0:48:40] Did you get that, sir?
[0:48:44] The do you want me to repeat that, Council?
[0:48:46] Well, it is recorded.
[0:48:48] So it is recorded. So in terms of sharing being able to write it totally down that we have that covered.
[0:48:54] And I think that's the amendment, but just the justification, it's not a matter of $5 and change.
[0:49:03] It's the amount of in charge for a service that perhaps has been subsidized by the big users.
[0:49:11] that the little users are just feeling that there's a little bit of an equity here.
[0:49:16] I'd like to add this amendment, I think, to recognize that we're encouraging reduced garbage
[0:49:25] output by virtue of recycling.
[0:49:28] And I think this would recognize the demographic part of our city that is a small user
[0:49:33] and they should be given a little pat on the back.
[0:49:36] And I thank you by this amendment.
[0:49:38] So at this point, we'll wait for a second.
[0:49:40] If we do get a second before we go into discussion.
[0:49:49] Do we have a second?
[0:49:52] Motion fails for a lack of second.
[0:49:54] Travis, did you want to comment before I go to Council?
[0:49:57] I did.
[0:49:59] Just real quick, so I know that I recognize
[0:50:01] that there's a motion on the table.
[0:50:03] Staff was looking for guidance on renewing and what option.
[0:50:10] And then we would like to go back with PSI
[0:50:12] to negotiate some other things
[0:50:14] bring a complete agreement at a later date back to the city council for its
[0:50:20] consideration tonight and I apologize that that wasn't a clear in the agenda statement
[0:50:24] but what we'd like to do tonight is first to test the water to see if the council was
[0:50:29] in favor of a ten-year agreement or or a five-year which was whichever those
[0:50:34] would be and then after we took the pulse of the council bring that a finalized
[0:50:41] negotiated agreement between both sides back to the City Council for its
[0:50:46] ratification at a later date. So let me get this straight. We're a little premature
[0:50:50] on actually voting on a ten year at this point. If you are satisfied with the
[0:51:01] current agreement the Council believes the current agreement here you can
[0:51:04] certainly make that motion staffs in vision that we would go back to the
[0:51:09] the table with PSI and have a couple of conversations.
[0:51:12] Thank you, Travis.
[0:51:12] We do have a motion on the floor,
[0:51:13] but we're in the discussion stages.
[0:51:16] Rebecca, Mel, so I could.
[0:51:17] Thank you, Mayor.
[0:51:18] Yeah, I just had a clarification on the motion,
[0:51:20] because what I understood is we were choosing either option one
[0:51:24] or option two.
[0:51:25] And so just a question for the motion maker,
[0:51:28] you're endorsing option two, which is the tenure
[0:51:30] with the value of gifted services that come with that tenure.
[0:51:36] Yes.
[0:51:37] Very good.
[0:51:39] John Berger. Before bringing it forward, I support the concept that Councilman
[0:52:00] Tockenton brings forward that folks who use the service less, having an option for
[0:52:06] a lesser level of service to accommodate that, I would be open to. I struggle with
[0:52:12] an age definer being the definition of how much trash you're producing. I think
[0:52:18] there are probably young people that do a good job of not producing a bunch of
[0:52:22] trash to. So if we're considering going back to the table, talking about the cost implications
[0:52:29] of that to PSI, because I know that was the discussion previously, it's cost the same amount
[0:52:34] of money to pick up a 35 gallon can as it does a 95 gallon can. Maybe there's a sweet spot
[0:52:39] in the middle there if we talk about a lesser single can service. I also would like to throw
[0:52:47] out the idea of offering recycling service to commercial customers or apartment
[0:52:53] dwellers and what that might look like to include in there as well because if
[0:52:59] we're talking about the level of service as opposed to the term of the contract
[0:53:03] I'd like to see an increased recycling focus in places where it's not available
[0:53:08] now and also addressing those who are conserving finding a way to make that
[0:53:14] that affordable on both ends of the contract.
[0:53:17] Greg Lanning.
[0:53:19] Well, in my mind, what I was making the motion for,
[0:53:25] and Travis, please correct me if I'm wrong,
[0:53:29] is that we were going to go into negotiations
[0:53:35] for a 10-year contract extension.
[0:53:37] And we were willing to do, we'll look at the 10-year,
[0:53:39] because Chris's motion, I really wanted to be able
[0:53:44] second I could because I know you're fixed costs if we if this was exactly as it is
[0:53:49] and we said suddenly all you everybody wants a 35 gallon can can do it then
[0:53:55] like shots it it costs the same amount to pick that can opposite as the big can
[0:54:00] it's just the the fee at the other end when you dump it off it's different but
[0:54:05] all of your fixed expenses don't change at all zero you still have to have the
[0:54:09] driver you still have to have the truck you still you know all you have to fuel
[0:54:12] the whole thing and so either our full the one can rate is going to have to go
[0:54:19] up or to subsidize that other what we're allowing the full service can price is
[0:54:27] going to have to go up to do so and so because if I look at this and I think of
[0:54:33] your cost what if you have we have a thousand people one-on-one can service
[0:54:37] suddenly you got to go out and buy a thousand thirty-five gallon thing because
[0:54:40] because it isn't reflected anywhere here.
[0:54:43] You have an expense, we've just thrown an expense on you.
[0:54:45] So in my mind, if I'm wrong, we're agreeing to a 10-year contract extension with PSI and
[0:54:53] then you're going to do the fine tuning and you've given us some examples of things you
[0:54:58] can probably do if it's a 10-year extension, is that correct?
[0:55:03] That's correct, you know, we still have to negotiate the contract, but in my ex understanding
[0:55:09] was if you approved it, then we negotiated,
[0:55:12] it doesn't really change,
[0:55:13] because we have to tweak some stuff,
[0:55:15] and like I say, add some service,
[0:55:17] or even change the rate structure at the end,
[0:55:19] it's, we can negotiate all that,
[0:55:21] because we still signed the contract in the end, so.
[0:55:26] And those comments you made are absolutely true.
[0:55:29] Those cards right now look like $55 each,
[0:55:32] so that's a lot of money.
[0:55:36] $55,000, there's a thousand people's foot.
[0:55:38] So it goes up quick, but again, you know, you said you could adjust the other
[0:55:45] rate, we compensate. Again, that's the nice thing about a 10-year agreement too,
[0:55:48] because say we can try things and if it's wrong and we guess and we say well we
[0:55:54] got to adjust it by 10 cents on this one and we do that and it's wrong, we don't
[0:55:58] have to come back and scream we need to figure out what's wrong, we got 10 years
[0:56:02] to fix it. You know, so that from our, it works both ways, that's the beauty of it,
[0:56:06] is that we can, you know, just because, like I said, it's on paper, we sit down and talk
[0:56:11] and we both agree, we want to contract, we both agree that we want to change something,
[0:56:15] we make an amendment, we sign it, we move on. I mean, it's not like the Constitution, you
[0:56:21] know.
[0:56:23] So Travis, I have a question for your clarification. The motion as it stands right now, is there
[0:56:30] in the negotiation piece attached to that? Or how did you take the motion?
[0:56:37] So what I understood the motion to be tonight was that you would enter into a 10-year agreement
[0:56:45] with PSI, and I believe that the agreement in place would be the agreement that would
[0:56:55] be part of that 10-year conversation and the rates that were provided by Kevin and PSI.
[0:57:03] So it does not give us the option or our ability to do negotiations about service and costs
[0:57:08] and all those things if we adopt the motion as presented.
[0:57:12] That was my understanding of the motion that was made.
[0:57:15] Well, I'll just weigh in.
[0:57:16] I'm not comfortable with the motion right now
[0:57:18] because I do like the idea of some negotiation.
[0:57:20] There's some services that I wanted to talk to you about,
[0:57:23] frankly, when it comes to recycling.
[0:57:26] I know personally at my house and I've talked to other folks
[0:57:28] that there are times that we have more recycling
[0:57:31] than we do garbage because we really work on that.
[0:57:35] And so recycling coming every other week
[0:57:37] sometimes doesn't work very well for us because it stacks up and we don't give you as much
[0:57:41] garbage.
[0:57:42] So I'd like to be able to talk about that.
[0:57:45] So as the motion sits right now, I can't support just doing a contract.
[0:57:51] So Susanna, it's my motion and we're willing to withdraw and maybe we'll alter a little
[0:57:55] bit so it allows for the negotiations.
[0:57:57] So are you withdrawing?
[0:57:58] I'll walk around the motion and then I'll second it briefly.
[0:58:01] So Omega, could we go through some lights for us to come back in?
[0:58:05] That's how I was going to get the motion forward for round discuss though.
[0:58:08] Well, let's see if there's some other concepts here for Suzanne Hawkes.
[0:58:12] Thank you.
[0:58:13] So this is for Travis.
[0:58:14] If we proceed with the tenure contract extension, will there be a clause or whatever in there
[0:58:20] for every year, every other year to renegotiate or to be able to look at this contract or
[0:58:25] is this the tenure's firmer?
[0:58:30] We always have the right and all the agreements have the right to open and to review and to
[0:58:35] to evaluate.
[0:58:36] Thank you.
[0:58:37] We're back in the next slide.
[0:58:40] I was going to float a motion but if Greg wants to make one that way or two.
[0:58:46] Chris talking to.
[0:58:47] How many contracts do you recall we have that are ten year now?
[0:58:52] The one for CH2M was the last one I recall that that was five or seven.
[0:58:57] It was a ten year agreement?
[0:58:59] It was.
[0:59:00] Do you recall other ten year contracts we have?
[0:59:04] I believe that for services, PSI and CH2M Hill would be the only ten-year agreement.
[0:59:20] The people for pets animal shelter is a five.
[0:59:25] He's a five and I'm not aware of any agreements for service entities after those three.
[0:59:33] What about the why? How long is the why?
[0:59:38] We get us with the pool. That's right
[0:59:42] And the golf course those are seven-year agreements
[0:59:46] Greg Lang I move that we extend the
[0:59:51] extended
[0:59:52] Pursuit a ten-year contract extension with PSI with the
[0:59:57] The city manager and his staff to be in negotiations with
[1:00:01] with PSI for the final numbers to be brought back to us.
[1:00:05] Second.
[1:00:06] And motion on board by Greg 19, seconded by Susanna Hawkins again.
[1:00:10] Anything further on that motion council?
[1:00:14] Rebecca Milsoyko.
[1:00:15] Again, should we include that it is with those options to just to include the mentioning of
[1:00:21] the donated services that is being offered with the ten years as opposed to the five year?
[1:00:27] Travis, you're part of the negotiation.
[1:00:31] It's not part of the current contract, but it was a part of the presentation this evening.
[1:00:35] I believe the 10 year proposal that was submitted by Kevin and PSI includes all of those options that he has presented.
[1:00:42] So all of the don't include all of the donated services.
[1:00:45] Sean Berger.
[1:00:46] I would also encourage consideration of some of the items that were brought up by council members tonight as you're looking at the negotiation as well.
[1:00:53] And perhaps if we have others, we can drop an email to the city manager to include that.
[1:00:59] Thank you, Sean.
[1:01:00] Anything further council?
[1:01:02] Sharon, roll call, vote, please.
[1:01:11] Chris Hockington.
[1:01:13] Although I strongly support PSI service, I think 10 years is too long.
[1:01:17] I'm voting no.
[1:01:20] Greg Lanting.
[1:01:21] Yes.
[1:01:22] Don Hall.
[1:01:23] Yes.
[1:01:24] Rebecca Mills-Soyka.
[1:01:25] Yes.
[1:01:26] Suzanne Hawkins.
[1:01:27] Yes.
[1:01:28] Sean Baraker.
[1:01:29] Yes.
[1:01:30] Motion passes 5 to 1.
[1:01:33] Thank you Kevin for being here.
[1:01:34] Thank you very much for your attention.
[1:01:36] with your patients, I'd like to switch around the agenda just a little bit.
[1:01:43] We have a council member that needs to leave early this evening and wanted to be part of
[1:01:47] the budget priority philosophy conversation and we are creeping on up to the time when
[1:01:55] that person would need to leave.
[1:01:56] So I would like to move us to item number seven and talk, have a general discussion about
[1:02:03] City Council's fiscal year 2016 budget priorities and philosophies followed by
[1:02:08] citizen input. We have our city manager Travis Rupple.
[1:02:13] Mr. Mayor, members of the Council, thank you for the opportunity.
[1:02:17] Tonight is the second of a whole series of meetings that will start to have a
[1:02:22] conversation about the budget and the budget process. Tonight's idea is to have
[1:02:28] the Council really begin to have a response, if you will, not only to the
[1:02:33] long-term planning presentation that was received and presented last week, but really to also
[1:02:39] share some of your thoughts and your ideas as they relate to the City Strategic Plan as
[1:02:44] we move forward.
[1:02:45] And then tonight also with the approval of the mayor obviously is the opportunity for members
[1:02:52] of our community to also share budget priorities that they would like to see considered as
[1:02:59] we draft this budget.
[1:03:01] The next opportunity.
[1:03:03] I just wanted to state publicly that any time we're going to be discussing the budget,
[1:03:07] there will always be, as long as I'm in the seat, a time for our citizenry to come forward
[1:03:12] and talk to us about budget priorities.
[1:03:14] Travis, thank you.
[1:03:16] The next opportunity will be on May 26th as we continue to have that conversation.
[1:03:21] We've really done what we've could so far to help spread the word to get people to become
[1:03:27] engaged and to have an opportunity to address the budget at the front end as it's been shared by the
[1:03:33] members of the council. The most effective opportunity and the most effective time to participate in the
[1:03:38] city's budget is not on the back end but really on the front end of that creation. So tonight is
[1:03:44] really staff's opportunity to listen to the members of the council, share their thoughts and their
[1:03:49] budgetary philosophies as we continue to move forward. Department leaders will take that information
[1:03:55] and we'll take the long-term planning recommendations,
[1:03:58] and we will then go through our process
[1:04:01] to really begin to build and craft a sustainable balanced budget
[1:04:05] that will be presented to you on July 6th.
[1:04:10] So with that, we turn it over to you.
[1:04:14] I'll open it up for discussion from Council.
[1:04:20] Chris, talking to him.
[1:04:27] It's kind of tough just dropping in the middle.
[1:04:29] Don't you have a little easier segue for the county?
[1:04:32] He's in and on this, I can name a couple of priorities I have that I think are consistent
[1:04:41] with their strategic plan.
[1:04:44] He would just basically say that with the impact upon homeowners for a wastewater plant
[1:04:52] and other tax-reported funds that I'd be very hesitant to go for much increase in the mill
[1:05:00] levy this year hopefully we'll have a lot enough growth coming on the tax
[1:05:05] rolls that it'll make an easy choice for us aside from everything that we have
[1:05:10] talked about in specifics on the strategic plan. I just have a couple of my own
[1:05:17] goals I'd like to as Don kind of alluded to is see what we can do to tweak and
[1:05:23] incentivize recycling and I would also remind us that we apparently in the
[1:05:28] midst or the beginning stages of a devastating intermountain west drought and I think water
[1:05:38] conservation is not getting quite the service it needs.
[1:05:42] I think we need to look for everything from advertising to enforcement to reviewing how
[1:05:49] we water our parks, pushing the secondary non-potable water supplies, everything associated with
[1:05:56] water conservation, including looking at reviewing the sum of our zoning plans eventually to
[1:06:02] encourage other than grass planting, and getting rid of a lot of these little tiny pocket parks
[1:06:10] that are planted in grass and require watering, so that's kind of a side ball through the budget.
[1:06:16] And I'll shut up now.
[1:06:18] Thank you, Chris.
[1:06:19] Rebecca, may I second?
[1:06:21] Thank you, Mayor, and appreciate arranging the public hearing now.
[1:06:26] Really, I want to make sure we hear from the public.
[1:06:29] But just a couple of things I'll throw out for the budget since I probably won't be here next week since my day.
[1:06:36] I might be having a baby next week.
[1:06:39] And if I'm not, I probably won't be comfortable enough to come join you.
[1:06:44] So I did just want to throw out a couple of concepts that I've been hearing from the public.
[1:06:49] And one is on our sidewalks.
[1:06:51] And I know that both of these items also
[1:06:54] have a strong presence in our strategic plan.
[1:06:57] So connectability and walkability
[1:07:01] and just providing safe routes around the city
[1:07:06] for non-motorized travel.
[1:07:09] Perhaps we can, I know we don't have the answer
[1:07:11] for the funding mechanism, but my thought
[1:07:15] is to maybe create some funding for incentive program.
[1:07:19] an incentive for homeowners to take that step and say, yes, I'm going to invest in my property.
[1:07:25] I'm going to invest, you know, maybe it's an 80-20 share where the city shares 20% or,
[1:07:32] you know, we organize the work so that we have a better economy of scale and it's more affordable for one neighborhood.
[1:07:41] But I would propose that we identify some high traffic, maybe some arterial or
[1:07:46] collector streets that need some work on the sidewalks and try to have a little bit of
[1:07:51] funding.
[1:07:52] You know, of course, you know, you know, we can't go out and put a lot of money.
[1:07:56] It's, I think the last time the engineering department talked about the total need for
[1:08:02] the sidewalks, it was just 30 million or something unattainable.
[1:08:07] But if we can somehow incentivize property owners, just a little bit, kind of help them out and
[1:08:14] encourage them to invest in their properties, invest in those sidewalks.
[1:08:18] I think that would make a lot of citizens happy because I just, you know, I don't know
[1:08:21] if you guys have heard of it.
[1:08:22] I've heard a lot lately about the condition of our sidewalks.
[1:08:27] Just the second thing is to continue with our strategic plan in diversifying our park
[1:08:32] system.
[1:08:33] I mean, we just received an incredible gift from First Federal Bank and to just partner
[1:08:39] with them and I appreciate the long-term planning committee that did recommend the pavilion out
[1:08:45] there in some seating but you know I drive by the dog park.
[1:08:49] I don't have a dog but you know sometimes I'd like to just stop by and visit other people's
[1:08:54] dogs and you know and I don't you know so I'm not that person at the park but you know
[1:09:00] people are always there and they're standing around and they're bringing their own chairs
[1:09:04] And they just they don't have any shade because the trees are small and they don't have any chairs or any place to sit.
[1:09:12] So I would encourage us to continue to improve upon our park system and also to support the number of employees that we need as we have been increasing their workload.
[1:09:26] We've been increasing their burden.
[1:09:28] We need to make sure to keep the staffing levels appropriate
[1:09:32] for the grounds crews and the maintenance crews.
[1:09:36] And I know there was a proposal for administrative position.
[1:09:40] But I think before we, in recreation,
[1:09:45] but before we look at our administrative positions,
[1:09:47] I think we need to make sure we have enough people
[1:09:51] on the ground taking care of those parks.
[1:09:52] And to continue to diversify different types of parks and
[1:09:57] be responsive to the needs of our citizens in that area.
[1:10:01] That's all I have.
[1:10:02] Thank you, Rebecca.
[1:10:03] Great landing.
[1:10:04] I'm going to, actually, mind your going to piggyback a little bit on both
[1:10:09] crystals and Rebecca's.
[1:10:11] I would like to see some numbers in the budget on whether or not we can
[1:10:17] expand the PI systems into some existing neighborhoods.
[1:10:20] at least make sure we have pumps and things in place on the ones that are already double
[1:10:26] piped. I think we may have them all done, but in case we don't, I think we certainly need
[1:10:30] to make sure that this conservation obviously is going to be, that's the cheapest water
[1:10:36] source you have is conservation. And then, I really like your idea on this
[1:10:44] sidewalks, Rebecca, but I just can't come up with the logistics to make it happen in
[1:10:48] my mind, but that's why we hired people, smart people to work for us.
[1:10:51] I know these guys can.
[1:10:52] Maybe they can.
[1:10:54] I'll throw out an example of one of our nearby cities who maybe they have more crews than
[1:11:00] they need.
[1:11:01] I'm not sure, but they have a standing thing.
[1:11:03] If you'll pay for the materials, they'll provide the labor to replace your sidewalks.
[1:11:08] And I'm not sure that that's one that we can replicate, but it's certainly one other city
[1:11:17] that does has made the effort to replace sidewalks in their city and it's replacement
[1:11:22] for the most part.
[1:11:23] It makes a lot of employees, I don't know and things but my last one would be is and I'm
[1:11:33] sure that the engineering department will have their own ideas of where this might be and
[1:11:39] think but I'd like to see if we have a road that we need to rebuild I think we need to
[1:11:44] to show the citizens that we have that extra 461,000 in our budget from the gas hacks that
[1:11:52] was just approved.
[1:11:53] And if we could find a road to rebuild along with our own funds to have that be an example
[1:12:00] of how we're utilizing that money to make our roads better, and not just throw it right
[1:12:05] into the maintenance department.
[1:12:06] I'd like to see something that we can point to and put again, and as I will caution all
[1:12:13] all of us were all one person and they can't, one person does not make a priority.
[1:12:18] So if other people have the same priorities, then it works, if they don't, then it's not
[1:12:23] really a priority coming from council, it's coming from one person.
[1:12:26] Thank you.
[1:12:27] Greg, Suzanne Hawkins.
[1:12:30] Thank you.
[1:12:31] I just kind of went down the strategic plan.
[1:12:32] So I'm going to try to read my notes and keep this straight.
[1:12:36] So of course, everybody wants to see the trail continue to get attention, but I also just
[1:12:41] kind of want to remind us not to forget about that big dream of a rec center someday.
[1:12:45] I know that's in our plan and sometimes we don't talk about it and I know the committee
[1:12:49] has already finished their work on it, but I'd like to see us do what we can do to try
[1:12:53] to push that dream forward.
[1:12:57] We did a street light survey last year or year before and I don't know if I ever saw
[1:13:02] the results of that where people felt safe and not safe on intersections and I've had
[1:13:07] I had a couple calls recently on people who feel there's some areas that are too dark.
[1:13:12] One of them being in front of CSI with students from the dorms walking along falls.
[1:13:17] They didn't feel like, well, the new section of falls that has all the lights was so great
[1:13:22] and then in front of the college itself it wasn't well lit.
[1:13:25] So maybe if we could see where that survey went and if there's money we have to check
[1:13:29] some of those dark areas for extra lighting.
[1:13:34] I'm, of course, supportive of continuing funding zone maintenance to the best of our ability to keep that project running because that seems to be working really well.
[1:13:45] I'd like to see us continue to work on the development codes that we've started looking at where we're lacking.
[1:13:52] And maybe I don't know what we need there as far as personnel and support to help with some of those issues.
[1:13:59] One thing I didn't really hear a lot of last week from the long term planning.
[1:14:02] And I was kind of curious because we gave it a number one priority in the strategic plan,
[1:14:07] is the business retention and expansion project.
[1:14:10] And again, I don't know if that means we need to hire someone to help get that program
[1:14:14] launched or what support we need to give to economic development.
[1:14:19] But I'd like to see us look closer at that and where we need to go with that one.
[1:14:24] And another one that I noticed that I'm not sure if we've made much headway on is we were
[1:14:30] We're going to conduct a communication audit on our outreach efforts.
[1:14:33] And I don't know if we ever really followed through with that study or not.
[1:14:38] I know Josh is doing a great job moving things out.
[1:14:42] There was also information on there in developing a welcome packet when people are new to the city.
[1:14:46] And I don't know, I've never seen one, so I don't know if we got one put together on that, but I'd like to see us continue.
[1:14:54] And then for our city staff to continue moving the pay scale in the direction we've started the last two years.
[1:14:59] like to make sure that we don't skim over that this year either.
[1:15:04] Thank you, Susan.
[1:15:05] Sean Berner, that one.
[1:15:07] Thank you, Mayor.
[1:15:07] So I don't have a lot of specific items that I'd like to bring forward.
[1:15:13] But I would like to just make the general comment that our community continues to grow.
[1:15:20] We have very robust economic activity going on.
[1:15:25] And I think what we as both residents and business owners in the community
[1:15:30] to think about is what level of service do we want from our city government, for everything
[1:15:35] from trails to roads to sidewalks to rec centers to whatever, and that that needs to be the
[1:15:42] focus of how we're crafting the budget, not what kind of a target tax rate we want to hit.
[1:15:49] We need to be prudent and responsible in that number, but I think that the presentation last
[1:15:54] last week from the long term planning committee, and even though my phone did die at the end
[1:15:58] of the conversation, I heard all but like the last priority.
[1:16:03] So but I appreciate the work that that group put together, really looking at not only
[1:16:12] what do we need to address our city's needs now, but as we continue to be prosperous
[1:16:16] into the future.
[1:16:17] So I would just encourage, again, both citizens and business property owners who may not live
[1:16:24] in the city but pay their taxes here to come talk to us about what level of service do you
[1:16:30] want, not necessarily what your project is that you'd like to bring forward.
[1:16:36] Thank you, Sean.
[1:16:37] I'll be the last one speaking, this evening, and then I hope we turn it over to the citizens
[1:16:42] and hear their input, but I'll just go through my list very rapidly, hopefully.
[1:16:48] Canyon Springs Road, we certainly appreciate that we're going through an engineering study
[1:16:51] and looking at that.
[1:16:52] I wish we had it in front of us.
[1:16:54] That could help us really guide on expenditures towards that,
[1:16:59] because we know that we're going to have to do something
[1:17:02] with that roadway, the safety of it, the safety of it.
[1:17:06] I'm going to jump on my soapbox again about water storage.
[1:17:10] We certainly appreciate and know that we have some water
[1:17:13] storage that we, a major project this year.
[1:17:17] But in my view, it's not enough.
[1:17:19] We need more water storage in this community
[1:17:22] as we grow with the population.
[1:17:24] I think that's very important.
[1:17:25] Roadways, we need to continue the focus on roadways,
[1:17:31] maintenance of them so that we can stand top of those
[1:17:35] as Jackie so eloquently tells us it's much easier
[1:17:38] to maintain them than rebuild them, much more economical.
[1:17:42] Trails and bike routes and those kind of things
[1:17:44] are very important to me because not only
[1:17:47] for the amenities of them for our community,
[1:17:49] but we have to remember that they are transportation routes as well.
[1:17:54] More and more of us are on to-wheeled transportation,
[1:17:59] and that's a big deal for our community, I believe.
[1:18:03] Workforce housing issues.
[1:18:06] I know that we're going to be speaking about that later
[1:18:09] with the Will's Booster Station issue,
[1:18:11] but we need to do what we can as a city to help our development
[1:18:16] community to develop workforce housing.
[1:18:19] And because we need employees for these industries that have come to our community.
[1:18:25] And then what's been touched on before is our employee compensation.
[1:18:29] We certainly want to stay on top of that.
[1:18:31] We have a lean, mean group of employees that work very hard for us and
[1:18:37] we need to compensate them fairly.
[1:18:39] We don't want to fall backwards again and then try to catch up.
[1:18:44] We need to make sure that we have the resources and
[1:18:47] We give the compensation package that can attract the best and the brightest to work for our community within the City of Twin Falls.
[1:19:00] So with that, Rebecca, I was really hoping to open it up to the public because I know we had limited time, but I'll turn it over to you.
[1:19:06] Okay, well I just wanted to second,
[1:19:07] the King Springs grade, I mean really and well done,
[1:19:10] but as Greg said, I wanted the staff to hear support
[1:19:14] for, I believe that should be a funding priority.
[1:19:17] Thank you for bringing that up.
[1:19:18] Very good, thank you.
[1:19:20] Now, I would like to turn it over to the community
[1:19:23] for anyone that would like to come forward
[1:19:25] and talk to your city council regarding budget priorities.
[1:19:29] This is one of the most important things that we do up here.
[1:19:33] working with staff, of course our city manager forms a budget, a balanced budget, brings it
[1:19:40] to us. We work through that issue, but we need to hear public comments. So podium is yours.
[1:19:51] Be careful on the way though, sir. If you would state your name where you live and then
[1:19:56] please address the council.
[1:19:58] My name is Steve Woods, I live in the area of impact, east side of town. The one thing that
[1:20:04] going here and he mentioned about as Twin Falls approaches the 50,000 population level is spending money on a
[1:20:12] transportation plan
[1:20:14] That is hopefully inadequate in town. We have all sorts of people driving
[1:20:19] One person in a car all over town and I think that needs to go away in the future
[1:20:24] I appreciate that sir, but that was a subject of one of our earlier
[1:20:28] agenda items. So we're on top of that, but we appreciate your input on that.
[1:20:35] Thank you. I just didn't hear it discussed in the budget.
[1:20:37] Very good. Thank you. Is there anyone else that would like to come forward?
[1:20:41] You might mention the multiple times or have public input times. This is not the only.
[1:20:47] Absolutely. Every time that we open up and have a discussion regarding the budget, we will be inviting the public up forward.
[1:20:54] If tonight you're not coming forward, please know that there'll be opportunities in the future Travis
[1:21:00] Can you tell us how many times we're going to do that because I know you have that memorization?
[1:21:03] This is for folks at home to listening 12 12 times 12 times and
[1:21:10] Not aware of a single entity
[1:21:13] Let alone in the Magic Valley, but just really not aware of a single entity out there that really
[1:21:18] tries to make that commitment to have the public become very engaged in the
[1:21:23] appropriation of the property tax dollars and the user rates. Our next time is
[1:21:27] going to be on the 26th. After the meeting on the 26th then we will begin again on
[1:21:34] the 6th of July and it will be every subsequent meeting in the month of July
[1:21:39] and August until its ultimate adoption at the end of July. Thank you Travis and
[1:21:44] also just let the public know that that's what we're here for to if you can't make
[1:21:48] it to a meeting you can certainly email your comments to either council members
[1:21:53] city staff and make sure it's not on to Rebecca during her labor process here
[1:21:59] soon okay that might not be her priority right then CC dawn on that one yeah so
[1:22:05] there's gonna be ample opportunity for the public to comment on the budget
[1:22:08] priorities is there anyone else that would like to come forward this evening
[1:22:12] All right, folks, I am going to, because it's 6.25 almost, I'm going to go ahead and take
[1:22:19] about a seven minute break and then we're going to jump into the next agenda item.
[1:22:24] So that's where we'll go.
[1:22:26] And Don, I'm going to see if I'm sure.
[1:22:28] Full City Council meeting for May 11th, it is about 6.32.
[1:22:34] So the next item on the agenda is presentation of an update on main avenue redesign progress
[1:22:40] with a focus on main avenue parking configurations by OTAC.
[1:22:46] I will first introduce our economic development director, Melinda Anderson.
[1:22:51] Thank you, Mr. Mayor and good evening, Mayor and Council.
[1:22:54] Thank you for this opportunity to give you an update.
[1:22:57] I just want to set a very short introduction before Mandy Roberts
[1:23:00] from OTAC comes and makes another presentation on our redesign, again,
[1:23:07] focusing on parking.
[1:23:09] After last month when Mandy was here, she spoke with our pack as she does every month.
[1:23:15] She also spoke with the Urban Renewal Board and she also came to City Council last month as well
[1:23:20] and talked about parking.
[1:23:22] Since then, there has been regarding parking a lot of outpouring by a lot of interested citizens
[1:23:32] regarding specifically back in angled parking as one of the options that we've been looking
[1:23:39] at to help create more parking and make it safer for everyone.
[1:23:44] I suspect that even you all have probably had conversations with interested citizens about
[1:23:49] this topic as well.
[1:23:50] So Travis asked that Mandy come again this evening.
[1:23:54] She's been here all day making presentations to pack again as well as to the Urban Renewal
[1:23:59] Board regarding potential parking configurations.
[1:24:06] She had come up with four specific ones to look at since these meetings have happened.
[1:24:11] She'll get into the details of it.
[1:24:12] One of them is not quite as viable as we had hoped because of certain life safety issues
[1:24:19] that need to be created, but she'll go into that with you.
[1:24:22] She's going to start out, though, talking about reminding us about the guiding principles
[1:24:28] that we developed last fall for this whole downtown redevelop process, as well as community
[1:24:34] value values that we've all talked about, but what is important for us as we're doing this
[1:24:39] whole redesign along Main Avenue. So instead of me just groaning on and on, I'm going to
[1:24:44] ask Mandy Roberts to step up to the podium and begin her presentation. Thank you.
[1:24:50] Thank you. First of all, Mandy, I want to welcome you, but before we begin, really, I
[1:24:55] want to, and I've heard this from a couple different council members, and I want to say
[1:24:59] this in front of the citizenry. We have not made any decision on the parking
[1:25:03] configuration of Main Street yet. We are just taking input. We're going to talk about some
[1:25:07] demonstration opportunities and we're just trying to figure out what the best option would be and
[1:25:13] I know that's that's what you're here for. But we're a little bit afraid that it's taken away from a
[1:25:19] little bit of the momentum of downtown. What's going on? There's great things going on downtown.
[1:25:24] So please if folks would just be patient with us while we're going through this process and looking
[1:25:29] looking at different options, I think that would be very, very helpful.
[1:25:33] Mandy, you're on.
[1:25:34] Yes, I agree.
[1:25:35] Thank you so much, Mayor and Council for inviting me.
[1:25:37] Thank you, Melinda, for the introduction.
[1:25:40] And I wanted to start out as Melinda indicated, just revisiting some of the guiding principles
[1:25:46] that we developed early on in our process for the main avenue project.
[1:25:50] We worked with our project advisory committee to develop those and then took them out for public input
[1:25:55] when we did workshops in October and also got input on them when we were here in February
[1:26:01] for the workshops.
[1:26:02] So, there's some overarching guidance there that's really important to think about as
[1:26:06] we look at these different options with you.
[1:26:11] Also want to go through some of our analysis and why we've been looking at some of the
[1:26:15] options that we have been and the trade-offs involved in spatial decisions.
[1:26:21] And then just summarize what we feel might be the potential scenarios to consider as we
[1:26:28] move forward and then at the end we'll talk about next steps in our process as well as
[1:26:33] some of the upcoming events including the demonstration of back-end angle parking downtown.
[1:26:42] So we have a long list of guiding principles.
[1:26:46] I'm just attempting to really summarize these here.
[1:26:49] I believe they were in your packet, and they're also on our project website, which is TwinFalls
[1:26:55] Main Avenue dot com.
[1:26:58] A few of the key points I would say that we've heard repeatedly in our processes, there's
[1:27:04] a real strong interest in making sure that the streetscape is sustainable, and there's
[1:27:09] a lot of different elements that relate to sustainability, but I think the clearest message
[1:27:15] is that it's a streetscape that's easy to maintain.
[1:27:18] It has lasting permanence.
[1:27:20] Once we build it, it's going to last another 40 years,
[1:27:23] just like the last one did.
[1:27:26] And that with that, there's a commitment
[1:27:28] to the long-term care of that streetscape.
[1:27:31] And so while we'll, in design, we'll
[1:27:33] look at water conservation.
[1:27:36] For example, we'll look at using materials
[1:27:39] that are really durable.
[1:27:40] But still, there will be some maintenance for the streetscape.
[1:27:43] And it's important for council to consider that as we move forward.
[1:27:47] Another really important message is that similar to what you were talking about with your strategic
[1:27:53] plan, there's a really strong interest in making sure main avenue enhances pedestrian and bicycle
[1:27:59] safety.
[1:28:00] And that when people are on foot or on bike, they have improved access on main avenue as
[1:28:07] as well as getting to Main Avenue across the seconds,
[1:28:10] for example, which are busy streets.
[1:28:13] We've talked about this in the past,
[1:28:15] but Hanson Street as a key corridor
[1:28:18] is something that there's a lot of support behind,
[1:28:21] and making that also a pedestrian and bicycle-friendly
[1:28:25] corridor has been important in our process.
[1:28:29] Lighting, that was interesting that that was mentioned tonight
[1:28:34] in the discussions.
[1:28:35] We do have some areas of main avenue that need better lighting, primarily to really enhance
[1:28:42] the sense of security and really bring warmth and attractiveness to the streetscape so that's
[1:28:47] something people have put as a guiding principle, and the alleyways as well, that those become
[1:28:52] more pedestrian friendly, more attractive, more pleasant places to be as potential connections
[1:28:58] between the rear parking areas and main avenue.
[1:29:03] We've talked in the past about the Shoshone main avenue intersection and its historic significance.
[1:29:09] And there's a very strong interest in commemorating that in the design.
[1:29:14] The signature public space, which is really the downtown commons project proposed at the Rogerson site.
[1:29:20] As well as making sure we have public restrooms associated with that piece of the project.
[1:29:26] And festival street areas, which I know you've heard me talk about in the past, but
[1:29:29] Those are really raised areas of streets that can be closed and really function as a pedestrian
[1:29:35] space when they're closed.
[1:29:37] So, a couple final points.
[1:29:42] There's a really strong interest in making sure that this five blocks becomes a downtown
[1:29:47] destination for families and not just in the summer but year round and that's why you've
[1:29:52] heard me talk in the past about programming the downtown commons, for example, with possibly
[1:29:58] a portable ice skating rink or holiday lighting as a theme downtown so other ways to really
[1:30:03] attract people in the community. Last but not least certainly we've been hearing from
[1:30:11] the community that everyone would like to see that Main Avenue really becomes the heart
[1:30:16] of the Twin Falls community. That is really a vibrant place and a focus for investment
[1:30:22] and pride and interest downtown.
[1:30:25] And we're seeing that happen.
[1:30:26] There's some successes, certainly.
[1:30:29] We'd like to see that happen
[1:30:30] throughout the full five block area.
[1:30:34] The city has stated, and the community has stated,
[1:30:38] interest in complete streets for everyone's use.
[1:30:42] And really what that means is that we design streets
[1:30:44] so that they accommodate all modes, pedestrians,
[1:30:47] bicyclists, motorists, eventually transit riders as well.
[1:30:51] And I think many of you will know and recall that Maine Avenue has been designated as a
[1:30:56] bicycle route in the city's adopted plans and it was subject of a survey done a few
[1:31:03] years ago.
[1:31:04] There was a strong interest in making sure that bicycling was accommodated on Maine
[1:31:09] Avenue.
[1:31:10] So with all of that in mind, you know, we want to create a really vibrant, active street
[1:31:16] similar to this photo in another place, but you can see that the more people that you
[1:31:21] accommodate whether it's pedestrians, bicyclists, transit motorists, the more people we're going
[1:31:26] to be able to have downtown and that's more activity, more economic revenue and just really
[1:31:32] contributes to the vibrancy.
[1:31:36] So with that, I wanted to take a minute to thank Council Member Talkington because he gave
[1:31:43] me some photos when I was here in April and we've been able to really look at these photos
[1:31:48] and reach back and understand what main avenue once looked like, and how it might look in
[1:31:53] the future with some of the design scenarios that we're considering.
[1:31:57] So from this photo in the 1940s you can see that main avenue was heavily parked, very efficiently
[1:32:03] parked with diagonal parking on both sides of the street, and very few, if any, I don't
[1:32:10] think there are any trees, frankly, or planting areas or amenities, it's just the sidewalk
[1:32:14] space.
[1:32:15] We don't have an as-built that tells us what these dimensions were, but we were curious about them.
[1:32:22] So we did some scaling.
[1:32:23] We looked at this gentleman here thinking, oh, he's probably about an average height, a little bit below average height, person, five feet, six inches.
[1:32:31] And if we scale him across the parking area, that tells us that roughly those sidewalks were about 13 to 14 feet.
[1:32:42] And what's really interesting about that is that's what they are today as well.
[1:32:46] We do have survey information, JUB did a detailed topographic survey of Main Avenue for this
[1:32:54] project, and we were able to really confirm the existing dimensions and also look at this
[1:33:01] design, how it was implemented in the past, some of the things that have changed over
[1:33:05] the years.
[1:33:06] For example, you'll notice that the light poles are different now.
[1:33:09] So those earlier modern light poles weren't very durable.
[1:33:14] So when we think about that sustainability, we want to make sure we have really durable
[1:33:17] light poles.
[1:33:18] Are those the same kiosks they look like?
[1:33:20] They are, yes.
[1:33:22] They're a long way.
[1:33:26] Yeah.
[1:33:28] So when we take that view and we put it into cross-section, here's the really interesting
[1:33:36] piece of information.
[1:33:38] We have about a 14 and a half foot sidewalk amenity space on either side of the street.
[1:33:44] And this does vary by the way in the streetscape.
[1:33:46] We do have some areas where we have parallel parking or no parking on one side of the street today.
[1:33:52] But just to kind of look at the angled parking both sides as a comparison, we've drawn that up.
[1:33:58] We have 16 foot parking bay links.
[1:34:04] So that's basically the dimension from the face of curb out to the end of where the parking
[1:34:08] striping is.
[1:34:10] And we have valley gutters, of course three foot valley gutters on three blocks, and travel
[1:34:16] lanes that are 10 and a half feet.
[1:34:18] What's really remarkable about this is that this street was designed in the late 1960s
[1:34:26] to a different set of standards even when cars were bigger.
[1:34:30] But today, we actually require wider lanes and longer parking dimensions than are out there today.
[1:34:38] So we've been working a lot with city staff to really understand that.
[1:34:41] And one of the issues is, and you'll see this if you go down, walk main, a couple times.
[1:34:47] A lot of times bigger trucks, pickup trucks, aburbins, vans, even some of the work trucks.
[1:34:52] They are parked extending out over the valley gutters and even into the travel lane.
[1:34:58] And so what happens is not only are you really backing out blindly under the current condition
[1:35:07] in a lot of cases, but you're also backing out around that extended vehicle, and sometimes
[1:35:14] people are backing out over the center line, which is a concern.
[1:35:21] So we started to evaluate what are our options to moving forward, knowing that we've got
[1:35:27] those values that we want to be consistent with, how do we fit that all into a 90 foot
[1:35:34] right of way?
[1:35:35] Basically, that's what we have, 90 feet, no one's talking about expanding that, we're
[1:35:39] going to be between the buildings at 90 feet.
[1:35:43] And one of the things we know is we need a wider street, and the dimensions vary depending
[1:35:49] on how parking's oriented, so I'll go through that in a minute.
[1:35:52] We need a wider street, we need longer parking stalls, and the red lines kind of represent
[1:35:59] the approximate dimensions of what we need as we move outward.
[1:36:06] We would like to have bicycling facilities, and those can happen in a number of different
[1:36:10] ways.
[1:36:11] It can be sherrows striped in a shared street.
[1:36:14] They can be bike lanes, which are typically five feet wide.
[1:36:19] We still want to have trees and areas for light poles and benches and amenities.
[1:36:25] And then last but certainly not least, in fact this is really a high priority.
[1:36:30] We want to make sure that we have a great pedestrian environment with generous sidewalks, similar
[1:36:35] to what's out there today, 14 feet would be great.
[1:36:39] And that provides space for sidewalk cafes and people to put their displays out and things
[1:36:44] like that they do today.
[1:36:47] So how's it all going to fit?
[1:36:48] It doesn't all fit, as you can see, and so in our design process, we have been working
[1:36:54] to really look at what are the options to share space, what are the trade-offs.
[1:37:01] We've through our process some of the things that we've heard clearly as priorities are
[1:37:06] making sure that downtown is a pedestrian-friendly environment, that we have space for sidewalk
[1:37:11] cafes. Parking has been kind of an ongoing issue throughout our process, but we've heard
[1:37:19] everything from, you know, keep parking about the same as it is today in terms of the quantity
[1:37:24] to try to increase parking on each block as much as you can in design. We've even heard
[1:37:30] a few folks say, well, what if we didn't have any parking at all on Maine and it was a pedestrian
[1:37:34] mall and people parked behind. But really the majority, I would say the majority of people
[1:37:39] would really like to see more parking on main avenue.
[1:37:42] We've heard that pretty clearly.
[1:37:44] We've heard a lot about bicycling safety, visibility
[1:37:47] from the groups that we've talked with, traffic calming,
[1:37:50] making sure that people are traveling at slower speeds,
[1:37:53] and then also encouraging more use of the back parking areas
[1:37:57] and enhancing the pedestrian way from the alleys
[1:38:02] to main avenue to really make that a safer route for people.
[1:38:07] So some of the things that we've been testing out
[1:38:09] in design and talking with folks about include looking at back-end angled parking and one of
[1:38:15] the reasons why we've been looking at this as an option is it actually helps us economize
[1:38:20] on space quite a bit because we can use sherrios with back-end angled parking.
[1:38:26] Just to do some comparisons of dimensions here, we've worked with city staff to identify
[1:38:30] by these dimensions, we would have 11 foot travel lanes
[1:38:35] and 17 foot parking links.
[1:38:40] And that basically would be an adjustment of the curve
[1:38:42] by about one foot on both sides.
[1:38:45] So just a minor impact to this amenity and sidewalk space.
[1:38:53] The nice thing about this idea is it really
[1:38:56] orients the driver to oncoming traffic,
[1:39:00] including bicyclists that might be sharing the road.
[1:39:04] And instead of having to pull out back around a vehicle,
[1:39:08] you can pull right out into traffic.
[1:39:10] I'll show you that in a minute.
[1:39:11] So if you are a partner adjacent to a bigger vehicle,
[1:39:16] you have a direct view of oncoming traffic
[1:39:19] in this back-end configuration.
[1:39:21] And of course, I've talked in the past about,
[1:39:23] you either have to back up when you leave,
[1:39:27] or you can back in when you arrive at your parking stall.
[1:39:30] So this is just kind of changing that movement around.
[1:39:34] We've also talked about making the stalls
[1:39:36] a little bit wider to give people a little bit more
[1:39:39] maneuverability as they're backing in.
[1:39:42] So the huge benefit is that drivers
[1:39:46] have an oncoming view of other cars and vehicles.
[1:39:50] They also would have, sorry about that,
[1:39:53] an oncoming view of bicyclists.
[1:39:59] And because of that, the city feels really comfortable
[1:40:02] that we could do a share of Mark's markers in the street.
[1:40:08] And that would serve as a formal bicycling facility.
[1:40:11] Mandy, you're probably going to get to it,
[1:40:12] but I want to make sure I address this
[1:40:14] because I've had this question.
[1:40:16] As you can see the pickup back in there,
[1:40:18] you can see the bed of the pickup
[1:40:19] is actually over onto the sidewalk.
[1:40:22] How do we ensure that that pickup doesn't go back
[1:40:27] and hit someone, run into a tree,
[1:40:29] run into a garden spot, all those dynamics?
[1:40:33] Yes, through design, we have a lot of guidance
[1:40:36] that tells us what the maximum overhang of vehicles
[1:40:40] would be in either front end or back end configurations.
[1:40:44] And so typically what you'll see along that curb edge
[1:40:47] is basically, in addition to the curb,
[1:40:50] maybe some paving or unit pavers or low landscaping
[1:40:54] that wouldn't be damaged by backing in.
[1:40:56] And you would place trees and lights and benches
[1:41:00] and all that further in to the amenity zone,
[1:41:03] so it would be out of that overhang area.
[1:41:08] So as I mentioned, then one of the advantages
[1:41:11] and one of the reasons why you don't need as much space
[1:41:14] as with front and angled parking
[1:41:17] is people can just pull right out
[1:41:19] into the stream of traffic really easily.
[1:41:22] Couple of other advantages, if you've got things to unload
[1:41:25] from your car, your trunk, or your pickup bed,
[1:41:28] is pointing towards the sidewalk, it's easier
[1:41:32] for unloading rather than sitting out in,
[1:41:34] standing out in the street for unloading.
[1:41:36] It also funnels your passengers, children, pets,
[1:41:41] as the doors open.
[1:41:42] People are oriented back towards the sidewalk
[1:41:44] rather than out towards the street.
[1:41:47] So there's a lot of reasons why we've been looking at this.
[1:41:49] Space is an important one,
[1:41:51] but there's also some other advantages,
[1:41:53] including safety, visibility,
[1:41:55] and just operations of this idea.
[1:41:57] How do you combat the flash or the pushback
[1:42:01] that some of us are getting from,
[1:42:03] on my case, the older segment,
[1:42:05] that they're adamantly opposed to the back end.
[1:42:09] You know what the question is going to be.
[1:42:11] You're facing the danger at the front end
[1:42:13] of your parking experience or the back end,
[1:42:16] but they're saying, well, I can't turn around,
[1:42:18] I can't see to back in.
[1:42:21] Yeah, and you really have to do that because I have that problem as well,
[1:42:25] Steph Neck, you really have to do that whether you're front in angle or back in angle.
[1:42:30] And Melinda, yeah.
[1:42:32] I actually had an experience with that last week and a half ago.
[1:42:35] I was out on a two week road trip.
[1:42:38] I was in downtown Tacoma to have lunch with one of my sisters.
[1:42:42] I had Tacoma has on some of their downtown streets.
[1:42:45] I have back in angle parking.
[1:42:47] I had never tried it before.
[1:42:48] So I said, okay, here's my opportunity, I need to try it.
[1:42:51] So I did, and at my first attempt, it took me two tries.
[1:42:55] So the first try, when I was looking back over out the windows,
[1:42:59] I realized I could not see the lines.
[1:43:01] I said, well, that's not gonna work, so I pulled back out.
[1:43:04] And I used my side view mirrors to guide me back
[1:43:07] in between the lines.
[1:43:08] That's how I was able to do it.
[1:43:09] Now, I don't know if that's the way everyone
[1:43:11] will be able to do it, but that's the way I figured it out.
[1:43:16] Suzanne Hawkins.
[1:43:17] Thank you.
[1:43:17] Well, we're asking real quick,
[1:43:18] How do you answer the concerns we've been getting about exhaust?
[1:43:22] Yeah.
[1:43:23] So a couple of things that we've been looking at in the design
[1:43:27] is that even though we're showing this cross-section,
[1:43:29] there's an opportunity in design to create
[1:43:33] curb extensions or bulb outs in front of some of the cafes,
[1:43:37] sidewalk cafes, where you wouldn't necessarily
[1:43:40] have to have parking in those areas.
[1:43:41] And I'll show you an example of that in a minute.
[1:43:44] But then you can have the outdoor cafes in those areas.
[1:43:47] We, honestly, when people park, they typically turn their engine off right away, and it's not
[1:43:54] that there would be this accumulation of exhaust.
[1:43:57] It could be, you know, in convenience, but it would be similar to what parallel parking
[1:44:02] is like today.
[1:44:03] And certainly, it's kind of worse in the winter.
[1:44:06] You know, it just seems to be more of a pollution issue in the winter, and that's when people
[1:44:10] aren't necessarily out dining.
[1:44:13] But anyway, in design, we would look at, you know, how to make sure we avoid having exhaust
[1:44:18] going directly in the sidewalk cafe areas. So yeah.
[1:44:22] Has anybody talked to, the one I think about is since they have
[1:44:27] parallel parking right next to their areas would be the Old Town GR.
[1:44:33] If they talked about the exhaust, because you're at that one table, you'd be sitting right by the
[1:44:38] the rear exhaust of the car that's parallel parked.
[1:44:42] I haven't had a chance to get down or ask them,
[1:44:44] I was going to do that.
[1:44:45] Yeah, you should.
[1:44:45] I haven't heard that from them, specifically.
[1:44:47] OK.
[1:44:49] So this next cross-section is, OK, what if, and there
[1:44:52] is this sort of visceral reaction to back-end parking
[1:44:55] with the public.
[1:44:56] We understand that.
[1:44:58] A lot of it has to do with we can't go out and visit with every
[1:45:01] single citizen and explain all of these reasons why we're
[1:45:04] considering it.
[1:45:04] So as you hear it for the first time, you're like, well, why
[1:45:07] How would you do that, and a lot of folks here maybe haven't experienced it, they don't
[1:45:12] know what the benefits are.
[1:45:14] So it's a tough nut to crack, we recognize that.
[1:45:17] And so if ultimately the decision is made to keep parking configured similarly to what's
[1:45:24] there today with front end angled, we can design that.
[1:45:28] It's not a problem, but there are some trade offs to be aware of.
[1:45:32] So because of that issue that I described earlier with vehicles backing out around other vehicles,
[1:45:39] we need to make the travel lane wider.
[1:45:41] So you'll see here we've got 12 foot lanes compared to 11 foot with back and angle.
[1:45:47] We also need to make the parking length, the length of the bay longer.
[1:45:52] So we've got 18 feet on both sides here as opposed to 17 with the back and angle.
[1:45:58] So what that does is it then just encroaches that much further into the sidewalk and amenity
[1:46:05] zone about three feet on either side and we start to see about an 11 and a half foot space
[1:46:12] on either side of the street.
[1:46:14] That's getting to be kind of narrow compared to in the 1940s that 13 or 14 foot length or
[1:46:21] width excuse me and what we have out there today.
[1:46:24] So it's a trade-off, it's something to think about.
[1:46:26] The other issue is that while by making everything wider, you would improve visibility because
[1:46:35] you would basically have a little bit more time as you're backing out slowly to see on
[1:46:39] coming traffic.
[1:46:41] But you still would be backing out blindly around vans and vehicles that aren't transparent.
[1:46:48] And certainly with the bicycling situation, there's a real concern about marking sheroes.
[1:46:55] This is a key point.
[1:46:57] With this design, the city is not comfortable marking sheroes in the travel lanes because
[1:47:04] it's just doesn't have the safety and visibility that you would have.
[1:47:09] So if we want to go by the idea of being a bike route, a bike way,
[1:47:18] This doesn't really meet that value, so we have to really decide if maybe we want to change
[1:47:23] that value, we want to look at other corridors for bicycling.
[1:47:27] There's some things that can be done, but it's, again, a trade-off that has to be considered.
[1:47:32] So with the wider lanes, again, we wouldn't see, we wouldn't expect to see as much of that
[1:47:38] issue of people backing out over the center line because they would have more space as
[1:47:43] they move around.
[1:47:46] So just a few other things to show you.
[1:47:51] We've also looked a few times at what kind of space would we get if we had angled parking
[1:47:57] on one side of the street and parallel parking on the other side of the street.
[1:48:03] And we certainly would buy enough space to have bike lanes or sheroes in that configuration.
[1:48:10] What we would lose is roughly a parallel parking space is about 20 feet long and you can fit
[1:48:17] two angled parking spaces roughly per one parallel space.
[1:48:22] So we would lose, wherever we had parallel parking, we'd lose the opportunity to have
[1:48:26] two spaces versus one.
[1:48:28] But there, on the other hand, there are lots of areas of parallel parking out there today.
[1:48:33] So it's a condition that's out there today.
[1:48:36] We have heard people be concerned about just how difficult it is to parallel park.
[1:48:40] a lot of maneuverability, and actually there's a lot of sources that say that back-end angle
[1:48:45] parking is easier than parallel parking.
[1:48:48] So another thing to consider.
[1:48:50] If we did this configuration with parallel on one side angled on the other, it could be
[1:48:55] either front end or it could be, sorry, too fast, it could be either back-end angle on
[1:49:01] the one side which we gain some space or front end where we have to provide a little bit
[1:49:07] more space for maneuverability.
[1:49:09] So both of those are viable options.
[1:49:12] I wanted to just share with you a couple of other 90 foot
[1:49:15] right-of-way streets that we've been studying.
[1:49:19] This is Higgins Avenue in Missoula, Montana.
[1:49:23] And the key message is that everybody has,
[1:49:25] every community has to make their own decision
[1:49:27] about how they want to use their space.
[1:49:30] So here on Higgins Avenue, they have a lot of access ways
[1:49:34] and driveways along this segment of the street.
[1:49:38] So they've got a center turn lane.
[1:49:40] We don't have the need for that on Main Avenue.
[1:49:44] So instead of having a center turn lane,
[1:49:46] we could use that extra space for angled parking,
[1:49:49] both sides, which is why you've seen what we presented.
[1:49:52] The other thing that's really interesting
[1:49:54] about this design is that they've got raised bikeways
[1:49:59] on either side of the street.
[1:50:00] If you can see, try to point it out.
[1:50:03] This area here is actually at sidewalk level.
[1:50:07] So they've got the raised, could be called a cycle track
[1:50:11] or raised bike lane and amenity zone
[1:50:14] and then the sidewalk here.
[1:50:17] So that's a becoming a popular approach
[1:50:19] to bicycling in a lot of communities
[1:50:22] is doing the raised cycle track areas
[1:50:25] and there's a lot of different ways to do that,
[1:50:27] whether it's just by a change in color or material
[1:50:30] or marking those areas.
[1:50:32] So it's something to consider.
[1:50:36] Let's go back this way.
[1:50:37] Moscow, Idaho, also a 90-foot right of way.
[1:50:41] I happened to be there a couple of weeks ago
[1:50:43] because I'm on the board for the College of Art and Architecture.
[1:50:47] And I noticed that they striped sheroes on Main Street in Moscow.
[1:50:52] This is an old Google Earth image,
[1:50:54] so it doesn't have the sheroes on it yet.
[1:50:56] But they actually have sheroes on both sides of the streets.
[1:50:59] And one of the reasons why they were able to do that there
[1:51:02] with the front end angled is they actually
[1:51:04] have a lot more street dedication areas. So they're basically making from
[1:51:11] stripe to lane here, that's about 30 feet. So these lanes are about 15 feet wide. So
[1:51:19] it gives you some room to put your arrows what you sacrifice is sidewalk space.
[1:51:24] The new art stiller? Yeah. Holy crap.
[1:51:29] Oh, yeah, so, you know, we'll put this all together in a matrix, you know, as far as the trade-offs and things to consider with each scenario.
[1:51:40] But, for example, if you do look at parallel parking or even no parking on one side, you could have the ability to meander the street.
[1:51:50] So, that's a possible option, sub-option.
[1:51:56] We have been working, we've had a few conversations
[1:51:59] with some of the merchants and property owners
[1:52:02] between Shoshone and Gooding,
[1:52:04] and they have a very strong interest in,
[1:52:08] right now between O'Dunkins and roughly the Brass Monkey,
[1:52:12] there isn't any parking today.
[1:52:14] So they have a strong interest in keeping that
[1:52:17] and extending it to the Paris building
[1:52:21] as a no parking area and designing that whole beige area
[1:52:24] there as a raised festival street area.
[1:52:28] So we drew this up to show what that would look like.
[1:52:31] This is showing back in angled parking,
[1:52:34] but basically through this design,
[1:52:36] we're actually able to get a few more parking spaces
[1:52:39] out there than what exists today,
[1:52:41] just because we're doing the angled parking
[1:52:44] much more efficiently than how it was laid out
[1:52:47] in the late 1960s design.
[1:52:52] We also took a look at, it was a fleeting look,
[1:52:56] but we also said, okay, what if main avenue
[1:52:59] could become a one-way street?
[1:53:00] What would that look like?
[1:53:02] How would the circulation work?
[1:53:04] And we actually looked at, well, what if you split
[1:53:07] the main avenue one way at Chashone,
[1:53:10] since that's the predominant direction
[1:53:12] that most people come to main avenue?
[1:53:14] And people, if you did this, people would be able to
[1:53:17] basically circulate around the blocks
[1:53:21] to find parking either in the back or to come back to Main Avenue.
[1:53:26] It would take people to parking areas.
[1:53:28] However, we worked today with staff
[1:53:33] on what the dimensions might need to be.
[1:53:36] And it doesn't really.
[1:53:37] You think it would buy us a lot of space,
[1:53:39] but it doesn't really.
[1:53:40] Because we need to have, in the event
[1:53:44] that there's an emergency or a fire on Main Avenue,
[1:53:46] we need to have enough space that fire trucks can pass a car
[1:53:51] a line of cars that might be in the main avenue.
[1:53:55] So basically, the only way you can make this work
[1:53:58] is if you had parallel parking on one side,
[1:54:01] and that doesn't really get us a lot
[1:54:03] because we've already got parallel parking on one side
[1:54:06] options with bikeways that are two-way.
[1:54:09] So we're thinking this might be an alternative
[1:54:11] that gets considered and rejected,
[1:54:13] but we've had a lot of people ask about it,
[1:54:14] so it's important to show that we studied it.
[1:54:20] So really, I think what we first see as the potential scenarios to consider moving forward
[1:54:27] is the back-end head-out parking with sheros, and that would be considered to be a complete
[1:54:33] street.
[1:54:34] You could also look at parallel parking one side, back-end angled on the other side, and
[1:54:39] you could either do sheros or bikeways, whether they're bike lanes at grade or raised to the
[1:54:44] sidewalk level.
[1:54:46] That would be a complete street.
[1:54:48] You could also do parallel parking on one side,
[1:54:51] pardon the typo there, and front end angled
[1:54:53] on the other side with churros or bikeways,
[1:54:57] and that would be a complete street.
[1:55:00] Or you could do head in, back out parking on both sides
[1:55:05] of the street, but we wouldn't put churros on the street,
[1:55:09] and therefore it wouldn't really be a complete street,
[1:55:12] and it would require probably the city to take a look
[1:55:16] at some of the plans that have been adopted
[1:55:17] that call me in as out as a bicycling way.
[1:55:23] So we understood and heard that there's a strong interest
[1:55:26] in really getting some more public feedback on this.
[1:55:30] And I will say I'm really pleased with how much feedback
[1:55:33] we are getting, whether it's negative or not.
[1:55:34] It shows that we're connecting with people.
[1:55:37] People are engaged and they care.
[1:55:39] So it's really wonderful to be working in a community
[1:55:42] that cares so much about this project.
[1:55:45] So through the demonstration that's
[1:55:48] going to happen on Main Avenue. It's basically going to happen between, on the segment between
[1:55:53] Hanson and Idaho on the, on Main Avenue South between DL 11th Bank and the end of the block.
[1:56:00] On May 13th through May 27th, that will be strived. People can go out and try their skills
[1:56:07] at back in angled parking. And then we'll also have a questionnaire online on our website
[1:56:13] Twin Falls Main Avenue dot com. Once you go out and try it, you can fill out the questionnaire.
[1:56:17] us know what you thought what your experience was like.
[1:56:21] Then we'll be back on May 26th to Council and the public's invited to provide input again
[1:56:26] at that May 26th meeting.
[1:56:30] Our hope is that very soon after that a decision can be made and today with the Board, the Urban
[1:56:36] Renewal Agency Board, there was a suggestion that perhaps there could be a joint meeting
[1:56:42] with you when you get to that stage.
[1:56:45] But ideally if we could get direction in June and the earlier in June the better, just to
[1:56:50] keep our process on track, that would be great.
[1:56:53] Then we would be able to finish up preliminary design, do your cost estimate for preliminary
[1:56:57] design and then hold an open house to really show that before the project moves into final
[1:57:04] design which would happen summer and fall.
[1:57:07] I do want to mention that actually the utilities design work in the alleys, we've talked about
[1:57:12] that in the past where we're going to be replacing and upgrading the utilities and
[1:57:15] alleys, that's already going to be moving ahead into final design. So that's
[1:57:20] consistent with what we've talked about, possibly staging construction in
[1:57:23] the alleyways first before main avenue. So even though we might be a little bit
[1:57:28] delayed by a month or two in our process, it still fits with the implementation
[1:57:33] staging that we've been discussing. And then before that utilities work, then
[1:57:38] and it's anticipated that that would be bid
[1:57:40] and construction would start sometime in early 2016.
[1:57:45] So I'm happy to answer any other questions you might have.
[1:57:48] I was remiss in stating that Rebecca,
[1:57:51] so I think our council member had to leave
[1:57:53] for an appointment and she's given me a laundry list
[1:57:55] of questions to ask you,
[1:57:56] but I'm gonna wait and allow the rest of the council
[1:57:59] to go first, Chris talking.
[1:58:00] Well, I think we've got some controversial decisions
[1:58:04] to make on Main Street as we know
[1:58:08] we're going to be castigated from left, right, up and down on whatever travel and parking
[1:58:14] arrangements are eventually decided upon by the council, but I think at this time it's
[1:58:21] not too early to start tossing overboard some of the more or less popular ideas that there
[1:58:30] are just going to waste time and resources and I've yet to hear a single person in favor
[1:58:36] of the one way main street and I think my personal indication would be jettison that
[1:58:43] plan right now I don't know what the rest of the council feels like just to make it one
[1:58:46] less step for Mandy and company to deliberate on.
[1:58:51] On that subject I think you pretty well stated that it's almost impossible to do for the fire
[1:58:56] trucks and those kind of things so I think Chris is right.
[1:58:59] Yeah it doesn't really buy us any space.
[1:59:01] Okay.
[1:59:02] I would try to live on that one.
[1:59:06] I was actually very much in favor of it till we got the fire engine situation because I think it would be if you look at the flow of on Main Street right now
[1:59:17] it really is very much one way the way you're talking about people come down to the street turn down to the street turn
[1:59:24] a lot of people come in from the other ends and so but if it doesn't work it doesn't work. Yeah, so
[1:59:31] Suzanne, how can you think you can you explain and I probably should have maybe been listening better
[1:59:36] why that the parking spaces have to be deeper for front-end versus back-end?
[1:59:42] Yeah, it really has to do with that issue I was talking about, particularly when a vehicle
[1:59:48] is taking up the whole length of that stall and hanging out into the valley gutter, that
[1:59:53] cars have to back out around that vehicle and they're backing out over the center line
[1:59:59] under today's condition.
[2:00:00] Well, I know, but we're looking at them the same way it's the same length cars, whether
[2:00:05] they back in or pull in, but under the two diagrams you have, you said you need an extra
[2:00:09] foot if it's front end, but it's the same size vehicle's going in.
[2:00:14] That's right, but because when you do the back end arrangement, your head out, you don't
[2:00:19] have to back out around behind that vehicle, you can just head out right into the stream
[2:00:24] of traffic.
[2:00:25] So you don't need that extra maneuverability.
[2:00:29] It's a narrower turn as I would say.
[2:00:31] and coming out of the parking space.
[2:00:33] Exactly, okay.
[2:00:37] Sean Berger.
[2:00:39] So, a couple of questions.
[2:00:42] With the review of these various options
[2:00:44] is the intent that whatever design gets picked
[2:00:48] is applied uniformly across downtown,
[2:00:52] or would there be a possibility of this block
[2:00:56] would be back in parking,
[2:00:58] this one would be parallel only, and so forth?
[2:01:02] Yes, we've vetted that with the project advisory committee.
[2:01:05] And also, I brought that up when we
[2:01:07] had block-by-block meetings in March with property owners
[2:01:11] and tenants.
[2:01:13] Folks really feel they've expressed to me
[2:01:15] that if you're going to do parking,
[2:01:17] it really should be consistent throughout.
[2:01:21] And that really speaks to whether it's back
[2:01:23] in or front end, block-by-block.
[2:01:25] That doesn't mean that we might have some areas of parallel
[2:01:28] parking still or no parking.
[2:01:31] We've talked about, I showed you that example in front of O-dunkins for as one possibility.
[2:01:38] But just in terms of flipping from back in angle to front in, block by block, probably
[2:01:44] wouldn't want to do that.
[2:01:46] People seem to be worried about that and it just would make people confused.
[2:01:50] But we might have some segments of parallel parking, you know, still, as we design and
[2:01:55] lay out the street.
[2:01:58] And then as you're talking about this five-block section, so some of these blocks are underdeveloped
[2:02:04] at the moment.
[2:02:06] How do you predict in the future where you might need sidewalk patio restaurant seating
[2:02:13] in a block that currently is unoccupied buildings, for example?
[2:02:19] Because to just design sidewalks for the restaurants that exist today isn't really a 40-year strategy.
[2:02:25] Yeah, no, that's definitely a challenge.
[2:02:29] One of the things that when we've talked about that
[2:02:31] with folks is that some of these buildings
[2:02:35] are equipped with kitchen facilities and some aren't.
[2:02:38] And we do have kind of a sense of where
[2:02:42] the restaurants are today, where they were in the past.
[2:02:46] That doesn't necessarily mean that somebody
[2:02:47] couldn't come in and retrofit their property to add a kitchen.
[2:02:51] So there's a great solution for that.
[2:02:55] And it's called portable cafes, sidewalk cafes.
[2:02:59] I don't know if you guys have seen these.
[2:03:00] They have them in Louisville, Colorado.
[2:03:05] What's another, there's some insult to the Utah.
[2:03:08] What you can do for the summertime
[2:03:10] when you have cafes seating is you can either let out
[2:03:16] or just let people use platforms
[2:03:19] that they can put over the top of parking spaces
[2:03:21] in front of their cafes.
[2:03:23] And it's really in the past where I've seen it done with cities.
[2:03:26] It's really kind of a choice working with that merchant
[2:03:29] or restaurant or of, you know, well, is it more important
[2:03:33] for you to have a couple parking spaces in front?
[2:03:35] Or could we do a platform cafe space for you?
[2:03:38] So I can bring some pictures of that next time,
[2:03:40] but it's one possible solution.
[2:03:42] And then I have one other question
[2:03:43] and then I'll let you put your list.
[2:03:46] What about the alleys as bike lanes?
[2:03:51] Yes, thank you for asking that
[2:03:53] because I neglected to mention that we did talk about that
[2:03:56] with staff and we looked at that.
[2:03:59] There's a couple of key issues.
[2:04:01] One is that there's really a lack of visibility
[2:04:05] as you're coming out of the alley
[2:04:06] and approaching cross street traffic.
[2:04:08] So bicyclists would have to be directed to stop
[2:04:11] at every street, whereas if they're in main avenue,
[2:04:15] they don't have to stop as much.
[2:04:17] So it would just impede their traffic.
[2:04:21] It also, you know, even though we're going to really fix
[2:04:24] up those alleyways and make them attractive,
[2:04:26] it's not the place to be that's vibrant downtown.
[2:04:29] So, those are some of the key issues that came up.
[2:04:33] Thank you.
[2:04:35] I don't know if you're prepared to answer these questions,
[2:04:38] but maybe we could take them down or I can share it with you
[2:04:41] and then you'd get back to us.
[2:04:42] But Rebecca really wanted to know about the spaces
[2:04:45] on Maine right now in its current configuration,
[2:04:48] how many parking spaces are there.
[2:04:51] How many do you project with the back end angle front end angle back in one side parallel
[2:04:58] on the other side?
[2:04:59] I can get these two.
[2:05:00] So I don't know if you need red to have it.
[2:05:03] Front end angle no park on the other side.
[2:05:06] Those are some of the questions she has.
[2:05:08] Right.
[2:05:09] And we do have some counts that I can put together for you all.
[2:05:13] One thing to keep in mind is it's not a continuous treatment the entire way.
[2:05:18] So on, for example, on the angle parking one side,
[2:05:22] no parking on the other side,
[2:05:23] there's only a couple of spots
[2:05:24] that we'd be looking to do that,
[2:05:25] but still we can put together some numbers
[2:05:27] that correspond to those options that I mentioned.
[2:05:30] That'd be awesome, thank you.
[2:05:31] Chris, talk.
[2:05:32] And since we just agreed to spend 40,000
[2:05:35] 10 out of our own pocket for public transportation,
[2:05:39] how do we incorporate the potential
[2:05:42] for a bus stop location somewhere in the downtown area?
[2:05:46] Yes, we actually had some conversations about that earlier in our process that, you know,
[2:05:53] that routing of buses might be ideally suited for the second avenues, and that you could
[2:05:59] do either near-side or far-side stops where you have in-line or bus pull-out stops on
[2:06:07] the far side of the intersections on second avenues.
[2:06:09] So that would be really convenient, people get off Second Avenue, walk a block, or I guess
[2:06:17] it's more like a block between Second Avenue and Maine, you know?
[2:06:20] But definitely not on Main Street as well as that.
[2:06:24] Well, we could have them on Maine, but again, it's just how can we fit everything in our
[2:06:28] 90 feet of space.
[2:06:31] So there are buses that use Maine today, for example, there's a facility down at the other
[2:06:37] in between Hanson and Idaho that have some people with disabilities that come there for
[2:06:44] customers and I know there's some different buses and shuttles that stop there and drop
[2:06:50] people off today.
[2:06:51] But I think as far as designing a stop that would be really efficient and the second avenues
[2:06:56] would work well especially for bus routing.
[2:07:00] I'm sorry, I got to think about that one, I don't have to think about what my question was, oh, I know it was.
[2:07:07] I just wanted to report as the liaison to the Urban and Hill Board,
[2:07:12] that the Urban and Hill Board knows this is our decision, but they know that we always take their opinion
[2:07:20] when we discuss things, and they have, as far as I can still tell, are still unanimously in favor of back in
[2:07:27] back-in-angle parking as a board, but they certainly want to look at the
[2:07:33] the demo and the information that's gathered and that kind of thing, but I
[2:07:37] report that as they're collective opinion.
[2:07:43] How many folks are here that wanted to talk about this? It's really not a public
[2:07:48] hearing, but I would be remiss in not allowing you to come forward. I would
[2:07:54] just ask we have two or three more agenda items so please be brief and in your
[2:07:59] [Muted for privacy: home address]
[2:08:04] [Muted for privacy: home address]
[2:08:12] [Muted for privacy: home address]
[2:08:17] [Muted for privacy: home address]
[2:08:20] recruiting and bringing additional business down there a lot of people invested
[2:08:24] their money down there, at about 30 plus businesses, some have come and gone, but definitely a
[2:08:29] lot of interest.
[2:08:31] And I want to make sure that as we go with whatever plan that we choose, that we keep
[2:08:35] that in mind in how the structuring and the planning of that goes so that we don't close
[2:08:40] down businesses over extended periods of time and have a downturn in what we've got going,
[2:08:46] which is a great thing.
[2:08:48] The others I think we always have to look toward the future of what we want this to
[2:08:52] look like.
[2:08:53] Right now, Chris and I might be looking at, we don't want to back up because our next
[2:08:57] don't turn that way.
[2:08:58] But on the other hand, we have to look at what the downtown wants to be in 10, 20 years from
[2:09:05] now.
[2:09:06] Those are my kids, those aren't me, and I have to understand what they want.
[2:09:09] And in speaking with some of the younger group, back in parking isn't a big issue to them,
[2:09:14] but they're more concerned with sidewalk width and bike lanes and pedestrian friendly things
[2:09:20] than they are worried about what the parking situation really is.
[2:09:24] The other thing is I'd like to keep in mind is this goes forward
[2:09:28] as these streets are narrow.
[2:09:30] We're talking about maybe not having buses there.
[2:09:32] I would like for the city to take a lot of look
[2:09:35] at the trucks that use Main Avenue, also the trucks that stop
[2:09:39] on second are on show shown, excuse me, between second Avenue
[2:09:43] and Main Avenue for delivery purposes.
[2:09:45] I just see that as being a real problem coming up
[2:09:47] and that those things should be addressed in some type of code enforcement or something
[2:09:52] like that as we go forward with that.
[2:09:55] And keep in mind, again, we're not making any decisions tonight, we're just taking some
[2:09:59] input.
[2:10:02] Come on up.
[2:10:07] My name's Kinsey Ringenberg and I own the Brass Monkey.
[2:10:10] I know I kind of speak on behalf of, we call ourselves the North Block District, we're the
[2:10:15] new block in town that's really gotten a lot of momentum going downtown and I know a lot
[2:10:20] of us are opposed to back-end parking because we feel like it's just another hurdle to get
[2:10:24] people to come downtown because people already complain about the parking as it is and just
[2:10:29] now asking them to do one more thing that they're not comfortable with or used to can deter people
[2:10:34] from coming in.
[2:10:36] I think to focus more on making the sidewalks better and making it slowing the traffic down
[2:10:43] would help with a lot of the parking accidents backing out.
[2:10:47] I think we've talked a lot about the back-in parking
[2:10:50] and that they don't cross over the line
[2:10:52] when they're pulling out,
[2:10:52] but we don't talk about them crossing over the line
[2:10:55] when they're backing in.
[2:10:56] I think you're still gonna have the same problem.
[2:10:58] I think we really need to focus on getting
[2:11:00] wayward signing to show people that there is
[2:11:02] a lot of parking downtown because just
[2:11:04] because you can't pull right up to the building
[2:11:07] doesn't mean that there isn't parking.
[2:11:08] People just have to get adjusted and used to
[2:11:11] walking around the block using the big parking lots
[2:11:14] behind all the buildings and just making those extra steps
[2:11:18] because it really isn't that much more
[2:11:19] than if you park at the mall.
[2:11:21] But people aren't just used to that
[2:11:22] because it's not visually right in front of them.
[2:11:26] And then I also want to counter what she said about having
[2:11:32] all of downtown the same.
[2:11:33] I think downtown is a good unit, but I would prefer,
[2:11:37] and I know our block is talked about,
[2:11:39] we need to look at downtown block by block
[2:11:41] because to Sean's point, every block is different.
[2:11:44] and has different needs.
[2:11:46] And I feel that, you know, we all can be different,
[2:11:50] but unified at the same time.
[2:11:52] So it doesn't, just because our block has certain types
[2:11:56] of parking, I don't think the other block has to have
[2:11:58] the same kind of parking.
[2:11:59] So that's it.
[2:12:00] Thank you.
[2:12:01] Thank you.
[2:12:03] Anyone else?
[2:12:07] Welcome back.
[2:12:10] Mayor, council members, again, my name is Steve Woods.
[2:12:13] I live in the area of impact on the east side of town.
[2:12:16] I'm a retired engineer, I've been trained through my whole career to say, what can go wrong.
[2:12:23] And when I first heard of this plan, I thought, okay, so a couple pulls around off Shoshone
[2:12:32] and vision this.
[2:12:33] They pull off Shoshone Street, they pull onto Main Street, and they're 80s and they say,
[2:12:38] I think I'm on a half a lunch at Sandwich Company.
[2:12:41] And they're driving down the street slowly and they say, oh, there's a parking place, all
[2:12:45] back in.
[2:12:46] And all of a sudden there's a suburban right on their tailgate because the Suburban didn't
[2:12:51] know they were going to park there.
[2:12:53] They didn't know they were going to park there, right behind the Suburban is a little Volkswagen
[2:12:57] beetle.
[2:12:58] And all of a sudden you're right at the corner with all this traffic being stacked up because
[2:13:03] the people want to back into that parking place but there's no room because there's somebody
[2:13:08] right on your bumper.
[2:13:10] And I can see congestion really increasing because of that.
[2:13:18] The concept was thrown out that perhaps it's easier, it doesn't make any difference whether
[2:13:23] you back in or back out.
[2:13:26] But I would say that it's one of the concepts is once you have pulled in straight between
[2:13:32] two cars, it's easier to back out than to try to back in between two parked cars, especially
[2:13:38] for older people.
[2:13:39] So there is a difference between backing in and backing out.
[2:13:45] The other two more items real quick on this demonstration, I would suggest that you don't
[2:13:53] just watch people try to back in, but have somebody pull up right behind them and find
[2:13:58] out what's going to happen when they try to back up with somebody right on their bumper
[2:14:02] and somebody on the bumper behind them as well.
[2:14:05] And lastly, this issue of the street not being wide enough
[2:14:10] for fire trucks if you go one lane.
[2:14:14] In the back of my mind, when we talked about morning sun,
[2:14:17] the new morning sun subdivision,
[2:14:19] and we had a discussion in planning and zoning
[2:14:22] about the width of the street
[2:14:24] and what some of the requirements were.
[2:14:26] And it was presented to us that I think the streets
[2:14:30] were gonna be 26 feet wide with parking on one side
[2:14:34] so that emergency vehicles could buy.
[2:14:38] Maybe you remember those.
[2:14:40] That was consistent.
[2:14:41] Yeah, but we ended up banning all parking.
[2:14:44] When it got to us, we banned all parking.
[2:14:46] I wasn't aware.
[2:14:47] It was presented.
[2:14:48] It was presented to us at finding and zoning
[2:14:50] the 26 feet with parking on one side
[2:14:53] was just fine with the fire department.
[2:14:55] So I guess I was a little bit concerned
[2:14:58] about the discrepancy between 26 feet on main not being enough
[2:15:03] in 26 feet with parking and morning sun being.
[2:15:07] Just things to think about.
[2:15:09] Thank you.
[2:15:10] Anyone else?
[2:15:19] Welcome.
[2:15:21] Ken Fitzgerald, I'm down here at 124,
[2:15:25] main avenue north, the old Paris building there.
[2:15:28] Maybe I should have gotten here when you were talking more
[2:15:30] about the budgeting, because I think some of what I want
[2:15:33] to say might have to do with some of the budgeting.
[2:15:38] The idea between back-end parking or polling parking,
[2:15:40] I think there's merits both ways.
[2:15:42] I know I understand the safety issues and some of the things that you gain with back in parking.
[2:15:48] I think the bigger issue is parking in general and I think we keep scurrying that over time.
[2:15:55] And I've spoke about this for probably the last five, six years as I was developing my property down there,
[2:16:03] that by the time I was done doing what I wanted to accomplish, that we were going to have a parking problem.
[2:16:08] If by going with parallel parking in some cases,
[2:16:12] diminishes the number of parking spaces we have,
[2:16:15] if we didn't have a parking problem to begin with,
[2:16:17] that wouldn't be an issue.
[2:16:19] And in our block, where most of the restaurants are now,
[2:16:24] and now the Orpheum Theatre is back operating,
[2:16:26] and soon to be three, four hundred people attending that facility,
[2:16:31] we have the smallest lot in the entire downtown area.
[2:16:35] but yet we have probably 95% of the foot traffic downtown.
[2:16:40] So budget wise, I know we have always talked about
[2:16:45] possible parking structures,
[2:16:46] and I understand that the cost is too great,
[2:16:52] but there could be some other solutions.
[2:16:53] I've brought this up to Melinda and even Mandy
[2:16:56] on a couple of occasions that if there were properties
[2:16:59] that the city or urban renewal can acquire and force,
[2:17:04] and that's another issue, but tenants and property owners
[2:17:11] and employees to park off-site,
[2:17:13] then if we give up five, six, a dozen parking spaces
[2:17:17] out front to give us what we really want
[2:17:20] on the sidewalk space, it's not an issue.
[2:17:23] We have no customer parking behind our buildings, zero.
[2:17:26] It's all tenants and employees.
[2:17:30] The lot is that small.
[2:17:32] So for us to lose parking right now is crucial,
[2:17:35] But not if we had another option, that we were forced apart a block away or somewhere
[2:17:39] over here, and some of these laws were designated customer owned.
[2:17:47] Going along with that, I'm sure you all heard about the KMBT survey that went on and the
[2:17:55] negativity that happened on all those.
[2:17:57] And now just recently today, I think the Times News did the same thing, and if not all,
[2:18:02] at least 98% of them were all, no, that's crazy who thought of that, you know, they need
[2:18:06] to be examined. Just like the parking, there were surveys done and all kinds of things done
[2:18:13] four or five years ago about parking and the college did some analyzing and there was not
[2:18:18] a parking issue but it's a perception. The entire city thinks there's a parking problem
[2:18:23] down here. So if the entire city based on some of these poles and surveys says that's
[2:18:29] a terrible idea. I'm never going down there. I don't want my truck getting bashed up by
[2:18:32] by somebody that doesn't know how to back up.
[2:18:34] It's an accident waiting to happen.
[2:18:36] That's one more in Kinsey, Condolewoo,
[2:18:38] that's one more reason for people not to come downtown.
[2:18:42] And collectively, at least on just on our block alone
[2:18:45] in the last few years, there's been several million dollars
[2:18:47] invested in this, which is what the city asked five,
[2:18:51] six years ago, the private sector, to come in
[2:18:54] and get this downtown to a thriving state.
[2:18:57] We're doing it, but it's still a struggle.
[2:19:00] people still don't even know that these restaurants exist.
[2:19:03] They still don't know that there's anything going on downtown,
[2:19:06] and they're saying, oh, forget it.
[2:19:07] If I have the back-end park, I'm not going.
[2:19:09] So as you're making these decisions,
[2:19:11] you got to think about not just is it safer, or less safe,
[2:19:16] or sidewalk space.
[2:19:17] It's also, what does the public think about coming down here?
[2:19:21] And everything we've been trying to accomplish
[2:19:23] for the last three, four years is for not,
[2:19:26] because we're already going to go through a transition,
[2:19:28] tearing up alleys, tearing up Main Street.
[2:19:30] Businesses are gonna really take it hard.
[2:19:34] And then on top of that, if everybody says,
[2:19:36] you know, this back in parking's a waste,
[2:19:39] I don't wanna go down there anymore,
[2:19:41] then we're spending a lot of money for nothing.
[2:19:44] So just keep those things in mind, it's all I ask.
[2:19:46] Thank you, Ken.
[2:19:48] Anyone else?
[2:19:52] You don't have to.
[2:19:53] Yeah.
[2:19:54] Yeah.
[2:19:56] That's right.
[2:19:56] That's right.
[2:19:57] Tim Stasney, I own Slice and Events at Slice, I basically just quickly will say the same
[2:20:05] things everyone else has said.
[2:20:09] I think if there's a way that we can implement something in a trial space, I don't think that's
[2:20:14] a problem.
[2:20:15] If you want to try back and parking on one of the lesser busy blocks down here where the
[2:20:20] D11s bank where they seem to be in favor of it, I think we need to exhaust all efforts
[2:20:27] before we go and ask a public that is adamantly opposed.
[2:20:31] I had four people in my restaurant five minutes before I walked over here.
[2:20:34] That all they were talking about was the K&BT piece today.
[2:20:37] And they just said, we won't come down here.
[2:20:40] And they were, you know, they were in their late 50s, 60s, couple of them there
[2:20:44] just like, we're not going to come down here.
[2:20:46] You know, we love the atmosphere, but we will not come.
[2:20:49] That was today.
[2:20:50] I mean, as someone that's put, you know, a lot of money into their business
[2:20:55] and has a great love for this downtown. I've been working on that block for five years,
[2:20:59] me and Kenny. Five years ago, you couldn't have laid that street and got ran over at noon.
[2:21:04] Now you can't, you know, there's people driving around the block 20 times to find a space out front.
[2:21:09] You ask them to do one more thing down here and they are not going to come. They're resounding
[2:21:15] in their voicing. They will not come. So I think I would just plead with you to at least be open
[2:21:23] to trying it somewhere first. I don't think, you know, three or four days parking in one spot
[2:21:28] is gonna do it. I mean, you gotta have, here I need to do an example where you've got two cars
[2:21:33] back in and you got someone trying to back in, you know, or like the other gentleman said with cars
[2:21:38] behind them. At least be open to the possibility of limiting that to a space. If it works, it's fine,
[2:21:44] it's great. I certainly don't want a F-350 diesel truck parked in front of my restaurant when someone's
[2:21:50] eating stomping on their desk like we all see them do on a daily basis and
[2:21:54] wiping people out with their exhaust. So that's a concern and that's all we
[2:21:59] would ask. That's not making any harder for people to remember that we have a great
[2:22:03] downtown. Thank you. Thank you. Is there anyone else? All right well we've heard
[2:22:09] and we're going to continue looking into this subject. Did you want to
[2:22:14] anything further from either one of you? Again not requesting that you have to.
[2:22:19] No, I think I did just want to clarify because I neglected to mention earlier how the proper
[2:22:24] etiquette for back-and-angle parking works.
[2:22:28] It's very similar to parallel parking in that when you're in traffic, you put on your
[2:22:34] right hand blinker that signals to the car behind you that you're planning to park.
[2:22:40] And so you want to do that as you approach the parking stall.
[2:22:44] But ideally, if that car is patient in polite, that driver is patient in polite, they would
[2:22:49] give you the space then to back into that space.
[2:22:53] So when we do the demonstration, I believe the city intends to have some kind of one,
[2:22:57] two, three steps out, some signs and some handouts to really let people know, okay, here's
[2:23:03] how it works.
[2:23:04] So it's similar to parallel parking in how the flow of traffic works.
[2:23:07] Thank you, Mandy.
[2:23:09] Great landing.
[2:23:10] Well, I wanted to talk about a couple of things that not the backhand parking, but other things that were brought up about this.
[2:23:17] I think the urban and rural is very in fit much in favor of increased signage on the back parking lots to let people know that's free parking.
[2:23:26] I mean, I think that's always been a problem. I don't think people know that those parking lots are free. They think they might be owned by the business or whatever.
[2:23:34] And then also the urban adults, I'm not sure they figured out exactly how they're going to do this yet, but they're really interested in
[2:23:42] helping businesses or encouraging businesses to dress up their rear entrances so those parking lots in the rear do get used more often
[2:23:50] and to a better usage because let's be honest, if this putting down time gets as busy as we want there, we'll never ever, no matter what type of
[2:23:59] parking would have been a parking in front. The parking is going to have to utilize those
[2:24:04] rear parking lots to better advantage to make sure that to have anywhere in there enough room.
[2:24:12] And I've actually taken on myself. I don't park on Mainstream anymore. I park behind in that lot
[2:24:18] that's behind Rudy's and that one because it seems like I can always find a parking spot back
[2:24:21] there and it's easy access to the very restaurants you're talking about. I go to Slice, I go to the
[2:24:26] So the sandwich company I go to Hotel GR, I go,
[2:24:29] that's in a place I eat anymore is downtown, it seems like.
[2:24:32] So.
[2:24:33] Thank you Greg.
[2:24:34] Well, I think it's time for us to move on to the next agenda on it.
[2:24:38] We appreciate all the input.
[2:24:41] Next item on the agenda is consideration of a request to reconstruct the Will's booster
[2:24:46] station and we have our city engineer, Jackie Fields.
[2:24:50] Welcome, Jackie.
[2:24:51] Sorry about that.
[2:24:58] I should start moving a little bit earlier.
[2:25:00] I didn't give you much notice.
[2:25:02] Okay, so that is our current Will's booster station, and it is located down at the in the
[2:25:32] south tank yard.
[2:25:33] It was originally constructed to provide a limited service area with some additional
[2:25:42] pressure, styling, drive subdivision, and it grew and grew as town grew.
[2:25:50] We constantly worked within the space confines and the budget to try to make that station
[2:25:59] the most that it could be. And that included finding old pumps and utilizing them. It included
[2:26:08] our current state of air conditioning, which are a recent state of air conditioning, which
[2:26:15] you can see by the open windows, which is not quite adequate ventilation for the controls.
[2:26:23] And that station is like fully occupied.
[2:26:27] We have, we can't squeeze another pump in.
[2:26:30] We can't even talk about sharing a pump well or anything like that.
[2:26:36] So, and everything in there has exceeded its natural lifespan.
[2:26:42] Now, we've known this for a while and we've been trying to figure
[2:26:45] out how we can fund a project to replace this in a meaningful way.
[2:26:52] And how we can do that so that future development can contribute
[2:27:00] to their portion of the upgrades.
[2:27:07] So last year, we started to have a formal conversation
[2:27:15] about the need to do something with Will's Brewster Station.
[2:27:17] And we had an estimate.
[2:27:19] And we were concerned that perhaps that number was not
[2:27:25] the minimum project cost analysis.
[2:27:28] So we withdrew that request from the budget cycle
[2:27:33] and issued a contract to investigate,
[2:27:37] to do some preliminary design, conceptual design,
[2:27:40] and see, make sure that we had a minimum project for wells
[2:27:43] so that we could maintain our existing equipment
[2:27:46] and also do so in a manner that makes provision
[2:27:50] for others to add to it at a later date.
[2:27:54] It's a similar kind of concept that we use with developers.
[2:27:56] We don't let them stick in the smallest pipe size possible.
[2:28:00] We ask them to make provision for the future.
[2:28:04] As it turns out, we did have something very close
[2:28:09] to a minimum project.
[2:28:11] And so we presented that to the long-term planning group.
[2:28:16] And they were able to understand that we have a really old
[2:28:19] station and that there is a problem.
[2:28:24] there is an impossibility of adding to it.
[2:28:28] So in its current configuration.
[2:28:31] And so they supported the concept of bringing the station
[2:28:36] forward into formal budget conversations.
[2:28:41] What we would like to do, OK, so the estimate for the job,
[2:28:44] for the minimum project job, is $4 million.
[2:28:49] And we would like to actually start design on that.
[2:28:53] So we would like to, we're seeking permission tonight,
[2:28:55] tonight, to have Will's Brewster Station be a project
[2:29:01] so that we could budget for it in the next fiscal year,
[2:29:04] but also so that we could begin design now.
[2:29:06] Because the delivery time on really large pumps is long.
[2:29:13] It's really long.
[2:29:15] And the ability for us to take care of that equipment
[2:29:21] is continually diminishing.
[2:29:24] So our risk goes up a little bit, all the time.
[2:29:30] And we also recognize that this is an area of town,
[2:29:34] that the community is interested in developing.
[2:29:37] Development community is interested in doing work there.
[2:29:40] So if we are able to take care of our own equipment,
[2:29:44] and also allow someone else to tie on pumps and controls,
[2:29:48] then that area of town is in a better position to actually grow and make the fireflows that
[2:29:55] we need to see out there, particularly since we're now placing a large middle school in
[2:30:01] the neighborhood.
[2:30:03] So at this point in time, according to finance, we have about $6.2 million in unrestricted
[2:30:10] cash reserves in the water fund.
[2:30:13] And we think that the use of the reserves is appropriate because this is the station was
[2:30:23] built once when Brad was a lad.
[2:30:28] And probably won't be built again for at least that long in the future.
[2:30:33] So it's a one-time cost, it's a huge maintenance project.
[2:30:38] And using reserves allows us to, we've been able to save the money over time, so we haven't
[2:30:46] had to have a large increase in rates to deal with a single project.
[2:30:56] So tonight I'm requesting that the Council approve adding Will's booster station, the design
[2:31:06] of the Will's booster station to the current budget.
[2:31:10] that scope looks like it's about $600,000, so that would be the immediate near term impact
[2:31:17] and then the remainder is construction, which we won't be able to do this exact year.
[2:31:24] So are you saying that the station was named after Brad?
[2:31:27] Is that what you were saying?
[2:31:29] You know, it might have been Urz, Daddy, or his granddaddy, so I don't know who exactly built
[2:31:35] that to these guys in subdivision.
[2:31:36] Did you really?
[2:31:37] Well, that's awesome.
[2:31:40] The wheels gave the land, that's why you have come forward if you're going to make testimony.
[2:31:50] I was 13.
[2:31:55] We have some lights.
[2:32:00] Chris, talk.
[2:32:01] Jackie, since this is anticipated to use about two thirds of our water fund unrestricted
[2:32:06] reserves, I want to make sure that that four million is a high ball estimate.
[2:32:11] It seems like our construction costs are shooting through the ceiling in a lot of ways, and so
[2:32:17] So I don't know what kind of contingency you've built into that for a million.
[2:32:22] I just trust even figures, something to come in at four and a half.
[2:32:26] Can you guarantee that?
[2:32:29] No.
[2:32:30] I rarely stand before you and guarantee any number or any schedule, okay, unless we're
[2:32:35] right at the very end.
[2:32:37] So we did place, we did the huge level of effort to try to confine a minimum project and find
[2:32:45] out what we needed.
[2:32:46] And there was a substantial effort made by JUBE to estimate the job with enough reserve
[2:32:51] so that we thought we could actually hit the number, you know, because we don't have a very
[2:32:55] good, we don't have a very small tolerance for projects that blow out the budget.
[2:33:03] Recognizing that that's the way that, you know, typically JUBE has a very conservative, I guess,
[2:33:15] conservative estimate at the onset of a job, that means that they have some comfort, that
[2:33:21] they won't be exceeding the budget because they understand how significant of an impact
[2:33:26] that is on our budgets.
[2:33:28] So they do that.
[2:33:30] We're also in an environment where that is becoming very, very competitive.
[2:33:35] So the best we can do is go forward with what we think is reasonable and bid the job and
[2:33:44] And then look at it and say, okay, really, you know, this bidding environment is absurd.
[2:33:50] We can't handle this project at this point in time.
[2:33:53] Or hopefully, we're all optimistic that we can actually produce the job within the budget
[2:33:59] that we've asked for.
[2:34:01] The relevance of my question, Don, is our airport terminal remodeling project just blown out
[2:34:09] of water by the costs that have been thrown our way is causing us to change the schedule
[2:34:16] and everything.
[2:34:17] A lot of those were hard construction costs and so I have to trust Jackie that four millions
[2:34:22] going to do it.
[2:34:23] Well and we were, staff was aware that that project bid and the results were quite dramatic.
[2:34:30] Travis did you want to weigh in?
[2:34:34] Yeah I want to just reiterate what Jackie has said because I think that she laid out a pretty
[2:34:38] good path. The first step is to get a good design and bid documents that we could get to the
[2:34:43] street and then go forward to bid it. What we're asking for like Jackie shared is that
[2:34:49] very first step with the intent of locking up the balance of the $3.4 million and moving
[2:34:57] forward assuming that the bids come in appropriately. If the bids do not come in as we're anticipating
[2:35:04] then we'll need to go back to the drawing board.
[2:35:07] There may be some parts of that project
[2:35:09] that we will be able to scale back,
[2:35:11] but as Jackie illustrated,
[2:35:12] there may be some really good value
[2:35:15] in maybe scaling back a portion of that project
[2:35:18] and still continuing to go forward with the funding
[2:35:20] that we have.
[2:35:21] Unfortunately, we don't know what that looks like,
[2:35:24] honestly, until we bid the job,
[2:35:26] and it's really going to depend upon the number
[2:35:29] of people who bid on that day,
[2:35:31] and what the bids look like.
[2:35:35] What kind of time frame are you looking at Jackie start to finish?
[2:35:40] Usually I know this and I can't remember the answer. So I believe we're trying to get the booster station up and running in 2016.
[2:35:55] So I'm off by a month.
[2:36:04] I'd say that's pretty good. Okay. Thank you.
[2:36:07] Do we have any further questions?
[2:36:11] Any direction, Council, Chris, talk?
[2:36:13] I would move to authorize the Wells-Buster Station project
[2:36:19] to be funded out of unrestricted cash reserves
[2:36:22] from the Water Fund in an approximate amount of $4 million.
[2:36:26] To be added to the current budget, that's what I'm saying.
[2:36:30] Second.
[2:36:31] Second on that?
[2:36:31] Anything further on that motion council?
[2:36:35] I'm just going to say we've got to do something.
[2:36:39] That area is ready to explode for development and we need to be prepared for that.
[2:36:46] As I stated earlier about workforce housing and the other dynamics that we truly need to
[2:36:51] look at for the future of this community.
[2:36:54] We need to open that area.
[2:36:56] So I think it's a good project.
[2:36:58] I hope that you're right about your budget.
[2:37:00] So do I.
[2:37:01] So do I.
[2:37:02] Sherry?
[2:37:03] Sherry?
[2:37:04] Sherry?
[2:37:05] Will Sherry call vote please?
[2:37:08] Greg Lanting?
[2:37:09] Yes.
[2:37:10] Yes, Suzanne Hawkins. Yes, Sean Baraker. Yes, Chris talking. Yes, motion passes five to zero. Thank you, Jack.
[2:37:21] Next item on the agenda is consideration for bread. Let's say some ball stop Brad. Did you want to say something?
[2:37:28] No, we're not going to call it Brad Wills
[2:37:32] We've shared tonight tonight because we this is very important is some we appreciate you supporting this because it's it is real crucial for the South part
[2:37:41] Thank you. Thank you, Brad. Thank you, Gerald.
[2:37:44] Next item on the agenda. Consideration requests to approve a contract with Logan Simpson Design Inc. to develop a comprehensive plan update. Mitch Humble.
[2:37:53] Thanks. You'll recall earlier this year, we went through a selection process to pick a land he's planning consultant telling us to walk through our planning master preference plan update.
[2:38:08] Renee's done a lot of work on this and she was kind of sick today and she couldn't be here.
[2:38:14] So, you know, I'm going to go out this alone without her input.
[2:38:20] Budgeting rate, we landed at Logan Simpson, which is a firm out of Colorado and we've worked
[2:38:26] through the last little bit to develop a scope and a contract with them.
[2:38:31] It proved to be a bit more challenging than maybe we thought going into it with the budget
[2:38:38] that we had $400,000, which was $50,000 less than what we spent
[2:38:43] the last go around six years ago, ended up being a bit of a
[2:38:49] challenge to get the scope and the cost to a point where we could
[2:38:52] do that. But we think we did it, eventually, in the end. So we
[2:38:55] got a scope that gets us through a comp plan update process,
[2:38:58] $400,000. Now, having said that, there are a few tasks that
[2:39:05] where we cut basically out of that scope in order to get it $200,000 that we thought we'd
[2:39:14] come and talk to you about potentially adding back in.
[2:39:17] And if you go to its attachment D at the bottom of the page is 13 and 13, there's four optional
[2:39:27] tasks that are listed.
[2:39:28] And then the very next page is a fifth optional task that's listed.
[2:39:32] total for those five optional tasks ends up being about $55,000 over and above the
[2:39:37] hundred thousand that we have in the budget. We thought we'd come and talk to you about
[2:39:41] these tasks and discuss whether they would be appropriate to add or we'd go
[2:39:47] ahead and leave them off. And so we had the scope and we asked Logan's
[2:39:53] and kind of prepare it this way so that we could kind of pick and choose. Now
[2:39:57] we said that we do have some money in our reserve, in our contingency fund this
[2:40:01] year that could cover if we chose all five optional tasks.
[2:40:06] I'm not sure that we necessarily need to choose all five, but there was a few in there
[2:40:10] that I did want to talk a little bit about.
[2:40:15] The first one on the list is the current plan audit.
[2:40:17] It's a very early step.
[2:40:19] It's look at what we have on the ground today with our various plans.
[2:40:22] I'm not absolutely sure that that's super critical.
[2:40:26] I think these guys can get going without really doing that.
[2:40:31] But that's the reason we decided to move it to the optional list.
[2:40:37] It's just looking at the various plans that we have,
[2:40:39] not just the comprehensive plan, but water systems facility
[2:40:43] plan and sewer facility plans and transportation plans
[2:40:46] and all these kind of things and bringing together
[2:40:48] to see how this kind of works.
[2:40:50] And what we'll have through the process
[2:40:52] by staff input on this plan is we create it,
[2:40:55] and perhaps we don't necessarily need these guys
[2:40:57] to have that in-depth knowledge of these other plans
[2:41:00] and maybe we can forego that.
[2:41:02] But maybe not.
[2:41:03] It might be really nice for them to do that
[2:41:05] and have that knowledge in-house.
[2:41:07] So that's why it's on the task list as an optional.
[2:41:11] The second one is kind of like a kickoff meeting.
[2:41:14] So there's lots of opportunities for them
[2:41:16] to come back through the process to get public input
[2:41:19] and share information with our steering committee
[2:41:24] with their playing zone in commission,
[2:41:27] and also meet out with the public.
[2:41:29] And this would be one additional time
[2:41:31] at the very front end of the process to kind of,
[2:41:34] I think what they had proposed was to go out
[2:41:36] with some community event kind of like Western days
[2:41:40] and set up a booth and just very early on,
[2:41:43] get some very generic kind of input.
[2:41:48] That one I think probably is, again,
[2:41:51] something that we could probably live without if we had to,
[2:41:54] that this is one that Renee feels pretty strongly,
[2:41:56] that maybe we should try and find some money
[2:41:58] at a contingency fund to maybe pay for this $9,500
[2:42:01] to put back in.
[2:42:04] More public input seems to be better than last, I guess,
[2:42:07] would be the argument there.
[2:42:09] The next two I want to talk about together,
[2:42:12] because I kind of think that they potentially
[2:42:16] come or go together.
[2:42:20] The creation of a digital plan, this
[2:42:21] be like a interactive kind of a plan that we would post online, somebody could go through
[2:42:27] all the various sections rather than just kind of static PDF document where we're at
[2:42:31] at the time.
[2:42:32] And this would be something that we don't really have right now in the digital plan.
[2:42:39] That would be kind of cool and kind of interesting to have our website, we don't believe we
[2:42:47] We have the technical expertise to actually make that happen without number four happening
[2:42:53] as well.
[2:42:54] So I don't think we should create that digital plan if we aren't going to go ahead and do
[2:42:58] number four as well.
[2:42:59] We could do number four without number three because number four is just a project website
[2:43:05] throughout the process rather than using the city website much like what OTAC is doing
[2:43:10] with the downtown plan.
[2:43:11] They have their own standalone website that OTAC is updating and operating and maintaining
[2:43:18] and hosting.
[2:43:19] The Logan Simpson will be a force as well.
[2:43:23] And then in that capacity, they can also put this digital plan up on there and host that
[2:43:29] that we won't be able to have the ability to have was to either.
[2:43:32] In the absence of four, we're probably posting more static type notices and draft copies of
[2:43:41] of plans and PDF format and that kind of stuff that's a little less user friendly.
[2:43:45] Again, probably we can do without it, but it would be nice to have it in there.
[2:43:52] So, those are those four options.
[2:43:53] I'll turn the page to the next one.
[2:43:55] This is the one that I feel the strongest about.
[2:43:59] We have a lot of things that are upcoming that we really need some answers on with
[2:44:03] regards to our fire stations.
[2:44:06] We have impact fees that we're collecting for fire stations yet.
[2:44:09] We don't know exactly if we got stations in the right places.
[2:44:13] We need to move these locations somewhere else.
[2:44:16] We want to go with a ladder company instead of a fourth station.
[2:44:19] There's all kinds of questions that we're struggling with
[2:44:22] as we look forward into our fire station planning,
[2:44:27] that this piece will help us address.
[2:44:29] So this would be Logan Simpson bringing on a sub-consultant
[2:44:32] emergency services consultant international
[2:44:35] who specializes in fire station planning.
[2:44:39] you know, response timing and stuff like that and making that part of this
[2:44:43] comp plan. So after we get to a certain point with updated growth information
[2:44:47] where development is likely to happen, we can run this, these guys into the
[2:44:51] process and they would help us figure out maybe what ideal plans, what our
[2:44:57] current plans look like in the growth scenario, get us to the point where we
[2:45:01] can actually start making some better long-term planning type decisions for
[2:45:06] the fire station that helped with our ISO that helped the fire district and those sites
[2:45:14] that they have already acquired.
[2:45:16] So, anyway, this to me is a big one.
[2:45:19] We kind of need to understand the future needs of our fire station and how best to meet those
[2:45:23] needs.
[2:45:24] If I could ask a question, Susan, I know your lights on, but specific to that, will it address
[2:45:31] the issue regarding having female firefighters and what our firehouses will need to look
[2:45:36] like in the near future.
[2:45:38] I don't know that this so much is, this is more of a location.
[2:45:42] Okay.
[2:45:43] Which is a response time sort of a thing.
[2:45:46] But I could ask them that question more specifically.
[2:45:49] I haven't actually talked to these emergency services folkship.
[2:45:54] My take on it isn't that, it's more in the response time types of questions.
[2:46:01] Okay.
[2:46:02] I didn't know if it would tell us that as well, Travis did you want to?
[2:46:05] That specific question is actually one that we're going to be addressing with humble architects
[2:46:09] when we're looking at our architectural review of the entire public safety complex which will
[2:46:15] extend to having a broad approach to adding female firefighters into other substations
[2:46:22] as well.
[2:46:23] Thank you.
[2:46:24] Please explain.
[2:46:25] Well, they definitely fire stations can be pulled off.
[2:46:29] Other piece of this I want to talk about was this.
[2:46:31] Could I have two lights on?
[2:46:32] I just want to make sure I don't ignore them.
[2:46:34] I know you probably can't answer this but maybe somebody can. Do we have any idea
[2:46:40] how many hits Otak's website has gotten on the redesign because it doesn't seem
[2:46:45] like there's been a lot of interaction with that. So Jamie's a sub with Otak on
[2:46:55] that and so that's why I look to Gary. Well with that price that just I don't
[2:46:59] know that we would get right sorry I'm trying to speak it but it's just not
[2:47:06] coming tonight. Thank you. And if I could allow Chris. Chris talking. Yeah, no, we approve the
[2:47:14] budget though with the amendments. I'm low of confused with that. I'll point to add 30 or 55,000.
[2:47:22] So it depends on which of those five options we choose to move forward with. So let me say you
[2:47:27] how the contract is written to. It's written for a contract of $100,000 scope and cost. And then
[2:47:34] If we need to, later we can add options 1, 2, 3, 4, 5 for the specified costs, but we
[2:47:41] don't have to.
[2:47:43] I guess what I was hoping for would be some council direction and yeah, maybe we should
[2:47:47] ask for two and five or something like that.
[2:47:50] And then we have a better field going into it what we might need and then we can actually
[2:47:54] calculate the cost.
[2:47:55] If all five are chosen, it would be $155,000 contract.
[2:47:59] If none of the five are chosen, it's $100,000 contract and our budget is $100,000.
[2:48:04] Are you asking us to make a decision tonight on those options?
[2:48:07] So what I'm going to say is that we have some contingency money
[2:48:10] to cover all 55.
[2:48:12] Should that be the priority for the Council's contingency,
[2:48:16] which is right?
[2:48:16] So we have other things that may come up
[2:48:18] through their manner of the year that might need to draw
[2:48:20] on those money in the contingency fund.
[2:48:23] The other thing I was going to tell you
[2:48:24] is that this $25,000 specifically for the fire strategic
[2:48:28] analysis is that we have a partner in the fire district
[2:48:34] that may or may not be willing to partner
[2:48:37] on the cost of that as well.
[2:48:38] And I have a meeting set up with them on Wednesday,
[2:48:41] the chief and I are going to talk to them about
[2:48:43] the scenario that we have approved at night.
[2:48:45] That would be a maximum cost of 155.
[2:48:48] And I would also hope for some direction,
[2:48:51] like Suzanne was saying, I'm having struggle,
[2:48:54] struggle finding the value in a $15,000 addition, right?
[2:48:59] So if the council says, don't do three and four,
[2:49:04] Then if we don't do four, I wouldn't do three
[2:49:06] because we can't do anything with three on our own.
[2:49:09] So if we don't do three and four,
[2:49:11] then that tells me one thing,
[2:49:11] that tells me $18,000 is off the table.
[2:49:17] If one is also off the table, now I met $20,500.
[2:49:21] But maybe we move forward with the contract
[2:49:23] plus options two and five,
[2:49:25] which I think would be a good way to do that.
[2:49:29] I think I can find some help funding the $25,000,
[2:49:32] which makes us spending something like 10 to 35 over the $100,000 budget.
[2:49:40] Showing our level of funding the fire district is willing to share if they're willing to share.
[2:49:49] So looking at the options, so option one to me seems to be something that they should be doing anyway.
[2:49:59] If they're going to do a comprehensive plan would they not want an assessment of what plans we currently have
[2:50:04] we have and how they might all intertwine themselves.
[2:50:08] So I struggle paying an extra $25 to lay the groundwork
[2:50:13] for the $100,000 plan that they're going to do anyways.
[2:50:16] So there's my two cents on that one.
[2:50:18] But I tell you how wide that's there.
[2:50:19] That's there because we asked them to put that there.
[2:50:23] We thought at the staff level we could help them do this without.
[2:50:29] We're trying to get that down to the $100,000 budget.
[2:50:31] So we were going through all the various tasks.
[2:50:33] And if we did this one, that makes their job a little cheaper.
[2:50:37] And so that's kind of how that ended up being there.
[2:50:39] But I'm all for it and then do it.
[2:50:41] I understand that.
[2:50:43] I just, that sort of seems to be a no-brainer
[2:50:46] that that's part of what you're doing.
[2:50:48] I appreciate you're trying to keep it restricted to the budget.
[2:50:51] But the second item, so I don't quite understand
[2:50:56] who the audience is for this outreach.
[2:50:58] Is it the, because reading the initials here,
[2:51:01] I'm guessing that is Planning Commission and City Council.
[2:51:05] Says joint boards PC and CC kickoff event.
[2:51:09] So if they're kicking the event off
[2:51:11] to the Planning and Zoning Commission and the City Council
[2:51:14] for $9,500, we're gonna be pretty in tune
[2:51:17] to this process anyways.
[2:51:19] That seems like a lot of money to spend.
[2:51:21] If this is huge community outreach
[2:51:25] above and beyond what they're already gonna be doing,
[2:51:28] then I might be a little more appreciative of it.
[2:51:31] But this sounds to me like a, let's cheer for ourselves in this great project we're doing
[2:51:37] and hope that the media picks up a little bit about that.
[2:51:40] So the kickoff event is not intended to be a kickoff event in front of the council.
[2:51:44] It's a public kickoff event and it would be like the mayor is going to go and talk and
[2:51:48] give a speech or whatever at this public event.
[2:51:52] There are also in that tasks little feedback reports to the P&Z and commission and they
[2:51:58] would be like an extra day to their stay so that they could show up at an evening meeting
[2:52:04] otherwise it's staff giving the feedback report to the commission or council.
[2:52:11] So let's kick off event is a public event hopefully in correlation with some other already
[2:52:16] going public event that we just take a little part of.
[2:52:19] So my two cents on that one is that's a lot of money.
[2:52:24] The digital comprehensive plan, I think, is a great tool to have, but I'm hearing from
[2:52:31] you that they can't create that for us and we can have it on our website unless we do
[2:52:37] this other $15,000 thing.
[2:52:40] That's my understanding of that.
[2:52:42] That's beyond my technical understanding.
[2:52:43] Totally, I'm just trusting people who tell me that.
[2:52:47] Because I like three.
[2:52:49] I like having a digital interactive comprehensive plan
[2:52:54] as the final product.
[2:52:56] I don't like the idea of doing a website like OTAC
[2:52:59] has done because I don't think it's worth $15,500
[2:53:02] for the community engagement it gets.
[2:53:07] So I would like to see us do three.
[2:53:11] If there's a way to do it without having
[2:53:13] to have some separate hosted website for $15,000
[2:53:17] that doesn't seem functional.
[2:53:20] And I'm all for figuring out what to do with Fire Department.
[2:53:22] So there's my three cents now.
[2:53:25] You said three then.
[2:53:26] That's when you see Faverin.
[2:53:28] Yeah, I see value to a digital version
[2:53:31] of the comprehensive plan.
[2:53:33] Because the way this is described,
[2:53:34] I mean, it's got interactive mapping.
[2:53:36] And I think there would be great functionality
[2:53:39] for the development community and people
[2:53:42] looking at moving here and all that.
[2:53:44] But if it has to be hosted on its own standalone website
[2:53:49] that we have to pay them for,
[2:53:50] I struggle with that.
[2:53:53] Travis, did you want to?
[2:53:54] You know, I think that let us explore that.
[2:53:57] Let us explore how we might be able to find other digital
[2:53:59] options that may not be directly with this company.
[2:54:03] Digitizing documents is becoming fairly common.
[2:54:07] And it might be something that we would be able to do with a
[2:54:09] different partner at the conclusion of the process.
[2:54:14] Mitch, I have a question for you.
[2:54:15] You state that our last comprehension plan costs more
[2:54:20] than 100,000. So why did we budget 100,000 for this one knowing that costs never, I don't
[2:54:28] know of any costs going down. Did we do the same thing where we started low and then we
[2:54:34] added on and that's what we finally had like what we're doing here or do you recall Travis
[2:54:40] is waving the sand so I don't know if you want to jump in. I'm kind of asking you Travis.
[2:54:49] The original plan was a full rewrite.
[2:54:52] And the full rewrite was really taking a plan that was very old in nature and really starting
[2:54:58] from the first page and rewriting every page thereafter.
[2:55:03] The reason we thought that this would be considerably less than a rewrite was that this was a simple
[2:55:08] update.
[2:55:09] Okay, makes perfect sense.
[2:55:13] And we were including some sections of it.
[2:55:15] We're not including, this does include any review
[2:55:18] of the transportation plan, which is a part of the cop plan.
[2:55:22] This does include any look at the parks master plan,
[2:55:25] which is a chapter in the cop plan.
[2:55:27] We're not looking at the impact fees,
[2:55:29] which is a chapter of the impact.
[2:55:30] So there's several chapters of the current cop plan
[2:55:33] that we weren't even touching at all.
[2:55:35] And yeah, it was generally an update.
[2:55:38] Thank you.
[2:55:39] Thank you.
[2:55:40] Anything, any further questions?
[2:55:41] I think I'm kind of leaning more towards what Sean said
[2:55:45] three and five I'm interested in if three makes sense, but
[2:55:50] the rest of them are
[2:55:52] Isn't that I was just gonna weigh in that five is the one that interests me the the other four if if the number three works
[2:55:59] For everybody else. I'm not against it, but I don't I don't see the overwhelming need for it personally great
[2:56:07] Well, yes, I'm gonna I'm gonna stand up for Renee here. I'm number two. I
[2:56:13] think we're getting two
[2:56:15] Stuck on the kickoff and not revise three lights that talks about
[2:56:23] Ongoing outreach and so does that mean we're not gonna have the full amount of public?
[2:56:29] comment and
[2:56:31] Involvement that we've grown accustomed to over the last few years
[2:56:33] But really trying to be everybody involved at every step of the way and are we backing off from that pledge or is that not necessary?
[2:56:43] not felt to be necessary in this, because it would be quite
[2:56:47] honest with you, if I get voted down on that, I'm not going to
[2:56:50] lose any sleep because people don't really understand a
[2:56:54] comprehensive plan, but maybe this would be an opportunity to
[2:56:56] help them to understand it. And so, and I don't, I'm not sure
[2:57:00] what was an update we're going to get. I worked, I worked on my
[2:57:04] first comprehensive plan in the 80s, early 80s somewhere. I was
[2:57:08] on planning the zoning at that time. And the only thing I can
[2:57:11] vividly remember from that working on a comp plan that year was that they told us
[2:57:17] that in the early 80s that blue lakes should be in a town of 70,000 people because
[2:57:22] there was that much traffic on them I'm pretty sure the traffic on blue lakes
[2:57:25] hasn't got any less so I'm wondering if they this group will come up with a
[2:57:28] number which was by the way JUB back in the 80s that did that the comp plan that
[2:57:33] time was it gonna say it should be in a city of 150 I don't know
[2:57:42] Sean, Gary.
[2:57:44] So I'm reading the scope of services.
[2:57:47] So it talks about project kickoffs and updates and all of that stuff.
[2:57:53] Is that assuming that we do this other piece?
[2:57:59] Or are those going to happen anyways and they just get enhanced if we do the add-on?
[2:58:03] So there's a kick-off meeting that's talked about in the scope that's more of a meeting with...
[2:58:07] It's not the public event kind of a thing.
[2:58:11] It's more of a meeting with staff and the consultant
[2:58:16] that is sort of starting the process.
[2:58:19] There are updates through the process.
[2:58:22] That additional item would have just been a few longer stays
[2:58:27] and some of their visits to come to the meeting meetings
[2:58:30] and provide those updates to the boards.
[2:58:33] The commission that accounts to themselves.
[2:58:36] There are some updates.
[2:58:38] This would add a few more.
[2:58:39] I wanted to say that project has three additional visits
[2:58:42] or extended visits if we were to add that optional task.
[2:58:48] So then again in the scope of work
[2:58:50] it talks about a celebratory kickoff event number one,
[2:58:55] to announce the initiation of the Complan,
[2:58:58] COTF will host a booth in association
[2:59:00] with Twin Falls Western days.
[2:59:02] So is that different than?
[2:59:06] Probably that would be staff sitting in the booth
[2:59:09] instead of the consultant coming down sitting in the booth.
[2:59:12] Okay.
[2:59:12] So it would provide general kickoff meeting materials for use to develop an online questionnaire.
[2:59:20] I mean, I agree with Greg's comment.
[2:59:24] I think we want as much public involvement as possible, but really $10,000 worth of extra meetings to engage the public.
[2:59:33] That's a lot of money.
[2:59:38] I agree with that last point too.
[2:59:42] Anything further, Council, did you get some direction?
[2:59:45] We know five.
[2:59:47] Yeah.
[2:59:48] We need a motion.
[2:59:49] We need a motion.
[2:59:50] We need a motion.
[2:59:51] We do.
[2:59:52] We have a contract that we need to ask the Council to authorize the Mayor on that sign.
[2:59:57] And the contract, like I said, it's written so that we can add these optional things later.
[3:00:04] And if it's proven to us later that one of these others that maybe we don't
[3:00:08] grab a hold up tonight is needed we could certainly amend it again correct
[3:00:13] okay very good
[3:00:15] well I'll have a couple of them because a couple those are like real upfront kind
[3:00:20] of things that we don't do and we won't do them okay yeah so what does the
[3:00:24] motion need look like this at this point just authorize the mayor's
[3:00:28] contract it would be enough and if you feel like adding some a Thor some
[3:00:34] direction in that motion to say and add number five and add number three that
[3:00:38] but be good if you don't deal with it.
[3:00:42] Suzanne Hawkins.
[3:00:43] Okay, I'll take a stab at it.
[3:00:45] I move that we approve the contract
[3:00:49] with Logan Simpson Design for the $100,000 plan
[3:00:53] to update the comprehensive plan
[3:00:55] and authorize the merit to sign it
[3:00:56] and add option five to deal with the fire stations.
[3:01:05] Thank you.
[3:01:07] Motion on the floor by Suzanne Hawkins,
[3:01:08] seconded by Greg Lanting.
[3:01:10] Greg Lanting.
[3:01:11] I'd like to amend the main motion to add item number three.
[3:01:16] Second.
[3:01:17] Motion on the floor to amend the main motion
[3:01:19] to add item number three,
[3:01:22] which is digital comprehensive plan.
[3:01:24] And made by great 19 seconded by Sean Barreter.
[3:01:29] That's $2,500, right?
[3:01:30] $2,500, correct.
[3:01:33] Second that.
[3:01:35] We already did the second, thanks Chris.
[3:01:36] Third it.
[3:01:38] I'm assuming you'll vote for it then.
[3:01:41] Very good. Anything further on? We're going to start with the amendment, Council.
[3:01:46] All right. Sharon on the amendment, please.
[3:01:49] Don Hall? Yes. Suzanne Hawkins? No.
[3:02:00] Sean Bericher? Yes. Chris Hockington? Yes. Greg Lanting? Yes.
[3:02:08] Motion passes 4-1 now to the main motion. Anything further on that Council?
[3:02:12] Sharon, roll call vote on the main motion, please.
[3:02:16] Suzanne Hawkins. Yes, Sean Bericher. Yes, Chris talking to yes, Greg Lantini. Yes, Don Hall. Yes, many main motion passes five to zero
[3:02:29] Moving on to public input and or items from city manager city council anything from the public anyone here from the public
[3:02:35] We would like to address the council at this point
[3:02:38] I see no one coming forward city manager
[3:02:41] The only thing I have for you this evening is just a reminder that we will start at 4 o'clock next week as a result of our M POG conversation.
[3:02:51] Good and hardly wait.
[3:02:53] Deputy City Manager.
[3:02:59] So just as a brief update I guess to our city hall design process we're having some programming meetings with architects and coming to town the 27th, 28th and 29th of this month.
[3:03:13] meeting with individual departments to kind of figure out their needs for the
[3:03:19] spaces that they'll be occupying. The council is going to be occupying space
[3:03:23] in that building in the form of council chambers and so I was wondering if the
[3:03:29] council would like to schedule a programming meeting with the architects.
[3:03:34] Right now that looks like the late evening of the 27th which is a Wednesday
[3:03:38] appears to be the best time perhaps the same anytime really on the Thursday might
[3:03:44] work out as well and if two of you show up then it's public meeting so if it's
[3:03:49] two it might as well be seven to you guys who want to participate I thought I'd
[3:03:53] throw that out there discussion on that council I'm good either way
[3:04:03] I'd be happy to, and I think we should have some input.
[3:04:09] Sounds like let's schedule something, publicize it, we'll go from there.
[3:04:15] Okay.
[3:04:16] Thank you.
[3:04:17] I mentioned bring that to our attention.
[3:04:19] Suzanne Hawkins.
[3:04:20] Thank you.
[3:04:21] A couple quick things.
[3:04:22] First of all, I went to make sure the Council and the public was aware that this Friday are the new director for the public library starts and on the job.
[3:04:31] My name is Tara Bartley, and if you get a chance to go out and welcome her to the community,
[3:04:35] I think that would be really great.
[3:04:37] Secondly, I wanted to remind everybody that Saturday morning at 11 is the Policeman's Memorial
[3:04:43] at City Park, so it's a great event to go out and support.
[3:04:48] And thirdly, if you get a chance and you have a Facebook account, check out the Twinfall City
[3:04:52] Youth Council's Facebook page and watch the new video they just produced to launch the start
[3:04:58] of their new program to take selfies with the police officers.
[3:05:02] It's a fantastic video.
[3:05:04] They've done a great job with it.
[3:05:05] And I think, as of today, we've had over 6,000 views of that video.
[3:05:12] Anything further from any council members?
[3:05:14] Chris, talking to you.
[3:05:15] I look to it earlier of a surprise in the bidding for Twin Falls
[3:05:21] Airport expansion.
[3:05:23] And I think Carberry and Travis and I
[3:05:27] will be presenting something next several weeks is that, yeah, it'll be an amended schedule
[3:05:37] for the construction, we'll put it that way.
[3:05:40] Thank you, Chris, anything further?
[3:05:42] All right, Travis, if you could say I need some guidance on some of the documents up here.
[3:05:48] We are adjourned.
