Oversight Archive: City Council meeting, 2016-09-19, recording 1 (started 17:00)
Machine transcript (faster-whisper base.en), not checked word for word; the Pledge of Allegiance is shown in its standard wording. The recording is the record.
Times are time into the recording. Passages with private details are muted in the audio and marked here.
The audio on the page below was re-encoded by software from the video the agency posted. Check any passage against
that audio before relying on it.
Page: https://oversightarchive.org/twin-falls-id/meetings/2016-09-19/

[0:00:00] So sometimes, I guess, inquiries may have an IA number and other times they may not.
[0:05:28] I will call to order the meeting of the Twin Falls City Council for, hold on, the day,
[0:05:34] Monday, September 19th, it is 3.30.
[0:05:37] We currently have five members of the council here.
[0:05:40] We are going to recess to head out to the airport to tour the construction projects that
[0:05:46] are underway there.
[0:05:47] And it is my understanding that Councilman Lansing will be meeting us there and perhaps
[0:05:52] Councilman Hall as well, but we will come back here by five o'clock for the continuation
[0:05:57] of our meeting.
[0:05:58] With that we will stand in recess.
[0:06:03] Sharing regular agenda now, so to start for those of you wishing to join me, please rise
[0:06:07] for the Pledge of Allegiance.
[0:06:08] Pledge of Allegiance. I pledge allegiance to the Flag of the United States of America, and to the Republic for which it stands, one Nation under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all.
[0:06:25] We do have a quorum of the city council here, all seven members are here this evening.
[0:06:35] Mr. Rothweiler, do we have any amendments to our agenda?
[0:06:38] Mr. Mayor and members, council, there are no amendments this evening.
[0:06:41] Thank you, we have no proclamations, so the next item is general public input.
[0:06:46] And I have Lee Strandahan, who has signed up to address the council.
[0:06:50] Again, we will limit the time to three minutes this evening to address the council on an issue
[0:06:56] of pertinent to the city and go from there.
[0:07:01] So Mr. Shanahan, welcome.
[0:07:02] If you please state your name and address with the record.
[0:07:05] Yeah, sure.
[0:07:06] Sure, Mr. Mayor.
[0:07:07] Hello, Mr. Mayor and hello to the City Council.
[0:07:09] My name is Lee Shanahan.
[0:07:10] I'm a resident of Twin Falls.
[0:07:13] And I was at the economic development meeting that happened last week.
[0:07:19] And I thought I would just make a couple of general notes in the public record about that.
[0:07:23] It was a, I thought a very good meeting.
[0:07:25] And I thought it was significant for a couple of reasons.
[0:07:30] I thought that the goals that were laid out, especially the recognition of the fact, and
[0:07:34] I thought Mr. Rothweil did a very good job on his presentation about this.
[0:07:39] The goals that were laid out at that meeting, for instance, bringing more young people
[0:07:45] to town and retaining the young people who are here, that kind of thing were great goals.
[0:07:51] I wanted to talk about one thing that I noticed, just to sort of put the thought in your head
[0:07:56] a little bit, there was a good deal of talk about the downtown development.
[0:08:00] And I thought that was also a good and very interesting, but I think the thing that was
[0:08:03] missing from that, and this isn't really a criticism because it wasn't there, maybe it's
[0:08:08] being discussed more, but I think one thing that's going to help the downtown is to have
[0:08:14] some anchor businesses down there. Right now, I think part of the problem with downtown
[0:08:19] is that there simply aren't businesses that are going to be magnets to attract people there.
[0:08:26] So a lot of development that's going on, for instance, with the new park going on, the sewer
[0:08:30] development that's going to be happening on Main Ave, those are all great. And even the
[0:08:34] City Hall, which again, Mr. Rothweiler did a good job of explaining the way the City
[0:08:39] Hall is going to look, that's all great, however, very few people are going to grab
[0:08:43] of the wife and kids and head down to the city hall.
[0:08:46] And I think that's the sort of thing
[0:08:47] that needs to be talked about.
[0:08:48] I spoke to a couple of people from the city about that.
[0:08:51] And it's obviously not the kind of thing
[0:08:54] that the city council can mandate,
[0:08:56] but it is the kind of thing that I think
[0:08:58] a little bit of thought needs to be put into.
[0:09:00] So again, I wanted to thank everybody for that meeting.
[0:09:03] I thought it was very, very interesting.
[0:09:04] And I just wanted to put that idea in your head.
[0:09:06] Thanks very much.
[0:09:07] Thank you, Mr. Shanahan.
[0:09:11] So that is all the folks that I had signed up
[0:09:14] to address the council this evening.
[0:09:15] I do have another gentleman who's on the agenda
[0:09:19] and a little bit Mr. Herring.
[0:09:20] So is there anyone else who just arrived
[0:09:22] that would like to address the council?
[0:09:27] Seeing none, we will move on with the agenda
[0:09:29] to the consent calendar.
[0:09:31] Council wishes.
[0:09:32] Suzanne Hopkins.
[0:09:33] I move approval of the consent calendar.
[0:09:38] Motion by Suzanne Hopkins, seconded by Greg Lanting
[0:09:41] to approve the consent calendar.
[0:09:43] Is there any discussion from the council?
[0:09:46] Seeing none, Sharon, we'll call vote.
[0:09:48] Suzanne Hawkins, Nikki Boyd, Sean Beriker, Chris Tockington, Greg Lanthine, Don Hall,
[0:09:57] Ruth Pierce.
[0:09:59] Motion passes 7-2-0. Under items for consideration, the first is a request to confirm the reappointment
[0:10:09] of Brady Workman for a second term on the airport advisory board. So Brady was appointed
[0:10:19] to the airport board in 2013, and over the first three years of his first term he's attended
[0:10:24] the meetings regularly, been a very positive contributor. City Code 8-7-3 says the airport
[0:10:30] board members are appointed by the mayor and confirmed by the City Council. I've visited
[0:10:36] with Bill Carberry, also with Councilman Tawkington, who's the liaison to the airport board, and
[0:10:41] would like to request that the council confirm my reappointment of Brady to serve a second
[0:10:47] three-year term on the airport advisory board.
[0:10:50] And Brady is here and I suppose could answer any questions
[0:10:53] if anyone has any for him.
[0:10:58] Oh, well, I just want to do a second,
[0:11:00] but I so move.
[0:11:02] Second.
[0:11:03] Hardly, so.
[0:11:04] Have a motion by Chris Tockington.
[0:11:05] Seconded by Greg Lanting to confirm the reappointment
[0:11:08] of Brady Workman for a second term on the airport advisory board.
[0:11:11] Is there any discussion from the council?
[0:11:15] Seeing none, Sharon, Ralcovo, please.
[0:11:17] Nicky Boyd?
[0:11:18] Yes.
[0:11:19] Yes.
[0:11:20] Chris Tockington.
[0:11:21] Absolutely.
[0:11:22] Greg Lanting.
[0:11:23] Yes.
[0:11:24] Don Hall.
[0:11:25] Yes.
[0:11:26] Ruth Pierce.
[0:11:27] Yes.
[0:11:28] Suzanne Hawkins.
[0:11:29] Yes.
[0:11:30] Motion passes.
[0:11:31] Seven to zero.
[0:11:32] Brady, would you like to come forward and tell us about your level of enthusiasm for getting
[0:11:37] another three years of serving on the airport board?
[0:11:40] Thank you.
[0:11:41] It's actually been very exciting last three years.
[0:11:44] I'm lucky enough that I came on as a lot of the paperwork process was done.
[0:11:48] work process was just finishing with the new terminal expansion and you got a tour
[0:11:52] and some other growth that's happened at the airport so I'm lucky to have been
[0:11:56] taken part in that and as it continues to go over the next three years we've got
[0:12:00] great airport and great staff so happy to be out there. Thank you again Brady we
[0:12:06] appreciate your service and you've done an excellent job we look forward to
[0:12:09] another term with you. Next on the agenda is a request from Alfred Herring to wave
[0:12:15] the non-conforming building expansion permit process for a home located at
[0:12:20] at 412 Blue Lakes Boulevard.
[0:12:23] Mr. Herring is here and we have Jonathan Spendlove
[0:12:27] from staff to share with us the information.
[0:12:39] We knew that with Mitch, it would be difficult
[0:12:42] for everyone to figure out how to run the overhead.
[0:12:45] So I'll just start into it and we can talk about
[0:12:47] get the maps up there in just a minute.
[0:12:51] Background sort of request from the Herring who's asked
[0:12:53] to build an addition on the front of his residence
[0:12:56] located at 412 Blue Lakes Boulevard.
[0:12:59] It's in the R4 zoning district, the minimum front yard for that zone is 20 feet from the property line or 80 feet from the street center line in which I'm just greater.
[0:13:06] It's a blue legs boulevard being in some major roadway.
[0:13:09] It's a rather large center line setback. That would actually be for future right-of-way acquisition if we needed to expand the roadway in the future.
[0:13:17] So we're up and give that back.
[0:13:28] Jonathan, is that microphone on?
[0:13:30] It should be on. Is it on?
[0:13:32] It is.
[0:13:34] I'm going to speak kind of close to it.
[0:13:36] Okay, it's a little quiet
[0:13:38] So the colors we're looking at we have the blue-exple of art would be on the left
[0:13:42] It's identified with letters, and then we have a right-of-way
[0:13:45] Which is the actual right-of-way owned by itd and then we have an 80-foot centerline setback and that's got a it's kind of a purplish
[0:13:53] Dark reddish dotted line it pretty much down the middle of the house
[0:13:58] Yeah, right there
[0:13:59] We had a request for a deck to be added on to the back, which would be the northeast corner of the house
[0:14:05] We had a permit for that, and that was approved and finished.
[0:14:09] During that, some inspections on that, we noticed that the front of the house, and we had some
[0:14:14] discussions with Mr. Heron before we kind of went through that building permit process.
[0:14:18] There's a small orange box that is up on the front of that.
[0:14:26] That shows the expansion of a, what is a front deck, and a covered porch.
[0:14:33] When you do that, it requires a building permit, you're essentially expanding the front of your
[0:14:36] house into that setback. That's what we have. It's a non-conforming building due to it being
[0:14:42] within that centerline setback. So the whole house is non-conforming along with a bunch
[0:14:46] of the houses on Blue Lakes Boulevard, a lot of them are that way. But we also have this
[0:14:51] addition which has been built without a building permit. So that's kind of where we are today.
[0:14:57] Once we figured out it was already built, we tried to figure out the legal ramifications
[0:15:00] of what we would do and how we would proceed. So what we would do is proceed to the City Council
[0:15:04] to act on a waiver.
[0:15:06] Typically, you do not see these waivers
[0:15:08] that add on to the front of houses.
[0:15:10] Staff is not supportive of that
[0:15:12] due to future roadway acquisition.
[0:15:14] We don't want to have a similar situation
[0:15:16] or a worse situation than we had in Washington.
[0:15:18] We try to expand that.
[0:15:19] We're really close to people's houses.
[0:15:22] So we don't typically bring these
[0:15:23] because we don't support them at a staff level.
[0:15:26] However, we have what we have here.
[0:15:28] So the council is tasked with making a decision
[0:15:32] on waiving this on the control building expansion
[0:15:35] or if it's not waived, there is another way going
[0:15:38] through the actual public hearing process
[0:15:40] through the Planning and Zoning Commission.
[0:15:41] They would make a decision which could be either
[0:15:46] be a final if it's a yes or no or it could be appealed
[0:15:48] to you as a body for expansion as well.
[0:15:52] That's kind of the history and we'll be here
[0:15:53] from the nutshell.
[0:15:54] If there's any questions, I could certainly ask any
[0:15:57] and if Mr. Herrins and the audience
[0:15:59] need to have answers from him.
[0:16:01] That's all I have.
[0:16:03] Thank you, Jonathan.
[0:16:05] Don Hall.
[0:16:06] Johnson, do you know when this took place the actual addition?
[0:16:10] We know the deck took place this summer through the building permit processes.
[0:16:15] The actual addition on to it, I don't have an exact date.
[0:16:18] Does Mr. Herring know that?
[0:16:23] He is here.
[0:16:24] Mr. Herring?
[0:16:25] Could you?
[0:16:26] Okay.
[0:16:27] Maybe beat him because I didn't hear what he had to say.
[0:16:33] My question to you, Mr.
[0:16:34] That's not a new picture, obviously.
[0:16:36] I have a new mellow roof and that's why we're here because I've really upgraded the property.
[0:16:41] I was told that my porch had to be 32 feet from the center line.
[0:16:45] It had to be 20 feet, it's 32, but I was told my house had to be 50.
[0:16:50] I don't know what site porch people are building, but that was odd to me.
[0:16:55] And also I went to go on record that I was told that I didn't qualify to meet the city council on this.
[0:17:01] So they're trying to keep me from coming in.
[0:17:05] The point I would like to make is that the overhang saves me on electricity.
[0:17:10] I don't have to run my air conditioner all day, it keeps my house cool.
[0:17:15] And the only reason why I don't meet the requirement is because my house isn't 50 feet from the
[0:17:19] road, but nobody's house that was built in 1920 is 50 feet from the road.
[0:17:25] My house was there first, you guys built the road too close to me, my house isn't close
[0:17:29] to the road.
[0:17:31] But the other weird thing is is that I would then be approved and meet city building codes,
[0:17:38] even though it's going to cost me money, then not be approved because the only way to make
[0:17:43] it legal is to make it a free standing, disconnected from the house, disconnected from the porch,
[0:17:49] put four by fours on the ground on the side of it, and then it's legal.
[0:17:53] Doesn't make any sense to me because I'd rather it be safe.
[0:17:57] Mr. Herring, could I ask you a couple questions?
[0:18:00] Can you hear me? Okay. Okay. When did you do the addition on the front?
[0:18:06] Well, the overhang
[0:18:08] We're just about three months ago. We back months ago. Were you aware that you needed a building permit to do that?
[0:18:17] That's why I but then
[0:18:19] When I you know when I was going through all the process that we wanted to build a balcony on the back which they approved and it's finally been written off
[0:18:27] I
[0:18:29] I found out I needed a building code for this too.
[0:18:32] I mean, I permit.
[0:18:33] Right.
[0:18:34] I'd rather be like I said, I'd rather be legal and I'd rather be attached to the house
[0:18:39] because strangely enough if I detach it from the house and make it a freestanding unit,
[0:18:44] it's legal.
[0:18:45] It's just not as safe.
[0:18:46] So you just weren't aware that you needed a building permit when you put the first.
[0:18:50] Not for an overhang for an existing porch, you know.
[0:18:52] Okay.
[0:18:53] That was my question.
[0:18:54] Okay.
[0:18:55] Thank you, sir.
[0:18:56] Thank you for your time.
[0:18:57] You bet.
[0:18:58] Jonathan, trying to look at the picture here, okay, and I know we're
[0:19:05] dealing with the, wow, you said orange, I'm not sure I'd see that as orange, that area right there,
[0:19:10] why does it look to be that the other part of the roof was already there?
[0:19:17] So that's kind of the angle of the aerial picture as you're taking it with the
[0:19:22] shadow, it's because the plane's like, okay, so that above that little dark in
[0:19:27] on that, but right above that. Right near. No, no go above it. Right there. That looks
[0:19:33] like it was already there previously. So that's part of the main roof and that roof is just
[0:19:38] in line with the building. It just looks like it's not. Oh, I see. So that's really in line.
[0:19:42] It's a line between the two. I see what you're saying. Okay. All right. So that's the extension
[0:19:48] out over the the new deck. Yeah, it's just there's a there's a small eave, but the front
[0:19:53] building line is still right there.
[0:19:55] Yeah, thank you.
[0:19:57] Who's talking to?
[0:19:58] Well, I encouraged, Al, Mr. Herron to seek the nonconforming
[0:20:03] building expansion permit.
[0:20:05] If you've driven in that area, you'll
[0:20:07] notice that his house is one of the nicer-looking ones
[0:20:10] on the block of an area that does not always have well taken
[0:20:13] care of homes, let alone upgrades.
[0:20:16] There's a vacant field to the south that's
[0:20:21] debt from up but well within the building line of 50 feet or so.
[0:20:26] I think we should give very strong consideration to granting us to encourage people, albeit to work within the code, which I'll
[0:20:34] admit that he didn't know until he asked me, to consider putting money into their homes and upgrading a part of the town is too easily, doesn't
[0:20:45] have money put back into it. I'm a very strong supporter of the request.
[0:20:52] Suzanne Hawkins.
[0:20:54] John, then I have two questions.
[0:20:56] So explain to me what the applicant's talking about,
[0:20:59] but if it was freestanding, it's legal,
[0:21:01] and if it's attached to the house, it's not.
[0:21:03] It's getting into building codes,
[0:21:05] and I'm not building official.
[0:21:07] I'm not going to get into what the department may have told
[0:21:11] them as far as what could be legal,
[0:21:12] and what's not legal as far as needing a building permit.
[0:21:15] And I don't know if they're here.
[0:21:17] Didn't think they would be able to get into the building
[0:21:19] code sections, but it certainly gets mentors
[0:21:22] different day if you guys are using those. Sorry I can't really give that answer.
[0:21:27] Okay and where I appreciate him trying to upgrade his house I think it's important
[0:21:32] that we don't set the wrong example for other people that if you build it they'll
[0:21:37] forgive it and let you have it which worries me in this case to be honest and
[0:21:43] I'm trying to find out so if we decide that this is not okay tonight and it goes
[0:21:49] to planning and zoning and they decide it's not okay, what does that mean?
[0:21:54] You would, it could be appealed by the applicant back to you.
[0:21:57] But what you're talking about tonight is just a waiver of the process.
[0:22:01] Okay.
[0:22:02] It could go through the full public hearing process and if you decide not to vote for it,
[0:22:08] the option for Mr. Herman be to go through the full nonconforming building expansion process
[0:22:13] which public hearing and planning and zoning commission, any decision they make is appealable
[0:22:17] to the city council.
[0:22:19] So at that time if it's decided that this was not in the best interest of the city, what
[0:22:23] would happen to his front porch?
[0:22:27] You mean if the final decision by the city council was to not approve it?
[0:22:30] Mm-hm.
[0:22:32] Would I let Fritz answer that?
[0:22:38] I will.
[0:22:41] If he did not voluntarily take it down, we could take legal action against him, requiring
[0:22:46] getting an order from the court, requiring him to remove it.
[0:22:52] That's not a very pretty picture.
[0:22:53] No.
[0:22:55] So I know this is tough, but we don't want people just
[0:22:59] to start building on and then coming to us
[0:23:01] on the hindsight like that.
[0:23:03] So how do we prevent this?
[0:23:05] How do we prevent from being put in this position
[0:23:08] to approve something that's against our own city code?
[0:23:12] It's not against your code.
[0:23:14] You have the right to waive the process and to grant it.
[0:23:18] So that's the request is not against the code.
[0:23:21] The question is whether you want, as Chris argued, improvements to the real estate in
[0:23:27] the area or on the other hand whether you need to protect the public right away for future
[0:23:32] widening.
[0:23:33] So if the state comes through and wants to widen this road, what does that do to his
[0:23:37] front porch that is that between them and him or are we still in the middle?
[0:23:41] So that's the problem.
[0:23:43] So it may affect the damages to be paid to him.
[0:23:46] If it's been approved, then you're paying for the I.T.D.'s paying for the porch in addition to the damage to the house.
[0:23:52] Thank you.
[0:23:55] Great.
[0:23:58] Any other comments or questions from the council?
[0:24:06] Nicky Boyd.
[0:24:09] Jonathan, he put a balcony on the back of his house, and he knew, and it was known that he needed a building permit, but he did not have to go to planning and zoning to do that.
[0:24:23] He didn't go to Planning and Zoning to do that.
[0:24:26] He didn't.
[0:24:27] He did not go to the Planning and Zoning Commission for it.
[0:24:30] He came to us for that and the permit was issued for that prior to the knowledge of the building
[0:24:37] and department knowing you need to go to either get a waiver from the council or go through
[0:24:41] the process.
[0:24:43] I'm not talking about the front floor.
[0:24:44] For the balcony, that's correct.
[0:24:48] I'm just trying to figure out how somebody can go in to get a permit and not realize that
[0:24:56] they can, that they go before planning and zoning or how, there were two projects on the
[0:25:03] same house and we have this discrepancy, I'm having a hard time.
[0:25:08] Yeah, two projects on the, on the building, we have, we have a balcony on the back which
[0:25:12] required a building permit, it came to the building department to get one, that was issued during
[0:25:17] the review of that process, basically reviewing the process and what happened, it was found
[0:25:22] out that the building department issued a permit for the balcony on the back.
[0:25:27] The back.
[0:25:28] The back deck.
[0:25:29] And we call it the deck now.
[0:25:30] Right.
[0:25:31] Okay.
[0:25:32] At that time we talked to the building official, we had already issued the permit, some work
[0:25:34] had already been conducted.
[0:25:36] We did not make him go to playing his zoning or to you for a waiver for that piece of, for
[0:25:41] the deck on the back.
[0:25:42] Because he came forward and got a permit.
[0:25:45] He should have gotten one anyway, but that was a...
[0:25:47] But the process was... I'm concerned is because when he came up and spoke, he wasn't clear
[0:25:56] on that he was going to come before planning and zoning.
[0:26:01] Yes, and we had a lot of discussion on whether or not this front part or any part of his
[0:26:06] house should go through a waiver process or the full process.
[0:26:11] The problem we have is we don't bring ones on the fronts of houses that basically are encroaching
[0:26:18] further to this waiver process.
[0:26:22] We feel they should go through the normal one, which is a full hearing process.
[0:26:27] Starting with planning and zoning.
[0:26:29] After finding out that it was already built, it took us some time to figure out what our
[0:26:34] legal ramifications were and how far we would have to go before bringing it into you.
[0:26:41] Thank you.
[0:26:42] Hopefully that answers is good.
[0:26:43] Yeah.
[0:26:44] Better.
[0:26:45] Okay.
[0:26:46] Chris Stockins.
[0:26:47] Well, if I were betting, man, I'd even give odds that the state of ITD will never widen
[0:26:51] blue lights in that area.
[0:26:53] I think it's a case where a situation like this where a person takes money out of their
[0:26:59] own pocket to improve the front elevation of their home or is so rare and so few in between
[0:27:07] that this is not a deluge of people trying to slide
[0:27:10] underneath a city rule.
[0:27:12] I think we're faced with a question of waving the nonconforming
[0:27:17] building expansion permit and the name of beautifying and increasing
[0:27:21] the value of a home or sticking to a code that is allowing us
[0:27:27] to do this because of its flexibility.
[0:27:30] As such, I moved to wave the nonconforming building expansion
[0:27:34] permit for the home located at 412 Blue Lakes Boulevard.
[0:27:38] Second.
[0:27:39] Motion by Chris Togginton, seconded by Don Hall to waive the non-conforming building expansion
[0:27:48] permit.
[0:27:49] So I need a clarification maybe from Jonathan, are we waiving the process or the permit?
[0:27:55] It's basically you're waiving the process but it's the same, it'd be the same.
[0:27:59] Okay.
[0:28:02] Don Hall.
[0:28:03] really not keen, Mr. Herring on allowing people to ask for forgiveness rather than permission,
[0:28:11] but I believe you that you didn't know that you needed a building permit on the front.
[0:28:17] And so I'm going to be in support of this waiver for you.
[0:28:21] Again, I'm not a believer in that we should, you know, beg forgiveness is easier than getting
[0:28:29] permission kind of thing.
[0:28:31] But on this case again, I believe you and I think you're trying to do the right thing here.
[0:28:38] Suzanne Hopkins.
[0:28:39] Thank you.
[0:28:40] I agree with you, Don.
[0:28:41] I do believe you also.
[0:28:42] But I don't think waving the process is the right choice in this one.
[0:28:46] I think the right thing to do is send it back through planning and zoning and let them go
[0:28:49] ahead and have their say that's what they're there for.
[0:28:53] And then see where it goes from there so I will not be supporting the motion tonight.
[0:28:58] Thank you, boy.
[0:28:59] I also appreciate people who invest in their own homes and who, um, one of the things that
[0:29:07] you did was because it, you didn't need as much air conditioning, it keeps your house cooler.
[0:29:12] And, and I, I, I wish it had gone through all the proper channels, but in this case, I
[0:29:18] am, I am going to support.
[0:29:21] We, we weighed this.
[0:29:25] Jonathan, can you tell me how much further into the right of way this encroaches the addition?
[0:29:31] I can give you an approximate since I don't have an s6.
[0:29:35] Is it about six feet?
[0:29:36] That's what I'm...
[0:29:37] Plus or minus six?
[0:29:38] That was four and a half.
[0:29:45] This is a picture of the front portage, I'm guessing it's between four and six feet.
[0:29:52] That would encroach further into the...
[0:29:55] Step back.
[0:29:56] Step back.
[0:29:57] Not the right of way.
[0:29:59] It's not actual right of way, it's just future right of way the right of reference.
[0:30:07] Thank you.
[0:30:08] Greg Lanting.
[0:30:10] Well, Mr. Haring, this is a hard one for me as well.
[0:30:15] I think I'll probably be voting in favor of this process.
[0:30:19] I can see why the staff was wanting you to go through the other process, because we typically
[0:30:25] see these and the people have just built on the back or built on the side.
[0:30:30] They haven't come any farther into the setback.
[0:30:36] But this picture helped me to say yes, I will be voting for it because it's, I don't know
[0:30:43] how much more that that will add to the value should we ever have to widen that street or
[0:30:50] the statements that it chooses to widen that street.
[0:30:53] I would like to see that street widen, but I'm not sure there's room to widen it, to be
[0:30:57] honest with you.
[0:30:58] So I'll be doing a favor, but I'm not, because of the way it looks like, if you'd build a whole
[0:31:03] addition out this way, I'd probably be with the staff and saying maybe it's time to tear
[0:31:07] to this down start over but it was just a porch has a different feel to me any
[0:31:16] further discussion from the council. Seeing none, chair and roll call vote please.
[0:31:23] John Baraker. Yes. Chris Tockington. Yes. Greg Lanting. Yes. Don Hall. Yes. Ruth Pierce. Yes.
[0:31:34] Suzanne Hawkins. No. Nikki Boyd. Yes. Ocean passes 6-2-1. Mr. Mayor. Yes.
[0:31:45] So in listening to the presentation, it sounds like that there was some confusion that was
[0:31:50] Part of the staff's process, and so we'll we'll have a conversation internally and look what we can do to shore that up as well
[0:31:56] All right. Thank you Travis
[0:32:01] next on the agenda is a request to approve an
[0:32:04] Airport utility plan update contract with JAB engineers and the amount of
[0:32:09] $30,000 and to authorize the mayor to sign the agreement. We have Bill Carberry our airport manager. Welcome Bill
[0:32:15] Thank you, Mr. Raggedy, good evening, council members.
[0:32:37] This is a fairly recent Google image, it shows really the footings for FedEx there, so it'll
[0:32:42] be good for our discussion today.
[0:32:44] In our budget, the airport budget this year, we have $30,000 budgeted for an airport utility
[0:32:51] master plan update.
[0:32:53] The last one was done in 2007, and it's certainly time for an update.
[0:32:58] One of the reasons we've waited to initiate this project is because there's a lot of things
[0:33:03] starting to happen on the northeast development area with the addition of FedEx that came
[0:33:10] about.
[0:33:12] It's really changed the landscape there.
[0:33:15] So we're tying the utility plan update in conjunction with a couple of other projects
[0:33:21] that I'll be coming to you in early October to discuss.
[0:33:25] One is, this is our main parallel taxiway, alpha taxiway that goes out to the runway, which
[0:33:30] would be down in this area.
[0:33:31] So this is in need of rehabilitation, it's been several years since we rehabilitated that.
[0:33:38] Don't push that by making sure that it's not a good limit, but.
[0:33:46] So, as I was saying.
[0:33:48] So what we want to do is incorporate this rehabilitation project to identify an area somewhere about
[0:33:54] here to work with a preliminary design project, which I'll also be bringing to you in October,
[0:34:00] that will look at the pre-design for a new taxi lane to come here as we develop our neighborhood
[0:34:07] out here.
[0:34:08] So those two will be coming, the taxiway project, I'll be bringing to you in October as well as
[0:34:13] this pre-design, which will have a lot of public input involved with it, a series of
[0:34:16] meetings to really determine how do we facilitate this area for future hangar development, aeronautical
[0:34:24] development and the ability to access the taxiway and then the runway. So taxiway
[0:34:30] pre-design here will be coming, but backing up to utility plan that really
[0:34:34] folds right in. As we're working on these projects and starting to determine what
[0:34:39] our neighborhood is going to look like here and how we'll access it and where
[0:34:42] future development parcels will lie, how we need to look at where our utility
[0:34:48] corridors, you know, that will come after we inventory, what do we have out there,
[0:34:51] what are our capacities, those kinds of things.
[0:34:55] The FAA is a great partner, and they give us a lot of money
[0:34:57] for capital improvements.
[0:34:58] But one thing that they draw the line on are utilities.
[0:35:02] When it comes to utility improvements, which really are
[0:35:05] what key developments, really what ties things together,
[0:35:08] you're pretty much on your own as an airport operator,
[0:35:10] sponsor, city and county and airport,
[0:35:12] to try to fund those utility improvements.
[0:35:14] So, hence, the utility plan study is in our budget
[0:35:18] made up of city and county support.
[0:35:20] So with that, we really share hats with developers.
[0:35:23] People come along, they want to develop something
[0:35:26] aeronautically at the airport.
[0:35:27] They wear a hat of a developer, but yet we do too.
[0:35:30] So it's a little bit of a different relationship
[0:35:32] out at the airport than we would have maybe in town.
[0:35:36] So with that, I've done a lot of chattering here.
[0:35:39] I'd like to answer any questions you have about it
[0:35:42] and seek your approval and the mayor's signature
[0:35:45] for the contract.
[0:35:47] Any questions for Bill?
[0:35:49] Thank you.
[0:35:50] Chris Stockton.
[0:35:51] Bill just wanted to, didn't have a chance to talk with you out of the airport, but this Thursday,
[0:35:56] I'm meeting with the head of Intermountain Gas about that line to go out there, so I'll let you know if there's some hopeful language out of that.
[0:36:04] Thank you, yeah, natural gas to the airport is something we hope to incorporate in the future and figure out how we might possibly do that.
[0:36:13] We'll be also inventorying fiber optic communications to the airport to support airport operations and data.
[0:36:20] and data, that's something that we really like to develop in the future as well to complement growth out there in future development.
[0:36:31] Any other questions or comments for Bill?
[0:36:35] Nikki Boyd.
[0:36:36] Ready for a motion?
[0:36:38] I am.
[0:36:39] I move that we approve the consideration of an airport utility plan update contract with JUB engineers in the amount of $30,000.
[0:36:47] I'll second that.
[0:36:50] Motion by Nikki Boyce, seconded by Ruth Pierce to approve the airport utility plan update contract.
[0:36:57] Suzanne Hock.
[0:36:58] Thank you. Two quick questions.
[0:37:00] Is this already in our budgeted items so it's been pushed through the right places?
[0:37:05] It is in the budget and we're looking to encumber those funds and
[0:37:08] move through this study through the better part of 17 halfway through.
[0:37:13] And this is a 50-50 split with the county, I'm assuming.
[0:37:15] Yes, it is.
[0:37:16] Thank you.
[0:37:20] Any further discussion?
[0:37:21] We need to add that allow you to sign.
[0:37:25] And just understood.
[0:37:27] Do we need that language in there?
[0:37:30] Understood.
[0:37:32] Sure.
[0:37:33] Enroll call vote, please.
[0:37:37] Chris Tockington?
[0:37:38] Yes.
[0:37:39] Rick Lanting?
[0:37:40] Yes.
[0:37:41] Don Hall?
[0:37:41] Yes.
[0:37:42] Ruth Pears?
[0:37:43] Yes.
[0:37:43] Suzanne Hawkins?
[0:37:44] Yes.
[0:37:45] Nicky Boy?
[0:37:46] Yes.
[0:37:46] Sean Baraker?
[0:37:47] Yes.
[0:37:48] Motion passes 7-0.
[0:37:50] Thank you.
[0:37:50] Thank you, Bill.
[0:37:53] Next is a request to authorize the mayor to sign a letter,
[0:37:56] requesting ITD participation in the consideration of improvement to the traffic flow through the Blue Lakes Boulevard and
[0:38:02] Fillmore Bridgeview intersection where city engineer Jackie Fields welcome Jackie
[0:38:09] this evening
[0:38:10] here to
[0:38:11] Talk about
[0:38:13] Having the council authorized the mayor to sign a letter
[0:38:17] Recently there's been a tremendous amount of development west of blue lakes
[0:38:21] near the Fillmore Bridgeview
[0:38:24] intersection and as that development has occurred
[0:38:28] Staff is noticed and citizens are noticing and talking to us about...
[0:38:33] It's not very loud tonight.
[0:38:37] Sorry.
[0:38:38] Well, you know, it'll be okay.
[0:38:40] So people have been commenting to staff and we've been attempting to try to make improvements to the flow of traffic through that intersection.
[0:38:53] When you stand there for a period of time, it appears that people are not comfortable
[0:39:01] entering the intersection from the Fillmore site primarily, although it happens a little
[0:39:07] bit on the Bridgeview site.
[0:39:08] And it might just be the width of the intersection, because it is the largest intersection most
[0:39:13] of us have seen in a long time.
[0:39:20] We would like to engage ITD in a conversation that results in improved traffic flow on the
[0:39:28] side streets without necessarily negatively impacting the state highway.
[0:39:37] And we felt that a letter from the council supporting that request would provide a little
[0:39:47] a bit of traction so that we can move on and go for it,
[0:39:50] because our level of comment from the public
[0:39:54] is increasing regularly and not quite dramatically,
[0:40:00] but it's time that we have that conversation.
[0:40:03] So this letter will identify this intersection.
[0:40:08] The intersection of Blue Eggs with Fillmore and Bridgeview
[0:40:10] is a priority for the city.
[0:40:12] And we'll ask ITD to participate in helping us
[0:40:15] evaluate the intersection so that all of our needs can be met.
[0:40:21] Greg Lanting.
[0:40:22] Well, Jackie, I really appreciate that we're trying to, you know, at least get a dialogue
[0:40:28] going with them.
[0:40:29] I have come out there on Fillmore numerous times needing to turn left onto the lakes and head
[0:40:34] over the bridge and whether it's the size or the fact that any intersection I've ever
[0:40:41] been in through in my life that that's big has a turn arrow.
[0:40:45] I know that the state may be blocking on a turn arrow because I don't want to back up traffic on the books, but I think that's the issue to me, is that without a turn arrow, you're not sure, you know, are they coming at me?
[0:40:55] Can I turn?
[0:40:56] I've seen numerous people turn and turn right into the traffic because they're just so used to a turn arrow on that make of an intersection that visited the name section.
[0:41:06] section we've we've trained them to use turn arrows and then we take one away
[0:41:10] or we don't have one and so we take away it just is never existed so I think to
[0:41:16] me that is one of the issues we need to discuss with them because without a
[0:41:19] turn error you're not sure what to do you know you turn up there are they gonna
[0:41:24] come because if they don't always start right away and then so yeah I've been
[0:41:29] confused myself and I know that they're gonna come but you just surprised that
[0:41:32] They aren't coming right away.
[0:41:34] And so you feel like you're in no man's land at some point.
[0:41:38] Chris, talk.
[0:41:39] Jackie, if we do, or wouldn't we give you this letter?
[0:41:43] That just gets us on a list for reconsideration.
[0:41:47] That first the state has to decide
[0:41:49] whether to consider it and then to put us on a priority list
[0:41:52] in maybe years before anything would come of this.
[0:41:55] But this is a first step.
[0:41:58] This is a first step.
[0:41:59] And I don't believe that this step would, at this point,
[0:42:04] result in trying to get onto the ITIP or their large capital improvement list.
[0:42:13] It may be analysis and very modest investment to make a change there.
[0:42:21] But I don't know that.
[0:42:23] It may turn out that the analysis of that intersection ends up having some rather large
[0:42:29] financial impact and then we need to plan the work out in the future.
[0:42:34] I would like to think it's as simple as putting on a signal head, but the traffic flow in that area is not particularly simple.
[0:42:43] So it may be a little more complicated than that.
[0:42:46] Mickey Boy.
[0:42:47] Two things.
[0:42:48] The first one is I very much think it's a signaling thing.
[0:42:53] And I've brought before this body before that we have two different kinds of lights.
[0:43:02] So we have the dog house, and then it says, you know, you can go on, you know, it's okay
[0:43:09] to go if it's on green.
[0:43:10] We have two different kinds, and so some of the people who are not firm around here, it's
[0:43:17] been a problem.
[0:43:18] And so I found out that over the course of the next two or three years were in the course
[0:43:22] of replacing all of those, so they'll all be the same.
[0:43:26] And I think this intersection is the same thing when it was new.
[0:43:31] I looked at that arrow for quite a long time deciding if those people were going to come
[0:43:37] at me or if I could turn and was I supposed to hit the gas harder to beat them.
[0:43:43] So that's going to help but I'm just wondering if the real crux of it is when you're turning,
[0:43:51] say you're coming south on the bridge and you're turning over to go to Best Buy or the
[0:43:56] Mall or something.
[0:43:58] There's three lane choices and people are just stopping and deciding where they're going
[0:44:03] to turn and did that need to be bigger from the get-go or I don't know, but it just seems
[0:44:09] like there's a bottleneck there on the bridge view when you turn on the bridge view.
[0:44:15] That seems to be a real regular to the point where I think a lot of people are just going
[0:44:19] down to falls and then coming back around because I don't want to deal with that.
[0:44:24] What is the accident count there?
[0:44:28] Do we have a problem with that?
[0:44:32] We have some accidents in that area.
[0:44:36] So Mike and I did a quick review of the accidents that were there for a somewhat different reason.
[0:44:44] And they are thankfully not fatal and not in the class that are serious injury, but
[0:44:58] Is there a property damage?
[0:45:00] Okay.
[0:45:01] Thank you.
[0:45:02] You bet.
[0:45:03] So did you get hit?
[0:45:04] No.
[0:45:05] I'm glad you were there.
[0:45:08] Suzanne Hawkins.
[0:45:09] Thank you.
[0:45:10] Jackie, thank you for working on this.
[0:45:12] I know it's an issue that we really need to address.
[0:45:14] And I appreciate you taking time to do that.
[0:45:17] I wonder if some of the problem might not also be some of that brick work there,
[0:45:20] so the lines aren't real easy for people to tell where they're at,
[0:45:24] where they're going and who's coming and going and what directions.
[0:45:27] I know the bricks are pretty entrance, but that might be somewhat deceiving to people
[0:45:32] too on which direction they're heading and maybe some different striping or something,
[0:45:36] even if we can't get I.T.D. to help with that.
[0:45:39] I don't know. Just a thought.
[0:45:45] I don't see any further discussion.
[0:45:50] Chris Stockington.
[0:45:51] Moved to authorize a mayor to sign the letter to I.T.D.
[0:45:54] for requesting participation in the traffic flow improvements at Blue Lights and Filmmore in Bridgeview.
[0:46:01] Second.
[0:46:02] Motion by Chris Stockington, seconded by Suzanne Hawkins to authorize the mayor to sign the letter.
[0:46:09] Leave further discussion.
[0:46:11] Seeing none.
[0:46:13] Chair and roll call vote, please.
[0:46:15] Greg Lanthine.
[0:46:16] Yes.
[0:46:17] Don Hall.
[0:46:18] Yes.
[0:46:19] Ruth Pierce.
[0:46:20] Yes.
[0:46:21] Suzanne Hawkins.
[0:46:22] Yes.
[0:46:23] Nikki Boyd.
[0:46:24] Yes.
[0:46:25] Sean Bericher.
[0:46:26] Yes.
[0:46:27] Chris Stockington.
[0:46:28] Yes.
[0:46:29] Motion passes 7-0.
[0:46:30] Good luck.
[0:46:31] request to approve the request for proposal preferred list and authorized
[0:46:35] staff to enter into negotiations with civil science incorporated for the
[0:46:39] transportation master plan Jackie Fields okay so I'll be brief in the background
[0:46:47] here so we made a decision to use the RFP process to seek a consultant for the
[0:46:53] transportation master plan we developed a team we evaluated the proposals the
[0:46:58] requirements of the law or that we rank these firms based on the criteria that we
[0:47:03] gave them when they actually submitted for a proposal and so we did that and the
[0:47:10] firms you know it was there were two that were very close and so we asked some
[0:47:14] supplemental questions and the team felt comfortable with the list as
[0:47:22] developed and it is civil science, kiddleson, jb, and
[0:47:26] redisyl engineers.
[0:47:28] So we've developed a list and the request this evening is to
[0:47:32] approve this list and allow staff to enter into negotiations
[0:47:36] with civil science to develop the scope for the
[0:47:40] transportation master plan.
[0:47:47] Any questions or comments for Jackie?
[0:47:49] Suzanne?
[0:47:50] I move that we approve the list and authorize staff to enter
[0:47:53] into negotiations with civil science for the
[0:47:56] transportation master plan. I'll second that. Motion by Suzanne how can I second
[0:48:01] by Ruth Pierce to approve the request the preferred list and authorized staff to
[0:48:06] enter into negotiations with civil science. So I will say I helped participate in the
[0:48:11] review of these and they were very tight but the input was really positive from
[0:48:18] from the firms and the supplemental questions I think are really going to
[0:48:22] help us get to a plan that addresses not only the technical names, but really provides an
[0:48:31] opportunity for some good public participation and some good communication with the community
[0:48:35] and gets us all to the place we need to be at the end of it.
[0:48:41] Thank you for the opportunity to be a part of it, Jackie.
[0:48:46] Seeing no other discussion, Chair and roll call vote please.
[0:48:50] John Hall. Yes. With peers. Yes. Suzanne Hawkins. Yes. Nicky Boyd. Yes. Sean
[0:48:56] Berricker. Yes. Chris Tockington. Yes. Greg Lanting. Yes. Motion passes 7-0.
[0:49:02] Thank you. Thank you. Next on the agenda is items from the city manager of the
[0:49:10] city council. Mr. Rothweiler, do you have any items for us? You do not. Any
[0:49:15] members of the council have any items of general interest for us? We're just
[0:49:21] Salem 3 here tonight.
[0:49:24] So next on the agenda we have adjournment to an executive session under Idaho Code 742061A
[0:49:32] to consider hiring a public officer, employee, staff member or individual agent wherein the
[0:49:37] respective qualities of individuals are to be evaluated in order to fill a particular
[0:49:41] vacancy or need.
[0:49:43] This paragraph does not apply to filling a vacancy in an elective office or deliberations
[0:49:47] about staffing needs in general, 742-061-B to consider the evaluation, dismissal or disciplining
[0:49:55] of or to hear complaints or charges brought against a public officer, employee, staff member
[0:50:00] or individual agent or public school student, and 742-061-F to communicate with legal counsel
[0:50:07] for the public agency to discuss the legal ramifications of and legal options for pending
[0:50:12] litigation or controversies not yet being litigated but imminently likely to be
[0:50:17] litigated. The mere presence of legal counsel at the executive session does not
[0:50:21] satisfy this requirement. Don Hall. Could you repeat that one more? So moved.
[0:50:26] Second. The motion by Don Hall seconded by... I'm going to get to the right page to
[0:50:34] write things out here. Seconded by Greg Lanting to adjourn into executive session
[0:50:39] for those various items. Is there any discussion? Seeing none. Chair and roll call vote, please.
[0:50:46] Ruth Pierce. Yes. Suzanne Hawkins. Yes. Nikki Boyd. Yes. Sean Beriker. Yes. Chris
[0:50:52] Hawking. Yes. Greg Lanting. Yes. Don Hall. Yes. Motion passes 7-0. I will note that the
[0:51:00] Council will not be making any decisions on these items nor will we be coming back into
[0:51:04] to the session following the executive session, and with that we will adjourn.
