Oversight Archive: City Council meeting, 2016-09-26, recording 1 (started 17:00)
Machine transcript (faster-whisper base.en), not checked word for word; the Pledge of Allegiance is shown in its standard wording. The recording is the record.
Times are time into the recording. Passages with private details are muted in the audio and marked here.
The audio on the page below was re-encoded by software from the video the agency posted. Check any passage against
that audio before relying on it.
Page: https://oversightarchive.org/twin-falls-id/meetings/2016-09-26/

[0:08:44] I'd like to call to order the City Council meeting for Monday, September 19th, and to start off, we do have Zane who is here, a Boy Scout, who I've asked if he would come up and lead us in the Pledge of Allegiance.
[0:08:56] So those of you wishing to join us, please rise.
[0:08:59] Oh, it's the 26th today.
[0:09:02] Sorry, I read the wrong sheet.
[0:09:04] September 26th.
[0:09:06] I pledge allegiance to the Flag of the United States of America, and to the Republic for which it stands, one Nation under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all.
[0:09:24] And Zane, before you run off, if you would please come up to the podium and tell us your name and your troop and what you're working on this evening.
[0:09:33] I'm with Zane, and I'm Zane, and I'm with Troop 76,
[0:09:37] Marvin Chamberlain's group,
[0:09:39] and I am working on my community service badge,
[0:09:42] which is my citizenship badge,
[0:09:44] and I'm one of my requirements is
[0:09:46] that I must attend a city council meeting.
[0:09:49] So that's what I'm doing.
[0:09:50] Great, well, thank you for being here this evening,
[0:09:52] and we'll try to make it super entertaining for you.
[0:09:54] Thank you.
[0:10:01] We do have a quorum at the council.
[0:10:02] All seven members are here this evening.
[0:10:07] Mr. Pike, do we have any amendments to our agenda this evening?
[0:10:11] Mr. Mayor, we do.
[0:10:12] We would like to add another executive session.
[0:10:16] So a session under 742061F, which is to communicate with legal counsel for the public agency to discuss legal ramifications of and legal options for pending litigation.
[0:10:32] Thank you, and my understanding is this issue has come up since Friday, and so that is why it was not noticed on an amended agenda on Friday, so I would entertain a motion to amend the agenda, Suzanne Hawkins.
[0:10:47] I move to amend the agenda to keep the, or to add the executive session under the session that our deputy city manager referenced.
[0:10:58] Second.
[0:11:00] Motion by Suzanne Hopkins, seconded by Don Hall, to add an executive session under
[0:11:05] I'd out code 742061F.
[0:11:09] Is there any discussion?
[0:11:11] Seeing none, Sharon Roll, call vote please.
[0:11:17] Suzanne Hopkins?
[0:11:18] Yes.
[0:11:19] Nikki Boyd?
[0:11:20] Yes.
[0:11:21] Sean Beriker?
[0:11:22] Yes.
[0:11:23] Chris Hockington?
[0:11:24] Yes, Riddle Ockenloin?
[0:11:26] Greg Lanting?
[0:11:27] Yes.
[0:11:28] Don Hall?
[0:11:29] Yes.
[0:11:30] Ruth Pierce?
[0:11:30] Yes.
[0:11:31] Motion passes 7-0.
[0:11:33] Thank you, Mr. Pike.
[0:11:35] We have no proclamations this evening,
[0:11:36] so the next item on the agenda is general public input,
[0:11:39] and if I can ask one of the staff
[0:11:41] to grab the sign in sheet fees for me.
[0:11:46] This is an opportunity to address the council
[0:11:48] on items that are not on this evening's agenda.
[0:11:56] I'm related to matters relevant to the City of Twin Falls.
[0:12:01] So we do have a couple of folks who have signed up.
[0:12:03] So first, we have Terry Edwards.
[0:12:07] So it would remind everyone to please come forward to the podium, state your name and address,
[0:12:12] and whether you're a resident or property owner in the City of Twin Falls.
[0:12:15] We will limit our input tonight to three minutes per speaker.
[0:12:20] My name is Terry Edwards.
[0:12:21] I have property in Twin Falls.
[0:12:25] I just wanted to commend the council for last week's decision to waive the nonconforming
[0:12:33] building permit expansion process for Mr. Herring.
[0:12:37] I thought it was appropriate thing to do in the situation that was there, and common sense
[0:12:42] prevailed, so thank you for doing that.
[0:12:46] Thank you, Mr. Edwards, and next we have Lee Strandahan.
[0:12:59] Welcome, Mr. Strandahan.
[0:13:01] Thanks very much, let me just, I want to talk about technology, so of course mine isn't working.
[0:13:06] Here we go.
[0:13:08] Good afternoon, Mr. Mayor and members of the City Council.
[0:13:12] I'd like to talk about something that's also related to something I talked about last week
[0:13:18] based on Mr. Rothweiler's presentation at the Economic Development Meeting about 10 days
[0:13:24] ago.
[0:13:25] And I want to talk about the role that I think the city can take in dealing with internet
[0:13:31] infrastructure and what I'll call a digital infrastructure issue.
[0:13:35] I'm going to talk about the issue briefly, broadly, and then I'll make a practical suggestion.
[0:13:40] Right now, Twin Falls, I just checked this today, ranks about 3,500 on a list of about
[0:13:47] 5,000 cities in terms of internet speed.
[0:13:51] This needs to change for a variety of reasons, but specifically to achieve some of the goals
[0:13:55] that Mr. Rothweiler and people like Josh Palmer addressed at that economic development meeting.
[0:14:02] Goals like attracting young professionals and just as importantly, retaining young people
[0:14:07] in Twin Falls, so when they graduate high school and college, they stay here rather
[0:14:12] than going to places like Portland, Seattle, and the Bay Area.
[0:14:17] Now at the time, I raised the issue, and Mr. Roth Reiler mentioned, I think, properly,
[0:14:23] that a lot of this stuff is handled by private companies.
[0:14:26] And I think that that is appropriate, but I think that there is a step that the city
[0:14:30] council can take as well.
[0:14:31] The first step is recognizing that there is a problem.
[0:14:35] In other words, it is an issue that can be improved and setting some big goals, not just
[0:14:41] to make it moderately better, but the next generation of internet technology, forgive
[0:14:46] me, is almost here, Gigabit Internet, and that's important for things like 4K TVs.
[0:14:52] Right now, if you go to Costco or Walmart, you'll see 4K TVs.
[0:14:55] They're cheap and affordable.
[0:14:56] That requires much more bandwidth than even the current infrastructure.
[0:15:01] So practically, my idea here is let's get some of those private companies together, let's
[0:15:06] set a goal from the city council to make this a priority, get those companies together
[0:15:12] and then ask them crazy idea, then ask them what do they need, what do you need to make
[0:15:17] it bigger?
[0:15:18] Do you need a bigger pipe coming in, are there technologies we don't know about?
[0:15:23] I think this should be something that the city should consider as a priority because in a
[0:15:27] a very real way the future of Twin Falls depends on it.
[0:15:30] That's my time, thanks very much.
[0:15:32] Thank you, sir.
[0:15:39] Those are the only two folks who signed up
[0:15:41] to speak to the council.
[0:15:42] Does anyone else from the public
[0:15:43] who wishes to address us this evening?
[0:15:47] Seeing none, we will move on with the agenda
[0:15:49] to the consent calendar.
[0:15:50] Council wishes.
[0:15:55] Susanne Hawkins.
[0:15:56] And move approval.
[0:15:58] Thank you.
[0:16:00] Motion by Susanne Hawkins seconded by Greg Lansing
[0:16:02] to approve the consent calendar.
[0:16:04] Is there any discussion?
[0:16:07] Seeing none, Sharon Rolkaldo please.
[0:16:09] Nikki Boyd?
[0:16:10] Yes.
[0:16:11] Sean Beriger?
[0:16:12] Yes.
[0:16:12] Chris Hockington?
[0:16:13] Yes.
[0:16:14] Greg Lanting?
[0:16:15] Yes.
[0:16:16] Don Hall?
[0:16:16] Yes.
[0:16:17] Ruth Pierce?
[0:16:18] Yes.
[0:16:18] Suzanne Hocking?
[0:16:19] Yes.
[0:16:21] Motion passes 7-0.
[0:16:23] Under items for consideration, the first
[0:16:24] is a presentation of the Certificate of Achievement
[0:16:27] for Excellence in Financial Reporting,
[0:16:30] received by the City of Twin Falls
[0:16:32] for the comprehensive audited financial report
[0:16:35] with the CAFR for the year ended September 30, 2015.
[0:16:40] Mr. Rothweiler is on the agenda for that,
[0:16:42] but he is tied up in an interview right at the moment
[0:16:45] with candidates for the library board,
[0:16:47] so I will turn it over to our deputy city manager,
[0:16:49] Brian Pike.
[0:16:50] Mr. Mayor, if it would meet with your approval,
[0:16:51] could we move down to item two?
[0:16:54] You bet.
[0:16:55] We'll do that.
[0:16:56] We'll hold off on that until Travis is able to join us.
[0:17:00] Number two under items for consideration,
[0:17:02] request to approve the professional services agreement
[0:17:04] the Civil Science Incorporated to develop the 2016 City of Twin Falls
[0:17:08] Transportation Master Plan and authorize the Mayor or City Engineer to sign the
[0:17:13] contract of our City Engineer, Jackie Fields. Welcome, Jackie. Good evening. So I'll
[0:17:24] briefly recite part of the background from the agenda item. So city staff made
[0:17:31] a decision to seek proposals for the Transportation Master Plan in the event
[0:17:37] that there was a larger opportunity out there.
[0:17:41] We received four proposals.
[0:17:44] The evaluation team proceeded through the proposals
[0:17:47] and made a decision to select civil science incorporated.
[0:17:53] So we came to council last week
[0:17:54] and council approved the prioritized list.
[0:17:58] And because we're nearing the end of our fiscal year,
[0:18:00] we jumped right on negotiating the scope of the contract.
[0:18:06] Much of the contract is similar in scope
[0:18:09] or was already known to the proponents
[0:18:12] as they develop their proposals.
[0:18:14] So the transportation master plan
[0:18:17] is going to be very similar to water and wastewater facility
[0:18:20] plans in that there are certain technical analysis type things
[0:18:24] that need to happen.
[0:18:26] You need to look at what is currently happening.
[0:18:29] You need to make projections for the future,
[0:18:31] develop a capital improvements plan,
[0:18:34] and some estimates for that.
[0:18:36] So those things are not dissimilar from the last time that we did our transportation master
[0:18:42] plan and are scheduled to occur again.
[0:18:48] We do have some things that are different.
[0:18:50] Last time we didn't have a pavement management plan.
[0:18:52] This time we do, that we've been trying to use and have been augmented this year with a
[0:18:57] LIDAR contract that did some analysis on more streets.
[0:19:02] So we have some more data points.
[0:19:06] And we also have transitioned to ISPWC.
[0:19:09] So there's been a difference in some of the way that we are going to be addressing paving
[0:19:16] and road loads.
[0:19:18] The ISPWC's materials report in advance of ISPWC's implementation suggested that the
[0:19:25] city consider a roadway alternative called minor collector or major collector.
[0:19:31] So, you know, it's a new subcategory, it allows for roads like locusts to be treated differently
[0:19:38] than roads like chute, okay?
[0:19:42] So we need to qualify chute.
[0:19:45] Chute is a collector.
[0:19:46] Chute is a collector.
[0:19:47] Okay, so it's not the same kind of road as locust or filmor, and nor does it need to
[0:19:54] be built in the same way that locust and filmor need to be built.
[0:19:58] So this will provide an opportunity to keep the pavement right, to get it right.
[0:20:06] So we also have a pretty robust public inclusion process because we need to talk about things
[0:20:15] like pedestrian ways, illumination standards, we need to deal with truck routes, and whether
[0:20:22] or not we should have them.
[0:20:24] We need to deal with some impacts to the development community.
[0:20:30] For instance, this business of looking at where collectors should be major and where they
[0:20:35] should be minor is something that we could do in a vacuum, but we don't function like that,
[0:20:40] and it's probably better to talk to people about why we would want to classify a road
[0:20:46] in a particular way and how it actually serves the public in the long haul.
[0:20:55] We also know that we're going to be facing within our next time frame becoming our next
[0:21:02] revision to the transportation master plan should be just in advance of when we are designated
[0:21:07] as a metropolitan planning organization.
[0:21:10] So we've started doing planning, making planning efforts to talk about that.
[0:21:14] There's been a transit plan out there.
[0:21:16] There's been some investigation.
[0:21:18] We need to do a little bit more.
[0:21:21] And so this plan will include some steps that we may choose to model as we move forward.
[0:21:40] So I think that I'm going to stop speaking unless you would like me to add more information
[0:21:47] about in particular sector of the transportation master plan.
[0:21:52] I think the only item I would add is that also as part of the evaluation was the public
[0:21:56] engagement process and how the general public could plug in and perhaps a less technical
[0:22:02] way in helping to address some of those issues as well.
[0:22:07] And there's a plan to use some more modern tools.
[0:22:13] Surveys are pretty easy to do.
[0:22:16] Response by telephonists are using your devices.
[0:22:22] Very attractive to many people.
[0:22:25] we're going to attempt to ask certain types of questions in that way. Obviously, capacity
[0:22:30] analysis questions don't need to be dealt with in the more modern methods of gathering
[0:22:39] information because there are technical analysis. But, you know, we're having discussions
[0:22:43] of people about pedestrian ways and incorporating the draft bicycle plan into the transportation
[0:22:49] Master Plan. Those are really good times to head up folks that don't normally read the
[0:22:55] newspaper for instance and to try other methods.
[0:22:58] Thank you, Jackie. We do have a few comments or questions. Great landing.
[0:23:02] I guess I'm having... I absolutely agree that the minor major collector. I guess I'm having
[0:23:09] a little concern. Maybe I didn't understand how collectors work because you mentioned
[0:23:13] and it's one block away from a major arterial
[0:23:19] and another block away from what I assumed
[0:23:21] was a collector being Haber.
[0:23:23] And so how does the chute end up being a collector?
[0:23:26] So collectors are traditionally placed
[0:23:29] on quarter mile roads between the mile.
[0:23:32] So I believe that even though chute appears to be one block,
[0:23:38] that it's a long block.
[0:23:41] So between calls and, oh you're right, I apologize, it's Haber.
[0:23:47] Haber, okay, now that makes sense to me, all right, thank you.
[0:23:51] So you know when we're dealing with developments, I always whip out the plan.
[0:23:55] I just want you to know that.
[0:23:56] I always stick with the plan, it's always good to look at the plan.
[0:23:58] I'm no longer confused, thank you.
[0:24:00] Chris Dr.
[0:24:01] Jack, two questions.
[0:24:04] One, will this incorporate at all our mass transportation, the bus route system?
[0:24:09] without have any involvement.
[0:24:12] So the work that's been done on preparing for a transit plan
[0:24:16] will be incorporated into this document?
[0:24:18] Into that, okay.
[0:24:18] It won't have to be reinvented then.
[0:24:20] No.
[0:24:22] Okay, and also a couple years ago,
[0:24:25] we tried to get some momentum going.
[0:24:27] There was interest on reconfiguring these five points
[0:24:31] to allow trucks coming through Kimberly Road
[0:24:34] to go straight through on truck lane
[0:24:38] instead of up East Maine and doing their goose necks.
[0:24:41] Is that still something that can be done,
[0:24:43] or is that outside the purview of this type of study?
[0:24:48] When it has a place in this document,
[0:24:54] so the discussion on what to do with Washington,
[0:24:57] six, and Minidoka absolutely has a place in this document,
[0:25:00] and that transportation master plan
[0:25:03] needs to prioritize that project
[0:25:06] as something that's of community interest.
[0:25:08] When I made the submittal last January for local urban funding,
[0:25:14] that project was not specifically identified
[0:25:16] in our transportation master plan.
[0:25:18] And there was a deduction on the score
[0:25:23] that was significant because of it.
[0:25:25] So it should be in the document and it will be.
[0:25:31] And I think-
[0:25:32] But don't have to have to have funding cycle on third long range.
[0:25:35] So we will not finish the transportation plan
[0:25:37] in advance of the next funding cycle.
[0:25:39] So there are opportunities to adopt a value
[0:25:43] that's determined along the way
[0:25:45] into the existing transportation master plan
[0:25:48] in advance of having the new income out.
[0:25:50] So we'll be able to remedy our particular situation
[0:25:55] in the short term, but in the long haul,
[0:25:58] if the community values that discussion
[0:26:02] and investigation on sixth and Washington,
[0:26:04] and Adoka, that area,
[0:26:05] And then we need to have it in our transportation house.
[0:26:07] I sure hope it doesn't day.
[0:26:09] It doesn't deserve to be deep-sixed.
[0:26:12] The where on Main Street, the inconvenience of traffic,
[0:26:15] slowing down the trucks coming.
[0:26:17] It should be able to shoot right through to South end of town.
[0:26:21] It looks like it should be a higher priority
[0:26:23] than we've given it.
[0:26:25] He just said.
[0:26:28] Donald.
[0:26:29] I just piggyback onto what you just said.
[0:26:31] The Minidocas Sixth issue with trying
[0:26:34] to get the seconds off the highway route around there.
[0:26:38] I would hope that there would be a lot of discussion
[0:26:40] during this for that direction as well.
[0:26:44] Just keep that on the front burner as well.
[0:26:47] Nicky Boyd.
[0:26:49] Mr. Mayor, if you're ready for a motion.
[0:26:51] Suzanne, did you have a comment on that?
[0:26:53] Oh, Mr. Thank you.
[0:26:54] Yep.
[0:26:55] So, Jackie, can you briefly go over the pay scope on this?
[0:26:58] I know that it showed that the 250,000
[0:27:01] was the same as the last study roughly.
[0:27:04] And then in the contract, it breaks it down between three separate entities.
[0:27:09] So we're contracting with civil science, and they're contracting with the other two,
[0:27:13] and that's how we came up with that fund, or how does that work?
[0:27:17] Help me.
[0:27:18] So I estimate it.
[0:27:23] What I thought would be a reasonable amount of money for professional services
[0:27:28] contract based on what I understood from the scope at the time.
[0:27:33] And then as we move through the scope discussion,
[0:27:36] the rules for professional services contracts means
[0:27:40] that we talk about the scope first,
[0:27:42] and then we have a discussion on what that correlates to financially.
[0:27:47] And if we cannot come to an agreement on the scope and the finances,
[0:27:52] you know, typically there could be some back and forth,
[0:27:55] and then we could make a decision based on how well we could meet that scope.
[0:28:00] So, the subcontractors for civil science have developed an estimate for the amount that
[0:28:10] they're going to charge civil science for the level of work that they anticipate to
[0:28:14] occur.
[0:28:15] And so we don't usually negotiate the actual subcontractor scope.
[0:28:22] We negotiate with what civil science is going to do.
[0:28:24] So the way that I do this from my experience in the olden days is that independently of
[0:28:33] what the contractor, the engineer prescribes, I do a mandate estimate or a man hour, a personnel
[0:28:40] hour estimate for the type of labor effort that I think is involved and I estimate what
[0:28:46] type of person would probably work on that whether they're a technician or a clerk.
[0:28:53] If my number is within 10% of their number, we're in pretty good shape.
[0:28:59] So we're just negotiating with civil science and then they take care of the rest.
[0:29:03] So we're not entering into contract with all three companies.
[0:29:06] That's accurate.
[0:29:07] Civil science will be held responsible for a robust public involvement program and for appropriate capacity analysis.
[0:29:14] Thank you.
[0:29:16] If that was what you were originally asking, I apologize for long-wind and answering.
[0:29:19] I did not ask it very well.
[0:29:20] No, you did great.
[0:29:21] Thank you.
[0:29:22] Thank you, boy.
[0:29:24] I move that we approve the professional services agreement with Civil Science Inc to develop
[0:29:28] the 2016 City of Twin Falls Transportation Master Plan and authorize the mayor or city
[0:29:34] engineer to sign the contract.
[0:29:36] I'll second that.
[0:29:38] I should invite Nikki Bright second to my root peers to approve the professional services
[0:29:43] agreement as presented.
[0:29:44] Is there any further discussion?
[0:29:46] Chris, I think it is appropriate we attach an upper amount on this rather than just signing
[0:29:54] a document without the specified amounts. It was $249, wasn't it?
[0:29:59] $249 in change?
[0:30:02] I would so move to include with the contract up to whatever it is, $249, what you say Susan?
[0:30:11] It would, I close that document. It was $249 in change. It was just under $250.
[0:30:15] Not your C250? Yeah.
[0:30:16] $250, $250, yeah.
[0:30:17] Jack has the number.
[0:30:18] No.
[0:30:19] If we'd like to get it from her.
[0:30:21] Okay.
[0:30:22] $49,982.
[0:30:25] So amended.
[0:30:27] Second.
[0:30:28] From motion by Chris Tackington, seconded by Don Hall
[0:30:31] to amend the original motion to include the not to exceed
[0:30:36] amount of $249,982.
[0:30:43] Actually, the wording was up, too.
[0:30:46] Let's hope it comes in significantly less.
[0:30:49] Tens of thousands.
[0:30:50] Any discussion on the amendment?
[0:30:56] Seeing none, Sharon, we'll call vote, please.
[0:30:58] Chris Tockington?
[0:30:59] Yes.
[0:31:00] Greg Lanthine?
[0:31:01] Yes.
[0:31:02] Don Hall?
[0:31:03] Yes.
[0:31:04] Ruth Pierce?
[0:31:05] Yes.
[0:31:06] Suzanne Hawkins?
[0:31:07] Yes.
[0:31:08] Nicki Boyd?
[0:31:09] Yes.
[0:31:10] Sean Bericke?
[0:31:11] Yes.
[0:31:12] Motion passes 7-0, so the amended motion to approve the professional services agreement with the up to amount of $249,982.
[0:31:20] and discussion on the amended motion.
[0:31:25] Sharon Rilko, please.
[0:31:28] Sean Baraker.
[0:31:29] Yes.
[0:31:30] Chris Talkington.
[0:31:31] Yes.
[0:31:32] Greg Lantine.
[0:31:33] Yes.
[0:31:34] Don Hall.
[0:31:35] Yes.
[0:31:36] Ruth Pierce.
[0:31:37] Yes.
[0:31:38] Suzanne Hocken.
[0:31:39] Yes.
[0:31:40] Nikki Boyd.
[0:31:41] Yes.
[0:31:43] Motion passes 7-2-0.
[0:31:44] Jackie, I believe you also wanted perhaps an input from us on folks to serve on the technical
[0:31:48] advisory committee and the.
[0:31:49] That would be great.
[0:31:50] Would you like to do that now?
[0:31:52] that now, or at a later meeting.
[0:31:56] Do we have a little time to work that out?
[0:31:58] I'm sorry.
[0:31:59] Do we have a little bit of time to do that?
[0:32:00] We have a little bit of time.
[0:32:02] How about let's put that on an upcoming agenda as you finalize the agreement?
[0:32:09] That's fine.
[0:32:10] And in the meantime, we'll all put some thought to who we think might be some good types of
[0:32:15] people to serve on that committee.
[0:32:17] Thank you, Jackie.
[0:32:22] We're going to go ahead and go to number three so that Jackie can get through her item
[0:32:26] and then we'll back up to number one.
[0:32:28] So item number three on the items for considerations
[0:32:31] request to award the contract for the sludge truck
[0:32:33] for the wastewater treatment plant to Jackson Group Peterbilt
[0:32:37] of Boise, Idaho, and the amount of $138,665.
[0:32:42] And again, our city engineer, Jackie Fields.
[0:32:45] So the engineering department initiated a formal bid
[0:32:48] and received two bids.
[0:32:51] The first was from Jackson Group, Peter Bildt of Boise,
[0:32:57] and the second was by Rush Truck Center of Tuanfosaihe.
[0:33:02] Both bidders had exceptions to the specifications.
[0:33:07] As required by the contract, Jackson provided
[0:33:11] supplemental information to justify their exception,
[0:33:14] and their exception was found to be,
[0:33:16] to at least meet the specification.
[0:33:19] The Rush Truck Center had three exceptions.
[0:33:29] The documentation was not sufficient for us to make a determination that they were at least
[0:33:37] the specification and we felt those specs had to do with the structural strength of the
[0:33:44] vehicle and we felt that they were important to maintain and so we are suggesting and recommending
[0:33:53] that the council authorized the mayor to sign a contract with Jackson Group Peter
[0:34:03] built of $138,665. The price difference for the record is about $1700. So they were
[0:34:11] very close bits. Chris talking so moved. Second. Go ahead. The motion by Chris
[0:34:22] talking to the second of my Suzanne Hawkins to award the contract for the
[0:34:25] sludge truck to Jackson group Peter belts of 138,665 dollars.
[0:34:33] Suzanne Hawkins.
[0:34:34] Thank you, Jackie.
[0:34:35] What was the exception and what was the conclusion of that?
[0:34:42] There was one irregularity.
[0:34:44] The exception on Peter built was we asked for steel and we were getting aluminum, but we
[0:34:55] But we were getting double-sided aluminum that actually
[0:34:58] seats the minimum strength required.
[0:35:01] And then at least two of Russia's exceptions
[0:35:05] had to do with strength.
[0:35:09] So the modulus and the moment of how this vehicle is going
[0:35:19] to form so that it doesn't buckle.
[0:35:25] And it was somewhat close.
[0:35:29] You know, it wasn't like it was way far off,
[0:35:31] but it did not meet this back.
[0:35:34] Thank you.
[0:35:37] That's going to be another discussion.
[0:35:40] Seeing then, Sharon and Volklow, please.
[0:35:43] Greg Lanting.
[0:35:44] Yes.
[0:35:44] Don Hall.
[0:35:45] Yes.
[0:35:46] Ruth Hairs.
[0:35:46] Yes.
[0:35:47] Suzanne Hawkins.
[0:35:48] Yes.
[0:35:49] Nicki Boyd.
[0:35:50] Yes.
[0:35:50] Sean Beriker.
[0:35:51] Yes.
[0:35:52] Chris talking.
[0:35:53] Yes.
[0:35:54] Motion passes 7-0.
[0:35:56] Thank you, Jackie.
[0:35:56] Thank you.
[0:35:58] So we will back up the agenda to item number one,
[0:36:01] under items for consideration,
[0:36:02] presentation of the certificate of achievement
[0:36:04] for excellence in financial reporting received
[0:36:07] by the City of Twin Falls for the comprehensive
[0:36:09] audited financial report.
[0:36:11] The year ended September 30, 2015.
[0:36:14] We have our city manager, Travis Rothweiler.
[0:36:16] Welcome, Travis.
[0:36:17] Good evening, Mr. Member, Mr. Council, sorry.
[0:36:19] I apologize for being late.
[0:36:20] I had the opportunity to sit on library board applications
[0:36:24] and interviews and some really phenomenal candidates
[0:36:28] that we'll be bringing to your review
[0:36:34] for ultimate consideration and impossible appointment
[0:36:37] at an upcoming meeting.
[0:36:39] But tonight we get the opportunity
[0:36:40] to really celebrate one of the achievements
[0:36:42] of our finance department that has taken several years
[0:36:46] to reach this step.
[0:36:48] And this is a really significant step
[0:36:50] in terms of our organization by what
[0:36:54] and how we start our budgeting process.
[0:36:57] And you've heard us speak about the importance
[0:36:59] of the budgeting process,
[0:37:01] how we open that process up for lots of citizen input.
[0:37:06] We start that process very, very early
[0:37:09] and we continue to move forward.
[0:37:11] And that budget is really a best plan
[0:37:15] that we hope to carry forward and to move forward.
[0:37:18] It lays out our goals and our purposes
[0:37:21] with the public resources.
[0:37:24] But at the end of the day, a report card is important.
[0:37:27] How did you spend those city dollars?
[0:37:31] How did you honor your fiduciary responsibility?
[0:37:34] And part of that is an audit, but the other piece of that
[0:37:38] is a comprehensive annual financial report, which
[0:37:41] is much more involved than just a simple audit and process.
[0:37:47] It is a complete description of what
[0:37:49] occurred inside of the city of Twin Falls
[0:37:51] from not only a financial but policy perspective.
[0:37:54] And the City of Twin Falls is now one of three entities
[0:37:58] in the state of Idaho that has received the GFOA's award
[0:38:03] for most distinguished budget and the GFOA award
[0:38:06] for the Comprehensive Annual Finance Report or CAPR.
[0:38:11] And with that, I would like Lori, Shane, and Brent
[0:38:15] to come forward and if the mayor could come down
[0:38:18] And we will present the first comprehensive annual financial report from GFOA.
[0:38:25] And then I would like Lori to kind of talk and Brent to spend just a few seconds talking
[0:38:30] about the steps that they took from 2011 forward to get to this point.
[0:38:35] Nice job.
[0:39:03] So just for the record, those three other local government entities inside the state
[0:39:07] of Idaho are the city of Boise, the city of postfalls, and the city of Twin Falls.
[0:39:11] I believe the City of Post Falls and the City of Twin Falls
[0:39:14] received that recognition for both of our works in 2015.
[0:39:19] So we're tied for second, if you will,
[0:39:22] in proving that forward.
[0:39:24] But our documents are far superior to what Boise does anyway.
[0:39:27] So there you go.
[0:39:31] So I would just like to say, before I turn it over to Brent,
[0:39:35] who really leads the charge, that there
[0:39:37] are a lot of folks involved in this.
[0:39:39] Brent will tell you that the auditors were part of that team
[0:39:42] that made it all happen, adjusting their report so that we fit in to what GFOA wanted.
[0:39:49] Brent leads that charge for our team and there are a lot of members of our team who prepare
[0:39:53] schedules and help make it happen.
[0:39:56] And I will say Travis is part of that as well.
[0:39:58] He sets a high bar for us.
[0:40:00] So, this is really a great achievement for not just our finance department but the whole
[0:40:05] city.
[0:40:06] And Brent can share a little bit more about it.
[0:40:10] Well, I think the Finance Department really should be proud of this.
[0:40:12] And I think one way to evaluate how significant this award is, is by letting you know that
[0:40:20] we made two previous runs out of it and failed.
[0:40:25] And these are reviewed by professionals on a national level, our financial statements,
[0:40:30] and they came back each time and said, here's why you didn't make it.
[0:40:34] Here's the critical things.
[0:40:35] And so we would address those.
[0:40:36] We took her on the second year and didn't make it again.
[0:40:41] And you know, our auditors or any auditors, if you say we want to CAFRA, they hate that.
[0:40:48] Because it is difficult to achieve that.
[0:40:51] Not just to do the CAFRA, but to do it in an appropriate way where you are able to receive
[0:40:56] the award.
[0:40:57] And so we're pretty proud of this, I have to say that.
[0:41:00] And our auditors did a super job of team approach on making it happen.
[0:41:05] Thanks.
[0:41:06] Thank you, Brent.
[0:41:07] And Brent, could I ask a silly question? We tried to try to sell for pride ourselves,
[0:41:13] I guess, on our transparency in our being squeaky with taxpayers' money. But how would
[0:41:19] we sell this to the public failing a couple of times when we made it? Now, what do you
[0:41:24] think this relates to the public? Sure. That might be, you know, I don't want to give
[0:41:29] the wrong impression because financial statements and the auto report have been sailing clean
[0:41:33] for years and years and years and what this is is it's a higher level and it's
[0:41:39] pretty much formatting and presentation to meet the professional standards so
[0:41:45] our financial statements what went into this financial statement is no
[0:41:52] different than what's going on in previous years it was just the whipped cream and
[0:41:59] the cherry that went on top of everything else that, you know,
[0:42:03] I'll let you sell it to the taxpayer that way.
[0:42:06] Yeah.
[0:42:07] We have higher expectations and standards internally that may not be visible to the public,
[0:42:12] but we can sleep better at night.
[0:42:15] Yeah.
[0:42:16] Whether or not we have cherry pie with the premium tonight.
[0:42:19] Thank you.
[0:42:22] So someone might ask, why do you, is the award important?
[0:42:27] And I think the award illustrates the recognition of the team that the staff goes forward with.
[0:42:34] But it's really the process involved that I think is the most important.
[0:42:37] When you look at what the government finance officers association said, says those bars,
[0:42:42] like Brent was talking about, in terms of what do you report, how do you report.
[0:42:47] If you take a look at past budget documents, you would see that they were lots of line items,
[0:42:51] and you would ask, what are we getting for those services, and what does that look like
[0:42:55] to our taxpayers and what is the rate and what is the cost and you really have to dig
[0:43:00] through the numbers to understand the numbers.
[0:43:03] What we're trying to do is to make sure that everybody who wants to have knowledge about
[0:43:09] how this government spends money has access and the ability to understand it.
[0:43:15] And I don't know if that answers the question, but really what we're trying to do is present
[0:43:19] financial information that can be complex, that can be difficult to understand, that can
[0:43:23] be laid with rules in a manner that everybody has a clear understanding of how their tax
[0:43:30] dollars and their utility rates are being allocated for the public purpose.
[0:43:37] Thank you, Travis.
[0:43:38] Greg Lanting.
[0:43:39] Can I have a comment coming from another public agency where I prepared a budget for my middle
[0:43:46] school and the transparency and the time we spend on making sure each and every one of
[0:43:55] us understand that I think that's the reason and the public as well understand
[0:43:59] where we're going and where we're coming because I came from the school setting
[0:44:01] where you didn't know most of your budget until the legislature got done and
[0:44:07] then you had to have it done basically by the time school got out. So you had
[0:44:11] about a month to say to figure out what you were going to spend what you were
[0:44:15] going to spend it on and then of course towards the end they just didn't give
[0:44:17] us any so it made it pretty easy but the legislature I mean and then I'm
[0:44:22] I'm never sure how we ever figured out
[0:44:24] what property taxes we're gonna have
[0:44:25] because we had to decide that by July 1st
[0:44:28] and we don't even know until August usually
[0:44:31] where we're at with property taxes.
[0:44:33] So I agree that our process, not only in transparency part
[0:44:39] because we didn't have time to have the public involved.
[0:44:41] We truly didn't.
[0:44:43] And to the process that we follow here
[0:44:45] where we started early in the year
[0:44:49] And sometimes it gets, as Sean said, the one time,
[0:44:53] do you want us to repeat this portion of it?
[0:44:55] Because we pretty much have it memorized parts of it
[0:44:58] by the time we get to the actual public hearing.
[0:45:01] And then we have a public hearing every night,
[0:45:03] ever that we talk about the budget.
[0:45:05] And I can't see how it could be any more transparent
[0:45:08] or our attempts to involve the public are far past
[0:45:14] what the schools have the ability to.
[0:45:17] part of the mic. Thank you, Travis.
[0:45:20] Well, I would just say to Laurie and Brent and Shane, and all of your team, and all of
[0:45:25] the folks on the city staff, and I think the efforts of the Council in waiting through all
[0:45:30] of that too, and getting up to speed on that, I think it is definitely a service to our community
[0:45:35] to make sure that we are being stewards of the public trust and the public resources.
[0:45:40] So congratulations, well-deserved.
[0:45:46] Next we have an update on the city hall public safety complex design process and a construction
[0:45:51] update.
[0:45:54] You're not mentioned humble.
[0:45:56] You're busy tonight.
[0:45:57] We have our deputy city manager Brian Pike.
[0:46:01] Thank you, mayor and members of the council.
[0:46:02] Tonight I'm playing a series of roles.
[0:46:04] I was traveling earlier on Mitch right now and just in a little bit I'll be myself under
[0:46:09] item five.
[0:46:10] And really speaking of these two items, with the council's approval, as we move forward,
[0:46:15] like to actually present both these items together. They really run together and we've
[0:46:20] got a fantastic team here and Clint Seavers from Hull and Michael Arrington from Star so
[0:46:25] I think I'll turn it over to them. So just for the record then say we're going to take
[0:46:30] the update on the City Hall and Public Safety Complex design process and construction update
[0:46:34] and roll that in with the ultimate action of request by Star Corporation to present a proposed
[0:46:41] guaranteed maximum price for the public safety campus project.
[0:47:25] Taking just a moment to get the technology up and running if you're watching online and
[0:47:30] wondering what we're doing sitting here.
[0:47:34] Mr. Mayor, remember the City Council, thanks for having us tonight.
[0:47:38] I'm going to give you a little update on your projects tonight, the new City Hall project
[0:47:43] and the public safety as well.
[0:47:45] More so on the public safety side with regard to the GMP and moving forward into construction,
[0:47:50] but I wanted to give you some updated information on City Hall as well since we're here.
[0:47:56] So I'll move forward with that and I'll ask Michael to just jump in and if you have any
[0:48:05] questions regarding the City Hall the way we'll go through this as the City Hall first
[0:48:09] and then the public safety side of it second and then end with action on the GMP.
[0:48:14] But if you do have any questions on City Hall the budget Michael can step up and answer
[0:48:20] those.
[0:48:21] As far as design goes with regard to the city hall,
[0:48:25] as you know, we've gotten farther in the process.
[0:48:29] The designs kind of settled down. Last time we were here, we showed you the
[0:48:33] extra renderings and how they've evolved materials and those types of things.
[0:48:37] The floor plans have adjusted a little bit.
[0:48:41] And if I can get this to me.
[0:48:46] Really what we've focused on is the evolution of the floor plan
[0:49:08] plan and the workflow with the different departments in that floor plan.
[0:49:13] It's, as you know, from programming all the way through construction, it's quite a process
[0:49:17] and things change from time to time.
[0:49:19] So we like to keep track of that and continue the conversations with staff and the departments
[0:49:26] and the city leadership to understand how they work, how it's evolving, how they're growing
[0:49:31] even as we're designing.
[0:49:32] And part of that is the furniture involved.
[0:49:36] We've done some really extensive work on how the furniture actually fits within the spaces.
[0:49:43] So what you see in front is the first floor plan of City Hall and one of those spaces
[0:49:47] being utility billing is in this part of the floor plan.
[0:49:54] You can see the L-shaped desks laid out here.
[0:49:57] You can see some front counter space to meet the public as they came up to utility billing.
[0:50:04] stations as well as it's really more evident on the second third floor where
[0:50:09] there's more staff but on the second floor you can see really a lot of work
[0:50:14] stations and both for present and for a little bit of growth on this side of the
[0:50:20] floor plan as well as the back and the offices and on this site but through
[0:50:25] programming we built that book if you remember that's an inch or two thick of
[0:50:29] of all this data of, you know, how much storage do people need,
[0:50:33] how much desk space do they need, and then we kind of shelf that as we work
[0:50:37] through the building and the code and the envelope and the rest of the bigger picture items.
[0:50:43] And now we've kind of come back to re-absorb what that means and make sure it's still relevant.
[0:50:48] And so, the same goes for the third floor, where there was probably the most change
[0:50:54] and the staff and the departments on the third floor really had a pretty collaborative
[0:51:00] work environment to begin with, but they took it to the next level and evolved to more of an open office.
[0:51:07] So what you'll see is really this large area, third of the floor plan is just all open office space.
[0:51:16] What that did is it made our mechanical systems a little more efficient.
[0:51:20] It was a little bit less in the way of construction, but I think it really created a cohesive work environment
[0:51:27] for finance HR administration in this regard.
[0:51:32] And so you'll see the consistent lobby, restrooms,
[0:51:35] elevators, stairs that we've had in the past.
[0:51:38] But simply within those departments,
[0:51:40] the barriers kind of came down.
[0:51:42] And now they're going to function as more big open space.
[0:51:45] Certainly comes with its challenges.
[0:51:47] What we've done is we've mitigated those
[0:51:50] by adding a few smaller conference rooms.
[0:51:53] People, when they need a little bit more privacy,
[0:51:56] They can go use those rooms or if they need to meet with two, four, six people.
[0:52:00] There's rooms available for that.
[0:52:02] And so you'll see those throughout the floor plan.
[0:52:05] In this area, there's a couple here.
[0:52:08] There's a little phone room here.
[0:52:10] And then, of course, our large conference capabilities,
[0:52:13] the executive conference room,
[0:52:15] those other larger conference rooms are still there.
[0:52:17] So same goes for high S. They're up in this corner furniture systems.
[0:52:26] they've already got some of those you've seen on the electric desks that go up and
[0:52:30] down so we'll probably relocate those into this space but also add to as they
[0:52:36] need for their staff and then the other thing I'd add is just the growth shell
[0:52:42] space that's continued to stay there so I think that's really a good a good
[0:52:47] thing that you'll have eight to ten thousand square feet in this building that
[0:52:50] you can still grow into in the future so what I wanted to show you from design
[0:52:55] perspective is just, I'll go through.
[0:52:58] Can I ask a question on City Hall?
[0:53:00] Yeah, you bet.
[0:53:01] I hope we are still planning to take advantage of
[0:53:06] advanced technologies for inter-office communications.
[0:53:09] I think I mentioned publicly before investigate
[0:53:13] LIFI so we minimize any hard-wiring.
[0:53:16] This might not fit in quite here, but I hope that we're not
[0:53:21] constructing any impermeable walls that would not allow us to
[0:53:24] us to take advantage of that high technology.
[0:53:28] Yeah, we have kept that a priority specifically, too,
[0:53:31] like when you mentioned the public and the council chambers,
[0:53:34] and with regard to that technology and the systems,
[0:53:37] the approach we've taken there, not
[0:53:39] unlike the conference rooms or other workspaces,
[0:53:42] we know it's going to change whatever we designed for today
[0:53:45] is going to change.
[0:53:46] So keeping that flexible and designing
[0:53:49] con duets or permanent structure that's
[0:53:53] going to prohibit you later, we're trying not to do that.
[0:53:56] So yes, that's still a pressure line.
[0:53:57] Thanks, plan.
[0:53:58] For sure.
[0:54:01] So I wanted to run through the floor plans,
[0:54:03] and then I'll show you some furniture
[0:54:04] that the city's actually going to demo.
[0:54:07] The police operations building really hasn't changed.
[0:54:10] You'll notice this is the existing plan on the left
[0:54:13] that we presented last time.
[0:54:15] The plan on the right-hand side is the newer floor plan,
[0:54:17] and really, really has stayed the same since the last time
[0:54:22] we presented it to you.
[0:54:27] The administration has changed, so if you'll remember the plans in the past, we had some
[0:54:33] center corridors similar to the way the building was previously, and then offices on the sides.
[0:54:38] We did have a little bit of open office area, but the folks in the police department have come
[0:54:44] back and said, you know, we're buying into this too.
[0:54:47] We'd really like to see this open office workspace.
[0:54:51] So it doesn't come without its offices.
[0:54:53] certain specialties as in narcotics and child crimes, officers, those types of
[0:54:59] uses that still need a room. But this is the basement level in the building and
[0:55:06] if you've been over there you can see really how that's opened up and how much
[0:55:09] daylight floods that basement. It's really pretty cool. But the way they're
[0:55:14] going to organize is through furniture systems have all the detectives out in
[0:55:19] in this open area, and then the existing concrete columns
[0:55:23] would fall down in between.
[0:55:25] So something that's different from what
[0:55:28] we showed you last time.
[0:55:30] The main level where the public enters
[0:55:32] and where records exist in the interview
[0:55:35] uses really pretty much stays the same.
[0:55:39] The records department in the past
[0:55:42] had always been a pretty open environmental furniture systems.
[0:55:45] That's going to remain the same.
[0:55:49] And then on the upper level, Lieutenant's offices,
[0:55:53] sergeants, they elected to go the same route.
[0:55:57] So you'll see the columns you can kind of see in here.
[0:56:01] But these walls will all go away,
[0:56:03] and we'll come in for an extra systems
[0:56:05] and just be really open day-lit space.
[0:56:09] We have kept conference rooms, work rooms,
[0:56:13] restrooms, break, that kind of thing.
[0:56:14] Obviously all enclosed and private,
[0:56:18] as well as the chief's office up in this corner.
[0:56:21] I can't do it.
[0:56:24] So any questions on PD?
[0:56:27] Done all.
[0:56:28] So I talked to Travis about this,
[0:56:30] and I don't know if it's visited with you folks,
[0:56:33] but that section that it used to be the old billing,
[0:56:38] and so you've got the two sections here,
[0:56:41] then this section over here.
[0:56:44] OK, that's just the one floor.
[0:56:47] I was looking at that, and I mentioned it, Travis,
[0:56:49] and I don't know, maybe to Michael.
[0:56:52] Is there a way that we can shore that part of,
[0:56:55] since it's all gutted out now,
[0:56:56] shore that part up that we could put a second floor
[0:57:00] to that someday, or is that a dumb idea,
[0:57:02] or is that, I mean, square feet is always needed.
[0:57:07] We'll need more, probably when we move in.
[0:57:09] So, if you know what I'm talking about, they...
[0:57:11] I don't know if we've probably
[0:57:13] had the best answer that has to be the team.
[0:57:14] Okay.
[0:57:15] We absolutely could.
[0:57:17] We're not budgeted for that currently, and haven't fully studied that, but it's certainly possible.
[0:57:26] Yeah, I just asked the question before to see if that's a possibility, what it would cost.
[0:57:32] Again, since it's all gutted and opened up, if you're ever going to do that, now is the time to do it, correct?
[0:57:40] That is correct.
[0:57:41] And that looks like, to me, to be 3,000 square feet that we could add to a 3,000 square foot.
[0:57:48] But maybe it's cost prohibitive.
[0:57:49] I don't know.
[0:57:51] Well, it's cost prohibitive in that we've not budgeted for that throughout this time.
[0:57:57] We would certainly gain the square footage, but we need to find a way to pay for that
[0:58:03] now.
[0:58:04] We'd also some of the other ramifications of that as we tap the brakes on the project
[0:58:09] in order to get that sort of out,
[0:58:12] saying that that's the wrong thing to do,
[0:58:14] but we would need to give you a number that was accurate.
[0:58:22] We'd need to do some more studying on that, but it's definitely-
[0:58:25] Well, and again, I don't want to put anything
[0:58:27] in the way of our progress.
[0:58:28] That's why I asked a couple weeks ago about this,
[0:58:30] and I do know that when they built the original
[0:58:35] original police department, we were told that we were going to be able to build another floor some day and then later on they went in there and said that it wasn't structurally built to do another floor, which was too bad because that would have saved, that would have really helped with this whole process anyway if we could have put another floor on the main building.
[0:58:55] So I'm just asking the question.
[0:58:57] That's one of the troubles with making a plant, designing a structure to potentially handle that upgrade someday.
[0:59:05] When someday comes, often the way that we analyze things have changed enough that we're no longer able to take full advantage of that future planning.
[0:59:17] But in order to gain that, it would be several hundred thousand dollars in order to do that work.
[0:59:26] sure the ceiling up and to add that into a well I wasn't
[0:59:31] saying to put the second floor on right now it's just a question
[0:59:33] again I'm just kind of throwing a monkey here and I don't mean to
[0:59:38] do that that's why I asked a couple weeks ago. No no I sure
[0:59:41] understand that. I guess that would be my thought is that if we
[0:59:45] were to go in and do that now with the possibility of doing
[0:59:49] that in the future there there's a high likelihood that when we
[0:59:53] get to set future date, whatever it is that we did may not work, depending on how the building
[1:00:02] was analyzed at that time, do you think that's the same?
[1:00:05] I can do that.
[1:00:06] You know, we've got that question in the past with other types of projects in older buildings.
[1:00:12] Oftentimes what we've found is when we study that, is that the square foot cost for that
[1:00:17] construction like that becomes so high that it's burdensome and it's actually better or
[1:00:22] more efficient to go elsewhere and expand.
[1:00:26] Given that block, as you know, and I know that's why you're asking the question, it's
[1:00:30] tight as it is. We've actually, when we did the program, we
[1:00:34] explored a couple of options for expansion that
[1:00:39] could help you in the future. We didn't have any costs associated, we really
[1:00:43] didn't have a program to go with it, but what we did is we studied
[1:00:47] the parking lot, what could fit if it was a potential garage someday
[1:00:51] with an addition of the ops building, I think cost per square foot for your building, you'll
[1:00:58] get more out of it that way than if you're to go up over existing. Okay. Thank you. So any other
[1:01:12] questions on floor plans or design or any of that? I just have a few slides here. I wanted to show
[1:01:18] you where the city's working with and Humboldt's working with a company out of Boise to design and
[1:01:28] to supply your furniture systems for all projects.
[1:01:33] So what they've been willing to do is we've gone through some tours.
[1:01:38] We've had a lot of staff involved, Mandy Thompson with Travis's offices, worked closely with
[1:01:44] the interior designer at Hummel, understanding what the needs are and aligning with that program
[1:01:49] book that I spoke of.
[1:01:52] And they've actually modeled, this is a 3D-generated model of the furniture systems that they're
[1:01:57] willing to demo for the city for a amount of time so that the staff can use it, understand
[1:02:02] what they like, what they don't like, how much is this, how much would this option be.
[1:02:07] And then as we complete these construction projects, we can order furniture that fits the
[1:02:11] need, you know, and then the budget and install.
[1:02:15] So just to give you a little bit of explanation of what this is, their typical modules, they
[1:02:22] can come on different sizes.
[1:02:24] A couple of the options are going to be these desks.
[1:02:26] We'll have some that are electric that can go up or down.
[1:02:30] As you can imagine, that stuff gets expensive.
[1:02:32] So we'll have to understand how that fits in with the budget
[1:02:35] and maybe who needs them now or who could get one
[1:02:37] in the future, that kind of thing.
[1:02:40] Some other options, the divider storage systems here,
[1:02:45] bookshelves, people's concerns with lower open office
[1:02:49] environments are acoustics, making sure they can have a phone call, not interrupt somebody
[1:02:55] doing work on the other side of the fence kind of thing.
[1:02:58] And so these are really time tested types of systems that have acoustic partitions in between
[1:03:05] and then these storage systems that actually act as acoustic dividers as well.
[1:03:11] They have a ton of all of that, as you can imagine, the one we're showing right now has
[1:03:15] an accent color.
[1:03:16] So Jennifer, our interior designer, is working with the finishes, carpets, tiles, all that
[1:03:21] kind of stuff and how we can tie in with these furniture systems.
[1:03:24] So it's all cohesive.
[1:03:26] There's also options with this to do glass panels on top instead of fabric.
[1:03:32] So if we need to go there, people like that versus the solid panel, we can do that as well.
[1:03:38] But I wanted to just show you a couple of the options and explain the exercise we're
[1:03:42] going to.
[1:03:43] there a couple of lights here. Great landing. Yes. Back on the furniture and
[1:03:48] also actually the actually the design of the office as well. Yeah. And you mentioned
[1:03:53] that you have an interior designer. Do they? I reason I'm bringing this up. I
[1:03:59] happened to have a conversation with a former classmate college that is that
[1:04:07] is her occupation now. She does it for the federal government. She designs the
[1:04:11] office space and decides what office equipment goes in there and I just wanted
[1:04:16] to make advantage of that same type of a thing or we do we have an interior
[1:04:23] designer at Humboldt that's an employee of Humboldt that's part of what we do
[1:04:27] regarding the furniture typically what we do is we work with vendors that are
[1:04:31] local and there's a state contracts list where all of the furniture is bid
[1:04:36] publicly and all the numbers are known and competitive so as an agency the city
[1:04:41] knows they're getting the best bang for their buck in that regard, but they'll often provide
[1:04:46] free services for us to help plan.
[1:04:48] And so, business interiors of Idaho is the one we're working with here.
[1:04:53] We took staff and ourselves and we watched some of their projects, some of their competitions
[1:04:59] projects, and then the lines that they represent more aligned with the budget that we have and
[1:05:09] the quality we're going for.
[1:05:10] So that's why we elected to work with them.
[1:05:13] And so they're just doing this free service.
[1:05:15] They're planning the furniture for us,
[1:05:16] and then we can drop those into our floor plans.
[1:05:19] All right, good work.
[1:05:20] So yeah, it's a similar thing.
[1:05:22] Thank you.
[1:05:23] Chris Stockington.
[1:05:25] Another silly question or two, Clint.
[1:05:27] With this open architecture, sound migration
[1:05:31] can potentially be a real issue.
[1:05:33] I've seen a number of open architectures
[1:05:36] where they've had directional fit sound of the sort of material
[1:05:40] to get the DB meter from pegging, are we fairly confident
[1:05:46] with this carpeting?
[1:05:48] And you mentioned glass panels are carpeting the week.
[1:05:51] We have a standard we're going for sound isolation.
[1:05:55] I don't know what the correct term is,
[1:05:56] but you know the concept I'm talking about.
[1:05:58] Yep, I get it.
[1:06:01] We are.
[1:06:01] We're pretty careful with that.
[1:06:03] I've had a number of projects where
[1:06:04] we've had value engineer items come up
[1:06:08] and you regret it later because now you have an acoustic issue, right?
[1:06:12] So we're very aware of that.
[1:06:15] We have an acoustic engineer that we typically involve in projects like this.
[1:06:20] And he's very good at giving professional opinion.
[1:06:25] I can like the council chambers, for example,
[1:06:28] I've given him some information and said the walls are going to be this flooring.
[1:06:32] We're going to do carpet.
[1:06:34] We're going to have a few acoustic panels on the walls and the ceiling.
[1:06:38] What is that going to do to us?
[1:06:39] What's our reverb times like?
[1:06:41] And he'll say, yeah, that's going to work.
[1:06:43] Or, no, you better be careful about that.
[1:06:45] So we are being careful with it.
[1:06:48] We're selecting carpets for a lot of the work spaces.
[1:06:50] By the time you get bodies and carpet
[1:06:53] and some sort of absorbing panels and ceilings,
[1:06:59] you've really did what you need to do
[1:07:01] for those work environments.
[1:07:03] Now is the time to worry about that.
[1:07:05] Exactly.
[1:07:11] I'm sorry I just have a couple other shots here and then we'll go into schedule and this
[1:07:17] is just another option.
[1:07:22] So regarding schedule for the City Hall, and this kind of goes hand in hand with the public
[1:07:28] safety as well, if you'll remember we started bidding in public safety, what was it a couple
[1:07:34] months ago, and the bid market was such that we were getting some high numbers on half the
[1:07:40] bids and we got really good numbers on the other half and so we awarded half of those
[1:07:44] and then we went out to re-bid and Michael talked about those in a minute, but what that
[1:07:49] told us is that the timing of the market maybe was pretty busy and maybe we had to rethink
[1:07:56] about the schedule and how that helps us from a bid standpoint.
[1:08:01] So you'll see, originally, I wanted to pull up the schedule on the bottom of the slide just
[1:08:06] to show you what we showed you last time and our intent was to start construction bidding
[1:08:11] being in August, September, and start construction September, October.
[1:08:15] So now we've kind of slid a little bit, and I think you'll see here in a minute with our
[1:08:19] Re-Bid numbers that it's helped us to get out of the summer season and to the fall.
[1:08:25] So that's what that says.
[1:08:28] Our intent with construction documents on City Hall is to finish up by the end of September.
[1:08:33] So you'll see we're pretty close now, and we're getting ready to bid in October.
[1:08:38] So that's going to be really exciting and telling if we have a good bid market.
[1:08:45] Construction would then go from November through November of next year.
[1:08:48] So the moving kind of slid a little bit, but that's a 12-month approach with the construction
[1:08:55] schedule.
[1:08:56] If there's any time we can make up, I think Michael would say we would, but that's just a
[1:09:01] forecast for right now.
[1:09:05] For the public safety campus, some of you probably seen,
[1:09:08] we've got the demo underway on the admin building.
[1:09:11] So it's the first half of the bid packages
[1:09:14] are under contract in the works.
[1:09:17] The bidding's complete now, and you'll
[1:09:19] see a GMP, which is our maximum price.
[1:09:22] The star will present in a minute.
[1:09:25] And then the completion will phase through fall of next year.
[1:09:29] So we had presented to you earlier kind of an August
[1:09:33] to December construction for the admin building,
[1:09:37] and then January, February to August
[1:09:41] for the operations building.
[1:09:42] That would then follow the same slide
[1:09:44] that the city halls take.
[1:09:46] And I know we may be able to finish faster
[1:09:48] because we've started faster,
[1:09:49] but it'll follow that same kind of lag.
[1:09:54] So any questions on schedule
[1:09:56] and how things have evolved?
[1:10:05] So this says, can everybody read this, okay?
[1:10:09] This is the spreadsheet, similar format to what I showed you earlier this spring.
[1:10:16] And what this indicates is a couple of things.
[1:10:20] The highlighted column on the right is fall of 16.
[1:10:23] These are our more current numbers.
[1:10:25] So you can see, you know, how we've tracked this.
[1:10:27] We've used the same format from the fall of 14 where we hadn't done programming
[1:10:32] to when we did programming and then we got some numbers and was higher than we expected.
[1:10:37] So we backed off and reprogram some spaces.
[1:10:41] What could we absolutely live with and put the wands aside
[1:10:46] for another day?
[1:10:48] And then the spring of this year, as we started to finish,
[1:10:52] these were the updated star estimates
[1:10:54] as the spring of this year.
[1:10:57] The top number you see on the far right call,
[1:10:59] and this is an updated estimate for City Hall.
[1:11:04] And if you follow this down, really, where I like to go,
[1:11:08] is down along this line on the bottom, it's close to the bottom I guess it's the 9.934.
[1:11:18] So what that includes is it includes the estimate for the city hall today and remember
[1:11:22] that's an estimate we're not really going to know what those dollars are until we bid
[1:11:26] and know those numbers for real.
[1:11:28] It includes the 3.6 number and this is indicative of the GMP number that Michael's going to present
[1:11:37] to you in a minute, but you'll see the only difference
[1:11:40] is we pulled the contingency item down below.
[1:11:44] So if you look, if you remember this number,
[1:11:45] it's not gonna match one for one with what Michael gives you,
[1:11:48] but just know it's that plus the contingency
[1:11:51] is what Michael's gonna tell you.
[1:11:53] So that's the real number for public safety.
[1:11:56] You'll see the total 9.684 as it aligned
[1:12:00] to the nine and a half in the spring.
[1:12:04] Same impact fees here.
[1:12:07] And then the contingency came down.
[1:12:09] So one thing we do as we progress through the whole design
[1:12:15] and construction processes, as STAR knows more information,
[1:12:19] the gray area or the contingency can get further
[1:12:23] and further neck down.
[1:12:24] And so that's what's happened.
[1:12:25] So it helps the overall budget in the end.
[1:12:31] But including the contingency, what we told you last time
[1:12:34] was this 9.9 number, 9.975.
[1:12:38] Today we're at about 9.934, including the contingency.
[1:12:41] So we're feeling like things are going to come down
[1:12:44] and they're getting better.
[1:12:45] We've worked really hard to stay at that or under.
[1:12:49] So that total number has come down a little bit.
[1:12:54] We have one item that's new to us about a month ago.
[1:12:59] Some seismic upgrades that we were not aware of that
[1:13:01] have come to fruition.
[1:13:03] So a little history on that.
[1:13:07] A year or so ago, when we were doing the initial planning,
[1:13:10] we hadn't allowance in the project
[1:13:12] for seismic upgrades from the banner.
[1:13:17] We hired our structural engineer that's
[1:13:19] been working with us on the project.
[1:13:22] This spring, I guess, when we started getting further
[1:13:25] detailed with the estimate, we requested professional opinions
[1:13:29] from them about the structure, about the seismic,
[1:13:31] whether it meets code and what we have to add or shore up with the building.
[1:13:37] Long story short, about a month ago they came back and said we've done our final calculations
[1:13:44] and we need to add significant steel to the columns and beams.
[1:13:48] So this is an item that's the 228 that you see down here
[1:13:52] that kind of caught us all by surprise. It's something that we have to do to meet code.
[1:13:58] but from a diligence perspective I don't think we're done there yet so we're
[1:14:03] continuing to work with the engineer we're continuing to work on what the code
[1:14:08] is interpreted as what is the most cost effective way to solve that and maybe we
[1:14:15] can use some design elements to take up you know some of the seismic racing and
[1:14:21] share costs that way. So not great news, but kind of is what it is and we're still working
[1:14:30] on that piece of it. Thank you, Clint. Chris Stockington. Glad to help me understand
[1:14:35] how we can, it looks like almost arbitrarily reduce our recommended contingency from 475.
[1:14:42] What is it? 249? Yeah, really it's, isn't that figured on a percentage of project? 5% to 3%
[1:14:49] is really where that came down.
[1:14:52] Well, how can we just to reduce it?
[1:14:56] I can try to ask.
[1:14:58] So I can answer that question because I asked the same question.
[1:15:03] So what was shared with me is that when you're getting into the beginning of the project,
[1:15:08] there are an entire host of unknowns.
[1:15:10] And the more unknowns you have, you start with a larger contingency.
[1:15:14] And as they've kind of gone through not only the exposing of the buildings
[1:15:18] buildings and the beams and the structures, they are now more certain with what they're
[1:15:23] dealing with.
[1:15:24] And so the amount of uncertainty is going down and therefore the amount of contingency
[1:15:30] that they feel that they need for the project is diminishing at that same rate.
[1:15:37] So earlier we could not have reduced it to that 3% without going through this process
[1:15:43] and refining that.
[1:15:44] That's right.
[1:15:45] When they set the contingencies, you have remember that it was prior to any form of demolition,
[1:15:52] and now that they've exposed the structures, they have a better understanding, and they're
[1:15:56] much more comfortable with not only the bidding environment, but also the structures that they're
[1:16:01] working to be able to move forward with.
[1:16:03] I just don't want the thing to bump up to 5 percent, and again, that's not going to happen,
[1:16:09] right?
[1:16:10] That's called the handle up to him.
[1:16:15] He has answered.
[1:16:16] Does that answer your question?
[1:16:22] Yeah, but I don't want that to be 5% contingency at the very end if we're just sure of ourselves, it should be a one-way process to lowering that.
[1:16:32] That's actually a good segue into the GMP.
[1:16:36] Unless any other further questions on this slide, Michael, would go into more detail on the public safety side of the GMP.
[1:16:46] Thank you, Clint.
[1:16:47] So, when we were here about two months ago, we presented a similar spreadsheet that only
[1:17:19] addressed certain packages to get us started on the demolition and certain packages on the
[1:17:25] public safety campus.
[1:17:27] As Clint mentioned, those are underway.
[1:17:29] The demolition is pretty well done and many of the packages, submittal work has started
[1:17:35] on them and equipment and things have begun to be procured.
[1:17:39] So tonight we come back with the other part of that story.
[1:17:41] I've highlighted the ones in yellow that we're presenting tonight.
[1:17:45] The ones that are not highlighted, such as selective demolition or masonry, are ones
[1:17:50] that were addressed at the GMP that we talked about back in July or early August perhaps.
[1:17:57] So we have good news to report tonight.
[1:18:00] of these packages that we rebid either came in under where they were last time. One of
[1:18:11] the exceptions to that is rough carpentry. We expected that to happen because of the strategy
[1:18:15] that we switched to with the way that we framed the inside of the building. The market between
[1:18:22] steel and wood studs varies a bit and that's market driven based on materials as well as
[1:18:30] contractors that are available to perform the work.
[1:18:34] Currently, wood studs for partition walls is a little less
[1:18:39] expensive.
[1:18:40] And so when we re-bid this, we acknowledge that and
[1:18:44] re-bid this as wood studs in lieu of metal studs.
[1:18:48] So that is one of the items that went up, but we expected it
[1:18:51] to.
[1:18:54] The effect that we see there, the positive effect that we're
[1:18:56] looking for, shows up in the package number 13, where the
[1:19:00] the metal studs were before that number came down significantly.
[1:19:05] Electrical came down quite a bit.
[1:19:07] Like I said, all of the ones that were highlighted
[1:19:09] came down quite a bit.
[1:19:10] There are two packages that we are listing as allowances.
[1:19:15] The major one there is aluminum store front.
[1:19:17] Those are your windows.
[1:19:19] And we still only got one bid on that.
[1:19:22] We're after surveying the market,
[1:19:24] we're confident that we can get at least two bids on that
[1:19:27] to make that a little more competitive.
[1:19:29] And so we have placed an allowance of $80,000 in there.
[1:19:34] I would move forward and would re-bid that package
[1:19:37] to make sure that we get good competition
[1:19:39] on that particular item.
[1:19:42] Some of the general conditions items below that
[1:19:45] have also been adjusted down a little bit
[1:19:47] as we take a final look at them.
[1:19:49] They've been adjusted down a little bit
[1:19:50] based on the guaranteed maximum price
[1:19:53] that you saw earlier at the 1.7 level.
[1:19:58] this to circle back and talk and speak to Chris's question about contingency.
[1:20:05] There's $96,000 in change listed there as a contingency.
[1:20:09] That's calculated on 3%, and would lock this portion of the project in at a 3% contingency
[1:20:16] that would be part of our GNP there as well.
[1:20:19] Pretty standard practice for us to carry about that much, and there's no intention or history
[1:20:26] of going back and suggesting more than that with this level of drawings so you
[1:20:31] wouldn't see that from us in the future when we come back to present on this for
[1:20:35] the city hall. So this evening the figure that you see at the bottom of 3.49
[1:20:45] million dollars would be the guaranteed maximum price for both projects combined
[1:20:52] not in addition to the one seven that you'd already authorized the one seven
[1:20:56] would actually be part of this. So that GMP would be amended to take into account
[1:21:01] these work packages to bring it up to three four, not three four plus one seven.
[1:21:07] Any questions for Michael? Don Hall? No surprises on seismic upgrades for the
[1:21:24] police buildings. No. We're confident? We are confident. Yes. That has been exposed
[1:21:34] those now, the drawings are in. We have a building permit. We have a building permit and we're
[1:21:41] ready to go.
[1:21:45] Any other questions? I don't see anything else from you, gentlemen. So, will Brian come
[1:21:56] up and tell us what action is suggesting?
[1:22:00] Well, and I just kind of go back a little bit. I do apologize. We worked really hard
[1:22:06] really this week to get this information out and we were really working under a timeline.
[1:22:10] We lost Leila really on, and so it limited our ability to get information into your hands.
[1:22:15] So I know you're feeling like maybe you're flying a little bit blind, and I apologize for
[1:22:19] that.
[1:22:21] The staff would ask that you would, the council would approve the STARS Guaranteed Maximum Price
[1:22:27] for the project.
[1:22:28] Understanding this includes both projects together.
[1:22:31] We're not talking about this in addition to anything else for a total of 3,449,492.
[1:22:39] $93 for the total project to maybe put this in perspective.
[1:22:47] This puts us at about a $3,000 difference in the total cost of what we thought we would
[1:22:55] be.
[1:22:56] And really, the credit goes back to Michael, Jason, to Clint and Brian for really working
[1:23:01] on this.
[1:23:02] This was when we started back with the first series of bids, we were a little bit spooked
[1:23:06] about how all this would come together.
[1:23:08] And I know between Starr and Hummel, they worked really hard to work on these numbers, to work
[1:23:13] with their partners, and to get us at a price that we could live with them in the $3.4 million
[1:23:20] project.
[1:23:21] If we're over by $3,000, I think the team did an incredible job.
[1:23:27] So that's the staff recommendation.
[1:23:29] We would stand for any more questions if you happen.
[1:23:32] Travis?
[1:23:34] I just want to add maybe just kind of refresh the memory of not only the council, but maybe
[1:23:38] also with the audience. This is a project that we've been going forward with for a
[1:23:43] while and so we use terms like GMP. GMP is a guaranteed maximum price and so what
[1:23:50] we're asking the council to do on this project today is to prove a guaranteed
[1:23:59] maximum price and when we started the very beginning of the CMGC process which
[1:24:05] which allows us to build a partner into that process as opposed to going out for a sealed
[1:24:10] bid project.
[1:24:11] I think that Brian really talked about that benefit in the beginning.
[1:24:15] But one of the benefits to the city is we work in partnership and what that does is that
[1:24:19] minimizes the amount of risk not only to the city, but also the amount of risk that would
[1:24:24] be to the general contractor.
[1:24:26] And so risk moving forward really does fall on stars and shoulders.
[1:24:32] And what they are saying is based upon what we know, we are going to deliver a package that
[1:24:38] has been designed at a price not to exceed, you know, the guaranteed maximum price.
[1:24:46] Unless we elect to come in and say, you know what, we found something and then at that point
[1:24:51] in time the council always reserves that right to modify that upward moving forward.
[1:24:59] We think that the partnership has really exhibited itself, especially in that re-bid
[1:25:04] atmosphere that we went forward with.
[1:25:07] And really I don't think it can be overstated the amount of work that Star did to bring this
[1:25:12] project to where it's at today.
[1:25:14] Now if there are savings that they realize along the way, the beauty of the project
[1:25:21] is those savings then are also passed on to the city.
[1:25:24] So you're not where you normally get a bid and a bid project and you pay a lump sum fee.
[1:25:31] We're a partner in this, in the fact that should there be cost savings, especially in the areas where you'll see project manager, project superintendent.
[1:25:41] If there are fewer hours that are spent on the job that what's anticipated,
[1:25:46] the city is the direct beneficiary of those savings as well.
[1:25:52] Thank you, Travis.
[1:25:53] Chris Stockington.
[1:25:54] Well, it's kind of hand holding time because although I greatly respect the confidence that you've shown here to four,
[1:26:03] this is a big thing to swallow. We have to do it at some time, but I guess I'm just speaking on my own part.
[1:26:12] I've got to have some updates on a regular basis on line items to know over and under.
[1:26:20] I don't want to be surprised at the end, either positively or negatively.
[1:26:24] I want to walk this baby through to completion, and one year is too long ago without regular
[1:26:30] updates.
[1:26:31] But other than that, I think it's appropriate that we've got to make the jump sometime, and
[1:26:37] it looks like it's ... How can I say it's a reasonable figure?
[1:26:46] So can we have assurance of regular council updates?
[1:26:50] Absolutely how when we can do that disfrequently as the council would like that if you'd like them not just on bottom line
[1:26:56] But specific to items listed
[1:26:59] so
[1:27:00] Monthly whatever the council would prefer. We're happy to provide those updates
[1:27:11] Give us four updates between now and the project between that or four and a half
[1:27:17] so
[1:27:19] quarterly on
[1:27:20] On like the public safety complex means that you would receive maybe one update those are going to be some pretty fast projects
[1:27:30] Might I suggest maybe monthly on
[1:27:34] on this public safety project so we can be over overly
[1:27:39] Communicating on those and then on the city hall project
[1:27:42] We can maybe start on a monthly and if we progress the quarterly towards the end we can go there as well. Does that work?
[1:27:51] Okay.
[1:27:56] Chris Stockington.
[1:27:57] Well, we're ready for a motion.
[1:27:58] I am ready for a motion.
[1:28:00] I would move to accept a request to start a corporation for the guaranteed maximum project
[1:28:09] price for the public safety campus project.
[1:28:14] Is this only the, this isn't the city hall, this is public safety, public safety in the
[1:28:20] amount not to exceed $3,449,493 American money.
[1:28:27] that motion by Chris Stockington seconded by Ruth Pierce to set the guaranteed
[1:28:33] maximum price for the public safety campus project three million four hundred
[1:28:37] forty nine thousand four hundred ninety three dollars any discussion I would just
[1:28:44] echo the comments that both Travis and Brian have made that I think this process
[1:28:50] of partnership has really helped us to keep this in check I think it shares the
[1:28:56] spirit of being frugal and responsible with the public's dollars and I appreciate all
[1:29:03] that Michael and your team and Clinton your team have done to help keep this
[1:29:07] in check there are a lot of unknowns it's very difficult to predict what's going
[1:29:11] to happen 12 months down the road 18 months ago so I think it's been a good
[1:29:17] process and appreciate your diligence and look forward to that continuing through
[1:29:21] through the rest of the projects as well.
[1:29:25] So with that, Sharon, roll call, vote please.
[1:29:28] Don Hall?
[1:29:29] Yes.
[1:29:30] Ruth Pierce? Yes.
[1:29:31] Suzanne Hawkins? Yes.
[1:29:33] Nikki Boyd? Yes.
[1:29:34] Sean Bericher? Yes.
[1:29:36] Chris Talkington? Yes.
[1:29:38] Greg Lanting? Yes.
[1:29:40] Motion passes seven to zero.
[1:29:42] Aye, gentlemen.
[1:29:47] Next on the agenda, we have another opportunity
[1:29:50] for public input.
[1:29:51] Is there anyone here from the public who wishes
[1:29:53] to address the council?
[1:29:57] Seeing no one, items from the city manager and city council.
[1:30:02] I'll do city council first, anybody have anything Chris talked to?
[1:30:07] Taking more than my sure time to talk, but I just want to congratulate the city and
[1:30:11] its contractors for the progress on the Eastland South.
[1:30:15] That's a first class reconstruction and it's such an important commerce route for
[1:30:21] us that look forward to its eventual completion all the way down.
[1:30:27] It's such an improvement now and I went through it there one time when we had some
[1:30:32] over in frequent rain and I don't think we're going to have any drainage problem
[1:30:35] under that road road crossing. And I went over that route I think every day for
[1:30:41] about seven years every work day and well some days yeah but it really looks
[1:30:46] nice to have you haven't been out there to see our concrete runway it's worth the
[1:30:51] trip. Anything else from council? Did you? Mr. Raspiler do you have any items for us?
[1:31:00] We will move now to public hearings.
[1:31:06] We do have a public hearing scheduled for this evening to amend the 2015-2016 budget.
[1:31:13] We have Shane Carpenter here to present that information to us.
[1:31:18] Welcome, Shane.
[1:31:20] Mr. Mayor, Council, this is a brief presentation on our budget amendment for this year.
[1:31:26] Everything on this list would have been presented sometime throughout the year from member city staff.
[1:31:32] So this is really just a summary of everything
[1:31:34] that we've done for the past year
[1:31:36] that wasn't included in the budget to start with.
[1:31:39] So the first one is the general fund.
[1:31:41] And this is actually from our audit from the end of 2015.
[1:31:45] It was excess reserves that we'd say
[1:31:47] that we took to the Capital Improvement Fund.
[1:31:51] The second one are police department repeaters,
[1:31:54] which is for the Com Center.
[1:31:57] And they use the E-91 reserves for those.
[1:31:59] Any question just interrupting when I'm going.
[1:32:03] The second was street fund was just a transfer to the CSI
[1:32:06] Student Safety Fund, which is the third one down.
[1:32:09] And that was for the Chaney Drive work that we did,
[1:32:12] that those were repairs and improvements that we did
[1:32:15] with the were not part of grant.
[1:32:18] And that project is almost done.
[1:32:20] We had a small little impact fee fund charge.
[1:32:25] We built an equipment storage shed.
[1:32:27] We'd budgeted 114,000 and it came in like 117.
[1:32:30] So that was a little bit of an increase there.
[1:32:33] And then in the Capital Improvement Fund,
[1:32:36] the big chunk were the fire department,
[1:32:38] the self-contained reading apparatus replacements
[1:32:40] that we got a grant for.
[1:32:42] So this is just adding those to the budget.
[1:32:46] We didn't put them in the budget until we reviewed the grants.
[1:32:48] Now we got the grant.
[1:32:52] The repeaters were from above from the Capital Improvement Fund,
[1:32:54] which were just transferred from the E-91 reserves.
[1:32:58] New cart pass on five and seven at Muni.
[1:33:02] The BDI boxes, I think Kathy was just here about a month ago
[1:33:05] to talk about replacing those with some new computers.
[1:33:10] The senior center word modeling, that was 100% funded
[1:33:14] by grant funds, so there was no cost to us.
[1:33:16] That was just us getting grant money and spending it
[1:33:19] on the senior center.
[1:33:21] And City Hall and Public Safety Complex,
[1:33:24] we spent about $852,000 this year on that.
[1:33:30] So that takes it to about a million and four.
[1:33:31] We spent so far in the last couple years on those projects.
[1:33:36] The airport construction, those are the small community
[1:33:39] grants, that's what we get every year.
[1:33:41] And this year, the grant was a little over $21,000.
[1:33:44] So that's going to be paid on advertising with Delta,
[1:33:47] pretty much.
[1:33:49] And then the AIP grants, those are just things
[1:33:51] that will be reimbursed, and we just
[1:33:54] haven't had the money come in yet.
[1:33:55] So it's not going to hit by the end of the year.
[1:33:57] So we've already spent the money.
[1:33:58] need to say that it's just a timing issue. The water fund, so these are the bond work
[1:34:05] that's been done. There's a lot of stuff. It's the rock re-cliff station, dewatering,
[1:34:11] wastewater treatment plant, all those things involved with that project out
[1:34:16] there in the bonds. Cliff fire improvements. This was some work we did at the
[1:34:20] J-code lift station for some of the expected growth that's going to come to happen out
[1:34:26] And then Caesar's in restitution, I think, Matt came to you guys asking for some reserves
[1:34:33] out of the Caesar's in restitution for a dog, the canine, and that's an additional training
[1:34:38] on that.
[1:34:39] So that's really what this is, just a summary of all those items that have been brought
[1:34:44] forward throughout the year.
[1:34:47] Thanks, Shane.
[1:34:48] Are there any questions for Mr. Carpenter?
[1:34:53] Seeing none, we will open the public hearing for the opportunity for anyone to give us
[1:34:58] input on this public hearing this evening. Is there anyone wishing to speak to the council
[1:35:03] on this item? Seeing no one, we will close the public hearing and turn it over to council
[1:35:10] for action. So my question is, Travis, is this an amendment to an existing ordinance? And
[1:35:15] do we need to do the suspension of the rules and all those things?
[1:35:18] Yeah, we will need you to suspend the rules. We ask then you consider the ordinance this
[1:35:24] evening. We'll have a number assigned to it and then we'll get that to the paper and
[1:35:28] I would like to publish it prior to the conclusion of this fiscal year.
[1:35:33] I would entertain a motion.
[1:35:35] We need the order to still with it.
[1:35:36] 2016-11.
[1:35:40] amended.
[1:35:43] 2016-11.
[1:35:44] Okay.
[1:35:46] 2016-11.
[1:35:48] Suzanne Hawkins.
[1:35:49] Thank you.
[1:35:50] So I would like to make a motion that we suspend the rules and put ordinance number 2016-11
[1:35:56] on third and final by title only.
[1:36:00] I would like to second that motion.
[1:36:02] Motion by Suzanne Hawkins, seconded by Greg Lanting to suspend the rules and
[1:36:05] place Ordinance 2016-11 on third and final reading by title only. Any discussion?
[1:36:11] Sharon, I'll call both please.
[1:36:15] Ruth Pierce.
[1:36:16] Yes.
[1:36:17] Suzanne Hawkins.
[1:36:18] Yes.
[1:36:19] Nikki Boyd.
[1:36:20] Yes.
[1:36:21] Sean Berricker.
[1:36:22] Yes.
[1:36:23] Chris Hockington.
[1:36:24] Yes.
[1:36:25] Greg Lanting.
[1:36:26] Yes.
[1:36:27] Don Hall.
[1:36:28] Yes.
[1:36:29] Motion passes 7-0.
[1:36:30] Sharon, would you read the title please?
[1:36:35] Number 2016-11, an ordinance of the City of Twin Falls, Idaho, amending ordinance number
[1:36:43] 31-05, the appropriation ordinance for the fiscal year beginning October 1st, 2015, and
[1:36:52] ending September 30th, 2016, appropriating additional monies that are to be received by
[1:37:00] the City of Twin Falls, Idaho, in the sum of $11,922,534 and providing an effective date.
[1:37:12] Be it ordained by the Mayor and the City Council of the City of Twin Falls, Idaho.
[1:37:19] Chris Stockton, who passed the 2016-11 as amended.
[1:37:23] Very.
[1:37:26] Motion by Chris Stockington, seconded by Greg Lanting to approve Ordinance 2016-11, any discussion?
[1:37:34] Chair and roll call vote, please.
[1:37:36] Suzanne Hawkins.
[1:37:37] Yes.
[1:37:38] Nicki Boyd.
[1:37:39] Yes.
[1:37:39] Sean Beriker.
[1:37:40] Yes.
[1:37:41] Chris Hockington.
[1:37:42] Yes.
[1:37:43] Greg Lanting.
[1:37:44] Yes.
[1:37:45] Don Hall.
[1:37:46] Yes.
[1:37:46] Ruth Pierce.
[1:37:47] Yes.
[1:37:48] Motion passes seven to zero.
[1:37:53] And finally, on the agenda this evening,
[1:37:55] we have adjournment into executive session at EOCODE 74206-1B
[1:38:03] to consider the evaluation, dismissal, or disciplining of,
[1:38:07] to hear complaints or charges brought against a public officer, employee, staff member, individual,
[1:38:13] agent or public school student, 74-206-C to acquire an interest in real property which
[1:38:19] is not owned by a public agency, and 74-206-1F to communicate with legal counsel for the
[1:38:30] public agency to discuss the legal ramifications of and legal options for pending litigations
[1:38:36] or controversies not yet being litigated but imminently likely to be litigated, the mere
[1:38:41] presence of legal counsel at an executive session does not satisfy this requirement.
[1:38:47] Council wishes.
[1:38:48] Great landing.
[1:38:49] So moved.
[1:38:51] Second.
[1:38:52] Motion by Great Lanting.
[1:38:54] Seconded by Suzanne Hawkins to adjourn into executive session under those three sections
[1:38:59] of the Idaho Code.
[1:39:00] Is there any discussion?
[1:39:01] Seeing none, Sharon, roll a call, vote please.
[1:39:05] Nicky Boyd.
[1:39:06] Yes.
[1:39:07] Sean Beriker.
[1:39:08] Yes.
[1:39:09] Yes.
[1:39:10] Greg Lanting.
[1:39:11] Yes.
[1:39:12] Don Hall.
[1:39:13] Yes.
[1:39:14] Ruth Pierce.
[1:39:15] Yes.
[1:39:16] Suzanne Hawkins.
[1:39:17] Yes.
[1:39:18] Motion passes seven to zero.
[1:39:19] It will remind everyone we will not be coming back into open session following the executive session.
[1:39:24] We will not be making any decisions in the executive session.
[1:39:27] With that, the meeting is adjourned.
