Oversight Archive: City Council meeting, 2017-07-17, recording 1 (started 16:49)
Machine transcript (faster-whisper base.en), not checked word for word; the Pledge of Allegiance is shown in its standard wording. The recording is the record.
Times are time into the recording. Passages with private details are muted in the audio and marked here.
The audio on the page below was re-encoded by software from the video the agency posted. Check any passage against
that audio before relying on it.
Page: https://oversightarchive.org/twin-falls-id/meetings/2017-07-17/

[0:00:00] Final nod again.
[0:00:01] We good?
[0:00:02] Okay.
[0:00:04] Good evening.
[0:00:05] I'd like to call to order the Twin Falls City Council meeting for Monday, July 17th.
[0:00:08] I would confirm we do have a quorum in the council.
[0:00:10] All seven members are here this evening.
[0:00:13] The next item on the agenda is the Pledge of Allegiance.
[0:00:15] Those of you wishing to join us, please rise.
[0:00:17] I pledge allegiance to the Flag of the United States of America, and to the Republic for which it stands, one Nation under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all.
[0:00:40] Mr. Rothweiler, do we have any amendments to the agenda this evening?
[0:00:43] Mr. Mayor, members of Council, there are no amendments.
[0:00:45] Excellent.
[0:00:46] And next on the agenda is proclamations.
[0:00:49] And I do have a proclamation this evening.
[0:00:52] This is the Twin Falls Schrebernitsa Genocide Remembrance Week
[0:00:57] proclamation.
[0:00:58] Whereas the United States House of Representatives
[0:01:01] and the United States Senate passed resolutions in 2005,
[0:01:05] acknowledging the genocide that Serbian forces perpetrated
[0:01:08] in Bosnia, Herzegovina, from 1993 to 1995.
[0:01:13] And whereas July 11th, 2017 marked the 22nd anniversary
[0:01:17] of the Srebrenica genocide, in which at least 8,372 Bosnian
[0:01:23] boys and men were systematically executed.
[0:01:26] And 30,000 Bosnian were expelled from their homes
[0:01:29] in the worst atrocity in Europe since the Holocaust.
[0:01:32] And whereas together with the 25th anniversary
[0:01:34] of the beginning of the war in Bosnia Herzegovina,
[0:01:38] the Srebrenica genocide anniversary raises awareness
[0:01:41] of the tragic suffering of the Bosnian people
[0:01:44] and remembers more than 100,000 civilians
[0:01:47] who died as a result of policies of ethnic cleansing.
[0:01:51] And whereas this day of remembrance also recognizes
[0:01:54] the 20,000 to 30,000 girls and women
[0:01:57] who were systematically raped and assaulted as a tactic of war,
[0:02:00] the two million people who were displaced from their homes,
[0:02:04] along with other nameless atrocious crimes against humanity,
[0:02:07] an unwarranted acts of aggression in Bosnia-Herzegovina
[0:02:11] between the years of 1992 and 1995.
[0:02:15] And whereas the city of Twin Falls
[0:02:16] recognizes the importance of these events,
[0:02:19] not just for Bosnians, but for all of humanity,
[0:02:22] to learn that hatred, intolerance, and discrimination
[0:02:25] can lead to the worst kinds of atrocities
[0:02:27] that mankind can unleash unfellow humans.
[0:02:30] And whereas the City of Twin Falls, its residents,
[0:02:33] and the College of Southern Idaho Refugee Relocation Program
[0:02:37] have provided support and aid to refugees of Bosnian descent
[0:02:41] in order to help bring closure to this tragedy
[0:02:43] and pursuit of justice and truth.
[0:02:45] Now, therefore, I, Sean Beriger, mayor of Twin Falls,
[0:02:48] proclaimed the week of July 11, 2017,
[0:02:51] as Schreber needs a genocide remembrance week in Twin Falls,
[0:02:55] and encourage residents to reflect and become aware
[0:02:58] about past and present genocides in order
[0:03:01] to identify early on and prevent future crimes
[0:03:04] against humanity.
[0:03:05] And here to accept this this evening is Mayor Seden.
[0:03:33] Mr. Mayor, Councilwoman, Councilman, members
[0:03:36] of the Green Falls community, family, and friends
[0:03:40] with the evening.
[0:03:42] My name is Mayor Saqadir Jallib in Green Falls 15 years.
[0:03:46] I'm veteran, attendant of Bosnia Army and survivor
[0:03:50] with Srebrenza genocide.
[0:03:52] During the war, Srebrenza was declared as the safe zone
[0:03:57] by the UN.
[0:03:59] 45,000 people were relocated to Srebrenza
[0:04:04] from surrounding cities and the left.
[0:04:07] The Villain-Boor, without food, water, and shelter,
[0:04:12] July 11, 1995, was the start of the 18th killings.
[0:04:17] The men and the boys were separated from the children and the women and educated.
[0:04:23] Some escaped to the mountains.
[0:04:26] Those who were captured became victims of mass education.
[0:04:33] I survived in the wilderness for 65 days during the ethnic killing,
[0:04:39] where taking place placed in my city.
[0:04:44] I walked during that time avoiding being captured,
[0:04:49] but I reached a safe zone.
[0:04:53] Civilians were helping one another,
[0:04:58] a way to capture and survive this genocide policy.
[0:05:04] In my family alone, my father, two uncles,
[0:05:07] to 16 years old nephews, my wife's father and the brother,
[0:05:13] where education and the laser find in the main grave.
[0:05:18] In 2016, my father remains where find it and identify four bones
[0:05:27] of my father, Barry, I was able to lay to find a rest
[0:05:32] with dignity.
[0:05:34] This year, 71 more bodies were discovered much and identified and led to arrest by Lord
[0:05:43] One.
[0:05:44] It has been 22 years since the Bosnian genocide and 6,500 bodies have been discovered.
[0:05:55] are still 1868 human beings unaccounted for families left without closure. This proclamation
[0:06:08] will bring closure to not only for my family, but many survivors of this reference as genocide.
[0:06:16] The both of us people know genocide and have composition for the people from other cultures
[0:06:24] who also survived genocide and war crimes against civilian.
[0:06:30] We thank our adaptive community and three-fals city
[0:06:35] cancel for this symbol of awareness and remembrance
[0:06:41] of the servants of genocide of 1995.
[0:06:46] Don't forget the sentence.
[0:06:51] Thank you so much for sharing your story with us
[0:06:54] and for being a part of this community.
[0:06:58] I appreciate all of you who come this evening.
[0:07:03] As you mentioned, this isn't only about the Bosnian people,
[0:07:06] it's about all of us to learn it.
[0:07:08] I appreciate you taking the time to share with us this evening.
[0:07:19] Suzanne Hawkins.
[0:07:20] Mr. Mayor, can we just maybe have a moment of silence
[0:07:22] before we move on?
[0:07:23] Yes, that's an excellent idea.
[0:07:25] Thank you.
[0:07:26] Thank you.
[0:07:27] Please join us in a moment of silence to remember those.
[0:07:46] Thank you.
[0:07:53] Next on the agenda is an opportunity
[0:07:55] general public input if there's anyone here wishing to address the council on an item that is not on
[0:07:59] the agenda this evening. Now is your opportunity to please come forward. Please. If you please just
[0:08:07] state your name for the record.
[0:08:10] I live here in Twin Falls for 23 years. Often when people hear my action they ask me where are you from?
[0:08:23] I answered with pride that I am from Bosnia, and most people know that there are plenty of
[0:08:32] Bosnia people here in Twin Falls, but they quite often don't know why we or how we ended
[0:08:38] up here.
[0:08:41] Why we had to be our homes to become refugees and relocate to this area?
[0:08:55] They don't know about Srebrenza genocide, about masculine, the war crimes, the crimes are
[0:09:02] to this, to Matt, please, no, seems it's cold.
[0:09:09] That's all, thank you.
[0:09:12] Thank you.
[0:09:16] Is there anyone else who wishes
[0:09:17] to address the council this evening?
[0:09:26] Good evening.
[0:09:27] If I may, I finish her statement.
[0:09:29] You may.
[0:09:33] They do not know a step needs a genocide
[0:09:35] about the mass killings, the war crimes,
[0:09:37] and the crimes against humanity.
[0:09:39] Not seen since the Holocaust,
[0:09:41] worst evil seen since the Holocaust.
[0:09:45] This here today is important,
[0:09:47] not only about Indian people, but for all people,
[0:09:50] to become aware of past and present crimes against humanity
[0:09:54] and genocide, genocides of the world today.
[0:09:57] We must never let this happen again.
[0:09:59] This proclamation is a reminder for all of us
[0:10:04] to condone any form of ethnic persecution or hate crime,
[0:10:08] both domestic and global.
[0:10:11] This pings a picture of the journey
[0:10:13] many of us refugees have made to plant our new roots here
[0:10:17] to involve. This is for our children for the next generation. To honor their heritage to
[0:10:24] know their Bosnia and American history, this proclamation is a path to closure for many families
[0:10:31] who cannot go to the graves of their loved ones. I thank our adopted community and to
[0:10:36] involve city council for this opportunity to share and raise awareness about Srebneza
[0:10:42] and crimes against humanity, the Bosnian people have survived.
[0:10:50] My name is Leah Bobayan, and I also have a statement if I may.
[0:11:00] Twin Falls is a community which is an adoptive community
[0:11:04] to refugees worldwide.
[0:11:06] Just in the 2012 to current faiths,
[0:11:11] there have been refugees from, or Congolese refugees, Sudanese,
[0:11:15] Iranians, Iraqis, boutonies, barundis,
[0:11:22] eretherians, Ethiopians, and many more.
[0:11:27] Most of these people that are arriving to this community
[0:11:30] are survivors of political conflict, religious ethnic
[0:11:34] cleansing, war crimes, policy of genocide.
[0:11:41] Twin Falls has become a mosaic of survivors of war crimes
[0:11:45] and genocide, who have war crimes, genocides, political conflict worldwide.
[0:11:51] These survivors are more than just refugees, they are more than just the workforce, they
[0:11:58] have the spirit of endurance, perseverance, and have the most appreciation for freedom that
[0:12:05] is valuable to any adoptive community.
[0:12:08] However, majority of these populations are underrepresented
[0:12:15] or let's be honest, unrepresented in the community,
[0:12:19] in the role of government and community.
[0:12:23] Majority of these diverse groups and residents
[0:12:25] are underrepresented and completely ignored their voices.
[0:12:33] Most of the time, it takes about 10, maybe 15, 20 years
[0:12:38] as in the case of the Armenian community,
[0:12:40] Russian community, Bosnian community,
[0:12:44] and usually in the next generation
[0:12:46] to have an empowered voice that can articulate
[0:12:48] for the community as well as bring closure
[0:12:52] to some of their wounds that have brought them here.
[0:12:57] 20 years is a long time to be invisible.
[0:13:00] It's a very long time, especially when you've already
[0:13:03] experienced trauma to be unheard and left unrepresented.
[0:13:08] presented in any community, especially a community that is an adoptive community.
[0:13:14] I feel that as a community, we can do better in our role and responsibility to help individuals
[0:13:20] integrate into their new society, heal their wounds, and get to know the democratic process.
[0:13:29] I would kindly recommend to the mayor and to the city council, respectfully, to evaluate
[0:13:39] and to establish perhaps a commission on diversity
[0:13:43] that can serve as input to the council.
[0:13:47] The role of this diversity commission, I'm sorry,
[0:13:54] can help identify these gaps in our community,
[0:13:58] can help bring representation to the council
[0:14:05] from these different groups within our own community.
[0:14:09] This commission could be an opportunity
[0:14:11] to give representation and seek input,
[0:14:14] not only from the refugee community,
[0:14:16] but also from the migrant community,
[0:14:19] and encourage citizens from all backgrounds
[0:14:22] to be welcomed, embraced, and included
[0:14:25] in the conversation as we move the community forward.
[0:14:29] Just for example, some of the primary goals
[0:14:31] of this commission could be to survey
[0:14:34] and identify cultural behaviors
[0:14:36] and cultural gaps within the community.
[0:14:39] engage with the migrant refugee and subcultural,
[0:14:42] subcultural, subculture residents and neighborhoods
[0:14:48] at the neighborhood level.
[0:14:50] Identify where the gaps in services, housing, employment,
[0:14:54] mistreatment, harassment, or any other integration factors,
[0:14:58] barriers, or obstacles for this population,
[0:15:02] and determine in ways to engage more citizens.
[0:15:06] That is all, thank you.
[0:15:08] Thank you, Liam.
[0:15:13] Is there anyone else who wishes to address the council?
[0:15:15] Yes, sir.
[0:15:20] Max Newland, Twin Falls, you had some voice counts
[0:15:24] show up with a concern about dogs and cars,
[0:15:28] and you passed an ordinance.
[0:15:30] This has ever been as important as that.
[0:15:33] I hope it gets equal or superior weight to that.
[0:15:36] Thank you.
[0:15:37] Thank you, Max.
[0:15:41] Is there anyone else who wishes to address the council?
[0:15:47] Chris talking to me.
[0:15:49] kind of a rough transition, but I like to report the event
[0:15:54] of this past weekend, the third annual
[0:15:56] Vietnam Veterans Memorial or a celebration salute,
[0:16:02] I guess, as a better term as held in City Park,
[0:16:05] Commissioner Tom Mike-Sell.
[0:16:07] Onshod the thing, Commissioner Don Hahn, myself,
[0:16:10] helped a little bit, but is extremely rewarding
[0:16:13] to see over 100 people close to 70, 80 cycles that joined the celebration for a tour of parts
[0:16:23] of a twin falls that salute the veterans protecting our freedom as we're all highly cognizant
[0:16:31] of the necessity for the sacrifice of others.
[0:16:34] They were my generation, some of them were a little rough around the edges, but they gave
[0:16:40] other lives, they gave of their courage and they gave their
[0:16:43] come up not to keep country free, the very country that you
[0:16:46] have joined with and become a strong part of. So I hope next
[0:16:51] year we get some very good public exposure, more public
[0:16:55] exposure than the 100 or so that showed up this time. Also,
[0:17:00] like just make mention that the first block, main street is
[0:17:04] now open. If you have not walked it, if you've not driven it,
[0:17:07] Cars were parked, the paint is on the concrete, so you can park safely.
[0:17:14] Most of the trees are in that first block and it looks marvellous.
[0:17:18] And in my twice a week sidewalk superintendent role, I thought I found a real bad gig,
[0:17:25] and two days later it was all correct and looked as smooth as you could expect any work to be done.
[0:17:31] be done. So please take a walking tour of downtown Twin Falls. There have all the concrete
[0:17:38] port now on that second block of the radio rendezvous. So we're starting to pick up speed.
[0:17:43] Thank you. Thanks to each of you for coming tonight and sharing this information with
[0:17:50] us and Leah, I appreciate your recommendation and we'll certainly give some thought to that
[0:17:56] of how we can perhaps better engage the sector of our community. And I think we may even have
[0:18:01] a chance to speak about some of that as we go through the budgeting process and
[0:18:05] dealing with our various focus areas for the strategic plan. So thank you. Next on
[0:18:10] the agenda is the consent calendar. Chris Reed. Mr. Mayor I move that we approve the
[0:18:15] consent calendar as published. Second. Motion by Chris Reed seconded by Ruth Pierce
[0:18:21] to approve the consent calendar as published. Is there any discussion?
[0:18:25] Sharon roll call vote please. Sean Berriger. Yes. Nicky Boyd. Yes. Suzanne
[0:18:52] Hawkins. Yes. Greg Lanting. Yes. Ruth Pierce. Yes. Christopher Reed. Yes. Chris
[0:19:00] talking to. Yes. Motion passes 7 to 0. So just heads up Sharon our little
[0:19:06] voting buttons. Yeah. Next is under items of consideration as a request from
[0:19:17] Jeremy Smith to waive the non-conforming building expansion permit process for a home located
[0:19:22] at 3220 Falls Avenue East. We have Jonathan Spendlove from our planning department. Welcome,
[0:19:31] John. Thank you, Mayor. And members of the Council have got an exhibit up here in just
[0:19:36] a second. The property we're talking about owned by Jeremy Smith is on Falls Avenue East
[0:19:42] And he is proposing to add an addition to the home.
[0:19:46] I believe this is all in the packet.
[0:19:48] And his addition is going to be on the east side of the property in the home and is an existing nonconforming residence built prior to our current zoning code.
[0:19:58] The blue is the home. The green is the closed garage.
[0:20:02] We also have a new code that was put in place after the home.
[0:20:06] The
[0:20:09] City Code allows the council to
[0:20:13] waive the non-conforming billing
[0:20:15] expansion process.
[0:20:17] That process is a public hearing
[0:20:19] process.
[0:20:20] Through a motion to find the council
[0:20:23] that can waive that process and
[0:20:25] simply allow Mr. Smith's ability
[0:20:27] expansion.
[0:20:29] the council that can waive that process and just simply allow Mr. Smith's ability
[0:20:34] expansion. Susan Hawkins. Thank you Jonathan. Don't judge me for my ignorance of
[0:20:43] building but is there a reason why the garage can't be moved four feet back so
[0:20:48] it does fall within the 80 feet and that way that part of it would least be out
[0:20:54] of our right-of-way. I do think there's a couple things we're trying to line up
[0:20:59] of the doorways and protection and other things that have to create another space across the
[0:21:05] building.
[0:21:06] That's a guess.
[0:21:07] Some educated guess.
[0:21:08] That makes sense.
[0:21:09] Yep.
[0:21:10] Much more educated than what I know.
[0:21:11] Thank you.
[0:21:13] Chris Stockington.
[0:21:14] I would move to approve the request from Jeremy Smith to waive the nonconforming building
[0:21:18] suspension permit process for the home located at 3220 Falls Avenue East.
[0:21:23] Second.
[0:21:25] by Kristokan and second by Christopher Reed to approve the request from Jeremy Smith as presented.
[0:21:31] Is there any discussion?
[0:21:35] Sharon Roll, call vote please.
[0:21:43] Nikki Boyd?
[0:21:44] Yes.
[0:21:45] Suzanne Hawkins?
[0:21:46] Yes.
[0:21:46] Greg Lanting?
[0:21:47] Yes.
[0:21:48] Ruth Pierce?
[0:21:49] Yes.
[0:21:49] Christopher Reed?
[0:21:50] Yes.
[0:21:51] Kristokanton?
[0:21:52] Yes.
[0:21:53] Sean Berriger?
[0:21:54] Yes.
[0:21:55] Motion passes.
[0:21:57] Seven to zero.
[0:22:04] Next is a request from the Twin Falls School District 411 to approve
[0:22:09] a building permit fee waiver for the remodel of Magic Valley High School. We have Jared
[0:22:13] Bortie, our building department. Welcome, Jared. Good evening, Mr. Mayor, members of the Council.
[0:22:19] Brady, you couldn't make it tonight, but he sent Ryan and Bill here to explain the project and the
[0:22:23] request. So I'll just ask him to come up and then I can stand for any questions you might have about
[0:22:27] building permit. Perfect. Thank you. Welcome, gentlemen. Welcome. Thank you, Mr. Mayor.
[0:22:39] We're just asking for a building permit fee waiver. I think you have it in your packet
[0:22:43] as we are remodeling at this current time Magic Valley High School down on Main Street
[0:22:49] are in the old Safeway's building. And as we have in the past, we're just asking for a waiver of the fees.
[0:22:55] I do the fact that a lot of his tax payer money going back and forth and we continue that good relationship
[0:23:00] that you guys have and we have brought together to continue to view for our citizens.
[0:23:05] So with that, we would stand for any questions you may have.
[0:23:06] Thank you Bill. Any questions? Chris Reed. Could you just go over what the
[0:23:12] remodels that you guys are doing? I just kind of like to know. What we are doing
[0:23:19] currently is we are adding three new classrooms in the back portion of that
[0:23:24] building. A computer lab, another restroom and then restroom area and probably the
[0:23:31] The biggest need is also a cafeteria that will fit all of our students, which is much needed.
[0:23:38] So we are currently in the process of doing that.
[0:23:41] We've hit a little bit of a snag with a load bearing wall that was not expected to be there,
[0:23:48] but we are in the middle of getting that all worked out.
[0:23:51] But it will be a great addition to this community and for our students of the Twin Falls School
[0:23:56] of History.
[0:23:57] Wonderful.
[0:23:58] Susanne Hawkins. I'm ready to make a motion if there's great to do. I do. Great
[0:24:04] landing. Okay. Dessert. Any talk or consideration about actually building them
[0:24:10] a school building at some point in the future? Councilman Lanting at this time
[0:24:16] there is not we're looking at trying to remodel that whole area with the
[0:24:19] property that's around there and bring it up to an acceptable level for the
[0:24:24] students over there and a lot of discussion with them at this time and
[0:24:27] And this is what we were able to afford at this time.
[0:24:30] Would we love to do that?
[0:24:31] Yes, we would, but trying to take into account
[0:24:33] the amount of money that we have off the bonds
[0:24:35] that we've just passed.
[0:24:37] Right now we're in a whole pattern,
[0:24:38] and we're looking at remodeling for the time being.
[0:24:41] Thanks, good.
[0:24:42] Chris talking to you.
[0:24:43] I think it's important to note that this isn't
[0:24:46] an absolutely free ride.
[0:24:48] It's very common for us to share or to waive the fees
[0:24:52] for other public entities.
[0:24:54] But as we saw in our notes, the additional sewer capacity
[0:24:58] fee of more than $1,600 will be assessed
[0:25:02] and paid for by the schools.
[0:25:03] So they are paying on an ongoing basis.
[0:25:06] And that's why I'm very supportive of this.
[0:25:09] All right.
[0:25:09] Suzanne?
[0:25:10] I would like to move that we approve the request
[0:25:13] of the Twin Falls School District
[0:25:15] to waive the building permit fees as presented.
[0:25:20] Second.
[0:25:22] The motion by Suzanne Hocken seconded by Christopher Reed
[0:25:25] to approve the request to waive the building permit fees
[0:25:28] as presented, is there any discussion?
[0:25:31] Sharon, I'll call vote please.
[0:25:38] Suzanne Hawkins?
[0:25:40] Yes.
[0:25:40] Greg Lanting?
[0:25:41] Yes.
[0:25:42] Ruth Pierce?
[0:25:43] Yes.
[0:25:44] Christopher Reed?
[0:25:45] Yes.
[0:25:46] Chris Talkington?
[0:25:47] Yes.
[0:25:48] Sean Beriker?
[0:25:49] Yes.
[0:25:50] Nikki Boyd?
[0:25:52] Yes.
[0:25:53] Motion passes 7 to 0.
[0:25:54] Thank you.
[0:25:58] Thank you.
[0:25:59] Thank you.
[0:26:00] Next is a request to approve a preferred design for the Magic Valley Regional Airport's Northeast
[0:26:03] development area, and we have Bill Carberry, our airport manager.
[0:26:06] Welcome, Bill.
[0:26:07] Thank you, Mayor.
[0:26:08] Good evening, council members.
[0:26:11] Looking back at 2012, the airport master plan was published.
[0:26:15] It's an FAA document for a 20-year planning horizon.
[0:26:19] And in that document, it identified the northeast hanger area as the appropriate location for any
[0:26:24] future cargo facility.
[0:26:26] So naturally, when FedEx came a couple of years later and was interested in building a cargo
[0:26:31] facility, we look to that area to build their facility.
[0:26:35] So with the construction of their three-acre site, it really called out the need for some
[0:26:40] additional planning, some additional pre-design work for future taxi lanes, hangers, identifying
[0:26:47] hanger development areas.
[0:26:49] So the FAA agreed to fund a pre-design study with the airport.
[0:26:53] So the airport contracted with JUB Engineering and Ken Dacken to conduct a public process
[0:27:01] to look at a pre-design study and work with the airport or to that end.
[0:27:07] So without I'd like to introduce Ken Dacken with JUB Engineering, he's also brought Bryant
[0:27:13] Kekely with the Langdon group who's very much in volunteer with the public process of this.
[0:27:21] So here tonight is Mike March, the chairman of the airport advisory board.
[0:27:25] So I'll hand it off to Kent to sort of take you through the process briefly.
[0:27:29] Thank you, Bill. Good evening, Mayor and City Council.
[0:27:35] I'll go through an evaluation process and what I'd like to start is
[0:27:39] this gets into how we evaluated options, but we went through
[0:27:43] a public involvement that Brian really helped me to put them together.
[0:27:47] So the first slide just kind of shows how we got to the three.
[0:27:52] So we had 11 initial development options.
[0:27:55] We were able to narrow it down to three.
[0:27:57] Those three included four A7B and C.
[0:28:01] So once we got those three, we actually went through,
[0:28:06] reviewed our project goals, we solicited stakeholder comment,
[0:28:10] and we went through up an evaluation based off those goals.
[0:28:16] So these nine items appear for the project goals.
[0:28:20] These also went side by side through public involvement of the comment.
[0:28:24] And the goals talk about redundant access, flow, current users, and how we can mitigate
[0:28:31] that and get the best solution.
[0:28:34] Now, stakeholder involvement, this identifies some dates that we had throughout from a public
[0:28:41] involvement.
[0:28:42] December 6th, board meetings, multiple opportunities to meet with users and talk about the project.
[0:28:50] The FAA was, they were not aware of the process or the project, and had been dealt with by working with us through this project.
[0:29:00] Had a little bit of some media out there for the open house, some pictures and what have you.
[0:29:09] So the options I go through real quick here, these are the three options that the board wanted to go back for further evaluations.
[0:29:19] So you have your 4A, 7B, 7C, we took these options and we went out and solicited more input from the stakeholders.
[0:29:30] So that's what this shows. And some of this is just presentation.
[0:29:34] Hey, don't show the hangars, show the hash. So we really wanted to make sure that we got what they were saying.
[0:29:41] So the 7B shows up, 7C. Now we go into the evaluation process.
[0:29:47] Those gold that we talked about earlier, that's how we ranked those options and that's how the board came up with it for production, which is 7c.
[0:29:58] This is the one we'd like to move forward.
[0:30:03] So I went through that pretty quickly and I hope I didn't leave anybody in the desk.
[0:30:07] But if you have any questions, people are happy to answer them.
[0:30:10] I'm going to make yes, slow down a little bit for me because I'm trying to grasp all this.
[0:30:17] Explain to me exactly what we're looking at there.
[0:30:19] What is the purple?
[0:30:20] What is the gold?
[0:30:21] What is the blue?
[0:30:22] What is the green?
[0:30:23] Sorry, but maybe explain exactly what it is you're proposing that we are planning.
[0:30:33] What you're looking at here, if you can see in our role, is the purple identifies hangers.
[0:30:43] And so, we're not necessarily looking at every individual hanger for, say, what we're looking at is a general flow.
[0:30:50] And so, he'll see the hangers in the hatch that your hanger development area.
[0:30:55] Now, the blue line, you have to go on the hanger.
[0:30:59] So, the blue line identifies a higher type, wider wingspan to access.
[0:31:05] The brown type that you see identifies a narrower, if you will, access.
[0:31:11] And so what we're looking at as we go through is how do you build for the future for parable growth that accommodates you to different types of aircraft that will likely be used?
[0:31:20] So are those hangers already there or is that possible growth area for hangers?
[0:31:26] Possible growth area.
[0:31:27] Okay. Thank you.
[0:31:31] Chris Tockett.
[0:31:32] Well, I guess one we would expand on Ken's role. He's done an admirable job of multiple times inviting a carport users.
[0:31:41] people invested economic and blithely about interest there and I think we reached a fairly
[0:31:48] good consensus. This whole thing kind of took on its whole inertia or momentum of a song
[0:31:56] about the time FedEx started planning the roots there. And this is a long-term goal. It
[0:32:03] It still allows for future expansion somewhat to the east,
[0:32:08] but it's again on the consensus of the scoring point seven C,
[0:32:16] was the one that was unanimously accepted
[0:32:20] by all the stakeholders?
[0:32:21] Yes, it was.
[0:32:22] I thought I was, so good job to camp.
[0:32:28] All right, thank you, Kent.
[0:32:29] We'll have Bill come back up.
[0:32:31] Just around things out a little bit.
[0:32:33] There is no cost associated with this plan.
[0:32:43] What the board and the airport are asking is for your concurrence with option 7C as the
[0:32:50] preferred direction to go in the future.
[0:32:53] The thinking is this will probably be done in phases over a period of time, but we do
[0:33:00] need some sites on where we're going.
[0:33:02] This allows, can I borrow your point, you can probably be angry at the current stakeholders.
[0:33:14] So this is, and it's hard to see, so just to orient, this is the FedEx facility here that
[0:33:21] was facilitated with front, some street side access that has a ramp here for its aircraft
[0:33:28] that come through here.
[0:33:29] As they planned for larger aircraft in the future, that was one of the development goals
[0:33:33] was to create this blue taxi lane in order for them to come in and get to this spot, their
[0:33:39] current ramp.
[0:33:40] The idea of putting this ramp in was to help
[0:33:43] associated development in that area utilize this ramp.
[0:33:46] So this green ramp not only allows this flow in here,
[0:33:51] but it'll also help with associated development around it.
[0:33:56] There's a fire house here.
[0:33:57] This is a road that comes through there.
[0:34:00] Precision aviation who runs a charter business is back here.
[0:34:03] They have a short-term lease here that they use.
[0:34:07] This option allows them to put forth a proposal
[0:34:11] to fill the hanger at some point.
[0:34:13] And we're working through that timetable with them.
[0:34:16] This also shows some future hangers here
[0:34:19] for spur aviation that may want to expand as well.
[0:34:23] So we're providing options for current tenants.
[0:34:26] The BLM was certainly consulted.
[0:34:29] They do have room to grow here.
[0:34:31] The avionics shop was consulted.
[0:34:33] So we really looked to try to create something
[0:34:35] that de-conflicted larger aircraft in the future,
[0:34:39] but provided ample access, good circulation,
[0:34:43] good areas for future development of hangers.
[0:34:46] And this is the choice that rose to the top.
[0:34:49] So we'll be looking, you know, for certainly if you do
[0:34:52] concur with this tonight, we'll be, next step would be
[0:34:55] to get with the FAA, to get their concurrence
[0:34:57] with this plan, any costs associated with this
[0:35:00] would be wrapped up into the airport improvement program.
[0:35:03] so we would be looking for future grants to create
[0:35:07] our roads, if you will.
[0:35:08] It's sort of our subdivision out there,
[0:35:10] as with the airport being the developer,
[0:35:13] we're looking to create those roads
[0:35:16] that'll service the aircraft.
[0:35:18] Utility planning would come right behind this,
[0:35:20] so there is a sort of a logical method
[0:35:24] to try to build this out.
[0:35:27] So I'd be happy to answer any questions you might have.
[0:35:30] Build this to comments, so that plan also would allow
[0:35:34] for some, so you have kind of the airport side,
[0:35:36] and then also the more public access on the outside
[0:35:38] of those hangers on the north end.
[0:35:41] Thank you, that's an excellent question.
[0:35:44] These hangers right here, this is a future road
[0:35:47] that's illustrated in here.
[0:35:49] And someday it may go all the way to blue lakes,
[0:35:51] and I'll scratch my head maybe in the 30 years
[0:35:53] as another terminal building out there, who knows.
[0:35:55] But as we're building out, what FedEx did
[0:35:58] is they created the first phase of this new access road here.
[0:36:02] So they invested a lot.
[0:36:03] to invest in a lot of utilities,
[0:36:05] and it really went hand in glove
[0:36:06] with some of our long-term plans.
[0:36:08] So to answer your question now,
[0:36:10] these hangers here could have street side
[0:36:12] associated with them as well.
[0:36:13] And that's a key ingredient
[0:36:15] when folks looking to build facilities
[0:36:18] is to have an street side access to it.
[0:36:21] Thank you, Bill.
[0:36:24] So with that, I would ask for the council's concurrence
[0:36:27] with the airport board's recommendation
[0:36:29] to move forward with option seven C as you see it here.
[0:36:36] Council was just Chris talking to those airport layers and I'd be more than happy to do that
[0:36:41] Council recommend a
[0:36:44] unanimous approval of
[0:36:46] option seven C of the airport
[0:36:49] the expansion
[0:36:51] North northeast development area expansion excuse me the motion by Chris talking to the second by Nikki Boyd to
[0:36:57] approve the preferred design
[0:36:59] For the airports northeast development area as presented is there any further discussion?
[0:37:04] Sure and we'll call those please.
[0:37:10] Suzanne Hawkins.
[0:37:11] Yes.
[0:37:12] Greg Lanting.
[0:37:13] Yes.
[0:37:14] Ruth Pierce.
[0:37:15] Yes.
[0:37:16] Christopher Reed.
[0:37:17] Yes.
[0:37:18] Chris Hockington.
[0:37:19] Yes.
[0:37:20] Sean Berriker.
[0:37:21] Yes.
[0:37:22] Nicky Boyd.
[0:37:23] Yes.
[0:37:24] Motion passes seven to zero.
[0:37:25] Thank you, Council.
[0:37:26] Thank you, Bill.
[0:37:27] Into your team there.
[0:37:28] Okay.
[0:37:29] Next is a request to approve a PUD agreement between the City of Twin Falls and Grandview
[0:37:38] farms, LLC, and once again we have Jonathan Spendlove, senior planner.
[0:37:43] Mr. Mayor Baerger, there is a lot of history on this one. I'm not going to read all of it,
[0:37:48] but I'm going to summarize it's basically the whole page. It started in February of 2008,
[0:37:54] goes through November 2008, basically up until today, almost 10 years later. Back in 2008,
[0:38:02] the property in the southwest corner of Grandview and Falls was annexed with a zoning designation
[0:38:09] of R2 and there were some conditions or conditions that the council put on there and then in May
[0:38:15] of that same year the ordinance was approved with some deed restrictions.
[0:38:21] November 2008 the developer came back for an additional rezone, a rezoned it from R2, to
[0:38:28] R2PUD and included a neighborhood commercial overlay as well within that whole development.
[0:38:36] The presentations were given.
[0:38:38] There was considerable public input upon conclusion.
[0:38:41] The council at that time put 12 conditions on the approval of that PUD.
[0:38:48] It was about after that 2009 when development just pretty much ceased throughout the City
[0:38:56] City of Twin Falls during the economic downturn.
[0:38:59] So we have a property that is zoned with an ordinance,
[0:39:02] R2-PUD, R2-NCO-PUD, but we don't have an actual agreement
[0:39:07] to enforce that ordinance.
[0:39:09] So what this is is bringing that agreement forward
[0:39:12] with the 12 conditions that the Council put on at that time
[0:39:16] and basically codifying that agreement
[0:39:18] so that we can now enforce those conditions
[0:39:20] and everything they've presented
[0:39:22] and actually have a developable piece of ground.
[0:39:25] So we've worked with the developer to assure that the PUD agreement accurately and correctly
[0:39:29] reflects the council's approval that was done in 2008, attaches a copy of the final draft,
[0:39:34] and it is a lengthy draft of that, as well as the council's conditions that are at the end.
[0:39:40] That is what we have.
[0:39:45] Thank you, Jonathan.
[0:39:46] Any questions for Jonathan?
[0:39:49] Suzanne Hawkins.
[0:39:50] Just because I'm curious, I see the list of things that are not permitted.
[0:39:55] Can you give us some rough ideas of what is permitted?
[0:39:59] So, R2 is residential and then there's some restrictions on lot sizes, things like that.
[0:40:08] The neighborhood commercial would be some small scale retail.
[0:40:11] I'm trying to find the actual agreement where there's more is what we're talking about.
[0:40:24] It'd be mostly small scale commercial.
[0:40:31] So, the R2 residential is going to allow strictly residential NCO.
[0:40:38] It's going to meet the requirements of the city's neighborhood commercial overlay district
[0:40:41] I have to have to look to the city code for what would be permitted
[0:40:47] That's okay, John that then I was just curious
[0:41:04] In title 10 chapter or section 21
[0:41:09] So there's a lot of permitted some parks residential the retail trade would be
[0:41:16] along the lines of bakery, book, store, craft shops, some restaurants, floor shops,
[0:41:22] general merchandise, hardware store, hobby, toy store, ice cream store, those are
[0:41:27] retail, the services, beauty and barber shops, daycare service, copy, store, and
[0:41:34] photography studios, those are outright permitted, and then the special uses are
[0:41:38] slightly and more intensive uses than those.
[0:41:42] Okay, thank you.
[0:41:44] Any other questions for John
[0:41:53] Seeing none
[0:41:54] Council wishes I move the we approve the pud grim twin citizen falls and grandview parks LLC
[0:42:14] second
[0:42:15] Motion by a great landing second advice Suzanne Hawkins to approve the
[0:42:20] Pud agreement as presented is there any discussion?
[0:42:27] Sharon roll call vote, please
[0:42:31] Greg landing yes with peers yes Christopher Reed yes
[0:42:36] Chris Hockington, Sean Berriger, Lickie Boyd, Suzanne Hawkins.
[0:42:43] Motion passes, 7-0.
[0:42:46] Next is a request to adopt the resolution for Federal Aid Highway Project A0-2-0-2-9-1
[0:42:58] and authorize the mayor to execute the state local agreement for construction for KN-2-0-2-9-1
[0:43:05] Washington Street and Falls Avenue.
[0:43:07] City Engineer, Jackie Fields. Sorry about the title. That's okay. It actually makes it really clear for following the lineage on the paperwork.
[0:43:15] So in October of last year, the City Council approved submittal of three projects for local highway safety improvement projects.
[0:43:26] And two of them were awarded this year. The first one is to do controller upgrades on falls in Washington Street
[0:43:33] Street and our relatively new signals that have obsolete equipment. It was the best of
[0:43:39] the time, but it's obsolete. And then next week I'll be back with the Shashone Street
[0:43:46] signal controllers, six, four, seconds, six. So in January the City Council adopted a resolution
[0:44:01] and authorized the merit assignment and agreement to do the design. That design is complete and
[0:44:06] that means that the city should go forward.
[0:44:12] We'll need to adopt a resolution
[0:44:14] that authorizes the merit to enter into the agreement
[0:44:16] with the state and submit the local match
[0:44:19] in the amount of $34,393.
[0:44:23] That's 7.3% or so of the total project costs of 538,99.
[0:44:35] There are street funds available
[0:44:37] We had a discussion on this in October and on January, it's a reallocation of funds that
[0:44:46] were intended for signal repair and improvement purposes, and it will work to help our long-term
[0:44:52] process.
[0:44:57] So the staff recommendation is City Council adopt the resolution for that long project
[0:45:04] Number two, number two, number one, and authorize the
[0:45:08] Merida execute the state vote agreement for construction.
[0:45:11] That will also authorize finance to pay the match.
[0:45:17] Thank you, Jackie.
[0:45:20] Sharon, do we have a resolution number?
[0:45:23] Resolution number 2017-11.
[0:45:27] Suzanne Hawkins.
[0:45:31] Just to clarify, so is this SLA construction PDF attached?
[0:45:37] Is that the resolution?
[0:45:38] because I don't see a resolution per se in my packet.
[0:45:41] Okay. The traditional way that this is formed is that they'll send the agreement
[0:45:48] and the very last page of the agreement has the resolution and it's page seven.
[0:45:53] Okay. It might be tucked into the very back.
[0:45:55] I don't know if it's the new software, but like when I scroll down to the end,
[0:45:59] the last few pages in mine go blank on me.
[0:46:02] It's so I can't.
[0:46:04] I can just as much of the contract as you'd like to see.
[0:46:10] No, that's fine.
[0:46:11] I just, we're working through it still.
[0:46:14] We are placing the resolution from my paper packet up there so that you can take a look
[0:46:19] at it.
[0:46:20] Thank you.
[0:46:25] Yep.
[0:46:26] So it generally says the state is going to conform to federal aid rules and that they
[0:46:31] only are going to pay for work on the federal aid system.
[0:46:35] So this is a local project.
[0:46:36] So the money is going to come from the federal government, or from the city.
[0:46:43] And we will be responsible for everything over the federal aid limit.
[0:46:48] So currently that's estimated at the $34,000 number that I gave you in your package.
[0:46:55] And then this provides the authority for the mayor to enter into the agreement.
[0:47:06] Yeah, there are questions.
[0:47:09] Greg Lanting.
[0:47:10] Mayor, I move that we approve resolution 2017-11.
[0:47:14] That's stated, the information is stated by Jackie.
[0:47:20] Second.
[0:47:22] Question by Greg Lanting.
[0:47:23] Seconded by Christopher Reed to adopt resolution 2017-11.
[0:47:30] Is there any discussion?
[0:47:32] Greg, did you have another comment for that?
[0:47:35] Sharon, roll call vote please.
[0:47:39] Ruth Pierce?
[0:47:40] Yes.
[0:47:41] Christopher Reed?
[0:47:42] Yes.
[0:47:44] Chris Tockington, Sean Berriger, Nicky Boyd, Suzanne Hawkins, Greg Lanting.
[0:47:51] Yes.
[0:47:53] Motion passes 7 to 0.
[0:48:00] Next on the agenda is discussion on the transportation master plan.
[0:48:03] Welcome, Jackie.
[0:48:04] Thank you.
[0:48:05] Thank you very much.
[0:48:07] So we've started work on our and been working away steadily on our transportation master
[0:48:12] plan for several months.
[0:48:14] several different types of attempts to get some public input specific round table groups
[0:48:21] and so on. So we thought that it might be an appropriate time to provide you with an update
[0:48:27] on what's going on and talk about our next steps. So tonight I'm going to be introduced
[0:48:36] to you, Rob Ramsey from Civil Science, who's the engineer that's been working on the project
[0:48:41] And I apologize for not getting you the exhibits, but we had one of our last discussions with
[0:48:47] folks on Wednesday in the evening and couldn't get those comments compiled fast enough to be
[0:48:55] able to incorporate them in our little summary sheets.
[0:48:58] So Rob has some handouts for you.
[0:49:18] Thank you, council members, for this opportunity.
[0:49:43] What have we got?
[0:49:45] I've handed you three individual handouts here.
[0:49:49] The first one comprises basically a summary of where we've been and where we're at and where we're going to.
[0:49:56] And so in January 2016 we are December 10th and December of 2016.
[0:50:03] We started the process of gathering data, doing some evaluation analysis and identifying an initial look at what we see as the traffic patterns in the city of Twin Falls.
[0:50:18] And then through this process, we've developed the second sheet, which is a map, which identifies
[0:50:25] what is called the level of service map.
[0:50:28] And these level of service are graded from A to F with A being good, F being pretty bad
[0:50:35] congested.
[0:50:36] And then the third sheet gives examples of what a level of service A through F would look
[0:50:42] like.
[0:50:43] Again, this map is an initial evaluation that if you look at it in detail, you can see that
[0:50:50] Chini Drive is not addressed in there and we have that data and we are currently analyzing
[0:50:55] it and we will update this map based on it.
[0:50:58] We will also look at other areas that are showing us red and evaluate those and make
[0:51:02] sure that information indicated in here is fairly accurate of what the public is experiencing
[0:51:11] as they travel around Twin Falls.
[0:51:15] As far as the schedule goes, we started the data collection
[0:51:18] in December and started evaluating the existing conditions
[0:51:22] in February through April.
[0:51:24] We've been going through the public involvement process,
[0:51:27] which has included interviews with stakeholders,
[0:51:30] 13 individuals as identified by city staff,
[0:51:33] where we talk to them about transportation.
[0:51:36] We have a transportation steering committee consisting
[0:51:39] of broad array of citizens throughout City of Twin Falls
[0:51:43] to give us advisement and recommendations
[0:51:46] as we proceed with the transportation plan.
[0:51:49] We've held three community round table discussions
[0:51:52] addressing specific items and gathering input
[0:51:55] from specific entities.
[0:51:58] For example, sidewalks.
[0:52:00] We involved CSI, we involved the school district,
[0:52:06] school district and other entities we did one on bike biking and bike pass and we also did
[0:52:12] one on truck routes and that was very very productive I felt the comments that we received
[0:52:18] there that applied specifically to those groups. We also participated in the city fair this
[0:52:25] past week which Jackie just talked about which was in conjunction with the city's strategic
[0:52:31] planning meeting that was held last week and gathered some more comments from that and
[0:52:36] And then we also have a comment sheet on the Twin Falls Transportation Master Plan website
[0:52:41] which has a link to it on the City of Twin Falls website.
[0:52:46] So we're going through the process right now still in the collecting comments from the public.
[0:52:53] Our next step is to gather those comments, evaluate the future traffic generations and
[0:53:01] traffic modeling and in that we will proceed with developing what we call a
[0:53:10] capital improvement plan and also discuss what the needs are to address
[0:53:16] congestion and not only now but in the future that will also include evaluating
[0:53:24] the city standards and policies and also integrating in a maintenance plan for the
[0:53:31] city to assist the city in evaluating and proceeding forth with their budgets,
[0:53:35] yearly for transportation maintenance activities. So we are hoping to have that
[0:53:43] completed, we're on schedule, have that completed in October with a draft coming
[0:53:48] out in November and then the final being presented to City Council in December is
[0:53:56] our schedule. The involvement of the City Council we anticipate is prior to the draft
[0:54:03] of the transportation plan that will have a work session with City Council to discuss
[0:54:10] and review some of the comments that have been brought up, some of the vital engineering
[0:54:15] analysis provided with not only the future but the existing conditions, and then also
[0:54:22] discuss potential projects that we anticipate based off of this, gather some input from you
[0:54:31] in that and then we'll proceed for it in developing and submitting the draft plan for your review.
[0:54:39] And then also submitting based off the comments off of that addressing that in the final draft
[0:54:44] and then submitting the final for adaptation.
[0:54:48] In general, as far as the public comments go, I've included a comment summary
[0:54:55] of what we've received as far as general comments.
[0:54:58] I try not to get too specific, but try to make it broad on the comments that we've received.
[0:55:04] As you can see, like number one, our number two bullet there is reduce lane widths, and
[0:55:09] then if you go in the back, the second, the last one says several roads need to be wide.
[0:55:14] So we've got a lot of work ahead of us.
[0:55:18] But we've received a lot of great comments from the public, and we look forward to getting
[0:55:22] more comments from the public through the website.
[0:55:26] We do have a comment for them and feel free to go to the website and fill out a complete
[0:55:31] comment form.
[0:55:32] We'll take that information and we'll evaluate all of the comments that are made as we go
[0:55:38] through this process.
[0:55:40] The city is also, Jackie and I have talked about going to other community organizations,
[0:55:47] city organizations and doing presentations together and comments from them also.
[0:55:52] We've also discussed maybe finding another opportunity when there's a city event.
[0:55:59] You know, western days have already passed by, but something that's larger in the central city park.
[0:56:08] We can have the blue and gather comments there too.
[0:56:11] So we just want to give you an update of where we're at.
[0:56:15] Jackie, if you have any questions, I can answer any questions.
[0:56:19] Well, this map is very revealing, especially the color coding.
[0:56:26] Is it too simplistic to say you're looking for a way to return,
[0:56:32] cover code D's and F's into the green, or less severe anyway?
[0:56:38] Yeah, the goal is to try to get it up to level C.
[0:56:40] Level C is what the city is determined to is acceptable.
[0:56:45] And so what we're doing is like, for example, North College, we know that that will be changed
[0:56:51] once I get the information from changing drive, the new addition there, and get that aligned.
[0:56:59] There's also been concerned express that between Fillmore and Blue Lakes that there's
[0:57:03] some congestion in there, so we're going to evaluate that some more and make sure that
[0:57:07] we feel comfortable with what's there in this representative of what the traffic is
[0:57:13] So, yeah, those areas will look at specifically and identify and discuss with the city, how
[0:57:23] we can address some of them.
[0:57:24] And I guess, just as a follow-up, were these traffic counters, studies that revealed, for
[0:57:30] instance, the F coding, or as a combination of counts, plus public input, a little bit
[0:57:36] of everything?
[0:57:37] So, that is this that you have right now is just counts and traffic points.
[0:57:43] That's all that the analysis is right now.
[0:57:45] Okay.
[0:57:46] Thank you.
[0:57:47] So, we'll go through and do some more detail.
[0:57:50] Go through that process.
[0:57:52] Suzanne Hawkins.
[0:57:53] Thank you.
[0:57:54] Just a thought.
[0:57:55] Maybe you can take one of these Thursday nights where city bands play and then set up out
[0:57:59] there.
[0:58:00] There's a good crowd out there and normally those are citizens that are willing to give you
[0:58:04] their opinion.
[0:58:07] That's a great idea.
[0:58:08] If they can get there on the crowded roads.
[0:58:13] Any other questions or comments for Jack here, Rob?
[0:58:18] Greg Landen.
[0:58:19] How much control do we have over the designated areas
[0:58:25] that are state highways or like US 9,
[0:58:29] Highway 93 or all of it is, how much actual
[0:58:33] can we change that without approval from the state?
[0:58:35] Or will this allow us to get approval from the state
[0:58:38] to do some changes?
[0:58:39] And that one there, I'd have to defer probably
[0:58:42] to Jackie a little bit on that with what the agreement is
[0:58:45] between the city and the state.
[0:58:47] Based on my experience, what it does identify is if that is included
[0:58:52] on the capital improvement plan which we develop at the end
[0:58:56] of the, as part of the transportation master plan,
[0:58:59] capital improvement plan is basically a list
[0:59:01] of the priority projects for the city.
[0:59:04] And so, Jackie can use that information to approach ITB
[0:59:09] about a need in the community.
[0:59:12] She can use that information to approach LTCH
[0:59:15] for federal funding and prioritize her projects.
[0:59:18] And so that is the part that I can see the benefit of that.
[0:59:23] But I don't know that the city has a final call
[0:59:26] within the city limits in that situation,
[0:59:28] but it definitely helps to motivate high-to-be,
[0:59:34] to evaluate and look at future construction projects
[0:59:39] on the one of the issues that it has right now is there hands are tied as far as the funding
[0:59:46] goes for expansion and that would be the difficult part here at this time thank you that first
[0:59:54] statement that satisfies me I figured I figured that was I would just keep clarification so
[1:00:01] thanks all right we'll see you know more questions or comments thank you so much to both of you
[1:00:10] So I believe some of you are probably here for the public hearing that is scheduled to start no earlier than six o'clock
[1:00:21] We still have another couple of items you want me to flip off them. Mr. Mayor
[1:00:26] I was going to say as much as I'd like to think that they're here for the budget
[1:00:30] That may or may not be the case the next presentations on the budget who wants to stick around for that?
[1:00:39] So because we are after six o'clock we will go ahead and move forward with the public hearing
[1:00:46] So this is a request for annexation with a zoning district change and zoning map amendment
[1:00:51] for approximately 9.75 plus or minus acres to be rezoned to R6 currently zoned R1 variable
[1:00:57] for property located east of Harrison Street and north of Canyon Falls Drive extended.
[1:01:04] We have Rob Struthers on behalf of Susan and Catherine of Brecken Ridge.
[1:01:08] So I have to call you Catherine in the case since it says Catherine on the paper.
[1:01:18] So, for the public hearing, if you're here to speak on that, what we'll do is we'll have
[1:01:22] a presentation from the applicants, then we'll have a staff report that will get us up to
[1:01:26] speed on where this has been in the process, and then we will invite public comments, and
[1:01:33] we will limit those to just two minutes this evening.
[1:01:37] So, if you could please keep your comments brief and non-repetitive, and then we will
[1:01:43] take it up for council discussion following that.
[1:01:46] So, welcome, Katie.
[1:01:47] Thank you. My name is Katie Breckenridge and I'm here with my husband Rob Struthers.
[1:01:53] I have one quick question about procedure. After the public has commented, do we then
[1:02:08] have a few minutes to reply to that? Yes. Thank you very much.
[1:02:13] Again, my name is Katie Breckenridge and I'm here representing my sister Susan Breckenridge
[1:02:18] and Rob Struthers and myself. I'm married to Rob Struthers.
[1:02:23] A quick note on the staff report at the very beginning, it stated that the land had been
[1:02:33] farmed since 1950.
[1:02:36] I think that is a typographical error because it's been farmed since 1905.
[1:02:42] It has been in my family for over 100 years.
[1:02:47] The only display that we're going to show you tonight
[1:02:50] is an aerial of the land.
[1:02:53] And what we want you to look at on this aerial of the land
[1:02:57] is how it is zoned.
[1:03:00] It is zoned on the west by C1.
[1:03:04] Where'd that map go?
[1:03:06] Yeah, I'm sorry.
[1:03:10] We haven't practiced.
[1:03:13] We want just to stay there, okay?
[1:03:18] It is zoned on the west.
[1:03:21] The zoning on the west is C-1.
[1:03:24] The zoning on the south to this land is C-1.
[1:03:31] On the east bordering this land is that parking lot.
[1:03:36] And on the north is land that Rob and I own
[1:03:40] that is in agriculture.
[1:03:43] It is interesting to note that on the comprehensive plan,
[1:03:47] it is all zoned for mixed use, all of the land.
[1:03:50] in this area. In talking when we decided to annex the land, we were talked to Steve O'Connor
[1:04:00] in the planning office. And at that time, his recommendation was not only to annex Susan's
[1:04:08] land, but to rezone it. And his recommendation from staff was to rezone it to R6. The reason
[1:04:15] to R6. The reason for that is if you look at this land, as it stands now, there is
[1:04:23] no there is no landscaping at all provided by any of the people that surround us
[1:04:30] with the exception of two trees that are on the southeast corner. There is a fence
[1:04:41] that walks along the bike path by next to La Quinta.
[1:04:47] But other than that, there is no landscaping.
[1:04:51] I bring that up because one of the reasons,
[1:04:55] and the main reason that we think it should be R6,
[1:04:59] is that within this zoning, somehow,
[1:05:03] this land has to be buffered by the current zoning of C1
[1:05:08] one that surrounds it and that parking lot.
[1:05:12] If you can have sea sit,
[1:05:14] pardon me, are sips,
[1:05:16] then you can buffer the land in some manners
[1:05:20] and then gradually work it down into townhouses,
[1:05:26] single houses all the way to where the land falls
[1:05:30] inside the Kangen Rim overlay.
[1:05:34] It is very obvious that no one would want
[1:05:37] to build a townhouse next to La Quinta.
[1:05:41] So that is the reason why we are asking to annex it
[1:05:46] and to move and to have it R6, is to be able to buffer,
[1:05:52] buffer the C1 that surrounds us.
[1:05:56] To give you a brief history of the land
[1:05:58] is almost impossible to make it brief
[1:06:01] when it has been in my family for 100 years.
[1:06:05] but I will try to do it as briefly as possible.
[1:06:10] In 1903, Elobarkenridge was sent from Denver
[1:06:15] by the Colorado Milling and Elevator Company
[1:06:18] to see if there was any opportunity
[1:06:21] to build mills in the Twin Falls area
[1:06:24] because the land was being opened
[1:06:26] and watered and grain was being grown.
[1:06:30] Well, the rest is history.
[1:06:32] There was an opportunity in the Magic Valley
[1:06:35] named because of the miracle of water on the land.
[1:06:40] And he built those silos that are still down by the depot grill
[1:06:45] that cannot be removed.
[1:06:47] Florence and Florence and LL were very active in the community.
[1:06:54] They helped build the old singing bridge.
[1:06:56] They built the Presbyterian Church.
[1:06:59] They brought the first suffix sheep into Idaho.
[1:07:03] They built the filer fairgrounds.
[1:07:05] My grandmother was a member of the Daughters of the Revolution.
[1:07:10] They were very active in this community, in building it, in the future.
[1:07:15] They had three children.
[1:07:17] Two of those children died at an early age.
[1:07:20] Their last son, my father, John Breckenridge, went through the school systems in Twin Falls
[1:07:27] and then got a Fulbright scholarship to this school in Pennsylvania called Swarthmore College.
[1:07:32] They gave him a Fulbright because they had never heard of Idaho.
[1:07:37] While he was there, he meant his future wife, Mary and Booth,
[1:07:43] who came from Bennington, Vermont.
[1:07:47] Her family was steeped in the arts.
[1:07:49] My grandfather was one of the founders of Bennington College.
[1:07:53] So in 1938, the East met the West, and my parents were married.
[1:07:59] These met the West every night at our dinner table
[1:08:02] from this hard, strong, Western man
[1:08:05] and this cultural New England lady.
[1:08:10] All right, now what happens?
[1:08:11] Okay, yeah, we came on the scene.
[1:08:13] There were four of us, four daughters.
[1:08:17] We all grew up on that famous farm,
[1:08:19] south of Twin Falls, or in the southern part of Twin Falls,
[1:08:22] northern part of Twin Falls,
[1:08:25] bordered by what is now North College Road,
[1:08:28] Blue Lakes Boulevard, Cheney, and now Lazy J. Mobile Park, and down through the Cang and
[1:08:37] Edge, on the west east side, bordered by Blue Lakes, and on the north side, the Cang and
[1:08:45] Rim.
[1:08:46] Miriam and John were very active in the community.
[1:08:50] But as the community chose to grow in that direction, they were asked to give of land.
[1:08:58] They gave when we first widened the pool line road in the 50s.
[1:09:01] They gave land when you widened the road, a blue lakes boulevard.
[1:09:05] They gave land again when you widened the pool line road for the second time.
[1:09:11] All the time being active in the community, helping to build the old, old hospital in the
[1:09:18] 50s, the campfire camp, the press new Presbyterian Church.
[1:09:23] They were active as a UNICEF, United Way, the lift goes on and on, and those four daughters
[1:09:30] grew up there.
[1:09:34] By 1990, the land was surrounded, the McMullens on the farm on the west had sold.
[1:09:43] Williams, the Williams Farm on the west, certainly, yeah, something like that.
[1:09:49] Williams Farm on the west had changed from a dairy to the mobile park.
[1:09:55] The college had purchased the land to the south.
[1:10:00] On the east, Blue Lakes Boulevard was now a mass of businesses, and the Barlow's sold
[1:10:07] their farm to the Neilsons and the development started.
[1:10:12] Now the farm is surrounded by the city on three sides and the canyon on the fourth edge.
[1:10:21] It became impossible to farm.
[1:10:25] And so my parents did the most noble thing that we knew how to do, and they gifted the
[1:10:30] farm to the College of Southern Idaho.
[1:10:34] All of it with the exception of some that had they had sold along Blue Lakes to give their
[1:10:41] children the education that they wanted, but the rest of it was gifted.
[1:10:47] The only stipulations on that gift was that they keep 40 acres, which is now across from
[1:10:53] the CSIS building, they requested and required that that stay in agriculture and that that
[1:11:01] developed the agricultural department at CSI. They moved to these 23 acres that you now see.
[1:11:10] Again, bear in mind, no money exchanged hands. It was all a gift. Then, mom, dad dies in 1996,
[1:11:20] dies in 1998, and my sister Susan and I inherent this land. Now they want to widen
[1:11:29] Poolline Road again. So our entrance, we went into an agreement with all of some of you,
[1:11:36] some of you who sat in those chairs, and some of you who weren't in the chairs, we rented
[1:11:41] an interim agreement. And that agreement was, you can have our entrance off Poolline Road,
[1:11:48] gift and easement or a grant an easement for the bike path. We get two entrances of Canyan Springs Road.
[1:11:57] And I think that was it. It was a win-win for everyone. And the owners on the east side said
[1:12:04] they would connect the bike path. Again, no money exchanged hands. So now we are here today
[1:12:15] because my younger sister Susan wants to sell her land. There are people in this
[1:12:22] room that do not want this land to be annexed or more than that they are very
[1:12:29] very critical of our six. If they want to control this land then they need to buy
[1:12:40] this land. The land is for sale and then they can control it and they can do what
[1:12:47] they want to do with the land. But for reasons for buffering the C1 that is why
[1:12:56] we are asking for it to be annexed and to have the reason to our six and now
[1:13:05] Now you have most of the history.
[1:13:09] Thank you.
[1:13:10] Thank you, Katie.
[1:13:14] Next we will have a staff report from senior planner Jonathan Smilov.
[1:13:20] Thank you, Mr. Mayor.
[1:13:23] I'm not going to go through the history.
[1:13:24] I think Katie did a better job than I could on the whole history on the property.
[1:13:28] The only things we talk about are the current zoning that's on there, which is R1, it was
[1:13:34] designated in 2004 with the area of impact agreement because this is not in the sea limit,
[1:13:39] So it's a very impact.
[1:13:40] And then in 2009, the City Council proved to conveyance
[1:13:43] flat, creating two lots north and south.
[1:13:46] This project or this application includes the one lot,
[1:13:52] and then includes a portion of the other lot, which
[1:13:54] is just the subtlety boundary, which
[1:13:56] kind of two parts of this annexation.
[1:13:58] But you can't get the bigger one without taking or having
[1:14:01] the smaller piece annexed.
[1:14:03] Smaller pieces is part of Katie's.
[1:14:06] It's where the bike path is.
[1:14:08] So Susan's piece is holy inside of Katie's piece.
[1:14:12] We have to kind of do a little bit of both.
[1:14:15] The annexation, I went to the Planning and Zoning Commission.
[1:14:20] I'm not going to go through the entire staff report as she
[1:14:22] kind of explained a lot of it and what we're doing here.
[1:14:25] But it's about 10 acres.
[1:14:27] I explained the two pieces of ground.
[1:14:29] City Code Section 1015, 1 and 2 require
[1:14:32] that hearing and recommendation from the Planning and Zoning
[1:14:35] Commission.
[1:14:37] And then the city council shall then hold an additional public hearing to determine whether
[1:14:40] the designated area should be annexed and if so, what the zoning designation shall be.
[1:14:45] If approved, an ordinance is prepared and at a later public meeting is adopted by the council.
[1:14:51] Once the ordinance is published and is sent to the state, an official zoning map is officially
[1:14:55] amended.
[1:14:56] So that's kind of the process.
[1:14:58] The comprehensive plan recently adopted, designate this area is appropriate for mixed
[1:15:02] use.
[1:15:03] Mixed use is a very broad category and encompasses an extensive list of land uses.
[1:15:07] However, mixed use areas are characteristically pedestrian friendly.
[1:15:11] They provide a range of uses while keeping the scaled development human friendly.
[1:15:15] The requested rezone to R6 fits that mixed use designation since it encourages a more
[1:15:20] dense residential development with pedestrian connections around it.
[1:15:25] And usually 10 to 20 dwelling units per acre while surrounded by commercial zoning.
[1:15:30] has determined the rezone request complies with the 2016 comprehensive plan.
[1:15:35] On June 13, 2017, the Planning and Zoning Commission heard and deliberated on this request.
[1:15:40] Many residents of the Breckenridge Estates Development, which is to the northeast over
[1:15:44] here, came to speak about the request to question the appropriateness of the request at R6 designation.
[1:15:52] R6 does allow for apartments or five or more units in a building.
[1:15:57] The residents raised concern of their property values
[1:16:00] and how those would be affected,
[1:16:01] as well as the piece in quite of the neighborhood
[1:16:03] and how it would be diminished.
[1:16:05] Another frequent concern was the amount of traffic
[1:16:08] and apartment complex or multiple units
[1:16:11] would bring to the area.
[1:16:12] The commission unanimously forwarded a positive recommendation
[1:16:15] with the zoning designation of R4, not R6,
[1:16:19] after deliberating and weighing the residents concerns
[1:16:21] and staff recommendation.
[1:16:23] In conclusion, council is tasked with making a decision
[1:16:26] on the annexation request for the entire 10.07 acres
[1:16:29] with a zoning designation of R6, it's zero.
[1:16:33] That is all.
[1:16:37] Jonathan, can you clarify the different densities
[1:16:42] between R6 and R4?
[1:16:45] Yeah, so it's difficult with our zoning code
[1:16:48] as we'll, there's like some development criteria,
[1:16:51] but I can clarify what our comprehensive plan points to.
[1:16:59] The comprehensive plan points to mixed use being 10 to 20,
[1:17:03] and the town neighborhood is being two to 10.
[1:17:06] So the difference between our six and our four,
[1:17:08] although allows for apartments,
[1:17:11] the actual density per acre,
[1:17:13] city code does not actually define.
[1:17:17] It really depends on how you build a building.
[1:17:21] And one of their clarifications,
[1:17:22] so the portion of this property
[1:17:25] that is within the canyon rim overlay,
[1:17:28] is that everything north of the?
[1:17:30] Yeah, it's this blue, there's this like blue hash mark
[1:17:33] that kind of goes from, oh, okay, here up,
[1:17:35] and it kind of follows this line right there.
[1:17:39] So if this were to come through with a plant in the future
[1:17:42] with the entirety of the property,
[1:17:44] fall under a ZDA or just the portion
[1:17:46] that's within the gain and removal.
[1:17:48] It entirely depends on who buys it and how they develop it.
[1:17:51] They brought something that just planted this area down here
[1:17:54] that would not come through a ZDA.
[1:17:57] But if they bought the entire thing
[1:17:58] and it was imperative that they develop
[1:18:00] the entire property of the whole thing would come through.
[1:18:05] It just kind of depends on how they developed it.
[1:18:07] It's something we don't.
[1:18:10] Thank you.
[1:18:11] Suzanne Hawkins.
[1:18:12] Thank you.
[1:18:13] So Katie mentioned that the reason she wants the R6 is so she can buffer around.
[1:18:18] Why can you buffer in R6 and not in R4?
[1:18:21] And can you help me understand what that means exactly?
[1:18:24] Yeah.
[1:18:25] So the R4 allows outright basically some duplexes.
[1:18:28] four plexes and three triplexes or special uses.
[1:18:33] It doesn't allow more than that in the zone at all.
[1:18:36] So you would get maybe two plexes or triplexes if there are four,
[1:18:41] and then you'd go from there down to two or one.
[1:18:45] I think she was talking of phasing the development from this point
[1:18:48] all the way to the rim or from this point,
[1:18:50] at least to this property line.
[1:18:51] You could phase in the R4.
[1:18:55] It's just a difficult thing to do, I guess.
[1:18:58] but I don't understand the buffer part of it.
[1:19:01] She's, you'd have to ask what her intent was on that, but.
[1:19:05] So, but you can buffer in R4 as well as R6, correct?
[1:19:09] You can buffer from a four-plex down to a single family doing unit,
[1:19:11] an R4 outright permitted today.
[1:19:13] Okay.
[1:19:14] And then in the R6, you could go from a larger down.
[1:19:17] Yeah, from R6, you could go from five or more units, or, you know, ten units,
[1:19:21] as many as you can hold on the property down to single back.
[1:19:24] Okay. And hasn't it been kind of our history recently that when we're
[1:19:29] budding up to C1 that that is what we have kind of recommended for most
[1:19:34] neighborhoods? That's something that we've definitely talked about in the
[1:19:38] comprehensive plan is having that from C1 to residential. There's got to be
[1:19:42] something in between. Higher density apartments is one of those things that
[1:19:46] you can have along C1 given the nature of how they're built. You could also have
[1:19:51] other things but it's definitely something we talk about in our currently adopted
[1:19:56] company. Whether we go R4, R6 there's still no commercial then that would be
[1:20:02] allowed in that property. Yeah as it currently stands in those zones that's
[1:20:06] correct. Okay thank you. Chris Dott. A little more clarification Jonathan on the
[1:20:11] CRO we can see the division line right there and yet no matter if it's a
[1:20:18] complete development or phased lot by lot or subdivided anything in that CRO
[1:20:25] still has to meet the requirements set back size usage of the CRO. That's great
[1:20:32] including the corner that is contiguous to the R4, Breckenridge.
[1:20:38] Yes including this area right now. Okay I want to get that I think that's an important point.
[1:20:44] any other questions for Jonathan. Okay so we will turn this over now to the public
[1:21:00] hearing public input portion of the public hearing. Thank you. So I do have
[1:21:06] some folks who have signed up. Leah did you want to speak on this item? Randy
[1:21:17] Steele. Last name starts with a B. Nope. You're welcome to speak still. I'm just
[1:21:33] going through the list of folks who have signed up first.
[1:21:36] So did you want to take your opportunity to speak?
[1:21:39] Okay.
[1:21:40] Tom Tucker.
[1:21:41] Welcome.
[1:21:42] Come on forward and again, if we could please limit the comments to two minutes, we would appreciate
[1:21:54] that.
[1:21:55] Sure.
[1:21:56] Tom Tucker, I live in Breckenridge.
[1:21:57] I have to be the president of the Homeowners Association, so I'm representing about 60 degree
[1:22:02] for the residents in that area.
[1:22:04] We had a great meeting, I came,
[1:22:06] many came to the finding and zoning committee meeting.
[1:22:09] And I'm a little confused because Katie at the end said,
[1:22:13] we would feel great about our board,
[1:22:15] we'd felt great about our board,
[1:22:17] we thought that's what the agreement was.
[1:22:19] And we're a little concerned about the change of art,
[1:22:21] but our main concern about this is traffic.
[1:22:24] And we talked about that, we addressed it before.
[1:22:28] You talked about it earlier today,
[1:22:29] to the struggle between blue lakes and on pole line and blue lakes.
[1:22:37] I just made a comment.
[1:22:39] I moved from Utah up here to get away from the traffic.
[1:22:41] And now I'm coming home.
[1:22:43] There's two or three times.
[1:22:44] And people are starting to cut in through the C1 area just
[1:22:47] to get back to their homes by the commercial tire
[1:22:52] on the corner by Costco in that area there.
[1:22:54] yourself. Others may talk from our board or from our community but that was our main concern
[1:23:03] was the noise and the traffic and the impact of that in our area. We feel like the Breckenridge
[1:23:09] is a great community to live in and we don't want to diminish from that. Thank you.
[1:23:16] Thank you. Next is a Grant Starly. Nope. Okay. So that's everybody who signed up. So,
[1:23:28] anyone else who wishes to address the council this issue come on forward and please state
[1:23:32] your name and whether you are a resident or property owner in the City of Twin Falls
[1:23:39] for the record.
[1:23:40] I'm Jim Stevens. I'm president of the Pregum Bridge III of States HOA. That's the one here
[1:23:52] in yellow. Right adjoining this development. Can I have the people in my subdivision raise
[1:23:59] their hands?
[1:24:00] I would first like to point out in the minutes of the July 13th P&Z meeting that I provided
[1:24:09] several petitions against this request, I in fact provided a hundred percent of the residents
[1:24:15] of the Rekka Ridge States III.
[1:24:16] I also presented the petitions from the manager of Serenga Place, and Glendy was senior living
[1:24:24] here and 20 of the residents against this request.
[1:24:29] said that our residents are fine with the change from R1 to R4 designation with the
[1:24:35] stipulation that the plant be consistent and similar to our neighborhood as we are
[1:24:39] R4. This R4 recommendation from B&Z appeared to satisfy the applicant as she
[1:24:46] publicly stated that at the 13th meeting. We trust this body will follow the
[1:24:52] unanimous positive recommendation of planning and zoning for an R4 designation
[1:24:58] not an R6.
[1:25:03] Thank you.
[1:25:04] Anyone else wishing to speak on this issue?
[1:25:10] It is not.
[1:25:11] This is a public hearing on a land use issue.
[1:25:15] There will as when we get to the conclusion of the agenda, we still have the budget presentation
[1:25:19] and a couple of other items.
[1:25:21] Anyone else wishing to speak on this issue?
[1:25:28] Seeing no one, we will close the public input portion of the public hearing and we will
[1:25:34] provide an opportunity to Katie, should you wish to address any of the comments that were made there?
[1:25:39] Thank you, I do. And they are correct in saying that I was and Robert's supportive of our four when we left.
[1:25:51] Since that time, there have been two very intense incidents on our property.
[1:25:56] Someone in the last two weeks jumped the fence and cut down six to seven of our eight ten-foot trees.
[1:26:06] the border, the property between Greckenridge's states, and our land. Someone entered our property
[1:26:14] and destroyed our property. The second incident happened about three or four nights ago. The
[1:26:22] man that has taken care of this property for 18 years for us is one of the senior loan
[1:26:28] officers in one of the largest banks, ag lending banks, in Magic Valley, and his name is Jeff
[1:26:36] off the crossboard. Jeff walked down to the edge of the property towards the Breckenridge
[1:26:43] States side to get his lawnmower that's in a shed there. He was met by two people on the
[1:26:52] other side of the fence that said, where's our dog? We've lost our dog. The gist to paraphrase
[1:27:01] what happened was that Jeff said, I don't know where your dog is, we don't have your
[1:27:07] dog. The alfalfa field on our property had just been cut and his dogs were out there running
[1:27:14] around and chasing mice, they're small hunting dogs. Jeff said, if I see your dog, I'll let
[1:27:21] you know. He got in the lawn mower, wrote it back to the house, turned around and looked
[1:27:27] And one of the individuals the man had climbed over the fence
[1:27:31] and was now out on our property.
[1:27:34] Jeff went back up there, said, asked him what he was doing.
[1:27:38] And the gentleman in a very arrogant and rude way accused
[1:27:42] Jeff's dogs of killing his dog.
[1:27:45] And if the dog was out there, he knew it was out there.
[1:27:48] And he was going to call the police and report Jeff.
[1:27:54] Jeff said your dog's not out there.
[1:27:56] But go ahead if you want to walk out, but please don't climb over the fence because it's
[1:28:01] a woven wire fence and when you climb over it you mash it down.
[1:28:06] So he went back, the man walked around the property, did not find his dead dog, walked
[1:28:12] back over, climbed back over the fence, did not go through the gates that are never locked
[1:28:18] and left.
[1:28:20] people, and I immediately changed my feeling of wanting to work with them.
[1:28:27] Over the years, this land has been worked and cared for by neighbors.
[1:28:35] If these are the types of neighbors that are in this area,
[1:28:40] then again, they should buy the land and control it the way they want to.
[1:28:45] They should not ask a 68-year-old woman, my sister,
[1:28:51] to keep it in open space, or let them control the use of the land, and ask her to be responsible
[1:29:00] for their lifestyles.
[1:29:02] So yes, I changed my mind, yes, I did.
[1:29:07] It should be in our six so that other people can enjoy the land.
[1:29:13] This land has been in my family for over 100 years.
[1:29:19] This land has been blessed by all types of people, working together, neighbors, helping
[1:29:26] neighbors, people from all walks of life working together through the good times and
[1:29:33] the tough times.
[1:29:35] Land that has been blessed by the miracle of water, the dedication of hard work and dreams.
[1:29:43] fueled by the principles of integrity and honesty and hard work, and if you do that the land
[1:29:53] will give you many rewards. This is the legacy of this land. If the individuals in this room
[1:30:03] and the individuals that they represent say that they represent want to control this land
[1:30:10] then they need to buy it and change the legacy
[1:30:15] to match their values.
[1:30:18] We will watch now as you vote on what
[1:30:22] will be the potential use of my sister's plans.
[1:30:27] Thank you.
[1:30:29] Thank you, Katie.
[1:30:32] No, you can't.
[1:30:34] So we had the public input portion,
[1:30:36] and then this was a rebuttal portion
[1:30:39] for her to answer the questions that were brought up
[1:30:41] by the public input, and now it's, to be perfectly honest,
[1:30:47] I didn't hear a direct accusation at any one of you.
[1:30:50] I heard her laying up a story of why she changed her mind,
[1:30:53] which was the response she was getting.
[1:30:56] Chris talking to you.
[1:30:57] I'm not doing a little clarification.
[1:30:59] Now R4 allows duplexes outright,
[1:31:02] and four plexes upon special permit.
[1:31:06] Yeah, let me pull up the code real quick.
[1:31:07] Thank you.
[1:31:08] I believe that's correct.
[1:31:21] So R4 allows detapsing,
[1:31:23] Attached single household, detached single household duplexes outright, and triplexes and
[1:31:31] foreplexes through a special use permit.
[1:31:33] And RSX allows what?
[1:31:35] Our sex.
[1:31:36] It allows permitted.
[1:31:40] Attached single, detached single duplexes, multiple household, which is your five units
[1:31:46] or more per building, or five units or more per project, triplexes and foreplexes outright
[1:31:51] permitted.
[1:31:53] Thank you.
[1:31:56] Great landing.
[1:31:57] No, see right there.
[1:32:05] What is allowed in the CRO?
[1:32:07] The Kingdom overlay basically allows that which is permitted outright in the underlying zone.
[1:32:13] So you have your base zone, in this case, right now it's R1, whatever we change it to later.
[1:32:20] And then it overlays on top of it and says those uses that are permitted are still permitted,
[1:32:25] but then it further restricts development in a certain manner.
[1:32:28] It requires a zoning development agreement, so the ZDA, multiple public hearings again.
[1:32:35] It requires that ZDA process, as you know, kind of, it's an intensive design-driven type
[1:32:40] of process.
[1:32:42] And then it goes further to prohibit some other types of uses, I can go through that
[1:32:48] list, but it really just makes it even more restrictive in terms of height, setback, the
[1:32:54] way things look.
[1:32:55] It's more of a design type of deal.
[1:32:56] Well, I guess the question I would have because you're talking about it allows the underlying zone
[1:33:03] Would it allow a fiber more within the strategy and development? Yes with without right?
[1:33:11] Yes, any any residential use so any apartment or duplex triplex or plex any residential use permitted in the zoning
[1:33:20] district upon which the overlay is placed
[1:33:22] Okay, because I never, well, the last one of the questions, I guess this is my comment
[1:33:28] time, it's my question time.
[1:33:33] Is it, as a council, may we zone the portion outside of the CRO R6 and the portion inside
[1:33:43] the CRR4?
[1:33:45] You could, you have the right to zone the property how you wish in this, for this piece
[1:33:52] of your ground, I believe, yeah.
[1:33:54] And then the last question I have the piece of property.
[1:33:57] If you look at the map that the, yes, Mr. Stevens,
[1:34:03] the piece of property that seems to be a bare lot,
[1:34:06] which is right at the corner, and we know whether that is,
[1:34:13] okay, so it's going to be built on?
[1:34:15] Yeah.
[1:34:16] Okay, thank you.
[1:34:17] That was my question.
[1:34:18] Okay, thank you.
[1:34:20] Okay.
[1:34:21] Chris Street.
[1:34:26] Jonathan.
[1:34:27] All right, so I guess the question I had, a lot of the discussion came up with traffic
[1:34:40] flow and that is an issue in that area.
[1:34:43] What are the access points to this property?
[1:34:46] Where are we looking at access points?
[1:34:48] You're looking access on to Harrison and access on both sides.
[1:34:51] So the Fillmore side is going to have access?
[1:34:53] Yes.
[1:34:54] There's a public, I'm pretty sure.
[1:35:02] Okay.
[1:35:03] There's like a little access road that stops right in there.
[1:35:07] Okay, perfect.
[1:35:08] Thank you.
[1:35:10] Greg, did you have another?
[1:35:11] Oh, sorry.
[1:35:27] So, Jonathan, in response to Greg's question about, could you designate different zonings
[1:35:34] for different pieces of the property?
[1:35:35] So, in reading the minutes from the planning and zoning, hearing that question was asked,
[1:35:40] and Fritz explained that he would not recommend that approach.
[1:35:45] It's tricky, but he was answering to the count of a mission at that point.
[1:35:52] They were recced their task is what's the zoning that would be appropriate.
[1:35:57] Okay.
[1:35:58] And then I'm going to have to look at the attorney whether or not you could actually do that.
[1:36:00] I'm looking at Mitch.
[1:36:01] I mean, that's not good.
[1:36:03] I just wanted to just point it out.
[1:36:06] James, you're...
[1:36:07] Chris, you have to have to be surveyed anywhere to delineate.
[1:36:10] Does that meet some bounds on the thing?
[1:36:13] I think you can clarify a couple things.
[1:36:15] I think Chris is hitting exactly the point is that you would have to have some kind of
[1:36:20] a line between the two that isn't in our application. It's a possibility to do that.
[1:36:27] The other clarification I wanted to make in response to Greg's question is you can't
[1:36:33] really zone anything you want. But the request is for R6. It was notified as a public hearing
[1:36:41] to consider R6. So the council could approve R6 or anything less restricted or less not
[1:36:48] restrictive, less intensive. So you couldn't, for example, say we're going to prove it as
[1:36:52] C1. Right. But you could say R4, portion R4 or two, something like that. So not anything
[1:36:59] is option, or not any option is available, but there are options available. Nothing more
[1:37:05] restrictive or nothing more intensive. Okay. Chris talked. Well, I don't know, Susan, I
[1:37:12] asked the question, so I'm going to write my question. I have a motion. Jonathan, I know
[1:37:16] you can't answer this exactly but with just less than 10 acres if it did go R6
[1:37:23] just to get filling how many bodies how many what kind of traffic are we is
[1:37:30] there any way to have any until somebody brings a development with
[1:37:33] something I don't have anything to give you other than what zones I mean somebody
[1:37:41] could bring something way less intensive but until it's actually designed but if
[1:37:48] If we, if we okay, our six, the residents in that section of town have no other voice about
[1:37:55] how those are designed or how they're laid out or.
[1:37:58] If their project comes in that includes any area in that CRO, there will be more public
[1:38:04] hearings to design the project itself.
[1:38:07] But there's a lot of unknowns.
[1:38:10] Yeah, right now you're strictly dealing with what the zoning is, which allows some permissive
[1:38:16] and some special uses.
[1:38:18] Mitch.
[1:38:19] The last apartment complex we approved to be developed in town was a five-acre complex
[1:38:27] with 60 units.
[1:38:28] It's fairly low, it could have been more dense than that.
[1:38:36] This is 10 acres, so if it followed the suit, it could be 120 units, but again, that could
[1:38:44] have been more dense than it was.
[1:38:47] So, but that's what the last one that came through us.
[1:38:54] No idea if that's what will happen here.
[1:38:56] For multiple, for five or more unit apartments.
[1:39:01] So not something that would be allowed in R4,
[1:39:04] but would be allowed in R6.
[1:39:05] R4 is gonna cap you at four places.
[1:39:10] Vice-peccity is permitted.
[1:39:15] Chris, talking to you.
[1:39:16] Yeah, this is a pretty unusual situation
[1:39:19] for the council I have to face.
[1:39:21] for the city effect and zoning, we have 50% or more of it
[1:39:25] in C1 already, another, I don't know, 40% or so,
[1:39:32] 30% in professional in a very small corner
[1:39:36] that abuts the R4.
[1:39:39] I find it as unconscionable to impose this R6
[1:39:44] on a great deal that R4, as I do the idea of an R4
[1:39:48] going against the C-1 and the pro, but I think that what happens to the land to the north of
[1:39:56] it in the still on the next Canyon Room Part R1, I guess it is, is going to be a whole different
[1:40:03] spiel that's going to positively impact the current Bracken Ridge residents more along the lines
[1:40:11] of what they think about. Folks, as far as traffic getting a problem, this ain't Twin
[1:40:17] falls 1940 and we're heading for 50,000 and I don't know any place that's going to be quiet
[1:40:23] until we get into electric vehicles. I'm going to throw a motion on the floor to approve an
[1:40:30] annexation and a zoning district change and zoning map amendment for the approximate 9.75
[1:40:37] acres to be rezoned or six currently zoned or one variable for the property located east
[1:40:43] to Harrison Street and North of King and Falls drive.
[1:40:50] I'll second it to get it on the table.
[1:40:53] It's been motioned by Chris Toggington, seconded
[1:40:55] by Suzanne Hawkins to basically approve the request
[1:40:59] as requested with the R6 zoning.
[1:41:05] Suzanne Hawkins.
[1:41:07] I'm very conflicted.
[1:41:09] I understand the concerns of the neighborhood
[1:41:13] out there in the traffic in that area.
[1:41:15] But at the same time as the council,
[1:41:18] We've been pushing for different types of affordable housing
[1:41:22] for the workforce wanting to come to our community.
[1:41:25] And I see this area as a place for young entrepreneurs
[1:41:31] and people coming here for jobs
[1:41:33] who want to live close to the canyon.
[1:41:35] They don't want single family homes.
[1:41:38] They want to live in some kind of a multiple home unit
[1:41:41] where they're part of a community,
[1:41:42] where they're still in walking distance
[1:41:44] and they have connection to the bike path
[1:41:46] and everything we have on that side of town going,
[1:41:49] and we've been begging developers
[1:41:51] to give us that type of housing in our community.
[1:41:54] The same time is this the right place for it.
[1:41:58] I don't know how you judge that
[1:41:59] without knowing what the future plans are,
[1:42:02] but it seems like what we've been asking for,
[1:42:06] so I kind of feel hypocritical on both sides of the issue,
[1:42:09] and I'm really not sure what the answer is,
[1:42:12] and I'd like to hear from the rest of you.
[1:42:18] Greg Lanting?
[1:42:19] Well, what's the same being as Suzanne?
[1:42:21] I mean, we, I understand the concerns of the neighborhood,
[1:42:28] or they doubt about it, but I really don't understand
[1:42:32] the part of the permission that they talk,
[1:42:34] they're petitioned, they talked about on the area
[1:42:37] that's already C1.
[1:42:38] I mean that C1 lets them basically do anything
[1:42:42] they want to do, and so I'm kind of,
[1:42:45] that's kind of concerning.
[1:42:47] We have been approving larger.
[1:42:49] So, he's talking about the adjacent property and again, we're now at the council debate
[1:42:58] of this issue.
[1:43:01] The, I'm sorry, my apologies.
[1:43:06] Okay.
[1:43:08] We have been approving multifamily units next to C1 as a buffer to C1.
[1:43:16] That's been something we have done multiple times here as a matter of practice.
[1:43:22] And then matter as our current grantee plan
[1:43:25] suggests we do that.
[1:43:27] People are not going to want to build a $300 in dollar house
[1:43:31] next to us commercial venture.
[1:43:32] We understand that.
[1:43:33] And that's the reason we most often approve
[1:43:39] multi-family units next to C1, or even the pro area.
[1:43:46] They're the parking lot.
[1:43:49] I don't think I would want to build a house next to the parking
[1:43:51] lot either.
[1:43:52] And so I see that this is going to have to be some sort of multifamily for it to be feasible.
[1:43:58] I don't see it being, if you try to put it in as a, even maybe you'd like to see my work,
[1:44:05] townhounds of my work.
[1:44:07] Again, I'm, I'm, I'm afflicted.
[1:44:12] I really would like to, and I guess I'm getting the mental advice that we, or not a legal advice,
[1:44:20] not mental, legal, excuse me, to, that we shouldn't do.
[1:44:24] to divide the area is R6 around the north half,
[1:44:30] assuming the south half, and then the part in the CRO
[1:44:33] is R4, because that would solve the problem.
[1:44:36] As far as I can see, the part that abuts the next
[1:44:38] to the current R4 would still be R4,
[1:44:43] and the part that abuts the RC1 would then be R6.
[1:44:48] And I think it solves the problem.
[1:44:51] And so before we get done, I may make that amendment.
[1:44:54] and we'll figure it out.
[1:44:55] It may not be easy, but I think it's something we could do.
[1:45:01] Christopher Reed.
[1:45:04] So before we had this, looking at planning and zoning's notes
[1:45:09] and seeing what their thoughts were,
[1:45:12] some of the comments that were made,
[1:45:15] traffic flow was a big issue.
[1:45:17] That is a very difficult road, getting in and out
[1:45:20] of pole line on.
[1:45:22] That's something on planning and zoning
[1:45:24] we discussed multiple times over the couple of years I was on there.
[1:45:31] And my heart breaks for you guys that happened.
[1:45:34] The trees, the individual shouldn't have happened.
[1:45:37] And so I feel bad that that did happen and you had to change your mind.
[1:45:43] I think R6 is too high.
[1:45:47] I think R4 fits in that area very well.
[1:45:50] You can buffer it very well with C1.
[1:45:54] Again, that's a small area.
[1:45:57] The roads are already in place.
[1:45:58] Getting in and out of Pull-Line is very difficult.
[1:46:01] We have issues.
[1:46:02] We don't get a sing on Pull-Line where they let you in and out on.
[1:46:06] And so I'm not in favor of R6.
[1:46:10] I'm in favor of R4, though.
[1:46:26] Nikki Boy.
[1:46:29] Mitch, Shane, Travis, Jonathan, realistically,
[1:46:37] can we do R6 and then R4 and the Can You
[1:46:41] room overlay realistically.
[1:46:45] So if that is a direction that you would choose to go, we would ask that you hold on
[1:46:54] making a decision on the zoning until legal counsel is with us next week.
[1:46:59] This week fits us on vacation.
[1:47:02] Move to table motion.
[1:47:05] Second.
[1:47:07] It's worth the research.
[1:47:08] So we have a motion to- Right now, we've checked off everybody.
[1:47:13] I have a motion to table this to a future meeting because I'm going to guess that it's
[1:47:20] going to need to be notified and all of that again correct or not.
[1:47:27] So you've completed the public hearing process and there is no process.
[1:47:32] We would notice it by putting it on the normal agenda.
[1:47:36] It would not be under the public hearing piece.
[1:47:39] it would be under items of consideration because you would be moving to actually take an action.
[1:47:46] So the process by land used to hold it public hearing has been fulfilled and the action can
[1:47:55] wait until next week.
[1:47:58] But what is important is you cannot take any new additional testimony, you cannot open it
[1:48:05] up for public conversation. As much as you may want to and as much as the public may want
[1:48:11] to without going through an additional public hearing process, you must make your decision
[1:48:17] based upon the record that is before you at the time in which you close the public hearing.
[1:48:25] You are allowed to engage with legal counsel as an exception to that rule.
[1:48:31] But we cannot take phone calls or emails from citizens at this point?
[1:48:35] No, not ever got it. Thank you. All right, so there's a motion to
[1:48:43] Table point of clarification
[1:48:46] That's the right way to say this
[1:48:48] so they're asking for annexation and
[1:48:52] Our six does that go hand-in-hand?
[1:48:57] It's a request for annexation and a recommended zoning. We have to take on motion isn't supposed to be debatable
[1:49:08] Well, we're not debating that motion, Chris, we're debating how we're going to move forward
[1:49:12] with this.
[1:49:13] It looks like we're debating amongst ourselves.
[1:49:16] I'm asking questions, I'm just saying, we're deciding.
[1:49:21] So the action by the council is annexation with a zoning designation of blank, film the
[1:49:28] blank.
[1:49:29] Okay.
[1:49:30] So it's a two part question.
[1:49:31] Current zoning is R1, that's an option, leave it as it is, requested zoning is R6, recommendation
[1:49:38] from P&Z is our four that's that's the task all right so we had a motion to
[1:49:50] table this do we have to do something with the first motion in seconds no so
[1:50:00] so in terms of so we don't technically follow a hard and fast
[1:50:06] Robert's rules of order but but the the most recent motion on the floor is the
[1:50:14] one made by Mr. Talkington. And if that motion were to pass all of the other
[1:50:18] motions are removed from the docket for consideration this evening.
[1:50:26] I seconded it, I wasn't taking notes fast enough.
[1:50:32] All right, Sharon, roll call vote on the table in the item, please.
[1:50:36] Christopher Reed? No.
[1:50:45] Chris Talkington? Yes.
[1:50:47] John Berriger. Yes. Nicky Boyd. Yes.
[1:51:02] Suzanne Hawkins. Yes. Greg Lanting. Yes.
[1:51:09] Yes. Yes. Motion passes 621. Mr. Mayor. Yes, sir.
[1:51:17] Just for information and for the members of the audience, we will have this placed on the agenda for next week and we will place that at the top of the agenda
[1:51:28] that of consideration for those who came this evening.
[1:51:35] Thank you.
[1:51:36] You all understand that folks next week?
[1:51:41] All right, so I'm gonna suggest that we adjourn
[1:51:45] for about seven minutes, take a quick break,
[1:51:48] and then we will come back.
[1:51:50] We still have the budget presentation
[1:51:52] as well as the general public input following that.
[1:51:55] So we will recess until seven o'clock.
[1:52:01] be unprecedented and have a survey of them.
[2:02:20] Yep, good.
[2:02:22] All right, we will reconvene the City Council meeting.
[2:02:25] It's five minutes after seven.
[2:02:27] The next item on the agenda is a presentation of the city
[2:02:32] manager's recommended budget for fiscal year 2018,
[2:02:36] followed by citizen input.
[2:02:39] Deputy City Manager Mitch Humble.
[2:02:40] All right, so buckle in.
[2:02:42] We got about an hour of this.
[2:02:43] So, last week you got your staff report from Travis and didn't change anything, so we just
[2:02:53] like moved the report over to this week.
[2:02:55] So it says 60 minutes in there, but Travis didn't stick to the 60 minutes last week.
[2:03:00] I'm not going to stick to it this week.
[2:03:01] I'm just going to go the other way.
[2:03:02] Hopefully we'll go fast.
[2:03:03] You promise.
[2:03:04] So, and you'll notice that the slides look similar to until after this one.
[2:03:14] This is right then they start to look different.
[2:03:16] So this just says that with our budget, we have all kinds of links to our strategic plan.
[2:03:23] In fact, if you don't have a link to the strategic plan, then we're going to really question
[2:03:27] why it's in the budget in the first place, and that's kind of what we're getting here.
[2:03:32] Okay, so this looks different, you can tell.
[2:03:34] So basically tonight we're going to talk about the two highlighted focus areas.
[2:03:37] The rest of them are kind of downplayed, and we're going to talk about accessible community
[2:03:41] and environmental community.
[2:03:42] First, I can talk about the accessible community.
[2:03:46] So these are the things that we've included in the budget, the notable conversations in
[2:03:51] the budget that help us further the accessible community goals.
[2:03:54] So right here we have the, this is language pulled straight out of the strategic plan that
[2:03:58] talks about our accessible community goals.
[2:04:01] And it basically, it's roadways, I'm not going to read it, I'll tell you, but it's roadways,
[2:04:07] it's halfway sidewalks, those kinds of things that help make our community accessible to
[2:04:12] more of the goals that are in the strategic plan.
[2:04:18] We've got some great projects that help us further those goals.
[2:04:21] So right here is just a big old list of them.
[2:04:23] So if you'll remember last year, actually the current fiscal year budget,
[2:04:27] we adopted the sidewalk reconstruction matching approach.
[2:04:31] We're going to continue that next year, so about $55,000.
[2:04:35] We're going to keep that going a second here.
[2:04:40] We've got some opticon improvements to our traffic signals.
[2:04:42] Opticon is that thing that sees the higher trucks come in,
[2:04:46] and it switches so that they can move through efficiently
[2:04:49] and really foul up the traffic for everybody else.
[2:04:53] That's really not the intended.
[2:04:55] It's an emergency response.
[2:04:57] So we've got some signal improvements in there.
[2:04:59] ADA improvements, these are ramps in the sidewalks, ramps
[2:05:04] at the corners.
[2:05:05] So we typically fund several ADA improvements each year.
[2:05:09] oftentimes we're able to maximize those dollars by adding some mighty grants and things like
[2:05:14] that with them and those really go a long ways.
[2:05:17] I don't know if any of you tried crossing the street, crossing Washington at Caswell,
[2:05:23] particularly in the morning when kids are doing it.
[2:05:26] That's a much needed crossing signal number funding day.
[2:05:30] The Canons rings road, we talked about that here a number of times so we're going to be
[2:05:34] funding some road improvements but also some rim stabilization at $1.7 million.
[2:05:39] The street department has a variety of capital improvements,
[2:05:44] including the new zipper, a brine maker, a snow plow, blade, and standing bed,
[2:05:50] and those total up all of them to $236,000.
[2:05:53] And then street construction, as talking to Travis about this earlier,
[2:05:57] and Jackie, I'm going to talk about it.
[2:05:59] We affectionately call this Dean's money.
[2:06:02] And you guys have probably offered that, right?
[2:06:04] This is my name's money.
[2:06:06] So this is the variety of street projects
[2:06:08] that come up each year and that Dean programs and John,
[2:06:12] they program this $927,000 for street construction each year.
[2:06:17] And then LED lighting, retrofits, and improvements
[2:06:20] for our street lights.
[2:06:21] This is probably probably should have said this
[2:06:24] earlier.
[2:06:25] Several projects on the list.
[2:06:26] I'm going to be talking about these two folks,
[2:06:28] I would say, accessible and environmental.
[2:06:31] Several projects on this list really kind of blur the line
[2:06:33] between focus areas.
[2:06:37] Street lighting is a good one.
[2:06:38] It's very easily can be considered a secure community focus.
[2:06:43] The zipper talks about, in our environmental section,
[2:06:46] we talk about reusing materials that we take out
[2:06:50] of roads, and the zipper helps us do that.
[2:06:52] And so that zipper could be an environmental focus.
[2:06:56] It could be an accessible focus,
[2:06:57] because it helps maintain a road base.
[2:07:00] We'll see lots of overlap between projects.
[2:07:04] At the airport, we have several projects that we're going to fund the new RF vehicle, that's
[2:07:09] the firefighting response vehicle that we're going to be at.
[2:07:11] Then we've got taxiway A designing construction.
[2:07:13] And taxiway is not the one that we talked about earlier tonight.
[2:07:17] That's the internal kind of the taxiway is the main taxiway that takes you off the runway
[2:07:24] back up to it.
[2:07:25] We're going to redesign and construct that.
[2:07:27] With accessible community, we have no new funded positions in this year's budget, not that there were those requested
[2:07:36] So that's kind of just the brief little summary
[2:07:40] About the things the highlights that we're including in addition to this we've got operational budgets for various departments that are going to be doing
[2:07:47] You know street repairs and sidewalk
[2:07:50] So this past year in the sidewalk match program, how many people did we have applied for that
[2:08:02] and how much of that money did we use?
[2:08:04] I'm going to be better than I do.
[2:08:12] I do recall we had something in the payables not long ago so I know at least one person used
[2:08:17] it.
[2:08:22] I can't remember and I know the question is coming.
[2:08:25] I know that there's been only a handful, probably four or five.
[2:08:29] I wish I knew the exact amount, I can find that out and I will get it.
[2:08:32] Okay, did we use all the money we put in there?
[2:08:34] No.
[2:08:35] No, there's still money available.
[2:08:37] So do you think it's going to grow in use?
[2:08:39] Do we need to keep putting that much in there?
[2:08:41] I mean, sorry Travis.
[2:08:43] I guess we'll go over to...
[2:08:48] Yeah, I would say that the program is growing.
[2:08:51] We probably need to put together another advertising campaign so people know a little bit more about it.
[2:08:56] I will also point out that when we came out with the money was
[2:08:59] towards the end of the construction season.
[2:09:02] Okay.
[2:09:02] And then this construction season has been booming so far.
[2:09:05] So for people to find contractors and get bids,
[2:09:07] it's probably been challenging.
[2:09:09] So it might not just be a lack of interest or lack of finances.
[2:09:13] It might be a bunch of things.
[2:09:14] So I guess I would suggest that it's the programs
[2:09:17] and its emphasis in community.
[2:09:19] Okay.
[2:09:20] If I continue to try to improve it.
[2:09:22] Thank you.
[2:09:23] But we don't need more money at this point.
[2:09:25] Okay.
[2:09:27] Chris Stockton.
[2:09:28] I've been talking about this project on and off and on for three, four years now, and
[2:09:33] I think Jackie, Mitch, John, all of you need input on this, but I really think despite the
[2:09:40] fact we don't have any money necessarily put aside for it, we need to address the East
[2:09:46] Five Point reconfiguration for the westbound truck traffic that are trying to get on to
[2:09:52] Currently, they come to East Five Points, go up Main Street for two or three blocks in
[2:09:59] front of the old license motors, flip a left on whatever that road is, tear up the pavement,
[2:10:04] slow down the traffic to go over a block, a half and then do a right to get on there.
[2:10:12] I realize that there's traffic signal reconfigurations, ITD needs to be brought into it, but I would
[2:10:19] personally really like to at least have this on the agenda so that that's a note
[2:10:24] next year that we need to work on it, communicate, have meetings, whatever. I
[2:10:29] mean we're talking about earlier, I can't even remember where I saw it today of
[2:10:34] providing better traffic flow for trucks on the south side of town and this is a
[2:10:41] case right now where it's a bottleneck. So that's the five-point reconfiguration.
[2:10:50] Especially when you're having the winter parade, they have a lot of time getting through there.
[2:10:56] Yeah.
[2:10:57] We're sitting on the fire truck watching them come up there and try to turn and everybody's set up for the parade.
[2:11:03] And that made us realize that that's where they're, that's how they get them in a docket.
[2:11:09] It's like coming in off the highway or off of Kimberly Road.
[2:11:15] the street construction projects here so these would not include any of the
[2:11:20] potential for gone funds that we discussed in Travis's just be the typical
[2:11:26] business the projects that they're gonna do right here not those four and a half
[2:11:30] million dollars or actually it was right
[2:11:33] more questions on this because I'm about to change I don't see any more
[2:11:42] Okay, so the second one we want to talk for a little tonight was the environmental community.
[2:11:49] This focus area in the strategic plan really talks about our natural setting that we're in.
[2:11:56] We've got this amazing canyon and beautiful vistas and clean air that we breathe,
[2:12:03] and all those kinds of things that make Twin Falls one of those special places to live.
[2:12:10] So the environmental community goals are those that help us take care of our environment.
[2:12:15] And so we have several opportunities that are budget funded for the coming year that help us with our environment.
[2:12:27] The first of them up there is the operational contract with CH to it to operate our wastewater treatment plant.
[2:12:35] That's a big chunk of money every year that represents about a third of the wastewater budget.
[2:12:41] and they do a fantastic job for us.
[2:12:46] The second one is our debt payments.
[2:12:47] I know it's just why I put that up there
[2:12:49] because this is a big conchonka money.
[2:12:51] It's three and a half million dollars.
[2:12:54] Another about third of our wastewater budget.
[2:12:57] And just to reiterate what we've done with our wastewater
[2:13:01] treatment plan, that's a massive improvement
[2:13:04] that we've recently completed down there.
[2:13:06] It gives us the ability for growth in him.
[2:13:09] You could say that that's a overlay with our overlap
[2:13:12] with our prosperous community think that allows us to have more opportunity to grow and develop
[2:13:16] presidentially and commercially as well.
[2:13:18] But in the meantime we've got that famous that we got to make and we budget for those
[2:13:22] we pay those.
[2:13:23] We've got 340,000 rebate last week, big check.
[2:13:31] PIMaster Plan is another, it's funny if you open up the budget document and you look
[2:13:38] at PIMaster Plan there's a strategic plan goal that it references and it's not an environmental
[2:13:43] It's a different focus area than the reference, but I wanted to bring it up here because we're
[2:13:55] taking pottable water out of the irrigation purposes and we're giving the ability for
[2:14:00] water conservation that we're talking about, which really is an environmental community
[2:14:06] focus.
[2:14:07] We have our annual trash pick up and recycling contract with PSI coming up.
[2:14:13] That's going to come with it, some new pilot programs for the smaller cans, and that's about
[2:14:20] a $1.8 million cost that we're looking at.
[2:14:22] We've got water debt payments as well for some, again, some big environmental projects.
[2:14:27] The arsenic pipeline, the pristine springs acquisition, there's a variety of little construction
[2:14:32] products that are also included in that $2.8 million worth of payment.
[2:14:37] We've got a reorganization to our code enforcement department.
[2:14:42] First, I didn't think that was necessarily environmental community, but then when you look in the strategic plan for environmental community, it talks about code enforcement.
[2:14:50] And those guys getting out there and keeping those properties up to codes and mowing weeds and stuff like that.
[2:14:57] And what we're doing with re-organization is we're putting Sean in the police department.
[2:15:02] We're giving them animal control and it's going to be this much more comprehensive and seamless and efficient kind of program.
[2:15:09] And we think he's going to be able to get a lot more done.
[2:15:13] And there was a cost to that about 18.5.
[2:15:15] He also requested a new position as an administrative assistant
[2:15:19] to kind of work with that group.
[2:15:21] And that's not funded in this year.
[2:15:22] Again, no new positions for environmental community.
[2:15:26] There were some requested.
[2:15:28] But we have high hopes for what Sean's
[2:15:30] going to be able to do in that position.
[2:15:33] And finally, we have in the environmental community
[2:15:36] focus area, there's a statement that says,
[2:15:39] We need to do a Parks Master Plan that helps us take care of our own properties and then
[2:15:44] we need to implement that master plan.
[2:15:46] And you'll remember last year we adopted a new Parks Master Plan and this year we've
[2:15:49] got $100,000 for capital projects that are consistent with that Parks Master Plan.
[2:15:53] I haven't identified what they are just yet.
[2:15:55] We're going to work with Wendy on that, but they'll be $100,000 for the capital projects
[2:16:00] coming out of the Parks Master Plan.
[2:16:02] So that's the list of the mental highlights.
[2:16:05] If you have any questions about this, we can address those now.
[2:16:10] Concerning recycling, I really feel quite strongly as a tree hugger that our downtown Main Street
[2:16:17] project is not going to be complete without PSI sub-sub-contract, whatever it's going to
[2:16:23] take to have periodically pick up recycling containers.
[2:16:28] I went to my five-year-old granddaughter's graduation, and those little kids, they're so attuned
[2:16:34] recycling, and I think our generation has an
[2:16:38] obligation and opportunity to stress the recycling
[2:16:43] as part of our life.
[2:16:44] It's not only an add-on when it's convenient.
[2:16:48] So I'd sure like to think what PSI could do is sweep
[2:16:52] through once a week or twice a week, pick up some
[2:16:56] containers, probably bigger problems where to put them,
[2:16:59] so they don't detract from the looks of the downtown area.
[2:17:05] primary we went through a recycling in the parks. Yeah,
[2:17:12] those cardboard boxes and well, we worked with PSI to put a recycle bins in our parks for some specific events and
[2:17:20] the real struggle they had was with contamination of the recycle bin. Yeah, I think with public
[2:17:28] like trash cans and publicly cycled and that's always going to be a struggle if you get contaminated
[2:17:35] then recycling them all in a school's can.
[2:17:39] There's a million reasons why we shouldn't do it.
[2:17:41] We need to keep working through it to find the right solution, that's why it's going to
[2:17:45] be an education process.
[2:17:46] Yep.
[2:17:47] And I think we want to do it in our parks as well if we can figure out how to get that
[2:17:51] out.
[2:17:54] And we're requesting about this.
[2:17:55] Okay.
[2:17:56] Then basically we saw this slide last week and nothing changed.
[2:18:00] This is just what it costs to get us through a budget, including this last two focus areas.
[2:18:05] So we see a slight increase, $1.49 monthly in our utility bills, and a slight decrease projected
[2:18:15] at $14.18 for that average home in the property taxes.
[2:18:19] And again, that's not new.
[2:18:21] We saw this last week, but I just wanted to kind of close with that.
[2:18:25] And if you have any more questions about any of this stuff,
[2:18:29] And deal with those, this is the calendar for the what you're looking at for the next six weeks or so.
[2:18:35] I adjusted it slightly to take care of our Wednesday hearing instead of Monday and August, so that's what we're looking at for the next week.
[2:18:47] So next week, we're going to come back, we're going to talk about focus areas one and two.
[2:18:51] I think that's going to be me too.
[2:18:54] that's healthy and learning communities.
[2:18:59] Polling week three and six,
[2:19:00] and that'll be Brian talking to you about three and six,
[2:19:03] that's secure, prosperous communities.
[2:19:05] And then Travis is gonna finish up
[2:19:06] our strategic plan conversations with seven and eight,
[2:19:11] responsible communities and our internal organization.
[2:19:14] On the 14th, we'll do our hearing for rate adjustments,
[2:19:17] if there's a read rate adjustments,
[2:19:19] then we'll adopt the preliminary budget
[2:19:21] and set our budget hearing date for 28.
[2:19:24] That 23rd meeting will be kind of our last opportunity
[2:19:27] to really just go through the whole thing.
[2:19:29] We're just going to kind of leave it out.
[2:19:30] See how you guys want to go.
[2:19:31] And then we'll adopt the budget on the 28th.
[2:19:33] Any questions?
[2:19:38] Any questions for you?
[2:19:44] As we're looking at the upcoming calendar,
[2:19:51] is there one of those slots that we might want to have
[2:19:56] a more in-depth conversation about the foregone balance
[2:20:00] so that we're not trying to do that on the 14th
[2:20:03] we have to set the preliminary budget amount.
[2:20:08] So we can have that conversation any time
[2:20:11] that you would like to do that.
[2:20:13] We could do that as early as next week.
[2:20:17] So Brian can do his or Mitch can do his on one, one, and two.
[2:20:21] One and two are really those two strategic focus areas
[2:20:26] that are much more of the city playing a supportive role
[2:20:31] under a learning community and a healthy community.
[2:20:34] and so that we could add that just as a conversation
[2:20:40] and we will once again reintroduce the three-pot scenario
[2:20:43] that we came up with, not saying that's the right approach,
[2:20:45] but do you want to take the foregone balance?
[2:20:49] Any portion of that, but we'll be prepared to talk
[2:20:52] about that next week or the following week,
[2:20:54] depending upon what works best for the council.
[2:20:56] We have those slides loaded up here
[2:20:58] if you wanted to take a look at them even tonight,
[2:21:00] I can pull those up.
[2:21:01] I can tell you that the meeting's looking forward at the other stuff that's coming up.
[2:21:09] 31st is lighter than the 24th, but the budget conversation on the 24th will likely be a little bit lighter than the budget conversation.
[2:21:20] I just wanted to make sure that we were kind of thinking about when we might want to discuss that so that we're not trying to do it then that of the 14th and then coming up with what that number is.
[2:21:28] So we'll put the conversation on next week and then the week following that as well so
[2:21:36] that you have that two-week window to consider whether or not that's something you choose to
[2:21:41] do.
[2:21:42] Thank you.
[2:21:43] Anything else for Mitch?
[2:21:46] If not, we have promised that we would give the public an opportunity to give us their
[2:21:51] two cents on the budget every time we have a budget discussion.
[2:21:55] So if you'd like to give us your two cents on the budget, now is your chance to come
[2:21:58] up and share with us. Yep, we'll get there when that's the next item on the agenda.
[2:22:09] I think I'm a budget. Max Newland. I am a participant of your 50% sidewalk reduction rate.
[2:22:19] Excellent. I got in and I said, oh, it's not ready. I was too soon. And I got in and said,
[2:22:24] oh, we'll do busy. And I had to wait and wait and wait and wait and wait. And I'm putting
[2:22:29] I had a camp ramp in my front place.
[2:22:31] Seemed that for an accessible thing.
[2:22:34] My sister's been staying, but she is appalled.
[2:22:37] She moved here from Washington that this twin false place
[2:22:40] is using drinking water for their grass.
[2:22:43] She has rain barrels.
[2:22:44] She used to collect free rain water for her irrigation system,
[2:22:49] so a sustainability will all over that too.
[2:22:52] Of course, I get 200 inches a year or one.
[2:22:54] It's to get a lot more.
[2:22:56] But she's raised in desert plants,
[2:22:58] So she's not going to have as much of that.
[2:23:00] So that's my two cents.
[2:23:02] Thank you, Matt.
[2:23:05] Anyone else with input on the budget?
[2:23:07] Wait, this is a paper.
[2:23:15] Computer is here.
[2:23:17] All right.
[2:23:20] Next is an opportunity for general public input.
[2:23:22] If anyone who wishes to address the council,
[2:23:24] now has your chance to come forward.
[2:23:25] Mr. Edwards.
[2:23:35] Thank you.
[2:23:36] Terry Edwards, Jerome, and Twin Falls.
[2:23:40] I'm going to put it in reverse here.
[2:23:43] Go back to the beginning.
[2:23:44] not to lessen the importance of the proclamation that was read tonight, but the proclamation
[2:23:51] tonight highlighted the human catastrophe against our own fellow man. I'm curious, who
[2:24:00] sponsored the proclamation? Does anybody have a clue?
[2:24:05] It was submitted by a citizen and I proclaimed it as the mayor.
[2:24:10] In the name of diversity and inclusiveness,
[2:24:16] shouldn't the council recognize all genocidal events,
[2:24:23] such as the Armenian genocide already mentioned tonight?
[2:24:28] This genocide occurred on April 21st,
[2:24:34] 1915 through 1922.
[2:24:38] It was conducted by the Ottoman Empire,
[2:24:41] where 150 million, 150 million, not 30,000, 150 million were died either being thrown
[2:24:52] off a cliff, burned the death or crucified, shot, strangled, hung, and it was a pre-meded
[2:25:07] systemic genocide of an entire people.
[2:25:11] recognizes genocide event on March 2010. So on April 24, 2017, on the 95th anniversary
[2:25:22] of this catastrophe, was that recognized by the city? I actually do. I believe we actually
[2:25:32] had a proclamation this year for the Armenian genocide. I'm sure glad that happened. I would
[2:25:37] recommend that not only that but every genocidal ethnic cleansing event be
[2:25:44] recognized in the future and not be selective as to what you're going to do
[2:25:50] but there's a lot of them so if you're going to do it on an annual basis or on
[2:25:54] 25 year basis I think it should be done for all events. Oh by the way thank you
[2:26:00] all that attended the two strategic planning meetings I didn't see you there
[2:26:05] Mayor. I was pre otherwise engaged. Yeah. Okay. Well, great. I'm glad all the city folks that came
[2:26:12] were there. I appreciate that. Show some interest. I did participate in about six other meetings
[2:26:18] during the day. Well, you'll get a story for that on your on your board up on the wall. Gold,
[2:26:23] maybe. But anyway, thank you for that. Thank you for the time. I just would ask that we would be
[2:26:31] be more receptive to all minorities, not just selected ones, thank you.
[2:26:36] Thank you Mr. Edwards.
[2:26:44] Mr. Rothweiler, do you have any items for us?
[2:26:49] Just one quick reminder of tomorrow's event that we've been invited to participate.
[2:26:55] It's with the Times News and the Idaho Attorney General's Office.
[2:27:00] It's an RSVP event and it tests to deal with public records and
[2:27:06] Open meeting law, and it's one of those opportunities
[2:27:08] we get together on an annual basis.
[2:27:11] With the Times News folks and the Attorney General's office,
[2:27:14] it's going to be hosted at the Magic Valley Arts Council room,
[2:27:20] and it is from one o'clock to three 30.
[2:27:24] So I just wanted to remind you of that,
[2:27:26] and I know that the publisher of the paper
[2:27:29] had sent out an invitation to each of you,
[2:27:31] but just to make sure that you saw that on your calendar
[2:27:33] says an opportunity for tomorrow.
[2:27:36] That's more as creepy as they did ask to see who was going to be coming in the
[2:27:43] topic. Thank Travis. Anything from the council? So one item that I would jump
[2:27:51] on follow up on something Chris mentioned earlier so the good thing to
[2:27:56] show shown street block of main Avenue is now open to traffic and on a
[2:28:01] Wednesday at four o'clock we will be having a official ribbon cutting with
[2:28:05] the Chamber of Commerce to celebrate that opening.
[2:28:09] Good chance to come down and visit some of those businesses
[2:28:13] before you stick around to go to the Twin Falls tonight concert
[2:28:16] that will also be on Wednesday night.
[2:28:17] So we'll be planning to do that for each of the blocks
[2:28:20] as they open through downtown.
[2:28:23] Four o'clock.
[2:28:24] It is mid-block between...look for the big scissors.
[2:28:29] I managed to make sure I drove and parked
[2:28:31] and ate somewhere on Sunday.
[2:28:33] The first day it was open.
[2:28:34] There you go.
[2:28:35] somebody tell me they felt like they were on the movie cars.
[2:28:39] Just want to do the circle all over.
[2:28:41] Suzanne Hawkins.
[2:28:42] Thank you.
[2:28:43] I just wanted to publicly give a thank you to everyone from the city's team who helped
[2:28:47] with paint magic this year.
[2:28:49] We got another house accomplished, barely made it by the deadline, but we got it.
[2:28:54] And the homeowner was very pleased with how the house turned out.
[2:28:58] And it's just nice to know that we were able to help somebody who needed a handout.
[2:29:02] So thank you to everybody who participated.
[2:29:05] And Suzanne, thank you for your leadership of that project.
[2:29:09] I know it is some times, thankless,
[2:29:11] but I appreciate the effort that you've put in
[2:29:13] to rally up the troops and get that done.
[2:29:15] Thank you.
[2:29:17] Anything else from the council?
[2:29:20] If not, next item on the agenda is an executive session.
[2:29:26] I'm trying to find the notes.
[2:29:28] Under Idaho Code 74206C to acquire an interest
[2:29:33] in real property which is not owned by a public agency.
[2:29:38] Council wishes.
[2:29:40] Suzanne Hawkins.
[2:29:41] So moved.
[2:29:42] Sorry.
[2:29:43] Motion by Suzanne Hawkins, seconded by Chris Tockington
[2:29:46] to adjourn into executive session as stated.
[2:29:50] Is there any discussion?
[2:29:53] Chair and we'll call vote please.
[2:29:59] Chris Tockington.
[2:30:00] Yeah.
[2:30:01] Yes.
[2:30:02] Sean Beriker.
[2:30:03] Yes.
[2:30:03] Licky Boyd.
[2:30:04] Yes.
[2:30:05] Suzanne Hawkins.
[2:30:06] Yes.
[2:30:07] Greg Lanting.
[2:30:08] Yes.
[2:30:08] Ruth Pierce.
[2:30:09] Yes.
[2:30:10] Christopher Reed.
[2:30:11] Yes.
[2:30:12] Motion passes.
[2:30:13] Seven to zero.
[2:30:14] Just a reminder we will not be making any decisions in the executive session nor will
[2:30:19] we be reconvening following the executive session and at that we are adjourned.
