Oversight Archive: City Council meeting, 2017-07-24, recording 1 (started 16:58)
Machine transcript (faster-whisper base.en), not checked word for word; the Pledge of Allegiance is shown in its standard wording. The recording is the record.
Times are time into the recording. Passages with private details are muted in the audio and marked here.
The audio on the page below was re-encoded by software from the video the agency posted. Check any passage against
that audio before relying on it.
Page: https://oversightarchive.org/twin-falls-id/meetings/2017-07-24/

[0:01:53] I'd like to call to order the Twin Falls City Council meeting for Monday, July 24th.
[0:02:01] Here we go.
[0:02:03] We do have a quorum in the council here.
[0:02:05] All seven members are here this evening.
[0:02:07] The first item on the agenda is the Pledge of Allegiance.
[0:02:09] Those of you wishing to join us, please rise.
[0:02:11] Pledge of Allegiance. I pledge allegiance to the Flag of the United States of America, and to the Republic for which it stands, one Nation under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all.
[0:02:32] Mr. Rothweiler do we have any amendments to our agenda and Mr. Mayor members of the council there are no amendments this evening
[0:02:39] Thank you. We have no proclamations
[0:02:41] So next is an opportunity for general public input
[0:02:44] This is a chance to address the council on items that are not on the agenda this evening
[0:02:49] There's anyone wishing to
[0:02:51] Dress us please come forward. If you would please state your name and whether you are a property owner or resident in the city of Twin Falls
[0:03:01] My name is Mary Ann Ward and I am both.
[0:03:05] I have two things I wanted to say.
[0:03:08] First thing is that a couple months ago or so,
[0:03:12] I was speaking to someone from New York who said,
[0:03:15] hey, did you know that your city passed some kind of a
[0:03:18] welcoming thing or something?
[0:03:21] And he was very impressed.
[0:03:22] I was that welcoming neighborly.
[0:03:25] He was very impressed with that and thought it was really great.
[0:03:30] really great. I have no idea how he heard about it, but I have to say I agree with him.
[0:03:37] The second thing is that a week or two ago I took a young friend of mine out to Durkey's
[0:03:42] lake to go swimming. He said he really loved to swim. So I got out there, you know how
[0:03:49] to swim? Sort of. So anyway, he's going in the seventh grade. So we went out and did the
[0:03:55] swimming test and he pushed off from the the side and immediately sank. He apparently
[0:04:00] was one of those people who sinks like a stone. I am entirely convinced he would
[0:04:06] have drowned if the lifeguard hadn't jumped yet. He was panicking, he couldn't
[0:04:10] see the flotation thingy. I didn't think to get the lifeguard's name or I would
[0:04:17] be publicly thanking him by name so all I can say is thank you whoever you were
[0:04:23] And also thank you to the city for having Derke's Lake and having lifeguards out there. Thank you. Thank you very much
[0:04:32] Is there anyone else who wishes to address the council? Yes, please come forward and back. I'm Mahona
[0:04:45] Ohm owner here in Twin Falls
[0:04:47] What else did you need to know about it? That's it. Okay. I just wanted to say how great the downtown is looking
[0:04:52] I have to tell you I was scared. I was frightened when they sliced all those trees off. I went what the
[0:04:59] So I just wanted to tell you how great I mean I keep telling the guys down there
[0:05:05] every time I go down there thank you it looks so great. The other thing is I want
[0:05:09] to encourage that you get housing down there because let me tell you that's where
[0:05:15] well my husband I first moved here to be quite honest that's where we want to live
[0:05:19] even though three years ago nothing really happened to happen we want to live
[0:05:22] in a downtown area so I'm just here to encourage that you when you do think
[0:05:27] about housing, think about down in the downtown area.
[0:05:30] Because that's where your young people will want to be.
[0:05:32] Thank you.
[0:05:33] Thank you, Chris talking to you.
[0:05:34] And I just wanted to say that we do have plans
[0:05:38] for housing downtown, but we need additional water pressure.
[0:05:42] And when the lines are completed in a year and a half or so,
[0:05:46] that whole quarter of Main Street will have not only water
[0:05:49] pressure for plumbing and domestic, but also sprinkler
[0:05:55] systems.
[0:05:56] So we have great plans to for housing that whole quarter
[0:05:59] along Main Street.
[0:06:02] Is there anyone else who wishes to address the council?
[0:06:08] Chris Stockington.
[0:06:09] Well, segue that our guests made,
[0:06:12] but I want to let you know, I play sidewalk super
[0:06:15] and 10 at least twice a week and do the five blocks
[0:06:19] and talk with as many employees and property owners
[0:06:21] as possible.
[0:06:23] And the tone is beginning to change,
[0:06:25] as far as you've since that first block has opened up.
[0:06:29] First of all, everybody that I've contacted says their business has been impacted from very
[0:06:36] little to devastating, probably more on the significant side.
[0:06:41] There has been the first most of a month, a lot more pessimism or questioning what's this
[0:06:48] going to look like.
[0:06:49] Now that the first block is open, there's an in that first block in protector, a great deal
[0:06:55] of enthusiasm and turning to optimism.
[0:06:58] So I think the scale progress and completion opening of the main street is kind of a self-correcting
[0:07:06] phenomenon to having all the trees gone and that block has two dozen new trees now.
[0:07:11] So thank you for your comments.
[0:07:14] Thank you.
[0:07:15] Seeing no further general public input, we will move on the agenda to the consent calendar.
[0:07:22] Chris Reed.
[0:07:23] The move that we approve the consent calendar has published.
[0:07:26] Second.
[0:07:28] Motion by Chris Reed.
[0:07:29] by Nikki Boyd to approve the consent calendar as published.
[0:07:33] Is there any discussion?
[0:07:36] Sharon Roll Call vote, please.
[0:07:51] Sean Berriger.
[0:07:52] Yes.
[0:07:55] Nikki Boyd.
[0:07:56] Yes.
[0:07:58] Suzanne Hawkins.
[0:07:59] Yes.
[0:08:00] Greg Lanting.
[0:08:01] Yes.
[0:08:01] Ruth Pierce.
[0:08:02] Yes.
[0:08:03] Christopher Reed.
[0:08:04] Yes.
[0:08:04] Chris Poppner.
[0:08:05] Yes.
[0:08:06] Motion passes 7-0.
[0:08:09] Under items for consideration, the first is a request
[0:08:12] for annexation with a zoning district change
[0:08:15] zoning map amendment for approximately 9.75 plus or minus acres, excuse me, to be rezoned to R6,
[0:08:23] currently zoned R1 variable for property located east of Harrison Street and north of Canyon Falls
[0:08:28] drive extended. This is the application on behalf of Ralph Struthers on behalf of Susan and Catherine
[0:08:35] Breckenridge. We did have this on the item on the agenda last week and that's when we accepted public
[0:08:41] input on this issue for the public hearing. Tonight, this is for council discussion from
[0:08:46] the item that had been tabled last week and also for some input from our legal council.
[0:08:51] So with that, I'll turn it over to you, Fritz.
[0:08:57] So because of the type of an application this is, I know it's a little, it doesn't seem like
[0:09:08] it's a regular annexation, I suppose it's not. You need to think of this in terms of two parts.
[0:09:14] One is, and it's really what the request is,
[0:09:18] should you annex this property?
[0:09:20] I mean, that's the real question before the council,
[0:09:22] should we annex the property?
[0:09:24] But statutorily, you're also required to make a determination,
[0:09:28] what should the zoning be if you do annex it?
[0:09:31] Because it has to have a zoning designation
[0:09:35] upon incorporation into the city.
[0:09:38] It does have currently a zoning designation
[0:09:41] within the area of impact,
[0:09:43] But you'll need to remember that that was a zoning designation really established by the
[0:09:48] county because they are required to actually do the zoning within the county, although it
[0:09:55] runs through our planning and zoning commission.
[0:09:59] The second part that I want to remind you of, in case you need additional information or
[0:10:05] people want to provide additional information, you're required to follow the notice and hearing
[0:10:12] procedures that are provided for in the local land use planning at 67-6509 and I think you
[0:10:20] all know what those are.
[0:10:21] It's 15 days notice before public hearing so tonight is not scheduled as a public hearing.
[0:10:29] You have not followed the procedures in order to have a public hearing tonight so you cannot
[0:10:36] take any public input tonight or ask questions of anyone who testified last week. So if there's
[0:10:43] a wish to do that, we'll have to do a notice of public hearing. Wait 15 days before you could
[0:10:49] do that. I think I also heard a question about, there was a debate about R6 versus R4 and whether
[0:10:59] it was possible to split the property. Legally, the answer is yes, you certainly can. I leave
[0:11:06] But you decide if you have enough information to know where to draw that line or how to draw that line.
[0:11:13] So Fritz, I think one of the comments was the possibility of using the Canyon Rim Overlay boundary as the limit between.
[0:11:22] So if that were of interest, would that be sufficient for a subscription?
[0:11:28] Sure.
[0:11:29] Thank you.
[0:11:29] And that's precise enough to the surveyors.
[0:11:32] Oh, that is a very precise line.
[0:11:34] Thank you.
[0:11:35] Suzanne Hockens.
[0:11:36] Are we allowed to ask city staff for clarification on things from last week or is that not allowed
[0:11:42] either?
[0:11:43] You may ask about what our ordinances provide for or legal issues but not additional factual
[0:11:51] information.
[0:11:52] Okay.
[0:11:53] And so I'm not sure what you're maybe giving me an example.
[0:11:57] I'll give you an example.
[0:11:58] If I wanted to know in detail what our comprehensive plan shows that property as being I can readdress
[0:12:06] That's that type of step to night.
[0:12:08] Okay.
[0:12:09] Just wanted to make sure.
[0:12:12] Thank you.
[0:12:13] Any other questions for Fritz while he is at the podium?
[0:12:16] I do not see any.
[0:12:23] Suzanne Hawkins.
[0:12:24] Okay.
[0:12:25] Now that I have the green light, I think Mitch is probably the right person to ask.
[0:12:28] But if we're looking at our future land use maps and our comp plan, what have we in the past recommended that that property be turned into?
[0:12:38] Do we have that?
[0:12:39] Oh, I did see Renee over there.
[0:12:40] Sorry.
[0:12:41] Good afternoon.
[0:12:44] Thank you.
[0:13:00] OK.
[0:13:01] It is got a mixed use designation on it
[0:13:05] by the Comp Plan, which is a suggested land use.
[0:13:10] That involves retail, office, restaurant, civic, entertainment,
[0:13:14] arts, and culture, vertical mixed use, townhomes,
[0:13:18] condominiums, apartments, senior student housing, hotels,
[0:13:22] plazas, and parks.
[0:13:24] So it really is encouraging a mixed use centered towards a smaller scale of a loud retail versus residential.
[0:13:36] Thank you.
[0:13:37] You're welcome.
[0:13:38] Suzanne, how can we?
[0:13:47] What the heck?
[0:13:48] I'll float the first motion if there's no other questions then.
[0:13:52] I would like to make a motion that we approve the request for annexation on the property that we have been discussing
[0:14:01] that the zoning district become our six in the area that is south of the canyon
[0:14:09] removerlay and our four between the canyon removerlay and the and towards
[0:14:14] the end of the edge of the canyon where that property is ordered.
[0:14:17] Great Stockington.
[0:14:24] Well I'd say a question for the maker of the motion before I second it.
[0:14:30] You said we're not dealing with the property all the way to the canyon.
[0:14:35] You know, you're just talking about to the edge of the property to the property line that we're talking about now
[0:14:39] I will second that motion. Thank you
[0:14:42] The motion by Suzanne Hawkins seconded by Greg Lanting to approve the request for annexation
[0:14:52] with a zoning of R6
[0:14:55] from the south boundary of the property to the Canyon Rim Overlay line and
[0:15:00] R4 from the Canyon Rim Overlay overlay line to the north edge of the property
[0:15:06] Chris Reed. Do we have any idea how many acres that's going to put into R6 versus R4?
[0:15:15] We'll play the 60-40-spline. And so I have a problem with that. As you look at that property,
[0:15:25] the biggest concerns that came out of it were traffic. And if we're going to put potentially
[0:15:33] six acres into R6, we're talking about apartments. And you have three exit points for that property,
[0:15:40] points for that property, all of which are very problematic intersections.
[0:15:45] Fillmore by Costco, going all the way out by Outback Steakhouse, that intersection, and
[0:15:52] the intersection on the other side, the Harrison Street, where you can't turn left.
[0:15:58] It's just too, there's potentially we're going to be putting too many people in that little
[0:16:04] area to try to get out of, in my opinion.
[0:16:07] And so I'm going to be voting no.
[0:16:09] I just think R6 has potentially too many people
[0:16:14] we're going to be putting on that property.
[0:16:17] Greg Lansing.
[0:16:19] Well, I think that was, I had a question in there,
[0:16:22] and I was listening to Ted Lee to Chris,
[0:16:24] and I can't remember my question.
[0:16:28] I understand your thoughts, and that's
[0:16:29] the one of the things that I've been mulling with all week long.
[0:16:33] We do have a light if they come out of the east side
[0:16:37] and go to the south, that does have a stoplight there,
[0:16:41] my Costco. So I guess that's one of your three referring to, and I would think anybody's
[0:16:47] who left is probably going to need to come out that way. Something that would be, it's
[0:16:54] something to think of. I understand your thought process. I really do. And I've been beyond
[0:17:00] the R6 doesn't make it. I will probably gladly go ahead and vote for the R4 for the whole
[0:17:07] property, but I still have the concern of what we've, the pattern that we have set on
[0:17:13] the council for quite some time is allowing the R6 or the apartments, which could also
[0:17:19] be condominiums. I have friends who live in a condomer a apartment complex in a Portland
[0:17:28] area that you see all the amenities they provide now and all the space and things. I don't think
[0:17:33] apartments are quite as what we think they are because of the other things they provide.
[0:17:37] It may not be as many units as we're concerned about.
[0:17:42] But we've also allowed R6 to be a buffer from C1.
[0:17:46] It'd be a look at that.
[0:17:47] It's got C1 all the way around.
[0:17:48] It's got hotels.
[0:17:50] It's got assisted living facilities, which are high income.
[0:17:55] It's just been a buffer, but I also
[0:17:57] agree that R4 could be a buffer to it as well.
[0:18:03] It's hard, but it really is.
[0:18:05] I understand the concern to the neighbors, without a doubt, that's the reason I first
[0:18:10] talked about doing R6 on the portion that doesn't about them in any way.
[0:18:16] The R4 will be about eating any of the neighborhood there.
[0:18:19] I can't see us doing R6 on the northern half of it at any point in the future.
[0:18:25] I think that will probably end up being R4, just because it's on the canyon and rim.
[0:18:31] And we've been allowing, we're really trying to be very careful with that.
[0:18:35] But I will be voting for this motion, but I'll be honest, if it fails, I will gladly vote
[0:18:39] for the R4 motion that I'm sure will follow.
[0:18:45] Excuse me, I'm not going to.
[0:18:47] I'm sorry.
[0:18:48] Oh, go ahead.
[0:18:49] No, it's okay.
[0:18:50] You have somebody else?
[0:18:51] Yeah, Nicky, I'm going to.
[0:18:52] Sorry.
[0:18:54] So, traffic, I'm not as concerned about the traffic.
[0:18:58] I don't think that's our main issue.
[0:19:01] Anytime we add it's bare ground and we add anything to it that increases traffic of some
[0:19:09] kind.
[0:19:10] That's part of progress and growth.
[0:19:13] I also think that this is a somewhat challenging piece of ground.
[0:19:22] What happens to it, I believe, is going to depend on the person who buys it.
[0:19:27] The person who buys this ground, if they want to profit in any way, they have to develop
[0:19:34] it.
[0:19:35] They have to put the road in behind the bottom where the dotted line is have to put the whole
[0:19:41] road in.
[0:19:43] It also, in my experience, anything near the canyon rim, across the street from the canyon
[0:19:49] rim, sometimes miles from the canyon rim, you don't know what you have until you start
[0:19:54] digging or start blasting. I don't know that anybody's dug test holes out there. We have
[0:20:03] no idea what really is, we would be up against there. So I really feel like the person who
[0:20:12] buys it is the one who is going to ultimately determine what this is. Because roughly 40%
[0:20:22] of it is in a canyon rim overlay, the developer has to do a ZDA and come before a public hearing
[0:20:31] process.
[0:20:33] And so that will 40%.
[0:20:36] It depends on what they want to do with it.
[0:20:37] Again, it's the person who ultimately owns this ground that wants to develop it, that is
[0:20:42] going to make these decisions.
[0:20:44] It's their investment, it's their money.
[0:20:47] And so that whole thing could become all zone the same, it could be zone differently like
[0:20:55] is being proposed right now.
[0:20:57] But I do believe that also Canyon Rim is very choice ground and it tends to be more expensive
[0:21:03] and it's more expensive to develop.
[0:21:06] So we could zone it something today and it could sell next month or in three years and
[0:21:14] And the person who buys it that time is going to have a vision for that.
[0:21:18] And if that whatever we zone it now doesn't fit what they want to do, they're going to
[0:21:24] come to planning and zoning and say this is what I want to do and we're going to have
[0:21:27] another public hearing process.
[0:21:30] So I feel relatively comfortable with that being the Canyon Rim overlay that we will
[0:21:36] get another set of eyes on it.
[0:21:39] In the meantime, the other thing we need to consider is that next to C1 all around like
[0:21:44] that, we probably not very many people are going to want to build a single family home.
[0:21:53] I think that's, you know, pre-logical.
[0:21:55] And that often we have apartment buildings or forplexes between.
[0:22:01] If we zone this so it's difficult to develop, developers will go someplace else.
[0:22:12] We need ground for the housing needs that we have that somebody can go in and look at
[0:22:20] the code and say I like this piece of land, this one section, and I read the list of what
[0:22:28] can go there and that's what I'd like to do.
[0:22:30] I have the money to do it and I'm going to go see if I can get a building permit.
[0:22:35] That's how these pieces get developed.
[0:22:40] If you have to go through a rezoned first, 80 to 85% of anybody with money that thinks
[0:22:45] they want to build something, they're going to go find something that zoned for what they
[0:22:49] think they want to do.
[0:22:52] It has to pencil for them.
[0:22:54] If we're providing housing, it has to pencil for the person building it.
[0:22:58] This could be a lot of things other than housing.
[0:23:02] And so I think there's a lot more to this than zoning and kind of a fear of the unknown.
[0:23:12] We don't have anybody coming forward saying this is my vision or this is what I think should
[0:23:16] go here and we can debate that.
[0:23:19] We just have to simply state something for the zoning at this time and that's where we're
[0:23:24] at.
[0:23:26] Thank you, Nikki.
[0:23:27] Suzanne Hawkins.
[0:23:28] Thank you.
[0:23:29] I just wanted to clarify my thinking a little.
[0:23:31] I believe that the property owners have a right to try to develop the property and make it profitable
[0:23:37] for themselves and by the compromise of the two zones, it gives them an option to make that
[0:23:43] parcel marketable in some way.
[0:23:46] It still gives the neighbors the reassurance that they're not going to have an apartment
[0:23:50] complex right up against their backyard.
[0:23:53] I think the traffic, you know, it might add at some point in the future.
[0:23:58] I'm not totally concerned about that.
[0:24:00] If we have to add a stoplight maybe at Harrison Street down the road.
[0:24:04] There's options for working around that and helping the traffic flow to go west instead
[0:24:09] of east to keep them off those smaller streets.
[0:24:13] So I think we can come up with solutions but I think it's fair to the property owner that
[0:24:16] they have a chance to market their property and if we zone it too tight, we're going to
[0:24:21] tie their hands and it's going to sit empty and we're never going to get that road finished.
[0:24:25] We're never going to get all of the trails connected through there where we're going around right
[0:24:29] now.
[0:24:30] I just think it's a win-win for the city to go ahead and give them a shot to do something
[0:24:34] with that land.
[0:24:35] Chris, talking to me.
[0:24:39] I'm driven by the C-1 that surrounds such a large portion of that land.
[0:24:44] And my experience as the city council has never been to mix a C-1 with a very low density.
[0:24:53] So I like Greg's idea the other week of seeing if we could use a canyon rim line, which I
[0:24:59] I think there's a unique opportunity, I'm not aware we've had one before, to delineate
[0:25:05] different levels of residential mixed-used housing, even in an R4 that I can put dupoxes.
[0:25:13] So that's going to be some sort of concentrated housing, yet also by allowing us to use that
[0:25:21] canyon rim overlay for an R4 designation to set the tone for the land of the north of
[0:25:27] that will remain R1 until it's applied to come in for annexation.
[0:25:34] The R4R6 split also shows a concern for the existing Canyon Park Avenue properties.
[0:25:43] This whole thing makes sense for me to use this as an experiment to see the Canyon Rim
[0:25:47] overlay as a legal demarcation point, use of the land, and I don't think the traffic
[0:25:55] is going to be nearly as severe as we think on it.
[0:25:57] So I will definitely support the idea Greg had last week
[0:26:03] about doing this.
[0:26:04] Split part four or six using Canyon Realm Overlight.
[0:26:12] Any other discussion from the Council?
[0:26:16] I would just add my thoughts.
[0:26:17] I think to the first question of whether this should be annexed,
[0:26:21] I think there's no question in my mind
[0:26:22] that this property should be annexed.
[0:26:24] It's an island that sits in the middle of development
[0:26:28] that's happened over the years.
[0:26:32] I do agree that we need to try to find some opportunity
[0:26:35] to provide a transition between this property and its neighbors.
[0:26:40] But I would also point out that two sides of the neighbors,
[0:26:45] two on a partial side of the neighbor,
[0:26:46] are commercial properties.
[0:26:49] Truthfully, it's going to be about, I think,
[0:26:51] buffering the new residents of this property
[0:26:54] to the commercial that's going to be the bigger challenge
[0:26:56] than figuring out how to buffer the new development
[0:27:00] to the R4 at Canyon Park.
[0:27:04] And I would echo Councilwoman Boyd's comment
[0:27:08] that as this moves forward in development,
[0:27:11] it will likely be before the Planning and Zoning Commission,
[0:27:15] again, for a more thorough discussion of a specific vision
[0:27:21] that a developer may have.
[0:27:24] So while I appreciate that the request coming
[0:27:26] from the Breckenridge sisters is for R6.
[0:27:33] I do think that this can be a fair compromise
[0:27:36] to get us down that road and move it forward
[0:27:40] with something that I believe the neighbors
[0:27:42] also compromise on as well, I hope.
[0:27:50] So if there's no other discussion or comments,
[0:27:53] Sharon Rolpow-Voten's.
[0:27:59] Do you want to remind everyone of the motion?
[0:28:01] The motion is to approve the request for annexation
[0:28:07] and that it be rezoned R6 from the south border
[0:28:12] of the property to the Canyon Rim Overlay line
[0:28:15] and R4 north of the Canyon Rim Overlay line
[0:28:19] to the north edge of the property.
[0:28:28] Nicky Boyd?
[0:28:29] Yes.
[0:28:30] Suzanne Hawkins?
[0:28:31] Yes.
[0:28:32] Greg Lanting?
[0:28:33] Yes.
[0:28:34] Ruth Pierce?
[0:28:34] Yes.
[0:28:35] Christopher Reed?
[0:28:36] No.
[0:28:37] Chris Tockington?
[0:28:38] Yes.
[0:28:39] Sean Barrieger.
[0:28:40] Yes.
[0:28:43] Motion passes 621.
[0:28:44] Thank you.
[0:28:45] So, next on the agenda is a request to approve the appointment of Mr. Ryan Bowman, Twin Falls
[0:29:01] School District Director of Operations, as a Commissioner, excuse me, to the Traffic Safety
[0:29:07] Commission, Mr. Bowman will represent the Twin Falls School District and will take the
[0:29:12] position Dr. Brady Dickinson has held since August 2013 and I see my name is on the agenda
[0:29:19] for this, and we turn to that page.
[0:29:22] So the Traffic Safety Commission is made up of seven members,
[0:29:25] one of which is designated to be a representative
[0:29:28] of the school district.
[0:29:30] Brady has served in that capacity for a period of time,
[0:29:33] but because of his new duties as the superintendent,
[0:29:36] he is requesting that we replace that position
[0:29:40] with Mr. Bowman, who is the new Director of Operations
[0:29:44] for the school district.
[0:29:47] Are there any questions?
[0:29:50] Suzanne Hawkins.
[0:29:51] not a question but I just want to clarify I did send Fritz an email on this earlier
[0:29:56] today because Mr Bowman does not live in the city limits and we can make sure in our in
[0:30:03] our motion that we're recognizing that and that we're allowing him to still serve in that
[0:30:09] position even though he's out of city limits.
[0:30:11] Waving the residency requirement as part of the motion.
[0:30:14] Thank you Nikki Boyd.
[0:30:15] And the reason for that is because he is representing the school district.
[0:30:22] Is there any further questions or counsel direction?
[0:30:39] Great landing.
[0:30:40] I move that we approve the appointment of Mr. Ryan Bowman as the Temple School District
[0:30:45] Representative on the Traffic Safety Commission waiving the fact that he does not live in
[0:30:52] the city limits.
[0:30:54] Is there anything else?
[0:30:58] I'll second that.
[0:31:00] Motion by Great Lantern, seconded by Ruth Pierce
[0:31:02] to approve the appointment of Ryan Bowman.
[0:31:05] Seconded.
[0:31:06] To the traffic safety commission waving the residency
[0:31:08] requirement.
[0:31:09] Is there any discussion?
[0:31:12] Sharon, I'll call vote, please.
[0:31:21] Suzanne Hawkins?
[0:31:22] Yes.
[0:31:23] Greg Lanting?
[0:31:24] Yes.
[0:31:25] Ruth Pierce?
[0:31:25] Yes.
[0:31:26] Christopher Reed?
[0:31:27] Yes.
[0:31:28] Chris Tockington?
[0:31:29] Yes.
[0:31:30] Sean Berriger?
[0:31:31] Yes.
[0:31:32] Motion passes seven to zero.
[0:31:37] Next is a request to approve the appointment
[0:31:40] of 13 citizens to the Recreation Center ad hoc committee.
[0:31:45] We have Wendy Davis, Parks and Recreation Director.
[0:31:56] Good evening.
[0:31:57] It's my pleasure to be here this evening
[0:31:59] to bring these 13 names for your approval.
[0:32:04] I don't know if you want me to list them.
[0:32:07] Or how do you want to do this?
[0:32:10] I think you've seen the 13 names as comprised as eight.
[0:32:15] Designated seats and three at large.
[0:32:19] We had 17 applications.
[0:32:22] We interviewed seven people and came up with three.
[0:32:29] And it was brought to my attention.
[0:32:31] And I thought I left it blank.
[0:32:33] But Kylie Gough is G-O-U-G-H.
[0:32:39] Gough is Gough.
[0:32:50] You want me to read them?
[0:32:54] Sure.
[0:32:55] Excuse me, can I?
[0:32:56] Sorry, Suzanne.
[0:32:57] Maybe if you can remind us who they're representing,
[0:33:00] because that's, I was kind, oh.
[0:33:02] I'll do my best.
[0:33:02] OK.
[0:33:03] So Bill Brewlot would be school district.
[0:33:06] Dr. John Myers represents St. Luke's.
[0:33:11] Brian Wright represents physical therapy, youth sports,
[0:33:15] adult sports.
[0:33:18] Dave Dickerson is a member at large.
[0:33:22] Eric Smallwood would be member at large.
[0:33:30] Darah Mackby would be of community interest, kind of adult
[0:33:39] sports, kind of Travis is saying running.
[0:33:43] Jam Midlighter has connections to CSI,
[0:33:46] but more senior fitness and health.
[0:33:49] and she's got connections with the Department of Health and Welfare
[0:33:54] and South Central District Health, I think.
[0:33:58] Brad Wills comes to us from URA and the building community
[0:34:03] and so on and how economic development.
[0:34:07] Chris Coles is a past member interested citizen.
[0:34:13] Angela Heiter is member at large.
[0:34:17] John Twis was recommended by the Wellness faction of CSI to represent CSI.
[0:34:23] Kylie Gough comes from, she's, her just got a brand new position.
[0:34:28] I think it's called Community Health or something.
[0:34:32] So she's the manager of Community Health for St. Luke's and Trevor Morgan is another member at large.
[0:34:41] Chris Tockington.
[0:34:43] Well, this is a good group of people.
[0:34:45] I'm disappointed I didn't hear back my recommendation for Mike McClimans who's a past business owner
[0:34:51] in the affected area of the fact even fundraising experience, he's still very active in the community.
[0:34:59] And I would like to suggest since we're way oversized with an effective working group which
[0:35:03] is about seven or so up to 13 that we accept these names but also appoint Mike McClimans
[0:35:11] and that was an alternative person.
[0:35:16] So as we went through the 17 applications
[0:35:20] to try to narrow this down, one of the things we talked to folks
[0:35:24] about is that there will be many opportunities
[0:35:27] through the ongoing meetings to not necessarily
[0:35:30] be a voting member of the committee,
[0:35:31] but we would encourage them to attend all of the meetings
[0:35:35] moving forward because we did not want it to get too large.
[0:35:38] So as we reviewed the positions,
[0:35:43] we felt this was a workable group,
[0:35:45] which was the direction that we gave when the last time
[0:35:47] she was here of what size group do you think
[0:35:49] you can manage and work with.
[0:35:51] And she feels that she can do that.
[0:35:54] And then with a council liaison
[0:35:56] and also a Parks and Recreation Commission liaison,
[0:35:58] we felt this was the best mix
[0:36:00] that brought the most kind of different groups together.
[0:36:04] And I think I wanted to add to that too,
[0:36:05] that we talked about the applications that we received.
[0:36:09] everybody that's expressed interest, I want to create a list, a email list, inviting them
[0:36:16] to every meeting, sending them agendas and giving them opportunities to come and input.
[0:36:22] There's going to be ample opportunity for community involvement in certain areas that
[0:36:26] people can plug into, including pickleball and the things that Mike represents.
[0:36:31] So that was the way we were hoping to keep many people engaged outside of voting members
[0:36:37] of the community.
[0:36:38] Well, have you been mayor of the last time we tried this, a little perspective on it.
[0:36:50] There are a lot of ideas, but the biggest issue is always going to be funding.
[0:36:56] And that's where we ran into a stalemate last time.
[0:36:59] I think we had a workable size of building and what it was going to include and we decided
[0:37:05] to not do the pool route because that caused a lot more operating expenses and things.
[0:37:11] They had them. I thought they had them. They'd came or come to a fairly good
[0:37:17] Plan, but we still run against that wall of fun and then tell we're ready as a group to
[0:37:25] go out and form a recreation district or
[0:37:29] Some find some huge sugar daddy like court lane did to give us 20 $25 million
[0:37:35] I think that's always going to be the issue and so
[0:37:39] Having I would make sure if we're not going to put
[0:37:43] Chris this person on, we need to have him there, because he's got experience raising money.
[0:37:49] That's going to be the need here, because it's not the ideas of what you want to have, it's
[0:37:55] where you're going to put it, and how you're going to fund it.
[0:37:58] Those are the big two issues that we ran into last time that we never got solved, because
[0:38:04] we as a group at that point weren't ready to go out into the recreation district.
[0:38:08] We were at the same time,
[0:38:10] passing the $38 million bond issue
[0:38:14] for the treatment facility and things like that.
[0:38:18] There just didn't seem to be a month up on the go-around.
[0:38:21] So I like your idea if we're not going to put him on.
[0:38:25] Let's make sure we can convince you to come,
[0:38:28] and make him feel wanted.
[0:38:31] So I would add to that in the discussions
[0:38:33] with the applicants, this is much bigger than a bake sale
[0:38:37] fundraiser project and I question whether even significant community fundraising gets
[0:38:44] to the scope and scale of what has been identified from the community so far in the Parks and
[0:38:53] Mac Master planning discussion and in some of the strategic planning discussions.
[0:38:56] So as we spoke to these members, we explained that similar to the wastewater treatment group
[0:39:02] and also with the City Hall Review Committee that their work would likely not end at the
[0:39:07] time that they bring a recommendation to the council.
[0:39:11] There may be further action, but again, I think there are going to be plenty of opportunities
[0:39:15] for all kinds of people in the community to plug in and appropriate times, but having
[0:39:20] a voting committee of 30 people isn't going to be feasible.
[0:39:24] Again, the direction we gave Wendy was, if you feel that that's the size you can manage,
[0:39:32] then we will be supportive of that at the last meeting.
[0:39:36] agreed on 12 at the last meeting so we've only added one since the charter was adopted.
[0:39:41] Thank you, Boyd.
[0:39:43] So, there's a lot of public input on this already.
[0:39:49] This is, I think like the mayor has said, this is something that people really want.
[0:39:53] We have it come up all the time and we had a lot of good people that applied.
[0:39:59] I think what we need to understand at this point is this is a new time.
[0:40:03] This is a different time.
[0:40:06] community is growing and we are adding things that the citizens want and so we will bring
[0:40:15] all the best things that have been learned out of the previous experiences and we will
[0:40:21] mix it with inject that with all new ideas and balance those out.
[0:40:27] So the committee is a group of people, in my opinion, the committee is a group of people
[0:40:33] that are going to attend meetings and hash out a lot of things on how the logistics of
[0:40:42] how it's going to get done and what different opportunities we could pursue. But we are
[0:40:48] counting on everybody who's interested in participating. I would imagine we're going
[0:40:55] to spend 18 months or longer getting a lot of information, but when it comes to what the
[0:41:02] money is going to be spent for and what people want to see, we want all the public input that
[0:41:09] we can possibly have, well, we'll be packing this room and it'll be packing the new building.
[0:41:14] So everybody can't be on the committee and we tried to make sure that we had a good cross
[0:41:23] section but also that these people were committed to that kind of work, that they were going
[0:41:29] to be there. You know, we can't have just half the people showing up that these are the
[0:41:34] people that are going to be doing a lot of logistic things and and everybody can't be
[0:41:39] on the committee, but everybody is needed and that's how we talk through all the interviews
[0:41:43] and I think everybody is comfortable with that.
[0:41:48] Suzanne Hawkins.
[0:41:49] Thank you. Just on a side note, I represent the City City Council at the Twin Falls Community
[0:41:55] foundation meetings and this topic came up at our board meeting and they were very interested
[0:42:02] at having a place on the table and wanting to get involved in case you're not aware they've
[0:42:07] helped with fundraising for the splash pad downtown. They work with MavTech helping with
[0:42:13] Canyon Room Trails. They work with our golf course. They help facilitate the money after
[0:42:18] the annual golf tournament fundraiser. They do a lot of financial help in the community
[0:42:25] to make some of these projects come together.
[0:42:29] And you know, after we sat down and talked about it, we really got down to, do we need
[0:42:33] to have a representative at this level right now and it's no.
[0:42:38] We need a group right now that can get this kicked off the ground.
[0:42:43] It doesn't necessarily need a representative from every little fraction of the community,
[0:42:48] but down the road when it gets to the point where we're ready to start working on the finances,
[0:42:53] Yes, they want to be a team player and they want to be part of this group and help make it come to fruition
[0:42:58] But right now we really felt like it's important to give a
[0:43:03] Group a chance to get the ball rolling first. So I'm happy with the 13 names that have been presented to us tonight
[0:43:12] Any further discussion
[0:43:17] Ruth Pierce
[0:43:19] Hi, Mayor Berger. I would make a motion to approve the appointment of the 13 citizens to the recreation center ad hoc committee
[0:43:27] Okay. Second.
[0:43:28] I thought I had a committee or a motion.
[0:43:31] Was it not seconded?
[0:43:32] It was never seconded.
[0:43:34] Okay.
[0:43:37] So there is a motion by Ruth Pierce seconded by Nikki Boyd to approve the appointment of
[0:43:41] the 13 Citizens to the Recreation Center at HUC Committee as presented.
[0:43:46] It's a further discussion.
[0:43:47] Chris talked to move to Amanda and include Michael McCliman's as an alternate.
[0:43:51] I have a question there.
[0:43:57] Is there a second?
[0:43:58] I'll second.
[0:44:01] So I can ask a question.
[0:44:03] Okay.
[0:44:04] Okay.
[0:44:05] Kristi, by alternate you mean that if there's other voting members aren't there at a particular
[0:44:10] meeting, he would be able to vote?
[0:44:13] He would, in all likelihood, be taking over somebody in a group of 13.
[0:44:19] It's going to be an 18-month committee.
[0:44:20] It's unlikely that all 13 are going to stay on the committee.
[0:44:24] Maybe they move, whatever.
[0:44:26] So the alternate would be a voting position, I would assume, in the absence of permanent
[0:44:33] or otherwise of one of the members.
[0:44:37] And there's nothing sacred about 13 or 14 or whatever,
[0:44:41] but it seems important to me to at least put up the name
[0:44:45] of a person who's had experience in business
[0:44:48] in that downtown area where it probably will be located
[0:44:51] as well as fundraising as willing to serve.
[0:44:56] Suzanne Hawkins.
[0:44:57] Wendy, you had 17 applications.
[0:44:59] Was this gentleman one of the applications?
[0:45:01] Yes, he was.
[0:45:02] So, you've selected these 13 and the other four are still invited to come to the meeting
[0:45:07] size it is.
[0:45:08] So, eight?
[0:45:09] Yes, absolutely.
[0:45:10] But, we only chose three out of that 17, right?
[0:45:16] So, four.
[0:45:17] Yeah, four out of that.
[0:45:18] So, another 13 or 14 that are still, I expect to reach out to them and invite them to be
[0:45:24] involved.
[0:45:25] Great.
[0:45:26] It was, there's a tremendous amount of enthusiasm and support for this and it was difficult
[0:45:32] So it keeps it to a reasonable number and there's some pretty really useful people out there that we could have a committee at 30 easily.
[0:45:45] I understand.
[0:45:45] Okay. Thank you.
[0:45:52] Sir, any further discussion?
[0:45:54] So we'll vote on the amendment first.
[0:45:57] The amendment is to have Mike McCleiman serve as an alternative member,
[0:46:03] alternate member on this committee.
[0:46:07] Sharon Rolko vote, please.
[0:46:14] Suzanne Hawkins. No. Greg Lanting. Yes. Ruth Pierce. No. Christopher Reed. No. Chris
[0:46:26] Hockington. Yes. Sean Beriker. No. Nikki Boyd. No. Motion fails five to two. I never have a chance to vote up here on my on the screen for some reason. Because you're not back to the agenda.
[0:46:50] I was looking at the details and kind of the U.S.
[0:46:54] So the main motion is to approve the appointment of the 13 Citizens to the Recreation Center
[0:47:00] at HOP Committee as presented.
[0:47:01] Is there any further discussion?
[0:47:04] Sharon, I'll call both, please.
[0:47:14] Greg Lanting?
[0:47:15] Yes.
[0:47:16] Ruth Pears?
[0:47:17] Yes.
[0:47:18] Christopher Reed?
[0:47:19] Yes.
[0:47:21] Chris Tockington?
[0:47:22] Yes.
[0:47:23] Sean Berriger?
[0:47:24] Yes.
[0:47:25] Nicky Boyd?
[0:47:26] Yes.
[0:47:27] Suzanne Hocken?
[0:47:28] motion passes seven to zero and I would recognize that we have several of the
[0:47:34] members of the committee who came to the meeting this evening so thank you for
[0:47:38] being here and thank you for your commitment and dedication to serve in
[0:47:42] this important capacity I know that Wendy will be getting a meeting scheduled for
[0:47:46] you very soon.
[0:47:49] Next is a request to use contingency funds or pool fund mid-year funding to
[0:47:58] purchase items for the pool. Again, Wendy Davis, Parks and Recreation Director.
[0:48:17] Hello again. That was close. Really, really, really fun there for a minute back. So I'm
[0:48:30] here this evening, and I didn't talk to Lori about this, so I might be blindsided here just
[0:48:34] a tiny bit, but our thought here is to try to use some contingency funds or pool mid-year
[0:48:42] funding if it's available to make some of these purchases for the pool now, rather than waiting
[0:48:48] until fiscal year 18.
[0:48:52] As we get in there and start to operate this facility
[0:48:57] and look around, there's things that need to be done.
[0:49:00] A few of these things that I brought to your attention today, including the pull blankets,
[0:49:05] the metal doors, and the handicap lift kind of rise to the top right now
[0:49:10] as fairly important things, and not super expensive.
[0:49:14] some things that we can maybe do to increase safety,
[0:49:17] to make a cleaner, safer environment,
[0:49:21] to make some, the pool blankets to hold the heat
[0:49:27] and the chemicals in, it works,
[0:49:29] it's good in the summertime,
[0:49:30] it'll be nice to get those up before the end of the season.
[0:49:33] And they also are important during the,
[0:49:36] when the bubbles up, but particularly in the summertime,
[0:49:39] when the wind's blowing and dirt's coming into the pool
[0:49:41] and things like that.
[0:49:42] And then the Handicap Lift piece is according to the ADA standards,
[0:49:49] if we keep the bulkhead in the middle of the pool,
[0:49:51] which maximizes the use of that facility, and the space,
[0:49:55] it creates two tanks and creates an accessibility issue.
[0:49:58] So one of the things that we need to do by October is either have a second Handicap lift
[0:50:05] to create access to that deep end of that tank,
[0:50:10] or we need to move the bulkhead back and run it as a 50 meter pool with just that one access
[0:50:17] until we can get that second access.
[0:50:19] So I have some pictures if you want to see some doors and some parts, please.
[0:50:48] I was trying to get, we didn't, they're all on a reel right now, but the pool staff doesn't
[0:50:52] pull them on to the pool anymore because as you can see the blue plastic is deteriorating
[0:50:57] when they pull it in.
[0:50:58] blue flakes everywhere. It also sucks up a lot of water, kind of like a pool
[0:51:04] diaper. And then it gets really heavy trying to pull it off. And so I just tried
[0:51:09] to take a couple pictures of the edges to give you a sense of the condition of
[0:51:16] these. At this point they last about eight or seven or eight years and I think
[0:51:19] these are about nine years old. And then the metal doors are all starting to
[0:51:27] rest around the edges. You can kind of see down at the bottom there and you can
[0:51:31] see some rust toward the top. This one is in the women's locker room and they put a strip
[0:51:40] of kind of rubber across the bottom because that whole bottom is pretty much deteriorated.
[0:51:44] It's just kind of jagged rusty metal across the bottom of that and they tried to kind of
[0:51:48] put a shield on it so people wouldn't catch their toes in that. This one goes into the
[0:51:57] pump room and that's just again the kind of rusting and deterioration is falling apart.
[0:52:13] So that's the request.
[0:52:14] Does anybody have any questions?
[0:52:16] So my question would be where would those funds come from?
[0:52:24] So we would prefer that they came from the pool fund and right now we're projecting that
[0:52:28] most of the funds that we're going to be able to look at right now looks like the pool fund
[0:52:32] can absorb it.
[0:52:33] Laurie and I were just chatting.
[0:52:34] We like to look at the pool fund as an enterprise fund which means that we like to have it cover
[0:52:39] all the costs that it can and then at the point which it can't we'll use capital contingency
[0:52:46] funds to to cover those costs and so our first preference right now is to look at
[0:52:50] the pool fund but then because contingency are on earmarked funds in our part
[0:52:55] processes to come to the council to ask for that permission to allocate those
[0:52:59] dollars should we need it that's that second part and there are contingency
[0:53:04] dollars that will be earmarked in the event that the pool fund is unable to cover
[0:53:09] those costs as right now we're projecting it again. Thank you Chris
[0:53:14] Could you speak just a little more in depth about the handicapped chair or are we out of
[0:53:19] compliance now?
[0:53:20] Yes.
[0:53:21] Okay.
[0:53:22] If we leave the bulkhead in the middle, we're out of compliance.
[0:53:26] And as part of our agreement with the Department of Justice, we had until October to resolve
[0:53:35] that.
[0:53:36] The easy answer is to slide the bulkhead back.
[0:53:38] The other would be to buy that second lid for about $5,000 and put it.
[0:53:43] The plan right now would be to put it on the south, kind of in the middle on the south side
[0:53:50] of the pool.
[0:53:52] And then just run another hose down through there so we have a second permanent lift to
[0:53:57] give access.
[0:53:58] Thank you.
[0:53:59] And I had imagined in this so that you can.
[0:54:04] Kind of those are all a cart menu if you like.
[0:54:07] Are those actual beds or are they estimates?
[0:54:09] Yes, these are estimates.
[0:54:10] Sorry.
[0:54:11] And all the lights came on.
[0:54:15] Well, I wasn't paying attention to Suzanne Hawkins.
[0:54:18] The prices you gave us include installation.
[0:54:21] And so, well, there's no installation on the pool blankets.
[0:54:24] So it would just be.
[0:54:24] Right, but like on the handicap lift.
[0:54:26] We know.
[0:54:27] There's no installation on that.
[0:54:28] There's not really.
[0:54:29] I don't know how at all.
[0:54:30] And the park staff will put the doors in.
[0:54:32] So, primarily those never.
[0:54:34] And I'm sorry.
[0:54:35] I had them all attached.
[0:54:36] I had a little disaster on Wednesday afternoon
[0:54:38] with Fort Sink.
[0:54:39] But when I hurried and did it again,
[0:54:42] my attachments I forgot to attach.
[0:54:43] But I had some bids for you to look at.
[0:54:45] But it wasn't much.
[0:54:46] It just tears what it would cost.
[0:54:48] but included shipping.
[0:54:49] So you can see that these numbers include shipping
[0:54:51] and the purchase price, okay, thanks.
[0:54:57] Greg Lanting.
[0:55:00] Oh, we've always been very cognizant of safety
[0:55:03] and I think the door is actually coming
[0:55:05] in the safety issue a little bit.
[0:55:08] The full blanket conceivably could save us some fun,
[0:55:11] especially come this winter, the handicap lift,
[0:55:15] I think we made an agreement to come into compliance
[0:55:21] and this is better for the tool.
[0:55:23] These are some of the concerns I had.
[0:55:26] I was taking it back over, but everything on there,
[0:55:30] this is our asset.
[0:55:31] So we would, who's in charge, no matter who's in charge,
[0:55:34] I think we would be probably spending a spot
[0:55:38] so I'll be voting yes.
[0:55:40] Chris Dockington.
[0:55:41] And with that, I would move to approve
[0:55:44] the expenditure of $25,066 for the three-mentioned project
[0:55:49] items to be funded first from pool funds as available and second one from
[0:55:55] capital contingency funds second motion by Christogan and second vice-
[0:56:01] Suzanne Hawkins to approve the request as presented and the amount of twenty five
[0:56:06] thousand sixty six dollars there any further discussion Sharon we'll call
[0:56:14] vote please Ruth here yes Christopher Reed yes Chris
[0:56:25] Yes.
[0:56:26] Yes.
[0:56:27] Sean Berrigger.
[0:56:28] Yes.
[0:56:29] Nicky Boyd.
[0:56:30] Yes.
[0:56:31] Suzanne Hawkins.
[0:56:32] Yes.
[0:56:33] Greg Lanting.
[0:56:34] Yes.
[0:56:35] Motion passes 7-0.
[0:56:36] Thank you Wendy.
[0:56:39] Thank you.
[0:56:40] Next is a request to adopt a resolution to authorize the mayor to sign the state local agreement for construction for project number A0-20-295, Signals and Turn Bays, Shoshone Street, Key Number 202-95, and authorized payment of $34,896.
[0:56:55] $34,897 Jackie Fields, our city engineer.
[0:57:00] Welcome, Jackie.
[0:57:03] In January, the city council adopted a resolution
[0:57:06] and authorized the mayor to sign a state
[0:57:08] local agreement to design this work.
[0:57:11] The work has been designed to improve the signals
[0:57:16] at Shoshone and its intersections with six seconds,
[0:57:22] second, fourth, and sixth.
[0:57:24] This is a project that has dual batch, the state will also participate, signals that it
[0:57:35] has legs of which is primarily the seconds and sixth minute dog intersection.
[0:57:44] So the total job cost is projected at 1.2 million or so and the city's match is 34,800.
[0:57:55] So staff is recommending City Council a doctor resolution to authorize the mayor to sign the agreement for key number two, two, nine, five and authorize payment of 3,400,897 that I didn't bring back the sketch for the term base, which are as small as we can legally get them to provide access at fourth and sixth and not compromise, you know, and compromise as little parking as possible
[0:58:30] next to the churches and the park park and I apologize for not bringing it but
[0:58:38] they're petite so yeah petite there's no we can legally get them thank you Jackie
[0:58:49] Greg Linton did you say that they were gonna cost $1.2 million the entire
[0:58:54] project yes okay that that includes some of the turnbades and things like that
[0:58:59] It includes re-striping and several controllers.
[0:59:04] Some of those signals are fixed time signals, so the work is a little more complicated.
[0:59:09] There's a little more wiring to do.
[0:59:11] It's not just put in a new box and take out the equipment.
[0:59:14] So, will a fourth and sixth now be controlled by one of those little camera things instead
[0:59:20] of setting their house on street when there's nobody on the other lanes?
[0:59:24] It will no longer be a fixed time signal.
[0:59:26] So it'll have some detection that's better for everyone.
[0:59:32] Well, they'll still be flashing after 11 o'clock at night.
[0:59:38] We have not even talked about the concept
[0:59:43] that they could still be flashing late at night.
[0:59:45] OK.
[0:59:45] That's a drafting safety-quipped commission question,
[0:59:48] probably.
[0:59:49] Well, it'll be possible.
[0:59:53] We just have it.
[0:59:54] The next question is, what's my doing there in 11 o'clock
[0:59:56] at night?
[0:59:57] And your point is your partner's valid at 11 at night.
[1:00:01] There is almost never any kind of real demand
[1:00:05] at that intersection.
[1:00:06] So the flashing situation is money safe.
[1:00:10] OK.
[1:00:10] Thank you, Jay.
[1:00:11] Chris Stockington.
[1:00:12] Well, Greg, you started to get to the point,
[1:00:14] but I'm still puzzled for this million, too,
[1:00:17] as if primarily to speed up the traffic
[1:00:20] and get more cars through a particular area in a time
[1:00:24] or is it really a safety directive or a combo,
[1:00:27] how can we rationalize this?
[1:00:30] So the project, so every one of these intersections
[1:00:35] has a controlling box that is obsolete
[1:00:39] and we're having trouble getting parts for those boxes.
[1:00:45] So when a semi pulls around the corner on 6th of Minidoka
[1:00:50] and tears the box off of the pole,
[1:00:53] We have a real effort to get that signal up and running because the equipment is, all
[1:01:00] of the rest of the equipment is obsolete.
[1:01:02] So the goal is to replace all of these controllers, to tie them in to the communication system so
[1:01:09] that they can be viewed from a desk and also coordinated together to write the logic for
[1:01:16] that, to place ADA ramps at every intersection and to redo the strip in the roadways.
[1:01:23] I guess it's yes. Yes, but there's it's not it's not as simple as just taking out a little card and plug in it
[1:01:31] in the box. Sometimes it's that simple, but in this case it's not Greg Lanting. I think I know the answer to this
[1:01:40] question, Jackie, but I want to be confirmed. We're gonna we're gonna pay 34,000 states gonna
[1:01:45] a basically 48,000 and who's paying the rest of the 1.2 million?
[1:01:50] The federal government.
[1:01:53] That's what I assume.
[1:01:55] The federal aid is matched by both of us, by our pro-rata proportion of how we have responsible charge of the likes of the intersections.
[1:02:05] Okay.
[1:02:06] Yeah, that makes sense.
[1:02:07] Be good.
[1:02:08] Thanks.
[1:02:11] At least I wanted to be there.
[1:02:12] Sharon, do you have a resolution number?
[1:02:19] Resolution number 2017-12.
[1:02:26] Council wishes.
[1:02:29] Great landing.
[1:02:30] Movely accept or approve a resolution 2017-12
[1:02:35] to authorize the mayor to sign a state and local agreement
[1:02:38] for construction project number 8022.95 for signals turn base
[1:02:45] on Street key number 2295 and authorized payment of $34,897,
[1:02:52] which I'm assuming is coming out of the signal line
[1:02:54] and white them mentioned below.
[1:03:00] Second.
[1:03:02] Motion by Greg Lanting, seconded by Nikki Boyd
[1:03:04] to adopt resolution 2017-12, and everything else
[1:03:11] that was presented.
[1:03:13] Any further discussion?
[1:03:16] Chair in roll call vote please.
[1:03:22] Christopher Reed.
[1:03:23] Yes.
[1:03:24] Chris Tockington.
[1:03:25] Yes.
[1:03:26] Sean Beriker.
[1:03:27] Yes.
[1:03:28] Nikki Boyd.
[1:03:29] Yes.
[1:03:30] Suzanne Hawkins.
[1:03:31] Yes.
[1:03:31] Planting Ruth Pierce. Yes. Motion passes 7-0. Thank you Jackie. Next, highly anticipated
[1:03:46] quarterly visit from our CFO. Presentation of the finances of the City of Twin Falls
[1:03:53] for nine months of fiscal year 2016-2017. This presentation will be an overview of the
[1:03:59] tax supported funds and the three major enterprise funds, water wastewater and sanitation. We have
[1:04:05] category race or chief financial officer welcome thank you and I know you mean
[1:04:11] that nice story what I'm thinking is I'm pretty sure that former councilman Jim
[1:04:16] Munn is probably tuned in right now
[1:04:21] well good evening welcome Lori tonight I want to take you out of the fiscal
[1:04:26] year 2018 budget process but just for a short time and I want to update you on
[1:04:32] the city's finances for the last nine months of our current fiscal year. Nine out of 12
[1:04:38] months equals 75 percent, so that will be our measuring stick. And as always, we start with
[1:04:44] our tax-supported funds. We'll look at the major revenue sources and compare
[1:04:49] actuals, how they're coming in, and then we'll do the same thing for the enterprise funds,
[1:04:55] water sewer and sanitation. So this pie chart is just a reminder of our nine tax-supported
[1:05:04] funds and the percentage that each makes up with the total and the largest revenue
[1:05:09] sources in these funds comes from property taxes, franchise fees, state shared revenues,
[1:05:15] street fund monies, and transfers. And in total those five revenue sources make up
[1:05:23] close to 86 percent of the total revenues in our tax supported funds.
[1:05:27] Nicky Boyd has a question. Lori, will you remind all of us what transfers are? So
[1:05:34] So, Inner Fund transfers, you know that we do fund accounting, so we have general funds,
[1:05:40] street fund, water, sewer, and the departments, or the funds, or the other funds for different
[1:05:49] services, so we do what's called an Inner Fund transfer so that those services are accounted
[1:05:54] for and paid for.
[1:05:55] Thank you.
[1:05:56] You're welcome.
[1:06:00] So, our property taxes contribute the largest amount of resources.
[1:06:05] And the 19.3 million we expect to receive is over half the total tax-supported fund budget.
[1:06:14] The three-year average of receipts this time of year is 64.2 percent.
[1:06:21] And that includes delinquency collections.
[1:06:25] So we're currently at 63.6 percent of our budget.
[1:06:29] And I'm thinking, things are coming in good.
[1:06:32] What's going on?
[1:06:33] Well, the amounts that I include in those collections include the delinquencies,
[1:06:38] and this year, they're much lower than how they've been in the past.
[1:06:43] So, if you strip out those delinquencies, we average about 62% of what we're supposed to receive on an annual basis.
[1:06:53] And I took a look at just the delinquency collections are down 34% for 2017 versus 2016.
[1:07:05] I thought that was a good sign.
[1:07:10] Brand size fees make up 5% of the total and they are coming in above where they were last
[1:07:15] year at 85% of budget.
[1:07:17] And I'm still projecting the revenue from power will come in at around 5 to 6% more than
[1:07:23] was budgeted. While we had a really harsh winner that contributed to that, that additional revenue
[1:07:29] doesn't nearly begin to make up for the cost that we incurred. State shared revenues are
[1:07:37] received quarterly and they're a little bit behind their three-year average of 76.9%.
[1:07:44] So the first quarter, the state of Idaho, sends out their general fund report and boy,
[1:07:51] sales tax receipts are 7% above projections? Well, then the next three months come along
[1:07:58] and they're down and they're attributing that to the harsh winner. Well, the next three
[1:08:02] months come along and they're picking back up. So my point in sharing this is just want
[1:08:09] you to know that all those crystal balls are a little cloudy out there. I'm still projecting
[1:08:15] an increase in actual collections over budget of around two percent. Highway user revenues
[1:08:22] up from the prior three-year average of 75 percent. Now, a year ago when I was projecting
[1:08:28] this revenue for our current fiscal year, AIC had recommended a one-person increase. What
[1:08:34] I'm actually seeing in projecting is almost a seven-person increase, and these funds are
[1:08:39] dedicated to the street fund. Great-lanting as a question.
[1:08:43] I just got an email from AIC, because Zenn and I are both on the board, and they're projecting
[1:08:51] that the city, how we district all the other entities that's going to, instead of the estimated
[1:08:58] 3 million of surplus is going to be 11 million coming our way, will we get that during this
[1:09:03] year or will that be a next budget year?
[1:09:06] So it's going to be straddled a little bit, Greg, because the state has a different fiscal
[1:09:10] year than we do.
[1:09:11] Okay.
[1:09:12] All right, so we'll get some of it this year,
[1:09:14] which will also help that number, that's it.
[1:09:21] Transfers are off due to the sweeping of the surplus
[1:09:25] in the general fund, the capital improvement fund.
[1:09:28] We do that after the annual audit,
[1:09:29] and we'll include that in a budget amendment.
[1:09:32] So that's really a look at the major revenue sources
[1:09:35] in our tax-supported funds, 75% through the year.
[1:09:40] We've received 77% of our budgeted revenues,
[1:09:45] and that's above what we typically are. A majority of this increase is due to
[1:09:50] grant revenues, investment income, and transfers.
[1:09:54] Great. Lori, I was known each other when you went that first pie chart and you don't know how to go back to it.
[1:10:01] That's fine. I just, just in comparison to my mind, is something that Wendy Travis said earlier tonight.
[1:10:10] We operate the golf course as a franchise fund, or not a franchise fund, the enterprise
[1:10:16] fund, excuse me, but we don't operate the pool in the same manner.
[1:10:20] Is there a reason for that?
[1:10:23] So really, the golf course, when we operated it and brought in user fees, it was an enterprise
[1:10:31] fund, but with the current contract that we have, he keeps all the revenues, he pays
[1:10:36] all the bills for the most part.
[1:10:40] With the pool, when we started out this fiscal year,
[1:10:43] we put money aside from taxes to help offset the expenditures.
[1:10:49] So it's classified as a tax-supported fund.
[1:10:52] And as long as we're subsidizing it,
[1:10:54] we'll probably include it as a tax-supported fund.
[1:10:57] OK, Travis.
[1:10:59] So one of the things to note is that our current provider of services
[1:11:03] by contract out the golf course has been able to every year have a profit.
[1:11:09] But what's also important is we have an agreement that says that we will have a minimum revenue.
[1:11:15] He'll be guaranteed to earn a minimum revenue as part of the agreement.
[1:11:19] And if there's ever a point in which the city is required to meet that minimum revenue process,
[1:11:25] it would also come from property tax dollars.
[1:11:28] Because there's no other funding source to be able to offset that Gulf contract requirement.
[1:11:37] So basically they're being operated the same now they're both actually, thank you.
[1:11:44] So for the expenditures and the tax supported fund, this slide just simply illustrates the
[1:11:50] percentage of the budget allocated to each category.
[1:11:53] As you can see, personnel is the largest portion at 60% with M&O at 19, CAHPS at 16,
[1:12:01] and our Interfund transfers at 5%.
[1:12:06] In reviewing the expenditure categories in all nine of those tax-supported funds, we
[1:12:11] start with personnel.
[1:12:14] And actual costs include 20 out of 26 payrolls.
[1:12:18] So this one should be about 76.7% of spent.
[1:12:24] And as you can notice, we're about 75% were a tick under.
[1:12:29] M&O is below the 75% benchmark.
[1:12:34] costs are higher than budgeted due to the progress on the police station and the city hall project.
[1:12:40] And from October 1st through June 30th, we've spent $6.1 million on this project and we'll include that year in budget amendment.
[1:12:48] Transfers are high due to the annual sweep we talked about.
[1:12:52] And overall, tax-supported funds are showing their 90% spend three-quarters of the way through the year.
[1:13:00] but if you exclude the capital expenditures
[1:13:03] for the big projects and the transfers,
[1:13:07] then this budget is about 70% spent.
[1:13:15] So I have just one more little review that I'd like to do
[1:13:19] in the tax-supported funds.
[1:13:22] So I included this handout in your packet.
[1:13:26] And then today I asked Leila to help me update that
[1:13:29] because I excluded that three-year history,
[1:13:33] shows the percentage just for each of those years.
[1:13:35] So you should have that now.
[1:13:38] And the things that jumped out to me on this were grant revenues.
[1:13:43] So we budgeted 60,000 for ADA ramps,
[1:13:47] but we've actually received 115,000 for the COPS grant,
[1:13:52] an additional 57,000 for E9-1-1 funding,
[1:13:56] 90,000 for body worn cameras,
[1:13:59] 50,000 for Flipbar CDBG grant and a little over 27,000 for state transit development plan.
[1:14:10] On the recreation fees, that additional revenue is actually from the pool and it includes daily
[1:14:16] admissions, swim lessons, and memberships and it equals about $116,000. Investment income,
[1:14:25] so you already know we didn't spend on cash reserves on our large projects as quickly
[1:14:30] as I had anticipated and it's resulted in our cash being invested in yielding 2.5% and
[1:14:39] court revenues, I wanted to follow up on that one because it was an issue last time.
[1:14:44] So you might remember that we talked about falling revenues in this category and it was
[1:14:49] kind of hard to nail down as to why.
[1:14:52] While the revenues haven't recovered completely, instead of being down over 12% like they were
[1:14:58] the last time we talked year over year. They're down about 4.9% now. I'm only seeing the money
[1:15:06] coming in, so I contacted Christina Glasscock because revenue is coming in, so just a small
[1:15:12] piece of the picture. And she ran a report showing citations issued by our police department
[1:15:18] for 2017. And the number of citations did pick up through May, but they fell off again
[1:15:24] through June. So that information is helpful in me to go back and try to
[1:15:29] understand the history but certainly not helpful in projecting forward. So
[1:15:35] overall our tax-supported funds are at 77% for this time of year and that exceeds
[1:15:40] our three-year prior average. Personnel and amino expenditures are below the
[1:15:46] benchmark and we've discussed caps and transfers. Does anybody have any
[1:15:51] questions about the tax-supported funds before we move on.
[1:16:06] In the water fund, this graph shows actual revenues received nine months of each of the fiscal
[1:16:11] years from 2014 through current.
[1:16:15] And in looking back at the past 12 years of revenue history, we're typically about 61
[1:16:21] percent right now of what we're going to receive.
[1:16:24] What this means is I'm projecting we'll exceed this budget for this revenue type, probably
[1:16:30] by a couple hundred thousand dollars, but I want you to know that that's less than two
[1:16:34] percent of that total fund. We currently stand at close to sixty five percent of this budget.
[1:16:46] Our personnel costs in the water funder below the benchmark and M&O expenditures are well
[1:16:51] below budget. Cap projects are showing their two hundred and ten percent spent, but it's
[1:16:57] due to the carry over the Will's booster station project. And if you remove those expenditures,
[1:17:03] cap budget is just a little over 54% spent here to date. We have made only interest payments
[1:17:10] in the debt category, but I've already received notice of principal and interest payments due
[1:17:15] in mid-September. Transfers are just as we'd expect, 75% through the year, and overall,
[1:17:24] we're 66% spent, three-quarters of the way through this year, before adjusting for the
[1:17:30] Wills Boosters Station carryover project.
[1:17:33] And if you reduce the total expenditures by that,
[1:17:36] we're at about 46% of budget.
[1:17:39] I want you to know in the sum,
[1:17:40] so this is just through June.
[1:17:42] So pumping costs certainly pick up in July and August.
[1:17:47] We have preliminary engineering taking place
[1:17:50] on the well project,
[1:17:52] and we hope to have that info by mid-August.
[1:17:55] Meter replacement continues.
[1:17:57] Two PI stations are nearing completion.
[1:18:01] And as Rob Bowling shared with me,
[1:18:03] there will be a lot of money going out shortly.
[1:18:08] Chris Stockington.
[1:18:09] Speaking of water, I'd like to ask Travis the question
[1:18:13] that it would follow up by over the weekend,
[1:18:14] had a resident at 9th Avenue, 9th Avenue North,
[1:18:20] right where it goes in Addison.
[1:18:23] And she has noticed a substantial
[1:18:25] or another simple drop in our domestic water pressure.
[1:18:29] I wonder if you could have any knowledge of that
[1:18:32] and if you had any other complaints.
[1:18:35] No, this is actually the first complaint
[1:18:36] that I think that we've heard, John.
[1:18:39] I'm not aware of-
[1:18:40] But why does one or more individuals?
[1:18:41] I'm not aware of any reasons as to why
[1:18:46] that John Keaton, our public works director,
[1:18:47] might be aware of something that we're not of.
[1:18:52] Where have any reason why they would be having
[1:18:54] low water pressure so they can take cold water
[1:18:56] department we can certainly have a diagnosis.
[1:18:59] Figured to appreciate, it was the only one that might be an individual issue and if you'd
[1:19:04] had a number from that area there might have been something to do.
[1:19:07] Thank you.
[1:19:12] So in the wastewater fund we start with a look at budgeted revenues for residential, industrial
[1:19:17] and municipal users and that's along with the actual amounts received to date.
[1:19:23] This information is provided for the last three years plus current and as you can see
[1:19:28] We are at 79% for 2017.
[1:19:32] So those revenues, residential, industrial, and municipal,
[1:19:37] they're all lumped together.
[1:19:39] And when I went back and looked at them individually,
[1:19:42] residential estimate is usually very close.
[1:19:46] In 2014, actuals were just like 1.6% short of budget.
[1:19:53] In 2015, they were about 2% over.
[1:19:56] and we're talking less than $100,000.
[1:19:59] Last fiscal year, actual revenues for residential sewer
[1:20:04] were only 0.33% over, so that's cutting it a little close.
[1:20:09] It's the industrials and the municipals
[1:20:11] that are so hard to peg.
[1:20:15] So that kind of accounts for that fluctuation.
[1:20:24] And on the expenditure side,
[1:20:25] personnel costs in M&O are well below the benchmark.
[1:20:30] CAP is showing it's over budget, but the majority of these expenditures are for the wastewater
[1:20:35] treatment plant where we're winding down on that and they'll be included in the Budget Amendment.
[1:20:41] Interest payment has been made in the debt category and just like in the Water Fund, the
[1:20:45] rest will be paid later this year.
[1:20:48] Transfers are right where they should be and all in all this fund is showing that it's 99.8
[1:20:53] percent spent to date, but after you exclude the things that will be including in the Budget
[1:20:58] amendment, so 3.1 million of expansion project costs, encumbered items, Chobani odor control,
[1:21:05] and land. This fund is closer to 51.6% spent three-quarters of the way through the year.
[1:21:15] Finally, sanitation. When looking at these revenues, you can see the amount received
[1:21:20] here today is almost 75% for all the years. That's where I want it to be. Expenditures
[1:21:30] need very little explanation. M&O looks like we're under the benchmark, but again we pay
[1:21:38] behind. So that includes eight months worth of expenditures. And when you plug in nine months
[1:21:44] for PSI of the landfill, it's really closer to almost 74% spent. We don't have any capital or any
[1:21:51] debtness fund. Transfers are on target. And overall, after adjusting M&O expenditures to include those
[1:21:58] nine payments instead of eight. This budget is about 74% spent, three quarters of the way
[1:22:03] through the year. So that's a look at the revenues and expenditures for our three major
[1:22:12] enterprise funds. Most revenues are coming in as expected and expenditures are at or below
[1:22:19] the 75% benchmark for both water and wastewater. We talked about the deviations. We know there
[1:22:26] are some approved expenditures that were not anticipated at the beginning of the fiscal
[1:22:30] year and those will be included in our year in budget amendment. Sanitations
[1:22:35] right on track with both revenues and expenditures. I noticed that it seems like
[1:22:41] my summary seldom changes but I want you to know the city is in good strong
[1:22:46] sound financial condition. Do you have any questions about any of that? Any
[1:22:51] questions for Lori? How do you argue with those speakers? Nice work by you and the
[1:22:57] whole team for keeping things in check and for a nice easy to follow presentation.
[1:23:04] Next on the agenda is a presentation of the city managers recommended budget for
[1:23:12] fiscal year 2018 followed by an opportunity for citizen input and we have
[1:23:17] our deputy city manager Mitch Humboldt again this evening.
[1:23:21] So Lori started by taking you out of our 2018 budget process. It's July and we can't have that.
[1:23:30] So I'm going to bring you right back to it and I think in the staffing part this time
[1:23:36] we actually reduced the time so it didn't freak you all out that I was going to stand
[1:23:40] up here for an hour.
[1:23:41] So I intend to go through this fairly quickly even more so than last week, say last month.
[1:23:47] Because really the two topics that we're going to talk about tonight, again, this is
[1:23:50] just I'll talk about the link to the strategic plan.
[1:23:52] But the two topics we're going to talk about tonight is health community and learning
[1:23:55] community and particularly learning communities is a difficult one for the city
[1:24:00] funds to really to go into so it'll be a little bit shorter tonight. We're going to
[1:24:07] first talk about health community though. So again our this language comes
[1:24:13] straight out of strategic plan this talks about our healthy community focus area
[1:24:17] and this is the focus area that talks about public health it talks about trails
[1:24:22] and parks and activity levels, but it also talks about maintaining roadway systems and water systems to help us have better access to and from our health-focused kind of amenities, as well as water and sewer.
[1:24:38] So, let's get right into it.
[1:24:41] So, for a healthy community, we have several park improvements.
[1:24:45] These are kind of all balled up into that $129,000 figure, but we're proposing improvements
[1:24:52] in Harman at Sunway and at the skate park that told $28,000.
[1:24:56] We talked a little bit about this last week, the park master plan improvements.
[1:25:01] This again is an example of how our focus areas tend to overlap a bit, and sometimes an
[1:25:08] expense like $100,000 in park master plan improvements can meet multiple goals in the strategic plan.
[1:25:14] So we're going to mention those again.
[1:25:16] We're going to spend $100,000 in park master plan improvements.
[1:25:19] Those specific ones haven't yet been identified,
[1:25:21] but we're going to take the money.
[1:25:22] We're going to go into that park master plan.
[1:25:24] We're going to start doing those as we get into that next week.
[1:25:27] In October, when we start spending the money.
[1:25:31] We're going to, tonight, we appointed a recreation center
[1:25:34] committee.
[1:25:34] We're going to get working on that.
[1:25:36] There's a little bit of money in this year's budget
[1:25:38] to start that process.
[1:25:39] But really, this $10,000 is to continue
[1:25:41] working with that committee.
[1:25:43] It's probably going to look a little bit like facilitator money
[1:25:47] lunches for the committee meetings, those kinds of things.
[1:25:50] So that committee is going to do a lot of work toward furthering
[1:25:54] our healthy community goal, the recreation center.
[1:25:58] We've got $117, $118,000 out of the golf course
[1:26:01] for improvements and equipment.
[1:26:05] Street overlays and maintenance.
[1:26:06] This is one that I thought would be interesting to talk about
[1:26:10] with healthy community.
[1:26:11] It's not typically associated with Healthy Community,
[1:26:14] but when you get into our Healthy Community goals
[1:26:17] in the strategic plan, there's a very specific one
[1:26:20] that says we're gonna maintain a street system
[1:26:23] that helps our people get,
[1:26:25] they need to be in an emergency
[1:26:27] and helps our first responders get
[1:26:29] where they need to be in an emergency.
[1:26:31] And so this is a direct correlation
[1:26:33] to our Healthy Community goal
[1:26:35] is maintaining our streets in a way
[1:26:36] that helps our emergency responders get
[1:26:38] where they need to be,
[1:26:40] which also gets you to North College roadway extension
[1:26:43] in the Sunway design that also gets access
[1:26:45] to our park out there.
[1:26:46] Again, get our emergency responders where they need to be,
[1:26:49] get access to our park in Sunway.
[1:26:52] Seal coat is exactly the same thing.
[1:26:54] We're maintaining our roadways, keeping them passable
[1:26:57] for folks to get where they need to be
[1:26:59] and particularly emergency response.
[1:27:01] And then again, with several of these,
[1:27:04] we're gonna see no new personnel requested this
[1:27:07] because this year's kind of a small year for new personnel.
[1:27:10] So those are the significant kind of highlight expenses for healthy community.
[1:27:16] Do you have any questions about that before I move on to the next one?
[1:27:21] So learning community, this is the focus area that talks about how we want to be a learning focus community
[1:27:28] or a community that ever increases our education.
[1:27:32] And we want to be in this case, I think, a partner in that with several other partner organizations out there.
[1:27:40] So while it's not specifically addressed anywhere in the budget,
[1:27:43] we're going to continue to partnership with CSI.
[1:27:45] We're going to continue to have positive results driven partnerships
[1:27:51] with the school district.
[1:27:53] But we do actually have a few places where we're going to spend our own money
[1:27:56] on our own learning community focus areas.
[1:28:00] And primarily, that's in the library.
[1:28:02] There's a bunch of money that we send to the library every year.
[1:28:05] This is $1.7 million in capital and operations at the library
[1:28:10] that comes from our taxpayers.
[1:28:13] We're also going to provide a new school resource officer
[1:28:15] to the new middle school.
[1:28:17] That's not new money.
[1:28:19] We're not hiring another one.
[1:28:20] We're reassigning a current officer to those duties.
[1:28:23] And so it's not necessarily getting showing up
[1:28:26] in this budget as a new request, but it is an expense
[1:28:30] that we're going to be making this year.
[1:28:32] And then, again, no new personnel related to learning community.
[1:28:36] Chris Tucker.
[1:28:37] Yeah, this is a question actually, probably for you, Brian.
[1:28:41] Speaking of schools, our SROs do not use body cams on school premises, do they?
[1:28:53] And I know I have the chief here just in case I get this wrong, but
[1:28:56] it's my understanding that they do use the body cameras while they're in patrol.
[1:29:02] So any time one of our patrol officers is performing their duties,
[1:29:05] the net would include in the community, and in the schools, wherever they're at,
[1:29:11] they have their body cameras on them.
[1:29:13] And there is a cheap, I don't know if you have anything
[1:29:16] added to this, but I had a parent ask me about that.
[1:29:19] Over the weekend, they're concerned about dealing
[1:29:23] with minors in non-offensive situations,
[1:29:26] and perhaps going over some borders
[1:29:30] or propriety of photographing students
[1:29:33] and their normal going on.
[1:29:37] That's never been an issue that's come out
[1:29:39] or a question that has been legally challenged.
[1:29:43] I'm not that I'm aware of.
[1:29:45] And I can, if the chief, Greg, do you have anything you want to add?
[1:29:57] Mayor and Councilman Talkington, city managers,
[1:30:01] we just rolled out the body cameras
[1:30:03] to the school resource officers right
[1:30:07] at the end of this last school year.
[1:30:10] So as we enter into the school year this fall,
[1:30:12] our school resource officers who do work in uniform,
[1:30:16] 99% of the time, we'll be wearing the body worn camera.
[1:30:20] Now, as you may remember from the training
[1:30:23] that you received at the City Council,
[1:30:25] those cameras are always recording,
[1:30:27] so they are always recording.
[1:30:29] But when an officer activates that camera,
[1:30:32] it then goes back 30 seconds,
[1:30:34] and that recording from the 30 seconds from,
[1:30:38] if I were to have one, when I turned it on,
[1:30:40] forward is what is going to be put into the Evans.com system.
[1:30:46] In the schools, our officers are only going to record what I would call enforcement contacts.
[1:30:54] They're not going to be putting things into evidence.com, such as school children in the lunch rooms or anything like that, unless we have some sort of police contact in that.
[1:31:07] And when they utilize the restroom facilities, are those cameras still recording?
[1:31:13] when the officers utilize the restroom facilities.
[1:31:16] By the way, well, if they don't actually reach up
[1:31:21] and turn it off, then yes, it will have that.
[1:31:25] I can check on that.
[1:31:26] That is an issue that we even deal with
[1:31:29] in our police headquarters building.
[1:31:31] So we have learned to be pretty careful with those.
[1:31:34] Okay, thank you, appreciate it.
[1:31:45] I have anything else to add for learning community
[1:31:47] that listens to our questions?
[1:31:48] So mention just a couple of comments
[1:31:50] that think about learning community.
[1:31:52] And as we're going through the strategic plan update,
[1:31:54] I think this is more of a strategic plan issue
[1:31:56] than a budget issue.
[1:31:58] But I do think we have a couple of areas
[1:32:00] of the strategic plan that we actually do more
[1:32:03] in that category than we give ourselves credit for.
[1:32:06] Learning community, I think, is one of those.
[1:32:09] I think about programs like our historic preservation
[1:32:11] commission puts on, talking about history
[1:32:13] in the community.
[1:32:14] I think even some of the recreation programs
[1:32:16] that we offer, the senior center activities.
[1:32:20] So I think as we move forward, we need to be thinking a little bit more about the kinds of things that we are doing to address these, and maybe even look for other partnerships.
[1:32:32] So maybe the senior center isn't quite us, and that's a partnership, but maybe it includes some money thrown in there to help support it, or recreation programs, so just an observation.
[1:32:42] I agree.
[1:32:43] I'm looking forward to when Phil comes back to talk to us again about what the results
[1:32:49] of all this public input was and I can see some changes being made, particularly to this
[1:32:54] strategic goal area, I'm sorry.
[1:32:59] So with that, we'll just move right into our summary again.
[1:33:02] This is probably one we'll bring up each time when we get through our budget.
[1:33:09] The proposed budget leads to a $14.18 decrease
[1:33:16] in the average home property tax bill.
[1:33:20] A $1.49 monthly increase in the utility bill
[1:33:26] for that average customer.
[1:33:29] And then the rest of this slide presentation,
[1:33:32] I'm gonna turn over to Travis,
[1:33:34] where you mentioned last week
[1:33:35] that you wanted to talk about foregone amounts.
[1:33:38] So I guess we're ready to go there now unless you want to get public input on these things.
[1:33:45] So, any other questions for?
[1:33:49] The questions for Mitch?
[1:33:54] I don't see any, thank you, Mitch.
[1:33:56] Welcome, Travis.
[1:33:57] Thank you, Mr. Mayor, Mr. Council.
[1:33:59] So tonight, my part is to talk about the foregone balance.
[1:34:03] What does it mean?
[1:34:04] How did it arrive?
[1:34:06] What does it look like?
[1:34:07] And so tonight, I'm going to spend a lot more time tonight than I am in the upcoming weeks
[1:34:14] about talking about the foregone balance,
[1:34:16] so that we can kind of create that foundation of knowledge
[1:34:19] that really we can all work from and understand
[1:34:23] how does it come to be, and how long will it last.
[1:34:27] So one of the most important premise or beginnings
[1:34:30] is to remember that everything that we can do
[1:34:34] as a local government comes from permissions granted
[1:34:38] by the Idaho legislature.
[1:34:40] So as a Dillon Rule State, that means that all of the
[1:34:46] opportunities, rules and regulations that we are
[1:34:50] afforded, the things that we have, the opportunity to make
[1:34:54] decisions around, those provided, those directions are
[1:34:58] provided to us by the Idaho legislature.
[1:35:02] And how we collect property taxes is certainly one of those
[1:35:07] key areas that the legislature provides oversight.
[1:35:11] And so you'll see Idaho Code Section 6382 subsection E
[1:35:16] states that you as a city have the opportunity
[1:35:20] to collect 3% more revenue than you did the prior year.
[1:35:26] Plus what we often will refer to as the growth formula,
[1:35:30] where you take the new construction and annexation
[1:35:33] report and we apply the prior years tax rate and that is going to create the total amount
[1:35:41] of money that a local government, non-school local government is able to collect on an annual
[1:35:47] basis. So every year we have the ability to really project. What does that 3% more revenue
[1:35:53] look like in subsequent years? The piece that gets a little fuzzy is obviously on the new
[1:35:57] market number, and we saw how this year it was less than what we had anticipated and
[1:36:04] we explained why.
[1:36:05] So what's important is the first piece, the opportunity to look at including a foregone
[1:36:12] balance into a local government budget is only available for as long as the legislature
[1:36:19] says that you can do it.
[1:36:21] And over the course of the last two legislative sessions, there have been two additional bills
[1:36:28] that have been placed, one requires a special public hearing to be asked for by the, or to
[1:36:36] be hosted by the local government entity, if you are going to take any portion of that
[1:36:42] foregone balance.
[1:36:43] And then the second this year is that if we were not going to be taking the 3% the statutory
[1:36:49] Allowances you as a council have a right to remove that foregone balance from being included
[1:36:55] into the total summation of that foregone balance. That's really unless we change the budget that
[1:37:01] we've put together and that 3% plus the new construction number is not used, that's not a question
[1:37:06] that we'll be asking during this budget process. What is important is that the budget that we've
[1:37:16] been having a conversation about does not include any of the city's foregone balance. So everything
[1:37:23] thing that we put together provided to you through the conversation is balanced
[1:37:27] without inclusion of the foregone balance. The foregone balance, it's at $2,186,000.
[1:37:34] And that has grown since the fiscal year 2009, 2010 budget. And it has grown in
[1:37:41] varying amounts over the course of the last several fiscal years. And so this
[1:37:46] kind of illustrates the amount each year since fiscal year 2010. And then the
[1:37:51] total as it has kind of moved forward through these different budgets that have been adopted
[1:37:59] by the City Council based upon the manager's recommendation.
[1:38:05] But what I want to spend a little bit of time talking about is an economic term called an
[1:38:10] opportunity cost.
[1:38:12] And an opportunity cost is really, really defined as the loss of a potential gain based
[1:38:21] of the consequences of the decisions that we make.
[1:38:24] And so when you take a look at the decision not to include the statutory allowance, there
[1:38:32] is a cost associated with that.
[1:38:36] There's also a benefit.
[1:38:37] So one of the benefits that we've talked about by not including the three, the entire statutory
[1:38:42] balance, the tax rate that is applied that's based upon our government's spending is less
[1:38:49] than what it otherwise would have been had we taken 3% plus new construction every year
[1:38:56] associated with this formula.
[1:39:00] However, the total cumulative cost of that decision far exceeds the nearly $2.2 million.
[1:39:08] In fact, the opportunity cost of that decision is nearly $13.3 million because every single
[1:39:17] year those dollars would have been included.
[1:39:20] And this is a chart.
[1:39:21] We recognize it's difficult to see, but we really want to illustrate, how do you get
[1:39:26] from 2.2 million to nearly 13.3 million?
[1:39:30] And what you can see is that in fiscal year 2010, you would have taken 539,000, and that
[1:39:39] is that total for that fiscal year.
[1:39:41] Well, that 539,000 then becomes part of your base every single year.
[1:39:50] And you would have then also had the opportunity in fiscal year 2011 to take an additional
[1:39:56] $476,000, plus the 3% is based upon the prior year.
[1:40:06] And so the budget for fiscal year 2011 was actually a million dollars, $32,000 smaller
[1:40:16] than what it otherwise could have been,
[1:40:18] had you taken the full amounts that are statutory allowed
[1:40:24] in each of those fiscal years.
[1:40:26] And you can carry that progression
[1:40:28] as though you took that exact amount every single year.
[1:40:32] And you could see that the fiscal year 2017 budget
[1:40:36] would actually be $2,509,000 greater than the one
[1:40:41] that we've recommended for this fiscal year.
[1:40:45] And if you add up all of those dollars across the bottom,
[1:40:49] you get to $13,279,420.
[1:40:55] Chris talked.
[1:40:56] And another way of defining the opportunity cost is every year
[1:41:00] from 2010, you're increasing the mill levy,
[1:41:03] and you're compounding that mill levy in successive years.
[1:41:08] And that's how you get to $13 million
[1:41:09] is by increasing from the late the mill lovers.
[1:41:14] Potentially.
[1:41:15] Yeah, so as we've illustrated, and we'll get to that point.
[1:41:18] So in some of those years, it increases,
[1:41:20] but really it depends upon what happens
[1:41:23] to the community's total taxable value.
[1:41:25] Because it's, remember, the tax rate
[1:41:28] is a mathematical product of government spending
[1:41:31] divided by the total taxable value.
[1:41:33] And so, then let me take the mill levy out
[1:41:36] and say that you are increasing taxes every year
[1:41:39] by doing that by the opportunity cost I was describing.
[1:41:45] I would probably argue in most cases, but again, because I can't say that uniformly across all properties,
[1:41:53] because what you have is a multiplier that is applied against an individual property,
[1:41:59] and how that property either appreciated or depreciated really determines whether or not they are going to pay more or less in property taxes.
[1:42:09] And you're saying as possible that the opportunity cost could actually decrease the tax load on an individual?
[1:42:16] It absolutely could depending upon
[1:42:19] What happened with that individual property?
[1:42:23] So even this year in the example you've given of the median property for the community, the average home based upon the evaluation that we currently have is actually a
[1:42:34] a decrease in the total tax dollars out of that homeowners pocket.
[1:42:40] Yeah, so if all of the information remains as created,
[1:42:48] we have only control over the amount of property tax dollars
[1:42:53] that we are willing to spend to advance public goods and services.
[1:42:59] And based upon the total taxable value of the community,
[1:43:03] that was provided to us by the assessor.
[1:43:06] We can illustrate that the tax rate
[1:43:08] is actually going to decrease by 52 cents
[1:43:11] per $1,000 of taxable value.
[1:43:14] Now, you can see that that property
[1:43:17] is based upon a house that actually grew in value.
[1:43:21] But the growth in that value is less
[1:43:25] than the decrease in the property tax.
[1:43:28] And so this individual, in our example,
[1:43:32] is going to pay about $14.18 less in property taxes.
[1:43:37] And we've watched lots of different ebbs and flows
[1:43:40] that have occurred.
[1:43:41] What's important is it's really hard to look and talk
[1:43:46] about the individual, because we're
[1:43:48] talking about a really big, big pie.
[1:43:51] And some of those slivers of that make up that pie, which
[1:43:54] are taxpayers, some are much larger than others.
[1:43:59] and how those slices get divided on an annual basis are really depending upon what your proportionate
[1:44:08] costs are going to be.
[1:44:11] We do not like to project what's going to happen globally because there's always been
[1:44:17] that one case when we say property taxes are going to go down.
[1:44:22] Someone will illustrate that property taxes for them went up and when we say that property
[1:44:26] taxes are going up globally. We hear people saying, well, I thought you said my taxes were
[1:44:30] going up. They actually went down. And so we don't like to talk in absolutes when we're
[1:44:34] talking about property taxes. So the opportunity cost of this decision is about $13.2 million.
[1:44:47] There's two ways to look at that. That's $13.2 million of revenue over the course of
[1:44:53] all of those fiscal years that could have been leveraged to other services.
[1:45:00] It is also the case that that is property tax dollars that were not collected.
[1:45:06] So a majority of our citizens actually received a smaller tax bill than what would have otherwise
[1:45:12] been provided.
[1:45:15] So that's the scale that you look at.
[1:45:22] So one of the things that we were asked by the council is if we were to look and take
[1:45:28] any portion of that, what would it look like, how would you recommend and what projects would
[1:45:33] you specifically call out.
[1:45:36] And one of the things I think that this illustrates, which kind of when we started to do the analysis
[1:45:41] really started to drive our decision, we didn't recommend any specific projects because what
[1:45:47] happens is this money becomes permanent.
[1:45:51] It becomes built in until you make a conscious decision to no longer include it and it's not
[1:45:57] by excluding it from a tax rate, it's actually excluding it from property tax collections.
[1:46:03] It means that you are no longer going to collect those dollars, so you are going to
[1:46:07] make a conscious decision to collect less property tax dollars than you did the prior year.
[1:46:13] So assuming that these dollars kind of move into that base because the conversations that
[1:46:18] we've had with the council in the past,
[1:46:20] talk about the 3% and that philosophy moving forward.
[1:46:24] What we said was we believe that we should break this
[1:46:28] into three pots.
[1:46:29] And you can create four pots or five pots,
[1:46:32] but this was our idea just to create
[1:46:35] some sort of ongoing stream to move this forward.
[1:46:41] So we automatically believe that 50%
[1:46:44] of all those revenues should be immediately placed
[1:46:46] industry fund related projects.
[1:46:51] John Caton has come to you, and he illustrated $12 million
[1:46:57] with the deficiencies that were a result of the last winter
[1:47:03] and road repairs that we have to move forward with.
[1:47:05] We had $4.4 million in our budget
[1:47:09] that we were able to apply to the greatest of needs.
[1:47:12] John was also able to secure a grant
[1:47:15] to cover some of those costs.
[1:47:17] But even with the grants and the dollars,
[1:47:20] we're not covering quite 50% of the total costs associated
[1:47:25] with that.
[1:47:26] And we've got $1.5 million left in the cash reserve fund
[1:47:30] based upon monies of the 2016 audit.
[1:47:34] So when we look at cash reserves, one of the things
[1:47:37] that we do is we look at that number based
[1:47:41] upon the most recent audit.
[1:47:44] And so when we take a look at that audit, right now,
[1:47:47] remember, in all of our funds, we take three months
[1:47:50] of operating capital, we've locked that away
[1:47:52] and we've restricted it.
[1:47:54] That is not included in the additional $1.5 million
[1:47:56] of unrestricted that could be available for projects.
[1:48:02] We recommend that you would take 25%
[1:48:04] and you would put that into community building
[1:48:07] infrastructure projects.
[1:48:09] Things that would help us advance the park master plan.
[1:48:12] things that would help us create additional trails.
[1:48:16] So this would go into that place making concept
[1:48:18] that we believe is critically important,
[1:48:20] especially as we look at being a prosperous community,
[1:48:23] healthy community.
[1:48:24] And then the other 25% is to take a look at special projects
[1:48:28] to be determined by the Council on an annual basis.
[1:48:31] To take advantage of those things that may not be known.
[1:48:37] So there's an opportunity to buy a piece of property
[1:48:42] that allows for the completion of our trail,
[1:48:45] you have some sort of revenue stream
[1:48:49] to be able to absorb that.
[1:48:50] And so just a quick little analysis, every $500,000,
[1:48:56] that was a really easy number for us to do analysis.
[1:48:58] We're not recommending you take $500,000,
[1:49:01] but you would put 250,000 towards advancing the trail system
[1:49:04] as connected to focus area for accessible community.
[1:49:08] that could be all types of transportation-related programs.
[1:49:14] Two hundred, again, towards parks and then one-time projects.
[1:49:20] So what we did here was then we said what is that impact?
[1:49:25] If you were to take increments into $500,000
[1:49:29] onto the tax rate, and what is the impact on that same home
[1:49:36] that we've been illustrated who's going to receive that $14
[1:49:39] than 12 cent property tax break this year.
[1:49:44] So if you take zero of the foregone balance,
[1:49:48] the tax rate we're projecting is going to be $7.51 per $1,000.
[1:49:54] You'll have about $19.9 million in total property tax
[1:49:57] collections.
[1:49:58] The tax liability is $552.77.
[1:50:02] Last year, that same property, which grew in value,
[1:50:07] pays $56.92.
[1:50:10] So you can see that that's the exact same scenario
[1:50:12] that when we show that conclusion page,
[1:50:14] that's what that looks like.
[1:50:16] If you were to incorporate $500,000 of the foregone balance,
[1:50:22] you see the increase in property tax collections.
[1:50:25] You see the potential increase in the tax rate.
[1:50:29] You see what the property tax liability,
[1:50:31] And so it grows to $5.69, $569.08.
[1:50:37] And if you compare that to the prior year,
[1:50:39] you can see it's about $2, $3 more than what it was for this
[1:50:45] property in the current fiscal year budget.
[1:50:48] And we do that scenario all the way down.
[1:50:50] So an easy way to think of it, for every $500,000
[1:50:55] that you would take of the foregone balance,
[1:50:57] you would increase the property tax
[1:51:00] load based upon the information that we have on the average home, $13.91 annually or 2.5%.
[1:51:24] There's just two last pieces. The first is where you don't have to make a decision tonight.
[1:51:34] In fact, we would advocate that you don't make a decision tonight, that you continue to process.
[1:51:39] and you look, there are a couple of dates
[1:51:42] that you absolutely have to make decisions.
[1:51:46] So the first date is when you set the tentative budget, which
[1:51:52] is on August 14, you will set under the preliminary budget.
[1:51:58] Excuse me.
[1:51:59] That's the maximum spending number.
[1:52:02] And that doesn't mean that's the amount that you're going to take.
[1:52:05] But by law, that's the highest amount
[1:52:09] your budget can't be. So that's the first decision. And what we will have to do is if
[1:52:14] you want to include any part of the foregone balance into the budget that we've recommended,
[1:52:21] then we also will have to set a public hearing date because that is a requirement that we
[1:52:27] have to have a separate public hearing outside of the budget public hearing to disclose that
[1:52:33] that we are taking the foregone balance.
[1:52:36] That is an extra step of transparency that we take.
[1:52:41] And so we would need to know that by the 14th.
[1:52:44] And then obviously the 28th.
[1:52:47] That is the last day in which we will have a conversation
[1:52:51] about the budget.
[1:52:52] So even if you go forward on the 14th
[1:52:55] and you say we want to include the entire foregone balance
[1:52:58] and we host a public hearing on the 28th,
[1:53:01] you're under no obligation to take it.
[1:53:03] You always have the right to remove, to reduce,
[1:53:07] to change any portion,
[1:53:09] whether it be the foregone balanced conversation
[1:53:11] or any part of the recommended budget up until that point
[1:53:14] in time that we present.
[1:53:20] That's my question.
[1:53:25] Thank you.
[1:53:26] I don't see any lights on for any comments or questions.
[1:53:30] Thank you for sharing that information.
[1:53:32] So one of the things that we've talked about
[1:53:34] is that we would have this conversation again next week.
[1:53:37] What we will do is it's probably so the foundation has been set,
[1:53:42] give you some opportunities to think about it.
[1:53:44] Staff will be in a position to really answer questions and talk
[1:53:48] about or answer any questions that you might have as you continue
[1:53:54] to navigate through this process.
[1:53:55] We want to be a resource to help answer any questions that you're in.
[1:53:59] Thank you, Travis.
[1:54:02] So as we have said through the whole budget process,
[1:54:05] we do want to hear from you the citizens as you're here.
[1:54:08] So if there's anyone who wishes to give some input on the budget specifically this evening now is your chance to come forward.
[1:54:15] All right.
[1:54:19] Seeing no one we will move on with the agenda to any advisory board reports or announcements.
[1:54:25] Greg Lanting.
[1:54:28] Well last night I was watching the as I do most nights I was watching the Mariners game.
[1:54:34] And a little hole up popped on the screen.
[1:54:38] They have a section that's called Where I Root.
[1:54:41] And people send in through their Twitter accounts
[1:54:45] where they're watching the game or listening to the game,
[1:54:49] whichever one.
[1:54:49] And up pops our chief, identified as the chief
[1:54:55] of the City of Twin Falls.
[1:54:56] It was over his right shoulder was the Shoshone Falls.
[1:55:00] And he was apparently walking the trail down there
[1:55:02] and got a little plug-in for the City Twin Falls
[1:55:05] and the Police Department and the Social Falls,
[1:55:07] all in one little post, and they made sure
[1:55:09] they everybody realized it was the chief of City Twin Falls
[1:55:12] that was posting that where I route.
[1:55:14] And Travis has a comment.
[1:55:17] Now, only if we actually had people
[1:55:19] who watched Mariner's baseball,
[1:55:21] they'd actually be able to see it.
[1:55:22] Yeah.
[1:55:23] Well, since I watched both Mariner's and Yankee baseball,
[1:55:27] that was a double treat for me last night,
[1:55:29] But I'm sure there's others.
[1:55:31] I know.
[1:55:32] Thank you.
[1:55:33] And I'll watch tonight when they're playing the Red Sox.
[1:55:40] Any other advisory board reports or comments from the council?
[1:55:43] Do I have to see anything?
[1:55:47] I just want to go back real quick and I don't know councilman
[1:55:50] talking to him if we really answered your question.
[1:55:53] And so it just really is a point of clarification.
[1:55:56] So when our school resource officers are in the school,
[1:55:59] They have always used staff restrooms and facilities.
[1:56:03] The only reason that they would be in a restroom where students would be that they would be taking some level of enforcement action.
[1:56:12] So that level of interaction just doesn't take place in its normal course of duty, so they wouldn't have that contact.
[1:56:18] Does that make sense?
[1:56:19] I hope that clarifies that.
[1:56:19] Well, that's comforting to know.
[1:56:21] That's a good common sense, but I hope that's a steadfast rule.
[1:56:27] Thank you.
[1:56:28] So many of you noticed that Renee was here tonight and Jonathan started that
[1:56:35] presentation last week. Jonathan is at home right now with the new baby. His wife
[1:56:40] gave birth to the new baby yesterday. A healthy boy, mother and son are both
[1:56:46] healthy I think they named him Raymond. So just wanted to pass that along to y'all.
[1:56:51] Great, always an excuse to get out of work.
[1:56:57] We do not have any public hearing scheduled this evening.
[1:57:00] We do have a chance for any general public input.
[1:57:04] If there's anyone here still from the public who wishes to address the council
[1:57:06] and any issues that were not on the agenda, how is your chance to come forward?
[1:57:13] Seeing no one, the meeting is adjourned.
[1:57:18] None of us got it correct.
[1:57:20] Not even seven.
[1:57:21] None of us got it.
[1:57:22] I felt like the president.
[1:57:23] They were all sent us a little bit different.
[1:57:25] They were on the agenda.
[1:57:26] Yeah.
[1:57:27] We're done.
