Oversight Archive: City Council meeting, 2017-11-13, recording 1 (started 15:30)
Machine transcript (faster-whisper base.en), not checked word for word; the Pledge of Allegiance is shown in its standard wording. The recording is the record.
Times are time into the recording. Passages with private details are muted in the audio and marked here.
The audio on the page below was re-encoded by software from the video the agency posted. Check any passage against
that audio before relying on it.
Page: https://oversightarchive.org/twin-falls-id/meetings/2017-11-13/

[0:00:23] Ready? I would like to call to order the meeting of the Twin Falls City Council for Monday, November 13th. It is
[0:00:34] 3.37. We are meeting early for the purpose of touring the Will's booster station.
[0:00:40] So we will be
[0:00:42] Resessing the meeting to go do that and we will return for the regularly regular meeting at 5 p.m.
[0:00:48] So with that we will stand in recess.
[0:00:50] So, that was my third item, Jim and I go back for you.
[1:25:03] My funny bone.
[1:25:08] I would like to reconvene the City Council meeting for Monday, November 13th.
[1:25:13] The Council did meet this afternoon at 3.30 and toured the Will's Booster Station out of
[1:25:18] the water tanks.
[1:25:20] And so, now we're here for the regular meeting agenda.
[1:25:24] I would confirm we do have a quorum of the Council here, six of the seven members are present
[1:25:28] this evening.
[1:25:29] The Councilman Reed is excused.
[1:25:33] Before we move on with the rest of the agenda, I would like to share just a little bit of
[1:25:37] information here.
[1:25:39] Earlier this month on November 2nd, former Congressman Orville Hanson passed away.
[1:25:45] Mr. Hanson was the uncle of Council Member Ruth Pierce.
[1:25:48] Mr. Hanson had a long and distinguished service in the practice of law and public service,
[1:25:53] and served in the Idaho House for many years, described it in his memoir as a time when,
[1:25:58] We wore our partisan labels lightly, party-lined boats and angry words and debate were rare.
[1:26:05] We played partisan games in fun mainly to keep up or morale.
[1:26:09] Debate could be spirited but it was civil.
[1:26:11] Friendships extended across the aisle.
[1:26:14] This spirit of bipartisan cooperation and statesmanship helped Mr. Hanson in his election to Congress
[1:26:20] and his three terms of service to the people of Idaho, during which he collaborated on landmark
[1:26:25] legislation to create the Sawtooth National Recreation Area and advocacy for the Idaho
[1:26:30] National Laboratory.
[1:26:32] Our thoughts are with the Hanson family and with Ruth during this time of mourning.
[1:26:37] Mr. Hanson will lie in state at the Idaho State House next Monday with public services
[1:26:41] planned in Boise.
[1:26:43] So tonight I would ask you to please join me in a moment of silence to honor the memory
[1:26:47] of Orville Hanson.
[1:26:48] Ruth?
[1:27:08] A moment.
[1:27:09] Yes.
[1:27:10] So I'm going to have a hard time keeping it together you guys.
[1:27:12] but I do want to tell you an anecdote about my uncle.
[1:27:17] Growing up having a political family,
[1:27:21] we cut our teeth on licking envelopes
[1:27:24] and folding campaign letters.
[1:27:26] That was before cell phones and the internet.
[1:27:30] And so when I was in high school,
[1:27:33] because I was super excited about having my driver's license,
[1:27:36] I got hired to be his campaign chauffeur
[1:27:41] all around our district, which is now the district that Mike has, and Mike Crippo.
[1:27:48] And so, or, Simpson, sorry, sorry.
[1:27:52] I had a lot of windshield time, as you know, when we didn't have cell phones, and I knew
[1:27:58] his political platform ad nauseam, and so that's my memory, and there's a lot of people
[1:28:05] I know in Twin Falls because they were his boots on the ground, and if you have time,
[1:28:11] There was an excellent article in the statesman a week ago or so.
[1:28:14] If you want to know some rich history that your parents or grandparents would have experienced
[1:28:20] and what put Idaho on the map, it would be a very interesting read to kind of know our
[1:28:25] history.
[1:28:26] So thanks, John.
[1:28:27] Thank you, Ruth.
[1:28:30] So next on the agenda is the Pledge of Allegiance and I see we have a number of Boy Scouts who
[1:28:34] have arrived now this evening working on their merit badges.
[1:28:38] I would ask all the Boy Scouts if you would please come forward and lead us in the pledge
[1:28:42] this evening, and then I'll have you all introduce yourselves.
[1:28:46] So for those of you wishing to join us, please rise for the Pledge of Allegiance.
[1:29:15] To the flag of the United States of America, and to the Republic for which it stands, one
[1:29:22] nation under God, indivisible with liberty and justice for all.
[1:29:29] Thank you gentlemen, before you get too far away, I'm going to have each of you come
[1:29:32] up to just head around the other side of the podium right there. If you pull that microphone
[1:29:37] down, if you would please introduce yourself, tell me which badge you're working on and
[1:29:41] which troop you're with, please. I'm Zach Hoover, I'm from group 42 and I'm working on citizenship
[1:29:48] in the community. Excellent, welcome. I'm Noah Cox and I'm troop 99, I'm working on
[1:29:55] the citizenship in the community. Welcome. I'm Sarah Gough and I'm working on the citizenship
[1:30:02] in the community and I'm juke 59.
[1:30:04] Thank you.
[1:30:05] I'm Tyler Jensen.
[1:30:07] I am working on citizenship in that community and I'm juke 59.
[1:30:13] Welcome.
[1:30:14] I'm Ryan Preen and I'm working on citizenship in the community and I'm also from juke 59.
[1:30:24] Thank you for being here.
[1:30:26] I'm Jacob Helms.
[1:30:28] I'm from juke 59 and I'm also doing citizenship in the community.
[1:30:32] Thank you.
[1:30:33] I'm Blake Archibald. I'm working on citizenship in the community. I'm from troop 59.
[1:30:39] Welcome. I'm Austin Welch. I'm from troop 90 and I'm working on citizenship in the community.
[1:30:46] Thank you. I am Cole Hoover from troop 42 and I'm working on communications.
[1:30:53] Welcome. My name is Seth Hurek and I'm from troop 59 and I'm working on citizenship in the community.
[1:31:02] Thank you. My name is Colton Draney. I'm in troop 59 and I'm working on citizenship in the community.
[1:31:09] Thank you. My name is Alex Coats and I'm in troop 90 and I'm working on citizenship in the community.
[1:31:16] Welcome. My name is Talmich Jenkins and I'm from troop 90 and I'm working on citizenship in the community.
[1:31:24] Thank you. My name is Jared Evan, I'm from troop 90 and I'm working on citizenship in the community.
[1:31:31] Thank you.
[1:31:33] My name is Tyler Evans, and I'm working in the community and that's what you've done.
[1:31:38] Welcome.
[1:31:40] I'm from group 42, and I'm working on my communication match.
[1:31:44] And your name?
[1:31:45] And your name?
[1:31:46] Nathan.
[1:31:47] Welcome, Nathan.
[1:31:49] Thank you all for being here.
[1:31:57] And we have numerous other guests this evening as well.
[1:31:59] We have the CSI student senate who is here this evening, and we have some other students who are here observing.
[1:32:05] Seeing all of the young people in the audience,
[1:32:08] Councilman Talkington and I were joking around,
[1:32:10] we hope that you take as much interest in your local government
[1:32:14] when you were voting age and taxpayers,
[1:32:16] as you are now when you are here participating in these activities.
[1:32:21] Someday we will retire, you will be up here.
[1:32:24] Someday.
[1:32:28] Mr. Rothwily, do we have any amendments to the agenda this evening?
[1:32:31] Mr. Mayor, members of the Council, city staff would ask the Council
[1:32:36] to consider adding an additional executive session
[1:32:40] to the agenda tonight.
[1:32:43] It would appear at the same area as the executive session
[1:32:46] that's already noted.
[1:32:48] The session would be under Idaho Code 74206-1F as in Frank
[1:32:58] to communicate with legal counsel for the public agency
[1:33:02] to discuss the legal ramifications and legal options
[1:33:05] for pending litigation or controversies,
[1:33:08] not yet being litigated, but imminently likely
[1:33:11] to be litigated, the mere presence of legal counsel
[1:33:14] at an executive session does not satisfy this requirement.
[1:33:19] Thank you, Travis.
[1:33:19] Chris talking to move to add the executive session
[1:33:23] that has mentioned under 74206-1F.
[1:33:27] I'll second that.
[1:33:29] Motion by Chris Talkington, seconded by Ruth Pierce
[1:33:32] to amend the agenda to include an additional executive session
[1:33:36] the item. Is there any discussion? Sharon Roll call vote please. Suzanne Hawkins, yes.
[1:33:52] Nicky Boyd, yes. Son Barakar, yes. Chris Tockington, yes. Greg Lanting, yes. Ruth Pierce, yes. Motion passes 6 to 0.
[1:34:03] I did have a question the minutes that were distributed earlier today are we also going to add those to the consent calendar? Yes I believe we are.
[1:34:18] I would entertain a motion to include the minutes of the
[1:34:23] over 30th meeting on the consent calendar
[1:34:26] that were distributed earlier today, Greg Lanting.
[1:34:29] So moved.
[1:34:31] Second.
[1:34:32] Motion by Greg Lanting.
[1:34:34] Second advice is Ann Hawkins to amend the agenda
[1:34:36] to include the minutes of the October 30th meeting.
[1:34:39] Is there any discussion?
[1:34:42] Sharon and I'll call both, please.
[1:34:53] Nicky Boyd?
[1:34:54] Yes.
[1:34:55] Sean Burger?
[1:34:56] Yes.
[1:34:56] Chris Hockington?
[1:34:57] Yes.
[1:34:58] Greg Lanting, Ruth Pierce, Suzanne Hawkins.
[1:35:02] Yes.
[1:35:03] Motion passes 6-0.
[1:35:06] Any other amendments, Travis?
[1:35:09] Excellent.
[1:35:10] We will move on now to our proclamations.
[1:35:12] We do have two proclamations this evening.
[1:35:15] The first is for small business Saturdays
[1:35:18] requested by the Twin Falls area chamber of commerce.
[1:35:22] Whereas the government of the city of Twin Falls, Idaho,
[1:35:24] celebrates our local small businesses
[1:35:26] and the contributions they make to our local economy
[1:35:28] community. According to the United States Small Business Administration, there are currently
[1:35:33] 28.8 million small businesses in the United States representing 99.7% of all businesses
[1:35:41] with employees in the United States and are responsible for 63% of net new jobs created
[1:35:47] over the past 20 years. And whereas small businesses employ 48% of the employees in the private
[1:35:52] sector in the US, and whereas on average, 33% of consumers' holiday shopping will be done
[1:35:59] at small, independently owned retailers and restaurants. And whereas 91% of all consumers
[1:36:04] believe that supporting small, independently owned restaurants and bars is important. And
[1:36:10] whereas 76% of all consumers plan to go to one or more small businesses as part of their
[1:36:16] holiday shopping. And whereas the City of Twin Falls, Idaho supports our local businesses
[1:36:20] that create jobs, boost our local economy, and preserve our neighborhoods, and whereas
[1:36:26] advocacy groups, as well as public and private organizations across the country, have endorsed
[1:36:31] the Saturday after Thanksgiving as small business Saturday.
[1:36:34] Now therefore, I, Sean Berriger, Mayor of the City of Twin Falls, Idaho, do hereby proclaim
[1:36:39] November 25, 2017, as small business Saturday, and urge the residents of our community and
[1:36:46] communities across the country to support small businesses and merchants on small
[1:36:50] business Saturday and throughout the year. To accept tonight we have John
[1:36:54] Brinkhurst from our Twin Falls Chamber ambassadors and the rest of the ambassadors
[1:36:58] would like to come forward as well. I'll hand this off to John. On behalf of the
[1:37:18] Twin Falls Chamber of Commerce and the ambassadors we'd like to thank you Mr.
[1:37:24] Mayor and the Council for your support. We truly believe that the part of the
[1:37:29] The magic in the Magic Valley is certainly the hard-working men and women that put everything
[1:37:35] on the line in terms of what they like to accomplish and the dreams they like to accomplish
[1:37:40] and start businesses and we certainly appreciate the support of the community.
[1:37:46] So let's go shopping.
[1:37:48] It sounds good.
[1:37:49] Thank you, John.
[1:37:50] And thank you, Ambassador, for being here this evening.
[1:38:00] The second proclamation that we have this evening is for No Shave November 2017, whereas among
[1:38:08] American men prostate cancer is both the second most commonly diagnosed cancer and the second
[1:38:13] leading cause of cancer deaths.
[1:38:15] Although prostate cancer mortality rates have declined over the past two decades in 2017
[1:38:20] alone, an estimated 27,500 men in the United States will die from this cancer.
[1:38:27] As during National Prostate Cancer Awareness Month, we remember those who lost their lives to prostate cancer, offer our support to patients and their families, and highlight our commitment to better prevention, detection, and treatment methods.
[1:38:40] Whereas the Twin Falls Police Department is committed to help support the treatment and awareness of prostate cancer by promoting No Shave November.
[1:38:49] Therefore, I, Sean Berriger, Mayor of the City of Twin Falls proclaim the month of November
[1:38:54] as no shade of November.
[1:38:56] By this action, let it be known that we, the employees of the Twin Falls Police Department
[1:39:00] and citizens of the City of Twin Falls, support research, awareness and treatment of prostate
[1:39:06] cancer.
[1:39:07] To accept this this evening is Detective Jason Kelly.
[1:39:35] As the police department, we'd like to thank you for your continued support of this program.
[1:39:49] over the last years we've been able to raise significant money.
[1:39:53] All this money goes to the Mountain States,
[1:39:56] two minutes to do here in Twin Falls,
[1:39:57] and it benefits directly our community.
[1:40:00] All the money raised goes to local patients that are suffering
[1:40:04] from or trying to recover from different forms of cancer,
[1:40:08] as well as it raises the awareness here in the community for us.
[1:40:11] And we deeply appreciate the support from the Council
[1:40:15] and from the Administration here in the City of Twin Falls.
[1:40:18] Thank you, Greg Lansing.
[1:40:20] Jason, like you, I started right after the campaign,
[1:40:28] so a little slow start, but the bond and the grade
[1:40:30] doesn't show up as well.
[1:40:32] I get to pay my $30.
[1:40:37] Could you remind us of the website to where I can go on
[1:40:39] and pay that?
[1:40:40] $30.
[1:40:43] OK.
[1:40:46] It's linked on the Twin Falls City Police Department
[1:40:48] Facebook page.
[1:40:49] OK.
[1:40:50] There's a link there that anybody can go on.
[1:40:52] All the money raised on the website goes to the same.
[1:40:54] local donations to support local patients of cancers and various forms of that.
[1:41:00] And you can also just walk right into the police department, right?
[1:41:03] Yes, you can. You can come in and make donations. You can ask for myself,
[1:41:07] Detective Jason Kelly, Detective J.R. Paredes, or Officer Sean Applewhite, and we can take
[1:41:13] donations, and those will all go to the same great charity.
[1:41:16] Thank you. Well, it always makes my neighbors talk when one of the boys comes
[1:41:21] to pick up a check, because my, I won't say, my neighbor across the street sometimes likes
[1:41:27] to know what's going on at my house. And so when there's a police car sitting in front
[1:41:32] of my house, she thinks I've been arrested for something. But I want to say I really, really,
[1:41:38] really appreciate you guys partnering up with the hospital, the city's stepping in, you know,
[1:41:45] cancer is a very much a passion for me and we just got done with breast cancer awareness
[1:41:51] month and so rolling into no-shave November is very, it's wonderful. Thank you.
[1:41:58] There's prizes at the end of the month for those of us that look the best with our one
[1:42:12] month of growth. No? That's much.
[1:42:15] Next on the agenda is an opportunity for general public input. This is a chance for members
[1:42:20] of the public to address the council on issues that are not on the agenda this evening.
[1:42:24] there's anyone who wishes to do so now is your chance to please come forward seeing
[1:42:32] no one we will move on to the consent calendar as amended Nikki Boyd I move
[1:42:39] that we approve the consent calendar as amended motion by Nikki Boyd seconded
[1:42:46] by Greg Lanting to approve the consent calendar as amended is there any discussion
[1:42:50] Sharon roll call vote please.
[1:43:01] Sean Berriger.
[1:43:02] Yes.
[1:43:02] Chris Hockington.
[1:43:03] Yes.
[1:43:04] Greg Lanting.
[1:43:06] Yes.
[1:43:07] Ruth Pierce.
[1:43:08] Yes.
[1:43:09] Suzanne Hocking.
[1:43:10] Yes.
[1:43:11] Sneaky Boy.
[1:43:12] Yes.
[1:43:13] Motion passes six to zero.
[1:43:15] Okay, because I just got kicked out.
[1:43:23] That's what I was going to say.
[1:43:27] All right.
[1:43:28] Next on the agenda and our items of consideration is the first is the introduction of the Youth
[1:43:32] Council executive board also young people who were here this evening that I forgot to mention earlier and we have our vice mayor Suzanne Hawkins
[1:43:39] Thank you
[1:43:40] I'm going to invite our president up and then the rest of the youth council that's with him tonight's gonna come up
[1:43:45] And we'll let them introduce themselves if that's all right
[1:43:47] So the youth council had their first meeting in the new city hall building today
[1:43:51] So we're getting acquainted with what we're doing and how we're doing things, too
[1:43:56] So it's a it's a learning process for everybody and this year our president has been walling and been if you want to
[1:44:02] bring the council up with you will let you introduce yourself first if you guys
[1:44:05] want to tell us your names if you hold a position what it is and what school you
[1:44:10] go to that'd be great tonight it looks like some of them had to leave huh yeah
[1:44:21] okay
[1:44:50] I don't currently hold a position, I also attend to the law.
[1:44:58] I'm Ed and Mon, I do not hold a position, but I go to the Twin Falls High in the freshman year.
[1:45:08] I'm Kennedy Dittmore, I don't hold a position, and I go to the Twin Falls High School.
[1:45:15] Thank you. Thank you guys for following me over tonight after our meeting, and I will see you guys on December 1st at the parade.
[1:45:22] Thank you all for for serving and for being a part of your local government to
[1:45:29] help good things happen in the community. Appreciate you all being here. Next on the
[1:45:34] agenda is a presentation of value awards to several city employees by the
[1:45:44] Employee Recognition Committee and we have Matt Hicks from the Employee
[1:45:48] Recognition Committee. Welcome sir. Good evening, sir. Good evening, Mr. Mayor,
[1:45:55] members of the council. As you may remember, I'm the current chairman of the Twin
[1:45:59] and Falls Employee Recognition Committee.
[1:46:02] Our parallel team was formed earlier this year
[1:46:04] and charted with the purpose of designing
[1:46:06] an employee recognition program that rewards city employees
[1:46:09] that display the highest standards of our organization.
[1:46:11] This is the second opportunity we've had
[1:46:14] to present awards in front of the city council,
[1:46:15] and we'd like to thank you all for that opportunity.
[1:46:18] We actually have two awards that we would like
[1:46:19] to give out here tonight, but before we get to that ceremony,
[1:46:22] I'd like to again take just a few moments
[1:46:24] to describe the program, reintroduce the team,
[1:46:26] and explain the way that this process works.
[1:46:29] So, in an effort to recognize outstanding acts of public service performed by our employees,
[1:46:34] our group was tasked with developing a formal award recognition program.
[1:46:39] Our initial work of the committee was to outline the award criteria, the committee structure
[1:46:42] of the nomination review process, and the approval procedure for the program.
[1:46:47] The program we developed will focus on recognizing employees that demonstrate behaviors consistent
[1:46:52] with the adopted employee values, as you see on the screen.
[1:46:56] As you may remember, the employee values were selected by the entire employee court in 2015,
[1:47:02] formally established an organization last year.
[1:47:06] Those are as follows, Integrity, Connection, Honesty, Commitment, and Teamwork with several
[1:47:10] examples written on your needs.
[1:47:13] The formal laws to be issued through this program will be a result after employee or a group
[1:47:17] of employees exhibit specific behaviors that abide by one or more of these values.
[1:47:22] For more recipients, I receive a distinctive token depicting the symbol of each specific
[1:47:27] value, depending on their applicable event.
[1:47:30] In addition, they will receive a formal citation suitable for display and placement of the personnel
[1:47:35] file.
[1:47:36] We will be handing that out tonight.
[1:47:37] At this time, I'd like to reintroduce the members of the Employee Recognition Committee.
[1:47:41] Some of them couldn't be here, but I'd like to name them anyway.
[1:47:44] Daniel Cole with the Fire Department, Lisa Strickland Planning and Zoning, Christy Fairinger
[1:47:49] with engineering, David Cook with wastewater, and joining us tonight are Cynthia Torres and
[1:47:54] Dave Nebuchar, so these are with utility billing, Davis with Parks and Recreation.
[1:47:57] When you turn the nature word should we give it out in public setting, ideally a city council
[1:48:02] may appreciate that, and keeping with that, we have two awards we'd like to present at this
[1:48:07] time, so I'd like to invite Dave Nebuchar for our first presentation.
[1:48:11] Thank you, Matt.
[1:48:17] Welcome.
[1:48:19] It's a recognition for somebody that has gone way above and beyond their normal responsibilities
[1:48:26] for the city employees, and that is Gretchen Scott.
[1:48:39] And I'm going to read to you the details of why she's being recognized tonight.
[1:48:44] Gretchen's work and effort to improve the city's health benefit plan for FY18 budget has been
[1:48:51] amazing.
[1:48:52] Gretchen recognized the need for employees input regarding the city's health insurance
[1:48:57] and sent out a survey for employees to complete. Gretchen then reviewed the responses from employees
[1:49:04] and worked hard with HUB International and the ELT group to build another insurance option
[1:49:12] for the city. The city now offers a D and HD HB health insurance option. Gretchen's work on this
[1:49:20] This shows that she is committed to listening to the needs, wants of the employees and made
[1:49:26] the employees request a reality.
[1:49:29] Providing two health insurance plan options is no easy task, especially in our current
[1:49:34] health insurance climate.
[1:49:36] I believe this shows Gretchen's excellent commitment to our organization and is worthy
[1:49:40] of a commitment coin.
[1:49:43] And so we would like to recognize her for her big efforts.
[1:49:49] Thank you.
[1:49:56] I'd like to also introduce you to Cynthia Torres,
[1:49:59] who will be recognizing a couple more employees.
[1:50:04] Thank you.
[1:50:12] Good evening.
[1:50:13] So first of all, I would like to introduce my nominees,
[1:50:18] Sergeant Brent Wright and Captain Matt Hicks.
[1:50:22] So Sergeant Brent Wright and Captain Matt Hicks
[1:50:35] were nominated by Chief Kingsbury for their efforts
[1:50:39] in workplace violence and active shooter preparedness.
[1:50:42] Earlier this year, Sergeant Wright and Captain Hicks
[1:50:45] held a workshop which the majority of city employees attended.
[1:50:50] In their workshop, they gave a presentation
[1:50:52] about what to do in the event that the unthinkable happens
[1:50:55] in the workplace or in their personal lives.
[1:50:57] They gave invaluable and life-saving information to us
[1:51:01] for which we are extremely grateful.
[1:51:03] These gentlemen have not only been a great resource
[1:51:05] to the city of Twin Falls as an organization
[1:51:08] but they have also given this presentation to many organizations in and out of the City
[1:51:13] of Twin Falls, such as the Twin Falls County, employees, CSI, Idaho Power, First Federal,
[1:51:19] and IPRIMPS Boise office.
[1:51:22] So for their extraordinary efforts and commitment to providing education and helping our organization
[1:51:27] and many others prepare for the unthinkable, I present the award for commitment to Captain
[1:51:31] Matt Hicks and Sergeant Brent Wright.
[1:51:33] No wrap up.
[1:52:04] Thank you. Thanks to all of the employees who served on that employee recognition committee
[1:52:11] and congratulations to those employees who were recognized this evening. Again, I think
[1:52:16] this demonstrates a true commitment to the citizens of Twin Falls who are not doing this for the
[1:52:22] coin and the certificate. It's in providing the customer service and service to our community.
[1:52:28] Thank you so much. Next on the agenda is the Twin Falls Urban Renewal Agency main avenue redevelopment
[1:52:35] project update and we have a parent Robinson with CH2M.
[1:52:41] Welcome, sir.
[1:52:47] Good evening, mayor and council.
[1:52:48] It's a pleasure to be here in front of you once again.
[1:52:51] So since last month that I was here before you,
[1:52:55] we've made some more progress out there
[1:52:57] on main avenue rehabilitation.
[1:52:59] Since that time, we have Hanson to Idaho Street
[1:53:03] is open to traffic again.
[1:53:04] Folks are utilizing that and hopefully enjoying
[1:53:07] the new stretch of main avenue there.
[1:53:10] The work continues from Idaho to Jerome, and we are targeting pavement going down asphalt
[1:53:16] paving for Wednesday.
[1:53:18] So the crews are very busy preparing for that.
[1:53:22] Also working on Hanson Street South, if you will, towards 2nd, and getting that prepped
[1:53:27] and ready for, hopefully, targeting asphalt placement on Friday of this week.
[1:53:33] So getting more progress being made.
[1:53:35] This is just a snapshot of crews getting ready for the asphalt going down, places to concrete
[1:53:39] on that I'd have hoded your own section.
[1:53:42] And you can't see it in that photo,
[1:53:44] but the digital image is actually a few snowflakes
[1:53:47] in the picture, so you can see the screws
[1:53:48] and look at a lot of different conditions.
[1:53:50] Here's the road preparation on Hanson Street
[1:53:52] in anticipation of the paving that's this to come.
[1:53:55] So a lot of concrete work has been done,
[1:53:57] and there'll be some more continuing on,
[1:53:59] but making a big push here.
[1:54:01] With the intent of getting all of the roadways opened up
[1:54:05] in and around that Thanksgiving time,
[1:54:07] So that's the target that they're pushing for.
[1:54:10] Things continue to go well.
[1:54:12] We had a few typos on the engraved brick pavers.
[1:54:16] As you may recall, those typos have been corrected,
[1:54:19] and brick pavers have been redone the ones that were in error.
[1:54:23] So those will be installed here shortly.
[1:54:25] Pull the ones in error out and put the replacements in.
[1:54:29] Also, last week, some work was done
[1:54:32] to get the pole sleeves in place for the flag poles,
[1:54:35] for the Lions Club, so hopefully some of all of you
[1:54:38] were able to see those flags fly on for better state.
[1:54:41] That was a nice accomplishment.
[1:54:44] So those are some of the highlights
[1:54:45] of what's going on out there.
[1:54:46] Things continue to go well, crews working hard
[1:54:50] and trying to beat the weather here.
[1:54:51] So we'll have a few more furnishings that
[1:54:53] will be coming in, some furnishings with some light poles.
[1:54:57] And those will be installed sometime in that January time
[1:55:00] frame.
[1:55:01] FU-Ho is going to be starting to immobilize from their yard.
[1:55:04] They've been utilizing as the work majority of the work is winding down.
[1:55:08] Then we'll come back in that January time frame to install some light poles, install some furnishings that have arrived.
[1:55:13] And then be back in the spring to work on some landscaping and things of that nature.
[1:55:17] But we'll be ramping down the vast majority of the effort out there.
[1:55:20] So stand for questions.
[1:55:23] All right.
[1:55:24] Chris Stockington.
[1:55:25] Well, the usual, I guess, labor is not an issue anymore.
[1:55:28] Your staff fully staff.
[1:55:30] They have been doing a good job of working with their subs and getting folks staffed, working some of their own crews to facilitate it, to perform some of the work, self-perform some of the work, so going well.
[1:55:42] We're not done yet, so hopefully that continues and we can still have good access to the participating crews and the concrete crews and asphalt papers show up this week.
[1:55:51] Well, the walking I do, talking with the business people, they're the repreciative of the sensitivity to this project that the workers are by and large cordial, informed, and just not an impediment to any business that's trying to make it go of it, so I don't know what kind of a special training you get them, but it's very effective.
[1:56:15] And of course the last question, no surprises on the budget.
[1:56:18] No surprises on the budget actually we have a we'll be talking more about that as we go along
[1:56:23] We've got a really nice story to tell so far
[1:56:26] We are under budget. We have some contingency that we had set aside or was set aside
[1:56:31] the onset of the project we've not had to tap into that at all and even a few of the individual line items that were
[1:56:39] Established at the start of the GMP process
[1:56:42] All indications are that we're gonna be underwriting a few of those line items too
[1:56:45] So I think we're going to have a nice story to tell at the end, but again, we're not done yet. So I don't want to get too excited. It's looking very good. Thank you.
[1:56:54] Any other questions? I don't see any. Thank you so much. Thank you.
[1:57:00] Next on the agenda is the International City County Management Association Credential Manager Recognition for City Manager Travis Rothwiler and Deputy City Manager Mitch Humble.
[1:57:16] So tonight it is my distinct pleasure to recognize two of the leaders of our city staff who have
[1:57:21] Recently received the credentialed manager designation from the ICMA
[1:57:27] City manager Travis Rothweiler and deputy city manager Mitch Humble joined an elite group of about
[1:57:33] 1,400 local government management professionals currently credentials for the ICMA voluntary credentialing program
[1:57:40] So gentlemen, I'm gonna embarrass you. You have to come stand up here while I read about you to please
[1:57:44] just like everyone else. To receive the prestigious ICMA credential, a member must
[1:57:54] have significant experience as a senior management executive in local government,
[1:57:58] have earned a degree, preferably in public administration or a related field, and
[1:58:02] demonstrated a commitment to high standards of integrity and to lifelong
[1:58:06] learning and professional development. In April 2011, Travis Rothweiler was appointed
[1:58:12] to serve as the city manager for the City of Twin Falls. Prior to this appointment, he
[1:58:16] served as the assistant city manager here in Twin Falls and also the city administrator for the
[1:58:20] city of Jerome. Travis graduated with a bachelor of arts degree in political science and a master's
[1:58:26] degree in public administration from Montana State University. He's a graduate of the University of
[1:58:31] Virginia's senior executive institute and leadership education and development program. Prior to working
[1:58:37] in the Magic Valley, he worked for former United States Senator Conrad Burns and five years as the
[1:58:42] the assistant to the majority leader for the Montana House of Representatives.
[1:58:46] Travis has been recognized for this leadership and work.
[1:58:49] He's a recipient of the Paul Harris Fellow Award presented by the Twin Falls Rotary Club,
[1:58:54] ICMA for program excellence and innovation, and as one of Idaho's CEOs of influence for
[1:59:00] 2016 by the Idaho Business Review.
[1:59:03] He and his wife Amy, a Twin Falls native and fellow triathlon enthusiast, have two children,
[1:59:08] David and Jackson, so please join me in congratulating Travis on this recognition.
[1:59:20] Mitch Humboldt has served as the Deputy City Manager of Community Services and Development
[1:59:24] for the City of Twin Falls for the past two and a half years.
[1:59:27] Prior to that, he was the Community Development Director for nine and a half years.
[1:59:31] And before coming to Twin Falls, Mitch served in city planning in Prosper and Frisco, Texas.
[1:59:38] Mitch graduated with a bachelor's degree in geography with an emphasis in urban planning
[1:59:42] from the University of Utah and a master's degree in public administration from the University
[1:59:46] of North Texas. He's completed the University of Virginia's Senior Executive Institute and
[1:59:51] has been an active member of ICMA since 2009. Mitch is actively involved with his church previously
[1:59:58] serving a two-year mission and he and his wife Megan are very engaged in the community,
[2:00:03] especially through the involvement of their four children, Barrett, Aiden, Cameron and Delaney.
[2:00:09] So please join me in congratulating Mitch on this accomplishment as well.
[2:00:13] So again, I would emphasize that this is a very distinguished recognition of a commitment
[2:00:23] to the citizens of our community for the ongoing dedication that these gentlemen and others
[2:00:29] have in professional development, ensuring that they are working through best practices
[2:00:35] and pursuit of excellence for our city and local governance and really in fostering to
[2:00:41] build a better community for all of us. So once again, thank you gentlemen and
[2:00:44] congratulations.
[2:00:51] Now you allow us to sleep at night. I think you understand.
[2:01:13] Next on the agenda is another opportunity for general public input. If
[2:01:19] there's anyone here from the public who would like to address the council now is
[2:01:22] your opportunity. Seeing no one advisory board reports anything from the
[2:01:29] council.
[2:01:32] Mickey Boy. Well as we speak our bubble for the new bubble for the city pool is in transit and this weekend
[2:01:41] Parks and Rec will have a bubble up
[2:01:44] Assembly so be looking for that
[2:01:47] Thank you, Nikki Suzanne Hawkins
[2:01:50] I just want to remind everybody that for the remainder of this month the library has lots of projects going on for our veterans and
[2:01:57] Also for families of veterans so their calendars online
[2:02:00] you can maybe get a hold of that and see what days they have their special events.
[2:02:04] But also this year for the holidays, they're bringing back their food for fines program.
[2:02:09] So if you have a library fine, you haven't been able to pay off.
[2:02:13] You can take in canned food and have that credited towards your account.
[2:02:18] And the food will all go to South Central Community Action Partnership.
[2:02:22] So it's a win-win for the community.
[2:02:24] Thank you, Suzanne. Anything else from the Council?
[2:02:28] Travis, any announcements?
[2:02:31] Mr. Mayor, members of Council just a couple of things in terms of the bubble installation.
[2:02:36] So on Thursday and Friday, it's going to be the mechanical pieces that on Saturday, if you
[2:02:41] have any free time or any interest, we're going to be raising the bubble and your help
[2:02:46] would be greatly appreciated.
[2:02:48] So if you're interested, please come and we can share those details with you.
[2:02:52] About what time?
[2:02:55] We don't know yet, probably leaning towards the morning as we'll start that assembly.
[2:03:02] Tomorrow, we're going to ask for the public's patience one more time as the folks in the Hanson
[2:03:06] Building begin their move into the new City Hall complex. Tomorrow, the folks associated
[2:03:14] with planning and zoning, engineering, and building services will not be offering services
[2:03:18] to the community or they have already made some arrangements to offer a very skeletal list
[2:03:25] of services as they move in transition. Then we would ask over the course of the balance
[2:03:29] of this week that as we're kind of sifting and working out of boxes that the public remain
[2:03:35] patient with us.
[2:03:36] I want to remind the community of the event and the dedication I'll take place on December
[2:03:41] 1st.
[2:03:42] We'll start the day, associate, we'll have some tours, we'll have the ceremonial dedication
[2:03:47] process and later that evening we're partnering with the Times News to do the light parade
[2:03:54] and the lighting of the city Christmas tree that will be placed right out in front of the
[2:04:01] new city hall complex in the comments today. Members of our parks and rec crew were working
[2:04:08] feverishly to install the anchor system to support the tree that will be placing out there.
[2:04:16] On the 13th for the council to mark the bless you on the council to mark their calendars
[2:04:20] is going to be the city employee recognition luncheon that will begin, they'll be on December
[2:04:27] 13th and there'll be more information but we just want you to balance and block that day
[2:04:32] for that. And if there's nothing else, Mr. Mayor, we do believe that we can accomplish one if
[2:04:38] not both of the executive sessions prior to the public hearing which is scheduled to begin
[2:04:42] at six o'clock.
[2:04:43] Okay, great. Thank you, Travis. So we do, yes, we do.
[2:04:48] So I have to apologize, I'm not allergic to you.
[2:04:51] I have year round allergy.
[2:04:53] So it had nothing to do with what you were talking about.
[2:04:58] So we do have a public hearing schedule that
[2:05:01] is noticed to not occur prior to 6 PM.
[2:05:04] So as Travis indicated, we believe
[2:05:06] we do have time to take care of our executive session items.
[2:05:10] So I would entertain a motion to adjourn
[2:05:14] into executive session under Idaho Code 74261C
[2:05:18] And one F, when C is to acquire an interest in real property,
[2:05:23] which is not owned by a public agency and one F,
[2:05:27] to communicate with legal counsel for the public agency
[2:05:29] to discuss the legal ramifications of and legal options
[2:05:32] for pending litigation or controversies not yet being
[2:05:35] litigated but imminently likely to be litigated
[2:05:38] in the mere presence of legal counsel at an executive session
[2:05:40] does not satisfy this requirement.
[2:05:42] Greg Lanting.
[2:05:43] I so moved.
[2:05:44] Second.
[2:05:45] Motion by Greg Lanting.
[2:05:46] seconded by Ruth Pierce to adjourn into executive session for those two items.
[2:05:51] Is there any discussion?
[2:05:52] Chair-General Cobo, please.
[2:05:55] Chris Tockington.
[2:06:02] Yes.
[2:06:03] Greg Lanting.
[2:06:04] Yes.
[2:06:05] Ruth Pierce.
[2:06:06] Yes.
[2:06:07] Suzanne Hawkins.
[2:06:08] Yes.
[2:06:09] Nicky Boyd.
[2:06:10] Yes.
[2:06:11] Sean Beriker.
[2:06:12] Yes.
[2:06:13] Motion passes 6-0.
[2:06:14] So we will adjourn into executive session.
[2:06:17] We will not be making any decisions in executive session.
[2:06:21] We will return to the open session of the council meeting after 6 p.m. for the public
[2:06:28] hearing that is on the agenda, so with that we will stand adjourned.
[2:06:32] Good to go, Sharon.
[2:34:45] I would like to reconvene the Twin Falls City Council meeting for Monday, November 13th.
[2:34:51] It is 11 minutes after 6.
[2:34:56] We do have a public hearing scheduled request for a PUD amendment to the Canyon Village PUD
[2:35:03] number 270 to remove residential development requirements for property located at the northwest
[2:35:08] corner of Eastland Drive North and Sheaney Drive, Kent Taylor on behalf of Northeast Investments
[2:35:15] LLC.
[2:35:16] Mr. Taylor.
[2:35:19] Oh, there you are.
[2:35:20] I was looking around for you.
[2:35:21] We were hiding out.
[2:35:22] So the applicant is Kent Taylor, so welcome, Kent.
[2:35:27] First out of the shoot.
[2:35:30] My name is Kent Taylor.
[2:35:32] And I represent Northeast Development.
[2:35:36] We are the developers on the property that's on the southwest corner of Full Island,
[2:35:43] it's commonly known as Canyon Village Multipurpose Development,
[2:35:49] and we've been to before you on several occasions as well as planning and zoning on several occasions.
[2:35:55] And the purpose of tonight's meeting is to request an amendment to the PUD agreement
[2:36:01] We entered into, with the city, at that point in time,
[2:36:10] tell you kind of what we were going to do, which wasn't very much.
[2:36:14] Because at that time, as very young talked about that piece of ground,
[2:36:19] it was a rock pile and wheat patch.
[2:36:21] We really didn't have a very definite feeling on what we were going to do.
[2:36:27] We went through a series of meetings and hearings for you
[2:36:32] at the planning and zoning, and met with the neighbors on a couple of occasions that we came
[2:36:36] up with what at that time we thought was the best that we could in order to protect the
[2:36:43] interests of the adjoining property owners, and to give us the flexibility to develop the
[2:36:48] property.
[2:36:49] In the meantime, I'm sure some of you, not all of you, have noticed that we've made substantial
[2:36:56] improvements out there, including the landscaping and the perimeter around the whole line in
[2:37:02] down in Cheney as well, installed sidewalks brought in quite a bit of fill and actually
[2:37:09] changed the topography of the ground. And we installed fence along Cheney that we said
[2:37:16] we would under the PUD, which was a uniform, some tech fence that is I think very attractive.
[2:37:26] So the reason for the request that we filed is to eliminate some of the architectural
[2:37:33] requirements that were in the PUD agreement when it originally negotiated.
[2:37:37] Now the, like I say, the reason for doing that was really to give neighbors the comfort
[2:37:45] that they requested in order to make sure that they didn't get something that was undesirable on that property.
[2:37:51] It was actually divided into three major parcels. One was a residential, one was a professional,
[2:37:59] And then the rest of it was the commercial.
[2:38:03] Within the professional site, that's been developed.
[2:38:08] Three of those eight lots have been sold.
[2:38:13] The 21 residential lots, 16 of those have been sold.
[2:38:18] And there are quite a few residences
[2:38:21] that are going to be constructed within the next year.
[2:38:25] Some of the restrictions that were placed in that
[2:38:27] the PUD agreement applied solely to the residential and the professional lot, and that was, that
[2:38:35] was to make sure that the neighbors had some comfort about protection of their property
[2:38:42] rights.
[2:38:43] And we agreed, we voluntarily put those in there, as you probably know, putting architectural
[2:38:51] requirements in PUD agreement is not something that's done by the city, in fact, this is
[2:38:55] the only PUD agreement that has architectural requirements in it, but because of the nature
[2:39:00] of the property and because of the discussions we had, we felt it was appropriate to do that.
[2:39:06] Now that we've come after two and a half, three years of development, we've been able to demonstrate
[2:39:12] our good faith in developing this property and because there was, I don't say, a misunderstanding
[2:39:24] were an oversight or whatever with respect to construction materials that were used and
[2:39:29] some garage doors that were potentially facing the chaining.
[2:39:36] We find ourselves wanting to clarify these PUD requirements.
[2:39:40] The two major ones in question was the requirement under the agreement that provided that no garage
[2:39:50] would face chaining. And I specifically remember the discussion took place at that time. The
[2:39:57] neighbors were concerned that if you had a lot of driveways off the chaining, that that may
[2:40:03] expose all those garage doors to those property owners, they thought it would be unsightly.
[2:40:08] Well, that did not occur, obviously. In fact, we have the landscaping, we have the fence
[2:40:14] there, but the garage door of the most westerly
[2:40:18] rehearsal that's being built, you could argue, I guess,
[2:40:23] that it faces Cheney, but not within the contemplation
[2:40:27] of the discussions that we have, because they do not face
[2:40:33] the street itself.
[2:40:35] And if you go out there, you cannot
[2:40:37] see those garage doors because of the elevations,
[2:40:40] because of the landscaping, and because of the fence.
[2:40:44] So that needed to be clarified.
[2:40:46] That requirement also applied to all of the residences
[2:40:50] within 280 feet of that property.
[2:40:59] That would mean that the one on the interior street
[2:41:11] could not be built as well.
[2:41:12] And you'd have to have side loading on those
[2:41:15] because they ostensibly face chain even though it are 200-some feet away, which doesn't make
[2:41:21] any sense.
[2:41:22] So we feel like that requirement is kind of absurd in its present interpretation.
[2:41:29] The other had to do with the use of construction materials, which was we put in their stone brick
[2:41:35] and stucco.
[2:41:36] Well, nobody builds with stone, quarridge stone.
[2:41:41] And so you have a lot of the stonework that you see on houses,
[2:41:47] there's nothing more than ground up rock that are reconstituted and hated,
[2:41:53] and then they put on a house.
[2:41:56] We're saying that the hardy board that was installed on this particular house
[2:42:02] is of a stone material, no different than the block.
[2:42:11] But once again, in order to clarify it, we're here before you so that we eliminate these restrictions.
[2:42:18] We don't have to worry about getting certificates of occupancy or problems with financing of these particular houses or lots.
[2:42:27] So those are the two issues that have kind of precipitated us coming before you.
[2:42:34] And I would only say that I agree with the recommendation
[2:42:41] made by the planning and zoning with respect
[2:42:43] to the residential and professional aspects
[2:42:45] of this development.
[2:42:47] So that being said, let's move to the other bifurcated part
[2:42:51] of this development.
[2:42:53] And that is, there's a parcel that's approximately 5 and 1
[2:42:57] half acres that has a town home designation.
[2:43:02] The PUD agreement says not that you can have apartments,
[2:43:05] which seems to be the ever fear of the neighbors,
[2:43:11] that somehow this is going to be developed
[2:43:13] into a low income riff-raff multi-family visit,
[2:43:18] multi-family filling, and it's thought.
[2:43:21] PUD agreements that specifically it'll be townhomes,
[2:43:25] who put in some restrictions about the size of those townhomes,
[2:43:30] number of garages, the pitches of the roofs and so forth.
[2:43:33] But when you look now in retrospect, they really don't make any sense.
[2:43:38] And the reason is, we are now planning the phase of the development of that.
[2:43:44] And it seems like if you have all of the roofs of the same pitch,
[2:43:48] and if you have the same number of garages, the same square footage,
[2:43:56] is you're going to have a kind of a cookie cutter outfit out there.
[2:44:00] So I don't see why, given the fact that the City of Twin Falls does not have any other architectural requirements and any PUD agreements, and that there is no, and all of the property owners who own property within this development have signed an agreement that says we are in favor of this.
[2:44:22] we feel that our property rights are protected.
[2:44:25] We want this to happen.
[2:44:26] They should be eliminated so that you have the freedom
[2:44:29] and creativity to do a real nice development
[2:44:32] without being hampered by these arbitrary architectural
[2:44:37] requirements.
[2:44:38] So we don't think that they should apply to that as well.
[2:44:44] We think we've shown our good faith, which
[2:44:46] was the reason why we put it in there voluntarily to start
[2:44:50] with.
[2:44:51] We think we've demonstrated that we're good developers,
[2:44:55] that we think that even if I were to die
[2:44:58] and leave it to somebody else,
[2:45:00] that the public process is in place, planning, zoning,
[2:45:05] city council, approval of plats, public hearings,
[2:45:09] all of those are significant enough safeguards
[2:45:14] for the public's interest.
[2:45:16] Now, who has public interest here?
[2:45:18] We have a general aesthetic public interest
[2:45:22] and how that's going to look for somebody who's driving by or walking by.
[2:45:26] I suggest to you that that is far inferior to the property owners who actually own property
[2:45:37] and are trying to maintain values in their development and on balance.
[2:45:46] The arguments are strongly in favor of, if not totally in favor of, eliminating these
[2:45:52] restrictions from the PewDiePie.
[2:45:54] Thank you, Kent. Nicky Boyd, did you have a question?
[2:46:01] Hey, Kent, I think we have a couple of questions for you if we could please before we go to
[2:46:09] the staff report.
[2:46:11] The question is, you talked about stone and the manufactured stone now and the hardy that
[2:46:19] is a cement fiberboard.
[2:46:21] Yes.
[2:46:22] So I was trying to determine are you saying that the hardy board, if people want to use
[2:46:29] that, that should completely be allowed because it's really no different than another fiber
[2:46:35] type composite.
[2:46:37] What were you saying there?
[2:46:39] I don't know that I understood.
[2:46:40] I was saying that there's kind of a blurry line between what is stone and what is hardy
[2:46:48] board.
[2:46:49] that the hardyboard you could actually consider to be stoned because it's ground up stoned
[2:46:54] reconstituted and put up many instances.
[2:46:57] Okay, so it currently says that it would be stucco stone or brick and therefore hardy
[2:47:06] which could to an unknowing person from a distance look like sighting and so you're saying hardy
[2:47:16] board should be allowed to be in there.
[2:47:18] Oh, yes. Oh, absolutely. Yeah.
[2:47:20] Yeah. And then a lot of that because it's flexibility.
[2:47:25] Sure.
[2:47:26] It's a very common building material.
[2:47:30] It's a good product.
[2:47:31] And it's pros and cons of it are greatly in favor of the pros.
[2:47:36] So we're saying that yes, it should be.
[2:47:39] Okay.
[2:47:40] But if we eliminate those requirements, then in our CC&R's,
[2:47:46] have a requirement that we have no steel siding, no final siding, but hardyboard is definitely
[2:47:52] in a loud product. Okay. Okay. I want to make sure I understood that clearly. Thank you.
[2:47:57] Sure. Thank you. I'm with that question from Chris Stocketton. I can't, you know, P&C has forwarded their
[2:48:03] recommendation to us and one of the conditions I suggested is that the residential town home
[2:48:09] home restrictions remain in the PUD, your thought on that?
[2:48:13] That's what I was trying to address. I don't see a very rational foundation for keeping those in for the town homes.
[2:48:24] Because the interest that was being tried, that we were trying to protect the time that they were put in, just no longer exists.
[2:48:32] The only remaining interest is kind of a general, distant, remote, aesthetic interest for people
[2:48:39] passing by, but the property that's owned by the adjoining owners, they have very good
[2:48:49] money invested in those projects.
[2:48:51] That is an adequate safeguard.
[2:48:53] In addition to the administrative process that you folks have, you apply to all other
[2:48:57] planning developments.
[2:48:58] I think I understand it better now.
[2:49:00] Thank you.
[2:49:01] That's it for now. Thank you. Sure. Yes
[2:49:05] So next we have Jonathan Spendlove
[2:49:10] We'll give us our staff report. Welcome Jonathan
[2:49:13] Members of the council the history it's it's long. I'm not gonna read the whole thing
[2:49:17] But I'm gonna paraphrase the beginning of it
[2:49:18] Which is they started in August in 2014 and ended the PUD process in January of 2015
[2:49:24] So it took four or five months to get through the public hearings with P&Z and then the council to get the PUD as it was applied
[2:49:30] And then in May 2nd, 2017, they applied for residential building permit for the house located
[2:49:36] shown in the picture.
[2:49:38] City staff did a review for compliance with building codes and typical zoning codes that
[2:49:42] include usually property line setbacks, height limitation, parking spaces, things that are
[2:49:47] within our city code.
[2:49:48] An extensive review of CCNAR is not done, typically a review of PUDs is not done for residential
[2:49:54] buildings.
[2:49:55] Against talking about aesthetics in PUDs, we have those for commercial projects all over town.
[2:50:01] Everything on the canyon rim has some of that aesthetic stuff in the PUD for those commercial buildings, those commercial projects.
[2:50:08] This is the only one that I know of that I've looked for that has anything to do with actually a private home, a residential home to have any type of aesthetic requirements.
[2:50:18] So yeah, we have many commercial stuff, not typically in any residential that somebody would buy as their personal property.
[2:50:25] On August 22nd, a phone call was made to the city about the home showing sighting in the garage on the south side.
[2:50:34] During that conversation the violations were listed in the garage, not face south.
[2:50:38] We also informed the applicant that the house would not receive a final certificate of occupancy until the conditions of the PUD were met.
[2:50:47] And then we had a meeting two days later with the developer and staff to talk about their options.
[2:50:52] It was to comply with the PUD or go through the process, this public process, if they wanted to change the PUD that was an option.
[2:50:58] And then on the 28th we received their application, then the Planning and Zoning Commission had their preliminary presentation in September,
[2:51:06] and then the public hearing was in October.
[2:51:09] And during that October meeting the Planning and Zoning Commission forwarded a recommendation to change the PUD,
[2:51:14] which essentially eliminates all of the requirements shown.
[2:51:19] It eliminates all of the requirements for the area down here in the south part.
[2:51:29] The townhome part we're talking about does not cross the unknown view.
[2:51:42] So the PNC Commission said they recommended eliminating everything
[2:51:46] to those individual homes on the south.
[2:51:49] They did recommend to keep the conditions in the PUD for that townhome area.
[2:51:55] During the original application process back in August 2014 there were several community outreach sessions
[2:52:00] Which resulted in a unique agreement the pud 270 has architectural elements and standards for the private residences within 280 feet of the size of the boundary
[2:52:09] Which is changing drive listed below is the staff report from the original
[2:52:14] By presented originally with the planning and zoning Commission and the City Council
[2:52:18] lists all of those items and the possible impacts that we had
[2:52:22] listed there during the original application process and public hearing
[2:52:25] staff analysis state of these standards are typically found in CC&Rs are not
[2:52:30] typically found in city code however these restrictions are legal to be within
[2:52:34] the PUD and as the applicant placed the restrictions upon themselves they remain
[2:52:38] within the document as generally indicated in the original report
[2:52:41] staff showed and also support for these standards being in the PUD and would
[2:52:44] rather than be in the CC&R agreement. In the past the sentiment of public officials
[2:52:48] and city staff has been to remain silent on architectural elements for
[2:52:51] residential properties in order to avoid conflicts with dictating the types of
[2:52:54] materials private property owners choose to construct their homes with. Staff
[2:52:59] supports the amendment to the PUD as it removes the staff from responsibility of
[2:53:03] enforcing architectural design standards on private residential homes which is a
[2:53:07] position the city has been reluctant to take up many times in the past.
[2:53:11] Oning is only commissioned for the positive recommendation with requests to
[2:53:16] keep that residential town home restrictions remain in PUD by unanimous
[2:53:20] vote. So tonight City Council's task of making
[2:53:23] decision on the request, approve the request as
[2:53:26] presented, approve the request with conditions or
[2:53:28] deny the request. These are, that's pretty much
[2:53:40] what the amendment looks like is to just delete those
[2:53:43] whole sections out of the PUD agreement.
[2:53:52] Jonathan questions, I didn't see the entire PUD
[2:53:55] agreement in our packet. It's really big. Okay. So
[2:54:00] Elsewhere in the PUD, does it refer to square footage limitations for a townhome development?
[2:54:12] That's the only location that has the square footage restrictions for the townhomes.
[2:54:17] Are there limitations on building height elsewhere in the PUD?
[2:54:20] They limited themselves in the commercial areas for size of building, I think it was 50,000 square feet.
[2:54:26] And then building height?
[2:54:28] I don't think they limited their height.
[2:54:30] If they did, it would be the same at 35, but the C1 zone allows for 50 right now, they may have.
[2:54:36] The density of the townhome development, is that addressed elsewhere in the PUD, or would it be addressed by other areas of the code?
[2:54:44] So, for example, that section there that's being proposed to be stricken talks about a density of no more than 8, or no.
[2:54:53] Yeah, so the area B has, it has to meet the R1,
[2:54:58] under it has to meet the R1 zone standard.
[2:55:01] So would the R1 zone standard be eight per acre?
[2:55:05] It would be pretty, yeah, it'd be that or less.
[2:55:09] Okay, that'd be my.
[2:55:11] And it's on this master development form.
[2:55:16] It's really small, it's called area B.
[2:55:21] That says R1 or town home or pro, it actually has three options.
[2:55:26] It could become professional offices
[2:55:27] that they wanted and meet the R1 standard for a lot size
[2:55:31] and then the buildings would be similar to what's to the east.
[2:55:34] Okay. And does that particular section of code,
[2:55:39] does it address a footprint size or anything,
[2:55:41] just the density?
[2:55:43] No, it would just be the density,
[2:55:44] just be the size of the lot really.
[2:55:47] Thank you.
[2:55:49] Any questions for Jonathan?
[2:55:51] Other questions for Jonathan?
[2:55:54] Craig Lantig.
[2:55:55] Jonathan, what plot is the house that's already been built
[2:55:59] Where is it?
[2:56:00] Which one is it, a lot is it on?
[2:56:03] So that's why it ends up being kind of on a kitty corner
[2:56:06] because it's a corner lot.
[2:56:08] Yeah, it's in the end of a cul-de-sac
[2:56:10] in order to kind of make the front yard.
[2:56:12] And for the picture of the pass that you put up there,
[2:56:15] is that going to be a driveway that comes all the way
[2:56:17] around there, I assume?
[2:56:18] Yeah, so the driveway would actually come towards
[2:56:20] where you're looking at and coming across the bus.
[2:56:23] Come around and meet this cul-de-sac, all right, thank you.
[2:56:27] If they were not allowed to access Chaney in any way,
[2:56:29] Any other questions for Jonathan?
[2:56:38] Seeing none, we will move on to the public input portion of the public hearing.
[2:56:45] Jonathan, is there a signup sheet?
[2:56:47] Do you check for me, please?
[2:56:56] So hold on a second.
[2:56:57] I'm going to get that signup sheet.
[2:56:59] All right.
[2:57:07] So we have several folks who have signed up to speak on this item.
[2:57:10] So what I'll do is I'll invite you up to speak.
[2:57:14] speak. I would ask that you keep your comments limited to three minutes. If you could please.
[2:57:21] And so when you come up, state your name and whether you're a resident of the City of Twin
[2:57:32] Falls, and property owner, and then we will go from there. So I've got Nathan Welch.
[2:57:39] I appreciate your time here at the City Council and this sort of dual purpose I had to sign
[2:57:47] here is the scout as well today.
[2:57:49] [Muted for privacy: home address]
[2:57:51] [Muted for privacy: home address]
[2:57:52] [Muted for privacy: home address]
[2:57:54] [Muted for privacy: home address]
[2:57:58] Kind of got volunteered or elected
[2:58:01] to kind of represent the neighborhood that's
[2:58:03] just to the south of this subdivision.
[2:58:06] And so we were the neighbors that they
[2:58:08] referred to during the initial creation of this PUD agreement.
[2:58:12] And we've enjoyed working with Kent.
[2:58:14] And now that Ann's been involved,
[2:58:15] enjoyed working with her.
[2:58:18] As these changes have been proposed,
[2:58:20] I mean, we first and foremost wanted to applaud Kent
[2:58:24] and Anne for the great work that they've done on the subdivision
[2:58:26] so far.
[2:58:27] I mean, they've been terrific to work with and think
[2:58:30] that they've done a great job.
[2:58:32] As these amendments got brought up,
[2:58:35] I guess we felt like with the planning and zoning meeting,
[2:58:38] we came up with what we felt was a good compromise.
[2:58:41] The two cul-de-sacs that you saw in the picture,
[2:58:45] You know, those now have CCNRs that are in place,
[2:58:48] that we can see, that we can read,
[2:58:50] that govern the future of that.
[2:58:53] There's homes that are already being built,
[2:58:55] that establish the character of what's gonna be built
[2:58:58] in those two cul-de-sacs.
[2:59:01] But, and like Kent said,
[2:59:03] there are obviously some interest in the property owners
[2:59:06] that have already purchased at the town home section be nice,
[2:59:09] but let's say the economy takes tomorrow,
[2:59:11] and those don't get built for 20 years,
[2:59:12] and they change hands,
[2:59:14] We felt like there was no need to eliminate the protections
[2:59:19] that govern that town home section.
[2:59:21] So we felt like a good compromise was saying change the PUD sections
[2:59:27] that govern the architectural things on the cul-de-sacs
[2:59:30] for the residential homes because there's a CCNR in place
[2:59:33] to protect the future there.
[2:59:36] But to go ahead and keep the PUD restrictions
[2:59:39] that govern the town home section for now.
[2:59:42] And again, they've been great to work with.
[2:59:43] That's the thought of myself and our neighbors
[2:59:46] to keep those restrictions in place
[2:59:48] on the sort of ambiguous portion.
[2:59:52] As you mentioned, there aren't restrictions
[2:59:53] anywhere else in the PUD to govern that.
[2:59:55] And so we felt like those were good compromises
[2:59:58] we came to two years ago and that there's no need
[3:00:00] to eliminate them at this point.
[3:00:02] Thank you.
[3:00:03] Thank you.
[3:00:07] And did you want to speak?
[3:00:10] Next up, Ann Taylor.
[3:00:14] Thank you.
[3:00:15] Good evening.
[3:00:16] My name's Ann Taylor.
[3:00:17] And the home that you've seen pictures of is a home that I'm building.
[3:00:22] So I sort of the genesis of all of this concern and just wanted to thank the neighbors for
[3:00:28] being lenient first of all and supporting the recommendation of the P&Z to go ahead and
[3:00:34] remove those architectural requirements for the residential area.
[3:00:38] I really appreciate that and hope that you all will support that recommendation as well.
[3:00:44] and then maybe offer a few comments and suggestions
[3:00:47] on the townhome portion.
[3:00:51] The townhome portion, as written, I think
[3:00:53] is unduly restrictive in terms of stucco, brick, or stone.
[3:01:00] If you have looked around at any type of townhomes,
[3:01:03] I personally haven't seen townhomes that
[3:01:07] are exclusively built of the stucco, brick, or stone.
[3:01:12] So you have the opportunity, I think,
[3:01:14] to approve the recommendation from P&C
[3:01:17] to come up with your own decision or to deny in part.
[3:01:22] And maybe one suggestion that I might offer
[3:01:25] is that it be broadened to allow hardy
[3:01:32] or a similar sighting for those town homes.
[3:01:35] And I think that would allow the developers some leeway
[3:01:39] to meet what's currently being constructed
[3:01:42] and give them some flexibility as they go ahead
[3:01:45] and develop that area.
[3:01:48] I'd be happy to answer any other questions
[3:01:50] that might come.
[3:01:52] Thank you.
[3:01:55] Next is Chian Hyatt.
[3:02:05] Welcome.
[3:02:07] [Muted for privacy: home address]
[3:02:08] [Muted for privacy: home address]
[3:02:13] [Muted for privacy: home address]
[3:02:18] [Muted for privacy: home address]
[3:02:22] there are probably 80 to 90% brick.
[3:02:27] I think that Candinann have done a wonderful job
[3:02:31] on the landscaping of the village and the signage
[3:02:34] and everything.
[3:02:36] But I think if you look at those homes in that subdivision
[3:02:41] and then you look at the one with the hardy board,
[3:02:45] there is a huge difference.
[3:02:48] I know what hardy board is.
[3:02:50] I've been a designer on a home for a very nice home
[3:02:53] and I know they had to have special installers come
[3:02:57] so that the warranty would be in place.
[3:03:01] I know it's an excellent product,
[3:03:02] but it looks like siding.
[3:03:05] And that's my concern is that the property values
[3:03:11] of that subdivision are going to be set
[3:03:14] by the looks of a house with Hardy Board
[3:03:17] and also that will contribute to the commercial buildings,
[3:03:22] the professional buildings and all of the other residential buildings and that's my concern.
[3:03:30] Thank you.
[3:03:31] Grant Hyatt?
[3:03:32] I didn't realize, my name is Grant Hyatt.
[3:03:40] I live my life.
[3:03:42] I was a subscriber who lived.
[3:03:44] I didn't realize when my wife said sign here, but I was signing it up for home and it was.
[3:03:50] I would like to maybe express congratulations to those city council members who won the election.
[3:03:57] That's great.
[3:03:58] I actually am in favor of the proposals from the staff.
[3:04:03] I thought it was quite interesting with the current restrictions on that.
[3:04:08] Those two cul-de-sacs as can't describe it.
[3:04:11] I don't really understand how the owners of those North laws will be able to exit
[3:04:18] if we don't let them put doors on the south side of their houses.
[3:04:22] There's no public access.
[3:04:25] And I'm kind of a believer that the subdivision, you know, they govern themselves, their covenants.
[3:04:34] When they buy into that property, those are recorded.
[3:04:38] They're encouraged to go down and read and see exactly what's going to happen within their subdivision.
[3:04:44] And I don't know that we as property owners, Jason, have as much of a vested interest as the actual owners do.
[3:04:52] So I'm all for their self-government, and I know that
[3:04:56] Canton and have done a beautiful job on the landscape,
[3:05:01] as I turn that corner and drive around,
[3:05:04] pole-line, my eyes are just drawn to that landscape.
[3:05:08] And maybe it's because for so long I looked at
[3:05:10] lavarot completely, but that's so beautiful.
[3:05:13] And I don't have a concern that they're going to finish off
[3:05:16] the subdivision with every bit as nice as so.
[3:05:20] I understand, you know, why some owners would want to leave those restrictions on the town
[3:05:28] homes within the PUD and not touch those.
[3:05:32] I understand also where Ken's coming from and he says, you know, if we have a little more
[3:05:36] freedom there, we think we can come up with something more beautiful.
[3:05:39] So I don't know if necessarily have an opinion on that, but I am in favor of what the staff
[3:05:46] is recommending.
[3:05:47] Thank you.
[3:05:48] Thank you, Brian.
[3:05:50] is Newell Tyler Ellison. Welcome. I went full name there. I usually don't go by
[3:06:02] [Muted for privacy: home address]
[3:06:05] [Muted for privacy: home address]
[3:06:10] [Muted for privacy: home address]
[3:06:15] [Muted for privacy: home address]
[3:06:20] did have, I did sign to Alaska planning and zoning. I do have a few concerns and
[3:06:25] questions. As I will be building a building in this, I know that I have certain restrictions
[3:06:30] on my building that will go in. And as a professional, a long-term investment is building. Therefore,
[3:06:38] I want this to maintain value. Back to that, we mentioned CCNRs. Who will be enforcing these
[3:06:46] CCNRs? The reason I ask is this. In my own development is south of here. There have been
[3:06:52] homes put in that violate the CC&Rs, but they've gotten past it.
[3:06:57] So my question is, who's going to enforce these?
[3:07:01] Because although there is an enforcer, there have been homes that have gotten past that.
[3:07:06] And so in the future, as this gets developed, as 16 of the, I guess, 21 lots are already
[3:07:11] owned by homes, are these going to strictly be watched?
[3:07:16] As we can see, and as Hyatt proclaimed, we don't want the value of this to drop.
[3:07:24] We want it to be kind of watched over it.
[3:07:26] It's the reason why people build in this area, the reason why people want to build this area
[3:07:31] is to maintain it as a, I don't know, a better word used and more kind of a higher end place.
[3:07:41] My concern is that right now my lot is dirt, but hopefully being an exterior, it begins
[3:07:48] to rise. And when that goes on I hope that this just maintains what I hoped it
[3:07:52] to be when I originally purchased that. So thank you. And we will get an answer to
[3:08:00] [Muted for privacy: home address]
[3:08:20] [Muted for privacy: home address]
[3:08:28] [Muted for privacy: home address]
[3:08:35] [Muted for privacy: home address]
[3:08:44] And I do see into the garage at my height where we're looking down.
[3:08:51] And it's just my opinion.
[3:08:54] I do love that they put a fence there that helps.
[3:09:00] It is my opinion that it looks like fighting, and I haven't really talked to anyone.
[3:09:07] That's my opinion.
[3:09:08] I kept wondering when the what was going to go on the house.
[3:09:16] Obviously, my husband and I have invested a great deal of money into what our house is,
[3:09:25] And it's our honest opinion.
[3:09:29] Long after we're gone and dead, we want that structure to go on looking beautiful.
[3:09:40] And I don't know what the life of Hardy Board is for years to come, but it's just my opinion
[3:09:54] as the closest neighbor.
[3:09:58] It looks like fighting.
[3:10:01] And as far as taking the restrictions off of that area, I'm one person, but that's my
[3:10:11] opinion.
[3:10:12] I truly, it looks like I might be far enough away from those townhomes, but I'm not very
[3:10:18] far, really, it does affect us.
[3:10:25] So that's the only input that I have, I guess.
[3:10:29] Thank you for your time.
[3:10:30] Thank you.
[3:10:36] Diana Wicken.
[3:10:37] Wiccan.
[3:10:40] Someone loves you a lot of snow.
[3:10:43] Wicher.
[3:10:44] Yes.
[3:10:46] [Muted for privacy: home address]
[3:10:47] [Muted for privacy: home address]
[3:10:52] [Muted for privacy: home address]
[3:10:59] [Muted for privacy: home address]
[3:11:05] of effort, a lot of money into.
[3:11:09] And one thing that I consider to be very important is that when Mr. Taylor and Mr. Ken Edmonds
[3:11:17] were there talking to us, they helped to draw up these plans and said, these are good. And
[3:11:24] we think that they would be a good value to the community. I'm trying to remember the
[3:11:31] name that he or the word that he actually assigned to it, but he said, this will work.
[3:11:37] And we'd like to make that as our effort to be in good faith, you know, to make sure
[3:11:44] that there is a quality of this neighborhood.
[3:11:46] And we were all very trusting, not specifically wanting this, but we understood that he came
[3:11:55] to us with a good idea for these CCNRs.
[3:11:59] Now CCNRs are there for our protection.
[3:12:01] And I feel like when we came to this decision of what those CCNRs were, we all agreed to
[3:12:07] that this was a good compromise at the time.
[3:12:11] I don't feel like compromising again is a good deal
[3:12:18] for the community.
[3:12:20] We put those there to protect ourselves
[3:12:22] and to protect those around us,
[3:12:24] the value of our community,
[3:12:26] what we want our community to be,
[3:12:28] what we want to see in the future.
[3:12:31] We want to see future growth.
[3:12:33] And those CCNRs are our protection.
[3:12:36] And so I'm pleading with you that as a homeowner,
[3:12:42] these things are there just as shortly important
[3:12:46] as a traffic light, just as important as our policemen are.
[3:12:50] They are there for protection.
[3:12:52] And if we keep coming back every two, every three years,
[3:12:55] whatever, to say they aren't important,
[3:12:58] let's try something else.
[3:13:00] I think we need to reevaluate where our goals
[3:13:03] and our values are as a community.
[3:13:06] So thank you very much for listening to us, I appreciate your time.
[3:13:11] Thank you.
[3:13:14] And last on the sign up list I have, I'm going to guess the first name is Suzanne, and I'm
[3:13:20] not sure I know what the last name is on here, but you know who you are, so that's good.
[3:13:29] [Muted for privacy: home address]
[3:13:48] [Muted for privacy: home address]
[3:13:55] [Muted for privacy: home address]
[3:14:00] [Muted for privacy: home address]
[3:14:06] To me, siding is siding.
[3:14:08] Even if it is, what's the name of that stuff, Hardy Board?
[3:14:11] I've never heard of it before, but it looks exactly the same to me, especially from a
[3:14:15] distance.
[3:14:16] I thought we'd work to this out before now.
[3:14:20] We pay the highest taxes in Twin Falls.
[3:14:23] I mean, I'm dying over my taxes.
[3:14:25] And I'm thinking, maybe they could cut my taxes in half.
[3:14:28] And we'd kind of go with that.
[3:14:30] But I suppose that's another conversation for later.
[3:14:33] But we don't want it to turn into an area that
[3:14:38] looks messy and uncared for.
[3:14:40] And I think if the housing and the apartments go down
[3:14:48] in rent or for sale, then people might be more inclined to move in there that might not
[3:14:56] take care of their houses as well as maybe we do.
[3:15:01] And I don't mean to sound snobby at all, because I'm really not, but just please know I'm the
[3:15:07] hottie board, keep the place looking nice, and please we hit two years ago, how can we
[3:15:13] just come back again to change what's going to happen in two years from now.
[3:15:18] So please know I'm the Hardy Board and let's keep this looking like a great place.
[3:15:23] Thank you very much.
[3:15:25] Thank you.
[3:15:28] It's not as all the people I have who signed up to speak on this item this evening.
[3:15:35] Is there anyone else who wishes to speak on the public hearing on this?
[3:15:54] Thank you very much.
[3:15:55] I'm Max Newlena Lille on the 7th Avenue East and I'm here because I saw a paper that says
[3:16:01] We want to make a change.
[3:16:03] And it seems like Americans are looking for a stability.
[3:16:08] We want to be shunned.
[3:16:09] No more change.
[3:16:10] Everything will make the rules.
[3:16:11] The rules are the rules.
[3:16:13] And I've seen this council have exceptions to the exceptions.
[3:16:17] And the rules, like these people are saying,
[3:16:18] they come back for another exception.
[3:16:20] And I was listening to Jonathan hoping I could understand
[3:16:25] the changes we'll make and it doesn't seem
[3:16:27] like it's something that's funny.
[3:16:30] And Zoni said it's OK.
[3:16:31] And so is it okay with those guys?
[3:16:33] Why isn't it okay with us, but it affects people's lives
[3:16:36] and their views out the kitchen,
[3:16:37] windows and everything else, you know?
[3:16:40] And so you bought a pig and a poke,
[3:16:42] if you're not, can count on what the changes are gonna be.
[3:16:45] If there's not gonna be any changes,
[3:16:47] then you know what you got, and if you're gonna make changes,
[3:16:49] then what's your gut is, who knows?
[3:16:53] So that's my public comment.
[3:16:55] Thank you very much.
[3:16:56] Thank you, Mr. Muhlen.
[3:17:00] Anyone else?
[3:17:04] If not, I will close the public input portion of the public hearing and turn it back into
[3:17:11] the applicant if you wish to have any comments to the testimony.
[3:17:31] I do appreciate the compliments that people have given to the development with respect
[3:17:38] to the appearance of the house that my daughter has built.
[3:17:42] I would respectfully disagree that it appears less than quality, a crap-man-type-style house
[3:17:51] like that is very difficult to build with, you know, quarried stone with brick.
[3:18:00] It allows a lot of flexibility as far as being a durable product.
[3:18:05] It's a very durable product that is, I think, the main objection to a sighted house, as they
[3:18:11] commonly called vinyl or steel is the durability and their parents after a certain period of
[3:18:18] time at a hardy board is certainly not in that category. I just don't feel that there's
[3:18:28] a real good underlying reason for having these restrictions continue on this development point
[3:18:37] once again to the fact that this is the only development that has such restrictions and so
[3:18:42] So if they were such good ideas, why aren't they being required of others?
[3:18:47] I realized that we can send it to them, but like I said before, that was done when things
[3:18:55] were unknown.
[3:18:56] And we didn't know if the fence was going to be in.
[3:18:59] We didn't know what the landscape is going to look like.
[3:19:02] We didn't know about the performance and capabilities of the people involved.
[3:19:06] But I think all of those concerns have been assuaged and should be put aside.
[3:19:12] and put us back on the same footing as every other development in the city.
[3:19:18] And we have the surrounding a lot of the people that own the property
[3:19:25] that are adjoining the pieces that we're talking about, specifically the townhomes,
[3:19:31] have considered to them, they're the ones who have the most direct and proprietary
[3:19:37] interest in this development.
[3:19:41] What we're looking for is freedom to develop and not be constrained by certain pitches on
[3:19:51] roofs.
[3:19:52] If you can vary the pitches to get a better design, we don't have to come back and say
[3:19:56] we need to have relief from that particular thing.
[3:20:00] If we can mix and match some building materials that are more aesthetically pleasing or maybe
[3:20:08] less traditional, but are more in keeping with the market, we should be allowed to do
[3:20:15] that. We have every intention, a continuing intention of making that a very nice subdivision.
[3:20:25] I somewhat disappointed that others don't feel like it's matched up to what their expectations
[3:20:32] were, but I think that the house that Anna's building is better than just a strictly stucco
[3:20:42] or drive a house. It has character, it has pillars, it's not a box, it has
[3:20:50] scalloping, it has changes in direction. Those are the types of things that you
[3:20:55] have to have, you have to have these flexible materials in order to accomplish
[3:21:00] that look. And so without there being a substantial public interest, then I
[3:21:10] And I think that we should be placed on the same footing as the other developers and allowed
[3:21:17] to go forward.
[3:21:18] Thank you, Mr. Taylor.
[3:21:25] Fritz, could you answer the question that was asked by Mr. Ellison regarding the enforcement
[3:21:30] of CC&Rs?
[3:21:31] Yeah, any of the property owners within the development has the right to enforce those CC&Rs, not the
[3:21:40] city.
[3:21:42] The interest is by the property owners that are subject to the CC&Rs.
[3:21:47] So the CC&Rs in the two cul-visac neighborhoods there would be enforced by a homeowner's association
[3:21:54] or any individual property owner or any one property owner.
[3:21:59] Thank you.
[3:22:01] Greg Lantik.
[3:22:02] Well, I think I'm going to maybe answer.
[3:22:04] We can't call on you.
[3:22:05] I apologize.
[3:22:06] I'm going to maybe answer your question because there seem to be in the discussion there
[3:22:11] was some...
[3:22:12] Hold on.
[3:22:13] to emphasize that we enforce the PUD requirements.
[3:22:18] Property owners enforce the CCNRs.
[3:22:20] Right, and I think that was the confusing.
[3:22:22] One of the speakers talked about that we would be taking the CCNRs off.
[3:22:26] We are not, we cannot, we can't deal with CCNRs.
[3:22:29] That's not the thing we have, we need to do it.
[3:22:31] We are dealing only with the PUD restrictions.
[3:22:35] The CCNRs will stay in place.
[3:22:38] Okay, for the day we're at correct, Mr. Taylor.
[3:22:41] CCN artist will stay in place, the PUD restrictions would change,
[3:22:46] would be if we voted for this.
[3:22:48] Okay?
[3:22:49] That's why there was confusion in testimony
[3:22:51] that we were taking off the CZR.
[3:22:53] We are not.
[3:22:54] The CFCN artist will stay.
[3:23:00] Ruth Pierce.
[3:23:00] So Fritz, I have a question for you.
[3:23:03] That's my neighborhood.
[3:23:06] So I live in the old Candlewood subdivision.
[3:23:11] Do I need to recuse myself from this?
[3:23:14] I know it's kind of late to ask, but.
[3:23:17] So we'll tell you that you have a conflict of interest
[3:23:23] if you feel that the outcome of this decision
[3:23:26] will adversely impact your own property value.
[3:23:32] Or other facts that I may have, correct?
[3:23:35] So I think I need to recuse myself.
[3:23:38] There are other reasons.
[3:23:40] I think I do.
[3:23:46] Chris talked.
[3:23:47] Well, having said that, I guess I better recuse myself too
[3:23:51] because I live proximally with the subdivision.
[3:23:59] I'll just keep my mouth shut.
[3:24:04] All right.
[3:24:10] So I will guess, Nicky Boyd.
[3:24:16] I don't finish your sentence.
[3:24:17] What were you going to say?
[3:24:19] I was going to ask if you had any other questions for the applicant.
[3:24:23] If not, I'm going to turn it over to counsel for deliberation.
[3:24:30] I'm sorry, the public hearing, public input portion of the hearing
[3:24:33] is closed, so we can't accept any more testimony from you.
[3:24:35] and we can't, no.
[3:24:42] This is a development on a very busy corner.
[3:24:54] This is a mixed-use concept.
[3:25:02] It's a wonderful concept because it
[3:25:06] allows for different type of housing to be mixed in with some commercial and some business
[3:25:17] park feeling things.
[3:25:22] All homes, such as some of the homes that you guys live in that are fabulous, you wouldn't
[3:25:30] have built it if you bought your lot out on the corner.
[3:25:38] There has to be some transition from pole line to the homes.
[3:25:48] Those style of homes that are beautiful, they're fabulously maintained, nobody's going to keep
[3:25:55] building those and live up to the edge of pole line.
[3:25:59] It will never happen.
[3:26:03] History and development and everything go anywhere and there is some kind of a transition.
[3:26:10] transition is a great concept and I know everybody love the concept that's not the
[3:26:15] issue here but those cul-de-sacs there is no way that you can build a house on
[3:26:22] that cul-de-sac and get in and out of your driveway and build a really attractive
[3:26:28] house. Stop and think about you can put a house with two windows a
[3:26:37] front door and some garage is right there. And so therefore the back of those houses would
[3:26:42] not have a garage, but that's restricting aesthetically pleasing construction. Having a home part of
[3:26:57] the beauty of utilizing a corner of a cul-de-sac is you have some funky setbacks and some shape
[3:27:04] where you can actually get your garage tucked back so that you can have a
[3:27:09] prettier front yard which is what everybody sees because you're fenced in at
[3:27:13] the back. Now the house that's being built there isn't finished. It's right now
[3:27:20] it's got hardy on it which is a product that you paint. A good paint will last a
[3:27:28] good ten years, and that is a product that is used to bring, if you look at architecture,
[3:27:39] there's a lot of beautiful architecture that is not accomplished through stucco or stone.
[3:27:45] It just isn't.
[3:27:46] So, there's lots of variety out there that could still be beautiful, high quality, expensive
[3:27:54] houses it would just not look exactly the same and I think this corner is about
[3:28:02] providing some variety that that's part of its purpose and so I also think once
[3:28:13] the land there's no landscaping there we're looking at that powder-dry-flower
[3:28:18] dirt that we have here and you've got a house that is painted so it's very
[3:28:22] and finished looking. And I do understand if you are located so that your elevation is
[3:28:28] different and you're looking down, landscaping will remedy that. It did take about five years,
[3:28:36] but it will remedy that and you will have a really viable neighborhood that's going from
[3:28:45] it's graduating out to Poland. I think it's a logical progress to get that. And I think
[3:28:55] That corner provides those beautiful homes,
[3:28:59] the nicest buffer zone in all of the Magic Valley.
[3:29:03] And I know everybody's not gonna agree
[3:29:05] on every style of home,
[3:29:08] but those houses will not be aesthetically pleasing
[3:29:12] to your neighborhood if they're all going to have
[3:29:16] a garage facing front and they're all made
[3:29:19] out of stucco or brick.
[3:29:21] It's not.
[3:29:23] And I think giving them the flexibility on that is really important to bring some of the
[3:29:33] current ambiance of what people want in houses.
[3:29:38] And I think that that's a good thing out there.
[3:29:42] I'm in favor of what's being asked for.
[3:29:45] So I'm going to guess there are no more questions for the applicant or the staff.
[3:29:53] I will close the public hearing will move to the deliberation portion here at the
[3:29:58] Council deliberating. Suzanne Hopkins. So this is tough because I have two moral
[3:30:08] personal beliefs at conflict here. I believe that personal property owners have
[3:30:13] the right to develop their property as they see fit, but I also believe that when
[3:30:18] we agree to a set of rules that we don't go back and change them. So that is the
[3:30:22] conflict when you get right down to it. I would like to think that we can come up
[3:30:27] with some kind of reasonable solution. I think that maintaining the rules on the
[3:30:35] townhouses and holding fast on that is one of those ways we can do it. I wish we
[3:30:42] would have had the foresight to realize the problem we created with the garages at
[3:30:46] the beginning of this because that that has to be fixed. Even though everyone
[3:30:51] agreed to it at the time, you can't do it. So we know we made a mistake when we agreed
[3:30:56] to those rules two years ago. I'm not a house builder, I don't understand all of the materials
[3:31:02] and the choices on the outside of the house. And again, I'm back to that conflict between
[3:31:08] we all came to a place where we agreed we would use brick and stone and now we're trying
[3:31:14] to change the rules and at the same time, property owners have a right to develop. But
[3:31:20] It was just two years ago that everybody was okay with the brick in the stone.
[3:31:25] So I guess in my perfect world the compromise would be to make the changes to allow the driveways
[3:31:30] and some of the other things, but maybe hold the line on the brick and the stone agreement
[3:31:37] because that was okay with everybody two years ago.
[3:31:40] And maybe that would be a compromise that we could all live with.
[3:31:43] Thank you.
[3:31:46] Greg Lanting?
[3:31:48] Well, again, I like Suzanne.
[3:31:50] There's a hard part to this.
[3:31:52] and he down about it.
[3:31:55] I agree, we got to change the garages.
[3:31:57] I mean, if you can't even face your garages south
[3:31:59] on the far side of the cul-de-sac,
[3:32:01] that doesn't make much sense.
[3:32:02] I also agree with Nikki that this does have
[3:32:05] to be a transition zone.
[3:32:06] I'm going to throw out a number and I have no idea
[3:32:09] if I'm being more close.
[3:32:10] Nikki would probably cope.
[3:32:11] Some of those houses on the, in the inside point
[3:32:14] are probably half a million dollars
[3:32:16] or maybe more, maybe less, I'm not sure.
[3:32:18] But, or more.
[3:32:20] But we can't expect that next neighborhood to be a half million dollars.
[3:32:23] I mean, it's just not feasible on the graduation process.
[3:32:26] If we had half million dollars, then also, they all had to be half million dollars.
[3:32:30] The next, the townhouses don't make any sense.
[3:32:33] So, I have a problem there.
[3:32:36] I'm a little concerned on the green with Mr., I'm probably in favor of the motion in general.
[3:32:44] But I have trouble with the townhouses, but it worries me, I can't, I respect you
[3:32:49] your daughter as developers, but I can't just throw them totally off. I know
[3:32:56] there's CC&Rs, but I also get phone calls and I go, we all do multiple times a year
[3:33:03] where somebody's not enforcing the CCRs and they want us to do it as a council and
[3:33:09] we can't enforce CC&Rs. We can force PUD restrictions, but not CC&Rs. So I
[3:33:15] I will probably be inclined to vote for the motion as it came from P&Z that the restrictions
[3:33:24] remain on the townhomes, but I would like to see us to go ahead and change them.
[3:33:31] I don't see the townhomes being out of brick stone or, I guess in my mind, when we said
[3:33:36] I saw this two years ago, stone to me, man, cultured stone.
[3:33:40] you see in like Settler's Ridge where a lot of the homes have stone that I can't tell the
[3:33:47] difference between I know it's concrete or something to make made to look like stone that
[3:33:52] to me was stone can't I so that's my concern I when we were voting on it back then I assumed
[3:33:58] that's what I was voting on was cultured stone brick culture stone or stucco or in a case
[3:34:04] of like on Settler's Ridge it's mostly cultured stone and stucco and so that's what I thought
[3:34:10] I was voting on so I would I could be willing to be swayed on that portion of the restrictions
[3:34:15] but I'm not sure I'm really willing to just be a part blank on the on the townhomes and
[3:34:22] at this point the townhomes are who are we protecting I guess now we're protecting the Colesacks
[3:34:27] they're not the ones on beyond and then whatever bills to the the west of the townhomes were
[3:34:33] we're looking at protecting them in the transition so I don't know if I made sense when I was
[3:34:39] but that's where I'm in.
[3:34:43] Thank you, Greg.
[3:34:44] Thank you, boy.
[3:34:45] I thought of another thing.
[3:34:46] A comment.
[3:34:47] And certainly, I've run across this a lot.
[3:34:51] Everybody in the city of Twin Falls pays the exact same property taxes.
[3:34:58] The difference is, it's based on the assessed value of your home.
[3:35:04] So, there is a perception that certain neighborhoods have higher taxes.
[3:35:12] It has nothing to do with the tax amount, has to do with the assessed value of the home.
[3:35:20] That's all it is.
[3:35:21] So, I just, every time I get a chance to specify that, I try to clear that up because that is
[3:35:28] how it works.
[3:35:29] If your house is 189,000, you multiply it by the little multiplier, it's a multiplication
[3:35:36] thing, and that's how much you pay, and if your house is worth 800,000, you multiply it by
[3:35:41] by the exact same number, and that's how much that house is assessed.
[3:35:45] So there's no higher tax neighborhoods.
[3:35:48] That's a misnomer.
[3:35:49] Thank you, Nikki.
[3:35:52] You're welcome.
[3:35:55] So the, so I too am struggling on this one,
[3:36:04] because in the name PUD, the word planned is used.
[3:36:11] It's a planned unit development.
[3:36:13] And this development was just planned two years ago, two and a half years ago, through
[3:36:19] a process that at the time I recall being very positive in its engagement of the neighbors
[3:36:27] and figuring out in a world of the unknown what they could be comfortable with when it
[3:36:36] was known.
[3:36:39] And now we know part of it, and it doesn't match what everyone agreed to two years ago to be what was planned.
[3:36:51] I appreciate that there are changes in the outside forces and things that can have an impact,
[3:37:01] but personally I don't think this is too far down the road from what was planned collectively with the neighbors.
[3:37:11] Specific to the residential development.
[3:37:16] I think truthfully, I share some of the concern about the further unknown of the town homes
[3:37:23] almost more than I am concerned about the homes that we are seeing develop.
[3:37:28] I agree with Nikki's comments, this has to be a transition and we have a responsibility
[3:37:34] for this orderly growth and development of the community.
[3:37:40] I don't know if what kind of exterior material is on the house has that much of an impact.
[3:37:48] I mean, the fact that these are 10,000 square foot lots
[3:37:53] as opposed to whatever size the lots are next door
[3:37:57] or 2,500 square foot homes as opposed to how many square feet
[3:38:01] are in the homes next door, that's the transition I see.
[3:38:10] But I have a hard time just throwing out all of these items
[3:38:15] that were just agreed to just a couple of years ago
[3:38:19] because it's well beyond just the exterior material.
[3:38:22] It's talking about the square footage of lots.
[3:38:25] It's talking about building heights when it gets to the town homes.
[3:38:29] It's talking about density and square footage.
[3:38:32] And this is not an easy one to come to a conclusion on further on that.
[3:38:46] But it's not an easy one.
[3:38:56] So that's the four of us who are left up here.
[3:38:59] I would certainly take any further discussion from the council
[3:39:07] or would entertain a motion on the request?
[3:39:12] That's right.
[3:39:17] Thank you.
[3:39:18] I'm just going to throw it out there.
[3:39:22] How's that?
[3:39:23] So, I would move that at this point in time, we remove the condition for the driveways
[3:39:35] not facing Cheney drive.
[3:39:39] I don't, I mean, I know we've already got up the fencing that's parallel, so I don't see any reason to strike that at this time.
[3:39:50] I guess let's remove the garage for right now, I'll start with that, and that's my motion, that we just make that one change.
[3:40:03] There a second.
[3:40:14] Okay, so that motion dies for lack of a second.
[3:40:17] Can I ask a question?
[3:40:29] You may.
[3:40:30] Those cul-de-sacs, it talks here that the lot area shall average not less than 10,000 square feet.
[3:40:43] Those are all planted. Are those all 10,000 feet or more? So I'm thinking. Okay.
[3:40:50] Yes, it has been planted and they are averaging 10,000 feet, all of the lots on the southern portion.
[3:40:55] Right. And the roof pitches and the building height and all that, that's all just the normal stuff, right Jonathan?
[3:41:04] I don't see I'm not a builder, but the so I can't ask for the roof bitches the building height not exceeding 28 feet is not our
[3:41:13] Code or code is 35 for every zone
[3:41:16] For residential zone. That's our two or four or six are one. They're all thirty five feet
[3:41:23] Okay, that's what I was verifying how how different is that?
[3:41:30] And then the roof bitches
[3:41:35] Yeah, well, the 612 is not very high.
[3:41:45] So generally, the items included in the PUD are more restrictive than the underlying R1 variable zoning.
[3:41:58] All of these are not found in any of our current code.
[3:42:02] The exception being nobody could access Chaney anyway.
[3:42:06] because our engineer wouldn't allow it anyway.
[3:42:08] Can I just, but the developers agreed
[3:42:12] to these two and a half years ago.
[3:42:14] Correct.
[3:42:15] OK.
[3:42:20] You have something else, Nicki, or even a kind of motion there?
[3:42:23] I'm working on it.
[3:42:24] OK.
[3:42:28] With the knowledge that I have with my real estate background,
[3:42:32] there is a conflict, the no garage door spacing,
[3:42:38] the roof pitches, the building height, all that kind of stuff.
[3:42:43] That does not flow with looking at attractive-like type of buildings.
[3:42:54] This is less than.
[3:42:56] So having a house that anywhere else can be 35 feet,
[3:43:01] but here it can only be 28 feet, that's a lot of difference.
[3:43:09] That's kind of, it seems like you're maybe
[3:43:12] getting a little bit pigeonholed into having
[3:43:15] look at Squatty Boxy versus a mixed maybe variety that would be actually better-looking.
[3:43:23] I don't know, that's some kind of interesting and you can't have it says you shall have
[3:43:31] a two-car garage or larger and in a lot of neighborhoods you know that one house that
[3:43:39] got through with only two cars on it is looked at as maybe not the best thing in this you
[3:43:46] mixed use. I think it would be awesome if somebody who didn't need three cars could build a house
[3:43:51] that only had a two car garage on it. That's great. But these are much, the requirements
[3:43:58] are much less than what you have around this. That's much nicer. And I don't know if that's
[3:44:05] accomplishing what you really want. I know it was agreed to, but I don't know if that's in your best
[3:44:12] interest. You guys are making us use all our brain cells trying to come out with a
[3:44:20] good. There are no conditions that's not allowed that we have not had marriage
[3:44:44] make motions, but I think that's only tradition, not actual. Anything written in
[3:44:49] stone. So if you'd like to make a motion, you're welcome. It's very sweet of you.
[3:44:55] I'll make them out of that. Okay, let's try this. I'm gonna go with the
[3:45:01] request. I move that we grant the request for a PUD amendment to the Canyon Village PUD
[3:45:09] number 270 to remove residential development requirements for property located at the northwest
[3:45:16] corner of Eastland Drive and Chaney Drive, Carif Kent Taylor on behalf of Northeast
[3:45:20] investments LLC application 2897.
[3:45:27] Question of clarification, would that be just the request
[3:45:29] or would you be making a motion to act on with staff
[3:45:34] recommendations from the Planning and Zoning Commission
[3:45:36] with the restriction to the planning and zoning?
[3:45:40] Yes or no?
[3:45:42] Yes.
[3:45:43] You have to, I just was verifying.
[3:45:44] I know, yes.
[3:45:45] So that would include the restrictions on the
[3:45:49] leave the town home restrictions in the field
[3:45:54] is what the Planning and Zoning recommendation.
[3:45:57] Yes, I'd like to see if we get a second.
[3:45:59] Second.
[3:46:01] So the motion is to approve, actually approve
[3:46:08] the recommendation from the Planning and Zoning Commission
[3:46:11] to approve the PUD amendment, but leave the townhome
[3:46:18] restrictions as stated.
[3:46:21] Is that correct?
[3:46:23] Motion by Nikki Boyd and seconded by Greg Lainting.
[3:46:25] So I have a discussion.
[3:46:27] Greg Lainting.
[3:46:27] I wish this had brought two men brought to us in a slightly different form.
[3:46:34] I wish it had been, instead of Mr. Carte blank on all the PUD, it would have went through
[3:46:38] the ones that maybe were egregious or were hard to meet and that we could vote on it that
[3:46:45] way rather than just taking them all off.
[3:46:48] I do know that this needs to be a transition and so thus there has to be some changes there,
[3:46:54] especially on the garage door open or openings.
[3:47:00] And I also wish that we would have brought through this would have been the same thing
[3:47:04] on the townhomes that there had been just the things that needed to be relieved, not just
[3:47:10] everything being relieved.
[3:47:11] Now I understand that it's pretty uncommon for us to have PUD restrictions on residential
[3:47:19] areas.
[3:47:20] But I also know we were trying to make some sausage here too, two and a half years ago,
[3:47:25] to make this acceptable to the whole neighborhood.
[3:47:28] And to me, we're going to probably have to make some more
[3:47:32] sausage in the future on those town homes,
[3:47:34] but I suggest if you bring those back
[3:47:36] for additional changes, that they be limited to just certain
[3:47:41] things that need to be done, so there's still
[3:47:43] more predictions there.
[3:47:44] I will be voting in favor of motion.
[3:47:48] Suzanne Hockham.
[3:47:49] Thank you.
[3:47:50] I just want to reiterate that this one is just pulling me
[3:47:53] in both directions, because I really
[3:47:56] feel like we need to honor the commitment that was made
[3:47:59] to the existing neighbors.
[3:48:01] They were promised things from us two and a half years ago,
[3:48:05] and now we're just kind of throwing it all out
[3:48:08] and saying, oh well, and it's not that I don't trust
[3:48:11] the developers, I know they're doing a good job there,
[3:48:13] and I know they want to develop it
[3:48:15] into a quality location for those
[3:48:17] that are going to be living there.
[3:48:19] And it's just really, it's a gut wrenching
[3:48:22] tear down the middle for me.
[3:48:26] I want to show good faith with those
[3:48:28] who made the agreement, but at the same time
[3:48:30] I want it to be developed in a way that is livable and is that transition that we're looking for.
[3:48:36] And my Greg said I wish we had more options than we could pick and choose because doing the whole thing at once just, it doesn't set right.
[3:48:44] Greg Lanting.
[3:48:47] I forgot to add that I would not be voting yes if the CC and ours on that those two cul-of-sex were not still in place, because they are still in place.
[3:48:56] We're not taking those off.
[3:48:57] with the CC&Rs and there are neighborhoods that do a good job of maintaining their CC&Rs.
[3:49:03] I lived in a neighborhood where the CC&Rs were in effect almost 20 years later where
[3:49:10] I put on an addition and I had to go through the CC&R committee to get that taken care of.
[3:49:15] So I'm not saying all CC&Rs but some there is a mixed bag without a doubt but if the CC&Rs
[3:49:22] We're not still in place and they are still in place no matter what we do here the CCNRs
[3:49:27] for that those two Colesecs will be in place.
[3:49:31] Just a question of how well they're enforced.
[3:49:42] Any other discussion?
[3:49:43] Chair in roll call vote please.
[3:49:57] Greg Lanthine.
[3:49:58] Yes.
[3:49:59] Ruth Pierce.
[3:50:01] Are Suzanne Hawkins?
[3:50:03] Yes.
[3:50:11] Nicky Boyd.
[3:50:13] Yes.
[3:50:14] Sean Beriker.
[3:50:15] No.
[3:50:16] Motion passes.
[3:50:17] 3, 2, 1.
[3:50:20] passes three to one, two extensions, I should note as well.
[3:50:29] Thank you.
[3:50:34] Thank you all for your patience as we work through that.
[3:50:41] So we do have one other item for executive session
[3:50:45] that we did not get to during the earlier recess.
[3:50:49] Be adjourning to executive session.
[3:50:55] Sorry, great, LinkedIn.
[3:50:56] I thought we had to make other books.
[3:50:57] We'll be adjourning to executive session.
[3:50:59] We will not be returning to open session.
[3:51:02] We will not be making any decisions in it, it's executive session.
[3:51:06] Meeting adjourned.
[3:51:07] We have enough.
