Oversight Archive: City Council meeting, 2018-03-12, recording 1 (started 17:00)
Machine transcript (faster-whisper base.en), not checked word for word; the Pledge of Allegiance is shown in its standard wording. The recording is the record.
Times are time into the recording. Passages with private details are muted in the audio and marked here.
The audio on the page below was re-encoded by software from the video the agency posted. Check any passage against
that audio before relying on it.
Page: https://oversightarchive.org/twin-falls-id/meetings/2018-03-12/

[0:00:00] the Twin Falls City Council meeting for Monday, March 12th, and confirm we do have a quorum
[0:00:05] of the council here, all seven members of the present this evening.
[0:00:08] And the first item on the agenda is the Pledge of Allegiance, and we have a number of Girl Scouts
[0:00:12] who are here who have agreed willingly to lead us in the pledge.
[0:00:17] So, girls, if you'd like to lead us in the Pledge of Allegiance, or wait for this stage
[0:00:52] and come and read us this bra.
[0:00:59] Thank you, and before you all sit down, I would like for each of you to please introduce
[0:01:03] yourself. So there's a microphone right here. I love that one. And is the little green light on?
[0:01:12] That is so perfect if you would just please each of you introduce yourselves.
[0:01:18] My name is Karma. I'm in troop 470 and I do Girl Scouts because it's a new way to meet other
[0:01:24] people. Thank you. I'm McKinsey and I'm troop 6 and I do Girl Scouts because it helps the community.
[0:01:32] My name is Abby, I'm in troop for 70 and I do Girl Scouts because it helps me build character.
[0:01:42] I'm Anna Gray, I'm in troop for 70 and I do Girl Scouts because it helps me meet other people.
[0:01:48] I'm Olivia and I'm in troop for 70 to have fun.
[0:01:54] Excellent.
[0:01:55] I'm Laura Tappellaris, I'm in troop for 70, I'm in Girl Scouts, I love people.
[0:02:03] or 70. We do Girl Scouts to help other people.
[0:02:27] Great.
[0:02:28] From True 513 and we're a little shy today.
[0:02:40] I am Paige and I am True 470 and I like Girl Scouts because we go to Girl Scout camp.
[0:02:51] My name is Bri. I'm in True 470 and I do Scales for fun.
[0:02:59] I am Madeline, I am in troop 470 and I do Girl Scouts because I like helping other people.
[0:03:05] My name is Jasmine, I'm in troop 470 and I do Girl Scouts to help me build my personality and characteristics.
[0:03:14] My name is Op and I am...
[0:03:34] Great, perfect.
[0:03:37] My name is Sarah 470.
[0:03:42] Cause it's so much fun.
[0:03:50] My name is Chris and I am 470, the Girl Scouts because I...
[0:04:00] My name is Anna and I'm Anna and I like 4 to 4 70 and I like to do the scouts because it's fun
[0:04:15] My name is Aspen and I'm in troop 470 and I like Girl Scouts because it helps the community
[0:04:26] My name is Laura and I do I'm in troop 513 and I do Girl Scouts to help other people
[0:04:35] My name is Laurel and I'm in troop for 70 and the reason why I do Girl Scouts is because I like making new friends.
[0:04:44] It's a lesson. My name is Natalie and I do Girl Scouts group.
[0:05:17] My name is Jasmine and I do Girl Scouts because not only does it grow my community,
[0:05:22] it allows me to opportunity to watch other girls grow and just become wonderful people.
[0:05:27] And we are here because it's Girl Scout week.
[0:05:30] I'm Nancy Staff and I'm the membership coordinator for Council in this area.
[0:05:42] So, and here we get the girls get week.
[0:05:45] Great, and we do have your proclamation on the agenda in a couple of more items, so we'll
[0:05:49] get to that very soon.
[0:05:51] Thank you all for leading us in the pledge tonight.
[0:05:53] Mr. Bathweller, do we have any amendments to our agenda this evening?
[0:05:56] Mr. Mayor, move to the council.
[0:05:57] There are no amendments this evening.
[0:05:59] Thank you.
[0:06:00] So next we do have our proclamation, and we have three this evening, so I have asked a
[0:06:04] couple of other council members for assistance in reading them.
[0:06:07] So the first is for Girl Scout Week, and I've asked Councilman to read if you would please.
[0:06:12] Yes.
[0:06:14] The Office of the Mayor, City of Twin Falls, Idaho Proclamation Girl Scout Week 2018.
[0:06:21] Whereas March 12, 2018 marks the 106th anniversary of Girl Scouts of the USA, founded by Juliet
[0:06:29] Gordon Lowe.
[0:06:30] In 1912 in Savannah, Georgia, and whereas throughout its long and distinguished history,
[0:06:37] Girl Scouting has inspired millions of girls and women,
[0:06:41] with the highest ideals of character, conduct, and patriotism.
[0:06:45] And whereas through Girl Scouting, girls gain courage,
[0:06:50] confidence, and character who make their local communities
[0:06:53] and the world a better place.
[0:06:55] And whereas more than 2.7 million current Girl Scouts,
[0:07:00] Scout members nationwide will be celebrating 104 years
[0:07:04] of this American tradition, with nearly 60 million women who are former Girl Scouts and
[0:07:10] living proof of the impact of this amazing movement.
[0:07:14] Now therefore, Sean Barreger, Mayor of Twin Falls, Idaho, does proclaim the week of March
[0:07:21] 11th through the 17th, 2018 as Girl Scout Week, and does hereby applaud the commitment
[0:07:27] Girl Scouting has made to the American Girls.
[0:07:30] It is signed by the mayor of Twin Falls and Sean Berger, and thank you girls for coming
[0:08:05] this evening and sharing some of the reasons that you're involved with Girls Gapping, we
[0:08:10] appreciate it.
[0:08:12] Next on the agenda is another proclamation, and this one is for a groundwater awareness week,
[0:08:18] and I have asked councilmen talking to them if you please read that proclamation.
[0:08:23] Thank you, this is the proclamation for groundwater awareness week, whereas groundwater is a one
[0:08:28] Another resource in the city of Twin Falls and where is clean of London groundwater is an essential resource for our citizens.
[0:08:36] And where is groundwater supplied? Approximately 95% of residents with water that used to meet their drinking needs.
[0:08:45] And where as the agricultural community, private industry, businesses and communities rely on large quantities of high quality groundwater for economic prosperity.
[0:08:56] and whereas groundwater can be vulnerable to contamination and degradation,
[0:09:01] and whereas groundwater and surface water can be interconnected and therefore degraded or reduced,
[0:09:07] groundwater supplies can at firstly impact surface water uses, including drinking water,
[0:09:13] recreation, irrigation, and power generation. And whereas groundwater is one of our most precious
[0:09:19] natural resources, it is appropriate to set aside a special time to call upon everyone young and old
[0:09:26] to learn about the importance of groundwater in their lives and also to learn how they can
[0:09:31] protect and conserve our precious groundwater resource. Now therefore Sean Berg or Maricidia
[0:09:38] Twin Falls does hereby proclaim the week of March 11th, March 17th of this year to be groundwater
[0:09:46] awareness week. Thank you, Councilman, and we have a rippling to accept this this evening.
[0:09:52] Aaron Castle, thank you. I'll make this quick as I can.
[0:10:16] We are glad that we're able to bring the recognition to our groundwater,
[0:10:22] that we so need in the city of Twin Falls as of all of our water.
[0:10:27] He is in the city of Twin Falls, comes from groundwater.
[0:10:30] So protecting our groundwater sources is a top priority of our agenda.
[0:10:36] And on that note, I'm on the groundwater,
[0:10:41] Twin Falls groundwater advisory committee,
[0:10:43] and we're gonna hold the third annual groundwater awareness fair.
[0:10:48] It will be Thursday at the Twin Falls County West Building
[0:10:53] from three to six, 30 p.m.
[0:10:58] I guess it'd be the north side of the old county hospital
[0:11:03] around about four yards are there.
[0:11:06] there'll be free night tape screening for private wells outside of the city. So, anybody
[0:11:15] in Twin Falls County and neighboring counties can bring in an example, bringing in a Ziploc
[0:11:22] bag or a mason jar, a clean jar. There'll be water, leak detection kits. They're also
[0:11:30] for like toilets that leak and that kind of stuff,
[0:11:33] and sample bottles for water qualities,
[0:11:35] that's sort of, they'll also have the groundwater flow model
[0:11:41] set up there for people to see which aquifers
[0:11:44] feed the hard ground water wells and that sort of stuff.
[0:11:47] So, you might just want to say thank you again,
[0:11:50] recognition, well, thank you, Rob.
[0:11:57] The final proclamation that we have this evening
[0:12:00] is for March 4 Meals, for Meals on Wheels.
[0:12:05] Whereas on March 22nd, 1972, President Richard Nixon
[0:12:09] signed a DeLa, a measure that amended
[0:12:11] the Older Americans Act of 1965,
[0:12:14] established a national nutrition program
[0:12:16] for seniors 60 years and older.
[0:12:19] And whereas Meals on Wheels America
[0:12:20] established the March 4 Meals campaign in March 2002
[0:12:25] to recognize the historic month,
[0:12:27] the importance of the Older Americans Act nutrition programs
[0:12:30] both congregate and home delivered
[0:12:32] and raise awareness about the escalating problem
[0:12:35] of senior hunger in America.
[0:12:37] And whereas the 2018 observance for March for Meals
[0:12:40] provides an opportunity to support Meals on Wheels programs
[0:12:43] that deliver vital and critical services
[0:12:46] by donating, volunteering and raising awareness
[0:12:48] about senior hunger and isolation.
[0:12:51] And whereas older Americans act nutrition programs
[0:12:54] both congregate and home delivered in Idaho
[0:12:57] I've served our communities admirably for more than 40 years.
[0:13:01] And whereas volunteers for Twin Falls Senior Center
[0:13:03] Meals on Wheels program in Twin Falls, Idaho,
[0:13:06] are the backbone of the program,
[0:13:08] and they not only deliver nutritious meals to seniors,
[0:13:11] and individuals with disabilities
[0:13:12] who are at significant risk of hunger and isolation,
[0:13:16] but also carrying concern and attention to their welfare.
[0:13:19] And whereas Meals on Wheels programs in Idaho
[0:13:21] provide nutritious meals to seniors throughout the state,
[0:13:24] and help them maintain their health and independence,
[0:13:27] by preventing unnecessary falls, hospitalizations, and or premature institutionalization, and whereas
[0:13:34] Meals on Wheels programs in Idaho provide a powerful socialization opportunity for thousands
[0:13:39] of seniors to help combat loneliness and isolation, whereas Meals on Wheels programs
[0:13:46] in Idaho deserve recognition for the contributions they have made and will continue to make to
[0:13:51] local communities, our state, and our nation.
[0:13:54] Now therefore, I, Sean Berriger, Mayor of the City of Twin Falls, we hereby proclaim
[0:13:58] March 2018 as March for Meals Month and urge every citizen to take this month to honor our
[0:14:04] Meals on Meals programs, the seniors they serve, and the volunteers who care for them.
[0:14:10] Our recognition of the Twin Falls Senior Center Meals on Wheels program and involvement
[0:14:14] in the National 2018 March for Meals can enrich our entire community and help combat senior
[0:14:21] and isolation in America.
[0:14:24] You have Jenette Rauff from the senior center here to accept.
[0:14:27] Here in the city council for all their support and thank you for the population.
[0:14:51] As a matter of fact, the mayor will be writing with us on Wednesday to go along and around to see what it's like.
[0:14:58] And see what we do. It is a life changing experience.
[0:15:02] And for those who have never taken that off,
[0:15:04] And that before it is something to really do, and if you have opportunity to do that, it
[0:15:10] just takes a little bit of time.
[0:15:12] Suzanne is also going to do it a couple days this week.
[0:15:15] Brian Pike is also going to come down and help us out.
[0:15:18] Because, like I said, it's hard to understand the volume and the capacity of what we actually
[0:15:23] do on a daily basis at the Senior Center, but to give you an idea is in January we reached
[0:15:29] our all-time high goal, and I've said that a lot over the last few years, but it just keeps
[0:15:34] growing. January we delivered 6,532 meals. That was to at the senior center and at the
[0:15:45] home delivered meal program. That was our total. But 75% of what we're cooking at the
[0:15:51] center goes out the door to the homebound. That's how big of the percentage it is. And
[0:15:57] in February, even though we were short three days of the month, because it was a short
[0:16:03] We still had a real high time and there was over a thousand more meals served this February
[0:16:09] than was last February.
[0:16:11] So the train will continue.
[0:16:13] We're always looking for drivers.
[0:16:15] We're always looking for support and we're looking for the community to help us with that
[0:16:19] because the Older American Act has not received any more funding, essentially taken decreases.
[0:16:25] We don't know what's happening with the budget and there's things that are becoming up that
[0:16:29] we face with and I've had to reach out to other organizations for for private
[0:16:33] funding to help make sure that we keep people in this community. Fed and the main
[0:16:39] thing is is remembering that almost 38% of our population is over the age of
[0:16:45] 60 by the year 2020 in this community because we are such a large return
[0:16:50] community. Thank you. Thank you, Jim. Next on the agenda is an opportunity for
[0:17:03] general public input. If there's anyone here from the public who wishes to
[0:17:06] address the council on an item that is not on the agenda this evening. I'm now as
[0:17:10] your opportunity to please come forward. Being no one, he will move on to the consent
[0:17:19] calendar. I've got to click a couple of buttons first. The consent calendar. Council wishes.
[0:17:27] Can we pull out the minutes from last time? Since I was in here so I can vote on the other
[0:17:37] I've been trying to buzz in for a little bit. I'm not sure how our system's working, but none of my PDFs will open tonight.
[0:17:50] I tried to speak when the Girl Scouts were here because I wanted to talk to them, and so I'm not sure if you're seeing it or not, I've seen it online, but I cannot get into any PDFs.
[0:18:01] I see you on this item. I did not see you on that other item. I apologize for that.
[0:18:06] No, that's okay. I just I'm not sure what's happening
[0:18:09] But I couldn't open any of the proclamations, and I tried to get down into my items under just checking while I'm sitting here
[0:18:16] And I can't open anything tonight. I can open the
[0:18:23] Proclamations, yeah, I can get the PDFs. I can't get the third one. I'm the folks from our IT. Hope you out there. Thank you
[0:18:35] Mr. Furry, I'll move to approve the consent calendar as amended by
[0:18:44] second
[0:18:46] Motion by Chris Reed, seconded by Ruth Pierce to approve the consent calendar, minus last week's minutes. Is there any discussion?
[0:18:57] Chair and roll call vote please.
[0:19:43] Any discussion? Chair and roll call vote please.
[0:19:47] Niki Boyd, abstain. Don Bericher.
[0:19:54] Yes. Chris Hockington. Yes. Reg Lanthine. Yes.
[0:19:59] Christopher Reed. Yes. Ruth Pierce. Yes.
[0:20:02] Suzanne Hawkins. Yes.
[0:20:04] Motion passes 6-0 with 1, abstention.
[0:20:07] At next under items of consideration,
[0:20:13] the first is a request to adopt
[0:20:15] the modified utility rate resolution
[0:20:17] for the balance of fiscal year 2018.
[0:20:19] We have Bill Baxter, our Utility Services Director and Council, it's a pleasure to be
[0:20:34] before you again.
[0:20:35] I hope you're not getting tired of seeing me, I've kind of become a regular.
[0:20:39] You're kind of recycled by this time.
[0:20:44] That might help you all out.
[0:20:47] Thank you again for letting me come before you this evening.
[0:20:50] After Council's action last week to approve a $100 per ton cost share with PSI, the rate
[0:20:59] resolution that has been in effect was modified to include the 53 cent increase to a standard
[0:21:07] sanitation charge, which includes wastewater, water and sanitation services.
[0:21:17] With that, other than in discussing the cost chair, PSI has handled the January and February
[0:21:27] costs on their own, and to participate in that part of the year's cost share as provided
[0:21:35] in the contract, if Council so wishes, we would need to take $10,703.96 from the Sanitation
[0:21:47] Fund reserves to share that portion of this year's costs to date.
[0:21:52] Right? Chris Stockton, I would so move to uh,
[0:22:04] and authorize the movement of the 10,000, what was it?
[0:22:08] 10,000, 703, 96.
[0:22:14] That stated, for the until the reaper solution.
[0:22:19] Second, the motion by Chris Stockton, seconded by
[0:22:24] Christopher Reed to approve the use of reserve funds,
[0:22:28] amount to whatever the thousand.
[0:22:34] I'm assuming that needs to be a separate motion from the approval of the resolution, since that's a separate action.
[0:22:41] Is there discussion on that motion?
[0:22:46] John Beierger?
[0:22:56] Yes.
[0:22:57] Chris Hockington?
[0:22:59] Yes.
[0:23:00] Greg Lamting?
[0:23:01] Yes.
[0:23:02] Christopher Reed?
[0:23:03] Yes.
[0:23:04] Ruth Pierce?
[0:23:05] Yes.
[0:23:06] Suzanne Hawkins?
[0:23:07] Yes.
[0:23:08] Nikki Boyd?
[0:23:09] Yes.
[0:23:10] Motion passes.
[0:23:11] Yeah.
[0:23:12] Yeah.
[0:23:13] Yeah.
[0:23:15] I realize I wasn't in on the training last week, but I am definitely on the agenda item
[0:23:19] and I have had my withdraw point request to speak.
[0:23:22] Yeah.
[0:23:29] Sorry.
[0:23:30] Okay.
[0:23:46] Thank you.
[0:23:47] As you know, I was in Oregon last week, uh, or, yeah, and called into the meeting, uh,
[0:23:52] have my feelings be heard and, uh, one of the things I'm interested in right after I get
[0:24:06] the phone call on the meeting last week I watched their news is actually
[0:24:12] 11 o'clock there since they're in the Pacific Times and they go on a leader's
[0:24:16] schedule and interesting that the one of the first stories on the news that night
[0:24:22] was the Oregon cities up and down the coast as well as in the Portland area
[0:24:29] that were working with the same problem and most of them to my surprise had
[0:24:36] chosen to suspend recycling. I was a little surprised by that. Not most of them, but
[0:24:42] chosen to spend recycling totally. I mean, that totally. I can figure out a way to have
[0:24:49] China is still to be able to take their their their waste. I think we were made a
[0:24:55] pure-proved decision last week to at least try to attempt to stay in the recycling
[0:25:01] game because I was concerned as some of our partners were concerned.
[0:25:06] that if we ever stop, we'll probably never get started again, you people get out of the
[0:25:11] habit of doing that, it might be hard to get started back up again, but I want to report
[0:25:15] that, that was a surprise to me, and we're not in it alone either. All the cities in the
[0:25:21] West Coast, I think we're working with the same situation, and maybe there can be a solution,
[0:25:27] a combined solution, and all of us to get the combination down below that percentage,
[0:25:33] that we need to be able to ship it to other countries.
[0:25:36] Thank you.
[0:25:38] Thank you, Greg.
[0:25:39] Chris, talk to me about the other questions or comments
[0:25:45] for Bill on the resolution.
[0:25:48] Mr. Mayor, Travis, he would be remiss if I didn't throw this out.
[0:25:54] We had talked about this a little earlier.
[0:25:57] So the threshold right now is $100 per ton.
[0:26:00] $100 a ton is that break point where items are
[0:26:10] not recycled, but over $100 we send them to the landfill.
[0:26:16] And right now, that cost is about $136 a ton,
[0:26:22] and that cost, from my understanding,
[0:26:25] does not appear to be going down.
[0:26:29] So, in a put in perspective, March is $164 a ton.
[0:26:44] So, when you start looking at the costs and the cost
[0:26:48] escalations as that continues to grow what I think is important to share and I
[0:26:57] understand every argument that has been made but the functionality of what you
[0:27:05] are being asked to do tonight is to increase rates and it will go to the
[0:27:13] landfill and part of that will be used to cover the additional tonnage that we
[0:27:20] will be sending moving forward, but I do not want us to think or have the public
[0:27:28] believe that we're going to be continuing with the recycling program when until
[0:27:34] that hundred dollar threshold is met it is going to be making its way to the
[0:27:40] landfill. And I think that that needs to be very clear so that you understand
[0:27:46] what you're being asked to vote on this evening. We had conversations with PSI
[0:27:50] and PSI has shared with us that unfortunately $100 is their
[0:27:55] breakpoint. They can't go above that $100 per ton from their profitability
[0:28:05] and financial standpoint. Alright, throw the monkey wrench into the
[0:28:15] and on top of the tracks, but I thought that was very, I thought that you needed to hear that.
[0:28:20] Thank you, Travis. Great landing.
[0:28:24] Well, Travis, thank you. I think I understood that that was going to be the case that I didn't expect it to be doing anything else very soon.
[0:28:36] But I also felt like it gave us some time, maybe, to find alternatives, find different programs, and others with ladies last week that gave up.
[0:28:47] a very complete program that we, you know, we could certainly need to take a look at all
[0:28:53] options here. But this was the bias of time in my mind, and to find other alternatives in
[0:29:02] case it's not coming down, including what I mentioned, trying to work with other cities.
[0:29:06] I know Boise Valley, Treasure Valley is grappling with the, almost all the larger cities in
[0:29:12] and so they're looking at ways to get, as a cooperation going, those cities to get their
[0:29:19] level down below the .05, so they can still begin shipping the chain or else might take
[0:29:27] it at that level.
[0:29:28] So I understand what you're saying, Travis, but I also think this buys us some time with
[0:29:34] that completely, because we don't know whether April is going to be a change.
[0:29:39] and other countries may be able to start taking more and so the price will come down.
[0:29:45] I'll have to say thank you for the information. Ruth Pierce.
[0:29:50] Well, last week the citizens spoke loud and clearer in my mind. First of all, things don't
[0:30:03] happen overnight and if we expect a big coalition of communities or businesses or whatever to
[0:30:11] try to flip that. I can't see it happening. Personally, I hate to see. I
[0:30:17] dislike to see the hundred dollars with, we're gonna go to the landfill, we're
[0:30:24] gonna go to the landfill, we're gonna go to the landfill, and I think we just
[0:30:31] need to listen to our citizens. They want recycling and they're willing to pay for it.
[0:30:35] Ruth, Chris, read a quick questions. As far as, as long as China is not going to be
[0:30:47] Are we going to be seeing any decrease at all?
[0:30:52] Are we just going to continue to see that increase?
[0:30:57] Good evening Mr. Mayor and members of the Council. To answer that question
[0:31:01] the products are being sold to other countries right now.
[0:31:05] Basically like we discussed last week, a lot of the product right now is going to relate countries like this.
[0:31:11] Nothing's really going through China. They're buying about 20% of what they used to buy.
[0:31:17] we discussed they were buying about 60% of the world's recycling material now they're
[0:31:22] 20% of what they are taking some but they're taking at a very low cost when
[0:31:28] it's sold to other countries and China's paying not paying them so that being said
[0:31:34] I think until the infrastructure changes and there's other markets forward I think
[0:31:38] the price kind of holds here for a little while but there are obviously
[0:31:42] China's going to need that material eventually like that so there are
[0:31:49] opportunities it's just when is it going to happen so when I'm hearing it's
[0:31:55] right now or in the process of setting a new standard for a no-ear-mount, that's
[0:31:59] what I know what it is, whether it's going to continue to go up, but at some point
[0:32:02] time it will normalize and we'll start seeing that. Yes, actually all the analysts, of course they're just
[0:32:08] predicting the future, but they are saying that the price will not only normalize
[0:32:13] but start to improve given time, but it's just going to take time for those new
[0:32:17] markets to materialize and then start creating those products. Okay, so the second
[0:32:21] The question goes to Travis what you were saying, um, currently at $100 a ton, everything's
[0:32:30] going to go to the landfill, earning as soon as this happens.
[0:32:34] The $100 a ton is that going to be paying, compensating for the amount going to the landfill,
[0:32:41] or is this excess funds that we're going to be spending on recycling, even though it's
[0:32:45] going to the landfill.
[0:32:46] I'm not certain I understand your question.
[0:32:51] Could you repeat it one more time?
[0:32:54] The work we've just increased $100 a ton to recycle, but over $100, which we're currently
[0:33:03] at, it's going to be going to the landfill.
[0:33:06] So we're not getting the benefit of that increase.
[0:33:11] Though with all those funds going to the landfill, is this extra hundred, these extra funds
[0:33:19] that we're going to be paying for, is that to offset going to the landfill, or are we
[0:33:23] just throwing this money away because it's going to the landfill?
[0:33:27] Does that make sense?
[0:33:29] So, I think that it's been illustrated that if you remove the cost equation, we've been
[0:33:39] able to divert hundreds of tons from going into the landfill.
[0:33:48] And each ton that we divert on the city side, based upon the current contract, there's
[0:33:53] a savings of about $37 per ton.
[0:34:00] Now what we're looking at doing is we're looking at increasing that rate and we would
[0:34:04] be sending more of that stream, in fact all of that stream, to the landfill rather than
[0:34:10] diverting it, and so a significant portion would, some portion of that is going to go
[0:34:19] to cover the increased tipping fees that we're going to see because the volumes that we're
[0:34:24] of sending to the landfill will be increasing.
[0:34:28] What portion of the 42 cents that it equates to be
[0:34:33] Bill might be able to share what that would be.
[0:34:37] I know that when we had taken a look last week
[0:34:39] and we had shared with the council
[0:34:42] that if we were to suspend under option one,
[0:34:47] there would be about a 40 cent savings,
[0:34:49] I believe, to the citizens.
[0:34:51] And that did account for that increased tipping fee.
[0:34:59] So does that make sense?
[0:35:01] So they have one more time for them.
[0:35:03] Option one last week, which was not
[0:35:08] the one that was supported by the community members
[0:35:10] that came and spoke, would have decreased the bill
[0:35:15] to our residential customers that participated single stream
[0:35:19] by 40 cents a month in comparison to its current cost.
[0:35:24] And that cost that we would have assessed
[0:35:28] would have covered the increased tipping fees
[0:35:31] that we would have seen from canceling the recycling program.
[0:35:35] Question for you.
[0:35:36] So option one, no longer recycling.
[0:35:40] Everything's going, which ultimately we will see
[0:35:42] as soon as if we approve this.
[0:35:45] Everything's going to go there.
[0:35:46] Their bill would have decreased by 40 cents.
[0:35:49] That's what we communicated last week, guys.
[0:35:51] So now, we're saying that it's 53 cents a month.
[0:35:56] We're gonna charge more, even though if this passes,
[0:36:01] 53 cents more, and we're still gonna send everything.
[0:36:04] So there's a 90 cents in there.
[0:36:06] Where is that gonna go?
[0:36:09] So, and functionally, what would happen to it
[0:36:20] is we are going to increase the rates,
[0:36:22] we're going to collect the money,
[0:36:24] we wouldn't be spending it,
[0:36:25] and it would increase our cash reserve position.
[0:36:28] So, let's just take this month, but say this month is over the hundred bucks a ton, so
[0:36:36] there's not going to be a $136 a ton charge from anybody, because we're not sending it
[0:36:41] to recycling.
[0:36:42] But there's going to be a $37.50 per ton charge increase at the landfill, the increased
[0:36:53] So out of that increased rate, we would pay a landfill fee and a difference into reserves
[0:37:04] because this month there's no recycling expense because we're not recycling anything.
[0:37:10] But if next month it's $95 a ton to recycle, then everything goes to recycling and costs $95 a ton.
[0:37:21] Can that what come out of those fees?
[0:37:24] So, one of the things that the council could do, just trying to help you through it because I recognize that I created the situation.
[0:37:33] I appreciate you creating that situation.
[0:37:37] But the situation comes from conversations that have been had.
[0:37:42] So, one of the things that the council can do, and I'll look at Fritz for just clarification, is that the council can adopt the rate resolution.
[0:37:54] but it could delay its effective date until the price dropped to a certain threshold per
[0:38:05] ton. It doesn't have to have an immediate effective date today. So it would cause a delayed
[0:38:14] effective date and so when that was beginning to come down, staff could, there would be a
[0:38:22] trigger that staff could move forward and we could implement the rate and and then
[0:38:30] take the recycling material to the recycling facilities. So don't we have
[0:38:41] a contractual obligation with yes I for cost sharing that wouldn't be accommodated by
[0:38:47] not implementing a rate. So the cost share is only on the recycled goods if
[0:38:55] If you're not recycling the goods, there's no need for a cost share, is that correct, Jeff?
[0:39:01] Well, technically, yes.
[0:39:05] Main, obviously, the cost share is for the recycling.
[0:39:08] However, obviously, our expense is still out there for picking up material and that kind of stuff.
[0:39:13] So, the equipment's still in place.
[0:39:15] The drivers would still run their house the same way as they have been, so,
[0:39:19] there would be no reduction on the cost of providing the service, but there would be savings on the cost share.
[0:39:28] But wouldn't we still be paying our normal recycling fee to you for a month or to cover those costs?
[0:39:34] Okay, Suzanne, how it comes?
[0:39:37] I'm kind of following along the line of Christopher Reed down there.
[0:39:43] When I started thinking after what we decided last week, it does not make sense to me to kind of
[0:39:49] collect extra funds that are going to go into our reserves funds. I know the citizens
[0:39:56] really have a heart for recycling but even with passing this rate increase we're not recycling
[0:40:03] and it doesn't look like we're going to be and I kind of feel like this is a knee jerk reaction
[0:40:09] and I don't want to see PSI stuck with this and I'm almost thinking that we were better off looking
[0:40:16] at option one for the remainder of this year instead of doing a midterm increase and then really taking
[0:40:23] a hard look at recycling when we come around to our budgeting, knowing that the prices are
[0:40:30] going up still and not coming down.
[0:40:33] I think we are maybe leading people to believe that we're offering a service we're not offering
[0:40:40] and I'm almost afraid we're making it more confusing instead of less confusing.
[0:40:45] So I'm going to have a really hard time increasing the rate, knowing that the recycling is going
[0:40:51] to the landfill, at least in the near future, and I would like to see us somehow salivatry
[0:40:57] cycling, but I don't think this is the right way to go about it.
[0:41:03] Well, if I might just say something because I dif, I'm not sure I followed the conversation
[0:41:10] between Councilman Reed and Travis.
[0:41:14] If we take the material to the landfill, our costs go up 40 cents per ton per account.
[0:41:21] If we take it to recycling under this rate resolution, they go up 53.5 cents a ton.
[0:41:29] That's not a 90 cent swing, it's a 13.5 cent swing.
[0:41:33] It's not a rate reduction.
[0:41:36] It's not a rate reduction.
[0:41:38] It's not a rate reduction.
[0:41:39] 40 cents, if it goes all to the landfill, it's a 40 cent decrease.
[0:41:44] It's a 40 cent decrease.
[0:41:45] The 40 cents cost at the level.
[0:41:47] It's 10 cents, different between recycling, whether it's going to the landfill or whether
[0:41:51] or whether it's being recycled.
[0:41:53] That's correct.
[0:41:53] Okay.
[0:41:54] Unless we're gonna take that 40 cents per account per ton
[0:41:58] from some other source, it would have to be a rate increase.
[0:42:02] No, that was not able to take to the budget.
[0:42:06] And the other, just to clarify,
[0:42:09] I'm not advocating just making sure the conversation is
[0:42:14] following along with how we got here.
[0:42:19] The purpose of that choice of a dollar amount per ton
[0:42:23] to call our breakpoint, both for BSI and for the city,
[0:42:28] was to allow for a more rapid response to a market change.
[0:42:34] If the first part of April, we find out it's $95 a ton.
[0:42:39] Those trucks won't go to the transfer station.
[0:42:41] They will immediately go to Magic Valley recycling.
[0:42:45] Without that, that rate change could happen in one month.
[0:42:51] And we'd be taking it all to the transfer station
[0:42:54] by the time we did anything with it,
[0:42:57] the price might have gone back up
[0:42:58] and we would have missed that opportunity.
[0:43:00] So the option about having some flexibility
[0:43:04] and where the truck goes and being able to respond
[0:43:07] with city management and PSI's consultation
[0:43:11] was to give us a better response time to market shifts.
[0:43:17] That's the reason that conversation took place.
[0:43:22] Great landing.
[0:43:23] Well, I think there's another reason I mentioned it earlier.
[0:43:27] I think we get out of the recycling business entirely
[0:43:31] for six months, eight months, whatever it may take for it
[0:43:34] to come down, then I think we're going to have a hard time
[0:43:36] getting back to the times that we've had.
[0:43:38] I mean, maybe I'm wrong, maybe people will come back
[0:43:41] immediately and they start doing it, but I don't believe
[0:43:44] it would, and then like I said at the very first meeting,
[0:43:48] I got the idea from last, the last that might be
[0:43:53] with the news program, I watched them in the preliminary.
[0:43:56] I got to fill in some of the cities.
[0:43:58] They were concerned that they were going to go
[0:44:01] with landfill either way.
[0:44:02] And so that's the reason they chose to suspend it,
[0:44:04] which is a little bit down Suzanne's argument.
[0:44:06] But I would like to be able to be ready.
[0:44:08] And we take one, I also like Travis's suggestion
[0:44:12] that we delay the increase until the amount comes back down
[0:44:18] where we need to cost here.
[0:44:20] And I think I got it not under first that that was kosher, except that that was based on the notion that it was a free market.
[0:44:30] Well, it doesn't accommodate the increased energy that we're going through.
[0:44:34] No. Okay. That was all the...
[0:44:40] It's very complex, but I think for us, either and pro-recycling to say that this is the ultimate status, both the free market value,
[0:44:53] free market value or markets. That's disingenuous at the best, but by some time, that's exactly what the bill has allowed us to do with this option too.
[0:45:06] I'm more comfortable with it than I am any other number one or number three.
[0:45:12] And I think when it changes, it could be either so disastrous that we have no choice or it's going to be a fairly decent surprise,
[0:45:21] But we can't tell the future on recycling.
[0:45:26] I'd rather take my chance running across a great way
[0:45:29] to survive than thinking that the recycling program is a safe one one way or the other.
[0:45:37] Let's adopt a resolution by some time.
[0:45:41] Is that how it is?
[0:45:44] I wish we had to spread sheet with last week's numbers again.
[0:45:48] Because I don't remember discussing a 40 cent increase for dumping it last week for whatever reason.
[0:45:55] We discussed that there would be a tonnage increase to what we were taking to the landfill to accommodate what had been being recycled.
[0:46:09] Thank you. I just wanted to look at those numbers again and refresh them real quick.
[0:46:13] So, I would argue as well that the difference between 40 cents and 53 cents or another six
[0:46:35] months to try to gauge the market or stand what might happen is a relatively small difference
[0:46:46] to be able to be responsive if and when it changes and at the same time I think it buys
[0:46:51] us the time through the budgeting process for the coming year to determine what we think
[0:46:56] The market's going to look like a mixture and make some decisions about recycling as a whole.
[0:47:01] My other concern with just suspending completely, even though with certain extent we kind of are,
[0:47:10] it does get us out of the habit of recycling.
[0:47:14] I think that's going to be a more difficult ship to turn later than just flipping the switch of where you're taking the stuff.
[0:47:24] So, I think it gives us some time as we talked about last week for some improved education
[0:47:29] on what we can in cam recycle, try to get that stream cleaned up, take a little time.
[0:47:35] It's a relatively small investment to buy that time for a few months.
[0:47:40] Great landing.
[0:47:41] I'd like to move that we adopt Resolution 2018-4 to increase the recycling.
[0:47:52] our sanitation rate by 53 cents to institute the program that we discussed last week with
[0:48:00] a hundred dollar breakpoint motion by a great landing second by Chris talking
[0:48:09] 10 to adapt resolution 2018-4 Christopher Reed I just like to thank for the thank
[0:48:16] everyone for the clarification I was under the impression that there was a
[0:48:19] reverse on the 40 cents and so no matter what there's gonna be an increase it
[0:48:24] Just depends on the, or he sends her 53 and a half cents.
[0:48:28] So thank you for that clarification.
[0:48:32] Rick Lanting did you have another comment?
[0:48:34] Sorry.
[0:48:35] There any further discussion on the resolution?
[0:48:40] And Sharon, roll call vote, please.
[0:48:45] Chris Stockington.
[0:48:46] Yes.
[0:48:47] Rick Lanting.
[0:48:48] Yes.
[0:48:49] Christopher Reed.
[0:48:50] Yes.
[0:48:50] Ruth Pierce.
[0:48:51] Yes.
[0:48:52] Suzanne Hawkins.
[0:48:53] Yes.
[0:48:54] Nicki Boyd.
[0:48:55] Yes.
[0:48:56] Don Berger.
[0:48:57] Yes.
[0:48:58] passes 7 to 0. Thank you Bill. Thank you Jeff. Thank you. Next on the agenda is
[0:49:12] discussion and possible action to adopt the City of Twin Falls 2030 strategic
[0:49:17] plan update Travis Rothweiler City Manager. Mr. Mayor, Mr. Council, thank you
[0:49:40] tonight for the opportunity to showcase the City's strategic plan. This will kind
[0:49:46] if you take team event between Mr. Kushan and members of our team, and I'll certainly add
[0:49:54] in, and I kind of want to talk about how we got to this place today, kind of scroll through
[0:50:01] the strategic plan. We know that you've gone through this process a few different times
[0:50:07] already, so we want to then take some opportunity to maybe answer any questions that you have
[0:50:12] kind of moving forward. So the strategic plan has been very much one of the focal points
[0:50:19] of the city manager's office for the last year. In fact, it was about a year ago and we
[0:50:24] kicked this off and started having those initial conversations. Over the course of the summer
[0:50:29] months, we had a series of stakeholder interviews, which were one-on-one conversations. We had
[0:50:36] Conversations with the governing boards and the leadership boards of the partnering institutions,
[0:50:44] whether they be government entities for profit corporations, non-profit entities.
[0:50:51] We had the opportunity to engage in conversations at the high schools with members of our community.
[0:50:59] We accepted written, comment into this process, we accepted email, we received phone calls.
[0:51:06] In total, we had about 250, 230 unique conversations, and sometimes, like often happens in Twin Falls, people serve on more than one board.
[0:51:20] And so, sometimes people got to participate at least twice, depending upon the role that they serve within our community.
[0:51:31] As Phil had shared in his past report to you,
[0:51:37] one of the first questions that we asked was to make sure
[0:51:40] that the focus areas were still valid
[0:51:42] and the focal points of where we're trying to achieve
[0:51:46] in 2030 still mattered to our citizens.
[0:51:49] One of the things that we found through this process
[0:51:51] is a vast majority of those said yes, that is,
[0:51:55] that is the pathway that we would like for you to take
[0:51:58] and that is how we would envision our community
[0:52:01] moving forward. And so that really then took us into exploring the different goals and the
[0:52:06] initiatives and the objectives that are outlined. We presented the series of goals and the initiatives
[0:52:14] and we then went into small working groups about a month ago. And we spent time in those
[0:52:21] small working groups with partners and leaders and members of our management team, our core
[0:52:28] leadership team, our long-term planning team, and we also had significant partner
[0:52:33] institutions from outside of our organization participating in that process.
[0:52:39] We then spent some time internally really working through the process as
[0:52:46] you'll recall, the strategic plan that was shared with you at that report out was
[0:52:53] right around 69 pages, we were able to remove 30 pages worth of redundancy, really
[0:53:01] in large part of spending a lot of time in a conference room, really making sure
[0:53:06] that it was succinct and it was clear. We also invited all of our members of the
[0:53:13] team who had participated in the process to form their comments. So this process
[0:53:18] has really been under an intensive review since we last left it. One of the things that
[0:53:27] we spent a lot of time taking a look at is to remember there were a lot of ones. And one
[0:53:32] of the things that we challenged our teams could we accomplish everything that we had
[0:53:39] set forward. And so you'll notice that some of those ones shifted to twos. One of the
[0:53:45] things that we are going to be doing different in subsequent years and that is
[0:53:49] in the second meeting of January every year we're going to be reporting out on
[0:53:53] the accomplishments of the City Strategic Plan. That is going to be something that
[0:53:56] we kick off as a part of this process and so you will go through that budget and
[0:54:02] as we fund those initiatives for the school year 19 when we're working in the
[0:54:07] budget in about January we'll be able to come back and give you a full
[0:54:12] accounting of what we were able to accomplish in 18 as we kick off for the fiscal year 20 budget.
[0:54:18] So you'll understand what we completed. You'll always understand what we're budgeting and then
[0:54:23] we'll be able to forecast how we plan on moving forward. Also one of the things that we spent a
[0:54:31] lot of time with is incorporating the library into the learning community section. You will see that
[0:54:38] that was one of the new objectives that we had listed in there under the goals,
[0:54:43] and it really I think highlights the strength of the library that in the last
[0:54:47] strategic plan we were remissed and over the course of the last few years we
[0:54:52] really built our relationship with the board and Tara oversees the library
[0:54:57] operations and they're really becoming more of a connected member of our
[0:55:02] organization than detached and you'll see really some of the great partnerships
[0:55:06] that are being built and constructed in this area.
[0:55:12] One of the areas that I think that I'm going to jump down very quickly too is under the
[0:55:21] area of a prosperous community.
[0:55:31] And this is probably, if you're, when I was asked, what is probably one of the most significant
[0:55:37] changes in our local area, I'll share mine that I'll also ask the field to maybe share
[0:55:41] is, is really the state of our economy.
[0:55:44] When you take a look at the environment in which we were constructing this plan, it was
[0:55:49] an errand which we were still trying to crawl out of the recession.
[0:55:54] Our unemployment rate was high.
[0:55:57] And now we have great growth opportunities through economic development.
[0:56:03] Our economy remains strong.
[0:56:05] In fact, our unemployment is at full employment and most of our partners in all sectors talk
[0:56:13] about the need for talent attraction. This is really a new section in our area that
[0:56:19] has been talked about in the community especially in 2006-2007 when the economy
[0:56:26] was equally as strong. This really does create a roadmap to help us really guide
[0:56:32] and move forward with a full-fledged economic development plan. It talks about
[0:56:36] you know looking at housing options which is one of those critical choices
[0:56:40] of looking and creating a workforce development plan that was
[0:56:44] attracted to talent and working in a leadership capacity to ensure that we
[0:56:49] have the right skill sets with individuals to be able to work in the
[0:56:56] roles and positions that we're actively recruiting in our community. I think that
[0:57:03] when you take a look whether it be the physical infrastructure, the capital, the
[0:57:08] marketing of the community through a plan, the workforce development piece is absolutely critical as we move forward.
[0:57:15] The prosperous community section is probably one of those areas that went underneath the single largest change, I think, that we saw.
[0:57:24] Thank you, Trevor. I think that's a good summary because I think we didn't talk much about this in 2012 and 13 because it wasn't an issue.
[0:57:34] Certainly workforce development was not even mentioned.
[0:57:39] Another thing that I was surprised by was the extent of the broad-based opinion on the availability and affordability of housing.
[0:57:49] And how that makes into your capability of attracting new employment, because you don't have any place for people to live in an affordable situation.
[0:57:59] I think those things are clearly a redefinition, I think, a major piece of your activities.
[0:58:07] I think the other thing that I think there's maybe highlights, but I think you'll find this through other parts of the plan,
[0:58:14] is much of what we see here is going to call for a different skill base that you might have had in the past.
[0:58:22] Because most of what you can do, you can direct things happen because people work for you.
[0:58:29] A bunch of what's here is going to depend upon developing partnerships and encouraging
[0:58:34] people to share your vision and encouraging them to kind of light up outside and how to
[0:58:40] support that dialogue and make that a success to.
[0:58:44] That's a different kind of skill set I think that traditionally you might have had before.
[0:58:51] I think there's some things here that might suggest that things are going to work a little
[0:58:57] bit differently than that has.
[0:59:00] But I think, really, this has been a broad-based effort.
[0:59:05] You're involved, it's been greatly appreciated, the number of people who showed up to discuss
[0:59:12] these issues with me were presently in the number, but their level of preparation was
[0:59:20] almost astounding.
[0:59:22] and they came to say something and they had something to say and so obviously people care about this community
[0:59:29] and will need to spend their time and energy and I think that suggests that they have a significant interest in the outcomes
[0:59:38] so again as we did this the last time you didn't want a document that was going to draw a dust on the shelf
[0:59:45] This is another one I think is that theory and I think the level of interest in the community will make sure that it doesn't
[0:59:53] you know the shelf and when I see from the staff would rather than go on I think if you have questions about any of this be happy to respond.
[1:00:06] Council Member Boyd did find out a typo will fix that and she let me just look a little further and I found another one just like it.
[1:00:16] So, we will fix those things for the final publication.
[1:00:21] We'll do that.
[1:00:23] Chris Stockton.
[1:00:27] Phil, I think when we were holding the workshop, you related something that might be interested
[1:00:33] to the public.
[1:00:35] We've had what I would think was a very small number of people and 230 or 50, but your
[1:00:43] work and other places even Boise showed that actually our representation by the general
[1:00:49] by the general public was disproportionately high.
[1:00:53] Am I exaggerating that or did I remember that kind of
[1:00:56] context with us?
[1:00:57] Your Honor, Councilman, you're remembering that accurately.
[1:01:01] I think 250 people out of 50,000 is not a big number.
[1:01:07] But in terms of statistical analysis,
[1:01:12] it's not a statistically valid survey for sure.
[1:01:16] But in the city of Boise, does their semi-annual survey of community attitudes, they survey about 860 people, 126,000.
[1:01:30] And so that, I think, suggests that this number is not inconsequential.
[1:01:38] I think, clearly, it's an opportunity for people who care to stand up and present their views.
[1:01:48] Frankly, as a council, you didn't even have to ask these people.
[1:01:52] You could have done this all by yourself, back to the past, that way used to work.
[1:01:58] But clearly, you've invited people in to talk to you and we've managed that process for you.
[1:02:05] So I think this does represent a legitimate sample, not a statistically valid one, but a legitimate one.
[1:02:13] And I think it's up to the individuals, say I'm here holding the election certificate, just exactly what way they want to apply to the input that's been given to you.
[1:02:26] Because you're ultimately the ones that are responsible for this.
[1:02:29] And you are the ones who have allowed yourself to be influenced by people's opinions.
[1:02:33] And so, you get to decide the way that you...
[1:02:39] I'd like to say thank you to everybody who worked on this.
[1:02:43] And when I read this final draft, I was really...
[1:02:47] It's like our next level.
[1:02:50] We just keep building on a very strong foundation.
[1:02:54] And I feel like we continue to create a culture that provides
[1:02:58] an environment where people really want to live and work and raise families and retire.
[1:03:04] And the other thing I noticed in this is how,
[1:03:08] consistently in the different areas, it was not just the focus of what we need to do as a city,
[1:03:15] but how we link our citizens to opportunities for them.
[1:03:19] And I thought that was rather profound.
[1:03:26] Thank you.
[1:03:27] Let me get in the weeds a little bit more.
[1:03:31] So as you said earlier, we did break up into small working groups.
[1:03:36] So until we saw this document Wednesday, we had not seen the whole thing put together.
[1:03:44] So going through it, a couple of things that caught my attention under Focaseria, she also
[1:03:53] shared the whole thing.
[1:03:55] Prosperous Community on page 26. The very last objective there. The city will
[1:04:05] host a multi-event sporting contest that demands stamina. That seems out of place
[1:04:13] of what government should be doing to me. I can see us supporting or aligning with
[1:04:19] somebody who wants to host an event, but for us to actually put on such an event
[1:04:23] I wasn't in that working group, so I'm not sure what the thought process was and where
[1:04:34] that came from.
[1:04:35] So I was, I have some ideas.
[1:04:38] I wasn't in the working group either.
[1:04:41] I can, I believe that that is referring to bringing in some sort of larger, maybe a branded
[1:04:49] draft on a branded cycling event.
[1:04:53] Oftentimes, when you look at the Ironman event in Court of Wayne as an example, there is a financial commitment made not only by the city but also partners to secure that event and to help move that forward.
[1:05:09] And so that might be how they're using the term host, but again, when they reported out as part of that group,
[1:05:17] do you remember those, in fact, Nathan was the one who had shared that it was part of a trying to bring and utilize the natural assets that we have here?
[1:05:28] You might have also known my passion for a certain type of sport that you plugged in there.
[1:05:35] It just seemed pretty, you know, the demand, stamina, everything seems pretty specific and I guess personally I'd be more comfortable with will help or will a support then will host.
[1:05:47] It just, it seems a little bit of a stretch to what I think we should be doing as government officers.
[1:05:56] And then this is probably might not my lack of knowledge, but on page 36
[1:06:04] under the internal organization
[1:06:07] 2.2 I do not know what MBTI stands for and I'm wondering if maybe that needs to be spelled up for others besides myself
[1:06:17] We can do that. So that's Myers Briggs type indicator. Thank you
[1:06:31] But maybe a better term could be used, but we kind of, in essence, even though we don't
[1:06:38] operate it, what do we refer to with all the support we give to, like, say, the Western
[1:06:44] Days Parade, where we pay a tremendous amount of overtime to officers and things to, as a
[1:06:51] parader out, things like that, we're actually hosting it, where we certainly have funding
[1:06:56] involved in it in some manner.
[1:06:58] So I guess that was my thought process that I don't care about what the wordy means, but we may be involved in
[1:07:07] the situation if we build it would be beneficial for the city to do so.
[1:07:13] I think we kind of do the same thing if the state amateur has helped the golf course
[1:07:20] it would be way of the greased fees.
[1:07:22] Yeah, and I'm all in support of that. I just don't think it should be our job to be the lead host or to take the helm on it.
[1:07:29] I think to come alongside and allow use of our resources, our facilities is wonderful, but it's just like with the trail having
[1:07:37] MAFTEC take the lead on those things and then we support them. That's great
[1:07:40] I just the way it was written and I don't think we should be putting city staff and time in that lead position
[1:07:54] I read the host as a city would host as we would be a location
[1:08:01] and so I was on the Parks and Rec and of it, and so that falls under Parks and Recreation,
[1:08:09] but it wasn't in our healthy community focus group, this came up in prosperous, and we've
[1:08:16] certainly talked about these kinds of things in Parks and Rec, and what were the heart
[1:08:21] of the intent on these things is to showcase what we have here, and to get more people
[1:08:28] to enjoy it, and come and use it, and participate in it.
[1:08:32] And so when I read the host, I just, I didn't read it as we were,
[1:08:38] so heavily participating in it, other than our new facility
[1:08:44] and our downtown.
[1:08:46] It would be a great event, and it would bring a lot of people to showcase our town.
[1:08:52] We can, I think that we understand.
[1:08:54] I think everybody is saying the same thing.
[1:08:57] What we can do is we can work on the word host, we can change that, it's easy.
[1:09:02] Because there's certainly, you know, lots of other words that allow us to get to the same end,
[1:09:09] that still allow us to have the opportunity inside of the community,
[1:09:13] the opportunity to provoke twin falls to the rest of the world.
[1:09:19] Just a couple of observations, I...
[1:09:22] There seem to be some objectives that are routine.
[1:09:28] I'll call out the one that Councilman Reid put out earlier to run background checks on coaches for our store activities and to sort of routine standard operating procedure as opposed to some visionary objective that we're going to shoot for.
[1:09:48] Maybe that's a poor example, but even reading through some of the public safety things, it's so they feel routine.
[1:10:00] And some of them are going to, what's important to recognize is that we also use this as a driving tool for our budgets.
[1:10:07] And when the long-term planning group is looking to find that connection between the strategic plan and awarding a financial allocation,
[1:10:17] in the past document, one of the things that they found was it wasn't clearly spelled out in some cases.
[1:10:23] And so while you will see things that are under the ongoing category, one of the things
[1:10:28] that we find is we spend significant resources in those areas and we wanted to have a very
[1:10:33] clear and direct connection to the strategic plan in the city's budget.
[1:10:37] And so when you look at a particular background checks, we're under the understanding that there's
[1:10:43] going to be a change in that process and we're going to be looking at some additional software
[1:10:48] possibilities for that, and so is there trying to build a financial connection onto that, it's
[1:10:53] already built into the strategic plan with the ultimate end goal of making sure that youth
[1:11:00] participants are safe from predators.
[1:11:06] So perhaps it's, again, a little wordsmithing to use, for example, works like enhance or
[1:11:12] improve or expand that it's not just do.
[1:11:17] I understand the rationale of having it in the document as it does drive the budgeting process.
[1:11:23] What I want to make sure we don't do is slip back to the old strategic plans,
[1:11:27] which was, here's my list of other things I want to accomplish next year,
[1:11:31] because I have to do my job and that that becomes the vision.
[1:11:34] That's not what this document is supposed to be.
[1:11:37] Comments?
[1:11:41] Mrs. Stockington.
[1:11:44] I think a little different fee with the strategic plan than some of my fellow council people.
[1:11:50] If we go through here, there's not one strategic plan that is going to meet all of our needs, wants, and satisfactions.
[1:11:59] I think we need to look at this as the background community participation, the council, and the staff refining these down to a manageable document.
[1:12:11] It is going to draw our budget for the next 12 years.
[1:12:15] I'm not worried about those specific things that we're holding, muscle man competition or whatever I look at the major points as actually facilitating a much easier budgetary process for the council if we follow the general guidelines and we can still modify, reject, or even older some of the points of the strategic plan.
[1:12:40] This is not a document cast and stone.
[1:12:44] I think we need to move on to pass the thing.
[1:12:47] Hey, there are other input comments.
[1:12:50] We adopt the final draft of the strategic plan as presented this evening.
[1:13:09] Second.
[1:13:10] I'm sorry.
[1:13:12] You're seconding, Chris?
[1:13:13] Not Ruth.
[1:13:14] Okay.
[1:13:15] Motion by Nikki Boyes.
[1:13:16] Seconded by Ruth Pierce to adopt the City of Twin Falls 2030 Strategic Plan update.
[1:13:22] Is there any further discussion?
[1:13:24] Seeing none, chair and roll call vote, please.
[1:13:28] Greg Vanting.
[1:13:38] Yes.
[1:13:39] Christopher Reed.
[1:13:40] Yes.
[1:13:42] Chris Pierce.
[1:13:43] Yes.
[1:13:44] Zann Hawkins.
[1:13:45] Yes.
[1:13:46] Nicki Boyd.
[1:13:47] Yes.
[1:13:48] Don Berger.
[1:13:49] Yes.
[1:13:50] Chris Hockington.
[1:13:51] Yes.
[1:13:52] Motion passes 7-0.
[1:13:53] Bill, thank you for your assistance with shepherding all of the kittens on that plan over the last
[1:14:03] many months. Next on the agenda is another opportunity for general public input if
[1:14:12] there's anyone here wishing to address the council on an item that was not on
[1:14:16] that agenda this evening. As your chance to come forward Mr. Edwards would
[1:14:30] please state your name and whether you are a property owner or resident in the
[1:14:34] city of Twin Falls is the green light on the microphone. That's in the middle there
[1:14:43] is a question now. Thank you Terry Edwards resident Twin Falls and council
[1:14:53] folks, I've set through a number of these workshops and trainings for this thing that
[1:15:01] you just approved and as an update and a lot of the information that was presented
[1:15:07] was directed to telling us how many people were involved and how many people had
[1:15:13] input, how many agencies were involved in this. The thing was that I was at several
[1:15:19] of these, and there was just a handful of people, and I think, originally, that was true when
[1:15:25] it was first promoted, and promoted to the degree where all the board members and people
[1:15:32] that have a vested interest came out, supported the planning process, well that planning process
[1:15:39] was what, ten years ago, eight years ago, things have changed a lot, and the only thing
[1:15:44] I saw was to re-value that and I don't see any changes that I've heard at the workshops
[1:15:51] or in the group planning over here and for the board to get this a week before the meeting.
[1:15:58] It doesn't make sense to me that you guys have had adequate time to review this.
[1:16:04] I was there, I saw what was going on and people have made a couple of comments and you guys jumped around.
[1:16:10] some of you were there, some of you weren't at those. There was two back-to-back, back in August or July,
[1:16:16] and there was really no input. And if you seek input from the public,
[1:16:25] strongly as you did when they first promoted this thing 10 years ago or
[1:16:32] whenever the first one was done, then I could say that you've got an accurate
[1:16:36] representation, even tonight, they were mentioning the fact that we needed to put in some new
[1:16:43] stuff. Well, that new stuff wasn't even introduced by the people that were at these meetings. It
[1:16:50] was in an enterprise introduced by this group here that were doing the planning. So, ten
[1:16:57] years ago, things were a lot different economic-wise, and that's why they inserted this deal about
[1:17:03] the economics, which is valid, but did anybody say, oh yeah, I agree with that.
[1:17:10] How much impact the city infrastructure is that going to bring, you know, bring business,
[1:17:16] great, that's good, let's have the business, but how is that going to impact the common
[1:17:22] citizen and cost of doing business here with increased taxes, property taxes and all that
[1:17:29] was that reviewed.
[1:17:30] It's for tree head plans are good. It's good to have a plan. And I agree with that, but this thing is what 66 pages long?
[1:17:38] My God, you guys got to narrow it down so people can understand what they're actually 37. That was the point. Well, it's drawn down to be a smaller size this evening, but okay, well, this brought down.
[1:17:49] That's a good thing, but I'm just suggesting that you guys need to pay more attention to these meetings that the public
[1:17:56] close to promote those more to get them out and I understand it's like
[1:18:00] Valenti you can promote all you want you're not gonna get them there but the
[1:18:04] original meeting was I mean you guys almost had a parade downtown to get
[1:18:09] people to be involved in that because they saw that they were gonna get something
[1:18:13] and when you offer freebies people are gonna come this was just a work session
[1:18:18] these sessions are people don't like to sit through that kind of thing and listen
[1:18:23] listen to people hash back and forth, what they think is maybe significant to them.
[1:18:31] Another thing I might mention is I didn't see a real good review of what we've got now.
[1:18:37] I haven't seen it online.
[1:18:39] It wasn't available to me.
[1:18:41] There was one incident that I asked one of the representatives at this meeting from the
[1:18:46] police department and I asked him, I said, why are we getting crime reports?
[1:18:52] reports and he says well we want to be transparent we're going to do that do
[1:18:56] this well I understand is the crime reports that we get here in Twin Falls
[1:19:01] it's not the same one that the Idaho State Police utilized so he said he's a
[1:19:09] group A crimes or group B crimes and we're going to change that I think all
[1:19:15] crimes ought to be reported he wanted to narrow it down just as severe crimes
[1:19:18] And I said, well, listen, he said, like, murder.
[1:19:22] I said, well, isn't rape a severe crime?
[1:19:25] Wouldn't that be on the list?
[1:19:26] I don't see it listed anywhere in any of our publications
[1:19:29] or the police department, all that.
[1:19:32] And he said, well, we're working on that.
[1:19:34] Well, I don't see it.
[1:19:35] I didn't see it up here.
[1:19:39] Thank you for your input.
[1:19:40] So the document was part of the agenda packet, correct,
[1:19:46] this week.
[1:19:47] OK, well, that's not adequate time as a week.
[1:19:50] You said you didn't have a chance to see the document and I'm trying to tell you where it was.
[1:19:55] So I appreciate your input.
[1:19:58] I actually appreciate that you did participate in many of the activities that we had over the course of the last several months that we were working on this, more so than many citizens in the community.
[1:20:09] So thank you for being a part of that.
[1:20:11] Anyone else who wishes to address the council this evening?
[1:20:16] We have any advisory reports from the council?
[1:20:21] So, yes, it's not, it's not advisory, but I do have a request for the council to consider
[1:20:33] our son to her kicks off April 13th through the 29th. This is the eighth year that somewhere between
[1:20:40] 90 and 120 or 30 artists local in the community area are involved with showing the right of the
[1:20:48] I've been approached by Art Oak, who's been the anchor for the city to participate.
[1:20:55] It's a one-time cost to the city of $125, and it would allow the showing of the art presented
[1:21:06] of the Art Center to be hung in our entrance hall.
[1:21:10] I'm not sure if we've done it in the past, but I certainly think it's worthwhile endeavor
[1:21:17] to push local artists to show the pavilion that we have,
[1:21:24] so citizen-friendly, we also can review the art and choose some
[1:21:30] that we think are more appropriate for a municipality.
[1:21:33] I'm asking for a request for us to spend 125 to engage the art
[1:21:39] to be our son to her in the city of all this year.
[1:21:42] Art, Art and Soul, I think it's called, Art and Soul, if I'm possible.
[1:21:51] Motion that you're asking to spend some money.
[1:21:55] Let's hope in y'all these don't carry away somebody else and make the motion that I'll
[1:21:58] so move, I would so move the expenditure of $125 to participate in our son to her this
[1:22:06] year.
[1:22:10] Motion by Chris Dagnan saying that by great landing to my sponsorship for the Art and
[1:22:15] Solve the Magic Valley event. Is there any discussion? I would say I do think this is
[1:22:23] an opportunity for us to continue to assist to look for ways to activate the downtown space
[1:22:29] and perhaps something that Nate could think about in the future for his budgeting. Look
[1:22:35] at opportunities like this. Turn it over, I'll call it a little, please.
[1:22:41] Christopher Reed?
[1:22:42] Yes.
[1:22:43] Rose Pierce?
[1:22:44] Yes.
[1:22:45] Is Anne Hawkins?
[1:22:46] Yes.
[1:22:47] Nicky Boyd?
[1:22:48] Yes.
[1:22:49] on Baraker, Ristalkington, Reg Lanting.
[1:22:55] Yes, I think it's 7-0.
[1:22:58] Can I have us anything from the City Manager's Office?
[1:23:04] All right, we do have a public hearing scheduled.
[1:23:09] This is a request for a zoning district change and zoning map amendment
[1:23:15] from C1PUD to R6 and C1PDA
[1:23:20] to allow a multifamily residential and commercial plan development for 12.46 plus four minus acres located at the northeast corner of Addison Avenue East and carriage lane north, also known as 2695 Addison Avenue East.
[1:23:37] And we have Scott Allen with GUB engineers on behalf of Thad Farnham. Welcome, Mr. Allen.
[1:23:48] Thank you, Mayor.
[1:23:50] I'm guessing that Jonathan's getting everything called up here,
[1:23:52] so you can have some pretty pictures to assist your presentation.
[1:23:56] Mayor and Council, my name is Scott Allen, which I UB engineers.
[1:24:13] I am here tonight representing the landowner, as well as for the development team.
[1:24:19] That is that part of the mixer from the Mr. Billy Company.
[1:24:23] The property question here is the etched area here,
[1:24:28] the dash line around it. This is about 12 and a half acres. It was originally part of the
[1:24:35] Cedar Park PUD agreement and master plan. Fortunately, when we looked at the master plan,
[1:24:42] it showed a big box of use on this property and our intent is a little bit different than that.
[1:24:47] So with meetings with city staff, they directed us to do a ZDA and go ahead and rezone this into
[1:24:54] in the zones in which allow for the uses that we're requesting.
[1:24:59] Properties that's surrounded at the uses on the south side of Madison Avenue.
[1:25:05] There's Mary out of uses there.
[1:25:07] We have everything from vacant land to storage facilities,
[1:25:11] farmers markets, rental companies, et cetera.
[1:25:14] About the south west corner is the St. Luke's facility.
[1:25:18] Directly west of our property is also part of the Cedar Park
[1:25:23] is vacant land not farmed north of that, in very delayed apartments, excuse me to the
[1:25:35] north of, directly north of our property, there's a religious facility that's far
[1:25:40] far, and a special overlay zone, and then to the east of that is an R4 area which is
[1:25:46] currently vacant in thought east rank culture at this time. Directly east of us is farmland,
[1:25:52] that's still part of the Cedar Park element, and that's undeveloped as well.
[1:25:56] But this is the ZDA master plan that was submitted.
[1:26:12] It ignores seven acres.
[1:26:15] We are proposing that this be utilized for four plexes.
[1:26:19] Eight plexes.
[1:26:21] There will also be a top lock to come off with that.
[1:26:24] Dog walking part which will be fenced in along with a clubhouse.
[1:26:29] That will be under one ownership.
[1:26:31] One locked.
[1:26:32] That will be multiple buildings on one lock.
[1:26:35] In the south of that, this will remain in C1.
[1:26:40] the ZDA designation. This will be on individual plots. This master plan shows
[1:26:46] four lots here. Repad sites and then on the east side, the southeast side there.
[1:26:51] There's also a bridge facility that has shown this master plan. Dealeen with the
[1:26:58] original PUD and looking at the allowances for access as we allowed one
[1:27:03] access onto Addison which is a joint use access.
[1:27:09] In other words, it's an easement granted for that, along with utilities from both the east
[1:27:13] and west of our property line on the east side that runs full length of this, which can be utilized
[1:27:18] for utilities for the adjacent properties as well.
[1:27:21] A carriage line would be restricted to two accesses and third points into the property.
[1:27:27] One common access for Jonathan Hesses is Persirad, which would also serve the access to the commercial
[1:27:33] and also second access to the housing authority or housing district, not housing
[1:27:38] 30, but housing project and then the northern access on carriage would be
[1:27:42] where the pointer is there for the housing development as well.
[1:27:47] ZDA, we're not asking for a lot of concessions with this.
[1:27:51] If we can pull that up, we'll go through those.
[1:27:56] On the R6 zone, which is the housing development area,
[1:28:00] the clubhouse is a special use permit.
[1:28:04] We're asking for a clubhouse to be an outright permitted use.
[1:28:07] of house will be utilized to be a common area inside,
[1:28:12] a work out area as long as well as an area
[1:28:16] for meldaliberty.
[1:28:17] So we'll have one centralized location
[1:28:19] for the meldalic community.
[1:28:22] Under the C1 zone, which is a commercial zone in the south,
[1:28:25] we're asking the storage room and units
[1:28:26] be an outright permitted use on that normally
[1:28:29] to see one it comes true as a special use.
[1:28:34] As we move down to the property development standards,
[1:28:38] Normally, we're allowed one structure per lot,
[1:28:42] since the residential portion is going to be
[1:28:45] under one ownership.
[1:28:46] We're asking that multiple four plexes, eight plexes,
[1:28:50] and a singular clubhouse be permitted on a singular plot.
[1:28:55] In discussions with staff, they had concerns
[1:28:57] about privacy for the residential to the north.
[1:29:00] It could be developed along with the religious facility
[1:29:05] that exists.
[1:29:06] And so we have placed a condition within the ZDA
[1:29:09] with a six foot high, side obscuring fins,
[1:29:12] be located along the North property line,
[1:29:14] we agreed to staff on that.
[1:29:17] Since there's no setback requirements along carriage lane,
[1:29:21] city also asks for 20 foot wide landscape strip there,
[1:29:24] kind of as a beautification item,
[1:29:26] as you're driving down carriage off Addison,
[1:29:29] we also have agreed to that condition
[1:29:31] in place of Dandlessy.
[1:29:33] In the C1 zone, we wanted to go ahead
[1:29:36] and call out the shared driveway approach on Addison.
[1:29:38] is very important, this project as well as the project
[1:29:41] to the east of us, and so we call that out
[1:29:44] as an outright permitted use, but it's only restricted
[1:29:47] to one access on to Addison.
[1:29:51] Once again, the 20 foot wide landscape buffer zone
[1:29:54] within the commercial property or commercial zone land
[1:29:57] is also included along here until late.
[1:30:00] The landscape is not shown in the ZDA
[1:30:02] and this landscape along Addison, since it's a gateway
[1:30:05] arterial will be required to have the 35 foot strip
[1:30:08] that's an actual code requirement.
[1:30:12] Item three, that normally, there's normally
[1:30:16] between residential and commercial, a 25 foot buffer area
[1:30:20] or setback area, since we control the residential portion
[1:30:24] and the commercial portion on this,
[1:30:25] we want to reduce that down to 15 feet.
[1:30:28] And the only place that this occurs on this plan
[1:30:31] is in the northeast corner of the commercial box.
[1:30:36] So it's where, it's right in that area there
[1:30:43] where we have a four plex that abuts a storage unit.
[1:30:48] That normally would be a 25 foot setback.
[1:30:50] We're asking on the commercial side
[1:30:52] that from the back of the storage unit
[1:30:54] to the property line, it would only be 15 feet.
[1:30:56] So we're also providing additional landscaping
[1:30:59] north of that in the residential area.
[1:31:05] Under the project phasing on this,
[1:31:07] our main goal right now is to get
[1:31:11] the entitlement process is done,
[1:31:13] the construction plans for the residential portion done
[1:31:16] and move forward on the residential portion
[1:31:17] as possible. The commercial portion of it will be platted, it will all be platted at one time,
[1:31:22] but the commercial will also be held in escrow until the demand for that commercial use is there.
[1:31:27] So what we've done on the project phasing is basically once all the entitlement work is done,
[1:31:33] the project plans are completed and approved.
[1:31:37] The initial construction of the residential portion began in 2018-2019,
[1:31:42] that's basically an overview of the ZDA in the middle of the semester.
[1:31:50] But stay in for questions.
[1:31:54] Any questions for Mr. Allen?
[1:31:57] I do not see any.
[1:31:58] Thank you.
[1:32:01] Thank you.
[1:32:02] We'll have Jonathan Stone, but give us our staff report.
[1:32:05] I have one document open and it goes to this one.
[1:32:29] I'm not going to, I don't need to contradict or change anything from what Alan talked about,
[1:32:34] talked about, really, the potential impacts, so what I'm going to talk about, we've got currently
[1:32:39] a C1 zone property under a PUD, they want to remove that PUD base anew element agreement,
[1:32:45] what we call a CD. The northern portion will follow our sixth standard with our current
[1:32:50] code, and the southern portion will follow the C1 code standard in our current code. The
[1:32:55] exceptions he talked about are the only things he's asking to deviate from our current zoning
[1:33:00] The four plex is a little bit of a weird deal.
[1:33:05] The C1 zoning code requires four units, or five units per building.
[1:33:08] He wants to do some four plexes, and so that's really the only reason he's asking.
[1:33:12] That's R6 standard, so he can do four plexes, which are permitted land use types.
[1:33:18] It's basically a permitted type of building in that zone.
[1:33:22] It also creates a nice buffer between the commercial, all in Addison,
[1:33:26] with the residential to the north.
[1:33:27] It actually works pretty well for a mix of types of uses
[1:33:30] of uses in that transition. The impact really is the number of units in that area who don't
[1:33:38] anticipate any large impact for that. Anything that's different than what's currently there.
[1:33:44] Most of those residents are going to go downcarriage to Addison. The arterial, that's where most
[1:33:49] of the people would thrive, require most of the lighting to be downward facing. There's
[1:33:54] very similar uses to the north from those apartment complexes that are there anyway. So, it's
[1:34:01] really the largest potential impact is the increase in traffic, which we think will put down to
[1:34:05] Addison and we believe that since large enough with the light, it's already there to accommodate that
[1:34:11] kind of traffic. There were a couple conditions that we placed on it or that let me get to the
[1:34:19] piece for the people that are watching on February 13th, the Planning and Zoning Commission held a
[1:34:25] hearing, the conclusion of the hearing, a commission for deposit recommendation with five conditions by
[1:34:32] We've added a sixth between the P&Z hearing and the meeting tonight.
[1:34:37] It came to light that there's an irrigation issue and I'm reading this paragraph right here.
[1:34:43] From irrigation water, staff in proposed condition replaced on approval,
[1:34:49] requires a separate agreement for working out the irrigation water issue.
[1:34:53] Terms of set agreement to be accepted by the city and share a priority building permit on the site.
[1:34:58] Typically we deal with irrigation water at the preliminary plant stage.
[1:35:03] Basically, what the code says is that they don't have the water and we can't approve
[1:35:08] this document as they feel like they may have a different way of accomplishing that single.
[1:35:14] So we wanted to deal with it on the CDA end, or if they don't have the actual water of the
[1:35:19] city engineer, could potentially intern to a separate agreement, I guess is that that agreement
[1:35:25] would have to come before this body to review it. Troy Vitek is the one that can answer the
[1:35:30] question if that's when you have the conditions and as I as they were written
[1:35:36] are here number one subject to site plan amendments as required by building
[1:35:41] engineering and fire zone officials to comply with applicable city codes and
[1:35:46] standards number two subject to recorded final plan prior to development or three
[1:35:51] subject all outside lighting being downward facing which shall not approach
[1:35:55] on its running properties number four subject to no temporary or off-site
[1:35:58] rental units or pods being utilized or stored on the property that's for the
[1:36:03] storage unit area. Number five subject to outside storage allowed with the
[1:36:09] storage and development site. Number six is the newly crafted one subject to
[1:36:13] city engineer consideration of reduction in the David Waters share of
[1:36:18] required and city code and 1242 only through a separate agreement between
[1:36:25] city and developer with accompanying documents detailing how the reduction
[1:36:29] is to occur adherence requirements by subsequent owners,
[1:36:32] and the other technical or administrative items relevant
[1:36:35] to successful performance of a reduced water demand
[1:36:37] irrigation system.
[1:36:39] Written by the city engineer, I placed it into the document.
[1:36:45] We will leave through conversations with Scott
[1:36:47] that the watersheds have, that issues kind of been resolved,
[1:36:51] but hasn't been finalized.
[1:36:53] So we believe that the shares probably are going to be
[1:36:56] with it with the plant.
[1:36:57] This is really just an in case item.
[1:37:00] go through it a different way.
[1:37:02] So that, and for questions,
[1:37:08] questions for Ken or Troy.
[1:37:16] Jonathan, with that, we will open the public hearing
[1:37:22] for public input.
[1:37:24] I don't have to sign in sheets,
[1:37:25] so as if there's anyone who would like to speak
[1:37:27] on this issue, please come forward.
[1:37:30] They turn name, whether you are a property owner
[1:37:34] or resident of the city of Twin Falls for the record.
[1:37:37] My name's Gary Nelson.
[1:37:48] I am a property owner.
[1:37:52] actually three different sides or part of a group of property owners that surround this property.
[1:37:57] We have been working for some time now with the owners and developers of this property
[1:38:04] working through various issues. We're here to speak in favor of this development.
[1:38:10] It will be a great addition to the area. This property has been something that would develop far before now,
[1:38:19] I think there was an eight-year recession that kind of got in the way and now that our economy is going again, I think it's the right time for a project like this, and I think it's a great location.
[1:38:30] One issue that we have spoken with the property owners and there's about is the area that they're talking about putting the storage units, the wall that would go around.
[1:38:46] that as we are property owners immediately to the east of this, we anticipate our other
[1:38:55] frontage being commercial as well with the property owners about having access coming
[1:39:05] off of Addison and possibility of having cross-use from one side of the property to the other.
[1:39:14] There's a little bit of a height differential between the elevation of Addison and this
[1:39:19] property that the property is a little lower than the Addison Avenue's elevation.
[1:39:24] This is quite important and beneficial to the both property owners if good access going back and forth between the properties and the
[1:39:39] edge may be relocating some of those storage units in a different part of it so that we don't end up with big walls
[1:39:49] and one that would keep us from having cross-use between the properties.
[1:39:54] We just wanted to go on record of that discussion is taking place
[1:40:01] and owners have been receptive to our thoughts,
[1:40:09] and wanted to have that be part of our record.
[1:40:13] Thank you. Anyone else who wishes to speak?
[1:40:19] Something my name is Jane George,
[1:40:32] and I am here also to speak in favor of the use
[1:40:36] has a neighbor and representing other neighbors in the entire Cedar Park project, which to date has primarily been
[1:40:46] residential.
[1:40:47] Through most of the
[1:40:51] preliminary work toward this plan, we were in close touch with that
[1:40:57] Arnhem and we want to think the team were working with us in a cooperative
[1:41:03] even a successful approach.
[1:41:08] I have and several of the residential neighbors
[1:41:11] have expressed some resistance to the storage facility
[1:41:16] being on the E.S. in frontage.
[1:41:19] So I am in opposition to that part of the plan.
[1:41:24] And in particular, we would want to attempt
[1:41:29] to preserve the ability to have a more open,
[1:41:34] cross-seasement for egress and ingress, and even for parking on the commercial.
[1:41:38] I'd like to point as an example to the commercial project that I had worked on years ago that
[1:41:47] ended up being three developments that are contiguous and are situated at the southeast
[1:41:54] corner, Falls Avenue East, and Blue Lakes Boulevard North, and this is the center where
[1:41:59] First Federal occupies the immediate corner, and just south of First Federal was a building
[1:42:05] that originally had been constructed for the Chamber of Commerce, and then at this point
[1:42:11] in time the Goodwill building and joins fabric and several other retail establishments in
[1:42:17] that strip.
[1:42:18] That is a good example in our community of important commercial frontage that does not
[1:42:27] function very well because there are three different developments there that do not have
[1:42:34] cross-parking and ingress egress agreements and so use of that center really there's several
[1:42:41] bottlenecks there and if you've I assume most everyone in the community has used that but this
[1:42:46] is what occurs when there aren't considerations to crossing um he cross easements for parking
[1:42:56] and in press, in press, we anticipate working with a Fed Tharnum's group to maybe
[1:43:03] consider small duration to that part of this plan, but we do, I personally, in several of the neighbors
[1:43:13] who ask me to speak for them, object in particular to the wall at the southern end of the storage facilities.
[1:43:22] It doesn't appear in my mind to be in keeping with the spirit of the gateway ordinance.
[1:43:31] It's been many years ago that I worked on that committee.
[1:43:36] I personally wrote the wording for that ordinance and it may be somewhat dated, but we need to take another look at that.
[1:43:44] in that I don't feel that solid wall right along the front edge of Addison is maybe as attractive as some other way that that could be designed and with that I thank you for your time.
[1:43:58] Thank you. Anyone else who wishes to speak?
[1:44:04] Hello, Council. My name is Gretchen Scott. I'm a property owner in this area.
[1:44:15] and I really only had two comments that I wanted to make relative to the
[1:44:19] development. The first one is, some of you may know, carriage there is a very wide
[1:44:30] street and traffic is really fast. I've seen people pass both on the inside and
[1:44:38] the outside of cars that they think are going to slow and with a 25 foot
[1:44:46] bumper or buffer up against the carriage, similarly across the street at the carriage
[1:44:52] way apartments. There's lots of kids that play football, they're with the ball, ride their
[1:44:56] bikes, walk their dogs right along that area. And with the same amount of space on the other
[1:45:03] side, I see that same kind of fun activity happening, which is great. My only concern
[1:45:08] is about the speed and what we can do if anything to try to slow traffic down. I have a lot of
[1:45:15] face in our police department. I know that they're out there often, but these will be, this will impact
[1:45:24] cars on that road. A lot of people go down carriage to, I think it's stadium, to the elementary school,
[1:45:37] and this will also increase traffic through that area too. So I'm not necessarily opposed,
[1:45:43] I'm just a little concerned. We have a high volume of kids that are walking to pillar falls,
[1:45:49] We have a high point with people who walk that neighborhood because there's really nice street lighting as well as sidewalks.
[1:45:55] We also have a huge turnout at Halloween.
[1:45:59] Pretty sure about a third of the city counts.
[1:46:02] So I'm just concerned about the additional traffic that it will cause.
[1:46:06] And I just want to make sure that we're considering that as it moves forward.
[1:46:09] I don't have necessarily a solution because I'm not a planner.
[1:46:12] But thank you.
[1:46:14] Thank you.
[1:46:15] Anyone else who would like to speak on this issue?
[1:46:20] You can go and we will close the public input portion of the public hearing, and it's back
[1:46:29] to the opportunity to respond to any of the comments there.
[1:46:35] Thank you, Mr. Mayor.
[1:46:37] The water share situation, the job is brought up, and the condition they added to that report.
[1:46:43] We're in consent with all three of the, or all six of the items that they put in there.
[1:46:50] We have secured water shares in the form of the Twin Falls Canal Company has re-served
[1:46:57] the share per anchor for this property unfortunately years ago before the city had ordinances to
[1:47:04] retain water shares, utilize it for irrigation.
[1:47:07] When Cedar Park came in a lot of those shares were sold off.
[1:47:10] A portion of this ground out there not only are piece but also surrounding pieces.
[1:47:17] may be struggling to find the shares available to more or more their developments.
[1:47:22] I think that's the reason that this has been put in.
[1:47:25] There may be other mechanisms in place, different types of watery systems,
[1:47:30] or escape, et cetera, which could be beneficial to the situation for water shares,
[1:47:35] but we have secured and reserved the ship breaker for the site.
[1:47:40] We've discussed this storage unit issue with Gary prior to the meeting.
[1:47:46] meeting that is talked to a we're very receptive to that and in fact moving in
[1:47:51] here we think the storage units in this area are a very good use there's a lot
[1:47:56] of apartments in here not only the ones that are being proposed but the ones that
[1:48:01] exist I see two city councilmen here myself that live in this neighborhood
[1:48:05] within two blocks of each other and we drive courage along a lot as well and we
[1:48:10] know that use is a viable use for here to short commitment to the neighbors though
[1:48:16] So, we have requested this item under the ZDA to be an outright permitted use, we're happy
[1:48:22] to pull that out and come back through as a special use program.
[1:48:25] That way it gives the applicant as well as the adjacent property owners a chance to discuss
[1:48:30] this and if this layout massages, it massages a little bit.
[1:48:36] If you want to have that discussion, we can, or if you want to place out as a condition
[1:48:40] approval to make the story changes come through as a special use program.
[1:48:44] as far as Gretchen's comments is on carriage lane,
[1:48:50] several of us drive that road several times a week.
[1:48:54] Carriage is a collector's stream that ties into an arterial,
[1:48:57] which is Addison.
[1:48:59] As carriage develops with these vacant lots,
[1:49:02] the road does get tremendously wider.
[1:49:05] Right now there's just a center stripe on it,
[1:49:07] so it really doesn't direct traffic to a center tour main.
[1:49:10] It directs it to two very wide travel lanes.
[1:49:13] I think as the city progresses and all of these properties get developed, I do believe the city street department will go on there properly stripes this.
[1:49:22] I think that will eliminate a lot of the speeding, the passing that takes place.
[1:49:27] And really people are, you know, when you have 25 to 30 feet of lane width, where do you drive it up?
[1:49:33] I think that will all be eliminated over time. Once this road gets, you know, a strike in its entirety.
[1:49:39] That's my ring.
[1:49:41] Thank you Mr. Allen. Questions for Scott?
[1:49:47] I've done a question for you.
[1:49:54] This motion of modification to have storage and as we have special use as opposed to a
[1:50:02] limited use from a staff perspective.
[1:50:09] So it's just part of their original.
[1:50:12] The C1 zone requires it to be specially used normally under our code.
[1:50:16] Only inside I can give the same people that were notified of this,
[1:50:21] this will be notified of that. They were notified of this item and knew the
[1:50:29] neighbors if there were an issue. The other part is they can make some minor
[1:50:35] modifications to the site plan that you see without coming back through for a
[1:50:39] CDA so that cross-use could be accomplished without a special use permit.
[1:50:42] There's a few criteria that can't change on a master plan like this.
[1:50:48] Modifying cross-use area, I'm not sure, is one that would come back for another,
[1:50:55] like another public hearing, it would just be something we could do at a staff level.
[1:50:59] I'm not sure there's any more information code-wise I could give you.
[1:51:13] I'm the keyboard. Yes, Jonathan, this.
[1:51:22] They still massage, as they call this, where the...
[1:51:27] Yeah, there's six criteria. You can't change
[1:51:31] increasing density, changing the use of the boundary, which
[1:51:35] would be changing the use. They would just be modifying where they're accessing.
[1:51:39] Don't believe a cross-use access between commercial properties is something that would require
[1:51:44] Anything to come back there could be some massaging of where that cross-use is right now
[1:51:50] Where my cursor is is the joint access on Addison?
[1:51:54] This is the access they've given themselves showing here. We don't know what this is going to develop as I
[1:52:00] Think this conversation is different if they had a plan for we're gonna develop X and our access is clear up here
[1:52:07] I don't have that. The only thing I do have is another road over here. I remember it's
[1:52:16] Meadowview. It has to be built down to Addison as well. So it's not like this property will
[1:52:23] have another road like Carriage is on the side. They'll have another road over here to
[1:52:27] access as well. But the only kind of additional I can give you is they'll be on a corner, similar
[1:52:35] looking to this.
[1:52:36] So I just want to, I know we need to adopt or adapt this motion a little bit, but if we go ahead with this, it looks like the parties are interested in to continue to work on this. I don't want to stop that if that's what they want to do.
[1:52:54] Yeah, it can certainly be changed a bit. There's some things that can't change. I don't believe that's one of them.
[1:53:02] Is there a comment?
[1:53:03] There was comment about having the storage along Addison isn't really the heart of what we wanted for our gateway arterials,
[1:53:17] but evidently this must meet all city code and be okay. It's just personal choice or can you kind of work through that a little bit?
[1:53:25] or Addison Avenue is a gateway and we call it a gateway arterial, that's why down here
[1:53:29] this green area landscaping has to be 35 feet deep on Addison. There is a
[1:53:35] gray change as well how that plays out with how the finish grade on the site
[1:53:40] works. I can't tell you because I have a construction plan but this area will
[1:53:44] have a certain number of trees and bushes with a depth of 35 feet.
[1:53:48] Thank you.
[1:53:51] Good questions for Jonathan.
[1:53:57] Two questions, I don't know if they're for Jonathan, they might be for the developer.
[1:54:06] Is there an on-site and Jerry's there a person that lives in one of those units?
[1:54:12] That's for the second question.
[1:54:14] Second question is, they talked about having cars parked under a building.
[1:54:20] Now they're in front of the buildings, but I want to know how many parking places per unit is it to?
[1:54:26] They would be required to have two, yes, per city code.
[1:54:29] Master has told me that there is no on-site manager. There is covered part of buildings.
[1:54:44] A couple of thoughts, one on Pefley in favor of this, is...
[1:55:05] I should I respond to as George's...
[1:55:12] Her comment about the, uh, cross-use thing, hopefully, that they...
[1:55:19] They should get together and work that out, because the fact of where she's talking about...
[1:55:24] I don't know if the statistics are still there, but where she was talking about,
[1:55:27] the way there is and the cross-use, and you can kinda work your way around if you try.
[1:55:32] I think that development may be a cause that where we have another our curi-ground, or there's
[1:55:39] never gonna develop like blue like ziz, which I doubt, but it certainly could be some, uh,
[1:55:46] also, Mrs. Scott's concerns about traffic, um, er, I don't get out there a lot, but I was
[1:55:57] out there a lot during the campaign, not gonna buy a car, but I'm not gonna buy a car.
[1:56:02] Gary, I don't get out there a lot, but I was out there a lot during the campaign, knocking on doors,
[1:56:07] and they had the office van, and we thought about going to Addison the Leaf, the area, I always went down.
[1:56:13] North on Carrey just to get to Filer, or you can't get all into Falls, but you get to Filer and go out that way.
[1:56:19] And so I'm not sure I believe that all the traffic, the majority of the traffic, is going to go to Addison.
[1:56:27] I think there's going to be some kind of carrey, but my plan there would be...
[1:56:32] Baffecomming measures to slow down the traffic hunt on carriage, bull bounce,
[1:56:39] nightlands, speed limits, those kinds of things will be hard.
[1:56:43] Would actually encourage people to go to
[1:56:48] Addison, but that'll be down the road as traffic becomes the issue.
[1:56:52] I move that we grant the request for a zoning district change and zoning map amendment from
[1:57:17] C1PD to R6 and C1 ZDA to allow a multi-family residential and commercial plan development
[1:57:24] for 12.46 acres plus or minus located on the northeast corner of Addison Avenue East
[1:57:30] in Kerry-Shelene North. This is 2695 Addison Avenue East, Cara Scott-Ellen, JUB Engineers
[1:57:37] on behalf of the FEDFARNAM application, 2924, as presented with all six recommendations.
[1:57:47] We're not going to have a note here to take the storage units, and they can come through
[1:58:01] as a special use, but it's more about the cross-use parking that we need to adapt, right?
[1:58:06] No? Okay. Then, as presented and with the six recommendations.
[1:58:16] Second. Second. Motion by Nikki Boyd, seconded by Kristoff, and to approve the request as presented with the planning and zoning staff recommendations, but not changing the special use, correct?
[1:58:31] and not changing the storage units to the machines, so as presented.
[1:58:37] Yes, okay.
[1:58:40] Their discussion, great lighting.
[1:58:42] Where I'd like to offer an amendment that would, if you could scroll down to Jonathan,
[1:58:47] we're going to talk about the, um, the word that's part of the best he used for me
[1:58:54] and the permitted use of the, I would like to remove item number N1,
[1:59:06] One, B, in other words, that would be, that would drop it back.
[1:59:13] I don't want to discuss it until I have a second, sorry.
[1:59:15] Okay.
[1:59:18] Emotion by piglanting to remove storage, rental units as they permitted use from the...
[1:59:24] I'll second it so we can discuss it.
[1:59:28] We'll discuss my motion.
[1:59:32] Alright, piglanting.
[1:59:33] The reason I'm doing this is I have just got referred to the fact that there have been
[1:59:37] multiple to this slight restriction of what they have proposed that would allow also by
[1:59:45] removing that it drops it back to the underlying code that says that it's a
[1:59:49] special use for it and so it still allows them to have them they just have to go
[1:59:54] to the special use for it to get them that would encourage them to me to work
[1:59:59] on the agreement on the cross-use as well as making sure that the neighbors
[2:00:04] are everything works with the way they have what they're planning so that
[2:00:08] of the surrounding neighbor's property can be developed in a way that we can do safe
[2:00:17] the wall involved.
[2:00:18] Another discussion. I too would be supportive of removing that. I think it just gives another
[2:00:30] level of opportunity for the neighbors to work together and to ensure that that e-way
[2:00:37] is on the east end of town, mesh as well. I don't trust that the developer is going
[2:00:43] to do a nice development out there, but I think it was mentioned by folks who spoke tonight,
[2:00:50] and I certainly would support that in that mystery.
[2:00:56] Understanding what everybody said tonight, I think it wasn't the issue of having the rental
[2:01:03] storage rental units.
[2:01:04] It was a placement cross-use land, how to get in and out, and so that's why I wouldn't
[2:01:09] be in favor of this, realizing that there can be some massaging, there can be some changes
[2:01:14] that made, not feeling that the rental units were an issue, just location and how you get
[2:01:20] around in that area, so that's why we're voting out for the amendment in the other discussion.
[2:01:55] to work with the neighbors so possibly we have a second look at it.
[2:02:00] Any further discussion? Yes, Chris Talkington.
[2:02:08] I'll just say that one of the main reasons for the request for the CDOA is the ZDA
[2:02:14] was in fact to allow the storage units as a permitted use.
[2:02:18] So I'll be voting against that last amendment in the other discussion.
[2:02:26] We'll be voting on the amendment, which is to remove original units as a permitted use.
[2:02:34] Share it in all column please.
[2:02:49] Is it in Hawkins?
[2:02:50] Yes, Nicky Boyd?
[2:02:52] No, Don Berwicker?
[2:02:57] Yes.
[2:02:58] Chris Hockington?
[2:02:59] No.
[2:03:00] Rick Lanting?
[2:03:01] Yes.
[2:03:02] Christopher Reed?
[2:03:04] No.
[2:03:05] Ruth Pierce?
[2:03:06] No.
[2:03:07] Motion fails, three, two, four.
[2:03:11] Oh, back to the original motion,
[2:03:15] which is to approve the request as presented
[2:03:18] with the conditions of the planning
[2:03:19] and zoning commission and staff
[2:03:21] as any further discussion on that motion.
[2:03:26] Share in a roll call vote, please.
[2:03:34] It is three to four.
[2:03:41] Motion is not passed.
[2:03:43] Ruth Pears?
[2:03:45] Yes.
[2:03:46] Suzanne Hopkins?
[2:03:47] Yes.
[2:03:48] Nikki Boyd?
[2:03:49] Yes.
[2:03:50] Ann Berger?
[2:03:51] Yes.
[2:03:52] Chris Houghington?
[2:03:53] Yes.
[2:03:54] Yes.
[2:03:55] Motion passes.
[2:03:56] Seven to zero.
[2:03:57] And with that, that's everything.
[2:03:58] So, meeting is adjourned.
[2:03:59] And with that, that's everything, so meeting is adjourned.
