Oversight Archive: City Council meeting, 2018-06-11, recording 1 (started 17:00)
Machine transcript (faster-whisper base.en), not checked word for word; the Pledge of Allegiance is shown in its standard wording. The recording is the record.
Times are time into the recording. Passages with private details are muted in the audio and marked here.
The audio on the page below was re-encoded by software from the video the agency posted. Check any passage against
that audio before relying on it.
Page: https://oversightarchive.org/twin-falls-id/meetings/2018-06-11/

[0:00:00] Council for Monday June 11th confirm that we do have a quorum of the Council here
[0:00:04] six the seven members are present this evening the Council on that
[0:00:07] landing is not here with us tonight next on the agenda is the Pledge of Allegiance
[0:00:13] for those of you wishing to join us please rise there are no amendments this
[0:00:41] evening no proclamations so next on the agenda is an opportunity for general
[0:00:46] public input if there's anyone who wishes to address the Council major
[0:00:49] opportunity to please come forward please state your name or resident of the
[0:01:00] I want to say I'm going to make it real quick, one I wanted to thank tell you about your code
[0:01:26] enforcer.
[0:01:27] He did a really good job, there's a real bad problem for walkers, now on the 9th Avenue
[0:01:33] East, at 11 23, the head just completely overthrown the sidewalk and it sounds a bad
[0:01:39] in the summer, there's a quarter sidewalk left but in the snow time it's a wind break,
[0:01:43] piles up you can't walk on the sidewalk, the sidewalks there, it took him six months to
[0:01:48] get the code in force but he finally actually got that hit shot through and so
[0:01:54] there's two people female and a male I talked to the male and well the female
[0:01:58] also but I think he's did it so thank him please if you can second of all I see
[0:02:04] in the paper about this recycle stuff I don't know how you're gonna make the
[0:02:08] decision to what you do I didn't really understand the paper but I want you to
[0:02:14] know as a resident and as someone who anxiously recycles, I'm really not
[0:02:19] concerned about the cost, but I'm very much concerned about the aggregate of
[0:02:23] pollution. And I like what McDonald's did. They used to try to make their big Mac
[0:02:30] in a star foam cup. They thought it was good, but their recycling costs more than
[0:02:35] making the cup, and they concluded that it increased the aggregate pollution. So
[0:02:42] they switched it. As a resident, I care about the aggregate pollution. I think you do, too,
[0:02:48] because you don't recycle glass, you don't recycle metal cans. I think that you know
[0:02:54] it's more than just a cost factor. So if we can recycle plastic and lower the overall
[0:03:00] pollution, immediate air pollution, water pollution, ground pollution, if we lower the
[0:03:05] aggregate pollution, having favor of it. Even if it costs a little more money, on the other
[0:03:11] If recycling something just adds to the aggregate pollution, I'm not in favor of it.
[0:03:17] I would hope that I would come into play with your decision-making even though it's got to be pretty tough.
[0:03:23] Thank you very much.
[0:03:24] Thank you Mr. Barrett.
[0:03:25] So just so you know tonight, we're just receiving another update on what's going on with the recycling markets
[0:03:30] and we'll continue to monitor that as we figure out any changes we might make to the program.
[0:03:35] But I appreciate your input.
[0:03:36] So sitting here for your witness at first hand.
[0:03:44] Is there anyone else who wishes to address the council this evening?
[0:03:52] Seeing no one, we will move on to the consent calendar, Ruth Pierce.
[0:04:13] Second.
[0:04:14] Motion by Chris Reed, seconded by Ruth Pierce to approve the consent calendar.
[0:04:19] Is there any discussion?
[0:04:21] We're talking to the council.
[0:04:25] It's for long care about $4,700 this last month, and I don't know.
[0:04:32] I'm sure we've been contracting out in the summertime rather than using existing employees.
[0:04:39] Has it been successful?
[0:04:41] They do all the parks the greats way or they carry their own insurance.
[0:04:52] Do we do any checks on their quality three second or three?
[0:04:57] So most of the contracted labor falls into two categories.
[0:05:01] One is going to be into kind of a commentary of maintenance in which those are set up through a process.
[0:05:11] You'll live in one of those areas. You'll notice an enhanced charge on your utility bill,
[0:05:18] which is collected that covers those common area costs that may typically be.
[0:05:28] The second is, yes, we do go out and we inspect that. In fact, our pod to the advisory team
[0:05:40] over in the parks department, the contractors, they inspect their work and they also send
[0:05:45] them back deal type tasks as they go forward.
[0:05:55] question we do strictly on service we we actually make a request for proposals
[0:06:06] and individuals submit those to us for review all right so we have a motion a
[0:06:19] second to approve the consent calendar
[0:06:26] excuse me Suzanne Hawkins yes Nicky Boyd yes I'm Barakar yes
[0:06:33] Yes.
[0:06:34] Mr. Fareed.
[0:06:35] Yes.
[0:06:36] And Ruth Piers.
[0:06:37] Yes.
[0:06:38] She passes 6-0.
[0:06:39] And next on the agenda under items of consideration the first is a presentation of Roadmaster Level
[0:06:48] II certification to Tom Billman and we have Ian Littler who have Dean at all, right.
[0:06:57] Lance Smith with the Idaho Technology Transfer Center.
[0:07:00] Dean.
[0:07:01] I had to see your hat.
[0:07:03] On that Dean if you would like.
[0:07:06] members of council it's a pleasure to be with you tonight especially giving this
[0:07:12] presentation out just a little bit of background what the roadmaster is what
[0:07:16] it consists of we have two two levels of education in the T2 Center which is
[0:07:24] administered by the local highway technical assistance council or LTCH you
[0:07:27] probably know what's better but for the road master for the road scholar
[0:07:32] program, there's four e-credits that have to be taken in classes. Seven of those are
[0:07:39] required classes, based classes, and then a three can be electives the choice of the
[0:07:45] person taking them. So that gives them a level of how to put down asphalt, how to
[0:07:50] dig trenches, how to make sure that they don't sink. When they fill them back
[0:07:55] out, calculate aggregate, all those types of things. Essentially best
[0:08:00] management practices for your transportation system. So we applaud you for sending your
[0:08:07] road people to these classes so that you get the most bang for your buck. The Roadmaster
[0:08:12] Program is the second level of that which is another 40 credits. There's five required
[0:08:20] classes and five elective courses. So this is the second level that we're presenting tonight,
[0:08:31] Tom Billman is the one that's receiving that and we give Tom a plaque and we also
[0:08:37] for Roadmaster we get them a car hard jacket so they can do their job better in
[0:08:43] the winter time so keeps them nice and warm so we'd like to bring Tom up and
[0:08:48] mayor if you'd come down we'd like to get some pictures of you and we'll publish
[0:08:51] that in our newsletter hope to see you again soon with an
[0:09:30] Tom has such a fine-looking Jack I think you should work in the summer in the winter
[0:09:35] Alright, next on the agenda is a request to approve the Twin Falls Old Town Criterion.
[0:09:47] We have Ryan Howe, our Police Department, Sergeant, which presents the Old Town Criterion Special
[0:10:05] Event.
[0:10:06] This is a new event for this year, and I hope Bob Seastrum would be here.
[0:10:12] I have not seen him yet, so I'm hoping that I can answer every question that you have.
[0:10:18] We have some other people.
[0:10:22] The Old Town Criterion, what this event is, this is a race, the bicycle race to be held
[0:10:29] on Saturday, July 7th, and the races begin at 7 and, I'm sorry, begin at 10 a.m. and end at 7th.
[0:10:37] You're looking at having seven individual races with some space and time in between,
[0:10:43] but to do these races and to do them safely, we will need to close several of the roads
[0:10:48] where the races will be held, that will be main, and main will be closed.
[0:10:52] I know the second will be closed from Hanson to be closed from second to Maine and it's
[0:11:08] going to be second east and be closed in between those two streets as well as Hanson
[0:11:18] Street will be again seven individual races approximately 15 to 20 minutes apart and the
[0:11:26] race is taking 30 to 60 minutes.
[0:11:29] The reason that we want to close this, we actually have to put barricades up to keep both the spectators and the bicyclists safe in case there's a crash, it keeps them contained to pedestrians out of the racetrack.
[0:11:40] Roadwork ahead, course for us, we call transportation department.
[0:11:51] They have based on our city as the police department.
[0:11:58] This is a race that is sanctioned by the USA cycling and our hope is to continue to grow this year after year, make it a margin.
[0:12:08] the largest. It's the focus on downtown with this starting at two and goes until ten.
[0:12:20] There's going to be a new board ceremony, not just the races but some festivities afterwards.
[0:12:28] Thank you, Sergeant. Suzanne Hawkins.
[0:12:32] Thank you. Hi, this and...
[0:12:37] So one of the requests is that we had the realizer deal with the businesses and individuals,
[0:12:49] pedestrians to cross in the races. When it's safe, we're going to shut down the businesses completely
[0:13:01] This is completely and should actually bring more business to the downtown area down the
[0:13:14] south.
[0:13:17] Chris Stockington.
[0:13:18] I just wanted to start a shot with it.
[0:13:35] So the law enforcement is actually going to be funded by the police department and the
[0:13:40] law enforcement we are not going to be involved with the traffic.
[0:13:43] That is going to be something that is contracted, agers, that they are going to be the cost for
[0:13:56] that.
[0:13:57] I'm not sure where that's coming from.
[0:13:59] That's one of the reasons I was hoping that Mr. Seastrum would be here.
[0:14:02] So I believe that Travis has an answer for that.
[0:14:06] is covered by the event organizers and our primary purpose with the police
[0:14:10] department is just to ensure safety of the individuals who are going to be down
[0:14:15] there one large part to also going to serve as a primary escort to ensure that
[0:14:22] the riders on the course also remain safe as well.
[0:14:27] Repairs. Travis isn't that the same weekend as our commons ribbon cutting. So the ribbon cutting is actually the day before on the 6th.
[0:14:38] See the same note here. The ribbon cutting right now is scheduled for four o'clock.
[0:14:43] It will be the dedication of the comments.
[0:14:46] Nate Murray is working on those final details.
[0:14:49] We'll be getting in contact with the council, but it's going to be like a four o'clock on the sixth.
[0:14:54] That really does conclude all of the events of the sixth, and then on the seventh it is this bike race.
[0:15:01] And is the Cliff Bar Band is the prime for this project,
[0:15:10] and then there are lots of multiple smaller sponsorships
[0:15:16] that are being driven by members of our local business community.
[0:15:41] I'd like to invite Chris Reed to the first one,
[0:15:44] Paul's Town Criterium, as presented
[0:15:46] as their key for their discussion.
[0:15:49] I just want to say I think this is another fantastic place
[0:15:52] making activity to celebrate our newly renovated downtown
[0:15:56] and just in general a new and exciting event
[0:15:58] to serve both not only the citizens of Twin Falls but visitors to the community as well.
[0:16:03] Nicky Boyd, Jan Berger, Chris Talkington, Christopher Reed, Ruth Pierce, Suzanne Hawkins, yes.
[0:16:19] Motion passes 6-0. Thank you, Sergeant.
[0:16:21] The next on the agenda, speaking of downtown, as that main avenue redevelopment project updating Robinson.
[0:16:30] I presented similar information to the URA board members earlier today and it was a special
[0:16:45] on this with Dan Pursi's last day sitting as chairman of the URA.
[0:16:49] So, he didn't have to celebrate all the accomplishments that he and Avenue be in one of them.
[0:16:55] So, I did want to come before you and give some updates as to where this project stands.
[0:16:59] It's been a couple of months.
[0:17:01] As you may recall in December, we did a walk through and deemed the project substantially complete.
[0:17:06] And with a few items on that punch list, several of which we needed to wait until springtime to be able to come back in fish ups more and also observe conditions of some of the elements.
[0:17:18] So in May we did another walkthrough because in April the hanging flower baskets were placed, irrigation systems were worked on some more so we walked through and made to check out the project.
[0:17:31] Parks department also had a walkthrough, streets department also conducted a walkthrough.
[0:17:36] And as a result of the May walkthroughs, we have an updated punch list.
[0:17:40] There are a few items still to tend to, some of which are the hanging flower baskets.
[0:17:46] There were a few that weren't thriving, most likely because of the irrigation system.
[0:17:52] The drip system wasn't working properly. It's isolated in areas.
[0:17:56] So those are some of the items that the contractor Guho is addressing a couple more related to
[0:18:03] bulging down some trash cans, moving some chairs around.
[0:18:06] There is some asphalt work to do, some seals, patchwork.
[0:18:13] So the vast majority of those punchless items that remain will be completed this week with
[0:18:21] exception of the asphalt work.
[0:18:23] contractors getting together with the asphalt subcontractor to work out a schedule and getting those asphalt items addressed.
[0:18:29] Last time I was here I conveyed that there was a $390,000 deductive change order that was going to be processed, that has been processed.
[0:18:40] So that has been taken out of the overall contract value.
[0:18:44] Another highlight is that Jacobs contract, we have not utilized contract capacity of that.
[0:18:52] approximately $200,000 of contract capacity that has not been touched, and can be returned
[0:18:59] to the URA for other endeavors as well, so some savings there in this project.
[0:19:06] That's the status, at least in the next couple of weeks, anticipating all of the pungsten
[0:19:10] sidems will be addressed.
[0:19:11] We'll conduct a final walkthrough, confirm that everything has been addressed, and then
[0:19:16] step through that final close-up process with you.
[0:19:20] We are very close to having this thing completely wrapped up.
[0:19:35] I take the back, Chris doctors, about $1,000,
[0:19:38] all of those might need input from you,
[0:19:39] try to do it, because I'd have to be expanded
[0:19:44] on setting around here.
[0:20:03] It'll be returned to the agency to be used for other activities,
[0:20:07] other projects, so don't want won't be expanded.
[0:20:11] It'll be returned to the renewal agency,
[0:20:15] and then they see fit, it'll just be returned into their budget.
[0:20:23] So I might maybe add to that maybe provide a little bit of clarity.
[0:20:27] So it's a project that the council, not the council,
[0:20:31] Excuse me, Bill Agency awarded a sum of funds to, in process, the amount it was less than
[0:20:41] or was anticipated, and so those funds would revert back into their cash reserves, and then
[0:20:48] what Perrin is saying is that the agency would have the processes to apply those to a future
[0:20:56] project, whatever the hell the city is, is that not good?
[0:21:05] I just want to say thank you so much, Efnar downtown, for unsure at first, say that we
[0:21:14] have swayed them.
[0:21:15] Thank you. It's been a great project and there are a lot of other folks that have contributed to this and
[0:21:36] I want to just be here to be the one to receive the thanks.
[0:21:40] Thank you sir. Next on the agenda is a request to award the 2018 CHIP CL project to Emory Incorporated
[0:21:54] in the amount of $539,876.64. We have Jackie Fields, our City Engineer.
[0:22:02] So this is zone 6. Our seal coat program is a three-component program as you're well aware.
[0:22:30] We have chip, slurry, and fox heel that occurs.
[0:22:34] Typically we use chip seals on roads or absolute less leg.
[0:22:47] Doris Street is the fragile little road chip seal.
[0:22:58] So the first project that was led was the chip component first of two to three contracts.
[0:23:07] Emory bid on the euro was no different
[0:23:17] $9,876 and 64 cents that price to be
[0:23:23] Based on things the cost of rock and so on
[0:23:33] Staff is recommending the council authorize the mayor to sign the contract for gypsy project
[0:23:40] We have any questions about the job or next week. I'll be back with slurry
[0:23:46] Slurry bits were pretty competitive so that's nice on here somewhere falls
[0:24:39] incorporated in the thousand eight seventy six dollars and sixty four cents
[0:24:46] thank you for second to project as presented is there any further discussion
[0:24:56] seeing that burger yes Chris talking to yes Christopher Reed yes
[0:25:08] repairs yes is an Hawkins yes Nicky void
[0:25:12] yes
[0:25:14] six to zero
[0:25:15] agenda is an update on the current state of the recycling program and
[0:25:25] market in a discussion at the next stage of the small cart pilot program Bill Baxter
[0:25:32] and Hilly Services Supervisor.
[0:25:36] City Council. It's a pleasure to be in front of you again. I brought, I asked Jeff if you would join me to
[0:25:45] do the market situation questions on what the status of the market and recycling
[0:25:53] pro looks like. To begin however I would like to mention that we are attempting a
[0:26:00] new way to advertise the recycle program very nice and on to Facebook it took off
[0:26:11] around the last Friday. There was some confusion on both Facebook one and the
[0:26:19] city website version which both elicited responses but we had to go back
[0:26:27] because of the confusion it resulted in that being removed from Facebook. Josh this
[0:26:34] afternoon we cart sizes it's really very attractive very explanatory we just
[0:26:44] have to pin down what area of town qualified for people that might call
[0:26:48] So for May we had 150.7 tons of recycled material collected.
[0:26:57] That is on the low end of the last six or so years.
[0:27:01] But we anticipated some resistance to the whole idea that it's going to have some phone calls to say, I'm not into this.
[0:27:14] There has been some pushback that we'll let Jeff talk about the markets, but we're still waiting for some movement.
[0:27:27] movement status of recycling right honestly it hasn't changed in the last
[0:27:53] months since that time they're hundred percent
[0:29:04] reserves out of the way and change the market yes actually that's some good
[0:29:44] news it's just different types of plastic so you're rich it's plastic I
[0:29:58] think by percent but we're seeing pretty much it's been kind of late the
[0:31:09] ground where it's been interesting there has been in some cases things have gotten
[0:31:14] better as far as content.
[0:31:15] The source for some of their recycling in Salt Lake.
[0:31:32] I know they're sending glass down there and it's other things.
[0:31:43] And if it's working for Pokémon...
[0:32:23] Once it's on your drive, just take it straight to the recycling.
[0:32:25] Something in Salt Lake would be...
[0:32:30] Just when I hear those things in the news, it makes me wonder...
[0:32:34] I mean, there's there and...
[0:32:47] The price is still the same, whether it's the costs are or costs are all that.
[0:33:06] So that's really the price that everything else is pretty much...
[0:33:11] I hear those things that always makes me wonder if there's...
[0:33:17] maybe somehow something that we're just not seeing our citizens be able to...
[0:34:54] to use in the reduction, just had a couple of things
[0:35:11] because of the publicity regarding this
[0:35:17] and picking a point in you recycling
[0:35:23] on the phone with both and Walla Walla Washington
[0:35:27] who done search our populations
[0:35:31] and when we negotiated with our contractor
[0:35:34] how the council wrestled that issue.
[0:35:36] So I simply referred them to some of the documentation
[0:35:39] we used and the recorded meetings so they could hear.
[0:35:44] Thing is the points that were continued
[0:35:52] by the issue and it is why we're struggling.
[0:36:23] Next on the agenda, another opportunity for general public input.
[0:36:26] If there's anyone from the public who wishes to address the council,
[0:36:29] that's your opportunity to come forward.
[0:36:31] So you know when any advisory board reports from the council.
[0:37:12] Each vary and based on size, what amenities they had, says, going to be starting.
[0:37:24] And I just, so our people, BRS and Pivot North, will both house from as many people as possible.
[0:37:54] Again, that's in the over from six to eight,
[0:37:59] and house on a council.
[0:38:16] I have anything from the same entrance's office.
[0:38:18] During this evening, so the next items on the agenda
[0:38:27] is adjournment into executive session under Idaho Code 742061-A
[0:38:35] to consider hiring a public officer, employees,
[0:38:38] staff member or individual agent,
[0:38:39] wherein the respective qualities of individuals
[0:38:42] are evaluated to fill a particular vacancy or need,
[0:38:45] Unless a vacancy in elective office is being filled.
[0:38:49] And 742061B to consider the evaluation,
[0:38:54] dismissal, or disciplining of or to hear complaints
[0:38:57] or charges brought against a public officer or employee,
[0:39:00] staff member or individual agent,
[0:39:02] public school student, Chris Reed.
[0:39:10] Second.
[0:39:12] Motion by Chris Reed, seconded by Ruth Pierce
[0:39:14] to adjourn into the executive sessions as stated.
[0:39:18] Any discussion?
[0:39:24] Yes, Christopher Reed, Ruth Pierce, Suzanne Hawkins, Nikki Boyd, and John Berger.
[0:39:31] Yes, I just let everyone know we will not be reconvening the meeting following the executive session, nor will we be making any decisions in the executive session.
[0:39:45] With that we are adjourned.
[0:39:47] I have a swam I have five members of the council come up on the voting record
[0:39:54] This rate doesn't exist for some reason
[0:39:57] or the total sorry I feel so lonely
[0:40:00] but does count
