Oversight Archive: City Council meeting, 2018-11-05, recording 1 (started 17:00)
Machine transcript (faster-whisper base.en), not checked word for word; the Pledge of Allegiance is shown in its standard wording. The recording is the record.
Times are time into the recording. Passages with private details are muted in the audio and marked here.
The audio on the page below was re-encoded by software from the video the agency posted. Check any passage against
that audio before relying on it.
Page: https://oversightarchive.org/twin-falls-id/meetings/2018-11-05/

[0:00:08] to call the city council for Monday, November 5th, 2018,
[0:00:12] and confirm that we do have a quorum of the council.
[0:00:15] Six of the seven members are here this evening.
[0:00:17] Vice mayor Nikki Boyd is absent.
[0:00:20] And next on the agenda is the Pledge of Allegiance.
[0:00:22] For those of you who have listened to join us,
[0:00:23] please rise.
[0:00:48] Clamations this evening, be too shaded to come up
[0:00:52] and say a few words.
[0:01:17] Veterans, I wrote this out so I wouldn't forget anything.
[0:01:26] Women choose to join the service.
[0:01:28] The truth is that not that long ago,
[0:01:30] there was no real choice when you got the letter
[0:01:32] from Uncle Sam with a draft number.
[0:01:34] But when there's no draft in place,
[0:01:36] what makes them voluntarily sign up with the Marines,
[0:01:39] the Army, Air Force, Navy, Reserves,
[0:01:41] Air National Guard and Army National Guard?
[0:01:44] When they graduate from high school
[0:01:46] and can go and do whatever they want, or nothing at all,
[0:01:49] when they could be getting ready for college
[0:01:51] or to go backpacking through Europe,
[0:01:54] when they could be starting a new job
[0:01:55] or getting married and settling down
[0:01:57] with their high school sweethearts,
[0:01:59] Why sign all those forms?
[0:02:01] Submit to tests and physicals and psychological exams
[0:02:05] just so they can be sent far from home to a place
[0:02:08] that's almost always hot and human and buggy.
[0:02:11] Then be broken down and built back up again.
[0:02:13] All the while, at least at the beginning,
[0:02:16] being yelled at and pushed to do things,
[0:02:18] but physically and mentally that they never thought
[0:02:20] they were capable of.
[0:02:22] The reasons are numerous and personal
[0:02:24] and can include everything from wanting
[0:02:25] to get out of the small town where they were raised.
[0:02:28] to do something they've seen in movies that seems really cool,
[0:02:32] to following in the footsteps of family members
[0:02:34] who served honorably before them,
[0:02:36] or just simply patriotism,
[0:02:38] and wanting to do their part for America.
[0:02:42] And if you ask any of them about it,
[0:02:44] I'm pretty sure they would disrupt their shoulders
[0:02:46] and say it was no big deal, it's nothing special.
[0:02:48] We were just doing a job that needed to be done.
[0:02:53] Of the 300 plus city employees and city council members,
[0:02:57] 47 are veterans of almost every branch of the service.
[0:03:01] And we want to recognize their service
[0:03:02] and give them a small token of appreciation
[0:03:04] to let them know that we know that what they have done
[0:03:07] is a very big deal and it is very special.
[0:03:11] Our veterans include everyone from those
[0:03:13] who have been in combat, the grunts and the medics
[0:03:16] and the airmen and the sailors,
[0:03:18] to those who have served their entire enlistment
[0:03:20] stateside, and to all those who have fulfilled
[0:03:23] the thousands of supporting jobs that make it possible
[0:03:25] for the troops in the field to fulfill their missions
[0:03:28] to the best of their ability.
[0:03:31] We believe that for America to be the best version
[0:03:34] of itself, we will always meet men and women
[0:03:37] who are willing to step out of their comfort zones
[0:03:40] and become the best versions of themselves.
[0:03:43] Joining the service literally means serving.
[0:03:47] Their families, their friends, their hometowns
[0:03:49] and their country.
[0:03:51] And we want to say thank you to Chris Talkington
[0:03:53] and Greg Lanting, and to our co-workers of the City of Twin Falls who are veterans.
[0:03:58] And we're starting by recognizing you here tonight, and we will be doing the same for the many city employees who are veterans.
[0:04:06] Thank you very much.
[0:04:07] Thank you so much for taking that opportunity to share our thanks for all of our city employees who are members of the service,
[0:04:33] and certainly for our colleagues that are on the council, and we look forward to you sharing that message with them, Veterans Day.
[0:04:41] Also on the agenda now is an opportunity for general public input. If there's anyone here from the public who wishes to address the council on an item that is not on the agenda this evening, now is your opportunity to please come forward.
[0:04:55] Just a little action today, should I expect the calls still find a way?
[0:05:19] Next on the agenda is the consent calendar.
[0:05:38] Yes, I'm sorry.
[0:05:39] I did consent, Calist, last week.
[0:06:01] Since we... Ruth Pierce, second of aye.
[0:06:04] Just read to approve the consent calendar minus last week's minutes as they're into discussion.
[0:06:10] Yes, where's Pierce? Yes, Mr. Fareed. Yes, Chris talking to yes John Barrigar. Yes
[0:06:28] passes six to zero
[0:06:33] By Chris Reed second by Greg Lansing to October 29th meeting is there any discussion?
[0:07:00] Yes, Mr. Fareed. Yes, talking to yes
[0:07:03] Yes.
[0:07:04] And Suzanne Hawkins, abstain.
[0:07:05] Passes 5-0 with one abstention.
[0:07:06] Next, under items of consideration, under action items, the first is a request to confirm
[0:07:19] the appointment of Shane, as the City of Twin Falls City Attorney.
[0:07:24] Very excited to have Shane and his family here tonight.
[0:07:30] His enthusiasm and his skills are going to really help us be successful as an organization,
[0:07:38] as a community. As our community continues to grow,
[0:07:42] Shane will bring leadership and expertise that we're looking forward to
[0:07:45] having to be critical to achieve our shared goals and expectations for the
[0:07:49] future. He's served as the deputy city attorney
[0:07:52] for the City of Twin Falls since 2014, received his bachelor's degree from the
[0:07:56] Mary F School of Business at Brigham Young University
[0:08:00] and law degree from the University of Idaho College of Law,
[0:08:02] Go Mandles. No has worked with the Idaho Municipal
[0:08:06] attorney's association since 2012 and currently serves as the association's
[0:08:10] president. He lives in Twin Falls with his wife and four children and we're very
[0:08:14] excited to have him accept the oath of office this evening as our city attorney
[0:08:19] and Lori race serving as our city clerk will administer that oath and then
[0:08:25] following that will have the council step down and we'll snap a couple of
[0:08:29] pictures. So welcome Shane.
[0:08:32] Constitution at the ends of the state of items of the city of Twitter.
[0:11:20] Mayor asked that I enter my son, Gabriel.
[0:11:32] I want to make sure I know that eight brothers and sisters throughout the United States watching this.
[0:11:38] I'd be remiss if I didn't say a hello to my paternal grandmother who's in Texas and my
[0:11:45] general grandfather who's in Georgia.
[0:12:00] And next on the agenda is a presentation of Idaho Post certifications to several officers.
[0:12:06] And we have Craig Kingsbury, our chief of police to eat the festivities.
[0:12:19] Thank you so much.
[0:12:20] That was first very nice to be here on the evening
[0:12:23] when Mr. Noob's appointed as our city attorney,
[0:12:25] and I would like to take them over and just also thank friends.
[0:12:29] I'll help you give us for the years.
[0:12:31] So as they're coming down there,
[0:12:32] if you could come over and assess us in this presentation,
[0:12:36] I'm going to actually turn this over
[0:12:37] to the two patrol staff sergeants.
[0:12:40] It's always our honor and our privilege
[0:12:42] to recognize members of our agency
[0:12:45] when they achieve the different post certification levels.
[0:12:48] They achieve these levels, sort of a lot of hard work, a lot of training, and quite frankly, for time on the job.
[0:12:53] So, I'm going to turn it over to Staff Sergeant Workato and Staff Sergeant Fusses for Patrol Division.
[0:12:58] Thank you, Mr. Mayor and members of Council.
[0:13:07] I would like to say that these certificates acknowledge those officers who have committed to the police profession
[0:13:22] and have successfully met certain criteria established by Post and it's very honorable to proceed these certificates.
[0:13:29] Tonight we'll be presenting the Hijabatagar, Tyler Campbell, Salko Lillich, Chris Ehart,
[0:13:37] with his advanced certificate.
[0:13:43] The officers are down here so if we could have Elijah.
[0:13:50] Elijah was hired by the Twin Falls Police Department on January 9, 2017 as a police officer.
[0:14:04] He was born and raised in Colorado Springs, Colorado, and he graduated from James Irwin
[0:14:09] High School in 2004.
[0:14:11] Elijah served in the Army Reserves from 2004 to 2013, and during that time, in 2006, Afghanistan in 2011, while serving, he also managed to further his education by attending Pike's PD Community College.
[0:14:28] Elijah's law enforcement career began when he left the Army Reserves and became an El Paso County Sheriff's Deputy in Colorado Springs in 2013.
[0:14:38] In 2013, 2017, Elijah serves in the Patrol Division and is a member of the Special Weapons
[0:14:50] and Tactics Team.
[0:14:53] Elijah was awarded his State of Idaho Basic Patrol certificate in October of 2017.
[0:15:00] It was a great pleasure that we present Elijah with the intermediate certificate from the
[0:15:06] State of Idaho Peace Officer Standard and Training.
[0:15:08] At Boise, in moved to Florida when he was in the fifth grade and returned to Idaho during
[0:15:40] of high school, at the Idaho State University Law Enforcement Academy and graduated in May
[0:15:50] of 2014, where it is post basic patrol certification in January, a pleasure that we present Tyler
[0:16:02] with his intermediaries in 2016.
[0:16:32] Go was born in Bosnia in 1991.
[0:16:38] Bosnia War took place from 1992 to 1995.
[0:16:44] This made life very complicated, and Selco lost his father in that war.
[0:16:50] Salko, his mother and one of his sisters, came to the Twin Falls area on February 12,
[0:16:56] 2002, to join some aunts and uncles who were already living in the area.
[0:17:01] He also has a sister living in Bosnia and another in Australia.
[0:17:06] Salko graduated from Twin Falls High School, further his education at the College of Southern
[0:17:12] Idaho, where he attained his associate degree in law enforcement criminal justice.
[0:17:17] In 2016, Salko received his bachelor's degree in criminal justice from Boise State University.
[0:17:25] Salko attended the Post Basic Patrol Academy Session 186 and graduated on June 3rd, 2016.
[0:17:31] He was awarded his Post Basic certificate in November of 2016.
[0:17:37] It was with great pleasure that we present Salko with his Inter-Media certificate for
[0:17:43] my own post.
[0:17:44] Also served on the department's award community serving on the leadership team.
[0:20:16] The vast certificate was hired by the Twin Falls Police 2017 as a full-time police officer.
[0:20:32] He was born and raised in Twin Falls and graduated from the Lighthouse Christian High School.
[0:20:37] He attended and graduated from the College of Southern Idaho's law enforcement program.
[0:20:42] Hal began his law enforcement career with the Rupert Police Department in April 2008
[0:20:48] and served in that department until he was hired by us in 2000.
[0:20:52] Hal has served in that since November of 2011.
[0:21:03] Currently serves in the Patrol Division as a field training officer.
[0:21:08] Officer Eaton was awarded his post basic certificate in 2009 and her media certificate in 2014.
[0:21:15] It was great pleasure. It is with great pleasure that we present Powell with his advanced certification
[0:21:21] on the state of Idaho Police Officer Standards and Training.
[0:21:24] Congratulations to all of the officers. Thank you for your dedication to the community and to the citizens who live here with your continued commitment to training excellence.
[0:22:06] Next on the agenda, a request to waive the non-conforming building expansion permit process
[0:22:20] for a residential home located at 347 Polk Street, and we have Steve O'Connor, our City Planning Council, Mr. Mayor.
[0:22:31] What you have for you is a request to waive the performing building expansion permit.
[0:22:37] Essentially, we took an application on October 11th from the applicant to waive this process.
[0:22:47] They're essentially adding on to the rear of the house, the west side of the house, 154
[0:22:53] square foot addition.
[0:22:57] Zoning on it requires a 7 foot set back from side yard.
[0:23:02] They're requesting a 5 foot set back for this expansion.
[0:23:06] expansion. So it would go to feet into that setback. However, the house currently sits
[0:23:12] two feet, approximately two feet off the side yard setback right now. So the building would
[0:23:17] now use. So if the council wishes it may waive the public hearing requirement as per section
[0:23:37] 1034. And this would allow the applicant to proceed immediately with the building permit
[0:23:42] process. If the council determines this request should go through the nonconforming building
[0:23:46] expansion permit, an application would be required and the public hearing shall be held
[0:23:51] with the planning and zoning commission.
[0:23:52] The full process takes approximately 40 days
[0:23:54] from the date of application deadline,
[0:23:56] and if their decision is peeled to council,
[0:23:59] it would have sent the timeframe another 40 days.
[0:24:03] So if the council does approve the waiver,
[0:24:05] the applicant would, like I said,
[0:24:06] state four, go ahead with the building permit.
[0:24:11] The council has tasked with making a decision
[0:24:13] on this request, and the council may approve the request
[0:24:15] as presented, conditionally approved
[0:24:17] the request or the matter request.
[0:24:30] Sentence has presented to the council.
[0:25:15] The house is already, the decision could come up.
[0:25:33] As far as liability, I'll have to refer to the legal counsel on the liability of the city
[0:25:38] and brings in with this, but I do know that per code through this process, it is allowed.
[0:25:44] Thank you.
[0:25:45] Yes.
[0:25:55] And next on the agenda is a request to approve, reserve funds to purchase a public safety radio system
[0:26:15] and to enter into an agreement with federal engineering for consulting services.
[0:26:19] We have Captain Marcus, our Information Technology Communications Manager.
[0:26:23] evaluation of us to officers to hear a current system
[0:29:13] and there's lines different for a certain server.
[0:30:15] Those were like some of the main people engineering times in spoke with them in their history
[0:30:47] and scoring change first to approve the spending of the reserve funds that have
[0:32:34] signed from last fiscal year for an assistant proposal.
[0:33:09] So 100 systems with the subscriber fees you've got so far well so before we
[0:34:27] the public safety radio system and
[0:35:25] treatment as presented as their
[0:35:36] discussion.
[0:35:37] Yes.
[0:35:38] Yes.
[0:35:42] Yes.
[0:35:49] Next on the agenda is a request to amend city code section 2-5-3 to allow the planning and zoning commission to be appointed to fulfill the duties of the city's traffic safety commission.
[0:36:00] City Manager, which once ago, traffic safety commissioners questioned, I guess, their work.
[0:36:20] The codes suggested that they should be doing and that causes to do the process that we have
[0:36:27] of the code says and our past work with that commission.
[0:36:32] What we found was a few different things.
[0:36:34] These are some duties for the commission for the traffic safety commission.
[0:36:40] They're more long term, kind of big picture, city wide, even shoes that they're basically
[0:36:53] of information to you all as the council. We had them doing basically a series of very
[0:37:02] specific, very localized kind of traffic controlled decisions. So if somebody would come in and
[0:37:09] say we'd like to have a crosswalk at this intersection or we'd like to change the speed
[0:37:13] limit in this stop sign at this location. And those were the kinds of things that they
[0:37:20] were doing and it wasn't the big long term kind of strategies that they're doing. So
[0:37:27] we found that maybe there's a, what he was saying.
[0:37:31] We also found that we did have folks
[0:37:33] looking at that big traffic impact kind of stuff.
[0:37:37] I'm ending in zoning commission.
[0:37:39] Does that pretty regularly
[0:37:40] when the big subdivision affect safety concerns
[0:37:48] in a bigger scale than it's such a local.
[0:37:51] We also have a master transportation plan
[0:37:53] that's being updated right now
[0:37:54] and advisory to the council.
[0:38:00] So the work's being done,
[0:38:01] it just isn't necessarily being done by having safety.
[0:38:05] The other things we found when we did that
[0:38:06] was that we have a time keeping that commission
[0:38:10] full-strength there's seven members of that commission currently today there's
[0:38:14] only three vacancies that we're trying we don't have for several months so
[0:38:23] August
[0:38:31] from city managers office from engineering etc on the big table and said okay what
[0:38:42] do we do the consensus was we kind of need this work to be done the council
[0:38:55] needs that from this advisory board so we got to keep it but there still is that
[0:39:00] linkering issue of you know we're canceling meetings because of lack of
[0:39:04] for canceling meetings because items they meet as often as they don't meet traditionally.
[0:39:12] So, as we were bouncing ideas around the table, one idea was floated that perhaps we could find
[0:39:17] another commission that is already standing that has work to do with this other commission,
[0:39:28] much like we did several years ago with the Parks and Rec Commission.
[0:39:35] Missing one.
[0:39:41] But keep standing and we're going to get it, right?
[0:39:43] There was four.
[0:39:44] Anyway, we combined them all together as one commission.
[0:39:47] A couple of years ago we combined our reimbursement commission with the impact fee commission for
[0:39:51] the exact same reason it's important work but we need to have a commission that can actually
[0:39:54] survive and so the planning and zoning commission came up as the potential because again they're
[0:40:04] already traffic safety work as it is. They have duties and things that are signed to them
[0:40:12] that are traffic safety related items where those are certainly concerns that the planning
[0:40:18] the meeting.
[0:40:19] We had a meeting in August.
[0:40:20] We had a meeting in August.
[0:40:21] We had a meeting in August.
[0:40:22] We had a meeting in August.
[0:40:23] We had a meeting in August.
[0:40:24] We had a meeting in August.
[0:40:26] We had a meeting in August.
[0:40:27] We had a meeting in August.
[0:40:39] We had a meeting in August.
[0:40:40] We had a meeting in August.
[0:40:44] We had a meeting in August.
[0:40:45] We had a meeting in August.
[0:40:46] We had a meeting in August.
[0:40:51] We had a meeting in August.
[0:40:52] We had a meeting in August.
[0:40:53] We had a meeting in August.
[0:40:54] We had a meeting in August.
[0:40:55] We had a meeting in August.
[0:40:56] We had a meeting in August.
[0:40:57] We had a meeting in August.
[0:41:00] We had a meeting in August.
[0:41:02] We had a meeting in August.
[0:41:03] We had a meeting in August.
[0:41:15] We had a meeting in August.
[0:41:16] we did was we went to a planning and zoning commission meeting in the mayor and
[0:41:19] the commission about it we didn't want to just handle a bunch of new duties
[0:41:22] from to the council to make this change and so what you've got on your
[0:41:38] agenda tonight is actually in order to prepare for you I want to say is this your
[0:41:42] first ordinance our new city attorney wrote this ordinance might be his first
[0:41:52] there's a couple in there and so I have to frame this one on this wall maybe it
[0:41:57] amends city code section two five three what it does is it adds a subsection
[0:42:02] to that code. Section 253 is the code that is the section of the code that says here is what it
[0:42:08] takes to be a member of the Traffic Safety Commission. We're standing at a quick statement at the very
[0:42:13] bottom of it that says the mayor can appoint and the council can confirm the appointment of the planning
[0:42:18] and zoning commission to fulfill the duties of that. And so members sitting around the table that day
[0:42:32] planning and zoning commission is part of that ordinance tonight. Traffic safety committee. We had
[0:43:02] Some of the positions were, and I think we all said,
[0:43:25] somebody from ICE who was involved in the BHP
[0:43:27] was already at one of the Commerce Ed position.
[0:43:32] As it works out, I think we have a team remember
[0:43:34] on our PNC right now, and that's not always
[0:43:37] with us at the table, and Jackie's team is the one
[0:43:56] that gets involved with all those school district
[0:43:58] kind of stuff.
[0:43:59] Oftentimes it comes up when we look at new schools
[0:44:03] and what we decided as a group that day was joining us
[0:44:19] and so that we can get the issues
[0:44:30] for those specific requests and then necessarily full-time standing
[0:44:48] members. It was his first to touch, like, how you be sitting down. Second. Back in
[0:45:55] 2nd of my room, so the place of work next 28. Yes. Mr. Fareed. Pass 6 to 0.
[0:46:22] Since number 2018 22, the Council of the City of Twin Falls, Idaho. Subsection
[0:46:45] higher and City Council to appoint two Susanne Hawkins to my Susanne Hawkins
[0:47:05] second by Christopher Reed to a protein-22 is there any? Yes. Yes. Christopher Reed and Chris talking to
[0:47:25] passes six to zero. Next on the agenda council I have a request being in zoning
[0:47:39] commission to fulfill the duties of the traffic and safety and that was made by
[0:47:48] Mitch like to take this moment to publicize three standing members of that
[0:47:57] Commission Rainbow and John Campularis and Kim serving on that commission and
[0:48:03] All of the past members of the traffic safety commission have done an outstanding job
[0:48:06] Shepherding those efforts forward, but has been explained
[0:48:14] Conversations and three second by traffic safety commission for their discussion. Yes
[0:49:17] Next on the agenda is another opportunity for general input is there anyone from the public who wishes to address the council?
[0:49:40] Mr. Mayor, members of the Council, then for those who may
[0:50:05] grab the Susan Hockens and the Council,
[0:50:24] we do have a schedule to begin after 6 p.m.
[0:50:29] So we will recess until 6 p.m.
[0:50:32] for that.
[0:50:44] I'd like to recon these city council meetings,
[0:50:52] which we'll start in just a moment.
[0:50:55] So in our haste at the beginning of the meeting,
[0:51:00] Council will actually here's recommendation point,
[0:51:05] chain, nope as our city attorney.
[0:51:07] In a motion from just for read to confirm the appointment
[0:51:16] of chain, nope as the city attorney.
[0:51:32] Yes, Mr. Fareed talking to yes
[0:51:37] Yes
[0:51:45] Thank you so much
[0:51:58] We have as a request for a special use permit
[0:52:02] Construct a maximum of eight four plucks units on individual lots on property located south of the intersection of
[0:52:09] of Bora Avenue West and Rose Street, North BHM on behalf.
[0:52:16] So just to quickly review the public hearing procedures
[0:52:20] for a request like this, we will have the applicant present
[0:52:26] and they will take no longer than 15 minutes
[0:52:29] to present their presentation.
[0:52:31] We do have a staff report as well
[0:52:33] that shall summarize the application history of the request.
[0:52:37] And the council may ask questions and staff
[0:52:39] for the applicant pertaining to that request
[0:52:41] the general public will be given an opportunity to provide their testimony
[0:52:45] regarding the request and do three minutes per person this evening their
[0:52:51] testimony and that public testimony in the applicant's response to the hearing
[0:52:56] which I'll continue and the council will receive as the applicant yes council
[0:53:17] I've also heard with the HM engineers I'm representing the applicant Caitlin
[0:53:22] Court LLC, Harry Nelson, Terreter, as well.
[0:53:28] Thank you, questions, if I might.
[0:53:38] This is an application.
[0:53:41] As you said, a Fort Plex development, a little Plex units.
[0:54:06] See, it's somewhat of an isolate parcel.
[0:54:09] Rose Street is not slated to go through.
[0:54:13] And some tile ups out, and it's a parcel
[0:54:27] that's somewhat isolated in that area.
[0:54:30] Just at the staff reporting city code
[0:54:42] and the site planters fire parcel itself.
[0:54:56] We also feel that, in itself, due to the orientation, inside the debate on the street,
[0:55:11] the site in itself, as you know, this is an appeal to the Planning and Zoning Commission's
[0:55:18] decision.
[0:55:19] If the September, most of those dealt with traffic, one person on a resident on Rose Avenue, one
[0:55:34] resident on Brack and the resident, all spoke about traffic within it.
[0:55:42] felt that we answered their concerns fairly well and also the fact that staff
[0:55:47] their concerns as well with questioning and answered their questions as well. As I
[0:55:56] heard their comm weeks go, the problems with traffic are generated, but we can
[0:56:12] see their point, but it seems to be generated by the people that in the existing
[0:56:18] streets. Also there's an office complex to the West which generates quite a bit of
[0:56:24] traffic doctor's office, and it's constantly surrounded by traffic as well.
[0:56:32] The Foreplex Unit that's a direct west of Zon Street parking older standards. As I
[0:56:44] drive through there's that parking lot is not full during the traffic on the
[0:56:50] street as if it were from the Foreplex development. But I see very little
[0:57:01] on it, I see it on the rest of the of the residences and especially the medical
[0:57:10] office on the course decision, conversation during our presentation, the residence concerns
[0:57:31] like development, how there is since it is in conformance with comprehensive plan and the
[0:57:43] zoning ordinance, it's our four, especially as being brought forth, concerned and expressed
[0:57:55] during that meeting. This field is like many other developments in the city should have
[0:58:03] based on its compliance with code and planning
[0:58:06] or less within the decisions was that it's detrimental.
[0:58:18] It's detrimental to the existing neighborhood
[0:58:20] because generated those streets that exist
[0:58:28] exist according to the master street plan.
[0:58:39] And always is that a choice that is detrimental
[0:58:49] against stress, this isn't compliance with code
[0:58:51] and comprehensive plan.
[0:58:54] You would ask that you approve the staff report the council.
[0:59:21] So this is a request to approve a special needs permit
[0:59:24] for up to eight, four plexus and the R4 zone
[0:59:29] on property located south of Rose Street and Bora Avenue.
[0:59:34] Currently the land is not subdivided.
[0:59:37] The Planning and Zoning Commission
[0:59:39] has reviewed the preliminary plan
[0:59:41] and did approve that based on staff's review
[0:59:45] of the submitted application.
[0:59:47] And then on September 25th, 2018,
[0:59:50] the Planning and Zoning Commission denied
[0:59:52] this request originally by the vote of four to three.
[0:59:56] Staff received an appeal from the applicant
[0:59:58] on October 10th, 2018.
[1:00:02] It's very limited as this is a vacant piece of parcel
[1:00:05] and was likely farmed through the early 50s and 60s.
[1:00:11] Brancet's a plan is this area is commercial,
[1:00:17] which is a very light commercial,
[1:00:19] but does allow for a little bit of higher density.
[1:00:24] And so the Brancet's plan specifically calls out
[1:00:28] need higher density housing or multi-family housing and therefore staff has
[1:00:34] determinate this request is in compliance with the 20 who recognize some increase
[1:00:41] and impacts originating from the increase in residents mainly due to
[1:00:46] vehicular traffic. However, it's not anticipated to increase to an unacceptable
[1:00:51] level as the surrounding public roadways are anticipated to
[1:00:54] handling so in conclusion council is tasked with reaching a decision to uphold
[1:01:01] Inditionally uphold, will go from roll the decision of the commission.
[1:01:05] This should be counsel over roll the decision of the commission.
[1:01:08] Staff recommends approval of the request as presented and recommends the following conditions.
[1:01:12] One, sub-decide plan amendments as required by CityCope standards and two subject to the
[1:01:17] approval of the final plan for Caitlin Court subdivision.
[1:01:26] I have questions for the apt streets around there, the face of curb, not maps, rows.
[1:01:50] Rose I believe is the same 36 looks narrow or must because of the trees and takes the gate and then behind to the east of Rose
[1:01:59] Is that a street or is that an alley? No, it's a sure it's an alley sir. It's
[1:02:06] There is a canal lateral that runs back there
[1:02:09] I believe that's where it goes down the I didn't also thin the street
[1:02:18] West of Rose
[1:02:27] the other one to go through there is that an alley?
[1:03:32] The 64.
[1:03:59] So, Rose Avenue, this has been a pack quite some time.
[1:04:26] They also said that the canal company,
[1:04:28] ancient system on site, and watering lawns
[1:04:45] as opposed to just flutter should leave you
[1:04:51] this parcel of wind.
[1:05:21] But there's no exit to the east.
[1:05:43] Signed up, I think, and I would ask that you'd let me
[1:05:47] because I have signed up as Susan Salazar.
[1:05:54] Next up, Randy Steele, on Rose Street and Street.
[1:07:00] We're just a little nervous.
[1:07:02] It's Rose Street, seems like it will be the automatic exit.
[1:07:13] There's some kids on Bracken Street.
[1:07:53] This used to be Don Anderson's home.
[1:07:56] Let's see right here.
[1:07:59] He has flood irrigation.
[1:08:01] And he used to flood this back part.
[1:08:05] There used to be, there is a lateral here on this corner
[1:08:10] and it runs right down through here.
[1:08:15] On Greece and that box here and it runs right underneath
[1:08:19] sidewalk, and then turns, runs down Bracken Street. And there is a manhole right there,
[1:08:30] because it is below the level of the water level, and that's irrigation law, I know
[1:08:38] it says sewer on it. I know these things because my father, Ron, I built these six
[1:08:43] four plexes right here, and we were required to have a year for a fire, and we're also
[1:08:53] I'm concerned that the new project doesn't have room for us.
[1:08:56] Also, we were a little nervous about this intersection right here, which I know you guys have talked about before, probably.
[1:09:16] I have studies, I'm sure.
[1:09:19] Need more traffic added onto this corner right here. It's already a bottleneck, and we'll make a more immediate clock. I think everyone knows that.
[1:09:26] Only names I have on the sign-up sheet. Is there anyone else who wishes to provide public testimony on this item?
[1:09:44] Close the button.
[1:11:06] I would say that no staff may.
[1:13:41] I believe we both have sidewalks on both sides, and I believe we both have sidewalks on both to build a sidewalk on for us, property which we'll connect it all over.
[1:14:56] With Rose Street, that might date Rose Street, for the imporced them, the roses a straight shot in.
[1:15:06] I can see that being more appealing to the end too, the Rose Street so that they think that that's a...
[1:16:15] That's just my thoughts. It tears some of the traffic off of Rose Street, which seems to be what needs to happen.
[1:16:24] Does now existing or is some bigger?
[1:16:52] So we have Troy Vtec and Staff seems to be configuring and I asked Troy to just looks kind of like a brandy other side
[1:17:15] Let it extend the level of service A which is really good in the city right now, streets
[1:18:00] This 32 units in the sea engineer made that this even goes to let me see your D.
[1:18:11] I can actually do the question but just like get comparisons that are buying 10 L street feet from
[1:18:28] South of Linwood Boulevard, 36th Street as well, something so, it's one way they put more
[1:18:42] parked up both sides, it's one way to this point, so it must be a 36.
[1:18:46] It's possible. And if you're just trying to get a, this is actually wider by staff.
[1:19:38] And it's also brought up and drive this area on a regular basis.
[1:19:49] Our boats, they're going to bypass all of those streets.
[1:20:15] They get on to just be a single stop. We're not looking at stop signs on filer.
[1:20:52] located south of the intersection of Bora, Avenue West, and Rose Street,
[1:21:47] Tatch City, Condetic, Special East, South recommended.
[1:22:05] Let's start with our neighbors. I know that, um, citizen surveys, the lowest score the city got.
[1:22:57] To add some, uh, prospect of this is encouraging to me, instead of keeping going,
[1:23:16] valuable farmland, oh, this is one that's, uh, less valuable.
[1:23:23] New York Farm Economy, uh, pasture land, more complex also than for housing.
[1:23:30] I'm also encouraged by their site plan that I don't think we're going to have the same issue we have over on Rivercrest, where it's just easier for the people to park on the street than it is in the parking that's available because it's easier to get to their apartment.
[1:23:47] Also be supporting this plan. I will throw the caveat out there if we do start to have a prop with parking on or I'd be willing to de-access and de-grafts from the
[1:24:06] second advice is in Hawkins to approve the special use permit as presented with the conditions placed on it. Is there any further discussion?
[1:24:31] Great land tanks. Yes. Yes. Is there a minute to executive session on the agenda potentially
[1:25:02] needing that this evening and we do not so with that the meeting is adjourned.
