Oversight Archive: City Council meeting, 2019-02-25, recording 1 (started 17:00)
Machine transcript (faster-whisper base.en), not checked word for word; the Pledge of Allegiance is shown in its standard wording. The recording is the record.
Times are time into the recording. Passages with private details are muted in the audio and marked here.
The audio on the page below was re-encoded by software from the video the agency posted. Check any passage against
that audio before relying on it.
Page: https://oversightarchive.org/twin-falls-id/meetings/2019-02-25/

[0:01:15] So first of all, I offer an opportunity for general public input if there's anyone who wishes to address the council on an item that is not on the agenda this evening.
[0:01:24] Now is your chance to please come forward and because we do have a fairly heavy duty agenda this evening and it'll limit input to two minutes of visuals in this portion.
[0:01:35] Comments, it is a responsibility to clear the snow on sidewalks in town as the responsibility of the adjacent property owners to those places, so I know, so I appreciate your comments and will certainly do what we event and cross-country schemes.
[0:03:39] So last very long.
[0:03:59] There's no city liability for recreational immunity that's already known as anyone else who wishes to address the council on an issue.
[0:04:23] I didn't let this not at the agenda this evening.
[0:04:25] Yes, I move that it can sink out.
[0:04:56] Second.
[0:05:44] request to a personius to survey five-year term,
[0:06:22] serving as commissioner for the Twin Falls Housing Authority.
[0:10:23] Our citizens need this was something excited that we were working as you
[0:10:35] recall. This is part of performance goals for
[0:10:40] set and so tonight I get the opportunity to present to you
[0:10:51] the City of Twin Falls diversity inclusion committee for those who as you recall
[0:11:18] organization to consider resolution to ask us to
[0:12:08] Our strategic plan is to be a responsible community and a responsible community about how the city of Twinphal.
[0:12:16] New residents are welcome to meet all the services that you have set for me this year were to explore and identify the specific needs within the resources and from that resolution, in conversations.
[0:13:19] Nice conversations were tough conversations.
[0:13:25] All of us do spend very significant for the city management.
[0:14:17] It is a bit different than some of the other advisory committees that we have.
[0:14:21] This will fall more as the city manage advisory to meet as that initial step.
[0:14:44] We want also to be the purpose of the diversity and inclusion.
[0:14:59] Yes, to advise the city manager and the city staff on issues related to diversity and inclusion.
[0:15:04] The goals of the city's strategic plan, specifically in the also work to accessing local government for all citizens.
[0:15:23] Those with physical and mental disabilities abroad spectrum of the city.
[0:15:40] Here's a quick listing of the purposes.
[0:16:05] most significant with discussing that their own way as an organization of trust, relationships,
[0:16:39] and with various key charter describes the roles.
[0:16:56] You start with a series of listening sessions.
[0:17:47] Those listening sessions will help us create an additional level of
[0:17:52] understanding the purpose is that we will meet one of those meetings with
[0:18:35] conversation and discuss and the second is that we were successful with
[0:19:23] with, and the areas that we made. So the charter is the first step. There is no
[0:19:38] member that is serving on the committee, because the committee after tonight, and to
[0:19:43] existence. It's a very simple term, so that first year service in Mission for
[0:21:10] Service, and the organization is allowed to establish committees as they are warned.
[0:22:59] We should, and have some input as. In really what we wanted to establish the
[0:23:27] committee, once that committee is established, one of the things that you'll
[0:23:31] notice that isn't necessarily here as a work plan. The whole state establishes it up. They go, this is an inclusive form. You also notice that it's not necessarily reserved for
[0:24:21] indivinicity of to replace a business. I'd be exclusive. That list should not be as a possible example. Vince, but certainly open to give us six
[0:25:16] presentation from Travis, this is the city manager. This is not something that with us this evening and I would just like to could ask them to
[0:29:07] stand because this is certainly not something that in this process please stand.
[0:29:20] And to our scout at the beginning of the example of citizenship in the community because these
[0:29:34] are just regular folks who gave up their time to volunteer and chase their passions as well.
[0:29:40] So, thank you for all that you've done.
[0:29:42] And next on the agenda we do have an action item. This is a request to approve the City of Twin Falls
[0:29:48] and Twin Falls Firefighters Local 1556
[0:29:52] Collective Marketing Agreement for Grinch and Scott.
[0:29:57] This isn't a very, um, so it has been accepted, the words as we parted the safe for granted place everywhere we saw in play resolution.
[0:31:26] And we also added a LSA place there, nearly assigned shifts.
[0:32:28] We've just done is essentially just re-figure so that everything that is scheduled over, data is scheduled over, so that it shows regular hours.
[0:33:06] on section 11, two new shifts that we had a D&E with the addition of the five firefighters being
[0:33:34] implicates, a way to try to disperse those shifts, three different shifts without
[0:33:50] overloading. So with that, we did have some language in the last contract, but there was some
[0:33:59] years in that when we figured pay schedules and pay cycles, FLSA days, the things that
[0:34:06] So, just like Gretchen spoke about, we knew those were issues, we had conversations with our local, and have just put the, so, as we had some other things to work.
[0:34:28] So with that, this is really a formality, this is just a change to make room. So, just on their side.
[0:36:19] Fire station, obligation, bond, better.
[0:36:33] Members of the Council, it's actually a real pleasure to be here tonight. Mr. Jurti started back in October of 2017. Very insightful.
[0:36:57] And I want to talk a little bit about just the question that I ask myself on a regular basis.
[0:37:04] Remember those days of being in street, police officer, and I'm wondering, how did I get here?
[0:37:09] And I think we do that sometimes.
[0:37:10] But really, before we have this conversation tonight, what I want to do is I want to thank,
[0:37:15] there's really two groups, there's the fire program, and I just want to thank you.
[0:37:28] Without taking too much time, Mayor, what I'd like to do is really get a conversation.
[0:37:46] I think it's probably start the conversation.
[0:38:02] want you to know that as a group and as a team for the resources, for the buildings,
[0:38:09] the resources that we have for sight, talk about deficiencies and improvements that we
[0:38:31] can not do so, as a matter of fact, we wanted so this really started for us back in October
[0:38:43] of 2017, and we started the process of conducting a needs analysis of our current fire stations.
[0:38:49] We thought that was important to just public safety complex, and we just our city hall and
[0:39:06] We thought it was time to look in process and they permit this amount of time.
[0:39:19] During that time that we asked the council to appoint a citizen advisory group, and that
[0:39:39] so we can attach them with the US to consider current locations of fire stations related
[0:40:27] to those recommendations.
[0:40:29] You asked them to help fund a solution.
[0:40:34] December 17, 2018, the fire station committee came back to you and made the following record
[0:40:40] in the current station.
[0:40:47] I am sorry, I think it's some other ideas.
[0:40:51] Their recommendation was to build three new fire stations.
[0:40:54] Placing, want to address the current efficiencies identified, current facilities do not support
[0:41:16] the increase in women in the fire service industry, that many standards set by the National Fire
[0:41:22] Protection Association, including existing facility layouts, do not allow for adequate
[0:41:31] separation between dirty equipment, equipment that's been contaminated, access to public
[0:41:47] and visibility to the communities in some stations, completely insufficient.
[0:41:52] The facilities do not meet the current building,
[0:41:55] the A essential facility, and life safety code requirements.
[0:42:00] Existing stations have inefficient floor,
[0:42:02] planned layouts, and do not support quick turnout times.
[0:42:06] There's an insufficient capacity for current
[0:42:08] and future personnel in apparatus.
[0:42:10] In their last recommendation,
[0:42:12] there's no training opportunity.
[0:42:13] The Fire Station Committee,
[0:42:28] they also weren't afraid to go outside of our area
[0:42:30] and have conversations.
[0:42:31] We see fire and other fire stations,
[0:42:33] departments, which I really,
[0:42:37] The other recommendation they made back to Council
[0:42:39] was that in building a new station one
[0:42:41] that we would purpose our current station one.
[0:42:53] They also mentioned the beginning of the training center.
[0:42:57] And when they did that,
[0:42:59] their recommendation to this Council was $4,657.
[0:43:10] A funding solution that was for the city
[0:43:13] to utilize a 20-year general bond.
[0:43:18] It debated over ago 20 years or 20 years
[0:43:21] decided on 20 years being in that,
[0:43:30] it's marginally it saved our,
[0:43:32] almost $6 million that you accepted
[0:43:38] recommendations on that date directed staff to prepare an ordinance and
[0:43:43] resolution to place that you tonight you have the fordance and the official
[0:43:54] intense resolution we've got two great partners we have John McDevitt from Skinner
[0:43:59] Faucet our bond council we also have Christian science public finance who is
[0:44:15] here to talk a little successful. As Bon Council, we know that Christian's going to go
[0:45:06] and assist the city in the process that the Council today is versus an election ordinance.
[0:45:42] The election ordinance calls for the special G.O. Bon election. It provides a description
[0:45:54] of the project. Once the election ordinance is adopted, then the City Clerk will court
[0:46:09] application of the collection, the property a sufficient
[0:46:17] ballot on setting up those, et cetera.
[0:46:25] Specific questions with respect to the election ordinance.
[0:46:27] I'm happy to stand and answer those.
[0:46:30] Official intent resolution, before being successful,
[0:46:43] the city would intend to make certain reimbursements
[0:46:47] from bond proceeds that the city had
[0:46:50] expended from its capital, capital expenditures,
[0:46:54] as it is, it's required for the IRS,
[0:47:04] by the IRS, as a city,
[0:47:10] the city's intent to make it's really a process of maintaining the tax exemption
[0:47:20] that if the city incurs expenditures that it pays for its capital improvement
[0:47:24] from the bond proceeds having this official action result in place allows
[0:47:32] the city to do so I think that's a general finance just a little bit about that
[0:48:16] science public finance is a very small division within science bank
[0:48:20] employees here in the state of Idaho, we work exclusively with cities, counties, school districts on the issuance of tax sent bonds.
[0:48:32] With that, just APP, some general information science has worked with the city for a number of people.
[0:48:50] Water and sewer revenue bonds, some new bonds as well as the first time we've done a general obligation.
[0:48:58] So I'll explain kind of the difference. What goes into that, the process and then answer any questions that you have.
[0:49:04] First, I want to state, again, we are engaged as a city's municipal advisor or financial advisor.
[0:49:09] With that, Zion's does not purchase your bonds. We do not make the loan to the city. We are actually on your side of the table in the bond transaction.
[0:49:18] We're there in interests. We have a fit to the city. I've listed out kind of the, is the city, is the issue work?
[0:49:37] Several others. So, municipal advisor, like I mentioned, maintains a fiduciary duty to the issue work.
[0:49:44] So, we're there to protect your financial interests. That means we have ordinance we provide.
[0:49:51] But we also should the voter to the sale steps needed and others the room with the pricing so if that's a negotiated underwriting
[0:50:36] We need to get a price before you the tax exempt the investor who purchases those funds that that investor so of course
[0:51:23] An investor with a higher tax rate is going to be willing to tax exempt and come taxes
[0:51:31] But you as interest rates benefit passes straight on to the city and of course ultimately to the taxpayers who are paying
[0:51:44] So you'll see much lower interest rates than you have the state.
[0:51:56] This will be the first time the city's obtained its own standalone credit rating based on your tax base and the fantastic work of others and staff.
[0:52:11] Lastly is the underwriter.
[0:52:15] So the underwriter supervisor does actually purchase all your bonds.
[0:52:20] Hey, you're there as an intermediary between you.
[0:52:22] So you can kind of, for that reason, it's an arms-length transaction between the city and the under threat pricing.
[0:52:38] It's in the market, which could include citizens of the community,
[0:52:48] since of the city, certainly citizens of Idaho.
[0:52:51] So just a quick over-bond on the cities issued in the past,
[0:53:12] maximum term is up to 30 years.
[0:53:15] As was mentioned, the consideration and the tax impact
[0:53:29] on the 20 years, a little bit of huggation bonds,
[0:53:44] I'm going to skip over a vote here and down to security.
[0:53:47] So the security for the bondholders is unlimited.
[0:53:50] Pay this, I didn't vote taxes.
[0:54:36] And so eventually, of course, the county
[0:54:37] can step in and the remedies that they have for any property taxes.
[0:54:42] So if a lot of their cities is extremely safe,
[0:54:47] bonds are generally considered the safest.
[0:54:50] And so you get the benefits rates relative to financing.
[0:54:59] Of course, in the state of Idaho, the Constitution
[0:55:03] views that also as a huge responsibility for the city
[0:55:07] to be able to take strong security.
[0:55:12] For that reason, we do have a two-thirds super majority.
[0:55:15] So cancels out two yes votes.
[0:55:26] So, of course, it's for the city to make sure the citizens are informed.
[0:55:34] Say, well, let's, you know, let's, you know, the police station,
[0:55:52] if it wasn't specifically listed in the ballot,
[0:55:55] find by statute as 2% of your taxable assessed value.
[0:56:15] For general obligation bonds, you are actually able to add back your taxes,
[0:56:27] and go to the city to pay the, the same way with school districts do the city to help you.
[0:56:42] So with that, it actually is about a 20% difference.
[0:56:46] It's so substantial in your case that having it in there reduces the tax rate impact, 2%
[0:56:58] of taxable assessed value.
[0:56:59] It's based on about $3.5 billion, that means you have a debt capacity a day of just under
[0:57:05] $72 million dollars.
[0:57:07] That's the most you could ask voters for in an election today, of course we're well within
[0:57:14] that at $36 million.
[0:57:15] As far as the actual tax impact, you can see that here, a $36 million dollar project, 20
[0:57:20] year term.
[0:57:21] We've an estimated rate here of 3.55%, which is working out to an average annual payment capacity there, sorry, not the capacity, the taxable assessed value, the 3.5 billion yields a 0007174, which works out to $71.17 per order, is actually going to be on the backfire by statute as of the last legislative session.
[0:57:55] So it's a very straight forward calculation, so this is 100,000 taxable, that means after
[0:58:08] $71.17 tax increase in today's numbers, this specific number is not based on today's rates.
[0:58:40] Rates have been rising and projected to get a rise because of that.
[0:58:44] Today's taxable value, but also we used interest rate forecast.
[0:58:59] The rates are very high and it's 4% of a reason in the unexpected habits that exist now and prizes.
[0:59:52] The rates are locked at the time when we sell the bonds.
[1:00:21] The process doesn't really start until after the election, complete an estimate.
[1:00:31] Since today, forecasting out till late 20, you can see we're at the very beginning of this bond issues process tonight.
[1:00:40] Election is about a C-State week process.
[1:00:46] type would say conservatively with that's the point of you see on the preparation
[1:01:25] established method of sale
[1:01:27] a head of versus negotiate underwriting negotiated
[1:01:31] and on a expectation right now
[1:01:34] a head of sale
[1:01:35] even this is a prospectus for digest about the city and its finances and its bonds
[1:01:47] tax base obtaining a bond rating a bond sale which again I'd say
[1:01:53] August piece of the ordinance that says the city council is approving sale of the
[1:02:08] bonds within certain
[1:02:10] sideboards that will update you on the interest rates but the council will say
[1:02:15] as long as the final pricing comes within low this interest rate in this term is
[1:02:24] as sale. So, do you question? But yeah generally it's about eight weeks up to the
[1:02:50] sale pricing is finalized at that point assuming the council either through
[1:02:54] its delegation or through a vote decides to accept that final pricing. It's about
[1:02:59] another two-week process before we deliver funds. Given the 20-year limit you
[1:03:04] have of tax receipts for the city then September from maximize. So with that
[1:03:18] we can expand it. So lastly this is a little interesting. I wanted to show you
[1:03:48] where interest rates have been. As I mentioned, rights have been rising.
[1:03:51] I'm interested to continue to rise if you look at the chart here. This is what's called the
[1:03:55] Bond Buyer Index. It's his snapshot of where 20 year municipal bond rates have
[1:04:00] been. This is over the last 10 years. I know this is year of
[1:04:05] Maturities over range of ratings. It's not indicative necessarily
[1:04:09] If Vermont is going to hit, you can see here the current is 4.23
[1:04:14] Wear rates have been. Few interesting points. The trough there
[1:04:38] It's mid-2016 if you go up a little bit to kind of the test breaks it
[1:04:45] So caught the market by surprise. Sent rates down
[1:04:49] Substantially. And then you can see the long climb there from that bottom
[1:04:53] There's a little blip right in the middle before it jumps straight back up
[1:04:57] That's election day 2016.
[1:05:00] Caught again, by surprise, San Andreas rates up quite a bit.
[1:05:05] Expectation of lower taxes, less regulation, things like that.
[1:05:10] You're going to make you say, I should sell bonds,
[1:05:13] work it instead, and see the stock market.
[1:05:27] You can see that plate of council you have before you tonight.
[1:05:59] Gished by the election ordinance and the official
[1:06:03] intent of resolution.
[1:06:05] Staff recommends that you approve ordinance
[1:06:08] and the resolution and the cover safe with our commitment.
[1:06:24] So the ordinances of 2019 use
[1:11:40] in the so absolutely general discussion
[1:13:25] about the Council's fiscal year 2018 priorities,
[1:13:29] use of $775,000 project fund and philosophies,
[1:13:34] I exist in input at the 620s Rothwiler
[1:14:15] for an action item, a general discussion
[1:14:17] about the city councils,
[1:14:18] fiscal year 2018 budget priorities,
[1:14:21] use of $775,000 project fund and philosophies
[1:14:25] We'll have an opportunity first this evening.
[1:14:30] Thank you, Mr. Mayor, members of the Council.
[1:14:31] So this, this is our first big conversations
[1:14:36] that we will have in the construction of the 2020
[1:14:46] some of which are processes for some time-jing processes
[1:15:27] that we would base as, and we would ask for questions.
[1:15:33] First question is, is this something
[1:15:35] that you would like to improve, and if so,
[1:15:38] but special projects would you place us
[1:15:43] in the rules that we, so we're here tonight,
[1:16:09] teaching about some of those projects.
[1:16:12] We want to walk through some of these projects,
[1:16:14] we don't expect this to be an all-inclusive list by any means is that you might have a conversation to be able to do this is also not the last time it's not a final decision that you're making this evening
[1:16:32] we recognize that when we start the budgeting process very early plot of circumstances that could change that might ultimately cause you to say for course of action
[1:16:47] So several months from number of business starting,
[1:17:03] we're also asking members of our long term.
[1:17:08] Yes, so that as you are looking at projects,
[1:17:12] they're not also trying to fund those same projects
[1:17:16] that provides them with even 170,000.
[1:17:35] It's not the last.
[1:17:37] And today, Mr. Mayor, members of the council,
[1:18:27] we have a list, the list was included in your packet,
[1:18:29] and it is also showing on the screen
[1:18:32] possible projects of things that we as a team
[1:18:36] have discussed, and some of these projects
[1:18:38] may look very familiar.
[1:18:40] Some of these projects were ones that were offered last year as part of our conversation.
[1:18:45] A lot of these projects don't quite have costs yet.
[1:18:55] And advancing and moving some of these forward, if the interest in what some of these projects
[1:19:02] may cost, or you don't see a cost, we will spend some time perfects that are sort of
[1:19:35] described as these to do some or more projects, right?
[1:19:54] And you can obviously see that some of these projects exceed the total amount of money.
[1:19:59] resources that we get was this is not 770 a portion that we cross the organ
[1:20:11] cover some of those areas that we typically and also conversations and
[1:21:14] redesign as part of facility and so we designed so we needed to say what
[1:22:42] group it doesn't mean this year we've got like 775,000 I realized also let me
[1:31:00] maybe so we spend about there's the opportunity to what we're asking you to
[1:31:24] resources that we have ships and resources to meet.
[1:31:44] Soften that, find the 6 million.
[1:31:49] I'm sorry to make that clear.
[1:31:50] We want to hear your highest priorities with our dollars
[1:34:12] and see certain things, choose sidewalks.
[1:34:31] And if sidewalks are a big thing, we have objects,
[1:34:39] those attachments, if there's something
[1:34:55] that we can place onto our website,
[1:34:56] is kind of a submit your budget idea proposal.
[1:35:00] And then we would also just opportunity
[1:35:09] while the fix is a citizen.
[1:35:36] See, you should process.
[1:35:45] I guess I grew in arts children to school safely is a high priority.
[1:35:59] I would like to echo Vice Mayor Boyd's comments regarding the Archway and at this point in
[1:36:08] time communicating events and emergencies including Amber Alerts other than what you get to your
[1:36:17] phone.
[1:36:18] There's no way to communicate those and the Archway would be difficult to do that.
[1:36:25] So I definitely think that's been estimated approximately half has been so thought so.
[1:43:23] that's the only one I can think of, just like...
[1:43:28] Federation, the North side, next to the...
[1:45:26] There come, uh, said have a number of resident of Twin Falls.
[1:45:29] I just wanted to comment on the closed captioning aspect.
[1:45:32] I think that that's really important.
[1:45:33] I'm really glad that it's up there in the first place,
[1:45:36] as well as the ADA complaint ramps places.
[1:45:39] And I do think that, you know, as Sean mentioned,
[1:45:41] it might be potentially something you could task
[1:45:44] to the Diversity Council, or Committee,
[1:45:47] Committee as that kind of gets up and running inputs together. It's plan that maybe something like looking into where
[1:45:53] A.D.A. ramps in the city could be useful where we would need them stuff like
[1:45:58] Getting better sidewalks out there for people who are in wheelchairs, especially
[1:46:03] Definite for children safety side comment
[1:46:05] I do live in those broad more things that were just built and you're correct that it's insane over there
[1:46:11] There's so many kids and those build like more and more people just keep buying those houses like they're getting filled up
[1:46:17] really quickly. There were only six of us this time last year and now almost all of
[1:46:21] this houses are full. So I think it is really important and a priority to kind of
[1:46:25] focus in on those areas where we're already building and improving and putting
[1:46:29] more population in the area making sure that as we do that the safety maintains.
[1:47:15] I'm saying to see which streets they believe, please some attention to council, I know, all right, see, no one on the
