Oversight Archive: City Council meeting, 2021-02-22, recording 1 (started 17:00)
Machine transcript (faster-whisper base.en), not checked word for word; the Pledge of Allegiance is shown in its standard wording. The recording is the record.
Times are time into the recording. Passages with private details are muted in the audio and marked here.
The audio on the page below was re-encoded by software from the video the agency posted. Check any passage against
that audio before relying on it.
Page: https://oversightarchive.org/twin-falls-id/meetings/2021-02-22/

[0:02:04] presentation, it comes in with a discussion on the upcoming March 9th supplemental levy.
[0:02:41] It's a pleasure to be here.
[0:02:44] Council partnered into projects as Board of Trustees that serves the Football School District.
[0:02:58] I just want to extend a thank you once again to all of the work and partnerships that we've had over the year.
[0:03:03] So with that I'm going to spend just a few minutes explaining our supplemental levy.
[0:03:06] So the supplemental levy comes up every two years in the school district,
[0:03:10] and so we have one that's expiring and one that we are proposing
[0:03:15] to replace it with. So the supplemental levy that is expiring is a $5 million
[0:03:21] supplemental levy, $5.7 million supplemental levy. In the process we're
[0:03:27] actually going to be able to lower property taxes. And so I always get a
[0:03:31] little bit of a fun look when I say that because it is a bit of an increase in the
[0:03:35] levy. But again through some work that I'll explain, I'm here just a minute we're
[0:03:40] actually going to be able to bring our experts as I know that's a real concern
[0:03:45] right now within the community and so I'm going to explain that. So high level view of the Twin
[0:03:53] Falls school district we operate on 62 million dollar general fund budget. Most of our budget
[0:03:58] pays for staff so we're a staff-based organization so about 80 percent pays for employee costs.
[0:04:05] What you're seeing on your screen here are salary costs so when you add in things like retirement
[0:04:09] and insurance and other employer costs it comes up to about 80 percent. We have three types of
[0:04:14] employees in the district. We have certified employees which are teachers and counselors
[0:04:18] make up about 25 million and costs and then are classified which are our
[0:04:23] secretaries custodians and service workers 7.7 now we'll draw your attention
[0:04:28] to that category. I'm going to talk a little bit about that tonight so just kind of hold on to remember.
[0:04:32] Last spring we went through a process to trim our budget so we needed to bring our revenues and expenditures
[0:04:43] and so we trimmed two million dollars out of our budget we made a variety of cuts
[0:04:47] In the staffing ranks, we reduced 22 classified positions to certified positions to building
[0:04:54] administrative positions, and then all of the administrators at the district office took
[0:04:57] a pay cut.
[0:05:02] You'll notice it was rather heavy in the classified staffing ranks, and there's a reason for that.
[0:05:06] And so here in a couple of slides, I'll show you why so many of the reductions came from
[0:05:09] that particular issue.
[0:05:12] This shows you what I want to spend a lot of time here, but again, 80% of our budget pays
[0:05:16] for staff.
[0:05:17] About 15% for purchase services and supplies and materials, and then the last 5% pays for
[0:05:22] for things like us seeing and food service.
[0:05:26] So this slide here is an important slide
[0:05:28] and we'll kind of tell the tale.
[0:05:31] Whenever we talk about the supplemental levy,
[0:05:32] one of the natural questions is where are you staffed?
[0:05:35] Are you overstaffed?
[0:05:36] Are you understaffed?
[0:05:37] In particular, people want to know
[0:05:38] about our administrative costs.
[0:05:40] And so the way that the funding formula and Idaho works
[0:05:43] is it generates a state allowance.
[0:05:44] So that's the number of employees that we're funded for.
[0:05:48] So there's your three categories of employees again.
[0:05:50] So under the certified, which are teachers and counselors,
[0:05:53] You can see the state allowance and this was in 1920 of 509.
[0:05:57] We had 504, so we were about five positions under the state allowance.
[0:06:01] Jump over two categories to administrators.
[0:06:04] This is before the cuts.
[0:06:05] So the state allowance was 34.7.
[0:06:07] We had 34.3.
[0:06:09] So we were under the number of administrative positions
[0:06:11] that the state funds us for.
[0:06:13] Now with the elimination of the two building,
[0:06:15] administrators were actually about two positions under.
[0:06:18] And so we have fewer administrators
[0:06:20] what the state generates for our their now look at classified 51 positions over
[0:06:28] that's half of the cuts and so before the cuts it was more like 72 positions over
[0:06:33] in classifieds again that's in your custodians and your secretary ranks I'm
[0:06:37] here to tell you that we're not overstaffed in that category this is an area
[0:06:41] within the state formula that doesn't generate enough employees for us to be
[0:06:45] able to adequately staff our buildings with our classified folks and so even
[0:06:50] When you talk to legislators about this formula,
[0:06:53] they'll recognize that yeah, it's very difficult
[0:06:55] to operate your building with the number
[0:06:56] of classified positions that the formula generates.
[0:06:59] And so you have to use other revenue sources
[0:07:01] and be able to have those.
[0:07:03] And so this is where like a supplemental levy
[0:07:05] will come into play, number of custodians
[0:07:08] that we need to have the number of secretaries,
[0:07:10] things like that.
[0:07:11] If we eliminated 15 new one positions
[0:07:13] from our buildings, it would be very difficult for us to
[0:07:15] clean this just the way that our expedited dress
[0:07:20] and it would take more money from the state level
[0:07:22] We've actually spent $2 for every dollar we receive in that category.
[0:07:27] That's why the costs were so heavy with our classified staff, the 22th positions, because
[0:07:32] it's the one position category that is so severely underfunded or that we're the highest over
[0:07:39] in terms of our.
[0:07:40] Anyway, that's an area where supplemental levy helps us out.
[0:07:47] So in Idaho, it's very lean.
[0:07:49] Idaho is 51st in the nation now in terms of dollars spent per student, meaning we spend
[0:07:55] less money on a per student basis than anybody in the country.
[0:07:59] If you look at the 18-19 average, it was about 13,000 per student.
[0:08:03] The Idaho average is a little under 7,000 per student in here.
[0:08:07] Twin Falls we spend around $6,000 per student.
[0:08:11] And so I look at this in two ways.
[0:08:13] I mean, obviously, as a school system,
[0:08:14] we would like to be able to have more funds to be able to operate.
[0:08:17] But on the other side, I'm proud of the system that we have.
[0:08:20] And I think we're stretching our money along with what
[0:08:24] we're able to offer on $6,000 per student considering that the national average is almost 13.
[0:08:32] And so I think as a school system we can be proud of the education system that we're providing
[0:08:36] our kids and we're stretching those dollars as far as we can. Again, it is lean. Now, why
[0:08:42] are we less than the height of our average is because some communities have much higher
[0:08:45] supplemental levy rates and so when you have higher supplemental levy rates and some districts
[0:08:50] lower and some you come up with them. So every year we go through and audit. It's
[0:08:57] required by state law.
[0:08:58] And so this last year, auditor came back
[0:09:01] and had no findings.
[0:09:02] And so hopefully, again, that gives the community
[0:09:05] a sense of confidence in our business practices.
[0:09:08] Our audits have been clean over the years,
[0:09:10] anytime there's ever been anything that's come out
[0:09:12] of the audit has always been extremely minor.
[0:09:13] So we're proud of that.
[0:09:15] And then last year, we went through another layer
[0:09:17] of accountability and financing
[0:09:20] that I'm gonna talk about here.
[0:09:22] And so I'm financed, credit check,
[0:09:27] if you were gonna know how safe their investment is,
[0:09:32] if they're gonna buy a Baltimore School District,
[0:09:34] they want to know their investment is safe.
[0:09:36] And so Moody's, they did the same thing as an in-depth audit.
[0:09:39] They come in, they look at all of our business practices.
[0:09:42] They looked at the structure of our organization.
[0:09:44] They looked at, do that gives the community
[0:09:52] a sense of who have sound business practices.
[0:09:59] So let's talk about that supplemental levy now.
[0:10:01] So we have a budget advisory committee
[0:10:03] that meets to make recommendations every two years
[0:10:05] on those levy amounts.
[0:10:07] The budget advisory committee has made up of people
[0:10:09] from all different walks of life here in Twin Falls.
[0:10:11] make sure we have retired individual, we have business folks, we have parents, there's a
[0:10:16] state legislator that serves, there's city folks, there's just a wide variety of people
[0:10:21] to come and look at our budget. So they look at our revenues, they look at our expenditures
[0:10:26] and they really dig into what that levy amount is that they want to propose for the for the
[0:10:31] cycle. And so this year after meeting, that's for that 5.7 million. So what do we use the
[0:10:40] levy for well the levy is nine percent of our overall revenue and so if you look
[0:10:46] at the breakdown of where our money comes from the majority of it's gonna come
[0:10:50] from the state level and then about nine percent comes from that supplemental levy
[0:10:54] if you went back prior to the recession districts would pass levies for very
[0:10:59] specific items so you might have three or four extra things that you want to
[0:11:02] have in your system it's really not that way anymore in Idaho now 93 districts
[0:11:07] and Idaho have supplemental levies just to be able to operate.
[0:11:10] And so there's been a shift in our state away a little bit from state funding a little more
[0:11:15] towards the local.
[0:11:16] And so again, you've seen this shift has occurred.
[0:11:19] And so now it makes up such a high percentage of our budget.
[0:11:23] And actually in some districts it's even higher than our percentage of their budget.
[0:11:27] And so it helps pay for everything.
[0:11:28] It helps with those classified positions that I talked about,
[0:11:31] but it also pays for programs that we offer.
[0:11:33] I'm pays for support staff, I'm pays for training and talk, I'm paying for some of the extracurricular activities that we have for kids, it just pays for a variety of items.
[0:11:43] So no longer is it just really pinpointing specific items, it's a revenue source that helps pay for all that we do.
[0:11:48] So what would happen without the levy? Well, we would have to trim $5 million out of our budget.
[0:11:54] And so if you look at what we did last spring, when we eliminated $2 million, we would have out of the system, and so you can't eliminate 9% of your budget right in the same way.
[0:12:06] same way, unless you have a large carryover, which, and so basically everything we do would have to be on the table, and we'd have to take a hard look at what we could live without.
[0:12:16] And that's just the reality, because we wouldn't be in you with the same services that we have. And as a city, you understand?
[0:12:23] Exactly what, so now I'm gonna spend a little bit of time talking about how we're gonna lower taxes.
[0:12:29] And so I said at the beginning, we're gonna lower the overall tax rate, and so this is how we're gonna do it.
[0:12:34] So rewind back to last summer, last summer COVID didn't do a lot of good things, but the one thing it did was lower interest rates.
[0:12:41] And so many of people in the audience or maybe members here refinanced their homes.
[0:12:45] We did that with our bonds. So when we sold bonds to build the new schools, we had an interest rate and we refinanced that interest rate based on the new lower amount.
[0:12:56] And so by doing that, just in and of itself, we were able to take our overall tax rate of $4.28 per thousand of taxable value and a $3.63.
[0:13:07] So it's about a 65 cent drop, which on $100,000 of taxable value is a $65 a year.
[0:13:13] So for us, that's pretty significant. When we talk levies and bonds, it's usually a few dollars.
[0:13:19] And so a $65 drop or a 65 cent drop just by refinancing is pretty significant for us.
[0:13:25] We also say $14 million in interest by doing that so just to put that into perspective. That's what
[0:13:32] Elementary costs
[0:13:33] We saved enough money just by refinancing the people
[0:13:37] It was pretty significant. It's not just a minor savings to the communities amazing given that so now we're in a situation where because
[0:13:52] We're a growing community and because we were conservative when we went out and built the schools on our projections for growth
[0:13:58] We assume that we wouldn't have growth in Twin Falls and we've had growth and so now we can back off more on those bond collections.
[0:14:06] And so this is where our committee had to come in.
[0:14:09] So we determined that we can back off another million dollars in collections.
[0:14:14] And so the committee recommended that we take $300,000 of that.
[0:14:18] I'm going to put it towards additional tax relief and the other 700,000 to go to the levy and help off the set of portion of the cuts that we made last year.
[0:14:28] that we made last year so we reduced 2 million this would be 700,000 to help
[0:14:33] bring back some of those positions it's not going to bring them all back so that
[0:14:37] would take that three dollars and 63 cent rate down to three dollars and 56 cents
[0:14:43] so it's another seven cents savings since now when people read their ballot language
[0:14:48] when you go to the polls that's what it's going to talk about you guys see that's
[0:14:51] seven dollar that seven cent reduction because the 65 came for the refinance and
[0:14:56] So I just want to make sure that nobody is confused by that when they go to the polls and they read about how to see this drop right here.
[0:15:03] So now let's go back and take a historical view of what has happened with the levy rate from our district since 2018.
[0:15:11] So in 2018 was really the high watermark rate at $4.75 and since then it's been dropping.
[0:15:19] So in 19 it went to $4.28.
[0:15:22] Here you can see for this year 2020, the 363 that I've been talking about with that
[0:15:27] refinance.
[0:15:29] And then for next year, assuming the levy passes, we would drop it another $0.07, dropping it
[0:15:34] down to the $3.56.
[0:15:38] And so that portrays the overall levy rate.
[0:15:40] Now we know that we're not the only factor in terms of property taxes.
[0:15:44] We're not the only taxing entity.
[0:15:46] And we also know that we don't control what property values are what they come in.
[0:15:51] So obviously that all comes into play.
[0:15:53] Again, our rate's been going, in my opinion, in the right, lots of numbers here, and I'm
[0:16:00] just going to go down and point to the bottom.
[0:16:03] You can actually see how that levy rate and the levy amounts are calculated, but you see
[0:16:07] here that 363 for this year, the 356, but even the 356 is conservative.
[0:16:13] As a district, I don't want to tell people it's going to be 356 and then it comes in at
[0:16:18] $4.
[0:16:19] People will be mad, and they won't vote for levies anymore if that happens.
[0:16:23] So this 356, again, assumes no increase in market value.
[0:16:27] So we're facing that on that we won't have more homes
[0:16:30] being built, more people coming, falls.
[0:16:32] If we have an average here next year,
[0:16:34] if we have 8% in market value, that's our five-year average.
[0:16:38] It's gonna be somewhere around $3.33.
[0:16:41] So it should be even better than the 356.
[0:16:44] It's just depending on how much this chart here shows you,
[0:16:49] and I know you're familiar with this,
[0:16:51] but it takes a breakdown of where property taxes go.
[0:16:56] So when people, folks pay their property tax bill,
[0:16:58] where does their money go?
[0:16:59] About 40.7% is from the city.
[0:17:01] Now this is a little different this year
[0:17:03] because of the COVID dollars.
[0:17:06] And so this would be, if you did 4% to the county,
[0:17:11] and then the district is in percent.
[0:17:13] So of the three of the three big entities
[0:17:16] and property taxes, you've got the city,
[0:17:18] the county, and then the school district.
[0:17:20] And then as you know, there's a few CSI
[0:17:23] and payment district.
[0:17:25] Well, that's where we would fall in that mix.
[0:17:28] Now some people obviously don't live in the city,
[0:17:30] Some live in a different highway district and some are rural districts, so why not?
[0:17:36] So the last thing is just encouraging people to vote, whether they think this is the greatest idea ever or they think we're full of mud, and we want people to participate.
[0:17:44] So I always want to stop short of saying, you know, please vote for a levy and say, please vote in the levy election.
[0:17:50] I think it's an important community decision. And so I just encourage everyone to weigh in on this proposal. Early voting actually started today.
[0:17:59] So if you want to go to County West, you can vote that way.
[0:18:02] Election Day is March 9th.
[0:18:04] You like voting on Election Day.
[0:18:05] And then obviously, absentee ballot
[0:18:07] is always an option as well.
[0:18:09] And the last day for those ballots,
[0:18:12] they must be received by the court by 8 PM.
[0:18:14] And then this year, we're just asking for folks
[0:18:19] to help spread the message.
[0:18:20] We have lots of information on our website.
[0:18:22] I am doing a community presentation on February 25th at 7,
[0:18:25] over Larry.
[0:18:27] We'll also like to stream that for folks that want to watch.
[0:18:30] We're also be sending out various flyers and other information that contains the presentation.
[0:18:38] And again, this presentation is recorded.
[0:18:40] And with that, I thank you for your time and I would stand for any questions that you might have.
[0:18:46] When you say that, if we count all of our subs and everybody, it's going to vary just a little bit.
[0:19:57] But it ranges, it's about 1,000 to 1,100.
[0:20:03] And how many students do 1,300?
[0:20:07] And we've tried to really hard to listen.
[0:20:38] We always are looking at how we can.
[0:20:41] I'm sure that we have adequate funding, but we also know that property taxes are open for full balance.
[0:20:47] We're here forever and ever and I appreciate the time.
[0:21:22] State, church, school, or that state will stop them from applying.
[0:22:29] So we're trying to help the business get in, Quilla is in the room.
[0:22:36] And so they're closer slices across the street to not receive any.
[0:27:06] Yeah, we've got a voice.
[0:29:55] The city of 24 accessible community support highways.
[0:30:15] So this grant program at the state does, it's a state administrative grant.
[0:30:29] The last seven years,
[0:30:30] engineering staff has applied for
[0:30:32] and the accessible community
[0:30:46] between the city and the also.
[0:31:00] Heron specifically,
[0:31:55] these ramps are located on Shum Street
[0:31:58] from South Park,
[0:32:01] second at its locations.
[0:32:08] Their answer is hundreds,
[0:33:03] if not a thousand ramps.
[0:33:05] The state, when they ended their audit,
[0:33:07] years ago,
[0:33:08] categorized them in three categories,
[0:33:11] high priority.
[0:33:12] So this last few years,
[0:33:15] we've only been doing,
[0:33:18] we still have a number.
[0:33:19] It's your question.
[0:33:35] We got sort of our comprehensive EDA staff, our nurse, both the state and the federal government.
[0:34:01] We're on the screen for you, so let's reach subdivision back in 2000.
[0:35:56] And actually, there's another new that's not in the picture of both sides of our P.I. station.
[0:36:21] Last summer, the developer reached out to us and asked us, so we need to
[0:36:33] since we're in there, we also want to add, you can see from the area of photo that this is one of those
[0:36:54] newer style stations that we did, just to kind of a box in the ground, a big concrete box.
[0:36:59] and what we found is their space saving, but they also don't really work so it has good
[0:37:04] when it sits in that pond for a little bit, it kind of settles out and so,
[0:37:16] and it doesn't sit in the pond, we're pumping dirty water through the neighborhood
[0:37:19] and some art filters, and clogs out filters on individuals' sprinkler systems
[0:37:24] and so we want to put a pond in next to this PI station
[0:37:28] water set a little bit for our stake and for the users' you figures that you can do them
[0:37:41] and so, not budgeted, we want to do this work, we got to do our starts coming in
[0:37:55] It's coming in, and so if you want us to jump up, and if so, use some water from the reserves, or we can budget it and do it in an octastation.
[0:38:09] And all the neighbors out there would love to have it sooner rather than later. That's what I've got.
[0:38:23] We had to say I would make an assumption that if we waited until October, there's the potential the cost would go up.
[0:38:30] Correct.
[0:38:32] The estimates that Lee has right now are going to ask to talk to us.
[0:38:38] get inflation rate, probably the prices going up,
[0:38:42] that you may see a little bit of.
[0:38:45] Neighbors are anxious for us to get in.
[0:38:47] The name of the developer, which is for us to go in.
[0:38:51] Fencing costs right now are crazy.
[0:38:53] Fencing, grinding, fencing hard-drags,
[0:38:55] is what I can do.
[0:38:56] This is going to be.
[0:39:31] I'm going to actually reduce the amount of lawns
[0:39:32] from that scheme we need to do.
[0:39:34] So that's, makes sense.
[0:39:35] And I'm trying to, citizens that they are quite,
[0:39:44] it's a little tough for them to find a spot
[0:39:45] when they can water with the system we have right now.
[0:39:48] So that's what helped that.
[0:39:53] As far as the house is built, my question would be is what was going along the treasure? What that is, that peaks?
[0:40:13] This is just gravel. We're not proposing to put any pulses, gravel, a little nicer, and then there's a few trees planted in them.
[0:40:39] This is going to be really low water use. It isn't so much about more output. It's about the, hopefully, in their systems.
[0:41:28] At the Settlers Ridge Pressure Irrigation Station, accounts of the intersection.
[0:44:45] 2-0-6-1.
[1:05:43] Not this is not necessary for vacation.
[1:05:47] These are some utilities in these areas.
[1:06:01] We have no closer look process by which it was.
[1:06:50] It's similar to like a problem.
[1:07:04] It's a process by which we attained some conditions.
[1:07:20] There's some utilities.
[1:08:25] Our next item that you'll see on house development in this area.
[1:08:31] And so when we started this process,
[1:08:44] We also quite sure how we're sometimes a conaround.
[1:08:58] So, it costs back more work with organizations when access onto the site.
[1:09:35] That's only the staff heads of items.
[1:10:57] So I see it's just for a zero-mount line just from the subdivision to also allow open space areas that they access at the subdivision of the requested condition.
[1:18:06] Also, there's power lines in height directly south of the key access point that was initially.
[1:23:00] some of these three stories.
[1:25:20] Those along the canyon are properties so as not to obey the city engineer.
[1:28:13] The answer is that those access points are not the part and not a close enough to eat.
[1:28:48] This can change.
[1:29:47] The CDA does not definitively say that this home right here in the middle,
[1:29:59] it says you can't set back line offset.
[1:33:38] cars may have some land and some
[1:34:57] dental have concerns about the
[1:34:59] here and for leases the property from
[1:35:56] some of the here's the existing road
[1:35:59] the services these town homes as you'll
[1:36:03] see will have some concerns regarding
[1:36:24] ingress me grass for parking lot into
[1:36:47] services forty-some odd rent not so much
[1:38:41] distance and tenants and brought up to
[1:40:38] staff in our advice
[1:40:58] in his 40 residents I'm believing that's
[1:41:41] to the number of whether that's 40
[1:41:46] people start with the conversation to this decision and you don't have two
[1:43:10] parties upset or frustrated when they leave if they can work together before
[1:43:14] bringing it here for me firstly I think that that would be I'm then saying yeah
[1:43:23] do it and then profession the lawyers are gonna get in full conversation and say
[1:43:35] how can we come to that that that's where I would like this to go first there
[1:43:43] isn't a way and then that decision can happen instead of we're doing is so you're
[1:44:44] point to make this zoning change and becomes that that is not really an access they're gonna have to come back and change their
[1:44:59] platform of the zoning from C1 of CRO ZDA which is a change obviously but it's not as dramatic as you might think and I would like to see
[1:45:18] them get that figured out on the other as well but I'm willing to go forward tonight like to see this kind of housing and if they
[1:45:28] come up with that the last three townhouses need to be parking. I'm good with that too.
[1:45:33] And so we'll see what best result in the decision from C1PUD to C1CRO ZDA for property located at 287 and 292 river vista place.
[1:45:53] Scares on behalf of Federation Point LLC.
[1:46:00] First I would say, you know, I do think that this type of kinds of concerns with multi-processor and
[1:47:33] the looking's process in and of itself is sort of part of that due process, the concept
[1:49:18] of the kitty rim setback, a rim setback.
