Oversight Archive: City Council meeting, 2021-04-19, recording 1 (started 17:00)
Machine transcript (faster-whisper base.en), not checked word for word; the Pledge of Allegiance is shown in its standard wording. The recording is the record.
Times are time into the recording. Passages with private details are muted in the audio and marked here.
The audio on the page below was re-encoded by software from the video the agency posted. Check any passage against
that audio before relying on it.
Page: https://oversightarchive.org/twin-falls-id/meetings/2021-04-19/

[0:01:34] in person this evening. Please rise. So, I'm going to victims write resources for this
[0:03:39] and social service systems, understanding groups that have access to healing efforts,
[0:05:21] assist all victims, expressing our care for those community service providers to receive
[0:05:55] this proclamation. Thank you, Madam Mayor and burs for once again, acknowledging the
[0:06:38] rights of crime victims in our city by declaring this proclamation to celebrate victims' rights
[0:06:59] and services, and most importantly, with our families, neighbors, friends, and colleagues
[0:07:05] whose lives have been forever to reach out, listen, and support victims as they press forward
[0:07:13] on a path to recovery we use services. Commit to making our services more accessible and to building
[0:07:30] partnerships so that we can truly honor the past efforts of the crime victims movement
[0:07:35] forward to a future of hope. The first step begins here by declamation.
[0:07:43] Yet, some of you may be questioning why.
[0:07:46] On research, the victims who feel heard and supported
[0:08:07] immunization seek services from formal support agencies
[0:08:16] and participate in the justice process
[0:08:18] from the initial investigation through to sensing
[0:08:21] of the defendant.
[0:08:23] It is a huge, huge step in process for a victim to disclose
[0:08:28] and to follow through with obtaining services
[0:08:30] and as such, we should react to disclosure
[0:08:33] with positive support.
[0:08:35] Victims to have their courses heard, and us listen as you are doing now.
[0:08:48] Education of and participation in awareness events.
[0:09:03] Wheels for Child Abuse Prevention runs the entire month.
[0:09:13] Wheels in your yard to support Child Abuse Prevention.
[0:09:18] Sexual assault awareness also runs the entire month.
[0:09:22] Wear a tail ribbons in support of the work participate in dinner,
[0:09:27] which is scheduled for Wednesday, April 28th.
[0:09:30] Anization will be part of the support victims by participating in crimes,
[0:09:38] Victims Rights Week, which is this week, and you can also learn about on-org technology
[0:09:45] various prevention measures.
[0:09:52] Need to then share your required knowledge of safety measures with others.
[0:09:57] Discussion on Cryization.
[0:10:04] Resource support to our community-based agencies by donating goods, financial support.
[0:10:17] We're challenged to you now for ensuring the victims in our city have a supportive
[0:10:40] voice.
[0:10:43] Thank you.
[0:10:45] Thank you.
[0:10:46] Appreciate you staying on top of all this force and keeping us.
[0:10:48] Whereas in 1872, J.A. Stirling, Portland proposed to the Nebraska Board of Agriculture
[0:11:25] that a special day beset us to set aside for the plenty of trees.
[0:11:29] And whereas this holiday called Arbor Day, was first observed with plenty of more than
[0:11:35] a million trees in Nebraska, whereas Arbor Day is now observed throughout the nation and
[0:11:41] the world.
[0:11:42] And whereas trees can't reduce the erosion of our precious topsoil but wind and water,
[0:11:47] Cut foot heating and cooling costs, moderate the temperature, clean the air, produce oxygen, and provide habitat for wildlife and,
[0:11:55] whereas trees are a renewable resource given us paperwood for our homes, fuel for our fires, and countless other wood products and,
[0:12:05] whereas trees in our city increase property values, enhance the economic vitality of business areas and beautifier in our community,
[0:12:14] where as trees were ever they are planted are a source of joy and spiritual renewal
[0:12:21] but therefore i citizen hockensburg city to involves
[0:12:26] delight hereby proclaim friday april 30th 2021 as arbor day
[0:12:32] in the city of twin falls and are all citizens to celebrate arbor day
[0:12:37] and to support efforts to protect our trees and wetlands and further
[0:12:41] Our adults, citizens to plant trees to glad the heart and promote the well-billing of this and future generations
[0:12:48] into this 30th day of Suzanne Hockett.
[0:12:52] So that award will be presented at our Arbor Day celebration on April 30th.
[0:14:08] We will be down in Shofshon Falls Park at 4 p.m.
[0:14:12] afternoon the 30th at some trees and you're all invited to join us as the community as I was sitting on the parking lot
[0:14:22] Oh, figure out some way at the ticket booth that people that want to come and participate
[0:14:30] in Harvard, they'll just say that that's what they're there for and we'll make sure that
[0:14:34] people can get in.
[0:14:35] So, I guess we're meeting near the concession stand down in the shashon falls park.
[0:14:41] I don't know exactly where they're planning the trees.
[0:14:44] So, we'll meet there and or axon I think.
[0:14:48] United States of America is served by more than 1,300 community and technical colleges
[0:15:18] that have contributed significantly to the richness and accessibility of American higher
[0:15:25] education, and whereas over 40% of all American college students are attending a community
[0:15:33] college to pursue skill, training, career development, personal enrichment, or transfer operation,
[0:15:44] and whereas the American community colleges provide educational opportunities at cost
[0:15:49] and locations which support accessibility while maintaining accredited quality instruction,
[0:15:57] whereas the College of Southern Idaho has served the Magic Valley and the state of Idaho
[0:16:02] well since its inception and has been recognized for its excellence within the state, region
[0:16:08] and nation, whereas the College of Southern Idaho has transformed the economic landscape
[0:16:15] of its service region, the Magic Valley by developing education, economic and workforce
[0:16:21] developed seeking to assure qualified workforce for the region and throughout the state of
[0:16:26] Idaho, and whereas the college enriches the region through a community education,
[0:16:32] fine arts, which provide opportunities for its students and regional residents,
[0:16:40] and whereas the college was created by vote of the citizens of the counties of Twin
[0:16:46] Falls and Jerome, and the college opened on September 1, 1965, and whereas the
[0:16:53] college continues to serve the region's residents with the state of the art
[0:16:57] programs and services, whereas the American Association of Community College and the Association
[0:17:04] of Community College Trustees recognizes April each year as the Community College Month and
[0:17:11] encourages its national recognition. Now, therefore, I, Suzanne Hopkins, Mayor of the City of Twin Falls,
[0:17:18] do hereby proclaim the month of April 2021 College of Southern I.
[0:17:24] So we from Christopher Reed, seconded by Ruth Pierce to accept the consent calendar as presented this evening, the 6-0.
[0:21:06] So as always, everyone is very welcome to stay until the end of our meeting this evening.
[0:21:12] It's on your schedule, the Crazy Daisy Med Magic Valley Refugee Day, St. Edward E. Show,
[0:21:30] farmers market and the old twin falls tonight concert series so if you were
[0:21:36] here for any of those special events they were all just proved I guess I
[0:21:42] should say thank you to all the event sponsors because we appreciate everything
[0:21:47] you bring to our community consideration the evening the first item is a request
[0:21:56] to reappoint Curtis Hanson David Detweiler and Craig Kelly to the Planning
[0:22:01] and Zoning Commission and Jonathan Spinnlove is here to walk us through this one
[0:22:06] So first of all, I apologize for Kelly as our vice chairman for our partisan day and Craig
[0:22:23] have all served for three years. All the decisions that are brought from. So we, there is the area of impact.
[0:23:43] SIS-6-DIZ is also going to be presented by Jonathan Spindlove and it's a request to adopt
[0:23:51] Ordinance 2021-006 for the annexation and zoning district map amendment for the southwest corner
[0:24:01] of Federation Road in Washington.
[0:24:03] as requested by the council who made this decision on March 29th of 10th as brought,
[0:24:12] put it in city limits, and to...
[0:24:19] This has been the rules of place ordinance 2021 day 006.
[0:24:52] I'm third and final by title.
[0:24:55] 006 on 3rd and final year of 6, as of the city council of the city of Twin Falls, Idaho,
[0:25:33] annexing certain rail property below described,
[0:25:37] providing the zoning classification therefore,
[0:25:40] and ordering the necessary area of impact.
[0:25:43] Yes, Mayor, I move we adopt ordinance 2021-006 for the annexation and zoning district map amendment
[0:26:02] for the property located at the southwest corner, the Federation Road and Washington Street, North.
[0:26:09] Mr. Fareed. I'll second that, but I also just want to state that I won't be voting that were stated
[0:26:17] two weeks ago during the public here.
[0:26:19] I think that's a very important thing to do with that.
[0:27:18] I think that's a very important thing to do with that.
[0:28:08] I think that's a very important thing to do with that.
[0:28:13] I think that's a very important thing to do with that.
[0:28:15] I think that's a very important thing to do with that.
[0:28:22] I think that's a very important thing to do with that.
[0:28:25] I think that's a very important thing to do with that.
[0:28:29] I think that's a very important thing to do with that.
[0:28:31] I think that's a very important thing to do with that.
[0:28:33] I think that's a very important thing to do with that.
[0:28:38] I think that's a very important thing to do with that.
[0:28:43] I think that's a very important thing to do with that.
[0:28:47] I think that's a very important thing to do with that.
[0:28:49] I think that's a very important thing to do with that.
[0:28:51] The financial statements is written by your staff and financial statements that understand
[0:29:30] the city council this year as we work as a finance director with the just and the flexibility
[0:29:48] of the community.
[0:29:53] It's smooth because there's a lot of staff that carried over from parryers but also that
[0:30:14] this one falls has very qualified staff.
[0:30:20] Not always the case that this city has qualified staff that are able to.
[0:30:36] So, just the city is in a strong financial position.
[0:30:40] Now, there's some required things that we have to say.
[0:30:48] As for your financial statements, the tests that we perfect in findings.
[0:31:10] Working with staff or counties, taxes.
[0:32:00] That's right, right?
[0:33:39] We will say, we don't spend a lot of time.
[0:34:53] Point two, we are going to start with an overview of expenses,
[0:35:05] which are the water wastewater sanitation funds.
[0:35:09] We'll also talk about what's going on in the city.
[0:35:12] and stats compared to the nation, and some of our current expectations.
[0:35:19] This is just a snapshot.
[0:35:30] Our non-tax supported funds, which is like the enterprise funds, make up 40% of our budget at 31 million.
[0:35:38] 60% of our budget is our tax supported funds, which is right around 46 million.
[0:35:43] On the right side, this graph is showing the major fund revenue composition,
[0:35:48] which you can see the general fund makes up most of it at 38%,
[0:35:52] and the second two largest ones are waste water and water.
[0:36:01] Who, to dive into the potential expenses
[0:36:10] for our tax-supported funds are 64% general
[0:36:13] and streets at 20%, those are the top two.
[0:36:16] And on the right side, when you talk
[0:36:18] about the contributing revenue sources,
[0:36:20] 23 million, almost 24 million makes up
[0:36:23] our general fund revenues.
[0:36:26] Of all these funds, the top eight,
[0:36:29] the top six largest revenue sources
[0:36:31] make up 88% of our budget.
[0:36:34] The other 12% includes other items like permits,
[0:36:45] a tax history, and 18, you can see we started off
[0:36:49] around 20 million four years ago,
[0:36:51] and we've incrementally gone up to just under the 24 million.
[0:36:55] So we're a little different in 2021
[0:36:58] because of the care funding that we received
[0:37:00] with Governor Little's plan.
[0:37:02] If you remember, Kimberly, or Twin Falls, Kimberly,
[0:37:05] and people opted in, citizens,
[0:37:13] but will eventually become from 23 less than 5 million,
[0:37:29] which is 18 million, 642.
[0:37:32] So to date, we've actually received
[0:37:34] the combination of the CARES fund of the 5.2 million,
[0:37:38] in addition to the 11 million from citizens
[0:37:40] to total 16,496.
[0:37:43] Unfortunately, that's not comparable to the last four years,
[0:37:47] nor will it be as we go forward and we continue to know
[0:37:52] it is that we're close.
[0:37:54] We're 20 million, we start out 20 million,
[0:37:56] and then we incrementally go up
[0:37:57] I talked with Becky Peters and a Treasurer and collections are at 63.44% as opposed to last year 61.71%.
[0:38:10] This doesn't mean we're going to receive more. It just means that citizens are being another thing to note interesting in our property tax history collection.
[0:38:20] their lowest point in December of 2009, which is 54.4%, and that of those were delinquencies
[0:38:28] of 1.25%, which is only $187,000. Glad to say. Next slide shows our major revenue sources,
[0:38:45] beyond property taxes, our franchise fees, which Sean asked two questions last time,
[0:38:51] and I included two separate extra slides for him, so you're going to have to rip him a
[0:38:54] little bit because the next slide is one for him and he's not even here. So
[0:38:58] franchise fees are 1.7 million that we've budgeted and we've received 65% of
[0:39:04] those. See revenue sharing is interesting so we've got 56% as opposed to last
[0:39:15] year's 53% which doesn't actually mean we're going to receive more as of last
[0:39:20] year the state legislature changed the formula for calculating our revenue
[0:39:25] sharing aka our sales tax liquor revenues etc. So now each quarter distributions are
[0:39:32] capped at 1% when we look at the last 10 years we can see our sales tax revenue going up up up
[0:39:39] until we get to this quarter where we have that 1% cap. So the interesting about that is
[0:39:47] because of COVID we've seen a huge amount of spending on tangible goods that we would normally
[0:39:54] have gotten a much larger increase that ever going to see what actually happened and what we would
[0:40:00] receive. Recent economic snapshot, I read, says pent up demand, stimulus checks, more vaccinations,
[0:40:08] and easing of lockdown restrictions created conditions for the perfect consumer buying storm.
[0:40:13] On a monthly basis, March retail sales jumped to their highest level in 10 years.
[0:40:18] One percent revenue sharing. So what we will see in difference is highway revenue.
[0:40:29] Prior year was at 55 percent and we're at 63 percent because of COVID. We've seen more people
[0:40:36] are traveling and spending money on fuels. This is impacted by our current environment.
[0:40:40] This comes from vehicle registration fees, state fuel taxes, and other transportation related fees.
[0:40:46] Finds and for for sure if people are traveling, they're consuming fuel. So we could anticipate
[0:40:52] relatively conservatively that we are going to meet that three new franchise fees are what we
[0:41:07] we receive from re-utility companies, gas, electric, and cable.
[0:41:12] Cable is small, starts out at 77,000,
[0:41:16] and it has continuously gone down to where in 2021,
[0:41:20] we're only getting 67,000.
[0:41:22] We'll be interesting to see what we do
[0:41:24] and how we replace this component of our revenue
[0:41:28] in the future as people stop buying more cable.
[0:41:31] And it's interesting to me because I feel like
[0:41:34] it's a frustrating tax to me,
[0:41:36] Because it seems like it's our older generation that uses cable, and it's the younger generation
[0:41:40] that uses Netflix and streaming environments that there's no tax, so I'm curious to see
[0:41:45] if in the future I'd host starts taxing streaming systems like an Netflix or a Disney
[0:41:51] Plus.
[0:41:53] As an electric, we're the highest in 2018, we actually had a record high year in 2018
[0:42:02] because it's ranked as one of the coldest in history with daily record low temperatures
[0:42:06] December 27th or January 7th. Additionally, several cities throughout the nation set records
[0:42:12] per length of time for this cold spell. So, our budget to actual expenditures. Most of
[0:42:28] our expenditures in the general are in the tax-supported funds as personnel. It's the largest
[0:42:33] percent of our budget and comes in around 60% of the total budgeted. These are just under
[0:42:38] the 50% benchmark because the city pays most of its departments on a quietly pay scale.
[0:42:43] Home, which is maintenance and operations is a little bit over, but some of this is from the timing of purchases and not pro-rata through the year.
[0:42:52] Improvement, fund, we haven't spent a lot in our capital improvements. Most of this, if six million seven hundred three is Hankins Road and Seal Coding, we actually haven't started much of the Hankins Road and so we don't have much of the expenditures there.
[0:43:12] So even though we're at 17%, this is going to be a timing difference that'll start to realize itself later on.
[0:43:20] Transfers are significantly higher because we did our annual transfer from the general fund to the capital fund because of excess money that we had left over last year.
[0:43:31] In total, we're just under budget at 47%.
[0:43:42] Our building for Miss and Travis actually touched on this a couple of weeks ago are crazy.
[0:43:47] They're off the charts.
[0:43:48] the first quarter of fiscal year 2021, we've actually received 91.6 percent. So you may ask why
[0:43:55] did we budget so low, but if you remember, we get to spend what we budget because we're a zero-balancing
[0:44:02] budget. So if we anticipate two, three, four times the amount, we're going to spend two, three, four
[0:44:07] times the amount, which means we would end up using reserves and we would much rather be
[0:44:11] conservative with our budgeting than budget excess and spend more. We budgeted slightly down
[0:44:21] So in 2020, we had 1,120 if you go back in time and remember we had no idea that but that
[0:44:28] building was going to be off the charts.
[0:44:30] So we bunched a little bit down because we had no idea about COVID and what it was going
[0:44:34] to, well, considering how close we are to what we budgeted, almost meaning at that 1.1
[0:44:52] million, remember that these are the slowest months, October through March is typically
[0:44:57] our cold winter months, which means we have a lot more that we're potentially going to
[0:45:02] If we were to take a conservative approach and multiply this by 2 just a flat 1,048, that would indicate we'd have 2.1 million in revenue for fiscal year 2021, which would be about $950,000 extra in revenue, if everything was flat.
[0:45:22] This is the building permit history slide that I showed last time, which was interesting.
[0:45:32] in 2007, that's right before after the housing boom crash.
[0:45:37] However, you want to indicate,
[0:45:39] and you can see how we had a historically high year in 2020.
[0:45:44] We issued this year 306 new single family permits
[0:45:48] in the first half of the year,
[0:45:49] which if we help this, we just times it by two
[0:45:51] because we're 50% of the year,
[0:45:53] would make it 612 with everything else held constant.
[0:45:57] Last fiscal year, on our historically high year,
[0:46:00] We actually issued 573 for the entire year of new single family home permits.
[0:46:06] In 2007, we had 641 to shoot that out of the ball.
[0:46:14] Multifamily home starts of steadily declining in the nationwide reports, but not in the
[0:46:18] city of Twin Falls.
[0:46:19] Talking with Jonathan's been loved, Anticipates more multifamily homes as the prices of single
[0:46:25] family homes rise beyond our median income levels and what our recycling program.
[0:46:37] The last audit that we did was in July of 2020 at 6.25 million tons that were analyzed.
[0:46:46] The percentage on this top left one is only for 2020.
[0:46:50] I didn't want to clutter up the chart too much.
[0:46:53] What I do want you to pay attention to is the top three.
[0:46:55] OCC, which is cardboard, tin, and aluminum have increased.
[0:47:01] We've actually started recycling more of these and less of plastic, mixed paper, and trash.
[0:47:07] So that's a good thing.
[0:47:08] not so good is the next one down, the tons were cycled. In 2017 we had 967 tons per
[0:47:15] person per user account and we've steadily gone down but what one thing you
[0:47:20] want to notice from 2020 we we encourage citizens to stop we're not going to take
[0:47:26] plastic or paper or the things that trash because it's costing us too much
[0:47:30] money so what you do what you need to focus on is the 443 tons versus the
[0:47:35] So our population is increasing, but our tonnage is actually decreasing.
[0:47:41] Right, this program cost shows what we are paying with the 2021 six month numbers compared
[0:47:50] to just the bar of the prior full years.
[0:47:53] So for half the year, our total cost is 56,000, of which PSI pays 21 and we pay 34.
[0:48:01] In addition to the 34,000, we've also paid the landfill costs of almost 17,000.
[0:48:08] So it's costing the city just over 50,000, and we're seeing a decline.
[0:48:25] Your 10th recycled of the 2021, is that a half a year for a set of full year?
[0:48:30] Well, yes, I'm just curious because I think can answer that later.
[0:48:44] I was just curious if years and years and years and that's what I want.
[0:48:49] I think it is the first six months compared.
[0:48:52] These are the annual this was the annual cost. I think this is the first six months, but I will double check in
[0:48:58] Which means that we're about be where we're last year halfway through the halfway through the year
[0:49:03] Yes, so I'll confirm I'll clarify and make sure that's the case
[0:49:47] It's strictly cable, they're televisions, they're strictly intelligent.
[0:49:54] The state law is written so we can't change this.
[0:49:57] It's me, it would be to help us realize some lawyer time service as well as until the last time I have a FCC prohibition.
[0:50:20] There's something that franchise are established now through the Secretary of State's office, but we can check into other players besides this.
[0:50:31] to how we compare. So this is a, I've subscribed to the relative state quarterly report and I love this report.
[0:51:53] It's from investment banker, Piper Sandler, and it compares all of the states and the nation against each other.
[0:51:59] And it's really intuitive and informative. Idaho was actually ranked the highest in the nation in our financial strength index,
[0:52:06] which includes employment information, housing price index, state revenue, and pension funding ratios.
[0:52:13] In this, you can see in this heat map, there are 24 states that are actually negative and
[0:52:21] Illinois being the largest, so we've done well as far as most economists project the economy
[0:52:37] to grow in 2021 with a consensus forecast of 4.8% gain in this index for the year.
[0:52:44] Idaho's performance is driven by its top ranking in terms of housing prices with a 14.3% gain
[0:52:51] and tax revenues of 11.4% gain.
[0:52:58] His slide shows a chart that indicates our tax revenue gains,
[0:53:01] which is personal and corporate income tax,
[0:53:03] along with sales tax, on a year over year,
[0:53:06] rolling 12 month basis.
[0:53:08] Idaho and Illinois are at the top 11.4%.
[0:53:12] And the lowest is Alaska and North Dakota,
[0:53:16] which are two oil related states.
[0:53:23] The next couple of slides, what are other states doing?
[0:53:25] How are they trying to fill that gap?
[0:53:27] What measures do they have proposed
[0:53:28] or what have they implemented?
[0:53:30] California, so ongoing sales tax relief measures, California's extended a program that provides
[0:53:36] 12 month interest-free payment plans on sales tax. Massachusetts, Maryland, and Nevada have
[0:53:41] extended due dates. In new taxes, Maryland has enacted the first digital advertising tax in the
[0:53:49] country. Connecticut, Indiana, Massachusetts, New York, and Washington are all considering tax
[0:53:55] on digital ads in 2021. Wyoming may extend sales tax to streaming or subscriptions
[0:54:01] services. Nebraska may tax additional services and increase sales tax. Indiana, Kansas, and
[0:54:09] West Virginia have proposed higher taxes on tobacco and being proposed increases. In the
[0:54:18] sales tax rate, Mississippi has a bill that is introduced to eliminate income tax for single
[0:54:23] individuals earning up to 47,700 and increase the sales and use tax rate from 7% to 9.5%
[0:54:31] It makes you realize once again how lucky we are to be in 6% sales tax in addition to
[0:54:36] hearing our legislature possibly wanting to lower our sales tax.
[0:54:41] West Virginia is talking about having its state income tax, expanding the state sales
[0:54:46] tax base, increasing sales tax from 6.7% to 7.5% and imposing a luxury tax on anything
[0:54:54] over $5,000.
[0:54:55] In tax is a fun one. That's interesting to me on what you would consider a sin and what
[0:55:03] other people would not consider a sin. Sin tax covers everything from tobacco and alcohol
[0:55:08] to gambling. I even read an article where they potentially talked about having soda
[0:55:12] pop as a sin subject to sales tax. The article in the county says experts note that states
[0:55:19] have raised taxes on tobacco products 111 times between 2000 and 2014 states collectively
[0:55:28] got over 32 billion in syntaxes. New York has proposed marijuana attacks to legalize marijuana
[0:55:36] in 2021 and cover a potential 59 billion. We all know housing is crazy. It's astronomical how
[0:55:54] how high we've done. Nothing crisis remains strong through every say but Idaho again has
[0:56:00] are past them all. The US averages 7.7% I know as a 14.3% game. So I took a couple of
[0:56:09] stats from some different sources to show and I know Travis brought this up.
[0:56:12] In fact, Travis did quite a few of the things I was going to touch on a couple
[0:56:16] weeks ago. So I apologize for doing it again. Mine was already written, he copied.
[0:56:20] Him home values is 258,776. The prior year was 221,000. This is a 17% increase
[0:56:33] with a forecasted 8 to 10% increase in 2021. I also went out and got the MLS got
[0:56:40] some comparisons from MLS in 2018 there were 196 homes this is December of 2020
[0:56:48] of 18 there were 196 homes listed as opposed to 71 listed. If I say checked it
[0:56:54] was around 90 something that's listed in falls the average sales price in this 18
[0:57:01] timeframe was 219,639 as opposed to $267,515. Average price per square foot was $104.00 and
[0:57:11] now 100.
[0:57:17] Yeah, who published an article stating mortgage rates were on the rise for a six consecutive
[0:57:22] week in the week ending March 25th. Following a four basis price from the week prior, 30
[0:57:29] year fixed rates rose by a further eight basis points to 3.17%. According to a new analysis
[0:57:36] by Freddie Mac, the housing shortage, has now increased to 3.8 million.
[0:57:40] However, the reality is that builders and ultimately home buyers are facing rising costs
[0:57:46] that risk-restraining demand indeed lumber prices have recently risen to 1,200 per 1,000
[0:57:52] feet, which is now a new one.
[0:58:00] So this one is a fun one too, again I like national reports, we all hear that the Californians
[0:58:05] are moving in, will I have proof that Californians are moving in actually, the national HPI forecast
[0:58:11] from data analysis company CoreLogic, shows by mortgage applications for Boise by incoming
[0:58:16] state. California is at 57%, Washington is 10%, Oregon 6%, and Utah 5%. Atlas 2020,
[0:58:25] migration report showed Idaho top the list with the most inbound moves. 66.4% of inbound
[0:58:32] moves are to Idaho, the leader for the fourth time since 2000. The economic snapshot from
[0:58:39] Shot from Piper Sandler says, after ending 2020
[0:58:41] at their strongest monthly pace since 2006,
[0:58:44] housing starts posted in January,
[0:58:47] their first decline in five months.
[0:58:49] The decline was driven mainly by a drop
[0:58:50] in single family home construction
[0:58:53] that was partly offset by an increase in multifamily starts.
[0:58:57] However, the sharp rising costs for building materials
[0:59:00] along with regulatory concerns and rising interest rates
[0:59:03] could erode housing affordability in Texas
[0:59:15] where they were one of our insurers.
[0:59:18] So as soon as they come back on and says supply starts coming back out, we'll see a drop, but who knows when?
[0:59:26] And in my experience when people raise prices already, it's crazy high and people are still buying, so there's money.
[0:59:46] So, always fun to look at unemployment. We are at 2.6% as opposed to the national 6%. We're seeing.
[1:00:11] This starts our enterprise. Water is our first one. Our water is our largest one.
[1:00:20] We have anticipated $6.9 million of revenue from our water fund and we've received about
[1:00:26] 45.7% so we're at $3,163.
[1:00:30] Enterprise means that they are similar to a business without a profit motive so we charge
[1:00:36] fees for our service as opposed to collecting the taxes from property owners.
[1:00:42] We budgeted less in 2021.
[1:00:45] We went from $7.5 million to $6.9 million because we anticipated that with the shortage
[1:00:50] of money, people would actually be less concerned about watering their lawns than
[1:00:54] painted supplies. We've actually received about 300,000 more in 2021 because we have
[1:01:03] approximately 500 more water accounts than in 2020 and the consumption for all
[1:01:07] the water accounts is up over last year by just over 181 million. Number for you, I
[1:01:23] didn't write it up for you. I know exactly where it's at, I just don't have it with me.
[1:01:43] On the expenditure side, personnel is our largest expense in the water fund with
[1:01:51] about over 19% of our budget expense since being personnel related. Maintenance operations
[1:01:57] is under again but again that's timing versus when we'll actually spend it. We will spend
[1:02:02] it at just point in time. Because 20% of the total budget expenditures and some of the larger
[1:02:09] projects that we budgeted for are the Southwell number five construction and 2.1 million which
[1:02:14] is most of it and the next biggest thing is a digester boiler replacement for 550,000. Everything
[1:02:20] else are smaller items. We've only spent about 5% at this point in time. Our debt, we have
[1:02:28] two debt payments on both the water and wastewater and ones in March and one is in September of
[1:02:32] which March is interest only. So we're at a small percentage here that we'll catch up.
[1:02:37] Transfers are at 50%. So our total is 23.5% of expenditures.
[1:02:44] waste water is very consistent we budgeted 9.5 million we have 4.7 million so
[1:02:56] we're about 49% of what we have budgeted there's little fluctuation in our revenues
[1:03:01] and we're typically around 50% as you can see the last four years on the expenditure
[1:03:09] side on the wastewater we actually hire out our personnel so it is not the
[1:03:17] highest expense in the wastewater fund. We have budgeted personnel to be about 9% of the total expenditures
[1:03:24] and have spent 42.8% the first half of the year. Minnow is 55% is 480,000. So 40% halfway through.
[1:03:39] Our debt is small because we'll make the larger payment in September. Transfers are at 50%
[1:03:44] and we have total expenditures are $3.9 million, so 39% of what we have budgeted.
[1:03:57] Sanitation is the most consistent in the smallest of all of them, and it's relatively 50%.
[1:04:02] We've received $1.8 million in our budget of $3.5 million, and on the expenditure side,
[1:04:11] much simpler as well. There's no capital, and we have no debt in the sanitation side.
[1:04:16] We spent 40% of our M&L, 1.2 million, transfers at 50% and a total of 42%
[1:04:24] expended. When we cap 50% through our fiscal year 2021, we have revenues at 45%,
[1:04:32] expenditures at 23, waste water is 49%, expenditures at 39%, and sanitation is
[1:04:40] revenues of 52%, the expenditures of 42%.
[1:04:44] So we are on track and doing good discounts.
[1:05:03] In conversations about our accumulated reserves
[1:05:06] and our SNCC debt and how we can potentially pay that off,
[1:05:10] what it would mean, we've got interest at 700,000
[1:05:13] if we don't, if we keep it going,
[1:05:14] there's 7.6 million of debt left.
[1:05:18] There's quite a few things that we've talked about
[1:05:19] doing ongoing maintenance and stuff that I've listed here.
[1:05:23] We're going to be discussing this during our budget process this next few months, and determining what's the best use of our funds, where do we go, and what we'll be presenting to you, council.
[1:05:34] In addition, our fire truck lease, that was fully anticipated to pay off when we took it out a few years back. That's the presentation on our...
[1:05:50] I want to thank you. That was a very good presentation, and I didn't see any here in the headlights up here, so I appreciate that.
[1:06:12] person so I'm glad some of you are consistently smiling the whole time and not
[1:06:29] just rude I appreciate that it's all
[1:08:01] Wednesday afternoon, one o'clock, if they was interested.
[1:08:04] You might take what Terrell to see if there's room.
[1:08:07] But they're going to leave.
[1:08:09] Fish and game office in Jerome.
[1:08:12] One o'clock on Wednesday.
[1:08:14] It's Wednesday.
[1:08:17] The board means Thursday with the tours on Wednesday afternoon.
[1:08:21] The tours on one o'clock on Wednesday.
[1:08:25] The, um, thing to say, we've moved into this much still.
[1:08:46] It was nice to have, uh, we had our first meeting with all the new members on the
[1:08:57] Mark's a wreck board and Travis and Shane came in and scared to grab a phone up right off the metal. What's the shame about their responsibilities and what they can and can't do?
[1:09:11] Just be careful don't do that. Yes. I can see that this is gonna be a good board
[1:09:19] Some of the new members started making not making but even making motions and things
[1:09:23] So I think they're going to be getting down the ground here pretty quick.
[1:09:27] The older members were in name of Vice Chairman as you might expect.
[1:09:32] Denise Park in rec reservations are your money now. It's $10 per person.
[1:10:39] You do get a t-shirt if you registered it before the event.
[1:10:42] You are welcome to show up the day of, but you will not get a t-shirt for the color.
[1:10:46] Life is worth living before we exist.
[1:10:58] And lots of hoping some of my fellow Council members can come out.
[1:11:03] I know Vice Mayor Pierce has agreed to help with the registration table that day of and
[1:11:09] she will need some support there, we'll need help with giveaways, but what we really need
[1:11:14] are our adults to show up next to our youth and they really need to know that we care
[1:11:23] about them.
[1:11:24] So everyone in the community is invited to come stand with our youth and let them know
[1:11:29] that we've all been there, we've all been through it and it's worth an invitation to
[1:11:37] to help support the youth, our council is everybody good,
[1:12:45] which is a request to make a presentation
[1:13:11] of the request and analysis,
[1:13:18] ask questions of the end or staff,
[1:13:23] ask the public opportunity to or ask questions
[1:13:31] about the request.
[1:13:32] This evening we will be limiting those
[1:13:34] to three, may at least step up to the public state
[1:13:39] your name and your address and present
[1:13:40] your comments or concerns.
[1:13:42] Before you leave this evening,
[1:13:44] there is a sign of sheet in the address there
[1:13:49] for the comments are concluded,
[1:13:53] the applicant will have a chance
[1:13:54] to answer any questions and make a closing statement.
[1:13:58] Staff will then answer or clarify any comments as needed.
[1:14:03] We'll close the public hearing
[1:14:04] and no further testimony or comments
[1:14:06] will be allocated as first one for us.
[1:14:22] We will start with the city's presentation.
[1:14:24] We have Lisa Strickland.
[1:14:34] This is a request to vacate the Platid sewer easement
[1:14:37] that is located on the south side
[1:14:39] of lots six through 14 block one
[1:14:41] of the fieldwood subdivision lots here.
[1:14:50] The sewer easement was originally planted
[1:14:52] When the Fieldstone Professional Subdivision was done,
[1:14:57] this has since been re-platted as the Fieldwood Subdivision
[1:15:00] to construct a residential development.
[1:15:03] Originally, Chaney Drive West was not an option
[1:15:05] when the Fieldstone Professional Subdivision East was plotted,
[1:15:08] and since then, Chaney Drive West was constructed,
[1:15:11] and Sura was extended through Chaney Drive West.
[1:15:15] When the reconfiguration occurred
[1:15:16] for the Fieldwood Subdivision, the decision was to connect the sewer
[1:15:20] In River Mist Path to the sewer and chaney drive west for the development of the newly configured lots.
[1:15:27] So if you look on the map, the sewer was here, chaney was constructed, and it was connected from here to the sewer and chaney.
[1:15:41] This easement was planted originally as a sewer easement, so there are not any other utilities within this easement.
[1:15:49] As required for a vacation request, all the utilities have been notified and there are
[1:15:57] no issues with the vacation of the planet Eastman.
[1:16:00] The Eastman is approved if approved for vacation when we come part of the lots of budding the
[1:16:06] north side of the Eastman and all of these property owners have given their consent to
[1:16:10] move forward with this request.
[1:16:12] Upon conclusion, the Planning and Zoning Commission made a unanimous recommendation to
[1:16:16] to approve the request to the council on March 23rd, 2021.
[1:16:21] And the council is tasked with making the decision
[1:16:24] to approve, approve with conditions,
[1:16:26] table the request for more information,
[1:16:28] or deny the request.
[1:16:30] This concludes my presentation.
[1:16:32] I'll stand for any questions.
[1:16:33] And if you have none,
[1:16:34] the applicant's representative is here to present their request.
[1:16:41] I'll leave this so we will move.
[1:16:58] So, I'll leave the other conversation now.
[1:18:36] Okay, the south of Chienidron.
[1:18:51] second it makes the six to zero acres CRO to MR6 CRO CDA for property located at
[1:19:32] the five falls drive. It is requesting to R4 CRO and R6 CDA. This property is
[1:20:02] located at four CRO and R6. The on this map is zone R4 CRO and then the southern
[1:20:21] or 2016 comprehensive plan doesn't exist as areas of excuse which is
[1:20:31] described as a mix of but not let me existing surrounding properties are residential to the
[1:20:44] west and east and the loud the subject property this is the concept plan access on the west side
[1:21:48] from Harrison Street but the change this was our four and our six they permit attached
[1:22:15] single-family households fronting arterial and collector streets or single-family just six are
[1:22:47] actually measures will also be developed this way as to your single-family exit
[1:26:51] the discussion was a right intersection. First of all, it's lower density than what was approved.
[1:27:26] Castle that, absolutely. This is to me, to the issue, and it's our desire to aesthetic
[1:28:14] illiterate sin. So, in case you have maintenance at the entrance of the pasto, that's a tough
[1:29:27] form of Costco we can see a little better. Although, as you're your first question drive or
[1:30:11] and since Caten falls, that isn't planted.
[1:30:13] As I was the engineer for Costco,
[1:30:28] and the city council condition requirement
[1:30:31] is where Planetos Shrops screen the back of the Costco building.
[1:30:35] So, I'm certain that Costco, preserving
[1:30:48] or has seen the view quite intersection.
[1:30:51] But it is a tax asset, it is the infill product.
[1:32:06] They want to save for their patrons too.
[1:32:08] I appreciate it, Joe.
[1:32:11] The questions, check the CME.
[1:33:10] It was several years, I appreciate that.
[1:33:18] And again, that intersection with City, that intersection really concerns me.
[1:33:24] Having on Saturday concept and fit, certainly the concern that has been expressed on one side of that.
[1:34:45] I guess I did have something else to say.
[1:34:47] So we will go ahead and close the public hearing at this time and turn it over to the council for conversation or decisions.
[1:34:58] 3-10 plus for me to say here's from our 4-6 CRO to our 4-6 CRO ZD-8 for property located at the 500 block of Canyon Falls Drive
[1:35:18] this is a cure of jail Martens in behalf of concept investors.
[1:35:30] Craig Hawkins.
[1:35:31] I second.
[1:35:32] A motion from Greg Lansing seconded by Craig Hawkins to approve the request as presented.
[1:35:39] This is a request to an access easement.
[1:36:21] access and public utility easement on the subject property, which is best known as the River
[1:36:32] and this property is part of the North Bridge number two, 229P. The purpose of this vacation
[1:36:43] is to accommodate the addition of a five-day existing development that shows the existing
[1:36:54] 26-foot wide easement, which is located on the southwest portion of the subject property.
[1:37:00] So this is showing the top area that is what they're for place, what they're being. So
[1:37:12] So there's still going to be a ditch I just want to go.
[1:37:32] Let's just show you guys how in this site plan.
[1:37:42] So that's where the five pucks is going.
[1:37:57] In addition to that, on the south side,
[1:38:00] they're adding new spaces, plus three.
[1:38:08] And then originally, you're required to have 360 total parking
[1:38:20] stalls, which is two stalls per unit.
[1:38:22] And then in addition, there were a couple of visitors
[1:38:24] spaces they needed.
[1:38:29] So with these parking spaces, we can take you away.
[1:38:37] So they're over March 23rd.
[1:40:13] Get some type.
[1:40:16] We also doing so by the sidewalk.
[1:41:41] Recycler, trash area, part of their relic, something that you see on the south of just an addition of some area there that was basically...
[1:42:23] Fairly from with this, uh, this is a area that they've losing three up there where the new stuff's going to exit.
[1:42:43] The driveway is where the trash used to be between the two, and then that was parking spots there where you're not going.
[1:42:51] That's absolutely correct.
[1:42:52] The correct clues that that's not actually a plus tree back there, then if you lose straight to the front.
[1:42:57] Well, the plus tree is where the trash enclosure was.
[1:43:12] The bottom one continues to start with this development,
[1:43:29] because of all the parking that ends up out on the street from it,
[1:43:33] and if we didn't lose any tree up at the front,
[1:43:36] it's going to mean three more cars parked down the street for some concern,
[1:43:40] and so that is my concern with this development.
[1:43:44] I think the other one is a little light as well, so I'm just wishing they could find a team for this. I know they're probably over the limit.
[1:43:53] It's just so many cars. Park, I visit a person there on occasion.
[1:43:59] And the parking spots that we still have 40 cars parked on the street, so it's very concerning to me that we're just not going to increase parking in the front.
[1:44:12] Not just increase parking in the back, because then every side built in D.
[1:44:19] More people aren't going to. They're just going to park on the street.
[1:44:23] And I think part of that, I'm just getting a person who's actually, and there's no parking there, there's no parking there to park almost any part of the time of the day.
[1:44:59] That parking lot is almost always full. That parking lot is the coolest future resident most of the time.
[1:45:14] It's makes it even, sure, as I've said, I've been, and we get the girls right off.
[1:45:32] We discussed when this newer portion was going in that we were not going to allow parking on that curve, is that still a case or?
[1:45:39] That's correct. Okay. All right. Thank you.
[1:45:41] Any other questions or comments?
[1:45:58] This issue this evening.
[1:46:00] Guys, because you're there.
[1:46:01] I'm sorry.
[1:46:02] Hey, I move.
[1:46:27] We vacate.
[1:46:28] We grant the request of a cate a portion of the planet access and public utility easement
[1:46:34] for the property located at 2-0-1-3 Rivercrest Drive.
[1:46:39] Here, VHM on behalf of our comms.
[1:46:43] Christopher Eats, peer segment Christopher Eats has presented 6-0.
[1:47:10] Shoutout, happy birthday to my grandsons, Zachary David.
