Oversight Archive: City Council meeting, 2021-05-17, recording 1 (started 16:59)
Machine transcript (faster-whisper base.en), not checked word for word; the Pledge of Allegiance is shown in its standard wording. The recording is the record.
Times are time into the recording. Passages with private details are muted in the audio and marked here.
The audio on the page below was re-encoded by software from the video the agency posted. Check any passage against
that audio before relying on it.
Page: https://oversightarchive.org/twin-falls-id/meetings/2021-05-17/

[0:01:13] meeting of the Twin Falls City Council. At this time I would like to call the meeting
[0:01:18] to order and confirm that we do have a quorum. We have all seven members in person this evening.
[0:01:24] If you would like to join us for the Pledge of Allegiance, please rise. Thank you. I have
[0:01:49] to tell you, this is really exciting to see such a good-looking crowd out there tonight.
[0:01:53] All the smiling faces, we appreciate everyone being with us.
[0:01:57] Before we move on to our proclamations, I'm taking the mayor's liberty this night and adding on to our agenda.
[0:02:05] So at this time I would like to ask Travis Rothweiler, Mitch Humble, and Gretchen to please come forward and if you would face the council, I know all three of you just love this kind of stuff, so you'll have to bear with us.
[0:02:33] from our team of people who award commitment coins for things that our staff does.
[0:02:44] And I'm just going to read you briefly what was submitted.
[0:02:48] The coronavirus outbreak of 2020 thrusts the world into an environment of uncertainty and fear.
[0:02:54] As we watched states shut down and stay home orders being acted,
[0:02:58] Travis, excuse me, Mitch, and Gretchen realized that the pandemic was something that our organization
[0:03:05] had never had caused a plan for.
[0:03:08] Without set guides or policies, our leadership team was tasked with the insurmountable task
[0:03:14] of creating a plan that would allow the employees to remain safe from exposure and help them
[0:03:20] through a positive diagnosis while also maintaining the level of service that our customers, our
[0:03:26] citizens have come to expect.
[0:03:29] An internal leadership team was gathered by Travis Mitch and Gretchen and through these
[0:03:34] meetings an emergency paid sick leave policy was created that provided 184 employees with
[0:03:42] the time and resources to care not only for themselves but also for their families.
[0:03:48] They advocated for our employees to be creative problem solvers and supported department leadership
[0:03:53] throughout the process.
[0:03:55] the closure of City Hall to the public, they ensured that our employees had the equipment
[0:04:00] and resources to work remotely, including being advocates for utilizing Microsoft Teams
[0:04:06] to continue public meetings. Through their actions, we believe that Travis, Mitch, and
[0:04:11] Gretchen embody the city core value of commitment. Each has shown that they appreciate that each
[0:04:18] individual is an investment and they will provide the necessary tools and resources and
[0:04:24] have advocated for the health and safety of everyone. This part is now from me. On
[0:04:32] behalf of the Council, I want to personally add our appreciation for the
[0:04:36] guidance and leadership that Travis mentioned Gretchen provided to us as well
[0:04:40] as to staff. I know this is a small token of our appreciation, but please know that
[0:04:46] it comes from a deep place of respect and gratitude. I know you three well
[0:04:51] enough to know that you do not want public recognition, but it is important for us
[0:04:55] us to have the chance to say thank you for your leadership.
[0:04:58] It's time, a lot of family here, and I think it's important the family supports everything
[0:06:56] that we ask of these folks here in the time we take.
[0:06:59] So this is going to be crazy, but I'd really like to have all the family members come up
[0:07:03] and join us for a picture as well.
[0:07:05] So everybody in that's related, come on up.
[0:07:08] And at this time, I have my husband, Dave, with me, to Dave, would you come up, please?
[0:07:12] Yes.
[0:07:13] If I can embarrass these guys, I can embarrass you too.
[0:07:19] Can you see?
[0:07:48] So I just want to say thank you very much
[0:09:02] It is an honor to work here and to serve the public and
[0:09:08] To represent you and the trust that you give us and I'm really proud to be a part of the organization
[0:09:15] And thank you for the recognition. I have my family here and those of you guys that know me know that I
[0:09:23] Live for my family everything I do is for them
[0:09:26] And it means a lot of fun.
[0:09:28] You go in front of them all here.
[0:09:30] So thank you very much.
[0:09:40] So before I turn the microphone over to Mitch, Gretchen and Travis, you need to understand
[0:09:44] that Mitch is really the brains behind this.
[0:09:47] And out of three of you, he is probably the most taken aback because he thought he was presenting
[0:09:52] this to you guys tonight.
[0:09:54] Right?
[0:09:55] I was just going to say it's about time you guys were making this up.
[0:10:01] 15 years
[0:10:51] for this, but I appreciate the opportunity to be here in the council and in this community.
[0:11:01] It's pretty awesome. So as everyone knows, I have this. I am so many more of us that worked
[0:11:44] through this process that day in and day out were exposed to things far potentially more dangerous
[0:11:54] than what I did from my office. I appreciate the recognition, but I will tell you that we're
[0:12:01] because of the men and women and the support that we have and some of them are here this evening and some are going to receive
[0:12:11] new opportunities to be part of our employee family, the ones for every single day to try to measure to them, try to reach that standard
[0:12:39] and blessed to have my family here, I leaned over to Mitch and I said, why are they here?
[0:12:46] and I looked over and I saw Gretchen's family and I said, well why are they here?
[0:12:52] And then Mitch's family walked down the stairs and he looked at me and said, I don't know
[0:12:59] what we appreciate everyone being here to help celebrate. We appreciate the council and I think it's been said that
[0:13:06] we're blessed to work for a phenomenal organization and I do appreciate the leadership that this council provides
[0:13:15] and the opportunities that you provide to us to help create a better Twin Falls.
[0:13:21] Thank you to everyone who allowed us the time to sneak that into our agenda this evening.
[0:13:37] We are going to move forward and this evening we do have a proclamation and our proclamation today is for Hope Day.
[0:13:47] Whereas adverse childhood experiences, known as ACEs or ACEs, such as abuse, neglect, and
[0:13:57] serious household dysfunction, or other events that cause trauma in children's lives, can
[0:14:04] have lifelong impact on physical and mental health.
[0:14:08] And whereas studies have shown that people who experience multiple ACEs are more profoundly
[0:14:14] impacted and whereas Idahoans have experienced four or more ACEs at a higher
[0:14:22] rate than much of the broader United States and whereas positive childhood
[0:14:27] experiences such as forming strong relationships with a trusted adult
[0:14:32] experiencing belonging and building coping skills to deal with stress in a
[0:14:38] healthy way have been proven to counter the impact of ACEs and whereas those
[0:14:44] experiences, promote healthy outcomes from positive experiences, or hope, and
[0:14:50] whereas Idahoans have shared values in ensuring the physical and mental health
[0:14:56] and well-being of children, and whereas May is Mental Health Awareness Month. Now
[0:15:03] therefore, I, Suzanne Hawkins, Mayor of Twin Falls, do proclaim May 21st 2021 to be
[0:15:10] Hope Day in the City of Twin Falls and this evening we have Kevin Sandow and
[0:15:16] Kylie, Kylie always say your name wrong off to receive this proclamation and they
[0:15:22] are going to come up and share with us a little bit about what Hope Day is. Thank
[0:16:05] you for having us. I am here representing Brutter Group Kevin and I together. We are
[0:16:11] a part of our Children's Mental Health Subcommittee for Region 5 which is a
[0:16:14] sub-community to our Region 5 behavioral health board and as a part of that group
[0:16:18] we have partnered with Idaho Resilience Project and really want to do as Suzanne said and build
[0:16:24] hope in our communities. And through that May 21st, we've led off an effort. Optivide-Oho
[0:16:29] has really lifted it off to give up 10,000 kites across the state of Idaho for people.
[0:16:34] Adults especially to partner with kiddos and help them fly a kite. It's sort of symbolic
[0:16:39] in a sense of really helping people who are struggling to lift their wings and adult to come
[0:16:44] underneath the child and help them sort of guide them to get that kite flying and thrive and be
[0:16:49] resilient on their own. So feel like we chose the right night to be here watching what you just did.
[0:16:54] That's what hope and positive experiences are about. It's just lifting up our community to be
[0:16:59] its best self. So that's what it's all about. I have some kites at the door. So Kevin and I brought
[0:17:03] those two sort of share with the crowd and yourselves to encourage everyone to fly kite
[0:17:08] with a kill and use the hashtag hope list here for social media if you do that to sort of promote
[0:17:15] that and encourage that across the state and you'll see images across the state of Idaho
[0:17:19] from that day of kiddos flying kites with adults who are there to mentor and support them.
[0:17:25] That's why I had her go first. She just said it all. Now we appreciate you
[0:17:30] having us here tonight and really what a perfect night that was exceptional and
[0:17:35] what an amazing community we have and this is just another opportunity for this community to lift
[0:17:41] lift up other people that might be struggling so thank you thank you we appreciate you being
[0:17:46] here this evening so just to tag on to that kevin was present saturday at the teen suicide
[0:17:58] prevention color run that we had and i believe we gave out three hundred kites that day as well so
[0:18:06] we gave out a lot of kites um if you would like to give them maybe to our um chief king's berry
[0:18:14] back there. I bet he can help distribute kites for us. Thank you. Yes, if you families want to leave, we understand. Except you're going to miss a really neat ceremony coming up with firefighters taking their oath of office. So just say, moving forward, we are going to continue on with our items of our with our consent calendar. Sorry, I was about ready to skip it. And I will turn it over to the Council for Council wishes.
[0:19:01] Mr. Fareed. Move to approve the consent calendar. Second. We have a motion from Christopher
[0:19:11] Reid seconded by Ruth Pierce to accept the consent calendar as presented. Amy
[0:19:17] roll call vote please. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Motion passes
[0:19:31] 7-0. First item tonight under our items of consideration is a request from our
[0:19:39] Fire Chief Leskin-worthy to recognize three new firefighters after the completion
[0:19:46] of their TFFD's Academy graduation. We will be administering their oath and
[0:19:51] pinning on their matches this evening. Or is it Admiral? Personally Chief sounds
[0:20:01] better but again like I said to the council, you guys can call me what everybody
[0:20:07] Thank you Madam Mayor and Council, just like I've said in the past, when we do this sort
[0:20:16] of thing, this is one of the probably more fun things as a fire chief that I get to do
[0:20:21] and that's celebrate new employees and tonight on top of that, we're going to celebrate actually
[0:20:28] the conclusion of the second fire academy that we've had in the fire department here
[0:20:34] So before I show you a little video, since we have a little time tonight, I just want to just talk a little bit about our strategic plan.
[0:20:46] So in the Fire Department's strategic plan, Focus Area 3 and other secure community.
[0:20:51] One of the first bullet points in 1.1 is that we will maintain public safety at the highest practical level.
[0:21:04] Part of doing that is providing the training for our new firefighters as they come in prior
[0:21:14] to us having a full-time training officer and having some capabilities of doing this.
[0:21:23] We brought our firefighters on basically as learn as you go type of a program.
[0:21:28] And that's not ideal in how to train new firefighters across the nation.
[0:21:34] Typically, most fire academies last between eight and 16 weeks.
[0:21:40] One of our members that I'll talk a little bit about tonight just left us and went to
[0:21:44] Boise and Eegis is concluding a 16-week academy.
[0:21:47] So this year we're gradually moving forward and increasing our training and this year
[0:21:55] we were able to do a six-week academy. These gentlemen tonight have graduated
[0:21:59] from that academy, and I'll show you a little snippet. So, let me take just a
[0:22:04] moment. We, this is just a really small touch at what they did, but kind of fun
[0:22:13] for their families to see, and hopefully you. I saw a couple little mistakes in
[0:25:37] their guys, the kinks. We don't want kinks. No, they did a good job. Our training
[0:25:45] the officer training captain and our crews helped with that academy. We continue to make
[0:25:52] it better. So again, I'd like to thank the council because we wouldn't be able to do
[0:25:57] what we did without your support. We also, as you know, are in the initial stages of building
[0:26:04] a training center and again, that wouldn't have occurred without the support from this council.
[0:26:10] So thank you for that.
[0:26:12] I think I'll have these gentlemen come down forward in front of him. I'll do oats and
[0:26:17] heading out their badge. So
[0:26:35] This is kind of a unique group in that two of their fathers
[0:26:42] were passed
[0:26:44] in public safety employees. So Bo Poland, his father, was a police officer for 20 plus years in the city of Twin Falls.
[0:26:52] And
[0:26:54] Mr. Poland, if you don't mind me saying this,
[0:26:57] I'm glad you talked some sense into your son and joined the fireside because we all know that
[0:27:03] please and fire have one thing in common and that is they both want to be firefighters.
[0:27:09] So you did well.
[0:27:12] So let's start with Cody Albert.
[0:27:21] He's Cody if you just raise your hand there you're in the middle.
[0:27:25] He's 26 year old.
[0:27:27] Can I say that?
[0:27:28] I don't know if that's the information.
[0:27:30] 26 years old, originally from Connecticut, he attended Central Connecticut State University
[0:27:37] where he received a bachelor's degree in exercise science, great fit for the fire service.
[0:27:43] Following college, he trained half-leats and worked for the Forest Service.
[0:27:48] Some hobbies that Cody loves to do on his off-time or mountain biking, snowboarding, and rock climbing.
[0:27:55] We'll let them introduce their families when we get through the pinning.
[0:28:02] One of his comments just, I should share this too, he says he's extremely grateful for this
[0:28:06] opportunity to work for the City of Twin Falls Fire Department.
[0:28:09] He looks forward to serving the community and helping keep it safe.
[0:28:13] Next up is Bo Poem.
[0:28:16] Bo has been pretty active so far for his first few months of being online.
[0:28:23] He's had some pretty significant incidents and not all fun and game incidents.
[0:28:32] They're all doing a great job.
[0:28:33] So, Bo was born in race in Twin Falls, he graduated from Twin Falls High School in 2013.
[0:28:40] After graduating, he continued his education, the College of Southern Idaho, and obtained
[0:28:45] his associate's degree in criminal justice and in health science.
[0:28:49] Bo spends most of his free time outdoors hunting, fishing, riding dirt bikes.
[0:28:55] One important goal of his, and his career is to gain as much experience as he can to
[0:29:01] continuous education and training. He continues, or he, excuse me, always has had a natural
[0:29:09] desire and commitment to serve others within the community. And hopefully that was the
[0:29:16] community he was raised in, and so far it looks like you're on that track. Next up is Luke.
[0:29:21] So Luke's dad was a former Twin Falls firefighter. He's unable to attend tonight because he's
[0:29:28] He was born and raised in Twin Falls, he spent the last 13 years in Boise, we won't hold
[0:29:41] that against you.
[0:29:44] Idaho where he started a family earned his bachelor's degree and worked behavioral intervention
[0:29:50] with individual suffering from mental health issues.
[0:29:56] In Luke's free time he was spending time with his family doing outdoors activities and staying
[0:30:04] activities and staying active.
[0:30:07] He's grateful for the opportunity to work for the Twin Falls Fire Department.
[0:30:11] It looks forward to serving this awesome community.
[0:30:18] So with that, if we could have the mayor come down and mayor and council and everybody else,
[0:30:28] we have shortened this a little bit, but we still try to keep the key components.
[0:30:33] And so hopefully this keeps our meeting, but maybe a little more easy to raise your right
[0:30:46] We're going to try to break this up.
[0:30:51] I state my name, due here by declare, that as a member of the Twin Cross Fire Department,
[0:31:07] my duty is to serve the people I swear to protect, the safeguard and preserve life, health
[0:31:21] and property against fire and other perils.
[0:31:28] I will uphold the standards of my profession, continually searching for new and improved
[0:31:36] methods of serving the people and will share my knowledge and skill with my colleagues and
[0:31:47] descendants. I recognize the badge of my office as a symbol of public faith and trust. I recognize
[0:32:05] the badge of my office as a symbol of public faith and trust and I accept so long as I am true
[0:32:24] to the ethics of the fire service. I will uphold the values and leadership philosophy
[0:32:34] of the City of Twin Falls. I will constantly strive to achieve the objectives and ideals
[0:32:49] that the fire service instills, dedicating myself to saving lives, preventing and suppressing
[0:33:05] fires and performing other duties enacted and placed upon me. I accept this self-imposed
[0:33:22] and self-enforced obligation as my responsibility and make these promises so solemnly, freely,
[0:33:39] and upon my honor. Congratulations, we made it true.
[0:33:45] And one of the traditions in Byron and police services to allow if you have a father, sometimes
[0:34:05] other family members in the service to allow them to pin their badge on.
[0:34:10] So with that, again, Luke's father couldn't make it tonight but both his father's here.
[0:34:15] So Mr. Pullman, if you would come down and we'll pin badges, Council City Management,
[0:35:23] late these gentlemen.
[0:35:24] Command staff, if I could have you come down, I think we'll keep everybody else in just
[0:36:04] in the light of time, and then we can do this the rest outside.
[0:36:08] Command staff, if I can have you come down and congratulate
[0:36:11] these gentlemen, too.
[0:36:13] Actually, we have time.
[0:36:14] Guys, come on down.
[0:36:15] This is a celebration night.
[0:36:17] It's a night of hope.
[0:36:18] Introduce your families.
[0:36:48] Families here.
[0:36:50] They're all going, right?
[0:36:51] So your family, Cody, is on the back.
[0:36:53] Go ahead and do it.
[0:36:55] Introduce your note.
[0:37:21] Congratulations.
[0:37:22] And we're looking forward to hearing great things
[0:37:24] from the future.
[0:37:26] And if Chief Kenworthy would like to come back.
[0:37:30] At this time, we are going to recognize our Firefighter
[0:37:34] Officer of the Year for 2019.
[0:37:38] Now you might wonder, 2019, we're in 2021.
[0:37:42] Typically the way we have done Firefighter of the Year Fire
[0:37:45] Officer of the Year is we do this at our annual banquet.
[0:37:50] So last year, as you know, we didn't have one.
[0:37:54] And we're kind of a few months off from when we choose it
[0:37:57] and when we celebrate it.
[0:37:58] So 2019 would have happened in 2020,
[0:38:01] and so here we are in 2021.
[0:38:03] So we've already done this in-house,
[0:38:05] but I think it's important to recognize these individuals
[0:38:09] at the council level and let you see them
[0:38:14] and let them do a speech in front of you.
[0:38:16] Yeah.
[0:38:17] Yeah.
[0:38:18] So I'll have, first of all, Eric Schmidt's come down
[0:38:23] for the fire officer of the year.
[0:38:27] Eric, if you can come down.
[0:38:30] Eric is our newest battalion chief. Eric's been a battalion chief now almost two years goes fast.
[0:38:39] This just talk a little bit about this award. These awards are chosen by their peers. So
[0:38:45] all the firefighters in the department get to choose or get to vote on who's the fire officer
[0:38:50] year. Of the fire officers, everybody's included in that that are uniform except for me. And this is
[0:38:58] is when you move up the ranks, as you get into the officer ranks and your battalion chiefs,
[0:39:06] it becomes a little more difficult because you're in between that kind of a more of a
[0:39:10] management position that's still more of a company position.
[0:39:14] So when I saw Eric being nominated and won the officer of the year, that really says something
[0:39:23] to me as far as how his crew thinks about him as a leader and how he interacts with
[0:39:32] them and how he's doing day-to-day business. Eric's doing a great job. All of our battalion
[0:39:39] chiefs are doing a great job. We're doing a lot of cultural changes in our department.
[0:39:45] They're doing a great job at that. Eric just gives you a little bio on what he does.
[0:39:50] He is his area of responsibility in the fire department, his policy and procedure and training, so he oversees training, he also manages our policy.
[0:39:59] He's also under health and safety, he's initiated a fitness program for our firefighters that we finally got through and got started last year, which is phenomenal.
[0:40:11] And I think he's talked about that a little bit in his, in our annual report, but that's some really good work.
[0:40:17] He's also, and this is not exciting in this part, you might have got
[0:40:20] unnominated for by doing policy. It's not one of the most exciting things, but Eric had over,
[0:40:27] he worked over 130 policies or something like that, and then some procedures as well. So he continues
[0:40:33] to work on that. It's a big project, but he continues to do that. So again, he's got great leadership
[0:40:42] qualities, good interpersonal qualities with his crew and fellow firefighters and so
[0:40:48] with that Eric was the 2019 fire officer of the year. Congratulations, no speech, congratulations.
[0:41:10] He's not here anymore, let me do this. Unfortunately for us, I spoke about before,
[0:41:30] last Andrew Merriman to Boise Fire Department about three months ago. He left and went to Boise
[0:41:42] and so we kind of had to speed this thing up and get his award to him before he left. But Andrew,
[0:41:48] I'd like to report his finishing as an academy in Boise. He still communicates with us quite often
[0:41:57] And I'm sure Andrew will in the future somehow contribute to our organization.
[0:42:03] He's a good man.
[0:42:04] So thank you to stay.
[0:42:12] But if you would like to leave before we start talking about a Title III rewrite, I know it's exciting stuff.
[0:42:21] Sure.
[0:42:22] We're going to have a moment.
[0:42:23] Sergeant Poland, one of the things I miss on the western age parade is I usually ride the fire truck all the way then and walk back.
[0:42:31] see the crate and you were always the person there on the corner around the
[0:42:34] shell up a little like some and so show when I miss that you're having a great
[0:42:39] retirement. Well we can bring it back. So next we are gonna have Jeanne Higgins
[0:43:00] present to us on a request. I guess it's an update and she's looking for feedback
[0:43:06] on the Title III, Chapter 14.
[0:43:10] Right, we've been working on it.
[0:43:12] This section is on transient merchants,
[0:43:15] inter-solicitors, and peddlers.
[0:43:19] I hope I got everything in there.
[0:43:27] Thank you.
[0:43:34] This is an update process that we've made
[0:43:39] in the Title III, specifically Chapter 14.
[0:43:43] And this has been a team effort.
[0:43:45] We have had tremendous support
[0:43:46] from the City Manager's Office,
[0:43:48] the Police Department,
[0:43:52] and zoning specifically, Jonathan's been low,
[0:43:55] and so this evening we are going to share with you
[0:44:04] how kind of an update of where we are at,
[0:44:06] going to look for some feedback from you
[0:44:08] on some of the proposed changes
[0:44:10] and get an idea of where we move.
[0:44:13] Also get some feedback on how some things
[0:44:16] are currently written in enforcement of those things.
[0:44:20] So tonight, we're not asking you to take any action
[0:44:24] because there is fingerprinting involved
[0:44:26] with this particular chapter.
[0:44:29] Any language that we do has to go through the FBI
[0:44:31] because it's typed. So throughout our review our primary focus has been safety,
[0:44:41] welfare, and the privacy of our residents. We are also looking to how we can improve
[0:44:46] our application processes, which is currently a paper application. We are
[0:44:52] looking to move that into Laserfish to make that available online. And we also
[0:44:56] recognize that this could be an opportunity for public education. Some of
[0:45:02] what we would educate the public solicitors, whether it be by city code
[0:45:09] code or state code. For example, if a solicitor comes to your door, they are required to show you identification,
[0:45:16] photo identification, to express their intent. If you ask them to leave, they are also per
[0:45:25] state law to provide a notice of cancellation. You make a decision for a door to door to sale,
[0:45:31] you have three days to change your mind, which is something I learned. I didn't realize that.
[0:45:35] They also need to exhibit a license upon request. Some of what they shall not do is make physical contact.
[0:45:45] Misrepresent their purpose, approach the premises if you have a no solicitation sign posted.
[0:45:51] Make a false statement on an application.
[0:45:54] So I just wanted to walk you through briefly what our current application process is.
[0:46:01] We have an application fee of $25 for the business and a $5 per salesperson.
[0:46:09] We collect approximately $800 a year.
[0:46:12] Each salesperson is also required to go through fingerprinting in a background check.
[0:46:19] Aries in recent years has been between forty two and forty nine dollars per salesperson
[0:46:25] The dollars of that is our fee to collect the fingerprints and the balances the fee that we pay are also
[0:46:36] requiring a surety bond or a cashier's check in dollars per salesperson
[0:46:43] I've had a few people give us the five hundred dollars which we hold and then return later
[0:46:48] But most of them choose to do a bond surety bond which can cost them anywhere between one and fifteen percent
[0:46:55] So one of the biggest changes would be changing currently titled Transient Merchants, Vendors, and Petlers, and Solicitors, but those are some of those are now addressed in Chapter 18, which is commercial vending.
[0:47:17] Chapter 18 addresses a vendor offering product for immediate sale, generally involves citizens approaching the vendor in a public setting.
[0:47:27] So that's our chapter 18. We recently went through that and you adopted that in October
[0:47:32] of last year. Chapter 4 is more designed for a vendor approaching citizens to solicit business
[0:47:41] either for a future sale of product or service and generally on private property. And so there
[0:47:50] are two differences between I would ask for your feedback on is should chapter 14 also
[0:47:59] Also apply to individuals who are soliciting business by leaving pamphlets or door hangers
[0:48:04] on private property.
[0:48:06] On one hand, they are approaching a residential area.
[0:48:15] Curious, if that's something that we should require, individuals would have to go through
[0:48:21] finger print license.
[0:48:25] And based on current code, answer right away if it is something to be included like pamphlets
[0:48:41] which are not selling, you will get to a list of exemptions and political is one of the
[0:48:51] exemptions.
[0:48:52] So this would be for people, um, it's not political, it's not religious, it's tell you something.
[0:49:02] The city of Boise does not, uh, leaving something under the person.
[0:49:13] If they have another thing I want you to be thinking about is some entities can fall into both categories.
[0:49:30] We have some entities that are both commercial vendor, solicitor, and that is based on language,
[0:49:40] and that's based on proposed language.
[0:49:42] So, the one I'm talking about primarily is going to be a nice spring trunk of a commercial
[0:49:48] vending license because they could powder wastewater, they have to go through everything with planning
[0:49:54] and zoning, they have to have this in residential neighborhoods, solicitor is someone who goes
[0:50:05] from place to place, house to house or street to street.
[0:50:08] So, as we're talking about some of these, I want you to keep in mind, in fact, we also
[0:50:18] have some entities that are exempt from needing a license at all.
[0:50:25] So, these are existing exemptions in chapter 14.
[0:50:28] wholesalers dealing with retail margins, let it be an auto parts dealer going to the individual auto parts store
[0:50:35] they would not need a solicitor's license, religious or charitable organizations are exempt,
[0:50:41] and political groups seeking funds or memberships are exempt, and that's the current language we would like to expand that to a little broader to include political candidates
[0:50:52] You may be early asking for funds or membership.
[0:51:00] Some other proposed additions would be school sanctioned activity, free of pre-ordered food,
[0:51:06] food goods for services, so that would be your grub hub, your pizza delivery guide,
[0:51:12] UPS, or if you're offering new services to an existing customer.
[0:51:17] So you could be a lawn care service that is offering an existing service to a customer,
[0:51:23] you have new services you want to offer.
[0:51:25] don't need a solicitor's license unless you're going to go to the neighbor who
[0:51:28] does not currently have your services. Some of the proposed language we are
[0:51:36] looking for is to add that just because an entity is exempt from obtaining a
[0:51:40] license doesn't mean that they are exempt from the roles of the chapter. So
[0:51:44] even though you are school sanctioned activity or political, if you're asked
[0:51:53] to leave, you should leave. That's what we're looking for.
[0:52:02] Our school-sanctioned activities not currently exempted as a organization, or as it is, is not since, so, for example, the
[0:52:11] Narrative of a school-sanctioned activity is charitable, and some could argue that it's not.
[0:52:33] I mean, I certainly would be supportive of that. I mean, I'm reasonable.
[0:52:38] And licenses are issued to salespeople who successfully pass a background check.
[0:52:59] So just because we issue a license does not mean that the city has investigated the business and that we are endorsing the business and product of the services.
[0:53:07] a license simply means that the individual went through fingerprinting and they passed a background check.
[0:53:13] In our activity from 2016 to 2020, on general we have about six applications per year.
[0:53:22] Applications are submitted generally by a primary sales manager.
[0:53:26] These are the number of salespeople that we've licensed each year.
[0:53:32] In 2018 we had one business that had quite a few salespeople.
[0:53:36] And we also looked at the salespeople that were denied.
[0:53:41] So these were denied either because they did not come in for fingerprinting or because they did not pass the background check.
[0:53:47] Due to COVID-19, no solicitor licenses have been issued since 2019.
[0:53:54] But that's another thing I'm looking for your feedback on.
[0:53:59] We previously had not been issuing licenses because we were not, we were trying to encourage social distancing.
[0:54:06] I would be interested to hear your feedback of when you might, should maybe be opening up or if you're prepared to give an opinion.
[0:54:14] You know, it's interesting, you said no licenses have been issued.
[0:54:28] I know there's a security company running around town, even going to homes with no solicitors
[0:54:35] on the door that's been causing some frustration for some people.
[0:54:41] You know, at this point in time, I mean, the CDC has relaxed the rules.
[0:54:48] I think of a homeowner who wants to put a mask on before you come in and make a presentation.
[0:54:54] So they're a call, but I don't have a problem in opening it back up personally.
[0:55:03] I think there's a capitalistic society that we live in that this is sort of an allowable function that occurs within guidance.
[0:55:14] I actually think that the opportunity for additional public education about what's reasonable, what's not reasonable,
[0:55:22] Is it like around selling security systems? Do you need to get a
[0:55:27] Citizens understanding their rights to say no, I don't want this and that's the end of the conversation
[0:55:33] I think there's an opportunity for that. So I certainly would not say we shouldn't be issuing
[0:55:41] licenses
[0:55:42] because of covid
[0:55:44] However, I do think that we need the education piece around it that it's not just
[0:55:49] With you briefly some historical trends, you can see how it's changed over the years.
[0:56:09] We do have some constants.
[0:56:11] The security systems are always popular.
[0:56:13] We have had some changes over the years.
[0:56:16] In addition to the home security, there is an entity that sells educational materials
[0:56:22] and they apply for license every year.
[0:56:26] Recent additions have been entertainment, including cell phones and cable TV packages.
[0:56:31] lawn care has control and solar power.
[0:56:34] 2019 was our most diversified year yet, types of licenses.
[0:56:39] Shout to some of our prior licensed holders four feet back on some of the changes.
[0:56:53] I was only able to reach one former solicitor.
[0:56:59] We also attempted to reach doing ice cream trucks successful in great post to the famous concerned about additional causes,
[0:57:17] which so surety bond is one of the things we're seeking in our research.
[0:57:31] We have found that most cities in Idaho do require a surety bond.
[0:57:35] Although when I reached out to some of the bigger cities, they could not remember ever
[0:57:39] acting on one at least in recent years.
[0:57:42] According to the language in our existing city code, it is to save the city harmless
[0:57:47] from any and all liabilities.
[0:57:49] It is to be approved by the city attorney, in addition to the act, it also states that
[0:57:59] action on the surety bond or cashier's check may be brought directly by any person damaged
[0:58:05] by a licensees violation of the chapter.
[0:58:07] It means you could have just a home security system
[0:58:12] and was not happy with the work,
[0:58:14] and they could come to the city
[0:58:15] and say I want to file it as a restitution on us to act.
[0:58:20] It's one reason we, if it's still,
[0:58:25] role is laws in place to our consumers,
[0:58:30] and violations of this chapter
[0:58:31] are already subject to panel of 2000.
[0:58:38] What does the protect the third attorney shame know about it?
[0:59:06] He is not concerned about eliminating.
[0:59:09] He doesn't, he's of insurance at the person
[0:59:19] if they're willing to spend the money
[0:59:20] and go through the hoops of getting a shirting bond, they're more likely to be a
[0:59:23] valent business person and how do I better tip it into the city and say, hey, I buy this
[0:59:39] night person. So if a consumer decides to make the transaction with the or in our
[0:59:53] salesperson, there are state laws that protect that relationship. Yes. Basically
[1:00:03] that the shirting bond is saying, do those handful of things that you're out of the
[1:00:10] If somebody didn't do that in the first place, that's the code enforcement and code enforcement says, hey, we're in our salesmen year now.
[1:00:22] So, what's, how, how do we, um, confirm the salespeople that have been fingerprinted, et cetera, et cetera, compared to who is actually out there selling?
[1:00:38] So is it possible for a vendor to sneak a salesperson in there that hasn't passed the background checks, that does something,
[1:00:49] I don't know what it would be, that might damage the, the, or the potential buyer.
[1:00:57] I can see it's not here.
[1:01:02] You know, I do get that there's $500, it's like, nothing, I mean, maybe if I was 5,000,
[1:01:08] that would be a shame, different story, and I guess what do we do to confirm that the people
[1:01:16] they have had fingerprinted are actually who they're sending out?
[1:01:19] Well, the license that we issued each sales person has the sales person's name printed
[1:01:24] directly on it and really we are at the mercy of citizens complaining if someone
[1:01:29] comes to the door and you ask for a license and they don't provide one or if
[1:01:33] they provide it doesn't match the name sort of stop having the police department
[1:01:43] stop every person going door to door. Well I agree with Sean it's a huge huge
[1:01:50] citizen education thing that I think we have an opportunity to do because certain
[1:01:55] people I know because of this but I wouldn't typically have known to ask
[1:02:02] somebody to see their license. And frankly it's very similar to many of our other
[1:02:08] maybe less criminal codes. I mean, eads and trash in your yard, that's all primarily
[1:02:15] driven by walking the streets and checking those things out. So, I mean, I
[1:02:24] don't see a value to the journey bond and the hands of people it's us. I guess I
[1:02:39] would agree with that as well. I don't want the city to be in monetarily except
[1:02:44] collecting the fee for the license itself. At that point in time the
[1:02:48] transactions between the individual and the household, and if there's a problem they go to the state, and the cities out of that book
[1:02:59] chase around are being chased for $500, doesn't seem like a good use of our time.
[1:03:08] I was going to ask if the bond should be eliminated, or been in place and update some of the language.
[1:03:18] I'm hearing that maybe we could eliminate anything if the action was changed, until we adopt a new code, the bond is in place.
[1:03:30] If you say one thing tonight and think about it, it is not set in stone tonight.
[1:03:36] Other things we're looking for in on is the term of the license.
[1:03:48] It's currently valid for three months.
[1:03:50] And then an additional three month extension is available for $15.00 for sales person.
[1:03:56] And then according to the code, they must wait six months to reapply.
[1:03:59] We're not figuring out where that last extension we pressed that we received was in 2015.
[1:04:08] that either means that they are doing all their sales within three months or
[1:04:11] moving on or they are continuing to sell with an expired license. Either way,
[1:04:17] maybe we should consider extending the term with the license. Maybe a six-month
[1:04:23] term, that would eliminate the need of an extension and that covers pretty much
[1:04:28] the summer months. We could do a 12-month term which would match our commercial
[1:04:34] So is the 12-month term is the license for the company and the separate licenses for the sales people or does that all happen at once?
[1:04:58] So my concern would be you do a 12-month license and three months later you have eight new sales people and you didn't bother bringing them in.
[1:05:05] The license is tied to the individual sales person. We don't license the business. The business pays a $25 application fee.
[1:05:13] The license is actually for the salesperson.
[1:05:17] Yes.
[1:05:18] I would certainly be supportive of a longer term for staff.
[1:05:42] It's doing something like that, seems like.
[1:05:45] Posting limiting hours of solicitation from 9am to 8am.
[1:06:05] Currently, there is no time limit in the thing to pretend to be policy and procedures.
[1:06:20] Just to match our recently adopted Title III, Chapter 18, listed it out there.
[1:06:25] This is in the summer months how long the...
[1:06:51] I mean, that seems reasonable to me.
[1:06:58] There's a few hours since people have gotten home from work because I have the
[1:07:05] viewers still even in the summer sometimes trying to wipe down their needs.
[1:07:10] Should I scream, man? Look, no music after I get caught.
[1:07:18] But now I can start on the heatheem and be the ice cream product and seem like
[1:07:24] they don't want us to get involved, so they grab on.
[1:07:31] Look at it, there's a difference in going door to door and street to street.
[1:07:36] We could have it so that door to door ends at eight o'clock
[1:07:40] and straight to straight, which would pretty much just be your ice cream truck at dusk.
[1:07:45] Ice cream trucks that are currently and in recent years have only had to get a commercial vending license.
[1:08:12] To get a solicitor's license, I'm not sure why. When license is enough, the solicitor would be curious to hear your thoughts on should they have to get a solicitor's license?
[1:08:28] Should they be fingerprinted? Sensitive to the fact that they don't want to have additional fees. If we eliminate the surety bond, that would help.
[1:08:36] We can't really eliminate the fingerprinting fee in my mind because it's a P.V.
[1:08:41] We're listeners if you want to do kind of a combination package deal.
[1:08:50] Technically they also meet the definition of a sound truck getting a license there which is $20.
[1:08:57] The nation had extra fees on through their successfuls of business but
[1:09:08] they'd be soliciting their children. Acceptable, but no, this isn't an license to stand.
[1:09:30] They had the soliciting children, they had the checks.
[1:09:39] But what if they don't drive around the streets and they just park someplace?
[1:09:42] That is correct if they-
[1:10:03] Consistency that it's not full of this entire rewrite of Title 3 is too simplified.
[1:10:10] Out to then carve out, but if you're selling this thing,
[1:10:15] or stops even if we do reuse the fees, I just want to make it consistent and I, again,
[1:10:23] I appreciate that that's probably the vendor I would be most concerned about making sure
[1:10:29] they have background checks out in such a way that doesn't single happen.
[1:10:39] think it's because of the ice cream or who they're selling to, but I think it's
[1:10:44] because they are in the neighborhoods and not in a public place. And you know to
[1:10:48] make sure that those folks that are driving through those neighborhoods aren't
[1:10:52] in attention to where children are.
[1:10:55] So is this street?
[1:10:57] So street and nursery as opposed to a food truck?
[1:11:01] Yeah, that is correct. It could be, they could be going around selling toys.
[1:11:05] I shouldn't use the word toys because I don't want to handle those. If they're going
[1:11:12] and selling candles from street-to-street background check.
[1:11:18] There's a license fee break that if you're basically applying for a dual license,
[1:11:24] because you're going to function as both of those things, that's a different fee.
[1:11:34] That's 65% of the cost of both of them.
[1:11:38] Yes, we're looking at how we can see laser fish application process,
[1:11:42] where you could get, if you are applying for a solicitor,
[1:11:45] so you already have the food truck license, commercial vending license,
[1:11:48] you would get a discount up to a certain amount.
[1:11:51] one has to have solicitor say oh I'm a commercial vendor because that's only a
[1:11:55] hundred dollars and the obvious I'm not sure how quickly we would have to go
[1:12:10] through the FBI the conversation we've just been having is based on existing
[1:12:15] city code not proposed city code when do you think we should start requiring
[1:12:20] our commercial vendors that are going into residential areas to obtain a
[1:12:24] solicitor's license race period
[1:13:24] My presentation, unless you have any additional comments or questions.
[1:13:52] This was very good this evening. Thank you very much.
[1:14:01] Appreciate it.
[1:14:02] Opportunity now for general public. If there's anyone in the audience who would like to talk to the council about an item that was not on our agenda this evening, now is your opportunity.
[1:14:21] Board and state your name and address for the record.
[1:14:28] Neil Harvester, resident over on Julie Lane.
[1:14:45] There's a problem that we have here in the community.
[1:14:47] I have discussed this with several individuals.
[1:14:51] And that is that we have a proliferation of family cats.
[1:14:59] I do not have a cat.
[1:15:01] In my neighborhood, there are an excess of 15 cats.
[1:15:07] My property has become a latrine.
[1:15:10] For all of the neighbor cats, I would
[1:15:14] I'd like to know, Chims, are for resolving this problem.
[1:15:25] Tech did code enforcement.
[1:15:27] Yes, I have.
[1:15:28] OK, so we had a meeting about six weeks ago
[1:15:32] with police, code enforcement, and other neighbors
[1:15:34] who were having the same complaint.
[1:15:37] And I'm not pushing you down the road,
[1:15:39] but we were kind of going over some options.
[1:15:43] And so Chief Kingsbury's back there,
[1:15:45] and he and Matt Hicks were both at that meeting.
[1:15:48] And maybe you can follow up with them and see where we can go because there's not a lot of options available.
[1:15:55] Well, the options that were given to me was that I could live trap the cats and take them out for the pound.
[1:16:12] Yes, they will be put down.
[1:16:13] Or those cats that are associated with the family. You're only going to entice a cat into a live trap once.
[1:16:27] Yes, we have to take it one step at a time.
[1:16:35] I think that this is a topic that really has to be addressed because there is a proliferation of cats in our community
[1:16:46] and while they are loved in their own home, they are not kept in their own and they're allowed to run on the neighborhood, dogs.
[1:17:05] So yes, we will make sure that city staff has heard what you've had to say tonight as well and we are aware.
[1:17:12] Yes.
[1:17:14] Thank you for coming this evening.
[1:17:16] Is there anyone else who would like to address counsel this evening?
[1:17:23] [Muted for privacy: home address]
[1:17:25] [Muted for privacy: home address]
[1:17:33] [Muted for privacy: home address]
[1:17:40] [Muted for privacy: home address]
[1:17:45] for you guys to think about.
[1:17:47] My wife and I are in the process of starting to build a new home and like every other home, it's part of an HOA.
[1:17:55] I know that the city has restrictions currently on water usage for watering lawns and such right now.
[1:18:03] The HOA requires grass on the front lawn, which is emosed or one of the most water-consuming plants there is.
[1:18:13] And my wife and I would like to do the right thing and just plant all his air escape and not have any grass.
[1:18:20] The HOA says you can apply for an exception, an exception, but who knows if they'll approve it.
[1:18:26] The point being is that on the one hand you have the city telling people to minimize their water usage.
[1:18:32] On the other hand, you have an HOA preventing people from minimizing their water usage.
[1:18:38] Again, I don't know if there's any such legislation moving here, the county or in the state, there
[1:18:45] is disregard my comments, but you may want to think about some kind of language that prevents
[1:18:53] HOA's from requiring grass and prohibiting landscape without grass that is, you know, zero-scaper
[1:19:07] drought tolerant plants.
[1:19:09] Thank you.
[1:19:10] Thank you.
[1:19:11] Thank you.
[1:19:12] So right up front here is our city attorney, Shane.
[1:19:13] Nope.
[1:19:14] So maybe you guys can get your heads together.
[1:19:17] The city council tries not to over legislate locally and we do not have any at this time legal
[1:19:26] control over HOA's.
[1:19:28] So I'm going to let the professionals take care of that one.
[1:19:32] How's that?
[1:19:33] So we do have an application for exemption to irrigation and landscaping, so from a water usage perspective,
[1:19:42] so for example, if you're on pressure irrigation, you can apply and say, hey, I don't use the pressure irrigation
[1:19:46] because I have a zero-scape lawn price reduced, but that is a disconnect.
[1:19:55] But to the mayor's point, we're legislated over HOA's, but I think that is an education process that we can work with HOA's on too.
[1:20:05] Can I ask him a question?
[1:20:06] So, yeah, do they have a square footage requirement?
[1:20:09] I know from fact the person I don't voice see that they do have a requirement.
[1:20:14] But they just actually have a patch. It's not very big.
[1:20:18] Yeah. The place we're building, I can't remember exactly what I have to read it again.
[1:20:23] I'm dripping around the neighborhood and I see varying sizes.
[1:20:26] Some have like a little strip of grass and then they've got zeros next to it.
[1:20:29] All those things. But it's just something to consider.
[1:20:33] like if someone wanted to not waste water on grass, prevented from doing it, as far as I can tell the rules are now.
[1:20:41] If I close with one final comment, I understand the reluctance to want to, you know, over-legislating those things,
[1:20:48] but its population increases and its resources become scarce.
[1:20:53] More legislation always comes to manage it. Thank you.
[1:20:56] I just came back from Vegas and went down to the regional softball tournament and they
[1:21:03] virtually have eliminated grass with fake grass if you consider that as an option because
[1:21:08] it seems to be getting much more recent on the course that you see any water.
[1:21:13] Looks like you can't tell it all from the other.
[1:21:16] You could do that too, but again, I don't think the HOA would allow that's my point.
[1:21:20] They would have to be forced to.
[1:21:23] I don't like the plastic grass. I worry about the microplastics that are coming off it prefer real plants
[1:21:29] But that's just me, but the point being I don't think they would even allow that
[1:21:32] Anyways, but thank you to some to think of thank you. Thank you for coming this evening
[1:21:37] So anyone else who would like to address the council this evening?
[1:21:40] No one we will move forward to advise report reports and announcements
[1:21:49] May I'd like to just mention that I had the privilege and honor it in the these officers Memorial Saturday. That was really a great
[1:21:57] It was very moving and very good to give the chief a chance to respond to the admirals comments if you would like to thank you chief. We do appreciate you.
[1:22:15] Chris.
[1:22:19] At the opportunity to attend Parks and Rec they had a track meet for 5 to 14 year olds and so they did a fantastic job and I appreciate Parks and Rec for the job that they did.
[1:22:34] There was hundreds of kids there, lots of parents, and it was a lot of fun, so I did not participate.
[1:22:41] So two other things this past week, we had the inaugural flight from Denver to Twin Falls at the Twin Falls airport,
[1:22:54] and there was a great celebration out there, and I just have to say this because I'm still amazed.
[1:22:59] I'm Dan Olmsted, who has served on our board for many years and has been a caretaker and lover of our airport.
[1:23:06] came out to that event Wednesday, less than 48 hours after hip replacement surgery.
[1:23:10] I just can't believe he came walking in there and it was like way to go down.
[1:23:15] He said that out of everything he could not miss seeing that plane come in and go out.
[1:23:19] So I thought it was a pretty touching moment of life in June 12th.
[1:23:27] Then Saturday was the Twin Paul City Youth Council's color run the Team
[1:23:32] suicide prevention and awareness, we had 71 pre-registered participants and we ended up
[1:23:41] with over 300 people out there.
[1:23:44] So thank you Vice Mayor Ruth Pierce for running the registration and taking in all that money
[1:23:49] and keeping track of everybody.
[1:23:52] I had at least a half a dozen mothers who personally came up and shared with me the stories of how
[1:23:58] they lost their children in the last two years.
[1:24:01] So suicide is definitely a problem in our community and the support that our teams were
[1:24:07] shown that day.
[1:24:08] I'm sure it's going to go a long way.
[1:24:12] You can't make up the stuff about how good the community of Twin Falls is.
[1:24:16] Add a number of businesses, donate prizes and cash to us and so I'm not going to try to name
[1:24:23] everybody but you know who you are.
[1:24:25] Thank you so much for all of the support we received.
[1:24:31] Anything from the City Manager's office this evening.
[1:24:36] So we do have a public hearing before we move forward, does anyone on the Council need
[1:24:40] a five minute recess?
[1:24:47] So this evening we have a request for a recommendation to the City Council for an amendment to
[1:24:53] the City of Twin Falls comprehensive plan to modify the future land use map designations
[1:25:00] from Twin Falls neighborhood, from town neighborhood to rural residential and rural residential
[1:25:08] to commercial for property approximately located at 2732 east to 4100 north in the area
[1:25:16] of impact and it is being presented from the Magic Valley Land LLC and I believe we have
[1:25:23] Lisa Strickland presenting on this issue this evening. Lisa, I'm going to go ahead and read
[1:25:30] our process real quick for those that are in attendance. So this evening we will have
[1:25:37] city staff present the request and analysis, then the applicant will have a
[1:25:41] chance to present their request. At that time the council can ask questions of
[1:25:46] the applicant or staff. After questions have been asked, the public hearing will
[1:25:50] be opened. During that time, anyone in attendance will be given three minutes to
[1:25:55] comment or ask questions about the request being considered. When giving
[1:26:00] testimony, please step up to the podium, state your name and address, and then
[1:26:04] present your comments, concerns, or questions.
[1:26:08] After giving testimony this evening,
[1:26:10] please sign in on the signage sheet
[1:26:12] at the top of the stairs right outside the door
[1:26:15] so that we have that for our permanent record.
[1:26:19] After the public comments are concluded,
[1:26:21] the applicant will have a chance to answer any questions
[1:26:24] and make a closing statement.
[1:26:26] Staff will then answer or clarify any comments as needed.
[1:26:30] After the closing comments, the public hearing
[1:26:33] will be closed and no further testimony or comments from the applicant or audience will
[1:26:38] be allowed. At that time the council will take it under consideration with an open discussion
[1:26:44] and they will make an action even if that action is to bring it back in another date.
[1:26:49] Floor is yours. Good evening Mayor Hawkins. Council, this request
[1:27:00] is to amend the future land use map of 2016 the comprehensive plan. Grow with us. The
[1:27:06] The applicant is requesting that the commercial designation along Poline Road East extend further
[1:27:12] west along the north side of Poline Road.
[1:27:16] The comprehensive plan map is used as a guide and it illustrates desired locations for land
[1:27:22] use with the city and the area of impact.
[1:27:25] The intent is to identify the most appropriate location for different land uses to essentially
[1:27:33] enable growth.
[1:27:34] The map is not intended to depict specific parcel locations or exact acreage, but general
[1:27:40] areas for specific types of land use.
[1:27:44] In this case, the map has illustrated a commercial corridor along the gateway arterial Holine Road
[1:27:50] West, shown here.
[1:27:53] After reviewing the map, it does not illustrate the alignment of Holine Road West correctly.
[1:27:59] Therefore, the commercial corridor is illustrated incorrectly in our future land use comprehensive
[1:28:07] plan.
[1:28:10] Staff believes the intent was the commercial corridor to follow Poline Road equally along
[1:28:15] the north and south frontage.
[1:28:19] This corridor would naturally follow the curve of the existing road.
[1:28:23] The current map shows the curve of the road incorrectly, so the applicant is requesting
[1:28:28] that the map be amended to show the correct alignment of Poline Road West and therefore
[1:28:33] correcting the illustration of the commercial corridor.
[1:28:37] The process for the commitment of a comprehensive plan requires a recommendation from the Planning
[1:28:42] and Zoning Commission to the City Council.
[1:28:45] The Planning and Zoning Commission heard this request on April 13th and has recommended
[1:28:49] a unanimous approval.
[1:28:51] The Council is charged with making a final decision.
[1:28:54] U.S. Council can approve, conditionally approve, deny, or table the request for additional information when acting on this request.
[1:29:02] Upon conclusion, staff would be in support of amending the future land map as presented.
[1:29:09] I will stand for any questions. If there are none, the applicant is here to present their request.
[1:29:18] Any questions for Lisa at this time?
[1:29:20] August Council passes the all. My name is Tyler Davis-Chefers. I'm here on behalf of
[1:29:40] Magic Thigh Land of LLC. As Lisa pointed out, we believe that this
[1:29:46] illustration was really just an illustrative oversight and we just
[1:29:52] are seeking a correction that represents the intent of the comprehensive
[1:29:57] plan. We realize the city does not believe that the future land use map should
[1:30:04] pertain to individual parcels, but there are zoning entities that don't share that opinion,
[1:30:09] so we're seeking a correction.
[1:30:12] Happy to answer any questions you might have.
[1:30:14] Any questions for the applicant?
[1:30:23] So with no questions, we will go ahead and open the public testimony portion of this evening's
[1:30:31] public hearing.
[1:30:32] If you would like to speak for or against this item, please make your way forward and
[1:30:38] Stay here, name and address, and we will give you three minutes.
[1:30:47] To speak this evening, applicant has a chance to make a closing statement if there's anything
[1:30:53] you feel like you forgot to address.
[1:30:58] So are there any other questions for staff or applicant?
[1:31:14] For staff, to make sure I understand each of the dotted line around the edge,
[1:31:20] is that the current city limits, or is that the area of impact?
[1:31:23] That's the water service or utility service boundary?
[1:31:26] Water service, sorry, thank you.
[1:31:32] And maybe it's just a future discussions
[1:31:37] when we move these complaint updates.
[1:31:39] So I noticed that our neighborhood commercial areas
[1:31:43] are highlighted at intersections
[1:31:46] and cover all four corners of the intersection,
[1:31:48] yet our corridors and the end at the intersection.
[1:31:52] So the corridor, for example,
[1:31:55] I'm certainly supportive of this move along
[1:31:59] the actual pole, I should those in the future
[1:32:04] encompass the other two quarters of an intersection,
[1:32:08] and only there, but you see it down on,
[1:32:10] can't really road as well.
[1:32:15] The corners, they tend to end at the intersection
[1:32:17] instead of overlap, because they think
[1:32:19] to the applicant's point, these are designed
[1:32:22] to be broad corridors, not specific parcels,
[1:32:27] but when they abruptly end at a roadway,
[1:32:29] I do think that creates future strife in discussing that.
[1:32:34] So I'm not suggesting we should push this further
[1:32:37] in this particular question, unless that's appropriate,
[1:32:41] but maybe something to think about in the future
[1:32:43] that has these general-made use maps
[1:32:47] or illustrated that they encompass those intersections.
[1:32:52] We can certainly have that discussion
[1:32:53] when we come up with those future maps.
[1:33:05] This correction would be, there's kind of a squiggled,
[1:33:11] oh, there's, and it seems like,
[1:33:15] end of something right there to me,
[1:33:26] comments from somebody.
[1:33:30] Oh, it just seems like there,
[1:33:31] I guess I could all be straight and degraded and everything.
[1:33:35] Is that the intent or is this the end of where
[1:33:39] that commercial zone at this point?
[1:33:43] Typically on these, we would take all the factors
[1:33:45] and have a heavily commercial zone.
[1:33:49] You'd really probably need city services.
[1:33:52] So most of these would end probably
[1:33:54] where the city service line ends.
[1:33:57] That line is one of the only lines that's more specific
[1:33:59] on this map.
[1:34:01] certain areas we cannot serve gravity and sewer and so we're pretty specific on
[1:34:06] down the line in some most of the cases we've looked into that water is easily
[1:34:12] serviced but sewer's not so that line's a little bit more specific in this case if
[1:34:17] that commercial would go further west the utility line isn't further west but in
[1:34:23] other locations I understand councilman burger that it should go to all those
[1:34:29] intersections. So we have those visioning exercises in the future. It's definitely something we'll be
[1:34:33] bringing up. In this case, really, the issue was the line work, which is this dark grayer.
[1:34:39] It's old line work when the road was a little bit, I guess, with straight lines. Now it actually
[1:34:48] comes straight here and then does a nice S curve up to this. And that's really what we're going to
[1:34:53] correct is the the road, which will show that this corner really is kind of on both sides of
[1:34:59] of that row and not just on one side.
[1:35:02] That's generally what the idea was supposed to be.
[1:35:04] It just happened that it hasn't been run up yet.
[1:35:17] It's a closing statement and everybody's good.
[1:35:19] So at this time, I'm gonna close the public hearing
[1:35:21] and turn it over to the council.
[1:35:24] We have Christopher Reed.
[1:35:26] I'll make a motion unless somebody else would like
[1:35:29] to make a comment.
[1:35:29] Okay, there first.
[1:35:30] All right.
[1:35:31] I move that we amend the city.
[1:35:34] The city of Twin Falls comprehensive plan
[1:35:36] to modify the future plan use map designation
[1:35:39] from town, neighborhood, and rural residential
[1:35:42] to commercial for property approximately located
[1:35:45] at 2732 East, 4100 North, in the area of impact,
[1:35:51] care of a magic valid land, LLC.
[1:35:55] So, we have a motion from Christopher Reed,
[1:35:58] seconded by Craig Hawkins to approve the recommendation
[1:36:02] requested this evening as presented.
[1:36:05] Any other comments?
[1:36:08] Go ahead, Craig.
[1:36:10] of this is to clean up the map. I do have some concern that if we're gonna have a commercial
[1:36:16] in the decommin, S is to be in that area that's on that side the road's over a mile and a third
[1:36:22] from any other commercial on that side the road. I start getting a little feeling of leapfrogging
[1:36:28] and I don't be an old farm boy. I don't like leapfrogging. I want to keep us as tight as we can because
[1:36:34] there's a good farmland out there and I hate to lose it. But other than that, I can see the
[1:36:39] I agree with the leapfrogging, but with the businesses that have been going out there,
[1:36:46] there's less than a mile now.
[1:36:49] Nope, there's a business on the corner of Grand B, so yeah.
[1:36:53] So it is really happening quicker than we thought.
[1:36:59] Yes.
[1:37:00] Well, I appreciate we're not zoning property tonight.
[1:37:03] We're talking about the, uh, the map.
[1:37:05] I would note.
[1:37:08] I would note that the philosophical platforms of our comprehensive plan is to allow residences
[1:37:22] so that it's not all clogged in borders and towns of the older cars to go under.
[1:37:30] I appreciate the preservation of the balance between them.
[1:37:33] We did receive had to deal with traffic in that area, but I believe the commercial will
[1:37:50] bring in less traffic than another residential unit going in.
[1:37:55] So, Nina what's out there?
[1:37:57] So, it doesn't always mean that it's going to affect track,
[1:38:01] think that, can they believe when it's a commercial project.
[1:38:06] Amy, roll call vote please.
[1:38:14] Yes.
[1:38:15] Is there a glanting?
[1:38:16] Yes.
[1:38:17] Yes.
[1:38:18] Yes.
[1:38:19] Yes.
[1:38:20] Yes.
[1:38:21] I should pass this.
[1:38:22] Seven to zero.
[1:38:23] Thank you very much for being here this evening.
[1:38:26] This evening, we have a request to adjourn into executive session under Idaho State Code 74-206.
[1:38:34] 6A to consider hiring a public officer, employee, staff member, or individual agent, wherein
[1:38:41] the respective qualities of individuals are to be evaluated in order to fill a particular
[1:38:47] vacancy or need.
[1:38:49] This paragraph does not apply to filling a vacancy in an elective office or deliberations
[1:38:55] about staffing needs in general.
[1:38:58] Second, we have a motion from Nicky Boyd, seconded by Ruth Pierce, to adjourn into
[1:39:06] Executive Session. Amy Roquolo please.
[1:39:09] Is there a pocket?
[1:39:12] Yes.
[1:39:13] Right Glanting.
[1:39:14] Yes.
[1:39:15] Yes.
[1:39:17] Yes.
[1:39:18] Yes.
[1:39:19] Yes.
[1:39:21] Motion passes 7-0. We will be adjourning into Executive Session. However, there will be no decisions made in that meeting and we will not be reconvening this meeting.
[1:39:32] This evening, everybody has a wonderful week. We're adjourned.
