Oversight Archive: City Council meeting, 2023-01-03, recording 1 (started 16:58)
Machine transcript (faster-whisper base.en), not checked word for word; the Pledge of Allegiance is shown in its standard wording. The recording is the record.
Times are time into the recording. Passages with private details are muted in the audio and marked here.
The audio on the page below was re-encoded by software from the video the agency posted. Check any passage against
that audio before relying on it.
Page: https://oversightarchive.org/twin-falls-id/meetings/2023-01-03/

[0:01:45] Good evening ladies and gentlemen welcome to the first city council meeting of 2023 January 3rd call the meeting to order and I confirm we have a quorum we have all seven members in council chambers first time on the agenda is the Pledge of Allegiance. If you wish to join me please rise.
[0:02:05] Thank you. No proclamations tonight. It's nice to see department heads here today. It's great.
[0:02:30] Consent calendar. Council wishes.
[0:02:34] Mayor, I move that we accept the consent calendar as published.
[0:02:42] Thank you. Do I have a second? Craig Hawkins.
[0:02:45] Thank you. Motion by Nikki Boyd. Seconded by Craig Hawkins to approve the consent calendar as written.
[0:02:51] Amy Roll call vote please.
[0:02:53] Ruth Pears?
[0:02:54] Yes.
[0:02:55] Chris Reed?
[0:02:56] Yes.
[0:02:57] Nicky Boyd?
[0:02:58] Yes.
[0:02:59] Ray Cawkin?
[0:03:00] Yes.
[0:03:02] Jason Brown?
[0:03:03] Yes.
[0:03:04] Alex Kavol?
[0:03:05] Yes.
[0:03:06] Spencer Kettler?
[0:03:07] Yes.
[0:03:08] Thank you.
[0:03:09] Motion passes 7-0.
[0:03:10] So if you were here for Cedar Park subdivision, CDAs, that has been approved.
[0:03:15] Moving to items of consideration, our first item is an action item.
[0:03:20] And actually, Mark, you've got both of them, don't you?
[0:03:24] OK, an action item to request to purchase a 2024 International
[0:03:29] Common Nations Snowplow Salt Truck using a cooperative purchasing
[0:03:34] agreement with Sourcewell in the amount of $221,856.59
[0:03:41] after trade-in.
[0:03:43] And we have Mark Thompson, our street superintendent.
[0:03:53] Members of the council, I am here tonight
[0:03:55] to kind of discuss a couple different pieces of equipment
[0:03:58] that we'll be replacing in our 23 fiscal year budget.
[0:04:02] There is a little bit of change on the first action item,
[0:04:05] and I'll explain why.
[0:04:07] The price should be $2.30, $3.56, $59.
[0:04:15] Could you say that one more?
[0:04:17] $2.30, $3.56, $0.59.
[0:04:22] And the reason we change the price is we feel
[0:04:27] after talking with staff just a couple hours ago
[0:04:30] that we probably won't take delivery of this truck
[0:04:33] until May of probably 2024.
[0:04:38] So we may have the opportunity to take
[0:04:41] our current truck to auction,
[0:04:44] and we may be able to get a little bit more
[0:04:47] at auction versus trading the dam.
[0:04:49] So we wanted to keep all of our options open
[0:04:52] going into this.
[0:04:53] So a little bit of background to start.
[0:04:56] Back in December 9th, 2019,
[0:04:59] City Council adopted a resolution to authorizing staff to use
[0:05:03] cooperative purchasing agreements. City staff can approve purchases up to the
[0:05:09] informal bid limits which is a hundred thousand. Anything over that we need to
[0:05:14] come to council to seek approval. We have our city attorney has reviewed all of
[0:05:23] our information and believes the source will is a cooperative program
[0:05:28] authorized to be utilized by idocode 67-2807.
[0:05:34] As you know, our street department utilizes several different pieces of equipment in our
[0:05:39] snow removal program, but with any fleet we have trucks that are reaching the service
[0:05:47] live and that's surpassed it.
[0:05:49] This is one of the trucks that have surpassed it.
[0:05:52] If the council approves this purchase, we'll be replacing a 24-year-old truck and plow.
[0:05:59] have had it a few years and it is getting to the point where it needs to be replaced.
[0:06:05] But as you can see, purchase prices more than we budgeted for.
[0:06:11] 2022 has been here that we haven't seen for prices that have risen more than we ever
[0:06:21] could imagine.
[0:06:23] So in order to make this purchase possible, we also had a 2011 skid steer in our budget
[0:06:30] that we were going to replace. We will forego replacing that piece of equipment in order to
[0:06:37] cover the cost difference in the plow. So we did have 190,000 budgetage for the replacement
[0:06:47] of this product or for this piece of equipment. As I said, we will forego replacing it and dedicate
[0:06:53] the dollars to offset the cost. And I can answer any questions if you have any questions for Mark.
[0:07:02] I do not entertain a motion then. Jason Brown.
[0:07:12] I move to approve the purchase of a snowplow salt truck using the cooperative purchasing agreement in the amount of 230,356.59. Is that correct, Mark? That is correct.
[0:07:30] Thank you. Do I have a second? Thank you. Motion by Jason Brown. Seconded by Craig Hawkins.
[0:07:38] to approve the purchases of a 2024 International Combination Snowpile Salt Truck using Cooperative
[0:07:45] Purchasing Agreement with Sourcewell in the Mount of $230,356.59.
[0:07:55] Amy Roll, call vote, please.
[0:07:58] Chris Reed?
[0:07:59] Yes.
[0:08:00] Nikki Boyd?
[0:08:01] Yes.
[0:08:02] Craig Hawkins?
[0:08:03] Yes.
[0:08:04] Mason Brown?
[0:08:05] Yes.
[0:08:06] Alex Cabal?
[0:08:07] Yes.
[0:08:08] Spencer Cutler?
[0:08:09] Yes.
[0:08:10] Okay, next item of consideration is a request to purchase a 2023M-B paints driving machine
[0:08:20] using a cooperative purchasing agreement with Sourcewell at the cost of $475,975.16.
[0:08:29] Again, we have Mark.
[0:08:34] So as I said earlier before, this is a source well purchase, so we do have to come before
[0:08:40] council to get approval.
[0:08:44] Our attorney has reviewed the information and believes it is a program authorized to
[0:08:49] be utilized by Idaho Code 672807.
[0:08:54] Pavement markings are an accepted method to communicate both in the intended travel path
[0:08:59] and roadway alignment for drivers during day and night time conditions.
[0:09:04] To ensure consistent application of pavement markings, there are correct characteristics
[0:09:09] and warranty and criteria are described in the MUTCD.
[0:09:14] In section 3A03, it requires agencies to use a method designed to maintain longitudinal
[0:09:20] pavement markings to a minimum retro-reflectivity level.
[0:09:26] So our paint machine is now 12 years old in 2023 in need of replacement.
[0:09:37] So we will be asking for that replacement, but as with the other piece of equipment,
[0:09:45] we started our budgeting process back in, we started preparing for long-term planning
[0:09:51] back in November and December of twenty one all through twenty two prices have
[0:09:58] gone up significantly. So what started out as about a three hundred and eighty
[0:10:04] five thousand dollar piece of equipment and now jumped to four hundred and seventy
[0:10:07] five thousand nine hundred and seventy five sixteen. So we are over budget and we
[0:10:14] We would ask that we use $90,000, $975,000 from street reserves to offset that cost.
[0:10:27] We are in the process now, Idaho Code, Idaho Statute 6723 allows us to sell equipment to
[0:10:38] other entities as long as we follow certain requirements.
[0:10:43] We begin that process and we will, once those requirements are fulfilled and we are able to sell our paint machine, we will reimburse the reserves that we used.
[0:10:57] Mark, what's the timing on this particular machine?
[0:11:04] So, as of right now, the company has a cabin chassis sitting on their lot.
[0:11:10] So as soon as we can find the contract, then they can start building it.
[0:11:16] So we're looking at, hopefully, July, August, maybe into September to get the machine here.
[0:11:25] So if we were to wait and we didn't have a chassis sitting there, then we would be into 24 before we would see it.
[0:11:37] Well, Chris Street, understanding that long-term planning is going to be starting up again,
[0:11:43] and you're going to be going through the exact same thing you did last year,
[0:11:47] where we did see a dramatic jump in both of these pieces of equipment,
[0:11:54] understanding that this is not exactly a part of this. What's your team doing? Because next year,
[0:12:00] we're going to have the same issue. Potentially, 2023 and 2024, we're going to be having these
[0:12:06] same types of conversations. Very good question. And we've been trying to go through and figure
[0:12:10] how we're going to do that. As of right now, from what we've heard, prices are pretty stable.
[0:12:18] We've seen steel prices drop. Hopefully, when we get quotes this year, we won't see the increases
[0:12:29] that we saw in 2022. We do have the option now of going to options, so that does increase
[0:12:38] our ability to maybe make it easier to recuperate the cost if there is big increases?
[0:12:45] No, thank you. Just a concern. I mean, on the first one with this gets here that we're not purchasing 55,000 this year.
[0:12:54] What will it be next year? I mean, those types of things, is it just snowballs?
[0:12:59] And as we spend time on a budget, are we going to actually be able to meet the needs of the community the way it's going?
[0:13:07] the way it's going. Yeah, and that's a, I mean, that's a great statement because, you know,
[0:13:11] any time we push back a piece of equipment, looking at our replacement schedule to get
[0:13:16] that skidster back in, we're looking at probably 2026 before we can fit a back into, to get
[0:13:21] a replay. So any time we do have to push something back, it does, it does make a real difference
[0:13:27] in, and all the other equipment that we have to replace.
[0:13:30] Thank you. Alex Kaval. Mark, what's the typical life of one of these striping machines?
[0:13:39] 12 years.
[0:13:40] Thanks.
[0:13:43] Any other questions for Mark?
[0:13:45] I'm ready for motion.
[0:13:52] Great.
[0:13:55] Take a motion to purchase a 2023 MB paint striping machine using a cooperative purchasing
[0:14:09] agreement with Sourcewell at a cost of $475,975.16.
[0:14:17] Thank you, Alex.
[0:14:18] I second that motion.
[0:14:20] Thank you.
[0:14:21] Motion by Craig Hawkins, seconded by Alex Kavad to prove the purchase of a 2023 MB paint striping
[0:14:28] machine using a cooperative purchase agreement with Sourcewell at the cost of $4.75, $9.75
[0:14:35] and $16 cents.
[0:14:40] You just need us to add the money coming out of reserves.
[0:14:43] Yes, please.
[0:14:44] And the money to reserve.
[0:14:46] $9,000, $9.75, $16 out of reserves.
[0:14:50] Okay.
[0:14:51] Is that okay?
[0:14:53] Yep.
[0:14:54] So, the motion is to approve the purchase of a 2023 MB paint striping
[0:15:00] machine using a cooperative purchase agreement with source well at a cost of 4.75, 9.75, 16 with 90,975, 16 coming out of
[0:15:11] any further discussion? Amy Roll-cuff-hold, please.
[0:15:17] Alex Koval? Yes. Spencer Kettler? Yes. Jason Brown? Yes. Craig Hawkins? Yes. Nicky Boyd? Yes. Chris Reed? Yes.
[0:15:19] Chris Reed Pierce? Yes. Thank you. Mark, motion passes 7-0. Great. Thank you.
[0:15:32] Hey, that's all for general business. Next on the agenda is general public input.
[0:15:39] public input if there's anybody out in the public that wishes to come down and
[0:15:44] speak please do see no one advisory board reports yes mayor yes so we are going to
[0:15:54] have a youth council meeting next Monday at four o'clock before city council
[0:16:00] meeting and just trying to get the word out there we'll get some fun on social
[0:16:05] media just trying to word a mouth trying to get some of the youth to tell their
[0:16:08] friends about it so feel free to spread the word perfect thank you Nicky Boyd
[0:16:13] yes I think this came out in in many forms but hopefully everybody saw this and
[0:16:21] you can tell people it's a big deal it's a trend of libraries right now but we
[0:16:27] announced that as of January 2nd which was yesterday the Twin Falls Public
[0:16:33] library will be fine free. So anybody who has looks that they've checked out and they haven't
[0:16:41] returned and they can just bring them back and there's no fine going forward. There won't
[0:16:47] be any fine. And then the accounts that have overdue balances are forgiven. So this is all
[0:16:55] The only thing is if you have equipment, hard assets that taxpayers have paid for, that is not part of the fine free, but all any books in that case.
[0:17:11] Anyway, I thought that was kind of a neat thing and hopefully that will get some people who aren't using the library who want to come back.
[0:17:19] Perfect. Thank you. Anybody else? Did he manage your office?
[0:17:26] Just a reminder, so January is kind of that odd month where we meet on a Tuesday than a
[0:17:33] Monday than a Tuesday. So next week we will be meeting at our normal time on Monday at
[0:17:39] five o'clock and then the following week will be closed on the 16th in observation of Martin
[0:17:44] with the King Jr. Day their forum meeting will be moved again to Tuesday at 5 o'clock.
[0:17:51] So just if people are watching, trying to understand our schedule happens every year in January.
[0:17:57] We kind of hopscotch for a couple of days, but again Monday next week Tuesday the following,
[0:18:01] and then we're going to contract for a little while.
[0:18:04] Perfect, thank you.
[0:18:08] Okay, and we have no public hearings tonight.
[0:18:11] on the agenda is an executive session action item under code section 74206 1B to consider
[0:18:19] the evaluation dismissal or disciplining of or to hear complaints or charges brought against
[0:18:25] a public officer employees staff member or individual agent or public school student.
[0:18:30] That moved.
[0:18:31] Thank you Jason.
[0:18:32] Second motion by Jason Brown second and by Alex Kaval it was very close.
[0:18:41] to move into executive session under 74-206-1B.
[0:18:48] Amy Rocha, vote please.
[0:18:51] Spencer Cutler.
[0:18:52] Yes.
[0:18:54] Ruth Pierce.
[0:18:54] Yes.
[0:18:55] Chris Rie.
[0:18:56] Yes.
[0:18:57] Nikki Boyd. Yes.
[0:18:58] Ray Cawkins. Yes.
[0:18:59] Jason Brown. Yes.
[0:19:00] And Alex Kaval. Yes.
[0:19:02] Thank you, motion passes seven to zero.
[0:19:04] We will not be making any decisions
[0:19:06] in executive session and we will not reconvene.
[0:19:10] So, meeting's adjourned, thank you everyone.
