Oversight Archive: City Council meeting, 2023-02-13, recording 1 (started 16:59)
Machine transcript (faster-whisper base.en), not checked word for word; the Pledge of Allegiance is shown in its standard wording. The recording is the record.
Times are time into the recording. Passages with private details are muted in the audio and marked here.
The audio on the page below was re-encoded by software from the video the agency posted. Check any passage against
that audio before relying on it.
Page: https://oversightarchive.org/twin-falls-id/meetings/2023-02-13/

[0:00:54] Ladies and gentlemen, welcome to the February 13th, 2023 City Council meeting.
[0:01:01] I want to confirm we have a quorum.
[0:01:03] We have six members present and I believe we have Councilman Hawkins trying to call in.
[0:01:11] So first item on the agenda is the Pledge of Allegiance.
[0:01:15] Anybody wish you to join me please rise.
[0:01:41] So first item on the agenda is the consent calendar, council wishes.
[0:01:47] I move the consent calendar.
[0:01:51] Thank you.
[0:01:52] Motion by Jason Brown second by Alex Kaval to approve the consent calendar as written.
[0:01:59] Amy Rokavo please.
[0:02:10] Yes.
[0:02:12] Motion passes six to zero.
[0:02:18] Next item under items of consideration and action item a request to approve an agreement
[0:02:24] as presented between the City of Twin Falls and the City Attorney, and we have
[0:02:29] Ida Clark, our HR Director, welcome Ida.
[0:02:32] Council and this agreement does not change the current compensation and it
[0:03:06] shall be automatically amended to reflect any salary and compensation adjustments
[0:03:10] that are provided or required by the compensation policies as directed
[0:03:15] in a post paid time off the performance evaluation and the termination.
[0:03:23] We meant Shell automatic C days prior to the end of the fist just so everybody understand she's changed been working for us since 2018.
[0:03:45] And it came to my attention that we didn't have any kind of contract with him at all.
[0:03:51] And so this is just putting in writing what we agreed to way back when and how we've been operating over the last half years.
[0:04:01] I just want to first thank all those parties that were involved in this. I know this took quite some time together
[0:04:10] So, so thank you for that and how it may falls in the city attorney. Thank you Jason Brown
[0:04:21] Thank you motion by Chris Reed seconded by Jason Brown to
[0:04:25] Approve the agreement is presented between the city of Twin Falls and the city attorney
[0:04:30] Amy roll call vote, please. Yes. Yes
[0:04:41] Thank you.
[0:04:46] Next on the agenda is a presentation of presentation from the Twin Falls School District Superintendent
[0:04:54] Brady Dickinson regarding the district's upcoming supplemental levy election.
[0:04:58] Welcome Brady.
[0:04:59] Thank you Mad Members.
[0:05:00] Got access.
[0:05:04] Thank you for the opportunity to present tonight to Council as one of the tax in entities for
[0:05:28] the city.
[0:05:29] I think it's important that we share information on levies in regards to our taxes.
[0:05:36] So tonight I'll just take a few minutes of your time and go through the renewal of our supplemental levy.
[0:05:45] As I go around the community, I'm often asked about the levies and the notion that it feels like we always have these.
[0:05:52] With the supplemental levy, that's because it's a two-year levy and so it expires after two years.
[0:05:57] And so after two years, you either need to renew it or it goes away.
[0:06:01] And so that's where we are today, in terms of this particular funding source, and so it's up for renewal, and it passed, but come back in two years.
[0:06:25] So I think it's important anytime we talk about school funding that we always look back to our past, and our community deserves a big thank you to the school system, or from the school system, because our community has always supported its schools here.
[0:06:40] And Falls, this is actually the very first school house right in the center.
[0:06:44] There here in Twin Falls, it was actually in the downtown area, probably pretty close to
[0:06:49] where we are today.
[0:06:50] It was 40 by 20 at one time.
[0:06:52] It had over 100 students in it and actually had a wood stove where they burned sagebrush
[0:06:58] in the winter for heat, which I'm sure was delightful.
[0:07:01] And eventually, you can see on the right there, the very first pickle elementary school that
[0:07:06] was opened in 1905, the first Twin Falls High School.
[0:07:10] which later became the first of Larry,
[0:07:12] now by the city park, and now we have 16 schools
[0:07:16] here in Twin Falls, and so we have a rich history
[0:07:18] of education here in Twin Falls,
[0:07:20] something we can be proud of,
[0:07:21] many of the very first people that moved to this area
[0:07:23] came from other parts of the country
[0:07:25] that valued education, and so the first thing
[0:07:27] that they desired was to have a schoolhouse,
[0:07:29] and so it is true that we had a school
[0:07:31] before we had a saloon here in Twin Falls,
[0:07:33] although somebody said the other day they doubted
[0:07:35] it was very long before we had the accompanying saloon.
[0:07:40] So whenever we make decisions on things like levy,
[0:07:44] we do employ a budget advisory committee.
[0:07:47] And so we have a committee of folks
[0:07:49] that we bring together about 25 people
[0:07:51] from all different walks of life
[0:07:53] to try to get a wide variety of opinions.
[0:07:57] We meet early in the morning
[0:07:59] and dig into district finances,
[0:08:01] which is always a good way to spend your morning
[0:08:04] if you've never done it.
[0:08:05] But they go through and they really look at
[0:08:09] revenues or incomes where we have areas of need and then they ultimately make a
[0:08:15] recommendation to the school board which then the school board decides what to go
[0:08:18] with. So this year the levy the excuse me the committee recommended to the board
[0:08:24] that we continue the same levy that we have right now which is a five point seven
[0:08:29] million dollar levy. They had a pretty good argument for looking to increase it
[0:08:34] because we have added security personnel in the district and with inflation our
[0:08:39] costs have escalated quite a bit but we still have S or funds available for the
[0:08:44] next year and a half and so those S or funds or federal dollars are really
[0:08:49] helping to to mitigate some of those costs and so it did not feel it now is
[0:08:54] the right time to look at any kinds of increases and so the rationale behind it
[0:08:58] is it continues with the programs we have we won't have to make any cuts in the
[0:09:02] district and it keeps property taxes where they are.
[0:09:05] We know that that's a real concern today.
[0:09:07] And so keeping those property taxes at a level is important.
[0:09:13] So the next couple of slides just kind of go through
[0:09:15] and show you what we operate on.
[0:09:17] This slide here shows you our overall revenues
[0:09:20] in the district.
[0:09:21] And so we receive about $65 million a year
[0:09:24] directly from the state, makes up 71.3% of that funding.
[0:09:30] And so you can see there that most of our money comes directly from the state of Idaho.
[0:09:35] The state of Idaho funds education through sales tax.
[0:09:38] And so when the economy is doing really well and everybody's buying cars and
[0:09:42] houses and everything else, there's additional funds where there's money being generated for education.
[0:09:48] When we go through a recession and sales tax revenues drop off, that's when you start hearing a lot of discussion about whether or
[0:09:54] not there have to be cuts or other things within the budget.
[0:09:57] hasn't always been funded by sales tax but since 2006 that's been our primary
[0:10:02] funding source. The other areas there you can see the next largest piece of that
[0:10:06] pie is money from the feds it's about ten million dollars a year and that and those
[0:10:11] are not our S or funds we didn't include those in there because S or funds are
[0:10:15] one-time monies. Federal funds come into the district for things like our title
[0:10:19] programs and title programs support, kids in poverty they support your English
[0:10:25] language learners, your special ed students, they come with a lot of strings attached, you
[0:10:31] can only use them for various programs. The other three sections there of that pie, those
[0:10:36] are the local tax monies that come into the district, those are the ones that are voted
[0:10:40] on by our community. I'm going to start at the top, the 6.5 million, that's the bond fund,
[0:10:46] that's the money that comes in to pay for the new schools. So we explain to patrons that
[0:10:50] that's kind of like having a house payment. You know, though that we build the schools,
[0:10:55] We don't have the capital to build a school up front, so we borrow the money through bonding,
[0:11:00] and then we pay it back over a 20-25 year period.
[0:11:03] The plant facility levy, it's a 10 year levy that pays for maintenance in the district.
[0:11:08] It was passed in 2018, so it will be backed up for a renewal in 2028, it provides $4.25 million
[0:11:15] a year, solely for building maintenance.
[0:11:19] The last portion of that pie is the supplemental, this is the 5.7 million that I'm talking to
[0:11:25] you today, makes up roughly 6.3% of this revenue chart, and so you can see it's not a huge portion
[0:11:33] of the overall money that comes into the district, but it is a really important piece of the puzzle.
[0:11:38] And so the first thing that I would note to patrons is that most of the money for schools
[0:11:43] comes directly from the state.
[0:11:44] If you look at the money from our property owners, you can see there the sections that
[0:11:49] make up that total revenue and it's definitely not nearly as great as what comes from the
[0:11:55] state.
[0:11:56] And they compare it nationally and to the state we're on the lower side of the funding
[0:11:59] scale and that's been a situation for a long time.
[0:12:02] I actually think that it's pretty remarkable what we're able to do with the dollars that
[0:12:06] we receive and that Biden was doing a good job and I'm supposed to click.
[0:12:16] So this is where the money goes.
[0:12:17] This shouldn't be a huge surprise.
[0:12:18] It goes to pay for people.
[0:12:20] So 53% goes to pay directly for salaries in the district,
[0:12:25] 23% for benefits, so health care and health insurance
[0:12:29] and other employee costs retirement.
[0:12:31] We do contract for some employees, some of our students receive,
[0:12:35] for example, physical therapy within the schools.
[0:12:38] We don't hire physical therapists, and so we contract for those.
[0:12:41] When you add it all up, about 80% of all the money that we bring in pays for people.
[0:12:46] Beyond that, we have about 7.8% for supplies,
[0:12:49] supplies and then our capital expenses came back on those bonds and then our maintenance
[0:12:54] costs.
[0:12:58] So this shows you the breakdown of our employees in our school system.
[0:13:02] We're really familiar with this, but for those people on the community being not know
[0:13:05] what these categories are, certify employees are teachers and counselors who are on a yearly
[0:13:12] contract.
[0:13:13] So they're not hourly, they're salary, not a yearly contract, classified employees all
[0:13:19] of our hourly employees.
[0:13:20] employees, so these are going to be our secretaries and our maintenance folks and our food service
[0:13:25] workers and custodians and they'll fall into that category and then 5.7% is administration.
[0:13:33] The reason I put this on here is I want to show that the vast majority of our funds go
[0:13:38] to pay for certified and classified.
[0:13:40] Most of it is not within the administrative ranks and I think that's an important point
[0:13:44] because we do receive the question about whether or not we're spending too much on administration
[0:13:48] or too top heavy, we're actually about half a position under what the state says that we
[0:13:53] should have in terms of the number of administrators. And so we try to put the most of the money
[0:13:59] as much as we can within those other classified areas or certified areas and not in the administrative.
[0:14:07] So what does the levy pay for? So a year ago, the State of Idaho passed a law that said
[0:14:11] we have to spell out exactly what the levy is spent on. The last time I did this presentation
[0:14:15] I talked about how the levy is just a revenue source that helps support all programs in the district.
[0:14:21] We can't do that anymore.
[0:14:22] Now we have to spell out exactly what it's used for.
[0:14:26] And these are the areas that you would see cuts if the levy is unsuccessful.
[0:14:30] And so these are the areas that as a community, we'll need to decide if we want to continue with.
[0:14:35] The first thing the levy pays for is school safety and security.
[0:14:38] The state of Idaho does not provide money in a category that says school safety.
[0:14:43] So you have to carve it out of your budget from somewhere and so the vast majority of
[0:14:48] our funds for security come from the supplemental levy about 1.3 million worth.
[0:14:54] So we have our resource officers, which we share costs with the city to have our resource
[0:14:58] officers.
[0:15:00] We have security and behavior aids and then we added an additional layer of the share.
[0:15:04] We hired an arm security guard for every elementary school and so we hired these folks actually.
[0:15:11] We hired 10, because one's over at Bridge Academy as well,
[0:15:14] at a significant cost.
[0:15:15] But again, feeling like that safety and security
[0:15:18] is something that absolutely needs
[0:15:19] to be increased within schools.
[0:15:22] A small portion of that 5.7 helps pay for activities.
[0:15:26] In particular, not having to use what's called pay for play.
[0:15:30] In some places, just to go out for an activity,
[0:15:33] you have to pay a cost up front.
[0:15:35] We have not done that.
[0:15:36] I was actually talking to somebody the other day
[0:15:38] who has a child, friends in another state, and for their son to play high school baseball
[0:15:43] is $1,200.
[0:15:44] I'll comment that is, but here in the district we do not have any fees for kids to go out
[0:15:52] for these activities.
[0:15:53] I don't believe in pay for play because it hurts kids in poverty.
[0:15:56] Some of the kids that are in most need of participating in activities, if parents have
[0:16:00] to decide between that activity and paying the power bill or putting food on the table
[0:16:05] they're obviously not going to participate.
[0:16:07] We're still have to buy all the things that go along with that.
[0:16:09] We're not buying the shoes, the spare packs or anything like that, but it helps so that
[0:16:13] we don't have to have those upfront cost of parents.
[0:16:16] And then the lion's share of the money, about $4 million of it pays for staff.
[0:16:19] This shouldn't be a surprise because I talked earlier about how most of our money pays for
[0:16:23] staffing.
[0:16:24] And so about $4 million, again, the lion's share of the money pays for those categories,
[0:16:28] and I'll break that down here for you next in the next couple of slides.
[0:16:33] So it pays for 70 classified positions.
[0:16:36] So we talked about classified being those hourly employees.
[0:16:39] The state funding formula, the last time that it was modified was 1994 and in 1994 they
[0:16:46] didn't have things like IT.
[0:16:49] And so the funding formula is really anemic in those areas.
[0:16:53] And so we have to pay for those positions out of things like the supplemental levy or
[0:16:57] the categories of supplemental levy.
[0:17:00] So, we have a hard time in two areas
[0:17:02] when our classified folks are short on numbers,
[0:17:05] and then our salaries are not competitive currently.
[0:17:07] We have a really time hard time hiring right now,
[0:17:10] because we haven't been able to keep up with inflation
[0:17:13] and what employers are paying within the community,
[0:17:16] so we're struggling to fill positions.
[0:17:18] About 21 of our certified physicians
[0:17:22] come from a supplement,
[0:17:22] let me say those are teachers primarily,
[0:17:25] and that does two things.
[0:17:26] One, it helps us to keep class sizes down,
[0:17:28] and then we are able to offer some electives
[0:17:30] within our community that we feel are pretty important.
[0:17:33] Things like elementary music and other electives
[0:17:36] at the secondary level, and we're able to do that
[0:17:38] because the levy helps provide that support.
[0:17:41] And then on the administrative side,
[0:17:42] we have the same problem that we have
[0:17:43] in the classified side.
[0:17:45] When the formula was written, it didn't,
[0:17:47] we are under in terms of the number,
[0:17:49] but it doesn't generate the kinds of funds
[0:17:51] that you need to have in order to have all the employees.
[0:17:53] And so it helps to ensure that we're able to have
[0:17:56] employees within each of the schools. The last thing that it does is it provides
[0:18:01] money for what we're calling temporary positions. We have all different types
[0:18:05] of clubs in after-school programs and the money has to come for some part of
[0:18:10] pay for those. And so we're able to pay teachers generally, some stipends in order
[0:18:16] to do a wide variety of work after school. Sometimes we pay them during the
[0:18:20] summer to come in and complete work as well. And so again that's an important
[0:18:24] piece but not a really large part of it. The last is probably something that might be
[0:18:31] of interest to those who are watching this actually shows you what money comes into the
[0:18:38] district from property taxes. So I'm going to spend just a minute on these next two slides
[0:18:42] to break this down. These are actual dollars and you can see each component of what we
[0:18:47] collect and so the black portion at the bottom, that's the supplemental levy that's we're
[0:18:52] talking about here tonight. The blue, that's the money for the bond. So the money that's coming in
[0:18:57] to pay back those bonds. The gold is the plant facilities. So those are the big three that I showed
[0:19:02] you at the beginning. And then the red we haven't talked about. The red is a tort levy, which is not
[0:19:07] voted on as a small amount of money to pay for liability insurance. And then if we have a lot of
[0:19:12] growth in the district, our board has the option of taking what's called an emergency levy. It's not
[0:19:18] voted on by the public, but it's some additional money right at the beginning of the school year.
[0:19:22] If for some reason we have explosive growth in the district and there have been some years where we had quite a bit more growth
[0:19:28] And when we anticipated we had to hire staff right at the beginning of the year
[0:19:31] And so if you look at the high point
[0:19:34] 2019 we were collecting 19 and a half million dollars
[0:19:37] and overall money from the community and property taxes since that time is really dropped starting in
[0:19:44] 2021 we said that if we and that's last time we increase this supplemental levy
[0:19:48] But we said that if we passed it we wouldn't take the emergency levy unless
[0:19:52] we really had a lot of growth and we haven't so you can see that that red
[0:19:56] category has stayed pretty low. The other thing looking at this year
[0:20:00] in 2023 and 17 million is two and a half million dollars less
[0:20:04] than what we were collecting in 2019. The major portion of that is because
[0:20:10] COVID didn't do really anything good other than lower our interest rates.
[0:20:15] So during COVID it was a good time to refinance your house or buy a car
[0:20:18] And so we refinance those bonds and so by refinancing the bonds, we saved our community a significant amount of money and so we were able to lower the amount overall in terms of colors that we were collecting from the community.
[0:20:32] More importantly, this is what's happened with your rate or your overall tax rate for the Twin Falls School District.
[0:20:39] And so again, I'm sure that councils used to see these kinds of numbers, but this is for every $1,000 of taxable values.
[0:20:45] So again, after your homeowner's exemption,
[0:20:48] what's remaining becomes your taxable value.
[0:20:51] We hit a high point back in 2017 at $4.82.
[0:20:56] And since that time, our rate has been dropping.
[0:20:58] The reason our rate has dropped primarily
[0:21:00] is because we collect a set amount.
[0:21:03] And so in order to collect a set amount,
[0:21:05] you have to raise lower the rate as property values go up.
[0:21:09] And so as the property values into and falls continue
[0:21:12] to increase, our rate will continue to decrease
[0:21:15] because we only collect $5.7 million in a supplemental levy,
[0:21:19] and that's the way all of our, pretty much all of our funds work.
[0:21:22] And so it's not a situation where,
[0:21:25] and some people have this misconception in the community
[0:21:28] that we collect more money as those property values go up.
[0:21:32] But we collect a set of amounts with great,
[0:21:34] just continues to drop.
[0:21:36] If you look at your overall tax bill for every $100,000
[0:21:39] of property value, it's about $6.25
[0:21:42] that overall tax bill goes to your supplemental fund, so you should just click any of these.
[0:21:51] So with that, I always stop short of telling people how to vote, people in Idaho hate to
[0:21:56] be told how to vote, so that's not why I'm here tonight.
[0:21:59] I'm simply here to ask that you participate in this community decision.
[0:22:02] So whether you think this is a great idea or a horrible idea, I hope everybody watching
[0:22:06] tonight will participate and take the opportunity to have your voice heard.
[0:22:10] You can vote on election day, which is March 14th.
[0:22:12] The polls will be open from 8 to 8.
[0:22:14] You can start voting in person early, starting on February 27th, and then apps and T-Ballots
[0:22:20] are the deadline on those as March 3rd.
[0:22:24] So again, I just want to encourage everybody to participate in the process, and with that,
[0:22:29] I would stand for any questions.
[0:22:32] Any questions for Brady?
[0:22:46] Someone's written a bill.
[0:23:02] So not really with this.
[0:23:04] What that bill does is it generates a pot of money that they would use to pay, they would
[0:23:09] give the money to us instead of the money coming from our taxpayers and then they
[0:23:13] would pay off some of these as primarily in the bond fund and so they would the
[0:23:18] idea would be that they would pay off some of our bonds and then over time that
[0:23:23] would generate additional funds that they would put into a pot which they could
[0:23:26] then give out to school districts as they build schools so that you wouldn't
[0:23:30] have to go to your necessarily your property owners for as much in terms of
[0:23:34] funding to build those new schools and so I wouldn't impact this is primarily meant
[0:23:39] to provide property taxes by taking over some of those bond payments and not having
[0:23:45] that money. Does that make sense? Thank you for your time. Okay before we go to
[0:24:01] the next item Shane Nikki did not get to vote on that last vote. Correct. That's not always clear.
[0:24:26] Next item on the agenda is an action item it's request to develop a new Jocelyn
[0:25:03] I'll bring up a so as I mentioned that this idea was born Mac in December, Angel and I had a discussion
[0:25:24] and he talked to me about the 75th anniversary of the airport here in 2023 and it might be a good idea
[0:25:32] to think about updating and freshening or a logo so I put together a slide here, lines a process
[0:25:48] So, just this past February 7th, I met with the airport to talk about this concept.
[0:25:56] They were very much in favor of moving forward and they wanted me to move this forward for city and county consideration.
[0:26:02] So, I'm here tonight on the 13th and I'll be visiting with our county commissioners or partners over at the county later this week.
[0:26:10] So, the process to perhaps roll us out.
[0:26:13] What we've come up with is to develop a task force, a little subcommittee of individuals.
[0:26:20] We've got Angel, of course, Terry Halberd, who's a community artist, photographer of
[0:26:25] the Arts Council.
[0:26:26] He's also the editor for the upcoming Air Show program and poster of those types of
[0:26:31] things that will be coming out, anniversary Air Show, Father's State Weekend.
[0:26:36] So we asked a couple of board members, one, J. P. O'Donnell's Accountee Representative,
[0:26:42] Gallim Organist City representative to assist Angel Gonzalez and Terry looking for submissions
[0:26:49] for consideration.
[0:26:50] And we really followed the model I talked with Mitch Humble a bit about the one city logo
[0:26:55] that came out some years ago that performance organization effort.
[0:27:02] So that would be the use of a web-based site that level for graphic artists to partake in
[0:27:12] and submit, you know, you fill out a questionnaire background, some of your branding, your history,
[0:27:18] whatever, and so the submissions are put in, the artists really all around, so the committee
[0:27:28] would work through the March time frame to come up with their top choices and bring that to the
[0:27:34] airport discussion, their recommendation, and final selection, and we thought that that should
[0:27:43] probably lie with that group. So in June, we'd be in time for production printing to display it
[0:27:50] at an air show close to on the poster and in the program.
[0:27:54] So down below here is our current logo
[0:27:58] and that coincided with our 50th airport anniversary,
[0:28:03] and that was back in 19 years.
[0:28:11] So very nice logo, but I think some folks
[0:28:16] feel it'd be a good idea.
[0:28:17] Updates on here tonight.
[0:28:19] Certainly to answer any questions you have,
[0:28:21] but to recommend from the council
[0:28:24] to move forward with the process as described.
[0:28:26] So, some of you on the council for the Stockland City, alright?
[0:29:36] Chris Reed, an estimated cost, but I think I put a thousand dollars in your report, plus or minus, I'm imagining, we've been some inflation since the one city production, but I'm thinking somewhere around that.
[0:29:54] Key Motion by Nicky Boyd, seconded by Alex Kaval to approve the development of the new Bow for Jocelyn Field.
[0:30:22] Amy Rokavo, please.
[0:30:29] Yes, okay motion passes six to zero. Thank you. That's all on under items of consideration. The next item is
[0:30:47] the time for general public input. If there's anybody in the public who wishes to address city
[0:30:53] council, please come up on an item not on today's agenda. Please come up to the podium, state your
[0:31:00] name, whether you're a resident of Twin Falls and you have two minutes. Welcome. Good evening
[0:31:12] Members of City Council, my name is Arnell. I am a resident of this community. I'm here to address
[0:31:18] the graffiti problem again. As you're aware, the city has ordinances in place to address this issue.
[0:31:26] I wanted to provide some other options the City Council has. Here's some of them.
[0:31:31] Increase the city ordinance fee for graffiti violation, provide resources for removal such as paint,
[0:31:39] Commission and art piece on problematic area, similar to how the city hall building has an art piece on it, nobody touches that.
[0:31:46] Science, communicating consequences for vandalism, so it just shows signs essentially run discouraged as to stop the behavior, make graffiti reporting more simple and convenient for residents.
[0:32:06] Most communities also reward for reporting this and leading to a violation and arrest or something, so they will have a reward system.
[0:32:23] And I know this city already has some type of system where they have it for the kids.
[0:32:29] Maybe that needs to be reset so that way they're able to go ahead and do more artwork on the designated area and so forth.
[0:32:39] So, those are just a few options that you have at your disposal, doing nothing is, I don't think it's the right approach,
[0:32:47] because there are different options that you can go ahead and take in addressing the graffiti issue itself.
[0:32:52] So, I hope you guys consider that. Thank you.
[0:32:57] So anybody else from the audience that wishes to come down and address City Council this evening?
[0:33:03] Okay, see and no one advisory board report on website, the City Manager's Office, and a slash Tuesday.
[0:34:27] Yours would be...
[0:34:32] So next item on the agenda is a public hearing which we cannot start till six o'clock.
[0:34:49] But at this point in time we're going to take a brief recess and we will back here a few minutes before six for the public hearing.
[0:34:57] Thank you, everyone. Good evening again, ladies and gentlemen.
[0:35:35] Now is time for the public hearing. Public hearing today is a request for an amendment to the C1PD
[0:35:50] agreement number 229, Canyon Properties to allow for additional building height, maximum
[0:35:56] 23, excuse me, 35 feet, or lot 28 block 13, Canyon 12 subdivision number 10, care of Gary Nelson.
[0:36:06] on behalf of County and Properties LLC and the IDO Department of Labor.
[0:36:11] So first I'm going to read the public hearing rules.
[0:36:15] First City staff will present the request in the analysis.
[0:36:19] The applicant will then present their request.
[0:36:22] The council will then ask questions of the applicant or staff.
[0:36:26] After questions have been asked, the public hearing will then be open.
[0:36:31] At that time, anyone in attendance will be given an opportunity
[0:36:35] an opportunity to comment or ask questions about the request. If you're going to participate
[0:36:42] in the public portion of the public hearing, please step up to the podium, state your name
[0:36:47] and address and present your comments or concerns. And then after you give testimony,
[0:36:52] please sign the public record upstairs or in the lobby with your name and address for
[0:36:59] our record. After the public comments are concluded, the applicant will be invited to
[0:37:03] to answer any questions to make a closing statement.
[0:37:06] Staff will then answer clarifying comments.
[0:37:10] After the closing statements, the public hearing
[0:37:12] will be closed, no further testimony,
[0:37:15] or comments from the applicant or audience will be allowed.
[0:37:19] And then after that council will have open discussion
[0:37:21] and take action.
[0:37:23] So first we have Jonathan Spinnlove.
[0:37:27] Welcome Jonathan.
[0:37:38] We are discussing his outline here in this yellow line.
[0:37:43] This is the use of a government office, is it right and by right he's permitted the original
[0:38:11] P, the council, allowing them 35 feet, just asking to have a little bit so they can be
[0:38:38] a structure that looks like this.
[0:38:42] It's not this exact one.
[0:38:44] This is the plans that the Idaho Department has commissioned in this edition, what they're
[0:39:03] asking for is the edition of those commission debates, somebody else that purchased this
[0:39:41] property and say this project fell through, have a two story building looking.
[0:40:03] So Jonathan, is there anything around that property right now?
[0:40:09] We don't have a...
[0:40:10] The only thing that's constructed is a Blake Street, which is listed on here.
[0:40:18] Blake Street's actually outside city limits.
[0:40:21] These two homes, hospice is here, which across this access driveway.
[0:40:34] There's another project that's constructed down here on the pulley.
[0:40:39] If that's all that's constructed in the air, there's a West, get it in a super dealer.
[0:41:01] Jason Brown.
[0:41:03] about some of those buildings that you had just mentioned.
[0:41:06] Yes, so I don't know the distance of 500 feet
[0:41:21] was the buffer zone, OK?
[0:41:22] So the vision's hospice is in it.
[0:41:24] The other buildings out here are at Southside with.
[0:42:13] I see your saying, Ken, this says,
[0:42:57] I've got a dic and dic process.
[0:43:04] I'm getting else into this.
[0:43:24] I mean, some of these things are definitely open for you.
[0:43:52] I guess I would.
[0:43:53] I say it's in your purview, but I advise
[0:43:55] that we just stick with it.
[0:43:57] Is there any factor for the extra seven feet?
[0:43:59] Because then you have a direct tie to what they're asking for
[0:44:02] and what the result is?
[0:44:04] Let's really fix a prior.
[0:44:06] Any other questions for Jonathan?
[0:44:36] It was stated, this is an example of our cold, well-building.
[0:45:01] In a state process, we cannot.
[0:45:04] And so, so this is to build, so no second floor.
[0:45:55] Any questions for the applicant?
[0:46:45] It's time for if there's anybody out in the audience that wishes to speak, come to the podium.
[0:47:42] You're concerned.
[0:47:42] So my question is, what is the property sewn dead?
[0:48:34] I don't know what the zoning is there.
[0:48:58] But he also wished to come down and speak.
[0:49:00] Sorry, thank you.
[0:49:15] This was a larger plus acre developed.
[0:49:26] This area is listed which is more commercial.
[0:49:43] And it has an idea of what's kind of listed over in this area is a commercial.
[0:49:52] There's a lot in this and I don't think every single thing.
[0:49:55] But in general, the commercial is more on pull line.
[0:49:58] That's where you see your banks.
[0:50:01] The stuff is closer to the exactly what's coming in because I don't have plain plots.
[0:50:11] stuff like what's being proposed tonight is generally what when this was put
[0:50:16] that this is what it looks like small changes happen with buildings coming up
[0:50:34] there's a lot that's where this amendment had in the zones and the T1 zone some
[0:51:06] things are notting it's a little bit difficult as C1PAD canyon properties the
[0:51:26] false this document and I can certainly get a qualifying statement by the applicant
[0:51:48] We'll close the public hearing.
[0:51:53] Council wishes, comments, questions, thoughts?
[0:52:00] Motion to have a second.
[0:53:31] Motion by Nikki Boyd, seconded by Alex Kaval to approve
[0:53:35] the amendment to the C-1B-UD agreement.
[0:53:38] Number 229, Kenny Properties.
[0:53:41] Any further discussion?
[0:53:43] Amy Rokal, please.
[0:53:47] Yes.
[0:53:49] Yes.
[0:53:51] Yes.
[0:53:53] You think your motion passes 5 to 0?
[0:54:01] That's it.
[0:54:02] Thank you everyone.
[0:54:04] Meeting adjourned.
