Oversight Archive: City Council meeting, 2023-04-17, recording 1 (started 16:58)
Machine transcript (faster-whisper base.en), not checked word for word; the Pledge of Allegiance is shown in its standard wording. The recording is the record.
Times are time into the recording. Passages with private details are muted in the audio and marked here.
The audio on the page below was re-encoded by software from the video the agency posted. Check any passage against
that audio before relying on it.
Page: https://oversightarchive.org/twin-falls-id/meetings/2023-04-17/

[0:01:53] Good evening, ladies and gentlemen, and welcome to the April 17th, 2020
[0:01:59] Three city council meeting. I want to confirm we have a quorum
[0:02:03] All seven members are present in chambers tonight
[0:02:06] Our first item on the agenda is the pledge of allegiance. If you wish to join me, please rise
[0:02:31] We have no proclamations tonight. So the first item on the agenda is the consent calendar council wishes
[0:02:38] Thank you, Craig Hawkins.
[0:02:46] Thank you, motion by Alex Cabal is seconded by Craig Hawkins to approve the consent calendar
[0:02:52] is written.
[0:02:54] Amy Rokal, please.
[0:02:56] Yes.
[0:02:57] Yes.
[0:02:58] Yes.
[0:02:59] Yes.
[0:03:00] Yes.
[0:03:01] Yes.
[0:03:02] Yes.
[0:03:03] Yes.
[0:03:04] Yes.
[0:03:05] Thank you.
[0:03:06] Motion passes seven to zero.
[0:03:09] Okay, first item on the under items of consideration as an action item are
[0:03:15] Request to approve the reappointment of Terry Winkle to the Twin Falls housing Authority
[0:03:19] And we have sunny Shaw. I believe hi, Sunny from the Twin Falls housing Authority to make the presentation
[0:03:27] Welcome
[0:03:32] Need the mic on
[0:03:33] That's much better
[0:03:37] Thank you Madam mayor and esteemed council. I am sunny Shaw
[0:03:40] I am the Executive Director of your Twin Falls Housing Authority.
[0:03:44] I'm going to be short and brief because you have some super cool things happening behind me.
[0:03:49] I am here just to request that you approve Terry Winkle for another term on the Twin Falls Housing Authority Board.
[0:03:57] He has served a partial term which according to our bylaws makes him eligible for two full terms.
[0:04:04] Each term is a five-year timeframe.
[0:04:08] He tells me that he will be retiring after a five-year timeframe,
[0:04:12] so we'll knock on wood about that one.
[0:04:14] Terry has been a fabulous addition to our board.
[0:04:17] He brings vast experience, obviously, in the real estate market,
[0:04:21] as he helps us to think to the future and vision for plans for development.
[0:04:25] And because of these reasons,
[0:04:28] furthermore, he does not miss meetings, and that's really hard,
[0:04:32] and help it's hard on us when people miss a meeting
[0:04:36] and it's helpful when they're there
[0:04:38] so we can move our work forward.
[0:04:40] So I request that you approve that he be given
[0:04:44] another term on our board.
[0:04:46] Thank you, Sunny.
[0:04:47] Thank you, Board.
[0:04:49] If you're a motion.
[0:04:50] Yeah, I'm if there's no questions for Sunny.
[0:04:52] Perfect, thank you.
[0:04:54] Air, I would be thrilled to the reappointment
[0:04:59] of Terry Winkle's housing in the board.
[0:05:02] Thank you.
[0:05:03] Do I have a second?
[0:05:05] So moved.
[0:05:06] Thank you, motion by Nikki Boyd, seconded by Craig Hawkins
[0:05:10] to approve the reappointment of Terry Winkel
[0:05:13] to the Twin Falls Housing Authority.
[0:05:16] Any further discussion?
[0:05:18] Amy Roll, call vote please.
[0:05:21] Chris Reed?
[0:05:22] Yes.
[0:05:23] Nikki Boyd?
[0:05:24] Yes, Craig Hawkins.
[0:05:25] Yes, Jason Brown?
[0:05:26] Yes.
[0:05:27] Alex Cabal?
[0:05:27] Yes, Spencer Cutler?
[0:05:29] Yes.
[0:05:29] And Ruth Beers?
[0:05:30] Yes.
[0:05:31] Thank you.
[0:05:33] Motion passes 7-0.
[0:05:35] Thank you, Sunny.
[0:05:36] Okay, next item on the agenda is a presentation,
[0:05:41] a swearing in ceremony for a new
[0:05:43] Twin Falls police officer.
[0:05:45] It is requested that Mayor Ruth Pierce
[0:05:47] administer the oath of office to Blake,
[0:05:50] Harakey, Harakey, I think I'm really close.
[0:05:54] Where is he?
[0:05:55] There, close, good.
[0:05:59] Thank you, Chief.
[0:06:01] Thank you, Mayor.
[0:06:02] You know, you're the Mayor's however you pronounce it.
[0:06:04] I'm sure that Officer Harakey will go.
[0:06:06] He'll change his name just for me.
[0:06:07] Yes.
[0:06:10] I feel your pain, my main name was Freund,
[0:06:13] and nobody knew how to say that, so.
[0:06:18] Good Council, thank you.
[0:06:20] As usual, I come before you to present
[0:06:24] a new police officer for swearing in.
[0:06:27] It's always a very special evening for us
[0:06:30] at the Twin Falls Police Department.
[0:06:32] Tonight we're very excited to welcome
[0:06:35] Officer Blake Howragie to our Twin Falls Police Department
[0:06:39] family.
[0:06:39] If I could have Officer Howragie come
[0:06:41] and stand over here to my left.
[0:06:47] A little bit about Officer Al Rege.
[0:06:49] I'm gonna go, you know me,
[0:06:50] I'm not one for Scripps, totally.
[0:06:53] I think this is kind of a cool stream.
[0:06:55] You come closer.
[0:07:00] This is kind of a cool story.
[0:07:02] So, Mr. Al Rege has wanted to be a police officer
[0:07:06] for a very long time.
[0:07:09] He put himself through the College of Southern Idaho's
[0:07:12] law enforcement program, graduating last December
[0:07:16] from that program as a self-sponsor.
[0:07:20] First of all, I'll get back to his life.
[0:07:24] He was born in Boise.
[0:07:25] He grew up in Winamucka, Nevada.
[0:07:27] He graduated from high school in 2020
[0:07:29] from Lowry High School there.
[0:07:31] He played football and basketball
[0:07:33] and also really enjoyed the mountains.
[0:07:37] Yes, he's quite a mechanic.
[0:07:38] He worked in a hydraulic shop before joining the TFPD
[0:07:42] where he could work on all different kinds of pumps,
[0:07:44] motors, and hydraulics off-norm ever.
[0:07:46] And he's helping the shop.
[0:07:47] We might have a guy here that can double up for that.
[0:07:50] He's down for them.
[0:07:52] But here's a really cool thing that you said earlier.
[0:07:54] He put himself through the College of Southern Idaho.
[0:07:58] When he did that, he graduated last December.
[0:08:02] He was not old enough to become a police officer
[0:08:04] because under Idaho law, you have to be 21 years old
[0:08:07] to be a police officer.
[0:08:09] Make sure I don't look at the council,
[0:08:11] because you can tell.
[0:08:15] I will say that for, well, I'll get to that in a moment.
[0:08:20] But it's a blank put himself through the colleges on an Idaho's program
[0:08:25] graduating towards the top of his class in many aspects through that program.
[0:08:32] We hired Mr. Howrege as a community service officer in late January because again as I stayed under Idaho's statute
[0:08:43] he cannot be a police officer until his 21st birthday.
[0:08:47] This will happen to this birthday's Valentine's Day.
[0:08:50] The next Monday or next Sunday was the new pay period.
[0:08:56] So, the pay period after Valentine's Day, the 17th of February,
[0:09:02] we transitioned community service officer,
[0:09:06] Hal Rege, to police officer recruit Hal Rege,
[0:09:10] and he joined our team officially as a police officer on that particular day.
[0:09:19] Now I will say that I swore him in so he could start his training.
[0:09:23] And in doing that we put a picture of he and I side by side on our Facebook page, on the
[0:09:29] department Facebook page.
[0:09:31] One of our top fans if you will, I hope he's watching tonight, but he put on there quite
[0:09:37] the contrast.
[0:09:38] And when I looked at it, at first I was like, hey, then I had to smile because it's really,
[0:09:45] really true.
[0:09:46] It's kind of a before and after photo, if you will.
[0:09:51] I too was 21 when I started this career, so it's kind of exciting to bring Mr. Al-Ragey
[0:09:58] to us this evening, to bring him before you and before our community.
[0:10:03] Now, I know you've heard me talk about the symbolism of our uniform as Officer Al-Ragey
[0:10:09] is joining this profession.
[0:10:10] I would remind everybody that is watching Mayor and Council and everybody here that it's
[0:10:17] It's a very somber week for those of us in the law enforcement profession in this region.
[0:10:22] On Saturday night, about 180 miles from where we stand today, in a small little town of
[0:10:28] Nissa, Oregon, which I know fairly well.
[0:10:31] A reserve police officer was murdered in the line of duty.
[0:10:35] He was murdered protecting and serving his community of Nissa, Oregon.
[0:10:41] Officer Johnson also worked at the Idaho Department of, the Oregon Department of Corrections,
[0:10:45] excuse me.
[0:10:46] Obviously, a man who I never got to meet,
[0:10:48] Officer Johnson, put a man at committed himself to service
[0:10:53] in many ways and paid the ultimate sacrifice.
[0:10:56] So tonight, Mr. Alregi's mom, Molly,
[0:11:00] is going to help us pin his badge on him.
[0:11:03] But if you notice, the badges of those of us in uniform
[0:11:06] right now have morning bands across them.
[0:11:08] As we empathize and show support
[0:11:13] for the Nissa Oregon Police Department
[0:11:15] and our brothers and sisters in blue
[0:11:16] throughout the region as we have lost one of ours.
[0:11:20] And I think that as we're swearing in,
[0:11:22] Mr. Elricki, tonight, we just need to remember that
[0:11:27] and realize what this badge means.
[0:11:29] It is truly that symbol of honor, that symbol of integrity.
[0:11:34] It's the symbol of law and order,
[0:11:38] good versus evil and protecting and serving.
[0:11:41] And that is what Blake is going to swear
[0:11:44] before this community tonight that he is going to do.
[0:11:49] He knows full well what he is getting into.
[0:11:52] As I have said, he has already completed
[0:11:54] the CSI Law Enforcement Academy.
[0:11:56] He is right now in phase two
[0:11:58] of his field training officer program.
[0:12:02] I will tell you that he may come to us tonight, young and age,
[0:12:06] but he is wise in spirit and he knows
[0:12:10] what this commitment that we have here in this organization.
[0:12:15] We also talk about the patch that we wear in our sleeve, and this patch represents this
[0:12:19] great organization, and this great organization that was founded many years ago, and the men
[0:12:26] and women who have went before us, including the two from the Twin Falls Police Department
[0:12:30] who gave their lives in the line of duty back in the 1930s.
[0:12:37] We represent all of them as we go forward to carry out the mission of the city of Twin
[0:12:43] Falls and this organization.
[0:12:45] And finally, I would remind Mr. Hough Rege that he has a nameplate above his right,
[0:12:58] razzle, with his last name. And that last name is probably more important than any
[0:13:06] other of the symbols that he's going to wear on his uniform as he goes forward.
[0:13:09] Because that last name represents who raised him. It represents his family.
[0:13:15] In fact, many of whom are here this evening to assist and to witness this ceremony.
[0:13:22] So at that time, I'd like to ask Blake to settle over to the microphone and introduce your family that you have here.
[0:13:31] Thank you. And just like Chief said, these are the people that raised me and I'm very proud to wear this uniform as well as this team plate.
[0:13:37] As it is my symbol of who raised me, starting with my mother, Molly Haredi, she is the backbone of my family.
[0:13:45] I'm who I am today because of her and I'm very proud to wear this name, please, with her last name
[0:13:52] of Harry and I'll be honored to always wear it on this uniform. With my mother comes my soon-to-be
[0:14:02] new stepdad Randy McCoy. He has taken us into his house and his family with open arms and has
[0:14:08] been there for me and provided me with the roof over my head for the last couple of years.
[0:14:12] So I just want to say thank you to Randy for everything he's done on his right is my grandma
[0:14:18] Mickey Howriege who was married to my grandfather who passed away a couple years ago so unfortunately
[0:14:25] he can't be here but he's with us in spirit as well as the last name of Howriege where
[0:14:32] last name came from sitting right behind me is my nephew Easton
[0:14:39] So, Easton is the son of my sister who had to take her other daughter out because little
[0:14:47] kids want to be little kids.
[0:14:49] So, I just want to say thank you to Easton and my sister Heather as well as my niece Ruby
[0:14:55] for making the trip down from Nevada to come see me swear in.
[0:14:58] It means a lot that they can support me through the biggest achievements in my life.
[0:15:05] Sitting behind Easton is my brother Tristan.
[0:15:07] He also lives here in Twin Falls, so I'll be having to look out for him on the street, see if I can't get him pulled over or something.
[0:15:14] So, he unfortunately does not have the last name of how Reiki is a hanyan.
[0:15:21] He took my dad's last name, so he's not as cool as me, but he is someone I get to look up to and have learned a lot from as an older brother.
[0:15:29] brother.
[0:15:30] The thing that's interesting is Denise, his girlfriend, and she's actually a part of the
[0:15:34] Twin Falls City, who's department as well, actually in dispatch, so it's kind of like
[0:15:39] a cool circle that we have going on.
[0:15:41] So I just want to say thank you to everyone for coming down to support me.
[0:15:45] This is my biggest achievement, and I'm honored to be standing in front of you guys.
[0:15:51] I'm just going to be with my badge pinned on, and we're in my last name on this uniform.
[0:15:57] Thank you.
[0:16:05] without somebody who can rival me.
[0:16:07] I know we're gonna sign up.
[0:16:11] Watch out.
[0:16:12] Oh, that's succession planning, right?
[0:16:16] Very good.
[0:16:17] Okay, at this time, if I could have Captain X come forward
[0:16:21] with his badge and if his mother, Molly Helregi,
[0:16:24] what's stepped forward?
[0:17:03] Now, please administer the oath of office.
[0:17:11] The mayor's coming down just for everybody
[0:17:13] in the audience.
[0:17:14] There's actually two forms here.
[0:17:17] Mayor Pierce will administer the oath of office afterwards.
[0:17:21] She will sign both of these forms and Officer Howe Rege will also sign both of these forms.
[0:17:26] One will go into Officer Howe Rege's personnel file at the Twin Falls Police Department.
[0:17:32] The other will wait there for one year and one year from today we will frame that oath
[0:17:39] of office and give it to you Blake to display to remind yourself of that oath that you took
[0:17:43] tonight.
[0:17:45] I have my oath of office framed and hanging in my office, and I refer to it, if not daily,
[0:17:52] at least several times a week, as a good reminder to this oath that I swore several years ago
[0:17:58] that you're going to swear to tonight.
[0:18:00] Here, as you are returning, I will have Officer How Reggy State down here as we go into the
[0:19:52] next item, the next agenda item, and then we'll be completed with that mayor council, City
[0:19:58] and the committee manager can come down and congratulate both of the officers.
[0:20:02] Perfect, thank you.
[0:20:18] Okay, so the next item is a presentation, a present presentation of post-supervisors
[0:20:25] to certificate to Sergeant David White. Is that right? Yes.
[0:20:29] And presentation of post-advanced and intermediate certificates to Officer Brian Caldwell.
[0:20:36] Thank you, Chief. Again. Thank you, Mayor. Sergeant White will not be able to be with us tonight due to illness.
[0:20:43] unfortunately he can't be here however if I could have Lieutenant Luke Allen
[0:20:48] come down and then officer Brian Caldwell. That may or may be presenting
[0:21:06] officer Brian Caldwell to certifications his intermediate and advanced certificate
[0:21:10] which is not common to give someone two certificates at once but because of his
[0:21:15] college and his years of service officer Caldwell those qualified for two
[0:21:19] certificates tonight. Officer Brian Caldwell was hired by the Twin Falls Police
[0:21:25] Department as a full-time police officer December 14th of 2015. Officer Caldwell was
[0:21:30] born in Bakersfield, California and grew up in a military family. Once he
[0:21:35] completed high school, he left for service in the Marine Corps where he spent 10
[0:21:38] years and was deployed several times overseas. After leaving the military, Officer
[0:21:44] Caldwell moved to Twin Falls, was hired by the Twin Falls Police Department. Officer
[0:21:48] Caldwell worked for a little over two years with the police department before
[0:21:52] transitioning to a reserve officer and he went to work for the State Department for those five years.
[0:21:57] After returning to November of 2022, Officer Caldwell returned the full service as a police officer.
[0:22:05] Officer Caldwell has completed an associate's degree in counter-terrorism and a bachelor's degree in
[0:22:10] intelligence studies with a concentration in counterintelligence. So tonight we would like to present
[0:22:17] Officer Caldwell with both his intermediate and advanced certification.
[0:22:21] So Mayor and Council and City Management like to come around and then after they are done it as the Police Department commands to have to also come through. Thank you.
[0:23:00] Could we have Brian introduce this family if they're here? Yeah. Okay. We'll be your family. Thank you, Brian. Thank you, Madam Mayor. Thank you.
[0:24:23] Okay, next item on the agenda is an action item, a request to adopt ordinance 2023-006
[0:24:33] or the Mr. Rims Zoning Development Agreement Amendment PC22-0177.
[0:24:40] We have Jonathan Spindlev, our Planning and Zoning Director. Welcome, Jonathan.
[0:24:45] Thank you, Mayor and members of the Council.
[0:24:47] This item came before the Planning and Zoning Commission on February 28th,
[0:24:51] It also came to City Council for final decision April 3rd after the decision we prepared the ordinance
[0:24:57] And it is presented to you as ordinance 20
[0:25:01] 3006 if you wish to pass it tonight there suggested motion
[0:25:06] Process section of the staff report here for any questions
[0:25:10] We will need to put this on third and final correct if you wish to pass it okay Christopher Reed
[0:25:16] I'll make the motion unless there's other comments crushed okay
[0:25:21] I move that we dispense with the reading rules in place, Ordinance 2023-006 on 3rd and final reading by title.
[0:25:31] Thank you, Nicky Boyd.
[0:25:33] Second.
[0:25:34] Thank you. Motion by Christopher Reed. Seconded by Nicky Boyd to put Ordinance 2023 on 3rd and final reading by dispensing the rules and final reading by title only.
[0:25:46] That was kind of backwards.
[0:25:48] Amy Roll Call vote please.
[0:25:52] Nicky Boyd.
[0:25:53] Yes.
[0:25:54] Haycock.
[0:25:55] Yes.
[0:25:56] Jason Brown.
[0:25:57] Yes.
[0:25:58] Alex Koval.
[0:25:59] Yes.
[0:26:00] Chris Rees.
[0:26:01] Yes.
[0:26:02] Thank you motion passes to seven to zero.
[0:26:06] So I will read the ordinance ordinance number 2023-006.
[0:26:11] An ordinance of the city council of the city of Twin Falls rezoning certain real property
[0:26:17] below describe providing the zoning classification, therefore, and
[0:26:22] ordering the necessary area of impact and zoning district map amendments.
[0:26:27] Christopher Reed.
[0:26:28] Move to approve ordinance 2023-006.
[0:26:32] Thank you.
[0:26:33] Do I have a second?
[0:26:35] Motion by Christopher Reed, seconded by Jason Brown.
[0:26:42] I had to think about that for a minute.
[0:26:43] Sorry, Jason.
[0:26:45] Seconded by Jason Brown to adopt ordinance 2023-006.
[0:26:50] any further discussion? Amy Roll, call vote please.
[0:27:01] Ray Cawkins.
[0:27:02] Yes.
[0:27:03] Jason Brown.
[0:27:04] Yes.
[0:27:05] Spencer Cutler.
[0:27:06] Yes.
[0:27:07] Alex Kaval.
[0:27:08] Yes.
[0:27:09] Ruth Pierce.
[0:27:10] Yes.
[0:27:11] Rhys Reed.
[0:27:12] Yes.
[0:27:13] Cindy G. Boyd.
[0:27:14] Yes.
[0:27:16] Thank you.
[0:27:17] Motion passes 7-0.
[0:27:18] Thank you, Jonathan.
[0:27:19] Okay.
[0:27:20] Next item on the agenda is also an action item, a request to award the Orchard Drive, Samantha recycled asphalt based stabilization.
[0:27:26] Stabilization called crabs reconstruction project to clever ink of twin falls in the amount of
[0:27:33] 287 and six thousand and sixty dollars in authorized contingency in the amount of
[0:27:40] thirty thousand for potential change orders and we have Josh Barrett our public works
[0:27:45] director welcome Josh thanks mayor and city council so let me give you a little background on this
[0:27:52] This is on Orchard Drive, and I've shown a vicinity map above, and over the audience can see as well.
[0:27:59] This is between Blue Lakes Boulevard and the Rock Creek Fill, and the road has been failing for a while.
[0:28:08] It's getting worse. We've hired a geotechnical engineer to come and figure out what we should do.
[0:28:13] The recommendation was to perform a method called CRAPS.
[0:28:20] We did this about long ago on Eastland Drive between Falls and Poline.
[0:28:25] We've had, we think we have a success with that.
[0:28:30] And so we moved forward with the request to use the same method.
[0:28:34] And the method includes taking the asphalt, we pulverize it,
[0:28:38] you add in some trace cement, we compact it, and then place a new layer of
[0:28:42] plant mix of pavement on top of it.
[0:28:44] This will provide the roadway with a 20-year design life,
[0:28:48] which is typical. On this specific project we are allowing the contractor up to 14 calendar days
[0:28:56] to close the road which means there will be a detour around. When we coordinate with the highway
[0:29:00] district as well it will go south on the 3600 north. If you're on majorone you'll still get through
[0:29:06] but for the most part that section will be closed for those 14 days and we'll try and minimize the
[0:29:11] convenience of public as much as we can. So we formally bid the project back on the 3rd of April
[0:29:17] We received two different bids with the low bid being $287,000 or $287,000, which was 64% of the
[0:29:26] engineer's estimates, so that was good. It was significantly below the engineer's estimates.
[0:29:30] The package was checked for complete lists and no erigors were found, and the engineer
[0:29:37] JUB has recommended that we award the bids, so with that, I can take any questions that you may have.
[0:29:43] Josh, what's your timeline? What's the timeline on this, we think?
[0:29:47] I'm guessing it'll be jimish when they get out there, but we'll keep you a prize with
[0:29:54] public service announcements. Thank you, Christy. Can you just give me a little history on that,
[0:30:00] but why is it failing? Why is it struggling? I would say this is an old road, and it is also a
[0:30:09] very heavily traveled road. A bunch of heavy semi-trucks are traveling and regularly.
[0:30:14] This isn't the only one that's sailing and we regularly check the pavement condition index of roads
[0:30:20] all around the city and so this is just it's old and it's time for it to be
[0:30:24] rebuilt in this case reconstructed so thank you.
[0:30:28] Any other questions for Josh? Jason.
[0:30:34] So on the map there Josh are you going to the intersection of Blue Lakes or are you
[0:30:40] going to stop prior to that? I believe we're stopping to shy of intersection and
[0:30:45] then back to the other question the mayor had asked because it is such a
[0:30:50] highly traveled road and there's also just down the way we anticipate the part
[0:30:56] of orchard will be open in front of the that charter school that's there I know
[0:31:01] that's being worked on I know that's created some congestion and I didn't know
[0:31:05] if the two would overlap in any way so that that section of orchard will
[0:31:12] continue to say open from the city's perspective okay I'm not sure with the
[0:31:16] private contractor and the right-of-it permit allows okay so that would be
[0:31:20] kind of up to the engineering department what what they can and can't do there but
[0:31:23] this should be separate apart from that and you should have access through it
[0:31:27] through the like spool for itself hey Spencer color are you ready for emotion
[0:31:34] here you have a question Alex I was gonna ask you were talking about the
[0:31:41] lifespan of the roads being about 20 years how much life did we get out of
[0:31:45] This one before we had to...
[0:31:48] That is a great question. I'm Mark, do you know that by chance?
[0:31:56] I'm guessing it's been at least 20 years since we did any major rehabilitation.
[0:32:00] Otherwise Mark would have been aware of it, right?
[0:32:03] So...
[0:32:04] Okay, at least 20.
[0:32:06] Before your time is what you're saying, it looks like.
[0:32:08] Okay, Spencer Keller.
[0:32:12] I move that we award the Orchard Krabs Project to Clifford for Incorporated Twin Falls, Idaho
[0:32:18] in the amount of $287,060 and authorize a contingency of $30,000 for potential change orders.
[0:32:28] Thank you, Craig Hawkins.
[0:32:30] So moved.
[0:32:31] Second.
[0:32:34] Motion, Vice-Menser, Cutler, second by Craig Hawkins to approve awarding the contract for
[0:32:40] or arch of drive, crafts, reconstruction project
[0:32:44] to collect for ink in the amount of $28760
[0:32:49] plus the $30,000 contingent.
[0:32:52] See any further discussion?
[0:32:56] Amy Rollco, vote please.
[0:32:59] Jason Brown.
[0:33:00] Yes.
[0:33:00] Alex Cabal.
[0:33:01] Yes.
[0:33:02] Spencer Cutler.
[0:33:03] Yes.
[0:33:04] Bruce Pierce.
[0:33:05] Yes.
[0:33:06] Chris Reed.
[0:33:06] Yes.
[0:33:07] Nicky Boyd.
[0:33:08] Yes.
[0:33:09] Ray Conquets.
[0:33:10] Yes.
[0:33:11] Thank you.
[0:33:15] So the next item on the agenda is a presentation, a presentation of the Twin Falls Urban Renewal Agency draft master plan by GGLO and we have Sean Berger, our economic development director. Welcome Sean.
[0:33:30] Good evening, Mayor and Council. Thank you for the opportunity to be here this evening. So last September, the Urban Renewal Agency retained GGLO to develop a master plan for the proposed Old Town
[0:33:44] to revenue allocation area in downtown Twin Falls.
[0:33:47] You had an update in January from this group
[0:33:51] on their work to date at that point.
[0:33:53] At that time, GGL and their partners
[0:33:55] have been working closely with city and agency staff,
[0:33:58] as well as the urban agency board to gather stakeholder input,
[0:34:03] study socioeconomic and market development trends,
[0:34:06] establish a vision for future development in the proposed area
[0:34:10] and lay out opportunities for development initiatives.
[0:34:13] We have representatives from GGLO here in town today, they made a presentation to the Herbronuil
[0:34:19] Agency Board at their regular meeting at noon today.
[0:34:23] It would be a great opportunity for them to provide an update as well to the City Council
[0:34:28] on where they are with the latest draft of the plan.
[0:34:32] I'm putting questions to them this evening as they're continuing to refine that final
[0:34:39] plan.
[0:34:40] and it worked well at the presentation today at noon for you to chime in with us as we go.
[0:34:46] We also will have a chance for Q&A at the end, so with that I'm going to turn the podium over
[0:34:51] to Samantha Jesser and Jessiah Brown with GGLO. Go from there.
[0:34:58] Thank you. Welcome. Madam Mayor, Council Members, we're happy to be here. Thank you Sean for that intro.
[0:35:07] I'm Josiah Brown, an urban designer with GGLO, and I'm Samantha Jesser, an urban designer with GGLO,
[0:35:13] and we are located in the Boise office. So we are in Seattle, Boise, and so today we're just going to
[0:35:23] walk you through some of the work that we've been doing with this downtown master plan. And
[0:35:30] like Sean was saying at any point, if you have questions, please chime in. We'll also have time
[0:35:34] for questions at the end. So Sam has kind of the home field advantage here because
[0:35:41] she grew up here but she has been teaching me a lot about Twin Falls and so just as
[0:35:47] we look at this whole process I think recognizing that history has been
[0:35:52] important to the work that we're doing so kind of recognizing the unlikely place
[0:35:59] that Twin Falls is located and how really the community started thanks to
[0:36:04] the introduction of irrigation in the area and how that made agricultural possible here.
[0:36:09] And then how the downtown kind of leapt as this farm to market community
[0:36:15] and really flourished as kind of the center of the community for a decade until really the advent
[0:36:23] of the automobile and we saw in kind of the late 1900s how a lot of the commercial development
[0:36:29] that was focused downtown started to stretch out a lot blue lakes boulevard and kind of get
[0:36:34] get pulled out to the canyon rim and we saw kind of a period a little bit of I would say
[0:36:45] in the last couple decades. Thanks to leadership in the community, we've already seen a resurgence
[0:36:52] starting here in downtown Twin Falls with the main of kind of renovations that have
[0:36:57] happened and so our work is really just continuing that momentum. See where else that goes in this
[0:37:13] place, what foster that growth and really pause, probably see the red line. We are completing
[0:37:24] the final master plan so this is a presentation of the draft master plan materials.
[0:37:29] Next we are moving towards the establishment, the possible establishment of this district,
[0:37:35] hopefully to be fully established by the end of 2023 and then January 24,
[0:37:41] it's on the ground implementation of this thing and the future is right.
[0:37:48] So just to outline where this possible urban renewal district area is, outlined in red here.
[0:38:06] So to begin this work, we went through a phase of discovery where we were learning about Twin Falls
[0:38:13] and studying some of the existing conditions, existing planning documents, reviewing those,
[0:38:21] and as well as engaging public and hearing from community members about what they'd like to see downtown.
[0:38:27] So some of those things that we studied are shown here just as a quick overview
[0:38:32] and use zoning, flood hazards, parcel ownership, existing parks and trail plans for downtown
[0:38:40] as well as the existing downtown programs. In addition to this we were looking at comprehensive
[0:38:47] of Plan Falls, Transit Studies,
[0:38:52] as well as the Transportation Master Plan,
[0:38:54] and then others.
[0:38:57] Throughout this process, we have conducted
[0:38:59] a rigorous public involvement process,
[0:39:02] and through both stakeholder interviews
[0:39:05] with business owners, community members,
[0:39:09] and city representatives, as well as two online surveys,
[0:39:13] one in the discovery process,
[0:39:15] and then one for the draft master plan process,
[0:39:18] where we actually showed some things
[0:39:19] we're going to get in here in a minute, but through this process we again we just
[0:39:24] wanted to express the importance of how do we hear from the community and see what
[0:39:29] their vision for Twin Falls is and their understanding and experience of what's
[0:39:34] been done so far. So we've had a lot of positive feedback overall throughout this
[0:39:40] public involvement process. The community is very enthusiastic about the changes
[0:39:45] that have been done on main avenue. In the last five years, they want to see more and more
[0:39:53] what's been happening. They see Twin Falls as a small town friendly place to be. It's a very
[0:40:00] strong community and no one wants to lose that. And so we have to be really careful with what we do
[0:40:06] to preserve this identity, this history of what we have, especially in downtown. So keeping the old
[0:40:13] restoring it, building upon that, as well as introducing this new generation of
[0:40:19] active businesses and density and housing as we move forward. So overall, quite
[0:40:26] positive and here's some of those responses that we have seen. But I think
[0:40:32] just like all of us, the public is also excited to see the future of downtown.
[0:40:35] We've also been engaging Eco Northwest, our financial consultant, and they've
[0:40:45] been helping us with some initial market study findings. This was during the
[0:40:49] discovery phase and that they've continued their work since then and will
[0:40:52] be reviewing some of that later. But this early work just helped to kind of
[0:40:57] establish what the market has been showing in Twin Falls and it's been
[0:41:02] markedly strong for both office and retail, evacency rates, and then also the
[0:41:11] multifamily rental market has been performing strongly. The addition of
[0:41:16] I mean, I have lost or I was great loss.
[0:41:20] Those kinds of projects put well for the future
[0:41:23] of housing downtown.
[0:41:27] So that work, the discovery phase,
[0:41:32] and that really has been forming the work
[0:41:34] that we've done since then.
[0:41:36] And so we're going to jump into some of that now
[0:41:39] in this next vision phase of work.
[0:41:45] To start, we outlined this list of seven goals.
[0:41:50] And this was a lot of thought went into
[0:41:54] These goals for downtown and what downtown should represent for Twin Falls, and so I'm going through these here.
[0:42:02] But first, we want town to be a regional center.
[0:42:06] We want to make sure that it remains uniquely Twin Falls.
[0:42:11] We want to enhance connections to the canyons, both to make river and rock creek.
[0:42:17] We want to ensure that there are opportunities for downtown living vibrant streets, emphasizing Twin Falls reputation as a recreational hub.
[0:42:29] for the region and even the nation.
[0:42:32] And then ensuring that there is easy access
[0:42:34] for everyone into and through and around.
[0:42:40] These are some opportunities that we've outlined
[0:42:43] that can kind of help us achieve those goals.
[0:42:47] And we're really excited about these opportunities
[0:42:51] and we will be talking about these more
[0:42:55] throughout the presentation.
[0:42:56] But if at any point you want to come back to the slide,
[0:42:58] we can't either know that we want to do this,
[0:43:03] that we have been incorporating sustainable design initiatives
[0:43:07] throughout this plan, whether that's the consideration of including self-sells in our
[0:43:13] streetscapes that foster strong healthy street trees that are going to last for decades, or
[0:43:21] creating the type of biking and pedestrian infrastructure that makes car optional lifestyles
[0:43:27] possible.
[0:43:29] I'm producing the car.
[0:43:35] Okay, so this concept of this drawing is the dark red that you see is that five block
[0:43:41] improvement that's been done in the last five ten years of this area and then how
[0:43:48] do we extend this sense of core of downtown so we're proposing that we
[0:43:54] extend the core to an eight block or a nine block core in the center move it out
[0:43:59] pass the second avenues and then eventually how can that expand to the
[0:44:05] termini of the district with improvements of Main Street as well as the second
[0:44:10] avenues here.
[0:44:15] Streetscape hierarchy, so main avenue again as this historic retail commercial driven place,
[0:44:22] how that movement and momentum can extend outwards to the termini of the district, how
[0:44:28] second avenue currently has this major barrier and couple it around main avenue really, it
[0:44:34] really confines what can happen in this place.
[0:44:40] So how do we create safe two-way new reinvented streets there?
[0:44:47] How can Shoshone keep being this main car-centric street, with improved connected streetscapes
[0:44:55] along, and Hanson Street becoming this really important park-like connection from Rock Creek
[0:45:02] to the city center and then connecting back to city parks.
[0:45:05] So we'll unpack these as we move along.
[0:45:10] Though main enhancements, the city has done a great job pushing these forward
[0:45:16] and their beautiful streetscapes in great design.
[0:45:19] And so how can we move these again out past the five blocks where they currently are?
[0:45:27] Shoshone Street, identifying the area by motor skate development as a good example
[0:45:34] for how Shoshone Street standards could be improved.
[0:45:37] We don't see Shoshone Street as a major city investment right away because it will remain mostly car centric
[0:45:45] But how can this consistency of street trees?
[0:45:49] Street furnishings lights, etc. Really just improve that second Avenue
[0:45:57] So this is where a huge improvement that we're suggesting comes into play
[0:46:03] So moving from these four way fast traffic
[0:46:07] streets to to lane to way
[0:46:10] streets with parallel parking, protected bike lanes, extended, great big sidewalks
[0:46:17] where you can have seating and pedestrian environments that are really great and
[0:46:24] enjoyable and then how can development, higher density development move to these
[0:46:30] streets and be supported by these streetscapes. This is another look at
[0:46:37] Second Avenue, this option looks like if we leave one curb the same and only
[0:46:43] change to change the curb on one side. So what this can do is maybe have some
[0:46:48] cost benefits but still have this really great safe bike bolt pedestrian zone on
[0:46:55] one side. Antsmen Street again is this park like street. We imagine it similar
[0:47:04] to the Pearl Street and Boulder or the Basque Block and Boise. It's this highly pedestrian street
[0:47:11] maybe with no curb so biking pedestrian access is just very enjoyable and safe here. The idea that
[0:47:21] you can close the street off and it can transition to pedestrian streets and how new housing,
[0:47:26] restaurant development, historic restoration in these awesome warehouse buildings can come
[0:47:32] and form Hanson Street.
[0:47:34] Samantha, we have a couple questions.
[0:47:37] Hey, if you could take a break, Chris Reed.
[0:47:39] Yeah, just, I know when we met,
[0:47:41] we chatted a little bit about 2nd Street's.
[0:47:43] So are you saying the design,
[0:47:46] but ultimately leaving the highway,
[0:47:48] because that's what the 2nd Street's are,
[0:47:50] leaving that as is,
[0:47:52] but converting it into a normal way,
[0:47:55] to slowing the traffic down by the design?
[0:47:57] Or would you say,
[0:47:59] moving, because that's something we've talked about,
[0:48:01] moving the 2nd,
[0:48:05] that the highway aspect off of 2nd Street,
[0:48:08] So what are you, what is this proposal looking like?
[0:48:11] Highway staying or changing the design, slowing it down?
[0:48:20] It's games to be workable in either scenario.
[0:48:23] So I think the end goal is to hopefully work with ITD
[0:48:27] and to get that couplet of different crossings made.
[0:48:41] And this could still operate as a one way.
[0:48:56] Thank you.
[0:48:57] Jason Brown.
[0:48:59] My comments were similar in the sense
[0:49:02] of getting over the hurdle of the I.T.D. and the highway through that, and what it would look like.
[0:49:08] You've answered that, so I don't think we need to labor that too much, but yeah, that has been a hurdle or a challenge to discover how to...
[0:49:21] Dance.
[0:49:27] Dance and Street.
[0:49:33] Pedestrian. Street. Really beautiful. A lot of things. Again, this park-like experience.
[0:49:43] We just threw a lot of improvements at you, and there's a lot to be done within the downtown area,
[0:49:51] and so one of the things that we wanted to do is to help identify kind of what are the priorities
[0:49:56] here. So, um, shown in red are the highest priority streets gave enhancements to be made,
[0:50:02] and so those are Hanson Street, um, from 2nd Avenue North down, um, as well as 2nd Avenue South
[0:50:11] and 2nd Avenue North within that four block core.
[0:50:15] So those improving the safety of those,
[0:50:19] making it safe to cross that way that downtown energy on main
[0:50:23] have can start to blend throughout the district,
[0:50:27] and also creating an environment that encourages development
[0:50:31] on these streets. That's why those are prioritized.
[0:50:36] What is the end of Hanson? What is that re-right before
[0:50:40] and a doku. I think that's 5th Avenue. It's what? 5th Avenue.
[0:50:45] You'll see later on, but the development that we are proposing follows these streetscape guidelines as well.
[0:50:54] Thank you. To be in this here in the medium priority, you'll see the 2nd Avenue north is prioritized over 2nd Avenue south,
[0:51:05] and that's to reach out to the elementary schools to ride safe travel there.
[0:51:10] So, we also recognize that parking is really important to the downtown and you want to
[0:51:20] make sure that people can come and easily access all the great things that are downtown.
[0:51:26] We also recognize that you don't want town that is just parking because then there's
[0:51:30] no reason to come.
[0:51:32] So what this parking strategy is working with is we're leveraging the street parking,
[0:51:40] angled and parallel throughout the district and then in places where existing surface
[0:51:46] lots will likely be converted to development and other uses. We've identified four key sites.
[0:51:54] Those are the dark red boxes where structured parking could be located. Those are on existing
[0:52:00] public lots. And as development pressure increases and the need for parking increases,
[0:52:06] could be developed into structured parking and then also talking about is
[0:52:14] the potential to incorporate parking within elements to serve their own needs.
[0:52:20] Bring that slide back up real quick though in one of your previous slides one
[0:52:34] of the ways that we don't have enough parking looking at this slide there's
[0:52:43] a lot of pink there and there's a ton of years and years and something keeps
[0:52:51] brought up as designers looking at this it looks like we have a lot of parking
[0:53:00] it looks like we have a ton of parking I just kind of find that I don't know if
[0:53:05] it's a question or comment but before I was on council and I attended people
[0:53:11] brought up how you know they couldn't find any parking downtown it looks like
[0:53:15] we have plenty of parking so and I know structured parking is extremely
[0:53:22] expensive so I mean I just had something found fascinating when I looked at this
[0:53:27] slide and I thought there's more pink than anything on this slide. Yes that is a good
[0:53:40] observation and we have observed the same there is a lot of parking but
[0:53:44] there is still also a public perception that there's not enough and I think that
[0:53:49] that just stems from maybe it's hard to park at certain areas that do get a lot
[0:53:55] of demand and so I think there to this parking strategy where there's clear
[0:54:08] signage about where public parking is provided. They like those types of capacity signs that show
[0:54:15] where parking is available downtown. I think as the streetscapes are enhanced and people are able to
[0:54:25] walk then from their destination and space and network green street as that connector from City
[0:54:43] Park all the way down to Rock Creek. What you're seeing here is an extension of the current Rock
[0:54:50] Creek Park that's down in the canyon and the edge of the downtown area of the trail here.
[0:55:09] So this is a look at the rock creek enhancements that we're recommending. So we really think
[0:55:14] that rock creek is this kind of incredible amenity that you have right here in your downtown a little
[0:55:21] bit under appreciated maybe right now but could be a big attraction for downtown living in the
[0:55:28] the same way that the Boise Green Belt is. And so here we're showing a five-acre regional
[0:55:35] park at the rim, that kind of anchors the downtown and draws people down from
[0:55:39] Hanson Street, a new pedestrian crossing over the railroad at Hanson, new access
[0:55:47] down into the canyon with enhanced trails along the creek as well as along the rim
[0:55:53] rail access points to increase this site represents character neighborhoods and
[0:56:04] building upon the characters of the areas that naturally we saw forming in downtown. Some of these
[0:56:09] are already named this, but we just wanted to build upon this idea. We have this big district,
[0:56:16] but maybe there's some sub districts or sub neighborhood feelings that can emerge through this
[0:56:22] with recommended programs to create areas. So they're just destinations within themselves.
[0:56:29] So Main Street, this is what we know.
[0:56:31] This has the shopping, the commercial, the restaurants,
[0:56:35] the history, Main Street North and South.
[0:56:38] This is where the schools are.
[0:56:40] There's some smaller businesses out here, transitional
[0:56:45] into some housing as you move out there.
[0:56:48] The Innovation District is a place that we have identified
[0:56:53] as a potential opportunity for maker spaces, live work unit,
[0:56:57] it's co-working spaces, light industrial,
[0:57:00] maybe a business forum.
[0:57:01] So maybe it's this place with this entrepreneurial spirit
[0:57:05] that can develop in a way for small businesses.
[0:57:09] Across the warehouse district,
[0:57:11] a place for nightlife entertainment,
[0:57:13] more restaurants and bars.
[0:57:15] The idea of maybe the two children's museum
[0:57:17] coming here in the near future,
[0:57:19] and how that warehouse district directly supports
[0:57:24] Main Street in aligns with that Hands and Street corridor.
[0:57:27] We've identified Rock Creek Rim.
[0:57:30] Again, this place has this recreational hub
[0:57:33] with this rim park, this trail connectivity,
[0:57:36] and identifying this as the place for the hotel conference
[0:57:40] center that you'll see come into the plan later on.
[0:57:44] So a potential location for that,
[0:57:46] and how that is a really great connection
[0:57:48] to this really awesome landscape that we have
[0:57:53] with the front creek and how all of those are
[0:57:55] can tied together with these key streetscapes.
[0:58:02] So we have identified three areas to zoom in
[0:58:05] as a place to give you guys key visualizations
[0:58:08] about how this development could look,
[0:58:10] what some of the cultural visual vibes
[0:58:15] of this stuff could be.
[0:58:17] So we have second avenue, main,
[0:58:21] or second avenue, Hanson Street, and the Rock Creek Rim.
[0:58:25] So we'll start with 2nd Avenue.
[0:58:26] This is the intersection of coding
[0:58:28] and 2nd Avenue North specifically.
[0:58:32] So here, again, 2nd Avenue is this place
[0:58:34] for higher development and a streetscape that can support that
[0:58:38] and create an enjoyable pedestrian room for bikers,
[0:58:44] people walking and outdoor seating cafes,
[0:58:47] retail on that ground level, two way street
[0:58:52] and parallel parking.
[0:58:54] see the bulbouts for a destination for some of this sidewalk seating and create
[0:58:59] those safer really identifiable crossings for the people. Here is the existing
[0:59:08] condition of 2nd Avenue. This is a photograph we took and then looking at
[0:59:12] how that can be reimagined. So you see a street tree canopy, those bulbouts, the
[0:59:18] pedestrian seating, people walking along the seconds where they're sort of dead
[0:59:23] as is mostly car traffic, so a safe place for everyone and an exciting place to be for this new development.
[0:59:33] Also worth mentioning here is that the new development is mostly in fill and so it's occupying land that is currently parking lot or vacant.
[0:59:43] Okay, Hanson Street again has this perpendicular connection from downtown to Rock Creek.
[0:59:55] This is again the pedestrian biker-friendly street that can be transitioned to festival
[1:00:02] street with removable ballerards and specific locations.
[1:00:05] We're showing this section between Fifth and Fourth Avenue.
[1:00:09] Here you'll also see this concept for the pedestrian bridge that connects you over the
[1:00:14] road in the railways into Rock Creek, which we'll show in a minute.
[1:00:19] this as this vibrant walkable street here in this existing photo of what that looks like with the
[1:00:28] historic buildings and warehouse district feel and how we can use that to create outdoor patio
[1:00:37] sitting for restaurants and transition these historic buildings into new uses and really restore them
[1:00:43] along with introducing new development like housing with retail and things like that. The introduction
[1:00:50] of public art as well is a great place on Hanson on Hanson Street corridor and
[1:00:57] again the the nature forward design of this really putting forward that park
[1:01:03] like field and so this would be showing at a street closure in the evening where
[1:01:09] you could be walking around and biking safely in the street across the railroad
[1:01:18] down to Rock Creek so there you can see up in the corner
[1:01:23] Hands of Street connection across to Rock Creek with the Hands of Street pedestrian bridge.
[1:01:30] We thought bridge could be a really good opportunity to create a new landmark for downtown with a signature design,
[1:01:39] something that invites people and continues that downtown across here to Rock Creek and vice versa.
[1:01:46] And so as it lands on the Rock Creek side, it's kind of into this plaza that is supported by for six.
[1:01:57] There's also proposed here, number 7 is a parking garage to support all of this development and traffic coming to trails on the rim as well as enhanced access down into the canyon.
[1:02:36] This is just an image of what that new destination park might look like.
[1:02:41] Something that really kind of reflects Twin Falls.
[1:02:46] Something that is kind of this special destination that people would drive from the region to come and visit in place, right?
[1:02:58] It's for questions before we dive into some of the phasing and implementation and financial feasibility of all this.
[1:03:10] This doesn't look like it. Go ahead.
[1:03:14] This incorporates the, or assumes that the railroad stays in place where it's at, correct?
[1:03:29] Yes.
[1:03:30] If you're planning on putting a convention center down there, do you not foresee like noise from trains being somewhat problematic?
[1:03:41] I think that so the convention, that's one of the reasons to kind of place that development on the railroad side is a buffer between that.
[1:03:57] So I think that'll help the pedestrian bridge. Is that what you're proposing?
[1:04:20] Yes, that's a pedestrian bridge.
[1:04:22] Um, but um, but it's just we're, we're just kind of a structure, but that controversy is kind of an experience in it.
[1:04:47] I think it's an interesting concept. I just don't like that you're staring at a bunch of train cars down below.
[1:04:53] Right, and it is interesting. Convention centers sort of have a typology of being next to freeways, massive, fuller vards, trains, and you'll sort of see that all around the US.
[1:05:04] And there's ways like just saying like pushing back of house against those and trying to mitigate that noise.
[1:05:10] but it is this sort of eclectic mix that we're dealing with down here. It's sort of an industry
[1:05:17] in public realm and this is a moment where they're coming in to direct adjacency, I guess.
[1:05:28] Okay, next. Okay, so we've been working with Equinort West out of Portland to make sure that
[1:05:36] what we're doing is financially feasible and has room in the market for Twin Falls. We are
[1:05:43] are presenting this information on their behalf.
[1:05:46] So we will try our best to field any questions you have,
[1:05:49] but we may have to relay some of those to them
[1:05:52] if we don't know the specifics.
[1:05:56] Okay, so estimated existing development.
[1:05:59] So you're seeing the numbers in the first column
[1:06:02] for what is existing in downtown Twin Falls as is,
[1:06:07] and what this preferred,
[1:06:09] what this development build out would be
[1:06:12] in the next 20 years of this district
[1:06:15] of this full build out that we're going to discuss.
[1:06:20] So really, all of these uses and programs
[1:06:23] that we're proposing need to work together
[1:06:26] to create this vibrant downtown that people want to go to
[1:06:30] and be engaged in.
[1:06:31] So you cannot have retail office residential
[1:06:34] one really without the other.
[1:06:35] They all need to work simultaneously
[1:06:39] to support one another, to create this vibrant place.
[1:06:47] As we looked down town,
[1:06:50] what you saw was an additional 700,000 square feet
[1:06:54] of housing over the next 20 year timeline.
[1:06:57] And so that is really kind of boosting
[1:07:00] the downtown housing stock.
[1:07:02] And what this chart is showing is in blue existing housing
[1:07:08] elsewhere in down town, or elsewhere in Twin Falls.
[1:07:11] And then the orange is showing the of that housing
[1:07:15] that would be, and so you can see in 2020,
[1:07:20] There's not a huge portion that is downtown, but as we move
[1:07:24] 20 years to 2043, you 700 to 800 more housing units downtown.
[1:07:35] And so that comes out to a reference, like,
[1:07:41] may not have losses about 50 units.
[1:07:43] So developments a year down to it.
[1:07:50] As we're looking downtown and we're talking about development
[1:07:54] and kind of the financial feasibility,
[1:07:55] we also need to be considering the place-making potential
[1:07:58] of all of these things.
[1:07:59] So these two work hand in hand,
[1:08:02] placemaking supports economic vitality,
[1:08:05] which supports additional placemaking.
[1:08:09] So as we're talking through some of these development types,
[1:08:14] we'll also be mentioning their placemaking potential
[1:08:18] because there are certain development types
[1:08:20] that might be really affordable or financially feasible,
[1:08:24] but they won't support a place that we're creating.
[1:08:31] As the Econorthwest has been conducting these studies, they've been using some comms for their reference, and so we're just going to show a few of these for multi-family.
[1:08:42] They've been looking at loss in the Mascarae Loffs downtown, or retail. They've been looking at the Broadway strip retail development, and I don't fall as well as the Mascara Loffs with retail incorporated on the ground floors.
[1:08:56] When it comes to office, I've been looking at the headquarters built specifically for them,
[1:09:05] and then as well as the belt offices in Meridian and a spec office.
[1:09:12] And then for Hotel, they've been referencing the Marcus Whitman Hotel in Walla Walla
[1:09:19] and the Hilton Hotel in Vancouver. They also just wanted to make a note that
[1:09:25] Hotel is a little bit challenging right now just because of what COVID has done.
[1:09:29] So, as well as to predict.
[1:09:32] Okay, so Econorth West has conducted several interviews with local developers, as well
[1:09:42] as developers that have been doing these types of developments in Boise, and those developers
[1:09:48] help them understand hard-cost, soft-caused efficiency ratios, parking requirements, and
[1:09:54] other factors that they're seeing with these types of developments in the area.
[1:10:02] So, is looking at those findings, so types of prototypes, specifically town homes, six-story
[1:10:10] mixed-use, three-story multi-family with tuck under parking, three-story multi-family strip
[1:10:16] retail, and two-story office, and checking their strengths with market trends, development, feasibility,
[1:10:25] market potential, what could twin falls support in the future of this district, and then adding
[1:10:31] this place making potential for what we want for that vibrant downtown. So you'll see market trends
[1:10:41] for housing, multi-family housing, mixed use housing, strip retail, sorry office is all strong,
[1:10:47] town homes are moderate and potentially something that we won't see as much in this downtown core,
[1:10:56] maybe more on these sort of outer edges of it as a transition to that housing and
[1:11:03] their development feasibility townhomes being medium six-story mixed use is not
[1:11:10] feasible in the current market for the construction costs that we're seeing as
[1:11:17] of now but then you'll look to the place making home potential where that's a
[1:11:22] high place making because of that vibrant street life that those create so that's
[1:11:26] where it's important for the city and the URA to have incentives to build this type of housing
[1:11:33] to help the developers with this feasibility. Three-story tuck under, that would be similar
[1:11:39] to the masquerade laughs, medium feasibility, low to moderate market potential and place-making
[1:11:47] potential is moderate, but again less active. Streetscapes, again, there can be design implementations
[1:11:56] to tuck under multi-family housing that can also help with their mixed use potential.
[1:12:02] Three-story multi-family housing, that's more your sort of suburban typology.
[1:12:10] So, again, not something that we really want to see in this vibrant core of downtown.
[1:12:16] As we move forward, strip retail is very similar as well as two-story office with their sort of large parking lots
[1:12:25] and inactive. So just an idea of the development feasibility of these things.
[1:12:35] Potential phasing plan. This is the stuff that we are proposing these specific land uses. So
[1:12:47] phase one you'll see a lot of housing, retail, some office, phase two more housing, retail
[1:12:56] and office steps up a little bit more in Phase 2 and then keeping the Phase 3, the Hotel Conventions Civic
[1:13:02] Center until Phase 3. And we'll talk about this a little bit more, but how it's important to create
[1:13:08] this really financial feasible vibrant place downtown that can support this Hotel Convention Center
[1:13:17] coming in in Phase 3. So here is those numbers in chart form and so you see 2022 is
[1:13:29] Now, last year, the current status of these things, you'll see housing rising through these phases at a really high rate, retail slowly stepping up, and then the office again slowly stepping up, and then a much greater boost for hotel, I mean for that convention center edition.
[1:13:54] Here is the existing conditions of downtown in an aerial view, and these are visualizations that are going to show
[1:14:04] These numbers come to life in specific places
[1:14:10] This is the city owned
[1:14:13] parcels between the city and the URA
[1:14:17] Outlined in red and so how we've been able to push development along
[1:14:22] these parcels and this is a really amazing gift that us designers had as well as
[1:14:28] what Twin Falls has in its back pocket for these developments. So again you'll
[1:14:33] see them all on Hanson Street, the second avenues, some in what we're calling the
[1:14:38] Innovation District on the other side of Shoshone and then as we start to show
[1:14:44] the build-outs through the phases you'll see they're following pretty closely
[1:14:48] those city owned parcels. So the first phase in 2028, so this is five years, you're seeing
[1:14:56] a lot of housing specifically on the Hanson Street corridor, and the intersection of Hanson
[1:15:02] Street in 2nd Avenue South, and the gray is a parking garage there as well, to we're taking
[1:15:10] up parking lots with this new development, so being sure to provide that. The next phase, so 2033,
[1:15:22] 10 years. Again, more housing on the second street. You'll see, you'll see more housing
[1:15:27] on 2nd Avenue North as well. You'll start to see some mixed use housing in the Innovation
[1:15:35] District as well. Another parking garage and more office and actual office building coming
[1:15:43] along 2nd as well. In 2043, you see this development along the 2nd again and hands with more housing.
[1:15:52] The innovation district is really coming to life and then the big thing to know is at the Rock Creek
[1:15:57] room that Hotel and Convention Center program has come to be. You start to see how that pedestrian
[1:16:04] bridge connects it and this whole downtown is transformed and there's tons of people living
[1:16:10] down here and using these active streetscapes along them. I do want to note too that the housing has
[1:16:18] retail included at its ground level for the active streetscape and it's
[1:16:24] important that the parking garages follow the same suit as their sort of major chunks of these blocks
[1:16:30] we want to keep those blocks active as much as possible and really try to focus on
[1:16:35] an attractive design for these parking garages as well so they don't just become these massive
[1:16:40] I saw holes in the district to the face of the parking deck. There's also, you can have the street facing half of that parking structure to capture it in these diagrams, but I do want to mention is that the improvements that are happening to Rock Creek in terms of the park and trail enhancements can be happening as early as phase one.
[1:17:21] So, here in the 2028, we're storing Rock Creek expanding the park in the canyon, rails and then just talked through a lot of things.
[1:18:05] And so, the next question is kind of what does this mean for downtown Twin Falls?
[1:18:10] How do we start to make this happen?
[1:18:11] What are some of the changes that might need to happen?
[1:18:14] And what are the actions that we can take?
[1:18:16] So, first, where I think one of the big things is to look for opportunities for the, you know,
[1:18:24] purpose in existing buildings, the historic building stock in Twin Falls is
[1:18:30] pretty amazing and so utilizing those and providing incentives that
[1:18:36] encourage businesses to start to reuse those.
[1:18:41] Downtown Twin Falls in a lot of areas doesn't have parking minimums at the moment
[1:18:45] and that kind of allows the market to set the amount of parking that they want to
[1:18:51] provide. So just being mindful of that and ensuring that there is, you know,
[1:18:58] parking provided and that parking requirements sometimes can be too high
[1:19:03] and if it's a feasibility. So I think Twin Falls is already set up while they're
[1:19:10] looking for ways to support shared parking across new developments. So you
[1:19:15] know there can be public own laws but there can also be public private partnerships
[1:19:19] and maybe you work with a developer to build
[1:19:24] substructured parking and dedicate a portion of that to public use.
[1:19:28] There's also selling city only about a discount to developers
[1:19:32] to make some of these project types more feasible, particularly the
[1:19:36] six-story podium that we want to see downtown
[1:19:41] and more other incentives such as additional height, density,
[1:19:45] lot sizes, and then to consider is raising
[1:19:51] the maximum height to 65 feet per higher outside of Maine and Avenue to support
[1:19:58] higher density development to make those projects pencil for the developers
[1:20:03] create a kind of housing activity outside of Maine Avenue just to keep that
[1:20:18] historic core intact as much as possible. So what are kind of the first action
[1:20:28] points for the city and the URA? We're looking at place-making investments
[1:20:33] a long Hanson Street, Phase 1, as there's a lot of ownership long Hanson, that's a great opportunity
[1:20:39] where we can kind of leverage that public land ownership and then starting to identify those
[1:20:45] near-term opportunity sites that we can already get projects happening underway on 24.
[1:20:52] One more question that you guys may have. I know this is a lot.
[1:21:04] I do have one question I noticed on your earlier timeline so it was one of those earlier slides
[1:21:12] that you talked about a public open house and it says April 20th which is
[1:21:20] like two days away so that is not happening but what is the what is the
[1:21:27] plan when it comes to reaching out the public on this more updated plan?
[1:21:35] Yeah we have yet to come up with an official plan but we're hoping that this
[1:21:38] This gets voted on next month by the URA and then hopefully a public, full public meeting
[1:21:46] either end of May or June.
[1:21:48] That's our cover.
[1:21:53] Thank you, Mayor.
[1:21:54] I just want to say I'm looking forward to your work on this and I appreciate this vision.
[1:21:58] To involve this is really worried about losing that small town feel and a lot of people's
[1:22:03] reaction to improvements downtown is don't do anything, you're going to make it worse,
[1:22:07] we're going to lose that feel.
[1:22:09] But I think this is critical, and here's a few examples of why.
[1:22:12] Nothing says we're not a small town anymore, like a six lane highway on the north side of town.
[1:22:18] This helps us avoid more of that.
[1:22:21] Nothing says you're not a small town anymore when most of your business is big, corporately owned box stores.
[1:22:27] This allows an environment for locally owned businesses to thrive.
[1:22:31] And finally, urban blight.
[1:22:33] Again, that's a big city problem, right?
[1:22:37] Well, it seems to me that mixed use neighborhoods are great for fighting urban blight, keeps things alive and active 24, well not 24, 7, but more than just 8 to 5 on weekdays. So, um, anyways, appreciate your presentation. Thank you.
[1:22:54] Thank you for those comments. Those are great.
[1:22:56] Any other comments or questions? Thank you very much.
[1:23:03] Okay guys, so that is the last item under items of consideration.
[1:23:14] Our next item is a time for public input, this is a time for anyone from the public who wishes to come down and address the City Council on a subject that was not on today's agenda.
[1:23:27] You're welcome to come down.
[1:23:30] They see no one advisory board report.
[1:23:36] Any Rick Hawkins?
[1:23:38] Mary, the opportunity to attend the AIC workshop in early this past week.
[1:23:44] There's crisis intervention training coming up.
[1:23:49] Chiefs, I think you're both aware of it.
[1:23:52] Interesting.
[1:23:55] And I think you would suggest and encourage people.
[1:23:59] Thank you.
[1:24:08] Jason.
[1:24:09] Yes.
[1:24:10] transportation, Magic Valley transportation. I just lost the word of any house, so the most important is there's an ITD district meeting this week on the 19th. It happens at Hilton Garden Inn.
[1:24:30] It won't be specifically talking about the third bridge, but that will be definitely
[1:24:36] a topic that will be addressed.
[1:24:38] This is more for addressing the commissioner that represents our area.
[1:24:43] And it's 130 to 430.
[1:24:46] Correct.
[1:24:47] Okay.
[1:24:49] Perfect.
[1:24:50] Thanks for bringing that up.
[1:24:52] Sitting manager's office.
[1:24:53] City staff will be attending that meeting.
[1:24:54] We have a series of things that we'll be talking or at least hoping to address in the
[1:25:02] next week.
[1:25:17] Okay.
[1:25:18] like there's any other business, so our meeting is adjourned.
[1:25:22] Thank you.
