Oversight Archive: City Council meeting, 2023-06-12, recording 1 (started 16:00)
Machine transcript (faster-whisper base.en), not checked word for word; the Pledge of Allegiance is shown in its standard wording. The recording is the record.
Times are time into the recording. Passages with private details are muted in the audio and marked here.
The audio on the page below was re-encoded by software from the video the agency posted. Check any passage against
that audio before relying on it.
Page: https://oversightarchive.org/twin-falls-id/meetings/2023-06-12/

[0:00:08] Good afternoon, gentlemen, and welcome to the June 12th,
[0:00:14] 2023 City Council meeting.
[0:00:17] On a current firm, we have a quorum.
[0:00:19] We have six of seven members present in person,
[0:00:22] and Councilman Brown is excused tonight.
[0:00:26] So first before we go into our regular meeting,
[0:00:29] which will be five o'clock,
[0:00:30] we're going to move into executive session under action item
[0:00:35] 74-2061-B to consider the evaluation dismissal or disciplining of or to hear complaints or
[0:00:42] charges brought against a public officer employees staff member or individual agent or
[0:00:48] public school student.
[0:00:52] So moved.
[0:00:55] Motion by Alex Koval, seconded by Nikki Boyd to move into executive session under 74-2061-B.
[0:01:03] Amy Roll call vote please.
[0:01:07] Ruth Pierce.
[0:01:08] Yes.
[0:01:09] Yes.
[0:01:10] Yes.
[0:01:11] Are you talking?
[0:01:12] Yes.
[0:01:13] Yes.
[0:01:14] Yes.
[0:01:15] Yes.
[0:01:16] Yes.
[0:01:17] Yes.
[0:01:18] Yes.
[0:01:19] Yes.
[0:01:20] Yes.
[0:01:21] Yes.
[0:01:22] Yes.
[0:01:23] Yes.
[0:01:24] Yes.
[0:01:25] Yes.
[0:01:26] Yes.
[0:03:18] Yes.
[0:03:19] Yes.
[0:03:20] Yes.
[0:03:21] Yes.
[0:03:22] Yes.
[0:03:23] Yes.
[0:03:24] Yes.
[0:03:25] Yes.
[0:03:26] Yes.
[0:03:27] Yes.
[0:03:28] We have a quorum. We have six of the seven members present in chambers and councilman Brown is excused. I want to note that we met at four o'clock
[0:03:39] Went into executive session for an hour and we're now reconvening. So first item on the agenda is the Pledge of Allegiance. Those wishing to join me please rise.
[0:03:48] We have no proclamations tonight. So next on the agenda is the consent calendar.
[0:04:12] Council wishes. Madam Mayor, I move that we approve the consent calendar as
[0:04:18] presented. Thank you. Do I have a second? Second. Thank you. Motion by Alex
[0:04:23] Kaval seconded by Craig Hawkins to approve the consent calendar as written.
[0:04:29] Amy Roll call vote please. Chris Reed yes. Thank you Boyd. Yes. Craig Hawkins.
[0:04:36] Yes. Spencer Cutler. Yes. Alex Kaval. Yes. Yes. Thank you. Motion passes six
[0:04:43] to zero, so if you're here for a special advance for the 4th of July, 9-1-1 memorial, or the
[0:04:51] summer carnival, those have all been approved.
[0:04:54] So next on the agenda, under items of consideration is an action item, which I think is just an
[0:05:02] information item.
[0:05:03] Is that correct?
[0:05:04] We're not approving anything.
[0:05:08] Approval of the joint powers agreement and the bylaws for the Magic Valley Metropolitan Planning
[0:05:12] organization and authorize the Mayor to sign the documents. We have Travis
[0:05:19] Rothweiler or City Manager. Welcome. Thank you, Mayor members of the Council. So the
[0:05:26] Mayor is absolutely right. We had hoped to present to you final documents today in
[0:05:32] terms of the Joint Powers Agreement as well as the bylaws at 8.30 this morning.
[0:05:39] We met as a regional group and it appears that the documents were not as final.
[0:05:46] for one organization as they were for the other seven.
[0:05:50] So we're in a bit of a holding pattern, but I still believe it's important to kind of share the work that we've done.
[0:05:56] And then we anticipate that the next round of documents for approval will be submitted to you about the August or September timeframe.
[0:06:07] At that point in time, we'll ask for you to adopt.
[0:06:10] But I think it's a good opportunity for us to have a conversation about the MPO,
[0:06:15] even though we won't be asking you to take a formalized action tonight.
[0:06:18] So one of the questions that we often get is what is an MPO and how many are there
[0:06:25] and why do we want to be a part of a regional planning group.
[0:06:30] And the first is, this is a group that really spends time focusing on regional transportation needs.
[0:06:41] This is not public transportation in the form of bussing.
[0:06:46] So Mandy, as you're very familiar,
[0:06:48] has been working on the microtransit grant process
[0:06:51] and the $3 million grant that we received from ITD.
[0:06:56] This is not that.
[0:06:58] The connection is both of those requirements
[0:07:01] were triggered when our urbanized area
[0:07:04] is determined by the 2020 Census showed
[0:07:08] that our area was greater than 50,000 people.
[0:07:12] So what happens is there is two different groups
[0:07:17] that are part of our group.
[0:07:18] And one, I'll first talk about those
[0:07:20] that are inside of the urbanized area.
[0:07:23] And what happens is we are required to follow
[0:07:25] what's called a comprehensive cooperative
[0:07:28] and continuing process or a 3C process.
[0:07:31] And what happens through that regional coordination
[0:07:33] and collaboration is a policy board will be created
[0:07:38] and that policy board will be the group that helps outline the larger transportation needs,
[0:07:45] not just for a singular community as we've been operating but for a larger geographic area.
[0:07:52] Informally, we've been operating as a regional group for several years.
[0:07:59] There's the greater transportation authority that has been loosely working over the course
[0:08:05] of the last several years. In fact, when Gary Young was the City Engineer, which is about
[0:08:11] five city engineers ago now, he was the chairperson of that group and he helped bring them together
[0:08:18] to have conversations. He brought individuals from the private sector, the different public
[0:08:24] sector, including the state and different cities and county to come together to have a regional
[0:08:30] conversation about planning, this formalizes that process. So over the course of the last
[0:08:38] several months, and when I say months, it's been about 18 months, we've gone through a
[0:08:43] process to talk about what do we need to be doing, how do we need to be collaborating,
[0:08:50] and what needs to, for us to, what do we need to do to move forward. So on December 29th,
[0:08:57] 22, we officially received our letter and this is a letter that the mayor had received
[0:09:03] that says, congratulations, the Census has determined that you are over that 50,000 threshold and
[0:09:09] that your population of thousands of people per square mile now allows us to create an
[0:09:15] urbanized area. So we spent some time negotiating. And there are five cities or entities that
[0:09:22] have to be a part of this group. It is the city of Twin Falls, the city of Kimberly,
[0:09:28] I.T.D., Twin Falls County, and the Twin Falls Highway District. Those five entities have
[0:09:39] properties that are within that urbanized zone and that they are required to be a part of
[0:09:45] this process. And then as a part of the other process, or we've invited others to see if
[0:09:51] they are interested and you can see that there were three entities that wanted to opt
[0:09:56] in and they believe that there is benefit in joining the Metropolitan Planning Organization.
[0:10:01] And those are the Durham County, the Durham Highway District and the Hillsdale Highway District.
[0:10:06] And so right now we have eight entities that are working collaboratively on a collection
[0:10:12] of bylaws as well as a joint powers agreement.
[0:10:16] And this is where we're engaged in the conversation, and this is where I had hoped that we would
[0:10:22] have you adopt tonight, but there were a couple of questions that one member had.
[0:10:28] I think that while we are in agreement and that the documents before you are generally
[0:10:33] true to form, I think it's prudent to wait rather than bring back amended documents for
[0:10:39] you to consider.
[0:10:41] Essentially, what is outlined in your packet are these two documents, and inside of these
[0:10:45] two documents. It talks about number one, the roles and responsibilities that each entity
[0:10:52] will have as defined in the joint powers and the bylaws, how we're going to work and how
[0:10:59] we're going to operate. Both of these documents have been reviewed by legal counsel and those
[0:11:04] comments were submitted and our comments were, I would describe, really based into the law
[0:11:11] and I think Shane did a good job in reviewing our documents and sending comments for us to
[0:11:18] consider. So each of the board members has taken a look at this. They have reviewed them,
[0:11:26] and what will happen next is that we will move forward for final approval and adoption.
[0:11:32] So what happens after that?
[0:11:35] Once the joint powers agreement and the bylaws have been adopted by each of its governing entities,
[0:11:44] there will be an official signing that will occur. And again, we anticipate that will occur in about
[0:11:51] August of this year. At that point in time, because the City of Twin Falls is the largest urban
[0:11:59] city inside of that urbanized area. We have the responsibility of communicating
[0:12:06] back to the governor and we will communicate in the form of a letter that
[0:12:11] responds to the letter that I showed earlier from the governor as well as
[0:12:15] with a copy of our joint powers agreement and with our bylaws and from that point
[0:12:20] in time we anticipate that the governor will officially create the Magic Valley
[0:12:26] metropolitan planning organization and then we will start moving forward. In the
[0:12:33] bylaws and in the Joint Powers Agreement it talks about the organizational
[0:12:37] structure and we anticipate that this will be a stand-alone entity and that the
[0:12:42] City of Twin Falls will host this entity for a period not to exceed five years
[0:12:47] but in hosting the entity it is not done without charge and so I've been able to
[0:12:53] work with members of our team to put in costs for a budget. The mayor has been there to help
[0:12:59] in creating the budget for the Metropolitan Planning Organization and all of those anticipated
[0:13:04] costs that would be on to the City of Twin Falls are reflective into that budget and it will be paid
[0:13:09] for equally by the member entities determined by the total number of seats that each entity is
[0:13:18] awarded. Inside of the bylaws, it talks about the number of seats that are shared. The City
[0:13:26] of Twin Falls will receive four votes and it will have four members on the policy board.
[0:13:32] The City of Kimberly being the next largest entity will have three seats and then each
[0:13:38] of the other entities that I talked to you about will each also receive one seat. The costs are
[0:13:45] per seat and so the City of Twin Falls will pay for the cost of four seats and the opportunity
[0:13:52] to serve on those boards.
[0:13:58] The total cost to the City of Twin Falls is estimated to be between 16 and $20,000 and
[0:14:03] that cost is to escalate over a five-year period of time at about two and a half percent.
[0:14:11] The reason that we're putting a cost escalator in there is because at the end of that five-year
[0:14:16] period, we want this to be a complete stand-alone entity.
[0:14:21] And so at that point in time, the City of Twin Falls hosting responsibilities will be terminated.
[0:14:29] And so that is kind of the process that we've gone forward.
[0:14:34] The seats will be appointed by the mayor.
[0:14:39] They will be confirmed by the council.
[0:14:40] will serve a term that is dependent upon how we want them to serve. We believe that it would
[0:14:48] be staggered terms just as if we were creating a new committee in that process. We would stagger
[0:14:55] the terms and so one person might have a one-year term, a two-year term, and a three-year term,
[0:15:00] and a four-year term, and then we would kind of rotate that so we didn't have all of those
[0:15:04] members leaving all at once.
[0:15:09] So what does hosting look like?
[0:15:12] Hosting means that our information services team will help with the technology needs and
[0:15:18] have had conversations with Kathy about that.
[0:15:21] It means that our finance team will help keep their books.
[0:15:25] I've had conversations with Brianna and Brent and they'll also do those types of by-links.
[0:15:31] This will not be an employee of the City of Twin Falls, it will be an employee of this board.
[0:15:38] And so they will not be necessarily eligible for our health insurance, but we've had members
[0:15:43] of our team that will assist with the recruiting process in standing up the entity and then
[0:15:48] we'll turn it over completely to the board.
[0:15:52] We anticipate recruiting for an executive director as a board.
[0:15:59] the December through March of 24 time frame and we believe that the board and the
[0:16:07] MPO will be fully stood up right around April to May of 2024. So that's the work that, you know,
[0:16:18] it took seven minutes to talk about the work that we've been doing for the last four years.
[0:16:28] So, that is the Metropolitan Planning Organization for the Magic Valley and the nutshell, and I'm
[0:16:36] happy to answer any questions.
[0:16:38] The mayor has been active, she has been involved in the creation of this process, and so it's
[0:16:43] a rare opportunity that I can defer the hard questions to her.
[0:16:49] I'm still the boss.
[0:16:51] Any questions for Travis on this?
[0:16:54] been an interesting process, that many entities coming together, and for the
[0:17:08] most part, has gone very smoothly. I would agree and know that there's lots
[0:17:16] of layers to this. So you're going to have a policy board that will guide the
[0:17:20] operations and assist in creating rules and policies for the executive director
[0:17:28] and evaluate his or her performance.
[0:17:31] But there's going to be a technical advisory board,
[0:17:33] and that technical advisory board is going to be composed
[0:17:36] of truly the professionals in the area that it's going
[0:17:39] to be the city engineers, it's going to be representatives
[0:17:42] from private engineering firms, planning and zoning professionals
[0:17:49] that are really going to be talking about land use strategies
[0:17:52] as well as creating long-term planning opportunities
[0:17:57] for regional transportation, they talked about the process
[0:18:01] of creating the first transportation plan for this area.
[0:18:05] And so that they believe will start in earnest in 2024.
[0:18:14] Yes. Two questions if that's all right.
[0:18:17] First, you talked about an executive director.
[0:18:19] Is that board when when if somebody is interested
[0:18:22] in being one of those board members or as we look to put people
[0:18:26] in those seats, when are you looking at forming that board?
[0:18:31] I believe that it would be after the official creation of the MPO, which we anticipate to occur in December of 23 at the latest.
[0:18:49] And so it would probably be appropriate that once the board makeup is officially known and has been set by the governor,
[0:19:02] that the mayor will probably ask staff to begin the process of going through our
[0:19:09] application process for people to serve on committees.
[0:19:12] Her phone will probably be late summer because I will say Travis before you came
[0:19:18] to the meeting we talked about trying to accelerate that so we could stand up by
[0:19:23] October 1. Perfect. So that may be earlier but we'll communicate that. And then how
[0:19:31] how will this work with the greater windfalls, transportation?
[0:19:41] I know that I'm not getting the title right,
[0:19:44] but Jason sits on that committee.
[0:19:48] How will those work together, or will one dissolve,
[0:19:52] or, you know, I think that it's always good
[0:19:55] to have regional collaboration.
[0:19:58] The MPO will be the official transportation body
[0:20:02] for the region.
[0:20:04] If that group was still meeting on their Tuesday mornings
[0:20:08] and to exchange information,
[0:20:10] I think that's a positive anytime
[0:20:12] that you can continue to have those regional conversations
[0:20:16] with all of the partners, it would be, it's a benefit.
[0:20:19] It's important to remember that there are only eight
[0:20:22] that have elected to be a part of this group
[0:20:23] at this point in time.
[0:20:24] There are several entities that have elected
[0:20:28] not to jump in at this point and to observe
[0:20:32] to see what would happen in Transpire in the future
[0:20:35] and inside of the bylaws, it describes how additional seats
[0:20:41] and additional membership occurs
[0:20:43] and how the group is expanded.
[0:20:46] Okay, thank you.
[0:20:48] Any other questions for Travis?
[0:20:52] Okay, might as well stay there.
[0:20:54] Next item on the agenda is a presentation
[0:20:58] Seeking City Council Priorities
[0:21:00] on the development of the fiscal year 2324
[0:21:03] budget and we still have Travis. Here I am. So this morning I had the opportunity to go
[0:21:11] on to the radio and I was sharing that we're going to start talking about the budget and
[0:21:17] to invite the community to be a part of this process. And so again I wanted to echo that.
[0:21:24] I can affirm that the council takes great joy in having individuals approach the mic
[0:21:33] and to share their thoughts and ideas
[0:21:35] through the budget and the budgeting process.
[0:21:38] So again, we would extend that invitation
[0:21:40] for people to become engaged in the very first opportunity
[0:21:44] if it's not this evening is going to be on July 3rd.
[0:21:47] And everything that we've been doing to this point in time
[0:21:51] has to been to hit that target date
[0:21:54] to make a presentation to you
[0:21:56] and present a balanced budget to the city of Twin Falls.
[0:21:58] And I believe that we're well on our way.
[0:22:00] It's really because of the amazing team
[0:22:03] that we have the many hands that start this process.
[0:22:08] So we share that everything is built
[0:22:10] around the strategic plan and that I want to share
[0:22:15] with this group that we will begin
[0:22:18] that strategic plan retooling process this September.
[0:22:23] So we will work through that process.
[0:22:26] We will work to get an RFP handled
[0:22:29] and then we will move forward,
[0:22:30] have under contract to review our strategic plan.
[0:22:34] because it is entering into its 11th year anniversary.
[0:22:40] If you can believe that, so in 2012,
[0:22:43] we started a strategic planning process.
[0:22:46] We did an update in 2017,
[0:22:50] and now we have funding in this budget
[0:22:52] to again do another update.
[0:22:55] And the idea is to validate
[0:22:57] that the strategic plan that we're operating
[0:23:00] still is valid, and it continues to serve
[0:23:03] as a guide post in moving forward.
[0:23:06] And so this is the strategic plan that you have,
[0:23:08] and you can see that it is designed to align activities
[0:23:13] and objectives to realizing our overall mission, vision,
[0:23:19] or our community.
[0:23:23] So there's a couple of things that really jumped out,
[0:23:27] and there are some things that have been,
[0:23:29] oh, that's the way it's been for a long period of time.
[0:23:32] So if you look at the unemployment rate,
[0:23:36] employment rate has really hovered below 3%, whether it's 2.7 or 2.6, it continues to be below 3.
[0:23:46] The housing market has tend to flatten a little bit where we are seeing rapidly increasing cost.
[0:23:52] We'll talk a little bit about that. The thing that really stood out to me this time was the fact
[0:23:59] that the City of Twin Falls since the July 2020 census to today less than three years is added more
[0:24:12] than 6,000 people. Just me and I want you to think about that just for a minute that the City of Twin
[0:24:21] Falls in a three-year period is estimated to have added nearly 6,000 people and were not the only
[0:24:31] community inside of the Magic Valley that continues to grow. And so when I talk to my peers that are
[0:24:37] in other communities, they share that their communities continue to grow at an unprecedented rate.
[0:24:43] And so that really means that that 275,000 people that live in this area called the Magic Valley
[0:24:51] has grown and that there's probably more than 100,000 people that come into our community on a
[0:24:57] daily basis. The other thing I thought that was interesting is where the Twin
[0:25:02] Falls housing market has been relatively stable and I'll show that it is the
[0:25:07] state's number that is down 5.1% compared to last year and so where last
[0:25:13] year or from its high. So in July of 22 is where we kind of reach the top of the
[0:25:22] housing market and now today that median home is dropped about $40,000. So
[0:25:33] here's the estimated, don't take them to the bank numbers, they're still way too
[0:25:39] early and subject to a lot of change. But this is where we're at today. You can
[0:25:46] see that the City of Twin Falls is going to grow by another estimated half a
[0:25:51] a million, half a billion dollars.
[0:25:55] You can see that the total budget for the City of Twin Falls
[0:25:58] is going to grow by about 10 million.
[0:26:01] And you can see that we're projecting that the tax
[0:26:04] rate is going to be about the same.
[0:26:08] Well, why is the city spending $10 million more money?
[0:26:15] We're budgeting four part of your SLFRF money.
[0:26:19] And we received $3 million over a two-year period of time
[0:26:24] to run a microtransit program.
[0:26:26] And so because the organization is spending $10 million
[0:26:31] of more money, it does not necessarily
[0:26:33] mean that it is all funds that are generated locally.
[0:26:37] In fact, these are dollars that have come into our system
[0:26:39] over a period of time.
[0:26:41] And we anticipate being able to spend those dollars
[0:26:44] as we move forward.
[0:26:46] So this is a graph of how the city of Twin Falls
[0:26:49] continues to grow.
[0:26:51] And we can show you that it's an increase of nearly 8%
[0:26:56] this year over the last year.
[0:27:00] And we can show you that the new construction number is
[0:27:05] the largest ever.
[0:27:07] And that makes sense when you start reflecting that the tax
[0:27:12] rate or the taxes are paid looking in the rears.
[0:27:18] And so 12 to 18 months ago, our economy was growing rapidly.
[0:27:26] Our housing market was issuing a significant number of permits
[0:27:32] were being issued.
[0:27:32] We saw a rapid commercial, and that has slowed.
[0:27:37] And what's interesting is, in the past,
[0:27:40] we would be able to share with you
[0:27:42] that when you received a larger new construction number,
[0:27:48] That would mean that you would receive more property tax dollars.
[0:27:54] But when House Bill 389 passed the legislature, I believe it's two sessions ago now, they changed
[0:28:01] the formula.
[0:28:02] They changed how that formula works.
[0:28:04] And so not only do you get only 90% of that value, but you also use the anticipated tax
[0:28:12] rate for the upcoming year as opposed to the prior year's tax rate.
[0:28:17] And so while we're going to earn more than a million dollars in new construction value,
[0:28:24] we're actually going to bring home $12,000 less in property taxes than we did the prior
[0:28:29] year.
[0:28:31] So it's a system that now, in our opinion, doesn't make a lot of sense.
[0:28:37] The more your tax base grows, the fewer property tax dollars you get.
[0:28:44] And the legislature has a mantra that says they want growth to pay for growth.
[0:28:49] But I think that the system that they created runs contrary to that.
[0:28:56] So here's some of the things that we've taken into account as we've constructed the budget.
[0:29:00] And I wanted to illustrate the Twin Falls housing price, the Idaho housing price, and
[0:29:05] the Boise housing price as we continue to move forward graphically.
[0:29:08] But one of the things that's important to remember is a lot of individuals have recently received
[0:29:14] their assessments.
[0:29:16] And I can share with you that my assessment showed that my property continued to appreciate
[0:29:22] and value.
[0:29:23] And one of the things that I'm hearing is housing, softening, values are falling.
[0:29:31] And that's true.
[0:29:33] They're falling from their peak.
[0:29:36] And our peak inside of the City of Twin Falls for a median home occurred in July of 22.
[0:29:42] But that's not the date and time in which assessment or the value of your home is determined.
[0:29:49] The value of your home is determined on or about January 1.
[0:29:54] And on January 1 of 23, the median home was greater in value than what the median home
[0:30:03] was in 22.
[0:30:06] And so while you see that little bump, the point in time in which they measured is on
[0:30:15] either side of that.
[0:30:18] And so inside of the city, according to Mr. Wills, they're seeing about a 5% to 7% increase
[0:30:28] in the median home value.
[0:30:31] What does that mean for property taxes?
[0:30:34] Nothing.
[0:30:37] tax rates remaining flat, but what happens is it is the individual tax rate multiplied
[0:30:46] by the individual property to determine exactly what is going to occur for an individual's
[0:30:51] property. And then there's a new wrinkle where the Idaho legislature has made the determination
[0:30:57] that they want to pay off the school bonds and the supplemental levies. And so they're
[0:31:01] going to remove those and give you credit.
[0:31:04] And so we believe that individuals inside of the city
[0:31:08] of Twin Falls will be paying less in property taxes
[0:31:11] this upcoming year than in the prior year.
[0:31:15] I am not going to predict how much.
[0:31:19] However, I will say I do not believe it
[0:31:21] will be the 20% as advertised when the legislature signed
[0:31:26] he died.
[0:31:28] Any questions on that?
[0:31:30] The other crazy thing that really kind of caught my attention
[0:31:34] is that the median home since January of 2019,
[0:31:40] which really isn't that long,
[0:31:42] has grown by $137,000.
[0:31:46] And that rate of growth since 2019 is actually greater
[0:31:51] than the median home value of the city of Twin Falls in 2013.
[0:31:58] So we continue to grow.
[0:32:02] The other thing that we find
[0:32:03] is that we continue the struggle to find talent.
[0:32:10] And one of the questions we often get asked
[0:32:12] is well, where did all the people go?
[0:32:15] And what's interesting is if you take a look
[0:32:17] at the number of people that are employed
[0:32:19] in the labor market today and reflect just a prior year,
[0:32:23] you can see that the state of Idaho added 12,000 people
[0:32:26] to its civilian labor force.
[0:32:29] 5,500 of them appear in the Twin Falls statistical area
[0:32:35] area, which is just to roam in Twin Falls. We've added 5,500 laborers according to the
[0:32:41] Department of Labor just in our little part of Idaho and the entire state as added 12,000
[0:32:48] the city of Twin Falls is responsible for 1,200 of them. And yet, we still have a 2.7
[0:32:56] percent unemployment rate. And previously, I shared a graph with you that showed that
[0:33:03] we have a labor deficiency that for every 53 individuals that are employed out of a hundred,
[0:33:12] there are still 47 vacancies that go unfilled.
[0:33:17] The City of Twin Falls is really no different.
[0:33:19] We've been hovering between 22 and 26 on vacant positions across the organization for the last
[0:33:27] three years.
[0:33:28] And we continue to see that trend.
[0:33:31] Where it is one moment, a department will be fully staffed, and the next moment they won't,
[0:33:40] and the one that had been struggling is now fully staffed.
[0:33:43] And so, great credit to our entire HR team as they continued to man the ship and continue
[0:33:50] to go through recruitment over recruitment.
[0:33:52] And one of the really creative things that they did was they had a job there at the Public
[0:33:57] Works Department where they did interviews on the site.
[0:34:00] So people would come in and we had the opportunity to interview 14, maybe 15 individuals to fill
[0:34:06] in positions inside of our organization.
[0:34:09] We are no longer asking people just to submit resumes.
[0:34:12] Well, we want that to happen, right?
[0:34:14] But now we are trying to create unique opportunities to have individuals join our organization quickly.
[0:34:22] And then COS continues to grow.
[0:34:25] And while you look at the MCI and you say, wow, it's only up 2.1%, we say that's really
[0:34:30] good news. But it's up 2.1% over last year's 12% and the prior year's 9% and so the composite
[0:34:40] increase over that period of time is still significant. And because of that, we unfortunately
[0:34:49] have to ask you to consider rate adjustments this year. So these are the goals that we set.
[0:34:58] Sometimes the meaning changes. Sometimes it remains the same. But all of these things we want
[0:35:04] to continue to be the employer of choice in the Magic Valley and we want to continue to find ways
[0:35:10] to fill those vacancies so that our citizens can receive the services that they pay for.
[0:35:19] We shared that we believe that the tax rate is going to continue to stay about the same this year.
[0:35:25] This is a really early number. I almost hesitated not to share this but we have it. This is where we're
[0:35:33] at. It is as accurate as the information that the county has been able to provide to us and
[0:35:40] the county continues to work with the tax commission because the complication this year
[0:35:44] is we're closing out an urban or urban district, which is not something that we routinely do
[0:35:49] and how those values get translated into dollars and into the tax base is still part of the learning
[0:35:55] process for all of us. So what does the budget include? It includes the 3% statutory increase,
[0:36:03] 90% of the new construction value, which is estimated to be $116 million, 80% of the combined revenue allocation area, which we believe the net from 2006 is $170.7 million and 1% of the revenue from the foregone balance as we continue to work that down.
[0:36:28] We're recommending a two and a half percent rate increase in water and in sewer, and we're still working with PSI.
[0:36:35] And one of the justifications for the rate increases is because both of these are very large power consumers.
[0:36:43] And over the course of the last two fiscal years, we've seen our power costs and our general fuel costs significantly increase.
[0:36:51] And especially in the sewer fund, we have a commitment to bondholders to make sure that
[0:36:57] we are maintaining our covenants of revenues over expenditures and we have to increase
[0:37:04] those rates to ensure that we are in compliance with those covenants that we set when we shoot
[0:37:12] the debt.
[0:37:13] I stole this from Brianna.
[0:37:15] This is an amazing slide and I want to continue to emphasize the point and the thing that stands
[0:37:22] out to me is that while we have increased property tax collections because we've grown
[0:37:31] in significantly from 2019 to 2021 as we reflected on the prior chart of the growth of the community,
[0:37:39] which is nearly $2 billion in that period of time, the residential property tax piece is
[0:37:48] in the one that has supported 100% of that growth in that period of time, where actually
[0:37:57] all other types of properties outside of residential have paid $100,000 less collectively.
[0:38:09] That to me was mind-blowing.
[0:38:10] I mean, just think for a minute that because of how property taxes are assessed inside of
[0:38:18] the state of Idaho, and it is determined by the growth and the value.
[0:38:23] We know that the growth of residential properties has significantly outpaced all other classifications
[0:38:29] of property.
[0:38:30] We see that not only locally, but it has also been shared through the associated taxpayers
[0:38:36] of Idaho and the different research in which they have done.
[0:38:42] And as we've collected more property taxes under the system in which we're operating,
[0:38:47] burden has fallen completely to our residential property taxpayers. And if
[0:38:52] there's been no other chart or graph to advocate for two things, a reinstitution
[0:38:59] of indexing of property values in the state of Idaho. And number two, a local
[0:39:05] option sales tax to provide permanent property tax relief to all
[0:39:08] classifications of property. I don't know if there's a better slide than this one.
[0:39:12] Our personal strategy is that we're looking at adding three and a half new positions to
[0:39:21] our organization.
[0:39:23] They include the Transit Coordinator, which is assisted through the grant, Information Security's
[0:39:28] Engineer, which is to help with additional cybersecurity issues and an Assistant Communications
[0:39:35] Center Manager to help with managing a team that works seven days a week, 24 hours a day
[0:39:41] 365 days a year, and a half-time custodian.
[0:39:45] In addition to that, we're moving one position from our organization, which is a currently
[0:39:51] vacant building inspector because we cannot justify the workload at this point in time.
[0:39:57] And in the spirit of One City, Matthew Long, our building official, offered that position.
[0:40:02] And positions through our process are tough to get.
[0:40:07] when a department leader stands up and says,
[0:40:10] I can give this one to the greater good.
[0:40:14] It tells me that what we're doing in changing
[0:40:17] and moving and advancing a culture is really working.
[0:40:21] Now I'm not saying that the other departments
[0:40:23] aren't following that, but I use that as an example
[0:40:26] of the good work that he did.
[0:40:29] We're looking at providing a competitive
[0:40:33] compensation adjustment package.
[0:40:38] And I share that without sharing a lot of details,
[0:40:43] because everybody looks to the city of Twin Falls
[0:40:45] to find out what we're doing.
[0:40:47] And in a really, really tight labor market,
[0:40:50] I don't want to lay down my playbook.
[0:40:53] And so when I was recently asked at the county,
[0:40:56] what are you doing for employee compensation
[0:40:58] at a meeting that I was at?
[0:41:00] I said somewhere between 0 and 25%.
[0:41:02] And I share that because we really want to be cautious on making sure that we're able
[0:41:14] to offer an employee package that is competitive.
[0:41:19] But most importantly, it's sustainable.
[0:41:21] We don't want to offer an employee compensation package this year that we can't forward in
[0:41:26] subsequent years.
[0:41:27] And at this point in time, when you look at building and the economy and the growth of
[0:41:32] new construction, new dollars coming into our system are going to be even more
[0:41:37] scarce than what they were in the past. And then fully funding our share of the
[0:41:42] Percy increases. We're also looking at establishing what's called a VIBA for our
[0:41:48] employees is something that we've talked about in the past. We're going to continue
[0:41:53] to do all of the things associated with operation and maintenance of our
[0:41:56] departments. We're seeing increasing costs associated with fuel, but the other thing
[0:42:00] that we're seeing significant increase in cost is associated with training.
[0:42:05] So for a period of time, we could not send our people to training because there were no
[0:42:10] training opportunities available because they were shut down with COVID or other things.
[0:42:16] And now there are opportunities, but one of the things that I'm sure that you have all
[0:42:19] seen is the cost of travel has significantly increased as well.
[0:42:24] And so not only do we have this return of opportunities to send folks to training, but we're also
[0:42:30] finding that those costs are much more expensive. And then we have a very robust
[0:42:37] capital planning budget moving forward and here are some of the capital strategies
[0:42:41] that we have which includes spending $6.3 million in the Water Fund for well
[0:42:47] number five PI improvements, mainline and meter replacement. Capital fund or
[0:42:53] street fund of slightly more than 3.5 million wastewater fund of 3.3 million
[0:42:59] fire station improvements at 1.5 million, the micro-transit program setting that up with
[0:43:06] the grant at 1.3 million police improvements at 451,000, pool improvements for 231,000 and
[0:43:14] IT improvements. I wanted to give you a sampling of what we're looking at as we move forward.
[0:43:21] What's not included here is the level of work that is going to have to go behind completing
[0:43:31] all of the FLF projects that have been established.
[0:43:36] And so as you kind of look at your council capital and these are the projects that you
[0:43:43] approved last year, lots of sidewalks, lots of very intensive engineering department time
[0:43:51] to move those forward, their time is going to be occupied
[0:43:56] with a lot of these things.
[0:44:00] And so we are going to be presenting to you
[0:44:05] one-time capital projects that may not require
[0:44:09] a lot of internal support from the engineering team
[0:44:13] to be able to advance, simply because the workload associated
[0:44:17] with this and the workload associated with the other projects
[0:44:21] is very significant, and again, going back to that issue,
[0:44:26] we are still working to fill
[0:44:28] position vacancies across our organization.
[0:44:34] So that's where we're at.
[0:44:36] We've got teams that are frantically scrambling
[0:44:40] to build charts and graphs and put words onto page
[0:44:43] to make sure that our budget is easy to understand.
[0:44:47] We don't believe in simply submitting line item budgets
[0:44:51] for you to try to discern what are we going to do
[0:44:54] and what are we going to accomplish?
[0:44:56] And this is the schedule that we hope to follow over the course
[0:45:00] of this year.
[0:45:01] Notice that we'll start with an overview on the third.
[0:45:04] We'll dive immediately right into focus areas 1 and 7
[0:45:08] on the 10th or 5 and 6 on the 17th, 2 and 3 on the 24th.
[0:45:16] Focus area 8 on the 31st.
[0:45:18] And then we'll also have a series of conversations
[0:45:21] about rate adjustments and what those rates might be.
[0:45:24] Right now we're having conversations
[0:45:26] about different rates that require public hearing.
[0:45:30] The utility rates are under the 5% threshold
[0:45:33] and they do not require a public hearing,
[0:45:35] but I believe it's still prudent and wise
[0:45:38] to get public comment.
[0:45:40] At this point in time,
[0:45:41] Brienne is still working with members of our team,
[0:45:43] but we do believe that you'll see some requests
[0:45:47] increase the pool fees when you're charging, I think it's $3 to go to the pool, it's very
[0:45:59] quick to cross over 5% if you want to increase it by a quarter.
[0:46:03] So the percent doesn't always tell the story in terms of the amount that you're looking
[0:46:09] at increasing the rates.
[0:46:10] But right now I believe that we will certainly be presenting and asking the council to support
[0:46:15] increases associated with the pool as we move forward. And with that I'm happy to
[0:46:21] answer any questions and if I look I got some pretty confident members of the
[0:46:27] team around here that can also kind of dive into that as well. So questions for
[0:46:32] Travis tonight. Mayor I have one. Yes. In the past several years we've come up
[0:46:41] with these things are being proposed and when it comes right down to the
[0:46:46] budget being proposed then there's there's things in there almost every
[0:46:50] department that are the B list that are we gonna be continuing with that we are
[0:46:56] okay because that I've been really happy with that in the past because we can't
[0:47:01] always think of things up front that we just ask for but as the process
[0:47:07] continues the actual departments themselves know exactly what needs to be
[0:47:12] done next, and that's been such a great way to do it.
[0:47:16] Yep.
[0:47:17] We've asked all the departments to share what the management team removed from their budgets,
[0:47:23] so that you can take into consideration are those items that would merit a portion of the
[0:47:30] 770, or maybe even changing what we're recommending to you from a spending package.
[0:47:37] might see a higher value than what we were able to, maybe the department leaders are able
[0:47:43] to make a better case before this group than what they were able to make during the budget
[0:47:46] balancing processes and hearings.
[0:47:48] But yeah, it's also important that when I think that you bring up a really good point,
[0:47:54] when the city manager's budget is presented to the council, it is a rough draft of a budget
[0:48:03] that we want to move forward.
[0:48:04] because it's written and it's 230 pages long
[0:48:07] does not mean that it's final.
[0:48:10] And so when the community reads it,
[0:48:12] I know that you know this,
[0:48:13] but when the community reads it, it's the starting point
[0:48:17] for us to begin the community conversation.
[0:48:19] It's not the end point,
[0:48:20] and that's why we really want involvement of our community
[0:48:23] to help us shape not only the Council 770,
[0:48:26] but also maybe sharing where they may believe
[0:48:30] that we made the wrong recommendations
[0:48:33] priorities for the Council to consider.
[0:48:41] Thank you.
[0:48:44] Or to come.
[0:48:47] Hey, so that's the end of our items of consideration.
[0:48:52] Next item on the agenda is the time for public input.
[0:48:56] If there's anybody in the public who wishes to address Council
[0:49:01] on an issue not being addressed on today's agenda,
[0:49:05] you're welcome to come down.
[0:49:10] I see no one.
[0:49:12] Advisory Board reports.
[0:49:14] Not a quiet way, the airport, right?
[0:49:24] No, I just want to remind everybody, though,
[0:49:27] that it is the 75th anniversary of our airport.
[0:49:32] And the show that's happening out there
[0:49:35] is going to be spectacular, a lot of things going on.
[0:49:39] But the website, if you go on it, it's super explanatory.
[0:49:43] You can actually see all the things you're going to see
[0:49:46] and realize what you want to be sure and look for and not
[0:49:49] Miss. So it's it's on Saturday and it's magicvalleyairshow.com. If you buy your parking ticket early, it's $10. If you buy it the day of the air show, it's 20, but the air show itself is free.
[0:50:06] Thank you. Anybody else? Did he manage your office?
[0:50:12] Just a reminder to the Council and members of the community, we will not be meeting next
[0:50:18] Monday as it is the Juneteenth holiday and we will resume our next regular scheduled meeting
[0:50:24] on the 26th of June.
[0:50:26] Thank you.
[0:50:29] Okay.
[0:50:30] Next, we have a public hearing is scheduled for 6 PM, so for now, executive session we
[0:50:39] probably can't get done in 12 minutes.
[0:50:48] We can, yeah, we were fine.
[0:50:51] Okay, well, we'll reconvene here in about 10 minutes.
[0:50:55] Thank you.
[0:52:02] Welcome back, ladies and gentlemen.
[0:52:04] I am reconvening the June 12th, 2023 City Council meeting.
[0:52:11] Again, confirming we have a quorum,
[0:52:13] six out of the seven members present.
[0:52:16] Our next item on the agenda is a public hearing,
[0:52:20] an action item request for vacation
[0:52:22] of a drainage storm water retention easement
[0:52:25] on property located at 2092 Dawson Drive,
[0:52:29] here of EHM engineers on behalf of
[0:52:32] Onion Village Plaza LLC.
[0:52:35] And before I start, I just want to review
[0:52:40] the public hearing procedures.
[0:52:45] First city staff will present the request and analysis.
[0:52:49] The applicant will then present their request.
[0:52:53] The council will then ask questions of the applicant or staff.
[0:52:57] After questions have been asked, the public hearing will then be opened.
[0:53:02] During that time, anyone in attendance is given the opportunity to comment or ask questions
[0:53:08] about the request being considered.
[0:53:10] If you're giving testimony, please step up to the podium, state your name and address
[0:53:16] and present your comments or concern.
[0:53:18] After giving testimony, please sign the public sign-in sheet located in the lobby with your
[0:53:23] name and address for the record.
[0:53:26] After public comments are concluded, the applicant will be invited to answer any questions and
[0:53:31] making a closing statement.
[0:53:35] Staff will then answer, clarify any comments as needed.
[0:53:38] After the closing statements, the public hearing will be closed.
[0:53:42] No further testimony or comments from the applicant or audience will be allowed.
[0:53:47] and then council will have open discussion and take action.
[0:53:51] So on this item we have Jonathan Spennlev, our planning and zoning director.
[0:53:56] Welcome, Jonathan.
[0:53:57] Thank you, Madam Mayor, members of the council.
[0:53:59] This item we are talking about is a, really, it's a drainage basin for the subdivision.
[0:54:07] It's actually in this area that's highlighted.
[0:54:09] Pull line runs to the north, curves down to Eastland.
[0:54:13] This subdivision is all one giant subdivision.
[0:54:16] This was the drainage basin for the whole subdivision when it was originally planted.
[0:54:22] Many of the buildings have been constructed in a few vacant spots. This northeast corner
[0:54:27] purchased by North Canyon Medical recently and they've gone through a process. We've talked
[0:54:32] about this area. This is the easement. We were talking about easement E, the drainage and retention
[0:54:38] easement. Originally part of the subdivision to take a lot of water for the whole area.
[0:54:44] Somebody has purchased this lot which is lot eight and they want to build a building and the building just doesn't quite fit for what they need
[0:54:52] And so they need to just modify easement e we are vacating easement e the owner will then
[0:54:59] Dedicate and easement to the city for the drainage of the street in the subdivision
[0:55:04] Basically changing the drainage of the building can be built and then we just get a new one
[0:55:08] It will accommodate the same amount of water
[0:55:10] water. There won't be any issue either go deeper and wider or longer and the
[0:55:15] engineering firm that's representing them can talk about that if you have any
[0:55:18] questions. That is what we're here for. The vacation will be done through
[0:55:23] ordnance at a later date, your decision tonight, and then kick off the
[0:55:27] ordinance. That is all I have in terms of staff. Okay, thank you. So next the
[0:55:34] applicant, welcome. Madam Mayor, members of the council, my name is Dave Tebow
[0:55:40] with the EHM engineers located at 621 North College Roma Road in Twin Falls. I am representing
[0:55:47] the applicant this evening in their request. Jonathan did a great job. Our firm has been
[0:55:52] retained for the site design of Lot A and we've designed a site layout that includes modification
[0:56:00] of this open swale retention facility. The architects have come up with a plan that lands
[0:56:07] two posts in conflict with the easement and the land value is important
[0:56:12] enough that we want to park over the top of the stormwater retention so we'll
[0:56:15] install a subsurface drywall for the for the stormwater retention and it
[0:56:21] will elongate in the north-south direction and shrink up in the east-west
[0:56:25] direction so this is the first step so that we can move forward with a building
[0:56:30] permit application because the building would land within that easement it would
[0:56:35] draw a red flag with our reviewing agency, the local building department, so we're trying
[0:56:41] to take care of that in advance of submitting for a building permit for a new commercial operation
[0:56:46] there. So we'd ask that you'd vacate it and get that started. I've read through the staff
[0:56:51] report and the condition. The condition is condition that we give you back another easement that
[0:56:56] would supply similar or greater capacity for storm water retention. I'd answer any questions
[0:57:04] that the council might have. Any questions for
[0:57:08] Spencer? Thank you mayor. I was just curious what other lots would be utilizing this
[0:57:17] easement. So this this easement was actually created for the roadway drainage
[0:57:23] and it drains a portion of the commercial property to the south. There's a
[0:57:28] there's a parking lot that drains out to the street as well and it collects the
[0:57:32] stormwater runoff from a couple properties from the south, but primarily
[0:57:37] commissioner Cutler. City Council Member Cutler is roadway drainage, so it's for
[0:57:43] the impervious roadway area. Thank you. You've had a lot more sense now. Yep, you've been.
[0:57:47] Thank you. Any other questions for the applicant or Jonathan? Okay, thank you.
[0:57:57] Thank you. Okay, so I will officially open up the public hearing. This time
[0:58:08] anybody who wishes to get give testimony please step up to the podium state your
[0:58:14] name and address and present your comments and concerns I would ask that
[0:58:18] you hold your comments to three minutes so is there anybody here that wishes to
[0:58:25] speak on this item hey see no one or close the public hearing so there aren't I
[0:58:38] it looks like we're good. So then, Council discussion, questions, thoughts, this read?
[0:58:51] I was just going to say, in preparation for this, I thought, you know, this isn't going
[0:58:58] to be a big topic or a concern. And then, this last weekend happened and all of the rain
[0:59:04] that happened, I thought, oh, this is kind of an interesting thing to have as far as a public
[0:59:08] but with the explanation, understanding that this is not just going away, that water is going to be taken care of.
[0:59:17] I don't have a problem with it at all.
[0:59:19] Thank you. Any other comments? I like the fact you're going to replace it, so we appreciate that.
[0:59:27] So given that, I would entertain a Nicky Boyd.
[0:59:32] Mayor, I move that we grant the request to vacate the drainage stormwater retention
[0:59:37] easement on property located at 2092 Dawson Drive care of EHM engineers on
[0:59:44] behalf of Canyon Village Plaza LLC.
[0:59:48] Thank you. Thank you. Second.
[0:59:51] I have a motion by Nicky Boyd and seconded by Chris Reed to approve the
[0:59:55] vacation of the drainage stormwater retention easement on property located
[1:00:00] at 2092 Dawson Drive. Any further discussion?
[1:00:04] I think we should add the condition in there that a replacement easement is given to us at some point in the future.
[1:00:11] With the recommendations.
[1:00:15] I'll amend your motion. I mean, adapt your motion to include accepting the.
[1:00:22] That's fine.
[1:00:23] Yeah, with a second. Okay. Thank you. Any other discussion? Okay. Amy Roll call vote please.
[1:00:36] Nicky Boyd. Yes, Greg Hawkins. Yes, Spencer Cutler. Yes, Alex Koval. Yes, Pierce. Yes, and Chris Reed. Yes, thank you motion passes six to zero. Hey, thank you.
[1:00:49] Thank you.
[1:00:51] Next item on the agenda is an executive session under Code Section 742061B to consider both
[1:01:04] of those or just the one now.
[1:01:07] I'll go through both of them to consider the evaluation, dismissal or disciplining of
[1:01:12] or to hear complaints or charges brought against the public officer, employee, staff member
[1:01:17] or individual agent or public school student, and E to consider preliminary negotiations involving
[1:01:24] matters of trade or comish in which the governing body is in competition with governing bodies
[1:01:30] in other states or nations.
[1:01:33] So moved.
[1:01:34] Thank you.
[1:01:35] Second.
[1:01:36] Motion by Alex Kaval, seconded by Chris Reed to move into executive session under 742061B and
[1:01:45] E.
[1:01:46] Amy Roll call vote please. Craig Hawkins. Yes. Spencer Cutler. Yes. Alex Cabal. Yes. Ruth Pierce. Yes. Chris Reed. Yes. Thank you Boyd. Yes. Thank you. Motion passes 6 to 0. Okay. Just let everybody know we will not be making any decisions in executive session and we will not reconvene so meeting is adjourned. Thank you.
