Oversight Archive: City Council meeting, 2023-12-04, recording 1 (started 16:59)
Machine transcript (faster-whisper base.en), not checked word for word; the Pledge of Allegiance is shown in its standard wording. The recording is the record.
Times are time into the recording. Passages with private details are muted in the audio and marked here.
The audio on the page below was re-encoded by software from the video the agency posted. Check any passage against
that audio before relying on it.
Page: https://oversightarchive.org/twin-falls-id/meetings/2023-12-04/

[0:01:05] Good evening, ladies and gentlemen, and welcome to the December 4,
[0:01:09] 2023 City Council meeting.
[0:01:12] I want to confirm we have a quorum.
[0:01:14] We have all seven council members present in chambers.
[0:01:18] First item on the agenda is the Pledge of Allegiance.
[0:01:21] If you wish to join me, please rise.
[0:01:23] Thank you. We have no proclamation,
[0:01:43] so we'll move right to the consent calendar.
[0:01:45] Council wishes.
[0:01:47] Move to approve the consent calendar.
[0:01:49] Thank you.
[0:01:50] Second.
[0:01:50] Thank you motion by Chris Reed seconded by Alex Kaval to approve the consent calendar as written
[0:01:58] Amy roll call vote, please
[0:02:00] Pierce yes
[0:02:11] Thank you motion passes seven to zero so if you were here for the jump time alcohol license or the special event permit for the life
[0:02:20] native activity event those have both been approved. So next under items of
[0:02:26] consideration is a request to confirm the city manager's appointment of
[0:02:30] Kristen Kontop to the position of human resource director and we have our city
[0:02:35] manager Travis Rothweiler welcome Travis. Thank you Madam Mayor members of the
[0:02:40] City Council. We'll have two appointments tonight. I'm the first of
[0:02:45] Kristen and the second of Craig Kingsbury both I'll be asking for
[0:02:48] confirmation this evening. But what I thought I would do is start at the very
[0:02:52] beginning and talk about the legal process that we have in moving forward.
[0:02:56] So there are a series of sections of whether it be Idaho Code or the Too
[0:03:02] Involved Municipal Code that govern the actions that we're about to take tonight.
[0:03:07] Idaho Code 5811 defines the role of a city manager in the state of Idaho. And under
[0:03:15] that section it says, among the enumerated duties, she'll make appointments of all
[0:03:19] department heads subject to civil service regulations that may be attached here
[0:03:23] too. The first to know is that we don't follow civil service regulations inside
[0:03:28] of the city of Twin Falls and number two, the other regulations that we have are
[0:03:32] any appointment of the city manager requires confirmation by a majority
[0:03:38] vote of the Twin Falls city council. And that is firmly described in Twin Falls
[0:03:44] municipal code 1-2-3, where it states the city council and its members shall deal
[0:03:52] with the administrative services through and only through the city manager, except
[0:03:56] for the purposes of inquiry. And either the city council and our members shall give
[0:04:00] any subordinates or directives to accept forth through the city manager and the
[0:04:06] responsibility of the council is to assist and aid in advisory capacity of all
[0:04:10] department heads and to appoint them upon or to confirm them upon the city
[0:04:17] manager's recommendation for appointment. And so we're going to do that this
[0:04:22] evening and these are two positions under Twin Falls City Code that fall
[0:04:27] under those requirements the chief of police and burst the human resource
[0:04:32] director. And that group that we ask you to appoint is it referred to internally as
[0:04:39] the city's executive leadership team. And that team helps and aids me in the day-to-day
[0:04:49] management of the city of Twin Falls. As we continue to grow, as we continue to become more
[0:04:54] complex in our operations, as there are more responsibilities that are placed onto the role
[0:05:02] of the city manager, it really does become almost too big for one person, for the organization to
[0:05:07] to be successful at the level that we expect and at what our citizens expect.
[0:05:13] And I'm able to do the things that I can do because of the great team that I've been
[0:05:18] able to have surrounding me and to help me lead and manage this city.
[0:05:25] And the first person I'd like to officially add to the team this evening with your concurrence
[0:05:30] is Kristin Konta.
[0:05:34] I won't ask Kristin to come stand next to me.
[0:05:39] But I want to tell you a little bit about Kristin, and then she'll clearly be available
[0:05:43] for any questions that you might have.
[0:05:46] But Kristin is not a stranger to our organization as she has been a part of our family since August
[0:05:53] of 2017.
[0:05:56] And inside of our organization, she has served a variety of roles.
[0:06:01] She has been instrumental in many of our processes.
[0:06:04] She first started as a recruiting coordinator and then after I'm in that role she became
[0:06:11] our benefits coordinator and after Gretchen was promoted and we had a vacancy inside of
[0:06:19] our HR position, she applied for that role and she competed amazingly.
[0:06:30] over a period of time that vacancy rose again and it was very clear to me that the right
[0:06:37] candidate at the right time was Kristin to be filled into this role.
[0:06:43] She has, we've allowed her some time to run her toast through the bath water, if you will,
[0:06:49] and where she has been serving in interim capacity for a little bit of time and in that
[0:06:56] time, which is also the busiest time that we have inside of human resources as we're looking
[0:07:03] at benefits, alignment, making sure that compensation adjustments are moving forward and just working
[0:07:12] through a myriad of personnel issues. She has performed brilliantly. She has certainly exceeded
[0:07:21] all of our expectations. And inside of your packet, we provided you not only the things
[0:07:25] that she's done as part of our organization,
[0:07:28] but also part of her resume.
[0:07:31] But what's not said here is the person that she is.
[0:07:36] She's kind, she has tremendous empathy,
[0:07:41] and she has tremendous love for our organization
[0:07:44] and the people who work here.
[0:07:46] She demonstrates and has the qualities
[0:07:49] that leaders want to surround themselves with
[0:07:52] because she's truly passionate and cares about what she does.
[0:07:56] And so it is my pleasure and my request to submit the name of Kristin Kontop to you
[0:08:04] or the position of Human Resource Director for the City of Twin Falls.
[0:08:09] And I'd be happy to answer any questions, and Kristin is here too,
[0:08:14] and we'll encourage her to answer questions as well.
[0:08:17] Nicky Boyd.
[0:08:19] That went through fast.
[0:08:22] I was just going to say if we're ready for emotion,
[0:08:24] for a motion. I don't know. Do we want to let's see if anybody has any questions for either
[0:08:29] Travis or Kristen. Just one. Let's see. A hard one. You ask an HR person a question.
[0:08:40] They might have a response for you. That's always concerning. That's a well trained
[0:08:46] individual right there. Answer. Did you have something? I don't have a question but I have a
[0:08:52] comment. Go ahead. I just want to say that before I was a member of council as just a citizen
[0:08:57] the community. I was on a hiring committee representing certain citizen interests and Kristen coordinated
[0:09:04] that and she was very professional and that was probably four years ago and I know she's
[0:09:09] even grown since then so I'm happy to have her on the team.
[0:09:13] Thank you. Okay Nikki.
[0:09:16] Well Kristen is such a pleasure to work with always. You are. And I would love to make the
[0:09:24] motion to confirm the city manager's appointment of Kristin
[0:09:28] Kontop to the position of our human resource director Jason
[0:09:32] Brown.
[0:09:33] I'll second it.
[0:09:34] Thank you motion by Nicky boys seconded by Jason Brown to
[0:09:37] confirm the city manager's appointment of Kristin Kontop to
[0:09:41] the position of human resource director.
[0:09:45] Amy roll call vote please.
[0:09:47] Chris Reed.
[0:09:48] Yes.
[0:09:48] Thank you Boyd.
[0:09:49] Yes.
[0:09:50] Greg Hawkins.
[0:09:51] Yes Jason Brown.
[0:09:52] Yes.
[0:09:53] Alex Cabal. Definitely yes. It's Spencer Cutler. Yes. And Ruth Pierce. Yes. Thank you. Motion passes 7-0.
[0:10:01] So Madam Mayor, before we move to the next one, I believe it would be appropriate to do these
[0:10:06] oaths individually. And so if we could have you administer the oath to Kristen.
[0:11:35] Thank you Council and Mayor. I'm very excited for this opportunity. I would like to introduce
[0:11:40] Here's my family here tonight. I have my husband, Jake, and my mother, and father-in-law, Doug
[0:11:46] and Jackie in the back, and my parents are watching online tonight.
[0:11:49] Congratulations. Thank you. Madam Mayor, before I move to the next one, I would be remissed
[0:12:03] if I didn't also publicly thank Gretchen Scott. So whenever you go through a process and you
[0:12:09] change over into a new role when she left over from the Human Resource Department to the Deputy
[0:12:16] city manager, she had coaching and mentoring responsibilities, and then when the vacancy
[0:12:21] occurred, she essentially pulled double duty as she was trying to really raise and get
[0:12:25] Kristin to a space of being to where she was. And so our organization is successful because
[0:12:32] we have people like Kristin that were able to appoint, but we also have people like Gretchen
[0:12:37] who are profoundly dedicated and are willing to go above and beyond always. I just want
[0:12:44] publically thank her for all of her effort during that window of time and now you can have your job back here here
[0:12:50] Thank you, Gretchen
[0:12:58] You want to talk Gretchen at all? You want to say anything?
[0:13:02] I guess there are no hair jokes. Yes
[0:13:07] So for those of the kids in you to follow along
[0:13:10] You'll remember that this way well
[0:13:14] Okay, so the next item on the agenda is an action item. It's request to confirm the city manager's
[0:13:20] Appointment of Craig Kingsbury to the position of police chief. Welcome Travis again. Thank you. And I went through
[0:13:28] Part of the process that we have and the reason that we're here and obviously
[0:13:33] The second appointment is one that is also of someone who's very familiar
[0:13:39] not only in the role but also in our organization and
[0:13:43] Chief Kingsbury will he was with not only the city of Napa before but also with the
[0:13:50] City of Twin Falls is always demonstrated the ability to lead, the ability to be innovative
[0:13:59] in thought, the ability to guide and marshal resources for the protection of our community.
[0:14:10] In July of this past year, the Idaho legislature adopted code 59-1302 subsection 14, which
[0:14:21] allowed for public safety employees the opportunity to retire and upon after that retirement they
[0:14:31] had the option of exploring whether they wanted to make that retirement permanent or to determine
[0:14:38] whether or not they wanted to come back.
[0:14:42] Greg spent some time away.
[0:14:43] He understood that when he retired from our organization there was no guarantee and there
[0:14:49] was no commitment that he would come back. The only commitment that we had was that we
[0:14:55] would be open to having a conversation. And Craig spent some time away. He was able to
[0:15:01] recharge. And if you see him sitting back there with his lovely bride, Loretta, he certainly
[0:15:06] looks a little bit more relaxed than the rest of us, right? Six weeks, we'll maybe do that
[0:15:13] for you. But in that period of time and in the conversation that I had with Greg, he
[0:15:20] recognized that he still had more offer, that he still has ideas and a commitment to service
[0:15:29] for our community that he wanted to see through. We had a conversation and we wanted to make
[0:15:37] sure, we wanted to make sure that he was coming back for the right reasons and service
[0:15:46] of the community, and in my conversation with him, I am convinced that he is coming back
[0:15:53] for all of the right reasons, and that reason is to continue leading the Twin Falls Police
[0:15:59] Department and to continue serving and protecting the citizens of the city of Twin Falls. It
[0:16:07] is with that and an individual who has my full faith and confidence that I recommend
[0:16:14] the name of Craig Kingsbury to the position of Chief of Police for the City of Twin Falls
[0:16:21] for your consideration. Mr. Kingsbury is also in the audience and available for questioning.
[0:16:29] Chris Reed, Craig's not HR, so I'm going to ask him some questions.
[0:16:33] Well, you're coming up, having the opportunity to step away for six weeks and evaluate things
[0:16:43] and to have that period of time, I would love to hear what your thoughts and impressions
[0:16:47] during those six weeks that drove you to ultimately have the desire to come back.
[0:16:52] Thank you, Councilman Reed, Mayor, members of the City Council.
[0:16:59] Honestly, I had a great six weeks. I did some traveling with my wife,
[0:17:04] customer time with family, but I missed the work. I missed the opportunity to serve
[0:17:13] I missed the opportunity to work with this team and found myself missing what was going
[0:17:23] on and feeling like I still had a lot to give.
[0:17:27] And if my career wasn't going to continue here with the City of Twin Falls, I may have looked
[0:17:33] somewhere else because at this point in time I decided that I'm not ready to retire on
[0:17:38] a full-time basis.
[0:17:40] I had fun, but a lot of international travel
[0:17:43] will worry out, so ready to get back and get back
[0:17:47] in the saddle, so to speak.
[0:17:50] I would say that during my absence,
[0:17:53] I know we've had a few major incense of crime that have happened,
[0:17:58] but I, as a resident, had the full faith and trust
[0:18:02] in the men and women of the Twin Falls Police Department
[0:18:05] and their partners.
[0:18:09] And also, I would like to take a moment to publicly thank the acting chief of police, Matthew Hicks.
[0:18:15] I think he did a wonderful job in that role while I was gone.
[0:18:21] And I think we're very blessed, the city of Twin Falls, to have people like Matt Hicks
[0:18:27] that have the ability to step into that role if and when it's needed and maybe even into the future for him.
[0:18:36] So I hope that answers your question, Councilman.
[0:18:39] It does, thank you.
[0:18:40] Craig Hawkins.
[0:18:42] Chief, I just was wondering over the last six weeks
[0:18:45] if you could confirm or not confirm
[0:18:47] that all your travels was done on a Harley.
[0:18:50] Yeah.
[0:18:52] Councilman Hawkins, none of my travels were done on a Harley.
[0:18:56] But I did visit a very neat Harley shop in Dublin, Ireland
[0:18:59] and got a few t-shirts.
[0:19:00] So that kind of counts.
[0:19:02] That kind of counts.
[0:19:03] That's right.
[0:19:05] Anybody else?
[0:19:08] Well, I, Chris Reed.
[0:19:10] I'll make the appointment.
[0:19:12] OK.
[0:19:13] Mary, move that we confirm the city manager's appointment
[0:19:16] of Craig King's very to the position of police chief.
[0:19:20] Thank you, Jason Brown.
[0:19:21] I'll second that.
[0:19:22] Great.
[0:19:22] Motion by Chris Reed, seconded by Jason Brown
[0:19:25] to confirm the city manager's appointment of Craig King's
[0:19:29] very to the position of police chief.
[0:19:32] Amy Roll call vote, please.
[0:19:35] Nicky Boyd.
[0:19:36] Yes.
[0:19:36] Craig Hawkins, Jason Brown, Alex Cavall,
[0:19:41] Spencer Cutler, Ruth Pierce, and Chris Reed.
[0:19:45] Yes. Thank you. Motion passes 7-0.
[0:19:48] Did you have something? I do.
[0:19:50] Welcome back. We're excited to have you, but to Matthew Hicks.
[0:19:54] Thank you. Thank you for all the work that you did during this time.
[0:19:57] I know there's a lot going on, so thank you for everything.
[0:20:00] He even took the big snowflakes on Friday night at the braid for you.
[0:20:06] Whereas you're coming down Travis did remind me to introduce my wife Loretta
[0:20:15] I think everybody knows her but I want to thank her for being supportive of me throughout my career and as I take on this I
[0:20:23] Guess kind of new role. I take it. This is day one
[0:20:28] It's kind of day zero
[0:20:31] Day one starts at eight o'clock tomorrow. I actually I know I'm meeting with captain Higgs after this to go over a few things too
[0:20:38] So, day zero.
[0:20:40] Madam Mayor, members of the Council, if I could take up just a moment of privilege real quick
[0:22:13] to thank Matt Hicks as well.
[0:22:19] I will tell you that when you look at an individual and he willingly accepts that role and position,
[0:22:28] and then you recognize the things that he has led through over the course of the last several weeks,
[0:22:36] weeks. He's done an amazing job. He has my full faith and confidence and had the
[0:22:45] conversation with Craig turned out differently. As I've shared with Matt at
[0:22:49] someday I hope to be the one that gets to point him and move him forward. He's
[0:22:57] brilliant. We're lucky to have people like Matt Hicks. He is genuine. He is
[0:23:04] thoughtful. He is committed to our organization and I cannot thank him enough
[0:23:13] for his tenure in that role and I look forward to many years of service with him.
[0:23:20] Thank you, Matt. Thank you. So the next item on the agenda is an action item a
[0:23:34] request to utilize City Reserves to cover additional costs with the purchase
[0:23:39] of a new plotter for the engineering department and we have our city engineer Troy the tech
[0:23:45] welcome Troy. Thank you Madam Mayor and City Councilor. So our process is long our budgeting
[0:23:52] process and this starts way in February so we have to kind of anticipate what we need.
[0:23:57] We started with going out to vendors in this case we needed a plotter ours was aging in
[0:24:03] fact the front now we're kind of on the bambaya on another plotter making it work but we start
[0:24:10] that process in February we reached out to vendors say what's the cost of one of
[0:24:13] these and haven't installed in February. If you go through the budget here it's
[0:24:18] approved come October 1st if council approves the budget and our capital item
[0:24:23] is in there we go forth and contact these people. We recently did that
[0:24:28] unfortunately the owner of the company Bonifil blueprint got bought out and the
[0:24:34] time frame between then and now with inflation as it is the prices have
[0:24:38] escalated and we didn't anticipate that and we didn't inflate the original cost
[0:24:42] we just put what they had in there anyway. Our request tonight is essentially trying
[0:24:48] to make up that difference so we can utilize the the plotter. There are
[0:24:52] options we can't go out and pay other facilities it's just an efficiency
[0:24:58] thing we have fire department coming to us please often comes to us to do maps
[0:25:02] and stuff and then we have our own stuff I believe this is a better to have a
[0:25:06] physically in our office and just be able to utilize all the time. So our
[0:25:11] recommendation is to award this or allow us to use reserves to cover the difference
[0:25:15] in cost and go forth. So if you have any questions, I'd be happy to answer them.
[0:25:20] Any questions? Jason Brown. I don't have any questions but I'll wait. Anybody else have any questions?
[0:25:27] Go ahead Jason. Thank you. I'd move to approve the request to utilize city reserves
[0:25:33] to cover additional costs to purchase a new plotter for the engineering department.
[0:25:38] Oh, second.
[0:25:39] Thank you.
[0:25:40] A motion by Jason Brown, seconded by Nicky Boyd to use City Reserves, do we need the dollar
[0:25:46] amount?
[0:25:47] Probably.
[0:25:48] On my question, when I said.
[0:25:49] City Reserves of $4,499.41 to cover the additional costs with the purchase of the new plotter for
[0:25:58] the engineering department.
[0:25:59] That's a set price, right?
[0:26:02] It is a direct quote that is still locked up for 90 days, so it is good quote.
[0:26:07] Okay.
[0:26:10] So do you want to amend your motion?
[0:26:11] I can amend it for the use of reserves for the amount of $4,499.41.
[0:26:17] Is that good?
[0:26:20] Okay.
[0:26:21] It's been moved and seconded to utilize city reserves of $4,491.99.41 towards the purchase
[0:26:30] of a new plotter for the engineering department.
[0:26:33] Alex, come up.
[0:26:34] Troy, I had a question.
[0:26:36] Is the 32,000 the current average going right for these things?
[0:26:40] I mean, I'm not familiar with plotters,
[0:26:41] but is this unusual for this device, or is this pretty common
[0:26:44] for the going right for this equipment?
[0:26:48] This is a pretty robust piece of equipment.
[0:26:51] It's not your office max or whatever.
[0:26:53] So it is a going price for the option
[0:26:56] that we chose in this case, which is capable of printing
[0:26:59] that's a paper and thanks anybody else before we vote
[0:27:07] Amy roll call vote please Craig hockens yes Jason Brown yes Alex Kaval yes
[0:27:17] mentor Cutler yes yes Chris Reed yes and Nicky Boyd yes thank you motion passes
[0:27:24] seven to zero thank you thank you Troy okay next that we're done with items under consideration
[0:27:35] next item on the agenda. It's agenda, excuse me, is general public input. It's a time for
[0:27:41] anybody in the public who wishes to address City Council and come down to the microphone.
[0:27:47] If you do, on any item that is not on today's agenda, if you do please come down the microphone
[0:27:54] and state your name and whether you're a resident of Twin Falls and then proceed with your input.
[0:28:00] Or anybody out there that wants to address City Council tonight
[0:28:05] Okay, see no one
[0:28:09] advisory board reports
[0:28:16] So we're just going to continue to make sure that we're over communicating with our community in our residents that next Tuesday is the city's
[0:28:31] annual organizational meeting and
[0:28:35] Several of our buildings will be closed
[0:28:37] to the general public for that day and so we are communicating that early. We're
[0:28:43] sharing out releases and we're going to do everything that we can to get cut up so
[0:28:47] that we can come together as an organization really talk about the
[0:28:51] strategic visioning of the organization in the upcoming years. So again, not this
[0:28:57] Tuesday but the following Tuesday we will be needing next Monday in a city
[0:29:01] council meeting but just want to make sure that we're providing that week's
[0:29:04] notice to citizens as they recognize this city hall and other
[0:29:09] ancillary buildings will be closed on that day.
[0:29:12] Thank you.
[0:29:14] Okay, we have no public hearings tonight.
[0:29:17] So the final item is executive section under action item 74-2-061-B
[0:29:25] to consider the evaluation dismissal or disciplining of or
[0:29:29] to hear complaints or charges against a public officer employees,
[0:29:33] staff member or individual agent or public school student. So moved. Thank you.
[0:29:39] Second. Motion by Chris Reed second by Jason Brown to move into executive
[0:29:44] session under 742061B. Amy Rokalvo please. Jason Brown. Yes. Alex Koval. Yes.
[0:29:53] Spencer Cutler. Yes. Ruth Pierce. Yes. Chris Reed. Yes. Hickey Boyd. Yes.
[0:29:59] and Craig Hawkins. Yes. Thank you. Motion passes seven to zero. So we will not be coming back to
[0:30:06] council chambers after our executive session. So our meeting is adjourned. Thank you everyone.
