Oversight Archive: City Council meeting, 2024-01-08, recording 1 (started 16:59)
Machine transcript (faster-whisper base.en), not checked word for word; the Pledge of Allegiance is shown in its standard wording. The recording is the record.
Times are time into the recording. Passages with private details are muted in the audio and marked here.
The audio on the page below was re-encoded by software from the video the agency posted. Check any passage against
that audio before relying on it.
Page: https://oversightarchive.org/twin-falls-id/meetings/2024-01-08/

[0:01:47] Good evening, ladies and gentlemen, and welcome to the January 8th
[0:01:52] 2024 City Council meeting. I want to confirm we have a quorum. We have all seven members present in chambers
[0:02:00] First item on the agenda is the Pledge of Allegiance. If you wish to join me, please rise
[0:02:05] Thank you. We have no proclamations tonight
[0:02:27] So first item on the agenda then is the next item is the consent calendar
[0:02:33] Council wishes
[0:02:34] Here I'm like to give a motion that we approve the consent calendar is written. Thank you. Do I have a second?
[0:02:42] Second
[0:02:43] Thank you motion by Craig Hawkins second by Jason Brown to approve the consent calendar as written Amy roll call vote, please
[0:02:54] Proof peers. Yes, please read. Yes, Craig Hawkins. Yes, Jason Brown. Yes, Spencer Cutler. Yes, Jerry Volmer. Yes, Grayson Stone
[0:03:04] Yes, thank you. Motion passes 7 to 0. Next, under items of consideration and action item,
[0:03:13] are we quest to reallocate 45,000 in pool capital funds savings from the DEC resurfacing
[0:03:21] project to the pool circulation project, and we have John Hawley, director of the pool.
[0:03:27] Welcome, John.
[0:03:28] Well, thank you. Good evening. How's everybody tonight?
[0:03:32] Thank you. So whenever we want to reallocate funds from one budgeted item to another, we need to go through console and get console's approval.
[0:03:41] So that's why I'm here tonight. So our background goes into detail as to what we're requesting.
[0:03:47] We'd like to move $45,000 from that deck project to put it into the circulation project so that we're able to complete that project fully when we shut down here at the end of February.
[0:03:58] And with that, I'll take any questions that you may have.
[0:04:05] So John, just for the audience, do you want to go in just a little bit more detail on how
[0:04:11] we have the funds available in the kind of three-year staff report?
[0:04:15] Yes, sure.
[0:04:16] So the funds became available when we went through our fiscal year 2024 budget.
[0:04:21] We allocated $100,000 for our resurfacing project and we threw some conversations and
[0:04:26] changes in looking at different contractors.
[0:04:28] We decided to go down a different path and we tested this path out and we believe this
[0:04:33] is the path to go for the pool so we should have a nice textured deck that should actually
[0:04:37] have some standing in it to make it look quite a bit better.
[0:04:40] Fortunately, that price came down quite a bit from the original quotes we had gotten when
[0:04:45] we first went through the budgeting process so that leaves some funds available.
[0:04:49] In another area where we weren't quite sure what was going to happen with the – we weren't
[0:04:54] expecting the pump the pipe reconfiguration project to be is what it was so we decided
[0:04:59] to put that to the side do more things that we know we needed to get done first and if
[0:05:05] we were able to if funds became available through this or what if we needed to go back next year
[0:05:10] and ask that's what we were going to do so with the funds remaining on the deck project we would
[0:05:16] like to use those funds, push that recirculation project from 100 to about $145,000, so that
[0:05:24] should allow us to complete that project in its entirety, especially since we're still working
[0:05:28] on gathering some numbers for that project.
[0:05:32] We just know that if we did that $45,000 project, there's no way we could finish that project
[0:05:36] the way the stuff we had to get done first.
[0:05:39] Okay.
[0:05:40] All right.
[0:05:41] Chris Reed.
[0:05:42] you mentioned that this would happen during February is at the timetable for
[0:05:46] for all of this to be completed. Yeah so we're looking at closing the week
[0:05:49] after exciting it's the week after president's day so like February 26th
[0:05:53] the last week of February and we're looking at being down for about a month.
[0:05:56] Okay. Thank you. You're welcome. Jason Brown. Yeah so John so savings from the
[0:06:04] decking the decking meaning the the walking area outside of the pool is that
[0:06:08] correct? The whole deck inside the bubble. Inside the bubble. Yes and some
[0:06:12] depth markers replacing those with fresh markers. So we're with have safety markings along the way too.
[0:06:18] Okay and then so take this money and and put it into some of the recirculation, the pump, the chemical
[0:06:28] part of the building, is that correct? That's correct. Yes. So I'm ready to make a motion if
[0:06:33] we're ready to go. I would move that we reallocate $45,000 in pool capital
[0:06:40] from the deck resurfacing project to the pool circulation project.
[0:06:45] Thank you. Do I have a second?
[0:06:47] I'll second.
[0:06:48] Thank you. Motion by Jason Brown, seconded by Grayson Stone
[0:06:52] to approve the reallocation of 45,000 in pool capital funds
[0:06:57] from the deck resurfacing project to the pool circulation project.
[0:07:02] Any further discussion? Amy Roll call vote please.
[0:07:07] Chris Reed?
[0:07:08] Yes.
[0:07:09] Greg Hawkins?
[0:07:10] Case in Brown. Yes.
[0:07:13] Yes.
[0:07:14] Yes.
[0:07:15] Yes.
[0:07:16] Yes.
[0:07:17] Yes.
[0:07:18] Yes.
[0:07:19] Yes.
[0:07:20] Yes.
[0:07:21] Yes.
[0:07:22] Yes.
[0:07:23] Yes.
[0:07:24] Yes.
[0:07:25] Thank you.
[0:07:26] Thank you.
[0:07:27] Thank you, John.
[0:07:28] Hey, next item on the agenda is an action item.
[0:07:31] A request to defer required improvements for building permit 22-0100 due to exceptional hardship, care of Brooke Redmond on behalf of Rob Green Hyundai.
[0:07:39] Monday and we have Jonathan spend love our planning and zoning director to
[0:07:44] start us out. Welcome, Jonathan. Thank you, Mayor, members of the Council. This is the
[0:07:49] staff report that was included with the packet. I'm just going to do a very brief
[0:07:52] overview of what we're doing tonight. This is a starting off. This particular
[0:07:59] request has never come before a City Council of the City of Twin Falls in any
[0:08:04] record that I could find from the last 25 plus years. So, I'm going to be clear what's
[0:08:09] being asked tonight is a sort of precedent setting decision. Since we've never had it,
[0:08:16] the decision made tonight is that we've never done it before, so those going forward will
[0:08:20] be looking at this decision. How we got here, the background on this permit is in the background
[0:08:29] in the history. The permit was from 22, which means it was issued in 2022 sometime in February.
[0:08:35] And I think it's more clearly defined in the history right here. It's January. They requested us
[0:08:42] to review the permit. We issued it in March. And then we had a September 22, a planning and zoning
[0:08:48] commission approval for landscape violence to be moved and grouped to a different location. On the
[0:08:53] 19th, we had to change order number one, change order number two. And then we kind of go through
[0:08:57] those as the time progresses up until July with the plan showing the parking
[0:09:04] island grouping and then we had a final request sorry a request for final inspection
[0:09:10] December 27th it was around that December 28th and 9th that we performed the final
[0:09:17] inspection at that point I believe the council was updated on the item so that
[0:09:23] was an email from me saying here's where we were on the item that was immediately
[0:09:27] after that we received the request which would have put this into a, it's a
[0:09:33] request on a certain property, so it's sort of a quasi-judicial decision. We're
[0:09:37] talking about a certain property, not a legislative act that applies to everybody.
[0:09:40] Certainly the decision you're making would be precedent-setting for everybody to
[0:09:44] look at, but in this case you're talking about a certain piece of property, so
[0:09:48] you're kind of in your quasi-judicial hat. The request stems from Title 10, which is
[0:09:55] the zoning and development chapter or zoning development title chapter 11 has
[0:10:01] required improvements this is an excerpt it's not the entire thing but
[0:10:05] there's a full paragraph the improvements required herein shall be
[0:10:09] provided whenever a building or structure is constructed place directed or in
[0:10:12] larger when there is a change of use of a building structure or parcel of land
[0:10:15] and then there whenever a building is constructed place erected or in large
[0:10:20] and that building is not sorry and that building is in and isolated or
[0:10:24] undeveloped area, separate thought is, or in cases of exceptional hardship,
[0:10:31] improvements may be deferred by the council, in cases where deferral would
[0:10:35] otherwise be unavailable. Title 10 chapter 11 contains the number of items that are
[0:10:42] required whenever you change properties. The list, which I didn't pull up the code
[0:10:48] from memory is usually streets, landscaping, storm water, trash enclosure,
[0:10:57] items like that. There's seven items total. Three of them or a few of them can be
[0:11:06] deferred for other reasons, like if the project isn't big enough, meaning it's
[0:11:10] not expanding over 25% of the property or the cost of them is too much. This
[0:11:15] This project did not meet any of those other exemptions.
[0:11:20] One of the items landscaping has an exemption written into it for the current planting season.
[0:11:26] So if you're planting in the winter and you can't get the materials or you can't plant
[0:11:30] them, we can issue a temporary certificate of occupancy for a building or a property,
[0:11:35] but we cannot extend beyond the next planting season.
[0:11:40] So if we got one for today, we can issue a temporary for the building and property, but
[0:11:45] We can't extend that temporary beyond, basically, next September, that's what the code would
[0:11:50] say.
[0:11:51] All the other items require this to be done prior to occupancy of the building, which means
[0:12:01] the items that are listed with this request, I'm going to open that up, are all the items
[0:12:06] that are not available for a deferral per the code, unless the situation meets the requirement
[0:12:14] or the wording of exceptional hardship.
[0:12:19] There's no definition of exceptional hardship
[0:12:21] in Twin Falls City Code.
[0:12:23] A lot of places don't have definitions
[0:12:26] of exceptional hardship.
[0:12:27] We know what a hardship would be.
[0:12:29] So in that case, generally you go
[0:12:31] with just the dictionary term of exceptional.
[0:12:36] If you wish, I'll give you my definition
[0:12:37] as a zoning administrator,
[0:12:38] what exceptional hardship would be for me, if you wish.
[0:12:43] The items that they're requesting,
[0:12:45] I'll open that.
[0:12:50] Is this list?
[0:12:56] This list was enumerated by Samuel Leary
[0:12:59] with the engineering department.
[0:13:00] The number one area is this part right here
[0:13:03] is what was on the building permit,
[0:13:04] which is a group island landscaping that they had moved
[0:13:10] from what would be the west area of the parking lot
[0:13:12] to the east side, which is closer to homes.
[0:13:16] That landscaped area and the trash enclosure,
[0:13:19] which the trash enclosure is supposed to be
[0:13:22] screening material. In this case it was planned to be a CMU traction closure with
[0:13:27] a gate. That area is being deferred along with the landscape plantings for the
[0:13:32] trees and shrubs, the curbing and the landscaped area, along with the parking
[0:13:37] stalls and the parking striping. So that was number one was the landscaping
[0:13:44] number two is the traction closure. Number three was the accessible route from
[0:13:51] the public way. This is a picture of the location. This is the plan set right
[0:13:56] here and then what's on the right is the basically a Google Earth image of the
[0:14:01] location. This ADA accessibility route from the public
[0:14:07] ways required on the picture it would come from here up through these parking
[0:14:12] through the cars and then run almost where the front tires are or right in front of
[0:14:16] the vehicles right here. Get to this point and then take a left or north to the
[0:14:23] building. That area would need to meet the accessibility route with some
[0:14:29] cross-slips and all that as well as be striped so that they get to know where
[0:14:33] people are going to go if you're in a wheelchair or other accessibility limited
[0:14:37] accessibility area. Number four, we have some stormwater issues. The roof drains a
[0:14:49] certain way and has the stormwater runoff to the what would be the
[0:14:53] the landscaped area or the hard surface area on the north and south of the building.
[0:15:00] That area, well, we believe might have been modified during the plan, but we don't have
[0:15:07] a change order yet that was approved and constructed.
[0:15:09] It has to do with basically the stormwater area in the back and getting the water from
[0:15:15] the building to the rear of the property, which is on the east side.
[0:15:19] It all contains going either through rain gutters or sheet draining off of the asphalt.
[0:15:25] back to the rear of the property and I'm going down to see if I can find the
[0:15:30] picture of where that gets to because all of this has to do with the stormwater area.
[0:15:34] This is the rear of the property. The building is just off the picture here.
[0:15:41] This is where there is supposed to be a stormwater swale.
[0:15:45] What had been used when we did our inspection was
[0:15:50] construction waste which is the concrete and asphalt
[0:15:54] and asphalt that was being milled or crushed into usable base, they planned on using that on the property.
[0:16:03] The area in this spot is where the swale is supposed to be to accommodate the stormwater.
[0:16:11] And that's not constructed.
[0:16:14] I believe they are in the middle of trying to move those items and get the stormwater to work for the air for the water that does get there.
[0:16:22] And then there is some additional parking maneuvering areas that need to be paved
[0:16:28] Per the code. I'm trying to see if that's all of it
[0:16:34] The rest of this is there's construction area that needs to be there
[0:16:39] closed off or fenced so that it prickly is people from getting into the construction area
[0:16:44] That's just a normal practice if they're doing that. That was just denoted. There were some other minor items
[0:16:53] meter like a water meter
[0:16:55] And some of these other items that weren't finished
[0:16:59] also have to do with that. All 17 of those items are the items that are being asked
[0:17:06] for deferment. And we don't have that in our packet correct? No this was this was
[0:17:12] emailed to the applicant to make sure that this is the items they wanted to be
[0:17:15] deferred. I got confirmation from them on Friday, late Friday, and now I have it
[0:17:24] here. It would be part of the record and I can get it to you. Thank you. The other item
[0:17:30] that I asked for was a time frame for the items to be accomplished. I did not get an answer
[0:17:35] on the time frame when I requested that last Thursday. But don't have a time frame for deferment
[0:17:42] or a time frame for when these items will be accomplished.
[0:17:49] Jason.
[0:17:50] Jonathan, thanks. Can you bring that back up? Sorry.
[0:17:55] So really what, so as you were talking, I have a couple of questions, but also, so what's
[0:18:02] It's really being asked of the council tonight to postpone these action items or to, when
[0:18:09] I hear the term exceptional hardship or some of that, it's like, hey, we just don't want
[0:18:14] to do these types of things.
[0:18:16] Are we deferring it or postponing it until the weather gets a little bit better that they
[0:18:19] can put striping on the ground, come back and pave?
[0:18:23] Or is it a truly, we just don't want to do these things?
[0:18:27] I believe in this case, they are asking a defer to a later date.
[0:18:31] I don't have that later date.
[0:18:34] The items that are listed here, these 17 items, normally are required per Title X, Chapter 11,
[0:18:41] to be finished prior to us issuing a Certificate of Occupancy, the exception being trees and
[0:18:46] shrubs.
[0:18:47] We give temporary certificates for those and allow that to be installed at a later date because
[0:18:53] You know, they don't have water on the property or it's
[0:18:55] sure easing the grounds frozen.
[0:18:57] The rest of those items are all required normally in the code
[0:19:01] to be done prior to us issuing even a temporary certificate
[0:19:04] to be in a building or use the property.
[0:19:06] So what they're requesting is an exceptional hardship
[0:19:10] with a later date to be installed,
[0:19:12] but I don't have that date.
[0:19:13] Okay, so then, so on the building application,
[0:19:17] on the permit, it was pretty clearly defined
[0:19:21] that these requirements needed to be done before.
[0:19:25] We would give at least a temporary
[0:19:27] or a permanent occupancy.
[0:19:29] Yeah, these are the pictures
[0:19:30] that were from the building permit that we issued.
[0:19:32] Okay.
[0:19:33] So the part that I think that I'd really like to know,
[0:19:38] I think for me a little bit is,
[0:19:41] what is that timeframe for this to be done?
[0:19:43] I don't think we want to leave it open ended
[0:19:45] as I was reading the packet.
[0:19:47] I think that was the biggest thing that stood out to me
[0:19:50] is okay, you're asking us to make a decision,
[0:19:54] but we don't have a conclusion to that decision,
[0:19:57] or at least some frame of reference
[0:19:59] of when you anticipate this could be done.
[0:20:01] So that's gonna be a little difficult for me to get over.
[0:20:06] So I believe the representative is Redmond,
[0:20:10] if you're done, if.
[0:20:13] Yeah, unless you have any other questions
[0:20:14] about the materials that I can answer.
[0:20:18] It doesn't look like it, thank you.
[0:20:30] Thank you, Mayor and City Council.
[0:20:31] My name is Brooke Redmond.
[0:20:32] I don't think I've had the luxury of speaking
[0:20:35] in front of you folks.
[0:20:37] Great while, and I don't think anybody's still
[0:20:38] on the council last time I did.
[0:20:41] As indicated by Mr. Spendlove, we are seeking a deferral.
[0:20:44] We are not seeking just to not do it.
[0:20:47] This is an issue of the weather, as you indicated.
[0:20:50] The timeframe we would be looking for
[0:20:51] would be summer of 2020 with a drop dead date of July 1st,
[0:20:55] 2024, but with the goal of it being done before then.
[0:21:00] weather determining and I find the code to be incredibly interesting because they do make this exception for trees and shrubs
[0:21:07] Because the materials aren't available. The water's not there. The ground's going to freeze
[0:21:11] That same exact reasoning is going to apply to curbing
[0:21:16] Concrete if you can get the concrete. That's not going to freeze
[0:21:19] efficiently or
[0:21:20] exceptionally or expensive
[0:21:23] The ground is going to freeze
[0:21:25] The same with the trash enclosure, you can't build that in the winter, everything we were
[0:21:30] asking for is the stuff that is outside of the facility.
[0:21:34] And for absolute clarity for this council, everything is on the back of the, nothing is,
[0:21:39] nothing we are requesting is on the front of the facility or inside the facility.
[0:21:43] What we basically want to do is get people back to work, want to be able to increase the
[0:21:48] workload right now.
[0:21:50] There's a very small facility and we've got workers ready to go back to work that can't
[0:21:55] work because you don't have a space to put them, or to just keep this open until it's
[0:22:00] live.
[0:22:01] It's obviously exceptional hardship on Rob Green-Hunday in Gaggot's employees, so I would say that
[0:22:08] that would be out of the ordinary.
[0:22:09] My definition of exceptional for what it's worth, that this would be an exceptional hardship.
[0:22:17] The same idea was a striping, again, and to do that, but when the ground is frozen.
[0:22:24] and hard surface parking, they're all the exact same idea.
[0:22:29] And it's my understanding that the water retention pond
[0:22:31] has been considered as exceptionally close to being.
[0:22:35] That all of these issues are outside work.
[0:22:37] And specifically with the hard surface parking,
[0:22:41] is they are actually in the process of grinding up
[0:22:43] the asphalt so that when the weather turns,
[0:22:46] they can use that asphalt to pay a parking area.
[0:22:49] Once it's paved, they can then put in the required striping
[0:22:51] and the required curbing.
[0:22:53] But all of these things have to be done in a very specific order.
[0:22:55] So for absolute clarity, we are not seeking any sort of deferral forever.
[0:23:02] We are good with an absolute drop-down day.
[0:23:06] We are endeavoring to get it done much quicker.
[0:23:09] They are actively working on this, as I speak, or at least we're actively working on it today.
[0:23:14] And this is not something that has just been ignored.
[0:23:16] They've worked diligently throughout the process.
[0:23:19] So we would just request that we can make occupancy
[0:23:23] of the building as the people in the back
[0:23:25] continue to do the work.
[0:23:27] And I also have Greg Olson, who is the contractor here
[0:23:31] who can maybe answer some more of the technical questions
[0:23:34] as well.
[0:23:38] OK.
[0:23:39] Any questions for Brooke or Jonathan or Greg?
[0:23:42] Go ahead, Greg.
[0:23:46] I just, I guess one of my questions
[0:23:49] is how did we get to this point?
[0:23:52] Is it from things going wrong?
[0:23:55] Hey, what, you know, materials not being available or whatever, you know, usually there's a timeframe
[0:24:02] and so forth that needs to happen.
[0:24:06] My feeling is, is I think that we need to be accommodating as much as we possibly can.
[0:24:10] But on the other hand, we also need to protect the city and others with the ordinances and
[0:24:14] rules that we have.
[0:24:16] I just was wondering how we got to this point.
[0:24:18] Well, and I would defer a little bit to Greg more on the specifics, and I will ask him
[0:24:22] to answer that question.
[0:24:23] before I do, I would say if you look at the time frame right now,
[0:24:26] costs of materials have been exceptionally high
[0:24:29] in the past few years, so I'm certain that had an impact to it.
[0:24:33] And there have been change orders and requests
[0:24:34] to modify the plans, which are always
[0:24:36] going to slow the process down.
[0:24:38] But I would like, great, indicate as to what you view them.
[0:24:43] Go ahead, you give them a bunch of good reasons, Greg.
[0:24:46] So this building was an old Hyundai store in the front,
[0:24:52] then had the shop and the body shop in the middle.
[0:24:54] and then we added to the back.
[0:24:56] So when you marry up these kinds of buildings together,
[0:25:00] it's extremely difficult.
[0:25:02] And because of COVID, the lead time on like TPL roofing
[0:25:06] and things like that are like 16 months.
[0:25:10] So we're ordering this stuff in advance,
[0:25:12] trying to work our way through this whole project.
[0:25:15] Court Thorpe was the one that did the demolition on it.
[0:25:18] The elevator caught on fire,
[0:25:19] it cost us a month and a half.
[0:25:20] I mean, it's just one thing after nothing really went right.
[0:25:24] In the end, it looks really good, but it was a giant nightmare, the entire time trying
[0:25:30] to marry those two buildings together, trying to make them happy, hit the engineer to figure
[0:25:33] out where we're cutting beams, rafters, putting posts in.
[0:25:36] I mean, it was absolutely.
[0:25:38] And working through weather delays, I mean, last winter went on a lot later than I anticipated.
[0:25:44] So, I mean, you can't buy the cart before the horse and you're trying to get stuff done.
[0:25:51] you want to do one thing, but you can't do it until you get the other thing done and it was just...
[0:25:56] Thank you.
[0:25:59] So I do have a question.
[0:26:03] It looks like the last change order was issued in July and it must have gone to P&Z.
[0:26:10] Was this for the parking island?
[0:26:12] Yeah, the parking island actually went to P&Z in September of 22 and then the change order was finally applied for in July of 23.
[0:26:21] I guess my question is what's happened between July 17th and today for us to get to this point?
[0:26:31] That's for the exterior?
[0:26:34] I'm just saying that July is pretty nice weather to poor parking lot and stuff like that.
[0:26:45] So I'm just trying to understand the timeline because it stops at July 17th and it's until just the other day.
[0:26:53] If I had all the front stuff done, but the problem was, is we had to tear the front out,
[0:27:16] we replaced the asphalt.
[0:27:18] So we took that out back to millings out of it, and you can't pave until you tear the old
[0:27:24] asphalt out.
[0:27:25] You can't mill the asphalt until you tear it out, right?
[0:27:30] So it's just a series of events, so we're tearing that out, hitting the concrete board,
[0:27:34] then repaving out front, then now we're crushing the millings, could lay that down, then lay
[0:27:40] oil down like Brooks said and pave the unpaved areas that are need to be paid and
[0:27:45] pressure broke down pressure has been down for two and a half months in part
[0:27:50] this is not my idea of a good time but I can tell you right now is what it is
[0:28:01] and I mean he just wants to open and help the cars. Okay thank you
[0:28:08] Spencer. Hey thanks mayor because of the fact that these aren't like
[0:28:13] like imminent life safety issues, I'm open to considering this.
[0:28:17] The main thing I'm weighing in my head is I don't want to open the door now that every
[0:28:22] single time there's a project delayed, we have contractors coming or owners coming to
[0:28:27] council.
[0:28:28] I mean this request honestly seems reasonable to me.
[0:28:30] I'm just debating in my head, am I ready to open this door now for dozens of projects.
[0:28:36] So with that said, I was curious about the property right now.
[0:28:42] understand there are some employees working there are some sales there's
[0:28:46] limited operations happening right now or none it's on the Nissan side on the
[0:28:51] Nissan side of that facility there is our operations but it's all being and I
[0:28:56] guess squished into one that one section and would be expanded significantly once
[0:29:01] they can okay thank you Maris oh I'm just going to point out one thing
[0:29:11] small clarification on this. We do believe there's one life safety issue. It's the storm water is the one issue the rest of them are
[0:29:18] aesthetic. We can have that conversation I think. Landscaping, parking, maneuvering, the trash enclosure. We agree on
[0:29:30] the facts of those are more aesthetic things. When you look at one property, the aesthetic is more limited, but if we look at a
[0:29:38] macro of the whole city, we're on that part.
[0:29:41] The stormwater, what we don't know right now
[0:29:43] is where it's going to go if there's an event,
[0:29:45] because it wasn't constructed for the plan,
[0:29:47] and we're working through that part of it.
[0:29:50] If they want to change the location,
[0:29:51] which they've indicated, we need a new plan,
[0:29:53] and then to inspect and do that part,
[0:29:56] because there's properties surrounding this
[0:29:59] or their own building, that would be the one where
[0:30:02] the stormwater is the one that's kind of a,
[0:30:04] really the big issue here, harshly because the stormwater has to sheet drain, which is
[0:30:11] not in a pipe, from the front of the building to the back of the building. That's where we're
[0:30:17] kind of, and some of the area where it needs to do that is unpaved. So there's a little
[0:30:22] bit of an issue of where how you get the stormwater to the location and then store it where it's
[0:30:25] supposed to be. I'm not trying to not agree with you, I'm just trying to clarify. That's
[0:30:31] That's the one item we don't let anybody not do is storm water that's always required
[0:30:35] no matter what your permit is, for what it's worth.
[0:30:39] What about the handicap access part?
[0:30:44] That comes from the ADA Act to federal requirement.
[0:30:50] In the end, I don't know what our city's liability is if it's not in when a building's
[0:30:55] in place.
[0:30:56] I do know if someone complains about it.
[0:31:00] the federal government comes, the Department of Justice is the one that comes, comes calling.
[0:31:05] So it's something we would want to have in, because we want to facilitate that kind of
[0:31:11] accessibility.
[0:31:15] Is it a safety issue?
[0:31:16] It could be for someone trying to get to the location.
[0:31:18] Sure.
[0:31:21] I mean, that was all.
[0:31:24] Let's see.
[0:31:25] Who, next Jason, I think?
[0:31:26] Yeah, I'll jump in if everybody else is...
[0:31:29] I do have a couple questions for Bruce before we get too far, but go ahead.
[0:31:35] So I'm kind of with Craig and Spencer. I think the biggest thing for me is I would agree that the striping that the parking lot, some of the curb and gutters, not a big thing.
[0:31:45] The one thing that I would probably get hooked up on is the stormwater issue and the timeline.
[0:31:51] Is there any way that you'd mention how far away are we from that stormwater facility retention being in a spot or location that it needs to be that it can at least collect water for the time being?
[0:32:04] Okay. Okay. So, John Kimo, John Kimo, run Thursday. Ready? And the contractors came on Monday. Okay. And we worked on it a week.
[0:32:22] So here's, here's some of the, and some of the struggle and the trial of working through some of the, the checking the boxes and things like that. And, and I think maybe we'll get Bruce's opinion on this as well.
[0:32:34] I'd actually like to see us go back out and check that and see if we can look at this next week and
[0:32:41] And say that that's been checked off or at least something's been done
[0:32:44] And then also get a response for a timeline saying yeah by you know honor before July 1st of 2024
[0:32:52] We'll have everything else done. I'd like to see I'd like to see something in the record that holds us to a little bit
[0:33:00] But I I mean that's kind of where I'm sitting
[0:33:02] and we would be agreeable with that.
[0:33:06] Grayson.
[0:33:08] Yeah, I guess this is more of a question for Jonathan or Travis.
[0:33:10] Can we tie a PMP bond on to approving this?
[0:33:16] So I'm going to say we struggle, or I don't think
[0:33:22] we're permitted to do work, like bond for work on private property.
[0:33:28] You can certainly, or someone in some jurisdictions,
[0:33:32] they have like a, what's it called?
[0:33:36] It's like a reserve up front to basically incentivize people to finish, we don't have that, but bonding for something typically includes bonding for the work and then we hire someone to finish the work.
[0:33:48] In the end to get compliance from Title 10, it is a judge ordering it to be done, that is the last thing you do.
[0:33:57] all these steps to say we're not going to give you TCO, we're not going to do this, we're
[0:34:01] going to give you violations. And then in the end, if all of those things are not done,
[0:34:07] we file to compel someone to finish because of the zoning violation of Title 10.
[0:34:13] Madam Mayor, Council Member, Greg did offer to do that in the beginning. That was one of
[0:34:23] the items that they did offer to put up some bond of other value, and Jonathan's right,
[0:34:31] we had a conversation about that and the ability to compel improvements by the government on
[0:34:38] private property, it's to be incredibly sticky. And so while the offer was made, and I think
[0:34:45] that's important for the record, it wasn't one that we believed that we could readily
[0:34:50] accept.
[0:34:51] Thank you Chris read I guess I'm going to have to just agree with Jason and kind of maybe as far as
[0:35:00] both boning this until a later time
[0:35:04] Also looking at this list the document
[0:35:07] Jonathan that you brought up where there's a list of items some of them
[0:35:12] I'm sure they were in the packet. I don't exactly remember all of them in there
[0:35:16] But I would like specific dates when those will be completed
[0:35:19] Also not being somebody in your world, understanding storm water retention.
[0:35:26] That's something that is life-threatening.
[0:35:28] So we do need to have that before occupancy.
[0:35:31] Sounds like there's been some work done on it.
[0:35:34] The ADA compliance.
[0:35:37] But exactly when those are going to happen and not just a, here's the entire list.
[0:35:43] I just need them to be done.
[0:35:46] So, tonight I wouldn't be willing to say yes, no, I would like to see those specific dates.
[0:35:53] I mean, ultimately I guess it would be a no, but I would like to see those dates because
[0:35:58] there are people who are trying to get back to work trying to run a business.
[0:36:03] So, for me, it's not just a broad brush, but individual items.
[0:36:07] I took that as a question, but maybe it wasn't one.
[0:36:18] Go ahead.
[0:36:19] It can be a question.
[0:36:20] It's difficult to speak when specific items are going to be finalized as the available
[0:36:25] are difficult, but we can't lie first and we're certainly open to allowing anybody from
[0:36:32] planning and zoning to come out and inspect the pond retention area and make any grant
[0:36:36] to him to go, to limit it on approval of.
[0:36:47] Bruce, do you have any, if you could to start with, when Jonathan mentions we're a quasi-judicial
[0:36:57] position we're in, do you want to explain that?
[0:37:00] Or all of us, especially the new council members,
[0:37:04] to understand what that means.
[0:37:06] I'll need you to come up to the mic.
[0:37:07] Thank you.
[0:37:13] Mayor, members of the council, excuse me, yes.
[0:37:16] As I do this, it's when the city council essentially
[0:37:19] puts its executive hat off for the moment
[0:37:23] and it's a decider of an issue here.
[0:37:27] And the issue obviously is whether to grant it to furlal,
[0:37:30] but you're doing it based essentially on the facts of this case here
[0:37:34] coming to a conclusion terms of what exceptional hardship means
[0:37:39] you're also going to decide whether
[0:37:42] and that in this case under these particular circumstances so
[0:37:46] actually become
[0:37:47] so to speak
[0:37:52] any questions for Bruce well he's up here
[0:37:56] I've got one
[0:37:58] so how would you define exceptional hardship
[0:38:01] I was looking up a law dictionary, but how would you say it?
[0:38:06] And then Jonathan, if either one, if you want to, it would be nice to know what we believe
[0:38:11] an exceptional hardship would be.
[0:38:13] Just for a future reference and starting to somewhat define what that would entail if this
[0:38:21] were to transpire again.
[0:38:23] Or, you know, I'd love to give you what we would call the black letter definition of
[0:38:28] of exceptional hardship and say, this is what it should mean.
[0:38:30] But honestly, and a court of law would do the same thing.
[0:38:33] It's going to come to a balancing decision
[0:38:36] of probably competing interests.
[0:38:39] And as the decider of the law in terms of what does this mean,
[0:38:44] I can offer you something to think about.
[0:38:48] We, a court would call this extraordinary relief
[0:38:52] meaning.
[0:38:53] It's optional, it's meant to be rare.
[0:38:55] It's meant to be applied in only a few certain circumstances.
[0:38:58] I think that I would suggest to the council that you look at the degree of hardship if it's something that you believe is unusual or if it's very unusual.
[0:39:10] I would look at essentially what is the cause of the hardship?
[0:39:16] Is it something that has been caused by the applicant?
[0:39:19] Something that's been caused by something out of his or her or its hands?
[0:39:24] Or is it a combination of those there?
[0:39:29] I would also say that you could look at it, whether a deferral would be fair to both sides,
[0:39:35] meaning to the applicant, to the city itself, something that you can weigh in that manner.
[0:39:40] I would also suggest that in looking at a deferral, you come up with a deferral that's
[0:39:44] well defined, and you certainly have the ability to put clear conditions placed on that.
[0:39:51] you don't need to do it open ended.
[0:39:53] In fact, that would probably work against the end,
[0:39:55] but those are just some things that I think if a judge
[0:39:58] were looking at it, they would try to formulate something
[0:40:01] along those lines.
[0:40:02] It's rare.
[0:40:04] Is the person coming with clean hands, so to speak?
[0:40:08] What is the cause?
[0:40:09] Was it out of their control?
[0:40:11] How hard or how difficult is this going to be on them?
[0:40:14] And how, what's the impact to the city going to be?
[0:40:19] How is the city going to be impacted
[0:40:20] by having this to grow in place for however long you have.
[0:40:25] Thank you, Bruce.
[0:40:28] OK, so I've got Craig and Jason up, maybe,
[0:40:31] because you haven't checked out.
[0:40:34] Yep, I'll pull it off here real quick.
[0:40:37] I was just typing notes as Bruce was talking
[0:40:39] and didn't take that down.
[0:40:43] So that's right.
[0:40:46] So any additional questions, comments?
[0:40:53] You said I do.
[0:40:54] Greg.
[0:40:57] I disagree with his life safety.
[0:41:00] I don't think that the storm water retention is life safety.
[0:41:02] I don't know how water coming off a parking lot is going to create a life safety issue.
[0:41:06] The building itself has been passed for life safety like fire suppression, exit signs,
[0:41:12] fire extinguishers, things of that nature.
[0:41:15] So the life safety portion of it, I'll get it done by July 1st.
[0:41:19] The life safety portion of the water retention area, though I just don't, I don't see, and
[0:41:25] I want to get it done.
[0:41:26] We all want to get it done.
[0:41:27] I want to place for the water to go.
[0:41:28] And the water went there this summer when there was two pretty solid days of rain and
[0:41:33] it handled, it's smaller, it was smaller than it is today and it handled that water and
[0:41:39] it wasn't a 50-year storm, but it was certainly a 20 or 25-year storm.
[0:41:43] Thank you.
[0:41:44] Thanks, sir.
[0:41:45] I'd be willing to offer a motion that temporary occupancy could be granted if there's an agreed
[0:41:52] upon ultimate drop dead date and the storm water portion can be constructed.
[0:41:58] So clearly if there's piping and excavation required, you know, the surface, final surface
[0:42:03] restoration would not be complete.
[0:42:05] But if the piping improvements and the actual volume of storm water retention are there,
[0:42:10] that would be a condition that would allow temporary occupancy.
[0:42:16] Does that work for you, Jonathan?
[0:42:18] Something like that?
[0:42:19] I'm trying to formulate.
[0:42:24] So what exactly he said?
[0:42:26] Yeah, and in all fairness, I'm here because they requested and the definition and exceptional
[0:42:33] hardship is what you can grant.
[0:42:37] It's really, I don't know what other guidance to give you.
[0:42:40] I will share some thoughts if you want me to.
[0:42:46] Over the last 12 years, we've had these discussions with a lot of development in town and these
[0:42:54] items are what we've required people to do. I believe we can have a philosophical discussion
[0:42:59] on whether we should keep requiring it or not. It is within your right to do this deferral
[0:43:04] however you guys craft it. Thank you, Jonathan, but you're correct. It comes down to is it
[0:43:13] an exceptional hardship and exceptional to me I guess would be somewhat unique and this
[0:43:19] is not really unique. It comes up a lot, so thank you.
[0:43:32] I guess my biggest concern is the precedent we set for others. We've all had COVID supply chain issues. I mean, I get things breakdown.
[0:43:44] I just am concerned that, but that opens up a Pandora's box for Council to be sitting in a quasi-judicial position every time.
[0:43:59] I mean, I don't know.
[0:44:04] Can I jump in real quick?
[0:44:08] Yes, Jason.
[0:44:09] A few other thoughts, I guess.
[0:44:12] I think for me, I would agree that there are some weather restricted items here, landscaping.
[0:44:19] I can buy the concrete a little bit.
[0:44:22] Obviously, paving is one of those temperature restrictions.
[0:44:26] I still, I think it's, in my opinion, it's in our best interest, if we can get a timeline
[0:44:35] in writing. It's in our best interest to hold off a week if we can do that. If there's a commitment
[0:44:41] from the applicant to do that, saying, okay, when's the stormwater going to be in? Is there
[0:44:47] a general by the end of the month and of February? I think that helps us get out of a little bit of
[0:44:53] the situation. I agree. I'd like to just be able to say a grant a temporary occupancy. But I think
[0:45:02] think we need to, because it is, at least from the explanation, and obviously in my tenure,
[0:45:09] this is the first time, and this is some of the bureaucracy that we get a little upset
[0:45:14] about, but this decision is will be used moving forward. I'm absolutely certain of it.
[0:45:22] Thank you, Grayson.
[0:45:25] Yeah, just piggyback off of what Jason just said, this will absolutely be utilized in
[0:45:30] future and part of me feels like it's almost a work around around the
[0:45:36] building department. And we need to be really careful about how we apply that.
[0:45:40] My second question or my second statement is more of a question to you, Madam Mayor.
[0:45:43] Would it be appropriate to have staff look at the other municipalities within
[0:45:48] their code to come up and provide a definition for exceptional hardship
[0:45:53] that potentially we could adapt or excuse me adopt into our code. That way
[0:45:58] Should this move forward? We all are on the same plane field on what an exceptional hardship
[0:46:03] is moving forward.
[0:46:04] So I'm not sure all that, yes, the answer is yes. I'm not sure for the sake of time that
[0:46:13] having that work done would take care of their issue. Travis, do you have any comments?
[0:46:21] I think that Jonathan had shared in his presentation that they looked at other areas and could
[0:46:30] not find where the term exceptional hardship was applicable. It doesn't mean that Jonathan
[0:46:37] and team did an exhaustive search of all 206 planning codes. But I believe that in knowing
[0:46:44] the team they probably looked at the larger incorporated areas, the ones that may be similarly
[0:46:51] situated and may experience these same type of things. And if I understood Jonathan during
[0:46:55] his presentation, the definition was not to be found. Really, I think that this council
[0:47:04] is in a position now where you are defining it. You are defining what exceptional hardship
[0:47:10] is and what legal counsel has shared, what conditions you should look at and incorporate,
[0:47:17] whether that be timing, whether that be whether that be financial and the like.
[0:47:28] Okay, so Spencer, you kind of talked about making a motion
[0:47:35] Jason talked about a timeline. I don't know
[0:47:38] Want to try to craft something?
[0:47:40] I'm gonna do a Spencer. Do you want to do it or what? What are you thinking? Well, I was just gonna say I haven't made up my mind for this evening
[0:47:48] I'm not willing to make a motion
[0:47:51] on this matter tonight
[0:47:54] I'd like to see if the applicant is agreeable
[0:47:57] I'd like to see, I'd like to postpone this until Tuesday next week, the 16th, right?
[0:48:05] We're meeting on the 16th.
[0:48:07] And see if we can get some documentation in the record that says, yep, we're going to do this.
[0:48:13] We'll have the stormwater done, or you may have already have it done, but having the building department planning and zoning go out,
[0:48:20] make sure that it's documented, we're good with that.
[0:48:23] Because to me, it sounds like the stormwater
[0:48:25] may be that only lynch pin that we're hanging up on.
[0:48:29] Initially, I think, I may speak out of turn,
[0:48:33] but I guess I'll just speak for myself.
[0:48:35] I'm okay with the concrete, the paving,
[0:48:37] and the striping to be done at a later date,
[0:48:40] on or before July 1st.
[0:48:41] I think I'd like to see some a little bit hard and fast
[0:48:44] on that stormwater.
[0:48:46] What about the ADA?
[0:48:48] I think that's part of the asphalt and some of that stuff.
[0:48:51] It sounds like that the owner is going to take on the liability of not having the ADA
[0:48:57] strived or approach at this time if there is any liability.
[0:49:02] I don't know.
[0:49:03] Madam Mayor, I can see where making a motion this evening would be difficult.
[0:49:08] I think that we've heard that from what I've heard, you have a series of requests of the
[0:49:14] applicant, of things that you would like to see, you would like specific dates tied to
[0:49:21] to the individual items and you would like to have
[0:49:24] verification as to the completeness of the storm water system
[0:49:29] and that you would like to also have this item
[0:49:34] considered next week at its council meeting
[0:49:38] which is at Tuesday at five o'clock pm
[0:49:41] and have staff place that onto the agenda.
[0:49:44] I think everybody's in agreement with that.
[0:49:46] So one more thing.
[0:49:48] Yes.
[0:49:50] So there's two things.
[0:49:53] In order to ensure the stormwater is done, some of that work is going to be drawing from
[0:49:57] their engineer and stamping a drawing and getting it through our process to review.
[0:50:03] I believe that could be done in a week.
[0:50:04] I don't know.
[0:50:05] I just want to verify that some of that might be out of staff's hands to confirm because
[0:50:11] all we do is review what their engineer stamps.
[0:50:17] I just don't know if that time lines too quick, but maybe I should clarify the storm water
[0:50:23] issue on my end a little bit.
[0:50:25] I want to know that there is a retention swell there that can capture storm water.
[0:50:30] I think obviously we're going to have to have a stamped drawing that says, yeah, it's going
[0:50:34] to retain the 50-year storm event or 25-year storm event, whatever we required at that time.
[0:50:41] But I'd like to see that there's at least something there that's going to capture.
[0:50:45] I mean, understanding we can go back and forth on a life safety.
[0:50:50] It kind of depends on how you define that one, but this property had stormwater retention
[0:50:55] at one time.
[0:50:56] I would definitely not want to see the backyards of somebody, somebody flooding.
[0:51:00] That's what I'd like to see.
[0:51:02] And then we can go through the process, just noting that, hey, something's there.
[0:51:06] It'll capture stormwater and then go through the process of their engineer making all the
[0:51:10] calculations, getting it stamped and done.
[0:51:13] Does that help?
[0:51:14] Yeah, and then that's more of like a temporary type of deal.
[0:51:17] And we had we sent somebody today just to make sure they were there.
[0:51:20] You have the ability to table this item for specific things to table to next week.
[0:51:24] We want to list an answer to one through 17 and when they will be complete.
[0:51:29] And they can bring that back to you with certain dates, which is what Councilman
[0:51:32] Rita was looking for for each of the items.
[0:51:35] That may not be just everything done at January 1.
[0:51:37] That's up to the applicant to kind of put in there that would be your option
[0:51:41] Tonight is to have a motion to table to next week
[0:51:44] and have that list with answers for dates for each of them.
[0:51:48] If that's what you believe that's what I'm hearing,
[0:51:50] at least from Councilman Brown.
[0:51:52] So is that what you're talking about?
[0:51:54] I'm going to disagree with Jonathan just quickly.
[0:51:56] I think that when you get convoluted with motions to table
[0:51:59] and the entire Roberts rule process,
[0:52:02] it gets to be five votes.
[0:52:04] And I think that the council can very simply,
[0:52:07] if the council decision is not to make a decision tonight,
[0:52:10] motion can be we instruct staff to place us on the agenda next week. I'll make that motion. I think
[0:52:18] it's important for us to to allow the applicant to come back. I know that's probably not exactly
[0:52:23] what you want to hear, but I think we need to build the record from our side of it. Sure. Yeah,
[0:52:30] Madam Mayor, is that okay? We have a motion on the floor. So if I could have a second.
[0:52:35] I'll second that. Thank you. Go ahead. If I give you the dates of when we're going to.
[0:52:41] No, no, no, no, no, no, let us vote on the motion, Greg, please first.
[0:52:47] Okay, we have a motion on the floor to ask the staff to have this item ready for next week's
[0:52:55] agenda on the six, is it 16th?
[0:52:59] Motion by Jason Brown, seconded by Chris Reed.
[0:53:02] Any further discussion?
[0:53:07] Amy Rojo, please.
[0:53:12] Greg Hawkins?
[0:53:13] Yes.
[0:53:14] Jason Brown?
[0:53:15] Yes.
[0:53:16] Yes, Harry Bummer. Yes, Grayson Stone. Yes, Pierce. Yes. And Chris Reed. Yes. Thank you, motion passes seven to zero. Thank you, everyone. Okay, next, Jonathan, you are up 123. Can I ask a quick question?
[0:53:32] Yes, I'm sorry. That's fine. Can we get this document that you were showing earlier? Yeah, it is to us. Yes, please. Before the meeting's over. Thank you. Thank you, Jonathan.
[0:53:45] Okay, so next on the agenda is an action item and actually all three of these are ordinance
[0:53:54] adoptions with Jonathan. First one is a request to adopt ordinance 2024-001 for the vacation
[0:54:03] of lots right-of-way and easements on property located within block four of the prime point
[0:54:09] subdivision.
[0:54:10] Thank you, Madam Mayor, members of the Council. The next two items are somewhat linked except
[0:54:17] the city owns portions of property near it so we separated them out. These are
[0:54:23] within the prime point and so division the developer owner would like to have a
[0:54:26] new layout so they have gone through the process with planning and zoning
[0:54:31] commission in September and the city council in October to vacate the block
[0:54:38] in its entirety basically the right-of-way and certain easements. They're going to
[0:54:42] retain other easements for utilities and then they're going to replant the
[0:54:46] entirety of that block which is block 4 for ordinance 2024-001. If you wish to
[0:54:53] enact this ordinance tonight you would be placing it out there and find them by
[0:54:58] title only and then vote half plus one. That language is in the staff report under
[0:55:06] I believe it's under the regulatory section if you need the exact wording. That's all I
[0:55:11] have for this number one. Thank you. So I need somebody to make a
[0:55:17] of motion regarding 3rd and final.
[0:55:19] If there are not, do it.
[0:55:25] Chris raised his hand.
[0:55:27] He's ready.
[0:55:29] I move we dispense with the reading rules and place ordinance 2024-01 on 3rd and final
[0:55:36] by title only.
[0:55:38] Thank you.
[0:55:39] Do I have a second?
[0:55:41] Motion by Chris Reed, 2nd by Craig Hawkins to put ordinance 2024-001 on 3rd and final
[0:55:52] Reading by title only. Sorry. Third and final reading by title only. Sorry. It's my first
[0:56:01] day back. Hey, Amy Roll call vote please. Jason Brown. Yes. Spencer Cutler. Yes. Harry
[0:56:14] Volmer. Yes. Grayson Stone. Yes. Ruth Pierce. Yes. Ruth Reed. Yes. And Craig Hawkins. Yes.
[0:56:21] Thank you. Motion passes 7-0. So I'll read the ordinance, an ordinance number 2024-001. An ordinance
[0:56:30] of the mayor and the city council of the city of Twin Falls, Idaho, vacating lots right
[0:56:35] of way in the easements to describe below. Chris Reed. Move to approve ordinance 2024-001.
[0:56:43] Thank you. To have a second. Motion by Chris Reed, seconded by Craig Hawkins to approve ordinance
[0:56:50] 24-001. Amy Roach, I'll vote, please. Spencer Cutler. Yes. Barry Bulmer. Yes.
[0:57:02] Grayson Stone. Yes. Ruth Pierce. Yes. Chris Reed. Yes. Craig Hawkins. Yes. Yes. Brown. Yes.
[0:57:09] Thank you. Motion passes 7-0. Okay. Next on the agenda is an action item a
[0:57:19] A request to adopt ordinance 2024-002 for the vacation of lots right of way and easements
[0:57:27] on property located within block 18 of the prime point subdivision.
[0:57:34] Thank you Madam Mayor members of council same thing this is the other block that same dates
[0:57:39] that were approved by planning and zoning and the city council again if you wish to adopt
[0:57:45] it tonight third and final I can walk you through the process if you need thank you Jason Brown
[0:57:53] I'd move that we dispense with the reading of the rules and put ordinance number 2024-002
[0:58:04] on third and final reading by title only.
[0:58:07] Second.
[0:58:08] Thank you.
[0:58:10] Motion by Jason Brown seconded by Grayson Stone to put ordinance 2024-002 on third and
[0:58:19] final reading by dispensing with rules and third and final reading by title only
[0:58:25] Amy well call vote please. Jerry Vomer yes Grace and Stone yes Ruth Pierce yes
[0:58:34] Chris Reed yes yes Jason Brown yes we're cutler yes thank you motion passes
[0:58:42] 7 to 0.
[0:58:44] Okay. Ordinance.
[0:58:46] That's like five ordinances here.
[0:58:50] Ordinance number 2024-002.
[0:58:54] An ordinance of the mayor and the city council of the city of Twin Falls, Idaho,
[0:59:00] vacating lots right of way in Eastman's describe below.
[0:59:04] Jason Brown. I'd move to approve ordinance number 2024-002. Thank you. Do I have a second?
[0:59:13] Second. Thank you. Motion by Jason Brown, seconded by Craig Hawkins to approve
[0:59:22] ordinance 2024-002. Amy Roll call vote please.
[0:59:27] Grace and Stone? Yes. Ruth Pears? Yes. Chris Reed? Yes. Craig Hawkins? Yes. Jason Brown? Yes. Spencer Cutler? Yes.
[0:59:37] And Sherry Vollmer? Yes. Thank you. Motion passes 7-0. Hey, last one. An action item. Go ahead.
[0:59:51] This agenda again ordinance 2024 003, which is changing the financial responsibility of the street sign and luminaire installation for new development
[1:00:01] Similar dates and went through P&Z and the council towards the end of the year. I think it was October and December
[1:00:08] the
[1:00:09] Section is really are just street name signs and street luminaries which are at each intersection will now be the
[1:00:15] financial responsibility of the developer when they install them and not the city of Twin Falls
[1:00:19] Thank you. Chris Reed. I'm ready to make the motion for a move that we dispense with the reading rules
[1:00:27] and put ordinance 2024-003m third and final reading by title only. Thank you do
[1:00:36] have a second second. Thank you. Thank you motion by Christopher Reed second
[1:00:41] and by Jason excuse me Grayson Stone I'm gonna have trouble with that. Grayson
[1:00:46] Jason Stone to put ordinance number 2020 4-0-3 by dispensing with the rules and
[1:00:54] putting it on third and final reading by title only. Amy Rowe call vote please.
[1:01:01] Ruth Pierce yes. Chris Reed yes. Craig Hawkins yes. Jason Brown yes.
[1:01:08] Councillor Cutler, Kerry Wilmer, and Grayson Stum.
[1:01:14] Thank you.
[1:01:15] Motion passes 7-0, so ordinance 24-003, an ordinance of the City Council of the City of
[1:01:24] Twin Falls, Idaho regarding the regulation and administration in the City of Twin Falls
[1:01:30] and area of city impact, amending Twin Falls City Code by repealing and replacing Section
[1:01:37] 10-12-4-2JNN to modify the financial responsibility of street sign and
[1:01:45] luminaire installation for new development. Craig Hawkins.
[1:01:51] There are moved that we approve Ordinance 2024-0-3.
[1:01:57] Thank you. Do I have a second? I'll second. Thank you. Motion by Craig Hawkins,
[1:02:03] second by Jason Brown to approve Ordinance Number 2024-003. Amy Rolkavo, please.
[1:02:12] Yes.
[1:02:15] Yes.
[1:02:17] Yes.
[1:02:19] Yes.
[1:02:21] Yes.
[1:02:24] Yes.
[1:02:26] Yes.
[1:02:29] Hey, motion passes seven to zero. Thank you, Jonathan. Okay, so that is all for item
[1:02:37] of consideration. Next on the agenda is the time for general public input and it's
[1:02:44] the time that anybody from the audience who wishes to speak in front of City
[1:02:52] Council. This is your time on items that were not on today's agenda. Anybody
[1:02:58] wishing to provide public input will please approach the podium or mic state
[1:03:05] your name and whether your resident of Twin Falls. Tonight the public input will be limited
[1:03:11] to two minutes and individuals are not permitted to give their time to other speakers. I ask
[1:03:18] all presenters to remain courteous and respectful and public input about any items that are related
[1:03:27] to personnel or personnel related issues or where items on the agenda will not be accepted.
[1:03:34] So, anybody wishing to come down, please come down, and we will give you three minutes.
[1:03:51] So there will be a timer.
[1:03:52] Okay.
[1:03:53] Before I start my presentation here, I just wanted to let you know that there is a handout
[1:03:58] that was provided to you.
[1:04:00] Excuse me, would you state your name and whether you're resident of Twin Falls?
[1:04:04] My name is Richard Aldama, and I am a resident and homeowner in the City of Twin Falls.
[1:04:09] Thank you.
[1:04:11] Anyway, the handout that I gave you basically includes a number of items.
[1:04:16] The first is how the state addresses short-term rentals.
[1:04:21] And basically it says that we can't ban them throughout Idaho, but we can institute local controls to address certain issues.
[1:04:30] The second part of that handout, the second tab, is my actual presentation, and I'll get to that in a minute.
[1:04:37] The third part is a few items that show a couple of social media posts that were made
[1:04:43] a couple of years ago when a house started being built in our subdivision.
[1:04:48] And what those posts identify are some of the offerings for that house.
[1:04:56] And then there is a page at the very end of that that shows an actual picture of the house
[1:05:02] That was taken recently that identifies or shows a driveway that was poured that covers
[1:05:08] the property in the front from one side to the other.
[1:05:12] So it does not allow really for very much landscaping of any.
[1:05:17] And then finally, there is a petition that I've included that includes signatures from
[1:05:25] our subdivision, Pioneer Point and Settlers Ridge.
[1:05:28] We live in Benoit Place, which is a court, and I was able to get signatures and full
[1:05:33] support from all of the residents, homeowners on that court, as well as homeowners that
[1:05:39] are in the surrounding area close to us.
[1:05:42] Hey, I just want to warn you to watch your time.
[1:05:45] Okay, I am.
[1:05:46] So anyway, basically, those signatures basically support my proposal that Twin Falls adopts
[1:05:55] local controls for short-term rentals.
[1:05:59] We're in a situation now where that house is being built.
[1:06:02] You know, they're talking about, you know, having up to 34 people there,
[1:06:06] making it an event center,
[1:06:08] renting vehicles, things like that.
[1:06:11] So it really goes beyond what the normal use of a short-term rental might be.
[1:06:16] We've got, we were the first ones to move into the subdivision.
[1:06:19] We've seen it develop.
[1:06:20] There are a couple of other short-term rentals that haven't been a problem.
[1:06:23] a problem, typically they'll just have a couple that will stay there overnight.
[1:06:28] Our subdivision has always been a place where children can play safely, there's peace and
[1:06:33] quiet.
[1:06:34] We all kind of know our neighbors and take care of each other and we really feel that if this
[1:06:38] house is allowed to become a short-term rental and offer those things that it is identifying
[1:06:44] on those documents, that will really spoil the integrity of our neighborhood.
[1:06:50] And I think that we need some local controls to be able to maintain that integrity.
[1:06:56] Thank you very much.
[1:06:57] Thank you.
[1:06:58] Perfect.
[1:07:00] Hey, is there anybody else that wishes to address the council?
[1:07:06] My name is Tim Mater.
[1:07:08] I'm also a resident.
[1:07:10] Hang on a sec.
[1:07:12] Amy, do you want to technical difficulties?
[1:07:20] Sorry.
[1:07:28] There we go.
[1:07:29] Go ahead.
[1:07:30] Okay.
[1:07:31] I'm here.
[1:07:32] [Muted for privacy: home address]
[1:07:33] [Muted for privacy: home address]
[1:07:34] [Muted for privacy: home address]
[1:07:38] [Muted for privacy: home address]
[1:07:43] so hopefully we're able to look at that prior two.
[1:07:46] I'm just going to go over it real quick.
[1:07:49] I lived next door to that structure.
[1:07:51] The investors that are building that property, they have web pages, social media and others
[1:07:58] that they're running a business called P&V Rentals with a slogan of B.K. Rentals and experiences
[1:08:07] are our expertise. So this property is going to be their third one that they're going to
[1:08:12] be going with. One's in Indiana, another's in Bliss, Idaho. This one's in our neighborhood.
[1:08:18] It's the most extreme of all of them. What they're boasting on their webpage is that this property
[1:08:25] is going to hold up to 34 guests.
[1:08:27] They're going to host weddings, corporate events, reunions,
[1:08:31] as well as providing motorized and non-motorized
[1:08:35] recreational vehicle equipment, all of which, I believe,
[1:08:40] is going to jeopardize the integrity of our subdivision
[1:08:44] and the surrounding neighborhoods.
[1:08:47] I did a little research online, and I found out it's not all
[1:08:51] inclusive, but I found 10 other cities, counties,
[1:08:55] that already have restrictions.
[1:08:58] Looking at what they offer as their restrictions.
[1:09:02] I think if we adopted them as a city of Twin Falls,
[1:09:05] it's not gonna jeopardize our ability
[1:09:09] to have short-term rentals,
[1:09:10] but it's gonna preserve our neighborhoods
[1:09:12] and prevent the ones that come in extreme,
[1:09:16] trying to run hotels and stuff, run from operating that way.
[1:09:24] So yeah, there's at least 13 other counties
[1:09:26] I guess in short, I'm asking that the council approves the request to go forward.
[1:09:35] I don't know what the process is afterwards, but I'm willing to provide my time and help
[1:09:41] to the city employees that are tasked to do this to help build this reserved city.
[1:09:49] Thank you.
[1:09:51] Is there anybody else in the audience that wishes to address city council tonight?
[1:09:55] Hello.
[1:10:05] Hi.
[1:10:06] My name is Danielle Titus.
[1:10:07] I am a resident of Twin Falls.
[1:10:09] I also live in the same neighborhood
[1:10:11] at Pioneer Point on Settlers Ridge Trail,
[1:10:14] and the neighbors did come around to me,
[1:10:17] and I agree that it is something that might benefit
[1:10:20] the City of Twin Falls putting regulations.
[1:10:22] There's a lot of short-term rentals or airbnbs
[1:10:24] in our neighborhood that have never caused an issue.
[1:10:27] It's more of a bedroom or two, and they're quaint.
[1:10:30] You would never know, it's not just a house guest.
[1:10:33] In this case, we're as being advertised as an event center,
[1:10:37] essentially.
[1:10:39] It's just something that I don't think
[1:10:42] is really fits in our area.
[1:10:44] We are zoned R2.
[1:10:46] That's residential single-family households and duplexes.
[1:10:48] It's not for businesses.
[1:10:51] It's not for an event center.
[1:10:52] It's not in the right zone to accommodate that.
[1:10:57] So again, with the amount of people or vehicles
[1:11:01] that they're trying to get into that space,
[1:11:02] I do think that some sort of regulation might be beneficial
[1:11:06] for the city to prevent this sort of thing
[1:11:08] where it's essentially a business.
[1:11:10] So something like that would normally need
[1:11:12] a special use permit.
[1:11:13] It would have to go through planning and zoning,
[1:11:14] come to the city council for approval
[1:11:17] and have public hearings to be able to do.
[1:11:20] This is kind of a work around saying it's a short-term rental
[1:11:24] but or a full event center of 30 to 40 people.
[1:11:28] So these are the things that do make sense
[1:11:31] to possibly limit or control to protect the neighborhoods
[1:11:36] in this city where things like this
[1:11:38] are not applicable in the zone.
[1:11:40] This is just a workaround for these people.
[1:11:43] So, thank you.
[1:11:44] Thank you.
[1:11:46] Anybody else?
[1:11:58] Well, you're coming up.
[1:12:00] There is a signup sheet in the back.
[1:12:02] So if everybody who's speaking tonight
[1:12:04] could please sign up,
[1:12:06] that way we have your name spelled right for the record.
[1:12:09] Thank you.
[1:12:09] Thank you.
[1:12:11] Good evening. I hadn't planned on saying anything. I don't have any notes ready. I am a resident
[1:12:17] of Twin Falls. My name is Matt Harrison. I also live in the noise place, Pioneer Point.
[1:12:23] I agree with everything that has been brought before you regarding this already. I wanted
[1:12:27] to make clear though, this is not a through street of any sort that we're talking about.
[1:12:32] This house sits at the dead end of a cul-de-sac that has six houses. You can imagine already
[1:12:37] just when one of us has company that restricts the parking significantly. Also, I'm sure that
[1:12:44] some of you have taken advantage in rented Airbnb's. I know I have VRBO's. They can be
[1:12:49] rented overnight for a couple for a couple of hundred dollars. The ones in question like
[1:12:55] this one for 34 to 40 occupants. There's only one way to keep that cost effective for the
[1:12:59] person that's renting that and that is to split it with multiple other families, travel
[1:13:04] teams, any sort of anybody to fill it is the only way that it's going to be affordable,
[1:13:10] okay?
[1:13:11] They have no loyalty to our subdivision.
[1:13:13] They have no incentive to take care of our subdivision.
[1:13:16] And I agree fully that I think that we need some ordinances in place for short-term rentals.
[1:13:21] That's all.
[1:13:22] Thank you.
[1:13:23] Thank you.
[1:13:25] Are anybody else tonight?
[1:13:26] Good evening.
[1:13:34] I'm Cant Lee, a resident of Twin Falls and live on the street which has been talked about
[1:13:39] here tonight, Benoit Place, and I fully support these individuals who have spoken already
[1:13:46] and do not feel that this building, this being built, is being used in an appropriate way
[1:13:57] for a residential area when it has been stated that it is going to be used as a entertainment
[1:14:08] recreation or everything else that they have said.
[1:14:11] So I totally support them and we ask that you
[1:14:14] would amend or help out in this area.
[1:14:18] Thank you.
[1:14:20] Thank you.
[1:14:23] Anybody else?
[1:14:26] OK, I will close the public hearing or public input.
[1:14:30] So Council wishes typically in a situation like this,
[1:14:33] we either say no, we're not interested in seeing it
[1:14:37] move forward.
[1:14:38] Yes, we would like staff to do some research.
[1:14:42] What's everybody's feeling right now, Grayson?
[1:14:45] Or Jason?
[1:14:47] I was going to ask a question for Jonathan if I can.
[1:14:51] Is that a term?
[1:14:54] So Jonathan, how did the application for this structure
[1:14:58] come in?
[1:14:59] Do you have any idea how it came in?
[1:15:01] Was it under the umbrella of a single family dwelling?
[1:15:06] OK, can you give us a little bit of history on that?
[1:15:08] I don't know the permit number, but the permit was issued under a single family residential
[1:15:13] dwelling unit reviewed for the International Residential Code, IRC Code.
[1:15:20] Reviewed and then issued, they did have a change of contractor midway through for the contractor,
[1:15:24] left new contractor, purchased owner as now the contractor, and they're trying to finish
[1:15:28] the building.
[1:15:29] That is how it was reviewed and approved.
[1:15:32] Do you want me to go further?
[1:15:33] But that's fine, I'm looking at this and not knowing where the subdivision is and some of
[1:15:40] that, but I'm trying to look at CC&Rs or something that would prevent this from happening.
[1:15:48] Not that I'm opposed to having staff look at some of the short-term rental thing, but
[1:15:53] I didn't know if there were some other avenues that we would need to address or look at or
[1:15:58] give staff direction to go.
[1:16:00] So you're looking at state preemption, banning, we cannot ban short-term rentals in the city
[1:16:09] limits and I don't remember the actual code, 67, 65, something like now in the teens or
[1:16:15] something towards the end of the 67.
[1:16:17] Looks like 67, 65, 39.
[1:16:20] It might be in the list.
[1:16:24] So we can't ban them.
[1:16:25] You can enact laws to enact public health safety and welfare.
[1:16:31] What most of the communities have done, and I don't know all, but if not most, it's a license.
[1:16:37] They require a yearly license to be registered with the city, and then they have certain regulations
[1:16:42] on the license to be put in place and to be inspected every year.
[1:16:46] Most often, it's a new body.
[1:16:49] It's a new position in a city to basically deal with the regulation of those and there's
[1:16:55] whole companies that look to proactively seek out the residential places that are being offered
[1:17:01] and then compel compliance with the licensure.
[1:17:06] And part of the licensure requirements can be and have been extra parking spaces for the
[1:17:11] guests based on the number of people, extra fire, inspection slash, safety issues because
[1:17:19] if you have a larger building, more people in it, you need to have a little extra fire
[1:17:22] safety issues.
[1:17:25] There can be a sign posted with a local property manager that's within a certain mileage to
[1:17:30] deal with issues that happen on the premises with the phone number to call, trying to think
[1:17:35] of some of the other ones that the McCall and some of those others have had, and I believe
[1:17:39] kind of given some of those I don't believe you can restrict the number of
[1:17:45] people that stay I have not seen someone do that maybe some have that but they
[1:17:49] might just classify them like this one zero to 20 and this one's over 20 and they
[1:17:52] just have different classifications and then different requirements you can
[1:17:56] restrict to just residential use so if a place ends up being a special event
[1:18:03] location that has events on the regular now that's a pattern of behavior that's
[1:18:08] not an Airbnb, but then we classify events
[1:18:11] that are differently.
[1:18:12] We said you're an event center, stop doing that.
[1:18:14] That's a Title 10 violation.
[1:18:15] You issue it that way or revoke the license or something.
[1:18:19] So you can restrict it to just residential over nice days.
[1:18:23] I'm trying to think of any other regulations
[1:18:24] that are normal throughout Idaho.
[1:18:26] I think that covers most of the big ones.
[1:18:28] I appreciate it.
[1:18:29] I know that we've had some other individuals come in
[1:18:32] and talk specifically about Airbnb's.
[1:18:35] To me, this one has maybe a little different fill than those other ones.
[1:18:39] So I would probably lean towards having staff spend some time, not a, not a, you know,
[1:18:46] you've got a lot of other stuff to do, but if there's something that we might be able
[1:18:50] to look at or at least have a conversation on again, I would be interested in doing that.
[1:18:59] Chris, is a short-term rental or vacation home classified as a business.
[1:19:06] And the reason I ask is, and this was several years ago,
[1:19:11] we had a couple of individuals need to come get a special use permit
[1:19:16] because they're operating a business out of their home.
[1:19:18] Those were always very interesting because they're open to the public.
[1:19:24] I feel like that's really what's going on.
[1:19:29] They have them in their community or in their neighborhood.
[1:19:32] Some of them are perfectly fine.
[1:19:35] This is quite different than those.
[1:19:37] and classifying that as a business.
[1:19:40] I don't know if that you can do that.
[1:19:42] I could say that the state code classifies
[1:19:45] as a residential home.
[1:19:47] We've been preempted in terms of the definition
[1:19:49] of a home rented to people is a home per the state legislature.
[1:19:54] That's what that's 65, 6, 7, 39, basically says this is a home.
[1:20:00] You treat it like one.
[1:20:01] Now, if they go beyond the bounds of being residential
[1:20:03] and now they're hosting an event and doing those types of things,
[1:20:07] then you're no longer protected under that preemption definition. Now it's you're not a home,
[1:20:12] you're now in a business. Now it's a business. And that's where I think this as the home's not
[1:20:20] finished. And this does occur when people say I believe this is going to happen. And I actually
[1:20:25] believe people when they say that, except no one's broken the law yet. And so we can have a conversation
[1:20:32] with the person that plans on doing it. I can say, hey, just so you know, you can happen to VRBO
[1:20:36] because the state preemption and we haven't regulated those yet, but in terms of you're
[1:20:39] going to plan on having an event here, that's not permitted. But until someone actually violates
[1:20:45] Title X, I can't issue a letter saying you violated it. So that's kind of where I want to separate
[1:20:51] what might happen to what has happened, because that's the world I have to live in. I fully believe
[1:20:56] that maybe that's what's been posted on the website. I mean, that's true. And I can have a
[1:21:00] conversation with the owner and we can talk about regulating VRBOs in terms of
[1:21:08] numbers, sizes, extra things to get it. I'd go on the record and say I don't
[1:21:12] believe any of them should be events, centers at all. They should just be as
[1:21:17] they are, they look and act like a home, a not corporate event retreats or you
[1:21:22] know these other types of things that people rent or events. It should just be
[1:21:27] I'm running a place to stay overnight.
[1:21:30] I don't know if I answered the question.
[1:21:32] Yeah, it was just a question that I had as far as the business,
[1:21:35] because going back several years,
[1:21:36] we had business owners who were operating out of their home.
[1:21:41] Yeah, and that'd be a short-term rental understanding
[1:21:43] that definitions are important.
[1:21:44] We just talked about that.
[1:21:46] They are.
[1:21:46] An hour ago, it is not a business.
[1:21:49] Yeah, the state legislature does, in terms of that,
[1:21:53] as they have the ability to do.
[1:21:56] Okay, Sherry, Vomer.
[1:21:59] I would, I would move to have staff take a look at this.
[1:22:04] I think there's a big difference between a one bedroom Airbnb.
[1:22:07] Somebody stays out for a few days or that a family goes and visits for a few days.
[1:22:12] I know my family is used one up to 12 to 15 people, but we have been very respectful.
[1:22:17] This is something that isn't a grander level.
[1:22:22] So I would like to see staff look into this and be cautious of our property rights as
[1:22:29] as well as the whole R&B.
[1:22:33] Can I clarify, is there a level we're looking at,
[1:22:35] like over 20 people, over 15 people,
[1:22:38] a square footage or?
[1:22:39] So I don't have that number, but yes.
[1:22:42] Now I'm careful with square footage as well.
[1:22:45] I think that's where I would kind of like to see staff
[1:22:49] go look into this a little bit,
[1:22:50] and then maybe we can start looking into this.
[1:22:53] Yeah, so metamare, what I'm hearing
[1:22:55] is that you would like staff to begin the process
[1:22:59] potentially creating an outline to construct an ordinance that would create balance between
[1:23:05] what state code requires for short-term rentals, balancing private property rights, as well as
[1:23:13] not only neighborhood rights, right, because oftentimes when we think about private property rights,
[1:23:19] it's about the one owner, but we cannot miss the private property rights of the other individual
[1:23:24] owners that are in and around the neighborhood.
[1:23:27] That sounds good.
[1:23:30] So just so you know we don't vote on this, just head nod.
[1:23:34] Yes.
[1:23:35] I know there's a couple other comments, Spencer.
[1:23:37] Did you want to say something?
[1:23:39] Yeah, I'd like to share my thoughts with council and staff.
[1:23:41] Just we need to do something because these are becoming so
[1:23:46] common pretty soon.
[1:23:47] If it's known that Twin Falls is a somewhat
[1:23:50] metropolis metropolitan area that has no regulation,
[1:23:54] It's going to be a target.
[1:23:56] And so I think if we do something now proactively,
[1:23:58] it'll save us a lot of headaches in the future.
[1:24:01] But to give some guidance to staff,
[1:24:04] I would hate to see that every single one has to be licensed.
[1:24:07] That creates a lot more work for staff and things like that.
[1:24:11] But if this was something as simple as an ordinance
[1:24:13] that provides some basic structure,
[1:24:16] that it could be as simple as a code compliance issue.
[1:24:18] If this is the same as calling because there's
[1:24:20] a vacant lot that hasn't had weeds taken care of for six months
[1:24:24] It seems to be that would be a lot easier than having a whole, well, I think I've said what
[1:24:32] I mean to say.
[1:24:33] Councilmember, I would just allow us to kind of build something.
[1:24:37] It does require an ordinance or a licensure process.
[1:24:42] I know that members of our team have been incredibly skilled using technology for the creation of licensure.
[1:24:49] see what that looks like. What is important for us to know is what businesses or what
[1:24:57] entities are truly out there. We don't know that unless we have some record of that. And so
[1:25:04] it may not necessarily be a licensure, but it may be a registry of some sort.
[1:25:10] Members of our team have been advocating for business licensure.
[1:25:13] and that conversation is you have to understand who they are and where they're
[1:25:21] coming from to be able to begin to construct that list from the beginning so
[1:25:26] I thank you with that said I will trust the experts to offer us something to
[1:25:32] vote on thank you yeah I just I I the my thoughts were clarified I didn't want
[1:25:39] step out there to say we were doing it all.
[1:25:41] Okay, so I think we have that message, Claire, Jonathan. Thank you. Um, so that is it with
[1:25:50] the exception of advisory board reports. I'm not sure anybody's had time to go to a meeting
[1:25:55] yet. Anything from the city manager's office? It's been alluded to, but just again for additional
[1:26:01] clarification while we typically meet on Monday evenings. If I have a clock next Monday
[1:26:07] is Martin Luther King Jr. Holiday and with Monday holidays our meetings get
[1:26:14] kicked to Tuesday so our next regular scheduled meeting will be Tuesday at
[1:26:18] five o'clock p.m. Thank you. Okay with that being said our meetings adjourned.
[1:26:23] Thank you everyone.
