Oversight Archive: City Council meeting, 2024-03-11, recording 1 (started 16:58)
Machine transcript (faster-whisper base.en), not checked word for word; the Pledge of Allegiance is shown in its standard wording. The recording is the record.
Times are time into the recording. Passages with private details are muted in the audio and marked here.
The audio on the page below was re-encoded by software from the video the agency posted. Check any passage against
that audio before relying on it.
Page: https://oversightarchive.org/twin-falls-id/meetings/2024-03-11/

[0:00:23] Can you hear me, Sherry?
[0:00:25] All right, so it can hear me.
[0:00:27] We can. Thank you.
[0:00:28] Good. Thank you.
[0:01:49] Good evening, ladies and gentlemen, and welcome to the March 11,
[0:01:52] 2024 city council meeting. I want to confirm we have a quorum.
[0:01:57] We have six members present in chambers and councilwoman Vomer is on the telephone.
[0:02:03] So first, this is a very crowded group here.
[0:02:08] In fact, I will say that in my nine years, I think this is the largest group of Girl Scouts we've had.
[0:02:15] So I'm going to ask you ladies to please come down to the front and help us say the Pledge of Allegiance.
[0:02:24] That will be the first item on the agenda.
[0:02:26] So if you could come down and then after we're done with that, I want you to introduce yourself by saying your first name and what troop you're in.
[0:02:36] So come on down if everybody would please rise for the Pledge of Allegiance
[0:02:46] are you ladies ready?
[0:02:57] Somebody start.
[0:03:00] I pledge allegiance to the Flag of the United States of America, and to the Republic for which it stands, one Nation under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all.
[0:03:19] Perfect. Excellent.
[0:03:22] Okay, don't sit down yet.
[0:03:24] So you're each going to take a turn. Can somebody turn on the mic?
[0:03:29] It's that I think they could do both of them depending on their height.
[0:03:43] My name is Juliana.
[0:03:46] My group number is 988.
[0:03:57] My name is Emma and my group number is 988.
[0:04:07] My name is Haley.
[0:04:11] It's 998.
[0:04:12] My name is not X and my name is Juliana.
[0:04:28] My name is Ella, and I'm 998.
[0:04:35] My name is Cecily, and I'm troop 984.
[0:04:41] My name is Gabby, and my troop number is 984.
[0:04:49] My name is Calvin Smith.
[0:04:52] My troop numbers.
[0:05:01] My name is Clara Troop.
[0:05:04] 984.
[0:05:09] My name is Paisley Troop, 419.
[0:05:22] My name is Josie, and I'm in 48.
[0:05:28] My name is Grace and I'm in troop for 614.
[0:05:38] My name is Grandma and I'm in troop 614.
[0:05:43] My name is Kira and I'm in troop for 18.
[0:05:48] My name is Sarah Fina and I'm in troop 173.
[0:05:54] My name is Zoe and I am in troop.
[0:06:01] My name is Piper and I'm in 418.
[0:06:11] My name is Violet and I'm in troop 418.
[0:06:14] My name is Ayan, and I'm into 141.73.
[0:06:26] My name is Lily, and my trip number is 173.
[0:06:34] My name is Cara, and I'm from 370.
[0:06:41] My name is Elena, and I'm in 966.
[0:06:46] My name is Joanna, and I'm in 264.
[0:06:53] My name is Emily, and I'm from 614.
[0:07:08] My name is Allison, and I am from 614.
[0:07:13] My name is Lily, and I'm from 966.
[0:07:18] Here, and I'm from troop 966.
[0:07:28] My name's Athena, and I'm from troop 966.
[0:07:31] Here we are.
[0:07:34] I'm Kia.
[0:07:35] And I'm a fan.
[0:07:39] My name's Mae Kinsey, and I'm from 418.
[0:07:50] My name is Julianna, I'm from 418.
[0:07:56] My name is Kay Lee, I'm my troop is 614.
[0:08:04] My name is Isabel, and our troop member is 614.
[0:08:12] My name is Ashlynna, and I'm troop 14.
[0:08:21] My name is Abigail, and I'm from troop 470.
[0:08:26] My name is Marie, and I'm from troop 470.
[0:08:29] My name is Victoria, and I'm from troop 470.
[0:08:34] My name is Okela, I'm from troop 470.
[0:08:38] My name is Alexis, I'm from Chup 470.
[0:08:40] My name is Julia and I'm from Chup 470.
[0:08:45] My name is Emily and I'm from Chup 470.
[0:08:48] My name is Gracie and I'm from Chup 470.
[0:08:53] My name is Lulu and I'm Chup 470.
[0:09:00] My name is Mercy and I'm from Chup 614.
[0:09:09] My name is Kaedalain, I'm Chup 470.
[0:09:14] My name is Kayla and I'm Chup 470.
[0:09:17] That's it?
[0:09:22] Perfect.
[0:09:23] Thank you, ladies.
[0:09:24] Okay.
[0:09:31] Next on the agenda, of course, is the proclamation for Girl Scout Week.
[0:09:36] It's the week of March 10th through 16th, 2024, whereas March 12th marks the 112th anniversary
[0:09:44] of Girl Scouts of the USA, founded by Juliet Gordon Lowe in 1912 in Savannah, Georgia, and
[0:09:51] Whereas throughout its long and distinguished history,
[0:09:55] Girl Scouting has inspired millions of girls and women
[0:09:59] with the highest ideals of character, conduct,
[0:10:02] and patriotism, including 6,000 current members
[0:10:06] of Girl Scouts of Silver Sage.
[0:10:09] And whereas Girl Scouts of Silver Sage
[0:10:11] provides a space for its Girl Scouts to dream big,
[0:10:14] be themselves, and find a venture.
[0:10:18] They have made a difference in our community for many years.
[0:10:21] and whereas every girl deserves the opportunity to thrive
[0:10:25] and through its programming, Girl Scouts of Silver Sage
[0:10:28] works to ensure girls in our communities
[0:10:31] know they can do anything they put their minds to doing
[0:10:35] and encourages them to feel empowered
[0:10:37] and embrace their unique strengths.
[0:10:40] And whereas more than 2.6 million current Girl Scout members
[0:10:44] nationwide will be celebrating 112 years
[0:10:48] of this American tradition with nearly 50 million women
[0:10:53] who are former Girl Scouts and living proof
[0:10:56] of the impact of this amazing movement.
[0:10:59] Now, therefore, I, Ruth Pierce,
[0:11:01] Mayor of the City of Twin Falls,
[0:11:03] do hereby applaud the commitment Girl Scouting has made
[0:11:07] to America's Girls and Proudly Program,
[0:11:10] the week of Sunday, March 10th as Girl Scout Week.
[0:11:14] So, who's coming down?
[0:11:16] Jackie, are you gonna get this?
[0:12:05] Thank you.
[0:12:12] We appreciate it.
[0:12:13] Our service unit has doubled this year, as you can see, and it's a lot of fun, like that,
[0:12:18] more than the more.
[0:12:19] Everybody's done a good job.
[0:12:20] Thank you.
[0:12:21] Thank you for all your commitment.
[0:12:22] And the cookies.
[0:12:23] What's that?
[0:12:24] Yes, I'll give you a minute to do that.
[0:12:27] You probably want your basket, so you know, ladies, this is our favorite meeting as we get
[0:13:00] cookies as long as you don't talk with your mouthful.
[0:13:32] So I'm going to take a break for just a minute and allow all of you to leave unless you're
[0:13:38] anxious to sit through the entire meeting.
[0:13:42] So go ahead.
[0:13:43] We'll take a break.
[0:15:20] Okay, so we'll move on to the consent calendar.
[0:15:30] Move to approve.
[0:15:32] Thank you.
[0:15:33] Do I have a second?
[0:15:34] Second.
[0:15:35] Thank you.
[0:15:36] Motion by Chris Reed.
[0:15:37] to approve the consent calendar as written.
[0:15:42] Amy Rokalvo, please.
[0:15:44] Ruth Pierce?
[0:15:45] Yes.
[0:15:46] Chris Reed?
[0:15:47] Yes.
[0:15:48] Craig Hawkins?
[0:15:49] Yes.
[0:15:50] Jason Brown?
[0:15:51] Yes.
[0:15:52] Spencer Cutler?
[0:15:53] Yes.
[0:15:54] Grayson Stone?
[0:15:55] Yes.
[0:15:56] And Sherry Vollmer.
[0:15:58] Yes.
[0:15:59] Thank you.
[0:16:01] Motion passes seven to zero.
[0:16:02] Okay.
[0:16:03] So under item consideration, our first item is an action item.
[0:16:06] The Twin Falls Public Library requests approval to enter into a joint powers agreement with
[0:16:13] the Lynx Libraries Consortium and we have our library director, Tara Bartley.
[0:16:19] Welcome, Tara.
[0:16:20] Mayor Pierce, Council Members, thank you for giving me the opportunity to stand in front
[0:16:32] of you tonight.
[0:16:33] I come to you today and ask for and request your approval to enter into a joint powers agreement
[0:16:41] with the Lynx Library Consortium.
[0:16:44] Just to give you a little bit of background,
[0:16:45] what the Lynx Consortium is, it started in the 1970s
[0:16:49] and Twin Falls Public Library is one of the first
[0:16:52] of four libraries to enter into the consortium.
[0:16:56] It originally started so that libraries could bring technology
[0:17:00] into their buildings, and it has since definitely expanded
[0:17:06] to 11 libraries that are now in the consortium,
[0:17:10] as well as a joint measure of sharing materials as well.
[0:17:15] We currently participate under a service agreement through the City of Wacie.
[0:17:22] And what we have found is that decisions that we need to make in a more timely fashion as
[0:17:28] well as just a more unified management system is no longer available under that service.
[0:17:36] So that's why we are looking to all come together and become part of a joint powers agreement.
[0:17:44] And with that, I can stand for questions.
[0:17:48] Any questions?
[0:17:49] Chris Reed, two questions for you.
[0:17:52] Exhibit B, the Lynx membership standards, are we comfortable with them and can we lift
[0:17:57] up to those standards?
[0:18:00] Yes, and I apologize.
[0:18:02] I don't have that in front of me right now.
[0:18:04] I will tell you that every city library and district library had all of their legal look
[0:18:09] at it.
[0:18:10] Every legal had the opportunity to address their concerns and we came back together, put
[0:18:18] all of those concerns, issues, and then the final agreement is what you have in front of
[0:18:23] you.
[0:18:24] Perfect.
[0:18:25] Second question with us.
[0:18:26] All right.
[0:18:27] I mentioned a board for the Lynx system who will be sitting on the board representing Twin
[0:18:32] Falls.
[0:18:33] I want.
[0:18:34] You are perfect.
[0:18:35] Yeah.
[0:18:36] Thank you.
[0:18:37] Thank you.
[0:18:38] Any other questions for Tara Spencer?
[0:18:40] I'm ready to make a motion.
[0:18:41] I'd move that we approve the library entering into a joint powers agreement with the Lynx
[0:18:47] Library Consortium.
[0:18:48] Thank you.
[0:18:49] Grace and Stone.
[0:18:50] On a mirror I'll second.
[0:18:52] Thank you.
[0:18:53] Motion by Spencer Cutler.
[0:18:54] Second by Grace and Stone to approve the Twin Falls Public Library entering in a joint powers
[0:19:00] agreement with the Lynx Library Consortium. Any further discussion? Amy Rollkavo, please?
[0:19:09] Chris Reed. Yes. Craig Hawkins. Jason Brown. Yes.
[0:19:13] Bencer Cutler. Yes. Jason Stone. Yes. Barry Bomer. Yes. And Ruth Pierce. Yes.
[0:19:21] Thank you. Motion passes 7-0. Thank you, Tara. If you just leave it up here,
[0:19:31] then I can... I've got a bunch of stuff to sign. You can leave it with Amy. Yep.
[0:19:35] Thank you. Okay, next item on the agenda is an action item, a request to adopt
[0:19:43] Ordinance 2024-005 to amend Twin Falls City Code by amending Title 10-14-3.2 OT
[0:19:53] Old Town District to include ambulance services as an outright permitted use
[0:19:59] and we have William Claver, our senior planner, welcome William. Thank you Madam
[0:20:04] Mayor and good evening to all the council members as well.
[0:20:08] Today we have before us a request to adopt an ordinance
[0:20:13] to allow for ambulance services on the Old Town District.
[0:20:18] Just a little bit of background and history.
[0:20:21] On January 23rd of 2024, the Planning and Zoning Commission
[0:20:27] sent a positive recommendation to the City Council
[0:20:30] for the zoning title amendments.
[0:20:34] And then also, and then the application was then brought forward to City Council on February 26th of 2024.
[0:20:42] And after discussion, voted to approve the zoning title amendment.
[0:20:50] Should the Council wish to approve this today, you would need to have
[0:21:03] to have one-half plus one of the members of the full council vote in approval.
[0:21:15] That means there would be a motion can generally, such as I move to dispense with the reading rules,
[0:21:22] replace ordinance 2024-005 on third and final reading by title only.
[0:21:28] should that pass then you can go forward with another motion to say I
[0:21:34] approve the ordinance 2024 0 0 5 as presented with that I'll stand for any
[0:21:40] questions thank you Chris free I'll make the motion for ready I don't have any
[0:21:45] are we good do you guys have questions no you're good we just saw this two weeks
[0:21:49] ago so I move that we dispense with the reading rules input ordinance 2024
[0:21:55] Thank you, Grace and Stone.
[0:22:02] Thank you. Motion by Chris.
[0:22:05] Three seconded by Grace and Stone to put ordinance 2024 dash
[0:22:10] zero zero five and third and final reading by title only.
[0:22:14] Amy roll call vote please.
[0:22:18] Craig Hawkins.
[0:22:19] Jason Brown.
[0:22:20] Spencer Cutler.
[0:22:21] Yes.
[0:22:22] Grayson Stone.
[0:22:23] Yes.
[0:22:24] Jerry Bulmer.
[0:22:25] Yes.
[0:22:26] Yes, and Chris Reed. Yes. Thank you motion passes 7 to 0. So I'll read the ordinance number for or the ordinance first
[0:22:35] Ordinance number 2024 dash 0 0 5 an ordinance of the city council of the city of Twin Falls
[0:22:42] Idaho
[0:22:43] Regarding the regulation and administration in the city of Twin Falls and area of impact amending Twin Falls city code by amending title
[0:22:52] 10-4-13.2 OT Old Town District to include ambulance services as an outright permitted use.
[0:23:01] Jason Brown. There's no discussion. I'd move to adopt Ordinance 2024-005 to amend the Twin Falls
[0:23:11] City Code. Thank you, Grace and Stone. Madam Mayor, I second. Thank you, motion by Jason
[0:23:17] Brown seconder by Grayson Stone to adopt Ordinance 2024-005. Any further
[0:23:25] discussion? Amy Rokal vote please. Jason Brown yes. Spencer Cutler yes.
[0:23:32] Grayson Stone yes. Perry Blomar yes. Ruth Pierce yes.
[0:23:37] Yes. Chris Reed yes. And Craig Hawkins yes. Thank you motion passes 7-0.
[0:23:42] Okay, next item on the agenda is an action item, a request to adopt Ordinance 2024-006,
[0:23:52] amending the Addison Springs Subdivision Zoning Development Agreement and changes to the Subdivision
[0:23:59] Master Plan.
[0:24:00] And we have William Clayver, welcome, again, still?
[0:24:03] Thank you Madam Mayor.
[0:24:07] Just I'll go through the background on this one as well.
[0:24:11] ordinances to amend the Addison Spring Sub-visions Zoning Development Agreement.
[0:24:18] Those items were listed with the updating of the master plan and then also allowing for extended
[0:24:35] after retail hours. And then also for doing, allowing for the drive through. This was this
[0:24:50] one before planning and zoning commission on January 23rd, 2024, which they recommended
[0:24:56] approval to to the city council on February 26th, 2024. The council heard an after discussion
[0:25:05] I voted to approve this ordinance as well.
[0:25:09] The same process that we just discussed
[0:25:11] with dispensing of the rules with needing one half plus one
[0:25:16] members of the full council to authorize an action.
[0:25:20] The sample motion is high move we dispense
[0:25:24] with the readings rules and place ordinance of 20,
[0:25:26] 4, 0, 0, 6, and third and final read-off by a title,
[0:25:30] that go forward. We would go forward with, I move to approve the ordinance.
[0:25:37] Thank you, Chris Reed. As William stated, and this is something we just saw a few weeks ago, so I'm ready to make a motion if there's any other discussion.
[0:25:47] I think we're good. I move that we dispense with the reading rules and put ordinance 2024-006 on third and final reading by title only.
[0:25:56] Thank you, Grayson Stone. Madam Mayor, I'll second. Thank you. Most of I, Chris, read.
[0:26:00] This read seconded by Grayson Stone to dispense with the rules and put Ordinance 2024-006
[0:26:08] on third and final reading by title only.
[0:26:10] Jason Brown.
[0:26:11] Okay.
[0:26:13] Amy Roll call vote please.
[0:26:18] Spencer Butler.
[0:26:19] Yes.
[0:26:22] Grayson Stone.
[0:26:23] Yes.
[0:26:24] Jerry Vomer.
[0:26:25] Yes.
[0:26:26] Ruth Pierce.
[0:26:27] Yes.
[0:26:28] Yes.
[0:26:29] Reid.
[0:26:30] Yes.
[0:26:31] Craig Hawkins.
[0:26:32] Yes.
[0:26:33] And Jason Brown.
[0:26:34] passes 7-0. Read the ordinance number 2024-006, an ordinance of the City Council of the City
[0:26:43] of Twin Falls, Idaho, amending the Addison Spring Subdivision Zoning Development Agreement
[0:26:49] and changes to the Subdivision Master Plan. Jason Brown.
[0:26:54] I move to adopt ordinance 2024-006, amending the Addison Spring Subdivision Zoning Development
[0:27:03] and changes to the subdivision master plan.
[0:27:07] Thank you.
[0:27:09] Grace and Stone?
[0:27:10] Madam Mayor, I'll second.
[0:27:11] Thank you.
[0:27:12] Motion by Jason Brown, seconded by Grace and Stone to adopt Ordinance 2024-006 as presented.
[0:27:20] Amy Roll call vote please.
[0:27:23] Grace and Stone?
[0:27:24] Yes.
[0:27:25] Sherry Volmer?
[0:27:26] Yes.
[0:27:27] Bruce Pierce?
[0:27:28] Yes.
[0:27:29] Chris Reed?
[0:27:30] Yes.
[0:27:31] Craig Hawkins?
[0:27:32] Yes.
[0:27:33] Jason Brown?
[0:27:35] Yes.
[0:27:36] Thank you, William.
[0:27:38] Okay.
[0:27:39] Next item on the agenda is an action item, a request to authorize the use of $100,000 of
[0:27:47] street light fund reserves to complete the planned street luminaire replacement program.
[0:27:54] We have Mitch Humboldt, our deputy city manager.
[0:27:57] Thank you.
[0:27:58] Welcome, Mitch.
[0:28:01] This item tonight was going to impact our IT department or engineering department and they were all fighting about who get to come make the presentation. So I just said, I'm going to do it.
[0:28:10] This is a good way. Thank you. We want no fighting. No fighting. No fighting. Really Bud really wanted to come down and do it. He's on his way. I see that.
[0:28:21] Okay, so briefly, the 2024 budget included $45,000 to replace some aging street lights
[0:28:33] and include $70,000 for the city to install new street lights in new subdivisions.
[0:28:40] And if you all remember recently, a few months ago, we adopted an ordinance amendment that
[0:28:45] says the sub-divider is now going to be responsible for that.
[0:28:48] And that's great.
[0:28:49] And we love that.
[0:28:51] that, that only takes effect for subdivisions that were applied for after that change in
[0:28:55] the code.
[0:28:56] So we have several that are in process that we're still responsible for, and those will
[0:29:00] come along the way as we go through the next, I don't know, two, three years, maybe, and
[0:29:04] we're still going to have to budget for these and we're still going to do these.
[0:29:07] At the end of fiscal year 23, we had a big backlog of subdivisions that were ready to go.
[0:29:12] And so as soon as the budget started in October, engineering went out and they spent all that
[0:29:17] money all that $70,000 and the $45,000 for the replacing of the old ones. I think actually
[0:29:23] a little bit more, like $10,000. And so they wiped through that whole fund. And so if you
[0:29:27] all remember when we do budgeting, the street life fund is a separate fund in the city's
[0:29:31] budget. It's dedicated to street luminaires. It pays for the electric bill that we get
[0:29:36] for all those street lights and then these two things and then maintenance. And so it
[0:29:41] It has to be used for this, it's funded with our electric utility, franchise fee.
[0:29:46] These are the purpose of these funds, and we still have that $45,000 replacement program
[0:29:53] that we would like to implement, as well as more subdivisions are coming in.
[0:29:57] And so we are talking about it, and the Streetlife Fund actually has a bit of a reserve, a little
[0:30:02] bit more than $400,000 in reserve that can only be used for these projects.
[0:30:06] we decided we would come ask for $100,000.
[0:30:10] That should give the street guys plenty of money
[0:30:12] to do the replacement program and the engineering team
[0:30:16] some more money to deal with these incoming subdivisions
[0:30:19] for the next six or so months that are left
[0:30:21] in this fiscal year.
[0:30:22] And so with that, the request is just to authorize $100,000
[0:30:25] of the street life fund reserves to be put
[0:30:28] into the fiscal year 24 budget so that we can continue
[0:30:30] this work that we started.
[0:30:32] And if you have any questions, I'm sure we've got people
[0:30:34] or they can help answer it.
[0:30:35] Okay.
[0:30:36] Craig Hawkins.
[0:30:37] I'd like to make a motion for any questions for Mitch.
[0:30:42] Okay.
[0:30:43] Great.
[0:30:44] Go ahead.
[0:30:45] I'd like to make a motion that we approve requests to authorize the use of $100,000, a
[0:30:50] street lighting fund reserves to complete the planned street illumination replacement program.
[0:30:56] Thank you.
[0:30:57] Jason Brown.
[0:30:58] I'll second.
[0:30:59] Thank you.
[0:31:00] Motion by Craig Hawkins.
[0:31:01] Seconded by Jason Brown to approve the request to use.
[0:31:05] $100,000 in street light reserve funds to complete the planned street luminaire replacement
[0:31:11] program. Any further discussion? Amy Rokov please?
[0:31:16] Sherry Vomer. Yes. Ruth Pierce. Yes. Chris Reed. Yes. Craig Hawkins. Yes. Jason Brown. Yes.
[0:31:25] Spencer Cutler. Yes. And Grayson Stone. Yes. Thank you. Motion passes 7-0. Thank you
[0:31:32] Next item on the agenda is an update, an action item, it says an action item, an update on
[0:31:39] progress of the exceptional hardship deferral for building permit 22.0100 Rob Green on date.
[0:31:47] Dealership and we have our planning and zoning director, Jonathan Spinnlove. Welcome, Jonathan.
[0:31:53] Oh, Mayor, members of the Council.
[0:31:58] So I was asked to bring this back.
[0:32:01] It has an update.
[0:32:02] I did not plan on going through the entire...
[0:32:05] That's okay.
[0:32:06] I think we're good.
[0:32:11] Okay.
[0:32:12] What we'll go through or what I'll just kind of briefly touch on is on some dates.
[0:32:18] Late December we had a final inspection request and I'm just going to read down through the
[0:32:22] history real quick in the staff report.
[0:32:25] In January, we received the written request and then we got to some city council meetings,
[0:32:34] some consecutive weeks that you put it to a different date.
[0:32:37] Eventually we got written request for certain dates on certain items to be accomplished.
[0:32:43] That's in Europe packet, the original list that was agreed upon.
[0:32:47] February 15th was the date to have, was the first deadline that the applicant placed on
[0:32:53] themselves for the stormwater retention and then between February 15th and March 6th
[0:32:59] we've had a little bit of correspondence on the stormwater retention and as of right
[0:33:05] now today we do not have compliance with the stormwater retention and where we don't
[0:33:10] have compliance takes a little bit of explanation. There is a hole dug on the
[0:33:16] property the issue comes in a paperwork problem. We do not have the
[0:33:22] the engineered calculations for what the correct size is supposed to be for the retention.
[0:33:27] We requested that back on January 22nd to get the correct calculations for the stormwater
[0:33:36] retention.
[0:33:37] The engineer has not delivered that to us.
[0:33:40] So, today we don't have the paperwork to know what size the retention is supposed to
[0:33:45] be so that we could do an adequate inspection.
[0:33:49] That's where we're at in terms of compliance.
[0:33:50] There's no, I call it a paperwork issue.
[0:33:54] I don't have an official application or a revision or change order.
[0:33:58] But today, as of I think it was three o'clock when I looked,
[0:34:02] we still have not received an official application.
[0:34:05] That would be March 11th.
[0:34:10] I can go through the list if you'd like to see
[0:34:11] what the next deadlines are.
[0:34:13] Otherwise, I will just stand for questions and discussion
[0:34:16] on what you would prefer as you ask us to bring it back.
[0:34:21] OK.
[0:34:22] Thank you, Jonathan.
[0:34:22] Grayson.
[0:34:23] Yeah, Director Spindlof, quick question.
[0:34:25] What is our outreach been?
[0:34:27] as far as not being in compliance. Has it been emails, has it been phone calls? So my
[0:34:33] question is in what kind would have we reached out to them in the frequency?
[0:34:37] Yeah, we have reached out probably every other week. I don't have the exact dates.
[0:34:44] Besides having the public meetings where they were here and the dates that they
[0:34:48] gave us, we expected them to apply for the items we needed and we gave them a
[0:34:53] a couple emails like one email after,
[0:34:56] and then I gave them an email, the date that you requested it.
[0:35:00] Sent them, saying, here's what we're looking for,
[0:35:02] this is a non-compliance.
[0:35:04] Let me go through all of them.
[0:35:06] January 22nd, January 26th, we gave them the CFO.
[0:35:12] It was on January 26th,
[0:35:14] or that day is from near there.
[0:35:18] Engineering had some correspondence
[0:35:20] with the engineer of record,
[0:35:23] and then I let them know the date
[0:35:24] the February 15th that it expired or that they passed their deadline and then I let
[0:35:30] them know again the day that you requested this come back to you. And then
[0:35:33] the follow-up question director is that traditional for or is that frequency of
[0:35:38] communication traditional with folks that are out of compliance? No that's
[0:35:44] more. Okay perfect. Jason Brown. So Jonathan you said that there was a storm
[0:35:52] water retention swell that was was dug in the not a sufficient paperwork to verify
[0:36:02] whether it was installed according to the engineer of record is that correct yeah
[0:36:07] so there's a storm water swell dug that was not part of the original approved
[0:36:11] plans that were issued by the city the engineer of record did go out and do a
[0:36:17] I said they did like a scan which is imaging to verify the size we got that
[0:36:23] drawing back and when we are looking at that drawing compared to the size that is required
[0:36:29] we don't have the original engineering calculations for the amount of stormwater it's supposed to contain.
[0:36:34] Now I'm going to show a quick visual to help you explain a bit more. We're at up here because Google is going to be the best bet.
[0:36:44] So while you're pulling that up, Jonathan, we have dimensions, we just don't have all of the dimensions that are necessary to do the calculations on our
[0:36:58] site is that correct or they haven't provided the methodology that they've
[0:37:03] sized it by yeah I'm gonna go through I think I can maybe answer that okay this
[0:37:09] is the Rob Green Hyundai this is the Rob Green Nissan up here the original
[0:37:15] stormwater containment area encompassed both properties it was shallow and
[0:37:21] encompassed both areas okay when they came through to modify this building in
[0:37:26] this area, there would have been a calculation made by the
[0:37:29] engineer record to say here, this area is either of sufficient
[0:37:32] size or they'll modify it to what they need, okay? We issued a
[0:37:38] building permit, what was constructed on the site did not
[0:37:41] match what was issued for the permit. And so we're asking for
[0:37:44] extra verification as to whether the size is correct.
[0:37:48] Additionally, when we go out there, and as you can see on
[0:37:50] this aerial, this is all filled in and has been modified with
[0:37:54] construction material and debris, dirt, sand, concrete, asphalt, grindings. This is
[0:38:00] where this stormwater was supposed to be. Since it was filled in, it was modified
[0:38:04] and we need to re-ferrify. Our issue is we don't know what this is supposed to
[0:38:11] be to accomplish or accommodate the entire site owned by both dealerships
[0:38:15] because they've been modified. So we've been asking for that paperwork.
[0:38:20] Does that satisfy our... Yeah, and that paperwork is coming through the
[0:38:25] the contractor or the engineer of record. Engineer record is responsible for the
[0:38:30] stormwater plans. Our code says that any stormwater plan is to be drawn up and
[0:38:35] stamped by an engineer licensed in the state of Idaho. The city is to check the
[0:38:41] work but the plan is theirs and their responsibility. And there's been no
[0:38:45] response from that engineer of record at this point.
[0:38:50] There's no response. We've had a couple phone call exchanges and some emails to
[0:38:55] detail the issue, but we do not have an official application or change order to get this accomplished.
[0:39:02] And in those conversations, there was no indication of when they would have that documentation
[0:39:08] up to us. So they've, I'll use the word violated, violated their own timeline that they provided
[0:39:18] us after our conversation in council meeting a month or so ago.
[0:39:26] Yes, February 15th was the date to have that accomplished.
[0:39:29] That they gave and I had it pulled up and I probably,
[0:39:32] yeah, no, you're fine, there it is.
[0:39:34] You have February 15th as a stormwater retention swale.
[0:39:38] I'm being very specific, there is a whole dug or a swale dug,
[0:39:42] we just can't verify what the size is supposed to be
[0:39:45] because we're not short.
[0:39:46] Your next deadlines, looking through this,
[0:39:49] some of them are May, may have told somebody April,
[0:39:52] but May 1st is some other items
[0:39:54] And then in the end, July 1st, with a lot of the other items.
[0:39:59] If I remember correctly, and I apologize, I was gone for that specific date with all of
[0:40:06] this, but I was there the week before or two weeks before.
[0:40:11] We considered one of this as a safety issue if my memory serves me correct, Council, if
[0:40:20] I need to be corrected, that's okay.
[0:40:23] Yeah, from an engineering standpoint,
[0:40:25] we'd say the storm water is the largest of these items
[0:40:28] in terms of safety issues.
[0:40:30] There's other things connected to it,
[0:40:31] but how you sheet flow, the parking lot to the front
[0:40:36] to the back, where does the water go?
[0:40:37] If it doesn't go to the back, is it gonna go to a neighbor
[0:40:39] and cause damage to a neighboring property?
[0:40:42] See another member wants to ask some questions,
[0:40:45] so I'll hold a few and just kind of think about this
[0:40:47] for a second, thanks.
[0:40:48] Thank you, Chris-Ree.
[0:40:50] I believe it was January 15th, we had the council meeting.
[0:40:54] So from January 15th, this document was submitted to us via an email from their attorney, and
[0:41:04] these are dates they set themselves.
[0:41:07] From January 15th, when we had the council meeting to February 15th, what was the communication
[0:41:15] back from them?
[0:41:17] Did they try?
[0:41:18] Did they attempt and fail?
[0:41:19] or is this just put in and really no communication
[0:41:22] at that up to the up till February 15th?
[0:41:26] If her email is dated the 11th of January,
[0:41:33] that would have been the meeting before probably.
[0:41:36] It was a Thursday before the Monday
[0:41:38] that we said we needed some items.
[0:41:47] These are the emails we received and were sent.
[0:41:50] I don't see anything until the 16th when I noticed
[0:41:57] the deadline passed.
[0:42:00] I believe they were trying to remember if there was a phone call between the engineer and myself
[0:42:06] or if it would happen before the 16th or not.
[0:42:13] Okay, so they set their own timeline and didn't achieve their own timeline?
[0:42:19] Yes.
[0:42:21] Okay.
[0:42:22] Have you had any conversations with the contractor on this or their attorney who was representing
[0:42:31] them that day?
[0:42:32] I have not had any contact with their attorney.
[0:42:35] contractor wrote an email in I think response this last week looking for if
[0:42:43] I save that or not here to have to say that but it wasn't directed at me was
[0:42:50] directed at other staff members yes you specifically do you have anything to
[0:42:57] add I see Mitch is no I think that Jonathan's done a good job in covering
[0:43:05] the background in the history there was an email exchange I know that Mr.
[0:43:10] Rick's is here potentially to represent some of the interests of the client, the
[0:43:17] developer and the attorney are not present this evening. I'm just kind of
[0:43:20] noting that for the record. I don't know if you want to have a conversation with
[0:43:25] him and I don't know what information he might be able to provide but in setting
[0:43:31] the stage for the evening I said that the council would probably really want to
[0:43:35] be focusing on solutions. I think there's an appreciation and understanding how
[0:43:41] We got to this place and the steps that have been taken over the course of the last few months.
[0:43:46] And really tonight's meeting at the request of the council is to understand,
[0:43:52] be interested from staff, the current status, and understanding of where the project is today in relationship to the timeline that was submitted by Ms. Redmond on behalf of the developers in advance of the January meeting.
[0:44:09] Mitch, did you have something you know?
[0:44:15] I was just going to remind the council that Travis already did this.
[0:44:19] The architect for the project is here.
[0:44:21] Okay.
[0:44:22] Rest of them are not.
[0:44:23] And I'm sure he would like to have something.
[0:44:26] I'll let Grayson speak and then we'll have the architect come in.
[0:44:31] Yeah, thank you Madam Mayor.
[0:44:32] And I think we kind of alluded to what my question was going to kind of hit on, but in the spirit of appreciating what we went through to get to this point.
[0:44:42] we put them on notice that we were requesting an update tonight correct?
[0:44:46] Yep, that's what the February 28th email to them was.
[0:44:50] Thank you. Thank you.
[0:44:52] Okay, Mr. Rex, did you want to come up and speak? Not really.
[0:45:02] Is that?
[0:45:04] I read my mind.
[0:45:07] You wear it on your shoulder.
[0:45:09] So, just a little information.
[0:45:15] So, during the construction of the project, we were asked,
[0:45:21] We were asked by the owner and I'm going to put blame on me right now for a little bit of this mess they were in.
[0:45:29] So we were asked to revise and provide a landscaping plan where we could group the landscaping so we didn't have as many islands on the property for car display and what have you.
[0:45:43] So we did our office, we redesigned it, we went to planning and zoning and went over the layout and it was approved by planning and zoning.
[0:45:54] And where I made a mistake is I did not take that updated site plan to my civil engineer.
[0:46:01] So the civil engineering plan did not reflect the changes that we made on the site plan and that we had reviewed by planning and zoning.
[0:46:11] So, that is my fault, 100%.
[0:46:16] So, when we were going through this process, myself and the engineer were not included on
[0:46:26] the timeline.
[0:46:28] And when the timeline came out, I should have spoken up that to have my civil engineer come
[0:46:34] down and field verify and then redraw all of his civil plans based on the new landscape
[0:46:41] being planned that that timeline wasn't achievable for the civil engineer to redesign everything.
[0:46:51] The calculation is simple, but gathering the information and redrawing at all.
[0:46:56] I should have spoke up and said that is not achievable for the storm water retention.
[0:47:03] So that's kind of where we're at.
[0:47:06] I received plans today for my civil engineer, and I went and walked the site.
[0:47:16] There were a couple of items that were not drawn correctly, so I asked my civil engineer
[0:47:23] to redraw the plans.
[0:47:25] We should have had the updated plans today, but there were a couple of items that were
[0:47:30] not drawn correctly, so I asked him to revise them.
[0:47:34] We are hoping to have the plans tomorrow.
[0:47:39] Then we can submit those plans to the building department, planning and zoning, engineering,
[0:47:45] and have everything verified and as long as it's approved, then we will have the contractor
[0:47:54] update the site.
[0:47:56] Okay, so just to be clear, you were not asked to give any input on the timeline is what you're
[0:48:06] that no one reached out to you about the timeline so they committed on your
[0:48:11] behalf. Yes. Thank you. Chris Reed. The question that
[0:48:18] Colby answered there is when would we be able to get this information? Which
[0:48:23] thank you for jumping in. Thank you for your engineers doing that. Is there
[0:48:27] anything else on this list looking at it now that you could say that's not
[0:48:34] that's not going to happen?
[0:48:37] No, a lot of those items will be addressed with the plans
[0:48:42] when they come.
[0:48:43] I know that the accessible route from the sidewalk along Blue
[0:48:49] Lakes onto their property, to their front door,
[0:48:51] that's addressed on the drawings.
[0:48:55] When I was there on site today, the contractors
[0:49:00] already started to remove the landscaping where
[0:49:03] the sidewalk needs to go so that they're kind of working on that already. So it's it's it's
[0:49:09] in the works, but I don't see anything else. The water meter, I don't know that I don't
[0:49:17] know if the water meter needs to be replaced. We changed the plumbing drawings so that the
[0:49:22] water line and the water meter could remain. I don't know if existing water meters in bad
[0:49:28] condition, but the water line did not have to be replaced.
[0:49:32] Thank you.
[0:49:36] Thank you.
[0:49:37] Jason Brown.
[0:49:38] Yeah, I think Chris and I were on the same wavelength there as I think of the timelines
[0:49:44] important.
[0:49:45] And Colby, this is not directed at you, but I think we're in a situation where we're
[0:49:52] a little bit frustrated from a council perspective, and I'll even say even from a staff perspective
[0:49:59] that we've provided an opportunity for the contractor and individuals that were here the
[0:50:07] night that we spoke to and now we're sitting here trying to figure out how to navigate through
[0:50:13] some of this. Do you believe you can have those drawings touched by Wednesday so if they're
[0:50:20] not here by Wednesday we might be able to talk about this again next week because my
[0:50:26] understanding this is a temporary occupancy building permit or occupancy permit and I guess
[0:50:35] I'm to the point where I think the council has extended some call it grace to to this contractor
[0:50:43] and it doesn't seem as if we've been getting the response or at least some update you know
[0:50:50] I wouldn't want to take an action necessarily but I think this is important for us or for
[0:50:55] for me to make sure.
[0:50:56] Do you think you can get that updated to Jonathan by Wednesday?
[0:51:00] So if we had to put it on to the agenda for next week,
[0:51:03] we could have a conversation about it next week?
[0:51:06] Yes.
[0:51:08] Is that Jonathan, does that give you time to do your thing?
[0:51:13] Receiving the plans is one thing, reviewing them
[0:51:15] would be a different one.
[0:51:15] But we can verify that we've received them.
[0:51:18] And that's really what I'd be looking for,
[0:51:20] is there's some progress towards meeting these goals
[0:51:24] as we're set by the contractor and the attorney that we're here tonight, again Colby, you weren't
[0:51:32] involved, it sounds like in some of that, and so I don't want to direct those comments to
[0:51:35] specifically to you, but I think we're in a predicament here that we want to get this
[0:51:40] resolved, we want to have an understanding that we're going through this process, but we
[0:51:44] also know we can't drag this out.
[0:51:47] Yeah, and when I first saw the timeline, I should have spoke up and said that wasn't going
[0:51:54] that we couldn't meet that deadline and I didn't so I will take some blame on
[0:51:58] that also appreciate it no I just just don't want to drag this out too long
[0:52:02] yeah yes I will let the owner and the civil engineer know that this is up most
[0:52:08] important to meet the rest of the schedule and okay thank you Grayson
[0:52:18] did you have something dad yeah Mr. Rick's I appreciate you coming and accepting
[0:52:22] some liability. This is a super uncomfortable situation. It's a really remarkably uncomfortable
[0:52:28] catch-22 that we're in. I think Councilman Brown outlined pretty well the situation on
[0:52:37] how we feel about things. Director Spendlump, do we have full responsibility on liability
[0:52:42] for the TCO and issuing the final permit since we issued the TCO under extreme hardship?
[0:52:49] Are you talking about the council itself or the city?
[0:52:51] Yeah, my question is, and I'm sitting here listening to Commissioner Brown and, sorry, Commissioner Brown, Councilman Brown, since we issued the TCO, I just want to make sure that everybody's on the same page since we issued it.
[0:53:04] Are we then the body that can revoke the TCO and or issue the final billing permit?
[0:53:10] I think you, there's an attorney in the back, but I'll give you my advice.
[0:53:16] I believe since you issued it, you could revoke it.
[0:53:19] Your decision was a discretionary decision to give.
[0:53:21] Correct.
[0:53:22] I think you could revoke.
[0:53:23] When it comes time to finish, the final certificate of occupancy
[0:53:27] would go through the normal process.
[0:53:29] I would believe once it's finished,
[0:53:30] you'd have the zoning official, building official signing
[0:53:33] it say this is now done according to the plans
[0:53:36] we've issued or got it.
[0:53:38] And my question is geared just to address
[0:53:42] and I think feelings that are on the peripheral on how we move forward with this, I really
[0:53:51] do appreciate you Colby coming up and helping us navigate these timelines, why they were
[0:53:56] missed and so on and so forth.
[0:53:59] So yeah, I appreciate it.
[0:54:01] Thank you, Grayson.
[0:54:02] Great.
[0:54:03] Hawkins.
[0:54:04] I'd just like to say that, you know, we as a council, I believe all of us feel that we
[0:54:10] We want to be as accommodating as we possibly can,
[0:54:12] encourage business to expand and to come into town.
[0:54:15] But on the other hand, we also have a responsibility
[0:54:18] to make sure we uphold the ordinances and so forth.
[0:54:23] We don't want to set a precedence here,
[0:54:26] but we can always give the lenient view, I guess,
[0:54:34] make accommodations.
[0:54:35] So I think that's something to keep in mind,
[0:54:38] and I think most of us feel pretty much the same.
[0:54:42] I appreciate your candidates.
[0:54:44] Well, I thank you for not for helping the owner out here.
[0:54:49] I mean, this isn't really his fault.
[0:54:53] Some of it's my fault.
[0:54:54] Some of it's the general contractor's fault.
[0:54:56] And you did help the owner out
[0:54:59] and just putting a little more pressure on myself
[0:55:02] and the contractor, so thank you.
[0:55:05] Thank you.
[0:55:06] Thank you.
[0:55:07] Hey, everybody, good?
[0:55:08] Okay, thank you.
[0:55:19] All right, so the next item on the agenda
[0:55:22] is a discussion item.
[0:55:23] It's a request to provide feedback regarding the creation
[0:55:27] of a fee waiver reduction policy,
[0:55:30] and we have Mitch Humboldt, our deputy city manager.
[0:55:33] Welcome, Mitch.
[0:55:38] Okay, so you'll all remember over the last several months
[0:55:42] that we've had a few fee waivers come to the council,
[0:55:45] and the direction was provided.
[0:55:48] Let's look at a policy since we don't,
[0:55:51] so we don't have to just do these each time as a one-off.
[0:55:56] And so we went back and started talking about that.
[0:56:01] Specifically, I've been working with Wendy
[0:56:04] in the Parks Department and Nicole in the legal department
[0:56:06] and the three of us have been talking about various things
[0:56:09] that we could include in a policy.
[0:56:10] And so I want to walk you through tonight
[0:56:12] as a presentation that has, I think what I'm trying
[0:56:14] to do here is this makes a lot of sense to me.
[0:56:17] So if it doesn't make sense to you
[0:56:18] and you've hype up any time, right, along the way.
[0:56:23] I'm gonna walk you through a series of like seven,
[0:56:25] I think questions that we were asking ourselves
[0:56:28] to include in a policy.
[0:56:30] And then I wanna check that where we're at
[0:56:32] is kind of where you're all at.
[0:56:33] So I'm gonna throw a question up there
[0:56:35] and there's gonna be a kind of a range of
[0:56:38] where we might land on an issue
[0:56:40] with our recommendation kind of being in there.
[0:56:43] And then if we're kind of where you want us to be,
[0:56:45] then we'll just kind of move on.
[0:56:47] And just so you know, most of the time, where I think we are,
[0:56:53] where we want to be, is kind of historically represented what
[0:56:57] we've done here for the last little while, right?
[0:57:00] And so it's kind of like this is what we've done,
[0:57:02] but there's an extreme this side, and there's an extreme
[0:57:04] this side, and we could really land anywhere we want.
[0:57:07] So anyway, that's what I'm going to try and do.
[0:57:08] I'm going to walk it through, and hopefully this makes sense
[0:57:11] in the order that we're going to go.
[0:57:13] And we can just sort of talk about these things as we go.
[0:57:16] And I apologize to Sherry for not being here.
[0:57:18] I didn't realize and I did not email this to her ahead of time.
[0:57:21] So I'll just try to explain what's on the screen too.
[0:57:23] It's just words.
[0:57:24] It's not pictures or fun stuff to look at.
[0:57:27] Gold coins, though.
[0:57:29] There are gold coins, right, because we're
[0:57:31] talking about money.
[0:57:34] OK, so the first question is, what
[0:57:36] is should our general attitude be about fee waivers?
[0:57:41] On one end, you have like, we should not grant fee waivers
[0:57:43] because the taxpayers shouldn't bear that burden
[0:57:46] of an individual's request.
[0:57:47] On the other end, we have whoever wants to ask,
[0:57:50] should ask, and we should be.
[0:57:51] And then in the middle, I think is where we've been, right?
[0:57:57] Yeah, they make sense sometimes,
[0:57:58] but it really depends on the details.
[0:58:01] And so we're gonna recommend
[0:58:03] our general attitude of this polish.
[0:58:05] You should be, we're not gonna say no every time,
[0:58:08] we're not gonna say yes every time,
[0:58:09] but we're gonna look at the details and the details matter.
[0:58:13] And so we'll get into the details later,
[0:58:15] but just generally while we're here,
[0:58:17] does that seem to jive well with where you all want us to be?
[0:58:21] Right?
[0:58:23] And I'm getting head nods.
[0:58:25] Again, if you have questions about anything,
[0:58:27] or if I missed something, is there a fourth statement?
[0:58:30] We should include somewhere.
[0:58:31] Just speak up.
[0:58:33] Okay.
[0:58:35] So moving on then.
[0:58:39] Next question we ask is,
[0:58:40] who should be able to ask for waivers?
[0:58:42] And you'll see I have a couple different colored check marks
[0:58:45] here.
[0:58:46] who should request a waiver.
[0:58:48] On one end, nobody should ever request a waiver.
[0:58:50] On the other end, this is probably not what it means,
[0:58:53] but this is just different types of people.
[0:58:56] Tax-supported agencies are one that we've got requests from
[0:58:59] and that we have generally approved requests from.
[0:59:03] And so we're gonna recommend the green check,
[0:59:05] the green lights being go, right?
[0:59:08] The green ones that we continue to do that process
[0:59:11] with our tax-supported partners in the community.
[0:59:14] A couple others that we've gotten requests from that sometimes make sense and maybe sometimes
[0:59:19] don't make sense and they've got a little yellow or yellow, but maybe they're orange, I don't
[0:59:25] know, or orange is that a UT color?
[0:59:28] A caution?
[0:59:29] Anyway, yeah, let's think about it for a minute.
[0:59:30] So non-profit organizations, they might be considered, maybe depending on the details.
[0:59:37] Service clubs might be considered depending on the details.
[0:59:39] Commercial ventures, we haven't generally done that.
[0:59:42] individuals coming to ask for a fee waiver, I can remember a time when we did that, but
[0:59:48] I don't know that everybody loved the idea of doing that.
[0:59:51] So our recommendation is other tax-reported agencies are who we should be talking to, and then maybe
[0:59:56] on these other two service clubs and non-profits, maybe we should consider those, but the details
[1:00:02] matter in those ones as well.
[1:00:06] So didn't, and I'll get to you, Chris, didn't we talk about the wear and tear on the park
[1:00:15] or the road or whatever, and the fact that this organization potentially is, it's a huge
[1:00:22] money maker for them, and so a normal other than the city vendor would request a fee.
[1:00:33] So that's when you say it's kind of our judgment.
[1:00:37] Yeah, so sometimes that's the purpose of the fee, really,
[1:00:41] is to kind of help take the administrative cost of getting
[1:00:46] everything set up.
[1:00:47] Sometimes we actually can collect a little bit
[1:00:51] to cover somewhere in Tare.
[1:00:52] But most of times, if you're in a park like Western Days
[1:00:55] in the park, the fee that we collect from Western Days
[1:00:58] is not going to cover the work Tare on the park.
[1:01:00] It just isn't enough.
[1:01:03] But what we do collect maybe shouldn't be waived because there is a wear and tear in the park.
[1:01:09] On the other hand, a nonprofit organization or a service club might be, and this is where the details matter.
[1:01:15] Like for example, MavTech used to be out there, right?
[1:01:20] And MavTech is a nonprofit organization.
[1:01:23] They would oftentimes do like fun run events and they would reserve a spot on the trail.
[1:01:28] And then they would raise their funds, and then those funds would come right back to the city in ways to improve our trail system.
[1:01:34] And we often would waive those fees for a group like that, which is, again, a non-profit kind of club.
[1:01:40] So the details make a difference.
[1:01:43] Hey, Chris, as far as other, I like this so far.
[1:01:48] But other tax-supported agencies, schools, for example, individuals acting on behalf of the school.
[1:01:55] We had senior projects come in.
[1:01:58] Where would you see that falling?
[1:02:00] So if this was me, I would say the district is the other tax
[1:02:08] for identity or somebody acting on behalf of the district.
[1:02:13] A student in the project is acting on behalf of the student,
[1:02:18] not necessarily on behalf of the district.
[1:02:21] So the district oftentimes will request building permit
[1:02:24] and we routinely kind of run through that process.
[1:02:27] We've also had the highway district request flavors
[1:02:32] for impact fees, we have the county do it,
[1:02:35] and we've been pretty good about working with our tax
[1:02:38] support entities.
[1:02:40] Individuals, like the individual with the
[1:02:43] all fundraiser, I don't think he was representing the district,
[1:02:50] I think he was representing himself on that one,
[1:02:53] say maybe they're different, though that one might be a little controversial. I wouldn't
[1:03:00] put it as the district.
[1:03:07] I'd be sure, right? Jason Brown.
[1:03:10] You mentioned, I appreciate you, you've clarified a few things, but I was looking, I was thinking
[1:03:14] about the one that came to mind was the middle school cross-country meet down at Durkeys
[1:03:23] Lake.
[1:03:24] You're like reading my mind.
[1:03:26] Okay.
[1:03:27] Okay, you have it on the slide later on.
[1:03:30] That is a great time for the conversation.
[1:03:32] Okay, so I look at that and by all means someone is acting on behalf of the school district
[1:03:41] to help set some of that up.
[1:03:44] That one was a tough one for me because I look at it that the car is going down there.
[1:03:49] I would have, thinking about this a little bit more, would have liked to see maybe a reduced entry fee
[1:03:55] fee for those parents if they could work with the school to get some type of
[1:03:59] reduced entry fee down at Durkys Park and then any other bystander were not but I
[1:04:05] don't know what kind of burden that would put on Wendy and her department but
[1:04:09] to me that would that would fall into that category of a reduced fee for the
[1:04:15] participants going I participate in a lot of sporting events and I pay I pay
[1:04:22] the admission fee when I go to a Treasure Valley high school or something like that. So that
[1:04:28] is understanding as a parent that my son or daughter is participating in a athletic event,
[1:04:35] I'm going to pay some fee. But I'd like it to be reduced, sure, but I understand that.
[1:04:42] So that one's a little bit tough for me. The senior project one is really tough for me
[1:04:47] because most of those are time of that student volunteering.
[1:04:52] It's on behalf of an educational opportunity
[1:04:56] or requirement for that person, that individual.
[1:05:00] That one, I still have to think about quite a bit.
[1:05:04] But I guess that's kind of where my mind is at.
[1:05:07] And I didn't know if the service club
[1:05:09] represented that middle school cross-country meet
[1:05:12] or the high school cross-country meet
[1:05:14] or if that was something outside of that.
[1:05:16] So I have at the end of my presentation
[1:05:18] like an examples slide where here's some things we've seen.
[1:05:22] And this one is one of my examples.
[1:05:25] So the school is holding the event.
[1:05:28] And the school I think is the district, right?
[1:05:30] I would say they are acting on behalf of the district.
[1:05:33] They asked to waive the vehicle entry fees
[1:05:36] to Derke's Lake for the people attending the event.
[1:05:40] And I think we approve that.
[1:05:44] And I had the exact same concern you have.
[1:05:46] I go watch my daughter play basketball at Caners.
[1:05:48] I pay seven bucks to go in there.
[1:05:50] And the district is not waiving the fees
[1:05:52] for their own events at their own facilities.
[1:05:55] So why would we waive the fee for our events at our facilities?
[1:05:59] Well, that's a question.
[1:06:00] Well, the other issue is it's not the district
[1:06:03] that's out the money.
[1:06:04] If the fee is there, it's an appearance
[1:06:07] that are out the money.
[1:06:08] To me, that's Travis, did you have some?
[1:06:10] So I was going to comment exactly what Mitch had said.
[1:06:14] Regardless of the activity, the school district,
[1:06:19] if a student wants to attend an event at any school,
[1:06:24] they must either one purchase an activity card, which grants
[1:06:28] them access to all the events, or they pay admission fee.
[1:06:33] And parents always have to pay an admission fee
[1:06:36] if they don't buy a pass.
[1:06:38] And that is a school district policy for all school related activities and events.
[1:06:46] The school district does not ever waive those fees for specific events and oftentimes clubs
[1:06:57] may go to booster clubs seeking assistance to cover some of those costs.
[1:07:02] So I think it's important to remember that the council is sometimes placed into a position
[1:07:07] to waive fees for events on behalf of others in which the primary entity is unwilling to
[1:07:14] do the same or itself.
[1:07:18] Grayson, Jason, were you done?
[1:07:20] Oh, yeah, sorry.
[1:07:21] Yeah, Grayson.
[1:07:22] Well, and I had a little bit more to add to Jason's question too.
[1:07:25] So that was a question that I was wondering myself.
[1:07:28] And if we get to the point where we're going to grant the district waivers, then this one
[1:07:32] was going to be one even in this case, right?
[1:07:36] mentioned a couple of other things that I wanted to address real briefly though. We
[1:07:41] do have the opportunity to already do reduced entry fees for the Shishram Falls
[1:07:47] turkeys like vehicle access fees and we do those. How we do them is we have the
[1:07:54] people that are rolling the event by ticket books and so instead of five
[1:07:58] dollars a car at the gate they buy the ticket books ahead of time and those get
[1:08:02] them in for about about 50 a car. So if you buy a ticket book, this is a great advertisement.
[1:08:10] Buy the ticket books, right? It reduces your rate from 5 to about 50. And so we've done
[1:08:15] that with several events where they've not looked for a full-on wavers. We had to come
[1:08:19] here. We just sold them the ticket books up front. And so that's an opportunity for a
[1:08:23] reduce fee. The other thing is that requires a little bit of planning on up front on behalf
[1:08:27] of the organizer. And sometimes we find that organizers don't really plan these things
[1:08:32] out well and so this is again to one of my next slides down piece a little bit is
[1:08:37] somebody's lack of planning our burden to solve for that right and so there's a
[1:08:43] planning issue that we need to think about there is a reduction for the vehicle
[1:08:47] access fee and then that whole question about school just gonna charge anyway
[1:08:52] so yeah I think I got it thank you Grayson thank you Madam Mayor Mitch
[1:08:56] pardon my ignorance on this one but could you give some more examples of other
[1:09:00] other tax for the agencies outside of schools?
[1:09:04] So we've waived fees for the county, and actually we have a standing agreement with the county
[1:09:09] on building permit fees.
[1:09:11] We've waived fees for the Twin Falls Highway District.
[1:09:15] They requested a building permit for like an equipment barn and their property down south
[1:09:20] and down.
[1:09:21] And so those would be two other examples of tax port entities.
[1:09:24] So thank you.
[1:09:25] Really any of the special districts, the state or the feds don't really ask us for permits.
[1:09:30] So they just build.
[1:09:33] They just kind of do the thing.
[1:09:36] We do have a, we do have a, in our fee structure for the
[1:09:41] Shoshone Falls, Turkey's Lake Park.
[1:09:42] We do have a statement in the fee structure that says,
[1:09:45] if you are a government entity doing government business,
[1:09:48] then we'll let you in.
[1:09:49] And oftentimes we'll accommodate like the National Guard
[1:09:53] to go in and do some ropes training on the cliffs
[1:09:55] and stuff down there.
[1:09:56] and or or
[1:09:58] It was the other one the search and rescue to do some scuba training
[1:10:01] Sure, like we don't usually charge them for that, but that fee structure is already in place
[1:10:07] So for example, we had the search and rescue reach out to train in the pool
[1:10:12] That's not in place at the pool and so we told them you have to pay the fee that the pool needed elected to go down to the lake instead
[1:10:19] Thank you Spencer
[1:10:21] Hi, thanks mayor
[1:10:23] So I supported Wave in the Fee for the cross-country meet. This is a great example and looking back. I think we probably made a mistake
[1:10:31] We we have cost we talked about the road and things but just things, you know, you have 2,000 people down there
[1:10:37] I'm sure there's a couple sprinkler heads the guy kicked or trampled or cracked or broken
[1:10:41] There's extra trash to be hauled off extra literally be picked up
[1:10:45] Playground swing that may have got broken whatever it was. I'm sure there was more cost too
[1:10:50] And if we have it in policy or ordinance that we automatically waive fees for things like that,
[1:10:56] well, why wouldn't they have a whole bunch of other activities on city controlled property because it's less burdened to them and
[1:11:05] we're shouldering it and I understand it's generally the same group or pool of taxpayers, but there's a reason different districts and entities
[1:11:13] have revenue and the taxpayer support those specific entities so I'd be scared to
[1:11:21] open up that as I hate to call it free for all but it's a it could snowball.
[1:11:28] Thank you Spencer. Okay, go ahead man.
[1:11:32] I want to move off this page I want to just make sure I'm restating what I
[1:11:38] I might have heard, generally OK with tax
[1:11:42] ported into these being on our group.
[1:11:45] We probably should consider nonprofits or service
[1:11:47] clubs, depending on the details.
[1:11:50] And when it comes to sporting events
[1:11:52] that the school district might be on,
[1:11:53] maybe we want to treat that a little differently
[1:11:55] from the rest of the school district requests.
[1:11:59] This kind of what I mean.
[1:12:00] And I'm restating mostly for Nicole's benefit.
[1:12:02] Nicole's up there taking notes.
[1:12:04] She's input a draft policy that will be back to you.
[1:12:07] And so, right, okay.
[1:12:10] Yep.
[1:12:12] Okay, moving on.
[1:12:13] Spencer, did you have something else?
[1:12:15] Yeah, maybe to clarify,
[1:12:16] as far as other tax-supported entities,
[1:12:19] maybe the details or the type of event matters.
[1:12:22] For example, waving a building permit fee.
[1:12:24] Yes, that does take staff time and there is costs,
[1:12:27] but my presumption is that's not as burdensome
[1:12:29] as having an event with 1,000 or 2,000 people
[1:12:32] on a public property.
[1:12:36] I think the idea behind the tax-supported entity
[1:12:38] And there was one on the agenda earlier tonight for the school district, for example, where
[1:12:44] they requested a building permit.
[1:12:45] It's the time of year where the school districts lining up their summer projects.
[1:12:50] So in the college school they can do some construction.
[1:12:53] There's three or four more in the wings that you'll probably see in the next week or two
[1:12:56] from the school district.
[1:12:57] But the idea behind that is if the school district has to pay those fees for the building permit,
[1:13:04] it's our taxpayers who are paying that to us anyway.
[1:13:08] So if we don't charge them, our taxpayers are paying for us
[1:13:10] to provide the service anyway.
[1:13:12] It's sort of like, I hate to say these things.
[1:13:16] Oh, wow, she's double dipping our taxpayers,
[1:13:19] because they're the same taxpayers as the district.
[1:13:21] And that's kind of the philosophy behind why we've
[1:13:25] done the building permit thing.
[1:13:27] And we're doing okay with our building permit fees.
[1:13:30] We can afford to do this $1,100 permit for the school
[1:13:32] district without a real hit to us.
[1:13:35] Thank you, Chris.
[1:13:36] I would like to just know from the council,
[1:13:38] I have a little bit of heartburn with senior projects.
[1:13:41] It sounds like maybe some others
[1:13:46] who are a variety of reasons.
[1:13:48] One of which, if we say that is not a wave,
[1:13:53] do you have to go to the council?
[1:13:54] We potentially could see a lot of senior projects
[1:13:58] on a regular basis here at council,
[1:14:00] and then we have to decide we like this one,
[1:14:03] and no, we don't like that one,
[1:14:04] and this one's gonna make money, but this one's not.
[1:14:07] And so a subset under there is one
[1:14:12] that I think we need to discuss.
[1:14:15] To me, that's where the individual's what is up there.
[1:14:17] And I'm a parent of three former senior project people.
[1:14:22] And I helped them pay for some projects
[1:14:26] that we either were dumb for picking the wrong project
[1:14:29] that we could ask somebody to wait for fee for.
[1:14:31] But the planning of it is part of the project, I think.
[1:14:36] That's part of what they need to be learning about.
[1:14:39] Is how to manage the finance part of it?
[1:14:41] Yep.
[1:14:42] I tend to fall on the side of the individuals probably should pay that fee.
[1:14:46] I agree.
[1:14:47] Okay.
[1:14:50] Okay.
[1:14:51] Well then, once we know who we're going to let talk about it, I think these are some details
[1:14:57] that matter.
[1:14:58] Why are they asking for the waiver?
[1:15:00] And right at the top of that list, I can't afford it, I didn't plan for it, right?
[1:15:04] And I'm not sure that that's our problem to fix for them.
[1:15:08] The taxpayers, we talked about that a little bit, if taxpayers are paying the fee, there
[1:15:12] are taxpayers.
[1:15:13] Talked about the funds will be raised for a city public facility the map tech example, right?
[1:15:17] So they raised funds for the trails another one might be the gooch slash is raising funds or funds for the for the animal shelter
[1:15:24] Which is a city facility?
[1:15:26] Though one that we've heard sometimes is they have this cause for the fundraiser
[1:15:31] And that might fall into the realm of the senior project that we talked about he was raising funds for a medical
[1:15:37] Research kind of a group
[1:15:39] Which is a worthy cause is it our cause?
[1:15:44] So that one, I have a maybe, right?
[1:15:46] Let's think about that a little bit.
[1:15:47] And then we often have heard the argument,
[1:15:49] well, this event is good for the community
[1:15:51] because people come stay in our hotels,
[1:15:53] they come meet at our restaurants,
[1:15:54] they come shop at our stores.
[1:15:55] And we don't get us hotel sales tax,
[1:15:58] we don't get retail sales tax.
[1:16:00] So maybe they are good for the community,
[1:16:02] not necessarily good for the organization city, right?
[1:16:05] And so our recommendation would be,
[1:16:07] let's continue doing what we have been.
[1:16:08] So those two green check marks are good reasons for that.
[1:16:13] If the council feels like there might be other causes that we want to support, maybe that would be something we could think about and talk a little bit more.
[1:16:25] And if I'm missing something altogether that should be on the list, it isn't on the list. Is there another reason why somebody might ask that?
[1:16:32] Well, I think this raising funds for a cause could be a can of worms, frankly.
[1:16:37] We all have passion over different causes.
[1:16:41] And, you know, if you have a passion for something,
[1:16:46] you're gonna figure out how to make a contribution
[1:16:49] to it one way or another.
[1:16:50] So I don't know that we waver on that cause.
[1:16:56] I can't think of a cause that I would waver a fee
[1:17:00] on right this minute.
[1:17:01] That's me personally.
[1:17:03] Grayson Stone.
[1:17:04] Thank you, Madam Mayor.
[1:17:05] Jack, or your point, I think the city of itself
[1:17:10] is nonpartisan.
[1:17:11] And I think when we start talking about fundraising causes,
[1:17:14] a lot of it can be politically motivated or other agendas.
[1:17:19] So I have a lot of heartburn on doing a waiver for a cause.
[1:17:23] I think the city needs to remain nonpartisan.
[1:17:26] I've held numerous benefits and numerous fundraisers.
[1:17:29] And there's always been somebody willing to step up
[1:17:32] and pay for a facility fee.
[1:17:34] So I would have a lot of heartburn waving a fee
[1:17:37] for a specific cause.
[1:17:38] And that comes from me being some of the oftentimes
[1:17:42] is involved in putting on fundraisers.
[1:17:44] I don't think that that's a social slash economic liability
[1:17:50] that we even need to mess with.
[1:17:53] So I would absolutely wipe that.
[1:17:58] OK.
[1:17:58] OK.
[1:17:59] Moving on.
[1:18:00] Moving on.
[1:18:02] So this one takes a little bit of explanation.
[1:18:04] So which fees are we going to consider?
[1:18:07] In preparing for this, I opened up our master fees
[1:18:09] schedule that you guys look at every August.
[1:18:12] is eight and a half pages of fees that we charge.
[1:18:15] And when it boils down to it,
[1:18:17] we get asked for about four different types of fees to waive.
[1:18:20] Building permits,
[1:18:22] hark reservations like the facility
[1:18:25] or the ban shallows, kinds of things.
[1:18:28] Vehicle access fees just don't fall,
[1:18:30] and then sometimes pull access fees.
[1:18:32] That's really it.
[1:18:33] I went around and asked department heads,
[1:18:35] do you ever see fee waivers coming in requests?
[1:18:37] And they're like, you know,
[1:18:39] and honestly if you think about it,
[1:18:41] how ridiculous would it be if somebody came to me
[1:18:43] of the school district, we're talking about school district.
[1:18:45] What if the school district came and said,
[1:18:46] we have our water bill or morning surgery,
[1:18:50] we have to do that, right?
[1:18:51] And we can't actually do that.
[1:18:53] There's a bond covenant that makes us, or impact fees.
[1:18:57] We cannot waive legally, we can't waive impact.
[1:19:00] And so this question of which fees should we consider,
[1:19:03] what we've historically done under those four,
[1:19:05] we're gonna recommend that we stick to those four,
[1:19:08] not necessarily expand that at all or reduce it.
[1:19:12] Although those would be options, right?
[1:19:13] We could expand it to any and every fee that we offer,
[1:19:17] some or none, right?
[1:19:19] But these four seem to be the ones that we've done
[1:19:22] in the past and ones that we might consider doing the future.
[1:19:26] That's kind of where we'd like to focus
[1:19:28] and for your consent there.
[1:19:32] Jason.
[1:19:34] Thanks, Mayor.
[1:19:36] Mitch, I can see that you've shown
[1:19:39] falls part because we had talked about it already. The pool access fee, who, so what, who, who is asked for that, or not naming someone specific, but what type of organization has asked for that?
[1:19:50] I kind of referenced that a little bit ago with the search and rescue, the scuba trading, they wanted to do that in the pool, and that was one that we turned down, and they just went somewhere else.
[1:19:59] But that's an example.
[1:20:01] What does swim teams do?
[1:20:03] The swim team actually depends on who you're talking about.
[1:20:06] So the schools can't reach in Twin Falls High School.
[1:20:12] We do not charge them to use the facility
[1:20:18] because we have an agreement with them regarding the pool
[1:20:20] itself.
[1:20:21] Schools on school district property.
[1:20:23] And so they have access to the pool.
[1:20:25] The individuals that are on swim teams outside of the schools
[1:20:30] need to have the ability to get in. So when my kids were swimming and they
[1:20:33] swim for the Marlins, we bought a pool pass so that my kids could get in.
[1:20:39] And then the Marlins, when they needed to reserve it to host like a
[1:20:43] swim meet, they would pay the reservation fee.
[1:20:47] The other schools that use our pool, not can't enrich, not Twin Falls,
[1:20:51] pay the reservation fee to hold the event. Okay, so
[1:20:55] very seldom do we get pool access fee waivers.
[1:20:58] their view.
[1:20:59] CSI is asked for it before, too.
[1:21:03] But CSI is another entity that we would, I guess I look at the pool access, we've spent
[1:21:10] a lot of money to try to keep the pool up with filtration systems, resurfacing, doing
[1:21:19] a lot of that.
[1:21:20] I would be more hesitant to physical therapists to do, you know, I just think we need swim
[1:21:27] lessons.
[1:21:28] So I think we need to look at, in the swim lesson, honestly, to me, I know this is going
[1:21:35] to sound harsh, but that should be part of the reservation fee should be part of the
[1:21:40] swim lesson because you're running a business in the zoom.
[1:21:43] You're making money.
[1:21:44] So it goes back to making money.
[1:21:46] I guess I would be hesitant to even, unless there's a good one.
[1:21:50] If CSI, another entity, as long as we're taking care of the schools, but it sounds like the
[1:21:56] Marlin's and other clubs swimming sports are paying for the reservation fee. I guess there's a good example of the pool
[1:22:03] Access fee I'd be more willing to pull that one off and I would believe it on the two that kind of my mind is
[1:22:11] Legitimate would be like the government one. Sorry the search you rescue from the county
[1:22:15] CSI, maybe what exactly they're asking for right?
[1:22:19] That's the reason why I thought it was worth keeping on here
[1:22:23] Okay, as long as it doesn't open up a
[1:22:25] the plethora of pool fee waiver requests, Grayson.
[1:22:32] Thank you Madam Mayor. So I'm going to actually kind of play devil's advocate here. So I was a rescue diver down in New Mexico.
[1:22:37] And we utilize the pool down at Carlsbad all the time for our training.
[1:22:41] And a lot of those trainings doing in Darkies Lake isn't necessarily beneficial because you can't see your instructors.
[1:22:46] You can't necessarily see what you're working with.
[1:22:49] You know, we're working with a lot of ropes.
[1:22:57] Anybody have an oil can?
[1:23:02] or working with a lot of mannequins that have submerged under water. So when you're training in
[1:23:06] zero visibility that training is essentially not effective versus doing it in open water so you can
[1:23:12] get your hand-eye coordination working with ropes, working with tangible obstacles. And so
[1:23:17] I would be inclined to keep that waiver in there for government agencies to be training because
[1:23:23] the end of the day that search and rescue team is our search and rescue for the city as well.
[1:23:29] well, we don't have anything within our municipality, whether it be with the Fire Department or
[1:23:34] the PD that has a dive team.
[1:23:36] And so I would be inclined to keep that in there, especially for our first responders
[1:23:43] to go in and train in somemersible environments so they can see hands-on what they're working
[1:23:49] on.
[1:23:50] So I would be inclined to leave that in there.
[1:23:51] And again, that's why I've kept it up here for that.
[1:23:54] That's the best example I could come up with, of why we would want that in there for the
[1:23:59] I guess with this slide here, which fees will be considered for a waiver, I guess a maybe
[1:24:10] or other agency or other groups.
[1:24:16] I mean, this one is only those who have historically been granted should be considered.
[1:24:21] So if something else comes up and you haven't come to us in the past that's a no, I'm not
[1:24:28] okay with that.
[1:24:29] I don't want to pigeonhole us in that or.
[1:24:32] So it's not the people, but it's the fee, it's the fee that's the way not the people.
[1:24:39] Yeah, this is the type of fee we're waiting to type of the fee.
[1:24:42] Not the particular people.
[1:24:44] Building permit fee, we've traditionally had some people we've laid those for, we'll continue to do that.
[1:24:49] But water bills, we haven't, I'm probably going to do that.
[1:24:52] And that's an extreme extent. Got it.
[1:24:56] Anything else on that? Okay, moving on.
[1:25:01] I think we're getting close.
[1:25:03] Okay, so this was a question that we asked amongst ourselves.
[1:25:07] Now let me preface this by saying, I don't recall people asking for reductions very much.
[1:25:14] The one that comes up is the vehicle access fee, and we already have that in place for Schonfals to just take a book, right?
[1:25:21] And so should we consider reductions or waivers or both?
[1:25:25] And our thought was, because we already have the deal in place for
[1:25:28] she shouldn't fall as access, but take it books, or ease of implementation.
[1:25:34] So talk about waivers, because no one's going to come and say,
[1:25:38] well, you give me a reduction, very few people will say that.
[1:25:41] But it's a matter of crafting the policy and implementing the policy consistently.
[1:25:47] It seems like reductions is it a 50% or a 40% or what are they asking for it?
[1:25:52] It just adds more complication to the process than just waving or not waving.
[1:25:57] So, our recommendation is just to leave it as waivers.
[1:26:01] We can deal with the vehicle access fees as we already have in place, and then the rest
[1:26:05] of it is just waivers.
[1:26:07] Thank you.
[1:26:08] Jason.
[1:26:09] Yeah, I'll just comment on Grayson.
[1:26:12] I'm on the pool thing.
[1:26:13] You know, I'm absolutely okay if the search and rescue need to use the pool as something
[1:26:18] that is, to me, is warranted.
[1:26:21] On this one, I would agree that only waivers with the exception of maybe when the schools
[1:26:26] come in and ask saying, hey, you know, you may want to communicate with the other schools
[1:26:33] that this option is provided, the booklet option is provided.
[1:26:37] I don't know how many people do the math on buying a book and handing that out, that it
[1:26:44] truly is a reduction, but I'm comfortable with a waiver.
[1:26:48] Really valuable reduction too.
[1:26:50] I don't like to say I don't know why I'm more people in my books, local.
[1:26:53] Okay, they're comments.
[1:26:58] Okay, so this one I'm actually going to recommend a slight tweak to what we've been doing.
[1:27:06] I told you that our recommendations are kind of what we've been doing except for this one.
[1:27:10] So who should approve the fee rate request? Right now we're bringing all the feedback requests to the council.
[1:27:15] So the considerations there were city council, city manager, department heads, some combination of the mix.
[1:27:27] And so when I was thinking through this and we were talking amongst ourselves,
[1:27:32] we have another policy for travel requests for city staff travel requests.
[1:27:39] And up to $1,000 the department had to approve the travel request.
[1:27:42] If it goes to 2,500 city managers office can approve the travel request.
[1:27:45] If it goes over $2,500 to come to you guys for approval,
[1:27:48] it seemed like a good mix of numbers to me.
[1:27:51] For ease of process, for simplicity's sake,
[1:27:54] Maybe we recommend the same thing for fee waiver requests up to $1,000 at the department head request.
[1:28:00] If it's more than $1,000 up to $2,500 comes to the manager's office.
[1:28:05] If it's over 2,500, it'll come to the council.
[1:28:08] And I would anticipate that looking much like tonight's did as a fee waiver request on the consent agenda.
[1:28:15] We explain it if you all have a problem with it, you can always pull it off and say, what I want to do.
[1:28:19] Our recommendation would be that, and because of that recommendation, the next one there
[1:28:26] is also a recommendation.
[1:28:27] If we have that process, we should also have an appeal process.
[1:28:31] So if I deny a fee waiver request, they should be able to pill my request to the council,
[1:28:36] or the department heads request to the city manager's office.
[1:28:39] So that's our recommendation here, that this does slightly tweak what we've been doing in
[1:28:44] the last recent history.
[1:28:46] I thought I'd throw that out there and see what y'all think about it.
[1:28:50] Jason sorry, I'm talking quite a bit, but as you're talking, I'm thinking about some things. I just pulled up the school district
[1:28:58] Building permit fee and it was a little over $1,100. Yes, but I look at this and say
[1:29:06] What would a what would an average building permit fee for you know is that number maybe a little bit too tight?
[1:29:13] specifically for the school district or some of that. I don't know if that's if
[1:29:19] that's a really tight number if it gets over $2,500 would it go with $2,500 come
[1:29:24] up pretty regularly. I shared with you that I've got three or four requests
[1:29:28] pending from the school district you'll probably see those on next week's agenda.
[1:29:32] So this one today and those other four or of the five are between 1,025
[1:29:39] There are minor remodels at a school.
[1:29:43] One of them is about 3,300, and so that one, if this polysquare in place, would be recommended
[1:29:50] to the council and not at the city manager's office.
[1:29:55] Most of these permits that the school district has asked for waivers for ended this lower
[1:30:02] end range.
[1:30:03] When they come in with South Hills Middle School, it didn't ask for a fee waiver, and honestly,
[1:30:10] we probably wouldn't have waived an $80,000 fee, okay.
[1:30:15] So, okay, no, that's fine.
[1:30:17] Full on new school, they know enough not to ask.
[1:30:20] If they did ask, we would bring it to you guys
[1:30:22] and you would say, what do you want us to pay, $80,000?
[1:30:25] So, these little ones that they're probably most
[1:30:30] of we're gonna follow that are just re-1000 to 2500, okay.
[1:30:33] Okay, but you'll see several, I think,
[1:30:37] but not as many as now.
[1:30:39] Thank you, Chris-Free.
[1:30:40] So pretty much what we're talking about,
[1:30:42] anything under $1,000, we're really looking
[1:30:45] in the parks area.
[1:30:46] Parks and rec is where this is gonna all fall.
[1:30:49] The majority of it is getting-
[1:30:51] Reservations for facilities and the point of this policy
[1:30:55] would be you're all waving in on the policy.
[1:30:58] If it's gonna meet the policy,
[1:31:01] we might wanna think about giving Wendy the authority
[1:31:03] rather than the staff report together,
[1:31:06] having somebody come taking time on an agenda
[1:31:09] every time one of those happens.
[1:31:11] If it meets the policy she'll prove it.
[1:31:14] If she doesn't prove it, they can appeal it to us
[1:31:16] and multiply to you guys.
[1:31:18] That would be the idea.
[1:31:19] But yeah, the little ones are mostly all gonna be
[1:31:22] in the parks, either park or pool, right?
[1:31:26] And that was, if y'all are good with the policy,
[1:31:30] then why not shuffle the workload onto us
[1:31:33] who are doing it all the time, anyway?
[1:31:37] That makes sense.
[1:31:39] Is there a recommendation for that last minute
[1:31:42] other than city council should have an appeal process.
[1:31:46] The recommendation I'm having is there should be an appeal.
[1:31:49] If we do, if we do anybody else, I don't think it would be right for
[1:31:55] Wendy to be the final answer.
[1:31:58] So if Wendy doesn't approve something, can they appeal to the city manager?
[1:32:03] Which then goes to council if-
[1:32:06] That's how I would do it.
[1:32:06] You just appeal to the next level up, whatever that level up is like that.
[1:32:09] If you don't like the next level up answer, you can go to the next level up.
[1:32:12] Right.
[1:32:16] That one's good, Mitch.
[1:32:17] Any more on this one?
[1:32:19] No more questions.
[1:32:20] Okay.
[1:32:21] Now I think we've sort of put the meat on all these bones and my final question is kind
[1:32:27] of rhetorical because I don't think we do want to do this, but we need to treat some of these
[1:32:31] different than others and my whole point in all this is I don't want to do that.
[1:32:35] I think we need to try and assemble a guy.
[1:32:37] Single policy that works.
[1:32:38] So I'd throw that up there for friends.
[1:32:42] OK, and then this is where I was going to talk about examples.
[1:32:44] So based on what I heard tonight, the school district building
[1:32:48] permit fee that you saw tonight would not have come here.
[1:32:53] Matthew would have got the letter, and it
[1:32:55] would have come to Travis or Gretchen or I,
[1:32:57] and we would have approved it if it met the requirements,
[1:32:59] and not if it didn't.
[1:33:01] The MavTech Fundroom fees, and the MavTech's
[1:33:03] not around anymore doing these things.
[1:33:05] But if they were to come in, what I heard was there
[1:33:08] are non-profit organization raising funds
[1:33:11] on behalf of a city project.
[1:33:14] And so we would consider that kind of a fee.
[1:33:16] Senior projects, maybe not so much, is what I thought I heard.
[1:33:22] The pooch splash, that's another partner organization
[1:33:25] raising funds for a city facility in the animal shelter.
[1:33:28] We probably would approve that one,
[1:33:30] which I'm going to rescue scuba training at the pool.
[1:33:33] If we say a government entity is willing or able to ask,
[1:33:37] we would approve that one.
[1:33:39] School District Access, this is the one I told you about,
[1:33:42] for the cross-country meet, right?
[1:33:46] That one will be a little trickier,
[1:33:47] but I kind of thought I heard a consensus saying
[1:33:50] we don't want to necessarily do that.
[1:33:52] But anyway, those were the examples
[1:33:55] that I could think of where I've been recent examples
[1:33:57] that we're all familiar with.
[1:33:59] So here they are.
[1:34:02] Any questions or if we get it right.
[1:34:07] Hey, son.
[1:34:09] Thank you, Madam Mayor.
[1:34:09] Go back one slide, if you wouldn't mind, Mitch.
[1:34:11] So when you say search and rescue,
[1:34:13] scuba training pool entry, if you guys want to clarify,
[1:34:15] what I mean by my comments, and I think what
[1:34:18] Councilman Brown was getting at,
[1:34:19] is any entity that's serving our taxpayers
[1:34:23] in lieu of us having our own entity
[1:34:25] that is able to perform the same function?
[1:34:28] Those are the government entities
[1:34:30] that I would be willing to waive access fees for.
[1:34:34] So pretty much partners that fill a gap within our own system,
[1:34:38] such as search and rescue.
[1:34:40] Right, ambulance.
[1:34:42] Correct.
[1:34:42] Or for this particular question, the search and rescue team
[1:34:46] that we have is a county-sponsored team.
[1:34:48] And they would be the ones doing that.
[1:34:49] Correct.
[1:34:50] I said that.
[1:34:51] We do have individuals that do scuba classes.
[1:34:54] They should pay for certifications, right?
[1:34:56] And that's a capitalist endeavor.
[1:34:58] So they need to pay the fee.
[1:34:59] They're profiting off of it, but what I've seen is government agencies that are providing a service for the taxpayers because that's what those taxpayers
[1:35:08] Those individuals are training so that they could join the search and rescue team later
[1:35:12] But they're paying the fee for the class now
[1:35:17] If you're taking a scuba class, you know that you're gonna pay up pool fee no matter where you go great great Hawkins
[1:35:23] I just want to thank you Wendy and everybody on this obviously required a lot of in-depth
[1:35:30] thought and consideration.
[1:35:33] I really like what has been presented tonight and I feel good about it, so thank you.
[1:35:39] Thank you.
[1:35:40] Perfect.
[1:35:41] Anything else?
[1:35:42] Parting shots.
[1:35:43] Great.
[1:35:44] That's it.
[1:35:45] Looks like we're good.
[1:35:46] Hey, awesome.
[1:35:47] Thank you Mitch.
[1:35:48] Thank you.
[1:35:49] Hey, that was the last item on the agenda.
[1:35:52] So next is a time for general public input.
[1:35:56] There's anybody in the public that wishes to address City Council on an issue that was
[1:36:01] not on tonight's agenda or is not a personnel matter.
[1:36:06] Please come down.
[1:36:07] Hey, seeing no one, Advisory Board reports.
[1:36:15] Chris?
[1:36:16] We had, I attended two meetings last week.
[1:36:19] The first one was airport, the airport.
[1:36:23] Are we going to have a presentation from the airport on their conversation with Delta before
[1:36:30] I...
[1:36:31] Yeah, as soon as we get the final numbers, and every so right now they're going through
[1:36:35] the final reconciliation process.
[1:36:38] As the Council will call you entered into a six-month revenue guarantee with Delta.
[1:36:45] They're working through that, early indications are that there will not be a request for an
[1:36:52] additional revenue guarantee in the next subsequent six months or or any point in the future.
[1:37:00] But they want to come back and they want to share the exact calculations and the numbers
[1:37:05] and then talk about what air service looks like in the future. But we're probably looking at about
[1:37:09] a month before Delta is able to reconcile those accounting numbers and get back to us.
[1:37:14] Perfect. That's what we discussed there. And then also the Public Arts Council met
[1:37:18] went over all of the submissions for the electrical boxes. There are some very talented
[1:37:26] people in Twin Falls. They are meeting tomorrow again to kind of take the top tier and those
[1:37:32] that they voted on and make their selection. And I believe that will be coming to us shortly.
[1:37:40] I'm going to jump in first.
[1:37:47] So we had an interview on the impact fee.
[1:37:51] There's a vacancy there so I had an opportunity to interview some candidates so here in the next couple of weeks, I'm sure we'll have a candidate come forward for that impact fee.
[1:37:59] But we're looking at an actual meeting sometime in April.
[1:38:06] Yes, ma'am. Sorry. Yes, Madam Mayor. Thank you. I'm sorry. I just want to reiterate either way. Chamber of Commerce does their public policy calls every Friday at 7 a.m.
[1:38:21] We're getting great turnout from our legislators that are willing to avail themselves, walk through bills, talk about what's going on up in the Capitol, and then are also willing to sit with questions.
[1:38:32] It's digital, it's over Zoom, but all of our legislators are doing a great job of
[1:38:38] availing themselves and taking feedback. So again the chambers hosting those
[1:38:44] events Friday morning 7 a.m. you can either go to the chamber office, believe
[1:38:49] there's donuts and coffee that oftentimes provide office, or if you're like me and
[1:38:54] sit at home and drink your coffee you can jump on the Zoom call, but I encourage
[1:38:58] everybody to take that opportunity and participate in those conversations.
[1:39:02] Thank you. Anybody else? Well, we are having our first Metropolitan Planning
[1:39:08] Organization meeting on Wednesday at 10 o'clock. It's a public meeting. So if anybody wishes
[1:39:15] to attend, they may. It'll be pretty exciting. Travis, do you have anything from the city
[1:39:20] matches? That's what I was going to share. And it's going to be in room 116. Just
[1:39:27] The last time I would have is that we will be meeting next week on the 18th as normally scheduled,
[1:39:32] but we will not be meeting the week of the 25th. And so we have one meeting and then we'll meet again the first of April.
[1:39:39] Perfect. Okay. That's, yes.
[1:39:44] Just have one question for Chief Kingsbury. I know she's out in the hallway there. I was wondering about what kind of contraband you were able to pick up.
[1:39:52] with the Girl Scouts. What a great that's great. Did you get two boxes or just one just one. Oh that'd be great. That's a great money maker. Okay that's it on the agenda so thank you everyone our meeting's adjourned.
