Oversight Archive: City Council meeting, 2026-03-30, recording 1 (started 16:58)
Machine transcript (faster-whisper base.en), not checked word for word; the Pledge of Allegiance is shown in its standard wording. The recording is the record.
Times are time into the recording. Passages with private details are muted in the audio and marked here.
The audio on the page below was re-encoded by software from the video the agency posted. Check any passage against
that audio before relying on it.
Page: https://oversightarchive.org/twin-falls-id/meetings/2026-03-30/

[0:02:37] Okay, we'll go ahead and call the Twin Falls City Council meeting for March 30th, 2026 to order
[0:02:44] I will confirm that we have six members of City Council in chambers and
[0:02:51] Councilman Stone if available we'll call in
[0:02:56] We'll start out with the Pledge of Allegiance any of those that would like to follow along please arise
[0:03:13] that it is all ever be and thus is all.
[0:03:18] Thank you.
[0:03:21] We do have a proclamation tonight,
[0:03:23] Strengthening Families Month.
[0:03:25] I'll go ahead and read that.
[0:03:29] It says, whereas the children of the Magic Valley
[0:03:31] are vital to the future of our community,
[0:03:34] and strong families are the foundation
[0:03:36] of healthy neighborhoods, a resilient workforce,
[0:03:40] and a thriving local economy.
[0:03:42] And whereas families play a central role
[0:03:45] nurturing the physical, emotional, social, and educational well-being of children, and safe,
[0:03:51] stable, and nurturing relationships are key to preventing child abuse and neglect before
[0:03:57] it occurs, and whereas communities strengthen families by fostering social connections supporting
[0:04:03] positive parenting, increasing access to resources, and creating environments where families can
[0:04:11] manage stress and grow together. And whereas strengthening family's month provides an opportunity
[0:04:18] to recognize the importance of family well-being and to encourage local organizations, schools,
[0:04:24] businesses, and residents to support efforts that help families thrive. Therefore, I, Jason
[0:04:30] Brown, mayor of the City of Twin Falls do hereby proclaim the month of April 2026,
[0:04:36] strengthening Families Month. I can't remember. Was there someone here to receive the proclamation?
[0:04:43] I can't remember. Nope. Okay. I'll just add to that. There's no doubt I wouldn't be able to do the
[0:04:53] things that I do in my life without my family. So families are extremely important and I believe
[0:04:59] that they are truly a vital part of our community and what makes us great is people. So I truly
[0:05:09] support that proclamation and what we do. We'll move on to the next item of business into the
[0:05:16] consent calendar. What are Council's wishes? Move to approve. I have a second. I have a first and a second
[0:05:25] to approve the consent calendar as presented. Is there any further discussion? Amy Roll call vote.
[0:05:33] Bruce Pierce, Chris Reed, Craig Hawkins, Jason Brown, Gary Volmer, and Nathan Murray.
[0:05:41] Motion carries 6-0. The next item is a request under our items of consideration
[0:05:50] or a request for a board member reappointment for John Michael Mason with
[0:05:55] the Twin Falls Housing Authority. Honorable Mayor Brown as Steam City Council
[0:06:09] members. I suspect that I'll be one of your quickest orders of
[0:06:13] business tonight. I come before you as the executive director of
[0:06:16] the Twin Falls Housing Authority to ask you to reappoint John
[0:06:20] Michael Mason to our Board of Commissioners. Board members
[0:06:25] terms are five years and each board member can serve two full
[0:06:31] terms of their own. Mr. Mason is currently our board chair and
[0:06:37] has served one full term of his own.
[0:06:41] He has been an amazing chair.
[0:06:42] He's provided strong leadership through a time of change
[0:06:47] and transition for our agency.
[0:06:49] He has a critical role in the decisions being made,
[0:06:53] and we would hate to lose his leadership at this time.
[0:06:56] We are truly an agency in transition,
[0:06:59] and I believe he brings great,
[0:07:01] and sightfulness, community knowledge,
[0:07:04] historical knowledge, and some financial knowledge,
[0:07:07] which we really need.
[0:07:08] So I request that you consider the reappointment
[0:07:11] of John Michael Mason for a second five-year term
[0:07:15] at the Housing Authority, thank you.
[0:07:16] Thanks, I think.
[0:07:18] What are Council's wishes?
[0:07:24] Oh, yeah, Ruth Pierce, sorry.
[0:07:25] I wasn't working on my board, it's been a week.
[0:07:28] You were on spring break.
[0:07:30] Yeah.
[0:07:30] Thank you.
[0:07:31] I move we approve the reappointment of John Michael Mason
[0:07:35] as a board member to the Twin Falls Housing Authority.
[0:07:38] Sherry Volmer.
[0:07:39] I will second have a first and a second to approve the reappointment of John Michael Mason to the Twin Falls Housing Authority is there any further discussion. Okay, Amy roll call vote.
[0:07:56] Yes, read. Yes. Craig Hawkins. Yes, Jason Brown. Yes, Jerry Bomer. Yes, Nathan Murray. Yes, and Ruth Pierce. Yes, motion passes six to zero.
[0:08:07] Chris, do you have something?
[0:08:08] Yeah, just real quick while we have you here,
[0:08:10] would you just mind quickly in a minute or two,
[0:08:13] just talking a little bit about the Twin Falls Housing Authority?
[0:08:16] Has he come every once in a while for these types of things,
[0:08:18] and I'd love to hear about the organization.
[0:08:20] I could talk about the Housing Authority all night,
[0:08:22] but you said quickly.
[0:08:23] So we actually, Twin Falls should be very proud.
[0:08:26] The Housing Authority was created in 1940.
[0:08:30] Housing authorities are part of FDR's New Deal.
[0:08:35] And so he said in 1937 that housing authorities
[0:08:38] be created.
[0:08:39] The mayor of Twin Falls at that time
[0:08:41] believed so strongly in creating a housing authority.
[0:08:44] That in 1940, he put up $500 of his own money
[0:08:47] to begin a building project.
[0:08:50] We were the first housing authority in the state of Idaho.
[0:08:53] And the state of Idaho did not even put it into code until 1958.
[0:08:58] So we should be very proud of that fact.
[0:09:01] We have 196 apartments in Twin Falls,
[0:09:06] elderly disabled, and some that are for families also.
[0:09:10] Because we are in such good standing with HUD
[0:09:12] and have continued to be,
[0:09:14] we have had a long-term management agreement
[0:09:16] with the Jerome Housing Authority that has 50 units.
[0:09:19] And I'd like to say about three years ago,
[0:09:20] we were volentold by HUD to become the management agent
[0:09:24] for the American Falls Housing Authority.
[0:09:26] And then about a year and a half ago,
[0:09:28] and told again to become the management agent for the fuel housing authority.
[0:09:32] They were both troubled and to bring them into compliance with HUD regulation.
[0:09:36] I have an amazing team, an amazing board, and we are in the process of trying to move out
[0:09:43] of public housing.
[0:09:44] HUD doesn't like public housing, and so they've made that abundantly clear that they are working
[0:09:49] to stop financing public housing, and their response would be like, well, we could give
[0:09:54] it to the city.
[0:09:56] well, you all don't want to finance it either, right?
[0:09:59] And so our goal is to move it out of a public housing portfolio.
[0:10:02] It's one of the reasons Mr. Mason is so important right now.
[0:10:06] Really it's a shell game with HUD.
[0:10:09] If you come out of this portfolio and into this portfolio, you just get a different stream
[0:10:13] of money.
[0:10:14] And so we'll still be funded, but it is our goal to be able to protect the long-term financial
[0:10:19] viability of the agency, the structure of our properties.
[0:10:23] in immaculate condition and to provide long-term homes for the most vulnerable in our community.
[0:10:30] I would love to talk on and on, but that's a synopsis.
[0:10:33] That's wonderful.
[0:10:34] Thank you for all the work you do.
[0:10:35] Thank you.
[0:10:36] Thank you for the question.
[0:10:37] Thank you.
[0:10:38] Appreciate it.
[0:10:41] Okay.
[0:10:42] Our next item on the agenda is to award the Tree Streets Waterline Project to A and B Excavation,
[0:10:50] and reserve a contingency for the total cost of 1.82 million and we have Jesse Sherman.
[0:10:57] Greetings, Mayor and Council.
[0:11:04] Does that work?
[0:11:06] Yeah.
[0:11:09] All right, here's some background.
[0:11:10] The Water Department and the Engineering have overseen the design of prioritized water line
[0:11:16] replacement projects within the area shown in the attached plan sheet.
[0:11:22] The 50-year-old water system has been a maintenance issue for the City of Twin Falls for several
[0:11:27] years. In our 2022 water facility plan prioritizes improvement for fire flow, the
[0:11:35] age of the lines and to get ahead of the zone maintenance that should occur in
[0:11:39] 2029. We received five qualified bids. A&B excavating was the apparent low
[0:11:47] better at $1,456,980. In the attached letter of recommendation our design
[0:11:56] consultant confirmed that A and B included all the bonds, insurance, and license
[0:12:02] necessary to qualify and complete the bid, ultimately recommending that we
[0:12:08] award the bid to A and B excavating. Staff would like to include approximately
[0:12:16] 25% contingency in the budget authority to allow staff to deal with any unknowns
[0:12:22] and or change orders during construction. With the contingency added in, the total
[0:12:28] is 1.82 million. The request is to authorize the mayor to sign the attached
[0:12:36] notice of award and authorize the city engineer Troy Vitek to sign the standard
[0:12:43] form of agreement between the owner and the contractor. Staff recommends awarding
[0:12:56] the project to A&B excavating and below us some suggested motion language. I'd be
[0:13:05] happy to stand for any questions. Any questions for Jesse? Nathan Murray. Yeah.
[0:13:12] See budget 3 million and it came in at 1.4. Were you just really high or we
[0:13:19] seen better prices? Well one of the things that I wanted to include and didn't was
[0:13:25] the engineers estimate. So the engineers estimate was I think it was two million
[0:13:35] $575,833.
[0:13:40] So we're getting good bids with this one.
[0:13:43] It's about a 57% engineer's estimate.
[0:13:47] So we usually don't be able to brag about stuff like that.
[0:13:51] This is a good, good, some good bids we got.
[0:13:57] You got a lot of them too, it seemed like.
[0:13:59] Chris, free?
[0:14:00] Yeah, so I'm going to piggyback on that one.
[0:14:03] Are we starting to see more bidders?
[0:14:05] I mean, I can go back to a few years ago
[0:14:07] when we were lucky to get one.
[0:14:09] Are we starting to see that a little bit more?
[0:14:13] I've noticed, engineering has noticed
[0:14:16] that there's been a lot more interest.
[0:14:20] And yeah, we're excited about being able
[0:14:23] to award more projects.
[0:14:25] It's gonna help our budget in the future, I hope, so.
[0:14:30] Perfect, thank you.
[0:14:32] Nathan, did I cut you off on your question?
[0:14:34] No, I'm good.
[0:14:35] take my sorry, I'd jump down with trauma credits. Everybody's on spring break. So, any other
[0:14:43] questions for Jesse? Mr. Mayor, just really quick and members of the Council. So, one of
[0:14:49] the things I think that Jesse would also agree is that bidding in today's market is pretty
[0:14:55] volatile and it can change at a moment depending upon what is going on in the world, especially
[0:15:02] with oil prices.
[0:15:03] And so when you start looking at pipes that are petroleum-based products, we really start
[0:15:10] making sure that the bid estimate is enough to cover the project.
[0:15:16] And so you will probably see us as we approach fiscal year 27, making sure that we're allocating
[0:15:22] enough money to do those projects so they can be completed in a timely manner.
[0:15:28] If we have savings left over, it allows Jesse to not only have a buffer but also consider
[0:15:34] other parts of the project that we may have left on the table that can be incorporated
[0:15:39] through a change order because we were concerned about a new cost.
[0:15:43] So good news here.
[0:15:45] We hope for more good news, but we're not going to bank that the world has returned to a state
[0:15:51] of normal because we don't believe that exists anymore.
[0:15:56] Thanks Travis.
[0:15:57] I move to award the tree streets water line project to A and B excavating for the little bit amount
[0:16:06] Interauthorize a total budget authority of 1.82 million
[0:16:09] Further where I move to authorize the mayor to sign the notice of award and authorize the city engineer to sign the standard form of agreement
[0:16:17] To the city and the contractor
[0:16:18] Ruth Pierce I'll second that have a motion
[0:16:22] in a second to award
[0:16:24] The tree streets water line project to
[0:16:28] and be excavating for the low bid
[0:16:31] amount and to authorize a total budget
[0:16:33] authority of 1.82 million and authorize
[0:16:36] the mayor to sign the notice of award and
[0:16:38] authorize the city engineer to sign the
[0:16:40] standard form of agreement between the
[0:16:42] city and the contractor. Any further
[0:16:45] discussion? Amy roll call vote.
[0:16:49] Greg Hawkins. Yes.
[0:16:51] Brown. Yes.
[0:16:52] Gary Bomer. Yes.
[0:16:54] to the
[0:16:57] council.
[0:16:58] Thank you.
[0:16:59] Next item is a recommendation for the Twin Falls Public Art
[0:17:02] Commission to amend resolution 2022-01-0 with regards to the
[0:17:06] funding percentage.
[0:17:07] We have Wendy Davis.
[0:17:08] Good evening, Mayor and Council.
[0:17:10] It's my pleasure to be here this evening.
[0:17:13] I would like to thank the council for the opportunity to
[0:17:16] thank the council for the opportunity to be here.
[0:17:18] I would like to thank the council for the opportunity to
[0:17:29] It's my pleasure to be here this evening to talk about public art.
[0:17:34] In January, Mayor Brown and I had a conversation about public art,
[0:17:40] and realized that this would be a great opportunity.
[0:17:43] We need to do this.
[0:17:49] It's wanting me to sign in.
[0:17:52] Let me just friend it without.
[0:18:00] This would be a great opportunity for us to give a presentation kind of about the evolution
[0:18:08] of the Twin Falls Public Art and some of the different agencies that have been involved,
[0:18:15] share a little bit throughout the presentation. There's a lot of pictures in here, and most
[0:18:20] of the pictures are of a Twin Falls Public Art, and so it's kind of a little dual presentation
[0:18:31] So, I'd like to start with the mission of the Twin Falls Public Art Commission, which is
[0:18:40] to enrich the lives of all Twin Falls residents and visitors through cultivating public art
[0:18:44] and programs, enlivening public spaces, and embracing the cultural identity of the region.
[0:18:50] I'd like to start with a little history, oh, there it is.
[0:18:56] So in 1994, the City of Twin Falls designated the Magic Belly Arts Council as the official
[0:19:05] arts agency, and at the time there was a resolution that identified the public art
[0:19:12] funding mechanism and empowered the public arts council or the Magic Belly Arts Council
[0:19:19] in making the recommendations to council regarding the acquisition of public art.
[0:19:27] Consequently, when the URA phase one, the most recent URA project, they allocated a certain
[0:19:34] amount of dollars for public art projects.
[0:19:38] And then they formed a subcommittee that decided what to spend that money on.
[0:19:44] And so they did several projects.
[0:19:46] And one of the projects was to create a public art inventory.
[0:19:52] And they also created a public art tour kind of based on that public art inventory.
[0:19:57] And their definition of public art was all art that is available to the public.
[0:20:02] So there's some examples up here that would include art that is not owned by the city,
[0:20:07] but is in public spaces.
[0:20:09] So CSI campus.
[0:20:11] The girl in the upper part of this is, she's an elevation 486 by the Magic Valley Arts
[0:20:19] Council.
[0:20:21] So now I'm going to draw a blank on it, Mary Alice Park.
[0:20:26] So all of the art over there.
[0:20:28] So it's all public, publicly available, but not necessarily owned by the city.
[0:20:34] Additionally, the URA did acquire some artwork that is city that was then gifted to the city.
[0:20:41] And that includes the mural on the back city hall and the work on the original downtown
[0:20:49] Commons, Meryl Artwork, a lot of the downtown utility box wraps, they purchased the piece
[0:20:59] that's on the side of the Claude Brown's building, which is the Idaho Department store piece.
[0:21:05] And I know I'm not including everything they did, but they made a large contribution.
[0:21:11] And then subsequently, or kind of at the same time, ish, the city formed the Twin Falls Art
[0:21:19] Public Art Commission, and that art commission was tasked with facilitating the placement of
[0:21:26] art in public spaces, in conducting community education on public art, and making multiple
[0:21:34] types of recommendations to council regarding the selection of art, the purchase of art, placement
[0:21:39] of our recommendations about public art policy,
[0:21:44] in addition to that, maintaining the inventory
[0:21:48] of the city-owned public art, and then also making
[0:21:52] recommendations for maintenance.
[0:21:54] And so it's kind of exciting to talk about the hard work
[0:22:00] that this commission has put in.
[0:22:02] And I have the privilege of working with these people.
[0:22:04] And it's been a lot of work.
[0:22:08] And they've accomplished some things,
[0:22:11] but they're a great group of people to be working with.
[0:22:14] As we've started to try to go through the city's inventory,
[0:22:17] we took that original inventory that the Urban Renewal
[0:22:21] Agency started and tried to sort out the difference
[0:22:25] between public pieces and city-owned pieces.
[0:22:28] And at this point, this is a work in progress.
[0:22:31] So now we're going to start talking about,
[0:22:34] I'm giving you some numbers, but understand that everything's
[0:22:36] kind of a guess.
[0:22:37] We believe there's about 56 pieces of art
[0:22:40] that are owned by the City of Twin Falls.
[0:22:41] And that includes paintings, murals, sculptures,
[0:22:44] wraps, different kinds of art pieces.
[0:22:48] And they're located throughout the city.
[0:22:49] And this map right here is an effort with Mabel,
[0:22:54] who's our project coordinator for Parks and Rec.
[0:22:57] And she went in and worked with GIS
[0:22:58] and mapped out just the city-owned pieces
[0:23:04] for this map for me to share with you.
[0:23:06] So you can see they're kind of scattered throughout.
[0:23:08] There's a lot of them downtown,
[0:23:09] and a lot of the ones you see right downtown
[0:23:11] are the utility box wraps.
[0:23:14] And then in the John Hayes statue,
[0:23:16] and the downtown commons,
[0:23:20] and the mural in the back city hall.
[0:23:21] So there's a lot,
[0:23:22] and it's pretty substantial right in that area,
[0:23:25] but then some of the projects the commission has done
[0:23:29] has scattered out,
[0:23:30] and then we've got Ivy Perrine on the Canyon Rim,
[0:23:34] And we've got the twin statues.
[0:23:37] So and here's some examples of some of the city owned public art
[0:23:42] that I'm sure you all recognize most of those pieces.
[0:23:46] Then Blue Line is at the police department.
[0:23:49] That picture of social and falls is a Thomas Moran.
[0:23:53] And that's in the overflow.
[0:23:57] There's an example of a box wrap and then the iconic twin statue.
[0:24:03] So as we go through the city's public art,
[0:24:05] We've identified, and again, this has been some real digging on Mabel's part, but we believe
[0:24:11] there's 28 pieces that were purchased by the city, and we're assigning an approximate value
[0:24:17] of $148,384 for those pieces that were purchased.
[0:24:23] Also, we asked her to try to estimate what the maintenance would be, and so she did a
[0:24:31] lot of research on how you maintain things.
[0:24:33] Obviously, paintings don't need a lot.
[0:24:35] Bronze statues might need some cleaning.
[0:24:38] Raps might need replacement.
[0:24:40] They might need graffiti removal.
[0:24:42] We may need to put coatings on some of the work.
[0:24:45] And came up with an estimate of about $35,773 for maintenance.
[0:24:53] Now I want to talk a little bit about the Public Arts
[0:24:55] Commission and the work that they've been doing.
[0:24:58] So instead of just going through each one,
[0:25:01] I just want to give you an idea of this inventory
[0:25:04] that we're working on.
[0:25:05] They've also really dug in on the mission and values
[0:25:12] of the Public Art Commission.
[0:25:14] They did a survey.
[0:25:17] They conducted a public art survey.
[0:25:19] They developed the process for doing call to artists
[0:25:24] and receiving and accepting donations of art.
[0:25:30] as well as, in part of this, we identified that the resolution that identified the Magic
[0:25:38] Valley Arts Council as being responsible for making the recommendations.
[0:25:43] So we went in and changed both the resolution and then there's a code that defines the duties
[0:25:48] and responsibilities of the Public Arts Commission, but we also had to fix the resolution to recognize
[0:25:55] the newly formed Public Arts Commission.
[0:25:57] So this is kind of the hard behind the scenes work and these guys, it's been tedious and
[0:26:02] hard, but we've also gotten to do some fun things.
[0:26:06] And if you recall maybe, it was just about this time of year last year, we hosted an
[0:26:11] open house as part of the completion of the two projects that the commission was involved
[0:26:20] in that were the electrical reps that we placed in various locations around the city and the
[0:26:29] replacement of the artwork on the downtown commons.
[0:26:32] And that night we presented those two projects and then we invited the artists and did a reception.
[0:26:39] And then they've also been involved in some donations.
[0:26:44] A couple examples here are we were approached by Mark Schauber who's the guy standing in
[0:26:49] that picture and he donated five pieces that are now hanging at the Twin Falls Public Library
[0:26:55] and right physical therapy donated the swimmer which is at the Twin Falls City Pool and about
[0:27:00] to be rehung somewhere. I'm not sure where it's going but they're excited to put that
[0:27:06] one back up. And all this work doesn't come without some challenges. So, and by the way,
[0:27:14] every single, like I said, all the way through the slide show, we're doing a tour of art too.
[0:27:19] Does anybody know where this one is?
[0:27:21] Yes, zero part, okay.
[0:27:23] So the challenge is really having to do with funding.
[0:27:28] So if you look at the resolution
[0:27:30] and the wording on funding,
[0:27:32] at the beginning of each fiscal year,
[0:27:34] the council shall place 5-100th of a percent
[0:27:38] of the general fund capital improvement allocated dollars,
[0:27:44] just the general fund capital improvement dollars.
[0:27:47] And then it further stipulates that no less than 75%
[0:27:54] shall be allocated toward the purchase creation
[0:27:56] or installation of such public art pieces
[0:27:59] and no more than 25% goes to the maintenance,
[0:28:02] acquisition of citing and those kinds of things.
[0:28:06] So what does that mean?
[0:28:09] If we were to take, so the public art cash reserves
[0:28:13] right now is at $57,337.19.
[0:28:17] In FY26, the general fund capital improvement dollars were $5,466,414, and of that 5-100
[0:28:31] percent is $2,732.
[0:28:35] So if we add that to the public cash reserves number, we get $60,069 and change.
[0:28:45] And then if we think about that the resolution requires 25% ish to be set aside for maintenance
[0:28:53] and we pull that 15,000 off, that leaves us about $45,000 for the purchase creation or
[0:28:59] installation of public art with a renewal of $2,700 a year.
[0:29:07] These two projects that we did and celebrated last March combined were $32,576.
[0:29:17] And what we're seeing is as we start to move forward, this isn't sustainable.
[0:29:23] So my presentation concludes with a request and a recommendation by the Public Art Committee
[0:29:31] Commission to consider amending that resolution and raising the funding
[0:29:37] percentage. So tonight I'm not necessarily asking to do that other than to say if
[0:29:45] you're interested in this then we'll come back with some recommendations in
[0:29:49] the language. If you want to talk about it and I'm kind of looking at my liaison I
[0:29:58] I did prepare some numbers of what some different percentage increases could look like.
[0:30:04] And I thought I got it included in this slide shoot, but I didn't, so I brought a little cheat sheet for you to take a look at if you wanted to kind of see what some funding increases might look like.
[0:30:16] I don't know, I don't know what you want to do now if you just want us to come back with a solid recommendation, or if you want to think about what that could look like a little bit, if you have any questions.
[0:30:27] I do have members of the commission here tonight as well.
[0:30:32] Maybe before Chris, I will say part of the reason when Wendy approached me, I felt like
[0:30:37] it was a good idea to have this conversation in front of council to potentially address
[0:30:43] this situation.
[0:30:46] Public art adds value to our community and definitely trying to maintain that and keep
[0:30:50] it in good standing is an important aspect.
[0:30:56] Wendy, and maybe the resolution is the reason.
[0:31:03] Is there a reason we haven't put some of these line items
[0:31:06] in the budget and just looked at these types of things
[0:31:09] year over year and instead of just saying,
[0:31:11] five basis points is what we're gonna do,
[0:31:14] because to your point, I mean, you showed us,
[0:31:16] it's a few thousand dollars, which when we look at
[0:31:20] some of these art pieces, I was on the council way back
[0:31:23] when we purchased that painting that's in the overflow
[0:31:26] and that wasn't cheap, but it's beautiful,
[0:31:30] and it's part of our community now, and we have it,
[0:31:32] and the story behind it's great,
[0:31:34] but I want to say Ruth, if you remember, it was what, 10 grand?
[0:31:40] And I think the diligent, I should have thought about,
[0:31:42] that was a small picture.
[0:31:43] That was a small picture,
[0:31:44] and that was a discounted price, I remember.
[0:31:48] So instead of, I dislike percentages,
[0:31:51] because three years from now, it's gonna need a change,
[0:31:56] It's going to go up and down, but instead of just looking at it and saying, hey, every year, going through the budget, like all the other departments do and saying, hey, as a city, we value public art.
[0:32:08] And so this is a piece or we need this for maintenance this year. And then some years, we're not going to need this for maintenance. And so we're not going to do it.
[0:32:16] I think you're hitting right on the conundrum we've been facing as the commission for the
[0:32:24] last six months trying to figure out how to have this conversation.
[0:32:27] Last year the commission approached the long-term planning.
[0:32:32] But what we realized is that it's not really a long-term planning thing because it's codified.
[0:32:39] So there is a funding mechanism that's described in that resolution that in order, so what's
[0:32:50] the route?
[0:32:51] Is it changing the resolution to raise that amount?
[0:32:54] Is it a different practice of asking for funding?
[0:32:59] I think we went back and forth and tried to figure out how to approach it and decided
[0:33:04] But maybe we start with the resolution, because that is the driving factor.
[0:33:10] And I'm curious to see what the panel of experts over here have to say.
[0:33:16] We're happy to share if you want us to hear as your panel of experts.
[0:33:19] Please go ahead, Travis.
[0:33:25] So I think that the first thing to recognize is every budget that we create goes through
[0:33:34] a competitive exercise for the allocation of funds. And if you take a look at the people
[0:33:42] who often create and balance the budget, public art is probably not going to fare as
[0:33:49] high as public safety. Now, my dad's an artist, and if he's watching right now, he's going
[0:33:56] to probably call me later, and I'll hear about it. But truth being told, when we are trying
[0:34:02] to balance scarce resources, and a police cruiser now is approaching $80,000.
[0:34:11] It begins to chip away and take away with the limitations that Idaho has placed on the addition
[0:34:17] of new monies into local government budgets.
[0:34:21] So if you go back to the dawn of time, and this precedes me and many of us in our organization,
[0:34:26] I really believe that it was the safeguard to guarantee that there would be something
[0:34:32] for public funding. Now, the reason that it is connected just to the general fund was because
[0:34:40] when you collect a fee in the water fund or sewer fund or bond proceeds, those fees have
[0:34:46] to be directly used or the operation maintenance and capital of the system. You can't just tie
[0:34:54] something off and say, well, this is part of a public art legally. You can't use bond proceeds
[0:35:00] for anything that's not fully described in the bond ordinance that goes before the voters.
[0:35:08] General fund dollars are property tax dollars and Idaho allows you to use them as you legislate
[0:35:15] NCFIT.
[0:35:16] So that's the why it is just contained to general fund.
[0:35:21] I think Windy has demonstrated that as we've expanded, so in my tenure I think that we've
[0:35:27] seen an expansion of public art, maybe that puts me in the good graces of my father maybe
[0:35:33] for a minute, and with that becomes an increase in cost. And it really credits the arts commission
[0:35:41] by kind of bringing these ideas forward because as an entity we can kind of get in our rut
[0:35:48] and say, well that's just the way we've always done it. It's five basis points, this is the
[0:35:52] money that goes into it, it becomes a mechanical part of the process, we don't think about it,
[0:35:57] move on, kind of like having, for the most time, $150,000 in contingency, right? I mean, we kind
[0:36:03] of have these set amounts that we have historically had. I will also say that some of the public
[0:36:13] art that has been acquired through the city has been through the use of cash reserves,
[0:36:19] that we haven't used the $2,700 increments repeatedly through these processes. Because if
[0:36:26] If you start adding up the totality of the value of the public art and you take the balance
[0:36:32] that's available and then the cost, you see that there's a slight difference in math.
[0:36:36] So if I believe that the Thomas Moran painting hanging in the overflow was acquired through
[0:36:42] cash reserves, I don't believe we used the public art piece.
[0:36:46] And other offsets I think that we talked about using that for different programs, but it's
[0:36:53] It's not necessarily enough to at least cover the maintenance cost of the system.
[0:37:00] One strategy may be to really understand what that maintenance cost is.
[0:37:05] Is it always going to be $35,000?
[0:37:08] Is that annually, or is that in a 10-year period of time?
[0:37:14] So maintaining what we have should be the floor.
[0:37:20] And then the ability to fund and go through additional art could be an appropriate use
[0:37:27] of other cash reserves moving forward included specifically into the parks and recreation
[0:37:35] budget because that's where the public art fund lies.
[0:37:38] It could be the use of council capital.
[0:37:42] If there was an initiative that the Council wanted to go forward with the funding of public
[0:37:47] arts aid to commemorate the nation's 250th birthday, we could design a piece to commemorate
[0:37:52] around those things.
[0:37:53] I think what the commission is looking for is a pathway to maintain public art that is
[0:38:04] different than the resolution that is not allowing us to capture the resources necessary
[0:38:11] just to maintain what we have, let alone expand moving forward.
[0:38:16] And I think that was Travis, some of the premises is Wendy and I spoke a little bit.
[0:38:23] I think having this as a piece of our community, being able to at least maintain and I think
[0:38:30] that was kind of where we're at.
[0:38:32] So, Nathan Murray.
[0:38:34] Yeah, Travis hit almost and asked about 35,000 numbers at annual projection and do you have
[0:38:41] have dedicated to do like these audits of like our maintenance year over year.
[0:38:47] We're in the process of trying to figure out what this maintenance looks like.
[0:38:52] And I believe that that was a number that she came up with.
[0:38:59] And I don't think it would be annually.
[0:39:01] I think it's like total.
[0:39:02] Like if we went out and fixed everything, it would be 35,000.
[0:39:05] I think.
[0:39:07] I don't believe it was annually.
[0:39:12] are some things that we need to clarify as we're going through this.
[0:39:15] So we weren't fully prepared to flush that out 100 percent, but that is some of the work
[0:39:23] that we had done.
[0:39:24] Those are some numbers that were identified.
[0:39:25] I had a different presentation that kind of broke that all down and went through it, but
[0:39:30] I'm not sure if it was just showing what would happen if we didn't do it, what it's going
[0:39:34] to increase to, or if it was literally an annual basis.
[0:39:40] As we know, so you could call the work we did out at the downtown commons.
[0:39:45] We chose not to just replace those.
[0:39:49] So we could have just reprinted the work that was there originally, and that number
[0:39:55] would have been less than doing a call to artists and replacing it with new work.
[0:40:01] Our intention is to kind of build up some holdings so we can rotate those through a little
[0:40:05] bit, but that's on about a five or six year rotation maximum. I think they lasted about
[0:40:12] eight this last time, but that would be, and unfortunately it's kind of an all at once.
[0:40:20] Or we could try to phase them out as they go, but that could be considered maintenance
[0:40:25] or as a replacement whichever way you want to look at it. The box wraps are going to fade.
[0:40:33] the bronze statue doesn't need a lot, it's going to need some cleaning. The painting doesn't
[0:40:38] need much of anything. The twin seems to deteriorate fairly frequently.
[0:40:45] Okay. Chris Reed, if others have questions first, I kind of have my thought on this, so
[0:40:57] if others have questions, I don't jump to Sherry and then come back to Chris. Is that
[0:41:01] Sure. So I am real big with the arts. I love the arts and I'm an oil painter myself when
[0:41:13] I have patience to sit and do it. So I understand the importance of everything. What I struggle
[0:41:21] with is pulling the funds out what's going to give so we can get. I think that's probably
[0:41:31] My question, I don't know that I feel comfortable making a snap decision.
[0:41:40] You don't have to decide anything right now.
[0:41:45] Ruth Pierce.
[0:41:46] So one of the things that I want to make sure is we don't think we need to spend all our cash
[0:41:52] reserves.
[0:41:53] I mean, the whole goal would be to build those up for a Thomas Moran or something that
[0:42:00] we really, really need.
[0:42:02] So as you're going through your calculations, however you're going through, I would not recommend
[0:42:08] spending all those reserves for sure in a short period of time.
[0:42:17] Craig.
[0:42:19] Travis, so what I'm understanding is right now we do not have the funding to just to meet
[0:42:25] our maintenance costs.
[0:42:27] And from what I gather, the percentage in the resolution is kind of a safety yet, so to
[0:42:34] And so, depending on what we feel we could afford to increase that percentage, then that
[0:42:42] would be kind of a backup for us in the future to be able to use as we need for maintenance
[0:42:48] or acquisition.
[0:42:50] So, I think it'd be nice to, and I suppose we still could, if we had that, we still could
[0:43:01] petition for a project or something out of general fund or something like that, so that
[0:43:06] wouldn't limit that either.
[0:43:08] Is that what I understand?
[0:43:10] Yes.
[0:43:11] So the council has the ability to award capital dollars to any project that you see fit.
[0:43:21] Public art is a qualifying expense.
[0:43:23] So if the arts commission came forward and said we would like to produce another piece
[0:43:32] of public art and we want to work and put out a request for proposals for us to review,
[0:43:41] that could easily go through that process.
[0:43:44] I don't believe that you're limited to only spending and I think that's probably maybe part
[0:43:50] of that misconception that we've had across the organization, well, you only have blanks
[0:43:54] so you can't spend anymore.
[0:43:57] As you witness throughout an entire fiscal year, every single department comes forward
[0:44:01] and says, hey, I need a little bit more, or I'd like to shift these dollars to a new emerging
[0:44:06] priority.
[0:44:07] And we always try to keep that sustainable and moving forward.
[0:44:12] My suggestion would be that you take a little bit broader definition than just simple maintenance.
[0:44:20] Recognizing that there is potential replacement costs that are going to be needed.
[0:44:29] So, you know, the amazing bronze statue that we have out in front probably doesn't need
[0:44:37] to have a placement cost assigned to it as much as the wraps and the murals and the other
[0:44:44] art that are going to be on a no-in replacement cycle of every five to seven years.
[0:44:50] Now, the difference with the new art that we put up this year is that it is a UV coating
[0:44:54] on it, so it should remain more bright and more brilliant than the ones that we replaced.
[0:45:00] But it doesn't mean that they're there permanently.
[0:45:02] So they will need to be replaced.
[0:45:05] They are increasing in cost like everything else.
[0:45:09] And so having a good understanding to say that those have a life expectancy of five years
[0:45:17] with an anticipated cost of $40,000, we need at least $8,000 to replace those moving forward.
[0:45:24] And I think if the public arts commission were able to say, and these are the other costs,
[0:45:31] that's a number that they could bring back to the council, if the council was interested.
[0:45:35] part of that piece is we never as staff want to present a resolution that has been adopted
[0:45:41] by the Council that completely undoes what you've done in the past without at least having
[0:45:45] an initial conversation to say, hey, we have a different idea for you.
[0:45:49] Thank you, Travis. Chris, it looks like we're back to you.
[0:45:54] I'll just share my opinion, especially with, and we've talked about maintenance, and maintenance
[0:46:02] means a lot of different things when it comes to art. So that's a very broad, very similar
[0:46:08] to some of our other departments. We're replacing vehicles that's maintenance, but that's also
[0:46:13] fixing a lot of other things. So understanding, when I say maintenance, I would like to see
[0:46:19] maintenance come through the regular budget because there's going to be some years that
[0:46:24] we're going to be replacing murals and it's going to be a little bit more and there's going
[0:46:27] to be some years where it's not.
[0:46:28] And so understanding that long-term budgeting,
[0:46:33] there's things that are a lot more higher priority.
[0:46:36] There's things that are lower.
[0:46:38] It seems like yours are not going to be, even though we're
[0:46:42] saying it might be a little bit more money.
[0:46:44] It's not $80,000 for a new police cruiser.
[0:46:46] It's several thousand dollars to change something
[0:46:51] out doing those types of things.
[0:46:53] I would like to see it come through.
[0:46:54] I think we would be able to support that maintenance,
[0:46:57] the ongoing maintenance much better than you guys saying we have, even if it's from
[0:47:05] five basis points to 10 basis points, that jump, that's $5,466, you might not be able
[0:47:15] to do that.
[0:47:16] So something that needs to be repaired one year, you're going to push to the next year.
[0:47:20] Instead of, okay, maintenance, we do that, and if it's acquisition, maybe we look at
[0:47:26] a different avenue for something like that, but instead of just saying a five basis points
[0:47:31] is what we're going to do and leave it on your shoulders like everything's fine. I feel
[0:47:36] like maintenance should come through the regular budgeting and if we want to talk about
[0:47:40] acquisition of new art or anything like that, we've already kind of done that with a lot
[0:47:46] of our stuff where it's gone through and we've pulled out of cash reserves because of the cost.
[0:47:51] And without wanting to get too far into the weeds tonight with this presentation, that
[0:47:55] was a piece of this. So the language in the resolution is a little bit confusing on what
[0:48:01] the intention is. You know, is it 15 or does a 25% of the 2700 that needs to go into a
[0:48:07] separate account? Or is it 25% of the total? And if we keep spending the total down, then
[0:48:12] the maintenance budget drops. So some clarifying language to better address those that intention
[0:48:21] there might be exactly what you're talking about, and maybe it is just pulling the maintenance
[0:48:27] piece out of it and including it somewhere else.
[0:48:33] I agree with what Travis was saying.
[0:48:35] There are top priorities.
[0:48:37] I want to make sure that public safety and art is important and percentage-wise of our
[0:48:44] budget is very small.
[0:48:48] And if it doesn't meet the long term, it can come to the council for the council's appointed
[0:48:54] funds as well.
[0:48:56] So if we didn't do an amendment to the resolution, we could leave the funding mechanism as is
[0:49:04] and invite the commission to come and request funds on a case-by-case basis, if that's what
[0:49:11] I'm hearing.
[0:49:12] Otherwise, for me, I would like the maintenance,
[0:49:18] especially where that 30,000.
[0:49:19] Again, I know that there's a lot that goes into it.
[0:49:22] I'd rather that come through the regular budgeting process
[0:49:26] where you know, hey, we're gonna, in five years.
[0:49:28] Okay, so as we anticipate it.
[0:49:31] You're gonna put that through.
[0:49:33] It's a budgeted.
[0:49:34] I think, for me, I think a lot of,
[0:49:36] I think of where we're at here is,
[0:49:40] I'm not sure we have a clear understanding.
[0:49:43] You know, we was at 58 pieces of art,
[0:49:46] getting a better understanding of what that hard cost would be,
[0:49:49] whether it's a replacement cost of a wrap,
[0:49:52] whether it's a, you know, however we define maintenance,
[0:49:55] whether that's a replacement cost,
[0:49:56] whether that's going in and cleaning bird droppings
[0:50:00] off of the statue.
[0:50:01] I think we need to have a better understanding
[0:50:03] of really what, when we, and I think this comes into play,
[0:50:08] when we buy our next piece of art,
[0:50:09] we better know what that replacement cost is,
[0:50:12] what the maintenance expectation is.
[0:50:15] And I think getting our arms around what that would be
[0:50:18] would then lead to, I think, what Chris is going into
[0:50:21] is, hey, on an annual basis, our annual maintenance
[0:50:24] of this collection that we have is only 5,000
[0:50:27] over a six year period, it's 30,000
[0:50:30] because of what we've done.
[0:50:31] I think getting our arms around that,
[0:50:34] molding it into a better, maybe clarifying
[0:50:36] some of the language in the resolution
[0:50:39] and then bringing that back.
[0:50:41] because I think Chris is right is if it's if it's a small amount of money for
[0:50:45] whatever we define that maintenance as it's a lot easier to go that get through
[0:50:49] that but I think we need a better understanding of when we buy a piece of
[0:50:53] art what are we getting and I think we you know the count the commission is
[0:50:57] very conscious of that as we've gone through the the process now is trying
[0:51:02] to identify with the maintenance costs and clearly if you think about it I don't
[0:51:07] don't know what the John Haystown shoe costs.
[0:51:10] And the maintenance percentage is pretty small on that.
[0:51:14] And then you buy the artwork that we put in the downtown commons and the purchase less
[0:51:24] the artist fees is the value is the same whether it's replacing it.
[0:51:31] So it's cost, I don't know the term, but the maintenance on that is a much higher
[0:51:36] percentage on something like that. And as we're working through that spreadsheet, I think what
[0:51:40] we're trying to find out right now is is there an appetite for the conversation? And is this the
[0:51:44] right conversation to have? And if it is, then we can come back with some adjusted numbers and better
[0:51:54] idea of what that maintenance piece needs to be. Yeah, I think overall, I think it appears at
[0:52:00] least to my ears that there is an appetite to look at what does public art look like going
[0:52:07] forward and how do we maintain the asset that we have, how does that look like? I think we can continue
[0:52:14] to have that conversation, but I think truly understanding what a lot of line number is is going
[0:52:21] to be a big part of how we move forward in making some of those decisions as a council, as staff,
[0:52:28] truly getting our arms around what that is, because when we get another piece of art donated or we buy
[0:52:33] something, we need to have a mechanism to evaluate that and then put that into our bottom line.
[0:52:39] Obviously, a bronze statue is going to last for 40 years. We're not going to have to do that.
[0:52:44] Sure, something that, but we also know that, and so, you know, it may be categories, different
[0:52:49] categories, it may be paintings, it may be statues, it may be a hardscape rock or something, and we
[0:52:54] need to understand what that is. And so, having a better idea to me is a way to move, but I think
[0:53:00] I think there is an appetite to get our arms around what that looks like.
[0:53:04] Is that fair?
[0:53:06] Yes.
[0:53:07] Does that give you some level of direction to maybe go back and work with the arts mission
[0:53:12] to help get our arms around?
[0:53:15] Yes.
[0:53:16] Our arms around it.
[0:53:17] I think so.
[0:53:18] I'm getting some head nods.
[0:53:22] Thank you.
[0:53:23] Thank you, Swindy.
[0:53:24] I appreciate it.
[0:53:25] Thanks for bringing this up.
[0:53:27] Our next item for consideration is a discussion of possible action related to modifying Title
[0:53:37] 10, Chapter 2, Section 10, Public Notice Sign Design Requirements.
[0:53:43] Looks like we've got Jonathan Spendlove bringing another display for us to view.
[0:54:00] As lively as that conversation was, Mayor, this one might get a little bit like that as
[0:54:04] well.
[0:54:05] So now we're revved up for this one.
[0:54:08] The staff report says the story.
[0:54:10] Essentially, a couple weeks ago, we
[0:54:11] were notified that our public hearing signs were no longer
[0:54:14] going to be available for rent.
[0:54:17] Applicants were used to be able to go rent them from a third party.
[0:54:21] That third party decided not to do that anymore.
[0:54:23] And so the staff report has the rental price.
[0:54:27] It's under the background.
[0:54:28] It's like the last paragraphs.
[0:54:30] It used to be $75 with a deposit.
[0:54:32] and then for the smaller signs and 125 for the larger ones.
[0:54:36] When they stop doing that, the smaller signs are now listed for sale, and somebody can purchase
[0:54:41] them to use for their public hearing, and they are $260.
[0:54:46] The larger ones are 280.
[0:54:49] That's just for the panel.
[0:54:50] You'd have to actually mount it onto something.
[0:54:52] The wood frame that they would create would be $640.
[0:54:57] This is important because state statute, which is also in the report.
[0:55:03] It's actually very slim as to what they say we have to put on the property.
[0:55:06] But every public notice, the definition of notice, is notice of the time and place and
[0:55:12] the summary of the plan, which is the thing you're going to discuss.
[0:55:17] And then further for special use permits, which is our usual bread and butter for the planning
[0:55:22] zoning commission and any item taking place on a property specifically, the notice shall
[0:55:28] be posted on the premises not less than one week prior to the hearing.
[0:55:33] your guidance from the state of Idaho on what needs to be placed on the property. So the notice,
[0:55:39] I'm going to point this, the notice is actually a little holder thing down here which is where the
[0:55:45] letter goes and the letter is where we say here's what we're discussing, which can be a special use
[0:55:51] permit or a, I was going to try and pick something that's like not very controversial. Let's do a
[0:55:57] daycare on this property in the neighborhood and then the meeting is
[0:56:03] going to be held on Tuesday or March 31st at 6 p.m. City Council chambers so we've
[0:56:10] got what it is where the where it's going to be and yep time, place, and
[0:56:17] summary those are the three things that are noticed it's all you have to put for
[0:56:20] the statute and then we put the sign on the property so that's following the
[0:56:25] state law. Now we as a city have enacted an ordinance it was 3091 that's where we
[0:56:34] created the size of the signs that we have a 2 by 3 and a 4 by 4 depending on
[0:56:40] where it's at within the community. 2 by 3 is placed so far apart on the
[0:56:45] property and then a 4 by 4 is what is what was going on the arterial roadways
[0:56:50] so that you're bigger streets. The sizes of those is dictated by the council not
[0:56:56] by the state of Idaho, okay? So each time someone had a public hearing that was
[0:57:03] taking place on a property, we would place a sign, the applicant would be
[0:57:07] required to place the sign depending on the size, but in the letter, into the
[0:57:12] little holder, which is the notice, and they would, we'd make them put them up two
[0:57:16] weeks before the hearing that's again our requirement. That size requirement and
[0:57:24] the dictation of what the what it looks like is what we create in 2015 we brought
[0:57:29] that forward into our new code on January 1st we didn't change it other
[0:57:34] than maybe placement and the certain number that had to be on the property but
[0:57:39] in general we have had a solid surface material the size which is the 4A4-2x3
[0:57:44] white background and black lettering, brochure holder mounted to the sign, and then we put
[0:57:51] the words notice of public meeting for more information, call, and then the phone number
[0:57:55] for the Planning and Zoning Department with the City logo.
[0:57:59] All of those things are extra from the state statute.
[0:58:03] This is something we can choose to do.
[0:58:07] When we were notified that they were not going to be for rent, especially these permit costs
[0:58:11] $500 to go to the application process.
[0:58:13] Someone that needed to purchase a sign
[0:58:15] for an additional $250 to $600 for each sign,
[0:58:20] we felt was going to be that onerous a bit much
[0:58:23] for the applicants already paying for a special use permit.
[0:58:27] So, I wanted to bring it to your attention.
[0:58:30] I have a conversation on what we should do.
[0:58:32] I have presented or within your packet four,
[0:58:37] kind of examples, one of them is the,
[0:58:39] The first one is, keep the regulations as they stand,
[0:58:42] and that's what you have in your package.
[0:58:43] The first one, they still have to get the sign the same size.
[0:58:48] They buy them instead of rent them.
[0:58:49] Maybe somebody else starts to rent them.
[0:58:52] We can continue as we are fully compliant with the law.
[0:58:55] Our applicants would then have something to do
[0:58:59] or some work to be done.
[0:59:01] People can make their own sign.
[0:59:03] I've seen it a few times out of plywood,
[0:59:05] and they just paint it wide, and they get the lettering,
[0:59:08] and they amount the brochure holder, it's happened.
[0:59:11] So that's option one.
[0:59:13] And these are just five options my team came up with,
[0:59:15] which is first discussion.
[0:59:16] Starting points really.
[0:59:18] We can remove the four by four size requirement
[0:59:21] on keep only the two by threes.
[0:59:23] They're less money, they're easier to put up for applicants.
[0:59:27] They're still not for rent, but it removes some barrier.
[0:59:32] Those large signs have to be on pretty substantial,
[0:59:36] I guess footing almost because they can blow over
[0:59:38] in our 50 mile-per-hour winds that are common.
[0:59:42] Option three was to change the requirement
[0:59:44] to something that's less expensive,
[0:59:46] like a corrugated plastic, like the yard signs,
[0:59:48] those are about 20 bucks a piece,
[0:59:50] 20 to 35 bucks a piece, the two-by-three size.
[0:59:54] And then I actually did some just AI-generated stuff
[0:59:58] because it was easy for me to do in a few minutes.
[1:00:01] So that would be attachment number three.
[1:00:05] we could also change the requirement to the minimum state code, which is just the notice
[1:00:09] letter with something to hold the letter and holder out there and people could take them
[1:00:15] or not.
[1:00:16] Believe it or not, we have pictures across the state where it's just a wooden stake with the
[1:00:21] notice stapled to it after it's laminated, that still meets the state requirement, but
[1:00:27] that's pretty minimal.
[1:00:30] The last one is all of those options with varying degrees of size, color, shape that you would
[1:00:39] wish to see.
[1:00:40] So what we have today is a code currently requires the two by three and a four by four depending
[1:00:48] on where it's located.
[1:00:49] It has to be out of a solid surface, it has to have a brochure holder and it has to be
[1:00:55] out there 15 days prior to the hearing.
[1:00:58] Luckily, we have few hearings in the next little bit.
[1:01:02] I also have a code amendment already started,
[1:01:06] but I don't have authorization to change this portion of the code.
[1:01:09] So, a few things. If we want to change what we're going to do,
[1:01:13] we're going to initiate a code amendment.
[1:01:15] Just kind of tack on to what I've already done,
[1:01:17] which is finding things we've got wrong with the code,
[1:01:19] the Scribbner's errors and some spelling and some things that got dropped off.
[1:01:23] And I can have that done and back to you after going to the commission
[1:01:26] for a public hearing sometime in May.
[1:01:30] We can just keep it as it is and don't touch that part
[1:01:33] and still move forward.
[1:01:34] And again, we have a lot of varying degrees in between there.
[1:01:36] So tonight I'm looking for discussion and direction
[1:01:39] if we want to change what we're going to do.
[1:01:41] I brought this as an example for size and material
[1:01:44] and we can have lots of discussion
[1:01:46] on varying degrees you'd like to have going forward.
[1:01:50] Okay. Chris Reed.
[1:01:52] Real quick looking at the corrugated ones.
[1:01:55] And I think when you kind of had mentioned,
[1:01:58] stick in the ground, stapled on it,
[1:02:01] they don't have to give something for somebody to take.
[1:02:06] I don't know how many I've driven by,
[1:02:09] where it looks exactly like that, with nothing inside of it.
[1:02:12] It's just this sign.
[1:02:13] Whether they put something inside or not,
[1:02:15] it's kind of like Halloween, the bowls outside,
[1:02:18] you're like, oh, just take one, and there's nothing in there.
[1:02:21] It looks exactly like that.
[1:02:22] So, I mean, I'm comfortable with the corrugated.
[1:02:27] I think that, cost-wise, whatever it is,
[1:02:31] with that information, whether they staple it on it,
[1:02:34] tape it on it, have it printed on there,
[1:02:37] can you do a QR code that would, that's, you know.
[1:02:41] They are available to do QR codes.
[1:02:43] We can, we investigated that.
[1:02:45] Part was almost like something we're gonna do anyway
[1:02:47] to have at least something that would point
[1:02:49] to our public hearing web page for whatever's coming up so that somebody could then click
[1:02:56] and go right to the website and find the item they're looking for.
[1:03:00] That does not satisfy the notice per the state, so I still have to do the other things the QR
[1:03:04] code could just be an add-on.
[1:03:05] Okay.
[1:03:06] Yeah, I'd be comfortable with that, especially where you can get pretty creative, well, we
[1:03:15] would want to have our standards.
[1:03:17] We could we would create the QR code with Josh with a specific Idaho or Twin Falls specific
[1:03:23] thing that points to the same location every time that everybody could print on one or I'm
[1:03:27] just saying it would be nice to have a layout so it doesn't get crazy. Oh, to keep the layout
[1:03:33] is what you're saying. Keep the layout size wise. I think it can vary my opinion.
[1:03:39] I think the corrugated, I agree with Chris on that, was there not another option anywhere
[1:03:49] else to have them as a rental or what?
[1:03:52] We only had one company that was renting them since 2012.
[1:03:57] It wasn't another option to have any other company.
[1:04:00] No one has stepped up.
[1:04:01] No one has mentioned that they have a desire to do or has a desire.
[1:04:05] I think keeping the cost down and the corrugated,
[1:04:09] being that they're up there for how long at the most.
[1:04:11] Two weeks at the most, we also have a provision
[1:04:14] for them to take them down.
[1:04:16] They're supposed to take them down after three days.
[1:04:17] Sometimes that doesn't happen.
[1:04:19] We have an idea that we put in a code
[1:04:21] on how to manage that from an internal standpoint.
[1:04:24] I don't wanna, I don't have it fully vetted
[1:04:26] with my team yet to figure out how there is,
[1:04:28] but I think there's a way to do that,
[1:04:29] to have them take them down.
[1:04:33] I know it is hard when it's real windy.
[1:04:35] And I think people who put up corrugated signs,
[1:04:39] we understand that those H-stakes make a big difference.
[1:04:44] So, but I think for two weeks,
[1:04:46] unless I'm hearing from somebody else,
[1:04:48] that that's not a good idea.
[1:04:49] I think that might be the best way.
[1:04:53] Any other council members?
[1:04:56] So I'd agree, I think we've become accustomed
[1:04:59] to the white sign behind you.
[1:05:01] I would probably, in my idea,
[1:05:06] would be to standardize what that size is.
[1:05:09] I think the two by three is a pretty good size corrugated.
[1:05:14] I think it's also important to identify
[1:05:16] that it's a city of Twin Falls public hearing
[1:05:18] because particularly as we get into some of those
[1:05:21] jurisdictional boundaries, it becomes a little bit unsure
[1:05:25] of who's public hearing it is.
[1:05:27] And so being the logo there, I think is,
[1:05:31] but having something standard,
[1:05:33] I think people are there,
[1:05:34] whether it's corrugated or not,
[1:05:35] I think the corrugated is just fine.
[1:05:38] And having a QR code would be something that would be nice
[1:05:42] as we forward, so kind of my general.
[1:05:46] But as for timeline, I think if we can get it wrapped up
[1:05:49] and put it into some of the other ones,
[1:05:50] I think it would be great for us to keep moving forward
[1:05:54] on a Craig Hawkins.
[1:05:58] So would this be, the city would be making these then,
[1:06:03] Are we renting them or very good question?
[1:06:07] Okay, we have two options.
[1:06:09] If we were going to keep it metal, I would say no, we would not want to do that.
[1:06:14] The corrugated, they can stack pretty well.
[1:06:17] We could do that and purchase them in bulk and have them available for when someone applies.
[1:06:24] They get their information, their paperwork, and we give them the one or two signs that they
[1:06:29] need and they purchase it with their application.
[1:06:32] We could then control a lot of the design that way, and that's probably the best way
[1:06:38] to control the design other than to giving the design to everybody.
[1:06:41] So that is an option that we could do.
[1:06:43] We could also just say, here is the design like we have in the past, make it wherever
[1:06:47] you want to make it, and attach this letter to the corrugated, either staple tape or whatever.
[1:06:53] Those are two options.
[1:06:54] We have had internal debates amongst ourselves as to what the best way to go forward is.
[1:07:00] We are split.
[1:07:02] I think I get the deciding vote between the five of us.
[1:07:05] It's like two and two or three to one.
[1:07:07] I don't know.
[1:07:07] I might be the outside person on that one.
[1:07:10] If we were to do that, would we want those signs back,
[1:07:13] then you're saying?
[1:07:14] Or I mean, it's going to take some manpower
[1:07:18] to make that happen, store them, get them out.
[1:07:22] Yep.
[1:07:22] That's part of the problem is the storage.
[1:07:25] If we had to place them as a whole nother discussion,
[1:07:29] which we've divorced ourselves from many years ago.
[1:07:33] I'm getting them back because the court
[1:07:35] get it sometimes, they may not last much longer
[1:07:37] than two weeks or a month.
[1:07:39] They may not be usable for the next person.
[1:07:41] The real important part is to get them removed
[1:07:43] from the public view when the item is gone and done,
[1:07:48] because we do get a lot of calls from people
[1:07:49] saying is that over, it's been a month past
[1:07:52] and the sign's still up sometimes.
[1:07:55] Otherwise, some of those are just gonna be one time use.
[1:07:58] That's kind of how those are.
[1:08:00] So that is a downside to it,
[1:08:02] is they are made of less durable material.
[1:08:07] There are issues with this type of sign
[1:08:09] trying to place it because if you try to use
[1:08:11] a sledgehammer on the corners,
[1:08:12] it will damage the angle iron and pop the sign out.
[1:08:16] Or if you step on that bottom ledge,
[1:08:19] those things break off.
[1:08:21] There's a constant maintenance to them as well.
[1:08:24] So we haven't decided,
[1:08:27] But we would definitely have the firm decision
[1:08:30] and the numbers if we were gonna do it
[1:08:32] or we would just say the applicant gets it printed
[1:08:34] and we know there's places that print these in town.
[1:08:38] There's multiple places that we'll print one or two
[1:08:40] at a time.
[1:08:42] Thank you, Ruth Pierce.
[1:08:43] So having bought corrugated signs,
[1:08:46] the timing isn't always good.
[1:08:48] And I think if we had a stack,
[1:08:51] even if they were, you bought them,
[1:08:53] you didn't have to bring them back
[1:08:54] because they're a one time use
[1:08:56] and we're able to store them.
[1:08:58] I think that makes it's a convenience for the applicants,
[1:09:04] that it might take two, three weeks a month
[1:09:07] to get a sign printed depending on whether it's election
[1:09:11] season or what's going on.
[1:09:13] And so I think having a stack,
[1:09:16] even though it's a little extra work
[1:09:18] and just be one and done, you know,
[1:09:22] for getting pretty expensive if you print up multiple signs.
[1:09:27] and then just make sure you have the right stakes.
[1:09:30] We'd get ones of the stakes already.
[1:09:32] Chris Reed.
[1:09:34] You're talking to a group of individuals that know corrugated signs.
[1:09:37] Yes, you do. I think that was coming in a little bit on downside of animation.
[1:09:41] Something we're really passionate about.
[1:09:43] So I would be in favor of, you know, I know you're working through this, both options.
[1:09:49] I mean, we have a developer back there that's been in these multiple times.
[1:09:54] Once you've done it a couple of times, you're going to know what works best for you to Ruth's point.
[1:10:03] There's not all stands are created equal, so you're going to want to get some that can deal with Idaho wind,
[1:10:11] and you're going to learn that very quickly, and zip ties that keep them on all those types of things.
[1:10:16] So I think it's one of those, if we ended up with 100 or 250 because you get them at a good price at that amount,
[1:10:24] we have them, they store pretty easy and if somebody's like, I got it myself, they go and buy it themselves.
[1:10:31] This is what I'm hearing and I'll regurgitate back a little bit, kind of get it all together.
[1:10:39] To do that, we would have a code amendment, a title amendment.
[1:10:42] When we bring the title amendment, we would have that information available to say,
[1:10:47] this is what we come up with and this will be our path.
[1:10:50] I give you both options if you want to see both options so you know the budget change
[1:10:54] because it would be a little bit of change there.
[1:10:57] To do the Title Amendment,
[1:10:59] I just need that authorization to say,
[1:11:01] initiate a Title Amendment for this thing.
[1:11:04] And then we will hook it to the one we've already started
[1:11:07] with our Planning and Zoning Commission.
[1:11:08] They just didn't have this information or the direction.
[1:11:11] You just want direction on the Title Amendment.
[1:11:13] I think we're on agreement or do we need a motion on that?
[1:11:16] I would motion for a Title Amendment to change
[1:11:19] that chapter and section.
[1:11:21] We generally had another Title Amendment
[1:11:23] to deal with other things.
[1:11:25] I just want to be really solid that we have this.
[1:11:26] I'll entertain a motion for the modification of Title 10,
[1:11:32] Chapter 2, Section 10, Public Sign Design requirements.
[1:11:38] Lulu?
[1:11:40] Second.
[1:11:42] I have a first and a second to modify Title 10, Chapter 2,
[1:11:47] Section 10, Public Notice Sign Design Requirements.
[1:11:52] Any further discussion?
[1:11:55] Okay, Amy roll call vote.
[1:11:58] Jason Brown.
[1:11:58] Yes.
[1:11:59] Jerry Bulmer.
[1:12:00] Yes.
[1:12:01] Nate Murray.
[1:12:02] Yes.
[1:12:03] Ruth Pierce.
[1:12:03] Yes.
[1:12:04] Chris Reed.
[1:12:05] Yes.
[1:12:06] Ray Cawkins.
[1:12:07] Yes.
[1:12:08] Okay, motion carries six to zero.
[1:12:11] The next item for consideration is a request to approve the use of $13,599 from contingency for
[1:12:18] the repair of the City Hall HVAC unit and we have Gretchen Scott.
[1:12:23] Hi and good evening.
[1:12:25] I'm happy to be here tonight with you.
[1:12:28] So we have a building that next year will be 10 years old and we are starting to encounter
[1:12:35] some of our first mechanical issues with our building.
[1:12:40] We have some wall mounted HVAC individual room units which we've had both some under warranty
[1:12:46] repair work we're having to do as well as some parts that are not covered under warranty.
[1:12:52] Some of the things that are not covered under warranty are also parts that are becoming obsolete.
[1:12:58] So the request before you tonight is multi-part, and in the Stafford part I laid out exactly
[1:13:05] what pieces were each of those, but essentially 4400 was for the repair of failed unit with
[1:13:12] labor included that is not under warranty. And then we have a total of 21 7,000 BTU
[1:13:22] individual eight-back units. So we're asking to buy three extra units in order
[1:13:29] to put those up if needed when we do additional HVAC inspections. And then
[1:13:36] an additional 9,000 BTU unit to be able to use if one of those fails as well. We
[1:13:42] have four of those. The other units that we have within the building are all single, so
[1:13:48] they're just one of those and we would only ask to replace those if they should fail. And
[1:13:53] then to round out the request because the new replacement heads are a little bit different
[1:13:58] sized than the ones that are existing, we're going to have some wall and some paint matching
[1:14:03] that we need to do in each of those rooms. So that brings a total to 13,599. Additionally,
[1:14:11] This for your information currently the contingency fund is using rounded numbers $190,000.
[1:14:21] This request would bring it to $176,401 left or remaining in contingency.
[1:14:29] Are there any questions?
[1:14:30] Chris Reed.
[1:14:31] I don't have any questions.
[1:14:32] I'm ready to make a motion.
[1:14:33] I think you guys should have heat and air conditioning.
[1:14:36] Go ahead.
[1:14:37] So I move that we approve the use of $13,599 from contingency funds.
[1:14:42] for the repair of the City Hall HVAC units.
[1:14:46] Ruth Pierce, second.
[1:14:47] I have a motion and a second to approve the use
[1:14:50] of 13,599 from contingency for the repairs
[1:14:56] of the City Hall HVAC units.
[1:14:58] Any further discussion?
[1:15:00] Amy Roll-Covote.
[1:15:02] Sherry Bulmer.
[1:15:03] Yes.
[1:15:04] Jason Murray.
[1:15:05] Yes.
[1:15:06] Ruth Pierce.
[1:15:07] Yes.
[1:15:07] Chris Reed.
[1:15:08] Yes.
[1:15:09] Greg Hawkins.
[1:15:10] Yes.
[1:15:11] the motion carries six to zero.
[1:15:13] Thank you, Gretchen.
[1:15:14] Thank you very much.
[1:15:15] Appreciate it.
[1:15:16] That brings us to our time and for the general public input.
[1:15:22] If there's anybody in the general public audience that would like to address the City Council
[1:15:26] for items that are not on the agenda tonight and also that are specifically related to
[1:15:31] city business, please provide your name and whether you're a resident of the City of Twin
[1:15:39] Falls.
[1:15:40] You may want to hit that, I don't think.
[1:15:47] Oh, there we go.
[1:15:48] My name is Maria Hernandez.
[1:15:50] I'm a native of Twin Falls, Idaho.
[1:15:52] And on 32126, I had the honor of meeting Aurelia Gilmartin.
[1:15:57] Aurelia Gilmartin is a young teen who attends Lighthouse Christian School.
[1:16:02] Aurelia started a diaper drive called Field of Dome.
[1:16:05] Aurelia managed to raise 12,089 diapers to voices against violence, the Valley House and
[1:16:10] the Sages Women's Center.
[1:16:11] After hanging out with Aurelia for a couple of hours to get to know her, I come to realize
[1:16:16] how kind and unselfish she is.
[1:16:18] Her vision for her project was an inspiration to me.
[1:16:22] How somebody so young with a big heart is chasing after her dreams.
[1:16:27] And I just wanted to say thanks Aurelia for being you and giving back to the community.
[1:16:33] I was really inspired that day and she had other youth helping her that day, unloading
[1:16:39] the pallets of diapers. And what was neat is that they were all helping each other and
[1:16:46] they were all getting along. That's kind of hard to have teenagers all get along. Anyway,
[1:16:51] they just bless my socks off. And so I just kind of wanted to honor her. She has such a
[1:16:56] gentle kind spirit and a giving spirit and I just really wanted to honor that teenager.
[1:17:01] Thank you.
[1:17:02] Thanks Maria. Appreciate it. Is there anybody else in the general audience that to address
[1:17:08] the city council. Okay, seeing none, we'll move on to our advisory board reports. Any
[1:17:15] advisory city manager's office. Okay. We'll move into our public hearing. Um, a public
[1:17:28] hearing card. Notice the public hearing. Here we go. Read this. Um, that's not quite
[1:17:49] yet. I'll, I'll turn it over. I just want to make sure this might, I think this is my
[1:17:51] my first public hearing of the whole time.
[1:17:55] So Craig had the last one,
[1:17:57] maybe you want Craig wants to take this one.
[1:17:59] So we'll, I don't need to read this now,
[1:18:03] do I until the public hearing's open?
[1:18:05] Go ahead and read it.
[1:18:06] Okay.
[1:18:07] So public hearing, during the public hearing portions
[1:18:10] of the meeting testimony will be taken
[1:18:12] from the public related to each item.
[1:18:14] If you have any issue you would like to discuss
[1:18:17] that is not listed on the agenda, please contact the staff.
[1:18:21] The city will follow these nine steps for each requested listed under the public hearing
[1:18:27] portion of the agenda.
[1:18:28] The city will present the request and analysis.
[1:18:31] The applicant will then present their request, the city, the council, sorry, the council will
[1:18:38] then ask questions of the applicant or staff.
[1:18:41] After questions have been asked, the public hearing will then be opened.
[1:18:45] During that time, anyone in attendance is given the opportunity to comment or ask questions
[1:18:50] about the request being considered.
[1:18:53] When giving testimony, please step up to the podium,
[1:18:57] state your name and address, then present your comments
[1:18:59] or concerns after giving testimony.
[1:19:02] Please sign the public, sign and sheet located in the lobby
[1:19:06] with your name and address for the record.
[1:19:08] After public comments are concluded,
[1:19:11] the applicant will be invited to answer any questions
[1:19:14] and make closing statement.
[1:19:16] Staff will then answer or clarify any comments as needed.
[1:19:20] After the closing statement, the public hearing will be closed.
[1:19:24] No further testimony or comments from the applicant or audience will be allowed.
[1:19:28] The council will then have an open discussion and take action on the request.
[1:19:33] We have Will.
[1:19:38] Thank you, Mr. Mayor.
[1:19:41] Today, today we have a before you an annexation request.
[1:19:49] The subject property is located on the south horse corner of Poline Road West and Sunway Drive.
[1:19:58] It is this, roughly 40 acres to the west is a residential subdivision.
[1:20:08] And then to the south is was recently annexed into the city for a believer's church.
[1:20:17] And then to the east was recently annexed into the city
[1:20:22] within the last couple of years,
[1:20:23] along with just a cross-polaring road to the north
[1:20:27] for this property right there.
[1:20:34] When we look at the zoning, the zoning map,
[1:20:39] the area is outside of the city limits.
[1:20:42] And so with this annexation, we are looking at
[1:20:46] what would be appropriate zoning if you should wish to annex the property.
[1:20:57] To the east, a cross-sunway, this property was recently zoned commercial.
[1:21:06] Then if you go to the south, the property that was recently annexed for Believ's church
[1:21:11] was residential and then to the southeast it was zoned as residential as well our TN1
[1:21:21] our lowest residential zoning designation. This area also went before the Planning and
[1:21:30] Zoning Commission then ultimately before this council for a water service boundary update
[1:21:38] along with a comprehensive plan update.
[1:21:41] And there it was determined at that time
[1:21:45] that it would go into a future land use designation
[1:21:49] of commercial and residential.
[1:21:51] This line is fuzzy and it can go up and down
[1:21:55] or be skewed in that area as the council sees fit.
[1:22:00] This is just the general guidance for this zoning designation.
[1:22:05] The water service boundary was extended
[1:22:08] to the west of the property.
[1:22:10] And then if I were to zoom out, it goes all the way up
[1:22:14] across Pole Line Road and then eventually connects
[1:22:17] to the Grand View Mall.
[1:22:25] But here's the subject zoning exhibit
[1:22:29] and annexation exhibit where the request would be
[1:22:34] to have the commercial zone along Pole Line Road West
[1:22:39] and Sunway Drive North.
[1:22:41] The Sunway Drive North is a collector slash arterial.
[1:22:47] I say it's both designations, because it technically falls under the arterial designation.
[1:22:56] However, with Sunway Drive that ending into the canyon, not too far south, the city engineer
[1:23:07] could designate that as a smaller section and be built to collector section. So along our arterial
[1:23:16] and collectors the wish is to go for commercial and then to provide a little buffer to the west
[1:23:23] would be the town neighborhood one zoning designation which is our lowest zoning designation.
[1:23:35] The application went before the planning zoning commission on February 24th of this year,
[1:23:44] 2026 and they recommended approval as presented with the zoning designations. When we come before
[1:23:59] you for public hearing, we don't just look at the zoning designation, we look at a little bit more
[1:24:07] how utilities would generally look if it can be serviced by the utilities, if it can
[1:24:14] And if there's right-of-way designations that we need,
[1:24:18] it's looking more broadly.
[1:24:20] What do we need so we can make sure
[1:24:22] that the property can be adequately served
[1:24:25] and that we can plan ahead for the future?
[1:24:29] And so we recommended five conditions
[1:24:34] with this annexation.
[1:24:37] And those conditions are as follows.
[1:24:41] Sunway drive north, so right here,
[1:24:45] We would request that we get right of way dimensions as determined by the city engineer
[1:24:52] to be dedicated to the city prior to the signing of the annexation ordinance.
[1:24:58] The second condition would be that Cheney Drive West, which is this south property line,
[1:25:11] We would get the right-of-way dimensions as determined by the city engineer to be dedicated
[1:25:17] to the city prior to the signing of the annexation ordinance.
[1:25:21] And then for both of those roads that I've discussed for right-of-way, we would get those
[1:25:27] built at time of development.
[1:25:32] The final condition, number five, the city of Twin Falls will not take ownership or maintenance
[1:25:37] of the canal.
[1:25:40] This condition resembles very similarly what we did with the annexation just to the south.
[1:25:49] Those conditions are very similar to the whole process as we approved it.
[1:25:53] I'll have that annexation as well.
[1:25:56] With that I'll stand for any questions.
[1:25:58] Are there any questions for Will at this time?
[1:26:06] I don't see any.
[1:26:09] Will, thank you.
[1:26:10] Good evening there members of the council.
[1:26:19] My name is David Tebow with EHM engineers representing Mark McAllister and the McAllister
[1:26:23] family in their application for annexation this evening. I believe you came before you
[1:26:28] for the comprehensive plan update change and future land use map change to just
[1:26:35] the water and sewer service boundaries on several of these properties along the
[1:26:40] Sunway corridor and this evening we're here for the annexation. We'll did a great
[1:26:45] job kind of laying the background and kind of where our setting is. We're
[1:26:49] requesting the commercial zone along the pull line front edge which is
[1:26:51] consistent with your future land use map and then also because of where Chaney
[1:26:56] Drive intersects the property at the southeast corner with the future approved
[1:27:02] plans for the Osprey Point subdivision. All of the property being north of Chaney
[1:27:08] Drive's extension to the west is zoned commercial on the east side of 2700
[1:27:13] East Road and we'd like to match that commercial mapping. Part of that reason
[1:27:18] is because we can gravity sewer out that portion of the property, where the proposed
[1:27:23] TN1 zone that we've designated on this map that's before you on the screen cannot be gravity
[1:27:29] sewer out. It will require a separate sewage system, probably a lift station, hopefully
[1:27:34] in conjunction with neighboring properties to eject the sewer back out to Sunway and to
[1:27:39] the municipal collection system. So there is a method to the madness and a reason for
[1:27:43] that delineation. We also have irrigation laterals that kind of follow that same
[1:27:48] topography. Turns out in the early 1900s the farmers were also good at finding
[1:27:53] water levels and following the topography. So we we've reviewed the staff report. We
[1:27:59] don't necessarily have any objection to the conditions that were identified by
[1:28:02] Will. There is a sequencing issue in my mind. Item number one requires that we
[1:28:08] give you the right-of-way for Sunway Drive North. That would include the
[1:28:12] Canell and condition number five says the city will not take ownership or maintenance of the canal. I don't know how to prevent that
[1:28:19] I'm by giving you the right-away
[1:28:21] You're gonna own the ground but perhaps item five's condition should read that the the landowner and or subsequent developer
[1:28:29] Will be responsible for the relocation of the canal outside of the right-of-way that's gonna be dedicated
[1:28:34] That's pretty consistent with our developmental procedures working with your jurisdiction
[1:28:39] And I just think the wording is ambiguous and probably in conflict if examined more closely.
[1:28:45] With that, I stand for any questions that you might have.
[1:28:49] Any questions for Dave?
[1:28:50] I don't see any at this time, Dave.
[1:28:55] Thanks.
[1:28:59] They will.
[1:29:00] Do you have anything else before we open it up?
[1:29:05] No, not this time unless I know this time.
[1:29:09] Okay.
[1:29:10] Can we address the comment?
[1:29:12] Yeah.
[1:29:13] Yeah.
[1:29:14] By Dave.
[1:29:15] Just the wording on that before we jump into.
[1:29:16] Go ahead, Chris. Yeah.
[1:29:17] Just again, maybe adjusting five if what we open up the public hearing, if we could maybe
[1:29:24] rephrase that and come back with something that would not come in conflict.
[1:29:28] Yes, I will be, I will be script, script team.
[1:29:33] Okay, perfect.
[1:29:34] Thank you.
[1:29:35] Okay.
[1:29:38] We'll open it up for the general public input at this time again, please state your name
[1:29:47] and your address, present your comments.
[1:29:52] I'll have two minutes.
[1:29:56] Is there anyone that would like to provide public comment?
[1:30:02] Okay.
[1:30:03] Seeing none, we'll close the public comment period
[1:30:08] and does the applicant have any additional information?
[1:30:12] Dave?
[1:30:13] I think I have any additional.
[1:30:14] We'll get you some language on item five.
[1:30:16] I think it can be manipulated just with the language
[1:30:19] to be more appropriate.
[1:30:24] We already have, all right, we got this resemblance
[1:30:31] of a condition.
[1:30:32] So number five, rather than reading what it reads,
[1:30:37] we would change it to the canal to be relocated
[1:30:41] by the owner at the time of development, okay?
[1:30:47] I see Dave shaking his head, yes, but that works, okay.
[1:30:51] All right.
[1:30:52] Excellent, thank you.
[1:30:57] Okay, I think that's our time as a city council
[1:31:02] to discuss what we want to do with this particular item.
[1:31:09] Appreciate that input, Chris,
[1:31:10] because that was one of my questions, Ruth Pierce.
[1:31:15] Well, I'm comfortable with this annexation.
[1:31:18] Yeah, and given the five conditions,
[1:31:23] I think it makes sense to move this forward.
[1:31:25] Go ahead.
[1:31:25] Okay, I will make a motion to approve the annexation
[1:31:29] approximately 41 acres with a zoning designation of COM and TN1 for property
[1:31:36] located at 1651 Sunway Drive North with the five conditions listed in the report.
[1:31:43] Mayor, I'm ready. Just to clarify you mean the four conditions on the report
[1:31:50] with the amended condition number five? That'd be fine. Now relocated at the time
[1:31:57] of development. Yeah. Okay. We have a second on that. I'll second that.
[1:32:01] Okay. I have a motion and a second to approve the annexation of approximately 41 acres with
[1:32:09] a zoning destination of commercial and T-1 for the property located at 1651 Sunway Drive
[1:32:19] in care of EHM engineers on the behalf of Mark McAllister
[1:32:25] with the four conditions listed,
[1:32:27] the fifth one being Canal Relocation
[1:32:29] at the time of development.
[1:32:31] Is there any further discussion?
[1:32:34] Amy Roll call vote.
[1:32:37] Nathan Murray.
[1:32:38] Yes.
[1:32:39] Ruth Pierce.
[1:32:40] Chris Reed.
[1:32:41] Yes.
[1:32:42] Craig Hawkins.
[1:32:42] Jason Brown.
[1:32:43] Yes.
[1:32:44] And Sherry Bomer.
[1:32:45] Yes.
[1:32:46] Motion carries six to zero.
[1:32:48] Thank you, Will.
[1:32:49] Appreciate it.
[1:32:52] That brings us to our next item of business which is an executive session.
[1:33:00] The request to adjourn to executive session pursuant to Idaho Code 74-0274-2061C to acquire
[1:33:13] an interest in real property not owned by a public agency.
[1:33:17] Also, the communication with legal counsel for the public agency to discuss the legal ramifications
[1:33:25] of and legal options for pending litigation or controversies not yet being litigated but
[1:33:31] eminently likely to be litigated.
[1:33:33] The mere presence of legal counsel and an executive session does not satisfy this requirement.
[1:33:39] What are you?
[1:33:40] So moved.
[1:33:41] Second.
[1:33:42] I have a motion and a second to adjourn to executive session.
[1:33:46] the city council.
[1:33:47] We have a motion that carries
[1:33:48] 6 to 0.
[1:33:49] We will not be returning to city
[1:33:50] councils.
[1:33:51] That means our meeting is adjourned
[1:33:52] at this time.
[1:33:53] Thank you.
[1:33:54] Thank you.
