Oversight Archive: City Council meeting, 2013-12-23, recording 1 (started 17:00) Machine transcript (faster-whisper base.en), not checked word for word; the Pledge of Allegiance is shown in its standard wording. The recording is the record. Times are time into the recording. Passages with private details are muted in the audio and marked here. The audio on the page below was re-encoded by software from the video the agency posted. Check any passage against that audio before relying on it. Page: https://oversightarchive.org/twin-falls-id/meetings/2013-12-23/ [0:05:34] The first ever 23rd 2013 meeting door changed that as well and our first time of [0:05:43] business is the pledge. All those like the joins please rise. [0:05:50] I pledge allegiance to the Flag of the United States of America, and to the Republic for which it stands, one Nation under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all. [0:06:09] the firm that we do have a quorum. [0:06:12] All seven members are present. [0:06:14] Introduction of staff, [0:06:16] the limits of introduction of the C-men, [0:06:18] the Travis White Project, [0:06:19] city attorney Fritz Wennerlich, [0:06:21] deputy city clerk, [0:06:22] recording secretary, [0:06:23] Lea Sanchez, [0:06:27] Travis, do we have any amendments to the agenda? [0:06:30] Mr. Mayor, members of the council, [0:06:31] there are no amendments this evening. [0:06:33] Thank you. [0:06:35] We'll have no proclamation. [0:06:36] So moving on to the first item of business, [0:06:39] which is the consent calendar. [0:06:40] Council wishes. [0:06:43] Suzanne Hawkins. [0:06:44] Move approval. [0:06:46] Second. [0:06:47] Then moved by Suzanne Hawkins and seconded by John Berger [0:06:50] to approve the consent calendar. [0:06:53] Right back to my second. [0:06:54] Thank you, Mayor. [0:06:55] I just had one quick question on the consent calendar [0:06:58] and then comment on the minutes. [0:07:00] So would you like me to remove those or just ask? [0:07:03] I want to ask if let's go or ask your question. [0:07:07] OK. [0:07:08] I'll make it quick. [0:07:09] On page three of the minutes, it reflects our conversation that we had about bond hearings [0:07:15] and sentencing hearings. [0:07:16] And I know we were unsure of the county prosecutor's practices. [0:07:21] So I emailed Twin Falls County Prosecutor Grant Lopes, and I just wanted to share with the council [0:07:25] his response. [0:07:26] He clarified that, quote, my office policy, which upon checking I have found is being complied [0:07:32] with, is that every DUI, every crime of violence, and every crime with a victim requires that [0:07:37] that a prosecutor represent the state [0:07:40] before the judge during sentencing. [0:07:42] In addition, of course, we attend over every sentencing [0:07:46] in cases we amend from felonies. [0:07:48] There are also many other cases with special circumstances [0:07:50] which require our attendance. [0:07:52] In addition, it should be noticed that when victims [0:07:54] are involved, my victim coordinator also attends [0:07:57] these hearings to support the victim. [0:07:59] Failure to participate in these hearings, in my view, [0:08:02] denies victims in the public. [0:08:03] The advocacy of the only person in the system [0:08:06] charged to look out for their interests. [0:08:09] It may be that the judges often ignore our recommendations [0:08:12] if that is the case that follows with them. [0:08:14] It is our experience though that our input is valued [0:08:17] and frequently affects their decisions. [0:08:20] He said a similar issue with bond arguments [0:08:23] and so I kind of thought that was interesting [0:08:24] and maybe we can consider in the future [0:08:27] in terms of when there's a victim, [0:08:31] maybe supporting having some representation there [0:08:35] for crimes of victims. [0:08:38] Yeah, that's actually an email from Grant to me. [0:08:40] We created some emails. [0:08:43] We are attending all bond hearings, arrangements, [0:08:45] and sensing hearings. [0:08:48] OK, thank you, Rachel. [0:08:49] Thanks. [0:08:53] Did you have two games? [0:08:54] Yeah, and then a question on item three, [0:08:57] the agreement for Fillmore Street. [0:09:03] Yes, for Troy. [0:09:04] Thank you. [0:09:05] Great to take care of. [0:09:07] I'm on page two of the agreement in the maintenance area talks about the quality of the materials [0:09:16] that will be laid and I was just wondering how that will be inspected or how you will [0:09:21] ensure the quality of the road that's laid down. [0:09:24] Is the street department or the city engineer is going to be part of that process or how [0:09:28] will that work? [0:09:29] Yes. [0:09:30] When they actually did construct the road we were involved in it was always understood [0:09:34] that the city needed to be built to our standards. [0:09:37] And so our inspection department was involved in it. [0:09:41] They went out and did all the standard inspections [0:09:45] that we would do on any other residential street [0:09:47] that we would make days. [0:09:48] OK, and any work in the future, would that be similar? [0:09:53] It's still their responsibility, [0:09:54] but if in the future they defaulted or something, [0:09:57] we had to take it over. [0:09:57] We know it meets our standards. [0:09:59] OK, thank you. [0:10:02] Hey, so you know what the lights we have, [0:10:04] Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes [0:10:37] comment related to our city attorney's new role and pay schedule. [0:10:44] I just find going through the minutes that your accuracy is much more often right on than [0:10:51] interpretive and thank you for your confidence that you spend endless hours doing that. [0:10:56] You probably stay up every night doing that. [0:10:59] I'm sure the council feels that the same way that we take you for granted but thank you [0:11:03] so much for your competency. [0:11:06] Thank you, Chris, good point and a valid point [0:11:09] that I'm sure all of us do agree with. [0:11:11] Thank you, Chris. [0:11:12] Okay, moving on to item number one, [0:11:14] consideration of a request from Doris Rial [0:11:18] to purchase a portion of City-owned lot [0:11:21] located at 2617 Paint Fresh Drive. [0:11:25] And I believe that the applicants are the ones [0:11:29] that are gonna discuss this first. [0:11:36] Just as a correction, it's 2633 Paintbrush Drive. [0:11:39] Okay, all right, 2633, all right? [0:11:44] I'm just here to speak for her. [0:11:46] She's coming to live with us. [0:11:47] And so we had put her house on the market. [0:11:50] And we have a buyer, they are also here. [0:11:53] And what has happened is the buyers went down [0:11:56] to find out where the property lines ran [0:11:58] and found out that part of this property [0:12:00] was now on city property. [0:12:02] And we tried to give you guys a little bit of history [0:12:04] that in 1998, James Ray built the house [0:12:07] and his wife lived in the house from 98 to 2000 [0:12:11] when Mr. and Mrs. Ryle bought the home. [0:12:14] Dick Ryle is now deceased. [0:12:17] In 2003, the developers deeded over the water retention lot [0:12:22] next to their property. [0:12:24] And with that was the part of the land that was part of, [0:12:34] I don't know how to say it, [0:12:35] and I think showing you may be easier. [0:12:38] But basically what's happened is there is a cement. [0:12:42] This is all cement, it goes cement, it's a RV lock, [0:12:46] a shed, and the fence line runs right here. [0:12:49] And the engineers came out, she paid to have the engineers [0:12:52] do the property lines, because we could not find them. [0:12:54] And then we find out this is their property line, [0:12:57] and this seven feet is actually now on what is the city property [0:13:01] that was deeded over to the city property. [0:13:04] In the 15 years she's lived there, [0:13:05] this was never filled with water. [0:13:07] really it just, you can see kind of a water line of water. [0:13:10] There's more than half a space to allow for the water. [0:13:14] And I've contacted the title company in different places. [0:13:18] How this was never caught before now is kind of a mystery [0:13:21] to all of us. [0:13:22] When they bought the house, it was just as it is here [0:13:26] on the plot. [0:13:27] They made no corrections to this. [0:13:30] And so I guess the thing, I don't know what your position is. [0:13:36] We haven't been able to complete our sale. [0:13:38] We've built a new house for her to come live with us, and so we're kind of up in the air [0:13:42] until something's decided about this matter, whether it's through easement or purchase or [0:13:47] however we can resolve it. [0:13:48] We can't see ever getting past this matter until it's addressed. [0:13:53] Do you have something you want to know? [0:13:58] When we bought the house, we went through a title company store. [0:14:05] We assumed everything was as it should be, and we didn't realize that there was this discrepancy. [0:14:15] Okay. [0:14:16] Thank you. [0:14:17] Did you have anything else you wanted to add about this? [0:14:22] Two equates to about seven feet is when we've kind of determined, I think, I think seven feet. [0:14:27] That picture that's up there is a little off, it isn't quite accurate. [0:14:33] Right, well, it looks the same, but in other words, there's seven feet that you have built [0:14:41] on, put sprinklers in, have lawn, you, not you, but in the past, it has lawn fence, the [0:14:46] whole thing, but it ended up being that somebody found a wrong pin and they put, it ends up [0:14:52] being on this city, which is now city property that is a water retention area. [0:14:58] Right, and they had purchased the property prior to the land being deeded over to the [0:15:03] city is a water retention lot. They purchased in 2000 in 2003. This piece was [0:15:09] beaded to the city to be used as a park or a water retention lot. I guess it [0:15:15] cannot be built on. Right. You cannot be built on. I agree. Do we have city staff [0:15:20] want to talk about this a little? All right. Thank you. We'll probably have some [0:15:25] questions for you. If you go ahead and sit down, we'll have city staff talk to us [0:15:29] about it. [0:15:36] Mr. Mayor, Council members, all the information correct. [0:15:44] The dates were all correct. [0:15:45] This person, Mr. Rail actually purchased it in 2000. [0:15:48] Then the city then was due to us in 2003 from the homeowners association. [0:15:52] They also dated Lot 8, which is of the lot. [0:15:59] Similar situation may have occurred at that same location, whereas we, somebody built [0:16:04] on portions of our property prior to us actually owning them. [0:16:08] So those are the facts I wanted to get out first. [0:16:12] We were contacted by the realtor, [0:16:15] Stan Tobiasen, about the situation approximately a month ago. [0:16:20] The issue we have, and I'm just gonna read this [0:16:22] straight from the staff report, [0:16:24] first in order to sell this, the cities have to, [0:16:27] it's a very specific process to take [0:16:28] when selling public property. [0:16:30] First step is for the city council to adopt a resolution [0:16:33] to claim the property to be accessed to the city's needs, [0:16:36] and that they intend to dispose of the excess property, [0:16:38] That resolution sets a public hearing, a date for arguments against or for this. [0:16:45] And they also determine at that point whether or not to establish a minimum value of the [0:16:49] property. [0:16:50] And the property we're talking about is about seven feet, the run is north-south along the [0:16:53] east portion of our property, the west portion of the applicant's property. [0:16:59] Following that declaration, it requires a notice time that Council then holds a public hearing. [0:17:03] This hearing is for the input of the property's disposal. [0:17:06] the hearing the council can then direct staff to take steps to dispose of the property. In [0:17:11] the case where a property is proposed to be sold to a private entity, in this case it [0:17:15] is private, there would be a public auction. It would not be a direct seller, buyer seller [0:17:21] issue, we have to go to a public auction. It has to be noticed and then property for sales [0:17:26] providing instructions on bids when they're due, when they must be submitted and the bids [0:17:31] and bids will be opened and reviewed at that opening time. [0:17:36] I'm going through this specific process [0:17:38] due to Mitch not being here to explain it [0:17:40] in the better terms. [0:17:42] Upon closing of the auction period staff will open [0:17:44] and read the bids receiving in the public hearing [0:17:48] in the public meeting and declare the apparent high bidder. [0:17:51] That will then be submitted for award by the city council. [0:17:54] If no bids are received and the council can direct [0:17:56] that the city sell the property [0:17:57] via another non auction process. [0:17:59] Now here's the crux of it, this generally describes how to sell it, but if the person owning the [0:18:08] lot next to us is not the high bidder, in order to sell that property the city would have to [0:18:12] go through a split of the property which is a subdivision process. [0:18:16] And that can be accomplished if it's to them, to the property adjacent to a lot line adjustment, [0:18:23] if it's not, if it's to a third party, it would have to be through that subdivision process. [0:18:29] It's fairly simple to do the lot line adjustment, but the subdivision process is not. [0:18:34] Both of those lots would not be, the seven foot would not be a buildable lot. [0:18:39] Also we have some issues with who would sign and be responsible for the subdivision process [0:18:45] with hiring different engineering firms, different people to go through that surveying process. [0:18:50] So there's a hitch in that process there. [0:18:54] Travis, I think Travis wants to add something about the Travis. [0:18:58] The process that Jonathan outlined is not a process that was created by the City of Twin Falls. [0:19:04] It's a process that is created by the state code. [0:19:07] I think that's important to recognize that we don't have a way to work and [0:19:13] negotiate through a different process because the disposition of publicly owned property is carried out through a process in accordance with state code. [0:19:22] So if there was a desire and there was a more flexible way, we wish that we could follow [0:19:29] it, but unfortunately this is where we really have, we can't just sell it. [0:19:34] We can't just gift it. [0:19:38] It's our hands are tied. [0:19:41] Go ahead, Jonathan. [0:19:43] Chris, as well. [0:19:44] Well, Chris, do you need to weigh in on this? [0:19:46] Is there not any culpability in the part of the title company, for not to catch any of that? [0:19:50] The title companies don't do surveys, they just check the title. [0:19:53] So part that... [0:19:54] What's recorded then? [0:19:55] Yeah. [0:19:56] Yeah. [0:19:57] Okay. [0:19:58] I know the request is for the purchase of the seven foot strip and as you're hearing, [0:20:02] that's not a very good solution here. [0:20:05] Also I think you saw further in your report here that we don't know that we don't need [0:20:09] this in the future. [0:20:10] I think the better solution here is temporary encroachment, easement to allow those improvements [0:20:18] to stay there as they are and tell such time as we know that we need to expand that retention [0:20:23] basin. [0:20:26] Say that again. [0:20:29] So we would grant a temporary, maybe a semi-permanent encroachment easement to allow them to encroach [0:20:37] on to the publicly owned property for such period of time until we know that we need [0:20:42] to expand that retention basin. [0:20:46] Without compensation to the city, doesn't it? [0:20:48] We don't have all the problems with granting an easement that we do with the transfer property. [0:20:57] And that would mean circumventing the hearing process. [0:21:02] Yeah, as you're hearing here, this is potentially this can create a problem for them. [0:21:10] If someone wants to come in and purchase this out from under her, she still has probably a worse problem than she has now. [0:21:21] Yes, my Jim. Okay. Thank you mayor. So it's a worst problem if we just do a long-term encroachment [0:21:27] If we did it. Yeah, temporary encroachment [0:21:30] Isn't allowed to allow those improvements to stay there for so long as we don't need to expand that how would that I guess [0:21:37] And then the question the second question is how would that affect the purchase of sale the property right now? [0:21:42] Well, I don't know I didn't know I did what I did the sale I did receive a call today from the real estate agent [0:21:51] Yeah, and his brokers here, so yeah, and and he asked about the alternative of an easement instead [0:21:58] So I assume it that works for them [0:22:01] We definitely like something that we got one as well [0:22:06] So right now the the fence the [0:22:10] Outbuilding sprinkler system landscaping is on our property. Yes [0:22:17] And concrete from the thank you from the RV pad [0:22:24] I guess I'm gonna have more, I'd like to figure out [0:22:27] how we can fix this because this is, [0:22:32] this is really inconvenient for these folks. [0:22:36] And then I wanna know how it happened, [0:22:38] and is do we have others around town [0:22:41] that are gonna creep up and do this? [0:22:44] That's what I'm more concerned with. [0:22:46] Need to get this fixed, and then let's figure out [0:22:48] if we have other issues. [0:22:50] Turn any other questions in the connection. [0:22:51] Well, we have come a little. [0:22:53] Can I talk to them a little bit? [0:22:54] I think, you know, I'm not sure how back when, [0:22:59] but we have a small amount of culpability ourselves [0:23:02] that when we had people go out and check the foundation, [0:23:05] I don't think that we found the right things either. [0:23:08] Our building department. [0:23:12] Well, but I mean, we still approve the building [0:23:15] of that house. [0:23:17] It's the building with the setback. [0:23:19] Yeah. [0:23:20] Yeah, the answer to that question, Mayor, would be [0:23:21] that the building does meet the setbacks [0:23:23] with the property pins in the correct spot. [0:23:25] I believe it's zoned our two. [0:23:27] I don't think it's in the report. [0:23:28] So in other words, even with finding the wrong pins, [0:23:34] the correct pins are the house is still seven. [0:23:36] Correct. [0:23:36] Okay. [0:23:37] We believe the house is built correctly. [0:23:38] We don't require building permit for concrete, [0:23:41] potentially outbuildings under 120 square feet. [0:23:43] We don't have building permits, nor do we check [0:23:45] a site pine for those either. [0:23:47] Okay, all right. [0:23:48] We're back this way. [0:23:49] Thank you, Mayor. [0:23:50] My question is similar to Councilman Hals. [0:23:53] So if that's the property line, how can that house be a certain setback from the property line? [0:23:59] The property line shown in that map is taken from our GIS system, which is not survey grade. [0:24:04] The survey grade map might want to reference the map they provided with that engineer assessment [0:24:10] down here with the survey, which is- [0:24:13] And what is the setback on that side of house? [0:24:15] I believe the setback is seven feet if it's an R2 zone, which I'm pretty sure it is. [0:24:19] And it shows that it meets the seven feet on the survey grade. [0:24:23] Okay, that's good. [0:24:24] So are these improvements that are built into the city property? [0:24:29] Are those inspected any time? [0:24:32] Concrete is not inspected and either is an out building or an accessory building or [0:24:36] fast. [0:24:36] I don't show any record of us having a building permit for that small building. [0:24:42] Okay, yeah, that's my question and maybe just thinking about the future, [0:24:46] thinking about other possible properties because we have seen this before in the [0:24:50] the area of impact where things weren't built, where they were supposed to be built. [0:24:56] Maybe in the future, we can talk about maybe how to prevent that. [0:25:00] And we have a lot of properties, probably more than we know that this has occurred. [0:25:05] One at the end of the block, which we suspect, we haven't inspected it and Mitch and I have looked at it. [0:25:11] That's a possibility, it's a lot eight. [0:25:13] I showed the plat just a minute ago, that's another location. [0:25:17] also a retention base and next to it. [0:25:20] There's also other retention bases that we have taken ownership of due to our storm [0:25:24] water requirements and Troy can talk about some of those storm water requirements and [0:25:29] what we may be facing in the future with our population growth. [0:25:33] The last thing that I had was a blurb from the City Engineer which was do the future need [0:25:41] for expanding retention capacity and the President that may be sent by approving this request [0:25:45] staff is not supportive of the request. [0:25:47] However, there has not been and still is not an immediate need [0:25:50] to reclaim the property where the applicant's [0:25:52] fence and concrete pad are located. [0:25:54] Staff does support allowing the fence and concrete pad [0:25:57] to remain in place until such time as retention [0:25:59] pond is expanded. [0:26:01] Troy can talk about the storm water requirements [0:26:04] that we may be facing in the future. [0:26:07] I have Travis's next. [0:26:09] It looks like to me, and there's a scary part about this. [0:26:12] It looks like the lot to the north [0:26:14] maybe doing the same thing. [0:26:16] Well, so it's important to recognize that when you take a look at the aerial photography [0:26:21] that's taken at a certain angle and that the shadows and the curvature of the earth and [0:26:27] other aspects don't necessarily make that look like it's seven feet because if we're [0:26:32] to look at it from a scale perspective you're saying, and I think it's easy to see, well [0:26:36] you probably missed the setback requirements on this and how did it make it. [0:26:41] When you orthally rectify the map, which is making sure you take into account the circumference [0:26:48] of the earth, this all falls into place. [0:26:51] I think it's important to recognize that there's a level of homeowner responsibility. [0:26:55] When you put in, we don't go out and we don't mark property pins when someone plants a tree. [0:27:01] When someone builds a fence, when someone installs a sprinkler system, we don't have the tools [0:27:05] or the resources for that. [0:27:06] So, once we go ahead and we ensure that the building has been placed into the right area in accordance with the setbacks, [0:27:15] really that's where our level of authority ends. [0:27:20] And the level of authority of what that looks like becomes between two property owners if they encroach on the other place. [0:27:27] And I, you know, this is, you know, we got a lot of people out there. [0:27:33] I know that one neighborhood in North end of town that the, the, the builder, [0:27:38] the developer, the developer puts in the fences and there was one over there. [0:27:42] I noticed they actually moved the fence 20 feet when the people got in there. [0:27:47] We're looking at it. [0:27:49] The back end of it, it's kind of like a pie shaped type thing. [0:27:51] The back end kept moved 20 feet whenever they got started to put the house in there. [0:27:55] So this is a bigger issue than I might realize. [0:27:58] Don Hall. [0:27:59] So I think, I agree with you, Travis, that, you know, it's the homeowner, but these folks, [0:28:05] it sounds like these folks bought it from someone else that had done the improvement. [0:28:09] Yeah. [0:28:10] So I think we're kind of caught behind, you know, this is a tough one because I like what [0:28:19] Fritz is saying, but that doesn't really give a lot of closure to whoever's going to [0:28:23] buy the house. [0:28:24] And I can see the danger of doing the resolution and going through the whole process. [0:28:31] I can't imagine somebody wanting to buy a seven foot strip of land, but maybe there is someone that will. [0:28:36] That doesn't give them a whole lot of assurance either. This is a tough one. [0:28:40] What was the timing be if we did go with the whole purchase? [0:28:46] How much time were we talking? It sounded like a lot of time to me. [0:28:51] There's a lot of public meetings and public hearings, so that's going to take your normal noticing of five weeks. [0:28:58] each one of those you can do concurrently. [0:29:01] I don't have the exact timeline, [0:29:03] given the holidays it'd take my best guess, [0:29:06] two, three months for everything to be done [0:29:09] and cut and dry, it could be faster than that. [0:29:14] I'm gonna call it Mr. Hesse, if you don't mind, [0:29:16] if you don't see the broker, I'm not sure for who. [0:29:20] Okay, all right. [0:29:22] And if we do go with the temporary dissolution, [0:29:27] is that gonna wipe out the sale, [0:29:28] or I want to help these people. [0:29:30] I already spoke to the buyers, and they're not [0:29:33] satisfied with the temporary easement. [0:29:35] They'd like a permanent easement. [0:29:36] That's what I was concerned with. [0:29:38] They feel comfortable. [0:29:42] OK, I get it. [0:29:43] I understand. [0:29:44] Well, I would be the same way. [0:29:46] OK? [0:29:47] So I just want to remind everybody [0:29:51] that when the city got heated this lot, [0:29:55] no one from the city went out and said, [0:29:58] I don't know what the measurement on lot one was, [0:30:00] but obviously it was seven feet short too. [0:30:04] So it's hard to pick up seven feet [0:30:07] when you're just looking at a lot, [0:30:09] to know if it's an 85 foot lot or a 92 foot lot. [0:30:15] People live there for that many years [0:30:17] and they never recognized it. [0:30:21] And the city has owned this for how many years in them. [0:30:23] And the city hasn't recognized it either. [0:30:25] So whatever resolution we could make [0:30:28] will be very appreciated. [0:30:31] Travis and then Jim I yield to the city manager. I was gonna answer questions. I'm sorry. I [0:30:38] Thought there was a question for me [0:30:43] Mr. Mayor you called my name and so I was I [0:30:47] Was ready to respond [0:30:50] Not this time [0:30:53] One question for Fritz what about abandonment [0:30:56] In other words, you know, I'm trying to compare and contrast this to other things I see in the past [0:31:01] If the city didn't claim this property, isn't there some area of the law where if somebody [0:31:07] abandoned its property, who doesn't care for or has no interest in it, if it was private [0:31:12] property on both sides after five years there would be adverse possession by the property on the right. [0:31:16] Adverse possession, so we don't have that solution, do we? [0:31:20] How does this compare and contrast to the Lance LeBaron debacle out of Wild Rose? [0:31:27] It doesn't because it involves the right-of-way which could be vacated. [0:31:34] So we can't give it to them. [0:31:38] We can't. [0:31:39] It's not abandoned. [0:31:42] So there are two pet-feed solutions. [0:31:45] If you, depending on whether you want to grant a permanent encroachment, easement, or a temporary [0:31:52] one, it has tells me a permanent one is what they would prefer. [0:31:56] they prefer that over the going through the process of transferring ownership to the land [0:32:04] talk to a temporary encroachment or a permanent encroachment. [0:32:07] What's the permanent? [0:32:08] Yeah. [0:32:09] The engineer's office is asking for a temporary one and the owner or the representative is [0:32:16] asking for a permanent one. [0:32:17] Can you tell us about the permanent one? [0:32:20] So when we grant an easement, we're not constrained like we are on the transfer of [0:32:25] ownership properly and other place is okay if I speak [0:32:29] so I turn it off. Rebecca we have to you. Is that fine? [0:32:33] Please. Thank you. So with the permanent it would be a [0:32:37] document we would file with with the be recorded and so forth. It [0:32:42] gives them permanent. Yes. Possession of that property right [0:32:46] now. Okay. But the engineering department doesn't like [0:32:49] that because someday that seven feet may become somewhat [0:32:53] operational in the in the world of water runoff. I want to hear the argument there. [0:32:59] So when talking with the and talking with the city engineer her her concerns here is [0:33:06] we're going to have a stormwater requirement come up here pretty soon as soon as we have 50,000 people. [0:33:10] We haven't seen that we don't know what that even looks like if we're having to do two times two and [0:33:14] a half times the water retention and we have facilities like this that are in place that were [0:33:20] built when they built the subdivision and made our current requirements but we don't know what the [0:33:24] the future requirements will be her concern as if we give this away at some future time [0:33:29] we probably possibly might have wished. [0:33:32] What would be a scenario in the future where this retention area would have to be modified [0:33:37] in some way to meet the future regulations? [0:33:42] What would be a scenario? [0:33:43] They can say no runoff. [0:33:45] Right now we allow runoff to dishes, historic. [0:33:48] And then how would that affect this? [0:33:50] It'd be about two and a half times bigger. [0:33:52] but what would you do it? [0:33:55] Go down or how? [0:33:56] That's okay, I get your argument, but I'm not convinced. [0:34:05] We're back in my selection then, Travis, okay? [0:34:08] Thank you, Mayor. [0:34:09] I just want to agree with the council that I think a permanent fix would be preferable. [0:34:16] You know, and it looks like from the staff report that that would be, you know, declaring [0:34:21] to access property and going through the auction, even though there's a slight chance that someone [0:34:27] else might purchase the property. But in the event that someone doesn't, it would probably [0:34:32] be an easy and simple fix. So I would just voice support for that option. [0:34:38] Well, you can expand on that quickly. And I got Travis. The concern, the thought process [0:34:46] is about talking about you on the permanent, Jim. It's that we are going to go through [0:34:51] through the whole process of selling, we'd have to say it was no more useful and I don't [0:34:57] see the engineering department agreeing with us on that either. [0:35:00] They're never going to let us get that far so we're either going to do it, to me I think [0:35:04] we have permanent traffic so I'm sorry. [0:35:07] The problem is we don't know and internally we had several conversations about this and [0:35:12] I wouldn't describe staff as being unified in a recommendation by any stretch because [0:35:18] I mean, we've talked about this extensively about what is the legal thing to do, what [0:35:25] are those processes look like, and what is the right thing to do. [0:35:32] And from the engineering's perspective, I think that we recognize that we don't know [0:35:36] what these stormwater requirements are, and they don't want to come back to you and say, [0:35:41] you know, we recommended selling that seven feet, and in truth, we need that now. [0:35:47] So they're kind of betting against not a certain level [0:35:51] of uncertainty. [0:35:54] One of the suggestions, or one of the solutions, [0:35:56] might be a combination of the two approaches, [0:36:00] where you put in a permanent easement [0:36:05] with the purposes of then going through the transfer [0:36:10] of the property. [0:36:12] The truth of the matter is, is in defense of Troy [0:36:15] and the engineering department. [0:36:16] We can't answer the question. [0:36:19] We can't answer the question right now [0:36:21] if it is indeed surplus or not. [0:36:24] And so we tend to staff to be a bit more conservative [0:36:27] and say since we can't answer definitively [0:36:30] that it is surplus, we're going to say that it's not. [0:36:34] I am not an engineer and I look at that seven feet [0:36:37] and if Troy's talking about an additional two and a half times, [0:36:41] I don't think that seven feet personally [0:36:43] is going to make a significant difference [0:36:46] and how deep that hole has to be, [0:36:49] or the other opportunities that we have to move forward with. [0:36:53] So it's not very often that you'll see the staff [0:36:55] kind of offer contrary opinions, [0:36:57] and we, this is a hard one, [0:36:59] because you want to be sympathetic to the property owner, [0:37:02] and you also want to recognize that the rules [0:37:06] and regulations that are going to impact us on stormwater [0:37:09] are very unknown and very uncertain at this time. [0:37:14] Okay, Mr. Hass, I don't, I, [0:37:17] Walt, could I call upon you again? [0:37:19] Sure. [0:37:20] I noticed that the prospective buyers came up and talked to you. [0:37:23] Do you think they would be satisfied [0:37:25] with a permanent encroachment? [0:37:28] Permanent easement? [0:37:29] Right, a pre-man easement. [0:37:30] Yeah, well, it's actually called encroachment. [0:37:32] In other words, we couldn't come take it away from them [0:37:35] unless we, easily, anyway. [0:37:38] Is that something they would be, [0:37:40] I know they want to say it. [0:37:41] I don't represent them. [0:37:42] I think they just want something hot. [0:37:50] He needs to come on. [0:37:59] Sir, I think we need you to come up. [0:38:05] This is all being recorded, so if you wouldn't mind, please. [0:38:10] And identify yourself, you could, please. [0:38:12] My name is Gene Bright, and I'm the respective buyer of this piece of property. [0:38:16] And actually, what has happened, you get a little bit more background, [0:38:21] is I was interested in putting a storage building out on the property itself. [0:38:24] So I went down to planning and zoning office just to find out what the requirements were [0:38:31] for setbacks and that sort of thing, regardless of construction of it. [0:38:34] And while we were in that office, they put this picture up on the computer screen and [0:38:39] then they overlaid the marks that you see and said, wow, looks like we have a problem here [0:38:45] because the property lines aren't what you think they are. [0:38:50] So contacting realtors and surveys being done is how we discover that there is a 7 foot variance [0:38:57] there. [0:38:58] Now myself as a perspective buyer, if this can't be resolved so that we can have that 7 feet, [0:39:05] this property is of no use to me because I want a place I can park in RV, which this [0:39:11] place provides with that 7 feet that's there. [0:39:15] So, you're asking me a question now about technicalities and legalese that I'm not totally [0:39:22] comfortable giving you an answer right this second as to whether that's acceptable to [0:39:27] me or not being a long-term property owner and how that might, if any way, shape or form [0:39:33] apply to my being able to sell the property down the road five or ten years from now. [0:39:38] So, those are my concerns at this point. [0:39:41] If I used to say that if this doesn't get adjusted, [0:39:44] then this sale does not going to conclude with us. [0:39:47] Right. [0:39:48] I understand that. [0:39:49] I think Fritz is poised to come up and speak [0:39:51] a little bit from the city's behalf. [0:39:53] Thank you. [0:39:54] And I'm not going to give him legal advice. [0:39:56] I just want to point out to the council [0:39:58] that if the council authorized a permanent encroachment [0:40:02] easement, it would specifically call out [0:40:04] that it would allow landscaping, fence, driveway, [0:40:10] and storage building to encroach on to the permanently encroach on to the whatever lot [0:40:18] number that is. [0:40:19] Okay. [0:40:20] All right. [0:40:22] So it would be a permanent. [0:40:23] Yeah. [0:40:24] So it would specifically call out. [0:40:25] It wouldn't grant any further. [0:40:27] That's something he would want to check with his real turn. [0:40:30] Right. [0:40:31] I'm sure before he would continue. [0:40:32] Jim. [0:40:33] Well, I was just thinking here. [0:40:34] The resolution idea where we go down the selling the seven foot track and go through those [0:40:40] the public hearings, the end game is the same because the engineering department is not going [0:40:46] to support it and say that they're in the future, that piece of property could end up [0:40:49] being encroached upon, correct? [0:40:52] So the only solution is that this permanent easement encroachment. [0:40:57] If we don't do that, she's never going to be able to sell her property. [0:41:02] She's there forever. [0:41:04] That's the end game here. [0:41:05] So I think we do have an obligation to try to help her. [0:41:09] So what's your idea, Jim, to proceed with the permanent encroachment and go through the financial, [0:41:17] excuse me, the P&Z process for the financial selling of the public property? [0:41:24] No, I do not believe, I think that if possible legally is to grant a permanent easement encroachment [0:41:32] right now and that is we can authorize that as we sit correct [0:41:38] you could authorize it we bring it back to you because you obviously don't have [0:41:41] it in front of you right now [0:41:42] so moved [0:41:45] second to get on the floor [0:41:46] been moved by jim and samer Chris talking that we grant a permanent [0:41:51] easement encroachment [0:41:53] on the property at [0:41:55] twenty six thirty three paint bus drive and we do have a couple of lights [0:41:58] don't hold [0:41:59] you know the only challenge i have with the motion is i want resolution [0:42:04] as soon as possible as well, but I don't know what ramifications this president might be [0:42:09] setting us up for in the future. There could be 40 other properties that this similarly [0:42:15] has taken place, even more a larger piece of city property. So I'm struggling a little [0:42:23] bit with giving it to them rather than having to go through the public process of selling [0:42:30] it. [0:42:32] Sure. [0:42:33] And if we grant this encroachment easement, it's still our property, right? [0:42:40] It's not theirs. [0:42:42] So it's not assessed as part of their taxes, the improvements on our and assessed as part [0:42:48] of their taxes. [0:42:49] It's still city owned with their stuff on it. [0:42:53] I have to talk to the assessor's office about that. [0:43:02] When there's a permanent ownership like that, they might treat it as own property. [0:43:06] I'm not sure. [0:43:09] I'm sure they are right now. [0:43:12] Right now, as far as the assessor's office knows, [0:43:15] they don't have any of their landscaping on that 7 feet. [0:43:18] So I'm sure it's being treated that way right now. [0:43:21] I think maybe to the point of what the engineering department [0:43:27] is struggling with, some of this we don't know. [0:43:30] I agree with Don. [0:43:33] I think I would like to have some level of comfort [0:43:35] of how many other places in town we might have this [0:43:37] before we set a precedent of how we're going to do that. [0:43:43] Again, I agree we need to help these folks out. [0:43:46] I think we need to also recognize [0:43:47] that we may have others in town [0:43:49] and we just need to make sure we do it the right way [0:43:52] the first time or we're going to do it 40 different ways. [0:43:57] Thank you, Mayor. [0:44:01] Yeah, I'm struggling with supporting the permanent easement [0:44:04] because it doesn't quite seem like a permanent fix, [0:44:08] especially as Council Member Berger brings up the issue [0:44:10] taxes and assessments. For me, I think the more or the better solution might be to declare [0:44:19] it as excess property and go through the auction process. With the information that we have [0:44:25] tonight, I think that's what I would support. But I also would like to have more information [0:44:30] about other possible properties. But I have no idea how much time that would take or when [0:44:35] that would be available and so it really doesn't sound like that's a very helpful solution to the applicant situation. [0:44:44] So, but I probably won't support the motion but it's only because I'm in support of more permanent, you know, probably the auction process. [0:44:54] I have my own initials down next. [0:45:00] I grew a gym in the fact that even if we do go that the entire direction, I think Travis [0:45:07] is saying we grant this now and then we go down that steps is what he is suggesting. [0:45:14] I don't see the engineering department ever saying to us that we can grant this as excess. [0:45:20] I think they're going to have the same position they do on this. [0:45:23] They're going to say it's not excess property. [0:45:25] I'm not sure of that. [0:45:26] As far as the precedents, and I realize [0:45:30] that there is a possibility of precedents, [0:45:32] but it will have to be a precedence for encroaching [0:45:38] upon city property, not encroaching [0:45:41] upon other private property, because that's [0:45:44] a whole different scenario. [0:45:45] This would be, if there is a thing, [0:45:47] it would be encroaching upon city property, not private property. [0:45:51] So I think that narrows the scope of problems [0:45:56] I will be supporting the motion. [0:45:59] I'll support the motion, too. [0:46:00] I think Jim recognizes, or I guess I'm saying that Mr. [0:46:05] Mrs. Ryle brought this property. [0:46:07] To some extent, they were unknowledgeable through no fault [0:46:13] of their own. [0:46:13] They depend on the title company. [0:46:15] They've acquired an existing condition. [0:46:17] Here, we're able to give them the ability [0:46:19] to execute their sale, close the sale. [0:46:22] and for the property acquires to have permanent use [0:46:26] of the facility as exactly as the outline. [0:46:29] If we do this, it's better to get this cleared [0:46:32] out of the way in my understanding, [0:46:34] and then Sean, if you want us to go [0:46:36] on a city-wide search for these, [0:46:38] I don't know how long that would take to do, [0:46:40] but I bet we'll find a number of them. [0:46:43] I don't know, adjacent to city property [0:46:45] or encouragement on private, [0:46:47] but here's a short-term solution on the one property [0:46:51] that affects the one transaction, and guarantees the new [0:46:57] acquirers that are a comfort of mind and know that it can't and [0:47:00] won't be taken care of. If we get a new permit system that [0:47:05] requires us to provide larger drainage basins, believe me, [0:47:10] this will be only one of many big problems. [0:47:16] Okay, see, no. So maybe Travis, can you re clarify what you were [0:47:24] talking about a potentially a two-step process here. [0:47:30] So the two-step process, I think, [0:47:32] provides a bit of a safeguard. [0:47:34] So the first safeguard is you're going [0:47:36] to grant a permanent vehicle that [0:47:41] allows the property to remain maybe as it is right now. [0:47:46] And it can't be changed. [0:47:47] It can't be modified and it's attached to the property. [0:47:51] So like Fritz says, it's going to be one of those things [0:47:54] that it can be for landscaping and it can be for a carport or for an RV parking spot, [0:48:02] so on and so forth. [0:48:06] And then that's kind of like an immediate fix to it. [0:48:11] And then what you're possibly allowed to do then is to move forward and say that we're [0:48:16] going to sell it. [0:48:17] And since it's already attached to the property, we are probably going to possibly lessen the [0:48:24] number of individuals that may be interested in acquiring the property, because it's already [0:48:31] attached. [0:48:33] And I would hope, in all honesty, there's not a lot of people that would go out in bid [0:48:38] on a seven foot strip next to someone's house because it's not a buildable lot. [0:48:43] So that would be, you know, hopefully that challenge doesn't really exist in what we're [0:48:51] looking at. [0:48:52] I don't think it is either. [0:48:53] Well this is kind of an interesting law. [0:48:56] That's the first step of the conveyance of property. [0:49:00] I know we call it excess property but it's property that's underutilized or which is [0:49:05] not used for public purposes. [0:49:07] What Travis is saying is if you grant a permanent encroachment easement to the adjoining property [0:49:15] owner you won't be able to use it anymore and it'll have no value so it's easy to go [0:49:21] through the second step to justify why you don't need it. Point of order. Can I [0:49:27] modify my amendment to include that second track that second process to run I [0:49:38] guess concurrently or after the permanent easement? [0:49:43] You close with the approval of your second. [0:49:46] Let me be sure what your amendment to your motion. [0:49:48] So the first of all, the first motion [0:49:52] is to grant a permanent encroachment easement [0:49:54] to that seven foot property to the homeowner. [0:50:00] The second part of the amendment, the modification [0:50:02] of the amendment would be to have the city proceed [0:50:06] with the disposal of that piece of property [0:50:12] in accordance with Idaho Code, what is it, [0:50:19] in accordance with Idaho Code Title 50, Section 1402? [0:50:24] Second death. [0:50:27] Day to motion has been changed to say [0:50:30] that we are going to grant a permanent encroachment easement [0:50:34] on the property, so in other words, [0:50:36] that they would be able to utilize that property [0:50:41] as if they were their own. [0:50:43] And the second part would mean that the city [0:50:44] would begin the process of, for the one of a better word, [0:50:50] abandoning that property and allowing it for purchase by the. [0:50:56] Yeah, you'd adopt a resolute, the way we always do this, [0:50:59] you adopt a resolution declaring the intent to dispose [0:51:01] of the property. [0:51:02] Right, OK. [0:51:03] So it's kind of a double, it gives them a double protection. [0:51:08] All right, Rebecca, it looks like. [0:51:12] With the amendment, that does change my support of the motion. [0:51:14] Yeah, I agree as well worst case scenario. Somebody comes in and bids high for that seven. I mean that [0:51:23] that could happen, right? [0:51:27] It could happen, but it's subject to an easement owned by the joining property owner to use it for landscaping [0:51:34] Fencing driveways, so it's so there's no value. It's worth it. Okay. Okay. All right [0:51:40] All right, so you know like the other roll call vote. Yes [0:51:48] Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes [0:52:21] areas that are city owned to see how difficult it might be to assess if we have other situations [0:52:27] like this around him. [0:52:29] So we're confident that we do have other situations like this. [0:52:34] In fact it's probably not just around retention areas but it may be around trail systems anywhere [0:52:40] that we have property where individuals have built onto our property. [0:52:52] And one of the questions you made ask is how do you prevent that? [0:52:55] You know, it's tough. [0:52:57] It really is tough because there's no inspection, building, [0:53:01] plant, or process that we have. [0:53:03] But we can certainly look. [0:53:05] We would ask for some time. [0:53:07] Because with it. [0:53:08] I guess my only concern is I don't want now, every time [0:53:11] somebody's trying to sell their house and it's oops, [0:53:14] I accidentally built on your property [0:53:18] that it becomes our problem to fix. [0:53:21] And I think that obviously the staff sentiment and opinion is going to be very, very different. [0:53:28] So had the current property owner, maybe last fall, built a fence and built a series of trees [0:53:36] and calls the groups, then I think that the council has the right to say no, clearly you [0:53:45] erred and you can cause a different course of action. [0:53:49] I believe that cases of precedent are important, but I also believe that the council needs to retain the right to look at things on a case-by-case basis because not all circumstances are going to remain the same. [0:53:59] You want to be consistent, but this case is clearly very different than I had the current property owner gone out and constructed the fence to be by herself. [0:54:09] Right, and I agree with that. [0:54:11] Thank you. [0:54:13] Well, it may not. Can we, Fritz, can we assure Mrs. Ryle that her sale can proceed? Does it [0:54:20] require some publishing or some follow up this going in? We can get the easement done for the [0:54:27] mayor to execute right away, but it's going to be up to the buyer to determine whether they [0:54:31] want to go ahead and close on that. Okay. All right. Item number two, consideration of [0:54:41] request initiation special use permit application for a new tourist information [0:54:48] center to be located on property city leases from the Idaho transportation [0:54:53] department and operated by the member commerce and I want to assume mr. I'm [0:54:58] gonna step down if I may be part of this presentation thank you that's nice [0:55:02] There [0:55:09] Jonathan [0:55:10] And me again [0:55:14] All right now this is a request a consideration to initiate a specialist permit application for a new tourist information center [0:55:21] To be located on property the city leases from the Idaho Transportation Department and operated by the Chamber of Commerce [0:55:27] Background we have leased about three acres of land or Baynosewood's first information center is up there by the prime bridge right? [0:55:34] It's about three acres. [0:55:36] Currently, the chamber runs the tourist information booth. [0:55:40] We have a bathroom located on that. [0:55:42] We are the people that lease the land. [0:55:44] The city leases the land from ITD in order for the city [0:55:50] to have this tourist information thing be built. [0:55:53] The chamber is the ones that are going to build it. [0:55:56] However, if three entities need to come together and agree [0:55:59] on who's going to actually submit the application [0:56:01] for a special use permit. [0:56:03] Our city code requires that the lessee or the owner be the ones on that application. [0:56:08] City being lessee, ITD being the owner, ITD is basically said they don't want to be on that [0:56:14] application necessarily as the applicant. [0:56:17] The city can do that. [0:56:19] The Chamber of Commerce cannot be on the application as the applicant because they are not the lessee [0:56:23] or the owner. [0:56:25] The property, the reason why it needs to be a special use permit, it's in the open spaces [0:56:29] that requires a special use permit to run a tourist information center. [0:56:34] It's permitted, but with a special use permit, so we'll go through the public hearing process. [0:56:38] It's also going to be expanded by more than 25%, which also requires it to come through. [0:56:43] There is a special use permit on it now, but since it's going to be expanded by more than 25%, [0:56:49] honestly, I don't know how big it's actually going to be, Sean, maybe able to answer how big it's going to be, [0:56:53] but it's going to be increased by more than 25%, city code requires them to get a new special use permit. [0:56:58] it. That permit will then run with the land. There's been some discussion about who is going [0:57:04] to be the lessee in the future. Everybody, all three parties, the chamber, the city and [0:57:09] I.T.D. believes that the city should be not the middleman anymore and that the chamber [0:57:15] of commerce will then become the lessee and they'll go into negotiations between I.T.D. [0:57:19] and the chamber to become lessee and owner respectively and the city will no longer be [0:57:25] involved in it at this time though for them to build it we need to submit it as a city [0:57:30] and that's why we're here. I think I've covered most of those things and Sean's [0:57:35] going to cover some of those other ones. Chamber has submitted a letter they'll [0:57:44] take care of the application details like providing the necessary site plan [0:57:47] and company documents mailing notification letters to adjacent property [0:57:50] owners also presenting the application to the planning and zoning commission. The [0:57:55] The second part of the Chamber's request is to, upon successful completion of the special [0:58:00] use permit process, they would like the city to terminate our lease with the subject [0:58:04] property with IPD so that they can then enter into their own lease. [0:58:08] Staff has reviewed the request and supports this change to the land lease, however the [0:58:12] city did not, did lease the property for a purpose other than the visitor center. [0:58:16] That being the Canyon Rim Trail Overlook and Trailhead Park. [0:58:20] Before the city terminates at least, we should enter into an agreement with the Chamber [0:58:23] regarding the continued maintenance and public use of the trail and trailhead facilities. [0:58:28] Those facilities are important to the city and the chamber and we are optimistic that [0:58:32] we'll be able to finalize such an agreement without concern. [0:58:36] Simple majority vote of the council. [0:58:38] In conclusion, staff recommends that the council approve the request from the Chamber of Commerce [0:58:41] and authorize the special use permit application for a new tourist information center. [0:58:47] Thank you, John. [0:58:49] Mr. President, CEO, Berger. [0:58:53] We'll put the other head on for you. [0:58:55] Thank you very much. [0:58:57] So I think that's, I think everyone understands the process here. [0:59:01] Just to explain a couple of things. [0:59:03] So one, the chamber has not determined specific details of moving forward with this project. [0:59:10] In the nine years I've been at the chamber, we have had visions and thoughts of a new facility. [0:59:18] And I think we are at a point where we have a more realistic opportunity to move forward [0:59:23] at that. [0:59:24] It still requires a significant capital funding campaign and finalizing design, but in order [0:59:32] to get the steps moving in the right process, the special use permit is something that could [0:59:40] move forward even if we weren't to finish the bill to pull the trigger on the building. [0:59:45] Our concern is moving forward with changing the lease with the state, and then not being [0:59:51] able to build a facility there because then it puts the responsibility of maintenance of [0:59:54] that entire area on the chamber at a somewhat higher cost than what the city is paying that [1:00:01] lease to ITD right now. [1:00:03] I have received a draft lease from the transportation department. [1:00:08] As Jonathan mentioned, I think all the parties are willing to move forward. [1:00:11] There are some specific conditions that outline maintaining public access to the pedestrian [1:00:17] and bike pathways out there. [1:00:19] And I think perhaps to address the issue that city staff has brought up, it might be easier [1:00:24] to inject that into the lease with the state rather than having a separate agreement with [1:00:28] the city. [1:00:29] The talks about the maintenance of public access and the trail system as well as any other amenities [1:00:37] out there. [1:00:38] do you have a, so this is the latest ballpark [1:00:46] estimate of the location of the building. [1:00:51] So the existing building, the visitor center building, [1:00:55] is right. [1:01:08] So the building sort of encompasses where those buildings are [1:01:13] and then to the north of there, it's approximately 5,500 [1:01:18] to 6,000 square feet. [1:01:21] But again, we don't have the final designs on that. [1:01:24] but we would have those prior to working with city staff [1:01:27] to move forward with a special use permit application. [1:01:33] We have some questions, Donald. [1:01:35] Sean, I'm just curious. [1:01:36] What's the history of the visitor center there? [1:01:38] When was it placed there? [1:01:40] I mean, that was some good thinking. [1:01:42] Yeah, so the existing building, I believe, [1:01:45] was constructed in 1989. [1:01:47] Okay. [1:01:48] And that was actually a somewhat volunteer project [1:01:51] of the Builders Association in partnership [1:01:54] the chamber. I do not know many more specific details beyond that. The restroom facility was [1:02:00] actually constructed with a grant that the city received. And I have had a conversation, it [1:02:07] was through the state Parks and Rec Department. I've had a conversation with them, there are [1:02:12] no strings attached to that grant funding, that facility could be removed. The new visitor [1:02:18] center or tourist information center would have restrooms available roughly the same hours [1:02:25] that they're available out there. [1:02:27] Thank you. [1:02:28] Mr. Stein. [1:02:29] I can provide a little background. [1:02:31] When I was running the cable company here I was approached by my old broadcast friend, [1:02:37] Buzz Langen, about the funding for this and we gave money I think in part to construct [1:02:44] that and it was in the last part of the 80s, but I would say 85 to 89 and that kind of concurs [1:02:50] with which you think. [1:02:51] And I think it was completed and opened actually after Mr. Langdon's death. [1:02:55] Yes, that's correct. [1:02:56] Yeah. [1:02:57] And my question is on parking with this large footprint. [1:03:01] Are you going to have to require more parking? [1:03:04] So this is the existing, um, that's made here. [1:03:10] There is additional parking. [1:03:11] So this is the roadway that comes in behind there now that's currently gravel and dirt in a good day. [1:03:17] So this would be improved parking. Any bad accessible parking right here? [1:03:25] Okay. [1:03:27] In the conversations we've had with Mitch, in his opinion, this meets the parking requirement. [1:03:36] Rebecca Masley. [1:03:38] Thank you Mayor. [1:03:39] My question is probably for staff just about special use permits. [1:03:42] Councilman Berger was talking about their timeline, so if they apply for [1:03:48] a special use permit now, do those ever expire? [1:03:51] Mitch described me that there is a timeline of when you have to actually [1:03:56] hold a building permit for that and so we would like to time that [1:04:01] appropriately so that we don't move forward with a special use permit and then [1:04:04] find ourselves not being able to meet our. Right, that was my question. Are we [1:04:09] sure we want to apply now or or is this kind of a and really I think my request [1:04:14] tonight is more about asking your permission to do that okay not make the [1:04:18] actual go ahead and hold the trigger and get that submitted today okay thank [1:04:23] you and in for the record the timeline is six months [1:04:28] six months thank you okay I see no additional light I would entertain a [1:04:36] motion to [1:04:38] uh... [1:04:39] well i was going to let you finish the motion i was going to say i said i have [1:04:43] so moved [1:04:44] to proceed with it [1:04:46] has the city agreed to proceed with the process for the uh... [1:04:50] s u p [1:04:51] for the new uh... tourist info center [1:04:54] located on property uh... city leases from my t d [1:04:59] operate by the chamber [1:05:01] and move by christian and second by don hall that we move forward [1:05:05] with the request for the special use permit [1:05:08] in the rest of it. [1:05:10] Seeing no additional lights, Lea, roll call vote. [1:05:13] Yes. [1:05:14] Yes. [1:05:16] Yes. [1:05:17] I don't think so. [1:05:20] I'm sorry. [1:05:21] I'm staying. [1:05:22] Yes. [1:05:23] Yes. [1:05:25] Motion passes six to zero. [1:05:27] Thank you. [1:05:28] Staff and Sean. [1:05:29] I'll let Sean move back up here. [1:05:30] Item number three is the discussion of the estimate of the motion. [1:05:35] I'll let Sean move back up here. [1:05:40] Item number three is a discussion of the estimates [1:05:43] of development costs for the evil, [1:05:45] commieval jump site display. [1:05:57] Thank you, Mayor and Council. [1:05:59] Yes, last week, you know, there was some discussion [1:06:01] about the development of the jump site [1:06:03] and now I was gonna ask you to prepare a staff report. [1:06:07] What we understood from the Council direction was, [1:06:10] there was kind of seven, you might say, [1:06:13] I've broken down to seven different improvements [1:06:15] at the jump site. [1:06:16] Quickly kind of go over them. [1:06:17] One was the access road. [1:06:19] Hankins road, it currently ends right here. [1:06:22] This little section that goes east and west, [1:06:24] that has been built by the developer [1:06:26] that's doing the southern half of his development. [1:06:29] We're talking the access road coming up here. [1:06:31] It's approximately about 2,500 feet. [1:06:33] This would be the kind of the proposed area [1:06:35] for the parking lot, and then jump site is right here. [1:06:38] So we talked about an access road being built here [1:06:41] to the parking lot. Staff has talked about a Jason to the road, have a 10 foot wide walking [1:06:47] trail, bicycle trail, running along here and kind of wraps around the parking lot and then [1:06:52] come up here. And also that would connect with, we talked about a Canyon Rim trail that would [1:06:58] connect from the Centennial trail that stops right now, runs along here and then stops at [1:07:02] the property line right here. Also, we talked about part of our agreement with the developer. [1:07:08] do have fencing on one side of this access road, but we talked about maybe fencing on both [1:07:15] sides of this road here. I kind of talked about a parking lot here, talked about the trail here, [1:07:22] and we kind of put in there because there was a little bit of discussion about a restroom [1:07:27] souvenir area. We thought looking at this, maybe we could put this approximately about right here [1:07:33] in the northwest corner of this rectangle area, [1:07:37] and also was talked about some landscaping. [1:07:40] So now I'll kind of go into detail [1:07:41] like each one of these areas. [1:07:44] The access road from basically the Hankins up to [1:07:48] the parking lot, it's approximately about 2,500 feet. [1:07:51] Working with the engineering department, [1:07:53] we're looking at a 24 foot width road here, [1:07:59] and they really stress to me, [1:08:00] and I'm gonna really stress to you [1:08:01] that the unknown factors is how much rock [1:08:05] they're gonna be dealing with out there. [1:08:07] You know, you can go places where you have nothing [1:08:09] but solid rock for feet or in other areas [1:08:12] you could have topsoil for feet. [1:08:14] So they're really stressed, this is just an estimate. [1:08:16] You know, they, I think they use 175 bucks, [1:08:19] a linear foot per section per 12 foot width. [1:08:23] So this trail, excuse me, this road of 2,500 feet [1:08:27] could cost $875,000, and it could be higher. [1:08:32] Just depends how much rock you have to deal with out here. [1:08:37] They really talked about, and also this [1:08:39] would, we have to worry about it, [1:08:40] the drainage of the road also. [1:08:44] Excuse me. [1:08:45] The 10 foot wide path proposed to be [1:08:49] run alongside the road, run along up here, [1:08:52] kind of go around the parking lot, [1:08:53] go by the jump site, and connect with this section of trail. [1:08:57] And that trail is, in my staff report I talked about, [1:08:59] just a little bit under 3,700 linear feet. [1:09:02] And if we go by our kind of our standard, [1:09:04] right now I'm using a 75 bucks, a linear foot, [1:09:07] that would be almost $275,000 to construct that. [1:09:15] One, we talked about that, [1:09:17] we don't know how much separation, [1:09:18] what I love to get as much separation from the road [1:09:21] to the trail, but it really kind of depends [1:09:23] on how much drainage we need out here [1:09:25] how much rockwork they're going to have to do, you know, if they're going to have to do a lot of leveling out there. [1:09:30] But the idea is try to get that trail by walking trail as far as away from the road itself. [1:09:39] And then the fencing estimates I've used is, you know, I talked about, you know, running it on both sides, [1:09:49] around the parking lot on both sides of the property here, and I was about a little bit over 7,200 then your feet. [1:09:54] So that's over a mile and we've been and our land and land trade agreement states that we have to put a pole fence [1:10:01] And I'm looking at right now [1:10:02] We use a lot of that wooden pole fence along the canaryam trails, and that's roughly now about 18 bucks a linear foot [1:10:09] So that estimate cost for fencing just a little bit under $130,000 [1:10:14] Parking lot would be in this rectangle area here [1:10:18] It looked like we can do approximately about 45,000 square feet of a parking lot, so that [1:10:24] basically is a little bit over one acre in size. [1:10:29] And that would also give us enough room around the side for the 10-foot walking path. [1:10:35] And also, you know, you could leave room on the north or south side for retention areas [1:10:39] because you do have to retain your water from the parking lot. [1:10:41] So there is room that you could, you know, it depends, it's sloped, mostly, would go north. [1:10:46] So if we could do that. [1:10:48] What I used is bids from the Urban Renew Block 133 parking lot down by the New Glenview building [1:10:54] because I was just built this year and using those estimates or those bids that they received [1:11:00] from that, the parking lot would be approximately about $185,000. [1:11:04] And that still could be low, just depends how much rock activation they have to do there. [1:11:11] And then the cost of the estimate to extend the trail from the Centennial Trail along the [1:11:18] Canyon Rim to our property on the West Side, that's approximately about 650 feet and using [1:11:24] our 75 bucks of linear foot. [1:11:26] So that price is just a little bit under $50,000. [1:11:29] It depends on the placement of the trail is how much fencing we have to put along there. [1:11:35] And if we have 100 foot of fencing, it's going to be another $2,500 cost there. [1:11:43] Number six was the kind of the restroom souvenir building out there. [1:11:48] I can say my 2,500 square feet of a building. [1:11:52] That is just an estimate on that. [1:11:55] For example, that new restroom we have out at the Oregon Trail Youth Complex. [1:12:00] That's a little bit over a thousand feet, right around a thousand feet. [1:12:02] I'm looking at a restaurant that can accommodate some people, but also look at a souvenir shop. [1:12:08] You could have kiosks, information in there. [1:12:11] I don't know if the city would be running that souvenir shop, but maybe it's something we partner. [1:12:15] We lease out like we do our other concessionaires or something. [1:12:17] Maybe we form another partnership with the chamber to manage that for us. [1:12:21] I don't know on that. [1:12:23] But I was looking at approximately 2,500 feet and had a price of about $140,000 per square foot. [1:12:31] until that building could cost up to $350,000. [1:12:34] Also, we would force me to drill a well for water. [1:12:38] And also, we'd have to put it on kind of a drain field [1:12:41] or a bolt system out there because there is no sewer out there. [1:12:45] The last part, I think Rebecca brought this up [1:12:47] about some landscaping around here. [1:12:49] There's not a lot of room for landscaping out here, [1:12:51] especially after you put the road in, put our trail, [1:12:55] do the parking lot, and if our trail [1:12:57] runs from the parking lot up to the the trail up here. There's not a lot of room [1:13:03] for landscaping but we could do some landscaping around if we have this [1:13:06] restroom souvenir and I just put an estimate of approximately $8,000 for [1:13:11] that. So from these recaps of these estimates you know you're looking at a [1:13:15] little bit less than $2 million and again the cost of all that road work [1:13:20] work. [1:13:21] Exervation is really unknown until you do some studies on that. [1:13:25] Correct, right, sorry. [1:13:26] We do have some lights here. [1:13:28] Okay, and that's kind of concludes my presentation. [1:13:30] Yeah, I'm going to let you get finished here for a while. [1:13:34] Susanne, good job. [1:13:37] On a parking lot that size about how many vehicles can you get in there? [1:13:41] That one, I knew someone was going to ask me that question. [1:13:44] Sorry. [1:13:45] I can't give you any idea what that parking lot on there holds up. [1:13:50] Does that uphold about 100? [1:13:57] Can't give you any right now. [1:13:58] No idea. [1:13:59] I can definitely get that. [1:14:00] Are you looking at room for buses and stuff for tourism out there as well? [1:14:04] And that's what we envision, you know, some tour buses going out there. [1:14:07] So that parking, like I said, we have no design on it right now. [1:14:10] We just look at about, you know, 50,000 square feet and we would design some [1:14:15] rooms for tour buses and parking. [1:14:17] parking so we don't have you know until we get a design is where right right you [1:14:22] have your space and we don't have a lot of fudge room if to make it larger if we [1:14:27] needed more I mean that's pretty much limited to what we have available right [1:14:31] it could probably kind of depends until you get a design right you know and once [1:14:34] you get the size of the parking lot determines and your retention area like [1:14:37] that and also depends we like to get the path that wrap around there until we [1:14:43] we actually do what we signed is we won't have the actual numbers of parking spots. [1:14:49] Thank you. [1:14:50] No. [1:14:51] Well, I had similar questions about parking spots and I was just thinking, you know, R.V. [1:14:55] Turn around when they have a, they're bringing an R.V. in with a car towed behind it. [1:15:00] Some of those things are bigger than buses. [1:15:02] So it needs to be room to be able to do that. [1:15:05] We have the 40 acres of the song. [1:15:07] Yeah, probably not. [1:15:09] So there's no curb or anything like that along the roadway. [1:15:13] You don't need that in that area. [1:15:15] If it was in the city, you would probably would. [1:15:19] I'm just curious about the regulations regarding curbside walking gutter. [1:15:24] And that's one of the emails I received from Jackie Fields, our city engineer, talked about [1:15:29] that would not have to include no curbing gutter. [1:15:35] Is that because of where it's at? [1:15:36] Yes. [1:15:37] Because if it's in the city, you have to have it, don't you? [1:15:39] for new development, am I wrong? [1:15:43] You do, but on these type of roads, [1:15:45] it would be more of a burrow detention facility, [1:15:48] where actually if you put curb and gutter, [1:15:51] it actually would significantly alter [1:15:54] the storm water retention. [1:15:55] Okay, I can explain that better than I can. [1:15:58] I'm just curious, make sure that we're doing [1:16:00] what we're supposed to do. [1:16:01] The biggest reason for curb and gutter in the city [1:16:02] is adjacent neighbors fill in barrow titches, [1:16:05] where this is only maintained by the city, [1:16:08] we won't, we'll maintain that. [1:16:10] She also wanted to talk about the big rock [1:16:14] that Dennis talked about. [1:16:16] This is an area we know that has rock, [1:16:19] but the contour of the land is pretty unjubating, [1:16:21] and I don't know what the jump person needs [1:16:23] as far as flatness, so if he needs to go down or up, [1:16:26] we're blasting on to rockers, large costs. [1:16:30] Good point. [1:16:32] Maybe he could stay up, because I have another question [1:16:34] regarding the sewer. [1:16:36] Maybe I was just under the understanding that [1:16:39] we couldn't put any more septic tanks out [1:16:41] in the area of impact. [1:16:43] Is that not right? [1:16:48] Well, if there's a Jason sewer. [1:16:50] Yeah, if there's a Jason sewer, [1:16:51] our own city code says if you're within 150 feet [1:16:53] of sewer, you need to hook into the sewer [1:16:55] and there's not one within 150 feet, [1:16:57] so a septic would be fine. [1:16:59] It's all septic in this side. [1:17:00] Okay, thank you. [1:17:01] Just thank you. [1:17:02] Well, I sure like Dennis, what you've done, [1:17:04] you've given us something to put our teeth into [1:17:06] There's no way I could personally encumber Big Ed with a million and nine on this. [1:17:15] However, there are a couple of things that to me make sense. [1:17:19] I prioritize that 650 feet of canyon trail for 51,000. [1:17:27] The road to me is not consumable. [1:17:31] people can get out there, it doesn't have to be developed at this time, and the restaurants, [1:17:38] why can't we just use porta-potties that are picked up and rotated? [1:17:41] This does not have to be first class as we go, we want to have some convenience for people, [1:17:46] but for people walking from Sichon Falls up here in porta-pottie, they'd probably think [1:17:53] that's the greatest thing they've seen in an hour and a half, and I'm not sure that [1:17:57] wouldn't do us for an interim period on this. I just see problems with getting too complex, [1:18:05] so with the souvenir building, and then there'll be the need for power. And we talk about the [1:18:10] rock clause in there. I got it. There's a quart of soil in there naturally, and you'd be bringing [1:18:16] in some fill. But a good job got us on this. But those are some of my priorities. [1:18:21] Okay, Dennis, I appreciate the numbers coming together, [1:18:25] appreciating also that there is some unknown out there. [1:18:29] A couple of items I would point out, [1:18:31] so the roadway and perhaps even the trail section, [1:18:36] if this is indeed to be some sort of a run up road to a ramp, [1:18:41] those improvements are likely gonna have to be made [1:18:43] anyway for the stunt. [1:18:45] And so I wouldn't see us saying, go build this road after you build your thing and then [1:18:52] tear it out. [1:18:53] But it might be worthy of talking about building whatever amenities need to be done for the jump [1:19:00] to meet city standards or be given back to the city at the end of it. [1:19:06] So those costs may be, they may seem out of the ordinary, but they may be necessary improvements [1:19:13] that they have to be making anyway. [1:19:16] And so I think it would be worthy of having that discussion of can the road be built to [1:19:22] such a standard that meets our needs as well as theirs? [1:19:27] I too want to thank you, Dennis. [1:19:30] This was a detailed report and gives us some really good ideas. [1:19:33] I think I probably, I kind of agree with both Sean and Chris here. [1:19:38] I don't personally think that we need to start looking at this and figuring out that I know [1:19:44] we talked about museums and all these other things. I think we need to be [1:19:49] reasonable about this and then as I was going to mention that too Sean about the [1:19:53] roadway sounds like probably won't be negotiable he'll need some sort of hard [1:19:58] surface if he's truly going to run a motorcycle still don't understand how [1:20:03] that's gonna work but he'll need some roadway so and I but I do agree with you [1:20:08] to chris that the trail is non-negotiable to me. [1:20:13] I think that's an improvement [1:20:15] and it needs to be done in that area. [1:20:18] Jim, I may have a favor. [1:20:21] Travis, do you want to go first? [1:20:22] Mr. Mayor, just clarification on the trail, [1:20:24] just so that we understand. [1:20:25] So the trail that you're referring to [1:20:27] is the $51,000 cost for the trail on the Canyon rim section. [1:20:32] Cost for the trail on the Canyon rim section. It is not necessarily the trail that runs north and south so is right [1:20:40] Okay, we understand [1:20:43] Thank you travis. Yeah, goes without saying I just absolutely love staff reports like this. It's fantastic anyway. I digress [1:20:51] Where is the police gun range from here? [1:20:59] You know we have always struggled through the years we do have a road that goes to the gun range [1:21:04] but it's it's not too bad but I mean I hate you know we have an interest out [1:21:10] there I know that we go straight north on the Hankins you go out there for a [1:21:16] while that it's you got a little road yeah you haven't been out there no it's [1:21:20] horrible bad but what I'm saying it's right is there any way to get a good [1:21:30] roadway over Chief, maybe you can jump into this thing, but we have an interest [1:21:36] out in this area that may offer us an opportunity to get a good roadway to that [1:21:41] gun rate which allows police officers to access it all year long without having to, [1:21:48] is it done deal? [1:21:52] They don't round me to shoot guns anymore since I retired, so I do keep a [1:21:56] a bullet in my pocket, but so go ahead. [1:21:59] The area that you're talking about actually has been developed rather extensively. [1:22:05] So it's nice out there now? It's nice out there. I do know the area that you're talking about. [1:22:09] As a matter of fact, to access this particular spot, you have to drive out through that subdivision area, [1:22:14] and then you know where you make the right and go back to the gun range. [1:22:17] Yes, that's all fixed. Well, not all of it, but probably, you know, [1:22:22] 85% of that is now paved and ready to be a subdivision. [1:22:26] I was out there a couple about a month and a half ago. It wasn't paid yet. So they paid it obviously [1:22:31] No, that's good. Okay. I was just trying to see if there's some way for us to jump in on that, but I'm obviously [1:22:36] way behind this. All right, Dennis, this was certainly, there's a little sticker shot going on up here [1:22:47] I'm sure as you probably realized we would have and I'm sure what Mr. Beckley gets with this little sticker [1:22:54] as well. But thank you for the information that gives us a place to start from and see [1:23:01] what we can put together. Thank you, Dennis. Appreciate your efforts. [1:23:06] Moving on to two-man Travis. [1:23:10] So Mr. Mayor, members of the Council, our intent is to share this list with and begin [1:23:16] that process with Mr. Simmons and Beckley Media, and then we will move forward through [1:23:21] those negotiations, and ultimately bring back to you something that is negotiated that is [1:23:30] both equitable for the city and equitable for Beckley media. [1:23:34] Well, I think we need to provide a little more guidance for city staff, like prioritizing [1:23:39] these. [1:23:41] We've locked down them over the weekend. [1:23:44] First part of the next month, at the very latest, I don't see any reason why we shouldn't [1:23:48] prioritizing, plus for right to do it tonight. [1:23:51] Travis. [1:23:54] Travis. [1:23:55] Travis. [1:23:57] As Fritz has so aptly taught me, it may be something where we don't want to negotiate [1:24:02] against ourselves. [1:24:04] And so we may want to enter into a conversation. [1:24:09] We understand the direction that you provided and that the $51,000 cost for the Canyon Rim [1:24:14] Trail is a mandate. [1:24:18] The rest of that might be negotiable. [1:24:21] as I understood it. [1:24:23] I'm pretty strong on the roadway, too. [1:24:27] Well, we need to see what he thinks of me. [1:24:31] You like parking lot. [1:24:33] But no road. [1:24:38] I guess one comment I would make is, I think, [1:24:40] in keeping with the discussion we've [1:24:43] continue to have since September, I think, [1:24:47] trying to find public access to improvements [1:24:52] for the public's sake are important. [1:24:54] And how exactly we get there, [1:24:57] I think that's a great conversation to have. [1:24:59] We're back in about a second. [1:25:01] Oh, thank you, Mayor. [1:25:02] I was just gonna ask if we were taking public input. [1:25:03] It appears that we might have some public wanting to speak. [1:25:07] And I know we solicited that on the compensation. [1:25:10] I don't know if I was going to do it at the end, [1:25:11] but we can certainly do it on each item. [1:25:12] If you think that would be more appropriate, [1:25:14] if anybody wanted to. [1:25:14] I would support that. [1:25:15] Speak on item number four or I come forth now, [1:25:18] identify yourself. [1:25:27] I'm Victoria Wakewood and I'm actually speaking, I have a question on item three and I live [1:25:36] in the area and I along with probably a number of other people have been in the area and we [1:25:43] jog and we walk and we're real interested and that being opened up, that area being opened [1:25:49] up as perhaps a possibility for future access for people in that area and wonder if it's [1:25:56] gated now and wondering if that area will be opened up at the end of Hankins Road so that [1:26:02] public, you know, especially the people that live in the area, can walk in that area? [1:26:07] Dennis, you want to cover that one? [1:26:14] The roadway on our property is not developed. [1:26:20] The subdivision is developed, but that's private property. [1:26:23] It's only available for the police department or authorized users to get back to the gun range. [1:26:29] So the neighbors cannot use that until our property is actually developed. [1:26:34] Good. [1:26:35] Sure. [1:26:37] There used to be a fence right here that the police department had access, I think engineering [1:26:43] and the parks department had access to get to the gun range, get to the centering ponds, [1:26:48] get to our trail system. [1:26:49] When this person started to develop, they removed that gate there and now it's wide open. [1:26:54] We ended up moving our gate where there's a cattle guard when it crosses out property. [1:26:59] So we have our gate here so people can't access that. [1:27:04] I know that I've heard that people have been driving out here, [1:27:07] but it is on private property, something like that. [1:27:10] So the idea is, believe this area, [1:27:13] this subdivision plans on being a gated subdivision. [1:27:16] Once they maybe get that with this first phase, [1:27:19] so my guess their gate will be approximately right here, [1:27:21] but once this access road gets built, [1:27:26] the general public will be able to get out this way. [1:27:30] Thank you, Dennis. I remember this like thank you mayor. So to clarify the [1:27:34] Area where the red hashes that's the city owned property and that is just natural ground and natural land there [1:27:42] I think this section right here is paved right here [1:27:46] This is part of chain chain road eventually [1:27:50] So this little thing about a hundred and fifteen your feet is paid and the developer of what he's done. He's paved a road [1:27:57] somewhere I can't don't know exactly but he's paved a road about this far and he's [1:28:02] got a Colesack back in here too so he's done painting on this property. Okay which [1:28:07] road do city staff and the police take? Well this kind of you can kind of see this [1:28:13] darkness has been the road that we have taken before. So it leads to a different [1:28:17] location? Well the street department has put that re-grine on it so it's packed so [1:28:21] it's not completely paved but it's it's that re-grine but the developer has in the [1:28:26] last month paid a good portion of this road for his development. [1:28:31] Okay, and those roads do not lead to the jump site? [1:28:34] No, it doesn't. [1:28:36] They lead to a different location. [1:28:38] Okay, thank you. [1:28:43] Okay. [1:28:44] We have one more. [1:28:45] I would like to speak. [1:28:48] Well, this was actually three, I'm sorry, we're moving on to four right now. [1:28:52] Okay. [1:28:53] I have turned two pages here, and I did this talking about four when he's next, talking [1:28:59] All right. Moving on to item number four is update of security plans for the [1:29:04] Canyon Jump that may be maybe taking place in 2014. Chief Brian Pike. [1:29:10] Welcome Chief. Thank you Mayor and members of the Council. One thing that Captain [1:29:13] Barnhart and I shared with you is that we'd be coming back before you on a [1:29:17] regular basis giving updates on how those plans progress. Probably up to and [1:29:22] including a full briefing on the full security plan. So tonight I want to do that [1:29:28] Although I will be very brief because there hasn't been a lot of developments, but we did [1:29:32] have a conference call with Rod Woodruff, who is the event director for the Beckley Media [1:29:38] Group on December 19th, and we talked in more detail, obviously Rod and his staff are moving [1:29:44] forward and putting together their plan. [1:29:46] We had a lot of discussion about site security and what that would look like and what their [1:29:49] plans are for the site on the south side. [1:29:53] And primarily right now, they're saying that they're not planning on having any, that site [1:30:01] will not be open to the public. [1:30:02] They will have some sponsors, they're asking if they can have some sponsors in there, but [1:30:05] they're not planning to have any public access on that south site. [1:30:11] We also talked a little bit about the traffic management plan and what that looked like, not [1:30:14] only just for the south site, but also Twin Falls as a whole. [1:30:19] We had quite a lengthy discussion about the bridge and what the requirements would be to [1:30:23] to make sure that we maintain an open access on the bridge. [1:30:28] And then the last thing that we were able to do [1:30:30] is we did schedule a meeting for January 9th [1:30:32] with all of our public safety teams. [1:30:34] So we'll have members of law enforcement, [1:30:36] fire service and medical providers meeting on the 9th [1:30:40] to start having kind of more of a regional discussion [1:30:43] about what this looks like, [1:30:44] not just only for the Twin Falls Police Department, [1:30:46] but for Jerome County and for Twin Falls County [1:30:49] and all those agencies that will be involved. [1:30:52] So that's where we're at. [1:30:54] I've made a couple visits to the site, [1:30:57] and I would encourage you. [1:30:58] If you have an opportunity to go out to the site, [1:31:00] walk up on the ramp, take a look. [1:31:02] It really brings a different reality [1:31:05] to the entire event, so you more have me [1:31:08] to stand for any questions. [1:31:10] Don Hall. [1:31:10] You know, I was gonna mention that, too. [1:31:11] Thank you, Chief. [1:31:12] Dennis, maybe we could have a field trip one these days [1:31:15] and go out and look at that really cool mound of dirt again. [1:31:18] But really look at the improvements of the road, [1:31:21] because I was out there, Jim, when they were tearing it up, [1:31:25] but I didn't know that they had paid some of that. [1:31:27] But also actually look at where the road's going to be. [1:31:30] I'm still, I don't have that in my mind's eye yet, [1:31:34] other than just on pictures. [1:31:35] So I would like to do that sometime. [1:31:38] Would the 13th at about 3.34 o'clock work for you guys? [1:31:42] Where's your meeting? [1:31:43] What day the week is that there's? [1:31:44] It's a Monday, it'd be a council meeting. [1:31:46] Probably. [1:31:47] That's public works open house, isn't it? [1:31:51] Yes. [1:31:53] We'll come up with another one. [1:31:56] We'll come up with another one. [1:31:57] When I do an alternative date, weather permitting. [1:31:59] Good call. Good catch, Susan. [1:32:04] Chris, are you? [1:32:05] Chief, good news. [1:32:07] But let me just play devil's advocate. [1:32:09] Can you assure us that our public safety program is going to involve as many impacted, [1:32:18] I've acted public agencies law enforcement as possible, [1:32:21] including Jerome County, what, National Guard, FAA, PLM, [1:32:31] and I was thinking more directly to the security. [1:32:34] I want to make sure that Twin Falls City, [1:32:36] Twin Falls County and Jerome are like, [1:32:39] Siamese, not triplets actually on this thing [1:32:43] because it has so much more to gain from it, [1:32:47] coordinating from the very beginning, [1:32:48] at it coming out of the last minute. [1:32:51] One of the things that we have talked about with Woodruff and his team is that it would [1:32:55] be nice if instead of trying to answer to every different agency that's involved that [1:33:00] we provided him with kind of an, I like to call it kind of an executive group of chiefs [1:33:06] and sheriffs and all the primary individuals that have been involved in the event. [1:33:12] Now honestly, one thing that we're trying to do is because we're working a little bit [1:33:15] it under a timeline is that we I can promise you we will be meeting with all [1:33:20] those individuals in different levels but the one thing that we're trying to [1:33:23] avoid is a meeting where we have 50 or 60 people in the room and it's not a very [1:33:28] productive meeting so I see the way I see this developing is probably starting [1:33:33] with our meeting on the 9th and then getting direction with with those [1:33:36] individuals so we we do have Jerome County there we have Jerome City we have [1:33:40] Twin Falls prosecutors Jerome prosecutor getting that group together and then [1:33:44] moving forward with probably different working groups coming out of that, you know, related [1:33:49] to traffic, maybe aviation, a number of those issues. But I think all of our partners deserve [1:33:54] it. And just as a follow up on that, you can assure us that R911 and CIRCOM can talk. [1:33:59] Yes, they can talk. Good. And we'll talk. [1:34:04] And do talk, actually. Also BLM, they have Law Enforcement League of their organization [1:34:12] as well and fire and all and EMS, all that. [1:34:16] Right. [1:34:17] Our goal is to make sure all of our partners have a seat at the table, perfect, and a voice [1:34:20] and event. [1:34:21] Thank you, Chief. [1:34:22] Travis? [1:34:24] I think it's important to recognize that as we work with all of our local government partners, [1:34:32] I think it's important to remember that the responsibility of this event still falls on [1:34:37] on Beckley media and that we will do what we can to coordinate an effort and an activity. [1:34:44] But the development of that plan really needs to be done through input of the chiefs, but from [1:34:51] that input a plan needs to be developed. [1:34:54] I think that we could, if the City of Twin Falls is responsible for constructing a public [1:35:00] safety plan for our community as well as all the surrounding communities and the inter-government [1:35:06] and agencies I think that will reach a place [1:35:09] where it becomes incredibly difficult. [1:35:11] I think the process that the Chief has set up [1:35:13] is a great venue and a great forum [1:35:15] that brings all of the interested parties together [1:35:18] in a nice location for Beckley medius folks [1:35:21] to be able to work and navigate through [1:35:23] that public safety process. [1:35:25] John Berg. [1:35:27] It would maybe just echo a comment that Travis made. [1:35:30] I think we need to remember on all of these things [1:35:32] that the responsibility of planning [1:35:34] and executing this event falls upon back the media [1:35:37] or whoever we select should we move forward in that process [1:35:40] and not upon the city of Twin Falls. [1:35:43] And it's not our responsibility to go choose [1:35:47] and select and hand pick who else we need to be working with. [1:35:51] Again, appreciate that there needs [1:35:52] to be that collaboration, cooperation, but chief, [1:35:56] and I know you went and clear back to the back [1:35:58] of the room to sit down and maybe you don't have to speak [1:35:59] back to me, but you can just listen. [1:36:01] You mentioned in your report here [1:36:03] that you're expecting a more detailed event security plan [1:36:06] for Mr. Woodruff in the next couple of months. [1:36:09] And while I appreciate the need for some flexibility [1:36:12] in crossing all the Ts and dotting all the I's, [1:36:16] I for one have an expectation that as we approach [1:36:20] the end of January and 1st of February [1:36:22] with the timeline that we've laid out, [1:36:25] that there be some significant progress [1:36:29] by Beckley media on those safety and security plans. [1:36:34] Again, understanding that there will still need [1:36:36] to be some fine details, but I don't wanna hit [1:36:39] the end of January and have the response be, [1:36:42] we're gonna have a plan because we've been hearing that [1:36:45] for many months from all groups. [1:36:48] Councilman, I agree, and one of the, I think, benefits [1:36:52] of regular updates is that right now, [1:36:54] this has all been preliminary, and like I shared before, [1:36:57] we have not seen a detailed plan. [1:36:59] we've had a lot of discussions. [1:37:01] We've tried to give them as much guidance [1:37:03] in the development of that plan as possible. [1:37:06] And honestly, probably hoping that the first draft [1:37:09] will go a little further, but we know it'll be a first draft [1:37:12] and there'll be revisions to it. [1:37:13] But I can assure you as we move into January, [1:37:16] if we don't start seeing detailed plans, [1:37:19] that will be part of our updates. [1:37:21] Our expectation is that Bechley Media [1:37:23] present a plan and a detailed plan and at least something [1:37:27] that we can work with and begin to work with. [1:37:30] So right now we've had a lot of discussions. [1:37:33] I think there's agreement, [1:37:35] but we have not seen a detailed plan. [1:37:38] Thank you. [1:37:41] So you've noticed on the lights that we have in the public [1:37:43] that would like to speak on item number four. [1:37:51] Katie Brackenridge, Peekaboo, [1:37:52] I'm here to talk about just what you were referring to, [1:37:56] and that is the whole overall plan. [1:37:59] As you know, I don't have to tell you, [1:38:02] We do a I, Rob, whomever, own that 13 acres on the other side of the king and the Jerome. [1:38:10] And what we would like to offer and have very much part of now is that if the first responders, [1:38:18] all of those individuals need a safe spot, that property, our property is fenced. [1:38:24] It is on .2 miles from the jump site. [1:38:32] I mean, we're right there. [1:38:34] And as we look at it, we had one, two questions. [1:38:39] Number one, how are you going to keep, [1:38:41] can you keep people off public lands? [1:38:45] Part of the discussion that we heard at the last time [1:38:48] was that Eclim Media said they were going to bust everybody [1:38:51] to the, by the light there. [1:38:56] And then there would be, or park there. [1:38:58] And then there would be buses to take them into the jump site. [1:39:02] Well, that's public lands. [1:39:04] That's state lands. [1:39:06] And can you lock up state lands so that nobody can get on that? [1:39:12] That's a question that I have. [1:39:14] And then the other question I have, [1:39:16] or the other thought to think about, [1:39:18] is that there's another access that comes in off of, [1:39:22] there are a lot of other accesses that come not just off [1:39:25] the highway, but around the backside on that state lands. [1:39:30] And that piece of property sits right on the end of that. [1:39:35] So we would like to be a part of the planning process [1:39:41] because it's huge what's going to happen on the other side [1:39:45] of the canyon. [1:39:46] And we don't particularly cherish the thought [1:39:50] of working with Beckley Media. [1:39:52] We trust a lot more of that gentleman [1:39:55] that's sitting in the back and the people over in Jerome. [1:39:58] And so if you say, we'll go work with Beckley Media, [1:40:02] that's not an option for us. [1:40:04] We want those first responders to have a safe place to be. [1:40:07] And we are here to offer that if that can help in any manner. [1:40:12] And I am concerned about the brand of Idaho. [1:40:20] I love Idaho. [1:40:22] And all of you in this room do too. [1:40:25] And I don't want this to be a dog and pony show. [1:40:28] I want this to be a very planned, professional, [1:40:32] safe environment. [1:40:34] Not just for those of us who might go and get [1:40:36] in the middle of that, but think about all the people [1:40:41] that are going to come to this. [1:40:43] 90% of them will probably be really good people. [1:40:48] But 10% of them might not be the kind of people [1:40:52] that you want to have, or I want to have around. [1:40:56] And how do we market and protect southern Idaho? [1:41:03] I hesitated to say much about this, [1:41:06] but I think it's very important that we think about the safety. [1:41:11] I was around when the last evil, [1:41:14] conical jump took place, and I've lived here forever. [1:41:18] And it's not the safety of the event itself. [1:41:22] It's the safety of those of us who live here [1:41:27] and have to deal with the caliber of individual [1:41:30] that's going to be attracted to this. [1:41:32] I mean that 10%. [1:41:35] I'm very concerned about that. [1:41:38] And I don't have any obvious answers to it. [1:41:44] But as a female who has been exposed to some really ugly [1:41:48] scenarios of the types of people that I'm referring to, I think it's something that we [1:41:54] need to think about. [1:41:57] And how are we going to protect the image of southern Idaho, specifically the image of [1:42:05] the Magic Valley? [1:42:11] Those are my thoughts. [1:42:12] But I'm here to offer. [1:42:13] If that land can help protect, Robin and I want to do that. [1:42:18] So know that, we've already said it to the general, to Mr. Chair, [1:42:24] Mike, I'm not sure how to address Chief, you know, honorable. [1:42:29] But I want to, I want to be apart, Robin, I want to be a part of it. [1:42:35] And so having said that, very Christmas. [1:42:37] Not very Christmas, you, Katie, anyone else like to speak on item number four? [1:42:45] Commissioner, come on up. [1:42:51] I appreciate everything you guys are going through this since I've been involved. [1:42:55] I realize what a huge vent this is and for any one group to take it on itself, I think [1:43:02] it's going to be a near impossibility. [1:43:05] I was kind of hit today with tonight with the facts that there's not going to be any public [1:43:10] in Twin Falls. [1:43:13] Well, that brings to mind where they're going to rest and where they're going to go. [1:43:21] He has talked to us yet, and I know it's not your building, that's not your place, that's [1:43:25] peckley medias. [1:43:27] But there are ways that we cannot take personal and public safety lightly at all. [1:43:39] That's an extremely hostile environment. [1:43:41] I was down there Friday, and the ridge that they go in drops straight off into the canyon. [1:43:47] There's a two-foot game trail that runs right below it, but it goes straight off into the [1:43:51] Canyon and I think would be extremely embarrassing plus saddening hugely [1:43:57] saddening for anyone to lose somebody at this event for money so I urge you to get [1:44:06] in touch with Jerome to not to let us know what you're doing so we can at least [1:44:11] pal up with you guys and try to stop this deal before I was here when last [1:44:15] time too and I have been in touch with some other people that one guy that owns a huge [1:44:23] campground in Nevada where they have where gatherings occur a lot and he's these already [1:44:31] hit his mailing list hundred thousand people on that list and I imagine out of that we'll [1:44:38] get a Harley or two in town maybe so this is this is nothing to joke about we're really [1:44:46] serious and there was serious things that happened last time that's what we're [1:44:49] paying to go into social falls so I would just like to say that I would be I [1:44:58] would act very expeditiously if if you want this plan to go forward in any [1:45:03] great event because it does end up in Jerome County and when we put safety [1:45:07] public safety out in the forefront thank you very much thank you Mr. Moore [1:45:13] Mr. Mayor, members of the Council and maybe for Commissioner Morley, it's our understanding [1:45:19] that Rod Woodruff had met with Jack Johnson, who is the Chief Deputy for Jerome County [1:45:29] when he was in town last Monday. [1:45:32] And we will encourage the representatives of Berkeley Media to get in direct contact [1:45:39] with the Jerome County Commissioners. [1:45:42] We would also, you know, this is one of those things [1:45:45] where we probably can't help but to over-communicate. [1:45:47] And so maybe it's one of those things [1:45:49] that we all continue to do that. [1:45:51] And so, but we'll certainly reach out to our contacts. [1:45:54] We'll see, see representatives of Jerome County [1:45:59] on that email to encourage them to get in direct contact [1:46:02] with them expeditiously as requested. [1:46:06] Thanks, Joe. [1:46:07] Donal. [1:46:07] Commissioner Morley, first of all, [1:46:08] I just wanted to say thank you for coming. [1:46:10] You've been to most of these meetings with us, [1:46:12] and you're keeping us honest on the north side, [1:46:15] and we appreciate that very much. [1:46:19] All right, before we move on to number five, [1:46:21] I'm gonna go ahead and order a 10-minute break, [1:46:24] or five as quickly as possible break. [1:46:26] We've been over an hour and a half, [1:46:27] and breastprints are probably not certain. [1:46:29] So a quick break for the rest of us. [1:52:00] I'd like to reconvene the December 23rd, 2013 meeting [1:52:05] at the Tonefala City Council, [1:52:06] moving on to item number five, [1:52:08] was a discussion of the first draft of the agreement [1:52:10] with Beckley Media to use Twin Falls City property [1:52:14] in his effort to jump to State River Canyon. [1:52:17] This will not be an action item, [1:52:19] proud of its Rothweiler and Fritz Wonder, [1:52:20] like our listed as the presenters. [1:52:24] So really Mr. Mayor, members of the Council, [1:52:26] what we're trying to do is get an agreement before you, [1:52:29] an agreement out to the community to review. [1:52:32] This agreement has been forwarded [1:52:34] to the both Chairman of the Board of Jerome County [1:52:38] It has been forwarded to Twin Falls County Prosecutor Grant Loeb's. [1:52:42] It was forwarded also to representatives of Beckley Media. [1:52:47] And earlier today we had a conversation on this very first draft with Beckley Media. [1:52:52] What's important to note is this agreement has also been reviewed by iCrimp. [1:52:56] And iCrimp has reviewed the first draft and they've said that it- [1:52:59] You might explain who iCrimp is. [1:53:01] iCrimp is the city's general liability insurance carrier. [1:53:05] And they're one of the entities that we have involved in this process to make sure that liability in no shape or [1:53:12] certain form can be transferred from this event to the City of Twin Falls and ultimately our residents. [1:53:17] They've reviewed this document and they've, we've incorporated their suggestions into it. [1:53:24] We're not asking the council to approve this. [1:53:26] In fact, what we want to do is just present it to you in a manner that in fact, [1:53:30] tonight is more of a, here's the agreement in what questions do you have. [1:53:35] a couple of quick notes and then I'm going to turn it over to Fritz. You'll notice that [1:53:39] there are some blank dates and there's some highlighted sections where we have to insert [1:53:43] the dates and those are probably going to be from guidance from you as well as in conversations [1:53:49] with Beckley Media. We believe that there are three pieces of this agreement that as is [1:53:54] constructed over the course of the next few weeks that will begin to take greater shape. [1:53:59] Number one, in Exhibit A, where we talk about the compensation, that will be a full piece [1:54:04] of what's to be included in here. [1:54:07] We'll present that to you for your review and consideration. [1:54:10] A detailed public safety and transportation plan will be a part, or at least a good framework [1:54:15] and outline, as we've discussed will be a part of this. [1:54:20] And then also a strategy to cover prosecution. [1:54:25] One of the things that we've had our conversations with the county prosecutor and we want to make [1:54:31] sure that in the event that there are some significant cases that require adjudication, [1:54:41] we want to make sure that the county prosecutor's office, the courts and the jails have some reasonable [1:54:49] protection, especially as we look at public safety. [1:54:54] In our conversations with the prosecutor, we're trying to set up a series of meetings at some [1:55:01] point in the future that will involve representatives from the jail, representatives from the courts, [1:55:07] representatives from his office to make sure that we're covering what that would look like. [1:55:15] We hope that over the course of the next few weeks we were going to have an agreement that [1:55:19] is going to meet your timeline. What we wanted to do was present the basic outline of what [1:55:24] this agreement looks like. We've had a conversation earlier today with Rod Woodruff who is with [1:55:31] again Beckley Media and he is the individual that is responsible for coordinating the security [1:55:40] portion of this event for Beckley Media and we talked primarily about insurance and the [1:55:45] ability to capture insurance. The amounts that are listed in here are the exact same amount [1:55:51] and that have been requested by the state in terms of their lease and it would be appropriate [1:55:57] for us to be listed as an additionally insured. We don't need two $10 million policies and so [1:56:02] we would be an additionally insured individual so just for that clarification. They were agreeable [1:56:09] and they were very appreciative of that. The second part of the conversation that we had [1:56:13] with them earlier today, centered around compensation, we shared that the Council would [1:56:17] be at least reviewing the list and then over the course of the next few weeks we would come [1:56:22] and move forward. [1:56:24] We believe at the staff level that Beckley Media understands the importance of preparing [1:56:28] a good framework for a public safety plan and a transportation plan and we continue to [1:56:33] reiterate that need and that importance moving forward. [1:56:36] So know that those pieces will be included in this document. [1:56:40] They're not there today because they're not fully mature and developed, but they will be included. [1:56:47] And so with that, we will turn it over for any suggestions, questions that you may have. [1:56:57] You may not have any at this point in time, which is very, very appropriate. [1:57:02] But we want, it's a big document. [1:57:05] And there's a lot of information, and we just want to make sure that you had it enough time [1:57:10] in advance to review that. [1:57:12] This again is out on our website, and individuals can review it and provide comment to us as [1:57:17] well. [1:57:18] And for all the fun technical legal questions, Mr. Wonder-Lick is my wingman and he will back [1:57:23] me up. [1:57:24] Did you have any additional thoughts? [1:57:29] Yeah, I just want to point out a couple of things. [1:57:33] The meat of the agreement in terms of how this will work is in Section 2 on the lease phases. [1:57:40] And you'll see that there's a Phase 1, which is the planning phase. [1:57:45] Phase 2 is the staging of the performance and phase 3's reclamation at page 3. [1:58:02] In the center of the page, you'll see what we're requiring to be included within the plan. [1:58:12] And that includes all government approvals, launch site development, modification, the access [1:58:19] and access controls, location of sanitary facilities, pickup schedules, location and supporting [1:58:25] facilities. [1:58:27] You'll see that we're requiring a lot of detail from them in the plan. [1:58:33] They don't get to phase two unless they complete phase one. [1:58:37] They do not get to the performance part unless they provide you with a plan. [1:58:43] As Travis indicated, we've left blanks. [1:58:45] You'll see blanks throughout and they're highlighted in gray where we want you to think [1:58:49] about timing on when you, for example, here when you will require this plan to be submitted [1:58:56] to you and you'll see throughout the document there are some other timing issues. [1:59:03] So one other item I want to draw your attention to that is not highlighted on page six, paragraph [1:59:14] four subleasing assignment. [1:59:18] It's there right now because this is a first draft. [1:59:21] You may want to allow it. [1:59:23] You may want to prohibit assignment of this so that because you've already prioritized [1:59:32] how you were going to grant these. [1:59:33] So if, for example, REO is your second on your priority list, you wouldn't want to allow [1:59:40] Pecley Media, for example, to assign this to your third priority. [1:59:44] So what I want, what we would like from you is direction on this one, whether we should [1:59:50] or should not allow subleasing or assignment. [1:59:54] But it requires our consent of the less, or wouldn't it? [1:59:58] consent, but it's better to say we won't allow it, and if you're not going to do it, we'll [2:00:05] start over with someone else. [2:00:07] Well, just a thought on that, and I mean, I can't be completely off base, so tell me [2:00:13] if I am. [2:00:17] To me, the allowance of the sub-lease would allow him, because we already have permission [2:00:25] to use if he doesn't individually feel like he can pull it off as a person, the [2:00:31] Bechley media can still have someone else be the person on the motorcycle. [2:00:35] Yeah that wouldn't be an assignment. That wouldn't be an assignment okay. But I'm [2:00:40] just wondering if this if we went through all of this and got it all there and then [2:00:46] they decide they can't pull it off and they would like to go to REO wouldn't it [2:00:50] would be easier just to allow it. We'd have all this work already done. If they [2:00:55] They want to go to REO, that works. [2:00:57] The problem is, is that they want to go with someone, for example, that didn't even participate. [2:01:02] That's okay. [2:01:03] And it does say that we have to granted permission in writing, but I'm just going to tell you [2:01:10] from a legal standpoint, it's better to recite why we're not going to permit it because you've [2:01:16] gone through a selection process already. [2:01:18] That makes sense to me, thanks for it. [2:01:21] All the lights went off too. [2:01:24] I guess I'm just going to state the obvious for folks that may be tuning in remember this is just this side of the Canyon and [2:01:33] And what we're talking about the land on this side of the Canyon [2:01:36] We're not talking about what's going to transpire on the Jerome side the north side [2:01:41] That's a whole different follow-backs for the Beckley media company. They need to work with those individuals again [2:01:47] I know that's obvious to us, but I think it's important to say [2:01:51] And that's a very good point. [2:01:53] So maybe an understanding of how this lease was drafted, it was drafted with considerable [2:01:59] influence from the state lease that was provided. [2:02:04] The state did a really good job in drafting their lease. [2:02:06] We took their lease, we took the pertinent parts of that lease, and we incorporated it [2:02:10] in our so that there was a lot of similarities moving forward. [2:02:14] We have forwarded this lease to the other government entities that would have jurisdiction in some [2:02:19] of the surrounding areas. [2:02:20] So that they may use this too as a template and a starting point moving forward so that [2:02:24] we all have some basic requirements. [2:02:28] So when you're looking at the $10 million of insurance policy, maybe that's something [2:02:32] to where Jerome County say, hey, we want to be labeled as an assigned as well. [2:02:37] And so then we're starting to take all of the consistencies and we're able to make a [2:02:41] process that is more user friendly than having nine different processes from nine different [2:02:47] entities. [2:02:48] Just a couple of items I'll throw out maybe as food for thought as we think through this some more. [2:03:00] There's a section here about reclamation of the land. [2:03:04] And one thing that occurred to me is technically the dirt pile now is somewhat historical. [2:03:15] And not knowing exactly what Beckley Media's plan is for modifications out there. [2:03:21] And we might want to think about what state we would like the jump to be in at the conclusion [2:03:28] of the event because I'm not sure that Ed Beckley jumped here in 2014 is as historical [2:03:37] and as much of an attraction perhaps as evil, can evil jump here in 1974 or maybe there's [2:03:44] some combination of that. [2:03:45] So perhaps it's just something to keep in mind about how we define what state we want [2:03:50] the jump site itself, but back in. [2:03:54] The other question I have is, should we [2:03:56] give some consideration to a monetary lease rate [2:04:03] for during the planning stage, assuming [2:04:07] that the event never occurs? [2:04:09] So if none of the improvements ever happen, [2:04:11] none of the activity ever happens down the road, [2:04:15] should there be some compensation in that earlier stage? [2:04:19] So it's like it's $5,000 ground lease [2:04:24] plus all this other stuff, or something like that. [2:04:29] Just a couple of thoughts that I had to keep in mind of. [2:04:33] Good food for that? [2:04:36] Chris, don't you? [2:04:37] I want to make sure, Fritz, that a third party claim [2:04:40] for property damage or anything like that [2:04:43] would be covered under the terms of this $10 million bonding. [2:04:48] A third party claim against? [2:04:50] Well, let's say if Katie and Rob had damaged [2:04:53] under their property on the North side, [2:04:55] are they, they're not even peripherally involved now [2:04:59] with Beckley, but their property was damaged in some way. [2:05:03] Yeah, so they, well, I would say, [2:05:08] so we're not trying to protect the world, [2:05:09] we're trying to protect Twin Falls. [2:05:13] So this goes as far as what happens in Twin Falls, [2:05:15] it's not gonna reach across the canyon. [2:05:20] So that same question though, but suppose it happens to Gary Storrer's property next door to the jump site. [2:05:29] Damage to Gary Storrer's property by Beckley Media. [2:05:33] By no. [2:05:34] So the real estate town and thus through Gary's fence and goes out to get a nice view of the place. [2:05:40] So theoretically under the bonding, the bonding would take care of that, not the insurance. [2:05:47] But only on Twin Falls side. [2:05:51] side. I think so. We don't have your [2:05:57] station over there. I'm hoping that they'll [2:06:04] meet with Jerome County, for example, and [2:06:06] they'll have something similar to this in [2:06:09] a special event permit that would grant [2:06:12] them the same rights on that side as on [2:06:15] this side. Might make a note of that, [2:06:17] Commissioner Morley. I guess it just goes [2:06:23] right back to what I said earlier. This is [2:06:25] about Twin Falls side. And again, that's why [2:06:30] I really appreciate Commissioner Morley being here. [2:06:33] Sean, I have a question about the monetary piece, [2:06:36] the $5,000, and I know you just threw that out. [2:06:39] What's the purpose of that just so that I can get [2:06:42] right in my head around, is that not for public safety [2:06:45] or our time and effort or what's, what's, [2:06:49] and I just throw it out there. [2:06:50] So for example, the state lease is $25,000 a year [2:06:53] if you do nothing ever, plus 5% of the take [2:06:58] of the take of the event and 3% of the residual [2:07:01] and perpetuity and, I don't know, [2:07:04] I just throw it out there, perhaps it's a good faith payment? [2:07:08] Perhaps it's a, you know, you're never gonna do [2:07:12] any of these other things and, you know, [2:07:14] maybe it's in addition to, you're gonna compensate us [2:07:18] for the time that we've spent working on this [2:07:20] through the planning stage or, I don't know, [2:07:22] I just throw it out as a possibility. [2:07:24] Well, I appreciate you clarifying that. [2:07:26] I just need to know where you were going with it. [2:07:29] So thank you. [2:07:31] Sean Burger. [2:07:32] So I have a question about Travis, [2:07:35] when you're talking about the conversation [2:07:37] with the prosecutor's office [2:07:38] and should there be, you know, above and beyond crime [2:07:43] or whatever, how do we define this horrible crime spree [2:07:49] happened in town because of your event [2:07:51] therefore you're responsible for covering that? [2:07:54] And that right there is the question that is being tough [2:07:57] as to define on how you move it forward. [2:08:00] And so what, in my conversations with the prosecutor's office, [2:08:05] we've asked, and they recognize that too, [2:08:07] and we understand what we're trying to prevent, [2:08:12] which is an inundation of the court system [2:08:14] as a result of this event occurring in Twin Falls. [2:08:19] We're struggling with what that looks like. [2:08:22] And so I've invited Grant to put together [2:08:25] whatever he can put together, [2:08:27] and we're happy to work with him on that. [2:08:28] And then after that, we would present it [2:08:30] as part of just in this inclusion. [2:08:33] Because like I shared with Grant, [2:08:35] I'm the last person you want to be talking [2:08:37] about the court system, because I'm not an attorney, [2:08:39] the person to talk about the prosecution, [2:08:42] because I've never been involved in that, [2:08:44] and jail is the place I had never hoped to go. [2:08:46] So, right, so those are all things [2:08:48] that I'm not familiar with, [2:08:50] But there are people who are that we're hoping to provide [2:08:53] some level of guidance. [2:08:55] Fritz and I have had that exact same question about [2:08:57] how do you determine that this event was directly attached [2:09:00] related to that? [2:09:01] And we don't have an answer to that right now. [2:09:03] But we think it's important to recognize that it is an [2:09:06] important concern of the prosecutor's office. [2:09:09] And what we're trying to do is include all of our partners [2:09:14] in the city of Twin Falls area that may be adversely [2:09:19] impacted from this activity. [2:09:21] I'd be curious to see if there are any [2:09:23] maybe precedents of other events like this staged [2:09:29] in more public places. [2:09:30] I guess I differentiate this a little bit from a, [2:09:33] you know, it's not a football game in a stadium. [2:09:35] It's not a confined space. [2:09:37] It's sort of, it's kind of in a confined space, [2:09:40] but it's not. [2:09:41] And you know, I know there are lots of other events [2:09:44] that occur in downtown New York City [2:09:47] on the pier in San Francisco and I'd just be curious how you how you really [2:09:54] define that. I mean that's like saying I was driving here on to see the event and [2:10:00] I crashed into a carload of people in Mountain Home. Therefore the event caused [2:10:06] this terrible thing that I did and you ought to pay for the prosecution of that. [2:10:13] I think it's a good question. I just can't help but think of doing some sort of survey. [2:10:20] While you were here and you committed your crime, were you here for A, B, or C? [2:10:26] One of the things that was, since this does talk about the beginning, we talked about [2:10:34] competition earlier and things like that, and Sean just listed the state's lease and his thoughts of [2:10:42] Maybe we should have a down payment and those types of things. [2:10:46] The state's least, and I'm using the numbers that came from Beckley Media. [2:10:51] I'm not, these aren't numbers I came up with, there's the numbers that they suggested that [2:10:55] they're negotiating to sell this deal for potentially $10 million. [2:11:00] The state's wealthy upfront is a half a million dollars, well, the other million you've already [2:11:07] collected. [2:11:08] And so it starts putting that $1.8 million in a little more perspective for them. [2:11:12] still don't think we get there but the state's gonna get if he sells it for 10 [2:11:16] minute they're getting another half million just because and they're providing [2:11:21] anything before that except for the land and that goes back to the katie's [2:11:27] question about state land I'm assuming that has a lot to do with what their [2:11:32] lease looks like and if they can fence it and say this is our closed for these [2:11:36] number of days and the state say agrees it's kind of like if I've got my [2:11:39] cattle on state land it doesn't mean that everybody or dog can come and have an [2:11:44] event and didn't like where my cattle are without me having some control over it so [2:11:48] on state lands that I lease from the state so again I probably have to do [2:11:53] what the police says and I just gathered a bunch of lights and I'm sorry I don't [2:11:57] know who was first shot or where back was first because I forgot my questions [2:11:59] we're back thank you Sean thank you Mayor actually you bring up a good point [2:12:04] And our refrain from being sleazy or a hustler this week. [2:12:09] And I, but that's why I'm more comfortable with, [2:12:12] with royalties or, or that sort of compensation. [2:12:18] Because then, if they make the money on the event, [2:12:21] it comes in, we can use it for these expenses for the park. [2:12:24] It's not asking for an upfront amount. [2:12:27] And so that's, and I'm merely joking about, you know, [2:12:31] the hustling, but. [2:12:33] But no, I actually, that I guess is why I'm more comfortable with putting a royalty or [2:12:41] some sort of residual income for the city in our lease because I think the state lease, [2:12:47] as you said, Travis, I think the state lease is well written and well thought out. [2:12:51] And I do think it provides a good template for what we should be doing. [2:12:56] So maybe just to quickly follow on that, maybe there's some happy medium between do these improvements or [2:13:04] imperative and we want those done and in addition some some piece on the back and [2:13:09] further improvements might be an option. I remember my question and and I don't [2:13:15] know quite how we get there but I think having some input into the broadcast [2:13:20] partnership and opportunities for the community branding might be something to [2:13:27] discuss with them. Again I'm not sure that that's quite a provision that the [2:13:34] at least, but maybe something else to throw on the plate [2:13:37] of having that conversation with Beckley Media. [2:13:40] I know we received a copy of one letter from a, [2:13:45] I'm assuming it was kind of like a production company [2:13:47] or something, but didn't quite understand what that meant [2:13:50] as far as what kind of broadcasting of this might there be [2:13:56] and what opportunities might there be [2:13:58] for the city to be involved in that marketing opportunity. [2:14:04] And again, maybe that's just a conversation to have with them. [2:14:06] I don't know that it needs to be a provision of use of the land. [2:14:10] But I think that's important because that's one of, [2:14:13] one of kind of the stated items we've talked about is the, [2:14:16] the opportunity to promote the community and the brand of the, [2:14:20] not only Twin Falls, but the region. [2:14:23] Donald. [2:14:24] Well, first of all, Rebecca, I appreciate you saying that you're joking [2:14:26] because I'm the one that made the comment regarding feeling. [2:14:29] And it was me that was feeling sleazy. [2:14:32] And hopefully you never think that I said that about anyone else [2:14:34] Council. I'm going to reiterate or repeat what I've said before. I think that for us [2:14:42] to be able to go down the line of getting some some trail improvements and other [2:14:46] improvements for public infrastructure makes perfect sense to me but I just [2:14:50] don't feel that we have the mission of making a profit. The municipalities, the [2:14:56] city of Twin Falls isn't here to make profit. This is my perspective. I want as [2:15:00] as much profit as possible for our area business folks. [2:15:04] Those are the folks that need to make profit. [2:15:08] And if they can make some profit off of this event, good. [2:15:11] But I'm just not a big advocate of us finding ways [2:15:15] of doing residuals and all these kind of things. [2:15:18] And again, that's just my perspective. [2:15:22] And again, I respectfully disagree. [2:15:25] You can? [2:15:26] So anyway, we have any other lights for item number five. [2:15:31] Seeing none, I didn't have any comments about item number five. [2:15:37] Yes, ma'am. [2:15:39] Need to come forward again. [2:15:42] Somebody else tuned in late to give your name as well. [2:15:48] Victoria Wakewood. [2:15:49] And my concern is in terms of living on Skyline and knowing [2:15:56] that more than likely we are going to involuntarily [2:16:01] be a part of this event. [2:16:03] and we are speaking of a bond. [2:16:07] And I would like to see that that neighborhood, [2:16:10] which I don't know if any of you are really familiar with, [2:16:13] Skyline, there's a lot of integrity. [2:16:16] There's a very close knit neighborhood. [2:16:20] We have gatherings three, four times a year. [2:16:24] I want to maintain that. [2:16:26] And in order to really feel good about this event happening, [2:16:31] which is happening, I'd like to see that we don't pay the price, okay, that we are happily [2:16:41] part of maybe perhaps that bond issue that covers some of that so that whatever involvement [2:16:50] we have maintains that neighborhood and maintains that integrity of the neighborhood. [2:16:57] So, that's my comment and my concern and why I continue to come to these meetings and [2:17:04] want to stay involved is to be more of a voice for our neighborhood and maintaining the integrity of our neighborhood going forward. [2:17:16] Thank you. [2:17:20] Sure, Commissioner Marley. [2:17:22] Sure, I think it was a misconception in the last meeting that we had at CSI. [2:17:28] L.M. said that we the lady from the BLM said we did not have a lease. Do you remember them? [2:17:35] We do have a 17 years left on our lease. And they've told us that we can go ahead and [2:17:40] lease up again. But I don't know who that lady was and I don't know why she said that. [2:17:46] But it was extremely embarrassing. And I've tried to find her. I've gone to the bill, [2:17:52] I've gone to the bill and offices and tried to hunt her down. [2:17:55] Find out who she is. [2:17:56] And I have no idea who she was, [2:17:59] but what she told you guys was absolutely false. [2:18:02] Thank you. [2:18:03] Thank you. [2:18:07] In the other public I've been on some other item [2:18:10] that somebody would like to talk about, [2:18:12] Katie, January 6th. [2:18:19] January 6th. [2:18:21] It will be the next discussion item [2:18:23] that's our next schedule meeting, okay? [2:18:29] Mr. Mayor, members of the council just a couple of quick items and as I relate to [2:18:36] Councilman Talkington during the break and the recess one of the questions that he [2:18:40] had asked was whether or not the city owns the titles of the property where [2:18:44] station two is located and it we do. It was fire station two. It is the only [2:18:50] parcel that we do and did retain. All of the others were deeded back to or the [2:18:55] deed was transferred to the college of southern Idaho for the rotary or for the [2:18:59] the Armory and for the baseball field. [2:19:02] Or to the State for the Armory and CSI for the baseball field. [2:19:06] Just a quick note that the City Hall will be closed tomorrow. [2:19:10] And also on the 25th in observation of Christmas. [2:19:15] I will be out of the office the balance of this week. [2:19:17] I will be in the office sporadically next week. [2:19:20] In my absence, Lori Race will be the acting city manager. [2:19:27] Our next meeting is scheduled to occur on January 6th. [2:19:31] Remember we are going to be meeting at 4 o'clock. [2:19:34] We'll meet in here. [2:19:35] We will make sure that a special meeting notice is published and then we are going to take [2:19:39] a tour of the 911 Dispatch Center. [2:19:43] Lieutenant Craig Statz is going to provide that tour and then we estimate it's going [2:19:48] to take about a half hour for that and then we're going to come in here and talk about [2:19:51] our dispatch capabilities. [2:19:53] We hope to dispel some maybe some rumors that were and had been presented in the past and [2:19:59] want to make sure that the community and the council has a good comfort level with the capabilities [2:20:04] of our dispatch center moving forward. [2:20:07] Thank you, Travis. [2:20:08] City Council. [2:20:09] Travis, I want to repeat your January 13th one on the city works. [2:20:14] January 13th, 3.35, I believe, is the open house for the public's works, new building out on [2:20:21] South Washington. [2:20:22] 3.35 looking at my calendar and that is open the public as well as council and [2:20:29] that is in so having a little trouble finding in their mind. Let's think lock [2:20:34] a seat and go across the street that's probably the easiest way to find it [2:20:38] few minutes. Well it's just most people if they give them a landmark it's a lot [2:20:45] easier than giving them an address so anyone else on the council have [2:20:48] something they would like to cover. Seeing that in the weird journey my [2:20:53] Christmas everyone. Merry Christmas.