Oversight Archive: City Council meeting, 2014-02-18, recording 1 (started 17:00) Machine transcript (faster-whisper base.en), not checked word for word; the Pledge of Allegiance is shown in its standard wording. The recording is the record. Times are time into the recording. Passages with private details are muted in the audio and marked here. The audio on the page below was re-encoded by software from the video the agency posted. Check any passage against that audio before relying on it. Page: https://oversightarchive.org/twin-falls-id/meetings/2014-02-18/ [0:05:22] All the meeting of the Twin Falls City Council Order is February 20, February 18, 2014, and [0:05:29] I'm going to try to make it through tonight's meeting with my voice, so bear with me. [0:05:33] We always start our meetings off with Pledge of Allegiance, so those of you wishing to join [0:05:37] us, please rise. [0:05:39] I pledge allegiance to the Flag of the United States of America, and to the Republic for which it stands, one Nation under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all. [0:05:59] I'd like to confirm that we do have a quorum and a yes welcome to friends and family of our officers tonight and of course the rest of our community that's here came out tonight as well. [0:06:12] Travis, do I confirm we had a quorum? [0:06:17] Yes I mention to you that I have a cold right now, a really bad cold. [0:06:21] So bear with me tonight, folks. [0:06:23] We do have a quorum of Council, [0:06:24] all seven members are here this evening. [0:06:27] Travis, do we have any amendments to the agenda? [0:06:29] Mr. Mayor, members of the Council staff [0:06:31] would ask that you remove item number seven [0:06:33] from the discussion tonight. [0:06:34] We'll bring that at a subsequent meeting. [0:06:36] Perfect, thank you, Travis. [0:06:39] Moving on to the first item we like to bring in [0:06:43] anyone that would like to have any comments [0:06:46] or have concerns or any thoughts they'd like to bring [0:06:49] to the city council briefly at the beginning [0:06:52] of tonight's meeting. [0:06:54] You certainly can go ahead Travis. [0:06:56] Mr. Mayor, in order to amend the agenda, [0:07:00] the council should take a vote. [0:07:01] Okay, thank you. [0:07:03] Council, it wishes for the amendment. [0:07:07] Move to amend as suggested by the city manager. [0:07:10] Thank you. [0:07:12] We have a motion on the floor by Chris Talkington, [0:07:16] seconded by Greg Lanting to amend the agenda. [0:07:19] do we have anything further on that amendment council? [0:07:24] I see no lies at Leila Roll Call vote with Susan Hawkins. [0:07:27] Yes. [0:07:28] Jim Munn. [0:07:29] Yes. [0:07:29] Sean Bericher. [0:07:30] Yes. [0:07:31] Chris Tawkington. [0:07:32] Yes. [0:07:33] Greg Lanting. [0:07:33] Yes. [0:07:34] Don Hall. [0:07:34] Yes. [0:07:35] Rebecca Masleka. [0:07:36] Yes. [0:07:37] Motion passes 7-0. [0:07:38] Thank you, Travis, for bringing that to my attention. [0:07:40] You might have to do that a couple of times tonight. [0:07:44] Again, we have a chance for the general public [0:07:46] to come make comments in front of the council. [0:07:49] If it's not something on the agenda already, certainly we're going to have some discussion [0:07:55] about those items and then we'll always open it up for public comment after the agenda [0:08:00] as well. [0:08:01] So if there's anyone interested in coming forward, again, no mad rush to the podium, [0:08:09] so we'll move on to the consent calendar, council wishes. [0:08:13] Great planning. [0:08:14] I move approval of the consent calendar. [0:08:19] Second. [0:08:20] motion on the floor by Greg 19 seconded by Suzanne Hawkins and I see a light. [0:08:27] Rebecca Milsoy. [0:08:28] Thank you Mayor. [0:08:29] I have a quick question on item number three. [0:08:32] In the staff report, it's an engineering question. [0:08:35] It talks about one of the projects as installing stop bars to decrease the failure to yield accidents along those streets. [0:08:48] I'm just not familiar with stop bars, but just in case any of the public as well aren't could you tell us about this project and [0:08:55] I'm not familiar expect. Yeah, I'm not familiar with stop bars either [0:08:58] But I know that Troy VTech probably is and Troy can thank you [0:09:04] Troy VTech is the city engineer the stop bars is those little white bars before you get to a sidewalk or crossing area [0:09:10] They are where your car shouldn't cross in order to protect the public and the crosswalk [0:09:15] And it's just that thermal plastic that the streets of paints are or you lay down [0:09:24] Okay, so it's just a marking. It's not actually a raised bar. Okay. Thank you [0:09:31] It's not a little rebar going across the street stopping people [0:09:35] I see no further lights. So the other roll call vote, please Jim. Yes [0:09:42] Sean Burger. Yes. Yes. Yes [0:09:46] Yes, Don Hall. Yes, Rebecca Melsweka. Yes, Suzanne Hawkins. Yes, seven to zero motion passes. [0:09:57] Chris talking. I'd just like to bring up to catch what we just approved were the minutes of the last four city council meetings and [0:10:06] complimented La Ila earlier day and hope the council concurs with death. That's we put her on the overdrive for this last month with our Canyon Jump [0:10:16] business and everybody that read through the minutes knows the complexity of having accuracy [0:10:22] and the context for the meetings, but she's done a wonderful job on this. [0:10:28] I can't agree with all my motions, how they were presented, but I guess truth has that [0:10:33] constant. [0:10:34] Well said, Chris, thank you for bringing that to you, and tonight, wholeheartedly concur. [0:10:42] We're moving down to the items for consideration, and the first item on the agenda is a presentation [0:10:48] presentation of post-certificates to the following individuals before the Twin Falls City Council officer Brad beige [0:10:57] Officer Dennis so Gevic [0:11:03] You even have music to your name [0:11:06] Congratulations officer Jerry Hutcheson [0:11:10] officer Dan Heil [0:11:12] detective Nate Sylvester and [0:11:14] and Detective Eric Barzi. [0:11:17] We have Chief Pike, Captain Anthony Barnhart, [0:11:20] and Captain Brian Career making the presentations tonight. [0:11:23] Welcome, Captain. [0:11:24] Thank you. [0:11:28] Good evening, Mr. Mayor and members of the City Council, [0:11:30] and thank you for giving us this opportunity [0:11:32] to recognize and honor the achievements of our officers [0:11:35] tonight. [0:11:36] It is vitally important to us that we have a well-trained [0:11:38] professional police department capable of providing [0:11:42] the best possible public service to our community that we can. [0:11:45] and I think that everyone would agree with that. [0:11:48] Tonight we will be recognizing Officer Brad Beish [0:11:51] and Dennis Soljubic with their basic certificate, [0:11:55] Officer Dan Heil and Jerry Hutchinson, [0:11:57] with their intermediate certificate, [0:11:59] Detective Nate Sylvester with his advanced certificate, [0:12:02] and Detective Eric Parsey with his master's certificate. [0:12:06] It takes hundreds of training hours, [0:12:08] college credits, and time and service [0:12:11] to achieve these certificates. [0:12:13] So now I ask that the police officers please come forward. [0:12:18] I would also ask that the Chief of Police Brian Pike and Mayor Hall please come forward to help present these certificates. [0:12:29] First we will be presented to Bradley Beige. [0:12:31] Bradley was hired by the Twin Falls Police Department on January 22nd, 2013 as a full time police officer. [0:12:38] Brad was born in Twin Falls, Idaho, graduated from Twin Falls High School, and he attended the CSI law enforcement program. [0:12:45] graduated from there in July of 2011. Brad has coached 7th grade and 8th grade [0:12:51] Holyrie football programs teaching them the rules and fundamentals since August of [0:12:57] 2010. Brad is an adult leader with the Boy Scouts of America and sits on the Eagle [0:13:03] Scouts review board. It is with great pleasure that we present Brad with the [0:13:07] basic certificate from the State of Idaho Peace Officer Standards and Training [0:13:11] Council. The next officer is Officer Dennis Sulyovich. He was hired by the [0:13:26] Twin Falls Police Department as a full-time police officer on November 26th 2012. [0:13:31] Dennis was born in Bosnia. He and his family left the country when he was four [0:13:37] years old due to civil war and moved to Germany. He and his family later moved [0:13:41] to Kennewick Washington in 2000 where Dennis attended middle school and high [0:13:45] school. Dennis chose to pursue his interest in law enforcement and attended [0:13:49] Columbia Basin College, where he graduated with an associate's in Applied Science and Criminal Justice. [0:13:55] Prior to his employment with the department, Dennis worked as a corrections officer for two years [0:14:01] with the Washington State Penitentiary, Walla Walla, Washington. [0:14:06] Dennis attended and successfully completed the Post Patrol Academy on March 15, 2013. [0:14:12] It is with great pleasure that we present Dennis with the basic certificate from the State of Idaho Peace Officer Standards and Training Council. [0:14:19] Dan Heil was hired by the Twin Falls Police Department on March 22nd, 2006 as a full-time [0:14:37] police officer. Dan was born in Twin Falls, Idaho and attended a private middle school and [0:14:42] eventually graduated from Twin Falls High School. Prior to his employment with the Twin [0:14:46] Falls Police Department, Dan worked for Dell computers and Shucks Automotive Supply. During [0:14:52] his employment with the department, Dan has become an instructor in several law enforcement [0:14:55] disciplines. Dan has worked with many different organizations in the community as a police [0:15:00] officer and has a special place in his heart for people with developmental disabilities. [0:15:04] It is a great pleasure that we present Dan with the intermediate certificate from the State [0:15:10] of Idaho Peace Officers and Standards Training Council. Jerry Hutchinson was hired by the [0:15:24] Twin Falls Police Department on March 13, 2006 as a full-time police officer. Jerry participated [0:15:31] in the Twin Falls Police Department's Reserve Officer Program from July 2004 to March 2006. [0:15:37] Jerry was born in Wickenburg, Arizona. He attended school in Las Vegas, Nevada, and also in [0:15:42] Twin Falls. Jerry has had a very diverse employment history. When in high school, he [0:15:49] worked in his family's mind. He then worked with Hamilton Manufacturing as a custom service [0:15:54] technician representing and training different companies about the application and science [0:15:59] of their products. [0:16:01] He and his family are very involved with sports [0:16:04] and outdoors activities. [0:16:06] It is with great pleasure that we present Jerry [0:16:08] with the intermediate certificate from the State of Idaho, [0:16:11] Peace Officers and Standards Training Council. [0:16:33] Good to be Mayor and City Council. [0:16:35] As a commander of the Investigation Division, [0:16:38] I am honored tonight to present two certificates [0:16:42] to a highly diverse and skilled work group. [0:16:46] If I can have Detective Nate Sylvester and Eric Barzi, [0:16:50] please come forward. [0:17:01] The Advanced Certification, in order [0:17:04] for a police officer to receive this Advanced Certification, [0:17:07] they must achieve a combination of college credits, certified [0:17:09] post-training hours, and years of service. [0:17:13] Detective Nate Sylvester was hired by the Twin Falls Police [0:17:16] Department on January 3, 2006. [0:17:20] Nate was born and raised in Twin Falls, [0:17:22] graduated from Twin Falls High School in 1999. [0:17:25] He attended Ricks College and is now attending the College of Southern Idaho, where at the end of this spring semester, he will receive his associate's degree in criminal justice. [0:17:36] During his employment with the police department, Native served as a field training officer, a SWAT member, a detective in the narcotics unit, and he is currently assigned as a case detective in the criminal investigations division. [0:17:49] Nate is a post-certified ground fighting instructor, a reactive impact weapons instructor, he and [0:17:55] his eight year old daughter, Haley, and his significant other, Melissa Rowe, enjoyed coaching, [0:18:01] especially, Haley's basketball team. [0:18:04] It is a great pleasure that we present Nate with his advanced certification from the State [0:18:09] of Idaho Peace Officer Standards and Training Council. [0:18:29] The master's certification is reserved for officers below the rank of sergeant and who [0:18:35] You have consciously decided to focus career efforts on line functions such as patrol and [0:18:40] investigations. [0:18:41] Officers must possess the advanced certification, have completed 1500 hours of post-certified [0:18:46] training, and completed a minimum of 15 years of full-time law enforcement service. [0:18:52] Detective Eric Barzi began his career with the Twin Falls Police Department on January 6, [0:18:57] 2003. [0:18:58] He was born and raised in Idaho Falls and attended Idaho State University, where he completed [0:19:03] the law enforcement program in 1998. [0:19:06] Prior to his employment with the Twin Falls Police Department, [0:19:10] Eric was employed by the Buell Police Department [0:19:12] for three years. [0:19:14] In October 2009, Eric was reassigned [0:19:16] to the Criminal Investigations Division, [0:19:18] where he continues to provide excellent customer service [0:19:21] while investigating felony crimes. [0:19:24] Eric married his wife, Danielle, in 2004, [0:19:27] and then adopted as two sons, Brody and Morgan, [0:19:29] who were six and eight years old at the time. [0:19:33] It is a great pleasure that we present Eric Barzi with the Master's certification from the [0:19:37] State of Idaho Peace Officer Standards and Training Council. [0:20:03] I don't know if I remember having so many at once before. [0:20:07] What a great opportunity for us to be here and thank you for your service, all of you. [0:20:11] Greg Lenny. [0:20:12] I would like to thank all of them for your service as well and I was interested in the [0:20:17] wealth of knowledge from different things. [0:20:21] I mean, Jerry, if I ever decide to go mining, [0:20:23] I know I'm going to talk to. [0:20:25] And then also the involvement in the community at all, [0:20:28] but I really appreciate that. [0:20:29] That it represented our city very well. [0:20:32] Proud of you. [0:20:34] Thank you, Greg. [0:20:35] All right, gentlemen, thank you. [0:20:36] And I'm assuming half our audience will go. [0:20:39] So we'll give you just a moment. [0:20:43] Thank you, friends and family, for sharing this time [0:20:45] with your loved ones. [0:20:57] It'd be nice. [0:21:03] I think we can get started with the next item. [0:21:05] It's a request from local 1556 to support legislation being proposed by the Idaho Legislature. [0:21:13] And we have Ed Morris coming up. [0:21:16] Ed, are you a fireman, driver, captain, to fill me in? [0:21:20] I'm a driver with the Twin Falls Fire Department and president of local 1556. [0:21:25] Perfect, welcome, Ed. [0:21:29] Hi, Stan, before you on behalf of Twin Falls Firefighter, Local 1556 and [0:21:34] professional firefighters of Idaho asking your support on Senate bill 1273. [0:21:41] This is presumptive illness legislation that covers firefighters on 15 different types of cancers that firefighters are known. [0:21:51] And it's been proven that we have a greater risk of attracting this disease than a normal public. [0:21:59] There have been many, many studies through Johns Hopkins [0:22:04] universities and other big medical schools [0:22:07] across the country that have shown this. [0:22:10] And that's kind of what we're asking for. [0:22:15] We've been working on similar legislation [0:22:17] for the past 10 years. [0:22:19] It's been more and more serious the last few years. [0:22:23] We've been working with the Industrial Commission, [0:22:27] some private insurance industries, [0:22:29] and some other board members on some subcommittees [0:22:32] to come up with the right language for our state, and we believe we've gotten there. [0:22:39] We've modeled our language after New Mexico and some other states that already have this [0:22:43] legislation in place, so we worked with the Industrial Commission, like I said, to tweak [0:22:51] it, to fit Idaho a little bit better. [0:22:55] That's what we're asking for, just a little bit of background about kind of our job and [0:23:02] the risk to go with it. [0:23:03] I think you all know we have a hazardous occupation, [0:23:06] but when we go into fires, we take extreme caution and pride [0:23:11] in using all of our PPE and any protective equipment [0:23:15] that's given to us. [0:23:17] But when we crawl into a structure fire, for example, [0:23:21] we go in, we fight the fire, we get out, [0:23:23] but some of you might know that went to our fire ops. [0:23:26] For about the next week, every time you take a shower [0:23:29] or sweat, you smell smoke, and you can, [0:23:32] As your body's releasing those toxins, you know that even with the protective equipment that we have, it still absorbs into your skin and into your body. [0:23:41] So we're just asking for support on this presumptive legislation. [0:23:47] Council, any questions for talking? [0:23:49] Yeah, it's very interesting. [0:23:51] I doubt that anybody would dispute that this is a hazardous profession that you're engaged in. [0:23:57] The mechanics of, is it House Bill 1273, or Senate Bill 1273? [0:24:04] What amends the workers comp act of the state or the federal level? [0:24:10] What would that result in or what is the change? [0:24:14] What it does now is if a firefighter comes down with one [0:24:18] of these certain types of cancers, it's presumed they got it off the job [0:24:22] and we have to provide proof of what incident we may have gotten that from [0:24:27] while we're on the job, which is almost impossible. [0:24:31] This presumption would change the law [0:24:34] to presume that we got it on the job, [0:24:36] unless it can be proven that we could have gotten it somewhere [0:24:39] else. [0:24:39] So for example, if some firefighter came down with lung cancer, [0:24:43] but it was proven that he smoked cigarettes two backs [0:24:46] a day for 10 years, then he still wouldn't [0:24:50] be approved under the workman's comp to get it, [0:24:52] because it's easily shown that he could have gotten it somewhere [0:24:56] It just changes it so it's a little bit easier for a firefighter to be able to get those services covered under Workman's Comp. [0:25:06] But the study that we've done in the last decade, it shows that there were four cases that could have been approved if the legislation was changed [0:25:15] and of those they believe only two of them would have went through. [0:25:19] So it's not a it's not going to be a big impact to this day but it makes it a [0:25:24] little easier for firefighters to be able to to fight to fight if they get one of [0:25:28] those diseases. If I just follow up on that at least reading the literature [0:25:33] though your say there's still a burden of proof to under the current workers comp [0:25:38] to provide a specific response to a fire for a diagnosis of something that [0:25:47] involves a sickness from asbestos, benzene, vinyl chloride, or formaldehyde. [0:25:58] I mean, those are such specific contaminants to your lung and your body, [0:26:03] but they're still the burden of proof to have a specific cause, a specific time event. [0:26:12] I don't know exactly how the legal system looks at that, [0:26:17] But the burden of proof lies on us to prove we got it here. [0:26:20] So we have to be able to tie it to a certain event or events. [0:26:24] And I don't know how many of these older houses we go on that have asbestos in them. [0:26:31] And we can try to prove it that way. [0:26:34] But the burden of proof lies on us and it's extremely hard right now. [0:26:39] Well, it still would, but it would make a little bit easier to call it to prove your case, [0:26:46] I guess, huh? [0:26:48] Yeah, this bill just makes it a little bit easier. [0:26:50] It's still going to be not, it's not a gimme, [0:26:54] but okay, you have this now, you got it on the job. [0:26:57] It just makes it where that has to be proven. [0:26:59] We didn't, instead of that we did. [0:27:04] Thank you. [0:27:05] Rebecca Milsica. [0:27:06] Thank you, Mayor. [0:27:07] Similarly, I have a question about the, [0:27:10] maybe the way that the origin of the cancer [0:27:13] or the illness is determined [0:27:14] and where the burden of proof lies. [0:27:16] It sounds like what you're saying. [0:27:18] The burden of proof is transitioned from being on the employee or the firefighter, and this amendment would actually put it on the city. [0:27:28] Would that be a correct summary? [0:27:30] Yes, if they were going to fight it and say yes, we think you got it somewhere else. [0:27:37] Travis, did you want to weigh in? [0:27:41] Well, I want to make it clear that this isn't necessarily a city. [0:27:47] It's more of a work comp issue in which the city would be engaged, but it's not. [0:27:51] or potentially engaged but it's not a place where the city would have to fight [0:27:58] against if you will against a decision made by workers comp or those type of [0:28:04] things so it's not us versus them it's more of a conversation that a [0:28:07] firefighter would go through the workers compensation process directly [0:28:13] through which is what the state of Idaho is I understand it is that correct it yeah [0:28:17] Right, so my question is then, just how does it change the burden of proof? [0:28:22] I mean, so the different cancers that are listed are brain cancer after 10 years, bladder cancer [0:28:28] after 12 years, kidney cancer after 15 years, and so on, is that how does this change, you [0:28:36] know, what a firefighter would do, say they developed non-Hodgkin's lymphoma after 15 years, [0:28:46] is the burden of proof? Does this change? Does this legislation change that it's the [0:28:51] firefighter's responsibility to have a doctor determine? I mean, our doctor's still [0:28:56] involved in determining the cause of these diseases? Yes, and it does change the [0:29:03] burden of proof from the firefighter where it currently is to, I guess, the [0:29:10] employer, if you want to say that way, or work competent. In one of our talking [0:29:15] point, it says that that's part of the proof that a position can sign off their lifestyle [0:29:23] could have caused this. [0:29:27] Thank you. [0:29:28] And then one more question on the cost summary. [0:29:31] It talks about the cost being with Workman's compensation and that's covered throughout [0:29:38] the whole state of Idaho. [0:29:40] So the cost, it talked about it being distributed amongst all of the cities. [0:29:45] So it's not specifically related to our specific fire department or [0:29:50] how many firefighters draw on this. [0:29:53] It's related to the entire state system, is that correct? [0:29:55] Yeah, it's based on the state-wide system. [0:29:57] And one thing that we found is the other states that have adopted this legislation. [0:30:01] They proposed similar rate changes that we proposed and [0:30:06] none of those states have actually seen a rate increase. [0:30:11] And do you know how long they've had this change in place? [0:30:14] varied. Some of them have had a burp between five and ten years and some of them are fairly [0:30:20] new. But I think New Mexico is one of the longest-standing ones and they have not seen [0:30:25] that rate change yet, but I don't know the exact dates of the job for the legislation. [0:30:30] And that was one other point we were making with the work comp being spread out that, [0:30:35] you know, if a firefighter actually did get this disease on the job, it's better to put that burden [0:30:43] And under the work comp system that's larger than on our city's blue grass or blue shield policies. [0:30:51] So we don't have to absorb those costs if they're actually on duty at the time when they get diagnosed. [0:30:58] Thank you. [0:30:59] Fritz, can I ask you a question? [0:31:04] Have you had a chance to review this legislation in its entirety and what's your impression? [0:31:12] So I have not seen the bill, I didn't see it in the packet. [0:31:16] from what I understand what he what he's saying is it just shifts the burden [0:31:22] of proof ordinarily in workers comp the worker who's been injured has to show [0:31:27] that they received an injury on the job and this creates a presumption so it [0:31:32] shifts the burden of proof to the employer to the workman's comp yet to [0:31:39] the state to prove that it was not caused on the job. Okay. I guess that's [0:31:47] And I'm in support of public service. [0:31:51] But I just don't feel like I have enough information here. [0:31:55] I haven't seen the actual bill. [0:31:57] I know that we have some background information. [0:32:00] But I don't feel like I can make a real educated decision right now. [0:32:04] That's my input. [0:32:06] Greg Manning. [0:32:08] I was actually going to make a motion of others. [0:32:11] Okay. [0:32:12] Other questions? [0:32:13] I certainly welcome to ask them. [0:32:14] I'll come back to you then. [0:32:16] Thank you, Mayor. [0:32:18] I too have questions in regards to this Senate bill, particularly before I would be feeling [0:32:25] comfortable on voting yes or no in support of the bill. [0:32:29] I would like to know precisely if there's any fiscal impact. [0:32:32] What the fiscal impact is on taxpayers throughout the state. [0:32:39] I would also, I know that, is there a component in this bill to eliminate or [0:32:45] stop fraudulent use of the bill? [0:32:48] I know back east, California, Palo Alto, had a problem with fraud. [0:32:53] New York City has had problems with fraud in this regard, so [0:32:56] I want to make sure that the bill has a component in place to ensure that there's [0:33:01] no fraud provisions and so forth. [0:33:04] So I guess in the final analysis, whereas I, [0:33:07] obviously as a public safety officer, [0:33:10] I would like to support this. [0:33:13] I do want more information. [0:33:15] So I'm not prepared to vote. [0:33:16] Yes or no on this. [0:33:17] Thank you. [0:33:18] Jim? [0:33:19] Chris, talking to me. [0:33:20] Yeah, I think we need to have more info. [0:33:22] If you can expedite getting that to us [0:33:25] that the next week of the city manager's office [0:33:28] so that we can study it, [0:33:29] I think it's not a matter of mistrust of intent, [0:33:33] but to make sure that we understand through due diligence our long-term responsibilities. [0:33:40] I might say that I'm extremely sympathetic in the Air Force who worked with nuclear weapons [0:33:46] and beryllium, and there are a number of people I work with that are now deceased because of [0:33:52] that. [0:33:53] The burden of proof remains entirely upon the individual, as it does with my fellow vets [0:33:59] serving of Vietnam and Asian Orange and all that catastrophe are resulting. [0:34:05] So if you provide us more information, I think we can act upon a more intelligent way in. [0:34:11] John Berger. [0:34:13] Yes, I was just going to comment so that the bill is available online. [0:34:17] I don't know if anybody had a chance to look that up. [0:34:19] So the estimates of the fiscal impact is approximately $48,500 to $165,000. [0:34:29] $65,000 total on government entities spread all over the cities and [0:34:34] fire districts in the state with no impact to the general fund. [0:34:39] And the bill is listed there, it's a pretty brief bill, actually, it's only three pages long. [0:34:44] And it just basically outlines the list of the presumptive diseases that are listed in the information there. [0:34:53] You know, I would be supportive of offering support for this bill tonight. [0:34:59] I think if the general sense of the council is they don't have enough information, [0:35:03] we probably don't want to move it forward to have that vote tonight. [0:35:06] But I think certainly protecting the health and safety of our employees is a critical importance to what we do as a council. [0:35:15] I think there is no question that you certainly work in a risk-filled environment. [0:35:21] And as I look at the list of other states that don't do this, [0:35:25] I see Idaho is racing to the bottom once again being one [0:35:29] of a handful of states that don't address any of these issues. [0:35:31] So I think it's certainly time to take the science [0:35:34] into account and address that. [0:35:37] I think the impact is minimal. [0:35:38] I think it shifts the burden of proof on that and would be supportive. [0:35:45] But again, I think of the general sense of the council is they don't have [0:35:47] that information and I'd probably should hold off on that. [0:35:50] Thanks, Sean. [0:35:52] Racing to the bottom, I'm going to use that, OK? [0:35:56] Rebecca Mills, so I get one of you. [0:35:59] Thank you, Mayor. [0:35:59] And I just want to say thank you to Ed. [0:36:01] I know that a few weeks ago you did send us a copy of that bill. [0:36:04] And it has been, I think, that was the beginning of the month. [0:36:07] And so I apologize that we didn't all get that in our packet. [0:36:12] But I did read it and looked at it. [0:36:14] And I think it's difficult for me and that it is so far outside [0:36:18] my area of expertise. [0:36:20] I have a sister in medical school, but I'm not there, [0:36:23] so, you know, and I certainly understand, you know, [0:36:26] after going through fire ops, that you definitely, [0:36:30] you know, have some diseases and some illnesses [0:36:32] associated with your work. [0:36:34] And so, you know, I'm not sure, you know, [0:36:37] with the information that I do have, [0:36:38] or if I could get more information, [0:36:40] that would really tell me to vote one way [0:36:42] or the other to support it, but I'm certainly supportive [0:36:45] of the fact that you do take increased risk to your health [0:36:50] with what you do every day. [0:36:52] And one of my questions would be what [0:36:55] is the impact of, and maybe larger cities, firefighters, [0:36:59] go on different types of events, or maybe more events. [0:37:02] And so those users that maybe drawing on the system more [0:37:07] than are folks in Twin Falls. [0:37:09] How does that affect the system as a whole? [0:37:14] but I'm certainly supportive of helping the firefighters [0:37:20] get what they need to get, [0:37:21] but certainly there would need to be [0:37:24] some sort of demonstration of cause, [0:37:28] and I think that's difficult in any case. [0:37:30] I mean, if you get lymphoma or you get cancer [0:37:34] of the esophagus or all of these things, [0:37:37] I don't even know if the doctors are able to say [0:37:39] you specifically got it here. [0:37:42] So I think it's a difficult task to determine, [0:37:46] but good luck with your legislation. [0:37:48] Okay, thank you. [0:37:48] Jim Monning. [0:37:49] Real quick question, time is of the essence. [0:37:52] Yeah, that was my question. [0:37:53] Yes, when is this going to be? [0:37:55] It goes to committee. [0:37:56] It goes to committee Thursday. [0:37:57] Okay, so if we would give you an answer [0:38:00] in the yay or nay Monday, is that too late? [0:38:03] No, that should be fine. [0:38:04] Okay, so Mayor, I would like to have this back [0:38:06] on the agenda if you're approval. [0:38:08] I agree with that. [0:38:09] Thank you. [0:38:09] That's a good point. [0:38:10] Great landing. [0:38:11] Well, I just, obviously I was getting ready to make a motion, [0:38:14] but if I don't have enough people, [0:38:16] people are worried about the exact wording [0:38:19] that things don't since doing it tonight. [0:38:21] But certainly we can talk all about whether we want [0:38:27] to support the firefighters, but this is a place [0:38:29] where we can actually support the firefighters. [0:38:31] So I don't think we can hide behind saying we like you guys, [0:38:35] but we're not going to help you. [0:38:37] This was obviously be a help, [0:38:38] so I'll be looking forward to voting for this next Monday night. [0:38:42] I will get you guys information, thank you. [0:38:45] And I think we, unlike our federal counterparts, [0:38:49] want to read the legislation before we sign off. [0:38:52] So, yeah, he gave it to us like a week ago. [0:38:55] I don't, I don't, I don't. [0:38:57] Yeah, we let him down, it's our problem. [0:38:59] He gave it to us, I read it a week ago. [0:39:01] But again, I still would like to read it before I vote on it. [0:39:04] I appreciate your presentation tonight. [0:39:06] All right, thank you. [0:39:08] Moving on to number three, present council [0:39:12] with an update regarding the Woodways site. [0:39:15] John Cateon. [0:39:17] Thank you, Mayor. [0:39:18] Good evening, Council. [0:39:23] Tonight I just wanted to talk to you [0:39:24] about the Woodways site. [0:39:26] And I think I'll begin with just a little bit [0:39:30] of background and some history. [0:39:33] The Woodways site, as most of you know, [0:39:35] is on the corner of Rose and South Park. [0:39:38] And today it is full and currently closed. [0:39:44] And I want to talk about how we got to that point [0:39:47] and historically what the original purpose was for the site. [0:39:52] It's been the exact year when we started, I don't have, [0:39:56] but it's been in service for probably 20 years, close to two. [0:40:00] And in the beginning, Southern Idaho Solid Waste [0:40:04] decided to be a partner with the city [0:40:06] by providing wood chipping services for free. [0:40:10] And they've done that for 20 years. [0:40:12] provided the agreement was that we would provide a location [0:40:16] and the operation and maintenance of the site [0:40:19] so for [0:40:21] approximately twenty years southern Idaho solid waste has come out [0:40:25] chipped our wood waste and and and helped us [0:40:27] without charge [0:40:28] they've been a great partner [0:40:30] over the years [0:40:31] and here recently they they made uh... a new purchase on a new [0:40:35] piece of equipment that i know you're aware [0:40:38] and it [0:40:39] it [0:40:40] has [0:40:41] It's different. [0:40:42] It has caused them to operate it differently [0:40:45] because it has a problem with flying debris [0:40:47] and it creates dust. [0:40:49] And so the location of where they chip [0:40:53] is can be a problem. [0:40:56] In case in point, our location is a problem for them now. [0:41:00] So today we have a problem [0:41:03] because we don't have a chipper [0:41:06] and our wood waste site is full. [0:41:07] Today, Dean Littler had a conversation with Josh Bartlemme, I think he's the executive [0:41:18] director for Southern Idaho Solid Waste, and he also sent an email expressing that he offered [0:41:30] that to work with us as far as the Solid Waste that's there. [0:41:34] I'm confident that we can work something out with Southern Idaho Solid Waste. [0:41:38] He has to take a proposal to the board and I think they would entertain reduced cost for [0:41:47] processing our problem that we have right now. [0:41:49] So I think if we could for right now maybe move on and before I do that is there any questions [0:41:56] with what the current problem is? [0:41:59] Because I think Dean and I can work something out with us other night at a solid waste. [0:42:03] Council have any questions? [0:42:06] No light? [0:42:07] Well, we can come back if you do. [0:42:13] So now we're in a position, well, let me back up to, the landfill can't take the waste [0:42:22] as is, we would have to sort through it. [0:42:24] There is garbage in it. [0:42:25] They have a policy that given it to dean, it describes the kind of things it can't be [0:42:29] in there. [0:42:30] So we're going to have labor involved in separating the waste and then to bring in what we can [0:42:36] process to their sites. [0:42:37] So I think that they would be willing to do that. [0:42:43] OK, its original purpose was also [0:42:45] to provide a site for citizens to bring waste. [0:42:48] And the theory was that we would recycle the wood waste [0:42:51] and reuse it. [0:42:52] And to my knowledge, if that has happened, recycling [0:42:57] was an isolated event. [0:43:01] I haven't seen it since I've been here. [0:43:03] Have you? [0:43:05] I mean, really the recycling issue never really took hold. [0:43:11] So we always would either chip the wood in place, [0:43:16] and we would either haul it to the landfill, [0:43:18] or in some cases we were able to bring it to feed lots. [0:43:24] Over the years, we've noticed that it attracts garbage, [0:43:30] and so it does require supervision and manpower [0:43:33] to not only supervise the site, but also [0:43:36] separate the garbage and it does create a problem. It adds cost to the processing. Also, we've [0:43:53] noticed that really the main users have started to become commercial users, landscape users [0:44:00] and that sort of thing. It's not necessarily the individuals that are using it, which is [0:44:06] the original intent. So, you know, I was telling Travis a week ago, I really, really don't like [0:44:14] coming to council and saying, you know, there's a service we provide, I don't like doing, Dean [0:44:22] doesn't like doing, and we don't think we should be doing it anymore. And it's not necessarily [0:44:25] because we don't, we don't like doing it. It's because I think one that distracts from [0:44:31] our mission. And also I think Southern Idaho Solid Waste is very efficient at it. They're [0:44:37] set up to do it. And if we want to do that, if the Council decides that we want to do that, [0:44:43] we're more than willing to facilitate that. There's some things that we'd have to do, quite [0:44:49] a few things. One of them is we'd have to find a piece of property that would work. [0:44:54] Dean has, Dean put a good write up together and he kind of talked about the sites that [0:44:58] he could think of, there were three of them and none of them will work. [0:45:03] So I'm not aware of a piece of property that the city owns where we could process wood waste. [0:45:09] We'd have to buy a piece of equipment. These shippers are not cheap. [0:45:14] We could probably buy a used one for a while, but they're high maintenance kinds of things. [0:45:22] And, you know, I like to think that, you know, when it comes to doing business with the city, [0:45:32] when providing services, we like to stick with what we know and what we're good at. [0:45:38] And I think that there are alternatives for the citizen out there, and they aren't that bad. [0:45:45] And I think that if we provided an education piece to the citizens, [0:45:51] Maybe we could come up with an alternative to the site. [0:45:56] Right now, PSI offers curbsight pickup for your brush provided that you pack gym and garbage [0:46:03] bags. [0:46:04] There's no limit to that. [0:46:05] You can bring as many as you want to the curb. [0:46:10] If you want, you can bring your waste if you have a large truckload that you don't want [0:46:15] to package. [0:46:16] You can drive it to the transfer station, which is where that is. [0:46:21] much it's not much more out of the way than our own [0:46:25] woodway site. [0:46:26] You have to drive south of town, orchard in Eastland. [0:46:30] Then of course you could go to the landfill. [0:46:33] So I think it's something that we have to decide whether we [0:46:42] want to provide the service. [0:46:44] And if we do, I probably need to investigate costs for you [0:46:50] and come back. [0:46:51] But at this point in time, I'm not sure if I'm leaving [0:46:54] anything out that Dean may want to add, but, you know, we feel there's, there's alternatives [0:47:01] out there and that if, through, through some education, we could probably, probably, um, [0:47:07] like to propose closing, closing this site. [0:47:13] Great money. [0:47:14] I guess John, I'm a little confused on the, uh, Southern Idaho waste concerns about if it [0:47:23] ends up, there ends up garbage in ours that they won't take it that way because if we put it [0:47:27] the curb, it's going to be mixed right in the truck with the regular garbage, sometimes [0:47:32] figure out why there's a difference between if we provide it to them from our wood waste [0:47:36] site because some people were inconsiderate and threw garbage in there with it as opposed [0:47:42] to going to the curb. [0:47:44] Is there a reason why that they would draw that conclusion? [0:47:48] Yeah, I believe I can answer that. [0:47:50] I know Dean can't do that. [0:47:51] I've talked about it and I'm trying to remember. [0:47:56] For the wood waste that has trash in it, it gets land filled. [0:47:59] And for the wood waste that is clean wood waste, just wood waste, they have a separate area [0:48:04] for that. [0:48:05] Okay. [0:48:06] All right. [0:48:08] But I guess if they partner with us in closing the wood waste site, that means all of it's [0:48:13] going to go to the curb and so it all would be, does that make sense? [0:48:17] Yeah. [0:48:18] It would either end up at that. [0:48:19] I can see why they wouldn't want to chip it and then have garbage in it, that would [0:48:23] make sense. [0:48:24] Right. [0:48:25] All right. [0:48:27] I'm good Chris talking to it. [0:48:30] So just to summarize John, then you say close the wood waste processing area right now during [0:48:37] the time of this education system, what 90, 120 days, what are you talking about? [0:48:44] Yeah, it's currently closed and we could start, we could put together, go ahead. [0:48:52] I mean, while ding, you're processing all that stored up [0:48:57] waste right now, aren't you? [0:49:00] Dean, you have to come to the mic because it's televised, [0:49:03] or not televised, but on the interweb. [0:49:06] We're not really processing what's there right now. [0:49:09] It's just piled up because we're unable to process it. [0:49:15] We don't own our chip or our shelf. [0:49:17] The southern Idaho is unable to chip it there [0:49:20] because of the dust and the flying debris and we got Sharp Mac trailer right there, railroad [0:49:27] tracks. We covered the railroads before with flying debris from their old machine and their [0:49:34] new machine produces quite a bit more dust than the old machine did. So they just can't do it there. [0:49:42] That's kind of what's brought this all about is we just can't chip wood at that site anymore. [0:49:49] the right now the pile is just stagnant static and it's sitting there and nothing's [0:49:55] being done yeah and it's a fire hazard probably to yeah well that's one way I [0:50:02] take care of it [0:50:04] I'd like to talk about the latinist. [0:50:08] I've got my micha's on too. [0:50:13] No, that's a serious problem. [0:50:14] It is. [0:50:15] That much wood. [0:50:17] And it's always been pretty complicated over there [0:50:22] because of all the legal dumping and the trash that ends up [0:50:25] in it. [0:50:26] We've had pieces of the little straps [0:50:30] that they both railroad armed together with. [0:50:34] regular tracks the other way. [0:50:36] Somebody threw one of those in the breast pit one time [0:50:39] and Southern Idaho saw the waist, [0:50:41] the boys tried to run it through their chipper and soon. [0:50:44] It done quite a little bit of damage. [0:50:47] Pieces of it ended up out in the road. [0:50:50] I've got nice trucks, motors, [0:50:52] the chipper operator standing there. [0:50:55] It's really dangerous. [0:50:57] The dust causes issues in the street. [0:51:01] Sometimes it gets hard for traffic to see [0:51:03] with the bill invested in the road, it's like say, [0:51:07] it's always been a little complicated, [0:51:09] just got a whole lot more complicated [0:51:11] when they purchased that and she. [0:51:15] Thank you, David. [0:51:16] Don, just one more comment, Dean. [0:51:19] I would guess also that we're in violation [0:51:21] of the South Central Health Standards. [0:51:23] I would guess that would be a fertile breeding ground [0:51:27] for rodents and others living on the refuse. [0:51:30] Well, you had, you know, all the time [0:51:33] we have rock chucks living in there. [0:51:34] we've had we've had stray dogs the animal control guys have been trying to catch [0:51:39] for the last month or so I don't know if they find the cat those guys caught [0:51:44] it off but yeah there's always critters in there you know a little bit of [0:51:48] everything garbage gets dumped in there if we had a residential lot and twin [0:51:56] falls with that much ref he's on it we would use that very nomenclature to shut [0:52:01] them down and force them to move it. We're in violation of it. [0:52:04] Big time. It's true. [0:52:06] Thank you, Dean. [0:52:07] We're back on the Hill's second. [0:52:09] Thank you, Mayor. Thanks for your presentation, Mr. Caden. It looks like in your report that [0:52:14] there are a couple of alternatives to the Woodway site, so I don't have any objections [0:52:19] to closing the site. It sounds like there are good reasons to close it that the citizens [0:52:26] really aren't using it. But I have a question. You talk about the Southern [0:52:31] Idaho Solid Waste Chipper. Where's that located and would that be the [0:52:37] transportation that you're talking about on orchard in Eastland? Would that be the [0:52:41] new location that they would go to? I guess it's two questions. Sure. Yeah. Yes, [0:52:47] you could the Southern Idaho Solid Waste would accept [0:52:50] would waste at any other facility so that's the transfer station at Orchard and Eastland [0:52:56] and then at the landfill south of the airport two miles south. [0:53:04] Okay, yeah, and the chipper that you're speaking of that doesn't fit on this location, [0:53:09] is that something that they have in the Rupert area or is that something that's locally here? [0:53:18] Just sit down here in this front road. [0:53:22] They travel around with that chipper. [0:53:25] They have sites scattered all over Sutter night. [0:53:27] Oh, they've got a site over in Gooding. [0:53:31] I believe they've got a site up in the Haley, Bellevue, Wood [0:53:34] River area. [0:53:37] Locally, if you want your wood waste to be chipped, [0:53:43] you would have to deliver it to their site [0:53:45] out south of the airport. [0:53:47] If you deliver it to the transfer station, [0:53:49] or you leave it for the garbage guy to pick up, [0:53:51] It's just going to get mixed up with the regular garbage [0:53:54] and it'll just end up in the landfill. [0:53:56] But if you separate your wood waste [0:53:58] and hauled it to the landfill, not to hub you, [0:54:02] they would separate that and put it in [0:54:04] or they got a great big huge pile out there [0:54:06] that they'd pull in with their chipper and tran, [0:54:10] and process every now and again. [0:54:13] Okay, thank you. [0:54:13] I would just suggest maybe having some information [0:54:17] at that site if people continue to come to the wood waste site [0:54:20] that they would have directions or some information [0:54:23] they're telling them where to go. [0:54:25] And instead. [0:54:26] My sign guys, I believe we could probably [0:54:29] build some kind of sign that would direct folks to the land [0:54:33] or to some of those other options. [0:54:36] Thank you. [0:54:39] If you notice my expression was Suzanne, [0:54:42] her lights on, off, on, off. [0:54:43] LAUGHTER [0:54:45] Go ahead, Travis. [0:54:47] You know, I think that Rebecca makes a great suggestion [0:54:50] And what we'll do as part of that educational material is we'll also provide them resources and [0:54:54] opportunities of where they can now take that information. [0:54:58] So it won't only be just a posting on the property, but it will also be before they load up their truck and [0:55:06] begin to maybe follow and become creatures of habit of where they take their wood waste. [0:55:11] So we can hit them on the front end that maybe they need to be depositing that at a different location because of [0:55:18] of the fact that the city is now longer going to be providing that service. [0:55:22] So maybe I didn't track very well tonight, John, but I had heard before that we were going [0:55:28] to buy their old chipper and what happened with them? [0:55:32] Well, they offered us to buy their old chipper for $50,000, which they'd had appraised for [0:55:43] probably in the $60,000 range. [0:55:45] were willing to make us a pretty good deal on their old chipper just so we could kind [0:55:49] of get our mess cleaned up over there. [0:55:53] We probably, you know, if we depict a good column quiet day, we probably could have used [0:55:57] their old chipper, bought their old chipper, used their old chipper and processed the [0:56:00] wood we had. [0:56:04] I originally thought that that might be a pretty good idea because I was comparing the [0:56:12] cost of buying that youth chipper against hauling all of that wood to the landfill and paying [0:56:17] a landfill price. [0:56:19] 20 bucks a ton. [0:56:22] I figured there's 310 wheeler loads over there, probably 8-10 tons of load. [0:56:26] You do a little math and you almost figure out if the thing don't blow up on you, you [0:56:32] could almost process what we've got for cheaper than we could haul it to the landfill. [0:56:37] talking to Josh today, he's thinking that, and he'd have to check with his board, but he's [0:56:44] thinking that, you know, they'd probably give us a reduced price, maybe could provide this [0:56:50] one time service for free to get our masks cleaned up. Those guys have been, you know, [0:56:56] trying to work with us to try and work that deal out. They feel as bad as I do about the [0:57:02] mess we've got over there and so that's kind of why we talked about you know maybe [0:57:07] purchasing a chipper but we purchased a chipper then we need a truck to move it [0:57:12] because we don't have a truck that haul that chipper around so you've got another [0:57:16] $20,000-$30,000 in a truck they probably take us you know 20-30 hours running that [0:57:24] chipper to process the wood waste we've got hopefully you don't have too much [0:57:29] trouble with it while you're you know you're you run a chunk of railroad [0:57:32] arm through one of those and you're gonna have $10,000 worth of repairs. [0:57:36] It'll burn a hundred gallons of fuel in a day. You know they're an [0:57:42] expensive piece of equipment to own and run and if we was to buy a new one [0:57:49] you're talking $200,000 plus the price of a truck. So I just don't think it makes [0:57:57] It's a good economic sense to purchase a chipper and get into the business. [0:58:03] Especially when we don't have a really suitable site to continue to do it. [0:58:09] Okay, that makes sense. [0:58:12] I mean, I just hate to see us quit doing something that we've done. [0:58:16] It's a service for the community, but I get it, it makes sense. [0:58:19] This says possible action, what action do you need from us tonight? [0:58:24] Jim Clips, which is happening. [0:58:28] So we list possible action in the event that you wanted to take one and provide direction. [0:58:34] Really, I think the idea today was to have John and Dean come in and [0:58:41] share the current issues at the Woodway site, the strategy that they have to fix it. [0:58:47] And then what the future may look like and just maybe for [0:58:54] Council awareness, but also for general that people may be watching or be reported on that this is the steps that the city's taken. [0:59:01] Thank you, Travis. [0:59:03] Possibly we have possible action, Jim. [0:59:05] Well, I would move to make a motion to permanently close the Woodway site located. [0:59:11] What's that street? [0:59:12] Rose, South Park. [0:59:14] Rose is South Park West. [0:59:15] Secondly, I would include a net motion to dispose and [0:59:21] Clean out that existing backlog of stuff, get it cleaned out of there, and then place some sort of reasonable looking sign from the street department saying if you want to get rid of your stuff, go to Hub Butte, or just dispose of it at the transfer station. [0:59:35] Second. [0:59:37] We have a motion on 4 by Jim Munn, seconded by Sean Berriger. [0:59:43] I'm not going to try to repeat that motion. [0:59:45] I'd just like to amend that to include an aggressive advertising or awareness program through the city services to make people aware of what they can and can do. [0:59:57] Could I include that, Mike? That would be fine. Sounds great. The maker of the motion includes it in the second. [1:00:04] So that is included in the motion anything further on that motion good call. Yes [1:00:11] The other roll call vote Sean Berger yes [1:00:16] Yes [1:00:18] Great landing. Yes Don Hall. Yes [1:00:22] Yes [1:00:23] Suzanne Hawkins. Yes, Jim. Yes. Motion passes seven to zero. Thank you gentlemen for your presentation [1:00:30] nation. [1:00:31] It's the other way. [1:00:32] What do you look on the question? [1:00:34] Number four, discussion and possible action seeking direction on how to proceed with the [1:00:40] Canyon Springs grade after impacts from construction traffic during the wastewater treatment plant [1:00:45] expansion along with a request for direction in regard to public access to agra falls. [1:00:53] Troy? [1:00:55] V-Tech. [1:00:56] I'm sorry, Troy, but V-Tech, welcome again, sir. [1:01:01] Thank you, Mr. Mayor and members of the council for the record, [1:01:04] Troy P. Tech Assist City Engineer. [1:01:06] Several weeks ago, I came before you to give you an update on the wastewater treatment plant. [1:01:12] My boss says I don't talk very loud, so I'm trying to improve it. [1:01:16] And in that update, I told you I would come back and talk about two major issues. [1:01:22] One was the Canyon Springs grade, and the second was Auger Falls. [1:01:26] So I broke those into two parts. [1:01:28] What I'd like to talk about first is the cadence brings great. [1:01:31] So as part of this, [1:01:33] wastewater treatment plant upgrade, we're going to bring 23 concrete trucks down that road daily [1:01:39] during the peak construction season. [1:01:42] We fill with that greatly impact that road, especially on the corners. [1:01:46] And my discussion with you tonight is what do we really want to do there? [1:01:50] Do we want to make the wastewater treatment plant contractor fix the roadway after they've impacted it? [1:01:57] it, which puts the cost of that fix on the wastewater treatment plant in that bond. [1:02:02] By putting the money there, that leaves us less for the sewer line improvements in the future. [1:02:08] I don't know if that's the right answer. [1:02:11] The other one is we hold off a little bit and that money comes from the streets fund and [1:02:16] we just make that a project in the future. [1:02:20] That's kind of the two part of that. [1:02:24] Which fund do we pull it from? [1:02:26] And when do we do it? [1:02:28] The other portion of that is there are several options of what we can do there. [1:02:32] We can't fix the road pretty much as it is today. [1:02:35] We think there are some drainage problems. [1:02:37] In fact, most of the slope being the rock falling, we believe us due to the irrigation [1:02:42] water and seepage and issues with the roadway and the base of the roadway. [1:02:46] So we think that road probably needs a little bit more than just an overlay on it. [1:02:50] Doug out and actually fixed. [1:02:53] it looked pretty much the same configuration as right there today. We can also widen it [1:02:58] and put pedestrians on the side. That would require two lanes, a K-rail jersey barrier, [1:03:06] and then the people to walk as a single-file line, and then they would be bounded by one [1:03:11] of the I.T.D. guard rails, one of those metal guard rails on their side. It would be roughly [1:03:16] four feet wide, is it? [1:03:17] So they'd be mostly single file, able to pass, but limited. [1:03:23] They couldn't really walk over us. [1:03:24] And I don't know how successful that'll be in that. [1:03:30] Another option would be to place a signal at the top [1:03:36] and the bottom. [1:03:37] And we did that previously. [1:03:39] And I don't know really what the takeaway from that was. [1:03:42] If it was well received by the public and the people down [1:03:45] there or if it was horrible and I believe more than anything, it will impact those residents [1:03:51] along the top canyon rim there. [1:03:53] Those driveways are very near the top and waiting for that signal and it would have to [1:03:58] be a time signal because you have to give people a truck time to get up that and make [1:04:02] those corners and stuff like that. [1:04:03] So it's a great, it's a long waiting period so there could be some stacking issues there. [1:04:09] And then the last one and the costliest option would be to widen that roadway and that can [1:04:15] go anywhere from blasting back and building out. Really be three lanes and you'd be two [1:04:22] for vehicles and one for pedestrians at that point. And that would be extremely difficult. [1:04:29] So I give you some real rough numbers. I put 700,000 lane mile in there. And that was [1:04:34] on a recent project. This project, I believe, would be pretty much representative of that. [1:04:39] This is a high level estimate here, mostly due to the how do you continue traffic flow [1:04:46] while you're doing the project there. [1:04:48] And so that would be probably the most difficult part of this project. [1:04:52] So I believe some hundred thousand to be a pretty decent rough estimate. [1:04:57] Option two includes signalization. [1:05:02] So you'd add about five hundred thousand dollars. [1:05:05] So the first one would cost roughly a million dollars, replace the roadway as it is. [1:05:11] No whitening, just dig it out and put a new roadway in. [1:05:15] If you add the option of a signal there, you're going to add another $500,000 signal [1:05:20] cost to that. [1:05:22] Option three is this two small lanes in the Jersey barrier. [1:05:25] You're going to be about a million and a quarter for that construction. [1:05:29] The Jersey rail, again, you won't gain any additional width, you'll just put the pedestrians [1:05:34] on the side. [1:05:35] able to occupy both lanes of traffic and then a full reconstruction project and not knowing [1:05:44] all the difficulty of what's in that slope and how stable it is, estimating at $3, $3, $3.5 [1:05:50] million for that project. [1:05:52] So it's considerably more costly than the other one. [1:05:57] So the reason I brought it for you before you guys tonight is I would like some direction [1:06:03] on what you guys would generally like to see or would point me towards if you want [1:06:10] to more information I could sure gather that for you and perceive that way and [1:06:15] would you rather talk about this or me do the second part of the conversation? [1:06:19] Well I have at least one light so maybe we'll stop here and talk but I'm gonna [1:06:23] tell you I don't like any of your options Chris talking to me. Tim would we [1:06:28] We have to condemn land to blast out. [1:06:31] That's the first part of my question. [1:06:42] A lot of that is a cross-cady's property. [1:06:44] If I remember right, she owns the face of that. [1:06:47] So we would have to at least approach her, I don't know, condemnation is the right way [1:06:53] word for that, but it is possible because it will end with. [1:06:57] And I guess, I'm sorry. [1:06:59] It would require additional whitening, which I would think would have to go in that direction [1:07:03] as well as over the other side. [1:07:05] Well, I think I can help on eliminating one of the ABCD. [1:07:09] C is not a reasonable option, even though it's [1:07:12] a million and a quarter cheaper than one other. [1:07:17] Putting a jersey barrier, a single lane, will not work. [1:07:21] You have high exercise on that area. [1:07:24] And I see 75 people at a time going up and down, plus bikers. [1:07:30] They won't all file through that Venturi tube. [1:07:34] They'll be on the outside to a stride. [1:07:36] And the only thing you'll end up doing [1:07:38] is narrowing your effective two lanes [1:07:42] for your motor vehicles. [1:07:44] So I just don't think that's reasonable. [1:07:46] OK. [1:07:48] Rebecca Milsoyka. [1:07:50] Thank you, Mayor. [1:07:52] Just a comment. [1:07:53] I think these are all difficult options as well. [1:07:57] But I personally wouldn't be comfortable choosing one without [1:08:02] somehow involving the public. [1:08:03] I think that this roadway is so vital to so many people's daily [1:08:07] lives and they really are very fond of it. [1:08:11] And so I think that there's got to be some way that we can [1:08:16] give a call for input because I think that we can all recognize [1:08:21] that the roadway is the normal traffic will be interrupted. [1:08:26] And I think we all have to recognize that, but how we go about addressing it. [1:08:30] I think we're just going to have to involve the public. [1:08:33] I just wouldn't want to make a decision on that without at least calling for input. [1:08:38] So. [1:08:39] Okay. [1:08:40] Greg Lanning? [1:08:42] Well, this may sound like somebody who apparently is not thinking of running, but that's a [1:08:47] dangerous situation. [1:08:48] I think we should close it to protection traffic and come up with a different way for them to [1:08:53] exercise utilizing that. [1:08:56] put that extra or whatever it would cost to widen or whatever into putting into the [1:09:01] additional trail that comes down off of a different spot and attain the right away and [1:09:05] just make it safer. [1:09:06] Because it's not safe the way it is. [1:09:08] I mean, every time I go down there to, if I play golf at King Springs or go down to some [1:09:12] of the other amenities down there, you wonder how somebody hasn't been run over already. [1:09:19] And so I'm looking at it from a safety aspect. [1:09:21] I understand, Rebecca, it's important, I say we build them something else and utilize the [1:09:26] money there, and I would prefer, you know, either whatever the [1:09:31] engineering department wants, feels would be the best on the [1:09:34] reconstruction of the road. And I would put it as part of the [1:09:36] surbond. I think the sur facility tears up the road, the [1:09:40] silver facility should fix the road. Right? Right? It's all here, [1:09:46] right? I was going to mention that you're running for counsel [1:09:50] or anything. Suzanne Hawkins. [1:09:54] This question is probably more for Travis or Fritz, just thinking ahead, if we decided [1:10:00] to proceed with widening the road and making it safer for pedestrians and traffic, would [1:10:06] in your opinion that be a good use for maybe using some of our foregone balance in the [1:10:11] upcoming budget to that one-time project? [1:10:14] And raise property taxes by doing that? [1:10:22] You would raise property taxes. [1:10:23] I think what's important to recognize about the foregone balance is that it does add [1:10:28] to the permanent revenue streams of the city. [1:10:33] And the city council has the ability [1:10:35] to allocate that during every appropriation process moving [1:10:39] forward. [1:10:41] Based upon the numbers that Troy provided, [1:10:45] it would take a few years of accumulated foregone balance [1:10:49] after it was collected to be able to cover some of the projects. [1:10:53] Right now, the city's foregone balance [1:10:55] is about $1.472 million, and if you look at some of the options that have been provided [1:11:04] by Mr. Vitek, they range in price from about $1 million to a $3.5 million project. [1:11:15] So how you compensate for that, whether it's a foregone balance, can largely be determined [1:11:23] by the council. [1:11:24] It would also be, maybe you could do a combination of things. [1:11:27] You could use tax resources as they were captured, whether that be for [1:11:32] gone balance or a direct appropriation process that we would normally go through. [1:11:36] As well as the use of sewer bond proceeds that may not be used directly for [1:11:41] the wastewater treatment facility or the collections. [1:11:44] We believe that that would be an eligible expense because the cause and [1:11:48] damage to the roadway beyond where it's at now would be as a result of the construction. [1:11:56] Now the challenge is, are we going to have enough money? [1:12:00] Because as we illustrated during the 60% review of the project, the wastewater treatment plant [1:12:06] project right now was coming in roughly about $34 million. [1:12:12] We had a successful bond sale that captured about $39.5 million because of the bond issuance [1:12:19] and the additional premium. [1:12:21] And then we do have some level of capacity fee and connection fees that have been accumulated [1:12:31] which amounts to about $3.4 million. [1:12:33] So when you think about $34 million for the project, you think about adding $6 million [1:12:39] or they're about to offset some of the improvements [1:12:41] to the collection system, [1:12:42] there appears to be some amount in there [1:12:46] for roadway improvement, [1:12:47] but I think it's also important that the engineering estimates [1:12:50] that we have right now are very, very preliminary, [1:12:53] and it is probably not going to be something [1:12:57] until we get into construction, actually, [1:12:59] when we start looking at those projects [1:13:01] because potential change orders [1:13:03] that could be applied to the project. [1:13:05] Thank you. [1:13:07] We're back from Elsoka. [1:13:08] Thank you, Mayor, in terms of the cost and which fund to take it out of your asking us. [1:13:14] But I would ask staff, I mean, do you have a recommendation? [1:13:18] I mean, I would assume that the work needs to be done shortly after the damage is done. [1:13:25] I really can't see there being much patience on the part of the citizens for [1:13:31] having that roadway torn up for a long period of time. [1:13:34] So, looking at the budget, the future budget process, [1:13:39] what is their recommendation that you would give to us, whether the money be taken from the waste water treatment bond or? [1:13:48] I mean, I guess the question is, do we even have the money there in the street fund for [1:13:53] shortly after the project is finished? [1:14:02] You could appropriate the funds, but it would cause us to maybe put, so one of the things [1:14:08] that the engineering department has done is they put the city on a eight year rotational [1:14:13] basis. [1:14:14] We put money in an annual project list so that we incurred, that we move through the different [1:14:19] zones in an eight year rotational basis. [1:14:23] I'm just speaking out loud. [1:14:26] I'm not saying this is a good decision. [1:14:29] you could forgo the projects that you have in that list and you could dedicate [1:14:34] whatever available resources under the constrained revenue sources that we have [1:14:38] to apply to this roadway project. You could use bond proceeds. [1:14:42] I think that Troy actually has a recommendation as I understand it. [1:14:47] It might be, you don't know. [1:14:50] That was bad information I got earlier today. [1:14:54] So we try to script these things for us. That didn't work so well. [1:14:58] Well, you know, maybe what we do is we go forward and really take a look at, I think it's appropriate for the engineering department to come up with a list of plausible solutions and then take those plausible solutions through a community process and to have those vetted and move that forward. [1:15:20] I don't believe that it would be appropriate to prevent or provide a wide menu of choices [1:15:25] that we don't believe are financially achievable without securing some outside level of revenue [1:15:33] source. [1:15:34] Unless the citizens were willing to, maybe that's a high priority where the citizens are [1:15:38] really willing to come up and step up and champion that. [1:15:42] And we've seen that occur on wastewater treatment plant bonds and the like. [1:15:46] We saw that with the senior citizen center when the citizen stepped up and really wanted [1:15:50] to have that project come forward as well. [1:15:53] So, I think that there are options, but I would really like to have a palliative options [1:15:57] that are in the realm of possibility that are presented by the true professionals there. [1:16:06] I would agree that that's a great process and actually if I may comment, I actually [1:16:11] would be interested in seeing a cost estimate of the idea that Councilman Landing proposed. [1:16:16] I mean, to compare, you know, the cost of maybe creating a solely pedestrian and bicycle [1:16:23] trail versus having to widen this road, which eventually I think would have to happen years [1:16:30] down the road. [1:16:32] But I think that that's a great idea to maybe get some options. [1:16:35] I also agree that maybe the money should come out of the wastewater treatment bond because [1:16:42] that's where the damage is coming from. [1:16:44] But of course there is years of prior wear [1:16:47] that adds on to the situation. [1:16:50] So I look forward to staff recommendations on funding. [1:16:54] Okay, Dean, wanna say something? [1:16:56] He does. [1:16:56] He does. [1:16:57] Why? [1:16:58] Of course. [1:16:59] You're here tonight, so. [1:17:00] This is kind of new to me, [1:17:01] but I do have a little knowledge of the road. [1:17:07] That's a cold mix blade overlay [1:17:10] that I laid myself probably 20 years ago. [1:17:13] So I know exactly what that road is. [1:17:15] There's a little dab of gravel under it [1:17:18] with probably a couple of three inches of cold mix [1:17:20] on top and a seal coat or two over the years. [1:17:23] And I truly do believe that a lot of construction [1:17:27] traffic is probably going to destroy that road. [1:17:30] Never built for that kind of traffic. [1:17:35] I'd really hate to see us do work down there on the road without addressing the rocks. [1:17:48] I send my guys down there every now and again to remove rock fall off the road. [1:17:56] I personally take a rock off that road that wouldn't hardly fit in the loader bucket. [1:18:02] I'm always concerned about my guys when they go down to do something like that, [1:18:07] clean the ditch or remove rock or ice out of the road. [1:18:13] I would really hate to see one of my guys get hurt. [1:18:17] And I think when we do road construction down there to a certain extent, [1:18:23] we kind of complicate the issues with the rock fall. [1:18:29] Every time you run a roller with vibrator down that road, [1:18:34] I've done that before. [1:18:35] You got little rocks falling off the edge of the wall, [1:18:38] down onto the road. [1:18:42] Here a few years ago, we had a big slide that pretty well [1:18:45] destroyed the road where it landed. [1:18:50] To me, to spend a lot of money on a new road [1:18:53] and not at least scale some of the rock off [1:18:56] or address some of that rock fall issue, [1:19:01] I think it would just be a matter of time [1:19:03] before we had a slide, and we ended up damaging our new growth. [1:19:09] This spring, I'm really concerned about with wet weather, the freezing and the thaw and [1:19:15] cycle that we've had, there's a rock or tea down there that I always kind of look at when [1:19:22] I go down there, and I kind of watch it all the time, kind of judge what it's doing, and [1:19:29] I can guarantee you that things working towards the river. [1:19:34] I just hope that, and I know it's a lot of money, [1:19:40] but for me and my guys to make it safe, [1:19:47] I sure like that we can do everything we can do down there [1:19:51] to make it better. [1:19:53] Thank you, Dean. [1:19:55] Thank you. [1:19:56] Sean Berriger. [1:19:59] Well, I'm glad that Dean spoke up, [1:20:01] because that's sort of where I was going, [1:20:03] is to, and not put a million dollars as piece-mealing, [1:20:08] but to sort of take the easy way out and just fix it up [1:20:12] to be what it is now without looking at the inevitable [1:20:16] solution, which is that road needs to be wider. [1:20:19] There needs to be some address of pedestrian access, [1:20:24] whether it's on that road or with a different trail [1:20:27] that goes down. [1:20:29] And as we continue to see more access to the river down there, [1:20:33] I mean, we have a park down there, [1:20:35] the county has a park down there, [1:20:37] There's a golf course down there. [1:20:38] There's a zip line down there. [1:20:40] Our waste water treatment plan is down there. [1:20:42] We need access for our water. [1:20:44] There's a lot of use of that road. [1:20:46] And to just sort of patch it back up after we tear it up [1:20:50] to the tune of the million bucks. [1:20:51] If we could be looking, even if it was five million bucks [1:20:54] to do the full meal deal, it's probably [1:20:58] a lot better spent on the front end. [1:21:01] So what I might ask is, is there a sort [1:21:05] of an internal staff brain trust that could get together and look at what might that look [1:21:12] like? [1:21:13] Yeah, if you guys wanted to pick one of these or even a combination of one of these or however, [1:21:18] I'd be happy to go back and get more detail on that and then bring it forward and give [1:21:25] you a little better figures and what that looks like. [1:21:30] I think that's the way to go because really I think throwing a million bucks and putting [1:21:38] and the road into exactly what it is now. [1:21:42] I don't know that that gets as much further down the road [1:21:44] than having the next problem show up. [1:21:50] Chris talking to. [1:21:51] Yeah, if I understand then, if we were to take that [1:21:56] alternative D, which would do pretty much what Dean [1:22:00] talked about, that would be three to three and a half million. [1:22:04] Very rough, guesstimation. [1:22:06] Yeah, I don't see short-term, I don't think long-term makes sense to waste the money and [1:22:15] not consider stabilizing or expanding that roadway into the unstable wall. [1:22:24] I guess I really have only one difference of opinion of involving the public with this. [1:22:30] This is one of these times when the Council cannot avoid making decisions based upon the [1:22:36] the technical requirements, the safety hazard, and for people that don't know that canyon [1:22:41] wall, yeah, you could come up with a trail. In fact, there already is one, but it's one [1:22:47] that Mount sheep and goat would have a hard time in a slippery day going on, and it may [1:22:53] also involve acquisition of a private property again. I think that all vehicular traffic and [1:23:01] pedestrian traffic can be accommodated on that road, if in fact it's white and Dean [1:23:07] I've had rocks fall off and fall off and fall on the road as I've exercised and [1:23:12] somebody's gonna be killed there shortly and every time a truck vibrates up or [1:23:17] down that hill it destabilizes more. So I guess I'd be kind of in the in the [1:23:23] realm of favoring that that item D if you can come up with some more [1:23:27] for particulars on that, and quoting the financing. [1:23:34] I wonder why Ian, first of all, [1:23:37] as far as the construction this summer, our spring, [1:23:44] I'm assuming we've thought about maybe this concrete [1:23:48] trucks not being fully loaded. [1:23:52] I know that that's probably gonna be more of an expense, [1:23:54] but I'm assuming what's killing it is the weight, [1:23:57] the vibration and concrete weighs a lot in those PIGO trucks. [1:24:03] So is that been a consideration at all or is that not realistic? [1:24:07] I'm just. [1:24:08] You know, we haven't limited. [1:24:10] We just said they have to meet the required weight limits [1:24:13] of Center City Road. [1:24:15] So we haven't said that in the least. [1:24:19] And I just would, I don't know if it'd lead to a vastly amount or more. [1:24:23] Or expensive. [1:24:25] Yeah. [1:24:25] Or a huge cost to that. [1:24:27] Yeah, a lot of times it's just paraxle weight that tears roads up. [1:24:31] So I don't know if that's an option that maybe you could look at. [1:24:36] And I guess I really agree with a lot of counsel that we need to find the fix. [1:24:42] It's probably going to be expensive. [1:24:44] Well, it's probably going to be expensive. [1:24:47] And I just personally don't so many people that utilize that roadway for not only just [1:24:53] exercise but also for recreation. [1:24:55] And it's their roadway and I, man, I hate to start talking about closing it, but I certainly [1:25:02] appreciate what Greg's saying about the safety. [1:25:05] We don't want anyone killed or hurt there. [1:25:08] And I think we've just been extremely lucky that that hasn't happened. [1:25:14] Jim, I just real briefly, Mayor, thank you. [1:25:17] I also agree that it just doesn't make sense to me to put a million dollar fix on a three [1:25:24] a half million dollar problem really because so the quick version is given the fact we have [1:25:30] such vital infrastructure down there in terms of generators, waste water, all those different [1:25:35] things, emergency access to the river for a rescue, all those different things that are [1:25:41] really, really vital to us. [1:25:42] I think that we need to proceed with a plan on plan D with a funding plan also. [1:25:50] I mean, no Travis talked about it. [1:25:52] And let's get moving on the same, [1:25:53] because we're just the city council [1:25:56] is encumbered with fixing this. [1:25:57] And it's been out there for a long, long time, [1:25:59] but as in other areas, this is our. [1:26:03] Is there a call? [1:26:04] All roads lead to this city council. [1:26:06] And I think it was time for us [1:26:07] to start making tough calls on this stuff. [1:26:09] So. [1:26:10] Okay. [1:26:11] Thank you, Jim. [1:26:12] Greg, Manny? [1:26:13] Well, obviously I've made my statement thinking [1:26:16] that the council wasn't gonna go for option D, [1:26:18] which was the only one that maybe provided some safety [1:26:21] and stuff the rest of it. [1:26:22] There's more enough counsel to go on with it, [1:26:26] especially what Sean said. [1:26:28] And I think the other one I would just add to it [1:26:30] is that if we're gonna fix it, let's do it right, [1:26:32] let's get the acquisition, let's talk to the owners, [1:26:35] what do we need to do to make that correct? [1:26:38] And I think we're gonna have to look at it [1:26:39] from a variety of funding sources. [1:26:41] I don't think we can put it all on the search [1:26:43] for my facility. [1:26:44] I think there's a portion of it [1:26:46] that is gonna be their responsibility, [1:26:47] especially because the road would be torn up, [1:26:50] but I think we've got to look at all the options, [1:26:53] including the one that Suzanne brought up. [1:26:55] Just whatever those pots that needs to come out of, [1:26:59] because it certainly can't come out of Dean's Street budget. [1:27:02] I'm pretty sure Dean can use a couple more million [1:27:05] just by himself, just around town. [1:27:07] So, all right, we'll dentists here, he'll share. [1:27:10] Yeah. [1:27:12] Sean Barriger. [1:27:14] So this may be a question. [1:27:15] So what's the time frame that this is going to be [1:27:18] They're actually going to start construction here in people, but not the concrete trucks [1:27:25] will become. [1:27:26] They're going to start removing the dirt which happens. [1:27:28] Right, it's the next item. [1:27:30] So is there a thought that during the time that these concrete trucks are running, are [1:27:35] they going to beat flaggers on the road or restrict traffic? [1:27:39] Right now the idea is to put that burn upon the contractor. [1:27:42] He has to provide some sort of safe and he chooses to do light or signal or people up there [1:27:48] That would be his prerogative at this point because we really don't want the concrete trucks on the edge of the roadway because that's worth [1:27:55] Sloughing right one of kind of centered in line. So it probably will be limited [1:28:00] One main road about those concrete trucks are coming down just to get around the corners and stuff like that [1:28:04] Right and I was gonna mention this on the next item too, but I think [1:28:08] And some good public education on what's going on down here is critical to make sure that I don't want somebody down there hiking and then complaining about concrete trucks when we knew about this all the time. [1:28:24] Travis, did you want to make comment? [1:28:28] So, maybe what we'll do from a staff perspective is we'll take this back. [1:28:34] I think that we have at least a good starting point. [1:28:39] We will take these options. [1:28:40] We'll apply some costs from that place then. [1:28:43] We'll provide a series of financial opportunities and we'll bring that back to the council for [1:28:49] review and consideration. [1:28:51] Yeah. [1:28:52] As you were speaking, numerous lights went off, so maybe you could speak more often. [1:28:58] So it sounds like we have a plant. [1:29:00] You wanted to go into second item within your agenda item. [1:29:05] That's right. [1:29:05] So the second item happens to do with the construction coming up here soon. [1:29:16] Right now the wastewater treatment plant was just a little piece right here. [1:29:19] It's going to be digging dirt and moving a substantial amount of truck loads along this [1:29:26] road and then right in this area there happens to be some area where the I.T.D. [1:29:33] mined out for the highway building and we're just gonna fill that in. It's a [1:29:38] recommendation project. So most of the material will be stuffed in this area. [1:29:43] Lee Glacement with the engineering department department is asked for a [1:29:47] small amount of material to be placed up here so he can use on future wetland [1:29:52] builds to build the dikes around there. So we're gonna stop by all some form but [1:29:55] The vast majority of material will be in this area. [1:29:59] That amounts to 33 trucks of 24 cubic yard trucks, [1:30:03] so the large dump trucks. [1:30:08] We feel that the public who now has the opportunity [1:30:12] to use Auger Falls will be impacted [1:30:14] and there will be a safety concern there as well this summer. [1:30:18] So in the staff report, I gave three options. [1:30:22] One is don't have them all there, [1:30:24] have them fall elsewhere. Well again that affects the Kingdom Springs Road and it [1:30:28] really just relocates the area of concern from here to the Great. Option 2 is [1:30:35] close to the park. I think where we had a close last year for a good portion of [1:30:39] the year while we constructed this the line that currently serves those wetlands. [1:30:44] I really see that as unfortunate for the public in that or option 3 share the area [1:30:53] I let the public have it from 5.30 at night to late in the morning. [1:30:57] I let the contractor have it for me in the morning to 5.30, accepting Saturdays and holidays [1:31:02] and stuff like that. [1:31:03] Let go back to the general public. [1:31:04] We feel that he can stockpile materials as necessary and still deliver to the area. [1:31:09] It doesn't open free access to the public, but there is a real concern there for public [1:31:14] safety and those trucks going back and forth in there. [1:31:18] One I didn't list is option four, and that is always leave it as it is, and let them [1:31:22] work together and we'll try to put on the contractor to have a good safety plan but that's a risk so my [1:31:33] recommendation or my question to you guys again is what would you like to see? [1:31:38] Seems pretty simple to me Sean. So I like option three [1:31:45] but my question is so what's the time frame that this would be happening? [1:31:49] You know is it three months or two months or? Yeah there's three months in there [1:31:54] up front initially and then there'll be a lull and then there'll be another two [1:31:58] months they're gonna have to construct the big project right in the middle of [1:32:02] the the plant there that's going to haul the majority of material up and then [1:32:08] while they're working on that and then eventually as we get towards the second [1:32:12] phase of the the 16 million gallons not the 13 million gallons we have to do a [1:32:17] secondary clarifier so they'll go to start digging that hole but a lot of that [1:32:20] could be used to fill in the first hole, [1:32:22] you know, kind of backfill it. [1:32:23] Right. [1:32:24] But there's still be some trucks going down there, [1:32:26] so we would put, during, we would work with a contractor [1:32:30] and say, okay, between these three months, [1:32:31] you can, this is your options. [1:32:34] And maybe two months later on, [1:32:35] but he wouldn't have, it wouldn't be continuous clear [1:32:38] till December of 2015, it'd be, it'd miss. [1:32:41] But the first part would be during the summer. [1:32:44] And that's when, I'm sure, public would be impacted the most. [1:32:48] And then do you think that putting a time restriction of that 8 to 5.30 or 8.35? [1:32:54] Would that really, would that limit how fast they might, so for example, [1:32:58] if those restrictions weren't there, would they be going from six in the morning [1:33:01] till eight at night, all in dirt and doing it more quickly? [1:33:08] There is quite the schedule. [1:33:10] It's very fast paced. [1:33:11] They possibly wouldn't use more than that. [1:33:14] Yes, I would say during the summer hours, they would try to extend at least a seven o'clock. [1:33:18] at night with the sunsetting there shadows and stuff like that. That'd be a great idea. [1:33:24] I don't know if I 30s answer either. I just pick those times down. [1:33:31] Sam Hawkins. [1:33:33] Would it be possible to maybe leave it open Monday through Friday for the contractors [1:33:37] and just have it for the public on the weekends and that way the contractors can get their [1:33:42] job done in a timely manner and along with that again making sure that the public knows [1:33:47] what plan we come up with and I was thinking even maybe [1:33:50] assigned at the top of the grade before they drive all the way [1:33:52] down to remind them that Auger Falls is not available during [1:33:55] these hours. [1:33:58] But I definitely think we need to have a fair compromise [1:34:01] because we don't want to hinder the contractors from getting it [1:34:03] done either. [1:34:05] And so maybe a five day for the contractor in a two day for the [1:34:08] public would even work. [1:34:10] three point B. Council any, oh, Dennis, welcome sir. [1:34:22] Thank you. I started to like to know, you know, I met with some of our user groups, you know, [1:34:27] what I call them, the Audubon Society of the Burgers. I met with the Mountain Bikers, [1:34:31] and also I met with the Historical Society. So there's kind of a lot of the large users of the park. [1:34:37] And I told them about what is happening. [1:34:39] And they'll don't close the park. [1:34:41] They said, do not close the park. [1:34:42] And I 100% agree with that, because it was close for eight [1:34:45] months last year. [1:34:46] And I just really believe that would be a mistake. [1:34:48] We'll close it down completely. [1:34:50] So I told them about the options that Troy came up with [1:34:52] option number three. [1:34:53] And they were acceptable of that option. [1:34:57] They said they'd like to have the option to be there early [1:34:59] in the morning if they want to go walking. [1:35:00] Some people, especially during the summer time, they'll get [1:35:02] down there at 6 AM to beat the heat. [1:35:05] And then also they like to have it after they get off work at five or so like that. [1:35:09] And the weekends definitely keep the weekends open, you know. [1:35:11] So I would be fully supportive of option number three, what is provided. [1:35:18] And also I think we have the option of by the treatment plant, [1:35:22] the original gate dog or falls is still there, you know. [1:35:25] So I hope on that, you know, the contractor work with that because, you know, [1:35:29] a lot of people you'll tell them it's closed, they're going to drive down. [1:35:32] They're going to walk down there anyway. [1:35:33] And if the gates open, they're going to keep on going in there. [1:35:36] So hopefully the contractor that, you know, our engineering department can work with them [1:35:40] about having a person there or you're going to have people going in there all the time. [1:35:44] But I think for the safety of all concerns of the users of the park, [1:35:47] option number three is the best option. [1:35:49] Thank you. [1:35:51] That's a good input. [1:35:52] Appreciate it. [1:35:53] It's changed the way I was thinking. [1:35:55] Chris talking to. [1:35:56] So move three. [1:35:58] Second. [1:35:59] We have a motion on floor for option number three by Chris talkington seconded by Greg [1:36:05] Lanting anything further on that motion council. I see no lights. Yeah, please [1:36:12] Talking to yes [1:36:14] Greg Lanting yes John Hall. Yes, that's like a mils like that. Yes [1:36:19] Suzanne Hawkins. Yes. Jim on yes Sean Baraker. Yes post [1:36:26] motion passes seven to zero [1:36:28] Moving on to number five, discussion and a request for direction regarding a city's regulation of on-street large truck parking [1:36:37] Mitch Humble. [1:36:41] So, I just turned that off. [1:36:44] I should probably put some photos in there. [1:36:47] We have, city code right now has some statements that have brought big trucks and big trailers and it's, [1:36:54] we define what big trucks and big trailers are as more than one and a half time capacity or more than 22 feet long [1:37:00] Those kind of things that they cannot park on city streets where the zoning is a residential zone [1:37:07] Unless they're actively being loaded or unloaded and we've had at times where that's been a problem where where trucks will park [1:37:13] and their block visibility is at intersections or they'll be in front of a business and and so at times what we've had to do is [1:37:20] We've used a different section of the city code that says we could put up signs that regulate parking along the streets like [1:37:26] you know, no parking for [1:37:28] More than two hours or no parking overnight or whatever and we can put these signs up and then we can enforce the signage [1:37:35] And what we found what we think we found is that that pushes the trucks somewhere else [1:37:39] It just moves the problem and so we saw that happen about two years ago around [1:37:46] Get the name of the street wrong the the one behind the [1:37:51] The Shiloh and by by UPS there, right [1:37:54] There we go. We put some signs up because we're having a problem with truck parking and [1:38:00] they cleared right out of there and then we found some trucks over by Walmart and the [1:38:04] Norco area and that's I think what we did was we just pushed the problem to another location [1:38:10] and we started to receive complaints about the trucks parking around Norco and Walmart [1:38:17] first from homeowners that said their refrigerator trucks were running the refrigerators all night [1:38:21] long and I got kind of noisy and then from business owners in the area and then from the [1:38:25] property owners just trying to sell lots and some of those guys who are here tonight might [1:38:28] want to come up and share their thoughts on this problem with you if you're inclined to [1:38:32] allow that mayor. [1:38:38] The problem also we took some photographs and showed you there's trash being dumped out [1:38:43] on the side of the roads and there's all kinds of issues that are coming up with this and [1:38:47] internally we talked about this at a staff level and how are we going to deal with this and we [1:38:51] You could put signs up and we think again that will just push the trucks somewhere else [1:38:54] and we'll have to do with it again and again and again. [1:38:57] And maybe the better solution is instead to do a change to the code. [1:39:00] And we've got looking at that. [1:39:03] If we're going to allow a use of someone's land as a truck parking lot, the only places [1:39:11] where that's outright permitted use is in the manufacturing zones. [1:39:16] So yeah, thinking, if that's an outright permitted use in the manufacturing zones, why would we [1:39:21] then allow that to be outright permitted on street in other zones? [1:39:26] And so maybe there's a justification to do a code amendment, and this is not Title 10, [1:39:31] this is a Title 9 parking, how we regulate parking and traffic on the streets kind of thing. [1:39:40] Maybe we do a code amendment there that says, parking on streets of these big trucks with [1:39:44] big trailers needs to happen in manufacturing zones, to be more consistent with how we would [1:39:51] treat it from a zoning perspective. [1:39:53] So we thought we'd come and chat with the council if there's any interest in moving forward [1:39:57] like that. [1:39:58] So that's kind of why we're here. [1:40:00] I didn't want to just bring you an ordinance and say, hey, what do you think? [1:40:03] Rather have a conversation first and let these guys come and share their thoughts with you [1:40:07] as well. [1:40:08] So with that, it's just like I said, short and sweet, and if you have questions, I'll [1:40:12] try to answer them, and these guys are here from the property owners of North Haven. [1:40:18] Subdivision is what it's called. [1:40:19] So this doesn't change anything regarding these trucks parking on private property. [1:40:25] So if you wanted to have a truck parking lot on private property, we would deal with you [1:40:31] from a zoning code perspective, not from a Title IX perspective anymore, right? [1:40:35] You could, then you're talking land use, and you could create that as a land use. [1:40:40] In the M1, M2 districts, you just build a truck parking lot. [1:40:44] You could get an SUP to do it in a C1 zone. [1:40:49] And we would, like I said, we would deal with that from a zoning perspective. [1:40:52] So I do still do that on private. [1:40:54] If you were to go through the process to establish and create the use. [1:40:59] So I do see that from time to time, Mitch, on people's residential private property that's [1:41:03] big enough within the city limits. [1:41:05] Okay. [1:41:06] And they park there. [1:41:07] I see what you're saying. [1:41:08] Yeah. [1:41:09] It's a totally different direction, Nick. [1:41:12] So a guy who drives a truck for a living, maybe, [1:41:14] he comes home and he drops his trailer wherever the office is, [1:41:18] and he pulls up and charges his cab at his property. [1:41:23] On his property. [1:41:24] On his property. [1:41:25] He can't park on the street in front of his house [1:41:28] because that would be a violation of Title IX, 968. [1:41:33] If he's on his property, that's currently kind of a gray area. [1:41:38] So, it's a type of vehicle that isn't normally found in a residential zone, and so, we get [1:41:44] into this home occupation sort of a business, and can they really do that or not? [1:41:54] We have a code amendment coming before the council. [1:41:57] I think fairly soon, we're scheduling it for PENZ right now, to redo our parking section [1:42:03] of our code. [1:42:05] And this is an issue that we dealt with with the Zwat Committee. [1:42:09] And as we moved through that process, and there's a provision in there for trucks and big things [1:42:16] parking on residential properties within required parking spaces for homes, which basically what [1:42:25] we're going to propose in that is you have a couple of required parking spaces. [1:42:30] Those need to be for vehicles that are normally associated with residential vehicles. [1:42:34] above and beyond that if you put like a little gravel spot on the side or whatever. [1:42:38] We're not going to go there. [1:42:40] I actually see. [1:42:42] I actually see in one residence that has a big, [1:42:46] he's got a lot of land next to his house. He brings his whole truck and trailer and parks in there. [1:42:52] And in that case right now, like I said, there's a [1:42:56] provision in the code where we might call that like a home occupation [1:43:01] with an exterior, I'm trying to word missing the words, right? [1:43:07] There's some kind of visual clue outside of the home that says there's a guy who lives here who works out of his home. [1:43:13] And a vehicle that isn't necessarily associated or isn't typically associated with residents [1:43:18] is one of those indicators that might say that guy needs to come through the SUP process [1:43:23] to get an SUP for a home occupation. [1:43:27] And then he's in front of the Planning and Zoning Commission saying yes or no, can I do this or cannot do this? [1:43:33] That would be probably how we approach that. In fact, we just had an SGP at last week's P&Z meeting. It was very similar to that. [1:43:41] It wasn't a semi-tractive trailer, but it was a smaller dump truck and a [1:43:47] backhoe, right, and they did get an SGP in that case. Very good. Chris talking to [1:43:53] So every summer, fall and spring, most of the time around the clock, Fred Meyer can have [1:44:04] a half-dozen or more semis perk there. [1:44:07] I don't know if they're related to deliveries, I mean they're refrigerated semis and everything. [1:44:14] That's not an M1 zone, so that would become a non-allowed use. [1:44:22] So slightly different scenario. [1:44:24] They're with Fred Meyer or Walmart itself [1:44:26] might have the trucks that are delivering to Walmart, [1:44:29] the same kind of a thing or Costco [1:44:30] or any number of businesses that are gonna have a truck [1:44:32] come and back into the place [1:44:35] and then maybe sit there overnight [1:44:36] and go away the next morning. [1:44:39] Wouldn't necessarily call that a truck parking lot, [1:44:41] rather just deliveries to the store [1:44:44] that is the allowed use there. [1:44:46] If they are selling parking spaces to trucks [1:44:51] As an overnight storage of your truck kind of a business as a side, then maybe we do have an issue there. [1:44:58] If they're delivering to the store and are staying there for day or two, I don't know that that's the same. [1:45:05] The same use as a truck parking lot. [1:45:08] Okay, and then back on this amendment to Title IX, if we allow off-street parking only in the M1 or M2, [1:45:17] to anything on street would be a tick of a bull item. [1:45:22] A truck, yeah, any truck that meets the definition of a big truck, right, and it's very clear [1:45:27] in here what that's defined as, yeah. [1:45:30] If it's on the street not actively unloading or loading, then, yeah, you could run out with [1:45:35] the police department or even the code enforcement guys as they have been now empowered to issue [1:45:41] traffic tickets or parking tickets. [1:45:43] I mean, they could, in one of those two groups, [1:45:46] he could go out and make sure it doesn't take. [1:45:48] And I forgot to ask, in your information, [1:45:51] did you include any review of what's done in other Idaho [1:45:54] studies, they must have the very same problem? [1:45:56] We haven't looked at it that closely yet, [1:45:58] but we've, like I said, we wanted to come have the conversation [1:46:02] before we went and prepared an ordinance. [1:46:04] So if there's any, this is typically [1:46:06] how we do it with the zoning code kind of a thing. [1:46:08] And so I guess when I got involved, [1:46:10] I just thought this was a fair step to take first. [1:46:13] Greg. [1:46:15] Well, actually, I would like to put my light on to, since we have the biggest area that [1:46:21] I've seen in town is the area in North Avon, I guess that's the name of your property over [1:46:26] there, where I was two there one day and there was 11 trucks there, several of them just the [1:46:32] trailers, no tractors. [1:46:35] And then like you said, I actually was walking from Ball Mart to the hospital back and tremendous [1:46:41] amount of trash those gentlemen go through a lot of different equipment [1:46:45] different things including concerns because a lot of it seems to be alcoholic [1:46:50] and then their truck driver so if we could hear from those gentlemen I would [1:46:53] appreciate it well I was just gonna allow council to ask questions of staff and [1:46:59] then I was absolutely gonna bring you gentlemen up so bear with me Rebecca [1:47:05] Thank you. [1:47:06] Thank you, Mayor. [1:47:07] Just a question. [1:47:08] You mentioned Mitch that, you know, some of the parking and title 9 has been covered or [1:47:15] talked about in ZOAC. [1:47:16] So how come this didn't go through ZOAC or is it on a fast track somehow? [1:47:22] The parking amendment that's going to come our way is an entitled line. [1:47:27] It's actually a title 10. [1:47:28] It's a zoning ordinance amendment that's coming. [1:47:31] the zoning ordinance amendment committee was established to deal with zoning ordinance amendments [1:47:37] and this one is not part of that. [1:47:38] So ZOAC hasn't talked about this on-street parking. [1:47:43] And what determines is it just because it's Title 10 or I'd be curious to see what the [1:47:48] ZOAC committee or P&Z might think about this, I was just curious and I kind of thought that [1:47:53] was a process. [1:47:54] Title 9 doesn't have anything to deal with ZOAC or with the Planning and Zoning Commission. [1:47:59] It's purely a council directed and if we wanted to, we can always ask them to do it. [1:48:05] We just wouldn't necessarily make that part of the process in default, I guess. [1:48:10] Just curious. [1:48:11] I think my goal is usually to not over regulate. [1:48:17] I guess I don't really understand maybe fully what the difference of what our code says now [1:48:21] and what this new ordinance would propose. [1:48:25] To me it seems like a C1 zoning would be adequate to be able to park these trucks in a C1 zone [1:48:32] if a property, you know, because I know you mentioned having it only M1 and M2, but honestly [1:48:40] these trucks are coming in and out of these stores and businesses, so I really don't have [1:48:46] a problem with them in the C1 zone. [1:48:48] This is Ann Hawkins. [1:48:51] Well, Chris might walk the grade, this is my exercise neighborhood. [1:48:55] This is my backyard and I can tell you there are days where I'm scared to walk down here [1:49:01] behind these lines of truck because you are totally hidden from everybody else's view. [1:49:07] And those guys in their truck sometimes scare me when I'm out walking alone. [1:49:09] I admit it. [1:49:10] I can take a bag with me and pick up trash while I'm walking. [1:49:14] And so to me this is personal because I deal with this regularly. [1:49:18] In fact, I was actually going to call and ask how come they're allowed to park there because [1:49:23] it has become a nuisance. [1:49:25] And I agree that the trucks do not belong in this neighborhood. [1:49:29] And I can't imagine the high school students that are affected by this. [1:49:35] It's right in their neck of the woods. [1:49:37] There's a lot of business starting to develop in this area. [1:49:41] It's a very nice area and trucks should not be parked on the streets here. [1:49:46] I'm very supportive of putting this to the M1 and M2 and keeping our city clean and friendly for everybody. [1:49:52] So, can I may, I should add to this been my presentation initially. [1:49:58] I talked about adding signage like under our current code would allow us to do. [1:50:02] We believe kind of pushes the problem for one place to another. [1:50:05] We've had enough complaints on this to where we have actually talked about adding signage [1:50:10] anyway, but we believe that again that's going to push from somewhere else. [1:50:14] We need to fix the problem as well, but we do want to add signs here anyway because of the problem [1:50:20] that's being done here. [1:50:22] in addition to fixing the code as well. [1:50:26] So, you know. [1:50:28] Thank you, Mitch Travis, before I bring the gentleman up. [1:50:30] Just from a case of precedence, I think it's important [1:50:33] to recognize that we've placed these signs [1:50:36] in other locations in the past based upon the number [1:50:39] of complaints that we received. [1:50:41] An example would be over by the Shilohin. [1:50:43] We had numerous complaints by individuals [1:50:47] that operate the Shilohin and then also [1:50:48] in that surrounding neighborhood where the tractor trailers would move [1:50:52] in their refrigerator units would be moving and that it would be causing noise disturbances [1:50:58] in the very early morning hours and so as a result of that, we actually took this similar [1:51:04] step. [1:51:05] It was Mitch and his team's idea to say, you know, all we're going to do, like he says, [1:51:11] continue to push these problems into different areas in our community if we don't find a way [1:51:15] to actively address it. [1:51:17] We're back. [1:51:20] Oh, just a follow-up question on that. [1:51:22] How many complaints have you had and for how long? [1:51:30] So this is a difficult one to measure because the police department gets a lot of the phone [1:51:36] calls on this, except that as I think Suzanne was starting to allude to, it's not a violation [1:51:42] of anything. [1:51:43] So they don't actually record it as a complaint as it comes in through dispatch. [1:51:48] So we asked dispatch exactly what it is. [1:51:49] How many calls do you have? [1:51:50] they don't even count them because there was nothing, [1:51:54] there was no violation to report, [1:51:55] so they just answered the people's questions, [1:51:57] say it's legal, and then they hang the phone up [1:51:59] and move on. [1:52:00] It was enough of a load to where our traffic sergeant [1:52:06] began to start paying attention, [1:52:08] and he's the one that went out and looked, [1:52:09] and okay, now we see trash on the ground, and okay, right, [1:52:12] so they're starting to piece it all together. [1:52:15] What has come into my department in code enforcement, [1:52:18] We've had complaints from the Norco business, [1:52:22] and then I think three different homeowners [1:52:25] in the neighborhood to the south of there [1:52:29] have called and complained. [1:52:30] So like four to five, maybe it'll be safe. [1:52:32] So about five different complaints [1:52:35] have come into code enforcement. [1:52:37] What we can't have, what we don't have a good count of [1:52:39] is those calls that came into dispatch, [1:52:41] and there were several. [1:52:43] Okay, and my other question is about the trash [1:52:45] I was actually thinking of, you know, [1:52:47] How do we know where that is coming from? [1:52:49] I mean, I have no idea how you would know. [1:52:51] I was actually thinking there's a high school nearby, [1:52:54] there's a lot of things going on, [1:52:56] not to blame anyone in particular. [1:52:59] So the trash, I don't know how that weighs into the decision, [1:53:03] but definitely the complaints would. [1:53:06] Gentlemen, if you'd like to come forward [1:53:07] and state your name and address, we'll allow you a few minutes. [1:53:15] Thank you for the record. [1:53:17] My name is Gerald Martin. [1:53:18] one of the owners and developers of the North Haven Subdivision that precipitated at least [1:53:24] this action or the push in the last couple three weeks. [1:53:29] North Haven Subdivision basically is a land to the west of Walmart between there and the [1:53:34] hospital. [1:53:36] The city streets are developed as a street, but the businesses haven't filled up the space [1:53:42] yet. [1:53:43] The truckers have found it. [1:53:44] We started out with two or three and we kind of ignored it up to 17 trucks over the weekend. [1:53:52] Some of them were there all weekend. [1:53:54] They're local people making a living. [1:53:57] They need a place to park their truck, the word spreads, and they will move somewhere else. [1:54:02] But a C1 zone is an inappropriate place. [1:54:06] We're trying to market that property. [1:54:08] It doesn't market well, and I think somebody else will address that. [1:54:13] businesses that are there, Norco, and the dialysis center. [1:54:17] People are afraid to go there early in the morning [1:54:21] or whenever with the trucks. [1:54:23] On Sunday, nine of the trucks that I went by [1:54:27] had the generators running on the coolers [1:54:31] to keep the product cool. [1:54:33] Most of the trucks are unoccupied, [1:54:35] but some of them, I think they were occupied. [1:54:38] There's no way of really knowing. [1:54:39] But it's a real problem, and it's getting worse every day. [1:54:47] Signage, we need signage, we need enforcement. [1:54:50] But the truckers need a place to go. [1:54:52] And they need, I don't know how you do that, but they need some. [1:54:59] They'll find it if we, they have their own internal communication. [1:55:03] They'll find the place to go park. [1:55:06] I know that the truck stops, for example, [1:55:10] used to accommodate a lot of them out of petrope, [1:55:13] but if you don't buy fuel, they won't [1:55:15] un-park there anymore. [1:55:17] So these are out of space. [1:55:19] There are a lot of trucks on the highway, [1:55:20] and it'll move unless there's an alternative provided. [1:55:24] But the C1 zone is not the appropriate location. [1:55:27] It's uncomfortable to buyers. [1:55:29] It's uncomfortable to residents around it. [1:55:32] It's uncomfortable to even the people that drive the street. [1:55:38] It's to drive down between those row trucks on each side. [1:55:41] You're not exactly sure where you're going. [1:55:44] So with that, let's somebody else speak. [1:55:46] Thank you, Mr. Martins. [1:55:56] Council, I'm Bob Thay. [1:55:57] I'm the owner of Kenyon Cider and Realty and the broker. [1:56:00] We're marketing agents for the owners on this property. [1:56:03] And I'm here just to reinforce, this [1:56:04] is a very negative effect out there to potential buyers [1:56:08] to see that. [1:56:09] We already have photographs of the property prior to when the trucker started there, but there's no way I'd want to shoot any photographs [1:56:16] Do any advertising of that property outside of the state? It's a very high-end commercial site. It's very nice [1:56:22] This is really detrimental to the site and to the marketing [1:56:26] Thank you, mr. Bay. Thank you [1:56:28] anyone else [1:56:30] No, they haven't [1:56:34] Yeah, we don't [1:56:36] Welcome, Mr. Robertson. [1:56:41] I think Councilwoman Hawkins sort of summed up exactly what I'm thinking. [1:56:46] We groused a little, we developed that, saw the winter, right away, [1:56:52] that was required by the city. We thought my word. [1:56:55] That looks like quite a boulevard. [1:56:57] Little did we know that now we're down to a single lane almost every night. [1:57:02] I don't know if you planned it that way or not. [1:57:05] which were after for the truck location, but they've certainly found it, and the only thing [1:57:09] I would like to add to what's been said is that I agree that maybe this is a land use [1:57:15] issue. It might be a policing issue, but whatever you do with your code, please take Mitch's suggestion [1:57:23] that we also use signage because that's a lot better than having to call the police [1:57:29] every time they're out there. I think if we could discourage it through signage, that [1:57:33] would be a lot of help to us. I've been amazed, as Gerald said, started with a couple of trucks, [1:57:40] and I kind of, like one of you mentioned, thought it might be somebody that was delivering to Walmart, [1:57:48] but then the next time I was out there with more, and now it's gone to the point where as Gerald said, [1:57:53] 14 or 17 trucks, and they drop the trailers and drive off and come back, some of them, and some of [1:57:59] them or both tractor and trailer so anything you can do to help would be [1:58:03] appreciated. Thank you Mr. Repson. Greg Manning. Well I would like to I would be [1:58:12] certainly in favor of having you bring forth a ordinance to us like you said I've [1:58:19] been through that area and as far as where the tracks from from there's [1:58:22] tracks where the trucks are you go around over onto the other streets that [1:58:26] the trucks aren't parked on and there's no tracks yeah it's not somebody else [1:58:29] It's coming out of those trucks and [1:58:33] Like Evan said there's times you go down there. There's trucks parked the entire length of whatever that street is there [1:58:40] That goes in front of Norco. They'll be there's trucks on both sides the full length of it [1:58:45] Which just means you got a one-lane road? [1:58:47] You mean you could see we'll get two cars there, but it feels uncomfortable and I think it's time I [1:58:54] Believe we need to we need to probably help them to find other places to park [1:58:57] I'm not saying that, but I just don't think that C1 works for these truck parking on-street truck parking [1:59:06] Thank you great Chris talking to me. I would so move that the council on his shade of code amendment [1:59:11] to 968 [1:59:14] allowing on-street large truck parking only in the M1 M2 zones [1:59:20] Second we have a motion on floor by Chris talking to him [1:59:24] seconded by Jim on my hair. [1:59:30] Suzanne Hawkins. [1:59:33] These questions for Mitch. [1:59:34] Are you ready for us to go that far tonight? [1:59:36] Or are you needing to do more work and decide how it's all going to play out? [1:59:41] That's actually what we're looking for. [1:59:43] Okay. [1:59:44] It'll come back to us. [1:59:45] Okay. [1:59:46] We'll bring you an ordinance. [1:59:47] I just wanted to make sure. [1:59:48] Yeah. [1:59:49] We'll bring an ordinance back. [1:59:51] Okay. [1:59:52] We'll look into a couple of other cities too, like Councilman Talkin and its [1:59:57] suggestion too. Thank you. We're back in Mill Soikum. Thank you Mayor. Well like I said I [2:00:02] don't really know I think having up information to really make a decision on [2:00:06] this motion but I do have a question. I am kind of bothered we haven't addressed [2:00:13] the on-street parking issue in some other areas that we've been talking about on [2:00:18] County Crest Drive and on North College between Falls and Locust. So what is the [2:00:26] process for that? I mean I am kind of bothered by the fact that you know this [2:00:31] can come up so quickly but we still haven't addressed our other on-street [2:00:34] parking. Why is that? So the on-street parking issues that [2:00:38] can encrest her residential cars in front of the parking in front of the [2:00:45] apartment complex and those could be addressed exactly the same way. I mean you [2:00:49] could put signs up to say no parking on that street as well. We have never got to [2:00:58] the point where we felt that was a big enough problem to I guess put the signs. [2:01:03] I would like us to I think we've talked about it enough and because I think [2:01:09] there are similar issues here you know of the safety and the visibility issues so [2:01:15] So I think we should move forward on addressing other areas in our community where we have [2:01:19] on-street parking issues. [2:01:21] I see no further lights. [2:01:26] The other room call vote please. [2:01:28] Greg Lanthine? [2:01:29] Yes. [2:01:30] John Hall? [2:01:31] Yes. [2:01:32] Rebecca Mel-Soyka? [2:01:33] No. [2:01:35] Susan Hawkins? [2:01:36] Yes. [2:01:37] Jim Mann? [2:01:38] Yes. [2:01:39] Sean Berriger? [2:01:40] Yes. [2:01:41] Chris Chalkington? [2:01:42] Yes. [2:01:43] Motion passes 6-1. [2:01:46] to the next item on the agenda is consideration to authorize the city manager [2:01:51] to sign an agreement with Cushlan and associates to review and assist the city [2:01:55] manager in aligning the organization around the two thousand the city's two [2:02:02] thousand thirty strategic plan Travis welcome [2:02:06] thank you Mr. Mayor members of the council just on the other item real quick we [2:02:12] will go forward and we'll take a look at those other parking issues councilman [2:02:17] And Rebecca feels like a brought up, and we'll take a look at those and bring those [2:02:21] also with possible solutions for equal treatment. [2:02:28] So again, what you have before you is an agreement, and in the agreement it also defines [2:02:34] a possible work scope that kind of outlines moving forward. [2:02:38] And I want to talk about how this kind of came about. [2:02:40] Because over the course of the last, well even before the last conversation of the last [2:02:45] If we had a conversation about, is there opportunities that we can better align our organization? [2:02:50] Are there opportunities that we can maybe do things different in terms of how we are aligned [2:02:54] internally? [2:02:58] And I thought that we had a pretty good course of action, but maybe hindsight being 2020, the [2:03:02] good course of action was probably largely dependent upon a personality in Mr. Williams [2:03:08] and the skill sets that he brought to the table as opposed to maybe what are the long-term [2:03:13] benefits and needs of the organization. [2:03:16] So I think with Mr. Williams departure, it really does provide us the opportunity to kind [2:03:19] of take a step back. [2:03:21] And then Caste focused out maybe ten years. [2:03:25] Because over the course of the next ten years, the organization is going to see some turnover [2:03:31] and key senior management roles and positions inside our organization because of their tenure. [2:03:39] We have been very, very blessed inside the city of Twin Falls to have individuals have [2:03:44] long ten years and to be able to grow up into our organization and assume different leadership [2:03:49] roles. [2:03:50] And when you look, that really is almost a celebration of our organization. [2:03:56] And in doing so, I think that it would be important for us to have a conversation about [2:04:00] what does the organization look like and what does it need to look like if we are going [2:04:04] to continue to further advance the strategic plan. [2:04:08] And I put this up here because this, when we had our conversation process, this was a chart [2:04:12] that was produced by Phil Kuchlin. [2:04:14] And in that conversation, he said, our strategic planning process is going to help us align our [2:04:19] fiscal priorities. [2:04:21] It's going to help us take a look at our organizational structure, our partnerships, [2:04:25] a strategic action, all to achieve a long-term vision. [2:04:28] And I think that if we take a moment and take the organization and begin to align it underneath [2:04:34] our strategic plan in a manner that makes good, logical sense, I think that we're going [2:04:38] to be able to advance the organization. [2:04:40] Now what I can't tell you is what that looks like. [2:04:42] Because if I was able to tell you what that looks like, [2:04:44] there wouldn't be the need to be able to move forward [2:04:47] with this contract. [2:04:48] The other thing is I think it's important to involve many people [2:04:52] in this conversation and in this process, [2:04:54] because this structure is not just mine, [2:04:57] it's all of our structure. [2:04:58] And I want to have a conversation with all the department leaders [2:05:02] about what this looks like. [2:05:03] Because at the end, we may find that the structure [2:05:07] that we have is works well for us and we maintain and keep it the same and there [2:05:11] are things shortly into the scope that we just stop and say we're fine or we [2:05:16] continue to say that there are better ways and that we advance through the entire [2:05:20] process. In any event I think it's important that we're all involved in that [2:05:24] conversation as we kind of look ten years out and move forward so with that I'll be [2:05:28] happy to stand for any questions the council might have. Any questions for our [2:05:32] City Manager. Rebecca Melsoika. Thank you, Mayor. The [2:05:39] approximate cost is about $20,000. Can you tell us more about what that would [2:05:43] include and what the time frame would be, how long this process might take? So if [2:05:48] you take a look at the very back of the, so the first three pages describe the [2:05:57] agreement and then attachment A describes the different tasks that we kind of move [2:06:02] forward. It talks about developing an organizational plan. I think one of the first things is to [2:06:06] recognize that when Mr. Williams was here, he was carrying a considerable workload. And [2:06:12] now that workload has been placed onto my desk. And right now I have a great team that's able [2:06:18] to help me out and move forward, but there's going to come a time where we need to probably [2:06:24] allow them to be able to go do their things. I've talked about in terms of helping creating [2:06:29] what's called an internal internship type program where I actually draft an employee [2:06:35] inside the organization to help me do some heavy lifting temporarily. We've identified [2:06:40] an individual to be able to do that, but we also want to make sure that we're utilizing [2:06:44] his time and his skill sets appropriately. And I haven't had a chance to really sit down [2:06:49] to see what skill sets he's going to be able to bring to allow him to be successful in [2:06:53] this role. It's a temporary duty. It's a temporary assignment. It's not something that is necessarily [2:06:58] to achieve long-term future of the organization. [2:07:01] The benefit of an internal internship program allows greater exposure to all people inside [2:07:09] the organization. [2:07:10] So not only is it a benefit to me, but it may be something that we carry on because it's [2:07:13] a learning benefit to members throughout the organization. [2:07:19] I really believe that when you start looking at these time frames, like the second task [2:07:24] is to talk about transition plan where you'll see a lot of that and then introduce the concept [2:07:28] of organizational structure and change. [2:07:34] So when you take a look at those, I [2:07:37] think it's important that really walking through what this [2:07:42] looks like to help the organization answer those [2:07:45] questions. [2:07:45] Now what I will say is I'm taking a long-about approach [2:07:49] to answer your question, because what you'll see here [2:07:51] is a lot of steps. [2:07:55] And at any point in time along these steps, [2:07:57] we may decide that we're good. [2:08:01] The organizational structure that we have in place [2:08:04] continues to roll forward and we hire an assistant [2:08:07] to and fill that position and fill that role and move forward. [2:08:09] Or we may define that we want to do a different role, [2:08:12] change the organization, have different people report [2:08:15] to the city manager or even have a full-scale reorganization [2:08:19] where you have different department leads [2:08:21] reporting in different areas. [2:08:23] To help further advance the strategic plan. [2:08:26] I am hoping because of the current workload that this project can be completed within the [2:08:31] next six months and then we have a course of action that we can implement in conjunction [2:08:37] with the upcoming budget process. [2:08:41] Thank you, Travis. [2:08:43] I think I could support definitely this expenditure if it is for that change and for that. [2:08:50] I think I would be less satisfied with this process if we were to come back and spend this [2:08:55] money and just to say, oh, we're good. I think we're doing well because I agree with the concept [2:09:02] and the philosophy of organizing the city based on the outcomes that we want to see and not [2:09:08] based on personalities and people, individuals. I think that it would be best for the overall [2:09:14] good of the city and the organization to do some reorganization. I know, as you've said, [2:09:21] been people that have just kind of come along and filled certain positions and it might be [2:09:26] a good time to take a look at where we're at and where we're trying to go rather than [2:09:32] just say this is the way we've always done it, it works for us. [2:09:37] So I would welcome change and I would welcome reorganization based on efficiencies and art [2:09:44] goals as a city. [2:09:46] Travis, I look at it this way. I think that we're moving from a big town to a small city. [2:09:52] We're making that transition. We're seeing a lot of different moving parts within our community, [2:10:00] all the way from very large businesses coming to us. And we as a staff have to flex and move with [2:10:08] those organizations to try to help them come into our community businesses. But also we're looking [2:10:16] in the near future, some issues regarding public transportation and other issues and I think [2:10:25] that we really do need to try to align that strategic plan. I think it was, I mean that [2:10:31] was in my humble opinion a really great work of art to give us some guidance with how do [2:10:39] we have our staff work at their most optimal function, [2:10:43] optimal abilities to get us there. [2:10:47] And we're still really structured under the small town, [2:10:51] or big town structure within our organization. [2:10:56] And sometimes it's really good to have someone [2:10:58] from the outside come in and really take a look [2:11:01] and interview and know what's out there, [2:11:04] what really works for other communities. [2:11:07] maybe our size or bigger that's been effective. [2:11:11] I think that planning would be very, very beneficial to us. [2:11:16] So I like the concept here. [2:11:18] Now as far as paying for this, [2:11:21] I'm assuming we could say that the salary savings [2:11:26] from the position we no longer have [2:11:30] could go towards that. [2:11:31] Is that what you were thinking? [2:11:33] To cover the cost of the scope of the concept. [2:11:35] Absolutely, so we will have a fully burdened salary savings associated with the departure of the assistant to the city manager. [2:11:43] And we would apply those salary savings to offset the cost of the professional services contract before you. [2:11:50] The other thing that the only concern I really have here, and maybe it's not a concern or maybe I'll just voice it, is the time table of [2:11:59] is potentially doing this fairly rapidly, right? [2:12:05] But it would not go beyond June of 2015. [2:12:10] That's, I mean, 14. [2:12:15] The agreement refers to. [2:12:18] Right, and it does, and I think that what Mr. Quishland [2:12:22] was thinking about is that if there were some other services [2:12:26] and so that may be provided, [2:12:28] he has a longer window and coverage here. [2:12:32] This, I will tell you from a survival standpoint, [2:12:34] speaking just from my current, you can't last that long. [2:12:39] Well, this needs to get in, get it done, get out, [2:12:44] so that it's in line for consideration [2:12:47] during the upcoming budget. [2:12:49] Well, that was my concern, is the 2015. [2:12:51] Certainly, we could maybe talk to him about other things [2:12:54] down the road, but in this contract for, I'd say, [2:12:56] 2015 leads me to believe that, [2:12:59] potentially, that's how long it's gonna take, [2:13:01] And that's not functional for our organization or you. [2:13:05] I want you to have some hair left on your head. [2:13:08] I don't know if you can prevent that. [2:13:10] I have four to six years. [2:13:11] I want to do all I can to prevent the loss of it. [2:13:15] How's that sound? [2:13:16] Captain Barnhart has a great hairstyle [2:13:18] that I'm looking at going into. [2:13:20] I understand that. [2:13:21] So is that something that we would want to adjust? [2:13:24] Do you want to keep that in there, June of 15? [2:13:26] No, I can make that adjustment. [2:13:28] I think that the June of 15 is just a real safe, [2:13:31] depending for Mr. Kushner to ensure that he gets in, [2:13:34] he gets the task completed. [2:13:36] I'm less concerned about the date of the contract [2:13:40] as I am about getting it done expeditiously [2:13:45] and completing those tasks that are described [2:13:47] in the attachment. [2:13:48] Very good, thank you, sir. [2:13:49] Chris, talking to you. [2:13:51] I have no problem with this, Coach. [2:13:53] I would guess that the sooner we could [2:13:55] get a meaningful result or a series of steps to take that certainly would be your priority [2:14:04] as well as ours. [2:14:06] Here's one thing that I'm most concerned with our current organization. [2:14:12] We have just completed four months of completely getting off track with the King and Rem fiasco. [2:14:19] We are now starting as of this afternoon meeting, trying to put more of our actions in place [2:14:27] with the strategic plan. [2:14:30] I don't see how you can run the city and monitor the strategic plan as effectively as [2:14:35] needs to be done. [2:14:37] It's an extremely aggressive document, and we put so much time into it, I would not want [2:14:43] to be diverted. [2:14:45] And I bring this down to a suggestion that you look into the role of an ombudsman. [2:14:51] Now the only ombudsman I'm really familiar with are those that are used in conjunction [2:14:56] with public safety as in Boise Police Department. [2:15:00] They had a series of communication faux-paws with the public from shootings or involvement [2:15:06] of, I think, police in contact with drug dealers that things went wrong enough. [2:15:14] They knew they had some policy and training issues. [2:15:18] I don't know if an ombudsman can or is effectively [2:15:21] used in other jurisdictions like ours, [2:15:24] but it seems to me that you could benefit [2:15:27] and the organization could benefit by somebody [2:15:31] who really has the hand on the throttle of the strategic plan [2:15:37] uses all the electronic tickle files [2:15:40] and everything that helped to assist you [2:15:44] so that you don't have to spend [2:15:46] in an ordinary amount of time following where we are. [2:15:49] I'm just suggesting that as a, [2:15:51] somehow within that organization, [2:15:53] I think it's too much to ask you to be [2:15:56] solely in charge or responsible for answering [2:15:59] our increasing questions about where we are [2:16:02] on the strategic plan, [2:16:04] because I'm planning to use that as my template [2:16:06] for this next two years of guidance to you and from you. [2:16:14] Sean Mariner. [2:16:16] And so I think that Phil's work with us [2:16:19] on the strategic plan was really helpful [2:16:23] in getting, yes, an aggressive document, [2:16:27] but I think something that really is guiding us [2:16:30] through budgeting and through our tasks. [2:16:34] I think using him to assist you [2:16:36] in making sure we have the right people in the right spots, [2:16:38] the right positions in the right spots to be implementing that. That was really important. [2:16:42] So if you think about it with Mike's departure, so for the first time in many years, you're [2:16:49] now the single person in the city manager office, because for a while it was Tom and [2:16:56] you and then you and Mike announced just you. So Tom and Gretchen before that. [2:17:01] So it's been some time and there definitely is a void there with that position vacant. [2:17:08] But I think you're thoughtful to make sure we're filling those positions correctly moving forward. [2:17:13] So I would be supportive of this proposal. [2:17:17] Suzanne Hawkins. [2:17:19] I'm going to echo what Sean just said. [2:17:21] I think using Cushlin Associates is a great choice. [2:17:24] They're already familiar with our city and how we function. [2:17:27] And so that kind of puts them a step ahead in the game plan. [2:17:32] When you were talking with Phil, how is his schedule looking? [2:17:35] And does he have the time to devote to us that we're going to need to move it on? [2:17:40] Or does he have other projects that are going to interfere with what we need from him? [2:17:44] Do you know? [2:17:45] When I had a conversation with Phil about developing a scope, I think that he was really [2:17:49] excited about this. [2:17:50] He's doing some work in some other communities, but I think that this is one that he's going [2:17:55] to be, and he seems to be very excited about. [2:17:58] And I think with that excitement, I think that we're going to be able to get through [2:18:01] it expeditiously. [2:18:03] I've shared with Phil that this is a huge priority, it needs to be done swiftly if it lingers. [2:18:12] It just means that I have greater opportunities than not being successful in my role. [2:18:17] Okay, thank you. [2:18:20] So are you looking for a direction, the motion to, so what I'm doing is I'm making an expenditure [2:18:27] that wasn't necessarily contemplated in the budgetary process and so I need the council [2:18:31] to authorize me to sign the agreement? [2:18:33] So with the caveat of working on that date, I mean you'll work on that, right? [2:18:40] Yes, I will. [2:18:41] Okay, thank you. [2:18:42] Greg Lanning. [2:18:43] I move to allow the City Manager or authorized the City Manager's on agreement with Cushlan [2:18:46] and Associates Review and Assist the City Manager in aligning the organization around [2:18:51] the city's 2030 strategic plan and the expenditure of $20,000 to do so. [2:18:58] Second. [2:18:59] Motion on four by Greg Lanning seconded by Rebecca Mills. [2:19:02] So I get up to 20,000. [2:19:04] Up to 21,000 is it? [2:19:06] I agree. [2:19:06] Yeah. [2:19:07] Very good. [2:19:08] Is the second good with that? [2:19:09] Up to. [2:19:11] Suzanne Hawkins. [2:19:13] Just a quick note. [2:19:14] I know that in our staff report notes, [2:19:16] it says approximately 20,000. [2:19:18] But if you look at the actual line item agreement, [2:19:22] it is showing 24, 480. [2:19:25] Yeah. [2:19:25] There are items that I don't believe [2:19:27] that we need to consider. [2:19:28] So I can party with those. [2:19:29] Okay, thank you. [2:19:30] Just wanted to make sure. [2:19:31] Good clarification, Suzanne. [2:19:32] Thank you. [2:19:33] Anything further on that motion council? [2:19:35] I see no lights. [2:19:36] Anything over the 20,000 comes out of Travis's park. [2:19:40] That's a no win. [2:19:42] I mean, I no lose. [2:19:47] I'll just linger on that just for the island, please. [2:19:51] Don Hall? [2:19:52] Yes. [2:19:52] Rebecca Melsoica? [2:19:53] Yes. [2:19:54] Suzanne Hawkins? [2:19:55] Yes. [2:19:56] Jim Mon? [2:19:57] Yes. [2:19:57] Sean Berger? [2:19:58] Yes. [2:19:59] Yes, motion passes seven to zero. [2:20:03] Next item on the agenda since we are not doing seven council. [2:20:07] It's public input and or items from city manager and or city council. [2:20:12] Anyone from the public wishing to approach. [2:20:16] I see no one items from city manager. [2:20:21] Nothing from our city manager. [2:20:23] We still have an executive session, of course, Council. [2:20:26] Greg Lant and our city council, Greg Lanning. [2:20:28] Yes, quick. [2:20:29] Just a quick note, the Gulf Advisory Board met last week [2:20:33] and they've had an interest from the HISTI family, [2:20:38] which is those of you who've been around here a long time [2:20:41] and at least played with my golfers, [2:20:42] know the HISTI family. [2:20:44] It used to be a superintendent and great golfers, [2:20:46] one of them including a quite lengthy stint on the PGA tour, [2:20:51] and they are looking to do some different things. [2:20:53] They're actually offering to help [2:20:56] with our friends and Muni tournament [2:20:58] And to bring in some names that will mean something to me, [2:21:02] but probably not to any of you, like Bill Rogers [2:21:04] and Don Janie Wiran, people like that [2:21:06] to actually participate in the tournament with us [2:21:08] to gather a bigger crowd. [2:21:11] And so we're looking forward to that. [2:21:13] We gave the commission, gave Dennis and Steve the go-ahead [2:21:17] to negotiate with them on how that's gonna look like. [2:21:20] They baseball players. [2:21:21] I know. [2:21:22] Golfers, golfers, Schumburger. [2:21:25] Amazing caddies. [2:21:26] So I wanted to make a clarification, there was a comment made actually last week during [2:21:32] the school bond levy presentation by a councilwoman Rebecca Melsoika that 85% of our citizens in [2:21:39] Twin Falls are within the poverty range and low income and that was then picked up in an [2:21:43] article in the Times News. [2:21:46] So I think that's an extreme overstatement of that number. [2:21:49] In fact, the US Census Bureau reports the city's persons below poverty level is 17%, 15.1% of [2:22:00] the state and 15.4% of the county. [2:22:02] So I wanted to clarify that because those kinds of things that get legs in a newspaper [2:22:07] article and then end up all over the internet are challenging for us and our recruitment [2:22:12] of companies and that positive image of the community. [2:22:16] So I just wanted to clarify that comment that was made last week. [2:22:20] I'd like to add on to that. [2:22:22] I actually talked to Rebecca just prior to the meeting, [2:22:24] and she was going to go back and research. [2:22:27] I think she, I don't want to put words in your mouth, Rebecca, [2:22:30] so you make sure you throw in here. [2:22:33] But I think she was meaning to say something different. [2:22:35] And because I had the same concern, [2:22:37] I actually asked staff to research it, [2:22:39] and they got a hold of Colleen Herring, [2:22:42] who provided the 2010 American Communities Report. [2:22:46] that actually shows all families below the poverty level [2:22:49] would be 14%, and then there's a bunch [2:22:53] of different related items, families with children [2:22:56] under 18 and single families and all those, [2:22:59] but all people in our area were 17%, [2:23:03] so vastly under 85% as well, so. [2:23:07] I'd like to also refute that with some figures. [2:23:10] Idaho as a whole, not one falls, [2:23:12] has the lowest weekly family paycheck income [2:23:16] of any state in the nation. [2:23:20] Thank you, Chris. [2:23:21] Rebecca, mostly. [2:23:23] Thank you, Councilman, for bringing that to my attention. [2:23:25] I didn't mean to say poverty level if I did. [2:23:28] I actually was talking about low income, [2:23:30] and I do know that our median household income is 41,000. [2:23:33] So as Councilman, [2:23:34] talking to his stating, [2:23:37] I was just referring to the level of income in our community. [2:23:41] And there are different charts in different areas [2:23:44] where low-income falls, but I certainly wouldn't consider 41,000 as being upper income level, [2:23:51] so. [2:23:53] Well, I think this was good clarification for tonight. [2:23:57] Certainly have this information if everybody's interested, we could share. [2:24:00] So if there's nothing further from council, we are going to move to number nine, Executive [2:24:05] Session 67-2345C to conduct deliberations concerning labor negotiations or to [2:24:13] acquire an interest in real property which is not owned by a public agency. [2:24:19] Council wishes. So moved. Second. Have a motion on board by Greg [2:24:24] Lanting. Seconded by Suzanne Hawkins. Anything further on that motion Council? [2:24:29] the other roll call vote please yes yes yes motion passes seven to zero we are [2:24:46] going to be moving into executive session we're not going to be making any [2:24:50] decisions while we're in there or coming back out and reconvening and [2:24:54] making any decisions