Oversight Archive: City Council meeting, 2014-03-10, recording 1 (started 17:00) Machine transcript (faster-whisper base.en), not checked word for word; the Pledge of Allegiance is shown in its standard wording. The recording is the record. Times are time into the recording. Passages with private details are muted in the audio and marked here. The audio on the page below was re-encoded by software from the video the agency posted. Check any passage against that audio before relying on it. Page: https://oversightarchive.org/twin-falls-id/meetings/2014-03-10/ [0:01:15] I'd like to call the meeting of the Twin Falls City Council to order. [0:01:21] It's Monday, March 10th, 2014, and it's 5 o'clock, and we are honored to have some Girl Scouts [0:01:28] with us. [0:01:29] So if I could ask them to come forward, they are going to lead us in the Pledge of Allegiance. [0:01:34] And then if you'll stay up here, ladies, I'd like for you to introduce yourselves and [0:01:38] what troop you're with. [0:01:39] So if everyone could please rise. [0:01:41] We've got one more. Oh, we've got a couple more. We can't leave them out. Okay, okay. [0:02:01] I pledge allegiance to the Flag of the United States of America, and to the Republic for which it stands, one Nation under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all. [0:02:18] You know, I don't know if I've ever heard more of a cute, [0:02:22] pledge of allegiance in my entire life. [0:02:25] Ladies, would you mind going to the microphone [0:02:27] and just pulling it down? [0:02:29] Just state your first name. [0:02:31] I've learned something new today, your first name. [0:02:33] And then what troop you're with. [0:02:35] Would you mind doing that? [0:02:36] Jackie, could you help them? [0:02:44] Gillian. [0:02:45] Thank you, Gillian. [0:02:48] My name is Rachel, and I'm in troop number six. [0:02:59] Excellent. [0:02:59] My name's Cara and I'm in troop six. [0:03:03] Excellent. [0:03:04] My name's Abby and I'm in troop six. [0:03:08] My name's Jasmine and I'm in troop six. [0:03:15] My name's Mackenzie and I'm in troop six. [0:03:18] I'm Rachel and I'm in troop six. [0:03:20] Well, thank you ladies. [0:03:21] You can have a seat and we can't top that. [0:03:24] So it goes downhill from here, ladies and gentlemen. [0:03:33] Next item on the agenda is a confirmation of quorum. [0:03:35] We do have six members here. [0:03:36] one is not able to make it. I think that Rebecca is a little bit under the weather today. Travis, [0:03:43] do we have any amendments to the agenda this evening? [0:03:47] Mr. Mayor, members of the council, we have two quick amendments. Number one would be a [0:03:51] technical amendment on the meeting minutes that were sent out to you earlier. They are [0:03:55] provided on your desk and those changes are noted in red. The second would be a request [0:04:00] to add a alcohol license to the consent agenda this evening under the ownership of El Parisio [0:04:06] at 164 Main Avenue North. [0:04:09] Greg Lanning. [0:04:10] I would move to amend the agenda as a. [0:04:13] Second. [0:04:18] We have a motion on the floor to amend the agenda by Greg Lanning, seconded by Suzanne Hawkins. [0:04:23] Anything on that amendment? Council? [0:04:27] Lee-Alyvall? [0:04:28] Call vote, please. [0:04:29] Suzanne Hawkins? Yes. [0:04:32] Jiman? Yes. [0:04:34] Sean Berriger? Yes. [0:04:35] Chris Tocanton? Yes. [0:04:37] Greg Lanning? Yes. [0:04:39] Don Hall? Yes. [0:04:40] Motion passes six to zero. We get to go into a couple of proclamations and the first one is going to be the Girl Scout Week, and I have the honor to read this. [0:04:51] It's Proclamation Girl Scout Week, whereas March 12, 2014 marks the 102nd anniversary of Girl Scouts of the United States of America, founded by Juliet Gordon Lowe in 1912 in Savannah, Georgia, [0:05:08] and whereas throughout its distinguished history, [0:05:11] Girl Scouts have inspired millions of girls and women [0:05:15] with courage, confidence, and character [0:05:18] to make the world a better place, [0:05:19] and whereas through the Girl Scout leadership experience, [0:05:25] girls develop the skills and lessons [0:05:28] that will serve them throughout their lives [0:05:30] so that they may contribute to their communities, [0:05:33] and whereas Girl Scouting takes an active role [0:05:36] in increasing girls' awareness of the opportunities in math, science, sports, technology, and many [0:05:43] fields of interest that can expand their horizons. And whereas Girl Scout members nationwide will [0:05:51] be celebrating this American tradition and welcome girls from every background to join. [0:05:57] Now therefore, I, Don Hall, by virtue of the authority vested in me as Mayor of Twin Falls, [0:06:03] hereby applaud the commitment Girl Scouting has made to support the leadership [0:06:08] development of America's girls and proudly proclaim the week of March 12th [0:06:14] 2014 as Girl Scout Week in the city of Twin Falls and urge all citizens of Twin [0:06:21] Falls to join in this observation. I've signed this along with Deputy City [0:06:29] Clerk Leila Sanchez, and do we have someone coming forward? [0:06:49] A few words. [0:06:50] Thank you for helping us celebrate. We're 102 years, not me personally, all of this year. [0:06:57] And thank you for always supporting the Girl Scouts in our community and everything that they do. [0:07:03] And just know that these are our future leaders. [0:07:07] And by helping now, you're creating the next generation that's going to sit at that table. [0:07:12] So thank you very much. [0:07:14] Absolutely, and thank you. [0:07:21] If everyone that brought us or asked us to do a proclamation brought us cookies, it would [0:07:25] be a good thing. [0:07:27] Thank you very much. [0:07:28] I'll turn over the next proclamation to Sean Barr. [0:07:32] Thank you, Mayor. [0:07:34] Fair Housing Month proclamation. [0:07:36] Whereas April 2014 marks the 46th anniversary of the passage of Title 8 of the Civil Rights [0:07:42] Act of 1968, commonly known as the Federal Fair Housing Act, and whereas the Idaho Human [0:07:48] Rights Commission Act has prohibited discrimination in housing since 1969, and whereas equal opportunity [0:07:54] for all, regardless of race, color, religion, sex, disability, familial status, or national [0:08:01] origin, is a fundamental goal of our nation, state, and city. And whereas equal access to [0:08:07] housing is an important component of this goal, as fundamental as the right to equal [0:08:12] education and employment, and whereas housing is a critical component of family and community [0:08:17] health and stability, and whereas housing choice impacts our children's access to education, [0:08:23] our ability to seek and retain employment options, the cultural benefits we enjoy, the extent of [0:08:28] our exposure to crime and drugs, and the quality of healthcare we receive in emergencies, and [0:08:34] whereas the laws of this nation and our state seek to ensure such a quality of choice for [0:08:38] for all transactions involving housing, [0:08:40] and whereas ongoing education, outreach, [0:08:43] and monitoring are key to raising awareness [0:08:45] of fair housing principles, practices, [0:08:48] rights, and responsibilities, [0:08:50] and whereas only through continued cooperation, [0:08:52] commitment, and support of all Idahoans [0:08:55] can barriers to fair housing be removed. [0:08:58] Now, therefore, Don Hall Mayor of the City of Twin Falls, [0:09:01] Twin Falls County, that is hereby proclaim April 2014 [0:09:05] to be fair housing month in the city of Twin Falls [0:09:08] in the state of Idaho. [0:09:10] Thank you, Sean. [0:09:11] You're welcome. [0:09:12] Is there anyone to perceive this this evening? [0:09:14] I think Carlin's coming. [0:09:34] But maybe later, right? [0:09:36] Thank you, Carlin. [0:09:37] Next item on the agenda, we've opened up [0:09:39] at the beginning of the council meetings a chance [0:09:41] for the general public to make comments. [0:09:43] We do that at the end as well. [0:09:45] So at this time, is there anyone in our audience [0:09:50] that would like to address the council, [0:09:51] that's not on something on the agenda this evening, [0:09:54] just the beginning of our council meeting. [0:09:57] Katie, come forward. [0:09:59] If you'd state your name and where you live, [0:10:01] and it's all yours, Madam. [0:10:03] Katie Breckenridge and Rob Struthers, Peekaboo. [0:10:06] And I'm here, we're here because we wanna make sure [0:10:09] that there is clarification, [0:10:12] and you know that we are here to work with you. [0:10:15] We read in the paper a couple of weeks ago [0:10:18] that you discuss the King and Falls Road. [0:10:22] And we read what you said, and we have no idea [0:10:26] if that's what you said, but we just wanted to make sure [0:10:30] that we would like to be a part of the solution. [0:10:34] We never want to be a part of the problem. [0:10:37] And all of you have looked and you know how we feel about it. [0:10:40] You know we feel that the wall is unstable. [0:10:43] You know that we feel there is concern. [0:10:46] We know that you feel it's very expensive, [0:10:49] and we know that somewhere along the line [0:10:52] there needs to be some type of a solution [0:10:55] to what goes on on that road. [0:10:58] And then on a personal note, [0:11:00] I don't want to be blamed in any way [0:11:04] for not stepping forward. [0:11:06] You know, when you have the history [0:11:07] of the Breckenridge name and all the things [0:11:10] that the Breckenridge did or have done [0:11:12] in Twin Falls around land, [0:11:15] We are blamed that we tore down the poplar trees. [0:11:18] We are blamed that we ruined the entrance. [0:11:21] We are blamed that we don't give enough bike path. [0:11:24] We're constantly blamed and it hurts my heart very deeply. [0:11:28] And I can't tell you how hard my heart would hurt [0:11:30] if we were blamed. [0:11:32] Somehow we did not cooperate and someone was hurt [0:11:36] on that road or maimed or killed or whatever. [0:11:39] And so it was very important to me and to Rob [0:11:43] that we step to all of you and say we are here in any way [0:11:48] to discuss the scenario in any way that you want to. [0:11:52] And we can't pay for it. [0:11:56] Which is what I know, you know, that's the huge hangup. [0:11:59] But just we wanted to come forward because many times [0:12:03] in the court of public opinion things are said [0:12:07] that are the farthest from the truth. [0:12:09] And so we came tonight specifically to say that to all [0:12:13] of you. And we might end up by saying it really felt warm when all of you smiled or [0:12:19] nodded or even acknowledged we were here. And we thank you very, very much, but never [0:12:25] hesitate for any reason. We do really well over and we do really well on a one-on-one. [0:12:36] And so thank you very, very much for that time. [0:12:38] Thank you. [0:12:39] Katie, I want to go on record to say that I've only felt like we've had complete cooperation [0:12:45] and a collaboration when we're talking about solutions. [0:12:49] And you brought to us ideas, and I remember not too many years ago, [0:12:54] we were talking about the rock wall and what we were going to do, [0:12:57] and you had to come and remind us, oh, by the way, that's our land up there. [0:13:02] And I've always felt that you've always been cooperative and collaborative about solutions. [0:13:07] So I'll go on record saying that. [0:13:10] Thank you very much. [0:13:11] Chris Dockingen. [0:13:12] Travis, I think since Katie's here, it'd be good for you to take a minute and give a little [0:13:17] idea and for the public understanding of the scope of the project, maybe some timetables, [0:13:24] and when we will really start doing some collaborating on this. [0:13:28] Yes, that's a great question. [0:13:30] Also, Jackie Fields, the city engineers here to maybe clarify where I might misstep. [0:13:36] The staff was charged with the responsibility to take a look at a series of different possible [0:13:43] options associated with the Canyon Rim, as you'll recall, Troy Vitek came in and he [0:13:49] shared some different possibilities and some possible different costs. [0:13:54] And after that, the cookies are tempting, I get it. [0:14:02] Hold on just a minute, we got to go ahead, Travis. [0:14:06] And from that point, the council [0:14:10] described what preferred alternative might be. [0:14:13] And now the staff is charged with that responsibility [0:14:15] of taking a look at the financial and the feasibility [0:14:18] of that preferred alternative, as well as [0:14:21] the possible alternatives that we're working on. [0:14:23] We believe that we'll be in a position [0:14:26] to share that information with you somewhere around March 31st [0:14:31] when we bring in the first part of the, [0:14:37] I guess the first contract for the earth work [0:14:40] out in that project. [0:14:43] And so we're hoping by the 31st, [0:14:45] it will be able to present to you a true cost estimate [0:14:51] to the different proposed alternatives [0:14:53] as we proceed to move forward. [0:14:55] And then also maybe be looking at some other solutions [0:14:58] that will more than likely involve partnerships [0:15:00] And one of those partnerships very well might be Katie and Rob as we look forward on that road [0:15:06] and also having collective uses to support not only the recreation, [0:15:12] but the transportation needs getting up and down that. [0:15:17] Thank you, Travis. [0:15:19] If when you do that, if someone could pop us an email, we try to watch what you do. [0:15:25] But somehow you're not quite top on the priority list right now. [0:15:29] But we would love to come and just sit here and and listen and anytime please just if someone could let us know [0:15:37] We would be more than happy to absolutely I saw Travis were shaking his head that we're gonna make sure of that Katie [0:15:43] Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Well, do we have your address? Do we have their address? We do [0:15:49] Yeah, we know how to get all of them [0:15:53] Thank you, Katie. Is there anyone else from the general public that would like to come forward? I [0:15:57] I see them, so we are going to move on to the consent calendar, Council wishes. [0:16:07] Suzanne Hawkins. [0:16:08] I move approval of the consent calendar as presented. [0:16:12] Second. [0:16:14] We have motion on floor by Suzanne Hawkins, seconded by Chris Tawkington to approve the [0:16:19] consent calendar as printed. [0:16:21] Anything further on that motion council, Lee Allen, roll call vote, please. [0:16:26] Jim on. [0:16:27] Yes. [0:16:28] Sean Berriger. [0:16:29] Yes. [0:16:30] Chris Tawkington. [0:16:31] Yes. [0:16:32] Yes. [0:16:33] Yes. [0:16:34] Yes. [0:16:35] Yes. [0:16:36] Motion passes six to zero with one Girl Scout cookie coffee. [0:16:44] We're moving under items for consideration and the first item is do not ever bring cookies [0:16:56] to the council again. [0:17:00] Update on the downtown commons and to formally request to name the project the downtown commons and we have the esteemed Terry McCurdy with us. Welcome Terry. [0:17:11] Steamed. Be careful. You just eat every cookie you want. It's just going to save me from eating one. [0:17:21] First of all, let me mention it's a pleasure to be here and to update you. You don't need to take any action tonight and I'll get into that so that you understand what we're doing. [0:17:30] but I wanted to just give you an update on what's happening [0:17:33] with the Twin Falls Community Foundation [0:17:35] and what's happening with downtown commons. [0:17:37] And I do need to pay particular praise [0:17:41] to my lovely esteemed, whatever, helper, my assistant, [0:17:47] Dennis Vanne Boyer for putting that up. [0:17:51] Those that can remember, this is what the downtown commons [0:17:54] is projected to look like. [0:17:57] We have submitted a request to the Parks and Recreation Commission to [0:18:06] officially name this the downtown commons. [0:18:09] This is a name that we have been using probably for the last year or so, [0:18:14] and finally had the opportunity to submit that request, [0:18:17] and that should be coming to you in the next month or two, [0:18:21] and as you do that, we'd appreciate your support and vote [0:18:26] in naming that the downtown commons. [0:18:28] The reason why it came to that name is first of all, [0:18:31] it's downtown. [0:18:33] That was a novel idea. [0:18:35] And the word commons is used throughout a lot of communities [0:18:40] for a gathering place, and we thought [0:18:42] that that would be appropriate. [0:18:43] So that's what the name is going to be proposed to be. [0:18:47] So as you get that, we'd appreciate your consideration [0:18:50] in that area. [0:18:53] You can kind of continue to do that, Hannah, [0:18:57] as we go through this. [0:18:59] One thing I did want to mention is we will have a change [0:19:01] in leadership in the Twin Falls Community Foundation. [0:19:06] My wife and I have been asked to serve an LDS mission, [0:19:08] as mission presidents, in the Philippine-Sebu mission. [0:19:12] We'll be leaving on the 21st of June for three years. [0:19:16] And for that reason, we'll need to turn the reins over [0:19:21] to someone else while we're gone, but rest assured we will come back to Twin Falls and [0:19:27] we'll be involved again in the future. [0:19:31] With that, I'd like to extend an invitation to the council and any citizens in Twin Falls [0:19:37] who would like to come to our annual meeting for the Twin Falls Community Foundation. [0:19:41] It will be held on March 28th, 2014 at noon at the Senior Citizen Center, and if you'd [0:19:48] like to have lunch that's optional. We will be holding our election of officers at that [0:19:54] meeting and anyone that would like to come, we'd extend that invitation to you. [0:20:00] Now the real reason why I came tonight was to give you an update and I believe in your [0:20:04] packets, you've probably had an opportunity to see what we're in the process of doing [0:20:11] as far as fundraising is concerned. Our original projected costs were $376,205.07 [0:20:18] $0.75, we've raised $341,814.04 so far. [0:20:29] We still have a balance to raise of $34,391.71 and you can get an idea of some of those [0:20:37] commitments and the amounts that have been donated thus far. [0:20:43] One item that I notated on there was the Urban Renewal Commitment and we hope that that [0:20:49] that will be approved as a final approval from them for $50,000, so we just wanted to [0:20:58] bring you up to speed so you know what was going to happen with that, the time frame [0:21:05] or the time table that we've decided to move with. [0:21:09] In order to get that done this year, we would have to wait until after August 20th, when [0:21:17] the downtown Wednesday night concerts will finish, they should be finished by August 20th, [0:21:27] by that time we should have all the funds raised, at least we're confident we can do [0:21:32] that and then we should have the project completed by the end of the year. [0:21:37] So with that I just thought I'd open it up for any questions that the council might [0:21:41] have or anyone might have about the downtown comments. [0:21:45] you Terry and Chris talking to it's real great to see a progress report like [0:21:50] this Terry looks like we're got a good action plan I want to make sure that the [0:21:57] the the group though is aware of the urban renewal money that we are putting [0:22:02] into the actually the Main Street quarter for water and sewer and streets and [0:22:08] sidewalks and hope that you don't do anything that doesn't coordinate with [0:22:12] that and certainly the city so that we only do it once the right way. [0:22:17] We just want to do it once and we want to do it the right way. [0:22:21] The reason that is there is to help the project with those actual items and we will defer to [0:22:29] the city for their request and whatever they need to have done in that area. [0:22:35] Thank you Chris. [0:22:36] Suzanne Hawkins. [0:22:37] Do you still have bricks for sale? [0:22:39] do anyone that would like a brick with your name engraven on it for eternity they [0:22:47] are for sale for a hundred dollars a piece or three for two fifty and you can [0:22:51] contact any member of the Twin Falls Community Foundation board or a member [0:22:56] of the Twin Falls Rotary Club to purchase one of those. Thank you. Greg [0:23:01] Lanning. Well Terry it's sad news that you're going off to serve and how you've [0:23:06] certainly been a community leader and we certainly hope you'll come back and [0:23:09] a community leader. We will. It's a place a lot of people run a community and you've certainly done your [0:23:14] share. We appreciate it. Well, thank you. I just want to say thank you for all of this. You've done [0:23:20] three years commitment to your church. So thank you for doing that as well. And please be safe. [0:23:28] Any other questions Council? Thank you for the. [0:23:30] None. Enjoy the cookies and we'll be back. Very good. [0:23:33] Next time on the agenda is a presentation of the City of Twin Falls 2013 audited financial [0:23:42] statement by Scott Hunsaker of Mulkey Hunsaker and company PLC and we have our own Lori race [0:23:51] to start us off. Welcome, Lori. [0:23:54] Thank you. Good evening, Mayor and City Council. Idaho Code 67450B states, the governing body [0:24:03] of a local governmental entity whose annual expenditures from all sources exceed $250,000 [0:24:11] shall cause a wave in their way back. [0:24:15] Oh, I thought you needed me to stop. [0:24:17] Okay, I'll stop. [0:24:18] You thought that I left, didn't you? [0:24:20] Oh, come on. [0:24:21] The exceed $250,000 shall cause a full and complete audit of its financial statements to [0:24:29] be made each fiscal year. [0:24:31] We've complied with that code. [0:24:33] However, we really don't want to stop there. [0:24:36] We feel it's important to have a formal presentation of the audit findings made to you, the governing [0:24:41] body of the City of Twin Falls. [0:24:44] We do this because we believe it adds a layer of transparency to city finances and government. [0:24:52] We believe the audit presentation adds validity and credibility to what we're doing. [0:24:58] It provides an independent review and appraisal of how we are handling taxpayer dollars. [0:25:04] You'll be receiving an unbiased expert review. [0:25:08] The finance team, headed by Brent Hyatt, put together an audit plan. [0:25:12] The goal was to have the audit completed before the end of January, with statements issued and [0:25:17] presented to you folks in early February. [0:25:21] Goal number one was meant. [0:25:23] We did receive a draft copy of the audit by the end of January. [0:25:28] And goal two was pretty close. [0:25:30] The statements were presented in early February, but that was due to the timing of my review [0:25:35] of the audit and then the managing and rearranging of agendas and schedules. [0:25:40] We are one week earlier than last year, and you'll notice that statements are dated February [0:25:45] 10th. [0:25:47] So Scott Hunsaker with Mulkey Hunsaker and Company is here this evening to present his [0:25:52] audit findings and audit opinion for the 2013 financial statements. [0:25:59] You should have received an electronic copy of the statements in your agenda packet. [0:26:03] We wanted to make sure you have those before time so that you would have time to review [0:26:08] them and have any questions ready. [0:26:11] I have asked Scott to touch on some specific areas and of course we'll talk about any other [0:26:17] items or questions that you might have. [0:26:20] So with that, I'll turn it over to Scott. [0:26:22] Thank you, Laura, and Mr. Hunsaker. [0:26:30] That's not as appealing as cookies. [0:26:32] I know. [0:26:33] Welcome, Scott. [0:26:35] That's a lot of pressure. [0:26:37] Is there going to be a test on this? [0:26:40] No. [0:26:41] Oh, I hope not. [0:26:42] It might be. [0:26:47] Thank you. [0:26:49] Thank you, Laura. [0:26:50] Appreciate it. [0:26:52] It's good to be with you this evening, Mr. Mayor and Council. [0:27:00] We're here to report on the audit as Lori just discussed and appreciate her kind of preview [0:27:05] of what we're here to do, appreciate the opportunity to come and present to you, the governing [0:27:10] body, the how the audit went and the findings that we had. [0:27:17] You just were handed a 95 page document and again I say this every year I'm not going to [0:27:22] go through it in detail. [0:27:23] We don't have time for that. [0:27:25] My voice won't hold out that long either. [0:27:28] And so we'll just kind of hit some highlights and we'll try to move it along as quickly [0:27:33] as we can and answer any questions with the help of Lori and Brandon if we need their assistance. [0:27:39] I know that Lori presents a pretty detailed financial reports to you so that would cover [0:27:45] the detail I think. [0:27:47] Overall the auto went very well this year. [0:27:50] As Lori said, we wrapped up in January. [0:27:53] As you said, the audit reports date of February 10, and getting schedules coordinated to present [0:28:00] this use is why we're here today. [0:28:03] Lori and her staff are very helpful in getting us the information that we needed, making themselves [0:28:08] available for inquiries and interviews, as well as pulling the selected documents that [0:28:15] were asked to be pulled. [0:28:19] And also part of this audit, we look at internal controls, that's a requirement of a governmental [0:28:26] audit is to assess the viability and validity of your internal controls. [0:28:34] We do that by selecting samples of transactions and following those transactions through the [0:28:40] process that they are, whether it's cash or checks, disbursements, receipts, as well as [0:28:47] payroll and other types of transactions. [0:28:49] we select a sample of those and make sure that everything is handled according to [0:28:53] control that the city has established. The city is very fortunate to have qualified [0:28:59] staff available to review and to account for the transactions. The city this [0:29:06] large has a significant number of complex transactions and this city has a good [0:29:13] staff that's able to handle those and that's a very significant component of [0:29:18] of internal controls that there is a qualified personnel [0:29:22] available to handle these transactions. [0:29:24] And so that assists us greatly in our internal control testing. [0:29:30] So you'd enter the statements a little bit. [0:29:33] Laurie mentioned as we were meeting, [0:29:35] going over the statements, that she'd [0:29:37] like that one page in particular was kind of interesting. [0:29:42] And I agree, if you turn to page 92, [0:29:46] We'll kind of start from the back. [0:29:49] There's a schedule there that's the schedule of findings [0:29:51] in question cost. [0:29:53] And she referred to it as like a report card. [0:29:56] And I've never heard it referred to it like that. [0:29:58] But I think she's correct. [0:30:00] It summarizes in a very condensed form [0:30:04] what we found or didn't find for that matter during the audit. [0:30:09] And you'll notice that there's two sections there. [0:30:11] The financial statement is what we're discussing now. [0:30:14] It shows that an unqualified opinion was issued. [0:30:17] There were no material weaknesses identified [0:30:19] in the internal control door significant deficiencies [0:30:21] identified and there was no instances [0:30:24] of non-compliance material to the financial statement. [0:30:27] The second section is similar but it's related [0:30:32] to federal awards and there was no findings there as well. [0:30:36] So that's just kind of a bird's eye view [0:30:39] of how things are going or how things went rather. [0:30:44] You'll notice on the foot back to the front table of contents. [0:30:49] There's many sections in this document. [0:30:52] And each has a specific purpose. [0:30:57] The first section is the management's discussion and analysis. [0:31:00] And if I were in your place, this is where I would start. [0:31:04] This is written by the city staff and it summarizes the data that's in all these financial statements [0:31:12] and the detail and the minutiae that follows, [0:31:15] that it summarizes and is written in it very well [0:31:18] in an understandable way in plain English [0:31:21] rather than account and speak. [0:31:24] And so it's a good place to start. [0:31:26] There's some graphs there and some things for you to review. [0:31:31] The PSB should start with the audit report, [0:31:35] which is on the next page after the table of contents, [0:31:37] which is an unqualified opinion, [0:31:38] as we just mentioned in that report at the back. [0:31:42] This is a new audit report. [0:31:43] The standards boards change the audit report [0:31:46] every once in a while, and this is a new one. [0:31:48] They're hoping to make it more user-friendly [0:31:51] by adding subtitles and additional paragraphs. [0:31:54] I'm not sure that accomplished the purpose. [0:31:57] They made it much longer, but there's some subtitles there [0:32:01] and the opinion, as I said, it's been unqualified. [0:32:03] So a few highlights we'll go into now. [0:32:08] into now on page 14 is the essentially your balance sheet [0:32:14] in the government wide taking into account all your assets [0:32:17] and infrastructure and all that. [0:32:19] That's on page 14. [0:32:22] Your hash position has increased over last year, [0:32:27] as did your net assets, or they call it now net position, [0:32:32] which is just your assets, less your liabilities, [0:32:35] that increased from last year to this year. [0:32:38] So it's a very strong balance sheet. [0:32:40] It's interesting to note that the only liability, [0:32:43] long-term liability in the governmental side of the city [0:32:49] is compensated absences, which is a crude vacation, [0:32:53] anytime like that. [0:32:54] So there's just not much on the liability side [0:32:57] as far as governmental accounting goes, which is very good. [0:33:03] The next page is a type of income statement. [0:33:07] It's hard to explain because of how they designed it, [0:33:12] but it starts with expenses and then runs through revenues. [0:33:15] The main thing that I'd like to point out [0:33:17] is down about the fourth line up. [0:33:19] That's your change in net position. [0:33:24] So in your governmental activities, [0:33:26] it went up by 1.7 million. [0:33:28] The business type activities went up by 2.7 million [0:33:32] this fiscal year. [0:33:36] Then you get into fund statements, [0:33:37] which are a little bit shorter term. [0:33:39] They're looking at the current year of term obligations. [0:33:42] If you can meet those obligations, [0:33:44] doesn't take into account your fixed assets and infrastructure. [0:33:48] And I think it's interesting to note on page 17, [0:33:51] even taking out all this investment, [0:33:53] significant investment you've made [0:33:54] into infrastructure and fixed assets, [0:33:56] there's still over 15 million of unreserved fund balance [0:34:02] on page 17 right in the bottom corner there, 15.4. [0:34:07] So it's, no matter how we look at it, long term or short term, it's still a very strong balance sheet taken as a whole. [0:34:13] The next section you'll get into the proprietary of business type activities shows them by fund, [0:34:23] water, wastewater, those sanitation, those types of funds. [0:34:27] They're around like a business, they show their assets, they depreciate assets. [0:34:31] It's much like a business and they show a statement of cash flows, which is included there for you to review. [0:34:37] The next section of the financial statements are notes, and there's pages of notes there [0:34:45] of probably 30 pages of notes, detailing your balance sheet, line items, describing what type [0:34:52] of energy you are, what types of funds are there for you. [0:34:57] One thing that is interesting is you have two different types of, two different entities that are [0:35:04] combined into your statements, which may be interesting to you. [0:35:09] You have the library, which is a, they call it a blended component unit, which gets very [0:35:15] much wrapped into your own statements, as shown as a special revenue fund. [0:35:19] And then the Urban Renewal Agency is also shown as a separate column you'll notice, and it's [0:35:24] called a discretely presented component unit. [0:35:26] But they're both included in your financial statements, so you can see those. [0:35:32] So then we get past the notes, there's detail about the budget to actual statements. [0:35:40] You may notice some differences in expenditures over appropriations, and looking at the detail [0:35:49] as to why that would be, almost always it is the basis of accounting. [0:35:54] Your budgets are based on cash, cash basis, cash in and cash out. [0:35:59] These statements are done on a cruel basis, and so there's some differences there. [0:36:04] Also depreciation on those business type activities isn't budgeted for because it's not a cash transaction. [0:36:11] So if you notice some differences there that generally is what's happened. [0:36:17] There's also combining statements if you really want to get into the detail of some of these small, very small funds. [0:36:23] It shows how they're combined. [0:36:25] The last section, starting on page 91, is the federal compliance section where it deals [0:36:32] with any federal grants that you've received, compliance with those, and our opinion as [0:36:39] to your internal control is in that document at the end as well. [0:36:43] So that's just kind of an overview of the documents you've received. [0:36:47] Very similar to prior years. [0:36:49] There's some new notes and disclosures and things like that that were required to present [0:36:54] this year, but nothing that really changes much. [0:36:59] So again, thank you for allowing me to come tonight [0:37:03] and present this, and I'm glad to answer any questions [0:37:06] if you have any. [0:37:07] Thank you, Scott. [0:37:07] Chris, talk to you. [0:37:08] Scott, I haven't digested, memorized this, [0:37:13] and you've covered a lot of areas of my questions, [0:37:16] but I would really like to specifically compare [0:37:20] the municipality of Twin Falls with what's happened [0:37:23] at the state treasurer's office level, [0:37:26] where there's some real improprieties [0:37:29] that apparently have cost taxpayers $10 million, [0:37:33] minimum, maybe much more. [0:37:35] You would think with that much control [0:37:37] at the state level that municipalities [0:37:42] are run less strict. [0:37:44] I would like to have a couple of minutes for you [0:37:47] to go through and talk at municipality of Twin Falls [0:37:51] relating to its surplus funds, any in- out-spected revenues, investments, and how this relates [0:37:58] to the security of our investments, the taxpayers' money, what sort of investments were allowed [0:38:04] to have that you get to adjust what I'm getting at? [0:38:07] I do, I understand that, and in fact, Lori wanted me to mention that night. I didn't look [0:38:12] at that bullet point when I went through it. [0:38:15] We don't want to be a Treasurer's Office of the State Idaho. [0:38:18] No, no, you don't. [0:38:19] It's important to understand as you review these statements and look at the investments of the city. [0:38:30] How accounting works now, 15 years ago it was different. [0:38:37] Now we account for things and we mark to market, which is just another term for saying, [0:38:44] as of September 30th, what balance did we have in that account? [0:38:49] What was the fair market value of that account? [0:38:51] If I sold it that day, what would that value be? [0:38:55] And so that creates some significant fluctuation [0:38:59] in your income statement, depending [0:39:01] on the market of that day and how the market's working. [0:39:05] And you're invested in several different types [0:39:07] of investments, some bonds and some other things [0:39:11] that there is some market fluctuation. [0:39:13] So you'll notice in the income statement as you look through, [0:39:17] there may be some negative income, which would be like an expense. [0:39:22] That's just because of the market fluctuation. [0:39:25] The risk for that is not, is would only be if you were to sell it at that date, [0:39:32] then you would recognize or realize that loss. [0:39:36] So if the intent is to hold those bonds or whatever to maturity, [0:39:42] that market fluctuation really doesn't come into play. [0:39:46] It's not an issue because it should be paid if the bondholder is secure and able to repay that debt. [0:39:54] So I think that's what you're addressing. [0:39:57] Well, the state had the same requirements to market the market, though, didn't it? [0:40:01] Yeah, absolutely. [0:40:02] And it depends what you're invested in, right? [0:40:05] You know, however, aggressive or conservative of an investment you're in. [0:40:10] We look at the types of investments that you have and make sure that it's in compliance [0:40:16] with the investment policy the city has established and to date you're involved. [0:40:22] Maybe that's the question. [0:40:23] What is the city's investment policy? [0:40:25] Do you understand that? [0:40:26] I'd have to pull and Lori could probably address it better than I can specifically, but it's [0:40:31] conservative type of investments. [0:40:33] I don't have it right with me. [0:40:35] I don't have it right with me either, Chris. [0:40:38] I can certainly forward you a copy. [0:40:40] We are very constricted in what we can do. [0:40:43] And I think I've shared with you all before, [0:40:46] safety's number one, liquidity is number two, [0:40:50] and then very last would be any kind of yield. [0:40:54] And if yield, I mean, right now the state investment pool [0:40:58] is paying 0.08%. [0:41:01] So to invest in a CD that's guaranteed at 0.5% [0:41:06] 5% kind of makes you look like a financial genius, so we're very constricted in what we can do. [0:41:13] And I will forward you a copy of our policy. [0:41:15] Well, I don't know what kind of bond holdings we have, but we generally hold those to maturity, [0:41:21] do we? [0:41:22] We do. [0:41:23] And Chris, I'm wondering if we use the term bond a little loosely, really it's like notes, [0:41:32] Even the longest our maturity can be is seven years. [0:41:39] You still mark the market on those? [0:41:42] We have to. [0:41:43] I don't know if you remember. [0:41:45] One of the presentations I showed, a slide of how our income truly came in. [0:41:51] But if you overlaid that with market adjustments, it would be up and it would be down. [0:41:57] But our intent is to hold our investments until maturity. [0:42:01] So we keep clipping our coupons and getting our little bit of interest income. [0:42:06] That's a difficult question. [0:42:08] I appreciate you re-emphasizing the safety and the preservation. [0:42:12] Yeah, in this low yield environment, we have to just go for the preservation of capital [0:42:17] a lot of the time. [0:42:20] But I think the public is always concerned about what these people in City Hall doing [0:42:26] with their money. [0:42:27] And I'm not sure I could figure out by reading this what we do and don't do, but Laurie, [0:42:33] if you forward something to me, maybe I'm going to get a better understanding what our [0:42:37] current investment profile looks like. [0:42:40] Thank you. [0:42:41] Thank you, Chris. [0:42:43] You know, we get an unqualified rendering. [0:42:48] And that's confusing to folks sometimes. [0:42:50] I know that when I first ran the Boys and Girls Club, mine came back as unqualified and [0:42:53] I thought I was going to lose my job. [0:42:55] And I said, no, no, Don, relax. [0:42:57] That means it's good. [0:42:58] Could you maybe go through that a little bit? [0:43:00] Because remember, folks are listening at home, right? [0:43:02] Yeah, it is confusing. [0:43:04] And I don't know why we accountants do this to ourselves. [0:43:07] We tend to speak backwards, I think. [0:43:10] But an unqualified is the best. [0:43:13] Qualifying your opinion would be to issue an unqualified [0:43:17] opinion, except for this qualification, your investments. [0:43:22] or you didn't handle fixed assets correctly would be a qualified opinion, that there's [0:43:27] certain sections of your financial statements that don't qualify to for GAP, generally accepted [0:43:33] to counted principles. An unqualified opinion means that there were no qualifications [0:43:37] we say it's all according to GAP, generally accepted to counted principles. So it is kind [0:43:44] of a counterintuitive statement to say it's unqualified. If you want it to be unqualified, [0:43:48] That's the best. That's what what you want. Exactly. Very good [0:43:52] Council, do we have any other questions for? [0:43:55] Scott or [0:43:56] Lori I'll get Travis and just a minute [0:43:59] Travis [0:44:00] So one of the things I want to want to hit on he is this kind of leads into that budgeting season that we're about to begin [0:44:07] And our budgeting season in the city of Flint Falls is going to begin on March 31st when our long-term planning group [0:44:13] presents their five-year link of financial budgets to our strategic plan. [0:44:21] And we spend probably somewhere between six to eight weeks describing the budget, creating [0:44:27] the budget, and describing the spending plan moving forward. [0:44:32] And what is important about this document is that it is our report card. [0:44:37] It talks about how well we did in meeting that overall spending plan, and did we follow good [0:44:44] conservative accounting practices do we honor our fiduciary responsibility and I [0:44:51] think that Scott has gone through that. One of the things I think that really [0:44:55] kind of sets us apart from other entities whether it be at the state or others is [0:44:59] that there's a section in Title 50 of the Idaho Code that really regulates on how [0:45:04] we can and make our investments. It is very restrictive and it says these are the [0:45:10] things that you at the local level have the ability and the capacity to invest in. [0:45:15] And it is a very, very small box. [0:45:20] One way to look at our audit is if we were a private entity. [0:45:25] This is our year-end financial statement that we would be providing to our shareholders. [0:45:30] And it would illustrate the financial strength of our company. [0:45:34] And if we were a private entity, we would go out and celebrate that. [0:45:38] we would probably see a rise in our overall stock value because of the strength of our year-end [0:45:45] financial report. At the local level, there's no rise in that stock value, but what it does [0:45:50] say to our citizens is that the City of Twin Falls honors that fiduciary responsibility, [0:45:57] and I think that testament is Scott would be here if it wasn't a good report. It might [0:46:03] be a little bit more uncomfortable for Lori, Herb's team and me, but I think that that fiduciary [0:46:08] responsibility is communicating accurately that financial information and I think that Scott [0:46:14] and his team do a great job and I think that Lori and Brent and their team, it's really [0:46:19] also a report card on how they care for our funds for the entire duration of a fiscal year. [0:46:26] Thank you Travis. [0:46:27] I did want to say thank you Scott for your thoroughness and your report to us. [0:46:32] Obviously, as Travis said, this is very important to us. [0:46:35] Thank you to Travis for your leadership, especially in this area, keeps us online. [0:46:40] Laurie Brandt, Bill, thank you for your team and what you provide for the city. [0:46:45] So, thank you, Scott. [0:46:45] Thank you. [0:46:48] Next time on the, Laurie. [0:46:51] Did you have, can I shut you off? [0:46:53] I'm sorry. [0:46:53] No, so I just wanted to say, it kind of ties to our wastewater bond. [0:47:00] important it is to have this document because we had actually had investors [0:47:06] call Zions to ask about the status if we were current on audits and it can be a [0:47:13] big deal if you don't have that done. So and one other thing Chris I will [0:47:18] definitely send you a copy of the investment policy but also in this [0:47:22] document pages 36 through 38 talk about our investments and I might even come [0:47:30] forward with a little presentation on the investments when these days. [0:47:33] Okay, that's all. [0:47:34] Thank you. [0:47:35] I was ready for that right now. [0:47:38] Next item on the agenda is consideration of a request to approve a contract with CSHQA [0:47:46] architects for phase one schematic design and feasibility study for the airport terminal [0:47:53] modification project. [0:47:54] Holy moly, Bill. [0:47:56] Sorry. [0:47:57] We have our airport manager, Bill Carberry, welcome, Bill. [0:48:00] Thank you, Mayor. [0:48:01] Thank you very much for reading that. [0:48:03] I mean, to learn how to use language better. [0:48:07] Good evening, everyone. [0:48:10] Just as it means of a little bit of background, things flow out of good planning. [0:48:14] Back in 2012, the master plan for the airport was completed as an FAA project, and back then [0:48:21] there were some development goals that were identified for our terminal building. [0:48:25] Those were to provide additional sterile room hold space in the hold room to take the check baggage function that you now see operating in the terminal lobby. [0:48:36] Get that behind the wall. [0:48:39] That would improve the efficient flow of passengers in the terminal and also accommodate some restroom facilities in the hold room, which is whatever our number one complaint. [0:48:47] So with that, that flowed into going for a request for qualification, for an architect, [0:48:54] we received a few responses to that. [0:48:56] There was a committee that did interviews, the airport board concurred with that selection, [0:49:01] and I was here January 21st to ask you for your concurrence as well, which was granted, [0:49:07] to move ahead to the contract phase with CSHQA. [0:49:12] What I've done is I've scoped a Phase I contract. [0:49:15] About a year ago, anticipating this moment, I budgeted $100,000 from a passenger facility [0:49:22] charge account that the airport has in its construction fund to go ahead and go ahead [0:49:28] with the Phase I. [0:49:29] So there's advantages to this Phase I. [0:49:33] Really what is it we want to build? [0:49:34] How big is it? [0:49:35] What are the things that we're looking to do? [0:49:39] So with that, we'll be able to look at what is it we want to build, how much will it cost, [0:49:44] what are some of the funding options that we have flexibility with to pay for what we want to do. [0:49:49] In summary, the scope of the work for Phase 1, we'll look at concept alternatives. [0:49:54] There'll be a narrative section that will come out of this. [0:49:57] There'll be a deliverable by the architect. [0:49:59] It'll look at a preferred alternative. [0:50:02] We'll have a public workshop through this Phase 1 to let folks know what we're up to. [0:50:08] some design drawings, opinions of probable cost, [0:50:11] and also some financial planning analysis [0:50:14] will be done in this first phase. [0:50:17] Through the phasing, actually, I worked with the architect [0:50:20] to make sure we had enough hours involved [0:50:24] to get with our stakeholders, namely being [0:50:26] the airline and the TSA. [0:50:28] They'll be very much directly impacted [0:50:31] by construction activity right there. [0:50:32] They're going to be moved around displaced, [0:50:35] so there's a lot of IT infrastructure, [0:50:37] things like that. So with that understanding with the architect, we developed a contract. [0:50:43] The contract before you tonight is for $113,395.70. As I mentioned, I had $100,000 budgeted. [0:50:53] I reviewed this with our CFO-Lori race. The additional $13,000 above the $100,000 I have [0:51:00] Budgeting can be worked in through to the Phase 2 and 3 phases of the architects contract. [0:51:08] Phase 2 would be the full design and bidding in Phase 3, the construction phases of the [0:51:14] work. [0:51:17] We can pay for those future phases as well as this additional $13,000 with FAA airport [0:51:23] improvement program grants or we also have the flexibility to use our passenger facility [0:51:28] charges account to make up with that. [0:51:31] Getting with Lori, she was in agreement with this approach for the additional monies that [0:51:34] we didn't anticipate above the $100,000. [0:51:38] So with that, I'd recommend the Council approve the contract with CHQA for Phase 1 of the Airport [0:51:44] Modification Project in the amount of $113,395.7. [0:51:49] I'd be happy to answer any questions you might have. [0:51:53] Thank you, Bill. [0:51:54] Any questions? [0:51:57] Bill? [0:51:58] So move the council approved contract for CSH QA for phase one and the amount of 113, 395.70 [0:52:08] We have a motion on the floor by Chris talking and seconded by Jim Munn. [0:52:12] Anything further on that motion? This is an easy one. I see no lights. The alla roll call please. [0:52:19] Sean Bergeber. Yes. [0:52:21] Chris Talkington. Yes. Greg Lansing. Yes. Don Hall. Yes. [0:52:25] Yes. [0:52:26] Suzanne Hawkins. [0:52:27] Yes. [0:52:28] Jiman. [0:52:29] Yes. [0:52:30] Motion passes. [0:52:31] 6-0. [0:52:32] Thank you, Bill. [0:52:36] Gentlemen, we have some Boy Scouts that just walked into the room. [0:52:40] We traditionally asked the Boy Scouts to come up and lead us in the Pledge of Allegiance. [0:52:44] The Girl Scouts beat you to that tonight, but I would still like to have the Boy Scouts [0:52:48] come forward one at a time come up and if you say your name and what troop you're [0:52:54] with and what you're working on this evening, what merit badge? [0:52:57] Well, we've got to do some adjustments, and then they're coming up, and again, this is [0:53:05] part, I'm assuming it's probably right there at the microphone, young man, if you say your [0:53:10] name, the troop, and what you're working on tonight. [0:53:13] My name is Bladen Bellnap, and I'm in troop 200 and I'm working on communications. [0:53:21] Excellent. [0:53:22] Are all of you with troop 200? [0:53:23] Yes, yes. [0:53:24] Okay, so we can probably skip that, so your name and what you're working on this evening. [0:53:28] Hello, my name is Mason Mumford and I'm working on citizenship in the community. Beautiful. Thank you [0:53:33] My name is Isaac Rasmussen. I'm also doing citizenship in the community. Thank you Isaac [0:53:40] My name is Cameron and I'm working on citizenship in the community. Good job Cameron [0:53:48] My name is Tyler Williams and I am also working in citizenship in the community [0:53:53] Thank you. [0:53:54] Thanks Todd. [0:53:55] My name is Kate McMillan and I'm also working in [0:53:58] citizenship and community. [0:54:00] Thank you Kate. [0:54:01] Hello my name is Gabe Laurent and I am working on the merit badge communications as well. [0:54:06] Thank you Gabe. [0:54:08] I'm based in the beginning and I'm also working on the citizenship in the community too. [0:54:13] Thank you very much and do we have one more gentleman back there would you like to come [0:54:16] forward? [0:54:20] Yeah I don't blame him. [0:54:22] There are going to be no test questions tonight. [0:54:25] your name and what troop you with and what you're working on young men. I'm [0:54:28] Don Simonson. I'm with Chupka 102 and I already have both these men badgers I [0:54:32] just came. In support. Thank you if we could give them a hand. [0:54:36] Thank you. Jonah you can go back and sit down and I won't bug you anymore. Mayor [0:54:43] we should have given the Girl Scouts good hand then too. We should have we [0:54:47] should have I apologize for that but they let us in the pledge and it was just a [0:54:51] beautiful thing. Next item on the agenda is consideration of a request to adopt an [0:54:57] ordinance for the zoning district change and zoning map amendment from R4 to Rb residential [0:55:04] business for property located at the northwest corner of Filer Avenue and Adam Street. [0:55:10] Mitchell Humble. [0:55:11] Thanks. [0:55:12] This was the zoning request we had back on February 10th. [0:55:15] It was approved at that night. [0:55:16] We're prepared the ordinance for your consideration tonight. [0:55:21] It's attached and I don't know the number 30 65 30 65. [0:55:28] ready to be adopted tonight if you choose to adopt it tonight we'll need to put [0:55:33] out third and final wave those rules if you have any questions I can try to [0:55:38] answer your good any questions and or a motion Greg [0:55:42] may I move that we place origins 30 65 excuse to spend the rules in place [0:55:48] ordinance 30 65 or third and final by title second we have a motion on the floor [0:55:55] Greg Lanting, seconded by Suzanne Hawkins. [0:55:59] Any further on the motion council? [0:56:02] Greg? [0:56:06] I see no lights. [0:56:07] Leila, roll call vote please. [0:56:08] Chris Tockington? [0:56:09] Yes. [0:56:10] Greg Lanting? [0:56:11] Yes. [0:56:12] Don Hall? [0:56:13] Yes. [0:56:14] Suzanne Hawkins? [0:56:15] Yes. [0:56:16] Jim Mun? [0:56:17] Yes. [0:56:18] Sean Beriber? [0:56:19] Yes. [0:56:20] Motion passes six to zero. [0:56:21] Thank you Mitch. [0:56:22] Looks like your name's on the next one as well. [0:56:24] Oh, Leila. [0:56:25] Oh, I'm sorry. [0:56:26] the title of the motion. I was just marching along again. Thank you, Lee Island. [0:56:32] An ordinance of the City Council of the City of Twin Falls, Idaho, [0:56:36] we zoning real property below described, providing the zoning classification therefore [0:56:41] and ordering the necessary area of impact and zoning districts map the amendment. [0:56:47] Do we have a motion to cancel? Great landing. Move approval of ordinance 3065. [0:56:54] Second. [0:56:55] I have a motion on the floor by Greg Lanting, seconded by Sean Berriger to approve Ordinance 3065. [0:57:02] I see no lights. [0:57:04] Leyla roll call vote, please. [0:57:05] Greg Lanting? [0:57:06] Yes. [0:57:06] Don Hall? [0:57:07] Yes. [0:57:08] Susan Hopkins? [0:57:09] Yes. [0:57:10] Jim Mun? [0:57:10] Yes. [0:57:11] Sean Berriger? [0:57:12] Yes. [0:57:12] Chris Hopkins? [0:57:13] Yes. [0:57:14] Motion passes 6-0. [0:57:17] Thank you, Council. [0:57:18] Next item on the agenda is consideration of your request to adopt an ordinance to meet the Twin [0:57:23] fall city code 10-9-9k real estate signs to allow temporary real estate open house signs [0:57:32] in the public right-of-way under specific conditions, Mitch Humble would give. [0:57:38] So this was a zoning request we had last week of the March 3rd meeting. That also was approved [0:57:44] by the council and we were directed to bring back an ordinance so we have that for you tonight. [0:57:49] I guess in this one will be 366, yes. [0:57:54] It's also been prepared and is ready for your adoption. [0:57:57] If again, we want to do it tonight. [0:57:58] We got a third and final. [0:58:02] Thank you, Mitch. [0:58:03] Council wishes. [0:58:04] Chris Stocky. [0:58:05] Move passage. [0:58:06] Suspending the rules, placing in 306, [0:58:09] on third and final by title, only. [0:58:12] Second. [0:58:12] We have a motion on floor by Chris Stocky, [0:58:14] then seconded by Sean Verriger. [0:58:17] to suspend the rules in place ordinance 366 [0:58:22] by title on, I think that's close enough. [0:58:26] Anything further on the motion council? [0:58:28] Lee Island, roll call vote. [0:58:30] Yes. [0:58:32] Yes. [0:58:34] Yes. [0:58:36] Yes. [0:58:37] Yes. [0:58:39] Yes. [0:58:40] Motion passes six to zero. [0:58:42] Lee Island. [0:58:49] In ordinance of the city council of the city of Twin Falls, Idaho [0:58:53] the Mending Twin Falls City Code Subsection, 10, 9, 9, K, [0:58:58] by permitting open house signs, off premises, [0:59:01] and within the area, within the right of waste subject [0:59:05] to certain conditions. [0:59:08] Council wishes. [0:59:09] Sean Berger. [0:59:10] Move approval of Ordinance 3066. [0:59:13] Second. [0:59:15] We have a motion on the floor by Sean Berger, [0:59:16] seconded by Suzanne Hawkins. [0:59:18] And we have a light, Chris talking. [0:59:20] I just wanted to confirm, Mitch, [0:59:21] that this ordinance contains the three added parts, [0:59:25] I think, that the entity as well as the amendment [0:59:28] to restrict it not allowing illuminated signs. [0:59:58] It does. [0:59:59] Okay, the point at the bottom there, [1:00:01] it's labeled number five, talks about illuminated. [1:00:05] Let's see here. [1:00:07] There were three conditions that were stand-alone, Zornker. [1:00:11] And then daylight hours is number four on the first section, okay, up here. [1:00:21] We have the daylight hours and then the eliminated down here. [1:00:26] I don't remember the third one either. Those were the two I think that we added. [1:00:41] The only two amendments? Yeah. Okay. [1:00:43] Chris, do you remember the two? Those were the two that I remember. [1:00:47] We might check back though because there were three points and then we had a total of four. [1:00:54] I don't know somehow these are incorporated different or what? [1:01:01] I guess we could always come back and amend the ordinance [1:01:03] if the same thing is substantive. [1:01:05] I think that's fair. [1:01:08] So we'll look at that a little closer and if there is, [1:01:10] we'll certainly bring that back. [1:01:12] Thank you, Chris. [1:01:12] Suzanne Hawkins. [1:01:14] Mitch, I just wanted to make sure Sean was going to be able [1:01:16] to come back in six months and give us feedback [1:01:19] on this ordinance and how it is going. [1:01:22] We had that and also the truck point that we're in. [1:01:25] We're going to come back on the same length of truck parking [1:01:27] and we're looking at. [1:01:28] September 19th, there you go. [1:01:31] Thank you. [1:01:33] Okay. [1:01:34] No, I see no further lights. [1:01:35] Leela will call vote, please. [1:01:42] Yes. [1:01:44] Yes. [1:01:45] Yes. [1:01:47] Yes. [1:01:49] Yes. [1:01:50] Yes. [1:01:51] Motion passes six to zero. [1:01:55] Moving to the next item, Mr. Mayor, I shouldn't have guessed it. [1:01:58] September 15th. [1:02:03] September 15th. [1:02:05] Oh, okay. [1:02:05] Okay. [1:02:06] And then you start walking this way and I see why now. [1:02:08] consideration of a request to adopt a resolution authorizing certain city officials to receive [1:02:14] informal bids, objections and specifications and procedures and to approve the lowest responsible [1:02:21] bid in the informal bidding process. And we have our city manager, Trapper Shoroth, welcome. [1:02:28] Thank you. Mr. Mayor, members of the council, this is a resolution to provide clarification [1:02:34] and in response to the Idaho Code. [1:02:38] So this is a process that we've been following, [1:02:40] and we are quite certain in knowing Mr. Dom Courtney [1:02:44] and how he was a stickler for rules and procedures [1:02:47] that this policy was executed. [1:02:49] But we want to make sure that there's a resolution [1:02:52] that clearly defines individuals that have this ability. [1:02:55] The Idaho Code, 672805 and 672806, [1:03:00] describe the different procurement processes [1:03:02] that we have to go through at the local government level. [1:03:05] And the different thresholds are set by dollar values. [1:03:08] You notice that we follow, and this is designed [1:03:11] to talk about the informal bidding process. [1:03:13] This does not change the formal bidding process, [1:03:16] which is a sealed bid process. [1:03:19] The informal bidding process is on services [1:03:21] and personal property between 25 and 50,000. [1:03:25] And for public works construction projects [1:03:26] between 25 and 100,000. [1:03:29] Most of those projects do fall closer [1:03:31] to the bottom end of that spectrum, [1:03:33] and that there are going to be things [1:03:35] that we discussed routinely during the budget. [1:03:37] Examples might be procuring gravel, procuring signs, [1:03:42] those type of things, where we go forward [1:03:44] and we follow the steps outlined in the code. [1:03:48] However, one of the things that it talks about in the code [1:03:50] is that all of those things that we want to acquire, [1:03:54] those many informal bid processes, [1:03:57] must come to the city council for approval, [1:04:00] or the council shall pass a resolution [1:04:03] and declare what individuals can move forward. [1:04:06] We know that occurred with the city manager [1:04:09] and we want to make sure that that is also allowing [1:04:12] for many other individuals that have [1:04:15] that department head responsibility in our organization [1:04:18] with that same line and level of authority. [1:04:21] So the resolution today is just to ensure [1:04:24] that we have a very well documented process moving forward [1:04:28] and describes the individuals that have the ability [1:04:31] not only to accept, but also to award [1:04:34] budgeted informal bid projects. [1:04:38] Do we have any questions, Councilor? [1:04:41] Chris, talking. [1:04:41] You define how, [1:04:44] if I get a call from John Cugh public [1:04:46] that a non-low bid was accepted on a project [1:04:51] and I'm supposed to time, but it was a responsible bid, [1:04:54] how would you define responsible [1:04:56] and words that are fairly tightly. [1:04:59] So, responsive bid means that they met. [1:05:02] Responsive. [1:05:03] Responsive, not responsible. [1:05:05] Responsible bid means that they met the items outlined [1:05:12] in the request for the bid. [1:05:17] So, in the bid outline, they clearly delineated all [1:05:20] of the different parts and pieces that we were asking for [1:05:23] and what they were offering met the spec. [1:05:26] And that is just ended, met with in the time frame. [1:05:29] So we will have to receive them by certain points in time. [1:05:32] They have to be delivered at the right place. [1:05:34] And all of that goes into being a responsive bid. [1:05:38] Individuals that may be the lowest bid [1:05:40] may not be the most responsive bid. [1:05:43] And responsible is a different terminology than what we're using. [1:05:50] The other, do we have a resolution number? [1:05:52] 1920. [1:05:54] 1920, thank you. [1:05:55] Jim Ma? [1:05:56] Thank you, Mayor. [1:05:57] Yeah, I don't really have a problem with this. [1:05:59] I was raised under the Tom Courtney plan for 30-some years. [1:06:04] And I'm just concerned that whereas department heads [1:06:08] are allowed to manage informal bidding processes, [1:06:12] I really like the idea of those passing your desk [1:06:16] or some vetting at your, and this is just how I was trained [1:06:22] at the city manager level before that would be concluded. [1:06:25] And I don't know if that really spells it out in here, but I see it as a department head [1:06:29] and the city manager approving these together just as a matter of process or policy. [1:06:38] I don't know. [1:06:39] Thank you. [1:06:40] And we can certainly make that as part of the process. [1:06:42] This isn't to remove the city manager from the process. [1:06:45] This is to ensure that, yep, absolutely. [1:06:50] How do you ensure that you are just your internal controls? [1:06:54] How does that work? [1:06:55] Hopefully, all the members of the staff are going to recognize that that is the directive [1:07:00] and they follow it. [1:07:02] At some point in time, we have to make sure that we have a responsive organization that's [1:07:07] moving forward. [1:07:09] The other thing is I check every, so on those accounts payable, I review those on a weekly [1:07:13] basis. [1:07:14] And if there becomes a large item that I generally was not aware of, I usually tap Mrs. Race and [1:07:22] have her help go through and track down that expenditure. I'm also the one that reviews it [1:07:29] to make sure that the description we're putting in the tagline meets the description of what [1:07:34] we're doing. And so I'm involved on the check issue inside. And before we issue the checks, [1:07:42] we require the council to sign off on that. And so all those green sheets will require [1:07:47] your signature. That's why you have the opportunity to review the accounts payable at the beginning [1:07:52] of the budget and should you at any time choose to remove one of those items prior to the acceptance [1:07:58] by the council, that check would be pulled from the batch run and it would not be mailed [1:08:02] out until it expenditure met the council's authorization. [1:08:05] So that's probably the best back check that we have in our organization for that. [1:08:11] There's a series of checks and balances. [1:08:12] I'm not the only one, but we also have individuals in finance that do that as well. [1:08:16] Pat Lehman and I kind of tag team that Sharon Bryant is probably the best guardian at the [1:08:21] gate that you have when she's putting that thing together from just the very first start. [1:08:25] Very well. [1:08:26] You read the playbook too. [1:08:29] You were a student of Tom Gordon-Yostle. [1:08:32] Yes, the playbook was agreeing. [1:08:35] Just talking about it. [1:08:36] I sure support what Jim says. [1:08:37] I think you need to be the loop thing either very formally or as a matter of practice. [1:08:42] Still hung up on response as if possible. [1:08:45] say for some communication equipment that has hard specs for it. You have multiple beds [1:08:52] come in. Would it be possible to have a response to the responsive bed that met all the specs [1:08:59] that was not the lowest bed? We have to go through a process and I'm [1:09:06] Gassbridge and Jackie to help, but we really have to go through a process to disqualify [1:09:10] somebody who is the lowest in the responsive bed. If someone meets all of the beds specs [1:09:15] that we're requesting and moving forward. [1:09:17] And they have the lowest price and value moving forward. [1:09:21] The only way then we'll wear that we're allowed to change [1:09:23] as probably through a sole-source process. [1:09:26] And we have to declare that on the front end by resolution. [1:09:29] We actually have to come to the council. [1:09:31] We have to share why we believe that it is important [1:09:35] for us to buy a particular item. [1:09:38] And maybe it's because of what we have in inventories [1:09:40] because of the type of equipment that we have. [1:09:42] But the council has to declare that by resolution. [1:09:45] We have to publish that in advance and then individuals have the right to come and say [1:09:50] and share why they have a comparative product. [1:09:54] We should never as an organization issue an award to, for a piece of equipment or a [1:10:05] service as delineated in here that meets the specs and is the lowest responsive bit. [1:10:16] if we are, I want to know about it. [1:10:18] It's just to add lowest responsive bid for this informal process is exactly the same [1:10:26] as it is for the formal process. [1:10:29] And we brought bids to you before and recommended not to the lowest bid but to the lowest responsive [1:10:36] bid because others have not complied in some way with the bid specifications. [1:10:41] So it would be exactly the same. [1:10:46] Any other questions and or motion from council resolution 1920 Greg landing move [1:10:52] approval of resolution 1920 second motion on floor by Greg Lanting seconded by [1:11:00] Suzanne Hawkins to approve resolution 1920 anything further on that motion [1:11:06] council I see no lights Lee Eilah roll call vote please Jim on yes Sean [1:11:12] I'm Berrigor. [1:11:13] Yes. [1:11:13] Chris Tockenshank. [1:11:14] Yes. [1:11:15] Greg Lanting. [1:11:16] Yes. [1:11:17] Don Hall. [1:11:18] Yes. [1:11:19] Rebecca Milsoica. [1:11:20] I'm sorry. [1:11:22] Suzanne Hawkins. [1:11:23] Yes. [1:11:24] Motion passes. [1:11:25] 6-0. [1:11:27] Thank you, Travis. [1:11:28] Next item on the agenda, just so folks know in the audience, [1:11:30] there are three different public hearings this evening. [1:11:34] If you're wishing to testify on one of those three public [1:11:36] hearings, there's a sign up sheet in the back. [1:11:38] If you put your name and which item that you're interested, [1:11:41] be very helpful so when we get to those we can get you up here quickly. Last item under [1:11:48] items for consideration is public input and or items from the city manager and city council. [1:11:55] This is a time for folks in the in the audience that's not here to testify on a public or one of [1:12:01] the public hearings or something that wasn't on the agenda if you'd like to come forward and [1:12:07] and talk to your city council, this is time to do it. [1:12:12] I see no one, so city manager. [1:12:16] Mr. Mayor, members of the council, just two quick items. [1:12:19] The first is earlier today, [1:12:21] you should have received an email from Josh Palmer [1:12:23] about illumination study. [1:12:26] The illumination study is something that Jackie and Josh [1:12:29] have been working on, [1:12:30] and it's really a public engagement process. [1:12:32] It's on our website. [1:12:33] We're encouraging citizen participation in this as well. [1:12:36] We want to go forward and really look at targeted and key areas identified by our city engineer [1:12:43] to look at areas that really are in need of additional illumination. [1:12:50] We are encouraging you not to do this while you're driving, but take mental notes of those [1:12:55] different areas. We do not want any texting data while driving and using that as an [1:13:03] an excuse should one of our officers pull you over. [1:13:05] So just take a mental note of those streets [1:13:07] and if individuals would help [1:13:09] and if members of the council would help [1:13:11] really kind of go through that process, [1:13:13] that would be really helpful to get a good sentiment [1:13:16] on very specific roadways within our community [1:13:19] and the lighting standards that we have [1:13:20] as Jackie moves forward on that project. [1:13:23] The second is on our backflow testing list. [1:13:27] As you'll recall, one of the things that we did [1:13:30] was we said that if individuals are willing [1:13:32] to meet a certain dollar value on that testing [1:13:36] that we would put and publish their name [1:13:39] on a informational sheet that we would place on our website [1:13:42] and that we would send back out. [1:13:45] We've had some individuals call us [1:13:47] and share some of their thoughts and their concerns [1:13:51] about that with your permission. [1:13:53] What I'd like to do is give them the opportunity [1:13:56] to share those concerns with you should they be willing [1:13:59] And I have that on the next council meeting [1:14:03] for your consideration. [1:14:05] But before I did that, I wanted to make sure [1:14:07] that that was an issue that the council [1:14:09] would be interested in moving forward on. [1:14:14] I'm seeing lots of nods. [1:14:17] Okay, that's all I have. [1:14:19] Very good. [1:14:20] Anything from city council? [1:14:23] Who's talking to? [1:14:27] I think the council's worked as a whole [1:14:28] into a predicament with our evil, [1:14:32] can evil take to bed since we have postponed the activity [1:14:36] of anything on the ramp for a year. [1:14:40] The proposed activities of Mr. Backley and True Axe [1:14:45] and perhaps Miles Dasher may or may not occur, [1:14:49] but I think that right now it's pretty clear [1:14:53] that whatever activities happen on the city [1:14:56] or county of land, we now have all of the cost [1:15:00] and none of the benefit. [1:15:02] None of the revenue or benefit will accrue to us. [1:15:05] We certainly will have the majority of the public [1:15:08] because still coming through the city of Twin Falls, [1:15:10] demanding place and emergency protection. [1:15:14] I want to see what the council feels [1:15:17] but I strongly suggest that the city develop [1:15:19] an alternative plan or a fallback plan [1:15:24] because I'm sure we're gonna be called upon [1:15:26] for our city resources, [1:15:28] and I don't think we can just wait and be surprised [1:15:31] to have 45 to 75,000 temporary residents [1:15:35] that when falls show up [1:15:36] and we're doing strictly business as usual. [1:15:39] It won't be strictly business as usual. [1:15:45] Jim, I'll jump in on this. [1:15:50] I don't find see the logic in [1:15:53] if we approve a jump [1:15:56] that we know can't be done safely, [1:15:59] if we would approve a jump merely for the fact [1:16:01] of losing control. [1:16:04] And that jump that we are very, very clear from a pointed [1:16:10] and thorough discussion with the police chief, [1:16:13] understand that we couldn't do it in a safe way, [1:16:16] and that the police chief wanted over a year [1:16:19] to look at that jump area. [1:16:25] I don't see the logic in approving it just to keep control [1:16:28] when the police chief says, we can't do this for a year. [1:16:34] I believe that if there is going to be a jump out in the county adjacent to the city, that [1:16:40] the sheriff and the county commissioners have a duty just like we did to examine that very, [1:16:45] very closely and determine in their own minds if it's something that they want to have happened [1:16:50] in their community. [1:16:52] That's their call now, and I would encourage people in the county and the city to let their [1:16:58] their voices me known with their county leaders as to whether they think that's a good idea [1:17:03] for their community. We made a decision not to do it this time. Now, I also think as a [1:17:11] part of that component and I believe that Chief Pike and probably the sheriff are going [1:17:14] to have discussions and that in the event that the city police may encumber over time [1:17:21] to assist the sheriff's office, anything that they might or might approve, then we could [1:17:29] be compensated for those issues. [1:17:31] I would yield to the city manager for any further on that, but that's just my take on [1:17:39] the logic there. [1:17:40] Travis, would you like to weigh in on that statement? [1:17:44] I'm not completely, obviously after the city made its decision and said its course of [1:17:52] action. That issue has not necessarily been at the forefront of the things that I've been [1:17:57] working on, but I do know that our chief of police has been engaged in conversations with [1:18:02] other entities in where possible jumps may still be occurring. I know that he had conversations [1:18:09] with individuals on the north side last week. I'm aware of conversations and continued engagement [1:18:15] that he has with Sheriff Carter, and I'm also aware of other conversations. So if it would [1:18:20] be of benefit. We are happy to have Chief Pike come in and chair or maybe just send an email [1:18:27] to members of the Council of the process that he is using and moving forward. I think it's important [1:18:33] to recognize that Chief Pike takes that safety component very, very seriously and that he's going [1:18:39] to be working with those partners because really law enforcement at that level is really working [1:18:46] between the men and women who are serving on the streets and I think that they do a really [1:18:51] good job in providing that blended service and I think that a special event isn't going [1:18:55] to deter them from that. [1:18:58] I know that one of the things that we've often, we've continued to have conversations about, [1:19:02] I've had conversations with the chief about is the desire to continue to work on those multi-jurisdictional [1:19:10] agreements because really at some point in time we really believe that there is going [1:19:15] to be a large event that may take place that is going to require the use of resources for [1:19:22] many, many different jurisdictions and how that is spelled out from a financial return of a [1:19:30] locality's financial investment to who plays the lead role is really, I think, important [1:19:36] to be done and can be done on the front end as opposed to waiting to the conclusion of [1:19:41] the beginning of the event. [1:19:43] Greg Manning. Well, I'm gonna concur. I'm somewhat of what well actually both council members talked about I was one of the two who voted to [1:19:54] Give mr. Backley some additional time to come up with a [1:20:01] Safety plan in my mind. We had the first date [1:20:04] I've been shown that maybe that wasn't the actual date, but that's the date I had in my mind anyway and [1:20:09] But I was also one of the groups that chose to, based on what she pikes, concerns was to [1:20:18] delay things. [1:20:19] So it's kind of on both sides of that issue. [1:20:21] I concur with the Councilman Mundt that we were, I believe we expected to keep the Sheriff [1:20:30] Department and the County Hall if the process had been on our land. [1:20:34] And I'm gonna judge that our County Commissioners and Sheriff would be working to keep us whole [1:20:43] to conversely be on county land as the first, though jumped out by Hanson is, I'm not sure [1:20:49] what kind of audience they're anticipating, but my plan would be that we should work very [1:20:53] closely and if you could have Chief Pike come in and talk to us about his discussions [1:20:59] that he may have had with Sheriff Carter, how are we having to have Sheriff Carter come in [1:21:03] as well. I'm sure Sheriff Carter would be very willing to come in and share with us what he [1:21:09] knows of this their safety plans and again we just need to work together to make it work. [1:21:16] I think I wanted to weigh in as well. There's potential of possibly two jumps. I keep hearing [1:21:24] that that number. I'm not sure where Mr. Beckley is completely but I did attend with both our [1:21:32] chief and capital, the meeting that the public meeting that took place in Jerome County regarding, [1:21:37] I guess I'll call it the Hanson Bridge jump because it's out by the Hanson Bridge. [1:21:42] And I think that's just an illustration that we're staying engaged. [1:21:46] They were engaged with our process, the County of Jerome, the County of Twin, or yeah, County [1:21:51] of Twin was engaged in our process and we wanted them to be engaged so that we could hear from [1:21:56] them and what their needs were so we could work collaboratively. [1:22:00] We in turn, now that we've turned it down within the city limits, we want to be engaged on any [1:22:06] jump outside of the city so that we can stay engaged as well so that we can make sure that [1:22:13] if there are some costs that just like we did for the counties, we would be part of the [1:22:18] solution there. [1:22:20] Chris talking. [1:22:21] And I haven't heard a thing that I disagree with from all these voice council people up [1:22:24] here. [1:22:25] to assure that this concept of a multi-jurisdictional cooperation is not forgotten. [1:22:32] I think Travis pointed out the fact that sooner or later we're going to have to heavily depend [1:22:36] upon it, and this looks like a way to carry through on the need for that continual discussion [1:22:42] between the law enforcement especially, and it doesn't have to be anything more formal than [1:22:47] just some acknowledgement that we're planning ahead. [1:22:52] I think the public expects that. [1:22:53] Thank you, Chris. [1:22:54] Jim. [1:22:55] I'm just going to conclude this by saying I hope that I'm not sure if the county has a comprehensive special events ordinance [1:23:02] like the city of Twin Falls does and [1:23:05] That we used and there was we were there was different philosophies on this council in regards to how we should proceed in that [1:23:12] And we find it came to a conclusion and it's to put to rest [1:23:15] But I I do encourage our county leaders to look very very closely at this [1:23:22] from a safety standpoint [1:23:24] Because the issues that we vetted here amongst our public safety personnel [1:23:30] Will be they will be confronted with those same endeavors [1:23:34] So I hope that they look very very closely at those issues [1:23:39] So I just couldn't find the logic in approving something that I believe [1:23:45] Couldn't be done safely just for us to maintain control. That just didn't make sense to me [1:23:54] Just real quick on that and just so the Council is aware [1:23:58] Representatives from Twin Falls County have requested a copy of our special events ordinance and process and that was forwarded to them [1:24:07] Good information good question Chris. I'm glad you brought it up [1:24:10] a couple things I wanted to bring Council's attention tomorrow. There is going to be an executive session of the ready team members and [1:24:17] And there's a couple council members that have been liaisons to them, [1:24:23] but we traditionally in the last few meetings have had a quorum of the council attending those meetings. [1:24:29] So we have been noticing those meetings. [1:24:31] It's not our meeting, it's the ready team meeting, but we've been noticing those. [1:24:36] I checked with our city attorney at the beginning of that, since we had a quorum of the city council to ensure that I wasn't supposed to also open a meeting up of the city council. [1:24:46] and we're okay with not doing that. [1:24:48] However, tomorrow is an executive session, [1:24:50] and there is the potential that there will be [1:24:52] another quorum of the city council there. [1:24:54] So after conferring with our council today, [1:24:57] our city council, our legal council, thank you, [1:25:03] we have determined that it would be best [1:25:05] if we do have a quorum of the city council tomorrow, [1:25:08] that we already noticed that the meeting's gonna take place. [1:25:14] I'll go ahead and open the meeting, [1:25:15] And then we will move into executive session as well. [1:25:18] And that's how we will handle those [1:25:19] to have the meeting in the future. [1:25:21] Just wanted to make sure that I sent that message [1:25:23] to the council, Travis. [1:25:25] Mr. Mayor, if there is a quorum of the council [1:25:28] interested in attending as you're aware, [1:25:30] the meeting is going to be in the police classroom [1:25:33] over in City Hall or the old council chambers. [1:25:35] Members of the council need to come here [1:25:38] and they need to enter into executive session here [1:25:42] and then you can walk over to that meeting. [1:25:44] So if there is going to be a quorum, [1:25:48] Leil and I will come over, we'll check. [1:25:51] If there is that quorum, we'll have you enter into it [1:25:54] and then move into executive session. [1:25:56] And then we'll have you join the meeting [1:26:00] at the alternative location, [1:26:02] but you do need to start the meeting in this room. [1:26:05] That's a good thing. [1:26:06] 330? [1:26:08] 330. [1:26:10] Leil could you send an email [1:26:11] because obviously one of our council members isn't here [1:26:13] asking them if they were planning on coming tomorrow, [1:26:16] that will give us an education if there's gonna be a quorum, [1:26:18] and then reminding them if it is, we'll meet here first. [1:26:21] Good call. [1:26:24] I believe we do, but I wanna ensure that. [1:26:27] Okay, very good. [1:26:28] Last thing, we have not been appearing at the Rise and Shine [1:26:34] recently, the television show in the morning, [1:26:37] the beautiful hour of six o'clock, [1:26:39] and we haven't put a schedule together, [1:26:41] and I was just going to quiz or ask the council [1:26:44] So what their feelings are, should we continue to do that monthly? [1:26:48] There's only five members of the council that would like to participate with that, two have [1:26:53] chosen not to. [1:26:54] Or should we go on a special invitation or if there's something that we would like to go [1:26:59] talk to them about? [1:27:00] So I just want to get the feeling of the council of a direction. [1:27:04] No preference? [1:27:06] I don't mind doing it, and I think it's an opportunity to communicate with the public. [1:27:13] at least it's on a Mondays, so I have it on Monday morning at 6 for the Chamber, so Monday [1:27:19] is for a weekly long day for good. [1:27:23] Greg, how are you feeling? [1:27:25] I don't want to do it. [1:27:26] I feel very strongly, since we do the radio, we do the TV, and we're at the back and [1:27:32] call of the public, and if it's 5am or 6am or 9pm, we have a responsibility. [1:27:38] the eiliken you put together a calendar and let's start the rotation again thank you council [1:27:44] next item on the agenda are there are public hearings and i'm going to go ahead and take a [1:27:50] five-minute break we'll come back to a to the public hearings there's three of them so again [1:27:55] it gives the audience the time to get back and fill your name out so that we can call you up [1:28:00] up here orderly. So we will take a recess like to reconvene the meeting of the Twin [1:34:17] Falls City Council Monday March 10th 2014. We took a short recess and so we [1:34:23] will be moving into our public hearings. We have three of those this evening just [1:34:28] one to remind folks or actually let folks know that generally we start off with the applicant [1:34:33] coming up forward. We give them about 15 minutes and if it starts getting close you'll see Suzanne [1:34:40] to my right she'll hold up a five minute or three minute and a thirty second and so we'll [1:34:45] give you about 15 minutes followed by deliberation and questions from from city council. We'll [1:34:53] ask a city staff to make their presentation followed by public input and then at one [1:35:01] point or another we'll close off the public input and go into the deliberations. [1:35:05] The public input portion of this, we generally give you two minutes. [1:35:09] So what you'll see from Suzanne is a 30 second. [1:35:14] Don't freak out when you see the 30 seconds. [1:35:16] It's not like there's a big hook that's going to grab you and drag you off stage. [1:35:19] It just gives you kind of that guideline so that we can kind of wrap it up. [1:35:23] So that's how it's going to go this evening, so the first public hearing that we have, [1:35:28] and by the way, remind you to go back and sign up if you're interested in testifying [1:35:33] this evening, is a request to adopt a resolution authorizing the mayor to sign and submit the [1:35:39] application materials for an Idaho Community Development Block Grant to partially finance [1:35:45] infrastructure development for the Cliff Bar's new baking facility and the applicant and city [1:35:53] staff report is actually going to be done by Carleen Herring from Region 4. [1:35:58] So, Carleen, welcome. [1:36:06] Council Mayor, thank you for having me this evening. [1:36:08] Again, I'm Carleen Herring. [1:36:09] I'm with Region 4 Development Association, where the planning district for the eight counties [1:36:13] of my role is generally to assist the cities and counties with infrastructure financing [1:36:18] projects that generally need community development block grants or other grant sources. [1:36:24] Tonight we're here to discuss a application for an Idaho community development block grant. [1:36:29] The funds are available from the U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development. [1:36:32] The state of Idaho gets about $10 million annually and they divvy it up into four different [1:36:36] pots. [1:36:38] One pot is generally for public facilities, sewer, water, that's of a general nature. [1:36:43] The second pot's senior centers. [1:36:45] You might remember I was here last month talking about the Twin Falls Senior Center project. [1:36:50] The third pot is imminent threat if the well goes down or as we were discussing this morning [1:36:55] if the pipeline from blue lakes gets washed out by a flood. [1:36:58] The fourth category has to do with economic development. [1:37:01] City of Twin Falls has been incredibly successful in using that particular pot of money to pay [1:37:06] for industrial improvements that help attract business or expand business that generate [1:37:12] jobs in the community. [1:37:14] The funds from HUD have a couple of strings attached. [1:37:18] We have to solve an issue, in this case infrastructure development, public facilities. [1:37:24] And the second has to be a benefit to low to modern income people. [1:37:28] Generally what that means in terms of job creation projects is that the company has to [1:37:32] commit to hiring a certain number of people. [1:37:35] And again, that's that open the applicants throughout the community. [1:37:40] When we take a look at those projects, there's several different steps that we have to go through. [1:37:43] It's a big application handbook, I've got it here with me, if anybody likes any light meeting, [1:37:49] having a couple sleeping at night, listen to it. [1:37:53] The application calls for a two-stage process. [1:37:56] The first step is submitting an application, which we will March 17th, so a week from tonight. [1:38:03] That application goes to the Department of Commerce, staff takes a look at it, make sure [1:38:07] that we've got it all our eyes and crossed all our T's, and then they invite the community [1:38:11] to make a presentation on that. [1:38:13] generally going to be, I believe Travis had thought it would be about the second or third [1:38:17] week in April. At that point in time the city can make a presentation to the Economic Advisory [1:38:22] Council that's made up of seven members from the six economic development districts of the [1:38:28] state and an at-large member. Locally our representative on that board is Kelly Anderson. He's a banker [1:38:36] with Zion's over in Burley. Great advocate. He's been on that economic advisory council [1:38:42] because of this in his third year now, so we're pretty excited to have him. He understands [1:38:47] the program and works real well at advocating for our projects. Generally after that, advisory [1:38:54] council meets, they will make their decision. We should have an indication of whether or [1:38:58] not we've got those funds, probably later in May, contracts available and ability to move [1:39:03] forward. Some of the strings attached to our environmental assessment, which we have completed. [1:39:10] has underway should be submitted to the Department of Commerce with the [1:39:13] application. Davis vacant wages tied to any construction contracts. There's some [1:39:19] the Fair Housing Resolution. That's part of it. The proclamation that you made [1:39:24] earlier in the council meeting. That's one of the other pieces to it. [1:39:27] Realistically because the city has done so well with block grants in the past [1:39:31] we've pretty much covered the other civil rights requirements so there aren't [1:39:34] really any honor strings attached to the funds. Once we have this public hearing [1:39:43] tonight, you put from the community as to whether or not they think is a good [1:39:47] expenditure of public funds, again that application will be submitted back to the [1:39:52] council with that resolution allowing the mayor to sign and submit that [1:39:55] application on behalf of the community. Mayor, that's pretty much what I have at [1:40:00] this time. We'll be asking for about half a million dollars from the State [1:40:04] Department of Commerce, it looks like we're going to be using those funds to finance electrical [1:40:10] improvements. [1:40:11] A similar that we did to Chobani, making sure that the plant has sufficient electrical power [1:40:17] to run all their equipment, and looking at the budget, we're $3.8 million. [1:40:26] There is match required looking at the budget we were working with Urban Renewal on their portion [1:40:33] of the funding. [1:40:35] Other points, Travis? [1:40:37] So the local match is going to be generated from the tax increment financing developed from this project. [1:40:43] As Carleen described, the tax increment is a product of the property taxes that are paid for by Chibani. [1:40:52] And that revenue stream is transformed into a long term debt instrument that allows us to pay as you go over time as the revenue comes in. [1:41:03] Did you mean Cliff Park? [1:41:04] Cliff Park, excuse me. [1:41:05] out in that general neighborhood. [1:41:08] I just want to make sure folks on this. [1:41:10] Cliff Bar is, thank you for that. [1:41:13] Cliff Bar, like Carlene said, has a power need and there's some power improvement. [1:41:18] And because our power system does a lot of its own line work, [1:41:24] Davis Bacon wages will not necessarily be impacted on this job [1:41:28] because it will be a sole source contract to the Idaho Power Company [1:41:32] the installment of the improvements. [1:41:36] The project and the improvements that are going out into the will be not only to the benefit [1:41:44] of Chibani, but there's also the opportunity for these, excuse me, Cliff Bar, but there's [1:41:49] also the opportunities for co-locations of some additional improvements that may benefit [1:41:54] Chibani in that neighborhood. [1:41:57] So this is one of two block grants that we'll be submitting on behalf of Clifpar. [1:42:05] The next one will be coming up to you in the subsequent quarter and it will be to assist [1:42:10] with lift station improvements, to assist with their wastewater flows. [1:42:17] It will be used to enhance an existing wastewater station. [1:42:21] Thank you, Travis. [1:42:23] Are you ready to stand for any questions? [1:42:26] We're ready. [1:42:27] a couple of lights great question I'll come at later I don't have a question [1:42:31] okay Chris thought what is our plan Travis should this walk around not be [1:42:37] approved carlings done everything she can and I'm sure that very good [1:42:45] opportunity that we will get but what's plan B plan B means that rather than [1:42:50] having a portion of these costs offset with the CDBG that means that we'll have [1:42:57] to have more TIF dollars used to be applied to the project. [1:43:02] And so rather than having an offset there, [1:43:05] there will be more TIF dollars that need to be leveraged [1:43:08] to complete that portion of the project. [1:43:11] Thank you. [1:43:12] Any further questions, Council, before I open up the public [1:43:16] testimony portion? [1:43:19] Carlin, I think you can just have a seat for a moment. [1:43:23] Just for clarification, is this resolution 3067? [1:43:27] No, but 1821. [1:43:29] 1921? [1:43:30] Okay. [1:43:31] I was looking to know where it was. [1:43:33] Thank you. [1:43:34] So at this time, I'll go ahead and open up the public testimony portion of the hearing. [1:43:38] Could someone go back and grab the sign up sheet and Josh's way ahead. [1:43:45] Thank you, Josh. [1:43:51] I'm looking at the list here, ladies and gentlemen, and I, well, I see one person. [1:43:56] That's Carleen. [1:43:57] Okay. [1:43:58] Is there anyone here that wish to testify about this item? [1:44:03] I want to make sure that I don't ignore you. [1:44:08] It doesn't look like, so at this time I'll close the public testimony portion and [1:44:12] any rebuttal to the public testimony. [1:44:15] Okay, Chris Stockton. [1:44:17] Move approval of resolution 1921. [1:44:20] So you have motion on the floor. [1:44:22] Chris Stockton is seconded by Greg Lanting to approve resolution 1921. [1:44:28] Greg Lanting. [1:44:29] just to expand a little bit on what Carly talked about because I've had the opportunity [1:44:33] to go up with her before and present in front of the the council I guess is what their term [1:44:39] is that the economic council that recommends to the governor and we have as she stated [1:44:46] we have been very successful in these grants we several million dollars and if you put [1:44:53] that in perspective if we were over fifty thousand and couldn't apply for them we would [1:44:58] would be lumped in with like really and some of those that maybe only get 400,000 a year [1:45:02] and we're gathering over a million out of these. So you can see the cusp of that we're [1:45:08] one of the largest cities, Caldwell, when falls are the only ones that are just under [1:45:13] that line. And I would imagine Caldwell got some for that Simplot plant that's coming [1:45:17] their way as well. I don't know that, but I think they would probably be applying. But [1:45:21] Yeah, and they are very always, it's a good group to present to because they're always, [1:45:28] I don't think they're the ones that came up with the term special sauce, but they certainly [1:45:32] have been wild with the economic development that we've been able to accomplish here in [1:45:36] our area. [1:45:37] So I will be definitely voting in favor of this resolution. [1:45:40] Anytime you get $500,000 of money, that's not ours that somebody else is going to give [1:45:46] to us, there's not really any reason to turn it down. [1:45:50] I want to clarify that all tax money is ours because it derives from the people. [1:45:54] It just happens. We'll take it here in our area, right? [1:45:56] If we don't take it, somebody else will. [1:45:58] That's exactly right. Yes, sir. Thank you for sharing that, Greg. [1:46:00] Anything further on the motion, Council? [1:46:03] Lee Allen, roll call vote, please. [1:46:05] Sean Berger? Yes. [1:46:07] Chris Talkington? Yes. [1:46:08] Greg Lanting? Yes. [1:46:10] Don Hall? Yes. [1:46:12] Suzanne Hawkins? Yes. [1:46:13] Jim Mun? Yes. [1:46:15] Sean Berger. [1:46:17] I don't know if you've got me any months. [1:46:18] Yeah. [1:46:19] I'll put two yeses next Thursday. [1:46:23] Motion passes six to zero. [1:46:25] Thank you, Carlin. [1:46:26] Thank you. [1:46:27] For all your hard work, you really helped make us successful. [1:46:31] We appreciate you. [1:46:34] Next item on the agenda for public hearings is a request for a PUD agreement amendment [1:46:39] to amend the Magic Valley Mall LLC PUD agreement number 215 to allow a modification to the [1:46:46] sign criteria on property located at 1485 Pole Line East and do we have David T-bolt? [1:46:57] Is that close? [1:46:58] That's correct. [1:46:59] Absolutely. [1:47:00] You're on, David. [1:47:01] Good evening. [1:47:02] I'm David T-bolt. [1:47:03] The EHM engineers at 621 North College Road and I'm here tonight representing the Magic [1:47:07] Valley Mall on this proposed PUD amendment. [1:47:11] This is, I think, the seventh amendment to the Magic Valley Mall PUD, which originated [1:47:16] in the early 80s as that site developed out. [1:47:21] There's been a need to modify it as they've grown and service the Magic Valley. [1:47:26] This particular amendment is specific to the signs and the regulation of signs that are [1:47:30] going to be constructed on the site. [1:47:34] Two prior amendments also amended the sign regulations that are described within the PUD. [1:47:40] We as the Magic Belly Mall and the representative have determined that it would be a lot easier. [1:47:46] Now that the City of Twin Falls has recently clarified and updated their sign ordinance to just comply with the City of Twin Falls sign ordinance. [1:47:55] So our proposed amendment to the PUD is that all new signs here after constructed on the Magic Belly Mall site [1:48:04] will comply with the City of Twin Falls sign ordinance and regulations therein. [1:48:09] We do ask for one exception to that amendment and regulation, and that is that the pennant [1:48:17] signs which are on a flagpole type deal and hang down that don't necessarily provide any [1:48:23] advertisement. [1:48:24] They only provide kind of a sense of location and a sense of destination be excluded and be [1:48:32] be allowed as previously allowed in the PUD. [1:48:36] And I need to make it clear that those signs are very similar [1:48:40] to the city of Twin Falls signs that are downtown [1:48:42] in the old town area, and to the hanging baskets [1:48:47] that are decorative in this downtown area. [1:48:49] And it's the desire of the mall to maintain that sense [1:48:52] of identity with those types of signs. [1:48:55] Furthermore, we would ask that by the way, [1:48:59] we wrote that, that that's a clear exception [1:49:01] that any square footage allowance dictated by the new code and the city's sign code ordinance [1:49:07] would not include that square footage on those pennant sites. They would be a specific allowance [1:49:12] as an exception to the proposed amendment. I would answer any questions if you have any [1:49:18] and enjoy the opportunity to respond to any public input. [1:49:22] Well, I think what we'll do next is we'll have a staff report from Jonathan's men love and [1:49:28] and then we'll open up for questions. [1:49:30] Thank you. [1:49:31] Thank you, Dave. [1:49:35] Thank you, Mr. Mayor and members of the council. [1:49:45] I think Dave summarized it very, very well. [1:49:47] The staff report's actually pretty short on this one. [1:49:49] The history, he gave early 80s on the model open in 86, [1:49:54] and they went through multiple years from dates of 94, [1:50:00] 2006, 2007, 2014 on all those amendments. [1:50:05] They also changed not only the signs, but also they added, you know, [1:50:10] pad sites for additional buildings. [1:50:18] So this amendment will only encompass this section of the mall area here. [1:50:24] It does not include the north section where the best buy in those are. [1:50:28] It's a separate PUD, nor will it include anything in Bridgeview or anything on the other side of Blue Lakes. [1:50:35] The, Dave also said it's for clarification. [1:50:39] They have multiple PUDs and multiple signed ordinances in there. [1:50:43] Whenever we get a sign permit from the mall, [1:50:46] it takes some time to digest what's in each different one. [1:50:50] And to get those approved, this will be a lot easier for staff [1:50:53] to evaluate the signs. [1:50:56] There was a question brought up in the minutes in the P&Z [1:50:58] hearing about specific signs. [1:51:01] There are too many variables for us to kind of go through [1:51:03] with this sign be allowed in this place [1:51:06] until we actually see a sign permit [1:51:07] from somebody that wants to do it. [1:51:09] At that time, we will make sure that it follows [1:51:12] the Twin Falls City sign code, [1:51:14] which is in Title 10, Chapter 9. [1:51:17] And that's exactly what they're asking for. [1:51:20] So, the proposed change will affect the sign design [1:51:24] and layout of proposed signs in the subject property. [1:51:27] The proposed change is as follows, [1:51:28] and I'll read it for the public as for yourself. [1:51:31] signs. All signs here after constructed or installed on the subject property [1:51:35] shall meet the applicable provisions of the City of the Twin Falls City code. [1:51:39] No other restrictions shall be placed on signs permitted under this agreement. [1:51:43] A. Exception. All flag poles and pennant sign [1:51:47] pennant type signs previously permitted under the PUD amendment dated [1:51:51] December 18th 2007 will be allowed. I have an example of that. [1:51:55] That is the example of the flag pole design and the pennant [1:52:03] signs of flag being on the left and the penance sign being on the right. [1:52:07] So those two things would be exempt from the City Sign Code and be allowed per the PUD [1:52:12] on that date. The proposed development and amendment is still in compliance with the comprehensive [1:52:20] plan which designates this area as appropriate for commercial and retail development. [1:52:25] On February 11th, 2014, the Commission, Planning and Zoning Commission held a public hearing on this [1:52:30] request. There was no public comment. On conclusion of the public hearing, the Commission unanimously [1:52:35] recommended approval of the amendment as presented subject to the following [1:52:39] conditions subject to master development plan amendments as required by building [1:52:44] fire engineering and zoning officials to ensure compliance with all applicable [1:52:48] city code requirements and standards and number two subject to recordation of [1:52:52] Magic Valley Mall LLC PUD agreement number 215 2014 amendment as approved by [1:52:59] the city council prior to development of this site both of those conditions are [1:53:03] or greater conditions of staff places on PUD agreements. [1:53:07] That's all. [1:53:08] Council, do we have any questions [1:53:09] of either the applicant or staff? [1:53:12] Greg, I have a question of Brett White. [1:53:14] If he's more, he'll be right. [1:53:16] Right. [1:53:17] Why? [1:53:19] Welcome, Mr. White. [1:53:21] Brent, this is my opportunity, [1:53:23] and I've had so many people ask me. [1:53:24] I've just got to ask me, the cutouts, [1:53:26] the cutouts on the south of South of Sears there, [1:53:29] what was planned there and apparently didn't happen. [1:53:32] I've just had too many people ask me to not take this opportunity. [1:53:35] It's been perfect. [1:53:36] It's got all sorts of people asking us questions, [1:53:39] and we have no idea. [1:53:40] And we haven't had any idea since the beginning, honestly, Greg. [1:53:44] The issue is that the elevation there, [1:53:46] in order to meet the handicap code [1:53:48] and have the proper elevations and slope in the parking [1:53:52] fields that were surrounded, would result in the pavement, [1:53:55] having to be substantially below grade, below the street. [1:53:58] And so tenants come to us and say, [1:54:00] where's my building going to be? [1:54:02] and it's been hard to answer them, so let's show them. [1:54:06] So at this point, we don't know who will be there. [1:54:07] OK, because it was just an opportunity [1:54:09] for a possible future set. [1:54:11] At least I have an answer we have. [1:54:13] At least I have an answer. [1:54:14] I have an answer. [1:54:16] People have asked me that I've never had an answer. [1:54:17] No, I have an answer. [1:54:18] OK, thank you. [1:54:21] Thank you, Mr. Dwight. [1:54:23] Any questions of the applicant or staff? [1:54:26] Council? [1:54:29] All right, I see no questions. [1:54:30] So at this point, I'll open up the testimony [1:54:33] portion of the hearing and I am looking at our list and this again is not a very popular [1:54:38] one to speak on this evening at least on the list. Is there anyone in the audience that [1:54:43] would wish to speak on this item? Okay, I will go ahead and close the public testimony portion [1:54:52] of the hearing seeing no one come forward and obviously I give you a chance for rebuttal [1:54:59] but there's really no sense in that at this point and turn it over to councils for the [1:55:05] questions or motion. Great. All I move that we approve the [1:55:10] request for a pud agreement amendment to amend the Magic [1:55:13] Valley mall LLC pud agreement number 215 to allow [1:55:18] modification to the sign criteria on the property located at [1:55:20] 1485 as described with the conditions placed by the [1:55:26] planning of zoning commission. I'll second that. We have a [1:55:29] motion on board by great landing seconded by Jim [1:55:32] I'm on. Chris talking to those conditions allow the retention or use of the flag [1:55:40] pendant signs. I believe that's unclear. Okay. Yeah I took it hopefully this is [1:55:45] right to the maker of motion not only the flagpole and pendant provision but [1:55:52] also the two items from the commission that they put on the master plan [1:55:56] development and the recordation. That was my intent. Is that your intent second? [1:56:02] All right anything further on this motion council. [1:56:06] I see no lights. [1:56:07] The island roll call vote please. [1:56:09] Chris talking. [1:56:10] Yes. [1:56:11] Great Lansing. [1:56:12] Yes. [1:56:13] Don Hall. [1:56:14] Yes. [1:56:15] Susan Hawkins. [1:56:16] Yes. [1:56:17] Jim Munn. [1:56:18] Yes. [1:56:19] Sean Burger. [1:56:20] Yes. [1:56:21] Motion passes six to zero. [1:56:22] Thank you. [1:56:23] Next item on the agenda and apparently the popular item for this [1:56:26] evening is request for a PED agreement amendment to amend the [1:56:31] to amend the WS&V PUD agreement number 263 [1:56:37] to allow a mixed-use development [1:56:39] consisting of professional and residential uses [1:56:43] on the remaining four undeveloped lots [1:56:46] within the WS&V first amended subdivision, [1:56:52] a PUD consisting of lots two through five and one [1:56:57] and totaling 16 plus or minus acres located west [1:57:01] of the 1,000 block of field streamway and southwest [1:57:06] of Chaney Drive west extended and it looks [1:57:10] like we have Mr. Fitzgerald. [1:57:11] It's going to be making the presentation for the applicant. [1:57:14] So welcome, sir. [1:57:15] Thank you, Mayor, Council, some of the eyes are kind of glazing [1:57:21] as to what we're talking about, so you're packed. [1:57:31] If you notice the area in Yellowfest, the Sudden Property, [1:57:38] and we have St. Luke's to the north, I guess, northeast, [1:57:46] Twin Falls Reformed Church, and then latitude 42 to the north, [1:57:52] and then Xavier to the south along with the LDS Church. [1:57:58] The apartments is that was the development that you previously approved for a village anyway. [1:58:07] So, in addition to that, you should have received or have in your packet a letter from Radfield's [1:58:20] President, my bill is incorporated in favor of the requested unmanned market. [1:58:29] Yeah, I just think you I thought it was just me. [1:58:33] They're a little squirrely all night, seems like. [1:58:42] That's much better. [1:59:08] Thought it was just me. [1:59:10] Again, the letter that I was referring to is from the president [1:59:16] of the local corporate whose property is for this. [1:59:26] And then we also have a letter from Gerald Martin, [1:59:30] who is representing Ladder 242 Subdivision, [1:59:35] which is, again, this property, too. [1:59:40] Included in your packet was a letter [1:59:44] that I prepared, dated November 4, 2013, [1:59:50] which outlined what the purpose and objective of this hot [1:59:54] after amendment is. [1:59:56] It is, in essence, to correct errors, conflicts, [2:00:00] and ambiguities in the existing PUD agreement, [2:00:04] as well as to amend the development process, excuse me, [2:00:08] without, and I emphasize without diminishing the opportunity [2:00:14] for public input, as well as oversight and approval [2:00:19] from the City of Twin Falls. [2:00:22] So as you look at the information and the amendment [2:00:26] to the Exhibit C. First amendment is there was reference [2:00:34] to doctors' offices in both the permitted use [2:00:37] and the special use. [2:00:39] The amendment is to eliminate it from the special use section [2:00:45] and put it into the permitted use. [2:00:47] Again, a conflict or ambiguity. [2:00:51] The second is to clarify accessory buildings [2:00:54] as attached accessory buildings relative to the development, again, to make it consistent [2:01:05] within the agreement. [2:01:10] We then are seeking part of the existing PUG agreement provides for dwellings with multiple [2:01:19] households up to six units. [2:01:23] We are seeking to amend the PUD agreement to allow up to eight units in a building. [2:01:30] Now, again, that is moving it from six units in one single building, not a number of buildings. [2:01:38] I'll come to that here in a second, to eight units within that one building. [2:01:44] In conjunction with that, we're also seeking an amendment under the special use permit process, [2:01:51] which would allow for more than eight units to a maximum of 12 units in a single building. [2:02:00] This doesn't affect the density. [2:02:03] What it does is it affects how many household units are in one single building. [2:02:09] The distinction and part of the issue that has been of concern with respect to the PUD [2:02:20] is allowing for a more manageable process [2:02:25] for the development of the property. [2:02:27] Again, this is a unique type of situation [2:02:30] with the PUD agreement in that typically [2:02:33] a PUD agreement says, this is what we're doing, [2:02:36] this is how we're going to do it, and so forth. [2:02:40] In this case, these are conceptual things. [2:02:43] So as we're putting this together, [2:02:46] we're establishing permitted uses, [2:02:49] and those that are allowed by special use permit. [2:02:53] And what we're looking for is rather than coming back, [2:02:56] you know, as the concept becomes more concrete [2:03:01] and having to come back and actually amend the PUD agreement [2:03:05] to allow for the special use permit process. [2:03:09] So as we go through and there is a proposed development [2:03:14] that it falls with under the special use permit process. [2:03:19] The applicant or the proposed developer would come [2:03:24] before file and application for special use permit, [2:03:29] would come before the planning and zoning commission, [2:03:33] present the proposal as part of requesting [2:03:36] the special use permit. [2:03:39] There'd be a public hearing allowing for public comment [2:03:42] from surrounding property owners. [2:03:45] and a decision to be made by the Planning and Zoning Commission. [2:03:51] If there is disagreement in one of the affected individuals, seeks an appeal, then it comes [2:04:00] before the City Council. [2:04:02] So there is that process for public input and governmental insight or oversight, but at [2:04:09] at the same time providing the process for this PUD development to proceed in a manageable [2:04:17] way. With respect to the staff comments, there was one that talked about providing for a [2:04:33] new sewer and water system model. The WSNB, the developer, is more than happy to cooperate [2:04:43] with the city, and to do such a new modeling if it is determined that it's necessary. [2:04:49] So in short, what we're looking for is to be cooperative, be a team player, not carte blanche [2:05:00] development, but rather to make a create a manageable system or process by which this [2:05:08] project the development of the subject property can be had without going [2:05:14] through the labor process of having to come back and amend the PUD agreement each [2:05:20] and every time. I'd stand for any questions. I don't see any lights so [2:05:26] Mr. Fitzgerald if you want to have a seat we'll have a staff report and then [2:05:29] there might generate some questions then sir. Thank you. Mr. [2:05:33] Spinela. Thank you Mr. Mayor members the Council. There are a few letters we [2:05:42] received throughout today and perhaps the weekend that we will scroll through [2:05:47] during the public hearing comment section so they will be shown up on the [2:05:50] screen later. Thank you. Normally I give a summary of the history and I'm gonna [2:05:55] try and do that. There's an extensive history on this property. I'm gonna go [2:05:58] over some of that. I know you have in front of you for your benefit as well so [2:06:02] people in the audience I will go over some of that. In 2006 this area and I don't [2:06:06] have the exact area on this general area but it did include this portion of the [2:06:11] property that is subject tonight. That was annexed into the city. That was in 2006 and [2:06:17] was giving a zoning designation of R2. Was it residential? Two. It permits a single [2:06:22] family residence on a lot. Also in 2008 we had a special use permit for a church to [2:06:28] be built at this location that is just currently now under construction. Later [2:06:35] on there were some more changes in Xavier came in and that was in 2008 as [2:06:39] well that is already in place. The Cottages which was a R4 which allows for [2:06:46] duplexes and more than that as a special use permit requirement. That was then [2:06:52] placed on part of this subject property. I don't have the exact boundaries. Then in [2:06:59] 2010 there were another PUD amendments and zoning amendments that changed part of [2:07:07] of it to the R6 Pro PUD that brought in a commercial element as well as a, with that PUD they placed [2:07:17] a maximum of six units in a building. [2:07:19] So from 2006 to 2010 that's four years when it was annexed to an R6 the density was increased [2:07:30] during those four years from a single family residence up to multifamily residence on the [2:07:35] lot. [2:07:36] I put that in there and I'm talking about it now because it is precedent to what we are [2:07:40] discussing tonight. [2:07:43] On February 6, 2012, the WSNV subdivision of PUD was approved, which is over this section [2:07:52] of the property. [2:07:53] Later on, there was another approval that granted this lot, this being lot one, and that [2:08:09] went through the PUD process, broken off into a separate PUD that allowed for an apartment [2:08:14] complex. [2:08:16] buildings on one lot with six units or more, I don't know the specifics of that [2:08:21] PUD but allowed for this development to go through has yet to be constructed, has [2:08:26] not gone forward. And that happened recently in 2012 and I believe it was [2:08:32] November was when that was done recorded. On January 28th 2014 the preliminary [2:08:38] presentation for this PUD amendment which we have before us went to the [2:08:42] planning and zoning commission and then later I'll talk about when they actually [2:08:47] approve it the specific days. There are multiple proposed changes to exhibit C and [2:08:54] exhibit C is where all of the changes are occurring. It's where the development, the [2:08:58] uses and all those things are occurring in this PUD. That is where all the changes [2:09:02] are. I'm going to go through the list that I enumerated those changes and I have [2:09:07] numbers on them myself. They're not corresponding to numbers in the PUD but [2:09:11] and it's just for organizational purposes. [2:09:13] Number one talks about the doctor's office [2:09:15] that was changed from the special uses and the approved uses. [2:09:21] I'm gonna put up that exhibit C here, [2:09:28] so we can go through it one by one. [2:09:34] The doctor's office found here, it was changed, [2:09:38] so it was under the permitted uses. [2:09:40] The next page shows it under special. [2:09:43] It was removed from the special uses, [2:09:45] it is just a permitted use. [2:09:47] the applicant did that to eliminate conflict which the Planning and Zoning Commission recommended [2:09:51] approval of. Number two was the detached or accessory building. Our code does make a difference [2:09:57] between accessory buildings and detached accessory buildings. So the applicant made this change [2:10:03] to eliminate confusion. Again, the Planning and Zoning Commission approved this change. [2:10:10] Number three, permitted uses. [2:10:12] This is residential under dwelling's multiple household units. [2:10:18] That is shown right here, it's down over there, E, right there. [2:10:28] That according to the applicant, it was done which was originated from the applicant's original [2:10:33] application. [2:10:34] The applicant points toward the Devon Senior Housing Project located at 1338 North College [2:10:39] Road East. [2:10:40] As an example, the conceptual design of a portion of this subject property, specifically this amendment changes the outright permitted use of a multiple household from six dwelling units per building to eight dwelling units per building. [2:10:55] There's much discussion during the planning and zoning commission, and in the end they did not recommend approval of this change. [2:11:01] The commission amended this section during deliberations and voted to remove the proposed change from the document. [2:11:07] Number four on my list, which is land use regulations under special uses, number seven. [2:11:14] Again, it talks about detached accessory buildings and it added associated to a residential use carports and clubhouses. [2:11:22] This was in order to clarify again, the Punning and Zoning Commission recommended approval of this section. [2:11:27] Number five, talked about multiple, so number seven F, multiple household units, more than eight in a maximum of 12. [2:11:36] to the applicant, the amendment originated from the original application. [2:11:41] Specifically this amendment would require a project that wishes to have more than the outrided permitted number of eight building units per building to get a special use permit before establishing the use. [2:11:52] It also places a maximum of 12 building units per building on the project. [2:11:56] Planning and zoning commission did not recommend approval of this change. [2:12:00] The commission amended this section during deliberations and voted to remove the proposed change from the document. [2:12:06] Number six, on my list, which is land use regulations D, property development standards. [2:12:13] This talks specifically about number of buildings on a single lot. [2:12:18] Throughout our code, in all residential zones, we require each residential building to be built [2:12:24] on its own lot. [2:12:26] There are very few exceptions. [2:12:28] One being commercial districts, allow multiple buildings on a single lot, and industrial, manufacturing, [2:12:35] They allow multiple buildings on a single lot. [2:12:38] This amendment would provide the opportunity [2:12:41] for a proposed array of multiple buildings, [2:12:43] consisting of permitted six unit buildings, [2:12:46] to be constructed on a single lot [2:12:48] through the special use permit process, [2:12:51] according to the applicant. [2:12:52] They believe this request is wholly consistent [2:12:54] with the City of Twin Falls desire and intention [2:12:56] to allow certain uses outright and other uses only with [2:12:59] its oversight and approval, [2:13:01] including public comment. [2:13:04] funding and zoning commission recommended approval of this change. [2:13:08] Number seven deals with, dealt with, access on the properties under development standards. [2:13:14] And there was a phrase added for roads to be by a recorded easement. [2:13:19] During the public hearing process, this item was withdrawn by the applicant. [2:13:23] And all analysis and all of the public or the staff recommendations were removed from your report. [2:13:30] Number eight deals with the property development standards, which is eight and nine on my list, [2:13:35] which is, it deals with the look of a building and added siding wood or cementitious materials [2:13:43] to both of those sections and the planning and zoning commission did approve those. [2:13:52] I'm going to focus most of my thoughts on the possible impacts of the PUD amendment as listed above. [2:13:58] I'm going to focus specifically on numbers 3, 5, and 6. [2:14:03] And those have to deal with, I'll read those again, [2:14:09] the land use regulations, which is the multiple household units, [2:14:13] 8 to 12, more than 6, and also the multiple buildings on one lot. [2:14:19] In eight years since this area has been up-zoned to include a dramatic increase [2:14:23] in available dwelling units and density. [2:14:25] In 2006, the area was annexed, R2, and I went over that. [2:14:30] In 2009, a portion of that was rezoned R4, which still requires separate lots for buildings [2:14:35] and a maximum of four dwelling units in one building per special use permit. [2:14:40] This rezone also brought an inclusion of some commercial office aspect into a portion of [2:14:46] the property. [2:14:47] In 2010, the entirety, both the R2 and R4 portions that were previously rezoned, they [2:14:52] were again rezoned R6. [2:14:55] This too required each building to be on its own lot and put a permitted maximum of six [2:14:59] units per building. In 2012, the PUD amendment was approved for that small portion where the [2:15:05] apartments aren't built yet, so that was a five-acre portion, and that allowed for multiple [2:15:10] buildings on a lot. The current amendment is asking to increase the permanent number of [2:15:14] units per building, as well as allow multiple buildings on a lot through a special use permit [2:15:19] process. The allowance of multiple buildings on one lot is a type of design language not [2:15:24] found in any residential zone. It is found in the C1 zone. The amendment to allow eight [2:15:29] dwelling units per building is significantly different from the total allowable units that [2:15:34] were possible in 2006 when this area was annexed under the R2 zoning district as well as the [2:15:39] subsequent re-zoned R4 Pro that took place in 2009. The approved R6 Pro PUD currently in [2:15:45] effect does place a maximum of six dwelling units per building. The base R6 zoning district [2:15:50] that we currently have in City Code does not have [2:15:53] a maximum dwelling units per building. [2:15:56] However, the increase in available density from 60 units [2:15:59] will have an impact on the current uses in the area, [2:16:01] as well as the potential surrounding uses have approved. [2:16:06] There's a City Code 1061-3A, [2:16:08] residential zoning sub-districts, [2:16:10] the number of units per building shall be determined [2:16:12] by Commission and Council action. [2:16:15] The Commission took that action with their amendment. [2:16:19] I will go to that right now. [2:16:21] On February 11th, 2014, the Planning and Zoning Commission held a public hearing on this request. [2:16:26] There were numerous comments from the public which can be reviewed in the approved minutes. [2:16:30] Upon conclusion of the public hearing, a motion and recommendation were made by the Planning [2:16:34] and Zoning Commission as follows. [2:16:35] I will read it verbatim, a perfritzes council. [2:16:41] A motion, Commissioner Tatum made a motion to approve the request as presented with the [2:16:45] following amendments. [2:16:47] To allow dwellings multiple household with a maximum of six units as a permitted use and [2:16:53] to remove the dwellings multiple household allowing more than eight units to a maximum [2:16:57] of twelve units as allowed through special use permit. [2:17:01] The commissioners buoyed, darecock, frank, grey, Munoz and sharp and Tatum and Devore voted [2:17:06] in favor of the motion and commissioner Woods voted against the motion. [2:17:10] So recommend approval of the request as amended by the Planning and Zoning Commission and as [2:17:15] presented with staff recommendations. The following recommendations were put on them. [2:17:20] Subject to amendments as required by building, engineering, fire, and zoning officials to ensure [2:17:24] compliance with all applicable city code requirements and standards, and the WS&V PUD [2:17:29] number 263, AR6 PRO, Plan U and Development, and number two subject to a new infrastructure [2:17:36] model for sewer and water systems and corresponding construction plans being approved by the city [2:17:41] Prior to any development occurring, I'm on 2-5 of the WS&V subdivision first amended. [2:17:47] The first of these conditions is put on there as a normal condition we put on everything [2:17:52] and all the PUDs. [2:17:53] The second one has to do with the infrastructure modeling and infrastructure plans that we normally [2:17:58] get with the subdivision. [2:18:01] If it is approved this way with multiple buildings on one lot, we will not have a subdivision [2:18:07] requirement before they can develop. [2:18:10] that's the implication. Normally we get with residential homes and residential uses a subdivision [2:18:19] if they want multiple buildings. If we don't have that, if we have multiple buildings on [2:18:25] one lot, it doesn't require them to subdivide. Therefore, we don't get that infrastructure. [2:18:29] And Jackie can talk a little bit more about the infrastructure modeling portion of it [2:18:34] and how that affects how we plan for the size of pipes in the future for the area. So those [2:18:40] Those are the implications. [2:18:41] Most of the conversation that took place in the planning and zoning centered around those [2:18:45] two things as well as the maximum number of units in the building, that's all. [2:18:53] Did Jackie, did you want to weigh in on a staff side, as Jonathan mentioned? [2:18:58] It was nice to see you. [2:19:01] Okay. [2:19:02] Okay. [2:19:04] All right. [2:19:05] Counseled, any questions for either the applicant or staff and I'll give the applicant another [2:19:09] chance to come up if there were some questions or additional comments about this. [2:19:15] staff. Come on up Mr. President general. Did you have a question? [2:19:21] Can I ask a question of Jackie? Absolutely. [2:19:25] Give him on. Thank you sir. And layman's terms kind of help me [2:19:33] understand this. What John Jonathan said was that with the [2:19:42] current configuration and this multi building configuration on [2:19:49] on the law. They're not required now to provide the city or I guess a city with [2:19:59] any plan in regards to infrastructure correct like water and sewer lines. I don't [2:20:08] understand what's this is kind of you know I think we're on at least I am kind [2:20:12] of wondering I don't understand this what does that mean in layman's terms if I [2:20:23] didn't even ask a question right that's indicative of my ignorance in this [2:20:26] So sometimes we have commercial developments and we don't know exactly who's going to end up there. [2:20:37] We don't know if there are going to be a high water user or a low water user. [2:20:41] And so we try to convince ourselves that we can flow the sewer off the property [2:20:45] and that there's some general level of water available for kind of what people need. [2:20:51] And then we move on. And then when those properties actually develop, [2:20:54] we actually develop them, we take a look again and see what they're proposing, aligns with [2:21:06] what we have out in the street, and we've done something similar to that, this particular subdivision. [2:21:16] So there's a sewer model out there, and there's a water model out there, and it has a basis, [2:21:21] and they don't know exactly how they're going to develop these parcels. [2:21:28] But if they stay with the basis of the original model, then they won't need to model again. [2:21:35] And we think that they can get their water to their property and around it. [2:21:41] And we also think that they're probably going to be able to get it off the property and have [2:21:45] it go responsibly all the way down the planet. [2:21:49] So am I getting anywhere close to what you're asking for? [2:21:53] Let me ask this question. [2:21:54] I guess this is kind of a wide-of question. [2:21:56] the event that the amendments were approved and we did allow up to 12 units with an SUP [2:22:02] on this. How could that impact infrastructure in this area? What would you have to do then? [2:22:09] Because that's different than what is approved now. [2:22:18] So at some point we keep looking back at the planning that we've already done and we see [2:22:27] if we're exceeding our original planning scenario. And when we think we're getting [2:22:36] closer we might be exceeding it. [2:22:38] Then we start talking to the developer about remodeling, [2:22:44] just to make sure everything fits in the pipe [2:22:46] or just to make sure the water flow goes out there. [2:22:49] Sometimes we ask for that if it's been a long time [2:22:52] and things have changed in the neighborhood, [2:22:57] but not very often. [2:23:00] So if they do, I don't know exactly where the cutoff point is [2:23:07] when the wastewater isn't gonna fit in the pipe. [2:23:09] So we'll keep looking. [2:23:13] And at some point we'll ask the developer to check it. [2:23:21] I guess. [2:23:22] So it could be, I don't know whether it's going to be one. [2:23:25] Is it the first set of four pluses or is it the first set [2:23:28] of 12 pluses or? [2:23:31] And then those costs would be forwarded on to the developer. [2:23:36] There is a issue. [2:23:37] That's accurate. [2:23:38] Yeah. [2:23:39] OK. [2:23:42] Thank you, Jim. [2:23:43] Chris, talking. [2:23:45] Not sure who to direct the question to, [2:23:47] But since its first conception, when it was an R2 to today R6, [2:23:54] we've gone from a dramatic land use change in density [2:24:00] of potentially up to 12 units where a single or a duplex [2:24:06] could formally be used. [2:24:10] Am I correct there? [2:24:13] And this has resulted from a modification of the plans [2:24:17] through a non-definite PUD concept, [2:24:21] the kind of dealing concept-wise, [2:24:23] and we're getting down to specifics now. [2:24:26] Right, so the R2, and I think, [2:24:28] my name is Chris, because I don't have a quote in front of me, [2:24:30] I believe the R2 allows for duplex with a special use permit. [2:24:33] Typically you find most of the properties around it [2:24:36] being R2 have single family residences on them. [2:24:40] So yeah, from the initial annexation in 2006 to today, [2:24:45] We have an increase as far as the density, a lot of times the density is put per acre. [2:24:53] Honestly, I can't tell you what the density is today. [2:24:55] It depends on how it's developed to be the most concerned about this ability of approved [2:25:04] to not have to go through the regular subdivision requirement so we can see if we have the issue [2:25:11] or can issue a will serve permit. [2:25:15] don't know of the density nor the this pipe sizing. It doesn't less than missing [2:25:22] something. I don't understand how this is an example of planning. It looks like [2:25:27] it's trying to go to the maximum density. I can't comment on the actual [2:25:32] will serve letter when there was some division. There wasn't a mount attached or [2:25:35] I don't know if it wasn't a mount. But yeah, those are concerns we have hence why [2:25:40] we have the condition if approved as presented to have the. Kind of like Jim, [2:25:43] I'm not sure I'm asking the right questions, [2:25:46] but it's as most unusual request for us. [2:25:51] Did you want to weigh in, Jackie? [2:25:56] I might try to answer it and maybe the answer [2:26:00] will be meaningful. [2:26:01] OK, so there was original modeling that occurred. [2:26:08] And there was a concept, and there [2:26:10] was original modeling that occurred. [2:26:12] And at the end of that modeling, there was a conclusion [2:26:16] that the piping that was originally a plan worked. [2:26:20] And the plan is changing. [2:26:22] And so if at some point in time it looks like we need to check [2:26:29] to make sure we're dealing with infrastructure responsibly, [2:26:32] then we'll do that. [2:26:34] So at this point in time, in the near term, [2:26:39] we're not issuing, we'll serve letters [2:26:40] for infrastructure improvements. [2:26:43] So that would mean if this development got to the place [2:26:47] where they needed to upsize a collection line or something, then they would need to adjust [2:26:57] their development plans so that we didn't have to issue a will serve for the pipe. [2:27:02] And it would still have to go back to the PNC process and come before us again. [2:27:06] I don't believe it's not for that part of it. [2:27:11] That's just a matter of if the math works or if the math does not work. [2:27:18] Does it not have to come back to the Planning and Zoning Commission if there's a request for [2:27:26] multiple buildings on one lot? [2:27:30] It does. [2:27:31] It would go through a special use permit process. [2:27:34] So for example the request to go from six units, six units per building to eight units [2:27:40] per building without coming back to a special use permit at most would put four more units [2:27:48] on this property because there are four lots there. [2:27:52] as that reads, yes. [2:27:54] Currently. [2:27:55] And if someone wanted to come back with something greater [2:27:59] than eight units, if we were to approve the original request, [2:28:05] it would have to come back through a special use [2:28:09] per-mer process for planning and zoning. [2:28:12] Or if they wanted to put two buildings with six units [2:28:15] on one lot, it would have to go back [2:28:17] through a special use permit. [2:28:19] So that process continues for anything short of go-build [2:28:24] the permitted uses on these four lots. [2:28:26] Correct. [2:28:28] Thank you. [2:28:30] Greg Lanney. [2:28:32] John or probably John. [2:28:38] Refresh my memory here a little bit on lot sizes [2:28:41] that are required for specific zoning R2. [2:28:45] For a duplex is placed, it's recursed 12,000 square feet. [2:28:49] I think it's something like that. [2:28:50] I don't have it in front of me. [2:28:51] I knew that one. [2:28:55] What about our four? [2:28:56] How big a lot is required for an R4, which would allow for a building. [2:29:00] It's four residents in the same building. [2:29:04] I'm going to need to look it up. [2:29:06] And then I guess the same question I would have would be, I'm looking at density, obviously. [2:29:11] Right. [2:29:12] And what would be the same, what would it be for our six? [2:29:15] So the density, and that's where it gets complicated, our density, I can give it the R2 and the R4. [2:29:21] There is a clause or a section or a code that deals with the design of the building and you add either 1,000 square feet or 2,000 square feet to the building if it's built below or above ground. [2:29:33] So, as far as the density question, there's too many variables to give you an overall, I tried. [2:29:39] It just depends on how it would be developed as to how many units they could actually get through the special use permit process on each of those lots. [2:29:49] if they want in multiple buildings on a lot. [2:29:52] But I can get those numbers of things. [2:29:54] But we do have limits or minimums [2:29:56] for those particular zoning designations, correct? [2:30:02] Our four lot area for a single household [2:30:06] dwelling is 4,000 square feet. [2:30:08] It's 7,000 for a duplex and multiple, [2:30:12] a multiplex will increase over the duplex area. [2:30:15] you take the 7,000 by 2,000 square feet per unit or 1,000 square feet per unit above or [2:30:26] below the ground level unit. [2:30:29] That's where it gets complicated to, are there invasements, are they on ground floor? [2:30:36] That depends on whether you get 2,000 or 1,000. [2:30:39] And when we moved to our floor and our sixth, do parking requirements kick in? [2:30:46] requirements are always kicked in at two per unit, per dwelling unit. So yeah, the [2:30:52] parking and landscaping doesn't go away, you still have to account for a certain [2:30:56] amount and a certain percentage. So in effect, the overall effect of this is [2:31:03] depending on how much land you use, it will depend on how many units you can get [2:31:08] and how they're constructed. So it does, you are required a certain amount of [2:31:15] landscaping certain on a parking and you have to provide for those and that [2:31:19] in effect takes away your buildable area. Thank you. Suzanne Hawkins. Okay. Do you [2:31:26] have any idea from this property owner and the neighbors on the completion of [2:31:32] Chaney Drive and or Creek Sideway? What we're looking at to get other access into [2:31:37] that neighborhood? Personally I do not. I'm sure there are some people here that [2:31:42] I personally do not. [2:31:44] Anybody have any idea on how that road construction is going to come about? [2:31:49] Sounds like I have an answer. [2:31:55] I hope so. Good evening. [2:31:59] Tim Foster with the HM Engineers representing the applicant. [2:32:04] As it stands currently, there's been some discussions with city staff as well as the adjacent property owners in hopes of getting Chaney Drive finished. [2:32:15] that, as you might expect, is an expensive proposition [2:32:20] and cooperation is the key. [2:32:23] So all property owners are going to have to be involved. [2:32:25] So I can't speak for all of them, [2:32:27] but I do know those discussions are going forward [2:32:31] to potentially move the chain drive out to Grandview. [2:32:35] Creekside Way is the development [2:32:40] to the North Creek's connection to Pull Line Road, [2:32:43] Their preliminary plans show Creekside as the only connection to Poline because it is control [2:32:51] access. [2:32:52] But if all goes well, you will conceptually see Ching Drive go out to Grandview and Creekside [2:33:00] go out to Poline in hopes of giving two other access points of transportation to this subdivision. [2:33:07] Five years, ten years, and the idea. [2:33:10] It bears the time frame really, but I do know they've been actively seeking to work cooperatively [2:33:18] together to get this done. [2:33:21] And there's no other access in or out besides what's there now then. [2:33:25] There's nothing else coming up that's. [2:33:27] The current access at this point is North College Road. [2:33:31] And North College going through to pass the soccer complex and out to whatever. [2:33:35] North College going to the easiest to act. [2:33:37] Right, but is there any plan for North College going west through to that next mile road as of right now [2:33:43] I don't believe that there's a plan. I'm not quite sure who owns the soccer complex on [2:33:51] I know who owns one side of the city owns that or [2:33:56] District I don't know if they have any plans there [2:33:59] There is a potential connection on Cheney drive to the west out to the next mile road section [2:34:07] But that would take development of the requel farm, which is somewhat far reaching, in my [2:34:14] opinion, as to when they would want to do that. [2:34:18] Also you have, at this point, nothing is really able to be developed until the wastewater treatment [2:34:26] plan. [2:34:27] Right. [2:34:28] Has there been any traffic study on that four-way stop on Grandview and North College? [2:34:32] What is the traffic buildup there? [2:34:35] Anybody have any members of that question? [2:34:39] Jackie Fields, City Engineer, the lady with all the answers. [2:34:46] We haven't done a traffic study since the four-way stop was placed to the best of my knowledge. [2:34:57] I don't think we asked for one as part of this process. [2:35:01] Okay. Thank you. [2:35:04] Great landing. [2:35:06] John or the applicant either one is just to make sure I'm you know I always [2:35:10] want to know what I'm talking about more of I'm talking but so [2:35:15] Selva was done. The apartments that are already planned that list is [2:35:21] apartments there would they remain as our six under this proposal. Yeah they [2:35:26] have their own PUD agreement. Okay just a second. That's what I was my [2:35:31] question. Thank you. Mr. Fitzgerald I said you could have another minute or [2:35:36] to keeping in mind I'm going to give you an opportunity after the public hearing [2:35:39] testimonies was very good. Are there any other questions from council before I [2:35:45] open up to the public testimony? At this point we are opening up to the public [2:35:50] testimony and I have a list here. Keep in mind that if you're so inspired later [2:35:55] and you don't have your name on here I'll certainly open it up to you. The first [2:35:58] person I have on here is Doug Bomer, second person and I believe it's for this [2:36:07] issue didn't list this as an agenda item but is there a Travis Simonson here next [2:36:18] person would be a Stephen Dixon when you come up Stephen if you could say your [2:36:25] name and your address and then you'll have two minutes we're keeping in mind we'll [2:36:29] [Muted for privacy: home address] [2:36:34] [Muted for privacy: home address] [2:36:40] [Muted for privacy: home address] [2:36:48] [Muted for privacy: home address] [2:36:57] notes. [2:36:58] So, first off, I feel like the controversial part of the request is the special use, the [2:37:08] special use, permeating process up to 12 units. [2:37:12] And I feel like that's been packaged in [2:37:15] with all of the other reasonable changes [2:37:19] that are made to the PUD so that it will make it easier [2:37:22] for the council to approve. [2:37:26] The second thing that I wanted to talk about [2:37:31] is that the developers, I realized they own all this land [2:37:37] and it's, they're trying to do what they need to do. [2:37:42] [Muted for privacy: home address] [2:37:46] [Muted for privacy: home address] [2:37:52] [Muted for privacy: home address] [2:38:01] [Muted for privacy: home address] [2:38:08] you know, would make a big impact on my family, I believe. [2:38:13] Just one more little point I wanted to make. [2:38:20] Special use sounds like an okay [2:38:22] if you meet these certain requirements, [2:38:24] and I don't know if it'll get the same attention [2:38:27] that it might deserve at a later meeting, [2:38:30] at a later point if it's granted in the PAD Act. [2:38:35] Thank you. [2:38:36] Thank you, perfect timing by the way, thank you Mr. Dixon. [2:38:40] The next person on the list, I believe, is Kevin Bloomquist. [2:38:45] I believe that's close, sir. [2:38:49] [Muted for privacy: home address] [2:38:51] [Muted for privacy: home address] [2:38:55] [Muted for privacy: home address] [2:39:00] [Muted for privacy: home address] [2:39:04] We bought into a subdivision that was a nice residential subdivision. [2:39:08] He's made changes. [2:39:10] And now he's backing more development around us. [2:39:14] And what I perceived at the time to be a nice residential area, [2:39:22] to me the issue isn't about cooperation. [2:39:27] I understand the development part of it. [2:39:29] I understand they've got to fill their lots to build the roads and stuff, but I envisioned [2:39:39] they would be filled in a different way when I bought to me it is who pays for the bigger [2:39:44] pipes, but why are we putting bigger pipes in? [2:39:49] So I oppose it. [2:39:53] Thank you, sir. [2:39:54] Megan Humble. [2:39:55] Welcome, Megan. [2:40:02] Thank you. [2:40:03] [Muted for privacy: street address] [2:40:04] [Muted for privacy: street address] [2:40:09] [Muted for privacy: street address] [2:40:14] how do you boil a frog, you put them in the water and then you slowly turn up the heat. [2:40:18] If you threw them in when it was boiling the frog would jump out. [2:40:22] And with all this rezoning I feel like that's what's happening to those of us living over [2:40:26] in this area that we're slowly, everything is slowly changing all around us. [2:40:32] Whereas if we would have, you know, when they annex this land, come in and ask for the zoning [2:40:38] at that time, I don't think it would have really been considered because it's such a huge change [2:40:43] from what it was. My other concern is that there's no real development plan. This, like they said, [2:40:51] it's all conceptual. There's nothing that they're handing us saying or handing you guys saying, [2:40:55] this is what we want to do. This is what we want it to look like. When they came in with those [2:41:00] apartments that are already there, there was a plan and you could see what it is. So we've got [2:41:05] at 60 apartments, 10 units. [2:41:09] What if we had 10 buildings with 12 units per building? [2:41:13] That's 120 possible apartment buildings on one, [2:41:17] five acre lot. [2:41:19] You put all of those in. [2:41:20] That's a lot of potential apartments. [2:41:24] I believe the con plan in this area [2:41:26] shows urban village designation. [2:41:28] That's a mixed use designation. [2:41:31] There's already, as we know, an apartment building zoned [2:41:33] for about 25% of this property. [2:41:36] I realize that there will be development, [2:41:38] but we already have the apartment buildings. [2:41:40] We don't need it anymore. [2:41:42] Let's mix the use now. [2:41:44] When the PUD was proposed, [2:41:45] the presentation was for medical, professional, [2:41:47] and assisted living. [2:41:49] Those would be mixed uses. [2:41:50] We don't need to, I don't believe the zoning needs [2:41:52] to be changed for that. [2:41:56] I don't know that the city needs more apartment buildings. [2:41:58] If they really do, maybe they can look somewhere else. [2:42:01] away from where we already have all of these 60 units. [2:42:07] I believe that P&Z was on the right track [2:42:09] with their recommendation, but they [2:42:10] didn't go far enough, specifically [2:42:12] with the possibility of multiple buildings allowed [2:42:14] on one lot. [2:42:15] They're especially used permit. [2:42:16] We don't get notified as neighbors in there of that process. [2:42:20] We just have to find out somehow. [2:42:22] And so that's a problem. [2:42:24] It's having to come over and over and over again [2:42:27] and say the same thing gets kind of tiring. [2:42:29] So I would ask that you please do not approve this proposal. [2:42:32] Thank you. [2:42:33] Thank you, Mrs. Humble. [2:42:35] Monica Rojas, welcome. [2:42:44] [Muted for privacy: home address] [2:42:45] [Muted for privacy: home address] [2:42:48] [Muted for privacy: home address] [2:42:50] [Muted for privacy: home address] [2:42:54] that they've come up here. [2:42:55] We have a lot of concerns as neighbors [2:42:56] about what this will do to our community. [2:42:58] There is a lot of traffic issues with North College [2:43:02] and what does that go to? [2:43:04] Grandview, already. [2:43:05] I'm surprised there hasn't been a traffic study [2:43:07] before we talk about this kind of change to our community. [2:43:11] The thing that I also attended the Planning and Zoning [2:43:14] Commission's meeting, the thing that stuck out to me [2:43:17] was when the planner spends all of that money, [2:43:21] and you can correct me if I say this wrong. [2:43:23] And he said this a little bit tonight, [2:43:24] was that in our city code, there is no other use. [2:43:29] There is no other multiple buildings [2:43:31] on one lot in any residential community. [2:43:34] It is in commercial, it is in industrial, [2:43:36] is not in residential zoning, am I sorting that correctly? [2:43:39] And the development that they are comparing it to, [2:43:42] the Devon project is also in a commercial development. [2:43:47] So we're talking about giving commercial rights [2:43:50] to a residential zone. [2:43:51] So are we wanting to change the process for all developers? [2:43:55] Are we wanting them to not have to come to the city council [2:43:57] unless they have an appeal? [2:44:00] Or do we want to give this one developer this freedom, [2:44:04] this making it easier for him as it's being worded, [2:44:08] and not what other other developers do that, [2:44:10] which to me would look like a special use. [2:44:14] It would not special use a special interest for him, [2:44:18] the other developers are not getting, [2:44:19] or are we wanting to change the way all developers [2:44:22] now get to bring this, and have the ability [2:44:25] to modify the way the city currently deals with this [2:44:30] to make it easier for them. [2:44:32] But I think we need to not give commercial zoning [2:44:36] to a residential area. [2:44:38] And that's all I have to say. [2:44:39] So I would hope that you would reject this request. [2:44:43] Thank you, Mr. Rojas. [2:44:44] Susan Young. [2:44:52] [Muted for privacy: home address] [2:44:55] [Muted for privacy: home address] [2:44:58] [Muted for privacy: home address] [2:45:01] [Muted for privacy: home address] [2:45:05] We purchased our home in 2006 with the exciting intent [2:45:09] that we were moving into an up-and-coming area. [2:45:12] And we were excited to live on the northwest side of town, [2:45:15] knowing that it was new. [2:45:16] And there were several changes that we knew that would be made. [2:45:20] We purchased our home in 2006 for $315,000, which we know, [2:45:25] of course, it's not worth that anymore. [2:45:26] But at the time, Fieldstone was supposed [2:45:29] to be a very lovely area with the home price in that average, [2:45:34] and we know that is different now. [2:45:37] But we still viewed our area as new and up and coming, and we were excited to see its growth. [2:45:43] And since then we've seen the school come in, and we've seen a new stop sign, the school, [2:45:49] the hospital, and now we have this new lovely LDS church, and also the high school is new, [2:45:58] the Walmart, and all these other new changes that we've seen since our time. [2:46:03] I do want to say something about the, um, in other neighborhoods around the town, [2:46:07] in town, especially on the east side of, in, in Twin Falls, where there are LDS churches, [2:46:12] especially the neuroones, beautiful homes come in around those, those churches, that's the [2:46:18] same way with the temple. It's just, it's just how it works. People want to live where [2:46:22] there's going to be a nice neighborhood. Um, we are seeing that with, in our neighborhood [2:46:28] as well, in Twin Falls, we are seeing a lot, in Philstone, a lot of homes are being built [2:46:33] recently a lot and it's just part of how it works. I do struggle with these proposed [2:46:38] apartments because I know it will change the feeling and the quality of our [2:46:42] neighborhood and we don't know what they're going to look like. Brad will is at [2:46:49] least we know what the cottages will look like and they have been proposed part of [2:46:53] the plan. We did not agree with them but we're okay with it. He's made it look like [2:46:58] they'll be nice. There are several large apartment complexes on the west side of [2:47:02] of new lakes, all of which are surrounded by commercial property. [2:47:06] The Canyon Crest Apartments, the ones off of Fillmore Drive, all of those are around commercial [2:47:12] properties. [2:47:13] I don't know if our site in town needs any more apartment complexes. [2:47:20] I don't think we would see that on the east side of Twin Falls, around $300,000 homes, where [2:47:24] you would throw in some apartment complexes. [2:47:26] I know that is an emotional plea, but I do feel very strongly about that there are several [2:47:30] places where apartments can be put. And I don't think all of the homes around that area that [2:47:35] are maybe not quite worth that much anymore. There are several further east that are. And [2:47:40] I don't think it's very fair to all of the homeowners in that neighborhood to have to [2:47:43] fill that and why ruin one of the nice areas of Northwest Twin Falls. Why should we have? [2:47:50] We don't know what kind of apartments move in to change the face of what we hope to make [2:47:55] an improvement of what Twin Falls could look like. And I really would encourage you not [2:47:59] to propose to approve this proposal and consider that we do not need 120 potential people and [2:48:07] my children go to Xavier charter school. [2:48:10] I don't think we need to worry about the traffic as well and thank you. [2:48:14] Thank you, Ms. Nia. [2:48:16] [Muted for privacy: street address] [2:48:22] [Muted for privacy: street address] [2:48:24] [Muted for privacy: street address] [2:48:28] also work at the hospital and so I drive very frequently through that area on Grandview and [2:48:33] I've noticed a lot of the impact over the last three or four years of the growth with the [2:48:37] stop sign, new school, a lot of people using that side of town now and so this area that's [2:48:42] been discussed tonight I guess concerns me more that there's too much flexibility and lack [2:48:49] of specifics in the plan so I feel that there just needs to be no further consideration of [2:48:57] this expansion of the current use, and we suggest that you oppose this. [2:49:02] Thank you, Mr. Packham. [2:49:04] And I believe it's Tara Packham. [2:49:10] I knew it was Packham. [2:49:11] I'm just not sure. [2:49:12] Yes, Tara. [2:49:13] Very good. [2:49:14] Welcome. [2:49:15] Thank you. [2:49:16] Tara Packham. [2:49:17] 966, Rice Circle. [2:49:19] The wife. [2:49:20] No. [2:49:21] I just would, I'm here on behalf of my friends and neighbors who live in the Fieldstone subdivision. [2:49:30] They have a beautiful subdivision. It's nice, big, spacious lots, wide roads that are beautiful. [2:49:40] And I know that this development that is conceptually planned is not consistent with what's already there. [2:49:51] And I would hope that you would stick with the integrity of what's there and provide opportunity [2:49:58] opportunity for more growth in that direction rather than in apartments and [2:50:05] with higher density and more traffic. Thank you. Thank you. Ladies and gentlemen [2:50:12] that's all all the folks that have signed up. Is there anyone else that would [2:50:17] like to come forward that maybe became inspired? Okay I'm going to close the [2:50:25] public testimony portion of this hearing and turn it over to Mr. Harris [2:50:31] to not come up Mr. Fitzgerald. [2:50:37] Thank you. The public comment is [2:50:50] focused upon we are presenting [2:50:54] an apartment proposal and [2:50:58] I do not believe and I think the council understands that [2:51:02] that is not what we're proposing. What we are proposing [2:51:09] is talking about the process. Yes, we would [2:51:13] would like to take it up from six units per building [2:51:18] to eight units as permitted. [2:51:20] But again, that's one building. [2:51:24] If there are to be multiple buildings, [2:51:28] then we come back through the process [2:51:30] of oversight and public input [2:51:34] through the special use permit process. [2:51:37] Likewise, if there is to be more than eight units [2:51:41] in a building that also invokes the government oversight approval public input. [2:51:51] I've asked this to be put up and as you can see where the field stream subdivision is as [2:52:02] compared to the subject property and I also want to point out that the council has approved [2:52:10] the field stone plaza are you are for PUD offices. [2:52:14] So you have that buffer, okay. [2:52:18] The other thing I wanted to point out is in terms of traffic, as the property is developed, [2:52:26] the roads will be built out. [2:52:31] So you can't look at it and say, oh, we don't have the roadways, because that development [2:52:37] will occur as the property is developed into the future. [2:52:49] The comment about we don't have the process of evaluating the will serve or the water [2:52:59] sewer as we would with a subdivision development. [2:53:04] As I understand the conditions that are being placed, that would require a modeling of the [2:53:14] water and sewer, depending upon what is actually brought [2:53:19] before the city for approval in terms of the ultimate [2:53:26] or the concrete proposal. [2:53:30] So as we've listened to the public comments [2:53:32] and absolutely respect the neighbors, [2:53:38] this is focused upon the process under which the PUD [2:53:43] agreement operates and and that's what we're focusing in on not hey we've got [2:53:50] this proposed apartment development for the property and we're going to be [2:53:56] inundated with with apartments we're talking about the process there have any [2:54:09] other questions I would certainly entertain those council this time we're [2:54:15] keeping the public hearing open for any questions of staff applicant and any of [2:54:21] the public testimony you can ask questions. I will be soon closing that portion and just [2:54:27] turn it over to council for deliberation. Once that happens just to remind you we can't [2:54:32] ask any other questions other than from our legal council. Great, Matthew. [2:54:36] John, could you explain to us again just to make sure we have it in our mind, the differences [2:54:42] between the applicant's proposal and the P and Z recommendation? [2:54:48] differences center around the maximum number of units in the building so they [2:54:57] denied or removed the proposed change from six to eight which limited it to six [2:55:04] as a permitted outright permitted use and they also removed or eliminated that [2:55:10] same or similar section in the special use which would go anything over eight [2:55:15] to 12 they remove that completely so in effect their changes limited the number [2:55:23] of units in a building to six and only six that's the maximum they put on in the [2:55:30] beauty what is it for anything I disagree possibly your use come up to that's what [2:55:36] that's what the motion was to do is eliminated those two items so in other [2:55:40] words so the the entire property the the new for the four locks under consideration [2:55:46] would have the same requirements as the PUD that is now listed as apartments. [2:55:51] You know, I don't know if it's the same as those, but... [2:55:54] But it would take away the eight and then later take away the eight. [2:55:58] They're asking for eight outright permitted. [2:56:01] Correct. [2:56:02] And they're asking for 12 through supposed to use for a bit. [2:56:04] Yep, they're asking anything over eight up to 12 through special use. [2:56:07] Okay. [2:56:08] They eliminated that as well as the increase to eight, [2:56:12] which eliminated it down to six as a permitted outright use. [2:56:15] That's what the motion talked about. [2:56:20] Mr. Fitzgerald, did you want to? [2:56:22] If I may. [2:56:23] Yes. [2:56:24] Okay. [2:56:25] I do not agree with Mr. Spendlove's explanation of what the P&Z Commission is recommending. [2:56:32] However, they did allow for the special use permit associated with multiple buildings. [2:56:40] So if you had six units per building, we could still come back on a special use permit process [2:56:48] for multiple buildings. [2:56:50] So two buildings with six units in it. [2:56:53] Mr. Spendlove was shaking his head in the affirmative to what you just said. [2:56:57] Thank you. [2:56:59] Okay. [2:57:00] Any other questions from council before we turn it over to deliberation and or motions [2:57:06] council? [2:57:07] We're closing the [2:57:11] Any more testimony any other questions other than to legal counsel and turn it over to counsel for deliberations? [2:57:19] Chris talking to Chris could you weigh in do we have any similar type of? [2:57:26] PUD agreements have a history chronology and and process some of the this [2:57:33] that we could use as a model or [2:57:35] or it is precisely with the residential. [2:57:39] Yeah, I think the difference is, [2:57:40] is you've approved them one at a time. [2:57:42] And as you approved the first lot in this subdivision, [2:57:47] you approved in a PUD process, [2:57:49] multiple buildings on a single lot. [2:58:02] Anything further from council? [2:58:07] John Berger. [2:58:10] So I had the pleasure of sitting through this process [2:58:13] once before at the Planning and Zoning Commission meeting [2:58:15] because that was the night. [2:58:16] It was also there for our chamber building. [2:58:19] And I might just make a suggestion here that there are a lot [2:58:25] of different items in this request, a lot of specific items. [2:58:29] And I did see that commissions struggle a bit in getting their head wrapped [2:58:33] around of what they were after. [2:58:35] So I think that as we move forward with a possible motion on this, [2:58:39] it might be handier to tackle these items one at a time, [2:58:43] as opposed to trying to do the whole enchilada at once. [2:58:47] And I also think we need to use the same sheet of paper for that, [2:58:51] because the commission was working off, too. [2:58:54] So I think that maybe what Jonathan has put up there now [2:58:58] highlights the various areas that were requested. [2:59:01] Perhaps we could discuss those and then craft a motion [2:59:04] around that, just a recommendation to try to not get confused [2:59:09] over the multiple issues. [2:59:10] I think that's a great suggestion, [2:59:12] because I'm easily confused. [2:59:14] Do you want to start the conversation off? [2:59:17] Sure. [2:59:18] So as we look at the request from the applicant, [2:59:23] I think some of these are pretty easy cleanup items. [2:59:26] So we have, so Jonathan, that's the, [2:59:30] you have the actual, what's it called, exhibit C, [2:59:34] that correct? [2:59:36] I have exhibit C and I've just added what the commission did. [2:59:39] Okay, so that's on, in the agenda packet, [2:59:44] I don't know what page that is, page 11 of the PUD agreement. [2:59:49] everybody on that same page there. [2:59:56] It's page 160 something, 90. [3:00:02] I touched the wrong place on the screen. [3:00:08] I believe it's attachment five if that helps. [3:00:11] I believe that's what it is. [3:00:12] But it's down their ways. [3:00:14] What page was it, Sean? [3:00:16] This is 11 at the bottom of it. [3:00:18] It's page 11 of the PUD. [3:00:20] Okay, says Exhibit C, W, S, and D, R, S, X, Pro, P, T, T, T, T, T, T, T, T, T, T, T, T, T, T, T, T, T, T, T, T, T, T, T, T, T, T, T, T, T, T, T, T, T, T, T, T, T, T, T, T, T, T, T, T, T, T, T, T, T, T, T, T, T, T, T, T, T, T, T, T, T, T, T, T, T, T, T, T, T, T, T, T, T, T, T, T, T, T, T, T, T, T, T, T, T, T, T, T, T, T, T, T, T, T, T, T, T, T, T, T, [3:00:56] building detached accessory. Everybody good with them? [3:01:01] Number six. Yeah, and then there's [3:01:04] renumbering that happens in the process. [3:01:06] But then I'm going to skip over the number of units thing because I think [3:01:14] that's the thing we're going to discuss at length here. So if you're old [3:01:17] at the next page now, you have detached accessory building under seven a B seven [3:01:24] a under special uses. Well first you have the cleanup of the doctor's office [3:01:28] under four, then under seven A, carports, club houses, talking about detached [3:01:38] accessory buildings associated to a residential use. So everyone good with [3:01:44] all of that. So then that leaves basically, oh, and then way at the end of [3:01:56] number seven under access is the the bottom of page 14, or page 14. I'll [3:02:07] a lot shall have a vehicular access dedicated improved public street [3:02:11] and then it talks about or by our recorded easement and that was that was [3:02:17] added in correct that was withdrawn or that was that was okay [3:02:23] we take that out okay and then we have the various building standard issues on [3:02:31] the siding and wood on the bottom of page 16 page 16 thank you so everyone's [3:02:39] is good with all of those. [3:02:41] So then that basically leaves the three items of number [3:02:45] of permitted units in a building, number of units allowed [3:02:51] by special use. [3:02:53] And the third item is the ability [3:02:55] to go through a special use process [3:02:56] for multiple buildings on the same lot. [3:03:02] Have I covered all of them now? [3:03:07] May I just clarify it? [3:03:09] Thank you. [3:03:11] You did address number D development standards. [3:03:14] We're talking about that. [3:03:15] Can you go to page 13? [3:03:16] Yeah, page 13, number D1, what are we doing there? [3:03:19] D1. [3:03:20] So that's allowing multiple buildings on a single line, [3:03:25] by special use. [3:03:26] Right. [3:03:28] Go ahead. [3:03:29] Those are one of the three. [3:03:30] I understand where we're at. [3:03:36] OK. [3:03:41] At least we all know what we're talking about. [3:03:43] So maybe that was helpful to them for the first time. [3:03:47] It was. [3:03:56] So. [3:03:59] Jim, what? [3:04:00] I was going to say, do we want to do, should we have a motion before we start discussing those other? [3:04:05] We certainly could. [3:04:08] Well, what I would propose is presenting a motion on one, each of the three. [3:04:14] On one? [3:04:17] On one. [3:04:18] On one of the items, address it, and then go to the second, there's three items that we're, [3:04:26] the three items that are of controversy will do those one motion at a time. [3:04:33] those items which we all are seemingly okay with we will conclude at the end. [3:04:39] Is that sound reasonable? [3:04:40] We're just trying to get this in some. [3:04:43] From our attorney and it sounds like that might be a smooth. [3:04:46] I'm trying to get this in some workable way to proceed here. [3:04:48] Would that work? [3:04:49] Okay. [3:04:50] I'm hoping for some. [3:04:51] Okay. Well, I will move to on, I guess, for no other. [3:04:56] So we're all in the same sheet of music. [3:04:58] I would move to allow under A permitted uses on page 11, now in red 6A detached, excuse [3:05:11] me, A number E, to allow for six multiple households to say eight units, from six to eight, right? [3:05:27] second motion on four under six e moving from six to eight units by Jim [3:05:37] Mon seconded by Sean Barriger so we're gonna take these one at a time and is [3:05:44] there any liberation about that or comments Greg mine I guess I have I [3:05:55] have some concern there mostly because it started out as our two if it had [3:06:04] It started out as our four, I think I'd probably be there. [3:06:08] And then I'm tempered by the fact that directly to the north is going to be commercial, the [3:06:18] designated commercial, C1 at this point. [3:06:22] And so I will be offering an amendment to the motion that allows from six to eight only [3:06:31] on that portion to the left of what would be the line [3:06:36] extended up of the current apartments. [3:06:39] So in other words, what I'm trying to go for is I would, [3:06:42] those would have to remain R6, [3:06:44] the remainder of the property could be, [3:06:46] another is a lot right above the apartments [3:06:48] could be, would have to remain R6, [3:06:51] with six per building, [3:06:53] the others could be then become eight per building, [3:06:56] the other three lots. [3:06:58] That's my motion, my amendment. [3:07:01] We have a motion on the floor to amend. [3:07:04] Do we have a second? [3:07:07] We have a second by Jim Mon and just to clarify, [3:07:11] say that all over again. [3:07:12] Well, another is the lot directly north [3:07:15] of the apartments, the existing artists, [3:07:17] they would stay after stay at six per building. [3:07:20] The other three lots could move to eight per building. [3:07:23] Could staff give us a name of those three lots [3:07:25] that he's excluding? [3:07:27] Lot two would be six. [3:07:28] I'd like to speak to my motion of a good, you certainly can't. [3:07:35] The reason I'm proposing this is this gives them some additional buffer to the neighborhood [3:07:42] to the east, which is like many which stated was a very nice neighborhood. [3:07:48] We do try to have allow for apartments and things that does have commercial to its north. [3:07:55] That does have commercial to its north. I doubt that that's going to ever sells aren't too lots [3:08:00] I understand that things have changed the [3:08:04] Pull line road extended is becoming the commercial quarter that it is [3:08:10] That's not likely that that could ever be single-filed [3:08:13] family, huh? How they [3:08:16] Would allow eight there it would remain six where the apartment line is that gives them some additional buffer that they're not going to be a [3:08:25] Full-scale apartments in there. There's gonna be a little bit smaller [3:08:29] Apartments that will be limited by [3:08:32] parking needs and things along that line to [3:08:35] To provide a buffer [3:08:39] That's my reasoning I may maybe it may be as somewhat of a compromise move here that will not be accepted by the neighbors, but at least [3:08:48] We're getting them some some additional protection [3:08:51] similar to the apartments they have. [3:08:54] I do have concerns about this project because one of the neighbors, I think Mrs. Humble talked [3:09:00] about, normally when we see these, when we see a plat, we see exactly where everything is [3:09:06] going to be so that it's a little easier to conceptualize and approve things. [3:09:12] But if you're just doing a lot and what it will look like, that's harder for me. [3:09:17] I'm a visual person, I guess I'd like to see, well this is what it's going to be, this is [3:09:21] where it's going to placement, this is where the parking is going to be, this is where the [3:09:25] landscaping is going to be, that's a much easier for me. [3:09:28] And we're used to seeing the PUDs for that matter as well. [3:09:31] So my purpose here is to soften the blow. [3:09:35] Thank you. [3:09:38] Any other comments from Council on that? [3:09:41] Amendment to the main motion. [3:09:43] Sean Berger. [3:09:46] So I can be supportive of the amendment because I do think it helps with that transition. [3:09:52] Can you put the other larger map back up there? [3:09:56] Please, thank you. [3:09:57] So I would agree with the observation [3:10:02] that this is a transitioning area. [3:10:06] And while I appreciate what the neighbors are saying, [3:10:09] that it's not necessarily exactly what you thought [3:10:13] it was going to be when you bought your lot. [3:10:16] Nor were all the folks who built their houses [3:10:18] around a beautiful golf course on the east side of town [3:10:22] and then had a temple built in the middle of it. [3:10:25] Nor in my neighborhood, over on the evil east side of town [3:10:29] that I've heard referred to a couple of times, [3:10:32] I have a stake center, and quite possibly depending [3:10:36] on how the vote goes tomorrow, a new school [3:10:38] across the street from my house that I anticipated [3:10:41] to be continued residential laws. [3:10:44] It is the price of progress to a certain extent. [3:10:47] So I believe that the transition that we see already [3:10:53] occurring with the cottage homes, with the fieldstone plaza [3:10:58] offices, and with this development, also keeping in mind [3:11:03] that this PUD has restrictions or parameters [3:11:08] around the amount of it that can be residential. [3:11:12] It talks about limits on that. [3:11:16] And I also think that, and maybe this is a broader philosophical question that we can discuss a little bit further, [3:11:23] I struggle a bit when we talk about housing, but apartments are labeled commercial. [3:11:29] So earlier in the meeting, and some of you weren't here, we read a proclamation tonight about fair housing in the community, [3:11:39] and talking about housing being a critical component of family and community health and stability, [3:11:46] and housing choices impacting our children's access [3:11:51] to education and our ability to seek and retain employment options [3:11:55] and cultural benefits we enjoy in the extent of our exposure to crime and drugs [3:11:59] and the quality of healthcare we receive in emergencies. [3:12:02] That doesn't all have to happen in a single family home. [3:12:06] A lot of that needs to happen in apartments. [3:12:09] We are underserved by apartment type living in our community [3:12:14] And I think that when we define it as commercial development, [3:12:21] it's personified as a negative thing. [3:12:24] And that's not fair to people [3:12:26] who would need to live in apartments too. [3:12:28] So that's a little bit of soap box there from me, [3:12:31] but I can support your amendment, Greg, [3:12:35] because I do think it assists with that transition. [3:12:38] Again, that you're seeing on the South Side there too, [3:12:40] with Xavier and the LDS Church. [3:12:45] anything further on the amendment to the motion? [3:12:50] Jim, how would that affect, because we're going to be proceeding now on to, [3:12:55] with this also, with your amendment, disallow any sort of SUP to further [3:13:02] build in that top block? [3:13:05] I was planning to offer that same amendment to the next issue. [3:13:10] The next issue. [3:13:11] Okay. [3:13:12] Just to clean it up to make sure we do. [3:13:13] Thank you, Greg. [3:13:17] I see no further lights council. So Lee Island roll call vote on the amendment. Greg Lansing. Yes [3:13:24] Yes, Rebecca milswicka. Sorry. Dang [3:13:29] Susan Hocken. Yes, Jim on. Yes, John Berger. Yes, Chris Tocquito. No [3:13:37] Motion passes five to one. Now on to the main motion. Anything further on the main motion council. [3:13:48] Leanna Rokov, please [3:13:50] Don Hall? Yes [3:13:55] Suzanne Hawkins? Yes [3:13:58] Jim Mun? Yes [3:14:00] Sean Berriger? Yes [3:14:02] Chris Talkington? No [3:14:06] Greg Lanting? Yes [3:14:08] Motion passes five to zero [3:14:12] Levine, five to one [3:14:14] Excuse me, thank you [3:14:16] Thank you [3:14:17] I am math challenge sometimes [3:14:20] Thank you [3:14:21] Council [3:14:22] Jim Mun [3:14:26] I'm going to go ahead and proceed with the second motion, which would be on page 12 under special uses. [3:14:34] I'm going to allow multiple households, any more than eight units, to be approved up to a maximum of 12 units. [3:14:45] Pursue it to a special use permit. [3:14:47] Second. [3:14:50] Motion on 4 by Jim Mon, seconded by Sean Berger with an amendment coming from Greg McManer. [3:14:57] I would like to make the same amendment that that that portion of the SUP [3:15:02] would that portion of the motion would not allow for a movement to any larger than [3:15:08] six on the area we just discussed and I would also like to throw in a secondary [3:15:13] part of that that if any of those SUPs come through that everyone in the field [3:15:19] still subdivision would be notified by the applicant within how many feet here [3:15:26] I'm just saying everybody in that subdivision the fieldstone the fieldstone okay second [3:15:33] We have motion on the floor by Greg running set seconded by Suzanne Hawkins [3:15:38] for the amendment [3:15:39] Sean Barreter [3:15:41] Well again, I'm not gonna disagree with [3:15:45] Extending the notification boundaries [3:15:48] But I will note that not everybody who spoke tonight north planning and zoning hearing is in the fieldstone subdivision. There are other [3:15:55] other neighbourhoods over there that feel affected as well. So, I don't know how big [3:16:01] it are out of circle, and this that put some undue burden on notification. I don't have [3:16:14] a solution to it. I'm just pointing out that it's not only folks in Fieldstone who are [3:16:19] discussing their concerns. [3:16:22] Jonathan, could you maybe go down the road a little bit because we had that question in the what's [3:16:29] our what's our committee? ZOAC meeting about on some of these type of developments that we would [3:16:36] broaden the circle of can you can you speak on that? There is a code section I don't know which one [3:16:42] it is but it allows the zoning administrator to increase the notification distance it doesn't say [3:16:49] an increase to a certain amount. It just says increase to include others. I believe in that [3:16:54] meeting we discussed this area potentially. The caveat is if you increase the notification [3:17:01] to more than 200 different property owners, they no longer have to mail and they only have [3:17:08] to do a general notification. So that's the drawback, Sean. I don't know if we get to 200 [3:17:16] depending on how far you go, it's possible, [3:17:19] but the zoning administrator has the ability [3:17:22] to increase that notification distance. [3:17:26] Johnathan, Chris talking to you. [3:17:27] I just can't support this, that's a 50% increase [3:17:31] we're calling for in density, going from eight to 12. [3:17:33] It's just unreasonable. [3:17:40] Well, great landing. [3:17:42] Sorry, I'm here, not even good. [3:17:46] Chris, while I agree with you, I'm putting my motion in [3:17:50] to guarantee a little bit of protection. [3:17:53] I believe I too will be voting against the 12. [3:17:56] I concerned that it started at R2 and goes all the way 12, [3:17:59] but I want to put my amendment in, [3:18:01] at least to shed the later amendment, [3:18:05] a major motion pass, at least there is some additional protection. [3:18:09] So that's where he's now will be voting for the amendment. [3:18:15] Anything further on the amendment to the main motion council? [3:18:20] Leyla, roll call vote. [3:18:22] Susan Hawkins? Yes. Jim? Yes. [3:18:28] Sean Burger? Yes. [3:18:32] Chris Talkington? No. Greg Lanthie? Yes. [3:18:38] Don Hall? Yes. Motion passes 5-1. Greg Lanth. [3:18:47] Again, as we were talking about a transitioning area here, and I still do have concerns with [3:18:56] with it going to all the way to 12 until we have a build out. [3:19:00] Could you live that map there, John? [3:19:01] That was actually what I was going to refer to. [3:19:03] Then we have a build out a creek side which goes [3:19:06] out that backside. [3:19:07] I'm concerned for, which I mean build out all the way [3:19:12] to Pole Line. [3:19:13] I'm concerned for if we had units of buildings in there [3:19:16] up to 12 units and that much density in that area. [3:19:20] I doubt we would have the traffic flow needed to make it work. [3:19:24] And although I think that's an area that can probably handle that [3:19:28] and we'll get a buffer to it on all sides, [3:19:31] because we took care of it by putting it [3:19:33] with that amendment doing the R6 portion, [3:19:35] I do have concerns that we wouldn't have enough traffic flow [3:19:39] to make it happen until Creekside is completed, [3:19:43] all the way from North College to Pullwine. [3:19:48] I think the traffic flow and possibly even police [3:19:53] the fire flow might be moved. Jim. Thank you, Mayor. This would be for Fritz. [3:20:03] By us approving or voting in the affirmative on this motion, we're certainly not in any [3:20:11] way approving the inclusion of 12 units per lot or per lot there. All we are doing is [3:20:18] providing a further mechanism for them to bring it forward that will allow a complete [3:20:24] vetting process from top to bottom, but it certainly doesn't give them cart [3:20:28] block on building 12 units. It just it just 12 flexes. It basically changes the [3:20:35] process. It would require especially use approval from planning and zoning, which [3:20:40] could be appealed to the City Council. Okay, and you recall you still haven't [3:20:46] voted on multiple buildings. Right. Anything further on the main motion council? [3:20:53] The a la roll call vote. [3:20:59] Yes. [3:21:00] Schonberger. [3:21:01] Yes. [3:21:02] Chris Chalkington. [3:21:03] No. [3:21:04] Greg Lansing. [3:21:05] No. [3:21:06] Don Hall. [3:21:08] Yes. [3:21:10] Susan Hunkins. [3:21:12] No. [3:21:13] Motion passes. [3:21:14] Three to two. [3:21:18] No. [3:21:19] It does. [3:21:20] It does. [3:21:21] It does. [3:21:22] It fails. [3:21:23] So it fails. [3:21:24] Thank you. [3:21:25] Motion fails. [3:21:26] Well, it's your math skills. [3:21:28] Thank you. [3:21:29] Schonberger. [3:21:33] So I'll jump in on the last one here. [3:21:36] So the bottom on page 13, property and development standards, use of lots under section D there. [3:21:46] I would move that we include the revision there to allow a special use process for multiple [3:21:58] buildings on a single lot. [3:22:03] I'll second because I have some questions. [3:22:10] Okay, we have a motion on the floor by Sean Berger, [3:22:17] seconded by Greg Lanting. [3:22:19] Greg Lanting. [3:22:20] Could you come up and help a poor councilman out there, [3:22:24] just to understand exactly what that means for sure. [3:22:29] This is where the old days when I was on planning [3:22:32] and zoning we used to have work sessions that were really valuable, [3:22:35] and we don't have work sessions anymore. [3:22:37] Could you explain what the effect would that would have? [3:22:41] I know John talked about we don't have anywhere else, [3:22:43] but apparently we do have it in special use permits, [3:22:46] other places, correct? [3:22:48] The multiple buildings per lot? [3:22:50] Right, in residential areas or just commercial. [3:22:55] But now we do have it in residential areas. [3:22:58] You've got, well, you've got this one? [3:23:03] Yeah, under PUDs. [3:23:04] I mean, Jonathan's talking about straight outright [3:23:07] permitted, we don't, we don't around, [3:23:10] but PUDs we do allow. [3:23:11] That's what I understood. [3:23:12] Okay, thank you. [3:23:19] We have a motion on the floor council. [3:23:20] Any further on the motion? [3:23:23] I'm just reading the planning ends. [3:23:25] I'm sorry, I'm just trying to read real quick [3:23:27] the planning and zoning recommendation on this particular [3:23:30] item and I'm trying to scroll through here [3:23:32] and find does anybody remember? [3:23:34] So they included in their recommendation. [3:23:36] They did recommend this one. [3:23:38] Okay, thank you. [3:23:42] Liberal public vote, please. [3:23:45] Sean Berger. [3:23:46] Yes. [3:23:47] Chris Dockington. [3:23:48] Yes. [3:23:49] Greg Lanting. [3:23:50] Yes. [3:23:52] John Hall. Yes. [3:23:54] Susan Hockens. Yes. [3:23:57] Jim. Yes. [3:23:59] OK. That one was easier six to zero and it passes. [3:24:04] You got the number, right? Yeah. [3:24:05] For once. Thanks, Chris. [3:24:09] Jim. I think so. [3:24:12] Well, I will move to approve all those other things [3:24:17] that we discussed. [3:24:20] And most of it was, let's just go through it really quickly [3:24:23] on page 11 on the Exhibit C, number 6A detached accessory buildings, [3:24:31] lesson 100, amending it that, yeah, I'll get that one in the next section. [3:24:43] Also going up to number 3A, putting doctor's office in permitted uses. [3:24:49] So we got those two on. [3:24:51] Going off to page 12, removing doctor's offices from special uses. [3:24:55] on number four B. On number seven A, detached accessory buildings more than [3:25:06] one thousand square feet associated to a residential use carport, garages and [3:25:10] clever assets and other accessory buildings making that amendment. And then [3:25:15] we're off to page 14 and correct me if I'm wrong, seven A or just a number seven [3:25:26] amending the sentence to say all laws shall have vehicular access on a dedicated [3:25:32] improved public streets with a 50-foot minimum right away, that was withdrawn, [3:25:36] okay, work with me here, page 16 number 12a, architectural steel siding wood, [3:25:47] cementetuous, is that the word cementetuous, is that close? [3:25:51] I mean, I have cement. [3:25:53] Oh, yeah. [3:25:53] Criminal Justice major. [3:25:54] You can go with that one very often. [3:25:59] Hardy Board, a number D, Wood, or Symentuous Materials, Hardy Board, make those amendments. [3:26:07] And that's it. [3:26:09] If I got them all, okay? [3:26:11] Second. [3:26:12] We have motion on the floor by Jim Munn, seconded by Susanne Hawkins of all the things [3:26:22] that we're just listed. Anything further on that motion counts? Leila roll call vote. [3:26:30] Yes. Greg Lante. Yes. Don Hall. Yes. Suzanne Hopkins. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Motion passes 6-0. [3:26:46] So Fritz do we need to roll all those up into one motion now and so the the only [3:26:57] the item that we didn't address were the staff recommendations and. [3:27:03] Yeah, it would be good to include. [3:27:05] Let me find those. [3:27:09] So that would be, so I would make a motion that we have those approvals that we just [3:27:16] made stand and also to include the staff recommendations. [3:27:25] Subject to amendments as required by building, engineering, fire and zoning officials to ensure [3:27:30] compliance with all applicable city code requirements and standards and the WS&V PUD number 263 AR6 [3:27:39] pro-planned unit development and subject to a new infrastructure model for sewer and water [3:27:45] systems and corresponding construction plans being approved by the city prior to any development [3:27:51] occurring unlocks two through five of the WS&D [3:27:54] subdivision first amended. [3:27:58] Second. [3:27:59] We have a motion on four by Sean Berger, [3:28:01] seconded by Jim Munn to add those recommendations [3:28:06] that were just listed. [3:28:10] I'm sorry. [3:28:11] Any further on that motion council? [3:28:15] We have a roll call vote please. [3:28:17] Greg Lansing. [3:28:18] Yes. [3:28:19] John Hall. [3:28:20] Yes. [3:28:22] Suzanne Hawkins. [3:28:23] Yes. [3:28:25] Jim Munn. [3:28:26] Yes. [3:28:27] Sean Berger. [3:28:28] Yes. [3:28:30] No motion passes five to one [3:28:36] Chris talking this isn't how zoning is supposed to work. It's been cumbersome from the applicant has been [3:28:45] totally [3:28:46] Non-understandable by both the council and the residents. This is what the Zowak committee has been trying to do is clean up some of this [3:28:53] I get away from [3:28:55] PUDs [3:28:57] because this is our most convoluted experience I've ever had with a PUD and [3:29:02] we can do better. That's been miserable. Jim, I'm not going to respond. I think that we did the best we could here. [3:29:10] I think that whereas that we can't improve our application of Zolac and we are moving in that direction, [3:29:16] that in this regard we were able to, this is called making sausages. I've heard that my right armable friends have referred to in the past. [3:29:24] I think we did okay and this is government 101 and so I am, whereas I, some of the things [3:29:35] that I requested were not approved, I do believe in the process and I think it did work here. [3:29:41] Sean Berger. [3:29:42] Chris, I don't disagree with you and I think that we need to address the process because [3:29:49] as it currently stands, I think we exclude a significant opportunity for people who want [3:29:59] to live in a residence that isn't a single family dwelling to a commercial zone or a process [3:30:09] that requires a subdivision to make fourplex apartment units. [3:30:16] And it's just the way our code is written, and I think it needs to be addressed, because [3:30:22] it's not the same community that was built in the early 1900s and was in the 1950s and [3:30:30] even was 10 years ago. [3:30:32] And I will say I think the developers are doing their best to try to navigate through [3:30:39] a process that is cumbersome for them as well as for us, as well as for the neighbors. [3:30:45] I think when you're playing unit developing everything in town, [3:30:51] it's difficult to know what might be down the road from you. [3:30:55] So I hope that the zoning ordinance committee [3:31:01] can take a look at that sooner than later [3:31:03] and try to figure out ways to address that. [3:31:07] Thank you. [3:31:08] Ladies and gentlemen, the next item on our agenda this evening [3:31:13] is adjourned to executive session 67-2345F to communicate with legal counsel for the public [3:31:21] agency discuss the legal ramifications and legal options for pending litigation or controversies [3:31:30] not yet being litigated but eminently likely to be litigated. The mere presence of legal [3:31:36] counsel at an executive session does not satisfy the requirement. [3:31:41] I move that we go into executive session under 67-2345-F to communicate with legal counsel on possible litigation. [3:31:56] Second. [3:31:57] We have a motion on board by Suzanne Hawkins, seconded by Greg Lanting. Anything further on the motion council? [3:32:04] The aye will roll call vote please. [3:32:06] John Hall? [3:32:07] Yes. [3:32:09] Suzanne Hawkins? [3:32:10] Yes. [3:32:11] Jim Mann? [3:32:12] Yes. [3:32:13] Yes, motion passes six to zero just wanted to remind the public that we will be meeting [3:32:20] an executive session. We will not be making any decisions in executive session and we will [3:32:25] not come out and reconvene this meeting. We are moving into executive session.