Oversight Archive: City Council meeting, 2014-06-02, recording 1 (started 17:00) Machine transcript (faster-whisper base.en), not checked word for word; the Pledge of Allegiance is shown in its standard wording. The recording is the record. Times are time into the recording. Passages with private details are muted in the audio and marked here. The audio on the page below was re-encoded by software from the video the agency posted. Check any passage against that audio before relying on it. Page: https://oversightarchive.org/twin-falls-id/meetings/2014-06-02/ [0:04:57] I'd like to call the meeting of the Twin Falls City Council to order as June 2nd, 2014. [0:05:02] Welcome everyone and we have the pleasure of a couple of scouts that are dying to come forward and lead us in the Pledge of Allegiance. [0:05:08] So those of you wishing to join us please rise. [0:05:11] I pledge allegiance to the Flag of the United States of America, and to the Republic for which it stands, one Nation under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all. [0:05:35] Thank you all, and gentlemen, if you wouldn't mind coming to the podium and stating your name, your scout troop number, where you meet, and if you're working on any badges currently. [0:05:51] I am Carter here. We're in the 2.70 and we meet at a church. I'm not working any [0:06:04] bad as currently. This, you're next. [0:06:10] Dude Pei, same troop working on citizenship in the world, in the community, yeah, community. [0:06:21] Well, we appreciate you gentlemen coming forward and especially with such enthusiasm. [0:06:27] Really appreciate it. [0:06:30] Moving on in our procedures tonight, we do have a quorum of the City Council. [0:06:35] All seven members are here tonight, and I'll turn it over to our city manager to see if we have any amendments to the agenda. [0:06:42] Mr. Mayor, members of the council, you'll notice under adjournment to executive session, there are two items. [0:06:48] Staff would request that item number 167, 2, 3, 4, 5, Subsection 1A be removed from tonight's agenda. [0:07:00] And Travis, you did say that we're going to keep executive session the second one that's 1F? [0:07:06] Yes, sir. [0:07:07] Okay, very good. [0:07:08] So do we need a motion to pull that off the agenda? [0:07:13] I don't think so. [0:07:14] Not really? [0:07:14] Okay, and we won't do it. [0:07:16] Thank you. [0:07:18] This is the time that we don't have any proclamations tonight. [0:07:21] This is the time for anyone in the general public [0:07:24] that's here with us this evening. [0:07:25] Now, John, I'm going to be calling you up in just a minute, sir, [0:07:28] that would like to address the council. [0:07:30] This is the time for you to do so. [0:07:33] I'm not seeing folks in the community that are coming forward, [0:07:36] so we'll move to the next section, which [0:07:38] is the consent calendar. [0:07:39] But before we go to the consent calendar, [0:07:41] I thought this was a very appropriate time to ask John [0:07:44] if he might mind coming forward. [0:07:46] Number three on the consent calendar is the bed race fund raiser. [0:07:51] And I'd just like to give you a little bit of free advertisement, John, if you wouldn't mind talking about it. [0:07:57] Well, thank you Mr. Mayor and members of the council for approving this for our fifth year. [0:08:03] It's shaping up to be a good one and I just want to let everyone know that there's still time to form a team. [0:08:09] Know anybody that has MS or just wants to have some fun form five person team and come on down. [0:08:16] And how would they get a hold of you folks to be able to put a team together and get with you, sir? [0:08:20] We have our Facebook page, Bed Racing, for Multiple Sclerosis, or you can call our home phone 733-0912. [0:08:28] Thank you, sir. Appreciate you coming forward. [0:08:30] Thank you very much. [0:08:31] I'll turn it over to council for what we're going to do with consent calendar. [0:08:35] Sean Berger. [0:08:36] Move approval of the consent calendar. [0:08:38] Second. [0:08:39] I have a motion on the floor by Sean Berger, seconded by [0:08:42] by Greg Lanting to approve the consent calendar [0:08:46] as listed in the agenda. [0:08:48] Anything further on that motion council? [0:08:52] Leila Roek-Haul vote please. [0:08:54] Suzanne Hawkins. [0:08:55] Yes. [0:08:56] Sean Berreger. [0:08:57] Yes. [0:08:57] Jim Mann. [0:08:58] Yes. [0:08:59] Grant Lanting. [0:09:00] Yes. [0:09:01] Don Hall. [0:09:02] Yes. [0:09:03] Rebecca Milsweka. [0:09:03] Yes. [0:09:04] Motion passes, it's seven to zero. [0:09:07] And congratulations on another fundraiser this year. [0:09:11] Under items for consideration, the first item is consideration of a request to approve the agreement between the City of Twin Falls and CH2M Hill OMI for the operations and management of the city's wastewater treatment plan. [0:09:24] And we have our city manager, Travis Rothweiler. [0:09:27] Well, Travis. [0:09:28] Thank you. Good evening, Mayor and Council. [0:09:31] Last week we had the opportunity to present and go in detail the agreement that has been negotiated between city staff and [0:09:40] CH2M Hill, OMI, CH2 has been the city's wastewater treatment plan partner for the last 30 years. [0:09:48] This agreement that is before you today reflects that relationship and that partnership that [0:09:53] we've built over time. [0:09:55] Staff is asking council to consider a 10-year agreement. [0:09:59] The significant changes to the agreement are detailed in the agenda statement and we spend [0:10:08] sometime going through those last week. [0:10:11] I think that there are a few that I would just like to point out as being probably key [0:10:17] to this agreement. [0:10:20] Number one is in the area of direct cost and the overhead cost. [0:10:27] The direct cost is going to set that base fee and is really going to be the true cost [0:10:32] of the electrical, the chemical, the labor, the manpower, all of the things that we are [0:10:38] needed from an input perspective to ensure that that plant maintains and PDS compliance. [0:10:44] Above that is what is their overhead or profit. [0:10:48] And you'll notice in here that that amount has been decreased from 22% to 20%. [0:10:54] And an additional change to that is that in the past we would provide CH2 with the direct [0:11:03] cost portion based upon the amount that had been budgeted in this agreement and for the [0:11:09] future years of this agreement we provide the amount directly attached to the actual costs [0:11:15] of what that is moving forward. [0:11:18] The liability amount in 7.2 has been increased from $150,000 to $250,000. [0:11:26] We believe that that is a sufficient amount to cover us in terms of any issues that may [0:11:33] occur, although very unexpected based upon CH STRAC record with us. [0:11:39] And the third and I think the one that I would highlight as representative of our partnership [0:11:43] is this agreement gives the city almost veto power, if you will, of the individual who is [0:11:52] responsible for serving as the plant manager. [0:11:56] Really we have a great plant manager in Sean Moffitt. [0:12:00] We've talked about that and we really believe that he being our primary point of contact helps [0:12:06] perpetuate a positive, ongoing relationship. [0:12:09] And should that change or not be the case, we have the right to ensure that should Sean [0:12:18] choose other opportunities that we get a seat at the table of who is going to help run this [0:12:25] We swear a facility that is critically important for us with that, Mr. Mayor members of the council [0:12:31] I'll stand for any questions. Do we have any questions for our city manager or we have Sean in the audience? [0:12:38] Chris talking to. No, I'm ready to make a motion. Chris, I see no other lights. I think we're ready. [0:12:43] I hope move to approve the final agreement between the City of Twin Falls and CH2M [0:12:49] OMI for operations management of the city wastewater treatment plant for the 10 year [0:12:54] duration. [0:12:55] Okay. [0:12:57] Motion on the floor by Chris talking in, seconded by Graham Lanting. [0:13:00] Do we have anything further on that motion council? [0:13:05] I just want to state out for folks that maybe just join us this evening as you state at [0:13:09] Travis that this is an ongoing evaluation, many man hours looking into this contract [0:13:16] and this was brought in front of the city council last week to discuss. [0:13:20] So it's not something that we just made a decision quickly. [0:13:23] We take this contract extremely seriously, [0:13:27] especially with the history that we've had with CH, [0:13:32] to Emhill, I think we're ready for a vote. [0:13:37] Yeah? [0:13:39] Yes. [0:13:41] Yes. [0:13:43] Yes. [0:13:44] Yes. [0:13:46] Yes. [0:13:48] Yes. [0:13:49] Yes. [0:13:50] Motion passes. [0:13:51] 7-0. [0:13:52] Chris talking. [0:13:53] Could I do a follow-up question? [0:13:54] Sean, I had a follow-up question. [0:13:57] your fine Kiwanis meeting and I hope I didn't overextend but upon the completion [0:14:03] of our wastewater plant project it was approved by the taxpayers is it fair to [0:14:10] categorize our new water system as a tertiary system or is that even the [0:14:15] lexicon that you use? It's not technically a tertiary treatment plant yet [0:14:21] with the treatment that's going in it's just extending the capacity that we [0:14:25] have right now to treat more of the pollutants that are coming in. Usually when you start [0:14:30] talking about tertiary treatment, you're talking about filters, open brain cells type of things, [0:14:37] and you're usually talking about pretty low numbers on what you're discharging out on [0:14:41] your ethylene when you're getting to tertiary. So we're expanding the quantity as opposed [0:14:45] to improving the quality really? Correct. Okay, thank you. So I did overstep, I apologize. [0:14:54] We have any further questions or concerns or thoughts. [0:14:57] Thank you, Sean. [0:14:58] Thank you. [0:14:59] I think we are going to move to the next item, [0:15:01] which is a presentation of an update [0:15:04] on the road, show, and zone maintenance project. [0:15:08] And we have our Public Works Director, John Dayton, [0:15:11] available, and welcome, John. [0:15:16] Thank you, Mr. Mayor and Council. [0:15:20] Yeah, so tonight I wanted to talk a little bit [0:15:22] about what we have planned for construction this summer. [0:15:26] Typically, we call it the road show. [0:15:28] I did want to talk about zone maintenance. [0:15:30] As you guys know, we've implemented zone maintenance [0:15:33] officially in the last year or two. [0:15:36] And so you'll be fairly familiar with this map. [0:15:38] This is our zone maintenance map. [0:15:40] It's slightly different than what you've seen before, [0:15:42] because we highlighted the arterials. [0:15:46] And so it kind of gives you a little better bearing [0:15:49] on where we're at. [0:15:51] So last year, zone one is the green zone there. [0:15:55] is the old town, thank you, we seal coated zone one last year and this year [0:16:03] going clockwise as zone two and we'll be seal coding zone two this year. [0:16:11] Eventually we want to get to a spot where we're doing utility construction [0:16:17] in the season prior to the seal code year so ideally we would be in zone three, we [0:16:24] meaning the utility, water and waste water making improvements. [0:16:28] But we're just getting started and so we're just now, underground is just trying to get [0:16:33] a head of seal coat, which we are on schedule as you know. [0:16:36] In zone two we have a fairly large project on Diamond Avenue. [0:16:40] We're replacing about 5,000 feet of water line. [0:16:44] We have about 3,500 feet in the ground now. [0:16:49] And so with that, I think I'll go ahead and I apologize. [0:17:02] These are hard to read. [0:17:03] I did not have a very technology friendly day today. [0:17:06] I couldn't quite get this printed the way I wanted it to. [0:17:10] So this is zone two and the colors are really hard to see. [0:17:14] I don't know if the lights would help or not. [0:17:24] So it's a little better. [0:17:31] In zone two we plan on doing chip seal this year which is down in the legend you can see [0:17:37] the red, and then we're also going to do a fog seal. [0:17:43] And this year, we're going to address about 95% of the roads [0:17:50] in zone two. [0:17:51] Thank you. [0:17:56] This year, we're doing 60% of the roads [0:17:58] are going to be done with a fog seal, which really stretches [0:18:01] our dollar. [0:18:04] And the fog seal, again, is in the green. [0:18:07] It is hard to see. [0:18:10] And ChIPSEAL is about 32%. [0:18:14] The remainder of the couple of percent is [0:18:18] reconstruction projects. [0:18:19] We have a couple of large overlay projects, [0:18:23] Orchard Avenue West. [0:18:24] This is Washington. [0:18:26] This is Orchard. [0:18:29] And this is Eastland in Orchard. [0:18:32] And as you know, we have two significant reconstruction [0:18:34] projects. [0:18:35] So if you add that repair to what we're doing with ChIPSEAL, [0:18:40] we're going to be right around 95%. [0:18:43] The 5% that we're not doing in this zone [0:18:47] has been planned. [0:18:50] Blue Lakes proper here, and some of Orchard [0:18:54] is being left out this year. [0:18:56] And we want to do that because we have significant construction [0:18:58] projects on Orchard. [0:19:01] And we didn't want to shut down more than these two [0:19:05] one-mile road accesses. [0:19:07] Plus, we can come back next year and hit these with the chip seal. [0:19:12] So if we need to, we'll come back next year and hit that. [0:19:21] Yeah. [0:19:22] Oh, and the other leave out is, sorry, go back down. [0:19:31] The water line project that we're doing right here down diamond, [0:19:36] we'll just get that road repaired at the end of the season. [0:19:39] And so we're leaving that out of the chip seal this year, [0:19:42] and we'll chip seal it probably next year. [0:19:45] So again, we're going to get about 95% of the roads done. [0:19:51] I talked to you about the underground maintenance [0:19:53] that we're doing in that zone. [0:19:55] And there is some out of zone work, [0:19:58] and so I wanted to briefly talk about that. [0:20:07] There's two little blowups there. [0:20:12] This is Old Town. [0:20:13] Thank you. [0:20:15] This is Idaho Street. [0:20:18] If you remember, we reconstructed it last year. [0:20:21] And because it's not too far in proximity from the zone we're in, [0:20:27] and because we like to chip seal about a year after a reconstruction, [0:20:31] Dean went ahead and added this to the seal coat. [0:20:36] And the zone, oh, let me back up. [0:20:40] The fox seal, like I said, stretches our dollar. [0:20:45] And between fox seal and chip seal, [0:20:48] We're going to spend approximately 675,000. [0:20:54] We haven't bid the fog seal yet, so that's based on an estimate. [0:21:01] But we're pretty comfortable without a amount. [0:21:02] So there's going to be some money left over. [0:21:04] And so what we've done is we've decided to ship seal a big project, [0:21:08] which is going to be Washington Avenue. [0:21:10] This is Addison, so north of Addison on Washington. [0:21:13] And then we have Shoop and Haber in here as well. [0:21:15] So we are able to add to this zone. [0:21:18] And that is Zone 3. [0:21:20] And so again, next year, when we're in Zone 3, [0:21:23] we're going to come back to Zone 2 and do a little bit. [0:21:25] So there's a little bit of bookkeeping here between the zones. [0:21:28] And like we said before, we're going to try to always stay in zone, [0:21:30] but sometimes it just doesn't make sense. [0:21:34] Any questions on that exhibit? [0:21:36] Chris, talking to John, could you tell us [0:21:38] the difference on the longevity of a chip versus a fog seal? [0:21:43] OK. [0:21:44] Good question. [0:21:45] So there are several different applications [0:21:47] that you can use to lengthen the life of a roadway. [0:21:50] As you know, chip seal is going to give you, [0:21:54] let's see, a fog seal is going to rejuvenate the asphalt. [0:21:57] So it doesn't have much wear. [0:22:00] It has some weathering, and it has some depletion of asphalt. [0:22:03] So you're going to rejuvenate it. [0:22:06] And you're trying to get your oil content back. [0:22:10] It also helps seal it a little bit. [0:22:12] Some roads that are further degraded, [0:22:16] you wouldn't want to, you wouldn't want to fox seal it. [0:22:20] So a chip seal does get you additional life [0:22:24] and wear resistance for traction, you know, let's see, [0:22:37] yeah, yeah, we're on an eight year cycle for a reason, [0:22:41] you know, the life on them is between five and eight years. [0:22:44] So if you're using a fox seal, [0:22:45] you're using them on a root that's in pretty good shape. [0:22:48] So. [0:22:50] John, I have a question about that. [0:22:51] So we assess these roads and we determine [0:22:56] what application to use because of their wear, [0:22:58] because of the weather that's taking place [0:23:00] the last few years or last winter's are obviously [0:23:04] very difficult on roads. [0:23:05] But that's how we assess and we say, [0:23:07] this one needs a fox eel or can get by with a fox eel, [0:23:10] this one needs a ship eel. [0:23:11] Yep, that's right. [0:23:12] You can question. [0:23:18] No other questions? [0:23:19] Okay. [0:23:20] One more? [0:23:21] Yep, thank you. [0:23:23] This past year we purchased a piece of equipment that rehabilitates manholes by taking out the [0:23:34] whole collar. [0:23:35] You know, we have a lot of these manholes around town where they're half-inch to an inch recessed [0:23:40] and they're terrible driving through them like you hit them pretty hard. [0:23:43] So it can be really costly and labor-intensive to go and do that. [0:23:48] So we found a piece of equipment next time I come up we'll bring some pictures of it. [0:23:53] it's called the Mr. Manhole System and it really optimizes and speeds up [0:23:59] replacing manholes and so what we like to do is after the seal coat is done we [0:24:07] like to go in the year after so this year we're in zone one we see a coat of [0:24:10] last year and we're going back and hitting these manholes and bringing them [0:24:14] up to up to grade it provides a really nice smooth transition go ahead Greg [0:24:19] planning? John, yes, you have the ones you drive on the ones you [0:24:24] notice, and it's not really our road, but the the mantle covers on [0:24:28] Addison between the two five points are pretty big bump each [0:24:32] time you hit one and they're right down the middle lane. Is that [0:24:35] something we will end up doing? Or is that a sense it's a state [0:24:38] road they will end up doing? Well, you know, we were talking [0:24:41] about that. That's something we do need to talk to the state [0:24:43] about the stormwater. There's there are utilities, there's some [0:24:47] of them are not ours. There's telephone and fiber that also have bolts that are rough too. [0:24:53] But I'm glad you asked because ideally what we'd like to do is stay in our zone ideally [0:25:02] and stay in zone one. And the reason we want to do that is once you replace a manhole, [0:25:07] you know you start chip ceiling and then you start building to the road and you raise the [0:25:13] elevation of the road and then that manhole becomes a problem again. So if we go in right [0:25:17] Right after we chip seal and replace, we got a whole eight years before we add a little [0:25:22] eighth of an inch, a quarter of an inch or half of an inch and so we're thinking that the [0:25:26] manholes can survive two cycles, so at least 16 years which is great. [0:25:32] We also like to focus on the arterials and so it's something that our customers or people [0:25:39] are going to notice. [0:25:40] They're going to see us replacing manholes in this zone and there's worse ones on other [0:25:45] zones. [0:25:46] I don't want to do is is undermine our zone maintenance and go go too far ahead and replace [0:25:51] the bunch and then that very same year they're already recessed a quarter of an inch. So if [0:25:56] we can stay disciplined and stay in our zone it is great. Now there's going to be some [0:26:00] that are huge and right like five points is a great example everybody sees it and you know [0:26:05] every now and then we'll go out of zone. So it makes sense. So Mr. Manholke I love that [0:26:12] Could you describe what Mr. Manhole does again? [0:26:17] Yeah, I really wish we had pictures. [0:26:20] Because you can't forget that name. [0:26:24] It attaches to a skid steer, so it's an attachment, and it has a plate that fixes to the inside of the manhole. [0:26:34] So it locks into the manhole, and then there's a bit that comes outside of the manhole, [0:26:40] and it just spins, has carbide blades on it, and it just cuts a perfect circle about a foot, [0:26:49] two feet greater in diameter than the mantle. [0:26:52] And then it just lifts the entire piece out, lid, ring, everything, pulls it out, and you [0:26:58] set it aside. [0:27:00] And the really cool thing is when you put a chimney on it, they call it, when you bring [0:27:04] it back to the roadway, the roadway can be at an angle in both directions. [0:27:10] We have a way of cutting the chimney so it custom fits and it's exactly, there we go. [0:27:18] It'll fit exactly to the roadway, yep. [0:27:23] And we purchased this not too many years ago because I remember a kind, I remember a presentation [0:27:27] on it a little bit. [0:27:28] Yeah, it was, it was a little de-bronit. [0:27:30] Wow. [0:27:31] Great, thanks. [0:27:32] Yeah. [0:27:35] You're sure we're not fracking or drilling for oil really, do I? [0:27:39] That's kind of looks like it. [0:27:40] That's our equipment. [0:27:41] That's cool. [0:27:42] And that saves, I'm assuming, a lot of money, a lot of, [0:27:48] and a lot of shocks and threats. [0:27:51] And back. [0:27:53] That's actually labor intensive. [0:27:56] The cost is, believe it or not, it's $180 to $350 to replace with the Mr. Manhole system. [0:28:05] And right now we're on average about one a day. [0:28:09] Depends on how far apart they are, traffic control coverage. [0:28:11] We can get a couple done in the day and eventually we'll probably be that but it's way more cost effective. [0:28:18] Will you call her that with concrete then? [0:28:20] Yeah, we do. [0:28:21] And how do you get the creek there? [0:28:23] Right now we're buying a half yard at a time and they have trailers. [0:28:29] That's me. [0:28:33] Suzanne Hawkins? [0:28:34] So after we fog seal or chip seal and then we go back in and repaint lines correct on both of those applications. [0:28:43] So what if there's areas that need painting line striping, is that right? [0:28:50] Yeah. [0:28:51] Address them out of the zones. [0:28:53] Are we still working on that part of it out of the zone or is that only zone specific? [0:28:58] I'm glad you brought that up. [0:28:59] There is actually on Eastland between Kimberly and 4th Avenue. [0:29:03] We had a reconstruction project and there's some old markings that are kind of confusing. [0:29:09] And it needs chip sealed anyway. [0:29:11] Like I said, we like to chip seal about year old pavement anyway, but that also gives us [0:29:17] an opportunity to revise the striping. [0:29:21] Since Greg was talking about his line of traffic, the one I'm thinking of as a corner of North [0:29:25] College and Fillmore from the new traffic light, the lines that are there are very confusing [0:29:32] where the new stop light. [0:29:36] before we had multi-directional both East and West and now there's only one lane if you're [0:29:43] going East but the lines are really confusing especially if you're making a left hand turn [0:29:48] off of Phil Moron to North College. So I've just watched people about run into each other [0:29:54] there a few times. Just a thought. [0:29:58] Thank you. That's one of those intersections I wish we could go back in time and make it [0:30:05] wider. I think that's everything I have. Oh, he's got one more minute. Nope. Do we have any further [0:30:21] questions for John Wallace here? John has an excellent presentation. We're back in the middle [0:30:24] circuit. Thank you, Mayor. Just actually, I don't have a question, but just want to say thank you, [0:30:30] really appreciate the zones that have been created. And I know we have a formal councilman, [0:30:36] Dave Johnson, really to think that I think he talked about potholes and zone maintenance every [0:30:42] every week for a year, and then that really spearheaded this very logical, very methodical [0:30:48] system which makes sense and it makes sure that every neighborhood in the community is [0:30:53] getting addressed in a timely manner, and so I think it's overall such a great program. [0:30:57] So thank you for all your hard work on that. [0:31:00] Thank you, John. [0:31:01] Thank you. [0:31:02] And thank you, Rebecca. [0:31:03] Next item on the agenda is Consideration of a Request to Award the 2014 CHIP Seal, Project [0:31:09] the amount of $522,999 and let's not forget the 81 cents. [0:31:16] That's right. [0:31:17] Jackie Fields, our city engineer. [0:31:19] Good evening. [0:31:20] On May 22nd, we opened bids for a chip seal project. [0:31:23] There are two bidders and Emory was the apparent bull bidder and they turned in a qualified bid. [0:31:31] Their price was $522,999. [0:31:35] And that we budget $80,000 for ceiling, but the seal coat budget includes not only chip [0:31:47] seal, but some years it includes slurry. [0:31:50] This year includes fog and it includes crack ceiling material, the tabs that we use so [0:31:55] people can find their way before the paint comes. [0:31:58] And some traffic control for some crack ceiling processes, as well as thermoplastic pavement [0:32:09] markings and towing costs. [0:32:13] And then in this particular year, we've made a small extension and the next one, because [0:32:20] Washington could really use to help. [0:32:25] asking that the council authorized the mayor to sign a contract for with Emory for 522, 99981. [0:32:32] Christy, are you going to make the motion? No, I have a question. Chris, I'm [0:32:38] interested in how our tonnage cost compares to last year. Do you recall the price of commodities [0:32:47] of the Ghana, or down? Tons versus square yards. And square yards you can actually kind of get a visual [0:33:13] So square yard cost is still good and we were able to fit our zone in the pricing. [0:33:27] I suspect so right at the time that we did the job, there hasn't been huge asphalt escalation. [0:33:36] So that's part of the question. [0:33:38] And then the next part is the right budget number, which you may not be asking, but I'm [0:33:42] going to tell you anyhow. [0:33:44] It's still a pretty good number. [0:33:49] Thank you, Mayor. [0:33:53] Have we talked to Emory about how they're going to notify neighbors and citizens when they're [0:33:59] going to chip seal a certain area and directional cones. [0:34:03] I mean, if they start working in an area, is there going to be a sign so people can detour [0:34:08] before they get to the work and have to do a U-turn, kind of speak from experience on [0:34:13] that one. [0:34:14] But just communicating with the public, I know we've had complaints in the past about [0:34:18] some people missing funerals and so on because the road ended up being closed. [0:34:23] But how are we communicating with them on the importance of communication when they do their work? [0:34:27] Communicating with them regularly, how they will progress the work so that everyone else knows what they're doing. [0:34:37] So we haven't yet reported this contract, so we haven't started the conversations. [0:34:42] We have modified our oversight in the last several years to attempt to address some of [0:34:50] the various current concerns that have popped up. [0:34:54] Great. [0:34:56] Yeah, and I understand once we, if we award this to Emory, hopefully we can, I would encourage [0:35:02] us to be more specific rather than more hands off in community and just making sure that [0:35:08] we know what their plan is and that that will work for the citizens. [0:35:13] The question I had, you mentioned that in this bid is also towing, that's towing of vehicles [0:35:20] if they don't move when we're getting ready to do a chit seal or a maintenance, right? [0:35:25] In the budget is towing. So we never know what our contract says that we'll split the cost of towing with the contractor. [0:35:33] And so we try to leave a little budget available for towing and we try not to tow. [0:35:41] So every year though we end up with some modest number of people that needed to be moved out of the way. [0:35:48] Well the only reason I ask that is because you know this obviously is recorded. [0:35:53] People watch this and I just want to encourage folks to really pay attention to those notices that go out. [0:35:59] And we don't want to tow your vehicle. We'd rather you comply. [0:36:04] And we recognize that it's very distressing to come out to your car and it's not there. [0:36:10] But at some point we need to do the work. [0:36:15] I do the work. [0:36:16] So we try to do door knockers and they try to look around for whoever's who's in front [0:36:22] of that house, you know, they knock on the door and set your car and kind of hunt around [0:36:26] for to home up lots. [0:36:28] Very good. [0:36:29] Thank you. [0:36:30] Great lining. [0:36:31] Mayor Hall, I move that we approve the award, I move that we award the bed for the 2014 [0:36:39] and tip seal project to Emory and incorporated [0:36:41] in the amount of $522,991 and $91.81. [0:36:47] I didn't, they just do 523. [0:36:49] Come on. [0:36:50] No, I'd love to round up. [0:36:51] I got a motion on the floor. [0:36:54] I'm Greg Landing, seconded by Sean Barrier [0:36:57] to approve this award. [0:36:59] Do they need to also state to have me sign it or is that? [0:37:04] Okay. [0:37:05] I'll approve the mayor to sign it. [0:37:06] Okay. [0:37:07] Very good. [0:37:08] Greg, do you have anything? [0:37:09] Nope. [0:37:10] Anything further from council before we go to a boat. Thank you, Jackie. [0:37:15] We have a roll call vote for this matter. [0:37:17] Jim Munn. [0:37:18] Yes. Greg Lansing. [0:37:19] Yes. John Hall. Yes. [0:37:21] Mr. Tarkington. Yes. Rebecca Nelsweicke. Yes. [0:37:24] Suzanne Hawkins. Yes. John Barricott. Yes. [0:37:27] Potion passes. Seven to zero again. Thank you, Jackie. [0:37:30] Next item on the agenda is consideration of the request to adopt an ordinance. [0:37:34] Amending City Code Title 4, updating cities adoption of building, [0:37:39] plumbing and mechanical codes. We have Mitchell Humboldt. [0:37:43] Welcome. [0:37:44] Thanks. First thing I wanted to do is I'm not here alone tonight. [0:37:49] I wanted to introduce a couple of folks that you might know or you might not know, but [0:37:53] I have two building officials with me. [0:37:56] I can just come up front here. You guys all know Dwayne. [0:38:00] Dwayne doesn't much care what we do tonight. He's kind of in the middle. [0:38:05] We understand. [0:38:06] We understand. [0:38:07] We understand. [0:38:08] We understand. [0:38:09] We understand. [0:38:10] We understand. [0:38:11] We understand. [0:38:12] We understand. [0:38:13] We understand. [0:38:14] We understand. [0:38:15] We understand. [0:38:16] We understand. [0:38:17] We understand. [0:38:18] We understand. [0:38:19] We understand. [0:38:20] We understand. [0:38:21] We understand. [0:38:22] We understand. [0:38:23] We understand. [0:38:24] We understand. [0:38:25] We understand. [0:38:26] We understand. [0:38:27] We understand. [0:38:28] We understand. [0:38:29] We understand. [0:38:30] We understand. [0:38:31] We understand. [0:38:32] We understand. [0:38:33] We understand. [0:38:34] do. Have you heard what we do for these? We'll find out here in a minute. [0:38:39] Okay, so we'll just go ahead and get started. I don't want to go this in super like read the [0:38:47] report to you because it's all in there. But generally every ever so often we like to review [0:38:54] our building coded options and make sure that we're still in compliance with all the things [0:38:57] that the state requires us to do. It's been a little while since we've last done this. I think [0:39:02] last time we did this was late, 06, in anticipation of the upcoming 07 year when we took on mechanical [0:39:09] plumbing and electrical permitting. So I haven't done this for a little while, and so we need [0:39:16] to make some changes actually. And I'll tell you that, like I said, in the staff report, [0:39:21] there's really 10 different, very specific changes that we're recommending we do, and [0:39:26] in almost every case, they are simply just outdated references that we need to update, [0:39:31] And there are outdated references either to an 06 code that we now use in a 2012 version [0:39:37] of or something like that. [0:39:39] Some of them are outdated for other reasons because like one of them for example we adopted [0:39:45] before we even did mechanical permitting for some reason and then all of a sudden when we [0:39:49] adopted a mechanical code isn't giant with what we had in our other code. [0:39:54] But I will hit on a few because I think there's a couple worth talking about where spending [0:39:58] some time on. [0:40:00] There's about three of these that apply to the International Existing Building Code. [0:40:04] Previously the state had not ever adopted that, with this round of adoptions. [0:40:08] They have said we're going to adopt this as a state, and all you cities and jurisdictions [0:40:12] out there who do building permitting, if you'd like to you can adopt that too. [0:40:17] The existing building code we think is a better code in that it allows us a bit more flexibility [0:40:24] when we're dealing with remodeling of existing buildings, [0:40:27] particularly older buildings, historic buildings, [0:40:32] you know those kind of things. [0:40:33] So it really applies down in Main Street. [0:40:35] And some more older parts are down. [0:40:38] And I think this actually, and I mentioned here in Stavar, [0:40:41] I think this actually helps us further strategic planning goals [0:40:44] really, in that it'll allow us to be more flexible [0:40:47] and work better with building owners in helping them come [0:40:52] into compliance with the existing building code [0:40:56] versus the international building code. [0:40:59] It just gives us more flexibility. [0:41:00] And apart from that, I don't know if these guys [0:41:05] might give you better examples of what it might be. [0:41:07] So I might misstate this and I'll ask them to correct me. [0:41:09] But if a new remodel were to require fire sprinklers, [0:41:20] for example, we might be able to look at that [0:41:22] with the existing building code and say if we do fire walls now [0:41:25] and break up areas, we can do something that might help us [0:41:29] still get to that same level of protection, [0:41:31] just not with the expense of a fire sprinkler. [0:41:34] And a fire sprinkler is gonna have a lot of these guys [0:41:36] just run away and not do their projects [0:41:38] because they're expensive, right? [0:41:40] And so we think, generally, we think the existing building code [0:41:44] is a good code to adopt. [0:41:45] So, three or four of these apply to the existing building code. [0:41:49] Another one that I wanted to talk about was the swimming pools. [0:41:51] Believe it or not, we occasionally get a permit for a swimming pool, not very often, but when [0:41:57] we do, we have an outdated pool code that we adopted some time ago that isn't applicable [0:42:02] anymore and it doesn't apply or it doesn't chive with what the state has now adopted and [0:42:07] that's an appendix. [0:42:09] I think it's PNXG and this is a disgusting number and we find out what you know I'm talking [0:42:14] about. [0:42:15] Two on my list, right? [0:42:17] So Appendix G to the IRC is the one that is the appendix it deals with with swimming pools [0:42:24] and previously we've excluded that from being adopted here at the city. [0:42:30] So anyway, we need something to regulate pools with. [0:42:34] So this is a good one that fits with what the states adopted for us. [0:42:38] So the other thing I'll just add in general is that the wording here in my report is sometimes [0:42:46] tricky to follow because it's a lot of times our code has been written to exclude something [0:42:53] from being adopted. [0:42:55] So when I'm proposing that we strike it, we're actually adopting it because I'm striking [0:42:59] it from being excluded and it just sounds weird but if there's any questions about that [0:43:05] let me know. [0:43:07] So anyway, we've gone through this process, we've looked through our several different [0:43:12] code sections that do all the building codes. [0:43:14] We think we have a good list of here that gives us [0:43:16] in compliance with whether the state's headed [0:43:19] in the coming state regulatory or starts in July. [0:43:23] So we're going to be pretty much consistent with them. [0:43:27] We knew this was coming, so we ran it [0:43:29] by our building advisory committee, [0:43:31] building inspections department advisory committee, [0:43:34] twice at two different meetings, [0:43:35] and they're all on board with it. [0:43:36] They've voted and they naturally recommend [0:43:39] adoption of the ordinance that's attached. So with that, we'll just leave it up for you guys if you have questions, let me just close with one more thing. [0:43:47] If we do have an ordinance that's right here at options tonight, if you choose to adopt it, we will need to go through the third and final thing. [0:43:52] If not, we can just read it three times. That's up to you guys. So anyway, thank you very much questions. I'll let them know what's the ordinance. [0:44:01] 3073. [0:44:03] 73. [0:44:05] Thank you. [0:44:06] And let's not forget to have Dwayne come up at least once while we're asking questions. [0:44:10] Rebecca Mills-Seika. [0:44:12] Thank you Mayor. [0:44:13] Just a quick question just to make sure I understand this right. [0:44:16] So are we switching over from the international building code to the international existing building code? [0:44:22] Is that? [0:44:23] So there's a chapter in the international building code that deals with existing buildings. [0:44:29] One chapter and right now that's what we have in place and it's what we've used for several years [0:44:34] The international existing building code would be adopted in lieu of enforcing the one chapter in the building the international building code [0:44:42] You still would apply the international building code all the rest of the chapters [0:44:47] but with existing buildings we would then apply the existing building code which is [0:44:52] bigger and a little bit more [0:44:54] I think it's a better code for us to enforce on building owners, so yeah. [0:45:00] Okay, so you're still using international building code as a dissection, right? [0:45:06] So they're all prepared by the ICC and they're all linking with one, at least those two anyway. [0:45:13] Okay, so there wouldn't be any case where the two different building codes would not coincide, so to speak, right? [0:45:22] They would always agree and always with all of our codes, but not these two, okay, thank you. [0:45:28] Chris, can I ask a question of doing? [0:45:30] Yeah. [0:45:33] Really, I want your practical feedback just because I don't understand. [0:45:39] I know I'm going to be pegged on it. [0:45:41] I think it's 4-1-2, exempting triplexes and four plexes from sprinkler systems, which [0:45:50] now will allow duplexes or still will allow duplexes not to have them but will [0:45:56] require them from triplexes on up as I understand doing right the builders are [0:46:02] going to say well we build in firewalls why do we need a sprinkler system for [0:46:07] this arbitrariness of a triplex not a duplex what what's the feeling on that [0:46:13] It's a number of units. [0:46:18] Single family and two family units are from the residential code. [0:46:23] There's a lot of exemptions in the residential code and one of those exemptions, actually, [0:46:28] the international residential code does require fire sprinklers as well. [0:46:33] The state of Idaho has decided that due to its cost-prohibity, so the state of Idaho [0:46:40] said we're not going to require sprinklers in one and two family dwellings. [0:46:45] That's our residential code. [0:46:48] Triplexes and on up, triplexes, four plexes, six plexes, or whatever. [0:46:52] That's a totally different code, that's in the, what we call the international building code. [0:46:57] And that's where the state draw the lines is, if you're going to put that many dwelling units together, [0:47:05] then we need to have a spring protection of the spring per system. [0:47:08] that's basically a state requirement, so that's what we're doing. [0:47:12] And they would still be built with firewalls separating the units. [0:47:16] Yes. [0:47:17] This is an additional cost because of more people involved on this AP issue. [0:47:22] Yes, the firewall is actually what they call a dwelling unit separation. [0:47:27] It's kind of, it's a little bit different, you don't have to have firewalls around the [0:47:31] exterior building on the kind of the dwelling unit, but still for anything out of the residence [0:47:38] residential code for dwelling units, we're going to look in the spring person and [0:47:44] fire separation between each unit. [0:47:47] Thank you. [0:47:49] You passed I guess. [0:47:51] Do we have any questions for Jared since he's here? [0:47:56] Or a motion? [0:47:58] Greg Lanning. [0:47:59] I move that we suspend the rules in place ordinance 3073 on 3rd and final by title only. [0:48:05] Second. [0:48:07] motion on the floor by Greg Lanting, seconded by Suzanne Hawkins, to place [0:48:12] ordinance 3073. Well, suspend the rules, place the ordinance 3073 on final, third [0:48:22] and final, and read the ordinance by title. Anything further on that motion [0:48:27] council? We have a roll call. Yes. Oh, it's good. [0:48:35] I'm currently Chris is really excited about. [0:48:38] Yes. [0:48:39] Chris talking to him? [0:48:41] Yes. [0:48:42] Rebecca Milsweigat? [0:48:43] Yes. [0:48:44] Suzanne Hawkins? [0:48:45] Yes. [0:48:46] Sean Baraker? [0:48:47] Yes. [0:48:48] Jim Young? [0:48:49] Yes. [0:48:50] Motion passes. [0:48:51] Seven to zero. [0:48:52] Thanks Mitch. [0:48:53] Oh and read the title. [0:48:54] Thank you. [0:48:55] In ordinance of the City Council of the City of Twin Falls, Idaho, amending to Twin Falls City Code [0:48:59] sections 4 1 1 4 1 2 4 3 1 4 5 1 by updating the city's adoption and building [0:49:09] humming and mechanical codes. Greg Lanning. I move that we approve ordinance 3073. [0:49:19] Second. I have motion on floor by Greg Lanning and seconded by Zen Hawkins again [0:49:25] to approve the ordinance. Anything further on this motion council? [0:49:30] Leila, roll call vote again, please. [0:49:34] Don Hall? [0:49:35] Yes. [0:49:36] Chris Talkington? [0:49:37] Yes. [0:49:38] Rebecca Milsoyka? [0:49:39] Yes. [0:49:40] Suzanne Hawkins? [0:49:41] Yes. [0:49:42] Sean Berriger? [0:49:43] Yes. [0:49:44] Jim Mann? [0:49:45] Yes. [0:49:46] Greg Lanting? [0:49:47] Yes. [0:49:48] Motion passes 7-0. [0:49:49] Thanks, Mitch. [0:49:50] Anything you want to say? [0:49:51] We got one more. [0:49:52] We got one more. [0:49:53] Oh, do you? [0:49:54] Yeah. [0:49:55] I think this next one, he'll want to ask him some questions on this one. [0:49:59] Excellent. [0:50:00] Very good. [0:50:01] of a request to adopt a resolution establishing a minimal minimum crawl space depth Mitch Humble? [0:50:09] Okay, so when we first started approaching our building advisory committee with these [0:50:12] list of code amendments, we were including this one as a list of code amendments and then [0:50:17] after the first time we talked to him about it, I went back and started thinking and talking [0:50:23] to the guys and in my own mind, I think I came to a different conclusion that this one [0:50:29] isn't exactly an amendment to our code, but rather a standalone kind of a policy that we [0:50:36] need to handle in here in Twin Falls. [0:50:39] And it matters because of the processes slightly different. [0:50:43] So what this one is talking about is the crawl space steps. [0:50:49] So here in Twin Falls, most of our residential construction, but sometimes other construction [0:50:54] It'll build like a footing wall, and it'll hang a floor [0:50:57] on top like a wood frame beam floor on top of the footing walls. [0:51:01] And the space between the floor and the ground underneath it [0:51:05] is this crawl space that we're talking about. [0:51:07] And nowhere in the building code, the IRC, the IBC, [0:51:10] does it talk about how much space is needed in there. [0:51:14] You can go in there and you can find, [0:51:16] if you have to put an access into it, yes, [0:51:18] and you can find how big the access has to be. [0:51:21] And if it's closer than a certain distance, [0:51:23] and it has to be treated lumber, so it doesn't rot and all that kind of stuff. [0:51:26] But nowhere does it just say it shall be this big. [0:51:29] And that comes into play when we have trades that are going down there and hanging plumbing [0:51:36] or air conditioning ducts or electricity or whatever, other kinds of things. [0:51:42] They often go into this crawl space and the guys doing the work down there have very little [0:51:47] space to work in at sometimes and sometimes they've got plenty of space. [0:51:51] But then we ask our inspectors to climb down in there [0:51:53] and actually inspect the work that's going to be done. [0:51:56] And Jared's probably climbed in way more crawl spaces [0:51:59] than he cares to remember, looking at ducks and dog work [0:52:03] and those kind of things. [0:52:06] So again, we approached our building advisory committee [0:52:09] about this one. [0:52:10] The thought was that we just need to say, [0:52:12] when we have crawl spaces here in Twin Falls, [0:52:15] we expect those to be 30 inches, and we [0:52:16] feel that's inadequate to have to move around [0:52:20] maneuver and not only for us and the guys who have to do the work, but also for the homeowners [0:52:25] who are going to end up owning that thing because they're going to store boxes of Christmas [0:52:29] ornaments and they're going to get in there and do a remodel now so they can wire the backyard [0:52:34] for a hot tub or something like that and they're going to inevitably have to get down in this [0:52:38] crawl space at some time or another. [0:52:41] So we approach that initially, like I said, as a code amendment, decided it really isn't [0:52:47] the code of it because the code doesn't ever say what it has to be and we're changing that [0:52:52] instead we're just going to say we think is what it should be. And so we've prepared [0:52:55] this resolution that's in your ordinance tonight that this says when you build cross [0:52:59] space in Twin Falls and these be 30 inches. And that's really that simple. There's a lot [0:53:05] of words to say that but. [0:53:08] When I read through this question that I had is that resolutions don't generally have [0:53:12] a lot of teeth to them. Is that accurate in this case? [0:53:15] We'll have the same teeth that we normally have with when we enforce a code, and that [0:53:21] is you don't meet our regulations. We're not going to give you a permit. [0:53:26] So that makes sense to me. I don't know that it matters for us. [0:53:32] Greg Lanning. Well, a couple of things. One of my, obviously I've seen different size [0:53:38] crawl spaces and the bigger they are, for the homeowner, certainly one or four as well [0:53:42] as I'm sure. [0:53:43] I mean, my sister lives in one that a contractor originally was built by, is a duplexus built [0:53:50] by the contractor for his mother and her friend, and you can practically walk in that crawl [0:53:54] spaces. [0:53:55] He knew he was going to be the one down there because of his mothers. [0:53:59] But the worst part that I have is that by setting, if we set a minimum, and I'm in favor [0:54:05] of setting them in them I think 30 inches is probably only not quite enough it's about [0:54:10] to be three feet but are we is that some going to take that as what they need to make it and [0:54:17] they won't make any bigger even if they were usually making the bigger that in the past [0:54:21] that's the little concern I have that's a question for Jared yeah yeah I don't think so [0:54:26] most of the contractors already doing it there's just a few that aren't doing it I think [0:54:31] the ones that build it deeper it's like the selling future forms they're going to continue [0:54:35] do that anyway. I don't think they'll use this as a baseline to just stick with 30 inches. [0:54:39] All right. Thank you. Thanks for talking to me. Well, I guess the question I have relates [0:54:46] to the building cost because if you're building that foundation at ground level not excavating, [0:54:53] you're actually adding six inches of concrete cost to the foundation or are you not? So [0:54:58] the cost of the concrete should be the same because we have frost protection requirements [0:55:02] of 24 inches, so it still requires a six inch [0:55:05] voting and a two foot stem wall. [0:55:07] So that doesn't change. [0:55:09] The what changes is they have to over excavate [0:55:11] inside of the crawl space, which most of them are doing, [0:55:14] because they use that for backfill around the foundation [0:55:16] of final to get great. [0:55:18] So the only thing that would change internally [0:55:19] would be maybe taller pony stud walls, [0:55:22] so maybe a little bit of lumber. [0:55:24] So most of them will just do that sub excavating [0:55:27] to get that extra six. [0:55:28] Exactly. [0:55:29] That's a good question. [0:55:31] Back to my own second. [0:55:32] I'm not sure this is for maybe Mitch, just a question on what other cities have done. [0:55:40] It seems like since the building codes don't address the minimum crawl space, [0:55:46] I mean is there a danger in having just the city of Twin Falls adopt this minimum crawl space? [0:55:52] And the second part of my question is how does that affect builders? [0:55:56] You know, it seems like looking at the international building codes like they address like a 16 by 24 access. [0:56:05] So it seems like the most common height is 24 inches. [0:56:10] So moving it to 30, how does that affect the builders financially or in their planning if they're coming from other communities? [0:56:18] They're building in Kimberly and Jerome and then in Twin Falls, all of a sudden they have to have this added height. [0:56:25] That's a good question. [0:56:26] Most of our local builders already do this. [0:56:29] One of the main reasons this came up [0:56:30] is because we've had builders from Treasure Valley [0:56:33] that were doing the smaller crawl spaces, [0:56:34] but there are jurisdictions up there that do require it. [0:56:37] And that's really where we got a lot of the ideas [0:56:39] from to do a deeper crawl space. [0:56:41] So, I mean, there's cleanouts down there too [0:56:43] for plumbing and stuff. [0:56:44] And once you get what they'll do is they'll build the access [0:56:47] and then you have a stem wall and a footing right there. [0:56:49] You can't even get into the crawl space [0:56:52] once they do what they've been doing. [0:56:54] There's actually no access in there at all. [0:56:59] So we weren't the only ones, I guess, [0:57:01] is the key that I wanted them to share there. [0:57:04] There's a few others. [0:57:06] The other thing that I thought I might share [0:57:08] is the access that we're talking about to the crawl spaces. [0:57:12] Typically, that trap door access, you'll [0:57:14] see in your closet or something like that. [0:57:16] It's not a vertical access. [0:57:17] Typically, it's a flat one. [0:57:19] So it shouldn't affect the size of the access at all [0:57:23] by going down 30 inches instead. [0:57:26] So, okay, and one of their cities, can you name a few cities [0:57:29] who have, and what their specific minimum height [0:57:32] that they've adopted? [0:57:35] You know, the guy who actually did the research forces [0:57:37] and here with us, but you were gonna say something, [0:57:40] Dominic. [0:57:41] Oh, he didn't have the answer to this question. [0:57:43] I had some questions. [0:57:45] I thought he was gonna give us the answer. [0:57:47] We actually had John Victor do the research force [0:57:50] and we'll have to get back with him [0:57:53] to find out what the cities were. [0:57:54] I didn't ever get the list from it. [0:57:57] Okay, thank you. [0:57:59] I'm allowed. [0:58:00] Don, do you want to come up and ask your question? [0:58:03] Thank you, Mr. Mayor and Council. [0:58:04] [Muted for privacy: street address] [0:58:05] [Muted for privacy: street address] [0:58:09] [Muted for privacy: street address] [0:58:11] Does that have any impact on flood certificates? [0:58:16] Great question. [0:58:17] Garrett? [0:58:18] I think it would actually help. [0:58:20] We were in flood zones. [0:58:22] I think the elevation of the finished floor elevation is critical on that. [0:58:26] I don't think it's going to affect by going deeper with the crawl space over dig. [0:58:31] I think the flood zone stuff would remain the same. [0:58:37] Rebecca, did you have any? [0:58:40] I guess my question can't be answered right now by the facts. [0:58:45] I found it fascinating. [0:58:46] I appreciate your question, Chris, because I assume that we were just adding more concrete [0:58:50] too, but actually digging a little deeper makes kind of sense to me, and it doesn't cost [0:58:56] really substantially anymore taking another few inches out. [0:59:00] So, turn it over, oh, [0:59:02] they either do, we have a resolution of 19, 24. [0:59:07] Thank you. [0:59:08] I'll turn it over to Council, Greg Lanning. [0:59:10] Mayor Hall, I move that we approve resolution 19, 24. [0:59:16] Second. [0:59:17] We have a motion on floor by Greg Lanning, [0:59:19] seconded by Chris Talkington. [0:59:21] And we have a question, Rebecca Mills, so I can. [0:59:23] Thank you, Mayor. [0:59:24] One quick question. [0:59:26] Did we hear from any of the builders [0:59:28] or building community any feedback [0:59:32] on how this change might affect them? [0:59:34] So we have this discussion at two different [0:59:38] building advisory board meetings. [0:59:39] They're public meetings. [0:59:40] We announced the agendas. [0:59:42] The whole board is made up of building community members [0:59:45] as well. [0:59:46] There are two different home builders that are on that board. [0:59:49] And so we absolutely have feedback [0:59:51] from those two specifically. [0:59:53] But at those two meetings none of the others came and shared their opinions at those two meetings. [1:00:00] But those two that were on the board, certainly were part of the special. [1:00:03] Okay, thank you. [1:00:05] I'm not necessarily against it. [1:00:08] I just maybe don't have enough information about the standards and other cities, what other cities are doing. [1:00:14] Unfortunately, we don't have that information tonight, so I just don't know what to think about it. [1:00:20] Thank you Rebecca. [1:00:21] Suzanne Hawkins. [1:00:23] It makes sense to me, not only from the standpoint of our employees who have to go out and inspect underneath homes, [1:00:30] but as a homeowner, to me it makes sense to require this. [1:00:33] I think it's an extra protection for us. [1:00:35] It is a selling feature, and I think most homeowners, if they're going to pay a little extra for this feature, [1:00:41] it's probably something that would be worth it to most people to be able to access that stuff under their home. [1:00:46] So I will be supporting it. [1:00:48] I see no further lights. [1:00:50] Leila, roll call vote, please. [1:00:52] Yes. [1:00:53] Rebecca Milsoica? [1:00:54] No. [1:00:55] Susan Hawkins? [1:00:58] Yes. [1:00:59] Schonberger? [1:01:00] Yes. [1:01:01] Jim Mun? [1:01:02] Yes. [1:01:03] Greg Lansing? [1:01:04] Yes. [1:01:05] John Hall? [1:01:06] Yes. [1:01:07] Motion passes. [1:01:08] Six to one. [1:01:09] Any final words? [1:01:10] Are you going to come back to see us, Duane, before the date? [1:01:15] I just like a bad painting. [1:01:17] It's a pretty good bat pen, so thanks to me, and welcome aboard in that position. [1:01:29] Next item on the agenda is consideration of the request for the mayor to appoint Chris [1:01:33] Toggutin as a member of the Twin Falls Urban Renewal Agency Downtown RFQ Response Evaluation [1:01:42] subcommittee and I would ask that Melinda come up and maybe lead us to where we are now in [1:01:49] this process. I know I was approached through Melinda by the chairperson of this subcommittee [1:01:55] asking for a council representative on this committee and my first thought was Chris because [1:02:01] of his long-time careful I'm trying to be kind Chris give me a second long time interest [1:02:10] in our downtown, in our community, and being involved. [1:02:14] So with that, I'll turn it over to you. [1:02:16] Thank you, Mr. Mayor and good evening council members. [1:02:20] As you probably know, the 2012 Urban Renewal Agency [1:02:23] is continuing its process, its work for downtown revitalization. [1:02:30] One of the things that the board, record staff to do [1:02:34] about a month and a half ago, almost two months ago, [1:02:37] was to send out requests for qualifications and for firms to help with the process of the [1:02:48] public visioning for downtown specifically Main Avenue along with preliminary design. [1:02:55] So staff, myself and our assistant Lori Bauer, we researched a lot of communities around [1:03:03] the Northwest as well as the Rocky Mountain region and found companies firms that we could [1:03:10] actually send out this request for qualifications to. [1:03:14] So we did that to about 18, 17, 18 firms. [1:03:18] We also placed a notice in the Times News for any local folks that we weren't aware of to [1:03:24] contact me for the same request for qualifications. [1:03:28] We had a deadline set of last Friday, May 30th at 4 o'clock to receive those responses to [1:03:36] the request for qualifications and at that point, as of that deadline, we received 7 out [1:03:43] of the 17 or 18 that we sent out to. [1:03:48] The Urban Renewal Board, actually Cindy Bond is chairperson of the Board, the last regular [1:03:54] board meeting, pointed three board members to be on this group, Leon Smith, who is Vice [1:04:02] Chair of the Board, but is chair of this subcommittee, Perry Gardner, as well as Sarah Taylor. [1:04:09] Since then I spoke with, and then staff, myself, and Mitch Humble were also appointed for it. [1:04:15] And then since then I talked with Mr. Smith, and asked him if he thought it might be helpful [1:04:19] to have a council person also on this evaluation. [1:04:22] He thought that would be a great idea. [1:04:24] And he asked me to talk with the mayor, which I did, [1:04:27] and asked him to appoint one council member [1:04:29] to be on this group. [1:04:33] Very good. [1:04:33] So I will turn it over to the council [1:04:36] for their questions and or direction. [1:04:39] Rebecca, Mel, so I can. [1:04:40] Thank you, mayor. [1:04:41] I have just a few questions. [1:04:43] I guess somehow I maybe got out of the loop [1:04:45] of how the downtown improvements were going forward. [1:04:49] I know Chris and I have been liaison [1:04:51] to the committee that has been talking [1:04:54] about the infrastructure and I actually didn't know that they were doing this visioning hire. [1:05:02] And so I just have a few questions about what is the budget and the scope of work that maybe [1:05:09] this consultant will be doing and where that money is coming from is that going to have to [1:05:15] come out of money that would be going into the projects on Main Street, downtown or how [1:05:20] this works. [1:05:21] request for qualification specifically, and as part of its Idaho Code, is that [1:05:25] where we, that board was looking for the experience [1:05:29] specifically for these firms and what they, [1:05:33] and what their experience has been and their skills are [1:05:37] in this whole process. And so there's been no [1:05:41] budget set yet. So what's going to happen with this evaluation committee [1:05:45] is it's going to evaluate the responses [1:05:49] responses that have come in, and this committee's going to be for the first time this coming Thursday afternoon or morning, one of the two anyway, and decide how it's going to evaluate those responses, whether we just want to use the written responses, whether we want to interview folks at these teams come in and respond to us, or even if we want to, the committee actually go out and visit some of the communities [1:06:18] communities that these firms have worked in so we can see firsthand how it went so that [1:06:24] process has not yet been determined and yes the so when I once the ranking is completed [1:06:33] the board will then negotiate with the number one ranked firm on both scope specific scope [1:06:41] of work. [1:06:42] The second is the timeline of that scope how long it would take to do the work and third [1:06:47] on the budget and if hopefully it can determine what the, it can come to a conclusion of successful [1:06:58] conclusion with that first rate, but if it can't, it moves to the second one, to the second [1:07:02] rate firm and goes to that process over again. [1:07:05] The funds would be paid for from urban renewal for the work with this firm for the value or [1:07:13] going through the public visioning process and preliminary design. [1:07:16] And is that from the general budget or is it from the TIFF dollars from that specific district general budget is TIFF dollars [1:07:23] Yes, okay from that area [1:07:25] From 4-1 correct right yes, okay, and so and so you're not sure about the time [1:07:31] I do you know how it'll affect? [1:07:32] the project going forward [1:07:35] Is it gonna coincide with the construction of the bids that you're getting to do the work on Main Street? [1:07:41] How would that work? [1:07:43] So we haven't started out with construction kids [1:07:46] for main avenue because we're going through the process, [1:07:49] the agency's going through the process first [1:07:51] of going through the public visioning [1:07:54] and the preliminary design. [1:07:56] And then once that's completed, the agency [1:07:59] would then take that preliminary design and find, [1:08:03] that's probably through another request [1:08:05] for qualification process, an engineering firm [1:08:08] to turn those into bidable construction documents [1:08:11] to actually start to be able to do that bidding, [1:08:15] or to do the construction, excuse me, I'm a little tired. [1:08:19] That's fine. [1:08:20] So, do you see the actual construction [1:08:25] on Main Street happening a year or two down the road? [1:08:29] I mean. [1:08:29] I don't have a timeline for you at present. [1:08:32] I briefly looked at the responses that we received today. [1:08:38] And I noticed in a couple, [1:08:40] And even though we didn't ask for a timeline, a couple of the responses indicated a six to ten month timeline just for this process. [1:08:48] I don't know that it's going to necessarily going to take that long, but that was in their particular response. [1:08:54] Okay, thank you, I, that would just be my main concern that it not lengthened the process. [1:08:59] And there's a lot of energy and a lot of movement to have something happening downtown. [1:09:04] And I know in our committee meetings for the downtown infrastructure committee, [1:09:09] We talked about how many visioning processes we've been through over the years and I thought [1:09:17] the general feel was that we need more action and less visioning because we've actually gotten [1:09:23] to the point where we've heard from the community what they want. [1:09:26] As long as this facilitation is focused on specific design plans, a heavier focus on the [1:09:33] actual design as opposed to the visioning than I think I could support it. [1:09:38] I think everyone agrees with that sentiment as well. [1:09:41] So the information or the former plans or studies [1:09:48] we've had have looked at downtown from a 10,000 foot level. [1:09:51] This process will actually take us down to street level [1:09:55] to design specific elements of streets, traffic, parking, [1:10:02] landscaping, streetscaping, lighting. [1:10:09] We also included, because we want to get it just not, [1:10:12] the agency wanted to do more than just the amenities, [1:10:15] but also look at what opportunities might there be [1:10:18] along Main Avenue in that five block area [1:10:20] for redevelopment of properties. [1:10:22] So that was included in the request [1:10:23] for qualifications as well. [1:10:25] Okay, one last question. [1:10:27] Are these meetings for evaluating the RFQ process, [1:10:30] are they going to be open to the public? [1:10:31] Yes. [1:10:32] Okay, thank you. [1:10:33] Great, Gladys. [1:10:35] Mayor Hall, I move that we approve your appointment [1:10:38] of Chris talking to the member of the Twin Falls River [1:10:41] and he didn't see downtown RFQ response evaluation [1:10:44] subcommittee. [1:10:45] Second. [1:10:46] We have motion on the floor, like Greg Lanting [1:10:49] seconded by Suzanne Hawkins to appoint Chris talking [1:10:52] to anything further on that motion council. [1:10:55] Rebecca Melsoika. [1:10:57] Yeah, I'm a little bit concerned about approving [1:11:03] this process before we even really know much about it [1:11:08] about this RFQ. [1:11:09] I mean, I think it's great that Chris is appointed to it, [1:11:11] but in my mind, we already have a committee [1:11:13] that's working on these downtown issues. [1:11:16] I don't understand the need for a second [1:11:19] different subcommittee. [1:11:20] So maybe I'm just confused about the process. [1:11:23] Great planning. [1:11:24] Well, remember, walls were approving here [1:11:26] as the appointment of Chris. [1:11:27] This is an Urban Renewal Committee, not our committee. [1:11:30] We don't have a say on the forming of urban renewal committees [1:11:33] only the Urban Renewal has approval. [1:11:36] Right, I agree. [1:11:37] I just are participation in the process. [1:11:40] I would like to add that I really appreciate [1:11:42] the Urban Renewal Agency even asking for our participation. [1:11:46] I think that that's a spirit of cooperation [1:11:48] that we've had for many years, [1:11:50] and I want to see that continue. [1:11:52] And again, express our appreciation [1:11:55] to the Urban Renewal Agency for this. [1:11:58] Certainly, very real thanks. [1:11:59] Anything further on that motion council? [1:12:02] We have a roll call vote, please. [1:12:04] Rebecca Masuika? [1:12:05] Yes. [1:12:07] Suzanne Hopkins? [1:12:07] Yes. [1:12:08] Sean Berger. [1:12:09] Yes. [1:12:10] Jim Mundt. [1:12:11] Yes. [1:12:12] Greg Lanci. [1:12:12] Yes. [1:12:13] Don Hall. [1:12:14] Yes. [1:12:15] Chris Talkington. [1:12:15] Oh, well, abstain recuse. [1:12:17] Whatever. [1:12:19] We have a motion on four that was passed six in favor, one, [1:12:23] abstention. [1:12:24] And I thought you were going to say no, Chris. [1:12:26] It's not going to. [1:12:28] Chris talking to. [1:12:29] Well, I'd like to address a couple of Melinda and Rebecca's [1:12:33] points. [1:12:33] So I think they're valid. [1:12:36] I thank you first of all, I take this responsibility as serious as any undertaken for the council. [1:12:44] There are three main touch points in Twin Falls history that we're aware of. [1:12:48] The first occurred about 1904 when the original Main Street was plowed in an old frontier town [1:12:56] named for Twin Falls, it was actually three falls, I've never figured that out. [1:13:03] Some years later in the 60s, we had our first urban renewal about 1965-66, about the time [1:13:10] I left for the Air Force, and that was the first substantive change to what is conceived [1:13:16] as the heart of Twin Falls County, that being the city. [1:13:20] As we all know, there was extensive reconfiguration, rethinking of what Twin Falls was to be for [1:13:27] the people shopping in the pre-Maul era. [1:13:32] And now some 50 years later, we are really reinventing [1:13:35] Twin Falls with Urban Renewal's assistance, [1:13:38] some $10 million assistance. [1:13:42] I see that there's great risk and great reward in this, [1:13:46] and I am most concerned about the downside [1:13:50] for being a project that gets out of control [1:13:54] for some of the issues that have been brought up [1:13:56] by the Council people. [1:13:58] The schematic I see involves at least four points, [1:14:02] if you will. First of all, the RFQs, when we get the suitable one or two of the clients, [1:14:12] we've already agreed in business today that we will be checking on the work that was actually [1:14:18] done in their communities for the projects that they are so well so forcefully say is [1:14:25] proof of their work. That may even involve some on-site visits to make sure that the business [1:14:32] community impacted, really thought that the work was carried out in the proper manner [1:14:38] and it's a net sum gain. The second point in this schematic is that [1:14:45] Twin Falls engineering has to be part and parcel involved with this from the very get-go. If [1:14:51] We have a 25 cent plan that shows a bunch of pretty [1:14:55] planings and issues that don't deal with the subsurface water [1:15:00] and sewer. [1:15:01] That's going to be a costly mistake, an unworkable one. [1:15:07] We thirdly need to maximize the contact with the main street [1:15:11] businesses from the get go. [1:15:13] And the city is a whole. [1:15:14] But to make sure that they realize the scope of the project, [1:15:18] the timetable, offer a lot of different times where people can contact the City, Urban Renewal, [1:15:27] the engineers, the contract, the party, and make sure that we are not reacting and not [1:15:35] behind the ball on doing the project in the fourth time as in a type of a time frame as [1:15:42] possible. [1:15:43] We've talked about it stretching out for as far as three or four years, and I know that [1:15:48] was hypothetical. That's that's non-functional from the beginning. We'll go for a very tight [1:15:55] concise bit of havoc that hopefully will present a beautiful end project. So again, I [1:16:02] thank you and I'll stay in close contact and advisory basis to the to the council and thank [1:16:09] you for that time. [1:16:10] Chris, I think you've just illustrated what we've asked you to serve on this committee. [1:16:15] So thank you for that. [1:16:18] Next item on the agenda is public input and or items [1:16:21] from city manager and city council. [1:16:22] Just let folks know, we do have a public hearing. [1:16:25] We'll not start any sooner than six, [1:16:27] so we again achieved our goal. [1:16:29] So the first folks in the community, [1:16:32] is there anyone in the audience from the public [1:16:34] that would like to address the council [1:16:36] on any issue that's not in the agenda this evening? [1:16:40] I will then turn it over to the city manager [1:16:43] and ask that I'm sure you're gonna emphasize this, Travis, [1:16:45] But the 16th meeting, I think you were going to maybe talk about, so I'll turn it over to our city manager. [1:16:50] Mr. Mayor, members of the council. [1:16:55] First on June 4th, this Wednesday from 6 AM to 6 o'clock PM is the opportunity to participate in the tip [1:17:02] a cup where all of the tips and proceeds from Perkins goes to support our local special Olympics group. [1:17:12] It's really a community law enforcement support of Special Olympics, so I would encourage everyone not only here tonight, [1:17:23] but also listening to go and participate as you see fit. [1:17:28] They'll also have a series of auction items and silent auction items that you can bid on if they interest you. [1:17:37] Second, it has come to my attention over the weekend that we will have several members [1:17:44] of the City Council absent for the June 16th City Council meeting. [1:17:50] So as a result of that, I do not believe that we will have a quorum. [1:17:55] And so that meeting will be postponed and canceled. [1:17:59] It has led to the question of whether or not I'm just doing a head count yet to determine [1:18:04] that we will have a quorum for the September 30th, June, excuse me, June 30th meeting. [1:18:13] I'll be here. [1:18:14] Yeah, I'll be here. [1:18:15] Why wouldn't it be? [1:18:16] It's the week of Fourth of July. [1:18:18] Just enough people are going to be leaving early. [1:18:22] We don't have the life. [1:18:24] We try to keep up with vacation schedules for sometimes it's. [1:18:27] Well, it's difficult with seven different individuals. [1:18:29] So thank you for asking, Travis. [1:18:32] Anything further, sir? [1:18:35] City Council. [1:18:36] Sean Berger. [1:18:37] Oh. [1:18:38] Suzanne Hawkins, I saw your hand moat to her. [1:18:40] I just didn't flick it. [1:18:42] I just didn't flick it. [1:18:43] I want to see years if you're doing what I think you're doing. [1:18:45] Shumbir. [1:18:46] Yeah, I guess was going to mention that the hanging baskets [1:18:49] were hung on Shoshone Street last week. [1:18:51] So that's another great project. [1:18:53] Another year of that project between the chamber and the city, [1:18:56] the baskets are deeper this year [1:19:00] and were planned for more in advance than they were last year. [1:19:04] So they should be much more robust and full. [1:19:07] Those are all sponsored again, and I believe it may just have a couple of signs that they're [1:19:12] still finishing up some repairs on to get those hung, but the baskets are up and the Parks and [1:19:19] Rec staff are taking care of watering them, and they should do much better this year. [1:19:23] Thank you, Sean. [1:19:25] Suzanne Hawkins. [1:19:26] Okay. [1:19:27] I believe on Thursday, June 5th at 2.30, we're celebrating the first jets coming into our [1:19:33] airport. [1:19:34] Does anybody know? [1:19:35] I got an email, do you, yes, and that's open to the public, right, 230 out of the airport [1:19:45] to see what services are coming. And then I also wanted to invite everybody Saturday to [1:19:51] Canyon Ridge High School at 10 a.m. for our bicycle rodeo that our police department is sponsoring. [1:19:58] Bike safety, I believe that the Safe Kids Coalition is going to be selling bike helmets [1:20:03] out there for $5. So a good event to come out and support at [1:20:07] Canyon Ridge High School, 10 to 2 on Saturday. [1:20:11] Thank you, Suzanne. Anything further from Council? [1:20:14] Question Council at 615. I'm not sure how long the public [1:20:18] hearing is going to take. Doesn't look like a robust group of [1:20:21] folks here to testify. So I'm wondering if you want to go [1:20:25] ahead and forge forward or yes, I'm seeing heads shaking for us [1:20:29] to go ahead and move forward. So the next item on the agenda is [1:20:33] public hearing if you are here to testify today please sign up in the back so that we can call you [1:20:38] up here orderly and it is a request to authorize the mayor to sign slash submit the application material [1:20:45] for an Idaho community development block grant to partially finance infrastructure development [1:20:51] for Cliff Bar's new baking facility and we have Carleen Herring from Region 4 but it looks like [1:20:56] Travis Rotherweiler is going to speak first. So very quickly this is the second of two [1:21:03] new community development block grants that the city was invited to apply for in conjunction [1:21:09] with the Cliff Bar Project. This one will move forward to assist with capital costs associated [1:21:18] with a lift station and other improvements. Carleen Herring with Region 4 is here to present [1:21:28] the specific information and to go forward with the public hearing that is required by Idaho [1:21:39] Department of Commerce as part of this process. [1:21:41] Thank you. [1:21:42] Travis, welcome, Carlin. [1:21:43] Thank you. [1:21:44] Please forgive me. [1:21:50] I've got a mic right now and I'm going. [1:21:54] So it's not contagious. [1:21:56] It's just that I probably won't have a voice by the time we're done again. [1:22:02] Travis mentioned the block grant is provided by the U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development [1:22:07] through the Idaho Department of Commerce. [1:22:09] What did you do? [1:22:12] Carly, why don't you have a seat and you'll hear for support and let's have Travis do it. [1:22:17] Thank you for being here, period, with what you're going through, Travis. [1:22:20] Well, I'm sure, Carly, in that if you could prevent my grants, there's probably others [1:22:24] in the room that would love to get that recipe for that. [1:22:28] So again, what we do is we go forward with this process. [1:22:32] The Community Development Block Grant has a series of processes. [1:22:36] Number one is we want to make sure that we're going forward with the adequate job creation. [1:22:42] So not only with the job creation, but the job creation defines how much funds are ultimately [1:22:48] we are going to be eligible for in moving forward. [1:22:52] This project is designed to complete the construction and aspect of utilities as we move forward [1:23:05] in particular, it's designed for the lift station. [1:23:08] One of the things that we learned during the Chibani piece is that we narrowed our scope [1:23:14] a little bit too much when we were looking at the electrical improvement associated with [1:23:19] that. [1:23:20] And as a result of that, we actually left money on the table. [1:23:24] And so what we're doing now, as we get more experience in moving forward with the community [1:23:29] development block grant phases, is that we begin to include much more items so that we [1:23:36] can exhaust all of the state's $500,000 block grant should we be able and move forward. [1:23:45] And this is the resolution for the submittal is contained in your packet. [1:23:51] As we've shared with you in the past, there are requirements associated with the federal [1:23:55] funds that we move forward. [1:23:57] One is certain of the environmental protections that we go through. [1:24:02] And I believe that the Fonzi has been already issued, associated with this project, which [1:24:07] means that there is no findings of significant impact associated with the project that we have. [1:24:13] We've had a conversation about the fair housing resolution and the new requirements with Kathy [1:24:20] Euchar last time she was in town. [1:24:22] The anti displacement and relocation assistance handicap accessibility, again the ADA stuff that [1:24:28] Josh had been talking about and that transition planning does revolve in part of this in which [1:24:34] humble as we've shared in the past is our coordinator for that. [1:24:39] And then also one of the things that not only because it's required, but it's probably a good thing, [1:24:43] is that as our community becomes more and diverse, where we look on finding opportunities to share messages with those who speak other native languages other than English and moving forward. [1:24:58] The total project that we're looking forward here has a total project of $6,326,323,300, $500,000 of that is the community development block grant. [1:25:18] The rest of that 92% is we're applying for local leverage to illustrate the community's commitment to the project. [1:25:26] Those funds are predominantly coming from TIFF funds associated with site renovation, water [1:25:32] lines, sewer lines, relocations of existing lines, and other pre-treatment facilities [1:25:39] associated with the project. [1:25:42] Jack De Field is also here to talk about specific projects in Jason Brown. [1:25:47] I believe it's the engineer responsible for, in particular, the lift station project associated [1:25:54] with this. [1:25:55] if that would be happy to stand for any questions. [1:25:57] Council have any questions? [1:26:01] I see none. [1:26:03] So Council, I'm going to go ahead and open up [1:26:06] the public testimony portion of this hearing gently, [1:26:11] for someone's sake. [1:26:13] So this is the point where we invite the public forward [1:26:17] for any comments or questions regarding this item. [1:26:22] I see no one rushing for the microphone, [1:26:24] so I'm going to close the public testimony portion [1:26:27] and turn it back over to Travis and or the city council [1:26:31] for direction, what is the resolution number? [1:26:34] Put it on. [1:26:36] Okay, very good. [1:26:39] Any further comments, Travis? [1:26:41] Anything you want to add? [1:26:42] Just a bit matter, a process. [1:26:44] So if our application goes through a series of reviews, [1:26:49] we will be scored a series of points. [1:26:51] If it scores enough points, we'll be invited approximately [1:26:56] in the middle of July to go in and make an official presentation before the governor's [1:27:01] advisory board. The advisory board, if they find our application to be sufficient containing [1:27:08] enough information for them to make a recommendation, will advance that to the governor for his consideration [1:27:14] and hopefully ultimate award. This is, I guess, one of the local steps that we'll complete [1:27:20] as we move forward. [1:27:21] Thank you Travis Greg Lanning Mayor Hall. I move that we accept [1:27:27] resolution [1:27:28] 1925 [1:27:29] Or approved resolution [1:27:31] 1925 [1:27:32] I have a motion on the floor by Greg Lanning seconded by Rebecca Mills so I can anything further on that motion council Greg Lanning [1:27:40] well as [1:27:42] Had a chance to go up to some of these meetings at the advisory board and see who else is applying for these different things [1:27:48] I'm being willing to bet there's enough a lot of smaller cities in the state of [1:27:53] Idaho. We're really glad when we reach that hundred there that fifty thousand mark and [1:27:58] we're no longer available for these because we've been eating up a really [1:28:01] lion's share of them of late. You know I'd agree with that I've had the [1:28:06] opportunity and privilege to go up there as well Greg and and you know got a [1:28:11] strike while the iron is hot and we're able to do that right now for our [1:28:15] community. So it's a blessing truly. Anything further on that motion council, the [1:28:20] yellow roll call vote please. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. [1:28:32] Motion passes seven to zero. Carlaan thank you for coming tonight regardless. I [1:28:37] mean I know that these are miserable times when you have these and you're [1:28:41] professional enough to be here. And thank you Travis for stepping in and helping her. [1:28:45] Thank you again. Absolutely. [1:28:54] There's a question regarding a timeline. Yeah. Travis, could you give us a timeline on this? [1:29:05] Yes. Which piece are you looking for a timeline for? But when we might be [1:29:14] awarded the grant should we be surprised so you're probably going to be looking [1:29:18] in about August could you could you go to the microphone [1:29:42] we did it for both projects because we knew the second phase was coming so from [1:29:48] that standpoint they should be able to move it a lot quicker once the governor [1:29:51] saw this thank you Carleen [1:30:00] I'm just going to move we move into executive session if you're ready why don't you go right ahead sir [1:30:06] Well, we moved that we move in the executive session 67 23 4 5 1 f [1:30:13] to communicate with legal counsel for [1:30:16] publication discuss the legal ramifications of and legal options for pending litigation or controversy [1:30:22] Not yet litigated, but I'm gonna be likely to be litigated [1:30:26] and I don't need to read the last part. [1:30:29] The mere presence of legal counsel [1:30:31] in an executive session does not satisfy this requirement. [1:30:34] Do we have a second? [1:30:35] Second. [1:30:36] We have a motion on the floor by Greg Lanting, [1:30:38] seconded by Suzanne Hawkins, Greg, anything further [1:30:43] on this motion council? [1:30:45] Before we make the vote, I do want to state out loud [1:30:48] that we will not be making any decisions [1:30:51] with the executive sessions. [1:30:53] Nor are we planning on coming out, [1:30:55] or are going to be coming out period [1:30:58] and reconvening this meeting today. [1:30:59] We always know this our meeting. [1:31:01] So with that, the other local vote [1:31:04] going to the executive session. [1:31:05] Some burger. [1:31:06] Yes. [1:31:07] Jim Mudd. [1:31:08] Yes. [1:31:09] Reglanting. [1:31:10] Yes. [1:31:10] Don Hall. [1:31:11] Yes. [1:31:12] Rebecca Mills, like that? [1:31:13] Yes. [1:31:14] Suzanne Hawkins. [1:31:15] Yes. [1:31:16] Motion passes seven to zero. [1:31:18] We are journeying the regular council meeting [1:31:20] going into executive session. [1:31:32] Yeah. [1:31:32] Yeah.