Oversight Archive: City Council meeting, 2014-06-09, recording 1 (started 17:00) Machine transcript (faster-whisper base.en), not checked word for word; the Pledge of Allegiance is shown in its standard wording. The recording is the record. Times are time into the recording. Passages with private details are muted in the audio and marked here. The audio on the page below was re-encoded by software from the video the agency posted. Check any passage against that audio before relying on it. Page: https://oversightarchive.org/twin-falls-id/meetings/2014-06-09/ [0:08:12] But this is all going to change about after the second agenda item on the items for consideration. [0:08:18] Are we? [0:08:20] We should. [0:08:22] The ally, are we ready? [0:08:25] I'd like to call the meeting of the Twin Falls City Council to order. [0:08:28] It is June 9, 2014. [0:08:31] I don't see any Girl Scouts, Boy Scouts in the audience. [0:08:33] Am I missing anyone? [0:08:35] I don't think so. [0:08:36] So if you would all rise and please join us in Pledge of Allegiance. [0:08:44] I pledge allegiance to the Flag of the United States of America, and to the Republic for which it stands, one Nation under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all. [0:08:59] I'd like to welcome everyone to our meeting this evening. [0:09:02] Thank you for coming. [0:09:04] We do have a quorum of the city council. [0:09:07] Five members are here too or not. [0:09:09] They had other commitments that they [0:09:11] had to attend to this evening. [0:09:15] City Manager, do we have any amendments to our agenda? [0:09:19] Mr. Mayor and members of the council, we do have a couple amendments. [0:09:21] Number one, I want to point out that the consent calendar was modified earlier today and we publish that. [0:09:28] There are two items there. [0:09:30] One is a consideration of a request to approve the Snake Harley-Davidson Outdoor Appreciation Concert. [0:09:37] The second is consideration of a request to approve the fit in welfare to be held in Twin Paul City Park. [0:09:43] Both of those items were published earlier today, but we wanted to make sure in the event that someone was looking at an earlier offering of the agenda that they understood that. [0:09:55] We also do have an additional ad that we'd like for you to consider this evening. [0:09:59] That is to approve an alcohol license for video Mexico doing business at 1960 Kimberly Road in Twin Falls. [0:10:08] This is for a consumption off premise of alcohol license. [0:10:16] We don't have to do any special motion on that. [0:10:19] We do need to add it to the consent calendar if you want to consider it this evening. [0:10:25] We'll do that just prior to the consent calendar. [0:10:29] Next item on the agenda is a proclamation. [0:10:32] It is general aviation proclamation. [0:10:35] We have Jared Bandercool from Reader Flyer's Flying Service and [0:10:40] Kerry Requal from Idaho Aviation here, Association, are you here this evening? [0:10:46] Very good, I will be reading the proclamation and I'd like to hand it over to you. [0:10:50] And if you would say a few words, that would be great. [0:10:54] Proclamation, general aviation. [0:10:56] General aviation and community airports play a critical role in the lives of our citizens as well as in the operation of our businesses and farms. [0:11:05] And the state of Idaho has a significant interest in the continued vitality of general aviation aerospace, [0:11:13] aerospace, aircraft manufacturing, educational institutions, and aviation organizations and community airports and airport operators. [0:11:23] And in total, Idaho has 126 public use airports, [0:11:29] serving 5,900 pilots and 2,900 general aviation aircraft. [0:11:36] And according to the 2010 Idaho Airport Systems Plan, the economic impact of general aviation [0:11:43] in Idaho is over $426 million. [0:11:48] The same report found that the total annual economic impact of aviation in Idaho is $2.1 [0:11:56] billion. [0:11:57] Idaho airports and visitors who arrive by air are responsible for 4% of the state's estimated gross domestic product. [0:12:05] And Idaho's general aviation airports create 4,096 jobs annually with an estimated payroll of 133 million. [0:12:17] And according to the Idaho Transportation Department, approximately 23,000 residents of Idaho owe their jobs to [0:12:26] aviation industry, representing 2.9 of all jobs in the state and the nation's aviation [0:12:34] infrastructure represents an important public benefit and direct congressional oversight, [0:12:40] which is necessary to ensure stable funding of the system and organizations like the Idaho [0:12:48] Aviation Association, the Alliance for Aviation Across America, National Business Aviation [0:12:55] Association, National Association of State Aviation Officials, Aircraft Owners and Pilots [0:13:03] Association, and National Air Transportation Association recognizes and promotes the interest [0:13:10] and importance of aviation in Idaho and throughout the world. [0:13:15] And general aviation plays a vital role in the state's response to emergency and natural [0:13:21] disasters, many communities in Idaho depend heavily on general aviation and [0:13:26] community airports for the continued flow of commerce, tourists, and visitors to our [0:13:33] state. Now therefore, I don't haul mayor of the City of Twin Falls. Do hereby [0:13:38] proclaim general aviation as a vital strategic resource to the state of [0:13:43] Idaho and declare June as general aviation appreciation month. Both [0:13:49] both myself and our Deputy City Clerk, Leilada Sanchez. [0:13:52] Sign this and I'd like to turn this over to you [0:13:54] and give you a few minutes to speak if you want to. [0:14:11] Thank you, Mr. Mayor, thank you, Council. [0:14:14] My name's Kerry Riequa, [0:14:16] and I'm pleased to acknowledge this proclamation [0:14:18] on behalf of the Idaho Aviation Association. [0:14:23] The Idaho Aviation Association has been in existence [0:14:26] for 25 years this year, so we're pleased to be a part of this. [0:14:30] Idaho is really rather unique in the lower 48 states in that we have a lot of back country [0:14:37] destinations that provide a wealth of destinations, remote destinations for people from all over [0:14:44] the country. [0:14:45] And in the general aviation world, the state of Idaho is well represented and well known [0:14:51] and is a very popular destination for pilots from all over the country. [0:14:56] So it is a very good economic engine that provides a lot of benefits to the State of [0:15:02] Idaho. [0:15:03] Thank you very much. [0:15:04] Thank you, Kerry. [0:15:05] Well, thank you for having us. [0:15:08] My name is Jared Vanderkoy. [0:15:09] I'm the General Manager for Reader Flying Service out at the airport. [0:15:12] We maintain all of the ground support at the airport. [0:15:15] And for us, this is a great day to have a proclamation to really understand what the need [0:15:19] of general aviation and aviation for the City of Twin Falls. [0:15:22] I have a quote from Norm Crabtree, who is the aviation director for the State of Idaho. [0:15:26] So the airport runway is the most important Main Street in any town [0:15:30] That's so important just to really realize the the just strong impact of what the airport does for the economy [0:15:38] We like to say that the economy is only as strong as its airport [0:15:42] And so thank you for your support and thank you for this proclamation. It's a great day for Twin Falls [0:15:47] Thank you gentlemen for coming this evening. Appreciate it [0:15:51] Next item on the agenda is general public input if there's anyone in the [0:15:55] audience that would like to approach and bring something to our attention that's [0:16:00] not already on the agenda. This is the time for you to do so. I see no one coming [0:16:08] forward so we are going to move on to the consent calendar but obviously we need [0:16:11] to do an add-on to the consent calendar for you. Jim Munn. Would that be done [0:16:16] with a motion? Yes. I would move to include a I guess it would be called a [0:16:24] a discussion to approve the alfalais for video Mexico and the consent calendar. [0:16:28] Second. [0:16:31] We have a motion on the floor by Jim Munn, seconded by Rebecca Mills-Soyka to add the retail alcohol [0:16:37] beverage license to the consent calendar. [0:16:42] Anything on that motion council? [0:16:44] Leila if you could do a roll call vote on that? [0:16:47] Suzanne Hopkins. [0:16:48] Yes. [0:16:49] Jim Munn. [0:16:50] Yes. [0:16:51] Don Hall. [0:16:52] Yes. [0:16:53] Chris Tockens. [0:16:54] Yes. [0:16:55] Rebecca Mills-Soyka. [0:16:56] And now I'll move on to the consent calendar. [0:16:59] Mr. Zand- [0:16:59] Mr. Zand- [0:17:00] Mr. Thruvel of consent calendar. [0:17:01] That's my second. [0:17:02] We have a motion on the floor by Chris Togington, seconded by Suzanne Hawkins to approve the consent calendar. [0:17:09] Anything further on that motion council? [0:17:11] Lee Adler, roll call vote please? [0:17:15] Jim Mine. [0:17:16] Yes. [0:17:17] Don Hall. [0:17:18] Yes. [0:17:19] Best Togington. [0:17:20] Yes. [0:17:21] Rebecca Mills, like that. [0:17:22] Yes. [0:17:23] Suzanne Hawkins. [0:17:24] Yes. [0:17:25] Motion passes 5-0. [0:17:26] following along we are now under items for consideration and the first item for [0:17:30] consideration this evening is a swearing-in ceremony for four new twin falls [0:17:37] police officers Mayor Don Hall to administer the oath of office to officers [0:17:43] Medina I didn't have the courage Medina a I almost medina has been with me for [0:17:51] about a year in our program and I still can't say her last name [0:17:54] Medina, Tyler Campbell, Tevita Messenger, and Eric Strausner. [0:18:01] I'll turn that over to Chief Brian Pike now. [0:18:04] Welcome Chief. [0:18:05] Thank you, Mayor, and members of the Council. [0:18:07] It's always a pleasure to be here. [0:18:09] And tonight we have the honor of squaring in four new officers. [0:18:13] So the groups are just getting larger as we go along here. [0:18:16] But it's exciting. [0:18:17] I'd like to invite all four of them to come forward. [0:18:26] You know, the police profession is a challenging [0:18:28] and rewarding career as Chief Jim Mon and former Chief [0:18:32] Leader Voor told us many times law enforcement is a [0:18:35] noble and honorable profession. [0:18:37] It requires the discipline to handle difficult and [0:18:40] dynamic situations, a courage to face adversity, [0:18:44] to go to the fight, to stand in the gap. [0:18:48] Sympathy and compassion as you help individuals and [0:18:50] families through their most difficult struggles. [0:18:53] The clarity of thought associated with life and [0:18:55] death decisions, and although those moments may be few and [0:18:58] far in between the same thought processes carried out in a daily basis, the application of force, [0:19:05] judgment, and your discernment. For you tonight, the expectation is no different. We believe [0:19:12] you have the background, the temperament, the education, and life experience to serve [0:19:17] our community in this role. Council, let me introduce you to your newest officers. [0:19:23] Medina, Ollie Beggavitch, was hired by the Twin Falls Police Department on May 19, 2014 as a full-time police officer. [0:19:32] Medina was born in Bosnia, she and her family moved to the United States in 1999 when she was seven years old. [0:19:38] They have lived in Twin Falls since then. [0:19:41] Medina graduated from Canyon Ridge High School and went on to attend the law enforcement program at the College of Southern Idaho. [0:19:47] She worked part-time for C3 and PetSmart while attending school. [0:19:51] her goal has been to successfully complete the law enforcement program and to work for [0:19:55] the Twin Falls Police Department. [0:19:56] And I believe she's about to accomplish both of those goals. [0:20:01] She values her family and has always had the support of her husband and family in the endeavor [0:20:04] to become a law enforcement officer. [0:20:07] She's excited to begin her career here in Twin Falls. [0:20:10] Tyler Campbell was hired by the Twin Falls Police Department. [0:20:14] Tyler's the front line. [0:20:17] The tiny one. [0:20:20] He was hired by the department in May of 19, 2014 as a full-time police officer. [0:20:26] He was born in Boise, Idaho. [0:20:28] He and his family moved to Florida when he was in the fifth grade and returned to Idaho during his junior year of high school. [0:20:34] He graduated from Fruitland High School where he played both football and baseball during his junior and senior years. [0:20:40] Tyler attended the Idaho State University's law enforcement academy and graduated May 9, 2014. [0:20:47] The goal was to work for the Twin Falls Police Department, and it was the only department [0:20:50] he wanted to work for. [0:20:51] He's very excited to begin his law enforcement career with us and we're excited to have him. [0:20:55] Tyler and his wife look forward to getting to know our community. [0:20:59] Tavita Massinger was hired by the Twin Falls Police Department in June 2nd, 2014 as a full-time [0:21:05] police officer. [0:21:06] Tavi was born and grew up in Boise, Idaho and graduated from Capital High School. [0:21:12] He pursued his college education by attending the University of Phoenix online and received [0:21:16] his bachelor's of science degree in business. [0:21:19] Prior to his employment with Twin Falls Police Department, [0:21:21] he worked as a dispatcher and a technician for cable one [0:21:24] for six years. [0:21:26] He and his wife, Jenny, have three children, [0:21:27] Jacob, Jackson, and Grace. [0:21:31] Tommy graduated from Idaho Post Academy in March of 2014 [0:21:35] and we're glad to have him. [0:21:37] Eric Strassner was hired by the Twin Falls Police Department [0:21:41] in May 12th, 2014 as a full-time police officer. [0:21:44] Eric was born in Waterburg, Connecticut, [0:21:47] and graduated from Terriville Kinetica High School. [0:21:50] At the age of 21, Eric enlisted in the Marine Corps [0:21:53] and was stationed at Kent, Pendleton, in Southern California. [0:21:57] He completed tours in Iraq and Afghanistan. [0:22:00] He obtained the rank of sergeant [0:22:01] and completed his military contract in 2011. [0:22:05] Upon leaving the Marine Corps, [0:22:06] he visited a good friend who happens [0:22:07] to live here in Southern Idaho. [0:22:09] He enjoyed it so much he decided that he would settle here. [0:22:12] Eric attended the College of Southern Idaho [0:22:14] and obtained an associate's of March degree [0:22:15] criminal justice. His law enforcement career began with a [0:22:20] Gooding County Sheriff's Office in June of 2011 as a detention [0:22:23] deputy. In December of 2012, Eric was hired by the Twin Falls [0:22:27] County Sheriff's Department as a detention deputy. Eric's [0:22:31] initial intention was to become either a police officer or [0:22:33] firefighter. We're glad that he chose the law enforcement [0:22:37] profession. So when he had an opportunity to apply for us, he [0:22:42] did, and was obviously selected for hire. [0:22:47] Eric closed the golf and exercise at the gym, [0:22:49] and he'll be attending the Post Academy on June 22nd [0:22:53] of this month. [0:22:55] Tonight, the ceremony consists of two parts, [0:22:58] the pinning of the police badge and the oath of office [0:23:00] administered by the mayor. [0:23:02] The oath that you're about to take tonight [0:23:04] represents the heart of everything that we do [0:23:06] and all that we stand for. [0:23:08] These are more than words repeated [0:23:10] and a piece of paper that you'll sign. [0:23:13] The badge that you'll receive represents this commitment. [0:23:15] It's the symbol of your office, and the trust the community [0:23:18] has given you in the performance of your job. [0:23:22] By raising your hand and affirming your commitment [0:23:24] to provide public safety to our community, [0:23:26] you'll be empowered to perform the functions of your job. [0:23:30] My charge to you. [0:23:32] Be always mindful of the community's trust, [0:23:34] and ever diligent in your duties. [0:25:44] You solemnly swear that I will support the Constitution [0:25:51] of the United States of America, [0:25:53] of the United States of America, [0:25:54] and the Constitution, [0:25:56] and the laws of the state of Idaho, [0:25:59] and the laws of the state of Idaho, [0:26:01] and the laws and the ordinances [0:26:03] of the city of Twin Falls, [0:26:07] of the city of Twin Falls, [0:26:09] and the rules and regulations, [0:26:11] and the rules and regulations [0:26:13] of the Twin Falls Police Department, [0:26:15] of the Twin Falls Police Department, [0:26:17] and that I will, [0:26:19] and that I will, [0:26:21] well and faithfully discharge, [0:26:23] to do these in the office of police officers. [0:26:28] To do these in the office and to do this in the office. [0:26:30] To do this in the office and to do this in the office. [0:26:31] To do this in the office and to do this in the office. [0:26:32] To do this in the office and to do this in the office. [0:26:33] To do this in the office and to do this in the office. [0:26:34] To do this in the office and to do this in the office. [0:26:35] To do this in the office and to do this in the office. [0:26:36] To do this in the office and to do this in the office. [0:26:37] To do this in the office and to do this in the office. [0:26:38] To do this in the office and to do this in the office. [0:26:39] To do this in the office and to do this in the office. [0:26:40] To do this in the office and to do this in the office. [0:26:41] To do this in the office and to do this in the office. [0:26:42] Congratulations, you know, out of all the things that we get to do when we're appointed or selected as a mayor, for me personally, this ranks right in the top one. [0:28:00] So, big deal. Congratulations to all of you. [0:28:05] Next item on the agenda is presenting police officer David Cushing with his basic certification. [0:28:11] And police officers Justin Sire, is that how you say Justin's last name? [0:28:15] Seer and Steven Gasser with their intermediate certificates [0:28:20] Certifications we have captain Brian career with us this evening welcome captain. Thank you, mayor and members of the council [0:28:29] Providing the best possible customer service is one of the most important objectives for our department [0:28:34] The first step in ensuring this high level of service is a selection and the initial [0:28:40] training of our police officers [0:28:42] And after an in-depth hiring process and then successfully completing the 16-week FTO program and one-year probation [0:28:50] Officers are eligible to receive their basic certification [0:28:53] And we're here tonight to honor the first career achievement for one of our officers and a higher level certification for two other officers [0:29:00] So if I could have the mayor and Chief Brian Pike assist me in the presentation [0:29:06] And if I could have officer David Cushing come forward [0:29:11] Dave Cushing was hired by the Police Department on March 4, 2013. [0:29:25] He was born in Richmond, Virginia. [0:29:27] He grew up in Caldwell, Idaho. [0:29:29] He graduated from Valley View High School. [0:29:32] David then attended Boise State University for four years, where he's seeking to complete [0:29:37] his bachelor's degree in criminal justice. [0:29:39] He played football for the Boise State football team for three and a half years. [0:29:45] And it's with great pleasure that we present David with his basic certification from the [0:29:50] and state of Idaho peace officer standard and training council. [0:30:10] Go Broncos. [0:30:12] And now if I can have officer Justin Seer [0:30:15] and Steven Gasser come forward. [0:30:21] And for those officers that have received [0:30:22] their basic certificate, the next objective [0:30:24] that they strive for is the post intermediate certification. [0:30:29] In order to reach this goal, officers must have [0:30:31] accommodation of additional years of service [0:30:34] and many, many post approved training hours. [0:30:38] Justin Seer was hired by the police department [0:30:40] on May 14th, 2012. [0:30:43] He was born and raised in Burley, Idaho. [0:30:45] He graduated from Burley High School in 2003, [0:30:48] where he then joined the United States Navy. [0:30:50] He served four years overseas as a military police officer [0:30:53] in Bahrain and in Okinawa, Japan. [0:30:57] When he separated from the Navy, he returned to Idaho. [0:30:59] He then attended the College of Southern Idaho [0:31:01] Law Enforcement Program. [0:31:02] And after completing the program, [0:31:04] he continued his college education. [0:31:07] Prior to his employment with our department, [0:31:09] He worked as a detention deputy for Twin Falls County Jail from 2009 until 2012. [0:31:18] Justin and his wife, Ashley, have two beautiful children, Slade and Ray Lee. [0:31:22] And it's with great pleasure that we present Justin with the intermediate certification from the State of Idaho Peace Officer, Standard and Training Council. [0:31:44] I want you to close. [0:31:46] Stephen Gasser, he was hired by the police department as a full-time officer in March of 2008. [0:31:53] But that's not where his interest in law enforcement and with this organization began. [0:31:58] So we back up a little bit where Stephen was born in Twin Falls and graduated from Twin [0:32:01] Falls High School. [0:32:03] He went on to attend CSI law enforcement program where he graduated in 2006 with a technical [0:32:07] certificate. [0:32:08] So in 2002 he began to pursue his law enforcement career when he joined the Twin Falls Police [0:32:14] Department Explorer program. [0:32:16] He participated in the program for six years where he logged over 10,000 right along in volunteer [0:32:22] hours. [0:32:24] And we hired him in 2008. [0:32:26] Stephen is currently assigned to the juvenile crimes unit as a school resource officer. [0:32:32] He's had an active involvement in the bully prevention education program at our local schools. [0:32:37] In June of 2013 Stephen was awarded the Innovation of the Year award from the Idaho Domestic Violence and Victim Assistance Council. [0:32:44] Stephen currently volunteers as a board member on a Twin Falls County juvenile probation and diversion board. [0:32:52] In that capacity, he mentors juveniles that have a drug problem, and he assists in getting [0:32:58] them off of and staying off of illicit drugs. [0:33:03] Stephen also sits on the Twin Falls County Juvenile Probation Drug Team. [0:33:09] It is off time Stephen enjoys volunteering for Camp Rainbow Gold, a program for Idaho Youth [0:33:14] Diagnosis with Cancer, and currently Stephen serves as one of their camp directors and is [0:33:20] active in their year-long activities. [0:33:23] And again, it is great pleasure that we present Stephen with an innovative certification from [0:33:27] the State of Idaho Peace Officers Standard Training Council. [0:33:45] Well, congratulations to all of our officers, our new officers, and our officers continuing [0:33:49] their education. [0:33:50] I'm going to go ahead and give it just a couple minutes, because usually the whole audience [0:33:56] clears out during this time. [0:33:58] So if that will work for you, go ahead and don't feel like you're obligated to stay. [0:34:03] We'd love to have you stay, but we'll give you just a minute or so. [0:34:07] Congratulations. I think we can probably carry on now counsel if you don't mind [0:34:45] Under items for consideration number two is consideration of request to adopt a resolution that approves participation in the state local agreement for construction [0:34:54] To build the signal at the intersection of carriage Lane and Addison Avenue east and to authorize the mayor to sign the agreement [0:35:02] We have our city engineer [0:35:04] Jackie Fields welcome Jackie [0:35:06] So the process for federal aid jobs is that we sign a state local [0:35:20] we initiate a project so I come and visit you about should be initiated a project and then [0:35:26] Initiate a contract that says we're gonna go through design and then as [0:35:31] Before they bid before the state bids the job then I come back with a state local agreement for construction and [0:35:38] in this particular item I was pretty close to [0:35:42] to getting our estimate right, but I appeared to miss the mark and then we had some really [0:35:50] terrific news that occurred because I complained about having to pay more money and so we went [0:35:58] through this little process of how can we possibly skin the cost on this job, that was [0:36:04] LTCH and myself and it turns out that our new hire, relatively new hire, Darren Scott [0:36:10] who came to us from ITD is still certified in all of the things that ITD needs to run [0:36:16] a job. [0:36:17] And so we had a discussion with the LTCH fellow and they have removed funds from the job because [0:36:26] Darren can cover the inspection. [0:36:28] Jackie, can I ask you a question while we're putting that up? [0:36:44] How do we keep him certified? [0:36:46] Can we keep him certified? [0:36:47] Yeah, we can keep him certified. [0:36:48] And right now certifications for WAQTC, which is materials type testing, are about 500 bucks a pop. [0:36:57] Our contribution had been $1,700, and now we're appearing to be $200 to the good. [0:37:04] So for him to take a test up at ITD to stay certified should be in that neighborhood or less. [0:37:12] I have training dollars budgeted for that, and it's in our best interest to do that. [0:37:16] for the future for other type of situations like this. [0:37:20] So on really large jobs, we won't tend to do that [0:37:23] because we'll have a hard time providing continuous support. [0:37:26] We'll have to think about that very carefully. [0:37:28] But the Signal Project is a very manageable job. [0:37:32] He did the inspection on our Signal Project [0:37:35] at Fillmore and North College. [0:37:37] So here's our new worksheet. [0:37:39] You had one similar in your package that had a different number [0:37:43] on it. [0:37:44] And so now, we are no longer required to make a financial contribution in order to bid the job. [0:37:50] And so I was instructed by LTCH to line out that section of the document. [0:37:56] And then I'm requesting that if you approve the contract, that you just initial the acknowledgement there. [0:38:04] So the request this evening is that the council adopt the resolution that's attached to the back of the contracts there [0:38:11] to approve participation in the projects and then authorizes the merit to sign those agreements. [0:38:17] Chris, talking to you. [0:38:19] Jackie, notice in the narrative that the impact fees cannot be used for our match on this. [0:38:26] Is there a warrant for that intersection? [0:38:29] Yes. [0:38:30] There is. [0:38:31] Yeah. [0:38:32] And that was the warrant existed before or at the time of the development of the impact fees. [0:38:42] I can't remember what the language that excludes it from the handbag. [0:38:47] The need for the signal is that if the need existed prior to the collection of the impact fees, [0:38:54] then it's not growth-related. [0:38:56] So this is growth-related, but it's growth before the initiation of our program. [0:39:02] There's no doubt that it's a real significant safety issue for people trying to cross out of this one right now. [0:39:08] So good. [0:39:10] Just for future reference, what is the resolution number early on, 1926? [0:39:16] Thank you. [0:39:17] Rebecca Milsoyka. [0:39:18] Thank you, Mayor. [0:39:19] A question for you, Jackie. [0:39:20] It says in the narrative also that the funding didn't provide for right of way acquisition and [0:39:26] major widening, is there some wisdom into doing any of this work now, or can it all be done [0:39:34] later without interrupting any of the construction that's going to be done with this signal? [0:39:45] So we can install the signal at this point and there are some undeveloped portions of [0:39:52] ground. [0:39:53] If those pieces of ground go into subdivision planning, then we'll have an opportunity to [0:40:00] acquire appropriate right-of-way and then address moving the poles and lengthening the [0:40:08] mass terms as appropriate, whether that's a developer paid cost depending on what ends [0:40:15] up there or a later city expansion project. [0:40:21] So it would have to be moved in the future as that develops. [0:40:27] Would that be, I know you said it could be the developer or the city, I mean, do we know [0:40:32] who it would be that would be covering that cost? [0:40:35] Is it wise to do it now? [0:40:38] I don't know who will cover the cost in the future. [0:40:42] It kind of depends what happens. [0:40:44] The wisdom of doing it now is that there's a huge multi-family housing development north [0:40:53] throughout, and my understanding is that there are a ton of people that come out of that entire [0:40:57] neighborhood, north of Addison, try to cross the street to get to the Thompson Park, and [0:41:04] that helped make the warrant. [0:41:07] So we were able to get the money now to build the signal without right away. [0:41:13] conditions of this funding don't include right-of-way acquisition. So they're [0:41:20] supposed to address short safety projects. Since we don't know when those [0:41:26] adjacent properties will develop, it's hard to decide how long we're going to [0:41:31] wait. So in engineering staff receive requests to do something with some [0:41:39] regularity. You know two to three times a year it's not usually with great drama [0:41:47] but it's still a request. No I certainly agree and I'm not suggesting that we wait [0:41:53] for the signal but we're just wondering if we should acquire the ride of way now [0:41:57] as we put in this signal but as you move ahead you probably don't have time to [0:42:03] to acquire the ride away or is that something we should consider in putting [0:42:08] in the signal. [0:42:09] This funding scenario, I'm not allowed to acquire a right-of-way. [0:42:12] So if we acquired right-of-way, it would be independently. [0:42:15] Right. [0:42:16] It would be from the city's funding. [0:42:18] So if the council decided they wanted that to be in priority for me, then for streets, [0:42:25] expenditures, then that's certainly what we do. [0:42:28] I would probably recommend waiting until the land subdivides because the right-of-way acquisition [0:42:36] would come with. [0:42:38] Okay. Great. I just don't want to see us put a signal there and then have to move it within, you know, a few years. [0:42:45] The difference between this area and North College is that North College is completely developed. [0:42:50] So, there aren't, it'll be the same situation on the south side of the south side of the road at Kerajan Addison. [0:42:57] That's pretty much developed. So, that kind of acquisition is going to be different than a subdivision of land. [0:43:06] Okay. Thank you. [0:43:07] How much more is it to not the right-of-way acquisition, [0:43:12] but the actual structure later on to come in and [0:43:15] longer poles and move them out? [0:43:19] Is that substantial cost? [0:43:21] Let's see, in my opinion, no. [0:43:29] It should be a fraction of the cost because, well, you know... [0:43:36] That's a loaded question. [0:43:37] I should ask you how much it is. [0:43:39] Yeah, I'm sorry. [0:43:40] It's a person's perspective. [0:43:41] Sure, sure. [0:43:43] So, I think that it would be manageable because the controller software is going to be current [0:43:48] and none of that has to be replaced to move the, so you have a foundation and you might [0:43:53] have a taller pole and you might have a, and you'll probably have a longer master, but [0:43:58] all the heads can be reused and, you know, you have some paint, so it's money, but it's [0:44:07] not like the initial onset for the design and construction of the work. [0:44:13] You know, I think I'm probably going down the same road that Rebecca has a little bit. [0:44:16] I just always, when we make decisions, I always like to look 20, 30 years out and try to spend [0:44:21] the money now because today's money is cheaper than tomorrow's money, generally speaking. [0:44:27] But I trust your judgment. [0:44:28] If you don't think it's not, it's going to be at this point we should just proceed on. [0:44:32] Well, I don't know when it's going to be warranted. [0:44:34] Right. [0:44:35] So the Highway District always teases me and says that they don't want to fix a road because [0:44:39] we're going to annex the roadway. [0:44:42] after they fix it and so you know this could very well be our reality where we [0:44:47] install the signal and the development comes but currently I can't see that [0:44:53] from here we don't we don't even have comments of interest very good thank you [0:44:59] Chris talking I would move past the resolution 1926 and sign and allowing [0:45:05] the sign up right second we have motion on floor by Chris talking and second [0:45:11] Vice President Hawkins to pass resolution 1926 and authorize the mayor [0:45:17] to sign the agreement. Anything further on that motion council? [0:45:23] Leah, I have a roll call vote, please. [0:45:25] Don Hall. Yes. [0:45:26] President Washington. Yes. [0:45:28] Rebecca Mills, I got yes. [0:45:30] Suzanne Hawkins. Yes. [0:45:31] Jim. Yes. [0:45:33] Motion passes five to zero. [0:45:35] You gave this to me. [0:45:36] You want me to sign it right now? [0:45:38] Okay. [0:45:38] I will do that while I'm signing it. [0:45:40] I'll go ahead and I'll ask our, and I'll sneak it around to you, I'll ask our city manager [0:45:45] to come forward for a presentation, followed by citizen input and general discussion about [0:45:52] the FY 2015 budget priorities and philosophies. [0:45:56] Welcome, Mr. Rothweiler. [0:46:03] Thank you, Mr. Mayor, members of the council. [0:46:05] So this begins the happiest time of the year. [0:46:08] It's almost like Christmas time because really in this process, we are going through what [0:46:20] I find to be one of the most important things that a city does on an annual basis. [0:46:27] And that is the prioritization of scariest resources and turning them into tangible good [0:46:35] and services for the community that we serve. [0:46:40] And when we do that, just as we've talked about in the past, [0:46:45] we want to do so with some different things [0:46:47] that are on the forefront of the conversation. [0:46:51] The first is we want to make sure that we are mindful [0:46:53] of that city mission statement, the mission statement [0:46:56] that says, this is why our organization exists. [0:47:01] We exist to serve as stewards of the public trust. [0:47:05] to meet the current future needs of the community, [0:47:08] to promote citizen input, to preserve our heritage [0:47:11] and to conserve and protect the social and physical resources [0:47:16] of our community that are designed [0:47:18] to enhance our quality of life. [0:47:21] There is a lot in that few word statement, [0:47:26] and the responsibilities and charges that come from there [0:47:29] helped us create a strategic plan that is also serves [0:47:34] as a governing document as we move forward. [0:47:38] So one of the things that I think is important to share is really about our process and how [0:47:42] our approach has changed over the course of the last few years. [0:47:48] We start our process earlier than what I'm aware of most organizations. [0:47:53] We started our budgeting process in March of this year when the members of the long-term [0:47:59] planning committee came together to share their thoughts. [0:48:03] We invited citizens to come and share their thoughts and perspectives, and we'll go over [0:48:07] those. [0:48:08] And this approach that we follow is called budgeting for outcomes. [0:48:12] Really trying to ensure that we are engaging our citizens, we are engaging our employees, [0:48:17] we are bringing comments into a budgeting process, we are trying to think and operate strategically [0:48:23] that's why it is connected to our strategic plan. [0:48:26] And ultimately, if we're successful in the first four, we're going to be able to transform [0:48:31] our government and we're also going to be able to transform our community. [0:48:38] Most importantly of those, engagement is critical and in that engagement it really goes back [0:48:44] to that strategic plan because in that strategic plan we engage our community like no other [0:48:49] time previously. [0:48:51] We engaged our citizens in many workshops, in many community settings through surveys and [0:48:58] the like. [0:48:59] We've engaged our employees through the long-term planning committee, all collectively working [0:49:05] together to advance the strategic plan that we have. [0:49:10] So we like to think how we align those resources to accomplish those number one priorities that [0:49:19] appear in that strategic plan. [0:49:22] Adjusting those number one priorities or number two priorities as the world changes, sometimes [0:49:28] there are greater needs than what we originally anticipated when we came up with that strategic [0:49:32] plan and that strategic plan is designed to be flexible. It is designed to be fluid because [0:49:41] the place that we operate today is very fluid. If we would have created a strategic plan back [0:49:47] in 2008, it would be very, very different than the strategic plan that we would have [0:49:53] created in 2009 and 10 and 11 at the beginning of the heart of the recession. [0:50:00] Our strategic plan was created the time in which we were beginning to see the light at [0:50:06] the end of that tunnel. [0:50:08] At the end of the day, we want to be recognized as a world-class community. [0:50:12] And that is an incredible endeavor and challenge as we move forward. [0:50:19] As a quick refresher, we have eight primary focus areas of our strategic plan. [0:50:23] one of them has a vision statement attached to it. It talks about the place that we want [0:50:29] to arrive in the year 2030. The strategic plan describes and discuss the things that we need [0:50:36] to do to be able to get there. And in a sense, like a planning continuum, we are trying to [0:50:42] design a spiral staircase to take us from where we were to where we want to be in 2030. It's [0:50:48] It's not just a merry-go-round going around in circles trying to see the same place, but [0:50:54] every year we want to elevate our performance, and we want to be able to do a better job in [0:50:59] meeting the citizens' expectations for the community that they've established for the [0:51:03] year 2030. [0:51:06] So this is a graphic example of how it all ties together. [0:51:10] We illustrate the mission statement and the guiding principles that came from that. [0:51:16] And underneath that, you see the eight different vision statements that help create the overall [0:51:22] vision that we hope to achieve by the year 2030. [0:51:26] One of the most important dynamics of this entire strategic plan is the need for partnerships. [0:51:32] And so we talk a lot about the establishment of partnerships and providing opportunities [0:51:37] for us to be engaged in the community, to be engaged with us. [0:51:40] You see at the bottom we have departments and goals, objectives, and budget, and then [0:51:46] from that process we go through assessment. [0:51:52] One of the things, and one of the great things that I think that we've done in the organization [0:51:58] is we have brought together truly some of the best minds in our organization, across [0:52:05] all aspects of it. [0:52:07] We call that our long-term planning community. [0:52:10] These individuals really kind of raised their hand. [0:52:12] They didn't know what they were signing up for, and they came forward, and they learned [0:52:16] about the city, and they shared their thoughts and their beliefs about what needed to be [0:52:23] accomplished. [0:52:24] They recognized the timeframes that we have, they recognized the budgetary constraints, [0:52:31] and they made a presentation to you. [0:52:34] And through that entire process, they created the foundation of the budget that we will present [0:52:41] to you in July. [0:52:44] A lot of their work, probably in excess of 80% of it, is completely contained and moves [0:52:51] forward. [0:52:53] The community learned about the different roles, they learned about the different functions [0:52:57] of our organization, and they think they had a better appreciation for the many different [0:53:05] companies or groupings that we have under our organization. [0:53:11] The long-term planning committee's task list to update the five-year forecasting model and [0:53:17] they've made that presentation again and I think that they did a great job. [0:53:21] They wanted to make sure that they are tying to the strategic plan in which they did successfully [0:53:26] but they also wanted to make sure that they are focusing on the needs of the organization [0:53:30] to maintain existing service levels and enhancing service levels where it was appropriate and [0:53:36] where it became expected by our citizens. [0:53:39] Here are the major things that they shared with you. [0:53:43] They talk about adding additional employees [0:53:45] across the organization as needed [0:53:47] to carry out the overall mission. [0:53:50] They shared the importance of addressing [0:53:52] facility needs in our organization, [0:53:55] investing in equipment to carry out [0:53:57] and to improve organizational efficiency, [0:54:00] investing in upgraded equipment to keep pace [0:54:03] with those demands as we move forward, [0:54:07] and then also recognizing that we're a service organization. [0:54:12] And then part of that service is paid for by citizens dollars, [0:54:17] and we need to respect the fact that we have [0:54:19] a fiduciary responsibility to operate fiscally, [0:54:24] conservative in a manner that is appropriate. [0:54:31] We asked our citizens to come and we had two groups, [0:54:34] One, talking about citizens and the importance of expanding our trails, and this is a group [0:54:40] that we've partnered with in the past to do good things, and they came forward, asking [0:54:46] for a renewed part of that partnership. [0:54:49] Also, we've had individuals come and talk about the need for opportunities for facilities. [0:54:55] I presented to you after that a series of what I believe to be important objectives or [0:55:01] may be touchstones for the organization. [0:55:05] We need to make sure that we're continuing to advance [0:55:07] the strategic plan, that the strategic plan stays [0:55:10] at the forefront of our organization, [0:55:12] that we continue to build collaborative partnerships [0:55:14] with our public partners, our private partners, [0:55:17] and our nonprofit community partners. [0:55:20] We need to make sure that we're continuing to invest [0:55:23] in our employees from a place of not only compensation, [0:55:27] but also with training. [0:55:30] We need to make sure that the basic infrastructure of our organization is sound, that we are building [0:55:37] not referring or relying upon concepts of deferred maintenance. [0:55:44] We need to look at our facilities differently. [0:55:47] We need to look at our facilities as a place that housed the organization and the employees [0:55:51] that work here, but it also is the public meeting places for our organization where they come [0:55:57] to access. [0:55:58] And also important. [0:56:00] We need to continue to pursue those innovative strategies as we continue to move forward. [0:56:09] From those conversations, what we want to do tonight is we want to make sure that we understood [0:56:16] and we took your sentiments and we applied them appropriately as we're creating that budget. [0:56:24] So we were talking about property tax revenue and we wanted to make sure that the property [0:56:29] tax revenue that we took, was that the 3% statutorily allowed increase was something [0:56:37] that was universally accepted as something that was important if the expenditures could [0:56:43] be justified and warranted for that. [0:56:46] It wasn't a place for an invitation just to take money for the sake of taking money, but [0:56:50] if it could be employed to advance our organization, the council was open to that. [0:56:56] Some members of the city council said that they would be open to moving forward with [0:57:02] some portion of the foregone balance if staff could present a sustainable movement forward. [0:57:11] In our work so far today, we have not included the use of any foregone balance in moving forward. [0:57:19] Chris talking. [0:57:20] You know, I might, since we're on the discussion of taxes, [0:57:24] I just got my assessed evaluation notice. [0:57:28] And for the first time, I think in about seven or eight years, [0:57:32] the homeowners exemption has shown an increase. [0:57:36] If that happens across the board, whatever level, [0:57:40] how does that adjust or how is the tax pay that the city [0:57:46] city participates in reformulated or how does it look [0:57:52] different than in a year of a decreasing home owners [0:57:56] exemption? [0:57:57] We'll get to that, I promise. [0:57:58] OK. [0:58:01] Yeah. [0:58:02] In fact, we're going to spend a lot of time talking tonight [0:58:04] about taxation, home owners exemption, [0:58:07] and what that may or may not mean. [0:58:13] Vesting in our employees was also [0:58:15] an important theme that was across all, implementing the 2013 Strategic Planning Objectives and [0:58:24] moving forward, investing in water, wastewater transportation, including the Canyon Springs [0:58:30] grade in a thoughtful, fiscally responsible and sustainable manner. [0:58:38] That continuing to look at the expansion of our trail systems and open space and the [0:58:42] continued development of innovative strategies and greater to create greater [0:58:47] efficiencies in our organizations. These seem to be the ones that were [0:58:51] universal across all seven members, and I hope we didn't get those wrong. [0:58:56] Did we get them wrong? Now we recognize that there were other pieces that were [0:59:01] shared. We included things that everything were moving forward. When we [0:59:11] We developed this process, we then take an opportunity, and this is a graph that we use [0:59:17] during our conversation, the creation of the budget of where it stands today. [0:59:23] So after we had our public conversations, members of the organization's leadership team [0:59:30] sat down in a series of meetings about 12 hours in total duration. [0:59:35] We used this chart as well as the other graph that illustrated the strategic plan, and we [0:59:40] We mapped out the organizational priorities that we felt were important as we move forward. [0:59:47] We did it collectively. [0:59:49] In the past, it was an individual conversation with the city manager. [0:59:54] In this year's approach, all members and leaders of all of the departments sat at the table to [1:00:02] have a conversation about the direction of moving forward. [1:00:06] And we used the long-term planning committee's proposal as the basis and foundation of what [1:00:15] we did. [1:00:16] So, truly, the budget that we are presenting to you has been built from the ground up. [1:00:23] It has been built with lots of conversation with employees who chose to engage. [1:00:33] Whenever we're building a budget, we want to make sure that we're very aware, keenly [1:00:37] aware of the current economic trends of our current area. [1:00:41] So tonight we want to spend a little bit of time talking about the different economic [1:00:46] trends that we're seeing. [1:00:49] Number one, we're seeing that nationally home prices continue to rise. [1:00:53] In fact, in all 50 states, the value of each home rose. [1:01:01] In fact, when you look at 95 of the 100 largest metro areas, prices continue to go [1:01:07] up by an average of nearly 12%. What's important about that number though is that they are still [1:01:14] about 14.3% lower than their all-time highs in 2006. That tells us that home prices are [1:01:23] beginning to recover, but they have not completely got there yet. And if you think about your [1:01:28] own individual tax assessment and where that property value was, and you think about where [1:01:35] is today, it's highly unlikely that you have seen all of that return. [1:01:41] That's important when we recognize where we're at in our budget. [1:01:46] We recognize that unemployment in most major cities has continued to fall and the unemployment [1:01:51] rate for the nation is at 6.1%, which represents the lowest it has been since December of 2008. [1:01:59] Stocks continue to set record highs. [1:02:02] If you take a look at the Dow Jones from January 2nd through 2013 to June 2nd of 2014, it has [1:02:12] jumped nearly 3640 points, which represents the single largest gain of the stock market [1:02:19] in its history. [1:02:20] What's important though is that it has continued to recover. [1:02:24] at 13,104, it was not, that does not represent the low point of the stock market during the [1:02:32] recession. Consumer confidence continues to grow, but it is not 100% stable. It continues [1:02:42] to have and flow and it has not returned to the highs that we enjoyed in 2000 and before. [1:02:50] Rebecca Mille, I like it. [1:02:55] Thank you, Mayor, and you may be getting to this. I was wondering about how [1:03:00] The local trends, you know, we've seen some job layoff lately and just wondering how that might be affecting our local community [1:03:07] We're gonna get there. Okay. Yep. So next we're gonna talk about Idaho as we continue to to drill down [1:03:12] I think what's important is that [1:03:16] How does things start to continue to grow but they're not as robust as what they thought that they would be? [1:03:21] Derek Santos, who is the state's chief economist, [1:03:25] has indicated that they believe that they will continue to see housing growth in each year of the next four fiscal years of the state, [1:03:33] based upon where it currently sets through fiscal year 2017. [1:03:38] Also an important driver is that when you look at those housing starts, [1:03:43] they're expecting an increase in the next year, about 13.7%. [1:03:48] They're also expecting that the state-wide labor market will continue in non-farm agriculture [1:03:54] to grow. [1:03:55] It will grow by 3% in fiscal year 2011, they're projecting 2.9% in fiscal year 2016 and 2.6% [1:04:04] in 2017. [1:04:06] And then real personal income continues to grow as well. [1:04:12] They're projecting that it will grow by an average of about 2.9% each year for the next [1:04:18] three fiscal years. So let's talk about what this means locally. Let's start with building [1:04:25] activity. This is a part of a report that we prepare in the building department on a monthly [1:04:33] basis. And what it illustrates is the total number of different types of permits for the [1:04:37] different types of dwellings or commercial properties that we've had for this current [1:04:43] fiscal year. And we use that as well as the historical data to try to forecast where are [1:04:49] are we going to end up? [1:04:50] So last year, we had housing starts about, [1:04:54] we completed housing starts of 182 single family permits. [1:04:59] And this year, with about an 8.7% overall increase, [1:05:04] we're also projecting that we will come close to that 200 mark. [1:05:09] We estimate that we'll issue about 198 single family permits. [1:05:13] New commercial starts right now is kind of a horse [1:05:17] that is waiting to go and peak right now if you take a look at the total number of permits [1:05:24] that have been issued, you'll see that we're down about 30%, but we've continued to make [1:05:29] ground on that. And if you look at where we ended up over the course of the last year, [1:05:35] we will end the conversations that we've had with developers, whether it be along Canyon [1:05:43] west or in other parts of the community, we believe that we will come close, but fall [1:05:48] a bit short of the total number of new commercial permits that were issued, but we'll talk [1:05:53] about the value of those permits in just a second. [1:05:57] What has significantly gone up is the commercial addition and remodels. [1:06:03] What that means is that individuals are making better use of existing spaces, and if we go [1:06:08] downtown. We talk about 30 new businesses in the downtown core. And when you think of [1:06:14] those businesses that are there, those are new remodeled buildings. They increase the [1:06:22] value and they expand the tax base. Those unfortunately are locked up in the urban [1:06:27] new area for a few more years, so we won't see the value of that. But that is an example [1:06:32] of what we're seeing is making better use of existing spaces and facilities within our community. [1:06:40] You'll notice that the total number of permits issued in all for all permits is up 2.1%. [1:06:49] This is where we start taking a look at the value of those permits and you'll see that [1:06:53] The total revenues are up about 41% from May of last year, from 455,000 to 641,000 dollars. [1:07:07] Now part of that was very intentional. [1:07:09] If you'll recall, we placed a $300 fee for plan review on new residential construction to assist with plan review occurring. [1:07:21] But that doesn't certainly come up with all of that. [1:07:24] What we're seeing is an increased value, which is the graph that's illustrated, of those different [1:07:29] works. [1:07:30] We issue permits based upon the value of the construction, and you can see that the year-to-date [1:07:34] values have gone up. [1:07:37] In fact, when you take a look at the new commercial permits, you can see that it is just 5.4% off [1:07:44] in terms of total value. [1:07:46] So even though we've issued significantly less permits, the value of those permits are [1:07:52] keeping pace with where we were in the prior year. [1:07:55] And when we look at the commercial additions in our model, [1:07:58] you can see that the total value of those permits [1:08:01] is up 112%. [1:08:06] The total value of all permits for the city [1:08:08] is up about $10,500 from $37,300 to $47,800. [1:08:21] I have a question about that. [1:08:22] I'm sorry, Rebecca, I didn't see that. [1:08:24] That's OK. [1:08:24] Thank you, Mayor. [1:08:27] We recently switched the way that we reported our permit values. [1:08:30] Do you think that has any factoring into this value being up? [1:08:37] Do you think that the, okay. [1:08:40] We do not. [1:08:41] In fact, what we're doing is this is the first month and I'm going to have [1:08:44] smhich to not if I get this right. [1:08:46] This is the first month in which we're using city works. [1:08:48] And this month was a bit delayed because we're doing a bunch of cross [1:08:51] referencing to ensure that the numbers that were inputted were equal in terms of value. [1:08:56] We're seeing greater value in terms of the permits that are issued today than what they [1:09:00] were last year. [1:09:01] Okay. [1:09:02] Thanks. [1:09:09] We've shared this in the past, but I think it's important just to touch on briefly is that [1:09:13] the cost of doing business for everybody, including local government continues to go up. [1:09:19] This is a fluctuating table. [1:09:21] It's based, it's indexed based upon cost today in comparison to cost in the prior year, for [1:09:27] Over the year so far in April of 2000, comparing April of 2013 to April of 2014, the Municipal [1:09:33] Cost Index is up 1.8%. [1:09:38] The MCI over the CPI over the same period of time is up about 2%. [1:09:48] Unemployment indicators are illustrated right here, and what's important is that we continue [1:09:54] to illustrate the trend of an improving local economy. [1:09:58] So to Rebecca's question, the best data that we have right now is here, and it does not necessarily [1:10:05] talk about the layoffs that you may be talking about associated with Chibani. [1:10:10] Our understanding is that those layoffs, while painful and to those individual families, were [1:10:19] associated with temporary labor, and it's our hopes that as we continue to grow and to [1:10:26] expand the local economy and with Cliff Barr knowing that they're soon to be in the process [1:10:34] of construction, that this will be a blip but something that continues to grow. [1:10:39] Overall, there are more people working today than there were last year. [1:10:43] In fact, it's about a 120 basis point increase. [1:10:48] The unemployment at being fully employed now is statistically considered at 5% and you [1:10:54] You can see that the City of Twin Falls exceeds what is considered to be full employment. [1:11:03] What's also important about the Twin Falls employment rate is this is for the City of Twin Falls. [1:11:11] There are lots of different rates out there, and it is safe to say that most, well I can't [1:11:16] say most, we don't know the demographics, but we don't believe that every single employee [1:11:21] that may be affected by layoffs, worked inside the city of Flint Falls, just as though in [1:11:28] other communities where they may experience layoffs, that individuals in our community may [1:11:34] not be affected or may not be unharmed as well. [1:11:39] We have a very migratory part of our local economy where individuals drive to different [1:11:45] opportunities for job and job opportunities, property tax values. [1:11:54] What we're starting to see is generally an increase in property tax values, and [1:11:58] that makes sense because we saw the homeowners exemption, which is indexed to overall statewide values, increase. [1:12:08] We'll talk about what that means. [1:12:09] We'll also recognize that commercial industrial properties are also seeing slightly higher taxable evaluations as well. [1:12:17] Again, the homeowners exemption, the exemption which is set by the state of Idaho has gone up about 3.6% for the current tax here. [1:12:26] It's $81,000 and it will go to $83,920. [1:12:32] So in layman's terms, if your value of your home went up, the exemption went up potentially as well. [1:12:42] So with the state of Idaho, they allow individual owner occupied houses. [1:12:49] That's the important part, owner occupied houses to take the maximum exemption. [1:12:57] If their property value is at approximately $168,000 over the course of this next year, [1:13:08] or 50%, whichever is less. [1:13:12] So as this continues to grow, those individuals with lower property tax values may not see [1:13:21] that benefit because the exemption is a lower of the two, lower of the, because you get 50% [1:13:31] or the maximum home owners exemption, whichever is less. [1:13:36] And the homeowner's exemption is used to define the total taxable value of a house. [1:13:43] And all of those taxable values are used to determine the total taxable value of the community. [1:13:51] And the taxable value of the community is what, and our spending, is what we use to create a tax rate. [1:14:00] Everybody's individual tax circumstances are going to be different. [1:14:04] And what we plan on doing just as we have done in all the years past is we will do a [1:14:09] sample, but we will also place our calculation and out on the website for individuals to be [1:14:18] able to determine their city portion share of their property taxes. [1:14:23] And that's an important point for us to emphasize. [1:14:26] It's just their city portion. [1:14:28] It does not include the other taxing districts. [1:14:31] It does not include the bondings that may be coming on as a result of the passage of the [1:14:37] school bond. [1:14:39] This is just the impact of the city. [1:14:42] We expect that as the housing prices and values continue to recover, you will begin to see that [1:14:49] swing and that move forward. [1:14:53] So as Councilman Tocquington shared that this appears to be the first upswing in the Home [1:14:59] one of those exemptions since about 2009 when it was at its all-time high of nearly $104,500. [1:15:10] Five years I was wrong on those, seven or eight, five years. [1:15:20] So we take all that information and we begin to share way too early information. [1:15:26] So let me, I mean, this is, so the emotional roller coaster of what is the tax rate is, is maybe about to begin. [1:15:37] So we encourage no one to go to the bank, if you will, with what all this means. [1:15:42] As we've had illustrated last year, our total taxable value went through a series of ebbs and flows. [1:15:51] And in fact, if you notice, the 2,200,000,000 number should be new to you, right? [1:15:59] You've probably never seen that number before, have you? [1:16:03] So after we used what we believed to be the final number, and we came in on a special [1:16:11] meeting after we were informed that, and by no fault, right? [1:16:16] But the number that we had used was different. [1:16:23] There was a certification of the taxable value that occurs in December, and that is the certification [1:16:30] that was received. [1:16:31] It's about a $7 million difference than the number that we used to moving forward. [1:16:37] As you recall, we were talking previously that we thought that the tax rate for the current [1:16:42] fiscal year was going to be $8.03. [1:16:45] It ended up being $7.85. [1:16:52] So I share this by saying I think it's important for us not to be to recognize this because [1:16:59] it's important. [1:17:00] We need to be respectful of the taxes that we are going to assess. [1:17:05] But I think it's also important that if we focus on the number it's going to be like [1:17:09] focusing on a ping pong match where really it may cause us to drift from our strategic [1:17:18] priorities and the elements that we choose to fund. [1:17:21] By state law, we have the ability to determine our own course when it comes to revenue, and [1:17:27] that is the 3% plus the new construction and annexation known as the growth formula, and [1:17:33] that is what has been incorporated in this formula. [1:17:39] So the taxable value for year 2015 is scheduled to be $2,237,000,000. [1:17:50] And when we talked about that number internally, it is the best number that we have, so it's [1:17:55] important for us to share it and it's important for us to use it. [1:17:58] And if that number is right, then the tax rate taking the 3% in the new construction [1:18:03] would be about $8.07 per thousand dollars of taxable value. [1:18:11] But where we get a little, where we begin to question the number is when you take a look [1:18:21] at the growth formula and the new construction number that appears right below it. [1:18:27] The new construction value of the city of Twin Falls was $31 million last year. [1:18:33] That is up from $22 million of what we projected. [1:18:37] That means that the entire rest of the city's net growth [1:18:43] was about $7 million. [1:18:46] All of it, all of the growth for the city outside of new [1:18:51] construction only amounted to $7 million. [1:18:55] So the houses that you're in right now and the houses that [1:18:59] $15,000 of our residents lived in in the prior year, [1:19:03] Their total value only grew by $7 million. [1:19:09] All of the new construction and development that has occurred outside of a tax agency, [1:19:14] on top of, only grew by $7 million. [1:19:18] We share that to say this number, we believe, is still subject to review. [1:19:25] And we know that because there is still a process that the county will use as they go [1:19:30] through a series of certifications, so as well as property tax appeals and moving forward. [1:19:40] We will not get a different number, probably until August. [1:19:47] And we will not know the true certified role until December. [1:19:53] And we are legally required to adopt a budget and send an L2 form somewhere around the second [1:20:01] to last week of August of every year. [1:20:05] That's why we focus on the amount of revenue [1:20:08] that we need to support local government operations. [1:20:12] And we are building the expenditures [1:20:15] without the inclusion of the foregone amendment. [1:20:18] Chris talking it. [1:20:19] What did the county do last year [1:20:21] or tried to escape from my mind? [1:20:23] They did a reset. [1:20:25] So there was, [1:20:27] So what occurred is a portion, so there were a series of different things that occurred. [1:20:34] Number one, the county assessors were placed into a very, [1:20:40] very difficult situation when it came to the personal property tax rules. [1:20:45] As you'll recall, the legislative session from the prior year made the first $100,000 exempt. [1:20:51] But they were very pragmatic in their rule making process. [1:20:54] And it was very difficult to see for the counties on what that was going to work and move forward. [1:20:59] That was part of the value. [1:21:01] The second part of the issue was how the Chibani property was assessed and [1:21:07] who got the Chibani property on their tax rule. [1:21:11] So part of that Chibani tax rule appeared on the city and [1:21:16] then the entire amount appeared on the city. [1:21:19] And then rightfully a correction was made and the entire amount was removed. [1:21:26] The Chibani property is located in a tax increment financing district and the property taxes that [1:21:31] are collected from there are used to offset the bond of the public improvements that have [1:21:35] been made to support not only the Chibani development but also all the developments that [1:21:40] have benefited from larger sewer lines, water lines and the like in that geographic area [1:21:46] of our community. [1:21:50] Really, it was a collection of very unfortunate events that really human error is probably [1:21:59] the best way to put it, but I will also tell you that they were playing with or working [1:22:05] in a process that was continually moving and continually being adjusted as a result of changes [1:22:12] and textbooks. [1:22:13] So, like I shared earlier, we do not, the budget that we have constructed so far funds [1:22:23] the strategic planning objectives and does not require any of the use of the foregone balance. [1:22:28] The foregone balance right now remains locked at $1,478,577. [1:22:36] It is eligible upon council action to incorporate into our process at any point in time. [1:22:43] So long as the Idaho legislature permits that from allowing for being allowed to happen. [1:22:50] We are seeing increases in building permits and we are projecting that as you saw we are [1:22:55] outpacing where we were in the prior year of the revenue. [1:22:58] Franchise fees, liquor, portion investment, dedicated monies and grants are all assisting [1:23:06] in those additional revenues and then also we are anticipating in the budget that we will [1:23:12] only use cash reserves for one time capital intensive projects that we could not absorb [1:23:18] into the budget. [1:23:20] The library is a really good example of that. [1:23:23] They're in the process of looking to replace a series of windows, do a PA system, a security [1:23:28] system, and the use of cash reserves that they have in the library fund cash reserves is an [1:23:34] appropriate use. [1:23:35] So we're looking at personnel expenses and we're projecting that personnel expenses [1:23:40] will increase by approximately 9.34%, or by $1.6 million across all funds. [1:23:48] And in the areas that we're looking at, we're looking at a 3% performance and compensation [1:23:53] adjustment for our employees. [1:23:55] We're looking at moving that table. [1:23:57] As we've shared over the course of the last few years, moving that table and keeping up [1:24:01] with market is important. [1:24:03] You'll remember two fiscal years ago, we moved at 8% to get a start. [1:24:09] And last year, we moved at 2%. [1:24:11] And this year, we'll recommend moving at half a percent. [1:24:14] And that represents the fact that we are really beginning on those ends moving up to a place [1:24:20] that is competitive. [1:24:23] But one of the things that is we started looking is that when we start looking at the [1:24:27] compression ratio for our 10-year folks, when we initially built that, we built it based [1:24:32] upon a model that we could afford with existing revenues, not on a best practices model. [1:24:39] And so we had the market number at 10 years. [1:24:42] by best practice standards, a market employee is usually reached by five years. [1:24:47] So we make an adjustment this year to move that, or recommending to move that table from [1:24:53] ten years to five years, and then we will have staggers outside of that to ensure that individuals [1:25:00] are moving through our organization to avoid compression and to recognize the value of tenure. [1:25:09] We budgeted for the city's proportionate share of 7.72% of the health care adjustment and that we have nine employees in the government type funds, 11 employees overall. [1:25:23] That would be new to the organization. [1:25:26] The new employees represent about $626,000 of the $1.6 million. [1:25:33] The deputy prosecuting attorney is one of them and that was actually something that we go through the process and the budget to assign funds. [1:25:40] As you recall, we were able to develop a funding strategy to incorporate the hiring of a deputy city attorney in this fiscal year. [1:25:49] This is a catch up process, if you will, to ensure that we have funding to ensure long-term stability of that position. [1:25:56] Deputy prosecuting attorney. [1:25:57] Deputy prosecuting attorney. [1:25:58] Not a city attorney. [1:25:59] No, he can't go anywhere. [1:26:01] I know. [1:26:01] Wouldn't we have shared that with him? [1:26:02] I just want to make sure folks heard that right. [1:26:04] He's an injured slave. [1:26:06] We've asked for information services tech to position. [1:26:13] One of the things that we're looking at differently is the number of pieces of equipment that [1:26:18] each one of them has to go forward and handle. [1:26:21] We have not added a person in that role in many, many years. [1:26:28] And we continue to grow the number of pieces of technology that we use from data-driven [1:26:34] approaches to computers and cop cars, to GIS, to city works, we have continued to grow the [1:26:44] number of total pieces of technology per capita to a place where it's probably not sustainable [1:26:51] for our techs and therefore we're not allowing them to be successful. [1:26:56] We're looking at incorporating two additional police officers, two additional staff engineers. [1:27:01] One of those individuals is to be funded by the urban and rural agency. [1:27:04] They have already made that commitment for that contribution. [1:27:08] The park's operator position is also very similar to the way we look at computers. [1:27:13] Dennis can tell you that he breaks out the number of park acres that they have per full time employee that they have. [1:27:21] And he has a great model. [1:27:23] We have started to reach that place where in order for us to continue to be efficient, effective, and maintaining our parks. [1:27:29] It's important that we continue to make sure that we have the staffing. [1:27:33] Could you tell me exactly what is a park operator? [1:27:37] Dennis, when we hire individuals from the department, that's the first step they're at a park operator. [1:27:48] They really might say they're a master of all, no, it's the jack of all trades that we have. [1:27:55] I have a jack of all trades where they're out there in the park taking care of the bathroom, taking care of the irrigation, they're mulling, [1:28:01] in the shop to take care of the equipment. [1:28:04] So when we do a rotation on these individuals, [1:28:07] because our next step is a senior operator, [1:28:09] and you can't be a senior operator [1:28:10] until you work three years in our department, [1:28:13] because we figured it takes about three years [1:28:14] that know all the different parks. [1:28:16] We have, out in our system, and the main thing [1:28:20] is a lot of irrigation problems that we might have. [1:28:22] They have to know where everything's at in that park. [1:28:25] So the park operator is just the position [1:28:29] that they start out. [1:28:31] Do they become more specialized as they move up? [1:28:33] Or do we do have certifications that have, you know, [1:28:35] we have some people that are certified in backflow prevention. [1:28:37] We have people certified in arboris. [1:28:39] We have certified pool operators. [1:28:42] All our employees give us spray applicators license. [1:28:45] That's mandatory within the first year of working for us. [1:28:48] So they're kind of a well-rounded. [1:28:49] But we let them after they give their spray applicators license. [1:28:52] Kind of see, we kind of looked at where we might see the need [1:28:55] for other certification to be helpful. [1:28:58] Thank you, Dennis. [1:29:00] Suzanne Hawkins. [1:29:01] Just to add on to that, how many park operators do we have now? [1:29:09] Operators are, I think we have two because there are just two of our newer employees, but [1:29:13] we have total of nine employees in the park site, nine full-time employees. [1:29:19] And just for the record, how many parks do they have to maintain? [1:29:22] Well, many acres maybe. [1:29:24] Yeah. [1:29:25] Well, okay. [1:29:26] We have over 210 manicured acres where we, you know, irrigate and mow and I think the [1:29:34] The National Average Order, National Parks and Recreation, is about 17 acres per full-time [1:29:40] employee. [1:29:41] We've been doing about 19 acres, and now we're at 22 acres until we get down to about 19.5. [1:29:48] And also we have about one seasonal employee for about every 15 acres of magnitude. [1:29:57] Thank you. [1:30:01] The record position is done very, very similar. [1:30:03] In fact, when you take a look at the total number of programs and offerings that we've [1:30:07] We've seen the increase in that portfolio as well as the number of participation and the current staff that we have in order to keep up is using significant over time. [1:30:19] The idea of this is to allow that we have a staff that is allowed being able to sustain the level of effort by the number of individuals that we have in moving forward industry, but street operator position rounds out what we're looking for in the government funds. [1:30:38] So looking at maintenance and operations moving forward by about $263,000 or 7.3%, and you'll see the two of them are in there, and you may not necessarily- [1:30:48] 3.7? [1:30:49] 3.7, sorry. [1:30:51] You'll look at some of these items and you'll question why their operation and maintenance, because they are contracts and contracts for services or professional services that we would bring in. [1:31:01] the professional services side would be the planning and zoning and if we're looking at [1:31:05] doing some comprehensive plan updates, we estimate that cost will be about $80,000. [1:31:12] And then in this, at the beginning of this current fiscal year, there was an increase [1:31:16] to the legal services contract that we have and that is reflected in this upcoming capital. [1:31:27] Capital and the government types funds is looking to increase by about $400,000. [1:31:31] And here is the initial list of capital items that we are looking at moving forward. [1:31:38] They range everything from IS to parks, recreation, to fire, to streets, as well as contingency funding moving forward. [1:31:47] One of the things that we've done in this budget is we've allocated $600,000 towards the engineering, [1:31:53] finding an engineering solution associated with Canyon Springs grade. [1:31:57] We believe that that is an important process. [1:32:00] We also believe that it needs to be a community-driven process as well, to help us find a solution [1:32:06] that is going to meet the needs of the community. [1:32:09] We also believe it's important not necessarily to begin construction of a fix for whatever [1:32:14] that may be until we've done two things, found a funding solution, and two, completed the [1:32:22] improvements down at the wastewater treatment plant. [1:32:26] The completing the wastewater treatment facility will not occur until about a year from December. [1:32:34] So we have about 18 months of construction, which would fall about the middle of the next [1:32:40] fiscal year. [1:32:41] So what we would like to do over the course of the upcoming fiscal year, fiscal year 15, [1:32:46] is that we would like to assemble and have a community-driven process and hire a professional [1:32:52] engineering firm to create a series of solutions as we continue to move forward. [1:32:58] Because after those solutions have been determined, then we need to find a funding strategy. [1:33:03] And that we believe that funding strategy will be expensive. [1:33:08] Chris talking. [1:33:09] On the Canyon Springs grade, you mentioned 600 thou for engineering work. [1:33:15] That's not the actual construction. [1:33:17] That does not include any construction. [1:33:19] We estimate currently that the project could exceed $7 million, depending upon options taken, [1:33:28] and that doesn't require any land acquisition should that be needed to move forward. [1:33:32] You did say $7 million. [1:33:34] Well, I thought an earlier cost had been several, but not seven. [1:33:42] That's why what we want to do is we want to make sure that we are very aware of the different [1:33:48] cost of the different solutions before we proceed in moving forward. [1:33:53] We do not believe that this is going to be an easy construction project and therefore [1:34:01] we believe that we'll probably pay significant dollars to ensure that that project is done. [1:34:10] The other side of the public involvement piece is if we think it's important that through [1:34:15] through their inclusion and through their involvement. [1:34:17] They have a good understanding of all of the different solutions and different options [1:34:21] as well as the cost associated with those. [1:34:24] So when you say 7 million, that's really just... [1:34:26] That's my ballpark. [1:34:27] Yes, yes. [1:34:28] ...guessing until we get this engineer on and really drill down, take a look at different [1:34:34] solutions, different directions, right? [1:34:36] And the type of solution that's placed there. [1:34:39] Right. [1:34:40] I mean, there are probably many, many different types of engineering solutions that you could [1:34:44] come up with. And each one of those solutions is going to have a different price point. And [1:34:49] what will be important for us is to determine the appropriate fix to ensure public safety [1:34:55] with the appropriate price point for something that we could afford moving forward. [1:35:02] Could you back up just a little bit on the fire department ladder truck to be paid with [1:35:06] grant funds and impact fees? Just walk through that room for us. [1:35:09] So, Mandy, our grant writer worked with the fire department and submitted a grant for [1:35:16] a brand new ladder truck. [1:35:17] The ladder truck that we have currently in service is about a 30 year old vehicle. [1:35:22] It's in great shape, but it's 30 years old. [1:35:25] And at some point in time, we really have to look forward to replacing that vehicle. [1:35:30] So we have submitted a grant to FEMA for $800,000 and we would apply the local match of the difference [1:35:38] of about $327,000 with impact fees. [1:35:41] It is an impact fee eligible cost based [1:35:44] upon the impact fee plan CIP that has been previously approved [1:35:49] and will be later discussed by the council. [1:35:52] Don, if we get that grant, that means we've been able [1:35:54] to leverage our impact fees by almost a factor of four, [1:35:57] three and a half, something like that. [1:36:00] Impressive. [1:36:02] One of the things. [1:36:02] I'm just impressed that fire truck is 30 years old. [1:36:07] They keep it in pristine shape. [1:36:08] They do, and that is, I think, a testament [1:36:11] to how they care for their equipment. [1:36:13] You'll also notice that under the general parks improvements, [1:36:16] there's $229,000 of impact fees associated, [1:36:20] not only with the shop, but also with the expansion [1:36:23] of trail systems. [1:36:31] So when we start taking a look at what the budget looks like [1:36:34] in progress by comparison to the budget that was adopted [1:36:38] in the current fiscal year, this is kind of how it runs [1:36:41] moving forward. [1:36:42] And again, we determine the tax rate by taking a look at the total government fund property [1:36:48] tax collections in comparison to the total property tax value. [1:36:53] If that property taxable value continues to grow, we will watch the tax rate continues to shrink. [1:37:04] This is a graphical illustration of how that the budget right now, as it stands, would stack [1:37:11] up by budgets moving forward in the past. [1:37:19] In the Water Fund, we're looking to fund one FTE. [1:37:22] We're looking at a 2% increase to balance the budget, which constitutes about a 75 cent [1:37:28] per month per household for the average water user and that is defined by a person who uses [1:37:34] 18,000 gallons. [1:37:37] We're looking at capital expenditures of about 1,382,000 compared to last years of 1,727,000. [1:37:47] The decrease is because we used $800,000 of cash reserves for the pumps that can't add [1:37:52] to blue lakes and this year we're using only $360,000 of cash. [1:37:58] We're trying to build a capital program that can be sustained with incoming revenues that [1:38:02] does not rely upon cash reserves except for those one-time capital projects moving forward. [1:38:11] One of the things that I want to spend some time talking about with the council is the [1:38:14] use of cash reserves. [1:38:16] And as we've talked in the past, cash reserves should be used when we have those critical [1:38:22] needs and sometimes we can't absorb those into an annual operating budget. [1:38:28] So in the state of Idaho, we have a couple of options. [1:38:30] We can save for projects. [1:38:34] In enterprise funds, we can assess for projects or we can bond for projects. [1:38:40] Those are the three funding vehicles that we have in the user or enterprise type funds. [1:38:46] In the government type funds, they are the same solutions, but the bonding rate is different. [1:38:54] In an enterprise-related fund, it's 50% in any fund that requires the user property taxes. [1:39:01] It's 66% or 2.30%. [1:39:09] We have sufficient cash reserves in an unrestricted account, in my opinion, and also in the opinion [1:39:16] of our CFO who happens to be in Colorado at the moment, to apply cash reserves to a water [1:39:25] reservoir. [1:39:26] And we're looking at about $3 million, or up to three and a half at the maximum outside, [1:39:33] to apply it to the Will's booster station. [1:39:37] And we'll talk about that as we move forward. [1:39:41] This is in addition to the $3.5 million that we spent for the click bar, water tank that [1:39:46] that is currently under design and construction. [1:39:48] When you take a look at the total capital improvements [1:39:50] that we've made outside of the possible use [1:39:53] of $3 million of general fund cash reserves, [1:39:55] we spent almost $9.9 million of cash [1:39:59] expanding and improving our water system [1:40:03] without impacting user rates. [1:40:08] I think that's an incredible testament [1:40:11] to the organization and to the staff and to the council. [1:40:15] So talk to me again about the 3.5 million, $3 million. [1:40:21] The $3.5 million is the cash reserves [1:40:24] that we use to fund the water reservoir out at Hankins [1:40:28] when we required the property. [1:40:30] $3 million project is coming up. [1:40:32] That was a T-use. [1:40:33] That's the clip bar. [1:40:37] Yeah, so it was to the $3.5 million water facility, [1:40:41] not only benefited Clif Bar, but it also benefited [1:40:44] the users in that general area. [1:40:46] Okay, and what's the three million for? [1:40:47] Is for the Will's booster station. [1:40:49] Okay. [1:40:50] Okay, we can't just throw it out [1:40:52] without me asking a question. [1:40:54] It's a tease. [1:40:55] I'm learning up from Josh. [1:40:58] It's a captivating keep your attention. [1:41:01] The sewer fund we're looking at about a 1% increase. [1:41:04] Wait, wait, wait, wait, wait, wait, wait, wait, wait, wait, [1:41:07] wait, wait, wait, wait, wait, wait, wait, wait, wait, wait, [1:41:09] 1% increase about a quarter a month for the average user. [1:41:13] What's important in the sewer fund [1:41:15] when we talk about the efficiencies, [1:41:18] we did not increase the rate last year [1:41:20] to cover any increases associated with operations. [1:41:23] So this is the first operational increase [1:41:28] in two fiscal years. [1:41:29] Now there's a 27% rate increase, but that is for debt. [1:41:32] That is for debt to allow for the expansion. [1:41:35] But in terms of operation, it's 25 cents [1:41:39] in a two year window of time. [1:41:41] I think that talks about the general efficiencies [1:41:43] innovation that our teams are moving forward, and that's for a user that's capped at 8,000 [1:41:50] gallons. So that's where we cap it at. At no point will a residential user ever pay more [1:41:57] than 8,000 gallons. So the maximum could even be less than a quarter. We're looking to find [1:42:05] one new wastewater operator to assist in the areas of collections, and that total capital [1:42:10] expenditures in this year are slightly less than last year. [1:42:16] But what's important to remember is we're also making upwards of a $38 million investment [1:42:21] in our wastewater treatment plants and our collection lines. [1:42:24] So you would expect some of those deficiencies to be caught up with that bonding process. [1:42:32] The sanitation rate is about a 1%, 1.5% increase at constitutes an additional 25 cents per month. [1:42:40] the PSI rate increase is right at 2%. [1:42:45] We continue to negotiate with PSI on that rate. [1:42:48] That is the maximum that rate will come in. [1:42:51] So if you compare the adopted budget and the rate schedule [1:42:56] with what we assess our residents on a monthly basis [1:42:59] for water, sewer, and sanitation, [1:43:01] and you compare that to what this budget represents, [1:43:05] it's a $1.25 increase per month for the average residents. [1:43:10] If you apply just the municipal cost index, [1:43:14] that would be a $2.69 per month fee, [1:43:19] rather than being a fee of $79.99 [1:43:24] to the average user for the upcoming fiscal year, [1:43:27] they would pay $81.43. [1:43:33] So that's the budget. [1:43:36] And then we have some projects [1:43:39] that weren't necessarily met. [1:43:41] So what we did was we went through this process [1:43:44] and we allocated the scariest resources that we had. [1:43:48] We took the 3% and we applied it. [1:43:51] We are incredibly mindful of rates [1:43:53] and what that looked like as we moved forward. [1:43:56] And we recognize that we had, in my opinion, [1:44:00] two significant needs that had not been addressed. [1:44:05] One are our facilities. [1:44:08] And two, the Will's Booster Station. [1:44:12] So what is not reflected in those numbers [1:44:15] Because what it is is an appropriation of cash reserves, [1:44:18] it does not impact taxes, it does not impact user fees, [1:44:21] is the application of tax, of cash reserves [1:44:26] to build or to assist in the expansion [1:44:30] and the renovation of city facilities [1:44:34] and to replace the Will's Booster Station, [1:44:36] which is located out at our South Low Field. [1:44:39] So we've talked about our facilities with you. [1:44:41] The Will's Booster Station might be something, [1:44:44] The Whills Boosters Station is probably one of the single largest unfunded obstacles that [1:44:51] we have south of town to assist with the continued growth and expansion of the new housing starts [1:44:57] in our community. [1:44:58] The Whills Boosters Station is something that we have started the process and recognize as [1:45:03] a need for our organization because in the current budget, I think it's a current budget [1:45:08] right, Jackie? [1:45:09] We paid for the engineering of the facility. [1:45:12] for conceptual design of what that would be in moving forward. [1:45:17] Now I will share that the $3 million wheels booster station [1:45:20] does not complete the project. [1:45:22] It only pays for our portion of that project [1:45:26] that is currently in service and allows for some additional power [1:45:30] feeds and for that facility to be expanded, [1:45:33] which is very common in our approach, [1:45:35] as we've done with the Rock Creek lift station. [1:45:39] So the $3 million doesn't cover the entire project, [1:45:42] but it does the city's share in moving forward. [1:45:47] Just really quickly for those watching at home [1:45:48] that maybe don't understand what a booster station is. [1:45:52] Could you just a quick rendition of what that is? [1:46:00] So when the water is in the reservoir, [1:46:03] it is not under a tremendous amount of pressure. [1:46:06] And in order to provide the right pressure for your house, [1:46:09] when you're close to the reservoir, [1:46:11] so we need to booster stations. [1:46:12] So the booster station's primary purpose is to raise the pressure on the very south side of town so that the people on the south side of town get the right amount of pressure so that they can operate their house just like the people who live a little bit farther down. [1:46:27] And fire flows and those kinds of things as well to our. [1:46:31] Pressure problems is there for everyone and it starts right at household pressure and goes all the way up to fire flow. [1:46:37] Thank you. [1:46:44] Rebecca Milsoy. [1:46:45] Thank you, Mayor. [1:46:46] Could you explain in more detail maybe how this booster station works and what the consequences [1:46:50] of doing nothing for this station, what that would do? [1:46:54] I mean, is this providing for future growth or, you know, what are the mechanics of the [1:47:02] system and who's responsible for providing for increase in pressure increase in the provision [1:47:13] of water for increased growth? [1:47:15] Okay, so currently we have an old station that is working at maximum capacity and diminishing [1:47:25] efficiency. [1:47:28] And so the goal here, the presentation is to replace our piece and the existing piece, [1:47:38] so that looks a little bit like a maintenance project, but it's a big one. [1:47:44] And the remainder, you know, when we do that, we'll be able to put ourselves in a position [1:47:49] where other people can actually come in and buy more pumps and controls and power and the [1:47:56] rest of the things so that growth can continue to occur. [1:48:00] Okay, and how much is that portion that is the maintenance piece? [1:48:06] It's about the same. [1:48:08] It's right at three. [1:48:10] So it's a five and a half to six and a half million dollar job, I believe. [1:48:15] Okay. And so the three million would just be going to the maintenance for this year. [1:48:19] It's our end. Okay. Thank you. [1:48:21] So that's similar to what we've done at Rock Creek lift station and Northeast sewer. [1:48:25] We take care of ourselves and we make provision for growth. [1:48:30] Thank you, Jackie. So that's a really good point. [1:48:33] So this is not a complete and universal fix for the wheels booster station. [1:48:39] Again, like Jackie shared based upon conceptual engineering, [1:48:42] And we believe that that total project may be in the $5.5 billion amount, but this provides [1:48:50] a basis that can be expanded by individuals with those additional pumps and controls as [1:48:56] we shared. [1:48:57] Right. [1:48:58] And as we move forward, we need to make sure that growth is paying for growth and as we're [1:49:01] going to discuss impact fees and so on, just want to make sure that we're providing the [1:49:07] adequate maintenance that we need to maintain the current level of service, but also allowing [1:49:12] our development partners to pay their share too. [1:49:17] And so if you take a look at the total amount of cash reserves that are unrestricted, we [1:49:22] have about $12,700,000 there. [1:49:28] And that excludes $1,066,000 that's in the library fund and again, so when we talk about [1:49:33] applying cash reserves for the library, they're looking at that $250,000 mark of that cash [1:49:39] reserves of a million dollars. [1:49:47] So after we fund these improvements, the question is how much money do we have left in the bank? [1:49:52] And based upon the high side of those costs, you could have about $3.1 million of unrestricted cash available for one-time capital projects. [1:50:04] That excludes the $5,117,000 that we isolate for operations. [1:50:14] the $700,000 that we isolate in the capital improvement plan for unforeseen issues. [1:50:26] And the library cash reserve balance, if that moves forward, would have $816,000. [1:50:32] If they spent the amount that you showed before. [1:50:34] If they did. [1:50:35] For Windows and security measures and the like. [1:50:36] And what's important is some of those items were appropriated in this year's budget. [1:50:41] And if they are unable to complete some of those projects on use library fund because [1:50:48] it's an independent fund, it rolls into the library and then they have the opportunity [1:50:52] to apply for the use of those monies if they were not able to complete those projects as [1:50:57] they had anticipated at the beginning of that fiscal year. [1:51:01] So that really ends our conclusion or concludes the presentation until July 7th. [1:51:11] So what we want to do is we want to see what we missed. [1:51:15] Because we miss things of significant nature. [1:51:18] We need to go back to the lab and have a conversation about what [1:51:21] that looks like and have a conversation with the council [1:51:25] about what may not be able to be included or some of the things [1:51:29] that we've funded as we move forward. [1:51:32] Before we start adding, I really do [1:51:34] want to win both Sean and Greg are back and able to participate. [1:51:41] we can sit down with them because we certainly want to get there. [1:51:44] I know you had that mind, but I wanted to say that in public that we're going to make sure [1:51:48] that we engage all seven members of the council. [1:51:50] Chris talking to. [1:51:53] Well, my thoughts are the capital requests like a tsunami. [1:51:59] They're just almost overwhelming. [1:52:01] We're blessed with good reserves. [1:52:03] And I guess there's a plan that we could begin or make good progress on many of them [1:52:11] and still have a fairly healthy reserve. [1:52:13] I don't know as a percentage of the budget [1:52:17] if that is above or below where we want to be, [1:52:21] but I recognize that we're frugal for a reason [1:52:24] that's now helping us on the Capitol. [1:52:27] I wanted to start back with something [1:52:29] that kept my head around a little bit easier, [1:52:30] though back on page seven where we're dealing [1:52:34] with tax support and enterprise funds. [1:52:38] And we were shown a chart that shows the lower lap down corner, [1:52:43] about 952,000 just to maintain inflation, I think. [1:52:50] Follow me there. [1:52:54] And we are conceiving that there could be 565,000 from tax support, [1:53:06] and about 387 from enterprise funding. [1:53:10] But of that 565,000 to keep up with inflation, about 244,000 I think you're forecasting from growth. [1:53:22] No, so let me shift. [1:53:27] If we did, this is not a look at revenues, this is a look at just expenditures. [1:53:33] And if we did not change our operations, we didn't add new police officers. [1:53:38] We didn't do anything differently in terms of parks or recreation or street or road maintenance. [1:53:47] And we offered the same menu services that we offer today. [1:53:51] We would need to have $565,000 more revenue to offer the same pallet of services based [1:53:59] upon the municipal cost index for the government fund and 387,000 in the total enterprise fund [1:54:06] and that's based upon their total expenses. [1:54:09] And if it's page six, the upper right-hand corner I was off a little bit, but that's, so [1:54:15] I was confusing a revenue with expenses. [1:54:18] Yeah, the municipal cost index is an economic indicator that just looks at the value of our [1:54:24] dollar. [1:54:25] And we measure inflation in local government. [1:54:30] Well, my general observation of the council, [1:54:32] I know we need to study this, [1:54:34] but because we had a fleeting discussion prior [1:54:39] about the use of uncaptured funds still available, [1:54:44] I think to provide direction to the council [1:54:49] or to the city manager early on, [1:54:51] we need to resolve among the seven of us [1:54:54] if there is a majority in favor of tapping [1:54:57] those foregone balances or not, [1:55:00] because we can waste a lot of time in his time [1:55:03] of making suppositions that may or may not come about. [1:55:07] So, I think that's one of the council's first directors on. [1:55:13] I agree with that, Chris. [1:55:13] And I think they all should weigh in on that. [1:55:16] Okay. [1:55:17] And then obviously continue [1:55:18] because two members aren't here. [1:55:19] Yeah, we need a full contention of us here [1:55:22] to make that decision. [1:55:23] Absolutely. [1:55:24] Rebecca, Mel, so I can. [1:55:25] Thank you here. [1:55:26] Thank you, Travis, for your presentation. [1:55:29] I appreciate all of the items that you've included from the council. [1:55:35] I think that the only place where I would exercise some caution is with the five to six and a half million of reserves in city facilities. [1:55:45] I certainly support addressing deferred maintenance. [1:55:48] I think that's just a job that we need to do. [1:55:53] As far as what it looks like to relocate a city hall and build a city hall. [1:55:59] I think just like the Canyon Springs grade needs to be involved in the public and [1:56:06] involving their perspective, I think that this equally large capital expense, [1:56:12] it needs to involve the public in the same way. [1:56:16] And I think that I would feel better about making that expense, [1:56:22] knowing that the public understands or is supportive or is not supportive, and [1:56:27] what they would like to see, because I can appreciate that the long-term planning committee [1:56:34] has seen these space needs and they need to be addressed. [1:56:38] I just don't know what that will look like right now, and I think we're moving for me [1:56:43] a little bit fast to find a location and build right now, although we've had this space [1:56:52] needs study since 2007, one that I wasn't aware of until just a month or two ago, even [1:57:00] though we had the conversation about six months ago for the strategic plan, we had an objective [1:57:06] to build a new city hall and we took it out because the report from staff, the report from [1:57:12] the committee, the council committee was that we don't need a larger city hall. [1:57:17] So for me this has been all a bit quick to move to all of a sudden we need to build a new city hall. [1:57:23] And so I think we need to back up and maybe just take our time. [1:57:27] And certainly budget plan for the expenses in the budget for this. [1:57:34] But maybe take some more time identifying the specifics. [1:57:39] And so we don't make any rash decisions. [1:57:41] We don't make any rush to buy the first property that comes before us or [1:57:45] the first project that's that's sold to us we need to take our time and make sure it's [1:57:49] the right move for the community and for the city because I'm a little bit cautious to spend [1:57:57] between seven and nine million dollars in our reserves, leaving us about three million. [1:58:02] I guess maybe I've just been used to those reserves being higher and it's given us great opportunities [1:58:09] with Chobani with all of the economic development projects that come in. [1:58:14] are in a good position to fulfill whatever needs we have when those recruitments come. [1:58:21] And so I would just also feel better if we need to make an amendment to our strategic plan [1:58:29] to say, hey, in light of new circumstances, we want to add the fact that we have space needs [1:58:36] and we need a city hall. [1:58:38] I would feel better as the whole presentation indicated, [1:58:42] Our budget needs to be driven by the strategic plan. [1:58:46] And I don't feel comfortable spending, you know, six to seven million dollars on an item that is really not in our strategic plan. [1:58:54] And in the last conversations that we had, we had deleted that from our strategic plan. [1:58:59] So, you know, if we need to make an amendment and reassess, I would be certainly supportive of that. [1:59:05] But I don't feel good about spending that much money in our budget when it is not driven by the strategic plan [1:59:12] Thank you Rebecca before I forget. I think you know, but you have radio this week. Yes, and I'm sure we'll talk about that [1:59:22] I do agree with Rebecca we shouldn't [1:59:27] Quickly and brash in regards to these [1:59:31] space needs I [1:59:32] I guess I'm going to look at this from a completely different perspective. [1:59:35] We haven't been a city employee for 31 years. [1:59:37] The police department is in an abysmal state. [1:59:40] We need to move forward with this. [1:59:42] I think that the public, whereas we are elected by the community to make decisions for them, [1:59:47] I think that there is a very clear and definitive need to have those areas fixed. [1:59:56] We have over 105 to 110 men and women working in a building [2:00:01] that was designed for 45. [2:00:04] The city hall, I can sit up here all evening [2:00:07] and tell stories about things breaking in city hall, [2:00:10] watching Mitch Humboldt, sitting in the city managers, [2:00:13] always with me, and the furnace turned on [2:00:15] and it blew stuff all over the front of him. [2:00:18] And Tom and I thought it was funny, [2:00:19] but he didn't think it was funny. [2:00:22] Our heating, we owe it to our community [2:00:25] give them a place to come in and do business and do business effectively. [2:00:35] It's not a dirty word to say that we should help our city employees work in an environment [2:00:40] that creates that synergy that helps us provide better service to our community. [2:00:46] I think that we have a fine staff of employees led by the city manager who have put together [2:00:53] a plan that will help resolve many of these issues and I want to see the plan as they say [2:01:03] but I do support you in your endeavor, I do support your staff, I have seen it with my [2:01:07] own eyes working here for the last, my whole life and let's get this done, let's quit screwing [2:01:14] around with it. [2:01:22] Yes, I was going to go, but I was going to go first. [2:01:24] I have to make it there so. [2:01:26] Suzanne Hawkins. [2:01:27] Thank you again, Travis, and everybody who's worked so hard on putting this together for us. [2:01:32] I'm comfortable with what you've presented to us tonight. [2:01:35] I feel like you're on the right track. [2:01:37] I think you guys have done a great job doing your research and putting together a complete budget. [2:01:42] I'm anxious to get down into the nitty gritty now and see all the little things that come along with the bigger package. [2:01:50] But I agree that the 3% is where we are headed and I think everything you've presented to us tonight. I'm in agreement with [2:01:58] Thank you, Suzanne. I'd like to weigh in now the my primary [2:02:03] Thoughts when it came to this year's budget were [2:02:07] four different areas one is the space needs [2:02:12] basically [2:02:14] buildings where we can house and put our employees in a safe [2:02:19] safe, healthy environment that they can not only engage each other, but they can, as Councilman [2:02:26] Munn said, engage the community, community has a place to come and have that synergy where [2:02:31] if I want to talk to someone in building, I can talk to them and then just walk down the [2:02:36] hallway and talk to somebody in the economic development if I want to, instead of going [2:02:40] clear across town, splintered buildings and all those inefficiencies that we see with that. [2:02:48] So that's one of my primary focuses. [2:02:53] Another primary focus that I have personally is the Canyon Springs grade. [2:02:57] I was on it last night actually, I went down and walked Ogra Falls and drove that grade [2:03:04] and saw the dozens of people walking up and down it. [2:03:09] And that is a safety issue that we need to address. [2:03:13] I certainly appreciate the city manager and your staff's ability to slow me down a little [2:03:18] bit in the sense of trying to get some ideas and engineering studies to see exactly what [2:03:24] we can do to that grade for that grade, for that canyon wall to make our area safer that's [2:03:32] being used by a lot of folks. [2:03:34] So you have that in the budget, you have the space needs in the budget. [2:03:39] area is employee compensation. It's all about recruitment. We recruited four tonight, [2:03:46] four, and retention. And the only way we're going to be able to do those two things together, [2:03:54] and we had some retention too. We were able to give some basic and intermediate certificates [2:03:59] to some of our police officers. That means we're retaining them. It's incredibly important [2:04:04] for our organization to retain our employees. And one of the ways that you do that is healthy [2:04:09] work environment and back up a little bit. Police Department, I agree with Jim, is in [2:04:16] terrible shape. It needs help. And one of the ways that we can do that is making this a [2:04:23] public service, public safety complex, if you will, across the street here. But getting [2:04:30] back to the compensation is we need to stay on top of that. You have a plan here, at least [2:04:36] preliminary that's addressing some of those needs of compression and I think we've made [2:04:42] great strides in the last few years and this is an area that we can't slow down on because [2:04:48] I think we've slowed down on it before and we've found ourselves in the state shape that [2:04:52] we're in today and we can't, we've got to stay on top of that. [2:04:55] And then of course the Will's booster station. [2:04:58] You have some money put towards that along with the community engagement regarding that. [2:05:05] I agree with Chris that the foregone probably needs to be a conversation, but I'm feeling [2:05:09] much more comfortable backing off personally from the foregone because of your budget that [2:05:15] you have at least preliminarily shared with us this evening, unless there's a surprise. [2:05:21] I still believe that the foregone amount is out there. [2:05:24] It's for a situation that is a half to and maybe that's a direction that we go once we [2:05:32] figure out the plan for Canyon Springs but this year it's not you don't have it [2:05:37] designed in this preliminary information that you've given us tonight Travis I [2:05:43] think it's a well-crafted well-designed and well presented to us this evening I [2:05:48] feel very comfortable with this direction taking into three percent not the [2:05:53] foregone at least at this point and addressing those four areas that I have [2:05:58] outlined. Anything further from the Council regarding Mr. Rothweiler's presentation? [2:06:05] I'm assuming all the Council does not agree to your entire mail ticket. I'm [2:06:13] assuming that you have some prioritization for reduction in either tax revenues [2:06:22] is available for gons and or capital. I'm just having a lot of difficult time thinking [2:06:33] about 7 million on that canyon road and pulling down our reserves that much. But I'm assuming [2:06:40] you're a smart enough guy. I know that you probably have this will be the first thing [2:06:44] that will have to defer for another year and you don't have to relate those to us. Sometimes [2:06:51] City managers don't get everything they want in the budget. [2:06:54] Well, certainly. [2:06:57] I think that when you take a look at the overall budget, [2:07:01] and that's why we isolated those items outside of it, [2:07:04] I think that the overall budget that moves forward [2:07:10] is something that reflects what the council had originally [2:07:15] talked about at the beginning of the year, [2:07:16] We're using the 3% not taking the floor gone balance, honoring the commitment to our city [2:07:23] employees. [2:07:25] All of those things are in that first collection and that's why we separated it. [2:07:30] The use of reserves is really something that can be applied and used at any time. [2:07:38] As long as we take those steps to budget and move those forward. [2:07:43] So what we have here is a 3% increase in taxable revenue which is allowed by the state statute. [2:07:52] It does not require the use of any foregone balances at all and those would remain intact. [2:07:58] And how we move forward with the expenditure of cash reserves will largely be probably where [2:08:03] I see the conversation and the discussion moving forward. [2:08:07] I think that there are certainly lots of different solutions, [2:08:15] as opposed to the one that may be conceptually presented here. [2:08:22] I do believe, though, that the police department [2:08:26] is the single largest, most important facility [2:08:31] that needs to be addressed. [2:08:33] And how we address that really determines [2:08:36] how long that solution is good for. [2:08:40] So that's part of the conversation. [2:08:43] And the use of cash reserves, again, [2:08:45] is a nice conversation because it can almost [2:08:49] be done by itself. [2:08:52] Because it does not impact tax rates. [2:08:54] It does not impact user fees. [2:08:57] And it does not do any of that. [2:08:59] It's cash that we have in the bank. [2:09:01] It's savings that has been accumulated. [2:09:03] And how we determine that can be almost done [2:09:06] in a separate conversation. [2:09:09] We're back in a second. [2:09:10] Thank you, Mayor. [2:09:12] Is there a way that you can break down [2:09:15] the different components and prioritize [2:09:18] the different components of the police station [2:09:20] that need to address? [2:09:21] And are there things that you can work on now? [2:09:23] I mean, even if we were to start building [2:09:25] a new city hall today, obviously, it would take a year or so. [2:09:29] So are there items that you can start to address? [2:09:32] I mean, maybe some of the things that Jim is talking about, [2:09:34] some of the, you know. [2:09:36] No, not without an eye in terms of what the total solution is going to be, because they're also, when you start down the path, how you remodel the police station largely depends to what you do to the existing space in City Hall. [2:09:56] So if you allow the police department to come and turn that into a public safety building, [2:10:04] that fundamentally changes how we reconstruct the existing police department. [2:10:13] If that is not something that is palatable and approved by the council, then we look [2:10:19] at what can we do with the existing structure? [2:10:22] do we rather than renovate, do we create and expand and do? [2:10:26] Does that mean that we have to go into Jerome Street, [2:10:30] isolate, remove those utilities, close that roadway, [2:10:34] and move forward? [2:10:36] I do not believe that we can encroach into the parking lot, [2:10:40] because parking is already a difficult issue. [2:10:43] So really, if you grow and expand the building, [2:10:46] you grow it generally to the north and generally to the east. [2:10:51] That has implications in terms of access and through streets and those type of things. [2:10:57] And the fixes in the police department, if you recall, this conversation came up about a [2:11:02] year ago from tonight when we were moving forward because we had money appropriated in [2:11:09] the budget to do the first of a five phase police renovation project. [2:11:17] We knew at the time that that project would buy us about five years and we felt comfortable [2:11:24] at the time spending what we believe, based upon architectural conversations, about $500,000 [2:11:31] on a five-year solution because we have found that five-year solutions, like the Hanson Building, [2:11:37] tend to grow into seven, eight, nine-year solutions. [2:11:43] In those bids for the first initial phases came in equal to the entire project, we asked [2:11:49] the council to reject all bids and allow us to go back to that drawing board, because [2:11:56] the additional phases may exceed a million dollars. [2:12:01] So when we take a look at renovations and renovating renovation costs, they are significantly less [2:12:06] than new construction costs. [2:12:08] So when we look at, and we'll go through our process, [2:12:13] but we can't do it alone. [2:12:15] And I can't, and when I say we can't do it alone, [2:12:17] we don't have architects on staff to assist in that. [2:12:21] And so if you look at creating X number of square feet [2:12:26] based upon a new square footage, [2:12:30] based upon a value of $140 to $170 a square foot, [2:12:35] by comparison to our model costs [2:12:37] that maybe somewhere between half to 75% of that, [2:12:43] you start seeing, well, what are those maximum opportunities? [2:12:47] And so in terms of just starting on the locker room today, [2:12:52] in order to build and expand the locker room, [2:12:54] we have to go into the officers meeting room [2:12:58] and meeting space where they're currently at right now. [2:13:01] And we have to find a place to put them [2:13:05] and knocking down walls may be an option [2:13:09] and growing that complex, it may not be the best option. [2:13:13] So, if you give us the opportunity, [2:13:16] we'll continue to do the due diligence [2:13:18] and I think that we would welcome community tours. [2:13:23] We would welcome community involvement. [2:13:28] We think that the community needs to be part of the solution. [2:13:31] Absolutely. [2:13:32] And then to follow up. [2:13:33] So can you give some examples of what are some things? [2:13:35] So you're talking about remodeling, but what are some of the things that are dangerous or an emergency situation that are not healthy for employees? [2:13:46] So I think that I would invite you to do the locker rooms in the police department. [2:13:52] Travis, would you mind letting Jim weigh in on that? [2:13:58] Either myself or Brian, we had environmental scientists looking in our roof because of mold issues. [2:14:06] Remember that, Brian, and we were causing some sort of distress to our records of personnel. [2:14:11] I remember that right before I retired. [2:14:14] I don't think we ever resolved it unless we go in there and gut it. [2:14:19] We have inadequate locker rooms for the women in the, there's not enough room for our women police officers. [2:14:26] There's inadequate jump in here chief. [2:14:31] There's inadequate ventilation systems for our drug vaults and so forth that we need to [2:14:36] make sure that we have that done properly. [2:14:38] Get on up there chief. [2:14:39] I've been gone for three years so I'm sure things have gone even worse since you were [2:14:43] there. [2:14:47] Crime lab issues on and on and on if we want to get into this tonight. [2:14:51] Chief, I could you weigh in please. [2:14:52] Well, you know, I think that Councilman Munna is correct. [2:14:57] I mean, these problems still exist over there. [2:15:00] And probably, if anything, are not getting any better. [2:15:03] We're simply running out of room. [2:15:05] The locker room is just not functional anymore. [2:15:08] It wasn't one time. [2:15:09] You know, at this point, we're out of locker space. [2:15:12] We literally don't have lockers for the people [2:15:14] that we're going to hire. [2:15:15] There's no room. [2:15:17] So what we're doing is we're vacating lockers [2:15:19] from people that have what we consider [2:15:21] to be a less priority for the need for the locker, [2:15:23] but they still have the shower facilities [2:15:26] aren't adequate for them. [2:15:28] And that's actually important when [2:15:30] you think about the role that our men and women play. [2:15:32] It's not uncommon for them to be exposed [2:15:34] to biological hazards in the field. [2:15:37] So when they come in, having some place [2:15:39] to be able to take their clothes off at shower, [2:15:43] a very important part of it, much better than going home [2:15:45] or taking their clothes home, things like that. [2:15:49] But the ventilation is an issue, you know, that there's that false floor above the ceiling. [2:15:54] I would encourage anyone to look up there and see, you know, it's really literally years [2:16:00] and years and years of the environment. [2:16:03] So going back into the cell, was it a comment for? [2:16:06] They were venting, when we were processing evidence, what those guys would do is they [2:16:10] would vent the processing material, be it an adhydrant stuff, whatever that came out. [2:16:19] into the false ceiling between the false ceiling, no regular one. [2:16:24] So it's up there and it could make our people very, very sick. [2:16:27] In fact, it did cause some issues with records personnel. [2:16:30] I remember that we had to try to address it. [2:16:32] Actually, we were never able to figure out [2:16:35] why that they were claiming they were good. [2:16:40] We did have a number of environmental signs. [2:16:42] I mean, some research done on it. [2:16:47] It's really just about a space need. [2:16:49] There's I think about 13,000 square feet in that building [2:16:53] And we're utilizing every bit of that space that we can. [2:16:58] We called it the Winchester Mystery House, [2:16:59] because we would remodel it about every five to 10 years [2:17:03] and go, wow, that was nice. [2:17:04] But you still don't have any room here. [2:17:06] And we know in the future we're going to go. [2:17:08] I guess the real challenge is we'll continue to grow. [2:17:11] We'll have to grow as our population grows. [2:17:14] The big question is where are we going to go? [2:17:18] Do we bring in? [2:17:19] Maybe you bring in a, I've kind of joked about this. [2:17:22] the point you bring a mobile home in, put it in the. [2:17:25] Modular unit. [2:17:26] Yeah, modular space, something, but at some point, if you don't address your space needs [2:17:32] as we continue to grow and add bodies, we have to put it somewhere. [2:17:37] Chris, talking. [2:17:38] I don't think they make bulletproof modular as I know where you're doing. [2:17:42] Well, listen, I don't think I've ever met a council person that's not driven by our public [2:17:48] safety portion of our mission. And this is certainly a predominant issue that's kind of [2:17:55] getting worse at Jim, as pointed out, and Brian's reaffirmed. [2:18:00] Nonetheless, I've never known a budget time when there is enough money for everything. [2:18:06] We have to make hard decisions. But the public safety issue demonstrated by the outmoded [2:18:14] overgrown, under-protected police department is, I think, a very legitimate and a sellable [2:18:21] one to the public that will drive our decisions. It will also, in necessity, drive decisions [2:18:28] about the city hall because they're just not compatible to do one without moving the other. [2:18:33] And Brian, I'm not pointing this at the police department, I'm making a general observation [2:18:39] about the budget that there's just no way we can fund everything, but the public service [2:18:45] issue is the driver for me. I also look at the remaining cognizant that the city taxpayers [2:18:52] have funded a $38 million bond, 30-year bond for the sewer expansion. They put a lot of trust [2:19:00] in us that this was important for the safety and the growth of the community. And I see that [2:19:06] They're kind of related in a way, but I also see some issues that I just has them on the [2:19:14] cash reserve side that we can do that all in one year. [2:19:19] Nonetheless, I think the police department should drive pretty much all capital expenditures [2:19:25] this year. [2:19:26] Councilman, one of the challenges that we have, and I agree with everything that you said, [2:19:31] one of the challenges, you know, how do we, you know, we've looked at this in a number [2:19:34] of ways. How do we make this work? What's the most effective and efficient way to make this [2:19:40] work? Do we expand? Do we vacate a road? Do we add on to our existing building? It really [2:19:45] does make some sense. It seems to be somewhat progressive in allowing us to take over that [2:19:50] campus and to utilize that entire space. Station One, we know we'll not move. We have a communication [2:19:57] center that would be very difficult to move. So we've got some anchors in that property. [2:20:02] It does seem to make sense to us at least logically, but we're willing to probably explore every, you know, possibility, so. [2:20:08] Rebecca, I'm going to start again. [2:20:10] Thank you, Mayor. [2:20:11] Well, I thank you, Chief, for sharing that with us and with the public. [2:20:14] I think it's good to know and maybe more to Councilman Talkington's point. [2:20:18] You know, I think for me, it's more with the timing, not that I doubt the importance of the needs or the existence of the needs. [2:20:25] I think I just want to take a good amount of time to assess the different opportunities. [2:20:30] like you're saying, there are a lot of different options and maybe we've only been looking [2:20:36] at one. I would just like to make sure that we vet all our opportunities and those opportunities [2:20:42] may not have come up yet. I mean, certainly there's been opportunities in the past that [2:20:46] we've turned down. But now that we're saying, you know, we have these space needs and we [2:20:50] need to move forward and consider that our options, you know, it may take another year [2:20:57] and we may have to work within the confines of the situation that we have, because certainly [2:21:05] it didn't happen overnight, and certainly we can all agree that somehow this issue of [2:21:11] deferred maintenance or not addressing our facilities has just piled up over time. [2:21:18] But I know I've been here for the past three years, and this is the first that I've heard [2:21:24] of it. [2:21:25] And in the first conversation that we had, you know, the message was, no, for the foreseeable [2:21:30] future, we don't have, you know, space needs or, I mean, and I'm just remembering the strategic [2:21:35] planned conversation where there were no red flags, you know, brought up. [2:21:39] And so now we're saying we're at a critical do or die situation, but somehow it didn't [2:21:45] come up in steps. [2:21:47] steps. [2:21:48] I think it came up in steps, but the connection that I see is we thought that we had a good [2:21:55] plan with the police department remodeled to get us for a period of time. [2:21:59] And so when we looked at that as a viable solution, we were able to say, maybe not now. [2:22:06] When this came up as maybe a much different scenario than what architects shared with us, [2:22:13] that we had hired to go forward. [2:22:15] We were a bit astonished, I think. [2:22:18] He was really mad when the bids came in double of what we thought that they were. [2:22:24] And we saw the entire concept that was created almost evaporate before us. [2:22:33] And the solution still exists. [2:22:35] The city can spend in excess of a million dollars and we can buy another temporary solution. [2:22:44] temporary, we have a tendency to really make use of the spaces that we have. [2:22:52] What that looks like as we move forward is certainly something that I think the staff [2:22:58] needs to do a really good job in sharing why and what the different options may be and [2:23:08] the cost of those options and then move that forward. [2:23:13] That's why we've removed them from the budgeting process in a sense because cash reserves can [2:23:19] be incorporated without, again, any impact to tax rates or user rates as the council sees fit moving forward. [2:23:30] Certainly, and like you're saying, whether the remodel went forward or not, you still have the space confined, so to speak. [2:23:41] you have your square footage and that wasn't going to change whether you remodeled or not. [2:23:46] So that's certainly understandable. [2:23:49] You know I don't want to be labored this but I just need to address a couple things. [2:23:52] We've known about the space needs issues with our police department and our city hall for [2:23:57] many years. [2:23:58] When I came on city council in 2006 we were talking about it. [2:24:01] We had architectural plans of remodeling city hall and doing some things with the police department. [2:24:09] So this is not a surprise to me. [2:24:11] This has been ongoing, it's an issue, we've been told about it, we've taken tours, I'm [2:24:17] just frankly, I'm at the stage now, I don't want to make any more temporary band-aid approaches [2:24:23] to these issues. It's time to have the courage to make the right decision, and I'll just [2:24:29] leave it, I don't want to be labored just anymore. Anything else for our City Manager? [2:24:34] Council with your permission, I'm going to give us a five minute break, I know that we [2:24:38] We have a public import section and city manager, city council section, and then we have a public [2:24:43] hearing as well as an executive session. [2:24:46] But I think that we've been at this for two hours and 15 minutes and it's time for us to [2:24:51] take a eight minute break. [2:24:55] Thanks Travis. [2:34:32] The island. [2:34:34] I'd like to reconvene the meeting of the Twin Falls City Council, June 9th, it is 726.5. [2:34:42] Next item on the agenda under items for consideration still is public input and or items for city manager and city council. [2:34:49] Is there anyone from the public that would like to address the council this evening? [2:34:56] City manager. [2:34:57] Mr. Mayor and members of the council, just two quick items, just number one. [2:35:01] Because we will not have a quorum, we will not be meeting next week. [2:35:06] We will resume our regular meeting schedule on the 23rd. [2:35:12] And the next item is to remind you, and because we will not be meeting next week that on the 24th, [2:35:19] and we'll send out another email reminder, which is a Tuesday, that we will be having a retirement celebration for [2:35:25] Dwayne Thompson, who has served with the leader of our building department. [2:35:30] He has made the decision to retire, so we invite you and the community to come to that. [2:35:35] But we'll also send out additional meeting notices to make sure that you are aware. [2:35:41] Thank you, Travis. [2:35:43] Suzanne Hawkins. [2:35:44] Thank you. [2:35:46] I just want to say a big thank you to our police department [2:35:48] for hosting the first bicycle road ago this past Saturday. [2:35:52] Some of my grandkids, of course, got to go out and I spent [2:35:54] some time out there talking to the officers and watching how [2:35:58] everything worked together. [2:36:00] And it was fantastic. [2:36:01] It was a great event that not only taught the kids safety, [2:36:04] but there were businesses that partnered and helped [2:36:07] with checking tires, checking breaks, checking their helmets and making sure they understood [2:36:13] hand signals and just basic bicycle safety and it was fantastic and I know it takes a lot [2:36:18] of work and a lot of energy to put those things together and I don't want to say thank you [2:36:22] to all the businesses because I will probably miss somebody but if you get a chance look [2:36:27] at the city's website, check it out and remember to thank our partners in the community who [2:36:31] help make those things successful. [2:36:34] If you don't mind, I'd like to clarify. [2:36:36] It's not our first. [2:36:37] We've had bicrodeos for years. [2:36:39] But it's probably our first in a long time. [2:36:41] I've never seen them. [2:36:44] Some bicrodeos. [2:36:46] Yeah, these were probably way better than what we did. [2:36:50] Yeah, I can remember one of Pennywise's drill. [2:36:53] I'll get Penny if you can remember Pennywise's drill. [2:36:55] Yeah, they've been around for a while, but it just happened. [2:36:57] I don't think we've done some in a while, chief. [2:37:01] Oh, just because people were listening. [2:37:08] Chief. [2:37:08] This is really, Officer Matt Triner put this together. [2:37:11] Was his vision, was his dream. [2:37:13] It was really one that we hosted ourselves. [2:37:15] We have done bike rodeos in the past. [2:37:17] Actually, we did one a couple weeks ago with Chick-fil-A. [2:37:20] This was Twin Falls Police Department bike rodeo. [2:37:24] And it was really, it made us look really, really bad. [2:37:28] Our old rodeos, because Matt- [2:37:32] Oh, they made our old ones look bad. [2:37:33] Yeah, I did a great job. [2:37:34] It was a great time. [2:37:35] They did a really good job. [2:37:36] So, all right. [2:37:38] Thank you, Chief. [2:37:39] Chris Donghy. [2:37:40] Is this time for Council input? [2:37:42] Yes, sir. [2:37:43] Okay, well, two items to update the Council on. [2:37:46] First concerning the airport, [2:37:50] several of us were out at the airport last Friday, [2:37:53] wasn't it, Tuesday, Thursday. [2:37:56] Our new jet service arrived complete with water cannon [2:38:00] and everything. [2:38:01] I don't know what the passengers thought [2:38:03] when they saw the water cannon, [2:38:04] but that was a great service. [2:38:06] The second is dealing with the terminal expansion, [2:38:09] as you recall, despite the cat back [2:38:14] in our boarding seats availability from about 120 to 100, [2:38:20] the airport commission is proceeding [2:38:22] with an 8,000 square foot expansion of the terminal. [2:38:26] We have an architect who has met with us several time [2:38:30] and provides several concepts. [2:38:33] last airport board meeting last week, one concept had been modified several times was [2:38:39] approved that will provide additional TSA screening and in a greatly large waiting area for people, [2:38:49] whether we have one, two or three commercial services. [2:38:52] It will be very unprecedented when it is completed because it will have a rolled aerodrome [2:39:01] look to it like you see in some airports. [2:39:03] So sometime when you're out the airport drop in [2:39:06] and talk to the city manager to the airport manager [2:39:08] and he can show you the proposed drawings of the thing. [2:39:11] I think it can be pretty pleased. [2:39:12] The other item is the Twin Falls downtown [2:39:15] urban renewal project. [2:39:17] We had sent out 17 requests for qualifications [2:39:21] of designers and planners and have received seven back. [2:39:26] And this morning after spending the weekend, [2:39:30] Each of us individually looking at the qualifications, [2:39:34] we narrowed that to three, [2:39:36] and those three firms will be here the last week of June [2:39:42] for review by the same committee to decide [2:39:45] the finalist to handle the project [2:39:48] and interface with the engineering department [2:39:51] for that 10 million dollar project. [2:39:55] Thank you, Chris. [2:39:56] Speaking of urban renewal agency, [2:39:57] I had the privilege of being at their meeting today, [2:40:01] I just wanted to report to folks that Cindy Bond, Dr. Cindy Bond from the college CSI. [2:40:08] This was her last day on the urban renewal after seven years of volunteerism. [2:40:13] She's the current chairperson and she, today was her last day and we were able to give her [2:40:17] a plaque and some flowers and I just want to publicly again say thank you to Dr. Bond [2:40:22] for her service in our community. [2:40:26] Yeah. [2:40:27] Anything else from council? [2:40:28] All right. [2:40:30] We're going to move right along to the public hearing, which is consideration of a request [2:40:34] to amend the Twin Falls Vision 2030, a comprehensive plan for a sustainable future to update Chapter [2:40:43] 11, Development Impact Fee, Capital Improvement Plans, and we have our City Planner, City [2:40:52] Economic Development Director. [2:40:54] No. [2:40:55] Community Development Director Mitch Humboldt. We have so many directors. Got it [2:41:02] at the end. The end one was right there. I've been asked to be briefed by several [2:41:09] people so I'm trying to be brief and then ask me your questions as they come up. [2:41:15] We adopted our impact fee program. It started collecting fees in August of 2009. [2:41:21] According to state law we need to have an update of our CIP every five years or [2:41:25] so we wanted to prepare this one in time to get it going before August of 2014 and I think [2:41:32] we're pretty well on track for that. So we spent a lot of time starting probably last summer [2:41:41] working internally at staff and then working with our impact fee advisory committee to come [2:41:46] up with this recommendation that we're going to share with you tonight. Generally speaking, [2:41:52] There's a lot that's the same. [2:41:54] There's not a lot of tweaking going on, but there is some. [2:41:58] And I think it's fair to go over the tweaks [2:42:01] and what they might do for our program. [2:42:05] Let's see if I can get this to come up. [2:42:15] Everything that I'm gonna show you is in the packet too [2:42:17] because that looks really small. [2:42:19] I'm not hoping it would look bigger. [2:42:22] But anyway, so the first thing I'm gonna go over [2:42:24] is the police CIP. [2:42:26] We collect impact fees for four different areas, [2:42:28] Police Fire Community Park in streets. [2:42:32] So far streets have been traffic signals, [2:42:34] but we'll talk with that a little more. [2:42:36] So I'm gonna go over the police one first. [2:42:38] And what I've highlighted here are some of the changes [2:42:40] that we're gonna see in the upcoming or the proposed CIB. [2:42:44] The first one at the top of the list [2:42:46] is obvious we're just looking at five more years. [2:42:48] So you should say 2017, now it says 2023. [2:42:53] It's a 10 year plan from today looking forward for 10 years. [2:42:56] The last one was a 10-year plan, so we're kind of halfway through. [2:42:59] We adjust them and tweak them. [2:43:02] That's important, because in the police one and in the fire, [2:43:04] one will see some changes that are due directly because [2:43:08] of the change in the how years of the plan. [2:43:11] The first change on here is actually [2:43:13] one of those, the 5,220 square feet of additional police [2:43:17] station is because we're looking at five more years of growth. [2:43:19] That number went up from 3,000 and some five years ago. [2:43:23] We're having five more years of growth. [2:43:26] We're adding five more years of hiring new officers, [2:43:28] so more square footage per officer [2:43:30] is needed for the handling that growth. [2:43:32] And then the revised cost based on that new square footage. [2:43:40] The same reasons behind the $375,000 [2:43:44] for the communication center. [2:43:45] Again, adding more growth, adding more need [2:43:49] for expansion to the communication center [2:43:51] adds the money to the communication center there. [2:43:56] The SWAT vehicle I have highlighted there, that actually was on the old one, but I couldn't [2:44:02] highlight what isn't there because we used to have two on the old one. [2:44:05] One was a replacement vehicle that's still here, but we also had a change in philosophy [2:44:10] in the police department since five years ago. [2:44:12] And there's no longer a desire or a plan to increase our SWAT team presence. [2:44:17] So impact fees are growth related improvements. [2:44:20] They aren't replacement, right? [2:44:22] They're additional services. [2:44:23] The old plan suggested that we were going to add a second SWAT vehicle. [2:44:28] The second one could be certainly played for with impact fees because it represented a growth [2:44:32] to the program. [2:44:33] You can't replace an old SWAT vehicle with impact fees. [2:44:37] That's just part of your maintenance responsibility that you have. [2:44:40] So we removed the SWAT vehicle from the impact fee program. [2:44:43] We still show them here that's going to be spent, but if you track along to the far right, [2:44:47] there's no money going into the impact fee program there. [2:44:51] The last change I'll talk about these two together is in the equipment line before we [2:44:56] talked about radios for new cars. [2:44:59] And I think what we're doing here is equipment. [2:45:02] We're splitting out equipment for new officers and then radios for new cars. [2:45:06] So one of the things about impact fees is they're only for capital items. [2:45:11] You can spend impact fee for capital. [2:45:14] Capital in the impact fee statute is defined as something that you buy the last ten years. [2:45:19] a squad car won't last 10 years. [2:45:21] Those guys are hard on their cars. [2:45:23] They only keep them for five or six, maybe. [2:45:26] But the radio's inside them, they'll pull them out [2:45:28] and they'll put them in the next one. [2:45:29] So we can pay for new radios. [2:45:31] The equipment that we have in our new officers, [2:45:33] the radios, the rifles, the handguns, [2:45:36] will also last for 10 years. [2:45:37] And so we're proposing to fund some of those improvements there. [2:45:41] And we did not do that in the last one. [2:45:43] We did the radios, but we did not do the equipment. [2:45:46] So there's some new expenses there. [2:45:48] The last thing I want to mention real quick, there's a note, the 375,000, this is just an [2:45:53] error that we need to verify what the problem is before we bring you back to final resolution. [2:46:00] There's a note right below the table in the handout that talks about 370,000 being spent [2:46:08] on understanding the communication center. [2:46:13] The notes are $370,363. [2:46:18] What made it to the table is $375,548. [2:46:21] Those two numbers should be the same, [2:46:23] and I'm not sure which one's right, [2:46:24] so I just got to go back and check the math and figure out [2:46:26] which one's right, and make the right one land in the table [2:46:30] and make the note the same. [2:46:31] Okay, so anyway, we're going to see that same problem [2:46:34] on the fire, which is up now. [2:46:37] Unless there's questions on the police, I can. [2:46:39] Do we have any questions? [2:46:42] I see no. [2:46:43] OK. [2:46:43] So moving on to fire. [2:46:45] Again, the fire when we see some additional changes [2:46:48] with the fire's growth, as it relates to the communication [2:46:53] center, the communication center is a shared cost [2:46:56] between police and fire. [2:46:57] It serves both departments. [2:46:59] The call volume was determined at the time [2:47:01] to be about 66% to police, about 33% to fire. [2:47:06] so the cost is split that way too. [2:47:08] The total cost of the project is $375, [2:47:11] but 34% of that makes it to the fire impact fee [2:47:14] and $66% of it makes it to the police impact fee. [2:47:17] So the total cost has gone up [2:47:18] because we're adding five more years of growth. [2:47:22] We changed, I'm going to make a correction [2:47:24] to something that Travis said earlier [2:47:27] as it relates to the impact fees and the aerial platform [2:47:29] when we're talking about that on the budget item. [2:47:33] We have on here, and we have had for five years, [2:47:37] an additional ladder truck. [2:47:39] This is not a replacement for a 30-year-old truck. [2:47:42] This is a second truck. [2:47:43] The intent would be to operate both one ladder station, [2:47:47] one and one out of station five. [2:47:48] This is not a replacement truck. [2:47:50] That's why it's eligible for impact fees. [2:47:52] If it was a replacement truck, it is not eligible [2:47:54] for impact fees. [2:47:55] We couldn't match the grant funding. [2:47:57] It's a second truck. [2:48:03] And so what we've done here is just revise the costs [2:48:05] because we've done through that process just a few months [2:48:07] back and so I have a better feel for what those costs might be. [2:48:09] So we've revised the cost for the trucks for the platform [2:48:13] and then for the engine. [2:48:15] The big change in the fire impact fee program [2:48:18] is that we've always shown two stations in there. [2:48:21] You can't really move station two without building station five. [2:48:25] And so those two things need to kind of happen [2:48:27] at the same time and they're both a direct result [2:48:29] of the growth in the community. [2:48:32] The problem that we have is that we can fund the creation [2:48:34] of station five or the building of station five. [2:48:36] We can't fund the staffing of station five. [2:48:39] And that means about $1.3 million annually [2:48:41] to staff the station. [2:48:43] And we don't know how we come up with that money in one year. [2:48:46] And so to be fair for the impact fee program, [2:48:48] we decided to back off station five for a little while [2:48:52] while we spend some concerted effort [2:48:54] with the fire chief and the city manager and us in finance [2:48:59] and trying to figure out really how we go about, [2:49:01] did a good plan together to man that station for operation [2:49:05] before we start collecting money and for that station. [2:49:08] So we've actually removed $1.5 million in station five costs, [2:49:13] I'll say temporarily, because there's still a need for it. [2:49:16] We'll add it back in once we have a plan [2:49:18] on how we move forward with the staffing act. [2:49:21] Rebecca Mills, thank you. [2:49:22] Thank you, Mayor. [2:49:24] So since the need continues for station five, [2:49:27] would it make sense to keep collecting fees for the cost? [2:49:31] Because you're only going to spend the amount [2:49:35] of building station five anyway. [2:49:37] So what's the philosophy behind taking it away? [2:49:40] Is that gonna set you back a year in collecting fees? [2:49:44] It could if we go forward with station five. [2:49:46] I guess the thought process is we don't know [2:49:49] what the solution might be. [2:49:53] I really think it's a bit out there, [2:49:54] but I hesitate to say, but potentially one might say [2:49:58] we could just relocate one and two to better locations [2:50:03] to address our response and I don't know that we thought much about it, I guess, is the point. [2:50:11] If that is a viable solution to relocate one and two, we don't really need to build five. [2:50:15] We just relocate one and two so they're in better places to respond to the entire community. [2:50:20] One of the things that we found five years ago, we anticipated station five being kind [2:50:26] of northeast with the recent ISO inspections that we've had. [2:50:33] We're finding that our real deficiency is actually not northeast, but actually southeast, [2:50:38] with all the addition of the commercial, not commercial, but the industrial development [2:50:43] we've had there with large buildings and the need for a ladder truck to run that way. [2:50:48] And exactly the opposite is the new high school, the new hospital, and those needs for a ladder [2:50:53] truck to run that way. [2:50:54] And so it might be that a better solution is to not build five, but find some other way [2:50:59] to accomplish it. [2:51:02] we just don't know. We're going to spend a real good effort this year in the coming year and we're [2:51:08] going to get Ron involved since Clark involved in that and his staff and we're really going to [2:51:13] try and figure out what the best solution is because funding $1.3 million worth of firefighters in a [2:51:19] year is a very hard solution. It might be the best solution in the end, but it's a very hard solution. [2:51:27] Travis Rothwell? You actually can't. So if you talk to, I mean you can fund them [2:51:35] right and you can come up with the money if you could find $1.3 million. But [2:51:39] what's important and if Chief Clark were here he would share with you that [2:51:43] there is a amount of time and training that goes into each firefighter that we [2:51:51] have in our organization and there is a question whether or not you can add [2:51:56] 12 firefighters in a single year and where you would place them and how you would place [2:52:03] them into the organization because you're not just going to take 12 firefighters that [2:52:07] are brand new and place them into a fire station. [2:52:11] And so really what we need to do is it's developing a very methodical approach, not only from [2:52:16] a manpower perspective, but also from a funding perspective, and that right now is the question. [2:52:25] It also has to do with response times. [2:52:27] And so when we were looking, and as I understand it in the creation of the current impact fee, [2:52:36] some of the significant road improvements that we made were not completed at the time. [2:52:43] And so when we start looking at the road improvements and [2:52:47] the different things that we're able to do with the transportation corridors that we're developing, [2:52:51] maybe the case that we only need to build one fire station [2:52:55] in the eight year planning scenario associated with these impact [2:52:58] so [2:52:59] before we collect money for something that was uncertain and then found ourselves [2:53:03] to be in a place where we had to return it [2:53:06] we wanted to make sure that we were collecting it in a manner that [2:53:10] that made sense and that we had [2:53:12] a long-term outcome [2:53:15] uh... that we could [2:53:18] Right, and I think they talked about that at Fire Ops, how, you know, really it is difficult [2:53:22] that other communities have to slowly build up their fire department, building up to, [2:53:27] you know, creating a new station. [2:53:29] My thought was just that if you're going to be either building station five or replacing [2:53:37] stations one and two with different buildings, you know, you might need that exact same funding [2:53:45] regardless of what you're doing. [2:53:47] That's what we've done for the last five years, essentially. [2:53:50] I think the idea really is to really evaluate [2:53:54] what the best plan to move forward is, [2:53:56] and that may or may not be adding a fifth station. [2:54:00] And I think it's fair to our development community [2:54:03] that we're not really sure what the solution is [2:54:06] to kind of hold off a little bit while we get short. [2:54:10] At the time, we were pretty sure that we wanted five years ago, [2:54:14] we were pretty sure about this plan moving forward. [2:54:16] As we've gone further and had these conversations about staffing a station, it's really caused us to reevaluate whether the plan was really the right one to start with. [2:54:26] I don't know what the solution will be, but we'll figure it out. [2:54:31] Right, but no matter what solution you bring, you're obviously going to have costs that need to be covered. [2:54:37] I'm just worried about what you'll be losing in the year that you're not collecting these fees. [2:54:43] And this plan still shows us collecting for one station, not two. [2:54:48] So what we're going to collect to build one, even in this time when we're trying to figure [2:54:54] out what's going on with the ultimate plan. [2:54:58] So question, if you replace two stations, you know, one and two, the current stations [2:55:06] with a new station's one and two, are those eligible for impact fees because you're replacing [2:55:11] current stations? [2:55:14] Yeah, if we had to relocate two stations due to growth, [2:55:18] then I would assume both would be eligible for, [2:55:21] just like what we have in now for relocation of two. [2:55:25] Yeah, so that if I didn't- [2:55:26] To the stubby house. [2:55:27] It is a solution. [2:55:29] Another one might be to leave station two right where it is [2:55:31] and then just build a fifth one somewhere else [2:55:33] that's maybe southeast of town. [2:55:36] And it is Travis mentioned that there's an element [2:55:39] of response time and really everything [2:55:41] about the fire plan is response time. [2:55:43] That's the basis for everything we do. [2:55:47] And there are road improvements that didn't exist. [2:55:49] And there will be more road improvements in the next [2:55:51] little bit here with Chaney making its connection. [2:55:55] But the CSI project, that'll be a big one. [2:55:58] Pole line getting built. [2:55:59] It wasn't when we adopted the program. [2:56:01] And that's significant too, in terms of east-west movement. [2:56:06] Washington is done now, and we're making some improvements [2:56:09] on east, and all these things are improving. [2:56:12] response times that may actually help us arrive in a solution. [2:56:19] Some of the solutions may end up coming in, again, we would kind of briefly flash by others. [2:56:24] There's some money in the budget for an update to our comp plan. [2:56:27] I think some of that update to that comp plan could be very beneficial in this very question [2:56:34] where the growth is happening and maybe we would make part of that comp plan update [2:56:39] some examination of where fire stations ought to be. [2:56:43] But anyway, we're going to have to do that. [2:56:46] So the committee felt it was okay to remove one for the time [2:56:51] being when the uncertainty in moving forward. [2:56:54] If I could add something just really briefly, [2:56:57] in my former life, I also was a fireman. [2:56:59] I went through the Orange County Fire Academy [2:57:01] and aircraft fireman for the Marine Corps. [2:57:05] And there were stations in the LA basin [2:57:08] and Orange County Basin that was completely manned by pay call firemen where they would have someone stationed there, [2:57:18] but they would respond, trained adequate fire personnel, and their response times were pretty good. [2:57:30] Of course, they have a huge population to draw from, and this is always a stepping stone for a lot of folks [2:57:37] trying to get into a full-time position much like many times with police departments and [2:57:41] reserve programs. But I don't know if that's ever been explored for helping because when [2:57:48] we're talking about 12 fire persons, that's a chunk of change. Maybe it can be offset [2:57:55] a little bit by take-all. I don't know. [2:57:57] It's something I don't think we've actually looked at that. At least not that I've been [2:58:02] So, well, you can certainly bring it up. [2:58:04] I submit it and might be knocked down [2:58:07] and maybe they don't do that anymore, [2:58:09] but I think they do. [2:58:12] City I came from was the same way. [2:58:14] Hey, Cole. [2:58:18] You wanna move on to parks? [2:58:22] So, parks, if you look at the one that's in your file [2:58:25] and you look up here, you'll notice I cut a lot out of it [2:58:28] because a lot of it didn't change. [2:58:31] Parks also has the change at the top to look out [2:58:33] five more years, but in reality, [2:58:35] didn't impact anything about this. [2:58:38] We made the changes to the park one for other reasons. [2:58:41] The first one that we're going to talk about here [2:58:43] is the new parks to support growth at $2,035,000. [2:58:47] It used to be quite a bit higher in that $2.6, almost $1,000,000. [2:58:53] When we got looking at it, we found [2:58:54] that there's just an error made in the calculation. [2:58:58] On the one from five years ago, we just did math wrong. [2:59:03] And so we were collecting fees for $2.6 million worth [2:59:07] of community parks, and it should have been $2.03 million [2:59:11] worth of community parks. [2:59:12] They just busted the math somewhere, and we fixed it, [2:59:15] and we'll collect it correctly now. [2:59:19] So that's the first change. [2:59:23] We've removed some improvements that we've completed [2:59:25] from five years ago. [2:59:26] So that's where the 85,000 have highlighted here. [2:59:29] That's come down from, let's see, [2:59:34] between how we dropped it by $40,000, I think. [2:59:39] The big changes I want to talk about in the park one [2:59:42] isn't really a change as much as it's clarification. [2:59:45] You see at the bottom, there's a note, [2:59:47] and I just included the one, [2:59:48] there's a couple of notes on the one in the file, [2:59:50] but there's a note at the bottom that says [2:59:52] community parks include open space trail parks. [2:59:54] We've always done that. [2:59:55] We've always kind of considered our open space trails. [2:59:58] When I say open space trails, I mean that to be open space trails different from on-street [3:00:03] trails. [3:00:04] This is Snake River Canyon, this is Rock Creek Park, this is Derkey's Lakes, Ashown Falls, [3:00:10] agar Falls. [3:00:11] These are these kinds of trails, not the wide sidewalk along Washington Street door. [3:00:17] Open space trails, we treat those as community parks. [3:00:20] People will come from all over, they will drive to our trailheads and they will recreate [3:00:25] in our community park. [3:00:27] And in their case, it's a linear community park. [3:00:29] We treated them that way. [3:00:30] We wanted it to be known that we treat our trails that way. [3:00:34] And so we just added a little note here. [3:00:36] When we say community parks, we're [3:00:38] including these trail systems. [3:00:40] What that does for us, and I think we are on solid ground [3:00:44] anyway, is it allows us to use that 2.035 million [3:00:48] to really grow and expand our trail system along Snake River, [3:00:52] along Rock Creek, along Hager Falls, and those kinds of things. [3:00:57] Which actually leads right into the budget request that we talked about [3:01:01] We saw seventy some thousand dollars in the request for next year for expansion of trails coming from the impact money [3:01:07] And that is specifically expansions to our think River Canyon trail that we'll see [3:01:13] Anyway, that's the the big clarification there is we corrected the error and we added the note about the about the trails [3:01:20] Everything else is generally not changing too much the question about park before I move on the streets [3:01:26] We're back in Middle Stuyka. [3:01:28] Thank you, Mayor. [3:01:29] Sure, I have a question about you're saying there's a mathematical error. [3:01:36] What mathematical concept do you apply to get there? [3:01:40] I mean, what is the right, but who sets that, what is it determined by it? [3:01:46] So in our old one, we had a price per acre, we had an acreage that we were after. [3:01:52] For some reason when they did the math they dropped in two point six million dollars, and it wasn't when we do the math [3:01:59] It's not it's two point oh three [3:02:01] But I don't know where they found an extra five hundred thousand dollars in there. It's just [3:02:07] Anywhere in any of the notes from Mac Band and any of the meeting [3:02:11] I mean we just look for it and look for it and it's just said it comes down to [3:02:15] The math was wrong so 16 and a half acres of New Park is what we were looking for at [3:02:21] at $80,000 per acre in developing cost, [3:02:26] and that just doesn't equal to six. [3:02:29] All right, my question would be because we have looked [3:02:31] at a couple of locations for a park, [3:02:34] and I mean, I could see where we could use that $2.6 million [3:02:39] because, especially where people want a community park [3:02:42] near the Canyon Rim, I mean, it is more expensive. [3:02:45] So why couldn't we leave that amount in there? [3:02:49] We certainly could use it. [3:02:51] We could do other things to get to that same point. [3:02:55] Here, what we just did simply was correct the error [3:02:58] in the calculation. [3:03:01] Instead, we could have gone back into the plan [3:03:04] to justify a new acquisition cost, I guess. [3:03:10] And so the acquisition development cost [3:03:13] is 80,000 per acre. [3:03:15] That comes from an established number [3:03:17] that we've been using for some time on our on our neighborhood part program, but yeah, [3:03:22] it we know that it's not going to be the same cost as I think River Canyon if we have to acquire, [3:03:31] but it'll be higher than what's necessary to develop agar falls trails, for example. [3:03:39] So it was just a given a take. [3:03:42] We just recognize that as an air calculation fixed the air. [3:03:47] The board was comfortable with it. [3:03:49] The committee was comfortable with it and that was. [3:03:54] Yeah, I will. [3:03:55] I just personally would recommend having more resources for this regional park. [3:04:01] I mean, we know anyone that went to Western days can see the need for as our community grows. [3:04:07] And as we talk about how fast we're going to be growing, I think we're really going to need to get on that concept of [3:04:13] of this regional or community park. [3:04:17] I think that the need will come up sooner rather than later. [3:04:20] I just hate to see a reduction in the amount set aside for parks. [3:04:25] Travis, you're out there. [3:04:26] We have to be able to validate the $80,000 number [3:04:29] or some other number. [3:04:31] We can't go through a process and say it is some number [3:04:36] so that we can collect $2.6 million. [3:04:38] We can go through that process. [3:04:40] like Mitch shared, the information that we have [3:04:45] and the processes that we've used in the past [3:04:48] illustrate that it's about $80,000 per acre [3:04:51] and based upon that per acre cost [3:04:54] is how you come up with the $2,032,000. [3:04:58] To increase that to some number larger than that, [3:05:02] we have to probably change what the value [3:05:06] of that property is and we could go through a process [3:05:08] to do that. There's also, I think it's important to know that when you go through that evaluation, [3:05:16] it could come in lower because when this was done in 2008, property values were 2007, right? [3:05:28] It was in 2008. [3:05:29] Yeah, 2000. Property values were slightly higher than where they are now, but it certainly [3:05:36] some we could look at and as I'm listening to Travis talk here I'm actually [3:05:42] reading the note to we split out development cost from acquisition costs [3:05:47] acquisition costs is 41 to 50 per acre development cost per acre was 8435 so an [3:05:55] acquisition cost of $41,250 per acre is probably low for Canyon Rim Land but it's [3:06:02] is also probably high for other parts of the town. [3:06:07] And again, that is a data from eight, five years ago, [3:06:11] six years ago, so. [3:06:14] Well, I would recommend, [3:06:15] I don't know how the rest of the council feels, [3:06:17] but I would recommend looking into an updated number. [3:06:19] I mean, I just want us to be realistic [3:06:21] about the cost that we will incur [3:06:24] in creating this community park. [3:06:26] And I mean, we need to have the correct amount [3:06:29] so that we can purchase what the community needs. [3:06:32] You know, no matter what that is, [3:06:33] I want it to be the correct amount. [3:06:37] So the cost, just for the cost from six years [3:06:43] goes $40,000 an acre, and we've applied [3:06:46] our automatic increases for the light. [3:06:49] We had four automatic increases since we adopted it in 09. [3:06:53] So the 41-250 right now represents $40,000 an acre [3:06:58] and acre from five years ago increased four times by 1.1, 1.4, you know, there's a few different [3:07:06] percentage increases, so that's where that came from. We can do it either way. [3:07:14] Let me move on the streets and we can move on to it. Please, I see no interest way in on that council. [3:07:23] Okay, so again, I did the same thing with the street capital improvement kind of condensed it, [3:07:30] So it would fit on one slide. [3:07:31] A lot of the stuff was kind of superficial changes. [3:07:36] The streets one I want to spend a little bit of time on. [3:07:41] And I'll probably go backwards. [3:07:42] But one of the changes we did here was the $418,263 per traffic [3:07:47] signal. [3:07:48] Again, that's the same 400,000 per signal [3:07:52] that we have started with five years ago with the increases [3:07:54] over the four years that have increased. [3:07:57] So that number has changed. [3:08:00] We had some signals completed. [3:08:02] We pulled them off the list. [3:08:04] We added some signals on the list that we foresee now, [3:08:07] potentially having a need that we didn't back then. [3:08:09] So the list of possible signals has changed slightly. [3:08:13] The big change here, really, though, [3:08:14] is in the top of the chart and it's on the streets. [3:08:19] Streets and street construction projects [3:08:22] has been the thorn in our side of impact fees [3:08:26] right from the start. [3:08:28] And it was, do we include them? [3:08:30] Do we not include them? [3:08:31] As soon as we include street projects, [3:08:33] the prices go through the roof. [3:08:36] And so many times we've had this conversation [3:08:38] and we've come to this point and the councils [3:08:40] that pulled those street projects out, [3:08:43] our development community can't bear the cost [3:08:45] of the street projects. [3:08:47] So here's one more attempt, I guess, by the committee [3:08:50] to get to a point where we're recognizing [3:08:53] that growth is having an impact on our streets [3:08:55] and we need to address it. [3:08:56] But we also need to address it in a way that doesn't scare off retailers, for example, from [3:09:04] coming to Twin Falls. [3:09:05] We don't want to have an impact fee for a retail that is so high that no more retail comes to [3:09:11] town. [3:09:12] And I say retail because there's very good reason. [3:09:14] Street impact fees are divvied out to the different uses by their traffic demand and traffic [3:09:20] demand is measured by trips generated. [3:09:23] retailers generate trips way more than everybody else generates. And not all [3:09:29] retailers are equal. A convenience store generates a lot more trips than a [3:09:33] furniture store. But we have them all lumped together as retail and when we do [3:09:40] that and we throw in $12.5 million worth of street projects it makes our retail [3:09:47] impact for you go out from $1.70 a foot to $8.00 and something per foot. And that is 800% [3:09:56] increase or 700% increase. And it's unbearable. We will lose retail development in town. And [3:10:03] so that's the balance that the committee was trying to make was how do we grab some support [3:10:10] for street construction but not drive the retailers away. We spend most of our time with [3:10:16] the committee on this very issue. In the end, we have five street projects listed up [3:10:23] there that we believe are growth related in street projects. They're all listed there [3:10:27] on the left, the Eastland from Kanderets, Kimberley, Eastland from Kimberley to Orchard, [3:10:33] Falls from Washington, the Grand View. You all know that we just did a repaving project [3:10:39] on Falls from Washington, the Grand View, right? This would be an additional lane width [3:10:45] in that project. If we added one more lane width, we could strike that as two lanes either [3:10:50] direction with the turn lane down the middle. So that is a growth-related lane addition. [3:10:56] Falls from Blue Lakes to Locust and then pole line from Bridgeview to Mountain View. They're [3:11:01] all growth-related improvements. They all have a cost associated with them and they all have [3:11:07] some percentage that's growth-related or some that's not. In the end, those five projects [3:11:14] come out to a cost of $12.5 million. [3:11:17] As I said before, if we include $12.5 billion, [3:11:20] it makes it jump to eight, some foot for retail. [3:11:24] And so we didn't do that. [3:11:26] Instead, what the committee came up with was this idea [3:11:28] to treat the street projects the same as the traffic signal [3:11:32] projects. [3:11:35] So have them all on there as potential projects [3:11:38] we're going to spend money on, but only collect a fixed amount [3:11:42] and do whatever we can do with that fixed amount. [3:11:45] So on this traffic signals, we put down 30 different traffic [3:11:49] signals that cost $400,000 each. [3:11:51] But we're only going to collect $2 million, [3:11:53] and we're going to build five traffic signals. [3:11:56] For the street projects, we're looking to do the same kind [3:11:58] of thing. [3:11:58] There's $12.5 million worth of product on there. [3:12:02] The impact fees will collect $1.5 million worth of fees. [3:12:06] When we have that money in the bank, [3:12:08] one of those five projects, which ever [3:12:10] has the greatest need, we'll apply that money towards, along with some other source of money, [3:12:15] obviously, because 1.5 only gets you two of those five projects in a portion of the other [3:12:22] three, right? So that's the big change or the big recommendation from the Committee on [3:12:32] Street Impact Fees. Note at the bottom just says exactly that, that describes that process, [3:12:38] and then we've added a paragraph in the text of the plan that further describes that process. [3:12:43] So, that is the change, the proposal for street impact fees. [3:12:50] So, I can try to answer your questions there, or I can move [3:12:54] on to what this does to the guy who pays the fees. [3:12:56] Any questions for, Rebecca Melsoica. [3:13:00] Thank you, Mayor. [3:13:01] So, what you're saying is the growth related costs [3:13:05] of the projects are a certain amount that is much higher [3:13:09] than what you're assessing. [3:13:10] Exactly, exactly what I'm saying. [3:13:13] So, for me, you know, I understand being sensitive about, you know, paying these fees, [3:13:20] but the point of the fees is to cover the impacts, to cover the costs. [3:13:24] And so, I mean, we're, for, you know, the amount above and beyond what you're collecting, you're [3:13:32] putting that on the average citizen who's not making money off of these development projects, [3:13:37] who's not selling these retail spaces and reaping the benefits and being in that business. [3:13:45] They're just paying it anyway. [3:13:47] So I would just recommend funding the projects that they cause to be needed. [3:14:00] Chris, talking. [3:14:01] Well, as I said, and on the impact fee committee, [3:14:04] You know, there was a lively discussion of not so much if a developer should or a development [3:14:12] should pay for its sharer, but how much and in what form and Mitch related already that [3:14:23] it would be like a 700% increase to provide the full impact cost. [3:14:27] And that's even unreasonable for people who aren't related with the building industry [3:14:33] and new growth. [3:14:34] And I think your point is valid, Rebecca, but I think that the impact fee is to help offset [3:14:41] growth, not to entirely replace it. [3:14:45] I don't think that that's ever possible. [3:14:47] Anytime you have a regular street budget dealing with widening or even seal coding, you're, [3:14:54] you're in effect asking the taxpayers to pay for somebody else's benefit to some extent. [3:15:01] So it's not perfect, but at this impact committee, I think was pretty reasonable in their approach [3:15:08] on this, and we also have three new impact people that don't have a lot of experience. [3:15:15] And I think that there would be kind of, without a lot of direction at this time, if we threw [3:15:23] much back on them. I looked at it as a pretty balanced output from this impact committee [3:15:30] that represented the whole gamut of the community. [3:15:34] Susanne Hoggins. [3:15:36] Thank you. I do think that the community as a whole benefits from new retail, new businesses [3:15:44] coming to our community. There's a lot of ways we all participate in that. And to have [3:15:48] And then pay a portion of this and help us continue moving the city forward. [3:15:53] I feel as fair. [3:15:54] So I think this is a good compromise and I can support the direction you're headed with this. [3:16:01] Thank you Mayor. [3:16:02] Well, and if I may respond, I think those are some good points, Councilman Talkington. [3:16:07] But I also believe that these rates have been too low for far too long. [3:16:11] And so if we look at percent increases, that really may not be the right indication of where they should be. [3:16:16] I mean, certainly we've waived the increase to impact fees for the past several years, [3:16:22] I think that I've been on council. [3:16:24] So I think that there certainly should be a balance. [3:16:31] We've all got to participate, but it just seems like this is a very small portion of [3:16:40] the overall impact. [3:16:45] just for clarification the three new impact fee committee members were seated [3:16:51] after the committee voted on this and I know Chris knows that but maybe the rest [3:16:56] of you didn't quite know that the old the old committee with all those guys who've [3:17:01] been on there for years was the committee that worked on this and put it [3:17:04] together and they made their adoption and then we see new people three new [3:17:09] people, so that is the debate, the debate that is the current, that is exactly the debate [3:17:18] that we had four different times now in the last five years. I was going to talk about [3:17:24] this a little bit, I already did, so you don't need to necessarily see it. This table right [3:17:29] here shows if everything is adopted as attached, then here's what we'll see. So on the far left [3:17:38] column we have a description of what we're looking at. The first column of numbers would [3:17:43] be the new fee if this was adopted as proposed. So down to the bottom we have single-family [3:17:50] $2,006, multi-family $1,834, and so forth. The very next column is what the fees are today [3:17:59] so that we can see the comparison. So new single-family $1,679, new multi-family $1,582. [3:18:07] The next column is the difference in the dollars and then the final column is the difference [3:18:12] between the two and as a percentage. [3:18:15] You see everyone on there is the smallest one is a 16% increase based on these proposals. [3:18:24] The committee while each individual little piece might not have been unanimous at the [3:18:31] end. [3:18:32] recommendation as crafted was a unanimous recommendation from the impact fee committee. [3:18:38] That was then forwarded to the Planning and Zoning Commission. [3:18:40] This is an amendment to the comp plan, I didn't spend a lot of time on that, but this is an amendment [3:18:44] to the comp plan. [3:18:46] And as an amendment to the comp plan, the Planning and Zoning Commission had to weigh in on it as [3:18:50] well. [3:18:51] They've looked at it. [3:18:52] We spent a full on hour worth of education in talking with the comp plan, with the Planning [3:18:58] the zoning commission, and they get [3:19:00] anniversary recommended approval of this as well. [3:19:04] So that's kind of the total impact, what it'll do to the guy [3:19:09] who's right in the check, right? [3:19:13] With that, I would maybe just have one more final thing. [3:19:18] Both the committee and the planning zoning commission [3:19:21] recommended kind of a notice period to let people know [3:19:24] this is coming. [3:19:26] We did it the same way in 2009 when they were adopted. [3:19:29] We adopted them in February. [3:19:31] They went into place in August, a few months later. [3:19:35] If we adopt these, the recommendation is that we actually [3:19:38] let people know they're coming and start implementing them [3:19:41] on October 1st and coordination with our new fiscal year. [3:19:45] It was reasonable. [3:19:46] So I guess that's where we're at here. [3:19:52] If the council approves this tonight, [3:19:54] We'll bring back a couple of next steps, right? [3:19:57] We'll bring back a resolution. [3:19:58] It's an amendment to the comp plan. [3:20:00] That requires a resolution to make that amendment. [3:20:03] So that's one thing. [3:20:04] Second thing we'll do is because every one of these fees [3:20:06] is more than a 5% increase. [3:20:08] We actually have to schedule a second public hearing [3:20:10] for the fee increase, which will then bring [3:20:13] with it a fee resolution as well. [3:20:14] So we'll have two of those things coming up. [3:20:16] There's a hearing notice that it'll be a few weeks out [3:20:19] before we can get that done. [3:20:21] Tonight we do need to open a public hearing [3:20:23] for the Compline Amendment and with that all. [3:20:27] It's not talking. [3:20:28] Any questions before I open up the public hearing? [3:20:34] This time I'll open up the public hearing [3:20:36] for anyone in the public wishing to come forward [3:20:38] and testifying on this item. [3:20:43] I see no one in the audience that is making their way, [3:20:46] so I'm closing the public hearing [3:20:49] and turning it over to council for any further [3:20:52] clarifying questions and or direction. [3:20:55] Well, I'm supportive of this measure. [3:20:59] It's not a perfect change by any interpretation. [3:21:05] I don't think anybody was terribly 100% sold on it, [3:21:10] but this impact committee, again, was a pretty good representation [3:21:14] from the people working in the industry. [3:21:17] And we could make substantial more changes on retail, [3:21:24] For instance, that Rebecca was alluding to. [3:21:27] But even if we make this change, [3:21:29] we're going from $1.76 to $2.86 a square foot, [3:21:35] and that represents a 62% increase. [3:21:38] That's a pretty big gun. [3:21:39] If you're building a 10,000 square foot facility, [3:21:43] that's quite a bit. [3:21:44] What I'm saying is, [3:21:46] this came after quite a bit of deliberation, [3:21:49] the new impact fee people, [3:21:52] I think would be no help for us [3:21:53] if we were to throw it back, it's not a perfect solution, [3:21:58] but it goes a long ways, I think, toward making new growth pay [3:22:02] more of its actual cost to the presidential [3:22:07] and the homo in this area. [3:22:12] Chris, we're back in the soil again. [3:22:14] Thank you, Mayor. [3:22:15] I would agree with Councilman talking to, you know, [3:22:18] I think it's a good step in the right direction. [3:22:20] It might not be as far as I would like to go, [3:22:23] but I think it's a good step to build on [3:22:24] we can build in the future. [3:22:26] I would like to make a motion to direct staff [3:22:29] to update the per acre cost of acquisition [3:22:33] for a community park to the most accurate numbers [3:22:37] that we have today. [3:22:42] We have a motion on the floor. [3:22:44] I'll second that. [3:22:46] We have a motion on the floor by Rebecca Melsoica, [3:22:49] seconded by Chris Talkington. [3:22:52] Repeat that motion one more time [3:22:53] so I can get it clear. [3:22:54] Rebecca, sorry. [3:22:55] No, that's fine. [3:22:56] To direct staff to just update the per acre cost of acquisition for a community park, that [3:23:02] number that we talked about, just so you know, whether it goes up or down, it's accurate because [3:23:07] it was created back in 2008 or so. [3:23:10] That way we can have a realistic idea of what it would cost the city. [3:23:14] And if we want to go out and buy a community park today, we want to have a good idea. [3:23:22] I agree with the motion. I don't really think we need the motion. I think we probably could just hold them to it, but I certainly will [3:23:29] Vote in favor. Sorry. No, I didn't assume that I had the support. No. No, it's okay to have a motion to [3:23:38] Anything further on this motion before we move on to the main [3:23:42] crux of what we're here for for the public hearing [3:23:45] The Anna can you do a roll call vote, please? Yes [3:23:51] Yes [3:23:53] Yes, Jim. Yes, yes, motion passes five to zero. [3:23:59] Chris talking to move to Amanda Twin Falls vision 2030 comprehensive plan for such [3:24:04] a single feature to take chapter 11 development impact. [3:24:08] He capital improvement plans per the outline. [3:24:11] Second. We have a motion by Chris talking and seconded by Jim. I just [3:24:17] one to weigh in. I think Rebecca's points tonight were [3:24:22] valid. I appreciate her bringing that. But as Chris said, I think that we, you know, [3:24:28] take one bite at a time and we're moving that direction. And although not perfect, [3:24:34] I think this is a really good step in that direction. So I will be voting in favor of it. [3:24:39] Anything further from council? Leila, we'll call vote on the main motion, please. [3:24:45] Yes. [3:24:46] Yes. [3:24:47] Jim? [3:24:48] Yes. [3:24:49] Yes. [3:24:50] Yes. [3:24:51] Yes. [3:24:52] Yes. [3:24:53] Motion passes five to zero. [3:24:56] And then you're going to bring the two back to us in a couple of weeks. [3:25:02] I guess I have a question on the updating of acreage cost. [3:25:08] We could bring the resolution back with an updated cost. [3:25:14] It might impact how quickly we get on the resolution back before you or we could bring [3:25:19] resolution back and then work on whatever needs to get work done and do that as a separate. [3:25:26] You got the real non-committal shrug. [3:25:32] Well then I have to go through the whole hearing process twice again. [3:25:38] I think we probably would bring the resolution back when we have an updated cost and then [3:25:41] you know, look at it and if you're not comfortable with it, we'll try again. [3:25:46] Yeah, sure. How are you going to [3:25:49] cap about those costs when they're such a diversion, acreage cost, depending on [3:25:54] location? I was going to ask you for some help on that one. [3:25:59] No, I really don't know. That's a free cut. [3:26:03] We'll have to find a way to do that, because really this could represent acreage [3:26:10] all over the city and the values are going to fluctuate dramatically depending on where [3:26:16] we land. [3:26:17] And it's just some information for us with future travices. [3:26:20] So what we'll do is there's obviously a process used to determine $40,000 per acre. [3:26:26] We'll research those notes and we'll just recreate that process. [3:26:30] I think it's important to recognize that it's going to be a community-wide process. [3:26:38] So we'll look at communities south part town, we'll look at community on the canyon rim of [3:26:41] the east, the northeast, south, etc. [3:26:44] And then we'll come up with a number and say this is what based upon how they created [3:26:49] the number in 2008, what that number would be modified for 2014. [3:26:56] Ultimately, that number will impact both of the resolutions we come back with. [3:27:02] So we won't bring either one of them back to you until we have that figured out. [3:27:06] You know, and you did mention about the October 1st roll out, and that wasn't in the motion, [3:27:12] did it need to be in motion? [3:27:13] It was, that was a recommendation from the Planning Commission and the Committee. [3:27:17] And it was in the report. [3:27:18] It's part of the presentation, I'm sure, that that was the way your motion was more comfortable [3:27:23] with it. [3:27:24] Okay. [3:27:25] I just wanted to confirm that. [3:27:28] Alright, anything, we are now going to be moving into adjournment if Council wishes into executive [3:27:36] of session 672345-1A to consider hiring a public officer, employee, staff member, or individual [3:27:43] agent wherein the respective qualities of the individual are not to be evaluated in order [3:27:49] to fill a particular vacancy or need. [3:27:53] There actually are to be evaluated to not – let me read that sentence again – to consider [3:27:58] hiring a public officer's long night, employee, staff member, or an individual agent wherein [3:28:03] the respective qualities of individuals are to be evaluating in order to fill a particular [3:28:09] vacancy or need. [3:28:11] This paragraph does not apply to filling a vacancy in an elected office or deliberation [3:28:17] about staffing needs in general. [3:28:20] So moved. [3:28:21] Jim Lund made the motion seconded by Suzanne Hawkins anything further on that motion council [3:28:26] to go into executive session. [3:28:29] I see no lice. [3:28:30] Leona roll call vote. [3:28:32] Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. All right. Yes. Motion passes. Just one dimension to folks on the air tonight that we will not be reconvening. We will not be making any decisions. And we are now adjourned. Into.