Oversight Archive: City Council meeting, 2014-11-10, recording 1 (started 17:00) Machine transcript (faster-whisper base.en), not checked word for word; the Pledge of Allegiance is shown in its standard wording. The recording is the record. Times are time into the recording. Passages with private details are muted in the audio and marked here. The audio on the page below was re-encoded by software from the video the agency posted. Check any passage against that audio before relying on it. Page: https://oversightarchive.org/twin-falls-id/meetings/2014-11-10/ [0:03:57] I'd like to call the City Council meeting to order. [0:04:01] It is 5 PM on November 10th, 2014 Marine Corps birthday. [0:04:07] So happy birthday, Marine Corps. [0:04:09] And the first thing that we do is, [0:04:12] traditionally we do the Pledge of Allegiance. [0:04:15] And tonight, we would like to invite our youth council members [0:04:19] to come forward and lead us in the Pledge of Allegiance [0:04:21] if they would do so. [0:04:22] for your release. [0:04:24] Shorty and OA and Ron Clark as well. [0:04:32] So if you'll come right here and just lead us in pledge, [0:04:37] thank you for all of your standing. [0:04:41] I pledge allegiance to the Flag of the United States of America, and to the Republic for which it stands, one Nation under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all. [0:04:54] If the four of you wouldn't mind just quickly [0:04:56] introducing yourselves to us, that would be great. [0:04:59] just go to the mic and tell us who you are. [0:05:04] My name is Ben Wallen. [0:05:05] Thank you Ben. [0:05:08] Caitlin Morris. [0:05:10] Thank you Caitlin. [0:05:12] My name is Sabia Nott. [0:05:14] Thank you. [0:05:14] How do you say your first name? [0:05:15] Sabia. [0:05:16] Sabia. [0:05:17] Sabia. [0:05:18] Thank you Sabia. [0:05:19] My name is Jesse Strew. [0:05:20] Thank you Jesse. [0:05:21] And I need to let you all four know that Suzanne made me do that. [0:05:26] OK, so we're mad at anybody. [0:05:28] Be mad at her. [0:05:30] No, it's absolutely. [0:05:31] Thank you for coming up and leaving us in the pledge. [0:05:33] That's an honor to have you up here. [0:05:35] I would like to confirm that we do have a quorum [0:05:37] of the city council. [0:05:38] Six members are here this evening. [0:05:40] Jim Mundt was not able to attend this evening's meeting. [0:05:45] Turn it over to our city manager for any considerations [0:05:47] of amendments to our agenda. [0:05:50] Mr. Mayor, members of the council, [0:05:51] there would be two possible amendments [0:05:53] for tonight's consideration for the council. [0:05:57] The first would appear as item number four, [0:05:59] should you choose to add it, [0:06:00] That would be a discussion of a proposed ballot for the Board of Trustees for the Idaho County Risk Management Program. [0:06:09] The ballot just came in and so that would be the first add. [0:06:12] The second would be a ballot for the FSA or Farm Service Agency under the USDA, both of those ballots that require review by the City Council. [0:06:24] And they would be submitted to you for consideration for addition to this evening. [0:06:29] Thank you, Travis and Fritz. [0:06:30] We can do both of those at the same time, Kevin, [0:06:33] add both or should we do them separately, separately. [0:06:36] Right, I'll turn it over to council for their direction. [0:06:39] Greg, I move that we add as item number four, [0:06:42] the I-Crimp, Region I, Director Ballot. [0:06:49] Motion on the floor by Greg Manton. [0:06:51] Manton, seconded by Chris Talking, anything? [0:06:54] I'm sorry, they could be added together, [0:06:55] but they need to be acted on separately. [0:06:57] Okay, I understand. [0:06:58] Oh, I'm sorry, I didn't, I wasn't clear of that. [0:07:01] Great. And I would like to add the farm services was up the other one. [0:07:06] Just say FSA, FSA valid as well as part of my emotion. [0:07:11] You okay with that second? All right. [0:07:13] So we have both being added four and five and anything further on that motion, [0:07:18] Council. We either roll call vote, please. [0:07:21] Susan Hawkins. Yes. [0:07:23] Sean Baricher. Yes. [0:07:25] Chris Talkington. Great glancing. Yes. [0:07:28] Don Hall? Yes. Rebecca Melsweka? Yes. Motion passes six to zero. Moving on to [0:07:36] proclamations we have none this evening and then we move to public input. Do we [0:07:41] have anyone from the public that would like to address the council this evening? [0:07:44] I see no one running for the podium again so we will then move to our consent [0:07:51] calendar and I'll turn that over to council wishes. Greg Lanning. Move [0:07:56] approval of the consent calendar as published second motion on floor by Greg [0:08:03] Lansing seconded by Suzanne Hawkins anything further on that motion council [0:08:08] the island roll call vote please yes John Berriger yes yes great landing yes [0:08:16] Don Hall yes Rebecca Milsoyka yes Suzanne Hawkins yes motion passes six to [0:08:23] zero moving under items for consideration number one is consideration of a [0:08:27] request to approve and adopt the collective bargaining agreement between the City of Twin [0:08:32] Falls and the Twin Falls firefighters local 1 5 6 and we have Susan Harris welcome Susan good [0:08:41] evening mary council it's my pleasure to bring forward the draft collective bargaining agreement [0:08:46] between the City of Twin Falls and Twin Falls firefighters local 1556 this draft is a combination [0:08:54] of our meetings that we've had over the last few months, [0:08:58] and we have Chief Clark and President Ed Morris here, [0:09:03] if you have any questions that you would like addressed. [0:09:07] Basically, as my staff report indicates, [0:09:11] there are very few changes. [0:09:13] The information that we would like to delete [0:09:16] from this contract has striked through it. [0:09:21] The new verbiage is highlighted in red. [0:09:25] Basically, do you want me to go through it a little bit? [0:09:30] Yeah, I think it highlighted, especially [0:09:32] for folks at home, that'd be great, Susan. [0:09:33] OK. [0:09:34] The major changes in this contract [0:09:37] were removing a section that refers to hazmat pay. [0:09:42] Years ago, the Twin Falls Fire Department [0:09:44] was involved in, at first it was [0:09:47] Ember, which was Magic Valley Emergency Response Team, [0:09:52] that became Region 5, Hazmat Team. [0:09:56] And several years ago, that Region 5 team disbanded. [0:10:01] And so that part of the contract [0:10:04] was no longer applicable to the Twin Falls Firefighter. [0:10:08] So we're removing that section. [0:10:10] We also removed some of the wording regarding the vote [0:10:16] for the, when the firefighters voted to withdraw from Social Security. [0:10:20] So we removed some of that language, just cleaned it up a little bit. [0:10:26] The two sections that we added, you'll see portal to portal. [0:10:31] And basically what that is referring to is when say another agency was to call [0:10:40] and ask for help from the Twin Falls firefighters if it was deemed [0:10:45] that they would go, we would pay portal to portal, which means from the time they left [0:10:50] home to the time they got back, the language was included in the contract because sometimes [0:10:58] if they're responding, they may get paid by that other agency or the city may get paid [0:11:05] by the other agency for just the time actually spent responding and so making sure that the [0:11:14] firefighters are covered from the time they need to the time they come back, which is actually [0:11:19] no different than anything we've ever done in the past if they've gone up to Haley or I [0:11:26] think they went to... [0:11:32] Well, that was something else. [0:11:43] It was in Jaromah, other places right now. [0:11:45] Jarbitch. [0:11:46] Jarbitch. [0:11:47] That's where they... [0:11:48] Not Jaromah. [0:11:49] Sorry. [0:11:50] So that language is just in there to make sure that they are covered in the time they [0:11:56] lead to when they get back. [0:11:58] The other section that we added in was a paragraph regarding the disability insurance. [0:12:06] Currently the city provides long-term disability insurance to all employees. [0:12:12] At some time we've looked at that and the cost benefit of it. [0:12:17] And so we had a discussion that should the city decide to drop the long-term disability coverage? [0:12:25] We have agreed to give a 90-day notice to the firefighters so that if they want to pick [0:12:33] up disability insurance, we could have discussion about taking part of the current 6.2 percent [0:12:44] that's being deposited into the Percy Choice, [0:12:48] they could use part of those funds [0:12:51] to pick up disability insurance at the Innocence. [0:12:56] Other than the date changes, [0:12:58] that's primarily the changes that are included [0:13:01] in this contract. [0:13:03] Thank you, Susan. [0:13:04] I know that we got at least one light on, [0:13:05] but before we do that, I didn't know if either Ed [0:13:08] or Chief Clark wanted to come up and make any comments. [0:13:11] You don't have to, I'm not calling, yeah, [0:13:13] But in case you want it to, I don't see them running for the podium either. [0:13:18] So Rebecca, Bill Syka. [0:13:20] Well, thank you, Mayor. [0:13:22] Thank you, Susan. [0:13:22] You answered one of my questions. [0:13:24] I did have a question about some of the language that is being deleted on the internal revenue service reimbursement. [0:13:31] The part on page nine, section three, that says, should they request reimbursement of any portion returned? [0:13:40] Funds, anyway, it says that the bargaining unit members shall be solely responsible for [0:13:44] emitting payment. [0:13:45] So is that no longer applicable anymore or who would be responsible since this is being [0:13:51] deleted? [0:13:53] Following the vote, the referendum vote, where the firefighters voted to get out of the Social [0:14:00] Security Program, those refunds were issued to all applicable members. [0:14:08] I talked with Brent Hyatt and he said that the statute of limitations for those years that [0:14:15] were refunded has run. [0:14:19] Okay, so it's just no longer. [0:14:21] Okay, great. [0:14:22] Thank you. [0:14:23] Okay, Chris, talking to you. [0:14:26] And I did note one change I'd like you to have us talk about Susan briefly, it's an appendix [0:14:30] a section E where there is a promotion, excuse me, a wage [0:14:37] scale adjustment when firefighters go to drivers. [0:14:40] The old rate was 5% increase, not a 7%. [0:14:44] And from driver to captain from 7 and a half to 10. [0:14:47] Was that a negotiated increase or what was the basis of that? [0:14:53] Actually, it wasn't a negotiated increase. [0:14:57] With the change to the pay scale and the differences, [0:15:02] we just felt that it was more applicable [0:15:08] in regards to what we're doing in some other areas. [0:15:11] From the driver to captain, [0:15:12] that's really the first step into a supervisory position. [0:15:17] And so most, what we were seeing is that most of the positions [0:15:20] that were taking that kind of a step, [0:15:22] we're getting about a 10% increase. [0:15:24] And so in an effort to be consistent, [0:15:27] we increase that to 10 percent. [0:15:31] Well, Mayor, I'd like to make a motion. [0:15:32] I'd like to preface that with saying that I worked [0:15:35] on management side and in private business [0:15:37] with organized labor. [0:15:40] And it was usually a very productive relationship. [0:15:45] But in my knowledge here in the city of Twin Falls [0:15:47] between local 1556 and an hour side of the desk, [0:15:53] I've seen nothing but a common vision [0:15:56] in working together. [0:15:57] I think this is a good harmonious work in relationship [0:16:00] with the betterment of a fireman like police [0:16:04] who put the lies on the line every day. [0:16:07] With that said, I would like to propose [0:16:09] amendment of the adjusted agreement. [0:16:14] We have a motion on the floor by Kristoffin [0:16:16] and seconded by Sean Berger to approve [0:16:20] and adopt a collective bargaining agreement [0:16:22] between the city of Twin Falls [0:16:23] and the Twin Falls Firefighters Local 1556. [0:16:27] I couldn't have said it better, thank you Chris, that's absolutely accurate, so thank you for doing that. [0:16:33] I do have one question, so Susan, do we, obviously this says from 2014 to 2016, so on 16 we'll do this again, so it's about it every two years. [0:16:45] It will automatically renew year after year unless either party chooses to open it up. [0:16:52] Okay, so I mean it could it could go on beyond [0:16:56] 2016 if no one wanted to open why does it just for my own benefit? Why does it say 2016? [0:17:03] It says 2014 through 2016 [0:17:08] But it will but it automatically roll over you don't have to do anything unless okay, okay [0:17:15] I'm going to say this thinking I know what it means and maybe a [0:17:24] French or a sizzle correct me that actually means that you probably only every two years [0:17:29] can you come one side or the other open it up is that the way it is no I'm not [0:17:34] too so alright I guess I'm just confused I'm getting them nods and yes [0:17:39] friends could you clarify for us so they can open it any year it just is two [0:17:46] years because that's the way they've done it it could have not any terms at all [0:17:50] and wait wait for someone to ask to reopen but that's just the way we do it. [0:17:55] Okay it just seemed kind of odd that it says 14 to [0:17:58] through 16 and it looked like you would automatically have to open it up again. [0:18:02] Okay very good. All right any other questions Councilor Lee Island roll call [0:18:09] vote please? Yes. Greg Lanci? Yes. Don Hall? Yes. Rebecca [0:18:14] Yes, Susan Hawkins. Yes, Sean Baraker. Yes, motion passes six to zero. Thank you, gentlemen. And thank you, Susan. Susan. I see that we have some boy scouts that have entered the room and we traditionally asked Boy Scouts to come forward and introduce themselves to us if they wouldn't mind because we know you're here probably working on some sort of a merit badge or something. Is that correct? Generally, it's like communication in the community or something like that. [0:18:41] something like that. [0:18:42] Citizen, citizen, yeah. [0:18:43] So, if you wouldn't mind all the Boy Scouts [0:18:45] coming up to the podium and one of the times [0:18:47] just introducing yourself, tell us what troop you're with, [0:18:51] what you're working on and where you meet. [0:18:59] I'm Jeffrey Liechman, we're with troop 100 [0:19:02] and I'm working on both the communications merit badge [0:19:04] and the citizenship in the community. [0:19:06] Thank you, sir. [0:19:09] I'm Jaren Rosen, we're, I'm part of troop 100 [0:19:13] and we're working on communications [0:19:15] and citizenship in the community. [0:19:17] Thank you. [0:19:30] Have a perfect. [0:19:31] Thank you. [0:19:33] I'm part of troop 100 and I'm working on that. [0:19:38] Thank you. [0:19:39] My name is Joshua Bell. [0:19:41] I am from troop 100 and I'm working on communications and citizenship in the community. [0:19:47] Joshua, you're the last up so you need to tell me where you guys meet. [0:19:57] Location, building. [0:19:58] We meet in the Eastland Church building. [0:20:02] The Eastland LDS? [0:20:04] Yeah. [0:20:05] Elizabeth, I mean. [0:20:07] Elizabeth LDS Church Building. Okay. Thank you. Thank you, gentlemen. And not a boy scout. [0:20:13] No, you were too sharp up here. We got you. He was taking great notes. [0:20:25] My name is Stephen Beases and I'm from the Shoot164. And what are you working on tonight, Stephen? [0:20:43] Communications. Perfect. Thank you for coming forward. Thank you, gentlemen, for coming this [0:20:47] evening and how we made you earn at least part of your merit badge now, haven't we? [0:20:52] Very good. Thank you. Next item on the agenda is consideration of a request to reject all bids for the [0:20:58] 2014 modification to the Kenyon Springs VOW project and we have John Cake and welcome John. Thank you, Mayor and Council about a month ago, we [0:21:10] advertised and published this project and we received two bids [0:21:15] one in the amounts of [0:21:18] 208,400 and the other one in the amount of 320,000 [0:21:21] which far exceeded our anticipated, our expected bid. [0:21:30] The engineers estimate the construction was 135,000. [0:21:34] We budgeted 100,000, 100,000. [0:21:37] And the reason we budgeted 100 is we were anticipating [0:21:42] on replacing just a thrust block and one valve. [0:21:46] But once we got into the design, we added to the scope [0:21:49] of the work, there were some other valves and other things [0:21:52] that needed to be replaced at the same time, excuse me. [0:21:56] So that's why our estimate went up to 135. [0:21:59] But still, it took us some time here [0:22:03] to figure out why the bids came in so high. [0:22:06] And I really can't tell you why they're high, [0:22:09] but we do feel strongly that they are, [0:22:11] and that if we go back out, [0:22:13] either open and re-bid these, [0:22:16] that we should get a better price, [0:22:18] or we might exercise the option in the code. [0:22:22] And I'm just going to ask you, I can't remember the code citation that allows us to go on to the open market. [0:22:28] We can negotiate directly with another contractor. [0:22:32] If they can prove that they can do it for reasonably less than we can enter in that contract or we can re-bid. [0:22:40] So I'd like a massive council tonight to have the authority to make that decision to either re-bid or to enter into negotiations. [0:22:50] If we were to exercise the option to go out on the open market, negotiate a price, I'd [0:22:56] have to bring that back to counseling for when we can't reprieve that. [0:23:01] So tonight you're asking to reject all the bids and then open it up for either fly it [0:23:09] again or just open market. [0:23:12] So one definitely and then one of the other two. [0:23:16] Fritz? [0:23:18] He's just asking you to reject bids. [0:23:20] Tonight. [0:23:21] When something else happens, it'll come back to you. [0:23:24] Okay, that's, that's, that's clearer. [0:23:27] Thank you very much. [0:23:28] Rebecca Milsoyka. [0:23:30] Thank you, Mayor. [0:23:31] Well, I think it's a reasonable request [0:23:32] and I appreciate your efforts to stay in budget [0:23:35] and for the wisdom to know that hey, [0:23:37] I think we can get a better deal. [0:23:38] So I would move that we reject all bids [0:23:40] for the 2014 modifications to the Canyon Springs [0:23:43] Valve Project. [0:23:44] So you're pushing on board by Rebecca Milsoyka, [0:23:47] seconded by Greg Lanting to reject all bids as stated. [0:23:51] Anything further on the motion counts? [0:23:54] Lee Island, roll call, roll call. [0:23:56] Great glancing. [0:23:57] Yes. [0:23:58] Don Hall. [0:23:59] Yes. [0:24:00] Rebecca Monsuica. [0:24:01] Yes. [0:24:02] Suzanne Hopkins. [0:24:03] Yes. [0:24:04] Sean Bericher. [0:24:05] Yes. [0:24:06] Yes. [0:24:07] Motion passes 6-0. [0:24:08] We will see you again next time. [0:24:10] Next item on the agenda is presentation by police, public information and information services on implementation of emergency mass notification system. [0:24:20] We have Josh Palmer, Lieutenant Craig Stoss, and Tammy Laudit with us this evening. [0:24:25] Welcome. [0:24:26] Thank you, Mr. Mayor, members of the Council. [0:24:29] So if you remember, in September, you asked staff to identify an additional tool that we [0:24:36] could add to our chest that would help notify citizens in the case of emergency. [0:24:40] We had a couple of recent incidents that included a boil order that went to a select area of the [0:24:44] community when we had a waterline break. [0:24:48] And then in, I believe it was 2012, [0:24:50] was when we had the declaration of emergency, [0:24:52] which affected the entire city. [0:24:54] So through a collaborative process [0:24:56] with police department information services [0:24:58] and public information office, [0:25:00] we try to identify a possible tool to them, [0:25:04] or a solution to that. [0:25:05] So what we're bringing to you today [0:25:07] is really just an information item [0:25:09] that we want you to get a better understanding [0:25:11] of what we've been able to identify, [0:25:14] so that it strengths some of the costs [0:25:17] and then give us direction. [0:25:20] We looked through various systems, [0:25:22] and one of them was actually one that we were already using [0:25:24] on a limited basis through a shared license agreement [0:25:27] with CIRCOM. [0:25:28] And it's called Ever Bridge. [0:25:30] It's used nationwide by local, state, county, federal agencies. [0:25:36] It has a proven track record. [0:25:40] It's also been used more close to home [0:25:43] in the cases of the fires that happened up north of what [0:25:45] River, did a fairly decent job of trying to inform citizens there about routes to take and [0:25:51] how to prepare for the emergency, things like things of that nature. [0:25:55] So I want to give you a little bit of background about our limited use with CERCOM. [0:26:00] So we have a shared license agreement with them. [0:26:02] So a couple of years ago there was a federal grant that was awarded to the region to CERCOM [0:26:09] and that would provide an ever-rich system that would be managed by CERCOM and we would [0:26:13] be able to tap into it as a locality. [0:26:16] So by limited use, we don't have complete control over it. [0:26:21] So for example, we had some password changes [0:26:24] that needed to take place, and we [0:26:25] have to receive CIRCOM approval from that to complete that. [0:26:32] There's also additional tools that make it more robust. [0:26:35] At the same rate, it's one of those decisions [0:26:38] that would have to be made through the CIRCOM board. [0:26:40] The one of the options that we've looked at that we're bringing for you today is the possibility [0:26:49] to manage and operate the Everrich system in-house with a dedicated license for the city of Flint [0:26:54] Falls. [0:26:55] Essentially, we would own it. [0:26:59] The cost associated with that though is there's a one-time fee set up and that's about $16,000 [0:27:06] And then after implementation, we're required to pay an annual fee of about $15,000. [0:27:11] If you look at the bottom of the staff report, there's an item there for $1,000, it's a cell [0:27:17] tower override. [0:27:19] So in the case of the boil order, we identified an area where about 320 homes were affected, [0:27:25] only about, well, only 118 of those homes actually had landlines. [0:27:30] So Everbridge offers an addition to make it more robust where it can actually override [0:27:37] cell towers in the case of a very severe emergency that would affect the entire community or [0:27:43] the region itself. [0:27:46] That's for an additional $1,000. [0:27:50] So the system itself is extremely sophisticated. [0:27:55] We're able to use our GIS data to target specific areas of the community, so in the [0:27:59] case of the boil order, to say we only want to send a message to this area. It'll send [0:28:04] it through voice, text, go through all the lists here, basically all the different methods. [0:28:15] There is, it will only reach without the cell tower override, it will only reach cell phones [0:28:24] from users who have opted into the system. This has been a real challenge for us in the past [0:28:29] with our current systems. [0:28:32] If somebody offs into the system, we do have that. [0:28:36] We can send them those notifications. [0:28:38] If they have not, and we have no cell tower override, [0:28:41] those people would not receive that notification. [0:28:46] Like I say, we're bringing this to you as an information item. [0:28:51] We have Lieutenant Craig Staughts and Tammy [0:28:53] Laut of an information services to answer any questions yet. [0:28:56] But ultimately, we're just hoping [0:28:57] to receive some sort of a direction of which [0:28:59] any down this path, let me go down the final alternate. [0:29:03] Okay, so just, I do have a light on, [0:29:04] but what I, you heard you say is that there's a one time 16 [0:29:07] grand, and then there's an additional, [0:29:10] if we choose the $1,000 over ride piece, [0:29:17] it's another 16,000 annually. [0:29:20] That's correct. [0:29:21] Okay, just another 1,000, 1,000. [0:29:23] 1,000, but there's a $15,000 annual fee. [0:29:27] That's what I'm saying, 15 in one, that's 60,000. [0:29:29] No, that's correct, okay. [0:29:31] So Greg Lanning, did we just get a test of this on our cell phones? [0:29:36] I just got an email, I got a text a little bit ago. [0:29:39] Greg's all about effect. [0:29:42] Thank you, nice visual, Lieutenant. [0:29:44] Here, this is just burning. [0:29:48] Rebecca Melsoika. [0:29:49] Thank you, Mayor. [0:29:50] Thanks, Josh. [0:29:51] So the CIRCOM system is exactly the same. [0:29:55] And you said we've had limited opportunity to use this, [0:29:59] is what limits our opportunity? [0:30:00] I mean, have we had trouble in the past when we make requests to utilize it or? [0:30:06] I would say that it's a good question. [0:30:08] You know, this is there are some drawbacks. [0:30:10] One is with Serkom having complete control, or managing the system. [0:30:15] In the case of say, I use the example of say a password. [0:30:20] So if we need to reset a password or get somebody access, [0:30:23] we have to send out information to Serkom and have them approve it before we can actually use it. [0:30:28] It took about an hour for myself to do that in the case of an emergency one hour, it's probably too long. [0:30:35] The other is that the grant will expire in 2016, and we don't know, we reached out to them, we don't know the direction it will take. [0:30:46] Because they are guided by a board, and they've told us they'll be up to the board if they want to continue that. [0:30:54] Within that, if we do, and we do plan to do this, a large promotion, education, and get people to sign up and opt into this, if we have a lot of people opt into it, and then we do decide down the road to do our own system. [0:31:10] Say, CIRCOM does not want to continue the system or there's other changes. [0:31:14] We just for one reason wanted to decide to bring it in. [0:31:16] We can, we will bring in those numbers, but we can't bring in the user's account information. [0:31:21] information so ultimately they're locked out again. [0:31:25] We would have to do some sort of a program to have them read, [0:31:29] I guess, re-opt it to lack a better term to the system [0:31:32] if we bring it in and house. [0:31:33] So those are some of the challenges. [0:31:35] And do you have to change the password every time [0:31:37] you use the system or is that just an example? [0:31:40] So we could have our passwords current in case [0:31:42] there was an emergency. [0:31:44] And that really just came up because there's [0:31:46] a lot of really moving parts in the system [0:31:50] as we've been learning. [0:31:52] And so, you know, we've tested it well, [0:31:56] so you can tell we tested it, [0:31:58] and we've been kind of developing some [0:31:59] but really kind of a preliminary plan [0:32:01] if we do need to use it in case of emergency [0:32:03] and what we did find is that myself and some others, [0:32:07] there were password issues or things of that nature. [0:32:11] Are you also able to target a specific geographic area [0:32:15] through the circum system? [0:32:18] Yes, yeah, we are. [0:32:20] Okay. [0:32:21] So I would just add, I mean, we talk a lot about our partners. [0:32:24] And so I think if we can work together, [0:32:27] we're so common and save taxpayers from paying double. [0:32:31] Because everyone, no matter what pays that 911 fee, [0:32:33] they pay that on their cell phone bills. [0:32:36] So if we can save some multiple buildings, [0:32:43] I guess for the same system, [0:32:46] I think we should try to do that. [0:32:48] The other thing is, if we want to opt into some of the options, [0:32:53] could we ask Circum, you know, maybe work out an agreement [0:32:57] with them, you know, that the City of Twin Falls will pay [0:32:59] for this extra service. [0:33:01] And then the smaller cities around us would actually benefit [0:33:04] from that as well from our partnership. [0:33:18] Well, right now, I think trying to understand your question [0:33:22] as far as working with them. [0:33:26] And obviously, that's what we're doing now. [0:33:28] It's a time where we can actually test the system [0:33:31] and see if it's a viable tool. [0:33:33] And I think that's the important thing [0:33:34] for this presentation tonight. [0:33:36] More of an information gathering for the council. [0:33:40] It's just one tool. [0:33:42] It's a very effective tool. [0:33:43] We highly recommend it. [0:33:45] And as you can see just by the tests that we did, [0:33:48] very quick, simple to use. [0:33:52] I just did this template in about 30 seconds [0:33:55] and then waited until we could send it out. [0:33:58] But I think the confusion that comes into play here [0:34:01] has to do with the auditing and portion of it. [0:34:04] And in two years, as you guys understand, [0:34:06] the grant is going to be done. [0:34:09] And then where do we go from there? [0:34:12] There's a really big educational component of this. [0:34:16] When we had this available to us to use, [0:34:19] we had to test it, obviously. [0:34:21] We had to get our people trained in how to use it, [0:34:24] Our dispatchers, we use it internally for a lot of SWAT [0:34:27] notifications, things like that. [0:34:30] There's a lot of different functionality with this [0:34:33] that we think is extremely valuable. [0:34:37] And I just think that the one thing that's going to be really [0:34:40] difficult to overcome is going to be that [0:34:42] opting in down the road, because it's going to be confusion [0:34:46] for the citizen. [0:34:48] And I would just like to bring that to your attention. [0:34:51] I think that right now, absolutely, [0:34:54] when we're working great with Sir Comin [0:34:56] in utilizing this technology, [0:35:00] I just think that down the road, [0:35:02] it could be a better thing for the city [0:35:06] if it wasn't confusing. [0:35:09] And there's a big educational component [0:35:10] that we still have to push out on this. [0:35:13] So are you thinking more about making that change [0:35:15] in two years when the grant is over? [0:35:17] Are you thinking about making a change prior to that? [0:35:21] Well, I think that we just wanted [0:35:22] to present you with options tonight. [0:35:23] And then we could have another conversation later and decide where to go from there. [0:35:31] Great. Well, I think it's a great system and if it's working, I think we should utilize our partner circle. [0:35:37] And I wanted to show you just real quick, if I can, I'm at the outstanding healthy. [0:35:43] Because you talked about a geographical location. Okay. So you can take this system and this is just part of the city right here. [0:35:57] right here. And every dot that you see represents a land line, so a hard line telephone in the [0:36:04] city. There's probably anywhere between 13 and 15,000 of these in the city limits. But that [0:36:11] just represents a small percentage of the people who have land lines because most people are [0:36:16] now switching to cell phone. So that's where the op-in portion of it is really important [0:36:22] because people are going to keep, if the trend continues, [0:36:26] they're going to be more cell phones and landlines. [0:36:28] But you can take this, and let's say I just [0:36:31] wanted to select this area. [0:36:35] Very simple to do. [0:36:36] I can just go down here to draw shapes, [0:36:38] because I don't want to notify the entire city. [0:36:40] There's just maybe the northern part of the city [0:36:43] needs to be notified of a flood or whatever. [0:36:46] I can just draw the shape on this block. [0:36:49] Let's just say we recognize that this is the area [0:36:51] that we wanted to call. [0:36:53] This is where the problem is with the water line, whatever it might be. [0:37:10] And then, so I've selected this area right here. [0:37:21] As you can see, on the map, it tells me I just selected 18 landline phones in that one block area. [0:37:29] So when I send my message out, and all it takes is just a title, the body of what I want to say, [0:37:34] like I said, you guys, the message, you know, boil order, whatever it might be, [0:37:39] you know, for the next 24 hours, and then I send it out. [0:37:43] And I can send it out either, and people can opt [0:37:48] into this portion of the two, as a text message, [0:37:50] as an email message on their primary phone, [0:37:53] which is going to be their landline, secondary phones, [0:37:56] all these different ways that they can be contacted. [0:37:59] And then when I'm done with that and I select it, [0:38:01] I determine how many times I want that message sent out [0:38:04] the 24-hour period, and then I hit send. [0:38:10] I just give you an idea of, yeah, you can, [0:38:12] you know, a lot of times fire departments use these [0:38:14] if they have a hazmat situation, [0:38:16] and there's a plume and there's a big gas leak [0:38:19] and winds blowing 10 miles an hour, [0:38:21] you know it's heading southwest, [0:38:23] and they're saying it's gonna affect this part of town, [0:38:26] we can use that and notify that section of the town, [0:38:30] and draw a plume and notify those people. [0:38:32] So there's a lot of really neat functions with this, [0:38:35] a lot of really good tools. [0:38:37] Thank you, Lieutenant, Sean Berger. [0:38:40] So how long has this system been available [0:38:42] through Circum? [0:38:46] They had the training for this [0:38:47] a little over a year ago. That was our IS people who went to the training and then it's just [0:38:54] a matter coming back and implemented. So we've maybe had a couple of opportunities in the [0:39:00] last year or so that something like this could have been beneficial. Yes and no. It could [0:39:07] have been. It's a tool again. Right. But what we found actually through utilizing this [0:39:13] there's a lot of things that we had to do to overcome some hurdles. [0:39:20] Whether it was training issues, testing issues, things like that so that we could learn how [0:39:25] to use the system properly. [0:39:26] We're at a point now where we're very confident in using it. [0:39:29] If we had an event tomorrow, we could utilize it. [0:39:33] And then the opt-in component, so if it had this cell tower override, while opting in [0:39:40] is still important, it's maybe not as critical at that point because it's going to blanket [0:39:44] it out and whether you're opt in or not, that would go out. [0:39:50] And is that based on geography? [0:39:52] So you're picking cell towers that are getting overridden or? [0:39:55] Yes. [0:39:57] OK. [0:39:57] Option right now, rather in your circle. [0:40:21] They would have to approve that to have that added in. [0:40:24] And I believe, and I'm going to look for Tammy here, [0:40:27] if we added in ourselves, do we need [0:40:29] a circle on the group to send them? [0:40:34] And their license, my worry would be that even if we paid [0:40:40] for it, it would be available to them for all four counties. [0:40:44] But if we left to mid here, we would have to buy it again, [0:40:48] because we would be paying for it for their license. [0:40:52] OK. [0:40:56] Yeah, so I'll just make a general comment [0:40:58] that we can hear from some other folks. [0:41:00] A little bit, I think, to what Rebecca's point was, [0:41:04] I think this is a great service, [0:41:05] and we need to figure out how to utilize it. [0:41:08] It exists right now, and while it may take some conversation [0:41:11] and understanding of the appropriate process for that to happen through the existing system, [0:41:18] I would lean toward doing that and figuring out the best way to do it as opposed to bail [0:41:27] out of one that's already there and go create our own when maybe we're not quite utilizing [0:41:32] the one that exists now to the fullest extent. Understanding their hurdles and their issues [0:41:40] and it all boils down to just communicating amongst people, [0:41:43] but if that means helping to support the override function, [0:41:52] I think I'd rather have those conversations first [0:41:55] before we were to decide to move out on our own. [0:42:00] Chris, talking. [0:42:01] I think we have a real public safety issue here. [0:42:04] I'm very concerned about the timeline [0:42:07] and the nonchalance of the discussion. [0:42:10] I think we had a damn serious wake-up call that ended up fairly innocuous. [0:42:18] Let's compare this to, as you mentioned, Lieutenant, a major natural gas blowout where [0:42:24] lies were impacted. [0:42:25] Let's talk about a terrorist attack on our water system, the entire system. [0:42:32] I think we need to move expeditiously and we need to move with our own municipal boundaries, [0:42:38] primary concern. I served, I think, three plus years as a [0:42:43] seek, Sir, calmly, as into the city, and is a similar [0:42:47] experience to to that of the land, uh, fill multiple County [0:42:52] solid waste district is driven by small, non populated rural [0:42:58] areas. It does not have the primary population center driving a [0:43:04] lot of us decisions. And in fact, the number of them they are [0:43:07] counter to our best decisions. So whatever decision more quickly gets us the ability to [0:43:15] identify down to a specific house by either a landline, email or a cell phone, I think we [0:43:23] should move. I am not optimistic at all of the cooperation capability of this structure [0:43:29] of CERCOM. [0:43:31] For other mark, every year, I think, Josh, you mentioned that we have a fewer percentage [0:43:36] of landlines and higher percentage of cell only homes. [0:43:41] The last I heard was an excess of 30 percent, primarily among younger people. [0:43:47] My direction is not to engage in lengthy discussions, but to move in the immediate and [0:43:53] best interest, the municipality of Twin Falls. [0:43:56] that $31,000 first year chart sounds pretty cheap. [0:44:02] Greg Lenny. [0:44:05] Well, similar to Chris, I'm a little concerned [0:44:08] and I didn't, I don't want to understand fully [0:44:11] of whether or not through the CIRCOM, [0:44:14] we can do the cell phone part, [0:44:15] because to me without the cell phone component, [0:44:19] it's less than half-assisted at this point. [0:44:23] Because most people, like on the boil order, [0:44:25] You can call them, but most people weren't work. [0:44:28] And so if they got it on their landline, [0:44:31] unless they had an answer machine that they [0:44:35] had availability to or even if they had one, [0:44:38] they weren't going to know about the well, [0:44:39] or even with this system, as it sets now. [0:44:42] So I didn't understand. [0:44:44] Can we add the cell phone component, [0:44:47] but what we're saying for $1,000, [0:44:49] would that do the whole four counties? [0:44:51] Or would that be just our portion, [0:44:53] and they would have to pick up the difference for the rest or. [0:44:56] We would have to talk to the CIRCOM board to see if that's something that they would consider. [0:45:01] From that point, if it's something they would support, there could be options about how that would be funded. [0:45:09] That's a very minimum. I would like to see this move forward with this. [0:45:13] I'm leaning much more closer to Chris's thoughts that we need to go ahead and do it. [0:45:18] but that would be the minimum that I think we should do [0:45:23] is we need to be doing it. [0:45:25] And be honest with you, to Chris's point, [0:45:28] the circum, I'm betting a lot larger percentage [0:45:31] of their residents in the four counties [0:45:35] have landlines than they do until it falls. [0:45:37] I'm just, I don't know why I'm guessing that, [0:45:39] but I'm guessing that, [0:45:40] because you always had a one out on the farm, [0:45:41] and a landline, because you might, [0:45:44] your self-service might not work [0:45:45] and those kinds of things. [0:45:46] So, and like the point being made, [0:45:50] I don't have a home phone line. [0:45:52] I mean, I could even have one with the package [0:45:54] I have with cable one, I could have a home phone [0:45:57] and I choose not to have it. [0:45:58] I just don't care to have one. [0:46:00] So I just use a cell phone only. [0:46:02] And so I would not get any kind of notification [0:46:06] without the cell phone option. [0:46:09] So Zann Hawkins. [0:46:11] Thank you. [0:46:12] I'm gonna go a couple different directions on you, [0:46:13] first of all. [0:46:15] What other software packages did you look at [0:46:17] And were they comparably priced or did you really put all your efforts into this one or? [0:46:24] Well, I don't think we did. [0:46:27] So we look at a couple of different ones. [0:46:28] I mean, there's really only a handful. [0:46:29] There are true mass communication systems that are reliable and will reach a large number [0:46:36] of people in a short period of time, especially with the options that EverBridge has. [0:46:42] So Everrich has the option to say our systems go out of our computers, you could call it in, [0:46:50] and they'll run it for you. [0:46:55] Many of the others don't have that type of service. [0:46:57] The other is also, I couldn't provide you with numbers, but there are systems that have [0:47:04] a limited number of users that they can send it to within a period of time. [0:47:09] At that point, you're going to be paying additional to reach a larger number. [0:47:14] So it was, you know, there are other providers out there. [0:47:19] There's additional costs to get to this level of Everbridge. [0:47:22] But I think probably what Craig or Lieutenant Stoss said earlier is really important is that [0:47:27] we are fortunate enough to be able to try this system through CIRCOM through the grants [0:47:32] and the charge to us. [0:47:35] And it's, there are a lot of moving parts, we've got, it's not ourselves, but there's [0:47:40] then an organization has had an instance [0:47:41] where they forgot to uncheck a box. [0:47:44] And everybody who received that notification [0:47:46] had to call in to get the notification. [0:47:48] And if you can imagine dispatch suddenly receiving 47,000 calls, [0:47:54] makes for quite a headache. [0:47:56] I know the police in the recent past were [0:47:59] looking at a reverse calling system. [0:48:02] Is that still something we're working with or is that this? [0:48:06] That would be this. [0:48:07] That is this. [0:48:07] OK. [0:48:08] I think I should point out is you have blackboards like in a company's blackboard mass communication [0:48:13] they target they specifically focus on schools ever bridges specifically focused on really for [0:48:20] governing organizations. [0:48:23] And did we pay for any of our staff training on that or that all came with the CIRC combit [0:48:28] and then who in our staff has been trained and knows how to use it and is it spread through [0:48:33] the departments or is it strictly with dispatch and IT or? [0:48:38] So the training I came with through the grant. [0:48:41] And we had three of our information services, actually two, from information services and [0:48:47] one of our senior dispatchers, attend that training. [0:48:51] Since that time, we've had the rest of the dispatch personnel trained and we've had some [0:48:58] ongoing training with myself, Josh and Tammy. [0:49:03] Nobody in the fire department's been trained in how to use it yet? [0:49:06] No. [0:49:07] You know, I think being able to reach out to our citizens is critical and we've seen that recently and, you know, I kind of side with the feeling too that I like having it in house and us having control over it. [0:49:21] I think that's important. [0:49:23] I don't like being held if we have an emergency to somebody else's contract. [0:49:29] If we need something, I think we should be self-sufficient to provide that for our citizens. [0:49:34] And it sounds like where we've already got training in this. [0:49:37] You guys are going in the right direction to me, [0:49:39] and I would be interested to see where it goes [0:49:42] as you keep researching it. [0:49:43] And I think another point too. [0:49:47] I think it's important before we really move forward [0:49:49] on which direction we're going to take. [0:49:51] We just need that direction from you because, like I said, [0:49:53] the next push is going to be this educational component, [0:49:55] which is going to be very big. [0:49:57] And we're going to have to use all forms of our media [0:49:59] to get that out, for instance, which [0:50:01] may mean a mailer in their water bill. [0:50:04] It could mean, you know, Facebook. [0:50:07] We may have a place that we could have the citizens call. [0:50:11] They, you know, the elderly that may need help working [0:50:14] through that so that they can get signed up on the system. [0:50:16] We'd have somebody there that could talk to them. [0:50:18] So there's a lot to do and we're just, like I said, [0:50:22] looking for that direction. [0:50:24] I have several questions for you. [0:50:26] First of all, talk to me about the wait time again. [0:50:28] So right now we're hitched [0:50:30] to circum's ability to send these out. [0:50:33] And there's an approval process? [0:50:35] What did I hear you say? [0:50:37] We can send them out without that approval process. [0:50:41] There's different parts to this. [0:50:42] And that's what makes it just a little bit confusing. [0:50:45] I think the main thing is is that if and when this grant [0:50:50] expires and Sir Commer whoever decides they don't want to go [0:50:56] this direction, they don't want to pay for the service, [0:50:59] whatever that looks like, and we've committed to that, [0:51:02] and committed to our citizens to do that, [0:51:07] then I think that, [0:51:11] sauce, my trainer thought, sorry about that. [0:51:15] I think it's important that, I apologize, [0:51:20] I just, if you had the question and I was going, [0:51:22] that was really where I was going, Lieutenant, [0:51:24] is I thought I heard, Josh, or you say that right now, [0:51:28] there's a wait time to be able to even get the information. [0:51:31] I remember, thank you, yes. [0:51:33] So when we do, eventually, if we have to get our own license, [0:51:39] all that data that is in the system now, [0:51:43] we can't just take that and move that to our license [0:51:47] that we would be buying. [0:51:49] Because the people that have opted in [0:51:51] will have lost their login password. [0:51:54] They have to redo it again. [0:51:55] Does that make sense? [0:51:56] Sure. [0:51:57] But my question was, I thought I heard someone say [0:51:59] there's some sort of a wait time of an hour. [0:52:02] What was that about? [0:52:04] That's on the administrative side of it. [0:52:06] So you had your users, which are your citizens, that use it. [0:52:09] Okay. [0:52:10] They're not going to have to wait to get a message. [0:52:12] If a user on that administrative side, [0:52:14] so people actually using it, need to use it. [0:52:16] And there's a hang up say on a password. [0:52:18] I just use that as an example. [0:52:19] Okay. [0:52:20] But on their set up of their account or anything like that, [0:52:23] that's got to go to Circum for permissions. [0:52:26] And for a good reason, even if you do it in house, [0:52:28] you want a group of people that can maintain integrity [0:52:31] the program that you're not having just anybody sent it out. [0:52:34] back in some cases that can be a penalty if you do. [0:52:37] Okay, just some, I have a couple other lights, [0:52:39] but it's kind of my turn now. [0:52:40] So I'm gonna say a few things. [0:52:42] Being someone that lived through [0:52:45] when we transitioned over to CIRCOM, [0:52:46] from our own dispatch center, [0:52:48] and then I was involved with the police department [0:52:50] when we were starting to transition back to our own [0:52:52] dispatch center, we lost so much when we went to CIRCOM. [0:52:57] We lost that personal touch, [0:52:59] we lost the ability to really communicate [0:53:01] with our citizens efficiently that we had before, [0:53:05] because we didn't have control. [0:53:07] I think Chris hit it on the head. [0:53:08] You have an organization that's managed [0:53:13] or directed by a bunch of different entities [0:53:17] that maybe don't have the same needs [0:53:19] that a municipality of our size has. [0:53:21] So I lean more towards, let's get on this. [0:53:25] We've had wake up calls, we've had three of them. [0:53:27] We had a power outage where I remember taking shower that morning and wondering why my water [0:53:33] pressure was so low, where I was actually draining the water that might be needed for fire flow. [0:53:40] And I didn't even know that I shouldn't because I hadn't heard it on the radio or anything [0:53:44] yet. [0:53:45] So this could help with that. [0:53:48] We've had a flood that we could have centered in on those folks that we knew were having [0:53:53] some issues with flooding to get some word out to them immediately and then we [0:53:57] had a boil order and I became extremely frustrated when we were talking about [0:54:01] the boil order how do we get the word out to folks immediately if it's if it's [0:54:07] at a stage that we have to issue a boil order that to me is a public safety [0:54:12] issue and we're not getting the word to him fast now this seems to me to be a [0:54:16] better mechanism there is no 100% I guess if I turn my cell phone off I'm not [0:54:22] kind of get it. I don't have a line line. I'm one of those families that we don't [0:54:26] have a line line anymore. We just have cell phones. I guess that's that's the [0:54:31] downside of this. But it's one more piece where I have in my family right now [0:54:36] three or four that have cell phones. And so one of us won't get it, I hope, [0:54:42] this information. So I if we were to take a vote tonight, I would say let's do [0:54:48] this full-fledged with a thousand dollar ad-in so that we can make sure we [0:54:52] we covered those cell phone towers so that's that's where I'm at Sean Barrow [0:54:57] Lieutenant the sample you were showing us up here because this the actual live [0:55:03] sitcom system or is this a demo so so truthfully today if there were an [0:55:10] emergency right now dispatch could access this system and make a call to [0:55:20] landlines in 30 seconds. So the functionality of it exists minus the [0:55:32] cell tower override today and cell phone opt-in. So what and I'm hearing [0:55:41] what everyone's saying here and I appreciate yes we need to have some sort [0:55:44] of a more robust system that we're utilizing to do a better job of [0:55:48] communicating this things. In my mind, we have at least parts of that right now, and [0:55:55] what I would rather see is to sit down and have a conversation with Sir [0:56:01] Com Administration and their board and say, this system exists, we all can utilize it [0:56:07] right now, establish some procedures for that to happen, and if the response is [0:56:12] no, then let's go find the solution. But I feel like we haven't had that [0:56:18] conversation yet, we're making a lot of assumptions about what [0:56:23] Sir Com's board may or may not do. [0:56:27] I appreciate that there is a potential in two years that, [0:56:32] well, in 2016, that they may not opt to re-up the license and [0:56:36] that would create a hassle, but you know, it's no bigger hassle [0:56:41] truthfully than changing your Netflix password and some of [0:56:43] those things. I mean, it's just, that's the world that we live [0:56:46] sometimes things change. It just seems to me that if we have a system that's in [0:56:52] place already, that's exactly what we're thinking about getting or close to it, [0:56:56] let's have the conversation about how we make it the system that works for us. [0:57:00] And again, if the response is not to move forward with that, then come back to us [0:57:07] and tell us that that was the response. But I hate making a bunch of assumptions [0:57:11] about what we think that relationship is going to be like when we haven't had [0:57:14] of those conversations. [0:57:16] I mean, a simple conversation with CIRCOM to say, [0:57:18] if we kicked in the 1,000 bucks, [0:57:20] would you go for the cell phone override? [0:57:24] If their answer is no, [0:57:25] then we probably know where we're going. [0:57:26] If their answer is yes, [0:57:28] we're in for 1,000 bucks now instead of 60. [0:57:32] I don't, I don't want to discount the week. [0:57:34] We've reached out to CIRCOM, [0:57:36] not over specific issues, [0:57:37] because we don't, we're waiting for council guidance [0:57:39] to see which direction you want to go. [0:57:41] But we have been in communication with CIRCOM [0:57:43] trying to get information from them. [0:57:45] We're not operating the vacuum of leaving Sir Comout or anything of that. [0:57:50] Ms. John, we're back in the mail so I can. [0:57:52] Thank you, Mayor. [0:57:53] You know, I would agree with Councilman Burger. [0:57:56] And also with Councilman Lanting that, you know, [0:58:00] I think the very least we could do it is try to see if Sir Com would be [0:58:04] agreeable to adding that override, that cell tower override, [0:58:09] whatever additional services we want to add. [0:58:13] because $1,000 is certainly less than the $30,000 [0:58:17] that it would cost the citizens that they're already paying for. [0:58:19] I mean, I agree. [0:58:20] You know, these emergencies are critical. [0:58:23] They're important. [0:58:24] And it appears by what you've told us [0:58:27] that we can get this information, these notifications out, [0:58:30] as quick as we could if we bought our own system. [0:58:34] And I think two years is plenty of time [0:58:37] to try out the system and let people utilize the CIRCON system. [0:58:41] You know, if the federal grant expires and the money's not there, we decide to go with [0:58:45] the different system. [0:58:46] I think two years is plenty of time for people to understand. [0:58:50] Certainly people move in and out of the community. [0:58:52] It would probably be a good idea to do another public information push anyway to have people [0:58:58] opt in. [0:59:00] But I just can't see how it's the benefit of the citizens of Twin Falls to pay twice [0:59:05] for a service that they're already getting. [0:59:07] I mean, in our strategic plan, we talk a lot about partnerships and partnering, and I would [0:59:13] just hate for us to make this move without actually trying to utilize this partnership. [0:59:19] I think it would really be a disservice to our own citizens, but also the communities around [0:59:24] us. [0:59:25] I think what's great about when we work together is that a bigger, stronger, more financially [0:59:30] strong city like Twin Falls can be a benefit to smaller towns that may not be able to afford [0:59:35] that service. [0:59:36] What a great thing that we can help the communities around us to enjoy better communications awareness system, you know, I just think there's really no way to lose. [0:59:47] And I agree with Sean that, you know, we need to talk to Sir Com and then if it doesn't work out, we can go different direction. [0:59:53] Chris, talking to well so much for assumptions. [0:59:56] Let me give you just one more story of what happened rather than the claim that it's all theoretical. [1:00:01] One of the driving arguments for leaving the multiple county [1:00:05] circumn was billing when an emergency call came into the [1:00:11] multiple county circumn from a rural area. There may be only [1:00:15] one or two homes. Let's say it was a car accident or a fire [1:00:19] bail of hay going up. There might be a farmer call in. [1:00:25] There would be one charge. When there was an accident in Twin Falls, [1:00:30] Let's say on any urban street, you may have a half dozen calls come in and guess what? [1:00:35] That's the same incident, but we were billed six times for as many people that called in. [1:00:41] That wasn't an assumption that was a fact that was driven by a rural versus an urban architecture. [1:00:49] I think that we have a spoonful of philosophy done and I think they just need to have a [1:00:53] motion to see whether we're going to go on our own or take our time and act like it's [1:00:59] not an emergency. I think it borders more on an emergency. And as such, I'll just blow [1:01:04] the motion that City of Twin Falls pursue its own emergency notification system per the [1:01:10] outline described. [1:01:11] Second, we have a motion on board by Chris talking in second and by Greg Lanting, as stated, to [1:01:18] go on basically to do with the addition of the idon of $1,000 direction that was in your [1:01:26] staff report. I have another light Sean Berger. I appreciate that there are challenges in [1:01:37] the functionality of the dispatch components between Circum and the city. That's why the [1:01:43] city when it made its own dispatch system. This is different. This is about a system that allows [1:01:52] us to communicate directly with our citizens, us, not Circum. Circum isn't sending the message [1:01:59] out, CERCOM isn't making the decision that we're going to send the message out. Craig [1:02:05] just used the existing system to send us text messages what we're sitting here and didn't [1:02:10] have to have a vote of the CERCOM board to make that decision to send it out. I think there [1:02:17] needs to be established procedures on how that works because it is a shared license. And I [1:02:24] think we can have that conversation soon. And again, if the response is, it's our [1:02:29] license and we're not going to play with you, then so be it. Let's move forward. [1:02:33] But I think to go out and spend $31,000 like that, when the system already exists, [1:02:41] we actually have use of it without having that conversation, is a waste of [1:02:47] resources for our taxpayers, but throughout the region. We have an [1:02:53] motion on floor anything further on the motion. Leila, roll call vote please. Don Hall? Yes. Rebecca [1:03:00] Milsoyka? No. Suzanne Hawkins? Yes. Sean Baraker? No. Chris Talkington? Yes. Greg Latin? Yes. Motion passes. 4, 3, 4 to 2. Yeah, 4 to 2. It took me a minute. Usually F7. Thank you. Thank you for [1:03:22] presentation, the three of you. Next item on the agenda, there's actually two and [1:03:26] we these are the two that we added. I had a little bit of a conversation with a [1:03:30] couple of you prior to this because I was a little bit unsure about these [1:03:35] ballots. Two of them came in to the city and they come to me many times in my box [1:03:41] and I wanted to go over them with you. So the first one is regarding an eye [1:03:45] crimp board of trustee election process. Well let me just cut to the chase. Maybe [1:03:51] maybe what we need to do with both these items and I'll just take your guidance on this council [1:03:56] is give me a few days of checking into this a little bit further because the folks that [1:04:01] I've talked to actually went to Greg as well as Chris because Chris is tenure on council [1:04:07] seated if he remembers if we had received these kind of ballots before and Greg because he's [1:04:12] so active in the AIC and asked and he was the previous mayor if we've had these kind of ballots [1:04:18] One of them is for a I-cramp board of trustee election process. [1:04:22] And the other one is for the FSA committee election. [1:04:26] So maybe the direction we should go is give me about a week. [1:04:30] I'll present this again next week and try to do some further research on them. [1:04:35] Does that sound good to the council? [1:04:36] Then we can just cut to the chase on both these items. [1:04:39] Definitely. [1:04:40] Great landing. [1:04:40] Well, that's one of those things where I've had a chance, [1:04:43] like you said, you have a chance to look at them. [1:04:45] And I fully agree that they look at them. [1:04:48] The one I know one of the candidates and I have no, you know one, so in most things you're going to vote for the one you know, on the other ballot, I actually know four of the six. [1:05:02] And so I don't know your, I didn't see whether you're supposed to vote for one or three or what it was, but I think that's the one vote for one. [1:05:11] out of the five. Like I said, I know one that will one, two, three, and four of the five. So, well, I just I [1:05:18] guess where I'm at is I don't have enough information with this is even my dynamics. I'm not sure why we're voting on the [1:05:26] second one. The first one, we're part of Minecraft. We belong to that crap. It's our week liability [1:05:31] insurance. We've thought we pay to them. I see why we're voting on I have no idea what we're voting on the [1:05:37] the other one. Well, give me if again, I got mostly head nods here, give me a week to do [1:05:41] some further research and I'll bring that to the council's attention. And both of them [1:05:45] state that we make the vote. So it's a public vote that we will do here and we'll roll from [1:05:50] there. Is that sound good? I see head nods. So next item on the agenda is the last item [1:05:56] under items for consideration. That's public input and or items of city manager and city [1:06:00] council. Anyone from the public, first of all, that would like to approach the council [1:06:04] with any thing that they'd like to talk to us about. [1:06:09] City manager. [1:06:11] Mr. Mayor, members of the council, just two quick items. [1:06:13] Number one, the city's offices will be closed [1:06:17] in observance and veteran say. [1:06:19] So thank you to all those veterans [1:06:21] and who have served our country and provided that freedom. [1:06:25] And so we'll be closed tomorrow. [1:06:27] We'll be reopened on Wednesday morning at eight o'clock. [1:06:32] Second item is there will be a ribbon cutting [1:06:36] and a celebration of the restoration of the nearly 100-year-old streetlights that was sent [1:06:43] out, an email was sent out just a few minutes ago by Kelly Weeks. [1:06:47] It will be this Friday at 4 o'clock PM and the location will be at 147 Lincoln Street. [1:06:53] So I just wanted to make that announcement so that if there are individuals in the neighborhood [1:06:57] or in the community interested in going to that ribbon-cutting, they are aware of it and you [1:07:05] should all have an email with the invitation in your boxes. [1:07:10] Thank you, Travis. [1:07:10] City Council. [1:07:12] I just want to mention that several of us [1:07:15] were able to attend the library 75th anniversary [1:07:20] of the new building. [1:07:21] I think that's right, 1939. [1:07:24] First of all, hats off to the library themselves. [1:07:27] What a beautiful building, well-kept asset [1:07:32] in our community. [1:07:33] And I learned so much that night. [1:07:36] I learned about City Council and Foundation Board differences back in 1939. [1:07:42] I learned that the actual library was built in 1939 and then the first edition was in [1:07:48] 75, Chris. [1:07:49] Is that 75? [1:07:50] I would, I remember studying me. [1:07:55] And then 91, 91 I think was the big edition on it and what a treasure for our community [1:08:03] and well-run and we're just blessed to have it in our community so anything [1:08:08] further from council all right moving on we do have a public hearing it is a [1:08:13] request for annexation of 4.75 acres of undeveloped land for the proposed [1:08:20] development of a municipal water storage facility on property located at 2951 [1:08:27] Marie Avenue for the City of Twin Falls. [1:08:31] This is a public hearing and our presenter this evening [1:08:35] on behalf of the city is Jonathan Spendlove. [1:08:37] So welcome Jonathan. [1:08:40] Thank you Mr. Mayor and members of council. [1:08:43] So this is coming for you, Frantic Station. [1:08:45] You heard previous presentation from the engineering department [1:08:47] about the water system they were proposing there. [1:08:50] The property is purchased back December of 2013. [1:08:54] And then we had that presentation by Lee, [1:08:57] at Gleason from the Hintering Department in July. [1:09:00] This is to annex the property. [1:09:02] It wasn't previously annexed when they acquired the property. [1:09:06] It did not need to be for us to go forward the project [1:09:09] to do the timelines this was coming after. [1:09:13] So we did increase the notification for this public hearing. [1:09:18] You have a map for that just so you have for your information. [1:09:31] difficult to see it, but the all the land within the red marks [1:09:35] was the increase on the occasion, [1:09:37] further than the regular or state required 300 feet, [1:09:41] wanted to make sure the council knew that we did that. [1:09:44] Twin Falls, Code sections 10, 15, 1 and 10, 15, 2. [1:09:48] There is a required public hearing [1:09:50] before the Planning and Zoning Commission. [1:09:52] They recommend the correct zone or the zone that they wish. [1:09:55] We would like to see this remain during their public hearing. [1:10:00] That was done on October 14th, it's a pretty simple one, we've already got the plans, they've [1:10:10] already been digging and we've already done a really good job with the proposed water towers. [1:10:17] On October 14th, the Commission unanimously recommended the existing C1 zoning designation [1:10:21] be appropriate for the site and consistent with the surrounding area. [1:10:25] In conclusion, staff concurs with the Commission's recommendation that C1 is the appropriate zoning [1:10:29] designation and staff supports the annexation of the site. [1:10:33] We will be annexing to the far side of the road. [1:10:37] So we'll be maintaining the road on that section. [1:10:40] That's something I have an agreement with the Twin Falls Highway District. [1:10:43] It was worked out with Jackie and the Engineering Department. [1:10:48] John, I have a question. What if we don't annex it? [1:10:50] What difference does that make? [1:10:52] The only difference really is that we would then go to the state for our electrical permit. [1:10:57] If not, you guys approved the use for a water tank. [1:11:03] The zoning allows for it and the only difference would be that we would go to the state for our electrical permit [1:11:09] We have jurisdiction over all the other building permits that are required. They've already been approved [1:11:14] The electrical permit hasn't been pulled because that work hasn't been done [1:11:18] That's it and we wouldn't take over the full session of the road even not yet if we didn't that [1:11:25] Okay, it's something we've done a little bit further up on [1:11:36] practice the last few years to do that so we have control of our own properties. [1:11:43] Okay, excellent. [1:11:44] We have a couple of lights. [1:11:45] We're stalking. [1:11:46] Just a peripheral question I might relate to, John, maybe you can answer it or are we keeping [1:11:50] that groundwater down all that loose soil? [1:11:54] The neighbors to the north are impacted obviously and I think without amount of dirt we've got [1:12:01] to make an extraordinary measure. [1:12:02] I think we can make sure they're following all the best management practices to keep the [1:12:06] construction cycling done. [1:12:08] That's a good point. [1:12:08] Cleaned up or watered down. [1:12:10] There's no. [1:12:11] The wind's been blowing a little bit better. [1:12:12] Would you get back to us on that with an email? [1:12:14] I can definitely direct the right person [1:12:16] to get back to you. [1:12:17] Thank you. [1:12:18] That's fur on us. [1:12:21] Did you want to address that, John? [1:12:23] I think John did a good job of thinking they are. [1:12:26] They have been watering it, but it's a lot of dirt. [1:12:29] Yeah. [1:12:30] And with the winds coming up. [1:12:32] Thank you. [1:12:33] Rebecca, Mel, so I got. [1:12:34] Thank you, Mayor. [1:12:35] So currently we're not maintaining any portion [1:12:41] of Hankins where it touches the proposed annexation [1:12:47] and when we annex we would maintain a portion of it. [1:12:50] It is one for the engineering department. [1:12:51] I know they have an agreement with the Twin Close High [1:12:54] with the district to maintain the roads [1:12:56] in a way that is beneficial for both us and them. [1:13:00] The easiest way as far as plowing on things like that. [1:13:03] I think it's a shared cause as far as ship sealing [1:13:07] and things like that. [1:13:08] exact locations I'm not sure of right now so is there an increase in cost of [1:13:15] road maintenance with the annexation if the if there is it's insignificant you're [1:13:22] looking at less than probably 300 feet less than 300 linear feet and it's [1:13:32] probably actually more costly from a management perspective not to work and [1:13:37] and probably do all of the work north of the Kimberly Road on Hankins in the sections that we have shared maintenance. [1:13:43] And it is to lift the plow for that little bit or to not chip seal when the appropriate zone maintenance schedule goes around. [1:13:51] I can't tell if I got an answer. [1:14:01] Well, I think the point is, couldn't make it planning. [1:14:04] Thank you. [1:14:05] Sorry, Mayor. [1:14:07] I think the point that Travis made, we're already maintaining half the road for that 300 feet. [1:14:12] and so to maintain the other half the road for that 300 feet. [1:14:16] I mean, how do you not? [1:14:18] If you think about it, if you're already maintaining half of it, [1:14:22] when our snow plot goes down that road, [1:14:23] I'm sure it doesn't only go one direction [1:14:27] and only plow the west side of the road. [1:14:30] I mean, it's one of those things where, [1:14:32] or the highway district truck goes down, [1:14:34] it doesn't just do one half the road. [1:14:37] So I'm sure that, and at some point, [1:14:39] And if you look at the direction our city is flowing, I think Hank is going to be urged [1:14:45] pretty quick anyway. [1:14:46] So John, can you like to address that further? [1:14:50] Just to comment on the maintenance. [1:14:53] Yeah, we have, there's several different pieces of Hankins that defies logic and who maintains [1:15:00] it. [1:15:01] But really it boils down to a good relationship with the highway district. [1:15:04] There's portions of it that we don't own that we currently maintain. [1:15:08] This intersection is one of those intersections that I believe is on our plow route. [1:15:12] I also know that as the northeast who are went through the half the roads already replaced. [1:15:19] So just the west half is like Mr. Lanning said, it's that 300 feet on the west side. [1:15:28] Rebecca Milsock. [1:15:29] Oh, thank you. [1:15:30] So I think that does answer my question. [1:15:32] I appreciate that. [1:15:33] So similar to Don's question, I mean is there an advantage to annexing it? [1:15:38] I mean, because it's in the area of impact anyway, correct? [1:15:41] And so we really have most authority in the area of impact anyway. [1:15:46] Yeah, it would be the practice of having governmental jurisdiction over our own property. [1:15:50] And we are doing the same with the school side with our PI station. [1:15:54] They came in, we added on to it, and so it's all false. [1:15:58] Really the only difference. [1:16:00] Paperwise is the electrical permit as far as this project goes. [1:16:04] That is the only thing. [1:16:05] Thanks. [1:16:07] Anything further from council before I open it up to public in comments. [1:16:13] All right, we are opening up the public hearing to public comments at this time. [1:16:19] Anyone in the audience that would like to address the council and the public regarding [1:16:24] this issue? [1:16:25] I've seen no one coming forward, so this time I'm close to public hearing portion of the [1:16:35] meeting and turning it over to council for their direction. [1:16:39] that they have any further questions or a motion. [1:16:42] Greg Lanning. [1:16:43] I move that we approve the annexation [1:16:45] of 4.75 acres of undeveloped land [1:16:48] for proposed development of a municipal water storage facility [1:16:51] and property located at 2951 Marie Avenue [1:16:55] for the city of Twin Falls. [1:16:57] Second. [1:16:58] Motion on board by Greg Lanning. [1:17:00] Seconded by Suzanne Hawkins as stated. [1:17:04] Greg Lanning. [1:17:05] Well, just a quick comment. [1:17:06] I really do believe that what Jonathan said [1:17:09] that we probably really should have jurisdictional control [1:17:16] of any property we actually own, [1:17:18] especially those that are next to city property. [1:17:22] And so I would think I would vote for yes, [1:17:24] on almost any of these, [1:17:26] you'd probably vote for where we're next [1:17:28] in our own city property. [1:17:29] We did a lot of that along the canyon ramp [1:17:32] and things to make sure that we have control of them. [1:17:34] And I just think that makes governmental sense. [1:17:39] You know, I agree. I mean, it just only makes sense. The only question, the reason I asked [1:17:43] the question is just such an odd thing, you know, what if we didn't and you answered that [1:17:48] well. I think that we need to have control of what's in front of us. And this is another [1:17:52] mechanism to help us have that control. If there's nothing further, Council, I will go [1:18:01] vote of vote? The item? [1:18:03] Rodeckin Milsunka? Yes. [1:18:05] Suzanne Hawkins? Yes. [1:18:07] Sean Burger? Yes. [1:18:08] He's talking to you. Yes. [1:18:10] Greg Glatte? Yes. [1:18:11] Don Hall? Yes. [1:18:13] Motion passes 6-0. [1:18:15] Next item on the agenda is a potential adjournment into Executive Session 67-2345-1E to consider [1:18:26] preliminary negotiations involving matters of trade or commerce in which the [1:18:30] governing body is in competition with governing bodies in other states or [1:18:34] nations Stanford motion council. [1:18:36] So moved. Second. [1:18:38] We have a motion on the floor by Greg Lanning seconded by Chris [1:18:43] Talkington to move into executive session anything further than that motion council. [1:18:47] We add a roll call vote. [1:18:48] Suzanne Hopkins. [1:18:49] Yes. [1:18:50] Sean Berriger. [1:18:51] Yes. [1:18:51] Chris Talkington. [1:18:52] Yes. [1:18:53] Greg Lanthine. [1:18:54] Yes. [1:18:54] Don Hall. [1:18:55] Yes. [1:18:55] We will be moving into executive session, [1:18:57] adjourning into executive session. [1:18:59] We will not be making any decisions in this session, [1:19:01] nor will we be coming back out this evening and reconvening.