Oversight Archive: City Council meeting, 2015-02-09, recording 1 (started 17:00) Machine transcript (faster-whisper base.en), not checked word for word; the Pledge of Allegiance is shown in its standard wording. The recording is the record. Times are time into the recording. Passages with private details are muted in the audio and marked here. The audio on the page below was re-encoded by software from the video the agency posted. Check any passage against that audio before relying on it. Page: https://oversightarchive.org/twin-falls-id/meetings/2015-02-09/ [0:14:34] I'd like to call the meeting of the Twin Falls City Council Order. [0:14:37] It's February 9th, 2015, and it is 5 o'clock in the evening. [0:14:42] Please rise for those of you wishing to join us in the Pledge of Allegiance. [0:14:49] And Pledge of Allegiance. I pledge allegiance to the Flag of the United States of America, and to the Republic for which it stands, one Nation under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all. [0:15:04] I'd like to welcome everyone to our meeting. [0:15:07] We do have a quorum of the City Council, six members are here this evening. [0:15:11] Rebecca Milsoica had previous engagements, she's not able to make it this evening. [0:15:16] Mr. Rothweiler, do we have any amendments to our agenda? [0:15:19] There are no amendments this evening. [0:15:21] Thank you, sir. [0:15:22] And this is the time for us to open up for the general public, for [0:15:26] anyone that might have something they would like to address the council on. [0:15:31] This is time for you to come forward. [0:15:33] We'll open it up for you. [0:15:36] see no one coming forward, but I'm going to take liberty of I got a card sent to me [0:15:42] and I'm just gonna say it's sent to the city from a Girl Scout through Silver [0:15:51] Sage Council and it says happy wish for happiness happy okay have a happy [0:16:00] Valentine's Day wish for happiness Valentine's Day is filled with [0:16:04] happiness hearts Cupid and Cupid arrows I just wanted to share that with the rest [0:16:08] of the council so that's very very nice and we wish for happiness but do they [0:16:13] know the bill of orange we could certainly ask yes Jackie [0:16:19] Jackie Fields our city engineer brownie scouts are the little girls that are [0:16:26] second and third grade and they're encouraged to send valentines to people [0:16:32] including government officials just as a matter of appreciation so I'm assuming [0:16:38] and that this is probably written by seven or eight year olds [0:16:41] based on the content and that's the context of it. [0:16:44] Well, thank you, Jackie, that's the actual relation. [0:16:48] Basically on the back, she's right on track. [0:16:50] This card was made by Katie, H8, truth 602, [0:16:53] service unit 19, three creek Idaho. [0:16:57] So that's awesome. [0:16:58] Just wanted to share that with the council. [0:17:00] Moving along to the consent calendar [0:17:02] and I'll turn that over to Council's direction. [0:17:06] Move it up. [0:17:07] Okay, I move approval of the consent calendar second. We have a motion on the floor by [0:17:12] Suzanne Hawkins seconded by Chris talking into approve the consent calendar as [0:17:17] posted anything further on that motion council. Leila roll call vote yes Jim [0:17:26] mine yes yes yes yes yes yes yes yes yes [0:17:31] motion passes six to zero moving down to items for consideration the first item [0:17:37] is consideration of a request to approve a contract with CH2M Hill for design of the [0:17:43] headworks expansion at the wastewater treatment platform for the amount not to [0:17:48] exceed $707,450 and we have Troy Vitek. Welcome Troy. Tonight I'm bringing forth a [0:18:02] request to allow the city engineer to sign task order number 15 amendment number [0:18:09] And what this is, is at the wastewater treatment plant, we went through the first project, and [0:18:17] we told the voters that we would like to get to 16 million gallons. [0:18:20] The project is underway right now, including IFS, Basin, the secondary clarifier, and some [0:18:25] other improvements throughout the plant. [0:18:27] In order to go beyond that, there's larger projects out there, and the next one, the next [0:18:33] trigger, would be the headworks facility. [0:18:35] So the sanitary waste comes into this building here as you enter the planets on the right-hand [0:18:40] side and that's where majority of the grid is removed and just taken to the landfill [0:18:46] right then in there. [0:18:47] And then the rest of the process takes the smaller particles out. [0:18:52] That project is estimated right now at six and a half million dollars for that construction. [0:18:57] But we don't know that for sure and we don't know the scope of it. [0:19:01] So we have engaged with CH2 email to say, what does this project look like and what is the [0:19:07] actual value of it, your estimate, and so that we can go into that process. [0:19:11] We currently have a contractor on site that is working on these projects and they may be [0:19:16] a very good resource to go to them and say, if you were to do this, how much would it [0:19:21] cost? [0:19:22] And that could, depending on how it's approached, possibly be available. [0:19:28] Or we can shelve the plans and do it at some of the future point when we have either another [0:19:33] need for it. [0:19:35] So the reason I'm here tonight is I'd like to start the process with CH2M here and have [0:19:39] you approve this contract with them. [0:19:42] This would include design of the plans for the headworks. [0:19:45] There's also some secondary stuff in there that's SCADA improvements. [0:19:50] The plan is to get in older. [0:19:51] The computers are starting to get outdated. [0:19:53] This is an update to those two. [0:19:55] They would go through the process. [0:19:57] In case we don't have the full amount needed to cover this. [0:20:04] So right now we have $5.1 million left. [0:20:09] This project is valued at $6.5 million. [0:20:11] We've got a really good deal. [0:20:13] We're found saving somewhere in the design. [0:20:16] It probably won't cover the future design of this. [0:20:18] But there's other projects we can do in this contract will dress skated, which is one of [0:20:23] those main projects. [0:20:26] So here tonight to ask for permission [0:20:29] to spend this contract and move forward. [0:20:31] Very good, looks like Travis wants to add. [0:20:34] Yeah, I just want to make sure that it is clear, [0:20:36] and just so what we're talking about is the savings [0:20:41] that has been realized associated [0:20:43] with just the wastewater treatment plant portion [0:20:46] of the project. [0:20:48] As you'll recall, there were two pieces [0:20:50] of the bond issue for $38 million. [0:20:53] There was $32 million that was set aside [0:20:56] for the wastewater treatment facility. [0:20:59] There was another $6 million that was set aside [0:21:02] for the collections facility. [0:21:04] The collections facility is not included in the conversation. [0:21:07] We've taken those dollars and we've placed them off [0:21:10] to the side. [0:21:11] So all of the savings that we're talking about [0:21:14] was on the original project and the original costs moving forward. [0:21:19] We also have some capacity fees that [0:21:21] have been collected. Capacity fees are fees that are paid by industrial, residential, all [0:21:28] users of the system, which is to buy capacity into the plant, and those funds can only be [0:21:35] used for the wastewater treatment facility, and specifically the collection systems or [0:21:41] anything that would assist with the overall capacity at the plant. We could use some of [0:21:47] those dollars and that's how Troy is coming up to roughly about $5.1 million [0:21:51] that could be possibly available for this again that is not including the [0:21:57] $6 million that is already put aside in your mark for collection projects. [0:22:02] Thank you Travis. Lee Island would you mind can you turn up the podiums might [0:22:08] just a little bit it's a little hard to hear up here. Sean Berger. So so within [0:22:16] In that 5.1 million in savings we've realized so far, this 707,000 would come out of that [0:22:25] as well. [0:22:26] That's correct. [0:22:27] For the design work. [0:22:28] And then I see as you go through the tasks that are different thresholds, you get a 30% [0:22:34] design, then a 60% design, then a 90% design. [0:22:39] At some point through this process, say you get to the 60% and it's, hey, it's going to [0:22:45] be a four million dollar project we think then we could have that conversation [0:22:50] about proceeding or you get to that point and it's hey it's going to be a [0:22:53] twelve million dollar project can you kind of say yes well then we're just [0:22:58] going to stop there and and when we think we can figure out how to have that [0:23:02] money then we'll finish it out yeah we can stop at any time this is a not-tick [0:23:05] seat okay so we would want to probably get to the 60% to say this is [0:23:10] file board or not because that'd be the point where they really start hardening up those numbers. [0:23:14] Okay. I mean again I think it's a great opportunity to look at other opportunities down there to further [0:23:23] expand within the what we talked to the voters about. So I would be supportive of them. [0:23:30] Thanks Sean. Thanks Sean. Chris, talk to you. [0:23:32] Well I tried to fathom through that first 18 pages on somewhat of a numbers guy but it was beyond my [0:23:38] but I guess I'm approaching Sean's questions a little different. [0:23:42] The 707,000 is that a fixed contract price? [0:23:46] No. If not, if you could explain about what [0:23:50] what about the inevitable weather delays and equipment problems [0:23:54] and change orders, how will that impact? So this is the design portion [0:23:58] only. Okay. So a lot of those are kind of take it out of it. [0:24:02] So there's kind of a construction manager and stuff like that, but they [0:24:06] a manager and stuff like that, but they do it per sheet in man hours. So if they get into it [0:24:13] a lot, so there's kind of an upfront cost and then it starts taping off as the design crew goes into [0:24:18] it. So there's, we can stop the project at any time and say, you know, we found that this isn't [0:24:24] working and we can stop this contract and that's the pages that we would get on the table. More [0:24:29] probably a conceptual type design, so it's what the 30% would be. We think there should be in this [0:24:34] This area should be roughly this big and this is kind of like a figuration. [0:24:37] When you get to the 60% design, you start to get it to the actual equipment, details, [0:24:42] and then at the 90%, you really start to find all the nuts and bolts on it. [0:24:47] So we can stop anywhere along the way. [0:24:49] We don't have to spend the whole contract if we find it's not viable. [0:24:52] Since this is largely designed, none of these variables really should play into that. [0:24:57] Very few. They will have some onsite stuff, but we also have a construction manager [0:25:01] currently looking after this facility so he can he can go out here and take [0:25:05] pictures of necessary measures and so kind of get the best of both worlds there. [0:25:09] Thank you. Do we have any further questions for Troy? We'll stand for [0:25:15] direction. Sean Berger. I would move to approve the contract with CH2M Hill for [0:25:22] design of the headworks expansion of the wastewater treatment plant for an [0:25:26] amount not to exceed seven hundred seven thousand four hundred fifty dollars [0:25:30] second motion on four by Sean and [0:25:33] server seconded by Greg Lanting as stated can we have anything further on that [0:25:38] motion council we have a roll call vote please Jim [0:25:42] mine yes Sean Baragurd yes yes talking yes [0:25:46] great one team yes Don Hall yes Suzanne [0:25:49] Hopkins yes motion passes sixty zero thank you [0:25:53] That's right. [0:25:54] Next item on the agenda is consideration of request and negotiate into an agreement with [0:25:59] the Twin Falls school district to construct irrigation improvements in the vicinity of the [0:26:05] new South Hills Middle School and to use funds budgeted for the Castlewood pressure irrigation [0:26:11] station for the work and we have Lee Glazeman, welcome to the lead. [0:26:17] Good evening, Mayor and Council, yes as I said in my staff report. [0:26:35] In the south side of town, the Twin Falls School District is planning on building a new [0:26:40] school in this region right here. [0:26:42] This is Harrison Street. [0:26:44] This is 3,600. [0:26:46] This is Washington. [0:26:47] So, the Twin Falls School District is planning on building the South Hills Middle School right [0:26:52] there. [0:26:55] Back in 2000, we started doing the pressureized irrigation for the different subdivisions. [0:27:05] We built a PI station right here, and it provides water for these subdivisions right here, and [0:27:12] also this to beneath a park up in this area, but it doesn't have the capacity to provide [0:27:18] pressurized irrigation to these new subdivisions here or any other subdivisions in this area. [0:27:24] It's limited, we can't get a water to it, we don't have enough power there, and we can't [0:27:30] waste the water. [0:27:31] So with the Twin Falls School District coming into this area, we knew that they would have [0:27:35] to pipe water across their property and they'd have to build their own pressurized irrigation [0:27:40] station. [0:27:43] We saw an opportunity to be able to build our own PI station in this area. [0:27:56] All right, our first picture of the school. [0:28:03] So the school district, they'd have to pipe a gravity irrigation level across the property [0:28:12] like this down and off to the edge of the property. [0:28:15] They're planning on building a pressurized irrigation station right there. [0:28:19] Historically, they have to deliver about a hundred shares through this pipe, and so we [0:28:25] saw the opportunity that if we could get as many shares as possible through there, I think [0:28:29] the number is 200. Then we could potentially build a new pressurized irrigation station [0:28:33] right there and then the piping across the property would be upsized. Since the Twin Falls [0:28:38] canal or since the school district already has to put a pipe through that area, we should [0:28:45] only have to pay for just the upsize of that pipe. If it's like an 8-inch pipe, we would [0:28:50] originally have to pay for the additional cost to go to like a 10 or 12-inch pipe. Along [0:28:56] Along with that, we'd also be installing a pressurized irrigation line up to the subdivisions [0:29:02] and tie in right here and then another tie in back over here. [0:29:12] One of the nice things about this is their contractor is already going to be in there [0:29:16] working. [0:29:17] And so we'd be able to enter into an agreement that when they bid out the work that we would [0:29:22] include the sizes that we need and then we would pay the difference in the cost between [0:29:27] what the school district would have built and we would take care of our costs. [0:29:35] This does not include the actual construction of the pressurize irrigation station right [0:29:38] down here. [0:29:39] The pressurize irrigation station also needs an additional easement to be able to fit it [0:29:43] in and we have an easement right here that we need and I think that may already be on [0:29:49] plan and the Castlewood pressurized irrigation station had there was $225,000 in the budget [0:29:57] to build a Castlewood PI station. [0:30:00] It's a similar type of a situation. [0:30:03] The pressurized irrigation station is going in into a subdivision area that's currently [0:30:07] being provided with irrigation water through potable water. [0:30:11] This is another remnant that we haven't upgraded yet, so rather than build the station over [0:30:16] at Castlewood this year. We'd hope to be able to use the funding for Castlewood to be able [0:30:21] to pay for this work. And once again, this is all piping pretty much. And so we would [0:30:26] still, in the current budget cycle, we'd be looking to budget for money this fall to be [0:30:31] able to build a pressurize irrigation station and take that. We'd like to enter into an agreement [0:30:38] with the Etrun Falls School District to partner up on this. [0:30:44] Chris, talking in has questions. [0:30:47] Lee, I'm a little puzzled now. [0:30:49] We don't have the system right now, but we're going to, in large or provide the system, but [0:30:58] using potable water, is that the long-term solution? [0:31:02] Or did I misunderstand? [0:31:03] I mean, why would we? [0:31:04] You want to do that pretty quick, Chris. [0:31:06] Currently, all these subdivisions, the early subject, when we started requiring subdivisions [0:31:12] do pressurize irrigation, that the City of Twin Falls had committed to building the pressurize [0:31:18] irrigation stations. The subdivisions built the internal piping. So this subdivision right here [0:31:24] has pressurize irrigation pipe. And so does all of these streets, but right now we're providing [0:31:30] water through potable water. And so we're using potable water for irrigation in those subdivisions [0:31:39] because we just don't have any canal company water that's pressurized to be able to put [0:31:44] into those pipes. [0:31:46] And so what this new station would do is it would tie into those pipes so we could shut [0:31:51] off the pot of the water going into those systems. [0:31:55] Okay so sometime in the future it would be non-potable. [0:31:59] Right. [0:32:00] And if we get the funding to be able to build the station we would hope to build that this [0:32:05] next fall. [0:32:06] Okay. [0:32:07] Thank you. [0:32:08] Sorry for being so thick. [0:32:09] I don't think I was clear. [0:32:10] That's kind of typical with most of our subdivisions when we first started out. [0:32:13] I've seen that on several occasions. [0:32:16] We start with potable and then we go to. [0:32:18] Yeah, the newer subdivisions are required to actually provide the pressurized irrigation [0:32:23] stations also. [0:32:24] But ever since we had the big crash, we really haven't had any of those come online yet. [0:32:29] So this is just kind of some remnants of the old way and we haven't really seen any of the [0:32:33] new ones coming in. [0:32:35] Sean Berger. [0:32:36] And leave the plan would be if the station were to go in, [0:32:40] it would serve the school district property, those current subdivisions [0:32:45] that are out there, and also be able to say if that other section [0:32:50] developed there, be able to provide service for that as well. [0:32:53] Yeah, the school district is going to be responsible for their own [0:32:56] pressurized irrigation station. We're not going to try to share [0:33:00] pressurized water with the school. You know, the school has its [0:33:04] watering hours, we don't necessarily want it to interfere with the residences, but we'd [0:33:10] probably be seeing about 160 shares of water that we'd be able to deliver through the pressurized [0:33:15] irrigation station. [0:33:17] And I think, you know, this is about 40 acres right here, and 160 shares is about 160 acres [0:33:23] worth of water. [0:33:24] And so, yeah, further developments came in, and they needed to have pressurized irrigation, [0:33:29] We would allow them into the station if they if they paid a prorata right portion of the station cost [0:33:36] Great. Thank you. Great line [0:33:38] Lee how many other state we I know I remember the change over the early subdivisions didn't have to build their own [0:33:46] We agreed to build them then we changed the rules and and [0:33:49] Asked the new subdivisions to build them. How many of those old ones do we have that we have promised? [0:33:55] We would build the station. We haven't got a bill yet [0:33:57] You know the only one that I know of right now is Castlewood and this and I don't know if Jackie [0:34:07] In other words ones that are double pipe but still using potable water besides [0:34:19] There's probably a few out there that might be some smaller areas [0:34:26] but I don't know. [0:34:28] Because I remember we had to complain at one point, [0:34:30] some of the people that it actually, [0:34:32] because when they bought their lot, [0:34:33] they had essence paid for double piping, [0:34:36] and yet they were still paying potable water rates, [0:34:38] and we made some adjustment with them in order to, [0:34:41] because they were having to use potable water, [0:34:43] they were being charged, [0:34:44] and so we made some adjustments so that it was [0:34:47] a little closer to what they would expect [0:34:49] with pressurized irrigation. [0:34:50] That doesn't sound familiar, [0:34:53] because the pressurized irrigation piping is connected [0:34:58] to potable water, but the individual connections [0:35:02] to the houses don't have meters on them. [0:35:04] OK. [0:35:05] So, you know, I mean. [0:35:06] All right, so maybe I'm going to. [0:35:07] So there. [0:35:08] Yeah, so there. [0:35:10] OK, thank you. [0:35:10] I must have misunderstood back when there was some conversation [0:35:13] about that. [0:35:13] I think there were some way back where they were wanting to tie [0:35:16] into potable water right away because they didn't want [0:35:18] to wait for the pressurized irrigation. [0:35:20] And we can explain that. [0:35:26] What did Jackie just say we should hear? [0:35:28] Montatz, we do have a few areas and I think Jack's more familiar with them than I am that [0:35:35] we needed to provide them with pressurized irrigation, but since there was no way to get [0:35:42] that to them, we allowed them to individually tie into potable water. [0:35:47] But once again, I don't believe that some of those were being needed. [0:35:52] This has been a few years ago because I remember Tom Courtney was still the city manager so I know it's been a while. [0:35:59] There were a bunch of different things that happened during the transition and it's kind of a case-by-case basis. [0:36:08] But typically speaking they would be paying if they were on the Twin Falls Canal Company wanted to be paying the flat rate based on their school. [0:36:15] Well, I'm glad to see we're getting able to get some more of these ones that are double-piped [0:36:21] To prepare a pressurized irrigation to say it's potable water for more [0:36:26] Appreciases, so thank you. Sean Mariner. Are you ready for a motion? I think we are so I would [0:36:32] Move to approve the request to negotiate and enter into an agreement with Twin Falls school district to construct irrigation improvements [0:36:39] in the vicinity of the New South Hills [0:36:41] Hills Middle School and to use funds budgeted for the Castlewood Pressure Irrigation Station [0:36:46] for the work as presented. [0:36:49] Second. [0:36:50] Motion on floor by Sean Berger, seconded by Suzanne Hawkins as stated. [0:36:54] I think further on that motion council. [0:36:58] The item will call. [0:37:01] Sean Berger. [0:37:02] Yes. [0:37:03] Yes. [0:37:04] Mr. [0:37:05] Yes. [0:37:06] Great last week. [0:37:07] Yes. [0:37:08] Yes. [0:37:09] Don Hall. [0:37:10] Yes. [0:37:11] Suzanne Hawkins. [0:37:12] Yes. [0:37:13] Jim. [0:37:14] school what is the what is the mascot have we determined that they're cougars [0:37:20] who thought that ups not a bad feels cool very good great mining [0:37:28] remember to do the consent code it will be a good goal [0:37:32] I need you to move on okay moving along next item on the agenda is Lee [0:37:41] placement again and its presentation of an update on the construction of the [0:37:45] Hankins water tank. Since I gave you an update last fall, well first just to give [0:37:55] you a quick background. This is Kimberly Road right here. This is Hankins Road. [0:38:01] This is our existing Hankins reservoir and we're in the process of constructing a [0:38:07] a new 5 million gallon water reservoir at this location. [0:38:11] The water reservoir is being built because we've entered into and agreed with the urban [0:38:18] renewal aid and the city of Twin Falls is entered into an agreement with the urban renewal agency [0:38:22] and Cliff Barr to build a 5 million gallon tank right there. [0:38:26] The original amount that was budgeted was $7.3 million. [0:38:33] contracted them out as roughly $4.4 million and as of right now, this has spent $2.1 million [0:38:43] in funding of the project and everything is going well. We don't have any change orders [0:38:49] at this time. We're on schedule that we should be completed in mid-June. There is just a little [0:38:55] bit of float on some of the minor tasks that the contractors are aware of and he's looking [0:39:00] for ways to catch up. [0:39:01] And there's about five days is what he's estimating right now. [0:39:05] But otherwise, everything has been going very cleanly. [0:39:12] Chris talking to Hanson. [0:39:12] So after mid-June, I guess when you fill it for the first time [0:39:16] or whatever, well, residents in the southeast area, [0:39:19] will they notice immediate change in water pressure? [0:39:22] No, it won't have any effect on their water pressure. [0:39:26] The water pressure is provided by the pump station [0:39:28] that we just upgraded out there. [0:39:30] OK. [0:39:30] This just gives us a bigger storage of water to be able to pipe fires and things like that [0:39:36] and it will also help with the additional growth out matter. [0:39:38] Were there any pressure issues out there before we updated that? [0:39:43] No, not well, after the upgrade, no. [0:39:45] No, but before some. [0:39:47] Yeah, we did some of the upgrades for Chobani. [0:39:54] Anyway, I think you remember the photo that I showed you before where we had the, this is [0:40:00] the bottom of the tank and we've got a rebar placed. This is in December. This is [0:40:13] when they start pouring the slab. You notice that they've got everything covered [0:40:17] with blankets in the wintertime. You don't want your cement to freeze so you [0:40:22] actually have to insulate it so it'll cure properly. And here in January they're [0:40:35] starting to put the walls up all the way around and what they have is they have [0:40:38] They have forms that they they they they they poor [0:40:43] And while they they put up the forms they cover them up with these tents and they to keep it insulated [0:40:49] And then after it's cured for a couple weeks. They pull the tents off and they move the form to the next next spot [0:40:55] You can kind of see that they alternate from one side to the other and so they're so they're slowly [0:41:01] Coming around the tank and they're doing one poor a week. They they so about every Wednesday. They're pouring a section of wall [0:41:08] and they're doing the same thing with the slabs. [0:41:11] All these photographs are taken from the same spot in this walls now [0:41:19] in front of where I was standing. [0:41:23] See the rebar as it's starting to wrap around. [0:41:27] What you're seeing in this shot is one of the things you'll notice [0:41:44] that they've got some existing columns right there. [0:41:47] So while they're going through the phasing, [0:41:49] they've also got columns that they're pouring in the middle. [0:41:53] These ones are in the process of being formed up and they're put in rebar in them. [0:41:59] These are poured and they're being insulated and these are ready to go. [0:42:04] Back in here they're starting to put in scaffolding and so when they get the full outside of the [0:42:10] tank constructed they're going to actually have scaffolding all over and they're going [0:42:15] to support the form works that they can pour in the lid. [0:42:19] And so everything that they're putting in here right now after they've poured the lid [0:42:26] has to come up out of a hatch that's three foot by eight foot. [0:42:30] So every single piece of equipment that goes down inside this thing has to come up through [0:42:33] that one hole in this time. [0:42:35] And so that'll be kind of interesting to see to watch. [0:42:41] But yeah, we're on schedule. [0:42:44] This is where we're at right now. [0:42:45] They're about ready to close in the wall, and once they get the wall closed in, everything [0:42:51] they do, they'll have to go over the top of the wall in the ladder and down inside and do [0:42:56] all the work. [0:42:57] There's just another angle right there. [0:43:02] Any questions? [0:43:03] How many yards of concrete? [0:43:05] I have no idea. [0:43:07] A lot? [0:43:08] A lot. [0:43:09] I think that's fair to say. [0:43:11] Yeah. [0:43:12] Great landing. [0:43:14] The when I drove by there more recently, I just I just went that [0:43:19] Kimberly road. I didn't go down the hank as part. It's really not [0:43:22] above ground very far. I mean, so really, most of it is below [0:43:26] ground. So it really, I was expecting a much more, a much, [0:43:32] much bigger presence, I guess, so to speak. So it really doesn't, [0:43:36] you don't notice it. You don't notice as much as the other one, [0:43:39] be honest with the idea. It doesn't look, it's not as [0:43:41] No, suppose the existing tank that's already there. [0:43:44] Yeah, so when we came to the council and talked about that, [0:43:47] that you're only going to see about two foot at the top of the tank sticking up by the time you've burned the dirt up against it. [0:43:52] The top of the two tanks is going to be exactly the same and the bottoms are the same. [0:43:56] And so the water levels in them flush away together. [0:44:01] The other one must be just a little bit downhill because more of it's above ground. [0:44:05] Maybe I'm just looking at the roof on the other one. [0:44:08] Just the way it looks right now. [0:44:10] All right, okay, thank you. [0:44:11] Chris talking to you. [0:44:12] You know, that's looks like a dangerous construction project [0:44:15] just because of its volume, its heights involved, [0:44:20] heavy material. [0:44:22] I'm sure that the contractor has her own [0:44:25] insight risk management, [0:44:26] but does the city do any supervision of their supervision [0:44:31] for OSHA compliance? [0:44:35] I would think that we'd have some contingent liability [0:44:37] of anybody broke their ankle or anything worse. [0:44:40] or is serious but how stringent of the city enforcement of the safety codes to [0:44:46] ensure that the contractors follow them are we doing? The contractor is [0:44:50] specifically required for safety on their job site and you know when you start [0:44:57] going on to their job site and and and running their safety program then you [0:45:01] start taking on that liability and so it's it's specifically their their [0:45:08] responsibility for safety on the site. And of course, you know, whenever we [0:45:12] visit the site, we make sure we wear our hard hats and our safety best and all [0:45:16] those types of things. [0:45:17] Let me ask a different way, though. I don't think that would absolve us a [0:45:21] liability of somebody got hurt. Do we have the flexibility and the contract or [0:45:26] the expectation maybe is the way to word it. If we saw an obvious safety and [0:45:31] fraction to say stop, change it, do it different. [0:45:34] We could certainly point out things that we think are a mess and things like that, but [0:45:41] it's up to the contract or two. [0:45:43] I understand. [0:45:44] Lee, I'm going to let that transfer sway in a little bit. [0:45:47] We do not have any liability. [0:45:49] Nothing at all. [0:45:50] Nothing at all. [0:45:53] We got the head nod from our city attorney. [0:45:55] Good. [0:45:56] We have any other questions, Council? [0:46:00] I just want to say we need about two more of these for our city. [0:46:04] Yeah. Two more positions. [0:46:06] When is it supposed to be completed? [0:46:08] Uh, Summer? [0:46:09] Mid-June? [0:46:10] It's exciting. [0:46:14] Where this is something I know that we've needed for quite some time. [0:46:18] We just need more capacity, frankly. [0:46:20] Great mining. [0:46:21] Uh, well you said we're probably brought to you, broadcasted, [0:46:24] so people understand the funding for this. [0:46:26] Do you remember the breakdown or maybe it was the breakdown of who paid for what out of that 4 million? [0:46:31] Yeah, the original breakdown was, you know, a total of $7.7.3 million. [0:46:36] $7.3 million was going to be provided and at that 7.3 million, 3.5 million was going to come from the City of Twin Falls. [0:46:45] 2.6 from the URA through TIP funds and an additional 1.17 through URA other sources and I don't know if those other sources are specifically. [0:46:55] And so we're using those percentage ratios for the actual amount that we're spending on the contract. [0:47:03] I believe our responsibility is about 52% of the project. [0:47:07] The balance of it is coming from urban renewal area number one, which is the other, because [0:47:15] there is a direct benefit to the other areas with a connected water system, and then the [0:47:21] cliff TIF is paying for their proportionate share, which was the $2.5 million number, the [0:47:29] the 2.6 number that Leah shared. [0:47:32] All right, great. [0:47:34] And this is one of those examples where Cliff Bar really [0:47:36] doesn't need this much capacity. [0:47:39] Well, they do. [0:47:39] OK, well, good. [0:47:40] But we still get the volume of this whole thing [0:47:44] for the entire city, the entire city [0:47:46] gains from having this backup water supply. [0:47:50] And that's what we were seeking. [0:47:52] That's why we like to use our corporate partners to help [0:47:55] us do that if we can. [0:47:56] There's a mutual benefit for them. [0:47:57] Yeah. [0:47:58] Well stated. [0:47:59] All right, Lee, thank you for your presentation. [0:48:02] It is 534 and the next item is public input [0:48:08] from city manager. [0:48:09] We do have two public hearings this evening, [0:48:11] and then we're going to come back [0:48:13] for an item consideration that reflects back [0:48:16] on one of the public hearings. [0:48:21] So we cannot start our public hearings until six o'clock. [0:48:24] So we might end up if we don't have a lot [0:48:26] from the public coming, making an input [0:48:28] or City Council City Manager might take a short break. [0:48:32] So at this point, I'll go ahead and open it up again [0:48:35] for the city, for the public, [0:48:37] if there's anyone that would like to come forward [0:48:39] and address the council. [0:48:41] See no one coming forward. [0:48:43] City Manager, anything further? [0:48:46] Just a reminder that next Monday is President's Day. [0:48:49] And as a result of that, [0:48:50] our council meeting will be on Tuesday of next week. [0:48:53] Very good, sir. [0:48:54] City Council, great morning. [0:48:56] Otak are the people that the URA is utilizing to kind of guide us through their plans for their upgrades to the downtown area. [0:49:07] It's having an open house that they really want public to attend to give them their ideas. [0:49:13] They will be presenting some possibly a little more concrete ideas. [0:49:17] What they've gathered for other meetings is what they may want to do both low ground and above ground. [0:49:23] and so they're inviting the public six o'clock the 19th was that when does that [0:49:30] first public meeting to the Thursday the 19th yes and it's fine to be I believe [0:49:35] right here and oh it's ballroom you're right I'm right 6 p.m. 6 p.m. [0:49:40] so the fighting the public to make sure you come out and and help guide what [0:49:46] downtown's gonna end up looking like absolutely thank you great anything for [0:49:49] from council. I wanted to mention to council that I had another conversation [0:49:54] with the radio again today or this last week and what we're going to probably [0:49:57] plan on doing is about every two weeks and rotating through council members that [0:50:01] are willing to do so and I've talked to Leila and she's going to help coordinate [0:50:05] that so we'll start that up again. I'll start this Wednesday and then we'll start [0:50:10] rotating through council members. Alright I see nothing further so at this [0:50:14] point we're going to go ahead and take a short recess until 6 p.m. [1:14:20] I'd like to reconvene the meeting of the Twin Paul City Council. [1:14:24] It's February 9, 2015, and it is 1,800 hours, 6 p.m. [1:14:29] First item on the agenda. [1:14:31] Actually, we have two public hearings, but the first one is a consideration of a request for a zoning district change and zoning map amendment from R1 variable to R2 for 51 acres located on the east side of 500, 600, and 700 blocks of Hankins Road. [1:14:49] of Hankens Road North. We have Brad Wills who will be making a presentation on behalf [1:14:55] of the Twin Falls School District. Welcome Brad. [1:15:08] I had a hard time hearing today back there. I noticed that earlier. [1:15:13] I mean, I, there's that's better. Oh yeah. Sorry. [1:15:20] I thought it was my age. Maybe Lee was back here. Brad Wills. That's pretty loud. Okay. [1:15:30] So I'm here tonight on behalf of the Twin Falls School District. [1:15:33] This is the site on the east side of the Pillar Falls Elementary School. [1:15:39] And we have gone through an annexation and a Complan amendment changing this from agriculture [1:15:47] to medium density residential, which encompasses all residential zones. [1:15:56] So this is the property that we're talking about. [1:15:58] And currently it's R1 variable, which is fine, but I'm going to take just a few minutes [1:16:04] and explain to you the problem with this particular site staying R1 variable. [1:16:20] So this is a little bit interesting way to look at the same area. [1:16:23] This is the side again, but what parcels are left to actually build out. [1:16:31] So when you look before you see this big R2, R1 area, but really there's only five large, [1:16:39] six large parcels in this area that have yet to be built out. [1:16:56] So when you change from an R1 variable to an R2, that doesn't necessarily mean that you're [1:17:01] changing from large lots to smaller lots as drastically as you think it might be. [1:17:23] So these are three subdivisions currently nearby that are one variable. [1:17:31] So we'll call it the Temple subdivision. [1:17:34] Those are around 1,200 square foot lots. [1:17:37] Morning sun, face. [1:17:38] 12,000. [1:17:39] What did I say? [1:17:41] 1,200. [1:17:42] Oh, thank you. [1:17:45] Phase seven of morning sun, which is across the street, average 10,500. [1:17:51] minor subdivision which is at the on filer and carriage lane averages. It's R1 variable [1:18:01] but an R1 variable can go down to 8,000 square feet. So I took the current subdivisions that [1:18:07] are real active and looked to see what the average square footage of those lots driven [1:18:13] by the market. So in R2 the average of hometown northern passage, settlers ridge, [1:18:21] northern sky, fieldstone and santara is 9400 square feet. So that kind of gives [1:18:28] you an idea that R1 doesn't necessarily mean you're going to go down to the [1:18:32] 6500 that would be legal. It's more of the market and this side of town has [1:18:37] lend itself to larger lots. But there's a reason I'm asking for this. In an R1 variable [1:18:54] where morning sun wasn't backing up into any other one acre or half acre subdivisions, they [1:19:01] didn't have a requirement that this parcel will. And where we are adjacent, the rule [1:19:09] in an R1 is any lot that's within 150 feet of another developed subdivision lot, you have [1:19:17] to be 85% of that square footage. [1:19:21] So where the LDS Church is right here has a 6 acre parcel, I have to be within 85% of [1:19:28] that or a minimum 18,500 square foot. [1:19:33] So when we developed this or whoever develops this has to meet that square footage on these [1:19:39] lots, down here because the city owns a two acre lot, I have to be 85% of that two acre [1:19:49] lot. [1:19:50] So any lots that are within 150 feet of the city own lot here, again I end up having to [1:19:57] be an 18,500 square foot lot. [1:20:02] These lots here, because the morning sun lots that back up here are extra deep because of [1:20:09] the setbacks, those are 15,000 square foot lots. [1:20:14] So any lot that will be designed on here has to be 12,900. [1:20:29] What is nice about this subdivision is that we do have a pretty big buffer. [1:20:33] We have Hankins is a 116 foot right away, [1:20:38] filers a 72 foot right away, and the school [1:20:40] is actually going to shelter this subdivision right now. [1:20:45] So we are asking that this be changed to an R1 variable. [1:20:51] We are the school district intends [1:20:52] on selling this property at public auction [1:20:55] to a potential developer down the road [1:20:58] to help fund the school projects. [1:21:01] But we are trying to make this probably maximize the opportunity [1:21:10] that somebody who buys this. [1:21:12] And so by allowing this to go from R1 variable to R2, [1:21:17] doesn't necessarily mean it would be smaller lots, [1:21:21] but it will give them the ability to make the lots, like 10,000 [1:21:26] to 11,000 square feet on the whole thing, not just [1:21:29] the interior lots. [1:21:31] Planning zoning heard this and they voted unanimously [1:21:36] to recommend it to be passed. [1:21:37] So I think that was a good sign that this is a good idea. [1:21:41] So I'll, if anybody has any questions, [1:21:43] that's my presentation. [1:21:45] Greg Lanning. [1:21:48] Is the rest of that likely to be a PUD, [1:21:53] where the council would have a little more control [1:21:55] of a lot sizes or will it be just a straight-out position? [1:22:01] Probably not a PUD. [1:22:03] I imagine it will be developed as a, [1:22:06] my guess it will be purchased and developed as a residential subdivision with with us a [1:22:13] density like the east side has typically been larger lots and the northwest has been [1:22:19] larger lots. So the difference between an R1 variable and R2 is that they can go down [1:22:28] an R1 variable is 8,000 square foot minimum size but you can see that they've never really [1:22:34] gotten down that far, and R2 they can go down to 6,500. And they can also be attached single [1:22:42] family dwellings, which is a better name than a duplex. So that is a possibility. I think [1:22:51] this lands, it lends itself to at least a similar density to what's around it to the [1:22:59] the west. But somebody could buy this and do higher density, but I don't think the market, [1:23:07] this is a nice enough area. I think it would still lend itself to the larger home because [1:23:12] that's what Morning Sun has done. And that's what the Eagle Park, which is now Morning Sun [1:23:17] 8, which is the Boy Scout subdivision is going in. And that's similar. Those are about 10 [1:23:24] 11,000 square foot lots, so. [1:23:29] Chris, talking. [1:23:30] So saying it another way, Mr. Wells, [1:23:32] then although if the R2 is granted, [1:23:36] then the interior could go down to a minimum of 6,500. [1:23:40] But along Hankins Road and the other areas identified, [1:23:44] you'd be upzoning the lot size to those figures [1:23:47] that you determined they would be. [1:23:49] The ones on the traveling roads would actually [1:23:51] be the largest lots that anybody would see in that area. [1:23:55] They typically have a larger back set back, [1:23:58] so they will be bigger regardless. [1:24:01] By law, by ordinance, they will be required. [1:24:03] And then feather that down to smaller lots, [1:24:05] potentially interior. [1:24:09] I'm not sure I might be saying this differently. [1:24:12] A regular subdivision could [1:24:16] plan for a 6500 square foot lot interior. [1:24:21] And they could do that to perimeter too though. [1:24:23] They would not, what were, by changing this, [1:24:28] you are allowing the perimeter lots to go smaller too. [1:24:32] We're right now, 18,500 as small as they can go. [1:24:37] I thought that, I guess I misunderstood. [1:24:40] I thought that that was her requirement [1:24:41] that within a certain distance you had to be 85% of. [1:24:45] In an R1 variable? [1:24:47] Excuse me, I understand. [1:24:49] Thank you. [1:24:50] I would have liked to suggest that. [1:24:54] Do we have any further questions at this point? [1:24:57] Well Brad, I'm sure we'll have some further ones. [1:24:59] We're gonna go ahead and turn this over [1:25:01] to staff for their presentation. [1:25:02] And I believe we have Jonathan Spinlow. [1:25:18] All right, Mr. Mayor, members of the council, [1:25:20] a little bit of history on the property. [1:25:21] On the school district bought this in 1990 [1:25:23] from Melbourne's Sacket. [1:25:25] It was always intended to be a potential school site [1:25:30] on their part. [1:25:31] It went through some different zoning [1:25:33] and subdivision changes throughout the years. [1:25:36] the conveyance plant in 2008, gave the city the two acres down here for our pump station. [1:25:42] And then August 2014, last August, they held a couple different public hearings for annexation. [1:25:50] That was annexed under the current R1 variable zone that we have now. [1:25:54] And then they adopted, that was through an adopted ordinance 3075. [1:25:58] Then in November, they went through the comprehensive plan amendment to change it from agricultural [1:26:04] to medium density and that also changed the water service boundary to the exterior of [1:26:09] the property here. [1:26:13] With this zoning district change and zoning map amendment, it's about 52 acres, 51 plus [1:26:18] or minus. [1:26:20] Since that, the comprehensive map change makes it medium density so they can ask for a different [1:26:26] zone. [1:26:27] The R2 is typically found in the medium density comprehensive plan description. [1:26:33] The areas immediately surrounding this partial are currently zoned R1 and most of them are [1:26:38] within the area of impact minus what's on the west side. [1:26:41] The area to the west is within C limits and was developed under the R1 code as it was written [1:26:46] today. [1:26:47] The areas to the north south and there's nothing developed to the east. [1:26:52] The areas to the north and south were actually developed under the now defunct rural residential [1:26:58] or R143,000 zoning districts. [1:27:01] Those are zone districts we do not have anymore [1:27:04] In 2004 when the city really got shaded the area of impact agreement [1:27:08] They went through a change and those districts were done away with and we established the R1 VAR. So [1:27:16] The subdivisions to the south down here [1:27:20] We're not reviewed in the R1 variable standards and neither was a subdivision to the north [1:27:26] They're reviewed under some different standards. So a lot sizes different things like that were not [1:27:31] done the same as the R as would have been done over here in [1:27:35] morning sun. [1:27:36] So there's a little bit of history of the area. [1:27:39] Part of the change going to the R1, it was partially done to [1:27:43] curb growth on the fringes towards the limits in favor of a [1:27:46] more compact urban development pattern. [1:27:48] Essentially made it impossible to develop some of these [1:27:51] parcels of land and directed it more towards the city [1:27:54] boundaries and the water growth boundary. [1:27:59] The Twin Falls School District has submitted a preliminary [1:28:01] the plan for this area that staff is currently reviewing. [1:28:04] Copy of the plan is found in your packet. [1:28:07] At this time the school is planning three total lots. [1:28:10] One is for the school. [1:28:13] One is to the west of the school [1:28:15] and the remainder of the site is one large lot. [1:28:22] So on this plan, you would see stadium here, one lot. [1:28:26] It's a lot one here. [1:28:27] It's where the school is going to be [1:28:29] or proposed to be. [1:28:30] Another lot here that would front Hankins and stadium [1:28:33] and the remainder of the land is in a third locked. [1:28:38] This rezone request would allow for future development [1:28:40] to occur under the codes and standards [1:28:42] as set forth in the R2 zoning district. [1:28:45] In reviewing a request for zoning district change [1:28:47] in zoning map amendment, the Planning and Zoning Commission [1:28:51] had two main tasks, one to determine whether the request [1:28:57] is in conformance with the comprehensive plan, [1:28:59] and two to evaluate the request to determine the extent [1:29:02] nature of the amendment requested. In conclusion on January 13th 2015 the [1:29:07] Commission determined the request was in compliance with both of the two main [1:29:11] objectives stated above and voted to recommend approval of the request. [1:29:14] Freeze on the site from R1 variable to R2 as presented by a vote of 7 4 and 0 [1:29:21] against. That's conclusion of the staff report. Do we have any questions for [1:29:24] Jonathan? I see no questions Jonathan so at this time I'm going to go ahead and [1:29:30] open up for public testimony. We're going to limit your testimony to about two minutes. [1:29:37] We'll give you a 30 second mark to let you know when you're coming close and Suzanne [1:29:44] to my ride will be our timer. So this time the public testimony portion of this evening's [1:29:50] public hearing is open and see if there's anyone that signed up. [1:29:54] I have one letter that I'll put on the overhead that we received. [1:29:57] Very good. Is there anyone that signed in the back of someone go check down on up? [1:30:16] I'll call you up. You're probably the only one certain you can stand up. We'll get you up here [1:30:20] And if you when you came up if you would just state your name and your address that'd be perfect [1:30:26] So John Martin come on up sir and welcome [1:30:29] Yeah, we want my wife and I wanted to speak in favor of the R1 to [1:30:39] Resoning [1:30:46] next door is ours and so I'm also wanted to say that the city staff have been really good [1:30:52] to explain to us and Renee and John both and then also the school district staff as well [1:31:01] and so we're understanding how this is going to work. We've enjoyed living in the country [1:31:06] but we're still be considered to be in the country I think that it's time to have some [1:31:15] good development happen there and I'm you know I I'm sure going to have some [1:31:21] really gorgeous houses around this and it's going to be continue to be a really good [1:31:26] place to live. That's all I need to say. Mr. Martin is your address 624 North [1:31:30] Hankins yes very good sir thank you for your testimony. Thank you. Is there [1:31:35] anyone else that is not listed that would like to come forward and testify [1:31:39] regarding this evening's agenda item. I see no one else coming forward so we're [1:31:48] I'm going to go ahead and close the public vote portion of this evening's hearing and [1:31:52] turn it over to council, Chris Dockingen. [1:31:55] I would move to approve the request for zoning district change and zoning map amendment from [1:32:01] our one variable to order two for the 51 plus or minus acres. [1:32:05] I'll get in the west on the east side of 500, 600, 700 blocks of Hankman's road north. [1:32:12] Second. [1:32:13] We have a motion on board by Chris Toggins, seconded by Suzanne Hawkins as stated. [1:32:18] Greg Lanning. [1:32:19] Well, this is, I'm going to be voting in favor of the, I still want to have a comment. [1:32:26] In favor of the motion, I do think this particular situation does point to the conversation, at [1:32:34] least I've had the conversation, maybe nobody else cares, but the, uh, where the possibility [1:32:39] in the necessary of just the straight R1, [1:32:42] that would be, let's say 8,000 feet or 8,500 square feet [1:32:48] on a lot that will allow situations like this, [1:32:51] because I see how Mr. Wells has pointed out to see unfairness [1:32:55] of trying to match up with a six eight church lot [1:32:59] in our two acre irrigation lot to try to make [1:33:02] cause 19,000 square foot lots of their posts. [1:33:05] I understand the reasons of that. [1:33:07] But I also would like to recognize that there's especially the new houses that are going to go across the street and maybe some of the others are already there. [1:33:14] I'm quite a bit bigger lots than so we had something that said, you don't have to come up with this particular thing to match large lots that are church or something, but you still have to have 8,000 square feet. [1:33:26] That's the reason I asked the question about the PUD that would give us some opportunity to say, hey, in this PUD we're going to require 8,000 square feet. [1:33:35] But, and we don't have that on the books, but I still point that as a necessity of maybe [1:33:40] an in-between zone there, because it seems like there's a long ways, at least conceptually, [1:33:45] to me between the R2 and the R1 variable. [1:33:48] Something in between that has set your ship size that we could just say, alright, we're [1:33:54] going to pose R1, which would require a little bit larger lots, but not some of the nuances [1:34:01] that the R1 variable brings about. [1:34:04] And I have to offer that what Mr. Will says is correct. [1:34:06] I believe these probably will be above 8,000 square feet. [1:34:09] That would give us the opportunity to guarantee [1:34:11] they were both. [1:34:14] Thank you, Greg. [1:34:14] Chris, talking. [1:34:15] Yeah, I just want to make it kind of what favored somewhat [1:34:19] tempered commitment to this ordinance or to this request [1:34:25] as well, even though I will vote in favor of it. [1:34:28] Unless we have a PUD, we could see those remaining acres go [1:34:34] into 6,000 foot duplexes, and I hope not. [1:34:37] I would suspect that the eventual platters of subdivision [1:34:42] in that area are going to go for maximum density [1:34:45] to maximize their return. [1:34:47] And we'll have to look back and say, [1:34:49] Mr. Lanning was correct, we needed something [1:34:52] in between the R1 variable and R2, [1:34:54] but I don't think we could do that, [1:34:55] not under grandfathering of the request underway. [1:34:59] So I hope that this is not pressing it. [1:35:02] I hope we don't see that this fills up a 6,000 foot duplexes. [1:35:08] That this is a growth area to deny the request [1:35:12] in its entirety, [1:35:13] is not looking out for the best interests at Twin Falls. [1:35:18] Well stated, anyone further on this motion from council? [1:35:23] Leonic, can we have a roll call though please? [1:35:26] Chris Chalkington? [1:35:27] Yes. [1:35:28] Greg Lanthine? [1:35:28] Yes. [1:35:29] Don Hall? [1:35:30] Yes. [1:35:31] Susan Hunken? [1:35:32] Yes. [1:35:33] Yes. Motion passes six to zero. Moving to the next public hearing is consideration and [1:35:39] request for vacation of thirteen minus acres of undeveloped property within a [1:35:44] portion of the North Passage subdivision number three and number four [1:35:49] consisting of 46 family lots and adjacent right away and easements to allow [1:35:54] the development of a new elementary school on the property located at the [1:35:58] northeast corner of Federation Road extended and Grandview Drive north. We [1:36:05] have Tim Vosser with EHM representing Northern Passage, Inc. and welcome Tim. [1:36:12] Thank you. Good evening, Mayor and Council. Tim Vosser with EHM representing [1:36:17] Twin Falls School District. And while I should say I'm not representing Twin [1:36:23] Falls School District at this point but I'd like to combine these two together if [1:36:28] if you don't mind. [1:36:29] I'm actually representing the developers of this subdivision [1:36:33] who have entered into an agreement [1:36:35] to re-plat this area in order for the school district [1:36:40] to have a buildable lot for their site. [1:36:46] So the first step of the process is to vacate [1:36:49] portions of platted subdivisions, [1:36:51] which were platted in 2009. [1:36:55] Planning and zoning exhibit does the best telling [1:36:58] the story. Northern Passage Number One and Northern Passage Number Two and Green are virtually [1:37:05] built out at this point. Maybe some empty lots in there as of this point. Northern Passage [1:37:12] Number Three and Northern Passage Number Four, Three and Blue, Four and Pink are... [1:37:18] T.A.D.D. Do you have the pointer that you could, did you have Brad to it? [1:37:26] Brad. [1:37:27] So then you're pocket Brad. [1:37:33] John. [1:37:34] John. [1:37:35] Excuse me, there's Northern Passage 1, 2, 3, and 4. [1:37:44] Those two separate subdivisions are currently in escrow. They're platted during escrow. [1:37:50] with the school district looking for a parcel out here in this area, they contacted the [1:37:55] shot wells and they agreed to sell them a 10 acre piece here pending vacation of the [1:38:02] subdivision. So that which is in red is the area of the request for the vacation [1:38:09] which would virtually vacate everything except for Federation Road and Grandie [1:38:19] drive right of way which is to be kept in place. [1:38:27] So we have 46 lots adjacent right of ways in the Eastmans that need to be in effect obliterated [1:38:36] so that we can start all over again. [1:38:39] Currently this is plotted as loop roads that comes out on Federation of Grandview. [1:38:45] So the reconfiguration of 15 lots needs to take place [1:38:49] to create a cul-de-sac bulb area here, [1:38:53] and reconfiguration of those lots, [1:38:55] as well as this small portion of northern passage number three, [1:39:00] to create a cul-de-sac there rather than a through road. [1:39:05] I'm gonna jump ahead a little bit here, [1:39:07] just so you can see. [1:39:08] And Tim, you're speaking of the final plot, [1:39:12] prove the final. [1:39:13] That's a separate. [1:39:14] Yes. [1:39:15] So you're trying to combine this, but you do realize we can only do one of them. [1:39:18] I do, sir. [1:39:19] But what I'm hoping to show is the validity of the vacation itself and how it serves the school district. [1:39:26] Therefore, with the vacation we'll go forward if you so see fit to plan a large parcel here, [1:39:33] as well as reconfigure the lots to serve the school district in that area. [1:39:38] If you have any questions else, Dan, for the now, thank you. [1:39:41] Do we have any questions for Tim? [1:39:44] Greg Lining. [1:39:45] Tim, will this, when the school district begins to build, [1:39:49] and will Federation go through at this point, [1:39:53] or will it have to wait until number three [1:39:56] of the bill now? [1:39:58] That was the same question, PNC. [1:40:00] And the answer is we will be building enough for Federation [1:40:05] to serve the school and get the internal looping [1:40:09] into their parking lots. [1:40:11] But at this point, nothing past the east boundary [1:40:15] of the school district parcel is planned. [1:40:18] I do expect this to accelerate lot sales within the area, [1:40:22] and so Federation will most likely go forward [1:40:25] in a work-seller at a time frame, [1:40:28] but at this point, just to the school's east boundary. [1:40:31] So how much, I was gonna say, [1:40:32] could you show us that, what you're talking about on the map, [1:40:36] so that we can have a better visual of what you're saying. [1:40:39] So right now, Caine Trails, number six, which is right here, [1:40:46] has constructed this phase. [1:40:49] And all the underground in is in on this phase [1:40:53] with paving to take place as soon as the paving plants [1:40:57] open up this spring. [1:41:00] Thank you. [1:41:02] So Federation will be built to that point, [1:41:06] at least a major portion of it. [1:41:11] And this would be the east boundary of the school district [1:41:15] parcel of the federation we built to that point, [1:41:17] or at least a portion of it to serve the school. [1:41:20] So basically, you have the equivalent of two more [1:41:25] subdivisions, two more phases of subdivisions [1:41:27] to get built to do that. [1:41:29] As I said, Northern Passage is here now, built out. [1:41:34] So you could see within a couple phases, [1:41:37] if lots sales start going, that that [1:41:39] could be finished out relatively quickly. [1:41:43] Great. [1:41:44] Well, kind of was the question at the point that they do three at all, if they're going [1:41:51] to get to Columbia Drive, which does go all the way through there. [1:41:56] It's the North Fork on the other end. [1:42:00] So they will be, that's probably the point when they would need to do it. [1:42:04] They won't do it until two is built, two still has got a few, if you will, that's correct. [1:42:09] Okay, so they probably won't be building three until so there will be some time [1:42:13] I'm just worrying about traffic flow in the area that that everything to that elementary schools and have to be on grandview and can't be utilizing [1:42:21] Another arterial or at least major street in Federation. I don't know sure it has an arterial designation [1:42:27] That's gonna be close right and so I and I you know [1:42:31] I'm I [1:42:32] I speculate as far as when things will build out. [1:42:36] I do know we'll be building a full 24 feet. [1:42:40] Our larger, I can't quite remember the section of Grandview [1:42:44] in front of the school. [1:42:45] City staff has also asked for some considerations [1:42:49] as far as fencing along the frontage of Grandview [1:42:52] so that parents don't walk Grandview unloading kids. [1:42:57] That's a deterrent. [1:42:58] so that Federation, even though it'll be a stub street, [1:43:02] will take the basis of the traffic, [1:43:05] getting kids in and out to school. [1:43:07] Along with that, the school district [1:43:10] has had a drop lane on Federation, [1:43:13] designed into their site plans, [1:43:16] so that parents pulling off, [1:43:18] will be pulling off the travel to drop children off. [1:43:21] And then my last question would be, [1:43:23] what about those students who live in settlers, [1:43:27] reds, northern passage, all those particular subdivisions, [1:43:31] and northern sky, for that matter, [1:43:33] who may choose to walk to school, [1:43:36] are they going to be able to get down Federation road [1:43:38] to walk to school? [1:43:39] That's a question I have. [1:43:41] Because that's going to be their only outlet from the east [1:43:45] is going to be Federation road. [1:43:47] That's true. [1:43:49] And at this point, there's no plan for that. [1:43:52] Although it's been my experience, [1:43:55] I see quite a few kids being carted to school [1:43:58] by their parents rather than walking, so. [1:44:01] This particular one where they got the subdivisions [1:44:04] really close, you would think, you know, [1:44:06] as you see kids walking in that area quite a bit, [1:44:10] and so it makes you wonder that the bus drops [1:44:12] from off-clear up a federation, [1:44:13] even those kids are in separate ridge, [1:44:16] so they walk the full length of several ridge [1:44:18] to get to the feet of their house. [1:44:20] True, that's the walking in some directions. [1:44:23] Again, under a normal circumstance, [1:44:26] that might be an area of deterrent for a farmer or someone like that, but these people are [1:44:32] renting their grant, their developers are renting their ground to their farmers, and [1:44:37] they're actively looking for this school to come in because they truly believe it'll [1:44:42] boost lot sales and make their lots more value. [1:44:46] So some of that foot traffic, although it might be kind of path of least resistance for kids [1:44:53] at this point, I expect you'll see something addressed in the near future. [1:44:58] And the school still has quite a time frame out for final completion as well. [1:45:04] And the same thing, do we have any kind of sidewalks on Grandview for the kids living [1:45:09] at home down? [1:45:11] Fronting the school district property and fronting hometown areas, unfortunately, there's a not [1:45:18] unfortunately for the people that own it, but there is an unplatted two homes I believe [1:45:25] and in this area here that unless they were to go forward with anything we simply don't [1:45:30] have the right way to put something in that form. [1:45:34] Thank you. [1:45:36] I just want to mention that obviously Greg you've been on P&Z and you have some experience [1:45:40] with school administration as well with your line of questions and I appreciate it. [1:45:45] the walking part. Yeah. Do we have any further questions for Tim? Were you? I see no lights [1:45:57] on Tim, but I'm sure we'll have some further questions and we'll ask that Jonathan Spindlop [1:46:02] come back up for a staff report. Thank you, Mr. Mayor, members of the council, a history [1:46:09] on this one in 2004, the joint application for annexation. This was 376 acres was approved, [1:46:14] the annexation, assigned this area the R2 zone as it stands today. [1:46:20] The subdivisions titled Northern Passage Number 3 and 4, which we are vacating, a portion of [1:46:24] were approved by the Council in 2006 and recorded in 2009. [1:46:28] There's no further zoning history. [1:46:30] The request, Tim, went through the request very well. [1:46:33] I'm not going to read my entire staff report as far as the number of lots or where it's located. [1:46:39] Basically what they're doing is vacating it so they can consolidate land in one lot for the [1:46:42] school district for their elementary school. There's a request for approval of Northern [1:46:47] Passage subdivision number five. There's a preliminary plan done by the Planning and Zoning [1:46:52] Commission and will be presented to the council tonight after this. The plan shows the replanting [1:46:57] of the vacated parcel into 16 lots, 15 single family and one lot for the school. The vacation [1:47:03] of roadways is needed to enable the creation of suitably sized lot for the elementary. Although [1:47:09] While the vacation will create some dead end streets, this issue will be addressed during [1:47:12] the future planning process, which you guys will be taking part of today. [1:47:17] The preliminary plan was being presented to the commission and your staff final. [1:47:24] The staff is unaware of any currently installed utilities in the area of the vacation and we [1:47:29] have received approval letters from all applicable utility companies. [1:47:33] Vacation and planning subdivisions including public easements in right of way require a [1:47:36] recommendation by the Planning and Zoning Commission followed by another public hearing [1:47:40] and decision by the Council. On January 13, 2015, the Commission held a public hearing on [1:47:45] the request. The public hearing was opened and had one public comment from an adjacent [1:47:49] neighbor who lives in the west side on the west side of Granby Drive. They were concerned [1:47:53] about the additional traffic generated by the new elementary school. They concerned it could [1:47:58] impact their farming business during the farming season. The public hearing was closed and upon [1:48:02] conclusion the Commission's deliberation. I made a motion to recommend approval of [1:48:07] the vacation requested, as presented, request that to the City Council staff [1:48:12] recommendations. It was seconded in all members voted in favor of that motion. The [1:48:17] conditions for recommendation of approval were number one subject to the site [1:48:22] plan amendments as required by building engineering fire and zoning officials to [1:48:25] ensure compliance with applicable city code requirements and standards. And [1:48:28] number two subject to submittal of all utility layers and any conditions that may [1:48:32] require that may be required prior to adoption of the ordinance. [1:48:37] In conclusion, staff recommends that council approve the vacation request as presented and [1:48:42] subject to the conditions placed on the commission's recommendation to the city council. [1:48:46] That's the end of the staff report. [1:48:48] We have any questions for John? [1:48:51] I don't see any lights on, so Jonathan, if you'd stand by. [1:48:56] I'm going to go ahead and open up. [1:48:57] We took the signup sheet, I'm not sure if there's another one back there or not. [1:49:00] But if you're interested in testifying regarding tonight's [1:49:05] this public hearing, this is the time to do so. [1:49:09] And so I'll open up the public testimony portion [1:49:13] of this evening's hearing and ask you to come forward. [1:49:21] Come on forward. [1:49:22] So what I need from you, sir, is your name and your address. [1:49:26] And then we'll give you a couple of minutes and welcome. [1:49:30] Thank you. [1:49:31] [Muted for privacy: home address] [1:49:34] [Muted for privacy: home address] [1:49:39] [Muted for privacy: home address] [1:49:42] [Muted for privacy: home address] [1:49:44] Two of the families and one of the businesses [1:49:46] that are on the west side of Grandview. [1:49:48] And just to express a little bit of concern [1:49:50] about the traffic that we have, [1:49:52] knowing that Grandview North of Poland is a country road. [1:49:56] It's not anywhere near capacity to what was done [1:50:00] to Grandview south of Poline with the addition of all of the hospital and all that where it [1:50:04] has four lanes right at its mouth. The only exits that we have on Grandview would be [1:50:09] the one stop at Poline and then down around along the canyon towards the gun club which [1:50:16] is the only other access to Federation. We're just concerned about making sure that we have [1:50:22] not the cart before the horse as far as transportation goes so that when the school is built we [1:50:28] you're able to get federation completed also, [1:50:31] so that we don't have to deal with, [1:50:33] and not just for the benefit of our farm, our business, [1:50:36] which we see a lot of movement of, [1:50:39] there's a bean company right there [1:50:40] that moves a lot of bean trucks in and out [1:50:43] during all time to the season. [1:50:46] There's also a spud warehouse nearby [1:50:49] and a machinery shop that moves a lot of tractors [1:50:52] and a lot of spud and beat trucks in and out of that area, [1:50:55] right along Randview. [1:50:56] And those two, you know, two spud trucks passing each other [1:50:59] on the road force each of them into the bar, [1:51:01] but as it is, just concerned about moving that [1:51:05] with the flow of school traffic also. [1:51:08] Other concern without having Federation finished [1:51:10] before the school opens is, you know, [1:51:12] you talk about making sure we don't have students [1:51:15] walking on Grandview during, you know, [1:51:18] chewing from school. [1:51:20] I substitute teach and coach, and I know a lot [1:51:22] of my students walk to school, especially in an area [1:51:24] like this where you have a ton of subdivisions right next to where the school's going to be, [1:51:28] you're going to have parents who are going to say, walk, you know. [1:51:32] And we're just concerned that with students walking [1:51:37] to their subdivisions right there, without Federation finished, one, [1:51:41] they'll be walking through farmland, which can be hazardous at times, [1:51:46] but also through construction as they're building those subdivisions [1:51:51] that road and you have students who want to walk home to their subdivision their houses. [1:51:56] They're going to be walking through lands that are going to be worked on at that time. [1:52:02] So our concern is just that we have, what can we do to have federation all the way through [1:52:06] and completed before the school is finished and running so that we don't have students one [1:52:13] in a dangerous or hazardous area and also to alleviate a little bit of the traffic on [1:52:18] Grandview or at least help making sure that Grandview is suitable for the traffic that's going to be going up and down it both [1:52:25] agricultural and commercial [1:52:28] Chances could you spell your slowly spell your last name for me? Sorry requah req ua [1:52:34] Just like it sounds mm-hmm very good. Thank you. Thanks. Thank you. Appreciate you testimony [1:52:39] Anything anyone further from the community that would like to come forward and testify regarding this item Brad wills [1:52:50] address [1:52:51] Brad Wills [1:52:55] So these are good good conversations and you know, we have Brady Dickinson with the school district, so [1:53:03] We're going to heed this just a little thought so [1:53:08] right now [1:53:09] This is this this is hometown and hometown is developed to [1:53:15] Let's see right right there [1:53:18] So there is a gravel all-weather road because there's a water line that goes [1:53:25] through here. This is being developed this summer if I'm not mistaken. So if [1:53:30] somebody is in here they would walk, they could walk to here. This will be [1:53:34] sidewalk here all the way down to here. But Brady and I were just talking before [1:53:40] this that we may need to look at some type of sidewalk or some type of path [1:53:46] there that we would need to do, the curb goes right up to here, but there's no [1:53:53] sidewalk there. So maybe we can get the shot wells to do that. So we're hearing [1:53:59] what you're saying and we will do some consideration. And so when we come back [1:54:03] again, which would be on the somewhere time down the road, we'll maybe have some [1:54:11] better answers for you, but we're hearing what's being asked. And we have [1:54:15] a special use application in for the planning zoning for the 24th and those these issues [1:54:22] will probably come up again there. So we'll give us some time to think about it. [1:54:26] Does your address 222 Shoshone Street West? Yes, I'm sorry. Very good. Is there anyone else [1:54:34] from the public that would like to testify this evening? Okay, at this time I'm going to [1:54:39] close the public testimony portion but leave it open to council for questions and then later [1:54:45] I'll close the public hearing for just Council's deliberation. [1:54:50] So at this time, public testimony is closed. [1:54:52] And this is for questions from Council. [1:54:56] Chris Stockton. [1:54:58] So I'm referring to the city staff. [1:55:00] If we approve the vacation prior to issuing a building permit, [1:55:05] can we hold the school district accountable [1:55:08] for providing safe access on Federation Avenue [1:55:11] through an improvement, like sidewalks? [1:55:17] whatever, you know. [1:55:19] So you need to remember that the vacation and the [1:55:22] Recept Division request is by the owner of the [1:55:25] properties, the developer. [1:55:29] So it would be our recommendation if you need a [1:55:33] condition, for example, development of Federation [1:55:37] Way, you could attach that to the approval of either [1:55:40] one of these, because it is the developer that is [1:55:46] sort of creating the problem all those school districts going to take it over so [1:55:51] it's not school district it's the it's the developer. Do we have any further [1:55:59] questions Council? Jonathan maybe I have a question for you. So looking into the [1:56:11] future generally when when development happens the developer completes the [1:56:18] roadway, or at least half the roadway, right? Half the portion of the roadway. And also upgrades [1:56:27] roads that need be, like Grandview. What's going to happen? How does this work with the [1:56:33] school district? Because I can hear what they're saying. I mean, we've got to have a safe travel. [1:56:39] Grandview is also a rural road that's utilized for agricultural purposes and the ability to [1:56:46] do agriculture and kids going to school, I see kind of a conflict here. [1:56:52] So the portions of the roads of the school would be adjacent to and be improved to the [1:56:58] size required by engineering. [1:57:00] Okay. [1:57:01] The other sections would not until they were developed. [1:57:07] So Federation Point will be built out? [1:57:10] Federation Road would be built to where the school owns the property. [1:57:15] Okay. [1:57:16] the whole lifetime. And what Brad was talking about currently the sidewalk and I [1:57:21] walked it today to get photos for the species permit. Okay. Currently the road, [1:57:26] the sidewalk ends right there. Okay. The road isn't actually built here. The [1:57:34] sidewalk and curb are built to that point right there. So tell me where the [1:57:39] school's gonna be again? Over here. When that school's built they don't have to [1:57:42] build the road out to it. They wouldn't have to build this second road to here. [1:57:47] So the section I'm highlighting right now would not be built. [1:57:51] It's not adjacent to where the school is building. [1:57:57] So there would be a disconnect from the sidewalk standpoint, as far as currently built from [1:58:01] this corner of that green over to about somewhere in here, and the roadway is currently not [1:58:13] built past. [1:58:14] I think it's this lot that has a house on it, so it would be somewhere right here. [1:58:17] From there to there on the north side would not be built. [1:58:22] The south side, that's where they build half. [1:58:25] The south side would be contingent on whenever [1:58:27] these subdivisions were developed. [1:58:29] Right, we're still in the question stage. [1:58:34] Chris talking to. [1:58:35] Well, I mean, can we not table this until the school district [1:58:40] comes back with an agreement of the user immediately [1:58:44] to the east for its about some sort of avoiding a deferral [1:58:52] agreement that the building out of the north side sidewalk, I guess, is where [1:58:59] Kurt got her sidewalk. Chris, I'm still gonna tell you this is I know the school [1:59:04] district is driving this. This is not a school district deal. Understand. This is [1:59:08] developers. They have approved Northwest Passage number three and number four [1:59:14] that they're asking you to replat. Vacate and then replat. Vacate and replat. So for [1:59:23] For example, when you talk about the development along the school, or the future school, you're [1:59:28] really talking about the development along Northern Passage number four, not the school. [1:59:35] Because they'll have to come in with a developers agreement, an agreement to develop all the [1:59:40] streets, curb gutter and sidewalk at that time, including the part adjacent to the school. [1:59:46] So I think you're getting a little bit off track when you're focused on the school here. [1:59:49] That's not to say that school might not get with the developer and make some arrangement [1:59:54] between them about how that needs to be done. [1:59:57] Thank you. [1:59:58] Okay. [2:00:00] Do we have any further questions for turn it over for deliberations? [2:00:03] All right. [2:00:05] We will close that portion and now it's over to council for deliberations at this point. [2:00:10] No questions for the audience, staff members other than legal questions to our attorney. [2:00:14] Suzanne Hawkins. [2:00:18] I do have one question for Fritz. [2:00:22] In your opinion, would it be better to put the extra condition on the vacation or on the [2:00:29] second part when we're looking at the rezone or the planning? [2:00:37] The plat, yeah. [2:00:40] Probably makes the vacation doesn't do anything. [2:00:43] I would say attached to the re-platting. [2:00:45] Okay. [2:00:46] Thank you. [2:00:48] Chris talking. [2:00:49] With that resolved, I would move to approved vacation of the 13 acres of undeveloped property [2:00:55] within a person in northern passing the subdivision of 3 and 4 consisting of 46 single family locks [2:01:01] and adjacent rights of way and easements to allow for development of a new elementary school [2:01:07] on property located at the northeast corner of Federation Road in Granville, North. [2:01:12] this include the [2:01:15] and that include the [2:01:17] attached conditions [2:01:20] Have motion on floor by Chris talking and seconded by Greg Lanting as stated [2:01:25] Anything further on that motion council? I? [2:01:29] Just want to say that obviously we're struggling with this a little bit because I you know we we look at these things [2:01:35] Of the future and the safety of the kids getting back for the school and transportation and livelihoods and all those dynamics that we're hearing about [2:01:44] So that's why we're asking so many questions, and it's really important. [2:01:49] I see no further questions. [2:01:51] They got it for a call vote. [2:01:52] Great Lansing. [2:01:53] Yes. [2:01:54] Don Hall. [2:01:54] Yes. [2:01:57] Suzanne Hawkins. [2:01:58] Yes. [2:01:59] Jim. [2:01:59] Yes. [2:02:00] Sean Dereger. [2:02:01] Yes. [2:02:01] That's talking. [2:02:02] Yes. [2:02:03] Motion passes six to zero. [2:02:05] Chris, Don, I would mayor, I'd like to make sure that the city keeps on top of [2:02:10] this and informs the council at the time of planning that this was a primary [2:02:14] concern of us of the extension or development of Federation. [2:02:18] I agree, Chris, you got to grand view. [2:02:20] Very good, sir. [2:02:21] And you do know that the final plot is next for items consideration. [2:02:26] So at this time, we were moving out of the public hearing and going into items for consideration again. [2:02:33] And this next item is consideration request to approve the final plot of the northern passage subdivision number five, [2:02:40] processing of 13 plus or minus acres of undeveloped property within a portion of northern passage [2:02:47] subdivision number three and four. Again, Tim Bossert, you want to add some more? EHM [2:02:57] engineer in northern passage ink. Tim Bossert with EHM. Now we're at the point where we're [2:03:08] back to where we started. Well, actually, kind of. So what we're asking for, thank you [2:03:16] for granting the vacation. What we're asking for now is for the approval of the final [2:03:22] class of Northern Passage Subdivision Number 5. This will create 15 single family lots, [2:03:30] and just for your benefit they are, we have stipulated that there are single family lots [2:03:37] on the preliminary class the developer has no wish to do any [2:03:40] duplexes or any type of development like that in them. [2:03:43] All these are 8,000 square feet or more except for the school [2:03:47] district lot which is essentially less right away at 10 [2:03:51] acre parcel for the school district's use. [2:03:54] We I guess I'll just put it out there. [2:04:00] I would ask that you approve this and if the need for [2:04:06] condition comes for any type of pathway or off-site connection. I would ask that council [2:04:13] consider it in a temporary manner as opposed to something in the vein of a hardened sidewalk [2:04:24] that because ultimately street improvements, irrigation improvements will ruin anything that [2:04:29] goes in there at this point when full development takes place. So I'd ask if you do look at [2:04:35] that as a condition you would think more in lines [2:04:38] of something temporary, temporary paved path [2:04:41] that could be obliterated with a little more cost effectively. [2:04:45] I would ask that that not be a condition, [2:04:47] but if it is, I would ask you to look at that method [2:04:53] and I ask for your approval. [2:04:54] Thank you. [2:04:55] Very good, sir. [2:04:56] I see no questions at this point. [2:04:58] There might be, so we'll turn it back over to staff report. [2:05:03] Jonathan Spindler. [2:05:04] Thank you Mr. Mayor. [2:05:05] As this is an item of consideration, typically, [2:05:08] I don't go through the entire staff report. [2:05:10] I think Tim's been a very good job in summarizing [2:05:12] what they're asking for. [2:05:14] He's shown the plat of where it's going to be [2:05:16] and we've discussed it in length. [2:05:18] There are conditions that staff has written into that report. [2:05:24] There's three, I'll read those conditions. [2:05:27] Subject to final technical review and amendments [2:05:29] as required by building engineering fire and zoning officials [2:05:32] to ensure compliance with all applicable [2:05:34] City code requirements and standards. [2:05:36] Number two, subject to arterial and collector streets [2:05:38] adjacent and within the boundary being dedicated [2:05:40] to the City of Twin Falls and to be rebuilt or built [2:05:43] to current city standards on development [2:05:46] or change of use of the property. [2:05:47] Number three, subject to approval and publication [2:05:50] of an ordinance for the vacation of the requested portion [2:05:53] of Northern Pass subdivision number three and four. [2:05:57] That concludes the staff report. [2:05:59] Do we have any questions for either staff or Mr. Bosser? [2:06:05] Greg Lanning. [2:06:11] All right, I will turn it over to council for direction. [2:06:15] Greg Lanning. [2:06:15] Well, I'm going to make a motion. [2:06:17] And then I think that would be the changes we want to do. [2:06:20] I think we should be doing that. [2:06:23] The request of the final plan. [2:06:25] Do we approve the final plan of one of the past [2:06:27] subdivision number five, consistent of 13 plus [2:06:30] and minus acres of undeveloped property [2:06:32] within a portion of the northern past and subdivisions three [2:06:35] and four? [2:06:36] This is replat with 16 residential laws [2:06:38] that allow for the development. [2:06:39] single public residence, London Elementary School, [2:06:42] on property located northeast border, [2:06:44] Federation Road, and Grand D Drive, [2:06:46] north with the staff, [2:06:49] right with these three staff, [2:06:52] very good sir. [2:06:53] Second. [2:06:54] We have Motion on 4 by Greg Lanting, [2:06:56] seconded by Sean Berger. [2:06:58] Sean Berger. [2:07:00] What is the, and this question is probably [2:07:02] for a brad or a brady. [2:07:04] What is the timeline for completion of the, [2:07:08] of this school? [2:07:12] You have to come to the school district, the school will open in September of 2016. [2:07:21] Okay. [2:07:23] Thank you. [2:07:24] Do we have any further questions? [2:07:28] Chris talking. [2:07:29] I would move to amend the motion that the applicant be required to provide an improved safety walking [2:07:39] a lame from the end of improvements on Federation Road to Grandview as part of the plating. [2:07:51] May that be a temporary one? [2:07:52] Well that's what I meant. [2:07:53] Okay, very good. [2:07:54] Thank you, Chris. [2:07:55] Second. [2:07:56] We have motion on board by Chris talking and seconded by Suzanne Hawkins to per as stated, [2:08:03] as stated. [2:08:04] Greg Lanning. [2:08:05] question, Chris, is the motion maker a while we have to have our kids to the school district [2:08:09] property? [2:08:12] Yeah, I would I would just stand for that change. Yeah, second. Okay, we changed it just the school [2:08:17] district property. Very good. Get the kids there. Greg, do you have anything for them? [2:08:23] Well, I'm a one-torn on this because this goes back to the game of my playing, as well [2:08:30] as I'm eating. I'm still a little worried that we're ahead of ourselves because we have opportunities [2:08:35] later during this bus used for many different things from the school district to attach those at that point. [2:08:41] And that's the reason I didn't put it in my original motion. [2:08:44] Because that's usually when those types of things are handled. [2:08:49] That also gives us good districts of time to go to the developers and work out something. [2:08:55] I mean, there may be a situation where the developers, they know that they're close to doing three, [2:09:00] and they're just going to go ahead and decide to do it now because they know it's [2:09:04] going to be part of the situation because it's money they're going to have to spend [2:09:07] anyway. When the tree goes in they're going to have to put the street in they're [2:09:11] going to have to put the sidewalk in all and that's to go in. And so I don't know [2:09:15] what that for this recession whether they're in case flush enough to do that or [2:09:19] not at this point I don't know they need some more lots before they could but [2:09:23] there's a chance that we could have it taken here and at that point and I just [2:09:27] It's like it's clean here that if we put it on a special use permit, I realized that special use permit only gets to us on appeal, but we have the right to appeal it to us into this special use permit. [2:09:39] So I guess that's my reason that I will probably vote against the amendment. [2:09:44] Not that I don't think it's needed because I do, I just would rather have it be on the special use permit not on the flat because the special use permit uses the school district. [2:09:53] The plot we're still developing, we're still working with the developer. [2:09:58] Thank you, Greg. [2:09:59] I have a light, but I'm going to turn it over to Travis for a minute. [2:10:02] He has comment. [2:10:03] Mr. Mayor, members of the council, thank you for the opportunity just to quickly talk about [2:10:07] it. [2:10:08] Staff would recommend that as you're looking at a temporary easement or temporary pathway [2:10:13] associated with this project, that the responsibility to maintain that, to be the responsibility of [2:10:19] the developer as part of that, so that it is very clear that it will not be the city's [2:10:24] responsibility to maintain a temporary path of reason. [2:10:29] I'll look at the motion maker and the second and see if that meets your approval. [2:10:35] What do you think second? [2:10:37] I think so. [2:10:39] Okay, okay, very good, Suzanne Hawkes. [2:10:41] Thank you. [2:10:43] So I'm really torn on this too, but where we're just asking for some kind of temporary path. [2:10:50] I don't want to wait and let it go to a special use permit and have something [2:10:53] missed down the road while we're addressing it tonight. [2:10:56] I think that the people who live in that neighborhood know the traffic and they know [2:11:00] the amount of pharma that's on that road and I think would be really [2:11:04] amiss to not have some other way to get these kids to the school and [2:11:09] where it's a year and a half from opening I think that we really we need to [2:11:13] hold somebody accountable to have a path put through there. [2:11:19] You know I'm going to vote in favor of the motion because it just gives us [2:11:24] assurance that this is going to be done not that these developers wouldn't do it [2:11:28] Because I know that you are quality developers. [2:11:31] You care about the kids as well. [2:11:33] But we just definitely don't. [2:11:35] This just gives us maybe some assurance that there [2:11:40] is this temporary path for our kids to get to school safely. [2:11:45] I think that's important. [2:11:47] Anything further on the amendment? [2:11:50] So we will go with the amendment first. [2:11:52] Leanna, could you roll call vote? [2:11:55] Don Hall? [2:11:56] Yes. [2:11:56] Suzanne Hawkins? [2:11:57] Yes. [2:11:58] Jim Munn. No. Sean Berriger. No. Chris Talkington. Yes. Greg Latte. No. Motion is three to three. [2:12:12] Read that right. Yep. So it fails. Moving to the main motion. Greg Lanning. I just want a [2:12:20] conversation on a clear discussion. I even though I wanted no one as part of that, I still [2:12:27] expected to see it as part of the special use permit and if it doesn't have it on [2:12:32] the special use permit I personally will appeal especially this permit to the [2:12:37] council so we have another chance to look at it. Very good thanks Greg. Sean [2:12:42] Berner. I just want to say I agree with the comments that Greg made earlier I [2:12:46] think as the special use permit process comes through is the opportunity to do [2:12:51] that I would also encourage the developers as well as the future purchasers of that property [2:13:01] to consider not only pedestrian access but vehicular access. [2:13:05] To be perfectly honest, I'm less concerned about kids being able to walk to school than [2:13:11] I am about a single vehicular access to the school. [2:13:16] I think that some of what the testimony we heard earlier is about the reality. [2:13:23] I would love if lots of kids walk to school, but as someone who drops my kids off at school, [2:13:29] I know most people don't. [2:13:32] And I do think the design of these new schools is more accommodating of heavier traffic flows, [2:13:40] but again, it's all in grand view. [2:13:43] It's all coming in one place and I would just encourage you all to be thinking about [2:13:47] are there solutions to getting Federation connected through to help alleviate that? [2:13:54] I'm just going to run into my life. [2:13:56] Great learning. [2:13:57] I agree with Sean. [2:13:59] Well, hardly my minimum is going to be the path. [2:14:02] I would like the other bits. [2:14:04] If you could put up the one that shows the land to the south of the school, you'll notice [2:14:11] down there, you've got to grab your state subdivision as a future possibility, but just [2:14:16] North of that is a farm field that has not been planted, has not been anything, it's not been planted, so we're not going to get [2:14:24] Grandview wide and all the way to that light anytime soon. And so that's what makes Federation even more important to the North of South of it. [2:14:33] South of it's to the south of our politics. The south of the Grandview comes all the way and there is a light there at pole line, but that's a farm field that I [2:14:42] I mean, I can see a plaque tomorrow, but I don't think I'm going to for that farm field. [2:14:49] So I don't see us getting brand new on either side wide there for a while, so that just makes [2:14:54] Federation road even more of that more important because we could be years seeing something [2:15:01] better on Grandpa. [2:15:03] Anything further on motion council? [2:15:06] We are back to the main motion. [2:15:08] The alder will call vote please. [2:15:10] Suzanne Hunkins? [2:15:11] Yes. [2:15:12] Yes, Sean Bericher. Yes. Yes. Yes. Greg Lansing. Yes. Don Hall. Yes. Motion passes [2:15:19] six to zero. Thank you all for your patience and that concludes our Fritz [2:15:25] Wonderlec would like to say something. I wouldn't but Gary Nelson is interested [2:15:29] in this and he does have something. Gary Nelson. Welcome sir. Gary Nelson [2:15:37] 2 4 6 9th Avenue North representing Canyon Trail Subdivision [2:15:46] 6 and 8 [2:15:48] We'd just like to could you show us 6 and 8 with a [2:15:53] 6 and 8 very good. Thank you, sir [2:15:55] As we stated earlier, we're going to develop [2:16:01] the street that goes [2:16:06] Can't quite read it there, but [2:16:08] We're going to develop this street this summer and we'll be taking Federation to that point [2:16:16] Is that Prospector Way? [2:16:18] Prospector Way. [2:16:20] The phase number eight right here, our responsibility for Federation would be over to this point for the Joints Grand U.S. States. [2:16:31] And I would just like to, the Council to know that we would like to participate in a way that would allow Federation to go through sooner. [2:16:42] sooner we think that it's it is a safety issue and it is something that will [2:16:46] benefit the community at whole and even though our plans have always been to do [2:16:52] seven before eight we would consider making improvements to that portion of [2:17:00] federation in order to enable that to happen sooner so we appreciate that [2:17:04] much. Yeah thank you Miss Nelson for your comments and bring that forward [2:17:08] appreciate your cooperation. Is there anyone else? Again, we are now adjourned.