Oversight Archive: City Council meeting, 2016-06-27, recording 1 (started 17:00) Machine transcript (faster-whisper base.en), not checked word for word; the Pledge of Allegiance is shown in its standard wording. The recording is the record. Times are time into the recording. Passages with private details are muted in the audio and marked here. The audio on the page below was re-encoded by software from the video the agency posted. Check any passage against that audio before relying on it. Page: https://oversightarchive.org/twin-falls-id/meetings/2016-06-27/ [0:00:00] Start off, we have some Boy Scouts here from Troop 164, who I'd like to invite up to lead [0:00:05] us in the Pledge of Allegiance. For those of you wishing to join us, please rise. [0:00:09] Boy, as you can come on right down here. [0:00:12] I pledge allegiance to the Flag of the United States of America, and to the Republic for which it stands, one Nation under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all. [0:00:53] Thank you, gentlemen, and if you could please step up to the podium here, there'll be very [0:00:58] easy questions, I promise. [0:01:00] If you could just tell us your name and which troop you're with and what you're working on, [0:01:04] your badges that you're working on this evening, we'd appreciate it. [0:01:07] So if you stand on the other side there and face toward us, the microphone's right there. [0:01:14] Great, thank you. [0:01:22] Yep, if you can just step up to the podium, right here. [0:01:25] Mitch, can you show them where the microphone is there? [0:01:27] Thank you. [0:01:28] I'm part of the square engine and I'm working on, I'm from troop 0.64 and I'm working on [0:01:34] my communications and citizenship in the community merit badges. [0:01:38] Welcome, thank you. [0:01:39] I'm Aiden Square Engine and I'm also working on my citizenship in the community. [0:01:46] Great, well thank you all for being here and thank you for leaving us in the pledge this [0:01:49] evening. [0:01:54] I do want to confirm we do have a quorum of the council here, all seven members are [0:01:58] here this evening. [0:01:59] Mr. Rothweiler are there any amendments to the agenda to this evening? Mr. Mayor members of the council there are no amendments this evening [0:02:05] Thank you, sir [0:02:07] Next on the agenda will be a general public input [0:02:10] But before we begin that this evening [0:02:13] I'd like to open with just a few remarks and a bit of discussion about developments in our community over the past week as [0:02:21] Gleest chief Kingsbury addressed last Monday at this council meeting [0:02:25] There is an ongoing investigation of a sexual assault that occurred at the Fund Brook Apartments [0:02:30] earlier this month. [0:02:32] At the heart of this incident is a five-year-old victim, a little girl and her family who I [0:02:39] send my thoughts and my support and my love to, just as you all have. [0:02:45] This young girl's safety continues to be protected through the work of law enforcement, prosecuting [0:02:51] attorney's office, and various partner agencies. [0:02:55] These partners continue to work together to bring justice in this case. [0:03:01] Justice through the due process of our Constitution and laws and ordinances, and justice specific [0:03:07] to the difficult circumstances of this case as it involves juveniles and has been sealed [0:03:12] by the court. [0:03:15] The three suspects have been charged. [0:03:17] The two who had been in juvenile detention were released from custody late last week [0:03:21] at the order of a judge. [0:03:22] And in cases like these involving juveniles, release includes agreements tailored to the [0:03:28] case to protect the safety of the victim and the public safety. [0:03:33] There are many more steps in the proceedings to take place in this case before it is resolved [0:03:37] by a judge. [0:03:39] And as that due process in this case plays out, I urge our community to pause. [0:03:47] to pause to remember the victim, to pause to remember the process ahead of us, and to show [0:03:55] faith in the law of our land that justice will be served. Through the discussion of this issue [0:04:02] here in these council chambers, emotions have run high on both sides of this dais. When [0:04:08] we speak from a place of emotion and without all the facts, we spread misinformation and [0:04:14] doubts, and as tidbits of this not quite truth and suspicion spread, particularly in [0:04:21] the world of instant and unchecked communication online, they were woven together into a narrative [0:04:28] of falsehood. And when people who do not live in our community, who are not our friends [0:04:35] and neighbors, who don't share our values and the positive experiences that we have in [0:04:41] this community. When these people latch on to that story and they spread it like wildfire [0:04:48] over the world wide web, a story that is beyond the bounds of reason and based on emotion and [0:04:57] fiction, it paints a picture of our community that is not us. It paints one full of hatred [0:05:08] and divisiveness and it brands us all as individuals and as a community as something that we know [0:05:17] know we are not. This is not us as a community. For all our differences, I know that we have [0:05:25] more in common than we don't have in common. We are friendly and neighborly and we love [0:05:33] this community with all of our hearts. It's why we live here and work here and play here. [0:05:41] It's why we want to raise our families here. It's why we continue to invest in our future [0:05:47] so that we can build on our collective prosperity and give opportunity to others to join us, [0:05:53] the same as the pioneers who came here and founded this region and settled here and found [0:06:00] new promise in the Magic Valley. [0:06:04] And it's why when we hear the report of a terrible crime, we step up and do our jobs to [0:06:11] protect and support the victim and the safety of everyone in our community. [0:06:18] As we move forward, I encourage us to do this in unity. [0:06:22] I'm certainly not saying that we're going to agree on everything. [0:06:27] But as we discuss these things, we need to do it based in fact and good information. [0:06:34] And we must all keep our emotions in balance with our logic. [0:06:40] And we need to do that honestly and respectfully. [0:06:44] So I would ask this evening as you come forward to address the City Council that you please [0:06:50] Please keep in mind the common goals that we have instead of the divisiveness that has [0:06:57] been painted about our community in this past week and that you be honest and respectful [0:07:05] and I will speak for myself that I will do the same with you. [0:07:11] So with that I would welcome members of the public to come forward to address the council. [0:07:21] Is there anyone who wishes to come forward and address the council? [0:07:25] Please. [0:07:34] And for the record please state your name. [0:07:36] Thank you. [0:07:37] First of all, I acknowledge that at least I understand not reading the article that there [0:07:48] were threats lobbied against someone or more than one person on this council. [0:07:54] So I will petition my God, Elohim, by Jesus Christ, for your security, each one of you, [0:08:02] for your family's security. [0:08:04] And I will pray that you are safe, no harm will come to any one of you or to anyone you [0:08:09] love or this community, and that the perpetrators of this crime, which is grievous, will be found [0:08:18] out, brought to justice, and obviously incarcerated, if need be. [0:08:26] Many of you are my friends, and I care about you as people. [0:08:30] I've respected what you have committed to doing in this community, and like I said last [0:08:35] week, this is an honorable seat. [0:08:39] I want to acknowledge you Ms. Hawkins for your excellence last week during a very fiery meeting. [0:08:47] You are an example to your peers, and I appreciate you keeping calm, speaking calm, and allowing [0:08:54] the community to actually have emotions about something that they should have emotions about. [0:09:01] This is something that we do come together with. [0:09:03] Thank God we come together and we are emotional about this type of issue. [0:09:08] type of people would we be if we were not emotional about the rape of a small child? [0:09:16] I would advise again to consider in any decision made forthcoming that we do, that you do, together [0:09:27] agree that the security of this community be held higher than any other desire for economic [0:09:35] gain or otherwise, that the security of this community be the priority in your mind as [0:09:42] you make decisions about who is or who is not going to be sought out and brought into [0:09:47] this community no matter what group they are from. [0:09:53] I'd like to be a little personal. [0:09:55] There's a little person who is afraid to go out of her house, who wears two pairs of underpants [0:10:02] to protect herself now. [0:10:05] And she can't go out of her house because her perpetrator is still living next door. [0:10:12] So who has become the prisoner after being dragged and attacked and violated, who has [0:10:19] become the prisoner? [0:10:21] It is the family who can't afford to move because of poverty, and I think we all know [0:10:26] that poor people in our community are the primary victims of crime, and it remains true [0:10:33] in this case, and there is a secondary offense when someone is not safe to go out of their [0:10:39] house because their perpetrator remains their neighbor. [0:10:44] I'm not certain if this is the way Idaho always governs violations for people under 18. [0:10:51] If it is, I think we need to address that as a state. [0:10:54] We need to address that as a city. [0:10:57] Perhaps we need to amend how we do things in order to protect underage people when they [0:11:03] are violated by a peer. [0:11:05] And instead of looking at two and three years as having a big significance, look at [0:11:10] the actions that were perpetrated by the offender. [0:11:18] We are responsible to keep her safe. [0:11:21] She does not have the power to do that. [0:11:23] I don't have the power to do that. [0:11:27] I can only petition my city and my police department to do that. [0:11:33] I know that they have already received an eviction notice, among other things, and they [0:11:40] are still there. [0:11:41] And this little boy is still in the neighborhood playing with all the other children, while [0:11:46] his victim is held inside of her apartment to be safe. [0:11:51] She's trying to recover, how can she? [0:11:59] I'll end being religious once again, [0:12:02] because it's important to me that we have [0:12:03] that religious freedom, no matter what faith we are. [0:12:07] Righteousness exalts a people, but sin is a reproach. [0:12:11] Thank you. [0:12:14] Thank you, Mrs. Ruff, for your comments. [0:12:18] Senator Welt, anyone else who wishes [0:12:20] to address the council this evening? [0:12:22] Please come forward, sir. [0:12:27] My name is Russ Krauss, and I live here in Twin Falls. [0:12:32] And I was going to talk last week, and as I told Don, I think that the council had been beaten up on quite enough, and anything I might say would not make any sense. [0:12:49] But having moved here, let me tell you, about a year ago, I did speak to this council, and that was in opposition to the refugees. [0:13:03] And I haven't been back until last week. [0:13:08] And now I'm thinking more and more about it. [0:13:15] But there are some things that bother me about twin falls. [0:13:22] And you may not remember my face, but you might remember the statement that I made [0:13:27] that I could move out of twin falls right now, and it wouldn't bother me [0:13:33] because I didn't like what I saw coming from Wisconsin to Idaho. [0:13:44] Some of the things that Don and I talked about also just a few minutes ago. [0:13:49] I've noticed either a lack of zoning or a lack of follow-through on zoning. [0:13:59] I see houses going up next to more modest houses. [0:14:05] It's almost like there's no plan. [0:14:08] And we all know if there's no plan, [0:14:13] any road will take you to that end result. [0:14:17] Your roads need help, excuse me, [0:14:20] our roads need help. [0:14:21] I'm a resident of Twin Falls. [0:14:25] There are some roads that are like going over a washboard. [0:14:34] Two things in particular that I think the council should take a look at because you probably [0:14:42] see it or look at it but never see it. [0:14:47] And that is approximately four miles west toward Filer. [0:14:52] On the south side of the road, there's a house up on, it almost looks like it could drive [0:15:00] it away and it looks like the whole front end has blown apart. [0:15:05] That house is not moved, but that's the first thing that people see as they get off of Highway [0:15:11] 93, coming down 30 to come into the city and then when you get to Rock Creek, there's [0:15:27] a twin falls, welcome to twin falls. The sign that says welcome to twin falls almost could [0:15:37] say don't come back. That is one of the, I'll use the word ugliest signs I think I have ever [0:15:48] seen going in and out of the city. It's not a friendly, warm-hearted greeting when you come [0:15:58] in. And it's right on, again on the south side of the road and right across from the [0:16:05] old hospital. And by the way, thank you for fixing this. It wasn't fixed last week and it [0:16:15] was flopping all over the place. And I was going to bring up the fact that when I did [0:16:22] speak to the council about a year ago, someone said, well, it is a problem and we're going [0:16:27] to fix it. It wasn't fixed as of last week, but it seems to be right now. And if I might [0:16:34] suggest I think Twin Falls has to get its house in order before it starts going out [0:16:45] and continuing on the refugee program, continuing on all of the other programs that I'm a Christian [0:16:59] And it kills me to say this. [0:17:02] But I think that things have to go into a logical progression. [0:17:11] And for heaven's sakes, I would hate to see this city, [0:17:17] my city also, get into the same thing [0:17:21] that Europe is potentially getting into right now, [0:17:25] because that would destroy Twin Falls. [0:17:30] Thank you, Mr. Mayor. [0:17:31] Thank you and your council for hearing some of these things. [0:17:37] Thank you Mr. Kras, I appreciate your comments. [0:17:42] Is there anyone else who would wish to address the council at this time? [0:17:54] My name is Terry Edwards. [0:17:56] I just wanted to say that I wasn't going to speak today, but then after this mayor's [0:18:03] soliloquy, which was very well thought out, very well planned. [0:18:12] I just wanted to ask each one of you. [0:18:14] It's been 25 days now since this incident occurred. [0:18:18] What have you done personally to soothe and comfort [0:18:22] the victim or the family, other than turning it over [0:18:25] to the police department, washing your hands of it? [0:18:28] So my concern is, is that you have little concern [0:18:32] because we would have heard about this week following [0:18:37] when we brought this to your attention. [0:18:38] In fact, we were almost chastised and called [0:18:42] by at least one person nearly a racist that we were connected with racist groups. [0:18:48] So the community comes and tells you things, turns out to be maybe not specifically totally [0:18:54] accurate, but this little girl was violated. [0:18:58] And you guys chastised us for bringing that attention to you, with that to your attention. [0:19:04] I don't understand it. [0:19:05] You're supposed to be compassionate. [0:19:07] We elect you folks. [0:19:09] I don't live in Twin Falls. [0:19:11] I own property in Twin Falls and I'm concerned about it, [0:19:14] but people elect you to be compassionate, [0:19:18] to hear the city council members and different views [0:19:22] and the city, when they come to you, they're concerned. [0:19:26] Do you think we would have walked down here [0:19:27] and come to you because we just made something up? [0:19:31] And by you guys not putting your foot forward first [0:19:35] and getting ahead of this issue, [0:19:37] this is what you brought on your own heads. [0:19:39] And it's a shame, but this is what's going to happen in the future if you don't step up and do your job and get ahead of the issue. [0:19:46] Instead of trying to sweep it under the carpet. [0:19:50] How long was it before anybody even reported it in the paper? [0:19:55] So, sir, I appreciate your concerns that you're sharing this evening. [0:20:01] Some of what you are discussing right now is the exact components of not quite truths that I'm concerned about. [0:20:10] crime was reported when it occurred, it was investigated when it occurred. [0:20:15] And our job as council members is not to investigate crime in this case. [0:20:20] Nobody's asking you to investigate it. [0:20:22] Excuse me, I was talking and you interrupted my comments here. [0:20:26] What I was saying is that it was reported and none of you had a clue. [0:20:31] You didn't know anything about it. [0:20:32] I heard each one of you that spoke, well, we didn't know that. [0:20:35] We haven't heard anything. [0:20:36] We don't know anything. [0:20:37] And we're sitting there with our hands in the air going, what? [0:20:40] What? [0:20:41] You mean there's something that's serious and since you're over the police department, what [0:20:47] I understand is that's one of your departments, why aren't you having a liaison come in here [0:20:51] and brief you on these situations so that you know what's going on? [0:20:55] So you don't have to look like a bunch of bumps on the log and embarrass yourself and embarrass [0:21:00] this community. [0:21:01] I would ask for respect, sir. [0:21:02] Bump on the logs and not showing respect and not showing knowledge of the things that go [0:21:08] on in this community. You embarrass yourselves. You are an embarrassment to this community [0:21:15] and it needs to change. Not all of you were because there are some people that actually [0:21:19] stood for something here. But most of you haven't from your experience. We've seen it. [0:21:26] We saw what you did. We saw what you said. We heard what you said. It's recorded. It's [0:21:32] not conjecture. It's fact. And sure, it goes viral because people don't like this kind [0:21:40] of attitude, you're supposed to support all the people. [0:21:45] I think it was you that said, Mr. Mayor, that you support everybody, that we all treat everybody [0:21:51] equally. [0:21:52] They're all under the law. [0:21:53] We treat them all equally. [0:21:54] Well, you're not treating this girl equally, from what I've seen, the experience that I've [0:22:00] witnessed in the media and comments that have been made by, I don't think you guys have [0:22:06] even made any comments at all. [0:22:09] else has checked in on it and made some comment except today now you come out with this beautiful [0:22:16] story about how you're so concerned why didn't you show that concern when we first brought [0:22:21] it to your attention and say wow that really something we got to look into but instead we [0:22:27] write down questions with our names to get answers so you have time to cook up some kind [0:22:33] of a report that covers everybody's tail. [0:22:38] Why couldn't you just spontaneously answer the question? [0:22:43] So I'm asking you, what have you, each one of you, done [0:22:47] since this occurred, personally, to support that girl? [0:22:51] Not calling the police chief, finding out what the details were, [0:22:56] calling the federal prosecutor and voicing and complaining [0:23:00] to them. [0:23:01] And I think this, I think you, Mr. Rockweiler, one of them that said that you were going [0:23:05] to return to all these people that had letters sent to their houses talking about Jesus Christ [0:23:16] and the Koran versus the Bible and reported to the FBI. [0:23:22] I think that's been reported in the media. [0:23:25] I don't recall that statement at all, Mr. Edwards. [0:23:28] I apologize. [0:23:29] We don't have to apologize, but I think that was reported by our news media here. [0:23:36] That was not just recently. [0:23:37] This was back a year ago. [0:23:40] I have some letters mailed out and there was a comment in the newspaper and they referred [0:23:46] to you. [0:23:47] You said, bring them to me if you get them. [0:23:49] I will report them to the FBI and the proper authorities in the police. [0:23:55] So we'll go back and look, but again. [0:23:58] I wish that you were that enthusiastic, but that's the case and that turns out to be accurate [0:24:04] that you were that way with this situation that we'd have before us now. [0:24:10] So are you guys going to answer my question? [0:24:12] Do I have to write it down on a piece of paper and give you my contact information for you [0:24:17] to come back later and give me an explanation? [0:24:23] No comment. [0:24:24] Thank you. [0:24:26] Thank you, Mr. Edwards. [0:24:27] Is there anyone else who wishes to address the council? [0:24:33] My name is Heather Stroup and I live in Twin Falls [0:24:48] Heather, could you please speak up so that this meeting is recorded so that that can be heard you can pull that down? [0:24:55] Heather Stroup and I live in Twin Falls [0:25:02] Yeah, I don't appreciate the parts of your letter in which [0:25:06] You seem to be saying that there are liars in this community who are who are actually just concerned for the well for this little girl and her family [0:25:15] And I believe probably it's offensive to others who really just want the truth. [0:25:24] And that's why we're here, really, because all of us are concerned with lawlessness. [0:25:32] We're concerned with lawlessness wherever it is found, whether it's in the community [0:25:38] from perpetrators, or whether it's under the cover of darkness somewhere in government [0:25:47] or law enforcement. We don't want lawlessness in our community. We want to be protected from [0:25:56] all lawlessness wherever it's found. And the group of us, excuse me, have been getting together [0:26:05] on Wednesday nights and praying somewhere in the city that lawlessness will be uncovered. [0:26:13] And I believe that my God, Elohim, will answer that prayer and lawlessness will be uncovered. [0:26:24] Thank you for your comments. [0:26:29] If anyone else who wishes to address the council seeing none at this time, we will, yes sir, [0:26:37] please come forward. [0:26:42] You need to wait until you get to the microphone, please sir, since this recorded for the record. [0:26:45] My name is Tom Bikini. [0:26:46] I live here in Twin Falls. [0:26:48] Thank you. [0:26:52] I wasn't going to speak today, but I've been bothered by what I've heard about the kids. [0:26:58] And I'm here for the kids. [0:27:01] not just for the girl, but for all of them. They're juveniles. They're not adults. From [0:27:08] what I understand, the little girl was not raped. I don't think that these little boys [0:27:18] should have to go through anything horrific over this from what I understand. Although it [0:27:23] was not right, we have to be very careful how we treat children. I think you're doing [0:27:28] the right job. I think the prosecutor is doing the right job. I think a lot of this is religious [0:27:34] And it's wrong. We have laws that protect children. I want to let you know that I am in favor of [0:27:43] protecting the children. I'm disgusted with what's taking place here because I think a lot of it has to do with fear. [0:27:54] Does it not? Do we not all fear today because of the things that are going on throughout the world? [0:28:03] Well, the things that are going on are because of religious extremism. [0:28:07] Screamism people who think they know God and have the truth [0:28:13] God is in all of us [0:28:17] He's not in one belief system. I think a lot of this has to do with [0:28:22] the people here that are coming from other countries the what is it the [0:28:30] Big group we the people that are helping [0:28:35] I think a lot of this has to do with the refugee camp. I think people are scared. They don't want these people [0:28:41] people. To me, I'm 100% in favor of helping these people. These people are trying to escape [0:28:53] murder, brutality. I'm in favor of helping people, try to escape this. Little kids trying [0:29:02] to escape hunger being killed. In this country, I'm not in favor of people going nuts and killing [0:29:08] other people. But why couldn't we as a community help these people get to know these people [0:29:14] Wouldn't that be better if we knew them and we helped them rather than just point our [0:29:22] finger at them and put them all in a big group that they're Muslim? [0:29:26] It's like the Christian right thinks that they're right? [0:29:29] Nobody's right. [0:29:33] The God that we share is in all of us. [0:29:38] God doesn't hate the Muslims, doesn't love the Christians. [0:29:42] He loves all. [0:29:43] We are always to forgive, are we not? [0:29:46] In your life when you don't forgive, what happens? [0:29:48] Do you suffer? [0:29:50] Yes? [0:29:52] These are our brothers and our sisters, regardless of where [0:29:55] they come from, what color they are. [0:29:58] The only thing that makes us different, [0:29:59] because we're all flesh people, is the way we think. [0:30:04] And I suggest it's time for us to start to forgive, [0:30:07] start to love, and start to help. [0:30:10] Then we'll get to know things better. [0:30:12] And what better way to change anything but through our example? [0:30:16] Is that not true? [0:30:17] You're going to force somebody to change? [0:30:20] What they think, what they believe, no. [0:30:24] Anyways, I wanted to say I was in favor of this group of people [0:30:29] and the prosecutor not giving any information out [0:30:31] that is not necessary to this public [0:30:34] to protect all these children. [0:30:38] That's all I have to say. [0:30:40] Thank you, Mr. Rinkini. [0:30:51] My name is Twila Chapman and I am from Kimberly, Idaho. [0:30:54] I have to say personally, this gentleman that just spoke [0:31:00] does not know what he's talking about. [0:31:02] We are talking about a five-year-old girl that has gone through horrific incidents that nobody's saying what it is. [0:31:13] I understand that the case is stilled. We just need to take care of her. [0:31:19] Right now, the perpetrator is living still next door. She can't go outside. [0:31:27] other families enveloped in this, they can't go outside. They are afraid of what's next door. [0:31:35] What are we doing to help her with this? We need to take the main concern of all this is not hatred, [0:31:45] it's just we need to take care of this little person. And from personal experience, they are [0:31:56] totally afraid. Still, this five-year-old girl has gone through a whole lot. They won't [0:32:04] not open it. I totally understand, but I know personally what has happened. And we are, it's [0:32:13] not hate, love, whoever we are. It's what has happened to her by three older people that [0:32:23] she didn't even know what was happening. [0:32:27] Thank you. [0:32:28] Thank you. [0:32:29] Council. [0:32:38] I'm John Hate and I spent about 15 years on volunteer for juvenile probation and I understand [0:32:47] a little bit of where you guys are coming from and where Travis is coming from. [0:32:52] You guys can't say anything about a juvenile case. [0:32:56] I've sat on diversion board for years and I once the people walk out with a juvenile [0:33:02] I don't say a thing and you can't either and I admire you for not getting back in the paper [0:33:09] and throwing mud because we have rules and laws and these laws take it all of us. [0:33:16] And juvenile law, I was around when juvenile law changed, changed for the better. [0:33:23] I was volunteering the prison system when the juveniles were kept with the adults. [0:33:29] juveniles were kept with the adults. That's how long I go back. At least now they're separated [0:33:37] in. You guys did fine. You guys don't need to talk to the press. I don't elect you to talk [0:33:43] to the press all the time. It's not. [0:33:46] Thank you, Mr. Hay. [0:33:48] Hello. My name is Nolan Stroop. I suppose I cannot agree with every sentiment that has been [0:34:02] expressed here before because I believe there is such thing as right and wrong. I recall [0:34:07] hearing nobody's right or everybody's wrong or whatever it was. Nobody's suggesting that [0:34:14] any children go through anything horrific, but I'm sure you all agree that justice needs [0:34:21] to be done and we do have a juvenile justice program. I'm hoping we're all on the same page [0:34:28] here. Thank you, Mr. Stroup. Is there anyone else who would like to address the council at [0:34:35] this time? Seeing no one, we will move on with the rest of the council agenda this evening. [0:34:45] Item for consideration is the consent of their council wishes. [0:34:49] Chris Tockington. [0:34:50] Move approval is printed. [0:34:52] Motion by Chris Tockington. [0:34:56] Seconded by Nikki Boyd. [0:35:01] To approve the consent calendar as presented. [0:35:04] Is there any discussion? [0:35:06] Nikki Boyd. [0:35:07] Yep. [0:35:09] That's fine. [0:35:10] You're fine. [0:35:13] Seeing no discussion. [0:35:14] Share and roll call both please. [0:35:16] Mrs. Anne Hawkins. [0:35:17] Yes. [0:35:18] Nikki Boyd. [0:35:19] Yes. [0:35:20] John Barriker. [0:35:21] Yes. [0:35:21] Chris Talkington. [0:35:22] Yes. [0:35:23] Greg Lanting. [0:35:24] Yes. [0:35:24] Don Hall. [0:35:25] Yes. [0:35:26] Ruth Pierce. [0:35:26] Yes. [0:35:27] Motion passes 7-2-0. [0:35:31] Under items for consideration, we [0:35:33] have presentation of Peace Officer Standards and Training [0:35:36] Council certificates to Officer Matthew. [0:35:39] Oh, man, I'm with a slot of that one. [0:35:41] Gelta, Officer Simon Rodriguez, Detective Javier [0:35:47] and detective John R. Wilson. [0:35:50] My apologies for my mispronunciations. [0:35:53] I have Craig Stots and Chief Kingsbury. [0:35:57] Welcome, gentlemen. [0:36:01] Thank you, Mr. Mayor, members of council. [0:36:03] Thank you for giving us the opportunity to celebrate the success and achievements of our police officers. [0:36:08] Obtaining levels of certification in our profession takes into account years of experience, education, training, and dedication. [0:36:17] You have a police department full of professionals that take their job very serious, and you should be proud [0:36:23] After reading each officer's bio, I would ask chief Kingsbury and mayor burger [0:36:28] Please come forward and present the certificates and pose for a photo with our officers [0:36:32] This evening we're pleased to present actually I think three certificates unless officer Jelt is here. He is not here [0:36:40] So the first certificate will be presenting tonight [0:36:43] will be the intermediate certificate to Officer Simone Rodriguez. Simone Rodriguez [0:36:48] come forward. Simone Rodriguez was hired by the Twin Falls Police Department as a [0:36:55] full-time police officer on April 14th 2008. Simone was born in Pocatello, Idaho. He [0:37:05] and his family moved to Twin Falls when Simone was seven years old. He [0:37:08] graduated from Twin Falls High School. Simone started working for Albertsons at [0:37:12] age 16 and during his 14-year employment with Albertsons, he worked his way up to [0:37:17] grocery manager. Simone has served on the police department since actually in the patrol division [0:37:23] and in 2013 he became a school resource officer. Simone is currently assigned to O'Leary Middle [0:37:30] School. Simone and his wife Brianna have four daughters and twin sons. With six children, Simone [0:37:37] doesn't have a lot of spare time, but when he does he enjoys fly fishing. Simone was awarded [0:37:44] his post basic certification on October 20th of 2010, [0:37:48] and it is with great pleasure that we present Simone [0:37:52] with the intermediate certification [0:37:54] from the State of Idaho Peace Officers Standards [0:37:56] and Training Council. [0:38:23] If I could have Officer Javier Paredes please come forward. [0:38:29] Javier Paredes was hired by the Twin Falls Police Department [0:38:31] on December 10th, 2007 as a full time police officer. [0:38:35] Javier was born in Twin Falls, Idaho [0:38:37] and graduated from Twin Falls High School. [0:38:40] He attended the College of Southern Idaho and graduated with an associate's of arts degree [0:38:44] and business. [0:38:45] Prior to his employment with TFPD, he was a personal banker with Wells Fargo Bank. [0:38:50] During his ten year with our department, Javier has served in the patrol division, narcotics [0:38:55] unit, and as a SWAT team member, Javier is also a post-certified instructor in ground fighting. [0:39:01] Javier was awarded his post-basic certification on December 22, 2008, and his intermediate [0:39:07] certification on May 1, 2012. [0:39:11] Javier, it is of great pleasure that we present you with the advanced certification from the [0:39:15] State of Idaho Peace Officer Standards and Training Council. [0:39:36] Detective John Wilson, please come forward. [0:39:42] John R. Wilson was hired by the Twin Falls Police Department on March 20, 2006 as a full-time [0:39:47] police officer. [0:39:49] John was born and raised in Northwestern, Montana. [0:39:52] He graduated from Knoxville High School in Knoxville, Montana. [0:39:55] He served two and a half years with the Montana National Guard and four years in the United [0:39:59] States Navy serving on submarines. [0:40:02] Prior to his employment with TFPD, John worked with the Twin Falls School District for ten [0:40:06] years as the District Plumber. [0:40:09] From November 2003 to March 2006, John worked as a patrol officer with the Kimberly Police [0:40:15] Department. [0:40:17] John was awarded his post-basic certification on May 24, 2004, and his intermediate certificate [0:40:24] on November 20, 2009. [0:40:27] During his employment with Twin Falls PD, [0:40:29] John has served in the patrol division [0:40:31] and is currently assigned to the criminal investigation [0:40:33] division as a case detective. [0:40:35] John is a member of the Crisis Negotiations Unit [0:40:38] and the Honor Guard. [0:40:39] John has been married to his wife, Marilyn, [0:40:41] who I believe is here, for 30 years, [0:40:44] and they have two daughters, Darcy and Echo. [0:40:48] John and Marilyn have two grandsons. [0:40:50] Their granddaughter, Danica, was born last week, [0:40:53] and they're expecting another grandson in September. [0:40:56] It is with great pleasure that we present John [0:40:58] with the advanced certification [0:40:59] from the State of Idaho Peace Officer [0:41:01] Standard and Training Council. [0:41:24] Thank you. [0:41:35] Thank you, Lieutenant Statz, congratulations gentlemen. [0:41:37] Thank you for your continued dedication [0:41:39] to service to our community. [0:41:43] Next on the agenda is consideration of a request [0:41:46] from Brady Dickinson of the Twin Paul School District [0:41:48] to waive the building permit fees [0:41:51] for a new equipment storage shelter located at 1155 [0:41:54] of Highland Avenue East. [0:41:57] And we have Chair Courtney from our. [0:41:58] So we'll just help everybody. [0:41:59] So we'll just help everybody. [0:42:00] We've come up and describe the project, [0:42:01] and if you have any questions for me, I'll be right here. [0:42:07] Welcome, Dr. Dickinson. [0:42:09] Thank you. [0:42:11] Brady Dickinson, Twin Falls School District. [0:42:13] Mr. Mayor, members of the council, [0:42:15] we have a maintenance yard that's located out on Highland, [0:42:18] and we would like to build a small structure to park, [0:42:22] basically yard equipment, [0:42:24] tractors underneath to get it out of the weather. [0:42:26] Generally, we have a long standing relationship with the city and in the past the city is way of building permit fees to the district. [0:42:34] We share facilities, park and rec is able to use our facilities, we use city facilities, we're both supported by tax dollars and so I would once again come before you to ask a waiver of this fee. [0:42:48] I have to answer any questions right now. [0:42:51] Chris, what would the fee structure be for this? [0:42:55] Oh, you have the handle. [0:43:06] So it should be in the staff report, total fees that I have, $1,100, $1,114.99. [0:43:15] Okay, thank you. [0:43:17] And the impact fees will be assessed. [0:43:18] This is just plain review of the bill. [0:43:21] Thank you. [0:43:22] That was going to be my clarification for the audience and those people at home. [0:43:25] It's not all the fees. [0:43:27] It's just those two. [0:43:28] Yes, Mayor. [0:43:31] Great landing. [0:43:32] Mayor, are we ready for motion? [0:43:34] I believe so. [0:43:35] Mayor, I move that we waive the building fees [0:43:37] for the maintenance building that's being built [0:43:41] at the Highland Avenue for the Twin Falls School District. [0:43:44] Second. [0:43:46] Motion by Great Lansing, seconded by Don Hall [0:43:48] to prove the request to waive the building permit fees. [0:43:53] Suzanne Hawkins. [0:43:54] Thank you. [0:43:55] This might be better after the vote, [0:43:57] but I'm gonna take a stab in the dark [0:44:00] that this is probably gonna pass the council. [0:44:03] And I just wanted to mention, [0:44:04] And last week we were at the Association of Idaho City's annual conference and [0:44:09] it was my pleasure and honor to host a round table meeting of council members where they could ask any questions. [0:44:16] And it was just a group from all over the state talking about issues that come up in their cities. [0:44:21] And the main topic was do any of the city's waive fees for school districts and other like government agencies? [0:44:29] And it made me very proud that the City of Twin Falls has such a passion for working with others in our partnerships and those that we team with. [0:44:41] Because I learned that we're one of the very few cities that has that relationship. [0:44:45] And most of the other cities, when it even considered this request, and so it made me very proud to represent our city and [0:44:54] a chance to talk about partnerships and common goals and hopefully gave some of the other [0:45:00] cities things to think about. [0:45:02] Thank you, Suzanne. [0:45:04] Greg Land. [0:45:05] Sorry. [0:45:06] I'm sorry. [0:45:07] I just wanted to add that the school district is very appreciative of the city and the partnership [0:45:13] that we have. [0:45:14] We always seem to work really well together in projects and I think it benefits us mutually. [0:45:20] Thank you very much. [0:45:21] I agree. [0:45:22] Thank you. [0:45:23] Greg Land. [0:45:24] I'm not going to defend the other cities, but obviously our situation is slightly different [0:45:29] in the fact that we, our school district, is outside the boundaries of the city of Twin [0:45:34] Falls, but really not very far, whereas other places, like, I'll just give an example, like [0:45:39] we, or filers, cast forth some of those, most of it's farmland outside the city, and so it [0:45:43] may not be quite the same feeling, but I echo what Brady said and what Suzanne said, I'm glad [0:45:50] for our cooperation between the city [0:45:53] and the school districts that's been that way [0:45:54] for a really long time. [0:45:56] And I can't imagine the other cities [0:45:59] not getting along like we do with our school district, [0:46:02] but I know other cities do struggle. [0:46:04] And I'm not sure who's called it is, [0:46:05] I'm not placing blame, I just know it occurs. [0:46:09] Thank you. [0:46:09] Any other discussion from the council? [0:46:12] Seeing none, Sharon, we'll call vote, please. [0:46:15] Nikki Boyd. [0:46:16] Yes. [0:46:16] Sean Baraker. [0:46:17] Yes. [0:46:18] Chris Stockington. [0:46:19] Yes. [0:46:20] Planting, Don Hall, Ruth Pierce, Suzanne Hopkins. [0:46:25] Yes. [0:46:26] Motion passes, seven to zero. [0:46:28] Thank you, Brady. [0:46:31] Next on the agenda is consideration of a request [0:46:33] to approve the purchase of real property located [0:46:36] at the northeast corner of Addison Avenue West [0:46:38] and Monroe Street. [0:46:40] We have our Public Works Director, John Keaton. [0:46:43] Welcome, John. [0:46:45] Thank you, Mayor and Council. [0:46:59] We were recently approached by the property owner of 277 [0:47:05] and 285 Addison Avenue. [0:47:07] And that is, that's these two lots right here. [0:47:13] This is Monroe, and this is Addison [0:47:16] right across the street as Lincoln School. [0:47:19] And the property owner has been taking care of this property [0:47:25] for several years, take care of the weeds, that sort of thing. [0:47:29] And recently, this person's health [0:47:31] has degraded to the point where they need to either [0:47:34] sell their property or do something different. [0:47:36] So they've been actively trying to sell it. [0:47:38] The problem with this piece is you can see there's some utilities that cross this property. [0:47:45] This is lateral 42. [0:47:48] It's one of the largest laterals, if not the largest lateral in the city. [0:47:54] And it runs underneath, if you remember, it runs underneath the sidewalk along Addison West, [0:48:01] turns northwest and goes behind back lot lines. [0:48:11] Yeah, just real quick John, could you explain to the audience those that don't know what [0:48:16] a lateral is? [0:48:17] Oh. [0:48:22] It sounds really important. [0:48:24] Just say underground canal. [0:48:27] Thank you. [0:48:28] Thank you. [0:48:29] It's just an underground canal and it provides irrigation to the, from Twin Falls Canal Company. [0:48:38] This map is a little bit harder to see, but right here is the intersection of Monroe and [0:48:42] Madison, again, lateral 42 comes from the east, moves west, goes back lot lines and crosses [0:48:50] here or goes to Washington and crosses in between Shoop and Haberne. [0:48:56] The city has maintenance responsibilities for laterals anytime they cross underneath roadways. [0:49:03] Also every now and then there's a maintenance agreement on particular segments of irrigation. [0:49:10] This particular one has a maintenance agreement along its length and back lot lines that we [0:49:18] have. [0:49:19] So from the Twin Falls Canal Company, we have the maintenance on this facility. [0:49:28] So that is this here and we also have a sewer line here. [0:49:33] Obviously when you look at this lot, corner lots have setbacks on both sides, front setbacks [0:49:40] that are significant, 20 feet I believe in this. [0:49:43] feet here. So it really limits what you can do this with this property plus you [0:49:47] can't put a footing on top of a utility like that and you wouldn't want to even [0:49:50] if you could. So the property has arguably little value to many people and [0:49:58] arguably reasonable value to the city of Twin Falls for a couple of reasons. [0:50:04] First of all that underground, matter of all, it is large and difficult to [0:50:09] maintained, so this would provide us a great location to get in safely and reconstruct that [0:50:15] in the off-season when it's not flowing. The other opportunity is a long time from now, [0:50:25] when it makes sense to potentially retrofit irrigation in downtown, it's very costly. [0:50:33] Right now it does not financially make sense. But as you know, when there's an opportunity [0:50:38] to buy a piece of property that could potentially be a part of that. [0:50:45] So what I've done here is taken a page out of our water facility plan and this shows options [0:50:53] to retrofit PI. [0:50:54] So as you know in the old parts of town that use potable water it would be a real opportunity [0:51:00] for us to retrofit with PI and use irrigation water. [0:51:03] So this law is about right here in this, what we're calling, phase three of a PI retrofit, [0:51:12] and it's a great location for a lot of reasons. [0:51:16] It's on the high ground. [0:51:18] It also has the lateral that we could deliver shares to. [0:51:22] So engineering wise, it makes a lot of sense. [0:51:25] Cost wise, it makes no sense at this point. [0:51:27] But someday, the value of water will be there and it'll make sense. [0:51:31] So for those two reasons, I'm recommending that we go ahead and purchase the property. [0:51:36] The tax assessment in the staff report, the tax, it's difficult to determine a value because [0:51:44] of the situation here. [0:51:45] The tax assessment value is $59,000 for those two laws. [0:51:50] The property, the seller is asking for a purchase of $20,000 for both laws. [0:51:56] Thank you, John. [0:51:59] Chris Tockington. [0:52:01] John and Travis, I really like to push the envelope of comfort on this and say, why are [0:52:08] we going to wait for some indefinite time to start utilizing, expanding that lateral [0:52:16] to take our dependence off of water by making the PI? [0:52:21] Is there not some long lead planning item that we can still incorporate into this coming [0:52:27] years budget. We always have capital money available, some former fashion. I don't want [0:52:33] to sit here, three and a half years when I go off the council and be talking about someday. [0:52:39] The more dependence off of our potable water, the quicker the better. [0:52:44] As in that I'll vote for it. [0:52:46] So I think that what John's trying to do is to make sure that the situations are right. [0:52:51] So when that opportunity presents itself, we are not landlocked without the land to be [0:52:56] be able to be there. And while there might be a source of water to be able to get into [0:53:02] that area, we still have to go out and make sure that the water rights are able to be spread [0:53:06] across those properties so you look at acquisition of water rights. And then after that, you need [0:53:11] an entire distribution system that isn't available in that area right now. And our water facility [0:53:17] plan estimated that it would cost about $19 million to transform that area from a potable [0:53:24] water to a pressurized irrigation system, not to mention potential impacts and costs [0:53:30] to the individual homeowners then to take that water and to be able to apply it to the properties. [0:53:35] That $19 million is our cost. [0:53:39] When we start looking at spending $19 million from a cost benefit analysis, we believe that [0:53:45] the $19 million is best served by taking a look at Sunnybrook Springs, by taking a look [0:53:50] an additional storage by taking a look at land that we could buy that have a more immediate [0:53:57] direct impact and value for that dollar. [0:54:01] Just to add to that, if I could buy. [0:54:03] If I could just follow up as one piece, then it has to be a complete $19 million project [0:54:09] that cannot be a phased introduction of this that would be $5 million or something of that [0:54:14] nature. [0:54:15] It's all or nothing in other words. [0:54:17] Well, if I can just answer the whole area, [0:54:21] if we retrofit the entire area, it costs that much. [0:54:25] And what we would get is 1.5 million gallons per day [0:54:29] at peak use in savings, which is something. [0:54:34] But we can, right now, for a couple million, [0:54:37] if we can find water out south, and we do have a well [0:54:40] that we have developed here recently, [0:54:42] we can potentially, the cost per million of gallons [0:54:45] that you can either conserve or find is factors away in cost. [0:54:52] But really, Councilman, go ahead, Josh. [0:54:57] Well, so the challenge that we have is, I mean, [0:54:59] to put the 19 million or 5 million [0:55:01] or even a million dollars in perspective, [0:55:03] the entire water fund budget [0:55:06] for the upcoming fiscal year 17 year [0:55:09] that we're currently working on [0:55:10] will present to the Council the first week in July. [0:55:12] That entire budget is estimated [0:55:15] to be right around the $10 million mark. [0:55:18] And that $10 million mark, probably 40% of it is associated with debt and debt service. [0:55:26] And then you have another large portion of it that is going to be associated with personnel to make sure that the system's running. [0:55:34] Spending, we have historically been able to take and [0:55:40] Save monies from revenues that are not expended in any given year and collect them over a period of time and then apply them to long-term projects to be able to help offset without having to go out to a debt measure. [0:55:53] The Wills Booster Station is one of those projects that we've been able to save money over a couple of years and then apply that to a long-term capital project. [0:56:02] The same is true here, but then it comes to a matter of priorities. [0:56:06] Is it more important to get 1.5 million gallons off of potable water during peak, or does [0:56:12] it become more advantageous for us to buy land and be able to have a 10 million gallon [0:56:19] storage facility located in an area that could be of a more direct and beneficial use today? [0:56:25] And so what John wrestles with is what does that look like, recognizing that we couldn't [0:56:30] Just collect $5 million in a single fiscal year [0:56:33] without devastating the rate payer. [0:56:36] And then you start looking at having a long-term [0:56:39] debt instrument if you don't have those cash reserves [0:56:42] available, and so we'll continue to look at these things. [0:56:45] I think the value of the water facility plan [0:56:47] is it does provide that road map, [0:56:50] but it provides the road map in terms of greatest return [0:56:53] for our dollars today, and it kind of keeps those opportunities [0:56:57] out there in the future for us to have awareness of. [0:57:00] So when land comes available, John is in a position to move forward. [0:57:04] John, just out of curiosity, because I know that some parts of that town, of our town in [0:57:14] that area, maybe not down that far west, has surface irrigation canal water off of these [0:57:23] underground canals. [0:57:25] And is that, does that play in that area at all? [0:57:29] Are there a lot of those in that area? [0:57:31] Does this lateral play into that game at all? [0:57:35] It does a little bit. [0:57:36] You know, is there a lot? [0:57:37] I couldn't tell you how many are actually being used, [0:57:40] because a lot of the ditches don't get maintained. [0:57:43] It's just difficult for some people [0:57:45] to get their neighbors to take care of ditches, [0:57:47] and obviously you can't get it delivered. [0:57:48] But yes, that is a part of it, and we [0:57:50] would have to get those shares transferred [0:57:53] and into a P.I. station and back out. [0:57:56] Travis was talking about the water rights. [0:57:59] Again, it's kind of a side note, but I [0:58:02] would just encourage us if we can utilize the already system that we have in place that [0:58:08] can take us further away from potable water because that's part of town that's used surface [0:58:14] water from the canals since they built the neighborhood. So I just think if there's anything we can [0:58:21] do to encourage that or help, I'd like to see us do it. [0:58:26] Greg Lanting. [0:58:27] I wish we hadn't let Brady get out of the room before we ask him. Do we know whether the [0:58:31] The school just like Lincoln is right there. [0:58:34] Do we know whether they're on potable [0:58:35] or whether they're on PI because that would be an out. [0:58:37] If they're on PI, they're potable. [0:58:39] That would be an easy one to convert [0:58:41] because it's right there. [0:58:43] And this lot could help us do that. [0:58:46] Yeah, that's a good question. [0:58:47] Yeah. [0:58:48] So they have large area and football, big football field. [0:58:52] We're checking in. [0:58:52] Okay. [0:58:54] They're on potable water. [0:58:55] So that's something we might be using that lot quicker [0:58:58] just to take care of that. [0:59:00] And that might gain us, [0:59:01] I don't know, it wouldn't gain us one a million gallons, [0:59:03] but it gains something. [0:59:04] So, all right, thank you. [0:59:08] Yeah, there are comments. [0:59:09] Suzanne Hawkins. [0:59:10] Are you ready for a motion? [0:59:11] I am ready for a motion. [0:59:12] Okay, I would move the approval of the request [0:59:16] to purchase real property located at the northeast corner [0:59:19] of Addison Avenue West and Monroe Street for $20,000. [0:59:24] I'll second that. [0:59:26] The motion by Suzanne Hawkins seconded by Ruth Pierce [0:59:28] to approve the request to purchase the property up to $20,000. [0:59:35] Any further discussion from the council? [0:59:38] Seeing none, Chair and roll call vote please. [0:59:43] Sean Berriger, Chris Tockington, Greg Lanting, Don Hall, Ruth Pierce, Suzanne Hawkins, [0:59:52] Nikki Boyd, yes. [0:59:54] Motion passes 7-2-0. [0:59:59] Next is consideration of a request to use contingency funds [1:00:03] to make necessary improvements to the city pool [1:00:05] to meet current ADA requirements [1:00:07] and we have our Parks and Recreation Director, [1:00:10] Wendy Davis. [1:00:11] Welcome, Wendy. [1:00:12] Thank you, good evening, Mayor and Council. [1:00:14] I'm here this evening to ask you to consider a request [1:00:18] to approve the use of contingency funds [1:00:21] to make the necessary improvements [1:00:23] to the city pool to meet the current ADA standards. [1:00:27] This pool was built in 1989. [1:00:30] And the ADA requirements have changed over the years. [1:00:34] And the most recent changes did not [1:00:37] grandfather in older facilities. [1:00:40] And so some of those updates need to be made, [1:00:44] such as fixing the locker rooms, lowering the front counter [1:00:49] so that it's wheelchair accessible, [1:00:51] changing the size of a couple of bathroom stalls, [1:00:54] lowering urinals, and some of those kinds of things. [1:00:56] I added a list or attached a list of the improvements that need to be made. [1:01:03] The estimated total cost of the project is about $32,350, but I guess I would just caution [1:01:10] that that's based on estimates talking to people that do these kinds of things, but they're [1:01:17] all just currently an estimate of about what they think it would cost. [1:01:21] So, I didn't really build a cushion in for myself with this. [1:01:26] I just gave you the flat out numbers of what I'm seeing. [1:01:29] But I guess I'm thinking that maybe if you'll consider approving the request, [1:01:34] we either do it not to exceed or give me a little cushion on that in case [1:01:39] something comes in a little higher than they anticipated. [1:01:41] So, that's basically the request. [1:01:44] Does anybody have any questions? [1:01:47] What is a little cushion with thirty-two thousand I don't think a very big I I guess I don't know I was thinking [1:01:54] What would be a reasonable cushion? [1:01:57] 35 35 hundred oh 35 thousand all together [1:02:01] Okay [1:02:02] Probably probably cover it [1:02:03] Suzanne Hawkins when did you know what we do have an our contingency fund now for this? [1:02:12] No, sorry [1:02:13] I should have asked earlier no so so this would come out of the capital contingency fund [1:02:18] And so we have the capital associated with that and that has not been significantly drawn down this year. [1:02:26] Very few projects have been attached to it at the beginning of the year. [1:02:29] We started with about $150,000 in the continued treatment. [1:02:34] Thank you. [1:02:35] Don't know. [1:02:36] Are you ready for a motion? [1:02:37] Sure. [1:02:38] I would move that we approve up to $35,000, not to exceed $35,000 for [1:02:45] the ADA requirements that you have outlined in the report. [1:02:48] Great landing. [1:02:49] Second. [1:02:51] The motion by Don Hall, seconded by Greg Lanting, [1:02:54] to approve the request not to exceed $35,000 [1:02:58] for the necessary improvements. [1:03:00] Is there any discussion? [1:03:03] Greg Lanting. [1:03:04] Well, obviously, those are one of those ones [1:03:06] where we like to throw around up. [1:03:08] I'm trying to mandate something like that stuff, [1:03:10] but if you look down to the list, [1:03:12] many of them are needed improvements anyway. [1:03:16] And so, where I don't see myself voting, [1:03:19] no one's something that might be in the closing of the tool, [1:03:22] so I think I will be voting in the affirmative. [1:03:26] Thank you, any further discussion? [1:03:27] Good thing. [1:03:29] Seeing none, Chair-in-all, call vote, please. [1:03:33] Chris Stockington? [1:03:34] Yes. [1:03:35] Greg Lanting? [1:03:36] Yes. [1:03:37] Don Hall? [1:03:37] Yes. [1:03:38] Ruth Pierce? [1:03:39] Yes. [1:03:39] Suzanne Hawkins? [1:03:40] Yes. [1:03:41] Nikki Boyd? [1:03:42] Yes. [1:03:42] Sean Berricker? [1:03:43] Yes. [1:03:44] Motion passes 7-2-0. [1:03:47] Thank you. [1:03:48] Thank you, Wendy. [1:03:52] Next is consideration of a request to enact a new chapter 13 [1:03:56] of Title VI of the Twin Falls City Code, [1:03:58] prohibiting graffiti, requiring removal and abatement, [1:04:01] and providing for a penalty for violation of this code. [1:04:05] Chief Kingsbury, welcome back. [1:04:07] Thank you, Mayor, Council. [1:04:09] Thanks for having me here this evening. [1:04:11] And if you remember, a few weeks ago, [1:04:12] we first brought this code before you as a Council [1:04:18] to review and discuss in that your direction, [1:04:22] working with our wonderful legal counsel, Fred's Wonderlake, [1:04:26] we went back and made some changes to the code. [1:04:29] And I think it's important to add for our community [1:04:33] that the purpose of enacting this code [1:04:36] is not to make graffiti illegal. [1:04:37] I mean, it already is under state statute with vandalism. [1:04:41] However, the purpose, [1:04:44] why I am asking you to enact this code [1:04:46] is to allow us as a city to have some better tools for tracking said vandalism, especially [1:04:53] when it is gang related type vandalism. I would point out that today if you are a fan of the [1:04:59] Twin Falls Police Department Facebook page or follow us on Twitter, two great follows. [1:05:04] You will have seen that we posted a photograph of some graffiti that was done to the Disabled [1:05:11] American Veterans Hall that was reported this morning and it was gang graffiti that was placed [1:05:16] on that building. Obviously, the men and women of TFPD are aware of it. We're working with [1:05:23] the community to try to find the perpetrators as well as to work with whoever we need to [1:05:30] work with to make sure that it gets cleaned up. But I think the timing on that is appropriate [1:05:35] as we discuss this ordinance tonight. Just as an example to let you know that we do have gang [1:05:41] graffiti that takes place in our city. So again, by asking for this ordinance, I am asking [1:05:47] council to look at this and give us as a city, both the police department code enforcement [1:05:53] and even use the council the tools to help us keep our city clean of this graffiti. I said [1:06:00] it before and I'll say it again and that it is not my intention as the chief of police [1:06:05] to dictate mandate or order members of our community, [1:06:11] especially those that are led to low the poverty line, [1:06:15] to have to pay a large amount of money [1:06:17] to clean up their property, [1:06:19] but rather to work with them, so that we as a city, [1:06:22] we as our police department and our code enforcement folks [1:06:25] and our great citizens out there can work with them [1:06:27] to get this cleaned up. [1:06:29] So we get it documented quickly and cleaned up. [1:06:31] So the changes were made as you asked, [1:06:35] We can certainly discuss those. [1:06:36] I think you'll find a field process in there [1:06:39] that makes you as a city council, [1:06:42] the Peleb Board, if you will. [1:06:44] And I think it spells out very clearly [1:06:47] what our intention is. [1:06:49] I would stand for questions. [1:06:51] Thank you, Chief Dunhill. [1:06:52] I don't have a question for you, Chief. [1:06:53] I just want to say that I like the changes, [1:06:56] and we both knew what your intentions were before, [1:06:59] but again, in 10, 20 years when you and I are here, [1:07:03] we want to make sure those following us [1:07:05] know what our intentions were and I like the line about you or your designee will enlist [1:07:13] partners to help folks take care of these kind of issues because there are going to be [1:07:19] some folks that are living under the poverty level and they need some assistance and this [1:07:23] spells it out well and I appreciate you taking it back and meeting with Fritz and making [1:07:29] those changes. [1:07:30] I think there's some improvements to this ordinance to make us all happier than the first run around. [1:07:38] I especially am enamored with the use of juvies from all the detention center that when they [1:07:44] get out doing public pick up or improvement projects and the eye of the public is on a [1:07:50] met has more of a shame factor and getting religion factor than about anything you can [1:07:55] do behind a closed door. [1:07:58] So I hope that we can use juveniles that need to work off some energy, whether they've been [1:08:05] directly related to that graffiti or not. [1:08:08] The word will spread real quickly. [1:08:10] So, well, and councilman, we're talking to that. [1:08:13] I am meeting tomorrow afternoon with the director of the Juvenile Detention Center. [1:08:17] So it'll be the first time I'll be meeting with him, but it won't be one of the things [1:08:21] I'll be discussing. [1:08:22] Great. [1:08:23] Nicky Boyd. [1:08:24] What I like about it is it shows pride in our community and it shows that we're paying attention up front and this is something that is near and dear to our heart and we're not going to let our town get jumped up and I think it's fantastic. Thank you. [1:08:39] Greg Lanten. [1:08:42] Again, on a timing issue, I think all of us were certainly [1:08:46] appalled about the Veterans Hall and the Civil Veterans Hall. [1:08:50] And then I happened to be on a walk last night. [1:08:54] And somebody who didn't care for Mr. Trump had written on a fence, [1:08:59] that particular thing. [1:09:00] And I thought, I'm wondering whether that's coming back to us tonight. [1:09:05] So we can get moving on this and we can help that community, [1:09:08] that person that have sent a D as well as Mr. Trump's name off their fence. [1:09:15] I'm sure that behind their property they might not even notice it because it's on a different, [1:09:19] not just on Harris in there. [1:09:21] So, but obviously we will be in touch with them to help them get it off there. [1:09:26] And Councilman Lanting, if you would shoot me an email or a text with the information [1:09:30] of where that's located, I'll make sure that we're aware of it to police department. [1:09:33] We'll do. [1:09:34] Thank you. [1:10:11] by his ordinance 2016-6 on third and final reading [1:10:15] by title only. [1:10:17] Any discussion? [1:10:20] Seeing none, roll call vote please. [1:10:22] Greg Lanting. [1:10:23] Yes. [1:10:24] Don Hall. [1:10:25] Yes. [1:10:26] Ruth Pierce. [1:10:27] Yes. [1:10:27] Suzanne Hawkins. [1:10:28] Yes. [1:10:29] Nicky Boyd. [1:10:30] Yes. [1:10:31] Sean Beriker. [1:10:32] Yes. [1:10:32] Chris talking. [1:10:33] Yes. [1:10:34] Motion passes seven to zero. [1:10:36] Sharon, would you read the title please? [1:10:43] Ordinance number 2016-6, an ordinance of the City Council of the City of Twin Falls, Idaho in acting a new chapter 13 of Title 6 of the Twin Falls City Code, [1:10:57] prohibiting graffiti, requiring removal, and abatement and providing for our penalty for violation of this code. [1:11:06] It ordained by the Mayor and the Council of the City of Twin Falls, Idaho that the Twin [1:11:11] Falls City Code is amended by the addition of a new Chapter 13 of Title 6 as follows. [1:11:20] Thank you, Sharon. [1:11:21] Don Hall. [1:11:22] I would move approval of Ordinance 2016-6. [1:11:27] Thank you, boy. [1:11:29] I'm sorry. [1:11:30] I'm sorry. [1:11:31] Motion by Don Hall, seconded by Nikki Lloyd [1:11:34] to approve ordinance 2016-6. [1:11:37] Is there any discussion? [1:11:40] Seeing none, roll call vote please. [1:11:43] Don Hall? [1:11:43] Yes. [1:11:44] Ruth Pierce? [1:11:45] Yes. [1:11:46] Suzanne Hawkins? [1:11:47] Yes. [1:11:48] Nikki Boyd? [1:11:49] Yes. [1:11:50] Sean Beriker? [1:11:50] Yes. [1:11:51] Chris Tockkin? [1:11:52] Yes. [1:11:53] Greg Lanting? [1:11:55] Yes. [1:11:56] passes 7-0. [1:11:57] Chief, thank you for your work on that, [1:11:58] and bringing you back to us. [1:12:03] The next item on the agenda is a presentation [1:12:04] the Council on the results of the 2016 National Citizen Survey, our presentation from Mandy [1:12:11] Thompson and Travis Rothweiler. Welcome, Mandy. Thank you, Mayor, Councillor. Sharon, can [1:12:19] you turn on the projector? Beautiful screens. Bear with us for a moment as we get the presentation [1:13:51] set up in case you're tuning in online and wondering what we're up to. I'm going to go [1:15:05] ahead and recess for five minutes. Take a little break while you all get that set up. So we will [1:15:11] come back in about 22 minutes after. Mr. Rothweiler. [1:15:18] Thank you, Mr. Mayor, members of the council. Just really quickly before I turn the mic [1:15:23] from back over to Mandy to begin the National Citizen Survey presentation. We had a slight air [1:15:32] on the agenda, we wanted to point that out. [1:15:36] The motion was made on item number three, and it is a staff air where it says, consider [1:15:41] the request to approve the purchase of real property located at the northeast corner. [1:15:46] It should have reflected into the northwest corner, and that was aptly pointed out by members [1:15:50] of the audience this evening. [1:15:54] And so there is no need to change the motion that was made because the intent is reflected [1:16:00] by a lot in block later in the application packet. [1:16:03] But for the record, and we'll make the correction [1:16:06] in the meeting minutes to the motion [1:16:07] with the council's concurrent, [1:16:10] that it should have actually reflected the northwest property [1:16:14] as opposed to the northeast property. [1:16:17] The northeast property has never approached us [1:16:19] nor they're probably interested in the property [1:16:21] for $20,000. [1:16:23] If they're watching. [1:16:24] And you know how great it is having that mistake come [1:16:27] from the engineering department, [1:16:28] We're going to give them a compass for education. [1:16:34] Thank you. [1:16:34] We were sharing that with John. [1:16:38] Thank you, Travis. [1:16:41] Welcome again, Mandy. [1:16:43] Good evening. [1:16:43] OK. [1:16:44] I think we're ready to proceed. [1:16:45] I apologize for that brief delay. [1:16:49] I'm pleased to be before you this evening [1:16:52] to present the results of the 2016 National Citizen Survey. [1:16:56] We have been on and off the agenda several times [1:16:58] over the last few months. [1:16:59] So, I had a lot of assistance in putting together and combing through the results of the survey [1:17:05] from our intern in the City Manager's Office, Jake Lassinsky. [1:17:09] And we, I told them at one point, I hoped that we would have the opportunity to present [1:17:13] before his internship was over, so we made it. [1:17:18] A little bit of background on the National Citizen Survey. [1:17:21] This is a survey that we have participated in now for the fourth year. [1:17:26] We do it every two years. [1:17:28] So we actually did the first one in 2009 and then we started on a every two-year platform [1:17:33] in 2012, 2014 and now again in 2016. [1:17:37] So that is what, some background on what, how often we do it. [1:17:45] The first question I wanted to, or the first item I want to speak with you about is just [1:17:49] exactly what does a National Citizen Survey identify. [1:17:53] The National Citizen Survey captures residents' opinions of their community across eight central [1:17:57] facets we look at or the survey looks at safety, mobility, the natural environment, the built [1:18:03] environment, the economy, recreation and wellness, education and enrichment and community engagement. [1:18:11] And what it delivers to the cities that participate in the survey is a report about the livability [1:18:16] of the community in which citizens are taking the survey. [1:18:21] who received the survey, a survey, random sampling through statistical selection was mailed to [1:18:27] 1,400 households this year, and we had 405 respondents that is about in line with the national [1:18:36] average of anywhere between 27 and 30 percent respondents from the initial mailing. And the [1:18:44] data was weighed in order to reflect the city population. And then the question of how we [1:18:49] use this information. Essentially what we do with this information is we use it to compare [1:18:53] similar, we compare it with similar surveys that were conducted in prior years so that we [1:18:58] can have a benchmark not only of where we've been but where we've come from the past and [1:19:04] how we've improved the delivery of particular services to our citizens and how the community [1:19:09] as a whole is growing and if there are areas in which the citizens do deem that we may be [1:19:14] have fallen short, and then that gives us an opportunity to address those areas as well. [1:19:24] One of the larger questions is asked in the Citizen Survey is about the quality of life, [1:19:30] excuse me, the quality of life in Twin Falls, and I'm pleased to report that most residents [1:19:36] rated the quality of life in Twin Falls as either excellent or good. [1:19:40] Respondents were able to determine that the safety, or determined through the questions [1:19:44] they answered that safety, the economy, and education are the most important factors moving [1:19:49] forward in our community. [1:19:54] Our citizens rated the quality of life in Twin Falls overwhelmingly as either excellent, 20 [1:20:00] percent, or good at 50 percent. [1:20:02] I find that to be very encouraging and I think it's absolutely showing the community and the [1:20:07] council that we're moving in the right direction, that over 70 percent of those responding felt [1:20:13] that we are moving in the right direction [1:20:15] and that we have a very high quality of life. [1:20:20] Additionally, 54% of the respondents [1:20:23] rated Twin Falls as a good place to live [1:20:25] and 26 rated as an excellent place to live. [1:20:30] Some of the other factors that played [1:20:34] into this overall question of a place to live [1:20:37] was that 73% of the respondents cited Twin Falls [1:20:42] as either good or excellent place to raise their children. [1:20:46] 65% said it was a good place to retire. [1:20:49] And 64% said that overall that we had a good quality image [1:20:55] in their minds. [1:20:56] So it's a very similar comparison to the national survey [1:21:02] and the comparisons that they do to other communities [1:21:04] of our size. [1:21:06] But it's also a slight increase over the last time [1:21:08] that we took this survey in 2014. [1:21:12] you have the comparatives? I do, and I can, I will make all of the, there was probably [1:21:20] about 65 to 70 pages worth of information, and so I'll have all of that, I will make [1:21:26] all of that available to you after tonight's meeting. I just thought I'd give you a little [1:21:29] bit of the highlights. So one area that we grew in our effectiveness is public safety. 68% [1:21:39] of the respondents positively rated that the city had an overall feeling of safety. [1:21:45] And furthermore, 93% of respondents said that they felt safe in their neighborhoods during [1:21:49] the day. [1:21:50] And that 87% also rated safety at the places they shop and do business as favorable. [1:21:57] So favorable being good to excellent. [1:22:00] So overall, the feeling of safety in the community of Twin Falls is continuing to grow. [1:22:07] And I wanted to share with you that overall the rating of our police department increased [1:22:21] this year. [1:22:22] In 2014 it was at 69% and again 69% is either good or excellent. [1:22:27] And in this year, the 2016 survey was up to 75%. [1:22:30] So we have a very positive response to not only our police department but also we have [1:22:36] a 91% approval rating for the fire department. [1:22:40] And 56% of the respondents felt that crime prevention was either good or excellent, which [1:22:45] is also up. [1:22:47] And another category where we grew significantly was animal control, which I know at some points [1:22:52] have had some, there have been some citizens with some concerns about how animal control [1:22:56] has been handled by the police department. [1:22:58] And so that's excellent news to know that those citizens' concerns are being addressed. [1:23:06] This table is just kind of giving you an idea of where our population is growing compared [1:23:13] to the criminal offenses in the community and just to let you know that I guess it's just [1:23:18] a way of showing on the left-hand side you're going to see the population and on the right-hand [1:23:22] side you will see criminal offenses. [1:23:25] This is not actually from the National Citizen Survey but this is just a visual representation [1:23:31] that while we do have some increase, we do see an increase in crime in Twin Falls, it's [1:23:36] also something that we have been telling you for a long time is a direct reflection or has [1:23:42] a direct correlation with the increase in population, but that it's not in line with [1:23:49] where the crime had been earlier in the decade. So that's just an anecdotal information for [1:23:55] all of you there. Another area where we saw an increase in the positive responses from the [1:24:05] citizens that took the surveys in the natural environment. 69% of our respondents rated the [1:24:10] of cleanliness and natural environment in our community [1:24:12] favorably, that it was 80% rated to one falls [1:24:17] as a favorable place to live. [1:24:19] And again, going specifically to the natural environment, [1:24:23] drinking water received a 58% approval rating. [1:24:26] Other areas that showed an increase were open spaces [1:24:36] and natural area preservation, which I think [1:24:39] and also be a direct reflection of the work that we've done, [1:24:46] the community has done towards the acquisition of areas [1:24:50] such as Auger Falls and our continued efforts [1:24:53] to connect the trail system. [1:24:57] Some other areas where we've improved since the 2014 survey [1:25:01] are the overall direction of the city that increased to 61%. [1:25:06] The value of services for tax is paid, 48% of the respondents rated that as good or excellent. [1:25:14] Confidence in city government increased. [1:25:17] Customer service and this is directly linked to customer service by city employees and city staff. [1:25:24] Economic development and the growth of the economy in Twin Falls increased to 65%. [1:25:31] And the belief that the city is acting in the best interests of Twin Falls also increased, and that increased to 65%. [1:25:38] That absolutely is a, I believe, a reflection of the hard work that not only city staff puts into their jobs at the city, but also the council. [1:25:52] And also the partnerships that we've created throughout the community. [1:25:56] the overall livability report and the quality of life that was reported in this final report [1:26:02] certainly supports the statement that Twin Falls is some place where our citizens are [1:26:11] proud to be proud to live and that they have pride in their community and that they want [1:26:16] to continue to see us going in that direction. [1:26:20] That this next area though is for there are obviously it's not always a glowing report [1:26:25] and there are always going to be some areas for improvement. [1:26:28] There were several areas that we saw declines, [1:26:32] some of them a little bit more so than others. [1:26:36] A couple of things, we don't always know [1:26:41] why citizens answer the questions they answer [1:26:44] and how they answer them. [1:26:46] We've had some questions as to when the surveys are conducted. [1:26:50] Typically the mailings go out in early January, [1:26:54] and the postcard, because the assistant gets the postcard [1:26:57] letting the know that a survey is on its way. [1:26:59] They received the survey early February, [1:27:02] and they had this year until mid-March [1:27:04] to complete those surveys. [1:27:06] We tried to send them out around the same time every year. [1:27:09] Sometimes that's varied slightly over the years. [1:27:11] But there are certainly some opportunities [1:27:15] for maybe the natural environmental factors [1:27:17] to affect the, maybe the responses of the citizens. [1:27:21] but without a lot of information to understand [1:27:26] why they answered the questions, [1:27:27] it's a little hard to make those links. [1:27:33] So I'm gonna have Travis come up here [1:27:34] and he's going to discuss some of the areas of improvement. [1:27:40] Thank you, Mandy. [1:27:45] So, Mr. Mayor, members of the council, [1:27:46] these are, I think Mandy and Jake did a really good job [1:27:51] kind of talking about the high points [1:27:53] and some of the successes that we had. [1:27:54] And I want to reiterate some of those, because one of the things that's important when you [1:27:59] take a look at the survey is the growth over time, because one of the things that you want [1:28:04] to make sure is that the actions that we're taking are sustainable courses of action, and [1:28:09] we continue to make ground to realize the level of service that the citizens are looking [1:28:15] for. [1:28:16] So, for example, when you take a look at the overall direction that the city is heading, [1:28:21] In 2009, we received 44% was either good to excellent. [1:28:26] And over the course of the last several years, [1:28:29] we've seen increases, and as Mandy shared, [1:28:31] it is now at 61% good to excellent. [1:28:33] So you can see that that is moving forward. [1:28:36] For the values of tax-paying dollars that it received, [1:28:40] it's kind of, it has moved 8% points from 40% to 48% [1:28:46] from good to excellent just in that past year. [1:28:49] And so what we want to do is we want to understand why is that occurring so we can continue to [1:28:54] move forward and we look towards that strategic plan. [1:28:58] Well just not only do we look at the successes but we also want to take a look at those areas [1:29:03] where we fell a little short. [1:29:05] And these are some of those key areas that we fell a little short. [1:29:08] One of the most frustrating things about a survey is it doesn't say why. [1:29:14] doesn't tell you why street repair has fallen each and every year since 2009, when the city [1:29:24] of Twin Falls has invested more money than it ever has in the area of street and road construction. [1:29:31] It doesn't talk about how travel by bicycle has fallen yet last year you'll recall we [1:29:37] took a major street initiative to create share rows to create more bike lanes to go forward [1:29:43] and revisit our city code. [1:29:45] And public transportation has been one of those hot button issues [1:29:48] that we've had conversations about. [1:29:52] It makes sense that we saw an increase in water [1:29:55] because we no longer are required by the EPA to put a note [1:29:58] in the water bill every quarter saying your water does not meet [1:30:02] the standards of the Clean Water Act as a result of our standards. [1:30:06] And so when you tell somebody something long enough, [1:30:09] it's going to take some time to watch that trend [1:30:11] and we're starting to see that move forward. [1:30:14] Parks, recreation, recreation centers, recreation programs, solid waste, and recycling, those [1:30:22] were some pretty key button issues as well as whether or not the City of Twin Falls [1:30:27] is open and accepting to individuals of different cultures and whether or not we're open to Spanish [1:30:33] speaking residents. Those were areas that we fell from 2014 to 2012. And while we might [1:30:42] I'll take a moment to say, well, I think it's this because of where we're at in street repair. [1:30:50] One of the things that my office is going to do, and I've asked Mitch to oversee this [1:30:55] process, is that we are going to have some intentional, citizen-driven focus groups to [1:31:00] have a conversation as a part of the strategic plan to understand why are we not meeting [1:31:06] your standards in streets in bicycle, in public transportation. [1:31:11] What can we be doing better in the areas of parks and recreation? [1:31:15] Because I do not believe that this is a reflection by the effort of the men and women in the department. [1:31:22] If you spend time with the men and women in public works and the street teams, [1:31:27] they work really, really hard and they take great pride in the work that they do. [1:31:33] And it's our job to make sure at our level that we are providing [1:31:39] absolute best tools and direction that we can to ensure that they are successful not only [1:31:44] from strategic planning perspective but also in the eyes of the citizen that we serve. [1:31:50] So really the citizen survey gives us a starting point. [1:31:55] It gives us a starting point to ask why? [1:31:59] Why did we not meet your expectations? [1:32:02] And so we will be having a call to action in preparation of the strategic plan because [1:32:06] we want to take this information as we launch in September in the degree crafting of our [1:32:12] strategic plan to take this information but also to bring more answers to the table than [1:32:16] what we're able to present to you this evening. [1:32:20] If you're interested in helping on one of those, please let us know. [1:32:24] We think it's important to have complete engagement and one of those areas that we grew was that [1:32:29] area of public engagement and so we want to make sure that we're continuing to engage the [1:32:35] Now, it's a blind survey. [1:32:39] And so we will not be able to go out and ask those who submitted, well, why do you feel [1:32:46] that we've failed to meet your expectations? [1:32:48] This is going to be more of a general call to the citizens and we'll dig deep. [1:32:53] We'll understand why. [1:32:54] But again, we certainly want to emphasize the point that we do not look at this as a [1:32:59] reflection by the quality efforts of the men and women that work in these departments. [1:33:04] work very, very hard, we just might not, from a city manager's office level, be providing [1:33:13] the right direction to supply the right services to our citizens as they're requiring. [1:33:17] So this will allow us to connect better with our citizens, have a better understanding of [1:33:20] the programs they're looking for, and then continue to see improvements in these areas, [1:33:25] hopefully the 2018 survey. [1:33:30] With that, we'll stand for any questions. [1:33:32] All of the citizen surveys will be, I believe we have sent those to you previously so you [1:33:37] could take a look at them. [1:33:38] We will also be making them available online for the community to take a look at. [1:33:43] We would encourage the citizens to take a look at it. [1:33:45] We believe that this is one of the fundamental report cards that we have. [1:33:48] It will help drive budgeting decisions and this right up there with the audit is a reflection [1:33:53] of our overall efforts. [1:33:55] And so we would encourage our citizens to take a look at that. [1:33:58] And then if they have any thoughts that they would like to share specifically with us to [1:34:02] reach out, and certainly again we'll be making that call to action for citizens to participate. [1:34:09] Travis to those reports that will have access to, do they show that trends since the beginning [1:34:14] of the survey and that's all included in the reports? [1:34:17] Yep. [1:34:18] Thank you. [1:34:19] Any other questions or comments for Travis or Mandy? [1:34:24] Chris talking to. [1:34:25] just a general observation that I think, especially transportation, probably is an area of improvement [1:34:33] because of the growing nature of our community more vehicular traffic all the time or congestion. [1:34:41] I would not expect that to be an easy one to change and further I would expect with our [1:34:47] widespread downtown urban renewal going on. [1:34:50] We'll probably get hit in some way, former fashion. [1:34:55] So that's why it's important to look at these on a comparative basis over years rather than [1:35:01] in one standing year. [1:35:04] I think that I think Councilman talked to me really good points there just to really make [1:35:09] sure that over the length of the survey we want to make sure we're marking improvement [1:35:14] and ignoring those single blips because we don't know what those particular causes may be. [1:35:19] Nicky Boyd. [1:35:22] Would you remind me how the 14, we, we send out to 1400 people, are those, is that a different [1:35:31] group of people every year, or every survey, or how, how are they selected? [1:35:37] So the National Citizen Survey at the National Research Center, we work with them to provide [1:35:44] a basic map of the overall city of Twin Falls, and then they move forward, and they will [1:35:51] send out random surveys to individuals that are selected and it is a complete [1:35:58] random selection. So we are aware of some cases of people who might have had the [1:36:04] opportunity to fill out the survey a couple of different times. We're also [1:36:07] aware of people who have never had that opportunity and it's a complete random [1:36:11] selection. It's broke into quadrants of the city and so we break the [1:36:17] the city into three different areas, so that if there's one part of the community that says [1:36:22] something different when it comes to road repair or road maintenance, we want to understand [1:36:28] why does this section of our community feel differently? Maybe they feel the same way [1:36:33] about crime or neighborhoods or fire service or recreational amenities, what does that [1:36:38] look like? Is there a particular area geographically that's weighing the entire survey down so we [1:36:44] look at that. Then what they do is they get those responses and as Mandy was [1:36:49] sharing it is weighted in comparison to the census and what that means is it [1:36:55] will take the demographics of our census and it will either amplify or mute the [1:37:01] voices to generally reflect the overall sentiment of the community so we can [1:37:06] also share in some of the demographic profile the sentiments of the citizens [1:37:11] who have lived here for 20 years, and so we can kind of take a look at that in comparison [1:37:16] to the sentiments of the citizens who have lived here for three years. [1:37:20] How do parents with children feel about our recreation programs by comparison to MD-Nesters? [1:37:28] And what does that look like? [1:37:30] Because it really helps us begin to ask the right questions. [1:37:33] It may not provide any answers, but it helps us ask those questions. [1:37:37] That is all fed to us. [1:37:40] we get the reports, Mandy had the great pleasure this year of collecting all of the [1:37:47] undeliverables and then we're still getting them and so what we do is we take [1:37:52] those and we send them back and then they would do a second round of mailings and [1:37:56] a third round of mailings each and every time to make sure that we get to a place [1:38:00] where the survey is statistically valid and and that's what we have in front of [1:38:04] you is a statistically valid survey and so what we could say is we are [1:38:09] confident that the survey that was supplied and the results that were provided this evening [1:38:17] reflect the overall sentiment of the citizens of the city of Twin Falls at that point in time. [1:38:24] Again, anything can change. There could be a significant event that occurs that could [1:38:30] shatter or elevate one of those current standings that we have. [1:38:36] Any other questions for Travis or Mandy? I'll thank you both for the presentation and we [1:38:41] and we look forward to seeing the full detail of the survey. [1:38:48] Next on the agenda, we do have another opportunity [1:38:50] for public input. [1:38:51] If there's anyone here from the public [1:38:52] who would like to address the council on an issue, [1:38:55] please come forward, seeing no one. [1:39:03] Items from the city manager, Mr. Rothwehr. [1:39:06] Mr. Member, members of council, [1:39:07] just a quick couple of updates about upcoming meetings. [1:39:11] The first is on July 5th, [1:39:13] we will not be having a council meeting [1:39:14] as a result of a quorum and then the second meeting in July, [1:39:22] the 11th of July will be our regular scheduled meeting [1:39:25] and we will be presenting the city manager's recommended budget [1:39:28] to you will be making it available to the public after the presentation [1:39:33] and we hope to be able to get your copies the week of the 4th of July sometime in that week. [1:39:39] So you have a few days to take a look at that. [1:39:42] And the team is feverishly working on the final document as we speak, and we do have a [1:39:50] balanced budget that we believe is sustainable that we will be presenting on July 11th. [1:39:57] Thank you, Travis. [1:39:58] And then items from the Council, Greg Lanting. [1:40:00] Well, first off, I would like to let everybody know that I have a little more free time now [1:40:06] because I'm no longer president of the Association of Idaho Cities. [1:40:09] My term was up last Friday, but I would also like to extend congratulations even though I [1:40:15] I tried to warn her about it, but congratulations to Susanne Hawkins who was elected by her peers [1:40:21] from around the state to be the third vice president and thus will begin the process of [1:40:25] moving forward and in three years will be the president of the Association of Idaho Cities. [1:40:31] We will, Susanne will make the third president that we have had in recent years of the Association [1:40:37] of the Alliance. [1:40:38] of President Association. [1:40:41] Thank you, Rick. [1:40:48] Any other items from City Council? [1:40:52] Seeing none, we have a under adjournment. [1:40:57] Executive Session 74206C to acquire an interest in real property, [1:41:03] which is not owned by a public agency, [1:41:06] and I would entertain a motion from that Council on that. [1:41:10] Chris Stockington. [1:41:11] Executive Session per 74206C. [1:41:15] Second. [1:41:16] Motion by Chris Tockington, seconded by Nikki Boyd, [1:41:18] to adjourn into executive session. [1:41:23] Section 74206C. [1:41:26] Is there any discussion? [1:41:28] Seeing none. [1:41:29] Chair, and I'll call those please. [1:41:31] Ruth Pears? [1:41:32] Yes. [1:41:33] Suzanne Hawkins? [1:41:34] Yes. [1:41:35] Nikki Boyd? [1:41:35] Yes. [1:41:36] John Beriker? [1:41:37] Yes. [1:41:38] Chris Tockington? [1:41:39] Yes. [1:41:40] Greg Miantine? [1:41:41] Yes. [1:41:42] Don Hall? [1:41:43] Yes. [1:41:44] Passes 7-0. [1:41:45] I would remind those watching that we will not be making [1:41:48] decisions in the executive session and nor will we return to an open session [1:41:52] following it. So with that, meeting is adjourned.