Oversight Archive: City Council meeting, 2016-08-29, recording 1 (started 17:00) Machine transcript (faster-whisper base.en), not checked word for word; the Pledge of Allegiance is shown in its standard wording. The recording is the record. Times are time into the recording. Passages with private details are muted in the audio and marked here. The audio on the page below was re-encoded by software from the video the agency posted. Check any passage against that audio before relying on it. Page: https://oversightarchive.org/twin-falls-id/meetings/2016-08-29/ [0:11:37] I'd like to call to order the City Council meeting for Monday, August 29th. [0:11:43] For those of you wishing to join us, please rise from the Pledge of Allegiance. [0:11:50] I pledge allegiance to the Flag of the United States of America, and to the Republic for which it stands, one Nation under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all. [0:12:05] I will confirm we have a quorum with the council here, all seven members are here this evening. [0:12:13] Mr. Rothweiler, are there any amendments to the agenda? [0:12:16] Mr. Mayor, members of the council, [0:12:17] there are no amendments this evening. [0:12:19] Thank you. [0:12:20] Thank you, nice. [0:12:21] Next on the agenda is proclamations of which we have none. [0:12:24] And so next is general public input. [0:12:27] I didn't see if the, I have Ryan run the signup sheet [0:12:31] up here for me. [0:12:39] Thank you, sir. [0:12:45] Those are, let's see, hold on. [0:12:50] So these are specific to agenda items. [0:12:52] So as there, I see no one signed up for general public input. [0:12:56] Is there anyone here which is to address the council [0:12:58] on an issue that is not on this evening's agenda. [0:13:03] Seeing no one, we will move on to the consent calendar. [0:13:07] Council wishes. [0:13:10] Suzanne Hawkins. [0:13:11] Move approval of the consent calendar. [0:13:14] I'll second it. [0:13:16] Motion by Suzanne Hawkins, seconded by Don Hall [0:13:18] to approve the consent calendar. [0:13:21] And let me ask Nancy, were you talking about item five, [0:13:26] which is the Walk for Wishes? [0:13:30] Did you want to address the council? [0:13:32] Okay, and Jan, you're here for the Brand Bridge Festival. [0:13:37] Did you want to address the council on that issue? [0:13:40] Thank you. [0:13:40] So we have a motion by Suzanne Hawken, seconded by Don Hall [0:13:43] to approve the consent calendar, is there any discussion? [0:13:46] Seeing none, Sharon, roll call vote please. [0:13:48] Suzanne Hawken, yes. [0:13:51] Nikki Boyd, yes. [0:13:52] Sean Bericher, yes. [0:13:53] Chris Tockington, yes. [0:13:55] Greg Lanthien, yes. [0:13:57] Don Hall, yes. [0:13:58] Ruth Pierce, yes. [0:13:59] Motion passes, seven to zero. [0:14:02] You're all approved. [0:14:03] Thank you. [0:14:06] Under items for consideration that- [0:14:08] There goes nothing from there. [0:14:09] Everybody clears that. [0:14:10] We'll miss you. [0:14:13] Under items for consideration, the first item on the agenda [0:14:16] is presentation to move forward with the development [0:14:18] of a 10-year contract with People for Pets Magic Valley [0:14:21] Humane Society. [0:14:22] We have Deputy City Manager Brian Pike. [0:14:24] Welcome, Brian. [0:14:25] Welcome. [0:14:25] Thank you, Mayor and Members of the Council. [0:14:27] Tonight, I want to seek a little direction from Council. [0:14:33] But at the end of September, we will be concluding our last five-year contract with Pets4People. [0:14:38] And our relationship with Pets4People and the Humane Society really goes back 27 years. [0:14:44] For 27 years, they've been running this program for us. [0:14:47] And what we'd like to do is take this time to really look at the contract and to probably [0:14:52] bring it in line with a lot of our other contracts that we have with our other partners and [0:14:56] consider a 10-year contract. [0:14:58] Of course, that would allow us to negotiate on an annual basis with them and it really [0:15:04] would limit our ability to arrange and make arrangements and modifications to the contract, [0:15:12] but it does allow us to kind of move forward progressively like we're doing with our other [0:15:17] partners. [0:15:18] So, I'm here really seeking the direction from Council before we get started in having [0:15:23] this discussion with their board. [0:15:26] We thought we'd come to you to see if it was something that you'd be interested in allowing us to move forward with. [0:15:33] Chris, talking to me. [0:15:34] A couple of random points, Brian. [0:15:37] It's an exceedingly important position for us to fill because we get a lot of spillover of animals brought in from the county into the city streets. [0:15:47] We have the health problem protecting against rabies, communicable diseases. [0:15:53] We have animals being dropped off and picked up, and quite a bit of cash transaction going [0:16:00] on. [0:16:01] And I think it's really important for us to insist on some sort of auditing process, [0:16:10] which is spoken of in this document that you provided to us. [0:16:14] But I'm not aware if we've had an annual, an official audit by the Humane Society. [0:16:20] is this a new concern? [0:16:23] You know, this is, it's not necessarily a concern of ours, [0:16:26] but I've been working with Lori Erase [0:16:27] and one of the things that we have set up with them. [0:16:30] And we've been hit and miss on our quarterly evaluations [0:16:34] of their financials. [0:16:35] But the reality of that is it's fairly easy [0:16:37] for someone to compile an Excel spreadsheet [0:16:41] of their finances and send it to us. [0:16:43] What we would like to do is take it really to the next step [0:16:45] where we ask for an annual audit to be conducted [0:16:48] by a third party every year, just to make sure [0:16:51] that everything's in line. [0:16:53] And we feel that that process is much more valuable [0:16:56] than the process that we have currently in place. [0:16:59] Put on just to a poem on these. [0:17:01] One of the reasons I brought up about the auditing process [0:17:04] I have heard only anecdotally that [0:17:08] there is not a firm process in place [0:17:11] for providing receipts for animals for cash, cash for animals. [0:17:16] And I think that's one thing we really need to reinforce and the people collecting the [0:17:22] money don't make the end of the day deposits if it all costs for just standard auditing [0:17:27] procedures. [0:17:28] We don't want to blur the good that the human society is doing by the community by sloppy [0:17:34] daily transaction accounting. [0:17:35] I agree. [0:17:36] And I think one of the nice things about moving forward and looking at this is that we would [0:17:40] have some flexibility to have those discussions and to address any issue that you would like [0:17:45] us to address in this contract moving forward, so I'd certainly take that into consideration. [0:17:51] Don't know. [0:17:52] You know, Brian, I'm always hesitant to talk about long-term contracts with companies other [0:18:02] than those that have had to make significant financial investments, and we've had a long-term [0:18:07] relationship with, and we can talk about CH2M Hill, obviously that is perfect. [0:18:12] That's a perfect example of the city and the private organization working well together. [0:18:18] In fact, if you look at the history of Krisken and the test of this, they saved their bacon. [0:18:24] See each two of them held it. [0:18:26] And then of course, PSI, big investment on what they do for us as well with the cards and all those dynamics. [0:18:34] And I kind of look at the same thing here with the Humane Society of People for Pets. [0:18:39] The only thing that I would say is that I just want to make sure that we have the ability [0:18:44] that if things aren't going well, the audit comes back and it's not in line with our expectations [0:18:51] because people don't separate, people don't separate us from these entities. [0:18:56] They just think we're one entity and they're a contractor of the city but when something [0:19:02] happens over there, the city gets pulled in. [0:19:05] So I just want to make sure there's that ability to pull out if we need to, to make adjustments [0:19:13] to the contract if we need to in the future and those dynamics. [0:19:17] Can you address that for us? [0:19:19] Yes. [0:19:20] And generally in most of our contracts we have kind of an out clause, which allows you to [0:19:24] party 90 days of written notice for either party to leave the agreement and we would include [0:19:31] that. [0:19:32] You know, we could go less than 90, but 90 is a reasonable one. [0:19:35] We would need 90 days, imagine if people for pets no longer wanted to perform this. [0:19:40] It would take us longer than 90 days to address this issue. [0:19:43] So we would always have that, and I would make sure that we included that. [0:19:46] Another thing that Lori and I talked about, one of the things that she uses, [0:19:50] that she uses the municipal price index to help guide that. [0:19:56] And that's kind of an informal process that she has. [0:19:58] And we'll probably write that into the contract just as a guide to make sure [0:20:01] that we are, you know, where we need to be at with our annual budget. [0:20:07] So, kind of as a guy. [0:20:08] So you'd see both of those issues addressed in the contract that we bring back to you for your consideration. [0:20:15] Thank you, Suzanne Hawkins. [0:20:17] Thank you, couple questions. [0:20:18] First of all, does the county participate financially with this program as well, or is it strictly the city? [0:20:26] I believe the county is participating, yeah. [0:20:28] Is it an equal basis? [0:20:30] No. [0:20:31] but they do cover part of the cost. [0:20:34] So if somebody from Jerome drove across the bridge [0:20:37] and took an animal out there, that's okay too. [0:20:41] I mean, I know that this taxpayers of Twin Falls [0:20:43] are paying this portion of it, [0:20:45] but do they allow others outside of Twin Falls County [0:20:47] to bring animals in? [0:20:49] Or are we footing the bill for all of that? [0:20:52] Or do you know? [0:20:53] You know what, it's a great question. [0:20:54] I don't have that information, [0:20:56] but as we move forward and we come back to you, [0:21:00] Deborah Blackwood and her staff will be here to address some of those concerns, but I would imagine that happens occasionally, but obviously, I don't think it's a real problem. [0:21:11] That staff is pretty sensitive to problem solving, so I think they would probably work the problem and find an adequate solution. [0:21:21] But I don't know the frequency of how that occurs on a regular basis or not. [0:21:27] And one last comment, I guess, again on that 10-year contract, I have a little bit of concern [0:21:34] with tying future councils hands because the seven of us won't be here most likely 10 years [0:21:40] from now. [0:21:41] Thank you. [0:21:42] But I understand the working relationship and the history, but there isn't a lot of cost [0:21:51] involvement from their side to extend it, and I would be more comfortable not tying future [0:21:57] council's decision making out that far personally. [0:22:01] In one of the things that you'll see in the current contract, and I really like this, it's [0:22:05] a real emphasis on people for pets to continue to fundraise and not be reliant solely on tax [0:22:13] dollars. [0:22:14] And so we think that's a portion, a good part of this contract that we need to continue to [0:22:18] work with them so that you know there's we can offset some of those costs to us but [0:22:24] I will certainly take that into consideration. [0:22:26] Nikki Boyd. [0:22:28] So that's I'm very curious in that is what does it actually cost them per month to run [0:22:40] and if we are contributing and basically we're in partners with them I'd like to know a little [0:22:48] bit more about quality control and I'd like to look at what the Humane Society you know [0:22:57] they're part of that whole structure so what are the basic requirements to be a member of [0:23:08] that organization and then how can we step it up and I love that they have a food pantry [0:23:15] for pets and that they're doing as much as they can with everything they have, but I'd [0:23:22] really like to look more at exactly what it costs to run that place and what they're producing [0:23:27] with that money. [0:23:28] Okay. [0:23:31] Ruth Pierce. [0:23:32] A couple of things I might mention, an annual audit would require an internal control analysis. [0:23:39] So with an annual audit, we will get some feedback on the internal control. [0:23:44] is after the fact as opposed to currently. The other thing is, is there a separate board [0:23:52] that manages the shelter? I mean, okay, so one of the things I see liability insurance [0:24:00] being a requirement, the other thing I see with a lot of nonprofits is no errors and [0:24:06] emissions for the board itself, board liabilities, so if there's a mistake made from a decision [0:24:13] from the board, I just think we need to make sure that they're covered one way or another. [0:24:18] Okay, we can do that. [0:24:23] Any other comments or questions for Brian? [0:24:27] So Brian, you're seeking, are you seeking, do we need the action to, I don't think we need [0:24:32] to move forward with that. [0:24:33] I don't think we need the action to move forward with that. [0:24:34] But I just think we're looking for a direction on what, I guess first off, whether you want [0:24:38] us to continue to move forward with our relationship with people for pets and humane society. [0:24:43] And I think that I'm definitely getting the indication that you do. [0:24:47] And then what we will do is incorporate your concerns into kind of a final product and then [0:24:53] present a contract for your review and your consideration. [0:24:56] Travis, why not? [0:24:58] There is maybe one action we can ask the council to take. [0:25:01] The first would be in the event that we're unable to have an agreement before the council [0:25:07] by September 30th that there is a mutual understanding by letter that the people for [0:25:13] for pets will continue to operate the animal shelter [0:25:15] under the current arrangement [0:25:17] until a new agreement can be put into place. [0:25:20] We would hate to have an agreement terminate on 30th [0:25:23] and does not have a contract done if that isn't the case. [0:25:32] Okay, Chris talking to me. [0:25:34] One other comment I think in line with what we've talked [0:25:38] about with the extended contract 10 years, [0:25:41] I think for that connection to be maintained between the board of the Humane Society and [0:25:48] the Council that we should request an annual summary report to the Council in person and [0:25:55] writing of something where we have closer identification with the past year particular [0:26:02] problems we may be able to help them with or be aware of. [0:26:06] We can do that. [0:26:07] That'd be similar to the YMCA in their annual presentation. [0:26:11] Okay. [0:26:12] We can do that. [0:26:17] So I would entertain a motion to Greg Lanting. [0:26:22] I move that we continue on negotiations with a possible long-term contract with people who [0:26:29] are pets and should it not be completed by September 30th that we continue our agreement [0:26:36] with them over the existing contract until a new contract is forged. [0:26:41] Nicky Boyd. [0:26:42] Second. [0:26:43] The motion by Greg Lanting, seconded by Nicky Boyd. [0:26:46] Is there any discussion from the council? [0:26:50] Seeing none, Sharon, roll call vote, please. [0:26:52] Nicky Boyd? [0:26:54] Yes. [0:26:55] Sean Bericher? [0:26:56] Yes. [0:26:57] Chris Talkington? [0:26:58] Yes. [0:26:59] Greg Lanting? [0:27:00] Yes. [0:27:01] Don Hall? [0:27:02] Yes. [0:27:03] Ruth Pierce? [0:27:04] Yes. [0:27:05] Suzanne Hawkins? [0:27:06] Yes. [0:27:07] Thank you. [0:27:08] Thank you, Brian. [0:27:09] Excellent. [0:27:11] The agenda is a request to award the 2016 City of Twin Falls Frontier Field Pickleball [0:27:15] Courts Project to tennis and track company, the amount of $112,614.29. [0:27:24] Wendy Davis with our Parks and Recreation Department. [0:27:26] Welcome, Wendy. [0:27:29] Thank you. [0:27:30] Good evening, Mayor and Council. [0:27:32] This request is a budgeted capital improvement project that included the removal of the existing [0:27:41] frontier courts and the replacement of those courts with a concrete surface pickleball [0:27:48] court. [0:27:49] And we are doing post-tension concrete and in the research on post-tension concrete, Josh [0:27:56] gets really technical in this description for you and I don't want to talk about tensile [0:28:00] because I don't know a lot about it, but basically this technology will make a much longer lasting [0:28:08] court as opposed to asphalt that requires an overlay on a resurface on a fairly regular basis. [0:28:15] And so the effort to do that, there was nobody that could help us with a really good bid. [0:28:21] So that's why we did a request for qualifications to find a firm that could do the post-tension concrete [0:28:28] and provide us with the workers that could complete that action. [0:28:32] And so we went through a request for qualifications found in Tennyson Track, [0:28:36] are very confident with their ability to put these courts in. [0:28:40] And I bring to you a contract for $112,620.29 to put in six of the 12 courts in a phased project. [0:28:52] Chris talking to that that a curiosity if we were to do an asphalt as opposed to this resisting [0:29:00] Compression load no post tension concrete, but what kind of cost differential is it? I? [0:29:07] I don't know the answer to that question we when we talked in this is substantial [0:29:13] I don't know okay [0:29:15] The only thing I would add to that is yeah [0:29:24] The capital cost is going to be different [0:29:26] but really the life cycle cost is going to drive the decision. [0:29:30] And with post-tension concrete, you're going to have less maintenance [0:29:32] than you would with asphalt. [0:29:33] You'd have to resurface more often. [0:29:37] Donald? [0:29:39] Wendy, could you explain to the folks at home what is pickleball? [0:29:42] Don, you and I are going to go play it. [0:29:47] So it's a similar game to tennis, but you use a, I'm going to get in trouble here. [0:29:54] I played it a little bit. [0:29:55] It's like a wooden paddle racket and with a shorter handle and they play with a harder ball. [0:30:02] So it doesn't bounce as high, it doesn't bounce as far as like a tennis ball. [0:30:07] But it's a similar, it's very similar game to tennis. [0:30:12] All I know is I'm not very good at it because I'm a tennis player and I think I know where my racket is [0:30:16] and I miss the ball because it's the pickleball racket's a lot shorter. [0:30:19] And we've had some call in the community for pickleball courts and that's why we're a dot. [0:30:24] And a designated pickleball facility is a nice amenity [0:30:29] because what they tend to want to do is put additional lines [0:30:32] down on tennis courts. [0:30:34] And so then you have courts that are trying to be multi-used [0:30:38] by pickleball and tennis. [0:30:40] And sometimes that goes well and sometimes it's not as. [0:30:45] That's a growing sport, for sure. [0:30:47] Suzanne Hawkins. [0:30:48] Thank you. [0:30:49] So at first we were talking about doing 12 courts, correct? [0:30:53] and now we're down to six. [0:30:55] So what are we doing with that extra space [0:30:57] in the meantime? [0:31:02] So the asphalt has been milled [0:31:05] and we do have a savings of the hundred, [0:31:08] because we have $140,000 budget for this project. [0:31:10] So the additional money that is still in that fund, [0:31:16] part of it will go to a sidewalk that will add, [0:31:19] that will go around the courts. [0:31:23] And then I think the other part of it was [0:31:25] to maybe put down a slurry seal over the top of the milled asphalt as a temporary piece [0:31:34] to hold that in a usable surface until we can come in and do the other half. [0:31:38] So will it be used for tennis or pickle ball? [0:31:41] Neither. [0:31:42] Neither. [0:31:43] Just a holding space for now. [0:31:45] We can put a picnic table out there. [0:31:49] Okay, thank you. [0:31:51] Maybe a hot scotch. [0:31:53] Hey, there you go. [0:31:54] I like it. [0:31:55] Great dancing. [0:31:56] Having played pickleball. [0:31:58] Thank you. [0:31:59] Actually, we used to, the PE classes used to set it up in the wintertime in the gym and [0:32:06] then they'd come up with a, this is the girl's PE classes, we'd come up with a champion [0:32:10] and then they'd play me in kick my ass and it's so, it's a kick your rear. [0:32:19] The thing I liked about it I think was the fact that the ball, I don't think the ball [0:32:24] Those nearly as fast and so you can cover more ground on your tennis how quickly the ball comes out [0:32:29] I want to offer Americans a new and much better future [0:32:33] Every inside getting rich off our body [0:32:36] Great throw this money, can't help [0:32:39] Yes, anyway, I'm glad to see that we're getting this pickleball [0:32:47] Some of the Disney football courts there and I think there are some [0:32:51] Some leagues thinking about forming as I recall there are leagues that are currently playing and something they're playing over it [0:32:58] I'm gonna call it South Park, but it's the Oregon Trail youth complex in that area where the old [0:33:02] Concrete tennis courts are okay. They've been playing over there, and they've got a few courts in town that they've lined with [0:33:08] tape and then there's [0:33:11] the [0:33:13] Sorry, and there's the [0:33:16] There's an indoor, I think it's a soccer place that they've been playing inside there. [0:33:22] And then they play at the Y, too. [0:33:23] So there's been multiple locations where they're playing. [0:33:28] And they've been involved in this process a little bit, too. [0:33:30] We've certainly tapped into them. [0:33:34] And I was like, we had the opportunity of watching all the engineers' faces as you were talking [0:33:38] about the specs and the different faces. [0:33:40] It was pretty entertaining behind you there. [0:33:42] I didn't think Jim Buck and Bailey had one. [0:33:44] Jackie, just about lost her beverage. [0:33:46] All right, any other comments or questions for Wendy? [0:33:52] Seeing none, I would entertain a motion. [0:33:55] Don Hall. [0:33:55] I'll make the motion that we award the 2016 City of Twin Falls [0:34:00] Frontier Field, Pitbull Ball Core Project to Tennyson Track [0:34:04] Company in the amount of $112,614.29. [0:34:10] Ruth Pierce. [0:34:11] Second. [0:34:13] The motion by Don Hall, seconded by Ruth Pierce [0:34:14] to approve the request as presented. [0:34:17] Is there any further discussion? [0:34:19] Seeing none, Sharon will call both, please. [0:34:22] Sean Bericher? [0:34:23] Yes. [0:34:24] Chris Hockington? [0:34:24] Yes. [0:34:25] Greg Lanting? [0:34:26] Yes. [0:34:26] Don Hall? [0:34:28] Yes. [0:34:28] Ruth Pierce? [0:34:29] Yes. [0:34:30] Suzanne Hockington? [0:34:31] Yes. [0:34:31] Nikki Boyd? [0:34:32] Yes. [0:34:33] Motion passes 7-0. [0:34:34] Thank you, Wendy. [0:34:38] Next is a request to accept an FAA grant offer, [0:34:43] Airport Improvement Project 38 for the terminal modification project in the amount of $1,855,648 [0:34:51] build Tarberry Airport major. [0:34:53] Thank you, Mayor. [0:34:54] Good evening, Council members. [0:34:56] Well, tonight I've got the last of three grant offers for the terminal project and what's [0:35:00] particularly satisfying about these kinds of projects that we do out of the airport is [0:35:04] they have long horizons. [0:35:06] I have advisory board members that come on and often I'll tell them the fruits of your [0:35:11] deliberations, your discussion, your planning won't happen for three, five, seven years from now. [0:35:17] So when I'll bump into some old advisory board members, I'll say, hey, look, remember that project on the terminal we talked about? [0:35:23] Here we go. It's really happening. So I appreciate their help on the board and the city and county's patients as we navigate our way through these projects, [0:35:30] and particularly the funding pictures. So it's the last of three grants for the amount mentioned by the mayor. [0:35:38] And the project through this and through some TSA funding [0:35:43] and passenger facility charges, it's 96% funded [0:35:46] on from the federal side. [0:35:48] So with that, it's a much needed project. [0:35:50] It's great to get this assistance from the FAA [0:35:53] and I'll answer any questions and seek your approval tonight [0:35:57] for the grant. [0:36:00] I see no questions for Bill. [0:36:02] Chris talking too. [0:36:03] I'll just give a quick update on that progress [0:36:05] of the terminal project. [0:36:07] Well, we're on time and on budget. [0:36:09] as I was here a few weeks ago and things are still moving along well and we should be substantially [0:36:16] complete sometime around the holidays at the end of the year and we'll be completely finished [0:36:20] with the project in the first quarter of 2017. So people are excited about it and I think something [0:36:26] people will be proud of out there and we'll be ready for whatever comes our way. [0:36:30] Thanks, brother. [0:36:33] Council wishes on the request. Chris talked. [0:36:36] I would move to accept the FAA AIP 38 grant offering the amount of the [0:36:41] 9855648 authorized mayor to sign. [0:36:47] Motion by Chris Dinington, seconded by Greg Lansing to accept the [0:36:51] grant offer as presented. [0:36:53] Any further discussion from the council? [0:36:56] Seeing none, Sharon, we'll call the vote, please. [0:36:58] Chris Tockington. [0:36:59] Yes. [0:37:00] Greg Lanthine. [0:37:01] Yes. [0:37:02] Don Hall. [0:37:03] Yes. [0:37:03] Ruth Pierce. [0:37:04] Yes. [0:37:05] Suzanne Hocken. [0:37:06] Yes. [0:37:06] Nikki Boyd. Yes. Sean Berry here. Yes. Motion passes 7 to 0. Thank you again. Thank you. [0:37:13] Thank you. Next is a request to award the contract for the City of Twin Falls 2016 Mill [0:37:24] and Inlay project to Staker Parsons Company, VBA item materials and construction of Jerome [0:37:30] Idaho in the amount of $103,076.10. We have Aaron Steele. Thank you. Welcome. By way of [0:37:38] introduction. My name is Aaron Steel, I'm brand new to the city I've only been here [0:37:41] about a year, so this is my first time at Council, so please be gentle. So today I [0:37:49] come with a request to approve the 2016 Millin inlay of three areas. So the [0:38:01] three areas are on to over on Washington Street right at Chaney Drive and the [0:38:07] other one is at the inlet of Walmart. The other project is a long film more [0:38:13] from Poleline to Chaney. These three areas are in pretty rough shape. They are in [0:38:20] desperate need of some repair. I have a couple of quick pictures here just to show [0:38:24] you. So this is right at Chaney looking north on Washington Street. As you can see [0:38:33] the area is just destroyed and they're actually trying to do some pothole [0:38:38] repair in there and the whole area needs to be milled. So they're going to do three [0:38:42] inches of mill and then they'll come back and put three inches of brand new [0:38:45] asphalt pavement back into that section. The contract was bid formally with three [0:38:55] people bidding the job, which were Idaho's materials and construction, valley paving, [0:39:00] and Cleptford. The lowest of which was idle construction materials at $103,000 [0:39:10] are $703,000, $76.10. [0:39:15] The budget, the impact, will come from the approved streets [0:39:18] mill on an overlay budget. [0:39:20] Now, the cost associated with this [0:39:22] is far lower than was planned. [0:39:25] As you can see in the fit tabulation [0:39:27] that I attached with you, these prices [0:39:30] that are coming, the $81 for the plant mix pavement [0:39:33] is a fantastic price. [0:39:34] Last year, I did a similar project to the smaller scope, [0:39:38] and they came in about $110 a ton, [0:39:41] where this one's coming in about $81. [0:39:43] Last year, they charged us about $5 a square yard [0:39:47] to mill the surface. [0:39:49] This year, it's coming in at $1.70. [0:39:51] So these are some fantastic prices to keep in mind. [0:39:56] So the area that's in question on film art [0:40:00] is gonna have some impact to surrounding businesses. [0:40:03] There's two hotels on the north side of the film art spot. [0:40:08] And while working, I will work with the contractor to ensure that there's a traffic control plan. [0:40:14] I can't request that yet until after we've awarded the project. [0:40:17] But there will be a traffic control plan overseen by him. [0:40:20] Also in the contract documents, we've written in there that he will come in contact with each of the business owners to ensure that they're aware of what's going on. [0:40:28] Now to protect the city, we've put a two day clause in there that once they start the work they have two days to finish. [0:40:35] Which is not an unreasonable request. [0:40:38] contractors are notorious for being able to figure tight problems and workout [0:40:43] solutions so I'm actually eager and hopeful to see what kind of solutions he [0:40:46] comes up with so that we have as minimal impact on these surrounding businesses [0:40:50] we can get. So myself and in the city staff engineering group would recommend to [0:40:58] improve this contract. Thank you Greg Lanting. Here in we see a lot of contracts [0:41:05] and we see a lot of times the bids are closed and then this time they're 25 and 35% higher. [0:41:12] We have used item materials instruction often, have we not in the past and we're satisfied [0:41:18] with their work? [0:41:19] Yes. [0:41:20] All right. [0:41:21] Thank you. [0:41:22] Just for the layman, could you explain to folks at home what mill and in light means? [0:41:27] What does that mean? [0:41:28] Sure. [0:41:29] That means, so there's three types of construction that can happen. [0:41:33] a total reconstruction, which means they dig everything out, replace everything, and put [0:41:37] it back. A chip seal, which is kind of just a surface of band-aid on the problem, and there's [0:41:42] the intermediate, which is the milling in there where they go, and they grind off literally [0:41:47] three inches of the pavement, and they haul that away, and then they come back and they [0:41:51] pour a brand new asphalt back where that was, so it'll be at the existing level, but it'll [0:41:56] all be brand new in that area. [0:41:59] Thank you. [0:42:00] Chris, Dr. Aaron, this is a little difficult for me to get my head around, because every [0:42:06] year we have quite a large amount of money set aside for redoing sections of the town, [0:42:14] eight or nine sections, and why is this not in them? Why is this a separately bent upon [0:42:20] project? Is it because of the nature of the streets being arterial, as opposed to residential, [0:42:25] Why is this not a normal summertime overlay redoing, [0:42:32] re-aspholding, rebuilding project? [0:42:34] I'm just trying to make sure I understand the question. [0:42:38] So this actually is in that normal overlay budget. [0:42:41] They're coming out of the normal overlay that we would do [0:42:45] on a yearly basis. [0:42:46] And so this is the repair of the sections that needed most [0:42:49] in this zone, which is zone six for this year. [0:42:53] I think is that what you're asking? [0:42:55] That's close enough, that's pretty good, thank you. [0:42:58] Suzanne Hawkins. [0:42:59] I have two questions. [0:43:01] First of all, welcome, it's nice to meet you. [0:43:04] So when they mill off that three inches on the top, is that reusable anywhere? [0:43:10] Does that go to our pile when we need a parking lot or something that we can sometimes use it in? [0:43:14] Yes, that's correct. [0:43:15] So I spoke with Dean Letler, the street superintendent, so he's coordinated a spot to dump those millings. [0:43:21] He'll actually use them on the Canyon Springs Great Road this winter. [0:43:24] Oh, good. That is a good one. And secondly, it seems like Washington and Cheney is a fairly new road. [0:43:31] Isn't this awful soon to have this kind of wear and tear? Was there something... [0:43:37] Do you know the history on it at all? Because it just seems like that road is awfully new to have this much problem. [0:43:43] Sure. I think part of that, and maybe Jackie can correct me if I'm wrong, [0:43:47] is the truck traffic that's on that road that wasn't foreseen would be my guess. [0:43:52] I wasn't here when they did the rotary, so I don't know when that comes into play, but [0:43:56] it's getting hammered by some big trucks that are coming through there. [0:43:59] So do we need to be looking towards something on that section closer to what we're doing [0:44:04] on Eastland with the concrete in the future? [0:44:07] Or is, I mean, what kind of life expectancy after this mill in LA should we expect on that? [0:44:13] So the asphalt that we're putting in isn't the same as the asphalt that was there. [0:44:16] This is actually a higher grade asphalt. [0:44:19] Try not to be too technical. [0:44:21] It has a higher oil content, which the temperature swing is going to be better and so won't be as [0:44:28] Soft as the last mixture. Well, so do you estimate five years seven years ten years? What do you probably an easy 20? Okay? [0:44:35] Thank you [0:44:40] I'll take that [0:44:47] Any further comments or questions from the council [0:44:54] to obtain a motion. [0:44:55] Greg Lanting. [0:44:56] I move that we submit the, accept the bid of vital materials and instruction and the amount [0:45:02] of $103,076.10 for the work as outlined by Aaron. [0:45:08] Second. [0:45:09] By Greg Lanting, seconded by Suzanne Hawkins to award the contract as presented any further [0:45:16] discussion from the council. [0:45:18] Seeing none, Chair and all those please. [0:45:20] Greg Lanting. [0:45:21] Yes. [0:45:22] Don Hall. [0:45:23] Yes. [0:45:24] Susan Hawkins. Yes. Nikki Boyd. Yes. Sean Bericher. Yes. Chris talking. Yes. Motion passes 7-0. Thank [0:45:33] you, Aaron. Thank you. Next on the agenda is a request to use street reserves to fund an unanticipated [0:45:40] and unbudgeted street mill and inlay project. Our public works director John Keaton. Welcome, John. [0:45:45] Thank you. Thank you, Mayor. Good evening, Mayor and Council. As I presented in the staff report, [0:45:55] excuse me. Last week, Dean and I went out to Grandview. We got a call from a contractor [0:45:59] out on the job. They're performing, they're constructing more subdivision at the intersection [0:46:06] of North College and Grandview. And that subdivision is required to reconstruct a portion of Grandview [0:46:15] and connect a lane and connect it to the existing Grandview. Well, the existing piece of Grandview [0:46:21] was prior to part, I was going to see new development rules, [0:46:26] but they're not new. [0:46:26] They've been, how long have we been having to build the money [0:46:30] in years? [0:46:31] About 10 years. [0:46:32] So this was prior to that, and this existing roadway [0:46:36] is the county road. [0:46:37] So it's just not suitable to connect to. [0:46:40] So we went ahead and executed a contract, [0:46:43] because it's just not a tolerable situation. [0:46:45] It's near Xavier, it's an arterial. [0:46:48] So Street Fund, Dean and I made the decision [0:46:51] to divert some funds from planned milling overlay [0:46:55] for this year to take care of this emergency. [0:46:59] So we did that project. [0:47:01] I estimated it between 15,000 and 18,000. [0:47:04] And the contract we signed to significantly less, it's 11,000. [0:47:10] But it still impacts our budget. [0:47:13] And the potential is that we wouldn't [0:47:15] be able to do all of our millen overlays that we've planned for the Zone Maintenance Project [0:47:20] this year. Now, obviously it's up to council. We don't have to do all of our millen overlay [0:47:26] projects, but it's always our goal to do so. So I wanted to ask council for approval to [0:47:32] use $11,000 of street reserves so that we can do all of our millen overlays. [0:47:39] Donahue. So let me see if I get this right. You want us to go in the street reserve so [0:47:45] So we don't use the budget that we're going to use for mill and overlay so that we can do [0:47:49] the zones as we made that decision years ago so that we can stay on top of the maintenance. [0:47:55] Is that fair? [0:47:56] Yeah. [0:47:57] Okay. [0:47:58] So you want us to go with a? [0:48:01] Okay. [0:48:02] You ready for a motion? [0:48:04] I would move approval of the use of street reserves to fund an unanticipated and unbudgeted [0:48:11] street mill and inlay project, do I need to say the location? North College and [0:48:19] and Grandview in the amount of 11,000 flat? Sorry, can I clarify? Yes, okay. So we're [0:48:34] gonna, if we want to do all of our milling on relate jobs, we're gonna overrun the [0:48:39] budget by $11,000. So I'm not asking to pay a grand view. We're [0:48:44] paying it. I'm asking to pay Oak Street. So I'm not sure how [0:48:48] you want to work here. [0:48:49] I retract my motion and ask for help with the motion. [0:48:54] So what John is simply asking is to use $11,000 of street fund [0:49:02] reserves to complete million overlay projects for this [0:49:05] fiscal year. [0:49:06] So moved. [0:49:07] Second. [0:49:07] Motion by Don Hall, seconded by Chris Tockington, further discussion with the council. [0:49:16] Seeing none, Sharon, roll call vote, please. [0:49:19] Don Hall? [0:49:20] Yes. [0:49:21] Ruth Pierce? [0:49:22] Yes. [0:49:23] Suzanne Hopkins? [0:49:24] Yes. [0:49:25] Nicki Boyd? [0:49:26] Yes. [0:49:27] Sean Veriker? [0:49:28] Yes. [0:49:29] Chris Tockington? [0:49:30] Greg Lanti? [0:49:31] Yes. [0:49:32] Motion passes 7-0. [0:49:35] Thank you, John. [0:49:36] to support the use of the 2015 Idaho Standards for Public Works construction [0:49:43] and the City of Twin Falls revisions to the 2015 Idaho Standards for Public Works construction [0:49:49] revisions as the city's standard specifications. [0:49:53] City Engineer Jackie Fields, welcome Jackie. [0:49:56] Good evening. [0:49:58] Okay, so we've had a city spec that has been in place for decades, many decades, [0:50:17] In the early 1980s, a group of engineering professionals thought it would be really nice to have a state standard, so that smaller communities and larger communities could work off a generally similar spec set to the extent possible. [0:50:38] The first spec was developed in 1985, so we already had our city spec in place when ISP [0:50:48] at WC was first developed, and well and truly, over time, it has evolved into a pretty darn [0:50:54] good document. [0:50:57] That is also combined with the idea that we were really, really busy in engineering for [0:51:04] many years, and our city spec became outdated. [0:51:08] We had increasing request by contractors and paving contractors and the like to try to amend [0:51:13] our specs to something that was used more commonly less expensive materials, use of plastic [0:51:20] pipe for water lines and things like that. [0:51:24] And so we had in our group a debate on what we should do. [0:51:28] Should we update city spec or should we move to adopting ISPWC? [0:51:32] And I chose to attempt to move to adopting ISPWC. [0:51:37] One of the primary advantages of doing that is that there's a team of professionals statewide [0:51:42] that regularly update the spec. [0:51:44] So some of the things that just make you want to poke your eye out with SharpStiff can be [0:51:48] done by a committee on a regular basis and their task to do that. [0:51:52] Meanwhile we can still enhance a revision set so that it can do the things we need it to [0:52:00] do. [0:52:02] in the decision to move to the ISPWC. [0:52:06] That's actually significant and a time-consuming effort [0:52:11] because our spec was totally different. [0:52:15] It was laid out differently. [0:52:20] And we found in reviewing ISPWC [0:52:23] that there were things that were missing [0:52:25] that we always want to have in our city spec. [0:52:28] So we have things that would fall into that always category [0:52:34] are telling people that we're doing work within 48 hours [0:52:44] before doing it, posting a sign that says, [0:52:47] this is a contractor that's doing the work. [0:52:54] We always want people to deal with dust control. [0:52:56] So we put them in this much smaller document [0:53:01] called city revisions. [0:53:06] We also wanted to provide an opportunity [0:53:08] to do things that were reasonable. [0:53:12] And so we added some reasonable things [0:53:14] into our city spec that are not allowable necessarily in ISPWC, like surface repair. [0:53:22] So, we actually worked on this for a while to provide an opportunity for a contractor [0:53:29] to hit winter weather and provide a temporary patch that can be taken out later [0:53:33] and it's not a big deal. [0:53:36] It's just something that can be done if you run out of time or weather [0:53:39] or you have a perfectly fine reason for putting down an intermediate surface [0:53:46] so that you can do other work and come back and finish our roadway. [0:53:50] So, you know, we tried to add enhancements to our existing city specs [0:53:55] so that they were always at the time for people to do it. [0:54:00] During this process, we also decided that it was probably a really good time [0:54:04] to question the traditional ways and means. [0:54:07] You know, why do we have a particular specification in place? [0:54:11] Do we really still need it? [0:54:13] Is it, you know, just because we've always done it like that, [0:54:16] does not necessarily mean that that's something we need to take into our future. [0:54:23] And then we also tried not to contradict ourselves between what we were, what we had in our city [0:54:28] spec that we really wanted and what ISPWC had. [0:54:35] We found in our process that ISPWC does not always have the specifications, all of the [0:54:43] specifications that we need. [0:54:44] And the reason that it doesn't do that is that it allows for communities to true the document [0:54:51] to what they really need. [0:54:53] So, let me see here. [0:55:02] So one of these examples, this is an easy one, is that ISPWC says, you'll use a pressure [0:55:11] class for pipe according to the contract documents, and instead of making everyone specify every [0:55:17] developer and every engineer that does work in the city, instead of making them specify [0:55:21] every single time. We thought that we would just include in the city spec pressure class [0:55:29] it's 165. So it's in our revisions and then if we need to do something special or different [0:55:36] we can just write that in as a special provision instead. So the goal is to try to make things [0:55:41] this document will also be used by developers and we need to have a document that's easy [0:55:46] for all of those guys to use as well. Okay the other thing that we found in the general [0:56:11] ISPWC is that it doesn't exactly tell you how often and fast you want your testing frequencies [0:56:18] to be. [0:56:19] You know, the agencies are required to develop that on their own. [0:56:22] And so in the same way as specifying what type of pipe class we wanted, we also did things [0:56:27] like trying to specify how often a test should be occurring so that we don't have to have [0:56:33] developers, including this in every single improvement agreement, and we don't have to [0:56:36] include it in our contracts, it's just there. [0:56:41] There you'd have it. [0:56:42] There's a typical example that says when you're putting in embankment you're going to take [0:56:46] a test every 300 feet of road and gives you a nice testing frequency and you can put that [0:56:53] on your sheets and turn it in and you have a reasonable amount of data to be able to say [0:56:58] yeah the material was put in for this particular road in a suitable manner. [0:57:10] So we had conversations, we've been having these conversations with some of these people, [0:57:15] paving contractors in particular for years. [0:57:18] Please let us use less fractured faces. [0:57:21] So we came and visited with, at least some of you, [0:57:24] in October of 2015, and had a little presentation [0:57:28] on the work that we've done. [0:57:31] We had a contract out there. [0:57:34] I don't know if any of you remember this, [0:57:35] maybe you've blotted it from your memory, but. [0:57:39] That was the name of the presentation. [0:57:44] And there were some very important pieces in there. [0:57:47] And one of them is that we did choose to go away [0:57:49] from a single fractured face spec, which is easier to produce. [0:57:53] And we decided also that we could use a smaller granulated [0:57:58] material for roadways that was also easier to produce. [0:58:01] So it cost the contractors less money. [0:58:03] That means we get a better buy. [0:58:04] We have an equivalent product, so we've still done our [0:58:07] stewardship of the public trust type thing. [0:58:20] You know, this was such a slick presentation in my own mind. [0:58:22] I had it all laid out, it was so smooth and it flowed really well. [0:58:30] So in the conversation that we had in October, we had something that I referred to as the 800-pound gorilla comet. [0:58:41] And it had to do with the depth of the typical section of the Robles. [0:58:45] I'm going to try to walk you through this, again, just as a gentle reminder. [0:58:55] Okay, so on residential streets our current section is 10 inches deep and [0:59:00] On collector roads our current section the depths of the pavement including the rock beneath it is 14 inches deep [0:59:08] So American geotechnics did some work for us and produced these tables that say hey [0:59:14] You know if you want to have a 75% likelihood that your pavement is gonna last [0:59:19] the entire time that you want it to last. Then you want to consider having your residential [0:59:25] street have a typical depth of 17 inches, not 10, and your collectors based on a future [0:59:32] classification that we don't yet have of 18 and a half to 20 and a half inches deep. If [0:59:38] you want to have a higher likelihood that your roads are going to stay in place as long as [0:59:43] you want them to, the full life cycle of the pavement, then you want to consider table [0:59:48] number 22 with the residential street section depth of 18 and a half inches and a major collector [0:59:53] depth of 26. [0:59:55] Okay, so we talked to the developers extensively about this and tried to understand what we [1:00:10] could and should do in like a consensus building kind of way. [1:00:14] It actually was consensus building. [1:00:15] And what the development community told us was, we really understand the need to have [1:00:21] major collectors and arterials be a stronger, deeper section, you know, we get it. [1:00:30] They happen, you know, these collectors happen with alarming regularity, but you know, it's [1:00:35] important to have the larger roads have the thicker section. [1:00:42] In addition to that, we started to look for residential streets that had not made it through [1:00:49] their lifespan. [1:00:52] What we found was that our residential streets are doing really pretty well. [1:01:00] Even though the theory says that we should consider having a section that's seven inches [1:01:05] deeper, what we have right now is really doing pretty well. [1:01:11] We have some streets like Granada that are not real roads, they're like they pay dirt. [1:01:17] So, you know, Granada is holding up pretty well and that was done a long time ago. [1:01:24] We have other streets like little old Tyler that's 47 years old and Tyler's looking a [1:01:35] little bit weary. [1:01:36] This is the road that Don hates but you know because it doesn't have any curb better inside [1:01:41] lock on it. [1:01:42] I don't hate the road. [1:01:43] I want to see improvements to the road. [1:01:45] You want to see it on ham's road. [1:01:47] Yes. [1:01:48] But really, you know, when you look at the pavement here, you know, it looks pretty tired and, [1:01:51] um, but you know, it's 47 year old pavement. [1:01:54] And so really, it's, that's exceeded the lifespan of the typical section and it's been doing [1:02:00] all right. [1:02:01] So, um, Jackie Don has a comment or question. [1:02:05] Just real quick, uh, quick about the residential roads. [1:02:07] It is part of the reason that they're maybe lasting longer than we anticipate. [1:02:12] as we stand on top of making sure the semis aren't driving through. [1:02:16] Because I'm assuming a lot of the road wear is about the kind of use, the kind of vehicles [1:02:21] on it. [1:02:22] That's accurate, at least so the life of the pavement is based on the kind of load that's [1:02:32] on it. [1:02:33] So if you have a road that does not reel, that load is used to describe how the load comes [1:02:40] down on the pavement. [1:02:42] And when you don't have as many easels, your pavement does tend to last longer, the base [1:02:46] lasts longer and so does the roadway. [1:02:48] The city does not have a policy that prohibits trucks from driving on roads. [1:02:56] If they can pull a permit on the state system, then they can drive on our streets. [1:03:03] But it just so happens that there's no reason for any large hauler to haul on a residential [1:03:11] street unless they're actually making a delivery. So, to your point, the loads have not been realized on the roadways. [1:03:18] I think I was pointing more towards the rules and regulations about overnight parking, [1:03:24] semis and things like that that would keep them off the rest of the roads. [1:03:28] That probably helps. [1:03:30] Nicky Boyd has a comment. [1:03:32] I just have a question then on these residential roads that we're putting in at the 10 inches. [1:03:37] is what is the expected, is it 30 years, 50 years? [1:03:41] I understand Tyler's looking weary at 47, [1:03:44] but what was the life expectancy perceived to be? [1:03:48] So typically the life expectancy [1:03:51] on a plant mix pavement section, [1:03:53] so black top is 20 years. [1:03:55] And on concrete you should expect [1:03:56] to be able to get 40 years out of it. [1:03:59] But we have leveraged 40, 50, 60, [1:04:02] some of these roads are 65 years old [1:04:03] and we know they're 65 years old. [1:04:05] Some we just can't even find an age on them, and they're really doing okay. [1:04:14] So perhaps on this particular round or set of discussions, leaving the residential road [1:04:24] section as it currently is a reasonable compromise. [1:04:33] So, Jackie, there are a couple of other comments, but I'm guessing we're maybe stuck here in the depth of street [1:04:39] conversation as opposed to the specifications discussion. [1:04:44] If maybe we might want to get, I want to make sure we'd stay on track with what you're actually requesting. [1:04:51] Okay, so part of what I'm requesting does include adopting a specification that shows this typical section. [1:04:57] This is TF 801 out of the new city revisions, and what it shows is a residential section [1:05:05] that is identical to the one that we currently, well not identical, it's very close. [1:05:09] It has a small amount, more plant mix on top, which everyone agreed is easier to place and [1:05:14] gives you a more consistent product, and everyone meant developers, engineers, and the plant [1:05:20] mix folks. [1:05:22] But it also recommends a deeper collector section. [1:05:27] Okay, and this collector section represents the 87.5% likelihood that the road won't live [1:05:34] its entire life. [1:05:36] So with your input, we have an opportunity to reduce that to 75% if you so chose, okay? [1:05:44] Thank you. [1:05:46] Chris talking to Pat. [1:05:47] How does this play in the revisionally updating the standards? [1:05:50] How does this play into the number of streets that we inherited from the county that were [1:05:56] built substandard to about any city standards as I understand, and a number of them have [1:06:02] not been touched the best of my knowledge. [1:06:04] I hear Anna Daudley from people that say, you know, there's used to be county and now [1:06:09] at city. [1:06:11] Have we compiled a hit list of those substandard roads that are in a planet some time to be [1:06:18] upgraded? [1:06:19] We have a list of roads that we are going to seal all the time, and then we try to stretch our overlay [1:06:27] Dollars and reconstruction dollars as far as we can regardless of how we inherited the road [1:06:32] So typically when we're choosing reconstruction projects, we try to choose ones where the roads are really failing and the lows are pretty high [1:06:39] Okay, so regardless of whether or not it's an inheritance from you know a county annexation or not [1:06:47] but it doesn't matter anymore because it's currently in our jurisdiction. [1:06:52] Yeah, but it's not built to the base standards that we build, so just an overlay is not solving the problem, Jack. [1:07:00] Oh, I see what you're saying. Okay, so... [1:07:04] I don't know what the county standards are, but I think they're throwing a spaded dirt down and throwing some asphalt on and calling it a county road. [1:07:13] But often those are getting rebuilt as the development is happening. [1:07:17] When we're attempting to rebuild them to the extent that we can't, [1:07:20] wherever when we can get reconstruction dollars applied to the roadways, [1:07:25] we'll rebuild them or developers are doing that as they're developing next to them. [1:07:31] To the centerline of the road where possible. [1:07:33] So we have not identified those substandard inherited roadways [1:07:37] in the county. [1:07:37] We just didn't counter them as is. [1:07:43] Yeah, that's probably fair. [1:07:45] So the I don't have a focus on how the road came to be substandard. [1:07:50] I just want to know what it really is. [1:07:53] Thank you. [1:07:54] Don't know if I'm asking this question too early, I can certainly wait. [1:07:59] But so are you asking for input from the county or from the council regarding the [1:08:04] 75 versus the 87 or 85% is that what you're asking this evening? [1:08:10] Because to me, 85 is better than 75, right? [1:08:13] 87 and a half is better than 75. [1:08:17] And again, what that all means is that it's built at a stronger base, which is more expensive [1:08:23] to the developer, obviously, than it saves taxpayer dollars later down the road because [1:08:29] once we adopt those roads, they are the city's roads that we have to maintain, correct? [1:08:35] And when we actually do have reconstruction dollars, we'll rebuild them to that spec. [1:08:39] Okay. [1:08:41] So is that one of the questions, or am I jumping ahead? [1:08:44] I'm sorry. [1:08:45] That is one of the questions. [1:08:46] So we've proposed an 87 and 1.5% likelihood of success. [1:08:53] And we didn't hear anything from any of our partners [1:08:58] in this conversation that led us to believe [1:09:00] that there was a compelling reason to go with 75. [1:09:06] So at the end of the evening here, [1:09:11] I would like the Council to support adoption of the ISPWC as proposed. [1:09:15] And I really did not want you to be in a spot where you were surprised about what those numbers were. [1:09:21] Because, you know, it's hidden in this back. [1:09:24] Do you want that input now? [1:09:26] Any times. [1:09:27] I like 87 over 75. [1:09:30] There you go. [1:09:31] Great landing. [1:09:32] And this is going to follow up with Chris's question earlier. [1:09:37] At some point, well, I have been on counseling. [1:09:39] We used to allow the developers to just, on these county roads, [1:09:43] you're tired of my Christmas, we used to allow them to just widen them. [1:09:46] And then we went to the plan where now they have to redo it to the center's line. [1:09:51] And so you didn't end up things that we kind of inherited like Easton. [1:09:55] We allowed them to widen it, but then the middle died. [1:09:58] Because it was built to a different standard. [1:10:01] So by requiring the developers to go to the middle line, [1:10:05] if we get development on both sides sooner or later, we end up with a full new road. [1:10:09] to our specifications. [1:10:11] So I think that was one of the major changes we made [1:10:13] that has helped this, some of these roads [1:10:16] that last longer was we got a rebuild from the developer, [1:10:19] not from us, overlaying and then laying and things. [1:10:23] Oh, and my last question I'll make quick, Tyler, [1:10:26] what kind of a, we're talking about base here, [1:10:29] about 10 inches, do you believe the Tyler has 10 inches, [1:10:32] or was it more than that? [1:10:35] That's your poster chart you used in the last 47 years. [1:10:39] I was just wondering if that had 10 on me or I probably satisfied with 10, or 10-5, you said, would you be the new standard? [1:10:46] I don't have 10 inches. [1:10:57] Okay. Thank you. That was one I wanted to know. [1:11:03] Okay. So we began, so we went through the ISPWC internally as a small engineering group, worked and worked and worked on the ISPWC, [1:11:16] and how it correlated to city spec [1:11:18] and what we needed to have in there. [1:11:20] And then we began to have more conversations. [1:11:23] And there was a tremendous amount of outreach [1:11:26] to public works to find out what people were using contractors. [1:11:30] We actually contacted contractors, paving contractors, [1:11:34] developers, the postmaster, the building community, [1:11:37] the Magic Valley Utility Coordinating Council, [1:11:43] the fire department and you know at the very end Fritz and our goal was to try to make [1:11:49] sure that we had documents that actually reflected what was being done. We wanted people to be [1:11:56] able to comply and we wanted to put everyone in a spot where we could have a successful product [1:12:02] at the lowest possible price point and people were really helpful. The Magic Valley Utility [1:12:11] The coordinating council really helped us on trench patch and got us helped us get to [1:12:15] a spot where we could do flow-able fill and the compactable fill and you know these things [1:12:20] are now incorporated in the city revisions to the spec. [1:12:26] Then we went through an attempt to have a public comment period so people could formally [1:12:30] object you know and we said hey you know if you have if you're really having heartburn [1:12:34] you know say it and then we met in like an informal group so that we could actually [1:12:41] hash through anything that was left and then we had to spend a little bit of time, folks, [1:12:47] because saying that you're going to implement a spec and actually doing it are two different [1:12:52] things. [1:12:53] It's like understanding that there's a math equation and then actually doing the math equation [1:12:58] are two totally different things. [1:13:00] So it took us several weeks to get ourselves through a spot where we understood how we could [1:13:05] do performance payment for asphalt. [1:13:09] payment for asphalt will, what we currently have in place now is that if you don't meet [1:13:16] this back, we don't pay. And that's not always the most reasonable way to get a reasonable [1:13:23] quality product. So we're recommending adopting a process that emulates what kind of what [1:13:30] ITD does except for smaller quantities. And it allows people to use a little bit of statistics [1:13:37] and there to get payment for the payment. [1:13:40] So, payment is placed, you care about standard deviation [1:13:47] in the placement of payment. [1:13:50] And the reason that you care about it is that you want these people [1:13:52] to put the payment down and have the right, the same quality, [1:13:55] all the time, to do the job the same way all the time [1:13:58] so that all of the payment is the same. [1:14:00] And so we're trying to award people based on that. [1:14:05] And they're happy with the idea of getting performance payment. [1:14:09] In fact, they've been on me for years to do this, so, you know, we're here, we've arrived. [1:14:15] We think we have a reasonably good set of specs, and we would like to move forward and implement [1:14:21] them for widespread use, and like now, if possible. [1:14:28] And so we're seeking support from the Council for implementation of the ISPWC and the City [1:14:34] And so that, you know, if you choose to adopt it or choose to support use of it, then we will incorporate the street standards into the transportation master plan as well. [1:14:48] We have all of our planning documents lined up. [1:14:50] So the recommendation tonight is that I would like the city council to support implementation of ISPWC and revisions. [1:14:59] Thank you, Jackie, sounds like you have done a tremendous amount of work with your team [1:15:05] and with lots of folks in the community who actually are engaged in this. [1:15:09] So I don't pretend to be a street engineer ever. [1:15:13] And the community was really awesome. [1:15:16] You know, there's all kinds of people that came out and I think that they really understood [1:15:19] we were just trying to get a good product that was easy to use. [1:15:22] And Josh is in here tonight because he's, you know, on the mitts' nights somewhere, [1:15:26] But some fun place. [1:15:29] But Aaron and Josh spent a huge amount of time [1:15:34] doing all the administrative support [1:15:36] to make this thing work. [1:15:37] So without Josh standing up there saying, OK, [1:15:42] I will take this on as my task until it's done. [1:15:45] And without Aaron working endlessly [1:15:47] on these standard drawings and spec revisions, [1:15:51] we'd still be at it. [1:15:53] Great. [1:15:54] Nicky Boyd. [1:15:56] So the difference, there's a 75% success rate [1:16:02] that it lasts the life cycle, or this 87 and a half percent. [1:16:09] What is the, and the full burden of that [1:16:15] is on the developer putting in the road, correct? [1:16:23] The cost of that, so in. [1:16:25] That's accurate. [1:16:25] Okay. [1:16:26] And on our jobs, the burden is out of our budget. [1:16:30] Correct. [1:16:30] And in all your research, it sounds like you drew from a lot of the community. [1:16:36] Do you feel like you had a really good representation of the developers that are going to be most directly hit by this? [1:16:46] I believe so. So we had two paving contractors. [1:16:50] We had two to three builders and then we had all of our usual development engineering types, [1:17:00] Civil Science, EHM, Rita Cell, JUB, they were present and active in. [1:17:13] So the cost difference between roughly what is that 12% or 11 half or whatever it is? [1:17:20] Okay, 12 and a half percent. Thank you. Everybody was comfortable with spending that extra upfront [1:17:32] was the way to go. That was general consensus. At the end of the conversation, did you have [1:17:42] general consensus? I believe we had consensus. So I did not, well, it's always going to be [1:17:49] what I believe, you know, because they're talking to me. [1:17:52] And what I asked them for was, help me explain why we would have a compelling [1:17:57] reason to use a 75% likelihood of success versus an 87, right? [1:18:03] And why that would be justified as, you know, and that includes cost. [1:18:09] And we never quite got to a place where anybody was volunteering anything [1:18:19] that said, hey, we really need to be at 75%. [1:18:24] And we can explain that to the community. [1:18:26] So the entire, everyone who participated in the development [1:18:30] of this spec was enlisted on the team [1:18:33] for being stewards of the public [1:18:35] for the entire time they were working on it. [1:18:37] So, and they put on their hat, I think. [1:18:41] They certainly didn't provide a written objection [1:18:44] or an end objection to that spec. [1:18:49] I'm just very sensitive to developers bear the burden of a lot of things outside of our [1:19:00] property tax. [1:19:01] They pay the freight for a lot of stuff. [1:19:05] And so I just wanted to make sure that they understood, I think, the 87.5% is great. [1:19:13] I want everything to be better here. [1:19:15] But I'm also sensitive to, it's great for the city because we have more years where [1:19:21] we don't have to take care of that. [1:19:24] But I just hate to put more and more and more things on the developers. [1:19:28] It's insensitive to that. [1:19:31] So we tried to be very clear in what the proposals were. [1:19:37] We also tried to be very clear in not pretending that it was no big deal. [1:19:44] Although their costs are going to be different than ours, [1:19:46] they have different pricing through their negotiations. [1:19:50] But still, it's going to be more money for them. [1:19:54] And we were not in a spot where there were folks indicating [1:20:03] that they really believe that 75% was the appropriate number [1:20:07] for us at the end of the day. [1:20:10] OK, thank you. [1:20:12] Greg Lanting. [1:20:14] Well, Jackie, I appreciate you and your team's efforts on this. [1:20:19] I'm certainly with 87% of the week save taxpayer money down the road. [1:20:24] And I will comment from my time as mayor. [1:20:26] I said it on one of the meetings where Jackie was talking about, [1:20:29] where developers came in and asked that, OK, here's a product that works just as well. [1:20:34] Research shows it works just as well. [1:20:36] But it costs us less money. [1:20:38] Why can't we use that product? [1:20:39] And Jackie, approving that product, we're talking about the plastic pipe. [1:20:43] So Jackie is very cognizant of their costs, [1:20:46] and I think that's why she gets the cooperation she does that. [1:20:49] And she was willing to agree to something [1:20:52] that previous engineers really weren't willing to agree to, [1:20:55] because it was didn't work as well. [1:20:57] That's how I think she gets this consensus. [1:20:59] They realize that, hey, this might going to cost me more, [1:21:02] but Jackie's been willing to work with us on this. [1:21:05] And so in the end run, they get what they need to get done. [1:21:09] We get a better product for our taxpayers [1:21:12] down the road, even the pipe one, it was evident. [1:21:16] And when we end up replacing, [1:21:18] we will be able to replace it with the cheaper pipe as well. [1:21:21] So I'm very confident that 87% is the way to go. [1:21:27] Chris Tockington. [1:21:28] Well, I appreciate Nicki's comments [1:21:30] coming from the development community, [1:21:32] but traditionally my experience has been [1:21:36] that new growth does not often pay for the cost [1:21:40] to the taxpayers who end up paying for additional infrastructure [1:21:45] or upgrade or needs. [1:21:46] This looks like it's an attempt to reach a consensus [1:21:49] with the building community. [1:21:51] If there are discrepancies that show up, [1:21:54] there's always an appeal process [1:21:56] or showing up at the council, [1:21:57] but in mind the council that we have the impact fees [1:22:01] that are paid by developers now, [1:22:03] they're more academically share of the cost of new growth. [1:22:07] So I think this is consistent with the direction [1:22:10] heading. But I think Greg, you brought up the valid point that we're not in the [1:22:16] environment where our engineering department is much more open door and [1:22:22] actually seeking comments and input from the development committee than we've had [1:22:25] in the past. That said, I would, unless Don, you're going to make a comment, I was [1:22:32] going to throw the motion out to have the City of Twin Falls adopt the ISP, WC, [1:22:39] certification standards, is that what it is certification? [1:22:44] Do we need to put the 80s? [1:22:46] Specification standards. [1:22:47] No, and the city of Twin Falls revisions. [1:22:51] Ditto. [1:22:52] Second. [1:22:54] Motion by Chris Doggins and seconded by Don Hall to support the ISP, [1:22:59] WC, and the city of Twin Falls revisions. [1:23:03] Don Hall. [1:23:04] So Jackie, if down the road, a couple years, five years, [1:23:09] whatever, we find that this isn't the right standard plus or minus. [1:23:14] Was the process of coming back and changing it again? [1:23:17] Is that, do we have to jump through all these same groups again? [1:23:21] Let's say that we find that the 87 really was overkill and we should have went with the [1:23:26] 75, or 87 wasn't enough or whatever. [1:23:29] How do we make adjustments? [1:23:33] So this process took a long time because we were adopting an entire specification to go [1:23:37] along with some standards. [1:23:40] When people want to change, they ask for it, [1:23:44] and then we try to gather enough information [1:23:47] to be able to say, you know, this is the same level of service, [1:23:51] higher or lower level of service, for whatever reason, [1:23:54] and then we make a recommendation. [1:23:57] So if we decide that if somebody believes [1:24:02] that we have too high the likelihood of success, [1:24:07] or it's okay to have a different likelihood of success. [1:24:12] And we can certainly talk about that when adopted. [1:24:14] In the same way that we can come back [1:24:16] some later time in the future and say, [1:24:18] you know what, we really thought residential streets [1:24:20] would be fine, but you know, they're not. [1:24:24] And so let's talk about this one. [1:24:27] It'll be the same way. [1:24:28] There'll be different, you know, [1:24:30] same way with plastic pipe when they can all, you know, [1:24:33] it's an opportunity. [1:24:34] I was just trying to illustrate that we can come back and make specific adjustments if [1:24:39] we need to. [1:24:40] And it's not really clear. [1:24:41] It's not totally fast because we want to make sure we're doing this responsibly. [1:24:46] It's possible and it's not going to take forever. [1:24:52] Any other comments or questions for Jackie? [1:24:56] Seeing none, Sharon, roll and call a vote please. [1:24:59] Ruth Pierce? [1:25:00] Yes. [1:25:01] Suzanne Hawkins? [1:25:02] Yes. [1:25:03] Nicky Boyd? [1:25:04] Yes. [1:25:05] John Berrigger? [1:25:06] Yes. [1:25:07] John Hall. [1:25:08] Yes. [1:25:09] Passes 7-0. [1:25:10] Thank you again, Jackie, for all of your work and your team's work on this. [1:25:19] So if there is anyone here who is here for the public hearing on the budget that was published [1:25:25] and not begin any sooner than six o'clock and we'll get there real soon. [1:25:31] Next on the agenda is a request to approve the adoption of a utility rate resolution for [1:25:35] fiscal year 2017 and we have our Chief Financial Officer, Lori Race. [1:25:40] Welcome, Lori. [1:25:46] Good evening. [1:25:47] So this evening, I'd like to request that you adopt our utility rate resolution for fiscal [1:25:53] year 2017. [1:25:56] First of all, none of our rate increases are greater than 5%, so we're not required to [1:26:02] hold a public hearing. [1:26:04] Also, I want to make sure that you understand that the anticipated revenues from these rate [1:26:10] adjustments have been incorporated into the fiscal year 2017 budget that Travis will be [1:26:16] bringing forward in a little bit. [1:26:19] So tonight, I just want to take a few minutes [1:26:21] to review the increases in water, sewer, and sanitation. [1:26:30] So in the water fund, we're requesting a half percent [1:26:34] increase in all but the arsenic compliance portion [1:26:37] of the fee. [1:26:39] This increase is in line with the municipal cost index, [1:26:43] which was 0.44% for this budget cycle. [1:26:47] As you'll recall, the Municipal Cost Index [1:26:50] is designed to show the effects of inflation [1:26:53] on the cost of providing municipal services. [1:26:58] The arsenic fee, which is the flat amount of this fee, [1:27:02] has no requested change. [1:27:04] And that causes the overall increase [1:27:06] to be less than the half percent requested, [1:27:09] as you can see in this table. [1:27:12] The table shows various samples of bills [1:27:15] and how the increase will affect consumers [1:27:18] at those various levels. [1:27:20] I've highlighted the 18,000 gallons used [1:27:23] because this is representative of our average customer. [1:27:27] And for this example, the estimated monthly increase [1:27:30] is 19 cents, making the annual increase $2.28 cents. [1:27:39] Now in the sewer fund, we're requesting a 5% increase. [1:27:44] And with the municipal cost index at 0.44%, [1:27:48] 0.44% while we are re-requesting 5% what's simple. [1:27:53] According to our bond covenant requirement, we have to maintain a debt ratio coverage of [1:27:58] 125%. [1:28:01] If at any time during the year it appears that we're going to fall below that, we must [1:28:07] immediately raise rates to ensure this level of coverage. [1:28:11] So that 5% increase is projected to produce some surplus dollars in that fund this year. [1:28:19] But based on revenues, less the operating expenditures, [1:28:25] we have to have a 5% increase to ensure that 125% target ratio. [1:28:32] With the current 8000 gallon cap on residential customer usage, [1:28:36] The largest increase our customers would be paying is $1.24 per month or almost $15 a year. [1:28:46] In the sanitation fund, we simply pass along the amount being charged by our service provider to our customers. [1:28:53] So PSI originally had estimated a 1.5 to a 2.5% increase in fees for next year. [1:28:59] But they've agreed to that lower end as they work through the logistics of providing some additional cart sizes and recycle service options. [1:29:08] The tipping fee at the landfill has increased from $35.50 per ton to $37.50 per ton. [1:29:16] And this additional cost, coupled with the increase from PSI, results in the 2.3% increase [1:29:22] we're requesting in the sanitation rate. [1:29:25] This fund is nothing more than dollars in and dollars out. [1:29:28] We have no capital expenses and no need for accumulated reserves. [1:29:33] The 2.3% adjustment will result in a monthly increase of $0.38. [1:29:43] And finally, this table shows the overall effect of all the increases for water, sewer, and sanitation [1:29:49] for those various sample billings. [1:29:52] And again, I've highlighted the average customer usage of 18,000 gallons. [1:29:57] And you can see the monthly increase ranges from $1.62 to $2.08 for these examples. [1:30:04] the rate increase in total is between 1.4% and a little over 2%. All of these rate increases [1:30:13] have been incorporated into the city manager's recommended budget for fiscal year 2017. We [1:30:19] are asking that you approve these increases and adopt the utility rate resolution this [1:30:24] evening. With that, I'd be happy to answer any questions. [1:30:28] Any questions for, sorry, Chris talking to me. [1:30:32] The solid waste district is increasing their fees 6% this year. [1:30:37] Yeah, about 5.6%. [1:30:38] 5.6, okay. [1:30:40] Thank you. [1:30:43] Laurie, question on pressure irrigation, so does that water increase also apply to the [1:30:51] pressure irrigation rate? [1:30:52] Yes, it does. [1:30:53] Thank you. [1:30:56] Any other questions for Laurie? [1:30:57] I see. [1:30:59] I would entertain the motion. [1:31:01] Greg Lant. [1:31:02] Mayor, I move that we accept the adopt the utility rate resolution for [1:31:10] physical year 2017 as outlined by our CFO Lori race. [1:31:15] Second. [1:31:16] Motion by Gray-Lanting, seconded by Suzanne Hawkins to adopt the utility rate resolution for fiscal [1:31:24] year 2017. [1:31:25] Any further discussion from the council? [1:31:27] Chris Stock. [1:31:28] I'm voting in favor of it, but I would hope this next year that we could end in the sanitation [1:31:33] transportation category, un-lived at dumping, as well as on of those people who are the very limited one can [1:31:43] nominal waste [1:31:45] contributors to our system. I think [1:31:47] one size does not fit all on sanitation and [1:31:51] hope we can work toward us some more equitability, including people not putting church pews and [1:31:57] Automotive parts out for us to have good [1:31:59] Thank you. Seeing no other discussion. [1:32:05] Share and roll call vote please. [1:32:07] Suzanne Hawkins. Yes. [1:32:09] Nikki Boyd. Yes. [1:32:11] John Bericard. Yes. [1:32:12] Chris Tockington. Yes. [1:32:14] Greg Lantine. Yes. [1:32:15] Don Hall. Yes. [1:32:16] Ray Pierce. Yes. [1:32:18] Passes 7-2-0. [1:32:20] Travis, would you like to hold the additional information from the manager and the council [1:32:26] till after the public hearing? [1:32:27] It's been sure standing out for the public hearing now. [1:32:31] But we still have. I know. [1:32:32] I made on the agenda. [1:32:33] I was just getting ready to go, whatever you want to do, Mr. Mayor. [1:32:37] Okay. [1:32:38] We'll slide that after we'll do the budget. [1:32:41] So next on the agenda is a public hearing regarding the adoption of the fiscal year 2017 budget and the associated annual appropriations ordinance for the city of Twin Falls. [1:32:50] We have our city manager, Travis Rothliver. [1:32:53] Welcome, Travis. [1:32:54] Thank you, Mr. Mayor and members of the council. [1:32:58] What we can do is in the event that, as I shared with you, [1:33:02] we'll go through the presentation. [1:33:05] We'll ask the council for those series of options. [1:33:08] There may need to be some prep time for staff [1:33:11] to be able to compile that ordinance after the public hearing, [1:33:15] based upon public input and direction that you provide. [1:33:18] And so that might be a good opportunity [1:33:20] to engage that public input section on the general stuff [1:33:23] that was left off the agenda. [1:33:24] Or we can do that now, whatever you would prefer. [1:33:27] That's perfect. [1:33:28] Thank you. [1:33:29] So tonight is kind of like the completion of our journey, [1:33:36] a journey that started for us about nine months ago. [1:33:42] And I relate this to kind of like my Iron Man training, [1:33:49] that as you kind of work through the budget, [1:33:52] sometimes you have what they're off to refer to [1:33:56] is dark moments, right? [1:33:57] Those moments that you're trying to work through [1:34:00] and find balance and find struggle. [1:34:03] And when you get to this point, if this is race day, [1:34:07] this is really a celebration of the accomplishment [1:34:10] that caused you and allowed you to get here. [1:34:14] And this isn't a sense of celebration of the many, [1:34:18] many hours that are put on behind the scenes [1:34:22] by members of our team to put together a balanced budget. [1:34:26] So for the last 11 weeks, Brian, Mitch, and I have had the [1:34:33] opportunity to stand before you and talk about different [1:34:36] parts of the budget. [1:34:38] But in all reality, there have been many, many [1:34:43] inputters to this process that started with our long-term [1:34:46] planning group who met and vetted for many, many weeks [1:34:52] to put together the best proposal that they said fit and connected to our strategic plan. [1:35:00] It then went to the city's core department leadership team where we discussed and we bet that it [1:35:07] we brought it back to you in which we continue to discuss and to vet. And tonight really is the end [1:35:14] of that journey where we can take just a moment of pause to celebrate because we will begin this process [1:35:21] again in November. We will begin our training again. And one of the questions I was asked [1:35:26] earlier today is it seems like you guys are always in a perpetual state of budgeting. And [1:35:32] I think that that's true because of how serious we take this role and responsibility. The fiduciary [1:35:39] responsibility that we have to allocate funds is probably one of the most important things [1:35:43] that we have and it's the fastest way to erode public trust. So we take great pride in what [1:35:48] we're doing it so to all the members of the team I say thank you and to the [1:35:52] council who is one last final journey the climb thank you for all my [1:36:00] sure hope so but here here we go and I have a lot of slides in the [1:36:07] presentation because you never know who's going to show up on the final [1:36:11] evening and want to be caught up and brought up to speed and so this is the [1:36:15] balance of the presentation and but I'm gonna kind of go through these [1:36:18] relatively quickly. So again, as we started having those initial conversations, we said [1:36:24] that the center focus of all of the efforts that we do in public service really starts [1:36:29] with our people, and the budget that I have presented to you is focused on our internal [1:36:33] organization, Focus Area 8, where we're looking at making sure that our compensation levels, [1:36:39] our training levels, our engagement levels, our ability to continue to drive towards one [1:36:43] City are fully funded and I think last week was a really good illustration of the success [1:36:49] that One City is having in our organization and that group did an absolute dynamite job [1:36:55] in sharing with you what I probably couldn't and that is real stories from the ground of [1:37:01] people who are making this cultural change possible inside of our organization. [1:37:09] We have shared from the entire beginning, what is the impact of this budget on our citizens. [1:37:15] Laurie did a great job going through the rates. [1:37:18] We illustrate that the increase of those rates are $1.81 to the average resident that we defined [1:37:26] who has that solid waste and recycling service, who has 8,000 gallons of sewer and uses 18,000 [1:37:34] gallons of water. [1:37:35] And then we also illustrate the property to actually impact based upon the median value [1:37:40] of the house, which in 2015 was 144,000 and in 2016 is projected to be 142,600. [1:37:49] Both of that, all that information comes from the United States Department of Census Bureau [1:37:56] that produces that information that we review that. [1:38:00] One of the interesting things is if you take a look at the overall health of a community, [1:38:05] One place to look is the total taxable value, you notice again, our total taxable value [1:38:11] won up by $50.5 million. [1:38:16] And that is after $67 million of new construction value. [1:38:21] So without that new construction value, all existing properties within the city of Twin [1:38:25] Falls depreciated by about $16.6 million. [1:38:30] It's important to remember that property taxes in Idaho are we're looking, as opposed to forward looking. [1:38:36] And so this actually might reflect the place that Twin Falls was 18 months to two years ago. [1:38:42] And so as we continue to grow, we'll see hopefully continued increases in the areas of new construction and [1:38:49] continued growth in the overall taxable value of existing structures. [1:38:54] The tax rate is an important piece because what it does is it helps us understand what the tax rate is for the individual citizens. [1:39:02] You'll notice here that the tax rate is still yet to be undefined because we have that question of are we going to allocate any or all of the portion of funds that came as a result of our underestimating the new construction number. [1:39:17] But the range of the possible increases of the tax rate range from $8.03 to $8.16 per $1000 of taxable value. [1:39:25] As we've tried to share in every point along the way, the tax rate is a multiplier and it is not an indicator of individual tax loads. [1:39:34] And we'll kind of illustrate that again this evening. [1:39:37] One of the primary factors in that is the homeowner's exemption. [1:39:41] We've included this chart again to reflect how the homeowners exemption has in the past [1:39:48] tied to the housing index. [1:39:52] And you can see that it is growing to $94,745 for this upcoming tax year. [1:39:59] It was at one time a high of $104,471, but as a result of action taken by the Idaho legislature, [1:40:08] The next home winners' exemption will be 50% or $100,000, whichever is less. [1:40:15] And so the legislature has made the decision to remove this from the indexing and [1:40:20] then take it more of a flat rate, at least for what we will be under as fiscal year 18 when we start those conversations. [1:40:30] This is an illustration of how we compared in the past, and [1:40:34] You can see that the City of Twin Falls is right in the middle of the major cities in Idaho, [1:40:41] but you'll also notice that there are two cities that have been left off of this chart, and [1:40:45] that's Boise and Meridian. [1:40:47] We keep them off this chart just as a reminder because the Ada County Highway District is a [1:40:52] separate taxing entity, and streets is such a significant component of what we do. [1:40:57] So including them here would not be a fair apples to apples comparison as it is with the [1:41:04] other cities. These are full service cities inside of the state of Idaho and we all offer [1:41:08] a similar collection of services. So tonight one of the things that we're going to ask [1:41:17] you is what to do with the nearly $287,000 that was a result of not only our conservative [1:41:24] budgeting as we're waiting for the new construction but our surprise of what occurred with the [1:41:28] new construction value. This kind of illustrates again what happens to that tax rate depending [1:41:36] depending upon which, if any, portion of that you would elect to take this evening. [1:41:43] Just as a quick recap, again, the average of $144,000 home, [1:41:49] that has a $72,000 home owner's exemption, because they're allowed to take 50% [1:41:55] in the prior tax year, would have been assessed $56.56 in total city property taxes. [1:42:03] That house that decreased to $142,600, [1:42:09] their homeowner's exemption decreased [1:42:11] because they can only take the maximum of 50%, [1:42:13] so that decreased to $71,300. [1:42:17] And you can see what occurs to the different amounts [1:42:21] that this individual would pay [1:42:22] in the form of property taxes [1:42:24] under the different scenarios that are before you. [1:42:27] What's important is the city, again, [1:42:28] the city of Flint Falls does not set the homeowner's exemption, [1:42:32] that is done for us by the Idaho Tax Commission and the state legislature through legislative [1:42:36] action. What is interesting, and I think that illustrates, it is then when you move up to [1:42:41] a $200,000 house and you take a look at the impact of the homeowner's exemption and what [1:42:47] occurs with applying the tax rate. So you can see that a house that's $200,000 in taxable [1:42:53] value last year enjoyed an $89,580 total homeowner's exemption. They qualified for the [1:43:01] maximum, and that same house would qualify for the maximum this year, and so you can [1:43:05] notice that it's slightly less than a $5,000 total tax difference, and that $5,000 [1:43:11] taxable difference illustrates that this person, regardless of those options, would [1:43:17] pay less in total property taxes under any of the tax rate scenarios that we [1:43:22] have illustrated to you. The total spending in this budget this year is $63,958 [1:43:31] And that is going to be when you take a look at all funds, we often talk about net funds. [1:43:40] And so when you look at the net budget is $60,958, that's the number that we talked about. [1:43:46] But when you include transfers going from those enterprise funds or [1:43:52] those small businesses like the water and the sewer and you transfer those operating expenses, [1:43:57] that's how and what the difference that you see. [1:44:00] We've been focusing on the $60.9 million all along, and that is very appropriate according [1:44:06] to GFOA standards. [1:44:08] We've talked about what we're looking at, and that's a 5% pay adjustment, a 5% table movement, [1:44:14] and covering health care increases when it comes to personnel costs. [1:44:17] We're also looking at adding only one new FTE in this budget. [1:44:22] We've asked for a second as a result of the conversations with the additional funds, but [1:44:27] and the budget that was submitted to you on July 11th [1:44:29] for your first review and conversation, [1:44:31] it only included the one operator position. [1:44:36] And so our total personnel count is 289.38 people [1:44:40] inside the City of Twin Falls. [1:44:42] You can see that that reflects fairly modest growth [1:44:47] in the total number of employee count. [1:44:48] You'll notice that's just up one. [1:44:51] And if you compare the City of Twin Falls total FTEs [1:44:54] to other communities our size, [1:44:56] you will see that we are very, very lean as an organization, [1:45:00] and that does not include the commuter population [1:45:04] that we have in our organization [1:45:06] that comes into our community on a daily basis. [1:45:10] Our operations, you'll notice that are very, very close [1:45:12] to the past year. [1:45:13] In fact, they're at 0.92%. [1:45:16] It's $148,000 increase operational cost across all funds. [1:45:21] And then if you take a look at the capital funding, [1:45:23] the capital funding is slightly down from the last year. [1:45:27] The single largest reason of that is last year, or in this current fiscal year, we're [1:45:31] using about $3.1 million of cash reserves in the Water Fund to fund the Will's booster [1:45:36] station. [1:45:37] And so this relies on a lot less cash reserves than we used in the past to complete one-time [1:45:43] capital operations. [1:45:44] And Will's expenditure is I going to cover it? [1:45:48] Yes. [1:45:49] Okay. [1:45:50] Yeah, we're not anticipating any additional need for resources to complete that project. [1:45:54] Okay. [1:45:56] And time as prior to your discussion of this and adopting the resolution that covered the [1:46:07] utility rates, and so those were covered in here. [1:46:10] The Water Fund, again, is looking at having about a 22.7% reduction, and again, that's [1:46:17] largely resulted in the Capital Project. [1:46:20] The Sewer Fund, again, we're looking at the rate adjustment largely to ensure that we're [1:46:24] We're meeting the one-to-one 25 coverage ratios associated with the debt and then the sanitation [1:46:30] fund, as Lori said, is really a pass-through account where everything is operated by private [1:46:37] contractors and it's dollars in dollars out with a very small amount taken to assist with [1:46:41] utility billing. [1:46:44] So this is where we left off last week. [1:46:49] The items in yellow reflect the items that were recommended to me for approval by department [1:46:59] leaders as well as the long-term planning committee. [1:47:05] As in an effort to find the resources to advance the priorities that we've spent the last 11, [1:47:12] 12 weeks talking about, those items were removed. [1:47:17] Again, and as I have shared, had we come closer to our estimate on the new construction, you [1:47:25] would have seen some of these other items included in particular the victim witness coordinator. [1:47:32] You'll also notice some items in white, those item in white are a result of decisions that [1:47:40] I made, namely in the reduction of travel and training, $75,000 across all of those funds [1:47:46] in an effort to present to you a balanced budget [1:47:50] that met the initial goals that we had established. [1:47:53] And then we are obviously still having conversations [1:47:57] with the YMCA and we're still determining [1:48:00] what is going to be the future operational status of that. [1:48:04] We have placed money in there in the event [1:48:07] that it is needed as an option. [1:48:09] We've also included money for possible mid-year compensation [1:48:13] adjustments we spent time talking last week [1:48:15] about how we are going through a BDPA review of all of our positions inside of our organization. [1:48:21] The $150,000 really is a guesstimate, but what it is is it's a start to move forward [1:48:28] to assist any mid-year opportunities in not having to wait until October 1st of 2017. [1:48:37] So with that, we're happy to answer any questions that you might have that you move forward. [1:48:44] I'd like to provide just one anecdotal story for the council about the mid-year compensation. [1:48:54] I was rather shocked by this, but been visiting with a lot of people in their own neighborhoods [1:49:01] lately. [1:49:02] It came across the placement currently on our payroll, who is leaving the city of Twin Falls [1:49:09] employment. [1:49:10] They love the town. [1:49:12] I think they have children. [1:49:14] But they have been offered a job in Twin Falls or outside of Twin Falls, excuse me, for $10 an hour or more, which is almost 21,000 a year. [1:49:25] We are sorely out of our league of retaining our uniforms and we have to close that gap. [1:49:33] I think we made a conscientious effort, but it is not over by any means. [1:49:38] Any other comments from the Council at this time? [1:49:45] I would just reiterate my view about the victim witness coordinator. [1:49:53] The rest of it is negotiable to me. [1:49:55] To me personally, that is not negotiable. [1:49:58] I think that is a needed position in our community to help our community. [1:50:04] It's something that we used to have. [1:50:07] When I was working for the police department, we had a victim witness coordinator. [1:50:11] I saw the results of that, better help with our victims and with their families and insight [1:50:23] on how to get them help and weave their way through the complex judicial system. [1:50:29] I can't overstate how important that position is to fill again and I'm just not going to [1:50:38] rely on that one personally. [1:50:44] So a comment I would make is, I agree I think the victim witness coordinator for all the reasons [1:50:50] that Don just stated as a valid request. [1:50:55] My question or maybe comment is, so with the known unknown of the pool operations, so some [1:51:05] of these things are just totally unknown, but we know we might have an unknown there. [1:51:10] I don't wonder if it's prudent to plug those funds [1:51:14] into the budget, perhaps in the Parks and Recreation Department. [1:51:21] And as we move forward with determining [1:51:25] whether we may be re-assuming those operations that if those funds [1:51:30] aren't needed for pool operations, they certainly [1:51:32] could be reallocated to restrooms or some [1:51:36] of these other parks, projects, Travis. [1:51:39] So our internal policy is that whenever the Council allocates money for a specific purpose, [1:51:45] and that purpose no longer exists or changes, we come back to the Council and ask how those [1:51:51] funds could be recommitted or reallocated. [1:51:54] So if you were to reserve $180,000 that we are recommending in the event that the city [1:52:00] were to assume pool operations, and that did not materialize, we would have $180,000 that [1:52:06] we would come back to the council and say how would you like to see that expanded on a series [1:52:14] of maybe these projects or other issues that just aren't even contemplated. The question [1:52:20] tonight is do you want to collect the money? And after that, once you've collected it, you [1:52:27] have the opportunities to move property tax dollars in the capital fund. And we would [1:52:34] a staff make a commitment to you that if in the event that we do not assume pool operations [1:52:41] that we would come back and engage the council and the community on the best way to spend that [1:52:46] $180,000. [1:52:47] So, do you need from us tonight how we want that money spent or do you? [1:52:54] I hate that this evening. [1:52:56] What we need from you tonight is the amount of property tax dollars that you intend to [1:53:03] ask for collection. That is what we need to do to complete the L2 form by the dates and [1:53:10] time. And these are property tax dollars in question. And so rather than, I mean, you [1:53:16] could simply say, we want to take the victim witness coordinator, the pool operations. And [1:53:22] one of the things I just noticed that we did not talk about, and I apologize we should [1:53:27] include that on the list was the council had asked us to include the $22,000 to place [1:53:34] them to the art fund and so if you add those three together I think you get pretty close [1:53:40] to $278 somewhere in there or if you just said you know we wanted to collect the statutory [1:53:48] allowance as allowed and part of that is to fund a victim witness coordinator and the balance [1:53:54] has to be determined, you know, with the mind that, you know, some of these things, that would [1:54:01] be an appropriate conversation for them. [1:54:04] Thank you. [1:54:05] Chris Stockant. [1:54:06] Well, Council is obviously made up as mine, I'm a victim witness, a coordinator. [1:54:11] I will not be voting for it. [1:54:13] It's unprecedented to fund the ongoing employment that is going to all begadis for future years [1:54:20] with one-time money. [1:54:22] So we're in essence raising property taxes [1:54:25] for the next years. [1:54:27] Having worked 13 years in Jovey with judges [1:54:30] and place officers city and county, [1:54:33] this position is not explained to the council. [1:54:35] It does not explain the position of the court of point, [1:54:39] as special advocate, CASA. [1:54:43] It does not explain what we should [1:54:45] and could be doing cooperating with the county [1:54:47] on funding for such a position. [1:54:50] And there's a great deal of use in the past at least with court-mandated victim of vendor [1:54:57] mediations. [1:54:58] We have not explored that. [1:55:00] I think this victim witness, a coordinator may be a position, but I would fund it after [1:55:05] considering it for next year, not in reaction to what has happened at Fonbrook. [1:55:11] The only fund that I will be voting for tonight would be the 180,000 approximately for the [1:55:20] reserve of the pool operations, if needed. [1:55:23] Craigland. [1:55:25] Travis, Craig, me and Ryan, something Chris said isn't what I really. [1:55:31] If we approve this whole $287,000, that is continuing money. [1:55:35] That is not one-time money, correct? [1:55:38] Yes, it is. [1:55:41] So it's property tax dollars, and so it's not like you're using cash reserves. [1:55:46] But so if you follow the every year you aren't hoped to collect that, it is not. [1:55:52] money that always goes in, but the Council does reserve the right not to collect and [1:55:56] levy the same amount of property taxes, but that would take an action and a [1:56:00] decision not to collect for you not to bring in those monies and subsequently. [1:56:04] Right, so in other words, if we collected this year, we will collect it every year unless [1:56:09] we say we don't want to collect. That's correct. I just want to clarify, Chris [1:56:19] said that it's in reaction to the fawnbrook. That is not why I am so in [1:56:24] that's one of the reasons I'm in support of this. [1:56:27] It's the other victims, we have plenty of victims [1:56:31] in this community because we have crime, [1:56:33] just like any other community. [1:56:37] We have those that would take advantage of others. [1:56:40] And this is an opportunity to help those [1:56:43] that have been taken advantage of, [1:56:44] including the Fonberg incident, but not solely on that. [1:56:49] Mr. Mayor, Mayor's Council Chief Kingsbury is obviously in the audience. [1:56:56] If it would be helpful for the other members of the Council, I could have him share his stance on the position. [1:57:05] I'd appreciate it. [1:57:06] Yes. [1:57:07] Excuse me, I need to get away. [1:57:11] Good evening, Mayor and Council. Welcome, Chief. [1:57:16] Thank you, Travis, for this opportunity. [1:57:20] You know, victim witness coordinators are a very [1:57:24] integral part of the service that we and law enforcement provide. [1:57:29] And as you know, you hired me to start January 1st of this year [1:57:34] to be the Chief of Police of this fine city. [1:57:37] And one of the areas that I identified very early on as an area [1:57:43] of weakness within the police department was the non-enforcement [1:57:51] services that we do not provide to victims. I assure you that I had these conversations [1:57:57] well before the aforementioned incident occurred with both Mr. Pike and Mr. Rothwether as well [1:58:05] as my command staff. When we talk about what will the role of the victim witness, coordinator [1:58:13] be within the police department, that role is primarily taken on prior to the actual prosecution. [1:58:21] So, Councilman talking to you, when you talk about CASA and you talk about utilizing the [1:58:27] victim which coordinators with the Twin Falls County prosecuting attorney's office, they don't [1:58:33] come into play until after the case has been filed. [1:58:38] And all too often what we miss is those important few days. [1:58:42] And that's where the victims and the services fall through the cracks. [1:58:48] I did come from an agency that utilized victim witness coordinators and utilized them quite [1:58:52] well. [1:58:54] One of the areas that I really think we could improve our utilization of victim witness coordination [1:59:00] has to do with domestic violence cases. [1:59:02] And when we look at our domestic violence cases, I'd like to just go over some numbers [1:59:05] here that I have put together. [1:59:07] In the year 2012, the Twin Falls Police Department took 177 domestic violence reports. [1:59:14] In the year 2013, we took 174. [1:59:19] In 2014, 195, and in 2015, 204 domestic violence reports were filed through the Twin Falls [1:59:28] Police Department. [1:59:29] Some of those reports resulted in arrest for felony crimes, some for misdemeanor crimes, [1:59:35] and some obviously didn't result in an actual prosecution. [1:59:39] A few of those obviously didn't raise to that level. [1:59:44] And if I look at those victims, if we just go back to 2015 and we look at the 204 reports [1:59:50] that were filed, especially in the misdemeanor area, because in the misdemeanor area of those [1:59:57] reports, and I apologize, I don't have to actually break down, but I assure you that way more [2:00:03] than 50% of those reports are going to be misdemeanor reports. [2:00:07] In domestic violence, the law states that if there is something such a strangulation or [2:00:12] other great bodily harm that constitutes a [2:00:15] felonious crime. [2:00:16] However, all other battery and battery quite [2:00:19] simply is illegal touching. [2:00:21] But all other battery of an intimate partner, if you will, [2:00:25] domestic partner is domestic battery by code. [2:00:31] And as the chief of police, I fear that we're not reaching [2:00:34] those victims to the extent that we need to be able to reach [2:00:37] those victims. [2:00:39] In fact, I was in a discussion with staff today at the [2:00:42] Police Department about, hopefully if this goes through, even being able to utilize some [2:00:49] folks in a volunteer level to even look at listening to things such as jail phone calls [2:00:54] that offenders make and help us to enhance the prosecution of those, especially on the [2:00:59] misdemeanor level. [2:01:00] So when we just look at domestic violence and we look at 2015 where we had 200 such reports, [2:01:07] 1995 reports in 2014 and we think well that's that's just one victim I will also tell you [2:01:14] that it's not because oftentimes our victims of domestic violence include the children and [2:01:20] the victim witness coordinators that I've worked with in the past are very very good [2:01:25] at making sure the services are rendered not just for the victim who most often is a [2:01:30] female but not always but not just for the victim but also for the other victims those [2:01:36] ancillary victims that maybe we don't think about, and that's the children. [2:01:40] And so, Council, I would just ask you to think about that and know that I did not come to [2:01:46] Travis for this as a knee-jerk reaction to one incident, but rather just as an overall [2:01:51] evaluation as to how we can better improve our service to our community. [2:01:56] I can also tell you that we have handled well over 40 Ludilous Civius cases in the year [2:02:02] 2016 thus far. And I worry about that gap from the time that a report is made to that time that [2:02:12] prosecution takes place. Yes, the Twin Falls County Sheriff's Office does have a victim [2:02:17] witness coordinator that we can utilize it. And she is wonderful. She does a nice job. But [2:02:22] she has a full time job with the Sheriff's Office. And actually, the victim witness part [2:02:27] of her job is only, as I understand it, 50% of her job. She also acts as the public information [2:02:32] officer for the sheriff's office. [2:02:35] So once she is available, she is very helpful, and we utilize her as much as we can. [2:02:42] But I fear, as has been mentioned, from the dias that we may have some victims, in fact [2:02:48] many victims falling through the cracks, and we have a great police department, we have [2:02:52] a great community. [2:02:54] I just want to make sure that we're doing everything that we can for all victims of [2:02:57] crime, and specifically this violent crime. [2:03:01] I would stand for any questions. [2:03:03] Thank you, Chief. [2:03:04] Suzanne, do you have a comment specific to this? [2:03:06] I do not. [2:03:07] Okay. [2:03:08] My question is different. [2:03:09] Okay. [2:03:10] Christoff. [2:03:11] If not enough, when the victim witness coordinator is hired, what education training requirements [2:03:18] will you job of delta job description around Chief? [2:03:22] Have that in here if you give me half a second. [2:03:47] Primarily, Mayor and Council, when we look at this, we need to look for somebody that [2:03:54] that is, first of all, probably not a police officer, okay? [2:04:02] As I mentioned, our officers are very good at enforcing the law and taking those reports, [2:04:07] and being empathetic and sympathetic to the victims. [2:04:11] I haven't actually sat down with human resources and drawn out the actual job description, [2:04:16] but I would tell you that it would be, and I know that there's some in the back here, [2:04:21] that if during the conversation with Mr. Rothwether and Mr. Feig and Ms. Harris, I would look [2:04:27] for somebody that has a bachelor's degree or some similar educational experience to that, [2:04:33] whether it be in criminal justice or whether it be in counseling. [2:04:38] We want somebody that can display, that has a knowledge of how the courtroom is going to [2:04:44] work. [2:04:45] We want somebody that can explain to a victim and a victim's family what to expect next while [2:04:50] at the same time being able to take a victim and explain to them how to fill out paperwork [2:04:56] for a no-contact order or excuse me a civil protection order, the no-contact order is [2:05:01] done at the jail, but the civil protection order. [2:05:04] How to work with members of the police department to develop a safety plan, even if that means [2:05:09] an immediate action response plan to their residents. [2:05:13] You know, I was talking to Captain Hicks today and I asked him if, at Twin Falls PD, [2:05:19] If we have ever done safety assessments of victims' homes, and specifically victims of [2:05:25] domestic violence situations, and drawn out a floor plan and a response plan, generally [2:05:32] with the tactical team and his responses, we haven't done that. [2:05:36] And that is something I would like to see our victim witness coordinators do to work with [2:05:41] our victims to get alarm, such as an aware alarm, something like that. [2:05:45] That's a personal body alarm that victims can wear, but if the offender shows up, [2:05:50] generally it's a pendant and they pull the alarm. [2:05:53] It's similar to the iPhone and I can't get up alarms, if you will. [2:05:57] And generally, these types of alarms run through different monitoring companies, [2:06:01] and then we at the police department are able to respond, and we already have a plan. [2:06:06] We know where the address is at that. [2:06:07] So if dispatch sees that address come up, they know this is the place where we've had problems. [2:06:13] So, sir, to get to your question, I would look for somebody with a bachelor's degree, [2:06:18] probably in criminal justice or counseling of some sort, psychology, something on those [2:06:22] lines, but also with a background in the criminal justice system, an understanding of the court [2:06:28] system. [2:06:29] I think most importantly, it will be looking for the right person. [2:06:32] It needs to be somebody that really has the right fit for this job because it won't be [2:06:37] an easy job. [2:06:38] I will tell you that in my experience is probably the second hardest job in law enforcement, the first being the dispatcher, but I believe this would be the second hardest. [2:06:46] Thank you. [2:06:47] That was a reassuring answer. [2:06:49] Suzanne Hawkins. [2:06:52] Thank you. [2:06:53] Chief, thank you very much for that information. [2:06:55] I'm very supportive of that position, but I believe tonight we just need to decide on 1%, 2% and 3%, and then we don't have to tell you to take that victim witness coordinator tonight. [2:07:09] coordinator tonight. Is that correct? We're asking you to do. Yes, we're asking you to [2:07:16] to the degree in which you can assign the priorities. We are asking you to do that this evening. [2:07:24] On those things that may be still in question or to be some level of uncertainty, that's [2:07:30] when we would come back and ask. And again, for the record and as I've stated in the [2:07:34] past, the decision to remove the victim witness coordinator rests with me. Right. And that [2:07:39] That was my decision as I was creating a balanced budget, the long-term planning team, advocated [2:07:45] for that role, the chief advocated for that role, and when we were sifting through the [2:07:51] priorities of the organization, that one just didn't rise to the top. [2:07:57] But again, it was really close there and had the new construction estimate been closer [2:08:08] And when we're looking at the estimates, and again, those are all, these are all things I take responsibility for, [2:08:14] then that position would have been included. [2:08:17] I just wanted to make sure I understood on what exactly you made it from us tonight. [2:08:21] Yeah. [2:08:22] Okay. Thank you. Greg Land. [2:08:24] I want to take a stab at the motion just so we get the ball rolling. [2:08:27] It may not be, it might not fly, but. [2:08:29] It's probably a public hearing. [2:08:31] Oh, sorry. [2:08:32] Well, we don't, we have to settle this before the public hearing. [2:08:35] I'm talking about a motion on which items to include in the budget. [2:08:39] Not a matter of the total budget. [2:08:42] I'm going to make a motion that we include the victim witness coordinator and then I'll speak to the Y on the next two. [2:08:52] And then the other I would split evenly between the reserve pool operations if needed and also the possible, which also means if needed. [2:09:02] year compensation adjustments to the full amount of $287,000 or the full 3% [2:09:10] yes I am. The motion on the floor is there a second? What is the motion? I was [2:09:24] gonna take the 64,000 for the victim, victim, boy, I'm gonna trouble that one. [2:09:29] Witness, we're gonna go here and then split the other two for the remainder of [2:09:35] amount or major amounts. So I'm going to say that guys for lack of a second. Okay, [2:09:44] so we would ask is when you're looking at the the reserve for the pool operations, [2:09:55] we ask that you not reduce that from $180,000. We're asking that based upon [2:10:02] the research that we've done in the amount that we believe that it would take for [2:10:06] us to migrate slowly into a pool operations strategy that we believe it would take in [2:10:16] first year of about $180,000. And that is to provide some level of safe landing for existing [2:10:23] patrons for the YMCA and also review of past overall expenditures at the pool based upon [2:10:31] the last time we operated, which was 2000, 2000 end line. [2:10:36] Root peers. [2:10:37] And Travis, I want to clarify that [2:10:41] is in addition to what we're already funding correct. [2:10:43] That is correct. [2:10:44] So the entire amount that we would set aside, [2:10:49] if you included the $180,000, would be this $180,000, [2:10:54] plus the $120,000 that we've already [2:10:58] have year marked into the budget for pool operations, [2:11:01] which would be $300,000 in the first year. [2:11:05] We're taking a very conservative approach to make sure [2:11:08] that we're able to fund those operations [2:11:10] and any piece of that funding that is not needed. [2:11:13] We would be able to return back to the tax-supported funds [2:11:17] because the pool is going to operate as an enterprise fund. [2:11:21] Don Hall. [2:11:22] I'll take your stab at making the motion [2:11:25] that we fund the victim witness coordinator [2:11:28] in the full amount of $64,000. [2:11:30] And then put aside the 180,000 towards the reserve [2:11:37] for the pull operation. [2:11:39] If that doesn't come to fruition that we need it, [2:11:42] I would then back down to the restrooms at the city park. [2:11:47] And whatever is remaining, go into replenish the arts, [2:11:53] the 22,000. [2:11:54] I don't think there's gonna be 22,000. [2:11:56] 43,000 flows. [2:11:57] Yeah. [2:11:58] 43,000. [2:11:59] three thousand after all that left over then let's replace the arts motion by Don [2:12:10] Hall to fund the victim witness coordinator the pool reserve and if [2:12:19] that's not needed then the restrooms at the park and the balance which would be [2:12:23] thirty three thousand or forty three thousand dollars depending on which of [2:12:26] those two projects it was into the public art fund they're gonna say that [2:12:37] that one died for lack of a second as well. [2:12:41] Chris talking to me. [2:12:43] I would really like to suggest the council [2:12:45] that we handle these one motion, one item at a time. [2:12:49] There are 10 items up there and we all have [2:12:51] our grab bag of ideas, but it might flow us [2:12:55] to proceed a bit quicker than packaging two or three [2:12:59] of these at a time. [2:13:01] That's just a common small motion. [2:13:03] I think it's good to see it. [2:13:04] Suzanne Hopkins. [2:13:05] I was actually going that way and going to make a motion [2:13:08] that we fund the victim witness coordinator for $64,000. [2:13:12] And if that's approved, then come back with the ballots. [2:13:15] Second. [2:13:18] Motion by Suzanne Hawkins. [2:13:21] I'm going to have a place that's right notes here. [2:13:23] Me too. [2:13:24] Question by Suzanne Hawkins. [2:13:26] Seconded by Don Hall to include the $64,000 [2:13:31] for the victim of witness coordinator. [2:13:33] Is there a discussion? [2:13:34] Suzanne? [2:13:35] Oh, no. [2:13:36] Sorry. [2:13:37] That's one item, just one item. [2:13:39] That item be included. [2:13:44] Seeing no further discussion, [2:13:45] Sharon Roll call vote please. [2:13:47] Nicki Boyd, yes. [2:13:49] Sean Beriker, yes. [2:13:51] Chris Hockington, no. [2:13:54] Greg Lanting, yes. [2:13:56] Don Hall, yes. [2:13:57] Ruth Pierce, yes. [2:13:58] Suzanne Hocking, yes. [2:14:01] Motion passes, six to one. [2:14:05] So let's just real quick do the math there before $223,000. [2:14:10] Thank you. [2:14:11] That was pretty quick. [2:14:14] Suzanne Hawkins. [2:14:15] I'll take this tab again. [2:14:16] I make a motion that we reserve the $180,000 [2:14:22] for the pool operations if needed. [2:14:24] And if not, that amount come back to the council [2:14:27] to be reallocated at a later date. [2:14:31] Second. [2:14:33] Motion by Suzanne Hawkins. [2:14:34] Seconded by Chris Talkington to reserve the $100,000 [2:14:38] for pool operations. [2:14:39] And if that's not needed, that that come back [2:14:40] to the council for reallocation. [2:14:42] Greg Lanting. [2:14:43] Well, this particular one hasn't been high on my list, [2:14:46] and I can understand our reasons for, [2:14:49] does he need the money now, [2:14:50] and so I'll probably be voting for it. [2:14:52] I also remember that when we went into the last negotiation [2:14:55] with the Y, we actually had other partners in the city [2:14:58] that wanted to partner, and they offered a deal [2:15:03] very similar to the Y to take over the pool. [2:15:07] Okay, that was being, it was Gold's Gym at that time, [2:15:10] Obviously they've had different they have different ownership down and they may not be interested, but so I'm not as worried about needing that hundred and eighty thousand dollars they're [2:15:20] Because of that and plus I'm also very willing to look at other options [2:15:26] Should we get the pool back including whether it needs to be open in the winter time? [2:15:30] Okay, I like I said last week [2:15:33] I've been there in the winter time on many occasions and there were like five of us in the pool from like [2:15:39] five o'clock to eight o'clock in the evening in the wintertime it's not well [2:15:44] utilized in the wintertime and so it may be something we look at I know their [2:15:48] agreements with swim teams and they may cloud that but we might be able to save [2:15:52] some money there but I will vote for it just because I don't think we want to [2:15:57] hang over here. Thank you boy. I have a question if we vote for that then we still [2:16:07] have a small amount left over, and I feel very strongly that that could become our responsibility. [2:16:18] Maybe not, but it could, and we would not be very fiscally responsible if we didn't set [2:16:23] aside money for that. [2:16:24] I'm hoping that we don't have to use that, but can we put more money than 180? [2:16:30] If we have eight or $9,000 hanging out or $15,000, [2:16:35] can we add it to that and put it there [2:16:38] and if we don't use it, allocate it for something later? [2:16:42] It's actually $43,000. [2:16:44] Well, we've got to have something for the arts. [2:16:50] So again, we believe that the $180,000 [2:16:53] is a very good estimate to move that forward. [2:16:56] If you wanted to adjust that upward, [2:16:59] you would be taking more funding and setting that aside [2:17:03] for the potential operations of the pool, [2:17:07] or you'd be setting aside additional funding [2:17:09] that we would come back to the council [2:17:11] to ask you to allocate at a future date, [2:17:14] some portion of that 43 that didn't necessarily [2:17:17] go to the arts as it was just suggested. [2:17:21] So the answer. [2:17:23] If you want to, you can. [2:17:25] Thank you. [2:17:27] This one. [2:17:28] Good, then I'll make you. [2:17:31] I would just, to answer your question or your statement, Greg, about the other partner [2:17:37] with the pool. [2:17:38] That would take a whole new process of asking for an RFQRP and through that whole process. [2:17:48] What we're trying to do is figure out if it doesn't work, having enough money to continue [2:17:53] the operations. [2:17:54] I agree with you, Greg, that there are some things that I would hope that we would do to [2:17:58] save some money at the pool. [2:18:00] people in the pool in the evening doesn't make sense to have all the staffing there, but again it's [2:18:06] going to take a whole process to get some other entity to come in here to look at operating the pool [2:18:14] that could take months. Any other discussion on the motion that is on the floor? Just a reminder [2:18:25] that is to allocate the $180,000 for the potential of pool operations. Sharon will call the [2:18:35] Please. [2:18:37] Sean Bericher? [2:18:38] Yes. [2:18:39] Chris Talkington? [2:18:40] Yes. [2:18:41] Greg Lanthine? [2:18:42] Yes. [2:18:43] Don Hall? [2:18:44] Yes. [2:18:45] Ruth Pierce? [2:18:46] Yes. [2:18:47] Suzanne Hawkins? [2:18:48] Yes. [2:18:49] Nikki Boyd? [2:18:50] Yes. [2:18:51] So that motion passes 7 to 0. [2:18:53] There's a remainder of $43,000 with the full 3% Don Hall. [2:18:59] I would recommend or make the motion that we replenish the public art. [2:19:04] What was it? [2:19:05] Twenty twenty twenty two thousand dollars twenty twenty not took [2:19:09] see twenty twenty thousand dollars your director was twenty [2:19:12] so the total cost was about forty five thousand dollars in that right twenty five [2:19:22] whisper I've been here twenty five went to the piece itself windy had an estimate of [2:19:27] twenty two thousand dollars for the landscaping the council approved twenty twenty so I revised [2:19:33] It's my motion of 20,000 to replace the arts. [2:19:38] Second. [2:19:40] Motion by Don Hall, seconded by Chris Tockington to allocate $20,000 to the public art fund. [2:19:47] Any discussion? [2:19:49] Suzanne Ockens. [2:19:53] Just to clarify, I'm going to be voting against that just because I feel that we have [2:20:00] higher needs in this budget than replenishing the art fund this year. [2:20:04] I'm on support of the art and I don't, it's nothing against the art. [2:20:08] fund, but I just think we have other needs. So I will be voting against it. [2:20:13] Greg, my answer. I do find myself, even though I've been on the Arts Council on different things, [2:20:18] I find myself voting against it. That's the reason we have the capital fund that funds that and it [2:20:26] built for years and we finally utilized it and it will build back again without a, you know, [2:20:34] So I will report not that I think it's not important. [2:20:38] I just, we had a fund that we used and that we'll build back on. [2:20:43] So. [2:20:45] Don Hall. [2:20:46] I would just say that we try to take make efforts to not bottom it out. [2:20:52] We pretty close to it's what do we have left in it now? [2:20:59] $15,000. [2:21:00] $16,000. [2:21:01] $6,000. [2:21:04] $6,000. [2:21:05] I think. [2:21:06] But how much do we have left after the forty five thirty four thousand so [2:21:12] We extended ourselves at this this public art we did we we extend ourselves with the landscape in which I hope [2:21:19] We can still save some money on and I would just hate to see us [2:21:23] diminishes so if another [2:21:27] appropriate public art [2:21:30] Project came our way that we would not be able to afford to [2:21:33] So that's why I'm in support of the motion. [2:21:37] Ruth Pierce. [2:21:38] Well, and I'd kind of like to echo what Sean brought up last week was, or the week before, [2:21:45] is that we really don't have a long-term plan in talking about trying to, I mean, we do [2:21:51] add six a year, and I mean, I'm not anti-art by any means, but I agree with Suzanne, there's [2:21:57] some other needs. We've promised the community that we would look at alternatives for the [2:22:05] banners across Shoshone Street, which is the reader board, and not being as much needed [2:22:12] as the victims. When as coordinator, there's still our other thing. Things out there, and [2:22:18] I would like to maybe take a little bit slower and think about utilizing this excess funds [2:22:24] for maybe something the community really wants to see. [2:22:28] Nikki boy. [2:22:31] Can we review real quick the fund? [2:22:35] So there is six, Lori, did you see there was how much money left in that? [2:22:41] In the art or Travis either one. [2:22:50] Nikki it has roughly $54,000 in it. [2:22:56] So we veered mark 20 so we have about 34 left. [2:22:59] Then we actually hear Mark 45. [2:23:02] Yeah, sorry. [2:23:03] I thought we have nine left. [2:23:05] The force came from something else. [2:23:07] That's what I'm thinking we had 9,000 left. [2:23:10] Could be. [2:23:11] I better go back and look. [2:23:12] So it's almost bankrupt. [2:23:14] Well, 9,000 is more than, I mean, that's better in bankrupt. [2:23:18] So where does this sit? [2:23:21] Well, that's true, Don. [2:23:23] Where does this 6,000 remind us of the 6,000? [2:23:27] And you say that's going to, it's going to replenish itself. [2:23:31] So on an annual basis, we take a percentage by council action of a 2007, I believe, resolution. [2:23:39] That takes a portion of the general fund capital improvement plan. [2:23:44] It's a percentage, and that percentage drive creates about $6,000 a year, it's variable. [2:23:50] But at the staff level, we tried to fund general fund capital operations between a 1.8 and $2.2 [2:23:57] million a year annual window. [2:23:59] So that's how you come up with the $6,000 on any basis. [2:24:03] Thank you very much. [2:24:09] Anything else from the council? [2:24:11] So there's a motion on the floor to replenish the public art fund with $20,000. [2:24:20] Sharon, I'll hello, please. [2:24:22] Chris, talking to? [2:24:24] Greg Lanting? No. Don Hall? Yes. Ruth Pierce? No. Suzanne Hawkins? No. Nicky Boyd? No. [2:24:35] Sean Baraker? No. Ocean Fails? The two. Five to two. Another piece of paper after. [2:24:49] Chris Tockett. So I guess what that means now that the full 40 45 will come out of [2:24:57] the art fund. Okay. So there remains $43,000 if we are to support the full 3% Greg Lantler. [2:25:10] I would like to suggest that we reserve $43,000 in the mid-year compensation adjustment fund [2:25:16] and if needed. That's just not very popular. Sorry guys, I keep trying. That motion will [2:25:28] fail for lack of a second. I thought I got a second out of Chris. He's the one to have [2:25:32] the anecdotal thing about the police officer. [2:25:36] You guys took all the money for the victim. [2:25:38] So even though I cannot make a motion, [2:25:41] I might take a suggestion to a comment [2:25:44] that Ruth made about the electronic reader board, [2:25:46] that while we do have some level of interest [2:25:50] from community members to assist with fundraising [2:25:53] for that project, perhaps the balance of these funds [2:25:56] could be dedicated to some sort of a seed money or reserve [2:26:02] if needed, should that project move forward? [2:26:06] Greg Lanting. [2:26:07] Well, I'm going to make that motion for you, Sean. [2:26:10] And also, through my presidency of the EIC, [2:26:13] it is only by custom that the mirror does not make, [2:26:16] under our form of government does not make a motion, [2:26:18] the mirror can make motions, and seconds as well. [2:26:21] I will second that. [2:26:24] The motion by Greg Lanting, seconded by Ruth Pierce, [2:26:28] to place the balance of the $43,000 [2:26:31] into seed money for an electronic reader board project. [2:26:39] Any discussion? [2:26:42] Seeing none, Sharon, roll call vote please. [2:26:48] Greg Lanthine? [2:26:49] Yes. [2:26:50] Don Hall? [2:26:51] Yes. [2:26:52] Ruth Pierce? [2:26:53] Yes. [2:26:53] Suzanne Hawkins? [2:26:55] Yes. [2:26:56] Nicky Boyd? [2:26:57] Yes. [2:26:57] Sean Beriker? [2:26:59] Yes. [2:26:59] Chris Hawking? [2:27:00] Yes. [2:27:02] Motion passes, 72-0. [2:27:07] So that plugs all the funds into where they need to be. [2:27:11] And now, Travis, unless you have something further, [2:27:15] we'll have the public hearing. [2:27:16] So maybe just going to the last slide, [2:27:19] what's going to be important is by taking the full 3%, [2:27:23] the tax rate illustrated here is going to be $8.16 per $1,000 [2:27:29] of taxable value. [2:27:30] What we have illustrated here is the average impact [2:27:34] to that average resident inside of the city of Twin Falls. [2:27:39] Thank you, Travis, so with that, we will open the public hearing for public input on the [2:27:49] budget, and I have the sign-up sheet up here from way early on, so I don't know if there [2:27:55] is one back there, if anyone signed up, or if there is, so if there is anyone here who [2:28:00] wishes to address the Council on the budget, you are welcome to come forward now and introduce [2:28:06] yourself and give us your address, and we will take your public input. [2:28:09] one you can just come forward you know you can just come on up but thank you [2:28:16] for all the rules yes so if you please state your name and address for the [2:28:21] record sorry mr. Hall but I should I go to Carlos now do you not want anymore [2:28:27] well I was there right back then I'll go with Carlos well one Carlos it will [2:28:33] be fine at 1063 to 1063 or Avenue West that's the address I want to thank you [2:28:41] guys for letting me address my concerns and also the first time in here so I'm [2:28:47] trying to fly and trying to get a little quintense with the program and whatnot [2:28:52] and more than anything I'd like to address you know just thank you guys and [2:29:00] I just ask you guys to be considered of all these changes that you guys are [2:29:07] making for all of our citizens, especially for us who are in the working class and lower [2:29:14] middle class in you guys raising all these fees and adding stuff to the budget and what [2:29:21] not. [2:29:22] More or less, that's why I'm here, I would like for you guys to take that into consideration. [2:29:29] I want to thank you, that seems that you guys are being cautious on the fees that you're [2:29:34] trying to increase I know Mr. Hall for a few years and I know he's a very [2:29:40] individual who has always questioned it the why and I'm speaking once again from [2:29:46] the lower class and the working class and more or less middle class for you guys [2:29:51] to really be considering on us you know and also for new if there are new agencies [2:30:02] or like Chobani or anything, one of those big organizations coming into town for them as well to be considered that this is not a New York area, this is through Volsada Hope. [2:30:15] And you know, the reason why I guess we are so pleased to be here is because it's a small community. [2:30:24] So we'd like to see it maybe eventually slowing down a little bit with all that, thank you for the time. [2:30:32] Thank you. [2:30:36] Is there anyone else who would wish to address the council on the budget this evening? [2:30:44] Seeing no one, we will close the public hearing. [2:30:47] And Chris Stockington. [2:30:49] We have adoption of 2017 budget as adopted as presented by placing on third and final by [2:31:01] title on my under suspension rules. [2:31:10] I hope it was edifying, Sam. [2:31:11] Very good. [2:31:13] Take care. [2:31:14] Is there a second to that motion? [2:31:18] So it is an ordinance number? [2:31:19] Yeah, Mr. Mayor, members of council. [2:31:20] So based upon the conversations that we've heard [2:31:24] over the course of the last few weeks, [2:31:28] really the members of our finance team, Shane and Lori, [2:31:30] who are this evening, put together [2:31:33] a whole series of possible options that you might consider. [2:31:36] It's almost like those magic tricks that you see [2:31:40] on America's Nutella. [2:31:42] Here is the ordinance that you have now put forward. [2:31:45] Wow. [2:31:47] So really, and really, credit goes to the staff. [2:31:51] I mean, they have really worked hard on this budget, [2:31:54] and they put together a series of options [2:31:56] by paying attention to the conversations that you've had. [2:32:00] And so again, this would be the ordinance. [2:32:01] It would be ordinance number 2016-10 for your approval [2:32:09] this evening. [2:32:10] It is allocated, the funds that we have are allocated in total, [2:32:14] illustrated on the sheet below. We will publish this to our website as soon as you [2:32:21] probably tomorrow when you approve it we're unable to do that this evening because [2:32:25] of the budget prior to today. So we do have a motion to approve ordinance [2:32:31] 2016-10. Let's just mention the roles in third and final reading by title only. I'm [2:32:42] I'm still awaiting a second. [2:32:43] Second. [2:32:44] I'm sorry. [2:32:45] I thought there was a second. [2:32:46] I did too. [2:32:49] Motion by Chris Toggington, seconded by Greg Lanting. [2:32:53] Is there any further discussion? [2:32:56] Council? [2:32:57] Seeing none, Sharon Rilkel vote, please. [2:33:02] Down Hall? [2:33:03] Yes. [2:33:04] Ruth Pierce? [2:33:05] Yes. [2:33:06] Suzanne Hawkins? [2:33:07] Yes. [2:33:07] Nikki Boyd? [2:33:08] Yes. [2:33:09] Sean Bericher? [2:33:10] Yes. [2:33:10] Chris Toggington? [2:33:11] Yes. [2:33:12] Greg Lanting? [2:33:13] Yes. [2:33:14] Motion passes 7-0. [2:33:16] Sharon, would you read the title, please? [2:33:19] Ordinance number 2016-10. [2:33:22] And ordinance of the city of Windfall's Idaho, [2:33:26] appropriating $60,958,366 for the 2017 fiscal year [2:33:35] to defray all necessary expenses and liabilities [2:33:39] of the city of Windfall's, providing for the objects [2:33:44] and purposes for which such appropriations are made, and the amount appropriated for each object or purpose. [2:33:52] Levian and Valorum taxes in the amount of $19,276,360 for the 2017 fiscal year. [2:34:05] Providing that a copy of this ordinance shall be filed with the county commissioners of Twin Falls County, Idaho. [2:34:12] with the Secretary of State of the State of Idaho, providing for this ordinance to take [2:34:18] effect upon its passage approval and publication according to law, the rule requiring that in [2:34:25] ordinance be read on three separate occasions having been suspended. [2:34:31] Susanne Hawkins. [2:34:32] I move approval of Ordinance 2016-10. [2:34:37] motion by Suzanne Hawkins say that by Greg Lanting to approve ordinance 2016 [2:34:43] dash 10. Any further discussion? [2:34:45] Seeing none, Sharon, roll call vote please. [2:34:49] Ruth Pears? [2:34:50] Yes. [2:34:51] Suzanne Hawkins? [2:34:52] Yes. [2:34:53] Nicky Boyd? [2:34:54] Yes. [2:34:55] Son Beriker? [2:34:56] Yes. [2:34:57] Chris Hockington? [2:34:58] Yes. [2:34:59] Greg Lanting? [2:35:00] Yes. [2:35:01] Don Hall? [2:35:02] Yes. [2:35:03] Motion passes 7-0. [2:35:04] I have a thank you to thank you to you and your [2:35:08] great team for all of the work that we need to blow these many months of [2:35:12] Of budget work, and we'll enjoy our three-month break, and then we'll start it all over again [2:35:17] Greg Lansing well, I just want to make sure that if we may who wants this to realize that [2:35:23] You can never say that we've been that we've been talking about this outside of school so to speak [2:35:29] I saw for this day as because if you watch what we just did right there, it's obvious we have been talking to each other at all [2:35:34] All right, so we will back up just a tiny bit on the agenda to any items from the city manager or city council council don't know [2:35:50] Jackie do you have just moment? I [2:35:54] Notice a lot of construction trucks and the like and frontier being closed off are we rebuilding that section of frontier by falls [2:36:03] What's going on there? [2:36:04] Did I hit you flat-footed? [2:36:09] Frontier between falls and [2:36:16] and the end of our agreement, which is, oh, it doesn't go [2:36:27] on to the armory, goes to the end of the fire station. [2:36:30] To the end of the fire station. [2:36:32] End of the fire station driveway. [2:36:33] Is that a complete rebuild? [2:36:34] Because some of it was pretty bad. [2:36:39] It's like a millen inlay. [2:36:40] OK. [2:36:41] Very good. [2:36:41] Thank you. [2:36:44] Anything else from the council? [2:36:49] Travis, do you have anything for us? [2:36:51] Just a couple of quick items. [2:36:53] Again, general city government will [2:36:55] We close next Monday in observation of a Labor Day. [2:36:59] We will not be having a meeting next Tuesday, but we will come back on Monday, the 12th of [2:37:06] September. [2:37:07] Tomorrow also is the Cliff Bar building dedication open to the public at relief starting at 3.30. [2:37:15] Great. [2:37:19] Thank you. [2:37:21] So next on the agenda is adjournment. [2:37:24] We have two executive session items this evening, executive session 74206 1A to consider hiring [2:37:33] a public officer, employee, staff member or individual agent wherein the respective qualities [2:37:37] of individuals are to be evaluated in order to fill a particular vacancy or need. [2:37:43] This paragraph does not apply to filling a vacancy in an elective office or deliberations [2:37:47] about staffing needs in general and also 742061B to consider the evaluation, dismissal or [2:37:55] disciplining of or to hear complaints or charges brought against a public officer, employee, [2:38:01] staff member or individual agent or public school student. [2:38:07] So moved. [2:38:08] Second. [2:38:09] Motion by Don Hall, seconded by Suzanne Hawkins to adjourn into executive session as stated. [2:38:16] Sharon, I'll call both of these. [2:38:19] Suzanne Hawkins, yes, Nikki Boyd, yes, John Berger, yes, Chris talking, Greg Lanting, yes, [2:38:27] Don Hall, yes, Ruth Pierce, yes, passes seven to zero. Just let everyone know we will not [2:38:33] be reconvening following the executive sessions nor will we be making any decisions in the session [2:38:40] or following it either. With that, we are adjourned.