Oversight Archive: City Council meeting, 2018-04-09, recording 1 (started 17:00) Machine transcript (faster-whisper base.en), not checked word for word; the Pledge of Allegiance is shown in its standard wording. The recording is the record. Times are time into the recording. Passages with private details are muted in the audio and marked here. The audio on the page below was re-encoded by software from the video the agency posted. Check any passage against that audio before relying on it. Page: https://oversightarchive.org/twin-falls-id/meetings/2018-04-09/ [0:00:09] Good evening, I'd like to call to order the Twin Falls City Council meeting for Monday, April 9th, [0:00:13] and confirm that we do have a quorum at the Council. [0:00:15] Six of the seven members are here this evening. [0:00:18] Councilman Lanting is not able to join us tonight. [0:00:21] Next on the agenda is the Pledge of Allegiance. [0:00:23] I know we have several scouts who are here, so if I could ask them to please come forward, [0:00:27] and those of you wishing to join us, please rise, and we'll have them lead us in the Pledge of Allegiance. [0:00:31] Thank you gentlemen, before you head back to your seats, please come up here to this podium [0:01:04] where the microphone is right there. [0:01:06] And give us your name and which troop you're with and what you're working on this evening. [0:01:11] Please. [0:01:12] Okay. [0:01:13] and I've been at LAM. I'm in troop 180 and I'm working on my [0:01:18] citizens in the community mayor badge. [0:01:20] Excellent, thank you. [0:01:22] My name is Riley Greaves and I'm in troop 180 and I'm working on sedition to the community. [0:01:35] Thank you. [0:01:36] My name is Kobe Dixon and I'm from troop 180 and I'm working on citizenship in the community mayor badge. [0:01:44] Thank you. [0:01:45] I'm Kate Finch and I'm sure putting it in on the community. [0:01:52] Excellent. [0:01:53] Thank you so much. [0:01:54] And thank you all for leading us in the pledge this evening. [0:02:01] Mr. Rothweller, do we have any amendments to our agenda? [0:02:04] Mr. members of council, there are no amendments this evening. [0:02:06] Thank you. [0:02:07] We do have a few proclamations this evening. [0:02:10] So I have asked some other council members to assist me [0:02:13] in reading them. [0:02:14] So I don't lose my voice on item four on the agenda. [0:02:17] So first is for a youth appreciation week and we have a councilwoman Suzanne Hockings [0:02:21] who will read that. [0:02:22] Thank you. [0:02:23] Sorry. [0:02:24] Whereas the vast majority of youth are concerned, knowledgeable, and responsible citizens and [0:02:32] whereas Optimus International and the Twin Falls Optimists Club have developed and promoted [0:02:37] a program entitled Youth Appreciation Week and whereas the citizens of Twin Falls have [0:02:44] indicated a desire to join the optimist in expressing appreciation and approval for the [0:02:50] contributions of youth. John Merigar, therefore, proclaims the second week of April as Youth [0:02:57] Appreciation Week in Twin Falls, Idaho. By this action, let it be known that we have [0:03:02] faith in the ability of today's youth as they assume responsible roles in the future of mankind, [0:03:09] and it is stated with today's date. [0:03:11] We have AMSA schools from the Optimus Club to accept that. [0:03:14] Here we have us here. [0:03:51] Oh, past president of the Optimus Club here to join me. [0:03:54] And every year we do a youth appreciation luncheon. [0:03:57] And the students are selected because they live by the Optimus Creed. [0:04:02] And we're very proud of our creed. [0:04:04] And we were hoping to invite all of you to our luncheon this Thursday. [0:04:08] If you can attend, we'd love to have you there. [0:04:11] We can learn more about what we do. [0:04:13] And if we could just take a minute, maybe to lead the whole group here in the Optimus [0:04:18] Creed, I think it might even make your meeting go better, so, so, so, promise yourself to [0:04:25] be so strong that nothing can disturb your peace of mind, to talk health, happiness, [0:04:31] and prosperity, every person you meet, to make all your friends feel that there is something [0:04:37] in them. [0:04:38] The look at the sunny side of everything, and make your optimism come true. [0:04:43] The thing only happens to work only for the best, and to expect only the best. [0:04:50] It'd be just as enthusiastic about the success as others as you are about your own. [0:04:57] To forget the mistakes of the past, and press on to the greater achievements of the future. [0:05:03] to wear a cheerful countenance at all times and give every living creature to meet a smile, [0:05:10] to give so much time to the improvement of yourself, that you have no time to criticize others, [0:05:17] to be too large for worry, too noble for anger, too strong for fear, and too happy to permit the presence of trouble. [0:05:26] Thank you very much. [0:05:29] Thank you. [0:05:35] The next is a proclamation for Idaho Crime Victims Rights Week. [0:05:41] Whereas Idahoans are the victims of more than 17,000 crimes each year, affecting individuals, [0:05:47] families, and communities. [0:05:49] And whereas providing victims with knowledge of their rights and available services further [0:05:53] strengthens their ability to recover from crime and trauma, and restores a sense of self-empowerment. [0:06:00] Whereas victims who believe they have a voice, empathy, and support are more likely to disclose [0:06:05] their victimization, seek services, overcome the sense of isolation and distrust, and participate [0:06:11] in the justice process. [0:06:13] Whereas a multidisciplinary response involving collaboration among victim service professionals, [0:06:20] criminal justice officials, legal professionals, medical and mental health providers, and community [0:06:25] leaders is essential to reach and serve all victims, especially those who are marginalized, [0:06:30] disabilities or live in remote locations. Whereas Idaho Crime Victims Rights Week, April 8-14, [0:06:37] 2018, provides an opportunity to recommit to ensure that all victims of crime are afforded [0:06:42] their rights. Whereas the State of Idaho and numerous organizations, including the City of [0:06:47] Twin Falls, are dedicated to supporting and strengthening victims and survivors in the aftermath of crime, [0:06:52] building resilience in our communities and our victim responders and working for justice for [0:06:57] all victims and survivors. Now there for I, Sean Barrager, Mayor of the City of [0:07:01] Twin Falls, Idaho, do hereby proclaim April 8th through the 14th 2018 to be [0:07:06] Idaho Crime Victims Rights Week. We have Kim Burke, Altar, our Twin Falls Police [0:07:11] Department Victim Services Coordinator to accept this. Thank you Mayor and Council [0:07:42] members for acknowledging the importance of crime victims rights week. President [0:07:46] Ronald Reagan enacted crime victims rights week nationally in 1982 as part of an [0:07:52] expanding initiative to provide for victims of crime. [0:07:55] Today, all states have passed laws to establish victims' rights, and in general, these laws [0:08:01] require that victims have certain information, protections, and a role in the criminal justice [0:08:06] process. [0:08:07] Idaho is one of those states. [0:08:09] Why should we as a community get involved? [0:08:14] It is important to acknowledge, for example, that one in five women and one in 67 men have [0:08:20] have experienced some form of sexual violence according to the National Sexual Violence Resource [0:08:25] Center. This statistic alone would indicate that the probability exists that we personally [0:08:30] know a victim, even if the person has not disclosed to us. However, more importantly, national [0:08:36] research supports that victims who feel heard and supported or are more likely to disclose [0:08:42] their victimization seek services from formal support agencies and participate in the justice [0:08:48] process. It is a huge step in the healing process for a victim to disclose and [0:08:55] follow through with obtaining services. We should react to disclosure with [0:09:00] positive support. You may be asking yourself and everyone in this room, maybe [0:09:06] asking themselves how can we get involved. The keys are education and [0:09:10] action. Educate yourself on local resources. Speak with those in the [0:09:15] community who provides support services to victims. Learn what their fuckships are, learn [0:09:21] what their needs are, then take action. When I say take action, I mean volunteer for support [0:09:28] service programs. Participate in public awareness campaigns, wear your ribbons of support, donate [0:09:36] items or money, or simply listen openly to victims who need to share their story. The [0:09:42] opportunities are endless. And I'd like to note that this month in April alone we [0:09:49] are acknowledging Child Abuse Prevention Month which I'm happy to see the pinwheels [0:09:53] up on your desk. Crime victims right week this week April 8th through the [0:09:58] 14th. Sexual Assault Awareness Month for Presidential Proclamation in 2013. And we [0:10:05] have Voices in Violence which I know Ms. Graybill is here. She has planned to [0:10:10] walk for this Saturday and we are also enacting citywide denim day to raise [0:10:20] awareness of sexual assault within the workplace as well as our community in [0:10:24] which all employees are afforded the opportunity to wear a denim to work. I [0:10:30] thank you for your proclamation to ensure that the victims of the city of [0:10:34] Twin Falls have a supportive voice. Thank you. [0:10:38] And a nice transition to our last proclamation tonight for National Sexual Assault Awareness [0:10:51] Week and Councilman Chris Reed is going to read that for us. [0:10:55] Whereas April 2018 marks Sexual Assault Awareness Month as established nationally by the National [0:11:02] Coalition Against Sexual Assault in the late 1980s, whereas throughout its history it has [0:11:08] grown to be nationally recognized as Sexual Assault Awareness Month as recognized by President [0:11:15] Barack Obama in 2009, in 2009, whereas through community awareness, Twin Falls can prevent [0:11:25] gender violence, promote the interest of survivors, and make Twin Falls a safer place to live, [0:11:32] whereas one in four girls and one in six boys experience sexual violence, and throughout [0:11:38] the national, the nation hundreds of organizations worked tirelessly to end this program, including [0:11:45] voices against violence in Twin Falls. Now therefore, Sean Berger, by virtue of the authority vested [0:11:52] in him as mayor of Twin Falls, does hereby applaud the efforts of community-based advocates to end [0:11:59] the violence and proclaim the week of April 9th through the 15th as sexual assault awareness week [0:12:07] signed by the mayor. We have Donna Grayville with voices and violence, I think you have a couple [0:12:13] board members here as well that can accept this. Thank you very much for this proclamation today. [0:12:48] I feel that Kim really did an excellent job of summarizing why it is important that we support [0:12:56] this in our community. So I want to give a short plug for a couple of things we have coming up. [0:13:00] She mentioned Wacomile in her shoes. It's coming up this Saturday. We're seeing a lot of community [0:13:07] involvement so far. It's an opportunity for men and women, although women don't [0:13:13] have to wear the heels, for men to come out and show that they do not stand for [0:13:18] or tolerate sexual violence. And so we really look forward to seeing many of our [0:13:25] law enforcement present as well as fire and health professionals. It's just a [0:13:31] really great event. It's a fun time and it's an opportunity to build community [0:13:37] and say thanks. Also, Denim Day, coming up on April 25th, this day was created in [0:13:45] response to court rulings based on clothing that women wear to justify [0:13:51] violent behavior against them. And so, one of the cases involved Denim. And so, we [0:13:58] will recognize Denim Day by encouraging anyone in the community to [0:14:01] we're done more is better. And we look forward to seeing that on April 25th. Thank you. [0:14:09] Thank you Donna. Next on the agenda is an opportunity for general public input. If [0:14:21] there's anyone here from the public who wishes to address the council on an item [0:14:24] that is not on the agenda this evening, now is your opportunity to please come [0:14:28] forward. Seeing no one, we will move on to the consent calendar. Council wishes move [0:14:44] to approve the consent calendar like that. Motion by Christopher Reed, seconded by Chris [0:14:50] Tockington to approve the consent calendar. Is there any discussion? Ruth Pierce. Nope. [0:14:55] Okay, let's just go in a second. Any other any discussion? Sharon, I'll call vote, please. [0:15:03] Sean Berger. Yes. Nikki Boyd. Yes. Suzanne Hawkins. Yes. Ruth Pierce. Yes. Christopher Reed. Yes. [0:15:12] Yes. Motion passes 6-0. Next, under items of consideration, the first is a presentation [0:15:21] of post-basic and intermediate certifications and the formal ceremony promoting officer [0:15:27] Sean Applewhite. Excuse me, to the position of Sergeant. We have Craig Kingsbury, our Chief [0:15:33] of Police. Welcome, Chief. Thank you, Mayor and Council. As we did a couple of weeks ago, [0:15:38] It's always an honor to recognize our employees who have worked hard to achieve some of these milestones in their career. [0:15:45] I'd like to call Lieutenant Wilson and Captain Barnhart down to help us with this celebration. [0:15:50] Training, Mayor, and City Council. [0:16:11] If I could get Officer Sean Applewhite, Officer Nick Gummison, Officer Elisha Badger, Badger, Radley Wendland, Justin Clark, [0:16:26] and Tracy Thompson to please come down. [0:16:42] What we'd like to do first is award the basic post certificate to four of our officers who've achieved and completed those requirements. [0:16:53] And the requirements for our basic post certificate is essentially to complete the basic post training, [0:17:01] which is done at a police academy or in an academic setting like CSI. [0:17:07] work for one year with the agency that hired you and complete their field training program. [0:17:14] The first year in police work keeps our men and women very busy training and getting up to speed [0:17:25] with all of the different types of tasks and assignments and everything else that's involved [0:17:34] in working independently as a police officer is a heavy load and is very impressed by the [0:17:45] quality of men and women that are agency hires and it's a great opportunity to recognize them [0:17:52] in this first step in their police career. And I'm going to begin by reading Elisha Baddaker's bio [0:18:01] And Elisha took a little different path. [0:18:05] He completed most of his basic training in the state of Colorado, [0:18:08] where he worked as a deputy sheriff. [0:18:10] He then sought us out and took a job with the city of Twin Falls and transferred it. [0:18:15] So his path was a little different because a lot of his basic police training had already been completed. [0:18:21] But he was still required to pass the same test that all Idaho new recruits must pass. [0:18:31] before they were able to attain their basic post-certificate. [0:18:37] And Elisha was hired by the Twin Falls Police Department on January 9 of 2017 as a full-time [0:18:43] police officer. [0:18:44] He was born and raised in Colorado Springs, Colorado, and he graduated from James Irwin [0:18:50] High School in 2004. [0:18:52] Elisha joined the Army Reserves in 2004 and served nine years until 2013. [0:19:01] While with the Army Reserves, he was deployed to Iraq in 2006 and Afghanistan in 2011. [0:19:09] During that time, he also managed to further his education by attending Pike's Peak Community [0:19:14] College. [0:19:15] Elisha's law enforcement career began when he left the Army Reserves and became an El Paso [0:19:21] County Sheriff's Deputy in Colorado Springs in 2013. [0:19:27] Elisha and his wife, Lisa Marie, have two boys, Maverick, who is seven, and Joshua, who is [0:19:33] five. [0:19:34] It is with great pleasure that we present Elisha with the basic certification from the [0:19:40] State of Idaho Peace Officer Standards and Training Council. [0:20:21] Tracy Thompson was hired by the Twin Falls Police Department on March 20 of 2017 as a [0:20:28] full-time police officer. [0:20:30] Tracy was born and raised in Jerome, Idaho. He graduated from Jerome High School in 1994. [0:20:37] In 1993 while still in high school, Tracy joined the enlisted reserves as a combat engineer. [0:20:44] Once he graduated, he went to Fort Leonard Wood, Missouri for basic training. Upon completion [0:20:50] of basic training, he returned to Idaho and attended the College of Southern Idaho as a [0:20:54] music major until he left on a two-year LDS mission to Finland. When he returned from [0:21:00] from Finland, he switched over to the 25th Army National Guard Army Band out of [0:21:06] Gowan Field. He left the military in 2001 after eight years of service. He went on [0:21:13] to continue his education at Boise State University and worked at the BSU [0:21:18] bookstore as a textbook manager. He attained his bachelor's degree in [0:21:23] criminal justice in 2008. Tracy's law enforcement career began with the [0:21:28] Twin Falls County Sheriff's Office as a detention deputy. He worked in the jail [0:21:32] four years prior to being hired by the Twin Falls Police Department. Tracey and [0:21:37] his wife Sarah have three children. Tracey successfully completed the Idaho [0:21:42] Peace Officer Standards and Training Academy session 189 and graduated on June [0:21:48] 16 of 2017. It is with great pleasure that we present Tracey with the basic [0:21:55] certification from the State of Idaho Peace Officer's Standards and Training [0:22:00] Council. Justin Clark was hired by the Twin Falls Police Department on November [0:22:31] 14th 2016 as a full-time police officer. Justin was born in Idaho Falls, Idaho. [0:22:38] He and his family moved to Twin Falls when he was seven years old. He graduated [0:22:43] from Twin Falls High School. After high school he served an LDS mission in [0:22:48] San Bernardino, California. Upon returning from his mission, he went on to further his education [0:22:53] by attending the College of Southern Idaho. Justin graduated in May of 2017 from the College [0:23:01] of Southern Idaho law enforcement program. He plans to continue his education and law enforcement. [0:23:07] He and his wife Kelsey have been married for over three years. It is with great pleasure [0:23:12] that we present Justin with the basic certification from the State of Idaho Peace Officer Standard [0:23:18] and Training Council, was hired by the Twin Falls Police Department on January 9, 2017, [0:23:51] as a full-time police officer. [0:23:54] Bradley was born in Bellflower, California. [0:23:56] He graduated from Valley Christian High School. [0:24:00] Upon graduation, he obtained employment with the Los Angeles County Sheriff's Department [0:24:05] as a custody assistant. [0:24:07] He worked in that capacity for eight years in multiple locations, such as the Men's Central [0:24:12] Jail in downtown Los Angeles and then the Norwalk station Jail. [0:24:17] Adley and his wife Taylor just celebrated their one year wedding anniversary in March. [0:24:23] Bradley graduated in May of 2017 from the College of Southern Idaho law enforcement program. [0:24:30] It is with great pleasure that we present Bradley with the basic certification from the [0:24:34] state of Idaho Peace Officer Standards and Training Council. [0:24:38] Good evening Mr. Mayor and members of the Council and thank you for giving us this opportunity [0:25:08] to recognize and honor the achievements of our employees tonight. [0:25:12] The next two officers will receive their intermediate certificate. [0:25:14] This is the next step in the certification process. [0:25:18] They accept several hours of training to achieve this. [0:25:23] First up, this is Nicholas Gilmerson. [0:25:26] Nick was hired by the Twin Falls Police Department on December 7, 2015 [0:25:30] as a full-time police officer. [0:25:33] Nick was born in Fayetteville, North Carolina in 1986, [0:25:37] Early thereafter, Nick and his family moved to Salt Lake City. [0:25:40] He graduated from Riverton High School in 2005. [0:25:44] He went on to further his education [0:25:46] by attending the College of Southern Idaho. [0:25:48] And the University of Utah where he attained [0:25:51] a Bachelor of Science degree in Exercise and Sports Science. [0:25:56] Nick played collegiate baseball [0:25:58] and following his graduation from the University of Utah, [0:26:01] he continued his baseball career in the Netherlands [0:26:04] for one season. [0:26:06] Nick successfully completed the Idaho Peace Officers Standards and Training and Academy [0:26:10] Session 185 and graduated in March of 2016. [0:26:15] He was awarded his post basic certification in November of 2016. [0:26:19] It is with great pleasure that we present Nick with the Intermediate Certification from [0:26:24] the State of Idaho Peace Officers Standards and Training Council. [0:26:27] Next is Officer Sean Appleway. [0:26:49] John was hired by the Twin Falls Police Department on December 6, 2011, as a full-time police officer. [0:26:56] John was born in Pomona, California. He and his family moved to the Magic Valley in 1984. [0:27:01] John graduated from Jerome High School and then attended the College of Southern Idaho. [0:27:07] In 2003, he received his real estate license, prior to his employment with the Twin Falls Police Department, [0:27:13] Sean sold real estate and Southern Idaho. [0:27:17] John successfully attended and graduated [0:27:20] from the post basic at the Academy in 2011 [0:27:23] and received his basic certification in April of 2013. [0:27:27] John currently serves as a police officer, [0:27:30] a field training officer, [0:27:33] and is a member of the SWAT team, [0:27:35] Bryce's intervention team in honor guard, [0:27:38] and soon to be sergeant. [0:27:42] It is with great pleasure that we present Sean [0:27:45] with the intermediate certification [0:27:46] from the state of Idaho, [0:27:47] peace officer, standards, and training council. [0:28:10] That doesn't get to get out of here that quickly. [0:28:13] As Captain Barnhart mentioned, [0:28:15] John is about to be promoted to the rank of sergeant. [0:28:19] That's Twin Falls Police Department. [0:28:21] Our first level of former supervision [0:28:24] is the rank of sergeant. [0:28:29] Six, eight weeks ago, [0:28:30] we had a very vigorous sergeant promotional process [0:28:34] where we had several candidates apply for the position [0:28:37] and had to put themselves through a rigorous process, [0:28:41] which included oral boards, one oral board, [0:28:44] which was an internal oral board [0:28:46] of members of the administrative staff. [0:28:48] We also had another external oral board [0:28:50] that consisted of members from other city departments [0:28:53] within the city of Twin Falls, [0:28:55] as well as other law enforcement entities [0:28:58] throughout the state of Idaho. [0:29:00] Aside from that, they had to do a writing assignment, [0:29:03] present on that assignment, [0:29:05] and then come afterwards and do meetings with me as the chief. [0:29:11] So it was a very rigorous process. [0:29:13] We had some wonderful candidates that applied, [0:29:15] put themselves in that process. [0:29:18] It's a result of that process. [0:29:19] So we are now prepared, Mr. Applewhite has risen to the top, [0:29:25] and we're prepared to promote him to the rank of sergeant, [0:29:28] a title that he will officially take over, [0:29:30] I believe he'll leave from today [0:29:31] when he takes over a patrol squad for the first time. [0:29:35] Sergeant Applewhite will then be running one of our patrol squads out on the streets. [0:29:40] So it is my honor, if I can have all the other supervisors come down over here. [0:29:46] If you remember Mayor and Council, we have a little tradition here at the City of Twin [0:29:51] Falls. [0:29:52] I'm going to replace Mr. Applewhite's police officer badge with the sergeant badge, and then [0:29:57] members of our supervisor, Recor, will go by and congratulate him and present him with [0:30:03] Sergeant Chevron's while they shake his hand. [0:30:06] Isn't Joe when I present Sergeant Sean Alpowi? [0:31:44] Sean, did he like to say? [0:31:53] Man, staff, and what family? [0:31:58] Do an excellent job. [0:32:10] Congratulations to each of you [0:32:11] who received certifications this evening. [0:32:14] Certainly congratulations to you as soon to be Sergeant. [0:32:17] Thank you for your commitment to the training [0:32:19] and professional development and really the service [0:32:21] that you provide for our citizens and our community. [0:32:25] Next on the agenda is a presentation of a service plaque [0:32:28] to Tom Reynolds in recognition of his service on the Parks and Recreation Commission. [0:32:33] So Tom began his service on the Parks and Recreation Commission in June of 2012 and served [0:32:41] two consecutive three-year terms from 2012 to March of 2018. [0:32:45] He's been a very dedicated and committed commission member during his six-year tenure [0:32:49] and really provided a lot of great insight and solid leadership on that commission. [0:32:55] If you think back of what Parks and Recreation has accomplished in the last half dozen years or so, [0:33:01] we've seen significant improvements, enhancements at Augra Falls, really improving the public access [0:33:06] down there, expansion of our trail system, bicycle facilities throughout the community, [0:33:11] reacquisition of the management of the City Pool and Aquatics programs and Parks and Recreation [0:33:18] Master Planning, just to name a few. So, Tom's been an integral part of the success that we've [0:33:23] seen with our Parks and Recreation programs and this is an opportunity for us [0:33:28] to thank you for a service so Tom if you please come forward Nikki did you have [0:33:32] anything you wanted to add as the liaison for Parks and Recreation while I'm [0:33:35] wondering down there yes it was a pleasure to work with you I appreciated [0:33:40] your good input and your thoughtfulness in preparation for meetings very much [0:33:45] appreciated thank you thank you again Tom next on the agenda with Tom's [0:34:14] comes departure. We have an opportunity to first of all confirm the reappointment of [0:34:21] Brian Rice and Richard Burrell and a new appointment of Chance Mums to serve on the Parks and Recreation [0:34:29] Commission. Yes. Yes. The door shut to cut down on the noise a little bit from the celebration [0:34:43] in the foyer. So, according to City Code, membership of the Parks and Recreation Commission [0:34:51] It consists of nine voting members appointed by the mayor and informed by the council. [0:34:56] It's been our policy to conduct interviews when vacancies occurred, [0:34:59] and resignation are people terming out on their seats. [0:35:03] So the Parks and Recreation Commissioners Brian Rice and Richard Burrell have served, [0:35:08] each served a three-year term, expressed interest in being reappointed of the commission to serve a second term. [0:35:15] As I mentioned, we had a vacancy from Commissioner Tom Reynolds, [0:35:18] who's served his two consecutive terms. [0:35:21] So we posted that BACON-C announced it [0:35:24] and the applications were received. [0:35:26] We had an interview committee consisting of myself, [0:35:29] Parks and Recreation Commission liaison [0:35:30] Vice Mayor Nicki Boyd and Parks and Rec Director [0:35:33] Wendy Davis on Monday, last Monday, [0:35:38] we interviewed the applicants [0:35:40] and the committee selected Chance Munns [0:35:43] to serve on the Parks and Recreation Commission. [0:35:46] So that would be our recommendation [0:35:48] for reappointment of Brian and Richard [0:35:51] and new appointment of chance to serve on that mission. [0:35:58] Nicky Boy? [0:35:59] Yes, I would like to move that we can [0:36:02] firm the reappointment of Brian Rice and Richard Burrell [0:36:06] and the appointment of Chance Munst [0:36:08] to serve on the Parks and Recreation Commission. [0:36:11] Ruth Pierce. [0:36:12] Second. [0:36:13] Emotion by Nicky Boy is second of my Ruth Pierce [0:36:15] to approve those appointments. [0:36:17] I should mention that Chance is here if anyone would like to grill him and offer him an institutional quiz or anything like that. [0:36:25] No, we're all good there. [0:36:27] So Chance is actually the professor in the horticulture programs at CSI. [0:36:33] So comes with some good background and some of the horticulture type programs that the Parks and Rec Commission absorbed when the tree commission became part of their function. [0:36:44] part of their function, so I think they'll serve an outstanding role there. [0:36:48] There are any further discussion? [0:36:53] Hang on, Sharon, roll call vote, please. [0:36:56] Nicky Boyd? [0:36:57] Yes. [0:36:58] Suzanne Hawkins? [0:36:59] Yes. [0:37:00] Ruth Pears? [0:37:01] Yes. [0:37:02] Christopher Reed? [0:37:03] Yes. [0:37:04] Chris Hockington? [0:37:05] Yes. [0:37:06] John Berriger? [0:37:07] Yes. [0:37:08] Motion passes with six to zero. [0:37:09] Thank you to Brian and Richard for their service. [0:37:11] Look forward to their continued service. [0:37:13] chance. Thanks for coming tonight and congratulations on your appointment. You'll be getting lots [0:37:18] of information about when your next meeting is. Next on the agenda is a request to award the [0:37:25] contract for the on-site sodium hypochlorite generator project to process solution incorporated in [0:37:32] Campbell, California through sales representative Waterford Systems of Salt Lake City, Utah on the [0:37:37] amount of $99,500 and we have Jason Brown, environmental engineer. Thank you, Mr. Mayor, [0:37:44] Council members appreciate this opportunity to come back again if you [0:37:48] remember about a month ago came and asked it the bits for this same project be [0:37:53] rejected since that time had an opportunity to go back through this [0:37:58] specification for this particular piece of equipment work with the water [0:38:02] department a little bit more and modify this this back to allow a few extra [0:38:10] items in associated with that. One of those being the PLC or the the brains of this [0:38:18] particular piece of equipment we allowed a more readily available PLC to be used. [0:38:25] The water department is transitioning and trying to do it more of what is [0:38:29] commercially available. The last one had a specific one that really is specific [0:38:34] to the city of Twin Falls and so tonight I come come back to actually go ahead and [0:38:39] have the council recommended the council to allow staff to go ahead and purchase this [0:38:46] piece of equipment, enter into contract to purchase this technically from Waterford [0:38:52] Tech company out of Salt Lake for the amount of $99,500. [0:39:00] With that I'll stand for any questions or are there any questions for Jason? [0:39:07] Yeah, I guess Jason, I just gave us an overview of what is a water disinfectant process, but [0:39:14] how is that different from the main water decontamination process? [0:39:18] So this process generates basically household bleach. [0:39:22] The hyperchloride is household bleach. [0:39:25] We currently operate a 100 pound unit down in the canyon right now, and this one allows [0:39:31] us, this new piece of equipment will do 200 pounds per day, which allows us to continue [0:39:36] to grow as a community. It's the same piece of equipment that we have in there right now [0:39:43] bought from the same company, same vendor, but what we're doing is generating household [0:39:48] bleach to inject into our collection system to help with disinfection and provide high [0:39:55] quality of water to our citizens. And so the requirement regulation by the state, the state [0:40:05] controls the the potable water system and so yeah it's it's a requirement for [0:40:10] us to go ahead disinfect or providing level of disinfection in our drinking [0:40:15] water system. Thank you. Thank you Boyd. I think you answered my question but I [0:40:20] need one clarification so currently we're doing a hundred pounds a day but we're [0:40:25] we're paying for that. Yes and no we we own the equipment that generates a [0:40:32] hundred pounds per day so you generate volume of this product and it's slowly [0:40:37] injected into the system so we own the equipment the hundred pound generator [0:40:42] is actually going to be put in another location here in towns we're gonna use [0:40:47] that same there's still life available for that unit we're gonna take that [0:40:52] and put it up down here and put a bigger unit down in the candy since most of our [0:40:57] water comes through that facility city. [0:41:00] And Jason, what is asked of the cost on this is significantly less than the engineering [0:41:07] estimate. [0:41:08] It is for that again. [0:41:09] So part of the part of the reason was is the initial one we had a very specific computer [0:41:15] program or a computer logic controller inside of that. [0:41:21] The city uses has historically used a GE version which come to find out is is quite a bit more [0:41:27] expensive than what the industry uses as an Allen Bradley unit talking to the [0:41:33] vendor because I had the same question trying to figure out where why such a [0:41:37] discrepancy and he quoted or estimated that was about a forty to fifty thousand [0:41:42] dollar change just with that controller itself because it's it's a Allen Bradley [0:41:48] is more of an industry standard and then there was a we chose it this [0:41:55] particular one, come to find out part of the lessons learned in the process was the actual [0:42:01] installation having somebody else install that for us really muddy the waters a little bit [0:42:09] and trying to figure out some of that logistics and so on this particular one we actually will [0:42:13] have city staff go ahead and do that installation we'll hire an electrician to do some of the [0:42:19] electrical connections that we have, but working out, so that's really where the [0:42:26] discrepancies came in from other discrepancies in the right direction. [0:42:31] Yes. [0:42:32] Yes. [0:42:33] The other questions? [0:42:34] Yeah, another question. [0:42:39] I would sum up to award the contract for the onsite, sodium, or right generator project [0:42:44] to process solutioning of Campbell, California through sales rep, Waterford [0:42:49] of Salt Lake City, Utah, the amount, $99,500, Ruth Pierce. [0:42:55] I'll second that one. [0:42:57] The motion by Chris Stockington, second by Ruth Pierce, [0:42:59] to approve the request as presented. [0:43:01] Is there any further discussion here? [0:43:05] And we'll call it, please. [0:43:09] Suzanne Hawkins. [0:43:11] Yes. [0:43:12] Ruth Pierce. [0:43:13] Christopher Reed. [0:43:14] Yes. [0:43:15] Chris Tockington. [0:43:16] Yes. [0:43:17] Don Berger. [0:43:18] Yes. [0:43:19] Nick Kiboid. [0:43:20] Yes. [0:43:21] Motion passes 6 to 0. [0:43:22] Thank you very much. [0:43:23] Thank you Jason. Have fun with it. [0:43:25] Next on the agenda is a request to award APID to Whitener Fire for Airport Firefighting Tools [0:43:33] and Equipment in the amount of $106,819.41 under FFAAAP Grant-40 and we have Bill Carver Airport [0:43:44] Manager. [0:43:45] Well thank you very good evening council members. [0:43:49] Going back to the fall, I came to you with a bit of award for a new fire truck for the [0:43:55] airport to replace the 1996 vehicle that we have out there now. [0:44:00] So that was awarded to Rose and Bauer Firefighting Equipment Company to build us that truck. [0:44:06] We're expecting delivery this December at the end of the calendar here. [0:44:10] So in order to dress that truck out with the proper firefighting tools and equipment and [0:44:15] radios and headsets, we went about to bid those separately from the truck and that was [0:44:20] through the advice of the FAA to sort of break the tools out from the manufacturer of the [0:44:25] truck. So with that we worked to get out the ARF equipment, we have craft rescue firefighting [0:44:32] the vehicle equipment bid out and in February we opened bids and we'll bring that up on [0:44:39] the screen here. I'm supposed to give them the highest sign I think is what it is. So on [0:44:47] So on the on your screens now we've got the engineers estimate for that [0:44:51] RF equipment and that includes everything from [0:44:55] the uniforms they wear, the coats, the turnouts, [0:44:59] all kinds of hooks, ladders, tools, all kinds of things like that. [0:45:04] So the engineers estimate on that equipment [0:45:08] was about $111,700. We [0:45:12] near fire came in low at $106,819. [0:45:16] Ellen Curtis was a little bit higher than, you know, 110,000, 897, so a very close bit. [0:45:22] We're thinking it would be somewhere in the small park, so we were pleased that the numbers [0:45:26] did come in there. [0:45:28] These cons will be funded through the FAA Airport Improvement Program, Ground 40, which the council [0:45:34] and both the county accepted back in the fall as well. [0:45:39] So we do have the dollars with the FAA to go ahead and do that. [0:45:42] We work closely with the fire department to spec out this equipment in great detail. [0:45:47] There's like 60 items, I think, overall on that list. [0:45:52] So we also have, coming up next, broken out the radio bit, which is more of an informal bidding process. [0:45:58] And I'll talk about that next. [0:46:00] But I'd like to answer any questions you have about this and also recommend approval to low-bid being weeding your fire. [0:46:07] Any questions for Bill related to the youth? [0:46:11] I move that we approve the request to award the bid to the wheat nerds. [0:46:24] I say why you're but I'm wrong. [0:46:27] I are at airport firefighting tool and equipment in the amount of $106,819.41 under the FAA [0:46:37] AIP Grant 40. [0:46:38] Thank you, boy. [0:46:39] Well, second that. [0:46:40] I had a question, but I'll ask it next time. [0:46:44] You can ask it now. [0:46:45] Can I ask it now? [0:46:46] So, Bill, tell me a little bit about, in all the report, it talked about a 6.25% local [0:46:54] match. [0:46:55] Is that attached to every AIP 40? [0:46:58] Is that standard that those go together? [0:47:02] Yeah, the relationship that we have with the FAA, it's a good one. [0:47:06] It's a good one, they've been with us a long, long time [0:47:08] and working through these capital projects. [0:47:10] There's a local match component, [0:47:13] and ours here in the state of Idaho is 6.25%. [0:47:17] And the airport is able, fortunately, [0:47:19] to fund that match through their passenger facility charges, [0:47:22] which is another program, sort of a ticket fee [0:47:24] that the airlines for to us and collect. [0:47:27] So we're able to use user fees, those that are passengers, [0:47:30] to match our products, our projects out there. [0:47:33] So, in a sense, that match is user feedback [0:47:36] rather than local, locally-supported taxes. [0:47:39] Thank you, and I do second it. [0:47:42] Thank you, Chris, talking to him. [0:47:44] Well, just like that, what Bill said, [0:47:46] it is in essence a user tax. [0:47:49] I'd like to look at it, Nicky, [0:47:51] and it's really almost 93 and a half percent local. [0:47:56] And also with the additional bar of fourth light, [0:48:00] I think it's all the more reason for us [0:48:03] keep our firefighting tools and equipment on the cutting edge of both the quality and the each of them. [0:48:10] So this is a very important addition. [0:48:14] Well Chris, I am a big local user. It's the only way I fly, so I'm happy to contribute my part. [0:48:21] Thank you. We see you out there often. Any further discussion? [0:48:27] We have a motion by Suzanne Hawkins, seconded by Nikki Boyd to approve the request as presented. [0:48:32] Sharon, we'll call a vote please. [0:48:34] Ruth Pears? [0:48:35] Yes. [0:48:36] Christopher Reed? [0:48:37] Yes. [0:48:38] Chris Hockington? [0:48:39] Yes. [0:48:40] Don Berrigger? [0:48:41] Yes. [0:48:42] Nicky Boy? [0:48:43] Yes. [0:48:44] Suzanne Hawkins? [0:48:45] Yes. [0:48:47] S is six to zero. [0:48:48] So next we have Bill with the Bill Carver Show. [0:48:52] Request to award a bid to White Cloud Communications for Airport Fire Truck Radio Headset Equipment [0:48:59] in the amount of $9,796. [0:49:02] Again, under FAAIAP grant, $40,000. [0:49:06] Thank you, Mayor. [0:49:07] Thank you. [0:49:08] This is a companion request here for headsets and radio equipment, and we took an informal [0:49:15] bidding process. [0:49:16] We, the estimate was somewhere around $10,000, talked with the FAA since these radios are [0:49:22] very particular to the firefighters. [0:49:24] They looked for some uniformity in their equipment and their headsets in the way they operate, [0:49:29] and considering the price range. [0:49:31] We were able to go out to three suppliers with a spec on a radio and the headsets, and [0:49:37] we got prices from all three. [0:49:39] So, Rosenberry was the vehicle manufacturer at $13,025, wireless $10,555, and local firm [0:49:50] white cloud communication came with low bid at $9,796, so all very competitive bids. [0:49:57] And I'd recommend we give the radio equipment and headset a bid award to White Cloud Communication. [0:50:03] I'd be happy to answer any questions I might be. [0:50:06] Any questions for Bill on this item? [0:50:13] In motion, Suzanne Hawkins. [0:50:21] I will move that we read award the bid to White Cloud Communications for airport fire truck radio headset equipment [0:50:29] in the amount of $9,796 also under the FAA AP Grant 40. [0:50:36] Motion by Suzanne Hawkins, seconded by Christopher Reed to approve the request. [0:50:43] Awarded in the bid to white-clad communications as presented. [0:50:47] Is there further discussion? [0:50:51] Mayor Wolkow, please. [0:50:52] Christopher Reed? [0:50:58] Yes. [0:50:59] Chris Stockington? [0:51:00] Yes. [0:51:01] Don Berriger? [0:51:02] Yes. [0:51:03] Nikki Boyd? [0:51:04] Yes. [0:51:05] Suzanne Hawkins? [0:51:06] Yes. [0:51:07] Yes. [0:51:08] Special passes six to zero. [0:51:09] Thank you Bill. [0:51:10] Thank you. [0:51:11] Next on the agenda is a request to present an update on the current state of the recycling [0:51:18] program and market and we have Bill Baxter, our utility services supervisor. [0:51:23] Welcome Bill. [0:51:25] Thank you, Mayor and Council. [0:51:27] It's a pleasure to be here. [0:51:29] Keep expecting you to turn down my invitation. [0:51:35] So, following our first roughly month of this program, I wanted to come before you. [0:51:43] and try to give you a little update as to where the month of March took us. [0:51:50] I don't believe, following that March 12th conversation, that there was any surprise. [0:51:58] Excuse me a moment. There it is. Okay. [0:52:07] We started out the month without having asked Council's permission to redirect recycling tonnage to the landfill. [0:52:15] So, PSI reported to me today that 31.99 tons went to the recycling stream at $164 a ton [0:52:27] for the first part of March. [0:52:29] PSI's cost on that $5246.36. [0:52:35] The yellow highlighted item would be the cost-share calculation, but that is there for informational [0:52:42] purposes only this evening. [0:52:44] I would be an item that under our contract, I believe I need to bring back to you, but I [0:52:49] had not had a chance to visit with Travis and Lori before this meeting, so I just have [0:52:54] that up there for everybody's information. [0:52:56] If we decide to come back and make that request, we will do that at a later time. [0:53:02] The tonnage that went to the landfill, which is probably our greatest appointment, but [0:53:07] still part of the plan, 122.75 tons at a landfill cost of $4,603.13. The fee increases that were [0:53:20] approved in the rate resolution on March 12 and beginning to be assessed April 1st will [0:53:27] help us cover that additional cost. So then garbage only just filled in for informational purposes, [0:53:35] $1,115,000 per 0.63 tons, again cost $41,836,000 total landfill cost there on the inside, actually [0:53:53] with a couple of odd items which is where the reconciliation comes in, the total amount [0:53:58] on our statement this month was $46,452.99. [0:54:08] So to put this in a little bit of perspective, the tonnage collected for recycling over [0:54:15] the last, I've got eight years here, but in 2017, 177,000, or 177.6 tons, 2016, 167.54, [0:54:28] 2015, 156, 82, and from there we were in the 150 range for 2014 and 13, and it had fallen [0:54:40] from 2011, which was our first big year of the single stream where it was 177 tons. [0:54:47] So we're in the range, despite the confusion and the disappointment, I guess, that has led [0:54:56] to perhaps a fall-off in that product as well as changes in the product going into the stream. [0:55:03] Market conditions at the present time, the price of the product continues to slide downward. [0:55:11] This is partly because of the volume stockpiles increasing without enough shipping shipped [0:55:18] because of contamination requirements. [0:55:21] In addition, Jeff tells me that they hear through the grapevine, some loads have actually [0:55:26] shipped in the last couple of weeks to China under the new requirements. [0:55:32] Everybody's watching that to see when it arrives, what the inspectors will do and or say about [0:55:37] the quality of the stream. [0:55:38] So we're hopeful, but there isn't any real bright spots showing at the present time. [0:55:45] Cost factor also because of a slide in the corrugated cardboard price and no significant [0:55:52] change in processing costs means that they anticipate the cost for April will be above $164 a ton. [0:55:59] So we will continue on the current path, hoping for some improvement. Change in the market conditions [0:56:07] as we've said before will require some time. Some end users are going to need to invest [0:56:13] in order to process the material here into a usable form. [0:56:18] What I hear from Jeff, and what's in the news, [0:56:21] some recyclers are beginning to modify and upgrade their sorting equipment [0:56:26] to lower the contamination standard, [0:56:29] and that as this takes place, they will then begin to fire up [0:56:34] and begin to accept and pay for recycled product costs [0:56:41] that our price being paid will affect the cost of the processing net to us, but that is way out in the future. [0:56:48] Jeff is also saying that most of the analysts are saying it'll most likely be between six and eighteen months before there is any swing to the positive side in this process. [0:56:59] So the city and PSI's focus at this time. [0:57:05] We're going to continue to work on more effective and complete delivery of information on the items that are recyclable. [0:57:11] I've heard a number of times in a number of places, it's very confusing and or difficult to find any information. [0:57:18] And we're looking for how those items need to be not only delivered but prepared so that they will better inform the public. [0:57:28] We're trying to get that kind of information out as to when the service is offered. [0:57:34] What week is your recycle week? We have an interactive GIS map, which on the city website [0:57:40] look on the garbage and recycle. It'll say see the map. All you have to do is accept the terms that are your address and it'll pull up. [0:57:48] Not only what week your recycle week is, but what day your garbage collection is. So it's really quite helpful, but we need to inform more people about how that is used. [0:57:59] We do have calendars available, but this map is awesome. [0:58:03] map is awesome. So, we also are linked to PSI's website and they have a new graphic, which [0:58:12] I'm going to try to pull up here, gives hopefully a little bit clearer information, not only [0:58:22] if they included placement of the cart, so we avoid some of the blocking of the cart from [0:58:28] collection and or other difficulties, but have narrowed down the definition of the kinds [0:58:34] of items that fit into the recycled single-stream process. [0:58:38] That little blue oval up on the top right, [0:58:41] as I'm looking at it, also says please be sure [0:58:43] to clean the product. [0:58:46] Because contamination continues to be probably [0:58:50] the biggest nemesis. [0:58:51] I don't remember if we have been in front of you [0:58:55] to share this, but one day I got an email from PSI's office [0:59:00] staff saying they're a driver. [0:59:01] just called in and dumping a recycle cart out on the northwest side of town, motor oil [0:59:06] went all over the side of the truck, ended up on the sidewalk splattered on the truck [0:59:10] at the residence as well as covering the cart. [0:59:16] So there's some communication that needs to take place, that doesn't go on the garbage [0:59:20] either. [0:59:22] But we're working to get out there, keep the communication going, and as our website is [0:59:28] modified we hope to improve the information that's available. [0:59:34] We also aren't going to try to spread the word about other recycling sites, I know that [0:59:41] the Times News had a nice link in there. [0:59:44] Some of those places, transfer station is awesome. [0:59:46] You can call those nice people. [0:59:48] They'll take batteries, motor oil, and other hazardous chemicals, appliances, tires, all [0:59:54] kinds of things that people tend to either put in the garbage can or just throw somewhere. [1:00:02] The other specific steel and recycling, United Metals, Magic Valley Recycling, and Dart Container, [1:00:08] I was pleased to see this because so much styrofoam ends up in blue cards, including mine sometimes. [1:00:14] So I've got a better place to go. [1:00:16] We want to work on contamination reduction. [1:00:20] That will make all the difference when the stream changes and the price of the product [1:00:25] changes. [1:00:26] If we can keep the contamination, dirty diapers, sticks, lawn clippings. [1:00:33] kind of things that just don't fit the single stream, brings us back to our [1:00:37] communication. We need to provide a good example. I have the pleasure each week of [1:00:43] taking our recycled cards out and I've been extremely happy with the few times [1:00:48] I've had to say, hey you need to take the lid off that bottle, you need to empty [1:00:53] the contents and this city staff responded with great speed. So our [1:01:00] Our recycle is much cleaned up, so we're providing a good example, I believe, and we'll [1:01:06] continue to. [1:01:08] We also need to be available. [1:01:10] Jeff Bruce, your Josh Palmer, and I were at Twin Falls High School to speak to the Environmental [1:01:13] Club last Friday, answer questions they had to kind of get the word out about what the [1:01:19] experience of collecting and trying to deliver into a stream of what those issues are that [1:01:26] we have run into and ask how we might, from their perspective, do a better job of communicating [1:01:33] and getting the word out at a very receptive audience. [1:01:38] And then on April 20th, we will be at CSI for the Sustainability Fair for about three [1:01:43] hours with some examples of what goes in, what does not go in at the issues we've had, [1:01:49] so we hope to get that communication out there. [1:01:52] So with that I would stand for any questions, comments, you know where I live, so we're always [1:01:57] willing to take any good suggestions about what you see as how we can improve. [1:02:04] Chris Stockington. [1:02:05] Will Bell, I could give extreme vote of confidence for what you're doing. [1:02:11] You've got your mind and your hands around a moving target. [1:02:15] And I hope every month we'll get a report from you on the changing economy of recycling. [1:02:23] I must say though that I have had a few city topics where I continue to get across the board. [1:02:31] I'm speaking of all demographics and ages of people who realize we're in a state of flux. [1:02:36] It'll be sometime before we get a clarification, but they are still even people on fixed income [1:02:43] of the social consciousness and awareness that they want us to stick with it until hopefully [1:02:50] there's more permanent uptrend in the market. I would certainly hope that we can do all [1:02:56] the advertising through City Resources, our website, and water bill for cutting down the [1:03:05] contamination factor. I would also be interested if you can find out more about cost associated [1:03:12] with the better separation of the viable versus the non-viable. [1:03:19] Is that an automated system or just a manpower and testing process? [1:03:23] Well, my understanding is this is, I told Jeff, I, you know, he was excused this evening, [1:03:28] but I believe, Chris, that what they do is they use mechanical to separate metals. [1:03:36] Okay. [1:03:37] But once it gets down to the paper stream, it's on a belt, and it is sorted by individuals. [1:03:43] Now there is technology available to improve the detailed amount of sorting that will happen [1:03:48] with the equipment, and that is the direction I understand these processors are looking to [1:03:55] keep their cost as low as possible, and improve the sorting. [1:04:00] And I guess most of the plastic is a manual processor, then? [1:04:04] Yes, sir. [1:04:05] But I think that the optical equipment can separate plastics, it just can't separate the types. [1:04:14] So we're stuck with that one and two, and I'm not sure what the report might be from Western, especially as we're not sending it there. [1:04:25] But we have to keep the three through seven out of that process. [1:04:28] Thank you. [1:04:30] Thank you, boy. [1:04:31] I really like pictures where it's a thousand words on this. [1:04:36] This is great because I have people email and call [1:04:41] and therefore recycling even if it, you know, [1:04:45] they have to spend a little bit more money. [1:04:47] But their question is, you know, what's changed? [1:04:50] And I said, well, you know, the one and the two is really big. [1:04:53] But not everybody knows that all the lids have to be removed. [1:04:58] And so I think this is a really good thing that you're doing and that they can find it on the website [1:05:04] Is that garbage and recycling click on the website? I can't picture that. It's just right on the front [1:05:11] I went if you go to the home page [1:05:14] There's a blue box. I think it says citizen services [1:05:19] If you hover over that box [1:05:21] box on a whole new window pops up in the middle of the screen and I always fail to do this. [1:05:28] I would not be a good video game person because I always try to cut across and as soon as you [1:05:33] leave the blue box the thing goes away so you have to hover over the blue box, drop into [1:05:37] the new one and then scroll over to Garbage and Recycling. [1:05:41] You click on that, it will open the Garbage and Recycling section of the Twin Falls City [1:05:46] website. [1:05:47] And then there are links to PSI environmental click on that and oh here we go [1:05:56] Recycling PSI environmental systems when you click there [1:06:00] It will open their home page and recycling services is where you want to click [1:06:05] And that opens the page where if you scroll down at the bottom of that page [1:06:10] This and if there are experts here at the city of Twin Falls [1:06:14] I'm looking around for who it all is there you go [1:06:19] Recycling Services, scroll down and click on the Recycle Flyer. The Washington Recycling [1:06:33] Resource Association is a is a verbal document with the list but this is where the BSI document [1:06:40] is. And these are the kinds of tools that I know we need to move to. I notice with great [1:06:46] interest they have an other section with lines and that addresses the who knows [1:06:53] some point in time we may have to tell people that you know the mixed paper [1:06:59] great throw your magazines in there but that little plastic wrapper that comes [1:07:03] on with the recycling symbol that's contamination if you put it in the [1:07:10] recycling bin with the magazine inside it I did have one other question which [1:07:15] was my first question really. So we're looking at as much as 18 months to really get a footing [1:07:23] on what the market's going to do, how this low to China is going to be assessed and what [1:07:29] our future is. Are we also, while we're pursuing all this stuff, are we also looking at new [1:07:36] avenues of how to use recyclable materials? I'm seeing a lot what other countries are [1:07:43] doing with your garbage and they're burning it. They're doing all kinds of things with it. [1:07:50] And I'm not an environmental biologist, so I don't know if that pollutes your error or what that does, [1:07:55] but it seems like there's a lot of options out there what to do with with recycled materials that [1:08:03] are going to the ultimately a landfill somewhere that wouldn't need any discussion on that. [1:08:09] There is, it's interesting that you bring up the alternative methods and the burning, [1:08:16] because I know I saw a video from Facebook that Travis shared with me, [1:08:23] Sweden burning their garbage and importing garbage apparently from other countries to do that. [1:08:27] So I asked Jeff Brewster about that when we were at the Twin Falls High School. [1:08:32] He told me that there is a facility like that in Detroit that is currently being sued, [1:08:36] or the pollution it's introducing into the environment. So and if you were going [1:08:44] to do that I didn't even bother looking up the cost of establishing that kind of [1:08:48] facility but it would push it out there and cost somebody quite a bit. So that [1:08:55] probably is not a near-term solution. The one thing I was interested in, I saw an [1:09:03] article. I think Jeff said this to me too from Boise about a project that they are [1:09:09] involved in with plastics numbers three through seven. They have to be [1:09:15] separated as it goes back to Sean's or Chris's question about sorting. They have [1:09:20] to be sorted manually by the resident. Boise is providing orange plastic bags in [1:09:30] in which to place those kinds of plastics. [1:09:33] It's at a curbside and they will be picked up. [1:09:36] They are apparently going to Phoenix, Arizona. [1:09:40] And the city of Phoenix has some kind of a project going [1:09:42] where that will be converted into a biodiesel kind of product. [1:09:47] So I asked Jeff about that, Boise. [1:09:50] Phoenix is coming through twin. [1:09:52] Can we participate? [1:09:54] And how would we begin to approach that? [1:09:56] And his first comment was, which addresses [1:09:59] the contamination issue is those plastics would have to be washed and cleaned completely before [1:10:07] being placed in the bag, because if there's any contamination in that, they will be turned [1:10:11] away from the program, because you can't create the biodiesel unless the plastic is just the [1:10:17] plastic. [1:10:18] Again, that's probably closer to a short-term solution for plastics that I'd love to be [1:10:24] able to throw in a bag, but what our success would be with contamination or who would be [1:10:32] be checking it. [1:10:33] Certainly, we are looking at those kinds of things, even glass, if we could figure out [1:10:39] a way to handle and manage glass and then a destination descended to, we would be willing [1:10:45] to do that. [1:10:46] The question just is, what kind of a facility, how would we load any trucks coming through? [1:10:53] So we are looking at those kinds of things. [1:10:58] Any other comments or questions for Bill? [1:11:00] And I think to kind of maybe wrap up some of the comments here. There's certainly a community interest in [1:11:07] Sustainability and trying to do the right thing [1:11:10] The economics and the market right now [1:11:13] Maybe aren't the most cooperative, but as we continue to move forward [1:11:17] Looking for alternatives and ways to make the program work as best we can in light of conditions that are way out of our control [1:11:24] I appreciate all that you've done and that PSI is doing to try to help us make it through that [1:11:31] Thank you. It's exciting to see that the community is behind this effort. [1:11:35] I think it's important to consider the environment we live in in the future. [1:11:40] Thank you. [1:11:44] Next on the agenda is another opportunity for general public input. [1:11:47] If there's anyone from the public who wishes to address the council, [1:11:50] now has your chance to come forward being no one advisory board reports from the council. [1:12:01] I think from the city manager's office. [1:12:08] Tomorrow is the state of the city address. [1:12:14] It starts at 11 o'clock at the Orpheum. [1:12:18] It is a event that the city participates with the chamber. [1:12:22] We're going to start at 11 o'clock. [1:12:25] So this is hopefully you all know because you have speaking parts tomorrow. [1:12:29] And this is really more for the audience than those who might be watching through streaming media and video. [1:12:37] After that you'll be receiving a coupon for lunch that you'll be able to participate in one of many downtown different merchants. [1:12:44] So, a really good diverse collection of topics really focused around the strategic plan. [1:12:50] So, we encourage everyone to come join here at the State of the City of the Love to Collect [1:12:54] Tomorrow at the Orpheum. [1:12:55] Tickets are $15 available by Colin and the Chamber. [1:13:01] We're here to launch a goop on. [1:13:05] Alright, seeing nothing else then, nothing else on the agenda, we will. [1:13:10] And adjourned. [1:13:11] Yes, for the Community Support Center open house on May 12th, yep, that was approved on the [1:13:31] consent calendar way at the beginning of the being so I apologize for that for [1:13:35] not pointing it out to you were approved so you're all good but hey you get to [1:13:40] hang out for a whole councilor so