Oversight Archive: City Council meeting, 2018-04-23, recording 1 (started 17:00) Machine transcript (faster-whisper base.en), not checked word for word; the Pledge of Allegiance is shown in its standard wording. The recording is the record. Times are time into the recording. Passages with private details are muted in the audio and marked here. The audio on the page below was re-encoded by software from the video the agency posted. Check any passage against that audio before relying on it. Page: https://oversightarchive.org/twin-falls-id/meetings/2018-04-23/ [0:00:05] going to call the meeting to order of the for Monday April 23rd of the Twin [0:00:09] Falls City Council. We have six of the seven members here and everybody who [0:00:17] would like to join us in the Pledge of Allegiance please stand. Travis do we have [0:00:44] any amendments to the agenda this evening? Madam Vice Mayor members the [0:00:48] Council staff would ask for an addition of one member to be included one item to [0:00:54] be included, and that is the city's commitment to a safer grant which stands for Staffing for [0:01:03] Adequate Fire and Emergency Response personnel. The safer grant requires us to fund the individuals [0:01:13] that we would bring on that were requesting for a 36 month period because this would encumber [0:01:19] funds in future years we wanted to get counsel's commitment prior to submitting to the grant. [0:01:25] We are asking tonight as opposed to next week because this requirement just came up [0:01:31] and was made aware of it and the grant applications do this Friday. [0:01:37] So we want to put it on the agenda tonight to have the conversation out of the debate. [0:01:42] So would it be an item of consideration? [0:01:45] It would be an item of consideration and we would move it to item D as in dog. [0:01:50] Thank you very much. [0:01:51] Motion by Chris Tuckington, seconded by Suzanne Moten. [0:01:59] Suzanne Moten. [0:02:00] I changed her last name. [0:02:06] Does Sharon Roll call vote please? [0:02:15] Suzanne Hockington? [0:02:16] Yes. [0:02:17] Nikki Boyd? [0:02:18] Yes. [0:02:19] Don Bambar. [0:02:20] Chris Hockington? [0:02:22] Yes. [0:02:23] Greg Lanting? [0:02:24] Yes. [0:02:25] Christopher Reed? [0:02:26] Yes. [0:02:27] Ruth Pierce? [0:02:38] carries 6 to 0. Proclamation is Arbor Day. Earth Day was Earth Day Sunday. [0:02:52] Arbor Day Proclamation, whereas in 1872, J. Sterling Morton proposed to the Nebraska [0:03:04] Board of Agriculture that a special day be set aside for the planting of trees, [0:03:09] and whereas this holiday called Arbor Day was first observed with the planting of more than [0:03:15] in a million trees in Nebraska, and whereas Arbor Day is now observed throughout the nation [0:03:21] and the world, and whereas trees can reduce the erosion of our precious topsoil by wind [0:03:27] and water, cut heating and cooling costs, moderate the temperature, clean the air, produce oxygen, [0:03:35] and provide habitat for wildlife, and whereas trees are a renewable resource giving us paper, [0:03:42] for our homes, fuel for our fires, and countless other wood products, and whereas trees in our [0:03:49] city increase property values, enhance the economic vitality of business areas, and beautify [0:03:56] our community. And whereas trees wherever they are planted are a source of joy and spiritual [0:04:03] renewal. Now therefore, I, Sean Verger, Mayor of the City of Twin Falls, do hereby proclaim [0:04:10] Friday, April 27, 2018, as Arbor Day in the City of Twin Falls, and I urge all [0:04:17] citizens to celebrate Arbor Day and to support efforts to protect our trees and [0:04:22] woodlands. And further, I urge all citizens to plant trees to gladden the heart and [0:04:28] promote the well-being of this and future generations, [0:04:32] it's dated the 23rd day of April signed by the mayor. I'd like to present this to [0:04:38] our parks and recreation director with the city's [0:05:01] Arbor Day celebration will be held at 4 p.m. on Friday, April [0:05:06] 20th. Oh boy. Great, so thank you. At 4 p.m. at Oregon Trail [0:05:12] Youth Complex, we partner with cactus peats, always makes a [0:05:17] donation for a couple of trees and bring a bunch of [0:05:20] volunteers out and we invite anybody to join us out there at [0:05:25] and we'll read the proclamation and this is our 20th year as a tree city so that's [0:05:31] kind of a neat thing to do so we'll get our award for our for our for our tree city USA and then we'll have plenty of [0:05:39] shovels to have people help us plant some trees. Thank you very much. At this time it is an opportunity [0:05:50] for general public input if there's anyone who wishes to speak on an item that is not on the [0:05:56] this evening's agenda. Please come down and state your name and whether you live [0:06:00] or own property in the city. I'm on down. I'm not sure that one is really working. [0:06:20] Has it been fixed? It is. Oh, here. No. Okay. Thanks. I'm Terry Edwards. I own property [0:06:30] in Twin Falls. I have a question and I might not be in the right location, but [0:06:34] under general public input, her items not on the agenda. Does that include what Travis [0:06:41] just talked about. No, that comes under under art. There are any amendments to the agenda item number three. [0:06:50] Okay. Well, can I speak on it then at this time? I guess what I'm trying to get at is I'd like a little bit more [0:06:57] clarification if this is an obligation for the city to expend expenditures past the grant period of the safe program. [0:07:06] I'd like to know a little bit more details about the program and what kind of financial [0:07:13] Requirement it would be for the city. Also. I would like in the future that any grants that we get that we get the full detail of the grant [0:07:22] And the city's obligation for that grant. Does that make sense? [0:07:28] We get grants and everybody's old clapping their hands [0:07:31] but then when the grant goes away then we have to foot the bill generally and I [0:07:36] would like to know what the details would be on that if there's any grants [0:07:40] that we get that have long-term obligations that encumber the city in [0:07:45] any way I would like to know that up from when those grants are presented and [0:07:49] accepted. So, Madam Vice Mayor, Mr. Edwards this is going to be discussed on [0:07:55] the agenda under items of consideration 7D isn't up and I will be more than [0:08:01] I'm happy to address all of your questions to my best ability at that point in time. [0:08:06] Okay, so I will be able to get up and ask you some additional questions. [0:08:10] That will be up to the chair of the meeting as to whether that should be able to participate. [0:08:14] Yeah, I was going to say it's not a public hearing, but often we have somebody who has questions, so that's fine. [0:08:20] And I have another question. [0:08:23] Yes. [0:08:24] While I'm talking here, on the back of this is public input procedures, but I don't see any statements saying that if it's... [0:08:30] If it's on the agenda, we can't speak about it. [0:08:37] You said, when you mentioned and made the announcement [0:08:40] of general public input for items not on the agenda, [0:08:44] where does that, where is that indicated in our code [0:08:48] or on this public input procedures? [0:08:50] Well, that is our general standard of operation in that. [0:08:56] If it's on the agenda, of course we're going to talk about it. [0:08:59] And so if somebody has something that isn't on the agenda, [0:09:03] where would we place it on the agenda? [0:09:05] So that's why we call it general public input. [0:09:08] So that gives people an opportunity to come up and say [0:09:12] something or ask a question that's not on the agenda, [0:09:15] because we follow our agenda as a order of rule. [0:09:18] I understand that. [0:09:19] OK. [0:09:22] This question really is, what are the rules of the public speaking [0:09:26] during the items of consideration as opposed [0:09:28] to the public hearings? [0:09:30] I believe so, I just want to add a different answer. [0:09:32] And the answer is, it's up to the city council. [0:09:35] You don't have a right to speak unless they recognize you. [0:09:38] Allow you to speak. [0:09:39] You have no right statutory or under code on items of consideration. [0:09:43] But as the acting mayor just said, I think frequently want that information from the public. [0:09:50] So you don't have the right to, but they may allow you to. [0:09:55] And that was my question when he brought that up for items of consideration, [0:09:59] because it's a slam dunk tonight to get this done [0:10:02] because apparently he needs to submit that request [0:10:06] or that approval for that to make a decision on it tonight [0:10:14] and it leaves a consideration item for consideration, correct? [0:10:18] Yes. [0:10:19] Okay, so it can't be discussed [0:10:20] because it wasn't somewhere else [0:10:22] on the agenda prior to tonight. [0:10:24] I believe he believes that this is sneaking in [0:10:28] under an item that doesn't allow public input. [0:10:32] The only items that go on public hearings are those items that statutorily require public hearings. [0:10:38] So whether this was on a regular agenda or not, it would appear on consideration and not the six o'clock calendar for this. [0:10:46] Does it this encumber and cost the city some money and it is a budget item? [0:10:51] Well, actually we're going to have a presentation by Travis and we'll get all the details. [0:10:56] details. The only reason it came up is something changed in the procedure and now the applications [0:11:03] are due on Friday. Okay. Yeah. You're welcome. Council wishes on the consent calendar. Second. [0:11:27] Motion by Chris Reed and seconded by Ruth Pierce. Any questions? Go call vote please. [0:11:44] Thank you, boy. [0:11:45] Yes. [0:11:46] Chris Hockington. [0:11:47] Yes. [0:11:48] Greg Lanting. [0:11:49] Yes. [0:11:50] Christopher Reed. [0:11:51] Yes. [0:11:52] Chris Pierce. [0:11:53] Yes. [0:11:54] Zann Hocking. [0:11:56] Yes. [0:11:57] That's a six to zero. [0:12:13] Thank you. [0:12:14] Items of consideration. [0:12:15] Our first one is a presentation on the Twin Falls County Emergency Operations Plan with [0:12:21] the request for a mayor signature on memorandum of understanding. [0:12:25] We have Jackie Fry. [0:12:27] Welcome. [0:12:28] Thank you. [0:12:30] Yes, I am the coordinator for the Office of Emergency Management and I do appreciate your time to the Twin Falls City Council to address the signature that I would like to ask you consider to sign, which would be the number and understanding to accept the Twin Falls County plan, which as you sign a tour to be a party to the plan, which is mirrored after the natural [0:12:58] National Response Plan is standard operating procedures that our first [0:13:02] responders use to support an event or incident within Twin Falls County. There [0:13:08] is no cost for your participation. At this time, I have a working relationship [0:13:13] with your first-responding agencies and over the last 21 years that I've been in [0:13:18] this job, which I deeply appreciate. But one of the things that I thought would be [0:13:24] very productive for each of you. I had visited with Brian Pike, was to give you [0:13:31] a brief overview of what I do and then actually show you a list of the items [0:13:36] that I've been able to support your city with with your first-responding [0:13:40] agencies that have actually been no breakdown for what I would say share [0:13:46] cost for you. It is of course federal funds but it is grants that I pursued on [0:13:52] on behalf of your agencies. [0:13:54] So I do a number of training and exercise [0:13:58] that I incorporate your first responders with, [0:14:01] as well as elected officials, or as well as any party [0:14:05] that you have within your community or city. [0:14:08] Citizens have been invited as well as those [0:14:11] that are from your public works, [0:14:14] fired upon law enforcement, any of those realms. [0:14:17] And those also have come at no cost to your city. [0:14:21] The incident command system is a methodology that we follow, all of the [0:14:26] first responding agencies address that, and so that we can coordinate, there's a [0:14:30] common practice to be able to respond to an incident. The eight cities that would [0:14:35] sign on to the plan are the eight cities under Twin Falls County. At this time here [0:14:41] one of two that are left to sign, but again it envelop or I guess I should say [0:14:47] and encompasses that opportunity for us to work as partners [0:14:51] and to be able to be team players, [0:14:54] to be able to support incidents, [0:14:56] or I guess I would say disasters within the county. [0:15:00] We certainly don't want to address that, [0:15:02] but we've seen the 2017 flooding issues. [0:15:06] We've seen that things that have happened. [0:15:09] With the state emergency relief funding, [0:15:11] we're seeing the city be able to receive some funding [0:15:14] that can come in to help support your infrastructure [0:15:16] in the city, such as the streets [0:15:18] the roads. So those are all kind of positive things. I also maintain a shelter board resource [0:15:27] inventory, critical infrastructure list at the state. So if something happens, we're [0:15:32] able to set up shelters with the American Red Cross, manage evacuations, and be able [0:15:37] to do those things to promote life safety. So all of those things are part of the, part [0:15:43] of those, I would say, mission for me, are the things that I believe strongly [0:15:48] and to make my program very positive. I'm working right now on a number of [0:15:52] whether it be school safety plans, it be plans for our functional needs [0:15:56] populations are with the Humane Society also with pets and being able to just [0:16:02] manage all of these rounds if something happened within the county. So, while my [0:16:08] job is very diverse and why it encompasses a lot of things, I have deeply [0:16:13] appreciate it, the opportunity to work with all of you and your first [0:16:17] responding agencies, and be able to have the support needed to continue [0:16:22] that. What I believe is a very positive relationship. And so that's really why [0:16:27] I was here today. I don't know if Mitch would be able to, well, present [0:16:32] that. But I know I have limited time, so I'm trying to be very professional. [0:16:38] But I do want to share with you in the 21 years that I've been in this job [0:16:42] After 9-11, it was critical that as a nation, we really see that the resources needed to sustain [0:16:51] and to promote safety within our country. [0:16:54] And the federal grants that were released to the county through pass-through funds from [0:16:58] the state of Idaho, Idaho Office of Emergency Management, is actually done by a population. [0:17:04] And I have been very fortunate to have this job for 21 years, but I feel strongly that [0:17:11] those funds should be used in a manner needed to support all agencies that help promote life [0:17:19] safety and also will help respond to manage and be able to recover from an incident or [0:17:27] disaster. [0:17:28] So the first grant actually or the first opportunity I had was to work with your bomb [0:17:34] squad for the City of Twin was our very first project and it was a $179,000 project to get [0:17:40] the robot which you're still using now which I was just able to if you look at [0:17:45] the very bottom project be able to work with JPO Donald and the team that you have [0:17:51] which again I have nothing but respect for to get a new robot the laptop and [0:17:57] portable x-ray machine so that it's smaller it's not as cumbersome and they're [0:18:02] able to respond to events I am having the hundred first civil support team [0:18:06] come into our county tomorrow. Over the years we've been very blessed. They're an incredible resource [0:18:12] and they will be working with your bomb squad, law enforcement, fire and our hospital tomorrow [0:18:18] to be able to really work on an event and use those resources to help support that. So [0:18:26] it's been really a neat opportunity. I've as you can see I've done things for the engineering department, [0:18:33] here again your police and bomb squad, your water department, fire police, [0:18:39] radios, a lot of the radios that we've needed have been to support, again [0:18:43] communication during an incident or disaster to promote life safety, and then [0:18:50] also now moving on down with current purchase. So totally I've been able to [0:18:59] support your city was $627,372.28, which I can tell you, none of the funding was, I guess [0:19:10] what I would say as it was gifted to your city or your departments, there was no matching [0:19:15] funds required, which I think is a tremendous blessing with the way that we see our budgets [0:19:21] and we see a cost to be able to continue those programs. [0:19:26] this I believe offsets money that you would have to use from your general fund [0:19:31] for these products we're able to support them. This is along with also our Twin [0:19:38] Falls Sheriff's Department. The eight cities we have five law enforcement [0:19:43] departments. I have four fire departments. I have public works departments that we've [0:19:49] put fencing and been able to do projects for and so not that I'm here to please [0:19:57] that I don't come to you because I'm arrogant. I think over the years that I've [0:20:02] been in my job people have questioned or wanted to know really what I've been [0:20:06] able to do and I thought it was important and Brian did too that I really [0:20:09] addressed those things with each. So I just wanted to give you that bit of [0:20:16] information. I am very excited to work with your new fire chief. I've done an [0:20:21] incredible job of firing him and we have already met several times and I believe [0:20:27] that the City of Twin with the growth we're seeing in population, transportation [0:20:33] issues and stuff. I want to I guess pledge to you or commit to you that I [0:20:39] will continue to support your community and continue to work with your departments. [0:20:43] So, thank you so much for the time and I hope that you will consider signing the MOU. [0:20:51] Susan Hawkins. [0:20:52] Jackie, I just want to thank you so much for all you do, not just the financial part of [0:20:56] it, but your monthly meetings, every month I learn something new that I don't know, and [0:21:02] the way that you go to other things, the joining forces and wherever you can be a support [0:21:06] in this community, it's noted and I'm very thankful for you and all you do and give back [0:21:12] to this area. [0:21:13] So thank you. [0:21:14] You do a very good job by attending one of your new elected official meetings. [0:21:18] Actually, I attended with Suzanne, and it was really eye-opening, and it's very impressive [0:21:25] to learn, and it was in our packet today if you didn't really read. [0:21:28] It was very lengthy, right? [0:21:30] A lot of pages there, I'm hundreds. [0:21:33] No, that's good, but it really showed the breakdown of the chain of command, and it's [0:21:42] very specific. [0:21:43] the exercises that you do at the class are really, really good if anybody else, you know, [0:21:50] touch Jackie Cuchel, give you the schedule and you can attend one of those. [0:21:56] Thank you very much. Does anybody else have any questions? [0:22:08] Request for the mayor's signature on the memorandum of understanding. [0:22:15] We have a second made by Chris Reed, the motion made by Chris Reed in the second by Greg Lanthie. [0:22:21] Do you have any questions? [0:22:23] Chair Enroll, call vote please. [0:22:26] Chris Hockington, Greg Lanting, Christopher Reed, Chris Pierce, Zann Hockington, Nicky Boyd. [0:22:44] Yes. Thank you so much. [0:22:47] You're welcome. Motion passes 6 to 0. Thank you, Jackie. [0:22:52] Next, we have a request to sign a contract with JAB engineers for the remainder of the Canyon Springs Road. [0:23:03] Project Design and Construction Services in the amount of $343,900 and Troy B. Tech is going to talk to us. [0:23:13] Good Council Members, I'm going to break this into two parts tonight. One, I'm here to talk about a contract with J.E.B. Engineers. [0:23:30] There's a contract that we would like to re-execute with J.E.B. Engineers from the amount of $343,900. [0:23:37] I'll tell you a little bit about our processes. On September of 2015, we executed a contract. [0:23:44] I came before a council before that. Not authorization to execute a contract with JB. We did that. [0:23:49] And they began designing the public process, so we all remember, so they did it well. [0:23:57] Jay runs from October, so come October, we're into one next year, starting in September. [0:24:04] So I immediately have to income funds to keep them. The funds are there. I talked with Public Finance Department. [0:24:31] They were set aside, slid, we would like the slide on that, budget is budgeted in this year's cycle in 2018 cycle for $700,000 out of streets phones, and $1,000,000 in a waste water treatment plan. [0:24:50] That is enough for the construction. It's not enough to cover the construction and the design side of it. [0:24:57] So if you have the option of saying no tonight, we can go forward with our e-budget of funds, but it means the project shrinks a little bit hard for us to complete it as we're listening to do. [0:25:09] to do. That brings me to get a discussion tonight. Originally part of the public process, option [0:25:22] six, option six is essentially a wide zero down to 28 feet. That puts in that grade sidewalk [0:25:47] about eight feet wide. That's all that. And it's 4.8 down on January. And staff's recommendations [0:26:04] on the public works came with council and said roadways are really hard. Takes away from [0:26:17] away from other projects, in this case it really took away from this project. It doesn't [0:26:22] leave me, it doesn't destroy this project. Coming up before we eat tonight is to reaffirm [0:26:28] that we believe all time before is still, it doesn't address the walkway portion of the [0:26:36] present, create that sidewalk. So, on a presentation tonight, going forward with our schedule, finish [0:27:13] design, the engineering. Be 30th, I'll talk to the public and say, you should expect to [0:27:37] out there. There's also going to be during the residence of that notice of a word on August 15th, [0:28:03] then we are trying to hold off the notices to proceed to around Labor Day. It's a little [0:28:08] little Italy in the summer, but when kids around here start to get back to school, because [0:28:12] using the road as long as we can, scaling up the rocks half the runway, it'll be flagged [0:28:39] during the day, lights drop that on the road. Some of this items is a guy for the council. [0:29:19] This is originally I presented an active restraint system and it will show you what that looks like. [0:29:31] This is an active restraint system for the rock wall. [0:29:40] This is what I permitted, or I present to you guys previously. [0:29:44] I'm recommending a slight change from that to a drink method. [0:29:50] The reason is this stuff is four times the cost of their alternative areas. [0:29:56] I would recommend proceeding with this tree system just due to the amount of flee restraint [0:30:17] and cost savings of this. [0:30:25] Others are very much of an asset to our town there so I'm trying to make the impact as low [0:30:36] as possible but still do the job that we have set us on. [0:30:46] So, tonight I engineered. [0:30:54] We have some Greg Lanting. [0:31:05] is right. So we're bringing all of that down or we just bringing out what we feel is unsteady or unstable is just a better term. [0:31:22] The, what I've just told from Strata via JUB is a, there's a particular aspect of that system. [0:31:57] Talking to. [0:32:00] This actually is a legal question as much as engineering. If we proceed with this road improvement, [0:32:09] without I guess I don't for us when we're talking about 34 [0:32:15] That's uh, we're not providing an improvement in a safe safety improved walkway [0:32:23] writer the lane [0:32:25] is an increased liability [0:32:28] Over this I say that because five years that for years for exercise, and I've had a rock actually drop [0:32:34] The lady was coming down. I was coming up and we were on opposite sides of the road [0:32:38] I mean, rocks can actually fall. [0:32:41] They can kill people if they hit you from that height. [0:32:45] So, with this action increase or liability over what we might expect it to be anyway. [0:32:52] I don't really expect any build. [0:32:57] I'll just start with people that use that for recreational purposes or using it for free. [0:33:02] We have, we can take advantage of their recreational use statute to provide in terms of vehicles that might get hit. [0:33:12] This makes it safer. I would say reduces our increase signage of any help of that warning people of... [0:33:23] I was just as control. I thought we had to put a sign up and you probably know better than I do [0:33:30] that a sign up there warning the walkers about the... I didn't know if we need to pull over lawyer [0:33:37] but when every 20 feet or so. I think we have the country when you drive next to areas like this. [0:33:47] you will see one sign following Rock and everybody else thinks it's good enough so I would think it that [0:33:59] Suzanne Hawkins, Troy, you showed us the two different versions of the mesh drape and you said there was a cost [0:34:06] savings what is the cost difference between the two options? [0:34:10] The active one is full cost. [0:34:17] A question, or does that come to the bottom of the drape? [0:34:50] How much open rock that's not being distracted from? How much is there? [0:34:55] So it's going to be right near the bottom of it. There's rock catches in this area right here. [0:35:11] This active one's way far away, but a good ass majority of places in the rock. [0:35:16] This canerim sits above this location. Most of this area is the upper 2000 feet. [0:35:21] In fact, it's 400 of the 1000 feet where this is really the dangerous portion [0:35:26] towards the lower hairpin. It was existing talus, and it's kind of vegetated, and I think it's actually stable, isn't it? [0:35:35] Sure. [0:35:36] Listen. [0:35:40] Cosmore puts a green merrier over everything. [0:35:44] Yes. [0:35:46] And this can still see and enjoy the beauty of the rock, and if something chipped off, it would catch it. [0:35:54] It would. [0:35:55] Yes, it would keep it on the inside, and then it actually falls to the bottom. [0:35:59] It's just catch ditch right here. [0:36:01] Not it. [0:36:02] But those up with rocks and streets on every so often. [0:36:20] Subsonded during the construction time, [0:36:22] we're gonna upper-distute traffic. [0:36:25] During the construction? [0:36:26] Yes. [0:36:27] It would be a recommendation not to allow pedestrian traffic. [0:36:29] Thank you. [0:36:31] So don't have to tell me twice I'm an Irish. [0:36:37] Chris, did you have anything else? [0:36:38] All right. [0:36:40] I would motion that we authorize contract [0:36:42] but JUB for the remainder of the King insurance. [0:36:45] Well, a road project design and construction services [0:36:49] in the amount of 343,900 dollars, following alternative four, as outlined. [0:36:55] Seconded by Greg Lantine, request to sign a contract with JUB Engineers for the remainder [0:37:07] of the Canyon Springs Road Project Design and construction services in the amount of [0:37:13] 343, 9. Other questions are just Chris Hockinton. [0:37:30] Yes. [0:37:31] Greg Lantine. [0:37:32] Yes. [0:37:33] Christopher W. [0:37:34] Yes. [0:37:35] Ruth Pierce. [0:37:36] Yes. [0:37:37] Nikki Boyd. Yes. [0:37:39] I'll she can carry six to zero. [0:37:41] Thank you, Troy. [0:37:58] It's to adopt an ordinance in minting city code 973 and 976C regarding off street parking [0:38:06] houses in Murray. [0:38:10] Council citizens. [0:38:12] Adam, we brought up last week to amend our code to the past program that we had previously. [0:38:20] All these laws and our laws has meanings in the last few days. [0:38:27] with me today and in the last week with our engineering staff and streets to talk [0:38:32] about to roll this out and just maintenance and responsibility for what so [0:38:40] we have to plan in place this is the streets our division's busy time so [0:38:45] we'll take some time to kind of keep going but not so wishes we have a [0:39:03] separate ordinance or we just doing these two here this is an amendment to [0:39:09] This ordinance number 2018-12. [0:39:17] I move that we suspend the rules on place ordinance 2018-12 and 3rd and final by title only. [0:39:37] Second. [0:39:38] Motion made by Greg Lanting, seconded by Suzanne Hopkins. [0:39:45] Would you read the title please? [0:39:47] No, I'm sorry, that comes next. [0:39:50] Please. [0:39:51] Greg Lanting. [0:40:04] Yes. [0:40:05] Christopher Reed. [0:40:06] Yes. [0:40:07] Yes. [0:40:08] Yes. [0:40:09] Yes. [0:40:10] Yes. [0:40:11] Yes. [0:40:12] Yes. [0:40:13] Yes. [0:40:14] Yes. [0:40:15] Yes. [0:40:16] Yes. [0:40:19] Yes. [0:40:20] Yes. [0:40:21] Yes. [0:40:22] Yes. [0:40:23] Yes. [0:40:24] Yes. [0:40:25] Yes. [0:40:26] Yes. [0:40:27] Yes. [0:40:28] Yes. [0:40:29] Yes. [0:40:30] Yes. [0:40:31] Yes. [0:40:32] Yes. [0:40:33] Yes. [0:40:34] Yes. [0:40:35] Yes. [0:40:36] Yes. [0:40:37] Yes. [0:40:38] passes. Be it ordained by the mayor and council of the city of Twin Falls, Idaho. [0:40:43] Made by Chris talking in second by Greg Lamteen. Christopher Reed. Yes. [0:41:10] Ruth Pierce. Yes. Suzanne Hawkins. Yes. Nicky Boyd. Yes. Chris Hockington. Yes. [0:41:16] Greg Lamteen. Yes. Motion passes 6 to 0. Move to our one manager Travis Rothweiler. [0:41:31] I think that if we move this here, it probably works a little bit better. [0:41:44] So, Madam Vice Mayor, members of the City Council, first let me again apologize for bringing this item to you on short notice. [0:41:52] We've been working through the fiscal year 2018-2019 budget, and as you know, we started with that process through our long-term planning process, which begins shortly after Christmas. [0:42:05] And from that entire period, our long-term planning members work collectively to build a budget that we ultimately will present to you after the Fourth of July holiday. [0:42:17] And we'll spend the entire summer having that conversation moving forward. [0:42:22] One of the things that we've spent considerable time in our organization taking a look at is making sure that as we continue to grow as a community, [0:42:30] that we have adequate staffing needs for all of our departments to be able to [0:42:34] deploy all the services that are expected by our citizens. And about a year and a [0:42:41] half ago we came to you and shared the importance of being a hard-safe community [0:42:48] and the importance of working forward and going on emergency medical calls as [0:42:54] opposed to going on only fire suppression calls which was a significant change [0:42:58] to our organization and we felt that as a professional fire team, and if you're looking [0:43:03] at modern day fire departments, responding to EMS calls is one of the first and foremost [0:43:08] functions that we do. [0:43:10] In fact, when we looked at the total call volume, and I think that as Chief Kenworthy [0:43:15] shared with you in his report just last week, the total number of calls that we had went [0:43:21] from 2,700 total incidents to over 5,500 total incidents. [0:43:26] It wasn't that we had more fires. [0:43:28] It's what we went to more and more calls for service. [0:43:33] Calls for service to render aid to members of our community. [0:43:37] So we started to take a look and our team has been looking [0:43:40] at the total number of firefighters [0:43:42] that we have on our team and inside of the city of Twin Falls. [0:43:47] We have 39 line personnel. [0:43:49] We break those line personnel into three distinct shifts, [0:43:53] A, B, and C, and those three men or 13 man shifts. [0:44:00] Sometimes, and most of the time, will drop to 12, [0:44:03] and that is because we may have an illness, [0:44:05] we may have a light duty, we have vacations, [0:44:08] and so being able to staff those all the time [0:44:12] gets to be fairly challenging, [0:44:14] and so 95% of the time we run on 12 man companies. [0:44:19] companies. It's important to recognize that NFPA standard 1710, which is the standard for [0:44:25] operations and deployment for fire suppression operations, emergency medical operations, and [0:44:30] special operations to the public by career firefighters recommend a minimum of 14 individuals [0:44:39] all of the time. And so if you do the math and you say that we have 12 95 percent of the time [0:44:46] and we are down to every shift, and we run three shifts, you can see that that is at least [0:44:53] six firefighters that we would need to be able to function all of the time. [0:44:59] In fact, Chief Kenworthy could probably share with you all of those details in terms of what [0:45:06] it looks like, but NFP standard also basically says that we should, as a public entity, strive [0:45:12] to have four managing companies all of the time and in order to be able to do [0:45:17] that we started to take a look at the total number of firefighter positions that [0:45:21] we would need in our upcoming FY budget and in the position justification sheet [0:45:27] that has been submitted by Chief Kenworthy he is asking and has asked for five [0:45:32] firefighters to be included in the FY 19 and 19 budget again which we will be [0:45:37] presented to you. And unfortunately, we don't have the ability to pick and determine when [0:45:44] we can submit for grants and grant applications have a cycle and the end of this grant cycle [0:45:50] occurs this Friday. That's when you get the window to be able to submit to move forward [0:45:58] for firefighters under the Safer Grant. And this is a grant that is very, very familiar [0:46:02] to us as an organization, but not on the firefighter side. We've done this routinely [0:46:08] on the police officer's side through cops grants. [0:46:12] And it is the very, very similar program for firefighters [0:46:16] in which we have the opportunity to add folks immediately [0:46:22] to our organization to be able to assist [0:46:25] with those deficiencies should we be selected. [0:46:28] Remember, this is a competitive grant process [0:46:30] and there's absolutely no guarantee [0:46:33] that we will be successful in our approach. [0:46:37] But our idea is that if we can get some assistance to cover the immediate need, then that's a real win for the community. [0:46:46] And so one of the questions that Mr. Edwards asks is, is there a cost? [0:46:49] Yes, absolutely. There's a cost. [0:46:52] The cost is that the City of Twin Falls would be asking for the federal government to assist in offsetting a total cost of $354,230,000 for firefighters. [0:47:07] The federal government pays 75% of those costs or $265,673 for the first two years. [0:47:20] And then in year three, the city would receive 35% of the fully burdened costs of $123,981. [0:47:32] And then in year four, the city of Twin Falls would be responsible for those firefighter [0:47:38] positions for a total cost of $354,230. [0:47:44] What we've done in those grants is that we've put in, again, that's the fully burdened cost. [0:47:49] So that's the Percy cost, the health insurance costs, all of those costs that are known to [0:47:54] us. [0:47:55] There are some additional costs and I'll look back to the Chief, but I believe that these [0:47:58] are just for Manning. [0:47:59] It doesn't include the protective clothing that we've come associated with that. [0:48:04] That total cost is approximately $22,500, which we move forward inside of the budget. [0:48:11] And so what we're asking is the opportunity to hire individuals and help the federal government, [0:48:19] namely FEMA, through Homeland Security, assist in the immediate deployment of those individuals, [0:48:25] just as we've done for the COPS grants, to ensure that we can continue to safely and effectively offer fire services throughout our entire community. [0:48:33] Chief Kenworthy is here to answer this specific and technical questions, but again, this is [0:48:38] firefighter grants to assist on the line level to help us meet NFPA 1710. [0:48:47] Whether or not we submit the grant or whether or not we're successful in the grant [0:48:54] does not diminish the need for hiring additional firefighters. [0:48:58] So we felt as a staff that it would be advantageous to our community to try to receive some federal assistance in hiring firefighters. [0:49:13] That's the purpose of the grant that's here today. [0:49:16] We plan on bringing this request before the Council for its ultimate consideration in July. [0:49:23] Unfortunately, when we bring that request to you in July, it will not have the funding source necessarily attached to it if we are not successful in the grant. [0:49:35] Our approach is that if we are able to hire the five individuals, they would be part of that grant process. [0:49:43] process and if we're not, then we'd have to have that conversation about what to do to move forward. [0:49:48] And it's, and the other options that we've taken look at is hiring three. [0:49:54] So I can share with you those numbers for looking at hiring three, [0:49:58] but really what we're trying to do is to make up those minimum manning standards of, of two officers, [0:50:04] or two firefighters, excuse me, per shift. [0:50:07] I'm happy to stand for any questions and I, as I understand it, Mr Edwards might have some additional questions [0:50:13] to Madam Vice Mayor, so if you would want to have him have the opportunity to ask his [0:50:22] questions, we would certainly as a staff stand ready for him. Thank you very much. [0:50:27] Ms. Tocky, Ted, how's it going? The bottom effect is that we're increasing fire by [0:50:33] up to five people should the grant be accepted, which will be a sliding [0:50:38] scale of reduction in federal level and increasing over those four years yes [0:50:45] well I've seen any time we had personnel on that increase or departments doing it [0:50:54] within the budgeting process is highly desirable this makes it look impromptu [0:51:00] I'm assuming that this an FPA 1710 standard is a new one that we have not [0:51:07] No, it's always been a requirement under the direction if Chief Kenworthy were starting to [0:51:19] move forward to become closer to meet that requirement. [0:51:21] And this is driven by our response to safety concerns, automobile accidents, everything [0:51:30] and anything we're doing now. [0:51:32] So what we're looking at is when you start taking a look at its desirous to have and meet [0:51:37] closer to 1710 when you start taking a look at the breadth of the calls that we're running, [0:51:42] whether they be the automobile calls, the hardiac, the cardiac arrest patients, the fire suppression. [0:51:47] Well some of us are driven by our growth. [0:51:50] Some of it is absolutely driven by our growth. [0:51:54] One of the interesting things that, and I can't explain this in history of talking to [0:52:01] You were probably the only one around in 1977 with the organization and I don't know [0:52:09] if you were or not but in 1977 to put this in perspective the City of Twin Falls had [0:52:13] 43 line personnel protecting a community of 25,000 people. [0:52:20] They we have 39,000 and I can't tell you what happened. [0:52:24] We've always had 39 in my entire ten years so I can't tell you what occurred in that [0:52:29] area and they ran 460 calls for service in 1977. Today, or last year they ran 5400 calls [0:52:43] for service on 39 individuals, often times on 12 men groups, but I guess I just like to [0:52:55] say that I understand the NHS of this request, I don't like fund personnel increases, but [0:53:02] I can not justify it under the safety consideration and only the safety consideration to the city. [0:53:11] We don't have this as an item, so I think this is in. [0:53:16] I know we've been doing a lot of discussion recently on the Fire Department and we know that there's changes that we're going to have to make to keep up with the growth. [0:53:24] Be nice if grants align with our budget process, but they don't. [0:53:30] If we're not successful in the grant after we submit it, [0:53:35] that doesn't mean we're still gonna hire [0:53:37] those firefighters immediately, [0:53:38] it'll still go through the process of the budget [0:53:41] to get to that point, is that correct? [0:53:45] I mean, we're not hiring firefighters next week. [0:53:48] Oh no, oh, this is a really, really long process [0:53:52] and what we're looking at is just the mere opportunity [0:53:54] to be able to find some assistance. [0:53:56] And what this says is that if we, [0:53:58] the grant letter that we're asking you to say [0:54:00] that should we be successful and we hire the firefighters we need to commit to [0:54:05] holding them for the 36-month period which if you look at the 36-month period [0:54:10] aligns with the federal schedule coming forward. What we're trying to do is to get [0:54:17] a hit. Now let's say that the council says you know this is moving to fast [0:54:22] force. What we want to do is to present this opportunity and if the council says [0:54:26] this is moving too fast for us we can't have the conversation during the budget [0:54:31] that says we will apply for that safer grant again in a subsequent year and we'll kind [0:54:39] of move that forward and we can have conversations but unfortunately it never will align with our [0:54:44] fiscal calendar as we as we move forward with those conversations just based upon the [0:54:51] federal calendar is different than our calendar. [0:54:55] With the exception of we know we're agreeing to maintain those employees for the three-year [0:55:00] period. Are there any other stipulations or attachments to that grant that we have to meet? [0:55:06] Not that we've seen. Thank you. Real quick, can you give me the $354,230? Okay, so it breaks down to [0:55:25] $70,846 per FTE, which is the fully burdened cost. Okay, of which year one, [0:55:35] and play 75% year 2 75% year 3 35% and then full amount is on our shoulders and [0:55:44] year 4 that's correct would you like those numbers that's all right I can I [0:55:48] should be able to do that hopefully I had it said to me how long from if this [0:55:57] is approved when is the estimated amount of time what when should we know [0:56:02] We either received it or no. We know that timeline. [0:56:22] So we have 180 days to hire individuals, associate after the announcement of the award, [0:56:31] and the announcement of the award is on July 1st of this year. [0:56:35] Okay. We would wait announcement and hire people [0:56:39] knowing that 75% of this would be paid for. [0:56:43] So what will happen is there will be the next step in which you'll actually have to accept the grant [0:56:48] in that process. It will give us the opportunity in our budgeting process to [0:56:54] then put our local allocation forward because our our local allocation begin [0:57:00] our fiscal year begins on October 1st. We have 180 days after July 1st to make [0:57:07] those hires. We would not be able to hire anybody prior to the beginning of our [0:57:13] fiscal year, but so sometime between October 1st of 2018 and January 1st of 2019 inside [0:57:22] of that window, we would hire the individuals. So obviously, we're talking about full year [0:57:29] costs. Our first year cost would be a little bit less than the $88,000 because we wouldn't [0:57:35] have them on for that full fiscal year. Just how you'd wrap that for a year would be the [0:57:41] the only thing that would be measured and different. [0:57:44] We would come forward in our budget process. [0:57:47] Again, a line for that. [0:57:48] And there would be further debate and conversation [0:57:50] that can certainly occur after we present that budget. [0:57:53] This is really that step to move forward. [0:57:56] I asked Mandy Thompson, our grand manager, [0:57:59] would there be the opportunity that as we roll [0:58:01] through the budgeting process, [0:58:03] and let's say that something occurs, [0:58:04] and could we refuse the grant? [0:58:08] And she said, yes, you could refuse the grant. [0:58:10] It doesn't look great with those federal agencies. [0:58:13] There's no next person. [0:58:15] It goes to those dollars just roll back to FEMA. [0:58:18] But there is certainly the opportunity that should we not [0:58:22] want to move forward, that possibility does exist. [0:58:26] What we're committing is that we're committed to this grant. [0:58:29] We believe that there's a true and valuable need, which [0:58:31] I hopefully have started that process of demonstrating [0:58:33] tonight, and that there is a way to offset that cost locally [0:58:38] through this safer grant sponsored by Homeland Security and FEMA. [0:58:44] So, can I summarize real quick to speak, sure I'm on the same page. [0:58:49] Once it's approved or rejected, if it's approved at that point in time, [0:58:57] we try to find those visuals. [0:59:01] So there will be a commitment that will happen, so we will get the grant commitment [0:59:05] and we will bring that forward, and that will be an agendized item [0:59:08] and you will accept the conditions of the grant just as we have done [0:59:11] with comps grants in the past. [0:59:12] So ultimately it is helping us offset something that we need in the fire. I mean, these standards, it's offsetting that cost. [0:59:26] Yes. [0:59:27] I do really like the idea of being active and getting help with this because as we continue to grow, we know we have to have this and we already know. [0:59:48] Like the police 48% of all their calls are for or outside of Twin Falls [0:59:55] So this you know [0:59:58] 5500 total incidents pretty overwhelming and big smart. Yeah, nay [1:00:11] I want to take some of the ownership of this [1:00:16] Part of that ownership is really trying to understand what those staffing needs are [1:00:22] are in fire departments and I really rely upon department leaders to be able to share with [1:00:28] me how they need to be able to staff their departments to be able to fully function, to [1:00:32] be able to move forward. [1:00:33] And I will tell you that Chief Kenworthy has done a good job in helping build my own faculties [1:00:41] and capacities on how we should be running departments and what that looks like. [1:00:45] He comes from an area with a different collection of experiences that has already proven valuable [1:00:51] to the city and I wish that I didn't place you into the situation this evening. These [1:01:00] are the cards that I have and so I'm playing the hand that I'm dealt. We want to be obviously [1:01:07] very judicious with property tax dollars and dollars as we move forward and we believe that [1:01:13] yes, there's a cost. There's absolutely a cost but we also believe that if there's an opportunity [1:01:21] to defer that cost and continue to provide the highest level of public safety services [1:01:26] supplied by our fire department. Then it's willing to stand before you to make requests [1:01:33] like this. At this time, would we like to hear audience? Yes, Mr. Edwards. Edwards, Twin [1:02:04] Falls property owner. Government grants are still our money and I realize that what would [1:02:14] come next from you folks, I'm assuming, would be, well, if we don't get it, somebody else [1:02:18] is going to get it. [1:02:19] I don't think that's appropriate way in the physical responsibility of you guys to decide [1:02:27] how government spends their money if they're offering a grant and you take it, you're still [1:02:32] spending our money. [1:02:33] I understand that we have to have a staff safety service here with the fire department, the [1:02:42] police department. [1:02:43] My question is, is how long have we been operating out of compliance, making twice as many calls under the manned requirement? [1:02:54] What were we 12? Are we 6? Were we 3? Now we got to be 14. How long has that gone on? [1:03:03] And you guys didn't know about it that we were understaffed. You did? Now you do? [1:03:12] No, no, but I mean, whenever you talk to the fire department, or you do a tour or whatever, you know that there are [1:03:19] generally twelve firefighters on each of that company. Which is out of compliance and understaffed. [1:03:26] Which is we were doing the very best with what we had. [1:03:30] And so what's changed now the money, right? And the opportunity to get some more money and get some more staffing. [1:03:37] Do a better job for our citizens. [1:03:39] health and safety right that's what they expect absolutely well of course but why [1:03:48] now because we have a grant available and its government money but it still [1:03:53] comes from the public I just wanted to be clear on that [1:04:03] one would during the latest fire chief Nikki that were [1:04:08] vice mayor boy never both on that committee I wouldn't say they were incredulous but [1:04:15] They were very surprised at the candidates that we are finalists that we were operating at 39 line officers. [1:04:22] I felt that that was apparently an adequate for staff of 50,000 I think to a man [1:04:28] talked about the need for additional firefighters. [1:04:32] We, part of this game when we made the decision was made to our Nancy Moore calls. [1:04:40] for answering all of the the accident ones that were medical emergencies. That's where a lot of the call [1:04:50] of them. So to the point of when we became understaffed, I knew we were understaffed. I've known our staff for years. [1:04:56] But the call of numbers did not justify to be the expense. We had bigger needs and other places in our budget. [1:05:04] and we've been a very frugal bunch in here. [1:05:07] And we've went years where we didn't take any percentage, [1:05:10] let alone the three percent. [1:05:12] And finally keep time, keep very apparent with the new, [1:05:18] all demands to grow through our population. [1:05:22] That we suddenly have 39 line officers, whenever, [1:05:27] in 1977 or so, 40 years ago, we had 43 officers, [1:05:31] or 43 line personnel, sure. [1:05:33] Part of that's better equipment. [1:05:34] that has helped us to meet that demand but it still doesn't run on the fact that [1:05:40] we're it's time for us to expand our fire service and if we can get federal money [1:05:45] to help us to expand that fire service yes that is my money but I feel I have a [1:05:51] right to it just like anybody else does and if it helps deflect costs we're gonna [1:05:56] have some problems most likely occur anyway from our citizens of Twin Falls [1:06:01] I think that's my job. I present the citizens when falls not the citizens of other states [1:06:09] And so if I can get money through this path to save the citizens of [1:06:16] And I'll say yes every time [1:06:24] You see analogy of the place department [1:06:27] We're that 48% of all the service calls for people out of [1:06:31] of city limits, or police department extremely efficiently [1:06:37] on the manpower versus the issue of residents. [1:06:42] The fire is as great as it is to some function of our growth. [1:06:48] But I tell you, when it comes to safety, [1:06:51] even though this is kind of the cart before the horse, [1:06:54] or the whole thing is backwards, in my days days, [1:06:58] I've seen fire at least in the M.T. [1:07:01] safe lives and accidents. I've also seen and witnessed lives being lost by an adequate [1:07:09] personnel. We're wasting money, but I'll tell you that I'll stand up and say to the people [1:07:18] whose lives are saved, that safety is going to take my vote to the upside. [1:07:26] I met a vice-americ, I don't maybe want to put this in perspective, so our local match is $88,557 for the first two years. [1:07:39] The cost of each FTP, FTE is $70,846. [1:07:48] How we staff, you can't bring them on one at a time. [1:07:52] It doesn't functionally work, you want to have evenly deployed teams. [1:08:00] So Mr. Edwards asked the question in terms of, is this a new standard? [1:08:03] No, it's not a standard, it is a standard that has been there for a while and as we've [1:08:07] been working to not only grow the competitive compensation but it's also important for us [1:08:13] to be able to look at manning and these things take time. [1:08:17] I get the sense that Mr. Edwards is looking for someone to blame and he can blame me because [1:08:23] at the end of the day I'm responsible for the organization and if it's important to [1:08:26] place blame, you can place that on me. [1:08:29] Move this letter of support for the application by the Twin Falls Fire Department for a staffing [1:08:47] of adequate firing emergency response safe for grant through the federal emergency management [1:08:53] agency FEMA of the US Department of Homeland Security. [1:08:58] Chris talking to Christopher Reed. Yes, Ruth Pierce. Yes, then Hawkins. Yes, Nicky boy. Yes, Chris talking to [1:09:24] Yes, Reg Lanting. Yes, passes six to zero. Thank you very much. It is after six. We have [1:09:35] Oh, let's cover our advisory board reports or any announcements, you know, just so that [1:09:51] didn't get lost. Arbor Day is this Friday at four o'clock at the Oregon Trail Youth Complex. [1:09:58] We hope that we'll see many individuals in attendance. [1:10:02] Yes, it's always fun. Dicking in the dirt is always fun. And I actually think the weather is actually so [1:10:11] in past it has been miserable. I think that this year it's it's looking to be a really nice day. [1:10:18] that's a lot better than 44. Yeah, where's that? [1:10:24] It's 330. Or a clock. Is that a youth complex? Is that actually on the Oregon? It's not an Oregon [1:10:32] trail school. It's just north, correct? Cross the street. Yes. It's time for public hearings. [1:10:42] Our first public hearing tonight is a request for a zoning district change and zoning map [1:10:49] amendment from R2 to R2 Pro for property located at 104 Lincoln Street [1:10:56] Cara Bryant Tanner and we have our brand new first meeting landing and zoning [1:11:02] director [1:11:10] Council members and members mayor for full disclosure the second item on this [1:11:18] Has some lengthy discussion at the planning and zoning commission, so [1:11:23] It took about I think was an hour and a bit [1:11:26] I just don't know about a break for anybody that would want to be for you get in the public hearings if you guys feel like you [1:11:31] Would like to do that or not? That's up to you. I just wanted to let you know about that [1:11:35] I don't know if that'll take this long tonight [1:11:38] I was just giving you the full disclosure for what happened at that meeting. Let's do it in the last time [1:11:42] I'm gonna get the set up and show everything and then I will have [1:11:59] have applicant come up to his presentation first, but be Brian Tanner. [1:12:12] I have an office on 104 Lincoln that's really close to five points you've probably all [1:12:33] been by there many many many times a day. It's a little great building. It's been a office [1:12:39] for about 20 years I think. We have signs all around us I wanted to put in a little sign [1:12:45] and I sign probably about this high. There's any questions today. [1:12:56] Ryan, do you have a cop or a picture of what your science is going to look like? [1:13:04] I know you asked for that and I do have a proposal from Little Science. [1:13:09] It's I have an email but I don't have it on me right now on my cell phone right now. [1:13:17] Did you use it? I can describe it if you want. That'd be fine. So it's um it'll be smooth. [1:13:23] it'll have brick. I'm hoping that it can be lighted at night so there'll be [1:13:31] some electrical input to it in monument time. [1:13:39] Do you know the dimensions? I don't know exactly, but I'm anticipating it over. [1:13:45] Are you winning the sign on the Blue Lakes side or on the Lincoln Street side? [1:13:58] I was told last time I was here that I had anticipated originally putting it on [1:14:03] the corner of Lincoln and Addison but the engineer told me I couldn't do that [1:14:08] because you have to have like visibility and stuff like that so I'm [1:14:13] actually planning on putting it very close to the car store so there's a [1:14:17] camper downhill really close to where the air is maybe a little bit to you [1:14:22] right there and there's a parking lot right behind there so that's where I [1:14:29] I anticipate putting it in. [1:14:39] Questions? [1:14:46] I'll click here. [1:14:48] I know. [1:14:49] I'm sorry Jonathan. [1:14:50] So Brian went to the heart of why he's here. [1:14:53] What I'm going to do is help you walk you through what we're doing in staff here. [1:14:58] He's in a R2 zone, which does not permit signs. [1:15:03] It's also part of an older agreement called the Stoker Agreement Area that allowed for [1:15:09] offices to be along Addison Avenue. [1:15:11] had some very specific development criteria for signage. [1:15:14] Mr. Tanner wants to kind of deviate from that agreement, [1:15:18] and he wants to have his property be zoned [1:15:22] as a professional office overlay. [1:15:24] So that's actually what we're here for, [1:15:25] is a rezone on the property. [1:15:28] He went to the heart of the issue that he wanted to sign, [1:15:30] that's what he approached us for. [1:15:32] The council's decision will be on the rezone of the property [1:15:34] and whether to put that professional office overlay [1:15:38] on the property, then he can come in for a sign permit under the regulations that we [1:15:43] currently have. [1:15:44] So he would have to meet all the regulations they are as they're written in the Code Title [1:15:50] 10, Chapter 9. [1:15:53] That's what the property looks on the exterior. [1:15:58] The comprehensive plan shows it as neighborhood commercial or residential business along Addison [1:16:03] on the south side and the north side. [1:16:05] Currently all the properties on the south side have the professional office overlay. [1:16:09] So there's nothing really crazy about this request. [1:16:14] During the public hearing, there was, [1:16:16] I believe there were one or two people that spoke. [1:16:19] Their questions were more on what does the sign look like? [1:16:22] Not necessarily as to whether it's appropriate to resolve the property. [1:16:26] So those questions were kind of separate from what the action was. [1:16:30] And the commission voted all and goes at nine to zero. [1:16:34] I think everybody was there that night in favor of forwarding a positive [1:16:39] to the city council for rezoning the property [1:16:41] with the professional officer, really, [1:16:43] and lighting as accepted. [1:16:45] Lighting is accepted in some situations. [1:16:48] We'd have to see some kind of what his plan looks like, [1:16:50] but we'll make sure it meets the code, [1:16:52] whichever it allows either a backlight [1:16:54] or another lighting as lighting down. [1:16:56] All you think is like. [1:16:57] It's possible, yeah. [1:17:00] So our charge this evening is to address the rezone. [1:17:05] Correct. [1:17:06] And if that's successful, then he will come back [1:17:09] He'll come back to staff and just apply for a sign permit. [1:17:16] That's an administrative approval per the code as it's written. [1:17:24] Suzanne, just clarifying what I think I heard. [1:17:27] Other adjoining properties already have the professional overlay in this area. [1:17:32] Let me get back. [1:17:33] Yeah. [1:17:34] This area, there's a dotted line. [1:17:35] It actually includes a lot of the original town site. [1:17:38] That dotted line kind of indicates some of it. [1:17:41] of it. Everything on Addison across the street, you can see this is pro right here, everything [1:17:47] along this street has professional office overlay. So the signage, if you drove down Addison on [1:17:54] the south side, you'd see a bunch of signage. On the north side, you may not see any of those [1:17:59] type of monument signs. It's due to the zone that's on the south side of the road, but not on the [1:18:03] north side. I see. And Lincoln Street is the street that we just put the heritage lighting on as well. [1:18:10] Is that correct? [1:18:11] Yeah, Blinken Street has that lighting and don't know how far it goes, but I do believe [1:18:14] it starts at Aniston and goes north, a block or two. [1:18:18] Thank you. [1:18:23] Other questions? [1:18:29] Right now we'll open up the public hearing portion and have anybody from the audience [1:18:34] who wishes to speak. [1:18:36] Mr Edwards. [1:18:40] First of all, I'd like to say I never said it was a waste of money. [1:18:56] I never said that you weren't looking for safety for the public and I resent the fact [1:19:03] that you infer that I needed somebody to play. [1:19:08] I just simply pointed out the fact that it's government money, [1:19:11] that we've been operating below the standard [1:19:14] for a number of years. [1:19:16] And I realize that you're trying to work up to that fact. [1:19:20] But I resent the fact that you would attack somebody [1:19:22] from the public that pays your salary in this way. [1:19:28] I resent it, and I'm not going to allow it to stand. [1:19:30] I resent it, and I'm not going to allow it to stand [1:19:33] If you are resented also for that comment that you made, you had no reason to do that. [1:19:40] You sound like you're running for public office. That's for sure. [1:19:52] I might stick around if you threaten my job. The last speaker wasn't speaking to the... [1:20:11] Alright. There anybody who signed in to speak to this issue of the zoning change? [1:20:17] See, no one will close that portion. Now we're back to council. [1:20:23] I'm ready to make a motion. [1:20:34] Fantastic. [1:20:35] I would move that we approve the zoning district change in zoning map amendment from R2 to [1:20:40] R2 Pro for the property located at 104 Lincoln Street. [1:20:47] Motion passes in Hawkins, seconded by Greg Lanting, another discussion. [1:20:53] Is it in Hawkins? [1:21:05] Yes. [1:21:06] Niki Boyd? [1:21:07] Yes. [1:21:08] Chris Tockington? [1:21:09] No. [1:21:10] Greg Lanting? [1:21:11] Yes. [1:21:12] Christopher Reed? [1:21:13] Yes. [1:21:14] passes 6 to 0. Thank you, Jonathan. [1:21:25] Is a request for a P&M into the Preserve PUD number 261 [1:21:31] to reflect changes in proposed uses, [1:21:34] project boundary completion of the Canyon Rim Trail, [1:21:37] dedicating a trailhead park [1:21:39] and to allow project specific roadway standards [1:21:43] on approximately 370 acres plus or minus, [1:21:47] located in the southeast corner of Eastwood Drive, North, [1:21:51] Holline Road East, Cara of Gerald Martins on behalf of Connie Store. Welcome, Gerald. [1:21:58] Thank you for the record. My name is Gerald Martins. I'm here this evening to talk to you about the [1:22:04] Preserve Project. Just a little bit of history. First of all, I'm going to try to meet your goal [1:22:12] of making it much shorter. At this evening, we're going to address the issue of this on the agenda, [1:22:18] specifically the amendment to the PUD. I'll be back to see you with a final [1:22:24] plan on the details of the project at a later date but I think for you to [1:22:29] understand that some of the changes in the PUD I have to show you a little bit of [1:22:34] what the vision is for the project and I'll try to limit that. [1:22:38] Fourteen years ago, first came before the City Council with a kind of sexual plan for [1:22:47] What was doing was to preserve mixed use residential [1:22:52] with some commercial element development. [1:22:59] Went through some master planning on the screen up here [1:23:02] is basically shows you the property [1:23:04] and basically shows you that master plan [1:23:07] configuration in a general form [1:23:09] as it was presented back 14 years ago. [1:23:12] Then along came some difficult development times [1:23:17] And Dr. Storr decided to focus more on raising cattle than the houses. [1:23:26] And there seemed to be more demand for cattle than the houses at that time. [1:23:30] In 2012 we came back with the PUD amendment and got it executed. [1:23:36] And the PUD agreement was executed in 2012. [1:23:40] Now we're moving forward with the actual development of the first phase, which we call the springs. [1:23:45] And in doing that, working with staff, we... [1:23:48] There are five, I believe, items in the PUD agreement or areas in the PUD agreement that need to be [1:23:56] Mr. cleaned up in an amendment. First is housekeeping items [1:24:03] which [1:24:05] PUD have been called for dedication of a trail and dedication of a park. Those things have been completed [1:24:11] Those are done. The amendment will reflect that they have been in no longer requirement. The PUD agreement called for [1:24:21] private, public irrigation system as a project is now envisioned and was really [1:24:29] always envisioned. It's going to have a lot of open space. It's going to retain [1:24:33] agricultural elements for a long time, maybe forever, that really not very [1:24:41] compatible with the city's pressurized irrigation system. So we will incorporate [1:24:46] a private pressurized irrigation system that will irrigate not only the [1:24:50] residential lots, but the common areas that are pertinent to the subdivisions, but also [1:24:56] the common areas that will remain both as agricultural pursuits and as wildlife habitat incorporating [1:25:05] the system. [1:25:07] The third thing is it never was designated on the master plan, but there was some language [1:25:19] to the possibility of some commercial development adjacent to Eastland. [1:25:28] This amendment takes out that element of potential and makes it what I believe is a high scale, [1:25:36] not high scale, but high quality residential development with a very residential flavor [1:25:46] and not compatible to a commercial development that you might see across the street [1:25:51] the street on down the Pull Line Road. Another thing that happened during the building [1:26:02] of the trail, there was a section of the trail and it shone on the mat that cut off a piece [1:26:09] of the property. There was about four acres, four plus acres that's been severed from [1:26:16] the rest of the property by the trail as dedicated. The alignment of the trail was worked out [1:26:23] to reduce the length of the trial and make it less expensive trial and a more desirable [1:26:28] trial. [1:26:29] We made better use of the stream crossings and the things that the alignment we came up [1:26:35] with, but this PUD amendment allows those four acres to potentially be developed as three [1:26:41] residential lots in an SUI category, which basically clear one acre minimum parcels with [1:26:50] wells and septic systems. [1:26:51] They would be accessed off from the pull-down road east. [1:26:59] The last thing, and why we need to probably show some pictures, is the roadway section. [1:27:04] I'll just walk you through these real quickly. [1:27:08] What you see here is the overlay of the initial phase of the project, which is, that is the springs he's outlined in. [1:27:16] There is an access road that comes in off from, it's chain, it comes in off of me, it's a primary access, it comes in to the community center and the initial phase. [1:27:29] It absolutely establishes a theme of this project as you'll see in future pictures on the borders and elements that we would like to work into the project as we move through it. [1:27:44] I think it's important because it identifies the key points, the big suns, what you're going [1:27:53] to call them are, the places where this project connects to the community or the trail. [1:27:59] You've got trail connections, connections to Eastland, connections to Trailhead Park, [1:28:05] and that smaller stars are, I think, key elements that benefit the community, and basically [1:28:14] their wildlife habitat locations and water features that will be enhanced and [1:28:21] emphasized as part of the project. It'll make the project the subdivision unique [1:28:30] at least for this community. Oh, this, excuse me, he's already there. The initial [1:28:36] phase of the project will be the community center. The plan calls for building not [1:28:41] to exceed 8,000 square feet eventually be built to provide services for the community. [1:28:49] The initial phase of the project will be the postal center, the mail center. [1:28:55] All mail will be picked up by all residents at this location. [1:28:58] The initial phase will also include a little bit of an area where the neighbors can meet [1:29:06] read there, maybe have a cup of coffee, meet to go on a hike on part of the trail system [1:29:14] for me to just as part of their activity and exercise, this project is going to really [1:29:20] focus on pedestrian activities and pedestrian facilities and take the benefit of being adjacent [1:29:27] to the wonderful trail song. [1:29:32] Now, my Arbor Day, black trees, the real reason for the fifth item on the PDM [1:29:42] in, but is allowed for a modified section. [1:29:45] As you can see, what I'm proposing to do is build two 24-foot roadways, [1:29:52] two-way traffic, each direction in and out, all from Eastland with a median down the center with trees [1:30:00] landscape and wrap that theme around [1:30:05] Eastland to the north and future faces. The entry [1:30:12] just another shows a background level view more of what it will be like. [1:30:18] The intent is to create a sense of arrival. This was a little earlier if you go [1:30:26] the next one. Okay this is one that we've been working with [1:30:31] staff on dealing with road to train each and continue to work with staff. [1:30:35] As you can see, basically is a very soft concept with the trees, detached pathways, swelled to accommodate the drainage. [1:30:53] This land, if you're not familiar with it, but I think most of you are, it's a lot of rock. [1:30:59] There's some ground water and some areas, and it's not conducive to a road that follows a terrain [1:31:09] is comfortable to lay it upon the terrain and I think staff agrees with that. [1:31:14] You know, we will probably not put this many flowers in the mediums because that's a big [1:31:18] expanse to the homeowners to maintain it, but I would expect there would be some opportunities [1:31:24] for flower beds at crosswalks and locations where the public could really appreciate the [1:31:29] flowers. [1:31:30] This will have a strong, well-developed community neighborhood association with CCNR's funded [1:31:40] to maintain those facilities. One key element is a ground about, that'll be in a future phase, [1:31:50] where Cheney would extend on over towards Hankins Road to the right and to the left as into the [1:31:57] initial phase of the project. Just a little bit of scale, homes will be set back much more than the [1:32:06] are required 20 feet from the streets for two reasons. First of all, to provide for roadside [1:32:14] drainage soils. I actually happened to be in Eagle this last weekend and it's an excellent [1:32:24] idea on how they get those made up very attractive. I'll be presenting that to staff. The concept [1:32:31] is, is soils that accommodate the drainage, both from the lots and from the street. This [1:32:38] is this cross-section that would, along with the red rings, that would be in the amended [1:32:44] PUD agreement. It shows the road section of the, where the island exists on the main entry. [1:32:51] Then there's another road section, which is the, for the sections that don't have the [1:32:57] median, specifically the residential streets, where the individual holds. So in summary, [1:33:06] It's five changes, the housekeeping ones reflect the things that have already been done, pressure [1:33:15] irrigation, modified road section, lemonade and the commercial, and the three lots that [1:33:24] were cut off and will be developed under a separate plant, receive city services that [1:33:31] will be any city water or sewer, extended to pressure irrigation will be extended to those [1:33:39] Homeowners Association, they will be members of the Homeowners Association because they will get the full benefits of pedestrian facilities, the pathways and the trails. [1:33:51] They're just a little different route to get to their homes. [1:33:57] With that, one of the issues of the conditions I would like to discuss in just a bit. [1:34:07] It has to do with the request for the sidewalk adjacent to Eastland. [1:34:12] Eastland is not being, the French on Eastland is not being developed in the initial phase. [1:34:22] I know there's a desire to get that sidewalk done as soon as possible. [1:34:28] I suggested that we put in a date certain that would happen. [1:34:32] However, I think it's important to note that I want to continue working with the city. [1:34:39] The design of that pathway along Eastland, because it can't be developed now [1:34:46] Not to the not to what I envision [1:34:49] We could put a sidewalk right adjacent to Eastland Street right now [1:34:54] But what I envision is that pathway and being detached from the street by landscaping [1:35:02] So that the pathway is not only more attractive meanders [1:35:08] with some landscaping and berms on both sides of it, but it's also safer by [1:35:12] moving the pedestrians and the bicycles away from the roadway. That [1:35:20] particular piece of the project is phase two. I'm hoping I'm there in three years. [1:35:29] Just a bit on the schedule this year, this summer and spring. We're out there [1:35:35] We've imported a lot of fill material already. We've done a rock coring. Our water, each one of our ground water and our rock is. [1:35:44] We are working with department water resources on cleaning those ponds. [1:35:49] We re-establishing the streams in a more natural state. [1:35:56] The cattle have walked the stream banks in and places and we're going to re-establish those. We are going to [1:36:02] to take all the turdlies out of the ponds and restore it to a lake like you see in the [1:36:10] pictures. [1:36:11] Mid-summer we will come to you with a final plan on the initial phase. [1:36:16] It's our intent to put the underground utilities in this fall for the first phase of the subdivision [1:36:22] with paving in the spring of 2019 and construction could be at sometime maybe July of 2019. [1:36:38] I think that's, I'll be just glad to have some stand for any questions. [1:36:41] That's out the uh, my memory mallet, marios lake, which is the natural lake that we're, we're [1:36:56] to now company lake, so it's more over where, I don't know where the trail head, but this [1:37:01] is not, it's down to very close to the current park, just immediately, so we're right in that [1:37:07] area, right? [1:37:09] That is the lowest, just to give you a background, that is the lowest spot on the entire property. [1:37:15] property, elevation-wise, okay? And that's where the gravity irrigation water for that area west of [1:37:23] the Cooley old drain. With the advent of sprinkler irrigation control of the water, the work by leveling [1:37:36] of the land and the things that have been done in the last 20 years, that lake eventually dried up [1:37:42] the wetlands expert no longer classifies it as a wetland but most of the [1:37:52] attributes of that old Mary Ellis Lake are going to be recaptured in the lake right [1:38:02] there that lake there that if you look at it today it's mostly cat tails 20 years [1:38:09] ago it was a lot of open water. Mostly we've done some test holes in it. It's full of [1:38:18] decomposed cattails for the most part. Decomposed vegetation needs to be [1:38:24] dredged out, reshaped, and the springs that feed it enhanced so that it's an [1:38:34] amenity rather than a... there's still some ducks in there but we're gonna make it a [1:38:39] nice duck pond. Further east of this, there was a significant fish rearing operation on [1:38:51] this property for many, many years. And some of those fish certainly were placed in these [1:38:57] ponds and in some of these streams. I think that is a long time ago. And the industry has [1:39:06] moved way beyond dirt, mud ponds to grow fish. So when they put in hydroelectric plant, [1:39:37] There was some efforts to consolidate that water [1:39:41] into a more predictable stream for generation. [1:39:46] I was also partly as part of the agricultural process [1:39:51] to more efficiently irrigate the property, [1:39:54] especially with the pivots that were installed on it. [1:39:58] A lot of the old ditches were removed or re-directed. [1:40:05] The result of that was, of course, [1:40:07] a nice counter-wrench for a lot of years, [1:40:09] but it also had a lot of significant impact on the groundwater supported by that ground. [1:40:19] It's an exciting project. It's going to be fun. I think it's something in the community. [1:40:25] We've received well since B and Z, or this. I've been many people calling one to know [1:40:34] whether they can reserve lots until they hear the price. [1:40:38] There's a click, but it is expensive to develop. [1:40:44] I think, you know, I kind of like the joke [1:40:47] when he called us an infill project, [1:40:49] and it is infill, he's developed us all the way around it. [1:40:52] He's been developed and wasn't developed [1:40:56] for the obvious reason, it's difficult to develop, [1:40:58] but it's also got some really unique rock features [1:41:02] and water, a surface water, ground water, springs, [1:41:08] wildlife habitat, if we get rid of the rock checks, [1:41:11] it would be a lot nicer, but yeah, [1:41:16] I'll be glad to answer any questions. [1:41:25] to my steering council members, [1:41:28] what little information that didn't come fully out [1:41:33] in the money and zoning hearing, [1:41:36] which I'll take a little bit more time to do. [1:41:40] This property was originally zoned and approved [1:41:43] for the zone that it currently has, [1:41:45] which is R2 to residential zoning district [1:41:48] with a PUD agreement for certain types of development [1:41:51] in the area over the entire acreage. [1:41:53] It's a large acreage. [1:41:55] that original approval came in 2005, 2006, [1:41:58] that's when the original public hearings came, [1:42:01] that came before the city council body. [1:42:03] So it's been some time since those original approvals [1:42:06] to when this is actually going to be built on. [1:42:09] What's being asked tonight is an amendment [1:42:12] to that original PUD agreement. [1:42:15] They're not amending the zoning, [1:42:16] they're not amending the base zone code [1:42:18] of the R2 district, and Gerald went over the four or five [1:42:21] things they're asking to amend, [1:42:23] But the original approval with the master plan here, [1:42:29] this master plan was the original master plan [1:42:31] that was approved back in 2006, [1:42:34] I guess I'll say the final approval. [1:42:36] Part of that established the size of lots [1:42:39] that can be built in certain areas. [1:42:42] The areas down here are denoted as the state lots. [1:42:46] Same with over here and up here. [1:42:49] These middle areas are residential low density, [1:42:51] residential medium density in the middle, [1:42:54] residential medium density here, [1:42:57] as well as here, and there was an element [1:42:59] of potential commercial along Eastland. [1:43:02] So the amendment takes the commercial away here. [1:43:06] It further amends this area up here [1:43:09] that is now disconnected from the rest of the piece [1:43:12] because that trail is that black line right there. [1:43:15] You can't effectively get to it [1:43:17] from the internal development any longer. [1:43:20] So they'll be accessing those three lots [1:43:23] to have to be one acre from Pauline Road. [1:43:26] So that's the second amendment. [1:43:28] The pressurize of your occasion is the third amendment [1:43:30] that they're seeking from the original. [1:43:35] No one else can remember the other two ones. [1:43:37] The other ones are roadway sections [1:43:41] that you talked about having a median. [1:43:42] That's not a typical roadway section. [1:43:44] There's some others with the drainage on the sides. [1:43:47] That's not a typical roadway section. [1:43:48] The final version of what that looks like. [1:43:52] We have a condition at the end of this that puts that. [1:43:56] There'll be a little bit more discussion with our engineering department to figure out if the road drainage is going to work. [1:44:01] So it doesn't undermine the road base of the collector, so that's something that we have a condition to have that kind of be modified a little bit, [1:44:10] as well as a condition for the median to be a little bit further from Eastland so we can have a turn lane potentially in the future. [1:44:17] So that's a condition you may see at the end of part of that men of our report. [1:44:23] But they're proposing actually reduces the density, we call the density, the plant that [1:44:32] was approved in this area could have had more lots. [1:44:36] This is the preliminary plant overlaid onto this master plan. [1:44:41] That's not something that this body has heard that the Planning and Zoning Commission did [1:44:44] approve that preliminary. [1:44:46] You will then see the final which would look substantially similar to that layout that [1:44:51] you see up here. [1:44:52] And that's really what Gerald spent a lot of this time talking about the look of the development. [1:44:57] Most of those features, minus the few that he mentioned as far as the road section, the drainage, the PI. [1:45:05] Those things are not part of the PUD. He could develop this with the current PUD as it's approved in a similar fashion. [1:45:14] He's just asking for a few amendments based on the things that have changed. [1:45:17] The trail section was the other, I guess the fifth section. [1:45:20] Now that that's built, they want to take that condition of the original PUD out of that, so it's no longer part of the paperwork. [1:45:27] The actual amendments are shown, I'm not going to this picture so fast, I'm sorry, right here. [1:45:35] The blue and green are what's shown as the amendments. [1:45:39] This is the new date of approval approved and subject to any additional conditions which I'll go over. [1:45:46] The green has to do with the three lots that can be developed to SUI zone. [1:45:51] I won't scroll through all of them because we've already talked about all of those. [1:45:56] The actual impact, as far as the amendment that we're talking about tonight, [1:46:00] not the overall development as it develops over time, [1:46:03] the impact of the changes he's asking are minimal in our mind and in our review of it. [1:46:11] However, as things develop and progress over this large acreage, [1:46:17] There's going to be more people living out there. [1:46:19] There's going to be houses where there used to be a pasture. [1:46:22] Those are the impacts that people will see, [1:46:24] but those are not really part of the amendment we're talking about. [1:46:27] It's already entitled to develop to that, [1:46:29] to have houses out there, to have people live out there. [1:46:32] So the amendments we're really talking about are just minor changes [1:46:35] to make the development functional based on those things we talked about. [1:46:40] So on March 27th, the Applying and Zoning Commission held public hearing. [1:46:45] The vote was 9-0 to recommend approval to the City Council and with the following conditions, [1:46:52] one was subject to site plan amendments as required by building engineering fire and zoning officials [1:46:58] to comply with applicable city codes and standards. [1:47:01] Number two was subject to approval and recordation of the first amended PUD agreement. [1:47:06] These could force him to board this agreement. [1:47:09] Number three was subject to the typical size of the bar outage to be confirmed in the acceptable stormwater plan [1:47:14] plan by the City Engineer. That was that stormwater on the sides of the roads. The number four was subject to a pedestrian slash bicycle path along Eastland Drive being designed and constructed by the developer as approved by city staff. [1:47:26] construction to be completed by June 1st, 2021, [1:47:30] or as separately agreed to between [1:47:34] developer and city council. That gives the developer an option [1:47:38] to come 2021 or 2022, bring [1:47:42] a plan that the city council would then accept as a future date of construction [1:47:46] of that. Kind of a way of things don't go according [1:47:50] to plan. We get a sidewalk from Cheney up to the [1:47:54] the Trailhead Park which is very essential to our network for pedestrian access. If that [1:47:59] doesn't work, then the developer and city council would have a discussion on what that [1:48:02] would look like in the future. The number five was subject to street islands of drainage [1:48:07] fields being the responsibility of the homeowners association for maintenance and uniformity [1:48:11] and management. The number six was subject to a final modified roadway section being [1:48:15] approved by the city engineer. That dealt with that turn lane and the potential drainage [1:48:19] the sides of the collector concludes our report. We have a Tyler Ellison. You want to go last? [1:48:44] Come on down. How about carrying his open? I have my name is Tyler Ellison and I leave at [1:49:07] 2264 Candle Ridge Drive right there. Close. I also own a professional lot on the corner of [1:49:17] Eastland and Village Park Avenue. This area of town is very professionally and personally [1:49:24] investment for me. That's why I want to talk about this. I appreciate I'll take [1:49:29] as close as I can to the PUD agreement. Mr. Martin is allowed to talk pretty [1:49:33] free about development and the echo things he addressed here. I understand [1:49:38] that 14 years ago this was okay or passed or the terminology is but why not [1:49:44] act on it then. We'll bring that up but nothing was done on it. It was brought [1:49:50] before us again after several communities little subdivisions have [1:49:55] since gone in. I live in Canada Ridge, what's considered Canada East. There's 30-some mod [1:50:02] developments in there. If you overlay that on his development, they're roughly the same [1:50:06] size acreage. This was bottom of the planning of the zone, I just want to bring this up again. [1:50:10] It states that there's going to be 58 roughly homes on 45 acres. Minus, 19 acres, that sits [1:50:16] to the west right there in that parcel. These acre lots, to be honest with you, do not match [1:50:23] the surrounding neighborhoods, the ones in my neighborhood are half an acre, the ones along [1:50:28] the pole line are close to an acre, these lots are considerably smaller, they're considered [1:50:34] a moderate density, for the place where it sits, this is me, this is turning into high density [1:50:38] housing, it goes without saying but I'll say it out loud, what's the reason for that, why [1:50:43] more lots? [1:50:44] So that's my biggest concern is I live here, I plan to build an office right next to this, [1:51:00] Before I'm very much invested on what this is going to turn into, I have no doubt that Mr. Mars will build a nice beautiful place. [1:51:06] But it is literally going to be home next to home, next to home with not much of a yard at all. [1:51:12] You're going to see homes, some landscape, and not a lot of grain. [1:51:15] I guess I could go on and on be basically addressed most of it there. [1:51:22] I'd like the Council to really consider that. [1:51:25] This does, I think, apply very much this beauty. [1:51:28] It's a looky bit there. [1:51:32] One last thing I want to bring up, you mentioned it. [1:51:34] mentioned it Mr. Mars as far as the trail goes if you can just map out where that [1:51:38] will go but long east one will go it'll go right there if you stop right there [1:51:47] Mike my subdivision right at that and has a portion of trail in it it goes right [1:51:54] along East one and then dumps onto East one right around north to South Temple [1:51:58] it's gone so our subdivision right there sits on an island if he goes to [1:52:05] develop this there's one gentleman's place that stands in there of a couple [1:52:11] 100 yards where we sit on an island we're forced to go on to Eastland on the road. I run this several times a week [1:52:17] And literally without running on somebody's private property on force. You're honest [1:52:21] One thing I like the city considers this goes along and also Mr. Mars to consider is connected, please [1:52:28] There are reasons and you do have an easement on that Joe's property [1:52:32] Or it might be to do it at the planning is only they said they couldn't do it [1:52:36] He said there's no we can do anything about that. It's gonna be like that [1:52:39] But I know you can do it. I'm in a domain, whatever you call it. You can do it. And you can complete that trail and help us. [1:52:44] Thank you. [1:52:46] Stay safe, Campbell. [1:52:54] Council members, thank you for your time tonight. I want to speak about this development openly, but I also want to clear some things here. [1:53:15] So I'm speaking not only on the behalf of my ownership of property within the skyline development, which is directly tied to this, but I also own a residence within the willows. [1:53:25] I'm also speaking for some of the residents of the willows tonight as we've held a meeting [1:53:30] and I'm here to speak on their behalf and some of their comments are included in this document that was sent to you guys last week. [1:53:37] So with that said, a couple of things that I want to address right off the bat are we represent a small portion of a homeowner group, [1:53:47] group, a body of homeowners, it's in this entire area, candle ridge, skyline, the other [1:53:53] ones that are associated next to the willows, show some heights, isn't any development out [1:53:58] there. [1:53:59] And what I want to address is a couple of things that I was actively involved in. [1:54:02] I've talked with some of you before, and that's partially due to the Vision 2035 document [1:54:07] that was put in front of you guys. [1:54:10] One of the key elements of that, and I'm going to pull up a couple of notes here. [1:54:17] There were some specific things that came out of the word cloud in that development. [1:54:21] One is, improve or expand pedestrian sidewalks and trail access. [1:54:26] That was one of the resounding things that came out of that document when the entire public [1:54:30] and the entire portion of the city was pulled in that process. [1:54:35] Manage growth had developed responsibly. [1:54:37] That was the second largest word cloud that came out of that document. [1:54:42] Another piece that was prior to that, they asked, what is key, what is the key things [1:54:47] the attributes of this city, the small-town field, and the outdoor activities, those are [1:54:52] two key things that came out of that document that frames how the city wants to develop. [1:54:58] A couple of things that I want to hit on here. We support the responsible development of lands [1:55:07] within Twin Falls and the surrounding impact areas. Further, we believe the intent of the [1:55:11] preserved development is to provide an architecturally appealing development that [1:55:15] I want to hands the property values of the adjacent lands and become a beautiful part of the City of Twin Falls, if developed responsibly. [1:55:23] We feel though, there are some things that are on this here, and some of those items I'm going to address and you have this document in front of you. [1:55:35] Any of you that have ever spent any time traveling down Hankins heading towards Evil Knievel's jump in any recent period of time [1:55:43] time realizes that that is the main thoroughfare for people who walk their dogs ride their bikes [1:55:48] run. It's a great access point. It has a connection from Evil Knievel's jump all the way to Morning Sun [1:55:54] and the other developments that are out there to main access area. This development is going to [1:55:59] exacerbate the issues that are associated with the traffic on Hankins. We're just talking about one [1:56:05] piece of it here and the developer is doing a good job of trying to focus on. I'm only talking [1:56:09] about this one section. It's a vision. That's the purpose behind the city is to develop reasonably. [1:56:16] The full development connects this back into Hankins. It connects it back into other city streets. [1:56:25] The roundabout that is shown in this development is intended to connect to Hankins. [1:56:30] On Hankins, especially at the willows or social heights or these areas, there's only one in and out. [1:56:35] We only have one way in and out of that area. We don't have a back row. We don't have any other [1:56:40] access and emergency services come into questions on anything that's high [1:56:44] volume. So from a safety standpoint, it's a great concern to us. As the phase [1:56:51] development intersects with Hankins and Carrij Lane, the connections will [1:56:55] ultimately drive traffic and pedestrians on to falls of Hankins. We believe the [1:56:59] development must incorporate changes to the frontage along the linear length of [1:57:03] Hankins property line. Additionally, we believe the city has to address the traffic [1:57:06] and pedestrian impacts on Hankins through the allowance of additional [1:57:11] developments such as social price and the extension of the canyon and trail system. Specifically, [1:57:16] the city without addressing the traffic and conditions on Hankins has exacerbated the risk [1:57:21] of a vehicle pedestrian incident. These are strong words, but I can tell you they're founded [1:57:27] in fact. There have been a number of incidents where people have reported in all these developments [1:57:31] of near misses. There's a lot of traffic and poor lighting. There's really no road lighting [1:57:35] out there. It's a very narrow roadway. Enemy enters. Some of the developments that were done [1:57:40] of the past actually have some form of curb and gutter on there, the others are very narrow [1:57:46] still rural area. Therefore, we suggest the following changes to Hankins, which must be [1:57:52] included as mandatory conditions for the developer and for the approval of the project. The willows, [1:57:58] speaking on the homeowners that were associated with this, will support the project if the [1:58:03] following items are incorporated into the design. I'm not going to ask for much, and [1:58:08] and I'm going to quantify that here in a short period of time, but we believe in this first [1:58:13] phase there needs to be something done to address Hankins and that needs to be either [1:58:19] around about to conform with what the developers already proposed. [1:58:23] I think that when he'd have formally adapted to what he's planning on the internals of the [1:58:29] development, the second aspect of that is we think there needs to be buffer lanes and greenscaping [1:58:35] which conforms with what he suggested within his development plan. [1:58:39] However, that needs to be extended to Hankins, especially along the linear length of his development, [1:58:45] so that we have meandering paths, and we have buffers between the roadway and the development. [1:58:56] Second section that I wanted to discuss is construction traffic and development access times. [1:59:01] It's been a key thing I've spoken to a lot of the homeowners that are in this area, [1:59:06] and the associated area and everyone's greatly concerned about the fact that, [1:59:10] The construction types for this large image of element as it's currently platted [1:59:14] And you can correct me if I'm wrong there's over 1000 building lots in this entire development [1:59:20] Correct. It's clatted that way. It's what shows the table. So how many ultimate building lots would there be? [1:59:26] Yes, we have one preliminary plan, so that's not actually the final plan [1:59:35] So there's no confirmed number of lots because it hasn't been planted yet [1:59:40] If we consider the lots that are currently preliminary platted [1:59:49] and you overlay that over that development, there be potentially 400 homes developed [1:59:57] within that cloud without any changes in density. It's a lot of foot traffic where those people [2:00:03] are going to go, how are they going to get to the tram? Those are the questions we ask. [2:00:07] During the construction periods, what we're asking for is at least some kind of constraints put on [2:00:11] by the city so that one, it doesn't affect the harmonious activities of the lifestyles of the [2:00:17] of the individuals that are in this area. [2:00:19] Large developments of this style, they can be very disruptive. [2:00:23] We've all invested a great deal to live in these areas, [2:00:26] and we would like to have at least a harmonious life [2:00:28] to where construction occurs during the normal business [2:00:30] hours as an ask. [2:00:32] We'd like to see you impose some of those restrictions [2:00:34] on this development. [2:00:37] Additionally, we believe that this is a great location [2:00:42] and a great area for you to start imposing dark sky [2:00:45] ordinances. [2:00:47] That's one of the aspects of the willows. [2:00:49] This is one of the aspects of Skyline and some of the beautiful things that happen out there in the canyon [2:00:53] Ramis, I can actually stand out in my backyard, look up at 9 seed stars. [2:00:57] It was one of the development agreements within the willows, it's a through-be-know-up lighting. [2:01:02] There is no up lighting, it's dark, it's very nice. [2:01:07] We think that reasonably this should be something that's placed on the development plan, [2:01:12] so that the developer has to conform to those standards to keep that nice urban slash residential interface [2:01:21] and to a country, moderate agricultural interface. [2:01:25] That's really what it is and sandwich in between that. [2:01:28] So those are some of the things that we've asked. [2:01:32] A couple other facts that we wanted to throw out [2:01:34] because there's been some statements by others that they've said, [2:01:38] well, how would the city pay for this and how would that work? [2:01:41] So I've got a few numbers here. [2:01:44] If 400 homes are developed and the average sale price of a lot, [2:01:48] I'd be very conservative on this. [2:01:50] $26 million in gross revenue. [2:01:56] Average home value $275,000 is the city's current published tax rate of 0.0765930 is [2:02:04] $2,106.30 per home collected. [2:02:08] That's based on the current rate. [2:02:10] 400 homes, $842,523,000 annually. [2:02:13] A lot of money, a lot of revenue. [2:02:17] You can get a lot done with that. [2:02:20] So with one in access in and out of the willows, [2:02:23] in and out of Shoshan Heights, [2:02:26] the congestion's on Hankins Road, [2:02:28] as I've shown here in the documents that you have, [2:02:31] we're asking that it's imposed upon the developer [2:02:35] to include those attributes within his section [2:02:38] that runs along Hankins Road, [2:02:40] all of his property line development, [2:02:43] and that the city addressed it from an overall road [2:02:45] and master plan to address the issues with the traffic [2:02:50] the walkways and the access to that area. Now I can speak frankly and say that I do [2:02:56] own the property on the corner of Falls Avenue at Hankins and I've already [2:03:01] discussed with the city plans to allow them to bring the trail around there [2:03:05] because I think it's an issue. They improved one section of the corner there by [2:03:09] the Boy Scouts Center. The fence has already sat back. I think that that needs [2:03:14] to happen along there and that's giving up property on that corner. I think it's [2:03:21] It's reasonable that we impose that on the developer and it becomes part of the master [2:03:26] plan as an amendment which you can do. [2:03:28] You have the power to do that. [2:03:33] I really appreciate your time. [2:03:34] These documents are available for you in review. [2:03:37] If you have any questions for me. [2:03:46] Seems like a major concern is the density of the overall alleged 400-on-lots that you're [2:03:53] You're realizing that this is offset in a PUD by open space that concentrates housing [2:04:01] but provides open space to break away from that or setting that you're taking this all [2:04:08] into consideration, I guess. [2:04:10] I have and what I'm really concerned about is it's not a solid housing development. [2:04:15] Absolutely. [2:04:16] We understand that. [2:04:17] We think that architecturally, we think that the journal of Marx is going to do a good [2:04:20] job of trying to aesthetically make this appealing. [2:04:23] concerned about where those people are going to go, they're going to want to take the trail [2:04:28] to get down to Shoshan Falls. They're going to want to access all of those areas. The people [2:04:34] that live in Shoshan Heights already put up signs, big signs to say private property do [2:04:39] not come on here because there's so much traffic in there for people trying to seek their way [2:04:42] out to even the needles jump. This is going to get much worse. It's shown in front of [2:04:48] you right there in black and white. It's going to connect the hankins. It's going to connect [2:04:53] to carriage. What we don't want to do is be irresponsible and impose this on the development [2:05:01] plan at this stage so that later on when it does become a major issue, we have no control [2:05:07] over it. Now is the time to put some of those things in place in order to protect the assets [2:05:14] of the city. We believe that the access down hankons and the evil canals jump is very important [2:05:18] to the city. We appreciate it. We just want it to be reasonable development with safety [2:05:23] and those are some of those key attributes. Any other questions? [2:05:32] We have Will Castro, Costello? [2:05:39] [Muted for privacy: home address] [2:05:53] [Muted for privacy: home address] [2:05:58] [Muted for privacy: home address] [2:06:02] [Muted for privacy: home address] [2:06:06] of the housing. Even with the green space I am concerned about the density [2:06:11] about the density and it is a little disruptive even with the [2:06:16] finishing of the canyon rim trail you said Greg you'd like to go up there and [2:06:20] enjoy it it's a great addition to the city but I can say that living on that road [2:06:24] the parking structure isn't big enough for the people that go there I mean [2:06:29] it's unbelievable how have such a like a postage stamp for the amount of [2:06:34] oil in there so and that's not that many people so you introduce a subdivision [2:06:39] with a lot more, you know, 400 houses, that is going to be disruptive from the standpoint [2:06:44] [Muted for privacy: home address] [2:06:51] [Muted for privacy: home address] [2:06:57] [Muted for privacy: home address] [2:07:01] [Muted for privacy: home address] [2:07:05] of mine too is just the repair of making sure that that road is maintained appropriately. [2:07:09] Just a couple of points. I think it's just it all can be done. I think it's just gonna be planned appropriately [2:07:18] [Muted for privacy: home address] [2:07:59] [Muted for privacy: home address] [2:08:07] Went into the barrow pit right next to the parking lot because it's not [2:08:11] It's not [2:08:12] No signs or anything to tell him where the roadway was to get into that parking lot and he just drove off the side of Eastland [2:08:19] And down straight down. He just knows died into the borrow pit [2:08:22] So it's it is dangerous. It needs needs help [2:08:27] My concern is those four acres [2:08:30] Across the street from my house [2:08:33] They are in the preserve [2:08:37] But they have access on our private road that starts at pillar falls [2:08:43] So that is a private road. [2:08:45] I addressed the planning and zoning meeting and Gerald Martin said that they would repair [2:08:50] those roads when the houses were being built, but we have a private road, we maintain that [2:08:55] road, we pay to pay that road, we pay for our own snow removal, so I don't understand [2:09:03] how those three houses that would be in that location can be part of their preserve and [2:09:11] be part of my subdivision. That makes any sense. They would have press raise irrigation from [2:09:23] the preserve, but they are part of my subdivision, so we have a continued long-term repair of [2:09:31] that road. How would they be addressed to help us maintain that road? Will they be required [2:09:38] and to access that. That is all I have. And I also want to make sure that when he develops those four acres, that's [2:09:54] Peller Falls. Peller Falls meanders through those four acres. And so will Peller Falls still exist? Will we still have [2:10:01] Peller Falls that everybody comes in and walks down to? So I want to make sure that is still. I would like to see that continue. [2:10:10] Thank you very much. [2:10:13] Time you can ask quickly. Is that the name of the stream that runs south to north? Is that the name of the stream? [2:10:27] The falls is down the canyon of course [2:10:37] Okay [2:10:41] Is there anyone outside? I have nobody else on the sign if she did anybody else come to speak to this issue tonight [2:10:50] Right, we'll close the public hearing [2:11:13] with and participated in the cost of paving that road and the maintenance there of as [2:11:33] though we were the other residents on that street. [2:11:43] Road discussion, Hank and Road fronts on this project, actually the right-of-way for almost [2:11:49] all of it is not within the boundaries of this property. [2:11:53] We extended the chainy over to Hank and because that's the requirement of the city as a connection. [2:12:01] several phases away in this development and I don't disagree that around about it [2:12:08] that location would be good when we get to develop in that phase will work with [2:12:12] the city on the design that the city feels as most appropriate for the [2:12:16] connection of Chaney and Hankins but it's several phases away in development [2:12:23] dark sky is a great idea and it will be in the CCNR as it turns on lighting a [2:12:33] A couple of other things that wasn't getting into the details of the CCNRs, but there will [2:12:38] be no screening fences on this project period. [2:12:40] It'll be left open if you have a fence to contain your dog, it will be right on her. [2:12:47] We'll walk to everybody to share in the green space. [2:12:52] We don't want to fight for six foot or seven foot, vinyl or wood or fence. [2:12:58] That's why I'm removing the berm along the along the eastland, reduce sight through that [2:13:06] So that it opens it up to the neighborhood, to the green space, there is going to be a lot of open space throughout this project, [2:13:16] partially because of the water, partially because of the rock, and partially because of the design. [2:13:22] But we are going to obviously have to be very careful as we go through the initial phases because we can create our own opposition. [2:13:34] if we don't clearly demonstrate what's going to be open, what's going to remain open. [2:13:38] That will be part of the master plan that we use as part of our marketing entity. [2:13:51] We're half on this fish phase. We're half of what that zoning allows for. [2:13:57] We spend a lot of time working with marketing people and what people are looking for, [2:14:02] elimination of fences, elimination of those type of barriers, give it a much more open [2:14:12] feel. Everybody to be able to see this, want to fence a screening fence all the way around [2:14:22] your lot and create your own little island that you probably don't want to buy in this [2:14:27] subdivision. But I've seen very many. In today's market, there's a big demand for that open [2:14:34] get to know your neighbor. Patable landscaping. Commonly met landscape. [2:14:43] Furnages commonly maintained facilities. I hope I'm right and I believe I am. [2:14:50] And the people that are moving here in the next generation. Much more [2:14:59] appreciative of the nature, the life, the open space, the trails, type of things and [2:15:07] We will put the dark sky in the CCNRs. [2:15:12] We'll have to work with the city on street lighting, [2:15:15] but this will not have the standard seat. [2:15:18] This will be light morning, so we will put custom street lights in. [2:15:22] We can identify street lights that are dark sky. [2:15:26] Don't light the sky, light the pavement, not the sky, [2:15:30] light the trail, not the sky. [2:15:32] I think those are the questions that I've asked one. [2:15:39] Well, obviously on the commit that's on the screen that shows the allowed density that's [2:16:10] Was owning some 12 or 15 years ago that matches his owning for [2:16:19] basically R2 on R1 type zoning. You can't get that, you could, but you could afford to get that because of the [2:16:31] Mount of Rock on the photography out there. I think the total density is going to be somewhere in the neighborhood of half of that if it's [2:16:41] market, that is going to be market driven. I can see [2:16:49] more estate lots and fewer R2 lots as it develops because of the topography [2:17:00] it's easier to develop a three-quarter one-acre lot than it is a quarter-acre [2:17:09] lot because you can be under around some of those rock outcroppings [2:17:15] corporate them into a lot and corporate them as a architectural feature but not [2:17:21] have to move the rock and so I think you'll see that as it moves east you'll get [2:17:26] more state lots fewer of the more typical residential lots. It gets rock here as [2:17:35] you go east. The West [2:17:44] That answer your question? [2:17:48] Yes. [2:17:49] Thank you. [2:17:49] Chris Cockerton? [2:17:50] Chris kind of goes back to basics on the PUD coming into the city trail. [2:17:55] The property will of course be on the city water and waste water and a pressurized irrigation system. [2:18:02] I'm not the city pressure, private pressurized irrigation. [2:18:05] How about the waste water and the potable water? [2:18:10] The city water, the city sewer and of course all of the other things you have to laugh now, cable and... [2:18:17] for staff, not for general. [2:18:41] Jonathan or the planning department or city staff, [2:18:51] there was a mention of Hagen Road, Hagen Road, [2:18:54] and I understand that most of it would be adjacent [2:18:59] to Shoshan Heights as well, [2:19:01] and so was there any plans in the [2:19:04] and our discussions with Shoshan Heights [2:19:06] when they went in about the extension of Hagen Road? [2:19:10] I'm not aware of the extent of those discussions [2:19:13] with Shoshan Heights. [2:19:14] Confirm the two areas that they have butt [2:19:17] Hankins are right here [2:19:19] and it jogs around the house [2:19:22] It comes back for [2:19:26] They don't actually have a lot of Hankins throat frontage [2:19:30] We're talking about the preserve itself [2:19:33] Right [2:19:34] We know Cheney [2:19:36] The plan for Cheney is to come through [2:19:38] and have a connection over to this area [2:19:40] because that would follow our grid of that quarter [2:19:43] It's a quarter mile [2:19:45] To connect those between the arterials [2:19:47] the other quarter miles. So that connectivity is important for all forms of traffic. That's [2:19:55] including pedestrian, bicycle, roller skates, scooter, whatever you want to call, whatever [2:20:01] you want to get on there, including cars. So we know that the plan is to connect it to [2:20:05] Ankins Road. As far as the discussions with Shoshan Heights, I was not personally involved [2:20:12] in those discussions, but I can't say that this is the City Limit Line. The Preserve [2:20:18] is what's in city limits and everything else out here. [2:20:21] It's not in city limits unless it's our property [2:20:24] and we have an access road to the jumpside [2:20:31] that is parallel to this eastern boundary. [2:20:34] Although that is not hand control itself. [2:20:38] We connect to hand control down here. [2:20:40] Small portion right here. [2:20:44] And we have the gun range which is further to the east. [2:20:46] It does not. [2:20:48] But hand control, our property kinda comes up [2:20:50] around into the canyon, connects with this at the jump site, bigger and this is [2:20:58] Turkey's Lake and Shushun, our property, the gun raid and the Shushun falls over here. [2:21:04] Well, Greg, I was around with Shushun falls, came in the subdivision of Shushun [2:21:11] Heights, I mean, Hankins Road, as a city arterial, will stop at that [2:21:16] intersection with Cheney, it does not continue north of Cheney, it is down [2:21:22] upgraded to a residential street and it goes north and they even renamed it and [2:21:28] it goes into the subdivision of Chishol Heights. This kind of me enters through [2:21:32] the subdivision a little bit but it as a city arterial, Anken's does not continue [2:21:39] north of the intersection with Cheney. Thank you, Madam. [2:21:48] So really the PUD, the density and all that has been previously approved by the city. [2:21:57] 2006 and really what we're discussing tonight are those five changes to it [2:22:05] What else we're hearing on some of these other things? Yeah, and that you know with large developments of 347 acres [2:22:16] It's not uncommon to have that [2:22:18] Something like this take a while to get developed as far as having any conditions that would amend some of that [2:22:30] Planning perspective. I think that would be rough trying to have the [2:22:33] what they're asking for in the condition that may or may not connect to what [2:22:39] they're asking for. The reasonable nexus is what we're going for. I think it's a tough [2:22:46] that'd be tough to do. I just want to make sure I was understanding correctly. Thank you. [2:22:52] The folks that have shown up that the urban surrounding area to the one-in-quest [2:23:21] can take this so many times over the years where existing growth is encroached [2:23:29] upon my new growth coming in. [2:23:32] It's the most difficult thing we have to encounter. [2:23:36] And I don't go out the way, [2:23:38] because I think some of you like to keep that space open [2:23:41] for eternity, and I could probably agree with that myself, [2:23:45] but the best protection the city can provide [2:23:48] is to go through our ordinances, [2:23:51] especially the one that allows the PUD [2:23:54] to give you the open space for pufferin'. [2:23:56] I have some great deal with some great hesitation because of the potential density of the homes. [2:24:04] But it's in compliance with our city ordinances, the attached conditions fiber, so conditions are, [2:24:14] I think a reasonable upgrade request with protection. [2:24:18] I don't know of a white bridge to the gap because it's such a dichotomous yes or no black or white issue. [2:24:26] issue. It's not an easy decision for us to make. [2:24:30] I would like to speak to it a little bit. This is an area where there is a great demand and [2:24:41] we do want to do it responsibly. And I have lived out in that area and the wide open space [2:24:50] is really appealing. What's being proposed has a lot of wide open space. And I think [2:25:00] As we continue to grow, this is a great location, and the reason it hasn't been developed is because it's really challenging. [2:25:14] We have somebody that has presented a really nice idea that has been supported through planning and zoning and all the things that they've gone through. [2:25:25] So far I appreciate those who came and spoke I can I can really empathize with because I used I don't live that far now [2:25:33] But I used to live out in that area and I think there this is proceeding with a nice way to do this [2:25:40] But I I also believe this this is a huge project and we're growing but we're not growing that fast [2:25:48] This is not going to happen and [2:25:51] And as this first piece is developed and the process continues, I think during that amount [2:26:02] of time, good decisions can be made as it goes, setting everything in stone right now may not [2:26:11] be in the best interest of everybody who already even lives out there. [2:26:16] But we do want logical, responsible growth, absolutely. [2:26:22] But I don't know that putting a big list of things that has to be done for the way future [2:26:29] right now is in the best interest of things change and as our town continues to develop, [2:26:36] I think we want the flexibility of what some of the next phases may produce. [2:26:43] So within the scope of what's been presented and the order in which it's going to be developed, [2:26:50] I think I would be in support of this. [2:26:53] Suzanne, yep. [2:26:57] I think this question is for you. [2:26:59] We had a couple comments about the parking area at the trailhead where we're at. [2:27:04] I know we have some things coming. [2:27:06] Maybe you could just speak to that for a minute so folks know that we know the parking lot needs attention out there. [2:27:12] That's kind of funny because when we were doing the plans for that, I told Gerald and Wendy 15 spaces out there. [2:27:27] They didn't listen to me. [2:27:28] They put 27 out there. [2:27:30] And it's inadequate, completely inadequate. [2:27:34] We need to double that lot. [2:27:36] Wendy's got absolutely aware and we've been talking about how that property is developing. [2:27:44] She's got plans that a restroom has also been talked about in that park, [2:27:48] while it's maybe doubling the size of that parking lot. [2:27:53] It probably won't be, I mean, this three acres park. [2:27:55] It probably won't be much more than parking lot in the restroom. [2:27:58] We're all sitting down with it, so that's coming. [2:28:02] We know. [2:28:03] But we are going to improve that parking and get signage and it's not quite finished [2:28:08] just yet what somebody mentioned the driveway going in and out of it and that was something [2:28:13] that we honestly didn't have time to finish before that cold weather came and that's [2:28:18] still yet to come is to make the final driveway location. [2:28:21] That'll happen here pretty soon. [2:28:24] Thank you. [2:28:25] Just want to make sure that citizens were aware that we are aware and we're going in [2:28:28] that direction. [2:28:29] Rick, Lanting? [2:28:31] Well, I have the Chris may have been part of this. [2:28:36] I was actually on planning zoning when this first came in way back with 14 years ago. [2:28:45] Then I happened to be on council when we approved it. [2:28:48] I got to see it both times then. [2:28:51] I'm struck by the difference and the number of people appearing to be concerned by it. [2:28:57] I don't remember a single soul speaking 14 years ago, maybe I'm wrong, but I don't think [2:29:04] there was at either time because of the fact that the vast amount of open space and the [2:29:13] state lots to the east, which was to protect those larger lots over there, I'm very familiar [2:29:23] with Mr. Mark's work, I'm certain and he is the information I have from him and others [2:29:29] about this is kind of his baby so to speak to make sure this is a great [2:29:36] addition to the city of Twin Falls and I will be in favor of it and because [2:29:42] partially because my confidence in him to make it the best development possible [2:29:47] and like I said this property has been waiting to develop for a really long [2:29:54] time and the market is now there for it to develop probably not very quickly [2:30:00] I'm pretty sure by the time you get all the way to the east I'm not going to be on this council any longer so [2:30:07] I will be voting in favor of this and if we're ready for emotion [2:30:15] That's okay [2:30:22] Just those that are out there, I know that I'm planning and zoning we've talked about roads [2:30:30] What is the process? [2:30:33] improving roads in a situation like this where we've gone from [2:30:37] more of a country road and recognizing as Mitch pointed out [2:30:41] the entire way to the canyon or to the gem site isn't [2:30:44] isn't city road but what is that process if you can just kind of go over that [2:30:48] okay so [2:30:50] when a developer such as Joe comes in [2:30:52] and I'll use the example of what we have on this western side [2:30:56] he's planning [2:30:58] this area he came in for preliminary plan for this general area [2:31:01] When that occurs, they identify the public roadway [2:31:07] that they're going to dedicate to the public. [2:31:10] City is a purveyor of the public, quote unquote, [2:31:12] the public in our jurisdiction. [2:31:15] And when it's not in our jurisdiction, [2:31:17] that roadway is not necessarily dedicated in the county. [2:31:20] They use that as easements, [2:31:22] it's an easement from the center of the roadway. [2:31:24] And they do 25 feet from either side of that [2:31:26] center of the roadway line. [2:31:28] When it comes in for development, [2:31:29] they would then develop or build. [2:31:32] They've built the road according to the standards that we have in engineering, but I'm not sure [2:31:38] what the name of it is, but it's like a city standard drawing or ISPWC standard drawing [2:31:42] of here's how wide the road is, here's the curve, the gutter to sidewalk. [2:31:48] So in his case he came in, developed this portion, he's going to build certain roads [2:31:52] to those standards, he dedicates the roadway to the city or the public. [2:31:57] That's how the roads get built. [2:31:59] So when he comes over here to the eastern side, and this starts to be planted preliminary and [2:32:05] then final, they would propose what those roads look like per the city's standard in theory. [2:32:13] There's other standards, not just their typical section, we have other sections that potentially [2:32:17] around about that might be in there, I'm not an engineer, so I don't know everything that [2:32:22] book. [2:32:24] So when we're talking about hankins specifically, when it gets preliminary planted, that is when [2:32:30] that roadway is identified as being dedicated, and that's when the road sections that they're [2:32:35] talking about could possibly be shown with those modifications they were looking at or [2:32:42] the exhibit you saw. In this case, it's a very small section of Hinkins that's on Mr. Martin's [2:32:50] property. We have Hinkins Road that was previously developed in the county. At a time, I'm not a [2:32:57] where I don't know when Skyline was done, I believe in the 70s, it may not have even been in the city's area of impact, so we have a road section that's under the county's jurisdiction, or the highway district I should say, and they have a typical roadway section of a width, borrow ditch, etc, so that's how roads get built, it's when they get developed and they dedicate them as part of the planning process. [2:33:24] So the only thing I would add to anybody is looking at it, you will be notified if you're within 300 feet of a preliminary plat of the exterior boundary of a preliminary plat. [2:33:34] When you see those signs that go up saying public hearing, you can call the number, we can tell you what they're developing, what it looks like. [2:33:43] I know when this area over here gets preliminary plated, there will be a sign on Hanken's Road [2:33:49] to call if any zoning change, any plat that comes through for the preliminary side of it. [2:33:56] That's the time to kind of potentially engage in some of those conversations [2:34:03] and bring them to the planning and zoning commission for that. [2:34:05] Thank you. [2:34:07] That's a good question for me. [2:34:10] I kind of got the drift that they would expect the city to rebuild Hankins Road to because [2:34:18] of the money, extra tax money would be receiving them, but that's not in the city limits, is [2:34:23] that even possible for us to do? I don't think so. I mean, it would be basically [2:34:30] a hard good nature to build a road that is under the Twin Falls Highway District jurisdiction. [2:34:35] The Twin Falls Highway District could rebuild. It could rebuild that it's under their jurisdiction, [2:34:39] Basically from falls up to Hankins on the north side, I mean, falls up to Cheney up to that area is not in city limits [2:35:04] Something else was mentioned that I'm just curious and I think this is probably for you Travis [2:35:09] They talked about that one little section of trail on Eastland that isn't finished [2:35:13] and he talked about using imminent domain, but you cannot use imminent domain for trial purposes, is that correct? [2:35:19] Yeah, my understanding is the legislature had removed that process in the 2016 legislative session as a result of issues that were going on in the city of Pocatello, and I also believe cities in the Treasure Valley. [2:35:34] This is making sure. [2:35:35] Thank you, so Zalad, I forgot that. [2:35:39] We're ready for motion. [2:35:44] I move that we read, approve the request for PUD amendment to the preserve, PUD number [2:35:51] 261 to reflect the changes in proposed uses, project boundary completion of Canyon Nrib [2:35:57] Trail, Dedekieke, Trailhead Park and to allow project specific roadway standards on approximately [2:36:05] 370 acres located in the south east corner of Eastland Drive north and Pole Line Road [2:36:10] East and Jonathan do we need the six conditions? [2:36:15] And the six conditions. [2:36:17] Second. [2:36:20] Motion eight, meeting seconded by here's other questions [2:36:26] at this time. [2:36:35] Nicky Boyd. [2:36:36] Yes. [2:36:37] Chris Tockington. [2:36:39] Yes. [2:36:39] Greg Lanting. [2:36:40] Yes. [2:36:41] Christopher Reed. [2:36:42] Yes. [2:36:43] Ruth Pears. [2:36:43] Yes. [2:36:44] Zann Hawkins. [2:36:45] Yes. [2:36:46] Motion passes six to zero. [2:36:54] With that, you have adjournment. [2:36:59] There's nothing else.