Oversight Archive: City Council meeting, 2018-10-08, recording 1 (started 17:00) Machine transcript (faster-whisper base.en), not checked word for word; the Pledge of Allegiance is shown in its standard wording. The recording is the record. Times are time into the recording. Passages with private details are muted in the audio and marked here. The audio on the page below was re-encoded by software from the video the agency posted. Check any passage against that audio before relying on it. Page: https://oversightarchive.org/twin-falls-id/meetings/2018-10-08/ [0:01:56] Council meeting for Monday, October 8th, and confirm that we do have a quorum of the Council here. [0:02:02] Five of the seven members are present here in the Council chambers. [0:02:06] Councilman Lanting is joining us on the telephone, and I'm a League Fire Station citizen committee. [0:02:16] So he is next on the agenda. [0:02:22] It's the Pledge of Allegiance for those of you wishing to join us. Please rise. [0:02:25] This evening, so next on the agenda is an opportunity for general public input. [0:02:52] If there's anyone here from the public who would like to address the council on an item that's out of the agenda this evening, [0:02:57] now is your opportunity to please come forward. [0:02:59] If you want to second that, push it by Suzanne. [0:03:31] I'll second it by Chris Tawkington to approve the consent calendar. [0:03:35] Is there any discussion? [0:03:36] Nicky Boyd? [0:03:43] Yes. [0:03:47] Chris Tawkington? [0:03:48] Yes. [0:03:49] John Berger? [0:03:50] Yes. [0:03:54] Craig Letty. [0:03:56] Yeah. [0:04:14] So, consideration of the first is a request to waive the 300 foot distance requirement [0:04:19] between an alcohol sales location at 156 Main Avenue North in a school church or other place [0:04:25] of worship. [0:04:26] We have Jonathan Spentlove, our planning and zoning director. [0:04:29] Thank you Mr. Mayor, members of the Council. [0:04:32] We received this last week. [0:04:34] There's a little bit of history. [0:04:36] I don't believe you've seen one of these in a while. [0:04:39] in a while, this is something that's kind of new to us. [0:04:41] We are trying to, after you're seeing up on the screen, [0:04:46] it is a location of 156 main. [0:04:48] It's the alcohol sales location. [0:04:51] Inca has been going through renovation process [0:04:53] to get a restaurant brewery located there. [0:04:56] It's seen, we've seen it in historic preservation, [0:04:59] some other bodies as far as the exterior to it. [0:05:03] The state code is 23-913. [0:05:08] That's the state code we're dealing with. [0:05:10] entirely, but what it talks about is no license shall be issued for any premises in any neighborhood [0:05:17] which is predominantly residential or within 300 feet of any public school of church or any [0:05:21] other place of worship. There's an exception and that is an exception with the approval [0:05:26] of the governing body of the municipality. So historically, we believe these have been [0:05:31] taking place just with the approval of an alcohol license. Right now the state has requested [0:05:37] that we provide an additional letter or decision by the governing body prior to the applicant [0:05:44] actually being able to receive the state license. The order of operation typically is [0:05:49] something that goes to the state. It gets the state license, it goes to the county, it [0:05:52] gets the county license and it comes to the city for the final license prior to operating. [0:05:56] As this is a brewery, Mr. Cook can't actually start doing anything with the equipment until [0:06:03] he receives all licenses. He can't start up the equipment or do anything. So, we're kind [0:06:08] of kind of catching up on this one. We don't know if the process is no longer [0:06:13] acceptable to the state. We're going to have a quicker process and get ahead of [0:06:18] these a little bit in the future. This is just something that we're now. So as far [0:06:23] as we know the process it would go is an approval by the Council majority vote to [0:06:28] waive that 300 foot. The past vacation up there at 164 which is the corner of [0:06:36] Maine and Gooding has a location with a license that was approved about a year [0:06:40] year and a half or two years ago, it was a restaurant that serves beer and wine, and [0:06:44] there's other ones along that street, so this is not unprecedented to have something near [0:06:49] this place of worship. And the school district office, even though not a school teaching going [0:06:57] on, the state codes aren't really clear as to what a school would call conclusion. Should [0:07:04] the council such use, there's three different options to take the request for additional [0:07:11] information, deny the request for the distance exception, or approve the request for the [0:07:15] for the distance exception as allowed per state code 23913 allowing an [0:07:20] alcohol license to be issued at 156 being out in north and feet of the school church. [0:07:25] As I saw Jimson here, so Kent is here, just signed up to put on this item, [0:07:53] come down some Mr. Edwards. I see you signed up for this comments. Edwards Twin Falls, [0:08:10] my concern is that you can waive code, state code, to waive that. I would like to [0:08:23] I know if you would weigh the cost of my water and my sewer, could you wave that also? [0:08:30] I would like to privilege of possibly within the 300 foot zone when somebody comes in and [0:08:46] buys a piece of property, they got to do their due diligence and find out if it's legal to [0:08:51] even have a burlesque hall or something in the zone. [0:08:58] don't understand why wasn't this resolved before the purchase the property and it [0:09:07] was for somewhere else the whole idea of not having within a school zone or within [0:09:17] a residential area or close to a place of worship is the fact that they don't [0:09:23] we don't want that stuff you know what are you gonna do because you want traffic [0:09:28] downstairs or downtown you gave all these restrictions so that you can gather [0:09:35] more people there so what's it going to come this is going to be bar night on Friday night which [0:09:40] it already has become I think it's just a wrong thing for the city council to do and I don't believe [0:09:46] that you're doing your job if you may have this required restriction as president said [0:10:19] and I found sort of like a worship board this morning conversations with other places about the [0:11:33] elders and this is where it gets kind of the code we're dealing with isn't the state alcohol [0:11:42] I'll license section. The zoning code is different. It's a separate deal that we're dealing with. [0:11:47] So it's normally wouldn't come into my purview of having those conversations with people. [0:11:52] It's kind of this new thing that we had dealt with in a divvy previously. [0:11:56] Now the state's come back and saying we can't even start with this process without the council approval. [0:12:02] So we're trying to get them through the process. [0:12:04] The worship went in. [0:12:10] Seconded by Suzanne Hocken, a two-way of the 300-foot distance requirement. [0:13:10] That's what we're purview. [0:13:17] Yeah, this is to approve by Chris Dockington, second advice to San [0:13:35] Hawkins to approve the request. [0:13:37] Is there any further? [0:13:37] Sean Baraker, Dan Hawkins. [0:13:46] Yes. [0:13:46] Rick Lanting. [0:13:48] Yeah. [0:13:49] Bruce Pierce. [0:13:50] Yes. [0:13:50] And Chris Dockington. [0:13:51] Yes. [0:13:52] Motion passes 6 to 0. [0:13:57] Next on the introduction of the Youth Council Executive Board. [0:14:04] Hawkins. [0:14:05] As most of you are aware, the City of Twin Falls sponsors [0:14:10] a Youth Advisory Council to give our high school students [0:14:14] a chance to participate in local government and activities. [0:14:25] So members who have joined the Youth Council this year, [0:14:33] at that first meeting, they and two of the first themselves [0:14:41] to you and our president will also introduce [0:14:44] the rest of her executive team. [0:15:42] Welcome, sir, on the Youth Council. [0:15:44] I, too, bring awareness to the problem we're [0:15:53] have teen suicide, and so we're hoping [0:15:56] to become a student to know that there is a. [0:16:10] Next on the agenda is a request to review proposals [0:16:12] and provide direction regarding the sale of real property [0:16:15] owned by the City of Twin Falls, located at 324 Hanson Street East. [0:16:20] To start off, we have Mitch Humbler, Deputy City Manager, [0:16:22] one of our Deputy City Managers. [0:16:45] So tonight, you have a last November process, [0:17:02] the state required process to try and dispose of that building. [0:17:06] In conclusion, that process, which involves an open bids [0:17:15] for the exhausted, the state required process, [0:17:22] had to move forward with do this sort of and sell the building. [0:17:28] And there's really work out. [0:17:38] So now week, and so since then, we've had conversations, five or six different parties. [0:17:50] Most recently, I've had three different parties that I've been working with pretty right times each. [0:17:59] I found myself in this kind of a weird position. [0:18:19] I'll be far ahead of chance to even bring the first one to the council for some feedback. [0:18:26] And so what I have for you today is actually three different kind of offers that we need to look at. [0:18:32] We need to take the process anymore. [0:18:53] This isn't that, this is more, I guess I would call this more akin to what the urban renewal does often when they request proposals for projects and they can look at those and evaluate those in lots of different ways. [0:19:07] And so we have that opportunity and offers that I've put in, of those three, two of the parties are here tonight, have requested that they be able to come and give a five minute presentation to you on their own. [0:19:21] their own. The first one I'll go ahead and do since they couldn't make it. I'll introduce [0:19:26] the others as they group called Summit Creek, Capital's, uh, Development Office Building. [0:19:48] So when we were in there it was like Government Office, won't be prepared else, so it'd be like [0:19:52] Full Office, $5,000, two points that they, they didn't say this in the, in the, he asked [0:20:08] me to make these two points for him since he couldn't be here, is that when it turns into [0:20:13] that office building, it will go back on to the tax rolls. So this building has not been [0:20:18] on the tax rule for errors before we owned it. [0:20:22] It was CSI that owned it, and so this has not been at the price. [0:20:44] So with that, then the next group is the Magic Valley Unitarian Universalist Fellowship. [0:21:21] So I'm a member of the Magic Valley Unitarian Universalist Fellowship, [0:21:25] and also the chair of the worship committee. [0:21:28] And with me are our president, Michelle Richmond, and board member, Michael Becerra. [0:21:37] So I'm really honored to be able to represent our fellowship, [0:21:40] But I'm really pleased to be able to speak to the City Council about this opportunity to purchase this building on needless to say, when we had the opportunity to come and look at it, all of us were very, very excited about the potential. [0:21:58] And this is really a unique opportunity, and we really hope that this will become our new building. [0:22:07] makes this really an exciting adventure to us and we see a lot of potential not [0:22:15] only for worship but to share this building with the Twin Falls community [0:22:18] and by the way others to use it for musical and theatrical events and [0:22:25] meetings and and all other sorts of think gatherings both the public and for [0:22:30] Unitarian faith has existed since the 1600s starting with his roots in Europe [0:22:43] The Magic Valley, the Unitarian Universalist Fellowship is relatively new. [0:22:49] We just celebrated our 25th anniversary and during this time period, we've moved around [0:22:55] to from many different venues as we've just rented a space for our church and now this [0:23:01] is an opportunity for permanent home for us and the potential for this is very exciting. [0:23:09] We currently have a membership of about 40 people with several non-members who attend our [0:23:15] services, and we do feel that the acquisition of this building will really help increase [0:23:20] our membership in looking at at least doubling it within the next 10 years. [0:23:26] And we are also fortunate to share a sibling support system with Inattaining Universal's [0:23:33] Fellowships in Boise, Pocatello, and Idaho Falls, and they've been extremely helpful [0:23:38] with us in because there are larger fellowships in ours and in helping us along as we have [0:23:48] celebrated this unitary and universalism and race is diversity and we believe deeply [0:23:56] in the dignity and worth of all human beings and we've chosen to donate our time and treasure [0:24:01] to local organizations to make a positive impact in the Magic Valley. [0:24:07] In the past, we've given support to the CSI Refugee Center to help people who have been [0:24:11] displaced from their home countries due to no fault of their own, and have chosen to live [0:24:16] in the United States. [0:24:17] And we help these people because we think it's the right thing to do and by helping them [0:24:23] help themselves become successful and productive members of our community. [0:24:29] But there are a number of other organizations that we have supported and they include Habitat [0:24:34] for humanity, Valley House, Idaho Food Bank, Kids Count 2, Planned Parenthood, Hospice [0:24:41] Visions, the Crisis Center of Magic Valley, and the American Burmese Friendship Organization. [0:24:48] Our preliminary plans for this building are all interior except for up. [0:24:54] We went out of sign that would meet city code to the building to show that it's our [0:25:01] fellowship for our church, but we want to maintain that original character of the [0:25:06] building exterior because we do think it's very unique and very nice. Inside though [0:25:12] our plans include removing several walls and a portion of the main floor ceiling [0:25:16] to create a higher ceiling room that would be serve as our sanctuary and [0:25:22] meeting room and we'd also move the kitchen or the area that was used as a [0:25:29] kitchen that's in the basement to the main floor and put a kitchen on the main [0:25:33] floor as well as established spaces for children's programs, some offices and [0:25:38] a library and a welcoming foyer. And then over time we plan to further develop [0:25:44] the basement and upper level or upper floor for use that can be shared with [0:25:51] our community along with other space on the main floor. We do need on Sunday [0:25:56] mornings for worship services and offer programs for adults, teens, and children. [0:26:01] And our mission is to help each person live, laugh, love, and seek truth. [0:26:07] To be a place of celebration, comfort, and learning for all ages. [0:26:12] To serve our community in the spirit of justice and democracy, and to respect all religious paths. [0:26:19] And lastly, we are cognizant that the use of this building as a place of worship does [0:26:25] exempt it from the city property tax rolls. [0:26:29] However, we do strongly believe that sharing this venue with diverse groups and engaging [0:26:35] in discussions with city sponsored causes will be a return on investment to the betterment [0:26:40] of our Twin Falls community. [0:26:42] Thank you. [0:26:44] You're on the signing sheet here, so I guess I can see if you wanted to speak for now. [0:26:58] I ask a question so you all 37,000. So fellowship have the wherewithal to make the [0:27:15] yes we do we we have a social association there are opportunities to apply for [0:27:28] grants as we've been conducting in anticipation of place like this we could [0:27:39] so we do have funds to not completely renovate the building on all three levels [0:27:48] but certainly with the name for we feel it started way back in the night today [0:29:57] gave us some of the girls down there, [0:30:01] and Odissi, American tribal style, [0:30:04] improvisational tribal style, [0:30:06] tribal fusion belly dance, [0:30:08] bahrra, just a super fun dance, [0:30:10] should look that up, [0:30:14] swords and arrows besides the thousands of hours driving. [0:30:21] Talls I did pop replacement, [0:31:06] I know it severely started with a dream. [0:31:37] My students, after they learned a very basic [0:31:41] to Utah, were often decided that I also, [0:31:48] what I wanted to bring this, [0:31:53] but also the opportunity to, [0:31:56] And so, my also I've been in concesee as I think is super important that we, as a American, [0:32:11] showing people how to speak our language. [0:32:14] And so, that's where the circus came into play. [0:32:39] These workshops learn what they have to offer, bring those as they show through the circus at the work. [0:32:45] Also, I've worked with group here in Twin Falls. They're very well known. [0:33:02] They will be offering a creative space for, um, [0:33:05] Oh, that they have to offer not just clog again, passion tap, but also they work with the Twin Falls High School and the circus would then bring to Prague. [0:33:23] So with our workshops that I'll be bringing in, personal friends of mine, Meg from Utah. [0:33:31] She puts on very large shows down there which do teach things like Vomita. [0:33:36] Also, we have other headliners and performers, tribal style, think of Lisa again, and I'm like, [0:34:10] And I'm like, so that's what the top, the idea that Joshua and I have is twofold. [0:34:22] For the past several months we've been looking for space downtown for attention for the spaces twofold. [0:34:30] The first is to have this facility that I've been talking about for the development of cultural performing arts and budget life at. [0:34:37] This portion of the facility I refer to it as the circus. [0:34:43] What's the circus? [0:35:27] I still can't say this word, I still seen Robose and Eden Woods from the starting excavation. [0:35:56] We had a pass it on to the scale study, Gary Stone, the task of students at the TSI. [0:36:43] We came out of this, we had this bill to contact the local schools. [0:36:51] We brought kids out by the bus loop for weeks on end to tour the site. [0:36:56] One of the opportunities to each and share this and part of our history. [0:37:04] That is very unique this area. [0:37:06] We'll talk about that in a minute, about how this site differs from any other site in the entire [0:37:11] plant as a sample, the mice, and the old child's spears. [0:37:49] I have a state university who also is in the chief curator here. [0:37:55] New Zealand actually has a system in studies, and two more students who look for human [0:38:11] PQ. [0:38:13] This group is carbon-dated, they can take a sample of the task, and it's actually days [0:38:19] about two thousand years before. [0:38:22] There are no settlers that we can close this group. [0:38:27] So this is actually very exciting because it is even in study. [0:38:36] There's a like, Elizabeth, a picture. [0:39:15] This lady's name is Sue, and she discovered the largest in tags ramps. [0:39:29] She saw this out in respect to the bill. [0:39:42] But I can read something quick. I have to start here from Dr. Spears. [0:39:55] He says, I understand this proposal is also fully supported by the Heritage Center and the College of Sloan-I-No. [0:40:03] By providing this well-studied space for research on the nine of the Olsen's plans for this bill, [0:40:07] this building also provide multiple communities in space for school tours to learn about Idaho's history. [0:40:12] Additionally, the Heritage Center, through the College of Southern Idaho, can facilitate new employment positions, internships, and numerous volunteer opportunities for students at the College to learn important job skills by working at the Elson facility. [0:40:26] To the completion of the math project, the ELSEN Extension Facility can give you to provide [0:40:31] service to the Harris Center and the Twin Falls Community to research for more. [0:40:41] As more finds are discovered, other regional entities require the service. [0:40:44] So our goal for the building relies the upper portion to remove most of the interior. [0:40:50] Add to the Erase Facility for also a couple of dance studios, 7 floor, higher basement. [0:41:15] Use of the study for the art research, but then to set up an opportunity for other great studies to happen, [0:41:27] It's to our kids be able to come to this research facility and study it hands-on [0:41:36] to be able to see what's going on, to give us some support. [0:41:40] They're the Heritage Center. [0:41:51] For financing this, they're in quite the same as it would be, so that's one. [0:43:30] Basically what it means is that the, and so public, that would certainly be of the solution, [0:43:54] are also for spaces to directly to this building and the next door site. [0:44:01] You can space them through with that. [0:44:18] Yeah, there's in that for the city. [0:44:27] We're in several spaces in that a lot. [0:44:49] Actually, in a conversation that they have with them. [0:45:59] you have it. [0:46:10] It's the second proposal, but not. [0:46:22] So, awesome. [0:46:23] So, we just recap the three and then I'll close up a little bit and then we request, or [0:46:39] the first proposal we got was from Summit Creek Capital for request, but it's 37,000 [0:46:52] be considered. [0:47:12] Okay, the council might feel really strongly because even though they're the lowest software, [0:47:23] we would love to have folks off the corner. [0:47:42] We're also sort of in an negotiation for $3,000. [0:47:57] Is it, is it, give me some direction? [0:48:18] Give me some direction. I've stoned you guys. I've done you one civilization that the word just scratch in the surface of the canyon [0:50:01] We jeers and not really know it myself. That's the river. We've got false side [0:50:20] We've got my side with full zip line just gets to all of these in the past [0:50:28] But we're just scratching the surface of all this and I feel like this is a really good direction to go with the history [0:50:42] There's other places that have tests like that [0:50:46] I had worse and when false, I'm going to be contrarian again. [0:51:31] What I see is that, by selling this, first of all, what's the value of this property other [0:51:36] than the $200 appraisal? [0:51:38] What does the city have meant to it? [0:51:40] And improvements in the original purchase price. [0:51:43] Thank you. [0:52:16] So I understand about $500,000 into the building. [0:52:21] So when you sell it for $300,000, you're basically subsidizing a private individual plus to the [0:52:34] $500,000. [0:52:36] So that sounds like it's kind of a giveaway. [0:52:40] You haven't been making tax dollars on it, and at $125,000 or $130,000 sale, you still [0:52:46] won't be making any tax dollars on it, not realizing people come there to get something [0:52:55] but you're basically subsidizing them. [0:53:00] I would think that since it's off the bid requirement now, [0:53:07] for the City Council to put some public notices out that [0:53:11] that thing is going to be available, and for 501c3s [0:53:15] and all the agencies that you folks promote and work with [0:53:19] have an opportunity and a shot at that, I think it would be prudent [0:53:24] to do that because there is value in that. Something that's more suitable [0:53:28] to the individuals buying it. Also tax dollars on it. The other option is just to [0:53:40] give it away. Why don't you just give it to one of those people and let them [0:53:43] develop and want to that meets that area and the parking restriction that's [0:53:49] there. When the city was using it as building, the building office there, you [0:53:55] couldn't find a place to park and you're just going in there to get a permit or [0:54:00] Ask a question. There's no parking there city sure we have working across the [0:54:06] Main screen. We got it down that way. We got it down that way and the youth center is supposed or the [0:54:15] They're supposed to have some kind of a thing built. That's all great [0:54:24] But you just give it away [0:54:29] $1,000. Just give the whole building away [0:54:34] Make more sense to me that to subsidize an individual [0:54:37] I was in really real special, but a bunch of money into it is historical, but it's not [0:57:43] heart vision says we did post that formation to anyone that search at first [0:58:29] so I was aware of folks that have some of those kinds of things [0:58:52] right to give a station like that personal thoughts ever since we started [0:59:51] looking at this building I know there's been a lot of talk about what it could [0:59:54] be candy store there that there's a library there that there's a city park [1:00:04] there I've always felt that this building needs to be something that speaks to [1:00:08] the youth and the young it's already to focus on that where the children have another [1:00:38] second [1:00:48] since we don't have sex here [1:00:53] glanting [1:01:13] roose pears [1:01:14] yes [1:01:15] was talking to [1:01:17] on bergar [1:01:18] the people [1:01:46] pre-saying [1:02:00] micholas to go market the facility [1:02:04] no i won't [1:02:06] did it go [1:02:08] through the applicant [1:02:09] becomes a fantastic [1:02:19] and i appreciate the interest that everyone has [1:02:22] official to the offense to the to the fellowship, but provide some value that I to concept a proposal [1:02:48] Pacific request due diligence for saying they're in their request [1:03:08] Today is 90 day to ensure that actually can't meet their needs. I mean, there certainly are [1:03:19] challenges in doing business in some areas of downtown because of [1:03:24] marking access of some on street parking spaces within the core of downtown is a lot of parking spaces [1:03:35] Because it's not in front of the exact place where you need to go. [1:03:38] It doesn't mean there's no parking lot. [1:03:41] So I would certainly be understanding that. [1:03:45] So since 1690, the process would give them the historic, oh, yes. [1:05:21] They would follow those things to me. [1:06:49] See what we can do. [1:09:01] Just in sale agreement together, that would include the price, the specifics, [1:09:06] short sentences in full and real English. [1:09:24] To include all the aspects of a purchase in sale agreement, [1:09:29] in which would include of course Ernest Munney and all the [1:09:43] Bolson's 1, 2, 3, Greg Lanting's. [1:10:53] Yes. [1:10:54] Chris Talkington. [1:10:55] No. [1:10:56] John Barrieger. [1:10:57] Yes. [1:10:58] Nicky Boyd. [1:10:59] Yes. [1:11:00] Zann Hawkins. [1:11:03] Yes. [1:11:15] Passes. [1:11:16] Next on the agenda is another opportunity for general public input. [1:11:18] If there's anybody who wishes to address the council, has your option to come forward. [1:11:21] Advisory board reports from the council. [1:11:27] Progress of the last airport board that met this last week. [1:11:42] First of all, taxiway Alpha, which is a multi-million dollar upgrade, not second of all in December, to Salt Lake and trim as well as Boise. [1:12:42] The year before they were of those somewhere, the Midwest Manager. He showed some very interesting data. [1:13:05] The Sky West currently served 77 sites in the West Northwest. Our city did fourth at a 77. [1:14:18] Next this evening, so next on the agenda is adjournment, [1:14:21] and we do have a request to adjourn to Executive Session, [1:14:25] no code 742061C, to acquire an interest in real property, [1:14:30] which is not owned by agency. [1:14:45] Can I state of this? [1:14:46] Any discussion? [1:14:53] Bruce Beres? [1:14:55] Yes. [1:14:55] Chris Tockington? [1:14:56] Yes. [1:14:57] John Berger? [1:14:58] Yes. [1:15:00] Nicki Boulton, Suzanne Hawkins? [1:15:01] Yes. [1:15:02] At Greg Lanti? [1:15:03] Yes. [1:15:05] So six to zero. [1:15:07] Great to executive session will be owing the session nor will