Oversight Archive: City Council meeting, 2022-05-09, recording 1 (started 15:59) Machine transcript (faster-whisper base.en), not checked word for word; the Pledge of Allegiance is shown in its standard wording. The recording is the record. Times are time into the recording. Passages with private details are muted in the audio and marked here. The audio on the page below was re-encoded by software from the video the agency posted. Check any passage against that audio before relying on it. Page: https://oversightarchive.org/twin-falls-id/meetings/2022-05-09/ [0:00:14] Good afternoon, ladies and gentlemen, [0:00:16] and welcome to the main ninth 2022 City Council meeting. [0:00:22] I wanna call the meeting to order and confirm we have a quorum. [0:00:26] Seven of the seven council members are present. [0:00:30] First item on the agenda is to move into executive session [0:00:35] under executive session 74-2061B [0:00:40] be to consider the evaluation to dismiss or disciplining [0:00:45] or to hear complaints or charges brought [0:00:47] in public officer, employees, staff, member [0:00:50] or individual agent or public school student. [0:00:54] Council wishes. [0:00:59] Thank you, motion by Nikki Boyd, seconded by Craig Hawkins. [0:01:02] To move into executive session, [0:01:05] we will not be making any decisions [0:01:07] and we'll be reconvening at five p.m. [0:01:25] Mayor Parris. [0:01:26] Yes. [0:01:27] Vice Mayor Reed. [0:01:28] Yes. [0:01:29] Sean Baraker. [0:01:30] Yes. [0:01:31] Nikki Boyd. [0:01:32] Yes. [0:01:33] Greg Hopkins. [0:01:34] Jason Brown. [0:01:35] Yes. [0:01:37] Senator Cutler. [0:01:38] Yes. [0:01:39] Motion passes 7 to 0. [0:02:20] Thank you. [0:02:21] Good evening, ladies and gentlemen. [0:02:23] Welcome back to City Council meeting for May 9th. [0:02:27] Again, we just came out of Executive Session. [0:02:31] Those decisions were made. [0:02:33] I will confirm we have a quorum. [0:02:35] All seven members are here in person. [0:02:40] The next item on the agenda is the Pledge of Allegiance. [0:02:43] So anybody wishing to join me, please rise. [0:03:03] Thank you. [0:03:05] We have no proclamations on the agenda today. [0:03:10] Next item, I didn't quite get there, is the consent calendar. [0:03:18] Council wishes. [0:03:19] Move to approve the consent calendar. [0:03:22] Thank you. [0:03:23] I'll second. [0:03:24] I'll second. [0:03:25] motion by Christopher Reed, seconded by Jason Brown, [0:03:28] to approve the consent calendar. [0:03:31] Erin Roll, call vote please. [0:03:34] Vice Mayor Reed. [0:03:35] Yes. [0:03:35] Sean Baraker. [0:03:37] Yes. [0:03:38] Nicky Boyd. [0:03:39] Yes. [0:03:40] Ray Cawkins. [0:03:40] Yes. [0:03:41] Jason Brown. [0:03:42] Yes. [0:03:43] Spencer Cutler. [0:03:44] Yes. [0:03:44] Mayor Pierce. [0:03:45] Yes. [0:03:46] Motion passes seven to zero. [0:03:48] If you were here for the extension of the BLM lease [0:03:54] with the airport or findings of fact and conclusions of law [0:03:58] for a federation point, the CDA, [0:04:01] both those have been approved. [0:04:03] Next time on the agenda is an action item [0:04:06] to authorize the reallocation of a portion of the unused [0:04:10] planning and zoning department budgeted salaries [0:04:13] to hire consultants for the purpose of finishing [0:04:16] the Title 10 rewrite project. [0:04:18] And we have Jonathan Spindlow of our planning [0:04:21] and zoning director. [0:04:23] Hello, Jonathan. [0:04:24] Hello, Mayor and members of the Council. [0:04:25] I'm not going to read in the whole report. [0:04:26] I know that that's furnished to you. [0:04:28] I'm really just going to tell a little bit of the story [0:04:30] that I've been trying to rewrite Title X for a number of years. [0:04:33] I put many, I don't know exactly how many [0:04:36] I've been working on it, but COVID in the departure [0:04:39] of staff members has really hampered our efforts, [0:04:43] personally my efforts as well. [0:04:45] And seeing an opportunity with a departure of a staff member [0:04:49] and salaries that would have been paid to that person [0:04:52] continue the project that are not being used. I'd like to ask to use those salaries, what we call [0:04:59] salary savings to hire a consultant to help me finish. I believe the project is around 85 or 90 [0:05:04] ish percent done. A lot of the terms have been defined and written. Really it's an organization [0:05:10] and I need some visual graphics for some of the items that we can't do in house that was going to [0:05:16] going to be needed to be hired up anyway. I believe I can package that into a contract, [0:05:23] haven't done this with anybody yet, so I'm thinking that the dollar amount is close to what I can do, [0:05:28] but ask people and get some proposals. I'm too able to do that. I think that's what I'm here for. [0:05:35] Thank you, Christopher Reed. Jonathan, can you go over what is Title 10 for those who might [0:05:41] I get a listening because there's a lot that's included in that. [0:05:44] Yeah, Title 10 is about 360 somewhat pages, 300 plus pages. [0:05:49] It's our land use code. [0:05:51] It's what's authorized to require to be authorized in state code for dealing with land uses in [0:05:57] terms of permitted uses on properties in the zoning districts. [0:06:01] It also contains our subdivision requirements, our special use requirements, the planning [0:06:07] and zoning bylaws, go through everything. [0:06:10] All of the procedural due process for people to ask for changes to land or rezones. [0:06:17] They think also entails definitions of land use terms. [0:06:23] Everything dealing with development essentially comes out of Title X. [0:06:28] It's a big chunk of how things get developed and built in the city. [0:06:33] It comes from that title. [0:06:34] Thank you. [0:06:36] I think it's just important to remember that. [0:06:38] I know that when you started this you spoke with everybody and talked a little bit about that. [0:06:42] that planning and zoning. Some of the permitted uses are things that we no [0:06:48] longer even do. Sanitarium is one of them. Yeah, yeah. So, a lot of grass station. [0:06:54] A lot of grass station is only interesting in the C1. Yep. At least I'm a lot of [0:06:59] photographs anymore. Don't really need that permitted. So, I appreciate that. [0:07:04] Thank you. Any questions for Jonathan? Jason Brown. Jonathan, how much? So just [0:07:11] three through the staff report. Are you estimating there's $43,000? Is that is that the number that we [0:07:18] Yeah, that's looking to reallocate towards plus whatever additional you had already [0:07:23] anticipated for a consultant to do graphics. Yeah, that was going to be [0:07:28] contained in this upcoming budget of any of the graphics. If I could compile it [0:07:32] together, this would be the salary savings from January 1 to June 1. Nobody's been [0:07:36] hired in that position. Okay. Not that we would need all and [0:07:41] And Travis is going to help me a little bit on this one. [0:07:43] Yes, so that's the minimum amount of salary savings [0:07:46] that we have incurred today. [0:07:48] We're in the process of looking for a member [0:07:51] to fill the vacancy on Jonathan's team. [0:07:54] That person has not been filled yet, [0:07:57] so just so the counts and those. [0:07:59] We intend to move forward. [0:08:00] We intend to fill that position as it's out. [0:08:03] And we believe that we have some really good candidates [0:08:05] in that pool. [0:08:06] We want to demonstrate that we've already [0:08:09] I have the salary savings in the department to be able to cover 100% anticipated costs. [0:08:14] Any other questions? I'd entertain a motion. [0:08:20] I'll make a motion. Thank you, Jason. [0:08:22] I move to approve or authorize the reallocation by portion of the unused planning and zoning department budget salaries to hire a consultant for the purpose of finishing the Title 10 rewrite project. [0:08:35] Thank you. [0:08:36] Do I have a second? [0:08:37] Second. [0:08:38] Thank you. [0:08:39] Motion by Jason Brown. [0:08:40] Seconded by Nikki Boyd to authorize the reallocation of unused P&Z budgeted salaries [0:08:47] for a consultant to finish Title 10 rewrite. [0:08:51] Any further discussion? [0:08:53] Aaron Grohl, call vote please. [0:08:56] Sean Barrigar. [0:08:57] Yes. [0:08:58] Nikki Boyd. [0:08:59] Yes. [0:09:00] Craig Hawkins. [0:09:01] Yes. [0:09:02] Jason Brown. [0:09:03] Yes. [0:09:04] Spencer Cutler. [0:09:05] Yes. [0:09:06] Thank you. Motion passes 7-0. Thank you Jonathan. Next item on the agenda is an [0:09:15] action item, a request to initiate a public process to amend City Code Title [0:09:20] 7, chapters 3 and a regarding property owners being responsible for city utility [0:09:26] accounts. We have Grant hired our assistant finance director or our finance [0:09:33] director right now, right? Yeah. Welcome, Brad. [0:09:37] Thank you, Mary, Mayor Pearson, members of the Council. [0:09:40] I was here about a month ago in the May presentation that said, let me let us explore kind of a point system [0:09:48] where we can identify troubled properties and shift those over to the property owners for responsibility for the utility accounts. [0:09:55] We explored it briefly and came up with some roadblocks that were probably a deal killer [0:10:02] to that approach. [0:10:04] Number one is we find out late when people have been turned over to collection. [0:10:13] That process usually runs six weeks or longer. [0:10:17] It would be impractical at that point to go back after a new tenant has moved into a property [0:10:23] and try and reclassify that to the owner after that relationships been established. [0:10:29] The other thing that was troublesome is when property owners and tenants enter into an agreement, a lease, [0:10:39] there's a series of negotiations that have gone on at that point. [0:10:44] And so for us to come along after that has been established and changed the ground rules, it's a little unfair. [0:10:52] So we backed off from that and we're back today asking for your permission to continue down the road a little bit differently with assigning property owners the responsibility grandfathering and existing relationships, but as those turn over and change we would like to assign responsibility to the property owners. [0:11:17] We reached out to communities within 100 miles, we contacted about 16 of those, 12 of them operate the way we want to go. [0:11:28] The policy we want to implement, four of them don't. [0:11:32] And then we reached out to the eight largest cities in the state, these ice twin falls. [0:11:37] Half of them have a policy that puts the responsibility on the property owners, [0:11:45] half of them, half the kind of relationship that we have where we don't differentiate tenants, [0:11:51] property owners, doesn't make a difference. [0:11:55] One thing that I didn't really go into, I talked about, you know, the financial savings [0:12:02] last time, when the city of Kimberly shifted their policy, their bad debts went from about [0:12:11] 33,000 down to 2,000 when the city of Jerome shifted the responsibility to the property owners [0:12:19] there bad that's about 50,000 down to 3,000. [0:12:24] So we're expecting that kind of impact on us, but the thing that I didn't really talk [0:12:31] about and I'm not going to talk about tonight other than introduce any idea is that we think [0:12:37] it would be a substantial reduction in work for our utility department because we have [0:12:43] a lot of collection activity, bad debts, turnoffs for non-payment arrangements and we think those [0:12:54] are disproportionately aligned with the tenants. [0:12:59] So I guess I'm asking for permission and action item to proceed down this to gather some [0:13:07] input through the use of an open house in a month, put the information out, requesting [0:13:14] people to come back. [0:13:15] I'm sure it would be primarily the landlords who can share their concerns and what they [0:13:22] are. [0:13:23] We would record those and bring them back in a written form. [0:13:29] And we would also bring back a little more definitive information about what the impact [0:13:35] could be on our department if we were to shift responsibility so that can be [0:13:39] considered and evaluated too. So we've worked with the prosecutor's office here [0:13:45] in the city to come up with a suggested ordinance change and that's what we would [0:13:51] use to for discussion purposes and then we've kind of set an effective date that's [0:13:59] out there October 1st. We give plenty of time for the information to get out. I'm open for the conversation with the council. [0:14:14] I have questions. [0:14:16] If you can just describe to me, the one route that you went didn't look like it was going to be able to happen. [0:14:24] We now know. [0:14:28] you the new route that you're exploring. He said that there's grandfather [0:14:32] individuals that would be grandfather did. If you could kind of just give me [0:14:35] a bit of color to that. Okay so when we constantly have shifting in accounts [0:14:43] in the utility department specifically a tenant would move and a new tenant [0:14:49] would come. When that happens there would be a new account. That account [0:14:55] would have to be in the property owner's name. [0:14:58] So we're anticipating the city of Jerome, [0:15:02] and I give them credit for courage. [0:15:05] When they made their policy, they said it dates certain, [0:15:09] and they took the names off the deeds, [0:15:11] and they created accounts for property owners. [0:15:14] Ours would be a little gentler approach. [0:15:17] We think it would probably take maybe three years [0:15:19] to cycle through the majority of tenants. [0:15:23] might be there through the end of at least 40 years or they might be there two or three [0:15:29] years. Probably in 20 years we would still have some policy some accounts and tenants names [0:15:37] because they're just there and they're happy and everything's working. And they're paying [0:15:41] their bills. And they're paying their bills. Yeah. So this would be a revolving thing as [0:15:47] new accounts come online after October 1st. They would be required to be in the name of [0:15:53] Thank you. It's a great explanation. [0:15:57] No. Nikki, boy. [0:15:59] Okay. [0:16:01] Do you have an idea that certain... [0:16:06] there's a pocket of troubled properties. [0:16:09] It's not everybody. [0:16:10] Right. [0:16:11] It's some certain ones that have been identified. [0:16:14] Can you tell me what percentage of the rental population that is? [0:16:19] Is there any way to say, [0:16:23] is this like 3% of renters are involved in this [0:16:27] or 18% of renters? Do you have any idea? [0:16:33] I can't, but when I come back, we know that if we look at our accounts now, we know that [0:16:41] about 16% of our utility accounts would fit into a category of being a rented property. [0:16:50] We don't know exactly how many of those we would have called, troubled, but when I come [0:16:56] back I can say I can go through five or six categories of work that we do and I [0:17:04] can say we have a hundred shutoffs a month on average and we think that you [0:17:11] know 60% of those are tenants and 40% are property owners so I can bring that [0:17:17] in for a minute. And that's really huge compared to it's only 16% of their utility [0:17:23] users are renters, but yet that could equal 80 or 100 shutoffs? That's a really disproportionate... [0:17:33] That's why we're here. I mean, yeah. Okay, and I'm not disparaging Tana. I had two years ago I was a Tana. [0:17:44] But we do have a population that doesn't have ties to the community. And we have a population, I'm ashamed to say it, but [0:17:53] they abuse that relationship and they're there and then they quit paying their [0:17:59] rent and they quit paying their utilities and their attention is just to move on [0:18:02] and that's the way they're rolling. [0:18:06] They might move to another community, they might move to another property. [0:18:10] And I understand that as a rental property owner it's you know there is [0:18:18] people who, there are people who have this system and it is usually six dead, it's [0:18:23] It's like two months later that all of a sudden, you know, the new tenant doesn't pay it because it's not their name on it, and so nobody knows about it. [0:18:30] Right. [0:18:31] So I get all that. [0:18:33] It's not really in our control. [0:18:36] The property owner, I mean, they can do betting, they can do background shacks, they can make sure the deposits are adequate. [0:18:44] They can do those things that are not in our control. [0:18:47] of that of course most people do but have you had discussion on so you have to have a [0:18:53] security deposit and you have to pay your first month's rent so it would be perfectly [0:18:59] fine to say and I'm going to collect $300 you have to put up $300 so if you don't pay [0:19:05] your utility bill it can be paid on your behalf. [0:19:09] Has a property owner? [0:19:13] I mean because I just have to say putting somebody else's bill on a property owner I [0:19:18] I've already heard all that, I'm sure. [0:19:21] That's just, you know, I don't vouch for anybody else [0:19:24] that you pay your bills or you don't. [0:19:26] Right. [0:19:26] I'll do the part I'm supposed to do. [0:19:28] So I'm just looking at how many creative ways [0:19:32] have people thought of collecting that money. [0:19:36] And I'm looking at the price of rents, [0:19:38] and I'm thinking if you have to add, [0:19:39] say, another $300 onto the security deposit [0:19:43] in order to rent a place, [0:19:47] How do people rent anything for under $1,800? [0:19:50] So those are some of the things that I'm expecting [0:19:54] would come out of that discussion from the, [0:19:56] I mean, I can think of creative ways to make it happen. [0:19:59] They're really not paying any more than they are to us. [0:20:02] It's just combined. [0:20:05] We have lots of renters in the community [0:20:07] who live in multiple units, apartments, duplexes, [0:20:13] where that's already factored in. [0:20:15] utilities are part of the rent. Right, because they have one. Right, they have one account. They have one account. There's a whole building or four [0:20:23] plexes. Exactly. So the owner pays that anyway, but of course it's back. Yeah. So I am not anticipating that this is going to be something [0:20:33] that's right there say well received by the property owners but I want to be we [0:20:44] want to be open and transparent and and as I was going to say I can think of [0:20:50] multiple ways that that can be dealt with but it'll be interesting to bring [0:20:55] back the information from their perspective where they can look at it and [0:20:59] say here's here's our concerns here's what we think this is a bad idea we'll [0:21:05] have maybe a few property owners. We had one from call up and say, hey I know how you can deal with this. I have property in Kimberly and here's what they did. [0:21:15] So we might have a few property owners who are supportive of the idea. It takes a lot of the unknowns out of it. [0:21:25] You brought up Kimberly. Can you tell me the number that they had collections on and what it went down to? I didn't write that down. [0:21:33] So Kimberly was interesting because they had the policy for years and they didn't enforce it. [0:21:40] And then they had a city manager who came in and said, [0:21:43] we're going to start doing this. So it wasn't a new policy to them, [0:21:48] but he indicated to me that when they implemented that, their collection, [0:21:53] they had 33,000 bad deaths. It went down to 2000. [0:21:58] And that kind of tracks with I think you know 33,000 for Kimberly ours is in excess of a hundred thousand at all kind of [0:22:09] Jason Brown rent what you're looking for tonight is just [0:22:15] the council to [0:22:17] Say go ahead and have the public process have the open houses have people come in and comment to you [0:22:24] And so we can start vetting out this process of what is going to be best for us exactly [0:22:30] to represent this is under consideration seriously, but council, we want your input and bring [0:22:38] that back. [0:22:39] Not an action item for policy establishment or an ordinance change, but it's an action [0:22:45] item to take the next step. [0:22:47] I'll make a motion if we don't have any more. [0:22:53] So I'll make a motion to have city staff initiate a public process to amend city code [0:23:02] Title VII, Chapter III, and VIII, regarding property owners being responsible for city utility accounts. [0:23:09] Five seconds. Thank you. Motion by Jason Brown, seconded by Craig Hawkins to prove initiating a public process to amend City Code Title VII, Chapter III, and VIII, regarding property owners being responsible for city utility accounts. Sean Barricker. [0:23:28] Thank you Mayor. So the anticipated input from the open houses would be to potentially [0:23:35] make revisions to the proposed draft ordinance, then there would be an additional public process [0:23:41] of the public hearing, and this may be a question for you. [0:23:44] It's to clarify that when the ordinance were to come to the council, [0:23:47] it would be a public hearing and opportunity for input. [0:23:50] They're potentially up to three times. [0:23:52] That's correct. If the council chooses to have a public hearing, [0:23:58] hearing, then yes, there will be at least the one time for the ordinance to be passed, where we typically take public comment at those meetings. [0:24:05] Thank you. Thank you. [0:24:07] Travis. [0:24:08] So, this wouldn't just so that the council have stand changed absolutely right. This would not fall under the classical definition of a required or prescribed public hearing. [0:24:19] If you wanted to set that, you could do that. [0:24:23] And you could instruct staff at the time in which you considered the ordinance to establish a public hearing. [0:24:30] It doesn't fall into a Title 10 land use. [0:24:33] It doesn't fall into a government expenditure, and it doesn't fall into an increased fee, [0:24:39] which are the reasons why it would be prescribed by a state code. [0:24:42] Thank you. Any other questions, Jason? [0:24:46] Jason. Yeah, so you'll come back after the public process and fill us in with [0:24:52] kind of what you understood was said after after all this. Okay, perfect. Any other [0:25:01] questions? Aaron, roll call vote please. Nicky Boyd. Yes. Craig Hawkins. Yes. Jason [0:25:09] Brown. Yes. Spencer Cutler. Yes. Mayor Pierce. Yes. Vice mayor Reed. Yes. Sean [0:25:16] Yes. [0:25:17] Thank you. [0:25:18] Motion passes. [0:25:19] 70-0. [0:25:20] Thank you, Brian. [0:25:22] Excuse me. [0:25:23] Next item on the agenda is the time for general public input. [0:25:26] Does anybody in the audience that wishes to come down and speak? [0:25:30] Now is the time. [0:25:34] Seeing no one. [0:25:36] Advisory board reports. [0:25:42] City manager's office. [0:25:47] This Saturday the 13th cracked. [0:25:51] 14th. [0:25:52] Friday the 13th Saturday at 14 at 10 a.m. Oh, okay. I'm very close very close I [0:26:01] Would have been early [0:26:02] We're having the Pardon me peace officer Memorial [0:26:11] City Park so everybody's encouraged to attend. Thank you [0:26:18] Next item on the agenda we have no public hearings on the next item agenda on the agenda is to move back into [0:26:27] Executive Session, under Executive Session 74-2061B, [0:26:34] to consider the evaluation dismissal or a disciplining number [0:26:39] to hear complaints or charges brought against a public officer, [0:26:43] employee, staff member or individual, agent or public school student. [0:26:50] Council wishes. [0:26:51] Okay. [0:26:53] Okay. [0:26:55] Okay. [0:26:56] Okay. [0:26:57] Okay. [0:26:58] Okay. [0:26:59] Okay. [0:27:00] Okay. [0:27:01] Okay. [0:27:02] Okay. [0:27:03] Okay. [0:27:04] Okay. [0:27:05] Okay. [0:27:06] Okay. [0:27:07] Okay. [0:27:08] Okay. [0:27:09] Okay. [0:27:10] Okay. [0:27:11] Okay. [0:27:13] Okay. [0:27:14] Okay. [0:27:15] Okay. [0:27:16] Okay. [0:27:17] Okay. [0:27:18] Okay. [0:27:19] Okay. [0:27:20] Okay. [0:27:21] Okay. [0:27:22] Okay. [0:27:23] Thank you, Boyd. [0:27:24] Yes. [0:27:25] Thank you. [0:27:26] Motion passes 7-0. [0:27:27] As we move into executive session, we will not be coming back. [0:27:31] We will not be making any decisions and we're returned. [0:27:36] Thank you very much.