Oversight Archive: City Council meeting, 2024-04-15, recording 1 (started 16:57) Machine transcript (faster-whisper base.en), not checked word for word; the Pledge of Allegiance is shown in its standard wording. The recording is the record. Times are time into the recording. Passages with private details are muted in the audio and marked here. The audio on the page below was re-encoded by software from the video the agency posted. Check any passage against that audio before relying on it. Page: https://oversightarchive.org/twin-falls-id/meetings/2024-04-15/ [0:02:41] Good evening, ladies and gentlemen, and welcome to the April 15, 2024 City Council meeting. [0:02:48] I want to confirm we have a quorum. We have all seven members present in chambers. [0:02:53] First item on the agenda is the Pledge of Allegiance. If you wish to join me, please rise. [0:02:58] Thank you. So I have three proclamations tonight. The first one is Optimus Club Youth Appreciation [0:03:30] week for 2024. Whereas the vast majority of youth are concerned, knowledgeable, and responsible [0:03:36] citizens, and whereas Optimus International and the Twin Falls Optimist Club have developed [0:03:42] and promoted a program entitled Youth Appreciation Week, and whereas the citizens of Twin Falls [0:03:48] have indicated a desire to join the optimist in expressing appreciation and approval for [0:03:54] the contributions of youth, therefore, I, Ruth Pierce, Mayor of the City of Twin Falls, do [0:03:59] do hereby proclaim the third week of April as Youth Appreciation Week in Twin Falls. [0:04:06] By this action, let it be known we have faith in the ability of today's youth as they assume [0:04:11] responsible roles in the future of mankind. [0:04:16] So I think we have a couple of optimists here, Bree and Stephanie and Ashari. [0:05:03] Okay, perfect. [0:05:05] Thank you. [0:05:06] appreciation luncheon is an event designed to recognize local high school seniors who are [0:05:11] nominated by their school administrators and we ask them to look over the optimist creed [0:05:17] and nominate students in their school that kind of exude what our creed is. So if you've [0:05:23] never seen our creed I encourage you to look it up online after this or come to one of [0:05:27] our Thursday meetings. But we also kind of challenge the administrators to maybe not choose the [0:05:33] the most popular student or the captain of the football team, [0:05:36] but to dig a little deeper and maybe find those students [0:05:39] that sometimes get overlooked, [0:05:43] but are still really making a difference in their school. [0:05:46] So we're excited to recognize them on Thursday [0:05:49] at the Stone House. [0:05:50] So thank you. [0:05:51] Thank you, ladies. [0:05:53] Okay, next proclamation is Arbor Day. [0:05:58] Is that right, order? [0:05:59] Arbor Day Proclamation, whereas in 1872, [0:06:03] Jay Sterling Morton proposed to the Nebraska Board of Agriculture that a special day be [0:06:09] set aside for the planting of trees and whereas this holiday called Arbor Day was first observed [0:06:15] with the planting of more than a million trees in Nebraska and whereas Arbor Day is now observed [0:06:21] through the nation and the world whereas trees can reduce the erosion of our precious [0:06:26] topsoil by wind and water, cutting heat and cooling costs, moderate the temperature, clean [0:06:32] the air, produce oxygen and provide habitat for wildlife, and whereas trees are a renewable [0:06:39] resource giving us paper, wood for our homes, fuel for our fires and countless other wood [0:06:44] products, and whereas trees in our city increase property values, enhance the economic vitality [0:06:51] of business areas and beautify our community, and whereas trees wherever they are planted [0:06:58] are a source of joy and spiritual renewal. Therefore, I, Ruth Pierce, Mayor of the City [0:07:04] of Twin Falls do hereby proclaim Monday, April 29, 2024 as Arbor Day in the City of [0:07:11] Twin Falls. And I urge all citizens to celebrate Arbor Day and to support efforts to protect [0:07:17] dark trees and woodlands. [0:07:19] And are you Wendy? [0:07:21] Are you it? [0:07:52] Thank you, Mayor Pierce. [0:07:54] I have a statement here from Chanson. [0:07:56] It sort of paraphrases the proclamation to say that [0:07:59] Julius Sterling Morton wrote [0:08:03] other holidays reposed upon the past [0:08:06] and Arbor Day proposes for the future. [0:08:08] And as American journalist and Nebraska territory secretary in 1872, [0:08:12] Mr. Morton proposed a tree planting holiday [0:08:15] resulted in over 1 million trees planted in the state, and by 1920, more than 45 states [0:08:20] were participating in now all 50 states observed the annual tree planting holiday, known as Arbor Day. [0:08:26] This is the 26th year that the City of Twin Falls has been named a tree city by National [0:08:30] Arbor Day Foundation, meaning all four standards for recognition. [0:08:34] Those standards include maintaining a tree board, implementing a tree care ordinance, demonstrating [0:08:39] at least $2 per capita spending for tree care and urban forestry and guesment, as well [0:08:44] is celebrating and observing Arbor Day. This year, the Parks and Recreation Department [0:08:48] requests the City of Twin Falls celebration be proclaimed and celebrated on Monday, April [0:08:53] 29th, 2024. And it's usually the last Friday in April, but we're moving it to Monday in [0:09:00] order to have better participation from the park staff as well as hopefully the community. [0:09:05] We will be planning four trees at Courtney Conservation Park by school and community volunteers [0:09:11] along with the Parks and Recreation staff and we invite the City Council, members of Parks [0:09:17] and Recreation Commission and members of the community to join us at 10 a.m. for this tree [0:09:23] planning celebration. Keeping it green, chance months, Parks Superintendent to involve Parks [0:09:28] and Recreation. Perfect. Thank you, 10 a.m. on Monday the 29th, right? [0:09:37] Do you want to read the proclamation there? I can if you'd like. [0:09:43] you'd like to. We'd love to have you. Okay. And everyone else, bring your shovels and your kids. [0:09:48] And your kids. Thank you, Wendy. Okay, the last proclamation is Community College Month, April [0:09:55] 2024, whereas the College of Southern Idaho has been an integral part of the Magic Valley [0:10:01] Census establishment in 1965, providing high quality education and trading to thousands of [0:10:08] students, and whereas CSI has significantly contributed to the economic development and cultural enrichment [0:10:17] of the Magic Valley through its educational programs, community services, and cultural [0:10:23] events, and whereas the college has fostered partnerships with local businesses, schools, [0:10:28] and organizations, thereby strengthening the community ties and creating opportunities [0:10:34] for collaboration and growth, and whereas CSI's commitment to the excellence in education, [0:10:40] student success, and community engagement deserves recognition and celebration, whereas the City [0:10:46] of Twin Falls acknowledges the role of colleges Southern Idaho in making higher education accessible [0:10:52] and affordable to its residents, thus enhancing the overall quality of life in our community. [0:10:59] Therefore, I, Ruth Pierce, Mayor of the City of Twin Falls, [0:11:02] hereby declare April 27, 2024 as College of Southern Idaho Day. [0:11:08] He had further resolved that the City of Twin Falls encourages all [0:11:11] residents, businesses, and institutions in the Magic Valley [0:11:15] to join in celebrating the contributions and achievements [0:11:19] of the College of Southern Idaho and to participate in events [0:11:23] and activities planned for the day. [0:11:25] So Dr. Fisher was then able to make it. [0:11:28] he has the board meeting today. [0:11:30] So he sent Jonathan Lords, [0:11:33] who's the Vice President of Student Affairs. [0:11:35] So. [0:12:09] Mayor Pierce, Vice Mayor Brown, council members, [0:12:11] thank you so much. [0:12:12] On behalf of the College of Southern Idaho, [0:12:14] we are thrilled to have this proclamation [0:12:17] and to continue to support the Magic Valley [0:12:19] in any way we can. [0:12:20] So thank you so much, we appreciate you, [0:12:23] and look forward to having you on our campus here. [0:12:25] Just a few short weeks if you can make it. [0:12:27] Thank you, thank you very much. [0:12:30] Okay, next on the agenda is our consent calendar. [0:12:34] Council wishes. [0:12:38] Make a motion that we approve the consent calendar is written. [0:12:41] Thank you, do we have a second? [0:12:42] I'll second. [0:12:43] Thank you, motion by Craig Hawkins, [0:12:45] seconded by Sherry Vomer. [0:12:47] To approve the consent calendar as written. [0:12:51] Amy Roll call vote, please. [0:12:54] Ruth Pierce? [0:12:54] Yes. [0:12:55] Chris Reed? [0:12:56] Yes. [0:12:57] Craig Hawkins? [0:12:58] Yes. [0:12:59] Jason Brown? [0:13:00] Yes. [0:13:00] Spencer Cutler? [0:13:01] Yes. [0:13:02] Yes. [0:13:03] Thank you. [0:13:04] Motion passes 7 to 0. [0:13:06] Okay. [0:13:08] Next, under items of consideration, we have an action item, a request to use 135,000 from [0:13:16] contingency funds to re-roof the street department shop located at 205-6th Avenue West and we [0:13:23] have Mark Thompson, our street superintendent. [0:13:26] Welcome, Mark. [0:13:27] Good evening. [0:13:28] Thank you for letting me come for you tonight. [0:13:32] make this request. So as Mayor Pierce stated, we are here to request the use of $135,000 [0:13:42] from contingency funds to re-roof the street department shop. Our street department shop [0:13:49] was built back in 1940 and for a building that's 84 years old, it's really in good shape. [0:13:57] back in 2000, 2001, there was some work done, but the extent is really, really unclear. [0:14:04] We don't know if it was, there were some patches made, there was a new roof put on, so it's really, [0:14:11] where it's really unclear. So over the last several years, we've had some roof, we've [0:14:16] had some leaks in the roof that have formed. They've been repaired many times, and it helped [0:14:21] for a while, but it seemed, they seemed to return. After speaking with our building department [0:14:27] a few different contractors in town. We felt the best option was to install a new [0:14:32] TPO membrane, which is kind of like a plastic membrane that includes a 20-year [0:14:37] warranty. This project was originally planned for fiscal year 25. In order to [0:14:45] get an idea of what to budget, we went to a couple different contractors. We asked [0:14:51] for some quotes. We explained to the contractors that these quotes were needed [0:14:57] for the next budget cycle so that we were hoping to ensure the prices would be good in [0:15:03] that next fiscal year. [0:15:05] During our long-term planning process, we presented this to the committee for the upcoming [0:15:12] budget. [0:15:13] But after some internal conversations, it was thought to be a good use of contingency [0:15:18] funds and it was approved by our city manager to bring before you tonight. [0:15:24] approved this if you approve this project it'll be able to move forward this [0:15:30] fiscal year. So a simple majority vote will approve it our balance and the [0:15:37] contingency funds as of Tuesday was 347, 256, 60. If you were to authorize us to [0:15:46] spend that 135,000 the remaining balance would be 212, 256, 60. Any [0:15:58] questions that you might have. Any questions for Mark? Chris Reed. Mark, how fast would [0:16:03] you be able to get this completed? So the availability from what I understand from the [0:16:10] contractors is a couple of contractors that I've talked to have material in their shop. [0:16:17] We could move fairly quick. Okay. I know that we're in spring, raining season, probably [0:16:22] We won't get it done now, but definitely by the fall snow. [0:16:29] Yes, yes, yes. [0:16:30] Perfect. [0:16:31] Anybody else? [0:16:33] Hey, I'd entertain a motion. [0:16:38] The street. [0:16:39] I move that we approve the use of 135,000 from contingency funds to re-roof the street department shop located at 205-6th Avenue West. [0:16:50] Thank you, Jason Brown. [0:16:52] Thank you. [0:16:53] motion by Chris Reed, seconded by Jason Brown to approve the use of 135,000 of contingency funds [0:17:01] to re-rof the street department shop located at 205-6th Avenue West. Any further discussion? [0:17:08] Amy Roel, call vote please. Chris Reed? Yes. Greg Hawkins? Yes. Jason Brown? Yes. Spencer Cutler? Yes. [0:17:17] Yes. [0:17:18] Grace and Stone. [0:17:19] Yes. [0:17:20] Sherry Bulmer. [0:17:21] Yes. [0:17:22] And Ruth Pierce. [0:17:23] Yes. [0:17:24] Thank you. [0:17:25] Motion passes 7-0. [0:17:26] Thank you, Mark. [0:17:27] Thank you. [0:17:28] Okay. [0:17:29] Next item on the agenda is also an action item. [0:17:31] A request to reallocate $3 million currently budgeted for Southwell No. 5. [0:17:37] Piping and pump house to the Kimberly Road Waterline replacement project. [0:17:42] We have public works director Josh Barrett. [0:17:44] Welcome, Josh. [0:17:45] Thanks, Mayor, members of the Council. [0:17:50] So anyone who might be following the budget year after year has probably seen that we've [0:17:54] had a southwell number five project in the budget year after year and we've been postponing [0:18:01] it because of protest, water protest that had been resolved, while they finally got resolved [0:18:06] and never postponing it yet again or requesting to. [0:18:10] And it's not that it's not a need, it's not that it's not important. [0:18:13] There's just a more urgent need we fill with a Kimberly Road waterline project, and that's [0:18:18] because IITD is planning on having a project where they're going to rehabilitate Kimberly [0:18:23] Road and that same section of road we have a waterline underneath it and we need to replace [0:18:27] it and we'd like to get there and replace it before they do their roadway project so [0:18:31] that we don't come in after them and tear up the road afterwards. [0:18:35] So that's the intent. [0:18:37] I think we had planned on moving this forward next fiscal year, this specific project, but [0:18:42] in order to make sure we coordinate with them and have enough time to do a request is to [0:18:47] bump the south one number five and we'll bring it up again next year. Hopefully we get a [0:18:52] constructive and then we'll still work on this one and get a bit out so we can coordinate [0:18:56] and hopefully be ITV and get that water line in first. [0:19:02] So I'll go ahead. [0:19:04] Do you have any questions? [0:19:06] My only question was are you hoping to get it done this year? [0:19:10] hope to bid it this year we'll go from there the other thing is it's a [0:19:15] it's a waterline project that will be underneath that road but there's a [0:19:18] portion of it also will be a part of the hankins pressure zone project there's [0:19:22] the big hankins pressure zone project which takes the bulk of it but there's [0:19:25] also a few little pieces here and there including a piece from this that [0:19:29] will go underneath the railroad we need to complete in order to have that [0:19:32] pressure zone done so I'm not sure exactly in the schedule but bidding it [0:19:36] immediately in a contractor on board will help get that process started it [0:19:40] It wouldn't surprise me if it ends up being a fall project or maybe an early next year. [0:19:45] Okay, Jason Brown. [0:19:48] Josh, so really part of the reason that we want to expedite this a little bit is long-term maintenance of that road. Is that correct? [0:19:55] Absolutely. [0:19:56] So if we go in and tear up the road now and then ITD comes back, they end up taking a lot more of that maintenance responsibility than the city does, correct? [0:20:05] Correct. If we come in after them, then we have to maintain that portion of the road that we tear up until they have a major rehabilitation project. [0:20:12] So this would avoid that and keep us out of maintenance of their roadway. [0:20:17] That's good. Any other questions for Josh? I would entertain a motion then. Jason Brown. [0:20:26] I'd move to approve the reallocation of $3 million currently budgeted for the South Wales Number 5. [0:20:33] piping and pumping house to the Kimberly Road water line replacement project. [0:20:37] Thank you, Sherry Vomer. [0:20:38] I'll second. [0:20:39] Thank you motion by Jason Brown, seconded by Sherry Vomer to approve the reallocation [0:20:45] of $3 million currently budgeted for Southwell number five piping and pump house to the Kimberly [0:20:50] Road water line replacement project. [0:20:54] Any further discussion? [0:20:56] Amy Roll call vote please. [0:21:00] Craig Hawkins. [0:21:01] Yes. [0:21:02] Jason Brown. [0:21:03] Yes. [0:21:04] Grace and Stone. Yes. Perry Wilmer. Yes. Ruth Pierce. Yes. And Chris Reed. Yes. Thank you. Motion passes seven to zero. Thank you, Josh. Thank you. [0:21:14] So next before we get to our public hearings, that is it for items of consideration. Next on the agenda is general public input. This is a time for anybody in the audience who wishes to address City Council on anything not on today's agenda [0:21:33] agenda and not the public hearing, please come down to the podium, state your name, and [0:21:40] your input. Is there anybody here that wishes to have City Council? Okay, seeing no one, [0:21:50] advisory board reports, right? [0:21:55] Councilman Vomer and I attended the spring meeting in Burley, Frei, I see it was really [0:22:03] well done and learned a lot. We had an exercise where we had to plan a [0:22:09] replan a city and you learn about all the facets that go into that. It's pretty [0:22:14] mind-blowing but it was a good exercise and I know I enjoyed it. I think Sherry [0:22:19] did too. Anybody else? Spencer? Yes, Mayor. In my other job I work at the College of [0:22:28] Southern Idaho and this last Saturday I was with a group of volunteers that [0:22:31] went to Rock Creek Park and did some cleanup work down there and I have to [0:22:35] say there's very little work to be done as far as picking up litter, some branches, things [0:22:41] like that. [0:22:42] So I just wanted to point out what a gem we have down there and thanks to the Parks Department, [0:22:46] I think maybe Wendy's still back there for what they've done as far as maintenance down [0:22:51] there. [0:22:52] Thank you Spencer. [0:22:53] Anybody else? [0:22:54] Sherry. [0:22:55] Parks and Rec Commission, the health courses up and running for the season, they have great [0:23:02] numbers, good great participation. [0:23:04] spring soccer is going, baseball and softballs signups are going on. We do have a I'm [0:23:10] also on the ref center ad hoc and they'll be meeting tomorrow we're finalizing [0:23:16] feasibility study working on spaces finalizing those spaces that would be [0:23:23] proposed to be in that up and going. Thank you everybody else. Okay anything from [0:23:31] the city manager's office at Travis? I just a reminder that we will not be meeting [0:23:35] next Monday, our next meeting will be on the 29th. [0:23:38] Perfect. [0:23:40] Let's answer your names to the leper, you good? [0:23:44] Anything else? [0:23:45] Okay. [0:23:47] So, next on the agenda is the public hearing. [0:24:00] So, this is an action item. [0:24:01] It's a request for a rezone of property [0:24:03] from R2 and C1 to C1. [0:24:07] We're probably located at 2794 out of San Avenue East. [0:24:11] Carav, Doug, Cone, PZ, 24, Dosto, or 07. [0:24:16] and we'll be for you present. [0:24:19] I'm going to read the rules. [0:24:23] The council will follow these steps for each request [0:24:25] listed under public hearing portion of the agenda. [0:24:28] Earth City staff will present the request and analysis. [0:24:32] Second, the applicant will present their request. [0:24:35] Third, the council will then ask questions [0:24:37] of the applicant or staff. [0:24:40] Fourth, after questions have been asked and answered, [0:24:43] the public hearing will be open. [0:24:45] During that time, anyone in attendance is given the opportunity to comment or ask questions [0:24:51] about the request being considered. [0:24:54] When giving testimonies, please step up to the podium, state your name and address and [0:25:00] present your comments or concerns. [0:25:03] After giving testimony, please sign the public signing sheet which is up in the lobby with [0:25:09] your name and address so we have it for the record. [0:25:12] each present or each public input person will be given two minutes for their presentation. [0:25:21] After public comments are concluded, the applicant will be invited to answer any questions and [0:25:26] make a closing statement. Staff will then answer, clarify any comments as needed. After the [0:25:32] closing statements, the public hearing will be closed, no further testimony or comments [0:25:38] from the applicant or audience will be allowed, [0:25:40] and then the council will have their discussion [0:25:43] and take action. [0:25:46] So, are you up? [0:25:49] Will, we have William Clayver from Senior Planner from P&Z. [0:25:57] Welcome. [0:25:58] Thank you, Madam Mayor, and good evening council members. [0:26:04] Today, we have before us a rezone, [0:26:07] a request to rezone the property located. [0:26:12] the east of Caragelaine, just south of Metabue Lane, from C1 to, or from R2 to C1. I'll get [0:26:22] into specifics of the nuances of this one as well and just a little bit. The vicinity [0:26:29] is residential is really to the south and to the southeast and southwest. This property [0:26:38] directly to the west was re-zoned in 2017 from R2 to C1 current. I believe [0:26:47] those right about here was R2 down was and here down was R2 and then if [0:26:57] it was in 2017 they rezoned it pretty much this whole area right here with a [0:27:06] little buffer remaining at the east is pretty intensity actual uses as well. So [0:27:24] So this is a two zoney designation parcels. [0:27:30] The north portion is C1 currently. [0:27:33] The south half, a little bit more than half probably, is R2. [0:27:39] The request today is the desire is to rezone the whole parcel to that C1 zone. [0:27:50] As you can see, the future land use map really just hugs the neighborhood commercial is a [0:27:56] long Addison and town neighborhoods so really protecting this town and these neighborhoods [0:28:02] is what this town neighborhood is calling for and that's higher up there. [0:28:09] That line is more hazy and is just a guideline but it is worth noting that it does commercial [0:28:17] oriented around Addison and not necessarily to the southern border. [0:28:30] We took this to Planning and Zoning Commission. [0:28:33] Staff felt that rezoning the whole property to see one, [0:28:41] would not be advisable. [0:28:46] We felt that we needed to protect the neighborhood, [0:28:51] wanted to just kind of match what the 2017 rezoning line was. [0:28:57] That line just took this line and just shot it over [0:29:06] over to the east. [0:29:10] Took this before playing zoning commission [0:29:14] after public comments. [0:29:16] Online zoning commission amended that recommendation [0:29:21] and their recommendation is to take it [0:29:23] from this property line to it over to the west. [0:29:28] So instead of having it halfway through this parcel, [0:29:32] they wanted to us protect the whole parcel [0:29:35] or whole property and just push it over. [0:29:46] That's the display of what it would look like. [0:29:54] I'll stand for any questions you may have questions for well at this time. Yeah, mayor. Yes, I'm just clarifying so [0:30:07] in the council packet there is a map that shows the [0:30:11] Current zoning map that is current right that's not proposed. So the north half of that property already is [0:30:18] commercial. Yes, the north half is already commercial. Okay. Thank you. Thank you. Grayson [0:30:25] Yeah, thank you madam mayor. Well, can you go back to page nine? [0:30:28] on your presentation. Yes sir, thank you. So access to that southernmost tip, is it [0:30:36] feasible that we'd be able to put a road in coming in to access that tip or how [0:30:41] would we be accessing that remaining piece of land? As of right now, there is [0:30:51] no crossing at that portion. There's a canal that just kind of stops with some [0:30:59] Jersey barriers. I mean has expressed desire not to put a road through there as [0:31:05] well and so the if they wanted to develop this other portion of the lot there would [0:31:11] have to be some type of agreement to go to the south. So unless there's some kind [0:31:18] of easement given to the city to come off Addison that lower parcel then [0:31:24] essentially becomes dead space in your professional opinion what are your [0:31:27] thoughts? Yeah, well I don't want to have happen is have that be a landlocked [0:31:33] piece of dirt that's not usable? Yes. So how they would need to, how they would utilize [0:31:42] it is there would be an R2 zone. No matter what if they wanted to develop that, they'd [0:31:47] have to go through the subdivision process. That subdivision process would come before [0:31:51] you again. But the intent would be to property and there would be some creative ways but [0:32:06] that's to utilize access off your however, that would [0:32:11] far beyond what it's very imaginable is not necessary [0:32:20] realistic, those creative, the most fly access [0:32:28] through the Madison South. [0:32:32] Thank you, Will. [0:32:35] Sure. [0:32:35] Wilmer. [0:32:42] I'm just wondering why they go straight across, [0:32:45] why they are having a thought of a border, [0:32:49] just like the neighboring property has, [0:32:52] to do an R2, say, what is it, the 100 feet, [0:32:56] that the other neighbor has to go along the edge of that. [0:33:02] This doesn't make sense to separate it [0:33:04] unless I'm missing something on here. [0:33:08] Can you kind of explain that a little bit? [0:33:10] So I heard you correctly or understood correctly, [0:33:13] you're talking about a proposal [0:33:15] of having just the buffer around the, [0:33:19] is definitely a viable option that you're more than welcome [0:33:23] to discuss and we plan zoning, we could get behind that. [0:33:28] Was that discussed in any of the meetings? [0:33:31] I, not initially. [0:33:33] Okay. [0:33:34] Plan and zoning commission, that is something that the applicant has talked about. [0:33:42] And so just going this straight across was just a straight line. [0:33:46] That was just, let's match the development, right? [0:33:49] See what they're doing if they want to rezone it in the future and at the market, the market [0:33:54] works for it, then assess that in a couple of years time or whatever. [0:34:01] Can you tell me what the setback is on commercial property in the rear part of it? [0:34:07] Yes, so normally it is 25 feet or zero feet, however if it's a buddy in a residential use and it's 25 feet. [0:34:17] So the 100 feet or so that's around the neighboring has the 100 feet of R2 and then it has another 25 feet? [0:34:26] It's just the 100 feet would be that buffer. [0:34:30] The property line, how it describes it, is 25 feet from property line. [0:34:35] So it would dictate the 100 would be the mortgage. [0:34:42] This we want to clarify something. [0:34:46] So what is the applicant actually asking for? [0:34:49] Because there's a couple of different maps that you've shown. [0:34:52] I just want to know what the applicant's asking for, what planning and zoning is saying in [0:34:59] And there map and then also the commission came back and said, here's another one. [0:35:02] So if you could just go through those three for me, make sure I'm on the same page as you [0:35:06] guys. [0:35:07] So I'll just use this map, uh, applicant is asking for the whole property. [0:35:14] Okay. [0:35:15] Planning zoning, uh, staff, when we looked at it to provide pretty, pretty significant buffer. [0:35:22] So let's just keep it from the C1 over. [0:35:26] So that would get you to halfway through this property line. [0:35:32] And then planning zoning commission said, let's protect this property and push it to the west as well. [0:35:40] As the applicant, and they're going to present. [0:35:47] So I'll just wait for them to present and then ask questions. [0:35:51] Thank you. So the next picture is what the commission has. [0:35:55] Yes, this is the commission's recommendation. [0:35:59] And that was the 7 to 0 vote that was in the minutes. [0:36:03] Okay. Okay. [0:36:05] Any other questions for staff? [0:36:07] Hey, why don't we have the applicant come up please. [0:36:22] Welcome. [0:36:23] Thank you. [0:36:23] Good evening to each one. [0:36:25] I'm Doug Cohen, owner of this property there on 2794 at [0:36:29] us in Avenue East. [0:36:31] And yes, like has been said, we are asking for that portion [0:36:36] that is our two to be changed to see one for development [0:36:41] purposes to give us some more options to that. As we've listened and tried to [0:36:49] communicate and work with some of the neighbors, we've heard some some resistance to that. [0:36:55] And as we've looked at that, we are we are open to what the planning and [0:37:05] zoning recommended at first there like we were showing, trying to keep that as [0:37:10] small as possible because it is, like was said, there's some real challenges to entry [0:37:17] ways into there and to how to develop that in a way that would be acceptable to everybody [0:37:23] involved. [0:37:24] So that's why we're looking at that as what would be the best for everybody involved and [0:37:32] and also for our future of developing that and to see [0:37:36] and that is a real challenge to, if there's too much spot there, [0:37:42] it would create a real challenge to for entryway and also development purposes. [0:37:49] So anyway, that's where we're at with it. I'm open for questions. [0:37:54] Questions for Doug? Anybody? Chris, your name's still up? Okay. [0:38:00] Yeah, just a quick question, so understanding that initially Doug, you came in for the full [0:38:06] property to be moved from R2 to C1, some of it is already C1, but you were comfortable [0:38:13] with the P&Z staff going down to the neighboring property line, it's not the one that's currently [0:38:21] being shown, but a smaller portion of it staying at R2, is that correct? [0:38:27] Yes, that's correct. [0:38:28] Okay, it seemed like in our meeting with the commissioner, [0:38:32] see it was, we feel like it wasn't communicated efficiently [0:38:37] or properly, and so therefore that was, [0:38:39] it was turned out different than that plan [0:38:42] that the planning and zoning created. [0:38:45] Thank you. [0:38:46] Thank you, Grace and Stone. [0:38:47] Thank you, Madam Mayor. [0:38:48] In our packet, we received this evening, [0:38:50] we received a packet of letters, [0:38:51] and one of these was from Miss Brown, [0:38:57] and she said that she had talked with you, [0:38:58] and she sold you the property. [0:38:59] Was there ever a deed restriction put on the property? [0:39:02] Okay, there was no recorded deed restriction. [0:39:06] They would show up on a title commitment or anything. [0:39:08] Okay, that was my only question. [0:39:09] Thank you. [0:39:11] Any other questions for the applicant? [0:39:16] Okay, seeing none, thank you, Doug. [0:39:22] We're going to, I will be opening up the public hearing [0:39:26] portion and just again to reiterate, please step up [0:39:30] to the podium state your name and address, [0:39:33] give your comments or concerns. [0:39:35] please limit your comments to two minutes. [0:39:37] And then after you give testimony, [0:39:39] please sign the public signing sheet up top. [0:39:42] I will mention that we received several comments handed to us. [0:39:47] I believe a couple people are here. [0:39:49] They may also speak, but we are in, we did get them. [0:39:54] So we all have them. [0:39:56] Okay, so I'm opening up the public hearing. [0:39:59] So I don't know if there's a signing sheet up there. [0:40:05] But first person can come on down. [0:40:15] Yes, I'll begin. [0:40:16] My name's Ron James. [0:40:17] I'm a property owner, resident in Twin Falls. [0:40:20] And first off, I'd like to preface the remarks of Carol Barrop. [0:40:27] You have a copy of her letter that she's submitted. [0:40:29] In caps, yes. [0:40:31] And in part, and anyway, she wrote her letter all in caps for a reason. [0:40:37] I'd like to provide a little context. [0:40:40] She had come in this in the email that she sent. [0:40:44] She mentioned how previously City Council [0:40:47] quote ignored requests for LaBaron not [0:40:51] to build his storage business, referring [0:40:54] to those storage lockers to the west. [0:40:58] He said we wouldn't see anything. [0:41:00] However, I see the top of his containers [0:41:02] from my dining room table as he didn't build the fence high [0:41:06] enough. [0:41:07] That's kind of a background for some of the concerns [0:41:09] So many of the residents have is the issues. [0:41:15] So currently, our home on 9th Avenue East, [0:41:19] we're living in a pleasant, safe, tree-lined, low-density, [0:41:23] residential family neighborhood. [0:41:26] I oppose the rezoning due to serious concerns [0:41:31] that rezoning the property to commercial [0:41:33] will adversely change the unique character and livability [0:41:36] of this neighborhood. [0:41:38] The zoning change will result in numerous spillover effects, [0:41:43] such as excessive and intrusive lighting, noise, traffic, [0:41:47] and safety issues, as well as overall aesthetic deterioration [0:41:52] and reduction in property values. [0:41:56] The proposed zoning change will not be consistent [0:41:59] with the existing adjacent residential properties. [0:42:03] So as stated above, there are serious and substantial concerns [0:42:07] about negative spillover effects that the zoning change [0:42:10] could have on property values. [0:42:14] So I also have to question some of the motives [0:42:19] for the rezoning request as well as the need [0:42:22] for this change in the first place. [0:42:24] So again, I just want to state that I oppose the zone change [0:42:28] as it will result in property values going down [0:42:31] and interfere with the neighborhoods, [0:42:32] unique characteristics and aesthetics. [0:42:35] Thank you. [0:42:36] Thank you, sir. [0:42:38] Who's next? [0:42:39] Oh, Jonathan, did you have, oh, thank you. [0:42:45] Josh Summers. [0:42:48] Josh here. [0:43:00] Hi, my name is Josh with Summers. [0:43:01] I'm a resident on 9th as well. [0:43:04] They are down by the tip of the field there. [0:43:10] I just wanted to say. [0:43:11] Could you hang on one sec. [0:43:13] We're going. [0:43:15] Our timer's not working. [0:43:17] Sorry. [0:43:19] Or we're trying to work it. [0:43:25] Jason, do you want to time this one? [0:43:27] Please, yes, two minutes. [0:43:30] Thank you. [0:43:32] Go ahead. [0:43:33] I just wanted to say that I also oppose [0:43:35] the full commercial zoning, even with the best intentions, [0:43:40] anyone who purchases the property in the future [0:43:44] is not going to be beholden to any promises [0:43:48] that were made by the current owner or any plans that [0:43:52] are currently in place. [0:43:54] I just, like Ron said, it's a community of well-established [0:43:59] homes, there's a neighborhood of dozens of homes and families and properties that [0:44:05] would be adversely affected by the rezoning. I think the only benefit to the [0:44:11] rezoning would be to add more money to the resell value of that and I don't [0:44:16] think that's a good enough reason to infringe on the characteristic of the [0:44:21] neighborhoods along the side and along the southern portion. It was it's it's [0:44:28] It's currently a farm. [0:44:30] It has water resources. [0:44:31] Canal is already in play. [0:44:36] It doesn't require any change for the current business [0:44:40] to be maintained the way that it is to stay it as it is. [0:44:45] And if someone does want to develop it in the future, [0:44:48] whether it's the current owner or a future developer, [0:44:51] I would just like to see the line behind Kimberly [0:44:55] the plant in zoning recommended to keep the residential portions residential and the already [0:45:02] established commercial portions commercial and if someone does want to go in and develop [0:45:08] it and add to that then part of that development could be a road. I mean if you're going to [0:45:12] tear it up and build houses or build businesses a road and infrastructure is going to be part [0:45:17] of that anyway. Just the with the storage sheds already adversely affecting those neighborhoods. [0:45:26] I think it would be a shame to bring more commercial into that area and continue to degrade [0:45:32] the homes and the neighborhoods. Thank you. Anyone else who wishes to speak? [0:45:39] My name is Genji James and I also live on 9th Avenue East. We have this field in our [0:45:58] backyard. I did make sure that my letter was included in your packet. I opposed [0:46:04] the zoning. I believe that the commercial zoning remains on Addison and it doesn't [0:46:10] belong on 9th where the residential is. I've also included the letter from the [0:46:16] previous seller who has owned this parcel since the 80s and she said that [0:46:20] when she sold it to the Coens, the intention was to keep the farmland and [0:46:25] and that it would remain his store front. [0:46:31] As it's currently zoned, it's already set up perfectly for that. [0:46:35] We've got a store on Addison, [0:46:36] and then the rest of it is farmland. [0:46:39] I feel like it's very valuable land that could be sold [0:46:42] as farmland, it could be sold as is. [0:46:45] And I feel like the zoning is unnecessary. [0:46:52] Is there anyone else that wishes to speak? [0:47:02] My name is Ellie Conno, and I also live on night. [0:47:05] And I oppose this as well because I feel like anything other than farmland in that plot will do more harm than good to the 9th Avenue East community. [0:47:16] Thank you. [0:47:18] [Muted for privacy: home address] [0:47:20] [Muted for privacy: home address] [0:47:35] [Muted for privacy: home address] [0:47:43] [Muted for privacy: home address] [0:47:46] neighborhood. I love living there and I'm mostly worried about the future of this [0:47:51] property. Like the previous speaker said, we don't have any control over what the [0:47:57] next property owner might do with that property and I just feel like if it's [0:48:01] commercial all the way back it will really adversely affect our neighborhood. [0:48:04] Thank you. Thank you. Is there anyone else who wishes to address City Council? [0:48:11] Lindy Christiansen and I also live on 9th Avenue and our street is a nice quiet [0:48:25] street. I have a secure old currently I just got a text on my way here that he's [0:48:30] just learning to ride his bike he's finally we're so happy and we just want [0:48:34] to keep this our neighborhood safe for kids. Kids from O'Leary use our street to [0:48:40] get to their houses over on Woodridge because it's just so less busy than [0:48:47] Elizabeth and we are just I'm just concerned that if this whole thing becomes [0:48:52] business eventually the road will punch through. That's the future that we're [0:48:57] looking at and that our road will become so busy and so that's why I am [0:49:01] opposed to changing the zoning. Thank you. Just want to remind everybody who's [0:49:10] spoken if you didn't already sign this sheet there will be one up there to sign. [0:49:13] Thank you. I'm Isabel Manning and I'm opposed to this rezoning project as well. [0:49:21] I grew with all the previously mentioned statements that this neighborhood is so beautiful and valuable and [0:49:28] It's full of families and it's such a great place to live and so I [0:49:36] Thank you. Is there anyone else here who wishes to speak? [0:49:43] Please come down. My name is Elaine Goldman directly at the field that we're talking rezoning to this this would not [0:50:21] not, this would not improve our neighborhoods either on either side of the field with commercial [0:50:30] zoning. [0:50:32] I'd like to pose a simple question to all of the council and to the owners of the property. [0:50:40] With all of you before this, if you were the ones who were living with your property [0:50:46] directly next to the property that was going to be rezoned, I especially would like to ask [0:50:53] the owners of the property who are asking for this rezoning. [0:50:58] Thank you. [0:50:59] And led better, I also live on 9th Avenue East, and I agree with the other comments as far as keeping it like it is. [0:51:22] I enjoy the sheep in the summer, I enjoy the farmland out there, and the quiet for the children. [0:51:27] And I just oppose this one. [0:51:29] Thank you. [0:51:30] Hey, is there anybody else that wishes to address City Council from the audience? [0:51:46] Okay, seeing no one applicant, you can come up. [0:51:49] If you'd like, if you've got any answers to any of the comments, follow up. [0:51:55] Things that I would like to mention. [0:52:08] I guess thinking about this, I've spent a lot of time thinking about this change. [0:52:14] And my thinking, and my, some of the reasons of the things that I've offered, [0:52:19] goes beyond today, tomorrow, possibly me owning it, maybe somebody else owning it someday. [0:52:26] And thinking about if I was one of those house owners there, that property, it's going to change, [0:52:37] much as we would all like to see a field stay there and that be in our backyard. [0:52:41] It's going to change and it's going to be developed, that's just the way it is. [0:52:47] But thinking about that process in the future, to me, the lady just asked the question to us as owners [0:52:57] as owners and I will try to answer that. [0:53:00] I would rather see a commercial zoning property development [0:53:06] there with a nice buffer zone than a residential where [0:53:12] possibly the people are changing their emergency vehicles [0:53:16] coming, there's things happening that you have no control over. [0:53:19] Kind of what I was thinking about is in the future. [0:53:22] That was me. [0:53:22] I would like to see a buffer zone and I've offered that, [0:53:24] but there's no interest in that as far as these neighbors. [0:53:30] But to have a nice buffer zone there [0:53:34] that would keep the back of their property, [0:53:37] their view attractive and safe. [0:53:42] It's all in the, you all know a lot more about that [0:53:45] than I do, but that's where I guess I would, [0:53:48] I've been thinking about it is in the long term, [0:53:52] if we could make a nice buffer zone [0:53:54] around the east and south border of that, [0:53:58] that would be long-term benefit to those property owners. [0:54:02] I think that would be a, [0:54:04] be something that I would appreciate anyway. [0:54:06] Thank you. [0:54:09] Anything from staff, Will, do you have anything? [0:54:15] Yeah, just a couple of clarifying comments. [0:54:21] Regards to screening, [0:54:32] and it's adjacent to a residence, [0:54:38] would have to provide for screening as well. That was a requirement that's not [0:54:42] a commercial bidding, uh, didn't show near, provide us either a six-foot-tall fence or [0:54:54] a wall or provide us with the landscape buffer of some sort. Uh, that the details [0:55:01] are outlined in order to be some, some sort of other, the other comment that [0:55:20] Asian, I guess, is currently right now at R2 zone. They can build a duplex [0:55:35] they subdivide it, they can do more. [0:55:42] What is before the council today is, [0:55:47] does the C1 zone make sense in this area [0:55:49] for the whole property that already has some of it? [0:55:52] So we're not establishing that portion, [0:55:54] but does it make sense to go further down? [0:55:57] Something that I forgot to, [0:56:02] that I wanted to outline was, [0:56:05] the sum of the intended uses that this could be, [0:56:08] that are permitted outright. [0:56:10] For instance, a floor shop, a food establishment, eating at places, a bookstore, an automobile [0:56:17] parts store, home furnishings and equipment, a laundromat, taxidermy, studio, business associations, [0:56:32] daycare services, employment agencies, those are the similar uses that will be permitted [0:56:38] by right-end-to-see-one zone. [0:56:39] But if you don't feel that that is appropriate in that area, then that's up to you to decide. [0:56:47] that's what we're voting on is are these types of uses, is this type of development what we're [0:56:52] needing in this area, does the context make sense essentially? And so just to really clarify [0:56:59] that no matter what thought to the screen, but then also does the context make sense? [0:57:06] Well, Jason, my question was really more for the applicant. I don't know if I can ask that real quick [0:57:17] or not is that okay mayor but you you had mentioned that you had offered a [0:57:22] buffer strip do you have any recollection or idea of what that buffer strip would [0:57:27] be along and I'm assuming it's along the east side and the south side of that [0:57:33] property is that correct what was that what was that distance of that buffer [0:57:38] strip could you pull the map back up for us we don't have anything on our [0:57:45] screen thank you yes I'm assuming the buffer strip sorry to jump and I'm [0:57:50] I'm assuming it's different than what was on the map we're seeing here. [0:57:54] Yes, and my thought was along the east side where that property [0:58:05] joins those residents backyard there. [0:58:10] There's just a small fence there. [0:58:13] That would be a 25, 25 foot buffer zone with a six foot solid fence and trees, [0:58:25] Maybe like we were thinking of gravel for the ground, so there's no weeds with stones [0:58:33] and several different options, maybe an open option where they see the fence, maybe a closed [0:58:41] option where it was just enough trees and bushes type things, so they didn't see anything [0:58:49] beyond it and also maybe another scenario of trees in a row where if you're standing on [0:58:56] that property you can still see out to the northwest and see the mountains and to just [0:59:01] to have a view scenario of that. Anyway that was my thought behind it. [0:59:07] What about the south side? I know you have the canal with these men. [0:59:10] That's right. There's a big canal around there and I what my thought was is do the same thing [0:59:14] that the neighbor did there is plant a row of trees on my side of the canal that would [0:59:25] be tall enough that would hide you and lights. There's already a wide canal and then those [0:59:34] residents along there already have a fence which is a block to that as well. [0:59:39] It's a pencil cutler. [0:59:45] I just wanted to share my thoughts with the council members. [0:59:48] I'm concerned that we could make changes that will lose the trust of the residents of the city. [0:59:53] When we have neighborhoods that have a long established zoning, [0:59:58] when we have future land use maps, I don't want to make changes that seem inconsistent or erratic. [1:00:05] Now there's mechanisms that exist for us to make changes, so why do those exist? [1:00:09] But when you consider the outskirts of town where there's new developments it makes change it makes sense to change [1:00:15] we have [1:00:17] Developments that are only partially developed it may make sense to change if we have [1:00:23] Neighborhoods that experiencing urban decay or distress it might make sense to change [1:00:28] But in this case it's a neighborhood that's been as it is for a long time [1:00:32] The existing zoning with commercial on the north [1:00:34] residential on the south has been the way it is for a long time. It runs pretty [1:00:40] consistent through all the properties through there and in this sense it [1:00:44] doesn't make sense to me to change the zoning at this point. Mayor before you get [1:00:48] into the deliberation part too much if you want to close the public hearing or at least have another question for the [1:00:53] reminder. Sorry I answered. Okay any other questions for staff or the applicant? [1:00:58] Madam Mayor I have one I guess it's more directed to Director Spendlove and [1:01:01] and maybe even Jonathan. [1:01:04] Sorry. [1:01:05] Sorry. [1:01:06] I'm a city administrator. [1:01:07] Are we able to restrict portions of the C1 zoning? [1:01:12] And where I'm going with this is a few pullback on page nine with the commission's recommendation [1:01:21] for that southern tip and that southern boundary? [1:01:24] No. [1:01:25] One where I align. [1:01:26] There we go. [1:01:27] Right there. [1:01:28] Could we designate that can only be used for yard space [1:01:34] into our leech field and oyster mortar retention? [1:01:38] No. [1:01:39] So what you have right now is the property that has a development [1:01:42] right of R2. [1:01:44] If your decision is where and what you're going to rezone to C1, [1:01:49] that is totally up to you how you do that and the distance [1:01:53] that you want to make. [1:01:53] But they have a right today for R2 [1:01:56] and there's uses that are approved and not right permitted. [1:01:58] They just have to get a subdivision permit to do it. [1:02:00] Right, but my question is if we make this whole portion, [1:02:03] C1, can we make it conditioned upon that this corner, [1:02:08] this piece can only be used for yard space, [1:02:10] leech fields, and stormwater retention? [1:02:17] Because according to Google Earth, that's about three acres. [1:02:20] What Will didn't mention in C1 is that if they go C1, [1:02:23] it could also be used for high density housing [1:02:25] as long as the project can park it. [1:02:27] So that could be used for a park, that could be used. [1:02:29] Yeah. So I get where you're at. I think that's shaky ground when you don't have an agreement [1:02:35] in front of you from the owner. That would be more restrictive on the zoning side. I mean [1:02:41] you could do with a contract to say this is our contract as long as the owner agreed [1:02:45] to that. But that also wasn't necessarily what was presented to the Planning and Zoning Commission. [1:02:51] So if you make a substantial change, you need to go back for a recommendation to them. [1:02:56] If you're going to start doing that kind of restrictive zoning on it or a contract zone. [1:03:00] Because I'm having a hard time creating a quote unquote dead zone right here and remating [1:03:05] this is R2 and I'm trying to figure out if we make this R2. [1:03:09] And I got one last bit for that to answer that. [1:03:12] So this doesn't actually create a dead zone. [1:03:14] So they still have an option to do a lot of other things. [1:03:16] You're not taking any property right away. [1:03:18] That doesn't mean they can't come forward future for a different re-zoned to future spot [1:03:22] do like a professional office overlay that's integrated with their commercial zone. That's [1:03:26] still an option. They have access to the north. They just don't have access to the south unless [1:03:33] you have any other additional information you need to seek. I'd close the public hearing. [1:03:37] Yeah. I mean, and I close the public hearing as. Go for it. Okay. So public hearing is closed. [1:03:45] Now it's time for Council of the Liberation Cristy. Can I see the zoning map up here real quick? [1:03:51] the options and again just going through it my thought process and it might change [1:04:04] okay okay I'm talking right now ultimately looking at the map on the left [1:04:11] there's a couple of options first of all brown is scene one currently where we're [1:04:17] at it looks like in the on either side of this property there's C1 well C1 that's [1:04:27] going down and that was the 2017 what we did as a council. The ones on the other [1:04:34] side, it looks like there's currently businesses that are operating C1 in an [1:04:42] R2 zone that are adjacent currently to some of the property owners. We have a [1:04:52] couple of things that we're looking at is bringing that line down [1:05:02] ultimately to be with the rest of the property owners understanding that they're [1:05:06] currently doing something in a zone that for whatever reason shouldn't be there [1:05:13] but that's a whole other discussion for another time bringing it down to where [1:05:20] the property to the east currently is or the entire thing or doing nothing those [1:05:26] are kind of the four options that we have unless we decide to do something [1:05:32] completely different make it make up fifth I understand the neighbors I [1:05:41] understand they've been there completely agree as far as where they're coming from [1:05:47] also this is somebody who owns the property and property rights and they [1:05:52] should get a say on what they do in their property as well at this point in time [1:06:00] I I would be comfortable myself with bringing it down to the property to the [1:06:08] east and bringing that over and having that buffer that entire rectane or the [1:06:13] the triangle esque down in that area I feel like that's a pretty big buffer I [1:06:20] don't know exactly how many acres how big that that parcel is if we bring it down [1:06:24] to that size but it's a pretty big buffer compared to some of the other [1:06:31] areas that are currently being operated right next to those property owners. So [1:06:37] you're talking the proposal from E&C. The staff. The staff was all the way [1:06:43] down to the property on the east and then the commission brought it up. [1:06:48] Property to the west. Sorry the west. Thank you. To the west. So would you flip [1:06:53] through those just one more time please. So that was that's the zoning how it is [1:06:57] this is that's the one you're looking at and then the other one was the [1:07:03] Commission. Okay. Thank you, Grayson. Thank you, Madam Mayor. I agree with [1:07:13] Councilman Reed's sentiments. Councilman Reed on that P&Z's recommendation. That's [1:07:18] roughly two and a half acres I did it off Google Earth. I didn't do an [1:07:22] independent survey and just quick calculation off Google Earth. I think [1:07:27] I would be in favor of P&Z's options. I do think that this highlights an [1:07:31] important piece when we're doing land deals going back and forth. There is an [1:07:36] option you can do when you're when you're selling land to do deed restrictions [1:07:40] and stuff so keep that in your back your head citizens are selling [1:07:43] land. Sherry did you have something are you? I can understand why this parcel would [1:07:55] want why you would want this parcel to be all C1 it seems a whole parcel should be [1:08:03] but you can see the the concern of the residents a group on Buchanan so I [1:08:11] So I understand, Marshall coming in behind you on that way, but this also seems very [1:08:18] premature with no plans of putting anything there or no real, I guess I'm not seeing what [1:08:27] your real reason of wanting to do this is other than possibly sometime in the future [1:08:32] selling. [1:08:34] Is that correct? [1:08:35] You can't answer. [1:08:36] You can't answer. [1:08:37] Sorry. [1:08:38] I'm learning. [1:08:39] No, you're new. [1:08:40] That's all right. [1:08:41] That's right. [1:08:42] I'm out with this right now and I think if the way that this sits up here, if any change [1:08:50] is going to be made at this point, you know, it seems the applicant is good with that lower [1:08:56] portion but we're only putting a few feet into there and I don't know what that does [1:09:00] to future planned uses if we're just creating another problem. [1:09:07] Any other discussion, Craig? [1:09:08] Did you have something? [1:09:09] I, you know, it's a tough situation, a tough decision, I certainly appreciate the property [1:09:16] owners that surround that and I also understand the view from the property [1:09:21] owner itself. It seems to me that when that property was purchased that he knew [1:09:28] what the zoning regulations were and so he had that knew that was part of the deal. [1:09:36] Now he wants to expand the commercial part of that which is understandable [1:09:41] But I guess I kind of feel the recommendation for the commission would probably be the best thing that I'd also don't like leaving the rest of the last parcel. [1:09:56] Maybe inaccessible for some time or but it does have potential. [1:10:02] So that's kind of where I'm coming from. [1:10:05] Hey, Grayson, are you done or did you have something else? [1:10:09] I may have a question for you. [1:10:11] So assuming that we shoot this thing, is there an option for the applicant to come back regardless [1:10:17] of the result and come back with a site plan and say, all right, I want to rezone the entire [1:10:22] 10 acre parcel and here's our site plan. [1:10:24] If you have an evaluate it that way. [1:10:28] The applicant has an option to rezone their property. [1:10:30] Regardless if we shoot it down. [1:10:32] Yeah, if you deny it, they can ask for another one. [1:10:36] They can come back in the future with a CCA or something like that or a multiple zone. [1:10:41] They have that option. [1:10:43] Okay. [1:10:44] Grace, or Spencer? [1:10:45] Yeah. [1:10:47] My thought was along those lines, you know, keep in mind this doesn't create a dead zone. [1:10:51] There can still be access to residential development through the commercial property, or they have the option to come back with something like a proposed ZDA or PUD that show the project as a whole. [1:11:03] That's an easier way for them to illustrate things such as intended buffer zones or things like that. [1:11:08] That's why those mechanisms exist. [1:11:10] And yeah, I just want to clarify that point. [1:11:13] Hey, Jason Brown. [1:11:15] Yeah, I'd like to, you know, just sitting here listening to the other council members and trying to collect some of my thoughts and figure out what, you know, what would happen in this situation. [1:11:28] I kind of feel, I kind of feel along the lines of I'd like to see what, see what this would would become in that C1 zone. [1:11:39] But I also want to echo the sentiment of what the applicant has said is, I think in some [1:11:47] ways the development of this area is inevitable. [1:11:51] It's just the city is growing in around it. [1:11:54] It's part of the process as we've grown to remain agriculture is probably not likely [1:12:03] out into the future. [1:12:06] But I would like to see a little bit more without, you know, I think it's easier to see [1:12:10] some of those defined buffer zones, see what that is. [1:12:16] And so I'm struggling to figure out how to work this, I would probably be more inclined [1:12:22] to accept the staff recommendation of leaving that as an R2 zone if that's the motion that's [1:12:32] made. [1:12:33] I'm just struggling a little bit around the residential development and what that buffer [1:12:40] looks like. [1:12:41] But ultimately you understand that there is some development that's going to come push [1:12:44] this area because it's a good piece of property for that. [1:12:49] Going back to what Councilman Reed had said earlier, looking at the commercial development [1:12:58] even inside of our map here, the boundaries off just a little bit. Jonathan, or will the [1:13:04] church itself, is that, would that be permitted in an R1 zone now, or would it have to re-zone? [1:13:11] I can clarify all of that. The church would be especially used permit in the R2 zone historically, [1:13:18] and I'm going to use the pointer instead of that one for the audience as well. At a point [1:13:23] in time, Addison Avenue basically had a C1 zone that was a distance from the centerline [1:13:27] of that road and that's why I see one by sex on those properties. [1:13:30] Okay. So what's on the southern portion would be illegal nonconforming use because the zoning [1:13:36] changed after those were already established. [1:13:37] Okay. That's all for me right now. I'm still trying to gather my thoughts a little bit. [1:13:47] history do you have? I was going to make a motion. I just wanted to clarify because there's been [1:13:54] a couple of conversations and a couple of comments made. As far as P and Z there was really there's [1:14:01] the staff P&Z staff recommendation and then there's the commission's recommendation I'll [1:14:08] make a motion based off of staff's recommendation seeing some head nods yes that's meaning the [1:14:17] staff recommendation with the lower boundary yes to the west in line with the property to [1:14:25] the west so I move that we approve the request for a rezone of property from R2 to C1 and [1:14:36] and C1 to C1 for property located at 2794 Addison Avenue East as presented for the staff [1:14:51] recommendation for the property line buffer with the property to the west. [1:15:04] Right here. [1:15:05] The map is presented. [1:15:07] Yes. [1:15:08] Okay. [1:15:09] Do I have a second? [1:15:11] I'll second. [1:15:12] Thank you. [1:15:13] by Chris Reed, seconded by Craig Hawkins [1:15:17] to approve the request for rezone of property from R2, [1:15:22] NC1 to C1, and I guess moving the boundary [1:15:28] as presented on the map as recommended by staff. [1:15:33] I guess that was it kind of sort of. [1:15:35] It works. [1:15:36] We all got the gist of what that was. [1:15:39] Nobody from the city manager's office [1:15:41] is freaking out, are we good over there? [1:15:44] Okay, so there's a motion on the floor. [1:15:47] Let's have some discussion unless we're discussed out and. [1:15:52] Mayor, can I guess and I'll just ask this to the maker of the motion, [1:15:57] would it be appropriate to add maybe that 25 foot buffer zone on that east side [1:16:03] for that little chunk of residential property? [1:16:05] So there's at least a little bit of a buffer there for them. [1:16:08] I don't want to make it too convoluted, but at least give some protection for that. [1:16:12] that little chunk of residential property right there. [1:16:17] Put that. [1:16:19] I would have no problem. [1:16:20] I think we should probably make an amendment to it. [1:16:24] But can I at least see what that looks like understanding [1:16:27] that we don't have the tools out here to make it look super [1:16:32] pretty? [1:16:32] I get it. [1:16:34] What does 25 feet look like on these maps? [1:16:40] It's not a lot. [1:16:41] It's 25 feet. [1:16:43] What's 25 feet? [1:16:44] Yeah. [1:16:44] Yeah, you're looking near that distance from where we'll sit [1:16:50] in that wall. [1:16:52] We can look at this. [1:16:53] We can pull it up on the map and show you. [1:16:57] And really, if we wanted more, I would be OK with that. [1:17:00] I just think there's probably needs to be some buffer [1:17:03] on that property owner to provide some landscaping for that. [1:17:08] But again, I don't want to make it too convoluted. [1:17:10] But if I may add, so 25 feet is the setback for a building [1:17:14] from a property line on commercial property [1:17:19] to where the building could be a commercial building [1:17:21] when that is next to residential. [1:17:24] In my world, that's not huge. [1:17:26] It's enough. [1:17:26] You can have a fire lane within there. [1:17:27] You could do some of this stuff. [1:17:28] If you wanted to make it substantial, I'd go more. [1:17:33] But I'm just giving some a little bit of advice here [1:17:35] that there's what you would be doing [1:17:37] is saying that is going to remain R2 [1:17:40] and therefore no commercial activity [1:17:41] would be taking place in there. [1:17:44] But I'd like to go along with the feeling of what the applicant had is making sure that [1:17:50] there's at least some vegetation buffer associated with that. [1:17:54] I don't know if that's we can do that or. [1:17:56] So didn't we say that part of the code says when you have commercial budding against residential, [1:18:04] that there is a requirement for, so do we have to add that? [1:18:10] I mean, wouldn't they be coming back? [1:18:12] There's a screening requirement. [1:18:13] Screening requirement is either a fence or vegetation [1:18:17] that is essentially a screening requirement [1:18:20] between commercial and residential. [1:18:22] To add a zone buffer, you would be saying there's no commercial [1:18:26] activity happening within that area, which you can do. [1:18:29] You can dictate where this goes and what you would accept. [1:18:34] I don't want to limit what your option. [1:18:36] I'm just trying to figure out how to, you know, [1:18:38] if it does exist on that east side to make sure there's at least [1:18:42] some type of screening that occurs in that zone. [1:18:48] Screening would occur, but the zone would allow some uses nearby except any [1:18:54] building would need to be 25 feet probably from that property line. [1:18:58] So if you want something further than that zone it or leave it R2 and create [1:19:02] that area to save no commercial activity in that area that doesn't [1:19:05] necessarily require your landscaping buffer [1:19:11] that you're looking for. But why don't we just move the line as to what [1:19:15] commission and it's done, right? I'm at a, I'm at a mayor if I can just jump in. That's [1:19:20] exactly what I was just trying to say is that the PNC's recommendation of moving [1:19:25] that line further north even gives a more or a greater buffer north to south and I [1:19:31] think is more congruent going east to west. But I don't want to have happen [1:19:34] is when the should those properties, excuse me on the eastern boundary line, so then they [1:19:41] can use that as the commercial line and keep creeping down further and further. [1:19:46] Okay, so we've talked about a lot of things. We have a motion on the floor, and it's been [1:19:55] seconded, so I would guess we would have a vote, and then if that doesn't, does or doesn't [1:20:04] pass then we move on to the next. Okay, so no for any further discussion. Yeah, and I think for me, I think the screening setback is comfortable with the first motion after we've talked about it. Okay, Amy, please roll call vote. [1:20:24] Benser Cutler. No. [1:20:29] Grayson Stone. No. [1:20:32] Jerry Bulmer. No. Ruth Pierce. Yes. [1:20:36] Chris Reed. Yes. Greg Hawkins. Yes. [1:20:39] Jason Brown. Yes. [1:20:41] Hey, I believe that motion passes 4-3. Is that correct? [1:20:48] Okay. So I guess that being the- is there anything else, gentlemen? [1:20:58] Okay. Then we have no executive session tonight and our meeting is adjourned. [1:21:03] Thank you, everyone.