Oversight Archive: City Council meeting, 2024-05-06, recording 1 (started 16:58) Machine transcript (faster-whisper base.en), not checked word for word; the Pledge of Allegiance is shown in its standard wording. The recording is the record. Times are time into the recording. Passages with private details are muted in the audio and marked here. The audio on the page below was re-encoded by software from the video the agency posted. Check any passage against that audio before relying on it. Page: https://oversightarchive.org/twin-falls-id/meetings/2024-05-06/ [0:01:59] Good evening, ladies and gentlemen, and welcome to the May 6, 2024 City Council meeting. [0:02:05] I want to confirm we have a quorum. [0:02:07] We have all seven members present in chambers today. [0:02:12] First item on the agenda is the Pledge of Allegiance. [0:02:14] If you wish to join me, please rise. [0:02:35] Thank you. [0:02:36] I do have a couple of proclamations tonight. [0:02:38] The first one is the Peace Officers Memorial Day and Police Week 2024. [0:02:45] This is a joint proclamation between the City of Twin Falls and Twin Falls County. [0:02:52] A proclamation by the County and City of Twin Falls, Idaho declaring Sunday, May 12th through [0:02:57] Saturday, May 18th as Police Week and Wednesday, May 15th, 2024 as Peace Officers Memorial Day, [0:03:06] whereas the Congress and President of the United States have designated the week in which [0:03:11] May 12-18-2024 falls as National Police Week and whereas the members of the law [0:03:19] enforcement agencies of the city and county of Twin Falls play an essential [0:03:25] role in safeguarding the rights and freedoms of the residents of the county [0:03:29] and city of Twin Falls and whereas it is important that all citizens know and [0:03:34] understand the duties, responsibilities, hazards, and sacrifices of their law [0:03:40] law enforcement agency and that members of our law enforcement agency recognize their [0:03:45] duty to serve the people by safeguarding life and property by protecting them against violence [0:03:53] and disorder and by protecting the innocent against deception and the weak against depression. [0:03:59] And whereas the men and women of the law enforcement agencies of the county and the city of Twin [0:04:04] falls unseasonately unceasingly provide a vital public service now therefore we [0:04:11] call upon all citizens of the county and city of Twin Falls and upon all [0:04:17] patriotic civic and educational organizations to observe the week of [0:04:22] May 12 through May 18, 2024 as Police Week with appropriate ceremonies and [0:04:28] observances in which all of our people may join in commemorating law enforcement [0:04:34] officers, past and present, who by their faithful and loyal devotion to their responsibilities [0:04:40] have rendered a dedicated service to their communities, and in doing so have established [0:04:46] for themselves an enviable and enduring reputation for preserving the rights and security of all [0:04:53] citizens. Furthermore, we call upon all citizens to observe May 15, 2024 as Police Officers Memorial [0:05:01] day in honor of those law enforcement officers who through their [0:05:05] courageous deeds have made the ultimate sacrifice in service to their [0:05:10] communities or have become disabled in the performance of duty and let us [0:05:15] recognize and pay respects to the survivors of our fallen heroes and this [0:05:20] is signed by both Commissioner Hall and myself. [0:05:24] So chief, or, gosh, okay, before I start my words, Madam Mayor and Council, thank you very [0:06:09] much for the opportunity to obviously present this during council and to the [0:06:13] city of Twin Falls and also the county of Twin Falls. I'm here, my name is Josh [0:06:17] Hayes, employee of the city of Twin Falls as a sergeant and also I'm on here as a [0:06:22] different role to. I'm also the president of the local fraternal order of police. [0:06:26] I've been doing that for 10 years and so I've also participated in this in many [0:06:31] years and unfortunately this week has been, last couple weeks, been very hard for [0:06:35] law enforcement, very close and dear to our hearts, losing deputy to Tobin Bolter in [0:06:41] Aida County. So this is going to be a tough day for us to remember this week and having [0:06:47] police officers Memorial Week. I also want to mention that this Saturday, May 11th, we're [0:06:53] having our Medge Value Law Enforcement Memorial in City Park. We have also unfortunately have [0:06:59] to add a name to that which we have already done so to recognize Tobin Bolter. And we [0:07:05] We also need to recognize that our fellow officer in Utah lost his life just yesterday [0:07:11] or the day before in an unfortunate series of events. [0:07:15] The violence is ever increasing within our country and everything and we just need to [0:07:21] take care of one another. [0:07:23] So we appreciate this opportunity to have the police week and have the citizens recognize [0:07:28] everything. [0:07:29] It's a good privilege tonight. [0:07:31] actually have two new officers graduating from the CSI law enforcement [0:07:36] academy tonight, Andy Taylor and Jacob Kennedy, so they'll be joining our team [0:07:41] shortly and going through training and and hopefully none of the unfortunate [0:07:46] events scare them away from these things because it is quite a wake-up call for [0:07:50] a lot but I thank you very much for this opportunity to stand for you and to [0:07:55] recognize police we can we invite all citizens to the Memorial to Saturday so [0:08:00] that they can recognize and ensure their support. [0:08:02] Thank you. [0:08:03] Thank you, Josh. [0:08:06] OK. [0:08:06] My second proclamation is in support of Twin Falls Military [0:08:13] Caregivers in collaboration with IDO, D-A-R, and Hidden Heroes. [0:08:18] Whereas the series of wars and conflicts [0:08:21] in which our nation has been engaged over time [0:08:24] since World War II has resulted in 5 and 1,500,000 military [0:08:28] and veteran caregivers who are parents, spouses, siblings, friends, caring for those wounded, [0:08:34] ill, or injured who have served our nation as documented by the 2014 RAN Study Commission [0:08:41] by the Elizabeth Dole Foundation, and whereas the daily tasks of these military and veteran [0:08:47] caregivers can include bathing, feeding, dressing, and caring for the injuries of wounded warriors, [0:08:54] administering medications, providing emotional support, caring for the family [0:08:59] and the home, and working outside the home to earn essential income, and whereas [0:09:05] the nation provides multifaceted support to our wounded ill and injured veterans [0:09:11] and service members through public, private and philanthropic resources, but [0:09:16] their caregivers receive little support or acknowledgement, and whereas most [0:09:21] military and veteran caregivers consider the challenging work they do as simply carrying [0:09:27] out their civic and patriotic duty without realizing they are in fact caregivers and [0:09:33] do not identify themselves as such and whereas an alarming number of military and veteran [0:09:38] caregivers according to research are suffering numerous debilitating mental physical and [0:09:45] emotional effects because of their caregiving duties and whereas the city of Twin Falls [0:09:50] desires to recognize and support those who are serving in these vital roads in our community. [0:09:57] Therefore, I, Ruth Pierce, Mayor of the City of Twin Falls do proclaim, hereby proclaim [0:10:02] May as Military Caregivers Month and urge all citizens to observe this month with appropriate [0:10:08] program ceremonies and activities. [0:10:12] We have Dr. Wendy French here with the Daughters, who pushed the button, or any of the light [0:11:04] That's it, like that. [0:11:08] Madam Mayor, City Council and community members and our peace officers that are here today. [0:11:15] My name is Wendy French. [0:11:16] I'm the region of the Twin Falls Chapter Daughters of American Revolution and also known as D.A.R. [0:11:24] In the audience today, our daughters that are with me and we are here for our mission of [0:11:29] promoting education, historic preservation and patriotism. [0:11:34] On behalf of the chapter, I stand before you to shine a spotlight on those individuals [0:11:39] near and dear to our hearts, the unsung heroes, the military caregivers. [0:11:45] These remarkable individuals often spouse as parents, family members and friends selflessly [0:11:51] care for our wounded ill or injured veterans. [0:11:55] They are the backbone of our nation's strength, resilience and compassion. [0:12:01] Allow me to introduce you to the Elizabeth Dole's Foundation Hidden Heroes, a beacon of support [0:12:07] and help for those caregivers. [0:12:11] There are five points of the Hidden Heroes that I'd like to share with you. [0:12:16] Number one is awareness and advocacy. [0:12:19] Hidden Heroes raises awareness about the daily challenges faced by our military caregivers. [0:12:25] Number two, inspiration to act. [0:12:28] We call on individuals, businesses, communities, civil servants such as herself, both civic [0:12:34] and faith-based to take action, whether it's volunteering, providing special, breast-care, [0:12:41] or advocating for caregiver-friendly policies, every effort counts. [0:12:46] Number three, National Registry Hidden Heroes.org serves as a lifeline for caregivers. [0:12:53] It's a place where they can register, connect with others, with resources, and find support. [0:13:00] Number four, Hidden Heroes Cities and Counties inspired by the foundation. [0:13:06] Cities and Counties across the nation are streamlining services for military caregivers. [0:13:11] And number five, caregiver community. [0:13:14] The Hidden Heroes caregiver community, H-C-C, we like acronyms, provides a safe haven online. [0:13:22] There's a space where empathy thrives and bonds strengthen. [0:13:27] Why does this matter? [0:13:31] Because when we honor our military caregivers, we are honoring the very essence of service, [0:13:36] sacrifice and love. [0:13:40] So if we've got caregivers in the audience today, I thank you. [0:13:44] We need to stand together, unite together, and gratitude and pledge to everything we can [0:13:51] do possible for these special caregivers. [0:13:55] So if we do have any, could you raise your hand if you don't mind, Madam Mayor would like to ask [0:14:00] our givers in the audience. [0:14:07] To honor you, our military caregivers in the audience, I ask you to come forward, but I [0:14:12] would be happy to deliver it for you, to receive this beautiful pink carnation. [0:14:19] Carnations are a symbol of love and devotion, and pink is a symbol of gratitude, and also [0:14:26] the Mother's Day flower is the pink carnation. [0:14:39] a legacy of hidden heroes continue to light our path toward a more compassionate and caring [0:14:45] society. Thank you. Thank you. Okay. Moving on to the consent calendar. Council wishes move [0:14:56] to approve. Thank you. Do I have a second? Second. Thank you. Motion by Chris Reed, seconded [0:15:02] by Craig Hawkins to approve the consent calendar as written. Amy Roll call vote please. Yes. [0:15:11] Yes. [0:15:12] Chris Reed. [0:15:13] Yes. [0:15:14] Greg Hawkins. [0:15:15] Yes. [0:15:16] Jason Brown. [0:15:17] Yes. [0:15:18] Spencer Cutler. [0:15:19] Yes. [0:15:20] Grayson Stone. [0:15:21] Yes. [0:15:22] And Sherry Volmer. [0:15:23] Yes. [0:15:24] Thank you. [0:15:25] Thank you. [0:15:26] Motion passes seven to zero. [0:15:27] Okay. [0:15:28] Next under items of consideration. [0:15:29] The first is an action item. [0:15:31] It's a request to allocate $11,667.91 in pool capital funds to purchase the two floor scrubbers. [0:15:40] floor scrubber to floor scrubber units and we have John Pauli from the pool. [0:15:46] Welcome John. Thank you. Good evening Mayor Pierce and members of the City [0:15:51] Council. Today I'd like to address an important matter related to our pool [0:15:56] facilities. As many of you are aware we recently applied a new deck coding to [0:16:00] enhance the safety and appearance of our pool deck. However during the [0:16:04] initial cleaning process our staff encountered an unexpected issue. Dirt [0:16:09] residue remained on the entire deck surface despite multiple attempts to rinse it away. [0:16:14] This residue not only marred the deck's appearance, but also gave me impression that it had not [0:16:18] been properly cleaned. [0:16:20] This is not totally surprising because we've always struggled to find an effective deck in [0:16:24] locker room cleaning solution. [0:16:26] In response to this challenge, our team decided to explore alternative cleaning methods. [0:16:31] We found success with a battery powered floor scrubber. [0:16:34] The innovative tool effectively cleaned both the pool deck and our locker room floors. [0:16:38] Unlike traditional hoses or pressure washers, [0:16:41] the floor scover allows us to maintain cleanliness [0:16:43] and disinfection more frequently. [0:16:45] Specifically, the pull deck would be cleaned [0:16:47] multiple times per week, [0:16:49] and the locker rooms would receive multiple daily cleans, [0:16:51] especially during the summer months, [0:16:53] ensuring a high-ogenic environment for our swimmers. [0:16:57] One of the key advantages of the floor scrubber [0:16:58] is its efficiency. [0:17:00] With just one operator, it outperforms a crew [0:17:02] of four using manual scrumming methods. [0:17:05] As a result, we can cover larger sections of the deck [0:17:07] within a shorter period of time. [0:17:10] Our staff recommends acquiring two floor scrubbers, [0:17:12] first a large 28-inch-wide dedicated to cleaning the deck, [0:17:16] and a smaller 11-inch-wide unit for the locker room floors [0:17:19] and hard-to-reach areas on the deck. [0:17:22] The total cost for both floor scrubbers amounts to $11,677.91 [0:17:28] to fund this purchase, we propose reallocating funds [0:17:31] from existing pool capital projects [0:17:33] to $11,183 from the remainder [0:17:36] the deck resurfacing project, and $484.91 from our facility maintenance projects. [0:17:43] By investing in these floor scubbers, we not only address the current cleaning challenge, [0:17:47] but also improve overall efficiency and maintenance. [0:17:49] I encourage your support for this proposal as it will enhance the full experience for [0:17:53] our swimmers. [0:17:54] Thank you for your time, and I'm open to any questions or further discussion on this matter. [0:17:58] Thank you, John. [0:18:00] Any questions for John? [0:18:04] Yes, John. [0:18:06] Is there any backlog on these or can they be purchased? [0:18:10] There's a little bit, about four to six weeks. [0:18:12] Okay, not too bad. [0:18:18] I'll make a motion. [0:18:19] Thank you, Jason. [0:18:19] I've moved to approve the request to reallocate $11,667.91 [0:18:26] in pool capital funds to purchase two floor scrubber units. [0:18:29] Thank you, do I have a second? [0:18:32] Second. [0:18:33] Thank you, motion by Jason Brown, seconded by Craig Hawkins [0:18:36] to approve the reallocation of $11,667.91 [0:18:43] in pool of capital funds to purchase two floors scrubbers. [0:18:48] Any further discussion? [0:18:49] Amy Roll call vote please. [0:18:52] Chris Reed. [0:18:53] Yes. [0:18:54] Ray Cockens. [0:18:55] Yes. [0:18:56] Jason Brown. [0:18:56] Yes. [0:18:57] Spencer Cutler. Yes. [0:18:58] Grayson Stone. Yes. [0:18:59] Barry Bomer. Yes. [0:19:00] And Ruth Pierce. [0:19:01] Yes. [0:19:02] Thank you. [0:19:03] Motion passes 7-0. [0:19:04] Thank you, John. [0:19:05] Thank you. [0:19:06] Thank you. Next item on the agenda is another action item. Are we quest to approve the use [0:19:16] of cooperating purchasing, cooperative purchasing agreement exceeding 200,000 for turf replacement [0:19:23] at the first federal playground? And we have Wendy Davis, our Parks and Rec Director. Welcome, [0:19:32] Good evening, Mayor and Council. [0:19:36] In February of 24, I made a request to have you reallocate the $369,000 from the Shop [0:19:46] Savings out of state and local fiscal recovery funds. [0:19:51] And we've been working on some solutions for repairs to both the turf and the splash pad [0:19:58] out of Sunway. [0:20:00] So tonight, I think I'm just going to take a minute to talk a little bit about what we're [0:20:06] trying to do here. [0:20:07] So, corporate purchasing agreements are used by government agencies to purchase equipment [0:20:14] and goods and services. [0:20:17] Those prices are arrived out through a competitive bidding process with the source well and the [0:20:25] There are some different organizations that arrive at prices that have been competitively [0:20:33] bid, which allows government agencies to use those prices and not go through a public [0:20:39] bid process. [0:20:41] In this case, we found that using a cooperative purchase agreement made a lot of sense to get [0:20:47] to the purchase for all the turf and the padding and everything that we need to replace that [0:20:52] playground surface. [0:20:54] So this evening, the way that in 2019 Council approved [0:21:00] the use of cooperative purchasing agreements [0:21:03] and authorized staff that are currently authorized [0:21:07] to sign agreements and do things [0:21:09] within the informal bid process. [0:21:12] So tonight I'm here to seek your approval [0:21:20] to use a cooperative purchasing agreement in this case [0:21:23] And because it exceeds $200,000, [0:21:26] you need to approve the bid as well. [0:21:28] So that's the request. [0:21:31] And I guess if there's any questions, [0:21:33] I don't know how clear that was, but. [0:21:37] So any questions for Wendy? [0:21:41] Chris, you look like you have a question. [0:21:43] I have a question. [0:21:44] It hasn't popped up yet. [0:21:45] Understanding that we've had some issues with, [0:21:48] I know this is the turf. [0:21:50] This is not the splash pad. [0:21:52] What is the, if it is installed [0:21:55] if we have issues, what recourse do we have? [0:21:59] On the turf? [0:22:00] On the turf. [0:22:01] Understanding, but we've had some issues in this park, in this area. [0:22:06] Especially with the splash pad. [0:22:07] The mayor is looking at the agreement. [0:22:09] I'm not sure that there's... [0:22:12] So I have learned a lot about turf. [0:22:16] The life expectancy of turf is like 10 to 15 years. [0:22:21] years. However, that playground gets heavily used. Everybody that's walked out there and [0:22:26] looked at it and said, oh my gosh. So there are things that we are doing this time that [0:22:34] should extend the life. So we're pulling everything up and where they're placing the seams, they're [0:22:41] changing the seam placement in an effort to make them less vulnerable for heavy use. [0:22:49] We're also using a, and now I'm going to tell them I can talk about carpet, but thicker [0:22:54] pile turf in the main areas, and then even thicker under the heavy use spaces, like under [0:23:04] the slides, under the swings, on the zip line. [0:23:08] So we're putting a different type of turf down in those areas that should strengthen [0:23:16] and reduce the wearer. [0:23:19] But I'm learning that maybe eight to 10 years [0:23:23] is about all we can expect. [0:23:29] Have you looked at this, Bruce, at all? [0:23:32] Yes, I see. [0:23:35] Do you want to come down for a sec? [0:23:36] You may want to look at what's on the screen. [0:23:39] So the only section I'm seeing on warranty [0:23:43] is on page three towards the bottom. [0:23:47] And it refers to equipment. [0:23:50] I don't know if you want to take a look at this, [0:23:53] or we can pull it up on the screen and send our packet [0:23:56] right there. [0:23:58] I just, we're not really buying equipment, [0:24:02] but it's referring to equipment. [0:24:04] So there's something in there that says a five-year, [0:24:26] but you're seeing it, but I don't know if it's referring, [0:24:31] I don't know what it's really referring to. [0:24:33] Like you're buying equipment, [0:24:35] we're not really buying equipment. [0:24:50] But do you speak into the mic? [0:24:52] All right, yes. [0:24:53] I believe that what it's referring to [0:24:54] in the event that we make a claim upon their product, which I think we can equate to the [0:24:59] equipment being the truth itself, in the event that they have to replace that. I believe that [0:25:05] this warranty paragraph is essentially saying that if we've had it for five or fewer years, [0:25:10] they provide the product and they will also pay the installation costs. If we've had it [0:25:15] for more than five years, they provide the replacement, but we have to pay for the installation [0:25:19] of the replacement product. [0:25:21] Okay. And that is in perpetuity or is that a 10-year max or does it say? [0:25:27] It doesn't say right off here. [0:25:29] Okay. [0:25:30] I apologize. [0:25:36] That's all right. [0:25:38] Better safe than sorry. [0:25:44] In his defense, we were looking more at the cooperative purchasing piece of it [0:25:48] to make sure it qualified, probably a little less than the terms. [0:25:54] I think the warranty language itself in this particular part of it would have to reference. [0:26:01] I apologize, I don't have that in front of me like that. [0:26:04] Does that answer your question? [0:26:05] It does, and I'm comfortable with the five years. [0:26:07] We seem to figure out that it's not working very quickly. [0:26:11] So I'm comfortable with the five years and the warranty. [0:26:16] OK, great. [0:26:17] Anybody else have a question? [0:26:21] I'll make a motion for this. [0:26:22] I move that we approve the use of a cooperative purchasing [0:26:25] agreement and accept a bid from Garrett Park and play [0:26:30] or $249,100 to replace the turf at the first federal playground. [0:26:36] Thank you, Sherry Volmer. [0:26:37] I'll second. [0:26:38] Thank you. [0:26:39] Motion by Chris Reed, seconded by Sherry Volmer [0:26:42] to approve the use of the cooperative purchasing agreement [0:26:45] and accept a bid from Garrett Hark and play for $249,100 [0:26:51] to replace the turf at the first federal playground. [0:26:55] Any further discussion? [0:26:57] Amy Roek, all vote please. [0:27:01] Craig Hawkins, Jason Brown, Spencer Cutler, Grayson Stone, [0:27:06] Mary Bomer, Ruth Pierce, and Chris Reed. [0:27:10] Yes. Thank you. Motion passes 7-0. Thank you, Bruce and Wendy. [0:27:15] Thank you. So next item on the agenda is a presentation. [0:27:23] A spring 2024 odor study update and we have Nathan, [0:27:29] Eric, and our environmental manager. Welcome, Nathan. [0:27:32] Thank you, Mayor. Good evening, City Council. [0:27:36] Appreciate the opportunity to be here today. [0:27:38] And yes, this is just a presentation. I'm not asking for any money. [0:27:42] But I do want to take this opportunity to ensure that, [0:27:49] just want to ensure that we keep the Council informed about where we're at with the orders, [0:27:57] because that sometimes can heat up pretty quickly. [0:28:01] And if we enter into the summer, we want to make sure you're informed so that you, if [0:28:06] you are questioned by anyone in the public, that you're able to provide some answers and [0:28:10] also recognize that if you don't have the answer, please send them to me because I do appreciate [0:28:16] the feedback. [0:28:17] And we really do need feedback from the public because we navigate this because we're collecting [0:28:23] data to help us make informed decisions. [0:28:27] But we don't always have everything. [0:28:29] So that's why it's good to get feedback from people within the community. [0:28:35] So and I will say that so that first picture was of the Otter Scrubber that we purchased [0:28:43] last year. [0:28:45] The second Otter Scrubber that was funded by Council, we received last week. [0:28:49] So we have both are able to start using them this summer. [0:28:55] So tonight I want to hit two points. [0:28:57] The first is our Grand View North area odor study, and then also the results from the use [0:29:04] of our hydrogen sulfide testing in the sewer. [0:29:08] So first thing, in your packet, there's more in depth, but I'm just going to kind of brush [0:29:14] through this. [0:29:15] In the North Grand View area, we found that the odor scrubber worked last year, but we're [0:29:20] trying to pinpoint where exactly it's going to be the best placement. [0:29:23] So we took some time over the winter, tried to identify any locations that we could possibly [0:29:28] test it, to give us multiple options. [0:29:32] We looked at seven locations, there were some limitations, we have to be close to power, [0:29:38] we don't want to close down the road, and we came up with two locations that actually fit [0:29:44] those needs, so Site G up on the top. [0:29:48] On this map you'll see the left side is Grandview Drive and then on the south is Pole Line, [0:29:53] just to kind of give you some reference. [0:29:55] So Site G up on the north there is right on the Canyon Rim and then also along Grandview [0:30:05] just south of Rock Creek Elementary, the city owns a property there that would be another [0:30:11] good place to test this. [0:30:13] So those are the two locations that are feasible, that we have found. [0:30:18] If anyone found something that would work, we're always open to test other places. [0:30:23] This plan has just kind of given us the options to kind of move it around this summer and see [0:30:27] what will work. [0:30:28] Now while we do that, we are also going to be collecting hydrogen sulfide readings at multiple [0:30:36] locations. [0:30:37] The last two years that I've been working on this, we've just been collecting at V147, [0:30:42] just on the very north there. That was the only place that we were collecting hydrogen sulfide. [0:30:46] So we've added four more sites in this area to give us a better picture of where our concentrations [0:30:52] are and what's going on. We also have put out that we're going to have a open house this Thursday [0:31:05] so the community, if anybody has questions or wants more information, to please come. It's [0:31:10] going to be here in the overflow room from four to six on Thursday. So, Council, if you're [0:31:15] welcome to come if you'd like. Okay, so now the next one I wanted to share was some of [0:31:23] the results we're having. So, last year, last fall, I'd like Council to know that we [0:31:28] had to purchase some, we were purchasing some hydrogen sulfide sensors that actually measure [0:31:34] the sulfide in the solution, which is kind of cutting edge as far as the ability to measure [0:31:42] it. Previously, we were just doing it in manholes, just the vapor, just the gas form. And so this [0:31:47] gave us a new tool that we could actually end point where the hydrogen sulfide was coming [0:31:52] out. It really helps us kind of follow it back to the point sources. And so we started [0:31:57] to use that and I wanted to share some of the results. And this gets really complicated [0:32:02] really quick as far as the table, so I'm going to try and talk through it and help you understand [0:32:08] what's going on. [0:32:09] But so this is one of our point sources that is working with us to try and figure out if [0:32:13] they were a problem. [0:32:14] Last year we had seen just downstream from them a lot of hydrogen sulfide gas in the sewer. [0:32:19] And so we went to them. [0:32:21] They allowed us to put one of these new sensors into their wet well and we put it in there. [0:32:28] And first of all, this first graph, what it's showing is showing their flow. [0:32:34] So you can see the dots are actually Sundays, so on Sundays they're off, but during the [0:32:40] week their flow increases and then on the weekend it goes down to near zero on Sunday. [0:32:47] So we put the sulfide sensor into the wet well and what it told us. [0:32:53] So if you look here on that second Sunday, you'll notice it kind of flattens out, or the [0:33:01] first and second, well, the second and third Sunday on that graph, you'll see it kind of [0:33:06] plateaus. [0:33:07] So the sensor actually maxes out at five milligrams per liter. [0:33:12] So what we were seeing is on those Sundays it was actually maxing out our meter. [0:33:16] We didn't, it was going higher than that. [0:33:19] We shared the data with the industry and they were great because it really helped them start [0:33:25] to see, okay, we got a problem. [0:33:27] And what it was really telling us is that that wet well, over the weekend, the waste was [0:33:33] sitting in there and it was going anoxic or septic, which creates hydrazosulfide and stinks. [0:33:42] And so they quickly asked if we could meet with them and they proposed some ideas and our [0:33:47] consultant has some ideas and so what we came up with was they immediately were [0:33:51] going to start putting in chlorine and chlorine tablets like pool tablets to try [0:33:55] and kill the bacteria the bugs that were in there that were producing the [0:34:00] hydrogen sulfide and so you'll see about in the middle of the the graph there that [0:34:05] that Sunday we didn't have that plateau it actually dropped off they had thrown [0:34:10] some hydrogen or some chlorine into it and then on Monday they actually started [0:34:14] to dose it better. [0:34:16] And so we saw an immediate response, lowered it pretty consistently. [0:34:21] We are still seeing some increase on Sundays. [0:34:27] We believe that better than chlorine tablets would be to aerate. [0:34:32] So actually put oxygen into it. [0:34:34] And that way, the bugs would start eating the oxygen [0:34:38] before they ate the sulfate and produced hydrogen sulfide. [0:34:41] So this was the blue line was the hydrogen sulfide sensor. [0:34:46] To calculate actually how much hydrogen sulfide is in there, [0:34:49] you have to know the pH. [0:34:50] So that's another parameter we're collecting. [0:34:53] And this shows the pH. [0:34:55] And when you take those two and enter them to an equation, [0:34:58] it actually shows you how much hydrogen sulfide was [0:35:00] in that wet well. [0:35:03] And so what you can see is towards the middle [0:35:06] when that change was made, we saw a reduction. [0:35:09] And the reason I wanted to share this with you tonight [0:35:11] was because we're seeing some really good results. [0:35:14] And for every point source we can find, [0:35:16] and that they'll work with us, we can get this figured out, [0:35:19] and find a long-term solution. [0:35:21] It eliminates one more source of hydrogen sulfide in our system. [0:35:24] And so this is exciting. [0:35:26] I'm excited about it. [0:35:27] It's cool to have the tools to be able to accomplish [0:35:30] this kind of work. [0:35:30] So I appreciate Council for funding that. [0:35:33] And there's any questions. [0:35:36] Any questions for Nathan? [0:35:38] I'm excited you get excited about this. [0:35:43] It's pretty exciting, Chris Reed. [0:35:47] We had, I guess, input this last summer about the noise from the scrubbers. [0:35:57] Have we done anything to address that? Because those will be in residential areas, [0:36:02] those ant hole covers and just wanting to be good neighbors, [0:36:07] make sure that we're not keeping people up or whatever it might be. [0:36:11] Yes, so we purchased a decibel meter and we've measured it, you know, we've checked it. [0:36:20] It's really not that high. [0:36:22] Last summer, we did spend, there were two weeks that we used a generator to run one of them. [0:36:27] So that definitely was a lot more noisy. [0:36:31] The scrubber itself, it's not much more than traffic as far as the noise. [0:36:38] And it kind of depends on the location, but I mean, we will definitely be sensitive to if there is a neighbor that has a problem with the noise, you know, we can adjust where it's at, we'll try and, you know, be a good neighbor. [0:36:50] I think the fan that's on the one right now is, it's not the full size, so it shouldn't be as noisy. [0:36:59] And even the full-size fan that would be on the permanent one, [0:37:02] once it's enclosed, you know, once it's in a structure [0:37:06] that could help kind of muffle some of that noise, [0:37:08] it shouldn't be noticeable. [0:37:11] Perfect. Thank you. [0:37:12] Thank you. Anybody else? [0:37:15] Okay. Great. That was great news. [0:37:17] Thank you. [0:37:19] Okay. Next item on the agenda is a presentation. [0:37:27] It's a presentation of the finances of the City of Twin Falls [0:37:32] For the second quarter of fiscal year 2324, [0:37:35] this presentation will be an overview [0:37:37] of the tax supported funds and the three major [0:37:40] enterprise funds, water, wastewater, and sanitation. [0:37:43] We have our CFO, Brianna Howard, welcome Brianna. [0:37:48] Welcome back. [0:37:49] Thank you. [0:37:50] Good evening, Mayor and Council. [0:37:51] Out of the real exciting stuff, right? [0:37:53] I was thinking, man, I have to follow up that. [0:37:55] That was fascinating. [0:37:57] I actually understood it too. [0:37:58] Why do I have to sign? [0:38:01] How do I sign in? [0:38:03] to sit the X. [0:38:04] Oh, here we go. [0:38:17] So this is going to be the finance update for the second quarter [0:38:20] of fiscal year 2024. [0:38:22] I'm going to talk about the tax-supported funds, [0:38:25] the big picture as a whole, and then some of our enterprise [0:38:28] funds, water, wastewater, and sanitation. [0:38:33] So this is our budget in a snapshot. [0:38:35] Oh, big smiles. [0:38:36] You guys are excited for this. [0:38:38] Thanks. [0:38:39] This is our budget in a snapshot. [0:38:40] We have $104 million that we spend annually, [0:38:44] that we have budgeted to spend, and this [0:38:46] is showing where it gets broken up into. [0:38:48] 42% of our budget is non-tax-supported funds, [0:38:52] which are like water, wastewater, and sanitation. [0:38:56] 58% of our budget comes from tax-supported funds. [0:38:59] And you can see the funds come to our dedicated [0:39:03] to the resources on the side of the right. [0:39:05] So 13% of our entire budget is for wastewater. [0:39:09] 16% is for water. [0:39:11] And our general fund, which is fire, police, parks, [0:39:14] and recreation, those kind of things take up 34% of our budget. [0:39:22] Tax-supported funds, this is anything, [0:39:24] this is anything that is supported by property taxes. [0:39:27] So almost half of our budget, $29 million, [0:39:30] comes from property taxes. [0:39:32] On the left, you can see the things [0:39:34] that make up the rest of our tax-supported funds. [0:39:37] We at State Shared Revenue have 6.6 million. [0:39:40] We have reserves that are funding this year, 6.4 million, [0:39:44] transfers from other funds, this is just the tax-supported funds. [0:39:47] So anything else that comes in from funds such as water or water and wastewater is 4.2 million. [0:39:54] We have dedicated street money of 4.2 million and franchise fees of 2 million. [0:40:00] The rest, anything else that is not included in those categories are typically around $1 million or less are in the other category. [0:40:07] That would be like permits of 1.2 million and grants of 1.65 million that are in the other. [0:40:14] The resources, these resources that go to the funds, are 60% almost, 59% that go to the general fund. [0:40:22] I thought I talked a little bit about the property tax history, so you can kind of see where it's come from. [0:40:31] In 2021, we had almost 24 million dollars of property taxes, and we've incrementally gone up since 2021 to the 29.5 million dollars. [0:40:41] We've had a significant boom in our construction industry, so we have seen significant increases [0:40:46] in our property taxes. [0:40:48] He may be aware, remember, that property taxes increase for the most part by a 3% increase [0:40:54] that you as council can elect to take, as well as new construction. [0:40:58] So we have seen huge increases, huge strides the last few years in our property tax funds. [0:41:07] Year to date, we've received $17.4 million. [0:41:11] taxes are not received pro-rata or equally. We would get two checks each year, mainly, [0:41:17] usually in January, February, and then around July and August timeframe. And so we save our funds. [0:41:22] We invest our funds to take care of everything throughout the rest of the year and to even out [0:41:26] the costs. 2021 had an odd 11 million that was received and that was because we opted into Governor [0:41:33] Little's plan of passing off property tax relief to individual taxpayers. We ended up receiving that [0:41:40] in the form of a grant versus property tax funds in 21. [0:41:44] It's hard to believe that was four years ago. [0:41:47] It's gone fast. [0:41:50] Other parts of our major revenues is highway money. [0:41:53] This is anytime you're traveling. [0:41:55] So it's a fuels, it's taxes on fuel, and this is not proretta [0:41:59] because it depends on when you're actually driving. [0:42:02] State revenue sharing is sales tax and liquor licenses [0:42:06] that are received quarterly. [0:42:09] Franchise fees are a smaller piece of our budget, [0:42:11] but we've actually received significantly more than what we had budgeted because Idaho [0:42:16] Power and Intermountain Gas have pushed out pretty large increases, about 25%. [0:42:21] The city receives 3% of those franchise fees off of their gross revenues. [0:42:33] State revenue sharing, I thought I'd share a few of the last four years of what we received [0:42:36] because this is a big part of our budget conversations. [0:42:40] What are we going to budget in the future? [0:42:42] As you're aware, again, we tend to budget conservatively because we don't want to over-expend ourselves [0:42:48] and end up not having enough money in the future. [0:42:51] State revenue sharing has been a pretty big topic the last few years since COVID. [0:42:56] We have seen significant increases in our state revenue sharing. [0:42:59] As you can see in 2021, we had 2.69 million and we've jumped over the last four years [0:43:05] of the 3.3 million that we've received this year and last year. [0:43:10] The interesting part of that is it almost appears that we've flatlined. [0:43:15] So the question is, is how much more are we going to get from state revenue sharing? [0:43:20] Inflation rises, people have to spend more to get the same amount as that they used to have, [0:43:24] but at the same time people start to pull back a little bit as well. [0:43:28] I would venture to guess that we're probably starting to see that plateau, [0:43:32] that we're not going to get the significant income amounts that we have had in the past. [0:43:39] Franchise fees on the right is cable. This is a little orange one. We don't receive very much in cable. [0:43:46] And we have to, we have continuously see it going down. [0:43:52] But on the other hand, the electric, [0:43:54] that started off in 761,000 in 2021, [0:43:58] and it jumped to almost $965,000 this last year, [0:44:03] or currently here to date. [0:44:04] And then on the gas side, it's 310,000 in 2021, [0:44:08] up to the 521,000. [0:44:10] It's interesting to note that intermountain gas [0:44:13] has actually said that they are decreasing their rates [0:44:15] close to 20%. So I think it's closer to 25, but between that 20 and 25%. So going forward, [0:44:22] we're going to see a little bit less in our revenue coming from Intermountain Gas, but [0:44:26] I have not seen the same thing from Idaho Power. Building permit revenues, that's a big indicator [0:44:35] of our economy here in the City of Twin Falls. So I have a next few slides to talk about the [0:44:40] building permit revenues. We, as you can see in 2021, sky rocketed surpassed expectations. [0:44:47] all know, we went crazy huge amounts in building permit revenues. We had budgeted 1.14 million [0:44:53] and at this point in time second quarter we were at just over a million dollars. Currently [0:44:59] we have budgeted 1.14 million and we have received 834,000. That was an anomaly and that [0:45:06] was because we received large building permit revenue from North Canyon Medical Center and [0:45:10] the housing company that were unanticipated. This slide shows the graph where we were from [0:45:18] 2007 clear to 2024 year to date. The rest of the numbers were annual numbers. To put this into [0:45:25] perspective fiscal year 21 was the highest year that was right after covid right during covid when [0:45:31] we saw the huge jump. We had issued 486 single family permits for the entire year. Last year to [0:45:38] date we had only had 38 single family permits and this year we have 134. So we have some more than [0:45:46] we had last year so it looks like we're increasing back up but who knows what [0:45:52] it's going to be in the future. On the expenditure side personnel is the [0:45:59] largest percent of our budget it's about 55% of our total budget and you can see [0:46:04] we've come in at 49.4 percent but before you get excited we actually had a [0:46:09] fifteen hundred dollar extra payment to in city employees in December that I [0:46:14] believe has inflated that number so although it looks great we still have [0:46:18] have about 20 open positions across the city, so that's not bad, it's not terrible. [0:46:23] I think that's like 6% of the positions open, but we are still under budget. [0:46:29] We typically budget 100% of the staff that we want to fund, because we are ideally wanting [0:46:35] to fill those positions, so if you don't budget them, you can't fill them. [0:46:39] So we budget 100% of our payroll. [0:46:43] M&O is pretty close in the tax-supported funds. [0:46:46] We'll see a much bigger difference when we get to the enterprise funds where they don't [0:46:49] spend as much yet, but M&O is pretty close to 50%. Capital improvements we have [0:46:55] budgeted at $12.4 million and a few things that are included in there are [0:46:59] some street stuff that we have not even started, chip seal of $1.9 million. We [0:47:05] have three projects of $720,000 and three construction on 11th Avenue in [0:47:09] Addison for $605,000. Neither of those, either three of those that have been [0:47:14] started. We have fire station roof budgeted of 300,000 and the certificate of [0:47:21] participation payment of 650,000. That is the payment for fire station 2 that we [0:47:27] will pay in September. We have the SSLF RF state and local fiscal recovery funds [0:47:35] for Idaho housing of a 0.7 million dollars that is expended and budgeted in [0:47:40] here. Transit we budgeted 1.3 million in our capital fund. We've spent about 600 [0:47:46] 50,000 to date. Across the city, we have about $1.5 million in auto expenditures, but we've [0:47:53] only spent about 560,000. One of the other items that we have expended but didn't budget [0:48:00] here is fire station number three. We've expended about $2.4 million. We did not budget for Fire [0:48:06] Station 3 because at the time of their budget creation process, we were still ambivalent [0:48:11] on how we were going to fund it, where we're going to pay for it out of reserves, where [0:48:14] we're going to do COPs for both stations, et cetera, [0:48:17] so they were not budgeted. [0:48:21] Transfers are at 28%. [0:48:23] This one is not 50% equally because we have a 2.4 million [0:48:27] for Durkeys and Sichon Falls that we do not transfer [0:48:30] until November-ish time frame. [0:48:35] Any questions on tax-supported funds? [0:48:42] So the next are the enterprise funds. [0:48:44] Enterprise funds are like a business [0:48:46] without a profit motive. [0:48:48] They're biggest three are water, wastewater, and sanitation. [0:48:53] On the water side, we typically budget about $4 million [0:48:56] for water revenue. [0:48:57] This is for users paying specific fees for this service. [0:49:01] And this shows what we had in 2021 up to what we have now. [0:49:06] You can see a slight little drop from 2023 of $11.2 million [0:49:11] down to $11 million even, almost in 2024. [0:49:16] There's a few reasons for this. [0:49:17] We're starting to see a tapering off of new accounts. [0:49:20] houses typically take one to two years to finish after permitting and since we started [0:49:24] to see the decrease in permits, we know that we're going to start seeing decrease in, or [0:49:28] we're going to start seeing the water drop off decrease. [0:49:32] Looking at usage, we are continuing a downward trend on what we use. [0:49:36] In 21, our max gallons per day was 25 million, which decreased to 23.7 and 22. [0:49:43] And then in 23, we decreased to 23.3 million, and that's calculated as the maximum day of [0:49:49] usage in July. Part of this is because a lot of subdivisions, anything that is created [0:49:56] after 2006, is on the city's PI system. So we don't use the tank for those. Talking to [0:50:05] Rob Bulling, our water superintendent, he believes the demographics are changing. People, not [0:50:10] everyone wants a huge grain yard anymore and then he thinks that this trend will continue [0:50:15] to go downwards. On the expenditure side, water personnel is 51.5% expended, same thing with the [0:50:25] $1,500 extra payment in December. It's inflating that number a little bit. It is not typical for [0:50:32] water to spend 50% of their M&O, 50% of the year, because they spend most of that in the summer months [0:50:38] when they're using water to pump. On the capital side, the largest budgeted item is South Wall [0:50:43] number 5 for 3 million Hillcrest drainage improvements for 678,000 and a [0:50:49] mainline replacement over 1.5 and none of these have been significantly [0:50:53] started yet which is why we are only 1.4 million expended. On the debt side we [0:50:59] have not made we make a payment in September and we only have one bond left [0:51:03] in 2017 the 2017 bond we have an $800,000 payment left so we are almost [0:51:10] step-free in our water fund. Waste water last four years is about 4.6 to [0:51:20] almost five million dollars the last few years. In fiscal year 22 we had a high [0:51:25] industrial usage which is why you see the blip up here. I asked Nathan, I guess this [0:51:34] isn't that interesting, I asked Nathan what he was seeing with industrial usage [0:51:40] and why it went down and he said Chobani has made significant improvements in [0:51:44] in their usage in which you want to be such a big player in our wastewater treatment plant, [0:51:49] we see that come across as well. [0:51:55] On the M&O side in wastewater, we contract out most of our services, so our personnel, [0:52:01] so it's not the biggest piece of our budget. [0:52:04] The prices in M&O consistently are a battle with increases in chemicals through the Jacobs [0:52:10] contract and personnel. [0:52:14] We have budget 4.4 million of M&O for wastewater. [0:52:18] the capital, 1.5 million is budgeted for the primary and secondary clarifier and [0:52:23] 500,000 for the sludge pad. We have 28 million dollars left in debt in revenue [0:52:31] bonds and the wastewater fund. Sanitation is much more consistent than water and [0:52:40] wastewater and smaller. We get about two million dollars in our sanitation fund [0:52:43] the last few years. We have no personnel and there's no capital expenditures so [0:52:50] So just some M&O and some transfers. [0:52:55] That's it on our enterprise funds. [0:52:56] Any questions for enterprise? [0:53:01] So another thing I like to do is to talk about the current event a little bit and see what [0:53:05] we're seeing in the nation as well as what we're seeing here locally and have a few things [0:53:09] that I feel fit in here. [0:53:13] We all know inflation persists. [0:53:16] It's not going down to the extent that the feds wanted to go down and so they're not decreasing [0:53:20] rates like they want to decrease. [0:53:22] For PCE, this graph shows how it's gone down, then gone up, and it's gone down, and gone [0:53:27] up, and it continuously goes up. [0:53:30] For PCI, it excludes the volatile food and energy prices. [0:53:34] There's a slower growth in consumer spending, exports in government spending, however this [0:53:39] was partially offset by the increase in investment in both residential and non-residential sectors [0:53:43] for services. [0:53:44] The CPI to put this in perspective was the latest one was $3.45, and the NCI, which is [0:53:50] the Municipal Cost Index, that's what we purchase as a government, was 2.26%. [0:54:03] I like to follow this pretty closely because if we can get rates to go down, if the feds [0:54:07] will decrease rates, it helps everything. [0:54:11] Hopefully, inflation's at a spot where it should be, and if the rates are decreased, that [0:54:15] means people can buy more than the housing industry, completely changes, et cetera. [0:54:20] It's been fascinating to watch the articles that come on the Fed's decreasing rates and [0:54:25] the volatility of that. [0:54:26] How many increases? How many decreases are we going to have? Previous market expectations [0:54:31] were that there would be six Fed rate cuts by the end of 24. We're all aware that has [0:54:35] not happened and now due to higher inflation rates they're anticipating only two 51% expect [0:54:41] that initial rate easing won't come until July I would say if that. Powell has said it [0:54:48] is too early for the Federal Reserve to consider rate cuts because inflation hasn't been low [0:54:52] enough for long enough. There's an article in April that says Goldman does expect inflation [0:54:57] to continue to fall, estimating that will be around 2.5% by the end of the year, however [0:55:02] the economy won't hit the 2% number the Fed is eyeing until 2025. Across Wall Street, [0:55:07] analysts forecast lingering inflation with JP Morgan quoting a February report that is [0:55:12] expecting it to hover around 3% all year. This directly affects not only our spending, but [0:55:17] the money that we hold. So as I indicated before, we invest in bonds, we use a very safe secure [0:55:23] bonds mortgage-backed securities and I'm typically making just over 5% right now. [0:55:28] And hypersamers projecting long-term rates dipping below the 4%. So we'll [0:55:33] start to see less on investment earnings as rates continue. So this was a [0:55:41] fascinating article from the Wall Street Journal that I pulled to put into [0:55:45] perspective. This is a typical grocery cart in 2019. It's $100. So you can see the [0:55:52] the pieces that are here, what you could have bought in 2019, gallon of milk for $2.73, [0:55:58] a dozen of eggs for $2.36. Then what they've done is they've put that into perspective with [0:56:06] the 2024 increase. It's a $36 increase and a $100 grocery cart. You can see the individual [0:56:12] prices. What that does is it makes this same grocery cart $136 more just a few years later [0:56:22] To buy that same grocery cart, you'd have to take out all of those items. [0:56:28] It's a significant factor that is affecting our purchasing power across the city, as well [0:56:33] as what our employees can buy. [0:56:39] The public sector faces high debt levels, stressed budgets, and wide-ranging priorities. [0:56:44] Government officials have been getting the following message from taxpayers. [0:56:47] Do more with the same, or less, be more efficient. [0:56:52] Stretch every dollar and justify every dollar that you spend. [0:56:57] So what are we doing at the city? [0:56:59] We're updating our strategic plan. [0:57:01] We're trying to figure out what is important to us. [0:57:03] We continue to work on priority-based budgeting. [0:57:06] What can we do to analyze how can we figure out [0:57:09] what things cost and what we need to spend our money on? [0:57:12] And also we started a fleet plan in January of 2023. [0:57:16] We've made huge strides in getting people [0:57:18] across the city, department-wide, [0:57:20] to figure out what is necessary in our city. [0:57:24] What do we need to do? [0:57:25] what do we need to spend our funds on? [0:57:27] What's dying, what needs to be replaced, [0:57:29] and strategically analyzing those dollars [0:57:31] so that we can come out better, [0:57:33] we can be more efficient. [0:57:35] I thought this was fascinating. [0:57:36] This is something we started, like I said, [0:57:38] in early last year, and there's an article [0:57:41] from American City and County [0:57:43] that talks about a fleet plan just now. [0:57:46] A good first step to improve fleet maintenance [0:57:48] and operations is to put better information [0:57:50] in the hands of senior experience to vehicle maintainers. [0:57:53] The high quality fleet information [0:57:55] will enable the senior managers to provide better tools and support for the junior maintainers [0:57:59] who have their hands on these vehicles. Leveraging such data to successfully shift from preventative [0:58:05] to predictive maintenance is the only way to truly optimize resources and achieve an ROA. [0:58:10] I thought that was fascinating because this is something that we have already started. [0:58:14] We're smack in the middle of doing it trying to figure out how we can better use our resources. [0:58:19] Briefly, housing due to limited inventory of existing homes were currently seeing a rise [0:58:27] in single-family and multifamily permits, which is explained by our 134 permits that we [0:58:32] have compared to last year. [0:58:35] But it's tempered by high mortgage rates, increasing about 7% currently. [0:58:41] Oil prices are at their highest points in October. [0:58:44] In $90 a barrel, this is due to a few things, drone attacks in Russia, unrest in the Middle [0:58:49] East, strong consumer demand. [0:58:51] expensive fuel trickles into prices for other goods and services all across the [0:58:56] city. This was an article that I thought was interesting as we're going through our [0:59:02] budget season compensation adjustments. What are other people doing? What are [0:59:05] other cities doing? Market research studies show CFOs plans for compensation [0:59:09] adjustments. 13% of their planning to increase compensation by more than 10%. [0:59:14] 58% planned increase between 4 and 9 with the remainder at a nominal [0:59:20] increased. As opposed to last year, 70% had planned between 4% and 9%. This is [0:59:32] because reduced labor rate increases are being cited to various reasons. Tighter [0:59:36] labor market, we know that. Previous pay raises were used to help lure in and [0:59:41] retain employees. And companies are prioritizing efficiency now and leanness [0:59:45] in an effort to decrease labor expenses. So that's all I have. Any questions, [0:59:51] comments? Anything? Thank you, Marana. Any questions, Chris Reed? No? [1:00:00] You're good. Just thank you. Yep. That was a really good presentation. It's good. I wish the numbers look better. I mean, the city's numbers look better [1:00:09] nationally, we don't we're not [1:00:11] The interesting thing is to see the [1:00:14] investment income and I mean that's typical of what I'm seeing with clients [1:00:20] That's what we're seeing is you know anybody who's projecting there obviously we're gonna project low and we did a good job of projecting low [1:00:27] And we will continue to project strategically because we cannot factor in an inflationary adjustment into investment earnings [1:00:36] I mean we probably are going to continue to have good investment earnings for at least the next two to three years because [1:00:42] The city purchases typically into two-year investment returns, but we don't know [1:00:47] I mean if if the feds drop rates we're gonna get less and we don't want to build a budget around [1:00:52] Which I am playing on. [1:00:55] Yeah, absolutely. [1:00:56] Answer. [1:00:57] Yeah, you mentioned the core price index and the simple price index. [1:01:01] Do you happen to know off the top of your head with the municipal? [1:01:04] I think it's the cost index is? [1:01:06] Oh, I just, I can get it for you. [1:01:08] I have it on my computer. [1:01:10] Okay. [1:01:11] I do MCS. [1:01:12] 2.26%. [1:01:13] Thank you. [1:01:14] Perfect. [1:01:15] Thank you. [1:01:16] I typically look at MCA a lot more religiously. [1:01:18] Anybody else? [1:01:28] Hey, thank you. [1:01:30] Brianna? [1:01:33] Hey, next item on the agenda is the time [1:01:35] for general public input, if there's anybody out in the audience [1:01:41] that wishes to address city council on an issue [1:01:43] that was not on today's agenda or is not a personnel-related issue, [1:01:49] you may come forward. [1:01:51] Dean, no one advisory board reports. [1:01:58] Craig. [1:01:59] Mayor, I just want to recognize Travis for completing the ICMA [1:02:06] We have a credential process, where to go Travis. [1:02:10] Thank you. [1:02:12] Anybody else have anything? [1:02:16] Anything from the city manager's office? [1:02:19] Not tonight. [1:02:20] Are we having a meeting next week? [1:02:23] We are. [1:02:23] OK, quick. [1:02:25] OK, Doug. [1:02:27] OK. [1:02:28] That is it. [1:02:29] We have no executive sessions. [1:02:31] So thank you, everyone, our meeting's adjourned.