Oversight Archive: City Council meeting, 2024-06-03, recording 1 (started 16:56) Machine transcript (faster-whisper base.en), not checked word for word; the Pledge of Allegiance is shown in its standard wording. The recording is the record. Times are time into the recording. Passages with private details are muted in the audio and marked here. The audio on the page below was re-encoded by software from the video the agency posted. Check any passage against that audio before relying on it. Page: https://oversightarchive.org/twin-falls-id/meetings/2024-06-03/ [0:04:08] Good evening, ladies and gentlemen, and welcome to the June 3rd, 2024 City Council meeting. I want to confirm we have a quorum [0:04:16] we have six members present in chambers and [0:04:20] Councilman Stone is [0:04:22] excused first item on the agenda is the Pledge of Allegiance if you wish to join me, please rise. Thank you [0:04:49] Next on the agenda. I have a proclamation and this is [0:04:53] is a proclamation for support Local Gems Day, June 7th, 2024, [0:05:01] whereas US Senator Jim Rish, a member of the US Senate Small [0:05:04] Business and Entrepreneurship Committee, [0:05:07] continually works to support and promote small businesses [0:05:12] in Idaho and the nation, whereas in partnership [0:05:16] with the Idaho Department of Commerce, Senator Rish [0:05:18] launch support local gyms in spring 2020 as a way to encourage Idahoans to support small [0:05:25] businesses during the early days of the pandemic. [0:05:29] Whereas small businesses are the backbone of Idaho's economy and now in its fifth year, [0:05:35] the support local gyms initiative continues as a way to engage with Idaho's small business [0:05:41] community and celebrates the entrepreneurs and establishments that make Idaho special. [0:05:48] as the 2024 support local gems initiative will take place on Friday, June 7th, therefore [0:05:56] I, Ruth Pierce, Mayor of the City of Twin Falls do hereby proclaim the 7th day of June as support [0:06:03] local gems day. And I think we have Mike Matthews from Senator Rish's office to accept. [0:06:36] I just want to thank Mayor Ruth Pierce and all of the City Council for doing this proclamation. [0:06:43] This is a project that Senator Rish is very dear to his heart. [0:06:47] He loves to support Idaho, and he loves to support Idaho's small businesses, and he has [0:06:54] done that throughout his whole political career and throughout his whole life, and he wanted [0:07:00] to continue doing that as a U.S. Senator for Idaho, and so thank you so much for the opportunity [0:07:06] of doing this and proclaiming June 7th as support local gyms day and remember on June 7th go [0:07:15] out and support your local gym and spend some money. [0:07:21] Yes, spend some money, help them out and support them. [0:07:24] So with that thank you very much, Mayor. [0:07:26] Thank you City Council members. [0:07:28] We appreciate it greatly. [0:07:30] Thank you. [0:07:31] Thank you, Mike. [0:07:33] Okay. [0:07:34] Next on the agenda is the consent calendar. [0:07:37] Council wishes. [0:07:38] Yes. [0:07:42] I'd like to move that we approve the consent calendar written. [0:07:45] Thank you to have a second. [0:07:47] Second. [0:07:48] Thank you motion by Craig Hawkins second by Chris Reed [0:07:52] to approve the consent calendar as written. [0:07:56] Amy Roll call vote please. [0:07:58] Poor Morgan. [0:07:59] Sorry. [0:08:00] I'll work on it. [0:08:04] Ruth Pierce. [0:08:05] Yes. [0:08:06] Chris Reed. [0:08:07] Yes. [0:08:07] Craig Hawkins. [0:08:08] Yes. [0:08:09] Jason Brown. [0:08:10] Yes. [0:08:11] Spencer Cutler. [0:08:11] Yes. [0:08:12] Jerry Volmer. [0:08:13] Yes. [0:08:14] Thank you. Motion passes six to zero. [0:08:18] Hey, under items of consideration, our first item is an action item. [0:08:22] Request to appoint Jennifer Colvin and we appoint Doug McAlindon and JJ [0:08:27] bride to the Urban Renewal Agency Board of Commissioners. [0:08:31] And we have you are a executive director, Sean Barricker. Welcome, Sean. [0:08:36] Thank you, Mayor and Council. [0:08:38] The Urban Renewal Agency has a total of seven commissioners. [0:08:42] And as of the end of June, Andy Ho-Wheeler will complete his two, three-year terms on the board. [0:08:47] So, due to this, they can see the agency sent out a call for candidates, and we had four applications. [0:08:53] A selection committee comprised of the mayor, myself and agency chair Rudy Ashinbrenner interviewed all four of those applicants. [0:09:02] And we are recommending that Jennifer Colvin be appointed to the agency board. [0:09:08] Jennifer is here tonight. [0:09:09] I told her there would be an extensive quiz. [0:09:10] But I'll give you the snapshot. [0:09:13] So Jennifer owns O'Dunkins downtown and is a financial advisor with the 11th Bank, certainly [0:09:20] has a vested interest in the community. [0:09:23] Very excited to hear about some of the projects we have on the horizon for the urban renewal [0:09:28] agency. [0:09:29] And as I said, she'd be happy to answer any questions you have following this. [0:09:34] Also Dave Mackeland and NJ McBride were appointed in July of 2021 to their first three-year [0:09:40] term. Those both end the end of June and both are active contributing members and are [0:09:46] interested in continuing to serve on the board for a second three-year term. So we have these [0:09:50] appointments before this evening and if they are reappointed those terms would begin on July 1st [0:09:55] and end June 30th of 2027. One item for the motion to consider would be that if you concur [0:10:05] that the staff recommends that the council confirm the mayor's recommendation to appoint [0:10:10] Jennifer Colvin, and to reappoint Dave McElan and JJ McBride, [0:10:14] including a waiver of the city residency requirement [0:10:18] for JJ McBride, he lives outside of the city limits. [0:10:22] And with that, I would stand for any questions. [0:10:24] Also, Dave McElan is here this evening too, [0:10:26] so you can grill them. [0:10:27] Grill him as well. [0:10:29] Thank you, Sean. [0:10:30] Any questions for Sean or Jennifer or Dave? [0:10:35] OK, I'd entertain a motion. [0:10:38] Mayor, I'll make a motion. [0:10:39] Thank you, Spencer. [0:10:40] So I move that we appoint Jennifer Colvin and reappoint Dave McAlindon and J.J. McBride [0:10:46] to the Urbary Newell Agency, Board of Commissioners, and that we waive the residency requirement [0:10:51] for J.J. McBride. [0:10:52] Thank you. [0:10:53] Jason Brown? [0:10:54] Second. [0:10:55] Thank you. [0:10:56] Motion by Spencer Cutler, seconded by Jason Brown to appoint Jennifer Colvin and reappoint [0:11:02] Dave McAlindon and J.J. McBride to the U.R.A. Board of Commissioners and Wave J.J. McBride's [0:11:10] residency requirements. [0:11:12] Any further discussion? [0:11:15] Morgan Roekall vote please. [0:11:19] Chris Reed? [0:11:20] Yes. [0:11:21] Craig Hawkins? [0:11:22] Yes. [0:11:23] Jason Brown? [0:11:24] Yes. [0:11:24] And Sir Cutler? [0:11:25] Yes. [0:11:26] Chair Yevonmer? [0:11:27] Yes. [0:11:28] Ruth Pierce? [0:11:29] Yes. [0:11:30] Thank you. [0:11:31] Motion passes six to zero. [0:11:32] Thank you, Sean. [0:11:33] And welcome. [0:11:35] Okay. [0:11:36] Next item is an action item, a request to approve the contract with BS&A software for [0:11:42] a total cost of 348,750 and to authorize the use of 58,750 of contingency funds. [0:11:51] We have our CFO Brianna Howard. [0:11:53] Welcome, Brianna. [0:11:54] Good evening, Mayor and Council. [0:11:57] So last year I presented to this Council a couple of new spots as well on the significant [0:12:03] need for an outdated and archaic software that we have had. [0:12:07] So after going through the large process of submitting some requests for proposals, [0:12:12] et cetera, we have narrowed down on BS and A. But before that, I wanted to share a couple [0:12:18] of numbers with you. [0:12:20] So we started with Springbrook. [0:12:21] That was our software in 2002. [0:12:25] Since then, our budget has grown from 27 million in 2002 to 2003 to the current 104 [0:12:32] million in this latest fiscal year. [0:12:34] Our property taxes budget has increased from $7.3 million to $29 million. [0:12:42] Our payroll expenses have increased from $13.9 million to $38 million in the last 20 years. [0:12:49] Currently, we have significant limitations in our software that we have with Springbrook. [0:12:54] It's outdated technologies that are hunky, patchwork, and sequel based. [0:12:58] If any of you ever tried to submit code and sequel, it's difficult. [0:13:03] can do it, and we have an amazing team that can get there, but it's hard. [0:13:08] It's fragmented systems. [0:13:09] We've got modules that don't talk well together. [0:13:12] Pulling data is extensive. [0:13:14] We have operational inefficiencies, the most complex payroll system in the state. [0:13:19] We have confirmed this with our RFP process and how difficult it is to accommodate every [0:13:24] single thing that we would like in our payroll system. [0:13:27] In fact, there are quite a few companies that could not even submit a proposal because [0:13:31] of our payroll system. [0:13:34] accessibility issues. We don't have real-time report manipulation. In this day and age where [0:13:39] everything is real-time, when we want to try to pull things to analyze data and use that [0:13:44] data, it's very cumbersome to pull stuff from our software. So we have a need for modernization. [0:13:49] We've got a need for innovative and integrated ERP system. Our objectives with this RFP, with [0:13:55] this software, is to integrate, modernize, gain efficiency, data visibility, gain user [0:14:01] friendliness and cost effectiveness. [0:14:05] Council already allocated $290,000 in this current year's budget for an ERP implementation. [0:14:12] We did an extensive RFP process that included department heads and users and IT specialists. [0:14:18] RFP, I'm sorry, if you don't know, is a request for proposals for a lot of different companies. [0:14:24] We publicized it, we put it on our website, we did a lot of extensive work with the RFP [0:14:28] process. [0:14:30] There's a comprehensive needs assessment to identify pain points and desired functionalities. [0:14:35] We ultimately chose BSNA software because of its functionality, scalability, user-friendliness, [0:14:42] customer support, and cost effectiveness. [0:14:44] It was amazing as we started going through some of these, the last few that we liked that [0:14:50] were within our cost estimate that gave us desired outcomes, et cetera, when we started [0:14:56] calling around to different cities in the state of Idaho [0:14:59] at the significantly different feedback [0:15:03] that we got from one vendor versus another. [0:15:07] Customer service was huge for us. [0:15:10] The contract that I have updated has been reviewed [0:15:14] by our attorney, and the total project cost is $348,750. [0:15:19] The allocation of $290,000 has already been budgeted, [0:15:22] and we are asking for $58,750 of contingency funds [0:15:27] to cover some of the overlap in our annual software costs [0:15:31] while they are running simultaneously. [0:15:33] The project timeline is about 12 to 18 months, [0:15:37] and this is a strategic investment [0:15:38] that the City of Twin Falls is partnering to do [0:15:41] with the ERP system. [0:15:43] Our goals are to enhance service delivery, [0:15:45] streamline operations, sustain growth, and prosperity. [0:15:49] So with that, I'm asking for a vote [0:15:52] on the contract that I have uploaded, [0:15:54] and if you have any questions. [0:15:58] Chris, we're going to thank you for the presentation. [0:16:02] What is the ongoing cost? [0:16:03] So I know that this is an implementation of going. [0:16:07] Annual fees, annual software fees, correct. [0:16:10] So is that annual that's going to be the dollar amount that we're approving right now? [0:16:14] Right now you're only approving the use of they're approving the contract with BSNA [0:16:18] and the contingency funds of the 58,750. [0:16:21] We already have calculated into our budget the software costs. [0:16:25] And what will those be? [0:16:27] So that's going to be around 90, it's part of the software package. [0:16:30] It's about $90,000 per year. [0:16:32] We currently pay around, it's actually between 50 and 60,000 to Springbrook. [0:16:37] Whether we upgraded with Springbrook's Cloud or which was our second choice vendor, [0:16:42] or we went with BSNA, it's right around the $90,000 that we would currently budget [0:16:46] from here on out into our software costs. [0:16:48] Perfect. Thank you. [0:16:51] Thank you. [0:16:52] Any other questions for Brianna? [0:16:58] Okay. [0:16:58] Well, I'd entertain a motion. [0:17:00] Chris, do you want to move to approve the contract with BS&A, [0:17:05] software for the total cost of $348,750 [0:17:10] and to authorize the use of $58,750 of contingency funds. [0:17:15] Thank you. [0:17:16] Jason Brown? [0:17:17] Second. [0:17:18] Thank you. [0:17:18] Motion by Chris Reed, seconded by Jason Brown, [0:17:21] to approve the contract. [0:17:24] Oh, OK, you guys. [0:17:26] That up too fast. [0:17:27] To prove the contract with BS&8, [0:17:30] software for a total cost of 348,750, [0:17:34] and to authorize the use of 58,750 of contingency funds. [0:17:40] Morgan Rowe, call vote please. [0:17:45] Chair Yavomar. [0:17:46] Yes. [0:17:47] Ruth Pierce. [0:17:48] Yes. [0:17:49] Chris Reed. [0:17:49] Yes. [0:17:50] Craig Hawkins. [0:17:51] Yes. [0:17:52] Jason Brown. [0:17:53] Yes. [0:17:54] Spencer Cutler. [0:17:55] Yes. [0:17:56] Thank you, motion passes six to zero. [0:17:57] Thank you, Brianna. [0:18:00] Okay, next item on the agenda is an action item. [0:18:04] Are we request permission for staff [0:18:06] to negotiate a contract with a 2024 CHIP seal project? [0:18:11] We asked Troy B. Tech, not Sam O'Leary. [0:18:15] Scared Sam away. [0:18:19] Welcome, Troy. [0:18:20] Thank you, Mayor and Council. [0:18:21] So tonight I'm here for a little different discussion. [0:18:24] We often, every year we send out a request for, sorry, [0:18:29] request for proposal for Chifsel throughout the city. We've broken the city of two eight zones. [0:18:36] This year will be on zone four, which is one of our bigger zones. It's from Addison to Falls, [0:18:40] who lakes to essentially Grandview, a large zone. And we were working with Public Works extensively [0:18:47] to try to balance the zones as we've grown in this process. This year's, the budget was for $1.9 million. [0:18:55] We sent out of the bid and we received zero bids. [0:19:01] So we've got with one of our local contractors who's often done it for us in the past and said, [0:19:08] what happened? [0:19:09] And these have changed in the past. [0:19:12] Their capability is kind of limited by the size of their company. [0:19:18] Last year, we were right on the threshold of about 1.5. [0:19:22] Now we've grown to 1.9. [0:19:23] It's making a little harder for them as well as the zone is just so big. [0:19:28] and lending institutions are starting to be a little bit more frugal with their money. [0:19:33] And so I actually physically submit a bit, but they reached out and said, [0:19:40] we'd be happy to do the work. [0:19:42] We said, okay, when we received zero bids, state code says, okay, [0:19:48] you've went through all the public requirements. [0:19:51] You have the option now to go out and negotiate if the council gives us authority to do so. [0:19:55] So that's what I'm here tonight, is to ask you guys give us authority to go on the open market [0:20:00] and negotiate since Emery. As has been our primary, that's probably our first [0:20:04] point of contact. If we come to some conclusion that works for both them and [0:20:08] us and maybe the institutions, I'll wait and or you guys, I guess is what I'm [0:20:27] here for tonight. If you have any questions, I'd be happy to answer. [0:20:31] I do, Jason does too. So could you in theory work with two different companies [0:20:36] if you broke that out or would your intention be to try to make them the [0:20:41] same. We would guess there's always an option for that. We usually work [0:20:45] with one and try to come to a reasonable time frame and within the budget. [0:20:50] They've performed in the past. Yes. They've been historically the number one [0:20:55] winner three or four years ago. We had another company bid on it. They were [0:20:59] substantially more. So pretty confident in their value. There's just not a lot of [0:21:06] chip selling companies. No, there are not. Thank you, Jason. Yeah, Troy. So, I mean, [0:21:11] You went out, you negotiated, nobody bid on that. [0:21:18] So we've followed the law up to this point. [0:21:20] We're just looking to negotiate. [0:21:22] I'd go ahead and make a motion if there's no other. [0:21:24] And sir, did you wanna have a question? [0:21:26] Yeah, I just had a quick question. [0:21:28] So if this is approved, how would that look? [0:21:30] Would anything come back to council or? [0:21:34] Yeah, it would come back once we get the contract [0:21:36] figured out the time frame and the total dollar value, [0:21:39] we would come back to the council for the actual board. [0:21:42] So you'd see that that point. [0:21:43] Thank you. [0:21:44] Okay, Jason, go ahead. [0:21:46] I'd move to approve for staff to negotiate a contract [0:21:50] for the 2024 CHIP SILL Project. [0:21:53] Thank you, Sherry Volmer. [0:21:55] I'll second. [0:21:56] Thank you. [0:21:56] Motion by Jason Brown, seconded by Sherry Volmer [0:21:59] to approve the staff, give staff permission [0:22:04] to negotiate a contract for the 2024 CHIP SILL Project. [0:22:08] Any further discussion? [0:22:11] Morgan Roekov, please. [0:22:14] Ruth Pierce? [0:22:15] Yes. [0:22:16] Chris Reed? [0:22:17] Yes. [0:22:18] Craig Hawkins? [0:22:19] Yes. [0:22:20] Jason Brown? [0:22:21] Yes. [0:22:22] Hunter Cutler? [0:22:23] Yes. [0:22:24] Sherry Volmer? [0:22:25] Yes. [0:22:26] Thank you. [0:22:27] Motion passes six to zero. [0:22:28] Thank you, Troy. [0:22:29] Okay. [0:22:30] Next on the agenda is an action item. [0:22:31] A request to approve a service agreement with Holly Troxel, attorneys and counselors for [0:22:36] consultation on the state of Idaho Department of Insurance self-funded plan [0:22:41] registration process and to authorize the use of 20,000 from the legal [0:22:46] department salary line for professional services and we have Gretchen Scott [0:22:51] deputy city manager welcome Gretchen. Hi thank you council and mayor really [0:22:56] excited to be here tonight before you with this item and the staff report I kind of [0:23:01] reviewed the process that we were talking about and gave you some [0:23:04] information about self-insurance. One of the things that I just wanted to touch on [0:23:08] is that we have been pursuing the idea of self-funding our health insurance for [0:23:18] a couple of years. I'll even say a decade. Our process through the state is very [0:23:25] complex. It requires a lot of groundwork to take place before you're able to do [0:23:30] that in order to protect employees and the public employees that have this option [0:23:36] underneath state law. We routinely ask in actuary about every three years to look [0:23:45] at us in our plans and our claim history to tell us how we're doing and whether or [0:23:50] not this makes sense for us. In previous years it has not made sense. We have not [0:23:55] been close enough in order to the risk was too great for us to take on self [0:24:00] funding, it made sense to continue to fully ensure with a another company. [0:24:06] In this last year, our actuary came back and said, you've got a really good probability, [0:24:12] 91% right now, of beating a self or a fully funded plan, and in future years, 99% you will [0:24:19] beat what a fully funded plan would look like. [0:24:25] When he gave us our actuary report based on our claims, the potential savings is anywhere [0:24:30] are from $88,000 to $908,000. [0:24:36] Our annual spend is just about, I think, actually put in this, [0:24:42] is looking at and budgeted for fiscal year 2025, $4.89 million. [0:24:48] That's what we spend for our health insurance in order [0:24:51] to provide that benefit to our employees. [0:24:54] The kind of potential for savings that we're looking at [0:24:56] by moving to self-funding is significant. [0:24:59] So just to give you an idea, who is self-funded in Idaho [0:25:03] in terms of public entities who has gone through this process, [0:25:06] Boise, including both their general and their public safety [0:25:09] employees, Caldwell, Cordellane, Lewiston, Meridian, Namba, [0:25:15] BYU, Idaho, and University of Idaho [0:25:18] are all self-funded plans. [0:25:21] But it is complex, and particularly given the timeline, [0:25:25] the Director of Insurance has 90 days to approve. [0:25:29] So you submit an application to register a plan. [0:25:33] So it's an application for a registration. [0:25:36] And he has 90 days, once submitted, [0:25:38] and if it's accurate and correct, [0:25:40] in order to make his decision. [0:25:43] In order to try to do the best possible job [0:25:45] and have a smooth process, [0:25:48] we would like to hire contract with an attorney [0:25:51] in order to do that. [0:25:52] As you know, the city attorney has been working [0:25:56] on a contract for the fiscal year. [0:25:59] And I've gone through and I have done some analysis on the salaries right now in terms [0:26:03] of what we are spending in professional services versus salaries to see if we would have money [0:26:08] in order to move some of the funding around in that line. [0:26:12] And it appears that we do. [0:26:14] Right now there's about 284,000 in full-time salaries remaining based on what we are spending [0:26:20] in professional services and the additional new attorney that just came on. [0:26:25] I believe that we will be safely funded if we were to spend or authorize about $20,000 [0:26:33] from professional or from salaries to professional services in order to do this. [0:26:38] So this is an additional money. [0:26:40] It's just repositioning in the budget where the money would be spent. [0:26:45] So with that, I'll stand for any questions about why we would want to do this, [0:26:50] what our interest is or anything else that you might want to know about. [0:26:55] So the engagement letter itself did not give a cap on the salary. [0:27:02] You're just estimating, based on them charging their hourly rate, [0:27:06] that that's what it's going to be. [0:27:08] You're pretty confident that it's not going to go over. [0:27:11] No. [0:27:12] OK. [0:27:12] I don't know if it's any more. [0:27:18] And the timeline on this is what? [0:27:22] Not for this budget year. [0:27:24] I would assume, but for the following budget year, [0:27:26] if it works out? [0:27:28] I believe we are going to try to have it in place [0:27:32] for fiscal year 25 for self-funding. [0:27:35] So there's a couple of steps, [0:27:36] and I've been really careful [0:27:37] on how I've been talking about this internally as well. [0:27:41] We are pursuing a whole slate of options. [0:27:44] Renewal with our insurance company as we currently are. [0:27:48] We are having our plan shopped to other providers [0:27:51] in order to see if we can also reduce the amount [0:27:53] we're spending and this third option pursuing self-funding. [0:27:58] So we're trying to present a whole slate for an October 1 [0:28:01] implementation in order to get the best value, best financial [0:28:07] purchase for our plan as we move forward. [0:28:10] We have to submit an application essentially by July 1 [0:28:14] in order to do 90 days for implementation October 1. [0:28:19] We are also, so part of this is shopping, access to networks. [0:28:25] Our broker is currently doing that if we were to go to self [0:28:27] funding. So there's lots of things that are in play to busy time in order to try to accomplish [0:28:33] it. But once we got the message from the actuary that it looks like we're in a good position, [0:28:38] we wanted to try to do this as well as put this option on the table for administration [0:28:44] in the council. Perfect. Any questions for Gretchen? Great. [0:28:48] I'm just Gretchen just wondering what are some of the possibilities of risk or downside of [0:28:55] So in the staff report, the difference between the range of savings, so there's a piece that [0:29:03] we do, the actual report, it talks about the 125%, there is a cap, a band, that if your [0:29:11] claims exceed what you expect, the top of that band is 125%. [0:29:17] There are some stop-loss coverages, so you have insurance on your insurance, but if you [0:29:23] exceed that in your claims that it caps at that point and that stop-loss coverage [0:29:28] comes into a play. That's the top end of what we expect that we would still save. [0:29:32] So the 88,000, even if we were 125% of the expected claims based on the [0:29:38] actual study, we would still save about $88,000. [0:29:42] I think it sounds great. I encourage you to pursue it. [0:29:48] Thank you Jason. [0:29:49] So, Holly Troxel is going to help us put together the paperwork to get submitted by July 1. [0:30:00] Did I hear that correctly that we're trying to get it in by July 1 so we can meet that? [0:30:07] There are two pieces specifically. [0:30:09] The documentation for the Trust Fund. [0:30:11] The Trust by State law is required to put together to fund the claims. [0:30:15] It is in my very simplistic way of looking at it. [0:30:20] at it, I look at it like the URA, you're going to create another little agency that's going [0:30:24] to administer those funds for the medical plan. [0:30:26] So we'll create this little separate public entity that is the fund that funds that plan. [0:30:32] And then the second piece is the application for registration. [0:30:36] So that set of documents that goes along with the establishment of the trust. [0:30:41] Thank you. [0:30:43] Any other questions? [0:30:44] I'd entertain a motion, Jason. [0:30:47] Thank you. [0:30:48] Go ahead. [0:30:49] Move to approve a service agreement [0:30:51] with Holly Troxel attorneys and counselors [0:30:55] for consultation on the state of Idaho Department [0:30:58] of Insurance Self-funded Plan, registration process, [0:31:02] and to authorize the use of 20,000 [0:31:04] from the legal department salary line [0:31:06] for professional service. [0:31:08] Thank you, Sherry Vomer. [0:31:10] I'll second. [0:31:11] Thank you, motion by Jason Brown, second by Sherry Vomer [0:31:14] to approve a service agreement [0:31:16] with Holly Troxel attorneys [0:31:18] For consultation on the State of Idaho Department of Insurance, self-ended plan registration [0:31:24] process, and to authorize the use of $20,000 from the legal department salary line for [0:31:30] professional services. [0:31:32] Any further discussion? [0:31:35] Morgan Roek, I'll vote, please. [0:31:38] Ruth Pierce? [0:31:39] Yes. [0:31:40] Chris Reed? [0:31:41] Yes. [0:31:42] Greg Hawkins? [0:31:43] Yes. [0:31:44] Jason Brown? [0:31:45] Yes. [0:31:46] Spencer Cutler? [0:31:47] Yes. [0:31:48] Jerry Vomer? [0:31:49] Yes. [0:31:50] Good job. [0:31:51] Next, we have an action item seeking council priorities on the development of the fiscal [0:32:00] year 24-25 budget and we have our city manager, Travis Rothweiler, welcome, Travis. [0:32:09] Hello, council. [0:32:10] The good news is it's not an action item. [0:32:12] I kind of thought that I would have to make you decide the budget this evening, although [0:32:16] we would all have a summer if we did, right? [0:32:20] So I know that a few of you are as biggest sports fans as I am, and one sports analogy [0:32:31] that I would share that often right after a basketball team wins the national championship. [0:32:39] Literally the next day, everyone wants to talk about who's the next number one. [0:32:45] And they come out with the way too early season poll for the upcoming basketball season. [0:32:53] Last year, the way too early poll had Yukon at number six. [0:32:56] They ended up winning it for the second consecutive year. [0:32:59] This year, Yukon's at number three. [0:33:02] I'm not a Yukon fan. [0:33:04] I would not bet against him on winning it all again. [0:33:07] So I share that because while it may be close, [0:33:12] we know that what we're presenting to you tonight [0:33:15] is not done. [0:33:16] It is not finished. [0:33:17] And there's a lot more information or play [0:33:20] that has to happen before we get to our own version [0:33:23] the final four which is going to occur in August. [0:33:28] So I want the council to remember that, but most importantly I want the community to remember [0:33:31] that because what we're going to be doing is we're going to be showing numbers and possibilities [0:33:36] of what it can be and what we don't want our people to immediately go to that's what it [0:33:42] is because it's way too early for us to start commenting on exactly what it should be. [0:33:51] And that's one of the dangers of our process. [0:33:54] We are incredibly transparent. [0:33:56] We started very, very early. [0:33:58] This is the second or third budget presentation that we've had this year. [0:34:05] And most organizations won't have their first until August. [0:34:08] And by the time August comes around, we will have had our 13th. [0:34:13] And so I need everybody to keep in mind that in our effort to be transparent, we're going [0:34:19] to give you what we believe is our best guess. [0:34:22] we reserve the right to be entirely wrong. [0:34:26] What we will tell you is that our budget is balanced. [0:34:29] It will be sustainable. [0:34:31] It will be nimble. [0:34:32] It will be able to adapt to an ever-changing environment. [0:34:35] But what we're going to share with you tonight is not right. [0:34:39] It is going to change. [0:34:40] And so if everyone could be patient with us and tolerant [0:34:44] as we work through this, it would be very helpful. [0:34:48] What we want to do is we want to make sure, like we always do, [0:34:52] is make sure that everybody is looking at the City of Twin Falls through the same lens [0:34:58] that we are looking at the City of Twin Falls as we're constructing this budget. [0:35:02] And there's a couple of things that we all always need to remember. [0:35:06] Number one, the City of Twin Falls is growing. [0:35:09] And I had a great conversation with Gretchen last week about, [0:35:13] is a 3% growth rate really significant? [0:35:17] And I told her, well, 3% doesn't sound like a lot if you're investing. [0:35:23] But when you're looking at a 3% growth rate, [0:35:25] that means that our community's population [0:35:27] will exceed 65,000 people at the next census, [0:35:33] which is nearly double the city of Twin Falls [0:35:38] since the year 2000. [0:35:42] And what's also important is, [0:35:44] it's not just the city of Twin Falls that's growing, [0:35:47] because if we were in Montana, [0:35:48] and we were in my hometown of Great Falls, [0:35:51] where it is fairly isolated, [0:35:52] and there aren't several other feeder communities [0:35:55] around like we have here, [0:35:58] and a 3% growth rate would be acceptable. [0:36:02] But it's Jerome's growth rate and fuel and filer [0:36:05] and Kimberly and Edelton and fuel, [0:36:09] the Wood River Valley, all of their growth rates impact us, [0:36:12] and our daily population exceeds 100,000. [0:36:16] There are 40,000 passenger vehicles [0:36:18] across the bridge every single day. [0:36:22] And so when we look at the city of Twin Falls, [0:36:25] we can't look at it as providing services to 56,000, [0:36:28] we need to recognize that it exceeds [0:36:31] 100, possibly 110,000 people every single day. [0:36:37] And so when Brianna's talking about [0:36:39] how our budgets have grown, [0:36:41] it's not just the community of Twin Falls that has grown, [0:36:44] but it is our need to supply services to other individuals. [0:36:49] On top of that, costs have gone up, especially homes. [0:36:52] And so we illustrate what the median home value [0:36:55] is not only in Twin Falls, but also what it is in other areas of the state and then employment. [0:37:04] How many people are working and where are they at? [0:37:09] As we shared, the City of Twin Falls is driven by a strategic plan that is before you was [0:37:16] first created in 2012 and as the Council is aware later this fall we will go through [0:37:22] a process to evaluate the key focus areas of the City of Twin Falls and determine whether [0:37:26] not those remain appropriate. What we do know is that the year 2030 isn't really that far away. [0:37:35] It's five budgets away. And as my kids used to say, it's one whole hand, which isn't much. [0:37:43] And we've extended that goal post to 2040. And over the course of this fall, we'll determine [0:37:49] whether or not these are appropriate. And we'll construct next year's budget with potentially [0:37:54] new focus areas but we're using these ones for this year. So here's the numbers way too early [0:38:03] right at the front of the page so overall what is the message total government spending is down [0:38:09] by three point two million dollars. You can see that our tax rate may be potentially going up [0:38:18] but it's also because the median home value of houses compared January to January [0:38:27] are projected to decline. [0:38:30] So remember, just because a tax rate goes up or a tax rate goes down, [0:38:34] does not necessarily mean that an individual tax burden [0:38:38] is going to follow suit. [0:38:40] Because the tax rate is just a multiplier that is applied against the value of a property [0:38:46] and we'll kind of go through and show that. [0:38:49] But one of the things that I think is interesting [0:38:52] is if you take a look at between 22 and 24, [0:38:56] you saw significant growth of the city's total taxable value. [0:39:01] Last year, part of that growth was fueled [0:39:04] by the inclusion of an urban renewal area, [0:39:07] but this year in 2025, you can see that growth [0:39:10] was less than 1%. [0:39:12] So the total taxable value of the city grew by less than 1%. [0:39:16] But it's total value when you include [0:39:19] the urban renewal area succeeds $6.8 billion. [0:39:28] This is our new construction net. [0:39:32] And remember, the new construction value of the city [0:39:34] of Twin Falls that we can claim towards property taxes. [0:39:38] We often refer to that as the growth formula. [0:39:42] He is 90% of the total value of the new construction [0:39:46] in the community for new construction. [0:39:49] If it was an urban renewal agency closing, [0:39:52] You get 80% as we shared last year. [0:39:54] This is the 90% multiplier. [0:39:57] That's going to create about a new construction taxable role [0:40:02] of $91,641,000. [0:40:06] And you can see it is less than the last three fiscal years. [0:40:13] And as a result of that, we're looking at about 533,000 [0:40:18] of new property tax dollars attributed to growth. [0:40:24] So it's off. [0:40:26] The good news is, and as an example of why it's way too early, [0:40:30] the 91 million exceeds our internal initial projection [0:40:36] of 75 million. [0:40:37] So it outperformed better than where we had previously [0:40:43] thought it was. [0:40:45] So we're gonna dive into some economic indicators really [0:40:48] quick to kind of level set the conversation. [0:40:52] So the first thing to remember is we continue to grow. [0:40:56] Idaho saw a total increase of about 1.8% of individuals. [0:41:02] And while it is not the fastest growing state [0:41:07] in the country any longer, it has far exceeded [0:41:10] the national growth rate. [0:41:12] Those in darker shades of green illustrate [0:41:16] more significant levels of growth that have continued to come into Idaho. [0:41:21] So as more individuals come into Idaho, we are seeing Idaho, as we know it, see significant [0:41:28] changes and pressures as it relates to growth and growth opportunities and understanding not [0:41:36] only growth, but where individuals are coming from is a key piece to understanding the budget [0:41:42] that we've built. [0:41:45] These are the total taxable values of homes as measured in January of each year. [0:41:52] And the reason we picked January is because the county assessor is required to determine [0:41:58] the market value of the property on or about January 1st of every year to determine what [0:42:05] the value is to be applied for property taxes. [0:42:08] So if you take a look at the city of Twin Falls, we're estimating that it is going to [0:42:12] grow slightly than the prior year, but not as much as what it was had been in the past. [0:42:20] You can see that the city of Boise currently is at 574,000, Idaho is at 418,000, and the [0:42:31] city of Twin Falls is at that 349. [0:42:36] So when you take a look at those different values, that is the number that they're going [0:42:41] to use less a homeowner's exemption to determine the total tax rate moving forward. [0:42:47] Unemployment continues to be very strong and you can see that right now, based upon the [0:42:53] April report that was published in May, there are 903 individuals inside of the City of [0:42:59] Twin Falls that are unemployed, but yet our labor market only added 241 individuals and [0:43:06] so when you think about the amount of growth that we've had, then you start looking at [0:43:12] the number of individuals that added into our labor market, and one of the things that [0:43:16] we know is that one of the defining characteristics of individuals choosing to move into Twin Falls [0:43:24] are largely retired. [0:43:28] So when we think about individuals coming into our community, they are not helping us with [0:43:33] that low unemployment rate, because remember, full employment is considered about 5%. [0:43:41] We often hear about the cost of doing business and lots of individuals have probably become [0:43:46] more in tune with the consumer price index and inflation as it relates to not only interest [0:43:52] rates earned on account but also interest rates paid on debts like credit cards or new mortgages. [0:44:00] And the Fed has said that until interest rates begin to, or the CPI hits about 2%, it's not [0:44:11] going to lower rates and we can see that it was up to 3.4% this year. So one of the [0:44:18] things that we do now is that the prices continue to grow. We have two cost [0:44:24] indicators here. One is the CPI and then the other is for what's called the MCI. We [0:44:29] look at the MCI which is the Municipal Cost Index. The Municipal Cost Index is [0:44:34] really what we use to determine costs of local government services. So here are [0:44:43] the goals. When we met with you earlier in the year, we asked you to verify or validate [0:44:51] that these continued to remain the goals that we wanted to have when we are making the budgetary [0:44:57] decision. So this was that starting place. It has to be stable, sustainable, and nimble. [0:45:03] Because one of the things that we've learned over the course of this past decade is that [0:45:08] there are potentially new challenges that we never thought of that may appear tomorrow. [0:45:13] And as a government entity, we need to be prepared to respond. [0:45:17] We need to be sensitive to our operating environment. [0:45:19] We need to understand that the budgets that we are passing, which cause a financial liability [0:45:26] on the citizens that we serve, is also sustainable in their own personal budgets. [0:45:31] And we believe that we're trying to do that. [0:45:33] Directly tied to the city's strategic plan so that we're not chasing those shiny things, [0:45:38] that it remains that goalposts that we are always driving and marching to because we're [0:45:43] We did that in a time that we had clear vision, and we're still trying to reach those faces [0:45:50] today. [0:45:51] We recognize that as a local government entity, we are largely a service industry, that everything [0:45:58] that we provide is provided by the hands of a very talented workforce. [0:46:04] And in order to meet the needs of a growing community, we need to be an employer of choice. [0:46:10] So we need to be focusing on benefits, like Gridget's talking about in terms of doing different [0:46:15] things with health insurance. [0:46:17] We need to be focusing on compensation to make sure that it is market competitive. [0:46:22] We need to make sure that we are focusing on creating an environment that is driven based [0:46:26] upon values and it's an enjoyable place to work and it also has quality structures that [0:46:31] are safe for our employees. [0:46:33] It does include the statutory three percent increases. [0:46:37] It includes the new construction value and 1% of the city's foregone balance and that we've [0:46:43] done our best to minimize utility rate increases and we'll talk about that. [0:46:47] In fact, the council will have some pretty significant decisions to make as it relates [0:46:54] to rate adjustments and the types of services that we offer moving forward. [0:47:00] I give you the PowerPoint presentation and I don't want to spend tremendous time just reading [0:47:05] slides to you, but know that we took a look at the financial challenges that are always [0:47:11] going to be coming in, that there are operational deficits in recreation programs in the airport, [0:47:19] the pool. [0:47:20] We know that Percy rates are going to continue to grow as set by the state, and we know that [0:47:25] we're going to have unexpected failures that are going to occur because we have aging systems. [0:47:32] We know that we have to have a long-term, sustainable budget and right now our capital [0:47:37] investments are significantly outperforming. [0:47:41] But two years ago our building permits were significantly outperforming and if we would [0:47:46] have elevated our building permits to what we were realizing over a two-year period, we [0:47:51] would have a million dollar hole that we'd be trying to patch in this budget. [0:47:54] And so what we want to do is to make sure that when we plug in the revenues, we're conservative. [0:48:01] And sometimes we admit that we can be overly conservative, but it is easier to balance budgets [0:48:11] with moderate, less aggressive rate adjustments than have to turn to our citizens and say we [0:48:18] screwed up, we have to increase utility rates 15%, 18%. [0:48:26] We want to make sure that we are providing the tools to the members of our team, that [0:48:31] We have the right staff in the right positions and you'll notice that we are adding new positions [0:48:37] in this budget to meet a continually growing community additional requirements in the dynamic [0:48:43] workforce. [0:48:45] We're challenging our departments to take a look at revenue generation. [0:48:51] I'll give you one. [0:48:54] We subsidize significantly youth sports programs. [0:48:59] We subsidize a flat rate. [0:49:02] We charge a flat rate. [0:49:03] Regardless of what those costs are, we supply it with property taxes. [0:49:11] And we know that it's a flat rate of say $35 per participant per sport, but we know that [0:49:17] youth basketball programs exceed $100. [0:49:23] Should we be offering that level of subsidy always? [0:49:27] Or should we be looking at ways to increase those costs to help us apply less property [0:49:34] tax and then utilize some of the generous contributions from places like the Seagrish [0:49:39] Foundation to offer scholarships to individuals who do not have the abilities to pay. [0:49:46] Because what we don't want is priced to be a barrier, but we also need to challenge ourselves [0:49:51] to ask should we be subsidizing youth sports at the levels that we are. [0:49:59] And it is just one place. [0:50:01] The airport is another, the pool is another. [0:50:05] And so we need to be thinking like a business [0:50:10] about what is that appropriate level of cost [0:50:12] that we should be assessing. [0:50:14] So not it is not an answer that we need tonight. [0:50:21] But as we get closer to August, [0:50:25] we want to challenge the council [0:50:26] as we challenge the members of the Parks and Recreation team [0:50:29] to be thinking about the cost of services, [0:50:32] the cost of our programs and making sure that we have some formula that recognizes that [0:50:38] the costs continue to increase. We need to make sure that we're engaging our community. [0:50:47] We offer amazing services. And one of the challenges that we've had and we've discussed [0:50:53] during our budgeting process was asking our department leaders, but are you offering [0:50:57] the right services? And are you offering those services at the right levels? And we [0:51:02] We believe that things like priority-based budgeting, which will help with programs, is [0:51:07] going to help us move some of those things. [0:51:10] But we also need to be managing overtime costs. [0:51:12] We need to be managing how we're staffing. [0:51:14] And so we've challenged our departments to do that. [0:51:17] We're also taking a look at infrastructure and making modernizations so that we can work [0:51:24] smarter and have great facilities. [0:51:27] So we have library issues with elevators. [0:51:30] have bookmobile issues. What are the best tools and ways to fix those as we offer [0:51:36] services to all members of our community? So here's the highlights. It [0:51:44] takes the 3% statutory increase. It takes 90% the $91 million of new [0:51:51] construction revenue of $553,000 and it uses the 1%. All of those three are [0:51:56] statutorily allowed and provided for and those are what are being passed [0:52:00] initially in this process. We're looking at a two and a half percent increase in [0:52:06] water initially and a five percent increase in sewer. So here's one of the [0:52:11] exciting things. One of our industrial partners has made significant [0:52:15] improvements in the quality of their effluent. Our plant is working better. When [0:52:21] our plants work better we have fewer issues like odors, but it also costs us [0:52:28] $600,000 of revenue. So there's a trade-off for efficiencies that are being captured by [0:52:37] our industrial partners and in order for us to hit bond covenant targets and to meet the [0:52:43] growing needs of we have to increase sewer rates by 5%. The good news is it's the first [0:52:51] rate increase in sewer that we've asked for in years and 5% is just that starting point. [0:52:57] Am I saying it's going to be 5%? [0:53:01] The next one is somewhere between two, possibly 4% for sanitation services. [0:53:08] And what that looks like is going to be driven by the council. [0:53:13] So our sanitation fund should be viewed as dollars in dollars out because we contract [0:53:20] with PSI for services. [0:53:22] And we will in this next fiscal year go forward with a request for proposals and solicit individuals [0:53:29] to offer their best price, to offer services to the City of Twin Falls as that contract ends [0:53:35] in December of 26, we want to make sure that should someone else other than PSI receive the [0:53:42] award for a 10-year period of time, that they have the opportunity to capitalize and to perform. [0:53:49] But one of the driving factors in our costs, in sanitation, is our recycling program. [0:53:58] Just to give you an idea, what is the potential cost [0:54:01] of our recycling program? [0:54:04] TSI offers garbage services in the city of Jerome. [0:54:09] They do not offer recycling. [0:54:10] The city of Twin Falls is the only community [0:54:13] in the Magic Valley that offers curbside recycling. [0:54:17] And we've had this conversation with the city council [0:54:20] a couple of different times, [0:54:21] and these are not apples to apples comparisons [0:54:24] because we do some things differently [0:54:25] in Twin Falls County than they do in Jerome County. [0:54:27] For example, the County Landfill Assessment [0:54:31] is paid for monthly by each individual user, [0:54:34] where in every other county in our landfill district, [0:54:37] it's included in the property taxes. [0:54:38] So it's not in apples-to-apples comparison, [0:54:41] but you get pretty close. [0:54:43] And Jerome pays $9.12 per month, [0:54:47] and we're paying nearly 20. [0:54:54] So if the difference is $5, [0:54:56] if the save recycling is costing us $5 more per month, [0:55:02] Then we could cut five dollars off and pass that on because remember it's a dollars in dollars out [0:55:08] We would save our citizens [0:55:10] 960 thousand dollars a year [0:55:13] So the return on the investment that we're going to challenge the council over the course of the next couple of years is is our recycling program? [0:55:24] Worth nine hundred and sixty thousand dollars to the citizens of the city of Twin Falls and how much more life is it adding into the landfill? [0:55:31] Because if you say recycling is important, then I need to probably increase rates because [0:55:39] not increasing rates this year means that we will eat away almost one half of the cash [0:55:46] reserves that we have in the sanitation fund. [0:55:52] Not a decision that you have to make tonight, but one that you should be open to if we truly [0:55:58] want to look at programs, services, and operating more effectively. [0:56:05] Here's an example of our tax rate over the period of time. [0:56:08] You can see that this tax rate is going to be slightly larger than last year, but slightly [0:56:12] less than the one issued in 2023. [0:56:15] I'm going to go quick because I don't want you to get lost in the tax rate because the [0:56:19] tax rate may not mean much. [0:56:21] But if all things are equal, you can look at the average citizen inside the city of [0:56:25] Twin Falls with a water rate increase, a sewer rate increase, and a property tax increase, [0:56:31] pay $8.60 more per month, all inclusive. We believe that there's some room in that number, [0:56:41] but it's always easy to start maybe a little bit higher, and again, maybe exceed your expectations. [0:56:51] Personnel strategy. So one of the things that we're looking at is a compensation adjustment, [0:56:58] and what's important to remember is that every 1% adjustment now costs the organization [0:57:06] nearly $314,000. [0:57:12] And in order for us to be competitive, we believe, [0:57:15] so if you remember, let me back up just a second. [0:57:18] When Brianda provided her last financial report, [0:57:21] she shared that most employers this year [0:57:24] are somewhere between that 4.5 and 9% compensation [0:57:29] adjustment for the year. [0:57:30] Inside of this budget calls for a 6% adjustment [0:57:33] for employees. [0:57:34] It also calls for some surgical adjustments [0:57:36] to move individuals in our organization [0:57:39] that are not placed appropriately [0:57:41] based upon the most kinds of levels. [0:57:44] It includes increases associated with perceived. [0:57:47] It also takes the more conservative approach [0:57:49] on health insurance and budgets [0:57:51] for the 4.5% increase if we were to remain with select health. [0:57:58] Let's say we go out and we bet on ourselves [0:58:04] and we believe the actuarial studies. [0:58:07] We can say potentially up to $900,000 a year. [0:58:19] That's not only savings for our organization, [0:58:23] but it's nearly, it's more than one and a half times [0:58:28] the new monies that we're getting in from the growth formula. [0:58:37] There are some additional employees [0:58:39] that we're looking at. [0:58:40] We have included the three employees for the Safer Grant [0:58:43] as the council approved us submitting for that grant. [0:58:47] Our total outlay for the first year is about $67,000. [0:58:51] The rest of that cost is covered over a period of time, [0:58:54] but we budget for the three portion of that [0:58:58] coming from the city salaries, [0:58:59] a portion of that coming from the grant. [0:59:01] If we are not successful in getting the grant, [0:59:03] those three positions will not move forward in this budget. [0:59:08] But we had to include them to make sure [0:59:10] that we're including our local match, [0:59:12] but we are not including anything more [0:59:13] than our local match that's needed. [0:59:15] Should we be awarded the grant? [0:59:17] And we'll know if we're awarded the grant about the same time [0:59:19] we're asking you to approve the preliminary budget [0:59:22] around August 1st. [0:59:24] We're asking for a new FTE as an assistant HR director. [0:59:28] An FTE is an open space provider, [0:59:31] which is going to help with primarily shishill falls, [0:59:33] but also do some work down at auger balls. [0:59:36] And about 75% of that cost is covered by durkeys like bees. [0:59:40] We've had our city attorney review that to determine [0:59:44] if it's appropriate. [0:59:45] He gave us a thumbs up that is appropriate to use [0:59:48] Durkis fees and access fees, [0:59:52] to show false fees, to cover for the maintenance of that park, [0:59:55] that balance of what they're not covering [0:59:57] is being paid for by property tax dollars. [0:59:59] And then an increase to expand leadership potential [1:00:03] inside of the street department, [1:00:08] an employee, senior operator moving to a lead operator, [1:00:10] which is a one-grade increase. [1:00:12] We talked about health insurance, [1:00:14] and then also liability insurance increases. [1:00:19] We have some additional increases associated with M&O. [1:00:23] One of them is a $50,000 increase associated [1:00:26] with the airshow marketing that was approved [1:00:27] by the city council, so we've included that. [1:00:30] We also have additional overtime. [1:00:33] So not only are we providing the $50,000 for the marketing, [1:00:37] but if you'll remember the presentation [1:00:39] by the airshow committee, we're looking at absorbing [1:00:40] about an additional $50,000 in overtime. [1:00:43] So the air show in for the City of Twin Falls [1:00:46] is more than $100,000 and we hope that that will be recognized [1:00:51] as a platinum sponsor or whatever that next level is. [1:00:57] And then there's some other additional work. [1:01:00] One of the important things you'll see on there [1:01:01] is an additional $39,000 for the animal shelter. [1:01:05] We had a great conversation with people [1:01:08] for pets Debbie Blackwood and Jackie Fry. [1:01:11] They do amazing work. [1:01:13] and their costs are going up in particular labor and bet bills. [1:01:19] And both of those things are driving those factors. [1:01:22] We looked at those numbers in that $39,000 is a fair ask [1:01:27] as they're also asking the county for a proportion to increase. [1:01:33] Our capital strategies continue to remain the same. [1:01:36] Inside your packet, you can see the initial priority [1:01:39] one budget projects that we started with. [1:01:43] It continued to move forward. [1:01:45] This year, we've upped like we did last year. [1:01:49] Our total capital new dollar buy is right around $2.8 million. [1:01:55] Some of us remember when it was $1.8, [1:01:57] and then we grew it to $2.2, and now it's in excess of $2.8. [1:02:02] And that is a reflection of increased costs, [1:02:04] because when we were talking about the fleet management [1:02:07] plan, we shared with you a police officer, or a police car, [1:02:11] that used to cost about $40,000 and now they're costing 80. [1:02:17] So it's important to recognize that the cost of our capital [1:02:22] are rolling stock and everything that we're doing is going up. [1:02:24] You can see that the price of four police cars now [1:02:28] is estimated to be $325,000. [1:02:36] Here's some additional park improvement projects, [1:02:40] street improvement projects. [1:02:45] Lots of capital strategies moving forward. [1:02:48] So here's where the capital projects at you allocated, last year you allocated $713,000 [1:02:56] for these projects in addition to nearly $8.5 million of SLFRF projects. [1:03:04] Those are not included here and so that workload is ongoing and it continues. [1:03:08] We have some more. [1:03:12] I have three projects that I want to introduce to you and some potential different opportunities [1:03:20] And there's a whole host of combinations of opportunities [1:03:23] that staff will be working on. [1:03:26] But we have three projects that are in a space that at some level [1:03:30] have been either supported by the council or entertained [1:03:36] by the council. [1:03:37] The police evidence training facility for $1.85 million [1:03:41] is a new cost factored in with inflation. [1:03:46] Inside of that facility, we presented it [1:03:48] during the SLFRF for projects for consideration, we shared at the time that the evidence storage [1:03:54] face that we have in the existing police station is inadequate and it's a new facility. [1:04:02] But the amount of evidence that we're requiring to hold on to and to safeguard for longer periods [1:04:08] of time continues to grow and we have to hold on to more for longer than we ever have. [1:04:15] existing facilities that we have are either too small or antiquated. They don't have appropriate [1:04:19] space for vehicles to be stored. Should they be needed to be part of an investigation? The [1:04:30] facility would go out at the fire training facility. We estimate that cost would be about [1:04:35] $1.85 million. The next piece is the city pool remodel of the lock rooms. As I showed [1:04:44] on the last sheet, the City Council authorized City staff to engage with an architect to come [1:04:50] up with a series of different renderings for the City Pool. The City Pool was constructed [1:04:55] nearly 40 years ago, 85. It's getting close to 40 years ago, and when it was constructed, [1:05:12] it was never envisioned at its time of construction that it would be anything other than a season [1:05:19] the pool and then we put the community call, put a bubble on it, we've replaced the bubble, [1:05:26] but the facility was never designed to be used all of the time. And it has shown its [1:05:36] where. Additionally, there are some other things that need to be included in modernized facilities, [1:05:43] the locker rooms, the layout. And so we're working on a whole series of options and early [1:05:49] estimates say that's about a $1.2 million project and then we've shared with you [1:05:56] the need for an additional attorney space. Part of that additional attorney space is [1:06:01] utilizing the existing city gym and the old city lab that used to function as city [1:06:06] council chambers and we need to preserve that building it has significant [1:06:09] importance to our infrastructure but the bottom floors can be repurposed and used [1:06:15] and our idea is to flip the city gym from where it is now to where the old city [1:06:19] the shop used to be, and then create the city attorney suite to be into that facility, because [1:06:24] we are going to need to continue to add more attorneys as we continue to grow because they're [1:06:30] adding more judges. [1:06:31] And as they add more judges, each attorney is assigned a judge. [1:06:37] And so in order for us to ensure that our city attorney can still function in the civil [1:06:43] side and we have appropriate coverage on the prosecutorial side, we're probably going [1:06:47] to have to add additional professional staff inside of the attorney shop and there's no [1:06:54] more room in the inn and where they're at. And so we've investigated the council authorized [1:07:00] funding and we've started that process and the all-in cost for that is about $1.81 million. [1:07:07] So there's some additional things that you may consider. We could use cash reserves and [1:07:13] fund them over a period of time, we could maybe enter into a certificate of participation and [1:07:19] use them or all a portion of the 770 for a period of time to cover those costs. There's lots [1:07:24] of different possibilities and funding solutions that we'll ask for you to consider moving forward, [1:07:30] but those are some of those projects. Inside of your packet, we shared for your just quick [1:07:38] reminder what the training facility does, what some of the storage space looks like, the locker [1:07:45] rooms, a potential design of what that could look like. [1:07:49] Know that it's far from certain, Mitch picked 104. [1:07:55] We still don't know what it's going to look like, but certainly as we get closer we'll [1:07:58] be working with the Parks and Recreation Commission and the City Council to determine what the [1:08:03] best project is. [1:08:05] And then this will turn out very well, but this is what the City Attorney's Shop and the [1:08:11] others are going to look like. [1:08:16] So those are the projects. [1:08:19] And we recognize in the past, we shared with the Council, we believe that this is the right [1:08:27] path and course of action and you can see this evening that we're over the course of the [1:08:32] next several months we're going to be seeking your guidance on several different concepts, [1:08:39] ideas and philosophies as we move forward. The good news is, we still have a lot of time to process. [1:08:53] Inside of the City of Twin Falls we're defining that as Q2 time. And so we're going to give to you [1:08:59] the preliminary budget on or around Friday June 28th with an initial budget presentation on July 1st. [1:09:06] We're going to give you the eighth off following the 4th of July holiday and we'll get back [1:09:14] added in earnest on july 15th following the different focus areas and you'll notice that we're [1:09:20] going to approve the budget on the 19th of august which is the date which will have the public hearing. [1:09:30] So with that I would stand for any questions that the council may have. [1:09:40] So Travis I just want to recognize you and your city team for working so hard to get to this point. [1:09:47] I know that we have a long road ahead of us, but we appreciate all your hard work. [1:09:55] It is definitely a team effort. The process started shortly after the first of the year [1:10:00] with the long-term planning committee. In the first week of May, we had 60 individuals in this room [1:10:07] experienced some level of frustration from me as we were trying to achieve balance. [1:10:13] We are trying to literally mix a $300,000 deficit [1:10:20] with $500,000 in dollars reductions. [1:10:23] As Mitch shared, we would still be here. [1:10:26] We started that process and we were able to make some significant headway [1:10:30] after some conversations. [1:10:32] From that point in time, we've been putting the budget together [1:10:35] and again, it's way too early. [1:10:36] It's still very preliminary. [1:10:38] Our tax number hasn't even gone through the Board of Equalization yet. [1:10:42] So individuals who probably haven't even seen their tax notices or had a chance to appeal it yet, [1:10:47] you know, that this is still way too early. [1:10:50] And so we asked for citizens not to get too excited about what they're seeing yet, [1:10:54] thinking about broader concepts of the budget. [1:10:58] Thank you. [1:10:59] Any comments or questions for Travis? [1:11:03] Robbyless, thank you. [1:11:05] Hey, that is the last of our items of consideration. [1:11:10] We do have a public hearing tonight. [1:11:12] but before we get to that. [1:11:14] Now is the time for general public input. [1:11:17] If there's anybody in the audience [1:11:19] that wishes to address City Council on an issue, [1:11:23] not on today's agenda or not personnel related, [1:11:27] please come down to the microphone. [1:11:31] Seeing no one, advisory board reports. [1:11:35] Anybody, today have advisory board reports? [1:11:38] It's been kind of quiet, Greg. [1:11:40] You and I had the opportunity to go in Shabani, it was the last week I think, and talk about [1:11:48] food insecurity. [1:11:49] It was really interesting and very well done. [1:11:54] They're definitely a great partner to have in the community and very concerned about [1:12:00] the food banks and their ability to meet the needs of the people that's continued to [1:12:05] increase and grow and expand. [1:12:09] The other thing I wanted to mention, it was the Western Days Parade, it felt kind of like [1:12:14] the Lone Ranger up there. [1:12:16] But as I watched the parade from the top of that fire truck, the thought occurred to [1:12:21] be, it's great to be an American. [1:12:26] For a few brief moments, a lot of people were together having fun, no fighting, arguing, [1:12:35] university or anything like that, you know, it was, it was just neat and enjoyable to see [1:12:41] peace and tranquility and that we've got a great community. I was surprised at how long [1:12:48] the parade was. I think it was two and a half miles long and I think I was in the first part [1:12:53] and when we got back to my car, the parade was still starting for some people. But it [1:12:59] It was a great day, and it just made me feel good to be an American. [1:13:05] It was nice to see people waving the American flag and enjoying themselves. [1:13:10] Thank you. [1:13:12] And last week they did roll out the new Fly the Flag for the Twin Falls flag, which is [1:13:17] named the Patriots, so that will be flying across the county and on September 11th. [1:13:23] So watch out for that. [1:13:25] Anything from the city manager's office? [1:13:28] Not tonight. [1:13:30] Okay, so next we have a public hearing [1:13:35] I assume here comes Jonathan. Yeah, there you are. I'm sorry. I didn't see you will [1:13:48] Okay, so the next item is an action item. It's public hearing a request to City Council to amend the city [1:13:56] Excuse me the st. Luke's pud adding multiple land uses and modifying the master plan layout on property located at 801 [1:14:05] one, Poe Line Road West, here of Rick Stewart on behalf of Curtis Wiedock, PZ24-0020. [1:14:15] And William, before you start, I'm going to read the rules real quick. [1:14:20] City staff will present the request and analysis. [1:14:23] The applicant will then present their request. [1:14:25] The council will then ask questions of the applicant or staff. [1:14:30] After questions have been answered, public hearing will be open during that time. [1:14:34] anyone in attendance is given the opportunity to comment or ask questions about the request [1:14:39] being considered. [1:14:40] When giving testimony, step up to the podium state, your name and address, present your [1:14:44] comments or concerns. [1:14:47] After giving testimony, please make sure you sign the public. [1:14:51] Sign in sheet located in the lobby with your name and address. [1:14:54] After public comments are concluded, the applicant will be invited to answer any questions and [1:14:59] make a closing statement. [1:15:00] Staff will then clarify any comments as needed. [1:15:04] the closing statements the public hearing will be closed and council will have a discussion. [1:15:10] Okay you're up William. Thanks Madam Mayor and good evening council. Today we have before us a [1:15:20] public hearing for or a amendment to a PUD, specifically the St. Luke's PUD. When I guess several [1:15:32] months back, they came in, requested a building permit to put a pharmacy in their [1:15:39] hospital location. We started going through their PUD. We realized that it [1:15:48] specifically, it didn't allow for it. They narrowed down the uses to be [1:15:57] specifically hospital and then a few other uses. So looking at it, we thought [1:16:05] we needed to go through this PUD amendment, make sure that they got that pharmacy dealt [1:16:12] with. But then we also started looking into it and we realized that I'm part of their [1:16:21] property of that block is in a different PUD. So this is, this application is to combine [1:16:32] or to amend the master plan to include that [1:16:35] nor this portion into this eight loops. [1:16:42] The second aspect of it is rather than restricting [1:16:47] the uses to a finite list or a smaller list [1:16:54] than what it would generally permitted [1:16:55] from the base commercial zoning. [1:16:59] we're going to have the uses go back to that base zoning [1:17:06] and then add the additional use of indoor [1:17:11] and outdoor recreation facilities for. [1:17:14] This, the reason for the indoor outdoor recreation facility [1:17:20] is in case they ever wanted to do them for a therapeutic [1:17:24] record or if they want to do a wellness center, [1:17:28] They have the option to do that by right. [1:17:31] In the base zoning of C1, it is current [1:17:35] that would be considered a special use permit. [1:17:40] So that is one of the exceptions [1:17:41] that they're seeking for at this time. [1:17:46] In general, staff does not foresee really any impacts [1:17:50] where you feel that aligns pretty well [1:17:52] with the hospital orientation that they've already established [1:17:58] I don't have anything in addition to add to what Will has already stated. [1:18:31] As he said, we are trying to align with the current zoning uses for that area and not [1:18:39] restrict ourselves to a particular list of uses with a caveat of having a fitness or a gym [1:18:51] potentially in the future if St. Luke's wanted to partner with somebody to get a use that with [1:19:00] the proposed use is already on site. We do understand that if such a project did come that [1:19:11] that we would have to align with zoning code as far as like perking and stuff like that. [1:19:18] So that's... [1:19:22] Any questions for the applicant? [1:19:30] Looks like that was clear. [1:19:34] Thank you. [1:19:36] Okay. [1:19:37] So not hearing any questions? [1:19:38] I'm going to open up the public hearing. [1:19:40] Is there anybody in the audience that wishes to address City Council on this issue? [1:19:48] Please come down. [1:19:49] Seeing no one. [1:19:52] I'm going to close the public hearing. [1:19:55] I guess we don't have any questions to clarify or questions to answer. [1:20:01] Okay. So now it's up to Council. What would you all like to do? [1:20:09] Mayor, I'd like to just say that I think it makes sense. I think it's Joe's good planning and don't have any concerns with it. [1:20:21] Thank you. Jason, did you know anybody else, Chris? [1:20:25] I don't have any problems with this. I think it makes sense. I'm not really concerned about a gym. I think it's going to make any less noise in a helicopter leaving as I live over in that area. So I don't have a problem with that. If there aren't any other comments, I can make the motion. [1:20:44] That'd be great Chris. Thank you move to approve the request to City Council to amend the St. Luke's pud adding multiple land uses and modifying the master plan layout on property located at 801 pole [1:20:56] Pole line road west [1:20:59] Care of Rick Stewart on behalf of Curtis we'd up. Thank you. Do I have a second? [1:21:06] Thank you motion by Chris Reed seconded by Greg Hawkins [1:21:10] to approve the amendment of the St. Luke's PUD adding multiple land uses [1:21:16] modifying the master land play master plan layout on property at 801 [1:21:22] Pole Line Road West any further discussion Morgan Roekaw please [1:21:28] Chris Reane yes Greg Hawkins yes Jason Brown yes [1:21:35] Spencer Cutler yes Jerry Volmer yes Ruth Pierce yes thank you motion passes [1:21:41] six to zero. Thank you so we have no other business so our meeting is adjourned. [1:21:47] Thank you everyone.