Oversight Archive: City Council meeting, 2024-07-01, recording 1 (started 16:59) Machine transcript (faster-whisper base.en), not checked word for word; the Pledge of Allegiance is shown in its standard wording. The recording is the record. Times are time into the recording. Passages with private details are muted in the audio and marked here. The audio on the page below was re-encoded by software from the video the agency posted. Check any passage against that audio before relying on it. Page: https://oversightarchive.org/twin-falls-id/meetings/2024-07-01/ [0:00:25] Good evening ladies and gentlemen and welcome to the July 1st, 2024 City Council meeting. I want to confirm [0:00:32] We have a quorum we have six members present in chambers and councilman stone is excused tonight [0:00:40] So first item on the agenda is the Pledge of Allegiance if you wish to join me, please rise. Hey, thank you [0:01:04] We have no proclamations tonight. So for next is the consent calendar [0:01:11] Council wishes Jason Brown move to approve. Thank you. Thank you. Do I have a second second. Thank you motion by Jason Brown second by Sherry Vomer to approve the consent calendar as written. [0:01:27] Hello, we roll call vote, please Jason Brown. Yes. Sure. You'll learn. Yes. Yes. Yes, Craig Hawkins [0:01:36] abstain Christopher Reed. Yes, that's our color. Yes [0:01:41] Thank you. Most just passes five with one of one abstention [0:01:47] Okay, next on the agenda under items of consideration is a [0:01:53] presentation a [0:01:55] Presentation of the city managers recommended budget for fiscal year 2024 2025 followed by citizen input [0:02:04] Welcome Travis [0:02:29] Madam Mayor members of the council. Thanks for the opportunity to present the budget on [0:02:34] behalf of the city of Twin Falls [0:02:37] We're gonna maybe take a step back and for some of you that have gone through this process [0:02:45] It becomes a little bit of old hat you understand what to expect and [0:02:50] One of the things that we want to do is that we want to make sure that both Sherry and Grayson will spend some time with them. [0:02:57] Understand exactly all the steps that kind of go through our budgeting process, but we also thought that would be really good for the members of our community. [0:03:04] Understand that our budgeting process isn't something that we just started tonight. [0:03:09] And so we're going to take some time in the beginning to share the processes that we use and really to illustrate that this is an all hands on deck process. [0:03:19] that night's book, I think it's 272, 278 pages of blissful reading, is the product of, I don't [0:03:33] think members of my team thinks it's blissful reading, is really a product of a lot of people, [0:03:40] and a lot of those people are in this room tonight, and so while I have the opportunity [0:03:45] to stand before you and present, and others will over the course of the next eight weeks. [0:03:51] This is a product of many hands and many minds, and we believe that it accomplishes the initial [0:03:56] goals that we set forward. [0:04:00] In the beginning, we want to talk about the legal process, and those legal processes are [0:04:04] clearly described in several sections of Idaho Code. [0:04:07] Those are provided on your screen for your review, and this is for our fiscal year that's [0:04:13] going to begin on October 1st of 2024, and we'll end on September 30th of 2025, and we [0:04:20] will refer to it as the fiscal year 25 budget. So one of the processes that we use is we [0:04:27] like to ask our citizens how are we doing, and in part of that process it's part of our [0:04:34] strategic plan to survey our citizens. And as you know, every year we go out and we ask [0:04:39] our citizens, how would you rate the quality of the services provided by the [0:04:44] many departments on an annual basis? And each year we take a look at those results, [0:04:50] we see and we try to find areas and ways to improve. We want to make sure that [0:04:57] we're providing the right services to our citizens. We examine economic [0:05:03] indicators. There are lots of different parts and pieces of our local economy [0:05:08] that in and by themselves do not tell a complete story. [0:05:13] And what we want to do is we want to take a look at all of those economic indicators [0:05:17] and we want to share them in a manner that makes sense [0:05:22] so that you can see the community through the same place that we are when we create the budget. [0:05:28] We engage our employees and really the budget that you see before you started shortly after [0:05:35] after the first week in January, the long-term planning team was led by Sean Barrigar and Mandy [0:05:43] Thompson this year. [0:05:46] Credit to them and credit to the members of the long-term planning team who met the different [0:05:51] capital requests have conversations about different additional employees that we need to be connecting [0:05:57] into our organization. [0:05:59] Huge credit to the Fleet Steering Committee team that really helped create a document that [0:06:03] help understand the rolling stock needs of our community not only today but as we go forward [0:06:10] and they take all of those needs. [0:06:12] They try to balance all the priorities from all the different departments and they try [0:06:16] to create a proposal that's not necessarily balanced but it does reflect the ongoing needs [0:06:21] of the organization. [0:06:22] If I were to create a budget as described in Idaho Code by myself it would be incomplete [0:06:29] and imperfect. [0:06:30] because I have my own preferences and I have blinders, but because we use the [0:06:35] expertise and part of the high-performance process of our organization to drive [0:06:42] home better decision-making, we're able to present a much better budget that [0:06:48] ultimately goes to a balancing process. And the balancing process isn't me and a [0:06:55] couple of members from the city manager's office and our finance team, it's 60 [0:07:00] employees who sit in this room who understand what the mission responsibilities of the organization [0:07:07] are, connecting each expenditure to the strategic plan and then creating a balanced budget that [0:07:14] is sustainable. And we refer to it as the big budget balancing bash. At least we have different [0:07:21] names for it, right? That may be the one that I call it. In each of the last few years, it's [0:07:27] been done in an afternoon, not because we're flush with cash. In fact, this budget doesn't [0:07:33] provide for all of the needs of the organization. It provides for the highest priorities, but [0:07:39] this team has the ability to create a balanced budget and move forward. And in all of that [0:07:44] process, it's transforming our government where we're balancing both the vision and the mission [0:07:50] of our organization, coupled with the values that we have to present to you a complete [0:07:56] proposal. And that effort has really produced some amazing accolades where the [0:08:03] City of Twin Falls may be the last city in the state of Idaho to receive both [0:08:08] what was formerly known as the CAFRA. Now it's referred to as the popular [0:08:13] annual finance report as well as the distinguished budget. The requirements [0:08:20] have changed. They've become more difficult to capture. We will continue to work hard to [0:08:26] make sure that we are receiving these acknowledgments, not for the sake of winning awards, but for [0:08:33] the sake of continuing to follow best practices. So credit to Matt Farnes and members of the [0:08:39] finance team who really work hard to ensure that our budget meets the necessary best practices [0:08:47] to be recognized as one of the best budgets in terms [0:08:51] of a document in the country. [0:08:53] So this budget is a team process, [0:08:55] and I get the opportunity to present it. [0:08:58] And I wanted to share that in the beginning [0:09:00] because if you were just to show up tonight [0:09:03] and you were to hear a budget presentation [0:09:05] without understanding the labor of the last six months, [0:09:08] I wouldn't be doing justice. [0:09:10] So thank you to the team who's here. [0:09:11] Thank you to the team who's not able to be here [0:09:14] for helping us to create a good solid proposal [0:09:16] for our citizens. [0:09:20] So here's some stats, right? [0:09:22] One of the things that we want to do in any conversation [0:09:25] is to make sure that we are looking at the community [0:09:29] through the exact same collection of lenses. [0:09:32] These are the lenses that we look at the city [0:09:34] of Twin Falls through. [0:09:36] Number one, we know that we're growing. [0:09:39] We know that we're averaging about a 2.28% growth rate. [0:09:43] And at that growth rate, our community population [0:09:46] is estimated to be 56,000 people. [0:09:49] It's an increase from 51,811 at the last census. [0:09:55] And if that growth rate continues at 2.28%, [0:10:00] by the year 2030 will be nearly 65,000 people. [0:10:06] And I want that to settle for a minute, [0:10:09] that the City of Twin Falls will be 65,000 people, [0:10:13] because when I first came to the Magic Valley in 2000, [0:10:18] the city of Twin Falls was about 35,000 people. But what's impacting us is not just that growth rate. [0:10:29] It is the growth of all of the surrounding communities that are growing at a faster [0:10:33] percentage than we are. And those members of the Magic Valley pour into [0:10:40] our community on a daily basis, more than 40,000 vehicles across the prime bridge every single day. [0:10:47] and our daytime population grows to 105,000 and that's the number that I want you to focus on. [0:10:54] And the reason I need the community to focus on a community of 105,000 is because that's what [0:11:00] we serve. As a service organization, we serve the members of our community and our community [0:11:08] includes more than just residents. You can see the retail sales per capita or at $28,871. [0:11:18] where the U.S. and national averages are half that, [0:11:24] based upon 2017 dollars, and then when you look [0:11:28] at our household median income, you can see [0:11:31] that we fall a bit short of both the national average [0:11:35] and the state average. [0:11:37] I think that that is a reflection that, [0:11:41] especially on the retail sales per capita, [0:11:43] the outside influence that is occurring [0:11:45] within our community, and today is not the time [0:11:48] to talk about a local option sales tax. [0:11:51] But I truly believe that if you want to have the opportunity [0:11:56] to provide the services to a community, [0:11:58] we need to look beyond giving our services for free [0:12:01] to every second person who comes into our community. [0:12:06] But if you are a private business [0:12:08] and you provided your services for free [0:12:10] to every even customer that walked in, [0:12:13] you may not be in business long. [0:12:16] And what's important is if you were, those services would be supported by those who are [0:12:20] footing the bill. [0:12:21] And the ones who are footing the bill into involves the property owners within our corporate [0:12:25] boundaries. [0:12:26] And so without a local option sales tax, it is going to continue to be strained, is again, [0:12:31] a conversation for another day. [0:12:33] But I do believe that as part of my obligation to talk about the financial concerns and issues [0:12:39] of the city as we grow forward, there needs to be other funding sources other than property [0:12:44] taxes if we are going to continue to remain vibrant and sustainable. [0:12:51] The median home is something that has grown considerably. [0:12:55] We'll spend some time talking about that in our unemployment rate sitting at 3.5%, which [0:13:00] is slightly higher than the state average and slightly lower than the national average of [0:13:04] 4%. [0:13:05] So right here talks about that median person, that fictitious person that we've created [0:13:14] about 12 years ago. And please recognize that there are no cases in which this is applied. [0:13:24] But if we take a look at the median and in traditions of what we have done in the past, [0:13:29] the budget that is presented before you will cost our residents $8.60 more per month this [0:13:34] year than next year. But let me share a quick caveat. So, my taxable value of my home decreased. [0:13:45] And as I've talked with many, although I know not all of you, [0:13:50] but a vast majority of you have seen a decrease [0:13:53] in your property values this year. [0:13:55] In fact, the decrease in my property value is greater [0:13:58] than the small increase in the tax rate for this year, [0:14:02] resulting in about a $55 annual savings in my property taxes. [0:14:09] And so when you're looking, I share that story simply [0:14:13] Because when you look here, you would see that this person would pay about $5.73 more [0:14:18] per month in property taxes. [0:14:20] If I would have used my valuation, I would be paying less in property taxes. [0:14:27] And then you'll notice that we're asking for a slight increase to cover costs associated [0:14:32] with water sewer. [0:14:34] We'll spend a lot more time talking about the fees. [0:14:38] But one of the things that we've learned is that few people are patient enough to get [0:14:43] to the end of the book. [0:14:44] So what we want to do is we want to share the last chapter first and now we'll take a minute. [0:14:48] We'll kind of tell you the rest of the story. [0:14:53] So here's some economic indicators. [0:14:57] These are the numbers that we used in the budget. [0:15:00] These are numbers that are taken from Zillow and you can see that the median value of a [0:15:07] has increased 68.2% since January of 2019, which is about when we can say that [0:15:19] significant level of growth occurred. And the reason that we picked January of [0:15:25] each one of those months is because that is the time in which the assessor uses [0:15:29] to determine the taxable value of your home, and that is the asset, so that is [0:15:38] is used to determine the taxable value of a community, [0:15:41] which then is determined the tax rate. [0:15:44] And you can see that they are projecting [0:15:46] that those increases are going to continue, [0:15:49] that there's about a 2.1% increase for Twin Falls, [0:15:53] a 2.7% increase for Idaho, [0:15:55] and about a 4.3% increase for the country as a whole. [0:16:02] I want you just to have a moment of recall [0:16:04] from one of the first slides [0:16:05] where I share the median income of a home or median income of a family in Idaho is substantially [0:16:14] less than a median income of those at the national level, but you can see that our housing [0:16:21] prices are very comparable. [0:16:25] And that's important when we start thinking about housing affordability and access, and [0:16:31] that is one of the drivers of this budget. [0:16:35] part of that concern and there's a lot going on on this graph and I'm going to try to walk [0:16:39] through it. But the bottom blue line that starts out at 94,000 and then ends like a [0:16:46] flat line at 125,000 is the homeowner's exemption. And that is the amount that the Idaho [0:16:52] legislature has set by code is the maximum owner's exemption that is allowed on a owner [0:17:01] occupied home in the state of Idaho. So the formula is $125,000 or 50% whichever is less. [0:17:13] And you can see then the bottom line of 79,000 and that 79,000 was the taxable value because [0:17:24] the median home in 2016 was estimated to be $158,500. [0:17:31] And because you can't take the maximum exemption, [0:17:34] we took 50%. [0:17:36] And you can see at that green line [0:17:39] that 50% was the most that individuals were assessed [0:17:47] on their properties until 2019. [0:17:53] And then in 2019, the value of the homes [0:17:58] started growing faster than the index. [0:18:02] And part of that reason is because the legislature [0:18:06] no longer had an index tied to the median value [0:18:11] of properties, they created a flat line. [0:18:15] And where it turns from green to red [0:18:18] is where individuals are now paying more than 50% [0:18:24] of their value in the form of property taxes. [0:18:27] And you may recall a year ago, [0:18:30] when Brianna presented one of her financial reports, [0:18:34] the increase in property tax collections [0:18:36] inside of the city of Twin Falls has been born [0:18:40] or 100% by the residential owners. [0:18:45] It's because that formula has not kept up [0:18:49] and the Idaho legislature truly needs to take a look [0:18:53] at restoring indexing. [0:18:55] Individuals will call it a tax shift. [0:18:57] And what my response would be is yes, it's a tax shift, [0:19:01] but it is shifting back to a way that it was [0:19:04] for the last four, the previous four decades. [0:19:08] And if you want to provide X relief, [0:19:12] it should be an apples to apples equity formula for all. [0:19:17] Here's another thing that I found pretty telling when you take a look at the median income of a homeowner, and then you take a look at the median value of a home, and this is a new index that was created, and Idaho is our little place in Idaho. [0:19:39] We are ranked 63rd worst place out of 1,310 counties to acquire a home. [0:19:49] And we are the worst in the state of Idaho. [0:19:52] And the reason is because our median income falls short of the median value of a home. [0:20:02] And you can see down the affordability gap right now inside of our community [0:20:10] is about $14,000. [0:20:15] So we talk about the struggles of home ownership, [0:20:17] and we talk about the ability to continue [0:20:20] to ensure that employees of our organization [0:20:24] have a place to live. [0:20:26] And so when we start looking at compensation, [0:20:28] one of the driving factors is to make sure [0:20:31] that individuals can continue to live [0:20:33] in the communities that they're serving. [0:20:35] We believe that's important, [0:20:37] that this isn't a place that they work, [0:20:38] but this is a place that they work, [0:20:40] they live and they play, create that community connection, [0:20:44] because I believe, truly, that if you live in that space, [0:20:49] you have greater connection to it. [0:20:52] Another thing that we're looking at [0:20:53] is those increasing in costs, [0:20:55] both the municipal cost index and the consumer price index, [0:20:59] and while both seem to be stabilizing, [0:21:02] not as fast as the Fed would like, [0:21:07] but costs have grown significantly since 2019, [0:21:12] And those costs are compounding. [0:21:14] And for us to be able to keep up, [0:21:17] it continues to make reductions in services [0:21:21] and to also ask for modest adjustments in service. [0:21:28] Labor is something that continues to impact all of us. [0:21:31] And while you look at a 3.5% unemployment rate, [0:21:35] you recognize that that represents [0:21:38] 902 people inside of the entire city of Twin Falls. [0:21:43] And in a year's period of time, according to the Idaho Department of Labor, we added 53 [0:21:48] labors since May. [0:21:51] But if you take a 2.27% growth rate, we've added 1,286 residents. [0:21:57] Part of that telling fact, and I believe the Secretary of State also shared this, is that [0:22:02] the individuals that are choosing to relocate and come into our community are not necessarily [0:22:07] working. [0:22:09] They're retired. [0:22:10] And so while growth has helped grow our community, they're not actively contributing to the labor force and many organizations like the City of Twin Falls continue to have physician openings. [0:22:23] I honestly cannot tell you the last time that we were fully employed. [0:22:31] And it is one of those things that puts additional strain on the members of our organization because as the community continues to grow, [0:22:41] The demand for services continues to grow, and we don't have the individuals in our organization [0:22:47] to be able to support that level of growth, it gets to be difficult. [0:22:52] It creates situations of stress and burnout. [0:22:55] And one of the things that we're doing is on apologetically pushing the envelope on compensation [0:23:01] this year. [0:23:03] We recognize that compensation is not only piece that keeps the employees in our organization, [0:23:11] we do not want to be a low-cost employer, that's not a badge that we want to wear any longer. [0:23:21] And the other thing that you'll notice is that this, while adding 3.1 million jobs, there [0:23:27] is still a deficiency of 2.3 million workers across the country. [0:23:34] But we're not the only one. [0:23:36] We're not the only one that is struggling to find additional talent. [0:23:42] And one of the great blessings of the City of Twin Falls is that we've had employees in [0:23:48] our organization have very long tenures. [0:23:52] And I think that that's a mark of equality employer. [0:23:56] The challenge that we have is those veteran stars that we have in our organization are [0:24:02] choosing retirement. [0:24:04] And as they choose retirement, we are having to bring in individuals into our organization [0:24:11] and we're also asking members of our organization [0:24:15] who stand into leadership positions [0:24:18] at a much more junior tenure than what we've asked [0:24:21] historically of them in the past. [0:24:26] All of that is used to create the budget strategies [0:24:31] that are before you. [0:24:33] Create a stable, sustainable, nimble budget. [0:24:36] The environment has not stopped changing. [0:24:38] It's just a different collection of issues this year [0:24:41] than last year and the other year. [0:24:43] And as the environment continues to change, we need to adapt to that environment. [0:24:48] We also need to be sensitive to our operating environment. [0:24:50] We need to make sure that our tax rates, our utility rates, our sensitive, which also works [0:24:59] to the bullet below. [0:25:03] We want to make sure that everything is tied to the strategic plan. [0:25:07] We also want to make sure that we continue to strive to be that employer of choice, which [0:25:11] is not just compensation, but it's continuing to drive training and in our [0:25:15] pursuit of high-performing organizations. So here is the budget in a nutshell. You [0:25:23] can see that this overall budget is about $3 million less than last year. You can [0:25:29] see the tax rate is going up slightly. You can see that we're asking for the [0:25:35] statutory allowed property tax adjustments, two and a half percent [0:25:40] increase for water to prepare for future water projects and increase [0:25:46] expenditures 5% to cover those same things but also to cover bond [0:25:50] covenants and then also we're not asking anything in the areas of sanitation and [0:25:55] recycling this year. So if you take a look at the total community and the [0:26:00] community value you'll notice that we are rate of growth this year noted in the [0:26:08] green box is much smaller than what we've realized in years past. In fact, one of the [0:26:17] interesting notes of our budget is that the new construction value at $91 million is [0:26:26] greater than the increase that we saw in the total taxable value. So without that [0:26:34] $91 million of growth, the corpus of our value actually shrunk in value, which is [0:26:41] not something that we've seen for quite a while. And when you add the urban renewal, the total [0:26:47] value of the corporation that is the City of Twin Falls inside it at that boundary is $6.8 [0:26:53] billion. You can see our tax rates over a period of time and the tax rate that were connected [0:27:01] to this budget is very similar to the budgets of 23 and 24 and among the lowest that we've [0:27:07] ever issued for the City of Twin Falls. Our new construction annexation role you can [0:27:13] see hailed in comparison to the prior three fiscal years is only slightly larger than what [0:27:20] we saw in 2021. That new construction is going to generate $439,661 in additional property [0:27:31] tax revenue. Building permit revenue is a significant portion of our revenue stream for [0:27:39] two reasons. Number one, in the upcoming budget, it's the permits that we sell through our [0:27:46] building safety department to ensure safety and structures that are going to be long-lasting. [0:27:55] The second piece of that is it aids and creates the new construction role for our community and [0:28:01] you can see that budget and actual numbers have significantly fallen since the 21 high. [0:28:09] And while we're seeing a slight increase in the number of building permits that are issued [0:28:15] comparison to last year. They still pale in comparison to what we saw in 2021, especially on the [0:28:25] new single-family home starts. One of the questions that we also get asked is, well, [0:28:33] how do our taxes in Twin Falls compare to others? And this is honestly a table that is getting [0:28:41] harder and harder to produce. A few years ago, we would only exclude two cities. We excluded [0:28:50] Meridian and Boise. And the reason we excluded them is because the Ada County Highway District [0:28:56] provides all of their transportation-related services. So our street department does an amazing [0:29:02] job. We are responsible for all the street, all the maintenance of our transportation network [0:29:08] that is done by a separate government entity in Ada County. And over the [0:29:14] course of the last couple of years the City of Napa has also fallen off. And the [0:29:20] City of Napa has fallen off is because the City of Napa no longer operates a [0:29:25] fire department that is now operated by a fire district. We've often joked with our [0:29:31] fire department especially the chief that if they step out of line we may look at [0:29:35] the same, not really. We can pick on less when he's not here. But in all reality, if [0:29:43] you think about the investments that we've made in the fire department over the [0:29:47] course of the last several years, it has been a substantial part of our budget. [0:29:53] And that's why they are also excluded. We come up with this by taking a look at [0:30:01] the tax rate and the January 23 values and so this is rear-looking and you can [0:30:07] see that we still remain one of the least expensive cities in terms of city [0:30:13] taxes in the state of Idaho for all major cities. This is only city taxes and so [0:30:22] if individuals take a look and they say I pay more you're absolutely right this [0:30:27] excludes all of the different mosquito abatement districts, the ambulance districts, it excludes [0:30:34] the colleges of their Idaho, it excludes the school district, it excludes the county. [0:30:39] This is just the city portion. [0:30:42] We focus on the city portion because that is the only piece that we have control over. [0:30:50] So that's all of the parts and pieces that go into the next section. [0:30:54] Are there any questions? [0:30:56] Any questions for Travis? [0:30:59] thorough. Thank you. So this is what our budget looks like. We're going to break it up into two [0:31:07] pieces. One is going to be the government funds. The second piece is going to be the enterprise funds. [0:31:13] Government funds are those that receive some portion of their funding from property taxes. [0:31:19] The enterprise funds are those funds that do not receive property taxes, but more importantly, [0:31:26] we operate them as though they were their own self-supporting business where they collect a fee. [0:31:31] for the opportunity to provide that service. Sewer, water, sanitation, [0:31:38] Herkisha Show, are examples of those enterprise funds where police, fire, street, airport are all part of those [0:31:50] government related funds. And then from there we break each into five different categories. [0:31:56] personnel, maintenance and operation, capital, transfers, and the waste water fund will have [0:32:04] debt. [0:32:05] So you'll notice in the general fund, we have no geo debt, and as a result, that debt piece [0:32:10] is not highlighted, but if you were to look at the water fund, that would be highlighted. [0:32:17] You'll notice that it appears that we've added a whole lot of employees, and in all [0:32:23] reality, the largest source of the increase is the folding in of the library employees that [0:32:29] have been supported by our organization and now having them be accounted for as city employees [0:32:35] as described in the Idaho Code. But new to our organization, we're asking for some combination [0:32:43] between three and six employees. The Assistant Finance Director, the Open Space Supervisor [0:32:49] and the fleet service advisor are the three employees [0:32:53] that we definitely want in the budget for sure. [0:32:56] And then the three firefighters are directly dependent [0:32:59] on our ability to receive the safer grant. [0:33:02] And so in that we've included funding for our match [0:33:07] should we be successful in capturing that grant. [0:33:10] That's a grant that the council gave permission [0:33:13] to the city staff to apply for. [0:33:16] Adding three additional firefighters is not the end [0:33:19] us adding firefighters in fact, we will be continuing to look at adding additional firefighters [0:33:23] to make sure that we're continuing to meet NFPA standards to fight fire structures on [0:33:29] residential structures. And as we continue to look at the creation of fire station number five at [0:33:37] some point in the future, we want to make sure that we have the staffing to be able to move [0:33:42] into that direction and those three firefighters are a part of that. The last is an upgrade from [0:33:48] a street operator position to a lead operator to provide greater leadership, but also upward [0:33:55] opportunities for members inside of our organization. You can see that the maintenance and operations [0:34:02] portion of our budget is going up about 1.95%. It's about $418,000 this year. And then you'll [0:34:14] notice that we're adding an additional $23.5 million to capital. It is less than last year's [0:34:22] 30 million but you'll recall that we had the SLFRF funding that really created [0:34:28] that larger balloon. There is some SLFRF funding in this budget as well and as [0:34:36] our auditors share during their presentation it's really hard to get a [0:34:40] pulse on those finances as that large infusion of money has come in and we're [0:34:45] completing those projects moving forward. So we shared that one of the things that [0:34:52] we do is we'd like to tie every part of our budget directly to the city's strategic plan. [0:34:58] And as you're aware, when we had our workshop, we had our initial conversation and we believe [0:35:03] that strategic planning is important and we've hired Gushlin and Associates to help us work [0:35:09] through that process. [0:35:10] We also recognize that when we started this process of a longer vision strategic plan in [0:35:16] We had 18 years, and quickly we're down to six. [0:35:24] And so one of the good conversations that I thought that we had was kind of lengthening [0:35:29] that goal post to the year of 2014. [0:35:32] And so members of our team have been working with Phil and thank you to Gretchen for the [0:35:37] hard work that she's doing right now on the back end for our strategic plan, and we will [0:35:42] kick off a robust citizen engaged, employee engaged, council engaged process in the fall. [0:35:49] We didn't want to layer that on top of the budget. We felt that that might be a little [0:35:53] bit hard of a lift. And we also wanted to get through this piece to say, how has our community [0:35:59] changed and what things do we need to be aware of for the year 2040 to have that community? [0:36:07] What's interesting is when I helped create the 2030 Strategic Plan, I had a belief that [0:36:14] I would still be working and my hope was still with the City of Flint Falls and I have maybe [0:36:19] six more years to get there, not cross my finish line. [0:36:23] And I can say with a high degree of certainty, I will not be here in 2040. [0:36:28] And that it's a fascinating place to be thinking about how to provide services, the types of [0:36:36] services, and how a community is going to be transforming beyond a time of your tenure. [0:36:43] And so it's going to, it's that recognition that we hope to leave it a little bit better [0:36:50] than we found it, and that we continually to build upon the successes we need to be mindful [0:36:55] of where we're going. So Focus Area 1 and Focus Area 7 will be the two focus areas that [0:37:04] that we'll focus in on at the July 15th meeting. [0:37:10] These are a couple of the highlights [0:37:12] that we pulled out of the budget [0:37:14] that directly connect to the city's strategic plan. [0:37:17] You can see that the $1.9 million for the park is included. [0:37:24] The restrooms that we're using CDBG at the city park [0:37:28] are included, parks, facilities, [0:37:32] as well as parking lot improvement, all part of that accessible community. [0:37:38] The library is probably one of the larger driving forces associated with the learning [0:37:43] community and you can see that we need to modernize the elevator and we're going to [0:37:47] replace some carpet in the library. [0:37:51] Inside of the police department they're looking at vehicles as well as some replacement of canines [0:37:57] and you'll see these payments for not only the two apparatus but also the fire station [0:38:04] that we're using impact fees to cover. [0:38:07] Recognize I'm going through these focus areas quickly. [0:38:16] I'm saying that gering that over the course [0:38:21] of the next eight weeks, members of our team [0:38:25] will be making 60 to 80 minute presentations [0:38:30] on each of these focus areas. [0:38:32] I just wanted to provide a quick highlight. [0:38:36] You can see all the street airport [0:38:38] And Durky's Lake, and just showing falls improvement as we continue to work for being [0:38:43] accessible, we continue to make investments in our transportation system, and you can see [0:38:50] this year it's going to be sizable and significant. And as we continue to grow, [0:38:58] and as the price of not only asphalt but labor to assist with routine performance activities, [0:39:05] It continues to grow and we need to find the resources to maintain something as critical and [0:39:10] viable as our transportation system. Inside of being an environmental community it talks about [0:39:19] the different projects that we have predominantly in the water and the wastewater fund and this is [0:39:25] really part of the larger bulk of capital that we have moving forward and the council not only today [0:39:32] but also past councils have been very mindful of making sure that the infrastructure that we [0:39:38] have, both in the ground and above ground, is a solid platform that will allow us to build [0:39:45] and grow the community in the future. [0:39:47] A prosperous community section really talks about us growing and expanding our tax base. [0:39:52] We're working with the Urban Renewal Agency, not only on economic development related areas, [0:39:58] but also the creation of a new revenue allocation area in the southwest part of our community. [0:40:05] a responsible community is part of that council capital. We spent some time, and this is one [0:40:12] that we started to prime that conversation piece, of we have three, probably more, but [0:40:21] we have three projects that are in need of a funding strategy and solution over the course [0:40:31] of the next years. [0:40:33] And so all three are here. [0:40:36] Two of these projects we've already received funding [0:40:39] from the council to begin preliminary architecture. [0:40:43] And that's the pool remodel and the city attorney [0:40:48] and the city gym space. [0:40:50] And Mitch presented what that initial concept looks [0:40:54] like with the city pool remodel. [0:40:57] And it's not complete. [0:40:59] But what you saw cost $1.2 million. [0:41:03] And to expand that and to grow that, it will cost more. [0:41:08] The evidence and police training facility [0:41:10] is the facility that was discussed and presented [0:41:14] to the SLFRF committee. [0:41:16] And as I had an opportunity to take a tour of the police [0:41:20] department as part of my annual tours, [0:41:23] I saw firsthand the evidence storage facilities that we have. [0:41:29] And because the courts are requiring us to hold on to stuff longer, and that we're required [0:41:35] to maintain that chain of evidence, the spaces that we have are inadequate, and creating a [0:41:43] true police evidence facility that vehicles can be brought into the inside of a condition [0:41:49] space for inspection and investigation, as well as creating a space where training facilities [0:41:57] can occur. [0:41:58] right now we're dismantling classrooms and then we're having to reassemble them [0:42:02] after the training activities have occur. Our all projects that are here will be [0:42:09] talking about different ways. One is a certificate of participation, another is [0:42:13] the use of cash reserves, another is buying these off in smaller chunks and [0:42:19] pieces as we move forward, but we wanted to present all of those going forward. [0:42:25] Being an internal organization that heart of our strategic plan is intentionally there because we are a service organization, the services that we offered are provided by amazing employees. [0:42:39] And those amazing employees are probably one of the most scariest resources that we have and the best, in my opinion, the best recruitment strategy is not have to recruit at all. [0:42:54] and to retain the quality employees that we have. [0:42:56] And so we're asking the council for a 6% compensation adjustment. [0:43:00] We're asking for a 3% table move. [0:43:03] We're asking for continued funding $900 to the VIBA. [0:43:07] We're looking at continued contributions to the HSA. [0:43:12] Funding health insurance and continuation of our retention program. [0:43:16] On the employee side. [0:43:19] And then wanted to joke, Kathy's here. [0:43:24] Kathy is here to ensure that I don't recommend the removal of the bucket truck. [0:43:29] It's an asset that has been, you've been following our budget, [0:43:34] it has been an asset that has been asked for repeatedly, [0:43:37] and it is absolutely expensive, and it is time to replace it. [0:43:41] So we would ask you to do that as well as the other items that are included on that list. [0:43:51] Here's the calendar. In the beginning of the budget process, [0:43:54] we said that it was pre-season and tonight's the first game and here's what [0:44:01] the calendar of events looks like over the course of the next several weeks to [0:44:09] critical dates on this on August 5th the council is going to adopt a [0:44:15] preliminary budget which is going to set the maximum spending and so we need [0:44:23] do know if the council wants to include any of those three larger capital projects on that [0:44:32] evening. So that's the first target and then also on that evening we'll have a public hearing [0:44:38] for the different rate adjustments that help create a balanced budget and that will be led [0:44:43] by our finance director, Brian Howard and then on the 19th we'll have the statutorily required [0:44:50] public hearing. But what's unique about the City of Twin Falls process is that we [0:44:55] don't wait until the 19th. We have citizen engagement that we ask the citizens to [0:45:02] engage repeatedly over the course of the next several months in this process. We [0:45:07] recognize that not everybody can get to a five o'clock meeting and that's why we [0:45:11] place this information online. We make ourselves available to respond to emails, [0:45:15] to phone calls and then also as the council has allowed providing a couple [0:45:21] of minutes at the conclusion of this for citizens to share their thoughts on the [0:45:25] then-in conclusion we really believe that the budget that is presented here is a [0:45:33] solid long-term sustainable solution that will move to involves into the future. [0:45:38] With that we are happy to answer any of the initial questions that you may have. [0:45:44] you all read it covered it. Thank you very much for that presentation and to all [0:45:59] this you and all the staff for a very thorough budget you'll be watching you for [0:46:05] the next several weeks. So as Travis mentioned we're going to give a few [0:46:13] minutes to anybody in the audience who wishes to have input on the budget today. [0:46:21] We'll move to other general public input in a minute but specifically if there's [0:46:25] anyone who wishes to comment on the budget. You're welcome to come down to the mic. [0:46:31] Okay, seeing no one. Now is the time for general public input which is on [0:46:41] subjects not on today's agenda. There's anybody in the audience that wishes to [0:46:46] address the council. I'll put the three of you on the spot one of these days. [0:46:54] Okay advisory board reports crazy and among so there's not much going on city [0:47:08] manager's office just a couple of quick items number one this Thursday is the [0:47:19] Independence holiday and the city will be sponsoring the fireworks again this [0:47:24] year. There's lots of detailed information on our website about the events that are going [0:47:30] to be occurring at the College of Southern Idaho. We encourage everyone to come out to [0:47:36] participate and truly celebrate our nation's birthday. The second is in recognition of that. [0:47:42] We recognize that it falls a little differently than in past years and so we will not be meeting [0:47:48] on the eighth and we'll give time for people to travel and come back from family celebrations [0:47:54] in our next City Council meeting will be on the 15th of July. [0:47:58] Thank you, Sherry. [0:48:00] A couple of weeks or so ago, some of us had attended the AIC, which is the Association [0:48:08] of Idaho Cities Conference, and which was for me, it was absolutely wonderful for the information [0:48:17] of collaborating with the other cities within Idaho, but I did want to give a recognition [0:48:23] to Craig. He is our district representative for the area for AIC. So that's awesome. I [0:48:34] love to be I'm glad that we're being represented. Great cheerleader. Chris, did you have some? [0:48:40] I just wanted to ask and see if any of our police officers that are in attendance or [0:48:45] fire if they would like to talk about fireworks. We've received several emails, see if they would [0:48:53] like to address anything every every year we kind of do this and I don't want to [0:49:00] have you miss an opportunity to talk about fireworks something that you guys [0:49:04] absolutely love I believe that's the first time today correct you yes madam [0:49:12] mayor first time today thank you for the opportunity council like mayor and [0:49:17] council as Mr. Rothweiler mentioned Thursday is the 4th of July our nation's [0:49:25] birthday. A day that the City of Twin Falls has worked to secure a great [0:49:32] fireworks show that has been permitted through our city permitting process and [0:49:37] will take place off the on the grounds of the College of Southern Idaho. Lots of [0:49:43] areas for our citizens and neighbors to view this wonderful fireworks show. As [0:49:49] As the Chief of Police for the City, I would remind everybody that in the City of Twin Falls, [0:49:57] safe and sane fireworks are legal and are okay to utilize and set off by the individuals [0:50:05] within our city limits. That statute also applies in the County of Twin Falls. I would also say [0:50:14] that anything that goes up in the air goes boom very loudly and may be considered really [0:50:20] fun that is not being set off by the professionals that are permitted is against the law. [0:50:27] I have instructed the members of the Twin Falls Police Department and our 9-1-1 communication [0:50:32] center when we receive those complaints that come into our 9-1-1 communication center. [0:50:37] Those calls will be listed onto the board, the computer in each of the officer's vehicles. [0:50:44] I will tell you that it's a very busy time of year for our police department and our brethren [0:50:49] at the fire department. [0:50:52] Under the law, members of the police department, including our code enforcement division and [0:50:58] members of the fire department, may seize illegal fireworks. [0:51:02] If appropriate, we may issue summonses charging people for igniting those fireworks in violation [0:51:10] of state code and or city code. [0:51:14] But if we cannot prove that a crime was committed, we did not witness that action taking place. [0:51:19] Or if a neighbor would like to sign, if a witness would like to sign a ticket against [0:51:24] somebody for sending those off, we will certainly take that proper enforcement action. [0:51:29] Again, this is going to be a high-call load next couple of nights for our men and women [0:51:35] in blue and probably our neighbors across the alley in red. [0:51:39] Well, now they don't wear red anymore, but their trucks are really pretty red. [0:51:44] Yes, they wear the black uniforms, but nice red trucks, apparatus. [0:51:50] And in order to keep the community safe, we are asking our neighbors, our residents, to [0:51:58] abide by the ordinances, to abide by the state code. [0:52:02] And if you don't, there's a chance you could get a hefty fine, and you may spend a lot [0:52:07] of money on those fireworks and members of the Twin Falls Police Corps may take them [0:52:12] and destroy them without them going boom. So please don't do that. I know that you [0:52:17] can go outside of Twin Falls County and sign a waivers and buy fireworks saying [0:52:22] that you won't use them in in the state. I've also been doing this for almost 35 [0:52:28] years. I know that people will sign that and not be truthful. So please don't [0:52:34] I've asked our neighbors and our members that are listening, please just don't set those [0:52:39] off. [0:52:40] We'll have great shows going on in the city, a great show that the city's putting on, that [0:52:45] you can just come out and watch and I have to pay for it because we're paying for it [0:52:49] as an organization, as your tax dollars, right, and donations, and you don't have to clean [0:52:54] up the mess. [0:52:55] We'll take care of that for you too. [0:52:56] So does that answer your question, Councilor? [0:52:59] It does. [0:53:00] Just a reminder. [0:53:01] Every year I started hearing them last week, all the fire stations, the stands are all open right now. [0:53:08] We've received some input already via email and so I just, I think it's important to just let everybody know. [0:53:18] I would also remind those people, everybody, that the law in the state of Idaho, which mirrors the ordinance of our city of Twin Falls, [0:53:27] allows for the sale and the use of fireworks between the 23rd of June and [0:53:33] midnight on July 5th. So, setting off fireworks on the 6th of July, even safe [0:53:41] and sane, is totally illegal. Chief Rex, next, rebuttal. [0:53:52] I'm not going to come up here in the bay, but I appreciate the opportunity. I do [0:53:56] appreciate the support and the nice vehicles that we do have. So what I would [0:54:02] like to say is just real quick, just a safety tip, the biggest thing for us and [0:54:07] what caused the most problems last year was the disposal of the fireworks. We had [0:54:13] seven or eight major fires last year during the 4th of July, so it's I [0:54:18] encourage residents those that are celebrating to make sure that they [0:54:22] discard them properly, put them in water in a container that's non-combustable and away [0:54:29] from the house. [0:54:30] That's really what we ask. [0:54:33] Other than that, be safe and have a good celebration. [0:54:36] So, thank you. [0:54:38] Thank you. [0:54:40] Okay. [0:54:41] That is it for our meeting. [0:54:43] So we are adjourned. [0:54:44] Thank you, everyone.