Oversight Archive: City Council meeting, 2024-09-16, recording 1 (started 17:00) Machine transcript (faster-whisper base.en), not checked word for word; the Pledge of Allegiance is shown in its standard wording. The recording is the record. Times are time into the recording. Passages with private details are muted in the audio and marked here. The audio on the page below was re-encoded by software from the video the agency posted. Check any passage against that audio before relying on it. Page: https://oversightarchive.org/twin-falls-id/meetings/2024-09-16/ [0:01:18] Good evening, ladies and gentlemen, and welcome to the September 16th, 2024 City Council meeting. [0:01:25] I want to confirm we have a quorum. We have all seven members present in chambers. [0:01:31] First item on the agenda is the Pledge of Allegiance. If you wish to join me, please rise. [0:01:56] Thank you. [0:01:57] Hey, we have one proclamation tonight. [0:02:01] Proclamation for Constitution Week, September 15th through 21st, 2024, whereas the Constitution [0:02:12] of the United States of America, the guardian of our liberties, embodies the principles [0:02:17] of limited government in a republic dedicated to rule by law, and whereas September 17th, [0:02:24] 2024 marks the 237th anniversary of the forming of the Constitution of the United States of [0:02:31] America by the Constitutional Convention and whereas it is fitting in proper to accord [0:02:38] official recognition to this magnificent document and its memorable anniversary and [0:02:45] to the patriotic celebrations which will commemorate it and whereas public law 915 [0:02:52] guarantees the issuing of a proclamation each year by the President of the United States [0:02:59] designating September 15 through 21st is Constitution Week, therefore, I [0:03:05] Ruth Pierce, Mayor of the City of Twin Falls, do hereby proclaim September 15 [0:03:12] through 21st 2024 as Constitution Week and ask our citizens to reaffirm the [0:03:18] ideals the framers of the Constitution had in 1787 by vigilantly protecting the [0:03:26] freedoms guaranteed to us through this guardian of our liberties and we have [0:03:31] Dr. Wendy French here Wendy. May I have just a few moments after the proclamation to [0:03:48] talk about Bells across America? This also marks Bells across America which on [0:04:11] September 17th which is tomorrow so tomorrow at 4 p.m. Eastern Standard Time [0:04:17] and 2 p.m. Men amount in Standard Time please ring a bell because this is [0:04:24] monumental in our history. This was done the first day at the Constitution when it [0:04:29] was signed. So Madam Mayor, there's a bear bill for you, one for each of the [0:04:36] council members. Thank you. Next on the agenda is the consent calendar Craig [0:05:04] Hawkins. Mayor would like to make a motion to approve this consent calendar is [0:05:08] written. Thank you to have a second. Second. Thank you motion by Craig Hawkins [0:05:14] seconded by Jason Brown to approve the consent calendar as written. Jody Rokalvo please. [0:05:20] Chris Reed. Yes. Ray Calkins. Yes. Spencer Cutler. Yes. Jason Brown. Yes. [0:05:28] Ruth Pierce. Yes. Sherry Volmer. Yes. Grayson Stone. Yes. Thank you. Motion passes 7-0. [0:05:35] Hey, first under items of consideration is an action item. Request to award a construction bid [0:05:44] for Chisholm Falls Grade to RS-Jauber Inc. in the amount of $2,447,578.2,447,578.30 and allow [0:06:01] the City Engineer to sign the contract along with reserving $24,758 for unforeseen contingency [0:06:12] utilizing 335,668 of Derkey's reserves to complete the project as bid and we have our city engineer, Troy Vitek. Welcome, Troy. [0:06:23] Thank you, Madam Mayor and Council members. So tonight, I'm coming before the Council. I think you guys are all aware of it for the position, Mike, yes, sorry, for the public behind me. [0:06:31] I'm bringing it before you. Social and Falls, great project. Again, this was previously contemplated in the SLF RF projects as an option as well as a previously bid. [0:06:41] the project originally came in over a bit as we originally scoped it. So we went back to the engineer, [0:06:47] we designed it and broken into smaller bytes. We were fortunate enough to receive two bits this time, [0:06:52] one from RS Jabber and the other from the same bidder who actually increased their price to slightly. [0:06:58] The unfortunate part is part of this bidding environment that we're in, [0:07:05] those prices have escalated a little bit. So when we originally presented this to the SLF RF committee, [0:07:10] They awarded $2,895,000. [0:07:14] We've expended some of that for engineering for design and as well as going back to the bidding process. [0:07:20] In order to fund the entire project, as we currently have at bid, we need around $335,000 of Durkeys reserves. [0:07:29] That leaves us, the engineering group, 10% contingency in case we run into our rock or something we just can't anticipate at this time. [0:07:36] This road is very old and I think it was originally hand stacked rock [0:07:40] We believe we understand it pretty well, but we just always want to have a little bit there [0:07:46] To kind of explain the road a little bit the city of Twin Falls owns from the ticket booth [0:07:53] Down the grade [0:07:55] Of course all the way in the show shown falls as well as up to Durkeys area [0:08:00] That's the portion that would be reconstructed the roadway portion would be constructed as part of that [0:08:05] There's also removing of the rock knob in this location and a bike portion of this is going to start at the Durkeys parking lot [0:08:15] Come parallel to the roadway till you get right about in this area and then it diverges and kind of comes behind [0:08:21] and onto this road, quite jamplin road. At that point we're going to try to eventually connect it down here [0:08:29] That would be an extension in the camaroon trail essentially all the way from the gun club [0:08:32] to Turkey's Park and then beyond into Quelridge. [0:08:36] So, at this, tonight I'm asking to utilize the remainder of the SLF-RF funds which currently [0:08:43] has $2,650,838, those are already budgeted and attributed as well as used $335,668 as the [0:08:52] Turkish reserves and sign a contract with this RS-Jobber and I can stand for any questions. [0:08:59] Okay, just to be clear, the SLFRF money left is 2.35668, correct? [0:09:12] And with the Derkey's funds of 335, 66830, that should total the... [0:09:19] Sorry, there's a lot of numbers on the sheet. [0:09:22] Yeah. [0:09:23] There actually is $2,653,868 available. [0:09:26] But you use that. [0:09:28] Of the two. [0:09:29] Sorry. [0:09:30] and then I need to use additional $297,000 for engineering which leaves the remainder. [0:09:38] Yes, I have an expend of that $297,000. [0:09:42] We have two million, three, 56, 668 available. [0:09:46] We're going to add the 335, 668, 30 from Derkeys. [0:09:51] That equals two million, 692, 3, 630, which [0:09:57] is the total of the 242.4 plus the 10% reserve, correct? [0:10:05] I also needed 297 million, sorry, 297,000. [0:10:09] Sorry, Mary, for making this complicated. [0:10:12] So you need our approval on the 297 as well as the other. [0:10:18] So I need the $2,653,868 currently set aside as well as the $335,000 additional. [0:10:27] Okay. [0:10:30] Do you got that, Jason? [0:10:34] Yeah. [0:10:35] So, Troy, do you want to, so you need, just so I have the numbers right, what was the, [0:10:40] 653,868. [0:10:41] Okay. [0:10:42] Plus the 335,668,630 with the Derkey's Reserve. [0:10:53] And our goal is to not utilize all that. [0:10:55] We're going to try to take some of this work in-house. [0:10:58] So the 2 million, 653,000 is SLFRF funds. [0:11:05] That's currently what's in place. [0:11:07] And then I took off the engineering portion, which would have left the construction portion [0:11:11] I would actually expend on that dollar. [0:11:21] So just, I guess again, so you're asking to spend the 2.447578 plus 244,000 and it [0:11:33] will present reserve plus you need approval for the engineering of 297. [0:11:41] Correct. [0:11:42] Yes. [0:11:43] Not quite what that said, but get there. [0:11:48] Well, if we mess up on numbers in the motion, let me know. [0:11:53] But, Troy, Madam Mayor, can I ask a question? [0:11:56] Sure. [0:11:57] I know there's a couple others. [0:11:59] So, go ahead. [0:12:00] So, it is, you know, a couple months ago we talked about this project, or I should say, [0:12:05] probably about a year ago, roughly. [0:12:07] So, you'll do whatever that was talked about at that time, resurfacing the grade, [0:12:13] taking off that really sharp corner or what we joked about at the time is the knob, right? [0:12:20] Yes, yes, Council Member. It does resurface the whole roadway, essentially from the ticket booth, [0:12:26] to both Turkey's parking lot, and then approximately, I don't know if you can see, [0:12:31] out in here, where the Chisholle Farce Park RV parking is, where we stopped our previous project. [0:12:37] Perfect. The entire roadway takes off that and does some bike path and some drainage improvements. [0:12:42] and kind of realigns this corner so it's it's difficult to see because it's easier to see as they come down off [0:12:52] this is anticipated to start ASAP we're going to shut down the park i'll come winter time and be [0:12:59] able to do it through the winter and have it open so we rarely don't affect the liturism that happens [0:13:06] here kris free you have a question yeah just the the bike path you had mentioned [0:13:14] And from Derke's to Chaplain Road, we're going to be doing some improvements. [0:13:18] That sounds like we'll be able to do that with these funds. [0:13:20] Yes, we'll be able to connect the evil trail, I mean that connected through that. [0:13:29] This doesn't include a portion between what we're going to call Chaplain Road, that's [0:13:33] us. [0:13:35] Shown on this to the picnic area, there's a portion there that is missing. [0:13:39] I'm going to try to work with the contractor, he needs a place to put this rock that comes [0:13:45] off of this rock knob we're gonna try to incentivize creating something through [0:13:50] there thank you. [0:13:55] Grayson did you have a question? [0:13:58] Yes thank you Madam Mayor. So Troy so when I add up the number so at the 2.4 [0:14:02] million and then we've got the 240,000 I'm looking at an Excel spreadsheet for [0:14:09] those who can't I just pull it up real quick did some math so it puts us [0:14:13] roughly at two million six hundred ninety two thousand three hundred and thirty cents [0:14:18] And from that is what we apply the 335,000, 668 to correct. [0:14:24] Yes. [0:14:25] Okay. [0:14:26] Just want to make sure I've got my head on appropriately. [0:14:27] Thank you. [0:14:28] Anybody else? [0:14:32] Except a motion. [0:14:34] Are you ready? [0:14:35] We'll give it a shot. [0:14:36] I'll make a motion unless somebody else has it. [0:14:39] Well, there was some conversation over on that side. [0:14:42] Did you guys have some? [0:14:43] You want to add? [0:14:44] I think what Grayson just explained has it right. [0:14:47] I got my spreadsheet. [0:14:51] Sherry, did you have something else? [0:14:53] Okay. [0:14:54] Okay, so move to approve or move to award a construction bid for Chisholm Falls Grade [0:15:00] to RS-Jauber Inc. in the amount of $2,697,336.30 with the use of what I have is SLFR funds, [0:15:18] F-R-F funds in the amount of, what's the S-L-L-L? [0:15:28] Two million, 356,668 dollars and 30 cents, [0:15:36] and then also you, Durkey Reserves funds in the amount of 335,668. [0:15:44] And so I'm just going to correct you, it's 2,692, not 2,697. [0:15:54] Okay, the city engineer to sign the contract. Yeah, and yes, and the city engineer to sign the contract [0:16:06] You need the 297 in there? [0:16:11] 297 for that's our construction engineering oversight. Okay, plus plus [0:16:17] 297 [0:16:18] Thousand dollars for engineering construction are oversight. That correct? [0:16:26] Sherry Vomer [0:16:28] I dare I second okay [0:16:30] Motion by Jason Brown, seconded by Sherry Volmer to approve. [0:16:36] Award the construction bid for Shoshone Falls, [0:16:39] great to RS-Jauber, Inc. [0:16:40] in the amount of $2,447,578.30 plus a 10% contingency [0:16:47] of $244,758 for a total of $2,692,336.30 [0:16:54] to 336.30 to be used to be paid for by 2.32,356,668 in SLF RF funds and 335,668.30 in [0:17:14] Durkies reserves and [0:17:19] Authorized [0:17:20] 297 to 200 to be paid out of the SLF art funds as well [0:17:26] How's that hey? [0:17:29] any further discussion? [0:17:32] Jody roll call vote, please [0:17:34] Chris read yes Jason Brown. Yes race and stone. Yes. Yes. Yes. Hey cockens. Yes. Yes. Jerry Volmer. Yes [0:17:46] Motion passes 7 to 0. Thank you [0:17:48] I guess you're up next here. [0:17:50] I thought they missed you. [0:17:53] Mr. Cutler. [0:17:54] Yes. [0:17:56] Thank you. [0:17:57] Motion passes 7-0. [0:17:58] Didn't quite sound like enough. [0:18:01] Okay. [0:18:02] Thank you, Troy, on that one. [0:18:06] The next item on the agenda is an action item. [0:18:09] It's a request to authorize city engineering staff to use 60,000 to acquire right-of-way [0:18:17] a long Eastland Drive and to allow a full road closure on Eastland during [0:18:23] roadway this reconstruction. There's probably two different items. So maybe we [0:18:30] do the first one first. The first one really what I'm here tonight asking for is [0:18:34] $60,000. So as many of you know we've won a bit of eight million change for [0:18:41] we're reconstructing this roadway. [0:18:45] It's an old concrete section that's since failed, [0:18:48] and there's some mass fault north of here, [0:18:50] but the stadium especially, that's in need of some attention. [0:18:54] So our goal is we put in for a grant, [0:18:58] we reward the grant for $8 million, [0:19:01] and our intention is to redo the roadway. [0:19:03] We thought, what a great opportunity. [0:19:05] Let's see if we can create a little bit more capacity. [0:19:07] So we've asked our engineers to look at [0:19:09] We need to go out and purchase some properties, we've currently negotiated one with one home, [0:19:41] I need to come to the council and see if you would like to do that. [0:19:46] We took their price per square foot, kind of extrapolated for the rest of the properties we intend on talking to. [0:19:52] Here, so we believe the 60,000 covers all the properties. [0:19:55] Our intent is to gather more right away so we can do a capacity improvement in this section. [0:20:02] We cannot guarantee that. We haven't approached everybody yet, but that's our real intent. [0:20:07] We think it'll leave the benefit of snower in the future if we can obtain this. [0:20:10] this is absolutely impact fee related and can be paid for through impact fees so [0:20:16] the it's just a transfer of the budget from impact fee into the city funds in [0:20:23] order to utilize this so that's our goal here tonight is kind of I think we should [0:20:28] talk about that first and then I'll ask the second question of the question [0:20:32] afterwards. Any questions on the 60,000 asked Chris Reed? No questions I'm [0:20:40] I'm excited we've been talking about this for a long time. [0:20:43] This is an area that's needed, that improvement, [0:20:45] that widening, grateful for the grant [0:20:48] to be able to at least give us this opportunity. [0:20:50] That was always the stumbling block for us. [0:20:52] We could purchase it, but we could never build it. [0:20:55] So we're at that point right now. [0:20:57] So I don't know if we want to do two different [0:21:02] items or actions. [0:21:03] Yeah, we're not ready to talk quite, talk about the second one. [0:21:06] So let's just do the 60. [0:21:08] Okay. [0:21:09] To start with, do you have a question, Jason? [0:21:12] Okay, go ahead, Chris. [0:21:13] Move to approve the authorization of city engineering staff [0:21:16] to use up to 60,000 to acquire right of way [0:21:19] along Eastland Drive as presented tonight. [0:21:22] Thank you, Jason Brown. [0:21:23] Second. [0:21:24] Thank you, motion by Chris Reed. [0:21:26] Seconded by Jason Brown to approve the authorization [0:21:31] of authorizing city staff to use up to 60,000 [0:21:35] to acquire right of way along Eastland Drive. [0:21:39] Any further discussion? [0:21:41] Jody Rokow-Volt please. [0:21:44] Grayson Stone. [0:21:45] Yes. [0:21:45] Jerry Volmer. [0:21:46] Yes. [0:21:47] Spencer Cutler. [0:21:48] Yes. [0:21:48] Jason Brown. [0:21:49] Yes. [0:21:50] Greg Hawkins. [0:21:50] Yes. [0:21:51] Chris Reed. [0:21:52] Yes. [0:21:52] Ruth Pierce. [0:21:53] Yes. [0:21:55] Ocean passes 7 to 0. [0:21:57] Thank you. [0:21:57] Thank you. [0:21:58] On the second portion of this, I [0:22:00] don't know if we really need an action item. [0:22:02] I'm trying to get your guys' input. [0:22:03] So as an engineer, we often are [0:22:06] confronted with these difficulties. [0:22:07] This is a large road project on a major arterial [0:22:10] for the city in Twin Falls. [0:22:11] North-South, the farm to market, the beach truck, stuff like that. Our goal is to make [0:22:16] the duration as short as possible. So we have to go forward and bid this project. [0:22:20] How do we do that? We emit traffic on it and now North-South at the same time [0:22:26] we're trying to construct it. There's a help or we can shut it down completely. [0:22:32] That helps the construction but really impacts the residences of the Twin Falls. [0:22:37] There's a cost savings there. If we can do it before we bid the project or if we [0:22:43] We can notify the bidder that they have these options. [0:22:45] We can see some cost savings from 20% to 50% possibly in the road closure portion of it. [0:22:51] I would guess probably more around 20%, but the duration could be significantly reduced [0:22:56] 50% as well. [0:22:59] A road like this in Napa takes 16 months to construct to redo 16 months this long time. [0:23:08] Even 8 months is a long time. [0:23:09] I don't know what the council's got reaction is there. [0:23:14] feels difficult for me but I want to give you guys all the options and kind of [0:23:18] just get a general consensus of how would you like engineering to proceed [0:23:22] with this because I believe you guys will get calls one way or the other and I [0:23:25] want to really get your feelings on what does the tolerance for or even a [0:23:31] partial closer say we can do options like that you have two months of full [0:23:35] closure but after that you have to open it to both ways there's a lot of options [0:23:39] on the table really give any direction I just kind of want to give a real [0:23:44] feeling the way you guys are interested in so I can write the contract appropriately. [0:23:48] So Troy, one of the things I recall is when we worked on the intersection of Falls in [0:23:55] Eastland, there was a combination of I think we closed the intersection for a period of [0:24:03] time which saves some money and the contractor I think could do I think and so we had a couple [0:24:12] options to look at. I guess my question would be could we have a couple options in the bid [0:24:19] so we know what we're looking at. I mean in my mind there's all sorts of studies that [0:24:24] go from 70% cost savings to 20% to time savings of one weekend versus a month. So that would [0:24:35] be my question. But everybody wants to comment so I'm going to let everybody speak and then [0:24:41] Maybe you can take your guys's input and take it back to my team [0:24:45] I come up with a recommendation that we can come back to you before we actually do the bid [0:24:50] but [0:24:51] Just trying to get your feelings on it because this is a huge impact [0:24:54] Well, I have five names up here, so you'll get it. Oh listen Chris read do we remember how long we closed the falls? [0:25:02] Intersection or I think we allowed hands or something [0:25:06] very long [0:25:08] Our team said I think we allowed 60 days or council out up to 60 days. I think they did in 42. Yeah [0:25:16] Honestly, I would not be willing to go longer than I mean at first it was two months tops [0:25:23] Past that I think that that's a thoroughfare that if we're gonna shut that down for that long that that's gonna cause some pain [0:25:29] For the businesses around there for the community [0:25:32] Are you talking the full-length of no I was just talking that little intersection [0:25:38] Sorry, that was the full length of east and that is an option. We can go from falls to Fyler Fyler to Addison [0:25:44] There's a lot of options in there too. Our goal would not to be close to that [0:25:48] Everything down, but there's a water line being replaced at the same time [0:25:51] I guess my question is the road that we're gonna be working on is it from falls to Kimberly Road not far? [0:26:01] He'll crest [0:26:10] Hawkins. There's private residents along that road. Would they be able to get to their homes? [0:26:18] Yeah, absolutely. But the road would stay close to local traffic only. Okay, and so we always have [0:26:24] to provide them access through the entire project of the church there. Grayson? Thank you, Madam Mayor. [0:26:31] Some I kind of frame this in my head is how we spend taxpayer dollars versus accessibility to the area. [0:26:38] My preference would be we go back to the contractor and have them explore their options and with prices [0:26:45] per option with the timeline and then we proceed from there but [0:26:49] for the cost savings because it sounds like baseball what you're saying that it boils down to [0:26:54] cost savings and close it down longer, but what's that timeline? [0:26:58] How do we you know hold them to the timeline? [0:27:01] So my preference would be to see all of our options for sure because we're stewards of our taxpayers dollars [0:27:07] but we're also people got to move around town. [0:27:10] The hard part there is we have to write the bid and kind of offer it to everybody afterwards. [0:27:18] Well, last time didn't they come to us based on the contractor. [0:27:27] We didn't actually allow them to do any closure. [0:27:29] And the contractor came and said, hey, I can do this in two months instead of six months or whatever the contractor allowed. [0:27:35] The council was like, okay, so that is an option. [0:27:40] But we got the bid for the full six work versus Spencer. [0:27:48] Thank you, Mayor. [0:27:49] So having been a construction estimator, [0:27:51] project manager, it can definitely be done cheaper [0:27:54] and quicker with the full closure. [0:27:56] However, if that option is taken, [0:27:59] there's a lot of pressure on your staff [0:28:00] to make sure we don't have conflicts on parallel roads, [0:28:02] such as locust or hankons. [0:28:04] And it may not be anything that cities do [0:28:06] and it could be the electric utility, the fiber company. [0:28:10] It could be a storm that's out of everybody's control [0:28:13] and there's emergency work or a pipeline that bursts. [0:28:15] So that's a huge risk to be aware of. [0:28:18] There's been some talk about having a contractor price [0:28:21] at alternate ways. [0:28:23] I also know that when you're putting out lots of bids [0:28:26] every week and there's a lot of risk for all of them, [0:28:28] you tend to give more thoughtful pricing to the ones [0:28:32] that are easier to price. [0:28:33] So the more you muddy the waters, [0:28:36] more difficult it is for a contractor to price it [0:28:39] if I could put that way. [0:28:40] So, if you'll take that and decide what to do with it, [0:28:44] we know you'll think of that a lot. [0:28:47] Thank you, Sherry. [0:28:48] Do we know when this is going to take place? [0:28:50] And I'm thinking more of if school is going to be in or out. [0:28:54] So we need to do some irrigation work for this winter. [0:28:57] But I think the most of this will start next summer. [0:29:00] We're not quite through the design phase. [0:29:02] We're trying to get direction so we [0:29:03] know how to write the contract and finish this. [0:29:05] Still would be more than likely it would be after school is out. [0:29:08] Probably after school. [0:29:09] which would like to traffic a little bit. [0:29:11] It would, it could go even through the... [0:29:14] Hey, Jason Brown. [0:29:20] You guys are thinking about school, I was thinking about the beat run. [0:29:22] Yeah, okay. [0:29:24] And some of the harvests, you know. [0:29:26] So, what were the time frames that you gave, again, Troy, for full closer versus partial closer? [0:29:34] Did you say 16 months? [0:29:36] Napa's experienced about 16 months for a project of this size. [0:29:40] Okay. [0:29:41] And they can save and work 20 to 50 percent on that. [0:29:43] I'm with Grayson. I mean, we obviously want it done, but you can see some of the complexities [0:30:00] of shutting that road down, which I know that you're aware of, and the staff are aware of, [0:30:06] just trying to think how I feel about it. I would say it can try to think to write the contract. [0:30:16] I would be more in favor of maybe a staged closure where the Hillcrest area, if there was something [0:30:23] in that area that you needed to get done. We do a 30 to 40 day, 60 day closure completely [0:30:30] there and then open it back up as you move down the phases and the road gets wider or [0:30:35] something like that. But to have the road close for over a year would be extremely difficult [0:30:42] I think just from a community aspect. I think I'm kind of an idea of what I would propose though. [0:30:48] Okay. I think enough direction for now. You have one anymore. Yeah, I'm just looking at the map [0:30:55] From that, I just I think it would almost be impossible to do a full closure. [0:30:59] I mean you have re-churches, a school there, one of our biggest parks for [0:31:04] summer soccer, that even for local traffic, it's gonna be heavily used. [0:31:10] I think it's almost that stretch right there is almost impossible. [0:31:16] Unless you use a helicopter to drop everybody in. [0:31:19] Jason, did you have anything else? [0:31:21] I'll remove my name. [0:31:22] Okay, so you think you've got some direction? [0:31:24] I believe so. [0:31:25] Okay. [0:31:26] Thank you Troy. [0:31:28] Thank you. [0:31:31] Okay. [0:31:32] Next on the agenda is a time for public input. [0:31:35] Now we do have two public hearings after the regular meeting and so anybody that's here [0:31:42] to give testimony during the public hearing, I'm not asking you to step down now to give [0:31:49] public input. [0:31:50] This is general public input on any item that wasn't on today's agenda that anyone in the [0:31:57] the audience wishes to speak about. [0:32:00] Is there anybody here that has an item that is not covered under the public hearing, but [0:32:07] would be part of a public input? [0:32:13] Okay. [0:32:14] See no one. [0:32:15] Advisory Board reports. [0:32:16] Anything from City Council? [0:32:18] Mayor. [0:32:19] Yes. [0:32:20] Just wanted to mention that, uh, Boone Falls City Police Department, Citizens Academy, [0:32:30] started and it really first night was really, really fun and participating and I'm going [0:32:39] to hopefully go let me graduate again. Hey, anybody else? Grayson? Yeah, thank you, Madam [0:32:46] Mayor. The Twin Falls area, the greater Twin Falls area, Chamber of Commerce is doing their [0:32:50] mini masters, the 26th of September. They've expanded it this year. Now, the mega mini masters [0:32:57] includes golf, axe throwing and cornhole. So, if you haven't signed up a team, it's always [0:33:03] is a great event. [0:33:04] Hey, thank you. [0:33:06] Anybody else? [0:33:07] The Magic Valley Metropolitan Planning Organization [0:33:12] met this last week and hired an executive director. [0:33:16] And so we're moving that process along. [0:33:22] That organization will help with transportation planning [0:33:25] and project functions as we move forward and as we go. [0:33:31] Yes, thank you. [0:33:31] Is that New Drug Nathan jerky? [0:33:33] and he started today and his office is right up here okay anything from the [0:33:39] city manager's office Travis just a reminder that next week the city council [0:33:44] be in a joint meeting with the planning and zoning commission as you review [0:33:47] title 10 perfect okay now we'll move into public hearings we have two public [0:33:56] hearings tonight do you guys need a break or anything are we good everybody [0:34:02] Okay. Okay. Our first public hearing is an action item and it's public hearing to amend [0:34:09] the fiscal year 2324 budget and we have our budget coordinator Matthew Farms to go over what [0:34:18] the ordinance. Thank you. Good evening. We go through the budget amendment process of fiscal [0:34:44] year and to include items previously reviewed and approved by council, encumbered amounts from [0:34:49] the prior year and additions for items currently in the budget. [0:34:53] The Budget Amendment for Fiscal Year 23-24 totals 8,331,574 included are in the street [0:35:02] fund, designed Eastland Drive we have 250,000 which is the city's share from reserves, 527,030 [0:35:11] from an ITD grant. [0:35:13] We have a snow plow salt truck and sidewalk project stating Boulevard both of these are [0:35:18] encumbered from the prior year. The shop roof which will be funded with [0:35:22] contingency from the capital improvement fund. In the street light fund we have [0:35:27] luminaires and subdivision lights funded with reserves. The airport fund, the Delta [0:35:33] minimum revenue guarantee, managing office and equipment also funded with [0:35:37] reserves and the capital improvement fund. We have fire station 2, there's 691,041 [0:35:45] from certificates of participation. This includes a GMT close-out from earlier in [0:35:50] the year. For Fire Station 3 we have 2.86 million of reserves, a [0:35:56] Jim Bierry training facility. There's 54,506 of reserves which is the city [0:36:03] covering some of the drainage work. 808,004 is from the Fire District. We have [0:36:11] police vehicles for 400,000 reserves, the Sunway Soccer Complex and Splasapats. [0:36:16] these are SLF RF funds and they were reallocated from the shop remodel. We have [0:36:22] facility enhancements at Harrison which includes a restroom and playground [0:36:25] equipment. This was encumbered from the prior year as was the multi-prose [0:36:30] prayer at the golf course. We have park impact fees to cover irrigation pipe and [0:36:35] sidewalk if we don't need a park and the can near Mchill had a pool in East [0:36:39] Land and street impact fees for the Fylar Hankins construction project just [0:36:44] left over cost from the prior year. In the water fund we have the Hankins pressure zone, [0:36:49] funded with reserves, common area maintenance, potential, a little bit of extra contract services, [0:36:55] maybe not. It will be funded with reserves. In the sanitation fund we have additional amounts [0:37:02] for PSI landfill and recycling. We're not sure how much it will be at this point. Of course, [0:37:07] 78,000 is a conservative amount. I expect it will be less. That will be funded with an [0:37:14] anticipated revenue in the insurance fund insurance premiums increased by [0:37:19] 40,000 which results from switching providers insurance claims 15,000 it's [0:37:26] also conservative and may not be needed so in conclusion ask the U.O.D.O.D. ordinance [0:37:33] 2415 to amend the fiscal year 2324 budget and we'll stand for any questions. [0:37:40] Any questions for Matt? [0:37:42] Okay. [0:37:46] This is something we'll have to put on third and final if you so choose. [0:37:51] But we have two motions. [0:37:55] Chris Reed. [0:37:56] I move that we dispense with the reading rules and put ordinance 2024-015 on third and final reading by title only. [0:38:04] Thank you. [0:38:05] Do you have a second? [0:38:06] Madam Mayor. [0:38:08] Yes. [0:38:09] You need to have a public hearing. [0:38:10] Oh gosh. [0:38:11] I'm so sorry. [0:38:12] I'm going to open it up open up the public hearing anybody who wishes to comment on the [0:38:30] fiscal year 2324 budget amendment please come down see no one I'll close the public hearing [0:38:45] Thank you for the reminder. [0:38:46] Go ahead, Chris. [0:38:50] Okay. [0:38:51] I move that we dispense with the reading rules [0:38:53] and put Ordinance 2024-015 on third [0:38:57] and final reading by title only. [0:38:59] Thank you, Jason Brown. [0:39:00] Second. [0:39:01] Thank you, motion by Chris Reed, seconded by Jason Brown [0:39:04] to put Ordinance number 2024-015 on third and final reading [0:39:10] by title only. [0:39:12] Jody Rokavo, please. [0:39:16] Craig Hawkins? [0:39:17] Yes. [0:39:18] Brown. Yes. Spencer Cutler. Yes. Terry Wilmer. Yes. Grayson Stone. Yes. Ruth Pierce. Yes. Chris Reed. Yes. Yes. Thank you. Motion passes 7 to 0. Okay. I'll read the ordinance. Ordinance number 2024 dash 015. [0:39:36] ordinance of the City of Twin Falls, Idaho amending ordinance number 2023-009, the [0:39:43] appropriations ordinance for the fiscal year beginning October 1, 2023, and ending [0:39:49] September 30, 2024, appropriating additional monies that are to be received [0:39:55] by the City of Twin Falls, Idaho in the sum of $8,331,574, and providing an [0:40:04] effective date, please read move to approve ordinance 2024 dash 015. Thank you to have [0:40:11] a set Sherry Vomer. I'll second. Thank you motion by Chris Reed second by Sherry Vomer [0:40:17] to approve ordinance number 2024 dash 015. Jodi Roekall vote please. Ruth Pierce yes. [0:40:27] Chris Reed. Yes. Mr. Cutler. Yes. Hi, Hawkins. Yes. Jason Brown. Yes. Grayson Stone. Yes. Sherry Volmer. Yes. [0:40:38] Thank you. Motion passes seven to zero. Thank you, Matt. [0:40:48] Okay, next on the agenda is another public hearing and action item are [0:40:55] requests to appeal the planning and zoning [0:40:57] Commission's decision regarding Special Use Permit EZ24-047 to allow drive-through services [0:41:08] and extended hours of operation on property located at 1965 Blue Lakes Boulevard North [0:41:16] here of Todd Smith on behalf of In-N-Out Burgers. Kelly, before you get started, Grayson. [0:41:26] Thank you, Madam Mayor. Prior to the intern outs proposed location being publicly announced [0:41:30] I solely in my professional capacity reached out to the internet broker and submitted additional locations [0:41:36] To the broker of record for internet out so I'll be recusing myself from the vote and stepping off the diocese [0:41:42] Thank you, Grayson [0:41:47] Mitch, do you want me to go ahead on the other item? [0:41:52] Read the [0:41:53] Oh, thank you, thank you. I'm glad you guys are here. Okay. These are the public hearing procedures [0:42:00] The council will follow these nine steps for each request listed under the public hearing [0:42:06] portion of the agenda city staff will present the request and analysis the applicant will then present their request [0:42:14] the commission will the excuse me the council will then ask questions of the applicant or staff [0:42:19] After questions have been asked, the public hearing will then be opened. [0:42:23] During that time, anyone in attendance is given the opportunity to comment or ask questions about the request being considered. [0:42:32] When giving testimony, please step up to the podium, state your name and address, and present your comments or concerns. [0:42:40] After you've given testimony, if you haven't already signed the public sheet, the signing sheet upstairs in the lobby, [0:42:48] please do so for the record. [0:42:51] After public comments are concluded, [0:42:53] the applicant will be invited to answer any questions [0:42:56] and make a closing statement. [0:42:58] Staff will then answer, clarify any comments as needed. [0:43:03] After the closing statements, the public hearing [0:43:05] will be closed, no further testimony or comments [0:43:09] from the applicant or the audience will be allowed. [0:43:12] And then the council will then have an open discussion [0:43:17] and take action on the request. [0:43:19] I know this item has been in the news and been talked about an awful lot. All of us have been approached. We've received public comment prior to today. [0:43:32] We've had people call us out in the community. We've received emails. And so I wanted to give everybody on the council an opportunity to disclose any ex parte conversation they have had or anything that they wish to share about. [0:43:48] about the events proceeding tonight. [0:43:53] And I'm gonna start with Jason. [0:43:54] Good, yeah, as the mayor had mentioned, [0:43:57] I think all of us have probably at some form or fashion [0:44:01] had interested parties approach us out in the public. [0:44:06] Oftentimes not able to say we can't talk about this [0:44:10] prior to them giving their opinion on that, [0:44:14] but most of the time being able to quickly shut that [0:44:18] conversation down because of the sensitive nature of this particular application. I will [0:44:25] speak for myself on this one. I did come in last week, talked to the Planning and Zoning [0:44:29] Department. I wanted to clarify a couple of things in preparation for tonight's meeting, [0:44:35] and those things were the items that are being considered, which are two items, the drive-through [0:44:43] and the extended hours, and so I wanted to make sure [0:44:45] for myself that was clarified. [0:44:48] Thank you, sir. [0:44:50] I have myself had people come up and ask and start conversations, [0:44:57] but I have not had any conversations. [0:44:58] I've let everybody know that I cannot speak about it [0:45:01] and did not take input and have asked directed everybody [0:45:04] to the city website or to come tonight. [0:45:10] I did submit questions to the city manager's office, [0:45:16] the planning and zoning. [0:45:17] but I, that was from a piece of paper to them, [0:45:21] I did not have conversations with them. [0:45:23] Thank you. [0:45:24] And I too have had several people reach out to me [0:45:26] who I've done the blah, blah, blah. [0:45:28] I can't talk about it. [0:45:31] Very consistently, making some people not very happy. [0:45:36] I did send a couple of questions to Jonathan [0:45:40] to be prepared to answer tonight and had one short conversation [0:45:47] just a few minutes ago regarding one of those questions. [0:45:50] But other than that, I have had no discussion outside of tonight. [0:45:55] Great. [0:45:56] Well, likewise, I've been approached [0:45:59] by a number of people in casual conversations, [0:46:02] and following the council given this that I just said, [0:46:05] I can't talk about it. [0:46:07] It amazes me that we just passed what [0:46:13] a week or two weeks ago, over $100 million budget, [0:46:17] and did not create near the concern that we have denied [0:46:21] about a fast food restaurant coming to town. [0:46:25] I also have really studied hard on the pack [0:46:27] that has been presented to us overwhelmingly. [0:46:31] The comments were in the negative, [0:46:35] not for them to come to town, [0:46:37] but for them were the traffic issue. [0:46:41] But I've not spoken to him. [0:46:43] Vice President. [0:46:44] Likewise, I've had many individuals approach me [0:46:47] with concerns, stopped those conversations, [0:46:50] and had a brief conversation with Jonathan. [0:46:52] Jonathan's been loved, just to make sure [0:46:55] that I understood the packet. [0:46:57] That's the conversation that I've had. [0:46:59] Thank you, Spencer. [0:47:00] Right. [0:47:01] I've read the packet. [0:47:02] I haven't had any follow up conversations [0:47:04] with city staff or the applicant or anybody. [0:47:06] And likewise, I've had people approach me [0:47:09] and wanna talk about it, and I've just said [0:47:12] state law and public meeting rules. [0:47:14] I'm just not gonna talk about it. [0:47:16] Thank you. [0:47:17] Thank you, everybody. [0:47:19] Kelly, you're up. [0:47:21] Good evening, Council. [0:47:23] This is a request to appeal the decision [0:47:25] of the Planning and Zoning Commission [0:47:26] on the special use permit request [0:47:28] for a drive-thru and extended hours of operation [0:47:31] at 1965, Blue Lakes Boulevard, North from in-and-out burgers. [0:47:36] On June 25th, 2024, the Planning and Zoning Commission [0:47:39] denied this request by a vote of five to two. [0:47:42] Denights decision by the Council [0:47:44] is a brand new decision on this request. [0:47:47] The Council may approve the request as presented, [0:47:50] add conditions to an approval, [0:47:51] deny the request or table for more information. [0:47:56] This is the location. [0:47:58] Right now, the property is owned C1, CRO, PUD. [0:48:02] It's located within the Canyon Park West PUD, [0:48:05] and it's been home to Outback State House since 2001. [0:48:10] Like Jason said, the restaurant itself [0:48:12] is an outright permitted use in the C1 [0:48:15] commercial highway district and is included [0:48:18] as an allowed use in the PUD. [0:48:20] So tonight's request is solely for the drive-through [0:48:23] and extended hours of operation. [0:48:28] Per City Code 101922, the special use permit process [0:48:32] requires a public hearing in which interest [0:48:34] or persons have the opportunity to be heard [0:48:36] with regards to the application. [0:48:42] There are nine criteria that especially [0:48:45] use permit requests must follow, [0:48:48] and they're shown about for you. [0:48:53] City Code 1048.2 states, especially use permit, [0:48:56] is required for any facility with a drive-through service [0:48:59] and permitted retail trade uses operating outside [0:49:03] the hours of 7 a.m. to 10 o'clock p.m. [0:49:11] All right, there's a lot here. [0:49:19] Here's the site plan. [0:49:22] The restaurant will have two drive-through lanes, [0:49:25] which merge into one lane for order-taking, [0:49:28] payment, and food service. [0:49:30] Per City Code, drive-through lanes have vehicle stacking [0:49:32] requirements of five cars per lane from the first window, pick a window order board or stopping [0:49:38] point. The proposed site plan shows the applicant meets this requirement and is also exceeded [0:49:45] this requirement with a total queue of 29 vehicles using both drive through lanes. City [0:49:51] staff analysis is as this is sufficient queue under normal operating conditions. With the [0:49:59] The opening and other busier times of the shopping and tourist seasons, the queue will [0:50:03] become overcrowded with vehicles. [0:50:06] The applicant has addressed this concern in their narrative by having store associates [0:50:10] available to manage the excess vehicle stacking. [0:50:14] Employees are deployed with handheld tablets to take multiple orders and a third grill can [0:50:18] be utilized to help prepare the incoming orders, getting the customers through the drive-through [0:50:24] in a line in a quicker and more efficient manner. [0:50:28] The applicant has provided additional traffic queue analysis by the Gandini group, recording [0:50:33] drive-through queue data from three existing drive-through locations closely matching the [0:50:38] conditions of this proposed drive-through with comparable locations and populations. [0:50:43] The analysis shows the maximum peak drive-through stack was 27 cars with an average maximum [0:50:49] dinner queue of 25 vehicles supporting the proposed queue of 29 vehicles. [0:50:54] Let me see if I can show you. [0:50:57] There's a site plan. [0:51:03] This picture isn't as easy to see, but this shows the full queue at the 29. [0:51:10] And the applicant has some slides to show you as well. [0:51:16] Per the ITE trip generation manual, an average fast food restaurant with a drive-through window [0:51:21] will generate 50.9 or vehicle trips per PM peak hour from 4 to 6 PM per 1,000 square feet [0:51:29] of gross floor area. [0:51:31] the directional distribution of 51% entering and 49% exiting. [0:51:36] Based on the statistic, a restaurant of approximately [0:51:38] 3800 square feet can expect up to 191 total vehicle trips [0:51:43] per PM peak hour. [0:51:46] That calculates out to roughly 97 vehicles entering [0:51:49] and 94 vehicles exiting per PM peak hour. [0:51:53] While this may not be the exact numbers experienced [0:51:55] by in and out burgers, it gives an average for comparison. [0:51:59] This is not the first drive-through request [0:52:02] that has come forth in this area. [0:52:04] There are currently multiple drive-through businesses [0:52:06] in the surrounding area, [0:52:08] which are all responsible for managing their drive-through queues. [0:52:11] Swig has a drive-through in the same parking lot [0:52:15] as this proposed location, [0:52:16] and it's the building at the north right here. [0:52:21] The habit is also located in the same shopping center [0:52:24] and has a working drive-through. [0:52:26] Across the street at the Magic Valley Mall, [0:52:28] there are two drive-through restaurants, Starbucks, [0:52:30] and Taco Bell. [0:52:32] Taco Bell and Chick-fil-A on Blue Lakes Boulevard North [0:52:35] are observed to be two of the busiest drive-throughs in town. [0:52:39] Both were constructed with a drive-through queue [0:52:41] of five vehicles before the menu order board [0:52:45] at each location as required by city code. [0:52:49] Request for extended hours of operation [0:52:51] is not an unusual special use permit request. [0:52:54] Any business wanting to open before 7 a.m. [0:52:57] or stay open past 10 p.m. [0:52:58] is required to have a special use permit. [0:53:01] Starbucks across the street, [0:53:02] traditionally opens by 6 a.m., [0:53:05] Taco Bell also across the street, [0:53:07] stays open until 3 a.m. for the drive-through. [0:53:10] There are many others in town that are allowed [0:53:12] to operate outside outright permitted retail hours. [0:53:17] This is a unique location with the prime bridge, [0:53:20] the visitor center, and the roundabout, [0:53:23] the private roundabout. [0:53:26] As visitors coming into Twin Falls, [0:53:27] we'll see in and out as one of the first businesses. [0:53:30] This will create a buzz with the restaurant's opening, [0:53:34] and there will be extra traffic generated to this area [0:53:36] for some time. [0:53:38] The intersection is one of the busiest and twin falls [0:53:41] with an average trip count. [0:53:42] This is blue lakes and filmware of around 40,000 vehicles per day. [0:53:47] City staff has discussed the traffic concerns [0:53:50] with the applicant and have added a few conditions [0:53:52] that should address opening traffic [0:53:54] and normalized traffic counts on local public roads. [0:53:58] In and out and Wood Investment Group [0:54:00] will be responsible to manage the traffic [0:54:03] through the shopping center private roads [0:54:05] to access the restaurant. [0:54:07] In Ann Arbor, has expressed that a traffic control plan [0:54:10] will be in place for the opening. [0:54:12] The City of Twin Falls Police and Fire Departments [0:54:14] are requesting a condition to review the opening plans [0:54:17] through the City of Twin Falls special event process [0:54:20] in order to adequately plan for emergency access [0:54:22] to this area through the opening phase of this new business. [0:54:27] The 2016 Comprehensive Plan [0:54:30] designates this area as appropriate for mixed use, [0:54:33] serving local and regional commercial businesses. [0:54:36] This designation allows for high density mixed use development [0:54:39] in a compact, pedestrian oriented environment, [0:54:43] sitting at intersections of major arterials. [0:54:47] Staff has determined the proposed use [0:54:48] is compatible with the comprehensive plan [0:54:51] and the area as it is a high density commercial center [0:54:54] with other retail stores and restaurants [0:54:56] serving the community at large. [0:54:59] Based on the standards for approval, staff does not foresee long-term impacts related to the land use, although traffic congestion may be an issue with the opening of a new highly anticipated business coming to town. [0:55:12] Under normalized operations, this area will continue to be busy with customers travelers during peak travel times of day and year. [0:55:22] Approval of this request does not preclude the applicant from obtaining the required permits and or licenses needed to complete the project. [0:55:31] In conclusion, if the Council approves the request as presented, then staff recommends the following. [0:55:38] Subject to site plan amendments as required by building engineering, fire, and zoning officials to comply with applicable city codes and standards. [0:55:46] subject to local public roads including Nielsen Point Place not be [0:55:51] detrimentally impacted by excessive traffic volumes directly attributable [0:55:56] to this business and subject to the opening plan going through the City of [0:56:00] Twin Falls special event process to ensure adequate public safety access to [0:56:05] the surrounding area during the opening phase of operations. Sorry, there was a [0:56:16] lot. The applicant has submitted their reason for the appeal and they are here to present [0:56:31] the reason for that. Here shows the zoning map. This location is in the canyon room overlay [0:56:41] PUDC1. Current land uses a restaurant and the proposed land uses a drive-through. It is [0:56:50] surrounded by commercial properties and prime bridge and it is located in the [0:56:56] mixed-use future land use. I will stand for any questions and Troy VTech is also [0:57:05] here to explain the road structure over there because I know like you said the [0:57:09] traffic was the major concern. Any questions for Kelly before we get to [0:57:16] I got here. There may be some after. Sure. So thank you. Come on out Troy. Thank you, [0:57:25] Mayor and Council. So I'm here to really answer questions for you, but I'll give you a little [0:57:31] input. I did call the the state on this the state. This is the responsible jurisdiction for [0:57:38] Lulex Boulevard in this area. I wanted to kind of get their opinion. What are your guys' feelings [0:57:43] on it? He input from not the district engineer, but the system I can become. This isn't a big deal. [0:57:51] There's 35,000 vehicles across the bridge. Our flocks say cameras are shown roughly 40,000 currently [0:57:59] that go through this area. The impact of the redways, they didn't really see it. So the city's [0:58:06] jurisdiction starts right about where the E is on this film or and right about where the F is. [0:58:12] That is the limit of our responsibility, our roadway system. The rest of this was previously [0:58:17] vacated and created a private driveway easement for this private roadway that goes here. It looks, [0:58:24] feels, kind of smells like a road, acts like a road. Most people believe it to be, [0:58:29] they can't really tell a difference, but it is truly a private drive in the minds of these [0:58:33] businesses here. That being said, people utilize it. They circumvent the business of this, [0:58:39] that the area south of here, the pole line, blue lakes, there is an issue there. We know that today. [0:58:44] We're trying to work through future options, but it's a so I don't know what else to kind of say about that [0:58:53] The roundabout looks like it's failing. It's it's in my mind. It's a private driveway [0:58:59] It's kind of fancy with a little circular [0:59:02] Evident it doesn't fail because it's around about it fails because it gets blocked by the signal [0:59:07] There's not a dedicated [0:59:09] Protected left turn at this place so it backs up and then backs up around here [0:59:13] It allows for a little bit more stacking, but it's kind of just a fancy tee in our section [0:59:19] of our mind. [0:59:20] We also control Neil's some point place, not as right away, but as real property of the [0:59:24] accesses, the jump, or the visitor center there. [0:59:29] Our condition on this application was you cannot block this roadway ever. [0:59:35] Our police and fire have kind of expressed their need to get out there as well as the [0:59:39] businesses there. [0:59:40] We feel that's responsible. [0:59:41] So, the condition that says if you start blocking this, we bring this back before, I don't know if they'll clarify this, I think it's before the P&Z Commission. [0:59:49] And there's a revocation process. I don't think in and out ever wants to go through that process. [0:59:53] So, if they're not blocking Nielsen Point Plays, it's hard to say a block the roundabout of a system that's already kind of failing. [1:00:03] Now, this may, there's going to be additional vehicles here. I think their start-ups is going to be extraordinary. [1:00:09] a very successful business. That being said, we're doing our best to really limit what the [1:00:16] season packed and the state didn't feel like they would have any packed on their roadways. [1:00:20] Other than that, can I offer any more insight? [1:00:23] So who owns the private road? Is that wood? [1:00:26] It is an easement that is part of the business development association, so... [1:00:31] Not wood? Woodbury? [1:00:36] Jonathan, thank you. [1:00:39] The owner is Wood Investment Group, and they have a representative here that owns this, [1:00:44] what looks like public road, but which is private easement. [1:00:48] Answering a couple of questions while I'm up here for people that you all have asked, clarifying [1:00:54] this is only for drive-through and hours. [1:00:57] We're not talking about the restaurant itself that's outright permitted. [1:01:00] No matter what kind of restaurant it is, it would be permitted. [1:01:05] We've only, I'm getting back to questioning the share we had. [1:01:08] We've had two special use permits that have gone through the revocation process in the [1:01:14] last 15 years. [1:01:17] Those two didn't actually get revoked. [1:01:19] What they did was they went back to the planning and zoning commission and the conditions were [1:01:22] amended and the owners fixed the situation. [1:01:26] One of them was Dutch brothers on Pole Line Road. [1:01:28] That one did have an issue on the local road. [1:01:31] We brought it back. [1:01:32] They worked on a process or on a new design. [1:01:36] They fixed their issue. [1:01:38] they no longer back up on the pull-in road. [1:01:40] The other one had to do with hours of operation downtown [1:01:44] with a nightclub that was exceeding 2 a.m. [1:01:47] He can remember that one. [1:01:48] Neither one of them actually got revoked. [1:01:49] They just amended the conditions through a process. [1:01:53] The same option is available here, [1:01:55] particularly with the condition that we have. [1:01:57] I believe that answered all of Sherry's questions [1:01:59] that she wrote to us. [1:02:01] The question I got from the mayor was, [1:02:04] have we reached out to Meridian, [1:02:06] police or punting and zoning. [1:02:09] Tried, failed, nobody went on the record, [1:02:12] didn't even reach out to the police department, [1:02:14] quite frankly, I didn't even have to call on that one. [1:02:16] What I did do is look for any type of official action [1:02:19] by the city of Meridian for the opening in that location. [1:02:22] I could not find anything that indicated [1:02:25] that they had a problem with their opening. [1:02:27] Whether they did or didn't, maybe they wrote tickets [1:02:29] to people that would be individuals. [1:02:31] There was no public issue with how that opening went, [1:02:34] even though it was widely advertised, [1:02:37] a little bit different, but similar. [1:02:40] Eagle Road and Fairview, I think, [1:02:42] here's the name there. [1:02:43] Eagle Road's a state road, similar to this. [1:02:45] So, and also Meridian doesn't deal with their own roads. [1:02:49] The Aida County Highway District deals with their roads. [1:02:51] So they kind of just point to Aida County [1:02:53] and say, hey, it's deal with that. [1:02:55] Go get approval from them. [1:02:57] It's not that you're doing this exact same thing, [1:02:58] but this is a state road just like Eagle. [1:03:01] And we have the state that's given us an answer. [1:03:03] the rest of it is private. Similar thing at the village, it's all private property internally. [1:03:08] Going down the line, I'm very, Chris was clarifying basically what the similar to Jason and also [1:03:16] some of the private property that Troy has also answered. I'll leave, that's all I have, [1:03:22] unless you have questions for me specifically. [1:03:25] Any questions for Jonathan while he's up here? Yes. [1:03:31] So, if this was to be approved, and we found out there was a major safety concern or traffic [1:03:39] buildup, is there is a procedure or a motion to be able to go back and maybe amend or work [1:03:47] with or correct? [1:03:48] Yeah, the process would be if we had something from any of our safety partners, particularly [1:03:53] our police, fire or engineering, they would write up, say, some of them, I would say, [1:03:59] we're experiencing not just a one-time thing needs to be a little bit more of a [1:04:03] pattern. It's a little bit of a fuzzy line on how long that is, right? If it's three [1:04:08] times, if it's one weekend, what if it goes on for multiple times? We would receive [1:04:12] that in our office. We would then put it on the agenda for the Planning and Zoning [1:04:17] Commission to hear. So here's the issue that we have received from our internal [1:04:23] partners. We believe we need to relook at this. We schedule for public hearing. They [1:04:29] can act on it so yep we're going to actually initiate revocation and we [1:04:33] can take it through the process if we need to. Thank you. Anybody else for [1:04:39] Jonathan Welles up here? Okay thank you. Next we'll hear from the applicant. [1:04:47] Welcome. Good evening, City Council and members of Twin Falls Community. My name [1:05:00] is Todd Smith. I'm the development manager for and now Burger responsible [1:05:04] for this project. I'm excited to be here with you and I want to thank City staff for all their [1:05:11] diligence and hard work in reviewing the project. Now I wish to thank you for your time dedicated [1:05:17] to the community and hearing the project tonight. Before getting into project details I'd like to [1:05:22] provide some background on In-N-Out Burger. In-N-Out Burger was founded in 1948 by Harry and Esther [1:05:38] Schneider in Baldwin Park, California. [1:05:41] Harry was a World War II veteran who used GI Bill money to open a modest 10 feet by 10 [1:05:47] feet, and Burger Drive-Thru restaurant in Baldwin Park. [1:05:52] Harry actually invented the two-way speaker in order for drive-thru orders to be taken remotely. [1:06:00] In and out burgers a family owned business, all 408 in and out burger stores are company [1:06:05] owned and operated. [1:06:07] We do not franchise. [1:06:08] The company is currently led by Lindsey Snyder, the granddaughter of Harry and Esther, in and [1:06:13] out just celebrated at 75th anniversary and the Meridian Idaho store was the company's [1:06:18] 400th store and Idaho became the 8th state and where it now currently operates. [1:06:26] All restaurant supplies and food products are delivered from company owned and operated [1:06:30] distribution centers and hamburger padded production plants by company owned delivery trucks. [1:06:36] We do this to maintain our strong company culture, our incredible customer experience, [1:06:41] and most importantly, the high quality food we serve. [1:06:44] And it continues to lead the company as a family business and holds firmly to the founding values, [1:06:50] guiding principles, and culture of the company. [1:06:55] Next slide, please. [1:06:57] I'd like to emphasize, in an Alberta's mission statement, this is not a once created and then [1:07:04] casually forgotten exercise. [1:07:05] This statement is printed on our business cards and is routinely emphasized in company meetings. [1:07:10] There are three fundamental principles by which we operate. [1:07:14] In-and-out burger exists for the purpose of one, [1:07:19] providing the freshest, highest quality foods and services for a profit, [1:07:24] and a spotless sparkling environment whereby the customer is our most important asset. [1:07:29] Two, providing a team-oriented atmosphere whereby goal-setting and communications exist, [1:07:35] and to provide excellent training and development for all of our associates. [1:07:39] Three, assisting all communities in our marketplace to become stronger, safer, and better places to live. [1:07:48] The commitment to the above is evidence throughout the operations of the company. [1:07:53] Some examples are the following. [1:07:56] We hire and train employees for each store and always pay above minimum wage in the area. [1:08:01] In and Out Burger is a place where every associate has the opportunity to make it a career, on [1:08:07] the store associate side as well as the sport associate side, as well as store management. [1:08:14] In and Out Burger enhances the communities we operate in throughout two foundations. [1:08:18] The In and Out Burger foundation started in 1984 by Esther Snyder with a focus on helping [1:08:23] abused children. [1:08:25] And the slave to nothing foundation started by Lindsey and her husband Sean in 2018 to [1:08:30] the fun solutions to human trafficking and substance abuse. [1:08:35] In and out underwrites these programs to ensure every pain donated goes directly to [1:08:39] worthy recipients. [1:08:41] And three, being a good neighbor and making a positive impact in the communities in which [1:08:46] we operate. [1:08:47] We are excited to come to the Twin Falls and to provide a great customer experience and [1:08:53] become a positive presence in the community and be a good neighbor. [1:08:57] Next slide, please. [1:09:01] At first like the highlight the staff report and presentation in and out is not the first [1:09:05] establishment to request a special use permit of this nature. [1:09:09] There are other busy drive-through restaurants in the vicinity that have been approved under [1:09:13] similar conditions and circumstances as well as longer hours of operation, busy drive-throughs, [1:09:19] Taco Bell and Chick-fil-A are notable examples. [1:09:23] The comprehensive staff analysis says no to consistency with city code and the city comprehensive [1:09:28] plan and is recommending approval of the special use permit. In and out is committed to managing [1:09:34] site queuing both during the initial opening honeymoon period as well as once more routine [1:09:40] patterns settle into ongoing operations. The Wood Investment Group is the overall owner [1:09:47] and in and out landlord. We have a great working relationship with them and are working with [1:09:51] them to ensure site queuing is managed from day one. A side note is that in and out always [1:09:58] meticulously prepares for a store opening with all stakeholders to work through plans [1:10:03] and strategies to manage the initial honeymoon period. [1:10:08] And the city will have us work through a special events permit for that time as well [1:10:12] as noted in condition number three. [1:10:17] We are in complete agreement with this and we'll of course go through the special event [1:10:20] permit process which leads to the next point. [1:10:26] In and out fully accepts the staff recommended conditions and particularly condition number [1:10:31] two which state subject or being subject to local public roads including Nielsen [1:10:36] Place not being detrimentally impacted by excessive traffic volumes directly [1:10:41] attributable to this business again we completely agree with this we recently [1:10:47] opened a store in Flagstaff Arizona which was on a busy state highway the [1:10:54] Arizona Department of Transportation among other stakeholders were working with us [1:10:57] to ensure that Milton Road that state highway was not impacted we first [1:11:01] proposed traffic controls on Milton, to which the city police participation to keep [1:11:06] traffic moving along the store and manage the queue for the large opening [1:11:10] weekend. However, the transportation department did not want that, so we [1:11:15] partnered with an adjacent hotel to use some of their parking lot area to handle [1:11:19] excess queuing. And the opening of Flagstaff I participated in, it was a highly [1:11:25] successful opening, and Milton Road was not impacted by that opening. We managed the [1:11:30] you in that circumstance as well. [1:11:32] And it now has vast experience with busy high-volume stores and queues above industry norms. [1:11:38] We have highly trained and capable staff who can handle the challenges that some stores [1:11:43] can present. [1:11:44] Our store managers are never hired from the outside. [1:11:46] They work from the bottom up. [1:11:48] They start at level one and work their way up through every station so that when a new [1:11:52] manager is put in place, they know store operations completely and are trained thirdly [1:11:58] and how to handle every task. In and out also possesses the commitment and resources to solve [1:12:04] any challenges that may arise beyond our already robust design and planning with respect to traffic [1:12:09] queues and more. I'll provide a couple of possible examples of ways we can manage temporary access [1:12:18] queues. So this is an image of our site plan with a 27 car queue as it's standard and that is that [1:12:31] Q determination is made using effectively 20 feet per space, so roughly a 16 to 18 foot [1:12:38] car with a 2 to 4 foot spacing in between, which is a generous spacing. [1:12:42] We could tighten that space up and actually fit more. [1:12:48] Next slide, please. [1:12:50] This slide depicts a Q going if we were temporarily beyond that 27 car length Q. We can show by [1:13:01] just handling it on the parking lot in the drive taking it up to about 35 cars if necessary for a [1:13:07] temporary peak. And the next slide is a similar plan where we show again 35 cars where we've just [1:13:14] moved them over to the parking area keeping more of the drive aisle open. These are just a couple [1:13:20] of examples. But then with concern about the opening and some excess queuing, the next slide, [1:13:29] We're making arrangements with the property owner that is depicting the [1:13:36] dirt area just beside the Petco where we could stack and cue approximately 60 [1:13:43] cars in that station and then of course you see depictions we would have [1:13:48] temporary traffic controllers and flaggers there as necessary. Next slide please [1:13:54] and we could even run that cue behind the restaurant or not the [1:13:59] restaurant with the mall shops for a lengthy queue heading in the neighborhood of a [1:14:03] hundred and fifty total cars if necessary. And these are just a couple of examples [1:14:08] and methods that could be used to maintain a significant number of cars as [1:14:12] needed to manage the queue that may occur and keep them away from impacting [1:14:18] the Nielsen Place or public roads. Again, we are committed to abiding by staff [1:14:26] conditions in our experience and resourceful at solving long queue challenges. Again, these [1:14:31] are just a few examples of how we can do that. We have fully committed to being a good neighbor [1:14:37] and working with the shopping center to find necessary solutions should the need arise. We [1:14:42] have the full support of the shopping center on this also. Next slide, please. I'll conclude by [1:14:51] summarizing the main points. City staff has reviewed the project and found it to be compliant [1:14:56] with City Code, provided appropriate conditions and recommends approval. [1:15:01] In and out is committed to abiding by the staff recommended conditions, including condition [1:15:06] number two, being subject to local public roads, including Nielsen Place, not being detrimentally [1:15:12] impacted by excessive traffic volumes directly attributable to this business. [1:15:18] Cue analysis of similar existing stores shows that our Twin Falls design meets or exceeds [1:15:25] expected demand. Again, just as a reminder, in the pack it was included a Q study where we had our [1:15:33] traffic engineer look at and analyze three comparable similar stores, Logan, Utah, Casa Grande, Arizona, [1:15:41] and Prescott, Arizona, similar to Twin Falls, and studied those Qs and found that the average Q [1:15:47] length at peak times was about 25 cars with the maximum at our Logan store having reached 27 cars, [1:15:53] And of course, our cue by design meets those obligations. [1:15:58] In addition, we will work with the shopping center, our landlord, as well, to ensure that any excess of cue is well managed. [1:16:09] And it now has developed functional methods to manage excess cue traffic without impact to public roads. [1:16:16] Some of those examples I showed you. [1:16:18] And now it's committed to being a good community partner that will embrace being a positive contributor overall to the Twin Falls community. [1:16:26] It's important to us, it's a part of our mission. [1:16:29] We are committed to making it work. [1:16:32] Thank you for your time. [1:16:34] I'm available for questions. [1:16:36] Questions for Mr. Smith. [1:16:38] Thank you. [1:16:46] Thank you. [1:16:48] Okay, if there aren't any questions of the applicant or staff, I'm going to. [1:17:00] Oh yes, open up the public hearing and I remind everybody that this is a public hearing. [1:17:09] I would ask that you be respectful and cordial and keep your comments concise. [1:17:16] I know we have a lot of people that want to speak today and I want to give everybody an [1:17:20] opportunity without being here until midnight. [1:17:25] So when I call your name, and if you're not on here, I'll give people a chance afterwards [1:17:32] to speak. [1:17:33] When I call your name, please come down to the podium, give us your full name, and whether [1:17:39] you're a resident of Twin Falls, and then you will have two minutes, and Jodi will be [1:17:46] timing. [1:17:47] She'll have the timer ready. [1:17:50] So I'm opening up the public hearing. [1:17:53] So first person on the list is Kirsten Stewart. [1:17:57] Kirsten, again, please come down to the mic and state your full name and whether you're [1:18:03] a resident of Twin Falls and then you have two minutes to comment. [1:18:07] [Muted for privacy: street address] [1:18:09] [Muted for privacy: street address] [1:18:13] [Muted for privacy: street address] [1:18:21] The safety and traffic congestion at that bridge, Blue Lakes, the traffic roundabout, [1:18:27] Bridgeview Boulevard was analyzed and you really thought a lot about that traffic congestion [1:18:34] in that busy area. [1:18:36] We as city residents wish to keep the traffic moving and not have accidents while entering [1:18:42] our city. [1:18:43] I appreciate that the city council knew that the building and allowing that drive-through [1:18:49] would that close to the traffic light, traffic backup on the bridge. [1:18:56] I want to thank the City Council again for your wisdom in this matter. [1:19:02] I do have a question. [1:19:03] The Buzz Langdon Visitor Center was renamed. [1:19:07] At one time it was the Buzz Langdon Visitor Center. [1:19:12] We all remember Sue, we remember Barry, and all his children, Brock, Brittany, and Trey. [1:19:19] We do know that that visitor center has historic significance, and I'm wondering if that historic [1:19:27] building needs to be protected, and I didn't know for sure if there was any significance [1:19:33] to that question. [1:19:35] Thank you so much. [1:19:37] Thank you. [1:19:40] Okay, next is Mary Karskadin. [1:19:45] Sorry if I botched that. [1:19:50] Welcome, Mary. [1:19:51] I apologize. [1:19:53] I didn't come prepared to speak. [1:19:54] Most of my friends couldn't make it today. [1:19:57] But I personally... [1:19:58] [Muted for privacy: street address] [1:20:00] [Muted for privacy: street address] [1:20:04] [Muted for privacy: street address] [1:20:08] Anyway, I am thrilled that In-N-Out is coming to our community. [1:20:14] But I, like most of my friends, [1:20:16] are very concerned about that particular intersection. [1:20:22] I'm a spoiled twin-false citizen, and that intersection there [1:20:28] is already turning into a nightmare. [1:20:31] And my hope is, in your coming, that it might be better [1:20:37] if it were closer to the college and schools [1:20:41] and some of the other locations that we have more people. [1:20:45] because this is a wildly popular place, [1:20:48] and people drive for miles to come to in and out. [1:20:54] So it's not gonna affect their business one way or the other. [1:20:58] But hopefully, my opposition is not being offensive in any way. [1:21:05] Thank you. [1:21:06] Thank you, Mary. [1:21:09] Hey, next is Joel Brown. [1:21:19] [Muted for privacy: home address] [1:21:23] [Muted for privacy: home address] [1:21:26] [Muted for privacy: home address] [1:21:28] [Muted for privacy: home address] [1:21:29] And since 1919, my family has owned [1:21:32] what is now one of the oldest businesses in town. [1:21:36] Considering or concerning the denial of in and out request [1:21:39] for a special use permit to allow drive-through services [1:21:42] and extended hours of operation, the Planning and Zoning [1:21:45] Commission failed in its responsibility [1:21:47] to objectively consider the data that was presented. [1:21:50] Their decision ignored all objective traffic studies [1:21:52] and data. [1:21:53] while also ignoring in and out eagerness and acceptance [1:21:57] to control traffic in the area, [1:21:59] something with which they have demonstrated great competence [1:22:02] in their many locations. [1:22:04] The data presented that night and tonight [1:22:06] shows that in and out plans exceed traffic control requirements [1:22:09] and that the state sees no issues with the effects on traffic. [1:22:13] Instead of considering these facts, [1:22:15] the commission chose to rely on anecdotal evidence [1:22:18] and biases to form their decisions. [1:22:21] The traffic study performed, I'm going to skip that section. [1:22:26] Most importantly, as a small business owner [1:22:28] and a lifelong citizen of Twin Falls, [1:22:29] I believe that fair and equitable treatment [1:22:32] for businesses and citizens is critical and essential. [1:22:35] The question at hand is whether or not [1:22:37] to allow drive-through services and extended hours. [1:22:40] This decision must reflect consistent equitable treatment [1:22:43] regardless of one's opinions of in and out [1:22:46] or any other business that may make similar requests. [1:22:49] The city has already considered and approved [1:22:51] drive-through for other businesses only feet away right across the parking lot to [1:22:56] allow one business amenity while denying another business is inconsistent and is [1:23:01] the result of ignoring objective facts and data instead relying on personal [1:23:06] biases and conjecture allowing this decision to stand would set a very [1:23:11] unfortunate and unjust precedent not just for in and out but for all local [1:23:15] businesses and citizens. Perfect thank you. Okay that's everybody that's [1:23:22] signed up is there anybody here in the audience that wishes to address City [1:23:28] Council on this issue? Okay before I close the public hearing is there anything [1:23:49] the applicant wishes to address on those comments? I wholeheartedly [1:24:00] agree with that last comment. Thank you. No we're good thank you very much. Thank [1:24:05] Thank you, Mr. Smith. [1:24:07] Anybody from staff have any additional comments? [1:24:10] John or Kelly? [1:24:11] I was just going to say we did receive some public comments as you referred to, and they [1:24:19] were all included in your packet. [1:24:21] I apologize. [1:24:22] I meant to say that. [1:24:24] Thank you. [1:24:26] Thank you. [1:24:27] Okay. [1:24:28] Seeing no one else. [1:24:30] Last chance. [1:24:31] Okay. [1:24:32] I'm going to close the public hearing and it's time for council discussion [1:24:36] who wants to start. [1:24:40] Jason Brown. [1:24:44] I got the finger first. [1:24:46] I got the finger first. [1:24:50] You know, is topics come up from the city council perspective? [1:24:57] We, you know, these are these are very difficult and hard conversations to have. [1:25:03] I think the last comment really has summarized my thought process in this, and there's really [1:25:13] two items of consideration that we've got to think about, and that's why I approached [1:25:17] Jonathan and his group last week to make sure that I had my information correct, my [1:25:22] fact straight because the city has already authorized drive-throughs in this area has authorized [1:25:35] extended hours. It's hard to punish somebody because they're popular. It's hard to punish [1:25:41] somebody a private business because other individuals like it. I've personally been to [1:25:50] other in-and-out burger joints down in Utah and other locations. I think the [1:25:59] comment was said is people will go miles and miles for in-and-out burger. But [1:26:06] again I think that all goes back to the premise of if they meet the standard of [1:26:12] our city code, if they meet the standard of the application and the intent of the [1:26:18] process. The other part that I've looked at is from my own personal experience looking at Chick-fil-A [1:26:25] and how that business itself functions in and amongst the target parking lot. Residents go to [1:26:35] the target area, I personally go to the target parking lot, and at times can be congested and [1:26:41] difficult to get through. I believe that Chick-fil-A has done their diligence, but I also believe that [1:26:48] in and out has provided a mechanism for traffic to work and function through that area, but again, [1:26:58] the two items that we were looking at tonight are extended hours and drive through, and to [1:27:04] me, they meet the requirements of that. [1:27:09] Thank you, Jason. [1:27:10] Chris, please. [1:27:11] I will echo what Jason said. [1:27:13] I'm just going to add one other thing. [1:27:16] I've learned a lot about the property in this area in the last week and a half or so. [1:27:21] As we've looked at different things, understanding that Fillmore is a private road. [1:27:26] I think a lot of people in Twin Falls don't understand that although it is named, it is [1:27:32] just like the road that goes around the mall on the other side. [1:27:38] So understanding that the flow of traffic in that area, a lot of people use Fillmore [1:27:44] get over to blue lakes to get across the bridge faster, but that is a private road and we're [1:27:52] treating it like a public road. And so understanding that as we look at that and how we were currently [1:27:59] looking at other things, they're two different things. So I echo what Jason says, I'm in favor [1:28:07] of this for all the reasons that we have done in the past staying consistent moving forward. [1:28:11] Thank you, Chris. Anybody else have any comments? [1:28:20] Thanks [1:28:22] My concern is strictly with extra vehicles that might be on Nelson Point and Fillmore Street [1:28:29] Any type of outright permitted establishment I have no concern with the extended hours requested [1:28:35] I have no concern with it's just whether to be extra cars on Fillmore and Nelson Point [1:28:40] And I think the information presented to us confirms that there would be [1:28:44] Just things, the fact that there's a large drive-in queue for lots of vehicles, [1:28:50] implies there'll be a lot of people coming and going, [1:28:53] and the assumption is, at least I'm assuming, they're not going to be parked there for a long time. [1:28:57] They're moving through there quickly. [1:28:59] I know there's some information in the minutes from planning and zoning [1:29:03] about what methods they can take to get through quickly, [1:29:07] implying lots of people coming and going. [1:29:10] The studies do confirm that a popular establishment with the drive-in is going to have more people coming and going [1:29:19] than a place where people have to pull up in park. [1:29:22] And so I'm not trying to hinder any uses that already happen here, but this is a special request for something extra. [1:29:30] And I think that's important to point out. [1:29:32] I acknowledge a segment of Filmor is privately owned, however also a large portion from Pole [1:29:38] Line around Costco up again to Blue Lakes is public, and functionally it's used by the [1:29:44] public. [1:29:45] I think that's justified. [1:29:46] You know, this is a development that wants the public to be there. [1:29:49] They're drawing people there, so for them to accommodate the public makes sense. [1:29:53] And they know the question of, well, we've already permitted other drive-thru's. [1:29:58] That's right. [1:29:59] right, but I don't think there was ever any intention to have more drive-throughs than [1:30:03] was appropriate. If this was something requesting 15 years ago before there was as much traffic [1:30:10] here already, it's a different scenario than it is today. And yeah, so that's my concern [1:30:16] is the traffic on Nelson Point and Fillmore. There's also information presented about Blue [1:30:20] Lakes and the 40,000 cars already on Blue Lakes and implying that the 11 or 1200 extra, [1:30:27] the net extra is minuscule compared to the 40,000. [1:30:30] Well, I'm not concerned about the 40,000 [1:30:33] that are going north and south. [1:30:34] I'm concerned about the small portion of 40,000 [1:30:37] that currently use Fillmore or Nielsen Point. [1:30:40] And I don't know what those numbers are, [1:30:43] but I believe it's very reasonable to assume [1:30:45] it's much smaller than 40,000. [1:30:47] So when you take that number, [1:30:48] compared to the extra 11 or 1200 cars [1:30:52] that are projected, that is significant. [1:30:55] And clearly congestion is a factor. [1:30:58] That's why people from the public have spoken up about it. [1:31:01] I think that this was an imagined concern. [1:31:04] We wouldn't have very many people taking the effort [1:31:06] to speak up. [1:31:07] So respectfully, that's my feelings on this. [1:31:10] Thank you. [1:31:11] Thank you, Spencer. [1:31:13] Great. [1:31:14] I concur with what's been said. [1:31:18] When I heard first heard they were coming to town, [1:31:21] I was excited. [1:31:22] And then when I heard that they were in that location, [1:31:24] I put a little bit of an amper on my excitement, as with many others, but having studied recommendations [1:31:32] from our city staff and reading the comments and so forth, I think that M&F workers done [1:31:38] their due diligence and I can see how it can work. [1:31:42] And like I asked Jonathan, if it doesn't work, then there's a process that could be used [1:31:47] to maybe correct that, so I'd be in favor of it. [1:31:53] Sherry, did you have a comment? [1:31:55] Yeah, assuming that Wood Group doesn't have an issue [1:32:00] with the plan that they have, [1:32:02] I think the plan that I would consider heavy overflow, [1:32:10] whatnot, I think that's thoughtfully done. [1:32:15] They had talked a lot about comparing to Flagstaff, [1:32:17] and so I had to look up what Flagstaff's population was [1:32:20] and the area around there. [1:32:22] So they are pretty close to us. [1:32:24] Flagstaff is 75,000, they have an area population [1:32:27] about 150,000 that's pretty close to what ours is. [1:32:30] So, putting faith in that they will work as a special event [1:32:38] when they open up because that will be very heavily used or attended. [1:32:45] And then having the overflow was actually pretty thoughtful around there [1:32:55] and it keeps it away from the other parking more so than I had anticipated. [1:33:01] So, before we vote on this, I just want to add, I agree, I was a little concerned about [1:33:10] the traffic. [1:33:11] Still, I'm worried about the roundabout of people would learn how to use it. [1:33:16] That might help. [1:33:18] But I'm very pleased that your options for the overflow, that was really a concern. [1:33:26] I do have a lot of faith in our police department and fire department that they're not going [1:33:34] to let this be a disaster. [1:33:37] That's their job is to make sure that the traffic flows smoothly and they're the ones [1:33:44] that have to deal with the issues and so I would expect that they would be very thoughtful [1:33:49] in how this is going to come about. [1:33:52] So I personally will be voting in favor of this request, Chris Reed. [1:33:58] I'll make the motion if we're ready. [1:34:00] Go ahead unless anybody else has a comment. [1:34:03] Okay. [1:34:04] Chris? [1:34:05] I move that we approve the request for a special use permit to allow drive-through services [1:34:09] and extended hours of operation on property located at 1965 Blue Lakes Pearl of Art North. [1:34:15] Care of Todd Smith on behalf of In-N-Out Burger. [1:34:19] We want to add the staff conditions. [1:34:21] the staff conditions and as presented this evening. [1:34:25] Thank you Jason Brown. [1:34:27] Thank you motion by Chris Reed seconded by Jason Brown to approve the request for the [1:34:38] special use permit PC24-007 to allow drive-through services and extended hours of operation on [1:34:46] on property located at 1965 Blue Lakes Boulevard North, [1:34:51] pair of Todd Smith on behalf of In-N-Out Burgers [1:34:54] with the added conditions by staff. [1:34:58] Is that good? [1:35:00] Got it? [1:35:01] Any further discussion? [1:35:04] Jody Rokalvo please. [1:35:07] Ruth Pierce? [1:35:08] Yes. [1:35:11] Jason Brown? [1:35:12] Yes. [1:35:13] Chris Reed? [1:35:14] Yes. [1:35:16] Craig Hawkins? [1:35:16] Yes. [1:35:17] Sherry Volmer? [1:35:18] Yes. [1:35:21] for Cutler. No, I need to add Grace and Stone. [1:35:28] I'm saying. Thank you. Motion passes five for, excuse me, five in support, one against [1:35:38] and one abstention. Hey, that is it for congratulations, gentlemen. That is it for items on the agenda. [1:35:53] There's nothing else, so we will be a journey. [1:35:56] Thank you, everyone, for attending tonight.