Oversight Archive: City Council meeting, 2024-09-23, recording 1 (started 16:58) Machine transcript (faster-whisper base.en), not checked word for word; the Pledge of Allegiance is shown in its standard wording. The recording is the record. Times are time into the recording. Passages with private details are muted in the audio and marked here. The audio on the page below was re-encoded by software from the video the agency posted. Check any passage against that audio before relying on it. Page: https://oversightarchive.org/twin-falls-id/meetings/2024-09-23/ [0:00:28] So you ladies from P&Z can you're welcome to sit here for a few minutes or we're actually gonna be meeting upstairs and [0:00:35] I know some of your cohorts are already up there, but we have a really good time down here [0:00:40] So he might as well stay [0:00:44] We're gonna do the pledge up here. So we'll left is that right? [0:01:39] Good evening ladies and gentlemen and welcome to the September 23rd 2024 City Council meeting [0:01:46] I want to confirm we have a quorum. [0:01:49] We have all seven members present in chambers. [0:01:52] First item on the agenda is the Pledge of Allegiance. [0:01:55] If you wish to join me, please rise. [0:02:15] Thank you. [0:02:16] We have no proclamations tonight, so we'll move on to the consent calendar. [0:02:20] Council wishes. [0:02:21] Move to approve. [0:02:22] Thank you. [0:02:23] Do I have a second? [0:02:24] Second. [0:02:25] Sherry's got it. [0:02:26] Okay. [0:02:27] Motion by Chris Reed, second by Sherry Vomer to approve the consent calendar. [0:02:33] as written. Amy Rolkavoe please. Ruth Pierce. Yes. Chris Reed. Yes. [0:02:41] Greg Hawkins. Yes. Jason Brown. Yes. Spencer Cutler. Yes. Grayson Stone. Yes. [0:02:46] And Sherry Volmer. Yes. Thank you motion passes seven to zero. So we're having a [0:02:52] special work session tonight which I'll talk about here in a minute. So we [0:02:57] don't have any items of consideration. So I'm going to move on to general public [0:03:02] input. If there's anybody in the audience that wishes to address City Council, now is your time. [0:03:09] You have two minutes come down and state your name and whether you're a resident of Twin Falls. [0:03:16] Okay, seeing no one advisory board reports, right? [0:03:24] I wanted to talk about, this is called Operation Red File. I don't know if any of you are familiar [0:03:30] with this at all, but it was at the Joining Forces meeting the other day which is a sport [0:03:36] group for veterans, this is talked about, but the office on aging at CSI will provide [0:03:42] these at no cost. What it is is an envelope that's read, it's got two magnets on the back [0:03:48] and you put this on your refrigerator, but it's got all your emergency information, medications, [0:03:55] do not resuscitate. I know Councilman Brown was worried about that, but I do have that. [0:04:03] But this is a great idea, it could be a great resource, [0:04:05] especially if you have relatives that are getting up in years [0:04:10] like me, then that'd be a good thing to have. [0:04:12] So it's free too. [0:04:15] Let's get it at the office on, Adrienne. [0:04:16] Yeah. [0:04:17] Oh, great. [0:04:17] Thank you. [0:04:19] Anybody else have anything? [0:04:22] Hey, anything from the city manager's office, Mitch? [0:04:27] Next week, September 30th is a fifth Monday. [0:04:30] Sometimes we don't always have meetings on fifth Monday, [0:04:33] I just want to let you know we have a pretty good agenda for you next week. So we'll plan on [0:04:37] being here next week. Perfect. Thank you. [0:04:41] Okay, so we will be next moving into a joint work [0:04:45] session with planning and zoning and instead of holding it down here, [0:04:49] we will move upstairs so we have plenty of room to work [0:04:53] and we can all be with microphones. [0:04:57] The discussion is going to be a joint work session with Council and P&C [0:05:01] and the commission regarding the title 10 update. [0:05:05] Jonathan, did you want to say anything? [0:05:08] Hey, so we're going to adjourn to upstairs [0:05:10] and then once we're done with our works. [0:05:13] Yeah, look how close. [0:05:14] I know you guys feel like we're close. [0:05:16] You know what I mean by the other side right there. [0:05:20] It's like two Easter shirts. [0:05:22] I know you're talking about it here. [0:05:24] I know you. [0:05:27] I know you. [0:05:28] Best of of of you want to sit by me. [0:05:31] She wants to break us up. [0:05:32] She's the yoko of the group. [0:05:37] Sorry, I said you didn't leave that baby. [0:05:40] There you go. [0:05:41] There you go. [0:05:42] There you go. [0:05:43] There you go. [0:05:44] There you go. [0:05:45] There you go. [0:05:46] Jonathan, you read that. [0:05:47] We're not being filmed right this second. [0:05:48] Are we? [0:05:49] Yes, we are. [0:05:50] Yes, we are. [0:05:51] Yes, we are. [0:05:52] Open my eyes. [0:05:53] Your microphones are all on right now. [0:05:55] And they are all hot. [0:05:56] That was awesome. [0:05:57] Thank you. [0:05:58] Thank you so much. [0:05:59] Well, I've got to call them. [0:06:00] Well, I've got to call the meeting to order, and then I'll give it to me. [0:06:07] I'm going to need one, I think. [0:06:32] Break it already. [0:06:43] Go. Red is off. [0:06:50] So Jonathan said I could call this meeting to order both sessions, so both planning and zoning and city council. [0:06:58] But for a minute, I think everybody should introduce themselves because not everybody knows everybody, so maybe start with Craig. [0:07:09] I've got my mic on my computer. [0:07:11] I'm on city council. [0:07:14] It's going to be a long night. [0:07:16] This is Mayor Ruth Pierce. [0:07:18] Jason Brown. [0:07:28] Spencer Keller, city council. [0:07:30] And P&Z. [0:07:36] Gary Volmer, city council. [0:07:40] Robin Wetherford, P&Z. [0:07:43] Callie Hargassale, P&Z. [0:07:45] Danielle Titus, P&Z. [0:07:48] Chris Reed, city council. [0:07:52] Courtney Campbell, P&Z. [0:07:55] recreation stones to the council. [0:08:00] There are currently four members of the Planning and Zoning Commission that's Tiffany, Robin, [0:08:06] Kelly, and Danielle, so that is a quorum out of the seven. [0:08:10] If we get more, they'll come out. [0:08:14] Other five, or Courtney's over there. [0:08:15] There are five, I'm like, I'm looking at the left side. [0:08:18] You moved, so there's five out of seven. [0:08:21] And then the full council, usually take it away. [0:08:26] Take it away. [0:08:27] Okay. [0:08:28] All right, so you're, I'm sharing the screen up here. [0:08:32] I've got a written version here. [0:08:34] It's anybody need a pen, Jason. [0:08:37] We'll get someone to get you a pen. [0:08:39] We'll go grab some, a pen. [0:08:41] Anybody else need a pen? [0:08:43] One, two, three, four, five, four pens, [0:08:47] ish, or five pens. [0:08:50] All right, so the following, [0:08:53] I put this out with the packet. [0:08:56] There are a total of eight items. [0:08:59] This is a truncated version that you got in your packet. [0:09:02] So hopefully everybody was able to read, [0:09:04] at least the agenda briefly, and I can, [0:09:08] there's one main question, but I identified something [0:09:11] that we needed to have a discussion about, [0:09:13] and this is meant to be a full discussion [0:09:16] of thoughts and potential direction for staff to go with. [0:09:20] On each of these items, I have some version [0:09:25] of the code to show, some of them I don't, [0:09:28] because they're not permitted right now, [0:09:30] but in particular, the ADUs, I do have that one, [0:09:34] So I'm going to pull it up and explain a little bit of where we're at. [0:09:38] ADUs are going to be part of the conditional uses and the land use conditions. [0:09:52] There are, it is the chapter that is the longest because it deals with types of uses, especially [0:10:00] uses, conditional uses or non-permitted uses. [0:10:05] Johnathan, can I put in for one second? [0:10:07] Go for it. [0:10:08] Do you want to do some like ground rules? [0:10:10] Do you want people just to holler out? [0:10:11] If they have comments or questions or do you want, like, we don't have the little lights [0:10:16] that we can turn on or names or anything like that, so how do you want to do that? [0:10:19] Raising hand would be great. [0:10:20] You want me to deal with the questions, Mayor, or do you want to go through you? [0:10:25] Okay. [0:10:26] I think what's an ADU to that, yeah. [0:10:32] It's already on their accessory dwelling unit, but we've got the number, and we have quite [0:10:36] a few to go through, so I don't want to be here for, we're hoping about an hour, hour [0:10:39] and a half at the most. [0:10:40] I don't think of any other ground rules that I'm missing. [0:10:45] Okay, I'm going to get right to the discussion. [0:10:51] Currently City Code does not allow accessory dwelling units. [0:10:58] Currently City Code has a list of zones, R1 through R6. [0:11:05] Some of them, R2, R4 and R6 are the higher density ones. [0:11:09] They allow duplexes by right permitted, just get a building permit. [0:11:14] R1 zone does not allow duplexes, I remember you following me on that. [0:11:21] So currently how we treat accessory dwelling units, if you have a house in the R2 zone, [0:11:26] which is what the majority of the city of Twin Falls is zoned for residential. [0:11:30] There's a lot of R2. [0:11:32] Very little R1, a little bit more, R4, and a little R6. [0:11:39] If you're permitted to have a duplex from the zoning standpoint, we would give people [0:11:43] building permits to build an accessory or second dwelling unit, because a duplex is permitted. [0:11:50] Not a lot of difference between a duplex and an accessory dwelling unit, it's just two dwelling [0:11:53] units on the same property. Otherwise, you just have two properties with a lot size that [0:11:59] makes you so you can have two houses. But right now, that's kind of how we deal with it. The [0:12:04] problem is the R2 zone requires around 6,000 square feet. Looking at wheel, I don't remember [0:12:12] the number 10,000 square feet for a duplex and 6,000 for each dwelling unit on its own. [0:12:19] So a lot size, yep. [0:12:23] So it makes it really difficult if you have an older lot that's only 8,000 square feet. [0:12:29] You're not big enough for a duplex, but you're a little bit larger than for a one single family [0:12:33] home. [0:12:34] So there's the, that is really the crux of the argument that most people have is it's [0:12:38] a little bit bigger than the normal or the minimum size, but it's not big enough for a [0:12:42] duplex. [0:12:44] So we are going to create accessory dwelling unit, and I just have to find it down here, [0:12:52] so give me a second. [0:12:56] Dustring dwelling unit criteria. [0:13:02] This gives a purpose as to why it doesn't all have to be here, but this is something we [0:13:08] created as to why. [0:13:11] There's a lot of reasons to allow for accessory dwelling units. [0:13:14] This highlights some of them. [0:13:16] From a professional standpoint, there are very few drawbacks to accessory dwelling units, [0:13:21] there are some that occur when they occur sometimes they are very loud to [0:13:27] neighbors or big issues to neighbors. So we're trying to accommodate them but [0:13:32] also regulate them to deal with those issues. One of the biggest ones that we [0:13:40] hear that we've heard professionally is additional parking. That's usually the [0:13:46] one people talk about because it's visual and it changes every day. The cars move [0:13:51] every day and so they get reminded every day of how many cars might be next door that's [0:13:57] really the biggest one looking at will he may have to walk up here and join me so he can [0:14:02] say some of the things he's remembering that I don't we created this section to allow them [0:14:10] by right in every zoning district every residential zoning district would have them be permitted [0:14:19] if they follow these conditions that are written here. [0:14:24] They can come, including R1. [0:14:29] Yes, sure. [0:14:31] I don't know if this is premature to ask. [0:14:33] This number one actually I had the most questions on. [0:14:37] But I think to start off, is there anything with fire code [0:14:44] because I'm looking at the difference of attachment [0:14:49] versus detachment? [0:14:51] And I'm looking at, you know, an ADU unit should be a certain size on a foundation, [0:14:59] and maybe it has less setbacks, owner occupied piece to it. [0:15:06] So I think to start is, you know, attached versus detached, what's the difference then [0:15:16] of somebody just adding on to their house? [0:15:20] It's a good argument as to just let it happen. [0:15:22] But in terms of fire and building code, they all get satisfied, [0:15:25] no matter what version that gets created here. You have to get a building permit. Some [0:15:32] of them will require fire separation. Some of them may not, depending on which version [0:15:37] you do. The zoning code we are trying to stay out of getting into the fire and then building [0:15:45] codes, primarily. The only thing that I believe we should be restricting if we want to, and [0:15:51] the discussion is the size if you have a 5,000 square foot detached house and an original [0:16:05] 1200 square foot house which one is accessory if this one is three stories 5,000 square feet [0:16:12] in the house up front is 1200. So that is something to somewhat discuss but in terms of building [0:16:21] and fire codes they get a building permit and follow the building fire codes however it is [0:16:27] designed. It could design it to be in the basement and it will follow certain things. It could be designed to be detached and [0:16:32] would follow its own building and fire requirements in terms of like fire apparatus access. [0:16:39] So how would you, if somebody wants to add on, how would you separate that as an ADU versus I'm just adding on to my house? [0:16:46] If it creates another dwelling unit, that's kind of what's in here is sleeping sanitation and cooking facilities together in that area. [0:16:55] What creates a dwelling unit think of bedroom bathroom kitchen if you're going to and I don't want to get [0:17:08] Yeah, I'm thinking that if somebody comes up and says okay, well, I'm going to add on a [0:17:15] Rec room that has a small kitchen [0:17:18] that better than ADU and a bathroom, yeah, maybe. [0:17:24] Rec room bathroom with a small kitchenette. [0:17:26] Awesome. [0:17:31] Jason had his hand up a little bit quicker, [0:17:33] but only after he spoke. [0:17:34] Yeah. [0:17:38] I'll try and keep a handle on it. [0:17:39] But when that, you know, you'd have to have it, [0:17:42] does it have to have its own sanitary sewer connection? [0:17:45] Or are you distinguishing the plumbing in the ground [0:17:49] how it gets into the street? [0:17:51] Yeah, because that would distinguish, if it was in, to me, if it was part of your original house or something different. [0:17:58] It would be truly accessible or accessory would be hooking up to the original and they speak to each other. [0:18:06] Otherwise, it becomes a true duplex, which is, or even a separate unit altogether and they don't speak to each other with a plumbing code. [0:18:15] There's a lot of what ifs and scenarios that I can't go through all of them [0:18:20] It's just if you meet this you can have another dwelling unit [0:18:22] Otherwise just out on your house where I say you had on your house [0:18:25] I'm gonna go back to grace and after [0:18:28] Jason's question the plumbing code will kick in on something to if you did a detached accessory dwelling unit the plumbing code would require [0:18:36] each building to have its own connection, but [0:18:39] Regardless the zoning code is gonna allow it and you'll submit for your permits and the the building code will apply the building code [0:18:46] I should say will apply, including fire plumbing, mechanical, and all of them, and they'll have [0:18:52] to comply with the various building codes. The question that we're talking about here [0:18:57] is should we allow them or not? And sometimes it's going to be a fine line, whether it is [0:19:03] like what Sherry described, a rec room with a bathroom and a kitchenette. Is that really [0:19:09] a separate unit? Maybe. And maybe not. It'll depend on the actual plan being presented. [0:19:16] So, I'm going to leave the building, coming to the side and say follow it, I'm going to [0:19:24] let the plumber deal with that. [0:19:26] So, thank you Director Spendlove. [0:19:28] So it appears to me that the intent of this revision is almost to apply the duck test, [0:19:33] right? [0:19:34] Like if it looks like a duck, acts like a duck, swims like a duck, it's a duck, right? [0:19:37] I don't think a rec room would necessarily apply or the intent of it is to apply it as [0:19:41] a rec room. [0:19:42] I mean, unless it's designed as a bedroom, right, with closets and I mean, I think that [0:19:49] There's, it is a little, I don't want to say gray, [0:19:52] but to me, I think being 10 is clear for an ADU. [0:19:58] So I don't have a problem with it. [0:20:04] I understand some people's issue with parking spaces. [0:20:09] When I'm thinking I'm an ADU, [0:20:11] I'm thinking of for an elderly person, [0:20:13] it could be for anybody, and I understand that. [0:20:16] I think the challenge of requiring a parking space, [0:20:20] an off street parking space, [0:20:23] I know somebody right off the top of my head that they're looking to try to do an ADU in [0:20:28] another area, their parents do not drive, so they have no need for an extra parking space, [0:20:34] so now you're talking about an extra cost, and that's a financial burden on somebody for [0:20:39] that. [0:20:42] So I would stray away from requiring an extra parking space. [0:20:47] Now if certain areas have CC&Rs, that could be different. [0:20:51] Danielle, then, I'm here. [0:20:53] I guess I'm a little confused on why parking spaces are an issue here. [0:20:59] Is there something in city code? [0:21:01] Maybe then I'm not familiar with that requires a number of parking spaces per residence as [0:21:07] it stands. [0:21:08] Can you refresh people here what that is? [0:21:10] Each house or dwelling requires two parking spaces currently unless you're in an apartment [0:21:16] and it kind of goes up from there, moderation from there. [0:21:19] Is that off street parking? [0:21:21] So how do you handle that with the number of streets of the town site when some of them [0:21:27] don't have the mover of legal nonconforming and mayor. [0:21:34] So it might be all fine not to require a parking spot, but that's for the resident that minute [0:21:41] that property sells then what do you do? [0:21:45] Yeah, I mean, yeah, got a future thought on the property itself. [0:21:52] And with this, as it's written, we put in one additional space for the accessory doing [0:22:01] unit to accommodate or in the middle between two and none. [0:22:07] You can have a half a parking space, I guess that's why. [0:22:11] I think it's what's the purpose of the dwelling unit. [0:22:13] Is it going to be a rental and it's going to be a second unit or is it a truly going [0:22:17] to be an accessory unit? [0:22:20] That's the crux of the argument, I'll be honest with you. [0:22:23] That's what I was going to bring up. [0:22:25] This is something that we've had many conversations about. [0:22:30] We don't get to decide what it's going to be. [0:22:32] It could be mother-in-law moved into it today. [0:22:36] Five years from now, mother-in-law passes away. [0:22:40] Maybe kids move in. [0:22:41] Maybe it's a rental income. [0:22:43] We don't want to be policing those types of things. [0:22:46] We know it's already happening in our community. [0:22:48] We don't have the time or energy to be able to go and police that. [0:22:51] So the standard of one car, I'm totally fine with it, I think that setting that standard, [0:22:59] yes, it for those individuals currently where mom is moving in and she doesn't drive, it's [0:23:04] an inconvenience, but five years from now when it becomes an Airbnb in the back of the house [0:23:11] or whatever it is, it will be there to protect the neighbors as well. [0:23:16] Answer was next and then back to Daniel a couple weeks ago. I would have said I don't really care [0:23:25] Some complaints about parking in general and it had nothing to do with 80 years and you know [0:23:30] There's all these arguments such as you know, you may not have an 80 you you simply have a lot of cars at your household [0:23:37] but [0:23:39] That we can't control we can control this so someone's gonna permit an 80 you I would support requiring one extra space [0:23:48] It's not going to cure all our problems, maybe not even a small minority of our problems, but it might help with a few. [0:23:54] Here, I'm going to share. [0:23:56] Danielle, first. [0:23:57] Danielle, then you will go this way. [0:23:59] My comment was actually going to be pretty similar to Spencer's. There's, you know, some people that own [0:24:04] or than one car per person in their household, and how do you know it's not one household versus multiple? [0:24:11] So that's where I'm going to get, is this, are all of these regulations, whether it is attached or detached? [0:24:16] detached they have to follow the same or are there separate regulations for [0:24:19] attached versus detached because kind of like what Chris mentioned the use may [0:24:24] change it could be just a rec room today the next person that buys the house [0:24:29] could be renting it separate as a studio and it's an open kitchen bedroom with the [0:24:34] bathroom so it's kind of you could still have it as a separate unit and rent it [0:24:40] out even if it doesn't necessarily have its own bedroom in that regard or for [0:24:45] or an Airbnb, we see that in our town today. [0:24:47] So I agree. [0:24:49] I think the one parking spot makes sense [0:24:50] if it's going to be an accessory [0:24:52] or it's going to be for another residence. [0:24:57] The concern I have is the attached versus detached. [0:25:00] I know others mentioned at what point do we say [0:25:02] it's for a second dwelling unit versus just an addition [0:25:07] onto the house. [0:25:08] So that's where I'm getting hung up. [0:25:12] Well, and then I guess the other question in your example [0:25:14] where the accessory is 5,000 square feet. [0:25:18] And you only require one parking spot for that accessory. [0:25:22] Is it a size? [0:25:23] You know. [0:25:24] Yeah, it's not. [0:25:25] But should it be? [0:25:27] There's a but. [0:25:27] So we did create, because of that, [0:25:30] we did create the size, 45% of the square footage [0:25:34] of the living space for the principal residents. [0:25:37] So in the scenario I gave, you could then simply build [0:25:41] the new house being bigger, and then you keep both [0:25:44] and the small one becomes accessory. [0:25:47] We did 45 because it truly ended up [0:25:48] being just less than half the size of the primary dwelling. [0:25:53] So if it's 1,000, you can have an accessory building of 500. [0:25:58] It's the primary residence before you create the accessory. [0:26:02] That's how that works. [0:26:03] That gets at the size thing, because that [0:26:06] has been an issue in other places, too. [0:26:07] They go, well, I can have an accessory, [0:26:09] and the addition is the accessory, [0:26:10] but it doesn't matter if you have to figure out the math. [0:26:14] that way you don't have one thing overpowering. [0:26:17] No dwelling unit in the city of Twin Falls [0:26:19] is based on, for parking, we don't base it [0:26:23] on size of the building. [0:26:25] That's commercial stuff. [0:26:28] Apartment complex as we do, but we give you a bonus. [0:26:31] Or we give you a, make you have another half a space. [0:26:35] And that's if you have like over three bedrooms [0:26:37] in an apartment complex. [0:26:39] So this is a three bedroom, a two bedroom, a one. [0:26:42] We want to even those out. [0:26:45] We get two and a half for the three bedrooms as apartments [0:26:47] because those end up a lot of the time being rented out [0:26:50] to two or three different people or households. [0:26:54] Let's answer that question. [0:26:55] I think we're going this way. [0:26:56] Sure, Courtney. [0:26:57] I don't know which way we were going anymore. [0:26:59] Is this modeled after what other cities do? [0:27:01] And can you tell us what other cities our size are doing? [0:27:04] Yeah, we looked at places in the Treasure Valley called well. [0:27:09] And then some primarily the resort communities [0:27:13] actually have more of the regulation than cities, that's as much as I look at all of them and [0:27:21] I don't know exactly which ones, but most of the treasure valley ones we looked at of our [0:27:25] size were bigger than Miller. We know two zoning codes are the same so they thought something [0:27:32] was more important than we do, maybe they don't think the parking is an issue where they do [0:27:37] and they want two spaces. Some people play with the percentage of the ADU, some don't allow [0:27:44] them to be detached, some of them do. Frankly, I didn't see the difference if it was attached [0:27:49] or detached as long as they meet the setback requirements like if building's a building. [0:27:57] All the fire code, if you can't get the fire truck near it, that's going to be a problem [0:28:00] and the fire marshal won't let you put it way far in the back because they need access. That [0:28:06] kind of stuff will kind of regulate itself how. Sherry, back to Grayson. Then Danielle again. [0:28:12] These have our questions. The parking space, what would you require for a parking space? [0:28:22] Nine by twenty. Nine wide twenty. [0:28:25] Of what? Heart surfaced of some sort. We allow a lot of things. Most people put asphalt and concrete. [0:28:35] I would probably want the parking on whether it needs to be a full 20 feet or how that is because it is cost prohibitive if you're doing a true ADU. If you're trying to do a rental that's different and I don't want to start regulating our city that way. [0:28:51] but I also don't want to make this so cost prohibitive that you just a true [0:28:58] honest person just wants to put an ADU for their parent that doesn't drive and [0:29:03] we still have to put a driveway in. So that and then one of the units does need [0:29:15] to be primary residence whether it be the ADU or the or the big house because [0:29:21] as it could be a parent moving into the ADU [0:29:25] and then having somebody in the bigger house, [0:29:28] doesn't need to be on a permanent foundation. [0:29:33] I'd say permanent, yeah. [0:29:34] Yeah. [0:29:35] Do you have multiple questions [0:29:36] between them and to go with first? [0:29:36] I know, I'm sorry. [0:29:38] I had them on, and it just sounds like we're talking [0:29:39] about everything all at once. [0:29:41] Yeah, the size would matter on it. [0:29:45] I would think that we would wanna let up a little bit [0:29:48] on the setbacks for an ADU unit of a specific size. [0:29:53] And I think we need to be careful about making it too small, but we definitely don't want it bigger than the primary residence. I would not think [0:30:00] Is it's a accessory? Yeah [0:30:05] I guess that kind of opens up the discussion for you. Yeah, I'll answer a few of them. Okay, the city engineer can accept a lot of materials as [0:30:12] Heart surface code currently says heart surface [0:30:16] Regrind double chip a lot of these things can be heart surface as long as [0:30:20] They don't drag materials from the property to the public street. That's one of the primary purposes. [0:30:27] The other one is to support any type of emergency vehicles in certain situations you need to have at the fire truck. [0:30:35] Otherwise, you got a way to get to 9x20. [0:30:40] One thing that might help is to, I don't know, which is tandem parking. [0:30:46] That'll be a discussion for y'all after, and that actually could help in a lot of ways to [0:30:53] allow that, because then you right now, so everybody knows right now, not to get to number [0:30:58] two just yet, but each parking space needs to be independently accessed on its own, and [0:31:03] that is pretty cost prohibitive. [0:31:05] You have three spaces, most places, most lots in town don't allow that, unless you have [0:31:13] like two act two roads one in the front one the back so because that ends up being [0:31:17] pretty wide 36 feet and doesn't really work so [0:31:22] Unforged separate yeah the setbacks for the accessory [0:31:29] E to use I think would meet the main or the intent of the accessory building setbacks [0:31:37] Meet that, you can build it. [0:31:41] We are requesting or written in here to modify some of those, but currently, best rebuilding [0:31:48] on your property can be three feet from the property line. [0:31:51] That's something that we want to allow accessory willing units to do, that we can certainly allow [0:31:58] that. [0:31:59] Or if we say, you know, I think they should just meet the main building setback for the [0:32:02] side and rear yard, you could do that too. [0:32:06] There's a lot of options there. [0:32:08] Currently we just wrote it to meet the main the accessory current three feet from property line [0:32:13] But that allows you to do though is build three feet from the property line [0:32:18] 35 feet tall because that's currently what's permitted in code [0:32:23] Necessary [0:32:25] Yeah, any like you build a shop in your backyard right now three feet from the property line 35 feet tall [0:32:30] That's what you can do [0:32:34] Yeah, that'll be a different number [0:32:37] I don't know if I answered all your questions [0:32:39] But in terms of the size that is for the discussion to say, I'd say stick with the percentage because that's something we can [0:32:47] Certainly regulate if if we like 45 or 53 or [0:32:52] 61% whatever we kind of get a general feel for I think we should [0:32:58] Get everybody to give their input on the general number then we'll go with it from there. We went back to [0:33:05] Thank you, Director Spunliff. So what I'm thinking about [0:33:10] about ADU's and additions to homes or accessory buildings. [0:33:17] I think in my opinion, there's a pretty clear clean cut definition in my head. [0:33:24] An ADU to me means that you can live independently without having to access any other part of [0:33:29] the house and or dwelling. [0:33:32] So to me, the ADU doesn't matter if it's detached or attached versus an addition. [0:33:38] If you're building a full kitchen versus a kitchenette in a rec room, it's pretty apparent. [0:33:44] So, if you can live independently in that space without having to access any other portion of the home, [0:33:49] you need an additional parking space. [0:33:51] And if it's just an addition, obviously you're not going to be putting [0:33:55] laundry and hookups, refrigerators, a full stove, stove, oven, countertops. [0:34:01] So, I think there's a pretty clear distinction that we could easily write in. [0:34:08] I don't know where we're circling back as a Danielle next. [0:34:12] Yeah, so kind of along those lines, I guess, to me, it would be we have entrances loaded [0:34:19] up there, but that just says about it's talking about like facing the road, right? [0:34:25] Yeah, that's right here. [0:34:27] Yeah, so it's just saying about the street side, unless it's detached or previously existing. [0:34:33] Is there anything that says it needs to have a separation from the like, if it was attached [0:34:39] Versus detached if it has a separation from the main building whether even that's just a doorway at the top or bottom of stairs [0:34:46] And it's own and trends their exit to the exterior of the home [0:34:52] Would that make it more of a dwelling versus a family edition or in that case [0:34:59] Then if it is just an honest person with an elder elderly and family member or mother-in-law suite [0:35:05] If it just goes right up the stairs, but it's just upstairs and there's no separate entrance or exit from the actual home [0:35:12] that even if it had a full kitchen to me that would not be a separate dwelling unit because you have to access it through the [0:35:19] Original house and to me that would then not require the separate parking because that's no different to me than [0:35:26] having another teenage child driving versus having a [0:35:31] adult living in the home driving [0:35:35] now if there's a if there's any separation including a door and ends up [0:35:40] being a separate dwelling especially most of them put a door on the outside and I [0:35:46] think what Grace is talking about is is what we're the intent is if you have an [0:35:49] ex separate entrance even if you have a doorway but it's just like a two-way door [0:35:54] it's locked right you those things are fine in the building but if you have a [0:35:57] separate entrance into this place that truly is a separate living space it's an [0:36:01] accessory doing or could be. We are not, we were not intending to require people to do [0:36:07] certain things. It was to allow it to happen. I didn't want to get into, you shall have a door, [0:36:11] or you shall have this. If you want to ask for one, just meet these criteria. If you don't want [0:36:17] to do that, then make it just an addition to your house that you have these options. [0:36:20] But is that what I'm saying? Is that what should define it as an accessory dwelling unit? [0:36:25] I don't think that alone should define it. [0:36:27] Not alone, but with it. [0:36:30] I guess where's it coming from? [0:36:33] Where do you say like, hey, I'm just building an addition versus it's a dwelling unit. [0:36:38] If it's just I get to choose and then hey, why are we making this part of the code? [0:36:43] It comes to cool. [0:36:44] There are like, if I asked 100 designers to give me 100 designs, I can't give you every scenario. [0:36:50] This will allow some to happen. [0:36:52] And we'll just have to work with it and massage it as we work with it. [0:36:55] Because it's not going to be perfect as I write it. [0:36:59] The key ones here, I'll be honest, the key things are the size, the parking space. [0:37:04] And the biggest one is owner occupancy or not. [0:37:07] Now I'm going to share with them back to Chris. [0:37:09] Those are the real main questions we have. [0:37:11] Everything else, we'll make sure that the safety things were set up, the plumbing code, fire code, the electrical code, I'll get followed. [0:37:18] So back to your question then on owner occupied, they definitely should be [0:37:23] owner occupied because otherwise you're making it into a duplex in my [0:37:27] vision. The whole point of an accessory dwelling unit is an accessory to an owner [0:37:32] occupied home. Whether that means the accessory unit is being occupied by the [0:37:37] homeowner or the main home. I don't think we should dictate who does but the [0:37:41] homeowner needs to be occupying something there on the resident or a [0:37:47] be on the residents of, for lack of better words. [0:37:51] And then I think we need to take in consideration of size. [0:37:55] And as we get into size on that, we need to understand that if it's a 1600 [0:37:59] square foot house, what makes a livable accessory dwelling unit. [0:38:03] So I don't think we want to go too low in square footage or in percentage [0:38:07] on that, but I do like the percent on that. [0:38:11] I think what's next is your hand. And then Chris says, I may have, [0:38:17] I don't know, other one of you was first to go for it. [0:38:21] I agree with the sentiment from Sherry that it should be owner occupied otherwise it's a duplex. [0:38:26] If a duplex is already permitted and they want to go that route, that's great. [0:38:30] But otherwise I think it should be owner occupied. [0:38:34] Okay, 2D and E up there who's going to enforce that, who's going to run around and make sure that this happens. [0:38:47] You know, it's really easy when they're building it to make sure that E has happened. [0:38:51] Totally agree with that 15 years from now when it's on the third owner, I mean, are we really gonna try to enforce that? [0:39:02] Are we gonna put that on the city? And then which group is the enforcement of it? [0:39:07] And then if we find out that they're not within code, are we gonna force them to move back? [0:39:13] I like it's just one of those things that [0:39:15] And if they end up bringing an extra child into that house indeed, are we gonna? [0:39:20] Sorry can't live here. I just feel like we're setting ourselves up for failure on D&E. [0:39:26] E's counterintuitive is if we're going to outright allow duplexes even in R1 and R2 across the board, [0:39:37] definition of duplex in our code doesn't say one of them has to be on our occupied. [0:39:42] And so it contradicts itself. So E becomes irrelevant. [0:39:47] It requires just a larger lot size. [0:39:51] I don't know how you can enforce E at all. [0:39:56] I think that at the time where you can enforce that while you're building it. [0:40:00] Because hey, I'm building this. I occupy that home. [0:40:04] When somebody sells the home, we're not following them around [0:40:08] making sure that as your family member is going to live in this [0:40:12] dwelling unit, I think we're putting both D and E in [0:40:16] in their place where we're not going to be able to enforce it and really we're [0:40:19] not going to know in a few years. I will tell you the E is the one thing that is [0:40:24] it's super controversial when we're talking about from any city when they [0:40:27] implemented this. Number of cities have removed this requirement because well [0:40:34] partially that but what actually what happens is when you come to find out [0:40:37] that they're no longer on our occupied, getting the council to issue a court [0:40:42] order to remove the items from a house is difficult. So if it's it's really hard to [0:40:49] do but it's legal-ish to do. Like you can require it when it's built, keeping up on [0:40:57] it is very difficult cities go. Alright so who's like are we unless you [0:41:02] institute like a licensure program or re-registration every year for someone [0:41:07] to continue to provide the proof of the. [0:41:12] Wouldn't that come under homeowners exemption with the county? [0:41:15] It would, but we'd have to keep track of it to make sure that they're still [0:41:18] complying if we want to make them be living in it. [0:41:22] We'd have to keep track of it and then issue and then require them to either [0:41:25] remove the unit or the items within the unit like the kitchen to say it's no [0:41:30] longer a separate dwelling unit. [0:41:32] That's for cities that run into this kind of roadblock of how do we make [0:41:36] can take stuff out. Just give me the pitfalls. [0:41:40] You've got personal property rights here, right? [0:41:44] If somebody buys a piece of property that has an AD you want it, [0:41:50] they may want to put two rentals there, and we can't really [0:41:54] dictate that. Would that fall within zoning if you're in an R1? [0:41:58] I mean with this you can. It's just whether you [0:42:02] want to order someone to remove the items that they're going to have two rentals. [0:42:06] Exactly. That really comes into your preference of what you want to do or not. [0:42:11] Spencer, I can't see behind me. I don't want to cut anybody off. [0:42:18] I've got some order in here, which is good. [0:42:21] No, I agree wholeheartedly. Enforcing D. I've got like a dozen reasons. I wouldn't even want to worry about that. [0:42:28] With E, I wouldn't want there to be a mechanism for us to enforce that after that's built. [0:42:36] but think about what happens in town right now. I mean we know there's a lot of [0:42:41] apartments and houses that haven't been permitted and that's okay you know it's [0:42:46] not really a detriment to our city but I'm thinking about the initial creation of [0:42:51] the ADU. We don't want large investors coming in and buying homes and dividing [0:42:57] them up. This would prevent a lot of that if and again we'll get to vote on this [0:43:03] later and if I get out voted I still like all of you a lot. But yeah you know [0:43:13] initially I think that if there has to be proof of owner occupancy that would [0:43:17] eliminate a lot of that out of town investment type groups that just want to [0:43:23] cut things up preserve a lot of peace and neighborhoods initially. Five years [0:43:27] later if it's sold to someone and they do whatever well that's gonna happen [0:43:31] and practically we know we're not going to enforce that. [0:43:34] But that's similar to what's happening now. [0:43:35] You can go through a lot of neighborhoods, [0:43:36] especially where there's not CC and R's, [0:43:38] and there's been apartments created, [0:43:40] and it's just happened. [0:43:41] And they probably renovated inside [0:43:43] and did things that should have been permitted, [0:43:44] and they did it. [0:43:46] And that's something we live with, [0:43:47] and we don't go door to door knocking, [0:43:50] trying to enforce that. [0:43:53] Not gonna come mainly from people, [0:43:56] are we gonna find out not because we're tracking, [0:43:59] but because they're like with code enforcement, [0:44:01] somebody's weeds. They've called and made a complaint. And so that's something that we have to look into. [0:44:07] Your point, I don't want to what I'm afraid of is we're going to start creating a whole bunch of rentals in an R1 zone. [0:44:13] That's since there is no turn here. I'm not sure that's illegal. That's really the issue. [0:44:25] What's not illegal? Having rentals in an R1 zone. Yeah, it's not legal to rent the house. It's not illegal to rent a bedroom. [0:44:32] But you've got two units on one lot in an R1. [0:44:36] So what's the R1 for? [0:44:39] What is an R1 zone? [0:44:40] To be straight up with you, we are proposing to give it a R1 [0:44:44] and combine it with R2 because there's literally [0:44:46] no difference other than that one thing. [0:44:48] But then if we go to an R2, then the accessory dwelling unit [0:44:52] basically has the difference between that and a second home [0:44:58] being built on there for a rental purpose [0:45:01] is that you can get away with less setbacks. [0:45:04] You have an accessory dwelling unit. [0:45:08] And it would have to be the same water sewer hookup, [0:45:12] so you couldn't do a separate water sewer hookup. [0:45:15] Yeah, technically. [0:45:16] That's how we're writing it. [0:45:17] And now that I think that having the same water and sewer [0:45:22] would probably might eliminate some of the rental [0:45:27] act of it, but not all of it. [0:45:29] I agree it's a valid concern of people saying the rentals because generally people see rentals as absentee landlord issues [0:45:39] That's what a lot of people see with least the biggest negatives of it is very visible [0:45:45] There's just nothing you can do from a land. No, and I'm all about property rights believe me [0:45:51] But I just want to make sure that we're not creating bigger problems in the end because there is a huge need [0:45:57] for ADU's right now [0:46:00] for [0:46:02] as a lead peoples [0:46:07] but that's the [0:46:09] the main question i wrote down is the one that i think is [0:46:12] most controversial across the lot [0:46:14] country particularly west [0:46:16] on our computer [0:46:18] so could you add language to [0:46:21] basically saying after [0:46:23] initial [0:46:24] transaction [0:46:27] kind of figure that out after the initial so initially has to be on our [0:46:30] occupied after that [0:46:33] it's fair game after it's gone through a purchase and sale transaction [0:46:38] I guess my problem is is we have a code that says it shall not be unless it's owner occupied. [0:46:53] If we have a code that says that shall not be and we're not enforcing it, we then run into [0:46:58] other issues that we have run into. [0:47:01] So I guess what I'm saying is if you put a shall not be owner occupied or beyond the [0:47:08] first, you know, whoever comes in for that building for years has to be owner occupied. [0:47:15] After that we don't necessarily care. [0:47:17] We know that it was owner occupied initially and after that we are not, we're not tracking [0:47:22] it. [0:47:23] We're not keeping up to speed with it, but at some point if you put it as written we have [0:47:29] to enforce as is, then to address the concern of other individuals is, at some point, is that [0:47:37] a guess a sunset clause? [0:47:39] Yeah, I think you could do that, it's like the first year or something like that. [0:47:45] And then, it's basically creating a bar for an owner occupancy to get the permit in the first place, [0:47:51] and then after that it wouldn't be, but the bar initially wouldn't be investment firms or somebody doing it [0:47:58] applying for it. They have to show proof to get the ADU and then problem is enforcing [0:48:04] it later. And a lot of people have a lot of cities have issues enforcing it later. [0:48:07] I just don't think for some of the things that were you had said and had been said I [0:48:15] do not believe you will enforce that even if you could enforce it. I don't [0:48:21] foresee a time where we would go in and say you've got to rip out your kitchen [0:48:26] or your whatever, I mean it's just in the state that we live in and what we've got, I just [0:48:33] don't see how that's enforceable and I guess I'm not excited about creating something that [0:48:38] we're not going to be able to enforce in the future. [0:48:44] Yeah, how other cities have enforced it is not necessarily rip it out but they'll give you [0:48:51] a title-time violation if you're renting it out to some two different parties. [0:48:56] So you can have the two units, but you can't be renting them out two separate times. [0:49:00] Again, that's an enforcement nightmare, but rather than going to the drastic change of [0:49:06] rip it out, they'll say you're renting to two different people. You can't do that. [0:49:10] It's still considered one rental with as owner occupied. [0:49:15] That turned into a fine. Does it turn? Fine. Does it? I'm trying to connect that with the [0:49:21] homeowner's exemption because if you're caught and you're not living in the home and it's a [0:49:26] a homeowner's exemption, then you get charged the full tax rate, correct? [0:49:30] Right. [0:49:31] So is there something that can be done with this? [0:49:34] Right now, Title 10 is a fine and then it goes up to a misdemeanor. [0:49:44] And I'm not pro-tracking. [0:49:45] I mean, I'm just telling you right now, just, tracking this is not going to be- [0:49:51] No, I was just going to echo what Jason said, I think a Sunk-set clause accomplishes and [0:50:02] a bit of a good compromise between making sure investors aren't coming in and scooping everything [0:50:07] up. I would probably want to see it like 24 months, like two years, to really make sure that the [0:50:15] intense achieved. I think that's a great idea, Jay. So clarity on that. Are you saying that they'd [0:50:23] have to they have to live in the house for 24 months before they could do this or they have to live [0:50:30] in it for 24 months, so once they do this, so what happens if they sell it within that 24 months, [0:50:36] are we still, do we still have to track it for that 24 months? I feel like if there's a sunset clause, [0:50:40] there's really no point in having it because anyone, if I'm an investor, I'm going, cool, [0:50:45] they're not, they don't care, it's done after 24 months, I can still buy it, say it's my address, [0:50:50] build it, and sell or rent it. I don't see the purpose of it at that point. [0:50:54] I was just thinking the same thing, Danielle, like, it kind of just takes away any teeth [0:51:04] that it had originally, I feel. [0:51:06] Really? [0:51:12] There's no teeth in it as it sits now, because we've already said we weren't going to track [0:51:16] it. [0:51:17] So I either think we either need to get rid of it entirely or put a sunset clause on it, [0:51:21] because if we're not going to track it, like we're, I mean, I can definitely see where this [0:51:27] is the sticking point that cracks the whole thing. [0:51:29] So we either had the sunset clause or it just goes away in its entirety. [0:51:35] My problem is the sunset clause to me means we would have to track it because if it got [0:51:39] sold within that 12 or 24 months, whatever that time frame is, we would then have to [0:51:43] keep track of that new owner and then continue, you know what I mean? [0:51:48] And is it, we would then have to specify, I'm assuming, of you know, 12 months from when [0:51:54] this was established, if it changes owners, that doesn't restart. [0:51:59] So we would still have to be tracking it for that 12 months to say, hey, was it sold? [0:52:04] Is the new owner still living there? [0:52:06] I feel like that is still not going to happen. [0:52:09] So to me, this, I mean, if we're not enforcing it regardless. [0:52:14] I'm answering real quick. [0:52:16] The Sunset Clause, I believe what you're just doing is creating an initial bar to cross [0:52:22] and then after that, over. [0:52:25] So to get the permit from us to do it, [0:52:28] prove that you are after that it's, [0:52:31] there is no tracking, [0:52:31] I believe that's how that would work. [0:52:33] You can say 24 months, I think, is just the initial, [0:52:37] there's no way we could create it [0:52:38] if you're not tracking it [0:52:39] and if you're not gonna force anybody to remove, [0:52:42] you can create the initial bar, [0:52:44] and then after that it's... [0:52:47] I just want to sit here real quick. [0:52:49] If you haven't heard the wise counsel of my colleagues, [0:52:51] I retract everything I said. [0:52:53] I have no opinion. [0:52:55] No, don't retract. [0:52:56] Okay, Spencer, the court needs back, the court needs back, and that's it. [0:53:01] So maybe the realtors in here can answer this, but wouldn't that at least, if we put that in the code, [0:53:07] wouldn't that might be flagged by a lender? Like when they had the first time home buyers loan, [0:53:12] but they said you have to live in it for 24 months, I know that there were some lenders that you couldn't adjust the financing [0:53:19] if you were violating that. [0:53:21] Good question. Go to Sherry. Maybe she knows she's the next one to raise your hand and then Chris. No, that would not [0:53:28] Have any it would not trigger anything for that [0:53:32] Good point though. I understand where you're going with that [0:53:35] so [0:53:36] Question do we track every single code that we put in here in the city? [0:53:42] What do you mean? We don't track every single code? [0:53:46] I track all the codes that are written but in terms of the violations violations. Do you go? Yeah, so see we so [0:53:52] we would not, so I don't see us tracking this. [0:53:55] I don't think the 12 months on there, [0:53:57] so I think you put it on there. [0:54:00] It needs to be owner occupied, you do the permit. [0:54:02] If it happens after that, [0:54:07] then I guess we figure out with code enforcement, [0:54:08] but we're not gonna be tracking this. [0:54:11] And how many people are going to call in on it? [0:54:15] Well, I think everybody's assuming [0:54:16] that everybody's gonna violate this. [0:54:18] You know, there actually are people out there [0:54:20] that follow code. [0:54:22] Exactly. [0:54:22] And so there may be people that will think twice before they're going to do something because [0:54:28] there's this clause, which is what we really intended. [0:54:31] So I don't think we're worried about all the people that are going to rush around and violate [0:54:36] it. [0:54:37] I think I'm guessing 90% of the people are going to follow it and we're talking about a handful [0:54:43] of people that might not. [0:54:44] It needs to stay as owner occupied otherwise there's no difference. [0:54:48] I think if I just simply delete the first one and then all you have to do is provide [0:54:52] proof that you're gonna do it that creates your initial bar and then after [0:54:55] that if you read it just proof of honor occupants he shall be required prior to [0:55:01] issuing any permit then that's it you just delete the must be occupied by the [0:55:08] owners and it's not has to be occupied but in order to get the permit to do it [0:55:12] you have to show proof that you are and then over here on track was a lot that was [0:55:25] the long one I don't be honest the next ones are way less if until you get to the [0:55:35] last one. Okay. Are we okay to move on? We have like a little head nod. Okay. So tandem [0:55:43] parking, not a lot to lead into it. It is exactly what it sounds like on parking spaces [0:55:49] and from another need to move the one car before you get the other one out. Is this something [0:55:54] that we care to want to do not to do? Sherry. Thank you. Allow it in single family only. [0:56:01] I think that's fine and single family. [0:56:12] Grace, how does that work if we're getting rid of the single family R1 zoning though? [0:56:17] We're merging it. [0:56:18] All of the zones allow for single family houses, so you just be a land use type, not the zone. [0:56:23] There's single family. [0:56:27] Being a family detached house, then you can do it, and if you just work with it in the permit, then if you have a duplex, [0:56:35] triplex, you may not permit them. [0:56:40] Yeah, that would be an option to make it allowable. [0:56:46] I will tell you from just a staff perspective, the only place that I'm looking at that doesn't [0:56:50] have any commercial application of it at all, doesn't really work. [0:56:56] It's trickier when you get to multifamily, like complexes, when you don't have like assigned [0:57:02] spaces, because then it becomes kind of difficult. [0:57:06] I've seen it used in other places like that and it doesn't work. [0:57:10] If you have assigned units like town homes, [0:57:13] where it's this one's their spaces, [0:57:14] that works because they're the ones that own them, [0:57:17] or they're the ones that are responsible for the one and two. [0:57:22] Those are the only times we know that like, [0:57:23] absolutely we don't think they work as any commercial [0:57:25] or industrial application whatsoever. [0:57:28] Apartment complexes, we can make it work [0:57:29] with some stricter guidelines. [0:57:32] Chris and then Ruth, no. [0:57:36] Real quick, single family is considered town homes. [0:57:42] one unit and duplexes. Otherwise, so that's what we consider single [0:57:48] families, so we're on the same page and we speak. If you're wanting to separate [0:57:53] them out, that's great. Just make sure we know that. Didn't we do this? Yeah, I mean, [0:58:03] just the stacking over off of Pole Line, that subdivision over there, the townhouse is [0:58:10] 42 apartments. There was garages and Naked Park, they had a unit right there, so [0:58:16] You kind of already have this if it's assigned. [0:58:19] Yeah, you did it through a ZDA and that's what they were asking for. [0:58:22] I think if it was assigned parking, I wouldn't have a problem with it. [0:58:26] Wherever it is, it just can't be a free for all. [0:58:29] I'll just drive over you. [0:58:37] Are there any other instances, any other comments? [0:58:40] Anybody's like, yeah, I don't really like it or I have no problem with it. [0:58:47] Okay, we're going to write it in. [0:58:54] A lot of people have asked for it. [0:58:56] It also helps with downtown when the people are redoing buildings houses downtown. [0:59:00] As Sherry pointed out, some of them don't have any and they could create just a 9 foot wide space to allow for those things to happen. [0:59:08] That's a big one. [0:59:13] Special use permits versus zoning administrative reviews. [0:59:17] I'm not going to read everything that I wrote in the staff report, but I can put up there for you. [0:59:23] Primarily, there are some uses that we need to or want to or have been directed at some point in the time to not have special uses anymore. [0:59:32] uses anymore. Those would then be either outright permitted with no additional conditions or [0:59:40] in this case I made the sub-zoning administrator review which is basically the code has a lot [0:59:44] of conditions to meet. They file a building permit that meets those and we issue like a [0:59:49] hey we've reviewed your permit as long as you continue to act this way you can continue to operate. [0:59:54] If you have the three that originally we were told to get rid of from special uses and go [1:00:00] to conditional slash zoning reviews drive-throughs, which I know you all have a lot of experience [1:00:06] with recently, home occupations and daycares. Primarily in home daycares but some of the other [1:00:15] commercial daycares as well. And there's a host of others that we could do. Yeah, let's just [1:00:25] start with drive-throughs because that's the one that could be... [1:00:29] Are you talking drive-through extended hour drive-through or drive-through or drive-through [1:00:33] We can talk about like senate hours as well because that's the fourth one probably. [1:00:38] Just drive through restaurants slash coffee shops. [1:00:42] Should they be special uses still or should we separate some of those out and potentially [1:00:47] create a if you're far enough from any residential house. [1:00:51] Don't do the special use permit. [1:00:52] Just follow some criteria and I'll start with Chris. [1:00:58] Question for you as far as what was the last time we said no to a drive through just a few [1:01:03] months ago. [1:01:05] Did you counsel? [1:01:06] No. [1:01:07] That's making awkward. [1:01:09] Wait a minute. [1:01:10] It's one of those. [1:01:14] I can't remember. [1:01:16] It's been a long time. [1:01:17] Like honestly, I could not find one as far back as the early 90s or late 80s. [1:01:24] And so I think having those requirements for review would be probably better than a permit [1:01:29] at this point in time. [1:01:31] Like a public hearing. [1:01:32] Are you separate? [1:01:33] Public hearing versus just follow the rules. [1:01:35] Follow the rule. [1:01:36] but yet that I would be in favor of that. [1:01:40] In all situations or in like distances from houses or do you? [1:01:45] I think if somebody went through the review, the ZAR, and people had concerns, there was [1:01:52] an area for them to appeal it ultimately, but besides that it just goes through that review [1:01:58] instead of the special use permit. [1:02:01] Public hearing. [1:02:02] public hearing and then moves forward if it meets those requirements that are put [1:02:08] in place. Yeah, Grayson, Courtney, there, Greg, in that order. If we're doing a ZAR [1:02:18] for the drive-through, can we restrict on which zones they can do it in? Yes. So we [1:02:22] could technically say, yeah, no more drive-throughs in the CRO. Yep, you could. I [1:02:29] would, or other things, be careful because that's 700 feet from the rim. That's a [1:02:32] That's a long way. But yes, I don't know. I kind of like it going on our [1:02:39] specialies. There's that extra set of eyes, but I think we definitely need to [1:02:44] look at where we're putting the drive-throughs in the zones, but Brittany. So I [1:02:52] also am a fan of the specialies permit for the drive-through, because when we [1:02:56] look at the city, we don't think that we have an enormous amount of drive-throughs, [1:02:59] but I think that there's a lot of people who would have just built a [1:03:02] drive-through had they not had to go through the process. So I hate to see [1:03:05] every smoke shop and tattoo parlor with it. [1:03:13] There, I think, Adrian, sort of a? [1:03:18] I just was thinking that I'd rather have, [1:03:22] you guys take care of that. [1:03:23] I think, you know, your expertise and stuff, [1:03:26] we respect that and we rely upon it a lot. [1:03:29] There may be the exception to that, [1:03:30] but if it can be appealed and come before City Council, [1:03:34] that's kind of a backup measure, so. [1:03:39] Well, that was actually my question is, [1:03:41] would there be a process if the neighbors were not happy [1:03:46] that your ZAR made a determination, is there a process to appeal it? [1:03:55] Currently, yes, it's a zoning administrator review. [1:04:01] You have to set it up if you want a discretionary review. [1:04:04] Right now, that zoning review administrator, like appeal, is really the question that gets asked of the commission, [1:04:11] and then the council, if it goes as far as whether the code was applied correctly or not. [1:04:16] It isn't a, is this a good idea, it's the, the code says this, is that what the administrator [1:04:22] said? [1:04:23] We disagree with the interpretation of that code, but if you created, it could get complicated [1:04:31] where you say you make the determination, zoning people, and then send letters to everybody [1:04:36] and say, here's the decision, here's the issue, if you want to appeal this decision, go through [1:04:41] the appeal process, because that, that could be done, and then if neighbors go, I don't [1:04:46] like the way that's drawn to have this issue then you could have the public [1:04:50] hearing be a discretionary decision with the commission. It would more or [1:04:54] less turn into the exceptional hardship argument. Could you just say I [1:04:59] don't want to. That's a process. Yeah. The neighbors would be the ones that [1:05:04] would be appealing not the applicant but yeah it'd be I don't like this here I [1:05:09] think there should be. It turns into a nimby argument. Yeah it ends up being a [1:05:15] nimby type of thing. I don't want it near me and so then you'll go through a [1:05:19] public hearing process to potentially alleviate any of the concerns. I think [1:05:24] we have a fairly good handle on most of the issues in terms of traffic noise, light [1:05:32] and if anything else that we usually forget those are honestly most of the [1:05:38] conditions we put on them. Build the fence, put the lights over here, make them [1:05:43] so they shine this way, make sure that your city engineers okay with how you're [1:05:47] entering and exiting the property and if you have to put up a barrier in the [1:05:51] the middle of the road, you do it. [1:05:53] We could still do that with a zoning review [1:05:56] for drive-throughs and get 90% of 95, [1:06:01] maybe as high as 98% of them, [1:06:02] like really almost exactly where the [1:06:04] specialist permits were issued. [1:06:06] It's those two percents that just, why not? [1:06:10] People just don't want them there. [1:06:12] When I say people that want them there, [1:06:13] neighbors are not expecting them to be there [1:06:15] because either the zone was there [1:06:17] in the 70s or 80s, or it was rezoned after, [1:06:21] before they moved in and so it's commercial property and so it's a [1:06:25] restaurant can be there but the drive-throughs extra that's really the [1:06:29] conversation Robin in the back and I don't know if there's anybody after that [1:06:33] and then Danielle. I'm in favor of keeping it as an as a special use permit and the [1:06:40] reason why I think that is because I look at the difference in drive-throughs [1:06:43] between in and out and Taco Bell. Let's keep that once and so and has it come [1:06:48] Let's not talk about that. [1:06:50] Okay. Well, sorry about that. [1:06:52] But it's just the difference between commercial and residential. [1:06:56] I think it would be nice to have that second set of eyes like they said. [1:07:00] I can honestly see this one both ways. [1:07:06] I don't think we've really denied much other than the one recently [1:07:10] that I've ever seen. And I think most of the conditions [1:07:14] are there. The biggest differences come if it's [1:07:18] what the neighboring properties are or the nature of the business's number of clientele. [1:07:25] So if you want the extra eyes and opportunity for the public input on that, then keep it. [1:07:33] If you're comfortable with [1:07:35] the stacking and the requirements as it is, I do think the City Code is set up at right now to mitigate most things, like you said, [1:07:42] with fencing, light, noise, and the required five stacking from that first stopping point [1:07:48] and escape lane. [1:07:50] So I think it addresses most scenarios, but if you wanted that opportunity, do not have [1:07:55] to go through the appeal and then keep it for those kind of special circumstances. [1:08:02] I don't, even if it was zone based or certain distance from residential, I'm not sure there's [1:08:11] a ton of spaces in our city that are that far from residential in some regard as it is I think all would [1:08:17] probably be yeah there's only some on pull line and blue legs yeah and maybe have a few but not very [1:08:25] many um that would if it were a distance based from residential property yeah this one i'm kind of [1:08:31] comfortable either way i'll be honest i think i've got like a 50-50s plate right now it's any way it [1:08:40] works of wisdom from over the corner. I was just going to say that it goes back to that [1:08:49] appeal question. I struggle with that because I don't want to have a code that [1:08:56] gives staff discretion because that leads us to lawsuits and that would be a bad [1:09:02] bad deal. So an appeal of a staff approval would have to be did you apply [1:09:08] the code correctly, not is this the right place for that thing to happen. And so I can see we're [1:09:17] an applicant who doesn't like the approval or denial appeal to like the Planning and Zoning [1:09:24] Commission because the staff didn't review the code correctly and then they would have to make [1:09:31] that case in front of the Planning and Zoning Commission. And we have that process already [1:09:34] set up with administrative appeals that happen, they don't have a lot, I think a couple times [1:09:41] in the last five or ten years maybe, but it's there already and it kind of works if it's [1:09:47] not a discretionary decision but rather a disagreement on how the code should be read. [1:09:55] If the thing should be there in the first place is not a decision for staff to make. [1:10:00] So what we're proposing here would be to set up the code in such a way that we're defining [1:10:07] that it is okay to do this here under these conditions. [1:10:11] And if that's what we're okay with, we're going to move forward with that, and there's [1:10:15] several uses that I think we could do that with. [1:10:17] These are just the three that he's thrown out there. [1:10:21] I think there's lots of them that every time an SUP comes up, we're approving it except [1:10:27] for maybe one or two and 30 years, right? [1:10:30] And in that case, it makes all of our jobs easier, [1:10:35] and the applicant, their work easier and more efficient, [1:10:39] and all those things that we wanna be, [1:10:44] it puts that in place, I think, better for everybody, right? [1:10:51] The downside will be the folks that really didn't think [1:10:53] that that should have gone there, [1:10:56] not that it shouldn't have had, you know, five spaces instead of six, right? [1:11:02] So, discretion should really come out of it if we're going to go this route. [1:11:08] We have that anyway, people who just don't want it there. [1:11:12] I have absolutely no problem with home occupations letting you take that one. [1:11:18] I don't have the ones that I've seen are almost like the nimby thing. [1:11:23] The massage oil is going to stink up the neighborhood kind of stuff. [1:11:29] Same with in-home daycare. [1:11:31] As long as they have the proper parking and there's exactly. [1:11:36] So it's just on the edge with the drive-thru. [1:11:40] Drive-thru's can be another topic for a different day or even further, [1:11:45] or we create the condition slash requirements and bring empty and say, [1:11:50] Yeah, that's kind of what we could go with and we can separate some of them out somehow [1:11:55] Will and I will have to workshop that on how that can be figured out [1:11:59] But the rest of them, I think the bigger ones that we know of home occupations and that covers everything from like the dog groomer [1:12:07] Gano teacher to the [1:12:10] An accountant that occasionally has some under their taxes that they have people coming like whatever it is those are people that are home occupations [1:12:17] There's no sign out front, but they have customers coming to their house [1:12:21] else. We can deal with that primarily by some conditions and they're pretty minimal. Yeah, [1:12:29] it happens a lot. And I think we just make it easier because the bar right now is a public [1:12:34] hearing. Back to drive throughs not totally. I was just going to say after hearing everybody [1:12:47] I'm comfortable with the ZARs as well. Give us to give a little bit direction to staff. [1:12:56] Is there a certain context you do not want drive-throughs in? [1:13:01] So residential, I'm assuming, no, but Blue Lakes, is there a context on Blue Lakes that you wouldn't want them in? [1:13:09] Or is there, Grayson, you called out the canyon rim over, or you said along the canyon rim? [1:13:19] Want them in close to the CSI campus? Do you want them? [1:13:27] the context if you describe the context that you don't want them in it gives us [1:13:33] more guidance on how we can form these conditions and what zones the conditions [1:13:38] can be tailored to. I'll put the target on my own back I would say anything north [1:13:44] of Poland right now until we get another additional access point across the way [1:13:49] I think that that would alleviate a lot of issues. Anywhere I'm pulling? I would say [1:13:57] between Eastland and Washington. We can talk a bit about that and I think I'm [1:14:10] going to just point out really the council prepared to pay for people's [1:14:14] property rights to take them away because if you take away the right to ask for it [1:14:20] that's what you're doing I just don't want to go that route unless we really [1:14:23] want to go that route. It's not a matter of taking away property rights [1:14:27] it's I mean you can make the same thing in the same argument with CROs right [1:14:31] on your property rights to how high you want to build something in the [1:14:34] structure you want to build so I just think I would be interested to see just [1:14:40] what that would look like I guess I can show it yeah we can get you a map I just [1:14:43] want if we if you take the thought of if you have a special use permit avenue now [1:14:50] and you don't have it tomorrow there could be a takings analysis issue I just [1:14:56] want to be aware so for example you could probably write the code to have to [1:15:02] have the ZARs in general, but leave an SUP in place for the [1:15:07] Can Your Moverlay, maybe leave an SUP in place for the [1:15:10] neighborhood commercial zone, something like that where those [1:15:14] are close to areas that might be sensitive or close to, I [1:15:19] like this, yeah, there's stuff like that we can do, but [1:15:22] everywhere else it would be allowed in a C1. That's the [1:15:26] kind of context because we currently allow a special use [1:15:29] permit that we just change the context. All we would change [1:15:32] this gives would be the C1 zone would be allowed by right under these conditions [1:15:36] instead of by SUP and the other zones but maybe the downtown there might be [1:15:40] some other zones we need to think it up but it's complicated there's a lot of at [1:15:44] least a couple right the sensitive ones can remotely the neighbor commercial might [1:15:48] be you know an SUP there is a question we do have do you want or like drive [1:15:56] through downtown like the downtown core blocks just let's just think of like [1:16:08] anything in the downtown core area okay works in some places it doesn't work in [1:16:13] others I was gonna say the banks you have drive-throughs in the banks and [1:16:16] some other things I think to me it the drive-through really comes down to a [1:16:21] zoning you know specify the zone in which it's outright permitted and which [1:16:27] zones have to go through special use permit like Mitch had said but I don't [1:16:34] think if we don't allow it downtown then we also then have a scenario where it a [1:16:40] bank or something like that and those ones that would be difficult to navigate [1:16:48] through but again you could leave it as a SAP in this central business is that [1:16:57] is called? [1:16:58] Yeah. [1:16:59] So again, I think it's defined in the zoning and not necessarily, I think to me, it goes [1:17:11] back to what Mitch was explaining, saying there's certain zones that it's outright permitted, [1:17:16] there's some that we're just not going to allow it in, but these ones, it needs to be [1:17:20] a case-by-case scenario. [1:17:22] And we can do that by zone and we could do it by area or specific area if you want to [1:17:26] as well. [1:17:28] Can you also get my youth like business drive-throughs versus yes restaurant drive-throughs like you can make that distinction? [1:17:35] I think you can you can say banks are fine or you can do it by the number you have a number of projected [1:17:45] traffic trips [1:17:48] There's a lot of things we can do I'm thinking there's some there is some appetite to [1:17:53] Permit and not to permit in a certain areas [1:17:58] Besides ad use I don't know do [1:18:04] Yeah, while we're on it and since I'm about do want to talk about extended hours. That's not on the list [1:18:16] Hours of operation for retail [1:18:21] Current code literally just talks about when you're selling stuff or service like [1:18:27] seamstress or [1:18:28] higher shops [1:18:30] Do we care if those are operating past 10 p.m.? And prior to six or seven a.m. Yes or no in residential areas I care [1:18:41] Okay in them but near them and [1:18:48] to me like I've extended hours because they're in a specific zone that we've designated is for commercial, but to Jason's point, yeah, I don't think any of us want to see that in the middle of a residential area. [1:19:01] If we're going to allow residential residences to operate businesses, we have to be careful not to extend the carte blanche of you can open up till midnight. [1:19:13] I know what you mean. [1:19:14] You mean like given voice lessons until midnight, is that what you mean? [1:19:17] Okay. [1:19:18] However, an accountant wants to work till midnight. It's okay. Is that right? [1:19:23] In your own house [1:19:26] But as long as customers aren't coming over [1:19:29] So the current restrictions just for retail uses [1:19:34] And you can't do retail as a home occupation. It's not one of those whole occupations [1:19:38] It's allowed. So this would be really the commercial type uses and so again, you might have a a sea [1:19:44] What's the right the neighborhood commercial zones are sometime and there's like one or two around the city, right? [1:19:52] Those are the ones that are generally gonna be closer to homes [1:19:57] Maybe that would be where the prop is but I'm the hours of operation thing. I'm a little less concerned about that personally [1:20:04] But I just need to know if we're gonna keep them. We're not right now [1:20:07] It says you can't operate retail past 10 p.m. Anywhere [1:20:11] Anywhere, but what do we do about black Friday? What I thought we're closed [1:20:28] Yeah, I mean most of them I'll be honest with you [1:20:30] It's one of those where when we know of a business opening and we say hey [1:20:35] Anyway, let's just throw the hours on there because we want to make it right, but other places just [1:20:40] to just go. There's a lot of businesses that are open retail that are open past [1:20:45] town. Yeah and I would stick and I haven't forgotten Sherry. I would stick with one or [1:20:52] two. Either it's a zone thing and it's all commercial or it's downtown and you just [1:20:58] say look there are no hours of operation. You just basically delete it or you [1:21:02] restrict it to like the community market which is gonna be nearer to homes that [1:21:07] has hours I'd say nothing is open past like one or it's 24 hours and we don't [1:21:13] care I'm only going with one o'clock because the chief usually says hey bars [1:21:17] close at one was just trying limits and things past one but I don't know if that [1:21:23] Walmart's open or someone such such as open past that and when goes open 24 [1:21:29] hours I'm not sure we care it's just one of those things I need to have a [1:21:34] direction that is deleted we just say we're not regulating it but in these [1:21:38] these certain zones we are, and that's commercial, [1:21:41] they're the near residential, I'm sure. [1:21:42] And I think that I like that point, [1:21:44] is the near residential, yes. [1:21:48] I don't know what, I'd like to hear what issues we would have [1:21:51] if we did 24 hours or no time zones in the commercials, [1:21:56] I'm leaning towards grown hours, whatever you want, [1:22:00] but not in the neighborhood. [1:22:02] And so when we talk about that, would that then limit [1:22:06] the hours of operation for the new, [1:22:10] I forget the new gas station that's out on ground view. [1:22:13] Yeah, that one's in like a neighborhood market. [1:22:15] Yeah, so if they wanted to stay open past 10 o'clock, [1:22:19] they would have to apply for special use. [1:22:21] Is that correct? [1:22:22] Or it's just not permitted. [1:22:24] Or it's just not permitted. [1:22:25] If you want to allow them to ask for it, [1:22:27] you can create that option, or you can just say, [1:22:29] look, we don't want you to open past 10 in the neighborhood [1:22:34] areas. [1:22:37] So my first instinct would be to, you could do a ask for [1:22:41] special use permit or some kind of a special use. [1:22:45] I don't know what that looks like right now, and I don't know [1:22:47] that we want to dive down that area right now. [1:22:49] But I think the neighborhood zones, we should limit the hours [1:22:53] of operation and commercial zones, limit them. [1:22:59] Right. [1:23:00] Great. [1:23:00] I have a question on that. [1:23:01] So all the businesses that are currently in those areas, [1:23:04] I mean, should we grandfather them in since, I mean, I'm sure [1:23:07] they built their performance based upon, [1:23:10] predicated on, extended hours of operation [1:23:13] if they already have it. [1:23:14] Like how do we go back and say, [1:23:15] hey, I know you just made this huge investment right here [1:23:18] on this piece of dirt, but you actually can't stay open [1:23:20] as long as you thought you're good. [1:23:22] On this case, we're not limiting, we're expanding it. [1:23:25] We try not to do that. [1:23:27] I wanna say, I don't think we're intending to do that. [1:23:29] I wanna make sure I understand. [1:23:31] I want everybody done to be clear. [1:23:33] There are a lot of places in town [1:23:35] just because of how it was done. [1:23:37] Commercial zones are right next to residential zones. [1:23:42] Just before clear with that, I know people that move in [1:23:44] know that, and quite frankly, a lot of these businesses [1:23:47] are open anyway right now, unless we're going [1:23:49] to see a lot of difference, it's just that line [1:23:52] will just disappear from code to say it's no longer [1:23:55] not permitted to see one's own. [1:23:56] You can just kind of go to or just delete it. [1:24:01] So I feel that needs is more thought put behind it, [1:24:04] and I don't know if this is the right day, time to be doing that, [1:24:08] because there is a lot of commercial up against a residential, [1:24:12] and I feel like I'm making a knee-jerk reaction decision on, [1:24:18] okay, yeah, I'll see all commercial zones. [1:24:21] We don't care what hours you're open. [1:24:23] Yeah, I don't think that's necessarily, I think it's more just trying to figure out where [1:24:31] and if we want to allow it. I mean, I kind of agree with Sherry. [1:24:34] almost want to create another zone or restriction that you have to be within [1:24:38] two or outside of 200 feet from a residence to have certain hours or stuff [1:24:42] like that but that definitely I think that needs to be flushed up I think I need to [1:24:46] see a map I need to be more because we are affecting people's [1:24:51] rights that would be easy to do what you just described and we have that you can [1:24:57] just say outside of these hours within X feet of a home you got it yeah got [1:25:02] I'd like to see how that affects the city currently. [1:25:07] We can get the map and I don't want to keep on this. [1:25:11] I'm going to ask a question. [1:25:12] Maybe I want the planning and zoning commissioners to ask this one or answer this one if that's okay. [1:25:17] What conditions would you place on any commercial entity that wants to go past those hours [1:25:22] as a way to mitigate the impact? [1:25:26] You're sitting on the stand and you go, I got a business. [1:25:29] You're residential. [1:25:30] I'm going to put a condition on it to mitigate it. [1:25:33] What do you think the condition could, would you, would you want it to do? [1:25:37] Or would you simply just say, we'll look at the hours they ask for and see if they're okay, [1:25:43] or then keep them shorter, and yell, and then I do want to hear. [1:25:48] I'm seeing her going, I'm not sure. [1:25:51] Yeah, I feel like a lot of it's kind of taken care of with, I mean, [1:25:55] as it is, they can't have certain lighting or allowed speakers, things like that. [1:26:00] So, I think that would be the biggest one if it's close to residential. [1:26:05] most of the things we get from neighbors in public hearings is concerns with noise and [1:26:11] light. [1:26:12] Um, possibly traffic, but again, at that hour, there's not going to be as much or it's, like [1:26:18] you said, it's the, I don't want that here or it's, you know, late hours, they're assuming [1:26:24] there's going to be negligent actions taken by the patrons at that hour, but that's kind [1:26:31] of addressed down other venues. That's not really the responsibility of the [1:26:35] business. So I think most of it's kind of, I don't know that there's additional [1:26:41] that's needed. Looking at Tiffany, Kishan said anything, someone asked her to answer this one. [1:26:47] So I agree with Daniel in a lot of ways. I think that three things that we hear the most of is [1:27:01] light and negligent actions. [1:27:10] Yeah, yes, rip-rock, I was okay with that word. [1:27:24] I don't necessarily know if it is or is not the businesses, that's the part that I'm not [1:27:33] sure of. [1:27:38] In the back, Courtney, Kelly, and then Courtney. [1:27:40] I'm not sure I understand your question. [1:27:43] If you get an application for someone to get extended hours, that's in a commercial zone [1:27:47] in the residence is like behind it. [1:27:51] What conditions would you place on the special's permit [1:27:53] for the extra hours? [1:27:55] Or would you just simply just limit the hours? [1:27:58] I mean, if I think about the one that just happened, [1:28:02] we limited the hours. [1:28:03] Yeah. [1:28:04] Because the other pieces were already built in like Daniel [1:28:07] is saying those were already pieces that were being addressed [1:28:11] to try to minimize the impact on the residents. [1:28:16] I also feel like that it's on a case-by-case basis kind of. [1:28:20] So I don't know, I feel like it's on a case by case. [1:28:30] Courtney? [1:28:31] I'm big on the operating hours. [1:28:32] I think if they're in that buffer zone, [1:28:34] we're gonna create that it's just a set, limited hour. [1:28:38] I got curfew, no more. [1:28:41] Go to bed. [1:28:42] All right, I think that's all the commissions [1:28:44] that go back to the council as well. [1:28:47] I think Craig and then Sherry. [1:28:49] Just a thought, I know some of these big franchises [1:28:52] require businesses to open certain hours and I don't know how that would work out but it's [1:28:58] just something to think about. [1:28:59] I mean you can limit them but I'm cherry. [1:29:02] So I guess I'm asking a question is you know so what do you do about businesses that currently [1:29:08] on blue lakes that back up to residential properties and they are open in their drive-throughs till [1:29:14] 12 or 1 o'clock in the morning. [1:29:17] I don't I can't think of what their hours are right now but I'll have to find out. [1:29:20] So now if you're going to buffer on residential, that's why I'd really like to see a map and [1:29:25] see how that affects our planning, our strategic plan going forward, our zoning that we have [1:29:30] on there. [1:29:32] I just have a problem making a knee jerk decision. [1:29:38] I would agree it's light sound and then the biggest issue that we have had in the past [1:29:43] was lovely bar bump and burnies a few years ago, which that was a whole other issue. [1:29:51] And so, which we handled, so I think a map would be fine to look at it. [1:29:56] I think having something in place for when you're near residence, even though we do a lot [1:30:03] to protect against residents, I mean, I think of the Domino's Pizza from several years ago, [1:30:09] where they butt up right next to it and they have extended hours. [1:30:12] They're open a little bit later. [1:30:14] I haven't heard any complaints, but I think that being able to look at the map, making [1:30:20] sure that we're not going to do a knee-jerk reaction would be appropriate, but I think [1:30:25] being sensitive to those where commercial and residential are next to each other, having [1:30:31] something in place would be appropriate. [1:30:33] If they had their hand up before Danielle? [1:30:36] Not me if I say something that I'm not supposed to say. [1:30:41] I just would encourage, because I don't know what has come to us that hasn't come to City [1:30:45] Council. [1:30:46] Talk about appeal hasn't gone to them, so that's the only one you can't talk about. [1:30:50] So the only thing I would say which in looking at some of the drive-thru is one of the things [1:30:58] that I take into consideration with light is which way the drive-thru faces. [1:31:06] Does it face, so yes, to go to sonic, it is next to residential, but the drive-thru follows [1:31:14] the direction where the headlights face other commercial properties. [1:31:19] I think that is something that should be taken into consideration, talking about the difference [1:31:23] between if it's close to residential, also how does it affect residential? [1:31:29] And how late they're open as well? [1:31:31] Correct. Yeah, in regards to the hours because that's... [1:31:34] I don't know who else, Danielle, I don't know. [1:31:38] I was just going to say, I do think it might be good to look at a map and just kind of see [1:31:42] how that looks right now, but I do think, if I'm remembering correctly, most of the areas [1:31:47] that are adjacent to residential are the town neighborhood and we could always leave [1:31:53] SUP requirement for those areas and if you're solely C1 not in the residential or you know [1:32:02] downtown those types of areas maybe it's allowed and or maybe we say hey it could be till one [1:32:09] but if you wanted to be 24 7 or till 4 a.m. or anything like that then we would still [1:32:13] require the special use that way it gives kind of the commercial a little bit [1:32:18] more leeway but anything extended past like that bar hour those those times that [1:32:24] we have seen some issues then it would come for review to make sure that any [1:32:29] other possible conditions that would need to be in place to protect those [1:32:33] surrounding areas would be there Kelly's questions right now it's seven to ten [1:32:44] do we care if it's like six we say hey we can change the whole thing generally [1:32:48] six or five I think for commercial if it's again if it's commercial I wouldn't [1:32:53] have an issue seeing it a little earlier five a.m. five thirty and then [1:32:57] until one a.m. personally something like that I don't know I think I have a question [1:33:05] and forgive me because I haven't been on PNC for very long but is what we do [1:33:12] when we're hearing is this considered part of like due process for those [1:33:17] individuals involved? Yes, both. So, harking back to what Mitch was talking about, the [1:33:23] Planning and Zoning Commission that Council have the ability to make discretionary decisions. [1:33:28] It's a weighing of the facts and weighing of the issue, and then you make a decision. [1:33:34] I don't get to have, I don't have that. So, from a staff perspective, what's the law? [1:33:38] It just makes you fall in the law, makes you get to that point. And then, the important [1:33:44] part for both of these groups, when you're in that hearing, you're talking about a specific [1:33:49] property, it's just like you're a judge against a defendant and the prosecution in a way. [1:33:56] You're looking at the facts only in front of you, and then you weigh the decision as a [1:34:01] jury does, whether it's guilty or not, whether it should be permitted or not, and you kind [1:34:05] of weigh these two things and come up with a discretionary decision to do it or not to [1:34:10] do it. [1:34:11] So it's part of the due process is the applicants to have a fair trial and the neighbors to have [1:34:17] an opportunity to speak. [1:34:19] That's what the state law requires. [1:34:21] And they can speak and bring up issues that you then weigh on whether you should mitigate [1:34:26] it or if it's just completely outland issue going on, it's not really in our purview to [1:34:30] keep such and such from being, does that answer your question? [1:34:37] It does answer my question. [1:34:38] I think it's helpful to frame like how do we want to set it up so that those, there's still [1:34:42] a process but doesn't need to be part of every single scenario. [1:34:46] Right, we're trying to kind of say, right, most of these it's going to be okay but maybe [1:34:49] there's some of these we still want to see discretionarily. [1:34:54] A lot of the complaints that we get after the hearing is that the neighbors feel that they [1:35:02] were invited out there for just procedural and that they didn't have a say that they didn't [1:35:06] have any due diligence. [1:35:08] So, for instance, in home occupations, we basically represent those every day, every time, and [1:35:17] the neighbors that are against it, they're saying, well, you didn't even listen to me. [1:35:20] So what I guess my caution is, if you're going to approve it every time, let us approve that. [1:35:31] If there are six circumstances you wouldn't approve it in, then that's when either we condition [1:35:37] it or we can bring it to you. [1:35:42] if you talked about that one, bring you something a little bit more. What, thank you, what is the [1:35:49] time that you would like to us to? And very specifically, I put an hour and a half and we're [1:35:54] there. Yeah, we are there. What does everybody want to do? We're on item three of eight. We could [1:36:03] go till seven, which is another 23 minutes. How does everybody feel about that? Are you done? [1:36:09] I was going to say, if we can knock the list out, then we don't have to do this a second time, and I feel like we can get moving to the adoption process, because that adoption process can take a little time, and I think at the end you're going to go through some of our procedural stuff. [1:36:32] If we could have a little bit more time to get through a little bit of this, I think it'll save us a whole other night of doing this. [1:36:39] If you're okay with that. If you're maybe beat and hungry, then let's end it. [1:36:44] Everybody's hungry because she didn't serve lunch or dinner. [1:36:48] But you have your number three. You're good? [1:36:52] Yeah, I think we're good with number three. These are the ones I did on purpose. [1:36:57] This is kind of quicker until the very last one, maybe. [1:37:01] Is there any, I guess, appetite to either increase building [1:37:08] heights uniformly or to change the process? [1:37:12] And I will tell you, so right now, residential, it's 35 feet. [1:37:15] Every residential district is 35 feet. [1:37:17] Every commercial district is 50. [1:37:20] Do those heights still sound good, [1:37:22] or do you want them go up a 5 or 10 feet? [1:37:25] Mary's moving to say something. [1:37:27] What do you see? [1:37:28] as their eyes and cherry. Sorry. I'm probably going to ask the exact same question she was. What [1:37:36] what have you what has come forth to you as far as building heights? Most of the [1:37:41] residential is just fine. Those that are larger houses have some things going to 40. [1:37:47] There's not very many of those, but they do happen occasionally like chimneys and like [1:37:50] some of the roof lines that they want especially certain look. Commercial 50s in pretty good unless [1:37:56] it's a special project. There just aren't very many going above 50. If the heights are fine, [1:38:03] I believe the heights are okay for now. It's pretty easy to change the number later. [1:38:09] Do you still want the process of two public hearings? Or should we just go to one? [1:38:15] And that's really the question that I think that I wrote down. Why would you see two would [1:38:18] be good? My main thing is go to one, but do you see a problem with having just one? I do not. [1:38:24] not the previous council is the one that wanted to. [1:38:28] And Mitch can give some picture and you can raise your hand. [1:38:30] That would be good because my first thing clean is for... [1:38:33] So when we changed this code in the first place, we created the code, the exception, the height [1:38:39] exception. [1:38:40] I think it was 12 or 15 years ago, it was a while back. [1:38:44] We used to not have it at all. [1:38:48] And it was like this really big nasty process to deal with these things. [1:38:56] So we created a, I think we pitched it at the time as kind of like an SUP for additional [1:39:02] height. [1:39:03] We didn't call it that, but the process was pretty much that. [1:39:05] Let's take it to the Planning and Zoning Commission. [1:39:08] After a hearing, after we've notified the neighbors, we can approve an additional height. [1:39:13] And when that recommendation found its way to the Council, the Council said no, we want [1:39:18] to hear that here. [1:39:19] And so the Planning and Zoning Commission makes a recommendation for a decision by the [1:39:24] Council. [1:39:25] direction at the time again like 15 years ago I don't think anybody here on [1:39:29] the council was here then and so I think it's a fair question to ask if we want [1:39:36] to have one and so I would further the question of one I have one hearing or two [1:39:40] is that the P&Z or the council and that's what's kind of what we got first has one [1:39:49] or stand up one yes I think he and see it with an appeal to the council somebody [1:39:55] what we currently have for other things. I don't think we need to have both. Jason I'm okay with one. [1:40:05] I would actually like to see us maybe consider raising the height of the downtown corridor [1:40:12] being allowed buildings to go a little bit more vertical than. We have a proposal for just a [1:40:20] downtown which is called the central city zone and maybe that just goes up to 60 or 65. Sure. [1:40:25] somewhere that is reasonable. [1:40:28] Like one more floor, essentially, is what, like, [1:40:30] at 60 feet is another floor and ends up [1:40:32] getting around four or five stories, depending on the, [1:40:37] or on the, on the height. [1:40:39] It seems like the things that have come forward, [1:40:41] it's not the actual height, it's, you know, an AC unit. [1:40:45] It's a chimney. [1:40:46] I mean, if there's something that we can write [1:40:47] into the code for those pieces where, I mean, [1:40:50] you're having people come forward, [1:40:52] spending a lot of money and time for an AC, [1:40:55] an elevator shaft, those types of things where it's not really the building itself. [1:41:00] It's an accessory and we can write something in like that. [1:41:03] An exception for elevator shafts and stairwell covered anywhere. [1:41:07] At like antenna towers or something on one building. [1:41:11] Cuz one might be a separate issue, but yes, you can see that unless it's for the building. [1:41:15] I was thinking just like a, oh yeah, for the building, not that one. [1:41:19] Yeah, like it's an exception up to whatever feet for an accessory on the roof or something. [1:41:27] So that way they can't just go with something crazy, but it would allow it would prevent them from having to go through the whole process if it's just, you know, five feet over or something for an accessory, not the building. [1:41:48] Gotcha. [1:41:49] We will come up with some language. [1:41:51] Could you use the term occupational space? [1:41:53] Occupiable space. [1:41:55] Occupiable space. [1:41:57] You could not exceed x because of it. [1:41:59] Kind of next to everything else. [1:42:01] The idea that I have in my head right now is for like safety [1:42:03] safety elements on the rooftop which is your elevator shafts [1:42:07] your AC units or your stairwells [1:42:11] because they have to be covered. [1:42:13] So if they have an x access up to deal with the rooftop units. [1:42:17] a lot of time we'll look at downtown only central city stuff which would be [1:42:23] well to do sick is probably sixty-five because that gets you the extra so the [1:42:29] building kitty corner from us how tall is that one just yes I think I was like [1:42:33] I want to say it was in like the eighty to eighty four range right for the top of [1:42:37] the elevator but the real building is like 70 or 68 the question I would ask [1:42:42] and is that building that's kitty corner offend folks and is that the [1:42:46] appropriate height because it's a six-story 80-foot high building or 75-foot tall [1:42:53] building. That's a standard. We could write that fairly easily. I'm good with it. [1:43:04] I'm good with it. I think I'm looking more into like apartment buildings too. [1:43:10] Then I might throw out one additional question on this issue. A lot of the [1:43:17] other additional heights we've seen in my 20 years have been manufacturing type [1:43:21] buildings, Chobani and you know those kinds of things and for a long time those [1:43:27] were the only things we saw really and so is that something we want to consider [1:43:33] for this additional above 50 feet as well and I would say maybe in the M2 zone [1:43:37] or something like that I was gonna say to me those were coming into a specific [1:43:41] area they were going through the downtown area and M2 and M1 and M1 we're gonna [1:43:51] I have a lot of M1, but I'm not sure about the M1, but the M2, for sure, you could go taller in the height. [1:43:58] It's on here. [1:44:01] Quickly through that one. [1:44:05] Similar to the heights of downtown parking, Wheelkeep's telling me to do that. [1:44:20] Is that big enough for sure to go bigger? [1:44:32] Craig, can you see it? [1:44:37] I'm good. [1:44:40] Nobody's out on the front row. [1:44:42] the explanation is there's three downtown parking overlays they do not [1:44:49] encompass all of downtown they primarily encompass the commercial areas of [1:44:54] downtown not generally the houses there's a few but not very many [1:44:58] proposal is do we just make it one downtown parking overlay and don't [1:45:02] require off-street parking and I will I know this is a bit of a discussion I [1:45:10] will tell you that the bigger projects that have been more successful as of late [1:45:16] in the downtown area would not have happened without being in that downtown [1:45:19] parking overlay that does not require off-street parking but I'm an issue where [1:45:25] we creating by not requiring the off-street thank you yeah it is a you're [1:45:39] creating more buildable area for the businesses or the whoever owns the [1:45:42] property to do it there is a public perception to not having enough [1:45:48] of parking, perception is harder to combat than reality, but. [1:45:55] I'm thinking going forward the newer businesses [1:45:57] that may be coming in possibly, I don't know all the plans, [1:46:02] but not, but in Old Town, look like on that. [1:46:09] Yeah, on the street, this is where we're talking. [1:46:14] Or if they need it, they build it. [1:46:16] It's just not required, [1:46:18] and there's the public parking lots that we have currently. [1:46:21] Chris and the Courtney, I think. [1:46:25] I'm okay with it, but I would like to see a map [1:46:27] where things currently are and what we're actually looking at that to get the [1:46:32] map that I do have access to. I don't think we currently have a shortage of [1:46:38] parking. That correct? Yeah, I understand the perception of that because I have [1:46:46] actually parked in the parking lot and walked a block. I know call me crazy. [1:46:55] But I just wanted to make sure that I'm not you know that I'm not oblivious to [1:47:01] some kind of parking issue that we do have. [1:47:08] I might pipe in here that I also agree [1:47:11] that we don't have a parking problem today. [1:47:14] The issue might be way in the future. [1:47:18] Someday, we might have a parking problem [1:47:21] and the solution to it will be a public solution, [1:47:26] meaning some public entity needs to figure out [1:47:30] how to build a parking garage, [1:47:31] like the urban renewal or maybe the city. [1:47:34] And I think about like downtown Boise and some of those large public parking structures that have been built recently. [1:47:43] That could be a future for us. [1:47:47] But I really think it's a long ways out. [1:47:52] If at all. [1:47:54] Yeah, like at that point too, we would hopefully have more public transportation and stuff like that. [1:47:58] That could bring the people that are currently driving downtown would have other ways to access the downtown area. [1:48:03] Can you please explain to me when I'm looking at your question, [1:48:08] should we remove the parking requirements downtown? [1:48:10] I would think yes, but I'm a little hesitant to do that. [1:48:15] What does it look like combining them, expanding them both? [1:48:19] Can you explain that just a little bit? [1:48:21] Yep, and the map will kind of help a little bit with that. [1:48:22] So up here, the blue dotted outline downtown [1:48:25] says downtown with the roads. [1:48:26] You're seeing the blue dotted outline [1:48:28] is where there is no, I'd say, private parking requirement [1:48:33] in the code. [1:48:33] So anything that's located in there, [1:48:35] you can build the new building, modify. [1:48:38] There's no off street parking to be constructed privately. [1:48:41] So like second South market, 100%. [1:48:45] Cause they're like right over here. [1:48:48] Green, there's a parking overlay. [1:48:50] It's parking overlay too. [1:48:51] It gives you like a 30% reduction in the required parking. [1:48:54] So you have a business that needs 100 per code, [1:48:57] take 30% off, build that. [1:49:00] Parking overlay three is a case by case basis. [1:49:03] And that, really the code just basically says, [1:49:07] show us what you want, and then typically we've just gone [1:49:10] with either like a public meeting with the commission [1:49:13] to say here's the case by case, and we won't require you [1:49:17] to do it or a certain number or just kind of [1:49:19] a little bit of everything. [1:49:24] Those are the three overlays currently. [1:49:27] Yeah, this is kind of like the old town warehouse area [1:49:29] down here. [1:49:33] You could remove overlay two and just call it, [1:49:38] to say everywhere that is currently overlay 2 is now just case by case basis. [1:49:44] We might require you, might not, and use the regulations of 3. [1:49:49] You could combine the 1 and 2 and just say look everything in the second overlay is now just overlay 1 [1:49:57] and you don't have to provide any. [1:49:59] The public parking areas are going to be just fine because there's a lot of it [1:50:02] and we want to incentivize downtown development [1:50:05] because every parking space is $10,000 to build. [1:50:08] Surface. [1:50:09] It's actually like 14 maybe now, I don't know if it's a structure. It's a bit more than that. [1:50:14] And then you just have another the case-by-case basis where we identify it or we just get rid of all of it and say everything downtown. [1:50:20] The whole original town site is just you don't have to build any off-street parking because we have a lot of it downtown. [1:50:28] There's a lot of options if you want to [1:50:30] Fast-grade apartments is where? [1:50:33] Over here. [1:50:34] And there was parking requirement. [1:50:36] There were parking requirements. [1:50:38] So if we eliminated that, there wouldn't have been. [1:50:41] Right. [1:50:42] I don't think that's a good idea. [1:50:46] I think we need to do case by case. [1:50:50] I don't see requiring a specific overlay. [1:50:54] So you want to, even the one you want to be a case by case as well? [1:50:57] Or leave one as it is? [1:51:00] Leave one as it is. [1:51:02] Take the two and three combined to be case by case. [1:51:05] Yeah. [1:51:06] Courtney and then Chris. [1:51:08] So I'm in favor of removing it because it's only been in the last decade that we've got a little bust hole going on. [1:51:13] going on downtown and I think we need to train the residents of Twin Falls that [1:51:17] it's okay to walk around downtown more than 10 feet and I think that that [1:51:22] activity of the pedestrians walking will only drive more traffic for those [1:51:26] Main Street businesses. The basically expanding the one to not require off [1:51:30] street parking? Absolutely. Chris, I'm really concerned about the case by case [1:51:38] because then it becomes very arbitrary and I don't like that at all. I understand [1:51:43] the blue, you know, a lot of these are historic buildings, they've been in place, if you're [1:51:48] going to try to do anything in that area, it's going to be very challenging. I would [1:51:54] be, I guess, okay, leaving blue and making everything then, too, getting ready to red, [1:52:03] so that there is a third, because I remember, Mayor, those, those apartments, and that was [1:52:09] a huge issue, and we have a lot of residential in that area where we start getting rid [1:52:14] of it and it's arbitrary depending on a lot of different factors. They're gonna [1:52:17] start parking in front of their houses. The city park, I think we need to be [1:52:23] very very careful and we need to have a very set standard. Again, the blue is [1:52:29] different and I totally understand that. Every place else, we need to have a [1:52:34] standard at which we're following. And I, so what I've done is turned on the [1:52:39] zoning districts. So the blue coincides like now we're looking at property blue [1:52:44] is central business that's commercial type the pink slash purple is the residential [1:52:51] so the overlay doesn't touch that currently I were proposing something I would [1:52:55] say the CB district can be parking over the one and say yeah you don't have to put [1:53:00] any in that area I'd expand it up all the way seconds basically keeping it on [1:53:05] just barely a little bit just where the commercial is on along second which is [1:53:10] north and east expanded to that second south like one more block or two and then have [1:53:20] make the 30 percent like a 50 percent everywhere else or something like that. That's kind of what [1:53:24] I was going to propose. I personally like that because normally I would say I'd be okay with getting [1:53:30] rid of all the requirements but the nature of our downtown I don't think is like most and I feel [1:53:35] like for the for the circumstances and the businesses where it is an apartment complex or [1:53:40] or we've got businesses more towards that Southwestern corner, [1:53:44] like the climbing gym of children's museum, [1:53:47] things like that I think should have a little bit [1:53:49] of private off-site parking required. [1:53:53] I think the main part does need to be expanded, [1:53:57] like you said, a little bit in all directions slightly, [1:54:01] and then having a standard, [1:54:04] because if it's all arbitrary, [1:54:06] then we might, yeah, [1:54:08] where we're going to get ourselves into trouble, I think, [1:54:10] if it's all discretionary. [1:54:12] Good. [1:54:13] Sherry? [1:54:14] Yeah, I think I'm probably along that lines. [1:54:16] And what I was thinking of when I said on a case-by-case [1:54:20] is that I don't want to see the large office complexes coming [1:54:25] in and the apartment buildings coming in that then [1:54:29] don't have a requirement. [1:54:31] So that's where my concern was. [1:54:32] So I think I'm thinking on the same line, [1:54:34] but I want this to be cautious of those. [1:54:46] We'll use your best professional judgment. [1:54:49] Yeah, but thanks. [1:54:52] Okay. Director Spindler. Yeah. [1:54:54] Couldn't you make it use specific within the zones? [1:54:58] You can. If you can hook a certain number. [1:55:02] So you can't. [1:55:05] You got to treat all of everybody somewhat equally within the zone, but you can separate the zones. [1:55:11] You can't forecast. I mean, let's. [1:55:13] I don't know when you're going to put an apartment complex. Somebody over here could do it right now. [1:55:17] I don't have no parking requirement and so it's almost like you could imagine if they turn the elks into an apartment building [1:55:24] I mean, that's okay. Yeah, so [1:55:29] That's what I'm saying is I [1:55:31] Would like to see some uses excluded from the blue area. I don't know if we can do that [1:55:42] If it was an apartment complex in that main corridor [1:55:45] I feel like it would be a new use and those people would have that expectation going in saying hey [1:55:51] This is an apartment building downtown because they want to be there because it's downtown. They've got restrooms [1:55:58] They've got everything they can access by foot [1:56:01] I'm okay keeping that main corridor still, but if you personally [1:56:05] But if you don't allocate spots for them and put a requirement on and you're gonna block all the other parking for all the different [1:56:11] uses downtown [1:56:12] But those have time limits and things like that as well and I think that ends up being you got to basically [1:56:17] to kick Shawn's budget up and put more parking enforcement on the street, because right now [1:56:21] the street's not utilized. We'll just create something and what we present you as our best [1:56:30] guess. Okay, next item. Quickly. Quick one. Do we care about how wide a residential driveway [1:56:51] is and or how much impervious slash asphalt concrete is in a front yard of a residential [1:56:59] This is Will's item. [1:57:01] Before I see a lot of shaking hands, maybe. [1:57:06] Um, ample. [1:57:07] There was an Airbnb, uh, out along the canyon. [1:57:11] Um, Bruce, primary complaint, was that the whole front yard was a parking lot. [1:57:20] But it changed it from a residential character to a commercial character. [1:57:27] The other aspect is, in our subdivisions, we, we account for roughly 60 per cent, [1:57:33] 60% storm retention, and so if you don't have certain amount of landscaping in the front, [1:57:40] then you don't really retain. So we're under utilizing our storm water retention that the sub-division is through. [1:57:50] Ouch, that's not funny. Ouch, I don't want to call it the funny bone. Couldn't they just do it dry well underneath? [1:57:58] Yeah. I mean, so it just gets caught on the design on the backside. [1:58:01] Yep, we do not look at that at this point. I guess I was under the impression that that's looked at when you go through permitting and codes for construction, the hard surface area. [1:58:20] There's a there's like a percentage of we just take a mathematical percentage of the subdivisions going to be around this impervious 60%. [1:58:28] But if everybody put in large and pervious areas in the front yard, we would need to bump that number up when you're building a subdivision to get to the adequate stormwater. [1:58:37] So a few people do it, not a big deal. If everybody does it, you have a problem. [1:58:42] I only brought it up because this is the property. It's basically asphalt concrete, no? [1:58:48] Old front yard. Whether that's an issue where we care about that or not. Sherry and then Courtney. [1:58:55] Oh, would we as a city require this or would it fall under CC&Rs because I'm thinking not [1:59:02] looking at this one particular property but maybe the guy next door doesn't want any grass [1:59:08] and so he would like to put in a rock garden in the front or he would like to put turf in [1:59:13] the front. [1:59:14] Who are we to tell you what you can and cannot do in the front of your property? [1:59:18] I don't see a problem with multiple driveways. [1:59:21] I personally think it would be covered if you have an HOA, which I live up in that neighborhood, [1:59:28] so there's no HOA. [1:59:29] There are CCNRs. [1:59:30] Half of the houses don't conform to those CCNRs, so it's, I mean, it is what it is, I feel like, [1:59:36] but I think that's a hard one, because I feel like you could also argue a piece-by-case [1:59:48] type of thing, too, like, if you were going to do it by a percentage and stuff like that, [1:59:52] like, especially in all these neighborhoods with cul-de-sacs. [1:59:55] house particular is on one of those cul-de-sacs as well and it's like a pie [1:59:59] shaped lot so it's really hard to orient your house and then you've got a [2:00:04] small front yard because it's a pie shaped and then your driveway takes up [2:00:08] more of that percentage because of you know what I mean so I feel like that gets [2:00:11] weird as well with I think you just need to account for some of that extra possible [2:00:15] extra hard surfacing for stormwater retention. I would definitely be in favor [2:00:22] of looking at something that you wrote well because I think that for the [2:00:26] safety issues that you mentioned and it really does change the character of the [2:00:30] neighborhood. So if you start going this way then the development community is [2:00:37] going to have a serious issue with how much retention of storm water just so we [2:00:43] all have an understanding in the plating process there's gonna be a big [2:00:49] disagreement with with not with some of that what that is specifically I mean I [2:00:58] could guess but don't have a law but I I think we need to I don't mind if [2:01:04] somebody wants to put rocks or or astroturf it's still an impervious [2:01:09] surface I think we need to look at what that impervious for non impervious [2:01:13] service looks like I mean the one there in the corner at 4 29 coin or circle I [2:01:20] and I understand the concern of trying to get into your driveway, but I don't see why [2:01:25] 36 or 40 feet of that frontage couldn't be some type of driveway, but you look at a neighborhood [2:01:32] like that. [2:01:33] I still think there is some aspect of aesthetics that you got to somewhat look at and consider, [2:01:40] but if we go to more and more, the hard surface, the development community was most likely [2:01:49] going to have an issue with building larger storm retention ponds? [2:01:53] This is a one, there's two questions. One, do we care if there's two driveways? If it's like [2:01:59] not sure we care if there's two driveways, we just want a maximum percentage of the front [2:02:05] area being pervious or impervious. If that's where we're at it, we can get there. It is a [2:02:10] design aesthetic thing. Do we want the look of rock is somewhat pervious? So you can put [2:02:17] rock gardens. It ends up being as it used for the driving on or not and then you can [2:02:21] pack and then becomes impervious or if it's just concrete and asphalt then it's [2:02:26] just the entire area. This is an example of I don't know what the percentages we [2:02:32] can get you percentages. If there's a thought that yeah we kind of do care [2:02:36] about how much concrete is in the front yard then we can talk about how much [2:02:42] concrete is in the front yard or asphalt. I'm not sure we're gonna get to the rock [2:02:46] because I think landscaping rock and other gravel [2:02:48] and where you step away from that one. [2:02:49] But it's really asphalt concrete for like driving surface [2:02:54] Sherry I think and then, you know, both. [2:02:56] I don't have a problem with the two driveways. [2:02:58] I just want to and I can fully respect the drainage issues [2:03:04] and whatnot. [2:03:04] So I think we need to look into that, [2:03:06] but we need to be very careful what we're telling people [2:03:09] they can and can't do with their yards. [2:03:14] So at what point is this currently reviewed? [2:03:17] But right now we have a maximum width of a driveway [2:03:21] when you access the public way. [2:03:24] It can be expanded with the city engineer review. [2:03:27] Other than that, we have been using the 60% impervious [2:03:33] as a cover, like a thing to get your stormwater. [2:03:37] That's a, I'm gonna say leave that topic over here [2:03:40] because I don't know if we can get into that one today. [2:03:43] That's why I kind of limited this to two driveways [2:03:46] yes or no, and do we care how much impervious areas [2:03:48] in the front yard? [2:03:50] I don't have an issue with two driveways. [2:03:53] I think as long as people could get approved for more [2:03:55] in the circumstances where it might be needed, that's good. [2:03:59] I'm not a Twin Falls native. [2:04:00] When I moved, I think it's the West in general. [2:04:04] I lived in Colorado before Idaho, [2:04:05] and it was kind of similar there as well. [2:04:09] Every single house has a garage facing the road [2:04:11] and a lot of concrete in my mind, [2:04:13] but I'm used to big lots, garages never face the street, [2:04:17] and you always pull up in a very long driveway. [2:04:20] So to me, all of it is a lot of concrete. [2:04:24] I'd rather not see it, [2:04:25] but I also know the nature of the lives [2:04:29] that people live outside of work [2:04:32] and the recreational things that people do here. [2:04:34] There's a lot more RV camping, [2:04:36] that type of recreational vehicles or things like that as well, [2:04:40] that a lot of the houses I see being built [2:04:42] in the newer areas have either an extra shop, [2:04:44] an extra driveway, something like that as it is. [2:04:46] So I think it depends on how much you guys are seeing [2:04:49] at that level right now on whether it needs to be changed [2:04:55] or if we could, are you trying to increase it [2:04:58] or decrease it, I guess? [2:05:00] I think we're trying to look at either a maximum percentage [2:05:02] of the front yard being impervious [2:05:04] and I just don't know what we'll add in mind. [2:05:07] Right now we have a max building coverage on the W-4. [2:05:12] that we would force what I was thinking initially was to just have a percentage of the law or [2:05:25] something be impervious surface. [2:05:29] That number I haven't thought of at this point because I wanted to know if it was an appetite. [2:05:34] Everything that I've talked about with, everything I talked about with Jonathan and with other [2:05:41] staff has been counseled, doesn't have an appetite, don't think about it. [2:05:46] So here's the question, is the appetite and we can start thinking about it more? [2:05:50] Would it be specific to a driveway or are you saying a percentage of the entire lot being [2:05:54] hard surfaced? [2:05:55] So would that include walkways and patios? [2:05:58] I guess that's just a distinction to make if you're thinking about it. [2:06:01] We can look into both. [2:06:03] If it's front yard that we care about, again, to Jonathan's point, that is more of an aesthetic [2:06:10] way to do it. [2:06:12] If we just cared about the retention on site, we could start saying 40% or 20% of the lot [2:06:18] needs to be impervious surface. [2:06:22] Whether that's rock or material that is, I don't, not caring, just kind of soak in the [2:06:28] water a little bit. [2:06:32] There's an appetite, at least on my end, and I don't know, I haven't really been looking [2:06:36] around for head nods, but for the second part of this, the impervious part, look into that, [2:06:43] but I'd like it thoughtfully done and out limiting as much as possible to what the homework can [2:06:52] do. [2:06:53] So I would like a reason behind that as far as allowing more than one driveway I think most [2:06:59] definitely. [2:07:00] Are you just looking at residential streets or collectors, arterials, what are you looking [2:07:08] at that because I know there's been an issue let's say falls and having two approaches [2:07:13] and conflicts with traffic and some other things. [2:07:15] So how far down that two driveway are you looking? [2:07:19] I'm actually thinking quite frankly that benefits people that are on collectors more [2:07:22] because then they're not backing on the collector. [2:07:25] But I think the city engineer will have some issue with MUTSIT and some of the traffic type [2:07:31] stuff if any on how close they are at intersections and stuff but we don't. [2:07:36] It's worse to have people backing out on a collector than having two driveways and if [2:07:41] I'm way in the two I end up having that conversation with Troy all the time. [2:07:44] a few times we go, which one do you want? [2:07:47] Because if we allowed a circle driveway [2:07:49] to approaches on a collector, [2:07:51] you essentially allow someone to not back onto [2:07:55] whether they don't as personal choice. [2:07:58] But at least you allow it to happen currently, [2:08:00] they're not permitted. [2:08:03] Or on double frontages, if you have some [2:08:05] that have double frontages like this, [2:08:08] do we care if there's a driveway on the back? [2:08:12] If it's not on a collector, [2:08:14] it's just on residential street doesn't matter just have a driveway on the back to [2:08:18] get to a shop in the backyard. I'm here and I gather probably instances where [2:08:29] it's not a huge deal. Seven is quick-ish. There's two areas in town that we have [2:08:44] the M1 zone. There's one on the east side which is 4th Avenue east. It's right [2:08:52] here and it's this light blue whatever this is right here. These areas right [2:09:01] here. That's M1. Dark Brown is commercial. And then there's a little downtown but not [2:09:10] enough. It's like a little two properties right here. I don't even consider that as [2:09:15] part of it because it's so close to the railroad. It doesn't really matter. And then there's [2:09:19] some over here. There's a little bit on Highland and there's the old, yeah it's now plant therapy. [2:09:34] these um yeah whatever warehouse distribution thing that's it those are the [2:09:40] areas that are really M2 M1 in the whole the whole city the question I have is [2:09:46] do we combine it do we care to combine it do we keep it separate so there's a [2:09:50] there's a problem with combining it you create in these areas that are near [2:09:56] residential have industrial next to people's houses particularly in this [2:10:02] spot down here, the one on Highland, and the one over here. That can be a problem. M1 [2:10:11] zone just does not let any manufacturing period without a special use permit. There's [2:10:15] just, it's utilized so little nobody asked for it because you can't do anything with it. [2:10:19] So nobody's really rezoning to M1. They're all just rezoning to M2 if it's even [2:10:26] possible to get a manufacturing. I mean this is a hard question, but it's a quick one. [2:10:32] Do you want to combine it we can just leave it as it is that was my intention and say it's not something we're gonna deal [2:10:37] With right now and just deal with it at some time future time [2:10:40] M2 [2:10:45] third option the council [2:10:47] Proactively rezones these properties to commercial and you go through the taking analysis with the property owners [2:10:55] To so that it doesn't happen in the future [2:10:57] For now, I can just my favorite of just leaving it [2:11:00] I had to have the answer because everybody's like what do we do with this like nothing okay [2:11:10] last one doesn't really actually need input per se we want it but this is a sign code and [2:11:18] Mitch might jump in here real quick to eventually we have to create our sign code to be content [2:11:24] neutral meaning I can't use the language of what you're advertising as a reason to deny [2:11:36] a sign permit. The language on the sign I would give one that is the one that was the case. [2:11:44] It was a religious sign that was used to prohibit signages in certain instances in certain locations. [2:11:52] And the Supreme Court of the United States said you cannot make a content based decision on approving signs or not. [2:12:00] So a church sign for example sitting on the corner of a say whatever it wants you can't deny that sign. [2:12:09] pretty much without foul language. [2:12:12] Yeah, there's some of those in decent language things. [2:12:14] And even then, quite frankly, they [2:12:17] can do some of that stuff, too. [2:12:18] But any other, like, the other part [2:12:22] would be no matter what the commercial language is. [2:12:24] So what you can do is it's commercial speech, [2:12:26] and it's first amendment speech, almost. [2:12:29] Commercial speech, non-commercial speech. [2:12:32] You get in two categories. [2:12:35] And we've created what is commercial, non-commercial, [2:12:39] permanent, and temporary. [2:12:42] And then those four things create a matrix [2:12:44] as to how much you can have and how big they can be. [2:12:47] We need to make the sign code content neutral, [2:12:50] basically because of the core cases [2:12:51] that have been coming out. [2:12:53] With that, we do not want to open the gates [2:12:57] for off-site commercial speech. [2:13:02] There is currently some signs that are allowed [2:13:05] in the right-of-way that will no longer be allowed in the right-of-way because they are content-based. [2:13:12] We allow any commercial speech in the right-of-way. We have to let all commercial speech be in the right-of-way. [2:13:20] Currently, we allow, like, estate sales, real estate signs, open-house signs. [2:13:28] Those are content-based type languages that are a part of the sign in the right-of-way. [2:13:35] If you allow that, you need to then permit Christmas light installations, sprinkler blowouts, [2:13:42] and cactus, well, political signs may be a little bit separate because that's kind of First Amendment [2:13:46] rights type stuff. But cactus Pete's advertising there two for one sale because they don't live [2:13:54] and they're not in this property and then they'd be allowed in the right of way with certain restrictions. [2:13:57] So I've written this code to be content neutral and to not allow signs off site or in the right of way. [2:14:07] I believe the alternative ends up being a lot of signs in areas that are going to be difficult [2:14:13] for us to regulate and deal with or just the downside of allowing everybody into it. [2:14:18] Let me give you a little history on this one too. [2:14:22] So we again Jonathan said we currently allow in the right of way off site commercial signage [2:14:32] and it's in the form of real estate signs whether it's an open house or basically just [2:14:39] really safe science, right? Because our code allows that today or the Supreme Court action [2:14:48] from a few years ago, if someone were to come to us and challenge our code, because we didn't [2:14:54] let them put their offsite commercial sign in the right of way, they would likely win [2:14:59] that lawsuit. And so we've written this code section to eliminate all of those offsite commercial [2:15:09] signs in the right of way and what that does is it takes them away from the [2:15:13] realtors who are using them now and now the history lesson right so that code [2:15:19] section is there because the real estate community came to the city and requested [2:15:25] a code change to be there and we approved it years ago like 15 again years ago [2:15:32] right and so this has been in place for a little while and it's been in place at [2:15:36] the request of our realtor community and we're about to remove it and it's going to make a lot of [2:15:42] realtors upset. Personally, I don't think there's a lot we can do about it. We have to comply with [2:15:48] federal law. We have to. We have a choice. And I believe that we don't want to litter our rights [2:15:55] of way with offsite commercial signage, which would be the other option. We can not allow any of [2:16:01] of it or we can allow all of it and that's it. [2:16:04] So we're proposing to eliminate it and so again I don't feel [2:16:11] like there's a lot of discussion here other than the heads [2:16:13] up people are going to be very happy about this. [2:16:16] So that's kind of why this is on the list. [2:16:19] This does not eliminate the signs [2:16:22] on the properties that are current for sale. [2:16:24] That's not what this does. [2:16:25] You can advertise properties for sale on the properties [2:16:28] that are there. [2:16:28] You can have the open house on the property that's there. [2:16:31] You can do that, you can't do it in the right of way, or you let everybody [2:16:37] that has commercial speech, again, putting it into commercial speech versus non-commercial speech. [2:16:41] Those are the baskets, you get to put them in. [2:16:44] You don't believe having the right of way with all that in it is a good idea. [2:16:49] There's a lot of liability that comes with that when you have all of that, [2:16:52] and a tracking mechanism to keep track of whoever's been in it. [2:16:54] If you do to permit it, distance requirements, all that stuff could be, [2:16:59] not that it's impossible, it is improbable for us and our current staffing levels [2:17:04] levels to deal with that kind of program. [2:17:07] Well, you're saying, for example, somebody [2:17:10] has an open house on the middle of my cul-de-sac, [2:17:16] and they want to put a sign on the corner of falls in Mountain [2:17:20] View. [2:17:20] They can't do that. [2:17:22] That's right. [2:17:22] That's off-site. [2:17:24] It's commercial speech in the right of way, [2:17:25] or just off-site in general. [2:17:28] If they have somebody else's permission. [2:17:30] But today, they can't. [2:17:31] No, I get that. [2:17:33] Yeah, so we would be a living. [2:17:34] No, I understand that. [2:17:36] Yeah, putting it in the sidewalk. That's right of way. That is not how this is written. If you allow off-site commercial speech on right-of-way or private property, you allow all of it. [2:17:53] If there's a break here, you want to put those signs on private property, then you allow all commercial speech on private property not on site of where that activity is happening. [2:18:07] So the sprinkler blow out things and all those can then also be on that property as well. [2:18:15] If you would like that to be explain that one more time. [2:18:22] So so I have an open house in my house or houses down. [2:18:31] We talked to that neighbor and they put a sign because they're on the corner directing [2:18:36] people there offsite commercial speech correct on private property on private property. [2:18:43] when you or the other neighbor wants to install Christmas lights and wants to [2:18:48] put it on that neighbor's property you would have that as well with with [2:18:54] permission. The point is if you allow it for one kind of commercial speech you [2:19:00] have to allow for all so it doesn't even have to be a sprinkler vlogs it could [2:19:05] become stay at cactus pizza this weekend and with their permission you could [2:19:09] give them permission to put that sign in your yard if our code was written that way. [2:19:14] You know, you want to think that's the main question. We guess there's a good a question [2:19:19] Offs we currently in our city do not allow off-site commercial speech [2:19:26] There are very limited billboards, but there are no more new billboards [2:19:33] Yeah, the only exception is the real estate stuff, right? And because we have real estate stuff [2:19:38] We have to either change that or allow everybody else [2:19:45] Right good [2:19:46] You but then you still allow everybody else [2:19:48] and so now I own the corner lot in a desirable location I can sell you yep [2:19:57] or your front yard it opens up for a lot of temporary temporary commercial [2:20:11] signs right of ways that you need to permit track or not I personally think [2:20:21] we keep it as proposed, no commercial signs off-site, and no signs in the right-of-way is [2:20:30] my personal opinion. [2:20:36] The right-of-way is one particular issue. [2:20:39] We currently keep these off now. [2:20:42] Sean has been picking these up. [2:20:44] We've never been challenged. [2:20:45] So what you see today is basically this, other than real estate signs, being permitted, none [2:20:52] of those things. [2:20:53] time you see the re-roof guy that I make 1200 bucks whatever week garage sale [2:21:01] same thing they're not permitted off-site and she'll Sean picks them up you you [2:21:07] have not seen this be permitted I don't really think we have a choice it's [2:21:17] unfortunate because it's federal law isn't all or nothing where you get all [2:21:23] or everything. You don't allow anything or allow everything. This has been brought up [2:21:28] a few times. In the Supreme Court case was another city who screwed it up for all of us. [2:21:36] Okay, so before we break I want Jonathan to explain our process moving forward with this. [2:21:54] I know that the Council has a desire to see this code amendment in your hands for approval. [2:22:02] There's a lot to this document. [2:22:05] This is hundreds of pages of document, right, that we're talking about reviewing. [2:22:10] So when we go to a public hearing, I think it probably would be not very genuine to expect [2:22:18] a single public hearing in the planning and zoning commission to go through a 200-page [2:22:22] document. [2:22:23] And so Jonathan's got a plan to maximize the amount of public input. [2:22:32] But that plan also takes us, it takes us some time to get through, right? [2:22:37] And so we just want you all to understand the best case scenario and then maybe we can [2:22:42] perhaps tweak it if you don't like that or whatever, but I want to. [2:22:48] This was our 60% chance of success rate per will in myself in terms of, we have a certain [2:22:53] number of chapters that are to the point of their PDFs up here, 1, 3, 5, 6, 7, and 11. [2:23:13] There's a couple of those that are nearing finishing, we'll put this together in terms [2:23:16] of planning and zoning commission could advertise, I'll be caring for these three chapters, next [2:23:25] three chapters, and then start rolling into council chapters. [2:23:28] For 60% sure we can keep this schedule, we're not 100% sure. [2:23:36] We are over 50. [2:23:39] It gets trickier when we get to the chapter 4 in chapter 10 because those are the bulk [2:23:43] of the items. [2:23:47] It puts us into a March 17th, the last council meeting hearing. [2:23:54] That's not the ordinance. [2:23:55] That's the hearing on the chapters and then the ordinance would happen after that. [2:24:06] One thing that this does do is, this is on me, right? [2:24:10] So I've been riding these guys, you've got to get this done by the end of the year, I think [2:24:17] it's probably not reasonable to get it done by the end of the year, right? [2:24:24] And so they put together a plan here, if the council ends the year okay with the plan, then [2:24:31] we'll try to meet this timeline, but I know that we had a conversation reset at council [2:24:36] meeting where the council was kind of pushing a little bit on, let's get this done. [2:24:42] So here's where we're at, to be fair, Jonathan did say he gave us a date, so it was his date. [2:24:50] Yeah, so, so I just say let's go with the schedule that you have proposed and we know [2:24:59] there's a quote drop dead date it looks like close enough, 60% chance. [2:25:06] We live with it. I mean, we can't expect them to double time this or it's gonna be wrong or messy or [2:25:15] Extended public hearings which we don't need so [2:25:21] This is a lot for people to digest and not just them for you guys right [2:25:25] This is a lot to digest in a single night [2:25:27] And so they're trying to break it out over several meetings [2:25:30] But that also means is both bodies are gonna be having several meetings [2:25:36] in a row of hearing, planning, zoning, title, ten amendments, right? [2:25:41] It's a lot of work. [2:25:43] This is a big undertaking. [2:25:44] I said we do what we've got to do, but we don't want to try and make it faster. [2:25:58] I'd move to adjourn.