Oversight Archive: City Council meeting, 2024-11-25, recording 1 (started 16:59) Machine transcript (faster-whisper base.en), not checked word for word; the Pledge of Allegiance is shown in its standard wording. The recording is the record. Times are time into the recording. Passages with private details are muted in the audio and marked here. The audio on the page below was re-encoded by software from the video the agency posted. Check any passage against that audio before relying on it. Page: https://oversightarchive.org/twin-falls-id/meetings/2024-11-25/ [0:00:56] Good evening, ladies and gentlemen, and welcome to the November 25th, 2024 City Council meeting. [0:01:02] I want to confirm we have a quorum. We have six members present in chambers, and Councilwoman [0:01:10] Vulmer is excused tonight. First item on the agenda is the Pledge of Allegiance. If you wish [0:01:15] to join me, please rise. Thank you. I do have a proclamation tonight. It's a proclamation [0:01:43] for National American Indian Heritage Month, [0:01:46] whereas the history and culture of our great nation [0:01:49] have been significantly influenced [0:01:52] by American Indians and indigenous peoples, [0:01:55] and whereas the contributions of American Indians [0:01:58] have enhanced the freedom, prosperity, [0:02:00] and greatness of America today, [0:02:03] and whereas their customs and traditions are respected [0:02:06] and celebrated as part of a rich legacy [0:02:09] throughout the United States, [0:02:11] and whereas Native American Awareness Week began in 1976 [0:02:16] and recognition was expanded by Congress [0:02:20] and approved by President George Bush in August 1990 [0:02:25] designating the month of November [0:02:26] as National American Heritage Month, [0:02:32] and whereas in honor of National American Indian Heritage Month [0:02:36] community celebrations as well as numerous cultural, [0:02:39] artistic, educational, and historical activities have been planned. [0:02:46] Now, therefore, I, Ruth Pierce, by the virtue of the authority vested in me as Mayor of Twin [0:02:51] Falls, do hereby proclaim November as the National American Indian Heritage Month and [0:02:58] urge all citizens to observe this month with appropriate programs, ceremonies, and activities. [0:03:05] Who is here to accept that? [0:03:08] Okay. [0:03:39] I'm so glad that you took the time for this. [0:03:41] My name is Lorraine Jordan, [0:03:42] and I'm with the Daughters of the American Revolution. [0:03:45] And as a national committee, [0:03:49] we have the American Indian Committee on a National Level [0:03:51] with the Daughters of the American Revolution [0:03:53] in Washington, D.C. [0:03:55] And they provide college scholarships and tribal grants, [0:04:00] and they also provide a lot of education [0:04:02] about how the Native Americans have affected our country. [0:04:05] And here in Twin Falls, [0:04:07] I am the American Indian Committee member, [0:04:10] and in our own Twin Falls group [0:04:12] of the Daughters of the American Revolution, [0:04:14] we have what we call an Indian Minute, [0:04:16] and we have little synopsis or synopsis [0:04:19] that are provided that talk about important figures, [0:04:24] Native American figures in our country. [0:04:26] Last year we concentrated on important women, [0:04:30] Native American women, and this year [0:04:31] we're concentrating on important patriots, [0:04:34] Native American patriots that actually fought [0:04:36] in the American Revolution, a lot of people don't know [0:04:39] that we have a lot of Native Americans that helped [0:04:40] and fought in the American Revolution. [0:04:44] So thank you so much for taking the time [0:04:46] and giving just another opportunity [0:04:48] to have a little bit more education [0:04:50] about Native Americans. [0:04:52] There's actually a really good website [0:04:53] called the National American HeritageIndian.club. [0:04:58] That gives a lot of good information about that. [0:05:00] And if anyone has a chance just to look at that [0:05:02] and just educate yourself just a little bit more, [0:05:04] that would be great. [0:05:05] So thank you very much. [0:05:06] Thank you. [0:05:14] OK, next on the agenda is the consent calendar. [0:05:18] Council wishes Craig Hawkins. [0:05:20] May I would like to make a motion to approve the consent [0:05:22] calendar is written. [0:05:23] Thank you. [0:05:23] Do I have a second? [0:05:24] Not a mere. [0:05:25] I'll second. [0:05:26] Thank you. [0:05:26] Motion by Craig Hawkins second by Grayson Stone [0:05:29] to approve the consent calendar as written. [0:05:32] Amy Rachel Roll call vote please. [0:05:36] Ruth, please? [0:05:37] Yes. [0:05:37] Chris Reed. [0:05:38] Yes. [0:05:38] Craig Hawkins. [0:05:39] Yes. [0:05:40] Jason Brown. [0:05:40] Yes. [0:05:41] Councillor Kiley. [0:05:42] Yes. [0:05:43] Grace and Stone. [0:05:44] Yes. [0:05:45] Thank you. [0:05:46] Motion passes six to zero. [0:05:47] Thank you. [0:05:48] Okay. [0:05:49] Under items of consideration, the first item is an action item, a request to approve Jose [0:05:55] Loya to serve as library board trustee and we have Tara Bartley, our library director, and [0:06:05] it looks like Jose too. [0:06:09] Welcome. [0:06:10] Good evening. [0:06:12] Mayor Pierce, council members, thank you. [0:06:14] It's a pleasure to stand in front of you today and bring forth, on behalf of the Library Board of Trustees, [0:06:20] the recommendation to appoint Jose, and he goes by Joey Loya to be our next library board member. [0:06:28] Our current member, Susie Kepalaris, she will end her term in December of this year, and then Joey would come on in January [0:06:38] 2025 and serve a five-year term that would go through December of [0:06:42] 2020-29. I know in your packet you have my report as well as the letter that Joey [0:06:49] sent in but just to kind of explain the process we did interview Joey earlier this [0:06:55] month and had the opportunity to ask questions. All five of my board members [0:07:02] were there as well as city manager Travis Rothweiler and council member and [0:07:09] and Library Liaison Spencer-Cutler. [0:07:12] And as you can see through his letter, [0:07:15] what stands out is that he has a desire to volunteer, [0:07:20] and he has a desire to give time and energy to community. [0:07:24] He even started his own Silent Book Club. [0:07:28] One of my biggest takeaways that I have to say [0:07:31] that as I sat through, and not only read his letter, [0:07:33] but sat through the interviews, [0:07:35] is that he also has a true desire to be committed to the library. [0:07:41] He understands what libraries stand for. [0:07:45] He is a library user. [0:07:47] He uses the services that we provide programs [0:07:50] that we have in the library. [0:07:54] And he wants to continue his journey for lifelong learning. [0:07:58] So with that, if you have any questions for me, [0:08:00] I'm happy to answer. [0:08:01] Or if you have any questions for Joey. [0:08:05] Thank you, Tara Spencer. [0:08:07] I just want to say, as Tara said, [0:08:08] I was part of the interviews. [0:08:10] I was happy there was three great candidates, [0:08:12] and Joey rose to the top, so I endorsed that selection. [0:08:17] And I'd like to offer a motion if you're ready. [0:08:20] Anybody else? [0:08:21] Good. [0:08:21] Go ahead. [0:08:22] I moved to approve Jose Loya to serve as a library board [0:08:27] of trustees, or as a library board of trustee. [0:08:31] Thank you. [0:08:31] Do I have a second? [0:08:32] I'll second that. [0:08:33] Thank you. Motion by Spencer Cutler, seconded by Chris Reed to approve Jose Loya to serve [0:08:39] as Library Board of Trustee. Any further discussion? Rachel, roll call, vote please. [0:08:46] Ray Cauken, Jason Brown, Spencer Cutler, Grayson Stone, Ruth Pierce, Chris Reed, thank [0:08:56] you. Motion passes six to zero. Thank you. You've got all three. There you go. Okay. [0:09:02] This item is an action item, Ward, Eastland Drive, Gravity, Irrigation, Improvements to [0:09:09] R.E.G. contracting for $425,708 and we have Stash, Staff Engineer, Jesse Schumran. [0:09:20] Welcome, Jesse. [0:09:22] Thank you, greetings, Mayor and Council. [0:09:25] So yes, this is earlier this year. [0:09:29] We received a grant to reconstruct Easton Drive Road and this is phase one of that construction [0:09:38] which mainly involves the irrigation [0:09:42] portion, so [0:09:43] We recently opened bids phase one this work which includes [0:09:49] irrigation and the sidewalk before the sidewalk in the road reconstruction [0:09:53] We coordinated with the Twin Falls Canal Company to determine which improvements were needed [0:09:59] for the road construction before the irrigation season begins in March. [0:10:02] We received five qualified bids from contractors, and the low bid was 102% of our engineers estimate. [0:10:15] With REG contracting, or $425,708. [0:10:20] Attached is the bid tab. [0:10:24] So in your packets, the bit tab shows the bids and the engineer's estimate. [0:10:32] Engineering request permission to award the project, allow for the City Engineer to sign [0:10:36] the construction contract, get budget authority for a 20% contingency to deal with unknowns [0:10:43] encountered during construction. [0:10:47] The total potential budget impact would be $511,000, including the contingencies. [0:10:55] We also would like to include a $43,000 construction engineering and inspection to be included with [0:11:02] this portion of the project. [0:11:04] I'd love to stand for questions. [0:11:11] So you're actually asking for $554,000. [0:11:17] So it's the $4,500,708 plus 20% plus the $43,000. [0:11:26] Yes. [0:11:27] That's correct. [0:11:28] that's different than the property or so. [0:11:32] Anybody have any questions for Jesse on this? [0:11:39] Jason Brown. [0:11:40] I'll make a motion if there's no questions. [0:11:43] Thank you. [0:11:44] So I'd move to approve the award for the Eastland Drive [0:11:49] Gravity Irgation Improvement to REG Contracting [0:11:54] for $425,708 plus a 20% contingency [0:12:02] and a engineering construction services for $43,000 for the total amount of $554,000. [0:12:15] Thank you, Grace and Stone. [0:12:16] Thank you, Madam Mayor, for a second. [0:12:18] Thank you, motion by Jason Brown, seconded by Grace and Stone to award the Gravity Irrigation [0:12:25] improvements contract to RHE contracting for 425,708, adding 20% contingency and a $43,000 [0:12:38] engineering cost for a total of 554. [0:12:42] 554,000. [0:12:45] Any further discussion or questions? [0:12:50] Rachel Roll-Cavo, please. [0:12:52] Ruth Pierce? [0:12:53] Yes. [0:12:54] Grace Reid? [0:12:55] Yes. [0:12:56] Jason Brown? Yes. [0:12:58] Spencer Keller? Yes. [0:12:59] In Grayson's Stone. [0:13:00] Thank you. Motion passes six to zero. [0:13:04] Thank you, Jess. [0:13:05] Well, if, so if I can, can I just explain one more thing regarding this project? [0:13:11] Sure. [0:13:12] Yeah. [0:13:13] So, um, part of this project also includes some sewer services needed right in the neck-down portion, and I can open up a picture if you guys. [0:13:26] probably would help yeah yes you guys can see that so if you look on this portion [0:13:49] this is where we're doing the this is the neck down area and there's only two lanes of traffic [0:14:00] we are involved with this project establishing two sewer taps on the west side of this road [0:14:12] If you see there's no room to have traffic while we're doing these tabs. [0:14:20] So really what's going to happen is when we award the project to ROG contracting, [0:14:28] they're responsible to give us a traffic control plan and we're supposed to prove that traffic control plan. [0:14:34] It's going to be very difficult not to have a few days where we have to detour traffic on Eastland to another road. [0:14:44] And so I just wanted to kind of, I guess, gauge whether it would be okay to potentially detour traffic while we do its isolated work. [0:14:56] So how long do you think it's going to take? How long would you have to detour the road? [0:15:06] So there's actually two portions, and let me open up this other, it's an overhead part of the plan set. [0:15:14] So, you'll see on the right side there's the sewer tap, load up just a little bit [0:15:33] Jesse. Okay, make it bigger. [0:15:38] How about the top? He's the plus, the middle, top. [0:15:45] So, one of the sewer taps is shown there. It's directly perpendicular to the road. [0:15:54] It's in this area right here. So, the part of the irrigation project is we're [0:16:01] re-establishing a connection that crosses Eastland and the original pipe goes [0:16:10] across here but we have to go through the road so that's another portion where [0:16:18] you know there's 20,000 vehicles a day that use Eastland and so we we want us [0:16:31] at least be able to use one lane of traffic, but when if we have a flag or a [0:16:37] temporary signal that's already the bottle point of Eastland. And so at the [0:16:47] wrong traffic times it's going to create mayhem. And so I guess I want council to [0:16:55] kind of understand our situation here and think about how I think what the [0:17:02] services we're only talking about about two days but with this situation we'll [0:17:07] at least have to close one lane and it makes more sense, especially during [0:17:13] high traffic times, to detour of like whether it be a northbound or a southbound [0:17:18] movement and then keep keep one of the lanes in service and so I know [0:17:27] originally we talked about Eastland closures but I wanted you guys to [0:17:32] to understand first of all what we're doing here. [0:17:34] And then I guess, as for, I guess, a little bit of a blessing [0:17:40] regarding some, maybe a lane closure [0:17:42] and at least two days of road closure [0:17:45] where we provide a detour. [0:17:51] So Madam Mayor, members of the council, [0:17:53] technically this is a request that's not on the agenda tonight [0:17:56] and in accordance with Idaho Code, [0:17:57] you can't take an action on something [0:17:59] that is not labeled on an agenda. [0:18:02] So there won't be, you can advise staff, [0:18:05] but there can't be any formal action in moving forward [0:18:09] because this was not an agendaized request. [0:18:11] Yes, thank you. [0:18:12] Chris Reed. [0:18:15] I know we discussed this a while ago, [0:18:18] and there was some concern because of how long it potentially [0:18:21] was going to be closed for this being two days. [0:18:25] I know this is not an action item. [0:18:26] So again, just my personal opinion. [0:18:29] If we need to bring it back, I'll probably share it again. [0:18:32] Two days I'm not as concerned. [0:18:34] weeks, months, that's where the concern comes in, [0:18:38] understanding what you've explained. [0:18:40] I would probably take the staff's recommendation [0:18:43] for a two day period, wishing like that. [0:18:47] So that's my personal opinion. [0:18:49] Thank you, Chris, Jason? [0:18:51] Yeah, Jesse, on this one, have you talked [0:18:54] to the contractor on kind of his thoughts or anything [0:18:57] like that at this point or any of the contractors [0:18:59] that admitted the project? [0:19:02] I know we haven't given guidance there, [0:19:05] especially since we haven't awarded it yet. [0:19:08] So, you know, I'm with Councilman Reed on this [0:19:12] is I think a couple of days isn't too bad. [0:19:14] Do you think that you could detour one of the lanes [0:19:19] or potentially work in those off hours a little bit easier? [0:19:26] I know when we did falls in Eastland, [0:19:28] it was just better to close it down, get the job done, [0:19:30] and then move on, open it back up. [0:19:34] Do you think they can get that pipe across the road [0:19:38] in a couple of days if they do some preparation [0:19:40] or do you think it's gonna take maybe a week, [0:19:45] detour one leg of traffic through that? [0:19:50] So I think two days for the services, like a whole closure. [0:19:56] But when we talk about the irrigation, [0:19:59] I visualized at least one lane being old then, but I mean we could have like a detour for one lane for a week to establish that and we also to be responsible we have to put back the proper base materials and like concrete materials or the B trucks and everything to. [0:20:26] So, I mean, there's a little bit of concrete curing that may happen and stuff. [0:20:30] So, the only reason why I bring it up is because this project is rushed. [0:20:35] We have to get done during the irrigation season and the contractor wants to start as soon as [0:20:42] possible. [0:20:43] So, that's why I bring it up at this meeting. [0:20:47] Yeah, I mean, I would, I think if you can make it or feel like you can make that a complete [0:20:54] closure for a couple of days, get as much as you can done in that time, and then get it [0:20:59] open back up at least for one leg for a little bit longer. [0:21:08] Any other comments? [0:21:12] Thank you. [0:21:13] Thank you, Jess. [0:21:14] Okay. [0:21:18] Next is an action item or request to accept the fiscal year 2024 impact fee report and [0:21:25] approve the 1.31% impact fee rate increase, PZ24-0149, and we have Will [0:21:34] Claver City Planner. Welcome, Will. Thank you, Madam Mayor, and grateful to be here [0:21:41] today. Today we have a report on fiscal year 24, impact fee report. In the [0:21:51] analysis section it kind of breaks it down. I'll go through that real quick [0:21:54] as in fiscal year 2024 we spent $16,595 in streets impact fees that was for the [0:22:07] finalization of Filer Avenue East and Hankins Drive North. It was a project along [0:22:14] the city on parcel and right-of-way negotiations for Eastland Drive and then [0:22:20] Then in Parks fees we spent $57,845 and that was on the Canyon Trail Junction in Chobani [0:22:31] Wellness Park where Eastland and Pole Line Road tie into each other. [0:22:38] And then the bulk of our money we spent was on the fire impact fees which was $650,100 [0:22:46] which was a certificate of participation, which is the COP, that payment towards the fire station [0:22:55] number two, which is on Chaney Drive. [0:22:59] Staff did not receive any formal inquiries or questions about the fairness or equity of [0:23:05] the implementation of it. [0:23:07] And we did report this to our city or the impact fee and development committee. [0:23:20] They met on October 24th of this year and they recommended approval of the fiscal year 2024 [0:23:40] The also on October 24th, we talked about increasing the impact fees. [0:23:51] This is important to do so we can keep the increase incremental rather than one large [0:24:00] Trump. [0:24:01] That way we can keep our paying for the services that we charge the impact fees for. [0:24:09] they stay relevant. In the end, we were looked at the August MCI, the Municipal Cost Index, [0:24:20] to increase the fees by end. They supported by a vote of five to zero, increasing that fee by [0:24:29] 1.31%, to give you a little bit of how this would affect a single family dwelling every time a single [0:24:41] single family dwelling would be built, it would be $5,000, or it would be an increase of $62.75 [0:24:50] to the, to, in addition to what they're currently paying right now. And with that, I'll stand [0:24:58] for any questions. [0:24:59] Thank you. Well, I'm glad to see that number is 1.31 instead of some of the larger numbers [0:25:08] We've had to deal with anybody have any comments or questions. [0:25:16] It looks like a motion for both accepting the report and approving the increase is what we're looking for. [0:25:26] Or, Grayson Stone. [0:25:28] Thank you, Madam Mayor. [0:25:29] I make a motion to accept the fiscal year 2024 impact fee report and improve the 1.31% impact fee rate increase. [0:25:37] PZ24-0149. [0:25:40] Thank you. [0:25:41] do have a second. Thank you motion by Grayson Stone second by Craig Hawkins to [0:25:47] accept the 20 fiscal year 2024 impact fee report and approve the 1.31% impact [0:25:55] fee rate increase. Do you have some dad? Okay any further discussion? Rachel [0:26:07] roll call vote please. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Thank you [0:26:18] motion passes six to zero. Go ahead Will. And this will come before you again in a [0:26:23] fee resolution later day. So that's when it will become effective. Thank you. Okay the [0:26:32] last item under items of consideration is a presentation. It's a presentation of the [0:26:37] finances of the City of Twin Falls for the fiscal year 23-24. This presentation [0:26:45] will be overview of the tax-supported funds in the three major enterprise funds [0:26:50] and we have our CFO Brianna Howard. Welcome Brianna. [0:26:54] Good evening Mayor and Council. So this is the fun one if you can call it fun. I think [0:27:05] of Nathan's presentation I don't know a few months ago when he presented on the [0:27:10] odor study and how fascinating that was. There's so much information and it just made sense to me. [0:27:15] I hope that this is fun to you guys and that you can get some kind of enjoyment out of the numbers, [0:27:21] but what I'm presenting on tonight is the fourth quarter, tax-supported funds, water, sewer, and [0:27:28] sanitation. There's a couple of nuances in this presentation. If you remember all throughout the [0:27:32] year, I give what the update on the accepted budget, so the budget that was approved earlier on in [0:27:40] in the year. This one's a little bit different because not only is it what it's [0:27:43] approved but I have a couple of extra slides in the amended budget. So Matt [0:27:48] come before you the budget coordinator and said we're gonna amend the budget for a [0:27:51] couple different things. So I have a few slides in here that shows the difference [0:27:55] between what was on the accepted budget throughout the year and then ultimately [0:27:59] what we ended up with on the final budget. This first slide I want you to note is [0:28:08] is the adopted budget. This is the budget that you adopted earlier in the year and I presented [0:28:14] the first three quarters on. We had an adopted budget of $104 million. Of that budget, 42% [0:28:22] who has non-tax-supported funds and 58% who has tax-supported funds. On the right side, [0:28:29] you can see how this is split up between the fund composition. With the biggest being the [0:28:33] general fund, which is like parks and rec, fire, PD, that's 34% of our budget, [0:28:40] comparing that to the next two biggest pieces, which are wastewater at 13% and [0:28:45] water at 16%. The difference between this slide and the next slide is where our [0:28:53] amended budget is. So amended budget came in at $112 million. The biggest [0:28:59] differences between the last slide that I presented on that was all throughout the [0:29:04] here and this one is a few different things. [0:29:07] We had an I.T.D. grant and reserves of $777,000, [0:29:11] of which is on the Eastland project. [0:29:14] The Delta minimum revenue guarantee of $500,000, [0:29:18] $3.5 million, which makes up the Fire Station 3 final build [0:29:23] out some of the training center and the COP certificate [0:29:27] of participation payment. [0:29:29] $860,000 was the fire district for the training center. [0:29:34] $400,000 from PV vehicles and $750,000 on the reserves for Hankins pressure zone. [0:29:46] I added a slide here that shows the tax-supported funds just to give a little bit of education. [0:29:51] Sometimes some of these are smaller and get lost. [0:29:54] So those are all the funds that are inside of the tax-supported funds that I'm going to dive into. [0:29:59] You can see airport, buildings, city councils, city manager, there's a whole host of them. [0:30:04] It's important to note that a few of these receive funds in different areas like the pool, [0:30:09] the airport, and streets. [0:30:11] They get additional funds outside of tax-supported funds, but are mostly funded [0:30:15] by property tax dollars and shared revenue. [0:30:22] The adopted budget showing the revenue that we made for tax-supported funds was $60 million. [0:30:30] Over half of our budget, or almost half of our budget, is from property tax dollars at $29 million. [0:30:37] The next three or next two are about six million state shared revenue and reserves and then we have transfers that's money coming in from other funds like water and wastewater to pay for council finance HR city manager etc. [0:30:52] That's at four million to 31 that created street fund money is 4.2 million franchise fees a little bit smaller is 2 million and then keeps getting smaller to where all the rest is in this other category. [0:31:06] So everything that is less than a million dollars is in this other category. [0:31:10] That would include things like permits and grants and airport revenue. [0:31:16] The next slide is the difference. [0:31:18] So we have the same slide presented with the amended budget. [0:31:22] With the biggest difference being that Eastland Drive, the fire station, and the COP payments. [0:31:28] Property taxes that stay the same, we don't amend for property taxes, that's 29 million. [0:31:33] state share revenues about the same, the biggest difference is that transfer amount, 4 million, [0:31:39] I'm sorry, the reserve amount of 11,374, that makes our total property tax dollars and tax [0:31:46] supported funds at 67, almost 68 million. A little bit of history on property tax dollars [0:31:55] in the last handful of years, we've grown from 2021 at 24 million to the 29 million dollars, [0:32:01] 150,000 that we have just barely received. Property taxes are the largest resources to the tax-supported [0:32:09] funds and they grow by a couple of things. You can elect to take the 3% increase in addition to new [0:32:16] construction and then ultimately urban renewal closure which is factored into these numbers here. [0:32:25] Other parts of our revenue sources are the tax-supported funds. We get highway money, [0:32:30] state revenue sharing and franchise fees. [0:32:34] Highway money, last few years, we have received significantly more than we budgeted, and mostly [0:32:40] that is because there's not really a great way for us to budget highway money. [0:32:44] In addition, because the state doesn't share that information with us, additionally, we [0:32:49] take a conservative budgeting approach, so we don't try to budget for up swings or down [0:32:54] swings. [0:32:55] We try to find that middle line that will show what we've had for the last handful of years [0:32:59] so that we ultimately don't over-expend ourselves because if we budget revenue, we're going to [0:33:04] budget expenses to match it. [0:33:07] So we've received 7 million of the 4.2 million. [0:33:11] State revenue sharing is another large component. [0:33:13] We've received just about what we had budgeted there at 6.6 million. [0:33:18] And the franchise fees are just a little bit over what's budgeted, due significantly to [0:33:22] the increases that Idaho Power and Intermountain Gas have increased last year. [0:33:28] One thing to note on this is there's a cumulative $16 million actual receipt of funds of which [0:33:34] we've only budgeted $13 million. [0:33:37] This is 123% of our budget and factors into the transfer that we do from regular general [0:33:45] fund to capital improvement fund at the end of the year. [0:33:51] Want to dive a little bit deeper into state revenue sharing because this is one of our, [0:33:55] this is one of the things that we talk about significantly when we're trying to figure out [0:33:58] our budget. [0:33:59] What do we budget for state revenue sharing? [0:34:02] This is the sales tax dollars that we get. [0:34:06] So we've gone, as you can see, from 2021 at 5.5 million [0:34:10] to the 6.6 million that we just recently received. [0:34:14] There's a couple of things that factor into these numbers [0:34:16] behind the scenes that you can only see the outwardly effects [0:34:19] on, one of which is we were capped from 2021 to 22. [0:34:24] We received a cap of 1%, so we cannot receive more [0:34:28] than the 1% of what the state calculates we had received [0:34:32] in the prior year. [0:34:34] So we were actually capped in 2023, sorry, not 22. [0:34:39] So the 6.6 million was not what we would have received, [0:34:43] but we don't find out what we would have received [0:34:45] had we not. [0:34:46] The interesting thing here is as we received [0:34:48] almost the exact same amount this year as last year. [0:34:52] So we weren't capped, but what is indicating [0:34:55] is that people are spending more because inflation is increasing, yet they are pulling [0:35:01] back because their costs are increasing. [0:35:05] So the question is, is if and when we're going to start to see a decrease, and I think [0:35:10] the numbers show today that we are flatlining to an extent. [0:35:18] The next piece is franchise fees, next biggest one of our tax-supported funds. [0:35:24] come from natural gas power and cable companies and they're the rent that [0:35:29] utilities pay for us to use our right-of-ways. The biggest one that we receive is [0:35:35] electric going from 1.4 million to 1.8 million and that's been a pretty big [0:35:41] increase at 27% if you look from 21 to 24. We don't receive as much from [0:35:48] in our mountain gas, but the increase is as significant from 21 to 24, we've had a 68% [0:35:57] increase over the last four years. [0:36:03] Building permits is not a significant portion of our tax-supported funds, but it's always [0:36:08] interesting because it's a touch on where our economy is at. [0:36:13] In the building permit section, same thing with some of the other funds that we budget for, [0:36:19] We receive 1.6 million of the 1.1, so we don't budget a lot when it comes to building permits [0:36:27] because we don't know where things are going, plus we want to conservatively budget. [0:36:31] So the 1.6 million over the 1.1 million this year was due in large part to North Canyon [0:36:36] Medical Center and the housing company that were unanticipated. [0:36:41] What you can note here is this red line is the budgeted line and we try to keep that pretty [0:36:46] standard across the last couple of years because we don't want to again increase for [0:36:52] higher amounts that are expected. Building permit history from 2007 to 2024, you can see where we [0:37:00] had the 2008 crash that lagged a little bit in the city of Twin Falls. So we had the low dip in 2011 [0:37:07] and we incrementally increased until we had the COVID hit into COVID gain I guess in 2021. [0:37:13] to put this into perspective in fiscal year 21, which is when we received the most, we [0:37:19] had received 486 single-family permits for the year. Last year we had 106 and this year [0:37:25] we've had 287. That's a 170% increase this year on the expenditure side. So [0:37:35] personnel came in at 98.3% which looks good but it's artificially inflated to an [0:37:41] extent because in December, we had a $1,500 payment that was given out to all city staff [0:37:47] that inflated that number a little bit, but on the interesting side is as we are actually [0:37:52] starting to close the gap when it comes to employment and positions that are open, we're [0:37:59] gaining ground because we currently have only 15 open positions, which is a 4% vacancy rate. [0:38:07] M&O came in under budget, capital improvements. [0:38:11] We budgeted 19 million and only expended 16 million. [0:38:15] There's a handful of things [0:38:16] that are inside the capital improvements. [0:38:18] The streets budgeted 2.1 million in projects, [0:38:21] and they're gonna end up having $850,000 in cumber. [0:38:24] Part of that is a mill and inlay project [0:38:27] that was completed just after the fiscal year, [0:38:29] so not included in these numbers. [0:38:31] I guess one thing extra, I'm gonna note, [0:38:32] these are not audited numbers, [0:38:34] so there will be some change in the audit, [0:38:36] but not significant. [0:38:38] The contract to widen Addison Avenue of $360,000 [0:38:41] will be encumbered as well. [0:38:43] Chip seal of $1.9 million was spent. [0:38:47] Auto equipment across the city was about $2 million, [0:38:50] with which was $500,000 underspent. [0:38:54] We had $3.5 million in the fire station number three build, [0:38:58] COP payment certificate participation of $650,000, [0:39:03] and the training center of $860,000. [0:39:06] And finally, we had the SLF-RF, so state and local fiscal recovery funds of 2 million, [0:39:12] of which Idaho Housing spent 1.7 million in Vista Bonito. [0:39:16] The remainder was not started. [0:39:20] Transit was $1.3 million of which was expended. [0:39:25] Transfers came in under budget because of the 2.4 million to Durkeys that was not significantly [0:39:31] started. [0:39:32] So with the bills starting now, we'll see that different this year. [0:39:38] Any questions on tax-supported funds [0:39:40] before I jump into enterprise funds? [0:39:47] Enterprise funds are like a business, [0:39:48] but they do not have a profit motive. [0:39:50] The three largest ones that we look at [0:39:52] are water, wastewater, and sanitation. [0:39:56] And the first one is water. [0:39:57] This is user fees that pay specifically for this service, [0:40:01] and this is the last four years of user fees. [0:40:04] We had a really interesting year. [0:40:06] The last time I presented to last quarter, [0:40:08] we weren't at budget, we weren't close to budget, [0:40:11] And I was really concerned that we were going to meet our budgeted numbers. [0:40:14] But we did. [0:40:15] We actually come in right at our budget at $11 million. [0:40:24] On the expenditure side, personnel again is close, but it has the $1,500 payment that [0:40:30] was made to employees. [0:40:32] MNO here was under-expended as well. [0:40:36] Capital, what's included in this $6.6 million, the largest budget item was Kimberly Road of [0:40:42] 3.5 million in mainline replacement of 1.5 million. The Kimberly Road one has not been [0:40:47] started and the mainline replacement was under 800,000. But on the flip side 4.6 million of [0:40:55] Hankins was encumbered from a prior year and spent this year. On the debt side of things, [0:41:01] that 845,000 is the last debt payment. So next year that will go away in the water fund. [0:41:12] Wastewater, wastewater is about $10 million. [0:41:15] In the wastewater fund, [0:41:16] this is the total residential, industrial, [0:41:18] and municipal user fees. [0:41:21] In fiscal year 22, we had a high amount [0:41:23] of industrial usage. [0:41:25] We are seeing a decline in the past few years [0:41:28] that is specifically tied to the improvements [0:41:30] that Chobani is making for updating [0:41:32] their pre-tribin plant. [0:41:37] On the expenditure side, personnel is not the largest expense. [0:41:42] MNO is high, it continues to be a consistent battle, [0:41:46] is because of large increases in the Jacobs contracts due to labor and chemical costs. [0:41:52] In the Capital Improvement Fund, in this 2.7 million, there was 1.5 budgeted for a primary [0:41:58] and secondary clarifier, 500,000 for the sludge pad, 300,000 for a sludge truck, and 550,000 [0:42:05] for mainline maintenance. [0:42:06] We have $28 million left in the bonds for the wastewater fund. [0:42:12] We'll pay that one off in 2033. [0:42:18] is much more consistent than water and wastewater, and continues to hover around that $4 million [0:42:23] mark. On the expense side, we pay PSI, so we have a contract for that that does all of the [0:42:30] expenditures there. Any questions on enterprise funds? [0:42:39] Any questions for beyond it? [0:42:44] So in the current environment, I'd like to show detailed statistics because it helps stakeholders [0:42:48] to understand the scale and implications of the economic environment clearly. This helps [0:42:53] frame our municipal decisions within broader economic trends and reinforces [0:42:57] decision-making rationale. There's a couple of different slides that I'm showing here [0:43:01] that relate to inflation, employment, and housing that we are experiencing in the [0:43:05] city. Some of you guys have backgrounds in these areas and so you see those just as [0:43:09] well as I do, but these are the things that consistently come up in our [0:43:12] conversations as we're budgeting, as we're making decisions, and when we determine [0:43:16] how we're going to finance or go forward. As far as inflation, despite [0:43:23] high borrowing costs, consumers are showing resilience, which is nothing different than [0:43:28] what we've seen. [0:43:29] But what is interesting is spending as increased in these categories, electronics, restaurants, [0:43:34] bars, motor vehicles, and online shopping. [0:43:37] Spending as decreased in furniture, health stores, and sporting goods. [0:43:42] Online shopping negatively impacts our revenue sharing. [0:43:46] If you drive up to Walmart and you made the purchase online, that is an online shopping. [0:43:51] If you walk into Walmart, that is not an online shopping. [0:43:55] The state does not share state shared revenues with us if it is an online shopping, but restaurants [0:44:01] and bars are local shopping. [0:44:04] There's a balance there. [0:44:09] So Fed Chair Powell said the economy is not sending any signals that we need to be in a [0:44:15] hurry to lower rates. [0:44:16] You'll note the most recent rate cuts if you were paying attention or if you watched that [0:44:21] kind of staff are interested in it. November they decreased it by 0.25% and in September [0:44:26] is 0.5%. Their next meeting is in December. Investors and interest rate futures, markets [0:44:33] expect the central bank to lower rates by a quarter point and then slow afterwards. Interest [0:44:40] rate adjustments by the federal reserve affect our financing borrowing strategies. We are [0:44:45] currently making about 5% on the money that we hold right now in investments. When I [0:44:50] started here about five years ago. It was right around 1% and even dropped just [0:44:55] below. So we are making some but we're losing some in other areas. Markets [0:45:03] reaction to Trump's reelection has not been measured yet. Tariffs over the next [0:45:07] 12 months. Maybe deflationary and not inflationary. Unemployment, initial claims [0:45:14] was a Piper Sandler report, economic snapshot that just came out. It was the [0:45:19] lowest level, initial claims are the lowest level in six months. From the other [0:45:22] side, continuous claims are the highest level in three years. We're at 3.7% this [0:45:32] is a graph produced by the Idaho, the Fort Merv Labor, 2023 was 3.1%. This [0:45:40] correlates to what we're experiencing in the city with our 4% [0:45:44] unemployment rate. What's interesting is the dynamic that we're seeing HR was [0:45:50] just sharing with me last week that we have a couple of other [0:45:53] couple positions I'll point out. We had the open space position that has brought in [0:45:58] over 60 applicants in just a few weeks. The utility billing position had 90 [0:46:05] applicants in a few days. We ended up actually closing the closing in a week [0:46:09] early because we have over a hundred applicants in the utility billing [0:46:12] position in just a couple of days. I don't know what that means. I don't know what [0:46:17] that's a trend but it's an interesting dynamic that we have not seen in the [0:46:21] recent history. Employment real capita per income is 59,000 as opposed to last [0:46:31] year's 57,000. We receive a status so this relates to employees and what we're [0:46:36] paying them. We receive a state of Idaho Pay Practices survey and the data shows [0:46:40] that we have moved our salaries roughly 2% more than the average which helps with [0:46:45] the actual per capita income that people are receiving in the city and allows us [0:46:51] to be the employer of choice. [0:46:54] But on the flip side is housing. [0:46:56] What can people afford? [0:46:57] Existing home sales at the lowest point in 14 years, [0:47:01] with the most significant change, this is a national report, [0:47:04] of homes less than 100,000, which has a 22% decline, [0:47:08] it's a huge decline, and homes over 500,000 have increased. [0:47:13] Which is interesting to note, because if you've been [0:47:16] in the city of Twin Falls long or you've walked around [0:47:18] or looked at Zillow, there's no homes [0:47:20] that are less than 100,000. [0:47:22] This map shows, it's a heat map showing how the cost, the average cost of home is in Idaho as compared to other states. [0:47:30] It's no surprise to see that Idaho is becoming more and more pink, more darker throughout, as we have experienced the move-in that we have. [0:47:39] So if real capita parent is 59,000 and a home costs 457,000, it's difficult to make a mortgage payment. [0:47:50] So in summary, we've received $16 million of tax-supported funds over our budgeted $13 million. [0:47:58] Our M&O in tax-supported funds is about a million under. [0:48:02] We have significant capital outlay this year and we're encumbering into next to say this [0:48:06] year is what I've just reported. [0:48:08] Inflation is tapering, but consumers are still spending. [0:48:11] Housing market continues to shift and employment is strong and the city is gaining ground. [0:48:18] questions or any questions for Brianna? [0:48:26] Very interesting. [0:48:27] Grayson. [0:48:28] Thank you, Madam Mayor. [0:48:29] I don't have a question. [0:48:30] It's general observation. [0:48:31] I'm a huge numbers guy. [0:48:33] And I absolutely love all the time [0:48:35] you put into these presentations. [0:48:37] It is so thorough, very, very impressive. [0:48:40] So just kudos to you and your department [0:48:44] and all the information that we can extract from it. [0:48:46] So good job. [0:48:48] Thank you. [0:48:49] Chief was going to present. [0:48:51] But I told him I had it for him. [0:48:54] Ooh, that's scary. [0:48:56] So he's up next time? [0:48:57] Yeah. [0:48:58] That's what it sounds like. [0:48:59] Yeah. [0:48:59] Quarter. [0:49:00] Q1. [0:49:01] Yeah. [0:49:02] Come on. [0:49:03] OK. [0:49:05] That good? [0:49:08] Thank you, Brianna. [0:49:11] OK, that's all for items of consideration. [0:49:13] The next item on the agenda is the time for general public input. [0:49:18] It's a time for anybody in the audience that [0:49:20] wishes to address City Council on something not [0:49:24] on today's agenda. [0:49:26] Welcome, Paul. [0:49:35] Pastor Paul, to your Michael. [0:49:37] OK. [0:49:38] I forget about those things. [0:49:40] The only time I get nervous to speak in front of people [0:49:43] is with you guys. [0:49:44] I don't know why that is. [0:49:45] Don't forget to state your name. [0:49:47] OK. [0:49:47] OK. [0:49:48] For the record. [0:49:48] Paul Thompson, a happy citizen of, actually, technically, [0:49:54] I live outside the city limits. [0:49:56] But I pastor East Side Baptist Church here in the city. [0:50:00] So, Madam Mayor and members of the City Council, [0:50:05] and to the city staff and to the dedicated city personnel, [0:50:09] as a minister of the gospel of the only begotten son of God, [0:50:14] I'm pleased to greet you this evening [0:50:16] as one of the happy citizens of our beloved city. [0:50:19] And I'm before you today with a heart filled [0:50:23] with gratitude to God to call Twin Falls, Idaho my home. [0:50:28] As a resident, I'm thankful to God for the police, for the fire department. [0:50:35] People in my church have expressed their thankfulness of the care that they receive at times of emergencies in their own lives. [0:50:44] I'm grateful for that. I want to express that to you. [0:50:47] I've witnessed firsthand the efforts of our city staff, and I'd like to extend a special appreciation to the public works department. [0:50:57] the public works department or they're around the clock efforts to ensure a smooth functioning [0:51:04] of our city. Their work often unseen unless we see it is essential to our daily lives and [0:51:15] so from our prairie roads to maintaining our water and our sewer system they play a vital [0:51:22] role in making our city a livable and enjoyable place for all of us. So I want to express appreciation [0:51:31] to you as well for the hard work that you put in the time that you give up of your family [0:51:36] and other things that you could be doing. Your unwavering commitment to our city is appreciated [0:51:42] and I'm honored to be a part of a city like this and have an opportunity to express my [0:51:47] deepest appreciation for all of you. So happy Thanksgiving. It's what I've come to say. [0:51:55] Thank you. Thank you very much. Anybody else in the audience that wishes to [0:52:02] address City Council tonight? Hey, see no one advisory board reports. Anybody have [0:52:13] anything kind of a slow week? City manager's office. Well, first, thank you to [0:52:22] Pastor Thompson for those kind words and we'll certainly pass them on to the [0:52:26] members of our team and we greatly appreciate the work that you do in our [0:52:30] community as well and on that Thanksgiving is this Thursday and so we [0:52:36] hope that like the pastor we can all just take a minute and give thanks for [0:52:42] amazing community amazing country and all the things that that we have that are [0:52:47] blessings before us and the city staff will be home with their families except [0:52:54] for a central personnel on Thursday and Friday. [0:52:57] Friday city offices are closed. [0:53:00] As a reminder, we exchanged Columbus Day 20 years ago, [0:53:08] I think it was before mid-ton I got there, [0:53:10] certainly before I got here, [0:53:12] in exchange for the Friday after Thanksgiving. [0:53:15] And so we recognize luck Friday, [0:53:20] rather than Columbus Day, that's my commentary. [0:53:24] Thank you. [0:53:25] Okay. [0:53:26] If nobody else has anything to say, we're adjourned and happy Thanksgiving, everyone.