Oversight Archive: City Council meeting, 2024-12-23, recording 1 (started 16:58) Machine transcript (faster-whisper base.en), not checked word for word; the Pledge of Allegiance is shown in its standard wording. The recording is the record. Times are time into the recording. Passages with private details are muted in the audio and marked here. The audio on the page below was re-encoded by software from the video the agency posted. Check any passage against that audio before relying on it. Page: https://oversightarchive.org/twin-falls-id/meetings/2024-12-23/ [0:01:34] Good evening, ladies and gentlemen, and welcome to the [0:01:38] December 23rd, 2024 City Council meeting. I want to confirm we have a quorum. We have all seven members [0:01:47] present in chambers [0:01:49] First item on the agenda is the Pledge of Allegiance if you wish to join me, please rise [0:01:54] Thank you. We have no proclamations tonight. So next on the agenda is the [0:02:19] consent calendar. To approve. Thank you. Do I have a second? I'll second. Thank you. [0:02:25] Motion by Chris Reed seconded by Jason Brown to approve the consent calendar [0:02:32] as written. Amy Rolkow, please. [0:02:37] Ruth Pierce. [0:02:38] Yes. [0:02:39] Chris Reed. [0:02:40] Yes. [0:02:41] Greg Hawkins. [0:02:42] Yes. [0:02:43] Jason Brown. [0:02:44] Yes. [0:02:45] Senator Cutler. [0:02:46] Yes. [0:02:47] And Grayson Stone. [0:02:48] Yes. [0:02:49] Thank you. [0:02:50] Motion passes 70-0. [0:02:52] Okay. [0:02:53] Next, under items of consideration, our first item is a request to approve the purchase of [0:03:00] of a VersaLift VST55 HDI telescopic lift in 2024, 2024 for truck F600 at a cost of $301,349 using [0:03:16] a cooperative purchasing agreement with Sourcewell and authorized IT director to execute the contract. [0:03:25] And we have Gretchen. [0:03:26] It's got hotening. [0:03:28] Not Norm Hoecky. [0:03:29] Welcome Gretchen. [0:03:30] not norm. Mondays are norms usually day off and given that it's the holiday week I [0:03:35] asked him if he wanted me to cover for him instead of him coming in for the one [0:03:39] agenda item and he said he would appreciate that. So we're here tonight to [0:03:44] ask for approval to go ahead with a budgeted purchase. The purchase amount is in the [0:03:52] contract route you read $301,349, it's above the threshold of $150,000 but we have a [0:04:03] sourceable contract we can use which is why we're here tonight for your [0:04:06] authorization. This purchase is part of the planned replacement schedule for the [0:04:14] fleet steering committee it was recommended for this year's budget. The [0:04:18] The unit that we are replacing is a 2001 GMC bucket truck. [0:04:24] It was purchased in 2012 and is past its useful life estimate of 15 years. [0:04:30] Primarily, this is used for maintenance and repairs to traffic signals and luminaries along [0:04:37] all of our streets. [0:04:38] It is also used in the water department for work on their facilities as well. [0:04:46] It primarily affects the information technology department, street department, and water department [0:04:51] to the primary users of the equipment. [0:04:55] It does have increased safety features and our current unit has experienced increased [0:05:01] repairs. [0:05:03] We expect the time to build from when we are able to execute the purchase bid six to eight [0:05:10] months is how long it will take for it to be built and then delivered to us. [0:05:16] In the type of truck, the difference is we moved away from a mid-sized diesel truck and [0:05:22] into a gas F600 chassis. [0:05:27] I think I used all the right words that Norm told me to use. [0:05:30] You sound very technical. [0:05:34] And so with that, I'll stand for any questions that you might have. [0:05:38] That's our cutler. [0:05:39] I think I know the answer, but I don't want to assume. [0:05:42] If we approve this, then it's authorizing the IT director to sign the agreement. [0:05:47] Is that because the electricians use this and do the electricians report to IT? [0:05:52] Yes, that's correct. [0:05:55] It's actually a pretty versatile piece of equipment. [0:05:57] IT people use it, the electricians use it, but they also do it work for the street department [0:06:03] when they do that. [0:06:04] So it's kind of a multi-department functioning. [0:06:07] Okay. [0:06:08] Thank you. [0:06:09] Any other questions? [0:06:11] Okay. [0:06:14] I'd entertain a motion. [0:06:16] Please. [0:06:20] I'd move to approve the purchase of the VersaLift VST-55 HDI [0:06:27] telescopic lift and a 2024 Ford F600 truck at a cost of $301,349 [0:06:41] using a cooperative purchasing agreement with Sourcewell and [0:06:44] authorized the IT Director to execute the contract. [0:06:47] Thank you. [0:06:47] Great. [0:06:48] Thank you, Madam Mayor. [0:06:49] I'll second. [0:06:50] Thank you, motion by Jason Brown, seconded by Grayson Stone. [0:06:53] I'm going to read it one more time. [0:06:55] Request to approve the purchase of a Versa Lift T-55HDI [0:07:01] telescopic lift in a 2024 Ford F-600 truck [0:07:05] at a cost of $301,349 using a cooperative purchase agreement [0:07:12] with Sourcewell and authorizing the IT director to execute. [0:07:17] Any further discussion? [0:07:19] Amy Roll call vote please. [0:07:22] Chris Reed. [0:07:23] Yes. [0:07:24] Craig Hawkins. [0:07:24] Yes. [0:07:25] Jason Brown. [0:07:26] Yes. [0:07:26] Spencer Cutler. [0:07:27] Yes. [0:07:27] Grayson Stone. [0:07:28] Yes. [0:07:29] Jerry Bölmer. [0:07:30] Yes. [0:07:30] And Ruth Pierce. [0:07:31] Yes. [0:07:33] Thank you, motion passes seven to zero. [0:07:35] Thank you, Gretchen. [0:07:37] OK, next on the agenda is an action item, [0:07:40] a request to approve transit improvement plan [0:07:45] for submission to Magic Valley, MPO, [0:07:48] and we have our transit coordinator, Maxine, Drianne. [0:07:52] Welcome, Maxine. [0:07:57] Need to push the button. [0:07:59] Sorry, I missed that. [0:08:00] Yeah, good evening, Madam Mayor, members of council. [0:08:03] So the item I'm asking for approval on today, [0:08:07] this is one of the main documents that the MPO works on, [0:08:11] the transit improvement plan includes all the transportation [0:08:13] operations in the urbanized area. [0:08:16] As the direct recipient for 5307 funds, CO2 falls kind of has that obligation to assist with this but also because we're operating right TFT. [0:08:26] This directly has our operating funds for the upcoming fiscal cycle included in it. [0:08:32] After your approval, this would go to the MPO policy board. [0:08:37] After their approval, it would go to ITDs board and then after ITDs board, it would go to FTA, etc. [0:08:42] So it's kind of just one step in the process. [0:08:45] The reason we're preparing this is because currently with the MPO just being stood up, [0:08:50] it's going to be about another two years for them to get through the process for developing [0:08:53] the tip on their own. [0:08:54] So we're working with the MPO to help them with this part of it so we can have kind of [0:08:59] a temporary like MPO or, excuse me, a temporary tip that they can get approved so we can access [0:09:04] our 5307 funding. [0:09:06] This document is one of several requirements for us to get that funding from the FTA. [0:09:13] This is not anything additional to what we're already doing. [0:09:16] This is just to switch over from our current CARES money, which will run out at the end [0:09:21] of this current fiscal year, and to ensure that we have 5307 funds, which will kick in. [0:09:26] They're available now, but we would be able to start drawing them down on October 1st of [0:09:32] 2025. [0:09:34] I submitted a copy of the document for your review. [0:09:38] There's a couple of items on here that I wanted to go over just to touch base. [0:09:44] So first of all, there's some stuff on here that first two lines on this are referring [0:09:49] to operating assistance on demand and twin falls and preventative maintenance on demand [0:09:54] and twin falls. [0:09:55] That is the program that we currently have. [0:09:57] It's just broken out into those two categories because that's effectively how FTA likes to [0:10:01] see that money split up. The short-range planning and long-range planning, some of [0:10:07] that is already included in what we're already doing. It's just broken down as a [0:10:11] separate line item so that match is already included in my salary. It's not [0:10:15] anything that would obligate the city any further. Same with the mobility [0:10:19] management coordinating marketing. There's also a couple of items here for [0:10:24] Lincoln County. These are for preventative maintenance and operations for [0:10:28] services that come into the Twin Falls urbanized area. This is money that is [0:10:34] available to us as like I said the direct recipients for the 5307 for our urbanized [0:10:39] area. Since this serves our urbanized area, Lincoln County has you know they [0:10:45] qualify for this so we're just kind of approving that. They would still be the [0:10:48] ones that would put up the local match requirement to obtain those funds so [0:10:52] it would not be the city of Twin Falls for any money there. It just has to be [0:10:56] included in this plan for us to go forward with it. [0:10:59] The other thing with this is that it's listed out for four years. [0:11:02] That's just because the tip is meant to be a four-year planning document. [0:11:05] It typically changes year over year and is updated on a yearly basis as it's being developed [0:11:10] anyway. [0:11:11] I think that covers the majority of the plan, so with that, I'll stand for any questions. [0:11:19] clarify for me this Lincoln County, we're not agreeing to provide transportation in [0:11:31] Lincoln County at all. This is just a protocol to include this. Why wouldn't they [0:11:39] be doing it on their own? So we're working with the MPO to help develop their tip. [0:11:43] Like I mentioned, it's going to take them time to get it off the ground and [0:11:46] it's a two-year process. We have to develop this for us to get our funding [0:11:50] in time so that we don't have a gap between the CARES and 5307. [0:11:54] Linking County Connections is kind of in the same boat. [0:11:57] They're just submitting this alongside us because it all ends up going into the same tip. [0:12:01] So we're working with Kelly Badesheim. She's the director of VRT in Boise, [0:12:06] and now she works as a consultant. She's doing some work for Linking County Connections. [0:12:10] And since they're one of the only other transit providers in the area that could potentially use these funds, [0:12:15] we're working with them to include this to hand it over to the MPO for approval. [0:12:19] wouldn't obligate the City of Twin Falls for any additional funds and it wouldn't [0:12:24] be us providing those services. It's for services that Lincoln County [0:12:27] Connections already does. They're just trying to get some of the 5307 funding [0:12:31] because it affects our urbanized area. So we have to approve the Lincoln County [0:12:37] portion or we just approving the Twin Falls request. The Lincoln County [0:12:41] portion has to be included in this document. We are approving this document [0:12:44] as our governing board for ride TFT to then go to the MPO. Okay legally is that [0:12:50] Okay. I don't see why it's not legally okay. Okay. I just want to make sure we weren't. I think [0:13:04] the what Maxine's asking is for our board to review and approve, send it to the MPO. The MPO [0:13:11] would be the entity. That would be the one that would have the legal question and before it goes [0:13:17] to the MPO. Should there be any we could have legal representation look at it? Okay. Well I kind [0:13:22] kind of had my MPO had on at the same time, so I apologize. [0:13:26] Well, and on that note too, Travis is correct. [0:13:29] And the other thing with this is some of this is for funding like the 5310. [0:13:33] That's not funds that the City of Twin Falls is responsible for. [0:13:36] That would ultimately be the MPO policy board. [0:13:39] But since we're preparing the tip, we're including it just to make sure that all of the, you know, [0:13:44] requests from reasonable stakeholders and partners are included. [0:13:47] Ultimately, we go to the MPO to approve that. [0:13:49] Okay. [0:13:50] I'm good then. [0:13:51] Sorry for the interruption. Anybody else have any questions? Spencer? [0:13:58] My question was answered. I was just withdrawing it but yeah I just I had [0:14:02] inferred before the meeting oh our MPO and our tip has to consider the region [0:14:08] so but you clarified so thank you. Yeah and the 5307 funds while we are the [0:14:13] direct recipient it's not purely City of Twin Falls money it's for the entire [0:14:17] urbanized area so we have to consider other projects that would impact the [0:14:21] urbanized area. And that's both for services that are offered by other members of the urbanized [0:14:26] area and also services that directly impact. In this case, bringing people to and from. [0:14:34] Chris Reed. I'm ready to make a motion. I had the same questions, but they've been answered. [0:14:39] Great. So do you have something else? No, go ahead. Go ahead, Chris. [0:14:43] Move to approve the transit improvement plan for submission to the Magic Valley MPO. [0:14:48] Thank you. Do we have a second? I'll second. Thank you. Motion by Chris Reed. Second by [0:14:53] to approve the transit improvement plan for submission to the Magic Valley MPO. [0:14:58] Amy Rokov, please. Craig Hawkins. Yes. Jason Brown. Yes. Spencer Cutler. Yes. [0:15:07] Grayson Stone. Yes. Sherry Bulmer. Yes. Ruth Pierce. Yes. And Chris Reed. Yes. [0:15:12] Thank you. Motion passes 7-0. Thank you, Maxine. Thank you. Okay, next item on the [0:15:22] agenda is a request to adopt resolution 2024-012, resolution authorizing the [0:15:29] filing of applications with the F Federal Transit Administration, and operating [0:15:35] administration of the United States Department of Transportation, [0:15:39] for Federal Transportation Assistance, authorized by Chapter 53, Title 49 of the [0:15:46] United States Code, and any other federal statute administered by the [0:15:51] the Federal Transit Administration, vaccine, that's a mouthful. [0:15:56] Yes, most things with FDA are a mouthful, unfortunately. [0:16:00] So this next item up for your approval, really, [0:16:03] this is just a similar agreement that we had with ITD [0:16:07] when we initially got the CARES funding [0:16:08] for our current program. [0:16:10] This is just in order for us to access the 5307 grant funding [0:16:14] that is currently already available, [0:16:16] and for us to be able to draw down and request reimbursement [0:16:19] from those grant funds. [0:16:21] Like I said, it's effectively, it's the same agreement [0:16:24] that we had with ITD, except now we have to go through the FED [0:16:26] since it's federal dollars rather than state. [0:16:30] I'll stand for any questions. [0:16:32] Thank you. [0:16:33] Any questions for Maxine on this? [0:16:37] Does it look like I'd entertain a motion? [0:16:41] Oh, Madam Mayor, thank you. [0:16:43] I'll make a motion to adopt resolution R2024-012, [0:16:48] resolution authorizing the filing of applicants [0:16:50] with the federal transit administration [0:16:52] and operate an administration United States Department of Transportation for federal transportation [0:16:57] assistance authorized by Chapter 53 of Title 49 of the United States Code and any other federal [0:17:02] statutes administered by the federal transit administration. [0:17:07] Thank you. [0:17:08] Do I have a second? [0:17:09] Second. [0:17:10] Thank you. [0:17:11] Motion by Grace and Stone, second by Craig Hawkins to adopt the resolution R2024-012 as described [0:17:19] here. [0:17:22] Any further discussion? Amy Roll call vote please. Jason Brown. Yes. [0:17:30] Benter Cutler. Yes. Grayson Stone. Yes. Terry Volmer. Yes. Ruth Pierce. Yes. Chris Reed. Yes. [0:17:36] And Craig Hawkins. Yes. Thank you. Motion passes seven to zero. Thank you, Maxine. [0:17:42] Thank you. Happy Holidays. And you. Hey, next on the agenda is an action item. [0:17:48] a request to adopt ordinance 2024-022 for zoning district change on property located on [0:17:56] the south side of the 1900 block of 4th Avenue East and we have our planning and zoning director [0:18:03] Jonathan Spentlove. In fact I see you have the next three so yeah and then the next two after [0:18:09] that as well. Oh good so tell me if you need a break okay I'll get a drink of water okay I'm [0:18:16] I'm going to go through these three ordinances. [0:18:17] They are in order. [0:18:19] This one came to the Planning and Zoning Commission [0:18:21] in early October, and then the City Council quickly there [0:18:25] after this is the rezone on the east side of town, [0:18:28] the Jaya capital, and we rezone from R6 to C1, [0:18:32] and the ordinances there. [0:18:33] If you wish to approve it, as with the next two, [0:18:35] it would be the third and final by title only. [0:18:38] If you wish to do it tonight, [0:18:40] and I will stand for any more questions [0:18:41] they have on this one. [0:18:42] Thank you, Chris Reed. [0:18:44] Don't have any questions. [0:18:45] You're gonna do your proverbial motion. [0:18:47] I can do that. [0:18:48] Oh, for it. [0:18:49] I move that we dispense with the reading rules input [0:18:51] ordinance number 2024-022 on third and final reading [0:18:56] by title only. [0:18:57] Thank you, Sherry Vomer. [0:18:58] I'll second. [0:18:59] Thank you, motion by Chris Reed, second by Sherry Vomer [0:19:03] to dispense with the reading rules [0:19:06] and put ordinance 2024-022 on third and final reading [0:19:11] by title only. [0:19:14] Give me a roll call vote please. [0:19:17] Spencer Cutler. [0:19:20] Yes. [0:19:21] Grayson Stone. [0:19:22] Yes. [0:19:23] Sherry Bomer. [0:19:24] Yes. [0:19:25] Ruth Pierce. [0:19:26] Yes. [0:19:27] Chris Reed. [0:19:28] Yes. [0:19:29] Craig Hopkins. [0:19:30] Yes. [0:19:31] And Jason Brown. [0:19:32] Yes. [0:19:33] Thank you. [0:19:34] Motion passes 7 to 0. [0:19:35] I need to read the ordinance. [0:19:36] You can or I can. [0:19:37] I have both. [0:19:38] Either way. [0:19:39] I'll do it. [0:19:40] I'll let you read one. [0:19:41] I'll read one. [0:19:42] Okay. [0:19:43] Ordinance 2024. [0:19:44] ordinance of the city council of the city of Twin Falls rezoning certain real property [0:19:50] below described providing the zoning classification therefore and ordering the necessary area [0:19:56] of impact in zoning district map amendments. Chris Reed. [0:20:02] Move to approve ordinance 2024-022. [0:20:05] Thank you. [0:20:06] Could I have a second? [0:20:07] I'll second. [0:20:08] Thank you. Motion by Chris Reed, seconded by Jason Brown to adopt Ordinance 2024-022 [0:20:17] for Zoning District Change on Property Located on the south side of the 1900 [0:20:23] block of 4th Avenue East. Amy Rojo, please. [0:20:27] Grace and Stone. Yes. Terry Bomer. Yes. Ruth Pierce. Yes. Chris Reed. Yes. [0:20:33] Great Hawkins. Yes. Jason Brown. Yes. And Spencer Cutler. Yes. Thank you. Motion passes 7-0. [0:20:40] A next item request to adopt Ordinance 2024-023 for a zoning district change on property located on [0:20:52] the 2,000 and 2,100 Bakha Poline Road East, entirety of Pillar Falls, laws of subdivision. [0:21:00] These dates were similar, it was October 8th and then November 18th by the council and this [0:21:08] as a reminder for anybody listening or for the council, this was the entirety of that subdivision [0:21:13] it went from a PUD with a very specific master plan to just see one that will follow the city [0:21:19] code as well as the Canyon Rim Overlay, that did not get removed either, same process. [0:21:26] So we need a motion to for third and final reading is if that's what you choose go ahead Chris and move that we dispense with the reading rules and put ordinance 2024 dash 023 on third and final reading by title only. [0:21:47] Thank you to have a second. [0:21:50] Thank you motion by Chris Reed second by Craig Hawkins to dispense with the reading of the rules and put ordinance 2024 dash 022 on third and final reading. [0:22:00] and final reading by title only. [0:22:03] Amy Rolkow, please. [0:22:08] Chury Volmer. [0:22:09] Yes. [0:22:10] Ruth Pierce. [0:22:11] Yes. [0:22:11] Chris Reed. [0:22:12] Yes. [0:22:13] Greg Hawkins. [0:22:14] Yes. [0:22:15] Jason Brown. [0:22:16] Yes. [0:22:17] Spencer Cutler. [0:22:18] Yes. [0:22:19] And Grayson Stone. [0:22:20] Yes. [0:22:21] Thank you. [0:22:22] Motion passes 7-0. [0:22:23] Ordinance 2024-023, an ordinance of the City Council of the City of Twin Falls, Idaho, rezoning [0:22:30] certain real property below described providing the zoning classification [0:22:35] therefore and ordering the necessary map, excuse me, necessary area of impact and [0:22:41] zoning district map amendments. Jason Brown. I'd move to adopt ordinance 2024-023 for [0:22:54] the zoning district change on property located on the 2,000 and 2,100 blocks [0:22:59] of Poline Road East entirely of the Pillar Falls Plaza subdivision. [0:23:04] Thank you, Grace and Stone. [0:23:05] Thank you, Madam Mayor. [0:23:06] I second. [0:23:07] Thank you. [0:23:08] Motion by Jason Brown. [0:23:09] Second by Grace and Stone to approve the adoption of Ordinance 2024. [0:23:14] Dash 023 for zoning district change on property located under the 2020 100 block of Poline Road East. [0:23:23] Amy Roole. [0:23:24] Roll call. [0:23:25] Please. [0:23:27] Ruth Pierce. [0:23:28] Yes. [0:23:29] Yes. Great Hawkins. Yes. Jason Brown. Yes. Spencer Cutler. Yes. Grayson Stone. Yes. [0:23:35] And Sherry Bomer. Yes. Thank you. Motion passes 7 to 0. Okay. Last action item [0:23:43] request to adopt Ordinance 2024-024 for annexation on property located east of [0:23:52] some way drive north from College Road North College Road West to Poline [0:23:58] road west. This item is an annexation this was the one as described it split that property [0:24:06] the north side would be commercial the south side would be residential the split lines up [0:24:11] right there with latitude circle might be chainy drive in my head I'm gonna mom mixed up now [0:24:18] anyway those dates came in October and then again in December the 9th of December was [0:24:23] were in council voted on it. Same third and final if you wish. [0:24:28] Thank you Jason Brown. I would move to we dispense with the reading of the rules and [0:24:34] put ordinance 2024-024 on third and final for reading by title only. [0:24:43] Thank you Chris Reed. I'll second that. Thank you motion by Jason Brown second [0:24:48] by Chris Reed to dispense with the reading of the rules [0:24:52] and put Ordinance 2024-024 on third and final reading [0:24:58] by title. [0:25:02] Amy Rokow, please. [0:25:05] Chris Reed. [0:25:06] Yes. [0:25:06] Ray Hawkins. [0:25:07] Yes. [0:25:08] Jason Brown. [0:25:08] Yes. [0:25:09] Hunter Cutler. [0:25:10] Yes. [0:25:10] Grayson Stone. [0:25:11] Yes. [0:25:12] Perry Volmer. [0:25:13] Yes. [0:25:13] And Ruth Pears. [0:25:14] Yes. [0:25:15] Thank you. [0:25:16] Motion passes 7 to 0. [0:25:19] Ordinance number 2024-024. [0:25:22] and ordinance of the City Council of the City of Twin Falls, Idaho, annexing certain real property [0:25:29] below describe providing the zoning classification therefore and ordering the necessary area of impact [0:25:35] in zoning district map amendments. Jerry Volmer. I move to adopt ordinance 2024-024 for annexation [0:25:48] on property located east of Sunway Drive North from North College Road West to [0:25:53] Poline Road West. Thank you Craig Hawkins. Motion by Sherry Volmer second by Craig [0:26:01] Hawkins to approve the adoption of Ordinance 2024 2024 for the annexation [0:26:09] on property located on Sunway Drive North from North College Road West to [0:26:13] in road west. Amy Roll call vote please. [0:26:20] Ray Hawkins, Jason Brown, Spencer Cutler, Grayson Stone, Kerry Bulmer, Ruth Pierce, and Chris Street. [0:26:30] Thank you motion passes 7-0. Okay the next on the agenda before we get to the public hearing section is time for general public input. [0:26:43] There's anybody in the audience that wishes to address City Council on an issue, not on today's agenda. [0:26:51] You're welcome to come down. [0:26:53] Hey, see no one, advisory board reports, City Manager. [0:27:08] Madam Mayor, members of the Council, we will be closed tomorrow and also on Christmas Day to celebrate the birth of Christ. [0:27:17] And so we'll also be closed on January 1st, so three closures in the next two weeks. [0:27:26] So the 24th, the 25th and January 1st, in addition to that, we will not be meeting next [0:27:31] week for a council meeting, so your next scheduled council meeting will be on January 6th. [0:27:37] Great. [0:27:38] Thank you. [0:27:39] Madam Mayor, I think we'd be somewhat reminisced to not acknowledge that I believe that this [0:27:44] is the first city council meeting that I've ever attended that Christopher Reed is not [0:27:48] in a suit and tie, so it's very [0:27:51] apropos to point that out that he's trying to dress like me now and I appreciate it, but... [0:27:57] And we were on the 24th ordinance for the year 2024, I thought that was a good one too. [0:28:03] Yeah, last ordinance of the year. [0:28:06] Okay, any other big announcements? [0:28:11] All right, then we'll move into the public hearing section. [0:28:15] I will read the rules real quick. [0:28:21] Council will follow these steps for each request [0:28:23] under the public hearing portion of the agenda. [0:28:26] City staff will present the request and analysis. [0:28:29] The applicant will then present their request. [0:28:32] The commission will then ask questions [0:28:34] of the applicant or staff. [0:28:36] After questions have been asked and answered, [0:28:39] the public hearing will then be open. [0:28:41] During that time, anyone in attendance [0:28:43] is given the opportunity to comment [0:28:45] ask questions about the request being considered. When giving testimony please [0:28:49] step up to the podium, state your name and address, present your comments or [0:28:53] concerns, and then after giving testimony please sign the public signing sheet [0:28:58] located in the lobby with your name and address for the record. After public [0:29:03] comments are concluded the applicant will be invited to answer any questions and [0:29:07] make a closing statement, staff will then answer, clarify any comments as needed [0:29:13] After the closing statements, the public hearing will be closed. [0:29:18] No further testimony or comments from the applicant or audience will be allowed. [0:29:23] And the commission council will then have discussion into a action. [0:29:27] So our first public hearing is an action item, a request for a zoning district change [0:29:34] from R2PUD to R2 for approximately 68 acres, [0:29:39] located south of South Hills Road and east of Harrison. Harrison Street, South [0:29:45] care of Tim Vosser on behalf of Sundance Partners LLC. And we have Kelly. You have me. [0:29:52] Lisa. No, I'm pinching tonight. Perfect. Thank you. Welcome, Kelly. Thank you, [0:29:57] Council. This is a request to remove the property from the current PUD and [0:30:03] rezone it to R2 zoning standards. On November 19th, the Planning and Zoning Commission [0:30:10] gave a positive recommendation to Council to rezone this to R2. In the mid-2000s, this property went [0:30:17] through multiple public hearings in the subdivision process. 48 acres of the original subdivision, [0:30:23] consisting of 176 lots, have been final-platted and constructed. The required improvements listed [0:30:31] in the PUD were accomplished within this phase of the project including roadway construction [0:30:36] and a pressurized irrigation facility. As part of the original PUD an area was dedicated for [0:30:43] parks stormwater retention area. This park dedication is no longer required by the city [0:30:48] as the city no longer accepts park dedications as part of the subdivision. Park locations are now [0:30:56] decided by the parks director and paid for with impact fees for new development. [0:31:01] There are two local schools in a regional park close to the subdivision and if there [0:31:06] becomes a need for a future park the parks director will choose that location. [0:31:09] The developer is still required to manage the stormwater retention on property. [0:31:14] Removing the PUD will allow the developer to replant the property using the R2 [0:31:20] standards. So this is the vicinity map showing it is on Harrison and South [0:31:28] Hills Road or 3,600 right here. This is a street view using this is the [0:31:40] intersection at Harrison Street South and 3,600 right here at that South [0:31:47] Hills Middle School. So this is looking north looking south into the developed [0:31:51] subdivision, looking east, and then looking west, just so you guys get an idea [0:32:00] of what we're talking about. This is the zoning map, this is the area in question. [0:32:08] Mostly area to the west and north is zoned R2, this area over here is R1 [0:32:17] variable, which allows for larger lots, and this area mostly is in the area of [0:32:23] impact. The future land use, or that could be a little bigger, the future land use shows [0:32:30] this as a town neighborhood, which is primarily residential and character with [0:32:36] single family duplexes and triplexes. This is the narrative just explaining the [0:32:43] reason for the request to rezone. Right here is the full subdivision. This is the [0:32:52] area that has been constructed already. This is the area in question that they [0:32:58] want to rezone and take out of the PUD and just own, sorry, to regular R2. [0:33:06] There's one condition from the PUD that is remaining as a condition of this [0:33:13] rezone request. The condition is that the first five lots on the southeast corner, [0:33:18] both north and west, have required 10,000 square foot minimum lot size to allow [0:33:23] Now for a transition between the R1 variable zone to the southeast and the subdivisions [0:33:28] R2 zone. [0:33:30] The applicant is aware of this condition and agrees with it. [0:33:34] Right down here, I can barely see it up there, I apologize. [0:33:40] These lots down here, I highlighted them in blue. [0:33:44] These are the larger lots in question that would remain 10,000, a minimum of 10,000 square [0:33:51] versus the 6,000 square feet for a single family dwelling in the R2 zone. [0:33:57] If the council approves the rezone request, the developer will be entitled to replant the [0:34:03] property to R2 zoning standards. [0:34:06] This property is designated as town neighborhood for the comprehensive plan. [0:34:11] Staff has concluded that removing the PUD and following the zoning standards is a good use [0:34:15] of the land and will not have any adverse effects on the surrounding areas. [0:34:20] I have the applicant here to give his presentation and I will stand for any questions. [0:34:29] Any questions for Tali right now? [0:34:32] I have one that I'm Mary. [0:34:34] Hey Kelly, so what's the reasoning behind maintaining those for 10,000 square feet? [0:34:39] It's for a transition. [0:34:41] Let me go back. [0:34:42] I just wanted to make sure I was. [0:34:43] Yeah, let's go back up here. [0:34:45] This shows it better. [0:34:46] So it's lots in this corner down here. [0:34:49] That would have to remain 10,000 square feet to help as a transition between this mean all R2 and [0:34:57] This over here, okay, which is our one. I just want to confirm understanding. Thank you. Okay. No problem [0:35:03] You anybody else? I'm a members of council. My name is David Tebow with the EHM engineers [0:35:21] Located at 621 North College Road and representing some N's partners this evening in their request for rezone [0:35:26] I think Kelly did a great job, but to give you a little bit of background, our office [0:35:31] has been working on this project for close to two decades now, just over. [0:35:36] And as we met with the city staff on subsequent phasing, Ellie, could we go to the other map [0:35:40] that you just had? [0:35:45] As we looked at moving forward with subsequent phasing, we discussed with the city how not [0:35:50] only the city code has changed in the intervening 20 years, put the need for parks and the desire [0:35:56] for parks to be better managed and located by the parks department has been expressed and [0:36:01] some of the requirements of the PUD had already been satisfied. [0:36:04] And so we determined together that requesting to rezone from the PUD to straight R2 would [0:36:13] satisfy a lot of those requirements and permit us to replant a portion of that dedicated park [0:36:21] land up in the northeast corner of the project so that we could capture some additional density [0:36:25] there and also maintain the stormwater drainage. [0:36:30] So the developer, I believe to answer Council Member Stone's question had met early on with [0:36:38] a neighboring property owner who owns and maintains the ground to the south. [0:36:43] He has a pasture there and would like to see larger sized lots. [0:36:46] We don't have any objection to that necessarily. [0:36:48] We would want to have all of this property zoned R2 and follow the R2 zoning requirements [0:36:54] and development standards in sub-suction phases [0:36:56] of the subdivision process. [0:36:58] So I don't have any other information to provide you [0:37:01] unless you have specific questions. [0:37:02] I will stand for questioning. [0:37:04] Any questions for the applicant? [0:37:11] Thank you. [0:37:12] Thank you. [0:37:15] Hey, given that, I will now open up the public hearing [0:37:19] if there's anybody in the audience that wishes [0:37:22] to address City Council on this particular item. [0:37:27] Please step up to podium state your name and your address, [0:37:31] and you will have two minutes to comment. [0:37:35] So anybody here that wishes to come down? [0:37:39] Announce, sir. [0:37:44] Good evening. [0:37:45] My name is Dan Corning. [0:37:46] I live at 2955 East 3600 North, which is adjacent right here [0:37:52] with this project. [0:37:54] I'd like to make a couple of comments. [0:37:57] When this was initially worked through, [0:37:59] It was expressed very important by the residents along Anderson Lane that those lots on the [0:38:07] south edge remain large, so potentially not decrease the value of some very nice homes [0:38:15] along there. [0:38:16] So I'd like to bring that up. [0:38:20] Also, I assume that with the, not the park, you want to put more houses there. [0:38:29] So we're talking 3.3 acres at 7 per acre, so we're talking 20 to 25, perhaps more units [0:38:38] there. [0:38:39] So the land is from Harrison to the east is downhill, and there's no sewer that's down [0:38:48] under Blue Lakes Boulevard north or anything down that way. [0:38:52] The sewer has to come up to Harrison to go north to the... [0:38:57] So this area down here, the sewage is going to have to be pumped uphill, correct, there's [0:39:03] a sewage pumping plant. [0:39:06] So if we increase the number of units there, then there may be a necessary increase in [0:39:12] pump size or pipeline, something such as that to deal with the additional units. [0:39:22] There's 447 units in this whole area, and the traffic dumps out onto 3600 North there [0:39:31] in three locations. [0:39:33] One right next to Skyland Trailer Park, Harrison, and then another, a little further east down [0:39:40] like across from Briarwood. [0:39:44] So we're dumping 447s house holes with maybe 1,000 cars into this half mile on 3,600 North. [0:39:56] So I think it's very important that we think about the traffic and make sure we have all [0:40:00] the traffic lights and the luminaries. [0:40:04] So this will be an awful lot of starter homes, it will be an awful lot of children crossing [0:40:09] 3,600 North to go to the middle school. [0:40:12] I think we need to think about these children and cross them to the street and I don't know [0:40:20] what specific plans have been put in for the traffic control but the traffic's already [0:40:25] increased terribly on that street. [0:40:28] I believe there's a traffic. [0:40:29] Your time here two minutes is up. [0:40:32] Thank you. [0:40:35] Is there anybody else that wishes to address City Council on this particular change? [0:40:43] Do you know when is there any, do you have any comments, Dave, to address his concerns? [0:40:51] Thank you, Mayor. [0:40:52] I'll try to just address each of them there. [0:40:55] So obviously, I mentioned already the Southern Southeastern Corner, we'll try to keep those [0:40:59] long sizes at that 10,000 or greater square feet, which compared to the R2 zoning requirements [0:41:05] as a 30% increase, 10,000 versus 7,000 as a minimum. [0:41:10] With regard to sewer, we're working with your city staff on lift station design that's been submitted. [0:41:15] Similarly with the traffic, we're building these roads and street networks to your standards. [0:41:20] So if you look at the west side of the intersection of 3600 south road and Harrison Street, [0:41:27] you'll notice that it's wide. [0:41:29] It's your 78 foot collector arterial size street width. [0:41:33] As we develop on with this project, we'll be wide in our frontage, which is typical with our developments. [0:41:39] elements. Similarly with traffic, you know, we've made every effort to mitigate the traffic. [0:41:46] There's multiple entrances in and out for emergency vehicles. So I think those were some [0:41:51] of the concerns and we are following your policies and the recommendations of your engineering [0:41:55] department throughout the development of this project. I have to look, I have a very small [0:42:01] printed copy, but I think that the density actually, there was 447 lots on about 111 acres. [0:42:08] I think if you look in your package, [0:42:10] you can zoom in a little better than I could. [0:42:12] So the overall density is about four lots per acre [0:42:15] that we're yielding with this project. [0:42:17] So pretty standard from my point of view. [0:42:20] So hopefully that helps answer Mr. Coring's questions there. [0:42:25] Thank you. [0:42:29] Okay, I will then close the public hearing [0:42:41] and then open it up for council discussion. [0:42:45] Just read. [0:42:46] Can we have somebody just maybe touch on the traffic concern [0:42:49] that we have there? [0:42:54] Yeah, if we're talking size of roadways, [0:42:56] we get the size of roadways, as Stays mentioned, [0:42:58] with the plat. [0:42:59] So rezoning the property, rezoning the property [0:43:01] is the first step, then we'll go through the platting process [0:43:03] for a preliminary and final. [0:43:05] That is when the city engineer requires roads [0:43:08] to be a certain width based on the master transportation [0:43:11] plan. [0:43:12] Most of those roads in that south area [0:43:13] are not at capacity currently per their design standard. [0:43:18] Also, South Hills Road and Harrison is a collector [0:43:21] in arterial intersections, so it does qualify [0:43:24] to have a traffic signal in the future [0:43:26] paid for through the impact fee program, [0:43:28] which every house pays a portion or an amount. [0:43:33] So I don't know if that answered directly. [0:43:34] No, it didn't, that was pretty much it. [0:43:36] That's perfect, thank you. [0:43:39] Any other questions or comments? [0:43:44] So basically we're looking at a zoning district change [0:43:48] from R2, PUD to just R2. [0:43:51] And there is a comparison chart in here that just shows the difference if there's any questions on that. [0:43:59] We'll need to do we need to put in there the the five lots on the southeast corner in that motion as well as as a condition. [0:44:10] It's already on there. [0:44:11] It's part of it. [0:44:12] So we're just we're just approving. [0:44:13] It has presented. [0:44:14] Yeah. [0:44:17] Do you want to go ahead and make a motion? [0:44:19] I'll make the motion. [0:44:20] Okay. [0:44:20] I'd move to approve the zoning district change from R2PUD to R2 for approximately 68 acres [0:44:30] located south of South Hills Road and east of Harrison Street. [0:44:35] Thank you. [0:44:36] Spencer Cutler. [0:44:37] I second and I'd like to add a comment that as presented it's five lots going north and [0:44:44] west. [0:44:45] So it's a total of 10 lots as presented. [0:44:49] It's been moved in motion by Jason Brown, seconded by Spencer Cutler to approve the zoning district [0:44:58] change from R2PUD to R2 for approximately 68 acres located south of South Hills Road [0:45:06] and east of Harrison Street, south on behalf of Sundance Partners. Any further discussion? [0:45:16] Amy Roll call vote please. [0:45:20] Mr. Cutler, Grace and Stone, Sherry Bulmer, Ruth Pierce, Chris Reed, Craig Hawkins, and Jason Brown. [0:45:29] Thank you. Motion passes seven to zero. [0:45:32] Okay. Next is an action item. Is it you, Kelly, still a request for zoning district change from [0:45:40] Are you swapping C1 PUD to C1 on property located at 1-8-222-2-2-2-2-2-2-2-2-8 [0:45:48] Who likes boulevard north care of EHM? [0:45:52] Engineers on behalf of Chasewood LLC [0:45:55] We have Jonathan's been love. We had to pinch it a few different things around [0:46:02] This property [0:46:04] lovingly named by most people in this town as the Albertsons Hole, as I've been told, [0:46:08] is what we're talking about today. It's the property right next to Blue Lakes. [0:46:12] It extends past what is called Ash Street all the way over to Elm. [0:46:16] It is the entirety of the property that was originally owned by Albertsons. It has been acquired [0:46:20] by Emorensen and he is the developer that is also [0:46:24] responsible for the development of the five points that Northeast [0:46:28] these who barn Jimmy John's that section as well as the Carl's Jr. and items going [0:46:35] north and go through the history but honestly it's been some time since early [0:46:41] 2000s and really we're here to remove the PUD and go to a straight C1 zone. We are [0:46:47] seeing this as we've talked about in other meetings we're seeing this happen [0:46:52] more often where an agreement took place 20 plus years ago the development [0:46:56] progressed in some parts or didn't progress at all in other parts, and it is [0:47:00] getting increasingly difficult to satisfy those original requirements from [0:47:05] 25 years ago. But we have a robust C1 zoning code that requires certain things [0:47:10] but allows for development to occur. That's what we're doing today, is to straight [0:47:16] C1 zone that encompasses all of those. The zoning map shows that Ash Street, [0:47:22] Albertsons PUD here, which is this lighter color that's in blue. The [0:47:26] surrounding area to the north and west is all C1. You get into some R4 over here [0:47:31] which is the housing authority property that's east of Elm and there's some other [0:47:38] properties to the north that are commercial. The future land use map has [0:47:41] all of this as a mixed use. Down here along Addison is the hip route commercial [0:47:46] and then you get to downtown to the east of that. Most of it would all be town [0:47:50] neighborhood. These are not exact lines on the map. Therefore general guidelines the [0:47:55] The council makes a decision on when they're rezoning property. [0:47:59] And as far as what it complies, you just need to refer to the map. [0:48:03] This is the original development agreement. [0:48:06] Essentially, if they were to build this, [0:48:08] they literally would have to build an Albertsons. [0:48:10] They couldn't do anything else with the property, [0:48:12] because that's what this plan shows, [0:48:13] is just an Albertsons store with a couple other shops. [0:48:18] As all of us know, some of that Albertsons is not moving. [0:48:22] They're not going to rebuild the stores that they've sold it. [0:48:24] And so this person simply wants to redo this [0:48:27] master plan, essentially just go to straight C1. Here's some street views, here's the old [0:48:34] literally over here, when you're looking north, looking south, it's here on the left, [0:48:39] looking east straight at it, this would have been the entrance to the store that was going [0:48:42] to sit in the back, and this is what's across the street here. Here's just a closer view [0:48:49] of basically all of the parcels and the reason for the request. I don't believe there's any [0:48:54] more items we need to see as far as their request and I will go back to stick with this map and we [0:49:05] have no additional conditions you will see an ordinance if you so wish to do this and I will stand [0:49:10] for any questions great any questions for Jonathan on this longtime piece of property okay the applicant [0:49:22] is here the representative welcome Dave in Madam Mayor [0:49:27] there's the council I'm still Dave Tebow at EH and 621 North College I'm [0:49:32] representing Chase with this evening for this request Kevin Mortensen's been [0:49:36] involved with Albertsons throughout the duration I think what I'd add to [0:49:41] Jonathan's presentation is really the Ash Street PUD was developed specific to [0:49:46] a grocery store and Albertsons being that grocery store so for the space of [0:49:50] several decades. That's been the intent. It's been zoned very, very specifically [0:49:55] with that agreement to allow grocery store and pretty much nothing else. So [0:49:59] fast-forward to today. Kevin has actually, he's in, he's acquired a [0:50:05] purchase and sales agreement so he's not yet the owner in fee simple but he's [0:50:10] hopeful that this is part of his due diligence to clean up the zoning to allow [0:50:15] something other than a grocery store to be built here. As we met the staff and [0:50:19] evaluated through our office. We believe the C1 zone is appropriate along the [0:50:23] Lakes Boulevard and would be commensurate with other uses that have been permitted [0:50:29] both north-south and west of this property. Compatibility, the housing [0:50:34] companies to the east with multifamily dwelling units there, still separated by [0:50:39] the road right away which is Elm. So there is some separation distances we go [0:50:44] back to residential away from the C-1 that would be more localized to Blue Lakes Boulevard. [0:50:53] That's our request this evening. [0:50:54] Straight C-1, it's time to move on. [0:50:55] The plan hasn't worked for a couple of decades and we don't think the dollars are going to [0:51:00] be spent. [0:51:01] Elbert, yeah, Elbert since did enter into an acquisition that blew up last week if you [0:51:06] follow that kind of news. [0:51:08] So maybe the acquisition isn't going to move forward, but regardless, Mr. Mortensen has [0:51:13] has been involved with the City of Twin developing the Jimmy John's the boot barn, all of them [0:51:18] in that strip mall, the Carl's Jr. And as he's able, he'd like to continue just working [0:51:24] on this project. So that's a request for you. I'd stand for any questions. [0:51:28] Thank you, Dave. Any questions for Dave on this particular item? [0:51:32] Thank you. Thank you. Okay. I'm going to open up the public [0:51:41] hearing on this particular item if there's anybody in the audience that wishes to [0:51:46] address city council ask any questions on this zoning district change from C1 [0:51:52] PUD to C1 please step up to the podium okay see no one I will close the public [0:52:05] hearing council wishes I think it's straightforward and something [0:52:13] needs has been needed to be done for a long time. [0:52:15] So I'm certainly in favor of it. [0:52:17] Thank you, Chris Reed. [0:52:19] Ready to make a motion of perfect. [0:52:21] I move that we approve the zoning district change [0:52:24] from C1PUD to C1 on property located at 182, 212, and 228 [0:52:30] Blue Lakes Boulevard, North K curve, [0:52:33] the H and engineers, Inc. on behalf of Chasewood LLC. [0:52:37] Thank you, Sherry Vomer. [0:52:38] I will second. [0:52:40] Thank you, motion by Chris Reed. [0:52:41] seconded by Sherry Vollmer to approve the zoning district change from C1PUD to C1 on property [0:52:49] located at 18212 and 228 Blue Lakes Boulevard North. Amy Rollcoveau please. [0:52:58] Grayson Stone yes Sherry Vollmer yes Ruth Pierce yes Chris Reed yes [0:53:06] Greg Hawkins, Jason Brown, Ann Spencer-Kutler. [0:53:10] Yes. [0:53:11] Thank you. [0:53:12] Motion passes 7-0. [0:53:14] Thank you, everyone. [0:53:17] That concludes our last meeting of the year, last vote of the year. [0:53:21] Merry Christmas and Happy New Year to everyone. [0:53:24] Merry Christmas.