Oversight Archive: City Council meeting, 2025-01-06, recording 1 (started 17:09) Machine transcript (faster-whisper base.en), not checked word for word; the Pledge of Allegiance is shown in its standard wording. The recording is the record. Times are time into the recording. Passages with private details are muted in the audio and marked here. The audio on the page below was re-encoded by software from the video the agency posted. Check any passage against that audio before relying on it. Page: https://oversightarchive.org/twin-falls-id/meetings/2025-01-06/ [0:00:00] Yeah, they're traffic signal boxes and if you drive around town, there's several locations [0:00:05] and they look fantastic. [0:00:06] They really have seen most of them. [0:00:07] Yeah, they're canceling the meeting on January 20th, it is Martin Luther King Day. [0:00:13] Normally our meeting would be following Tuesday, but with the Association of Idaho City's [0:00:20] events that week, it might get too good to get the data. [0:00:26] Thank you. [0:00:28] Okay, so we'll move on to public hearings. [0:00:32] I will read the public hearing rules. [0:00:36] The council will follow these steps for each request list. [0:00:39] Additional height of 75, [0:00:41] so approved of additional building height [0:00:44] for two other silos on the subject property. [0:00:47] And then in August of 2021, [0:00:49] the city council approved another additional height permit [0:00:53] for an additional silo. [0:00:55] It's just shown that it goes into Washington Street South. [0:00:58] Here's the Glamia property. [0:01:01] This shows the zoning, which is right here. [0:01:06] It is M2, you can see we've had a lot of properties, [0:01:10] a few properties in this area be annexed in recently. [0:01:13] And this area on this side of Washington [0:01:16] is generally heavy manufacturing. [0:01:20] It is part of the industrial category [0:01:25] for the future land use map. [0:01:28] Here are some street views. [0:01:30] This is looking north on Washington. [0:01:36] This one's looking south on Washington. [0:01:38] Here is the property to the right. [0:01:43] This is looking west, sorry, thank you, [0:01:50] to the facility and you can see the location [0:01:52] of the silos as far back here and on the property. [0:01:57] And then here is just a rendering of what the additional silos [0:02:01] would look like next to the ones that are there. [0:02:06] Here is the existing, there's four silos now. [0:02:10] Oh no, there's three silos now, sorry. [0:02:14] And then silo nine would be the same height as silo eight, [0:02:18] that was approved, I think in 2021. [0:02:21] And then they want to leave room to build another one, [0:02:24] which would be up to the same height. [0:02:28] Again, this shows from Washington Street, [0:02:30] South, how far back the silos are located [0:02:33] and the proposed location of the silos. [0:02:38] And then those are the minutes. [0:02:40] So the applicant is here to give their presentation, [0:02:44] and I will stand for any questions. [0:02:49] Any questions for Kelly at this point in time? [0:02:53] Okay, thank you. [0:03:00] Good evening, my name's Kim Jasper, [0:03:02] I'm the project engineer for this project. [0:03:06] Thanks, Kelly, for doing that great. [0:03:07] I don't have much additional, [0:03:09] one clarification on the elevation is, [0:03:15] for the two silos, it would be back-to-back. [0:03:17] So this elevation look is looking west, [0:03:20] And so the second silo would go behind nine as silo, [0:03:24] silo 10, and there's other silos behind these two, [0:03:29] looking at the elevation, or the plan view, [0:03:35] looking from Washington Street as what that elevation's [0:03:37] looking at, and you see the three existing, [0:03:40] and then the additional silo as well. [0:03:42] So looking for the request or approval of the, [0:03:46] especially as part of the added height. [0:03:51] Thank you. [0:03:52] Any questions for Kim? [0:03:56] Yes, Mayor. [0:03:57] Yes. [0:03:58] When I'm reading, it's the request just to add one additional silo, or is this request [0:04:03] for one now and possibly a second one in the future? [0:04:06] For two silos. [0:04:08] We have plans for one and looking to do plans for the second one. [0:04:14] Thank you. [0:04:15] Yep. [0:04:17] Any other questions for Kim? [0:04:18] Okay. [0:04:22] Thank you. [0:04:23] Next, I will open up the public hearing. [0:04:28] If there's anybody in the audience that wishes to comment on this particular item, please come up to the podium. [0:04:35] Okay, you see no one. Anything additional, either one of you? Okay. Then I will close the public hearing. [0:04:50] And Council, Chris Reed. [0:04:54] Makes sense. It's not a nicer. [0:05:00] Clamby has always been a good partner with the city, with the community. [0:05:04] So I don't have a problem. There's not other comments. I'll make the motion. [0:05:08] I think Grayson, how to come in? [0:05:09] Grayson? [0:05:10] Oh, I'm in a minute. [0:05:11] I'm just prepared to second. [0:05:13] OK. [0:05:13] And read. [0:05:14] All right. [0:05:15] Go ahead. [0:05:16] Move to approve the request to allow additional building [0:05:20] height for new solos, silos, 02, up to 75 feet. [0:05:26] I'm properly located at 236 Washington Street, South. [0:05:34] Grayson, so I will second the motion. [0:05:36] Thank you. [0:05:39] Do you want to add the condition of the site plan amendments as presented? [0:05:46] Okay. [0:05:47] That's presented works. [0:05:48] Okay. [0:05:49] Motion by Chris Reed, seconded by Grayson Stone to approve, allow the additional building [0:05:56] high for two new silos up to 75 feet on property located at 236 Washington Street, [0:06:03] South Caro Kim Jasper on behalf of Glamby and Nutritionals as presented. [0:06:08] Any further discussion? [0:06:12] Rachel Roquevo, please. [0:06:14] Senator Cutler? [0:06:15] Yes. [0:06:16] Harry Bulmer? [0:06:17] Yes. [0:06:18] Grace and Stone? [0:06:19] Yes. [0:06:20] Ruth Pierce? [0:06:21] Yes. [0:06:22] Grace Reed? [0:06:23] Yes. [0:06:24] Grace Hawkins? [0:06:25] Yes. [0:06:26] Yes. [0:06:27] Yes. [0:06:28] Thank you. [0:06:29] Motion passes 7-0. [0:06:30] Next, action item, a request to City Council for a zoning development agreement amendment [0:06:34] who allow additional building on property located [0:06:37] at one, three, two, Falls Avenue West, [0:06:40] here of Jared Nielsen on behalf of Falls Crossing, [0:06:44] and we have a senior city planner, Will Laver. [0:06:47] Welcome, Will. [0:06:50] Will or William is great. [0:06:51] Thank you, Madam Mayor, and good evening. [0:06:55] Today we have a PUD amendment for Campus Park PUD. [0:07:00] This PUD was originally created. [0:07:05] Let me find the date is escaping my mind. [0:07:17] So I apologize that. [0:07:18] It is on 7.27 acres. [0:07:20] The location is on the intersection of Washington Street, [0:07:25] North and Falls Avenue West, just west of CSI parking lot, [0:07:30] to the south of fall off. [0:07:34] to the south of the proposed project across Falls Avenue West is a surgery [0:07:41] center there is apartment complexes just to the west of that surgery center if [0:07:47] you look kitty corner there's a bank so this is a very commercial intersection [0:07:52] just to the north is your is pretty heavily single family residential and [0:07:58] same with to the west. I'm looking at the zoning. We currently have this PUD in [0:08:06] place. The base zoning is R6, so it's our highest density for residential. The zoning [0:08:16] to surrounding it is just to the north and west is our R4 district, so it allows [0:08:20] up to four plexes with special use permits by right. It allows duplexes [0:08:26] And then just to the south, I believe this map is out of date, or the map showing that [0:08:39] it's R4 as well. [0:08:42] Our future land use map designates the eastern half of this property as neighborhood commercial, [0:08:53] is highway oriented large formatting developments and then to the west of the west half of the [0:09:04] property is our town neighborhood style. This line is really just a guide so it's up [0:09:13] to really your interpretation of if that makes sense or not. However the proposed development [0:09:19] is a residential to do that. [0:09:24] There's a little closer up of the aero view. [0:09:30] And then looking at Street View, this top one [0:09:36] is looking north. [0:09:37] So on your right side of the screen is CSI. [0:09:42] Left side of the screen is the proposed, [0:09:45] or the current PUD with the proposed amendment [0:09:48] that the proposed amendment would go just behind these trees [0:09:51] right around here. [0:09:55] And this is at the corner as well, looking west on Falls Avenue West. [0:10:05] This is the south, so you can see the banks over here and the surgery centers over here. [0:10:12] And this is looking east, so behind us would be proposed, just so we can see a little there. [0:10:28] Currently the master plan only allows for these residential apartments with the clubhouse. [0:10:36] So the applicant is wanting to do is to add additional units onto this master plan. [0:10:47] It would allow for 8,000 square foot footprint. [0:10:55] The density is not being proposed to change. [0:10:57] The parking ratio is not being proposed to change. [0:11:01] The height limits, the architectural drawings are not being proposed to change. [0:11:06] What is going before you today is is it possible if they meet all these other requirements, [0:11:12] all the other requirements in the current PUD, all the other requirements of the base zoning and [0:11:17] building code if they can have this building here. This is the floor plan. It's already the floor plan [0:11:27] that's in the PUD. It's just reaffirming that this is the floor plans that are going to be there [0:11:32] And then here are the elevations. [0:11:36] These elevations are also in the peak current PUD as well. [0:11:39] This is just to reaffirm. [0:11:40] But yes, it's what they want to keep, the same look, feel, [0:11:44] and context. [0:11:48] I'll go back to this to reiterate that what is being asked is, [0:11:54] can they apply for a billion permit for 8,000 square feet [0:11:57] on this property? [0:11:59] Not a reduction in anything else or a change in anything else. [0:12:03] But that helps to answer any questions. [0:12:07] So Will, you're basically saying that gray square, if you scroll down to the next sheet, [0:12:14] the proposed replacement for that is the very right? [0:12:19] Yes, this would be the outline of it, and if you see that this two bedroom right here [0:12:26] would be this, to zoom down. [0:12:28] Yes, this outline. [0:12:30] Those? [0:12:31] The same square footage as the clubhouse, so to speak. [0:12:36] Club House so to speak but the other residential buildings I thought that was [0:12:40] the clubhouse right okay okay any other questions for will yes Chris but but [0:12:53] ultimately understanding what you said it meets all the city's requirements [0:12:58] for parking and set everything else is fine even with this addition increasing [0:13:03] Yes, that's correct. At least for preliminary review, we will get in-depth review and make sure that they get [0:13:11] they follow all the other amendments of the PUD, all the other PUD requirements and all the other city code requirements, [0:13:18] but still have to be enforced. This is the only thing that they're asking for at this time. [0:13:22] Okay. Thank you. Thank you. Well, any other questions for Will? Okay. Do we have the applicant here? [0:13:32] Yes, we have Jared Nielsen, the applicant. [0:13:34] Perfect, welcome, Jared. [0:13:41] Thank you, Will. [0:13:45] Main reason why we are doing this [0:13:47] as we start building the first buildings, [0:13:50] we found we needed to add more into the units. [0:13:54] So the other units actually have [0:13:59] laundry and other services built into the units [0:14:02] and stuff having to go to the clubhouse. [0:14:03] So the density reduced as we changed [0:14:06] and added more amenities into the units, [0:14:10] so to speak and so the density has reduced substantially [0:14:16] because of that and that's why if we had this building, [0:14:19] we're still meeting the parking requirements [0:14:22] and the density requirements. [0:14:26] We just found providing a little nicer product [0:14:28] in the later phases was actually helping. [0:14:31] Okay, any questions for the applicant? [0:14:39] Okay, thank you. [0:14:40] Thank you. [0:14:42] So I will open up the public hearing [0:14:45] If there's anybody in the audience that wishes to address City Council on this particular item, [0:14:50] please step up to the podium. [0:15:00] Seeing no one, I will close the public hearing. [0:15:03] I ask for any comments, any comments from either one of you before I close the public hearing. [0:15:10] Okay. Thank you. I'll close the public hearing. [0:15:13] Grayson. [0:15:15] I'm prepared to make a motion. There's no other conversation. [0:15:19] Any discussion, questions? Anybody? Go ahead. [0:15:23] Thank you, Madam Mayor. [0:15:24] I make motion to approve the request [0:15:26] to City Council for a Zoning Development Agreement Amendment [0:15:28] to allow an additional building on property located at 132. [0:15:33] All's Avenue, West, Carrot, Nielsen, [0:15:34] on behalf of Falls Crossing, Key Z24-014 [0:15:40] with staff recommendations. [0:15:42] Thank you, Jason Brown. [0:15:44] I second. [0:15:45] Thank you, motion by Grace and Stone, [0:15:47] seconded by Jason Brown to approve [0:15:49] the Zoning Development Agreement Amendment [0:15:52] to allow an additional building on property located at 1-3-2, [0:15:56] Falls Avenue West, Cara of Jared Nielsen [0:15:59] on behalf of Fall Crossing, with staff recommendations. [0:16:05] Rachel Roquevo, please. [0:16:07] Spencer Cutler. [0:16:08] Yes. [0:16:09] Grayson Stone. [0:16:10] Yes. [0:16:11] Sherry Bulmer. [0:16:12] Yes. [0:16:12] Jason Brown. [0:16:13] Yes. [0:16:14] Chris Reed. [0:16:15] Yes. [0:16:16] And Ruth Pierce. [0:16:17] Yes. [0:16:18] Thank you. [0:16:19] Motion passes 7-0. [0:16:20] Thank you. [0:16:22] Okay, next action item, request to city council [0:16:26] for a zoning district change from R4 to C1, [0:16:30] on property located at 929 Washington Street South, [0:16:34] care of the city of Twin Falls, and will is back. [0:16:48] So, at the corner of Washington Street South, [0:16:52] and the Orchard Drive West, [0:16:55] it's right on where my pointer is, [0:16:57] I apologize it is zoomed out, so it's kind of hard to see. [0:17:00] The blue rectangle is a city owned property, [0:17:03] which is the old fire station, number two, I believe. [0:17:08] Great, great, thank you. [0:17:12] This old fire station is currently re-zoned, [0:17:18] or zoned, has a R4 zoning district. [0:17:22] When we built the new fire station three, [0:17:27] the city doesn't need the property anymore, [0:17:30] and so if we utilized it, [0:17:33] It would be hard to transform that into a residential property. [0:17:39] So the property is a commercial property. [0:17:42] It's been built as a commercial property. [0:17:44] Reason it was allowed to be the fire station [0:17:48] was through a special use permit way back in the day. [0:17:52] And so it would be weird to sell or to have a commercial property [0:18:01] zone does residential that can only be used as a residential property and so let [0:18:07] me get through a little bit of the details but then I'll continue the narrative on [0:18:13] this but right now the orchard park ZDA is a has a base zone of C1 so it's a [0:18:25] commercial park that that's where the Swenson's building is there was just [0:18:31] to prove the special use permit for an auto shop just south of here to the west side is [0:18:37] heavily is C1 where you have the family dollar and then you have some shell buildings we [0:18:45] don't know the tenants yet but there's some commercial shell buildings that were built [0:18:49] just right here on the northwest corner is a gas station and then on the if you go just [0:19:00] directly north across Portrait. You have your single family residents. A future land use map [0:19:08] causes this whole area to be what we were designated as mixed use. It basically is saying we don't [0:19:17] we know that these are big heavy areas. We want to mix up uses here. We want retail. We want office. [0:19:25] We want apartments, we want vertical mixed-use buildings here. [0:19:31] So it really gives a lot of leanings. [0:19:34] Our ultimate mixed-use zoning designation is our C1 designation, [0:19:40] because it allows for all the things that I just described there. [0:19:43] It allows for more residential density, it allows for retail office, [0:19:49] it allows for restaurant, it allows for all those heavy commercial penters. [0:19:55] give a little bit more context. This is looking north. The subject property is, I [0:20:03] guess, directly to the right of east. I just looking west, thank you. I'm looking [0:20:14] west so it's directly left side right here. And we have the gas station. This is [0:20:23] vacant land but there's the shell buildings just over here and then the [0:20:26] family dollars. On this the bottom picture this is the subject's fire station that [0:20:35] we're looking at to rezone. This is the fire station where rezone these are the [0:20:43] single family houses to go through a little bit more zoning. Our floor is really [0:20:59] residential. The max you can get is a fourplex on each fly and you have to go [0:21:05] through especially use permits to get it. If you want to just build something [0:21:08] by right then you would have to do a duplex in that commercial allows for all [0:21:15] these other girls slowly. I guess the difference really being besides the [0:21:30] uses you get the front yard setback you actually have an increased front yard [0:21:35] setback in C1 zone but you have a reduced setback on the rear and side for [0:21:40] those building height and instead of 35 feet it would go up to 50 feet. Otherwise [0:21:50] with the intersections of orchard and Washington being major roads. City staff [0:22:05] feels it's it's a optimal place to have a C-1 commercial entity with that I'll [0:22:13] stand for any questions. Any questions for Will on this particular item and since [0:22:23] we're the applicant. We are the applicants so I'll turn over to Mitch if he wants to [0:22:27] had any why or he can just say dido. [0:22:30] What I would suggest is just briefly that our intent is to start the process to sell this property [0:22:39] as soon as this process is finished. [0:22:43] The reason I made the application to the planning department was again a lot of stuff that Will said [0:22:49] but it opens up the opportunities to sell this to a larger group of people than whoever would buy an R4 property [0:22:56] property, and jives with the future landage plan, so it makes a lot of sense to do this. [0:23:01] I think it's better for the city if we do this as well. [0:23:04] Perfect. [0:23:06] Any questions for Mitch on that? [0:23:11] Okay. [0:23:12] Then we'll open up the public hearing. [0:23:16] Is there anybody in the audience that wishes to address City Council on this particular [0:23:21] issue? [0:23:22] Please come down. [0:23:27] Hey, seeing no one, anything to add? [0:23:31] No. [0:23:32] Okay, then I will close the public hearing [0:23:35] and turn it over to council. [0:23:38] Grayson Stone. [0:23:39] Thank you, Madam Mayor. [0:23:40] Two things, one, I just want to say thanks to staff. [0:23:43] That land use comparison chart [0:23:44] that you guys are included in our staff reports, [0:23:46] is pretty awesome. [0:23:47] So, appreciate your guys' efforts on that. [0:23:50] It makes it really handy. [0:23:52] Coming from a position of selling commercial development land, [0:23:57] that allocation zone absolutely makes it more valuable, [0:24:00] converting it over to C1, just from our buying pool, [0:24:03] But other than that, I'm prepared to make a motion. [0:24:06] Any other discussion? [0:24:09] Go ahead, Grayson. [0:24:10] Thank you, Madam Mayor. [0:24:11] I make a motion to approve the request to see Council [0:24:14] for Zoning District change from R4 to C1 [0:24:16] on property located at 929 Washington Street, South. [0:24:20] Care of the city of Twin Falls, PZ24-0102. [0:24:25] Thank you, Craig Hawkins. [0:24:26] I'd like to second that. [0:24:28] Thank you, motion by Grayson Stone, second by Craig Hawkins [0:24:33] to approve the zoning district change from R4 to C1 [0:24:37] property located at 929 Washington Street, [0:24:40] South, care of the city of Twin Falls. [0:24:44] Any further discussion? [0:24:46] Rachel Roel, call vote please. [0:24:48] Grace Reed. [0:24:49] Yes. [0:24:50] Grace Hawkins. [0:24:51] Jason Brown. [0:24:52] Yes. [0:24:53] Spencer Cutler. [0:24:53] Yes. [0:24:54] Gary Palmer. [0:24:55] Yes. [0:24:56] Grace and Stone. [0:24:57] Yes. [0:24:58] And Ruth Pierce. [0:24:59] Yes. [0:25:00] Thank you. [0:25:01] Motion passes 7 to 0. [0:25:02] all the business we have tonight so thank you everybody for hanging in there and the meeting is [0:25:08] adjourned.