Oversight Archive: City Council meeting, 2025-01-27, recording 1 (started 16:59) Machine transcript (faster-whisper base.en), not checked word for word; the Pledge of Allegiance is shown in its standard wording. The recording is the record. Times are time into the recording. Passages with private details are muted in the audio and marked here. The audio on the page below was re-encoded by software from the video the agency posted. Check any passage against that audio before relying on it. Page: https://oversightarchive.org/twin-falls-id/meetings/2025-01-27/ [0:06:07] Good evening ladies and gentlemen and welcome to the January 27th, 2025 City Council meeting. [0:06:14] I want to confirm we have a quorum. [0:06:16] We have six members present in chambers tonight and Councilwoman Volmer is excused. [0:06:23] First item on the agenda is the Pledge of Allegiance. [0:06:25] If you wish to join me, please rise. [0:06:45] Thank you. [0:06:46] We have no proclamations tonight, so we move on to the consent calendar. [0:06:52] Council wishes. [0:06:53] Mayor would like to move that we accept the consent calendar as written. [0:06:58] Thank you. Do I have a second? I'll second. [0:07:00] Thank you. Motion by Craig Hawkins seconded by Chris Reed to approve the consent calendar as written. [0:07:08] Rachel Roquevo, please. Ruth Pierce. Yes. Chris Reed. Yes. Craig Hawkins. Yes. Jason Brown. Yes. Spencer Cutler. Yes. [0:07:16] increase in stone. Yes. Thank you. Motion passes six to zero. Okay. Moving on to items of consideration. Our first item is an action item. A request to adopt ordinance number 2025. [0:07:30] 0-1 or an amendment to the current Twin Falls City Code Title 3 Chapter 4 and we [0:07:38] have Brent Wright. Welcome Brent. Thank you Madam Mayor, members of council. Yes we [0:07:45] are here tonight to ask you to adopt an amendment to the current city code Title [0:07:52] 3 Chapter 4 also known as our pawn shops brokers and second-hand dealers [0:07:56] ordinance. If you recall just little history last year in February the City [0:08:04] Council directed staff to review our current city code and come back with some [0:08:12] recommendations and our last time this ordinance was reviewed was 2012. So as a [0:08:21] As a result of that, we had three separate public meetings and we tried to include all [0:08:28] of our current licensees under this ordinance as well as anybody else that we thought was [0:08:34] affected. [0:08:36] I also worked with the city attorney and came up with some proposed changes that you have [0:08:44] in front of you now. [0:08:45] You should have two different documents. [0:08:47] is a clean document with all of the changes incorporated and the second one [0:08:53] has all of the changes in red anything underlined is new language and [0:09:03] anything with a strike-through is gonna be removed. Essentially as a result of the [0:09:11] meetings and working with the city attorney I'm gonna kind of summarize these if [0:09:17] if that's okay, unless you want me to go through line by line. [0:09:19] But essentially we removed the requirement for any firearm [0:09:25] or firearm accessory to be applicable [0:09:28] and to be entered into our leads online system, [0:09:30] which is how we track items that are pawned. [0:09:34] We also added a section that under definitions [0:09:38] that says that this only applies specifically [0:09:42] to type two federal firearms license holders, [0:09:45] which we have a few gun brokers in town [0:09:47] that do not have Type 1 FFLs, Type 2s are specific to pawn jobs and firearms. [0:09:55] We added a specific definition of firearms and we took that straight from federal code [0:10:01] that the ATF defines guns as. [0:10:05] As far as the application process, we took away any fingerprint requirement. [0:10:11] We also took away criminal history checks. [0:10:15] That makes it a little easier for us. [0:10:19] We also took out the provisional license, and again on the criminal history side of things, [0:10:24] we're only going to perform a local background check and a state Idaho I-Courts check. [0:10:35] And then we added on page 5, in to paragraph C, you'll see that we, and that's where it [0:10:43] talks about the time frame that businesses are required to enter items that they take [0:10:48] into their possession into our system and we just added a voluntary component to [0:10:55] entering firearms on Lee's online and that's essentially the proposed changes so [0:11:04] again it takes away the requirement to enter anything that meets that firearms [0:11:10] definition and unless there's any questions before I go any further [0:11:14] any questions about the specific wording of those changes. Anybody have any [0:11:20] questions for Brad on this that he just went over I do my to marry so anything [0:11:27] with a tax stamp like pre-83 is still gonna have to go through the same [0:11:30] process I mean they're class two but a classroom require that I don't believe [0:11:37] so I don't believe those would apply either okay I'd have to defer that one [0:11:42] to the city attorney but I don't believe so I'm gonna ask him to come up here in [0:11:47] just a second. Any other questions for Grant? Okay so as I mentioned we had three public meetings [0:11:59] I do think I need to tell you that I have been in in email contact with one of our local [0:12:05] businesses today and they still have some concerns about some of the language in the ordinance [0:12:12] and and whether or not it complies with the Idaho Constitution and so I thought I would [0:12:19] to bring up City Attorney Bruce Castles [0:12:21] and to address those. [0:12:24] Thank you. [0:12:27] Welcome, Bruce. [0:12:28] Good evening, Madam Mayor, members of the Council. [0:12:31] First of all, Councilman Stone, to your question, [0:12:33] no, this doesn't affect those types of firearms. [0:12:37] This is essentially, they still have [0:12:39] to follow federal regulations, but they [0:12:42] will have no application to the city code, as far as that goes. [0:12:48] The question that we, the issue has been raised [0:12:51] is whether even having language in there [0:12:53] regarding the voluntary acceptance of information [0:12:57] for leads online meets constitutional muster. [0:13:00] Must I can tell you that idle constitution [0:13:03] prohibits the imposition of a gun registry? [0:13:06] And I believe that this is what we're talking about here. [0:13:08] There is no language or prohibition [0:13:10] on allowing the voluntary submission of that information. [0:13:14] Of course, the police department uses that simply [0:13:17] to check against stolen firearms that are reported. [0:13:21] I can tell you that we have had discussions [0:13:23] with the Attorney General's office, [0:13:25] and when we communicated to them that our potential code would [0:13:31] only allow for the voluntary submission [0:13:34] or that we would remove any language in terms of requiring [0:13:37] that it was their opinion to us that that met their satisfaction. [0:13:44] They believed that that would be just fine for us [0:13:46] to have a voluntary provision in our city code there. [0:13:50] So I just wanted to let you know. [0:13:52] Do you have any questions with respect to those issues? [0:13:55] Any questions on that? [0:13:57] For Bruce, doesn't it look like it? [0:14:00] Okay, thank you. [0:14:04] So, Brad, it looks like we could put this [0:14:10] on third and final today. [0:14:12] Correct. [0:14:12] Ordinance 2025-001. [0:14:17] Is there anything else you wanna add [0:14:19] before we have. [0:14:20] Unless you have any further questions for me. [0:14:22] Further questions? [0:14:28] Chris Reed. [0:14:29] Mayor, I move that we dispense with the reading rules [0:14:32] and put ordinance 2025-001 on third and final reading [0:14:38] by title only. [0:14:40] Thank you. [0:14:41] Do I have a second? [0:14:42] Spencer. [0:14:45] If there's a motion or I actually have a question I missed [0:14:49] earlier. [0:14:50] OK. [0:14:51] So do we have a second? [0:14:54] Thank you, motion by Chris Reed, seconded by Craig Hawkins to put ordinance number 2025 [0:15:01] on third and final reading by dispensing the reading rules and having a third and final [0:15:08] reading by title only. [0:15:09] Okay, Spencer, go ahead. [0:15:10] Public hearings before. [0:15:16] We talked about a lot and I was just asking a question either for the attorney or staff. [0:15:24] has this been publicized other than talking directly to like firearms dealers resellers brokers [0:15:32] what are the kind of public notification has been given for this if that makes sense [0:15:46] sorry councilman color we have not done any publications but we did include [0:15:54] all current license holders under this ordinance to include people other than the gun brokers [0:16:03] Thank you. Madam Mayor. Yes. Councilman, I know that this has also been a conversation [0:16:13] piece for some of us who have been on the morning radio show. It was a conversation [0:16:21] that I had today sharing that it would be on tonight's council agenda and it was part [0:16:27] of a dialogue that we had this evening as well. Thank you. Grace and Stowe? Thank you, Madam [0:16:33] I guess this is a question for you and City staff. [0:16:37] Is there a way that we could move this item down [0:16:41] so we could have a public hearing [0:16:43] and hear from our gun brokers and our own charges? [0:16:44] We can't change the agenda. [0:16:47] No, could we? [0:16:50] Type 1FFLs was a recommendation from them [0:16:53] as well as the firearms accessories component. [0:16:56] That was a direct input from some of the people affected. [0:17:01] In your professional opinion, [0:17:02] Do you feel like the adequate stakeholders [0:17:04] have had a seat at the table? [0:17:05] I do. [0:17:06] And that this is a consensus of those stakeholders? [0:17:09] With the exception that I provided when I had Bruce come up, [0:17:13] there is at least one business owner that believes [0:17:16] that we're still not in compliance with Idaho Constitution. [0:17:21] OK. [0:17:22] Thank you. [0:17:24] OK, so I would entertain a motion. [0:17:27] Pardon me? [0:17:28] Oh, read the title. [0:17:30] Usually we do the motion. [0:17:33] Ordinance number 2025-001, ordinance of the city council of the city of [0:17:39] 001. Thank you. Do I have a second Jason Brown? Second. Thank you. Motion by Chris Reed. Second [0:17:44] by Jason Brown to approve Ordinance 2025-001 for an amendment to the current Twin Falls [0:17:51] City Code Title III. Chapter four. Any further discussion? It's a request to approve the [0:18:01] Ranking of construction manager general contractor [0:18:05] candidates for the city pool remodel project and authorized staff to negotiate a contract with top ranked firm core construction and we have Mitch [0:18:14] Humboldt deputy city manager welcome Mitch [0:18:18] Thank you [0:18:19] As you'll recall we have some money in the budget this year [0:18:23] The fiscal 25 budget 1.2 million dollars to complete a remodel of the city pool [0:18:29] We have hired [0:18:31] Coal architects to work on that and they're well underway with those plans and while they're doing that [0:18:38] We would thought we'd proceed with hiring the CMGC to do the construction project [0:18:42] And so we formed a little committee of some staff members. It was six that [0:18:48] selected four to come and do interviews [0:18:52] Great contractors all four of them would good would be good [0:18:56] But when we did the ranking core construction came out on top and so [0:19:02] Actually, the full ranking is there and the staff report core is first, star, second. [0:19:07] The request tonight would be to have the council prove the ranking and authorize staff to proceed [0:19:13] with negotiations of a contract for a CMGC with core if we're unable to arrive at a price [0:19:21] and scope with them, then we would move on to number two, star, and so forth down through [0:19:26] the four. [0:19:27] I don't believe that will be necessary. [0:19:29] I think we'll get there with core. [0:19:31] Anyway, that's the short of it. So if you have any questions, I'm happy to answer them for you [0:19:36] Thank you. Any questions for me a child in this particular item [0:19:41] Jason I don't have any questions, but I'd be willing to make a motion if there are none [0:19:46] I'd say go ahead [0:19:47] I'd move to approve the [0:19:50] the request for the rankings of construction manager general contractor candidate for the city pool remodel project an [0:19:57] an authorized city staff to negotiate a contract with, with core construction. [0:20:02] Hey, Grayson. [0:20:06] Thank you, Madam Mayor. I'll second. [0:20:08] Thank you. Motion by Jason Brown. Seconded by Grayson Stone to approve the selection of the construction manager general contractor for the City Pool Project [0:20:18] and negotiate a contract with the top ranked firm core construction. [0:20:24] Any further discussion? Rachel Roekall, vote please. [0:20:28] And Sir Cutler. Yes. [0:20:29] Grace and Stone. Yes. [0:20:31] Jason Brown. Yes. [0:20:32] Ray Cauquins. [0:20:33] Chris Reed. Yes. [0:20:35] Yes. Yes. [0:20:38] Thank you. Motion passes six to zero. [0:20:41] Thank you, Mitch. [0:20:43] Hey, next on the agenda is an action item. [0:20:46] A request to adopt ordinance 2025-002 for a zoning development [0:20:53] agreement amendment on property located at 2035 Washington [0:20:57] Street North and we have Will Clayvers. Oh, no, we don't. [0:21:01] Yeah. Hello, Jonathan. Hello. [0:21:04] Planning Zoning Director. Welcome. [0:21:08] Thank you, Madam Mayor, members of Council. This item came from the Planning and Zoning Commission on the 10th of September, and then Council heard it in October as a 14th of October. [0:21:17] This was amending the ZDA to allow for individual lots on that property. [0:21:23] the developers having issues getting financing for the entire project and so [0:21:27] they need to subdivide it out to have each property be its own so they can [0:21:33] leverage the property itself and it is an ordinance you can place on third and [0:21:38] final if you wish by the normal operating rules. Perfect, any questions [0:21:44] for Jonathan? Chris Reed. I move that we dispense with the [0:21:49] Sorry, I don't know. I have no questions. I just go for it. Hold those. You do that one well. You do that one well [0:21:57] We dispense with the reading rules and plays ordinance 2025 dash zero zero zero two [0:22:04] On third and final by title only. Thank you Jason Brown second. Thank you [0:22:10] motion by Chris Reed second by Jason Brown to [0:22:14] to dispense with the reading of the rules [0:22:17] and put an ordinance 2025-002 [0:22:21] on third and final reading by title only. [0:22:25] Rachel Rojo, please. [0:22:27] Chris Reed. [0:22:27] Yes. [0:22:28] Greg Hawkins. [0:22:29] Yes. [0:22:30] Jason Brown. [0:22:31] Yes. [0:22:32] Spencer Cutler. [0:22:33] Yes. [0:22:33] Grayson Stone. [0:22:34] Yes. [0:22:35] Yes. [0:22:36] Yes. [0:22:37] Thank you. [0:22:38] Motion passes six to zero. [0:22:39] Okay. [0:22:40] I'll read the ordinance. [0:22:41] Number 2025 does. [0:22:42] So 002 or 002 because this says one and that says the other way. [0:22:48] I think the three zeros on Civic Clerk are like auto assigned, I think it's just three, [0:22:52] but we don't ever get a thousand ordinances. [0:22:54] That's what I thought. [0:22:55] Okay. [0:22:56] So I'm going to go with 002. [0:22:59] An ordinance of the City Council of the City of Twin Falls, Idaho rezoning certain real property [0:23:04] below describe providing the zoning classification therefore and ordering the necessary area [0:23:10] of impact in zoning district map amendments. Chris Reed, move to approve the adoption of [0:23:16] Ordinance 2025-002. Thank you, Jason Brown. Thank you. Motion by Chris Reed, second by [0:23:23] Jason Brown to adopt Ordinance number 2025-002 for a zoning development agreement amendment [0:23:31] on property located at 2035 Washington Street North. Rachel Roquevo, please. Ruth Pierce, [0:23:38] Piers, Chris Reed, Greg Hawkins, Jason Brown, Spencer Cutler, and Grayson Stone. [0:23:45] Thank you, motion passes six to zero. [0:23:49] Thank you, Jonathan. [0:23:51] Okay, next item on the agenda is an action item, a request to adopt an ordinance amending [0:24:00] city code Title VII, Chapter 8, sections three and four regarding the use of potable [0:24:06] water for irrigation purposes. [0:24:09] We have our city engineer, Troy Vitte. [0:24:11] Welcome, Troy. [0:24:13] Thank you, Mayor and Council members. [0:24:14] Tonight, I'm before you, requesting an ordinance change. [0:24:19] There's several portions of city code that indicate [0:24:23] you cannot use papa water to irrigate from. [0:24:26] And there was some reasons historically [0:24:27] in the past we're trying to prolong our natural water system [0:24:32] and use it for a good, suppable water [0:24:34] for people on the like. [0:24:36] During that process, we developed a pressurized irrigation [0:24:39] stations and then we put the responsibility onto the developers. Well, this has kind of [0:24:43] resulted in some unforeseen circumstances in which these developments are developing [0:24:49] really small pressurized irrigation stations that are managed privately. There's a fear [0:24:54] on my behalf that in the future, not everything's always managed well as based on past experience [0:25:01] that I've seen throughout the city and that may become our responsibility to take care of [0:25:08] these private properties, private watersheds, and some things that [0:25:13] mislead future consequences. We've created a master irrigation plan that shows [0:25:20] that the city should develop some regional stations around the city of Twin Falls, [0:25:24] but these regional stations are larger to serve thousands of acres, [0:25:29] and we've worked with the Twin Falls Canal Company trying to get the water to the [0:25:32] right locations to be able to feed these. So we've gone through the master [0:25:36] pressurized irrigation plan. There's a good plan together and we've worked with the development [0:25:40] community on this and we think we've come up with some language that they are acceptable to. [0:25:46] It really requires them to pay a fee and transfer their watersheds to the city at which point we'll [0:25:51] collect all these fees and then we'll go build the station through a capitalization discussion [0:25:57] that's going to come in the future before you guys. But there's a portion of the city code [0:26:01] title 10, this is the City Engineer can negotiate for that and we've kind of [0:26:06] proceeded with that in the past that I've been negotiating and several past [0:26:11] attorneys we've kind of went around the improvement agreement for him. This says [0:26:15] let's put it the Council can act on an improvement agreement essentially saying [0:26:22] we're gonna accept a fee in lieu of forcing the developer to put on the [0:26:27] private station. We've negotiated that but there's a Title 7 that essentially says [0:26:32] you cannot connect. My goal here tonight is with our new city attorney. He's like if [0:26:38] this is really what you want, ask the council, change the code and do it [0:26:42] properly or more officially. So this would modify city code that says the city [0:26:48] engineer can also negotiate on these other titles that will reflect the Title [0:26:53] I hope that was clear, and I'd stand for any questions. [0:27:01] Questions for Troy, Jason? [0:27:03] Yeah, Troy, I'll just question for you. [0:27:06] So I see this ordinance doing a couple of things for us, [0:27:09] allowing some infill in some of those areas that may no longer be able to be [0:27:16] delivered through a surface water system or a pressurized system, [0:27:20] but also give the city the ability to find the right location [0:27:25] for pressurized irrigation systems, and then also allow the developer to continue to move. [0:27:32] That's correct. [0:27:33] So, funds would be collected on a gross acre basis and depend on where you are throughout the city [0:27:37] and the city would utilize the funds to make the stations in the right locations [0:27:41] that we determine in this master plan. [0:27:45] There's portions of the outside of the town that's very easy for us to develop [0:27:49] and continue with the systems, with the developers of mine. [0:27:52] And now, say the system, it's the station itself. [0:27:55] The developers still have a responsibility, [0:27:57] put in the piping houses, [0:27:59] and they have some responsibility there, [0:28:02] but the city will own and maintain and manage the station. [0:28:04] So just like that, we would collect these ones, [0:28:07] and when we have enough available, [0:28:08] we'll go build the next one. [0:28:10] There's several sprinkled throughout the round outside. [0:28:13] At some point, there may be opportunities within the city, [0:28:16] but that is harder to retrofit downtown. [0:28:20] Thanks Troy. [0:28:21] I'll make a motion but I see some other questions. [0:28:23] Yeah we have a couple of questions Chris. [0:28:24] Yeah Troy thank you for your presentation. [0:28:26] You mentioned the developers in that community. [0:28:29] Can you talk to me about the outreach that we had in having a discussion about this specific [0:28:35] change? [0:28:36] So there has been two developers, Councils we meet by annually twice a year and we've [0:28:41] brought this up on both occasions. [0:28:44] There was going back and forth about the prices and what the responsibilities were. [0:28:48] I think it was, there was some confusion at first. [0:28:53] I think they wanted assurances that the city's gonna own and maintain and operate all this, [0:28:58] and once they pay their fee, they're out of that. [0:29:01] They once they understood that, and that the city's taking that risk and responsibility [0:29:06] to the future, and they just hand over the cash funds in a phased approach, because they're [0:29:12] not gonna develop 80 acres, they're gonna develop 10 acre chunks, so they would pay the [0:29:16] fee for the 10 acres at the time. [0:29:18] I think it was well received by the development committee after that discussion. [0:29:24] As long as there's a clear understanding of the fees, take care of all their responsibility [0:29:30] with the station. [0:29:31] Perfect. [0:29:32] No, thank you. [0:29:33] As you were talking about it, we have a couple from the development community back there and [0:29:36] it didn't make faces as you were lying or anything like that. [0:29:39] And as you were talking about it, they also were slightly nodding in agreement, so perfect. [0:29:43] And I've actually been in both those meetings. [0:29:46] Perfect. [0:29:47] Okay. [0:29:48] I just wanted to say thanks Travis when I read this packet over the weekend [0:29:51] I couldn't quite understand what this was all about and there's all my notes call [0:29:55] Someone from the city this morning, and then I did hear this part on the radio and I thought oh looking back Troy [0:30:01] You're right it makes perfect sense, but I I don't maybe I was tired, but I could not [0:30:06] Thank you. So member madam mayor [0:30:10] Maybe just kind of add a little bit to this and I think that Mitch has a couple of comments as well [0:30:14] going all the way back to when we first started our PI systems. We installed the [0:30:22] systems but not necessarily had the ability to get the water to those [0:30:27] stations and to those locations and so we had the developer construct the [0:30:33] systems that are independent from our drinking water system and that we charge [0:30:37] those with fire hydrants as we attached literally attached a hype or hose from a [0:30:42] fire hydrant into a PI station and it filled that station and then one day later we were [0:30:49] able to connect those different systems and make sure that the PI water got into that [0:30:55] system. [0:30:56] So in a sentence we're returning back to that allowance because we're in this space where [0:31:04] the city has a policy and I'll own I think Dave will appreciate this. [0:31:09] I'll own the disruption that we had in the PI station plan moving forward because I'm the one [0:31:16] that's concerned about the cost to the city ongoing and so this place is on hold but as we [0:31:22] work to modify that the development community still needs the ability to drive and to move [0:31:28] forward and to and to create subdivisions so we look at this as a stop gap in the right circumstances [0:31:34] for this to be able to apply and then I think the Mitch has a couple of thoughts as well. [0:31:37] Go ahead, Mitch. [0:31:39] Yeah, the only thing I wanted to see is that there's a, the question tonight is not about [0:31:46] the program to, um, to charge a fee and build and have the city build the stations. [0:31:52] This is simply a question is, can we modify title seven to allow the city engineer to let [0:31:58] hot water go into the PI system? [0:32:02] It's a practice that we've been doing for 20 plus years. [0:32:05] Prior city attorneys didn't feel like it was an issue [0:32:09] It probably is right and so we should correct it [0:32:13] And and we still are doing it today, right? So title 10 does allow the city engineer to negotiate some of these things [0:32:20] In doing so [0:32:22] We're violating title 7 and so this is really a corrective measure and tonight [0:32:27] That's all it is. We will bring back the fee program at a later date for your for your consideration [0:32:33] in the much more full and complete presentation. [0:32:38] So I just wanted to make a slight distinction between the two. [0:32:41] Right. This is just bringing Title III and Title X. [0:32:45] Title VII and Title VII and Title X to say the same thing. [0:32:49] Yeah. That makes sense. [0:32:52] Hey, Jason, I think we're ready for motion. [0:32:55] I'd move to dispense with the reading of the rules [0:32:58] and put Ordinance 2025-003, [0:33:04] Mending City Code Title VII, on third and final reading by title only. [0:33:14] Thank you to second. [0:33:17] I'll second. [0:33:18] Thank you. [0:33:19] Motion by Jason Brown, second by Chris Reed to dispense with the reading of the rules and put Ordinance 2023-003 [0:33:27] three on third and final reading by title only. Rachel Rocco, vote please. [0:33:32] Ruth Pierce. Yes. Ruth Reed. Yes. Greg Hawkins. Yes. Jason Brown. Yes. Spencer [0:33:38] Cutler. Yes. And Grayson Stone. Yes. Thank you. Motion passes six to zero. So I'll [0:33:44] read the ordinance. Ordinance number 2025-003, an ordinance of the City Council of [0:33:52] the City of Twin Falls, Idaho amending City Code by amending Title 7, Chapter 8, [0:33:58] sections 3 and 4 regarding these, the potable water for irrigation. Jason Brown. [0:34:05] I'd move to adopt Ordinance 2025-003 amending City Code Title 7. [0:34:16] Thank you. Do I have a second? Second. Motion by Jason Brown. Second by Chris [0:34:22] This read to adopt ordinance 2025-003, amending City Code Title 7, Chapter 8, sections 3 and [0:34:30] 4 regarding the use of potable water for irrigation purposes. [0:34:35] Rachel Rokavo, please. [0:34:37] Grace and Stone. [0:34:38] Yes. [0:34:39] And Sir Cutler. [0:34:40] Yes. [0:34:41] Jason Brown. [0:34:42] Yes. [0:34:43] Great Hawkins. [0:34:44] Yes. [0:34:45] Yes. [0:34:46] And Ruth Pierce. [0:34:47] Yes. [0:34:50] Thank you. [0:34:51] Motion passes 6 to 0. [0:34:52] is an action item. It's a request to negotiate on the open market for the Rock Creek sewer [0:34:58] crossing project and to use wastewater reserves to complete the project in the amount of $550,890 [0:35:07] in week. Thank you. Thank you again, Councilor Mayer. I believe most of you are aware of [0:35:14] this project. Rachel, can you show this screen right here? This is a pipeline that crosses [0:35:20] Rock Creek is south of Addison, shown on the screen here. It is a steel pipeline. We've [0:35:27] brought this project before the council before. There was actually some money associated with [0:35:32] it on the May 13th. It was estimated or anticipated this would be a CIPP job. We would go in and [0:35:39] put a new plastic liner in this project. So we got in to it and studied it and went with [0:35:46] the owner there. This pipe is literally deteriorated to the point where that is [0:35:51] unpractical. It is missing portions of the the side. You have the jet it clean at [0:35:57] first. We would blow it apart just in the cleaning process. So it wasn't something [0:36:01] that we could utilize. So the dollars associated that with that went back into [0:36:05] reserves. That project wasn't completed. We hired EHM engineers to do a design on [0:36:10] this. They've completed the design got DEQ approval on it and it's our [0:36:15] Our goal to bid it and start construction of it. So we set it up for bid. We received zero bids per the state procurement [0:36:23] requirements [0:36:25] Maybe it's a difficult site [0:36:29] There's things that make it difficult by pass bumping the stuff like that [0:36:33] I can't really guess to why the contractors didn't but they didn't what the state code does [0:36:37] I was to do is if the council so chooses we can go on the open market talk to contractors [0:36:42] directly and negotiate the price of this repair replacement of this pipeline and [0:36:49] that would be my goal at this time. Also to reclaim those reserve dollars, the [0:36:57] dollars that went back into the reserves to the tune of $550,890. Now that would [0:37:02] cover our engineers estimated probable cost of the construction project, [0:37:06] construction oversight, we're also working with a property owner down there [0:37:10] and obtaining an easement to do the work because of the spills and clean up and we just want [0:37:17] to make sure this is all in conformance. DEQ is very supportive of this. In fact, they're [0:37:22] almost to the point where they're going to mandate it anyway. So I come before you. I [0:37:26] did talk with Finance, they're substantial funds and they're reserved, they're the wastewater [0:37:30] reserve so I definitely can cover the cost of this but we have to go through this process [0:37:35] and I'm requesting the funds as well as negotiating on the open market. Any questions? [0:37:39] Jason I don't have any questions. I'll make the motion looks like Grayson [0:37:45] Go ahead Grayson. Thank you. I was just wondering our thank you madam mayor and our kind of [0:37:51] Plationary times. Do you think that that's enough to actually get it done? [0:37:55] It was engineers estimate and I put a 15% additional contingency on top of that we believe so again [0:38:05] 15% pretty good and I think negotiations [0:38:08] So when you bid a project, you have to take the lowest bidder. There's not much [0:38:12] negotiating in there. We can actually scope the project differently in order to [0:38:16] obtain a certain goal. So it allows us a lot more flexibility by doing that this way. [0:38:21] Right. Yes. Troy, this is something that we've been talking about for some time. The [0:38:27] issues down there. What's the timeframe on something like this? We wouldn't start [0:38:31] conversations tomorrow or effective. And I would guess it's probably gonna be April [0:38:37] before we got all the pipe and everything completed before they can get on site. [0:38:41] Okay. [0:38:42] I know the landowner is anxious. [0:38:44] Absolutely. [0:38:45] As well as we need to work out, he's got animals down there. [0:38:48] We have to store them and kind of do it. [0:38:52] Thank you for all your work on this. [0:38:53] I know that this has not just been a very easy thing. [0:38:56] We thought one direction had to be of it, so thank you for everything you and your team [0:39:00] have been doing. [0:39:01] Thank you. [0:39:02] Thank you. [0:39:03] Jason. [0:39:04] move to approve the negotiation on the open market for the Rock Creek sewer [0:39:09] crossing project and use wastewater reserve funds to complete the project in [0:39:15] the amount of $550,890. Thank you. Do we have a second? Madam Mayor, I'll second. [0:39:21] Thank you motion by Jason Brown second by Grayson Stone to approve [0:39:25] negotiated on the open market for the Rock Creek sewer crossing project and to [0:39:30] use wastewater reserve funds to complete the project in the amount of $550,890 dollars. [0:39:39] Any further discussion? [0:39:41] Rachel Rokalvo, please. [0:39:42] Greg Hawkins. [0:39:43] Yes. [0:39:44] Jason Brown. [0:39:45] Yes. [0:39:46] Spencer Cutler. [0:39:47] Yes. [0:39:48] Grayson Stone. [0:39:49] Yes. [0:39:50] Ruth Pierce. [0:39:52] Yes. [0:39:53] And Chris Reed. [0:39:54] Yes. [0:39:55] Thank you. [0:39:57] Motion passes 6-0. [0:39:58] Thank you, Troy. [0:39:59] Thank you. [0:40:00] actually my action item. As you all recall, over a year ago, actually a year ago last fall, [0:40:11] the MPO was stood up, and the Twin Falls City actually has four seats on the policy board, [0:40:21] we authorized Travis Rothweiler for a one-year term, Jason and Bart Kauffman for a two-year [0:40:34] term and me for a three-year term. Well, Travis' term has expired, and so we're in a position [0:40:40] where we need to approve the confirmation of a three-year term. So the way it's set up, [0:40:48] rotating so that not all of us go out at the same time, we're coming at the same time. [0:40:54] I might mention that the City of Kimberly has three seats, the City of Twin Falls has four, [0:41:00] Twin Falls County has one, Twin Falls Highway District has one, I-T-D has one, Hillsdale Highway [0:41:07] District has one, Jerome County has one, and Jerome Highway District have one. [0:41:13] So what I'm asking is for counsel to confirm appointing Travis Ross Bylar to serve an additional [0:41:21] three-year term on the MPO policy board. [0:41:28] Any questions, comments? [0:41:30] Did you have something you wanted to say? [0:41:32] You are not required to vote yes. [0:41:34] If I was going to say you must vote yes, either that or you step in Travis's shoes if you [0:41:42] vote no, right? [0:41:44] Okay, so I would actually have, oh, I'm open for motion. [0:41:50] So many? [0:41:51] I'll do motion. [0:41:51] I'll be happy to make that motion. [0:41:54] Move to approve the mayor's appointment [0:41:57] of the city manager, Travis Rothweiler, [0:42:00] to serve a three-year term on the Magic Valley Metropolitan [0:42:04] Planning Organization Policy Board. [0:42:06] Thank you. [0:42:07] Do I have a second? [0:42:08] Second. [0:42:09] Thank you. [0:42:10] Motion by Jason Brown, seconded by Craig Hawkins [0:42:12] to confirm the mayor's appointment of city manager, [0:42:16] Travis Wyler to serve as a member of the policy board [0:42:20] for the MPO on a three-year term. [0:42:24] Any further discussion? [0:42:26] Rachel Roquevo, please. [0:42:28] Ruth Pierce. [0:42:28] Yes. [0:42:29] Grace Reid. [0:42:30] Yes. [0:42:31] Grace Hawkins. [0:42:32] Yes. [0:42:33] Jason Brown. [0:42:33] Yes. [0:42:34] Spencer Cutler. [0:42:35] Yes. [0:42:36] Thank you. [0:42:37] Motion passes six to zero. [0:42:39] You're on, Travis. [0:42:40] Uh-huh. [0:42:41] OK. [0:42:42] So that is all for items of consideration. [0:42:46] We have three public hearing tonight. [0:42:49] So before we move on to those, [0:42:51] now is the time for general public input. [0:42:54] If there's anybody in the audience [0:42:55] to wish us to address city council on an issue [0:42:59] that was not on tonight's agenda, [0:43:02] you're welcome to come down to the podium. [0:43:09] Hey, see no one, any advisory board reports? [0:43:17] Everybody was gone. [0:43:19] AIC. [0:43:20] I might mention Mayor that on the AIC, AIC board, they're looking into forming or taking part [0:43:33] in a salary survey for all the cities and stuff that might be helpful for our city down the [0:43:38] road. [0:43:40] Anything from the city manager's office? [0:43:43] You know, we just echo what Councilman Hawkins had shared and that was an opportunity to engage [0:43:49] with some of the members of the regional delegation at the Association of Idaho [0:43:54] Cities, Luncheon, and connect with them throughout. There are a series of policy [0:44:00] board meetings that are occurring. One is the chamber, so it's our opportunity to [0:44:05] not only to continue to build with connection with those who elect to [0:44:08] participate, but it's also our opportunity to kind of share ideas and help build [0:44:13] understanding of their thoughts of behind the legislation, but also share our [0:44:17] thoughts on the potential impacts and so those that have reached out we really [0:44:21] appreciate the relationship and will continue to work forward in this [0:44:24] legislative session with them. Perfect. Oh, Madam Mayor, if I can piggyback off [0:44:28] that on what Travis had just said so the policy meetings are 7 o'clock in the [0:44:34] morning through the chamber the delegation gets on I think the last [0:44:38] meeting we had we had probably 45 participants there will they're well [0:44:43] received. It's a chance to meet with your delegation and ask questions if you'd [0:44:48] like to participate those and I remember the chamber I'd encourage you to reach [0:44:52] out to Kyle Tarbert at the Chamber of Commerce to get the link for those new [0:44:57] meetings but they're at seven o'clock on Friday mornings. We have those [0:45:01] throughout the entire session. Correct. They're really good. They're really [0:45:04] engaged everybody. Okay well we'll move on to our public hearing section. Our [0:45:13] Our first public hearing is an action item, a request for a zoning title amendment to [0:45:26] repeal and replace Title 10 focusing on Chapter 5 parking regulations. [0:45:31] Jonathan, do I need to go through these this time? [0:45:35] Yes, please. [0:45:36] Why don't I do that while you're getting ready? [0:45:40] Okay, public hearing procedures, city staff will present the request and analysis. [0:45:46] The applicant will then present their request. [0:45:49] The council will then ask questions of the applicant or staff. [0:45:53] After questions have been asked, the public hearing [0:45:55] will then be opened. [0:45:56] During that time, anyone in attendance [0:45:58] is given the opportunity to comment or ask questions [0:46:00] about the request being considered. [0:46:03] When giving testimony, please step up the podium, [0:46:05] state your name and address, [0:46:07] present your comments or concerns. [0:46:10] After giving testimony, please sign the public signing sheet [0:46:13] located in the lobby with your name and address for the record. [0:46:16] After public comments are concluded, [0:46:18] applicant will be invited to answer any questions and make a closing statement, [0:46:22] staff will then clarify any comments, answer or clarify any comments, after [0:46:28] closing the public hearing, no further testimony or comments from the applicant [0:46:33] or audience will be heard, and then council will have discussion and take [0:46:37] action. Okay, so it looks like Jonathan and Will. Yeah, we're kind of taggy because I [0:46:47] I sometimes forget some stuff because a lot of stuff we're going through. [0:46:51] I'm going to start with the staff report which has basically these seven bullet points about [0:46:56] the main changes we're taking or proposing with the parking regulations. [0:47:02] It's currently in Title 10 and we are staying in there, it's a new chapter number. [0:47:08] We are addressing seven major items, at least we believe that are the major items, tandem [0:47:12] parking for single family and duplex situations which a lot of people have asked us for, which [0:47:17] If we got feedback from the commission and the council [0:47:20] during that work session we had, [0:47:22] that is going to be allowed. [0:47:24] Adjustment and off-street parking by land use categories. [0:47:27] We currently have a number of items that are listed. [0:47:31] We are combining some categories, [0:47:32] making some more general. [0:47:34] An example would be everything that's gonna be more [0:47:37] of an office use. [0:47:38] It's gonna just have the same number. [0:47:40] And we currently have different kinds [0:47:41] for like financial office versus professional office. [0:47:45] and they're different. [0:47:46] So we're just gonna combine those. [0:47:48] We're going to expand the parking overlay district one [0:47:52] to engulf the overlay two, [0:47:54] and we'll show you that map in a minute. [0:47:56] Downtown has three overlays currently. [0:47:58] We're just gonna have two. [0:48:00] One of them is like a 30% reduction. [0:48:04] The third one is a case-by-case basis. [0:48:06] We're just gonna go with, [0:48:07] there's no requirement and a case-by-case basis. [0:48:10] Some people will still choose to build parking lots downtown. [0:48:13] It's one of those we're not going to require. [0:48:15] We have a lot of on-street and public parking lots that are still less than 80% utilization [0:48:21] and parking lots are really expensive to build. [0:48:25] We're adding some bicycle parking standards. [0:48:27] Some have asked for that as well as a bonus along the Canyon Rim as we get a little bit [0:48:31] more robust network up on the rim and on the trails. [0:48:35] We've changed the stacking requirement for drive-through facilities from numbers of cars [0:48:39] to a measurement in feet. [0:48:42] This was a direct, this was not asked for. [0:48:45] This is something Will and I kind of talked about after we've had recent drive-through [0:48:49] special use permits and there was a difference when some say we have X number from our window [0:48:58] to our order board, some of them have 5, some of them have 10, they're always touting the [0:49:03] number. Our current code says, hey from your order board we need 5 but that didn't always [0:49:08] account for the total number that we're really needed in the end. We'll talk with that number [0:49:13] here in a minute and why we came up with that. We changed the allowance of [0:49:18] shared parking to utilize up to 1,000 feet of the requested use from 500, 500 [0:49:23] particularly downtown in some of those areas, which is enough. I know it seems [0:49:27] far but it's not really that far when we actually pace it off to the entrance of [0:49:31] the parking lot to the business. And then we moved parking lot design [0:49:36] standard, we're trying to move it into a manual which is approved by the City [0:49:40] engineer as a whole construction and design of projects. We get people that [0:49:45] have unique designs that could work, but when we put these standards in code, but [0:49:51] you'll see some that are in code currently, we're going to try and pull [0:49:53] those out, you can't change those standards if they're in code without going [0:49:58] through this public hearing process. If we have a design manual that says, hey, [0:50:02] we've got this unique design and this could work from engineering standpoint, but [0:50:06] it doesn't meet your code, there's no way to go around it being in code. So we're [0:50:10] trying to pull some of those standards that are just really general engineering practices [0:50:13] into a manual and we rely on the city engineer with their expertise and how those things work [0:50:19] as well as the fire marshal to kind of determine whether or not a fire truck accessibility is [0:50:24] going to work or not. [0:50:25] If it's in code, it's hard to change or have those unique designs. [0:50:28] Okay. [0:50:30] So I'm going to start with what we're current code looks like just to give a refresher. [0:50:37] Nope, it was there. [0:50:39] Yes, this should be for me. I don't intend anybody to read this by the way. So I'm just kind of showing you what it looks like [0:50:46] with some of the tables and [0:50:48] How they how they look they're kind of long with a lot of different numbers. We're looking for [0:50:53] term to spaces as well as our stacking this gets at the [0:50:59] Parking lot design. It's actually an older table [0:51:02] we're gonna have a newer one and then you get into some other parking overlay districts and [0:51:08] and parking lands, parking on landscaping up to regulations. [0:51:14] We're gonna show you the proposed chapter. [0:51:18] Looks nicer, it's in double column, [0:51:20] it works a little bit easier in terms of reading it. [0:51:24] Moves to chapter five, numbers kind of inconsequential. [0:51:27] A lot of the language is similar. [0:51:31] I'm not gonna highlight every line here. [0:51:33] If you look at 1051F, that's where the tandem parking comes in. [0:51:38] We talk about no more than two vehicles placed behind one another. [0:51:42] Both have to be assigned to a single dwelling unit and then it shall have a [0:51:47] 40 feet long by nine feet wide, which is essentially just 20 feet long, [0:51:52] which is our normal parking space length. [0:51:53] We know that some vehicles are longer than that. [0:51:56] The average vehicle is around 15 feet long. [0:52:00] There are some pickup trucks that are extended that are longer than that. [0:52:03] They're 20 to 22 feet. [0:52:05] This gets at just the average. [0:52:06] I don't want to make it 44 feet long, [0:52:08] just to accommodate those because then that'd be [0:52:10] onerous for a lot of people. [0:52:13] So what that requires is that space to be off the road [0:52:17] and on private property. [0:52:19] So we start measuring from the private property line, [0:52:21] 40 feet, that means that they won't be obstructing [0:52:25] most of the time, say 90% of the time, [0:52:27] any sidewalks or anything like that. [0:52:29] Occasionally, sidewalks are in easements, [0:52:31] but we can deal with that separately with building permits. [0:52:35] Most of these other regulations are all similar to what we have. [0:52:40] I'm wasn't going to go through this line by line on this page. [0:52:44] We do not allow tandem parking and multi-dwelling developments. [0:52:48] So three or more for the direction that you gave us at that work session. [0:52:55] Okay. We're getting at a parking plan and when they're required. [0:53:04] And then this is where we start the new table. [0:53:07] So what we're trying to do is get everything that has a designation on our new matrix list [0:53:24] and parking requirements that might be required, not everything. [0:53:29] So how this works is that bulded items are the categories. [0:53:34] Those categories have a requirement and that's the requirement for anything listed in that [0:53:40] category unless we specifically pull the land use out and made a special one or a specific [0:53:45] one. [0:53:46] of agriculture animal care has multiple uses. [0:53:49] We say there's no minimum parking requirement. [0:53:52] You need to accommodate your people. [0:53:54] These are the ones where we've had, say, issues [0:53:57] where we can foresee issues, [0:53:59] particularly of say veterinary clinic. [0:54:02] They need one per employee and one space [0:54:03] for any examination room. [0:54:06] We've had some of those veterinary clinics [0:54:07] that just get too many of these [0:54:09] starting to get on the other areas. [0:54:12] Not a whole lot in the agriculture animal care, [0:54:15] because that's just like the type of land use category. [0:54:18] It makes more sense as we go down. [0:54:20] Yes, assembly, we put everybody into one lump, [0:54:23] one space for 15 people of total occupant load. [0:54:27] Each building's designed for an occupant load. [0:54:31] We know that, let's say a church, [0:54:34] for example, has a certain occupant load, [0:54:36] you need one per 15. [0:54:37] That doesn't equal one per car. [0:54:39] I mean, some spaces are really occupant load heavy, [0:54:43] but they don't have 600 people there in the congregation. [0:54:47] That's just the occupant load of the building [0:54:49] per the assembly of the use. [0:54:52] As we've done some back checking, [0:54:54] we don't think anybody is adversely affected by this. [0:54:57] We're generally gonna get the same parking amounts. [0:54:59] This is just what the code says. [0:55:02] Before it used to be a one space per four seats [0:55:06] in the, we call it like sanctuary, [0:55:10] but it was in basically one pew, [0:55:12] one space per four feet of pew. [0:55:14] This amounts to about the same amount, [0:55:16] it just is a little bit more technical, [0:55:19] because we have occupant loads a lot easier [0:55:20] than I know how to calculate four feet of pew [0:55:22] and measure that. [0:55:26] We're gonna just skipping through the classrooms, [0:55:30] that kind of, that actually stays the same. [0:55:33] Commercial services is where most of our commercial items [0:55:37] or commercial businesses are. [0:55:38] We generally have one space per employee [0:55:41] and one per square, five underscore feet [0:55:42] of customer floor area, unless indicated below. [0:55:46] If you think of any kind of retail establishment, [0:55:48] that's what most of those are gonna be in. [0:55:50] One per employee, one per 500 square feet, slowly down, [0:55:59] so we're gonna see parts of these. [0:56:02] Residential state, the same super dwelling unit, [0:56:05] that's been usual other than if you have studio bedroom units [0:56:09] or accessor dwelling units, we added some items. [0:56:19] Industrial, I made it no minimum. [0:56:21] Like honestly, most of our industrial, [0:56:23] it's really difficult to get some parking. [0:56:26] How do you park Chobani, for example? [0:56:29] Our current code has certain amounts of our warehouse, certain amounts of our office, we [0:56:32] can kind of deal with that. [0:56:34] These businesses have been really good actors in our community of getting the number they [0:56:38] need and they just need to develop the parking lot per our standard, which is pay it in the [0:56:44] commercial area, put lights in it, make the design work. [0:56:48] They haven't had a lot of bad actors in the industrial side of things. [0:56:54] They tend to, they know their business and they're working really well to have their accommodations [0:56:59] that people accommodated. [0:57:03] Office, there were a lot of office uses which put them all under 500 square feet of office [0:57:07] floor area. [0:57:12] Okay. [0:57:15] Parking overlay district. [0:57:18] This shows our change that we made which was to eliminate P2, which is the 30%. [0:57:26] I'm going to show you the map now where our proposed overlay will look now or what our [0:57:33] proposing it a little bit too close. This is our only in our downtown area, it's [0:57:40] good the original town site. What's up there in the orange would be our P2 [0:57:45] overlay and the P1 becomes slightly larger and then parts of the areas the [0:57:54] ones on just shown were a 30% reduction I believe if I'm remembering that right [0:57:59] and we just changed it to a case-by-case basis for that area. Now the [0:58:06] decisions not final any direction you give me during any of this type of stuff [0:58:09] we change so if it's you have any idea of a direction we want to make this all [0:58:15] of this P1 or parts of this a case-by-case basis that is totally on the table [0:58:21] these hearings are more like official work sessions as we're getting input and [0:58:26] making these modifications. I'm gonna pause here for questions comments or anything [0:58:31] you've heard so far. Any questions for Jonathan at this point in time? [0:58:39] Just to clarify this P1 shape the reason why it's already down there is it was already in the P1 [0:58:50] So that's why we did that. It's a weird [0:58:53] jog, but we didn't feel like [0:58:56] Making that away [0:58:58] We do have some minimum just standards in terms of how [0:59:14] widths minimum widths and lengths that's nine by 20 [0:59:18] We've already noted that we didn't make those one of them's in [0:59:21] words and numbers so we're gonna make that equal. Don't don't call us on grammar [0:59:28] and spelling. We've got some of those things we need to be made aware of but [0:59:31] we're aware that it's not perfect. We're proposing we don't have a current [0:59:37] wheel stop over any issue or at least our current codes we're gonna put that into [0:59:42] code to make sure that we don't have things overhanging sidewalks. That's [0:59:45] important for us to keep the AD accessible routes on our streets and we [0:59:49] have some alley access and parallel parking spaces. Those are some minimum [0:59:53] designs we wanted to keep coming down to the diagram. These two portions honestly [1:00:00] are the ones we're hoping to potentially pull out into the design manual if we can [1:00:03] we can do that. We may not have that design manual finished so it might be [1:00:08] something that comes later but eventually want to take these out in case [1:00:12] somebody has a unique design. Some of these are also just minimum requirements [1:00:16] safety reasons and trying to get people in and out as well as emergency services in [1:00:21] So we took, we basically had conversations with our farm marshal on trying to get these [1:00:27] areas for all parking lots to be accessible for those emergency services, as well as the [1:00:33] city engineer input on what can work. [1:00:39] Going to the bicycle infrastructure this hasn't been in here before, so we thought we'd have [1:00:44] a few things if somebody wanted to do it, then they can all of these rules to do it. [1:00:50] but it's not a requirement for a bike parking 50 or something like that, but it's just 1-5. [1:00:57] You can't do any more than that. [1:01:02] The rest of these things are all, I believe, the same or very, very similar to our current [1:01:07] code, particularly the loading spaces. [1:01:14] The stacking spaces is different. [1:01:19] We went from vehicles to length and just feet to kind of preface that a little bit. [1:01:28] you've had about three public hearings in the last year on drive-throughs with stacking. [1:01:33] A lot of the comments and some of the, I will say, some of the trickery or magic that some [1:01:40] people were playing was having the cars be very close to each other on their drawings, [1:01:48] which people don't get within inches of each other. [1:01:51] So they were able to smoosh cars together to say, here's how many cars we can have. [1:01:58] they were playing with the window of picking it up to the order board or they [1:02:03] don't order here but there is some sort of menu or pre-menu. As we were brainstorming [1:02:11] one day it was it all kind of it matters but it all kind of doesn't matter. In the [1:02:15] end you just need a space for people to be. We came up with 300 feet. It ends up [1:02:20] being on average 15 to 17 cars that you can get in there and we're talking from [1:02:26] the pickup window. So however many people are going to be waiting you end up [1:02:29] having a 15 to 17 car queueing area. We also took out the requirement to all of [1:02:37] it to not interrupt their own parking spaces. If we go to 300 feet and you don't [1:02:45] take away that provision or that requirement virtually hardly anybody [1:02:49] will comply with this. If they have a problem with their own parking lot I'd [1:02:55] like to basically streamline government efficiency in a way and just say it's [1:03:00] your problem to deal with your own parking lot on private property. What you [1:03:03] can't use is public right-of-way to get your 300 feet. It has to be private [1:03:08] property, but it can come in the form of a joint parking area. And I would use an [1:03:16] example that's a prominent corner. Let's just use the McDonald's at Poland and [1:03:21] Blue Lakes, right? They have a joint use agreement with that parking lot to the [1:03:27] north. They would also have 300 feet to use to queue as long as they have that [1:03:32] agreement. It wouldn't wrap around back on the pole line, at least on paper. And then [1:03:39] we would need to be talking about managing their queue. Another example is [1:03:44] the Chick-fil-A, which we know is a prominent one that backs up, doesn't back [1:03:49] out onto Blue Lakes as a public road, but it is a joint, and we'll even pop the map. [1:03:53] It's a joint agreement with, technically it's Woodbury that owns the parking lot area with it and they manage the queue into their parking lot. [1:04:04] They don't have 300 feet totally. It's close, but it's not. [1:04:09] That drive aisle is all private property to the West. [1:04:13] I'd like to give that to them and just it's easier for us to measure when we're reading, when we're looking at the plans and it's much more uniform in terms of how it's displayed. [1:04:24] displayed. [1:04:25] My mayor is now at okay time to ask Director Spindler the question. [1:04:32] My Director Spindler, so when you got to the 300 feet buffer and you said it's 15 to 17 [1:04:40] foot cars, what were you using for an average car length? [1:04:42] I actually used the 20. [1:04:44] Okay. [1:04:45] So that was the same metric, generally. [1:04:46] Okay. [1:04:47] We just know people don't like park really close together. [1:04:49] I mean, they just don't do that. [1:04:51] So that's the same metric all the way through. [1:04:52] Very similar. [1:04:53] Yep. [1:04:54] Thank you. [1:04:55] retroactive, we looked at most of our drive-thru's. I'm not going to say I looked at every single one, but most of the ones we looked at [1:05:02] percentage wise, it's 90% of the ones we looked at could meet the 300 feet. I don't think we want to make it [1:05:09] something that only four or five need to have, like that's like a hundred cars long because then you kind of [1:05:18] create a regulation that the smaller ones can't ever comply with. We think this is somewhere in the middle that most can [1:05:24] comply with. If we have issues where they go into the public right of way, we have [1:05:30] believe the power to deal with it by having those conversations and talking [1:05:35] them about obstructing the public way, particularly when you get to the use of a [1:05:39] drive-through. We'll talk about that in a later public hearing item when we're [1:05:45] talking about what they need to comply with. This is just simply the stacking [1:05:49] distance. Any questions or if you'd like to see any other places we can show you [1:05:56] if you have any other? Keep going. We have the other, these others we've never had [1:06:08] issues with in terms of the financial institution car washes on mobile. The way [1:06:15] this reads we can keep adding uses if we know some of them don't like need to be [1:06:19] added to like an extreme user we can add an extreme high user that needs to have [1:06:24] 500 feet if we wish. We can just add that to the table later if we need to. We have [1:06:29] that issue come up. We're going to be reworking the escape lane and the [1:06:35] escape lane is going to be used basically on the property after you order. [1:06:39] It's to get out if you have an emergency or if there's a medical [1:06:43] emergency for somebody in it that no longer can move their car. This is not [1:06:47] necessarily outside in the dry vial. This is only on those areas where you [1:06:52] basically it's an emergency escapeling. That will be rewarded till only be on the [1:06:57] property after the order. Shared parking is similar, we just increased that to 1,000 [1:07:04] feet instead of 500. We've had a few people say the parking like that thousand [1:07:08] basically from the door of the building, they're going to the entrance of the [1:07:11] parking lot. 500 really couldn't get through to a shared spot all the time. [1:07:16] Thousands in walking distance we thought was okay and an okay request down. Then [1:07:26] we're trying to strike some of those annual. [1:07:30] That's all the parking items that I have to talk about. [1:07:33] I think I went through all seven major items. [1:07:36] There's any further questions? [1:07:40] Any further questions for Jonathan at this point in time? [1:07:48] Last statement I'd make is this is not the final time [1:07:51] you'll see this. [1:07:52] This is the direction we're going. [1:07:55] We'll finalize some of the items. [1:07:57] In the end, I guess it's the last time [1:07:59] when any other subsequent public hearing, [1:08:02] There's going to be another public hearing when you will see this item. [1:08:05] This is a series of hearings and at the very, very, very end, we'll still have another one and go through an ordinance process as well. [1:08:12] So this is not the final addition. It's just the main direction we're heading. [1:08:16] The modifications that's already to give me. [1:08:19] So we're not going to have a vote. [1:08:21] You basically voting on the direction we have. [1:08:24] Okay. [1:08:25] This is the direction we're going. Okay. [1:08:26] That's really how we're taking these kind of formalized work sessions. This is the direction we're going. [1:08:30] In the end, if we make bigger changes, [1:08:32] there's another public hearing [1:08:34] that will show the final document in the end. [1:08:36] Perfect. [1:08:38] Hey. [1:08:43] Any questions before we move open the public hearing? [1:08:47] Okay, I'm gonna open the public hearing [1:08:49] if there's anybody in the audience [1:08:51] that wishes to address City Council [1:08:53] on this particular item, the parking regulations. [1:08:57] Please come down to the podium, state your name, [1:09:00] and whether you're resident of Twin Falls, [1:09:03] And you will have three minutes to... [1:09:07] Hello, Franny. [1:09:09] [Muted for privacy: home address] [1:09:11] [Muted for privacy: home address] [1:09:14] [Muted for privacy: home address] [1:09:16] [Muted for privacy: home address] [1:09:17] Okay. [1:09:18] Three. [1:09:22] You've likely all seen my manifesto that I offered. [1:09:27] It focused a lot on landscaping, [1:09:29] and the reason I brought this up now [1:09:31] is because you'll be seeing the landscaping very soon, [1:09:33] And I think the item regarding parking, [1:09:38] there's a concern I have about landscaping [1:09:41] allowed in the parking lots. [1:09:43] And if I think you've read it, if there's any questions [1:09:49] on what I presented, I would be here to answer those. [1:09:52] But in my short amount of time, I just [1:09:55] want to make certain that you understand [1:09:59] that I guess my request would be that parking regulations, [1:10:03] especially in the dimensions that are in the new exhibit [1:10:09] in the new proposal, the dimensions call for a minimum [1:10:15] of 62 feet per unit for 60 degree parking. [1:10:21] 62 feet times two is 124 feet. [1:10:25] Currently we have parking lots in the downtown core [1:10:28] that are 116 feet wide, virtually all the parking lots in downtown are 116 feet wide [1:10:36] of parking and we're making that wider so the parking lots that exist would be out of compliance [1:10:42] and those exist but any new parking lots would be required under this code to become take [1:10:52] up more space and you could possibly fit them into the city blocks that are [1:10:58] 185 feet deep but if you do you're going to eliminate the option for landscaping [1:11:02] as a part of that. I would like to keep an overlay if you will or carve out in [1:11:09] parking and in the future for landscaping for the downtown area because we have [1:11:14] restrictions on the lots that we have in downtown. We don't have green fields to [1:11:19] to design new parking lots, we're stuck with what we have. [1:11:23] And if we, under the new standard, it's very likely we'll have [1:11:26] to give up something, either give up parking, [1:11:28] which is in some cases at a premium, or give up landscaping, [1:11:35] which in all cases is something that I'd like to encourage us [1:11:40] to consider at every juncture when we go through the code [1:11:43] and how it affects downtown. [1:11:46] In my offering, I've said that downtown is special. [1:11:51] I believe that absolutely, clearly with my heart that's downtown special, and we have [1:11:56] to take a look at these codes, how they affect the downtown. [1:12:00] I'm one of the few developers, if not the only one, trying to do some things downtown. [1:12:07] And so I'm more keenly aware of how these minute changes that don't seem like much [1:12:11] affect us. [1:12:13] And finally on the parking, stacking, I've got 11 seconds left, I'd like to see that stacking [1:12:20] kept at five cars or 100 feet in downtown. [1:12:25] We don't have the mass of property sizes. [1:12:29] We don't have the large parking lots to drive through to use the 300 feet. [1:12:35] Thank you, Franny. [1:12:36] Thank you. [1:12:37] Is there anybody else in the audience that wishes to address City Council on this particular [1:12:43] item? [1:12:51] Okay, anything you'd like to address, Jonathan? [1:12:59] Only if the council wishes me to address those items. [1:13:02] We can talk about options and what we think we can do. [1:13:07] Yeah, I think, yeah. [1:13:10] If the council wish to have the different dimensions [1:13:14] for downtown, my recommendation would be to do it [1:13:17] in that overlay section, [1:13:19] where parking's not required to be built [1:13:21] for a lot of the items, [1:13:23] But we can have an alternative design approved by the administrator or city engineer and we [1:13:29] will bring up that kind of language. [1:13:32] While still meeting the safety requirements we believe we need from fire marshal or any [1:13:38] of the emergency service access. [1:13:41] What I don't want to have happen is, I think around two extremes, we're looking at it as [1:13:46] a worst case scenario and they look at the best case scenario. [1:13:51] my viewpoint if I had to truncate it down, we get in trouble if we don't think of the worst-case [1:13:56] scenario when it does happen. And that's kind of where I don't want to have a design that doesn't [1:14:01] work from an emergency service standpoint and have the city then be part of the problem. [1:14:08] But at the same time, if some things are going to be unbuildable in some instances, [1:14:13] we should have a combination for trying to make both. If we were to carve that out, I would do it [1:14:18] in the parking overlay section, where P1 talks about there is no requirement for parking, [1:14:24] and I'll just add if you wish to build it all the standards unless otherwise approved by [1:14:30] or some version of language, I'm thinking this up a little bit, that we can be approved by the [1:14:36] administrator slash city engineer with the Fire Marshal for access. That's kind of getting at the [1:14:44] distance of how deep the parking spaces need to be, how big the drive aisle needs [1:14:49] to be. That's really what friends talking about is when you have a degree angle of [1:14:54] parking you need to be able to reverse out of it and you need enough space to do [1:14:58] that as well as having a space for a fire truck or other emergency services to [1:15:01] get through. Particularly if it's a fire lane you're trying to get to a building [1:15:04] too. Those are things we're trying to take into account. If you make them too [1:15:09] wide then there's no space for landscaping to be along the road if you [1:15:12] you want it, or you can overhang the sidewalk. [1:15:16] That's really where we're at. [1:15:17] So if the council's general direction is, [1:15:21] yeah, we'd like to have those types of unique designs [1:15:24] downtown, the parking overlay is only downtown. [1:15:28] It doesn't apply to Greenfield. [1:15:29] It's really just down here. [1:15:31] We can carve out some sort of approval design [1:15:35] for those areas. [1:15:43] Yes, sir. [1:15:44] That seems reasonable. [1:15:45] I'm trying to wrap my head around all the implications. [1:15:49] I guess the goal is to encourage landscaping. [1:15:54] Does that accomplish that versus, [1:15:56] does it mean if there's someone that knows [1:15:57] how to work through the gray areas, [1:15:59] they could fight for landscaping versus it being approved. [1:16:04] But I understand your concerns too, [1:16:05] in a six minute time frame here, [1:16:09] think of all the different angles or implications. [1:16:15] Yeah, to be honest, [1:16:17] there's been very few new parking lots built downtown. [1:16:19] other than by us in the last 10, the 12 years, 15 years. [1:16:23] That's not to say somebody won't build a new one. [1:16:26] It's just we haven't experienced it [1:16:28] at the ones that are already constructed. [1:16:30] So that's where I'm kind of going off of, [1:16:32] I think we could have alternative design for distances. [1:16:38] And we're trying to balance both, [1:16:39] as we've heard from public testimony, [1:16:41] we're in Idaho, we drive big trucks [1:16:43] and we need to have a space to be able to get through them. [1:16:45] But if you make the angle and the distance not big enough [1:16:49] and you've got two jar and try and pick up trucks, [1:16:50] there's only seven feet between them because they're 22 feet [1:16:54] long, like those are the types of things we're trying to think [1:16:56] of, and now you can no longer get through there. [1:16:59] We worry about that worst case scenario. [1:17:02] Most people are more positive than us, government employees [1:17:06] always thinking about the worst thing that can happen, [1:17:08] but we always get called when something doesn't have to happen. [1:17:10] We didn't think of it. [1:17:11] So that's kind of where we're trying to balance. [1:17:13] I think there's options to do that. [1:17:15] I don't have everything, all of the answers for it. [1:17:18] However, I can propose language, and it would be in that parking overlay section. [1:17:23] Rachel, can you show this map so I can kind of talk about, it would apply to these areas. [1:17:28] We just carve it out and say, these areas, you can have alternative design, [1:17:32] approval by the city engineer, accomplishing the safety welfare, [1:17:38] you know, that kind of language. [1:17:40] I'm just spitballing up here, and sorry about that. [1:17:44] It's better than I spitball. [1:17:47] It actually made sense. [1:17:52] Any other, Jason? [1:17:54] I would just say, I think, Jonathan, what you've been [1:17:56] talking about, as long as we're thinking about those [1:17:58] and having conversations with people that have some ideas, [1:18:03] I'm comfortable with moving forward. [1:18:05] I was like, Fran, has some ideas or potentials [1:18:10] as long as we can capture a large majority of scenarios [1:18:16] or situations where we're obviously [1:18:17] I'm not gonna catch all of them. [1:18:19] I'll have to figure out how do we deal [1:18:21] with some of those unique challenges. [1:18:24] Yeah, and I evidenced by what we're talking about. [1:18:27] The legislature, nobody creates the perfect law [1:18:29] because they keep amending everything every year, right? [1:18:31] So it's a similar thing here. [1:18:33] We create a safety valve that we can have a process [1:18:35] to look at it. [1:18:36] And then if we don't agree, it gets appealed. [1:18:39] I'm getting a general sense. [1:18:41] We will in future drafts or any version of this [1:18:45] have that kind of safety valve process for this downtown area overlay for parking lot design [1:18:53] that does not meet the specific width diagram that every everywhere else in Greenfield [1:18:59] will have. We'll have a process to go through that we can review something that's different than that [1:19:04] or smaller sizes is that I'm getting a general direction. We will have that you don't need it [1:19:11] as a condition as a direction to me now we will have that created and we'll have a draft version [1:19:15] an update for you going forward. Any other questions? Any to answer? So I have one question [1:19:25] on that one section where you called out the P1, P2, and there was a reference to P3. What [1:19:32] is P3? The P3 was a current code section that was the 30% less than required or we actually [1:19:39] had like. So P2? Yes. Go back to the current one. Yeah, there you go. I get a mix up on [1:19:48] So the current code is this, one is there's no requirement, P2 was a 30% and P3 was case by case. [1:19:58] We just deleted the current, P2 made current P3 the case by case basis. [1:20:05] Okay, because 30% less known as using, they were just like, it doesn't really. [1:20:09] Okay. [1:20:10] It wasn't really working. [1:20:11] Okay. [1:20:12] That makes sense. [1:20:13] The really just be two spots. P1 will be no requirement. P2 is a case-by-case basis when [1:20:19] something is built or constructed. We look at the parking to make sure it will work for [1:20:23] what's being constructed. They work. We get evidence that we can defend and say here's [1:20:29] how what it is, here's how many we're going to have. Downtown is a little bit less than [1:20:33] other places because there's a lot of public parking. We work with them on a case-by-case [1:20:37] basis for what makes sense less defensible. [1:20:41] make sense. Any other comments, questions before I close? [1:20:48] Yeah, just wanted to have you speak to, and maybe we've already kind of talked about this, [1:20:53] the stacking downtown. I know we don't have a lot of drive-throughs downtown. Probably a [1:20:58] reason why we don't have a ton of drive-throughs. There's not a lot of space for that, but also [1:21:02] kind of the same thing, understanding that space is very limited down here. 300 feet looking [1:21:08] at that would be challenging, it would prohibit it to somebody bringing in a drive-through downtown. [1:21:16] Agreed. I don't believe every drive-through what we have currently or the drive-throughs are the most [1:21:27] appropriate use downtown if we're going for more walkable urban environment. Drive-throughs [1:21:34] and people walking and bicycles don't mix. Well, they usually have a lot of conflict points, [1:21:40] Particularly when you have current setbacks downtown that are zero property line setbacks. [1:21:47] So when you come to some of those that someone can build right on the sidewalk and you have a drive-through coming out onto the road right next to it, [1:21:55] those things are difficult when you have a high user. [1:21:59] It's not necessarily the stacking that's the problem. [1:22:01] I'm answering it with more of a statement in a different direction, [1:22:04] which is drive-through should be really looked at downtown on whether they're most appropriate use. [1:22:08] We're not taking it away, but some scenarios that just may not be appropriate. [1:22:13] That's why drive-threes are going to be R and have are going to be special uses to kind [1:22:17] of look at that. [1:22:20] The minimum 300 could preclude some if we needed to carve out some users. [1:22:25] The problem is I can't treat a restaurant downtown different than a restaurant somewhere [1:22:30] else unless you do it in an overlay type of fashion. [1:22:34] That doesn't mean that this drive-threes won't be popular and busy though. [1:22:38] And that's kind of where you go. [1:22:39] And I was the drive-thru, the most appropriate spot for this location, restaurants are fine, [1:22:43] but it's the use of the car. [1:22:46] And that's kind of where I don't have a good answer for you other than it's a different [1:22:50] direction of maybe drive-thru, aren't the most appropriate downtown. [1:22:53] And while we were having this discussion, just looking at Google Maps, and I mean the majority [1:22:59] do not hit 300 feet. [1:23:02] Downtown? [1:23:03] Or in Twin Falls. [1:23:05] We have a handful, but I mean I think of Starbucks. [1:23:07] They do. [1:23:08] We checked and it goes through the parking lot. [1:23:11] Yeah, at the mall, it goes out onto the road. [1:23:13] No, I'm talking about the one on Blue Lakes. [1:23:14] The Blue Lakes, yeah. [1:23:15] Yeah. [1:23:16] That would meet three hundred. [1:23:17] That would meet three hundred. [1:23:18] That would meet three hundred. [1:23:19] That would meet three hundred. [1:23:20] That would meet three hundred. [1:23:21] That would meet three hundred. [1:23:22] That would meet three hundred. [1:23:23] That would meet three hundred. [1:23:26] That would meet three hundred. [1:23:27] That would meet three hundred. [1:23:28] That would meet three hundred. [1:23:29] That would meet three hundred. [1:23:30] That would meet three hundred. [1:23:31] That would meet three hundred. [1:23:32] That would meet three hundred. [1:23:33] That would meet three hundred. [1:23:34] That would meet three hundred. [1:23:35] That would meet three hundred. [1:23:36] That would meet three hundred. [1:23:37] That would meet three hundred. [1:23:38] That would meet three hundred. [1:23:39] or I can just say go back to the list. If we want coffee shop drive-throughs to be a separate, [1:23:52] instead of commercial services, we can say coffee shops have a certain distance. So you can do it [1:24:02] in two ways. You can say the land use has, then all of the land uses are treated equally, or you say [1:24:06] because of it's in a certain area, we can treat everything different in this area. Everything in [1:24:12] the downtown original town site only needs to be a hundred feet long for dry [1:24:16] through stacking or this type of land use non-restaurant eating locations or [1:24:24] eating establishments can be a hundred feet but I can't can't say because you're [1:24:30] Dutch brothers you need 500 and because you're Starbucks you need a hundred yeah [1:24:34] that's I think the area is where I'm going okay that that that would be the [1:24:38] area, not start carving out all these different places. I would want to do that. [1:24:44] We actually have a restaurant on show shown that it has a drive in that I'm positive is. [1:24:50] Yeah, it does not make 300 feet. No, not even close. So, [1:24:53] going right across from first bed. Yeah, yeah. And since it's been built and drive [1:24:58] through has been open and closed and signs of some don't. And to your point, it is very [1:25:02] challenging to use that those that do open up the drive through, it's almost impossible. [1:25:07] It's very hard for eating particularly. They just they rely on the constant movement of cars [1:25:12] different than like a financial institution which means they're slower than the same volume. [1:25:19] So what I'm hearing is particularly potentially downtown, maybe having the stacking with the [1:25:24] downtown allowance for less cars specifically for commercial services or would it be specifically [1:25:34] for restaurants or more of a non-restaurant drink establishment type things and I'm getting [1:25:45] in the weeds but we're kind of having to get there a little bit. [1:25:47] Do I have to get there? [1:25:48] Absolutely. [1:25:56] I'm kind of staring at Councilman right here because I think there's a difference between [1:26:02] the drive-through that you have at first fed and D11s. [1:26:05] Absolutely. [1:26:06] And those already have one separate? [1:26:08] Yeah, those are separate. [1:26:09] Correct. [1:26:10] drive-through that goes in and out on-show shown, but at the same time, I'm just [1:26:16] thinking out loud question for you, hey stop using the drive-through, they try and [1:26:21] use it again as the businesses change hands. Don't they have to go back for a [1:26:26] special look in that district they don't have to? No, honestly, there's actually a [1:26:30] state called the preempts us from taking things away that are purpose-built and a [1:26:33] drive-through is very purpose-built so that's a little bit way more in the weeds [1:26:36] for you. So there's already a drive-through present. Yeah. Purpose bill. [1:26:42] Stop it. Purpose bill things are actually protected for 10 years in state statute. [1:26:47] I just don't remember the number 67-65 towards the end. Wow. So that wouldn't [1:26:53] preclude any back-camera with the restaurant right there. The commercial [1:26:57] services are the area that I just, if somebody's trying to broaden. Yeah, somebody's trying to come in, [1:27:02] and there's a wide variety, and we know that, I mean, one restaurant. There are [1:27:07] no restaurants, the same commercial business is the same, but we can create [1:27:15] downtown to be more like a hundred feet. This also sounds terrible and I'm all [1:27:21] four downtown businesses but where that building's been a bit of a revolving [1:27:25] door I think that that markets that I drive through, you know, actually function [1:27:29] there because people don't have to deal with the traffic going in and out of [1:27:32] there. And that's specific area but if somebody decides to build elsewhere off the [1:27:37] And we have a couple of areas that somebody could easily come in and build there from the [1:27:45] ground up, it would be challenging to get to 300 feet. [1:27:50] For sure. [1:27:51] I agree with that. [1:27:52] So if you dropped it to 100 feet, they'd still have to not block roads and I mean, still [1:27:56] have those other areas. [1:27:57] It might not be good in general, but that requirement wouldn't be. [1:28:00] But you'd still have a safeguard because it would still have to go to P&Z, correct? [1:28:03] For the drive-through. [1:28:04] Current application. [1:28:05] Yes. [1:28:06] where we'd kind of look at these have to meet the minimums and will the windows [1:28:12] actually up around the corner. But I think we could carve out a downtown [1:28:18] exemption or with a distance. Can just say the downtown either the parking [1:28:28] overlay or the original town site has a drive-through stacking requirement of 5 [1:28:32] which is under feet or it gets you 5 cars. [1:28:38] Is that the direct that's coming from here and that's what I'm going to do? Yeah, that's what you'll see in the future [1:28:46] Based on the comments we have that kind of stuff anything else [1:28:49] You've concluded your public hearing you've got questions my public hearing so I will do that [1:28:59] So it's up to the council to [1:29:03] Do a vote? [1:29:05] Do we like the direction he's headed somebody needs to make a motion Chris read? I like the direction [1:29:11] and I like that they're still, [1:29:12] we're still gonna be talking about this. [1:29:15] It sparked my interest as we were going through this. [1:29:17] Google Maps is a great place to go in there [1:29:19] and start looking at things as we were talking about parking. [1:29:22] The difference between certain parking lots [1:29:24] is really easy. [1:29:25] There's some that I will go to, [1:29:26] and some that there's one on blue lakes [1:29:29] that if you're trying to park and you were weaving [1:29:33] through their parking lot because of big trucks. [1:29:35] So I appreciate the carve out, [1:29:37] but also the understanding that, [1:29:39] hey, it might not work in that area. [1:29:40] So I'll make the motion if we're ready. [1:29:42] Go ahead. [1:29:43] Move that we approve the zoning entitlement, [1:29:46] title amendment to repeal and replace title 10, [1:29:49] focusing on chapter five, parking regulations as presented. [1:29:54] Thank you, Jason Brown. [1:29:55] Second. [1:29:57] Thank you, motion by Chris Reed, second by Jason Brown [1:29:59] to approve the zoning title amendment [1:30:02] to repeal and replace title 10, focusing on chapter five, [1:30:06] parking regulations as presented. [1:30:09] Any further discussion? [1:30:12] Rachel Roach, all vote please. [1:30:14] Grayson Stone. [1:30:15] Yes. [1:30:16] Spencer Cutler. [1:30:17] Yes. [1:30:18] Jason Brown. [1:30:19] Yes. [1:30:20] Craig Hawkins. [1:30:21] Yes. [1:30:22] Chris Reed. [1:30:23] Yes. [1:30:24] And Ruth Pierce. [1:30:25] Yes. [1:30:26] Thank you. [1:30:27] Motion passes six to zero. [1:30:28] Okay. [1:30:29] The next public hearing is an action item, request for zoning title amendment to repeal [1:30:33] and replace title 10, focusing on chapter seven, required improvements of development. [1:30:40] All right, we did the hard one first, [1:30:43] so these next ones are pretty, should be okay. [1:30:48] We've already gone through this [1:30:49] requirement improvements recently with this past summer, [1:30:52] and so that was in December 17th, [1:30:57] as we actually had the ordinance, I believe, [1:30:59] or the, nope, sorry, it's up further in the seat. [1:31:02] I'm gonna go to the scene of this. [1:31:04] We're in this 2024-12. [1:31:06] This is where we kind of restructured everything. [1:31:10] We haven't changed pretty much anything from this. [1:31:13] What we did pull out though was the floodplain regulations, [1:31:17] which is the bulk of that chapter. [1:31:21] And it's gonna be its own chapter [1:31:23] because floodplain regulations have two things. [1:31:25] One, it's regulated by federal government [1:31:28] and the state floodplain coordinator [1:31:30] and the state floodplain requirements. [1:31:32] So those things we just pulled out to its own chapter. [1:31:35] If there's changes per federal requirements [1:31:37] or state requirements, [1:31:38] we can just deal with them on their own chapter. [1:31:40] This chapter will simply just point to it to say [1:31:42] you need to comply with that when you're having development. [1:31:46] The rest of it, I don't believe we changed it [1:31:50] from the ordinance that you saw earlier. [1:31:52] The formatting's different, but the words are the same. [1:31:56] We still go through when the installation's required. [1:31:59] The temporary certificate of occupancy stuff [1:32:02] is all still within this. [1:32:03] We didn't change any of that. [1:32:05] Landscaping is required when you have certain type of buildings [1:32:11] certain type of buildings happening. [1:32:14] I'm not going to go into any more because we've really just talked about this a few months [1:32:17] ago and those are the changes we just kept, it's just the formatting. [1:32:21] And then the next public hearing is on the floodplain anyway. [1:32:24] So, okay. [1:32:27] So. [1:32:28] Real quick. [1:32:29] Yes. [1:32:30] In the first section when it's applicable, we did add that one especially user condition [1:32:36] use permit is required. Currently, that is not in code that has been generally our practice, [1:32:43] that when we have a significant special use permit, that even if it doesn't constitute [1:32:50] it with the expansion of a building or changing the use category, then it would require the [1:33:00] improvement. So now we're just codifying that practice. And condition leases are a new type of [1:33:05] a thing where they we are going to be writing out this types of requirements, um, they'll [1:33:10] be listed as conditional if they meet them, they get the permit to do. Right. So that would [1:33:16] be a new thing we added. That's all we, we added a building, we have some standards that [1:33:27] was for the fire marshal. Um, they wanted to have those standards in code, not just by practice [1:33:34] but plain regulations. And that's the building addressing right there. It's 10, 7, 4. [1:33:47] Any questions before I open up the public hearing? [1:33:49] Hey, I will open up the public hearing on this particular item required improvements [1:33:57] of development. [1:33:58] If anybody in the audience wishes to address City Council on this zoning title amendment, [1:34:04] please come forward. [1:34:10] Hey, see no one. [1:34:12] I'll close the public hearing. [1:34:14] Any questions for Jonathan? [1:34:17] Or will? [1:34:22] Okay. [1:34:25] Chris Reed. [1:34:26] I'll make the motion if we're ready [1:34:28] Move that we approve the zoning title amendment to repeal and replace title 10 focusing on chapter 7 [1:34:35] Requiring improvements of development as presented. Thank you. Jason Brown second [1:34:41] Thank you motion by Chris Reed seconded by Jason Brown to approve the zoning title amendment to repeal and replace title 10 [1:34:49] focusing on chapter 7 required improvements of development as presented [1:34:54] Any further discussion? [1:34:57] Rachel Rolkow, please. [1:34:59] Greg Hawkins? [1:35:00] Yes. [1:35:01] Jason Brown? [1:35:02] Yes. [1:35:03] Spencer Cutler? [1:35:04] Yes. [1:35:05] Jason Stone? [1:35:06] Yes. [1:35:07] Ruth Pierce? [1:35:08] Yes. [1:35:09] Thank you. [1:35:10] Motion passes six to zero. [1:35:11] Okay. [1:35:12] Last item action item request for zoning title amendment to repeal and replace title 10 focusing on chapter 12 floodplain regulations. [1:35:21] Okay. [1:35:25] You're up. [1:35:26] so we literally copied and pasted the entire thing from one section to this one because [1:35:31] we went through it just like a year ago and we went through with the state floodplain coordinator [1:35:37] that's no changes we didn't take any changes format unless we found any kind of like [1:35:42] spelling or grammar but no I want the other format that's the current format right now [1:35:49] oh it looks so much better the other way [1:35:51] Okay. [1:35:52] Thank you. [1:35:54] It's just kind of how you that's it. [1:35:56] Hey, any questions for Jonathan on this before I open up the public hearing. [1:36:00] Hey, thank you. [1:36:03] I will open up the public hearing on this action item and request for zoning title amendments [1:36:08] replacing title 10 focusing on chapter 12 blood plane regulations. [1:36:13] If there's anybody in the audience that wishes to adjust City Council on this issue, please [1:36:18] come forward. [1:36:19] Okay, seeing no one, I will close the public here in Greyston Stone. [1:36:26] I'm in a mayor for ready. [1:36:27] I will make a motion. [1:36:28] Anybody have any questions before we go ahead? [1:36:31] Go ahead, Greyston. [1:36:32] Thank you, Madam Mayor. [1:36:33] I make a motion to approve the zoning title amendment to repeal and replace title 10 folks [1:36:38] on chapter 12 floodplain regulations. [1:36:41] As presented. [1:36:42] As presented. [1:36:43] Thank you. [1:36:44] Do I have a second? [1:36:45] Second. [1:36:46] Thank you. [1:36:47] Motion by Greyston Stone, second by Chris Reed. [1:36:49] To approve the zoning title amendment to repeal and replace Title 10 focusing on Chapter 12 [1:36:55] floodplain regulations as presented. [1:36:58] Rachel Roquevo, please. [1:37:00] Ruth Pierce. [1:37:01] Yes. [1:37:02] Chris Reed. [1:37:03] Yes. [1:37:04] Ray Cawkins. [1:37:05] Yes. [1:37:06] Jason Brown. [1:37:07] Yes. [1:37:08] And Sarah Cutler. [1:37:09] Yes. [1:37:10] And Grayson Stone. [1:37:11] Yes. [1:37:12] Thank you. [1:37:13] Motion passes six to zero. [1:37:14] Okay. [1:37:15] convene into executive section under 74206C to acquire interest in real property not owned [1:37:23] by a public agency, F to communicate with legal counsel for the public agency, to discuss [1:37:30] the legal ramifications of and legal option for pending litigation or controversies not [1:37:37] yet being litigated, but imently likely to be litigated. [1:37:41] the mere presence of legal counsel and executive session [1:37:44] does not satisfy this requirement. [1:37:47] So moved. [1:37:48] Thank you, do I have a second? [1:37:49] Second. [1:37:50] Thank you, motion by Chris Reed, second by Craig Hawkins, [1:37:54] to convene into executive session under 74's 206C and F. [1:38:02] Any discussion? [1:38:03] Rachel Rocha-Rocov, oh please. [1:38:05] Ruth Pierce? [1:38:06] Yes. [1:38:07] Chris Reed? [1:38:08] Yes. [1:38:09] Craig Hawkins, Jason Brown? [1:38:10] Yes. [1:38:10] Yes, yes. Yes. Thank you motion passes 12 6 6 to 0 [1:38:17] We will not be making decisions in executive council, and we will not be return turning [1:38:25] Back to chambers, so we'll be adjourned. Thank you everyone